CorpusRecord 124931

December 10th, 2024 Meeting of the Hopkins School Board

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
Vimeo / Hopkins Public Schools
Date
2024-12-11
Location
Hennepin County, MN
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,569 words · about 120 min
Collected
2026-06-18

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001Hello, everybody. Welcome. I'd like to give my board colleagues a moment to return to the table before we get started at 7 p.m. Thank you for coming out tonight. It's nice to see you here. All right. I would like to call to order this Hopkins Public Schools board meeting for 12-10-2024. We will start the meeting with our first order of business, which is our open agenda, public comment. And we do have some public comment cards that were filled out this evening, which means that there are people in attendance who would like to address the board. I need to read a very long statement so that we are all ready for this part of the board meeting. We have changed how we do public comment just a little bit here in Hopkins in order to accommodate

002hearing community voice. But we still do have two public comment periods per meeting. The first period is what we are doing now, which is the beginning of the meeting. It is for a maximum of 30 minutes long and speakers will be heard on a first-come first-served basis. And we will in this section prioritize topics that are on the agenda. If a person has not indicated their topic on the The comment card, we will assume that it is a topic not on the agenda and thus will not give priority to it. But we do have a second period for public comment, which is at the end of our meeting, which will be used for any comments that are not on the agenda or if they are on the agenda, but we're not able to be fit

003into the first section of the meeting. So I hope that was clear to everyone. We do have two ways to submit public comment to the board. One is to be here in person and fill out the card. The other is to submit a voicemail. Instructions to do so are included on our board page. And you need to leave the comment before 4 p.m. on the day of the school board meeting in order to have your voicemail played. And I want to make it clear to our community that those comments are subject to the same time, place, and manner restrictions as public comment in person and therefore will not be played if they do not meet those requirements. Just one moment. So now it comes the time when I read through those public comment requirements and

004our guidelines. So please keep your comments to three minutes or less. Public comment is for input only. and members of the school board will not respond directly to public comments that are made at this meeting. No specific action will be taken at this meeting in response to comments that are made or issues that are raised during the public comment period related to items not on the agenda. If the board determines that action is appropriate, the action will occur at a future board meeting. If you left your contact information on the comment card, a district representative may follow up with you after the meeting. I will recognize one speaker at a time. Only those speakers who are recognized will be permitted to speak. And individuals who interfere with or interrupt speakers, the board, or the proceedings

005may be asked to leave. Personal attacks on any individual, including any other speaker during the public comment session, are unacceptable, as are obscenities or profanity. Persistence in making such remarks will end the individual's opportunity to address the board and may result in the individual being directed to leave. I will rule out of order any statement that would violate state or federal law, school board policy, or the privacy rights of an individual. Minnesota's open meeting law prohibits the discussion of private educational data during an open meeting. Accordingly, during the public comment session, no person may discuss private educational data on an identifiable student. The open meeting law also requires the board to close a meeting for preliminary consideration of allegations against an employee. Accordingly, community members who have concerns about an employee or want to file

006a complaint or allegations against an employee are encouraged to contact the superintendent. We ask you not to name an employee by name during your comments. Repeated violations of these time, place and manner restrictions may also lead to the meeting being briefly recessed. Community members will have an opportunity to be heard within the limits of the law and subject to the time, place and manner restrictions above. Thank you very much for participating in public comment this evening. And I did want to state to anyone tuning in tonight, hoping to hear their voicemail message being played that It was determined because employees were directly named. They could not be played. So I would encourage people who left a voicemail to resubmit within the guidelines presented at our board meetings. So with that, and hoping that anyone who

007has a comment prepared will make any necessary changes. With that, I will invite Katie Klopinski. To the board table. Welcome. Thank you for being here. She's here to talk about Xinjing support and an invitation to Chinese New Year. My name is Katie. I'm the parent of a third grader and an incoming kindergartner at Xinjing. We live in Crystal and have chosen to open enroll even though we have a 20-minute commute one way. I'm here today to express my appreciation for the experience my son has had at Xinjing and the profound impact it has had on my family. From the very beginning of kindergarten, my son's teachers have nurtured a love of learning and fostered respect for every student's needs. His teachers are native Chinese speakers with a long tenure at the school. and it's clear

008that the Shinching teaching team operates as a close-knit family. The collaboration extends beyond the classroom with teachers and other programs working together to ensure that every adult who interacts with my son knows and supports his unique educational and social needs. They've earned his trust through their consistent belief in his abilities, not just academically, but socially as well. The fact that he's part of a cohort of two classes per grade, which will stay together until graduation, has created an additional sense of security. Shin-Ching fosters a collaborative atmosphere where students help one another and feel comfortable seeking guidance. An openness to learning from mistakes has made us, as parents, confident that our son and his peers feel both safe and loved in school. The results speak for themselves. In 2023, 100% of Shin-Ching third graders passed the

009math MCAs, and in 2024, 97.1% passed. These scores far outperform virtually any school nearby. For example, Minnetonka and Edina elementary school scores are 91%. In 2024, 64.7% of Shinching third graders passed the reading MCAs. Impressive considering those children were introduced that same year to English in third grade. This is on par with peer schools in Edina and Minnetonka that have received English curriculum since kindergarten. One of the most significant benefits of being part of this program is the global perspective the children gain by immersing themselves in a different language and culture. They're learning to think beyond their own experiences and to appreciate different perspectives, not just in terms of culture, but also in relation to any differences they may encounter in their everyday life. Given the political tensions between the US and China, the importance

010of cultural education has never been more critical. There is a growing need for Americans with expertise in Chinese language and culture. According to Bloomberg, just 211 Americans studied in China during the 2021 to 22 academic year. That's down from nearly 15,000 a decade earlier when China was the most popular destination for US students outside of Europe. The US faces challenges in engaging with China. Our children are fortunate to be gaining the skills and experiences necessary to contribute to a global understanding. Thank you for investing in Chinese Immersion. However, I hope that you will go beyond just investment and engage with the students, parents, and teachers who make Xinjing so special. So I have an invitation. On February 6th, our students will perform as part of our annual Chinese New Year celebration. Teachers are seeking a

011few adults to attend practice sessions with the children and participate in the closing dance. I hope that a few of you will join us and participate. In doing so, you will experience the authenticity of Shenzhen's cultural education firsthand. It promises to be an unforgettable evening. Thank you for your strong support to the Shenzhen community. We look forward to engaging with you closely. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Next, I will invite Laura Ciotti to the table to talk about Alice Smith issues and concerns. And please correct the pronunciation of your name if necessary. Hello, welcome. Thanks. Hello, my name is Laura Ciotti. I have a first grader at Alice Smith and a fifth grader who used to go to Alice Smith and is no longer there. I live just a few blocks from our school,

012and this is my third year on the Alice Smith PTO. Both Alice Smith and the Hopkins School District were big reasons why our family relocated to Hopkins in 2021 from out of state. I have recognized from the start that Alice Smith has complex needs and I was initially very impressed with how the needs of our families and students were being supported, including my own. However, despite having wonderful teachers and a really strong community, I now see a huge disconnect between our school's leadership and our teachers and families, affecting our students' safety, well-being, and education. My family has personally faced some issues with Alice Smith's leadership over the last several years. Despite having really wonderful, experienced teachers in second, third, and fourth grade, my older daughter faced increasing frustrations about classroom behavior issues and disruptions that

013caused disruption to her learning experience. And as a parent and a member of our PTO, I asked questions, wanted to know what was going on, how I or other parents could help. I just never felt like the communication I received from our leadership was fully honest or transparent. And over the past year, I've come to understand the fuller picture of some of the negative impact of our leadership on our school's culture, our climate, and academic environment. I've come to distrust our school's leadership to the point where I decided to move my older daughter to a different school district this year, where she and I both feel she is being better prepared academically and socially for middle school. And I've heard and seen of other families leaving the school, and I know this is not what

014we want. Our grief in making this decision is real. We really embrace our community. We want to be at our neighborhood school. We want a safe, inclusive, and high-quality education for all of our students. And this vision that I see in Hopkins is not playing out at Alice Smith. Instead, our concerns are downplayed or dismissed or explained away by our school and our district's leadership. I also, I do know that we're living in challenging times and that many schools across the country are experiencing challenges. However, I need to see a clear plan and a tangible improvements that are responsive to the reality of the needs at our school this year to rebuild my trust in the system. And this includes seriously investigating the ability of Alice Smith's current leadership to meet the needs of these

015challenging times. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. I will now invite Anna Grady to the table and there's no topic listed so I'm not sure what we're going to hear about. Hi, thank you. Welcome. Thank you. Good evening members of the Hopkins Schools community. My name is Anna Grady and I'm honored to speak with you tonight as both a mom of a first grade Junto student and previously a teacher for community school program at Eisenhower for the past few years. During my time teaching at Eisenhower, I've had the privilege of teaching second and sixth grade. briefly kindergarten, and briefly music. I've worked closely with students and staff across many programs and grade levels, and I've seen firsthand the incredible work being done at Eisenhower. I've also witnessed and experienced firsthand the growing challenges that our

016school faces. One of the most pressing issues is the need to maintain smaller classroom sizes and have support such as paraprofessionals in our classrooms. Our classes today are grappling with more intense mental health needs than ever before. I've been in education for 11 years and I've seen a change in our society and I see it everywhere, not just at our school. As educators, we're doing everything we can to support our students, but without proper resources and people, we're being put in situations where we just can't meet these needs. Year after year, I've seen amazing teachers leave, not because they don't love their students or the work, but because the demands on them are just unsustainable. These teachers pour everything they have into creating safe and loving, effective learning environments, but it's just not enough. And

017with more budget cuts looming, I fear it will get worse. Larger class sizes and losing paraprofessional supports will stretch our teachers even further, making it impossible to provide individualized attentions our students deserve. I don't believe anyone here will argue against the importance of smaller class sizes or having more adults in the classroom. Research has consistently demonstrated the benefits of smaller classes, especially in early grades. Studies highlighted by Charles Achilles in the article posted by school superintendents association organization demonstrates that class sizes around 15 students in early primary grades can create systemic change. Students in smaller classes are less likely to need remediation or special education services later. Discipline improves and long-term costs are reduced. These are benefits that we cannot afford to ignore. The study also noted that the most disadvantaged students benefited the most

018from the smaller classroom sizes. When we fail to provide this, we risk deepening inequities and compromising the future of the children who need us the most. At Eisenhower, we have exceptional teachers who are deeply committed to their students. Protecting small class sizes and maintaining paraprofessional support is essential to keeping educators and fostering a sense of community that makes our school special. Thank you. Appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you. I'd like to invite Jocelyn Kahn to the table who will be speaking about smaller classes and more support for teachers. Thank you. Welcome. I'm here today because I can imagine the day when our schools truly meet the needs of every child, a place where all students feel safe, supported, and are given the resources they need to thrive academically and emotionally. I do feel Hopkins has

019done many things to address different needs, especially on the emotional level. For instance, my daughter attends grief group for the loss of her father. However, I have seen other areas of the school, specifically due to larger classrooms, affect our children's ability to learn. My family moved to the district in 2019 after the death of my husband. We moved here specifically to be in this district, particularly because of Eisenhower, where my sister's children attended, and she had just raved about the district. I was hopeful this district would be the right place for our children, too. My oldest child began kindergarten in 2019, and my middle daughter started at the community school in 2022. My middle daughter has autism and anxiety. We had been doing in-home therapy since she was two. Eisenhower was initially willing to allow

020a six-week transition period for her therapists. Data was collected during the time and it became clear she needed significantly more support. She needed up to 20 prompts at times to follow educational instruction. With a class size of 25, I did not feel the teacher or paraprofessional would have the time to provide this. Her outside therapists, who were covered by her health insurance, were willing to provide support during the school day, but the school was not open to allowing this. They would only allow one hour a day. I knew this would not meet her needs. I realized the school didn't have the necessary resources to provide the level of support she required. I was advised to consider legal action, but instead I chose to withdraw my daughter and homeschool while I searched for a more suitable

021school. At Eisenhower, my daughter had an IEP, but I found out there wasn't enough staff or resources to ensure her success. For example, she was placed in a social group to help with peer interactions, but I later learned that there was no social worker to facilitate the group. I learned this through my therapist, not the staff at Eisenhower. Additionally, her therapist noted troubling behaviors in the classroom that my daughter was beginning to model, behaviors that weren't being addressed due to lack of staff. I also did not feel the Eisenhower staff was transparent in identifying my daughter's needs. They mentioned she was like all the other kindergartners. However, she is my child, and I know she was behind academically and socially. I would have felt safer and more supported had the staff been honest, too. My

022oldest daughter was devastated when I pulled out my middle daughter. She repeatedly told me it wasn't fair that her sister couldn't attend the same school. She began trying to see the counselor daily, but the counselor was rarely available. Later, I discovered the counselor was often in the kindergarten classrooms doing behavioral intervention, the same classrooms I had pulled my daughter out of. My daughter relied heavily on the counselor as her safety net, and when she was unavailable, her anxiety worsened. She began to miss school and became overwhelmed by the chaotic behavior she was witnessing. Over the last five years, I've witnessed a significant lack of resources in key areas such as counseling, special education, classroom teachers, and paraprofessionals. When I've raised these concerns, I feel like it hasn't been transparent with the answers I've gotten. For

023example, I sought help for my oldest daughter who struggled with reading and was two grade levels behind, but I was told her challenges weren't significant enough to warrant extra support. As a result, I hired a tutor privately. I'm sorry, time is up. Thank you for being here. Thank you. Next, I will invite Eric Mann to the table to speak on para support and class sizes. Thank you. Welcome. Hello. My name is Eric Mann. I will be fairly short and sweet with you here today. I have two children here at Eisenhower, one in first grade. in the Juntos program and another one in kindergarten in the Juntos program. When we joined the school last year, we were very excited and felt very fortunate that we had the opportunity to be a part of a school that

024our neighbors had touted, that had gotten a lot of great reviews, that we liked the people that we met before coming here. And we had a great year. Honestly, our kid has grown significantly. He speaks more Spanish than he does English at home, which is crazy for us because we don't understand what he's saying. And he had a great year. Unfortunately, we have not had the same experience with our kindergartner. More recently, we've learned that lack of the support in the classrooms has led to what I would equate to a pretty hard environment to send a child to every day. We've heard of multiple class evacuations where the children are the ones who are telling. us as the parents that there was a violent or oftentimes disruptive action that had taken place in the classroom.

025And, you know, how unsettling that is for a five-year-old to come home. And good days that used to be explained to us as curriculum-based, having fun with friends, are now about good days where the teacher felt that they were happy or that they were safe or that children didn't have to leave the classroom to go and find help. inside of a classroom. And I feel that a lot of that is due to class size and paraprofessional, a lack of paraprofessionals. And so, you know, we've raised this numerous times to the leadership team here and recently found out that there is another... cohort of our peers or other parents that feel the same way. And so we're here today asking for more support in the classrooms, more support for our teachers so that we're not looking

026at a ticking time bomb where kids are injured or teachers are injured or they leave the school altogether. So we appreciate your time and appreciate the opportunity to voice concern. Thank you. Thank you. I'd like to invite Sarah Memon to the table who will be speaking about para support and class sizes. Thank you. Welcome. My name is Sarah Memon and I'm here to speak for a third time regarding the cut to paraprofessional support in kinder and first grades at Eisenhower Elementary. The response at the school level and the district level has been insufficient and often dismissive. Classrooms are regularly being evacuated. Teachers are being physically harmed. Children are scared to enter their classroom. And our children are losing learning time. These are not rumors. These are firsthand accounts from our own children and staff within

027the school. We ask that the superintendent step in at the school level to address this matter and reinstate full-time para support in all kindergarten classes and part-time para support in all first grade classes at Eisenhower. We understand that funding is a constant issue facing all schools and request that the district look in to its administrative budget to fund the additional para support for the remainder of the school year as Hopkins District has an administrative budget 12% higher than surrounding districts. When we invest in our children, we invest in a brighter future and we ask that you help us help our students. Thank you. Thank you. Next, I'd like to invite Kendra Theory to the table to speak about para support. Welcome. Thank you. Thanks. Hello again, everybody. My name is Kendra Theory, and I'm here

028on behalf of many parents, teachers, and 337 community members that have signed our petition to restore para support. We're here because we're deeply concerned about the support or lack thereof being provided to our youngest learners. Class sizes in kindergarten and first grade with 26 to 31 students should be unacceptable. Research shows smaller class sizes around 17 students are critical for academic and social success. Other districts have been able to implement clear class size caps working with the teachers union. Why can't we? Para support. Para educators are not optional. Their absence stretches teachers too thin, leaving students without the individual attention they need. We need full-time paras in all kindergarten classrooms and support in first grade. The Amity interns. Interns are not para substitutes. These young adults are here for cultural exchange, not to manage classrooms

029or assist in ways they are untrained for. It's unfair to them, our teachers, and our students. The impacts are clear. Overwhelmed teachers, struggling students, and rising safety concerns. It is not sustainable. We're not just creating problems for today, but setting these students up for long-term challenges. Our asks. Tonight, we asked the board to implement clear K-3 class size caps. I know this involves working with the union, but it has been done and it's important. To reinstate para support for kindergarten and first grade. Three, ensure the Amity interns are being used appropriately. And four, communicate transparently with parents about all these decisions and how they're made. We want to work with you, not against you, but we will not stop advocating until our youngest students receive the support they deserve. Thank you. Thank you. Next, I'd

030like to invite Haley Degrella to the board table. Hello. Welcome. Some of the people here may recognize me. I have now spent, this is our second year having pulled our children out of Hopkins schools. We were previously at Alice Smith. My oldest son started there in 2018. We loved it. It was everything I could ask for in a school. We loved the Hopkins district. We moved here from Michigan specifically to Hopkins to attend the Hopkins school district. After leadership change at Alice Smith, it was immediately different. By two years ago... It had gotten so bad that I ended up pulling out my special education fifth grader. I reported the district to the state of Minnesota, and I won, and I was awarded $10,000 in compensatory services. That's $10,000 that could have been spent on para

031support that went to us because my son's rights had been violated. The lawyer I spoke to said she's never seen a decision that was that on a parent's side from the state of Minnesota. I also moved my two other children from Hopkins District, and we are all at Minnetonka. They are thriving at Minnetonka. The extreme behavior and peer and administration issues that my fourth grader at the time was experiencing in fifth grade at Minnetonka, we got one call home the entire year. This was after being sent home constantly, suspended in fourth grade. My middle son has been identified as having ADHD. He is now on the gifted track in Minnetonka. All of that was missed in Hopkins because there is not enough support. My youngest son, who Hopkins was trying to send to a level

032three classroom, was fine in a regular classroom and is now not even having para support in first grade. This is impacting families. This was traumatizing for me. I have emailed This committee about this never received even a courtesy response. All of my neighbors are now leaving. My friends are now leaving. This was a community that I was so involved in and excited. I mean, obviously, I'm still here, right? I'm at this meeting, even though my children don't go here, because I live in Hopkins. I want to send my kids to Hopkins schools. I do not want to send them to Minnetonka, but I literally have no choice for the safety of my children and for their ability to learn and become successful adults. These are serious issues. This is not just parents complaining. This is

033something that is your job to deal with. Thank you Thank you I'd like to invite Adam Schuster to the table to talk about high school passing time Adam Schuster, please if you're here. Hi. Thank you Welcome Good evening, and thank you for allowing me the opportunity to address this body. About two months ago, the high school instituted a new practice of locking doors when class began and not admitting students without passes. This is fairly typical practice for other high schools I have worked in, so to be clear, I am not opposed to this policy. I think it has created for many a healthy sense of urgency to clear our hallways and get to class on time. It's a good start in clearing our hallways and making sure that they are safe for all our students.

034Unfortunately, and what I'm here to speak to, is it has created a high number of tardies, a number that I believe is higher than it should be. Let me explain. The high school currently has five minutes of passing between classes. Last school year, we added 500 students to the building and subtracted one gender-neutral restroom. We changed the school start time to be five minutes earlier, 840. One of the rationales I was explicitly told for this during a ninth grade transition meeting was to add a minute of passing between each period. Did not happen. I'm here specifically because of my AVID 10 students. They're the light of my day, and they have been very clear with me that they do not feel this is enough time to push through our crowded halls. At one point, not

035sure what else to say after listening to them complain, I told them they should take their complaints to the school board. I started to realize from their faces that they had never considered this was even an option. And unfortunately, as their teacher who tries never to ask them to do something I'm unwilling to do myself, it became clear I had to model the process. So to all of my students who see this in the future, hi. To give you a more tangible grasp on the problem, I brought some late passes with me. I will drop them off. These 33 passes come from the last 10 instructional days, not counting DLD or this week. It's 33 knocks on my door, 33 interruptions that cost a few moments of instructional time that adds up. It's also useful

036context to know that I do not currently teach first block this semester. That's my prep time. So these are not tardies attributable to transportation or busing. These are kids, for the most part, already in the building. When we started asking around about this issue, me and my students together, we asked some veteran teachers, And we learned that passing used to be seven minutes. This was without the addition of the ninth grade class. It was cut by a previous administration down to five in response to a series of fights between students no longer in the building. Since I started the same year as half of our current administration team, I honestly wouldn't be surprised if they're unaware of this historical context. Why would they be? I don't fault them. However, they are carrying over, our current

037administration is carrying over a punishment from predecessors against students who no longer attend the school. It did not make sense to a lot of us. The students are not the only ones who benefit from increased passing time. The teachers need it too. Given how far away I am from staff bathrooms, I can barely make it to my own fourth block class that I co-teach almost directly above my regular classroom. In fact, because my third block has a ton, 35 new excited freshmen that want to talk to me sometimes after class, it's not uncommon that they need a moment of my time and I'm late to my own class. I encourage the school board to request Tardy data from the high school at the end of the year to give it a good look. I want

038to thank you for letting me speak to you and sorry in advance if this brings an increase of public comment from my AVID students. Thank you. Thank you, Adam. That concludes our public comment section of open agenda. I appreciate all of you being here tonight and your comments. And that moves us to our student board representatives report. Who would like to kick us off? I can go first. Great. Hi, I'm Praise. I'm a senior this year, and this is my second year on the board. To start off with my report, the Hopkins High School Black Student Alliance is hosting a movie night next week as part of their series titled Films for the Culture. The goal is to celebrate the season, explore the depth of black culture. Black cultural narratives and engage in meaningful community

039discussions about family, friendship, and the resilience of relationships while in alignment with our mission to enrich, entertain, and inspire. Next week's theme is cozy holidays. Also, graduation caps have been a student's right of passage for more than 700 years, and our HHS class of 2025 have begun to order their free caps and gowns for when they walk the stage. Speaking of seniors, I'd also like to present our alumni spotlight, Paige Buckers. Recently in the limelight, she has been named the first college student to have a shoe deal. Her sneaker with Nike, the GT Hustle 3, Paige Buckers' player edition, will be... was available just three days ago on the Sneakers app and at select retail locations. It features a baby blue and lavender purple colorway. The shoe includes the area codes 8860 for UConn and

040612, which pay homage to her hometown of Hopkins, Minnesota. There's also the incorporation of the message, Be You, Be Great, embroidered on the right tongue and the heel to take a... And the heel takes creative play on her surname, replacing her last name of Buckers with Buckets. The creation of the shoe was led by a woman from the start, with female athletes compromising more than 90% of those involved in the development. I could go on and on about her accomplishments and accolades, but I'll conclude on the note that Buckers is currently projected to be the top pick in the WNBA draft in April. Thank you. Hello, my name is Mia Osman and I'm a senior on the board. I'm a senior board representative. Me and also along with Praise are part of this year's National

041Honor Society chapter. And I'd like to share some things that we've done. To kick things off, we held a fundraiser a month ago with proceedings donated straight to charities. Following that, we raked leaves to assist senior citizens in the Hopkins community who may be struggling to do it themselves. Over the course of several Saturday mornings, we worked hard and even turned it into a friendly competition to see who could rake the most leaves. By the end, we filled countless bags of leaves. And on this Thursday, which is also a digital learning day, we'll be baking cookies to distribute to homeless individuals. We will be using the school's culinary room and we'll work together to bake a variety of cookies, creating a wonderful bonding experience while giving back to those who need it. I would also

042like to update you on a new club that my co-president Damilola Okana and I have recently made. Our club, Immigrant to Success, was created to promote cultural representation and the success of first and second generation immigrants. Each meeting features a cultural spotlight on a specific region of the world accompanied by food that holds significance to that region. For example, in our last meeting, we spotlighted East Africa and shared sambusa, a beloved dish from Somalia. Beyond cultural representation, we also focus on promoting success. Many of our members are first-generation college students whose parents may not be fluent in English. To support them, we plan to invite guest speakers to address student concerns and provide peace of mind, especially in light of recent events regarding immigration. Additionally, we are working with the college readiness counselor, Dr. Kuhl,

043to help students with FAFSA applications, scholarships, and general college preparation. Our club also encourages personal growth through activities like setting goals and discussions on success. Finally, we've partnered with the student council to help plan Hopkins High School's Culture Night on January 27th. This event brings our diverse school community together to celebrate dancing, cultural clothing, and food from various cultures. We are excited to help create a memorable experience for students, families, and friends who want to come and see the show. Thank you. Thank you. To start, I would like to remind everyone about concerts. It is concert season right now. The orchestra concert was last Wednesday. This did not include the freshman orchestra because we'll be performing tomorrow. This was the symphonic orchestra, symphonia, and philharmonic and chamber. And then tonight is the band concert, which

044is symphonic and wind ensemble, as well as a percussion ensemble, which is new this year. Tomorrow night is the freshman ensembles concert. It includes royal orchestra, royal choir, and royal band. and there is a choir concert next Tuesday, the 17th, which includes Bella Voce, Concert Choir, Royal Blues, and Sirens. Also, talent show auditions are starting. They are tomorrow during Royals Connect, so students can sign up for a specific SST or student support time Royals Connect session. And then the talent shows will take place again during Royals Connect on the 7th and 8th of January. Also during Royals Connect, we have Peer Jury. This is a student group, and it is a restorative practice. So students who get in trouble can choose to go to admin or peer jury, depending on what they get in trouble

045for. And they, if they go to peer jury, can be given... sentence per se. Like peer jury could decide that they should go clean the cafeteria or write an apology letter or volunteer after school because of whatever they did. And that is an alternative to going to admin. And that's all I have. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, my name is Sufjan and I'm a freshman and start my board report. Last night, our girls basketball team delivered an amazing performance, dominating Two Rivers High School with an incredible 91 to 32 victory. Their heart. Their hard work, dedication, and teamwork truly paid off, and we're so proud of everything they've accomplished. Congratulations to the players and coaches. Let's continue to show them our support as they move forward in their season. Meanwhile, our boys' basketball team has

046a game happening right now against Southwest Christian High School. This is a great opportunity for us to come together and show our school spirit and cheer them on to victory. Make sure to check the school website or announcements for details on the time. the Somali Student Association, one of our school's amazing clubs, is organizing a movie night. This will be a fun chance to unwind, hang out with friends, and celebrate cultural diversity, all while enjoying a great movie. Details about the date, time, and movie selection will be shared soon, so keep an eye out for updates and plan to join in. Thank you. Great. Thank you so much. And I just want to quickly say, I brag about the Hopkins student board representatives all the time and you never disappoint. That was amazing update. So

047any questions or comments from my board colleagues? Chair Andreessen? Yes, Director Giles. Yes, I do have a question for Mia. So you mentioned first-generation college. Do you have a sense for how many, like what percent, like how many do we send? Is it a lot? Is it a little? Like for Hopkins High School? Yeah. Do you have any idea? Maybe it's a Dr. Cole question. I'm not sure about Hopkins High School, but I do know for my club specifically, like a great majority, like I think there's like five that like parents actually went to college. So I assume since like our club's like a small portion of it, like it's probably bigger within the high school because not just immigrants, but there's probably also like students whose parents have been here who just chosen not

048to go to college too. So they're probably playing a factor into like. That. It would be interesting to see that number. That's good perspective, too. Chair Andreessen, can I ask a quick question? Yes. Thank you all for providing your reports. I always enjoy listening to them. Could you tell me the, I don't know if you mentioned it, the date for COSY holidays and the time? Yes, so it'll be happening in the high school in the College and Career Readiness Center on next week Thursday I can double check the date real quick, which is the 19th and it will be starting at 5 p.m. I'm sorry is a kid friendly. Yes, I can double check with our advisor to make sure okay Any other comments or questions? Yes, Chair Andreessen. Yes. I was curious about peer

049jury and how, do you know how long, like is that new or has that always been a part of our restorative culture practices? So I'm a freshman, so I haven't been really a part of it, but my understanding is that it's come back this year, and so they had it in the past, and then I think it maybe wasn't there for a little bit, and now it's back. Interesting. Thank you. Great. Thank you so much for being here tonight and for all the amazing work you do in our community and in our schools. You are very appreciated. And you are welcome to stay if you'd like. Otherwise, we will see you later. Thank you so much. Turn it over to Dr. Mary Perry-Reed for the superintendent's report. Thank you, Chair Andreessen. Well, for starters, I

050too would like to just acknowledge and welcome everyone in the audience. Thank you, parents, families, and teachers and staff for being here this evening. and also for providing public comment. As Chair Andreessen mentioned, while it's not within the board's guidelines to respond specifically to public comment, we do value your candid expressions of what's going well, what has been challenging, and what you'd like to see differently. And the work of educating our children does take all of us, so we do. need your engagement including your critical perspective and we look forward to partnering with you to determine the best way forward so thank you i do want to highlight a few very cool things happening in our schools and this superintendent report will be a little bit on the shorter side because we have a longer

051board meeting this evening that our student board reps are not staying for too It's okay. I'm just giving you a hard time. You sound a little busy, Mia. We'll let you. Make sure you study tonight. Be safe. So here are a few wonderful things happening across our spaces. So last Thursday, Glen Lake's Principal Radel, he was tardy to the district budget meeting, but he had a tardy pass. He was flipping pancakes, actually, for students and staff from House Amistad. The pancake breakfast treat was awarded to the house that raised the most money for Glen Lake's walk and roll-a-thon. Mr. Riedel shared that as he was serving hotcakes to students, it was wildly entertaining to hear kids talk about the different ways they make pancakes at home. Some students said they put syrup in the batter.

052Some add M&Ms and one student uses muffin mix in their recipe. Students sharing their family routines and traditions brought life to the breakfast experience. Thank you, Principal Radel, for feeding and treating our students. For an Alice Smith feature, last year Principal Navidad connected with MinnWest Bank to create a partnership involving 16 bank employees, including branch managers and CFOs to serve as math tutor volunteers. This has resulted in two volunteers heading to Alice Smith each week for an hour supporting fifth graders in math. Chief Investment Officer Allison Robertson even donated learning supplies and materials to support the fifth grade team. Thank you very much to the generous staff at MinnWest Bank. We are grateful for your volunteerism and we thank you for investing in our students' future. On Monday, Meadowbrook welcomed artist in residence, Frank Centuali,

053who will work with fifth graders on spoken word poetry that they will share at Meadowbrook's January student showcase night. Frank Centuali is the creator of EduPoetic EnterBrainment, a Twin Cities spoken word and music ensemble. Frank has spent years in the education system as a tutor, teacher and mentor. He facilitates learning programs in schools as well as in community centers across Minnesota and we're very appreciative of his service here in Hopkins. Eisenhower Elementary recently hosted trilingual bingo. That would be bingo played in Chinese, Spanish, and English. Hundreds of families came out for dinner, hopefully relaxed while their kids ran around competing for prizes, and the evening culminated with a raffle. Thank you to the PTO for organizing, to Principal Nest for hosting, and gratitude. to everyone who came out with a special thanks to student bingo

054callers as well as the Eisenhower staff and cultural interns who were in full force to help. In North Middle School's 8th grade product design course, students took on an exciting challenge, creating scale models of rooms or spaces they frequently use in their everyday life. Science teacher Kurt Carlson asked students to identify a space they often use and pinpoint areas for improvement. Without the constraints of a budget, students were free to propose innovative solutions to everyday challenges. Grace McVan created a model of her living room. Inspired by this social hub in her home, she reimagined the space to promote openness and conversation by adding extra seating and a new fireplace. She learned how to be flexible and how to think about the design cycle, about how the design cycle applies to real life. Henry Wyman focused

055his project on enhancing the classroom itself. His model incorporated sound panels to minimize distractions by diverting the noise from group work and creating a quieter space for individual tasks. In closing, this project underscores the importance of teaching students not just how to design, but how to think critically and creatively to solve real-world problems. Also at North, academic counselors Amanda Clark, Andrea Yesnes, and Kiara Stonebreaker have begun to host Royal Coffee Cart win sessions. So three times a week during win, students walk in teams to sell coffee to staff, and they learn real-world business skills by taking detailed orders, collecting payment, and making deliveries. As students get better at their business, they have aspirations to expand to hot cocoa. tea and maybe some other goodies. The Royal Coffee Cart Win gives students a place to belong,

056an opportunity to practice business skills, have meaningful conversations with adults, and of course, learn the importance of detail. Thank you, North Middle School academic counselors for supporting the Royal Coffee Cart Win. And for tonight's school spotlight, we are spotlighting Eisenhower Elementary. So every superintendent report, we spotlight a different school. We have spotlighted Harley Hopkins and we've... spotlighted I think four of the six elementary schools. So now we're up to Eisenhower Elementary. I'll invite Principal Ness to the table here. And as we introduce her, we're actually gonna share a quick video. So this video was produced by our Communications and Marketing Department. And you'll see our high schoolers reading notes that they received from Eisenhower elementary students giving high schoolers advice on life and how to do well in high school. So this is a really

057cute video. And then we actually showed this video to all of our leaders and staff at our biweekly budget. meeting last Thursday and then spent about five minutes after the video with each adult writing a letter to a middle schooler. So this week some of our middle schoolers at both middle schools are receiving letters of advice from district and school administrators. And you'll love this video. Dear high schooler, if you're reading this, that means you're in high school. I can't even imagine how hard high school must be. I'm in fifth grade. I want to remind you to give yourself some time to do something you like. Take some time for yourself. You deserve it. You're amazing, kind, smart, and your friends are lucky to have you. From Tilly. Thank you, Tilly. You are smart, strong,

058beautiful, and capable, and never forget that. You are amazing. Dear high schooler, if you are ever under pressure, just take a deep breath. and do your thing. You have made it really far. Since you made it so far, you can't give up now. So basically what I'm trying to say is never give up. That's really cute. To a senior, hi, I hope you have a great school year. From Teddy. You are a sweet and heartfelt person, and I think you are so amazing, and my dream is to make your day. Dear high schooler, always be kind and don't give up ever. Do your best at all times. Good luck with everything. Have fun. Believe in ourselves. It's a great message, man. It's good. Kids going places. Joke. Why did the kids eat their homework? Because

059the teacher said that it was a piece of cake. What do you call a key that doesn't turn? A turkey. Knock, knock. Who's there? Knock, knock. Stop. Stop knocking on my door. I'm finishing my college essay and it's very stressful so I appreciate it and thank you. Thank you for your gratitude it is very much appreciated. This is just really kind and I'm very grateful this made my day. Thank you guys so much from the elementary school this is very heartwarming and very nice to see that you guys care about us enough to write this. Your notes are very awesome they're very cute and they're so sweet thank you for writing them to us. Well, those connections between our littlest learners and our biggest learners are really important. So thanks to Communications and Marketing for

060that video. It is on social media. Hopefully lots of people are enjoying it. And Principal Ness, thank you for being here this evening. You do run a very unique school. There are not many schools in America that... offer three language pathways and so thank you for your leadership and really for leaning into the complexity and the challenges. We have parents from Eisenhower here this evening and we have lots of work ahead and I appreciate the work that all of the staff at the school do to support student learning. So please share more about Eisenhower Elementary. Thank you, Dr. Reed. Thanks to the board for having me here today. And I also want to echo Dr. Reed's statements of gratitude to our parents who are here. Thank you. I appreciate all of the public comment and

061look forward to partnering. While I won't be specifically addressing the public comment today, I do want to highlight some really amazing things that are happening at Eisenhower. So I'm going to start with a few examples of IB, our International Bachelorette Framework, in action. So many of you know that... At Eisenhower, our way to operationalize Vision 2031 is through IB. We have recently appointed school ambassadors in fourth and fifth grade. And so here's a picture of them. They have been selected for their leadership qualities, strong communication skills, and embodiment of the IB PYP learner profile. And so the learner profile traits are things like communications. being a communicator, being a risk taker, being balanced, being principled. And they have some jobs to do this year, so they're going to represent their peers, they're going to help

062us plan school-wide events and assemblies, and work together to discuss and solve school-related challenges. So we're very excited to have our school ambassadors partner with us in our work at school this year. It's a great way for our students to build leadership and agency, two really important parts of IB. Another example of I be in action. This is one of our first grade units. It's one of the projects in the unit. And the unit is called How We Organize Ourselves. That's one of our units. Every grade level does a version of this unit. It's part of our program of inquiry. And the central idea for this unit is people's choices impact their local and global communities. And so there are three lines of inquiry in this first grade unit, and they are just wrapping this

063unit up. However, one of the projects in the unit is something that they've done now. I think this is either their second or their third year doing this lesson. But what they do is each classroom gathers all of their school supplies, and they put it out in front of them on the floor, and they... incorporate math into it. And so they start by counting all of the school supplies. And the concept that they're working on is scarcity versus abundance. And so they try to figure out, okay, which school supplies do we have an abundance of and which do we have scarcity? And so then after they have, so you can see there's a picture of that graph there. They determine which school supplies can we share. with our peers, with other people in the school,

064maybe with outside agencies or organizations or families, and what do we need, what do we want to request? And so then you can see them with their bags, they assemble. all their data, all their information, and then they go around and they pass out school supplies to people that need them in the school. For example, I requested 10 pencils and they delivered 10 pencils. Lots of other classrooms requested things that there was an abundance of. And then they trade amongst themselves for things that they have scarcity. Another important part of our school this year is many of you know we have been awarded the full service community school grant by the Minnesota Department of Education. The goal of this grant is to develop sustainable full service community schools. And so we are excited about this

065grant because it aligns very well with two things that we incorporate into our school, our multi-tiered system of support, our MTSS model, and also our IB framework. And so right now we are at the point in our... grant process where we are conducting our needs assessment. And so on the slide there you can see that there are six core components of full service community schools. We have a team that is conducting the needs assessment. They are currently gathering data from staff and community. And by February we will have created a plan for a proposal for how to use our grant. We have a community school grant coordinator. Her name is Naima Osman. She is directing the work. And next week will be all about fun. The first project of our student ambassadors was to determine

066our spirit week next week. So we have our important days coming up and no pressure, just fun. So we have five days and five fun themes for the week. That is the end of our presentation from Eisenhower. Thank you for having me. Thank you, Principal Ness. You know, when you were describing the math lesson, I think I was in... first-grade juntos classroom because I saw all of the staff names and he and of course the whole lesson was conducted in Spanish and I saw the school supplies and I kind of wondered why they had different amounts of school supplies per staff member so now I understand what was being done and if you think about the complexity of concepts like abundance and scarcity in Spanish, then that really elevates the rigor of the lesson. So

067thank you for describing that and appreciate your comments about Eisenhower Elementary this evening and all of the fantastic things that are being done at the school. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. So that concludes our open agenda portion of the meeting. Everybody that's here is welcome to stay for the remainder of our meeting, but we also understand if you want to get on with your evening and perhaps not spend it with us. So that takes us to approval of tonight's agenda. Do I have a motion to approve? So moved. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion? Second. Oh, I'm sorry. Did I not get a second? I don't think so. I jumped past the second. I assumed the second and now have it. So any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor, please

068say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The agenda is approved. That then takes us to the consent calendar. The items provided to the board on the consent calendar are information considered to be more routine in nature. If the board deems an item necessary for additional discussion, a motion will be made to move the item to new business. I would look for a motion to approve the consent calendar. So moved. I have a motion. Is there a second? Second. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The consent calendar is approved. And that takes us to the treasurer's report. Treasurer Hartland. Wonderful good evening everyone. Thank you very much for being here. I appreciate it. An impactful piece of news broke this last week where

069the Minnesota state budget forecast was released and the surplus for the forecast of the biennium encompassing fiscal year 26 and 27. is about $616 million. And that sounds like a decent amount and is certainly better than being in a deficit. But on the scale of state budgets, it's basically a balanced budget and is a very small surplus. So for context, we're currently in Minnesota's fiscal year 2025. Our total budget for the state is $59.1 billion, and that's down some from the last several fiscal years. If you look back to this point two years ago, the forecast ahead for the fiscal year 24-25 biennium was that surplus was forecast to be $17 billion. And so therefore, our current surplus is about a 20th of that figure. And that's due to green lighting, some really big infrastructure

070programs and projects that have been built up for years and many investments in all kinds of public services across the state, including in Minnesota. It is also due to the amount of taxes collected at the state level being decreased. And so an additional piece of context is the state of Minnesota has about 850,575 pre-K through 12 students and about 38,000 adult learners in 330 school districts. So the point of all of that information is that this $616 million. surplus that the state is looking at over the next two years is not a huge amount to serve all of us that live here and there will likely and obviously cannot tell the future but we cannot count on a lot of additional state resources. to help us and other districts to combat the rising costs of

071paying our staff living wages and to provide buses and all of the myriad costs that come with serving students in the district. SPECIFIC TO RECENT EXPENDITURES, SOME EXPENSES OF NOTE WERE $29,709 PAID TO UNIVERSITIES AND COLLEGES IN THE AREA FOR PSEO CLASSES. THAT IS MONEY THAT directly saves our families college tuition when their students go to college. We paid $30,607 to National Life Insurance, $28,344 to Xcel Energy for utilities and various buildings, $7,450 for a district-wide lease for Adobe Acrobat. $922 went to Meadowbrooks the fall commission PTO payout. So when a PTO like sells food at an event, for example, for a fundraiser, the district, most of the time anyway, has to accept that money, subtracts the cost of the food and then pays any profit or a commission to the PTO. Arbiter Sports, we

072paid $21,000 for official game fees. It's software for high school sports that lets us collect payments, sell tickets, organize a schedule, assign refs and officials to games. We paid a little over $14,000 to the city of Golden Valley for utilities, about $9,300 to the city of Hopkins for utilities, about $5,300 to the city of Minnetonka. For utilities, $4,600 to water specialties in Minnesota for pool upkeep and water chemicals. $1,031,383 in busing. Just transportation of students in the district, about $6,400 of that was for a couple of charter school students that we are obligated to provide transportation to within our district bounds. We paid $4,700 to Indigo Sign Works to change the signage at North Middle School to reflect its updated name. And since I've been touching on the upkeep of the myriad systems we have,

073like the physical actual systems that keep our buildings running, we paid $51,341 to Modern Heating and Air. That represents a couple months' worth of invoices to pay for upkeeping, repair, and new equipment for heating and cooling equipment at buildings across the district. With that I move that we approve total disbursements in the amount of two million eighty nine thousand five hundred thirty eight dollars and fourteen cents for the period of November 16th to November 30th, 2024. And I want to give one final piece of context since there's more people than usual in the audience. The treasurer's report and the posted expenses do not include payroll expenses. So these are supply and utility type expenses that keep our buildings running. I'm sorry, 2 million. $89,538.14 for the period of November 16th through November 30th, 2024. I

074have a motion. Is there a second? Second. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The treasurer's report is accepted. Thank you, Treasurer Hartland. That takes us to our first order of due business, which is the presentation of the Legislative Action Coalition State Platform for 2025. So I will invite our esteemed LAC colleagues to the board table. as uh treasurer hartland director roper and myself move to that side to um present it i will then i think probably run back here yes please do yeah thank you chair andreessen And thank you LAC members for joining us at the board table. So I just wanted to provide a quick framing today I attended an executive board meeting for the Minnesota Association of School

075Administrators Masa and was able to listen to Their lobbyist Valerie Dossland as well as our executive director Deb Hinton provide masas 2025 Legislative priorities. So there are three legislative priorities adequate funding educator workforce and local control and flexi with several bulleted items under each. I just wanted to provide a few examples of what that platform includes as a backdrop for what you will share with our community this evening. So adequate funding on the MASA. Platform included things like providing a 3% basic formula increase over current law Permanently funding summer unemployment insurance eliminating the English learner and special education cross subsidies holding districts harmless for compensatory Funding while directing a study group to figure out what the long-term solution will be for compensatory education dollars and increasing local optional revenue to $974 per pupil. On the

076educator workforce, there were items including improving pension benefits, expanding alternative pathways to teacher licensure. and supporting restorative practices and student discipline through locally determined policies. And then finally, on the local control and flexibility priority, there were a few bullets including renewing capital levies locally, allowing districts to design school calendars to align with community needs, and allowing schools to focus on learning outcomes rather than seat time. So just to give you an example of what... The platform at MESA looks like the Association of Metropolitan School Districts also develops a legislative platform and then some of the school districts across Minnesota have their own LAC. Hopkins Legislative Action Coalition is one of the strongest in the state and so thanks to all of you who work on that and will, Catherine, do you want to? I don't

077know who's going to speak first, but thank you very much for being here. We have Catherine Callahan, our board members, Beth Durker. Did I say that right, Beth? Okay, and Jen Cameron. So thanks all, and I'll let you take over. And I just wanted to quickly clarify to you that the LAC is a committee of the school board, and therefore we have one of the co-chairs is a school board member, and then other members agree to be on the LAC. So I just wanted to give that context. Yeah, thank you. Good evening, everybody. Me again. Thank you, school board members. Thank you, Dr. Mary Puri-Reed. We appreciate you having us. We're the Hopkins Legislative Action Coalition, or LAC, and we, the very royal we, have been advocating for the district, its students and staff, and

078community members to the Minnesota legislature for an amazing 40 years. Some of the things that the LAC does is translate the issues and wishes of our district's members into legislative asks. We host a candidate forum for our state-level representatives in election years, and we just did that in October. We post those forums online as an enduring resource for the community to better understand their candidates' or representatives' positions and perspectives on public education. We host a legislators breakfast in January once the session starts and that's where we invite all of our reps to a changing location in the district and we highlight both successes enabled by state's funding and actions and also to highlight an ask of them to further the district's goals. It's an ask that they take with them and keep in mind as

079they go about their work that session. Because we, the LAC, have such an established relationship with our reps, our continued work once the session starts is that they actually contact us to kind of contextualize things that they're considering, either budget requisitions or changes to policy, things that they're considering. They might ask us, like, how much has your transportation costs increased? and then we serve to provide that context. The LAC's ask tonight would be that you, the board, look over our legislative priorities and platform and authorized to advocate for this platform at the breakfast and in our other actions from now through the end of the session. And one final thing I want to note is that our student board reps actually are a part of the LAC and they serve several in several roles including

080at the candidate forum and that breakfast i mentioned some of our students have even testified before the legislature and introduced bills so let us introduce ourselves quickly and then we'll get started you know me i'm rachel hartland hello my name is brooke roper i'm a member of the school board i'm catherine callahan i'm the legislative liaison and i want to just acknowledge steve adams who is our co-chair and he was not able to be with us tonight I'm Beth Durker and I'm a parent in the district. I'm Jen Cameron. I am a parent in the district. That's Shannon Andreessen. She's your school board chair. She's handing out a copy of our legislative priorities for you to review while we talk about them. All right, so this slideshow and the papers in front of you are

081the platform that we have put together. This first slide is an introduction. I don't, you want me to read, if we read all of these words. This is a message specifically to our legislators, right? We're grateful for your ongoing partnership that allows Hopkins to stay innovative, student-centered, and authentically inclusive. Moving forward means we have to acknowledge that change is necessary. Hopkins Public Schools has a long history of excellence of doing what is right for our students, and this foundation allows us to build a new model of education together, one that puts students at the center. To reduce the opportunity gap, we must move beyond traditional practices that fail to equitably serve all learners, and we are committed to creating a school system that ensures a bright future for every student, regardless of race, gender, culture,

082or economic status. We urge the Governor's Office and the Minnesota Legislature to collaborate with us in prioritizing the individual student growth, encompassing academics and key traits like critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, empathy, adaptability, and multiple literacies. These qualities empower Hopkins scholars to view themselves as agents of positive change. With legislative support, we aim to advance student-centered learning and assessment. And one way that we are hoping to get the legislature to help us out in doing that is to expand and stabilize student safety and wellness by increasing funding, resources, and access. I think I joined the LAC 13 years ago, and I think we have always had this on our platform in some way. In particular, The mental health grants that we receive, while appreciated, are not a sustainable source of funding. We also want an

083increase on the Safe Schools levy from $36 per pupil to $108 per pupil. And we would like a lot more flexibility than is provided by the legislature as to how we spend those dollars. They are very restricted. And up until recently, we're really for hard escape safety. There have been some adjustments and we were just talking about cyber security at our last board meeting where we were given some updates on the very real threat to school districts who are I believe this I remember the wording correctly, target rich and resource poor. And so hoping that we will increase that funding as well as allow it to be used in different capacities. And in particular, one of the biggest asks post pandemic for school districts across the nation is a mental health supports, not only for

084our learners but also for our staff. Restorative practices are essential, especially now that we have gotten direction from the legislature in regards to this when it comes to discipline. And I think that we are feeling the pinch of that here in Hopkins because we lost our restorative practices coordinator because the grant money that funded her position is now went away. So I think that these are important issues. The next point on our legislative priorities is to reduce educator and staff workforce shortages and elevate the teaching profession, providing greater access. One way is to expand, grow your own and other apprenticeship programs to accelerate. teacher education and to provide alternative licensure pathways. Another would be to expand and make permanent the pilots to fund student teacher stipends because this is an enormous burden on college students

085who are seeking to enter the profession. It is essentially asking college students to take on a full-time non-paid job. And it is cited as a barrier to people entering the profession having to make that leap. There are some limited state-funded grants, as noted, and our ask would be that those are expanded and hopefully made permanent. With regard to paraprofessional staff, our ask of the legislature... because not every ask is directly for funding, but that they analyze real data on current and projected paraprofessional salaries from their resident school districts in order to understand the true cost of retaining these valuable and mandated staff members. So Hopkins employs more than 200 paraprofessionals, and their wages are not livable. I mean, the average wage of them is under $25,000 per year. And we would ask that our legislators

086really understand that, understand what it would take to give them a really substantial raise and to hire more to expand their role here at Hopkins and to know what an impact that would have on our budget. The pairs are clearly a treasured resource in our community and support for their wages is lacking. And then finally we would ask, not finally, for this point, finally, we would ask that they provide increased funding for our non-licensed staff and help families cover the cost of before and after school care. In Hopkins schools, we currently have 747 students in our Kids & Co program. With 86 still on the waiting list, this is better than in previous years, and we work continuously to reduce that waiting list. But it is a major, a significant enrollment barrier for families to

087have that many students or to have students without before and after school care. And it is, I mean, it just is simply expensive to. provide staff and to hire as many people as need be to get everybody off that list, though we would dearly love to do that. Our third priority is asking the legislature to expand student-centered learning and assessment through various avenues that we've highlighted. focused on creating personalized learning experiences, not just in academics and as we focus on student growth, but also those traits of the Hopkins Scholar from Vision 2031 of critical thinking, problem solving, collaboration, empathy, adaptability, and multiple literacies. So we need to focus on the student-centered learning approaches and being able to assess them. So one of the priorities we summed up was modernizing education, promoting that competency-based education, thinking

088about alternative graduation pathways, career readiness certifications, and things like health services, technology, and education are application-focused ways of modernizing education. The second item was reforming outdated seat time or hours of instruction requirements to grant students credits wherever and through whichever modality their learning occurs. Again, you see this student-centered approach that is flexible and reflects our changing educational framework and reality. The third priority under this under priority number three is transforming assessments. So we rely a lot on standardized tests. We need to implement systems that better measure growth, mastery, and readiness in the ways that we're defining and pursuing it. And the Every Student Succeeds Act allows flexibility for districts, and we need to ask the legislature. to use that flexibility and allow districts to find measures that work for their learning. And in 2017, a

089working group was established and they had several recommendations that have yet to be picked up and carried through. So we'd like those to be picked up by the recommendations from the working group to be revisited. One of those working group recommendations was aligning career and college readiness standards with the assessments that we use in our education system. Okay, so our priority number four is to empower local school boards. Excuse me. So school districts need more time to implement the expanse of new programs and requirements adopted during the last, what does that say? We urge state policymakers to refrain from enacting any new mandates and to, one, allow school boards to manage school calendars, prioritize innovative spending, and to negotiate e-learning dates and class sizes. And number two, to enable school boards to post proceedings and

090decisions online. for community access rather than requiring districts to post them in the local newspaper. And so providing school board members with the power to manage school calendars, like we're parents first before we are school board members. And I think that it's really important for our community to know that we, when we're in our meetings, we're thinking in the mindset of a parent and not of a... you know, a policymaker or an elected official, like we're thinking about what our needs, how we would like our needs to be met. And so we would love to see some of these changes take place. As far as, you know, innovative spending, that could be such as, you know, reallocating funds to focus on e-learning infrastructure or teacher training or smaller class sizes, which has been... bought up

091numerous of times and we would like to see our us had the power to be able to um you know, help ensure that taxpayer dollars are used efficiently for maximum impact. Replacing paid advertisements. I think that having, you know, decisions and things made online, it's more equitable and it's more accessible for folks to be able to access information in a quicker way. Everyone does not read the newspaper, let alone everyone else have a subscription to a newspaper. So there are a lot of our community members who are missing important information when we have limited access to our decisions as a school. We can respond to information quickly such as you know issues on severe weather since the winter months are coming up we have a lot of that that's probably going to be happening or

092health crisis and being able to integrate more e-learning days or adjusting class sizes to comply with safety protocols so there are a lot of you know, power that we're, excuse me, there are a lot of decisions that we're looking to make as a school board and would love the support from our legislative partners to see that, hear that, and to implement that so we're able to advance our school district forward and to serve our community and our students with the utmost impact and respect. Thank you. And our fifth and final priority for the 2020. legislative session is to continue to fund equitable education for all students. Despite a significant educational investment during the past two sessions, school funding is still short. So we are asking yet again to increase the per pupil funding. formula by

0933%, raise the inflationary cap from 3% to 5%, especially considering what we're looking at. The increase in just basic essentials has gone up for not only businesses and school districts, but also for families. You can see it at home. So the ability to... Help by sending those supplies is a lot less and then increase the local optional revenue from up to 957 per pupil and support essential mandated services, essentially for special education programs, English language learner programs, and the universal school meals program that is being currently funded, but the projected costs are much higher than anticipated, which is a good thing. It means more kids are being fed. But there is a worry that as the state is want to do, if so they cost more than what they projected that that extra will fall

094on school districts so we are reminding our legislators that that is something that the state took on and they need to meet their commitment and i think we would welcome lots of questions and feedback from our board colleagues on what you think about this so i'm going to run back to that side of the table Chair Andreessen, can I begin as you're moving back to your chair seat? Thank you so much. This is such an impressive. platform. I'm not surprised those of you who serve on our LAC really have your finger on the pulse of our community's priorities. I think those of us who have been working and leading in education for many years see a lot of repeated themes here, but the way that you've worded them and the specificity of the ask really

095meets the moment. And so I think this document can be really helpful for our community when we're talking with our elected officials who tell us things like, we made historic investments in public education two sessions ago. And we can say, that is amazing. It is wonderful. And we are still severely underfunded. And this is how it shows up. And this is how it affects my child. And this is how it affects my child's teachers, my child's building leaders who are dealing with scarcity, which we've always been dealing with in public education, right? So this gives us, as community, really specific language to be able to talk with our elected officials about these things. And so I thank you for that. One question I have so that... I know what I'm talking about when I'm advocating

096is under the first platform plank. It's the first bullet point safety resources increase the safe schools levy from 36 to 108. I'm wondering where that 108 comes from and if that's a number that has been floated by a legislative working group or how I might be able to talk about that 108 in more meaningful ways. Catherine, is that something that came from AMSD? I think that was an AMSD thing. Okay. That's the Association of Metropolitan School Boards, who we are a member of. They are really great on these specific numbers that they share out to school districts so that we can use them when we are talking with our legislators. So, yeah. I think that they probably have crunched the numbers and sent that out. Fantastic. I'm pulling up their platform now, so I have

097that to reference. Thank you so much. And I think... And we're kind of missing Steve Adams here, who probably would have this right at his fingertips, but I think that that number represents, you know, that is another one of the levies, just like Director Chapman-Duca talked about earlier, that was introduced and then has sat at that level for years. So I believe that that is where that dollar amount comes from, is somewhat either inflation-adjusted or matching the increase that we've had in our formula. increasing that up accordingly. The actual AMSD platform doesn't mention a specific number, but it does mention increasing per pupil safety and security. We asked for the 36 to be doubled, so up to 72. That didn't happen, and now the costs have just increased so much, and we want to use

098it for broader. purposes than were first allowed. So we do think that the 108 is at least closer to what we actually need. Yeah, it says increase the per pupil allocation for the long-term facilities maintenance, LTFM, operating capital and lease levy programs to recover ground loss to inflation since 2014 and expand. the allowable uses of LTFM to include security modifications and additions for instructional space and then increase the Safe Schools levy. Thank you for that context. Any other questions? Feedback? Chair Andreessen. Yes, sorry, Clerk Thompson. Thanks. I just have one question on number four regarding empowering local school boards. There's a bullet point saying allow boards to including negotiate e-learning days and class sizes. So do I take that to mean that there are requirements today set by the state that says You know, this

099is how many e-learning days you can have or this is what class sizes are a maximum. And so is that the situation today? And so the ask would be, let us negotiate that a bit. I think, yes, there were changes made legislatively that restrict the school board's ability to enter into negotiations around those topics. Okay, I guess where I'm going with that is like, I don't know, my concern would be, you know, would we try to increase those? And maybe that wouldn't be in the best interest. So that was just kind of what I was thinking as I saw that point. The number right now is five, correct? Is Mr. Wetter back there? Five. For e-learning days? For e-learning days, yes. So this part of the platform would allow local boards to have more control

100over that. Is that correct? That's correct. Because it does impact. So when you talk about e-learning days and then talk about school calendars, it ties into school calendar. discussions as well because we can only have, we are required to have so many instructional days, we can only have so many e-learning days, and then we can't schedule school between these dates, right? So there's a lot of restrictions around how we're going to meet those instructional days that's legislated. and not within our control. And what would be the benefit of having flexibility to negotiate class sizes? I don't know. I can't really speak to that. It's become legislated that it's part of contract negotiations. Yes, that's how we do it currently in Hopkins. We negotiate with each teacher as we are hiring them. But they're asking us

101to use class size as a More of a blanket. I think Nick would be able to answer so we yeah, we wouldn't want the legislature to mandate specific class sizes across the state we'd want to maintain local control and if they have to be negotiated then make sure that we're negotiating those locally. And then about e-learning, I'm just looking at the state statute. It says that school districts that choose to have e-learning days may have up to five e-learning days in one school year. So I think the thinking for the LAC is that this is stuff that used to be under school board local control, and now it has been taken over by the state. So the state is telling local school boards what to do. Thanks for that explanation. I appreciate it. So this

102would allow us more flexibility in negotiating with our teachers union in kind of grappling with these calendar complexities so that our staff have enough development time, enough prep time. Students still get instructional time. Right. And so we're not asking for any sort of change in instructional days. We would still be. supportive of a state mandate when it comes to instructional hours. But this is about how we get there. Right. We're increasingly the state is taking away our ability to meet those mandates. I think specific to class sizes also I'm reminded of a conversation we had in the spring around the impact of a mandated class size where if And these are not the right numbers, right? But like, let's say the state says, okay, every class size has to have 28 kids or less, whatever

103the number is. We did the math on how many additional classrooms. And we looked at like K through eight. If you had to add one additional classroom in each of these. eight schools that we have, how many teachers would we need? And then we compounded that across the state. We needed like 10,000 extra teachers or something across the state in order to meet that state mandate. And we wouldn't even have that many. bodies to fill those roles. And so there's some awareness that we're asking for from the legislature around what these mandates mean when it comes to the real world implications. We don't even have enough teachers to fill those roles were those kinds of mandates to be handed to us, right? And so it's just in keeping those kinds of contexts in mind when

104we think about controlling those abilities at the... local school board level or funding to pay for it depending on what those caps are right and What's the on-ramp for the teachers that we would need to be able to fill those roles? How many and when are we graduating in the state right exactly? Is that helpful? That's helpful Chair Andreessen, I had a question on the third plank, expand student-centered learning and assessment, third bullet point, transform assessments. The last piece of that says direct the Minnesota Department of Education to establish a working group based on the recommendations of the 2017 future assessment design working group. So 2017, that was a long time ago now, especially in... post pandemic world. And I remember vaguely some of the recommendations coming out of that group and that they were

105solid and would support a more expansive way to assess students. I'm wondering if you could give me a little bit more detail around that. Is it... do we need a working group to reassess based on the current moment? Do we need to include the 2017 or are the 2017 recommendations still so solid that we should just be implementing instead of advocating for another working group, right? I'm thinking about like what is the most direct pathway to expanding assessment in the state in a timely manner? I guess that's the... the core of my question. And this came directly from the AMSD platform that they want to, maybe a new working group is going to take a better, a closer look. 2017 was a long time ago. But again, it was never, they had a group, they

106made some recommendations, and that was the end of it. So we didn't follow through. The legislators, you know, I think could use a new, a fresh look. I think the working group should be our IDL team. That's what I think. That'd be great. I don't know if we can legislate that. We can't? Oh. Oh, thank you. Back to school board control. Right. Empower school boards, right? Thank you. Oh, great. I think that was some really good feedback. I also... I am very appreciative of all the people who put so much work into developing this platform every year. It's like Dr. Mary Peary-Reed said, the Hopkins Legislative Action Coalition is one of the top in the states. We get asked all the time, how do you do it? And I am so appreciative of what you

107do. So with that I have a recommendation that the board adopt the Legislative Action Coalition state legislative platform for 2025 So moved I have a motion. Is there a second? I have a motion and a second any discussion Seeing none all those in favor. Please say aye aye aye any opposed the The state legislative platform has been adopted. Thank you all for joining us. Thank you. Thank you for all that work. Thank you. And I want to just remind everyone that we do take trips in the spring to the Capitol, and we are delighted if we can have people join us. Spend a day on the Hill with us. And this will be posted on our website. It's usually in March. What? In March. In March. And we take it directly to our legislators, and

108you get to talk with them. So, yes, I also plug that activity. It's a lot of fun. Yeah, it is. It is fun. Catherine, that day isn't established yet, March, the specific day? It's an AMSD day at the Capitol. I don't think they've set the date yet. Usually March. Thank you. So that takes us to the certification of the 2024-2025 tax levy. I would invite Director Chapenduka to the table to talk this through with the board and turn it over to Dr. Mary Perry-Reed. Thank you, Chair Andreessen. So back to finance. As Director of Business Services, Tura Chapenduka comes to the table. We did have a... Truth in Taxation hearing earlier this evening, which began at 6.15, was open to the public and lasted for about 40 minutes, and that recording will be available on

109our website. Back on September 24, the school board certified the proposed property tax levy at the maximum for the fiscal year 26 levy cycle. At this time, Director Chapenduka will review the proposed property tax levy for our school board and community. Thank you, Dr. Maype-Reed. Again, good evening, Chair Anderson. Good evening, board members in the community. As has already been alluded by the superintendent, yes, we did meet at 6.15 to do the truthing taxation. So the levy certification process is mandated by the state. We have to do a presentation to the community and this process actually started in September. when the Minnesota Department of Education prepared and distributed the levy limits reports to districts, authorizing the maximum levy each district can pass on through property taxes. And on September 24th, we presented to the school

110board and the school board approved a proposed levy which at that point in time was authorized at maximum. What that meant was if there were any changes which increased the levy to the district we wouldn't lose the opportunity to get those resources since a lot of the revenue components are formula based. And then in mid-November, the county mailed proposed property tax statements to all property owners in the Hopkins School District. And those statements also incorporate other municipalities and local authorities. Today, we did present to the community and to the board. the proposed levy and its impact to property taxes. And at this point in time, this is the opportunity for the board to actually certify that levy and then work with the Department of Education as well as the county auditors. The number of factors

111which have an effect or impact on individual taxpayers' taxes. This could include changes in value of individual properties as assessed by the account auditor, changes in total value of all property within the district, increases or decreases in levy amounts, caused by changes in state funding formulas, local needs and costs, voter-approved referendums and other factors. And in Hopkins, we have a combination, a mixture of rich commercial properties, which does dilute the net effect to residential properties. as I'll present to the board and the community in terms of the proposed tax levy, which is about 2.6% less than what was certified by the board in 2024 for 2025, and some of the net tax effects to our community. So for example, when you look at a residential property which had a market value of about $250,000 in

1122022. At that point in time, the tax assessment for that property was $981. If you fast forward that to 2025, The estimated tax assessment for that property is about $924, which is a net change effect of about $57. If you compare that with what was certified in 2024 for the same property with $250,000 market value, The assessment for 2024 would be $978. So if you do a side-by-side comparison between 2025 and 2024, you see that there's a net effect of about $54 less, which will be showing on your... tax statement. And again, some of these numbers may change, but we anticipate that the change will be slight. If you take an example of a home with a market value of about $600,000, and again you do that assessment going back to year 2022, the tax

113impact for that property would have been $2,516 in 2022. And if you fast forward that to 2025, the net tax effect for that property is about $2,427 estimated. That shows a $89 impact, meaning $89 less over that period. If you do a side-by-side comparison with the 2024 tax assessment for the same market property valued at $600,000, for 2024, the tax assessment would be $2,511. for 2025 estimated $2,427, which shows a change of $84, meaning $84 less on your property tax assessment. I will further go on to maybe do some review of commercial and industrial properties. An example being a million dollar market value on a commercial property. In 2022, that property would have been assessed $4,686. Fast forward to 2025, the estimated assessment for that property would be $4,565. showing a net change effect of

114$120 less on their tax statement. If you compare 2024 for the same property valued at $1 million, in 2024, the tax assessment for that property would have been $4,926. And in 2025, estimated $4,565. Net change effect of about $361. So those are some of the examples I would want to share with the community, just knowing that there has been some net changes to the property tax assessment. for what the board will be voting for tonight. That being said, the estimated property levy payable in 2025 is $68 million, $992,950. If you compare that to 2024, which was $70,919,363, the net change effect is about 2%. on a year by year comparison. And that takes changes across the board. Our property tax levies do impact our general fund. They fund about 40% of our operations. They also

115fund the payment of our debt for the bonds we sell. and they are used to pay for the interest in principal for the debt to the district, as well as also fund some of the community initiatives through community education to a tune of a little over a million dollars. So that being said, I would propose to the board to... certify the levy for pay 2025 at $68,992,950. And I'll take any questions from the board. Thank you. Is there any questions from the board? Chair Andreessen? Yes, Director Zhao. I do have a question for Torero. What is the implication of certifying here? Does it mean... It goes to the voters or what if we say yes or no what happens in either case? So what the implication for certifying here is this doesn't go to the

116voters the bodies the authority to certify the live on behalf of the community So the number of components which are affected into the levy some of the items voted by the taxpayers. So when we go for a referendum, which we did in 2017, the community voted to give the board authority to actually issue these levies. The levy is used to support, like I said, a number of our operations. It takes about 40% of our operations. Those operations are funded either through some of the operating referendums, some of the capital projects levies, some of the debt for deferred maintenance. as well as some of the community initiatives. So if the board decide to vote for a different amount, what that will do is it will just have an impact to the operations for the district. Thank

117you, Director Chapman-Duggan. Any other questions? Chair Andreessen. Clerk Thompson. Thanks, Director Chapinduka. I've been tracking with you for like four hours tonight here. So just one other question that has come to mind as I'm looking at the document that you've provided us. And we had seen a slide on it during the truth in taxation. Regarding the debt service levy, what is the difference between voter approved and non-voter approved? How do you get a non-voter approved debt service levy? Sure. There are two components to our debt service levy. So the voter approved debt service levy is when we go for a referendum for capital bonds. So for example, in 2017, we had a ballot question which raised about $25 million to fund some of the projects in the district. So that one requires voters to approve

118the sale of the bonds. Every two years we also sell bonds which do not require voters to approve. And those bonds do fund our long-term facilities maintenance and deferred maintenance. Got it. All right. Thank you. You're welcome. Chair Andreessen. Yes, Treasurer Heartland. Thank you. Just to summarize, because as Clerk Thompson said, it's been for four hours now and we've had a few talks. So right now, this action that we're taking. It'll be the exact same action that we've taken for at least the previous two cycles that I've been a part of the board and that's certifying that yes, the school district will exercise the maximum levy that levy that is like hemmed in both by state requirement, a cap and voters approved this back in in 2017. So we have the ability to levy this.

119And if we do this exact same action that we've taken for at least two years and more, there still will be a decrease in taxes. two homeowners, two commercial property owners, and it's going to result in our school district getting a little more than $2 million less in the next cycle, which is going to contribute negatively, of course, to our budget. And there's nothing else really that we can do right now. The best thing that we can do for our budget is to approve this at the... Correct, because the formulas are set by the state. So, again, based on a lot of variables, some of which are tied to... to our tax base, some of which are tied to legislative formulas which have been set. So based on a lot of variables, the state does

120set those formulas and then they do the calculations for the district. What the board has authority over is they can tell the state, like, well, you have calculated this much. we don't want that much, we want this much, which may lead to us maybe losing some revenue, which will definitely have impacts on our operations. Or, like we did during the September 24th meeting, the board authorized that we'll leave it max, because when we do the pre-certification, we don't have all the information. The state continuously changed some of those formulas. And then they give us the final allocations around this time. So what this will mean is this is the final number which we have been given based on the calculations, and that's what the board is certifying tonight. Thank you. I appreciate that. Just confirming

121that we are doing the best action we can, the maximum we can, and that will still result in fewer dollars for our district. Correct. Thank you. Any other questions? I would then look for a... A motion to approve the resolution establishing the school district tax levies authorized for general and special purposes. So moved. I have a motion. Is there a second? Second. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion? Seeing none, I will turn it over to Clerk Thompson for a roll call vote. Chair Andreessen. Aye. Treasurer Hartland. Aye. Director Rober. Aye. Vice Chair Ross. Aye. Clerk Thompson is an aye. Director Westmoreland. Aye. And Director Zhao. Aye. You have unanimous passing, Chair. Thank you. The resolution has passed. Thank you, Director Chapinduka, for all your many presentations this evening. Thank you. Thank you,

122Drew. And... Oh, sorry. I was going to say, can I note something? I don't know if we can do it now or later, but for the consent calendar, we have the wrong date. I mean, excuse me, time for our board workshop. We started at 5 o'clock today, and it was at 5.30. I mean, I'm sorry. It was 5.30. That's posted online, and we started at 5 o'clock today. So I just wanted to note that. Thank you. That's why I was late. Thank you. That's good feedback to have. So I will then invite our next presenters up to the table for World's Best Workforce and turn it over to Dr. Mary Perry-Reed. Thank you, Chair Andreessen. So this is an annual report that requires a lot of data analysis and many hours actually to prepare in

123order to present a thoughtful and accurate. update to our community so I'm grateful for all of our presenters and for all of the hours that they've already put into preparing this for you so just a little bit of background and framing so world's best workforce the the state bill was passed in 2013 2013 to ensure that every school district in the state makes strides toward increasing student performance School boards are required to develop a comprehensive and long-term strategic plan that addresses four goals, children being ready for school, racial and economic achievement gaps between students closed, students ready for college and career, and students graduate from high school. And then at Hopkins, we do weave into our world's best workforce our achievement and integration goals and plan because there's an overlap with those goals, which are

124to increase achievement and reduce disparities. So here at the board table, thank you team for being here. We have our director of innovation design and learning, Dr. Ertl. We have our principal and special assignment and director of... categorical revenue or I'm not sure what the long title is but Dr. Leanne Campy, our instructional data scientist Dr. Abby Holm and our director of assessment and state federal program coordinator Melissa McDonald. Did I say that right or no? Close enough. Okay specialist, guru. So thank you for your work and we'll just hand it over to you to begin our report. Thank you for the introduction, Dr. Mary Perry-Reed. Good evening, board members. We're excited to present to you this evening, and especially after the LAC presentation where they referenced part of the platform that was related to

125assessment. Our team is really interested in things like assessment, and in particular, this group that I'm here with this evening. And so we are here as Dr. Mary Peary reads. said already that to present the world's best workforce and achievement and integration plans and outcomes and this will serve as our quarter one data review and we look forward to bringing more data reviews to you in the next two quarters So I always like to begin with the Hopkins promise because it's a foundation to our strategic plan and the improvement work that we're doing collectively as a district. Hopkins promises an educational experience for students ages 0 to 21 that prepares them to succeed in our increasingly complex, rapidly changing world. Our students are recognized as global scholars who work collaboratively, disrupt the status quo. and

126solve some of the world's most complex problems. They are the best and brightest citizens of tomorrow. Together we are creating a better world by inspiring each student to reach their full potential. Just a brief overview and Dr. Mary Perry-Reed already mentioned most of this about the world's best workforce and achievement and integration. Each year we report out on this data around this time. This report is coupled with a report that we file with the state as well. It's important to always remember that the data we're looking at is retrospective, so we are looking backwards at 23-24 data. So the world's best workforce reporting was legislation that was developed in 2013 as a strategic planning mechanism for school districts to work toward improvement. And the Achievement and Integration, or you'll hear us call it A&I, program

127was designed to facilitate racial and economic integration within schools and districts. The World's Best Workforce Plan and the ANI Plan overlap in a couple of goal areas, and that's why we report on them at the same time. And at the end of our presentation, we will be talking about how the World's Best Workforce is transforming into a new MDE-mandated strategic planning framework called the Comprehensive Achievement and Civic Readiness Report. It's not rolling off our tongues very easily yet, but I'm sure by this time next year it will be. So Hopkins also has its own local long-term strategic plan and part of the work of local educational agencies is to do sense-making between our own local strategic efforts and the requirements of the state to assure alignment. So in previous World's Best Workforce presentations, we have

128highlighted the connections between state required planning and our own local strategic planning. This year, we will also be using a fidelity and outcome framework through which to view our world's best workforce and A&I reporting. And the framework is important and will be helpful in understanding the complexity of the multiple implementation processes that we are working through to install, like new literacy practices and other various pedagogical class practices in each one of our classrooms. So I'm going to turn it over to Dr. Holm, who's going to go over that framework and share some information about that. Good evening, everyone. So before we jump into any data review, we will introduce this framework that Dr. Erdl mentioned. This framework is really rooted in the idea that high fidelity practices will yield strong data over time. So what

129do we mean by that? Outcome data is what we see at the surface. It's kind of like the iceberg analogy. But fidelity practices are where the real work or most of the work lies in a school year. And like many fields in education, there tends to be a hyper focus on outcome data. That's what we're reporting today. We report on whether we saw the outcomes we expected and if we're making our goals. But what many fields often neglect to do, and what some would argue is more important, is to review the fidelity practices that contribute to the outcome data. This means rather than just expecting our data to move one way or another, we need to be hyper-focused on what we're doing day to day to influence that data. So what's easy to do is

130to introduce new practice and then just cross our fingers that the outcome data changes. But in reality, good implementation requires much more. Ideally, then we introduce a practice, then staff have to be trained, then the bulk of our time over the next several years should be focused on fidelity. How is this going? Are we doing what we said we were going to do? If things are not going as intended, do we need to adapt? Do we need to abandon the plan? Do we need to ask why? And only then, when we see strong fidelity practices, can we look at our outcome data and know with some confidence that it's a result of our new practice. So we'll take an example. You might consider our letters implementation. In 2018, we brought letters to Hopkins. Then we

131began training teachers, and we are still training teachers. And our fidelity checks, which we do in a couple of ways, are ongoing. And only in the last year, so that's about five years post-implementation, do we think that outcome data may be influenced by this change. We have enough teachers trained that we think, okay, the fidelity is probably there where we can start saying these outcomes are a result of this new practice. And most of our letters, or sorry, most of our teachers are still in letters training. So we mention all of this today because our goal is to present the outcome data. That's what we're mandated by the state to do. But we also want to build our community's trust and awareness of what we do all year long to determine the degree of fidelity

132in our changed practices. So at this point, I'll turn it over to my colleague, Dr. Campy, to share the outcomes from achievement and integration. Thank you, Dr. Holm. Good evening, everybody. So as Dr. Erdl said earlier, the achievement and integration plan in Minnesota provides school districts funding for the purpose of pursuing racial and economic integration and increasing student achievement by reducing academic disparities based on students' diverse backgrounds. The information that I will share this evening relates to the A&I plan for the years 2023 through 2026. So as Dr. Ertl mentioned earlier, it's a three-year plan. Last school year was year one of this plan. Along the way, I will also share what we call key indicators of progress or KIPS to help us determine whether we are on track to meet our goals. So since

133it's a three-year plan, it is laid out to have like a mini goal every year that you should be meeting to know that you're on track to meet the final goal at the end of the three years. For the plan that we are currently in, we set two achievement goals and the first focuses on math proficiency. and you can see that that goal identifies 2026 as the year to meet the goal it also aligns with the learning goal from our hopkins learning framework So I'll talk first about some outcome data. One thing to note with regard to our outcome data for this goal is that we do not have an apples to apples comparison from spring of 2023 to spring of 2024, which is when the data is taken from, due to the fact that

134in 2023, our middle schools did not take the test, and in 2024, they did. So we're looking at data, and the goal was built around data for students in grades two through eight. And so this is really like a baseline. Our data from last spring shows that we are making progress toward our goal, but we are just shy of meeting the 2024 key indicator of progress. We wanted to see 63% of students in those grades meeting or testing at meets target low risk. We see 61%. So we are close, but not quite there. Given the fact that we are not quite on track with our progress in this area, it is important to be clear about what fidelity practices could contribute to our desired progress. For example, we are currently in the midst of a

135math program review, which includes a review of our elementary math curriculum. We are also using our Hopkins Instructional Leadership Team Sessions to focus on elements of Tier 1 instruction, which is the best means of improving achievement for all students. Given the fact these efforts are relatively new, it is not surprising that our outcome data has not yet fully shown the results of our efforts in this area. Our second A&I achievement goal focuses on increasing our graduation rates for our Latinx students, which also aligns with our Hopkins Learning Framework learning goal. In this case, we are able to report some strong outcome data. Our three-year goal for the A&I plan is for 60% of our Latinx students to graduate on time, and we have exceeded that as of this time. As I stated previously, looking at

136our fidelity practices is important. And as Dr. Holmes said, the longer that the practices have been in place, the more likely they are going to yield the outcomes you want. And that definitely applies in this case. In this case, our AVID data, we've had AVID at our high school for a very long time. And the key indicators of progress in that AVID data are right on track. And that's a very well-established program. So it reinforces the importance of being very clear about how we will reach our outcomes. Our next ANI goal area is integration. You may recall from our presentation last year that we talked about integration being more than merely the diversity of a space, but how people in that space experience their day-to-day. This attention to human experience is shown in Hopkins' culture

137goal, and the parallel in ANI is communicated via the panorama survey that our students take multiple times each school year. You might think about culture as forming the bottom of the pyramid in Maslow's hierarchy of needs. Our students need to feel safe and supported in order to do their best learning. So we'll talk first about the outcome data for our integration goal. As I mentioned previously, our identified outcome data points are drawn from the panorama survey, specifically the areas of emotional regulation and sense of belonging. So there are multiple points within the goal that was written. The goal states that we will increase by a certain number of percentage by the time we hit 2026. In this data, we see mixed results. But overall, I would say that we are not quite on track to

138meet the three-year goal for this area. So we need to be clear about why we might be seeing the results shared on the previous slide. One element to note is that this is the first year we have had a consistent curriculum available throughout all levels for SEL or social emotional learning via purposeful people and character strong. While this is an important step in the right direction, I believe we need to analyze the fidelity of the supports that we have put in place to achieve our goal. For example, we need to examine whether all of our students are experiencing the SEL curriculum we have in place on a regular basis. We also need to determine whether students who are identified as having social-emotional needs through Panorama are receiving the recommended interventions so that they have the

139best chance of increasing their ability to regulate their emotions and their sense of belonging. Finally, restorative practices are a key component in this area and also a place for us to consider the fidelity of our implementation because while we see an increase in the use of restorative practices over time, we are not meeting our indicators of progress with regard to restorative outcomes at each level. So if you look there, you can see that we set a different goal or key indicator of progress at each level for 2024. And I didn't write the plan, but I would surmise that the goal was set based on what the data of the previous years told us would be reasonable. And you can see that at each of our levels, we did not meet that target. So, again, this

140points to a need to inspect the fidelity of our implementation of restorative culture. Earlier this year, our Hopkins instructional leadership team spent time reflecting on their current state with regard to our restorative culture innovation configuration map, which is essentially a plan for how we would fully implement restorative culture. And each team identified action steps to help move their work forward. The final goal area for achievement integration relates to teacher equity. Our focus is on increasing the percentage of licensed staff of color, which is also one of our success indicators for Vision 2031. When we look at the outcome data, we have met our three-year goal in this area, but one of our key indicators of progress is related to retention of our staff of color, and this is an area that we need to continue

141to monitor. So as you can see, we doubled our percentage of licensed staff of color from 2022-23 to 23-24, and we have actually exceeded the three-year goal. The three-year goal was to be at 10%, and we are beyond that right now. That said, like I mentioned, this key indicator of progress, there are multiple pieces to each goal, multiple strategies that we're trying to enact to meet the goal. And in this area, an area for us to look at is the retention of our staff of color. While we have multiple supports in place to help us retain staff, we do need to monitor the fidelity of the work we're doing. It's important that we retain all of our staff, and especially our staff of color, since that is the focus of this goal. That is it

142for A&I, so at this time I'm going to hand the presentation back to Dr. Holm, who will start the portion that focuses on the world's best workforce. All right, so moving to world's best workforce, our first goal is to ensure that all students are ready for school. We measure this via the work sampling system in Hopkins Preschool. So looking at our outcome data, looking at our outcome data, we see that we met our goal. 87% of our students were rated proficient in the spring of 2024, specifically in the personal and social development domain. When we look at our fidelity practices for this goal, we know that our early childhood program is grounded in the Reggio Emilia approach to learning, which facilitates child exploration while supporting children in their development of routines, conflict resolution, and independence,

143among other things. We also use the second step curriculum in early childhood, which contributes to these social-emotional learning components. The second goal is about reducing achievement gaps. We wanted to reduce the gap in our MCA reading scores from 33.8 percentage points to 31.8 percentage points. This is the difference between white students and students of color. We did not make this goal, and unfortunately, we saw the gap widen a little bit. So it's really important here to look at our fidelity practices. Of course, we have letters training and a literacy for leaders version for our district and building administrators. We are working on a new program review process, which will include ELA, that's English Language Arts Standards K-12. This is what the MCA assesses. And we engage in regular disparity reviews. What do the gaps look

144like each year or even quarter to quarter between our students of color and our white students? To be clear, all of these are relatively new strategies for adjusting and monitoring our practice, which ultimately serve to improve literacy instruction in each classroom for all students. But they're important because we're not satisfied with any gap. We want to see our scores improve district-wide, but especially for students of color who are scoring in the lower proficiency. One fidelity practice we've really honed in on is letters implementation. Here we can see via Chi-Square analyses that students in letters-trained classrooms did reap the benefits of their letters-trained teacher in 23-24. We showed you similar data last year. And that's good. It's good news that we see the trend continue. And the other good news is that 90% of our staff

145are in or have completed letters training as of, or are in letters training or have completed as of this year. But I'm going to point out in this graph that these data are for K-2 teachers. And remember, MCA testing starts in third grade. So we're excited to see the results in the next couple of years, knowing that we have really strong implementation, particularly in those primary elementary grades, and that's eventually going to be applying to all grades. So those are our first two World's Best Workforce goals. I'll turn it over to my colleague, Missy, to talk about the last two. Yes, two more to go. Our World's Best Workforce goal next focuses on college and career readiness. So our outcome for this is measured using the ACT, which is taken by 11th graders in April

146at the high school. And it's aligned to our Hopkins Vision 2031 goal of having 100% of Hopkins graduates placed in their college and careers of choice. So our outcome data, if you hop down, yep, is, let's see, mine's not hopping. So on this slide, you can see the Hopkins Public School ACT averages over time. The Hopkins School is represented in gold. The state average for the ACT is represented in dark blue. And then the national average is that aqua. And you can see that these are stable scores and that our average is consistently higher than the national average. In 2023, students actually scored higher than the state average for the ACT as well. Note that the numbers here were rounded. So there is slight fluctuation in the scores. For example, 20.7 for the state in

1472024 and 21.3 for Hopkins. So this accounts for the slightly different bar heights despite their integer equivalence. Go ahead. All right, the next goal. and it's the final component of World's Best Workforce for this year, is all students graduate from high school. And this is measured using our grad rate for both high school and virtual EDU. And this aligns as well with our 2031 vision and goal. The data is provided by MDE and it's released about 10 months after graduation to account for student future plans. So we had a total of 87.4% of students graduate in four years in 2023. And this slide, you can see the state grad rates. results compared to our school district grad results. And this graph shows the state's graduation results remain stable, while ours can fluctuate a bit due

148to the smaller amount of students. And this year, we had an increase in grad rates from 84.8% to 87.4%. Some of the fidelity practices that impact these goals can be found within our college and career readiness and our graduation rates. Fidelity practices so college credit opportunities are available to students who participate in our AP exams or CIS college and schools and PSEO which is the post-secondary education option students have the opportunity to take the PSAT which is a national standardized test in 10th grade and We have college and career readiness coordinator and assessments in our new system, which is called Maya learning available at the high school Additionally, we do offer a credit recovery program that consistently monitors students who are at risk for not graduating. So we mentioned earlier today that the state accountability

149system is changing slightly in Minnesota, and I'm going to walk you through some of those changes that you can expect to see. So World's Best Workforce as we have known it has been these five goals. And you'll notice we didn't actually report on students will read well by third grade due to the changes. So during the 2024 session, the Minnesota Legislature renamed World's Best Workforce to Comprehensive Achievement and Civic Readiness, or CACR. And the Students Will Read Well by Third Grade goal has been moved to the Local Literacy Plan, and that will be presented to you at the board by Kim Smith in a future board meeting. A new goal has been added, and it's called Prepare Students to be Lifelong Learners. So the new plan name emphasizes dual roles for the goals set forth

150in district plans, both supporting academic achievement for pre-K through 12 students, as well as preparing them to be active members of their community after graduation. This change will take effect as of the 24-25 school year and be reported then to you in the 25-26 school year. So how we measure the new goal, prepare students to be lifelong learners, is yet to be determined. We intend to collaborate across the district to determine the outcome data in alignment with our fidelity practices. On the right side of this slide, you can see some of the practices we believe lend themselves well, including our scholar traits and academic competencies as supporting evidence of this potential goal. We look forward to engaging the community for input in this goal creation process. Thank you so much for your engagement on this

151late evening, and we look forward to future data reports with you all. Thank you. I appreciate you being here tonight and for this presentation. I'll open it up to my board colleagues. Any comments or questions? Chair Andreessen? Yes, Treasurer Heartland. Do you know what percentage of our Hopkins, is it juniors that take the ACT? How many of them take it? I can look into that for you and get the exact percentages. Thank you. Any other questions? Yeah, Chair Andreessen. Yes. Can you guys remind me again for CACR, is that being funded by a grant or are we looking for legislators to be able to provide some level of, identify what a funding source would be for this particular? No, it's it's Mandated reporting it it's does not come with any funding. Thank you It's one

152of those unfunded mandates. They're fond of yes one of those Chair Andreessen? Yes, Director Zhao. Hi. So thanks everybody here for all your hard work. I know there's probably billions of data points and it's not an easy task for sure. Maybe just a comment really quickly, but I was very... heartened to hear in a way that there were certain targets that we didn't meet. And I think that's actually, from my perspective, a good thing. I would be much more concerned if you were like, everything's fine. We have nothing to work on. So I really appreciate that you are taking a look at this and saying, hey, we didn't quite hit the mark, but here's the plan. I had one question around the Fast Bridge, Goal 1. Just wondering why there's only two buckets but there's

153four areas, right? To me, probably high risk is like, okay, that's really what we worry about, right? That's what gives us the gray hairs versus some risk, like, okay, right? So why was that not bifurcated? I can take a stab and then if Missy wants to add anything to it, she can. I believe the... The way that FastBridge works is that students that we've identified as being in either of those first two categories, if they meet target, they're there. And if they are at low risk, that if they receive strong tier one instruction, they will be where they need to be by the end of their current grade. And so that's why they're bucketed together. And we know that the students in those other two categories are going to need more than tier one instruction

154to make sure that they are at grade level. by the time they move on to the next grade. Okay. Ding, ding, ding. Yeah. Okay, perfect. And then maybe just one last comment. I think, you know... As we're taking a look at this and things aren't working or aren't working, I'm just kind of wondering, I have a sense of urgency in some ways here because things take time to move through the system. But in the meantime, these are students that are not left behind, but I worry about their lifetime outcomes. So can you talk a little bit about like, hey, you know. You know, we're seeing some indicators of problems. You know, what can we do even while we wait for the fidelity to get there? Like, what can we do to intervene in general? We

155are, too. And so I think how I would start, and then any of you feel free to add in. While we are implementing the new practices that will improve Tier 1 instruction, which is what we've been describing, we are also strengthening and building our multi-tiered systems of support across specifically math, literacy, and social-emotional learning. And so right now what's happening is we think we are serving too many students in that second and third tier of support. whose needs could be met with Tier 1 instruction. So that's why we have been focusing and talking so much about Tier 1 instruction. That's not to say that those supports are not present and in place for students who need them right now. We just think we have too many students needing those interventions right now. So maybe better

156triaging, basically. Exactly. We'd like to manage more of it in that Tier 1 setting. Thank you for your time. I appreciate it. Sharon's reason I just I had been asking principal Ballard a few days ago about a CT data, so She shared that last year 71% of the junior class took the a CT and then we'll find out some follow-up information about what's preventing the The remaining yeah the 20 plus percent not taking it What are the barriers to that and we can get back to you on that because I'm curious as well clerk Thompson Thank you. Echo director Zhaos appreciation for you know the work you've done pulling this together for us and I appreciate your comment as well. Doctor Ertl about that. You know you'll bring us some data as well in Q2

157and Q3 and so I appreciate seeing that. Couple questions, couple comments. First one so just so I kind of understand. what we're doing here as well. So we have these goals as laid out by World's Best Workforce, which is changing its name. You know, for example, one of them reducing the achievement gaps, and then you've chosen to report out on reading, for example. Is there a reason reading was chosen as opposed to math or something like that? That's a good question. I think I think it's pretty typical for districts to use reading or math as the means by which they set goals and the reason is because we assess a lot in those things and so I think. That is why those areas typically are more representative of goal areas. Those are local decisions though.

158So we choose what we want to, how we want to set that goal and what we want to make the goal around. And then it gets reported to the state. Yep. Is A&I a state funding mechanism or a national one? State. It's state. Okay. All right. So now here's kind of my final question. And I understand the talk here about the fidelity, outcome fidelity framework. When we look at the MCA scores in reading that were reported out, slide 42, and I think I heard you say, Dr. Holm, that 97% of teachers are trained in letters right now. 90 are in training or have already completed training. So if I understand there's probably some degree of art to this, but when do you say we have enough, we've had enough fidelity to make a decision on

159if what we're doing is right or if we need to course correct? Because how many more years do we need to see this pattern to say maybe what we're doing here needs to change? Well, I think one thing to note is we haven't seen the pattern matriculate into third grade. So with our letters training, the majority of it going into K-2. And that's fine. There's reasons for hope. I'm with you. I'm with you. But, like, how, you know, if it's 95%, but it's still going down. Clark Thompson, if I may, I believe that during the presentation, correct me if I'm wrong, The way I interpreted this is the MCA scores that you are looking at is testing third graders. They are telling us that the letters training is only impacting our K through two students.

160So we will not see MCA data that reflects that fidelity investment until next year's test scores. Yeah, but then, you know, if two years from now, it didn't improve like we had hoped for, would that be enough to change the curriculum or not? Letters isn't a curriculum. It's a professional development. So the curriculum is not being analyzed when teachers are in that training. They're learning about how to teach reading. Or would we change the letters how we train the teachers? I'm just wondering, like, you know, at what point do you course correct? Or is there always more fidelity to be gained? And we are seeing strong benefits with letters. Agreed. So while we don't have third grade data yet, we're not ready to throw in the towel because we do see the improvements in the

161places where we have the most teachers trained in letters. So that's encouraging for us. I don't think you can put a number on it, but I think it's a constant. Like you said, it's an art and looking every single year and saying, how much fidelity do we feel like we have? How much do we think it's affecting the outcome? I mean, it's like any kind of measurement. It's impossible to know like X is causing Y, but we can do our very best. and that's what we're trying to do understood thank you thank you any other questions yes chair andreason yes treasurer hartland once you do thank you for coming today um tonight it's very late i know um once you do all this work like you're building your understanding here and who it's like what's

162the next phase so like you know this and then and so what is it building leaders that take it to teachers like what happens now that you know this so that we can all work more towards those goals because I think there's information yeah yeah and who kind of owns these goals that are set when you look at world's best workforce and you translate them into Hopkins goals like When you find out like oh, it's not going quite as well as we thought, what happens next? Sure, I think I would say a couple of things about that. So all of our schools set learning and teaching goals, culture goals, and operations goals. And so the learning goals are all aligned to kind of what we have been talking about. And then I think to... Maybe

163what you were also asking is like well who owns the work of it and or now that we know Oh here we made this maybe we didn't make this one. I would answer that twofold. So we I mean we do work closely with our building leaders and their leadership teams to bring that awareness and our instruction Hopkins instructional leadership team as well. I think one of the other ways that we are working on fidelity was mentioned on one of the slides was also. really helping our school leaders and our school leadership teams to understand what do these changed practices actually look like, sound like in a classroom so that they can be highlighting and emphasizing where... these practices are in place and we can then correlate data that say, yeah, we think we saw practice

164X, Y, and Z here using, we have an observation tool that we use, and we think that there's a strong correlation there to improved data, like Dr. Holm was saying. We're training our leadership teams on that as well, and in addition to supporting all of the teachers who are kind of going through the training. Thank you. Great, thank you. I just wanted to echo appreciation on the fidelity focus. I think that that is often, when you made the comment that you said we make a change and hope it works, I feel like that happens all the time. So it really resonated with me. So I like that we are focusing on that. And I also just want to make sure that to urge the administration that that is something that's consistent across all sites. I

165think we get a lot of anecdotal feedback that that's not necessarily happening. So I'm thrilled that fidelity is a focus and part of this report. I also just have just a few questions where I think my understanding was not quite wrapping around. When I looked at the ACT data, I was wondering why it was a goal to keep our score where it's at. Yes. So the goal is actually not showing the averages. The goal is around, let me pull it up so that I say the words correctly. The goal is around the percent of students who score that average. Right. Is that what you were asking? I'm sorry. Yeah, so I'm wondering why it's a goal when we are attaining a score of 21, or maybe we didn't see the data on that. Do we

166have data on that? Yes, but we can't compare it to our state and national. So it's been a... It's been a practice where we share the state and the national averages with you as well as our school average. So we just maintained that visual. So the percentage of students in grade 11 at Hopkins High School increased by 48% of a composite score of 21? Is that what we're seeing? 48% is what the goal was, and we did meet that goal. Okay. Yeah. Okay, that's what I was wondering. So in the past? Yes. Had we not? Right. Scored at 21? Because the graph is saying that we have consistently scored 22, 22, 22, 21, 21. Yeah, it's not the average that we're looking at. We're looking at, so if we think about the distribution of, you

167know, the student gets a 21, the student gets a 24, the student gets a 28, we want 48% of our students to get a 21 or higher. So that's what we're looking at. And so it's a little bit. mismatched but because we can't pull the data for this on state and national and that's what we've been asked for before we provide the state and national data. Think the thing I would add that I'm stuck in me to understand it was So when you have an average it's made up of all these numbers, right? And it could be that you have ten really really high numbers and ten really really low numbers and I think what we're saying is we want to reduce that span and have a higher percentage of our students actually at the

168average so that our average is not made up of like Enormous gaps. It's more made up of a lot of small spaces along the way with close to half of our students, right? 48% of our students meeting that average number. Because over time that will then help raise our average number. Average or higher. You want a normal curve around 21? Yes. Okay, so that's something that I guess we're not seeing the data that says that we've hit that mark. We can follow up with that data if that would be helpful. Yeah, we didn't think it would be confusing, but it seems like it is. Sorry. No, that's okay. Numbers are not my strong suit. And then I was also wondering about the fidelity goal around the PSAT. Is this an aspirational PSAT administration for all

16910th graders? Because currently I know we only offer it to juniors. No, the PSAT is for 10th graders and the ACT is for 11th graders. I'm sorry, repeat your question again. Yeah, I'm wondering about the PSAT administration at the high school. Yes, and it is administered to 10th graders. But our goal is to administer to all 10th graders, just as our goal is to administer the ACT to all. But we have 71% complete the ACT. we want to increase and provide the PSAT opportunity to all students. Just gets them ready for the ACT their junior year. Okay, thank you. Oh, and that's all. We don't have any board action here. This is information. Sorry. I was waiting for somebody else to... I just want to thank you for all the work that goes into this.

170I do want to mention that we are sitting in the midst of multiple truths. So on the one hand, we are required to look at these traditional measures and report out how we are doing with our teaching and learning systems against these traditional measures. And at the same time, we just heard from our LAC, which on their platform is a recommendation to decrease our reliance on standardized tests. and implement systems that better and more accurately measure the strengths and gifts and talents of our students and also their readiness for real world expectations. So I think we just have to hold that we are doing those two things at the same time. We're reporting out on these traditional measures and we're also really working hard to reimagine student success metrics here in Hopkins. This team and

171I recently attended a four-hour training by John Tanner at the Association of Metropolitan School Districts meeting along with probably 60 or 70 other superintendents, some board members and district office leaders, including in teaching and learning. And we were reminded that standardized tests were never designed to inform instructional decisions. Standardized tests were never designed to indicate school, teaching or student quality. They were never designed to pass judgment about what students know or are able to do or what schools are doing well. Instead, they are designed to, at a very high level, identify patterns and trends amongst large tested populations. And so we have to really... remember that as we are reporting on these traditional measures as well as continuing to work on building balanced and more holistic assessment systems. So I thank you all for sitting

172at the center of that juxtaposition. Just you know partnering together so we can think of ways to educate our parents and teachers and community that a single score is not the end-all be-all We have to be balanced and holistic and we have to help our students do well on tests Thank you so much And that takes us to our next agenda item, which is policies in first read. I will invite Assistant Superintendent Nick Lightfoot to the table and turn it over to Vice Chair Ross. Thank you chair Andreessen. Yes, we have five policies that we are going to review today with the collective peers here at the table and I'll turn it over to assistant lightfoot assistant superintendent lightfoot, please Good evening. Good to be with you As mentioned, the Monitoring Committee is continuing its

173set of work with the 400 series and in addition the Policy 531, which is the Pledge of Allegiance. So all of those are in front of you this evening. Just by way of going through these with you, what we did review, I'll go through each of these individually, but the first one that the Monitoring Committee took a look at was... Gifts to employees, policy 421. You will note that the Minnesota School Board Association has a corresponding model policy as well. There were no recent revisions to that Minnesota School Board Association policy. There are no specific changes that the monitoring committee was recommending. Pretty standard, been in place for periods of time. If there are specific questions or other comments from. monitoring committee members would entertain those at this time. I don't see any questions. All

174right. If none there, policy 427, special education workload. There were some minor revisions in 2023 based on just a couple of notations within the statutory framework for the policy. This is really an authorizing policy. What it does is it identifies the definition, the components that are to be considered, and then obligates the district to make sure that it is doing its work in partnership with Education Association. to look at the specific conditions, the specific components. Some of those are in statute. Others are locally determined in partnership and then authorizes that work to move forward as part of the collective bargaining process. So that is the nature of 427. Are there specific questions related to 427 or comments by monitoring committee members? I don't see any. All right. 451, this is a policy that does also

175capture required information. This information is staff notification specific to sets and conditions that are outlined when there is violent behavior. They are outlined according to the model policy that was developed through the Minnesota Department of Education and has been carried forward into the policy that you see here with you. There are specific questions on 451. There are no changes for the staff notification policy so noted. Nothing has been recommended to be changed and there were no other model policy changes to reflect any different need at this time. If there are other comments from monitoring committee members or questions, happy to entertain those also. Chair Andreessen? Yes, Director Zhao. I do have a question for Dr. Lightfoot. So we're required to notify the teacher. I'm reading the policy. What are they allowed to do with that,

176right? Do they take different action? Are they just aware? You know, what is the implication of telling them? Yep, absolutely. So if you look the notification and the receipt of notice, there are specific parts that are taken into consideration and dependent on the nature of what has occurred in partnership with the instructor, the administration will work on looking at what those plans are and developing those plans for what that future action would be. And then how that information is captured and then how that information is then communicated forward. As you'll note in the policy, there are some specific actions that need to occur such that there is notification that moves forward even as it identifies here to substitute instructors, other information that can be moved forward into plans that are even beyond the present school

177year into the next. So that partnership is really the essence of what next steps would happen. Thank you. I don't think there are any other questions or comments. All right. Policy 453. Policy 453 is a part-time policy for staff. And there again, that is an... 450 range, a Hopkins local policy. So if there are specific questions, there is no model policy. This is information that pertains particular to our work here in the Hopkins School District. And as such, if there are questions on the part-time professional staff employment, I am more than happy to entertain those questions. I don't see any questions. All right. Last policy that we have is an annual review policy. This is the Pledge of Allegiance. In the Pledge of Allegiance policy, you will note that there was just a minor edit

178to the language there. Monitoring Committee may want to speak to that change, but it was really just a minor edit to the language. And then in addition, There was staff request for the board to consider what is outlined within statute, which is the option that a school board could consider. And it has been a practice in the 2020-23 school year. That the statute that requires that we have a Pledge of Allegiance policy also allows the board to annually, by majority vote, waive the requirements that are part of this policy. So, yes, we are required to have the policy. The policy is here. The policy is up for an annual review. As such, as a board, annually, you also have the ability to waive this being a requirement in the way that it is brought forth

179within the district. Monitoring committee members, did I capture that correctly? It's not an easy concept, but I know we discussed that at length and tried to think about how we could present that to the board. Based on staff feedback, asking the board to consider again for 24-25, the action that it took in the 22-23 school year. Chair Andreessen, Vice Chair Ross, do you mind if I provide a little context? Sure, OK, please great. Thank you. So when we discussed this previously in 2022 and decided to to vote on this waiver that is contained in statute, it was really to provide more flexibility for individual schools to determine how and when they wanted to say the pledge, how they wanted to do instruction around this. How they wanted to do instruction around because contained in the

180policy is this idea of how we treat the flag, how we show respect to the flag. And each school community. might want to approach this in a different way. So what's been confusing for staff who have come forward to the policy committee members is that we have not done the waiver since 2022 and it's an annual waiver. And so now schools are. required to follow this policy that is really stringent about when the pledge recitation happens. So the vote on the waiver wouldn't be saying, you know, you can't recite the Pledge of Allegiance. That's not what the vote on the waiver is at all, right? The vote on the waiver is we want to provide flexibility to our schools to approach this in a meaningful way with students and staff. Thank you for that context.

181Sure. I believe that's kind of historical in nature too with the board. Yeah, absolutely. Chair Andreessen? Yes, Director Zhao. I do have a question. Is there a difference between saying may and having a waiver? To me, it seems kind of the same, but what's the difference? I think I need some clarity on this too. The policy states shall students in the school district shall recite the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America. I feel like I'm saying it one or more times each week. The recitation may be conducted. And then it gives ways that it would be conducted, which is by an individual classroom teacher, over a school intercom. So the waiver would be applying to the shall recite. Or the existence, right? If we waive it, we're saying you

182don't have to. Right. Okay, got it. So if we waive it, then we could change it. It could read students in the school district may recite the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States. So we could. possibly change that shell to May? Or is the better practice to keep it exactly how it's written in statute and then put a note in the policy saying that for this period of time, the school board has voted to waive this? And then I would like for our community to have a little bit more narrative around that saying to provide schools flexibility for how to teach this. and do this. Yeah, I think to that point that was reflective of the conversation that we had and looking at that to your question, yes, it shall does

183reflect the statutory element of these, which is part of the requirement. I think as you gave context to what the waiver is, is once a week via intercom, that level of... Absolute specificity, the additional that there would need to be the proper etiquette, the correct display, when does that happen, all of those elements. Looking at that also as part of the required elements, if not waived. And so I think that's been part of the dialogue. The note would allow for that inclusion of including that. with more context, but it would keep the same language reflected from the statute with shall. So if we change that proposed. May back to shell that mirrors statute, right? And then the note provides really more of this intent around the flexibility of how it's done and The clarification that

184if the board decides to vote on the waiver That that waiver was voted on for this period of time because that's an annual vote that needs to come up. Correct chair Andreessen Yes, clerk Thompson. Thanks, Director Westmoreland, for some of the background there as well and some context. I'm just curious, was there a vote for 23-24, or did it just slip people's minds and then it became in place? Yeah, I think it just fell off the radar. Hence staff questions about this. So this is a response to this issue coming back to us from the community. Chair Andreessen? Yes, Treasurer Hartland. Would that action, would we do that at, say, the next board meeting? Do we need anything else in order to consider that? Or is the policy committee wanting us to take that action

185tonight? I would propose that we take the action tonight and make the changes, make the note, and we can bring it back in second read. Yeah, the only statutory requirement is a majority vote. On the waiver or the policy? On the waiver. Oh, we're talking about both right now. Right. And you would have two actions, one on the policy itself and then the other on the waiver. Okay. Chair Andreessen. Yes, Clerk Thompson. Can I ask the policy committee's reason for changing the may tell shall for those two ways to do it? I believe that statute has the language shall, and there was a proposed change from the second shall to a may. Yeah, I'm wondering why that proposed change. I will take responsibility for it because it was my proposed wordsmithing, and I thought, oh,

186like this could, if we voted on the waiver. then that becomes a may, right? Because it, again, provides more flexibility around how this is taught, how this is done. But I think the better, after this conversation at the board table, I think the better option is to keep it shell-shell so that it mirrors statutory language and then have a note around the waiver component. Oh, so we don't forget. Right. Like we did. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. One, so we don't forget. Yeah, one, so we don't forget. And also so that we're not tinkering with the policy language every time. Because there might be a board that doesn't approve the waiver. And then you've got this random may in there that doesn't make any sense. And it doesn't reflect statute. Right. Yeah, I think that's good.

187to add the note about the waiver, why, maybe a little bit to provide flexibility. So would we direct the monitoring committee to make those changes and then just have it be on approval, the consent calendar for second read? Does everyone feel comfortable with that? Chair Andreessen, I think I would be more comfortable seeing the wording of the note before I were to vote on it. You will as part of consent. So if you didn't like the wording, you could pull it for discussion. So the policy would be in second read, removing May, going back to shall, and then there would be a note about the waiver. And like anything on consent, you have the opportunity to review it before it's voted on. It just means one less agenda item for us. That's all. So process-wise,

188we would vote on the waiver tonight, send the policy back to, because the note is moot if we don't vote, if we don't waive it. We would vote on the waiver tonight, send the policy back to the monitoring committee to be able to add the note, and then that would appear on consent, and it could be pulled and discussed if needed. Yeah. Is that good for everyone? I mean, I apologize. I'm still, I suppose you'd see it in consent, but I'm just not comfortable doing. something, you know, approving a waiver when I haven't seen the note, that type of thing. No, we're not approving the waiver. I mean, unless we are, but we're discussing this policy language, retaining the second shall, inserting a note about the waiver. That's what's going to appear on consent. The

189waiver will be voted on tonight. Okay. Does that make sense? It's been a long day. I know. Yeah, it has. And the point of the waiver is just really to give more freedom to each site to make whatever decision they want to make. There's nothing being stripped from a language or nothing that we're mandating to any sites or any... teachers of what they they cannot say or they can say to her just basically it's almost like the federal government saying states states rights you manage how you see fit and so that's kind of how the approach is with what we're trying to do so a building would not have to teach flag etiquette for example specifically right correct if we pass the waiver if we pass the waiver okay And this came directly from community

190members. So let me clarify. This came specifically from staff. So this is not like a... Support of. Right. In support of having the freedom to be able to let each site choose how they want to manage. Do you know how difficult it is to teach flag etiquette? Like, is there... Free resources or something I would imagine So for purposes of this policy, I'm sorry to continue to try and like Separate the two because I would like to just know what we're doing with this policy So are we all okay with having this policy? with a note added the change not accepted Go to back to the monitoring committee to add in the note about the waiver and then beyond consent. So we can pass these as a slate into second read. We're all good. And

191then now we can discuss the waiver. Can we have that be a separate action? Yes. Is that okay? So we can continue discussion if necessary? Awesome. So I would look for a motion to pass, sorry, that is not the correct wording. I would look for a motion to approve the above policies in first read. Further the board directs the administration to prepare the policies with all suggested revisions for approval and second reading at the next meeting as part of consent So moved I have a motion. Is there a second second? I have a motion and a second Any discussion see none all those in favor, please say aye aye any opposed the Motion passes and we can move on to discussing a waiver of Hopkins Policy 531 on recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance. Thank

192you. Any discussion? I would look for a motion to, I'm not quite sure the language needed, but to waive the recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America one or more times each week and that it shall be conducted in individual classroom teacher or over a school intercom system. I move that we waive the requirement as contained in statute. Do I have a second? Second. I have a motion and a second. Any discussion? Seeing none, all those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? I'll abstain. The motion passes. And we are now moving on to our board member reports. This will give everyone an opportunity to introduce themselves and to give any updates for the community. I will. Oh, thank you, Assistant Superintendent Lightfoot. Thank you. Appreciate

193your time. It's too late for me to be conducting a meeting. Clerk Thompson, would you like to begin? I think I began two weeks ago, so I would not like to begin this time. Okay, sorry. That's all right. I will take it to Director Westmoreland. Hi, I'm Dr. Jen Westmoreland. I've served on the Hopkins School Board for seven years. I am a proud graduate of Hopkins Schools. I am the parent of an eighth grader who went through the Xing Xing program, is still in the Xing Xing program, is moving through the Xing Xing program. And just one thing to update the board on. So for the past two years, I've served as the only school board representative in the county to the Heading Home Hennepin Executive Committee. That is a continuum of care partnership that

194is convened by Hennepin County with the goal of eradicating homelessness throughout the county. And so they brought me on two years ago. I was the first school board member. to be appointed because they really wanted a school district perspective on the work. So I'm completing my term and I have made a recommendation to that committee that Director Burke-Roper take my seat on it. So hopefully that transition will happen in January. And that's all I have. Hello, this is Jim Ming Zhao. I am on my first year on the school board. I have two kids in the system in Xingxing fourth grade and first grade. In light of the time, I will skip my board member report. Good evening. My name is Jason Ross. I'm in my third year and my first term. I have three

195kids in the system, two at North, one at Tanglin. And my board report was that I attended the 2024 Delegate Assembly. I received some nice reading material. If anybody is interested in reading it, you can read it to your kids and put them to sleep. So I did that, and it was interesting to see kind of the platform from a legislative perspective. that we were interested in bringing forth to our local legislators. So hopefully everybody similar to what you saw tonight with the platform for Hopkins, it is eerily similar to what MSBA platform was hoping to shape up to be. And so, yeah, speak to your local legislator and tell them we need money. That's it. In a nutshell. Hi everyone, my name is Shannon Andreessen. This is my fifth year on the Hopkins School

196Board. I work as a paraprofessional at Gatewood Elementary and I have a junior at the high school and a recent, well, maybe not so recent graduate. And I was also at the Delegate Assembly, so I will. pass it on to Dr. Mary Perry-Reed. Good evening. I'm Rhoda Mary Perry-Reed, superintendent. I've already provided my board report for the evening. I do have a junior at our high school and a seventh grader at West. I am Treasurer Rachel Heartland. I'm in my third year on the board. I use she, her pronouns and have three children in the district at Meadowbrook, North, and the high school. And in light of the time, I'll refrain from further board report. Hello, my name is Brooke Rober, and I'm serving my first year on a board. I have two amazing students

197in the district. A really quick report. Last week, I had the opportunity to sit on a panel with other school board members from across the metro to talk about the future of education. and with a specific focus on black and brown students. And it was a really good discussion with the Minneapolis NAACP and the United Black Legislative Agenda, and just determining the best way forward to support black and brown students' outcomes in our districts, excuse me, in our public education system. I look forward to having more conversations and being in collaboration with partnership, in partnership with the districts and the community to move that forward. I'm Kai Thompson. I'm in my first year on the board, and I serve as the clerk. I've got three kids in the district, fourth grade, eighth grade, ninth grade.

198Board report I would have is, you know, I've just had some conversations with... with parents of kids in the school and district recently. And you know, I just wanted to echo something I had heard Dr. Marypeer Reed say earlier about, you know, really the importance of hearing from the community, both about the good and both about the bad. And I just really was impressed by some of the bravery of some of the parents who were able to speak in public this evening. So appreciate that dialogue. It's just very important for our district. So that's the end of my report. Thank you. And with that, I would look for a motion to adjourn. So moved. Is there no more public comments? No. Oh, okay. Thanks for checking. Yeah. I have a motion. Second. And a second.

199Any discussion? Hearing none, all those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Any opposed? The meeting is adjourned at 1022 p.m. Thank you all for staying. Thank you all, parents, families, staff.

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.