CorpusRecord 12800

January 29th 2025 King George School Board Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / King George County Schools
Date
2025-01-30
Location
King George County, VA
Material
Transcript
Extent
22,007 words · about 123 min
Collected
2026-06-03

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001read by Pastor Sherman Davis after that we will have a moment of silence let's pray our heavenly father we do bow in Thanksgiving we thank you for the wonderful opportunity the wonderful privilege we have to be able to pray thank you I thank you for the as we prayed in the back room with others tonight with the throne of grace we're glad it's a throne of grace and uh Lord uh where Grace does abound Lord where sin does abound as Grace much more abound so tonight we pray for our school board we pray for uh for David Bush the shadow District we pray Lord for Ed Franks at large we pray for car Cleveland Lord James Monroe Colleen DAV from alren and Kathy Hoover from James Madison and Lord we pray for our superintendent of

002schools uh God we ask you would bless uh Jesse boy as he uh does what we believe you called him to do and Lord uh if there are Vice principles and principles in our schools that covered our prayers we pray for them uh Lord the teachers Lord if they cover our prayers we pray for them lift them up before you and Lord for the students who may be interested in Lord Prayer we ask you Lord to work in their hearts and lives and Lord uh we not only pray for we hear a lot of prayer about wisdom and Lord Lord know we we need wisdom but Lord we pray also tonight just for Good Old Common Sense com and dealing with issues Lord uh uh this life is filled with issues the Bible tells us

003to protect our hearts because out of it are the issues of life so we ask in Jesus name tonight as we uh deal with County uh schools and students and all that's going to be taking place in this year God that you give yes give these uh members wisdom and Lord good all common sense they lead have to make decisions that Lord affect everybody and Lord being in that position you're always popular with everybody sometime decisions are hard to make and so we just ask that you'd give them that understanding they need we'll thank you we'll praise you for all all that you do and all that you accomplish in Jesus wonderful name we pray amen and amen thank you Pastor so next we have the Pledge of Allegiance then the moment of silence and

004the Pledge of Allegiance today will be led by the King George Elementary School kindness crew uned states of to the stand Nation indivisible thank you thank you kindness crew can we hear a little bit about you if you don't mind before any of them want to speak I just want to tell you guys a little bit um about our crew so it's a true honor to talk about something very near and dear to all of our hearts so since I created kindness crew back in 2019 this group has embodied the core values of empathy leadership and giving back to our community more than I could have imagined the kindness crew isn't just a club it's a movement it's about fostering positive self-esteem among our students empowering them to lead with kindness and compassion we've witnessed

005firsthand how kindness creates Ripples and uplifts both students and staff when we lift each other up we build stronger more connected communities through various Outreach programs we've been able to volunteer at organizations like Love Thy Neighbor Ellen's blessing box Balor Ranch clutch for Paw which is an animal group and we've created our first Community kindness Library you can find that between the op shop and Napa Auto Parts and we support our Beloved School programs just to name a few these acts of service not only benefit those in need but also teach our students invaluable lessons in generosity leadership and the power of community so with that being said we're excited to announce that as part of our ongoing mission to spread kindness we are celebrating Virginia kindness week again February 10th to the 14th this

006year's theme is constellations of kindness and we're thrilled to show that kindness is truly out of this world so we will invite you to celebrate this week by spreading kindness in your own way whether it's a smile a helpful hand or a thoughtful word together we can light up our community just like the stars in the sky so I will invite some of my crew if they'd like to say something I think we have a volunteer Miss Laurel just right in there y okay I let you tell us your name and what you like about the kindness crew my name is Laurel um what I like about kindness crew is that um it's really fun and last week and this week we made we made um little dog toys out of shirts did you give

007them to dogs um they're going to be for they're going to be um donated to dogs oh that's so awesome does anybody have any questions for Laurel what do you like best about being in part of the group um because I like being kind and it's fun so we get to stay after school that's good so what do you are you any plans for next or for are you g to stay with us next [Music] year thank you Laurel I'm sorry does anybody else have anything to say to her no does anybody else want to say anything the crew want to say something Harrison not my name is Harrison tlon and my favorite part about kindness crew is um it's fun and I love making people happy that is my favorite thing too good job

008thank you for thank you oh oh thank you guys thank you guys so much you have any questions or good chairman I have a question how does one get into the kindness Club good question so we have a total of 25 spots so it's grade 2 to fifth grade and these students have to go through like a application including a teacher recommendation they have to answer their own essay questions of what they would like to do for their mission and then um I do not select them it is a blind audition per se and that's how the 25 are selected so not so every year there's new members constantly getting the opportunity so nice yeah thank you it's my favorite thing thank you guys thank you kindness crew we give him a hand now we

009have public comment on the list to speak is Sherman Davis you wanted read the scpt oh I'm sorry if you have not signed up for public comment please see the clerk now to sign up public comment is a time for the community to present matters that they believe deserve the board's attention comments are one-way communication from the Community member to the school board and they are not a form for dialogue or debate School Board applies the following procedures to all speakers and does not discriminate based on the identity of the speaker or the Viewpoint of the speaker comments should be presented in a courteous respectful and appropriate manner the public shall address the board only on matters that are related to the services and policies of the school division speeches that cause disruption to the

010meeting promote private business ventures involve threats of any kind involve intimidating language relate to members I'm sorry relate to public office campaigns involve complaints identifying individual students or personal attacks of Staff members is prohibited proper deorum and the provisions of this procedure directive are expected to be followed at all public meetings of the school board the members of the audience shall conduct themselves in the same manner as outlined above for the individual speakers and shall not disrupt an open public meeting of the school board nor incite others to do so at the discretion of the chair any person violating the rules listed above may be asked to leave the board meetings when recognized by the chair speakers will be asked to identify themselves by name State their relationship to the school division as in staff

011member student parent parent Community member Etc and indicate in which magisterial district they reside com commentary during public comment time is limited to three minutes and our first Speaker of the evening is Sherman Davis wow is there anything left to be able to say after all that stipulation anyway it is good to be here thank the Lord for the privilege my name is Sherman Davis uh pastor of the Tabernacle Baptist Church in King George and we're open every Sunday anyway I want to read a verse of scripture to you if I may and uh the scripture says in Romans chapter number three and verse uh 22 even the righteousness of God which is by faith of Jesus Christ unto all and upon all all them that believe for there is no difference for all have

012sinned and come short of the glory of God the uh authorized uh version of the scripture has the word all in it 5,620 times if that's of any interest to you and so I thought I would read all 500 50006 out no don't have enough time but anyway uh the very first time that's used in scripture the word all is in Genesis 1 and verse 26 where the Bible talks about how God gave man dominion over the all the Earth the last time it's used in the scriptures is revelation 22 and verse 21 which is actually the last verse of scripture in the uh New Testament in the Bible the Bible says the grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you all and then he says amen now between uh the Genesis chapter 1

013and verse 26 and revelation 22 and verse 21 there are 5,000 28 other verses and like I said I'll try not to read all of them but I'd like to give you just kind of a a thought of what some of them may say the Bible says for example all are are mortal the Bible says that all have sinned the Bible says that all are under condemnation scripture says that all are loved by God and all are provided for by the Lord Jesus Christ and all are saved who believe in their heart on what Jesus Christ accomplished on the cross for us when Jesus died on the cross he said it is finished and everything gets takes to get us to Heaven Jesus is already done there's nothing left to do he said believe and

014uh all invited through the gospel to come come unto me all that labor and heavy laden and I will give you rest Jesus says so whosoever will let uh him take uh the Water of Life freely as an invitation to all who will come and Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ I uh sometimes I wonder what people are so worried about about reading the Bible there's no such thing as freedom from religion we all have we believe something we all have some kind of religion if there nothing but our believe in ourselves but all of us have a religion so I'm just confused sometimes why people want freedom from it and so God bless you and thank you thank you does anyone have anything to read in to the record for public comment Davis um

015this email that I'm that I was asked to read from a parent has been addressed partly and then they responded but they asked me to read this out loud hello Miss Davis we live in dogr our grandson is in 10th grade at King George high school as the King George board representative for our district I would like to pose the issue to the school board during the scheduled meeting on January 29th this past week King George High School presented a play in which Benjamin participated as crew member I did not attend because the only means of admission was to play was either purchase a ticket using credit card debit card or through a thirdparty vendor gofan.com then using a cell phone gofan.com send you a confirmation code to the cell phone which you present at

016the door or purchase a ticket at the door again using credit card or debit card only in other words cash was not acceptable means of a payment for admission yet cash is acceptable to purchase concession in fact cash at the door is not acceptable means of payment for admission at King George High School football games and my guess is the same is true for all King George High School events question why why is Cash not acceptable means of admission and two what if I did not have a credit or debit card or sell you of a phone or even internet access am I prohibited from attending these functions to support my child in the school thank you very much and then they were responded to on why we went to that and um basically wanted

017us to wanted me to bring it up if this is something that we could change where we can have cash thank you anyone else have anything to read okay I'm closing public comment next we have superintendent comment yeah so thank you Pastor Davis we always appreciate your uh attendance at our Schoolboard meetings it's always uh three minutes of of good information so thank you so much sir for that uh I did have an opportunity in terms of the other public comment that was read out loud I have spoken with uh our athletic director at the high school and gotten some pretty good feedback from him certainly something that we can uh continue to talk about in terms of cash you know a lot of this came through um came through covid but for a few

018reasons um secur was one of the reasons that we we oftentimes go cashless now at the school level uh what what that consideration is is um oftentimes you have uh volunteers students uh and even staff members who are collecting money uh this process going cashless is one that um really kind of eliminates a lot of the uh middleman and and uh provides more direct um I guess um account balancing I guess all the money goes directly to the school without the middle you know about a lot of people touching it if I'm making sense there um that was one of the considerations also got feedback that I think in the battlefield District right now six out of eight of our schools are mainly um cashless right now so it seems to be Trend across the

019state growing right now um we do have opportunities we do have like a senior citizen pass we have some other things that um folks can apply for if they would like to um but as it stands currently we have not for I believe since Co for a couple of years accepted cash as as uh for for tickets but uh something we can certainly look into uh to address that individuals public comment moving forward so that's my comment ma'am and and I'll stop there because I know we've got plenty to talk about okay next we have changes to the agenda does anyone have any changes I just want to uh comment before we get started that we are supposed to end at nine o'cl so if we have to modify that we can discuss it when

020that time comes okay let's go with our first presentation so as they come forward Madame chair we have uh as a result of uh board member Cleveland's request at the end of I think that was the last meeting in December uh we had a we had a question about pulling together some data in terms of really assessing where we are with uh postco learning loss in terms of I think specifically the question was literacy but numeracy is also a very important topic that we're focused on right now I think you have this evening the opportunity honestly this presentation is going to be much better than mine but um I've had the opportunity for many many Mondays to listen to M stuff and and our instructional team provide this level of of discourse when it comes

021to ex clearly explaining data and and I think um without stealing her Thunder uh I think you'll be happy with what she has to present so without further Ado Miss Miss stuff and the instructional team good evening everyone um thank you so much for this opportunity to review our current math and reading data and share our efforts that we are making in each school to make progress um the first thing that I kind of want to explain is that we had a 2-year Gap in so data for from covid but a lot of other things also happened in that two-year Gap and those things are going to affect the data and the numbers as well so we had um covid closures for 2019 and 20 and then 20 and 21 was a hybrid year where

022accreditation didn't count because students weren't expected if they could come in the building to test they were allowed to but they didn't have to we also during that covid switch we transitioned our sixth graders to the middle school so the data pre-o has our sixth graders in the elementary data and then postco um the sixth graders are in the Middle School data there was also a change in English standards so they had changed the English standards right before covid and then they were tested for the first time the year we came back so there and we traditionally see a 1 to 2% drop in data when there are new stand being implemented just as teachers and curriculum get up to speed on the new expectations um the biggest change in the data is that the

023state took and made a part of accreditation growth metrics so for grades three through eight students who did not pass the but made significant growth from the year before we were we're given different measures of points in our accreditation data so you'll see when I show you the chart that that is a big impact and then the final thing is that we had um there was a transition that happened postco where students who um take the VAP testing which is our special education population if they in an IP team they determine that an so is not appropriate an assessment for them there is a VAP which is a Virginia alternate Assessment program that allows them to take a different test and postco the state put the expectations that less than 1% of our population would

024be doing that program so there were a lot of students that we had to reevaluate in I meetings and as a team if it was appropriate to put switch them to an track we are going to look at the data from two different perspectives um my presentation probably has just as many numbers as Dr Boyd is going to have but they're very different um our accreditation data is data that you are used to seeing the public is used to seeing it's what's in the newspapers it's it's all over the place it's data that has been adjusted and refined by the state so um students that transfer in andout or subgroup data is clar ified growth is added in so students that didn't pass still get a percentage of a point and then expedited retakes are

025included so that is where we give students credit for progress and the exped retakes or where they're able to take a test a second time and try and pass it the pass rate data is raw data it is the number of students who passed an so divided by the number of students who took it so if 300 kids took a reading so it's the 180 that passed it it's just raw data which tells a very different story than the data that has been through the accreditation machine so this first chart is our reading data for the for the 10 years it looks like a lot but if you hang in there with me so it's the five schools and then it's division numbers and State numbers the pr is the pass rate data so it

026is the raw percentage number and then the ACC is the accreditation number so if you look at the five years that are on there pre-co you'll see roughly a 3 to 5% difference between the pass rate number and the accreditation number and like I said that comes from the transfer students being taken to account and stuff like that then postco with growth being included in the accreditation you only see it at 3 through eight so you only see it at the elementary schools and the middle school but it roughly translates to about a 15% difference between the pass rate and the accreditation number and that is because we are giving students who didn't pass the test but maintained grow but showed growth Credit in our accreditation Matrix so if you focus on the elementary schools

027those kids are testing the pre-o data is 3 through six the post covid data is three through five Middle School is also a shift because it's s it's seven and eight pre-co and then 678 postco and then the high school is always for reading English 11 so it's our 11th graders that are being tested um I I kind of want to point out a couple of Trends to you if you focus on the state average pre-co it's a 78 so postco the first year back is a 73 so it was a 5% loss if you look at the division we had a 4% the high school actually increased Middle School was a write down the number 6% loss so you can see we we we matched very closely with the state um you can see

028that in the pattern of the data too if the state average pass rate for the last 3 years has been 73 um our division average has been 76 75 and 75 so it all is in a line yes there was learning loss you can see it in the numbers but we are in the same boat as everybody else trying to make up that learning the next chart is a line graph that shows the accreditation data I figur I thought it showed a good because the Gap in the middle shows you where covid occurred and if you focus on the black line which is the division and the pink line which is the state you can see that our division line is right in the middle of all five schools and then the state is the

029pass rate number and that was sitting at that 73 um the next slide tells a little bit more information because it's the pass rate data so it's the actual raw data this is the data that the classroom teacher inside me wants to know because this really tells me what my kids if they're passing or if they're not growth is is a wonderful metric to to focus on and make sure your students are growing but when push comes to shove when they get to high school they're passing these tests to graduate so I would I appreciate the the raw data as a classroom teacher um there is a I'm sorry Amanda can you go back two slides if you I wanted to mention those yellow lines so the yellow line between the covid Gap and 2122

030is the new standards so we saw that the state um put new testing and new standards in place and then there's a yellow line at the bottom of last year because this year we are testing new standards in the spring so we will have another round of new standards our our 11th graders who tested in December were on the old standards but the new ones that test in May will be on the new standards it's a shift in the middle of the year that always happens at the high school because the December ones stay with the old standards thank you the next chart is our math chart if you look at that you'll see the same pattern of between Pass rates and accreditation preo there was roughly a 3 to 5% um difference between the

031pass rate and accreditation and then counting growth at postco it's roughly 15% um I didn't mention on the reading and I should have the growth is not represented at all in the high school data because the high school is not given credit for growth growth is strictly a 3 through eight metric um looking at the yellow line between 1617 and 1718 you can see that we had new standards that were place and there was a natural drop um of but for the state was 2% for our division was 2% um we can expect something similar you'll again see the yellow line at the bottom of last year we are also assessing new math standards this year um the state rarely doubles down on us like that but this year I think they're trying to get

032themselves back in sync with everything and so we have a switch of math and reading this year which definitely puts a burden on our elementary teachers who sometimes teach both it's a it's two new sets of Standards to learn um looking at this I just want to bring your attention again to the state average from pre-co was an 82 um the state average postco for math was a 66 so the state saw 16% drop in math um pre and postco um King George County saw the same we saw an 18% um loss during that time and it's definitely rebounding a little bit for us you can see there's growth at kingor school from a 68 to a 74 to a 76 but it's it's slow growth it's it's a work in progress trying to get

033those numbers um back where they need to be and it is um King George High School doesn't have the the growth number so when you look at their pass rate and their accreditation they're they're the same thing there is a slight difference in that transfer kids are taken into account and and everything like that but for the most part they don't see the the 10 to 15% shift that um elementary schools and the middle school does the new standards this year will prove to be a little bit of a drop there but we can see that when you look at the state average being 66 69 71 and our division being 67 69 then 70 we are we're right with the state in that information I did the graphs the same way here you can

034see the accreditation data um shows coming back from covid having um not as much of a drop in the elementary schools as it as did at the high school because the high school didn't get credit for growth whereas when you go to the pass Ray data you will see that there is a can you go to the next one you'll see a drop everywhere um but if you look at the pink in the black lines they are almost on top of each other the division average and the state average are right there along with each other and showing that other places are struggling like we are and we're making gains to to fix that Dr man is going to come up and talk about the next slide because it's Pal's data and then the instruction

035team just has a a bunch of information for you guys on the hard work that our schools are doing hi didn't mean to sneak up on you good evening uh it's my pleasure to talk about our Pal's numbers remember this is our kindergarten through third grade uh my name is Dr Andrea manin the coordinator of reading and language arts and I see some new faces and I see some faces from last year so it's good to see you all again um this information was provided by the state dating back to 2014 I am not going to review too much of those boxes prior to our covid years what I will tell you is the boxes that are in green King George County Schools is ahead of the state percentage in that and we have less

036identified students than the state does that need additional um intervention or instr instructional services that is a win for us and that speaks to how hard our staff is working just like Miss Duff said so let's talk about that covid year um 2019 to 2020 you can see that when we came back and assessed our students the numbers um are alarming are quite high and they were quite high for the state as well we unfortunately were higher in a majority of those grade levels I will tell you that my predecessor um started to implement science of reading aligned instructional practices that were evidencebased knowing that the Virginia literacy Act was coming started putting those procedures in place and educating staff members holding professional development working with students and you can see what that amounted to

037for our students green boxes ahe of the state in those areas um all all the way down to almost in the single digit close to close to single digits in some of those grade levels so it is very exciting to see what we have for our students go ahead ask you a question real quick I'm sorry but I'm just the percentage what is the percentage mean on here thanks for asking so the percentage means that that percentage of students did not meet The Benchmark for the pal the phonic um thank you you're welcome and of course we have our 23 324 school year the state does not release those State results until much later in the school year so I was only able to provide what we had as a county and so of course

038we will add that information in as we receive it but I too have a double yellow line on the bottom because we have our new vs assessment this year it if you remember when I came and spoke earlier we we took that one Pals and then we made it in an infinity sign understanding that there were more components that were reflective of beginning reading skills so what you see for data here is listed off of that older Pals test and the data that we'll re present in the coming year will be our newer vs test good evening members of the board and other um school board and community members my name is Karen De Clute and I am the division elementary math specialist and I'm excited to talk to you about what we're doing in

039response to student needs um so here we have a list of many things that we're doing um to support student learning in King George County Schools um but I do want to highlight just a few of these points that we're particularly proud of so we consistently leverage all of our available data to inform and enhance instruction across our division ensuring that our practices are targeted and effective specifically we focus on initiatives such as enhanced parental communication by utilizing Power School incorporating K to2 report card cover letters and sharing parent reports from Virginia's visualizations and analytics solution known as vivos for students in grades 4 through 12 we've dist distributed these vivos parent letters um with report cards for grades four and five um and we've sent them home with our middle school students this past

040Tuesday and we plan to send home um these same reports with our high school students this Friday this allows parents to be part of the conversation and see where their student falls in the context of their same grade level peers across the state we've collaborated with teachers to update our standards based report cards for grades K through two for our more rigorous new standards and standardize the instructional minutes um all sorry allocated um to math and reading across our division so that students are all receiving the same number of instructional minutes um this unified schedule protects and provides the maximum use of instructional time for reading and math in a a consistent and systematic matter we continue to collaborate with K12 teachers across the division with plc's to analyze data to drive the instruction and

041identify areas in which students continue to need spiral Remediation in preparation for spring testing administrators teachers and Specialists meet on an ongoing basis to discuss student performance instructional planning and intervention to support learning thank all three of you very much does anybody have any questions additionally I know a lot of work went into that and it's it's data that's valuable as we move forward thank you very much thank you m chairman I thank you for putting this together I appreciate it I guess this was at an ask of me so I really appreciate you putting this together some of it's a little bit confusing I must say um I'll look at it more in detail um but it it really shows you know that there was a decline I mean not saying that King George

042was the decline right it's a decline across probably the United States I would imagine we're seeing Virginia definitely decline so um I'm understanding that there are steps being taken we're recognizing this and we're putting additional work in the curriculum to try to off offset some of the learning that was not um had during the during the time that they were home the virtual learning so we are getting ahead of it per se is there anything that I mean any additional information to add about you know what the state is um saying about this particular issue or um anything about the curriculum that they're implementing I can tell you from a testing standpoint the the state tried to offset it by recognizing growth and and wanting to As Long As students were making progress they were

043recognizing that they had so much progress to make that the growth was an attempt at you know giving them the credit that they were making that progress and vivos is a analytical piece to the state that is they're very proud of it's very new um I just went to a training this fall I'm new to my position so I was figuring out what this piece does and it definitely gives the schools the power to look at cohort data and look at how kids are tracking across but also individualize students on how they there's like a predictive model that basically will say if this student maintains only grade level growth they should score within this range next year if they make growth if they make progress and growth it it puts them in this range so

044it gives teachers the ability to look at a student's historical data and see how they performed in third fourth and fifth grade and maybe as a sixth grader group them differently based on the the progress that they have historically made and what they could continue to do so that analytical piece is is new to to us and is definitely something that I can see us using more because vivos allows us to me to have an account but it also trickles down to teachers and and um all the way to teachers but through Administration and everything to see those patterns and how kids are performing compared to their peers across the state and what we can do to separate them differently during the instructional process yeah that makes sense thank you um just a general question

045you kind of answered some of this but um what would you attribute the um most of the success that we've G you mentioned the teacher that established that um process recognizing that this kind of thing was going to be an issue and that was some help what are some other things that show I mean obviously there's a normal progress that they would improve but is was there anything else that you know reasons that you could come up with and say this is the reason why it got better and will continue to get better other words what's the reason for the improvements house both I guess okay both I can speak to Pals in the elementary World um a little bit of dabble sector I think part of what we're doing as a school division is

046because we now have these tools um that will help us we can progress monitor our students and determine those needs far um more easily uh before that so test at the end of the year or the growth assessment mid year so we know within a short amount of time the school year starts I know we're very cognizant of testing but I'm trying to keep it short sweet and it do we see a potential concern area let's go ahead and work on that now instead of waiting until February or a March time frame to get the students skills up there's a that's good thank you I think there's also an effort coming out of Co yes we were focused on academics but there were also a lot of other things to f focus on there was

047you know an increase in mental health and all those other concerns that are keeping our teachers and our administrators very busy in the buildings and I think we are reaching a point where the the focus on academics we can support our teachers by having all fifth graders in the county take a common assessment and then see how they're doing on it and and working with our teachers to sit down with that data after they take that assessment and working through what students didn't make progress and why and and remediating that in January February March and not waiting till the end and giving them a practice so and realizing we have all these holes so it's just good oldfashioned data analysis after an assessment is given to to have that conversation and we have you know

048teachers in the classroom where we have teachers who taught through covid we have teachers that came out brand new and are so new to the teaching profession that they have to learn that data analysis piece um and if we could have a fully certified amazing teacher and every classroom we would do it in a heartbeat it's a struggle and it's a struggle that we have the state has and the country has um but I think that going back and doing that progress monitoring and reassessing the instructional process as well as the testing that we're giving them periodically throughout the year is going to strengthen bring our kids to close the gap faster because they are going to be remediated throughout the year as well as giving our teachers the foundation they need to better meet

049the needs of their students Dr Min and you mentioned um the tools have improved and therefore you're able to be more current with analyzing the data on a more current basis what tools are you speaking about specifically that vows assessment that just began this year is very important and then now that we are offering specific evidence-based instructional intervention practices having that followup to see how did they do after six weeks can I do a five question check with them and go aha we have it we can move on oh I need to go back and revisit those or resp spiral those skills so just those little quick checks throughout their intervention all right good thank you m chairman can I ask one more question um so I I see the parent reports the reporting that

050you were talking about um are there tools that the teachers are giving like the parents to that you know they can help their kids with at home if they recognize that there is some sort of you know issue or um that they need to work on I can speak to the literacy side I know specifically this year we have student reading plans and part of that Virginia literacy Act is to offer those tools but those tools are actually on our kgcs website um under the literacy you can go and find phic awareness you can find some fluency tools and that is continuing to be built up within our web page so you can check those out um it also offers resources through the vdoe and VA act itself has some specific links to websites and

051I know that Miss dud I'll let her speak to some math supports yes so typically what we do on the math side because we do not have Virginia State Testing in the primary grades um we do have something called Emos which is part of the vkrp um assessment that is given to all kindergarteners um and many preschoolers across the state and that is given in conjunction with the vs testing and so we do always send those reports home and those come um with access to a state site that has many resources um for families to use at home of course we're always trying to get the word out about math um at our math nights at our elementary schools um and we provide um families with lots of information about math development we communicate with

052families using our kgcs newsletter that we send to families I always try to have some helpful hints for families um regarding math development and a lot of those things that we are customizing to the students and are given to families when we're doing conferences um and alerting them to some needs Miss Davis you had a question anyone else thank you so much again I appreciate it our next uh presentation is our health insurance review and we have we have Heath here this evening that uh is is our um a broker for our um benefits package and he came last year and will again brief us this year on what he's seeing in terms of healthcare trends for King George County school so thank you sir good evening to the board Dr Boyd thank you so

053much for having us here um glad to be back the second year uh this past year was a great year for the partnership with Mark II and King George we rolled out some new products for your employees instituted some new enrollment opportunities as well as some new software systems for the administrative staff that I think all have gone over very well so for this year a couple update slides uh we are the largest broker across the southeast specializing in the public sector uh you guys have me here locally and then we have a whole team of people behind me to help uh a quick snapshot of our block of business in Virginia obviously we don't have everyone listed here but a good uh look across the state and the groups here are going to VAR

054local Choice groups fully insured groups and large self-funded groups as well and so we're going to have a vast array of knowledge of what other people in the state are doing and can help bring that to King George some of the other things we've added in uh your employees now have a dedicated uh account manager who is there to answer calls claims your administrative staff has that same person and we've been rolling out new communication tools along with the benefits books websites videos uh I think they've been great for your employees for communication and the next slide talks a little bit about communication as well so really trying to bring everything under one umbrella I know we're working with the staff uh right now to plan a health fair for the employees in the springtime

055so just again trying to bring education and knowledge to your employee base about what's happening in benefits what their opportunities are and what good options they may have for them so in regards to the health insurance obviously the main topic of today um I have on the next slide a rolling 36-month picture of your claims oops okay perfect um and a couple things that I want to point out on this slide so first off you'll notice on the far left your medical subscriber count has ticked up slightly over the past 36 months so we've got some new employees going onto the plan the member count uh has gone down slightly I'm sorry gone up slightly as well uh so they're adding in some family members so we've gone from 750 up north of 800 almost

056pushing towards 850 but in the middle two uh columns there you've got medical claims paid per member per month and per employee per month and when I was here last year we were looking at a pretty substantial increase and you can see on the second the bottom half of this chart that we get some numbers especially in that Medical paid per employee PE PM column uh north of ,000 a month so the claims have gone up substantially in the last 18 months uh they have flattened out slightly in the last six to7 but the last year's renewal and this year's uh claims projections have been a of a rough one for the employees at King George and we'll dig into a little bit more of that on the next slide so this particular slide uh

057highlights 38 people out of the uh covered staff uh and their dependants out of those 38 people uh which represents just under 5% of your population on the plan they are currently spending just north of 60% of the total claims spent so 30 uh 37 seven people are still active you can see a yes no those are active and not so most of these people are still on the plan uh these could be employees spouses or dependants of of employees we've removed all that and these actually represent individuals in the group and you can see the amount of money that some people are spending is astronomical so we have uh about seven or eight people that have spent over $100,000 this year out of the population we have one pushing a quarter of a million

058in the last 12 months and then again 38 people uh in total spending just under $2.8 million and the entire group right now spending about four and a half million uh this slide because you all are on local Choice local Choice does not provide any pharmacy data I'll talk about that in a second about what that means to you but this is purely medical claims only okay questions about that slide before move on okay and we could you might get there but that's fine what um what is the total that we've paid into you to the Health Plan compared to what we all spent great great question so um if we can go to the next slide so this is our renewal projection that we've put together for this year so on the far right

059column uh and this is purely a mirror of what local Choice gives you in their renewal breakdown so we take their calculation we add in what we anticipate they're going to be and then we can produce this so uh last year uh your income you paid about 5.68 million to Anthem for uh benefits and you had $3.9 just under $4 million of paid claims for that same period of time what we are projecting this year so last year you see at the far bottom right they were calling for about $6.3 million of total uh cost for the plan year that we're in currently um the current projections if you see the the column just the left there up at the top 6.4 million the reason for that increase is because as I mentioned a moment

060ago you've had an increase in subscriber count and so the overall total number is slightly higher um and as we walk through this you can see the paid claims for the same 12month period this year uh were at just over $4.5 million so about a 13% increase in total claims spend in the last 12 months and the previous 12 months wasn't a great year for to start with and so we're adding in an additional expense beyond that the second line item that you'll see here is claims in excess of $150,000 because of your size local Choice gives you some credit on amounts of claims over 150 and you saw we had some high claimants on that previous slide a moment ago uh but this year because you haven't had many that have gone significantly over

061that 150 limit you're we're only crediting you $132,000 whereas last year you got almost 400,000 okay uh a couple other items on this uh listing here the trend number is merely a function of what we are seeing in the market and anticipating of what the general increase of claims are and right now that's trending at about 8% per year in the health insurance space there are a couple highlighted items in this uh projection that I wanted to mention to the board the first is the impact of blending you can see this area last year they gave they being Anthem gave 100 $30,000 Credit in this line item uh I left that at zero when we built the projection in this year just because we can't purely count on them coming back and giving us that

062type of relief again um as we were standing in this boardroom a year ago the claims were trending in a similar Direction and they came up with some opportunities to save you some money and give you a reasonable renewal we're hopeful that they're going to do that again this year but we can't Bank on that and so that's why I left that in as a zero um a couple other things on this list uh I item number six is projected drug capitation uh I mentioned we don't have Pharmacy data uh it's it's not Anthem doesn't have it they have it they just won't release it to you or to me uh what Anthem does under the local choice is they come up with a capitated rate for your employees and right now we're projecting that

063to be just under $1.6 million for next year uh last year you spent $15 million so a little bit of an increase there but if you think about the amount of money you're spending on medical spend right now which again is about $4.5 million if you were to spend 40% of that on Pharmacy which is what we would see probably in a a self-funded environment 30 40% you would be looking at two to$ two and a half million dollars in Pharmacy spend and right now they're only charging you about $1.6 million so you're getting a pretty good deal on that uh the other thing is on the slide of high cost claimants we had all the health conditions removed but I can tell you that when looking at those things you have some serious pharmace

064pharmaceutical spin in your uh group that you're getting some benefit from this uh arrangement with local choice so even though it's not transparent which is not our recommended philosophy just because we like to see all the data uh I can tell you with what the claims are in your group that you're getting pretty good value on the pharmacy side of that uh the second yellow item on this is a contingency risk Reserve fee this is another area that Anthem last year gave you a huge credit almost $300,000 so between those two areas about $420,000 of credit that they gave you last year which it was the Saving Grace for the renewal last year that's the reason the renewal came back at a reasonable rate um and again we're hopeful that that may be a similar

065scenario this year it's going to depend on how the entire block of local Choice uh business does for Anthem as far as some of those numbers will do uh but as it sits right now with the numbers we are anticipating approximately a 20% rate increase to the current premiums okay uh next slide please thank you um again just to wrap up last year we got some significant rate relief in a couple areas uh even though the claims were high last year the renewal came back very reasonably so uh and then with those High claims last year they're up another 133% this year so again I I think the increase is Justified based on the claims pend I don't think this is uh a situation where King George is in any way getting singled out the

066the claims are going up and so I think the premium will need to go up in accordance to that um summary of high cost claim it'ss again less than 5% of the me Members spending almost 2third of the total claims of the group uh that 5% will change you're going to have some people that are consistent flyers in that 5 per and then you're going to have other people that come in and out of that uh group year-over-year I mentioned the pharmacy and then just from a timing aspect uh local choice is scheduled to have their renewals out in the middle of February so sometime mid to late February we should have the firm renewal from local choice in hand uh if at that point we find that the renewal is out of the realm

067of reasonable uh thought then we can certainly look at shopping the plan if that is in the interest of the school board Mark II will handle the leg work on that and help you as much as we can um but if that is something that the board wishes to do we can certainly do that uh I think that as it sits right now based on the claims in the last 24 months uh being high uh you're not going to be a huge appeal for a lot of people that are going to come in and aggressively shop your group but that doesn't mean there aren't savings that could be on the table if you're willing to make some changes okay questions from what I understand that you're recommending is overall you feel as though Anthem is

068still the best um company to stay with that if we put it out there that we might be interested in others um there might be somebody interested but probably not I mean what is I understand you're you're leaving it up to us obviously but your recommendation is that we stay with Anem is that generally what I'm hearing that's correct yeah at this point I don't think that the the claims would be uh the claims spin is trending in a way that companies are going to get aggressive in pricing your business at this point in time I'd like to see that flatten a little bit before we shop the business uh but again if it's the mission of the board you know 20% is not anything that anyone likes to see no that's true and so

069uh I get to be the bearer of delivering that news but if it if that is an unacceptable number that they come back at and hopefully they come back lower again like what they did last year uh but if that is then we can certainly handle the leg work to make sure we can find an alternative so how much time based on last year between now is just an estimate and what it will actually be uh when will we know how much time last year between the estimate and when they actually said how much would be of an increase so the firm renewal will be mid mid February to late February I think last year we had it around the 20th if I recall um but ideally they're working the the renewals now they run

070the claims through November so they had the claims data essentially around December 15th where they could start doing the calculations um and then so they're going to start producing those uh the other wrench that's thrown into this equation was the state went out to bid for anthem's part in the local choice in regards to the network uh I haven't as of today I haven't seen an update on that I'll double check on that but that could throw a small wrench into the timing of things if there's a change I'm not aware of what the status of that bid is at this point in time one last question I'm sorry with me and I know others probably have questions um what I'm hearing you say is that almost no matter what it's not going to be

071above 20% Which is I even hate to say that number it will probably be lower I know you can't say for sure is that kind of what you're thinking that that's our thought process the the problem with local choice is ultimately they control the formula and what goes into that and so as last year we were anticipating a much worse year and then they were able to change the the formulas to your benefit in theory they could change that to your detriment but we wouldn't anticipate that to be the case uh you obviously there the goal of local Choice one of the big goals is to try to stabilize your performance in your health plan and so they're going to have groups that are running really well and they're going to have groups that are

072running really poorly and the idea is to try to spread that out so that people aren't having those shock loss uh increases unless necessary okay and I would recommend with the rest um Madame chair that when the final figures come out that we talk about this again I agree I think other people have questions Miss Davis so you said about 30 uh patients what do we call them uh staff members is what's really making that increase what do you see other school divisions or insurance companies offer to try to not affect the how many do we have 300 other staff members on our insurance plan or 300 on it's about 50% right so we still have 300 out there that are healthy as a button whatever um how can we help keep their rates down

073like what are you seeing out there as a trend for instance into it they offer programs like $1,000 a year year per member to buy equipment to keep them healthy or exercise or programs and gyms and different things smoking plants to help them get off smoking if they're smoking whatever um do you see anything like that yeah so there's some things that you're never going to take out of the equation like cancer for instance car accidents there are lifestyle Choice things that come into play uh the issue that you have is that to spend a lot of money on say a wellness activity so uh we at spot County Schools they just did a bid and they're going to implement a diabetes and weight loss management program but there are 4,000 life group that's self-funded

074and has the ability to see the benefit of that Downstream on that Roi expense with you all being with local choice you don't actually see that because you're not seeing all the claims data come back you're not seeing necessarily you may in in the in the long term prevent some claims we're not seeing what specifically is causing the healthcare issues we can can see the claims but you're not able because you're not because you're not actually funding the claims yourself you're actually paying Anthem to fund the claims you're not being able to take necessarily the savings on the claims coming down over time Anthem and the state are always going to build in a certain amount of pushing to be able to maintain and we want them to you want them to be profitable to

075maintain the the premiums negotiate on the doctors and all of those things you don't want them to make an absorbent an amount of money certainly um but we want them to remain so that yeah I'm more interested keeping it going up every year that high yeah so I'm not worried about maybe making money off of it or saving money at the on the proclaims but on the 300 other people that have health insurance that are being affected by the 30 people yeah so Wellness programs are a great thing like I said you're not going to get the ROI back but you could do things like EA you don't think it'll help them get the claim the medical the prescriptions down by like a healthier lifestyle it can the problem is is that without incentives a

076lot of times those things don't really provide much strength in the back end of it right so unless you are going to incentivize employees in some way where you're going to pay them additional money into say an HSA contribution or you're going to pay them to do things motivate them in some other way it's tough to get them to do things now will a smoking cessation class help some of your people sure um but could you also say I'm participating in this class and I'm still smoking on the weekends and not telling anybody that's a possibility as well um so there's some things to consider on on that front as well it it can help but it's not going to be a an end all Beall the problem is is that a lot of the

077cost saving life-saving uh health care that we have nowadays is super expensive the medications are expensive the care is expensive uh and these are things that may have killed individuals years ago and now we're able to survive and thrive which is great um but unfortunately that comes at a cost so a lot of the things could not be prevented there are things with Healthy Lifestyles you know if we could prevent a couple people from becoming diabetic that would save them a so it's just small bracket people we could aim at but yeah and and those that 5% is going to change you probably out of those 37 38 people you I would say probably have 10 or 15 who are probably going to be pretty consistently in that top bunch and then the others have

078had shock loss they've had a car accident they had a slip and fall they had you know things that are just way out of their control that none of us could prevent thank you good question did anybody else have a question chairman I have one um on the uh where you break down the income and the projected medical claims in the 20124 at the bottom it says 11% last year's increase what does that mean that was the increase that uh the group received this past year that was the increase it was 11% yes ma'am okay what is what is typical for a percentage year after year so it varies most of the projections that I've been doing this year so far have been in the mid so somewhere between 10 to 15% I've had some

079that were in the mid single digits and then I've had some that were 20 or North so it's all over the place it all depends on the claims this is really high it is 30 people yeah anyone else thank you so much for your we'll be back in touch thank you okay Dr Boyd we're looking forward to your uh budget proposal so I'm going to step down here and present to you guys it'll be a little easier that way and we won't have to you know Bend our necks to talk to each other so uh good evening again from this vantage point so thank you so much for providing me this opportunity this evening to initially provide our funding request for King George County Schools FY 26 so this evening for those that are new

080to the process is really going to be an overview I'm going to give you guys a lot of information a lot of avenues to explore some more information uh and then really as far as the timeline's concern our our next board meeting we will have a public hearing to allow the public an opportunity to weigh in on our budget request and then we'll also have a work session where we can dive in deeper into anything you guys may want to see so before I jump into the slides everyone received a budget book uh we provide these budget books to the school board we also provide them to our Board of Supervisors uh and our County Administrator as well so really quickly take a look at this budget book everything you're going to see in the

081presentation tonight uh and then really even in Greater detail you're going to see in this budget book here there's a lot of information there's no way we're covering it all tonight but I just want to make sure that you guys are armed with the information of how to use this book as you dive into the budget information moving forward so opening the book kind of in landscape View the first thing that you're going to see is uh a copy of the presentation that I'll give this evening the second tab titled revenues is a state generated report that provides information on the amount of money that we receive that we believe we will receive and you can look at that report in Greater detail again I'm going to I'm going to explain this in in you

082know kind of a cursory fashion tonight you'll have much more opportunity moving forward the blue tab is our budget book so when you were asked by a constituent uh how much money does the assistant principal at a particular School make this is going to be the document that you can thumb through it's a 70 page document but if you look in the top leftand Corner what you'll see is the particular area so the the cover the first document is patomic elementary school and then you can work your way through the specific budget categories for each of those particular schools and again it's 70 pages so it's all of our schools all of our departments uh and pretty great detail all right as you continue to go through the next document or the next tab is

083the white tab that's going to be your budget Builder summary what I tell people is this is kind of the stuff of the budget this is not Personnel uh this is materials uh curriculum things of that nature the cover page the colorful color page cover page is the summary what you're going to see there it starts off with technology if you slide over to the right you'll see the different Cod the funding codes associated with technology you'll see the general area that is funded through that line so the first one is stiped you see that everybody following me on the far right you will see uh excuse me on the next column over you'll see the proposed amount in this year's budget followed by the approved amount from last year's budget and then the difference

084so this is going to allow you to see where we currently are where we hope to go and then the difference between those two amounts okay uh red tab if you flip over to the red tab this is even in Greater detail so this is the budget book this is not the summary budget book this is the budget book complete so in that last tab you saw technology as the first tab there what you see now in the budget book complete is uh all of the information all of the uh items in great detail uh associated with each of those budget categories so you see technology and then in the desri description you see all of the uh materials that we purchase through technology uh by by title again I want on the far right

085you'll see proposed approved in the difference okay it's good to know this book because this is where you'll get your questions and you'll be able to uh answer the questions and again you know as is always anytime you have a a question just please give me a phone call and uh we'll work together to answer our constituents questions as well the final tab there is the requested positions and that again is colorcoded but what you'll see on the left hand side is the department that the position is associated with uh you'll then see a list of the positions under the title column the color codes are it's important to explain this right now just briefly the Orange Lines or rows are positions that we believe we can cover right now with breakage that we have

086from FY 25 budget so we're we're figuring out ways to afford those positions without asking our Board of Supervisors for addition funds the blue positions you'll see in my budget presentation are those will be new requests those will be new position requests okay all right and that's a brief overview of the budget book I'll now draw your attention to to the uh slides Colleen did you uh Miss Davis did you have a question I figured it out I was asking what the other colors were but you got it broke down okay thank you does anyone else have a question right now before I move away from the budget book it's going to be an important tool as we uh go through this process and work with our community to address any questions or concerns okay

087so I draw your attention now uh to the uh screen the first part of this budget presentation because we've got some folks that are new is talking about really the process uh so the process right now in terms of the timeline you can see that we started this process way back in November uh this is a lot of the information gathering phases but believe it or not we are already way down into the um almost two-thirds down into the uh into the timeline there we're giving the budget presentation to the school board this evening we just had our health insurance renewal information uh and then our next Schoolboard meeting as I mentioned earlier will be our our public hearing and our work session followed by uh traditionally the board approving the budget at that um

088it was originally if you remember the second meeting in February but we move that meeting uh at our organizational meeting to the first meeting in March which is March 3rd so March 3rd it is predicted that we'll approve the budget to move forward to our Board of Supervisors next slide all right so the process uh what you'll see here is myself in that blue circle in the middle on the left the superintendent uh takes all of the information that is provided through those other uh colored tabs there we take information from the Strategic plan as you guys know our current operating budget information from the general assembly we do staff surveys and listening sessions both within the School Division and outside in the community uh we go through a budget Builder process where all of

089the Departments and all the principles I have an opportunity to provide feedback and then we do some Community fors as well my responsibility as superintendent my state required responsibility is to construct a needs-based budget so what I'll deliver to you tonight uh without much consideration to the cost associated with it although I will share those is a needs-based budget based on the feedback that I've gotten from those sources I deliver that information to the school board we work through it through work sessions and finalize it before we deliver that um request or proposal to the Board of Supervisors for final approval next slide okay so in most budgets uh even your household budget it's it's it's sometimes a very simple process of uh Revenue how much money's coming in and expenditures how much money is

090going out we don't have the luxury of it being that simple in public schools it gets it gets a little more complex uh one of the things that we have to use to measure the amount of money that we're going to receive from the state is what we call our ADM or average daily membership basically that's the number of students that we believe are going to attend King George County schools because the amount of State money we receive is based on that number of students so you can see and this is always an opportunity to see that in King George right now we are there's an upti there's an uptick in the number of students we had uh our growth rate right now I've heard conservative estimates as low as about 2.3% which you'll see

091in the census data and then you'll see later in my presentation there's there's estimates always as high as 4% or higher so when we have 4,500 students what that means in hard numbers is we're we're bringing in anywhere between 80 to 120 new students a year right now across K12 year-over-year you see how those numbers break down in our enrollment numbers I always like to bring that up but as you all know that's a continuing conversation when we're talking about the new schools so next slide please we are predicting 44 thou uh not 44,000 4,475 students next year we're using that number uh to plug into our Cal tool to determine State funding okay this uh actually came out in the Winchester Star just two days ago and this is a map of Virginia and

092what it is and I I think it's it shows uh it's pretty illustrative of where the growth is in the state right now so as you can see uh if if you are dark red your growth exceeds 4% uh and if you are gray or blue you actually have a uh declining population within your community uh so you see areas like Fairfax county is is actually declining but uh King George is is bright red and and this uh information coming from the Winchester Star just two G two days ago so uh what this is saying is that according to Welden Cooper which is the state one of the state recognized uh companies that recognizes population growth we're we're exceeding 4% growth next slide okay local Composite Index uh as board members it's important that we

093have at least a cursory understanding of this there's 132 School divisions in the state of Virginia for many many many years now the way that the state has determined a locality's ability to pay for public schools is a measurement called the local Composite Index and what they do is rank all 132 school or localities based on three factors those three factors are the true value of real real estate property gross income gross houshold in household income and then retail sales and you can see how that measurement breaks down so in the 2022 2024 bium our uh local Composite Index was 3805 what does that mean what that means is that the state believes based on that number that King George County should pay at minimum 38% of the total cost for public education in King

094George and they make up the difference along with Federal funding okay so 38% coming from the locality by by recommendation and then the inverse of that 62% would be from state and federal funding in the 2426 banial it actually helped us out our um LCI changed to. 36 meaning that we're responsible for 36% in the county and the state and federal makes up the inverse next slide so if you measure those those factors and you take all 132 localities in the state of in the state of Virginia you can see where King George Ranks and and I think this is important and and I'll tell you I I just provide this information for information purposes I can tell you right now now um my impression is we've had a great working relationship with our local

095government we've had a great working relationship with our Board of Supervisors and Schoolboard uh but we're all here adopting these current numbers and datas and and working with it so I do I do think it's important to at least take a look at where we are uh as a locality this is important uh so right now in all 132 localities King George Ranks 55th in terms of the value of their property out of 132 they rank 50th in income yes just which is of the higher Which is higher like if it was cl 132 or one yeah so you want to be one you want to be ranked first right good question though right so you want to be ranked first uh in taxable retail sales uh we rank 70th right now if you stacked

096all 132 on top of each other if you take a look at that terms of uh where we fall in per pupil expenditure which is you know the usually the amount used to um assess how much we fund for public schools we rank 106th out of 132 okay Ju Just for information purposes and if you want to go deeper into any of this information any of the information in my presentation I shared this with you guys digitally you can click on these links to find the sources of this data uh we've talked a little bit about the jlar study and and uh that information is there you can find some other very interesting information next slide so this information uh I think is pretty interesting as well so uh again the link below you can

097take a look at how this information is put together what you'll see here is uh you'll see two factors on the bottom are the xaxis you will see per pupil expend the amount of money we pay per student on the Y AIS on the left hand side you'll see average household income okay so what this looks at in essence is the amount of money that the community has on the left-and side and the amount of money they contribute to public education on the bottom what was done here is they've taken the average so going from north to south you have the average per pupil expenditure which is $133,000 $3,463 okay can't go over there ac across the middle you have the average household income which is 66,000 that's the line going across the middle it

098kind of separates this graph into four quadrants each one of those dots represents a school division or a locality with a School Division oh awesome man Jee you're always on it each one of these dots represents a school Division and a locality in the state of Virginia in the Commonwealth if you look at these four quadrants I would say they could be represented in the following way if you're in this quadrant you have low income in your community right your per your income is is relatively low uh and you also have a low per pupil expenditure you don't have much money and you're not contributing much to public education yes sir one quick question maybe everybody knows that 66,000 24 is that household or individual household for the state for the state average ours is

099the Red Dot I'm gonna get to that yep so uh this quadrant is low income low contribution to public education all right the opposite quadrant very similar High income communities these this is like your you know your lowens your fairfax's uh those areas High income and they contribute a lot of money to public educ okay these are the commendable folks right in my mind down here they don't have a whole lot of money I guess I have a bias but they do contribute a lot of money to public education in their communities okay don't have a lot but give a lot to public education all right this quadrant here is based on that data that I provided previously High income in the community low per pupil expenditure okay okay so King George is here right

100now okay and again just Just for information purposes all right next slide Bo real quick yes sir sorry the only thing about where that stands is I do know that a lot of that number comes from the base and only 30% is known 30% of people who work on base live in King George so it it's not as accurate as we it's what the state says we are right unfortunately but it's not as accurate as as much as money as we're getting in King George right now there's there's a lot of factors that we could and again just for information purposes you can dive into this in a number of ways I've heard the base analogy I've heard some other ones as well that are important to consider but these are the things that will

101be talked about in our community right these are the things that will be discussed when we're talking about budget any other questions on this slide right here no okay next slide all right so our budget is always aligned as I explained last time and we provided an overview of our strategic plan to our strategic goals these have not changed uh these are part of our strategic plan first goal is employees second goal is instruction third goal is community collaboration and the fourth goal has to do with our learning environments our facilities next slide every year we survey our staff uh and in all the years I've done this and I think even prior to me being in this position these are the same numbers that we typically get and what they say is that nine

102out of 10 of our instructional staff believe right now that they have the equipment supplies and programs that they need in order to be successful so that's that's a good thing all right we also have an open-ended question at the end of this survey and I'd like to put down there where those open-ended comments fall in term of in terms of our instructional goals so this year 41% of those open-ended comments were related to employ investment and development so often often times those open-ended comments are uh pay our teachers more um things of that nature you know consider Healthcare consider some other it's it that's falls into that area uh 39% of the comments this year had to do with instruction zero comments were about Community collaboration and again this is this is in relation

103to uh staff okay this is their comments 20% had to do with uh safe secur healthy learning environments and the number that you see in Gray there was last year's number so you can see how those figures have changed based on the current environment that helpful next slide okay budget initiatives I'm going to organize into those four areas next slide all right so strategic plan goal number one the first thing you're going to see in our budget presentation this year is increase salaries by 3% uh we believe believe 3% is a safe number right now this is the number that quite frankly in all the years I've done this is um similar everywhere right now we see it in the general assembly they provided it last year and they're recommending it again for this year

104a 3% salary incre salary increase we see it in the governor's budget right now he's recommending a 3% salary increase our local government is considering the same uh and our surrounding School divisions I believe are considering the same so unlike other years most folks right now are on the the 3% uh side of recommendation what that means for us is that's a $1.8 million ask uh from from uh state federal and local funding okay that's not one that's not just $1.8 million asking from our our Board of Supervisors it's it's from all of our funding sources uh the other initiative that we have in our employee investment and development is we need to increase hourly pay scales for our building level secretaries we've seen a great turnover in that we've talked about it a little

105bit with our registrars um we need to update that pay scale and that's the cost of that initiative uh again we're going to take a stab this year at adjusting our compression we have to really relieve that compression in the middle of our pay scales we've talked about that before I'm going to show you some data here in a minute as to why that has to be addressed and then finally we're we're moving into the uh 21st century when it comes to uh our onboarding process uh using a platform that uh is very efficient in terms of processing our employees and making sure that we can um I guess uh communicate via online as opposed to do paper documents and such next slide so this is why we really need to adjust compression this is

106an important slide and this is one that I think you should be familiar with over here will see King George and our surrounding School divisions across the top of this you'll see uh teachers in uh the first the starting salary fifth year salary after teaching for 10 years your salary all the way up to 30 years of experience in comparison to the school divisions that we compete with in terms of finding qualified teachers the highlighted cell if you can see that it probably see it better on your screens is the lowest School Division the lowest value so as I've told you guys in the last two years we currently have compression in our pay scales from the economic downturn right here these are teachers that are seasoned these are teachers in the five to 10

107year range these are teachers that are making life decisions about whether or not to stay in King George or to leave King George and currently in comparison to the school divisions that we compete with our salaries are the lowest in that band okay so that's why the initiative is to address the compression in the pay scale any questions about that I take it the fredicksburg data was not available yeah they don't they don't produce it publicly for whatever reason and then if you want to at a later time click on this link here you're going to see the Virginia Education Association salary study and you can get all this information and a whole lot more from across the whole State okay next slide okay last year when we had this Healthcare debate and we've got

108a lot to talk about as as you know with Healthcare probably more so than this uh but last year this is where we arrived at in part of our conversation so I thought I'd provide it on the front end right now as as Mr Thomas recommended we're probably going to see a 20% Health Care increase yeah that's a big number uh what you asked for last year is what I provided this year was an example you have a current teacher up top that's at step 14 this year you move down to this one we consider the 3% salary increase that we recommended and then we consider the school board covering the entire cost which was one of the options from last year what you'll see over here is that their take-home changes or their gross

109Chang es uh to $272 58 their healthare premium stays the same because the school boards picked up the cost their gross then becomes this this number minus you know this number minus this number and when it's all said and done their rais for the month after health insurance increase and proposed 3% raise is a gross of $315 okay now now the other option that has existed that we've discussed in the past and is in in in part of our current health care option is the traditional one that we've talked about in the past the school board covers 85% of the premium the employee picks up 15% of the premium for a shared increase okay those numbers slightly shift the premium goes from 115 to 150 for the employee and the difference of their take-home is

11080 versus the $315 so it's about a $35 difference month over month okay well done thank you next slide all right strategic plan goal two again you saw this last year but we will continue to uh operate with the Academy of technology and Innovation we all know as ATI now uh ATI tuition for our next set of students we will again have seven students a 10 ATI next year that's a $71,000 uh expense uh you'll see in a later Slide the additional staff support that we need to to accommodate increased enrollment and other academic needs that's $595,000 and then again you're going to see as as we are all well accustomed to supports that are needed for the uh VA Virginia literacy act that's 154,000 I'll show you how that breaks down in the next

111slide strategic plan goal number three I know some of you have asked and we are working diligently to update our new web website platform uh Amanda has done a good job of working with vendors to figure out how to move forward with that my watch is tell me to try again later we will uh teacher communication tool again we've talked a whole lot about this that'll be a cost of of $99,000 and again this is a this is a tool uh where we kind of um standardize our communication practices it's good for parents too that we they know exactly what we're doing in terms of communication how we communicate uh and then the year review publication we talked about I think last time that's a zero sum cost next next slide uh the final goal

112strategic plan goal four uh project kind which was here tonight the renewal of that that uh plan is $155,000 to address our safe and secure healthy learning environments uh the virtual Virginia program we've talked about this that cost there that $144,000 is associated with the director position that we would need to oversee the virtual program that we hope to start next year see nods if there's any questions at any time just stop me and I can I can uh so that's the cost to start the program is there a a recurring cost or is there just that start up and then so that's going to be the cost for the position associated with running the program right and so the question is is there going to be recurring costs I mean obviously the salary of

113the of the Coordinator would be but what about the cost to tuition so the other cost is tuition uh we pay King George County Schools will pay tuition to Virtual Virginia and we will we hope that for the most part and again we'll see how this plays out in terms of the number of students interested in this program and the types of students interested in this program uh but our per pupil or not per pupil our uh average daily membership could increase the amount of State funding could increase and really could offset some of these costs but really we won't know that until we get an idea of how many students and what kind of students are interested in that program and again February 6th and February 11th we have two uh in introductory sessions

114to the community for that uh and then the third initiative there to combat chronic absenteeism is an attendance intervention specialist and again that's the salary associated with that position next slide all right you have the budget builder in front of you in your budget book what you see here is the sums or the increases associated with each of those categories and now uh Schoolboard members Board of Supervisors members County Administrator can go into the budget book and really see you know for example technology is increasing by 43,00 why why is it increasing by $43,000 you can use your budget book to to answer that question and obviously ask me to uh answer those questions as well but you see it broken down by departments and then probably most importantly what you'll see is the total

115sum there uh and then this is a link to the budget Builder calculation uh spreadsheet you do have the ability to just view that document uh but it's it's the same one you have in your budget book next slide these are the additional Staffing positions again this is the last page of your budget book but this is broken out uh in a way that's a little easier to read for our for uh those in the community what you see on the elementary level is again VA needs to reading teachers at the elementary level we are seeing an uptick and and are required to address esol or English language learner needs so we would need an esol teacher uh also based on VA and some other needs at the preschool we would need four additional paraprofessional

116positions uh at the middle school um we've been working this year with some instructional coaches but we have a middle school instructional coach there at the middle school um we've talked a lot about this in terms of um the number of students that have increased and really having to match that with teaching positions so at the high school level what this is is full-time equivalent teacher basically an additional three teaching positions at the high school really to address High numbers uh and then we these two we' just talked about the virtual instruction coordinator and the attendance interv intervention specialist the total cost for the new positions is $982,000 next slide this this is a summary Slide the major differences between last year's budget approval and this year's budget approval what you see is the first

117one is compensation that's the 3% salary increase that sum is 1.8 million the compression that I talked about earlier is 436,000 the health insurance renewal rate of 20% right now is $1.1 million once we plug it into our current uh employees budget Builder I just went over those those costs are 1.5 million and then the new positions is what I just uh explained in the last side 982 th000 and if at anytime you have any questions you can stop in uh next next slide next uh all right so this is the revenue and expenditures and again this is using the Cal tool from the state uh next slide all right Revenue summary so this is our current budget Year fy2 all right this is our current budget total budget with state federal and local uh

118Revenue sources is $64 million this is what we're operating off of right now uh currently all we have is the governor's recommended budget which came out December 18th the reason this is blank is because what we will get next is the general assembly's budget the general assembly's budget will come out I think towards the end of February is what we're looking at right now hopefully fingers crossed uh and then we'll be able plug these numbers in but this is where it gets uh important so what you'll see based on that budget request and all of those things that we positions budget Builder things of that nature the projected uh Revenue state revenue goes up by 1.4 million federal grants go up by 410,000 these sums remain the same and this number right here 4.1 million

119based on everything that is in the budget right now is the request from the local government is the is our request to our Board of Supervisors okay next slide this breaks it down by appropriation category so again our budget within the school division is broken down into these areas and then you can see currently where that money resides in those areas and then you can see uh where we hope it would reside moving forward all right so what you have right now is our current local funding amount and based on the governor's recommended budget this would be the request this would be the local government's amount to public education as the presentation is presented today does that make sense I think okay so what's different from this year than last year how we did this

120is that you broke down really the funding where the funding is coming from so it looked like last year we were asking for 55% from our local government when really so you broke it down to show that we the local government has to match the 25 million per state regulation right well so what we would be asking from our local government based on the governor's is is 4.15 right it's this exact number right now based on everything that's in that budget request is that above the that's above that's 2 what is that what 38 what is our percentage that the local government is supposed to match or well that goes back to the LCI that's 36 36% and again there's a whole conversation there that that's that's a suggestion the LCI is really just kind

121of a suggestion and you you get into uh the jayar study and public school funding and and that's a whole another conversation for probably another day okay Mr chairman I have a question um that um funding the 36% um and I know that's another day conversation but how often is it that you get near that percentage here uh we're usually right around that percentage uh we're we're uh I don't believe and again my my history is is brief but uh in that time we're usually a tick or two above it um but you know and it goes back to that that slide on uh those quadrants you know those School divisions that that are uh probably down here in that in that quadrant are up around I mean they may be 10 percentage points easily

12210 15 percentage points above the local Composite Index down here those School divisions up here are are meeting the local Composite Index but just meeting it okay thank you um and I think that's the final slide before questions so I can take any additional questions again you know I know that's a lot to digest right now this is just an overview this is just providing you guys the tools and the information to probably dig a lot deeper and be prepared to answer other questions there's a lot that we have to discuss Health Care things of that nature so you will have the budget book now I'm always available and uh am happy to answer any questions as they will pop up here in the next probably months public hearing uh the public hearing will be

123our next uh board meeting which is February 10th is that correct February 10th yeah weeks way so we have our homework to do before then yeah well yeah I'm here for you too so when you go I just want to make sure because I'll end up going back home and talking to somebody um and I want to make sure I know what I'm fighting about so when you sorry maybe I should do this behind scenes with you um but the 25 million right here under the fiscal year for local funding what are you looking at 20 currently yes 25 million um and then this 4.1 million that says government yes both of those are coming from the local government B supervisors are going to be out of out of the budget the local budget yeah

124so so all right let me see if I can explain it this way th this is our total budget this is state federal and local okay okay what this does is is this this is the pull out of the local contribution this is the local amount that you know we're going to get automatically I don't know that we're going to get it automatically I guess my question is why are we breaking it apart the 4.1 and then the 25 if it's coming from the same Source this is current oh that's the current that's what this is current yeah so this is where we are right now our local government right now our total budget state and federal and local funding is $64 million total okay out of that $64 million the local government provides $25

125million if you take that entire presentation and all of those positions and Healthcare include everything that was presented there and you plug it into the state C tool then and and it the State Cal tool is currently built around the governor's budget what it says is that that's going to cost us a total of $70 million of state federal and local funding out of that $70 million the request is for $29 million of it to be local funding that's a difference of I .1 million and so the request from the school board right now today again you guys approved this and everything else but if we were doing this today then we would be asking our local Board of Supervisors for an additional $4.1 million of local funding over last year over last year now

126now that you broke it down like this what's our percentage as far as the overall County budget so because you know that was an issue last year we I don't have that right now so is your um are you can you can you you're saying know the room what is our percentage of so it's it's roughly right below if you take current year numbers it's roughly below about 40% okay just below 40% so it's above our Composite Index it was 38% last year wasn't it right it was somewhere in that ballpark but the discussion was we thought it was 50 some some people thought it was 55 then when we understood it better we realized it was really only 38 yeah I think it's 53 um now what that considers is we don't have to

127go through that's that's a deeper convers are we on the same page with the Board of Supervisors on that number I I think so yeah I I think we've had some very good conversations I I mean I you know of course I don't and I'm not asking because I've heard anything I just know that's going to be like where we at on the percentages sort of school budget compared to the county budget yeah and I think we've had some very good conversation again we're talking about a finite amount of resources here so you know this this is a a ongoing conversation but I I'm I've been very pleased with uh and later in my superintendent report we'll we'll share my some information about even the fund balance conversation that we've had recently so it's been

128a very good working relationship with our Board of Supervisors but nevertheless my responsibility is to deliver a needs-based budget that's what this is and and that's where the conversation really uh should probably start thank you for breaking all that down like you really did a good job and a lot of work whoever helped you or if you did that yourself thank you she is she's right there Miss [Laughter] Williams anybody else have questions Mr Frank you good Cleveland okay thank you very much I'm looking forward to reading [Laughter] this okay next on the agenda we have our student rep comments thank you Chad looking always look forward to your feedback good evening um thank you guys so much for having me back here um I'm sure coming back into this new semester over at the

129high school everyone was very thankful for that extra week off um and we're definitely getting adjusted to the new semester uh nothing significant to report other than we're starting out and starting the semester strong um recently theater just had their line the Witch and the Wardrobe production which was very successful and winter sports are still currently ongoing and then the starting of conditioning for some spring sports but other than that I do not have anything significant to report thank you thank you very much um do I have a motion to go to into close session I move that pursuit to state code section 2.2-inch as permitted under 2.2 D 3711 a number one of the code of Virginia second all those in favor I I shair votes I we are now in close session e

130e e turn to open session I move that the King George County School Board return to open session and certify that pursuit to state code section 2.2 3712 D only public business matters lawfully Exempted from open meeting requirements under this chapter and only such public business matters as were identified in the motion by which the closed meeting was was convened were heard discussed or considered in the meeting by the public body second ctif certifi all in favor certif I I I I I votes I what I just said um motion passes um and now I need a motion for actions resulting from the closed meeting I'm sorry do we have a motion to approve the personnel as presented I make a motion that we approve the personnel as presented second motion made and seconded all

131in favor I I chair votes I motion carries okay next we have our consent consent agenda to review has anybody had a chance to look at those they were one's the or the organizational and one was the regular meeting is there any comments orever or can we just approve them both I make a motion that we approve uh the cons the meeting minutes as presented second all in favor I I I think we need to say what both dates both dates maybe um January 8 2025 uh with the organizational meeting January 8 2025 regular meeting second okay Miss Miss Cleveland do you need more time to review it okay all in favor I I chair votes I motion carries okay next on the agenda we have an action item regarding the Early Childhood provisionally licensed

132teacher incentive Grant uh yes Madam chair so you have in your packet a uh King George County Schools board meeting agenda item again this is in reference to the Early Childhood provisionally licensed teacher incentive this is good news this is the acceptance of $6,000 uh the Virginia Department of Education has awarded King George County schools with Grant funds in the amount of $6,000 for our early childhood provisionally licensed teacher incentive program we would like the school board to accept these funds so so that we can allow our provisionally licensed teachers uh in early childhood uh Preschool teachers with funds for their cours workk and Associated fees necessary to become a fully licensed Early Childhood teacher uh so that's what we desire to use the funds for my recommendation is superintendent is to approve a motion

133to accept $6,000 from the early childhood provisionally licensed teacher Inc of Grant um make a motion to approve um superintendent recommend ation to approve a motion to accept 6,000 from the early childhood provisionally licensed teacher incentive second all in favor I I CH votes I motion carries and then next we have another action item for the intervention contract renewal uh yes Madam chair so you will have in your packet again um a board um document to review uh this is before you because the purchase requisition is in excess of $50,000 so any expense in excess of $50,000 we have to bring toward you the uh the reason it is above $50,000 is because of a delayed invoice so if you look below uh this is a contract that we have traditionally had uh this is

134a contract with a company that we use for our cyber security and making sure that um no nefarious activities occur on our Network and what happened was that they delayed the December payment so if you look at that purchase re requisition form I think it's like the second or third piece of paper there you can see the December invoice for $7,000 $7,000 and some change and then our traditional payment of $44,000 which which covers six months of that contract so because the company build does for the six-month contract and also the December invoice it causes the sum to go over $50,000 so this evening I would request uh make a recommendation uh to approve a motion to issue a purchase order in the amount of $ 51,470 for the service uh through June 2025 I

135make a motion that we approve the motion to issue a purchase order in the amount of $ 51,470 for the service through June 25 2025 second any discussion Mr chairman I have a question yes um I I assume this was in the budget originally yes ma'am good question this this was a this is already budgeted for thank you thank you okay all in favor I I chair votes I motion carries next we have discussion items um if you if the board would look at the pile of papers that you have on your in front of you I printed out in red the um the staff morale survey and it was just the first one is um the morale questions and there's just if you look at the last question um I'm sorry does everybody have

136it in front of them last the last question was just clarification of some words for an open-ended question um just wanted to make sure that everybody was okay with how that was worded um before we published this I'm just give us just a minute okay right Madam chair um I assume with the we're dealing with the morale one first right that's the one I was yeser there was only one change on the on the mor one it was at the very bottom number 20 and I just we just make clarification on no no I just wanted yeah both of the administrators input with this is I remember you're saying is that correct okay but you didn't um this is now who's this going to be going out to exactly so all the schools or just

137the yes the intention is to send both surveys to all the schools in the division but you didn't contact the elementary administrators I did not I intended to forward it to them but by the time it was finalized I did not well it's not quite finalized yet we're doing that tonight and then she was going to send it to them because that's just where we are with it because we've been back and forth with every yeah I just think it would be good that if we do finalize this because to me that the change you made is fine especially from the original couple of changes were made from there based on our suggestions and I thank you for doing that um but um I do think it's important once we finalize it here that maybe

138you send it to the elementary administrators before we actually let it go out I will do and let me clarify that Mrs Cleveland did most of the work so thank you for your help she actually drew a lot of the Sur did I read it thank you madam chair when we do this does it breakdown it's going to break down per school or is just going to be division wide we would like to have the breakdown per school yes I'm going to work with Mrs Higgins to figure out how we can do that get you know have it separated that way so youall are good with the morale one yes I'm fine with it especially with the changes that you made thank you okay now the cell phone um survey is the next one that

139we're looking over and um I don't think it changed that much but um Miss chairman can I can I add the policies the survey looking at surve yes ma'am can I add a couple comments on this sure so I just wanted to make sure that you guys are aware because I typed this up um in red would be uh s some consideration for any changes that would want to be made additions the other um questions had already been uh passed through us and U modified based on the feedback that was given so the in red would be for something for us to consider either adding or changing so we can start with number three if you would look at that one right it would be um so number three for example where it says leadership

140is enforcing the cell cell phone policy consistently uh we uh the we we could the feedback was we could word that differently saying what word best describes administration's enforcement of the cell phone policy um whether it's consistent inconsistent not enforced or unsure versus the statement of agreeing to okay so on these that you haven't read um okay those that you haven't read obviously they're not um you don't want them to strongly agree they're going to circle one of those or two of those words can they only Circle I assume one of those and three and each one of those they'll only Circle one correct yes so um but they're not going to say anything about the strongly agree disagree obviously no it would just be the A B C or D that are listed beneath

141beneath that um otherwise it would be strongly agree somewhat agree neutral somewhat disagree strongly disagree based on whether or not leadership is enforcing the cell phone policy consistently really it's the same question just a little bit different in the response so you're not going to have the in Black it'll just be what's in red then yes okay I would suggest this is very good but I would suggest up top rather than putting that a through e for strong leg all the way to strongly disagree as you put that under each one since you already want them circling on those that you haven't read and others why not just go ahead and put those in one four seven and eight just go ahead and put the strongly agree disagree so they understand each time they can

142just circle one of those yeah and and when we submit this for them to put it on the that's whatever we're going to do that yeah every question will have a answer key and some will be slightly different based on what's on here good good so if you want to glance over number six and then 10 and 11 um let me know so I can also make some comments on number six so uh number six the addition would be um instead of answering as we said the strongly agreed to the strongly disagree that I observe students using cell phones headphones or earpods during H hallway transitions we would add compared to last year to see if there was a difference between last year versus this year are we talking a school year because we had

143no policy until the 3rd of June well there was but it wasn't being enforced there was but it wasn't enforced I know so that's I was say school year yeah so we can change it to school year so we can't but we didn't have one last year compared to when we had one versus when we didn't yeah so what would you suggest I think I think what you'll be a leave it I observe students using cell phones you know just Improvement after policy it's more of it's still going to show whether there was Improvement or not compared to last year when there was no policy do you see students using cell phones more or less or yeah what's in Black okay I think it would be important there they put school year though um yeah

144because last year it was yeah because they might think it was 2024 as opposed to last school year now again these um you pass these through the administrators I did high school high school middle school but not the elementary well they don't need it that's right sorry forget what I said sorry I mean we're going to give the surveys those schools as well but I don't I there's no perception that it's a problem I agree so just for clarification the cell phone policy audience is students or staff and and I the morale the morale is is staff and I thought the cell phone was staff also staff as well okay all right just just point of clarification yeah I think yeah would so and then um Miss chairman number 10 and 11 were possible additions

145that we can consider based on feedback from um the school administrator at the high school how would we what would the answers to number 11 be the same as uh like strongly agree and somewhat disagree number 11 yeah yes okay I think they're good questions I I I think we should add them but I need the opinion of the board before we move on so did you want to read what 10 was or no what's 11's question right here parents are supported and help us enforce cell phone policy that doesn't match this I'm not sure what you're I don't these questions where's number 11's question no so the answers would be there 11 is the liky scale it's the it's going to be the top will be the top scale does that make sense yeah

146why AR yeah okay this is just a draft so we can figure out we're g to move on M chairman a question I have about number six I just want some clarity so compared to last year the we're not we're not saying compared to last year meaning semer we're saying last semester semester would be better yes that would be good you want to lead it that way yeah sure okay you agree to last semester yes and we're only one week into this semester so I'm not sure that they well by the time this gets I mean and this is a this is a start we we we we agreed that we were going to use this to measure right success moving forward wouldn't it be easier just to take out compared to last year completely

147well you could say something along the lines from the beginning of instituting the new new cell phone policy then ask okay I think what you're in other words you see what I'm saying that would show know that from the beginning until now from the beginning of instituting the new cell phone policy until now then you asked the question would that be helpful there you got that yeah right thank you is that with good with you Mr Frank sure but we're going to change the the destructors too because less frequently last year yeah yeah yeah more frequently than last year so okay yeah cross okay make it clear in the question then you don't need to say last year all right okay next on the I'm sorry when does this go out I we don't know

148yet I don't know I have to get with Mrs Higgin and find out when she can get to it the reason I'm asking because you're going to send this to well not this one but you're going to send the morale one to the elementaries and that way give them a notice of hey it's going out on this date right the intention is or the goal is to to do it soon but I understand that Survey Monkey has to be purchased as well so okay just just as soon as possible right as soon as possible I could I get that all the time okay now the next discussion that we were um um we had been talking about our joint Board of Supervisors and School Board 2x two meetings and um think were you gonna talk

149on that or well I just want to lend my help and support I know it's it's been challenging as as as far as um communication and figuring out uh schedules that line up so we had talked about it a little bit uh in our meeting and if there's anything that I can do and and seeing if I can call members of the Board of Supervisors mesh that with you guys in your schedule I just want to express that I'm I'm happy to help I think uh in terms of timing usually in the past right now as we've presented this budget this is going to be a very important time to uh work with our Board of Supervisors and see if we can sit down and uh discuss the budget book and things of that nature

150I know we've all been trying to do that but it's been challenging with everyone's calendar so I just wanted to lend my help if in any way I could so this suggestion would be to First partner up with your uh District representative so you know my counterpart of the James Madison district and then one other person so there'll be two Board of Supervisors two school board members and then you and Mr smick okay um I would love for you to assist with that because I think you have a better connection with the the Board of Supervisors so I'll do my best I'll do my best thank you and now are we prepared to talk about athletic eligibility yes Madam chair I just wanted to provide an update so uh this this uh discussion item stemmed

151from a conversation we were having about really Bridging the Gap between Middle School athletic eligibility and High School athletic eligibility and uh recognizing that we have a hole right now we have a hole between the eth and 9th grade year so more specifically and I and I tell you uh I had a wonderful meeting with both principals at the secondary level middle and high uh and both athletic directors at the middle and high level uh also Mrs fiser who manages our code of conduct and our athletic code of conduct and Dr Wright was in that meeting as well I I was very pleased to hear that we were all really in consensus on recognizing the concern that the board had about that hole and addressing it uh currently I think there's very thorough Pro there's

152a very thorough process at the middle school level um that has a very high frequency the athletic director there does a very good job of uh checking grades making sure students are uh academically eligible to participate in athletics and does a job there that I was very pleased to hear when we had the meeting on the high school level we follow vhsl guidelines vhsl guidelines for a 4x4 block schedule which is what we're on our students have four classes a day um VHS SL dictates that students have to pass three out of four classes the preceding semester in order to be eligible for the current semester so through a lot of conversation and discourse with the middle school and the high school uh we thought it was a very good idea to make sure that

153um to bridge that gap between the eth and nth grade year uh we take a look at the vhsl X um expectation and on the uh it gets a little gray here but vhsl says if you have six seven or eight classes in it in a day you have to pass at minimum five of those uh so what we agreed on in that meeting and what we would like to uh deliver to the board and ultimately get put into our athletic code of conduct is the expectation that our middle school students uh outside of the rigorous grades that they check every day they still have to be academically eligible 6th seventh and eighth grade right now and that process is working quite well but in order for you to move from the eighth grade year

154to the ninth grade year you would have had to have passed five classes as is the vhsl expectation to be eligible your ninth grade year you remember vhsl says you have quote unquote a blank slate you can come into the ninth grade year doesn't matter what grades you had at the middle school you start off with automatic eligibility I can tell you that our Middle School principal High School principal everyone in that meeting was very interested in supporting our students through that entire eighth grade year so that they remain academically and athletically eligible when ninth grade starts um right now what happens just by the nature of the way that the policy has not it's not even a policy the practice has set itself up is once that eighth grade student in essence is done

155with sports at the eighth grade level then they fall off a cliff they recognize that well I'm no matter what my grades are I'm academically I will be eligible when I become a ninth grade student because there's a clean slate what we would prefer is to say no we're going to keep we're going to we're going to keep tabs on you we're going to keep supporting you we want to be held to that vhsl expectation because that's what will you will be held to when you get to that to the secondary to the high school level uh and we want to make sure that we continue to support those students through uh the eighth grade year and through that summer so that when they show up as ninth graders uh they are vhsl academically eligible

156from the start there's no clean slate what you do in the eth grade counts for what you do in the ninth grade so I can stop there for questions Madam chair yes um so I'm just curious if the other school divisions are doing this um I think that's really important for us to consider as well uh we haven't had a chance yet to consider uh what other middle schools are doing I can tell you as far as high school eligibility most schools are the minimum that they have to do is vhsl uh I'm just referring to the Middle School eligibility the so as it is right now they come to high school they have a blank slate and they can play sports but we're proposing that we keep that level the same which makes sense

157and I agree however I I think that it's important for us to know how that looks taking a look at our other maybe Battlefield districts and seeing what they're do on the Middle School level as well we can do that middle school too high school middle yeah that that that hole right now that exists I mean the question is why um Apples to Apples competitive uh um mentioned what what your staff told you about how it would keep them accountable in eth grade not to just drop off and not finish yeah I tried to explain that yeah um so so to to Colleen's to miss Davis's point right now our Middle School administration our Middle School athletic department was very interested in in the ability to hold our second semester eighth graders accountable um because

158as it's set up right now that blank slate idea gives some the impression that the second semester of 8th grade doesn't count uh it doesn't matter what my grades are because I I have a fresh Blank Slate when I start in the ninth grade and really it's it's a it's a probably a poor message from the school division to deliver to a child that um you know you're going to fall off the radar here for a little while uh we want to keep you on our radar and we want to hold you to those high expectations uh throughout your whole K12 experience so we don't want there to be that hole between the eth and ninth grade year and I think this approach addresses it chair I'm sorry somebody else can um I guess Miss

159Cleveland to your point is and also I think maybe what you're saying Miss Davis is that it really I can see some value at least making a comparison or other divisions is doing this but the reality is it sounds like we all agree it needs to be done here regardless if there maybe one or two that are not doing it in other words it sounds like everybody's on the same page with doing this no matter what um but we can still find out if if other divisions around it are doing it to me the only way that that would come into play is if somebody say failed in eighth grade here and they wanted to play football in ninth grade and they found out that Carolina county or somebody else they do a clean slate

160they well it'd be difficult obviously because of the residency requirements but that would be the only case I would see where it would even come into question as to whether another district is doing it or not doing it I suspect that the reason Miss Cleveland is asking is for competitiveness because you have yeah so yeah so I was just GNA ask you because I know you know sports stuff so why like why would that come to your mind and then that's but I don't think I think with we hold our students to that standard I I would hope that that would not be the case that we would be able to continue to be competitive there's a lot of research and studies that show that students that are successful academically create stronger teams you know

161their ability to to take direction from coaches their ability to do to meet the expectations of the coach I mean there's a ton of research out there for that but I would I would say in terms of the timeline I this is important to mention too and and probably uh why I say I that um Miss Cleveland's request is one that we can satisfy in terms of asking around the next steps for this is the um athletic handbook committee you know committee will meet uh they'll finalize recommendations uh and then we will put this into effect for next school year um we we had a pretty healthy discussion on you know not changing the rules Midstream for some of our current eighth grade students we want to make sure that we we allow if we're

162going to change these expectations we don't want to pop them on anybody we want to make sure that uh it would be for our current seventh graders that would then be rising eighth graders so from day one they know the expectation is is I have to meet this okay so we can we can talk about it further after we have that data I'm sure yep okay can I just add too did you get any feedback from the um like the coaching athletic director and things like that too yeah no they were very interested in it they thought it was a good idea and and actually a lot of our coaches right now um we we do like and traditionally have enjoyed and and coaches enjoy giving them autonomy of their programs with a certain you

163know expectation being met um what that means is that you know they oftentimes have more rigorous depending on the program uh academic expectations uh you know like I don't want to see any zeros in the grade book that kind of thing uh discipline expectations are one that often times is if you're representing this this team then you're representing you know uh so so we usually set kind of a minimum expectation but in talking to to coaches athletic directors that minimum expectation is something that they're comfortable with and then this would also this would go not not be in effect for eighth graders right now for ninth grade it would be for the next so they would have time to yes so so it's fair if that we're going to change these expectations that we give

164everybody the opportunity to have a full year to meet them so if we changed them right now we would be telling an eighth grader that starting their second semester we're going to hold you accountable for classes last semester that you didn't really understand this expectation for we we didn't think that was fair um we would push this through the athletic handbook committee finalize these recommendations put them in writing and then push them out to our families and our parents of our athletes at the beginning of next school year so that a rising eighth grader a current seventh grader says okay here's the current expectations so as I work my way through my 8th grade year and I get toward second semester I know that I have to be passing five classes to be eligible in

165the ninth grade year okay thank you okay so we can add this to a to discuss it uh yes our well I I'll provide you guys updates as we get more information perfect okay now before we continue I have to point out that it's four minutes of nine so I need an agreement from the board that we can continue more minutes pardon do you want to put another 9 at least what time do you think we should I think uh I don't know I I have a couple questions but my suggestion Madam chair would be um that if it goes past 9:30 that no matter what happens we stop at 9:30 okay um is everybody in agreement with that okay we don't have to vote on it or anything do we okay all right so

166let's move on to the proposed cell phone policy policy and what I what you have in front of you is hard copies of a bunch of different things because I wanted you to know what you were looking at so we had the initial policy and then there's some cross throughs on it and some highlights um and to start with we have the state Bill I'm sorry Senate bill number 738 um that is what is proposed uh by the Virginia Senate um I believe it's passed the Senate it has not passed um the house but uh anyway there's some language in there that pretty much supports what we're proposing in our policy um and I also have I think that's that's all I guess I would just ask you to look at the first page where

167um it says definitions um so we we we we put some clarification in there and uh the Bell to Bell definition uh pretty much goes along with what the with what the bill in in the proposed bill has so we were at the legislative conference earlier this week one of the um discussions was that these things will be passed voted on and then go into effect on July 1st so the the philosophy behind tightening down the um policy is that then when the law is passed and we're forced by Virginia Department of Education to to do these things our students already prepared if they're not as stringent then we can dial it back a little bit but we're just to be prepared um we'll follow what the that's the philosophy you guys don't have to

168agree but you have it in front of you I know I have some comments yes all right well first of all I like everything there's I only have two comments one is a larger discussion first one is just the fact that um there's no mention of the exemption of obviously Chromebooks am I missing it somewhere was it in here and I just didn't see it other words obviously they're going to use Chromebooks throughout the day but it fits the definition of things they're not supposed to use I think Mr Bush that wording in their personal the word personal you think word personal I think is covering that okay I mean that's fine if everybody agrees I'm just saying you know the problem the discussion we had before is that Chromebooks right could be possibly used

169for personal use but they're not but the word personal you think is enough okay I'm fine with that I can I add something to just but there's a one little caveat that I remember that and I think that's a good explanation but uh personal laptops right now we have some populations that it's almost recommended Governor schools Governor schools um they they often are um because they have a Windows operator opting system at Governor school and and a Google operating system at King George often times use a personal laptop so thinking about some way to consider that might be valuable we could write simply something about um exceptions may be made for requirements by um uh what do we call Governor schools ATI what's the category of um or just academic I don't um exceptions can

170be made if there's an academic requirement by the I don't know how about we say um division issued Chromebooks are allowed along with um required um uh personal laptops when deemed appropriate by I'd say required not deemed well okay I mean they don't require them they they strongly suggest that they use they can't require them to have when approved they don't it's their personal laptop about when approved when approved yeah that's good yeah when approved by Administration okay when are we going to do when approved by Administration or when approved by the governor school that's what I'm saying is if there was a category Governor School Chesapeake ATI you know we have three of them I don't know what category programs um there's a name I'm missing what is it Regional programs Regional programs there

171you go thank you thank you I knew there was a word so yeah except for regional programs all right so it's also going to be important to note on there and I don't know how to say this but um that it's used for you know academic purposes because yeah they might approve it for use for for academics right when used add that right at the end must be used for academic purposes for all regional May exceptions may be made for Regional Schools when used specifically for academic purposes and the governor school has policy that states that um those students have to follow their home school regarding computers good okay then on the next page um I changed the last sentence in the expectations fa failure to comply with the this expectation will result in disciplinary

172action and then I just crossed out all the consequences because the disciplinary action is listed in the code of conduct from last year yeah and we also aren't in the business of signing disciplinary action so yeah I actually have a copy of from the code of cond I think Miss Fischer gave you guys an email too that was pretty good actual document is madam chair yes sir those those uh infractions diary infractions that are in the code of conduct right now talk about one day uh ISS two days ISS and this new Senate Bill specifically states that a student cannot be taken out of the classroom expressly prohibits any student from being suspended expelled or removed from class as a consequent thank you for that I that's why I added in the removal of the

173phone rather than removal of the student okay yeah I have some go ahead anything else with that oh are we gonna keep these consequences in or take them out or put them in the in the code of conduct if I can make a suggestion again I know I've said this so many times I just really feel consequences the policy is very important for us as a board to but I think the consequences should be up to the in the code of conduct and up to the principles but I agree with you that something needs to reflect the law that's about to go into effect that they can't be removed from class I don't disagree with that but I would say Mr Frank is let the administrators you know will notify them that hey in terms

174of cell phones this can't you can't follow the code of conduct because it's about to be a change in the law but let them make that consequence not us I understand in my research for this uh I went through the original phone policy that King George had and consequences were in that uh West Morland county has consequences col beach has consequences uh what is it appach has consequences there's several there's a lot there's as many schools out there with consequences as there are without well I'm not saying there doesn't need to be consequences I totally agree with that within their policy well that's what I disagree policy I don't think it's the job to um to dictate in policy how the administration Mets out consequences I think that's the administration's job it's not ours it

175never has been regardless of what we've done in the past if we did in the past and I was on this board I'd have said the same thing and not even on about cell phone but about any time in a policy that we begin to dictate what we want the administrators to do as far as consequences I think here's the reason why let's say that let's say we did these consequences let's say the administrators find out you know what that first it's just not working and you know what and they get together maybe some talks with the teachers and another administrators whatever and say let's change that they could change that in the code of conduct rather than coming back to us and changing the whole policy again it has to do with allowing them

176who's on the ground boots on the ground seeing what works and does wasn't work but making sure they're following the policy I understand what you're saying however you know we had one kid with 17 violations okay the again that's up to the administration to make sure they deal with those sorts of things but okay and I have something else too on this I mean so I like the fact that you have Miss chairman had crossed out the consequences and I agree with that but I do agree also to let the administration especially in terms of what the you know saying that they cannot be taken out of the classroom which does not match with the code of conduct which I have right here regarding cell phones there was something else here though that I really

177I'm having a little bit of a problem with when it's says may not be in a pocket but instead must be placed out of sight in a backpack Locker or locked pouch okay um in my mind if it is in a pocket and there's simply like an outline back pocket front pocket you know it's like we don't know for sure if it's a cell phone I just don't want to get into the business that if a an administrator sees somebody you walking down the hallway and they see a bulge in uh a a girl's back pocket or front pocket and they say you know take that cell phone out well how do you know it's a cell phone now I guess what I'm saying is I don't want us to be in the business of

178looking at the kid the administrators having to look at these kids going down the hall now I do totally agree that if it's visible and many times it's in their pocket and it's visible if it's visible in any way then it must be placed in out of sight in a backpack Locker locked pouch and so it's just my recommendation would be to slightly change that um the wording so that it would say let me go to what I wrote here let me interrupt for one second if you go to the Senate Bill 738 number one um we're going to have to figure out how to word it so it goes along with that because it says restrict to the fullest extent possible student cell phone possession possession well that's in the backpack too then I

179I'm what I'm the point I'm making is is that in my mind I understand if it's visible because you do not want to get into the fact of having students say how do you know what's in my pocket um is is but if it's visible which many times in the back pockets you can see half of it sticking out and I would just simply say um cell phones must be not be visible but instead be placed out of sight in a backpack and so on that would just be my suggestion again Mr Bush that came from the Department of the the Department of Education which on the the definition of stored which stored means cell phone or personal electronic community device not being carried on the student's person including not in the student's pocket options

180School Division may choose to to Define as storage options include but are not limited to in a student's backpack in the students Locker uh in a locked pouch or in a designated place in the classroom so that's totally agree but I don't think you okay we do not know if we cannot see the cell phone we do not know that that's a cell phone you're making these assumptions that I think think is dangerous I think seeing the cell phone is the key and that needs to be put in the backpack but if you're sitting there bulges in pockets and we don't know that it's a cell phone now if we see them take it out visible yes deal with it if we see it sticking out yes deal with it if we see it in

181any way but if it's not visible and we're guessing as did you see that girl walking down theall did you see that boy I think he's got a cell phone in his pocket I think that's very dangerous Mr Frank okay thank you guys um does anybody have anything else to say um I do mad chair so I am still not convinced not to say to carry it on a person um mainly because I think when it's carried on a person that's when we have some of our biggest concerns going into the bathroom videoing things so that's I can kind of understand both arguments and I didn't really look at the executive order um that much so I don't know what it says in there but it's going to come down in July it's it's you

182should have a copy of it but I had I hav it highlighted here G to look at it um I think we probably still going to have to have more discussion about it to to clarify but in the interest of time and we have a couple more agenda items Mrs Davis do you have anything to add are we going to be discussing this again at another meeting I don't know I I don't know that we can come to an agreement tonight no we're not going to so your suggestion is that we put this for discussion at the next board meeting Madam chair what's the will of the board how are we uh can we I thought that the way it was written everybody agreed other than we took the consequences off and that's what went

183forward until we got from the government what they expected here's what confuses the tar out of me is that why can the government the Board of Education legislation all that tell us what our consequences can be but we're I don't want us to tell them what the consequences because I think you made a good point and we'll keep having to change it when it doesn't work so that was a good call out maybe we can um tighten it up on what we would hope are the consequences if they keep going what we can do then but to say that we can't be a part of like hey this is what we'd like to see the consequences be that I don't agree with but I agree with why you're saying leave it to them makes sense

184and then they could and then the administration can come back I just out yeah I I'm not I'm not saying there shouldn't be consequences there should be I'm just saying that let them dict and then they can let us know what those are yeah okay um but I guess as right now what we told um Mr Ed Mr Frank at the last board meeting and then the is that we would make a decision today right um and then we all were in agreement before we got here that we would agree that as far as I'm that we would go forward with what is written on here except for the cont consquences well we do have to make a few changes because of the Chromebooks andou other things amend the changes and then throw it in

185there Madam chair there is also a change um about the expectation for administrators teachers and other school Personnel because they're having to need right I I added that um at the end there I please take a look at the last page because there are times when staff will need to use laptops or cell phones and they're not instructing students but they may be in front of students that was I thought that was ah don't think yeah I also I don't think making it really tight and then if it's loose loosening it I think that's confusing to kids I think we what what you did Mr Frank here is you defined and got more specific with what our expectations and then give that to the admin and let them rrap that up how they would and

186then if it gets stricter than what we have we can come back to the table and move forward but anyways yeah so make the changes okay so the changes that I have are regarding Personnel electronic commun communication devices and I'm going to say division issued Chromebooks are allowed along with personal laptops when approved by Regional program for academic purposes and then I'm changing just taking out the consequences and I qu that it will result in disciplinary action period not to include suspension ah it's good yeah Madam chair we're not making the change about if it's we're letting we're requiring the administrators to try to figure out what B are in the pockets I agree with that too well he's not saying um that we don't enforce an out ofsight policy you're not even saying don't

187encourage it to put but we can't be looking at bulges yeah so we can still encourage to put it in a book bag yes yes and if they see it if it's visible then absolutely but if it's not visible I just think that's that's a dangerous thing to do sorry so it's and I'm speaking not only as a board member but also as a p out right pardon that would be up to admin to figure it out yes yes saying we would like it in a book b so this definition of stored came right out of the Virginia doe guidelines um and I guess we'll just have to follow it Loosely we're following it you know we're saying that it's not supposed to be on their person we're just not going to do a search

188right that's it okay I don't want to get into searching or guessing but we absolutely need to say if we see the phone needs to be put in the backpack and then consequence and then on the last page where I have you could say nothing in this definition requires Administration to conduct a search of any nature I don't know I mean I'm or you could say what about just what I said if it's if the cell phones must must not be visible but instead be placed out of sight in the backpack I think may not be visible that is that it's like that right now and they're just still walking around with it in pocket going in the bathrooms and causing issues and stuff they can do that if it's in their backpack too it's

189e well it's not as easy to pull it out of your backpack as it is your pocket I know I know that there's still some research going on in terms of how how to remedy the backpack bag situation and I'd like to give the I think the whole idea of this thing about not being on the person was that if that phone goes off if it's on silent you're going to know it's going off and it's going to take your attention away from whatever is going on you know that's that was a I think the whole purpose behind the Department of Education putting that in there it it's supposed to be off because it's supposed to be off but you know if you're not going to check to see if it's a bulge you're going

190to check to see if it's turned off that's the same if it's in the backpack it's the same thing I agree needs to be turned off the headphones will tell you if it's off or not what I'm saying is if it's in your pocket you're going to know when it goes off the student is going to want to look at it I mean it's an addiction that they have I agree so they're going to want to look at agree I just don't want administrators searching kids nobody said the definitions don't say anything about searching kids it just says it can't be on their person I agree and that's I mean we'll have to go with that definition for now leave it as is when it doesn't say to search them Madam chair can I uh

191go back to the point about the regional programs and personal laptops sure miss half um has let me know that currently uh this school year at King George Middle School we have 25 students and at King George high school we have 70 students uh who sign and this is part of our Uh current policy who sign an opt out form in order to use their personal devices while at school so it's not just it's not currently just Regional well it's not currently just Regional programs is is I guess the point there um I guess you can look at that two different ways you know the board can make a change to to not allowing uh part of part of um our acceptable use policy uh to allow our students to use personal laptops for instructional

192for I think what do we put in there academic reasons or something like that uh or or we could massage that to say you know not Regional programs but um you know may maybe just for academic purposes personal laptops can be used for Approved academic something of that nature I I think uh may be deemed as somewhat discriminatory just to our regional programs if we're just pulling them out can you read that verbiage again that you had right there division issued Chromebooks are allowed along with personal laptops when approved by Regional programs for academic purposes but I can just say when approved for academic purposes but my question is are the are the same restrictions on the personal laptops in terms of websites they can get to and stuff as as so what do you

193mean by that they goes through the same filter and [Music] I also have a solution why why do we have students using their own because the Chromebooks are slow and they don't allow them to download certain right you want to come up Hillary wouldn't mind speak into that question I can understand for the Governor's School but she can speak to it yeah we have some families who prefer not to use School issued Chromebooks because along with signing on that line if a student damages it or comes home with a shattered screen they don't want to be responsible for being charged for that screen so they just assume have that child with their own personal device that way if something happens to it that family handles it on their own and so I feel like it's

194a matter of preference as Miss Hoover said there are some students they want to use a Macbook we're only resp responsible so when they bring a Macbook there are some things that are not compatible with say programs that a an English teacher is using and the parent understands that we have some families that changed their mind halfway through the year because the student device isn't doing what the Chromebook can be doing in the building so right now it is an opt out it's part of our registration forms at the beginning of the year so when they do a device checkout for middle school and high school they can choose to opt out of being responsible for a student device it's a small population like Dr boy said very small at the middle school 25 yeah

195and about 70 to 75 students right now at the high school so I think the board has posed with a a choice of you know do do we make a consideration in the policy or or do we not and and then go back and adjust our acceptable use policy to not allow for personal devices which I can just take out when approve um by Regional programs and just say or just when approve for academic for academic purposes and we do approve the device in order to add it to our wireless network we get the MAC address we have information off that device so there is some tracking with that so if there were ever an issue you could okay correct and so is there any way to I mean is laptop the appropriate term is

196there any way to interpret that into something different like a tablet or a you know what I'm saying we have some students who have an iPad you know that we have approved on the technology side because of a certain app that they need in a specific classroom so I don't even know if I can say it's right down to a laptop we have approved a tablet um and I know our special education students for for uh communication will use and again you're getting into this kind of like um you know where you almost have to have a clause that says you know um as to the discretion of administration discretion of whoever you want to give discretion to but you're going to find some situations where um you're going to have a tough time fitting

197it that into into that box again exceptions yeah well what was the wording again I liked what you said except well I said division issued Chromebooks are I'm sorry thank you Miss half are allowed along with personal laptops when approved for academic purposes but laptops I guess is well you could say personal electronic devices when approved well we have up there the definition of a personal electronic communication device means personal device cap of connecting to a smartphone the internet or cellular Wi-Fi network or directly connects so you know I this reminded me it didn't we have this kind of similar conversation when it came to the use of uh devices for monitoring uh medical you know when we had this conversation about um people with that the blood monitors and and um Sugar Sugar monitors

198was there still something in there that said I mean maybe that covers this instead of having to write it out maybe uh personal the last for students with medical needs communication devices may be used with approval of building administrators maybe under that sentence we could reword that statement to um include these exceptions like you know with with uh administrative approval so um maybe I I would maybe take out four student students with medical needs because it's really now broader than that um personal communication devices may be used uh with approval of ad um building building Administration for academic purposes and or medical purposes I don't know some I'm just spitballing right now but maybe it can all be captured in that exception line right there so that we don't have to write a separate section

199I think it I think it yeah like that too we'll fix it up also something else about what I was talking about earlier I think if we kept in may not be in a pocket but instead be placed out of sight in the backpack Locker or locked pouch and this will be enforced at the discretion of the school administration I don't know what where would that's we're back to instead of saying it's got to be visible I would be fine if we can say and this will be enforced at the discretion of the school administration another they won't have to search somebody if they don't want to but would we would we even want to open that up though they make the decision but I mean but do we want them to search kids do

200you know what I mean can't do you see what I mean it's like at the discretion well we don't want them to do that right well again I go back to the best thing for me is to say if it's visible it is and I I just for for for me I just think that if our expectation is that it's not on them we need to say that I I don't disagree I don't think you're following me I don't disagree with that at all well that's what we're saying here that's what this sentence is saying it's not to be on them how do you know it's visible or not how do you know but we don't want them to you know Pat them down stop them in the hall if there's Bulls in their pocket

201yeah right my point we don't want it on their person so I think what we're saying is the same thing because what we're saying is we don't want it on your person we're not asking you to you know Pat them down but if you see it on their person you might want to say something to them if you visibly see it if you just see a bulge in their pocket don't start stopping okay if if that's understood by the administration and there's not an expectation that they're going to stop kids just because they see a bulge in their pockets and I think it's fine so we just need to figure out how we can say that appropriately in this policy without them thinking that they need to Pat them down but I I I don't

202think that we should take off that it should not be the person because it's an expectation for everyone I mean if you read that sentence about I mean that paragraph about stor the only invasive thing is including not in the student's pocket and I would say 99% of the time if it's in your back pocket you're going to see it right yeah you're going to visibly see it most of the time if it's in I don't I don't know that that I don't know that that's not good enough enough that like I said this follows the guidelines that are written in the bill so I don't know if if we can come to an agreement or not but so which part are you saying now we're going to keep this but I'm sorry where the

203whole thing what the definition of stored means right out of the well you're yeah just keep the defition from the Department of Education guidelines yeah it doesn't say I mean it I don't but you think that's encouraging people it perhaps we we need to make a caveat to say you know I I think that's it's something along the lines of being visible visible visible on a person's body visible we don't want it we don't want it on your body so that's why I said if it's visible so where where would you like me to add that in that definition that's what I cell phones must not be visible but instead be placed out of site I'm just Jing that's what I said so instead of instead of putting including not in a student po pocket

204so take that out inp put cell phones must not be visible and let the administration decide whether the building is visible or whether they physically see it okay I don't think you I don't think it's I don't think that's what he wanted to cross out I think so because I'm thinking you want to take out you want to take off off the device not carried on a student's person you want to take that out too or no no no I don't want I said the cell phone should not be visible whether it's on cell phones and electronic devices may not be visible must be placed instead in a side pocket and where am I putting that right under the definition of stored no where it says cell phones must not be visible instead of cell

205phones or electronic devices may not be in the pocket may not be visible that's it but if you do that you're not following the Board of Education nor senat you don't have to follow the Board of Education we have to follow Virginia law yes yeah and that's one of the things that's there it says not in their possession pocket is in their possession what I was just saying Circle why don't we uh why don't we ask the principles you already did all right and they they were okay with that no you're not okay with it okay I'm sorry it's not appropriate Madam chair it's not appropriate necessarily unless you give permission for us to speak I sent everybody the feedback that Mr Watson sent me is that pretty much what I was saying that's what

206I thought I guess what I'm saying is the administration I I don't remember that but that's what I assumed is there agreeing with me okay so I'm going to add that to the expectation for students if it is clearly visible or or I'm sorry cell phones must not be visible but instead placed out of sight in a backpack right I think yeah not going to address on the person I I I just I I can't get my head wrapped around that so I don't think that we're going to be able to agree on this because I I just can't get my head rubbed on that I I I do not think it should be I I do not think that we should set the expectation that it should be carried on their body I don't

207necessarily think that we are but I hear what you're saying M CLE well it looks like we're not going to come to an agreement because it is now 9:30 and it's possible we could figure out a way to word it differently I think I do to appease everyone and make it so that it's not an issue which I know why it would be an issue because we don't want to pat down the kids we don't want to have teachers being engaged in that kind of behavior with with with why don't we sit down why don't we just what you said why don't we think about this and contemplate it maybe even have some discussion with the administration again how they might suggest that it would be worded that they feel comfortable with administering I I

208I believe you have most of that already um I just think that we we as a board need to look at that and come to an agreement on how to write it but perhaps we can talk about that in our work session I know Mr Frank was hoping to get this it's fine with me whatever everybody agrees on but work session is fine okay so include that to the on the work session yes please when when is the next work session February 10th our next board meeting is so M that's our next I'm sorry go ahead I do think that you know um the principles at the school and their input is is very important and I think that we could all probably work together to get what we want done yes in it I

209agree yeah I agree just need a word it differ probably I requested feedback from them and I provided it to you guys and I think we just still had some disconnects it's it it's hard when we can't all talk except here um so maybe at the work session two we can have we will already have previous discussions maybe with the administration but I would suggest we even have a work session with the administration why not just what you said Miss Huber I think it's a lot of good progress guys yeah and I I do appreciate um everyone's feedback from the from the schools that and please feel free to reach out to us more and since you've heard this conversation let us know see the value of you being here we do want to make

210we do want to make it work for all of us so thank you okay does anybody have any committee reports yeah who are you starting with it's already 9:35 or we're supposed to adjourn at 9:30 we don't have to finish our business we can do committee reports committee reports that have to occur this evening don't have to occur okay of them do yeah all right we'll do the committee reports and just do it over a month period that's fine yeah it's fine um no laog you can just okay can I have a motion to adjourn please I make a motion we adjourn February 10 until February 10 for the work session second all in favor say i i p votes I adjourned motion carries whatever e

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.