CorpusRecord 129950

#DPSCommunity | DPS Board of Education Special Called Meeting | 1/6/25

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Durham Public Schools Board of Education
Date
2025-01-07
Location
Durham County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,990 words · about 73 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e good evening everybody uh the dur Public Schools Board of Education special meeting is now in session at this time we wish to extend a warm welcome to everyone who is joining us this evening uh the interpreters for tonight are Martha Romo oriles and Vanessa Peña Ramirez thank you so much for taking the time to join us the um first item on the agenda is a moment of silence thank you the next item on the agenda is agenda review and approval move approval of the agenda as presented second it's by moved by Miss berer and seconded by Miss Chavez to approve the agenda as presented this evening all in favor I I I I all opposed please use the same sign right passes unanimously uh the next item on the agenda is transportation

002plans and with that I will pass it over to Dr web thank you Madam Vice chair uh good evening board members Dr Lewis and cabinet members and all in attendance uh we have a presentation tonight responding to some of the questions that were submitted uh to our transportation team Mr Palmer is going to be uh presiding over that uh he is with joining us remotely uh we have with us um some of his staff and he'll introduce those folks toble to talk to you uh Kristen Burkshire is here and uh I think Kristen's the only one with us tonight Mr Palmer are you with us indeed I am Dr web excellent well welcome Mr Palmer The Voice from the ceiling we're glad you're here uh so with your permission I'll turn the turn it over

003to Mr Palmer thank you Dr web oh Mr Palmer sorry before you get started I'm sorry I forgot to say one thing we have four board members here this evening um but we are unfortunately three board members were unable to join us um because this meeting was scheduled at the last minute or um it was a specially called meeting so not everybody's able to join but we did feel like it was important to go ahead and continue having the transportation discussion um in advance of Thursday's meeting um I'm sorry for interrupting go ahead Mr Palmer okay thank you Vice chair Carter Aon and Dr Dr Lewis and administrative and board members in the room with us this evening uh we are providing a overview of progress made since we last met on December 19th and

004with that let's go to the next slide thank you U the board has submitted questions to the administration um and we are putting those together in three groups around family responsibility zones secondary magnet Express Stop service and runting improvements in optim iation in addition um the Administration has administered a transportation survey and there are some early results on that next slide please okay so we have three topics within uh board submitted questions wanted to give an overview here and then Avail ourselves make ourselves available for additional board discussion and questions sort of topically thematically with respect to family responsibilities zones there have been several questions about the approach to developing our DPS family responsibility zones which we have an acronym for f frz uh as well as questions from the board about when and if

005Maps will be available we can speak a bit on that tonight Community Support how can volunteers get involved and how the community of Durham support its schools and children uh particularly with respect to walking groups and carpooling and then District and school communication to Families how will we know um at a family level if this uh family responsibility Zone would impact a family or a student and in certain extenda circumstances the appeals process itself so um we want to start upfront with a review of the approach to developing the family responsibility zones again um here in North Carolina it is established that school systems are U providing transportation for students that live 1.5 miles or further from their home to school um what we are aware of is that here in Durham we do not

006currently have established walk zones or family responsibility zones prior to the December 19th vote by the board and many of those family responsibility zones as we've discussed are A4 mile or a half mile from the school and none go further than one mile that's important because even though the 1.5 miles is sort of the state standard and a common practice for most school systems and leas here in North Carolina our approach to developing the family responsibility zones was a bit more different and reflective of our values here in Durham prioritizing in particular uh safety and access to school for families so we looked at our existing Road speeds and I will remind the board uh not only the the speed of the road but the traffic of the road to consider the infrastructure and routes

007that students if they chose to walk within a certain perimeter uh from home to school could access the School site itself uh that's considerate of existing sidewalk as well as low speeed roads 25 miles hour or loader lower um and those intersections that would need to be navigated across to ensure that there is an appropriate uh either a full-on traffic light along with interventions like a pedestrian hybrid Beacon or other pedestrian activated devices to enhance safety in addition to that once we looked at it from a sort of technical planning and Engineering lens on infrastructure we also worked with our School principles to ensure that their input and voices were heard as well and we're able to I would say enhance access to school within those areas we adjusted five overall family responsibility zones uh

008based on principal feedback and a technical review and that has reduced the overall impact slightly uh as we look at the number of bus routes Andor students that are impacted by the F frzs now with regards to geography and the maps themselves we have received approval from the administration and are excited uh that we have worked with public affairs to to make those Maps available through the DPS Transportation website those will be posted this week uh and in there uh we'll have access to street names again every family that is directly uh already living within these geographies has received communication from the district and schools uh this is more for I think Community awareness and any efforts to ganize support Andor resource es for students or schools uh of the 21 that have family responsibility

009zones in addition of with respect to Community Support well DPS cannot directly at an administrative central office level connect volunteers with schools and families we are here to support our school leaders as they work through um kind of liasing between Advocates as well as volunteers and our students and families to promote Walkin groups and carpooling any efforts that would reduce the burden of uh student arriving to school safely Within These smaller geographies and again district and school communication we've been prior to the break itself uh communicating directly through principles with our families including take-home letters and ribel call notifications uh two impacted families I know there has been a question if folks did not get a call was it an oversight um and often times folks are finding that the the actual eligibility areas that

010we're talking about are quite a bit smaller uh than that state standard again many of our areas are between a quarter and a half mile a few stretch up to a mile where there is extended sidewalk connectivity in some of our newer neighborhoods uh that have appropriate infrastructure and then lastly in accordance with 6322 in the appeals process we are working through that to have extenda circumstances and again uh this is very much like a a bus stop appeal process or others within the district and so with that let me go to the next thematic grouping and we're available this evening to answer any additional questions we may have um next slide please secondary magnet Express Stop service U one of the things that we're being very cautious about is ensuring that we've had the

011opportunity to work with our School principles both those schools DSA Rogers her and Creative Studies that are receiving are slated to plan to receive Express Stop service and those schools that are servicing as a hub host ing site these are areas again middle and high schools throughout Durham city and county wherein families would bring their student and then the students would access the express stops to DSA Rogers her or Creative Studies um we do we are continuing to finalize those locations with school leadership to ensure that not only that the locations are a fit but also the pickup and drop off times in accordance with the other traffic patterns at those schools and there are questions about the supervision of students we are in transportation not equipped or staff to provide direct on-site supervision I

012know there were questions about that and that relates to the times itself and again encouraging families that there is important value if safety is a concern for your student or the supervision of students is a concern to go ahead and arrive in accordance with when the scheduled Express Stop times are as well as um for afternoon departure as well that district and school communication again we're talking current bus riders that are routed for DSA Rogers her and Creative Studies um we are intentionally wanted to ensure that those locations and times uh have been reviewed with our secondary academic leaders at the school level uh and then communication that goes to families this week will have have those places and times embedded within the district communication next slide please and lastly with regards to routing improvements

013and optimization I want to reset for the board uh and the community that uh rout optimization is truly a year round Endeavor wherein our student ridership team is seeking to maximize the appropriate effective and safe use of our resources there are several statutes here in North Carolina that specify you know the proximity of our school bus stops we're continually reviewing that to ensure that they're in compliance not only with State legislation but also we have had many different stop appeals uh for a variety of reasons and so our routing improvements and optimization currently I shared at the last board meeting that our ridership numbers have increased over at least since this work began in October and in it's into November um those ridership numbers are we were right at about 19,000 and are now at

01419,500 um the consolidation itself I want to I want to speak to that and ensure that we've started our route consol our stop and Route consolidation in the fall of 2023 in anticipation for the opening of 2425 U our student ridership and routing team is perpetually looking at any opportunities to enhance efficiency and level of service but we do want to emphasize that that routing improvements and optimization without additional efforts at a district school or family level with student ridership those efforts around routing improvements and optimization are really trying to ensure less stress for our drivers and overall higher levels of service for our families that includes consistency timeliness and length of our bus routes and when we have an opportunity to collapse or consolidate routes uh then we certainly would do so um that

015is again an ongoing Endeavor uh our ridership team has been working on this aspect as we are also braiding in the other improvements with regards to the family responsibility zones and the Express Stop service so I wanted to name that here that as we are enhancing our routing uh it may not be in a direct Savings of number of routes carried as much as it may may be increasing our overall level of service for timeliness and consistency of service getting kids to school okay next slide please and with that I will hand it back to the administration I believe Dr Lewis has a a few points of information with our transportation survey yes thank you so much uh Mr Palmer and good evening um board members and members of the of the public uh as

016indicated by our vice chair Carter Aon at the beginning of the meeting this is a special call board meeting if you recall during our last board meeting we Shar that we provide an update at our January 9th board meeting and so tonight allows us an opportunity to just provide the board an update in terms of where we've been since the last meeting as we continue to prepare for uh January the 9th within the communication that we sent out to our families particularly those families are that are impacted by the family responsibility zones uh and the express stops uh we sent out a a a survey or a thought exchange to gather some questions from them uh to further uh assist us with the um operational operationalizing these family responsibility zones as well as the um

017Express stops uh next slide please and so this thought exchange that we sent out is just an opportunity for us to gather um um collective intelligence but also it allows us to um focus on where um we're hearing um what we're hearing from our parents and and focus on those areas that we're hearing uh concerns from the most and so the question that we asked as our families is what are your thoughts regarding the implementation of Express stops and family responsibility zones to solve dbs's Transportation um challenges and so this was an opportunity for them to provide spe feedback to District leaders uh again this is just a snapshot as of today um uh we did let our families know that they would have up until July I'm sorry not July January 9th which is

018Thursday to complete that and so we'll bring back um the final results of the survey and definitely go in more detail than what I'm going to go through tonight but I just did want to provide high level as up today in terms of where we are um with u the the feedback that we that we are receiving from our families next slide so as a we look at the breakdown of participation again this was just sent to families that are impacted by uh family responsibility zones and express stops uh as of today earlier today we had about 417 participants uh and they left um 232 234 thoughts but they also rated um I just checked a moment ago it's now it's over 5100 um thoughts that they have rated and so what they do is

019uh and we use this Tool uh during the latter part of my listening and learning uh um session as well they'll look at the thoughts and then they'll rate the thoughts that they agree with or the questions that they agree with and what that does is allow us to focus on where we need to focus our our efforts on and so um an average participants rated about 12 um thoughts next slide quick um breakdown of the role uh we did ask the role were your parent student staff or or other and you can see overwhelmingly uh 92% of the respondents are indeed um parents next slide we think about um our during Public Schools families uh 84% um were english- speaking families and 15% um or Spanish-speaking families next slide and what this tool also

020does is really looked at themes what are we hearing from our families what are we hearing from our communities um and it rates it rates these themes based on um what our families are seeing and so just again a snapshot some of the feedback and questions that our families are asking us or the comments that they are leaving us are centered around Equity issues they have a lot of questions around the um Express stops and also are leaving comments as it relates to family hardships and also some comments on R rotational busing what what this tool allows us to do is to click on either one of those bars and go directly to those thoughts that were related to for example rotational busting or those thoughts that related to equity issues so that we can

021address um and be able to respond uh to those uh concerns from our families and so if we were to sum up just where we are today with the um feedback that we received from our families the next slide just kind of highlights uh the responses again as of today of what uh we're hearing from our families next slide and so the response is highlight significant concern with the implementation of Express stops in uh family responsibility zones and so we wanted to make sure that we're transparent and we'll tell you exactly what our families are are sharing with us parents Express difficulties in driving their children to school daily safety issues with children walking in the dark and the impra impracticality of work I'm sorry for working uh parents many emphasize the inequity of the

022plan particularly for low-income families single parents and those without reliable transportation uh there are worries about increased treny traffic congestion and a lack of supervision at at Express stops the timing of the implementation mid school year also is also criticized uh for causing undue hardships overall the plan is seen as Shifting the burden from districts to families exacerbating existing challenges so again that's probably what you've been hearing um as you were receiving uh emails as well and so again we wanted to make sure that we providing real time um transparent feedback that we're receiving from from our families as of today and as I mentioned we will come back you can go to the next slide we will we will come back on Thursday with the full breakdown um of the feedback that we have

023been receiving from our families time uh open it up for any questions as relate to those areas and please know we will have additional details and information to share out a January 9th meeting all right board members you like to kick it off with some questions or comments okay Miss har go um I'm really here you know just to hear the update and to prepare for Thursday um but I do so appreciate um seeing the information coming in from families and that being considered for what we're going to decide on Thursday thank you so much for the for that data I'm looking forward to seeing um hearing um how far how far that goes um also just really thinking about um wanting to really understand or be assured that these what we're looking at now

024as a Band-Aid doesn't prevent the proactive approach to you know what we can do you know what we need to do for really getting bus drivers in the seats um and um I don't want the Band-Aid to become The New Normal um so very interested in how what we decide um is going to lead to those stronger campaigns for getting bus drivers in the seats um so that it doesn't become The New Normal so that these things that we're having to do quickly don't become The New Normal um let me see what I said here um my only other thought has to do around which was which is of course we're seeing in the emails and through the data around Equity um I think that is my my concern around the decision is that it

025because this is you know a a response that is urgent um it would be very difficult to make any of these decisions completely Equitable quickly um and so when we're doing it again it it just goes back to we have to really address the heart of the issue is which is the the shortage the staff shortage so I'm looking forward to when you know when we can get to that conversation and hopefully you know come up with some solutions some answers for what we can do that's Innovative to get more people in the seats more quickly that's all thank you thank you Mr hel goof is there anything that transport wanted to say in response to that before we move on to somebody else's or questions or comments I'll be happy to respond thank you

026Miss har go for your comments and your concerns and and the comments um we have shared and I think everyone is in agreement the permanent solution to this is to have enough bus drivers uh CDL licensed CDL with pass pns endorsements who work for dur public schools and drive the buses and to that that effort is ongoing and um all of our conversations regardless if we're talking about a short-term fix a long-term fix they always come back to what can we do to increase Personnel to increase family members who are there professionals who are providing that skilled uh task every day so that is that is the only permanent solution and I I appreciate you sharing that um as far as decisions moving forward I mean we're that is our main long-term goal um the

027the length of time these other initiatives are that would be a discussion with the board and on basic basically when they start and and continuing we're open to the and we appre so appreciate this ongoing conversation where we're we're working together as partners on this our transportation team is working for the Here and Now but they're also working to resolve the the problem completely and permanently thank you Dr web um yes Miss Chavez um well thank you I want to Echo the um appreciation for the survey especially and I like the tool that you all used um to uh for people to lift up you know other people's thoughts um that was a a gave gave us a good picture of what um many families are concerned about and also uh is reflective of the

028emails that we have received um but I I that kind of Outreach is um is great and we should you know continue to to do that um I also appreciate that you contacted families individually um that I think that's really helpful and it's helpful to know um for us um and um and then I also wanted to just appreciate the many mostly parents who have written to us about their concerns um and because it really gives a a fuller picture of what people are um are thinking worried about um also you know trying to um ways that people are trying to solution as well um so first on the topic of Recruitment and Retention the long-term uh goal and strategy um I just want to put out there that um I thought of this when

029you were talking um miss harof that perhaps we want to have another special meeting around that um in February or March but um another emergency meeting but about our long-term strategy so I'm just putting that out there um where we can embed it within our you know regular um monthly meeting but again I think that's going to take considerable conversation and discussion a lot of strategizing and I know among board members we're thinking on these different levels as you all are um where should you know where is where should we put our energy um into sort of inquiring about um about what the plans and strategies are whether that be the Band-Aid you know um Solutions or the longer term Recruitment and Retention strategies so um I wanted to offer that um I was thinking

030uh before uh before this meeting I think um that as I was reading through my emails I caught up on my emails today um hundreds of emails so um I uh was um really thinking about how we're applying an equity lens to this situation and I will say with the rotational busing we did not get a a lot of emails about that we got concerns but then I think it did it was um it has been um a pretty effective Band-Aid approach for managing the chaos that people were experiencing before um but it also it w it was equalizing it wasn't Equity um because there were a lot of kids as we heard about who missed multiple days of school um certain buses that routinely didn't run it didn't prioritize those students I know I

031asked about that but the plans have been laid out and I'm not saying it shouldn't be as it as it was designed but um it it equalized everything it is appropriate sometimes to equalize everything but also with an equity approach we've all seen the diagram where some um people get the you know bigger foot stol to see over the fence and um and so I'm thinking about that now who needs a biger foot stol to see over the fence um I am I will say was you know um some um some schools have more PTA infrastructure than others we've talked about that but and so there is sometimes you know more advocacy which I appreciate um U from those groups that have been able to sort of gather um input from a lot of people

032so I am I am still even um with the family responsibility zones um concerned about those who are not that were hearing who really have don't know what they're going to do to get their kids to school they have younger kids or they um they only have one they have one person they rely on um for child care who can't drive the the child or something like that so I I guess right now I'm thinking a lot about the um policy the appeals process and 6322 um and how that can be laid out very clearly I know we talked about that but before the family responsibility zones would go into effect so that we are able to um basically capture those with the highest need who really really need it um and um and so

033I'm just thinking about how we can apply that Equity lens and those who are more privileged there are families who for whom not having bus service um it really changes their schedules they work all day two parent household or one parent household um but they might be able to afford child care you know or afford someone to pay you know to uh Drive their kid to and from school if they're affected by the family responsibility Zone I'm just thinking about how we can ask those with more privilege to use it and those who have the greatest need that we can serve them um so that's what I would ask as we continue to work on the implementation of this um and then I want to note that we have received the um most uh concerned

034messages about Express stops we've received a lot so um I would be interested just when you report the survey results on Thursday to know if you um are able to break this down who was responding from the who's affected by the family responsibility zones and who's affected by the express stops um so so I wanted to note that um questions let's see um so let me ask this question the appeals process would be one thing um are there other ways that you all feel we can prioritize who are um who are low income or who um I mean that's a that's a sweeping way of saying someone with less resources and people may have more or less like social resources or you know um network resources that kind of things so we don't know but

035are those is there a way we can prioritize students who have um who have less resources whether that be Financial or um social familial capital or uh Network kind of resources thank you Miss Chavez um any thoughts and response to that before we move forward thank you for that and I'll ask Mr uh Palmer and the team to wait in in just a moment I will say we're working on the mechanics of this making it work making the making the the um the initiatives implementing the initiatives uh we will look to the school level that that the parents are the parents are not necessarily communicating their needs to to the district level they would communicate that to the school there are a number of resources that our team is going to make sure are available

036uh we certainly aren't endorsing or recommending but making those uh opportunities aail ailable not only to individual parents but to the schools as well and then the schools will be working with us and we we want to we want to help everyone we can within the resources abilities and charge that we have as well Mr Palmer or team would you like to expand upon that thank you Dr web um I I wanted to ask for just a moment uh Miss Chavez a clarifying uh question to the to your to your question uh in respect to prioritizing low soci economics status students um are you referencing uh could you say more about prioritizing with um are we talking well please say more about what priorities you're looking for us to bring in or or a little

037bit more about the question itself Cor um I I specifically mean for um families within the family responsibility zones and when I looked at that survey data the top things were Equity I write down all of them but Working Families like all all these oh thank you oh yes that's right we have uh family hardship um okay Express yeah working parents it's a lot about parents needing to go to work it's a lot I mean what we're hearing is families with have you know there are families who only have one car there are um a parents have to go to work if they can't go to work and and um you know put their kid on the bus they have to quit their job that's going to cause problems immediately um for their family and

038um and so a lot of this has to do with money it has to do with finances it has to do with you know Survival on that level so that's kind of where my question comes from is there a way that we can um are there any other ways to kind of um decipher who most needs transportation that we're cutting it that we would be potentially cutting it off from with the family responsibility zones does that clarify I I think MRIs to repeat back um looking to prioritize low income students that live within the F frzs and in particular uh alternate means of transportation is that what you're inquiring about or or some other form of a resource that we could provide or supplement those families is that what you're asking yes okay any any

039yeah yes thanks I like the way you put that okay I think that's something that certainly um I'm going to look to Dr web and the administration on with regards to what would be in the portfolio of additional resources that are available right now our conversation our lens has been really fixated on the delivery of the safe arrival of students and what we can do with our limited school bus drivers in relationship to those students that have requested service and so in that space of alternate means of accessing school I think there are there was an certainly an opportunity there to lay out what might those resources include how could those be other things in addition to yellow bus service what other efforts might there be and I I certainly think that that is a

040a board and administration sort of galvanizing point if you will and what I would add to that is um our ultimate goal is to ensure that we are preparing our Scholars for that next level and ensuring that um we're able to reach our mission I'm sure that we're able to meet each individual schools goals and so as we think about you know just some of the feedback from the survey data and what I've been hearing from board members that are things that are coming through emails and whether it's a working families and I certainly want to be respectful of some of our families with that uh come from social low socioeconomic backgrounds that do have transportation and maybe the Working Families that may need it and so I've had experience and we had we briefly

041discussed this as it relates to um looking at these at a case- by casee basis and so if my home is this building and my school is the Durham Bull Stadium I just looked it up as like a half a mile from here and I was once getting Transportation but I'm no longer receiving transportation and I'm must come from a single parent home my mom has to be at work at 5:00 a.m. um working with Transportation or some other resources um if there's a bus that comes right here on Cleveland Street even though I don't qualify for transportation again looking at our case by case bases is there is there an existing route that's going to come by my house that I still can put this child on uh we have to make make sure

042that we're making uh student centered decisions but also at the same time uh ensuring that what we're hearing from the survey what we're hearing from this community that we're able to respond uh to our families and so whether it's putting this child on the existing route or connecting them with existing um resources in the community to ensure that they get to school so that's something that we can work with the schools with um before we get to the appeals process we'll we'll please be ass sure we'll do all we can to ensure that if there is this family that there's no way absolutely no way I can get my child to school um that we explore those options with the with the family I appreciate that I I think um you know to your point

043there's no hard and fast like this category of people or that category of people um you know uh need exactly this thing um that's not that's not true um but we do know some in categorically there are some um situations in which people are more disadvantaged than others but I really like what you said and also um I know that I I I think if if School leader you know building leaders know how every single student is getting to school I know that's big ass but that would be reassuring to me that they know every single student has a new way to school if they're in the family responsibility zones but now can take you know whatever bus or now they're in a carpol or this or that um I know that they are have

044their eyes on every single student um in any case but um I'm really just thinking how can we ensure that so we're just not leaving anybody out so thank you for that I'll pause there um okay Mr Hof thank you I just I wanted to also just um lift up that the reason why I think this is you know this is a really hard thing it' be really really hard to make it completely Equitable is because you're you're going to run into those situations too where families are not going to trust to share their information you know what I'm saying um in order to be supported in that way and so I'm interested in what is the process um if a family really needs this transportation and they're overlooked or we miss them that process

045of appeal that that we were talking about before Miss Carter I think Miss Carter Alton brought it up in the last meeting of I have to have transportation regardless of my economic status of where I am this is not going to work for my family what is that process and I that being very clear and transparent before we Implement especially um if it goes as far as to implement before the end of the school year and then I'm also I'm looking forward to Thursday knowing if if this has to be like if is it really necessary to implement this early in order to make it in order to make it work um I'll be looking for that conversation on Thursday if there's a you know if if that's absolutely necessary like um so one the

046process for I am that family I'm in this in this Zone it's supposed to work but it's absolutely not going to work what do I need to do you know and then on the flip side of that [Music] um for the families that are privileged what is the you know more or more privileged I'll say or more privileged and could have options you know could make could be easier for them to take their names off of the bus list and um what are our what is our campaign um for that how can we be more aggressive for that I do I don't think that um the number of people that we've heard from so far that that's all the families who would be willing to help we're hearing from community that they want to help

047they're trying to figure out why I think there are more people and and then how would how would that shift um the numbers so um are we doing a campaign for those families um the bigger asks how many different ways have we done that already I know we've done it but how many different ways have we done it um and how would that shift the numbers and would that make it easier so that if we were to implement something like this um it would make it easier to have spaces or you know accessibility for those families that really really need it um so that system for allowing those families to appeal if they're in those zones and really cannot um get their kids to school or you know um don't have the relationship to trust

048you know to reveal whatever information they would have to reveal in order to be able to do that um then what do they do what is the process for us being able to hear them and then get them on a bus thank you for that um question I I do um want to thank those families that have done that already I've had parents come up to me and said hey I removed my kid from the bus I have that privilege uh as far as official campaign we haven't had an official campaign we have communicated with families and that's something that we certainly can revisit in terms of recommunity that to families that this is the way that you if you um are in a position where you can take your child to school there's another

049other means to get your child to school and you can give up a seat on a bus that will help you know increase route efficiency then we can still you know we can communicate at again with families at risk of of sounding a a bit evasive I did want to offer that um and thank you for the question um the reality is that the the question really gets at in addressing these kinds of scenarios there is going to be um a need for a level of detailed personalized information that frankly you know there is no way to to create kind of a broad answer to that question um the answer to that question is that that is where where our building level administrators are going to come in because they are going to be the

050the folks someone asked a minute ago about um principes knowing how every child arrives at school I assure you that in this very second um with very very very few exceptions virtually every principal in this District right now knows exactly how each one of their children um get to school they know who their car riders are they know who their walkers are they know who their bus riders are um and so those folks will be the folks um who have the context um and the connection that will allow them um to be able to figure those things out specifically because um the answer to that question is going to to in terms of how we provide that family with the support they need um to get their child to school is going to be completely

051tied up in what the support is that that family needs to get to school and it may very well be different for every individual right and so part of what we'll want to do is have our administrators be in a position to ask you know the right questions um and we are working on a protocol that we would we will share with administrators um to make sure that they have um that they ask the right questions in order to know what those families needs needs need um and then you know from my perspective there'll be an opportunity and a need for us to work in a in a bit of a dual fashion right um you know perfect example there there might be a a child whose family cannot get him or her um to

052school and is in that space that child needs a ride to school well that principal is going to know that there's another family whose child um is driven to school by the parent who might even be available uh to stop by and pick that child up on a daily basis if those families can partner together but it's the people who work in the school on a daily basis who know those families that are going to know that information they're also going to have the relationships with both sets of families that will allow them to make those introductions and to facilitate those kinds of connections at the same time you know we're going to ask our principles to communicate with us at Transportation as well as in student services to share when we identify a family

053who really has specific needs and and that'll be the point at which we start to identify the different services that are available from around the community that we might be able to partner um with that particular family so I think it's important to note that you know addressing the these issues is going to require very spe specific personalized information um you know that it would just be impossible for us to to point to very broadly um but will need to be addressed on an individual idual family by Family basis um and and our our help our plan you know my at least thought about what that protocol will look like is that it will start with conversations and end with the appeals process right meaning the idea will be that our administrators will work both

054as individuals and with the collective um sources and resources within the community to help families through a whole plethora of options before we get to the place where we need to go through that appeals process with the Hope um that working as a community we can address that need um for that family or you know with that family um thank you so much Dr King I actually have a um couple of um follow-ups to that to some of what you just shared um I was um I've heard from different schools that part of the challenge right now with um connecting the volunteers with the families that need the support for car pooling like or like walking groups or things like that is that administrators don't feel comfortable sharing the names and contact information for those

055who need support um citing liability issues can which makes it very difficult for those who want to help to help um than they're left with just being able to like kind of put out messages on list serves I've been told also that when they tried to distribute flyers in classrooms that that was stopped because that was also a liability issue seen as like the district taking too much responsibility for like carpool coordination can you speak a little bit to like where that line where that line is and how given the constraints how are families or community members supposed to be able to support their neighbors oh so I'm going to take a a a small swing at that and then toss it to Dr Giovani um but but what I want to share is this

056I think we we want to differentiate between this kind of broadscale sharing of information people's personalized information um in in a way that might suggest say there's a group that says they would like to support a family you know I would not support giving a list of the names of students who need rides right that that's too broad um but if I am the principal of the school and Johnny's mother comes to me and says you know this is what I need and I know that there is an organization or an agency that is available to provide that information then Johnny's you know mother then has the the ability to give me uh the kind of clearance that I and permission that I need to share their specific information with that community group or or

057organization understanding that that's the purpose of that sharing that's particularly different than doing this kind of broad based sharing um of information where we might be in a position where we give information to folks um that we haven't been authorized to to provide that having been said and and Dr Giovani can I'm sure will share that we talked about some of those issues today in cabinet in terms of where that liability lies and and I'm I'm I'm not ashamed to tell you that's something that we we went a few rounds about today um and and and we are working through you know as as quickly as we can much of this is new um and we're going to be plowing some some new Earth um as it relates to some of these questions and so

058um we we want to be as proactive as we can be but we also want to be careful um and make sure that we don't put families and students um or our Educators um in in situations that might you know have them feeling compromised in terms of you know stepping outside of the the appropriate bounds around um um sharing information with folks but but it speaks again to that point I was making about those personalized interactions right to the extent that we get to a place where we're able to have those you know we are in a much better place and a certainly a much safer place when it comes to sharing information if L Johnny's Mama tells me Dr King you can give my information to this person this agent see this organization that's

059a whole lot different than just passing out flyers and saying these are people who are who want to help or these are kids who need help if that makes sense yeah absolutely thank you um it sounds like then um more communication clear communication might be needed at the for school administrators to make sure that everybody's on the same page about what is allowed what's not allowed and how to facilitate that appropriately yeah so I think it's important to note just from a timing perspective we are at the front end of this work um not not Midway you not towards the end we we are at the front end of this work and so we are you know while transportation is working on their pieces um you know Dr Giovani is working on it from her

060from her side I'm beginning these conversations with principal supervisor so we're at the front end of the work there is much more communication um to come as we work through some of these questions uh thank you I Dr King I think he covered most of am I okay okay I'm sorry um I think Dr King did cover most of it and we did discuss it in cabinet and kind of where our operational lend is that principles already have like an extremely heavy load and an extremely difficult job and so what we have started conversations around today is continuing to flesh out those central office level supports so that it's basically just an easy handoff to principles for kind of facilitating those conversations right and so that's kind of what we talked about today and what

061that looks like I don't know I was unaware about people handing things out you know and like what that like just wasn't shared right and so I think as we kind of make it clearer that there's a central office person that is kind of the contact and can help facilitate those in the transportation department with our schools and principles that I think will ease that and assist with getting those resources to our families without overly burdening our already overworked principles I mean they just they really are um and so um I think what I would say is we're talking um Dr King um and Dr Lewis lead the principal meeting we have one Wednesday and kind of start having those conversations with them and it's a two-way street right I think it's presumptuous for me

062or anybody to say oh this is what principles need we need principles to tell us what it is that they need they know their families and their schools and so we're going to start that um conversation and really make sure we're providing the supports that our principles and schools need as well as our families so again I know it seems like a broken record but just kind of that patience piece but recognizing that we are in a crisis and that we do appreciate the urgency and the frustration in where our families are and wanting to know like what's how is my child going to get to school on January 22nd so um I think we can maybe have some additional information um depending on Dr Lewis's uh guidance after that principal's meeting maybe we'll have

063some some additional things to share and kind of have more of a maybe a timeline for when those packets and those supports for our principles and schools will be ready thank you so much um I think Miss Chavez do you have a follow-up question before we move forward yes thanks um just on this piece so um I wanted to know so a principal could share the name of an individual another say parent a who is offering to carp offering to help um and say organization might be a church it might be a whatever not you know nonprofit um they can share those and there's no liability on the district's behalf um because that's you know that's the whole thing we haven't vetted anyone who works for another organization or um parents have you know so

064I just want to be clear um that that's that's allowed right that is what we are doing it's similar to like when there's camps Etc right we share that information and just letting them know we haven't vetted them we haven't done that background check but we would be and kind of providing like a toolkit of resources for families um in those situations and there are spaces for like Dr King was saying if we can have a list like if there's a group of a family that's struggling right like has just been like there's no way you know I'm in I just cannot get my child to school Etc that we would then work with them in that toolkit and they could and again with Transportation central office supporting the schools and saying okay we're going

065to are you okay with us maybe sharing your information or vice versa right a two-way street so you know you want to make sure that not only are we handing somebody a flyer because people have different levels of comfort right and reaching out and different levels of comprehension and so making sure that it is a two-way street but that that they do understand that you know we're not saying you know that this person is safe necessarily but for you to be able to talk with them and say you know is this somebody that you as a parent you know have met with and vetted and are comfortable with they are offering this service so it I do think that that's you know really the only way and we are prepared and we do that you

066know for other things um in schools as well so as I indicated before you know and like King just said you know we're kind of at the front end of this you know we're all you know I just came up with this new saying that no one's ever heard before that we are building this plane as we fly it so um and but just wanting to make sure that you know nothing is off the table as far as making sure our students get to school you know but it needs to be safe and we do have to protect the district but we don't want to let that be a barrier you know like overly being overly cautious be a barrier to making sure that these resources our families have have access to these resources and

067our generous Community Partners who want to help have that um access as well um yeah I'm being told that we need to take a quick recess for it reasons do you have can what you're going to say um hold or would you like to make one more statement before okay okay so we will recess quickly e e e okay and we're back thank you all for your patience um uh board members anyone else have uh questions or comments to share Miss P so I just want to um start with gratitude Dr Lewis for you and your team for um indulging Us in this uh called meeting um I think we've just come out of the holiday season um staff were supposed to be getting a well-deserved break and I know that they've been working on

068this urgently um for us and for our families I appreciate the calls to equity from um colleagues I know that that is um unanimously shared by this board but also by your leadership team um and so I know that as you all are um continuing to lead us through this crisis um that you will continue to H bring that Focus um bring the individual attention that each and every family needs as we support our students um I'm glad to hear that the uh family responsibility zone maps will be um released and in a more transparent way I think after the last press coverage there was so much misinformation shared that it's important to me that as much as possible we try to um bring Clarity to what we are doing to address a a crisis

069that is not DPS created but is created by chronic underfunding by the state of North Carolina a labor market that has shifted post pandemic and um particularly wages that we are using local money to supplement when the state needs to raise uh driver pay needs to provide resources to districts across the the state of North Carolina and so I know as we draft our legislative agenda we'll be looking to you all for or um things that we can add that specifically address this that put the responsibility firmly where it is um with the state of North Carolina um I look forward to um as we move forward seeing I hope attendance data or or some type of here's how many of our students that are bus riders that we were able to transport and I'm

070I'm hoping that the re rotational service is actually leading to improvements as we move towards longer term Solutions I appreciate you continuing to reiterate that um you know 100% Staffing and actually overstaffing is where we aspire to be as quickly as possible um but as we work with um the state you know one thing that we heard last time was there's a significant delay in in getting drivers licensed once we are piloting this program in Durham right to um train our own drivers to get them their own CDLs and the licensure that they need we're waiting waiting waiting tick tock tick tock the state could help us with that and so ways that we can Advocate our community can advocate for that I think would be helpful you all have prioritized with an equity lens

071you've prioritized mckenny vento students you've prioritized um students with exceptional needs and so I know you will continue to do that in the planning going forward um I wanted to thank Mr Palmer for being online and the attention he's paid to all of our questions that came late frankly um people were concerned that materials weren't posted our questions were coming late um all through the weekend I think and even um today um I want to thank Miss Brookshire and Miss fulwood who is here who are um really leading incredibly comple work as as we transport and work to transport every student as as um efficiently and and thoughtfully as possible and safely um I think um the maps coming forward I think more information coming about the family responsibility zones I was noticing that a

072lot of people's emails were coming with concerns but perhaps they just need more information they need to know that that my child's bus will be at this high school at Northern at 8:00 in the morning and that's where I can pick them up at 4:30 right they need the details of where Express stops right I'm missing I'm I'm mixing my two strategies here sorry but um I think as further details are shared with families they will have more clarity about how it will impact their their uh family directly and so I think that information coming forward will be will be helpful um these are these are impossibly difficult decisions to make but I also want you all and your team to be empowered to move forward as aggressively as you need to I I've never

073been convinced that the Board needs to weigh on on these I think you all are are authorized and empowered to do um whatever is needed um to move this through us through this crisis as quickly as possible um I did note language Equity concerns I was glad to see we had % responden is in Spanish to the survey but um hope that there's work that we can do to continue to reach out and engage in in that community and I know often that's not an email but maybe it's a WhatsApp maybe it's a trusted um Community member that they may engage with more directly um I uh look forward to hearing more as you all continue to bring plans of of just lessons from our drivers and what would make retention and and uplifting their

074profession um and their longevity um assured and their a desire to work in Durham I think North Carolina has worked by poaching drivers from other districts for a very long time um a lot of districts used our covid federal money which is now evaporated to um beg borrow and steal bus drivers um and so that money has clearly ended that ability to pay sub drivers a lot has has ended I think North Carolina needs a a a deep deep investment at the state level into this profession and um as you all are helping us craft ways that we can work on this strategy so that we not only address it this year get get 100% of students that need rides to school this this year um but that we over staff in in the coming

075years and um have have Personnel that that love working in Durham and um love working with our students specifically if they have needs for um if there are Behavior challenges that we have strategies for addressing um those issues and things that we hear from our drivers I think that's going to be critical um so I guess I've said a lot without asking a a lot of questions but I I do um consider our team to be um unanimous in our focus on on equity and and addressing this crisis urgently together and I'm just so appreciative that you've brought further information and that we'll have more on on Thursday as we continue to move forward um centering students always centering students so thank you um thank you Miss buer um any other comments from anybody else

076before I make a couple yes Miss Chavez I just want to kind of come back to this um I I have I noted that we had received the most messages with concerns about ex Express stops I have the most ex concerns about Express stops um the the super Vision issue seems significant um I think Mr Palmer what you said was like if supervision is an issue for children the parent should wait until the like drop off like last drop off point if I heard that correctly but I would say all all of the children should be supervised I know some students might have more um tendencies to you know act up or whatever but um but also I'm just concerned about the roll out of that part um also um my understanding is um there

077are no or let me back up a number of people have asked if they're about walkable um roots to the express stops if they would be walkable and I was under the impression that a lot of our middle school and high school um areas are maybe not walk as walkable I mean they might be from some areas um but uh maybe don't have as great uh a zone that would be walkable compared to the elementary schools where we're implementing Family Express stop or family now I'm mixing family responsibility zones um so I just want to note that that's where I'm at right now with the express stops um I know we asked for um I forget the exact language but like more of a plan around like with Family Resources like how this would look

078um but there I I'm very concerned about the effect of this implementing this if um you know if it had if it will have a a drastic it kind of impact on who applies um you know in the lottery as it's open right now this month so I just wanted to note that and if you want to respond to any of that be great uh Dr web thank you um one of your points M JIS thank you for all that very well said um just spoke with Miss Brookshire uh for the um Express stops the priority there was to get stops near where the children lived um school's closest to it so the the the walkability the suitability for walk zones or that type of thing was not the priority it was to get them

079as close to where the children were as possible so I mean it it there was no uh conscientious effort to choose sites with sidewalks it was what is the closest as the crow flies destination to hop on an exp us to go to your your school but your point was well made just wanted to share that we we do know that answer um okay um I really appreciate uh the comments from all my colleagues this evening both the um the gratitude that was expressed by Miss buer and the questions and concerns from Miss Harold Goff and Miss Chavez and would Echo all of that and then I so I only have a couple other things to add I think um things I wanted to clarify further um the first is again going back to this

080we keep calling it appeals but basically like what happens when somebody has no other way to get to school and this could we've talked about it in the context of family responsibility but it could be maybe for Express Stop too I don't know and I guess I've Dr King you said um you're working on protocols that would enable them to ask the right questions the administrators to assess a family's needs um I'm wondering in your mind does that mean that and then I was looking at policy 6322 indicating that the um parents Guardians can request bus services these go to the principal and then it continues to say could be forwarded to the superintendent design if denied by them right go to the board so could there be a process whereby a principal could approve

081or the or the principal could then forward the the request for bus service to Transportation as you noted earlier we don't want them all to be going to the board I'd like this and as we've said before we want this to be clear transparent easy for I don't just want like somebody doesn't have a way to get to school so we reach out to a community entity I want a process whereby the district can approve bus service for that family if they don't have another way to get to school and do it without that family jumping through a bunch of Hoops or needing some special does that all make sense sorry that's a lot to say to say could you please clarify uh so it it makes sense uh um I'm a little wary though

082because I I would not want to it seems to me that if the purpose of the process in the policy is for transportation to be approved at some point I don't know that we would want to put a process in place that would allow someone at the school level to make that approval short of the board's decision um because that that that feels like it puts a a a building level person um in a pretty difficult spot in that they have to be the person to say um yes or no I think right now the way at least I Envision this process is that the staff members at the school would be in positions to try to facilitate connections that make things work for families rather than being the heavy who have to say I

083know that you have a difficult situation um but you can have this or you can't have that um you know at at at at at risk of of sounding Tred a little bit I I think we would want to reserve that kind of heavy handed um response um for for the folks who are elected to do that rather than putting our principles in that space now certainly would be glad to hear the the the will of the board as it relates to that um but if if I'm if I'm honest I I do feel like that might be a little bit of a difficult circumstance to put uh building level administrators in yes absolutely totally agree and it's my preference as a single board member that not all of these requests go to the board

084and so what is the like can the school administrators be the facilitator and then that go to Transportation whereby there's a process to assess the hardship or the need and then it can get approved prior to and as a called design of the superintendent or something like that and I don't know if there's an appetite it sounded like my colleagues were interested in something similar but I'm not certain so I I think I better study the policy a little bit closer before I get that deep into it I but I mean I think we certainly I think our goal would be the same as yours our our whole purpose here is to you know as I Envision the process and as I've laid it out again you know the appeals process is all the way

085at the end of this process and and you know our our vision my vision for this is that we we will be you know working diligently with each family you know through numerous steps before we get to that place with the hope that we can find something that works for everybody um before we get to that point um I want I want to study the policy a little bit closer and and make sure that that that's something that can happen um but I certainly hear what what you're what you're what you're driving at and what what the board is suggesting there um M Chavez or M go um my thank you I understand um what you were saying about um looking for every option before it comes to the appeals process I'm thinking about this

086also as a solution you know for the long-term solution about ridership in general um and thinking about how what is the process of identifying those families that should get priority writers ship um over other families that would be willing you know to who who say I can do this I don't need that writers ship that's the part of it that's a little bit um muddy for me I just want to make sure that with that as we as we're you know wearing our Equity lens that there is a process for prioritizing those families that absolutely you know for whatever circumstance would not be able to um to ride the so if they go through the principle and things like that when they get to that process it's more than just um their appealing for the

087ride but what is that process if it is you know because then that could affect the numbers and the writers ship and everything else and it could help with uh the buses that are available so as we're thinking about what that appeal process looks like um how does how does what is the process for making sure that you know those rather than you know even if we can find maybe there is another solution like you can do this um carpool or you know this organization or we can they make these connections how how do we also you know identify you know if we're going to you know as we're tightening up these are the families that really need the rides let's make sure they get on a bus and then all the other things are

088for everybody you know who doesn't necessarily have to have it so that's the kind of appeal process that I'm thinking about because and sometimes I don't feel like some of those families may you know again there's a a relationship trust issue where they might not be willing to just go through the principle or you know is there a process if they don't want to share all that information with their Community for whatever reason is there a process for them to still be able to get there um formally to make their own personal appeal you know of why they should be able to I feel like somehow that that in addition to the um that in addition to the work that we're doing to identify families that were would give up their bus seats could could

089bring some balance to well you know I think that's something that we can work through and think through part part of the the the one challenge you know that I see with that is um you know we talked about putting staff in certain kinds of difficult positions I also don't want to put staff in positions where where they are um in a scenario where they are essentially overriding um board policy at the school level um because that that becomes you know a kind of difficult space too um for for for our building level administrators and you know again that that's one of the reasons why generally these kinds of processes um end at a board appeal because it's the board's policy and so in gen as a general rule when we start talking about a

090scenario where we're going to operate outside of the board's policy we don't want to put a create a scenario where either building level or District level employees make that decision right um because that's that's difficult for us I agree yeah um so I think we'll we we'll want to keep you know that concern in mind but but find a way to really you know stradle that line um because you know we don't want to set a precedent you know even in this scenario I think that District level staff building level staff somehow have the authority to circumvent what the board's policy has laid down um we want to save that kind of decision for you all to make um to the extent that we can um and I I hope that doesn't sound like I'm

091I'm dancing um but that's a that's a that's a that's a little bit of a slippery slope I think um yeah I I I think it's if it if it needs to come to the board I I think that that is important I'm just I'm looking for ways to to Really to even if we can accommodate a family that really needs that support absolutely I'm I'm looking for ways to give those families priority seating and then also ways for other families to be able to identify themselves as you know I can give up this seat you know I don't really need it I think I think I'm I feel confident saying and um Dr leis hadn't kicked me under the table yet I feel confident saying we will approach each of these approaches each of

092these situations with that as the mindset while also trying to leave ourselves short of crossing over that line um of stepping into the space uh where where the board ought to reside M Chavez oh what I'm I want to comment on this policy and how I'm thinking about it now from this conversation is that if a family says I need Transportation I'm in a family responsibility Zone but I really um I don't feel my child is a kindergartener they you know I don't feel safe with them walking to school or what have you um and I rely on bus service because of these you know factors um with our household would it be that they would be presented an option to either access the Community Resources whether that's individual families carpool connection you know family

093in you know um connections there or an organization or that's one box or they say I want I I don't trust people like that I want to ride them to ride the school bus and that's the only way I want them to get to school because I want that's what that's what I choose so then they're offered the appeals process I'm just thinking of a chart in my head of what we're offering them first that's what this conversation has brought up for me um I think there will be a lot of there already are a lot of um you know informal networks at are schools where parents rely on each other um and you know some schools have more robust uh ptas than others um but I I think not that that's everything but you

094know there are other networks too in any case um but there anyway are we I think it' be helpful to know are they offered kind of those two things the Community Resources and then also the appeals process um or are we saying that we're really gonna you know try to steer them toward the Community Resources first and then if that's as a last resort the appeals process now the other thing as I'm looking at the policy thank you Miss car for directing us to the language of the policy the way I read it is that um if a if someone a parent applies for bus service the request should be made to the principal but then the principal or other designated officials shall forward the application to the superintendent or design so I was reading

095it as the principal would not make the decision it would be the superintendent or design um and I think that what you know I would invite others to share their thoughts on this we might want to strengthen this policy because what it says is that um the superintendent or designity shall consider applications for transportation services in the following situations one when factors are present they may endanger the safety of students walking to the school two when the student is medically certified as temporarily incapacitated so the second one is more clear and like documented um the first is not as clear what how we would determine that because somebody could say your student is a fifth grader they're safe walking to school they don't have to cross any major roads their sidewalks the whole way but

096the parent says no that's not safe for them for these reasons you know um so I think and the hardship is not if I'm reading this correctly is not in this so the word hardship and we've had a conversation about you know what that means when we go to um our school transfer policy but in any case we I'm wondering if we want to strengthen this policy so it's very clear and there is sort of um uh some criteria by which we would prioritize to use your word students um who want bus service and um I also just want to um say that I share the energy around um asking people with privilege to continue to use that privilege as they as they can I appreciate that there it seems like there are many people

097who are doing that who are trying to say I can do these things um I have the time you know all the resources I can help um but I think that continue that has to continue um to be to be an ask because we're things kind of have to balance out out um at some point so thank you Miss Chavez I think Dr Webb you had something you wanted to share thank you ma'am uh to one point m is that specifically the the items you listed I don't see foresee a situation where there is a request where we would not offer the full pallet of what we can do at the school level and what we can accommodate some of what you're talking about happens on a daily basis with our students needing to change

098routes uh today and our our our uh our team does a good job of making that decision without appealing it to the board they're if they if there a way to put a child on a bus they're going to do that uh Dr Lewis mentioned earlier if there's a bus that's close by that's already running can we get that child there's a room for them on that bus so there's a lot of options before we even get to any type of appeal process I would though in full uh just trying to be have the full picture um the reason we're doing we're having to do these things is because we don't have enough bus drivers and currently um so you know if we have to make very surgical decisions sometimes and with those appeals and

099we'll have to Define what that looks like moving forward but my point behind all this was to say there's a lot that can happen to accommodate families before it even gets to the appeal level specifically at the school level or even at the at the the transportation level as well yes Miss buer so um we've had a lot of um conversation about um Express stops and so I've been over here kind of looking at our neighbors and if I'm checking websites right I think Wake County already does Express stops I think Charlotte meinberg does Express stops I think Guilford does Express stops um I think all of them seem to do family responsibility zones that many of them are using a true 1.5 mile radius which is um State Statute and so I do want

100to acknowledge that I think um these strategies are are already being employed by by a lot of our counterparts in the state and have been for many many many years um it is stressful to think about doing them midyear in Durham as a as a crisis response but I do think um there is there is president for for districts having to to move to these strategies um in order to to um deal with the low Staffing levels that that we're facing um are we currently using Express stops for uh CTE pathway students um for for other programs within the district because I don't think we've talked about that but I think that I thought that we were m is that true Miss fulwood I don't know I want to put you on the spot um

101I thought that we were currently um utilizing that strategy not just for school for Creative Studies yes ma'am currently um CTE CTE students that are attending um a program that is not within their school district they go to their base school and are picked up so if a student is attending Northern but they live in the southern district they have to go to Southern to catch a bus um to their to their school and then I mean our Hillside has their um IB program we provide a bus stop if that stop is already a stop in place for our IB students thank you so much I amum I think making sure that we're clear about what what we're already doing how it's working and how we're able to keep students safe while doing that is

102is helpful to to reassure folks that that this can be done well and um efficiently and safely for for students and families um none of these changes are are easy to to contemplate they really aren't and and particularly changes that we in Durham we love to give people a long time window to know that changes are coming like we did it when we changed start times we we gave folks 18 months Dr Lewis which is really unheard of but we wanted people to know was coming and so having to make these decisions in crisis is is really um extra challenging for our families um and so you hear that and I think in a lot of our questions about how we can be as gentle as possible with families and these changes um but if

103we could get to 100% of students that need to get to school within weeks rather than months I mean I think that's our shared goal um thank you thank you Miss ber um some of my other questions were um along the lines of what um missp you shared earlier about how we're hearing a lot from folks about Express stops but it feels like some of it's just because they there's not been a lot of information out there so there's where there's where things feel like a black box it feels scary sometimes right so I was wondering I'm hoping that we could flesh that out a little bit more soon um as I was thinking through this I was remembering and I wanted to just clarify that I thought it was stated that the drop off

104time would be 7:15 to 7:45 maybe some of these are still in conversation and not just fully decided yet but I'm I was remembering 75 to 745 and they would be at middle and high schools in someone's growing together region is that what has been shared is that true did I imagine that and if that's not true what is the case like what can be said about drop off times when windows and where these stops might be um relatedly I think the communication that came out to families via email on December 20th said that parents need caregivers need to stay with their student um so would that mean they just hang out for that half hour window then or what's the vision for how this works Mr Palmer are you still with us I am

105indeed Dr web thank you and um thank you Miss ca auton for the question uh there'll be several respondents on it myself as well as Miss fullwood let me give a high level and then Annie if you're available provide additional details if helpful um the I want to reset the board and the community that our start times for middle and high school are at um again right in that 820 to 8:30 window for middle and for high school at 9 15 the benefit of Staggering drop off times at the 7:15 to 7:45 window again miss C on to your point we want to be precise with that uh so that families that are utilizing the service and students arriving at these Express hubs whether they are driven by a family member take the god Durham

106Bus and many of these sites are God durum eligible uh I know Miss Brookshire is with us as well there's other colleagues that are working with Gham on Transit alignment um accessing those Express Hub stops wherein as Miss fullwood pointed out we're doing for CTE and Creative Studies currently and carrying them into the Final Destination whether that's DSA Rogers her or Creative Studies um that is about an hour in advance of the bell time itself which is intended to stagger any sort of traffic concerns there um again on the on the other side of it uh we have a bell time release at the 320 to 330 window for middle school with an understanding that those Express buses are arriving at middle and high schools on the back end typically a 15 to 20 minute

107service window so to clarify that again or just to sort of reboot it there I think Miss C you were asking about possibly any concerns about traffic mode conflicts particularly in that morning window um these Express stops are designed to stagger in an alternate fashion with the middle and high school bell times I think you can see with the high school one for example 7:30 for a locational jop when um High School arrival times are typically closer to that 8:45 to 9:00 window so we are intentional about understanding that currently Creative Studies has over a dozen Express stops uh and in those instances when we can stagger the times it reduces any stress or conflict uh for particularly for car riders so wanted to pause there and and ask Miss food any additional context Miss

108food that you wanted to add for Miss cartter Aon yes we try and strategically base the times for pickup when the buses would how long it would take that bus to leave their Elementary School to get to their um that Middle School stop and it would take about 15 to 20 minutes barring traffic so that's why those pickup times would be typically between 7:15 and 7:45 as to how long it would take for them to get to their location after they have let their students off of the bus and been released to start their next run which is typically about the same time that it would happen anyway if we were going to their homes is the buses are are expected to leave within 15 to 20 minutes of their departure time and most pickups

109start around 7:30 7:45 in the morning trying to get to their home addresses so we're hoping to have those buses sitting and waiting for the majority of the stops for parents to get there and that it would be a smooth transition okay that's very helpful so to um just to confirm so the as of now the pickup window you you all anticipate it being between 7:15 and 7:45 um in the morning for the express stops is that that's the anticipation but as we start working on the pairings and seeing how quickly we can get the buses to those areas you know some stops could go a little later but it just it takes that looking at how we move once we say okay this bus will be doing this then what's it going to be

110paired with so we have to make sure that once it's paired with the things other the runs how fast or how soon it can get to its location okay that makes sense so say I'm a parent of a student at Rogers her and I'm trying to plan when will I learn what my window what my drop off and pickup window is um and how large will that window be because again will they have to sit and wait with their student um which does feel different than um a pickup time in the morning from a bus where the student could walk walk to their bus stop and wait on their own so that's we're hoping after we have it all fleshed out is that the the wait time shouldn't be more than 15 to 20 minutes

111we're hoping for that but we won't be able to see that until we actually see that these routes are in place we have the stops in place and I have um a listing of the preliminary times of when these buses would get there but that's without um having done the extra work of where this bus will be coming from and making sure that that is a viable um bus to do that stop okay all right thank you so much I was um um to follow up to if um so so far families have been notified if they are going to if there is planning underway for them to have an Express stop is that right yes and then when will they be notified of where their Express Stop is and what time that that will

112the drop off and pickup is I'll need to speak with my team concerning that on when they would like to release release that information we like I said we have I have preliminary data um and I just want to make sure that before we put that data out that we you know that we've we've actually made sure that it is is you know the best data for the parents to be able to plan um they could see you know this information and there maybe some slight changes um after we've evaluated some of the distances that parents may have to travel um to get to those locations um we do know that we have some students that live a little further out from what their closest school would be so some of those items may need

113to be re-evaluated as to where their school pickup would be um and so those are things that we still need to flesh out but right now we do have a a sense of where everyone's stop would be according to how they're actually routed now okay um I appreciate that this feels like a an enormous task you all are undertaking right now I can see in your face it is um I and yeah I'm asking ask in because if I were a parent that was going to be affected by this it would take me a couple of weeks at least to be able to figure out how to make the changes I needed so um so I would need that information um but I also really appreciate that you're trying to make sure it's the right

114information that you're sharing so thank you [Music] um I think well also the I'm sure you all are also thinking about the logistics of like where the these I guess I'm wondering how this fits with current like um carpool patterns like will will the Express Stop be where the carpool drop off is at that school or does it just really vary by school depending on that the needs and the infrastructure that's there would vary by the infrastructure but the plan was to you utilize our bus parking lot um because that's the most room for parents to be able to come in and out and we'd have to look at each location and the leg itics of that um we're hoping to be there in a time frame where we won't have to compete with um

115existing car cues because we we should be in and out before those car cues actually begin in the afternoons we're hoping to be there right after those car cues should be gone because of the time frame that we're coming in okay all right thank you and then my last question um which I had um raised to you during in that uh recess briefly was I'm wondering if we could see the um distance from family's houses to their Express Stop um ideally as like a minimum a maximum like at a range and then a medium or a median and a mean something to help us understand the burden for families as I know yall are looking at that too but if the board could see that so that we just have a better sense for what

116we're giving a thumbs up to so I did put together a spreadsheet sheet um over the weekend I put together a spreadsheet for the individual schools but did not include the distance um I can rerun that report tonight and add the distance and provide a spreadsheet that shows those that preliminary data of those um projected distances um we already know looking at that that there are some distances that we'll need to look at and see if there's another school um we tried to to really concentrate on using middle school and high school but in some instances if there is a way to cut down the distance for a student that may be above um five miles and use a elementary school then we'll have to that those are the things that we have to consider

117thank you so much I really appreciate that colleagues oh I'm sorry Dr Webb M Madam Vice chair thank you um Mr Palmer I think has some insight to some of your questions so Mr Palmer thank you Dr Webb I think just some clarifying remarks uh with regards to the expectations and the ask of families um it it might be helpful to think of Express stops say just a a big bus stop if you will um so many families currently at the bus stops will wait with their students until the bus arrives at a neighborhood level even um we are not requiring families to wait for the bus as much as for families that may have a safety concern or otherwise you that is an option for families if they were to choose either being there

118you know until the bus arrives in the morning and or being there prior to the bus's arrival in the afternoon just wanted to clarify it's not a requirement as much as oftentimes in other uh Urban school systems that deploy Express tops that's a sort of ensuring that families understand that you know it's okay if you can't Mar it right when the bus is there that said um when you are there it expedites the amount of time that the students on another campus uh and accelerates overall the level of knowing if that's a concern for families so just wanted to to point that out that uh it's not a requirement but it is for families that have a a safety concern or otherwise around supervision that is an additional option to to be there um before

119and after school that is helpful so it is not a requirement that families stay with their students at an express bus stop but it is a option and maybe a preference right correct thank you okay thanks so much yes ma'am and I also wanted to clarify that that is a goal and what we've communicated with families is that we will um uh notify or communicate with families by uh by the end of this week regarding the express stops so that's the goal that transportation is working towards to finalize locations with the principles and to message families on stop time and place they've been doing a lot of U calisthenics with this over the last over the holidays and um working different scenarios so but that is the goal at this point you colleagues are there

120other questions or um comments you'd like to make yes Miss P so I I know that um we discussed this the last time but I think it would be helpful as we move forward for yall to let us know your recommendations and and the notion about weighing this end to rotational coverage at the time that we promised and and whether we're fully y'all feel fully ready to move forward with both of these strategies at this time I I think that's the that's the reassurance that would be helpful to me as um as yall have worked on this really incredibly complex work um knowing that some questions you will need to see how things roll forward and and adapt and adep you know but um that your level of confidence and the Readiness of of things

121to move forward I think um on Thursday would be continue to be helpful um as we move forward thank you um I agree with that so what you're asking for is for that to come Thursday in addition to I'm I trust it will because I think I think y'all are WR y'all are it sounds like in cabinet wrestling with the same questions that we're we're discussing tonight just the these logistical changes for families and making sure that we we are ready um as we can be um and I think another question that would be helpful for us to um talk more about I think on Thursday is when we if we move forward with both of these is are we saying we're going to be doing that for the remainder of this school year or

122is that saying like this is you know Miss heral goof kind of referenced this earlier like is this the new normal is that the plan um because I think those might be different things for the board to be considering like what we're doing for this year versus next and as we all know this is Lottery season so I think we need to be giving people very clear information about what to expect um next year very soon as they're making decisions about what schools they're able to attend and yes Dr Jon you you want that addressed on Thursday just kind of like long term I think we need to consult with like Dr Lewis and kind of determine that so just making sure you weren't wanting us I we're not prepared to answer that today no

123no Thursday okay thank you thank you yes Thursday that would be very helpful anything else from colleagues other requests for Thursday Miss bu no I I just as y'all are continuing to lead and frankly through crisis I think that could be a maybe answer like I don't know how much Clarity you will have I know you will hope to have more clarity but um yeah yeah I yeah thank you for for that and I as I alluded alluded to that at our earlier meeting is as we're looking at what has been referenced and these are band-aid and I've been I've stated these are Band-Aid um Solutions is that we are looking at longterm you know because I don't want to continue to to be reactionary you know terms of setting the system up and being

124proactive um yes there are some things that we are doing and will continue to do to address retention and Recruitment and if the bus driver shortage doesn't get better despite our efforts what have we done during this time during this crisis to set the system up for future success so yes we definitely will be able to share as families and I do recognize and understand the hardship in the middle of the year that we are are placing on on families and so as we're going through this we owe it to our our families to uh as you mentioned the magnet applications to and in just any families that are either contemplating on coming to durm public schools that they know that this is the transportation situation for next year and years to come so yes

125we definitely will be able to share um some long-term strategies and what we're thinking as we are grappling through this okay that sounds great anything else from Administration Dr giovan just wanted just and Advan understand that this is new and so today was the deadline to get the PowerPoint submitted and so it may be that there may be some delay in getting kind of a transportation to address some of your stuff from today and your requests for today but we will be working dilig to have that but I just want to note that it probably won't be up in maybe Wednesday maybe Thursday morning but we will have a PowerPoint for you so just want to be respectful I do appreciate I know families want see that you don't have some things in writing and

126so just wanted to put that out there for the board and the community thank you um any final words Dr Lewis before we close I know it had been it has been stated uh this evening I think it Bears repeating uh and that's appreciation for our transportation staff um you know learning about the special call meeting then coming back Friday um getting the questions midday some of the questions midday and trying to put answers to the questions in a presentation as well as today and they spent um about 75% of their day in cabinet meeting preparing for tonight and now uh we'll continue to prepare for Thursday um but I do want to again Echo those sentiments to our transportation team that's here and present and those that are working behind the scenes uh to

127make sure that um and I think it was stated today we all have the same goal in mind and that's to ensure that we are providing reliable transportation getting all of our students to school because their academics are hugely important to us and we have goals and it's difficult to be the premier and the best school district in the country if we can get kids to school and so please know um Community parents board that we are taking this very serious and uh want to come out on the other end um that much more successful so thank you all so much for your engagement this evening thank you um we will see everybody on Thursday for our work session and uh with that this meeting's adjourned for

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.