001to the the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all Aaron do we have anyone signed up for public comment okay then let's get right to our discussion items um the first on the agenda is our cellular phone and personal communication and de device policy and I had sent everybody a marked up version of what we talked about before um there's some red everything was good until we got to the definition of stored um and there was some back and forth about that so um Miss Cleveland went back to the notes and um actually I appreciate it um put all the things that we discussed in Red so if you'll look on page two that was one of the things
002that was in question um so if there's conversation about that fine if not we'll accept it and move on accepting it means to put the red in make it black is that what you're saying correct we would put we would make the red words part of the policy let's see if nobody has any comments we're all good with that we'll move on and then the expectations for students we added words in there as well and red and we had many conversations about kind of goes back to the definition of stored right um and I honestly have gotten a lot of feedback from teachers as well over the last week about this and I I I see the point of if it you know if it vibrates or you hear it or whatever um so I
003kind of now in of agreement that it must not be on the person's body um and if if we have to take some kind of I don't know action to help kids have something to sort in I don't know what that would be but we can be creative um if I can make a statement Madam chair sure first of all I wanted to apologize to the board I did something that it's funny if I was the chair I probably wouldn't have done I uh talked to even though I mentioned something to um you madam chair I still ended up asking a question of Mr Watson and I should not have done that so I ask for your forgiveness that was wrong of me to do that I've already talked to miss Hoover I know better
004than that it's just that I wanted to see his opinion but I shouldn't have done that if I can to say one other thing is after praying about this and looking at this I know um some of us were rather adamant and may not be in the pocket and I talked about the bulges and so on my point is is I now after thinking about this I wouldn't mind even leaving that statement in r as long as we understood that we don't expect the administrators to um first of all to search kids obviously not but then also if they just see a bulge in the pocket we don't expect them to stop every kid if they see a bulge in the pocket um and if we understand that we don't expect administrators to do that
005then I would be fine with leaving this as being not in the pocket of course I like the idea of being visible as I mentioned last time but I'd be fine as long as we have an understanding we don't expect the administrators to call out every kid because they see a bulge or whatever so that was my point Thank you madam chair anyone have anything to add to that everybody's okay to add that if I can so I'm fine with it either way I mean obviously I'd like it in the black without the red but I'm okay with the red as long as we as a board have an understanding we don't expect the administrators to search the kids or call them out with bulges yeah I don't think that we need to put that
006in the policy though as far as we don't expect you to you know pass no no no I agree I agree as long as we have an understanding I don't want to have to us be calling oh I was there and there's three kids that walk by with a bulge in their pocket and the administrator didn't say anything I I don't as long as we don't have that expectation but I do want to note that it does say out of visible sight as well and powered off that's so meaning that if it's in their pocket and we can clearly see it then that's against the policy and they do need to take action but not to Pat them down in the hallway it's kind of at the discretion of the of the staff right if
007we leave it it's the discretion of the staff and that's fine as long as we understand that however if we go into the school often and we're we're thinking you know you can see phones in pockets and stuff we still as a board have the right to talk to Dr Boyd about that like we're still seeing a lot of phones out not expecting them to check them but I'm just saying like we we shouldn't be seeing I guess I shouldn't say that they're visible yeah shouldn't see them yeah that's why I like the word visible there yeah I know I like leaving it like it's in Black I like that okay next okay then the I just lost my spot sorry um the next thing was the consequences so I had a a thought um
008and I think I discussed it with everybody um that if we don't put any of the consequences in but we just say something along the lines of what What U Miss Cleveland put in there if the student gets a third referral they'll be asked not to bring a cell phone for 30 days if it happens same student again then students won't be allowed to bring the cell phone to school for the Remain the remainder of the year that way we're not saying this is the first offense consequence this is a second offense Etc but we're not going to have seven and uh several of us did look at local um District policies and they do have these kinds of this kind of verbage in there so I'm open to feedback um I I just I
009think we get dangerous when we say first second third because then what's fourth like fourth fifth six kind of thing I just say if you get three then it it goes away and we don't want to tell you know Administration that they have to take it and be responsible for it or anything like that but what what do what does the board think I'll wait to hear others before I respond I think we have to have the consequences to be Stern enough to make an impact just like we had earlier today we had right consequences Stern enough to make an impact therefore I like those consequences that are there uh as you said we've checked several schools in the area uh and they have those same consequences um and as far as consistency goes I
010understand I'm not sure about this Dr Boyd can tell me uh doesn't the Middle School confiscate bones they do right now then why can't we be consistent and have the high school cons confiscating phones also uh it's just what we're looking at consistency there so I mean I think the first offense confiscated till the end of the school day and then the second and the third what happens after the fourth uh you know that can be left up to the principles that are there to decide that so you disagree with saying after the third referral they can't bring it for 30 days I'm sorry on there he said after the fourth he didn't care no no no I didn't say after the fourth it says down here after the third or on the third they
011can't bring it for 30 days so you agree with that I agree with that what happens after that time after that they can't bring it back for the rest of the year that's fine that's the thought process then they're out of that business after I agree with that did you I know we talked a lot about this last time did the administrator see this this particular thing that they didn't they they saw the consequences I mean which you wrote this third one they I did not the one on the top no that's what I'm saying is they didn't see this for second and third offense thing so they saw that initially when I when I met with them before the last meeting um and he the feedback that I got was that it didn't belong
012there um something along those lines yeah that's my um however you know if the board chooses to do that now we I didn't go back and ask for opinion after the third referral yeah well again I'll just repeat the same thing is that um I just think that when you get into consequences whether there's the first second third fourth whatever we tie our administrators hands when the board starts to develop a policy when they may want to do something even stricter they may want to do something less strict they know their schools they know their students far better than we do so I just think that we don't need to put consequences there they're in the handbook let them develop let them make the decisions because we've got a very clear policy and I just
013don't feel it's the board's responsibility to put consequences I think that's the administration's okay can I can I comment on that real quick so while it's not the board's responsibility to impose their procedures one of the responsibilities of the board is to govern to make sure that the policies are followed when we have an administrator come here and tell us that he had to give out 17 referrals to a student in my thoughts we failed as a leader because that is not what we want to see we don't want to see our students having to get or our teachers having to write up 17 referrals for a student and then obviously our policy isn't working right so that's why we're here right now um I will also tell you that West Morland uh Stafford County
014um hold on I know I have more um coal pepper and there was also another one I had here Floyd all have consequences in their policies so Madam chair yes could I make a motion that we take a vote on the consequences uh just on that just on that one thing that's there can we can we just go through the rest and if and then we can vote because I don't think anything else is going to any any I understand what you're saying but I don't think there's going to be issue with anything else that of the changes then we'll just make them someone can make a motion to pass as is or not okay so if we go down to expectations for administrators teachers and other school Personnel um we added the word administrators
015and then also personal electronic devices you know to include everything a personal electronic device includes Madam chair can I just Qui because we actually took out administrators and the exception um we took out administrators um needing to uh be prohibited from having their cell phones because we feel like um see your notes down at the bottom now they would need to have those in case you know of emergency situations or be able to communicate um whatever they need to communicate we also had that discussion to add that they could have them they needed them for academic per purposes like we discussed sometimes they're doing evaluations and and they they would need to have them to take notes on and I guess so you're right sorry about that and then the exceptions this is one thing
016that Miss ha had shown an issue with or expressed an issue with about that they can use the school issued Chromebooks and approved personal laptops she said they have about 100 students that bring their own laptops and they kind of manage them the best they can so those are the only other changes were there any issues with any of those changes yes ma'am that comment you just made they manage them the best they can well that probably came out wrong but they the the same controls that are on the network or on those students laptops right but I think um she didn't say that those are kind of my words um they manage them but they don't have the only thing that they can do is uh prevent them from the network things right so
017does that make sense yeah shouldn't be an issue if they don't have their phones because the only way they can go outside of the network I believe if I'm correct is if they can use their Hotpot from their phone but if they're using the school network they can't do nothing else and and we have had teachers and staff members tell us that students are using their phones as hotspot so you're right they can't bypass however at the technology committee meeting there was a student there that said there are ways and are they can put it in their backpack but you're just not gonna no like kids are technology Savvy way more than we are so where there's a will there's a way but we can only do our best in trying to help so all
018those other things acceptable Madam chair can I also make another comment about this I had spoken with one of my um friends in another um district and I was talking to her about you know the policy that she had in her district and how well it was going and to my understanding you know there was um an opportunity for King George County schools to get those bags um that you lock and unfort we we lost the under bags Grant or whatever that was so these have been successful to my understanding in other schools so I I also when I've been thinking about this the 17 referral situation just blows my mind but if there is um a way you know that we can try to get in our budget since we are budget time if
019that's what's needed to help um it might be a consideration for us because um you know from the feedback that I've been getting um this has not been you know unsuccessful at other school at other high schools so um I just want to make sure that you guys I don't think it's been unsuccessful at our school either it just hasn't been instant you know right and I don't think it's been I'm sorry that was the wrong terminology I don't think it's been unsuccessful I don't but I do think it has been bit a bit challenging and I do believe it's because we don't really have I mean I think it we don't we don't we lack the parental involvement and we just need to incorporate that in somehow where the parents are actually involved in
020having to come to the school and get the phone if it's taken away I know for sure if my kid got their phone taken away and I had to go to the school they're never having a phone again so that's what I Madam chair can I ask Dr boy a question question sure don't we have some of those bags or you said 30 of they're like boxes right now they're combination boxes that uh if they violate the policy at the at the high school then the then they take their phone and they lock them in these boxes and um the boxes open up at a particular time so they're very similar to the Yonder bags are they cheaper they're cheaper yeah they're cheaper the Yonder bags think if I remember correctly we're about I think
021they were up to $30 a bag or something like that 30 back $30 a bag and then I think the boxes were maybe half that yeah 14 something I said yeah I think the boxes would work too Miss Cleveland but you have a good point yeah and what would we do would we we're kind of getting off the cell phone policy here but would we get a box for every student or would we just get like we do now and just give them to the students that can't seem to not touch their phone I think we've probably got about 10% of Hardcore that are going to try to keep their phone all the time so we if we get 150 bags for the high school or 150 bags okay I'd rather see the bags in
022the boxes but you know if we get those 150 or whatever I think that'll be enough okay we have I I called about getting a smaller sum of Yonder bags when I spoke with the Yonder folks they're not interested in in selling you 150 they won't sell you 150 bags they'll only sell you a school uh amount of bags I actually asked that specific question that's kind of why we explored the the other options you know and they're not all great the Yonder bag's got there's some issues there too every you know you we're all going to draw a line in the sand and kids are going to put their toe over it sometimes um but Yonder will not right now unless things change won't sell you a a percentage of bags compared to your
023student population okay um I guess we'll have to address that when we hit the budget discussion we G say something yeah well the other thing because like Riley called me today from the office phone he had to go to the office and call me and I was like why are you calling me from the office from and he's like because my phone is in my book bag mom like it's supposed to be and so I I don't I feel like maybe how can we help all staff get on the same page and not have some enforcing it and some not but I guess that's their thing but that's going to help with the policies and not kids not getting referrals and stuff because if the teacher is allowing it so how can we help curve
024that well I think that's going to be up to Dr Boyd and the principles to to handle that uh I mean I don't think it's not fair to the kid if the no leader is telling them they can it's it's nothing consistent then so I mean kids students love structure you know and they don't go from one classroom to another uh if it's not the same so I want to say and I hope and I think we all know this that um the high school admin has been making effort since well the whole time I think but like more of an effort um is what I've noticed well besides when we went that one anyways this is a good step I think um I will make a motion to accept the cell phone policy as
025written with the exception of the following um so I'm gonna I don't know what copy everybody has take out administrator I don't know what copy of okay they everybody should have the copy marked in red that you sent me because I sent it to everyone okay so I'm gon to I'm going to make a motion that we accept the policy as written with the exception of we're going to take out on the top of the exceptions where it says do we want to include exceptions we're going to take out that after third referral student will be asked to not bring a cell phone we're going to accept the consequences as written for first offense second offense and third we are going to take out administrators on the second paragraph of exceptions for administrators teachers and
026other school Personnel we are going to add uh we going to add um underneath that paragraph or for academic purposes for them to be able to use the um cell phones when on break during their planning time or for academic purposes and we are going to add to the exception that students can use issued Chromebooks in a approved personal laptops for academic purposes so you're suggesting we leave in that may not be in the pocket I thought we said we were going to keep just the the black are we going to add the red in that too I think we're in a motion right now right I know but I want to up here what the mo so to clarify yes so it would be as written may not be in Pocket May in must
027instead be placed out of sight and a backpack Locker or lock locked pouch does anyone want to second into that second all in favor discussion discuss sorry any discussion yeah again um I I was one of the first ones back when I first came on the board I wanted a cell phone policy and um I do believe we got a good one I still do not think we should put consequences I think it ties the hands of the administrators I realize there's other divisions that have done that and I I do not think that's appropriate just cuz somebody else has done it um and I I would say as a past administrator and I'll be willing to bet if you talk to administrators in those schools they would probably say I would rather have let
028the administration do consequences so I just have a major problem with putting these consequen everything else I think is fine but the consequences I do not think is appropriate to do as a board so why were we why did we have the last meeting that we were at talking about cell phone policies I'm I guess what I'm trying to I'm want hear you out cuz I think you're smart and you have a lot of experience but when when we were told what the consequences were and they're 5 13 winner winner was 17 like is that okay no I think the administrators need to do a better job but I don't think they do a better job by us forcing or telling them here's the consequences you're going to abide by you're going to do this
029in your school it's okay to invite them in to making our policy pardon inviting them into create our policies okay but us not setting guidelines of what we expect because we weren't getting the results we were hoping for the first time so where do we step in and say okay we not getting the results where do we govern we govern by if we do not think that we're not getting the results I okay I think that they need to have consequences absolutely I think they need to be in the handbooks um of what those consequences will be if those consequences are not working and we as as a board see that then they need to change and we need to make sure through Dr Boyd that they will change those because they're not effective they're
030not working allow them the ability to make the consequences worse maybe far worse than what we see here maybe easier better in other words my point is give them the freedom to be able to make those decisions and if they're not I agree with you Colleen if they're not then they need to change them and we go through say Dr Boyd we've been to the schools and these aren't working so what are their current current consequences well you need to tell them that they need to make changes in them but allow them the freedom to be able to make those changes that's my point so miss Hoover you had suggested that in the beginning um but there's something missing you said take out four I don't see the well it's on the original one that
031we had it didn't have what's on the top of do you have the one that's marked up in red M okay it didn't have that first paragraph where it says after third referral student will be asked to not bring a cell phone to school for 30 days we didn't have that I just put that in because I wanted to have it as a discussion because Kathy asked me to I I my my thought is we don't put consequences to First and Ed and I had this discussion and we disagree um I don't think we should put first second and third and tell them what to do I just think if you get three you don't bring your phone for 30 days and if you get another one you don't bring it back the rest of
032the year and I think that's an acceptable consequence because now we're we're giving them leeway to control the first three but if anybody that gets more than three then we're stepping in you understand I think these consequences are great I just think the administrators need to do them not the board that's it no I I I understand and and I'm on the same page a little bit with you but what I don't like is that you're saying hey we're crossing in a procedure but then you're telling them that they can crossover into policymaking no yes by saying have you talked to them have you given this to them to review so it makes me just that there I guess then when I talk to you later you say yeah you have a good point but
033then you go right back to saying it again no no no you're misunderstanding things no I'm not I'm not misunderstanding well I guess what we need to decide is if I mean as obviously we're not going to come to a a no I think yeah we just have to make a motion to vote on it but I do I like the that the three I think it's a fair compromise but in their defense we're here for a reason right I like what you said maybe give them a opportunity because here's the thing they get the 30 days don't bring a phone back and what what do they do if they bring another phone back a different you can't suspend the kid for it so then what now it's back to the what did they come
034to the school board for re you know whatever this one does input some um parental involvement so I imagine that when parents are coming to get their cell phones every day it probably won't happen as often I think we need to think about it if it does so like I like the fourth one being in there or being at the third at least like your phone's gone for the year um but then what happens if they bring another one Madam chair yes there's been a motion and second can we we're in discussion let me let me ask you a question about that real quick um because it doesn't include in the third it says in addition for a period of 30 calendar days the student shall be banned from yeah okay but it doesn't say
035year for the year that's what I was asking you in the very beginning and I got off track yeah yeah so do we need to include that so I guess it would be after the fourth referral instead of after the third so we have the third down there so we can take all those away and say after the fourth referral the student can't bring it back for the end till the end of the year I don't know that it's just a thought we have to if we have a unanimous decision to make it the other way then that's fine oh I see what you're saying though if we take out the parental involvement it's going to be back at square one all the time constantly yeah you see and that that's a that to me
036is Mak an a parent come in would really help enforce the policy yes and um so that would I mean we can't search them when they come to school so at the end of the day if they do bring it back and they're using it then every single time their parents going to have to come and get the phone at that point yeah or yeah okay so we have a motion that's been made and properly seconded and any more discussion okay then let's take a vote Mr Bush no I I really want to pass one just being an administrator for 15 years in secondary schools just don't like the idea of a board telling the administrator you must do these consequences okay yes Mr Frank yes Miss Cleveland yes okay we have an unanimous decision
037um you got to vote oh I vote yay well it's not unanimous I'm sorry it's okay four to one 4 to one and then Madam chair we need a copy we don't have a copy of you're right can you can you send him that I'm sorry thank you for doing that Madam chair so what I'll do just to make sure that we're on the same page with the one that I have I'm going to make the edits on and I'll send it to you guys as well so if there's any issues with what I typed up you'll see it before it goes to Jesse Dr voice took me a whole year to do that I do need the that you're using now okay okay I'll forward it to you all right now that that's done
038we can move to the FY 2526 budget discussion yes Madam chair so uh hopefully everybody brought their lovely budget book so we talked about the budget timeline a little bit earlier uh we have some uh we're here Miss Williams is here tonight I think everybody knows Miss Williams she's our finance director myself and Aaron are here and uh we're certainly willing and able to field any questions from the board on the budget request uh I know in my mind one of the biggest questions we need to answer tonight is the health care question um and then really as as I talked in my superintendent uh comment um hopefully we can get to a place tonight where we're in a relative agreement with where we what modifications we may or may not need to make to
039the budget so that we could possibly have a special meeting before the Board of Supervisors meets so uh with that I'll uh stop and and take this in any direction the board would like to go in my question um Mr Frank mentioned to me would we if we had a meeting next week would it would there be any opportunity do you think to have the Board of Supervisors attend and have at a joint discussion like we did before or or are we just running out of time that typically would probably be after it's presented to them ah okay and maybe we could work I could work if that's the request to the board I can request that from Mr small Nick and see if we could have a work session after it's presented to them
040which would be March time frame we normally have that every year uh we've had it every year that I've been here I don't think it was here the first year I was here but we've had it the last three well let's why don't we talk about the I don't know if anybody has a preference but I think the um healthc care is is a big thing that we have to talk about and I just like to kind of get a a feel for where everyone stands I know um I could go first or I can let somebody else go first do you have a preference Mr Frank how do you feel about it this is a big com this this is a big we need to how much is if we take on the if
041we take on the full 20% what's that going to cost us so so that's in the table you're looking at right now if you take on the full 20% then it's going to be 1,112 $715 1, 11127552281 doubling uh it wouldn't be d uh 5 million we would be adding an additional million so right now we're at five we're at 5.5 million we're at 5.5 million right now and if we took on the 20% that would be an added 1.1 million but right now we're paying or last year we paid 11% correct right and how much additional do you know how much we paid last year uh what what the bottom line was in terms of that remember what that was I want to say 565 or somewhere in that ballpark so so we're talking
042about doubling what we paid last year that's a good way to look at it yes sir I just feel like if we here we're we're working so hard to give them more money right and yet this expense is going to take away any money we give them so I know it's a huge amount of money and it's an estimated 20% there's still a possibility that could be less that's a good point I have a question about that actually so is there a way to bid it to other people or do we just have to be stuck with this one carrier we we can bid it in fact that's why we partnered with Mark I last year the gentleman that spoke to us Heath Thomas he he is our broker uh he done a good job
043by by us so far he really takes a look at a number of different metrics the point he was trying to make to us right now now is because of our current usage we're not that strong of a candidate uh to to bid it out we certainly can I can tell you in terms of uh the state what we have right now local choice is what most um public entities use because it's known to be the least expensive most quality option that's out there uh many school divisions many local governments our local government all uses local choice um local choice is going out to bid in terms of the provider right now so that's a variable that's still out there that we're waiting to hear some more information about um I think Heath's recommendation right
044now is that we're probably in a place where we need to stay in terms of going out to bid but probably next year or something like that he'd be it might be a good time to look at it if you remember I asked him that exact question I said is it would it be better or is there a chance that we would save money by looking had another vendor and he said no so I I do recall that but what I'm saying is do we have to use him is there another person that we can use oh rather than him as the broker I see I thought you're talking about the insurance company I'm sorry because some Brokers only have the ability to broker out to certain people so is it possible for us to
045I mean we can have a relationship with him as well but give it to somebody else to see if they can do better I think we certainly could right we're we're in a contract with them but that's that's for third party benefits so how long is the contct that's something we can look into I know right now it's late uh in terms of doing that for this this cycle um we've we've dove into this in different places in the past we often times come up short with with some other things but but another vendor or excuse me not another vendor but another broker that's a possibility I mean there's some out there that work with school divisions that we've seen at vsba and stuff but but isn't it a little bit late I mean I
046don't even know how we would accomplish that this year that would be a next year that would be a have to be next year I think Miss um Cleveland when the when the contract and also if you remember he did say that it will probably be less do you remember that he yeah I do and and I'm and I I just know that Brokers only have the ability to broker out to who that they do business with so there is other companies I don't I don't know about the the um you know school and how that works with the government and their contracts but I do know that most Brokers can only broker out to the people that they broker to are you sure of that I'm not is that right I had never heard
047that before no I know that's true in some cases but you're saying maybe he can use all of them I don't know but and that could be a question for him yeah could you we find check with him yeah that's a good question that's a good question well because Mr RS talked about this last year already so it had been brought up last year to start looking at yeah and so and what you're saying is maybe we can start doing that for next year and and he's interested in helping us out with that and we can also go and we'll start asking you know what type of network he has access to it's an excellent question I I assumed was he wasn't limited but you might be right and he may not be but in
048my experience most Brokers are limited to the only people they can broker too and there's in my experience you you have to have a relationship with them and there's like paperwork involved to be able to broker to those particular people so there might be other companies that he doesn't have that that's a good point let's yeah and I don't know if if it's that way with us or not but it's worth looking into I I always say get three bids so although has you know this broker has all these different bids he's doing there might be a couple other Brokers that can bid out too okay um a lot of time and this the reason for the rate increase is because of our internal claim so that's something to think of you know like even
049if he can get a somebody else can get us a lower rate there's still a possibility of the of the percentage going up because of the number of claims that that's that's the reason for the increase so where is the board stand on I know last year we had numbers on if we pay 10% if we pay 50% if we take it all I kind of want to get a feel for how everybody feels about just paying the difference and not paying the difference Dr Wood what we're talking five a little over 500 or almost $600,000 what do we have to cut in order to pay that where where would that money come from in order to pay the whole full 20% the full 20% is $1.1 million so we'd have to look at our
050budget and figure out what it would be up to us where would we cut that yeah what will we cut the difference between I mean what last year we paid five something this year we got to pay uh 1.1 so that's another 550 say but where's that 550 that wasn't used last year going to come from this year so if you take a look at your budget book you've already done yeah the presentation really the major differences is probably the best slide to look at right now and that is towards the end right before the revenue and expenditure slide it's it's this slide right here and it's it looks like yeah this see it's probably about two-thirds of the way through this page 20 it's towards the back oh yeah keep going towards the back
051okay what this slide shows you it's kind of a summary of the major cost increases I keep going at couple more couple more um you've already put in while he's looking for that the 20% you did already put that in there yeah so uh let's see uh one more one or two more uh Pages uh right there stop right there at the top yep so if you're looking at that what you see is the major differences and the major costs sum summarized in in this table here the first major cost is the is the raise so so this is a question to the board I I guess I'm I'm posing it back to the board if we were to pick up the whole cost you see the second row there the health insurance premium increase
052that rental that renewal rate at 20% that's the School Division that's the school board picking up the entire 1.1 million I think what I heard you say Mr Frank is if we paid what we paid last year where can we find $500,000 the answer is in this table and and it's it's posed to you because we can take you know I'm not saying these are good options but we can take $500,000 out of the compensation increase meaning Actually I don't even think this is a viable option we couldn't give less than 3% because the state's asking us to match that compensation rate uh you have the compression issue that we're trying to address if we didn't address compression there's $436,000 if we went deeper into I'll skip healthcare because I already talked about that but
053the budget Builder that's that's in your budget book that's the brightly color kind of rainbow uh presentation of all of the stuff in the budget book we could dig into that and find some savings if we had to that's the stuff of the budget and then finally at the on the last page of the budget book you've got staff positions I I'm a little we continue to increase the number of students in the division we we've got 80 more students in the school division than we had last year if we continue to lean on cutting staff positions then all we're doing in effect is increasing class size we continue to increase class size if we cut staff positions do um I can tell you that typically this in the past when we have this conversation
054with the Board of Supervisors and we talk about you know where we're going to land in between we always think it's a priority to cover the compensation increase because the state is contributing a certain amount of money for that that's like the first priority making sure we cover the raises we wrestle over Healthcare a little bit but when we fall in the middle we're asking for $.1 million total when we fall in the middle at like $2 million then what we typically cut short over previous budget years is the stuff in the budget you know that $1.5 million there in this in this budget summary in the new positions we've done that over the last couple years so when we increase by 80 students every year because of our Capac you know and we're dealing
055with our capacity issues if we continue to cut staff positions we're just in increasing class sizes so I I know that this is a you know kind of a negotiation but I don't want us to stop short of understanding that we need to add teaching positions right now and over the years if we don't you know like last year we didn't add as many as we should have in year before then that adds up and now we're at 30 plus kids a a room so I would propose that we look through the budget Builder Tab and I mean everything obviously is important right um and just see where we could maybe cut I don't know something we turn to page 13 though where he broke down can I can I address that too what we've
056done in the past is we will go back to the department heads here and we will say to them we want you to cut your budget by whatever 10% 15% 20% they've got those eyes that they know exactly what they're looking at and if we agree on an agreeable percentage or something in that ballpark I can take that recommendation from the board and take it back to our supervisors and say here we are you need to cut 20% or what sorry about that I forgot we did that do we know do we know if there's renewal rate was the same for all divisions or is it just is this 20% just King George what Stafford at it well so the rates depending on you remember when he get yeah depend because we have a lot
057of sick people well no we only have sick people but they're very out of 715 they're very sick probably a handful of them are very sick yeah so to your question we don't know what other rate increases are yet right now uh we'll probably know within about a month I think is is usually the time frame for this I've asked Mr small Nick they don't know their County increase yet because that's important to us as well to figure out where they are uh they're still waiting to figure out what their rate increase is we just know that ours is estimated at 20% we hope it comes in Les than that but we don't know yet didn't he say oh I'm sorry go ahead sorry um when I ask him this question I asked when and
058I thought he said March he will know yeah yeah it's March so 20% the way he was explaining it seemed to be the maximum it seemed like he was indicated almost for sure it was going to be less 18% he yeah yeah he said about 18 did he all right I think it's safe to plan for the high end uh and if it comes in less that's wonderful that's a cost savings we certainly want wouldn't want to plan for less and then have to figure it out no I'm I'm top agreeing I just I don't know I want to look at the the compensate the compression I think when you let me ask you a question and I'm pretty sure I already know the answer going back to teacher salary comparison 2012 bachelor's degree years
059five and 10 I'm assuming we're low because of the compression I'm looking at this page right here that is absolutely correct okay I just wanted to make sure so when we look at I mean comparing us to all the rest of the divisions around us were we're good where we we should be except because of the co and the compression situation and if we don't correct this you know the teachers between that five to 10 year mark those are our key teachers and so I'm only saying that we've got to do the compression this year we can't put it off any longer it's got to be done and then once it's done we won't have to worry about it well it it's take a few years to but at some point probably in about five
060to 10 years from now and we won't have to worry about it so what David is referring to is this slide here that shows our average teacher salaries uh and what you see is the highlighted cell is the lowest salary in those particular years you have year one year five year 10 all the way up to year 30 these two cells here that are highlighted are we don't want to be highlighted there it's it's an unfortunate number because what that's saying is that King George among all of our competing School divisions where the has the lowest salaries in the region at years five and years 10 that's the compression issue we're talking about and it's really an inopportune time to have that compression because it's a pivotal time for professional adults you know you're five
061years in you're 10 years in you're trying to figure out if you want to stay in this profession you're trying to figure out if you want to start a family and make some major life choices if you want to move to King George uh all of those are decisions around year five to year 10 of teaching so right now the fact that we're the lowest in the region in terms of teacher salary is is a tough pill to swallow for some of our Educators so I liked Kathy's recommendation and I and I think you hinted at it and the budget Builder request that 1.5 million what do you suggest that if we as a board did ask you to go back to the administrators what would you think would be more palatable or less palatable
062in a percentage that they might be able to cut if we kept everything else that's a tough one I know yeah the high school asked for 42,000 I think which is not much not much at all yeah but we had pic didn't ask for anything yeah usually it's elementary schools ask for almost nothing right uh middle and high is a little more expensive because of the added activities and things but really it's it's our other departments like if you look at the summary page maintenance is the highest request by far uh that's that's an area we've got maintenance issues coming up uh We've really Dove deep into our contract with Honeywell and and taken a greater appreciation for our HVAC systems and the ages of those things uh so in consideration of that we've kind
063of Pumped up our maintenance uh request because some of our equipment is getting old and terms of our HVAC system it's a risk but that that's that's a possibility I just don't want to see teachers walk because we're not yeah yeah want to see that if you look at the page 13 veral Virginia that's 144,000 144 do that something that we have to do how many uh how many people you said there was 30 100 okay so you're talking about the new position the director position right 100 we we can it's not ideal uh but we can run that program without having a director for for the first year if this if this program grows which we hope it does because there's value to not only addressing our capacity issues uh but also attracting our
064homeschool Community back into our public there's a lot of value there uh if this program grows but I think we could get by a year we are putting extra workload on our school counselors and things of that nature but we could get by without having that virtual uh director for a year Stafford does this program now they have a director she's expressed to us the demands of that job we would have to lean on our our guidance counselors to do some of that stuff but we could do it can we Sorry K yeah see all of these things they're no I mean you you wrote off um the shared increase cost if we did the shared increase would you put on here on page 13 if anybody's wondering what would that help cover as far
065as the teacher pay and everything if we did it um the 85 15% okay so take a look at this this paper here all right back to the healthcare question so on the far left you'll see in it so that's the uh table on the far left that has the the blue uh title block right that's our current setup for healthcare you have our plans you've got uh in the highlighted red you got key Advantage 250 key Advantage 500 all the way down all of those are our plans and then if you dive into each one of those you can see I'm I'm going to use key Advantage 250 as an example the employee only the school board cost for the employee only there is $740 a month and the employee coming out of the
066employees paycheck is $115 I just gave you that example understand you told me that what I was trying to figure out is what's the difference of the full 20% versus the 15% and like almost a million so look over to the far right at the bottom on the far right if the Schoolboard picks up the entire cost on the bottom there it's $1,127 15 it's small text I can't even see it you see that in the middle in the in the middle in the middle column all the way down to the bottom yes the cost of the school board is going to be 1.1 million if you go over to the right and use the same cost sharing structure that we currently have the cost to the employer which is the school board would drop
067to $997,500 550 so would that be worth it 115,000 that's the question and then if you if you looked at um that c that whole section over there you can see the increased cost to the employe based on the plan that they choose so for example the key Advantage 250 employee only their healthare is going to go up $232 every month so if you're asking is it worth it that's the increased cost to the employee okay so are we going to lose an employee because now they're paying $23 more a month for Health Care um and and what is the value to us as the school board the value is $115,000 try to give back to them in a different way yep but but I think another question is when we look at the teacher
068salary comparisons this isn't total compensation so really it's not a true comparison because we don't know what the total compensation is for the other school divisions we know that we pay you know the full health care cost but does Stafford Spotsylvania Colonial Beach do we know that so that's also something to consider here yeah we we have an idea of what their health care costs are usually I mean in in and teacher compensation those are really your total those are your two factors it's your salary and it's what we're covering for Health Care we've pulled their health care uh costs usually your larger School divisions are pretty competitive uh with with Healthcare Stafford and spotsy are pretty competitive um would that be a correct assumption and then usually down the Northern Neck to your point
069they're they're paying more our their employees are paying more for healthare I mean Healthcare is going up healthare everyone's healthare is going up got it and it's gonna it's GNA continue it's probably going to keep going up I mean it's something to think about you know but like you said we can't keep pushing off fixing the steps for five and 10 those are our seasoned employees that are leaving because they're not yeah so it's a hard thing hard thing we're always going to have this increase happening every year I think I think a healthcare increase is something that so if we did give the if we did say the teachers will take the responsibility for this increase which would be somewhere between 23 a month or if it's a family 137 um do you personally
070think that would have a very negative effect because it doesn't seem that much especially for a single employee compared to us saving $115,000 yeah but I mean if if we're going to reality is if we're going to ask for or spend 100 I'm sorry a million 112 or a million it seems that 115,000 seems minimal and if if if our goal I think our number one um strategic goal is what employee investment so how are we standing behind that if we're not investing in I was just asking a question I'm not disagreeing I'm just the thing is is the compensation to me I mean excuse me the compression to me at this point is almost more important than the insurance cost because it's minimal but you're right $15,000 compared to a million 1.1 is it's
071not minimum with the family side I agree with what you're saying except for the family that hurts a little bit the family I think yeah if I was a individual employee and I had to pay $23 more a month for my insurance I would like well yeah I expect that that's that's what my point now a family maybe a little different and then I mean I know kind of getting off topic here but take into consideration that you have one parent working and one parent at home raising kids and they're working on a teacher salary and now that I'm sorry $232 c a month that's just a single person but you know $100 a month is a lot when they make $75,000 a year I don't think anybody makes maybe 60 50 yeah so I
072don't know I'm just yeah I think I think I think I stand by my let's go we paid it the last two years we've took taken on the whole cost yes we have well you know and part of this too is uh even if we just present everything like it is the odds are pretty good that there's a chance we're going to have to come back after it's presented to the Board of Supervisors we're GNA have to have this discussion again I think part of what I'm thinking is you've done a good job putting all this together maybe we should just go with this with the 20% knowing it'll probably be a little bit less hopefully but we know we're going to have to have this discussion again and the next discussion might even be
073a joint meeting between us and the Board of Supervisors and talking about all this together I think that's a good point to see also with the Board of Supervisors of what their costs are going to end up being because you know they're probably going to have some thoughts on this as well and maybe we can work together to come up with an solution since they're going to be um affected with the same issue and considering that they're going to have to you know we're going to have to ask them for more money well and also hear what they're giving their employees well that's what I mean like we need to find out that's my point is yeah maybe just go with this like it is because we're going to have and let M Small Mr
074smik present that and then knowing and then having this joint meeting afterwards and then ask the question you know what are you doing for your employees for insurance because insurance is the big one I did talk to some of the board members bard of Supervisors it's looking like half or they're almost willing like half of what we're over we're asking so out of the 4 million looks like we're going to be given two of that well that's that's talk that's that's just talking yeah and maybe between now and our next meeting we could each reach out to our prospective for of supervisor and just explain you know because I know some just say you know that's how it is they got to pay it they can leave you know and that's that's not how we
075feel we need to invest in our staff so maybe even have some of the 2 by two meetings if we could I know so hard to do schedules I know I think we need to talk more about those two by two meetings if we can do that after this but we need to talk about that yeah it affects this yeah I agree with you the more communication we can have the better well if somebody wants to I mean I I don't have any more time to coordinate meetings if somebody wants to take that on and schedule meetings I'll well you know get I'm Sorry Miss Madam chair um I know you and I tried to do it you know with our two perspective people and one of them is just impossible the other one was
076and maybe I'm thinking try to do the 2 by two if you can't then then 2 by one you know what I mean if you can't get everybody then go with three or a phone call it's better than nothing that's true or yeah maybe three in a phone call or whatever but I think maybe we need to be meeting individually with them even before we have this joint meeting and I'll try to do that maybe with the person that you and I contacted or missing one maybe that person could call in and the three of us will meet okay Bill and TC said nobody's reached out to them and I don't want to be I'm just saying so there's I was just sitting here thinking that I would reach out to cuz I know certain
077people on the board of supervisors have lighter schedules too and the one that I'm thinking about probably is going to be the hardest on the budget so yeah I have not reached out so Madame chair uh every one of the Board of Supervisors and the County Administrator have a copy of the budget book you guys I'm always available but I think you're well-versed in in the budget book now um so that you is probably the best tool you can use right now to advocate for the U the things that we need in the school division if um I'm hearing you guys correctly I would I I think I'm hearing you guys correctly would we be willing to make a motion tonight to approve the budget as presented right now and then we will wait to
078get some more feedback from the Board of Supervisors uh that way we've got an approved budget that uh the County Administrator can present we miss cev were you going to say something no does the anyone want to make a motion yeah I'll make a motion I make make a motion that we approve the budget as presented second any discussion we've had a lot all in favor I I chair votes I motion carries do we have a motion to adjourn I think Ed wanted to oh I'm sorry no I'm good no you wanted oh we did talk well I do think it's important the 2 by two and if we can't do 2 by two let's do 3x one or whatever or phone call or online by one yeah and then the also the discussion about
079um what was the other thing was mentioned at the beginning or at the beginning we talked about social promotions but that oh no that's that's about that now uh but goals we we talked about goals earlier are we stilling oh we were supposed to I that's not on the agenda for tonight I know and I never got any feedback from anyone I didn't get I sent an email out and and let's let's establish some goals everybody send me some I'll organize them and well I think it's because there's so many the couple of this was a big one the cell phone so on yeah I'll I'll I think we can get back to you this week that's I've got mine well you didn't send them to me I know okay we got to talk about
080one more sorry about the possibility of us Dr Boyd you had mentioned in the other meeting about the possibility of us needing to meet um before um like meeting again but we don't really need to now we we won't need to meet now until we get some feedback from the Board of Supervisors good all right just want to make sure we're okay with that okay I have a motion I make a motion to adjourn second all in favor I I chair Road ey motion carries we are adjourned good work guys e