001December 9th 2024 to order please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance followed by a Moment of Silence I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you Madam Secretary please call the role I'll start with our student board memb Sam Cook Alex sner Arabella Stanley here Mr helverson here Mrs Wallace Mrs Waton is absent Dr Borders Mrs Alward I am here Mr Smith here and Mr Bass I am present we have a quum thank you for that and uh my understanding Mr ridway have no modifications to the agenda correct no modification to the agenda okay I will keep it very short on my uh president's remarks uh welcome to all those in
002the audience online happy holidays hope everybody is has a great season of cheer and all that good stuff so um yeah sounds really good doesn't it the way I put it I'd like to congratulate our own Arabella Stanley student board member on your recent signing to Spring Arbor University play golf correct we hope you have a great career and look forward to hearing about your academic and athletic accomplishments any holes in ones yet not yet not yet close season all right at spring over all right if you get any hold one you got to come back and tell us about that too so um lots of winter concerts right now that are coming up so check the website and um look for all the extracurricular activities and with that I will pass it on to
003Mr Ridgeway again Happy Holidays all right I will jump right into the concert so we have three this week actually four if you count the wild BG Elementary so we have our Middle School choir concert tomorrow in the auditorium at 7 the high school choir concert on Wednesday in the auditorium at 7 um the wild park elementary winter vocal concert at wild park uh developmental kindergarten through second grade is at 1:30 if you want to attend and third and fourth grade is at 2:30 in the gymnasium at Wild um and then we also have our uh band and Jazz Band concert on Thursday uh December 12th Middle School robotics will be traveling for the state competition on Friday and Miss Keegan I sent out but they had won the lake view Invitational a few weeks
004ago which qualified them and I talked to some of their coaches and it sounds like they should have won the last one and got third place so they're doing really well in Middle School robotics so good luck we have half days of school in the 19th and 20th for exams as well as professional development for teachers um and the last day before break is the 20th so I wish everybody a great holiday season as we get closer all right thank you for that and just in case every doesn't know our own Dr Borders is it's his last uh meeting again want to thank Dr Borders for his six years of service to the board and um wish him well as he moves into a new house new house new house that that darn Ford plant
005right all right um Madam Secretary do we have any Communications we do we have two donations to make note of Douglas and Michelle Cashman donated $500 to the iron Dam's robotics team and WK Kella company Sabin Brown donated $2,000 to be split between High School band and choir so we accept those with thanks a thank you to those individuals we appreciate their support and and uh move on to student board member report what do we got nothing to report all right we'll move on pres we'll give you a pass since since December uh presentations grow your own update Tammy Chapman I am very excited to bring Tammy Chapman up to the Podium as well as some of her grow your own completers all right good evening um as you may know Harper Creek received $3.6
006million in a grant called grow your own to help our staff go back to school and either earn um an initial endorsement a bachelor's degree and a teaching certificate or add an endorsement um and get a master's degree um since the program launched in Fall of 23 um we had 19 staff members today we have 30 staff members participating to get a degree it's pretty significant um right now we have 10 teachers pursuing a master's degree adding ASD learning disabilities counseling English as a second language um we have two substitute teachers who earned a master's degree that are here with me tonight and we have 18 staff including parapros substitute teachers and a secretary who will be getting their bachelor's degree and earning their initial teaching certificate super excited um thank you for your continued
007support and helping us invest in our staff and building a stronger future for Harper Creek unless you have questions I'd like to introduce you to the first graduating class from the grow your own um program so we have Alex Decker fifth grade he's getting a master's degree in elementary ad Jennifer fry second grade at be Lake Elementary getting a master's degree in elementary on and Melinda Forest she's a teacher she's had a teaching certificate but she added autism spectrum disorder endorsement um she'll be graduating as well they're all walking on Saturday than me hello and thank you for the opportunity of letting me speak tonight on behalf of the grow your own program I'd like to begin by publicly thanking the Michigan Department of Education for the opportunity of making the grant available and of
008course also thanking Mi Western Michigan University and Harper Creek Community Schools I had been a district sub for a little over a year before I was approached by Tammy Chapman about this opportunity in full transparency I believe she as well as as many others in the district may have identified more of my strengths as an educator before I did myself it was my second year as a district sub that I began the Journey of beginning my masters in elementary education through the grow your own Grant and I am grateful that I continue to have further discussions with Tammy and other Harper Creek professionals within the district that encouraged me to pursue the degree after 16 months of an intense program I am proud to say that I will be walking the stage this Saturday of
009of Miller Auditorium and receiving my masters of Elementary education while it was not an easy 16 months I am grateful for the journey I have persever persevered through a few personal situations during this time and had incredible support from my mother and son and incredible friends the friends and colleagues that I have gained support from through the district especially that of Waddles Park Elementary and most recently at Beetle Lake Elementary has been unbelievable I am currently holding a position as a second grade teacher at Beetle Lake Elementary and was welcomed with open arms from the minute they learned of me joining their team I again would like to thank Waddles Park element sorry Waddles Park Elementary and Beetle Lake Elementary and the professors at Western Michigan University for their knowledge guidance and patience throughout the
010process to Harbor Creek Community Schools the Board of Education the administration fellow teachers thank you for your guidance patience and support and believing in me to the current and upcoming grow your own candidates you can do it one saying a dear friend taught me during this process is don't talk about it be about it I stand behind this 100% uh my name is Mindy forest and I will be graduating with my masters in ASD and I'm just glad for this opportunity I've wanted to uh go back to school for a long time but monetarily I could not afford it so this is such a great opportunity and I'm so happy that I can feel a need that for Harper Creek and um provide services for children that might not have had it otherwise so thank
011you my name is Alex Decker um graduating with my masters of um Elementary ad and I just want to share my appreciation for Harper Creek and for the G program to give me this opportunity uh the patience that has been shown to me um I'm going off the top of my head sorry um yeah I'm just very appreciative and thank you all right so Mr Besson I would like to give a note of thanks from the Board of Education to each of you all right so we have a congratulations letter for each of you so Mindy congratulations on your most recent master degree thank you and then Jenny congratulations thank you for those kind words and Alex congratulations very proud moment for me as a superintendent here thank you Tammy for your work as well
012again thank you Tammy she really spearheaded getting the the yeah that's awesome own all right our next present is least restrictive environment I believe we have attorney Rob deel from true law firm good evening good evening I don't think it's fair that I have to follow that I do have a handout that I'm going to pass out for anybody who wants it if not it the recit at the end and I appreciate you having me here tonight uh a little bit of context uh superintendent Ridgeway and ISD superintendent lunger thought it would be a good idea for me to come and just share some basic overview of the legal requirements under the special ed laws for least restrictive environment when I talk about least restrictive environment I'm really talking about keeping students with disabilities in
013their natural home school environment the environment where their same age non-disabled neurotypical peers would be and the reason and I've been doing a lot of these presentations lately the least restrictive environment obligation isn't new it's been in the law for at least 20 years and probably longer last time idea the federal special ed law was reauthorized was 2004 and all of these things I'm going to talk about are in that law but you'll see some guidance documents that predate that so we've been talking about least restrictive environment for a very long time why am I seeing an uptick in these presentations it's because our focus on L least restrictive environment has changed law hasn't changed obligations haven't changed but the Michigan Department of Education and the US Department of Education have both said that this
014is a priority area for compliance so I'm going to talk a little bit about what the law says what the guidance says and I'm going to talk a little bit about some case law at the end to use as a guide post on how you move forward as a district so when we talk about L idea regulation specifically say that to the maximum extent appropriate students with disabilities must be educated in the same classes and programs as their non-disabled peers are educated and may only be moved to special programs or segregated schools if the nature and severity of their disability is such that they cannot through the use of supplementary AIDS and services be educated in that non-segregated environment so key to that nature and severity of the disability and the use of supplementary AIDS
015and services so when I talk to my special education teams about this concept I tell them you have to show that you've maxed out all practical supplementary AIDS and services those accommodations those teaching strategies those supports those Behavior plans all of those things that we see as part of both good teaching and accommodating for individual needs before we can think about moving to a more restrictive setting and then we have to show that the nature or severity of that student's disability despite those accommodations and supports suggest that education can only be provided in that more restrictive setting so that's the that's the analysis that we go through LR is all areas of the school program we often times think about it as what school or what classroom is a student in but the LR obligation
016applies to recess to lunch to before and after school care programs we'll talk about in a few minutes Athletics and extracurriculars it's that whole idea of mainstreaming within the community so that our neurotypical students and our students with disabilities are receiving the same educational benefit throughout idea we see additional support for this obligation of mainstreaming or lre so idea focuses on ensuring that students with disabilities have access to the same curriculum as their non-disabled student their non-disabled peers and the definition of special education those things that we do through the IEP process includes adapting as appropriate to the needs of the eligible student to ensure that they're able to access that General curriculum and meet the same educational standard standards so again L is an Express mandate but we see those concepts of mainstreaming throughout
017idea as well and then the last piece and if we're looking at a checklist on what we go through to move a student to a more restrictive setting nature and severity of the disability supports a change of placement we've maxed out all practical use of supplementary AIDS and services and the team has to show that it considered any harmful or negative impact that move would make on the student so things like increased Transportation time losing existing relationships with peers losing existing relationships with staff members does the need for a more restrictive setting outweigh those sort of additional harmful impacts of a more restrictive setting and that has to be something that the team the IEP team expressly determines oops I think my clicker stopped working rob it did there we go so some guidance and
018this pre goes all the way back to 1994 the office for special education programs that's the office within the United States Department of Education says that in addressing the issue of L the IEP team the students team that determines placement in programming must consider the range of those supplementary AIDS and Services those accommodations and supports in light of the students needs and abilities that would facilitate that would make it easier for the student to be in that less restrictive mainstream setting so talking about maximizing those supplementary AIDS and services now every district and every ISD does have to have a Continuum of placements there is no requirement that every student be in general at 100% of the time within those there we go within those continuum you see regular classroom regular classroom with consultative supports
019embedded regular classroom with those supplementary AIDS instructional Services embedded resource program that would be a separate class within the same school building and then all the way up at the top of the Continuum we see separate classrooms separate schools residential schools and homebound settings and to move up that ladder of Continuum at each step we have to show nature and severity of the disability support this we can't find any supplementary AIDS and services that would make a lower rung more successful and we've considered those harmful impacts again this is a mandate that comes from idea and the guidance tells us that anytime the placement is changed up that Continuum it has to be based on the students individual needs not on the needs of the organization not for practical impact but because the student requires
020that level of Support Office of special education programs reiterates that that has to be through all parts of the school day including lunch and recess and again that if the student is moved to that more restrictive setting it's not to address the needs of the system but to address the needs of the student most recently mde issued guidance back in May of 2022 that really reiterates all of that Federal ederal guidance that we just talked about going to talk at the very end about MD's monitoring of these standards and this is why there's such Focus because MD has said after this may guidance document we're looking at this issue we're doing audits we're doing compliance reviews our six Circuit Court of Appeals the court that governs here in Michigan has said that in some cases
021a placement which may be better academically is not the selected placement because it is more restrictive and so I always tell my IEP team clients if we're looking at this right if we're saying that academic benefit in a more restrictive setting would be slightly better than academic benefit in a mainstream setting this is the program that the team has to offer when we start seeing the Gap go like this and we considered what we could do to narrow that Gap and we can't narrow that Gap that's when moving up that Continuum becomes more appropriate [Music] our six circuit said that that nature and severity of the disability occurs really in one of three circumstances what about the more restrictive setting makes it better can we replicate that in gen Ed if not that weighs in
022favor of that more restrictive setting or do we see that any marginal benefits of mainstreaming are far outweighed that balance is huge because of the students individual needs if that CA if that's the case then that supports a more restrictive setting and then third and the one that I get most questions about does the student pose a disruptive force in the general environment and if the student is a disruptive Force then that is based on nature and severity grounds to move to a more restrictive setting but again only if we can show we've maxed out those accommodations and supports we've done those behavior intervention plans that are based on good evaluation data so it's not enough to Simply say that supplementary AIDS were used we have to prove it and that doesn't mean that we
023have to say that every student before they can go to a more restrictive setting that we've tried 30 different accommodations but we have to explain that we've tried all of those that are practicable and feasible and we don't think that there are other accommodations that would support this student in the more restrictive in the less restrictive setting in other words we don't have to try everything under the sun we have to be able to explain why nothing Under the Sun would work better this oery case not a six circuit case but it basically says if you've not shown that you've tried in the General Ed setting that you've tried to accommodate through those supports then you're probably in violation of that LR mandate and then most recently in 2018 the six circuit again reiterated that
024if there is educational benefit meaningful education benefit that can be provided in the less restrictive setting with those AIDS and supports then that is where the student must be placed even if they would get more benefit from a more restrictive setting if they're getting meaningful benefit here more is not a basis to make that move and I think this was a a case that a lot of people in the advocacy Community were surprised by right because where is that Gap and we don't know and that's what the IEP team has to figure out but one of the things that the courts look to is is the student making meaningful progress on their individual objectives passing classes is not the standard are they receiving educational benefit in that setting and if so then that's where they
025should be unless again whoops I'm G to keep doing that that Gap keeps getting wider so I want to point out this yoner case not a Michigan case but this was a unique situation the office for civil rights US Department of education's arm went into yoner New York a district that has tens of thousands of students in that District they had 4,100 kids who were on IEPs and Yonkers did a review of Just those students who were learning disabled and what Y what the office for civil rights found is that of just the LD students who were new to special ed either they transferred into the district with an IEP or they were found eligible for an IEP in the district that over a 100 of 164 started in a more restrictive setting than Jed
026and so as a result of that finding the office for civil rights looked at each one of those students IEPs and each one of those students IEPs had the same boilerplate explanation the student needs a smaller class setting more intense instruction and nothing within the body of those IEPs showed what supports were tried or considered to make gened successful and as a result the office for civil rights says Yonkers was not following the L mandate that we should not have this many students as their initial placement with an LD label in segregated settings and so as a result the district had to write a memo to its staff telling them what L meant and provide sta training and then review every IEP for every kid who was in a more restrictive setting and consider whether
027LR was appropriately considered and if not offer compensatory education so if you can imagine going through hundreds and hundreds possibly thousands of IEPs and then determining relief for every one of those students so academic progress is not determinative I said said that already that grades and passing grades is not the Benchmark it is is that student making meaningful benefit non-academic services that LR mandate requires for after school programs before school programs launch recess Athletics extracurriculars clubs all of those things are of the same approach that we start with the premise that students with disabilities have the same access and the same rights to those programs Athletics same thing a student must be accommodated for sports unless that accommodation would create an unfair advantage to the student or fundamentally change the program and the classic example
028is a student who has a Mobility impairment and wants to play baseball and asks to have a fifth base added to the game that would change the nature of baseball you don't have to do that but if it wouldn't change the nature of the sport and it wouldn't create unfair advantage and that's an accommodation that has to be provided can't make placement decisions based solely on label or severity it is an individualized decision determined by the IEP team and the lack of appropriate or adequate resources or Personnel is not a basis to move a student to a more restrictive setting last point and then I'll seed my time back uh mde this year told school districts that least restrictive environment was its priority for compliance reviews and mde picked 10 separate isds and I don't
029believe Calhoun was one of the 10 for each of those isds mde is sending a team of seven to 10 officials including the state director of special education and the assistant director of special education to spend a week in each district or in each ISD and in each of those cases and they're traveling they went up to the up they took the state plane spent a week up there they're interviewing teachers they're interviewing parents they have a whole list of questionnaires they're reviewing random documents they're basically doing in a smaller scale what the office for civil rights did in Yonkers and from that review mde has said that they are going to work with each of those isbs on a fiveyear Improvement plan five years of technical assistance and one year to address any student
030level non-compliance essentially MD has already predetermined that they're going to find compliance issues and now mde is going to be working with these districts and isds for five years I suspect that this is a cyclical review so at some point Calhoun ISD is going to get that audit so that's all I have uh I think my last point is again that this is an IEP team decision and taking this training back to the building levels and back to the IEP team so that they know that before making any placement change and it is lawful and it is allowable but it requires homework and due diligence and an understanding of these standards that only when those standards are met should a student be moved to that more restrictive setting any questions yeah you know I Rob
031I think the reason this came up at least for me is um you know I hear you know words about supplementary AIDS and Services which is resources and I think where it becomes a the rubber hits the road at every school district is lots of work to be done lots of legal requirements yet we're we're having to work real hard to find teachers in the classroom yeah so my again I you can't I don't expect you to have the answer to this but this is the frustration right where a lot of EX a lot expected for all the right reasons but where do the resources come to make that happen and that was a little bit of our push back on the ISD as we we have we review we take a look at their
032budget and we see a lot of a fairly sizable fund balance and saying okay we have we have a resource issue here sure that resource issue is tends to limit the I'm going to use the word supplementary AIDS and services which then has a negative impact potentially on the system which in this case is all the kids in the classroom so don't expect more of a comment than a question but I mean I'd be interested in what you know the Michigan Department of Education is going out and auditing people but uh it'd be nice to have them helping with some solutions as well 100% agree uh I I have to be careful but I I I I do think that our department has become a compliance Department more than a Solutions Department um the is
033is that you just spotted is not unique to Calhoun or Harper Creek I talk to districts every day about that issue and the the biggest part of that issue is students with disabilities who are exhibiting behaviors right and when we do advocacy for resources oftentimes that advocacy is opening new classrooms which is counter to this message so how do we advocate for resources to build those supplementary aids to bring Behavior teams to help with Fidelity checks to do all of those things before we open more because we'll fill the classrooms right right and and the more classrooms we have the quicker they're going to get filled and I think sometimes we skip steps along the way if there's an opening in a classroom so really if we're looking at this from a compliance standpoint and
034a what's best for kids how do we get those sub AIDS and services in a way that makes sense that's meaningful that's impactful and that doesn't weigh down the resources that you already have so thank I mean this is very helpful in terms of helping us understand the the legal requirements good appreciate that I think we still have um some help we need sure uh from from the ISD on on resources I thought the presentation was was really spoton I think um my question is when we come back to those highly disruptive students and it seems like those highly disruptive students are are not only getting they're not getting the education they need but they're also disrupting 24 25 other students and then the the time Gap it takes to get that proper designation to
035get them to a different environment I think that's what I have heard as Rob and I have uh went to you know the different uh elementaries especially in the district district over each semester over a period of years now um and it seems like the staff members are frustrated with the the slowness of uh and reaction time it takes to get a student um moved to a a different environment yeah I again I hear this a lot and those supports do take time right and especially when behavior is so amorphous I've always said if I if I could figure out the magic of behavior I wouldn't be a lawyer and I'd be retired somewhere uh and so yeah by by its nature it's a timec consuming process and the reality too is there are some
036students who disruptive impact nature and severity of the disability can be moved to a more restrictive setting but it doesn't exist so that that goes back to your point too is where do we allocate the resources do we build more classrooms or do we put it into those supplementary AIDS and services or do we do both and part of the slowness is I I can pick 20 students right now that I'm working on their cases on that I think they're ready to make the move and there's not a classroom for them and then I can think of 20 cases where I think they made the move too quickly okay I appreciate you having me in here this is thank you Rob I'm K do you have any any thoughts that you want to throw in
037it's it's really you know booh talked about the staff and going out to the staff this the staff um teachers who are in the moment with with students that are disruptive it's really hard for them I mean I I want oh yeah them to know you know I I hear them I see them and when when when we hear things like you know we aren't being supportive we're not doing enough it's it's hard because we you know we have somewhat limited resources but i' virtually do anything to help these folks it's just a matter of we have to stay within the law and that's part part of this is I want to make sure that our board because they're hearing the same things because they they're community members they're friends with with with staff uh
038parents who are in classrooms and so so they just need to know that there's a process it's possible that students are placed in a on the Continuum but it takes time because we have to go through the go through trying many many different things before we find something you know I had a situation in a classroom where we we found a supplemental that that actually helped and the students were able to stay in class uh in that same classroom and just finding that sometimes is really frustrating because it takes a lot of time to what is that thing that's going to help work the student any uh for lack of better words any best practices that are out there that are found with other districts not that we're not doing those but yeah um when
039it for Behavior specifically leaning into and and I I I have said in presentations before too I think sometimes we give functional behavioral assessments fba's magical uh uh ability or magical thought and they're not magical but leaning into those really intentional data collections on what is precipitating this behavior and then leaning into your behavioral experts and then the the last piece from a a compliance and best practices standpoint is writing a good plan based on data and then making sure that you have processes to implement that plan and recognizing too that when a student is disregulated and we're in a crisis situation it's really hard for anybody to sit and read a seven page Behavior plan and know what to do and recognizing the reality of that so not only doing really good targeted behavior
040intervention plans but making them usable and practical and having people Implement them with Fidelity and that that's something that I've seen is that we write we do really good stuff on the front end and then that crisis hits and human nature sets in and and it's hard to train that and the best way to train that is to have something that's usable sure board members any other questions thank you rob thank you did an excellent job appreciate all right move on to District updates and curriculum Mrs good evening good evening happy holidays um just a couple highlights from the narrative report we are working feverishly on implementation as you know um as a board you approve to move forward on dk8 L curriculum amplifi or DK through fifth and El education both with um based
041in the science of reading and evidence-based practices and so um well it's a monster a lot of good feedback from staff as far as having um the resource and just giving each other Grace and time to learn all the pieces a component that we added um is some additional them from the company coming in to come alongside us so that we can make sure that we are implementing it with Fidelity um and that was well received across the district um and we have another time set um in early spring for that also simultaneously working with our uh administrators in high school math team um to look at our to look at curriculum resources for high school math um that are evidence-based we started at the foundation uh while we knew the ref some work that's
042why we started with elementary and middle school and so now we are in we've narrowed it down and we're in the process with them of looking at a couple of different resources um and so I've been meeting with them weekly and they're digging in and um sample lessons and things are provided so um they're closing out the semester right now so in the in January we will have some additional training and um for that for that team um our assessment NWA Benchmark assessment we did open the window before break in the past we've only done it in January but our instructional teams um as we just looked at some data and where we see come how we see kids coming back asked if that would be okay and since it does fall within the standardized
043window uh we did open that up this week and um so some testing is happening with nwaa maybe expecting better results or um I don't know so much as that as I mean possibly right because you have a two we window but um just the thinking that they could be more timely as we're getting more refined with responding to those priority standards and they're ready to see that Benchmark assessment how are they doing they have their internal assessments but but they want that data um I think some um well only a couple said this some wanted to have it over break to look at so they could do some intentional planning that is not the expectation that over break they do that but some did want it so since it really is a two week
044window and it is Falls within the Norms of the standardized um requirements we're moving forward on that and the window basically goes for a month from now till mid January um so so those are the Nuggets did you have any um questions relative to those or what when do you expect the curriculum math curriculum to be brought to the board our hope is in the spring spring we have yeah so we that would be go into effect for next year school year is the goal um one of the hurdles I mean it's one of the hurdles is the the the most Cutting Edge practices the revision won't be out till the fall so that is a hurdle but it is certainly not um so you're basically buying a car that might might but with a
045new engine in it or Honda Honda or you know I think we feel like we have enough of the understandings and we're continuing to learn um and they have some of them have some samples um that we can see so I'm not overly concerned I'm just naming it that is a reality MH and we're looking at just one particular curriculum right now or is there we're looking at two different ones right now okay we looked at six and narrowed it down through a very methodical process um which align like at the end of the day our um which is why I included them in this report our portrait of a graduate and our mathematical transfer goals that's our destination so we need to make sure that as we're looking at curriculum that it's going to
046get us to those pieces um that we're expecting of our graduates as we're preparing them for that so do we ever look at like for example we sent a lot of people to the ad Stevenson High School we ever look and see what it's a part of our process so first we look at um Ed reports and evidencebased there's different um spaces where evidence-based evidencebased is different than research based because the research philosophically it should work evidence that it did work and so we narrowed it down to uh the evidence-based ones and then we're also going to be doing as part of the process some site visits um and there's the content but there's also the mathematical practices that have to be integrated into the curriculum um quite honestly um without those we probably be
047similar to where we are so so there's training visiting looking at the resources those are the three it's a process M Strat and process process yes sir yep so I just want to commend the Math teachers they're working hard to dig in I mean they have a lot there navigating and um they've been open we've had three I'm sorry four outside resources come in basically salese SLT trainers come in and so um like I said the next step is okay now where is it actually working um having been at this for a bit you can buy a evidence-based resource but if you don't implement it with the Del just like anything else it's only as good as should be implemented I can cheat doing push-ups right or I can do them the right way Mr
048G me anything you want to add on the math side of things anybody have any you there further questions thoughts all right if not uh move on to facilities Mr Robinson good evening thank you uh I submitted a report couple little highlights and trinkets we'll talk about on the report uh we I'll talk about filter first in a little bit um we talked in the report about uh the crosswalk and we'll talk I guess I can talk about it now we do have both sides of Lights working now so I just received an email prior to the meeting tonight uh we are working with our architect and getting everything turned over to the county and the city so that they can begin the main maintaining of that and everything I just heard that tonight so
049get those get all the parties together review it we're really looking at a long and St short story is getting some more signage out there so it's able to be seen better um right now why lights work people still tend to drive through it so uh also we talked about I had a salt spreader listed on there that we thought was down and out we had somebody else look at it recommended we get a new one uh my team actually took it upon themselves we kind of put our heads together and actually fixed it so we were able to get that up and running so save the district about almost $1,000 and then also we had a building committee meeting last week um a couple of the items discussed um where are just our district
050needs we talked about those um from probably the next year till the next 10 years out and there was a a pretty big Hefty uh price tag on those we discussed uh you know just those facility updates and just future bra you know what we're looking at and we're still early discussions but time frames on maybe future bonds um whether it be small or large so those are some of the the the big ticket items we talked about at the building committee meeting and last but not least uh filter first requirements that we've talked about the legislation's out the grant uh award came out and Harper Creek received 88,2 48 for that so uh also will help pay for items that have been purchased back to October of 23 that would uh mean the grant
051specifications so we're excited for that um thanks to Jared Ransom our our grant writer he helped me out a great deal and he submitted it for us and just we're glad we got that and really thank you the last thing I have thank you Dr Borders for all your work and with the board and have a safe and happy holiday season all right thank you move on to finan and Mrs OB all right I'm going to talk off of the um board reports a little more this time because we did not have the finance committee because of the snow um first one is the board breakdown I it's the budget from uh June that you guys passed uh you see this every month but couple of things I wanted to point out the state funding
052we get um to the right I have a little note we have received our second out of 11 state aid payments which would put it at 18% it's a little more than that mostly uh because there's some carryover of Grants um from the previous year um and some onetime payments um the uh retirement sometimes does it in four sections we got our first section so it's a little higher than normal uh the incoming transfer is zero it always is just so you know that makes up um the special ed re urement and then the um pil money and so we don't receive we'll receive our first special ed reimbursement either the end of this month or the beginning of January so you'll see that increase in the next one down at the um expenditures I
053uh teachers are the primary out of 111 through 113 113s um so it's about 30% 8 out of 26 payroll have been paid out which is tracking pretty closely um the insurance is usually a month behind so it's a that's why it's a little bit lower and same with year round employees I showed you what function codes those are uh 11 out of 26 payrolls which is a little bit higher uh 42 43% um which is right on track also is there any questions on this one the ones that are you know 100% are just if you look at the actual dollar amounts I budgeted 2600 and it's 2700 um the summer programming is just because the the it's all Grant funded but I budgeted that we'd have 71,000 and we spent 104 but again
054it's all Grant funded so when I do the revision I believe it will be in February um we'll get that taken care of the actual dollar amounts are not huge dollar amount differences just one question I see the uh deficit is up a million dollars over the proposed deficit no that's just because the the way that funding comes in it's um the revenue we've only received 28% of our revenue and um we've expend around 33% it's just because of the the way the funding comes in suspected that I just yeah confirmation you've been to one a couple of my finance committee meetings so so a question for you so we're about a quarter in do you have any areas of expense that you've identified for potential that as that expense um it would be less
055Revenue if anything so I think the expense is pretty right on I mean we'll we'll go over it in Fe February but I think the expenditures are are pretty much right on um because there's been no major major changes it will just be the revenue and pupil uh count the next one is the cash balance uh my laugh again uh a bigger portion I've been putting into Mya uh cash what's my for people are Michigan liquid asset fund so it's an investment place that we that we've been utilizing yep and they this year or it was 4.76% every seven days it changes but for that month it was seven or 4.76% whereas I was getting uh like 1% on our uh checking so we actually I actually went back and just looked CU I was
056curious last November versus this November in general fund we made $7,000 more in interest um we did have a little bit more cash on hand though also so it's combination of the two things debt was significantly more we um have $500,000 more in in debt right now in cash for debt um but we made $9,200 more in interest also so that helps some yeah how much do you think we were adding to our bottom line in just smart smart money management at the end of the year with these tools per se do through the CDs or the my laugh well in in just a month it's been $20,000 so good y That's month to month I mean we are we do have more cash so and none of that was budgeted in your Revenue model
057uh as a a small increase but not this much no there's some Revenue right there I just found it there's some Revenue yeah we'll we'll look on in February what what all that'll do and then I just had the regular check register I went through it it it nothing weird this month that I that I saw and that's probably the one piece in the that the budget committee does if you're you know we obviously will have a new member in the budget commit at least and we look through here at the committee meeting and look for things that you know hey why is that high is that I don't know what that is and um they get a more detailed list of what it actually is but it is our what we are spending out
058of our every check that we've written for the district and then I have more fun later in the meeting the salary schedule I will say that only I was curious about was Michigan's finest chocolate that got 10,850 well that's actually from sixth grade Camp the fundraising so some of it does look weird but it's it's a lot of chocolate though yeah there are some things that I'm like hey just so you know this is a Student Activity uh fundraising item or something like that so thank you Mrs over thanks move on to technology and Mr mayard all right not a lot new this month but um we talked earlier at the committee about when the clocks might get installed and the guy was waiting for me when we got out of the meeting so picked
059up the clocks and took him over to Beetle Lake today I'm assuming that means any time now we're going to start seeing those go up as finishing the Middle School um and the large clocks as well um camera wise we're still waiting on the County's project to unfold they are doing little bits and pieces here and there they got another guy coming over this week to get GPS coordinates off our existing cameras um but while we wait uh the server migration is probably going to happen over break and then I'm hopeful we can take the ones we take out of service and use them as stop Gap servers until we get something better because I think they will function in that role we do anticipate getting servers from the county Grant correct yes one maybe
060two or one really big one where that's kind of the discussions that are ongoing all right questions for Mr maard move on to comments related to agenda items all right consent agenda Madam Secretary chair calls for a motion at the Harper Creek Board of Education approve the consent agenda as follows approve the general fund checks School Services fund checks school lunch and student and school activity fund checks in accordance with the list discussed and approve the following minutes as reviewed November 11th 2024 regular meeting minutes December 4th 2024 building committee meeting minutes so moved support it's been moved by Mr Smith supported by Mrs Wallace do we have discussion hearing see none please call the rooll Mr helverson yes Mrs Wallace yes Dr Borders yes Mrs Alward I vote Yes Mr Smith yes and Mr
061BS I vote Yes motion carry all right thank you for that uh move on to information discussion school safety Mr rway yeah the School Safety Committee met one thing that we've been talking about is doing a tabletop exercise which would be a simulation of an event um basically Chris Young the emergency manager from K County said what what worries you and I asked a few of our administrators and one is uh what if we had a threat to school safety that at an extracurricular event like a athletic contest on a Friday night or maybe even at a band concert in the auditorium um how would we react and what would we do so at the next meeting we're going to do a tabletop of a extracurricular event and that just simply means we will talk
062through how that event how we would react to the event so that we can see holes and make adjustments to get better we have been meeting about um specifically Friday night U fall uh football games because that seems to be our largest event and we would we meet prior to the game um to make sure that everybody is knows where they're supposed to be and what they're going to do um but we have not done so much for the smaller events so we want to take a hard look at that conversation about the radios uh the um County dispatch put in new uh radio or towers for the radios we have one at phoma we've noticed that there's been a diminished uh use of radio in terms of clarity and so that we found out
063from the from the emergency manager is happening at the county level as well so they're looking into to see what's going on our radios are hooked to the state police system a crosswalk we synchronize the lights doing pretty well you hear Jim we want to now put in some signage so people slow down when students are crossing the road in the lights are fles I thought that was in driver's ed 101 but I could be wrong that's just being funny uh for emergency operation plan the board had approved that a while back we are we think at least onethird of the way through Jim and I received another email today to do to do the next third um and so we'll continue through the process it looks really good so far as a draft um
064and we will bring that to the board more than likely in a couple of months is my guess uh talked about the camera project Jim just talked about the notification system Jim just talked about I asked any future things one thing that one of the members had said is we need to make sure that our substitute teachers or contractors coming into the building know our safety plan so if we have a substitute teacher in a classroom that they know you know what to do in the case of a a lockdown a secure mode or anything that may that may happen that they are briefed U now if we have Subs that are in the district on a daily basis we feel pretty good about that but sometimes we do have substitute teachers who are not
065here daily and so how do they find that information and and making sure that we're consistent and then finally uh there there was a lot to talk about emergency um uh like we have the Rave alert Rave Panic alert uh with which goes straight to 911 that's working very well within the district but what are some other ways that we could do similar things um and one of those is having the the panic button that we have that will attach to these notification systems so when you press the panic button all of the strobes come on mechanical voice says lock down lock down lock down so that everybody knows what to do and gets behind the lock door as quickly as possible I think that was the Safety Committee this time for me all right
066uh Item B salary schedule okay I'm going to talk a little and I'm have ginger then clean up so you're going to back clean up on this one I I don't want to say anything incorrect but uh basically there was a case at the at the Michigan Supreme Court about uh retirement especially of employees in Michigan in which there is a job category with three or less employees and so in the past they would take a look at the contract employees they would take an average of the three to five highest years that that person made in their salary and they would calculate the um pension uh because of the lawsuit there was a change and they I mean when they say they the office of Retirement Services is expecting a salary schedule last year
067in the spring um Mrs overmeer brought to you a salary schedule and it was a basic salary schedule I want to it's it's in your it's in your packet of stuff that on on your board table there was two years worth it had most of our uh employee groups but you will notice that there was very or not very few but there were some at in the new salary schedule that we missing and so basically we took the salary schedule took best practice from other districts as well because it's brand new and came up with a salary schedule I want to be really clear about this that these numbers you see on here are can be changed because when we negotiate let's say a teacher's contract they have a salary schedule and every third year
068or so we renegotiate and those numbers change um these are not set in stone if we had somebody leave the district in a in a job category we could reset there we can do all of those things still with this schedule but the office of Retirement Services expects that we have something to hand to them to say what did Rob Bridgeway make over the last last three to five years so that I can calculate the retirement for him and then anybody in a category for example assistant superintendent High School Principal Finance director Tech director uh all the way down to our hourly employees that you can see on the list have to be within the schedule so that we have um something to give to them of actual salaries and what anticipated salaries may look
069like so a real salary schedule um we are very detailed on this Mrs OBM made this up but I think that she did a pretty good job to make sure everything was included oh we plan on bringing a salary schedule when we do the budget meeting in June on an annual basis so basically we'll take the schedule and add one more year onto the end and that will happen every June before um the salary start for the school if that makes sense go ahead your betting clean up go ahead so um this you get you already passed this well you guys have heard about this for a year and a half right this is just with the right we keep getting more and more information of what they think we should do without saying black
070and white what we should do so this is all the recommendation from ORS TR Masa all combined into one and this is actually the one that other districts are using like we I pushed it out to other districts so that anyone in these rules will not be um nothing will miss a beat when they go to retire and in fact just so one of the clarifying thing is um it's actually not it's you're not supposed to be able to look at it and say what is Rob riding making what does a superintendent at har schools that that was a clarifying thing whereas here it was more um that was something that was important to ORS to say so that's why it has levels instead of it literally saying superintendent or Finance director or um so
071all it is is it's the same information it's extended out it's going to still come to you guys even when we hire it if I were to leave and someone else were to take my place I would recommend that they bring this or or you know a principal leaves and someone else comes they they bring this to be updated um with that hiring instead of their contract that you guys approve you'll be approving their Sal schedule that goes for the contract so it's the same information the the years out are really just in truth me making up numbers right and then but every June you guys are going to look at it and and approve the salaries just like you do with every other group but we're just getting it so that it's um in
072black and white for for ORS purposes to benefit the employees so it appears there's like increases on every single one of these except level 15 yeah I noticed that too just now I notic that the level 10 um level 15 is a um that's just how it always has been so that that's actually um a position that is a position and it's it's an added Duty and I just wanted to make sure that that person um like we normally don't even have that honest schedule but I wanted to make sure it counts towards that person's retirement so they get another regular pay in addition yes so there this is actually a principal who gets an extra duty pay but I wanted to have it clear on there so when he goes to retire it clearly
073says this is his base pay but he's also getting this base Goa really not and it only incre increased this year because that we added a program so it's a little bit more of the sh got you gotta thank you and so what what the ask of the board is if you feel comfortable is to uh take action to approve the salary schedule um in case we do have folks that decide to retire at the end of the school year it really is a retention issue on top of not only uh making sure is people are going to want to be at districts in which they're taken care of in Terms of their retirement uh what happened uh in the mess of the lawsuit um ORS had started to give people what they made the
074first year they were on the job so for example if I started 10 years ago and I I was at a certain salary that's what that they would base your retirement on instead of any increases that you may have received so that's why the salary schedule was something that they're mandating it's in the law it's just it was meant for you know really for teachers because that's the majority of the the folks within the system but we have to take care of everybody in the system and we we also have employee groups like let's say our par professionals that have a salary schedule our maintenance employees have a salary schedule Transportation they have a salary schedule so this is just doing a salary schedule for this everybody now anybody have any questions all right move
075on to masb conference update which was going to be done by Shay this evening uh as she is sick I think we will push at to our January meeting and move on to superintendent contract all right superintendent contract so basically uh this is the time year that we taught contract uh for me um I'm not talking about contract in terms of salary or compensation I'm talking about we have to get it updated for the language that was changed in the law that's the the primary purpose I had talked to Mr Bess um when we met about the agenda setting he thought that should go to the superintendent compensation committee to discuss uh but my suggestion would be very simple send send the contract to the true law firm um and have them tell us what
076needs to be in the contract to be up with the law language wise we don't have to do a evaluation this year thank goodness for all of us uh but because of the three years of Highly Effective which is NI so really no action tonight except for if you'd like to call a meeting we will get on that here probably for January I don't know do we need to do it before nope no there's no timeline really the timeline is getting it done before June 30th okay so anytime we just happen to do it this time of year because it it revolves around evaluation typically okay uh fa uh item e facility dedication okay so we received a request for for a facility DED dedication uh what the request was is that we rename the
077um I'll call it the access road for lack of a better term the road between the high school and the middle school that travels next to the soccer field and the practice facilities that are over there the request was to um name this after deceased Alum and citizen Matt burn um uh I'm just going to talk a little bit about Matt because this was what was given to me uh generally Matt was a very special person who helped with the football team during his his time at Harper Creek uh during school and then after graduation he happened to have Down syndrome and suffered from A congen congenital heart condition he passed in 1999 at the age of 29 um and he had left an inable mark on those who came in contact and so much
078so that the team continues to do a prestigious Awards in in his honor and so the request came in that hey maybe we could name the ACT Road after Matt um and thought that would be good the building committee took this topic up and it came uh the suggestion came up that well what's our policy first of all and we do not have a policy from true and Law Firm on naming of facilities um and so what is our procedure and we looked back in time and I looked at the Neola policy and it was very basic it said that the board will decide if on naming the facilities and you cannot name a facility unless someone is deceased or no longer employed with a district and I think that uh based on the conversation
079from the building committee they don't make the decision but they they they do give recommendation and the recommendation that that I heard is that we need to have a procedure in place so that we can feel good about naming all facilities as we move forward um I did put a sample or a draft procedure in the in board book I'm not sure if everybody had a chance to take a look at that but it was a somewhat detailed procedure and I also contacted TR law firm and they said although they don't have it in their basic policies they have written um naming a facility policies for districts so we could ask for that uh my suggestion if the board wants to move down the road of setting a procedure or a policy is to push
080it back to the policy committee um to look through review drafts look at Children's potential policy and then come back to the board with a um suggestion for for procedure I don't think there's a question in terms of the person and the naming of the facility I think that's a it would be something very nice for the district to do I think the concern is we need to have a procedure so that we follow it when when somebody would like to have parts of our facility to named after them we have parts that are named as right now I think we've done as a board since I've been on um two or three different times where we've named some parts of the facility I put on the draft auxiliary facility because the first time I
081looked up drafts it was like naming the entire school like the process to name a school not the process to just name a portion of the property I'm open for any discussion at this point um uh sounds like we need to move forward with TR to have them bring their information policy and get it in front of our policy committee agree I'm a little concerned tr's policies are a little not say basic but they don't go into too many details like step by step by step so we may have to in addition have have guidelines well maybe that our policy committee can take the best of all worlds of what you have here what trun has and see if they can mold something together uh maybe we could get get that done in January so
082in February's meeting we can approve that and then consider the request consider the request okay yep I definitely want to see the policy but I don't also I want to see this not get kicked down the road much further yeah just put it up on the screen so people in the audience can see what the board is talking about just it's just a real simple sample uh basic some good things some things things that I potentially don't agree with but for the most part it's reviewing having a committee that reviews and then gets feedback and then recommends to the board who makes the final decision and we don't need necessarily need yet another committee it could be maybe part of a current committee that already exist right okay yep that is true sounds like a
083job for the policy committee yeah easy for you to say your let's get one really quick December December December still still time two weeks three weeks left in the year Dale I'm free for three more weeks right all right uh we'll move on to comments from the audience oh we got one back that wants to raise her hand do you want to get a comment card or they can come on up so slide right over and tell us your name and address and then in the future we'll have you fill out a comment card but thank you for coming up and talking with us yeah my name's Jay car my address is 160 Chapel Drive okay when you speak in the microphone so we can hear you my name is Jaye Carr my my address
084is 160 chap Drive okay okay I just had a question about the band senior night recognition because we were told that would be discussed here tonight about it being during either halftime or before the night for the football game okay can I respond to that uh yes just so you know we don't generally do not respond to uh audience questions but I have a feeling Mr rway would like to just say a couple words yeah so typically what happens just so just for the process wise uh comments come in and then I think in this case the board asked me then to go back and talk to uh those involved you know to say what should we or should we not do um and we are going to do a recognition at halftime it's just
085we've got to figure out exactly how that that works at during halftime because I know the recognition before the game it wasn't quite the same so to give a short answer is they gave it to me and it's my job then to implement but I can assure you that that will happen all right thank you yes thank you thank you for coming anybody else want to put a last minute hand up all right uh action salary schedule Madam Secretary chair calls for a motion that the Harper Creek Board of Education approves the salary schedule for groups of three or less as presented some moved support moved by Dr Dr border supported by Mr helverson do we have discussion hear and see none please call the rooll Mr helverson yes Mrs Wallace yes Dr Borders yes
086Mrs Alward I vote Yes Mr Smith yes and Mr Bass I vote Yes motion carries 6 Z all right we are going to need a motion to go into a close session before we do that I just want to recognize our favorite liais on officer Mr Victor peers back there thank you for all your service to the district and thank you for being here tonight and if you would read the motion thank you chair calls for a motion that the Board of Education of Harper Creek Community Schools convenes in closed session at the request of a students parents pursuant to section 8B of the Michigan open meetings act MCL 15. 268b to consider the dismissal suspension or disciplining of a student whose identity is known to the board of education so move and moveed by
087Mr Smith supported by Dr Borders do we have discussion hearing see none please call the rooll Mr helverson yes Mrs Wallace yes Dr Borders yes Mrs Alward I vote Yes Mr Smith yes Mr Bess I vote Yes motion carries 6 zero all right thank you all right we will now go into close session and uh Mr ridway we're going to read see e