CorpusRecord 122771

December Regular Board Meeting 121624

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Caledonia Community Schools
Date
2024-12-18
Location
Kent County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
7,637 words · about 43 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001all right good evening everyone we're going to call to order this regular board meeting for calonia Community Schools December 16th if you all rise for the pledge Ali to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you just a couple quick housekeeping items if you are here for public comment public comment does tend to creep up pretty fast we do ask that you fill up one of these cards it does ask for contact information this is a meeting of the board that's held in public so there is not a back and forth with public if you do have a question or things that need followup that will come from an appropriate administr administrator after the meeting

002um in the near future so if you please fill one of those out and get it back in the back corner of the room to Kelly Clark she will get those up here to us all right could we please have roll call yes Arbor Garcia here Rando here eich Morris here Nichols sidu here white here just as a note for other board members I did receive a message from Jennifer Nichols who stated something came up with a child that she needed to be at with and Katie is still dealing with sickness and fevers in their house so we hope they are all well soon we are going to move on to recognition thank you you go first perf all right um so we just wanted to take a moment um on behalf of the entire

003board of education for the calonia community schools to thank both our board president Marcy white and our board Treasurer Jason suu uh for their excellent and numerous years of service to calonia Community Schools as board members as many of you probably know Marcy has been serving on the board of education for 14 years and Jason has been serving for six years so you have a combined 20 years of board experience sitting up here just in two individuals and I'm very mindful of um not only the uh institutional memory you hold and all of the leadership and um mentorship you've shown all of us um but also the guidance uh with skill and with dedication with transparency with communication to all um that has really been a guiding force for for all of us here on

004the board so um we've put together a gift from the rest of the Board of Education and I'm happy to let everyone speak if they would like but I just wanted to say a few words on behalf of all of us uh to really thank you for your mentorship for your service for your dedication um for bettering the education of all students in our district for for thinking of all families in our district and for being really um mindful that that's what we're here to do every day so thank you for that uh always appreciate you thank you I I can't say that it's not emotional I didn't think it'd be emotional really it has been a long time it has been a complete blessing to um work with all of you and to serve

005alongside each one of you um on multiple occasions for some so I do appreciate that it has just we've given a lot of our time both Jason and I have through through many things um my kids I asked them I said what are what are some of the things that I've done over the last you know years why we where you were in school and here and they started listing off ridiculous things I'm like okay these these things are not things we're putting down so but it has been time um my kids have there was a lot of things I missed out on over years to make sure that this became my priority um and and it was worth every minute of it so I just want to say thank you because without all of

006you this would not have been here so it it has been a great experience so thank you very much and I wish you all a merry Christmas thank you for being here to support us all the way along and I will continue to stay involved in whatever ways that I can on the other side of this so thank you that's why she's the president so I can Echo a lot of what she said but it's it's been a great uh six years it's been challenging in a lot of ways and it's been rewarding in a lot of ways um made some great friendships and relationships along the board table here um along with the staff and and other people that I've gotten to know so I wouldn't have traded the last six years for anything

007and I'm looking forward to seeing my oldest kid go off to well not looking forward to but it's coming whether I want to going off to college next year um and the youngest one a couple years after that so turn this over to a new generation that I know will um you know keep us going so thanks so as Britney um grabs these things for these two I just wanted to list off a few of the things so we're going to start with Jason so as Jason mentioned he and his wife Crystal they've got a senior and a sophomore who are involved in choir dance theater and a whole bunch of other things during their time middle school and high school and so here's some of the things Jason's done he's been a key Communicator

008he was on the uh participant in the interview process for Dr Martin he's done fundraising helped build a replacement playet out at Kettle Lake for their playground um he's been a watchdog out there a caloo is a volunteer a March reader in the classroom a youth sports coach uh help start and fund the calonia dance team as a club support uh rais money for the choir program fundraising efforts through uh Butcher Block social worked in concessions volunteering and then you've been vice president and treasurer of the board and um I just have to say Jason too I appreciate that uh you make lots of motions so that's always nice you're always willing to read the long list and that's always a challenge uh but I'm really um just really grateful that you're so driven to

009make things better and uh that you provide your perspective on a number of topics and you're always trying to think ahead uh to the next things and asking questions and that's really helpful because it's you know like they always say the iron sharpens iron and uh the questions are important and for us to uh be able to get to the best possible thing that we can be as a school organization so I really appreciate and just thank you for that uh opportunity to work with you here for the last year and a half now so and then Marcy you've got a similar list and so these are some of the things that I know your kids were probably talking about you're a classroom volunteer a book fair coordinator a Junior Achievement instructor volunteer at career

010day a student Mentor at craft Meadows you've been on the PTO at various buildings you sixth grade Camp nurse which that was probably one of the bigger challenges a key Communicator Sports rep for athletic boosters you've managed concessions you've coordinated family tailgates you've been on the senior all night Party Committee uh Bond project growth committees um you parent and also we look forward to seeing you soon as a grandparent um and then yeah this time on the board where you've been vice president and president since 2017 and as you mentioned uh the last time I was here you were president and um appreciated your support at that time and uh that's what was a big part of me and you know courage to come back again so um yeah and with the board too your

011the road cleanup work the concession St work night all those sorts of things so um public may not always know but uh the board and superintendent in our relationship um you know we try to work together as a team on things and for me as a superintendent uh the first person you go to is the president and um you know I've worked with a few through the years but I just have to say Marcy our relationship's been uh fabulous and uh really appreciate your uh straightforwardness and your thinking of all again different sides of uh issues and where a whole variety of folks would be coming from and that perspective has been very helpful and uh um just really um cherished our time together so hate to see you go but U we know there'll

012be great things ahead for you too so thank you very much appreciate it I just want to say a few words here too if I may um it's been uh a a great time interesting time serving with both of you um Marcy you've been the longest serving president as long as I've been a board member and that's 12 years and thank you for your 14 and six years service to both of you we've had a lot on the table we've been through a lot um we've seen a number of bonds we've seen a number of contract negotiations we've seen some resignations but nonetheless I you're still friends and um we're we're serving the community the best we can right and I want to thank you for that thank you Tim we good everybody good all

013right thank you all right we are going to move forward with board business so before we get to there we we're going to start with our student representative we have Aon um NVA okay there we go I I spent so much time thinking about it so your your replacement coming in that you will introduce to everybody and we we welcome both of you thank you for being here yes so thank you too first of all for all that you have done for the community um so narva Kumar will be um your new student representative for the rest of the year after this so yeah that'll be that um so in late October our music department had an incredible opportunity to travel to an arber to witness a performance by the Berlin philarmonic the department staff

014enjoys working together to provide unique educational experiences for all of the dedicated students with 130 students and 30 chaperon in attendance this event was truly memorable in addition our CHS choir is performing tonight at 700 as well as our band performing tomorrow at 700 the student council is running our annual adoptive family Drive the school is helping 13 local families in need providing food clothing and personal care these donations will be picked up Tuesday Wednesday and Thursday of this week the theme for capturing kids Hearts this month is community so it has been a great way to bring the community of the high school together to help struggling families during the holidays and this year we have received more donations than the last so it was great to see all of them and yeah NVA

015is here and have a Merry Christmas and thank you guys thank you Merry Christmas to you you are welcome to stay we love to have you stay but we do understand if you have other things that are of interest to you tonight so thank you at this time we're going to move into our public comment if you didn't get that card turned in I ask that you have it turned in now to uh Kelly Clark in the back of the room otherwise we have first up is jet you do have three minutes to speak to the board as a whole followed by Bob and then Katie uh thank you very much for hearing me and everyone else tonight uh my name is jet black I'm a senior at at calonia High School uh and I'm

016here tonight to bring to your attention an issue uh taking place at our high school with the virtual learning program uh for context I started uh with the virtual program this semester um I found it to be very helpful with pacing myself uh but unfortunately this uh past week Friday uh December 13th I was informed that I would be required to stop the stop taking school this way and return in person because I was not meeting the attendance policy um unfortunately and the reason that I'm here today is that um this policy that requires you to be there for six hours per week um was not taking into account the fact that I have gone in on Thursdays Thursday was canceled because of inclement weather and unfortunately I wasn't able to fulfill my duties that

017week and the next day I was informed that I was no longer able to do this program it was not what I wanted to hear and I definitely wanted to find a solution so I have reached out to the director of the virtual learning program my counseler as well as the principal and have not been able to come to a solution which is why I'm here tonight uh I feel that I've exhausted the rest of my options um I think of myself as kind of a model student that's what I try to be um I've maintained good behavior and good grades through the virtual program a current weighted GPA of 4 .17 I have no issues with my academics simply this one issue with the snow day has caused me to unfortunately uh be pushed

018back to either in person or I was informed that if I would like to continue online learning that I would have to transfer to a different School uh this isn't what I want I feel that this way of learning has been you know this is my style of learning it's been the most successful semester of my high school career up to the this point and so I felt it necessary to come here and speak to you guys today inform you guys of this issue because this isn't something I want to lose and it isn't something I would want other people uh you know to have to face either so thank you guys very much uh that's all thank you next we have Bob followed by Katie I'll just pass that's okay okay are you sure

019yep I'll bring it up a later date okay all right thank you Katie hello I'm here on behalf of the calonia Education Association with only a few short weeks of school in the month of December our teachers and students have been hard at work not only have our students continued rocking it with mid-year benchmark assessments such as aadience and I ready but they've also had time to add in Holiday activities that have brought a lot of joy into our schools from dress up days to selling candy grams to benefit a peer-to-peer group there is a joyful Spirit Alive in calonia schools I'd also like to take a moment to brag about our hardworking Educators at calonia elementary calonia elementary not only acquired all of our young five classrooms this year but they have also had

020the privilege of becoming the new home to a new Elementary autism program they've shifted and adjusted to new staff moving classrooms and changing processes we have 23 CA Educators working hard in calonia Elementary each day and we are thrilled to hear that Cal L was just listed as a top 25 Elementary School in the state of Michigan we are very thankful to all of our CA teachers that worked hard to help put in the many Christmas and holiday concerts over the last few weeks the talent being fostered in our calonia music department is absolutely beautiful and in fact my daughter's kindergarten class got to walk over today and watch the concert practice and she came back and said it was beautiful they're the best singers in the world and she listens to Taylor Swift so

021that's a compliment calonia staff everywhere are looking forward to our annual tradition of raising funds for senior scholarships by wearing comfy attire the week we return from holiday break this comfy clo week will run from January 6th to January 10th and all staff are invited to participate all funds raised will go directly into scholarships for our seniors as with any contract our current calonia teachers three-year contract will expire on July 31st of this year our CA members are currently voting on a bargaining team to represent our calonia bargaining unit this spring we look forward to the future and anticipate many productive and respectful conversations this spring lastly we'd like to Echo our sentiment smoken in November and again earlier in the meeting and thank Marcy white and Jason S for their years of dedication serving

022our community on the board of education with that we wish our entire staff our community our students our neighbors a very merry Christmas and happy holiday season we look forward to The Brighter year ahead in 2025 may you all have a healthy and fulfilling winter break thank you for your time thank you and Merry Christmas to all of you and I hope you all have a restful break you need it at this point I'm sure so all right we are going to move forward to our consent agenda we have November 13 2024 closed session minutes November 18th 2024 meeting minutes December 11th 2024 meeting minutes November 2024 payables and December 2024 Personnel report I move that the Board of Education approve the consent agenda as presented second thank you John are there any questions Corrections

023concerns with those I please have a roll call barber Garcia yes Brando yes Morris yes uh suu yes white yes motion carries thank you we will move to eight which is superintendent report all right we'll begin with a update on student achievement so Dr Diaz come up good evening everyone um this is an update to the presentation that I provided to you all back during the committee of the whole in November so much of the will look familiar there are some um updates that were made for tonight's meeting so there might be a few changes but we'll move through it relatively quickly since we have a choir concert uh that I know some people may want to get with uh to get to this evening so if you do have any questions of course feel

024free to ask either now uh this evening or at a later time so just a reminder the context behind test scores we know that students are constantly assessed whether it's a verbal uh question and answer whether it's just observations in the classroom whether it's a small little exit ticket to check a particular concept or our larger Benchmark and state assessments um we use them for multiple reasons to try to help guide instruction as well as to take a look back and see whether or not what we're doing is working to support all of our students um at any particular age or grade level we have different types of tests Norm referenced and Criterion referenced again Norm referenced Compares our students to other students in the same age um group across either the state or even

025the country and then Criterion referenced have a particular predetermined criteria and it's measuring students against that established criteria so kind of themselves um measuring themselves against that criteria and not necessarily against other students um proficiency is most often the way that we think about or hear about score reporting so many students were proficient or met that proficiency but another really important measure is growth um because particularly for our students who may be uh below proficiency to be able to grow those students um more quickly than a Year's growth in a year's time is really important so being able to kind of look at those growth pieces are also really important so we'll be doing a little bit of that tonight as well as well so I ready uh we use I ready both in reading

026and in math for K8 to look at benchmarking across the year so we look at fall winter and spring scores um at some grade levels there are additional pieces added at different times in the year so you aren't necessarily taking the same assessment or looking at the same set of criteria across the year but there's an expectation that we we are learning new things so it makes sense that we're testing new things but just again for context we're not necessarily testing the exact same things fall winter spring so um take that into consideration starting with reading looking between fall of 23 and spring of 24 so the growth that we see from kindergarten through 7eventh grade from the beginning of the year to the end of the year um those scores um again are very

027strong and we feel good about the work that we're doing but we also recognize that there are students that are not yet meeting standards and so we want to continue to support those students and work to bring those proficiency levels up um to the kindergarten level so look at that 95% of our kindergarteners are meeting Benchmark at the end of the year in Spring of 24 so we'd love to see that level across the grades over time um as I mentioned before looking at growth um when we look at the I ready scores we have both what they call typical growth as well as stretch growth so typical growth for a student is that Year's growth in a year's time stretch growth is what we're looking for students to reach if we are pulling them

028either up from underneath proficiency or for students who are at uh proficiency levels how do we stretch them to even move beyond that grade level rather than just staying stagnant so we look at both that typical and that stretch growth so just kind of a little bit of a graphic to help you understand that a little bit more um the red line solid horizontal line is where you would want the typical growth to be and then the dotted line is where they set the stretch growth targets for students and again depending on where they sit in terms of below grade level on grade level wherever they might be um those are always going to look a little bit different because they're set independently for each student student individually so when we look at reading um

029again 23 24 uh the first bar dark purple bar is uh the percent of students that met their typical growth the second light purple bar is the students that met their stretch growth so the students that met stretch growth are included in the students that met tripical growth because in order to meet stretch growth you have to meet your typical growth first um and then the yellow bar the gold bar is the number or the percent of students excuse me that actually improve their placement and what I mean by that is in I ready students are um categorized across five different bands and when they move across the year the goal obviously is to improve their placement so this is another way of looking at that data at the beginning of the year in the

030fall the first horizontal bar we had 15% of our students in K through fourth grade who were mid or above grade level placement by the end of the year we had 65% of our students that were at Mid or above grade level placement so the goal is to get those two green bars to be higher percentages and the gold pink and red bars to be smaller percentages of students who are one two or three um plus grade levels below this is for fifth sixth and seventh same information in terms of meeting typical growth stretch growth and then improving their placement and looking at it again in this format making that shift to higher levels in the green bars and lower levels in the gold pink and red we also use I ready particularly our winter

031Benchmark to help us plan for support uh in the spring as students prepare for M steps so specifically at third grade and above we're looking at that light purple bar that's our winter I ready Benchmark and we look at that as kind of a um estimation or a projected proficiency on mstep so we look at those um students and where they are kind of falling in I ready and then we create intervention groups and support for students who are not yet meeting that winter Benchmark to try to help really fill in some of those gaps so that they can perform um at a higher level when they do the M step in the spring so just a comparison of where they are with I ready and then the final bar in each grouping is the

032mstep score in the spring switching to math same data sets so here's our spring scores across 2122 22 23 and 23 24 so we have really strong math scores um we actually adopted a new math curriculum in 2020 2021 um and that is ready math and we have seen um really positive results across K8 um using those uh resources this is the growth again we look at typical growth stretch growth and then improved placement in math as well as reading looking at it from a um different perspective this is really exciting data when you're looking at this uh as you're looking back to see the growth that students have made we had only 25% of our students on or above grade level at the beginning of the year and we moved it to uh 81%

033of our students uh at or above grade level by the end of the year and this is K4 all together so really some substantial movement for students um in mathematics this is 5ifth through 7th um again significant changes there increasing in the green bars and reducing in the gold pink and red this is the mstep comparison for math so again you're looking at that light purple bar which is the winter Benchmark to estimate or project proficiency on mstep and again we use that winter um score to help us uh Define our groups for intervention support between winter and mstep testing switching to mstep um M step is a state assessment as you probably are all well aware given annually uh across the grades so looking at mstep reading scores from 21 22 22 23 and

03423 24 from third through seventh grade uh a question was asked asked to add in the ISD comparisons when I did this presentation previously so you will see that the ISD uh bars for 2223 and 2324 are added into the data set um we um traditionally do outscore the ISD and the state um however again although we're very proud of the work that we've done and that we continue to do we also know that we're missing a chunk of students um and really want to continue to focus our efforts on uh bridging and building those skills across all of our students this is an additional chart that I've added in that gives you a little bit um of a different look at the data in terms of kind of the trends so this is our

035Ela passing Trends and the um this the I don't know if they're not dotted lines but the the line graph the first one that you see that is not circled is the grade level Trend so different groups of students year-over-year pretty steady um until you get a little bit higher and then you see some es and flows um again those are year-to-year at a particular grade level different groups of students when you move over to the far right where the red oval is that's cohort data so same group of students across the grades so you can see there are some that you know go up and down and it varies even in their performance with this when you're talking about the same group of students so just a little bit of a different way to

036look at some of the data shifting to mstep math again scores over the years adding in that ISD comparison in mathematics uh scores our lower trending than in ela both at the state BISD and within calonia um again recognizing that we're proud of the work that we're doing and what we've done but recognizing that there are still groups of students that we are missing and want to continue that Focus this is the same added chart that I just went through but this is for math so again the first line graph is different groups of students across multiple years at third grade and so on the far right is cohort data so same group of students over time and then finally shifting to the higher levels PSAT starting at 8th grade and then um in 10th

037and um as well 8th 9th and 10th and then sat data for 11th grade so this is our PSAT reading data for 89 and 10 um which is very strong and um really great to see especially at those grade levels sometimes you see quite a dramatic uh drop off in just kind of investment in test taking for one but um those scores tend to move a little bit in the downward direction as you move into those upper grades so um it's really nice to see these staying stronger again adding in the ISD for this data um our math um I'm sorry our reading PSAT and sat data remains strong um the state and the ISD as you'll see are also quite strong in um across these assessments moving to PSAT math we do not see

038a strong um of data here um particularly as we get into 10th grade we start to see um a pretty significant drop so one of the things we've really been digging into is kind of the why behind that um even including meeting with groups of students at the high school and talking to them about these scores and getting kind of their thoughts on some of the reasons behind the change in the data where we see stronger scores at seventh or eth grade and then 9th 10th 11th we see this significant drop so really trying to get student voice into that conversation as well this is the math comparison for PSAT and sat again including ISD and the state um as you can see the difference in ela performance and math performance is dramatically different um

039but in all places again not just Cal but also we see the reduction at the ISD and the state so looking ahead we're really making intentional efforts to address those decreasing proficiency rates especially at the higher grade levels um and then that buck of students that are not yet meeting proficiency so how do we Bridge those gaps and then also look at how do we take students that are at or above and provide additional opportunities for those students to be successful as well so a continued focus on building relationships we all know we learn better from people that we have strong positive relationships with so really keeping that CK as a foundation uh we're working on our professional learning communities and really building that out and um working through how we can add time into

040our day for that to actually happen intentionally as we look to next year and Beyond and then strengthening our tier one instruction and the work that happens day-to-day in our classrooms and finally strengthening that tier 2 and three interventions so students that might need just a little bit of additional support as well as students that might need more significant intervention support um and that is all through Jed and then looking of course um to students who might need support through specialized instruction and special education questions ahead so you you mentioned in that last slide that the the data is applied to a score Improvement plan with those four categories I don't if we can go back to the slide these here is this where the we're looking at the data and we're applying with the

041that is telling us into a an improvement plan to increase scores so part of it is our broader myip um the Michigan continuous Improvement um plan that is a districtwide plan through the state and then we also of course have our strategic plan and so these goals are embedded in both of those um plans moving forward okay so we we do have a plan to address the areas where our scores need to improve yes we do I I notice with I ready the proficiency is high when you get to kindergarten but we we go down to like 50 some per when we're in seventh grade is that being addressed yes all of it everywhere where we're missing the mark which of course you'd love to say 100% of students will be proficient um I don't

042know that in my lifetime we're going to see 100 students 100% of our students proficient in every grade but that certainly is the work that we're doing is where are we missing you know where are we missing that connection um where is the whole in our resources in our instruction in our interventions we've added some specific intervention supports um at craft and at the high school this year that were not previously in place so we're continuing to look at where we can add additional supports and then work to move students forward okay has has there been any uh teacher feedback on IR already we've been using it for quite some time but is there any are the teachers providing any feedback that might be helpful to addressing Improvement in scores with our kids so since

043I have been here I have not done a specific I ready um survey or gathered specific data from teachers around I ready um what I have heard just through word of mouth is that teachers really like the IR um tools and the my path intervention supports that come along with it um when we adopted ready math and the assessment and resulting than my past supports back in 2020 2021 we did not adopt the ready Ela curriculum um but last year we added in the I ready Benchmark and Ela and the my path intervention supports so that is something that we are in year two of um implementation to support in ela uh we use different curriculums with have CA and my perspectives in K8 um but we are using the I ready Benchmark and my

044path um additional resources so we're looking to watch and monitor how those are also uh impacting student scores great and I do want to thank you for providing the scores of similar districts size and in in the area so it's helpful and getting perspectives as how we compare with our peers in similar areas anybody else we know this is no small task and this is not anything you know the ships don't turn around fast on any of this stuff so we appreciate the work that goes into this and I'm sure our kindergarten PA Pros out there would you know love to move themselves up and continue so but no it's great work so thank you thank you all right bu your first yeah just a few other items uh to update you on uh the

045filter first uh program this is uh legislation that came down uh within the last couple of years and so um we are in the process of implementing and uh the big update for uh you all is that the state uh just within the last few weeks has awarded $50 million in uh grants that came through Federal money that ended up at the state level and um so uh Mr hess uh put in for um a lot of stuff to be utilized in us meeting all the requirements of this program and so we were awarded over $380,000 uh from that and just for context that uh in our entire side of the state that's basically the fifth highest uh amount and uh there's only 25 uh Statewide that got more than that so I just appreciate

046Mr hess's work putting that together and uh they have a lot of work that will be ahead of them uh as all of our uh sources of water in the district will need to be labeled and uh filters for everything that uh is water that could end up being drink drunk drunken drinking and uh maybe I was um so you've been drunk yeah exactly so um anyway just wanted to uh update the board on that um and then another update for you is that um our finance department has been working very very hard um revamping the entire uh computer software uh that we utilize for all of our financial uh stuff and that is a massive massive lift uh we've been on the same system for a long time at this point um and that

047system uh was made end of life and uh not all that long ago they announced that and so uh it has been a real uh heavy lift and uh just want to thank Sarah and her entire team uh three of them were here last week like till 9:00 every night uh trying to get everything together and uh they still have a ways to go but uh they are making it happen and U it was it's been a huge huge huge task um and then beyond that just uh hope you've had an opportunity to um see some of the Great stuff going on and uh we got a lot of concerts and programs and other things that have been going on and our winter sports season is in high gear now so uh it's been fun

048to see and I also think though at the same time everybody's going to be ready for a nice break so a few more days from now and we'll be able to rest up for the next next stretch so that's it for my all right we're going to move forward to nine our action items 9A is Bond 2020 calonia Elementary Remodel and move that the board approve the Chrisman company to initiate contracts for renovation in calonia elementary school from the 2020 bond funds for the following bid categories and amounts work category 21 walls and ceilings from sher's Brothers company 136,137 work category 22 flooring risma Associates 249,796 we category 24 painting eof and Dev re 78995 we're C 28 electrical Excel Electric board meetings before before the action items are items that we have talked about

049on multiple occasions they have been at committee meetings this is not the first time we're seeing it so for if you've never been here before and you're thinking what are these people doing to have no questions and and voting on it that is just not the case so they have been discussed um that is the difference between um potential items that we talk about next month and our action items for this month so all right we'll move on to 9B Bond 2020 Transportation School Bus coverage I move that the board approve the Chrisman company to initiate contracts for the construction of a school bus covering structure from the 2020 bond funds for the following big categories and amounts work Category 2 site work velting Contractors Inc 134,000 work Category 6 Paving Michigan Paving and materials

050$69,500 work category 12 steel Bennett Steel LLC 384 $ 4,640 work category 14 Roofing action custom Roofing ink $99,250 work category 20 General trades DND Building Inc $2,115 work category 24 painting blaste LLC $318 25 work category 28 electrical Excel electrical Inc $280,400 thankk you can I have a second please thank you John any further questions on this maybe just a comment for the community to know that as in uh the calonia elementary remodel uh the transportation slow bus covering we received better bids than we expected so we're able to do more extensive work on the transportation bus covering than we had thought so more for the money that doesn't happen very often it certainly hasn't happened recently so this was very exciting to see this be able to be completed in full so that

051is a great thing so big sigh of relief over there isn't there all right can I have roll call please Rando yes Barbara Garcia yes Morris yes s yes white yes motion carries 9 c bond 2020 community resource center Furnishings I move that the board approve the purchase of office furnishings and installation for the community resource center from kuster office furniture at a total of 35,3 849 I have a second please second thank you any further questions on this all right roll call please Morris yes Brando yes Barbara Garcia yes St do yes FL yes motion carries 9d is 2024-25 budget amendments I move that the board adopt the proposed 2024 2025 budget amendment resolution you have a second please second thank you John any questions on this I think go through it okay Mr

052de to go through a few things on that yes just a quick um overview I know we talked about this at our committee meeting um but looking to uh bring another amended proposed amended budget to the board tonight um to update some things so we're going to look um at what some of the key Revenue swings are so just a refresh um we adopted our initial budget in June and in at that time that was before the state had their adopted budget we were anticipating flat enrollment and we had included a $241 per pupil increase that was based from the governor's budget proposal so at the end of June after we adopted our budget is when the state adopted its budget and there were substantial changes um which typically we don't see such substantial changes

053um so we came back uh also had done some other work um on the budget so we came back in August and amended the budget that um then included a zero Foundation per pupil increase and instead the state had provided a one-time increase through um retirement reimbursements so we included estimates of what that would look like in the August amended budget um so now um looking at this amended budget we now know our fall student count so that is a 19 um FTE increase we also then have received our um state aid um status reports and so we have a better idea what our state allocation will be for um retirement reimbursement so we were able to update that and another um Revenue swing is at the original budgets had estimated our Special Education Act

05418 millage so needed to readjust that to what we're um projected to receive this year another area again in the retirement system so as you know over the last several years we have a requirement to run they call it 147c that's the category where districts are required to funnel through its books the acred unfunded liability um obligations and so we have to pay the state um and then the state reimburses us so really it has a net zero impact on our budget however it's a substantial amount so it does impact our totals um when you're looking at total revenues and total expense so in the 2324 fiscal year that amount was 6.2 million that was running through our books for the 2425 fiscal year that amount the budget um or sorry the state's budget is

055decreasing um what that flow through looks like this year and so now it's 3.3 million so that's a reduction of 2.8 million both on the revenue side and on the expenditure side this year they also are implementing a one-time pass through um separate line items still for the UN acred unfunded liability um and for calonia that is 761,00 that of an increase so that is also both on the expense and the revenue side so the net impact of that is roughly 2.1 million decrease both on the revenue and on the expenditure I know it gets wonky but the numbers are quite large so it plays an impact so I thought it was important to note so overall this is just a summary um First Column is our audited numbers from fiscal year 24 the second

056column is the adopted budget from June to for this fiscal year 25 the middle column was our amended budget in August and then the fourth column is the totals that you're looking at tonight um for our December proposed amendments so with that we're looking at revenues ending at 70.7 million expenditures of 72 million for a 1.3 deficit pulling from fund balance and then our estimated ending fund balance would be 10.7 million or 14.9% of expenditures and that last column is comparing our August amended budget to this December proposed amended budget so our revenues looking to increase by 431,000 expenditures are pretty much flat um they're decreasing by about 19,000 so the overall net impact is um saving us um a reduction in the deficit of 450,000 so are there any questions questions from board members

057say yes here in a second and then I'm run okay all right all right no I think we're good thank you can I please have Brando yes Morris yes s yes Barbara Garcia yes white yes motion carries thank you again Sarah all right we're going to move to 9e which is authorization to issue 2025 School building and site Series 2 and refunding bonds we did talk about these separately but please make note that they are together in the motion all right right all right looks like we Lo lost our [Laughter] reader recommended motion I move the board adopt the resolution authorizing the issuance of the 2025 School building and site bonds series two general obligation unlimited tax and authorizing the refunding of the 2014 Bonds in according to the terms of the resolution thank you

058can I have a second please thank you John are there any further questions on this well let me just provide just a brief bit of context so um it um as we've talked about for a couple of times here now we have two sets of bonds that we're talking about here and uh one set being the final um issuance of bonds that are tied to the 2023 uh Bond uh approval by the voters and then the second part of these is refunding refinancing um the bonds that were sold in 2014 so they've now reached a point at which they can be resold so uh in so doing you hope to bring down that interest rate and save our taxpayers uh significant amount of money um so the way that this is set up is that

059um it will save us a lot of money if we're able to do those two sales together um from all the other Associated things that go on with that so that's why it is one resolution uh for both things but uh as you will note in that resolution they talk about each of the two different sets of bonds separately and again as we've discussed if we do not uh realize a savings of 1 and a half% on our refunding we will not be uh moving forward with that and that is Incorporated in the resolution any additional questions when will we have an idea if I know this is performed in May I'm looking at Sarah but right you want to give the those kind of sequence of what happens yes so we'll have get together

060um our preliminary official statement has a lot of the data um around the district we need to have our then Bond rating call that happens these things will be happening between January and March and April so at that time um before the actual sale itself it's going to probably be within the pricing to see where the market is that day for pricing um so it will go out if if we can't realize the savings at that point um and the pricing is scheduled um for end of April May right around on the 1st of May so our financial advisers are watching the markets through the time and of course by that point they will have our updated Bond rating which we hope will still be very strong and so they'll be seeing where bonds from

061similarly rated uh issuances are going from a percentage rate and so that's where they can make a they can advise us of that point about which direction to go anything further um only that after this if this uh passes you we won't need any additional action on this before that right you not before the bond uh pricing is done um and then the way that this uh process will work is we will be back to you in May uh with the actual confirmation of that sale so um that's the way it kind of works it goes out for pricing investors say yes we will have X number of your bonds and then we come back to you and you approve that ultimate sale so this is just authorizing us to go into this whole project

062thank you we have a roll call please barbert Garcia yes s Brando yes Morris yes right yes motion carries to n okay NE policy second reading adoption recommendation in in motion I move that the board conduct a second reading and adopt immediately the following policies one 0151 organizational meeting 1130 conflict of interest 3110 conflict of interest 31208 employment of personnel and Co extracurricular activities 4110 conflict of interest 5136 personal communication devices 5340 student accidents 5500 student conduct 6110 Grant funds uniform Grant guidance 6111 internal controls 6112 cash management of Grants 6114 cost principles spending federal funds 6325 procurement federal grants and funds 6550 travel payment and reimbursement 7310 disposition of surplus property 74403 small unmanned aircraft systems 7450 property inventory 73 I'm sorry 7530 .02 staff use of personal communication devices 8321 criminal justice information

063security 8760 to delete student accident Insurance 9111 to delete telephone Communications that's all I have a second second thank you any updates you need to give on these I don't think so we've talked about them a few times we have so any questions on them no can I please have roll call Morris yes Brando yes Barbara Garcia yes white yes motion carries at this time we are going to move to 10 which are discussion items these are things that will be anticipated for board consideration as of our January 27th meeting so we have the Strategic plan action steps so just uh brief update for you on that and uh we're certainly open to any comments you want to make now uh we also will return to these uh as we move forward and um continue

064to revise them based on uh input that we receive and then um yeah they'll continue to be our framework uh we adopted that overall IC plan um and then these are the pieces underneath that now that are going to be or steps to take was there any feedback to be given based on the initial you've got something yeah I I think it's pretty easy to not easy but we have a a system in place on how we can track student uh achievement so I think that's that's probably the easiest one out of all of these but the others are they Encompass so much maybe it would be best to ask staff for their recommendation on how these would be evaluated knowing the in workings knowing the information you're compiling and then present that to the

065board for consideration evaluating or benchmarking the Strategic plan items a lot of work has certainly gone into this and so there's obviously more work to be done this is obviously a living document well or certainly should be looked at that way is there's nothing that becomes set in stone right things can always be updated continued to work on throughout the process so um again it was a huge undertaking to get to this point and I think that certainly the um steps that are written down are absolutely in the right direction and going the right way combining the um categories that we're looking at so um certainly additional feedback and certainly as board members if you continue to read through it if there's things that come to mind you know certainly share those don't sit on

066them because the more information you can give and the sooner you know the sooner that happens is more beneficial for the administrative team John did you have anything to share from you're okay all right Britney yeah just one thought um one of the things that would be I really like the overall vision and I like where um a lot of the uh kind of individual um uh goals are I would love to see if we could for each of the um individual kind of goals underneath the larger buckets like what are the indicators right it would be really helpful to see kind of what are we going to be using to determine if we've met that individual goal I'm sure that there are lots of ideas about those things so um it would just be

067great to kind of hear from the rest of um you know the cabinet members you know what are how are they planning to evaluate you know if they've met that uh goal sounds good we will keep uh yeah we'll keep working on it this was just the first draft of these uh just to start getting your eyes on them and so good ideas we keep working all right anything under other items not at this time no the other items is always a sneaky thing you just never know what might pop up under there so short one in January yeah absolutely so any board comments uh just regarding we had talked uh at committee about uh House Bill 6058 there was a lot going on this week I don't know if we've heard anything as of

068today as to where that sits or yeah both the Senate and the house have passed uh similar versions uh each in their own chamber and they've crossed uh to go the other direction so um yeah it's uh not been a ton different than uh what we discussed uh last week at our committee meeting um so uh we are yeah we're watching it very closely it would represent a significant impact on the budget um if it's passed as it currently is written so yeah we have to be very careful moving forward and uh there's also talk well would there be some sort of supplemental budget to help uh cushion the the cost from the state some additional money coming down so hopefully they're aware of the impact on districts when it comes to the health benefit

069premium and um I know probably Friday we'll we'll know a lot more yeah uh that's going to be this week and then currently there are no session days scheduled for after Friday but uh they did add a session day last Friday so they can always do that um it's we'll we'll see how this uh transpires so thank you nobody loves government stuff more than Mr W dryer I think he spends a lot of time on this weite so we appreciate all of that government teacher yeah I know exactly pity of the kids who had me any other board comments well I just wanted to um point out to the board at this point we have no committee meeting scheduled for January um and um we've already shifted that meeting back to the 27th of January

070and uh it would be a little awkward to have a committee meeting given the fact we won't have had our organizational meeting before that and it would be a meeting of seven board members uh without like who's running this thing so um unless uh directed differently at this point we were not anticipating a committee meeting uh for January but um we that's I kind of need to hear if you're thinking differently than that because that's the way at this point I was thinking we would be proceeding so I think that's reasonable given the factors you mentioned and um if we can just stay I know you're awesome about the weekly memos but anything that you would want us to be able to anticipate that we're not already anticipating for the January meeting um in a

071weekly memo would be great yeah yeah I'm okay with yeah hi us on Committee in January yeah and as you can see right now we are not anticipating a ton of things there will be some things that we're anticipating for first reading in January um but at this point we do not have a lengthy agenda planned for you that for now so you good John okay if you decide you want an extra meeting you let us know all right so we are good with all of that um again thank you to all of you for being here for for the time we appreciate it we are um going to go into close session this is one of the times when we go into close session that we do anticipate an action item afterwards um you

072are certainly more than welcome to stay in this room um we will come back to here to for any action item after um our close session you certainly do not have to stay that will um that information will obviously um be posted it will be out there with our our regular meeting stuff as well um but why don't we go ahead and take maybe just a few minute recess for board members before we come back up and vote to go into Clos session all right thank you right we just need a motion to go into close session no you're good yeah you're good you're good okay I mean you can stay but you are welcome to leave but we are going to leave the room whatever you want to do you are good with know

073what to do I move the board meet and close session for per Michigan compiled laws 15268 D for the superintendent's evaluation at the request of the superintendent have a second please thank you can I please have roll call Barbara Garcia yes bro yes moris yes white yes motion carried so we can go into Clos session we can discuss this but we cannot make any decisions in Clos session so we will come back out of closed session do the same voting thing to come out of closed session and then if all goes well we will have a motion for the superintendent evaluation going forward so that's what will happen afterwards but you are welcome to stay or leave whichever you want to do thank you merry Christmas if you're not here thank you how are you

074okay we need a motion to come out of close session please make the motion we come on a close session second thank you can I please have a roll call Barbara Garcia yes bro yes Morris yes light yes motion carried onto 13 which is our anticipated action item superintendent evaluation rating I move that the board accept the superintendent rating of effective support this is for the superintendent 2024 evaluation support thank you that right can we please have a roll call Morris yes Rando yes barbert Garcia yes white yes motion carries congratulations and thank you very much we they will all look forward to we as a District look forward to you staying with us next year so I just need a motion to adjourn I move second thank you all in favor say I I

075the oppose all right thank you everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.