001called to order it is December 4th 2024 and the time is 6:35 p.m. our mission is to provide a safe and caring climate and culture in which we engage Inspire educate prepare and Empower all Learners in partnership with their surrounding Community to be successful in today's and tomorrow's Society Zach can you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for [Music] all thank you Zach can you please call roll um The Following board members are present at the District administration office Scot andron here El dalren here Zach dhol is here Shannon hos here Heather Williams here following board members are currently not present wait this one is Monica
002Zer Schwartz here okay and absent this evening is uh Natalie Copeland uh following cabinet members and staff for present at the District administration office Dr or superintendent Dr Lorie putam assistant superintendent of secondary education Dr Jason Harris assistant superintendent of E12 Education Services Shannon Aon executive director of Community Education Adam Holm executive director of finance and business services Amy scal executive director of operations Joel Hamp executive director of research enrollment and assessments Don rooper executive director of Special Projects Gary gangji director of community engagement and Communications Tammy Dand media technicians Paul Novak Gordy Scott and custodian on site is Abe Abbot thank you Zach then I'm looking for a motion to approve the Board of Education meeting agenda and work session agenda so move and I I have a second somebody has to fill Natalie's
003shoes thanks Monica motion by Scott second by Natalie Zach can you call vote Monica sorry Scot and Dron yes Shannon H yes Zach D holdz yes Heather Williams yes El doen yes Monica Sara Schwartz yes thank you then we have the consent agenda the consent agenda consists of non-controversial items that the board adopts routinely without debate any single member May remove an item from the consent agenda by requesting removal at the time the consent agenda is move for adoption on tonight's consent agenda item a approval of personnel staff changes Item B Appollo parking lot change order totaling $4,600 item C Apollo ltf improvements change orders totaling $2,682 30 item D approval of board policy 606 textbooks and instructional materials as revised third reading item e approval of board policy 66.5 Library materials as revised third
004reading and item F authorize review and comment submitt to mde at this time does any uh board member wish to remove an item from the consent agenda okay then I'm looking for a motion to approve the consent agenda as read so move and do I have a second second a motion by Scott a second by Heather Z can you call vote shanon hos yes D door holds yes mon SAR schwortz yes Scott andreon yes Heather Williams yes Al doen yes thank you moving on to information items we have one tonight we have the summary reports for the 2023 2024 world's be world's best Workforce and achievement and integration plan presented tonight by Donna Rober executive director of research enrollment and assessments and Ian Omar director of equity Services welcome good evening chair hot superintendent putam
005members of the board listening Community uh it's my pleasure to be here this evening I am here with director Omar um tonight to just share with you a brief um update there have been a number of changes to the world's best Workforce which is an annual report that we have been bringing here to you all for the last several years um it's uh it originally started in 2013 and it was part of the every student succeed EDS act it was the state's way of implementing the every student succeeds act uh it has it's evolving it's transitioning to a new report called the comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness report and so for tonight it's just a brief um what we're required to submit to the state you're going to see our um highlight of some of
006the goals in the areas for that um State requirement that we have you're also going to hear from ion uh direct director Omar on the achievement in integration goals that we set um and going forward what you can expect is that the achievement and integration report will be sort of decoupled from what they're now calling the comprehensive achievement and Readiness report so just a little Logistics on that do you want me to go first Ian or you want to do AI first oh okay so go ahead um Shannon if you want to just go to the next one so um as you all know there are five Big Goal areas in the world's best Workforce uh School Readiness third grade reading on grade level closing gaps career in college readiness and graduation rates these are
007all foundational pieces in our um strategic plan not going away um however they are not all going to be in the comprehensive achievement and um Civic Readiness reporting going forward because in 2023 the state adopted the um the read act which is where they will be moving our third grade reading information to because they'll now be requiring districts to report on all um grade levels in the reading area um the other change that you're going to notice is that they have added um some additional um metrics for us to consider which we're really excited about because they um are going to um compel us to look at other things like Civic Readiness lifelong learning um and metrics that we think matter to Career College and life so we're very excited to see that the state
008is transitioning to this new format um again you can you can go ahead and go to the next slide Shannon okay I think um for for our system and for our strategic plan work all of these are embedded in our strategic plan um one of the changes to the all children ready for school section and you may have heard of this um earlier because this is this is um this is where we talked about rather than just making sure kids are kindergarten ready we we believe it's more about supporting um you know systems and making sure that our students not only have a smooth transition to kindergarten but that our systems are really truly ready to to receive kids coming in so um it it expands our scope of the work when we think about
009Community Partners when we think about just um alignment of our early childhood work to our kindergarten work etc um again growth in the areas of math and reading we are those are areas that we care about and we monitor closing gaps um the world's best Workforce has historically um used language that um asks us to close gaps between groups and we are shifting to closing gaps between learning um proficiencies which which we think is is going to help us move move those gaps more quickly um and then again in the career in life ready just expanding expanding that to um Civic Readiness metrics looking at credentialing and other ways of measuring um career in college readiness and then of course graduation is our our sort of penultima metric that we go we look to and
010that is um a rate that we won't be able to share yet this evening because it hasn't been released so you will see some information on that but um the official graduation rate is TBD and then again just indicating that third grade is moving to D District literacy reporting um and each of the goal areas for the goals that we highlighted for reporting um you can see here that um we are setting very ambitious goals striving to um have as many of our early learning participants ready so while we have 89% and 87% up their meeting we we categorize our progress as continuing and not quite yet met because not all of our incoming kindergarteners even participate in our programming so um as we continue to try to increase participation rates and just increase um
011uh performance in the multiple areas that matter for early Learners um we we set very ambitious goals and so that that one is not yet met um we um although we aren't required to do this one anymore we know that you all care about third grade reading so we decided to include it in this um mini little update and you can see here that we are seeing some progress um again our reading Trends need a little bit more time we're using new measures so we've only got a short amount of a runway on these um new measures the fastb assessments but we do think that we are seeing some really good progress um in instruction and we just know with all of the development that's happening with teachers around training around letters all of that
012is really um going to take time for us to realize that in our um reading Trends but we are we are monitoring that closely uh as far as closing gaps while we did see a small decrease in the gap between uh the student group that we identified which was ourl and our non-fl um we still feel we have more to do we didn't quite meet that one we'll continue to work on that um and then with our career in college readiness again continuing to work on making sure that all of our ninth graders all of our sixth through e8th graders are participating in the new get ready Gear Up activities um kids are participating in some credentialing College course um uh experience and that um all of our kids leave us having a personalized learning
013plan that sets them on a pathway to success beyond beyond graduation um and then again our four and seven-year uh grad rates which will be coming out uh and we will get those to you when those do come out um interestingly we had a conversation at the last AI committee that I think um director Reams brought up related to just graduation success and we said you know that's a that's a good idea for us to look into so I am sharing just the raw numbers for you to see the number of grads um in the 23 and the 24 school year and these would include kids who are in a four five six seveny year cohort so and then just as we move forward we Are You Know A District that is embracing continuous Improvement
014and so we will continue as a part of um not only the comprehensive achievement and Civic Readiness work that we're required to do but our own strategic plan um we will continue engaging and collaborating with folks um we are obviously monitoring supporting um monitoring and supporting the needs as we go um our hope is that we are finding new and novel ways to innovate and activate around those best practices not only in tier 2 and tier three but also in our just general tier one classrooms and again that's happening with all the new learning that folks are doing around the science of reading letters Etc and then again just that very important practice um we we grow our muscles by reflecting and learning and so making time to make sure that we're doing that um
015I is going to give you an update on what we set for AI and the results there Shannon I have all right uh good evening chaira superintendent Pam and members of the school board uh this evening per state legislation I will provide an achievement in integr integration progress update for year one of three uh specifically looking at 23 year 23 24 the plan which can be found on our district website outlines strategies to address racial disparities and improve student integration from 23 to 2026 uh the plan details goals focused on improving academic achievement for our uh historically underserved students increasing access to diverse teachers and boosting racial and economic integration it lists specific strategies including targeted interventions family engagement initiatives and professional developments which measure with measurable key indicators of progress for each the plan
016also incorporates a multi-district collaboration Council and a community collaboration Council to ensure diverse stakeholder input emphasizing collaboration with a joining districts and a commitment to meaningful engagement with napac previously known as APAC finally our plan includes a dedicated section focusing on District's racially identifiable School Lincoln Elementary adapting the districtwide strategies to address its specific needs um the achievement integration plan focuses on reducing the achievement disparities increasing access to effective and diverse teacher Workforce increase racial and economic integration um if you recall uh about I would say two years ago I sat here and presented uh a new set of goals that we will continue continue to progress monitor for 23 to 2026 we have two achievement goals one focuses on our graduation goal and the other one focuses on our third grade MCA reading proficiency
017rates for our black non-el our American Indian students are Hispanic and our two or more racist uh students by 2026 we're looking to raise our raise our uh third grade MCA readings to 50% % um looking at year 1 update um 22 to 23 um starting with our graduation goal we set a goal of graduation rates for students who identify as black Hispanic American Indian or two or more races to reach 85% we have not yet met that goal um if you can see our our data shows that our black students are graduating at 61.2% our American Indian students at a small count are about 40% our Hispanic students 48.3% and our two or more racist students um are at 40.8% if we look at that same group of students and focus on our Elementary
018uh third grade MCA reading proficiency we are we have not yet met that goal as well um with our black students reading at 22.5% um American Indian student group is too small to count looking at our Hispanic students at 13.8% and our two or more races at 23.1% um we also have an integration goal that focuses on concurrent courses um and we Define our concurrent courses to include our AP our college and schools and PSO students um in 9 through 12 so we we set a goal uh that we were going to go from 11% to 25% by 2026 and we have surpassed that goal at 28% um we and we're continuing to monitor that um and then finally we have our access to diverse teacher Workforce as our final goal um we set a
019goal uh to go from 6.38% uh teachers of color to 8% and that's another goal that we have surpassed at 8.5% um so while we're closely monitoring all these goals to continue to sustain and improve um it's it's exciting to report that we have met our integration goal and our access to diverse teacher Workforce um we have one racially identifiable school and that's Lincoln and for Lincoln we set an achievement goal that monitors the um MCA reading test for our uh students who are eligible for free and reduced uh price meals um to go from 16.7% in 2022 to 36% by 2026 we have not yet met that goal at Lincoln um we are currently at 14.7% um our integration goal for Lincoln focuses on ensuring that 100% of our families new to linin new
020to linoln feel supported and welcome um through social emotional um learning meetings uh as well as welcome meetings um and we have met that goal I had the pleasure of sitting down with principal Murphy to take a look at uh what how what those welcome meetings look like and feel like and uh they continue to be in in progress continue uh to be in place it's something that principal ebnet started that principal Murphy continues to uh ensure is in place through the Seal team at Lincoln and then also ensuring that um Lincoln has access to a diverse teacher Workforce we set a goal for Lincoln in 20122 there were three teachers of color at Lincoln and we wanted to maintain that number um but I'm happy to report that we have increased from three teachers
021of color to four teachers of of color and just for context for this group um when we set these goals uh third grade was at Lincoln and since link uh third grade has moved to tahi so even with that we continue to maintain a pretty good number there uh just looking at next steps and ongoing um just different ways that different initiatives that we hope to um Implement uh to boost all of our goals uh to maintain maintain improve and so forth uh really looking at that safety belonging and Excellence across the district um looking at new instructional practices fast Bridge reading uh we have the attendance campaign uh new classroom teachers new staff increase in family Advocate positions um we have the future 100 initiative that started this year in collaboration with Community Partners
022we have our fles learning program um uh Dr Jer has done amazing work in our district with both staff teachers and students uh and just new learning all around thank you okay thank you very much does anybody have any questions at all Scott what's future 100 so that's a new program or something yes I I will start and I invite both Dr Pam and Dr Harris to contribute as well um the future 100 uh is in collaboration with uh Community Partners organizations and businesses to really secure uh the transition from for our seniors from a from from us to postsecondary Opportunities whether it's military uh the trade school going to a four-year College whatever the opportunities are just making it accessible and attainable for our students students does it have anything to do with the
023Community Schools no no okay that it okay um Heather and then El can you go back to the slide um the first one that has the met and the end metet yeah the next one I think go back on yeah I don't even know what I'm asking I guess when you look at these um and you're trying to think about how we actually make progress as a society what what's the answer I and I know that that's a broad question that really asks nothing because it's too broad but if we're assessing grade level reading um at third grade and the percentage no it's not this slide go to the um I mean our goal is 50% and we're in many cases in low 20s and Below that's a lot of kids who are not meeting
024um what is a basic assessment and I I mean I think about kids and I try and think about if you're not hitting that Mark at third grade what magically happens beyond that how what's the what's the key to to increasing that and then I guess another question that I have and Donna this gets to what we talked about in the committee meeting a little bit is um how does this reflect the true number how how um and remind me like for students who start and leave you know how do we track that or are they included in these numbers and so we never really know what the progress is because there's no way to track a there's there's so much with this population of students that is transitory and um I don't know like
025and I know you're you're implementing actions and you're trying to look at best practice is um but we talk about it well as the world's best Workforce and and the need for Community um partnership what does that look like uh and do we have measures that give us hope so let me throw one other thing in there like do we measure anything around Community engagement um so do we know if students have Big Brothers Big Sisters if they're involved in that organization do we know that that creates a better outcome if they're involved in um kid stop or boys and girls club or some if they're involved in theater programs or some something if they have mentors is there something that correlates in any sort of fashion that says hey here are some in the
026world of college we talk about high impact practices what are high impact practices that are more likely to help kids graduate or stay stay enrolled or these sorts of things where's what sort of tips can we give to our community that say these are investments we have to make both both personal and and community- based thank you for that question it's that's a really hard question right um let me say a couple things first of all the highest performing third grade school if you will school that had the highest rates of proficiency in the state their their proficiency rate was 87% and they have 16 kids so so I'm just going to tell you that a school with 16 children got 87% right um I also want people to understand that the Minnesota I'm not
027making excuses but I want you to understand the Minnesota standards in Minnesota are much higher like if you were to use a norm referenced assessment to see who's on grade level versus the MCAS you know when I look at the MCAS I I tend to think even if you're not at 350 or 450 or 550 if you're at like 443 you're probably at grade level right but we don't always you know get to to get to include that so that's another thing is just to know that our standards are really pretty rigorous and um and we want all kids to achieve our standards because in Minnesota we have very good highquality education and we are striving to improve those um I do think this is a broader conversation that's happening around accountability systems and what
028we want and should be adding um so you bring up you know some really good um pieces there for example you talked about what I would call the the student well-being metrics which often you know Al talks about that often too and I've I've heard many of you speak about that we know that you know there's been um lots of research on Readiness to learn in your brain and where you need to be and so those are really important metrics opportunities and access to learning those are also really important um you know so and I do think that our teachers are working tirelessly to improve the performance of students when it comes to learning and reading and comprehending and writing and speaking and you know it it's it's huge and so I and I and
029I believe that they are working tirelessly right and um that still there isn't the clarity in the community at home you know of what it takes to be ready for the next level always and so we have work to do in those spaces and I and I think those are areas that we are trying to like um do more in um and so I don't know Ian what you would would add to that um I I feel there's hope I believe there's a lot of Hope um and I know that these rates are disappointing I every time I see them I'm super disappointed but I will tell you I believe people are working really hard and I think kids are working really hard and these are not necessarily meant to describe our kids as much
030as they are meant to describe how well the Minnesota state standards are being mastered Donna can I just add one piece this is an old metrics of way of how we're assessing learning this is one test this it's assessing proficiency on a any given day right look at the category what we're and who we're assessing to to the point right we're in the transition to Donna's point on how learning occurs in transitional ways around skill knowledge and character right that's why we're going to look at the our new assessment of moving away from just Workforce right we're we're in the I'll say this again and I've said this just recently to our group right we provide a service of education and and the students and families are our customer and how we support them in
031all the things and our teachers work tirelessly every day to make sure and I was just in the building to keep me grounded in all the fabulous things our folks do you can't put it until one test that's just this is the oldway we have to look at learning through experience and asking our students in choice and voice and our teachers and so we're not going to meet these pieces because it's set up that way right now through this system around what we need to do really assess and learning right like how's it look in the classroom well how does how does Heather show up to the class every day how do I support her around learning in a lesson design where she sees herself and how does the teacher assess that the MCA is
032not going to tell you those those things of the everyday experience experience of how we'll say our students show up and it's a wide range the metrics look at asset development right we know it's 40 what seven assets to assess how students should know and how we grow them from prek Readiness until when they leave us to Future Ready Learners right we we are we have a good system that we're refining more and more to how we're looking at different metrics this is old right to your point we look at how many Advanced courses to give kids opportunities and how we get the community involved to give them experiences around jobs and Readiness and the future 100 does all those things when we get the Community Partners involved in all the institutions you can't put
033it on one test right and so when we see and I'm just going to go on my emotional quadrant it's not met it's not because we're not doing a great job the metric is how we're looking at learning right and so Donnie you said that so eloquently just had to say it in a way that this is the old way that we're looking at learning right to your point last time we met all the kids there if I have a disability or special need want to come because they get a great service from our folks right and if they're mobile or transient we do a balance check when they come like how they show up are they ready to learn or do they play well with others right those things don't show up on the
034test so I just had to in in that sense of when we look at assessed learning our teachers can tell you and that's what we're getting at a heart of not just the assessment of proficiency right it's good that we want every student to read that's a that's a right every student deserves a great teacher to be able to give them a good education how to write read and be a good person we offer that I saw it today the test can tell us that and and we're now trying to do and you sat in this meeting with us the other day were to say go back to the slide where we showed go go back to the slide the the graduation number that you just put in the 55 that was on Donna it
035was on Donna slide to your point right let's see how a student shows up senior year to us wherever they come from and do we get them across the line to graduate most of them do but we have a metric to say if you didn't come in this cohort and if you moved and did all of these things that it shows up and so I think we have the voice and I love all of you because you Advocate into the things that we need about public education and learning and how it looks to down to the state department on movement on what do we assess around learning we're in that transition now to really build true individual human beings right around learning so I just had to say that in the in the goodness of
036just being authentic my comments real quick weren't intended to be critical of of where we're at and I understand that part I I just um it it's hard to think about and particularly as we continue to see as um even just in society the Gap increase between halves and have kns and those who are uh living in poverty and and you know my assumption is we will continue to see that which begins at home and what sorts of things and it is so hard to to break patterns and and so many of our students I think are um I mean there's a point at which yes you can pull yourself up by your bootstraps but it's all of the questions about um where are you starting and what does it take for that to happen
037and yeah you get some you know rare opportunities where you see those great stories but you also have a lot of of kids and families who are just struggling and and that's where again looking at Community Partnerships and how do we all own our pieces of the things that we need to do to try and help folks and help students to succeed because there's a lot of things that make that difficult for them and so I I I mean I think that I come to these meetings you know and I I go to the committee meetings and and every you know two weeks I get to hear about the great things that are happening um it takes a village and and it's going to continue to take a village and I think that that's that's
038the challenge is where do we all make our mark because it's it can't just be left in your hands to make these things happen great great point and we talk all the time so I know why she said that publicly to to the group uh we did a just a a quick check on community numbers of who's partnering with us we have all the universities right stcloud state stcloud techn St John St Ben and I think Lori was it 98 Partners from centri care to and so they all are on board to your point of we can't do this alone we have to use all our partners to we just sat in a collective uh meeting superintendent and I with all the local folks to make sure you we can't do that alone we need
039everybody to be a part of that and the partners that are involved and want to make sure to Heather's point that I have the basic needs first to do all those things and let's be clear food clothing shelter are the essentials and so our partners they believe that too and I think that's good and that's all to the superintendent right she she called folks to a table and they came all of them remember all the institutions and all the business folks and so we just need to continue to improve our partnership and collaboration with them because that does get to the result of getting good folks out in productive in in society and seeing it from multiple perspectives okay well we managed to take and have two presid presentations and both of them always get
040under my skin every year uh they they're and not not because of the way you guys are presenting them it's because I get really frustr I get really frustrated with the information and the data that gets presented in them and I I have about four hours worth of stuff that I'm trying to condense down to about four minutes um I Heather you brought up third grade reading and yeah like I know you asked the question what Happ you know what about all the grades after that or you know where do those kids go from there but I think it's important to note that third grade reading they look at specifically because k k to3 you learn to read 3 to 12 you learn you read to learn and if you get if you if you're
041not reading by third grade you're not not going to learn and so you're going to be behind the whole way through um doesn't change anything it just that's the way that I always look at that one and why they measure I never understood why they were so concerned about third graders but uh testing or when you when we anytime you're looking at test results you're either looking at testing against a St standard which somebody sets and they could set that so 100% of the kids fail and they can set it so 100% of the kids pass it's just where they decide to put that standard somewhere in the middle and then we're going to measure against that standard so it really me it's it isn't so much telling of what someone knows it's just how
042difficult was to standard and and how many kids were able to pass beyond that and if I grade on a curve there's always going to be gaps there's always going to be some that score higher uh some that score lower I mean I was thinking hockey is a great example there's how many teams in the division one hockey and how many of those teams go to the Frozen four four how many of them were how many of them are national champion one so are there opportunity gaps or are there are there gaps in in their performance absolutely there's gaps gaps in their performance from the top to the bottom and it's the same in learning there's there's going to be gaps so then when we get to integration and equity and we start we start
043measuring gaps we're always measuring by skin color that's the only thing that we measure by and we look at black and we look at Hispanic and we look at American Indian and we look at was the fourth one there's four uh tar R and we don't look at white students I don't there's no comparison for white we don't look at Asian students we don't look at glb students we don't look at transvestite students we don't look at rich or we don't look at wealthy families we don't look at poor families we only look at skin color like skin color is the differentiating factor and we're gonna put that out there for everybody to see and I just I've never bought into the fact that skin fact that this skin color is a reason for someone
044not to be able to learn skin color is the one thing that shouldn't matter at all or doesn't matter at all and it's all environmental factors social emotional type factors that determine how well a child can learn it's life experiences wealthy families have a lot those kids have a lot more opportunities to have life experiences they they have role models who show them how to be successful how to integrate into that you know what's expected of us to be successful um poor people or poor poor families don't have that same social experience and I think if you just looked at White students alone you're going to see that they're they're it's going to be the same thing it's going to be this economic kids who are in growing up in po white kids growing up
045in poverty are going to suffer from a lot of the same learning challenges as black students that grow up in poverty and black students who grow up in wealthy families are going to have the same rates of success as as white students that grow up in wealthy families so I just it's so much more environmental factors and so much less skin color I don't know why we have to pull that out and then highlight that as the only reason that someone that there's opportunity gaps we're going to look at the opportunity gap between black students and white students and there now we got to figure out how to solve that it it's not it's not a fair goal a fair goal is to look at students and at where they are in their achievement and
046work with the students who are underachieving and the students are achieving at or above grade level let's let's continue to push them and strive for them to learn at a higher level and be as be as successful as they can Poss possibly be but it it it shouldn't be this racial divide that we put out there for everyone to latch on to and and say that we have opportunity gaps and they're only based on people's skin color it ju it just it drives me nuts uh on the first so that's the second half and I and I'm not picking I'm not picking on you so I hope you don't take it that way uh I'm just stating my belief that I think that all kids can learn and I think that if we looked at
047where they're at in their learning ability and we focused some resources on the kids who need help and we challenge the students who are doing really well that we would come out ahead but there are still going to be winners and losers just like there is in NCA division one hockey we're never going to have how many teams are there Heather we're never going to have 64 national champions in the same year we can't it has there you know it's always a sliding scale and somebody's going to be at the top somebody's going to be at the bottom that's the way our society works but we can do things to bring some teams that aren't performing really good right now up to the point where they are competing for a National Championship uh you we
048put the efforts the time and the money forward to do that so that's that's my first piece that's on the integration and Equity piece on the world's best Workforce piece I had a few questions on that um dnie you said that in the new way of measuring they're looking at closing gaps not by race but by and I have a question mark because I didn't really follow what you said so it's not I think you know for years we have and I'll say I in my profession and in my work we out in the way that you mentioned earlier where we are you know showing performance by race and the Gap and in reality just as you said there are high- performing black students and high performing Brown students and high performing white students and
049so you know in hindsight if I think about it in my work and I'll just speak from My Lens I might have decided to show you all histograms every year and people might have had to do some learning with me to to understand what a histogram is actually telling you over time so you could see how well the student groups you know are progressing but we didn't do that right in the measurement Community we went out and we said we're going to show you this data and we're going to continue to enforce this idea that you know there's this gap between white performers and black performers and there is a performance Gap I don't want to deny that we we know that there's a performance Gap but the idea of um goal setting um it
050has occurred to me over the last 5 years that we really ought to be setting our goals on learning gaps so we're going to move all groups are going to try and close their learning gaps to proficiency so the MCA is a standardized Criterion referenced test used to help us and so that's how we we have sort of reframed it is is to say we want all students and and here's the other thing if you if you were to give the the results to kids you would get a really interesting perspective and because they will say the students who identified as because they recognized that identity is multipli you know there's so many things to their identity it isn't just their race um and you know and they also will tell you that they're not
051okay with those results as they sit next to their friend who doesn't maybe look like them right so I appreciate your comments and I I think that there is movement there is in fact I was at a um convening of folks around the consequential uses of assessment this has been one of them is that we've really put a picture out there that really has has created this perception that you know that we don't we don't think is is productive so how's that I don't know that that answered well so the goals the goals that we would set to close learning gaps would be you know we would we look at we're setting we're setting I I was understanding that the state was changing something in what they're asking for so what the state is is
052still going to include um closing learning gaps that's still a part of the comprehensive achievement in Civic Readiness report but they're giving districts permission to set their goals instead of in the past it was you had to do it sort of they they gave you really tight guidance on that now they're just saying nope we want you to because they also I think realize the same thing I mean it isn't just Donna Roper's brilliant right like no it was it's more of a everybody kind of sees that this has um this hasn't gotten us where we where we really want to go we we're now in 20 years of measuring things in this manner it's not working one of the sides I I my question was what percent of graduates come to Minnesota schools in
053in kindergarten because we were there was a was there was one where we're talking about graduation rates and the assessment from kindergarten through but there's so many students that come to us at different varying times during their educational career that how do we measure so they don't measure at kindergarten I I will just tell you that that the way that the grad rates are calculated is based on a student's very first entry into ninth grade right so that's their cohort year and if they come and stay with us for 50 days in ninth grade and they leave and we don't know where they went and there's very very few of those cuz we're starting to really track those very very carefully um you know or they go to Bloomington for 20 and then somewhere else
054for 10 and then somewhere else for who but they were with us the longest then they they count in our in our rates but you know the state I appreciate the state's desire to ensure a a graduated populace right you know that everyone graduates the public schools are saying we care about all kids you know we're going to be the net to make sure they all graduate um so they had to come up with some way to do it and and the business rules that they use are meant to be fair although they don't always feel that way um but I do think their intentions were very well-meaning and very much about ensuring all kids graduate because we know that that is just so important for our society and for our state so with the
055system changing going away from world's best Workforce I I've my experience has been that every time we change to a new whatever a new acronym uh all of the comparisons go away and we start over it's like well we don't measure this anymore we measure this differently now so that's not an accurate comparison and it happens about every three or four years so we never get a track record where we can say hey let's look back for the last 10 years and see where we've come on this it always changes midcourse is that happening again with this or are they carrying forward enough that's going to be measurable I I think you'll see some consistency but I think what you're going to see is people adding metrics if you will based on learning science based
056on what the research says based on you know the fact that um we know to be Future Ready it's more than just the foundational literacy numeracy right there's other things that kids other skills so the answer is you will see some consistent and then you're probably going to see new ones okay so again this is just a really frustrating in piece of information for me I really wish that we would spend time giving kids hope giving them a clear path on how they can be successful working with them through that the state not having a whole bunch of Assessments and things that that show districts in comparison because it tears down some districts while it lifts up others on Fa l and it tears down teachers while it lifts up other teachers unfairly and it
057just seems to me like we could have a much better system if we would give kids hope give them give them a plan for how to be successful and educate them to the to the best of their ability without regard to any of the other factors that are meaningless that's it thanks thank you thank you you're really Downer here a downer I I need to rebreathe after your speech let me see what was say um um I'm going to take off from some of things that I was saying so in in I'm I'm also concerned about um accurate like Baseline and accurate comparation um I'm also concerned Why are you two together in this presentation cuz really this was I don't know it's like I don't know it just kind of went like from one
058side to another side and kind of I think that doesn't make justice so in 2021 or 2022 the state combined Ai and the world's best Workforce to a combined report and in 2024 they have now decoupled them and they will no longer be together so yeah we like each other I mean but you will see these separated going forward again they they were separate at one point then they came together because they were required to be reported together so that's kind of my first confusion because the presentation here that you have given us you're not presenting to us because um so the the reason why you present this specific thing to us is because this is a report that goes to the state right that that's the basic reason because we need to have accountability
059about the report that goes to the state right and none of us as you can see like the way that the state ask us for these reports right think think that's true I think that that's our biggest problem and I think that that's why Al is so depressed in this presentation because we just don't like the way that the state ask us to report on this so what I'm Wonder M to moving towards the future is if it's in a way if it's a way to have what we need to count for the state but kind of um um another column in the report that is more about what is what we look at how do we follow kids because what I think that we lose here is the Milestones it it it just looks
060even I I see a little bit of that in in in your in your presentation Donna I say A Little Less in yours um aan but um but I but I don't think that you spend enough time explaining us how is that we are moving towards meeting those goals that the state has the state the state goals are very black and white meet or do not meet it's like the American Indians presentation that we said no no compliant and then we all get mad um so so it's kind of that what what I'm looking for um the the the one thing that I really have to tell you ala I'm completely agree with your assessment about people of color and kids of color can learn yeah I agree with that I also going to say
061that I'm agree with that there are life experiences that makes a difference I also going to say racism exist and that marks a very big life experience and there's a lot of people that is in agreement with that part and I think that that's why it's important to consider those gaps those those gaps are showing here maybe they're not the only ones but I I I don't think that it's about to take away that that Mark there can I answer sure I mean I don't I I don't think that I have ever said that it shouldn't be looked at I don't think that it should be published that should not be the data that we're putting out to the public because that creates a monster okay if you're looking at it for understanding differences and
062looking for ideas and ways to support students absolutely we should be looking at it we should be looking at everything just like when you go to your doctor they look at a lot of different things but they don't publish to the public every single result and we shouldn't be doing the same within the schools because it creates a lot of issues not it but everybody else should beting it um so the so the part of the M Stones I did not hear an answer from any of you neither you when Heather asked what are those experiences that we are looking at and and she mentioned few examples um she mentioned theater she mentioned um arts or U mentors what what are those good practices that make a difference in the life of kids um so
063I'm I would like to have an answer for that not that much about which ones are they but in the things that that that Heather was mentioning um that are some of what I just mentioned I do believe that we do a little bit of all of that and I also know that kids are all different and so for one is the mentor for the other one is the coach for the for the other one is the friend that they found um how do you put all that together into advancing kids and other things how do we follow how do we follow kids because the the one thing that is sometimes frustrating from these statistics on or not identifying kids is that I know that the difference between what we get to see here and
064what you get to see where you are standing is that you actually see the kid so you see when a kid is making progress from first grade to graduation and you see when the kid is about to fall we don't we just see we don't know if the kid that that that you have there if if the one that is is one that just came into the school or or or that something happened in their life that is really remarkable and then um what why not part of those 16 kids and not getting 90% at least so how do you track those experiences how do you see the like the two questions is the the kid and experiences I'll I'll start but I I think both um assistant superintendent avenson and Harris can also speak
065to this you know we are really monitoring Learners at a level that is quite detailed and and over the last three years especially with some of the new systems that we put in place um and our desire to have learner profiles for all students or personalized learning plans so you've heard of mtss you've heard of multi-tiered systems to support success for all students and so that I would say is the key pra multi-layered practices that are um happening in our schools with kids and and I think there you know through the Community Partners there's all kinds of opportunities for experiences that kids are gaining access to I think and I'm not the expert to speak on this but I do think either um of the assistant Sops could could tell you more about each of
066those yeah I can just start with the pieces of our assessments are out are outdated to your point again right of what we're looking at we just heard that in the experiences of students when they start from prek what are the the checks right what experience do we give them in the classrooms in each grade level we look at that street level data right so to your point you're here and we're we call it an achievement dashboard right and so it starts with attendance first who show who shows up the school and so we do we do a measure and our folks do it beautifully the the building administrators the teachers start with the track of who comes to school every day and how that looks through Assessments in the classroom around learning right the
067teacher says okay Monica she plays socially with everybody she can do her basic fundamentals and we assess those things and then we try to when we don't when you don't fit it we call it a tiered response right we worked we talked about that this week in admin PD right the tier is the first response that everybody gets right and so it typically happens in for students in the lesson right the lesson designed to a point and when you see if you had a classroom of 30 that the students that were not doing the basic things right you assess that from the teacher and then we try to put an intervention in place right they sit down in a group like us four to say okay Monica we don't see she's doing X Y and
068Z she's not reading or she's not doing these things we had to help our folks switch from a deficit base to a asset base what are all the great things she's doing how do we catch her up or wherever she's at and we look at as a tier two a tier two if you're not with the everybody and then if we give you that intervention to say all right Monica we see that your reading skills are to our Point around literacy and proficiency are deficient in our asset based was terms that we used to use to say all right her her learning is not at a proficient level it's the language in it and so then we would say Okay ion's a language arts teacher let's find a way to see see what she needs
069by assessing her in those things let's look at her pheic awareness let's look at her comprehension and then we have systems that trickle along the way to help them in grade one from prek all the way on and it's good when they stay with us our data could show if they stay with us from when they started to the gr our numbers are better than everybody's with this sense but we don't have that population and to your point and you know we have to then teer everything so we look at we know mentors work right we give kids mentorship that's a asset we know if I develop a positive relationship with kids to say I'm going to get a better amount of learning if you take any type of specific like or asset based way
070to say I care about you I love you your grades are going to be great your attendance is going to be right we we track those things to an individual learning plan systematically right they our folks do a great job of checking it right and so we do have a system and it starts with us and how we look data and to your point we don't get it out there to everybody cuz we're in the muck of it sometimes and we don't you know it's when you ask those questions for us it's like all right we got to go overview we can't go into every in the day-to-day classroom every second because our teachers are fabulous they're great and they're looking at all types of kids but we assess it in that way Monica to
071your point and we we found like if I have a partnership with the community if I'm mean and so to the point I am in activities and I make sure we can track like she's involved in something if she's involved something most likely she's going to be better off in her grades are involved in school and so they track in that way in the building okay let me interrupt you for a second so I got it you you you do it you have a plan just because of the SE of effect you or you please tell me a story of one kid don't tell me the name that did not start with us and that you could see great progress for an intervention that for a program or an intervention that you have one a
072story one story I'll be quiet I can speak to some kind of General stories we've had a couple um I don't know if you remember Katie Schneider but she has come in and done a couple of presentations around dyslexia supports and now she's a literacy specialist so when I think of success stories I always think of Katie's stories about some of our students who have come in to our system in sixth seventh or eighth grade they've moved in from somewhere else and they're reading at like a first grade level and she has had some really touching Beautiful Moments with kiddos that she's worked personally with who have made incredible and I mean like outstanding gains in reading and that actually like continue to seek her out so we have we have those stories when you
073originally asked about some of those individualized stories um I all three of my kids are 74 two kiddos um one's graduated and off and running and I have two seniors this year um and so we have a lot of varied friend groups and I can think about a million stories but I don't want to go into them because they get me really emotional but just we're we've had some amazing staff from our chemical health it's about meeting those kiddos where they're at so Jason's talking about all these systems right that we do have that edge of climber where we're tracking student academic progress and student um seal social emotional where they're at with their needs but my mind goes to all of the individual stories that I know about kidos who we've had staff who
074have made those really amazing connections chemical health counselor at Tech High School who has changed the path for some of our kiddos our chemical health counselor at McKinley who are kiddos who um need recovery at the same time they're doing their learning that they're going into those systems um making sure our counselors are connecting um kiddos to Greater so to support um and and getting therapy at school because we can't get them to you know a therapy session offsite um so I think about there's a million of them and so but I I love Katie's because she she just tells them so passionately but and I get a little emotional when I think about my my own kids as friends and their their path and sometimes kids step off that path even if we have
075all the things that they need right I and sometimes kids step off but what the we have to be ready is when they're ready to come back on we're here for them and then we're ready to help them continue to grow so hope that helps a little I forg I forgot it was your last meeting too and then I opened up early and I saw the superintendent look at me like Monica's last I I'll take one right because in the practical sense I was a middle school principal and high school principal and I have the love and pleasure of seeing that happen all day long for kids that showed up from all over the place if it was Chicago Indiana across the country Somalia uh Asia all over right they might just show up and
076we start to track like where are they coming from New York Connecticut my family moved here from X Y and Z and so I'll share one Joel just text me uh we had a student that was that tier three kid that like they were they could change the whole dynamic of a school right like you could feel when you have those kids in school it's one that feels like 500 and so this was a kid right Joel was a teacher in the CL Joel taught this student in the classroom how to do all the things of what we call compliance at school follow directions get in go to class be on time and all the things but the relationship that Joel and I'll talk about principal sener uh today in my update that built the
077relationship with this kid he went all the way through school he went he tier three to honors classes advanced classes to four-year University to all the things right to just what we want to see when we plant the seed and it blossoms like a flower to this day where we have those students that come back that future 100 they're out in the world and they come back to tell kids don't mess up in ninth grade do well in algebra take advaned uh geography because that's going to get you a credit up they all those things that we you know sometimes we don't assess and say hey put this in a report but it happens every day and so that student that I have had to pleasure of just seeing Blossom that's just one of in
078my time and I've been here uh 11 years and soup and all the folks we have I could say probably a thousand those students that showed up from I don't from somewhere that we were like yeah you didn't you didn't you didn't start with us you came from somewhere else and so let's help you understand how we create belonging and safety and collaboration and excellence in that in that sense thank you questions anybody else um the mca's measure at a point in time a few years ago we talked about a test that uh determined progress over time kind of a longitudinal test and I haven't seen that test for a while but uh what we discovered was that uh kids were often progressing at uh maybe a grade and a half or a grade in
079three months and but the Baseline was so low and that's kind of why we have our our seven-year gradu or three 3x year graduation rate because the Baseline is low but they're moving up at faster than normal and we should be giving our teachers a lot of credit for moving it so that we get our our graduations that's it okay thank you guys both for being here appreciate it then we have um two action items tonight the first one is we need to approve the date time and location of the 2025 board reorganizational meeting um proposing the first Monday in January Monday January 6th at 5:00 p.m. at the district office um and again 5:00 p.m. not our usual 6:30 p.m. um looking for a motion to approve the date time and location of the
0802025 board reorganizational meeting so move and do I have a second second I have a motion by Scott and a second by Heather any discussion at all he that can you call vote Monica SAR Schwartz yes yes Scott andreon yes hether Williams yes Zack DS yes okay and then our other action item is the approval of the date time and location for the first 2025 board meeting and that um is going to be Wednesday January 8th at 6:30 p.m. at the district office so Wednesday January 8th 6:30 p.m. at the district office looking for a motion to approve the date time and location for the first board meeting in 2025 so Mo second I have a motion by l a second by Zach any discussion okay Zach can you call vote Shannon hos yes Z
081doorold yes Al doen yes Monica sigara Schwarz yes Heather Williams yes Scott andreon yes okay thank you um then moving on to reports uh Board of Education standing committee reports I believe we do not have any does anybody have any reports all right then we have future agenda items December 18th board meeting topics will include the South Junior High School presentation full service Community Schools presentation presentation of final Levy certification and opportunity for public input approval of the final Levy certification approval of the Apollo referendum budget approval of the high school course cataloges and some policy readings at this time does any board member want to suggest a future agenda item okay thank you um that is everything on our regular board meeting so I'm looking for a motion to adjourn our board meeting so
082move second of a motion by Scott a second by Monica all in favor say I I I opposed okay meeting is adjourned at 7:52 p.m. and at that same time uh starting the Board of Education work session we have three items on our work session tonight first is the schools update presenting Dr Jason Harris assistant superintendent of secondary education and Shannon avenson assistant superintendent of E through2 Educational Services good evening chair HW superintendent putam and members of the board um I will be presenting uh Nikki's portion tonight because unfortunately she is not with us here we go um our first uh presentation is around safety and this is for uh clear view the first picture represents um every classroom that created a poster for inclusion for Unity day and then they did the mile walk
083around the baseball fields together and for belonging um here uh Clear View school picnic with over two joining them uh belonging at the beginning of the school year collaboration they collaborated with their PTA and Community to hold their annual fundraiser and wathon this culminated in dress like your favorite storybook character and um with a wathon assembly and then for high expectations High supports um they're showing Excellence here at clear viiew as students engage in open-ended creativity designs using their Spa uh maker space materials in the library J all right for secondary we have uh McKinley ALC you have a picture of uh principal cator and sister principal chakolas they create safety if you ever go see these two in action I was just there today they know all the kids so they the visibility in
084relationships to what we talk about of what are some of the characteristics these two are role models of it and so you just see them there uh the sense of belonging we got a chance to do the uh be a part of the Grand opener for the new uh McKinley area we had a student 10th grade student share her testimony just of uh why it was important to have the new space and it uh you see uh executive uh director high camp over there and we talked to this young lady after and and to to Monica's point of a student that just wasn't originally ours to went all over the place to multiple and McKinley let's be clear has some of our students that have some of the most challenging needs and she was look
085at her face she was so enthused about this new space that she was going to get to see every day so they're creating sense of belonging there and then just uh they continue to find ways to get our students Ready for the World Around career and college uh they I was walking down the hall and I CAU this picture of just uh them promoting all the experiences to my point earlier around Who's involved with us to those uh corporations and companies they're promoting and giving our kids hands-on experience right like if I want to be a a retail chain person or if I want to be uh into mechanics they're giving the experiences and we're working with them to give kids all types of opportunities and then you have the uh picture where they took
086the school to the Epic event to help them explore around multiple CL uh Pathways and so that collaboration to Heather's Point earlier of can't do it alone that's just the true Testament and then they do this big thing where they had the whole school do a newspaper roll who got the tallest and they were doing the challenge and measuring it so you see the teachers and the students together with high expectations and high support so uh just you know it's I back to my point I said just being in that environment every day is always just uh Inspire from our from our people uh and this we or this month I decided to highlight some of our nurses I think sometimes we forget all the work that our amazing nursing staff does in our schools
087um this is Melissa Nico and she was not happy that I took her picture um but she's adorable she is our LPN at uh North Junior High um and I she's showing you there one of our backpacks and in just a thinking about every time our students go on a field trip or there's some type of activity our nurses are checking that list of those kiddos any of those students who have a health plan eer emergency medications Etc you name it and there's a lot diabetic needs our nurses are either going on the field trip with them packing that bag training the staff if they're not going on the field trip to do all those things there's just so much care that goes into making sure that every time our students are going offsite that
088they're safe and that they're cared for and that they have what they need in the event of any kind of emergency um it's it's quite it's quite something um this is Melissa's office too over at North and I just thought this was super special you can't see it very well but um she definitely creates a sense of belonging um it's just a great space and kids feel really welcome in there her little sign on the door says you matter and you are enough collaboration um this is just today we had I I do I have a meeting on my calendar that says measles meeting this is my third measles meeting um luckily uh mdh has said that uh you know it has scaled back quite a bit there were some measles outbreaks earlier this uh
089late summer early fall um luckily that has died down but we wanted to be on the Forefront of that and you cannot believe how many people we have to have at the table when you're thinking about what do we do for students to support them in the event that they we have to do a 21-day quarantine which is worse than Co um to keep their education going to make sure they have the nutrition that they need what are we doing for cleaning response so um it's not only our nurses at the table for this but uh Joel's team it's just it's an intensive process learning and teaching and here we don't have an issue but we're just trying to be prepared in the event because if a kiddo has to stay home for 21 days
090we want to make sure that they have what they need and our of course our nurses are are really our masters at this meeting we we're really kind of leaning on them quite honestly and then hi expectations and high supports um if you've not met lead nurse uh supervisor Jessica Voss she's absolutely outstanding um and we do have some turnover in our LPN and LSN roles um and so there is just kind of a constant stream of her supporting and orienting new people this is over at tahi with one of our newer RNs this school year and one of our newer lsns um and just you can see the smiles on their faces that this is just what Jess does every day as a lead nurse supervisor is supporting people responding to phone calls if
091there's emergencies at all our our whole team knows that they have that amazing supervisor who's there and ready to support them with any questions that they have um so it's just I can't I can't stress enough and and believe me Jess has high expectations but she definitely has amazingly High support um so just wanted to highlight her as well you're asking about the measles meetings is this new I mean you've gone to three now this year we had three to be proactive just to say what if we had a measles outbreak in one of our schools because if you are not immunized then you do have to go on that 21-day quarantine so really this has just truly been a proactive what if it does come to one of our schools and and and really
092getting information out to families and student you know is it related to lower vaccination rates um I can't honestly I can't speak to that um I I don't have the the that kind of medical background with it but um we did review our immunization compliance rates as a part of that process as well and you know it really varies I think depending on which school you're at some of our Littles our littlest are going through that vaccination process right now and so kind of varies on on where you're at but our nurses in fact just had to do an immunization compliance report for the state um and they they know and they're pushing out information to parents we pushed out a a measles update information to parents so that they knew there's a 21-day quarantine
093um and so really I think we're trying to take that lens of being really proactive and getting that information out there and I respect that I just um given how our world works right right now I think understanding public health and the impact that that has on schools is important and if that's something and particularly if the medical folks start saying that in the state of Minnesota and in our district we're seeing something that would lead us to believe that it's more likely I think that's something that our community needs to know um because then it has impact and and um particularly for folks who or kids um or families who have uh immun immune problems it becomes a major issue thank you and that that is we were pushing out um the measles update
094posters uh to All Families through newsletters and and really it was about that just an awareness piece to have it on people's radar so thank you okay thank you um Scott there was a a time a while ago when uh the state was pushing uh having nurses on all the bus activity trips and there wasn't enough nurses in the state to do all that um whatever became of that is they still trying to force that on us or what well um I can speak to it's really about whether or not there is a need so like when I mentioned that sometimes when there's an off-site activity or field trip or event um we really have to look at the individual students that are going on that event and there are lots of things that we
095can train and we can delegate on right um so certain medications we can train and delegate and that's what happens we always train and delegate when we can sometimes there's no medical needs but in the sometimes there are uh uh instances where it would not be appropriate for our nursing team to delegate um something for example if it's a seizure medication response that requires like dosye and and we have some of those then we would need to send a nurse on that field trip um and so it's very very individualized and really not as it does not happen as often as you think we might have an event here or there or a sport season where a student is a newly diagnosed diabetic and just needs a little support maybe for the first few um
096months of that diagnosis and so really um we we don't automatically put nurses in after school activities or field trips or things like that it's really is very thoughtful and only when really needed well that's good to hear because I know there was a time where kids at Kennedy's couldn't go to a a field trip at St John's ARB burum because there wasn't a nurse to ride on the bus so apparently there's been some flexibility developed okay thank you again okay next up we have uh input channels for school board members and this is presented by board member Monica Sakira Schwarz yes you did hello everybody um thank you CH house for giving me time here and everybody else had to um give me some time for this I was um the the idea of
097this was to to what I was doing at the beginning was to have um was requesting an agenda item for the retreat but as many of you have discussed before I be in the retreat and I will probably have a chance to explain myself so this is kind of an explanation is this this is this is an explanation for you what what I what I was looking forward for you to discuss at The Retreat or at any other time later so um a little bit of background you can move on I was just looking for a presentation to just put something together to keep my ideas and this came up with from from from from Microsoft the power of communication so I left the title there cuz it was Dr um key and the parts
098as things that are that I actually put together there um thinking about what what's what I'm looking for so the part of communication allow us to solve conflict to help us connect and to allow us to act as a collective that's kind of what I'm looking for for this um for for what I'm suggesting so this um since I have been in the board I have always looked for ways that we could gather input from constituents and that we that I particularly feel will feel more responding to constituents in general and then I had been thinking who the constituents will be who do we respond to and we respond to anybody and everybody um but we have have always some sort of a differentiation between families and staff um so we in in in my
099opinion um think about ourselves responding and having channels to for for the community or for for people that are not vinul with the district to to talk to us um and we do believe that those same channels are also being able to be used by a staff um but but I wanted to recognize that there is a difference between input that we will get from community members and input that we will get from from people within the district so um this is kind of what I'm looking for something I think the communication help us do these things um what have we tried in the past for for people to give us input or or what we have we have public comment at board meetings so that's what we have before before The Bard meeting start
100people come and tell us whatever they want to tell us that is a one way communication we don't respond to the people directly there there the reasons why we do that I'm not proposing that we change that but just want to keep track of that other things I have been um that I other things that I'm aware that have happened in the past um conversations with board members um I believe that there were three board members before the board meeting and then they opened the idea to have people to come to talk to them and some people came um not sure what happened with that that was my for before my time I heard that did not really work um but I don't know that we know why exactly uh we had the school leason
101that they were attending to PTA meetings um that's something that we that was part of kind of Poli policy or practice um during my time we decided not to do that that was not depending of the board and me in my opinion some of the things that will concern me about that depending of the board member that was assigned to was different not every school school has PTA meetings um the people that gets to communication with the board member was the people that participate in the PTA meetings not the school that's at large or not the population of parents at large um so there were other things there uh personal Communications to board members that's something that that information is is public anybody can contact board members I don't really think that the public in
102general knows this and I also think that this is more reative because in my experience people are more likely to contact us when there are problems and when the problem is bsing bother some enough that they actually decide to do that so I think that that's more of a and again this is all my opinion more of a complaining mechanism um individual initiatives every board member have their own way to getting input from constituents from whatever way they they they find when I'm trying to show here or what what I would like the board to have a discussion is um I don't see anything that the board as a body is responsive to the public neither to the staff um and we do that through the administration but I think that sometimes sometimes there is
103an expectation that the board does it another way um and again this is my opinion and this is the discussion that I wanted to have at the at the retreat or that I wanted you to have at the retreat about those ways and and what does it happen um I think that people has come to me in the past and I heard things like um people you guys Don't Care About Us um I have I have heard that those that statement from from staff I have heard the statement from A specific group of parents um and I also have heard um things that are confusing about or or confusions that are about what is what we think or do um that people just just believe that that are things are not necessarily not necessarily what
104we are thinking so people in general don't understand what the the role as a board is unless they really pay attention to it um and when they don't understand many just start making assumptions so that's part of that communication thing so why we have had issues with some of the ways of or or of communication of opening channels like why do we if we open if we have um if we have a time like a coffee with the board member I think that that actually was another thing that somebody did so coffee with the board member or um the Le of the schools one thing that happened with the of the schools if I'm a delation of the school and I go to the school and then get a list of things that need to
105happen in that school then as a board member I start needing a little bit of um start getting confusing between what is governance and what is operations and if I get the list of things that the school needs and requires and I don't have the visibility of the rest and I go into the superintendent and tell superintendent now you need to pay attention to all this but I don't really have neither the knowledge or or anything else and and then after having my conversation with the principal or the teacher or even the parent whoever it is then then people start expecting that things are going to change just because they told us um I think that that's a problem that needs to be considered and I think that that is a worrisome that may many
106people many of you will have if if we open certain ways of communication but I don't think that it should be a paralyzing problem that keep us from doing it um so that has to do with governance versus operation that has to do with accountability um and stakeholder support is it's part of what what we need to do I I I I don't think that everybody feels supported by the board or heard by the board so that's that's part of what I think that we need to consider so suggestions that I have for all you since I'm my last day I'm going to leave and just going to leave you with this um I really think that you need to consider open channels and when you do that then you think about how how long
107do you try them what problem they have so if you decide to have three board members at the beginning of the meeting and then nobody comes then maybe you have a conversation about why nobody came um or or who came at what moment um I think that we need to be more proactive in soliciting input and and we could have I mean just when I was thinking about this brainstorm about how do you solicit input or what kind of input you can solicit um I was asking today um day and story of a student why don't you just ask for the story of the student that a person can that a teacher or a principal can give you um I I just think that it comes to be a little bit more work for us
108in terms of taking the time to read those things I don't know how many stories we will get if we open that channel so that could be another nice problem to have like oh grap we have thousand stories and I didn't have time to see it I think that you can deal with that if that's what happens but I think that you should solicit input solicit input that says what was good in your day this week and see how many people respond to you and if you don't get any answer of what was good in your Daye this week maybe next time asking them why you didn't answer was not anything good your day maybe you kind start thinking about what what was um what creating a culture of communication is not going to be
109easy and to do something that we had ever done and that expects that works at the beginning just because it's not going to happen but if we don't try it then then we have things like we had had in the past think that might think that we don't care um I going to mention also that um one of the things one one event that ProMed me to wanted to have this conversation with you and to wanted to say this um was was something that I heard from the staff at a specific point and I'm going to say that of course the first thing that we will do is to go to the administration talking to to Administration about it um talking to Lor about it um I wasn't the only person the only board member
110that here what I hear and I think that I know I wasn't the only one that talked to Lori about it but what I wanted to highlight is that I do believe that Lori did something about that specific event and had conversations with many others and had some input and have some channels open um I think that you're still working in the in the outcomes and follow-ups of that and and I and I think that that's exactly what I will that I expected to happen that's exactly what I wanted to see and I really really appreciate that and I appreciate that you're taking the time to do that and to connect with others but one time and it's not a bad for for what you're doing because I know that this is not the one
111time but I'm saying one time it's not going to it's not going to build trust that process of communicating and talking to others is also a process of building trust and I still think that we have a lot of issues with trust within a this which is which is actually expected in a institution that is this size so it's a it's a challenge that we that we have because we have a large institution and we have too many stakeholders and by too many I mean just large number of stakeholders we respond to the entire Community we we respond to the entire stuff um and and we and we we are constrained by by our own legislation and our own rules and we are completely public so that's that's actually expected but I I really think
112that that if we don't if we just respond to our own constraints and said this is impossible to do well we're not going to try anything so I think that we could continue to build trust and I think that we need it so I think that that's it all what I wanted to tell you thank you thank you for giving me the time absolutely Scott did you want is this something we're going to be talking about on the retreat or is this something we should be talking about now right it's not on the retreat and mon go going to be here for the retreat either so um we have a the board is involved in governance and um the superintendent is involved in operational and sometimes there I get the feeling that if the the
113board member gets into talking with other people that the U operational side isn't real pleased that we're doing this uh for example the open houses I've been to open houses is at Tech Apollo Katherine Johnson McKinley and when I go it's not unusual for uh for me to ask questions how are things going what what do you need here uh what can I pass on to Administration that'll help you uh well for example I went to a play and after the play I talked to the director and I said what sort of things do you need and the director gave me a list of stuff and I brought it up to um Gary or or somebody like similar and things got got fixed uh there was a sound system out at uh at Tech and
114just having a board member speaking to the superintendent I don't remember if it was Willie probably Willie and um all of a sudden things started to happen um at cop house uh I've went to the open house there and uh on one hand the administration seemed to appreciate I was there but on the other hand when I started asking questions from staff or just the neighborhood uh they didn't seem to like that too well uh um when I was at uh Tech as a new board member and people didn't know who I was I was uh asking questions uh of different uh different uh teachers in different classrooms and I was getting feedback about uh stuff that was breaking down or stuff that was need fixing and uh then a little later on I could
115met with Jason and I said hey we got these this this problem and uh Jason took care of stuff um we used to have uh ptas that were very active in some districts and uh I know that uh Al was the layers on to the PTA and people would tell how problems and I would talk with Lori or Willie and things that get fixed it's I don't know there's there kind of a conflict between governance and operational it's it's like people are may be afraid to talk to uh the operational leaders and rather go through the anonymous board member to to get the problems looked at um I remember when I was leaz on at Lincoln I asked the uh uh principal what are the problems here what needs to be fixed and the principal
116gave me a list and I went to Wy and say hey we got this list of stuff that linkoln needs to be fixed and Will was very un unhappy that I was bringing stuff up and then he sat down and he showed me all the things that had already been done for Lincoln and he made some good points too it's it's just kind of kind of stuff like as a board member I feel like we should maybe know what's going on but uh it's kind of like the administration doesn't want us to know what's going on it's it's a strange situation that's all I got to say so um my point the point of the presentation for me what I was trying to present today was alternatives for you as a body to get input
117not for you as a individual board member I think that the examples that you mentioned are as an individual board member and you as an individual board member you can do whatever you feel that you need to do um but I was suggesting something that you as a body could do to get input from from the community and from every stakeholder um I also may suggest that yeah there are important considerations between between um operations and governance and it is important I also believe that it's important to understand those considerations um because you as an individual Bor member not do not have the the view of what the operations need neither the knowledge neither the constraints um and you generate expectations when you're asking for questions so so I I I I mean that's you
118have some other questions there but that's those are not for me to answer but if you want to talk another time we can chat but but what I was suggesting was for you as a body of board I I do want to respond to that a little bit and say that yes I think that in any sort of administration where there's there's board management there is always going to be some level of tension um because what we know is not the same as what the operational folks know and we have to be very thoughtful and careful um about not overstepping our boundaries because we don't know what's been communicated we don't always know how the priorities work we don't know what what's been asked of and we can float in and ask questions and think
119that we have all of the answers and we simply aren't responsible for that I want to be careful and Scott I would disagree with you you said that the board or that the administration seems to not want to be transparent and give us information I would highly contest that based upon my sitting in these meetings we are given an opportunity through a process to add things to an agenda every single time we meet we are given the opportunity to sit on committees we are given the opportunity to talk to any of the folks at the table and at no point have I ever experienced a time where when I asked a question or provided a perspective I was told that I was it was not welcome so I want to be careful that just because
120um they can't share everything or uh we don't have full view of everything I I guess my expectation and my experience has been that we have a very transparent process um and and and that the point of the presentations that we hear every W or every other Wednesday night are to educate us and give us opportunities so that we can understand the overarching 30,000 foot view our job is not to manage the the granular piece of what's going on in any single building it's to ensure that the direction and the questions that we're asking make sense and deliver great educational outcomes for students generally I'm passing the information on to the superintendent or the assistant superintendent so that they can be aware I'm not trying to override anybody well boards are governing units they operate
121their job is the governance of the district their job is to hire a superintendent the superintendent's job is to hire a team the school board's job is to watch that watch over that team and determine make a determination whether they're happy with or not happy with the direction that the district is moving and if they aren't happy with the way the district is moving then they have the opportunity to work with the superintendent and the superintendent's team to make changes or to change the superintendent or the superintendent's team when you go to a school and you talk to a a teacher or you talk to a um person that's doing the play you're talking not to the superintendent you're talking not to the superintendent's team you're talking directly to a line member that they are
122responsible for overseeing and you're getting information from that person and making that person feel as though I gave that information to the superintendent's boss now it's going to to get taken care of and you Short Circuit the entire system in the way that the system is built I've I I have made more calls to Gary than I'm sure in the last 12 years than anyone in this District complaining about grass not being cut complaining about about we need to trim around these light posts we need to get this window fixed here well all kinds of calls like that just every week and Gary always gladly took them listened to them and a lot of and most of the time reacted to them not once did I get any of that information by talking to someone
123at of school saying what do you need that was all based on my own observation and my own observation was that we weren't doing a very good job of taking care of the buildings in our district so I was going to drive around from school to school and I was going to look for things that we could do and changes that we could make and I was going to communic Comm unicate them directly to Gary or either a lot of them went directly to Willie but then it went directly to Gary because Willie didn't want to have me call him about that stuff but I dealt directly with the superintendent's team but I never made a promise to anyone that that stuff was going to be taken care of you are wrong about me being
124the liaison at Kennedy and bringing things back to Willie about what needs to be done at Kennedy i i attended I attended PTA meetings at Kennedy when I was invited by the principal who at the time was Lori and I did a board report telling the people at telling the me the members of the PTA what the school board was working on on that particular month I didn't really take input from the PTA I mean I listened if I say any you have any questions or anything that I'd be able to answer but I wasn't there with the Express purpose of getting input to come back and say hey we need to do this for Kennedy I hire a superintendent I give them the control of the district and they have to be the ones
125that are responsible for it if I can't give them a responsibility for it then I can't be judging them if I'm going to take responsibility for what's going on in the schools then I'm the one that's responsible for it not the superintendent we can't short circuit that that whole process and so I I'm going to disagree with you too that's not that that is just absolutely not the role of a Schoolboard member Schoolboard also Schoolboard members are elected representatives that means you're elected by the public to represent the public to the best of your ability the best of your ability is you you may develop a process to go out and get feedback you may not that's that's your choice the board can't tell me that I'm going to go out and collect data from
126the public to bring back to the next meeting it's not the board's prerogative I'm a I'm a elected representative they don't like what I'm doing they don't have to vote for me I'm not going to be sitting in this chair next month so I didn't get voted for I got that that's fine that's that's what this is all about but I don't know that we have public input at the beginning of every meeting anyone any member of the public can come and speak to us yes it's intimidating of course it is uh but it's also intimidating to sit down one-on-one with a board member it's also intimidating to call a board member and I've taken phone calls and I react I mean I've reacted to some of those phone calls I know last negotiations period
127or no no during when we were doing the health plans we I I had spoken to someone who called a a member or employee of the district who had called and asked that there be more time given so that the the union members could absorb what was be about to take place and call board members and callwell and so we did uh the other thing is that employees through collective bargaining have a process by which they can raise raise issues and complaints if they're not if they're not happy with what is happening with the superintendent they can go to their Union head and they can talk to that Union head and if they wish to they can go to what do it called it's advise and consent and meet and confer that's it meet and
128confer and and work out issues like that there is a process in place for employees to to bring those issues forward so it's not a board's me board members responsibility to go out and negotiate with employees on behalf of the super it again it's just s short circuits that entire thing Lori is responsible for the operation of this District if you don't like what's going on with the operation of the district as a whole then you you bring it up with Lori and and you you can bring it up with other board members and the board me the board can bring it up with Lori but you can't Short Circuit the system or the system will fail and that's true of every boardroom in America corporate boardrooms are no different than School boardrooms other than
129our meetings are public corporate boardrooms are not public but the board for Target is not out talking to Cashiers saying what do you need is there anything you need here are the registers working good do you need some different cabinets what do you need here that's up to the CEO to take care of that stuff to to determine and the CEO and the CEO's team to determine exactly what's going to be happening in the stores and you just best step back and allow them to operate and if you if you need changes address it with them but you can't step in and operate at that at that micromanaging level or you're going to shortcircuit the system and the system will fail that's my two cents I think I just want I don't want to I
130agree with what Heather and Al said and I don't want to reiterate my agreeing with that but I do um before we end this conversation um that I heard two things that I felt are really hurtful um in maybe describing the district I'm I'm not sure one is um trust issues probably have 2,000 employees is somebody going to not trust another employee absolutely but to to say to describe the district as having trust issues is very hurtful um to me because in my time here um I I see um a very trusting Administration and a very transparent Administration and if there is something that I don't know it's not because Administration doesn't want me to know it it's because this is I'm a Schoolboard member and the school district in public education is extremely complicated
131and there's way more that I don't know um compared to what I do know is um a small amount so I don't think anybody's hiding something from me um and I'm very um trusting and appreciate the honesty especially when we are doing contract negotiations you can see that trust um that is coming forward to have honest conversations and I just want to thank Administration for for that and um the leadership there because I I don't know if it's in every District um but I'm very impressed with it here so thank you um so I'm sorry that you got hurt for anything that I said I did not say that the district doesn't have trust um I I I don't think that I characterize what I me me um in that way so I do I
132I set kind of the opposite I said that I actually gave an example of Lor hearing and and and listening to input that she has gotten and acting on it and that is all the opposite that is trust and transparency um so so again I I I got back to what what I was asking you to talk about um and yeah you might not talk about it anymore and might not visiting ever again um what I see in the ways that we get input from stakeholders is that are reactive and I'll describe them very well and he says that they're intimidating yes they are intimidating and they are reactive and that's what I was um asking you to maybe think about ways that you can get a input that is not reactive and that people
133um feel that you're hearing the more I do think that there is a difference between a corporate and and a public board because we're public and because nobody think about the corporate board as the place that they have to hear them um but they do think about uh School Board as the place that they can they have to hear them um but again I was suggesting something that you do as a board as a collective and if you don't want to do it nobody's going to tell you that you're wrong and I'm not telling you that you're wrong if you don't do what I'm suggesting as I said it's a suggestion and um and I think that might help to build trust in the board not in in the institution as a whole and I
134don't know that we I don't think that this is a criticism of the organization I'm saying that we are all wrong and that we do stuff bad and that and I don't really want to hurt you as an institution as organization I don't want to any of you sitting in that long table please don't hear me as I said that you're not doing what you're supposed to be doing because I do believe that you do amazing jobs so just want to get that through I just I want to I want to respond a little bit to that Monica I just I this getting feedback directly from the public as a board member I come to a meeting and the administration is has got a set of recommendations on an agenda and these are recommendations from
135the administration these are things that we would like to do these are things that we would like to change these are things that we need going forward and and we would like to get the board's support for that I would expect not that we on the board who don't we're waiting for the for the administration to tell us why they need it what it's for this and that I wouldn't expect the board to be the ones that would go out and get the feedback from the public I would expect the administration to be the people who would go out and get feedback from the public so like for example uh on the referendum that was just presented a couple of weeks ago I would expect that Lori had been out speaking to people in the
136schools saying what do you need people in the public do you think that you would support this maybe at the chamber to say if we bring this forward would you guys be on board with this is this a good idea or a bad idea and the administration would gather all of that information and only if they felt that it was a good thing for the district they're going to bring it forward to us as a recommendation but for us to form some type of thing saying what do you I mean what do you think I mean I guess when it comes to the referendum we're going to do the ultimate feedback Loop in that we're going to allow every single resident in the district the opportunity to vote yes or no on it so that's
137pretty good feedback but I just can't see where on agenda items routine and and informational agenda items coming forward we would be looking to go out before it's being presented by the administration to get feedback from the public to to I don't for what purpose I don't know it just seems awkward to me it's just and that's just me thinking that's me thinking out loud I didn't that's not prepared but it just seems like it's awkward and short circus short circuiting and a lot of the reason that nobody comes forward at public at at public input sessions I think it's just that there aren't very many people that have a whole lot of need for that I mean n first of all 20% maybe 30% of our of the homes in our school district have
138a student maybe less so that would put it down to about 20% are are directly affected by what happens in the school district and I would bet 90 to 95% of those their communication is going to be directly with the teacher the coach and the principal at the school that they're attending and to have a issue at a level that would be presentable to the board is just I don't I don't I don't believe that there are that many I don't think I don't think we'd have people standing in line if we made it really easy to give us feedback and I think that was really pre really um obvious when we did those sessions and we did it for a while we did it for probably six six months where before every board meeting
139we'd have that half hour of conversation with a board me member and three of us would be showing up for that not the same three it was always rotation but the three of us would have a little powow at the round table cuz no nobody ever showed up it was like the first two or three meetings one or two people showed up and that was it even brought yeah we did it just didn't it didn't amount to anything but I don't think that there's that many major issues I if if we were talking about whether we should build a gymnastics practice facility and it was going to be out a meeting we'd have 50 people at that meeting but that's something very specific and and we've we've had we've had overflow crowds for public input
140so when there is an issue people do come but I just don't think that at every meeting there's a real purpose for it that's I don't know so thank you so much for giving me the time to tell you my ideas and for considering what I was saying for thinking about it absolutely I will say that's one thing since I've been on the board the process of getting items on the agenda that that's become well defined because it was very confusing at first we're like how who do you go to how do you do that um when I first got on the board it wasn't really possible yeah it it it was the chair and the vice chair and the superintendent and there was no real line of communication for input and it was really
141frustrating because I was low mana on the totem pole when I first got on the board and and I and I had thoughts and I had ideas and I could not voice that in any constructive way to have it brought forward at a board meeting right and I think now that we seven equal people yep yeah so speaking of that um for those of you watching um and here tonight you may not know that this is Monica sigir schwarz's last meeting um she will not be here uh for our 2nd December meeting so on behalf of District 742 um we wanted to thank Monica sigar Schwarz for eight wonderful years of dedication serving on the school board um and present you with this plaque and welcome to celebrate after the meeting is adjourned with cupcakes
142but thank you very much um and I'll bring this over to you thank you so much and if anybody would like to comments and Monica as well uh does anybody have any um farewells or anything that they would like to say Zach fig i' say something tonight so umum so just I don't know what to say thank you I mean that the time you've you've been here and the passion you put in for the Arts and for um was everything you've done um I think people sometimes minimize how much time and effort someone like you has put into this um and it's very appreciated even though it might not seem like it a lot appreciated um your voice and speaking up on issues when sometimes they were a little too quiet so keep doing that
143even though if you're not here so um I think back to the times when I was a community rep on the board finance and knew were the board member and I got to think wow this lady's really smart [Laughter] but thank you for your service I just think on behalf of the public um it is a anyone who serves in this position obviously is giving them themselves and of their time and and believes that in what public education means and and how it matters and I think that you always were very um intentional about your comments and were thoughtful about various uh students and particularly those underrepresented uh and how we continued to look at them fairly and and how we and what language mattered so um your work is appreciated your caring concern for
144for our students for our staff um your work even uh Personnel committee and and Lor's um or the superintendance um what am I trying to say what evaluation evaluation um I think was great so um hopefully you can enjoy Wednesday nights in in a different scope not have to come out in the weather but thank you for the time and for your commitment and Monica it's been fun um for the last eight years uh but I I agree 100% with what Heather said there it's just you know I I can see the level of commitment I can see the level of care uh we didn't always agree on everything and we probably never will always agree on everything but I don't doubt the sincerity with which everything was presented um and I and I do
145appreciate that a lot and I think you've been very good for the board in many ways and I can't say we'll miss you cuz I'm not going to be here either so Monica thank you very much for serving it's been a wonderful eight years you've definitely made um an impact and impression on the the school board and and the presentations um and I think that that won't be ending when they pull something up and there's these slides and they have art on um that's because Monica once was here so uh thank you very much it's been a pleasure serving with you thank you all of you for having me here um I do want to say um I won't be here next meeting so I do want to say something really special to you all
146because probably going to do all this all over again next one um so um I I do appreciate a lot your input um different than you I don't think that we are in disagreement as much as people may think I think that we're more more in agreement than in this agreement um I I think that the the the there are there are differences not in what we agree but sometimes in in how we want it to bring It Forward um and and that makes it interesting and makes it interesting in in the discussions and Mak makes it interesting in how we approach the board and how and why it's important to have just different perspective it's not really about agreeing or it's not really about getting to is how do we see that Baseline that
147that Common Ground um getting there and and how we see to the eyes of others um so I do appreciate that um about you and and about being willing to challenge and to put your voice forward even at the times that you felt that attack personally attack or or that you felt that that wasn't welcome by other boards members and sometimes by me um so we we we got to cross those bridges and and that is great and being an immigrant person that has arrived to Minnesota and being the straightforward person that I am in the land of no conflict which is this land really really that is a a breath of fresh air to have somebody that will go into me um from everybody else thank you so much really really have enjoyed my
148time here and I have enjoyed to be part of this thank you to you guys that are then at the end and nobody says anything to you the ones taking take making sure that this everything works here so I really appreciate your work and that you are here for for for us and keeping communication with us keeping everything working um yeah put a camera there so come here um and thank you for that all of you that that have been here um please remember to have a grounded education for everybody and Define how what is the class of type of education that we want to expose our kids to I really really really hope that that goes somewhere in in what the future that you have so okay um better let just leave though or
149cupcakes yep before we dig into the cupcakes can I get a motion to adjourn tonight's work session have a motion by Scott did somebody else say uh second by Monica all in favor say I opposed uh we are adjourned it is 8:55 p.m. have a good night thanks for watching and we will be back December [Music] 18th so we have cupak