001e e e ucation meeting today's Monday January 6 2025 uh Happy New Year to all who uh go by this calendar we are here to inspire and Empower each individual to learn grow and Excel and um I'm happy to have two kids in here today I that just makes me always so happy and I can help myself and so welcome uh we are joined by director poce director Bank scop show director Lee director Spencer director CER superintendent yanowski board secretary Cassandra kwam and our lovely uh student Representatives I'm so glad that all three of you are here also today uh it's going to be a great night uh I'm Paula Cole and I am calling to order this meeting which is also our board organizational meeting do we make a motion for that one um
002well no because we don't have an the agenda comes later um as you can see I'm ready to get off this chair uh so I have had the honor of serving as your board chair for two years uh we have I've been working very closely with with Vice chair carer I hope that he is able to uh become our next chair um so let's let's get started do we have a motion uh a nomination for chair is Mr Carter willing to serve his chair I am I'm thrilled to nominate Mr Carter to serve as chair why thank you is there a second I have a second we have a motion by director police and a second by director Spencer all in favor please say IE you have to call for more nominations at least three
003times I'm sorry three times we don't do this a lot for those who are watching it's a once a year GI thing I did this last year yeah you got to do the awkward are there any other nominations are there any other nominations for chair any nominations do one of the student reps want to nominate themselves just kidding are there any nominations okay can I call the vote now all right same motion same all right have a motion by director police and a second by director Spencer all in favor please say I I any opposed the former chair vsai and wow welcome to the welcome to the chair seat uh Mr Carter enjoy enjoy the G thank you well that's it your name she was ready to get out of that chair she was it's
004uh I don't think it's warm yet thanks for everybody's patience while we flipflop okay so next step we need to see if there's any nominations for vice chair are there any nominations I'll nominate Kirk Spencer for vice chair I'm second you need a motion a second has it turned to Tim aged person nominations do not need a second it's okay if they have them um and but it's fine perfect any other nominations for vice chair I was asking a second time are there any other nominations for vice chair that's our third request hearing none we have a motion by director list and a second by director Cole I can say it that way now for uh director Spencer to be promoted elected as Vice chair all in favor please say I hi hi all pleas
005say nay and the chair votes I and we have a new Vice chair did you guys want to do a seat swap would be good for today okay we we'll make that happen next time next we have on our agenda the election of clerk is anybody interested in nominating themselves or someone else for clerk I would be interested in being clerk if paus does not oppose I would be thrilled to support this Banks cuff Cho as clerk do we have any other nominations for clerk is anybody interested nominate themselves or somebody else for clerk we do the hand wve so we know that we've done our three count looks like a gang sign three looks like Count Dracula you threw it sideways Carter my bad uh so we do we actually need a motion I
006want to go back to him again because you've been here for so a nomination is on opposed it technically doesn't need a vote but so it goes you can treat it as a motion I did second it so you're true so we have a motion by director bank skro and a second by director paus elor police say I hi hi and the chair I and director cro is now Bank sorry is now our clerk our last position Treasurer are there any nominations for treasurer did we have a previous leading candidate for that one I I you know what I didn't take notes on that ironically enough someone's got to do it here okay so we had a fallen Fallen nomination Fallen told Fallen told director list second thank thank you for that I appreciate that
007Dr PA this is Mayhem uh so we have a nomination for treasurer any other nominations for treasurer asking a second time asking for a third time any nominations for treasurer hearing none we have a motion on the floor by director bank scro and a second by director paus all in favor please say I I please say n and the chair votes I and we have a new treasur welcome director dor Liss it's a lot of work saying your names all right well thanks for that that concludes that component of the agenda and it brings us to our first item of business to prove the agenda before us as approval of the agenda is routine business I will briefly pause to see if there are any comments or questions regarding the agenda hearing none is anybody
008prepared to move the agenda as presented I move to approve the agenda as presented second second wow guys on fire we have a motion by director Cole and a second by director Banks cro any final discussion I'm assuming none all in favor please say I I all close please say a and the chair vs I and the agenda is approved we move on to the next agenda item which is information and proposals non action items um we don't have public comic tonight correct um thank you just a reminder that our next opportunity for public comment will be at our board meeting on Tuesday not Monday January 21st 2025 now on to superintendent we ask all right items on the superintendent report um the second of which will be Mr Holi and the where we are
009in enrollment but the first thing on the agenda tonight I'm excited to call up uh stem principal woods and her fantabulous team of staff and students to come on up to the microphone so just work your way up to the microphone at that front little table push the button until the green goes on and then we will be excited to hear from our stem student leaders principal and staff we'll pause while they transition good evening board my name is Kelly Woods I'm the proud P principal of richal Stem Elementary and I am honored to be here with um my team Mr McMillan and Mrs giron and then also our wonderful students Quinn West and miam coma and we are here today to talk about student leadership and um just encouraging student voice with within our
010school and it's just really nice for the students I was talking to them about having the student Representatives here all three of you um and just told them that's something they could aspire to do um when they get in high school so the first thing um we would like to talk about is just the reason why um we have a student leadership group and when I came to stem last year so maybe Mr McMillan might want to speak to this as well um there was already a student leadership group at at stem um and one of the things that really um impressed me was that the group was all about really increasing student voice so that's one of the goals at our school is just really increasing student voice and having our older students our
011student leaders in the building um just have opportunities to be a part of the leadership group um and just really giving them opportunity to develop their leadership skills um and I know that in their meetings that they have that is a big focus of that and how they can become leaders and how they can also impact um The Learning Community and the environment in which they attend every single day um and being a positive role model and also having a positive impact on um the climate at school as well as really thinking about ways that they can have some influence on um maybe getting any feedback from their classmates and how they can um impact even learning that's happening or instruction within the school um so with that I'll just say that at the beginning
012of the year we are invited Mr melmans who is our Dino students and myself are invited we get an invitation um for Mr McMillan to come and Mrs gton to attend student leadership to just hear um what they have to say and for them to also um get some ideas of maybe some areas that we might want to talk about um and that group is really um fourth and fifth graders that are encouraged to participate so all fifth fourth and fifth graders who are interested are encouraged to I guess apply um they fill out um a form to say that they want to be a part of student leadership um and they really have to be in interested in being involved in the community um and really wanting to increase student schoolwide um events that
013happen so that's some things that they work on and really increasing decision making and things that happen um I don't know if either of you want to talk about this but they meet your meeting schedule we meet wednes it's not just for us it's for the millions watching at home uh so um this is formerly known as student council we took the student council part of it because uh we thought student council was kind of a popularity thing you know where they voted in class and whoever the most popular kid end up being the leadership so we open it up to everybody that was interested and becoming a better leader so we limited it to fourth and fifth grade ERS uh we meet from the start of uh November to all the way to the
014end of the school year at least twice a month on Wednesdays uh or whenever we don't have a staff meeting or something uh and we talk about we always have a task uh Miss giron does a fantastic job of making sure that we have a task and I do more of the leadership piece of what it means to be a leader uh what type of leader you can be how to communicate with different people and also as well uh hold yourself accountable so they have uh couple requirements that are kind of maybe tough um you have to attend at least 85 or 90% of the meetings that we have throughout the school year um you also have to uh do volunteer work um it's 20 to 25 sessions uh and they and I'll let Miss
015Geron talk a little bit more about that uh and then we also have to uh participate in a schoolwide project last year was our first year we didn't follow through with it but we did a a student leadership sip plan as well too a school Improvement plan uh we didn't get to that as uh this year because we had a lot of other stuff that we wanted to try to accomplish as well too so that is kind of the criteria for being that and then we don't make no judgment of who's there we hold them accountable uh for their leadership throughout the school and I think what but and I she probably has more data or information this but it also decreases behavior issues as well too because you're getting held accountable by your peer
016as well as peers can be a part of the student leadership as well too so miss G I said you because you kind of make the you kind of made the volunteer schedule and I know how much you like talking on the microphone um so this is my uhing student leadership with Mr McMillan um the kids uh kind of put some voice into where they would like to volunteer this year um and we work with kindergarten first and second grade teachers um as well as Specialists um this year we also added the cafeteria and um the the custodial staff and the media center as is that they're able to volunteer um so they're assigned a specific spot um and they go one or two times a week and um they have a form that they're
017filling out so they're really responsible they know that they're in charge of um having to have that and making sure that the teacher signs it um and they've really seem to enjoy it um they also are um in charge of giving announcements to classes um so kids are assigned to a specific uh class and they'll go out um and tell them about some activities that we're doing in school thank you so with that um I just want to you to be able to hear from the stars of the of the night um and have our student leaders um we will have um Mariam miam sorry miam coma talk about volunteering hello my name is maram coma and I'm a fifth grader at stem I've been a student since third grade and this is my second
018year of being a member at student leadership I wanted to join student leadership because I'm already a leader at home for my young siblings and I also wanted to be involved in student leadership this year because I had good experience last year I like helping others student leadership has have have the privilege to volunteer and work with other students we like mentoring the students young students we can volunteer in cafeterias doing morning announcements or helping students I volunteer in the music class in music class and I hope the teacher passed out materials and I talk to the students in the class and get to know them know them this helps them feel connected to the school and Community I love being part of student leadership because I like helping the school and connecting with other
019students who are not my age or not my grade thank you for letting us share about our student leadership group Next we will have Quinn West who will talk about doing um her why she wants to be a student leader and then morning announcements hello my name is Quinn West and I am a fourth grader at stem I have been at stem since prek and I am also a member of the student leadership group I wanted to join student leadership because I wanted to be the first in my family to be a school leader I also joined because I wanted to help out the school I wanted to help make the school a better place for students we have a very big school and this year we wanted to connect Everyone by doing morning announcements
020we do the all School morning announcements every day at 7:30 we share upcoming events what's for lunch and we also give shout outs to students and staff our families teachers and students can give shoutouts to people we also share tips on how we can be safe kind and responsible for the day one project we will work on this year is improving our Courtyard so classrooms learn outside and can use it more often thank you for allowing us to share about student leadership so one thing that I'm very proud of these two students but just spending time um listening to why they wanted to be student leaders um was it it really um I shared this with the the two staff members but it just really touched me because of um they're two of 20 a
021group of 25 um students within our school and um they just really it just their heart to me speaks of like their pride of the school and how much they love helping and wanting to create a um as as she says a better um Community um for for students and making sure one thing that came out is connection and as you know stem is very large and so um just that they really want to take it upon themselves of making um our community feel a little smaller and then um creating a a sense of community in our building so I really I also want to add one more thing I did get feedback from teachers and just the impact of having the student Volunteers in their classroom um I had a teacher share that um
022she has a student that um needs a lot of movement so he gets to have movement breaks with the student leader um volunteer Mentor um and they listen to um the student listens to him read I think Quinn didn't share that either but she also listens to second graders read but it's really just building this connection between the younger and older students so I just wanted to highlight our student leadership group this month so thank you thank you for that I personally want to say good job guys principal W so quick to jump in it's like we want to clap you guys for stepping up to the mic you guys did a great job so thank you for that questions comments from the board yes I love that you call it student leadership as opposed
023to student councel because you guys are the leaders of your school you're the example you know you're setting the example for the little kids and if they see a good behavior not Behavior but a good academic leader in their classrooms hopefully they'll aspire to that so I like I like that you call it student leadership as opposed to student council however student council is usually helps make policy you know or or put in suggestions to The Faculty do they do that I mean when it affects them yeah could get to the microphone throughout the school building and then we uh write those things up and then we submit those to Mrs woods and she'll oftentimes bring these up at the staff meetings or things like that or we'll share emails uh we have taught them
024how to write emails as well too to their corresponding teacher uh so when we have things like that we kind of send out things to the staff thank you well I love this so much and I loved how organized and prepared you were for tonight's meeting I think that shows a tremendous amount of leadership because you two were the representatives for the student leadership group and you showed up and you showed out so way to go all right um and I absolutely positively love this model because it to me is um reminds me of the page Education Foundation model very much in terms of the um volunteer aspect and um the servant Leadership Model which is near and dear to my heart um so thank you so much for everything that you're doing because you're
025the big kids in the school so all the younger kids they're looking at you like whoa they're so big they're so cool I hope I'm like them when I get older and I get to do student leadership so they're definitely paying attention to you so what you do matters big time so thank you for being such a good role model and keep up the great work um and I'd love to come hang out sometime and see you all in action would that be cool if I stop by yeah okay cool thanks for coming tonight and sharing with us all the good work you're doing I want to comment uh beginning with the students I am so inspired by your leadership your your courage uh and really your willingness to make the world around you a
026better place beginning with your school I'm sure you uh also started at your house um so thank you for that I also want to uh give a shout out to Mr McMillan bringing the initiative to make it a student leadership group and also to our principal for welcoming staff input into changing the things so I I I think what makes richf a a really good place for our kids is our willingness to work together and to really collaborate and nothing think so much about uh the bureaucracy but really understanding how things are are happening I I had the pleasure having my child in Mr McMillan's class and I can just see how this is just one of the many ways to continue that uh environment uh that I was able to see in your classroom
027room and how your students collaborated with each other and I'm glad that them gets to now see that uh experience uh happening throughout throughout the school so thank you and thank you parents for supporting uh your kids also okay and then one comment I'd like to add is that you guys are very confident and Brilliant students I'm like really proud of you guys for like showing that good role model you guys are really great role models um not only that but like the you guys volunteer it's like you're building that connection with other students and I feel like that's something that like lasts forever you're going to keep doing that even as you get older like whether you're getting a job you know just like connecting with um different people from different backgrounds it's like
028I think it's beautiful and amazing that you guys are getting like a head start or an early start to with connecting with other students so yeah great job to you guys any more comments or back don't have to just one if I may um uh so echoing those uh the comments that were made before really proud of you kids coming forward tonight and it's it's not hard to come it's not easy to come and speak into a microphone um thank you to the the teachers um Miss girton and Mr McMillan for for leading this um group I love the model of having student leadership and the comments you made Mr McMillan around um bringing in students that are interested in leadership rather than a popularity contest I think is a really key way to make
029sure that we're inclusive in those who want to lead so appreciate that um I did have one question because I understand this is an after school activity and I'm curious if um there's been um either barriers or we've had opportunities to remove barriers from students that maybe can't stay after school or is there rides home that look like I think for the years that we have been doing this parents have been very receptive to picking those their kids up after school um or car pulling to make sure that uh kids have a ride after school so we haven't seen too much of that uh I do want to say this and she she probably going to kick me after we done um uh you know the after school activity does require like snacks and different
030things like that and Miss gon does a fantastic ftic job of going out and making sure that the kids have something to eat after school as well too um and sometimes people don't always see uh that you have a facilitator that's willing to dig deep into her Pockets to make sure the kids have what they have um so that's one of the barriers that you might have if we don't you know that after school snack can be kind of a problem sometimes unless you got a Sam's Club membership or something there she I just want to add on to that one thing that we considered this year we offer um dreams Academy which is after school programming on Monday and Wednesdays at stem and um we had a conversation about really connecting um student leadership
031pairing it up with dreams Academy to so it's open for more students because we provide transportation on those days so kids are able to take the bus if they if their families aren't able to come and pick them up they're able to have transportation home that's great thank you thank you again I will say I hope to see you guys up here right in the upcoming you know five six seven years uh to be student Representatives so thank you again appreciate you guys thank you I just notice this is this a prerequisite that I uh you have to be in my class to be a school board member I see like I got like three or four parents up here that had their kids somehow I dodged it thank you all right so drawing the
032shorts draw and following the lovely children and leadership group is Craig Holi talking about where we are in enrollments we thank our group from stem and we move on to business and operations with Holi where we are in EN kid so you know you're on YouTube so you can come back and watch this afterwards I know parents were trying to video from the back but it's going to be up on YouTube it is right now so you can check that out yeah it's on YouTube and the camera was right there so you can click it Forward send friends I do that sometimes I watch myself all right see you stu now very good thank you very much uh tonight we're going to take a look at where we are in enrollment and class sizes specifically
033we're going to drill in a little bit to the number of students that we have in each one of our buildings take a look at um class sizes across the district as well as some of our student demographics um we are going to highlight information from the data that's included in this report but at the end of this report you will find a lot of the details that are connected in with this information um for more specific questions about specific class sizes you'll be able to look at the end of this report really even about how many kids are in how um each one of the seventh grade English classes at the middle school for examp example or stuff like that so um there's a lot of detail included this report we're just going to
034highlight the information here uh so taking a look the first year the multi-year analysis this is something you've had a chance to see before it provides a good snapshot of the number of students um enrolled on October 1 in each one of our buildings at each one of our grade levels and then how that compared to projections and how that compared to last year so a lot of data there just as a reference um and if there are any questions on that um really looking at the next slide here and an overview um in O um as of October 1 we had 4,117 students districtwide in retrial schools uh 3,963 I call our traditional count which excludes our VPK program um 1,739 are at the elementary 813 at the middle um 1,272 at the high
035school and then you can see our pre kindergarten or early childhood special education program and then the transitions Plus um we also have 154 students who are enrolled in the voluntary pre kindergarten program at that point which is about a halfday program for preschool kids um this was 143 students more than what was projected and 44 students actually more than the 23 24 year um so while we've had some gradual declines over the years this was a year that we saw an actual increase in our enrollment um here in Richfield schools um comparing that to last year you'll see we're up 44 students this breaks it down a little bit by the grade levels here you were down 43 students at ecse so pretty consistent but up 54 students at the elementary up 16 students
036at Richfield Middle School down 55 students at Richfield High School which was partially offset by being up 23 students at Richfield or the RP program or Richfield college experience um so there's a slight decline at our 9 through 12 programming this is primarily due to some transitions of the grade levels where we had some larger grade levels graduating at the 12th grade level and some smaller grade levels coming in at nth grade um the next slide shows a multi-year analysis of since 2007 so a real historic look at this um you'll see in 2016 there's a blue bar that was added to this that is when we added our VPK programming or our voluntary pre kindergarten programming so we separated that out to show from um the students that previously would have been enrolled in
037our traditional um K through2 programming and then there's a little gray bar that's in each one of those um after that date those are students who kind of cross over between Early Childhood special education but are also in the VPK program as well um so just showing that 154 students at VPK 18 in kind of that crossover program and 3,945 in the traditional K through2 programming uh next taking a look at Elementary class sizes uh you can see we're at 2 24.15 for the average kindergarten through fifth grade elementary class size really relatively consistent since 2018 um you'll just note that in 2017 we had almost 26 per class we're at about 24 per class or just over 24 um in 2017 the voters referendum approved increasing funding specifically targeting reduced class sizes so you
038can see that we've held true towards that commitment of reducing class sizes since 2017 uh the next slide shows that breakdown by and kind of a trend history by each one of our buildings um each one of our buildings had an increase in the class sizes this year primarily due to that increased enrollment that was unanticipated um so we were able to um keep our target class sizes within range but and still add those additional um students into those programs um and then the next slide is just a little cleaner slide looking at this year again really relatively consistent across all buildings between 23 and a half and 24.6 five for our average class sizes at each one of those Elementary buildings uh next slide takes a look at our six through eight um programming
039or our middle school program here you can see our average class size is also at 24 .19 this year um in 2017 that was at 2 27.8 so again below that um commitment to be reducing our class sizes below that area and relatively consistent or up slightly from last year and then at the high school um we're at 26.0 two which is up a little bit from last year but down from previous years and since 2017 that was at 28.6 eight so again um down below that um target from the 2017 referendum uh the next couple slides take a look at um some Trends um so the Middle School class siiz Trends the yellow bar is the um current year for 2425 and this shows the number of sections per class size so the um
040left hand column or the vertical is is the number of sections at each one of those class sizes and then the horizontal is the number of students in each section so you can see on that yellow bar we have a few classes that are below 15 um but relatively flat um once we get at the 18 and above with very few I think it looks like one section at 35 Plus um but again um up slightly in those number of sections above 30 at the middle school but still um with then kind of where we would be hoping to be when we look at our average class sizes um and then the next slide just is another way to look at it with bars um you can see it's relatively consistent with the number of
041those that are at that blue bar um 30 55 versus 56 um but a few more in the upper group of 30 plus and a few more in the lowest group of less than 20 um in those sections looking at the high school similarly you can see a relatively consistent um line here when we look at the trend and Trend history um on that far right though one of our goals was to get the number of sections that are above 35 down um 2122 is that gray or 21 22 is the Red Bar 22 23 is the gray bar um but you can see 23 24 and 24 25 are relatively consistent between those two where we have fewer than 20 sections that are at those higher levels of 34 and 35 um and then
042the again just a similar look at that just people like bars versus graphs line graphs and things like that so um next we're going to move on and take a look at who is in our student or the demographics of our student population looking at student diversity um first of all 7.73% of our students identify as bipo um you can see since 20 14 that is a really consistent trend line um with just slight variations within about a percent or two um so real consistent in that student diversity um similarly within the English language learner again relatively consistent we have 24.7% of our students um that identify as English language Learners um which has really been consistent since about 2016 you'll see a fairly large drop between 2015 and 2016 that wasn't because the number
043of students had dropped but because the identification process as far as who qualified for elll services um changed during that year and so that's the reason for that change um but then you can see it's relatively consistent across that board with um a slight decline since 2016 2017 um up slightly from last year but really pretty consistent when we look at overall demographics um free and reduced enrollment this this is an area that we are watching carefully um you can see that we're at 53% um students that identifies with free and reduced um education benefit eligibility um this is down from 57% last year and 62% the previous year this is dropping back down into the co years with the free lunch programs and things like that so one of the things that we anticipate
044is that the identification process is significantly different now that we're offering free meals so one of the the um one of the um unintended consequences I think of the free meal program which we greatly appreciate is that we see this um reduced identification of free and reduced um from a financial standpoint this really ties in with our compensatory funding so we're watching that carefully as far as how the state will be analyzing it um right now we are projecting significant decreases in our compensatory funding for next year but we haven't seen updated projections from the state but our internal numbers using um the formulas would show that um we're down significantly in that compensatory funding so we're going to be watching how that is in place um that's obviously part of our legislative platform as
045a school district um to make sure that that benefit of the free meals isn't negatively impacting districts like Richfield schools can I I'm sorry can I just ask a question quickly is part of it I don't know how like down in the weeds we've gotten about that but are we asking that they track like a couple years back at least so that they can see that there's probably been some consequences unintended consequences of identification related to the funding yeah I mean we we clearly have this data um and we know that the state has that data specifically um are you asking like in as far as well who because sorry right I mean basically if if the data for just like say 2024 is going to be looked at that's not going to you know
046that's that's only going to tell part of the story so what I'm saying is if as a part of our legislative platform if in there we can say hey like you know last year is not going to be a complete telling of the story it would make more sense if we are looking Statewide at you know multiple years to show that everyone one is dealing with this yeah definitely um we we are definitely sharing this information with organizations like amsd and msba in their legislative efforts they are specifically seeking out some of this information as well um so our our partners at the capital are aware of the issue or aware of the concern um and I've been working with um Scott kist at DS specifically to make sure that he's he's seen the analysis
047that we're doing and how we're driving it and how some of the even legislative changes um with how compensatory funding is going to be in place really is not going to be positively impacting districts like Richfield schools that have traditionally received larger amounts of compensatory funding um will have an adverse impact on the district so yes we're working with them yes we're sharing the data okay um I mean I imagine the governor is aware of this based upon the fact that his you know in-laws are all still teachers and probably have been you know have brought this to light and you know I'm just curious if that we are all kind of moving in that direction of addressing that so yes can you answer my question I think I think the storyline you're you're teasing
048at here and we've talked about this is that change from 21 to 22 where it went from lunches are free to they're not free and the dramatic jump in people that are filling out the free and reduced lunch paperwork and how that is gone back down it's not because our population has changed no right exactly because yes if you look at 2022 and then you look at 2024 I mean that's that's pretty significant and it's not that's that's not an accurate telling of the story unless yes you're like talking about all multiple years here right yeah so thank you thanks um next we're we'll kind of move on and take a look at the students who are choosing to come to Richfield um the students who live in Richfield and who are choosing to go
049other places and kind of um summaries of some of that information as well again there's a lot more details so the if you're looking at this chart and expect the overall total to fully add up it doesn't fully add up um on this chart because there's a bunch of data that's not included in this snapshot here um first of all open enrollment this is when students choose to enroll in um Richfield schools from another Community or enroll in another Community from Richfield um so you can see on the right is the 2425 data um we have 7006 students who enrolled in open enrolled into Richfield schools 779 students who open enrolled out of um Richfield schools to other districts um the primary districts that we see open enrollment Trends with are pretty obvious going to
050be our neighbors so Bloomington um Edina and Minneapolis are the largest of those uh districts where we have open enrollment Trends um in addition to Burnsville um uh Burnsville Rose mountain in St Paul um sec shows up here as an open enrollment but it's actually a partner of Richfield school so we're we're the fiscal host for South Education Center Alternative Program so in the spring those students actually become Richfield students on our official books and things like that but in October they are considered open and rolled out um so most of those students at SCC tend to be Richfield resident students um but that's just an anomaly on that section in there um so net impact last year we had about 80 we had a net positive of 83 open enrolled students into the district
051um this year our net is ative 73 so there are more students that open enrolled out of Richfield schools than into Richfield schools this year uh the next slide shows that Trend history again you can see there's wide variations of changes in 12 it spiked up and then it kind of dropped down and then there's been a peak in a valley and a peak in a valley so not a lot of consistency there for us to be able to really track and see like what are the reasons for that um those variations and changes and things like that um next taking a look at non-public and charter schools so non-public schools are going to be those private schools or homeschool so we have 439 total students that are um Richfield residents um that are enrolled
052in non-public schools um the largest of those are Blessed Trinity um interestingly the second largest is homeschool students um so not a formal public or non-public school but homeschooled student programming and then Holy Angels which is obviously also in the Richfield school district and then some neighboring chryst Ray and and Annunciation um for Charter Schools um we have 807 total students um in charter schools this was a decrease of 46 students from 23 24 and and again you can see it's going to primarily be those within our community of Seven Hills prep and partnership Academy are the largest of the two um along with Hokies and Eagle Ridge Academy um scitec and Horizon Academy um so those are some snapshots there and then finally we take a look at kind of trying to encapsulate all
053of those enrollment options into a retain Richfield um this takes a look at our open enrollment out and our Charter nonpublic um factors those in tied with the Richfield Schools Enrollment and then the Open Enrollment in which we pull out of our Richfield Public Schools Enrollment to figure out how many actual Richfield residents are attending Richfield school so this year that's 3,411 which is up from 3,264 last year and then the total Richfield residence students um is also up um from to 5400 from 5200 so our market share is a slight increase this year of 62.75 compared to 61.6 3 from last year uh again in the packet there is a whole lot of detail that we can dig in if you want to um look at some of those details or if there are
054other questions I'm happy to respond to those questions as well thank you for all that detail there a lot questions I'll that our open enes probably a we open affects where we once we inbound at correct microphone I just uh the totality of my comment was that the uh the Open Enrollment we did vote to close close in so it's it's at a low point in part because of that action as well as the regular EB and flow um question I have not necessarily for you to answer today but maybe we can get some followup um from um the high school as I look kind of deep into the numbers at the middle school and the high school it seems like the Middle School most of those larger classes are the electives the gyms the
055um consumer sciences and health kind of classes but at the high school um there's a good number of core classes that have 30 plus students in them um and in some cases that's just fine in other cases that's a concern and I I'd just like to hear some feedback maybe from the high school on um you know whether uh leaders at the high school are concerned about some of those larger class sizes that are Core Curriculum we can check with principal uh Collins and and gather some follow other questions guess it's my turn then um page 20 and um I always think about people who look at the deck after the fact uh it would be valuable I think it was unclear uh the axes um what was what and that hearing you talk right
056it's um sections on the left class SI on the right or on the right on the bottom really good map got it um so but I figured it out based on kind of what you're saying um on 32 page 32 with the um the question that Kirk had asked earlier about um or I guess Rich Kirk both talking about the um free and reduced enrollment we was there a point in which we didn't track I mean it's like during Co we didn't track as well right I mean the whole as it dipped down as you watch free go from 60% down to 50% in 2021 were we not tracking or were was there less forms or different forms um so what we found is as fewer families were filling out the education benefits form mhm
057so when the form is tied to free meals more families were participating in filling out the education benefits form when those free meals went into play um both during covid and we also believe here during the most recent years um there are fewer families that have that immediate need to fill out the education benefit form because of that direct relation to the meals um isn't necessarily in that same connection so um we believe it's just that incentive tied in with the free meals versus realizing that there are some other education benefits like reduced um athletic fees and things like that that are part of it um so our teams at each one of our buildings do a lot of work reaching out to families to really encourage that completion of the form if they at
058all think that they're eligible um um for that um it has been by no means a reduced effort on the part of the district or us not tracking um because we have work to get those forms completed um so these reductions come even with diligent work at each one of our buildings reaching out to families and parents to get the forms completed um part of it um more recently it's offset a little bit because there's some direct certifications that are now eligible um or there are some increased numbers of direct certifications that are tyed in with those um education benefits qualifications um but it still is not at that same level and the eligibility under direct CT um is not the same eligibility um through the traditional Federal program um maybe I'm not ask my
059question right and I guess the point I'm trying to make is that uh I'm trying to understand if there's other factors which I think you just talked to some that that are impacting the the stats and I mean Kirk kind of said that it's like we know that from a population perspective it didn't we didn't have a big change in population then it didn't happen overnight or based with the school year so just as I'm thinking about you going around and I appreciate that you're sharing the data with other people is what other messaging are we giving and if we just take this graph this graph alone on kind of page um page 32 it's what message is it saying and does there need to be other context other than like I always worry like
060does somebody take a graph like this and just run around and go look here's the data right it's like without the context and like how do you explain that context with there aren't any notes or like what conclusion am I am I brought to with this graph so maybe it One impact that we might be able to tease out of this is did eligibility change in the last four years right did the did the floor stay the same and people through making just a quarter more 50 cents more a dollar more an hour pass through that threshold and they're no longer in the free and reduced um cap um is that kind of what you're asking like are there other factors that might be reducing that number it um if we don't think that the
061population changed in Richfield it um this is showing people who filled out the form right I mean I guess um it's showing those who are eligible so it's those who fill out the form but it also includes the direct certifications yeah um that get communicated to the district from the state right so so there's a there's a period on here probably through through well pre-co it was all forms alone I believe then we had covid when things went crazy and meals were provided for free then we had 2022 where they were not going to be free and we worked really hard to make sure that everyone filled in the forms and I think in the aftermath of that then we started the direct we I believe the the direct certification started in the last two
062years as well as now free for free for everyone the direct certification is so if you receive um State assistance of a Kind like medical assistance or things like that you your family is automatically qualified for free and reduceed lunch you don't have to fill out this additional form and those are the the members that that Mr hoi is saying we are told about so there there's a population that we are told about there's a population that has to fill out the forms then there's a population We Believe used to fill out the forms and is choosing not to because it's it's very personal and private and they don't know where it goes and they're getting the free lunch so so what does it matter so so from where they sit it doesn't matter and
063I guess that's um maybe it's that aspect of you know it's like here's Co right right so we could add some some footnotes to this slide if you're concerned is someone takes this slide and says it looks like the district's doing a lot better because we used to be 62% free and rud Lune now we're 52 so a significant portion of the population has now risen Above This threshold of whatever it means right when we don't believe it's it's real correct right and that's love to believe it's real but I don't but also the district May deem somebody eligible when you may not qualify for state benefits too so it's not the same thing right so does that make sense so you you can huh what do you mean so say for example okay well
064this isn't even a for example my hours were reduced at my job so now I I don't know for sure but I may qualify for benefits through the state and so if so facto then I would automatically then qualify for the free and reduced let's just say for example the state didn't pay for it that automatically would qualify me now let's say for example my hours hadn't been reduced but I was making a different amount of money than by the district standards perhaps then I would qualify for free and reduce based upon making a lower amount of money even if by the state standards I wouldn't qualify for benefits right the state that for benefits you have to meet a certain threshold either in hours or in like um amount of money you take in
065annually and that threshold is crazy it's it's pretty crazy and so I I mean Through The Years here even I have met the threshold for the district but not the state and the treasure for the district is also for the state it's just that there's a different rubric for health benefits food the district for the state is also for the district it's not necessarily for the district it's also for the state the the threshold for the state is much higher right and so that's what I'm saying that the district has a threshold what I mean is not to say it's not a Richfield set number it's a stay set number so the state has a a the state sets a a cap for some things and then it sets a cap for you know for
066meals at school at a different way so I think for us was what what I'm hearing is that the automatic certifications bringing some of the numbers in to us right because let's say that you you you might qualify and choose not to apply for state benefits but if you apply for the school free and reduce form then that family will be getting that um and I know that in conversations from before we have said how challenging it is for some families uh especially because of immigration to to to decide to fill out this form so then it's like the benefits to not the probably consequences so I just want to share that because sometimes it's like oh you know I don't have to do that I don't get the free food but it's not it's
067not something often done lightly of course um and that's yeah it's not what you said I'm just going backtracking on like things that I heard before I understand where you're going with that and I cut myself off before I said something in response to it is all so yes yes I get your stream of thought that that has been an issue why some people don't fill out forms like that and why some people don't their status is why they don't apply for benefits is that is that what I hear you saying yes okay yes I yeah I understood what you were what you were saying with that so so so Mr Carter I just separate from the discussion we're having about who who does and doesn't but I think this slide is is in need
068of a couple of footnotes so someone doesn't take it out of context and misconstrue something I mean there's a couple easy things to to that we could build into it you know just sort of to to demarcate where of course Co and then um you know the the 2022 legislation yeah the the the legislation actions right whether it was free lunches or the the direct qualification and then you know those I think those are probably the most seismic kinds of things and then then of course the overall concern relates to the the the mention uh Miss Banks cupo made earlier about you know what what are we doing about this and it is later in our legislative platform stuff so so thank you for that discussion uh the other question um 20% swing um on
069the enrollment options on the next Slide the this and I think I think we talked about this before and we talked about potentially like how do we show percentages I mean you know we're talking about numbers here and I appreciate your comment Tim about the um the reminding us that we capped enrollment right and the fact that it's like does that change the number inverses right the overall the change for the the year um a 20% swing seems like a lot and it's how far back do we track this again or have we've been tracking this um we there on the next thank you yeah and we actually have more history than this if we go back through all the board packets I think this is been going since the 80s or 90s Soh and
070just out K have you looked at I mean is that Trend it's like where we're 100 100 out kind of year over year I mean there have been those anomalies if you look at 11 12 12 13 up down you look at uh 2021 2122 22 23 23 24 you can see um it does lead to questions of reporting um um are are all districts reporting open enrollment in open enrollment out effectively to the state um if they are um then there is some volatility in those numbers particularly in the last four or five four years or so and and again back 15 years ago also definitely interesting I I don't have a question it's more just trying to understand I mean I think I'm kind of been the one bugging about like how do
071we your what did you call it I thought it was a great way to call it the um investment in Richfield or the market share that word um so I think that's good I think it's interesting we're tracking how do we how do we increase it um then the last comment I had is just on page 36 I think that's interesting as a graph too of like looking at what is our market share number look like so you have 73% and as we're down to 62% how does that number continue to fluctuate I mean the downward trend is concerning and how do we just increase it so and that answer but yeah and you see in 2022 we start then to move ourselves back upwards so yes you did have that that one Trend and
072now moving slightly the other direction but yeah hopefully yes Hope well 22 23 23 24 are going that direction slowly right more questions comments I'll just say for a comment for for other board members um you can spend a lot of time digging through this this report and others right it's it's kind of like our audit report in that there's just so much stuff buried in the details that you can learn about in terms of how the makeup of our students and over time it's really important I think to to there are parts of it that are really helpful to understand so if you have extra time to to dive into the um the just the the Deep detail that's here I I would encourage you to do so it takes a I mean it's
073it takes a long time to get familiar with this report you also um you can find there could be footnotes on many of the slides like on this slide that we just had up 22 for example um you could track that to uh schools opening uh different schools different Charters uh schools expanding um providing different options um then impacting Us in terms of enrollment or Charters moving um and each of those having different different impacts indirectly or directly I'll offer up if any board member wants to sit down and look at all of the details in there I love it so happy to sit down with anybody that wants to go through the pages that are behind the presentation that try to do a snapshot of the information that's in there well Kirk when you
074and uh greig talk you let us know how it goes this is Kirk's round two with it because he's on fiscal planning so we looked at this in December we can read whatever we want into the data exactly it's what is the data telling us right right well that's the question you can tell stor sorry any more questions or comments thank you for that appreciate it that brings us to the consent agenda uh which contains a collection of routine and fairly routine business items that we consent to pass in bulk without individual discussion I'll pause for a moment to see if there any questions or requests before we proceed hearing none is there a motion to approve the consent agenda as presented I will move the consent agenda as presented I'll second that we have
075a motion to approve the consent agenda by director Banks Cal and by director Liss any more discussion all in favor please say I I I all post please say n chair votes I and the consent agenda is approved tonight we have policies before us for review and possible action actually not policies but we have information for review in action tonight the First on our list is policy 414 staff professional boundaries all right so we are looking at read four not asking for passage of our professional boundaries uh policy 414 um and guidelines then 4141 and 4142 and so we did split it up based on some feedback into a suggested policy with um two guidelines to go along with it uh we continue to get feedback anticipate to continue that forward in the coming uh
076month or so and then also um coordinate with our attorney and the attorney for some of our labor groups to make sure that our language is clear um and again this is a new policy there are msba model policies but we continue to really try to refine uh around staff professional boundaries making sure that we are supporting our staff and then also supporting our community cultivating those respectful and professional relationships and this policy talks about um how do we put our best foot forward and how do we also at the same time protect ourselves and our students by clarifying the boundaries of professionalism uh we do have that additional input in here I'm not going to walk through all of those changes today uh the big change is moving things from um a policy um
077and then you have guideline in regard to the best practices for building positive relationships which is been moved out it's really around behaviors and those are often revised um as a guideline and then ALS Al tutoring of students which is also that other guideline so we have that in uh almost like a first read again uh because it's that uh policy and to guidelines we do have a little bit of input and questions that we've gotten and we will continue to revise as we bring that forward so with that I will pause see if there are other things for tonight otherwise just know that we continue to work on this looks like we're good to bring it back back later which brings us to our legislative platform and looks like you want approval tonight uh
078yes our hope is to finalize this as a reminder we have a study session in two weeks at our next board meeting with our elected officials to talk about the things that we are uh most focused on and so you'll see um there is a set of keys in here including things that are highlighted in blue on this draft that are the same from last year's legislative platform you'll see um one two and three things aligned to the legislative platforms of our partners we have walked through all of these before so I don't plan on walking through them again but you'll see um starting on page 92 um we'll say those are the additional notes document and so some of the additional information or things we talked about as possible footnotes for example during Co
079free and reduced eligibility what we just kind of talked about dropped by 9% uh we continue to have that drop and its impact on compensatory education so looking for that long-term of that um and so you'll see that backup data on pages 92 93 and 94 of the packet um which we would share in our conversation um if we are able to pass that platform so with that I will pause and see if there are questions comments or a motion let got for deep in discussion for tonight and when we share it will be the just the one pager right correct and then the bullet points will be for us and we'll use those um as we plan our interaction with our legislators uh we'll plan that dialogue um and we'll use those bullet points
080to talk it through is there a motion I move to approve the policy has [Music] presented I'll second like to we're deep in thought do we want discussion this or are we good to go to approve the legislative platform no discussion no discussion wasn't sure everybody so quiet all a sudden um we have a motion by director Cole and a second by director PA to approve the legislative platform all in favor please say I I all oppos please say n the chair votes I and the legislative platform is approved that brings us to the preschool sliding scale fee again uh yes so this is returning from our last meeting uh just as a reminder we approved in concept um with um the understanding that we would bring back data and so we want to highlight
081the yellow components uh the backup there was a couple of typos or clarifications that needed to be um informed in regard to income guidelines and we also uh provided that formula and then also board members um had expressed an interest in seeing comparison um to other districts and what other districts are charging from a price perspective in their sliding scill so you'll note that our sliding scale proposed um is lower um than our surrounding districts um and then we also did clarify um these are the federal poverty guidelines so the the sliding scale level one is 185% of the federal poverty guideline level two is 240 um and level three is then above that and we did fix those and you'll note the yellow highlights um clarify that information so we appreciate board members for
082capturing that um and wanted to make sure that we brought that back so board members could see and then approve the plann fees for uh students who would have to pay for voluntary prean so just as a reminder um we talked talked about at our last meeting is the state changed the guidelines for voluntary prek um qualifying for free voluntary precare free four-year-old School programming means you had to meet one of the qualifications that um is defined at risk very similar to targeted services or summer school those could in include poverty um those could include um El status those could include a wide range of components or being in um not prepared quite yet for kindergarten or kindergarten entry and so we are working our way through that um and so the students who didn't
083qualify then they would be they would be charged on that sliding scale and so I have that for questions otherwise um generally we do put fees past the board for a motion um and so we would hope that the board would add the sliding scale fees to the Motions from last last meeting um given the recent conversation about free and reduced lunch and who's applying to that I'm curious if the eligibility of free and reduced is isn't the same paperwork for this as it is for free and reduced lunch uh it is the same paperwork yes um in summer school and after school I believe there are 13 categories by which somebody can qualify so there is a wide range um and then there is the district defined at risk and so we have defined
084an assessment so for students who are not being self-identified as qualifying in one of other categories um they can choose to then pay um or opt for an assessment the assessment would determine from a social emotional mathematic or reading perspective if the student was at entry level for kindergarten um as a four-year-old um if they were not yet at entry level because that's the definition of the program and why we're there uh they would then be defined at risk and would qualify for free uh VPK um and so it's a very liberal interpretation of how we provide that free programming um to as many students as possible I think we asked or talked about this last time how how do families get notified of that what you just said um and so we have our
085VPK application um which indicates right now that there will be a possible charge or sliding scale and then once the board passes this we will put that communication out uh people apply for prek um they are then notified if they are in or not um at which point our district will communicate with them um and Dr Clarkson's here to provide any other tangal details that'll support good evening um yes we have a whole um application process and then we have staff right at um Community aded The Early Childhood office that contact all of the families and go through that whole process so it's new um and we've had limited um direction from the state uh and so um we have it communicate it'll be communicated within the application process and within the community aded book
086that ad it through so adverti through the community ed book it it lists that in there and then it has contact information um this was in this is also shared at kindergarten enrollment or kindergarten kickoff you have a question on your face Mr yeah I still feel like it's a followup of what kind Kirk was asking originally of like so um if I as a family so so I may know that there's educational benefits or depending on U Financial qualifications that I can kind of ballpark where I'm going to be at my question is more around if a family Steve had said that there were other factors that might allow a family to to get free benefits how does that family know right until they they have to apply first and then they're told that
087they're no the factors that qualify you are on the application factors that qualify you are on the application and then um and then if you don't think you meet any of those you can choose i' like to sign up for the optional assessment or I don't want to got it and then that will start we'll start doing those Assessments in like February March but we say that right on the form and when you put it into the the advertisement it does on your website on the website it yeah and on the form if you do it by paper yeah so there's a website an early childhood web page that has all of that information once this has been passed that'll be posted for families fantastic more questions I I believe that when we met a
088couple weeks ago the reason why we passed kind of everything but the schedule of fees was that you were already publishing information and people were able to sign up have we had people already sign up is there any risk for people being surprised that oh I thought I was signing up for something that was free no no we still put all the the language in there we just did not publish the sliding skill okay um so we even put the fee like the max Fe a family would pay is this okay but we don't have the actual income breakdowns and the the different fee levels published anywhere okay since that wasn't passed but they do know their yeah good thank you more questions discussion or we ready for a motion I'll move the the fee
089sliding scale as presented I'll second fantastic we have a motion by director paus to approve the preschool sliding scale fee in a second by director Spencer any more discussion I think we probably discussed it out all in favor please say I I I all oppos pleas say a chair votes I and the preschool sliding scalp is approved that brings us on to new business all right so as is our practice the first meeting uh we do a viewing renew or uh review of represented school and then the next one will be board liaison assignments um represent a school we like to check in with people just remind them the school that they have chosen to represent for the 24 years see if anybody is interested in changing here input in feedback and then I can
090coordinate with people uh if people want to stay that is also absolutely lovely um but um just making sure people have that opportunity to share that before we take motions and finalize that later in January any thoughts on represent a school from our folks I would like to stay I'll be happy to continue my assignment unless somebody really wants one of them word it differently is anyone really interested in in a new opportunity because the other one was so good you want to share it I'm certainly open um if someone wants any of the assignments that I have um are we talking school and schol at the moment represent a school at the moment there are some forced changes within liaison because there's a couple staff that have changed um so we'll be changing some
091of those out but that is a much broader group I'm also happy with both of mine but if someone's like oh all right hearing nothing oh you have okay hearing nothing on represented school I'll just double check with people this will probably come back then with the same list um at our next meeting which brings us to then uh a similar review of uh board liaison assignments and so there is that wide range you'll notice things um where for example Mr cing has moved on and so we are working with Mr steel and so those internal changes will occur um and so we'll make those changes uh we do have one more year so I just want to plant this we have one more year of Miss brackie um with 287 unless somebody is really
092really really wanting to do that uh but Crystal bracky has uh it's a two-year term supporting our district at 287 so hopefully we are able to retain that until the 2026 calendar year uh but we also want that in front of people in case there are people who want to uh make any changes in liaison assignments or anything we wanted to make sure people have the opportunity to review that today too I'm seeing a head nodding mhm is that a I want to stay I want to change no I I I want to I want to change I'm hoping that can would maybe swap with me safe and supportive schools for Human Rights Commission so we won't put him on the spot to do that at the moment but what we hear is that's my
093proposal um also Headway has never happened I don't really know what's going on with that okay we will follow up and check and see if there is still a component connected to that okay uh the other piece is so do I hear you are so just to clarify are you wanting to shift off of the Human Rights Commission I don't need to I just thought that would be a nice swap um I do want safe and supportive schools um and based upon the fact that um well I could take another one and I would like um the curriculum advisory committee if Spencer has a lot on his plate I would be happy to alleviate you of that Ken is on that one oh she want to take everything that was the well it doesn't say
094l I'm not trying to rob L Daniel's W J well not the one that I have ah that was the typo that that Ken corrected Eagle Eye got it I would presume that Ken probably also really wants the um fiscal fiscal oh he hasn't had fiscal yet wants Fisk LZ wants Fisk I will say when we'll talk yes when Liz agreed to be treasure he did say that doesn't have to include uh fpac but we'll see hey I've had to do it bro so so I have no business in F sounds like we have some reflection to go offline so yes I hear Banks cup cho is interested in um safe and supportive and something I just want to put out for the board members we can add people and have multiple board members as
095long as we do not hit a quorum um and so what I will commit to doing is I heard some interest in some shifting so I have a few board members to follow up um in the coming weeks uh prior to us coming back with that but I did uh we did capture some notes is there other things people wanted to put on the table for switches they were very interested in to confirm calendar is not here right that's a separate committee that's the onee does not have a board leaz on I don't believe no but there a I mean what what do people need to do to get into that one show concerned Fair uh I believe Craig just got the most excited I've seen him in years so Craig will follow up with
096you miss Cole about we need to talk about his calendar I I said said differently I mean I think I agree with Dr Cole that it's like I don't know about other board members but when I look at committees that's one that we tend to hear about yeah even though we don't have a representative right now not that we need more like as I look through some of the represent representation I'm like there's a lot of committees we're on and this might be one that's worthwhile to have us on let's chat so I one warning yeah I I would say a warning that I've heard in the past is if we show up and say it should be this way then people feel like as though the board is bullying or pushing them into accepting
097something that we ultimately vote on anyway right so what happens is the committee puts together a consensus of the community members whether it's parents community members staff members who whomever it is and they bring we think this will work for what we have and then we consider it but if we had someone there it's possible that we could be accused of engineering it to our satisfaction and then we really hear about it yeah right there's a couple of things I'm going to I'll start by going back to safe and supportive that i' I've watched Mr Liss very articulately hold himself quiet um and hear from the students and really encourage students uh because the board acts on policy um and so it's really he's he's grown very skilled over the course of this year in
098making sure that as a board member he's not over speaking students um so that their voice shows up into into our policy rather than and only board members and so with the calendar committee that is the one danger I am very deliberately not on the calendar committee um I will tell you in the next year the twoe winter break versus going later in June is going to have different perspectives every year it does um and there are very strong feelings and everybody will not be happy regardless of those types of decisions um and that committee has that conversation um so the board if if a board member chooses to be there I would just CAU may I suggest yes I appreciate what director paully said about that perception and I can totally see that happen
099but then I think when we are reviewing the calendar here then we have to look at it then from like if they're expecting us to provide input then we need to to to take that then and really go out and have the that conversation here like I don't know what that will do like if something's got to go back because the way that I I understand it is by the time it comes to us is pretty much like consensus has been built you know and then and then it's really not helpful to try to change it at that point so how do we find the a a a a midp point here so I can certainly have um Mr Holi reach out to board members and see if there is a consensus amongst the six
100board members that something with the calendar has to be um if there is something I mean it doesn't have to be but I think right now it's it's it's either or right so like if the if the calendar committee is going to feel and I understand like as a manager I am the last one to share my opinion because I don't want my direct reports to agree with me just because I said it so I understand that absolutely but then it sounds like they have the perception that then we are offering some input that we are not really offering in a way that goes actually back to the drawing table and by then it may be a little late so what we try to do from a governance perspective is take take the values of
101the board um and this is what the charge and and Craig starts out with the calendar Committee in that conversation and so what we start talking about is this is about supporting students and families this is creating the best educational opportunity um one thing that often comes up as the calendar committee will offer to reduce days of instruction um we very consistently share that the board is interested in reducing instruction for our students because we know educational days are important um and then um the conversation goes around what is the most effective calendar to have um and they really look into it and they dig into um days they dig into opportunities I think if there is something missed um I think those are easy things for us to point out but there are a
102lot of perspectives in that room um in my 11 years I would say the biggest conversation ends up around winter break in June um that is that is the one that I would say gets the board conversation the most um I have watched PD days move around I have watched uh other uh conference comp days move around I've watched conferences move around as we've shifted them to support families as we shifted them to support staff and we basically try and that group flexes uh based on the needs um and then then um what I don't think ever will come to a a full unanimous agreement will be the the winter break versus June conversation I don't want to go into Administration I've always try to be very aware of that governance line and at the
103same time as elected officials we do hear from families and so what I am trying to convey you don't want to know the grief I hear either way like the the the the break went too late because you know it's you know NOA Christmas Eve now it's like too close or in this case like why are we going back on Thursday January 2nd MH and so I I I want to like we we need to figure out this out because I and it may be a matter of me to feel a little better if I know who's in the committee and like what which voices are being heard and the demographics of the folks you know like the the the the the the the percentage of power between district and and actual committee members like
104from teachers from admin like I I yes so let me just start and then I'll turn it to Craig so admin is told your opinion is not that important um just so we're clear all admin and and I said it today in teaching and learning and I say it in the principal meeting every single administrator works the days or every single administrator is on vacation so it does not matter matter to a Holi a owski or a principal if we go three extra days in June into the second or even the third week in June um versus a two-e winter break or extra days at break so this is never driven by the administrator um this impacts teachers this impact students and this impacts parents um and there is always a we don't want to
105go longer in June and there is always a we want two weeks at winter break um Craig you have sat through years of this argument conversation do you want to help with some context um yeah I I would just I would just say the conversation that you're having in hearing with people is exactly the conversation that takes place on the committee a lot of times people come in well my people said that they want this my people said that they want that and then all of a sudden um because it's a puzzle that has to be fit together people want you know two weeks of winter break they want to have um more days of PD and they want to finish at the end of the first week of June so ma we don't get
106those number of days to add up into that and so that's we we talked about this a cabinet next year is going to be interesting because you know and then do you end on a Monday as your last day of school or do you end on a Tuesday as your last day of school and how do those all play in so um what I will tell you and I've been doing this since I came to The District in 2005 um leading that committee and things like that that and um while people have their personal interest by the time we get to the con the end of the conversation everybody understands like Yep this is actually why we're doing this and there are still people that walk away wanting two weeks a winter break but they
107also acknowledge that they don't necessarily want to go farther in June or that there's enough people on that committee that are saying that this is the tradeoff and so um it really gets a little bit specific um year by year as far as how that plays out um I don't know it's it's it's a complicated piece it's a complicated puzzle the conversation is exactly the conversation that takes place um when we're looking at the different options and looking at how do we do it and trying to weigh in on those different pieces um so and the rules again on starting early it's only if there's construction or correct you have to have a certain size of a construction project to be able to start um the school start student instruction before Labor Day we have
108generally found that to be unpopular we have done it I think once or twice I don't think we've done it don't know if we've done it we did it we didn't do it once same we've had class start before La I thought we did it once I thought we did it once with the construction project I think we did one time and it was not well received like it was like the 7th of sep and so yeah I think so what I what I would say and I would encourage board members if you are uh wanting to so next year's Calendar's Quirk is the 22nd 23rd of December are a Monday Tuesday okay so we could go those two days and end on the June 5th or we could have a two-e winter break and
109end around the 10th of June and so if you want to engage and just sort of gather your own perspective feedback on that particular that is those that's the grind right there that's going to be the Quirk nobody wants to go to June 10th and nobody wants to do the Monday Tuesday of of winter break or of of this 22nd 23rd of December and so so with this so it's possible we're considering adding someone to be a representative on the calendar committee which is great I don't think we there I don't think we like I am persuaded about what what what I've heard but we already have had seen I believe a recommendation from last last year's calendar committee they usually give us this year's to vote on and a preliminary one for the subsequent
110year so if we dig up the old board packet we can find the proposed written in pencil next and I think both those options were sitting there as two versions one is a with December 22nd 23rd uh ending on the 5th of June and there the other one I believe is uh with a twoe winter break ending on the 10th of June and so and again there's there's little nuances with days here and there and those end up working out really I mean those still take a couple of meetings but those work out in a different way where people come together on them um where where there often is that rub um and where board members will hear is two week winter break versus ending the first week or the second week of June so
111here's what I um there's two things I'm thinking about number one I think that I am so encouraged to hear that the discussion is is you know happens and that ultimately people find consensus so I think it may be a matter of when we are talking about the calendar to have a better maybe someone from the committee to come and like when you come and present it so that then we can have a little bit of that public discourse of how we got there will be one thing that we do um and then the other thing is like I know we don't want to remove instructional days but I have my doubts about how productive those two days are either June SEC January 2 and third or December 21st 22nd so like I I'm always
112for we're not we're we're not here to look good on paper but we we want to make the decision that actually make moving the needle so I don't you know if we were to say that we're going to cut the the instructional list by two or like I'm not a fan of adding PD in June cuz I was the teacher and he thought that's crazy like why like we're going to go on on vacation and then we're going to forget I also know that mid May kids are crazy they want to go outside because it's nice out so like I I understand the two things but like it comes out to a math game like I'll be curious to know then how how you know how's the attendance on those days like what kind of
113content that the kids you know I is is is learning actually happening and so that's yeah and and um I when it comes time for the I mean at any time we can have the conversation regarding calendars some of the other conversation that occurs regarding the two weeks is access to meals and families going two full weeks without access to meals so that's one of the conversations and um some of the parents have looked or some of the teachers have talked about those two days being a transition so they aren't necessarily direct you know academic but the first day back from school often isn't and so sometimes those shorter weeks are transition pieces there um and then learning loss is the other piece of just having that full two weeks sometimes that just provides extended
114time so all of those are conversations that occur at the calendar committee um I don't know that I've got the data to say exactly what is right or what's wrong but and which is more valuable future facing what I'm thinking about I really don't like to Dell on the past I'm just trying to think about like we just came back from you know the holiday break and so I'm thinking ahead well I think the ACM sounds like sending out the calendar again for us review I mean it's there we have access to it to the preliminary we can certainly have Mr holdi send you the drafts that'll be reviewed by the by the calendar committee um as and again those are just on paper and sort of where they launch from we can also send
115back he can send back the one that was shown at the board last year and then as say I don't mean I agree with you I hear the feedback right it's like does it make sense to make an official appointment or does it make sense for us to to sit in as a concerned parent as well could be an option I'm actually if I I guess what I would have liked is to have like what do I even tell people like like talking points gu princip we the committee and and one of the concerns is access to meals if you got a two we break and one concerns is you know kids check out June 5th or sixth or can't start before Labor Day right a third of our kids don't show up the day
116after New Year's right so whatever those guiding principles are that we that went into the decision I think would be helpful for us I go one page right up or think of a slide I mean I think it's a good point too right it's like if we're not asking for it now it's like whenever the the calendar comes back we're going to bug you about it which then keeps one of us off the committee potentially sounds good we will make sure that uh there's full background and summarized synthesis of the conversation of calendar committee and um Representatives along with Mr holdi when this comes back so thank you thank you thank you glad I could help you thank you for that so then brings us next to setting the honorarium which like is exciting stuff
117uh yes so just as a required action uh we are recommending since there was just recently a change that things remain the same which is the honorarium at 600 a month with an additional 300 per year for the clerk and 900 for the chair um and then 600 for our student board reps per calendar year that they serve on the board uh we did set that last year um after doing an analysis or in 2023 I suppose that's a year and a half um doing an analysis um and then uh most districts do not it is not a common practice for students but we're proud to to be providing that to our students so with that we'll leave that with the board for comment or action um one comment I had regarding the student on
118Ray we talked about this last summer of potentially splitting that out by semester instead of by year because then that only I I understand there might be a tax consideration for the $600 per year so if it was broken up by 300 per semester instead of per calendar year that that might be um a good change and but you know what like our school semester bleeds into January that's true fall spring yeah what if we did it in September and then September January or something to split up the yeah we could we could amend it however I mean so so the concern then is someone who graduates so my understanding was that at $600 a year we still report there's a we report either way there's something that they have to do is it that
119it hits when it hits six I don't know what that number is $500 Mr hold you told us last year that they or we report regardless that no one is counted as independent contractor kind of thing okay so if it doesn't make a difference then I would say don't change it okay is that a motion I'll move the honorarium as presented I'll second that treasure treasure hey I make the call we have a motion to approve the honorarium by director Paul the second by director list looks like we've had our discussion for theight all in favor please say I hi all post you say nay chair votes I and the motion carries and we have an honorarium for another year brings us to draft admin guideline language access plan 9263 correct so this is brand
120new but this is required by updated statute from the state of Minnesota and so we did was go out um in connection with our 926 public relations involvement um which connects to communication and events uh these guidelines document the things that are already in place they align to the board's perspective of documenting the things that we do and making sure our policies and guidelines align to practice um and so we have for a first read language access plan which really talks about the interpretation procedures the translation procedures um and then also um overall dissemination of communication and so this is something that actually will be a review based on statute every two years rather than the fiveyear cycle um and so again uh this is for um just a first read today make sure we
121have that in front of board members to align a statute do we have other docks that are every two years versus every year because right um I can't think of any no we have yeah one year and and now one and now a one every two years but I'm pretty sure miss quam can handle that um she is a sharp cookie I might argue that some of the one-year documents might be okay to do every two years if the state let us but it's fun to review policies there we go questions comments on this one if not then that brings us to to policy 524 promotion retention and acceleration all right and so similar first read 524 and 5241 guideline about guidance of students moving from one grade to the next and also possible for
122retention or acceleration Advanced academics or enrichment programming so it has already um been put to the teaching and learning department for review and then this will continue to get refined as we move it forward but this is here for a first read no questions comments looks like we're on to our next item donations all right so recommended to accept with gratitude rhs Spartan Food Shelf received $20 from Christy Carr Richfield thank you Christy Carr rhs music department received an anonymous donation of $1,000 for band and the RMS music department received an anonymous donation of $1,000 for band so thanks to our generous Anonymous band donor or donors RPS football team received the following donations in memory of Ted Johnson $100 from Mr and Mrs Steve Hannis of Georgetown Texas $25 from Mr and Mrs Anderson
123Montgomery of St Paul $40 from Ann Sweeney of Plymouth Minnesota $20 from Mr and Mrs Jack hints of Richfield $20 from Linda frell of Minneapolis and $20 from Sue eer of Hopkins Minnesota so in memory of Ted Johnson we thank the donors to the football team I move that we accept these donations with much much gratitude I'll second we have a motion on the table by director bank skro and second by director Palace to accept the donations with much much gratitude all in favor please say I I I all po please say nay the chair votes I and we accept these donations with much much gratitude brings us on to Advanced planning legislative update don't know if there's much other than couple quick things obviously we approved the platform um then on Friday is the
124amsd um opening legislative preview session um and that is at Kora education center um and so I will be attending um I believe chair Carter will also be attending along with me um and we will bring bring back information from that um and then obviously um we'll be back in a week and a or two weeks with our local legislators information and questions from the board unless there's questions sorry on legislative update pass that quick guys close it information and question from the board suggested future agenda items we're all excited for the close session and that brings us to future meeting dates which will be Tuesday January 21st that we have a study session at 6 pm. so we're going to be in for a long night that night and then following meeting will be
125back to Monday February 3D so at this point we'll consider a motion to move into Clos session by allow by midate Statute 13 d03 for labor negotiation strategies I move that we go to close session as Allowed by min so to statute 13 d03 for the for labor negotiations strategy discussion second I'm going to shorten that by saying we have a motion by director paace and a second by director Spencer to move in the close session all in favor please say I hi hi hi all please say nay and votes I and that will bring us to close session after a brief brief recess the board will begin a closed session in a private room we return to this meeting to officially adjourn upon completion of the closed session but there will be no further
126business other than toour the meeting for those on live stream thank you this will end our session you know that they meet during the day