001I call this meeting to order this is a regular meeting of the Northfield Public School Board today is Monday December 9th 2024 and the time is 6 PM this meeting is being live streamed and recorded the recording of this meeting will be posted on the district website as soon as possible welcome members of the community here tonight to observe the important work being done on behalf of all School District stakeholders Dr Helman we have some items in the table file can you update us yes we have several items in the table file this evening we have um an updated policy 402 we discovered a typographical error so an updated policy is in the table file we have some additional gift agreements additional Personnel items um we have an updated substitute pay schedule to reflect um
002new minimum wage requirements uh we have two uh overnight field trip requests included in the table file as well that's the table file for this evening okay thank you very much if there are no objections we will add these items to the agenda as we move for okay is there a motion to approve the agenda as presented okay moved by Jeff second I have a second okay Rob thank you all those in favor say I I post passes we're moving on to our public comment section we do have one Community member signed up and I have an additional um statement on making comments tonight as we are doing our truth and Taxation presentation so bear with me while I read these tonight we have two opportunities for public comment in conjunction with our regular school
003board meeting we have the truth and Taxation public hearing at this time those who have signed up to make public comment at this regular meeting will do so after the truth and Taxation presentation North held school district taxpayers will have an opportunity to ask questions or make comments regarding the truth and Taxation public hearing presentation Robert's Rules of Order is used to govern the Govern the conduct of this meeting and now I will read our regular public comment guidelines this is an opportunity for residents businesses business and Property Owners parents Guardians students and employees of the Northfield school district to address the board all comments to the board must be must adhere to the guidelines set in place by District policy 206 regarding public comment this is not a time to debate an issue but
004only for the board to hear your comments you are prohibited from making comments about specific students staff and administrators the board respects and values input but when it relates to specific individuals or a specific matter this input must be heard by the appropriate personnel including the building principal or superintendent and not during an open meeting of the school board you will be gabbled out of order if your comments are not in compliance with these guidelines please address the board from the podium after being recognized by the chair identify yourself and if you represent a group we require that you limit your remarks to 3 minutes you're not allowed to yield your time to another person and it is expected that members of the public will address their remarks with Civility and respect personal attacks by
005anyone addressing the board are unacceptable the board has allotted up to a total of 30 minutes for public comment at regular school board meetings I will now begin to call those who have signed up to speak in the order in which they have signed in Vice chair Corey Butler will be monitoring the speaker's time he will signal each speaker with the time they have remaining at 1 minute 30 seconds 10 seconds and 10c intervals please make your comments as brief as possible but no more than three minutes okay we have Andy turn here come up and make your comment hi good evening uh I got a put the mic down for you there thank good evening I have here a handout everybody got here that little hand out that was for a um presentation a
006year ago in December I just updated it a little bit and made it a little bit more readable you look at it on the right you have the performance standards which are accepted in this country on the left hand you have your buildings and my little comment was regarding I was wondering what's going on in in this town how many what are the colleges doing with their buildings and how they're performing that was my question and when you look into it I put in some comments about it where they are actually and I found an interesting thing and that was actually the uh re Regency Hall at s Olive which is actually doing pretty well when you look in there for their performance it they were actually surprised was doing that well they were thinking
007about the twice of the energy almost twice of the energy use it and they figured out oh it's actually doing better what that means for you when you have a better performing building you have less of investment cost and you have less of maintenance cost and this is what that is all about it and this should gives you a little bit a guidance where we are and where you have po potential to improve your buildings my uh hunches about it and I own actually also on the Schoolboard election on that thing we want to have better performance of our buildings and when we start the reemerging project we should look at this and set actually standards one thing actually came out out this that New York SC SCA is a large organ organization which does
008actually the rebuilding of their schools in New York they have 1,800 buildings under them and they build about 40 new schools every year they have a very good programs and very good information out in the internet you can access actually so what we can do to get that better well we can do better envelopes we can do avoid termal bridging and we can specify performance for our building which would actually make sense right and stick with that and the lack of imp performance actually caused the uh nonperformance in my opinion of the uh Green Well project we built just a few years ago I hope this helps a little bit to make a decision and U if you have questions I'm open for questions thank you so much Andy any questions I'm sorry this is
009just a listening time so thank you for sharing right we only had one person signed up tonight so we'll move on to our announcements and recognitions and tonight we have a very special recognition turn it over to Dr Helman yes this evening um I am proud to share a little bit to begin with about our cesa Centennial minute we're honoring nol Straton and we can't honor nol Straton without also honoring Lois and so nol and Lis are here thank you for being here to let us recognize you so to begin with I'm going to read just a couple of passages from the book that we've been uh using during the district cesa Centennial year city of schools by Bruce calwell and I'm reading from page 141 at the May 20th 1980 special election voters also
010selected two School Board directors in a closely contested horse race among controll data manager NL statmon and Rural Farmers Harold Paulson and Phil Parsons Paulson and Parsons as expected swept the five rural precincts but statmon won both City precincts to win a seat along with Paulson in the remarkably close finish statmon had 1,319 votes pson 1,318 votes and Parson's 1,254 V votes staton's Victory marked the beginning of the longest tenure in board history statmon has served uninterrupted from 1980 until the present so NL statmon has been an amazing public servant for 44 years um elected 12 times and he did not run for reelection this year and this meeting would have been the end of his 12th term and we are here to thank NL for his service I also want to thank um Dr
011Rob hard for filling in for NL for these last several months as NL has been recovering with some health issues um we all know NL is dedicated to norfield in all aspects and something I'm really appreciative uh about nol is that he always followed up with a very kind word at just the right moment and no is a model of exemplary public service and uh no we have a couple of special things for you tonight and so first is uh Dr Hardy our uh the northfield's first poet Laur has composed a special poem in your honor no and he's going to read it now no when I sit here in front of everyone I lose my importance and think only of the importance of the work we do together you have shown me this way
012of being present of being centered without being the center that so much can be accomplished with a steady hand a soft voice and A Generous Heart elected and reelected three times before I moved to town and eight times since you have always been the anchor and the sail Rudder andc Compass both the wind and the calm when it was needed each year new words are added to the dictionary and definitions change with changing times but you have remained the definition of service of Duty and humility if there is a word for the greatness that comes of raising others above self that word must be no so no to use one of your phrases you've touched all the bases my friend as a member of the board and the entire Community is grateful for your service
013and it gives me great pleasure to be able to announce that uh tomorrow December 10th 2024 will be NL and Lois Straton day in the Northfield school district for their outstanding service and dedication tireless effort and const support for the Northfield school district so I have a couple of uh um I'm going to bring these over to you NL and Lois and while I go over to give them if board members want to make comments or share Thoughts with nol and then I know nol has a few things he'd like to say as well we'll get a few pictures as well so if board members while I'm heading over want to make any comments what you mean no I I don't have a poem for you but I do have so many fond memories of
014working with you on the school board and I must say I will always remember um your colorful language but I don't mean swearing I don't don't remember ever hearing you swear but you always had a way to turn a phrase to produce a picture in my mind and really make your point and sometimes you would even have stories behind it where you tell a story and you would get to your point and I it was just such a wonderfully diplomatic and memorable way of explaining how you felt about things and I always call them Noel's Parables because um that's what you were doing you you teaching us a lesson while telling us a story so thank you for the time I've been on the board the last eight years to serve with you and thank
015you for everything you've done for the students in our district over several Generations thank you thank you Amy anyone else want to make a comment Jeff all uh Jeff quell here thanks for your service um spent many years sitting by you you know over at the school and stuff and I just uh one of the things that I when I think of of you is just uh your ability to be able to give perspective over the many years that you were on the board and kind of um help us as board members to compare that to what's happened in the past and I hope to be able to add some more perspective to that from what I heard from you and things just going back because we want to we want to build a future
016as much as as honoring the past and the tradition too so I I thank you for your time thank you thank you chff anyone else want to make a comment at this time Jenny no um unfortunately I um only was able to serve with you for a just a tiny glimpse of your 44 years of service so I I don't have that strong common Bond as as some of the other board members do with all those fun memories but I do have a a little memory um of when we were chatting and you have raised two sons and that's kind of what um I do share that common bond with you because I'm also raising two sons and I remember you were giving me advice um because I was asking um about raising them and
017and I didn't have my notebook and my and my pens with me though so I remember getting home and immediately uh writing down all of that advice as as much as I can remember anyway and um I just I appreciated that so much um and I just want to wish you a happy 44 and also happy 44 to Lois too because she was um obviously standing by you and supporting you for those 44 years very nice share something B sure thank you no I didn't serve with you long either but you uh rightly told me when I sat next to you over on that side of the table that you couldn't hear me talking so it was good coaching advice so hopefully you can hear me now and I've taken that advice every meeting like
018what would Noel say so I'm just you know trying to be uh as articulate as possible but thank you for your service you know I think that's a long and and storied career and any Community is lucky to have somebody that serves for 44 years so thank you no anyone else Cory no just want to say thank you for your four Decades of service to the community uh obviously that's a Untold number of years that you've committed to our community and it takes uh a baton being handed off among seven people over that time and hopefully we can carry it forward and continue to serve our community for the betterment of our students and everyone else who lives here so thank you and no I've only known you a short time as well um but
019you made an impact on my life um and I appreciate you for that for your kindness for your words of encouragement and most of all for believing in me so just glad that our paths crossed would you like to come up and make some comments else I think I think it's fortunate that God suggested the knes give out first because you need the brain longer than the knees so my advice Lo where are you we thank you for all your generous comments it's been a great ride and uh when I when Jane McWilliams asked if I'd be on the board consider running from board I didn't expect that I was going to be here all these years but uh I met a lot of wonderful people lot of opportunity so wanting to share something but
020keep it short I'll quote agan Nash it was one day in September when rightly I remember I was walking down that street with Tipsy Pride not a word did I gutter when I lay down in the gutter and a pig came up and lay down by my side not a so we were disturbing As We Lay there by the curbing when this high class lady came and I heard her say you can tell someone who boozes by the company he chooses and the pig got up and slowly walked away thank you so much for your generosity it's been a great experience being with you and uh rest assured we will continue to read the newspaper and listen to the radio so don't mess things up it has been a privilege for me to be able
021to to support for all of these years we are so proud of the school district the E excellent education our young people are receiving here and of the and of the people that that work here yes we have two sons that graduated from here they went on to be exemplary students in college and U anded are now young excellent young men and never did they live in our basement which which is a clue that graduation from Northfield is a good way to go thank you all that Lois here all right ready one two three hey one more time one one two three right wonderful thank you that Mary will carry the song for you she'll help make sure you guys get out the thank you see you later been a good run you said you
022put in the middle ofe I won't let that thank one more part of that susco Centennial and I just did the quick math and N statmon have served for 30% of the time that the school district has been an experience in uh existence so I know 30% that's pretty great so thank you no and Lois and while your service is is ending you will still be um part of our hearts thank thank you we are on to item five which is items for discussion and reports oh you yes uh well I hate to say anything after that wonderful experience but I I think we have big news from um that uh one of our people who have been in the theater Department the director of the theater department for many many years over 25 years
023um and also very involved with the community this year has received the Northfield living treasure award and that's Bob Gregory Borland so anybody who's worked with him and there's a lot of students who've gone through um have have had the blessing of being able to um have him direct them over the years so very exciting news thank you Amy thank you for sharing that anyone else have any comments or recognitions announcements or recognitions no okay thank you so much for sharing that okay truth and Taxation presentation for the payable 2025 property tax levy and fiscal year 2024 2025 general fund budget revision followed by public comment um Director of Finance Val murder surf will review The Levy and recommend revisions to the 2425 general fund budget the general fund budget revision accounts for legislative impacts
024final audited data settled contracts and benefits and the public is invited to speak following this presentation the final certified Levy for 2025 is 27,7 40, 32316 representing a 26.4% increase from the prior year the increase from the preliminary Levy to the final Levy includes the initial debt payment for the reimagined Northfield high school bond welcome B thank you my pleasure to be here so we are going to talk um a little bit about the pay 25 Levy and then I will jump into the revised budget and I have to say this is not always the most exciting topic but feels like really a bummer to follow that excellent scene so all right so as you know we don't start any presentation without talking about our strategic plan um our Levy is 25% of our budget
025um and so when we talk about preparing every student for lifelong success by developing critical thinkers who are curious and ready to engage in our society the budget in the resources we have is how we accomplish that um each day and so our budget is really making sure sure that we are prioritizing our dollars to match up with our strategic plan and this Levy is a very significant component of that and how we work through that every day so the ly cycle um I won't go into too much detail um as most of you have heard me say the property tax system in Minnesota is one of the most complicated in the United States so lucky me I get to explain it to you um really our process in the district is we certified the
026preliminary Levy in September and now we are finalizing that um as you will see as I go through this we saw an increase and the there are very limited reasons uh why you can increase between the preliminary and the final um and one of those is a voter approved referendum which all three questions um passed on November 5th and so that is the reason for that increase but really we are certifying a dollar amount um there's a a common misconception that if our tax base goes down um that the district sees less money and that's not the case we certify a specific dollar amount and that is spread through a very complex calculation um across our tax base which includes the entire 178 square miles of the district so we have property in rice Dakota
027and good Hue counties um and rice county is obviously our home county and they take our final Levy and then they distribute that across um that calculation based on all the property values in the different classes there are five major classes of property and 50 sub classes actually I looked it up today I had an estimate of 40 in my narrative um so there's some more specific information for you but it is complex and there are a lot of factors that play into the dollar amount that actually shows up on your tax statement um the other thing to note is um some governmental agencies have quite a bit of leeway and what they can choose for their Levy uh that is not the case for the school district the vast majority um of our Levy
028is uh State authorized levies or voter approved um it is extremely regulated and so we can't decide that we're going to be in a tough budget situation and increase the levy um just to help us out it all has to be either voter approved or through a formula through the Department of Education and so this talks a little bit about all of the different they set not only the tax policy um but the different Levy authorities so we have the max um voter approved operating referendum Allowed by law for 10 years with the inflationary Factor um and then there's lots of miscellaneous other leves um that are included in our calculations which we'll talk a little more in detail about in a minute so property tax changes um there are several things that can impact
029the dollar amount that you pay so obviously the voter approved referendum um the bond passing in November is the significant change that we're seeing from the preliminary to the final because several of our formulas are enrollment based changes in enrollment can change the amount that we're levying for there is also up to 3 years prior for adjustments so start to finish when we're doing the preliminary to when it's very very final is nearly a 5-year process um legislative changes can also change it dramatically um changes in Market values you can see in the graph on the right there um in 2022 our total market value went up 15.6 and in 2023 it was 11.7 this data is a year behind on the levyt um just the way the timing works for when we're certifying things
030but those are pretty significant jumps um that obviously coincide with what we've heard from our community um that market values are increasing um and then in addition to the change in market value for your property any changes in class rates um and things like that can impact it as well as levies by other taxing jurisdictions so we are one of the taxing jurisdictions um obviously the county and the city and some other miscellaneous entities also play into that total so the levy for us um covers three different funds in the district the general fund the Community Education fund and Debt Service so this for the general fund is 25% of our general fund Revenue um like I mentioned that's a very significant portion um and we are grateful for the partnership in this community uh
031to support the dollars the additional dollars to help keep our programming strong for every student The Debt Service uh we are required by Statute to Levy 105% of our debt payments for the coming year so every year we we pull together the schedule based on our principal and interest payment schedule um and then we enter that into MD system and they Levy 105% of that um it also includes voter approved and state authorized which we talked a little bit about and we'll talk some more when we get into the detail and really the levy fills the Gap uh from The Chronic underfunding that we've experienced at the state level with our general formula so in terms of the summary overall our Authority is up about almost 5.8 million or 26.4% over the prior year the
032preliminary Levy was 2,836 96345 and our final certified is 27,7 4,323 now again the only difference between the preliminary and the final is that all three questions of the reimagine Northfield High School passed and so this is including our first year of Levy for The Debt Service for the bond that will be talking about probably at the second meeting in January so it's anticipating that um Bond issuance if that makes sense and so this is uh just a percent chart of how that 7 million breaks out um so this looks a little different than it did last year so our debt service fund is now 33% which is the same as our referendum prior the referendum was a much bigger um chart of the P but with the increase in The Debt Service that is
033now 33% for both of those general fund others about 25% that includes um our cap operating Capital long-term facility maintenance um other post- employment benefits are building leases um and local optional Revenue capital is 8% that's the voter approved uh Capital project Levy and then the community service fund is about 1% so this is a lot of numbers on a small slide so I'll try to talk through them there are are three different categories and ways we're required to talk about the levy so the first on top is just by fund so of the 27.7 million 18.2 million of that is the general fund so that's 25% of our general fund budget Community ad is about 412,000 and then The Debt Service you can see was the significant jump from 3.3 million to 9 million
034to make sure that we have funds to pay that first year of bonding for the um high school reimagine project the second breakout is really just voter approved another um so 20.2 million of the 27 is voter approved and 7 just shy of 7.5 million is other other means that they were state authorized formulas that we were able to access so we saw a 48% increase in our overall vo approved which is again a testament to this supportive Community um I had a dollar amount in here or percentage I want to say it was like 70 probably already passed it 73% I think yep 73% of our total Levy is voter approved um I feel incredibly fortunate to work in this District um the sport we have in our community is Second To None the
035last Breakout um is just by tax based so the referendum market value is primarily the tax base calculation that they use for our operating referendum and net tax capacity is the calculation for basically all the other formulas um so there's a slight difference basically in the um how agricultural property is taxed for referendums versus all the other levies and so that was um pretty similar um the increase in the net tax capacity is really where that Debt Service payment shows up so this gives you a little bit more detail about the general fund and all the different um authorized levies that are included within that again most of them are relatively consistent year-over-year uh we uh we talked about this in September but the other post-employment benefits increase was really related to um some additional
036teacher retirements and the severance payments that are associated with that the long-term facility maintenance decrease was really a change in um the legislative calculation and so we are getting additional state aid so it's not that we're getting less money it's just shifting it from a local ly to a state aid and then the adjustments for up to 3 years that went down about 500,000 and again the pay 24 had a pretty large um adjustment for a referendum related to enrollment so that was actually cleaning up from the 22 school year where we had a very conservative enrollment estimate during the pandemic just because there was a lot of uncertainty about where students were going and so that was um an additional kind of extra Revenue we got in to catch up from from 22 Community
037Ed had about a $227,000 increase um Again part of that is some of their formulas are tied to the basic increase that the general fund gets some of it's related to a sensus um increase and then um other just statutory calculations excuse me and then again that service which we've talked about several times already but that increas is just related to the bond that we're going to be issuing in the spring and then just for some additional context um in terms of the levy overall um including pay 25 um our average over the last 5 years is a 7% increase um overall very reasonable if you look at the prior five years it's a 1.8% increase um and so overall with the declining enrollment it's been pretty stable um really the only increases that you
038see in Pay 23 was the voter approved capital projects Levy and then pay 25 is the um Northfield high school bond so now we'll dive into a little bit about the budget so there are lots of things that can happen uh from when we're estimating our adopted budget in the spring to today we you're going to hear in just a little bit about the audited information from the prior fiscal year that's now finalized and so we know where our fund balance landed we know where our Revenue expenditures were and we can take that information and Roll It Forward and compare it to what we had adopted our October 1 enrollment is no longer a projection so we can analyze that and see if we feel like we're on target or not or if we need
039to change that we have settled employment contracts and staff hired in those employment contracts so we can make sure that the salary budget is up to date we've received a few grants since the spring that we need to make sure are included in the budget we've renewed contracts um we've had some benefit changes and so all of those things come into play um when we're talking about the budget I'm just going to grab my water so I don't cough on night okay so for enrollment um overall I was actually really pleased um I got pretty nervous when we had our initial September October enrollment report and it showed it was way under um not way under 20 year 20 or so under what what I was originally projecting um but when I put it into
040the model um what I will say is overall we're only I'm only reducing it 8 in terms of our weighted calculation that's in all of the formulas but there's quite a bit of adjustment between the the grade level bands um so overall enrollment stable um we're just kind of cleaning up some of the um transition and things from the adopted to the revised that just weren't quite lining up so overall enrollment stable I'm the estimates basically the same um in terms of all the calculations for the revenue so that's a good place to be in terms of Revenue um I think it's like a $4,000 increase which is flat and stable in my opinion um really the biggest change that I want to call out is the switch between state and federal sources and so
041if you recall last spring uh when we talked about the adopted budget we talked about doing a one-time switch um that's allowed with our special education Federal funding to use it to pay for um our tuition billing cost and so what that effectively does is move it from federal to state so we're using federal dollars to pay state tuition bills um and there's a one-time basically not a onetime it allows for an increase in that special ed reimbursement rate in the next year but in the year we did it it was a one for one change and so that's what that switches again not more or less Revenue just shifting the category in which it sits in um and then the local sources increase was really just um an increase in our interest Revenue protection
042again lots of data on one slide um but I felt like it was easier to see that this is the same data set just broken out in two different ways um so the top one is by program so where are we spending it and then the bottom one is by object so how are we spending it and so you can see there's quite a bit of um adjustment in the expenditures and really that is related to um some of mostly related to things that we saw with our audited financial data that we needed to roll forward um so there were some I would say some significant benefit changes throughout um in addition to just our standard process of increasing or analyzing our health insurance premium the benefits advisory committee recommended a 10% increase we're still
043seeing some challenging claims experience uh with our health insurance and so a 5% 5% of that 10% increase is picked up by the district and I think I included in my narrative just for perspective because 5% doesn't sound like a lot um but our total health insurance budgets about 6.4 million and so a 5% increase that is $320,000 for just health insurance um so that's a significant increase in addition um I talked about the teacher uh Severance payments with our old PEB Levy that is a trend that we're anticipating to continue um we have a a veteran St staff and so we're expecting some of that to continue which results in some increases in our other post-employment benefit offerings um as they access their contractually required benefits um what other things did I have on
044here um special ed Transportation was another big one that we saw last year um was significantly higher than what we had budgeted that can be incredibly volatile depending on the students um and where they need to be transferred and when they need to be transferred um we had a a pretty solid number of care and treatment transportations in the past year which depending on where they go can result in one student being transported daily for several days um and so that was just an increase over what we were expecting um we've also seen increasing special education numbers um year-over-year and so we're not anticipating that to slow down um and so we're just adjusting to the budget to make sure that we have a reasonable amount to cover that on a positive note we did
045or are changing our work comp carrier January 1st and saving about $100,000 in premium so I was pretty excited about that work comp's been increasing pretty substantially the last couple of years so I will take 100,000 savings any day of the week um those were kind of the big um changes there were a few Staffing things that we were just making sure we're aligned in the different programs um but overall uh we ended last year with about 1.6 million more expended than what I budgeted and so I want to make sure that this budget is appropriate for what we are anticipating moving forward again last year you'll hear in the audit we also had additional Revenue to come in and offset that we actually grew our fund balance last year but just making sure that
046we have the right um the right amounts and the right buckets um to get through the rest of the year so this is where you pull it all together um one of the things that was most um interesting to me when I pulled it together was just analyzing the balance and so I included a chart in the narrative which I realized I totally clipped off all of the headings or labels so it was maybe not as helpful to you as it was to me because I knew what it was saying um but for 2324 we um had a a surplus of 1.3 million which was more than what we had originally projected and I had projected ending at 4.14 for on assign fund balance so when you look at that it says 13.83 and of
047course initially when I look at it I'm like ah we're under 14 that's not what I planned but if you look at the actual on a sign number the 8,365 731 in the budget that I did last year I actually projected that we would end with 8,335 545 so we ended with a additional 30,000 in onon fund balance more than what I had projected which is great but because our expenditures were 1.6 million higher than I projected it's 13.83 instead of 14.14 um so unassigned fund balance is right where we expected but our expenditures were higher than anticipated which means the percentage is less so then we roll all that forward the proposed budget obviously um had a goal or had ascending at 14.35 but again we're increasing those expenditures um and by adding those
048expenditures we're obviously going to um have a deficit now which was not originally anticipated of about 592 th000 and so we're projecting to end at about 12.17% so the next step for this process is really an updated Financial forecast which will come in January um and so we'll be able to forecast there are some significant um expenses coming up that we need to be planning for uh which I'll talk about more in January when I present that but this will obviously set into motion a plan for us um to know where we need to be the declining enrollment is still a Factor last year was kind of the the blip where we had a slight increase but we are expecting it to decrease um again and continuing for the next couple of years so um
049really I just I want to say that the culture of stewardship um obviously that's one of the Strategic commitments that was on my second slide but it uh has given really the district a sense of financial stability that is not common place in school districts in Minnesota in my opinion um and we continue to operate from a position of strength having a projected 12% fund balance is probably several districts dream to have projecting 12% and for us again it's below the fund balance goal but that means that we can be planful we have funds and resources um but we can choose to be planful and proactive and how we respond to that uh rather than just reactionary so that was a whole lot of information um but I will gladly answer any questions you have
050at this time thank you Val thank you for your presentation and all your work um to get to help us understand I I'm going to open it up right now for the district taxpayers who want to ask questions or make comments regarding the truth and Taxation public um hearing presentation is there anyone who wants to come up and make a comment or a question about that truth and Taxation presentation is there anybody NOP nobody on the side um board members do you have any questions about the truth and Taxation presentation Amy first thank you for taking a lot of numbers and condensing them down into something that's still very complicated but yet has a chance of being understood by people like me so I really appreciate that um I just have a question about something
051you were explaining to us on the revenue revision page um you mentioned tuition billing costs and I didn't know we charged anybody for tuition so if you could just clarify for me what that is that would be great so we don't actually charge anybody for tuition um the tuition billing is part of the special educ education calculation so for all of the students that we enroll in the Canon Valley special education Co-op that's a a charge back to the district that is comes through the tuition Billing System that's what the state calls it so if we are the resident District on record um any students that are attending special education students attending other districts go into a Statewide calculation that we end up um paying a portion of if that makes sense so for Canon
052Valley Special Egg Coop we're we're paying 100% of their costs because they're residents and it's a joint power arrangement with the four districts that we're part of there's lots of other calculations depending on um the student and disability and how they're placed and where they're placed and why but it's all part of um the the special education statutes and who's responsible to pay for what parts of their education so it's that something that the state handles at their level then so we're not giving money to Canon Valley special education instead the state is taking it from us and giving it to them that's exactly how it works yep so that's why on it's a flip because the tuition billing is a um reduction of our Revenue so whatever I'm projecting for special education revenue is
053this total minus tuition billing and so what we effectively did was we paid it with federal dollars and so it's reducing the amount that we lose in special ed or that's taken off the top if that makes sense yeah that helps a lot thank you very much you bet anyone else question or comment Cory hi Vale just want to thank you and your Finance team for all the good work you do I appreciate both the levy portion and the budget discussion tonight obviously 12.17 is not where we want to be and is below our uh goal of 14 by two points so I look forward to the January forecast and some of the discussion we'll have from that and likely some difficult decisions in the future I did want to just Elevate and highlight a
054couple things you said during the levy just for general knowledge or general you know reassurance to the community that your friends and neighbors vote at 73% of this Levy over the last several years right so I think that's very important it's not just the one from November it's two prior levies as well is that correct so there's three on the books right now so while the other vo approved debt correct that's so while we look at 26.4% increase this year which is significant no doubt yep uh it was overwhelmingly supported by the community uh and you had mentioned that in the 5 years prior that it was 1.8% outside of that so again looking at the very complicated formula that we have and I think it was two out of the last five years and
055this year would have been a reduction in our Levy had not there been a positive vote across the board is that fair to say it is those are my comments thank you thank you I'm gonna go to Jenny and then Ben thank you Claudia and thank you Val I just actually have a question regarding something you mentioned not so much the report itself sure um on the workers comp savings was that realized um because of an annual um report for application for Renewal or because our modifier went down or do you know so we actually um we got the renewal from our current carrier and then actually went out and sought another um quote from a different vendor we've been with the same work comp carrier for several years now and so the um premium
056that they were offering was uh $100,000 less than our current carrier so we're switching carriers um so not necessarily our mod rate I I don't know if they set their own mod rate or how that works in terms of the calculation the information I had was that it was their initial premium was $100,000 l than our current carrier and during those annual uh renewal applications you usually seek out quotes from other companies or just not always it depends on where they're at um we have uh and I'm going to this is not my area of expertise so you can help me out if I'm wrong but we have a a broker and then the actual carrier and so we have um used the same broker um actually the same person and kind of followed her
057because she has done an excellent job depending on where she has been but the carrier has been the same for quite a while um and so that was a recommendation that we look for something different and there's lots of work behind the scenes and what that means for our human resources team and that sort of thing but obviously that was well worth the savings that we're going to experience thank you yep okay Ben thanks as always quick question on and maybe you can take us through these complex tax calculations but you know I think you show that slide in terms of the estimated market value going up kind of 22 to 23 and you know double digit increase there but then when we looked at the levy prior to this year obviously it's going up
058because of the referendum but those increases weren't of that same percentage of propor can you talk a little bit about the relationship between like I'm a you know homeowner so from a residential taxing standpoint like as my estimated market value goes up like what's the general relationship between the district's Levy in that value does that make sense sort of uh hopefully my answer will make sense um so our overall market value is the entire amount that we have to spread the district levy over so in a in a year when we'll pretend we're back at the preliminary Levy where it was basic basically slightly declining almost flat this market value increase of 11.7 not only is property value increases but also includes any new business valuation and so what it means is our dollar amount
059that was the same from the prior year to this year is spread over a larger dollar amount and so the preliminary Levy um tax impact calculation was actually reduction of your school district taxes across the board across all categories if I'm recalling correctly um because there was additional Market base but our Levy didn't go up in in a percentage that exceeded that and so most people saw a reduction in their school district taxes now obviously our final Levy looks a little different um and so those numbers will be different on their final um tax calculation that they receive um we are working to get updated tax estimates but we haven't received those just yet so we can share that out once um those are received but that that's the general relationship if our Market base
060is growing but our Levy is relatively similar you should see a reduction in what you're paying for the school um if it if the tax base isn't going up significantly but our Levy is obviously that's going to be a more dramatic increase but obviously lots of factors that play into all of those numbers but that's kind of the base assumption sure is that helpful it is no and I think you said something at the beginning that I think it's helpful just when we think about this in general that we certify a specific dollar amount it's not sort of proportional to the value of the taxable Market in the district overall so sometimes I think those things get confused at least in my mind that that's helpful yeah two more questions I'll make them quick but
061there's a decrease in the long-term facility maintenance from 24 to 25 what was the driver of that so that was actually a legislative shift um where they increased the um Equalization factor and so we actually just getting more state aid so same amount of Revenue just more coming from the state versus the levy good to know and then looks like we landed the plane right on the runway in terms of Revenue side it was good to say that the enrollment matched I assume that was because we picked up more in the kind of six seven eight kind of higher grade level is the part of the formula isn't it if I remember correctly um yes so there was a kind of a swing um there the kindergarten number from last year was lower than what
062I had in our revised budget and so that that part got cleaned up so that's why there was like a 30 student decrease um but we picked up some additional 712 kids that have the 1.2 rating so overall that weighted Kelk was 8 less um uh which is really good yeah still declining but really good in the terms that it didn't go backwards and we had less Revenue than I anticipated and so when we look at what are the top three bullets then for the propose versus Revis because we're about a million and a half different there so remind us kind of what those top three drivers are for expenditures um benefit so both health insurance um other post-employment benefits due to some anticipated Severance payments and retirements and access to those benefits uh which
063those are leviable and so we'll see that Revenue coming in the levy in future years it's just not a clean in the year you earn it here's the revenue um and so that's that's at least a sort of positive there's Revenue coming benefits were the big one um special education Transportation was the second big one and then just some kind of Staffing cleanup changes uh to make sure we were lined up correctly and the special education Transportation B is the same as the OPB where we'll get that money back from the state but not until another fiscal year correct yep the special education State um Aid is paid on prior year expenditures so we will see that come through um what we were what we had extra in 24 will actually come through this year
064and then that kind of just keeps rolling forward yeah so of that 1.5 how much would we expect to make up in the future of that difference maybe that's not a great way um I know what you're trying to say um I would say probably n almost a million 900,000 to a million of that was two of those formulas probably we would expect to see that revenue and sub years it's just that we have to pay for it now yeah okay hopeful thank you yeah questions okay Jeff yeah thanks for your report yep if I recall correctly I believe the middle school was built for about 41 million in 2001 and we did a 20-year Bond and that is off the tax rols or coming off the tax rols to the people paying taxes um
065what will they see or how is that reflected in anything and how does that come into um you know your current situation for just reporting on that because that's a big deal if people don't have to pay on that anymore yep so um the the final debt Levy for the middle school bond was actually on this Levy we're paying it off in February but it's only um like a halfe payment and so it was pretty small the biggest change for that was actually on the pay 24 Levy where we saw a pretty substantial decrease in our debt service but that was offset by the capital projects the voter approved increase for the capital projects Levy so overall the levy looked like it balanced but there was a pretty big shift between debt service and um
066general fund and so had we not had that voter approved increase there would have been a substantial decrease in The Debt Service taxes that then would have been offset by the pay 25 increase with the high school does that make sense no not really but I understand thanks yes so overall the the bulk of the debt for the Middle School fell off on the pay 24 Levy um and so but there wasn't necessarily A a reduction on your tax statement because the voter approved capital projects Levy offset that so in other words to Jor Jane public when they're looking at that it you're not really going to see that because boom we're adding on uh yep the the timing of those two helped offset each other so there was not a significant increase when the
067capital projects Levy came on um because the debt was falling off at the same time but it's it's all about the timing good thank you anyone else question or comment okay thank you Val thank you Item B is our fiscal year 202 for audit results and presentation and we have Ben Johnson with Clifton Larson Allen LP who will present the results of the 2324 fiscal year audit and a full copy a copy of the full audit report is available upon request okay welcome Ben hello thank you Claudia and thanks for having me here today um yes so my name is Ben Johnson I've been with CLA for about five years probably in the past you've had Craig presenting he's the principal um that I work with at CLA most closely and Believe on last Monday
068he presented to the four of you on the middle here so that was a little bit more detailed than we're going to get today um but I'll be open to questions at the end here so we are issuing a clean audit meaning there is no internal control deficiencies noted yellow book issues Minnesota legal compliance issues or single audit um issues which that's the federal um dollar audit of the 40 or so audits that Craig does eight of them have this clean of it audit with no findings across the board and only two of those have a in-house accounting department where they don't pay um or have an outsourced accountant help them so that is a really big deal and is a testament again to um the financial operations going on here so thank you Val
069and Matt for your leadership um and then based on the size of the district you guys have are when any district has over $750,000 of federal expenditures you need to have a compliance audit over some of those expenditures and just on the size of the Child Nutrition program which is your you know food service and federal dollars there that's the the program we audited as I mentioned there 's no findings there we're kind of looking at contracts and vendors and basically making sure those dollars are spent responsibly and yes okay this slide is breaking down our general fund and the columns are kind of like your unassigned general fund and then your restricted your state restricted funds which is made up of a lot of different sub restrictions and those are very restrict Ive on
070how you can spend those dollars and then there's two columns for your Capital expenditures operating Capital being you know kind of smaller scale textbooks curriculum you know upgrades and then your long-term facility maintenance obviously would be your large purchases but with the small exception of the operating Capital this is overall a really good year um with all fund balances going up steadily um your covid this this year we kind of see covid ending to a large degree in terms of fiscal year 23 there is Big covid projects still ongoing but a lot of those project have dropped off in fiscal year 24 but that's um made up by the fact that your general education Aid is going up ALC is up um your operating capital is steady and then your long-term facility maintenance basically no
071major projects ongoing so that's going to go up with your Levy and other revenues uh the next three slides will break down basically a five-year Trend over how these fund balances have gone so your general fund unassigned fund balance is up from last year due like I said to that general education Aid um is uh significantly increased from fiscal year 23 uh your covid Aid and Co expenditures dropped off from fisc year 23 um and then your this is a pretty good year for Investments as well which your investment interest income doubled over fiscal year 23 AS Val mentioned previously this is 133% of your uh expenditures and is your unassigned fund balance uh which is health compared to a lot of districts that we see but is under that policy that you guys have
072set which is we see policies all kind of in that that range it's that's a normal policy uh this slide we're Switching gears now over to the Food Service fund balance this is a pretty typical graph from that we see in terms of that fisc year 22 went way up as covid happened and that though that um program was heavily supplemented by Grant dollars however in fiscal year 24 those meals were more subsidized are free from paid by paid for by the state uh you guys were budgeted to break even here and a lot of districts are trying to spend this fund balance down because like I said this is a pretty common Trend and it's just like a lot of districts have made you know upgrades to their equipment and things but now they're
073running out of you know what where how are we going to spend this money so that is something to continue thinking about is how are you going to spend this food service fund balance down because I wouldn't say it needs to be as high as it is here and then this uh graph shows a five-year trend of your Community Education and from my experience this is your graph that looks the most unique because a lot of times Community Ed is what really struggles at the different at different districts where it is really close to negative and Trends down significantly so you guys have very healthy fund balances in your Community Education and it is declining a little bit from fisc year 23 to 24 but that is a really like amazing graph on honestly to
074see I think there's expanded programming and increased participation going on this year but this is a great graph to see now we're switching a little bit towards your enrollment Trend which over the last five years has been relatively steady with a slight decline overall but from fiscal year 23 to 24 there was about a 40 student increase and sounds like that's obviously on all of you guys' mind moving forward as well and FIS 25 is going to drop again okay these last three slides are breaking down or are showing two different things going on here so the dark blue is showing your five-year trend on your expenditures for in per in this case Administration your Administration expenditures per student and then we're comparing our dark blue 2023 number because we're waiting for finalized numbers we're
075comparing that number the 2023 to the state average and the similar size District averages so looking at our expenditures our Administration expenditures per student those are steady slowly and slowly increasing but your expenditures compared to similar districts and the state averages so we're looking at that again 2023 number though all all have this be are true um is less so you're spending Less on Administration per student than similar size districts or uh the state average and this contrary to the other slide is showing your expenditures on your regular instruction so your your student your expenditures on education you're spending more more P per student than similar size districts or the state averages which both of those Trends is and also this final one showing a similar thing is something that we as Auditors see as
076a a really good sign of how a district is run because it means you're spending less of your money on your Administration and more of your money on your students so that last slide was showing your regular education expenditures and this is is showing your special education expenditures per student which also steadily increasing and you're spending you're you're putting more of your money towards your students and special education than the rest of the state and similar siiz districts and I think that's the last slide I have for you so my contact information is here but are there any questions you have for me at this time thank you so much ben board members any questions Ben can answer at this time questions or comments Ben sure thanks Ben informative and we got a deeper dive
077from Craig last week during our finance committee meeting so I appreciate the recap excellent work so if two districts passed with any outside help how many districts have a Val mestor that's the question no I think that you know I think this is just reflective of kind of what we were hearing and going through the budget you know I think Val and Matt and the fact that we're so efficient in terms of you know comparatively in terms of our administrative costs I think just is a continued good reflection on the district and why I so enjoy being a board member here so thank you and just by way of context I think what is this our sixth seventh year of a clean audit eth sixth yeah so right say that again six there you go
078a sixe streak yeah know so I think that just highlights the excellent work that we do and you know gives hopefully the taxpayers and voters continued confidence in the fact that o have seen an increase in you the referendum for the reimagine project that that's certainly funds that will be well handled and and well overseen so thank you again and thanks Ben yeah thank you thanks Ben for the report and I'm just trying to understand the special education instruction cost per student um that's over all the students so that's divided by the total number of students or is that divided by the number number of special ed education yeah that's a good question this is per all students is how is how this calculation is working at the state level here okay and that's helpful
079to know but it seems like there's a the percentage of special education students varies between districts so I'm not sure what the comparison numbers actually tell you because some districts might have a lot more special ed students or you know percentage wise and yeah I I'll add I guess additional context here of this is this is a interesting graph in terms of yeah some districts heavily use their you know like special education Co-op or something and so like this this graph is less comparable to other districts for multiple reasons because there's different solutions that different districts have okay yeah that's that's um the clarification I needed but I also have a comment and that's I want to comment to V first amazing vow truly amazing and I have to say I've been here longer than
080six years B and I know it's been six years of a clean audit but it's in my mind it's been longer than that because you had clean audits before except for a technicality so if you could discount that technicality that you were required to have a dirty audit because of that technicality how many years would it be though um I do not not I don't know it's on um I don't know that off the top of my head but I can certain go back and please do please I would like to know that number okay I can do that hi Ben thanks for being here uh couple questions so just pigging off piggybacking off of Ben's our Ben's question about the percent so of the CLA clients you have 40 school districts you said eight
081had clean audits two of those have in-house staff so 5% of your clients had in-house staff clean audits is that correct yes okay just wanted to verify that because it's a lot easier to digest 5% so that's uh High Praise obviously and then obviously six consecutive years with an asterisk of maybe more uh even higher I have a question about the comparison ranges so we are on the high end of the our peer groups of 2,000 to 3,000 99,999 is that like a is that an industry standard is that CLA selecting what audiences to put us in since we're at the very high end yeah that this is like State numbers these are these are state reports these are State classifications so the state would identify Us in the two to 4,000 yeah I mean
082obviously having the state number is great to average out because you can see we spend a lot of money in our classroom and less so on our Administration and um I think we are talking talking walking walk when we talk about being good stewards of our money and I just was curious how we would pair up against 4,000 to 6,000 if that's the next peer group but obviously having a state comparison shows that story anyhow yeah I mean and we can you know build these slides however you guys as a as a board finds most valuable so if that is something in in the future like we can definitely add that column in as well and so no that certainly is not required on my behalf I just you know when you're at either the
083high end or the low end you know you like to be kind of in the middle so it feels like it's a closer comparison yeah I can I can actually run that data and share it um later this week we used to be in the 4,000 to whatever the range was um and once we were consistently below 4,000 we we decided to switch it just because that felt more appropriate but um I'm happy to show it both ways um it's not necessary I was just curious kind of how the process goes and again compared to the Statewide we're still looking pretty positive with how we allocate our dollars thank you anyone else comment question Dr Hamm okay very good thank you Ben thank [Music] you item C of our uh sessions and reports is director
084of instructional Services hope Langston presenting the 2024 2025 comprehensive achievement and Civic R bones oh look at that I'm a little shorter hi everybody I was last here in at the end of October and uh I'm glad to be back to present these new goals um the comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness goals otherwise known as kaker um AS Val said we start every meeting with our vision and uh are are grounded in preparing every student for lifelong success by developing critical thinkers who are curious and ready to engage in our society and really this these goals and our Benchmark goals uh speak to that so as I alluded to in October the 2024 legis ISL made a shift from world's best Workforce wbw to kaker um and that involves some changes in goals set by
085districts and here's just a little information from the mde site and um really they're looking for a more holistic measure from each district and uh this really will be measured on goals we set this year so this is a little bit confusing because you won't receive the actual report to the fall of 2025 because world's best Workforce and now kaker are reporting on the prior school year so I hope that's that's clear to everyone so that part hasn't changed um but again encouraging us to to look at a more holistic view of our students that is the the focus of of this legislation and then they delineate um what road role you all play and really that's having um the board establish an advisory committee and for us that's uh Northfield forward formerly known as
086DPAC back in the day um and so that that group gives us feedback and uh participates in in planning on many different things and so they there were 22 board uh committee members present at the October meeting November meeing sorry and they um helped to discuss what how we might measure these goals this year and they really they're looking to to uh have districts use a multi-year plan and um and we know change doesn't always occur as quickly as we would like it to um but we we had some robust discussion around each of these goals uh at our meeting and I'm I'm happy to share those with you tonight so there we go 22 Northfield forward members um talking about these five goals they were given a little sandbox to play in um the
087parameters were that any any go metric had to be cost neutral so we weren't going to add any new assessments we wer going to spend any more time um assessing students both academically or social emotionally we're going to use what we have um and then and then this is key because we had to do a little research after this meeting but we need to be able to efficiently measure whatever it is that we are going to use reach goals so um as you just saw in Val's report we are lean administratively and that means we need to set up structures and systems that allow us to measure uh measure accurately but measure efficiently so that was one of the other parameters that the group needed to use when they were generating ideas so these are
088the five kaker goals um in place uh for this year and and you're going to see that four of the five look very familiar in fact they were in world's best Workforce so all children are ready for school racial and economic achievement gaps between students are closed students are ready for career in college all students graduate and here's the new one that we prepare students to be lifelong Learners now think about this districts all over the state have have been studying how they are going to measure each of these goals and we we um Can locally develop the metrics that we use to um measure these these particular goals so you know as you've sat through many world's best Workforce reports over the past decade um you know we've tried a bunch of different things
089we talked about that at um at our Northville forward meeting and and again I'm excited to to share with you the ideas that were generated that night so all children are ready for school um we as you know are now required to give uh the fastbridge assessment to our kindergarten students and really what it is is uh five different subtests that um measure foundational reading skills that that uh research says are good predictors of future reading ability um so we talked about that and then we also talked about and this one had a lot of traction would what uh preschool screening rates so that would be um at what age do our incoming kindergarten students get screened and we know this is important because if a student needs intervention the early they get it the
090the more successful um they can be and and and the response can be quicker and so um we we looked at this um and I want to just let you know that preschool screening rate data from mde is a little bit like the attendance data conundrum we found ourselves in last spring where our local data um didn't EX exactly match what mde was reporting publicly and when I dug into our use of preschool screening rates because I believe locally we keep very good um we keep very good records of who screened and when but when I actually started digging around the data analytics site for mde um I couldn't get there the last publicly reported data set is from the kindergarten cohort of 2223 so those kids are currently second graders um I couldn't get
091the data to match and it was a variance that I was not comfortable with um so I of course go to our expert which is Chris nesset who knows all and uh and we started digging into it and and here's where it becomes very messy um is that we have out ofd District students who come to Northfield to be screened we also have Northville kids who might go to farbo to be screened or might go to another town screen and we're not super clear and we couldn't get a super clear answer from mde on how those kids are um factored into this into this metric that's publicly reported and I get a little hesitant to report um something that's going to be public like this metric uh with a piece of data that's local that
092does not match what's on the mde so for this year we we just thought you know what until we can and explore this a little more uh carefully and um and really understand what's happening with mde data we we're going to stick with the fast Bridge results it's efficient it's accurate we know it measures um literacy and math Readiness so we landed on this one um for this year that's not to say that we cannot revisit preschool screening rates it's just that in the time frame of the November Northville forward meeting to now we we just don't feel comfortable with the publicly reported data um so we're landing on uh 72% of incoming kindergarten students next fall will be will meet the grade level Benchmark on their early reading fast Bridge assessment this year we're
093at 70% that's our Baseline um we know that there's a um consistent and United effort to continue to prepare kids we just had our pkk meeting um that we have every December with all the area preschools and the kindergarten staff and everybody loves this data they want Ain and I to come back and report on their cohort level data um but they are invested in in preparing kids and they want to know what this new assessment looks like and um and so that's where we landed for kindergarten Readiness all rational and achievement gaps economic achievement gaps between students are closed we've seen this before um we we have been working on attendance as you all know um and we are and the uh Northville forward um had generated some other ideas one of which was
094after school activity attendance because we know that um kids who are engaged in uh activities that appeal to them will um will generally have higher in School attendance um in any case we decided to stick with School attendance because of the efforts that we are making uh both through that State uh attendance pilot and uh the work of of our family engagement Navigators and their cohort level work with with specific students and families so we are going to um continue to try to meet this goal This truly is a multi-year goal because it is hard to move the needle on attendance in a single year so we have seen Improvement in this and we want to see this through um and and know that the work that we're doing is making a difference so that
095will look the same for um for this year all students are ready for career in college as you recall we used to um measure 8th grade MCA results and ACT scores for the last few years uh we had a lot of discussion about this Jeff and Jenny were there along with Matt um about what what does it mean to be career in college ready um and we also have some really great special education parent perspective on that team saying hey we want to see our students represented in in this data um so where we landed was uh really making sure that that our high school students are on track for graduation and that means credit attainment and you can see in the in the gold box to the right of the circle where our Baseline
096semester two data was for last year so that's our starting point we want to reach 95% um and really this would apply to every student at Northfield high school so so we feel comfortable that that every family and student uh can see themselves represented in this goal uh for Readiness and um we're excited to see the work that the high school is doing to to increase those numbers the again this was a this was a robust discussion so I I really just wanted to make you aware of all of the great ideas that were generated that night um eighth grade students completing a career interest inventory AP and PSO course enrollment the uh what we formally use act and grade 8 MCA and then um again keeping in mind what kind of postsecondary opportunities for
097students who access special ed services and how can we uh include them in that measurement so these were just some of the things that that our uh committee talked about that night in small groups then goal four all students graduate from high school um we did actually talk about course completion rates as a possibility for this this goal as well but um we decided we would stay with graduation rates um we know that this data is clean when it comes to us from mde it is a year delayed but they actually give us a graduation roster and we see student by student what their outcome was um and that's really allowed us to clean up our system um whereas when Chris Ness and I tried to do that for the preschool screenings couldn't couldn't come
098close to that so um this this is a good metric and it and uh we're going to stick with this one for now um you can see the 2023 rate as our Baseline and we're going to continue to try and hit that 95% Mark and now we get to our new goal preparing students to be lifelong Learners which aligns nicely with our vision um so we talked uh again quite a bit about this goal the additional proposed metric that we did not select were the social emotional competencies and as you know we we do have our social emotional screener that we give twice a year to all our students um and so in some ways that makes sense but but kind of tying that to a lifelong learner goal seemed seemed like um uh a
099little bit it it was an indirect path let's put it that way so we were looking at other options and really people were um talking about like if you are a lifelong learner you are passionate about something right you you want to continue learning you like learning you um will try new things and and so we kept coming back to really participation in not only activities but some kids work outside of school um kids taking elective courses outside of the graduation requirements so the graduation requirement for example calls for one our class but somebody's taking three our classes um but once I came back and started to talk to Chris nesset about how remember one of our parameters was efficient measurement um we were talking about where this data lives and right now this data
100lives in multiple systems in our district and so it is not efficient ly gathered especially the work metric um the high school as part of some surveying that they used to do of all students a few years ago preo actually uh they used to ask kids about their work participation so we want to take year one uh which would be this year to to look at how we can as a system pull all of that information into one place so that we can efficiently measure it because we believe this is important data to have on our kids and we want you know a global view of participation and work um work experience in one place and so that that's where we landed for year one is okay let's look at how what our structure is
101for doing that and um and we'll be able to report back to you about where the progress that we made in pulling all of that together in one place so that we can have an accurate measurement of it um I think there's a strength of Northfields there's a lot of opportunities for kids so we want to be able to report it accurately um and have it reflect what students are truly doing outside of the classroom so that that is our year one goal that would be a multi-year goal because obviously we want 100% of our high school students to either be participating activities um doing outside work and or taking elective coursework we kind of see what how that goes this year um for Baseline data so we may tweak the the broadness of that
102measurement for year two but again year one is is creating creating the the how the process for for pulling that data so you know we've been up here for for a number of years saying hey we are streamlining our goals we want to streamline our goals we don't want so many goals that people lose track um of what it is we our Focus areas are so I thought it was important to say like hey we have District benchmarks that are student facing benchmarks and I wanted you to see the alignment to the kaker goals because it's it's it's nice to have either complimentary goals or goals that that are streamlined so on this slide you can see the kaker goals on the on the left um and where we will get those results and then
103um on the right you can see our district benchmarks and where our data source for those outcomes um because I think I think you may notice that the kaker gos aside from kindergarten don't have any academic testing measurements included in them but they are reflected in our district benchmarks so we feel like this is a good comprehensive view of of what our students are doing um and they're just happen to be measured in in two different places for the district now I'm ready for your questions so much hope okay board members any questions or comments Rob um I just have a question thank you for your report by the way um I have a question about two of the things the on track for graduation the grade 12 in for the year that you have
10423 24 it's 97% and then the next goal is about actually graduating and that's also 97% for that year so is that the exact same data point so is on track the same as actually graduating um grade I think that's a great question and on track means and I think we said um I go back to that um so that was semester two so that would have been grade 12 grad so grade 12 so the class of 2024 and we will get their graduation rates in it could be anywhere from February to April of 2025 depending on how MD does processing the data um so I would expect that the graduation rate would be very close to that for Northfield High School remember we for our graduation rate look at the district rate which includes
105the alc and Northfield high school so yes did that answer your question Rob uh I think so yeah I I had a similar question so the way I would phrase it is are we like double dipping Rob called it SA data point are you saying it's not well I'm saying that this was so we want 95 at least 95% of each of our high school grades to be on track whether or not we should include 12th grade in that probably not I was giving you the Baseline data for um for where we landed last year but you're right that should reflect what our graduation rate is um I think there's probably some other things that happen in in that graduation because it's not just about credit attainment you also have to meet all the requirements
106to graduate in your course selection um so perhaps we'd take 12 out you know and just do 9 through 11 okay thank you that Rob did you have a followup no okay Ben yeah I was G I mean maybe just put it more bluntly it seems like we're using the same measure for two goals right graduation right is MD okay with that in terms of this kaker approach cuz don't they sign off on the whole at least if that follows the world best Workforce model well I think that we can revisit how we word this skull so really what we want to make sure and really the whole purpose of the discussion around with this was we want to intervene on students as early as possible if they are not on track for graduation so
107I think probably to clarify that cuz I see your point we just remove grade 12 because they would be in the graduation rate and this would really be ninth 10th and 11th graders do we does MD publish I I guess I would imagine they do what other districts look at for these same goals as measures is that something that's publicly available actually they don't um so what you have to do which I did was just go every every district is required to post their reports um but this is the first year of kaker so nobody's got a kaker report posted yet um however I did see I did see many districts having this same discussion that we are having about what what they should use to measure these goals um and so that's really where
108I I uh did a sample across the state so that the Northfield Ford committee members could see a sample of what other districts were doing but there is no Central reporting of um kaker or world best Workforce goals results okay maybe that's an idea for MD but it is a great idea this uh this one here is not a new goal correct the career in college ready no the only new goal is prepare um lifelong Learners okay so any interesting when you looked kind of across the peer districts if you will however you want to Define that but any ideas Stand Out specifically for this career in college writing is one I will tell you and I think it relates to some of the parameters we set about no extra assessment no extra cost efficiently
109measured people use test scores sure that was probably the most common common metric that I saw okay we and the reason why we looked at the first four goals again is because um honestly we've been doing world's best Workforce since 2013 and we thought it was a good time to just pause and ask the the Northfield forward group for feedback um on on how we are measuring those goals and really to relook at every single one of them as part of this shift to kaker gotta yeah no I certainly respect the work of that group I do think there's probably value in differentiating a measure right between those two goals because it seems like we're maybe in the same place for two I think we removed grade 12 yeah and I I appreciate that we
110would see it that way but I do think it's two distinct different goals one is the um lagging indicator right the piece about how many students graduated this is the leading indicator and I think that if we can agree that we believe that the requirements that we have for our students are robust and a variety of different areas we have maintained through a lot of different things a comprehensive High School approach with all sorts of selections for our students that are not usual for a a high school R size and so this measure of our people on track right so if they are completing what we expect for them in each year leading up to graduation even if they if they really doveet tail together I'm comfortable with that and the reason that I'm comfortable
111with it is in is intending that if you take advantage of the variety of courses that we have at the high school the electives that are required Etc that if you are on track to get you get the number of credits you're supposed to get in that year that it is leading to the graduation require but it's not I don't believe it's duplicating it I do think you will see great I'm I would be okay with keeping grade 12 it depends when you measure it right if we say we're measuring at the end of the year fair point I would argue we should measure grade 12 at the middle of the year because there are students who are on the edge between January and June of their senior year and so the four-year graduation rate
112is one of the key metrics that is reported every year and so the leading indicators are really important to me if if we're going to use this I agree there are other ways to measure career in college readiness there's a variety of different metrics in terms of act acup Placer I even argue the ASVAB the military Readiness test would be part of that but when we discuss there's a desire to think a little bit more broadly than those um those particular metrics so as we are really wrestling with this one of the things that you can expect to see likely this spring is for for us to do some work to further align what these state required goals are and the benchmarks if you remember the benchmarks that we have were in alignment with what
113norfield promise benchmarks were and we got a little bit lucky when the world's best Workforce uh goals came out that they were a nice fit at that time but we are also trying about how do we simplify to provide Clarity so that when people are doing the work each day they know how their work connects to this broader set of goals if that makes sense so in this case regardless of what you teach at the high school you know how you're contributing to this particular goal right because we're working on making sure students successfully complete the coursework so you can expect to see we've been we've been wrestling with this right what's the right way forward because if we have too many goals then none of them matter right so we want to be able
114to come back to what are the core sets of goals we don't think we should be duplicative so if this is what the wisdom of the legislature says for Minnesota schools we think that our local items should align reasonably with our own flavor on it of course we get to determine a lot of that but we don't want to have three different reports that go three different ways and don't tell anyone what is the direction that we want to go so this is a great discussion because we wrestled with a number of things based on the feedback from Northfield forward about what to present to you tonight yeah and there's two other things I just want to clarify one is about that graduation rate um let let us not forget that students who are legally
115able to stay in school till they are 21 are counted against our four-year graduation rate um we also have uh MD's path of students and if they enroll in Northfield and go to school here for a month but we are the last Minnesota school on record we're going to take the hit against our fouryear rate if they unenroll and and we don't know where they went right so there's there's little things that that count in that four-year graduation rate that would be cause it to be different from that on track rate on track rate and then the other thing you know the biggest thing to me that is missing from here that was in world's best Workforce is third grade reading and um and here we are all in on the redact and and uh
116we all know how important that skill is um but they have moved that now to the local literacy plan which doesn't get near the public press that this does right so um so we have discussed it a lot because third grade reading is still a super important metric to us and we want to keep that at the top of everybody's mind as well even though it's not no longer included in in in the kaker goals yeah thanks for that clar ification you know I think to your point in terms of graduation rate and I mean there's different ways right you know it's the tyranny of math right and the way that calculation is done in some ways but I think to Matt's point you know it's how you see is a district or somebody that
117teaches in the district how do you look at those goals and sort of see how that drives you know your motivation and actions within the classroom and as an educator you know I and I do think I mean to that point it's worth considering right are there other measures here in terms of graduation one outcome proficiency another you know certainly as we look at not just did we learn something but how well would did we learn it and how do you take that out in terms of career in college writing this but no it's it's a good conversation I appreciate it okay Jenny thanks Claudia I just wanted to kind of hitch on to Dr helman's uh perspective and point about the career in college writing a school because in our in our committee um
118of course I mudded the water a little again and I and I did ask um you know wouldn't it be easier if mde could separate um or or if we had a separate two separate goals for this so one career being being career and one being college readiness and um hope was nice enough to remind me that you know this is what the state requires of us and um not only that but also the state gives us the parameters that we were talking about um before and so we have to hit on all of those and stay within those and also um you know come up with this metric for what should actually be in in my opinion two separate goals and maybe that's where the the difficulty um comes from I I sure know
119that that was difficult for me maybe I'm the only one but I I just definitely wanted to mention that perspective can I add one thing to Jenny's um comment um it is really valuable to have high school students on the Northfield forward committee and um so one of the things we talked about because it did come up like boy these are two different things career Readiness college readiness um is is like hey everyone should take do a survey when they in eth grade about what they want to do and those and those kids were adamant like no way and eighth grade you think act that might change a lot by the time you get to 10th grade so their perspective was um super valuable but they also felt like Jenny did like boy these could
120be two very different things Amy in eighth grade I was going to read books or a Publishing House to decide which ones would get published but see that didn't happen um anyway um I think Dr Helman has a really good point about the 12th grade uh Readiness scores if they're done earlier like in January of the year would be a very important forward-looking measure well our graduation rate is something we kind of wait a year and a half or whatever to get that information uh but along those same lines my question is do we compare the names of the people that we see as our students in their senior year of high school with the mde list and look for people who might have fallen through the crack somehow we do it kid by kid
121every year and and people wait for it and we put it in a Google doc and I send one list to Daryl and we send one list over to the counselors um you know for us Northfield thankfully the the numbers of kids um who we need to follow up on are quite small um and so that does make it easier but we do that on a student by student basis to make sure um that all of our syst systems are functioning the way they should be and um and I I don't know if you remember but back when the the graduation rate um became an accountability measure we did discover some holes in our processes and uh and and have since you know sort of tried to clean that up um and and I think
122we do a much better job but it it really requires very careful tracking and and occasionally we continue to be surprised by who who is this student on our list that MD assigned to either the alc or Northfield high school and then we just have to start doing some digging and and figure out what happened but um they get to call the shot right and it's and it's those cases are generally related to kids who enrolled here for a very short period of time but we are their last school of record and so when they enroll do we have to fill out a form confirm that they've enrolled so we know first or does MD send us a list and say hey you have a new person enrolled no they're after the fact so mde
123actually measures graduation rate on what is your incoming ninth grade cohort so all of your ninth graders they're going to track through um and then and then with the addition of new kids enrolling but no we don't know until we get that cohort you know we track our own kids in the high school and the AC are really good about doing this student by student but until we get MDS list in anywhere from February to April um then we don't we don't exactly know who they might surprise us with actually so um it it is pretty good it's come a long way from from the starting point of graduation rates being an accountability measure but um yeah we do we do take a lot of time to look at that list thank you yep okay
124Jeff yeah I mean I think over the years I've always kind of remembered 95% as a Target or whatever for a graduation rate but I think you know if you're picking to me I I wouldn't phrase anything like that I'd say I want to give you 100% of what you need to do to graduate by June of your senior year and if you don't make it by then you know then because a lot of people I've met so many people from even Northfield that that got into substance abuse or family issues or depression that didn't graduate I mean you know and and it's kind of like so within that 95% I mean you're you know we're talking about statistics here and getting tagged with people but these are you know forget about all of that
125this is a person's future so if we're saying hey if we could give you 100% of what you need to do to graduate by June I know when when they leave regardless of what happens a lot of those names are they're tagged with us or whatever School District that that is so how long do they have and then what encouragement um whether it's GE or whatever it is that we have to keep them engaged and encouraged to go finish so what's your comment on that so I think I I would like to say 100% there there's four code you're going to get when you're you're either going to graduate you're going to be a Dropout you're going to be an unknown or you're going to be a continuing and again those continuing students our special
126education students who can legally stay in our school so they're 21 yet they count against this fouryear rate so in any given year we won't hit 100% because we have a subset of kids that stay in school till they're 21 and should stay in school until they're 21 um the the other kids yes we need to do everything we can and we do and I think the alc you know we count every student that walks for the alc is a win right and um and they may be helping and supporting kids who might have run into some challenges that make get difficult for them to to graduate on time but um you know 95% I think builds in as a district remember because Northfield high schools has been higher than that um but as a
127district it builds in that that set of kids that is staying in school to their 21 I just make a couple clarifications um one thing is we're all used to saying until 21 but there's a new law change that allow students to stay until they're 22 okay 22 I because that's an entire additional year of and I think that that's important for a variety of reasons and Jee I couldn't agree with what you just said more uh the four-year graduation rate is the is the metric for what is the traditional um time it would take to graduate high school but as you said we have numerous students who face challenges that would put most adults in the fetal position who need more time and so I really am focused on looking at our five six
128and they will even calculate a seven-year graduation rate because the resilience that it takes for someone whose friends that they grew up with who they were in third grade with to continue on past what their High School date you know would have been their the FI the regular four-year rate um is really astounding and I think it is a testament to the work that uh the alc staff has done they have a very high rate of continuing to bring students back even after their traditional graduation date would have happened and they do get students in the the celebration that happens when students graduate in that ALC time frame after they're 18 you've all attended the alc graduation and entire I mean we have a huge attendance because people are so proud and so I think
129we have a system to get almost everyone right there's going to be a few people who we just we can't find they're unknown those kinds of things and then I also want to highlight the great work that's happening um at the nce with GED and with the adult basic education course where depending on how old the student is if they're past that time frame where they can use the alc they can still do the work and capture their traditional high school diploma and so there's those multi- layer it'ss are multi-tiered systems of support but in that way so I really appreciate you bringing that up this is the four-year graduation rate this is what I think the average person on the street thinks of a graduation rate but when you look at the five six
130and sevene rates we get very close to 100% MH you have a am this just made me think of outgoing exchange students who do it in the middle of their High School career do we have many of them and if they come back and then have to add an extra year on to graduate how do they fall into the four or fiveyear approach so for instance a student who leaves to go junior year abroad they're they're still in that graduating cohort and when they come back they're either finishing in four years or they're not so it depends on the student and I think it's important to remember for high school students in that circumstance you can take extra courses which many students in that case probably do and be able to graduate in four years
131I think there'd be a good chance of that having birthed one of those children um there's a lot of planning that goes into ahead of that junior year departure to make sure that the student knows and the family knows what they need to do to graduate when they get back as a senior um and and the courses that they need to take I think the high school counselors do a great job helping everybody understand what those requirements are Denny did you have a question anybody else Rob yeah um I guess this is probably the last time I'll have to keep track of all of these acronyms but I find it very confusing that career and college readiness and comprehensive achievement and and Civic Readiness are both kacker uh so I wish that the MD had
132come up with some other name for it we do too Rob well and let's be clear the name is not MD that's legislative right so the actual name of the plan is a legislative action we've had a lot of fun with it though I will say it's a little more exciting than world's best Workforce all right thank you hope all right thank you okay item D is our policy committee recommendations and superintendent hman will present the policy committee's recommended updates to policies 103 401 402 403 404 and 405 this will be an item for individual action at the next sport meeting yes so I won't go through each individual policy I'll certainly take questions on all of them what we are now doing is we are past the point of taking care of the statutory
133policy changes and we are back to our traditional review of policies which we look at um policies whether they've been updated by Statute or not at least once every four years that's the schedule that we have um we are looking this year mostly at the 400 series which is really about um employees policies that cover employees uh but you'll see that most of the policy changes that were recommended by the committee are really this point of trying to in the purpose statement um explicitly connect the policy to the Strategic plan in some way shape reform there are a handful of other what I would consider to be modest changes in some of the policies but the vast majority of these were really about just making That explicit connection as has been recommended uh by msba
134to really try to customize that purpose statement to take what is um more of a consistent policy and make it our own so that's most of what is in the uh policy changes this time but I'd be happy to answer any specific questions about individual policies any questions or comments okay Jenny and then am uh on policy 403 discipline suspension and dismissal of School District employees uh we added or you added for those who belong to a union representation will be offered that was added can you just explain what representation means in that context yes so um first of all even without being the policy um union members have a right to the representation by uh a person from their collective bargaining unit in the discipline process if if we believe there's a likelihood that
135discipline could occur from an investigation so what that happens a what representation is is a union member is allowed to have what typically is called a member rights advocate so these are individuals who are well versed in due process they're trained um by the collective bargaining units and what the member rights uh and I I think the union um leaders would tell you this as well the the point of the members right Advocate the representation is to ensure that the individual who's being investigated or potentially disciplined has due process Fair due process so they have a right to know what the accusation is they have a right to be able to put uh share their perspective on what the um you know what they're be what the investigation is about and it really is simply
136to make sure that someone who's in a a fairly tough spot right if there's an investigation going on that they have a person a trusted person who understands due process to make sure that they have their rights uh upheld and so in this context that's what it typically looks like and then on policy 103 concerns or complaint resolution um it's underlined process summary document uh was that document itself changed at all or or is it just underlined because of a hyperlink yes the procedures are underlined because of a hyperlink and so um we do have a procedural document that really reflects what board members would know as the chain of responsibility so it really just gives a um a road map if you will for a person who has a concern or a complaint about
137the District of how they should proceed and we know that we work very hard in this District to use the chain of responsibility so you would go to the person that you have a concern with first if you aren't able to bring it to resolution there you may go to their supervisor after that you may come to the superintendent it just outlines that method and also connected with those procedures we even created several years ago just a little document that a person can use so that they can take notes and you know document how they went through that process so it's underlined because um it is a hyperlink thank you I just have a quick comment on policy 404 in the purpose um it talks about U um applying for employment with political subdivisions including
138school districts and I would like to suggest that we say change the word to geopolitical subdivisions because I think with our current culture people think of a political anything to be a political party um and I think we're talking about a land area so uh can you can you tell me which policy you're asking about again 405 under 405 I'm sorry I thought I heard you say 404 okay thank you under purpose it's fourth line down all right just 405 Veterans Preference yes okay and where are you looking um I got it okay yep okay so I will check on that Amy the Veterans Preference act you know typically a policy like this and I I have to do a little more close reading to answer the question specifically in general with policies like this
139that are um really taking a legal process and converting it into school district policy language many times in a purpose statement they will use language directly from the statute and I certainly understand what you're saying we're trying to remove that it isn't I think when people read that political subdivision I'm hearing you say they may hear it as partisan right and and that's not what it means but I can understand why that might be the case if there's no if there would be no reason why we can't do it I don't have a problem adding that we've just learned over the years to be very careful about adjusting anything that was included in a policy that had gone through the msba and Masa review process if it's intended to reflect statute so I think your
140point is valid and the question is um sometimes a valid point doesn't mean we should change the policy language if it directly aligns with what statute says we will look into it we will uh check in we can Al always check with Terry Morrow from msba to say would it be a problem to add that word or that segment uh to the beginning prefix prefix there you go I never thought of Goo as a prefix but but now I do so um we'll look into it thank you and on those sometimes we have um a section that's definitions but that could be another route right yes it could okay anybody else questions or comments on the policies no okay thank you so so much item e is the superintendent Focus areas um Dr himman will
141provide an update for his 2024 2025 Focus areas so what I've provided for you in the packet is uh an update based on um tonight December 9th report just giving some um updates on progress toward each of the Five Focus areas I'm not going to outline each one but I will highlight one segment from each uh Focus area the first Focus area on mathematics Mathematics Curriculum I really just want to congratulate H blankston Ray kudr all the math leads who have really been working hard to take um the new Bridges to math implementation process and get it keep it going as well as it has I think for me the game changer that we worked very hard to uh have happen is something that are called teacher lab days one of the best pieces of
142professional development that teachers can do is watch other people teaching and discuss uh the instru ruction with each other this has been a very hard thing to pull off in the past and yet we had 66 teachers so far participate in these lab days in November so it allows teachers to go observe someone else teaching this new curriculum get ideas give them feedback it really creates this culture of adult learning which we know is so critical um as a precursor to Student Success in all academic areas but specifically mathematics the second one on the Career and Technical education uh school to work program program this is in its stages of development as we're looking toward trying to be able to include something in the next year's in next year's um student registration guide we're working
143through what are the hurdles or the um check boxes that we need to do to be able to make that happen talk with Shane Byer High School principal about it this morning but the Highlight here is cultivating the relationship with those businesses and you can see on the second page we just had the maiden Northfield tour this is I believe the second year that that has happened on December 3rd this was is about uh focusing helping students understand local career opportunities in manufacturing and Healthcare so 56 students these were students from Northfield High School the alc some recent graduates who participate in the Northfield Community College program and uh students from Arcadia Charter School of visited a variety of different um workplaces including things like Ali of clinics um Cardinal Glass engage printing mechanical systems
144there was a a panel at the end so this is part of that work with the Workforce Development that we been um engaging in and really pleased with that continued support from the Chamber of Commerce for that area uh when we think about the first Northfield school district leadership development Institute we've been taking time to be able to identify the specific themes we've identified the themes as four it would be four sessions um three hours each leadership development um leadership culture decision-making and Resource Management these are the areas that we would include in this first uh leadership development Institute um we are working to get that application available for people this month want to uh thank uh Rich Larsson and KY and radio for an amazing partnership we have realized uh our desire to have
145a podcast and we have a full recording studio right there in downtown Northfield and we have now produced two episodes with a third one uh being prepared uh to be recorded in just the next week or so here that is being standardized is the fourth Monday of each month uh the educational campaign to inform the public about the November 20 the November 5th uh Bond referendum I think enough Bond referendum updates for me um and I can uh just yield the balance of the time on that one and then uh our continued work to make sure that our friends and neighbors um from demographic groups um who we want to make sure that they're represented at the table uh folks who maybe haven't always been represented at the table uh are black Hispanic and Indigenous
146students especially their families uh we have conducted a Latino family engagement and October we've had one indigenous parent advisory committee um cble betting our indigenous cultur Le and doing an excellent job cultivating the parent group there and we are uh have the black parent advisory committee meeting notification going out in the next week uh those meetings will begin in January I've also listed a number of other updates um as has been the practice in the past with this report so I'd be happy to answer any questions that board members any questions at this point Amy I was just wondering if you could tell us a little bit more about the Massa Advanced Leadership Academy yes I'd be happy to um so the Minnesota Association of school administrators is the Statewide organization mostly of superintendents there's
147a number of other um other component groups instructional leaders technology leaders special education leaders and we have in in there's several different programs there's the aspiring superintendent cohort which I was part of the first cohort back in 2014 and so that is for folks who are interested in the superintendency it's not a lure program but it's a uh year-long program that helps people be successful when they start the superintendency there's the national certification program through aasa which I completed in 2020 and that again is in for those um people who have a little bit of experience but are really coming into that I would say fourth to eth year you know of their um experience in this role so our organization Masa was seeking to strive another piece for people who are in my age
148range if you will uh people who are experienced superintendant who have completed these other uh programs and are looking to continue to develop their leadership skills so this is a 15-month program sets of two days at a two days at a time and some virtual meetings it's being led by Steve Murley the former superintendent of Iowa City Public Schools Green Bay Schools former um University of Iowa Professor our first session in October was two full days days on uh School leadership and artificial intelligence so thinking about how we leverage artificial intelligence in all aspects of public school work and so I've already come back and challenged our district leadership to see could they be even more efficient by finding ways to include AI tools as part of how we lead the district and how we
149administrate the district is that good enough for now any thank you for the update on the second Focus area regarding the school to work program could you just explain what um you mean by by Pathways in that last box Pathways for hiring a credentialed work-based learning teacher yes so in order to continue forward with a work-based learning program you're required to have a work-based learning licensed certified teacher so we do have one of those people in place already but that individual Works solely with students who are receiving special education services so in order to add general education students to that program we would need to have um capacity with a teacher who has a work-based learning vocational license if you will so it's a license through the state very likely at the beginning of this
150program it would not be a large enough program where it would be a full-time equivalent so we would likely have to try to invest in one of our existing staff to be able to help get the license so that they could have that as part of their workday um maybe someday it would we don't we've looked into it it's unlikely that we would be able to add the general education work-based learning component to the individual who is doing the um services for students with who are receiving special education services that doesn't appear that there'd be the capacity in that role at this point there's some other ways that we're looking at it but we're looking at how would we be able to expand the number of people on our staff who have that work based
151learning lenser so that they would be able to oversee the program okay thank you and then on in the third Focus area um you state that there's going to be four sessions or or they're already scheduled that we are working on the final scheduling okay um and are those four sessions actually your key themes which you list as the um leadership culture decision- making and Resource Management yes okay and and um then you also mentioned um application for credit is the so then is the credentials that the teachers or the staff receive um to be used locally only or are they able to take that to state level for the State Licensing Board so that's a great question I think there are two things that are true there number one is that we have a
152provision of our teacher contract that allows the professional growth committee to designate certain local professional development experiences as being enough to where they could earn a graduate credit the equivalent of a graduate credit to move on the salary schedule the second part that you're asking about I would argue is about continuing education units and yes they would be able to use these for continuing education units um for renewal of their teaching license I do want to point out that I think of course with teachers who are being the that's the largest employee group that we have but we would not limit the application to just teachers we have um a lot of people who are not in the teaching group the teaching bargaining group who have we have a need for leadership in lots of
153areas you see that on display our Director of Finance is an exemplary um uh visualization of that right in terms of the leadership that Val provides um when we think about our director of buildings and grounds Child Nutrition there may be people in other units who would benefit from that kind of leadership development in those career ladders in those those areas so I I do think the majority of people who will participate will be teachers right but we want to keep it open for everyone in those cases there aren't those same kinds of renewal credits right but it would be very helpful for people as they're moving up the career ladder in our district to have learned about the way that we facilitate um meetings the way that we set goals the way that we
154uh work our cascading communication approach how we uh come to consensus and solve problems so so for the teachers it would sort of almost be like a dual enrollment they would receive the credit that they could use locally and state level that is correct should the professional growth uh committee determine uh that they would approve that credit at their meeting in January I do think they will but we don't they we they only meet a few times a year so the next time that they meet they'll consider approving that credit I don't see an issue with it but we don't have the formal approval yet okay thank you anyone else Rob I just have a question about the Benchmark I mean sorry the um podcast yes which um says it's meeting The Benchmark or addressing
155The Benchmark all parents report satisfaction with their children's educational experience so I'm just wondering if there's a way of measuring progress toward meeting that Benchmark do you have audience reactions or something that show that people are listening to this podcast I do not have that data as of yet but we will get it because I know on the kymen website they have a d detailed listing of or they are able to get detailed data about who has listened to the stream in fact they'll even be able to tell if it came from um a referral from our family update so I'm been working with Logan to learn about when we link to that are we able to see how many people clicked in fact I can even see in the s'more how many people clicked
156the link to go to that so I don't even need Logan's data on that but that's all that behind the scenes web data and that connection is that the theory behind the way we made that connection is that shockingly sometimes children don't always talk about their teachers and the people around them right to their families and so this is another way that we can expose families to the variety of different people who work in the school district anyone else good questions comments okay thank you so much next we have the construction update number two construction update number two um we are still working through a number of uh components in getting the processes set up so what I will share with you this evening are a couple of different items um number one we just
157were able to have the four planning team application Clos last evening there are around the last time I checked there around 65 people who have applied now what we're trying to do is just to put those into the different buckets of people who had applied in the different positions and we may make some adjustments depending on how people and there will be um there are some stakeholder groups where only a few people applied and they're likely to be part of the mix there are others where we had quite a bit of interest and anyone who's not able to participate in the core planning will of course be invited to in uh attend the hopes and dreams session that we have on December 17th that's 6:00 to 7:30 p.m. that's for the general public to be
158able to give um our team feedback about what they hope to see in the design and of course as you know like we did did with the Greenville Park projects before we involved a lot of people's feedback along the way it's very heartwarming I mean this is not for the faint of heart this is eight you know Wednesdays that you have to come to one of these meetings and then attend the tours so it was just so heartwarming to see so many people who are interested so like we said that just closed last night we're starting to review that we anticipate having um notifications midweek um so that people are ready for next week on the 17th so that's exciting and I we included the um schule for board members again in the packet just
159so you can see the definitions of what is the um oversight team what is the core plan team what's the activities team Etc um I mentioned the hopes and dreams event uh that's coming up on um the 17th of December and then just a couple of other items we are um moving ahead with some of the basic uh Provisions to start so one of the first things you do with a project like this is you uh hire a company to do the surveying that's everything from locating um you know different utility services and a variety of other different kinds of site analysis that um they do and so we did work with wal who got three quotes we are going with Bolton and M uh to be able to conduct that site survey and then
160the other thing that we've done is um Excel Energy has a program called the energy design assistance program and so by applying to be part of that they will provide some advice and some support on building design in which we would then qualify for an um some substantial rebates I'm not going to I'm not going to give you the number here off the top of my head tonight but it's a way that we're being proactive working with the utility provider to design a building like you heard earlier um about trying to make it as sustainable and efficient as possible so we are right where we should be right now in this process um I think people are normally we probably wouldn't have even started in the core planning stuff until January but people are chomping
161at the bit and so we want to get people involved and and uh maintain that excitement so that is the construction report for this evening board members do you have any questions or comments Rob so I've noticed on my walk every morning that there's some drilling being done at Carlton to explore the um geothermal for some of the buildings at the edge of campus and I'm wondering if there's any use of piggybacking on that for what we have to do at for the high school why yes there is and so we're very grateful uh to several people in the community who alerted us to the Carlton uh in fact they're drilling they're doing the Darcy well testing which is a technology that we have an interest in and so uh W Architects and Engineers have
162been looped in uh with the folks at Carlton who are doing that they're anticipate being able to share some of those results whether they're applicable to our project or not we're not sure yet but we do think that um even just the experience of seeing the test Wells being drilled is going to be helpful for the team and the other part is we applied um we've been trying to find a um vendor to do the test Drilling for us for quite some time the city of Northfield uh has provided $20,000 to the school district to fund that test drilling for the geothermal system um through one of their climate action um funding accounts so if anybody wants a really good business opportunity right now is to be able to drill test Wells for geothermal sites
163because we can't get anybody right now yet until the at least the spring to be able to do some drilling so w continues to work on that we learn from what Carlton is doing um and again Carlton has been wonderful in being a strategic partner and helping advise us based upon what they learned from their geothermal experience anyone else at this point all right we'll move on to item six which is our consent agenda and as a reminder there were some Personnel items in the table file added to that consent grouping is there anything anyone would like to pull from the consent grouping for separate consideration okay is there a motion to approve the consent grouping okay move back for second second by all those in favor say I I opposed motion passes item seven
164is our items for individual action and we have two routine items board members make sure your mic is on when you are voting our first item is to certify the final 2024 payable 2025 tax levy as a reminder this actually completes the school district's process that began in September with the pl preliminary uh Levy certification to Rice Dakota and good hu counties and the Minnesota Department of Education the district has reviewed and analyzed MD's calculation and the school district's property tax base estimate by rice Dakota and good Hue counties this Levy payable in 2025 will be a component of the 2526 fiscal budget I move that the board CER IES to County Auditors the 2024 payable 2025 final certified Levy liation and certification report in the amount of 27,7 40,320 2016 which represents a 26.4%
165increase from the previous year can I get a second second by cor is there any discussion at this point none all right then all those in favor say I I oppos motion passes next Item B is our fiscal year 2024 2025 general fund budget revision details of the revision are in the memo published publicly on our website Director of Finance Val is available for questions I'll make a motion and then I'll take a motion and then we can discuss is there a motion to approve the revised 2425 general fund budget with revenues of 67 mil7 49,1 122 and expenditures of 68 m341 666 moov by Ben second second by R thank you is there any discussion or questions at this all right all those in favor say I motion passes next is our items for
166information we have an enrollment report for uh December on the screen I'm showing the on the screen I'm showing the enrollment report for uh December you can see the totals and the data there I think tonight you learned about the difference between what we see as this raw student count and the um ADM in terms of the weighted uh the weighted um student um calculation so we do focus on this as you know each month just as a precursor or a way to try to keep tabs on this so you see uh those totals there and then I also just always like to pull up so that um especially at the elementary school level board members can see current class sizes so what's on the screen right now for you are the current the latest
167class size reports that we have from our student Information Systems Department and you can see those there so um fairly it's this has been fairly consistent through this school year be happy to take any questions that people have Ben just the C remind us what that means on the companeros so the comper the C designates uh the Spanish Immersion section at that grade level and what you'll notice with that from time to time as you will see we do um have those sections larger um rer on because companeros begins in first grade and there's inevitably some um there's there's some attrition in that cohort people move maybe it's not exactly for them the closer that we get as we go up in years it becomes more difficult for students to join that cohort so you'll
168often see the cohort be larger at the beginning and smaller at the end that's not uncommon but the C designates companeros at each site okay Amy I have a question about Greenvale Park um has their General attendance numbers gone up since the new school was built I mean have we do we now have more children attending that than they they used to attend in the old I would have to go back and look at the data um Amy I my Val do you have a do you have numbers that you can pull up on that right now yeah I just sort of remember them being the smallest well I think that your statement there is for sure because just up until last year Greenville Park was the smallest school right and now we see Spring
169Creek for over a year has been the smallest School school um I do feel that the enrollment has increased at Greenville park over the past few years um but it also would be less than what we saw when we have those real enrollment spikes in the I would say the mid 2010s the early 2010s as we are getting ready to that peak in 2018 AS Val had mentioned so we saw especially around that when the development happened um you know there's that last round of development that really occurred in the I would say the early early to mid 2000s um example 22 kids used to get on the bus stop at right in front of my house when Mike 10 years ago now two get on right so that's just how neighborhoods change over over
170time thank you anyone else time okay next we have a district committee meeting recap yes I just wanted to highlight that uh we tried something different in our continuous Improvement model our what's next mindset said we are always looking at how can we take some of our established systems and do them just slightly differently so a week ago tonight uh we attempted our first multi- commmittee evening and um most board members were able to attend we had seven different committees meeting simultaneously and this at the same time uh we did this for the purposes of efficiency um so that people could what I call cross-pollinate between uh committees which I witnessed firsthand at the end members of different committees who would have never seen each other in the previous silad example where one committee met
171on this day another committee met on this day so that was a very helpful piece um we have 19 survey results back so far after that meeting and so far people really did like the time they felt it was something of use for them they did give some good suggestions for feedback as we move ahead and so this is part of that continuous improvement process advisory committees are designed to help School leaders and school board members here the feedback from the community without them having to be technical experts it's about what is your perspective and that is intended to give us a base of knowledge to helps us make better decisions so we do think that um you know this really had some positive impact of course board members who attended those committees can submit
172your committee reports in January we can hear a little bit more about them um we didn't have an exact count we estimated there was probably between 70 and 80 people there I I we had 100 Chairs set up several board members who are very good at estimating gave me their estimates of what they thought they saw in the room but the room was you when you looked around people saw oh look at all of the people who are here giving feedback and we think that that's an important piece when those committees operate in a silo that you look around the nine or 10 or 15 people there and here people were able to see all of the people on the different committees and how they were there to give their time to help them make
173the district a better place so we look forward to the committee reports coming ahead in the next month but I just wanted to give you the high level overview the next iteration of this is on March third so um we'll have some more before then but I'd be happy to take any questions yeah I thought it was a good setup a lot of great energy it was it made it feel exciting to show up so nice job anyone else comment or question at this point all right then we are on to item nine our future meetings we have our organizational meeting Monday January 13th at 6 PM in this boardroom that will be followed by a regular meeting and then Monday January 27th another regular board meeting in this boardroom and we'd like to also
174say thank you to everyone for your service this year and um we'll be welcoming a new board member in January and saying goodbye again to Rob Hardy thank you so much for stepping up and for helping us and for participating and bringing all your um talents and your your passion to the role okay that is all the business that we have tonight is there motion to adjourn okay moved by Jeff is there a second I right here all right second move by Rob all those in papor say I I post okay we are adjourned