001next item is discussion item that is a first budget amendment for 2024 2025 with Mr Thomas wall good evening again um I I try to do this in five minutes but I won't do it so I just get get you off of that expectation you always got to manage expectations with the audience you're with um as part of our normal budget heing process uh we do our first budget amendment at this time frame and actually you'll actually approve it at the next board meeting but this is just a discussion so we can have a discussion what it's all about um if you look on the screen this is our budget calendar so our budget process usually starts in January for the next fiscal year 2526 and our first step is for our purpose is to
002do our budget amendment because we do a budget adoption by July 1st and when we did our budget approval back on June 3rd of last year it was based on a lot of estimates because the state law was not passed at that time uh so now that we actually have our student count all the revenue is kind of figured out by the state how to handle it we update our budgets and we bring it to the board for formal adoption so this is basically our current operating program we're doing for the 2425 school year now as in the calendar the state has started their process for next fiscal year so we kind of look at where we're at now taking what the state information is going to be coming forward for the next several months
003we start developing our budget for next year but this is the part we look at for today is just the adoption of the First Amendment you'll see on the days that we'll be meeting again constantly talking about this um our next big one is in April we'll look at a first look for next year because we'll have a better idea what the economic factors are and where the state is going for next year's budget but looking at this year again this is I always like to lead off with this screen showing you where all the money is in the fund on a pictorial basis we have our Capital project fund which is restricted our debt funds was restricted our special Revenue funds we have more control over it but it's based upon the individual grants
004or the funding source and then we have the general fund that kind of captures all the remaining funds in that that's mostly our operational budget if you have questions feel free to rup me as I go along it won't be as fast as Dr bar I won't speak that fast uh a big component we have three big components obviously state a student count and our compensation those are big things we always want to make sure we look at when we look at the operating budget last year we were in June we actually expected to increase slightly by 41 kids that's on the Blended count now we have two counts once in the fall and once in the spring actually kind of winter more like it now um February 12th is the upcoming one the counts
005are based on the calendar year so we're looking at last February of 24 count and this Falls 24 count account to get our true revenue for this school year um our actual count was 385 kids less than we expected from our budgetary projection now with that and the actual decrease we add those two together we're actually at a shortfall that'll look at a future screen on the actual Revenue because we get our our foundation allowance of 9,921 per pupil uh just looking at the pictorial for all funds um you can see the majority of our funds which is the yellow comes from the state of Michigan uh since proposal a passed in 1994 most of our money comes from the state prior to that it was local elections that we would handle for our own
006Villages but now majority of our money comes from the state recently a lot of money has been coming from the federal side too Esser funds and we're just finishing it up this year with a little bit of construction funds that ended September 30th so that you'll see that actually phasing down as we go forward but if you look at our total budget you can see our amended budget is $463 million that's broken down here more by categories and numers so you can see percentages a little better same information from the other side but this is just looking at the revenue side now and you can see that for all funds that majority of the money comes from the state on the right hand side the amendment of roughly 290 million you'll see the state on
007the left side we originally projected 278 million and you ask why is that number higher when we got less money from the state for our foundation is Grants State has now moved to more of a grant discussion as we talked about in the past and you can see the federals roughly about the same but you'll see that going down next year as the Esra funds move out looking at the just the general fund which is our operating fund you can see that roughly about 73 to 75% of our money is from the state so the state does make up a large portion of that the other portion as big is the blue which is local as we as part of our foundation allowance even though we get $992 per child we are required to Levy
008that 18 Mills on non-homestead property which is the businesses the total of that the blue and our foundation allowance make up our full $992 so just realize that that's even though it's the local portion it's still part of that 9,921 people you won't see a large variance between the two but just so you're aware of how the larger portions work out looking on the expenditure side you you can see we spend majority of our money on instruction that is the basic classroom which is in the classroom we spend the majority of our money in the classroom as we kind of philosophically planned every year so when every time we do adjustments the classrooms are usually the last ones that we adjust to make sure that students have the resources they need in the classroom the
009only thing you'll see slightly here Al is the increase in transfers that we'll get a little further on in discussion of why that is happening this is just broken down the same thing in the general fund but broken down more by different categories so you can see that on the bottom part of the expenditures that you'll see that our salary projections were pretty on on online with what it was roughly about 130 million of the 267 which is roughly almost 50% is based on just salaries the next three items benefits biker retirement workers comp another 35% of our budget is based on the benefits you look at that total we're about 85% of our operating budget is spent on salaries so again that's our third component so that's something we always have to be aware
010of so when we look at significant changes uh if you remember I recalled I said that we adopted our budget before the state a is passed and unfortunately last year they kind of took a a left turn on how they were funding it they were promise promising money for us in our P Foundation allowance our most likely scenario we do three different scenarios as we go through the process best case worst case and most likely we adopt the most likely as we get through forward to the end of the adoption process we expected $2 $241 they gave us zero so that was a significant change of roughly about a $4.7 million loss they were going to take away some of the grants enrollment stabilization was one of the grants but they gave it back to
011us miers which is our retirement fund is where they really started messing with dollars as you can see some of those numbers are pretty big so them messing with dollars could really impact us unexpectedly on an individual District than what they see at the state level fortunately for us it worked out to our benefit and taxes uh if you remember we had that issue where they didn't L some the taxes the prior year so that's why it's higher in the subsequent year so the net effect was roughly about a $6.4 million increase in Revenue which was good for us now granted some of the taxes were a one-time Revenue but for on a single year basis it was good but on the next count you see we're student count our other big piece we always
012talk about is that we actually lost the total of 385 plus the 41 so roughly about 426 kids we lost revenue for because we have a lower student count that was about a 4.2 million doll loss so nting those two we are about roughly about $2 million higher overall from on look on the general fund change looking at staff compensation you can see you know budget actually was pretty good again we could control that one so it's easier to forecast where we're at now are we higher than staff because we lost those 421 kids yes but we usually don't make those kind of adjustments in the same year because that means moving teachers out of their normal classroom kids being reassigned we don't usually do that we roll that into next year's work of figure
013out how to balance that number if we're too high other expenses only bigger things is Contract Services are up you know we have older buildings we have to spend more money in our maintenance and operations and we also have uh we're doing those Consultants this year for the communication of reaching out to the public on the potential Bond that's that's in that cost also with that $2 million surplus we're actually moving some of that money over to our building and site fund again to handle some of the repairs that we need to get done so I know the community is not going to be able to read this but this just gives you a larger picture of looking at the original and the other Amendment side for special Revenue funds uh just beware that you
014can see most of them are balanced you know for Grant purposes you know we getting grants we only expense what we have so there really isn't a common go you'll see that the food service and Adult Ed are the only ones that really have a fund balance because they operate on a year-to-year basis they could have a loss or a gain in any given year so that's why you see a little bit of fund balance but most of the other funds the Student Activity fund funded projects and act 18 are all self-balancing we only get the cost that we can that we spend and we get reimbursed for those exact costs [Music] you'll see in front of project that little three it's on a screen later but I'll kind of touch on it now uh
015you'll see that we originally estimated 84 million actually came in 104 million again there more grants that came up as the year progressed we applied for them and received them so a lot of those are grants that we applied for one of them was the V Ed grant that we got for expanding Michael Barry for their construction trades and autot Tech you'll see another one that we received received was for Energy Efficiency from the federal government we applied for that renewed America that we had to do and you'll see some other ones that I'll mention later looking at the this is just a general fund side by side we kind of went over those numbers but just kind of give you a comparison if you want to get in further detail um you'll see here
016for the overall all funds you'll see the debt fund that right now we're at 1.35 Ms when we originally went back out in 2019 for the bond we at 4.82 so that number has dropped as bonds have come off and that 1.35 until 20134 will continue to go down slightly as we get near the 20-year Mark for the original 2014 bonds the other one is the capital projects you'll see that there's roughly 8 million in that Asser funding that's the federal portion that finished up in September 30th is still in this fiscal year and next year you'll see that rolloff so just looking at this I've already talked about the erss and debt funds so some of the other was that 12a that's the energy Improvement bonds 74b infrastructure we applied for a grant to
017help offset our electrical buses infrastructure that was accepted uh the 994 9995 is the vocational Capital Improvement in Green Schools 31aa we got they were originally going to cancel that one at the last second they came back and extended it for mental health 31n was for mental health H for mental mental health so we are AB you know looking out there for any grants that we can get to help offset cost for the district stronger Connections mental health and 21st century which you approved at the last board meeting is tutoring uh normally access has done that in the past but the state has limited the number of buildings they can help so they asked us to be a Fiscal Agent so we're running the program collecting indirect cost but they're still running the program as
018a subcontract that was quick so I'll open up anytime you have questions I met with Jamal earlier today we went through spent an hour just going through budget items always glad to do that it is a broad big area and it's hard to be you know an expertise and everything but you need to have that General understanding I'm always glad to meet with you and go over it trusty P okay the elephant in the [Music] room we hear a lot of instability right now coming from the federal right side and a lot of these grants energy improvements electric buses Capital Improvements I'm assuming are federal grants correct since we can't be reassured right now that we're actually going to get that money in the bank I know my understanding from what I'm hearing and reading
019is is that we're probably okay for right now for things that we've already correct for this year we're good yes we're good how much of these projections can we withstand some seismic shifts coming from Washington DC and potentially from Lancing um number one and number two and I'm going to kind of mix the question my understanding when we lost the 400 so student count that we eventually got back a number of those students but we did not get the funds correct follow with them I thought originally laning had changed that so that the F the money would move with them if they came in after so let me give you a little what's going on with that so we have firm you know dates that we collect student data and any given day it's done
020across the whole state of Michigan so they can know where every child is on a given day if they were in another schol school district prior to us so if they came in after our count day we get a proportional credit for that and you'll see that as part of the student counts you'll see 23A those that kids that transferred they might have started in Crestwood but then came to here and vice versa they started here for our account date and they went there afterwards they get a perational amount up to the secondary count date those kids are accounted for but those kids that were never in public schools this year those are students that would not be in our count because they came in after the count day the state was promising to do
021a supplemental for us for those districts that had that happen because they knew the refugees were coming in or coming from out State because of you know issues outside of their control they just traveled later that they were going to give us a supplemental and that was on the agenda to be approved in December but unfortunately things kind of blew up and everything nothing got passed so the money there is extra money in this school year we don't know if they're going to still do a supplemental or not with the new legislator they're still working through their Kinks and so we have not heard anything about those additional students my understanding there about 385 kids that could be counted that we get a perational foundation allowance for so I just I wanted to make sure
022that our community members understand that while it sounds like we lost this amount of students we really didn't lose them it's just a the accounting right um Sor the financial support we get from the state does not allow us to count those kids for funding we actually didn't lose that many of students at the end of the day okay so that I wanted to clear up and then we're back to a lot a lot of this uncertainty right now in our political landscape with um a lot of our funding um are are we prepared to weather the storm so to speak well that's one of the things that we're going to have to make some assumptions because right now any Grant that's coming forward we were going to talk about American schools in the finance
023committee about whether we could apply for it again because there's a 25% match and unfortunately we don't have necessarily the operational money to match that that we were considering going into our fund balance to match that to do some school improvements so basically getting $4 to $1 doll on that money they end end up pulling that off just today they pulled that off the shelf and Clos that window because that was due in April now it's not even open so we don't even know if it's going to reopen again uh the other things we're seeing now is language being associated with federal grants that if you're going to apply for a Federal grant you've heard some of the White House Executive offices you can't offer a Dia program right and if you're doing it you're
024not eligible for the grant and they said they are going to audit districts or any grantees to see if they're actually are or not doing that so now it comes into the question whether we can even apply for federal grants so as you're also aware you know the states are following lawsuits one after the other opposing some of these you know White House mandates that are coming through so where it's all going to end I'm not sure but what we're going to do is look at all our grants especially the federal ones and see if we don't get that what the impact is now that impact will affect next school year right so as we go forward we'll have to make the assumption that we're not going to get that and have to figure out
025how to handle it because some grants do have staff in it and we don't want to lay off staff so that means they have to roll into our current Staffing and maybe we look at those that are retiring we don't hire new people we roll those people in so it's going to affect a lot of different departments HR might not be able to hire things like we like to hire early get the cream of the crop from the graduating classes we might have to not look at that this year so those are the things we're going to have to decide as Administration and board where we're going to go with that and how it's going to impact next year's budget this year we're fine but it's next year it's going to be the issue yeah
026all right trusty Wat so two things what is the current fund balance percentage 11% you mean the rainy day what's yeah we have a certain percentage that we always like to so when you look at the general fund um it's the 37 million 639 is our fund balance on the oh sorry wrong side 30 million is our fund balance on the amended side out of a 283 million so you're probably just under 10% and what does the state like us to have what is best practice uh well if we're under 5% if we're under 5% we're going concerned and then we have to start filing reports with the state of Michigan to show how we're going to get out of that okay so we're the recommendation is usually anywhere between 5 and 20% okay I
027was going to say we like it around 15 our own board policy it says 5 to 20 anytime we're over 20 we're expected to work as a group to figure out how to get it back under 20 okay so we're at 10% and I think you had already mentioned this um and I know that this is what I'm doing my position is looking at the language for those grants to start looking through the application to see what sort of verbage right they're they're hunting for yes okay matter of fact we have I just talked to Jo put some language on the cabinet to start talking about do we even qualify or not qualify you know I I don't know necessarily know every single program we do so that's something we're going to work as a
028group effort to see if we are and if we want to be what's the compliance we would have to take I was going to say are we going to have our legal maybe start to have to wait in on some of this if they're more up to speed about what's going on it's something we're going to have to consider we're going to have to consider yeah trusty Barry yeah let's clarify student count Tom Mr wall the students that we lost they're not the same students that came into our school dist correct correct because we were based on students they were here for the February count of last year is what we do as a projection correct but I mean I heard earlier it was a good question that was asked it's we're not losing we
029didn't lose any students we we lost the students we had last year but more new students came because what's going on on the other side of the ocean is you know like if we didn't lose the students that we did lose we would be up 400 students yeah I don't know if we're actually they could have been a student just came in yes yeah I just want to make S um f me farage and Ros they were tracking every student we do have some for example that they didn't come back they were in our district last year but they didn't come back at the start of the Year normally the that's not the 400 students no not not all of them not that many PE not that many families went overseas during all this trouble
030going on what we looked at though with the data and again every situation is different um but they would count for one or two reasons if they weren't enroll and this is what the supplemental was going to be and then it blew up during the lame duck um was that if they weren't already enrolled in another District or if they were enrolled in our district and just didn't re didn't come into class before the October 10th they would have counted but you are right there were different reasons we've looked at previous years and this was an odd year um it was not within the norm because we generally would get 70 to 80 students that would come within that time frame and this year it was about 380 so it was an odd phenomena again
031we can't say for sure on each individual but was the data showing that it wasn't within our Norm I just want to make sure that the discussion that we've had before that we're bleeding students oh with the that's that still exists we need to keep an eye on that we can't just say oh student count was low but now it's okay because it's different different students yeah we're losing students at the high school we look good at the elementary levels but the high school is and we've had some that are going online in other places that was virtu you're right we don't want to say to the community that oh yeah no no we're good over there no we're not good we need to have that discussion sure absolutely but this was just a unique
032phenomena that we were trying to work with the legislature to get the funding for our students sure and the problem most likely we're not going to get these funds we're still going to Advocate we're going to Advocate but the reason we're not going to get these funds we're probably one of the very rare districts that this happened to well we do have support from some of the educational organizations for this so I'm hoping that we can use those I mean I don't want to sound negative but if this was a Statewide issue you'd have more we'd have more sure yeah I mean the fact that we got guesstimating about 400 students because of what was going on overseas maybe a local another District got 40 maybe a district out in Oakland County got a couple
033hundred where the minority in that discussion that's why sure right it's only 2% of our student count but still it's a large number large large a large amount any other questions for Mr W and I always again anytime one wants to get further deep into a certain section I'm more than willing to do thank you for what you do and congratulations again congratulations again you got a fun job it's not an easy job next item please okay next item will be acknowledgement of Correspondence now we did receive um a letter today that you I believe you all have from Mr Dugen right Dennis dou um all of the emails that we received about Personnel have been responded to uh accordingly with Dr Malo so thanks to all parents and citizens who have corresponded with us
034next item next item is board member committee and organization reports I uh Finance uh committee did meet I I was sitting in for treasurer D Ambrosio and um the items that were discussed were the amendment um to the budget as well as um the explanation of the budget that Mr wall just did uh he did also mention the renew America competitive Grant which is needing a 25% matching fund and possible usage of the fund balance for that that's to be looked at um there was also the banking services there will be an RFP for that service um so we can get a better better rate from the banks believe that was any other item trusty trusty Legal Services on the agenda but we didn't get we didn't have enough time to get to that today
035okay we are looking for for information on that yeah thank you uh any other committee reports trusty Barry the policy committee also met earlier I sent out an email earlier today asking my colleagues that if there's a certain policy you want us to get through this year please share it with uh Mr musen and myself also I CC we had Joan circulate the minutes of the study session from uh February 28 2023 we kind of want get on the same page on some of those uh policies that were discussed some we were got updated on some we were still looking for information but we will get to it some of the items on the agenda was uh board meeting agenda regarding citizen participation yes Mr President uh the discussion we had is we're going to
036keep it the same but give you flexibility give the president flexibility to move things around okay if there's uh what this is uh we're talking about here if we get a room full of uh our constituents or students the president will have the right to move citizen participation of the agenda okay yeah just just so that we're following Robert's Rules he really needs to um entertain a motion entertain a motion that sure sure but we're saying that's always been his prerogative sure sure the other thing we president's prerogative the other thing we discussed is the self phone search uh protocol and all that was was just kind of updating and educating our staff on the protocol and at the same time moving forward we're going to try to figure out we're going to follow up
037on how do we educate our students on their rights when it comes to search protocol uh placement of administration was also discussed administrators now that was we're just updating the policy to kind of like mirror state law was there anything else okay thank you that's all I have Mr President okay thank you any other committee reports seeing none we can go to the next item please the next item is board member and superintendent commentary I do have some commentary but I'll wait for anybody to say any commentary trusty I just want to um I'm sure a lot of you know Mr B who works at at so for he's a counselor um a great person a good friend and I just want to send our prayer to him he's um he had a heart attack
038and our heart goes to him and his family we wish him the best of health and it's really uh I mean he's the kind of person that always gave a genuine person a person that cared about our kids and impacted impacted the the community in so many ways so we want to wish him the best of health and you know we wish him to be back at etel forward and continue what he's doing absolutely all prayers to Mr vun and his family uh trusty zah yeah um I would like to bring up something uh to the superintendent that we talked about briefly before but I also brought up at our uh College meeting last month and and that is how we classify and count uh our students and how we look at categories especially racial
039and ethnic categories um uh I know that we have a software system I believe called myar in the schools that keeps the profile of the students and one of the things that it tracks is um race or ethnicity and for the longest time Arab Americans were absent or invisible from these things uh counted as white Under federal law that seems like it's being rectified by the federal government as of March of last year but still for um you know uh educational institutions from uh direction from the Department of Education have been able to add more categories to these things if they wanted to so what I'm asking is that if we can get a clear answer of what are the categories that are currently depicted on the myar system and how um they're currently classifying
040students and to update it to reflect our population so if there is not a box for Arab American American or the government uses Middle East North African which I don't like but whatever that's what they use if if uh if there's not a box for that that we ask a software company to add a box for that and to add sort of specification boxes beyond that we have a unique population and um we can we should get the proper data so we know exactly how to um address all different concerns in our district so uh that would mean if we do have a box uh for let's say Middle East North African or really any other thing that people can specify beyond that um let's say what country they're from or whatever and very importantly
041that they can check more than one box you know we are in increasingly uh diverse and uh you know quote unquote mixed you know we have a lot of mixed families and all that kind of stuff so it's important that also students can uh classify for themselves or their parents do it more than one category if necessary I know sometimes I you know I teach this class and or teach us stuff at school and people get confused sometimes where you know how can you have four people in the room and have you know three of them be white and three of them be Arab well and there's only four people well you know somebody married somebody so you have somebody that is a uh a member of more than one racial someone can check more
042than one box so we need to have those uh uh things available so we can have an accurate depiction so that um we know right away when we're speaking and when we're talking about our district exactly how many you know especially in a place like Dearborn you know what's the percentage of Arab American students right now I think we have no idea and um it's important that we have uh that kind of accurate information so I'm just asking you I know we've discussed it uh before but I'm just asking you to look into that so we can get clear answers so we know exactly how to um uh what to ask for from the software companies and hopefully to start a process where maybe in a year from now uh after we've gotten the right
043classifications and gotten people to fill them out that we do have accurate numbers of of all of our students thanks any other commentary I've also sent the entire board the link to a form where you can input the board goals for 2026 so please look for that and uh I'd like it to be shown in the March meeting here as a presentation item uh that we can track uh for the next for this year and the year after um thank you trust for mentioning mrun he was also on my agenda I know Founders Day for the PTA is happening on the 27th I know Mr nabila the president of PTA is here I hope that some of us can make it um I know I plan to be there and uh I wanted to mention
044about um news about ice raids in certain places in our community and um uh I've talked to Dr Malo about this and some of you as far as uh the what we're doing as the district and the district does have a plan of addressing uh these kind of situations if if they were to be happening at our schools sorry you said ice rates yes yeah so um um Dr Malo has a plan has addressed it with his administration addressed it also with the teachers and secretaries uh if this issue would to happen um and then I don't have anything else so uh next item next item is request for information and or future agenda items oh I guess that's when I should have said what I just said to you but okay sorry thank you
045for that you're new here sorry I'm very new here yes thank you we already have that request any other request trusty bar just for the record my opinion you're doing a good job don't go anywhere thank you s thank you so uh good nice to hear that from everybody I would like to get a history of uh I'm going to go ahead and call it we called it earlier the guido fund balance Dr Malo oh just to kind of follow up on trusty Watts question see where we've been and what direction we're going and just got to keep an eye on that please maybe over the last 10 years or longer do you want to see uh let's see we started uh yeah 15 years 15 yeah thank you we seen it not too long
046ago we just need sure we'll have it just needs upd that's all thank you thank you any other requests no trust um one of thing that I'm looking for and and we should all be looking for is to kind of get a better handle for understanding of our El students um I met with Dr uh Patterson and did an amazing job G giv me up to speed but one of the things that I I was hoping that from a data perspective we could get some um data analysis based on number of kids designated as El students in the district per School in the number of years those kids are in the program uh because there are some kids that are saying six seven years whatever I know the data is there because he showed it
047to me but he can provide it to me it's just you know probably doing some kind of pivot table or something to that extent uh and also the number of kids that have exited the program okay uh because right now from what I'm being told is if you look at at the high school level the number of the exit is very small where the exit is more at the elementary school and this will give us a good gauge you know as far as our proficiencies where is it impacted by is it the El students and and so on and just to make a statement um the number of yours will dictate a lot of things because I do think if you take kids that are in just my personal opinion that are not an uh
048a second language speakers and they take the waa test they might struggle with that but it gives us an idea as far as you know how many kids do we have in the program how many exen and how long we' been there great got that Dr got it okay perfect thank you all right there are no more requests next agenda item please next is future meeting dates Monday February 17th 2025 the Henry Ford College Board of Trustees policy committee meeting 6 p.m. at the administrative services and Conference Center in the cabinet conference room Monday February 17th 20 2025 the Henry Ford College Board of Trustees meeting at 700 p.m. at the administrative services and Conference Center in the Rosen all boardroom and Monday March 10th 2025 p12 Board of Education meeting 7M at the administrative
049service center in the Frank Frank franie boardroom thank you this meeting is adjourned at 9:49