001my pleasure to welcome you to the organizational and regular Board of Education meeting for calonia Community Schools on this January 27th 2025 and if you all would please rise to say plce I pled alce to the flag of the United States of America to the Republic for it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all can we have call rber Garcia here Rando here Collins here eich here con here Morris here Nichol here great thank you it's good to see everyone welcome um we are going to start with um our uh fourth agenda item here which is our election of officers for 2025 and after we elect our new president then we will have that person take us through the rest of the meeting so um with that said we will
002open a call for nominations for president I'd like to nominate Tim Morris president thank you second second thank you I humbly accept that thank you okay Ka roll call B Garcia yes Rand yes Collins yes eich no con yes Morris yes Nicholls yes all right so that motion carries and we now have a new President congratulations Tim thank you abolutely I will now turn it over to you for the rest of our officer elections thank you trustee Brittney um next uh order of business is 4B Vice President are there nominations for vice president I'd like to nominate John Brando for vice president of the Board of Education I'll second that all those in favor of John Brando call the r Kat Barbara Garcia yes Rando yes Collins yes eich yes con yes Morris yes Nicholls
003yes congratulations Mr Brando on to item 4 C which is the nomination for secretary are the nominations for secretary I Nate Casey ISAC who the secretary ISAC is you're fine okay sorry second Madam Secretary you can call the roll call Bar Garcia yes Rando yes Collins yes eich yes con yes Morris yes Nichols yes congratulations on to item 4D the office of treasur I nominate Britney Barbara Garcia for Treasure I'd suck at that thank you Mr brand happy to accept thank you very much and we may call the RO rer Garcia yes brandal yes Collins yes eich yes con yes Morris yes Nichols yes great congratul ulation officers and thank you for your support with uh with this position we're going to move on to item five recognition Mr superintendent yeah so uh on your
004table there you have a uh just a small token of appreciation I know that uh for two of you this is brand new and so uh we appreciate you being willing toh step forward and serve the community and our children in this uh capacity and for the rest of you thank you for all you've done over the last well two or four or more years Tim I've lost track how many that is but uh we we appreciate all the time and effort you put in and uh it's sometimes can be a thankless job we know and uh people um you receive all sorts of uh instructive criticism but um just appreciate all that you do so just a small token of our appreciation for you great thank you I I do want to pause for
005a minute here and and uh reach out to those who have public comment tonight there's cards out there and about and if there are any can they be collected here before with Cy over here back here she can collect those number six item number six student representative do we have a student represent we were notified that the student represent wasn't able to be here okay and we'll move on to item seven public comment is there any public comment tonight seeing none we'll move to item eight consent agenda includes December 16's regular board meeting minutes December 16's Clos session minutes December 24 payables January 2025 Personnel report anticipated overnight trip for 2025 legal firms that may be retained as needed Clark Hill PLC I didn't get that could you try again trying to silence this one
006more time Miller Johnson SN Kaminsky kisy sorry true law authorized the superintendent associate assistant superintendent and chief pH Financial Officer or their Des designes to sign checks contracts agreements and purchase orders and item H authorize the Chief Financial Officer or their design as a District's electronic transfer officer and I authorize a superintendent design to assume specific responsibilities of the board secretary I move that the board approve the consent agenda as presented second any discussion we'll call the RO Barber Garcia yes Rand yes Collins yes eich yes con yes Morris yes Nicholls yes thank you on to item nine superintendent report all right there will be a few items here uh tonight first of all I want to start with the uh construction update and so um we'll begin with the uh activity at the pool
007it's uh making great progress we have water in the pool uh all of our pumps are running uh we have had uh some of the final inspections and uh so we are going to meet tomorrow and uh hopefully be able to determine a opening date uh for when we're going to be able to open to the public we have a few punch list items to still work through and a couple of remaining uh inspections but all things are looking great and we're getting very very excited about that so watch for um updates coming out in the very near future on when that uh when that opening date will be we're intending to have a ribbon cutting and um I have an openhouse opportunities for the public uh before the facility goes into full operation uh
008under y and our um calonia Resource Center um Mr hes would like to make a comment just wanted to add to about the pool before we got too far off we received our eagle pool licensure this late this afternoon so eagle of the state of Michigan has put their stamp approval on the pool so that's a huge step y yes another great step forward exactly so we're very excited and uh it's almost here and will be also a relief I have to say um uh new Dutton continues uh really making great progress and um so for the board I think it would be wonderful if we get you back into uh the new Dutton facility just so that you can take a tour and see uh the latest work in there for two board members
009to get your first opportunity to get in there and um so we are working with Chrisman and based on what our uh decisions are tonight on like committee meetings and this sort of thing we will look for a date when that might work to pair up uh with a future board meeting and uh have you be able to tour that so uh great work uh happening there at new Dutton and then of course the stadium too um being outdoors they are working uh here through the winter and and um so it's making good progress we got a lot of footings in walls should start to rise here uh in the very near future at uh another good meeting with the township today uh regarding some water M things that we're going to need to work
010on there and so that continues to move forward well and then we are now turning our attention to the next projects on the horizon authorized by the voters and that's our fields at callex and uh work at dunan Middle School um and we've been working on those already and we're continuing to try and push that forward so that we can get to uh some bidding here in a few months time so great progress and uh very exciting things to see in construction um in other items then a couple of other things that I just wanted to pass along to you first of all Mr hess uh handed us this thing a short time ago and that is that um Consumers Energy has uh given us an energy rebate check uh for this past year of
011nearly $42,000 41,9 so uh thank you Mr hes for your work in filing all that stuff and getting that uh approved and getting 42 Grand back in the coffers so thank you for that um had an opportunity for a couple of wonderful uh activities here this weekend on Friday afternoon uh our corals uh were a featured group at the Statewide Michigan Music Conference there were only four groups selected to participate in the coral hour uh at that event and uh so congratulations to uh Miss Stevens and the corers they had a wonderful performance uh I was privileged to be able to be down there and uh to see them in action so that was wonderful as was uh the performance by our calonia youth theater of Beauty and the Beast Jor so uh don't know
012if any of you were able to go but that was also terrific and just really thank all all the staff who worked so hard to pull that off I think the number was 138 2nd through sixth graders uh were in the cast so if you can imagine the logistical work to make that happen it's uh remarkable um and then the other thing that I wanted to uh give you an update on and give you an overview of is uh we will be talking in a little bit about the non-homestead uh millage renewal and so I wanted to provide you with a little bit of background information and uh for The public's benefit here tonight too so that we uh just wanted to go through a few things uh for you here so well let me
013all that okay so um we are coming up upon the time where our non-homestead millage needs to be um renewed and I need to turn on the clicker like Christy told me to do and I forgot um so in order to do that I just want to give you a little bit of background on this so um in the calonia schools budget we have a number of actual subf funds under that it's not just one budget but many and the primary one we're going to talk about here is general fund we're not going to dive into any of the others but you know when we come around to budget approval time we actually do talk about all these different funds so within the general fund um a big big part of that general fund comes
014from uh our foundation allowance the foundation allowance is an amount that re we receive on a per pupil basis and that's something that um the state of Michigan says this is your amount that you're going to get in every school district uh across the state of Michigan it's kind of their guaranteed number from the state of Michigan and for the current year that we are in 2425 and actually it was also the number for last year that number is 9608 per people $968 uh per student so for us in calonia when you multiply that out you got our number of students uh which we have full-time equivalent students just over 5,000 students times at 9 9608 uh we are over $48 million of our Revenue comes in through the foundation allowance and that amounts to
015approximately 68% of all of our general fund revenues that includes federal government stuff other local I mean it's it's a big number 68% okay so when we look at the foundation allowance this is impacted by our non-homestead millage the foundation allowance we get money from a blend of both state money money coming from the state of Michigan and our local money okay that local money is calculated on a district byd district basis to get to that 9608 and it's done by looking at the non-homestead property in the district so when they do this they look at the taxable value of all the property in the district homesteads and non-homestead so non-homestead includes of course business property and um second homes and so they will look at that total taxable value and then from there they
016will determine how much uh non-homestead taxable value we have and that will serve as the local portion of what counts toward our foundation allowance so of that $48 million that we're getting a chunk of it is generated here locally on non-homestead property okay then what the state says is the state port they will backfill to get to the total okay and I'll show you a couple examples here right now so this is our most recent uh state aid report uh for this past month we get revenue from the state each month uh we get actually only 11 of the 12 months but uh so on this state aid report you can see right here in the red box uh this is what we're guaranteed per student our foundation is 9608 per year uh then down
017here in this lower red box is where they figure out how much local revenue is going to be and if you look at the total there assumed local Revenue it's over $16 million so out of our 48 million in Foundation allowance over 16 million of that is generated locally on our non-homestead property and uh on another piece so you see the two lines above so our non it says non pre TV um that's the non-homestead taxable value okay okay and you can see the amount of that taxable value within the calonia district is 869 million then times the 18 Mills is the amount of Revenue that's expected to be generated from that okay the second line is a different kind of stuff called personal property that's like Machinery within factories and stuff there's a separate
018taxation on that you can see that's at six Ms that's not what we're talking about here tonight we're talking about the first line the uh 18 Ms okay so that's the amount that we're we're talking about here when we talk about non-homestead property tax here up in the upper right is that's that number of our students on a full-time equivalent basis and then down at the bottom that last uh Red Box on the left at the bottom this is when they figure all that out and they divide that out out of that 9608 the amount that's coming locally they are assuming we will be collecting 3236 point uh 62 okay now how does that rank how does that compare with any other districts I wanted to show you this is just a little bit of
019a comparison okay so the blue bar part of the bar everybody you see here goes out to 9608 right the blue plus the paint goes out to 9608 the blue portion uh that is the part that's being generated locally so we often think of East Grand Rapids I think it's thought of in a certain way but you can see that East Grand Rapids actually locally generates very little non-homestead value right because most of their value is homesteads okay they have very little of the non-homestead property and you can see how that progresses on Down the Line This is not all of Kent ISD and I also threw in Wayland as a neighbor of ours just so you could see for comparison how those things lay out and then you see where we are uh down
020toward the bottom in all of K ISD there are only two districts that generate more locally than us it's Grand Rapids and then the one that generates the most I didn't have on this CU they aren't a direct neighbor of ours is Kena Hills and they are slightly over $5,000 per student but you can see non-homestead property is very very valuable to calonia and of course where is most of that located it's in general up near and north of M6 right is where a lot of that non-homestead property value is situated for us okay so that's kind of how that plays out and so there you can see it's roughly 2/3 oneir for US one3 logal two3 state backfield to get to the 9608 so state law requires that districts Levy 18 Ms on their
021local non-homestead property when this was all set up it was set up under proposal a back in 1994 they didn't want districts to um kind of Sher this non-homestead part so that they would backfill the entire portion of the 9608 they wanted to make sure that all districts tax themselves in this non-homestead property so this was the arrangement they made that you must Levy 18 Ms or you will forfeit a portion of your foundation allowance and also the 18 Ms is the maximum that can be levied locally okay so we forfeit the corresponding amount if we don't Levy all 18 Ms and that can happen really in one of two ways either a non-homestead operating millage question fails and in that case you have none you have zero and so in our case as you
022saw we would lose a third of our foundation allows okay or it can also uh fall under 18 Ms because of Headley reductions and so I just wanted to run through that real quickly because some people uh we've been dealing with Headley for a long time now in the state of Michigan but it still can be somewhat difficult to understand so the Headley Amendment dating back to 1978 really is saying that if a governmental entity's property values as a whole rise at a rate that's greater than inflation there must be a reduction on their tax collections called a Headly roll back so this means that yes local individual properties can go up by that amount and you don't see an increase in your taxable value Beyond inflation but it also means that as new property
023are built within the district right and new subdivisions are built or new factories are built the district's total property values can also not rise at higher than the rate of inflation so in other words that's our limit is the rate of inflation and if they rise at greater than that rate if you're at 18 Ms you have to move that rate down so that the net product at the end of that math problem remains at that rate of inflation right so if we go up higher than the rate of inflation you got to bring the Mills down so that it stays at the rate of inflation make sense this a little mathy okay so I'm getting glazed over looks no I'm just going to keep moving forward so therefore if we if we have that
024happen to us it ends up forfeiting we end up having to Forfeit some of our Revenue um in our foundation allowance so that has impacted calonia in the relatively recent past so here as you see on this slide in 201819 that H situation happened to us our overall property values increased by greater than the rate of inflation and so our Mills our 18 Mills were reduced by 01548 that lost about $71,500 in Revenue there in 201819 the following year it happened again and in fact we're reduced by a higher number and then that was added to the previous reduction from the previous year so it reduced that year Alone by 02053 total then was 3609 that we lost that caused a loss of $186,200 in Revenue that's that's real money right so that led um
025the school district and School Board to go and ask the voters uh to approve an extra uh amount um so not only to renew the non-homestead property tax they were right at the situation we are now the previous authorization was at the end of its 5 years so they had to go back and asked for 5 years additional plus they asked for an additional 1.8 Ms to serve as a cushion to put above that um that renewal to help guard against future headle reductions and we'll show you how that works okay in just a second there has been a millage reduction for calonia schools in six out of the last seven years because of our growth okay so here's what that has looked like so going back I I did the past 10 years um
026going back to 25 uh 2015 16 16 17 17 18 we were right able to Levy at that 18 Mills because that's what we were authorized and there was no Headly roll back okay at that point our district property values were not increasing faster than the rate of inflation but then in 1819 you can see that's where we had that first thing kick in and we lost that $71,400 of Revenue and then the next year was drawn down further 186 200 okay then in uh when that millage was passed you can see the net result there are two things to look at first of all do you see the purple bar remained the same okay it did not go down that year we actually would have reduced but because we went to the voters and
027asked for the renewal it was renewed at the same amount so kind of overrode that reduction for that year because the voters said no you can renew it at that same level notice though it didn't get pushed back up to 18 it was at that same level because it was called a renewal okay and then on top you see the yellow plus the kind of greeny yellow parts that together represents the 1.8 Ms of additional cushion that was there so that put us up again over the 18 Ms now remember the state says all you can ever Levy is 18 Ms that's the red line going across okay so even though voters gave us more authorization that's all we could Levy and that's all we can ever Levy is 18 okay the next year in
028uh 20 2122 you can see we chewed that down because again there was another Headly rollback and the same thing for the next year in 2022 23 another Headly roll back okay if you look at 23 24 however do you notice the purple stayed the same you see that the purple from 22 23 to 23 24 stayed the same and if you think about that time period coming out of covid we had super high inflation right so for that year we did not have a Headly reduction because inflation was so high our property values were still going up but they weren't going up at a rate faster than inflation okay so that year stayed flat and then this current year we have had again a small reduction not at the same level as some of
029the others because again I would say it's probably because inflation was still somewhat High High okay but it continues of course to uh kind of go back to pre-co Lev levels so as we come into considering um action tonight um the thing we need to try and do is to project what uh the future is going to look like right and what the Headly impact will be so I ran a few numbers for you and I wanted to share those with you the inflation that we've seen following the pandemic um you know is this has made this a bit difficult because especially the last two years are not what I would call typical from an inflationary standpoint where we've been for much of the last you know quarter Century probably but at the same time
030we know that our property values in calonia and the Grand Rapids metro area are continuing to increase uh even while inflation is slowing and on top of that we see all the new development Happening Here in calonia so I think it's almost a guarantee that we will see a Headly roll back again this year and really for each of the years in the first SE future so we have have to I think kind of take that into account so what number do we use so um from a projection standpoint the numbers I ran kind of throughout the last two years of this OD inflationary cycle and looked at the five prior to that so for 18 uh 19 up through 22 23 and the way this is done they calculate a millage reduction fraction that's
031what they multiply by your number of Mills to get you uh to where you need to be so to calculate this we have we use an average there of those 5 years or 9865 and that gave us this chart so a couple things about this chart um the first thing I want to point out is that do you see how we're looking at 20 24 25 is our current year and then what it would be next year in 2526 okay notice that the purple Remains the Same because just like happened five years ago if the voters approve the non-homestead millage we will it will be a renewal at the exact same rate so that purple bar carries across and then for the next four years beyond that I applied that sort of average uh reduction
032that you saw there and you can see that it whittles everything away um so we are in a little bit of a question and in fact I worry about particularly these last two years if we see larger headle reductions than we have seen and I think it's quite possible given the increasing property values that we've had uh we could well be in these last two years back into a situation where we are losing Revenue um due to these Headly rollbacks okay so I wanted to give that to you it's I think a fairly uh I think it's a very fair uh projection I think it could be worse or it could be better but we don't really know so trying to kind of shoot through there so um as I said we may run out
033of cushion before the end of the next 5 year and they're just projections so they may be an Interac both to the good and the bad so just as a couple of reminders then we have to Levy the 18 if we don't we forfeit the difference and also just another reminder that all Homestead Property that gets taxed at the State education tax that's six Ms that does not have anything to do with this that is money that goes from the taxpayers to the state of Michigan and the state uses that to help out with their uh education budget uh obligations okay so we can ask for a range of years we've typically done five years and part of why that's done is because we bear the cost of this election and that election um we
034don't have the exact amount yet but the estimate is it probably would run around $330,000 to conduct that election so so we don't want to be going out every year uh to do it and um so what we have uh suggested um is we have two real avenues for um that we prepare for you to consider we can go in different directions than this too but these are the two that we've considered based on our past uh history and that is um when we get to this item on the action items uh we have proposed 5year uh renewal uh for you to take U to authorized to take to the voters and there are two options for you to consider option one is renewing it at the current Headly reduced amount so in other words
035that would not add any cushion back and would not reset us to the 18 as you saw in that chart I was showing you with those assumptions we might get to the end of the five years or we might not option two is that we can renew plus as for an increase to the cushion and this is uh allowed for us to ask on the same question in other words it doesn't have to be two questions on the bout it's one question where we can ask for up to 5.5 Ms of increase when renewing uh on the same ballot question and so that wording was in the materials that were sent to you um that is going to be our recommendation uh to you as the board uh that we do that we think that
036that will enable us to get through the five years I I think it will be pretty close uh but that will enable us to get through um the 5 years without seeing a loss in Revenue I think it's a possibility and I would say I'm worried about a loss of Revenue if we uh go with option one okay so there's that chart again uh and this that's where you can see now if you add a half mill on those bars it get it would get us hopefully through that period until the next 5year renewal would come up in uh um early okay all right there's the reminders and disclaimers Homestead Properties un affected this is only for non-homestead and the max we can ever authorize is 18 or we can ever Levy is 18 okay
037any questions on any of that I know again we're this is a thing we're having to kind of do without as much discussion as we would have liked had we had committee meetings this month but uh that's why I want to spend a little more time to kind of go through this make sure everybody's on the same page thank you Derk I'm glad you did there's a lot of information especially for new board members and even even seasoned board members it's a good refresher to to know what what this all involves and in operating the district's budget um moving on uh item 10 discussion item board consideration 2025 regular board meeting schedule yeah so um this also will be considered tonight and uh just uh we laid out some dates for you on a uh
038tenative board meeting schedule of course any of these can be uh altered but uh the basic idea behind it was to pattern just like we have done in the past uh at least couple of years is my understanding for me it's only one year but um so in other words next month uh we would also not be on the third Monday because of midwinter break uh being on that third Monday so that would put the February date is February 24th uh then we would have a long string of them where we would have uh be on the 3D uh Monday but then in July we have typically also push that one back and so that one is on this calendar as July 28th or the 4th Monday again and the reasoning behind that is uh
039because we are coming into the start of school and um the third Monday in August is when we're actually in session and so we have Personnel related things that sometimes need to be taken care of and we have a better idea there on July 28th than we might on July 21st and it just gets us that much closer um to that August start of school and we are uh we are required to have a meeting a month on our schedule so uh that's that and then the rest of the year would again be at the third Monday so just based on past that's we prepared for you uh to consider tonight great thank you moving on to number 11 action items a authorized financial institutions I will move that the board authorize the use of
040United Bank Fifth Third Bank and Michigan liquid asset fund plus is there second second second and discussion um oh sorry I'm goingon to recuse myself um from voting on the authorization of the financial institutions for 2025 due to my employment with fif Third Bank um although the contracts predate my board election and there is no conflict of interest in the policy um that I read I want to avoid any appearance of any impropriety at this point you certainly have every right to to do that thank you for bringing that up tonight any other questions comments okay please call the RO brandow yes Barber Garcia yes Collins yes eich yes Morris yes Nicholls yes motion passes on to 11b 2025 board meeting schedule I move that the board adopt the 20125 regular schedule as proposed second
041any discussion G work okay for everyone better than most I'll a vote please Robert Garcia yes Collins yes Brando yes Nichols yes clone yes Morris yes eich yes motion passes on to item 11 C resolution calling non Homestead millage renewal election May 2025 in this uh motion we do have to make the motion with option one or option two is there a motion I move that the board adopt the option two resolution calling for a special election on May 6 2025 there a second second discussion any more discussion I should say I see none we call the vote please e yes Barbara Garcia yes brand yes Collins yes con yes Nichols yes Morris yes motion passes option two on to number 12 discussion items board considerations item a school bus purchase Mr H good evening
042uh okay uh before we jump into a couple of first reads I just want to share that uh as board appreciation month is here uh the staff and obviously the leadership of operations and transportation do appreciate everything that you guys do for us and you do for the district and uh I wish to thank you as well so uh a couple of and I want to say the same thing um I'm sorry I have my hat on but I've had it on all day so I have hat hair so um but I was not able to make it here last month to um for the last one the last two board members to leave but I want to welcome you guys here and um I'm grateful to be here and look forward to having a
043conversation about our school buses and my welcome comes with a couple new hard hats for you so it's exciting it's exciting so this evening we have uh first reading of uh the proposal for the purchase of school buses and vans School transportation vehicles um this is kind of an interesting one um as it spans multiple budgets multiple budget sources um so we're try to break it down as easy as possible um we are recommending the purchase of four school buses um in that four that is um three that are full 77 passenger school buses and one 47 passenger special needs vehicle with a lift U as a wheelchair bus um and two uh Vans currently in the this proposal uh the vans that we use are used for a lot of small p uh small
044trips uh small what's the word I'm looking for small use items they are 8 to 10 passenger vans we transport the golf team occasionally the Bing team occasionally a smaller ski group we also transport some of our students to some of the nonlocal programs kctc um up at the IST and other things of that nature so they serve a variety of P purposes they are predominantly used for athletic though um I would say the vast majority of their use goes to athletic use um we do currently have five vans in our Fleet um there were a couple questions that came up um on the way to this um and I've answered one by attaching a full spreadsheet of our current bus fleet um you'll see that in the as an attachment now to the uh
045to the document um and it also identifies the three buses that we would like to be moved off the fleet and into um auction pardon me that's how we dispose the buses um this year um a good news that auction buses are going for a higher price so we're getting more return value um unfortunately a $124,000 investment in a new school bus um gets us $3,000 at the other end when they go out of the fleet so 3 to $4,000 right now so U but actually that is more than usual more than we have been getting uh so the inventory is there uh a question was asked about the use of the word spare in the report um we use the word spare because that's a state word um and they use that in the
046their reporting of school buses think of this as a substitute substitute teacher um we have a bus that's in in for repairs we need to have a number of buses in the fleet that are able to back them up able to get out on the road at a you know either a moment's notice or planned um and be ready to go to serve to back up the regular Fleet um the state has a general rule of thumb that says one for 10 um we tend in calonia to run a little higher than that um mostly just because of our rural environment um we don't have a lot of the dirt roads but that certainly does contribute to some of our challenges here um so we have traditionally run a little bit higher in our spare
047count um appropriately so and we do have um nine smaller buses I say smaller they range anywhere from uh 24 to 47 passengers 54 passengers uh for special needs use uh we do do a lot of miles of special needs transportation in calonia we're really proud of the abilities and the fleet that we've generated to transport a great number of special needs students safely uh and again we do have five Vans three of those vans are currently uh one is a 2010 two of them are 2011's I'll be adding that to the Future report here um and all three of those are while not as high mileage as one of our newer ones they are all showing their age um I think you can think of a 2010 van 14 years old on the road
048um it's starting to look its age it's starting to have a definite rust problems definite suspension problems and uh we'd like to keep those kids safe for those longer road trips that we take with those vans um out of the district um beyond that I think that pretty much sums it up uh we're looking like I said some of these are going to come from current budget the Vans uh because they're available they're in stock um usually a 45 day delivery date um is out there um and then we are looking at three excuse me the school buses for delivery in the 2526 school year uh we have moved we have a bond line item for school buses um however we've discussed as in the past we've done this we've purchased them from general fund
049to keep that Bond money safe and looking forward into other areas and against the future possibility of needing more buses for that um a third question was raised regarding the insurance costs on buses we do have a pretty substantial blanket policy obviously covering the fleet of 54 plus the Vans uh plus any other school Vehicles we own including uh maintenance trucks plow truck and things like that so the impact of three or four new vehicles um is not significant as we take off older vehicles some of our insurance costs are actually higher on older vehicles because of the chance of us having an issue so um it pretty much balances out as we grow the fleet just a little bit um this purchase will grow the fleet by one regular head bus just something moving
050us forward um into um looking at our number of kids we're transporting looking at the number of routes looking at the way we're dividing up schools uh we're building in some future potential future planning into the program any questions questions anyone a lot yeah just a couple um uh remind me when were the most recent buses delivered I remember last time or are we still waiting we we we literally took delivery in November de November okay that was the ones that were purchased last year in February thank you that was my question trying to find it in my they take a while to get here yeah for sure okay and so these will be delivered in the fall this this year yes that is correct 2025 thank you what is the typical longevity of like
051you guys are on a you guys are on a renewal or a program that you want to continue to get new buses what does that look like is it every 10 years 12 years what do it look like well we're currently moving uh couple of 28s out of the fleet okay so they are math in my head 14 16 years old 10 to 15 years is is pretty much a good life ex toy for a school bus um there that's about as much as we can expect um I am proud of the fact that we generally run 15 years here um very few surprises that we've had a any go out faster than that uh one of the ones on the list is going out faster than it was involved in an accident um almost
052two years ago now um and it it just has issues that are Beyond coste Effectiveness to repair so we're moving that one out early but nonetheless but yeah we try to aim for that 15year Mark and we do pretty well with it okay another question um do we always buy new instead of use is that just something we've always done or occasionally we have purchased a few off leas buses uh buses that come off of short-term leases from other districts they do experience more repair issues um they are generally not specified in the way that we would build a bus um they're good and they have been remarkably you know an effective solution currently and for the past several years there are very precious few Off Lease buses available um the leasing program availability just
053vaporized um with the economy and covid and other things so districts were holding on to them just buying them off their own leases so there's very little of that available thank you and buying a used bus would mean buying one that somebody else has put out for 12 years so that's really not worth it yeah scary just uh as an additional note uh School Bus fleets get inspected every year um and um so it there's a lot of work that goes into maintaining them uh if there's rust and so on that all has to be addressed and so the older a bus gets the more it takes to get that bus up to uh being able to still be Road worthy and uh so that's where I I agree that 10 to 15E window is
054typical very typical I would only add uh another piece of the puzzle here if you are looking at the spec sheets uh with the price comparisons that are available we use the uh msbo bus purchasing program just put in your specs you put in your needs and the bus companies go to work and give you a price we are not necessarily buying the cheapest bus they're very close price um and they're very close um I think the lowest cost we're getting is on our Special Needs Bus our 77 passengers May cost a little more however these buses are of the same make and model of the buses we own um to move to a different manufacturer at this point would be very cost prohibitive it would have to be a very planned long changeover moment
055with uh no a lot of surprise costs as we retool and bring other Parts and Equipment into the garage to repair them um just when I was looking through the spec sheet there is a added it looks like not insurance but a warranty looks like there's warrant an added warranty on the one that you're also proposing where the other ones did not have the warranty correct no they do so as yes so sorry well I've only been here two years so I would say in the two years we have added warranty um but I know the previous four buses that came in did have have that warranty added on into them okay thank you and I also know that we've been updating some of our technology on our buses and so are these buses being
056equipped with that on frontend oh yes um yes these are coming uh some parts will be added afterwards we'll do the camera systems we'll do the uh the GPS and the stuff that we were adding um as a side note if you have seen one of last year's buses out on the road you cannot mistake the difference they are they glow um the amount of reflective and the Ford school bus on the front is llit up and the safety levels that we are adding and growing in our Fleet thanks to michelita are terrific um in my first 20 years I honestly did not see much growth in that and there wasn't very much in the industry and there has been recently and um michelita is certainly taking advantage of the opportunities there to get us
057definitely safer Fleet Jennifer I guess just to kind of piggyback off of that with the new cameras and things that we've added are we able to remove I mean those are brand new cameras on on the buses we're trying will we be able to reuse that Hardware moving it over absolutely buying new licenses and yep n everything we strip them well before they go out I see we have roughly looks like 920 what are we doing are we going to get hit in two years with buying nine new buses or what are we doing we are we are trying to spread that out part of that you see in picking up one extra now um and trying to spread that out we don't like those bubbles um they are a hardship and they're they're not
058a good thing to face right that's the difficulty sometimes if you do purchase through Bond issues you end up with a big bubble right and then that's all well and good at the moment but over time that really causes you problems with sequencing and how you're going to deal with that so that's where getting a soft Landing so to speak and getting past that bubble point is going to be important so we as you could tell we're nearing that life expectancy on those buses so that's where this really comes into play there's other things if you you know you pad them with more and maybe you move a few of those into substitute roles a little sooner so that they last longer so we can spread that out spread out that bubble over time perfect
059thank you any other questions okay seeing none we'll move on to 12b bond 2023 Paris Ridge playr back to you Mr all right one of the 2023 Bond categories is dedicated to playground improvements at Paris Ridge Elementary um as you may recall over the 2020 Bond we've been doing playground enhancements at emmans Lake uh Paris uh excuse me Kettle Lake and uh cell um and we wrap up with Kettle Lake this coming spring um and we would like to introduce the next one in the row um at Paris Ridge the good news um Paris ridges equipment Paris ridges playground items are probably uh without using a word are they are significantly better from the word go the purchases that were done when we built that building were at a level that were absolutely a much
060higher quality of playground equipment because of that we really don't have to replace much of the hardware of the equipment at this point our biggest interest is replacing What's called the playground safety surfacing we are for years the standard has been the wood chips the wood chips the wood chips um unfortunately wood chips are good they're not the best and they are also not um in any way shape or form um special ed compliant we want our playgrounds to become more inclusive the number one way to make a playground more inclusive is to make the ground something that you can use in all forms of physical handicap um so what we would like to do is as we move forward we're transforming and we're going to be start to have more playground with more of
061a firm surface the playground safety surfacing that we're looking to replace here is called poured in place Paris Ridge does have some port in place um it's a a crescent shape around each one and then it's supplemented with a lot of wood chips U we're going to tear looking to tear all that out and suck out all the wood chips clean it up and put more port in place in there um it's a firmer surface um but it is still absolutely compliant for the fall height uh for all the the dangerous things that we're doing out there on the playground the fun things we're doing out there on the playground um we looking to add a few minor events to that playground um uh some of the options that they are looking at have been
062included um as a link on that one document they're looking to add a rope climber they just don't know which one they want yet um so they're hoping to make that decision this week um couple of the Rope climbers that they're talking about adding will put them over budget U but their PTO is talking about stepping up um to help U fund the playground renewal um so that's exciting so I'm hoping they decide to get something cool I kind of like the Vista star three that one that's my favorite personally uh we have done a few minor things out there we removed an old spinner um that the secretaries actually brought to my attention this year um by the end of September they had already filled out a substantial part of the spreadsheet they were
063keeping with injuries um from the old Spinners so we got that right out of there um and took care of that safety challenge um but they'd like to put in a new different spinner to help them out and they'd like to add some things and we want to obviously add that playground safety surface so um this would come through um Sinclair Recreation game time equipment um this is what we've been using in all of the new upgrades um and it is an Omnia uh purchasing Cooperative purchase any questions thank you thank you moving down to 12C 2025 technology Bond projects Mr V good evening um been battling the cold for the last week so I'm hoping the cough doesn't interject itself in here but um we'll see how far I get uh the report you
064have before you um includes several different um technology projects they're all Bond funded projects some come out of the 2020 Bond so those are the very end of the technology things in that bond issue the others are getting a start on the 2023 um bond issue uh we released the RFP in mid December uh January 17 we held a bid opening here and we did have great turnout for that uh there were several biders for each category so we're very pleased with that there are very a number of very good options for us to choose from uh we are currently um conducting postfit interviews uh we did some last week and we will finish those up this week uh so we don't have numbers to share with you this evening um but we will come
065back uh at the next month's committee meeting and the board meeting with with those numbers for for your hopeful approval uh the first project in that packet is the replacement of all of the copy machines in the district uh those devices were all purchased as part of a bond project in 2017 um they are again nearing their um some are already at the end of their life as we um got a request from the high school this week to please help us do something so we move things around so we can get um printers within um acceptable use of teachers and there their duties so they they are at the end of their life um Unfortunately they don't have um plus lives um they're 5 to seven years and they're um sadly have less value
066than a used School Bus does um so um the new units will purchase um we've asked for an extended warranty um which will include all of the toner and pieces and parts to keep them functional um hopefully for another six years is what we're targeting with these and we have asked vendors to provide a fixed guaranteed cost um for the copies for the life of that um device and we're also purchasing with that warranty um a number of copies up front with copers you're paying for not only the device itself but your ongoing cost are the cost per copy which is the toner and all the parts and labor and stuff to keep them running so um questions on that piece I don't know if we want to take questions on each section of this
067bid or wait till the end I can do either go ahead okay uh the next one is the paging system at the high school north campus uh the paging system that is in there now is the original analog system that went in with that building um we have been working to upgrade all of the paging systems in all of our buildings this is the last one that is still operating on a purely analog system so this will bring the building up to all the common standards that we have throughout the building the last one we did last summer was uh emans Lake um south campus at the high school already has a digital system though it is somewhat different than what the rest of the building is that one would be addressed um at some
068point during the 2023 Bond um project and after that the classroom instructional technology uh this is the first of three phases where we will go into each and every classroom in the district and replace the pieces in Parts the instructional pieces that the teachers use on a daily basis so that includes the projector the amplifier which in this new set of equipment will also include voice amplification that or a pendant microphone around their neck if they choose which will amplify their voice over the speakers in the classroom that the computer audio and um sound from multimedia presentations they use we'll go over that so it'll make that easier for them to be heard by all of the students uh phase one of this will include Cal L the e CC emans Lake and Paris Ridge
069and we'll do a similar number of buildings um in the subsequent years two and three of that and finally um there's a low voltage structured cabling portion of that vid document that went out uh the classroom instructional technology as well as the paging system at the high school requires data cabling to be run to support the devices that were we're putting in there and not all vendors that might provide AV services do structured cabling themselves so that's why we break it out and do the cabling separately there are some companies that have submitted bids for both categories um but this does allow us to pick best of breed um if there are advantages using separate contractors so those are the four categories that we're looking to do this summer questions any questions we'll be voting
070on this and the other previous four three sorry next month of the way it looks correct all right and I would be remiss if I didn't also thank the board for your um support of everything that we do here in calonia it is very much appreciated uh by those of us behind the scenes um Co thank you thank you on to 12d School of Choice resolution right uh also uh for consideration next month will be the schools of choice uh resolution this is an annual authorization and um the attachment that you see is the same one that we've essentially used over the last several years uh there are two pieces to schools of choice there's what's called Section 105 that's within the county so that's within Kent County the Kent ISD so including TK and
071then there is what's called 105c and that's uh for uh school district for students who are residents outside of uh the Kent ISD so um there are three things on that particular resolution if you've taken a look at it there's a resolution to opt out of 105c which we can do either opting in or opting out we uh have historically in Kent County opted out of Section 105 and used instead the Kent County plan which is the second uh item there so we would be opting out of 105 and into the Kent County plan uh if we choose to continue what we've been doing and then the final one down at the bottom um is the consideration of 105c the uh outside of the county um the district has done different things through the years
072but for the last few years has opted out of uh section 105c so we can discuss this more at the committee meeting just to give you a heads up that's what's coming and that's what those different things relate to any questions okay moving on to number 13 board comments we have uh a question as to whether we're going to maintain the committee as a whole moving forward so I I kind of want to get everyone's feedback to see if we're on that same ground or if we want to choose another Direction so I'll open it up I personally appreciate the committee of the whole structure with the board meeting to follow um for me it's been good this year to kind of have the opportunity to hear um from what would have been at least
073in my experience I know not everyone had this experience but what would have been previously presented in maybe one committee but not the other it's just given an opportunity to kind of hear all the things that are going to come to presentation to the board um in a timely manner and I feel like by the time I get here I usually have heard it two or three times or i' I've heard it at the committee and then we maybe heard it in a presentation here as well as had it in the board notes I feel very well prepared um by the time I get here so that's just my personal experience I'm in favor of keeping our current structure or most recent structure iess I agree with Britney on that I like the the committee
074as a whole yeah I I I would agree that um I definitely didn't appreciate the separate committees because I think that it made it slower for communication and then our poor administrative staff sometimes having to repeat presentations over and over so I really think that the committee of a whole uh I do appreciate I don't know if it would be possible to do that that instead of like every other week having a meeting if we had the community of the whole the week prior so that they were consecutive weeks um I think that there would be some advantage to that just being able to um have them closer to one another I don't know if that would be potentially consideration I I too agree I think the committee as a whole is a good use
075of everyone's time I don't feel like I'm not getting the information or the disc discussion that I think is important to making decisions on behalf of the community so I'm I'm good with it sounds like uh now Sean and and Jessica you have not experienced this you you've seen it I think as a community member um but I I think that's the direction we're going to want to we're going to want to go um I hate to be a naysayer I appreciate the committee of the whole essentially so that it is not wasting our Administration and our cabinets time that they're not doing the presentation twice however the issue that I have raised multiple times at Committee of the whole is if we're not going to utilize it and actually have the discussions and we
076kind of Blindside our cabinet so that they can't be prepared in the public meetings then I think it is still wasting everyone's time and we're just basically having two meetings like a week apart where we get to have the agenda read to us so if we can have discussions in good faith I support Committee of the whole if not then I think it takes time on my life and our administrators have to stay later everyone else has a life too thank you are there any other board comments so it would be helpful for us if we can land on a how we going to do this so we heard a suggestion um from for us from a scheduling standpoint I think we need to um we' love to hear from you on how you want
077to schedule this at least the February one and then we can at the February one talk about the rest if we want to do it that way can I hear from you as a representative of the rest of the cabinet about what you would think of of J's proposal I'm not inherently opposed but I'm just curious how that would be for you guys to structure uh preparation of the agendas and if that's giving you enough time to no I I think it's actually advantageous the closer that you get to the regular board meeting uh the more um the agenda will have come together and um so I I think there is advantage to that as a whole and I I'll look to other would you agree or disagree on that darl Michelle what do you
078think about the week before rather than like two weeks before I think we've done that in the past so it's not I think the week before is also also more where the Rhythm was when we were doing separate committees that was in that week before as well so I think that makes a lot of sense I just have a question of being new um let's say we decided uh not even decided but we discussed some items at that meeting but then maybe we say hey can you get us more information on that so the concern I have is we have now we have a week though to get the information and and divest that and there's not all I'm asking is is a we going to be too short of a time span to get
079the information we need to to make the final decision great question the way that I think the flow worked and you guys speak into it as well as I but what I think is good is as we talk about like right now tonight we were talking about February right so at February we're going to start talking about March so the first committee the whole in February right before that meeting will be will also give you the first preview potentially at what's coming in March now there are always things that add okay but that so that's part of it and I know we sometimes we don't go as much in depth in March perhap for the March stuff in February because we don't want to go through this all four times with you but uh it's
080just all part of informing the community having you have an apple time to uh consider things and all so that's really the idea behind it I think so that if we if we go along that lines for February we'd be looking at the week of the 17th of February um the winter midwinter break which is midwinter break but um you know if we go toward the end of that week that's not an issue I don't think for us uh administratively how about for the board uh so you'd say the meeting on the 20th we did we do Wednesdays last time Wednesdays so that would be the 19th or we could do the 20th either would be okay from my point of view what about the other board members work okay I do think Wednesday's work
081pretty well because it does give us a little more time to turn things around like Jessica was talking about from Wednesday to Monday the later we get in that week before it does get more problematic so at least for this where we're coming back from winter break to do it at Wednesday and then maybe there we discuss when we're going to do it from there on M it sounds like we've landed on the 19th that works and moving on in into March do we want to keep with that same Wednesday and as needed adjust I personally think a Cadence is nice it's a little easier to plan on so so then we would always go to the Wednesday prior to the board meeting even when they are pushed earlier or later in the month it'll
082be the Wednesday prior to the board meeting on the schedule we just approved that's the way I'm feeling we're going perfect sounds good D does that work for staff yeah I think that's good and then we'll so what we'll do is we'll put together that list of dates of what that looks like for you just to confirm we're all on the same page and that we aren't running into some other thing that we're not foreseeing right now uh like spring break or something like that we have to think through some of that but uh we'll bringing this to you at the committee meeting make sure we're all thank you now are there other board comments I have a comment really quick um first I just want to thank everybody for um putting your trust in
083me uh to be on the board of education um very excited to um be in this capacity and really looking forward to working all of you guys on the board I've had the opportunity to talk each to each one of you guys and I think uh we have a really good thing going and I think we're going to really try and make our schools better than they've ever been so I'm just really excited to serve and just wanted to thank everybody for um putting their trust in me so thank you anyone else move on to item 14 which is ajour is there a motion to adjourn so moved second all those in favor I post your adjourned