001All right. The Monday, December 9th, 2024 Invergrove Heights Community Schools Board of Education meeting is called to order at 5.29 p.m. We are meeting tonight in the district office boardroom. As a reminder, all public comment during regular school board meetings must be related to an information or action item on that night's agenda. The district holds public listening sessions prior to all regular board meetings to allow participants to speak on topics that are not on the agenda. More information on public comment and public listening sessions can be found on the district's website. This meeting is being recorded. Access to the recording will be made available on the school district's website as quickly as possible. Our school district's mission is to inspire, innovate, excel. A community commitment. Board Clerk Larson, will you please take roll? Of course.
002Member Warrick is absent tonight. Member Dukes? Here. Member Klingner? Here. Member Pearson? Here. Member Nehemiah? Here. Member Larson? Here. Member Lonsberry? Here. Please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. This evening is our annual Truth in Taxation hearing, and the presentation cannot begin until 6 p.m. This is an information item on this evening's agenda. We are asking the board to continue on with the regular meeting agenda and to insert the Truth in Taxation presentation into the agenda at the first natural break on or after 6 p.m. Thank you. Do I have a motion and a second to approve the agenda items and to amend
003tonight's agenda if needed as requested? All right motion by member Klingner second by member Nehemiah. Any discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? The motion is carried. We would like to welcome Director of Community Education Barb Pierce to introduce this month's highlight. Thank you. This year the state of Minnesota is celebrating 50 years of early childhood family education in the state. So my early learning wonderful team is here to let you know all about early childhood family ed in the state, in our district, and all the wonderful things they do. So Laura Lambert is our early learning coordinator. So I'll let you introduce her. Okay, thank you. Well, introduce us. Always familiar faces, which is fun. So ECFV is really unique and special to the state of Minnesota. It was started in 1974. So 2024
00450 years quick math, right? hasn't been here that long. And we'll talk about that a little bit. But here's the ECFV mission. and to support all parents and provide the best environment and healthy growth of children and then components of all ecfe programs parent ed parent child interaction and early childhood education and always nurturing relationships and making connections are the cornerstone of ecfe and all early learning that says why we're here Okay, sorry. The, just, I will read through all these, but just a little bit of timeline for early learning in IGH, because some of you may or may not remember. Before 2012, everything was, both districts had money, but I went to South St. Paul, and they directed the programs, and most of the programs were held on their site. except we did have
005preschool at Salem Hills and at Hilltop and then preschool was the first thing that separated and brought over and then a year or so later screening came over here and first to three for early childhood special at home visits and our new early learning center and I know I remember Liz you were there at that opening a long time ago and you were there at that opening um yeah And then the two Daves got together and put together an ECFE task force who spent a good half a year or longer kind of really looking at both programs. And in the end, the recommendation was to split the programs. And the full, that's a link there. If anybody wants to ever go back and look at it. And then we did. We started our own program.
006We're actually the third. newest ECFE program in the state and the other two that just started really were the result of bigger districts combining so we're kind of unique at that I feel like we're starting we had a lot of work to do so one of the first steps before we even had classes was to create an early learning advisory council that's something that's required by statute for all ecfe programs and the primary purpose is to advise which makes sense our advisory council wanted to do some of the role of pta to help support early learning so they did but still the primary focus is to is advising and that was our first Board. Aren't you on the first one? Or the first meeting, first year? Oh, I get one. That's your secretary. When Invergrove,
007oh, it was the fundraising. Yeah, fundraising, okay. I guess when Invergrove just split off. Right. That was the first one? Yeah. Then yeah, probably. Yeah. um caroline snodgrass second from left is here tonight she was on the trends she did a lot of work with transition she was our first advisory council president she's going to share a little bit about that transition process thank you laura yeah again my caroline snodgrass i know a lot of you already know me um i've got three kids in our district i've got a seventh grader i've got a fifth grader and i've got a kindergartner And I'm excited to help celebrate 50 years of ECFE because it's very near and dear to my heart. My daughter started going to ECFE, my oldest, when she was six months old. And
008as you well know, parenting is a little bit of baptism by fire. And that first one, she was extra something. And ECFE became a central part of my life. because it was an opportunity to connect, to learn, to commiserate, and to share joys with each other as well. When the programs were joint, I started attending ECFE in 2012. And when the programs were joint, I remember, there's a lot of information when you're a new parent, and I remember feeling like, I was a little confused. put our school districts together and am I a Packer or am I a Spartan? It was actually a little bit to navigate at first and I served for two years on the Early Learning Advisory Council for the joint program for two years and when it was announced that we
009were going to develop our own program just for Amber Grove, I got excited. And because I loved that idea of my kids were going to be Spartans because I felt more connected with the school district. I felt like I understood what was the progression of how they would move through the school when I knew we were going to be little Spartans. And so I really liked that because for my own brain, I wanted it to be less confusing. And so I had the privilege of being the first president of our Early Learning Advisory Council in Invergrove. And that was a really great experience because I was surrounded by other volunteers on the Learning and Learning Advisory Council that were just fantastic. And we got to write our own bylaws. And we got to, thanks in
010part, and okay, entirely, to Megan Parsons. We developed our 501c3. and to do some of our fundraising function, as Laura mentioned, kind of PTA role. Or we did a little fundraising for the program as well. But our primary role was to advise. It was different when we started working on our own independent program and Laura really wanted our feedback and took that all to heart. That was our primary goal and I think that it's really unique that early learning or the ECFE programs require you to have an advisory council. I think it's fabulous. We felt part of the program and Laura always came to us, took our information, took it to heart, made things happen, and so it was a real privilege to be a part of the start of our own early learning program
011in Inver Grove. Look at my chicken scratchings here. Laura, when we first started developing the new program for Inver Grove, she jumped right in. She was excited about it, and you could tell. And she went out and found the best darn people you can imagine. It was the best. And I'm looking at all these people back here that I've known for years. I don't know how she did it. I don't know if you were looking for years or if you pulled the hat. She pulled the rabbit out of the hat. And they together created a very dynamic, very strong program. I always used to say that after the first couple years of our program, I said, when I go to ECFE, and at times I was going twice a week because I had two kids
012and different ages, and I was like, this is like taking a college course in parenting. It was so supportive. It gave dynamic things for my kids to do when we went every week. It gave me an opportunity to connect with people and parents that had kids similar ages as me. And I met some of my best friends there. And so I can't tell you enough what ECFE means to our family. The connections for how I've learned and grown as a parent and the way that has set my children up for a successful career in education, of their educational career, I should say. The one major thing I have to say about... having our own ECFE program and early learning program all together, including our preschool program, is that it gives you that opportunity to connect
013with those parents and those families really young and keep them here in our district. Once you have that commitment that you've been going since you've become your six-week-old to ECFE, once you've been going that long, really, in your heart, you become a Spartan. And I really think that our early learning program really sets us up for retention of families in the district. So I will pass it over to our next speaker. But again, thanks for letting me be a part of our 50 years of ECFE program celebration. Thank you. Thank you. We were so lucky as a program because not only did we hire the most awesome staff, but our the board we had the women who supported us getting going we're just this is our first facebook post in 2017 our first class and
014teacher julia rhoda hello i'm the early childhood teacher for our ecfe program here in isd 199. I serve as an educator, facilitator, mentor, advocate, and entertainer for families. Our teacher insights into child development and best practices help empower parents and guide them through the struggles of raising young children. Trust and communication are the foundation of the educational process in ECFE. So building strong relationships and connections with families is essential. As early childhood family education teachers, we provide significant benefits to families by fostering strong parent-child connections and offering valuable resources. Our work empowers families with the tools to support their children's success, ensuring every child gets the best possible start in life. My personal journey into ECFE started in 2004. I started bringing my kids and joined the ISD 196 Advisory Council to meet families in
015our community. This program became the center of our lives. We met the best and greatest friends and mentors who we still have connections with today. During this time, one of the teachers helped me to find classes so I could have my teaching license renewed, and I accepted a job as a para in the ISD 196 program. The ECFE position here in ISD 199 came up right when I had finished my coursework. I don't know if you believe in science, but that one seemed pretty clear. When I think back on the journey, I don't know where I would be today without the connections that I made in the ECFE program. And now I'm lucky enough to be able to provide this opportunity to families here in ISD 199. Thank you. And I'm going to introduce Patricia
016next. Go ahead, Patricia. Go ahead, Patricia. I am the parent educator for and last is familia escuela class which is up and links between family and school and this class is taught in Spanish and our class also includes the parent child time, parent education and early childhood education. We follow the parent education core curriculum framework, but we focus on the relationships and trust among Spanish-speaking families. And we also educate families so they can integrate themselves into our school system, keeping their language and culture, which is important. So one thing that I don't like is to see statistics in our school district when ELL students are performing lower than other students. But based on this, we have a lot of work to do. I do know within my Spanish-speaking families. So we need to prioritize the
017family education within this community and start from the very beginning. At ECFE we provide a lot of support. to families and also we try to help them connect into the community resources and share strategies that help their children's growth and development and yeah those early years are very important and parents, families need to know it so yeah that's our main focus. One of the parents who attended who attend our program is Halima Tarifa. She's not here, but she also has something to say. And she first started, I think, our Learning Across Cultures class. We have that, too, with different languages. And she wrote a lot, and she was so excited. And she did record it, but I paraphrased her a little bit. Do you want to just come to that first part? Sure. Okay, so
018Halima, yeah, she started in our family learning program. We at that point had an English language learning component too, which was great. And since it shifted to just called Parenting Across Cultures, and it really wants to celebrate what Patricia is saying. We want to honor people retaining their first language of origin and heritages, and so we get to talk about different cultures and learn from each other. And she's been coming since Ansar was two and a half. And he's still in ECFE and also doing preschool in our district and she has some great things to say. I can talk to them, I can spend quality time with them, like a routine. The routine is discipline. The most important for me is discipline and they listen and support me. That's the most important for me because
019I want to be there when they need me. So I can see them, how they are doing well. I really, I really, because of this. And the other most important thing is I never ever ever sat with other cultures out of my culture. I never sat with other cultures like Spanish, white people and discuss with how we raised our children. I never did before. But now I do. I have a lot of experience like different backgrounds, different background, religion, culture, you know what, on raising children, we all are the same. Halima would have maybe would have been here tonight it would have been a stretch she's always says my English is not great miss Brenda and I'm like it's amazing and you're amazing and so it was wonderful she spent a lot of records and
020rerecords sending me that so I'm very grateful to Halima she watches this So my name is Brenda Larson, and if you're wondering who has the most amazing job in the district or maybe the world, it's me. I'm a parent educator, and what that means is when the children come to ECFE, they kind of have three parts of our program. We have a non-separating time where we're in a classroom that Miss Julia or other early childhood teachers sets up with developmentally appropriate activities and games and toys and the mess that the parents don't have to deal with and clean up. And then there's a part where they separate as they're older and comfortable and the kids stay and play in that safe early childhood environment and the parents come to a classroom with me. I started
021my career as a middle school counselor but quickly became frustrated as I felt the adolescents were taking one step forward and two steps back if they went home to a unsupportive or just not very stable home environment. So hence my second and favorite career is a parent educator. I discovered ECFE and love it. I'm from Wisconsin. We don't have ECFE. I don't know if people know that Minnesota is the only state in the union that has ECFE. So believes that all parents can benefit from support and education and learning from a young age. Other districts and other states have programs need-based and resources, but ECFE is only in the state of Minnesota, and it's amazing. I heard about it from one of my girlfriends that raised her young kids through ECFE programs in the cities.
022So my goal as a parent ed is all about connection. Parenting can feel really lonely, especially in today's world. And ECFE connects parents to their children, connects parents to our school and to our community, and it connects parents to research-based parenting information and most importantly to one another. Parents coming to ECFE share their questions and struggles with no judgment. They ask questions ranging from tips on potty training to the ever-elusive, how do I get my child to sleep through the night, or even in their own bed, or sleep at all, to handling tantrums and public meltdowns, make sure to target toy aisle. They bounce ideas off one another and realize they're not alone in their struggles. Parents also become really vulnerable saying things like I'm super stressed out and I feel like I'm always losing
023on my child. What do I do? So within the safe supportive walls of the parent ed classroom parents from traumatic backgrounds have opened up and shared about their past struggles and how those struggles are impacting them as they parent their own children. These parents learned that an unregulated adult cannot regulate an unregulated child. We talk a lot about self-care, parents needing to take care of themselves as well. They gain not only new skills and ideas from me, the parent ed, and Patricia and other parent eds, but more importantly, they gain support and encouragement from the other parents in the room. When they come back to class and share a parenting success story, we all celebrate together. Parents are all just trying to do their very best. I'm so grateful to have a job that encourages
024them on this journey. A few years ago, a mom reached out to me during a divorce with the following email. Said, thank you for being a light in my life for the last year. Thank you for creating a safe and uplifting place that welcomed me in every form. Devastated, terrified, overwhelmed, grieving, and clawing my way back. On a journey that has felt more isolated than not, your classroom was one of the few places I could go that it felt enough to just be. My life is infinitely better because of ECFE. And my life is infinitely better because of the opportunity to be part of ISD's 199 ECFE program, so thank you for your support. Rachel, this is one of our awesome parents that comes twice a week right now. We have a couple of double
025dippers like Caroline and we love it. I'll take it. Two times with Brenda a week. Just to kind of piggyback on that, I also reached out to Brenda last summer or the summer before just totally at my wits end from being with the kids all day every day in the summer and not having ECFE. So she happened to be in the cities that day. We met at Starbucks and walked around Burlington Coat Factory and I vented to her about how hard the summer had been with the kits. So very grateful for Brenda. I'm Rachel. I have two kids in the district as well. My daughter is eight and I hear your voice on my voicemail all the time. I was like, oh my gosh, I'm like having flashbacks. It's okay. It's a nice voice. Do
026you delete it right away? I don't know. It's hard. There's a transcription so you can read it too. So I used to joke with Shelly, the other ECFE teacher that left last year, that if she ever needed somebody to write a 10-page paper about ECFE, I'm your gal. So I'll try to keep this within five minutes. ECFE is just such a gift for parents and families, and I am so, so, so, so grateful for it all the time. I really, I do not know, I would be totally crazy without ECFE. I mean, this is how parenting is meant to be, in my opinion. A village, a community, and the fact that... Minnesota's had it for 50 years. Like, that's just crazy. And the fact that other states don't have it, I'm from Iowa, as you
027can tell, and we don't have it there. And I see my sisters struggling, you know, with building community. And here I have this wonderful gift, like, two minutes from my house that I get to go to for two hours twice a week where I can be with other parents. And I just wish that other people had that wonderful gift that I have. And something I always point out to people is that unless that you are a parent yourself, you don't really understand. And so when you go to ECFE, it's sort of like group therapy in a way. Everybody in that room is going through the same thing that you are going through either currently or they have gone through it before with other kids or they're about to go through it. So they kind of
028get a little worrying about it. So that's one really nice part about it. Personally, I have a history with mental illness and a lot of depression, especially around parenting. And ECFE is just, oh, it's such a savior when it comes to that. Because, first of all, it gives me a reason to, you know, get out of the house and get dressed and, you know, make my way to talk with friends and have support. With all my family out of state, that's especially helpful. And a lot of people in this community don't have. Family like that, you know, especially like Halima, you know, she doesn't have that extended family. I don't think so And the way it's set up is just so perfect because you go in and everything you have different stations And it's all
029safe for your kid. You don't have to be on edge like oh is my kid gonna knock this over or do anything like that? So the way that Julia has it set up is so creative and they have little activities for the kids to do and you don't have to clean it up. And it's stuff that maybe you wouldn't have thought of for your own house either or bought. So that's really fun. And then you get to go have coffee without your kid for an hour, which is just really relaxing. Brenda really does a great job about making the class feel safe and welcoming. Everyone's heard all different opinions, all different backgrounds. And the best part is that we have fun. We laugh a lot. We have a lot of jokes. We have a lot
030of inside jokes. I think what was our recent one, like campy CFE, we're going to get like a cabin. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, we want to like have a cabin. And it's just all judgment for you. Come as you are. and it makes you feel less crazy um yeah and oh uh my son was speech delayed so i got resources for his speech through uh helped me grow and you know it's just right there in that hallway and you know she could even see him during ecfe if there was not time to come to my house that week um yeah i just i wish every state had it i'm just such a huge huge advocate for this program and i'm very grateful for this community resource so thanks Thank you. So seven years strong for
031our program. Going strong and as you can tell we have just incredible people in our program, teaching our program, supporting it. Melissa and Bridget, a lot of the background work and supporting in class. Very lucky. These statistics, we'll go over them all. of the families that are in other school districts have grandparents here or child care here so it was kind of fun because I was like oh that's really high and I kind of dug into it a little bit more. That's it. Thank you very much. Any comments or questions people have? Just go ahead. I would just say And Dave remembers this. I was very nervous. Caroline, you brought that. I was very nervous when we were splitting off from South St. Paul because my kids, I had started in ACFE with the joint
032program in 2007. And it was... I needed it so much, Rachel. I needed it so much in my life. It kept me sane. So many things about it made for the rest of my kids' experiences better. And then, Laura, you came in and you got Patricia and you got Brenda and Shelly, and it just became such an incredible program here. And I said, I was wrong. This was amazing. It's such a great... great start for our families and the only thing is I wish every family knew about ECFE. That's the only thing is we still, some people still don't know about it, but wow. And Laura, what a great job you have done and I want to thank you and I know you're retiring soon, so I cannot thank you enough for the work you've
033done. Liz, I remember that quite well because when we decided to take that leap into looking at whether or not it was feasible to stay together or split, there was some apprehension. And once we made that move, it was very evident that it was the right move. And it's so wonderful to be able to celebrate that tonight in addition to the 50 years. And when you hear that phrase, early family childhood education, Brenda, you just reminded me that it's not only your own family, but it's a family you develop. And you see that in the programs all the time, that you develop another family that you can go to. And as Caroline was sharing, it's the thing that we talked about at our house when we had kids, where the heck is the owner's manual?
034Because there isn't one. And to be able to commiserate with other people and to see that they're actually going through the same things you are actually grows your confidence and grows your understanding, but also grows the people that you can have conversations with. Thank you all for the wonderful work that you do but also thank you parents for taking the time and finding ECFE to help establish that foundation not only for your family but for their time in school as well. And then yes, Laura is probably in that less than six weeks club maybe? Laura? Wow. And just want to thank you for the commitment that you have had to the program and for the work that you did to ensure that it got off to a strong foundation so it can continue. Because when
035you separate, and realistically, if I remember right, when we separated, we didn't really have any buddy. And if I remember the first, the person next to you is the first person we went after, if I remember right. Yeah. Do you remember that, Patricia? Yeah. Maybe it'll be okay. Maybe it'll be okay. And it was a leap of faith, but it was exactly the right leap of faith. Carolyn, you summarize it because people could be a Spartan because you could tell people are wondering, what's this all about? How come I'm in South St. Paul or doing things with South St. Paul? So it's that piece that's right behind us, community, and establishing that UCFE community, which does establish the foundation. And I think The other thing we saw today was I think when ECFE first started
036out here, it didn't necessarily mirror the population of the school district, but it sure does now. And that's because of the work that you all are doing to bring families in and to make sure that they're a part of it. I think the last time I was there, I was probably one of the only people that didn't speak English because of the class that was going on and the excitement that was happening in that classroom with parents and their kids. So sometimes I would say it's the jewel that a lot of people don't really know enough about. So thank you. Congratulations on the 50 years, and it's great to be in a state where it has ECFE. But even more so, our seven years of success, and look forward to more years of success. And
037Laura, we know where you're at, so if we need help, we can find you. Now you just have to have parent education for the parents of elementary teenagers. Sign me up. We do have an office. yes we should expand that was a huge i i wrote that down that how much i missed the ecfe um i we started when my oldest was 18 months old and met many many faces in this room and started because she didn't have any cousins that were her age there was no kids in the neighborhood and i did not in any way anticipate to get what i got out of it i was all looking at it for her and and and That's the reason I'm in the seat I'm in today. I kicked off my advisory council journey with
038ECFE and moved on to the PTA and here with the school board today. But it's just been phenomenal. I can't... I can't you guys all summed it up so well this the the staff are amazing and support I think I pushed my sister to get involved when she had kids and like you have to do this I don't you know you just need to do it it's it's it's great and Laura I didn't know that you were retiring congratulations and congratulations yes thank you and and please share with was Halima was that her name how heartfelt her message was that was just i mean she summed it up so very very well that that last couple sentences just it i think it got all of us so yes yes thank you yes thank you so
039much for coming and sharing and just so you know you don't have to stick around for the rest of the meeting unless you really want to you should All right. Do I have a motion and a second to approve the consent agenda item? So moved, Member Nyamioya. Seconded by Member Dukes. All right. Member Nyamioya and seconded by Member Dukes. Any discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? The motion is carried. Thank you to those who have donated to the school district this past month. Your generosity and support of our schools is very appreciated and it makes a difference for our students. All right, moving on to information items. Superintendent Dave- Let's go right to the truth in taxation. Oh, yeah, sorry. So 6 o'clock, is that okay? Yes. This is my first time doing this,
040sorry. Yeah, it's kind of one of those wonky nights. Yes, yes, thank you. Okay, the annual truth in taxation hearing information. is able to begin because it is past 6 p.m. Do I have a motion and a second to... No, sorry. This is all new. We don't have to do that. We'll just let her go. All right. Director of Business Services, Heather Ani, will present the annual Truth in Taxation. Thank you. The annual treatment taxation needs to by statute be held between November 25th and December 30th at 6pm or later and can be part of a regularly scheduled meeting like this one. And we allow for public comments and then can adopt the final levy at the same meeting. And it's a presentation of the current year budget and the proposed property tax levy. We'll
041give some background information on school funding, the district's budget, proposed tax levy, and then public comment. So the Minnesota legislator sets the funding for Minnesota public schools, and so they have to establish a uniform system of public schools by making such provisions through taxation or otherwise. And because of this, funding is highly regulated. Formulas which determine their revenue are based on specific amounts usually by pupil and tax policies for local schools. They also set maximum authorized property tax levy and authorize the school board to submit referendums for operating and capital needs to the voters for approval. Since 2022 or sorry, I knew I was going to mess that one up. 2002-2003 school year, general education revenue formula hasn't kept pace with inflation. So over those 22 years, if it had kept pace with inflation, it
042would be 18.7% more. to be 1364 more per pupil. And for ISD 199, that would be $4 million. So it's significant when it cannot keep pace with inflation. For 2023 24, we had an increase of 4%, which is 275 per pupil. And then for this school year, an increase of 2%, which is 143 per pupil. And according to the Minnesota Department of Education, the 2023 costs of providing programs that were underfunded statewide were 726 million underfunded. Our biggest underfunding is special education and the legislator has worked to increase that funding and still we'll see a an underfunding of 455 million statewide by fiscal year 2027 and districts to bridge that gap in in funding need to cut into regular program budgets or increase referendum revenue and most districts have done both this is our our
043new graph a voter approved referendum authority per pupil for fiscal year 2526 we're obviously the blue one on the graph and although we've passed referendum we still have a lower amount per pupil and we'll talk later about how that affects taxes per average home anything you wanted to say on this one i think this just depicts exactly what we shared with our community that we were lower but we still are didn't change our spot and that was very much we're doing and making sure we set it at the level that we knew it could pass but also wanted to make sure that we're being as effective and efficient as possible Right and for some reason the numbers aren't showing up here, but it's 1361 per pupil. The school districts budgets are divided into separate funds
044based on purpose of the revenue and restrictions and the funds that we have are general food service, community service, which is community education, debt service, internal service, and then other post employee benefit trust and debt service. I don't like putting a spreadsheet up there, but I do need to show this. This is the budget publication that needs to be posted in a local paper by November 30th of each year. So this was posted in the Pioneer Press, and it just shows last year's beginning fund balances, revenue, expenditures, and ending fund balances, and then the projections for 24-25 in our revenue and expenditures and what we would expect for an ending fund balance. So... of our 66 million dollar budget it is divided up into those funds so it's supposed to look different than it does
045right now it's supposed to look a little different there's a pie chart highlights that it's confusing right yeah because it turned into a pdf oh no it doesn't like that oh yeah next oh yeah that yellow square you're close And I can talk through it, but it's hard to visualize. It's building the anticipation. You want to go into the email? I can talk through it, and then we can come back to it and look at the graphs. So our overall revenue is just under $66 million. Of that, our general education funding is just over $55 million. It makes up 83.5% of our budget. Food service is at 2.8 million and makes up 4.3 percent. Community service is 2.1 million and makes up 3.2 percent. Debt service is 4.9 million makes up 7.4 percent. OPEB Trust
046and OPEB debt service are less than 8 percent. So then in the next slides we'll focus more on the general revenue. So for 24-25 our general revenue budget is just over 55 million. And 75.5% of that comes from the state, which is 41.6 million. Federal makes up 3.6% of our budget, which is 1.9 million. And local sources are 11.5 million and 20.9%. That's 20.9%, Heather. Sorry. Yep, 20.9% is local. And you don't, so just looking at it. And then by expenditure type, salaries and wages and benefits make up 75% of our budget, which is $41 million. Purchased services is $9.3 million and 16.9%. Supplies, $2.3 million, 4.2%. Capital expenditures, $2.1 million, which is 3.8%. She doesn't have PowerPoint. I got it. That's probably why I went over. I think Dave's going to pull it up.
047I sent him. Oh, there it is. There it is. There's a pie chart. So it's, yeah, if we go back, I'll just. This is the overall the 66 million that includes all of our funds. So obviously you can see why the general fund is makes up a big portion of it. It's nicer to look at that than just listen to me list off numbers. And then the next one, this is the state, federal, and local. And after that, this is what we spend our money on, the salaries and benefits being that 75% or 41 million. And then next. one that I haven't talked about yet. So by program the majority of our budget is spent on regular education 38.2 percent followed by special education at 19.1 percent. Instructional support services 9.1 percent. Public support or
048pupil support services 12.8 percent. Sites and buildings 11.6 percent and then administration 4 percent and district support services 3.7 percent. So tax levies are based on many state-determined formulas plus the voter-approved referendums. Some of the increases in tax levies are revenue-neutral for the school district because it's offset by a reduction in state aid. And then our expenditure budget is limited by state-set revenue formulas, voter-approved levies, and our fund balance. And so an increase in school taxes does not always correlate to an increase in budget. This year, because we have the referendum, there... There is an increase in district budget, but it may not correlate to that same percentage that taxpayers see in an increase. Oh, there. I was off on my slides. This is the tax amount for an average price home of $350,000 and
049what it would look like if compared to a $350,000 home in one of our neighboring districts. we are lucky to be on the low end of that and if you remember from the prior graph farmington was less than us they were the only one behind but um somebody with a 350 000 house in farmington would have to pay about 800 dollars more than a 350 000 house in invergo heights in our district boundaries and that's mainly attributable to the different diversity of properties and taxes so um commercial agriculture all of that So when you hear the conversation about equalization, this is exact, this fits into that category. Okay and then um see here a property owner received a tax statement or an estimate between November 10th and 25th. Every owner of taxable property has different
050taxing jurisdictions, county, city, township, school districts, special districts in which the property is located. And so this is an example of a home in our district. Tried to find one around $350,000 and it got kind of close. And you can see that it's broken up between the different taxing jurisdictions and has meeting information such as tonight's meeting and shows the prior year and the proposed levy. and what that difference is in a percentage at the bottom. And the county sends the bills, collects the taxes from property owners, and distributes the fund back to other taxing jurisdictions. And Dakota County Assessor's Office determines the property values. Each school district has limited authority to levy taxes, and MDE calculates levy amounts for various categories set by the state law and voter approval. So back on September 8th,
051MDE prepared and distributed the first draft of levy limit reporting, and that's something that they work on and improve, look for errors and adjustments over the next several months. So on September 23rd, the school board approved the maximum levy, and that just allows for fluctuation in those formulas, adjustments and errors, and adding a referendum. And then mid-November, the county mailed those proposed tax levy statements to property owners. Tonight we have the public hearing, and then following the hearing, the board can certify the final levy. The proposed payable 2025 tax levy is an increase of about $3.5 million, or 22%. It includes $2.2 million from the initial proposed levy approved by the school board in September and approved by voters on November 5th. And changes by levy category and reasons for major increases and decreases will
052go over in some of the following slides. Sorry, another spreadsheet. This just shows the general versus community ed and debt service and how those levies have increased. So you can see the... The main increases in that general fund and the very first line is the voter approved operating referendum and some of that is the new levy, but then there's also the inflation because it's factored to reflation on the prior levy that we had. So for the general fund, the voter approved operating referendum and equity, we had an increase of 2.5 million and a little bit of a decrease in that equity aid. That's one of those equalizations. this was based on the referendum and And the inflation like I said, sorry already talked about all this okay, and then the next one is fluctuations there's
053prior year adjustments, so just over 500,000 in In adjustments, the initial levies are based on enrollment estimates and we had an increase in enrollment in the fall of 2023. So we had under levied our residents inadvertently. then factors that impact taxpayer school taxes are the changes in individual property value the total value of all properties within the district and Then increases or decreases in levy amounts caused by changes in state funding formulas local needs and costs voter approved referendums and other factors and kind of simplified that there's the district's levy is a pie and the higher the market value the bigger slice of the pie lower market value smaller part of the pie so kind of a comparison the impact of property valuations so if the district had a 500 levy and two homes were
054valued at a hundred thousand they would each pay 250 of that levy But then if the if one of the homes was a hundred and ten thousand and the other was a hundred and twenty five thousand the district still would receive the five hundred dollars in the levy but a hundred and ten thousand dollar home would be paying less and the 125,000 dollar portion would be paying more so that's what we mean when it's it's not just the value of your home But the value of all of the homes within the district boundaries and then we're going to show some examples of School district taxes with both a no change in value and a 17% increase in property value for residential homes over the past four years And that shows the actual change or the
055actual change of value could be more unless this is just a an estimate and these were prepared for us by Ehlers, which is our financial advisor, so the first one this is if values did not change and It's really not fun to look at this one either, but changes in taxes from 2022 to 2025, if we just look at that first one of $200,000, over that four years it was $73, but taxes changing from 2024 to 2025 were $123. So a little bit of a reduction in prior years if you were looking at just a $200,000 house without any changes in value. So if we show on the graphs, there's just a visual of that with the $200,000 on the left-hand side. and showing the impact of $100 of the additional referendum. So they have
056a $722 referendum. And then the $350,000 property on the right side has a $175 referendum. And you can see how it dips and then increases in this year. Again, this is no changes, but million-dollar property in commercial and apartment, you'll see the same fluctuations, and they have an increase of about $501. Now if we look at a change in property value at 70 17 percent cumulative changes over those four years You see how it raises slightly over the years. It's still showing that hundred dollar increase in the current year At seven hundred and forty one for a two hundred thousand dollar house, but that house would have been about 170,000 a few years ago. So Just gives a little bit more realistic Example of what how it increases Alright, our next steps would be for
057the board to accept public comments and to certify the property tax levy. Do we have any comments? We don't have any comments. Did the board have any comments? No. Thanks for the pictures. Sorry about fumbling. No, the pictures help me in my brain, so thank you. I agree. I agree. I just watched 2023 for fun a couple days ago. I love these presentations. I think it's so helpful for our citizens to understand and for us honestly to understand too. I think you explained this school funding is so complicated and I did a deep dive into some of these issues this weekend with the MSBA but I it's just nice to have a nice basis from you so. I think that's a great point to remember that there are aspects of this that we have to
058remember as we have questions throughout the course of the next year from people to help explain it to them. So it's one of those things that you may want to make sure you know where it's at so if you get asked you can access it because it really does provide a lot of foundational things and there's things that we do very often where we go back and have to pull it from this presentation as well. Thank you for all of your work on that. I think that we can get back to our regular agenda now. We'll get to you when that time comes. All right. Returning to information items, Superintendent Bernardson will introduce several district policies for our first reading. Thank you. Yes, the policy committee reviewed the policies that you see in front of
059you in November. These policies had no changes, minimal changes, limited changes, and one had an actual total revision. And they'll be brought back for a second reading at our next regular meeting on the 27th. So we have no changes to 209, Code of Ethics, 212, School Board Member Development, minimal changes to 210, Conflict of Interest for School Board Members. 211 criminal or civil action against school district school board member employee or student and 214 out of state travel by school board members and we did have limited changes to 213 school board committees and then a total revision of 522 which is title 9 sex non-discrimination policy grievance procedures and process and that's a total revision because it's a new policy that suggested based on MSBA making those total revisions and we kept it as is
060so it is a total revision and again these policies will be brought back to you again on the 27th of January and we'll take questions tonight or if you have any questions before the 27th feel free to let me Tracy or policy committee know thank you any discussion All right, moving on. Superintendent Bernardson will share a discussion on the 2025 legislative priorities. Thank you. Yes, we are in the process of developing our school district legislative priorities. As I also shared with the board, we're working with other Dakota County districts to look at arriving at common priorities because we do share those with our legislators in a joint venture. I'm not gonna go through them all with you this evening because we did go through them at a work session, but we really focus on the
061financial aspect, the opportunity aspect, and the safety aspect. And then also we wanna make sure we're looking at that aspect of local district control and those unfunded mandates. As you know, we've talked after the last legislative session about those unfunded mandates. So some of the things you heard from Heather this evening are in the financial piece, which would be cross subsidies, comp ed, our local optional revenue, We do have that capital projects levy that we would like to see the board have the opportunity to review on their own, just like we do with a levy one time. And unemployment insurance, paid leave programs, basic formula and redact are all financial aspects. When it gets into opportunity, there's some negotiation around a number of things with e-learning staff ratios. We'd really like that opportunity to develop
062our own calendar. That's something we're working on right now, which is the 26-27 calendar as an example. And then that falls in next year as well, where Labor Day, falls late in September so we'd like to have that opportunity to start school a week earlier and then we also have a piece which we'd like to reduce the special education paperwork It's something that we've had on our legislative priorities for a number of years, but it was something we wanna make sure we keep alive. And then a piece about data requests. As we've talked about data requests can become a very cumbersome and expensive opportunity, I should say aspect for a school district. So we'd like to see language improved around that and then increasing our school safe levy and our long-term facility maintenance aspect as
063well. So those are the things we brought forward. I know Liz, you also attended. msba and shared with me today that these are very much in line with what they have shared they're very much in line with the msc i don't know if you have anything you want to share about msba tonight or um i i think i i think we're right on pace with a lot of folks in the state about what what people need to help fund their schools right um um we we need a little more time to figure out compensatory funding for example too um that's a that's a really big issue um There's there's just a lot of a lot of ways that this fits in perfectly with what I think the legislature needs to hear that mandates can That
064without funding are really it's really burdensome and then too much top too much control from the legislature to try and dictate what every district does Is really tough so because we know what's best for our kids. Mm-hmm. So I think that was a pretty universal theme. Mm-hmm And thank you for sharing that because I think it's important too for those that are listening that we do work with AMSD, the Association of Metropolitan School Districts and the Minnesota School Board Association, which is MSBA. And they are very active at the Capitol with legislators. But then we also provide our local with more in-depth information to our two state representatives and to, I should say, one state senator. And they are very responsive to our needs and very much in touch with us as these things come
065about during a legislative session. important for people to know that I know I had a couple questions during our levy campaign about are you out there advocating it's like absolutely absolutely so any other thank you yeah any other discussion thank you we will move on to committee reports and the finance and personnel committees have not met this month Liz, will you please share an update on facilities? Sure. The facilities committee met on December 2nd and our agenda included updates on completed work in 2024, works in progress and upcoming projects in 2025. And Shana, will you please give an update on the policy committee? Yes. The policy committee met prior to tonight's meeting. The agenda included a review of several policies from the current cycle and review of the MSBA suggested model policy updates. Thank you.
066Moving along to membership reports, Dave, will you please give an update on AMSD? Yeah, as mentioned, AMSD met on December 6th and their agenda included regular routine business, but also the approval of their legislative platform for this upcoming session. And then also took a look at their website. And if you ever look for information legislatively, that's a great place to go because they've got some really easy touches there to find out where things are at and where they're potentially going as well. Thank you. Shana, will you please give an update on the IGH Best Foundation? Yes, the Best Foundation is not met yet this month. Thank you. And Dave, MSBA update? Yeah, Liz gave a update over the course of what took place this weekend and just want to remind people that if you're looking
067to go through to the Leadership Conference, that registration closes on January 6th. So if you're interested in going, please contact Tracy. Yeah, just that Thursday of that leadership conference There will be a vote on the bylaws of MSBA that would change the formula a little bit for delegates to help create the legislative platform for the MSBA and our District with is part of district 7 for the MSBA. It's essentially Dakota County get two more delegates under this new formula And I think it's really worth voting because I do think we are in a line in a lot of ways but sometimes it is you want your your kids to get what they can get so I would suggest if you can go or at least go Thursday that would be the day to go it's
068a great point because they've been working harder to get more of a balanced representation rather than just who shows up yes sure the easiest way to put it probably right and Dave is give an update on intermediate school district 917 that'll be short they did not mean Moving along to our action items. Welcome back director of business services Heather on e to introduce the certification of the 2024 payable 2025 property tax levy. Thank you. So everything that we just went over with the property tax levy I won't go over completely again, but It amounts to $19,299,763.89, very exact. And tonight I would like to ask for the board's approval to certify the property tax levy. Do I have a motion and a second to approve the certification of the 2024 payable 2025 property tax levy?
069Motion by Member Pearson. Second by Member. Right by member Pearson second by member Clinger any discussion? All right all those in favor aye opposed Motion is carried Thank you, thank you Superintendent Bernardson will introduce the recommendation to approve several policies for the second reading Thank you, Carrie. Yes, the policy committee reviewed these policies in October, and they had minimal changes, limited changes, and one had a total revision, and then we brought them to you for their first reading at our November meeting. So we have minimal changes to 208, development, adoption, and implementation of policies. 505, distribution of non-school sponsored materials on school premises by students and employees. 509, enrollment of non-resident students. 510 school activities. Limited changes were to 202.2 replacement of district 917 board representative and 205 open and closed meetings. Then we had
070a total revision and this total revision was due to moving aspects into an appendix and that was to policy 613 graduation requirements. And that movement to appendix was to make it so that policy wouldn't have to come back every time there were some things that were natural things that took place. would take place with things related to this policy and again these policies had their first reading on november 18th and we are bringing them to the board as an action item and hoping for the approval this evening thank you do i have a motion and a second to approve the policies presented for a second reading review motion member yamio second member lounsbury any discussion all those in favor aye opposed the motion is carried We will move on to our comments. We'll begin with
071you, Superintendent Bernson. Well, I think that we already had a lot of our comments in our district highlight with our UCFE share with their 50 years and their seven years and Laura's leadership. So I want to really thank those that are involved in UCFE and actually all of our early childhood programs in our district because they really create that foundation for our kids. uh and again as i mentioned earlier there's sometimes one of the things that people forget about and it's one of the most solid foundational things that we do for our kids and it's also that aspect of where we share that we're here to serve people our kids or whoever from birth forever as long as they want to be served because we have program for them today was a flex day for
072us so what that means is there's a flex day for a 6 through 12 students so there's professional development and i also remind people that it's the opportunity for our elementary teachers and others that are getting REDACT training and want to thank them for the work they're doing in learning about REDACT and getting themselves ready for all the aspects that come after that. Also, we've got winter break coming up on December 23rd and school resumes on January 2nd. And as a reminder, we do have a special meeting on January 13th before our work session because that's where we get organized for the next school year. So it's amazing how time is flying by. amazing yes it is i want to thank everybody for again the share by ecfe tonight it's wonderful to hear the one
073the great things that are happening and continue to happen day by day in ecfe and in early learning thank you uh now we will have school board comments board member cleaner other than echoing sentiments on ecfe which we also participated in and are still friends with families we met through that i don't have any comments board member name um yeah i think i already said what i wanted to say about ecfe um i can't love it more um and i then the only other thing to just keep adding on to what dave mentioned earlier uh the work is not done for anyone in the community listening that thinking we just hey we passed the levy and we're we're good see ya um i know this entire board every staff um whatever we can do at
074the legislative level to make change and and cause create efficiency um and and help our district get fully funded and functioning that's what we're going to keep doing so that's it thank you remember dukes Yeah, same thing about early learning. It was just so nice. One thing that came to my mind was just the trust that we have in the district in general. You know, families have trust in their teachers and people who are part of their programs. We have trust in each other. And I think it's important as you, you know, come across things that may make you feel a little about things to seek out to those people that you know you can trust in our space and trust that they're going to get you an answer that is, you know, honest and
075and up front right even even if sometimes not what we want to hear because i'm one of those people too or if it's not what i want to hear like actually i didn't get anything you know um so just just think about trust when you're when you're navigating these spaces because that's the through line of community that's the through line of making commitments it's good trust so that's it for me thank you uh board member larson I think I also said my piece about my fabulous experience in ECFE. It was just such a great baseline getting into, we knew the school, we knew so much more about the district. We got to meet the superintendent, you know, before we were ready to come into elementary school. And just a really quick story, my favorite, when
076my oldest was in, no, she was in four-year-old preschool at Hilltop. And she's like, we got to go to the picnic area today. I'm like, the picnic area? What are you? I had no idea what she was talking about. She's like, yeah, I'm like, oh, the lunchroom. So they took the preschoolers out to go tour the building. And she didn't know the lunchroom, but it was the picnic area. But it was just such great for her. I mean, that's a little fast forward from ECFE, but we did ECFE in preschool. But she got to be in that building, in that space from the time she was a couple years old until she moved on after fifth grade. So it was just a. That's a great, great way to start. Board Member Pearson. Kudos to Heather
077for this incredible presentation and the work that goes into it. I know that it's something that's required that we do, but you do such a nice and detailed job of also helping folks understand it. We don't look at stuff like that. So thank you for all your work and preparation in that. a kudos and a thank you to pine bend principal richardson the staff there on how they have handled the two day in a row power outage i have a child at pine bend and so in our neighborhood including the school there was two days in a row that they were without power for about 20 minutes each time of course my house was without power for several hours but i have to tell you i have never received so many updates via call, text,
078email. Like, they don't have power, but they're sending out updates telling us our kids are okay and how long it's going to last and sending a cute picture of how the band still had band practice with these boom lights. And I just thought, like, wow, the communication was stellar. If you could pass that on to Xcel Energy, if they could communicate that way, that would be great. But it was wonderful. I didn't share this when ECFE was here and I'll email this to each of them directly because we had a little bit of a non-traditional experience with ECFE. I am fortunate enough that my kids go to my parents for childcare, which sounds great and it is great until your child is approaching school age years and you realize, oh, we have not socialized him.
079And I'm at work all day. And so the grandparents were actually the ones that took him to ECFE. And I have to say that it was such an inclusive environment for grandparents to be there, still part of that little parent group. And I will tell you, year after year, I would be at Target or I would be at a park and some random stranger would know my child, would know my toddler. And she's, I'm like, how do you know? Why are you using my child's name? This is uncomfortable. She's, oh, I had him in ECFE and I know your mom. And the staff there are so inclusive and know people by name and know kids by name. Even years later, I've still been astounded by people that know him, but not me because of that
080experience. And so thank you to them for that. I will be at the MSBA conference in January. I watch for that vote on Thursday and look forward to what I can bring back. So thank you. I just want to thank Aleema for sharing your story and your willingness to I mean, I understand that it can be awkward trying to speak in another language. The only other language I know partially is Spanish. But we understood you very clearly. So thank you so much for your willingness to share and, and for your willingness to step out and meet other parents. I think that can be the thing that is challenging and you know when you're in when you're in the throes of the early years you're so exhausted and then at the end of the day you
081don't quite know what you accomplished and so I think it is it is a gift to be able to meet with other other parents who are in similar situations and so much brain development happens in those early years so for those parents who are participating Thank you for investing in your child's development in that way. Let's see. The note of that it was the 2002-2003 school year that funding stopped keeping up with inflation. And my first year of teaching was the 2001-2002 school year. And I did not... you know in our in our education um classes at in college they didn't talk or i don't recall learning much about school funding um and so that following year uh one of the seasoned teachers in our building was talking about it and um you know something
082like an iou to education and how they balance the budget or whatnot and And I, you know, my naive 22-year-old's like, oh, well, when is that going to pick up? She goes, oh, honey, it is not. And that's sobering. So thank you, Board Member Nehemiah, for your passion for this and for continuing to encourage the rest of us to act. And we will we care about this community and I also want to give another plug for the listening session. Thank you to those who came tonight to share and we are listening and we would love to welcome more more people to come and share and share concerns share Joyce, something that you appreciate. I think so often, and whether you want to take the time to come in to speak on something you appreciate, but
083even an email of something that you really enjoyed is also great to hear at times. But we want to listen. And so with that, I want to say happy holidays and a couple more weeks before the children are home. teachers can have some holiday time. Yes. All right. There will be a special meeting on Monday, January 13th, followed by a work session. And the next regular board meeting will be held on Monday, January 27th. Do I have a motion and a second to adjourn tonight's meeting? So moved, Member Mimioya. Second, Member Larson. All right. All those in favor? Aye. The motion is carried at 6.48 p.m.