CorpusRecord 122914

HCS Board Meeting - 01/13/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Hartland Schools Board Meetings
Date
2025-01-14
Location
Livingston County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,268 words · about 63 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001and of course the partners in progress are a big part of having that uh Unity within our community and the board passed this uh resolution uh 1920 or 2021 just to bring some verbage to reason respect and responsibility because prior to 2021 there there was no defined definition we all assumed we knew what it is we talked about it but we didn't Define it and then the health and safety committee is the newest committee so their goals here increased percentage of student parents and staff who feel that schools are safe and then uh close out the village monitoring well situation uh that we worked with uh last year as a school district um you can see again strategies and assessments uh you see Deputy chuff in the back he's our high school resource officer we

002appreciate deputy chuff there every day today with our students and our staff creating that environment we've had some committee meeting when needed school safety uh what do we have uh what have we done this year you can see the types of things that we've done uh We've again continued to take care of the SEC safety consultation suggestions Alice Based training continues to be something we're working on and I won't read all these but uh one of the things that is coming coming up and I would like the board to think about this um prior to me reaching out to you say hey we need to talk about it is the renewal of the safety patrols we have two we started in this District by helping the Heartland Township fund two Road Patrol uh deputies we

003then had a three-year contract with the road Patrol deputies in the sheriff's department while also Contracting our two resource officers at the high school and the middle school this is the last year of that road Patrol contract I think it's important that the district continue to help support the road Patrol on top of what we're doing and here's why Deputy Chu and Deputy King are in our buildings every day and we don't necessarily want to pull them out of those buildings once school starts right we want them there being on campus if we have an issue in front of Village Elementary School with traffic or whatever we can call the road Patrol and say hey can you be in front of Village today watching what's going on and maybe someone needs an award today for

004their driving behavior we can ask them to monitor some other parts of the district where we need help and so I think we have to look at being serious contributors to making sure that Harland and the township and the district have Road Patrol here on a regular basis so I have asked the township to get the together and uh the manager Mike loose was meeting with their administrative team we'll get together and talk about what could that look like moving forward but I think we have to give a heavy consideration I think it's an it's an important piece of safety and having people around Megan can I just ask a question on that sure do we have any data or have we collected any data and maybe this is something that um Sheriff Murphy has

005around like the impact of those Road Patrol over the last several years in you know Heartland have they maybe data of um calls that they've responded to here locally calls within the district they've responded to here locally um and I don't know if at the township level they're tracking crime rates and those types of things that would just be good to have um again that's a great question question and that's why I reached out to uh Mike loose the manager to say we haven't met in a while we which we have it we need to get together so we can ask those questions so that I can share that with the board because I'd want to have something very concrete for you to look at to say yeah this is of value right versus well

006I just think it's a good thing so I appreciate that Mr Hughes does that expire at the end of the calendar year or do you know what the August August of uh 25 so okay yeah thanks yep we've been uh working with our school resource officers and our um school safety officers at all of our buildings uh if you've been to our buildings you know you got to sign in with the Raptor system you have to have your ID your state issued ID and so there's quite a few things there that we're doing to make sure that our buildings are safe uh this is last year's data but I thought it was pertinent uh all of our safety officers uh and school resarch officers 100% said yes to all these questions uh so it's nice

007because when I see Deputy chuff or I see Deputy king or I see one of our uh Mr fluto or Randy mice I asked them how do you feel about the safe environment of our school buildings and they always tell me we feel they're very safe now doesn't mean something can't happen but that's why we have them there um these are some uh s thoughts from the groups uh that are are safety officers and again this is something you've seen before from 2324 uh updates that we continue to look at making sure that we have these things in place and you'll see that partnership with oh by the way Cheryl Stockwell also helps us with that Patrol unit or uh that's in the district on a regular basis and so ends my update on evidence

008of effort hopefully that was helpful to you and of value right any other questions what's the original date of our syncing fund gosh 2017 that was my first year as superintendent okay we passed it yep and the reason why we want to go out uh uh president gach uh on the in May of 26 is because you can uh do a renewal versus you know a brand new uh trying to pass a brand new one so the renewal language is important to us okay thank you moving forward um forward excuse me item 1 E call to the public Miss brayen do we have any call to the public cards okay no call to the public write this down in a history book item 1 F committee and building reports Mr Scott we'll start with you

009so obviously with the holiday there hasn't been a lot of action uh with the with the Committees but I am pleased to see that Mr Hughes and his staff have got the Transportation uh evaluation underway and I really look forward to that process how it rolls out I think I think that probably was a um offshoot of some of what was discussed at the last building and site committee meeting uh I just got my building assignment I'll be assigned to the high school so I have not made my first visit yet uh so I don't have a building report but I did uh attend in Lancing last week uh opening day for the state representatives as a guest of uh Mr Wolford the 50th District representative and that was a really great experience and I

010hope to build some bridges with uh with Mr Wolford with um other state reps that that represent our district to make sure that our voice as a school district and a community is heard and Lancing and I look forward to that thank you Mr Scott Mr galeski yes thank you U Megan um last week I was with the Dei committee and we went uh down to Indianapolis Plus for some training from the uh Great Lakes equity center the uh Midwest and plains uh division um the information presented to me was everything I thought it would be um but I do feel rather positive that our Heartland Representatives have a very clear vision of what some of that material should look like when it becomes material that we're going to present to students and staff and

011what have you so um it was very uh very enlightening for me um and I'm glad that I'm part of it really am so thank you thank you really quickly um before we move to you Mrs Coleman I would just like to thank you and Mrs Coleman for your work in um uh collaborating with our administrators and our teams that are going down there I know it takes time out of your personal life there's travel there's a lot associated with that so thank you very much so it's a very good group too so yeah and thank you to our administrators and our teachers and and um social workers and counselors that are a part of that because I know one night away from kids activities and sports can really put a a burden on a

012family so thank you very much Mrs Coleman thank you um yeah I guess just echoing what uh Glenn said um it was a great experience um to go to the the training I'm looking forward to the next session um I got I got a lot out of it and it's always great to spend time with with our administrators and other people from the district get to know them a little bit better outside of the typical uh setting so um so thank you for that and for all the time that invested um I guess I just wanted to say welcome back to everybody I hope everyone had a very uh restful break um and that you've hit the ground running I know my kids have um let's see no building visits yet this month but I

013will be seeing uh the Creekside team on Friday and the round team later this month um I was able to stop by quickly um each of those schools before Christmas break and it's always cool to see all the things that not only the students do and the fun activities that the teachers coordinate and orchestrate but all the things that the pto's do for our students in the schools and then also for our staff to show them the appreciation as they are rounding the corner you know at the high school getting through finals doing all the things and to to try to give our teams a little bit of a boost um so I appreciate all that the PTO and the pack members do for our teams in the schools it's very and it was very

014cool to see some of that firsthand um I was able to join the senior center advisory council meeting last week and just a few highlights um a date to put on your calendars um to support the uh the center they're doing a fundraiser through Tony SOS on February 11th and the funds raised through that event will help offset the cost for the second pool table um and to get that refurbished and put into place which is a big big deal so um that's just to offset those costs and they may also do a fundraiser at Heartland Brewing but they don't have a date set for that one yet but great restaurants um and businesses locally that love to support our schools and I I love to support them too um they've got lots of upcoming

015events dinner theater this spring spring music concert in April uh the Rocket's performance in June um they're still planning out on an outdoor pickle ball tournament in the spring as well um possibly a Trash to Treasure sale they're looking for some other um ideas um for some new and different fundraisers a lot of their fundraisers are coming in shorter than what they've come in in years prior so um anything that uh that the Community can do to help support that is a definitely a great cause and that's all I've got thanks Mrs colan Mr Keller I don't have a board report or building report rather no committee meetings either so I uh have nothing to report thanks thank you Mr kellerer Mrs Shaw thank you um I since I am just back on the board

016again after um being elected um I will be meeting with Mrs brisky at farms later this week um to catch up with her and um of course no committee reports um either so that's all I have Mr Campbell no report uh all right happy to help on any committee I can be of assistance on I've been assigned Lakes Elementary so look forward to meeting with them and uh yeah awesome good to go thank you Mr Keller thank you for getting those updated assignments out appreciate that you're welcome um as for me I too have no building or committee reports um this break seemed to last a little bit longer than I think it felt like it lasts a little bit longer than historical breaks and so um with one week back into school I have

017not I've been up to Village and been in the office but haven't met with Mr recck um and so I will plan to do that next week um and that so ends my report before you do the next section can I just point out that it at the whatever the board wishes to do uh at the end of this uh next section there is a alternative version if you want to read that instead of that that's the one I was planning to to start with I saw that I thought it was missing and so I just leaned over to Mrs Coleman to see where it was but we will move on move on to item 2 a new and revised policy I move that the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the superintendent and

018the assistant superintendent of personnel approves the revised policies as presented Edgar revisions 1130 311 04110 6110 6111 6112 7450 7455 additional updates 312 0.08 533 0.02 support motion by Mrs Shaw supported by Mrs Coleman discussion yeah so there's maybe half of the policies there's some items that I wish to either seek clarification on or maybe propose some uh edits or some typographical changes that um I had so I guess I would uh I'd like to at least have those discussed is there a reason why you didn't let the board know before now that there were changes so that we could review before we sat here at the board table I'm not going to comment on that at this uh yeah prepared to know what the chain I think you'll find these are not it's a

019lot of typo typographical things maybe you came across them as you read through them maybe you didn't read through them I don't know I guess but maybe you didn't but um it's important that we talk about these as a team so that's why we want to bring it up now and we found after um reviewing some of these there are some definite issues some definite typos and we need to make those clear we just can't pass all of these as is mrki who is we um well obviously Mr Keller myself okay I think it'd probably be best and easiest if we just took it as they're as they're together in the packet does everyone have the packet in front of them yes I'm happy to make a motion to amend Mrs Shaw's motion to at

020least move forward on the ones that I know I don't have any questions I don't and I don't know if these are the same ones that anybody else may have questions I don't so if they're typographical and simple errors like you said why don't we go through those first and then if that's if no one else on the board has concern we could in theory amend to accept those changes but if there is concern then we can go back um and you can amend uh or throw another motion on the table and or go back we'll go back to the original motion so do you want to do that first and kind of go through them so I I guess I'm just trying to clarify do we not have to vote then on Mrs Shaw's

021motion we will eventually have to vote on it but I think it would be beneficial to understand that bad question I asked do you want to do it all through discussion prior to either going through each one of them individually or um voting on the motion that's at hand just trying to clarify well I think if we go through in discussion your concerns then everyone at the table can either consider whether or not to vote on those edits as part of an amended package or if we need to take them out separately do you understand what I'm saying but if you're not comfortable doing that you can certainly put another motion on the table yeah guess I just want to go through them because I'm not I'm not understanding which what they are you know

022what I mean right well I'll just kind of rattle off a few just to give some color on to what I'm looking at so for the first three policies conflict of interest 1130 3110 and 4110 my understanding is that they're all essentially the exact same or the intent is that they're all the exact same is that the understanding they are exactly the same and the reason why they are 11:30 and so on and so forth is they different sections of the policy book so one would be professional staff one would be support staff and because it covers those sections they have to have the same reading okay that's my understanding as well so as an example policy 11:30 this is minor it misspelled board in in section A1 in section A4 the third sentence is

023missing language that on the other policies in the third sentence it says the employee officer agent or board member in place of the word they so again trying to make these match exactly I think that's the the difficulty with having three policies that are all supposed to read the exact same one approach might be to have it all written out in one of these policies and then take either 3110 or 4110 and say please see policy 11:30 if there's a need to have them um if I look at 3110 there was some missing language that was found in 1130 and 4110 in paragraph 2 that reads pursuant to Federal rules the district has standards for situations where the financial interest is not substantial or the gift is an unsolicited item of nom value for purposes

024of this section nominal value means the gift has a monetary value of $100 or less so that was not included in the review and then there's language that was struck on 1130 and 4110 that wasn't struck again it's I think these are all relatively minor so it's not intended to cause Strife amongst the board but I think you know you know we should try to get these 100% you know complete and accurate sure yeah I agree with the with the typos and correcting that stuff but in my mind that if it's minimal and it's it's nominal it doesn't affect the content or it doesn't it's not I guess controversial or not like a big issue that that you want to discuss then that's the kind of stuff that we we could do ahead of time

025that we could say you know so that our final packet includes those typo Corrections instead of waiting to do typo Corrections here feel me so um but like the issues where you guys have heartburn where there's you know a discrepancy or something big absolutely let's discuss that here but the typo stuff I I don't know I mean it would just be nice if we could do that ahead of time just so it out loud maybe it'd be more appropriate to table these till next month if we can fix if there's a lot of just typos and stuff sorry newbie question is this is the attorney the any firms who prepare this are they the same that generally prepare the Neola updates or are they different do you know same same it is Neola yeah well

026they have uh it said oh I won't say them but there's two two firms listed on here I didn't know if those were the same as usual or not and outside of the the the simple type ofes I agree Christen that's that's easy stuff but there's some cross references or either that are wrong or not made in some of these policies and that gets a little confusing in terms of wait a minute if you're referencing this and we go to it either it's not the same or not the one or whatever and I think that's the kind of thing that I think these fixes are fairly easy it's not like you know we're we're talking about massive content changes it's just making sure that we have all the right references together so Mr goleski do

027you have an example I just want to make sure that we're here's what I I don't want to table this for you know minor Corrections and then us be in the same boat next month and so um if we're going to you know potentially consider a table um it'd be just nice to have an example or two so we don't so we we're sure we're not have we don't we shouldn't discuss that andate that discuss the second piece is I just and Mr Hugh this is more for you I don't think I don't know that there's anything that's burning in here from an MCL standpoint that would put us at risk if we do table lease there really there's not be because um even even if you pass them as is like I'm using Greg's

028example while they may have different languages a little bit of different language they all talk about the1 100 monetary $100 or or less less value so they all cover the same content they just might say it a little different so I mean even if you were say hey it's a good policy accept the policy I think the the minor type of graphical errors we already have leniency uh in board uh bylaws to go ahead and make those changes without having to come to the board so correcting L uh words and uh adding apostrophes and all that stuff we can do without that but the policiy themselves as I read them I just read them again they really say the same thing it's really it really does I mean I don't think there's a a major

029discrepancy that would be a problem there but that's really up to you if you want to table them we can table those three Chuck I have a question for you if um is there is there verbiage that is specific to each of those policies because of where it sits in the policy manual meaning the one that's that's in the is Administrative um the the 10,000 numbers is there a reason like is there a a valid reason to have different verbiage there versus the version that's sitting under staff or you know like professional staff be identical that would be my very first question to Pat who is our naola rep is is there a reason why you change the language just a little bit in each one and there could be and I could come back

030to the next meeting and say yep here's the reason why uh I think would be beneficial to know um I don't I do like Greg's idea of hey if we have a policy that is the supposed to be the same but under six different I'm just going to tell you under six different sub subtitle sub sections do we have a means of saying this is policy 11130 in this section 2130 in this section 3130 in this section but it's all one policy and then we only have to update one policy and and one other thing I noticed is actually there's an a fourth conflict of interest policy it's a 01443 and that doesn't get addressed in this so that's the only thing that I I can't really weigh in on because I don't know if

031it was intended that that one also gets updated what was that policy number it's 01443 that would be under bylaws so that would pertain to the board well but a lot of these policies you know board is added in the language so again we would have to review it with Pat definitely to see if the MCL changes are relevant to board bylaws regardless of what the policy says right but I think it's a plausible question you know like again just to make it's a lot to kind of go through so just making sure nothing's missed I would love to go through a bunch of examples however um they're on my kitchen counter okay so I apologize for that but um I I can give some examples so um 6114 cost principles again I don't know

032if this is a typo or if it was intended to be this way but in the very last sentence under the section that's I'm I'll let you guys get some time to flip which section I'll read it again at 6114 what section it's the uh last sentence of the section that says determining whether a cost is direct or indirect so in in the rest of the policy it was updated from 5,000 to 10,000 in that case it's it still says 5,000 so I again I don't know if it's supposed to be 5,000 or if if it should be 10 like everything else and to me that's beyond kind of the scope of changing a comma and changing they to his her Rachel do you have any thoughts on that give me a sec I'm reading

033it through right now so the only thing I can think about here is that mde this is referencing mde and the um certain um mde agencies require special approval if it's over 5,000 like food service and example of that if you spend over $5,000 in Food Service dollars you have to get special approval for that so that's what I believe this so it is appropriate that it's different in this regard that this says 5,000 yet the others um say 10 because 10 is the federal threshold okay so I don't um if the board would like to consider I would have some requests if we do table these is that Mr Keller and Mr goleski that you meet with Mr Hughes to try to get a clean version out to the board prior to February and

034then if there's any like outstanding items that aren't just simple swapping for swapping or clarification from Rachel or those types of things I think then we'll just need a list of those and take them separately okay yeah a a lot of these things are not major content it it's a lot of cross referencing and what have you and what worries me is that if we do pass these um now we're just adding to the um chaos of trying to cross reference different policies and maybe some of them not matching up and what have you so yeah I was able to uh thank you Mr Hughes and Miss Braden for for having a copy of the policies and bylaws here in the boardroom I was able to pull up uh 01 44.3 which is the conflict

035of interest for the board so the 1,000 level policies should be for administration but they've gone through and put added board member to all the administrative policies when already a board conflict of interest policy exists so sounds like maybe these aren't coming from from niola exactly ready to roll or or maybe our numbers don't match up with theirs or changes that we made in the past just don't align with what they have as maybe a master template but okay um well we would certainly need to put a motion on the table to table this um so and just as a point of clarification it wouldn't be tabling it would be postponing postponing excuse me you are very correct we do we have to vote on the current motion can you go through the rest of

036the policies in case there's somebody else some other policy you want to postpone and supposed to put them all together are there other ones you need to go through Greg well I I think there's eight that I'm willing to move forward with but again I don't know based on everyone else's review if there's anything else that if that they had that they wanted to talk about but I can I'm happy to amend the motion um so what are those eight so yeah I uh I move to amend uh that the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the superintendent and assistant superintendent of personnel approve policies 7455 312 0.08 533 0.02 5500 and 75409 as presented a motion to amend by Mr Keller second supported by Mr Scott I think at this point we should

037if we're just going to table some we should we should postpone them all right like we're going to be in the same position in February with the ones that we didn't postpone I mean this board has had a month to look these over and get these questions asked so at at this point pulling might as well just postpone voting on the entire package but it's also important that this board discussed them with all members too so since we only meet once a month um I think that kind of displays a bigger problem but that's for another day and I mean if for example the question that we just asked Rachel I mean that there's been 30 days between when the board had these and to ask Rachel that question so if we're going to you

038do recall we were on holiday right for the last if we're going to postpone and it's postpone them all okay but wouldn't the benefit be we at least are only looking at 10 next month Mr goleski can I ask you a question as part of this discussion yes yes please are any of these outlined policies that Mr Keller has outlined do you know if they're on your list or no I have six of them can you list those um yeah that would be 655 um .08 02 um 5500 and I believe the other matching one is 754 0.09 okay there was a couple there that I I uh so for six this discussion it sounds like the whole thing needs to be postponed so he just listed off half of the ones Mr Keller that

039you I guess just to clarify or Glenn the ones that you read those are ones that you have issues with or that you are also okay with no I'm I'm I'm okay with okay yeah he's okay with the six out of the eight and and again too the the items are fairly minor um no we're not talking just about typos but we're just talking about a lot of little cross references and maybe couple of words too that maybe are not uh very definitive but um I don't think it's going to be a major roadblock to fixing these all right so we need to vote on the amended motion on the table um is there any further discussion on Mr Keller's amended motion that includes 6112 6550 7450 745 5 3120 0.02 55074 7 54.0 oh

040my gosh that last one is 75409 so Mr goleski I believe the only one that uh is in that motion that you had mentioned was 7455 are you should we should we pull that one out well let me ask did anyone else have any issue with that the only observation I'll make on50 again it was a typo where it references policy 7300 in section c it has the wrong title for what the policy is so it says disposition of real SL personal property and and technically the word personal does not EX on that policy but I think that's probably just again probably a clerical thing that could be fixed you are very correct without a board approval I would be fine with that okay any further discussion on the amended motion by Mr Keller hearing

041none Mr Scott yes Mr goleski yes Mrs Coleman yes Mr Keller yes Mrs yes Mr Campbell yes I'm a yes that motion passes second um that was supported by Mr Scott original amendment by Mr Keller we have to go back to the original so I have to close out the original motion that included all of the policies that was motioned by Mrs Shaw supported by Mrs col Coleman any further discussion on that matter so just to clarify what we just voted on was to change the original motion so so now we've just agreed to change it so it includes just those eight policies okay and then now we're voting on the amended motion perfect Mr Scott yes Mr goes yes Mrs Coleman yes Mr Keller yes Mrs Shaw yes Mr Campbell yes and now by

042yes that motion passes um Mr Keller and Mr goleski um if we could just get you with Mr Hughes and then just keep me posted on anything that would be outside of the normal change up and then we can strategize on how we move forward come February and discussing those sound good yeah that's fine I don't think they're going to be uh too major so okay I'd also like to get clarification from Pat on the um conflict of interest if we combine um or if we need to keep separate yeah and why we're not modifying the board conflict of interests by law all right moving forward item 2B contract Award Team Building and 51 building for the 2020 Bond I move that the Board of Education upon the recommendation of the superintendent and the director

043of operations approves the B approves bp10 f for the team building and bp11 a for the 51 building motion by Mrs Coleman support by Mrs Shaw any discussion I did have sorry has some just kind of a general question um I appreciate Matt Mr Marino for um giving some additional information on those projects and as well as Rachel I did want to I guess kind of clarify what the original budgeted amount was for that project because I I couldn't find it in our bond presentation I did find one that was for the 51 building I we're talking about the team building now but I think so I think you're looking at so the presentation is showing you what the budget was in the bond app for the building as a whole so that $600,000 that

044that you're referencing that was the total Bond app for 51 so that included the technology upgrades that we did that included the roofs that that was everything that's not necessarily a one for one for this project if that makes sense um the team building was in the original Bond app um it's built in that um probably in I can't I don't know if it was in the high school number the athletic number that you're referring to in that presentation that that you were referencing um but I want to say the original budget was like just over a million dollars and again that was done five years ago so yes it's much more expensive than it was back then I guess what what I was trying to understand is did the scope change because obviously I

045expect things you know prices change right but are we now doing more things that we didn't initially have planned and that's you know adding new Services well I think I can I think Matt and this is Carla she's with bar mow as well um what the 51 building is we did we did decide that we needed to do some things like the air condition in uh HVAC because it's bad and it just needs to be done it wasn't in the original scope of the 51 work and then while we're doing that we've got to rip out ceilings and we might well do the lights while they're there and we might well do the carpeting and the floors while we're there and so that kind of added to that scope so that's why that price is

046what it is to get 10 15 more years out of that building because we're not in a position to build another building at this point in time the team building uh was part of the whole overall scope of that facility um but we bid it out three times prior to this or two times for sure at $24 million for both times and we said no this one came in we said okay Carla Bart mow we got a $2 million budget like we want to we want to complete the Bond as we told the public we would complete the bond because if if you know anything about bonds if you don't then the public says wait a minute you said you were going to do X and you never did and so because we have the

047dollar set aside to do it we said let's put a budget of $2 million if it comes back that we can do it let's do it so it's came back at 1.8 million or whatever this number is in here and let's get it done because we said we would do it so that's why it's sitting before you today because the public asked for it they passed the bond we can do it now we couldn't do it at the time we we know that we can get this done yeah and and again you know I don't really have concerns necessarily with that I'm just trying to understand the original plan versus where we were at where we're at today and how things have changed um the other thing I I guess just sort of trying to

048learn more about the project I noticed that it was actually um the bids and everything were read in December on December the 3D so I guess I would respectfully ask if these can be I know that sometimes there's not going to be an opportunity to but if we can please include these as a discussion item in the the previous board meeting whenever possible the one of the and respectfully I understand what you're saying however um how we we've done the bond work today and reason why we've not done discussion is because the board already approved the bond projects the board already blessed the bond project before it went out to the public on what we're going to try to accomplish and so there's not been a need to come back and do disc discussion items

049it's the board the board whether you were on the board at the time or not the board approved it the community approved it we now are getting to it's time to do it and so we bring it right to action it so while I I can hear what you're saying discussion we may not have time because we're working hard to get the bids in get them all calculated out and get them awarded as quick as possible so that we can get these contractors lined up to get the work done so that's there's just it's it's a little different than something that's not part of a bomb project is what I'm saying which you know I can appreciate and know I wasn't on the I as a member of the public yep I I recall the

050the you know the proposal and that's kind of why I'm trying to understand where it was then versus where it is now because you're not presenting the exact same thing that you did five years so I to me it's it it changes things and therefore I do think it is worthy of having some additional deliberation so and discussion at the table yeah it's a dovetail on that so did we've we've bid the team building prior at 2.4 now we got to 1.8 has the scope or size of that building changed to get the bid down no Matt if anything we find it just a little bit um with help from the um athletic director and some athletic coaches to make sure when they did come in high we wanted to make sure we're building what

051we actually needed and so we sat down with the athletic director and some athletic coaches to discuss that to make sure we were doing um it uh fiscally responsible at that time so really it has not changed in um terms of scope it's actually maybe gone down just as a hair um to make sure we learned a little bit from when we built the athletic building over at the aux field as well as the baseball field so so what what would you see is a bulk of that you know5 or $600,000 difference between when we bid it out previously and now it decreased be clear to anybody yeah the cost of lumber decrease what is it the cost of lumber decrease cost of building materials has decreased cost of some labor has decreased because people

052have been able to find people um sometimes what we found is um some contractors were building or bidding exorbitant amounts just because they wanted to see if they could get it and we were sitting here going no that not correct we're not going to do that uh type thing and so that's why we kind of Pumped the brakes and put those previous projects on hold until we could make sure that we actually were in a good position to build these projects so Carla and and Matt this is Carla again from Bart mow uh she works with our projects um we also know that we tried to put this out with the 51 building to try to get the same biders to bid so we get a better more competitive package so that's what we were

053trying to work on as well in the hopes that the competitive packages would would come in and again when we saw 1.8 we're like okay it's a heck of lot better than what it was I don't and I think that's what we did correct yes and just to kind of like bounce off of both of them we received 26 bids for this Cate I mean that's it was really there was a lot of competition so that's probably why the numbers were so good on the previous bid we did not have that many biders we maybe had three or four and that's why we again pump the brakes on that to say no we're going to wait so are you seeing just from apartment Al standpoint the market softening a bit from a project standpoint at

054the time that we put it out was great timing we had a lot of you know we were reaching out to contractors really making sure and not only that they were familiar with you know the project before because like they said it was put out before so yeah there was it was very competitive um the numbers were close and I think that was in our favor have we done work with Midwest in the past is there anything that we currently have so as a school district we have not however as part of the pro bid interviews and things like that they have done work in the community uh they have actually built the Oola Township they've built the fire uh police station over at Green Oak which is if you've been over there is beautiful

055um they've done some $4 million projects in clarkon so they've done a lot more um outside school work uh but they are there are some local individuals in our community and so uh Barton mow is aware of that and and willing to work with them and Harland is willing to work with local community members and so kind of kind of looked at this as a win-win on both sides so yeah I love to see local contractors kind of an incidental question remind me exactly where the team building will be so it's the grass area to the south of the football field most people call it the playpen um but it's going to take that place uh over there um and it's going to increase the uh locker room usage for all the teams that we

056have using that entire complex whether it's soccer LaCrosse or uh football uh or track um it's going to be a good fit for over there that we heard loud and clear from our community so Matt is there a potential second team building that we're looking at in the auxiliary building cuz I know in the b b excuse me bond package yep there was just kind of an indication of a potential one so in that site we designed that site to allow for an additional um we're going to call it a team room not a locker room um because it has to be called something different but there is a space available able um to the west of that current building uh the utilities are sized for that infrastructure if we ever choose to do that

057in the next Bond or next thing you fund correct okay yep any further discussion hearing none again this is item 2B contract award for the team building and 51 building Mr Scott yes thank you Mr goleski yes Mrs Coleman yes Mr Keller yes Mr Shaw yes Mr Campbell yes and I'm a yes that motion passes thank you for answering the questions yeah thank you guys hi car item 3A clarification and second review of uh two po three policies excuse me policy 1241 um 5611 and optin policy um policy one 2 41 sorry pulling it up clarification on the limits of the 8mon period every two years so eight months out of every 24 months um especially given now that we've gone to four-year terms there will be a a 2-year every other um that we

058would not be able to hire a superintendent um during that time um again this is just a discussion item open for discussion um and I will add my comments at the end so there's no changes on here correct because I couldn't find any so I wasn't sure exactly what we would be discussing um I think it would be the the um and thanks for pointing that out Mr Keller it's the highlighted area um but in just respects of that first sentence I can get a revise um portion of that out to the um to the board since no one is um adding any discussion for full transparency um had the opportunity to talk with the recruiter um also had the opportunity to review some notes from um some of the conversations that had occurred um

059with some of the masb sourcing individuals that occurred a year ago in that I really want to be ensure that the board understands two things so every 24-month period now that we enact a 4-year term we would have an 8mon period in which we would not be able to employ a superintendent on anything other than an interim basis two things I want to point out in this and again this is just a discussion item so there will be no vote is that um solid superintendents are not they're looking for stability and I don't know that we would be able to find a permanent solid that would take an interim within the hopes of 8 months later actually becoming a permanent the second thing I'd like uh the board to consider is that on that interim

060basis so finding a con I'm just going to say a contracted contracted individual to take on an potential 8 10mth interm assignment that gives our district two points of transition and then much like um many of you who might be in larger Industries we all know that interm leaders don't always necessarily have the same commitment to the district or um to a company I'll you know that permanent individuals do and so um really feel like this is pigeonhole Pigeon ho holding us a little bit personally I have no concerns about the contractual periods it's really our ability to only employ an interim every 24 you know eight months of every 24 months and so that gives us 16 months um if timing works out if the stars a line where we could actually employ a

061superintendent in which is one of our duties as a board so Megan do you have any proposal to like how how do you I don't know if you've given thought yet to what you're proposing to change my proposal would be to eliminate the first sentence of the second paragraph So a thought that I have on this is obviously if if we're in extenda in circumstances the board could hire a superintendent they would just have to change the policy and therefore justify to the public why they were taking steps th those steps so I I kind of see it as a a safety measure to make sure that if we are going to do this and and do a contract right before an election that we don't just do the contract but have to justify it

062to the the public to the taxpayers and to the parents I would also be in support of striking that first sentence um as we've talked about many times and over the two years I was on the board before having a superintendent that stays um there is proof to show that it's it's all positive for students so I think anything we do to limit who can sit in our superintendent and we have to remember it's not the person it's it's the role that we're voting on and to think that if we're going to hire someone interim an election happens new board members come on we could not employ that interim and then again have another turnover um it's important for this community for our students for our staff for parents that we have a superintendent that

063we can hire that knows we are committed to them we are committed to their vision and their culture for this district and I think anything we do to limit that um I think that would be a mistake Mr Scott just to answer your question I think regardless of interim or permanent the we have to justify a new hire regardless as particularly on the superintendent front but it's not just for new hires right is for renewals as well or is that only the second part of the paragraph [Music] well it says offer a contract or extend or extend it would cover yeah I mean my my perspective is the this board has a really bad habit of giving long contracts right before elections that's why this is on here to protect the taxpayers and the community

064from changes made at that level immediately before an election so that the voice of the people can be heard at this and represented at this table so I I would um if you wanted to I I would maybe be open to the new hire part being being held out but extending a a contract for superintendent immediately before an election I I think is a really bad practice and on the contrary I would I would disagree because the people who are seated at this table when it's time to renew a contract are the people seated at this table not not who will be or who could be or who might be when an election happens so as we've seen this board has acted you know and made many decisions over the past that um with the

065people who are seated there so you know again I think it does not offer stability for this community or for a superintendent we're going to employ or for our students and staff I take this as new I guess the language as new it says extend um because we're extending a contract for employment so maybe we need to actually realign per uh sentences one and two to ensure that it's clear because in my mind they're not the same yeah I'm open to that so the board shall not offer or extend is that what you're saying you would add I guess just real quick you you had mentioned you concerns new higher yeah okay so you talked to the consultant did they give you a average timeline to hire somebody I uh I have it written down

066I do not have it in front of me but I will get you that my assumption is is probably not like a one month 16 is coming to my head and I don't know why 16 months or weeks 16 weeks probably there was okay there was no hold on there was 16 superintendent um positions open last year I believe 16 in the state of Michigan um and I wrote down their average fill time but I don't have it in front of me I'll go back do do you happen to know I I I believe we've talked about before isn't the average tenure of a superintendent three years average is three three I'll get that information though so there again why would you want a fiveyear contract I'm not asking for a five no no no

067no I know but as a community right to start out with a fiveyear if the average of three seems a bit this this could non prudent based on some of the language we read and the other policies that we postponed this could be good food for discussion with our strategic planning as well m yeah because I know Megan we' talked about kind of the timing of the contract and we we would we need to make sure that you know the superintendent's evaluation wouldn't cause a concern in terms of this policy right so I I think that's something that would well in a perfect world like perfect world any superintendent transition would occur at the end of a school like at the end of a school year not in the middle of a school year again

068perfect world um which in theory every other year would put us into this time frame so that's my concern is is that every other year we're just in this risky Zone um where we can offer stability to our district and that that's my concern I'm not concerned with the other language in the in the so for clarification uh Renee uh will um have this in the next packet as an action item with the first line of the second paragraph stricken and then that will be the policy that you vote on yeah I will can I will take a look at the second sentence and I can send out an FYI um ahead of time with my uh to the board with my considerations um the other two pro uh policies on this um are in

069regards to the most recent memo that we received that's attorney client privileged um I will not be reading that to the public um but I ask that each of you review that in detail prior to having to vote on this in the upcoming um next meeting um if you have not done so already um but open to any other discussion on that are there proposed changes um if you read the um the memo the memo is very specific on one of them and the other one is proposed changes on the due process rights [Music] will we have an opportunity to discuss this with legal councel yep so what I ask for each of you is um uh we can do one of two things dependent on the amount of questions um if only a few

070of you have questions we can do small groups with um our Council um if there's a broad questioning that is that can't be summarized for everyone we can just do a close session in February so are we rev voting on this because of the urgency of the memo yeah so we won't be voting today but in no not not today but is so a lot of the feedback that was given last time was in specific to case law and specific examples and clarification and expansion around that and so that's what um our council did and provided that in that memo May I just ask a point of clarification so was this memo generated as a result of the attorney taking it upon himself to write this and send it or was he specifically requested no

071we requested clarification after that was requested at the board thank you all righty moving on to item 3B policy changes for policy 0166 agenda these changes are outlined in policy 0166 um that puts some structure around when non-emergent I want to be very clear um Cindy do you want to talk about this one sure um so I am bringing this to the board for consideration um mainly it's that third paragraph that was added that um agenda items for consideration to the full board shall be submitted to the board president no later than five business days before a board meeting um it's been common practice for members on this board to send policy updates the morning of board meetings and sometimes as soon as two hours before board meetings which does not allow us to prepare

072for good conversation and as we saw at the December meeting for 3 hours the shell game that happen to try to get those policies correct um so this will hopefully you know limit um things being added to the agenda in which the full board has not been able to preview before the board meeting and is also not transparent to the public if those policy updates are not in the board packet for the board then Renee has not uploaded them to the website so the public doesn't know what they are either and when I was sitting in the audience in December trying to follow along with those updates um that's not how we should be operating when we're sitting at this board table so this um and then there's a couple of lines that are are

073that I struck out to on this um policy update but that's the the main reason for me bringing this policy to the board and those lines um just for clarification or because we no longer use snail mail exactly right and this does not prohibit us um as I was reading through it does not prohibit us for adding any urgent things on in full transparency and I know Mr Scott knows this cuz him and I went over at on on an actual calendar but generally speaking if a board meeting falls on a Monday I would meet with chuck on um uh the Friday before uh not the Friday before the Monday but the Friday before that excuse two Fridays two yes so two Fridays before that um or that Monday uh prior to if something doesn't

074align in scheduling and we can always wave board policy too right if something emergent needs to be added we can always vote to wave board policy as well if something needs to be added yeah we can add emergent things as we it but it still says the order of business may be altered in items added at any meeting by a majority vote which I think should so I don't understand what this policy attempts to accomplish I think attempts to accomplish structure of saying hey if we have items that you know about that you're working on that you want the agenda get them to me 5 days ahead of time so would that get it to the full board right so would that guarantee that any individual member sitting here if they as long as they

075send it within five days it's guaranteed to be on the board or on the I don't think that anything is necessarily guaranteed I think if it's flushed and and all figured out then yes if I have 75 questions for you or there's some huge operational impacts I think that if we're not ready to bring it forward but generally speaking speak I give that feedback and say hey have you thought of X Y and Z but in that case it's solely at the discretion then of a single individual and that's how it's written as the consideration to the board the board president will consider and that's why it says items can be added at the meeting by majority vote correct yes there's still a majority opportunity but I think this this should Define our Norm so

076if there's a project you're working on or something you're working working on I don't understand and and it's not urgent or there's going to be impending things that come along for the district all the time truly like um there's things that Rachel has to bring forward because you know of the way the state budget drops or things happen but I think that if we can create a standard where this has a there's a thoughtful discussion ahead of time it allows us to prepare a lot better and I can include it we can get it out in the packet we can include it to everyone as opposed to just being reactive you know what I mean so if something's added as a discussion item the day of with no notice to the board it would still

077be a discussion item and still could be voted on at the following meeting though I mean we can vote as a board to to to do a majority action regardless yeah there's nothing preventing that I mean personally I would love to see the agenda earlier and the supporting documents I mean uh I I was a little surprised when I got on the board to see that we really only have two business days on some of this one one and a half business days on some of this um and so I I think making an effort and I've I've talked to Mr Hughes about this and others and and president glack making an effort to get that to the board sooner certainly would help so we have more time to review and I think um Mr

078Hughes and I have also discussed some more transparent ways and using technology that we can create our agenda and board packages uh to sh that are going to be more um useful for the board and for the community so it's certainly any way to increase transparency Communication in that manner give us more time I would certain support any further discussion on item three yeah um there's been many instances where people have requested items to be brought onto the agenda and those requests have been continually denied and it is my feeling that why should I try again I'm just going to bring it out in the uh in the meeting and let people explain why we're not going to either talk about it or vote on on it that's what happens when you don't have the

079confidence that your suggestion is going to be given um the uh the um glance that it should be given thank you for your input Mr goleski any further discussion I I think I Echo what Mr Scott says that it's nice to have more time to prepare and I think this eliminates having to rush to figure things out in the moment uh sitting also in the audience November December and seeing things brought up although I think they were important and I supported those from where I sat there and I'm glad they were brought up but it was a lot of um impromptu discussion you could tell that there wasn't planning and and thought so I do like that idea um things being prepared for but Mr goleski I do there absolutely has to be an Avenue

080for everybody's voice to be heard um and discussed somehow so keeping that in mind as well well and if I read this it's the the agenda submission is not necessarily the same timing as when you as a board member will receive it am I correct there's no proposed change in terms of timing for the board to receive I don't see any of that written in here not that it can't be considered but I guess just drafting that language and understanding what that might look like so we can get the full edit to everyone would be helpful okay thank you yeah I think that language would be helpful cuz I know it has been it was discussed last year and kind of informally agreed to but not put into policy and and um it'd be nice

081to actually have a policy that dictates the timeline uh so that we know when to expect the information and can can put aside the appropriate amount of time to research because if we're getting you know some of this information is coming in Friday afternoon last week uh so for a board member to try and schedule time with staff uh or Mr Hughes that really gives very little time or consult uh Council whatever it is um that it's a very shorttight window and I thought we discussed this and I can't give you a date way back then but the board packets would be sent out on Wednesday before the meetings I think we had disc I don't it wasn't written in policy Mr goleski but I think there was a lot of discussion around Wednesday Thursday

082if Wednesday was impossible I think if we're going to write something in policy one thing we got to be consider of is considerate of is we just got back from break and I don't you know for instance my Friday turned into a Tuesday of of meeting because of you know staff being out and so um perhaps consideration for that December to January time frame um but it wasn't to your point Mr goleski written in policy all righty moving on to item four closed session for the superintendent midyear progress review I do want to be transparent with the public that we will be going into closed session to discuss Mr Hugh's um progress with the midyear review however we will be coming out of closed session to discuss any changes in goals or goals moving forward

083um so other than that there will be no action that comes out of after the superintendent meeting I didn't want people to think that um fireworks were going to go off or anything like that so um you can make your decision on whether or not you choose to stay or leave but we will be discussing so if I can just clarify a little bit for folks in the audience or listening at home the superintendent midyear progress review is new this year it is a two- part where part is in closed session and part is in Open session so when we return we will talking about essentially in Clos session we're talking about the goals as they were outlined earlier by Mr Hughes and in the second half we're going to talk about any goals uh

084new modified goals for the remainder of the school year so there will be some yeah there will be some discussion continued after the Clos session uh do we have a formal request from Mr Hughes to go into close session I sure do yep I received that earlier this week [Music] need to do a call all right I will be doing a roll call vote to go into Super to into a Clos session for the superintendent midyear progress review please note for the minutes that I want to call it out real quick um is it mcl1 15 268 by which this is appropriate for Clos session only to talk about the progress and to give doc Mr Hughes feedback not to and I sent a all board email not to discuss goals changing modifying any of

085that that has to happen in Open Session Mr Scott yes Mr goleski yes Mrs Coleman yes Mr Keller yes Mrs shaww yes Mr Campbell yes and I'm a yes that motion passes or we all agree to go into close session on a roll call vote we're going to go into Central e e e all right am I okay to go Jason awesome all right item five coming in from a closed session that we discuss the superintendent midyear progress review item five superintendent mid midyear progress report um just very quickly before I um before we go into any goals for the remainder of the year I will read um the consensus comments just for transparency um and then those will obviously be posted building and site on track continue progress in this area curriculum data not

086available will evaluate at the end of the school year Finance on track continue progress in this area Personnel sub goal one continued efforts needed to achieve goals sub goal two on track has been met sub goal three unable to assess data night available will evaluate at the end of the school year Dei sub goal one on track continued progress sub goal two Trend not favorable continue effort in this area health and safety sub goal one parent data reflected no change student and staff does not uh data not available will evaluate at the end of the school year sub goal 2 continued to track and monitor we're moving on to the third page of the superintendent midyear progress report in which we will now discuss goals um any goal changes for the remainder of the year

087and then um I know there were a couple of comments that I wrote down um just to remind us to discuss in um additional artifacts of evidence that we would like to see in the future um can we do you want to take them by goal sure let's start um keep them in can can I say can I say a few words first before we get into specific sure so and and I've I've discussed this with Mr Hughes and and uh I think president gach and a few others so um and I I have the privilege of being the only one who's going through gone through the Raider reliability training with this new component of the midyear evaluation so hold on no that was a requirement of us and we went through it oh you

088did with the midyear added all right sorry sorry so that was so um I guess my my thoughts on this are and and this is a question I asked masb directly whether the superintendent goals should be the same as the district goals and the answer I got from masb was no uh I think right now we have District goals and superintendent goals which are essentially the same thing and the challenge I think that brings is that most of these are already in the masb rubric that we're looking at so you know with masb 20% of evaluation is already Finance uh related deals with um the same things our goals to curriculum achievement a lot of these other things so what I'd really be interested in seeing is some and the other thing is if you

089look at the masb goal report they kind of have three goals for the superintendent and here we have 15 or 10 12 a ton and so the goal section of the final evaluation is going to be about 20% I'm not saying we rewrite the whole thing but more thinking forward if we're going to have goals set for the superintendent my thought is they need to be specific to the superintendent to achieve District goals but not necessarily the same thing and also not having all the overlap because right now it feels like it's 95% overlap with the things we're already evaluating the other thing is the goal section is 20% if if we have 15 goals then any one of those goals is only some teeny tiny portion of the of the superintendent final evaluation so

090again not looking to you know rewrite the rules in the middle of the game but specifically looking forward trying to find a way where we can make those goals really separate from what we're already evaluating the superintendent on through the rest of the evaluation Matrix but we don't set the goals Mr Scott to your point yeah um uh I think that now that the board is complete and we can take ourselves through the strategic planning really when you take a look so there has to be a myip component we can't just say the myip component in the student growth assessment data you know we we have to have some type of goal surrounding that and it has to align um but I think if you do the work and Define a strategic plan it probably

091creates a more um a better structure to have three key goals or four key goals um again plus the you know myip or whatever we do but um to then work towards those three outlined goals or we don't have that this year and I think that you said it you hit the nail on the head we can't rewi the entire game and throw out the effort that's been done but I think be more strategic in the future about okay here's our three strategic Point areas I'm just going to throw it out there we and and we want to achieve X Y and Z in the next 5 years so how do we achieve those and back into goals yeah yeah and and I'm fine you know going forward having 10 12 15 District goals that's

092great those are the goals that the whole District should be keeping Their Eyes On And then trying to really like you said key in on some specific things for the superintendent um on what what um you know above and beyond those you know the having the unmodified financial audit yeah that's great but that you know for us that should be a given and it's already addressed in the um in the uh the rest of the evaluation rubric so I'd like to find something more specific to Mr Hughes even with his input and passions and and vision we talked about this last week that we can key in on so yeah just just food for thought as we progress through this there was also two uh evidence of effort items that I wrote down that were

093um necessary um for final evaluation that I just want to be clear um is a check cross comparison for the bond projects and then a breakdown um and more detailed indications around our expulsion hearings versus incidents and our Dei goals so I do want to call those out um as two items that came up as needing additional artifact um if the team is supportive of those additional artifacts being included all right goal for the remainder of the year is there anything that we would like to modify pull attention out um understanding that we're Midway throughout the year we have fiveish months probably at this point in time to modify change anything I think that in our midyear progress report we probably identified two stretch goals that we probably just need to be cognizant of um

094and whether or not we modify those or um evaluate them as is and so I'm going to start with building and sight any modifications on building and sight so I have probably my only two modifications are building in site and um so one as we learned the the bus driver the transportation positions are not included in that goal and yet I think it's a big Focus I don't want to set something unachievable but I would like to see some sort of goal for how many of those open positions we can potentially fill that's in Personnel Mr uh well transportation is building in sight I guess so we could put it in either one so we can address Personnel then so that we don't have to go back to it okay and then my second one

095was going to be pretty simple and straightforward Mr Hughes has already got the um bid together from amen um so I would recommend a goal um something about progressing with that project and and doing some certain amount of updates to the Community or to the board on that project over the next 5 months do we need to vote on adding okay yes it has to be consensus and so I want to go back I was going to say okay you're going to go back to Personnel um well we're in Personnel right now but so let's start with Personnel um I just want to take it section by section so that we can have an organized approach to this your first comments were on Personnel in regards to the fill rate goal um and wanting to

096include Transportation but not wanting to um but a fill rate of 98% with Transportation um is probably nationally unachievable no no and I and that's why I was putting it under building in sight because building and sight oversees transportation and the transportation is through leesa so I mean it was a stretch goal at 98% anyway if you had bus drivers it's going to be way less than 68% no I I mean I'm thinking with Mr Hugh's input like what is a number we can realistically it might be two it might be three it might be one I'm not saying 98% fill rate on Transportation so so do we take a step back because I think setting the goal might just be sort of arbitrary at the end of the day right the goal for transportation

097is that you know every kid get P gets picked up on time doesn't get left at home or left at school so I mean I would be more um I guess wanting to approach it from the standpoint of that we set a goal that there's zero route disruptions or something like that that translates back to the community and then it kind of leaves Mr Hughes with the ability to kind of work towards and and put together a plan on how to achieve that goal as opposed to maybe setting a goal for fill rate that a we don't know if it's even achievable and B if it's realistic so we just talked about having 15 and I'm just putting an arbitrary number out there goals and we're going to add now goals and so what are

098we going to modify or take away is my question and and Bard I would ask you to think about this again and I and I and I think it's really important for the public to know I mean I'd love to sit up here and say let's set every goal at 100% of what we want right I think that we would all love to be able to say let's set every goal at 100% but it's unrealistic that we'll get there and so when we talk about stretch goals of filling uh all seats on the bus so that there's no more disruptions for the year I'd love beill say yeah that's a great goal and if we could make that a goal what I would hope is at the end of the year once again when it's

099time to evaluate me that the board is in tune with what is the evidence of effort that you tried to do it and evaluate me on that not eval me evaluate me on you said you're going to be 98% or 100% and you weren't and therefore you're automatically uh you know um terrible or whatever that need support or whatever that new rating is so I think that's all I caution the board is we can set goals but the board has to be realistic on what evidence of effort is going to show that we tried to get there that's the important piece for how we do business in public education so I guess what would I get rid of if I was looking at building in sight I'd say go subg goal one three and four

100I mean we've pretty much said they're done uh achieved or or they're slamed dunks so but I'm not sure we want to remove goals that were completed right that was what we set in the beginning of the those will go towards the evidence of effort at the end of the school year so to take away a goal that's been achieved and add one that hasn't been or we don't know if can if can be achieved I'm not I I don't think I support that again I'm not looking like I said I'm not looking to rewrite president gach had asked about what can be removed in its place um and and maybe instead of number of drivers maybe it's I mean even if it's a 10% reduction in the bus route disruptions I mean 5% %

101disruption 2% disruption just a goal that second semester this second part of the Year we're not going to have as big of an impact on families as we have on the in the first half of the year so let me take a different step back focus is currently on Transportation I think that's a large focus in our district we can all agree on that yes anyone not agree yes I'm not going to take a roll call on that one um two things I think if we're going to add something it makes sense to add something around the greatest focus in our in our in our district not necessarily add things to add things and so what can we come up with as a achievable goal or progress towards an achievable goal in the next five

102months we have a consultant coming in I would hate for Mr Hughes and Mr Marino to go out and do a bunch of of things that won't have a strong return if we're if we're hiring people to come in and tell us about this so how can we position a goal that creates progress in that Arena um and then I would caution the board to say we don't want to drown in goals much like Mr Scott said and have you know when you have 75 goals you really have nothing you have no goals and so we focus on that I say we recognize the two stretch goals and we'll have to come back to those at the end of the year but perhaps we focus on the transportation issue as the addition as opposed to

103try to pinpointing every little nitpicky detail in all of these District goals well anyone what I wonder is are we getting the cart before the horse if we if we're paying 30 whatever thousand for this consultant to come in and tell us here are the ways that you can improve here are the changes that you can make to make things better to retain to whatever why would we invest a ton of funding or resources or create a goal that may not be worth striving to achieve necessarily or it may not that the steps that we would that we are structurally restricted to taking right now with the way this with our system is set up are is that wasted time and effort because we're going to completely change big facets of that system based on

104what the what they tell us what the consultant says so can we come up with maybe like we did with these other goals like an artifact some other type of data or information or evidence of effort related to transportation that we can ask Mr Hughes to share in his evidence of effort report at the end of the year and then maybe um Pro not maybe definitely we'll come up with new and better goals for transportation with next year's evaluation because we'll have more information then we'll have we have more of a plan in place we'll have Direction I don't want to take Focus away from Transportation I think it's great to add something in there I just don't think right now is necessarily the best time to do it because there's so much we don't

105know from this consultant what would we want to see from that evidence progress with the what kind of pre-work do you know what kind of pre-work you're having to do with these Consultants Mr Hugh um no no uh just to give them you know the lay of the land where we at why you know the Consortium which they're aware of because they're involved in the front end of that so they really got all that so they're what they really got to do is just come on in and start talking with people seeing what it is they've got all the wage information already do you think that at the end of the school year as an artifact you could provide the board an update on the progress of that work absolutely in the in the hopes

106of that we have a full compliment of drivers going into 25 26 school year now that that's past the evaluation cycle but that's the intent what what do we know what the timeline is if we sign the agreement tomorrow when you expect a kind of a final the 90 days at a minimum minimum so I I wouldn't say to set the goal that it'd be done but I like the idea of of um setting some sort of progress towards that I mean and knowing it's already in the works but just having that be I think the idea here is having that Transportation component be a focus of the district in this next five months and making it clear to parents that we're working on it and that we've set a goal towards it I agree

107that should be something that's uh scored or graded on but um maybe a moot point because we already know that that's going to happen you know we know based on your update today that that's already going to be an artifact of evidence so maybe at the end of their report we're going to know what they say where we should be where we could be and that would be a 25 26 school year category to grade on whereas right now we don't know what the increase should be and they're going to tell us where we should be perhaps or what a goal could be maybe that'll be in their presentation and then we can use that for the 2526 school year for this is where we're at now now during this school year let's redu and

108disruption or addition of to drivers something to that effect but cuz we already know even if we add that now just another category we know we're going to have it we know we have the report so I put it on there I can document the artifact of evidence and effort that we are expecting from Mr Hughes though just as an update um in that we can also indicate in the goals for the remainder year maybe continuation of previous goals but just recognize that he's doing this work maybe not TI specific goal to it but recognize it in the formalized documentation that this work is existing and we will be given evidence of effort of the progress towards that goal uh because it's also hard to create a smart goal I guess around that if we

109don't know what that progress is but I can note it on here as an area of focus for Mr Hughes um and then artifact of evidence and data would be that he would provide us an update um and then we would expect that to be a formalized process and goal into the 252 school year so what you're really saying is if I would have held off and not sent you that report on Friday then you could have created a goal around do this and I would be able to got it get it to you see Y no I mean kind of yeah we're essentially saying we're we're kind of setting a goal that we already know is in the works but I think it what the goals we set especially the midterm goals here we

110set tonight what it could just be this one shows the the community that hey this is a focus of our district of our superintendent and hey we're making great progress towards the district goals we've set Transportation continues you know kind of creeped up on us a little bit more and so our middle of the year uh maneuver is going to be to just prioritize this this angle so what we could write in just the summary portion um and I'm looking to all of you to get Garner a consensus here is um continue progress to towards existing goals um superintendent Focus will include um development of Transportation uh progress towards development of Transportation strategy alongside consultant um for consideration of future year goal thoughts on that am I have a consensus yeah Mr goes I can't

111tell if you're saying yes or if you're just I was just listening to that whole Spiel I'm like H okay no no that's okay I'll go with it are we okay with maintaining um the progress on the current goals um recognizing that internally we know we have some stretch goals and those will have to be tough conversations that we have at the end and understand what progress is made and truly what evidence of effort is made um in achieving those goals is everyone okay with that yes yes Renee would you um are you able to pull that lovely comment that I just made out of the recording to put into our goal for the remainder of the Year okay perfect I'm going to write it and then I'll put a little note off to the

112side all right any additional artifacts of evidence or data that we are requesting I have three three items on here thus far Bond project cross comparison a breakdown of the Dei goal incidents and then progress towards um transportation strategy yep okay I am just going to take a quick roll call of support of what I've documented thus far this is just a document of the consensus comments that we have agreed to and so um would anyone like to add any additional training forgot to ask that question okay um again just taking a roll call vote on the consensus comments this isn't Megan's comments this is the comments of the board Mr Scott yes Mr galeski yes Mrs Coleman yes Mr Keller yes Mrs Shaw yes Mr Campbell yes and I'm a yes wonderful thank you

113all for your participation in this midyear review I also want to say thank you um I thought it was good conversation and I think good conversation always leads to better results so thank you okay item six informational items 6A our next meeting is February 17th at 6:30 p.m. right here in um The Boardroom item 6B does anyone have any informational items NOP item seven we are adjourned have a great night e for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.