CorpusRecord 123324

February 10, 2025, P 12 Board of Education Meeting. part 2

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Dearborn Public Schools
Date
2025-02-11
Location
Wayne County, MI
Material
Transcript
Extent
3,501 words · about 20 min
Collected
2026-06-20

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001next item please next item is Union leadership commentary this new section of the board meeting is being added to further enhance the already strong commitment and longtime partnership between District administration and all bargaining units both instructional and non-instructional union members serve on a wide variety of standing and ad hoc committees that drive the work in decision-making in the Dearborn Public Schools in addition administrator Administration meets monthly with the leadership teams of all unions as well as a group meeting with Union presidents these meetings are not required but are an extension of the collaborative partnership that has long existed in the Dearborn Public Schools this new section will further enhance the commitment to valuing all suggestions views and opinions brought forth by all staff members in the district and I'll just skip directly to see where

002we have someone okay so who we have here tonight with us is from the Dearborn federations of teachers DFT Miss Kathy Martin [Applause] good evening how are you good theater people it's nice to have support from everywhere um uh I'm here tonight to talk about building conditions um this has been an issue for a long time I understand that having the bond fail several years ago did have a negative impact on how you know buildings and infrastructures being handled in the district um however even if we pass a bond today some of these building conditions won't be addressed for years to come and we have students right now learning in classrooms that are 60 degrees um now maybe they're in and out of that room you know for an hour but teachers are in there

003teaching for eight hours we have uh actually sitting here just now I got an email from a teacher at one of the high schools who says her room is basically an inferno and there are no windows in that room and she's put in work orders but the district now contracts out to just two companies and they're under staffed and she has to wait who knows how long so I don't know what the details are um but these kids are in and out of I mean in that classroom and it's making it hard for her to teach and hard for the kids to learn we have mold issues in the district we have um rodent issues and these things would definitely be resolved with the bond however they need to be taken care of now not

004when a bond passes so I really hope that um we're able to look at each individual building and figure out which ones can be resolved right now I don't think anyone here wants their student learning in a classroom where black mold has been found and we're not clear as to whether it's been cleared out or not and to ask teachers to spend eight hours a day in those rooms we have teachers right now who are having health issues whose doctors are telling them you need to quit your job because it's an unsafe environment for you because of your health so I I mean the money should be found somewhere because this is the health of our students and our staff so I hope we can focus on that thank you Miss Martin thanks I I

005do have a question do you have a question for Miss Martin yeah yeah trust go ahead sorry when we talk about the different conditions or issues are they reported and this is a question to uh Dr moo is do we have a list of issues that you know whether it's mold whether it's a um any type of issues is there um is there a list of items that's been reported is I guess what I'm saying I have an incomplete list I have a list of the people who've reached out to me um I don't know at the district level though so safety is our our top priority and obviously we want to address issues so if you have some specifics if you send it to me and to Mark Andrews we will get on top

006of it we do have a protocol um depending on what it is because there were different um things mentioned here uh that we would look into it address it and bring in contractors I mean there's a lot of different things like I know for example in one of the schools you know uh the roof um needs to be replaced or portion of it so there was water leakage so they addressed it you know I think the teacher had to move for a certain point in time just as one example um but I appreciate the collaboration with Miss Martin if you could send us those uh things there are things though when I go to um like chatting events and I'm saying like a lot of things that requests that are made for example I was

007telling people this example uh there's things that we probably should replace but what we're doing is prioritizing you know boilers and heating and electrical and things that you have to like you would in your home uh versus like requests for bleachers and new things that we probably should have but we just don't have the funding for and we did talk about you know how we're funding some things today in the uh finance committee meeting but if you could send me a list then obviously we'll look into it I know there's ever uh mold or some other specific safety issue Danielle's on top of it we bring in Consultants we bring in contractors we look to it we make sure we're in compliance with all the you know the state and federal rules and you know

008to make sure people are safe but I can understand their concerns and I would just say this is another reason why we are also talking about a potential bond in the future because we do not have infrastructure funding from the state as was discussed in the finance committee or the federal government so we need to to find another way to do it and uh while a bond may be longterm it's something that we need to do you know now for the future but in the interim I know Mr wall and his team and we discussed it today they find ways to uh use our general all we have now is our general fund which most of it does go you know for uh the people that work uh work in our district but I do

009know that Mr wall is always bringing what can we put on and put more money into infrastructure um as well so I appreciate you bringing these forward and we will definitely and and the collaboration we always uh are trying to work together and of course we want students and staff to make sure safety is number one I just want to add to that it's it's when we say there's issues I would prefer there's a reportable mechanism a reporting mechanism so we could track them and then I agree with you the bond is you know for major infrastructure but if there is any safety issue mold or anything like that that's where they get prioritized but if there's a reporting Mech a way for teachers to report issues and it gets to the say something see

010see something say something there is a ticketing system I believe yeah what was that kind we can have Mrs Z come and address some of the concerns as far as addressing good even somebody reports an issue infrastructure so as far as reporting mechanism we do have an air quality Complaint Form and we use that for anybody in Dearborn schools can f fill this form out it gets reported through the engineers and then we take a look at it and if it's something that needs to be tested so if it's something like mold or um something that just smells in the air that the teacher would report we do have an environmental consulting company that comes out and they do testing and they give us recommendations and then we follow up and make sure that the

011recommendations that were given are um followed and if the room needs to be um vacated while that work is being done then we ask the teacher to relocate we work with the school to relocate the teacher and then once the room is safe to be reoccupied we make sure that the teacher can go back in the inside of the classroom so we do have all of those mechanisms in place it's just that I do want to say one thing too about mold so the EPA and the state do not have a mold threshold and the reason for this is because mold is forever changing mold gets um will grow when it's hotter outside it gets less active when it's colder um in a place or a space and so like if I were to test

012my home today it would come back positive for mold guaranteed and that's the reason that there is no threshold because mold levels are continuously changing so you could test something for mold today temperatures change environment changes and then the test for mold tomorrow would be different so we just try to work with our buildings and trades guys and operations and um the testing company to just make sure that we look at each situation and try to clean up as much as we can so when Mo sorry when mold is discovered we do address it immediately yes we get it tested and then the environmental company gives us recommendations we make sure that the recommendations that we're given are followed through and um try to remediate the issues trusty Watson so I think part of this

013was already um kind of discussed I was just thinking if I were a teacher and you were saying that there is a reporting system is this Reporting System electronic or is it a paper Reporting System it's electronic and paper you can do either one so they can do both yes Some people prefer to email it to us some people prefer to send it in her school mail okay um yeah so it could be done either way reporting it up to the principal and then like then the principal we're waiting for them to it usually goes through the engineer okay so it goes straight to the engineer so it's normally some teachers like to fill it out themselves and send it to me okay and we don't want to tell them that they have to go

014through somebody it's it's fine if I get it from the engineer we take a look at it if I get it directly from the teacher we take a look at it if I get it sometimes I'll get it directly from the principal so um so for instance if I had like a classroom that those extremely hot so I went on my app or my on the form and I said it's really you know it's it's got so hot and there's no windows what would be then the turnaround until I would hear back from somebody saying I acknowledge this and I'm sending somebody out okay Heating and Cooling yes not my I think okay I'm going to call up Mark Andrews I'm just thinking what would the turnaround be so that they would be able to

015so it's normally the engineer would start a ticket for something like that and then they'd get the HVAC guys out if it's something that they can take care of right away they do okay correct so good evening so yeah we have a separate work order system for heating cooling issues and other building issues um and we would direct those to the building engineer we always like to have the building Administration a part of those conversations so they know what's going on in the building as well would like to add to um Miss El added the form we use is recommended by the EPA so it's a Google doc and it can be either done electronically or printed and done by hand but it is a document that the EPA um suggests to use okay so

016it sounds like the teachers would have this tool that they could put in a work order and what would be the turn around until they would so every year trusty Watts maybe even twice a year I send out um classroom classroom tips and guidelines and then that Google doc is goes out to the entire district and that Google doc the air quality Complaint Form is actually linked in that document so it's shared with staff about twice a year okay so my question would be like in the morning I'm it's you know it's ungodly hot in my classroom um and if I put in that request would I be able to get some sort of reprieve or fans or something very shortly to start helping with the temperature control so a lot of options I'm one

017if like if there's Windows you know that'd be something that the Billy could look at again we like to have the building Administration involved because yes you know there's times where we might our hbac technicians we have three I'm going to plug in we'd like to hire more in the future but we understand right now we can't um so they could be overwhelmed and you do it by a priority right so and or first come first Ser but they you know we try to get to them within at least a look at them within the same day but as far as resolving them it it can depend on what parts are needed what's the cause of it so a lot of times with our older buildings there's late lead times you know can be a

018couple weeks to get the proper parts that's why we like to work with the building administrator and see if we can relocate them even for classroom that's too warm okay truste Barry and then Martin brings some issues that we've heard about before but I want to concentrate I want to make a comment uh I don't think anybody's qualified to look at something and call it black mold I mean this is just I mean for my industry I know that for a fact but uh what I'd like to see is you communicate with m z or Dr Malo or both uh what buildings this is at and let's get it inspected because black mold is very serious and to allege out there on this world that you know we have black mold in our buildings uh

019it's alleged a it came from a report well that but okay came from a report but we we just need to be there's some responsibility some responsibility on us here not to put that out there that there's black mold because that's some very serious stuff just have let's let's just get this please Dr Mal Co thank you trusty I I think what trusty aljami was kind of alluding to um do we have any kind of spreadsheet so to speak of what's going on in every building when these kinds of work orders and or air quality complaints so that there's like a master list that somebody can look at and maybe just like we've done in the past for where we're at with schedules of construction um projects and what could we have something that would

020somebody could look at and track and say okay this is where you're at with this building this room this issue kind of thing so that it can be followed a little more transparently so with uh the building issues outside of the air quality the work order system you can run a report to see what that's why we're very strict about making sure Engineers submit a work order so that's in the system and it can always be tracked about what's you which room when it's been done and what the problems were when it was logged in corre and how Andre where it's at and Mr walls we're we're moving to another system electronic system from we do kind of bigger projects we can track what um infrastructure improvements have been made in the district as well

021okay that's great yeah trusty sorry I'm conf I'm a little bit confused who so there is like some Central system of work orders tickets whatever who submits those so in other words can a teacher directly submit a work order or a ticket or does it have to go to someone in the school first who then submits it so the building Engineers are some build some buildings our middle schools and and um our high schools have two building Engineers our small elementary schools only have one Elementary unless you're at like Henry Ford Elementary um so the building engineer are the ones are responsible for submitting a work order okay and so okay so how does it work before that so I'm a teacher in the classroom I what write an email to the engineer I talk

022to the engineer or whatever and then the engineer submits the work order so we leave it up for the billing administrator for each building to uh um make the rules on how to report it most of them like to keep it through an email it can be done verbally really so but email is what what a lot of Administrators prefer so that it can be recorded as well that way why don't teachers directly submit a ticket or workorder it's a complicated system and we so the person that has to do it we want to make sure that it's done properly and it goes to the right to the right people can we have a I mean the reason I'm asking is just like so somehow we can you know maybe one day track okay this

023a many or this many requests came in instead of there being some informal system before it gets to the engineer you know maybe there can be a system where a teacher or someone in the building submits something through the system and then it gets approved by the engineer whatever since it's a complicated system right I'm sure the teacher can figure it out though and so uh um you know just so that we really know so we have metrics right so we can hold everybody accountable at every step also to protect against people making too you know that way you know if people are making too many requests and make too many silly requests whatever but just so that there is some way to track everything from the beginning seems you were hitting it a little

024bit there why would you like the building engineer because a lot of times it's something that can be small and and because part of their job responsibility is to take care of problems in the building so that's one of the reasons why we like to directed to the building engineer so first they're aware of the issue so things aren't being submitted without them aware of it two a lot of times they can investigate it you know they all hold boiler license so they can look into the system sometimes it's an easy as just make an adjustment on our buildings that are newer that have um controls our electronic so it might just be a matter of it the schedule needs to be reset so there's there's a lot of reasons why we like it to

025go through the building engineer so they're aware of it and they can make sure that even when our trades come out that they can help the trades show them where the problem is and what the problem is and I already started the investigation no I understand all of that I'm just saying you know maybe we have a system where something gets approved by the building engineer before it gets further whatever but sounds like right now there's no formal system formal uniform system of a complaint getting from a teacher to the to the engineer in the building is that right correct their teachers AR they don't have access to and we can look into expanding it to them for sure okay and then my other question Kathy is how long has all this stuff been going

026on in the schools since I've been hired however um things don't come to me right when it first happens so usually like the person who contacted me has gone through like I'm only talking about today I'm not talking about the reports I have you know in the computer she has gone through the proper channels and said that I'm basically her last resort um and I will say when I get involved things do get resolved so it's not like stuff you know it continuously gets pushed aside but you know for the past two weeks she's had a sweltering classroom with no windows um but I mean we've got old buildings so some of the stuff is it it just it is what it is you know I've brought heaters into some of my rooms I you

027know sometimes stuff you can figure out how to work with it but some stuff I can count off the buildings but you know some stuff you can work around but other things it's just difficult and it's hard it's one thing for you to be struggling but to have a whole classroom of kids who are lethargic and have their head down and you're trying to teach it's kind of tough to me this just kind of highlights how we all need to everyone everyone we all need to get on the same page because you know these schools are these kids' homes for eight or 10 hours a day and so we need to make sure that we all get on the same page so that when we do submit a bond to the to the community um

028it's been well reached researched well uh um thought out and has input from everybody so that it passes overwhelming I really do believe that it'll pass overwhelmingly if we get everybody on board from the beginning so I thank you for bringing all this up and being a voice for our teachers trusty wats so I I think this was all great discussion as well because I'm sure that there's probably some program out there or some way to be able to be transparent so we can see when the reports being made but I think also as a teacher like two things number one you want to be able to say like this is the status of what is happening and how long it's going to happen but the other thing is sometimes some teachers like a nice

029colder classroom some like a warmer classroom so it's also a personal preference but you also know which room is that room in the school building and you kind of paper rock as to who gets that one so I think everyone knows who that who has that one classroom in the building um but all of that said I think that having a transparent document that people can look on there to say like or just the email saying this is when the part's ordered this is how long it's going to be it helps you then plan accordingly with your students yes and then you can then go ahead and know like it's going to get fixed this is short term and my needs are being met so J um just to piggy back on the trustees he

030made a good comment if we have a list of issues it's easier to justify the bond because you know the different issues that's happened but I was just going to share my experience um um for tracking things of this sort usually similar to a help Des system um and sometime help Des system could handle there which all you have to do is uh you know make a service type of building issues and this way you have a trackable item you could justify it later on to say we have buildings with heat and problem ventilation and and so on but it gives you a trackable but I I I understand it has to go through the engineer because they have to sign it and create a work order so I I get that part but there

031is easy ways to report those similar to help that system and they're not very expensive trusty Barry trusty Zar did I hear you say that teachers can figure it out I think imagine that I think so but on more serious note uh I mean we've experienced before where the engineers kind of run the building and and you know don't pick on Kathy here Kathy's a troublemaker in this building she's always pointing things out she's always pointing out and they sort of kind of make an executive decision on needs to be done or not done so I can't imagine I I don't remember the last time we disciplined an engineer custodian for not following protocol somehow I mean there's one particular building we had the same problem for over a decade two possibly three different principles

032couldn't figure it out so yeah you're right I mean there's got to be a process where if I'm a teach teacher and I send it to my building administrator or my engineer and doesn't happen there's got to be somebody I can reach out to directly so I agree with that think that feedback can definitely be taken back to Dr Malo operations to discuss a way of tracking those requests and we'll put it on cabinet agenda for tomorrow discussion and see if there's any with technology and things of a workflow system that maybe we can do what you're saying so yeah just just to re to sorry I just to reiterate just one more time is that the same system be from the teacher's desk all the so so the teacher right and again there can

033be stop like stop measures right so if the engineer can like stop something or go back to the whatever I understand that the engineer on site is the one who is obviously more and obviously we want most of the communication to happen in the building I mean they're the ones that are on the ground and know what's going on but it just seems to be to create transparency and accountability across the board from A to Z if the teacher can be submitting a request right away or sorry I mean into the same system that the engineer is going to do it to so that everything is tracked from the beginning so no one can ever say hey I didn't get request hey uh the engineers not listening to whatever it just creates all transparency and

034accountability from the from the top it just seems to make and it would just probably solve a lot of conflicts too I imagine and and also I would say just our teachers have a lot on their plate to begin with it to make an easy system that takes 30 like something that takes 30 seconds it should not be very comp complicated to put it in order so and I and I think it's a good idea we do the same thing for field trips it starts the form goes and it goes to different people throughout ends up with me actually this one ends up at the board at the end just getting the notification so it's an example thank you good ideas thank you thank you Miss Martin it's great discussion

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.