001e e e okay we're going to call the organizational meeting to order um we will foro the pledge until the workshop okay okay fair enough good all right um do we have a motion to approve the agenda so moveed support support oh we usually do roll call well we could do that we could do that I am sorry all right roll call can we have a roll call please me on my order here 100 here HBO here stus here Gardine here pal here danan here V here present okay and do we have a motion to approve the agend so move support support okay move support uh all in favor yes yes oppos okay carries uh ceremonial oath of office um Sally you please come up here I'm gonna bring my glasses because I might not
002go this don't bring them Sally if you would please raise your right hand and repeat after me I do solemnly swear or affirm I do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support the Constitution of the United States that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the State and the constitution of this state and that I will Faithfully discharge the duties of and I will Faithfully discharge the duties of the office of member of the Board of Education the office of member of the Board of Education of Granville public schools of Granville Public Schools Kent and adawa counties Michigan Kent and adawa count Michigan according to the best of my ability according to the best of my ability I'm you got your whole familyes raise your right hand I
003do solemnly swear or affirm I do solemnly swear or affirm that I will support the Constitution of the United States I will support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of this state and the constitution of the state and that I will Faithfully discharge the duties of and I will Faithfully discharge the duties of the office of member of the Board of Education the office of member of Board of Education of Grandville public schools of grand Public Schools Kent and Ottawa counties Michigan Kent and Ottawa counties Michigan according to the best of my ability according to the best of my ability Sally and Jason welcome AB board again GL glad to to have you here and I know You' be a great part of this wonderful team that we have uh would would
004like to open it up for the election of officers uh and I will run through uh a little background on that um board bylaw 2405 States the board must elect a president and vice president the board may also elect a Treasurer and secretary please do that a candidate for the board officer position must receive a majority of the board members um then serving on the board a majority vote of the board members than serving on the board the floor will be open for nominations for each officer's position according to Robert's Rules of Order the nomination need not be seconded after all nominations have been received for an officer's position a motion to close nominations for the specific officer's Position will be requested and a vote will occur and I would and this may not be
005second but I would just like uh can we have a motion to open up the Board of Education um officer election nominees someone support thank you uh we're going to start with President uh at this time if anyone has anyone they would like to nominate please make that known I'd like to nominate Jason hi boy I'd like to nominate Bob Wonder jum okay so we have Jason and Bob any other nominations any other nominations say it one more time any other nominations do you have a motion to close yes could you have a motion to close please support okay all right and we will do a roll call vote okay hboard hbor stus Wonder J Gardine hbor danan Wonder Jim Palmer highboard vanck highboard okay three so do I get a chance to vote you're
006not on my list Jem sorry who would you vote for I think I'll vote for myself oh I knew that and I apologize sorry okay so Jason G is yours all right all right so we Clos last motion do we need to reopen the motion to for nominations for vice president we we don't we just opened for um nominees for each position so um we'll do each one um and then do a final motion to approve all for all right so looking for any nominations for vice president I'd like to nominate Brett danan any other nominations any other nominations one last time any other nominations can I get a motion to close so moved support right okay BR uh we'll go down the line Palmer uh Brett vanc this is Brett danan myself I guess
007stus Brent W J Mr hior Don and Gardine Don all in favor thank you thank you all right now uh open for nominations for secretary I'd like to nominate Amy Gardine okay are other nominations any other nominations one last time any other nominations can I get a motion to close move support okay V Gardine Palmer Gardine hbor Gardine stefas Gardine Gardine Wonder jums Gardine danan Gardine cardine gets it yeah come over here I want her to finish the this is really you'll do better than me I don't know what I'm doing over here it's all since I have not seen any of this paperwork it's pretty easy actually I know it's an honor [Music] exciting okay here thank you so much that's your cover sheet and I I started my for membership I'm leaving my
008code over there that's where I start we'll open up the uh nominations for treasur yes do thank youly so it looks like I'm starting another yes you will so this will be for Treasure probably any nominations for Treasure I nominate Bob Wonder Jim I'm going to De thank you anyway I'd like to Nate Sally it's a big job though so that's what I've heard got to tell Heather what to do and everything yeah there are some signing of papers so sometimes okay if you get it yeah yeah any other nominations any other nominations one last time any other nominations all right can I get a motion to close so move who who supported no there you go I said it and Jason support it all right all right so I I got to find myself
009all right do an m and an S okay there we go this is exactly a pro like when your hand start to shake it's will help you little and don't forget to call anyone's name okay and they're always in different order I do like I was like how she decides look at that Wonder J sometimes I change it hore V stus vck Guardian vck Palmer vck danan vck vck vck nice um our treasur is B thank you okay all right so we need to close an overall or not what I would suggest is read just go through it with all me yeah then we'll make a vote on it this overall yeah all right so to wrap this up it is recommended uh the Board of Education elect the following officers for the 2025 calendar
010year uh for president Jason hore for vice president Brent danan um for secretary Amy Gardine and for treasurer Sally vck can I get a motion so move all those in favor yes although opposed motion passes congratulations everybody thank you con all right now all right you just tell me when you're ready to keep going CU I don't want you to get behind seriously seriously yeah yeah good all right next up help next up Professional Services providers uh it is recommended the Board of Education designate the following firm firms to provide Professional Services to the school district uh for legal tles and Teague law Miller Johnson and TR trun Law Firm financial advisor pfm and meter Investments auditing firm yo andyo certified public accountants architectural firm gmbb Architects and engineers and construction management uh Owen Ames
011Kimble or O A can I get a motion still moved support discussion so Raj yes let's talk about a couple of these items number one gmbb so you gave a board update October MH that you were going out for an RFP we we talked about going out for an RFP and we did a board update that said that we decided to go out uh in the spring um to do that that will give give the um our bond projects time to uh be for the most part completed we have the transportation department and the uh diesel uh tech building that are being constructed right now um and we want to make sure that those um are completed we have notified gmbb that will be going out for bid uh in the springtime um just think
012it's a cleaner time to do that um to to take that opportunity to do that that time so GMB has been the architectural firm for how many years long time for me and I've been here 10 yeah so my I'm I'm fine with most everybody else on this list have a problem with gmbb in the fact that every construction projects we have done over these many years have been with gmbb and we never and I understand we we put them here I don't want to keep them here and set them up for easily winning the RFP so my assumption is you would do a fair process but I just want it to be known that it's they just don't get an in and I'm not saying that they would but them being on this sheet
013there's a percentage in my mind that they they're the front runner in the RSP process we've been very clear with gmbb that we'll be going out um forbid to do that so we'll you know I I mean right now there are architectural firms they're a big part of the project that we're doing the bond that we're completing I think they've done an amazing job with our facilities um so I don't have a knock against them but at the same time I do think it you know it's it's been a while and it makes sense to go out for bid so we'll do that in the springtime just curious Bob why why gmbb and not o Oak also is there no Oak is on my list I'm going one at a time so anything that's longterm
014standing you would like to have it re reevaluated and not just a you're you know this District over time has seen Errors By architectural firms and the high school whether or not they own up to the errors that they seem to make um and the one thing that's that really sticks in my craw with regard to gmbb is the issue we had when we added on the new gym the fitness center and the stairs to Nowhere the doorways and their perspective is we saw it as a as a district we saw it and we should have said something to them they are the experts they're the ones that made the mistake so there are other law or other architectural firms that we've used in the past that have made a mistake and depends on the
015uh this very Verity of the mistake as to whether or not uh they were retained so mhm they didn't step up as easily as I would have liked them to do they weren't as stand up as I wanted them to be they get a lot of money as our provider in that area and I just want that's that's what sticks in my Crow with regard to Owens Ames Kimble so they started out I learned something back when we did the the boiler project um and what I didn't know at the time until after the meeting is that they have a contract with us I don't I've never known that I don't think anybody else on this board knew that that we have a contract with them a service contract or an agreement to some degree
016so I guess as a followup to the information that we're seeing here is I would love the board and if if the whole board doesn't want it at least I want to see it is I would love to see a copy of each one of these agreements because as stewards of the of the district I want to know it I'm going to give you a perfect example when we did that boiler approval in the past up until this one our staff have handled the install we're not doing that so we're Outsourcing all that budgets are getting tighter hey you know what we got a huge budget but I still think we have to have that conservative Edge into how we're spending our money and the fact that Fred had stated that he's uncomfortable with that
017well he he can be he's he's the guy directing it but I always thought we had capable staff that could do it I mean everything's got to be inspected but I'm just wondering why we're not utilizing our maintenance team as effectively as we can and then I'm just going to add one more piece to this if if Administration truly believes that Oak we're going to lean against them and they've provided great service for us overall I mean the admin would know that not the board correct and if that's the case in the role that they're doing do we need somebody do we need somebody like Fred or can just should is Oak do we all that work can we do more managers I'm not looking for an answer tonight it's just I never knew there
018was a service contract so I'm trying to put all my reflection into that that I've done on these things may I ask how far back it was that staff was doing that work do you remember when every other every other boiler replacement that I've ever known of so we had staff in boiler business kind of thing like they knew what they were yeah managing you know and I know we've lost some that they have done the majority of the work that is not true and you're right you wouldn't know okay and we would know and I I'll tell you these two companies have done a phenomenal job here and saved us a lot of money during those times and if we can't do something having a service with them helps us get something done for
019a lot lot cheaper than finding somebody else out there to do it they're they're experts in it they they day in and day out their reputations are very strong in this area and I you know going out for a bid is not a problem I think that's fair but at the same time you know you're how you are communicating in my mind is saying that they haven't done a great job for this district and if they haven't then that's on me and that's on our administrative team because we work with each group day in and day out and if if that's what you believe that's what you truly believe then I guess you don't trust our decision um of you know when we're working with them because we'd be the first to tell you if
020we didn't think it was good that's not where I'm going with that at all well I I think sure sounded like it it's not well how long has Oak how long has Oak been part of this long before I've been here and there in a lot of districts and rightfully so because they have a great reputation and do we ever my my whole thing is do we ever go out for bid do we I mean did did anyone else on this board know that we have a service contract with them I did because I helped put in gardening and all that other stuff and I had to work with o so you knew there was a service C I did okay many years I just thought we approve that here that that was part of
021what we were doing you know allowing for service contracts as needed and that was just because you approve them here doesn't mean if you go out for bid you're locked in with them but they are right now gmbb is our architectural firm Oak is our construction manager and they've done a great job I I I stand I stand behind you know what that's great here's the thing though you talked about going out for bid but then you started saying what they didn't do right I know for a fact there's a pool at the high school that they weren't a part of that we're dealing with right now still that's been there since the high school was built yeah I'm not saying that I you okay you're putting a specific project out there Roger you just
022did though stairs to Nowhere they were in charge they were they is the same okay let's go back on history since you've already stated that with regard to the high school who was the architectural firm of record at that time for what for the high school when it was built 30 years ago I don't know I know they put a pool on the second floor and I know we're dealing with so where I'm trying to take that is you're you're you you took an extreme example I'm not trying to take an extreme example I'm taking an example of what gmbb one of the projects they did for us the errors that were made how they addressed them and at least how the board felt at the time that they addressed them and they have remained
023the architectural firm of choice because that's what this is yeah an interesting I mean I've mentioned it to you before Roger but an interesting metric to just judge how well they do I mean or it's would be the whole overall package as if CU on all of our projects we allow I think it's a 10 we have to allow a 10% over contingency how much of that do we use I mean if we depends right sometimes we use all of it depends on what you run into sometimes yeah so if you Quantified that if you Quantified that and said you know we use this much of it and and this is the reasons why is it's because our Administration or somebody messed up or it's GMB messed up or it's just couldn't couldn't have known
024it's conditions I mean look at Excavating alone you can run into things and have no idea and it can cost you a whole lot more money I think both companies have done a great job I'm not saying that they didn't at looking out for us well I hope not because youve you've you've approved them for nine years in a row and now we're on our 10th and you never asked for a bid before I I believe I've questioned GMB for many years not saying we should if you were to go back if we were to record it and you go back I mentioned g i I think I think at the end of the day though I mean we're going out for bid in the spring right right we're going up for a business spring
025that that satisfies what you're looking for it doesn't change for this year but it helps get them through the construction pro project they have right now I mean I think we all can admit if you change a contractor if you change a group Midstream I mean that's really that's a lot of turmoil and if we go out there and get a new bid and someone else comes up forward that that satisfies what we're looking for right I think it satisfies your concern and if we go out and get new bids what what would be future projects that you would see coming forward is that like roofs and sinking fund type things future bonds whatever you might might do yeah and I'm thinking in this year or maybe in the next two years well right now
026we're mainly working on the bond and the sinking fund stuff so it's it's that stuff that we're involved in yes okay where they you needed Architecture Firm to figure okay and and they're in I mean deep in the middle of it right now of course that's why it makes more sense to go in the spring and like I said we did notify them notified them was it October or November how you remember when we notified G it have early November late October yeah we notified gmbb that we'd be going out for bid in the spring so if you like us to do that with Oak we can do the same thing that that's not a problem we can certainly do it I don't have a problem with going out for bid I have a problem
027with talking about going out for bid and then for a lack of a better term badmouthing the two companies about what they didn't do right when they have worked with us when things haven't been right you wouldn't know that we would know that because we deal with them on a weekly basis and if something's not right how are you going to fix it what are you going to do I understand that and again I'm just going to reiterate my statements okay let we gra to gmbb I've mentioned my dis pleasure with them over this particular meeting for many years for Oak when we went over the the boiler situation Rob's connection and you I I don't have any issue with Oak's work it's how close they were working with Fred and I did not know
028that our staff wasn't more involved this to me was the first time that that had occurred and my me my discussions even during the meeting and after the meeting with them tied to my statement so that's where I'm taking this is you know open be open to some ideas of this is the time we talk about these I mean we do it once a year this is when I'm talking about it and you've never done it in nine years yes I have not at this time yes I have I disagree Rog I have one question if if you can go back on YouTube for last year once don't you check it out it's there I just say like our company is in the role of like GMB and a lot of stuff and we definitely
029I know in our role we bring a lot of efficiencies to our customers yeah so that's just something that it's not uncommon for organizations of size to have service contracts um especially too when you look at overall staff right we we've reduced overall staff whether it be in our you know uh Landscaping whether it be in a lot in our custodial staff we've outsourced and and done a lot of that type of thing and I can't imagine that our maintenance staff is any different because things have got more complicated it's just the way it goes I mean how common are you said a lot in the schools you see service agreements right like they don't hold positions any or if we don't have the if we don't have the in-depth expertise that some things require
030I mean you're dealing with hundreds thousands of kids and people you want to make sure it's right and if your people have the expertise you have your people do it and yeah it gets inspected we're not going to I mean we're not going to say well hey just do everything because we know that would be costly we're good stewards of the money and when you say we're not I mean you you basically are saying we're not when you say that and I take that personally I really do never said that well you might not have meant it but it's how I took it well I'm sorry you took it that way I think expertise is one thing but also bandwidth is another because if we remember the situation it was Fred was also working on
031the he was doing the dryer um I think it was was it the shop wood shop or what was it the coil thing yes yes he was doing another project the time so it became a bandwidth issue right CU you don't have the ability to run five six different projects at once sometimes you do have to Outsource some of those and that's what I think that's what to me they picked and shoes and said Yep this one I feel comfortable with this one hey it's probably better for an outside firm to handle but I think he's Frank Frank said he could learn it if you give him you know a year or so to right yeah get a skills up but you know again is that really worth where we want him to be we
032want him to be in these other right no projects and I have to say been in many many buildings and Fred is all over this District working very very hard on many projects so I think that that is not his like we said it's not his expertise and he is currently an amazing an amazing head of Maintenance Raj can I ask one question sure of all those firms that are up there you told gmbb already that they're you're going out for bid yes obviously we're happy with the others that are up there have you notified any of those other firms that you're going to go out to bed or not nope okay cuz we're just completely happy with everything they're doing it was mentioned earlier by Bob that he thought we should go out for
033bid that's fair to me it's been a long time it was before me I mean these two were here before that that's fair I'm referring to the rest of the rest of them on the list up there not just those too I'm sorry I was talking like yo and yo and Neer all those none of those are going out for b no because Bob doesn't want them to that's what it feels like to me Bob you're deciding whether what goes out to bed and I don't think that's fair well clarification have voice have a chance to say something too like I don't want that did those words come out of my mouth Barb yes you said I want EXA no no let's order okay make sure we're taking I think need to be careful of
034you're accusing I am saying that you have a lot of influence and that none of us have known that there's a bid being asked for why isn't that brought to the board for a discussion whether we want one well we did we did we discussed brought to the board Barb was I at that me yes you were and did we vote on it no Roger just told us what he was going to do okay yeah cuz it just feels like it's one more step that maybe weren't planning on because you said so we have to now do it that's what it looks like to me now maybe other folks knew yes you know but it just seems like you're pushing that and I don't really toally know why but if they think it's good then
035okay but it should be a board decision and not a bob decision I I don't think we have an ironclad rule um that says hey we should every x amount of years go out for bid on certain things and maybe that's we have we develop something where we say hey every three years it's good to at least go out for bid on these things maybe it's every six years it's for this thing and just you know it's not an ironclad rule it's not something we put down but it's a a way we kind of operate because I I think you're right I think there is always value in going out every now and then just to see you know what's out there there's nothing wrong with that and then sometimes sometimes we've done that and
036I going to always use this one Bob because one of the first things we talked about when I was on the board was the Landscaping group and sometimes we go out for bid we find that group that has been the incumbent is a little bit more expensive but you know what they've done a a good job for us and we kept them it was only like 40 bucks a year but we said you know what there's no reason to change you know we've gone on for the bids we've got these other groups and there's no reason for us to change um so but I think it is valuable to do that every now and then and like I said we can meet with the administration to say hey which groups does it make more sense
037for there are some like yo and yo right that know us right and uh you know it may make sense to keep them for a while um there's other group suggesting that everyone go through a process not every year not every year but we kind of maybe we sit and come up with the plan because I do think it is worthwhile doesn't mean we have to change no and but it does make sense to to see what else is out there and see what other sorry what other services other groups can offer Sally had a comment yes well my my only question was if there are problems that you have with any of these groups that you're working with do you feel as the administrators that things are usually worked out in a way that
038is advantageous to the district and we wouldn't be recommending them if they were okay so my question and Bob is like what would you expect if there's an error that you see how would you expect them because it sounded like to me and correct me if I'm wrong that you were dissatisfied with how they reacted to what you thought was wrong like the Staircase to Nowhere so um how would you expect any group to respond to the dissatisfaction with that that it would be satisfactory in your eye because I feel like in your mind's rubric something's not check in for you when issues were brought with regard to that the the issues it was brought to the board and my my whole thing is be standup just be a standup company if the eror is
039noted agree and correct and in this situation initially they did not they threw the blame on the district and because of that they why do we have these here they are our experts so when the expert that you've hired tells you well you approved it wait a minute you have to then then explain to me what I approved because you're the expert is everyone here reading blueprints their group did something wrong admitted fix it and move on we are a public organization and we're accountable they need to be accountable because they're now working with a public organization so our public wouldn't stand for I'm going to bring it right back to the pool 30 years ago that that was shoddy work we have had lawsuits and we have dealt with issues over and over and
040over we've broughten attorneys into play we have soed them over many things that have occurred in this District just be stand up and do the right thing if you do then we don't need attorneys but not everybody is and when they do it leaves a sour taste and do you feel like it it was dealt with eventually I mean in in the way that it was remedial no I actually don't don't I think we've accepted what they did but I don't think we received a discount or we received any any uh feedback for the errors that were made when was that project completed the one we're talking about 12 years ago no it no it wasere 2013 and 2017 yeah I was here I was here on the tail end of that b I just
041I'm just trying to understand some of those things were brought up I I can tell you and I'm going to go back to something you said earlier we wouldn't know our administrators would I can tell you both of these companies have done a fabulous job working with us when their issues they have saved us money along the way on several things there are some things that yeah you go you know uh we've got you know this isn't right we've got to do something with and we I mean we had something recently that that happened uh at the middle school when it was being built they worked with us we found a way we made it happen they've been very good at doing that I can't speak with what for what happened be I mean I
042caught the tail end of that Bond um but I do know during my time that I've been here going into my you know I'm in my middle of my 10th year the both companies have been great in working with us in those areas so I mean we've gotten awards from it some of it yeah you I know them might mean nothing but I feel like at least you know we're being they're being recognized in the business for their work but I don't have a problem going off for a bid okay I I just want I want that to be clear I'm not upset he's asking for bid I'm upset because I take the other stuff very personal as a superintendent and I you know our people work very hard with these two companies and it
043to me if if you know uh some of the things that were said just aren't that they're more of an attack on us I look at than the company I don't think on purpose but we take great pride in what our facilities look like in the work that we've put in to make sure this community has outstanding facilities for our kids because we've been very blessed that they have passed bonds and sinking funds for us okay any other discussion let's move forward can I get a motion It's Already Done um just a vote all those in favor yes opposed motion passes all right is recommended the Board of Education approve the attached schedule for Schoolboard meetings for 2025 that designates meetings to be conducted on the 1st and third Monday of each month unless otherwise
044noted all meetings will begin at 700 p.m. will be held in the Board Room of the administration building unless otherwise posted can I get a motion support any discussion look good to me all right good all those in favor yes o osed motion passes board compensation um it is recommended the Board of Education approved compensation to board members has permitted by law to receive $30 per meeting uh payable in two installments the first half being paid in January or before in the second half in July this is this is consistent with the past practice over the last several years can I get a motion so move support any discussion good to me all those in favor yes opposed all right designation of depositories um it is recommended the Board of Education designate 53d Huntington bank
045and Lake Mission Credit Union as the depositories for school district accounts deposits and Investments may be placed at other institutions uh consistent with board policy 3203 deposits and 3204 investment of funds can I get a motion so moved support any discussion all right uh all those in favor yes opposed motion passes electronic funds transfers an electronic transfer officer is recommended the Board of Education adopt the attached resolution authorizing the school district to participate in electronic fund transfers it is further recommended that the Board of Education designate Heather rosowski assistant superintendent of Business Services as the electronic transfer officer and authorized agent to complete such electronic fund transactions on behalf of the board can I get a motion so support supported okay did I get your name right all right Perfect all right there we go
046not too bad all right uh um all those in favor yes yes opposed motion passes designation of signatures as recommended the Board of Education doign its signatures for the various accounts as follows the capital projects funds the board president vice president secretary treasure and Chief Financial Officer 105 other accounts board treasur or Chief Financial Officer uh one of two uh Debt Service board treasur or financial officer uh one of two and the contracts and agreements board president vice president secretary superintendent Chief Financial Officer uh one of the six can I get a motion so moved support any discussion all those in favor yes yes opposed motion passes authorization of president to appoint liaison assignments is recommended the Board of Education authorize the board president to appoint board members to Liaison positions with various organizations in
047the Granville uh Parks and Recreation board can I get a motion support any discussion all right all those in favor yes opposed motion passes all right okay that's all we have for now so we'll adjourn this meeting and we'll come right back here after we need a five minute break nope anybody okay good to go okay all right did you need something