001e e e good evening welcome to the regular board meeting for the Richfield Board of Education today is Monday December 16th 2024 um and I'm calling toward this meeting Richville Public Schools inspires and empowers each individual to learn grow and EXP and we're here for them um here in the boardroom I am joined by director Police director Lee director Spencer director CER uh superintendent yanowski board secretary Cassandra kwam and our lovely uh student representatives tanai and Vanessa I would also joined by members of our staff um our Community Partners uh and also everyone watching us live on YouTube or later during the recording is anyone ready to review and move the agenda for approval sub I'll second that have a motion by director K CER and a second by director Lee all in favor please
002say I I any opposed shair vot side and our agenda is approved so now moving into uh information information and proposal non-action items today would have been a public comment uh meeting but no one has yet signed up so I'm going to move to next item with superintendent Yow all right so we have three items on the agenda going from three up um comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness report formerly known as world best Workforce which will be preceded by our audit report and our first thing which is just more conversation which is just a reminder to our board members about the board reorganization that occurs every January where the board board must take some action um to choose for the next year a chair a vice chair a Treasurer and a clerk um this will
003be the end of um chair Cole's second year and historically we have often changed from chair to Vice chair um if that were to happen um that would leave an opening in terms of Vice chair but of course whatever decision is up to you board members so I'm going to pause and see if anybody has anything to say about the upcoming board reorg or their interest or willingness I can say I'm interested in continuing as clerk if if the if needed if someone else feels strongly I welcome them to take it I'm when I fight you for it it won't be much of a fight but I've enjoyed it so far I suppose that the big question I I would have then is is for vice chair Carter again if we follow the P the
004pattern of practice we've had for a number of years would you be would you be interested in serving as chair so that means you're going to put me on the spot here then well would you consider it you you know I mean the truth is none of us are bound to these answers right how we how we answer and vote on the first meeting in January is the one that really carries and you could change your mind as I could like I could say maybe I want to be chair right all right maybe I I forget what it was was like and say I want to do it again I mean if you want to fight for it I would concede sure sure right okay uh I have got my head around it um and
005it would be willing to serve in position if this board W that all right if if you could muster a majority of the quum of the board president maybe we'll talk on the side to make sure that I've got safe majority we don't really have conversation on the side Mr Carter he's trying to our votes which is why we actually weirdly are having this crazy once a year conversation Bo whip we have six people and and and we have need to fill four four spots right um so we think we have two of them Miss Cole would would you be interested in receding into a quiet time what is is your preference to to to resume an Untitled director role yes this really is an awkward discussion it is it is it was I mean
006it it just is what it is but I make it awward so I will say that if theoretically Mr Carter was the chair there would then be an open Vice chair position um I'm not sure if anybody present is interested in a future um as Vice chair anybody I have some eyes on me so I would be willing to serve in that role called on should your nomination be receive a second nominated Excell again so thator I I think I think from a statutory standpoint we need a chair a Treasurer and a clerk I don't think I think Vice CH optional of all things and we have done that and we will continue doing that but if he did that uh that would vacate the treasure which would then leave us needing a treasure if
007there was anybody interested or willing to do that so the anybody Falls to at this point room and has Mr would probably be interested in most anything but treasure all right okay good so we will wait and so you're saying there's a chance this is great I am curious of our senior members not age but tenure on the board have you both served all four roles not not me um I've served three of them oh which one have you served uh clerk clerk I mean so I thought is a badge of honor to have all four name PL I have time I have three years unless I quit I I I have completed the full tour okay with uh you know obviously we we're here to serve so if if I need to serve as
008you know if if uh director Bank sculpture is not interested in pressure I'll be happy to feel in that very extenuating role got it so what I'll do uh we have thrown those out for things to think about it seems like we have a couple of people interested in certain roles um and some other thoughts to have I'm also curious about the different um board responsibilities that we talked about last year is that also something that we would discuss at that uh yes that one takes a couple of meetings so we do in the first meeting in January is we review um represent a school in Le aison assignments we ask at that meeting if there's interest in transitioning or or other ideas um and then we will finalize that usually at the second meeting
009in January sometimes even the first meeting in February so all right so with that I'm going to transition us out of that conversation introduce Craig Holi to come up and introduce the team for our spectacularly scintillating audits reports very good thank you very much um the audit actually started I say 18 months ago when the board approved the budget in June of the previous year so June of 23 this audit is for the 232 four year um the actual audit work um in partnering with Bill L and mmkr um actually started in about June of this year with some on-site work and some prep work um we do have with us as well uh Director of Finance Jim Gilligan and finance manager John laurenzini um who put in a lot of workers in partnering and
010working with Bill's team to kind of gather the information look at the details and put everything together so with that I'm going to turn it over to Bill to share um the audit report and we'll both be available for any questions welcome thank you good evening what I would like to uh go through with you this evening uh is kind of three things quickly first of all I'm required to remind you as a body that oversees financial reporting for the District of what our role is and how that differs from the role of management when it comes to the responsibility for your financial statements second I'm going to go through the audit process how that went and uh the different reports that we issue and the results of the audit and then third I'll just
011spend a little bit of time going through some of the high level uh Financial results for the year ended June 30 of 2024 um so on this first slide it talks about our role as auditor as I mentioned the main document you received in your package tonight is the district's annual financial report all of the information that goes into putting that together is provided by District management they're responsible for the for the document uh we come out and audit that and give an opinion as to whether it fairly presents your financial position and the results for the year under audit um also because the district earned more than $750,000 in federal Awards again this year uh you are subject to a separate single audit of those Federal award expenditures it's more of a compliance audit
012on your specifically on your federal spending um in regard to both both of those audits uh were required to review uh your internal controls over financial reporting and over compliance with those Federal uh federal dollars um and also uh the compliance with the various regulations that apply to those so you'll find report letters at the back of your financial statements uh regarding both of those and finally you're subject to an audit of compliance with Minnesota laws and regulations there's an audit program that the state auditor office puts saw it for all local governments uh we audit to that and and uh provide a opinion letter also in the back of your report with regard to that so as far as the results of the audit um first just let me say that Craig and Jim
013and John and their team uh had things ready for us everything went very smoothly they were well prepared the records were in good shape uh I think you're going to find that the results of the audit I'm about to go through reflect that uh once again we were able to provide an unmodified or what we call clean opinion on your financial statements we had no issues it's the highest opinion that we can give on financial statements um as far as internal control and compliance over your financial audit uh we had no internal control issues or compliance finding report this year uh with regard to Minnesota legal compliance uh we also had no findings to report uh for 2024 just to follow up from last year one of the things we always do is if if
014there is a finding in the prior Year we're required to follow up on that and expand our testing in 2023 you did have a couple uh dispersements that were paid late um we tested that again uh this year and expanded that testing and everything was paid on time so there was no repeat finding for that in 2024 um and then finally your federal single audit um required to issue an opinion as to whether your schedule of expenditures of federal Awards is fairly stated in relation to your financial statements that was also a clean opinion um we did have uh One internal control matter to report and this is um actually something that was an issue last year too um you have a requirement anytime you spend over $255,000 with a vendor in any federal program
015to uh go out and make sure they are not on the list of vendors that are uh suspended or debarred from doing uh from participating in a federally funded contract um we uh this was a finding in 2023 as well you did put um corrective actions in place clean this up for the most part but uh something that's fairly common in Your Child Nutrition uh Child Nutrition program um this requirement isn't just if you're spending $25,000 at at one time it's cumulative with a vendor for the year um one of the vendors that you typically don't spend more than $25,000 with ended up going over that uh this year that was one of the ones we selected for testing um so they should have been checked for that suspension in dearment um we did not
016site any compliance issue with that we checked they were they were not barred from doing business but uh as part of your controls you're required to check that and document that you did uh before I move on to the financial results questions on any of the reports or opinions I have one question so just over the methods that you when you come across a finding like that in the current year do you expand the scope in the current year or just apply that for the following year um we we do our testing based on uh not only the risk assessment for this year but prior results so like for the legal compliance uh we picked a certain sample size last year um found late payments so this year we picked a larger sample when we
017retest that um similar to the federal finding because that was an issue last year we pick a larger sample size when we're testing that particular uh compliance item and when you find a finding in the current year do you then expand for the current year or justly um it depends in this particular case we covered most of the ones that were over the $25,000 limit so we didn't okay uh we did test we tested three different programs we tested that particular compliance requirement and all three the only one where there was an issue as one contract okay in Your Child Nutrition program okay thank you oh go ahead Eric it's a quick one um and this may be a question for Craig actually or either so and I get you're not going to like it
018when I say it but is how many vendors do we have that fall into that category of federally funded is just food or just federally Federal fees any goods or services that are over $25,000 in a particular Grand I don't know the number I understand any over my question is is how many total vendors fall into the category of federally matched funds and the reason where I'm going with this is that why not just check all of them I mean if if this is two years in a row right or second time it would seem like why not just be proactive about it yeah I I think um we do that with everything that we know is going to be $25,000 and over um we have a lot of vendors that are smaller vendors like
019this vendor previous previous year was at about $14,000 so they had a larger jump to get to that point one of our um testing measures moving forward is we're going to be measuring those on a monthly basis and tracking and seeing when when they're progressing um if we looked at every vendor we have some vendors where um it's much smaller less than $5,000 or an Amazon Amazon order or different online orders that are occurring within federal funds so those that are over 25,000 the contracts that came to the board specifically nutrition services that are over 25,000 they all have those testing procedures in place this is one that it wasn't anticipated to be more than $25,000 it did go over $25,000 and we just didn't catch that in that provision so one of our quality
020control pieces will be looking at setting an amount of everything over10 ,000 or everything over $15,000 will then have that tagged in at that point but that still doesn't answer my question the question of how many vendors fall into that category so how many vendors fall under the 25,000 just into the category that I don't know if it's specifically nutrition services or that match the federal funding and and the reason why I asked because take the number amount aside if it's if it's 10 vendors why not check them all if it's 100 vendors I get that you may be reluctant to check them all but right I'm just trying to understand how many is I I'm going to estimate that we have over a 100 vendors that are participate that we make purchases using federal
021dollars with which is what this is testing so it's in our nutrition services it would be in any of our federal programs for title um and those dollars specifically too okay we'll we'll look and find out how many numbers that's part of what we're taking a look at um we did kind of assess and say what is that tier is it anything that we spend money in um some of it gets compc ated bill and I had a conversation earlier about what's an appropriate compliance procedure kind of quality control and um had some conversation regarding exactly how to manage that okay thank you so I want to clarify because you said something about that it happened again and I haven't heard that this is a recurrent thing so that is a question I have I
022don't think I understood and then I was repeating what they said I I thought that they said because it had happened previously with did a wider scope there was a finding last year as well yes yeah about the about the 25,000 about we contracted for services with without without checking that someone you're right I think it was milk or something without checking that the vendor was you're saying that because it happened last year that we should have checked everyone I'm asking so it happened last year it happened again my question is happened or like two years in a row yes yes okay yes so so all right so that's is the milk I'm like milk apples okay milk milk then apples okay and then now my question is if it's happened twice right and we
023we we didn't we didn't catch it the second time my question is why not do all of them I see okay and then then it's an nonissue right if we verify that they are not on the the watch list or whatever right uh but again if it's 10 seems like an easy task if it's 100 now the question is if you say to do 100 it still takes five minutes each I still might say is it really that time consuming that was like is it worth it to not get audited and like I'd love to have a clean audit right it's like so that that's my question okay thank you uh and so then I one thing I I'm about like team help but I'm thinking about accounting uh what is the regular process because
024I know when we do audits we don't check everything ever right like we there's there's there random uh things and I know like at work we always you know we keep our receipts you know just in case the Audits and then sometimes Auditors come to some of I mean not here in this uh at the school board but like in our daytoday jobs and but I I understand is not everything so I heard you say that because of something had happened like you took a bigger sample so can you walk with through for uh those of us not very familiar with the uh accounting procedure features of audits how is the like what are some of the guidelines that you think about sure um I'll use the the late payment finding that was corrected this
025year as an example okay so when we tested that um for 2023 we might have picked a sample of say 25 when we did our testing and maybe we found one or two uh that were paid laid out of that sample so that was listed as the finding so this year when we came back we increased that sample to 40 or 50 50 just because there was an issue in there part of part of what you do when you plan your audit is you do a risk assessment and part of what you have to take into account for that when you're deciding you know where to spend your time and your resources is if there were problem areas in the past you need to make sure you're you're following up on any findings like that
026and typically then we would expand our testing and in the case of of the federal finding as well since that was a repeat finding whereas our guidelines might have said you know if you've got I'm just throwing numbers out 10 10 vendors over that $25,000 uh threshold we might test three or four in a typical year if we haven't had any problems there you know this year we tested six or seven so each each year we assess that based on the programs we're testing and any results from the past thank you got question you know in regards to Eric's comment what would happen and this is you know completely if the one guy you haven't checked in 10 years has been doing it for 10 years has been out out of compliance for 10 years
027but you have never checked that that business it's possible it's a sampling process so what would happen to us I mean what would happen we don't we're only auditing one year we're not going to go back and check to see if if they were if we find like this vendor is out of compliance this year we don't go back to Prior years to see if they were an issue and the purpose for this check is to ensure that government sectors are doing business with people who are not at risk of fulfilling their contracts that that's is that the sort of thing that it's a protection you if there are are vendors out there that have you know committed fraud or things like that they get on the naughty list and you're not supposed to do
028business with them it's a protection for for you and a protection for the federal agency that's giving you the money and can can I ask just for I think we asked before but I forget the answer we we are supposed to check at the time we enter into a contract at least at that time or every subsequent purchase that's made um we we look for once a year but it needs to be before you spend $225,000 with them obviously before you've spent the money with the vendor so um typically what we see is pretty similar to what you're doing where all of the you know you tend to use the same vendors or you bid for new ones for food that kind of thing and all of those that you know are your main providers
029people do that right away up front um what what we see most often in the Child Nutrition area is that some of these vendors um that you maybe didn't do do as much business with last year start creeping up because it is cumulative if you spend 25,000 over the course of the year um and having a mechanism like Craig was talking about where you're keeping track of what you're spending so that before you get close to that threshold you're also checking them is you know one one control that we see fairly often as well um there's nothing that says you can't check them all I don't know when you start getting down to you know you are going buying I don't know paper plates or something at cob I mean you know there's there's an
030an area where I no longer make sense but it also just just to be clear this report is from 7123 to 7124 is that correct yes okay so we heard about last year's which was 7122 to 3 in December and at that time we we spoke about can we take corrective action but we at by then we'd already had six months perhaps of the correct action not happening which could lead into this audit right so we we spoke a year ago about hey how you know what what what can we beef up how we review and then demonstrate that we check like I think the the next contract we'd approved the one question that came up with did we validate and make sure that they were on the not you know were not on the
031naughty list um and so but it it's possible that that in the six months that's within this audit before we take in that extra step to to have a heightened sense of um scrutiny on the list is that this could have happened in that time frame and so as a board member I'm not as up like it's frustrating it's all frustrating but um I'm not as frustrated like I thought we had talked about this and then it happened again it's entirely plausible that the the violation of sorts happened within the six months of the of the Year under here which was already underway when we found about last year's result and spoke about can we take corrective actions so okay that that's I'm just trying to work through that in my head and understand like
032and is anyone who's at the $25,000 threshold cumulative throughout the year and so we could go through with someone if we don't typically buy much but all of a sudden we're up to $800 a week and then we we get to it at some point okay well thank you I I appreciate the the clarification and I'll I'll just add this was a Miss because it was the cumulative piece I think that since the last finding we got really good at any one of the contracts which is usually those that are going over 25,000 um any one of those contracts we were checking before we we're bringing them to board um there's either a website some of them are not listed on the website so we have to track down those vendors so those that were
033the contracts that were over 25,000 we knew this one grew in a year from um beyond what we expected and we just missed it on that piece um raised our awareness of it raised our awareness to look deeper at some of those pieces that are cumulative so we are putting actions in place place now this year to make sure that we're monitoring those purchases on a monthly basis um to make sure that um we aren't getting that point where it's getting close to the 25,000 and we haven't run it so so so then I hear you're saying Tim thank you for that um my question then would come back to the so if the the audit period ends June 30th um that is a big window right it's like you're almost running in a six-month
034lag is there a way to shorten that window down from an office perspective to get it done faster I'd have to go back and look when we actually did the testing but when we find it we make them aware of it so this isn't the first time they've heard of it I we've been talking about it for four months probably got well I'm just I mean hear what you're saying and right it's like or if that's the case right it's like it's useful information to have so thanks for your questions it's it's challenging to suggest that we have the audit process happen and faster while still asking for it to be as rigorous as we expect so right to me the question in this case is how do we make sure we are tracking the
035cumulative amount spent with one vendor um and not having that slip through the cracks right so as as they said at $25,000 Reeder contract that's easy um but we should have some form of running total that we are paying out to a particular vendor and our computers do track that that should be something that's right and we're more aware of it now than we were a year ago or six months ago and we're more aware of you know so correct I imagine right with that that sixth month that that the Gap that i' suggested about the the repeated finding here I'm sure with the awareness we'll go back and look through all our purchases and make sure that we've we've certified compliance for everyone who who should be at this point forward okay John was
036just sh sharing that they've already implemented the corrective actions on this one so they are doing that monitoring on a regular basis that's great thank you anything else otherwise I'll move along to the uh financial information um first thing I'm going to touch on is your general fund your primary operating fund uh this graph shows a history of your general fund yearend financial position in terms of uh your unrestricted fund balances the blue bars there and your cash and Investments at the end of the year which are the yellow bars at the end of 2024 fiscal year you had just under $23 million in cash and Investments and total fund balances of about $8.7 million uh your fund balances were up about $1.1 million in total um about and you'd budgeted pretty much Break Even
037you'd budgeted to uh spend fund balance down by $822,000 um the next slide shows uh some of the numbers behind uh the total fund balance you report fund balance and different components uh nonspendable restricted fund balances and then then the the two unrestricted categories assigned and unassigned which you control essentially at a local level um your nonspendable fund balances of $535,000 went up uh by about $458,000 from last year and that's basically due to uh cutting a check for a uh Chromebook purchase uh where you didn't have the the goods yet it was a prepayment for that um the restricted fund balances are essentially the state mandated spending restrictions kind of the strings that come with some of your funding uh of that $4.7 million uh you have about 2.3 million which is related to
038Capital operating Capital long-term facilities maintenance uh we've also got about $545,000 for Student Activities and scholarships and those are both kind of funds that you don't really spend on general fund purposes the the Student Activities are for the Student Activity accounts uh at the building levels um you got another 700,000 for your area Learning Center programs uh about $850,000 for basic skills programming and a little over $300,000 of other uh smaller uh restrictions there and and those are the two categories where you saw the increase in fund balance your restricted fund balances went up by 1.1 million and as I mentioned nonspendable nonspendable was up by about 458,000 um the two uh remaining categories assigned which you earmark uh locally and un assigned which you can spend for everything um we're pretty close to last
039year actually went down by about $435,000 in the total of those two categories um that's why you're seeing at the bottom there we track those unrestricted and unassigned fund balances a percent of your annual expenditures um even though your total fund balance went up you're seeing those ratios go down that's kind of a a both where the fund balance went up and also because the size of your general fund operation your spending has been growing also another thing that we track year toe is a number of students that you serve that generate general education aid for the district these play into some of your larger uh funding formulas um you had a pretty stable year student wise you served an average daily membership of about uh 4,035 and that when the pupil waiting are applied
040uh the pupil units that generated were about 4,413 that's the students that go into your Aid calculations that was a decrease of about 12 from last year so so about a quarter of a percent uh change year-over-year your total general fund revenues for fiscal 2024 were just under $82 million uh you're about $230,000 over budget a variance of about 3/10 of a percent um mainly that was in your federal sources uh which were 8 131,000 over budget that's because you made an election uh for the first time in 202 to utilize about $87,000 of your federal entitlement uh to pay tuition for special education uh State sources offset that a little bit you're about $445,000 under budget on State uh state aid mainly special in general education we slightly under budget uh revenues grew by
041about 7 million roughly 9% overall uh the majority of that or almost all of that basically was in state aid uh you did receive funding increases uh both on the general education formula and on the percentage of special education costs that the state was paying so you saw uh increases in both of those AIDS of about $4 million each uh over the prior year on the expenditure side you spent just under $81 million for the Year this is where most of your budget variance was uh you're about $985,000 under budget roughly at 1.2% uh under spending salaries and benefits were about $1.8 million under budget mainly due to the inability to spend to fill all of your budgeted positions due to the challenging labor market um as a result of that you did see purchase
042Services over budget by about 1.4 million um a lot of that was in special education uh and then your other expenditures were about $760,000 under bud and mainly that's Debt Service you had less uh lease payments and finance purchase payments than you had projected spending grew by about 3.2 million in the general fund a little over 4% uh salaries and benefits uh went up by about 2.8 million purchase Services by another 2 million that's basically where that increase came from your uh Capital spending offset that a bit it went down by about 1 a. half million some of that's timing your projects and also uh you had a $825,000 in lease purchases in 2023 that you did not have recurring in 20124 then briefly to touch on a few of your other operating funds excuse
043me your uh Food Service fund ended the year with a total fund balance of about $942,000 your annual revenues and expenditures in that fund are just under $4 million uh fund balance went up by about 220,000 which was uh roughly 340,000 better than projected in your budget and that year and fund balance represents about 25% of your annual expenditures in that fund uh the community service fund ended the year with total fund balance of about $358,000 uh it's about 16,000 I'm sorry 16% of the annual expenditures in that fund uh which are about $2.25 million uh for the 2024 fiscal year uh your fund balance went up by about $65,000 uh that was about 150,000 better than budget uh two other funds which I don't have picture here pictured here that I'll just mention briefly
044they kind of run themselves you maintain a building construction fund and a Debt Service fund and these are um essentially where you you are uh accounting for some of the debts you're you're issuing to build Capital assets uh your building construction fund you had a $2.3 million bond issue in 2024 um you spent a little over half of that on projects the rest of that's going to be uh wrapped up in the current year you're operating in so your fund balance was about $933,000 higher at the end of the year uh and your debt service fund uh fund balance there was about $2.2 million that went up by about $125,000 and pretty much everything in that fund uh is approved when you uh issue issue bonds All The Debt Service levies are approved in the
045that process so you're collecting the tax levies and paying debt uh you retired a little over $5 million in outstanding bonds through that fund during the year excuse me I'm just going to grab us of water here my voice is going my last uh slide here is a very very compact version of the first financial statement that you will find in your overall document it's the districtwide statement in net position so there's kind of a second layer of financial reporting in your statements this takes all of your fund information which only reports current assets and current liabilities all those funds that we just talked about converts it to a full acral basis and it provides you with more of a long-term indication of your financial position and change from year to year so the top
046part of this walks through how you get from the fund balances so the about $26.2 million total fund balances and the funds we just went through uh to a total net position that's a deficit of about $8 million uh you've got Capital assets and at a depreciation of about $151 million and I'll just remind you this is based on the cost of those assets this isn't replacement value or actual value today um then below that you see the bonds leases Finance purchases these are the capit Capital related debt that you issued to purchase or construct those assets and then um the two uh things below that pension liabilities and other post-employment benefits are long-term uh benefits for your employees the pension liabilities are primarily uh your proportionate share of the two Statewide pension plans through
047p and TR that the bulk of your employees uh belong to um each year they do a Actuarial study determine the level of funding of those plans and everybody all the school districts cities counties that have employees that participate in those plans are required to report uh their proportionate share of any Ender funding on their entity-wide full of cruel financial statements just like you see here so your share um for employees of your District that participated in those plans was about a $43 million liability at the end of 2024 um so you can see from the bottom there this is the different pieces of net position that you report on your financial statements you've got about $25 million in your net investment and capital assets that went down about $3 million mainly due to depreciation
048and amortization uh your restricted net positions are basically those uh fund balance restrictions we talked about in the general fund plus anything uh that's restricted by the fundit in like your food service capital service funds uh all those fund balances convert to restricted net position and then that unrestricted net position is essentially your um your uh fund balance in the general fund that's unassigned or unrestricted offset by those pension liabilities and other post-employment benefit liabilities that are not funded that's why you're seeing the deficit there um you did see an improvement in that uh portion of net position of about $5.3 million a lot of that is coming from if you go back to the top part there uh the funding levels of both pension plans and your other post-employment benefits uh improved from the
049year before so that's part of what's driving that Improvement in that unrestricted net position that's everything I typically go through from a number standpoint unless you had questions thank you questions over here thanks for all the detail and your patience with our questions absolutely that's what I'm here for you have any questions no going once going twice thank you so much lot of detail appreciate the clarity the visuals uh the graphs everything thank you so much see you next year all right and so with that and just as a reminder the world's best Workforce has changed into the comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness just because we like to change titles and like to change names so I'm going to bring up Dr Daniels and directors Jens and Ward um so let's turn it over to
050Dr D for our presentation good evening good evening everyone I am here um along with Rachel JY who is our director of Elementary education and Alex Ward our director of secondary education and we are about to report out on our results around the comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness work um our learning Target for tonight and keeping with um the best practices around instruction is we will review the outcomes of Richfield school's comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness goals for Success criteria we would like you to walk away understanding the results and outcomes around our our School Readiness career and college readiness High School graduation and the work we've done around the racial and achievement gaps um superintendent yanowski has um shared um what the acronyms cacr stands for but it is simply the world's best Workforce
051rebranded in the last legislation and it was rebranded to um accomplish a few things it was rebranded to of course capture the achievement of our students prek 12 and their learning experiences within our school district and within respective school districts across the state but it was also rebranded to um ensure that we are preparing students to be active citizens in our Society once they graduate and also to prepare them to become lifelong Learners next we're going to have Rachel talk about um School Readiness so as I've shared with you in the past the assessment that we use to measure kindergarten Readiness is called the teaching strategies gold assessment it's an assessment that we use in all of our preschool programs uh and it is a blend of both teacher observation of students demonstrating early literacy
052and numeracy skills as well as work sampling collecting samples of students applying those skills in action um so some of the early uh literacy skills that we are measuring include phonological awareness so students ability to hear and uh manipulate individual sounds and words um being able to recognize features of books the front cover the back cover things like that demonstrating knowledge of the alphabet um and emergent um letter sound correspondences students being able to retell familiar stories um as well as recognize and write their first name and some common um letters that they're learning in their classes as well in math um the skills we're measuring include basic counting skills both forwards and backwards um as well as recognizing numerals matching quantities of items to uh to the numeric representation of the quantities um and
053understanding positional words identifying basic shapes and then also comparing and ordering objects by size length and weight um those types of attributes so you can see that last fall fall 2023 um we experienced uh a bit of a decline in the number of students entering our preschool programs with some of these skills already in place so we had about 9% of our students entering preschool um with a beginning mastery of those kindergarten Readiness skills in literacy um we did a a really good job accelerating their progress ending the year with close to 90% of those students demonstrating kindergarten Readiness benchmarks in place so even though we had a a wider Gap to close than we did um during the 2022 23 school year um we did accelerate progress but did fall short of meeting um
054our 10% increase increase goal we had about a 5% um increase in our overall proficiency instead um in math similar to literacy we saw um fewer students entering our preschool programs in the fall already demonstrating Mastery of some of those early numeracy skills um but made a tremendous amount of progress right about 77% of students exiting preschool having those skills in place so we actually made more progress in closing that fall to Spring Gap last year than we did the previous year um but again you see that we didn't quite hit our our goal um we were down to about 77% 10 10% less than what we had hoped to to gain so overall we're seeing that our preschool programs when looking at where students come in in the fall compared to where they uh
055leave in the spring are very effective in helping students be prepared for for kindergarten we see this paralleled in our fast brid reports where we have anywhere from about 20 to 25% of students in the fall um demonstrating high risk in reading and math so um very similar to what we're seeing in terms of the proficiency levels at the end of our preschool programs excuse me c can I ask is was there something like are we um recruiting or attracting um different students with different backgrounds or something else that that would lead to like the drop off from Fall to 22 to fall 23 in terms of like that the the entry point um literacy and math awareness I mean that that fall 23 ranked at you know score to zero is is surprising right
056so we we seem to be getting a a different group of kids than we did the prior year it's somewhat that it's also um after covid we did see a decline in the number of students attending our early childhood family education um classes right so they um some parents or families were maybe reluctant to bring young children into a space where they were shared we are starting to now see increases in families returning to our ECFE classes but that was something immediately following the pandemic we did have a decline in the number of students um participating in those programs but but the and also the the total number of students is about the same for fall 22 and fall 23 yeah we've had a slight decline I would say within the past year um in
057our preschool program programs we did have to close one section last year so all right thank you yeah all right so um reading proficiency for third grade reading proficiently by third grade is no longer a part of the world's best Workforce or um the the renamed comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness goal areas but we did want to include this information for you tonight um as you're used to seeing this data and wanted to give you a compar Arison um from from years past in the future we will be reporting our reading proficiency through the read act local literacy plan and data report that we submit annually to the state rather than the um comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness Plan so you can see that last year we had about a 1.5% increase in the percentage
058of students demonstrating proficiency um based on our state assessment so this is from the m CA as well as the mtest assessments so our state accountability assessments um we continue to to make this slight upward progress despite the state actually showing a decline in the number of students uh demonstrating reading proficiency at third grade overall within our system we also had um an increase so not just at that third grade level but as we look across um our K12 system as well um as you know we have put a number of very specific strategies and measures in place to really Target uh improvements in our literacy instruction and I will share more about what those are later when we get to our priorities and our strategies page thanks Rachel closing the achievement Gap um in
059student groups and so the achievement Gap describes persistent discrepancy between um groups of students and though it is called an achievement Gap we know that the achievement Gap is informed by many socioeconomic um factors even some systemic factors such as race gender um socioeconomic status Etc and so although we call it an achievement Gap we know that there are many factors baked within the Gap that um makes it exist um for the purpose of this presentation I will be sharing um the achievement of our students Latino and black in comparison to their white counterparts as measured by the Minnesota comprehensive Assessments in math and reading um I will share the data on the next two slides and at the end of the presentation we will talk about how our team is targeting the Gap here
060in Richville Public Schools as you see both our Latino and white students made growth in math from the 2223 school year to the 2324 school year our white students um they were able to almost hit 60% proficiency um doing very well exceeding the state however our white students grew um our white students grew faster thus the gap between our Latino students and our white students also grew our Latino students they grew from 17.6% to 19.3% so about a 1.7% um percentage in growth um and our white students again they grew almost 5% which means that our Gap grew between our Latino and our um white students the same is true for reading our Latino students and white students grew in Reading with our Latino students growing from 23.4% to 23.7% but our white students growing
061by 5% to almost 65 65% and exceeding the state um average and so again you see that we have a persisting gap because although our Latino students are growing in math and reading our white students are growing at a much faster rate and looking at our black students um we see our black students took a slight step back in math proficiency from 16.4% in the 2223 school year to 15.7% um last school year our white students again they were at about 60% and so that means that our Gap widened to almost 5% more between um looking at our black students and our white students in math in reading our black students took a slight step forward from 24.3% to 24.4% in Reading proficiency but the St stubborn Gap grew by 5.1% um in conclusion from
062looking at this data we want to celebrate the resilience of all of our students especially our white students um as it relates to their proficiency and how they continue to outperform the state um we also want to celebrate the growth of our students of color as we look at how they are responding to the strategies that we have in place um to bounce back from what happened to them um during the pandemic however we are very clear and certain that much more intentional work has to happen in order for them to accelerate their achievement such as our white students in closing the achievement Gap next we're going to have Alex talk about the act and College and Career readiness all right thank you in 11th grade uh Richfield students take the ACT test um and
063often we think of 36 as the perfect score right what is less known typically is each of the subtests has a college readiness score which makes it a little confusing is each one is different so English the college rightness score is an 18 math and reading the college rightness score or Benchmark is at 22 and in science the college readiness is at 23 and so what this graph shows is what percentage of our students are hitting that college readiness Benchmark in each of the four subtests of the ACT um in 2024 if you notice we made improvements um in all areas right um and in fact in 2024 we even improved to 2022 scores other than math and so while we're not at the 2020 2021 levels that we have been we uh outperform 2023
064and in all areas outperformed 20 in all areas other than math outperformed 2022 um when it comes to math we are working with the math team especially in the high school to think how can we um do instruction differently one thing we have started this year is we brought the math fast test into nth grade and we gave it to all n9th grade students in intermediate algebra and we're starting to use the progress monitoring with nth graders to see if we can start offering the appropriate interventions for our nth grade students in math um next slide our four-year graduation rate um continues to be well above the state levels and in fact uh surpassed our goal this past year talking to leaders at both the high school and arp it's clear that our work in
065standards-based grading offering multiple opportunities uh for students to demonstrate proficiency and providing real-time supports in our buildings has contributed to our continued um upward Trend in our graduation rate um the next slide here just shows um rhs and RP um separate but you'll notice ret basically maintain the same and rhs made nice gains now we're going to talk about some of the work that we're doing to Target some of these achievement opportunities we've share with you as we shared earlier this fall um you know that we have made some significant shifts in the curriculum that we are using for K5 literacy um specifically reading and writing um instruction last year we had about 40 of our classrooms who piloted Benchmark advance and adalante um and because we saw students in those particular classrooms using that
066curriculum outperform their peers um using our previously adopted curriculum the teachers College reading and writing project units of study we did move forward with districtwide implementation this year so our teachers are continuing to get training in how to use uh Benchmark advance in adalante effectively um both from Consultants from the company as well as from our literacy coaches who have received some additional training as well um we are also continuing to use Mystery Science as our core Science Program one of the wonderful things about Benchmark advance and adalante is that it embeds science Concepts within the curriculum but we still know that students need those Hands-On science um science experiments and opportunities right to do science not just learn about the concepts so we're continuing to use that curriculum at the elementary level and then
067in the Middle School amplify science is in its second year of implementation and it's clear from talking to the science team the administrators and even observing through our learning walks that the curriculum is really solidified our science um offering in the Middle School we're seeing very clear learning targets and guiding questions and just use of materials um that students are showing that they're learning science and then our secondary Ela curriculum review is in process the team has heard from all three providers and is using um this month and part of next month to kind of review those on their own and then January 27th is our professional development day where the team will have uh virtually the entire day to go through the materials and make a recommendation on where uh which materials they' like
068to to use moving forward we also have um curriculum nights for parents uh and community members happening in January and February um and that information will be coming out in an email tomorrow or Wednesday so instruction continues to be the main vehicle in which we attack achievement and achievement disparities we believe strongly it's conclusive um in looking at the research that high quality tier year one instruction is not negotiable it is an expectation and is it is an expectation that we inspect in Richville Public Schools it is not popular um at every um MOA committee meeting or at committee meetings that we have with our Advisory Group as Ken witnessed last week we we receive heat for going into classrooms twice a year to look for evidence-based practice at practices as they are aligned to
069our um learning walk practice profiles that have been designed specifically for what we should be looking for at the elementary level with Rachel in partnership with um instructional leaders at the elementary level and Alex in partnership with instructional leaders at the secondary level but we continue to do learning walks to um inspect practices and collect aggregate information to inform professional development so we can improve instruction and again outcomes for students um that happens twice a year in the fall and the winter and um we um have concluded our first learning walk and we will start our second one again in February and conclude it in March um for the 20 um 23 24 for the 24 25 school year we also have coaching cycles that again support instruction um we have instructional coaches because we
070no longer have the literacy Grant at the elementary level so we have instructional coaches across our buildings we also have peer reviewers but our coaches are aligned in what we should be looking for in our classrooms um each year teachers are engaged in at least one formal coaching cycle with their instructional coach and they can request additional coaching sessions from their coaches um as needed and as um their time permits but the coaching Cycles are around curriculum implementation for example Benchmark or adalante um as Rachel has shared um the work that we are implementing the curriculum that we're implementing right now at the elementary level it also can be around a new math curriculum the new science work that's being rolled out and so coaching can happen around curriculum it can happen around instruction and
071and it also can happen around something specifically that a teacher requests and lastly um this year it is expected that all principls are in classrooms at least once per month giving feedback to teachers around instructional practices it is an expectation from superintendent owski and so principes are in classrooms visible monthly providing feedback but also coaches are in classrooms supporting and our directors are in classrooms as well observing and providing instructional um feedback they are also at the table when the teams have meetings around the data our data teams meetings instructional leadership team meetings they attend plc's all of these different things infrastructure to support instruction in our schools we also have a strong focus on uh a variety of professional development activities uh with our staff one of our biggest lifts this year is letters
072training so letters as you know stands for language Essentials for teachers of reading and spelling um and this is a professional development program that all of our K5 classroom teachers um as well as our K5 teachers and our K12 special education staff and K12 reading interventionists are participating in so this is really around what are evidence-based practices in literacy instruction aligned with um the science of reading and then how do we make sure we're implementing those practices in tandem with our curriculum so we've got uh a variety of different ways that teachers are engaging in that learning this year both through Afterschool learning acmy as well as sessions on professional development days um we are also training all of our districtwide coaches including our instructional coaches and our peer reviewers in letters as well so
073that they are fully equipped to support those practices when they are doing their coaching when they're co-planning with teachers when they're modeling when they're observing when they're co- teing alongside of them we also continue to have a very robust um professional Learning Community model so we um have teacher leaders who facilitate their plc's and those teacher leaders participate in ongoing training and feedback sessions throughout the year to increase their skills in facilitation to increase their understanding of how to effectively look at data um and make instructional decisions using that data um how to look at student work samples and consider what's the next best step for students based on those and then we have aligned all of our our calend professional development days to follow a similar structure um with Choice sessions in the morning
074followed by building specific professional development and then teacher directed professional learning um the choice sessions have allowed us to offer differentiated PD to all of our staff so that they have the opportunity to take courses that are aligned to what they teach um sometimes what they need some relicensure credits um in or what they feel is going to best help them move forward in their practice while also making sure that we stay focused on our district priorities and then with data and systems we use fastbridge to screen all students in reading math and social emotional behaviors K through 12 and then K through 9 um I'm sorry we use fast bridge to screen all students at social emotional Behavior twice a year K through 12 and then in academics K through 9 nine three times
075a year once in the fall once in the winter and once in the spring students who are below Benchmark in any one of those areas uh fastbridge recommends an intervention and our teachers are learning to use the intervention report to do either whole class small group or individual interventions now the cool thing about fastbridge is it also provides a progress monitoring tool so instead of waiting instead of doing an intervention and waiting three to four months to see if it worked or not um we can also do progress monitoring either weekly or bi-weekly depending on what how intense the intervention assessment is some are one-on-one and some are more computerized so depending on how intense it is you might do that bi-weekly or weekly but then we can monitor um whether or not the intervention
076is working and either um increase the amount of time we do the intervention for increase the number of days we do the intervention for or if the intervention is not working find a different intervention Al together right and so um I think K through n the progress monitoring has gotten much better this year and we're starting to see um Trends going in the right direction standards-based grading continues to make improvements both pedagogically and technically on the PED pedagogical side we continue to increase uh instructional Clarity with professional development and coaching making sure our learning targets and success criteria connect connect to standards and that those standards have a direct correlation to rubrics on which the students will be assessed um on the technical side we're just getting much cleaner on being very clear to students
077um when things will be graded and when things need to be turned in by or retaken for additional scoring and so um that's that and then analytics and insights formerly called who knew it our director of technology has spent hours and hours and hours um making sure we have accurate clean live dat data um to continuously look at how our students are doing bless you so at the conclusion of our presentation we hope we have accomplished our learning Target by sharing um the outcomes of our comprehensive achievement and career Civic Readiness goals and also you've learned about our School Readiness outcomes career and college readiness outcomes High School graduation and racial and achievement gaps and with that we will take any questions you have for for us thank you very much right open floor who
078has questions comments I just have one comment uh it's back to like the the age gap for Latino students and I think like I see it in classrooms all the time where like teachers put translations of like in Spanish of the instructions the lessons or even writing it down on paper and I think it's like a really good like step to take for students to make that effort or like to see that growth I like there's so many Spanish speakers that are now like learning that English and I think it's very nice cuz I'm like I guess we both have a better set of communication set and yeah that's it I just appreciate the schools thank you so much Bess always appreciate the insights from the classroom I'll say way right on to that it's
079like a Rosetta Stone for Spanish to English but you know we do test everyone for MCAS okay and we do have a increasing number of newcomers and less than two years in country kids from all over the world but when you look at the Latino kids no you know of course our scores are going to be low they can't read they can't they're not literate in English yet is there a way and I'm sure I've asked this before is there a way that we can Factor them out to see what the over two years or the you know the those who are more literate in English are doing and I don't know if that's a Richfield issue or if that's a I think that's a state issue around expectations for the MCA we do know
080that um our what we do know is that our e director Dr will height um she assesses in partnership with principles and our e teachers um our e students um annually um using the access test to assess how well they are um progressing academically and so that is a test specifically um to assess them around Reading Writing and speaking and so that is used to again um director Ken to figure out you know how they're growing but I think as as far as what is expected for the for motans um around the MCA all students must be um must be tested it would be interesting to someday factor out the the the newcomers and see what our scores are thank you uh that was a lot thank you that may be one of those back
081to where we chunk it up a little bit because I I feel like my questions are delayed and we I I'm going to hold my hand in advance in case you answered this and I totally blanked on it um one of the things that got my attention is is back to the naming very very back to the beginning right is uh world's best Workforce to CCR comprehensive achievement and career Readiness um and one of the things you talk about is is Civic Readiness which I feel like we gloss over that is that me or did I miss that no I don't think we I so so Civic Readiness then strictly like um whether not our students ready to go get a job and work versus what I would consider true Civic Readiness so um in
082moving forward we will be able to pull data as to see where our students are enrolling in college that could be something that we could share dur during this report that will be an indicator of Civic Readiness um and again his graduation rate this is this is new we pulled this report together for this school year but this is um a new format and it will continue to get better as we continue to report out to you all I'm just curious and this is not necess a question for you guys right this is this is a state thing and like Curious what the state's going after and like what it really means to districts outside of the metro area for example right and so I just um right it it has certain undertones and I'm
083curious how that'll change in the upcoming years so that's I'm just curious cuz it that's good it didn't feel like guys really address that and I don't think that's a d on you it's just more of a we use a term but it's like does it really apply MH right how do we measure Civic Readiness and what what does it really mean right is it just to be part of ability to work like are they going to be good citizen yeah I think there's a lot longer discussion on that one um so then uh I'm gonna try my best to say this right because I I thought I heard flip-flopping on terms but the teachers weren't keen on the two times year learning walks is it is that it's not popular no okay so so
084then the my immediate question especially as we think about close session and negotiations did they come back with a we prefer this if you guys are saying we want to do that they don't like it then what would they propose as a better choice from their perspective I think they would prefer that we just trust them as professionals and um not be in their space for the the 10 to 15 minutes that we're in our space twice per year they not not everyone but some teachers view it as us not trusting them and trusting them to be professionals which we do we do understand but we um have an expectation we report to you all annually around this work and we look at the data as a team quite frequently with the um fast assessments
085the screeners that we give in the fall the winter and the spring and when we look at the results we feel um the a moral imperative to do things differently in order to raise achievement for students and so it may cause some discomfort in the moment but the the the larger picture the larger goal is how are we improving around our instructional practices when we know that instruction is the main lever to pull or to push whatever you want to call it in order to improve achievement so we have to have a pulse on what's going on in the classroom do we share these numbers of these charts with the teachers absolutely and just because I'm looking go again right is like they go well stop doing the learning walks we don't like them they're
086dumb whatever they want to say but but then look look at the numbers right it's like the numbers are like there's a problem we're trying to fix it right because your point is like we're asking these questions going I mean uh when I look at this of the four numbers that you're tracking three of them we got worse on one we stay the same on right that doesn't it's not a great showing right so then there's a problem somewhere and if they don't have a recommendation to fix it right it's like we're trying to do something MH okay yeah so we do share and this work is Led um directly by our directors but the the rubric or the practice profile that's used that's shared with all teachers that's shared with the principal that's shared
087with the instructional leadership team we invite instructional leadership team members the directors to participate in the learning walk protocol with us along with other directors again to build trust to build transparency around the process as well and then at the conclusion when they've collected the aggregate data Rachel and I Alex and I we go back out meet with the instructional leadership teams around the aggregate scores for them to discuss their wins and their opportunities to um address some of these things in their um School Improvement plans and building level professional development we use it to drive District level professional development um perhaps program level professional development but this is how we're using that data to drive Improvement and change and so um we continue to um fight that fight the good fight that uphill battle
088but it is it is not a popular um strategy for us to be employing right now it's not and I think just to paint a picture for board members so you can hear what is different so our teachers are used to a principal coming in their room on a regular basis they're used to an instructional coach coming in on a regular basis typically they get some form of specific feedback based B on their performance that comes out of those visits um a learning walk is about systemwide data so it's not giving an individual teacher feedback and it is done by a group of people not an individual or one or two so imagine walking in in the middle of a lesson right so imagine five people coming in it's like rounds and er when we
089it's like rounds and er like you might see on TV so there are five or six people coming in rather than the one or two and then they're not giving you specific feedbacks three or four there's a group but they're not giving specific feedback on how you did they're actually trying to do this from a systemwide level but it creates a feeling a feeling of stress and it doesn't happen every day if they did it every day which we're not suggesting uh that would actually reduce the stress level when I started it wasn't as much of a common practice for principles to be in rooms on a regular basis or um I recall for my first year people were very uncomfortable that the superintendent was going in classrooms on a regular basis and so was
090the assistant soup and so once people get more and more accustomed they do get more and more used to it and it creates less stress um but this is because it only happens a couple times a year it it just is always going to increase some tension so and that's attention we're just going to have to Little B I I think that's one of the things that with anything that's different like what can we do to help our staff understand why we do a big because what I hear is similar arguments to against the MCA like but why do we do it if I like I personally am not getting but maybe if we get to understand that this is actually just the quality control so that we can have an a good picture of
091like kind of comparing Apples to Apples and hearing that you know certain grade levels are teaching the same things that the quality of the instruction because I think sometimes we study and I know that we don't have that many lessons and I'm sure that's that's probably been in an email but like uh that kind of understanding like maybe during the staff meeting like I want you to know that like and this is these are the results because I think sharing back like collectively speaking this is what we learn from the thing and this is how that's changing can make it a little bit less cuz I'm imagining you know that's never you know a a a little thing and disrupt the remainder of the day especially in early Elementary in my position you know so
092that but if teachers get to see the the value of that then can negotiate more and and and in my director's defense they do so from um fall to winter they will share in fact they'll even share from um from what winter to fall if there is Improvement and then also from fall to winter if there is Improvement and that those changes are shared with with the team and when we target target specific areas with professional development many times we see a jump and that's also shared with teams as well with respective instructional leadership teams and principles as well so yeah we do share the the wins with the staff that is an area of strength for the teaching and learning department so they will also then offer professional development based on the findings and
093they're very clear you know if we are implementing Benchmark and there's something that needs more attention uh Rachel will Design professional development for our staff on our PD days related to that work and related to the findings and then we share back these were the findings hey by the way here's the PD that we're going to be serving and be offering because that was defined as a need for our system thank you that answer your question or do you have more go ahead I do have one more yeah thank you uh just that that last comment you may see if all principles are in are are now in the classroom once per month I'm assuming that's one class per month no all so the principles are in classrooms on a more than monthly regular regular
094basis um that's every classroom in every building the expectation is that the principal is in that classroom and rece the teacher is receiving feedback on what is seen at least one times per month and they are expected to be in classrooms a significant time more than that um and so they're in classrooms on a regular basis and then they documenting feedback at least on a monthly basis and so like in the high school then is that divided between the assistant princip uh they do yeah they share responsibilities in buildings with the multiple administrators and then I believe in both of our secondaries they are generally responsible for each different curricular areas but they also rotate to make sure that they're all getting a glimpse of all of the classrooms thank great took one my questions
095thank you um you had mentioned that the third grade reading um is going to be reported in the future under the redact report is it the same data the same test or is it switching to something new no it will be switching to fast Bridge so it's based on our Universal screening assessment required by the state okay and then as a part of that is there like a three to five year trajectory goal that we can see when you bring that to that information to us I'm just wondering like how fast f are we hoping to close that Gap yeah um so as you know last year was our first year with fastbridge what we are um all of us at the management team level and principles we've all aligned our goal right so that
096we are looking for at least 80% of our students to be making typical or aggressive growth so um rather than you know necessarily a certain proficiency level we're looking for um that closing in the gap for all students okay good thank you and then um Alex you had mentioned um in the fast Bridge fast Bridge test is tests reading math and social emotional Behavior can you talk a little bit about how it tests social emotional Behavior what does that look like yeah so there's two components to that and it's done twice a year not three times a year okay um one is there's a student survey more or less so students kind of fill out a survey and then advisory teachers actually also fill out something for each student in their ad and then I
097don't know the inner workings have fast but there are numbers that are reported and then just like in literacy or math there are students who are okay you know identified as maybe needing attention and then we see so it's like a it's like a rating from the teacher based on what they've experienced in the last few months or correct okay yep I was trying to figure out how that would be tested on a computer yeah well one day you'll just look at it it'll just know yeah hey pay attention yeah good uh um uh going back to Ken's comment about you know is there a way for us and we've talked about this before like how do we look at students that we've had enough time to make a strong impact on right so students
098that have been here for two three years um I think I'd like to see in data like what does what does churn look like for our students how many like what percent of our students have been here less than 12 months by grade what percent students have been here less than 24 months per grade and anytime we look at that kind any data where we're comparing to the state I want to know I want to know about the success of what we're doing to help our teacher or our students rather acclimate into the systems of teaching that we have rather than you know a swath of everyone is the same you know if someone's been here as Ken mentioned for four months and they don't speak the language yet it's really hard to expect them
099to do well so each spring um Alex and Rachel they provide an update to the board and that's something that we can um ensure as a part of the presentation how our students are the students who've been in Richfield for x amount of years how are they performing also our als's how are they performing on the access test and and um Dr will height will definitely give um her presentation with that information in it but that's something that we can include in our spring presentation to the board great thank you any other questions comments I want to just say thank you so much for all the work that you do um uh from from my mom experience I know that uh both my kids seem to be having a lot of fun uh and learning
100at school and that's always so encouraging to to hear and I know you uh have invested a lot of time and resources with the professional learning communities making a learning culture uh for our staff and that's that's that's a culture on its own all so thank you for the work that you do building that uh because that's that's that's how we move kids forward thank you thank you director call we leing I look forward to seeing iic as a chair having to wait till the very last minute to ask questions that's going to be fun the expectation is that you guys will get all the questions that was a nice present to close we will what right right all right that concludes our superintendent update and and now we move on to commendations all right
101so we've got two commendations for you tonight first RPS would like to commend CJ Armstrong senior basketball player at Richfield High School CJ recently broke the alltime boys basketball scoring record of 1,747 points he's now working towards scoring 2,000 points a number that also has not been done in Richfield history CJ recently signed on to play basketball at Augusta next year congratulations to CJ the basketball team will be having a celebration for him tomorrow night in correlation with the Bas game so congratulations CJ and then RPS would also like to commend Associates and Women's Health and obgy Specialist Clinic sonography Department donating pants um underwear and products to uh feminine hygiene products to be given to RMS students through the health office was part of the power to you pants Drive which aims to support
102and Empower students in experiencing menstration at school so thank you to the members of the sonography department for supporting our RMS students we put this in combinations because um donations that come to Richfield public schools go in through donations but donations that are funneled off to students um come in a different way and so this was uh this was something we just wanted to acknowledge with accommodations we thank them also thank you very much uh and congratulations to CJ quite a nice fit all right with that we moving into consent agenda is anyone ready to uh move the consent agenda for approval I'll move the consent agenda I'll second we have a motion by director police and a second by director Spencer before we move into a vote are there any additional questions to be
103made about any of the items in the consent agenda see known can go for a vote uh all in favor please say I I I I any oppos chair vot and the consent agenda is approved and this brings us to all business beginning with policy 979 Community use of school facilities and grounds this one's for Action yes we are hoping for a passage Upon A fifth read we have major uh major changes but not related to um our new update of the policy just a couple of small changes uh very small since the last reading um but just as a reminder um this governs our facility usage our facility rental not long-term lease and also the prioritization about how space is governed and so we just wanted this in front of you um for um
104the final review for hopeful passage are there any questions final questions about this one see know anyone ready to move move this uh policy for uh review for approval I'll move the policy as presented I'll okay um uh director police has made a motion director car I'm G to give this one to you here you first H for a second all in favor please say I I oppose CH vot I and policy 979 has been uh the review has been approved next one is policy 5:1 graduation requirements and administrative guidelines this on also for Action today uh yes so this is a third read we have gotten comprehensive feedback on this particular policy um this um would realign our credits uh the specific changes are most important on page two um updating the components of
105the class of 2026 where students would only be required to complete one credit of PE thus expanding by one uh to 17 elective credits and then in 2028 um the new requirement of the state for a credit of personal finance which would then uh reduce them back down again to 16 elective credits and so just clarifying those components and making sure that all the expectations realigned to the state uh providing that full flexibility for our kids um while also making sure we get the comprehensive opportun unities um and just as a reminder elective students have all of the choice they could possibly want this would not change any of that are there any questions comments or concerns um I want to thank the uh seniors at the high school for their uh excellent uh presentations
106uh public comments and participation uh during the ma um meeting I also want to share that after three years of my son being at the high school I had no idea that he only needed two electives for PE and he's been take he's taking like seven by now so we had some conversations at home about the elective so yeah from an elective perspective um our fax classes and our PE classes are amongst the most popular of the things that are not uh required for kids and we have a number of students who just take repeated numbers of those uh again none of those things change and we try to drive our staffing based on the requests and needs of our kids yet we have enough who didn't want to do to required well so there's
107a difference between required and choice right there are as we also heard and you heard there are are also students who do not necessarily participate or feel it feels like they're assigned and then there's also some who feel like their choices are restricted by that this would again kids who wanted to take seven times um could absolutely still take seven times probably five again based on the priorities of the board providing that opportunity for choice for our kids providing fewer restrictions um that aren't required I'm impressed with the sophomore with seven PE credits down well no I I I recounted he's a junior so this will be five I I I added an extra two because he feels that way um but for someone whose favorite subject was recess I guess I shouldn't have been
108surprised that's right well so you can the two required okay so it's an interesting point whether intended or not of like would we ever want to go ahead and say restrict the number of electives in a certain class or like could you retake certain class or you're like to right than put stipulation that I think that I think for a lot of students the their electives are kind of cut out for them based on like what they need to graduate uh there's also some things that I know for example at my house we have like a mom required elective that required elective uh and to get out of that requirement there's like permissions need to be made and I actually allowed the skap of Spanish because of PE this year so I'm like you know
109he didn't H so you make a good point but I also don't know I don't know restricting sounds kind of harsh and and sports is so important well on the other hand if a kid want to get into a physically related postsecondary program for example exercise science or something like that the more PE credits they have the more competitive they'll be for the college too our our limitations I would say are limited to as long as the student is not mathematically eliminated the potential of graduation right right and and I trust that the guidance department is catching that I mean it's just at some level right our job here is to discuss these things and like think it through right I mean and it's interesting to hear Steve's comment of like we're trying to be
110as least restrictive as possible and then I also think from a parent perspective like PA point do I look and reflect on the electives that my children have chosen because like I'm like do you really need another study hall you know it's question we have in the Carter household right it's like so um not that ever hear me say that on mic but but that's the case right so um and then I look and to go if we help give direction for um other families and right we're we're trying to help other parents like how do they get this advice Guidance just reflecting on it I guess right so I'm I'm just going to remind the board in my lovely 11 years in Richfield um the values of student voice student empowerment and choice have
111been a consistent message of the group um and so certainly educating and informing our kids and we've often heard feedback that we need to do a better job of informing our students or communicating in a way that is heard and lands um but it would be a very significantly different move on behalf of this board if we were to suggest um that we're going to begin reducing student voice um which would be telling them no we have decided that you don't get those options I I don't I just will always say I don't prefer to have students taking 10 of the same class and it's not my role and responsibility restrict that that that's up to the student and the guidance of this board has been consistent in it really helps me lead that you
112all have been very consistant in and yet that's what the kids want it doesn't hurt them in any way from graduation it doesn't uh do anything it is it is what they want and what they value that we're supposed to try to align to so I think there's also at least my experience with my kids and the guidance counselors there's been a couple examples of the guidance counselor going are you sure you want to do that or I recommend you do this other thing instead right and so I think we let the guidance counselors guide um the students in that way and and the requirements that are put out by the state and ratified here within this for our own students um you know there are a good number of electives but depending on what
113your career path is those electives very quickly go away um if you want to get um the Dual language certification that takes a lot of the credits away if you want to go on to um post-secondary education there's additional Math and Science requirements that are part of that or second language requirements that are part of that that very quickly eat away at those electives and so I don't think you're going to see very many students take that many pa pe courses um yes and I hear what you're saying and I appreciate it those are the kids who are going down those special tracks really my question is more well than kids who aren't right and it's like um I also appreciate C's point I just GL see do we say anywhere in here that the
114whole point is to get the students choice because I think to your point it's like at some level writing down that directive I think is helpful in general like how do we leave our Mark and saying that in five years when we look at this policy when we are all not here um that the policy that we say oh yeah right it's like we talked about it and well you may be here Tim I don't know um where we say where we say this was kind of the direction and guidance of the board and the spirit of the policy just again reflecting on why are we all looking at you I don't know I never know because Tim might be here in five years I I I just come back to like we are setting
115you know what the requirements are for graduation and leaving as much as we are comfortable up to student choice is is the way we want our students to do it so they can guide their own path and take what is relevant and meaningful to them but yeah so that it keeps them in engaged it's not up to us it's not you know C certainly you know my own children don't take my advice I don't imagine many others would so I'm not you know I I we we want to you know align with statute we want to align with um what what makes sense from a community standpoint and then after that it it really is student choice and if a student decides they want a lot of physical education classes as director list had said
116it could be you know certainly very relevant to them for for post-secondary life um or it could just be something that keeps them coming to the building on a on a routine basis and keeps them interested and and aligned and attached to the building and the community in that way and helps all their other courses that might not be their favorites so as as flexible as possible I think is what we should be and thank you for highlighting the uh relevant section that says the spirit of what we're trying to accomplish which is on page two of policy 5 21 yeah just say it's intended that students have some Choice as to when requirements are met those pages will shift as soon as the red lines are right done all right Some Mo a second
117I'll second it have a motion by director carer and a second by director Lee all in favor please say I I oppos Che vot I and policy 5 to1 is approved the next one is policy 606 for homeschooling and administrative [Music] guideline yes uh just trying to go through policy three with a recommendation for passage um this one is mostly updated in regard to formatting um and um remains um um a very similar policy to what it had in the past so this is our third reading guiding how we support homeschooled students um there are currently 90 in the district representing 45 families so with that we have um again no significant changes since our last meeting third read I'm hoping for passage tonight of homeschooling and the accompanying guideline all right any questions comments
118motions I'll move the policy as presented I'll second it's a motion by director police and a second by director Spencer all in favor please say I I any opposed CH vot I and policy 606 is approved the next one is a draft policy 414 staff professional boundaries and draft administrative guideline for our review yes and so this is for a second read and again this is a second uh Reed we've had this reviewed by HR uh safe and supportive schools the student groups at RMS and RP and then we have also had a read from education Richfield I will summarize and synthesize to say we have gathered a great deal of feedback um we got a list of comments asking for some additional clarification some rewarding uh we do have a set of that in
119front of you tonight um and so there are some changes and some additional clarifications in regard to um how we clarify safeguards for adults when interacting with students um in the community and on time uh we actually don't anticipate this one being passed with just three reads we might um but we also believe that this needs to go through our attorney um we'll gather additional feedback as we redraft um so we're going to anticipate possibly taking a break um prior to seeing this again and this one will we'll probably take a couple of more reads before we pass it and so we just want this in front of you with the updates uh for you all to read tonight right quick question about parents Square because I think I feel like when we talk about
120this policy we keep coming back to parent square and um are we doing additional training with par Square uh yes we're continuing to do additional training in paren square we continue to do additional training with coaches um and our plan is to continue to implement that in a more effective way it still does provide challenges um but I would also say there are additional questions um clarification for those who live in the community um work in the community and also have relationship with families inside and outside and how does how does this policy provide Clarity on that uh questions were related to what is where does the Richfield Public Schools um oversight stop and when does somebody being a Community member begin um how do we make sure we're being clear about what is an
121emergency when people should drive home when they shouldn't drive home how you do communicate how you don't communicate how we post things publicly and at times gather things together to create a an amalgam of pictures together rather than just one at a time and so there there's a bunch of questions that that as we play this out um again we're just going to need to work our way through and take our time this one might take um again several readings and SE several revisions and as a reminder this is the kind of thing that we Implement in the fall um as we pass um as we pass this over the course of whatever time over the course of this year thank you um I I just had one question because I know that this is
122a this is a new policy for us correct yes um and so is this replacing anything or is there something similar to this that's already in place that we should be referencing uh not in Richfield schools there is an msba policy and there's a large number of districts that have a similar policy um and so we are just working our way to do that to provide some clarity and some of the things we've had long-term Clarity challenges on are um how does one determine what's appropriate to place on the internet how does one determine what is appropriate in terms of communication with students and how do we how do we get super clear about that um in a way that supports our team members and supports our students most effectively and was it uh a
123state mandate that created this or uh no it is just strongly recommended um and then also based on some of the practices we're really trying to make sure align to board vision and successful oversight we want we want to try to provide that Clarity to our team members thank you any other questions comments it's just great to see that the student input has been input and I think we need to recognize the students one way or another that they actually had a voice and I can do that the next yeah we do that in safe and supportive but similarly um so if you think about graduation requirements where we had the high schoolers um in social studies um I'll be meeting with the instructional coach and the team at the high school and there will
124be conversation in uh Senior High School Social Studies classes uh to review the changes that were made and the conversation that happened so so we do try to Circle back and make sure that communication occurs all right looks like no more questions at this time I can move on to the next draft RPS legislative platform 2025 yes legislative platform um take two and so again we now have um we just did a little bit of rewording um we now have the amsd msba and M ASA platforms just as a reminder of the code um the one uh at the end so if you look at provide permanent funding for future comp Revenue left in Jeopardy du to Universal free meals you'll see one two and three one is amsd two is msba three is Masa
125um and so we wanted to leave that documentation for you all we also highlighted in blue the things that carried over from last year and then I also want to point you to um 109 and 110 and 111 in the packet what our legislators typically ask for is some of the data and information backing these up and so we added that to our draft um and so we are um looking for additional feedback which could certainly occur tonight or anytime over the next couple of weeks prior to our next board meeting uh we'll look to finalize this at our next board meeting and then use it as a conversation piece at our second meeting in January and then use that as we support our legislative Partners um during the legislative session thank you any questions
126comments suggestions okay we see those return next time uh we're now moving into new business with a resolution designated bowling places for 20125 all right and so um as we do have an election coming up although this happens every single year uh reported uh it's being asked for us to approve the designated polling places 2025 um we can make future changes by board resolution at least 90 days before the election is needed but uh the resolution asks for this to occur um in December for polling places for the 2025 election cycle so with that I have this for you for a proposed resolution and there's nothing new about these locations correct they they appear to all be uh they are the same to the best of my knowledge the okay thank you I'll move the
127resolution as presented I'll second that have a a res my gosh a motion by director police a second by director Le I'm going to pull the board starting on my left for because it's a resolution director Spencer Hi director car hi director Le hi director police hi and chair vot I and this resolution is approved uh next one is preschool and prek fees for the next coming year 202 2026 yes and so um we uh previously provided free prek for foure roads through voluntary prek however um in the last legislative session there is now a requirement that students and families meet eligibility to participate in free emphasis on the free preschool programs funded through VPK um and so what that means is that it's on each District's responsibility to determine eligibility and determine who doesn't
128meet eligibility and then make decisions about pre and so it's our responsibility to provide a sliding scale for our four-year-olds um and so how this works is um similar to ALC in extended time if students meet one of 12 possible categories um they qualify for free prek if they are determined by our district to be at risk um they also would qualify for free pre and so our process involves um students if they are um if families are voluntarily sharing that they qualify for one of the 12 areas um they would receive free pre um those then choosing to participate in the assessment um may qualify for free pre prek depending on the results um our assessment will determine if they are ready for kindergarten um Readiness for kindergarten um means that they would be
129entering prek already complete and already at a place where they were ready for pre or for kindergarten which is in the entire goal of our prek program um and so then students who weren't ready for kindergarten would also be determined at risk and they could receive free prek the students who are already ready for kindergarten and don't meet any of the other qualifications would then be subject if they wanted to participate in the program to our sliding scale um and so what you have in front of you is um what that sliding scale would be um for our students um to pay if they were required to pay for the prek program and again this is not fully our choice how we choose to implement this is uh we do have some some processes related
130to uh but this is a decision that's made at the state level through legislation um so again the ways to qualify for free prek have changed um and so we have developed and devised the system and have that in front of you um because all fees and things like that uh we bring to the board and so this is this is a collection of fees not currently in use correct that is correct and it's for next year that is correct okay do we have a sense for if we could pretend we had the applications and understanding what what kind of Revenue would we be have been collecting if this was in place already we assume very little um very little and and that and that's based on the the premise that like you'd said there
131are many many ways for someone to qualify for it to be free correct and then there is that District methodology for determining at risk um and so most of our students who are entering prek meaning they are four um would not already be ready for kindergarten which then makes them at risk and so most students would qualify for free prek there would be a small handful um don't know the exact number we'll have that data after this year um but we need this decision to be made now or we need to move forward with this now because people are already beginning to enroll um and we need to be able to inform them as soon as possible about the new impact of the rules um and then have that conversation with them about how they
132choose to handle this I'm just my concern is that some of the the the income cut offs and and and cost related are like I look at the household size of two and the 37815 and that that the person would be be charged $120 a month is that I mean we we we've come up with these figures are they based on um these are we we worked in collaboration with other districts with sliding scale pre okay um and and worked to find I'd say a happy medium and we are generally on the significantly lower end um in regard to projected chart lower end in ter in terms of fees projected fees for participation yes I just I just okay I I don't have more questions right now I'm just I'm been exposed is not being
133as as in the details on this one as I'd want to be in the need to be approved tonight um it's helpful to be approved now because people are already inquiring about enrollment we we could if we determined that fees were too challenging or if our assessment that almost every student is going to qualify for free prek was incorrect um we can come back um and readjust or revise um as we move forward but we need a starting point um and we did the research and work to believe that this is an effective starting point point and we believe this will have an impact on very few families so I think what you're saying is this is this kind of sets a floor that you feel is fair at this point but if we get
134to May or April and we're hearing feedback that it's either too expensive or too expensive for my family's income level it gives us an opportunity to reset that it'll either be less expensive or have a we can adjust it so that it doesn't hurt anybody we could we could revise this in the future if we wanted to yes this would be a start point and we could gather data as we go along because this is brand new we have to find a place to start um and we we thought that this would work um just to make sure I'm understand the scale so like I'm looking at level three so so we go from two to three to four and then to five it dips two to three so these are the annual income yes
135that fifth child is is a bonus that is the threshold for educational benefits we think but yes that that does look like it should be much smaller like these yeah they both dip and overlap in there which is it suggest a household of size five is that sweet spot where everything gets gets easier I have reason not to believe that yeah I think that like like I said I believe this is based on the educational benefits so to pay so so let's use that as an example um if a student whose family is at level two has five children or five in the household sorry three children two adults um or one adult four children they'd have to make between 67 and 73 um their student would already have to be performing as a four-year-old
136or a newly turned four-year-old as a three-year-old not turning four-year-old yet at the entry to kindergarten level and showing that they have letter letter sounds math and numericals and social emotional Behavior at the level of an entering kindergarten then they would be in a position where they would be set up to to not be determined to be at risk um frankly what I would tell you is if that kid exists um that kid does not necessarily need free prek um and the reason to be in prek is um to prep kids for for school now no again we we don't want to eliminate them from the opport I I I think Mr Carter are are you questioning you're willing to support this as is except that the top end of household of size five needs
137to be at least as big as the top top end of household of size four right that that seems like a start because that looks like a typo it does yeah it does so with with that as a correction at least make the top end 74 probably more like 83 160 would be my guess the three was not supposed to be an eight or scale it to to whatever it's supposed to be but that will require some some logical correction yes with that correction coming and I will trust that it is I'll I'll move the item I before we do that because now we're getting into it the uh the the the jump between five and six also like change so are we going to not have rules about are we okay with the I'm
138very comfortable with I will say it looks to me like if if I'm looking at level three um they are increasing with a going from 74 881 in 3 down to 73161 that doesn't seem I would agree it looks like it should probably be a different number um and so I am absolutely going to make sure we go back and double check that and alter that number um to again it looks like a typo that should probably be 83 but I'm not 100% sure um and so I can ack Trend would say 80 the trend Trend would say something not even because that's 9,000 difference and what I'm thinking about forms is that there's when when I've seen tables like this like what the conversation has made me think now is the is the increase
139from one to the from by one adding one human to the household does and generally these tables will have like add this much mhm for any additional person and so if if which we don't have that's so then I'm wondering like these seems arbitrary oh they they seem tremendously arbitrary but they're based on some prior version that was passed and we believe they come from the free and reduced benefits format um and that that's where they they came in um and the cut offs from that okay so so okay so I I I'd moov the item with the need to correct household size five and and and MCO is suggesting that we need to address seven plus household of seven plus or or just make it six plus well no I I Believe Miss Cole
140was saying that there are other forms where you've seen this where each incremental from six to seven would add n or $10,000 to each of the you're right to be in line with other benefits yeah so do we need this today I we can they I'm guessing that the four person will will get us ahead a lot as you know we go through registration Craig is taking a look at the moment and taking a look about the free and reduced information just to match that um what I'd say if we're not comfortable is that if we are able to move it with the expectation that we bring back a revised chart with numbers um that we are able to share that there will be a a sliding scale um a sliding scale and an assessment
141methodology for identifying um at risk which is essentially what we're moving forward um but actually as I look at this um Craig do you have anything otherwise yeah I think we have to bring it back okay so I will I I I move the I'll withdraw the moving the item if we're def certainly bringing it back fine we're just going to bring it back on the 6th of of January I guess I wasn't trying to shoot it down I mean the the one thing I look at to good I get just get concerned as like if I'm seeing this does this makebe go I'm out right I'm not bringing my kids to Richfield for for at least prek uh and and that's not so we're trying to say either right um so that's so every
142District in the state of Minnesota offering free prek has to offer a scale of fee for those who do not qualify for benefits so this is for those who do not qualify for the benefit um okay so in getting communication several ways to to qualify what I would ask the board um since this is hopefully going live tomorrow since the applications are going live is that we are able to pass um that there is a sliding fee scale and the bottom part of the chart that says monthly tuition fee um with the expectation that we bring back the income levels um prior to the next meeting or for the next meeting and so we are saying that there is a sliding scale um that would involve the level one free level two 120 170 250
143and 290 250 and then level three 160 230 and 370 um and that we are expected them come back to the board with cut offs for what qualify for each of those levels um that allows us to communicate out that there's a sliding scale here is the fee um and that we will clarify out what allows us to to qualify for that fee so going back to way earlier in the discussion I believe Mr Spencer had clarified we can update this in the future as needed so what we need this so for business purposes we need something as a placeholder as early as tomorrow ideally yes and I think what Dr Yuni is saying is the monthly tuition fee at the bottom chart the bottom half of the chart is the important thing that we
144need to publish we'll come back with the sliding scale okay at a future with what qualifies for one for the sliding scale huh is that a motion help I will move Craig has one tag in of information so I'm just looking it looks like the level one is um the reduced fee annual salary under educational benefits the level two annual income other than that for family of five I believe each one of those top amounts are 29% more just just over 29% more than the um level one education benefit limit um I'm not and so that range is just generally going to be 29% so you would anticipate if I if my assumptions are right doing the calculations that 67673 if we use that same factor as the others to multiply it'll be 87,000 I
145think is what I came up with but that makes sense with the so that clearly needs a change so so again so I'm just going to bring us back to sliding scale and Mr Spencer you'd move this is that correct yeah I'll move the monthly tuition portion of what we're looking at on on the slide here again with the understanding that the sliding scale is coming yep that's right I will second that wonderful we have a motion by director Spencer and a second by director police in favor please say I I and you post Che votes I and we are approving this one uh with the expectation that we will see an updated uh annual we will have that back for you and cleaned up um and clarified for January 6th perfect which I believe
146is our first meeting or we the fourth so with that we're now into advanced planning uh starting with legislative update are there any updates related to the legisl not um the only update we have um so we just want the board to be aware we have invited um we we had some questions about whether representative Howard will be able to make literally any of the dates um so we actually um have reached out to Senator man and representative green both the elected official from me Dina Who oversee our area of Richfield schools um and Dr man is now in the never mind that's a different one yes um and they are actually uh Ed policy Ed finance and um have voice into some of the things that we are looking at and so it might
147also make our our meeting even more relevant one um I want to share that I went to the uh Minnesota school board association annual delegate assembly last weekend not this one the one before and uh there were 28 policies reviewed mostly passed uh I would say they're mostly in alignment to some of the same things that that we know mostly related to budgets uh the BET be called for uh pushing back against uh unfunded mandates from the legislature uh the feeling that I heard there's not a lot of hope that things are going to uh that not a lot is going to happen next year because of the divided uh Minnesota house um 5050 and all of those chair uh committees there's also h a potential expectation that session is going to go longer that
148there's no way that we're going to end uh by the by the date uh required in May uh but in the meantime what msba directors want us to know is that the meetings where they shat about all the legislative updates are about to start in January and they encouraging us all to go and they also want us to participate when they do their Lobby day uh and also they want to know who Among Us uh is ready to be connected with our elected officials uh for any kind of conversation uh related to that I think in Richfield because we're small and we already have such a strong relationship with our elected official that might not be uh you know something that they will need to do for us but I'm sharing just so that you
149know that Schoolboard members across the state are being encouraged to to to doing that so that'll be that thank you okay informations and questions from board members uh only one quick thing uh reminder that Wednesday uh 2 o'clock is the RP graduation I know that I will be there I know that uh director list looks like director paus will be there um and so if anybody else is interested it is uh I think there are between s and 10 students who are anticipated to graduate in a small brief and yet lovely ceremony when is that 2:00 at orup which day wnes on Wednesday Wednesday thank you some other information about uh City Hall tomorrow's hosting the legislative breakfast beginning at 7:30 that is correct I am attending um and um Mr Holi is also attending
150in case there are connections um or things related to um anything Mr holdi can help with so it should be fun what is that again uh that is the legislative breakfast for the uh City and they they run a little differently than we do so they just run through presentation after presentation um and we try to have a more of a conversation so it's just uh different styles it's a it's an interesting event so like the city council reviewing there the city council reviewed their legislative platform um but theirs is uh they run through each department has a platform and so there are about seven or eight different runs of things that the city will run through um in their conversation we should go what day is that again tomorrow tomorrow 7:30 is that the
151new city council members are we between they have not been seated yet they are seated in January because I think that this week was or last week rather was the last meeting for the previous I'm sure the new members will be present um but they won't be officially council members right council member elects okay any suggested our future agenda items right seeing none I'm going to share the future meeting dates we will be meeting again January 6 uh 2025 at 700 p.m. again this is going to be our board organizational meeting the next meeting after that will be on a Tuesday not a Monday as we uh commemorate Martin Luther King Jr day as so we'll be here Tuesday January 21st at 6: PM uh with a board study session with the local legislators followed
152by a regular board meeting with public coming at 7:00 after that I'm we're going to need to to approve a motion to go into close session as Allowed by Minnesota statute d03 for labor negotiation strategy I'll move that we enter closed session as Allowed by Minnesota statute 13 do3 for labor negotiations strategy second we have a motion by director police a second by director CER all in favor please say I I I any opposed chide and we will now be entering into close session um at 9:3