CorpusRecord 125306

Byron School Board Meeting (12/16/24)

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Byron Bears
Date
2024-12-17
Location
Olmsted County, MN
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,900 words · about 50 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001here mat here Wayne here David here all if I could have everybody stand for the Pledge of Allegiance please pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands Nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank Environ Public Schools a community of Learners committed to make the world a better place mission is to learn share innovate and Inspire priorities are one personalized learning in the pursuit of academic Excellence two Inspire students and staff to develop their character sh their talents and apply their learning and three maintain excellence and Resource Management any changes to the agenda motion to approve the agenda as presented motion was the ma and seconded to approve the agenda all in favor say I I all oppose same sign agenda is

002approved unanimously next we have the truth and Taxation FIS year 25 revised budget and final 25 2025 payable L good evening um I'm here tonight to go um to review your truth and Taxation um this is required by law to have this and then a board will need to approve a final Levy tonight um we do need to talk about these things on the agenda the levy cycle basic school funding um many factors contributing to the change in the levy the levy certification itself graphical analysis and the revised budget I'm in the levy process um we saw this in September when it presented the preliminary Levy but for anybody who hasn't seen this we certify the levy now um it's collected in um the calendar year of 25 and the school district um uses the

003These funds for the FY 26 school year so even though they're collected throughout the whole calendar year 25 um the money is used for the 25 26 school year um so School tax levy must be either set by state formula so the legislature decides or to voter approved um some factors that um we can switch to the next slide some factors impacting a tax change are any anything that's driven by the state level so legislators determine any changes in the levy um for the state formula um changes in sales R um ratios impacting our adjusted tax capacity and that just means maybe they'll change a property from being residential to Commercial and that would change your impact um to your lby um to the whole as a whole and any laws mandating mandating Code Compliance

004and then those issues determined by District voters so if there's a bond referendum a levy or Tech Levy which is also called the capital projects Levy or any voter approved excess Levy referendum so a bond is for buildings Levy is for additional Revenue um for the district and then capital projects is normally a tech Levy so those are all voter approved things um that have to go to the voters otherwise the district cannot um lovey for those and then any local factors um that do affect and we'll see later on in some of the graphs how much your district has changed over the years um some inflationary pressures on real estate market any abatements property improvements not previously taxed will adjust your Levy changes in assess market value or classifications so what is included in

005the school district lby all of those things we just talked about the voter approv referendums the only thing that this district has at this point time are bonds for the buildings there is not a referendum an operating referendum nor is there a tech Levy in this District um those levies are set by state formula the equity and when I talk about Equity that doesn't mean Dei um it means Equity between school districts to make sure funding is the same between school districts operating Capital there's some transition Revenue that we get because of old laws and so we get some money very small amount of money for that community service and long-term facility maintenance and then those are other levies authorized B by the state based on our local needs so re-employment um save schools Revenue

006achievement integration curent Tech fac any facility leases that we have integration and cuom of which this District does not have C count either so some factors contributing to the levy change and it really affects your property owners um their an adjusted net tax capacity was an 11.4% increase from 22 to 23 uh the referendum market value same it went up 12.2% and we did have a reduction in pupil units so 11 students less so we Levy less so when you see a reduction we Levy less and we actually receive less Revenue so just to so that you understand that so that will be for the FY 26 year when we're talking about that I'm um the adjusted net task Capacity Analysis um I found this very interesting because if you look at it's really over

00710 or 11 years you've more than doubled your adjusted NE tax capacity so that means the property values in this for the school district have more than doubled over 10 years and that's that's quite a bit um so um definitely people are not seeing big increases in their especially like we have a 6% the district will approve tonight A 6% increase in um in your Levy but when you spread when there's been an increase of over 12% most people are going to see a decrease in their School portion of the levy unless they have big increases in their personal property value does that make sense so valuations are going up way over what you're seeing as the district increase in in the levy and the same thing works for the referendum market value um we've

008increased it and it's increasing the same doubling over the years our enrollment Trends um you can see you've been growing um until these last this last year um we were actually down six students and um when we're budgeting for the the current year we're down 11 from previous year so um when you're down students you lose Revenue both state aid and Levy because those factors are based on formulas those formulas are usually based on student population so you're losing Revenue when you're declining in enroll this is very detailed Levy um information um I presented this at the preliminary um you can you can see that you don't aren't showing any operating referendum or adjustments because you don't have one um you can see there's some money there in equity none of this has really changed

009um since the preliminary Levy so I'm not going to go through all of it unless you really request me to the one thing that has changed at the very bottom the prior year adjustments that was negative at the prary levy and now it is a positive so between now and then the state made adjustments and when they reviewing things and so they actually are showing a positive adjustment for prior year and that's usually prior year that you can't get it exactly perfect when you're leving it's based on student enrollment and we don't know what that student enrollment will be for FY 26 yet and so you're always estimating so those prior adjustments are just based on that enrollment difference over those prior years and same with Community ad and dead service those really haven't changed

010since the preliminary Levy um and so there there's very little change in those areas as well you can see your biggest part of your um Debt Service is your really your biggest piece of that voter approved all of this in The Debt Service would be border approved Levy Choice and then your Levy um summary it's just the summary of The General community service and Debt Service you can see those increases from prior year in the general fund last year it was 2.9 Million you're at 3 almost 3.2 million this year um community service went up a little bit $30,000 debt Services um up up a couple hundred, so overall you went from 8.68 7 million to 9.21 five million so it's a 6.07% increase over the prior year and again most people will not see

011increase in their School portion they may see an increase based on other leving um organizations but it won't be most likely been the school um if you go to the levy history you can see where you had voter approved items um when you voted for the bond referendums those were big increases those years but the other years they were mainly in that less than 5% or around 5% um the budget process proc we also are in this December January where we're talking about the truth and Taxation at the bottom of the screen there um midye budget adjustments so you're going to see a budget adjustment tonight a revised general fund budget only um we're going to bring that to the board so we have something really good and solid to move forward in this district

012with um for the future this should look somewhat familiar to you um um this is what was you approved in the gold the FY 25 adopted budget that's what you approved in June um and so what I'm showing you in the red is the revised um it's based on the same pupil units um and the beginning fund balance is the actual fund balance from what you're going to hear later on tonight from the audit so we're taking those actuals and we're putting them in there for um 20 um fy2 for and you're going to see um those are the real numbers when we go through that audit so you can see that we have a very small fund balance um we actually after revising the budget and making all the changes we're pretty much at

013a Balan budget um it's really caused by um one major error in the expenditure budget and so once she took that out and made some adjustments to the revenue and corrected those a um you're actually having pretty close to a balance budget you're negative $54,000 for next year for the current year I said next year but sorry it's for this current year um so um we've been I've went through every line item of your budget and I revised you didn't have an original budget you approved one but there was nothing in um the Smart Systems no one ever entered anything in so I had nothing to go by to decide what those were so I actually had to start from Ground Zero I recreated an original budget so that went into your tried to recreate

014that the best I could at the same time I recreated your revised budget or created one and so that's what you're seeing tonight is what I've done through all the work for the last couple months going through every line item on your budget um we've been monitoring it we know exactly where we're with that budget Dr net can look at the budget now and say we're this much percent through the year and this is what we' spent to each to these categories you can go down the line and you can see all of those it's pretty easy to follow at this point and so um I don't know what more to say about that we're pretty much a balanced budget it will be helpful going forward for the district um knowing they don't have to

015make additional budget cuts over the 1.6 million you're just you're still only at less than 1% fund balance predicted at the end of this year um one of the things that I do when I am predicting a budget is I'm pretty conservative in your revenues so um if we think we're going to get enroll you know fees and student fees of $300,000 we may only be budget in 280 because we don't know if our basketball teams are as good as they used to be or our football teams are as good as they used to be and all of that depends so pretty conservative in our Revenue budgets um and when it comes to our expense budget we put everything in there that we know we could possibly expend so we're should be the opposite you

016know so hopefully we'll come in under revenue and or we'll come in over revenues and under expens so actually it could come out better than what I'm predicting but you have the max in there for both um if you look at the revenue by Source in the graphical you can see I put the numbers out there the levy the local Revenue State AIDS and grants special ed and I separated special ed out of your state AIDS and grants because it's a big driver um sometimes in what we're re in funding that is a piece that we are receiving additional Revenue over what your adopted budget was you're seeing additional Revenue in special ed because there's something called Adis um and so that's part of special ed it helps to keep we have a program that

017helps keep students out of our special ed program so it's an intervention program we actually hurt us in FY 24 because we had the expense but we wouldn't get the revenue for this year until this year and so that Revenue was never accounted for in this year's budget in the adopted budget so I accounted for that Revenue in here the other piece that wasn't in here was we received another $100,000 in um Title One funding that you didn't know about and no one would have known about um as part of the adopted budget so that is in here as well and then there were a few other pieces of the budget knew that were in years so I added those um if you look at the revised budget this is by we call it program

018series but you can see it's by District administration Support Services regular instruction special ed instruction and you can see our regular instruction is 52% of the budget special ed is 15% and other pieces but those are your majority of your um budget is the regular instruction and special ed and then all the other smaller pieces of the budget um I did a comparison of the program series the same thing as the previous slide but for the last three years and so that orange line in the middle is the big increases that you saw in every category for last year so those really big increases and then you can see the um the FY 25 budget is the blue and so you can see it coming down because of the reductions that you made last year

019for this year's budget so all of those numbers are out there as well the actuals and then what we predicted for the budget this year um this does looks at it a little bit differently but the number total number is the same um this looks at it by wages and salaries benefits purchase Services supplies and materials um we added The Debt Service in here for the borrowing of the money for um cash flow purposes so that expense that 8,000 is out here where you didn't have anything before so you can see where those and the majority is wages and benefits um for all of the staff we're a service organization and when you're a service organization it's people that drive your expenses and then I did the same thing here a three-year comparison by object

020series and you can again see the Orange is last year's actual expenses and you can see the blue is 25 budget and then where you were iny 23 actual and all the numbers out there you can see the growth um in those areas right year and then this kind of goes back to the same slide that I had before you can see what that is again any questions I went through that very quickly but I wanted you to see it um if you want detail it's out there now it's all available for you it's been um and interesting to go through a whole budget like that and recreate it and try to um and do a revised budget at the same time but hopefully we've caught most of the airs and issues in there and

021I feel pretty confident about this budget we appreciate your time this definitely was that easy any questions from the board thank you okay all right uh I didn't have any public comment cards were there any that I missed asking the audience no okay no public comments moving on reports AIT presentation yes so we have Andrew Fetti here from Smith schaer and Andrew you at that table there sure and uh we won't make you stand through your old presentation so you have a seat there all right thanks for having me tonight I'm Andrew M schaer and we are contractor for audit or buing school district for the year end of June 30th 2024 uh I did also hand out the actual audited financial statement to the board members but tonight we will look at this PowerPoint

022um everything in that audited financial statement gets taken out and put into the PowerPoint so if there's any questions on Where the numbers come from we can jump back into audit uh to see where we are at with that so I'm slide there we start with our audit summary our audit opinion is a clean unmodified opinion which means we believe everything is really stay in accordance with gap is the highest level of assurance you can receive on a financial statement uh we did sit down with management and some of the accounting staff on November 26th and went through the financial statement more line by line detail uh tonight we took kind of the highlights out of those and put them into this PowerPoint for you guys um our audit opinion provid reasonable not absolute assurance

023that the financials are free from interium the statement is not absolute assurance as we do not look at every single transaction that occurred throughout the year we take a risk-based approach and make selections based off those perceived risk um also included in that audit uh we have to provide a letter on the Minnesota legal compliance uh we had one compliance finding related to insufficient ceral for coverages um so when you have funds out the banks they need to have pledged collaterals in excess of FDIC Insurance limits of that 250 and then 110,000 on% 110% on top of that um so the One Bank uh did not have sufficient collateral I believe there is a resolution working on with the bank to get that rectified um so you will have adequate clal going forward um there's

024also included in our audit is the letter on internal control uh we had four findings related to internal controls the first one there was improper controls over cash dispersements um during our testing of dispersements we did hit some um federal dollars for um that means you have to follow the compliance Matrix and there's various testing um we found some were feder dollars were not for allowable purposes or had proper documentation in total they were about less than $4,000 so not a big amount uh for those federal dollars that we did find in our testing related to that uh the second finding there is the segregation of theing Duties which is very common in most uh smaller most districts just making sure you can the different functions of the cash uh custody of the cash and

025the according of the responsibilities um the third one there is another very common uh finding that we have in our financial statements it's the oversight of the financial reporting process um so the cing standards actually require that the school district or the Rd prepares their own financial statement with all required disclosures um you guys relied on us prare that financial statement for you so it is a very common finding that we do have and then some material audit ad as we did help close some of the audit books uh making journal entries into your accounting system for you um and then the Student Activity compliance there was one finding related to assigned statement of purpose so every activity that has activity needs to have assigned statement of purpose so you had them for all except

026for one um which is a common as well and then the audit committee letter I did hand out to you as well just say there are some use of estim such as appreciation uh pension liability special liab General edit some those fin after a right next we look at your average daily membership um just as you guys got to hear about how much of that deres your revenues I'm not going to spend too much time on that but your total adjusted average daily membership was 2,328 or up 36 students from FY 23 to 24 or 1 and a half% over the seven years presented here year over 700 students years next we look at your revenues across all the funds so total revenues there about 38,1 100,000 that's up about 2.5 million or a little

027over 7% of revenues broken out into the four main categories there the first grouping there is your property taxes uh property taxes was up about 400,000 in total revenues collected the largest portion of your funding as mentioned earlier comes from State AIDS um over 25 million comes in through State AIDS that's up about 3.2 million from the prior year the largest increase there is due to your additional student numbers of and the formula increase so increase in general education due to the uh average daily membership was about 800,000 your special education was up about 500 excuse me J is up about 800,000 special that up 500,000 um and then The Debt Service also get some Aid credits related to that um so that Debt Service Aid credit and other sources coming for The Debt Service

028credits was up about 600,000 and then the other large change in the f in the state Source was a Food Service as everybody provided free meal so that brought in about uh for if you are a part of that program we brought in about about 700,000 in additional State sources of revenue third group in there is your state a or federal AIDS 691 th000 so you are below that 750,000 so there was no single audit required in the current year and then the far right grouping uh about 3.6 million brought in in the other category most of that is to be down about 800,000 from the prior year as those food sales um they were now free meals so food sales were down about 200,000 and then uh prior year had larger balances in cash

029due to the bond proceeds for the building project so investment income was down about 500,000 um as we continue go on there a different way of looking at how the school was funded uh the 2024 school year on the left about 68% of your total revenue coming in is from the state sources property tax is about 21% are Prett consistent between the 24 and 23 school year slide six then we get into your property tax levy history um so that's the second from the right is the one that funded the 24 school year the one on the far right is funding the current FY 25 school year um so we do see that increase in the bottom which is going to be your general operating uh that comes into the general fund so we saw

030the increase of revenues about 400,000 coming in into the general fund a little increase in your orange in the community service and then the fy2 um is a slight decrease of this funding for the current year that will bring us into the expenditures uh just for the general fund going across there um the different categories that you guys looked at um are yeary year trop tax station there U we have a few more years presented here um you can see the largest uh expenditure or cost for the school is in the third group in there which is your regular instruction that is the amount that goes into funding uh the teachers and educating your students so that increase was about 1.7 million uh in the current year um most of that increase was related to

031salaries was up about 620,000 health insurance was another large increase in the current year that was up about 385,000 just in the regular instruction category um we did see a little bit higher in instruction of the rctc tuition so that was up about 120,000 was an additional expenditure for the school district um and then some additional athletic fees uh for services is up about 120,000 uh the fifth grouping there is your special ed which was another large increase for the current year that was up about 95,000 again that was related to salaries being up about 520,000 and benefits up 190,000 um so the total expend in the general fund going across there was 29,6 195,000 up to 3.7 million from the prior year about 14% um of that increase um a little over 2.7 million

032related to salaries and benefits where your largest portion of your budget did come over um so the budget was about 27 million spent about 2.2 million over budget and again as mentioned majority of that was based on the salaries and benefits of being over budget in those categories we just look at the general fund uh the blue is going to be the revenues the yellow is the expenditures um so total revenues are up about 1.8 million in the current year as I mentioned general education Aid up about 800,000 so compensatory aid about 120,000 special ed up 500,000 and then 400,000 in additional ta is coming in their expenditures are up about 3.7 million about 1.5 million for salaries 1.1 million for benefits uh there was the bus uh lease purchase in there for a little

033over 100,000 as well um other increases for payments to other districts uh including rctc came to other uh agencies was up about 380,000 as we did see some higher costs related to that um and then on the far right is going to be your change in fund balance in the green deficit in the current year well 1,750,000 so we did use that fund balance so if we look at the next slide we look at where our fund balances are the blue is going to be the unassigned amount so that's the amounts that are available without restrictions that the district can spend um that did go to a deficit of about 22,000 in the current year down a little over two 2 milon 50,000 in the current year the yellow is going to be your restricted

034fund balances that we have on the next slide so we'll talk in the second assigned fund balances are going to be for Student Activities and then some nonspendable funds on the far right in the green so one metric that is determined to use the health of a district is if you take your unassigned fund balance and divided by your current year expenditures b a percentage of how much of your reserves are on hand you're at a negative 8% in the current year your policy right around that 8% so you're about 7.8% in the F 23 right at 8% in so we did see that in the current slide 10 then is your restricted fund balances um so the largest one there is going to be on the far right which is your ltfm so that

035is in a deficit as some of those funds were spent and you're slowly getting repaid back on that it's at a deficit of Just Around 900,000 in your ltfm scholarships has a little over 200,000 set aside um some other in those other categories Food Service on slide 11 um so we see all the increase in the blue in your revenues up about 450,000 most of that is due to the state sources being up 700,000 and then the decrease in the regular food sales expenditures were up 211,000 additional meal serve so they did operate excess of about 92,000 so your food service is in good shape and they have a fund balance on the of about 270 positioning F service fund community service and then on the next slide there on slide 13 you have your

036revenues in the blue we're up about 180,000 up about 7,000 from Project kids and some tuition charges up 880,000 expenditures were up 300,000 200,000 of it salary salaries and 70,000 of those benefits so that's the majority of increase in your expenditures there um and then had still operated at an excess or positive fund balance added about 30,000 to their fund balance on the next slide you can look at your community service fund balance the blue is going to be the regular community service fund balance of about $8,000 the yellow is going to be made up of three different categories School Readiness which is a deficit of about 73,000 Community Education has about 83,000 and then the ecfd has about 195,000 Debt Service fund balance on the next slide uh total set aside for Debt Service

037of a m 108,000 to pay for future principal interest payments on your bonds that standing in the current year the district did refund one of the bonds um and it didn't have a actual future cash savings about 750,000 with a present value Savings of 662 th000 so that did save the district money with 3 that interest the fiveyear debt service requirements uh the principal in the blue interest in the green so just around that 600,000 uh the next kind of five years that jumps up in 2026 a little of bit stays pretty consistent right around that 600,000 for the next five years the sorry 6 million I say 600 sorry 6 million uh sorry and the next slide then SL slide 17 is your average daily membership we look at this again because these next

038slides are going to be 2,328 and divide them by the different expenditure categories to get a per ADM cost for funding the different areas or various functions of the school district so the first comparison that we're going to look at is the district and School administration and support services um so spend a little over $1,100 per ADM on the district and School administration uh districts and the color there is going to be district with 2,000 or 4,000 students and then the state average on the far right in the yellow uh those are both comparison to the 2023 those are the latest available information uh to us so you are right at districts of the similar size uh slightly under P of those categories there so the district does a good job in allocating those cost

039and then on the next slide you your regular instructions so you spend about 62 63 $ per ADM again you're right at the districts of similar size within $2 of that spending amount and then below the state average one last comparison there is a general fund cost per ADM um spend a little over $12,750 per ADM uh under the districts of similar size of the 14,000 and under the state average of 15, 636 um so then we have a brief summary here at the end so the general fund expenditures exceeded revenues and other financing sources by a m753 th000 decreas in the total general fund balance to 124,000 the far as general fund unassigned fund balance is a deficit of about 22,000 or 8% of the current year expenditures um and then the signed fund

040balance set aside for S activities about 27 years the Food Service revenues exceeded expenditures 2,000 increas in the Food Service fund balance to 270,000 and then the community service fund revenues exceed expenses by about 30,000 and they have 23,000 set aside and then the building construction fund expenditures exed the revenues of about 17 million as spending down the bond proceeds and completing the construction project spending down the bond that issued in 202 a lot of numbers questions am I interpreting this correctly on slide 20 that we're spending approximately 2,000 less per people than school districts that are our approximate size that 12756 versus 14631 yes $22,000 less okay any other questions from board thank you sir up next we have a superintendent report yes so um it is December first of all I want to

041congratulate all the many Great Performances that our students have had November and December it's performance season so our actors our musicians all the great concerts that we've had Middle School level high school level band Player uh plays it's it's been awesome I'll be able to see them in in some of them are new facilities and uh and they sounded great so thank you very much to those and it's a it's great for not only for our students but also for our community to be a part of that also thank you to students and staff uh in the buzz the last few weeks I've been pointing out all the different things that our our kids are doing in collecting toys collecting food doing all the things just um understanding their real um effect in the community

042and and the things that they can do sometimes they they only understand their world and they only see their world so it's great that they can go out collect these things go shopping at Target do and then be able to hand them out to people who who have the need in our community so we we do that uh many of our schools many of our programs do that so thank you and and I know the community appreciates that this time I also want to thank Julie sink um this is her last week with us as an interim Finance director she came at the end of August and as as you heard she's gone line by line from not only FY 24 last year but also FY 25 um I know that's taken a long time

043but that's the reason why we did it so that we make sure that we have the verified and true numbers moving forward so we're not guessing and and not being able to plan right so I know a lot that's um uh kind of went against people's patience and people really want to know but it also I think challenged her patience at times and um and the office and you know she does drive down uh a couple a couple hours drive and she was here Mondays and Tuesdays and virtuals most Wednesdays and and and then even Beyond and so um we are in a much better spot because of jewelry and I want to thank you um and she's here yet tomorrow and it'll be helping us out and Dan pen who has already been with

044us for a couple weeks is uh um they know each other and um he he has Julie's number and so do I so I'm sure we can reach out when we have questions but they're already transitioning uh very well and Dan stepping right in and being able to take over so again I really want to thank Julie I think uh when she it was a cold call and she answered and um she said yes I'll be there and then um she's put in a lot of work probably more than what she may be expected um but we really appreciate where she's got us to and you made by in a better place at this point so thank you very much appreciate it so um enrollment update right now we are at uh let me see

045if I can move it over here um I'm I'm on here so it's go added that one we are 2317 at this point um so we're holding steady right around between 2316 2320 and that's where we want to make sure that we're staying and we're not dropping and so forth now remember we'll start looking at the next year and at the 2 January meeting when we look at that's when we will accept the first round of open enroll students for next year and so forth and we'll start working with Dan on projecting enrollments then for next year and looking if if we have to revise anything as we move forward into the adopted budget but we'll be looking at in moments but it's holding steady right now which is good um any questions on my

046thank Mike Y and thank you Julie um next there is no old or unfinished business so on new business action on resolution Levy paval 2025 so from what you heard from Julie tonight now we need to approve the uh School tax levy from her information so read it do you want to Mo whereas pursuant to Minnesota statutes the school board of Byron School District Byron Minnesota is authorized to make the following proposed tax levies for general purposes maintenance general fund includes the referendum of 3,191 3444 community service $7,810 and Debt Service 5,865 19772 for a total proposed School tax levy of 9,2 $1,442 now therefore be it resolved by the school board of Byron School District Byron Minnesota that the levy to be levied in 2024 to be collected in 2025 is set at 9,254

047426 any discussion Mr chairman I'd move to approve the uh resolution that's read second motion made in second any further discussion on the solution is read hearing no further discussion can I get a w CL please David I he I Lisa hi M hi jery hi hi carries unanimously next action on fiscal year 24 audit so we just need approval on the audit that was presented tonight any further discussion on the audit was presented by chaer Mr chairman I move to approve the audit is position with the board and the community second motion made in second any further discussion all in favor say I I I I'll oppose same sign approved action on fiscal year 25 revised budget so again this is just uh to approve um what Julie had presented as this year's revised

048budget um at this time any further questions of Julie Dr newer on the revised budget would motion to approve the fy2 revised budget as presented second motion theate and second any further discussion all in favor say I I lose same sign approved next up report on early retirement incentive yeah so um last spring as we were looking at reductions one of the ideas that came out was a early retirement incentive and we were working on one um with our lawyers and the teachers union was working with their um Council and it got to be so late in the year that we were unable to do one so we started working on one for this year and um you know we would proposed a a onee um incentive that they would get extra bonus for one

049year if they were to retire early and there was stipulations that they still had to be 55 working in our district for 15 years and and so so forth um as the as working with Union and as they started looking at the people that might qualify I think they went and talk to some of those and started asking questions in order for it to really be helpful for us and for them um you would definitely need several to to take advantage of it one of the things is that ones who are getting closer are probably more like three years out two or three years out so the one year really didn't help them and they came back and asked about what we do three years um now that spreads everything out and it will end

050up being more money over the three years and and so when I talked with Julie and Dan um about it it just sometimes that you really don't get the benefits that you think you're going to have um and then we spread out over three years it really does not not help um and so forth so at this time it's not that we won't do it if there has to be reduction for future years because now they're a little bit closer and maybe you can entice some a year or two out but at at this time uh we I just want to let you know that the plan is unless you tell me different the plan is not to go out and do an early retirement incentive for this year we have um we right now

051we just know we know of one that's put in for retirement at the end of the year um there may be one or two more but that means we would offer to everybody if we were to put it out there now and there's only one or two then we're kind of giving them some extra money who's already retiring and so we just have to be smart about that as well and we're kind of holding off on that early retirement incentive and we'll look at it if we have to in future years as people get closer we get older as our staff gets older you know so any questions thank you next action on NY C 2026 out of state trip yeah so we have Katie here as our choir director and and I asked her

052to be here and she offered I I if she just want have a and you can kind of explain rest my candy cane just I'd clear that up why so feel look comfortable um so this is just my formal proposal I started doing choir trips in 2019 on in every other year basis um they're open to anybody that participates in the class choirs um so we went to Chicago and in 2019 we were supposed to go to New York YK in 21 and that got pushed back to 22 um I did propose a trip to New Orleans in 24 but it ended up conflicting with a Spanish Department trip to Spain and so we didn't have the enrollment to run that trip but I'm just on an every other year basis we've had that um

053kind of it's in writing on a different document that it would be I've moved to even numbered years now since Co um we're TR we're planning to redo um pretty much the same trip that we did uh in 20 22 so this would be four years separate so it's a totally different batch of students in the high school and the goal is to run that the New York trip every four years so everyone gets a chance to go to New York once in their um time in high school if they're inquir for the years that the trips happen um we do things like go to Broadway shows we visit the 911 memorial um we do the Statue of Liberty Ellis Island we get backstage tour of um uh the Radio City Hall where the Rockets

054um where the Rockets perform uh and there's a um almost 100y old hydraulic system that runs that stage which is really cool to see from from the back um back view from backstage um we spend time in Time Square um we just kind of a general like tour of the entire city um and it's really a nice way to be able to um um just expose our Byron Minnesota small town students to a different part of the world um this trip is like I said four years different from the last time um it is a bit more money than I wish it was but everything has gone up um I know even my my daughters I have daughters that are two years apart and the the DC trip went up $500 between those two years

055so this has gone up um it is one big difference this time around is that this is a we're going to fly there rather than take a bus um and part of that's because New York City has really cracked down on bus ticketing and and uh the way that they don't allow um just any old bus driver downtown and they don't allow him to idle and things like that and so um Midwestern bus companies are basically refusing to to drive in the city anymore so what we would do if we bust is we would take let's Rochester City Line we' drive there and then we pay for our Rochester City Line driver and bus to sit in New Jersey while we were in New York for three or four days and then just pay for

056them to sit at the hotel and wait for us to drive us back home and have to hire a different company to take us around town so it ends up only being a couple hundred dollar difference so due to just you know time factors and the nuisance of that um and then also our um tour company that I go with um the last few trips they've gone they've actually stayed in Time Square rather than staying in New Jersey and driving back and forth every day um so by flying we're going to be able to utilize Subway and get that experience as well and stay right in downtown the right in Time Square um and just really get that feel for the city and get to see it at night and and things like that so

057um the itinerary is linked for you know if you guys need to look at it the inclusions with the the meals that are included and those things are on um there I think I linked that somewhere else down lower um so there's the inclusions link that blue one right there um the additional cost rate there is because what's not included in the proposal from the tour company is getting us to the airport so I worked with Val to figure out how much that would cost and that's what that number is it's like a ,200 something dollar um I it worked out to about $25 participant based on a 50 person uh trip and so I would just add that into the the cost is to help um get us to and from the import so

058um there's not a cost to the district for this trip um any additional funds um at one point on this policy 610 it asks how are you going to fund raise um we do an annual fundraiser for driven coffee with the with the high school I maintain a spreadsheet with all the students balances and then I have um the school cut the cut a check with all of the um participants and their amounts itemized and then that goes toward the tour company and that offsets those people that have participated in the fundraiser um it offsets their balances um and then I said that you know if there's a one question also that says how are you going to help students that are economically disadvantaged Al have an opportunity um and I said we could pay

059for 25% of one person's trip based on my general acire fundraising account um and I don't know exactly how we would go through that process but that was something that we added in the assignment we do to the board how do you guys advertise the fundraising is that just Word of Mouth for the buzz advertise the fundraising you mean like for the students yes uh it is the students choose to participate so if they choose to participate it's their job it's like a door too sales situation so and it's all independent like if you go out and sell $200 you're going to get 40% of the $200 so it doesn't go towards other people it's really like I did the work I get the money from it so that's how that works and then I

060you know if seniors graduate and there's a little bit left over um that rolls into my general funds so do we have minimums that you need have to be able to go and do this or it is a he did two different prices he did it based on a 40 he being my tour manager person um he did it based on a 40 participant and a 50 participant pricing um I think when you go lower than much lower than 40 and that includes parents and students parents that are invited to be participants as well what level of interest do you have right now um lots of people say they want to so I can't officially like get anyone to sign up until we're officially approved so uh I won't know until until I start and

061then I mean if we were to get people to start start signing up and put down a deposit if the trip gets canceled due to low enrollment everyone gets their money back so would you consider co-oping with another school if another one wanted to go if you didn't have enough numbers or um I have I I have talked to the cast and directors about that they do their theirs a little bit differently because they do competitions every time they travel and they go band an I have talked with our band director and he's not interested in tours um so I mean it's I I would be open to it I don't know if there's anyone that it would work well with right now but any other questions thank so we just need to approve that

062I would make a motion to approve the New York City 2026 out ofate trip as presented second MO second any other discussion by the board no all in favor say I I all OPP same sign all right it's approve thank you thank you all right car's gone tonight so I don't think there's a Z update unless you have anything no I don't have anything okay uh moving on city council update city council update pull it up here all right um so they did a vote to keep the tax rate study um steady the tax rate is actually lower than many other area cities similar in size and it's obviously your house um your home value that determines your property taxes so when your value goes up so do your taxes so they were happy to

063keep it stable in light of the fact that will probably go out for a referendum again short and speak thank you is anything on the consent agenda anyone would like to discuss hearing none I entertain a motion regarding the consent agenda I move to approve the consent agenda as position with the board and the community second motion to B and seconded all in favor say I I I I'll oppose same sign all right on to donations all right so from the Rochester mail tus we had $500 for a choir fundraiser Harvey bird gave $200 for the Bearcats and also Harvey gave $150 for the food pantry and Community closets thank you Harvey can't retain a motion regard the donations i' move to approve the donations is readed motion of made in second approved donations as

064read any further discussion there no further discussion can I get a K Jeremy hi hi Lisa hi Heather hi mat hi David hi moving on uh January 6 board retreat organizational meeting yes so I just want to um inform those that are staying and let the community know that uh January 6th we will be having a board retreat in the afternoon starting at 2:00 um and then we have our organizational meeting with the new board members uh starting at 5:00 that evening and then there will be a regular board meeting a work session type board meeting at 6:00 uh on January 6 so that'll be the first time that the new board members um will the new board for the next two years will be together and um so we're excited to have that and

065get people off to a a great start so just want to let the community know that that's what we'll be happy on that day and because of that we there won't be a listening session like we usually have for the half hour before um that meeting um just because the board members will be in in their group probably until 4:30 or so and then um that'll be at the district office and then they will be coming over here for the organization meeting at um 5:00 and then we'll have the regular meeting after afterwards so that's how January 6th will happen so okay any questions are in January 6 okay moving on recognition of The Parting board members yes I don't have anything in writing but uh two two years ago when we uh had uh

066elections and remember because of the previous years before that we had people resign and so we had six of seven positions open on the board and uh people answered the call and and came on and so we have a couple people who were on a twoyear term who are now leaving the board and so I wanted to uh recognize them at this time and thank them for their service and U I think they came on wanting to one maybe see what it was like to really get back to the community thought maybe this two-year deal will be okay and so forth but they uh were moving are moving on to other things and trying other things so we really appreciate their service their time especially the last year as you know for for Community our

067school community and our board has not been easy so I really do appreciate their their leadership at this time and um and so I have something here for for for Heather Holmes and Dwayne who took over board chair this year thank you for doing that and then I also want to make a a special uh thank you to Matt pry I put in the buzz last week that he was he's on the board for 20 years uh been on the board for 20 years and then I look back at my notes and last year during the msba conference he was recognized for his his 20th year so he's actually his 21st year of serving on the board um and so he said it's about what a third you said of your third of my life

068a third of your life he's been on the board so woohoo you know good and uh but i' want to thank him for all of his work his care for the community um giving back the hours upon hours and all the emails upon emails and phone calls and so I want to thank him for doing that and being part of this um and and retiring from from the border I think unless he's going to come back in a couple years but I don't his wife's back there saying no way no way otherwise if he says he's if he's running he may go missing we'll but I do want to thank you also for all of your work and uh for what you've done for our community and for everybody here so thank you very much

069I appreciate it any anything else from the board members I just uh you know Dwayne and Hill it's been a couple years but Matt has I think truly taken me under his wing and been available for advice um good or bad and and uh help me look at things a different way and then I know Matt will still be available to to all of us and for a quick call uh nothing more than a quick call um but I really appreciate just being in meeting with you Matt and and listening to the questions that you ask and and it's helped me grow and and learn the aspect and still have a lot to learn but I just wanted to personally say thank you thank you I've got some comments to share if nobody else has

070got anything else to share well I the last thing we have on our agenda before adjournment is retiring board memb share thoughts and experience I'll go last unless anybody else yeah just it's been a it's been a journey for the last year so two years really last year has been a lot um it's been fantastic to serve the community I look forward to continuing to serve the community in other ways so this isn't goodbye this is moving on to something different um that's started and I'm excited to see where that goes to yeah Sam kind of got into this not really you know totally knowing what to expect um overall it's been a good experience this year has definitely been challenging stuff that none of us expected to have to deal with um I agree

071it's great giving back to the community and trying to help serve our staff because they do a fantastic job and you know most of you know I ran for office that's why I wasn't able to continue on in this position hopefully still be involved in our community and help out and Yeah and Matt I also appreciated your Insight you know your experience like when you especially when you start it's like you don't know what you don't know so sometimes you don't even know what questions to ask and you were always really good but so through your incitement too I've got a few pages to share I wish I had PowerPoints to share but uh I don't my apologies in advance I'm going to read this because if I had to do it from memory I'd

072probably start crying so culture is not what you say it is what you allow what is our culture here in Byron has it changed For Better or For Worse this story comes from any school in America I want to point out the importance of Role Models character and culture and the impact on lives a mother passes away at age 36 from cancer and leaves three kids Behind one is a boy in fourth grade she was diagnosed in August and gone in January school was an opportunity for the boy to escape the void left at home Role Models like the lunch lady we'll call her grace or a teacher from a previous grade playing horse caller Miller Mary Ellen during recess helped ease the pain of the loss later other teachers would also have an influence

073in science English and accounting people that were kind well educated and nurturing and had values that were Second To None they were one can imagine where the characteristics of a person that once was here and now gone other Role Models came along but none as influential as a single father that was toiling at home on a farm to keep providing for his mother's family a high school a instructor a guidance counselor basketball and football track coaches all had an influence in shaping the character and the future of this young man by pushing him to expand his thinking and moving him along his journey years later he returned to his community and was looking to pay back the efforts of others he was contacted by an old coach and teacher to come into the classroom to

074teach Junior Achievement after class one day the teacher and the two men were brought in for discussion talking about the impact of positive male role models in lower grades due to the incre in Reed uh divorce rate in the country it was just another example of the value of a school and the role it can play in helping students thrive in a way that is not always educational teachers do more than Teach as time passed his children attended the same school that he had the oldest had developed depression in Middle School due to low iron levels and was put on Prozac by the doctors unknown was the impact of a genetic issue that put the student in the path of suicide from the prescribed medication were it not for an attentive teacher who knew the

075student well the plan might have succeeded only by the help of the teacher who knew the signs a death was prevented another example of the influence of a teacher the student from that time on worked to stand up for those who needed someone to advocate for them even if it was a teacher that was later uh exited the district with the acceptance of a resignation by the board when the girl turned 16 it was a happy day it seemed until she got home from school after getting a driver's license and checking out the PSO op opportunities at a local community college she returned to her home High School previously a counselor had informed that she was not the best candidate since she wasn't in the top third of her class this day her friends turned

076on her telling her that she wasn't smart enough to graduate from the local school and others saying that she should have committed suicide back in middle school the daughter never wanted to set foot in that school again she did her High School career at the junior college and received her associate degree before high school diploma in college she was recognized with the outstanding underg graduate innerfield this is uh was followed by obtaining a master's degree at the number one institution in social work and beginning a PhD program in education her grit and determination to prove others wrong had been a driving force and providing the impetus to have a broader platform to advocate for others I know this story well I've lived it this is my life I tell this story because I know what

077a difference the schools can have on a life it can Propel a passion for Lear learning and it can save a life I'm concerned that we are at a pivot point here in Byron I've spent over onethird of my life 21 plus years on the Byron School Board most of it been very fulfilling most of it I ran this last time in 2020 after the outbreak of Co because of a growing concern that community members and staff wanted to get rid of our superintendent because of a difference of opinion over mask bandaids and the budget adjustments that he also faced in trying to get a fund balance backup to the board budget I consulted with with a trusted friend in our district her comments about uh being concerned that she could be fired for violating

078six-foot social distancing mandate if she gave a hug to a student that desperately needed one led me to believe that I could make a difference she also informed me that there were teachers that were writing their obituaries because they were concerned about Contracting Co it was not a good situation my writing campaign then stated we currently face some daunting challenges Financial Health of our state in school covid-19 increased social unrest psychological well-being and more I was concerned that some bad things could happen since then I observed a small group of people that have used tools and tactics of solinsky to attack and ridicule our board and administrators over a difference of opinion on how to operate in govern a school against the decisions of those elected to set the policies since 20121 I have witnessed

079the following our previous superintendent left after threats tires being slashed and and threatening the no vote of confidence two board members resigned one citing that the duties of the school board were negatively impacting mental and physical well-being the others stated the real estate business they owned was in financial downturn because community members that didn't agree with the masking decision on the school agent or organization uh or that school organized to not do listings bookings or showings with that agency a replacement board member was contested because of an old posting by their spouse on a deleted Facebook account and labeled them as potential homophobes media being contacted to ridicule a boarded Administration over enforcing an existing rule that uh what can be done on school grounds our Ukrainian flag issue I later found out that the

080reason was more about a concern that the board was impeding on freedom of speech of students and teachers and a genuine concern for the plight of those in Ukraine there was a time when we contacted the media to celebrate a National Blue Ribbon award or being a finalist in the Malcolm Baldridge award now we called to eror dirty laundry and the media comes and droves more recently the ridicule and harassment of our current superintendent board chair and other board members from our current Financial issues including again a threat of no confidence vote by the union Freedom of Information requests that have cost the district over $10,000 through the end of October in legal fees this is money better spent or saving teacher positions than trying to prove a conspiracy that does not exist our current

081situation could and should have been avoided through numerous ways but it was not personal accountability myself included by all members in the district and the community could have made this all go differently but we failed in the short term some have stated that a more experienced board superintendent would have prevented this from happening I cannot say one way or another but having more time in the seats gives you more life experiences and context to make decisions public and social media taxs that destabilize the board and administration when they make decisions that are unpopular some does not help with the attainment of longevity and needed experiences to affect government long term in effective vote Yes campaign could have been the difference in the operating Levy it appeared that no effective vote Yes campaign resulted and the

082board Administration was blamed even though it's illegal to fund a vote Yes campaign with District funds it's a conflict of interest now we have staff with less seniority that are risk of being cut to make a financial number why wasn't there a campaign I don't know since 2013 our homeschool population has doubled and our open enrollment out of the district has more than tripled what needs are we as a community and District not fulfilling if we were appealing to those 204 students it would have meant an additional $2 million in Revenue in 23 and 24 school year what are we missing do homeschool parents disagree with mandates or a lack thereof uh or curriculum and sex education class contests are some of the PSO students looking to escape a bullying situation I don't know the

083answers but it Bears investigating the day after election I was returning an election Banner to one of our newly elected board members that I put up after dropping it off I decided to take a short drive and area of Byron that I had never driven before after driving through the culac I waved to a group of walkers in the sidewalk one of which I knew the next day I was tected by this individual who wanted to talk about the current School situation the initial conversation started out by informing that I was going to be personally liable for the negligent manner the district was run that I should not be protecting the superintendent that jail time was likely for some at the end of the conversation I was asked what were you doing in my neighborhood

084yesterday you don't belong there that was is creepy in my life I have never felt like someone was looking at me as a second class citizen just for driving through a neighborhood that I had once considered living in how are people made to feel that we don't know in this town our community needs to decide what the culture of our district is going to be going forward I'm concerned that if we have people leading this District either internally or externally that have a Personal Agenda that it will not be good for our school to our community when the board received an email from a local resident during Co about the bond ref rning back in 2021 that stated you messed up the masking mandate good luck getting money from the smartest as wealthiest people in

085Byron I felt that something in Byron had changed people that claimed to support the schools were putting their own interests ahead of that of the District of the students in the district this was further emphasized during one of the Freedom of Information Act requests when he found out that a newly elected member of the board emailed Dr numac from the text requested it was revealed that even though the individual knew that the district needed an operating Levy they would lead the vote no campaign until he resigned critical thinkers need to be aware of their own biases and do what is needed despite their own beliefs to do what is right for the community in the district we at a turning point in Byron what do we want our culture to be going forward it's not

086what we say but it's what we allow is what we have currently gone through the type of home that our students want and what they deserve I appreciate your time thank you very much it's been a pleasure being on this board thanks Matt I appreciate you sharing your story and thank you for the two3 spending a 30-year life here it's a long time with that um the last item on our agenda is adjournment motion second motion with made and second you get sure all in favor of ajour say I I I all oppos same sign we're [Music]

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.