CorpusRecord 130279

Asheville City Board of Education Special Called Open Session 2/18/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Asheville City Schools
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Buncombe County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,765 words · about 66 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e equity and anti-racist policies for all students and staff to learn and Thrive we recognize that our positions come with power responsibility and public service for the entire ACS Community we will model our commitment to equity through our practices and decision during this meeting we invite a pause if harm has taken place a moment to name the harm and space to practice repair thank you um oh right on time Amy Ray um peepe is sick and at home and hopefully asleep and um is going to watch this recording later to catch up on what he missed and I have his permission to share some of his thoughts so he will not be with us tonight and otherwise we have a quorum um and so at this time I would take a motion to approve

002the agenda who Moved thank you George second thank you Lia can we approve by consensus any concerns thank you um just a quick note I don't think it will be relevant um I anticipate this taking no more than two hours if it does go past 7 I have to leave in re is taking over but don't know that we're going to come to that um and so at this time I turn it over to Maggie and Heidi right good evening everyone glad to see everyone here tonight um I actually want to take a u moment just to recognize Heidi um she was honored with the Lou Thompson um Award of Distinction and let me just read you a little bit about this award um it is to honor uh where is that leaders in the

003finance department that um are make substantial contributions to improve the organization and the school business and official um an official position profession um so Heidi was nominated and was selected for the Lou Thompson award and we got to go out and surprise her last week so we snuck out there completely surprised her we got to meet her daughter and some of her other colleagues um but this is a very prestigious award um and we are just thrilled that they recognized Heidi and um what your 34 years of working in school Finance thank you yay congratulations uh with that we'll get started on the budget build your confidence so you know you've got here um so first thing we're going to go over some historical information on the budget board members you have a printed copy

004you also have this um in your in drive if you want to bring this up the first couple slides um I'm going to spend some more time on the historical budget information I'm not really going to touch on unless you have specific questions um but what did I wanted to pull for this uh board to see is our enrollment and some staffing ratios so what I did is I pulled enrollment and Staffing numbers back to to 2019 which is preco and the first slide you'll see a light blue bar and that light blue bar is our in total enrollment um by here then you'll see a green line let's start with the ADM teacher so let's start with the green line um that is total oh wait yellow line admin ADM staff teacher ad remember

005what I did with those lines um at any rate I think I've got the labels mixed up there so the green line is total staff in the district and then the red line are just teachers and then the yellow line is non-teaching Staff those two got flipped um but what you'll see is this is the per student ratio so if you look at 2025 um our teaching our teacher ratio to students is for every student or for every 12 for 388,000 3 thou 3,823 students we have um 12 teachers 12.37 teachers um you'll see that the non-teacher ratio is lower and that our total ratio overall 5.7 um so just to give you some numbers on what our teacher ratios are and how they are now starting to align a little bit better with our

006student enrollment before you move forward I I just want to check on the language the if we just look at fy2 our total enrollment 3823 and the 12.37 is a ratio correct per student there are 12.37 adults of a certain category per teacher there are 12.37 students per teacher and so we think red is teacher yep I know red is teacher and the 10.74 that is non um staff or non-teaching staff so everyone else else and then the gold is all total staff together all adults so literally all adults who work got itre thank you so Maggie just to make sure I'm tracking if we look at 2019 through 2022 there were more non-teacher staff than teachers per pupil correct and so what we saw in 2022 was that flipped I just want to make

007sure I'm interpreting that corly between 2022 and 2023 that ratio flipped okay thank you okay and then the next slide is the same information but in the actual numbers so you'll see the um from the across the same span of time um you'll see the 722 that is the total number of Staff the 767 that is um teachers and then you'll see the 346 and that's nonteaching staff so everyone else other than teachers and the blue line is our average daily is our um enrollment um I'm not sure if this is the right time to ask this question but my my curiosity is if the black so we see in 2023 that the non-teaching staff eclipses the teaching staff in terms of numbers oh yep those flipped sorry no oh oh I think that's probably

008right yeah and my question is I'm guessing these are all the behavioral supports and mental health staff maybe that we've compared to the number of teachers you know what I mean no the it's everyone else teacher assistants psychologists principles the reason though that it flipped so at one point we had more teaching staff stud non teaching staff we had more non-teaching staff per ratio than teaching staff so the confusion is and I'm so sorry the first slide and the second slide and it's not not clear what's teachers and what's not teachers so if you could right the red line is just teachers classroom teachers the green line is total um non-teachers NTS not teachers non- teers are bigger than teachers the a that's total staff yellow is ADM per staff that's total staff it's not

009though because that's number of students per teacher thank you okay so my question is still exists which is if we look at the Historical enrollment Staffing numbers with the bar graph yep which doesn't have the different colored lines other than the blue one yep in I'm just curious and maybe this is beside the point but we have a we have an um non-teaching staff take over and become more numerous than the teaching staff in 2023 and it's and that is about the time we started really emphasizing mental health supports and behavioral supports and so I'm just curious if that's why I haven't looked to see which positions changed I was just looking at total numbers and we also have to keep in mind when the eser money came in yeah so honestly for a period

010of time no matter what we look at a lot of these numbers will be skewed uhuh because that was a lot of money that we wouldn't have had before or after so it is a trend line but there are some conditions within the trend line understood I just think it's interesting and I'm just guessing that that's maybe why we all of a sudden have non-teaching staff getting higher but maybe not okay thank you all right um and then the next several slides our just some historical budget it's a three-year look back at the the year so FY 23 you'll see that it's Revenue it's broken out into a p chart so you can see of all the different funds and how we bring in um Revenue um how that is broken down by percent and

011fund and then the next page are the actual value numbers and then we've done the same with expense um so you can see the percent of expenditures by um is that category changes the first year the first year is done by object code so area but the last two years is done by purpose code like you get your budget amendments because we don't have the final numbers for fy2 yet so I'll update all those to be the same as FY 23 once we get those final numbers uh Maggie can I ask a question between the py graph and the next slide that has the actual numbers um most or a lot of these percentages aren't lining up for me so for example local Ela share says 33% no that's correct um Federal 7% I don't

012see that on the py graph is that ncdpi okay so you've just youve just rounded you've rounded okay can you quickly remind me in the chart fund to local Charter share is revenue but it's like we're a pass through so it comes to us and then goes back out the door both it's on both sides because we get funded and then we have to send it through yes ma'am right you can look through those or have questions um just for your of refreshing your memory on these past three years of budgeting um so budget calendar um for this upcoming year we are at the work session um our first work session today in March we'll continue with budget discussions um the first work session in April we'll have a more formalized budget presentation with more

013finalized numbers and better indicator indicators on on things that we're kind of guessing on now and you'll see some of that we're trying to make some best estimates um and then by April 21st we hopefully will have the board the budget request ready for approval um we may if it's not ready by them we may have to call a special meeting at some point to get that approved um we're still waiting on the official dates for when the budget presentations are for us to present to the county um but the numbers in red are dates that we have to meet per um law which is May 1st I have to submit a budget and a message um a budget request and a message to the from the Asheville City School Board to bunam County um

014and then the deadline for us to actually submit our official budget to the county is May 15th um we've got a hold date for our final budget approval and then July 1st is the deadline for bunam County Commissioners to complete action on the budget any questions about the calendar actually Maggie do you mind if we go back I'm looking at these this data as well again yep so for example fiscal year 23 budget expenses uh the largest category salaries infringe benefits at 7 73% but then if you go to f school year 24 uhhuh the largest is instructional at 65 so what's the difference and why are they not the same so that's what I said in the I have the FY 23 done by object code which I think is the way you would

015prefer um for tonight's presentation I didn't have time to update the FY 24 but and then FY 25 is obviously not ready yet by object code because we're still spending money um so once I had the FY 25 numbers I was going to go back and do the other two years for buy object code right now the 24 and 25 is presented like you see your budget amendment by purpose code instead since we have that information but if you would like some other reports I would be happy to provide those could you do just the quickest reminder object codes versus purpose codes and how they play and how they don't okay so for your budget when you go to approve the budget um all you have to do is approve at the 1,000 level the

016purpose code so that would be instruction support and sary services and then things like indirect cost so 5,000 6,000 7,000 8,000 the other segment of the budget code that we use the object codes are the ones that actually tell us what we spend the money on salaries benefits Contract Services supplies that type of thing so you don't actually approve the budget based on the object code you approve based on the purpose code and so right now obviously we have have a budget with purpose codes but we don't have all the object code detail yet because we're still spending money this year so I was going to wait until we had that complete and give you that information so it' be comparable to the FY 23 and I think I'm hearing you say that in general

017we have we prefer to see things in object code because then we're seeing where our money is going to spend on salaries you know but that when we make a budget we have to be looking at purpose right so that bucket called instructional Services includes more than just salaries but it's some people's salaries and it's other things too related to instructional services and by regulation whatever it is we have to start there and that's what we're required to approve and then in our work together you can you show it to us because we want to see it right more as the object codes yes thank you okay Hardy I am totally lost I'm not sure how many others are but I am lost uh which today budget this meeting right here which one should we

018look at which one should I be looking at in order to follow guys the pie charts are really just information just so you have just I'm looking at I'm looking at FY 25 budget overview is this the amount with the total amount that we are looking at right here that's the we budgeted so far this year and it's still subject to change yes sir so what are we okay all right so we're just giving you that as kind of background in order to move forward to next year's conversation all this history I can go like that I'm just saying that's just does this include the 700 and however much thousand dollar that the County Commissioners approved to clawback the last budget amendment I made that revision but I'm does this is reflected it is reflected

019thank you all right all right so um a great question that I know boards would like answered this time of year which I would love to oblige you but I really cannot um would be how much fun M do we have left to apply into our budget for next year so I just wanted to touch base again since the retreat um we gave you this spreadsheet uh during the retreat and just to let you know that that total at the bottom was how we ended last year really the only time you can measure fund balance exactly is when you close out a year so that is where we started um what we anticipate doing is is spending up to $4 million this year because we had three in there and then we had revised sales

020tax projections and then we had a cut from the county so again I hope it won't reach all the way to $4 million but uh the projections are that we just received in today from the county are not looking any better if if anything they're looking a little worse so I'm I'm just going to say I'm hopeful that we would not have to spend that much but it's possible that we would but if we do I just let to let you know going into next year you know we still have a solid foundation of a fund balance that we can use to try to meet the Gap we're going to talk about in just a few minutes um but now again we we all understand fund balance is onetime use savings so once we use

021it it is gone so um part of the drivers I just wanted to touch base on what we still don't know right now because like I say I'd love to answer that question I just really can't um out obviously the sales tax and property taxes um are more uncertain at this time of year normally we could make a decent projection but with the hurricane it it is really kind of all over the place right now um here it makes it a little bit more difficult to project salaries because we have so many hourly staff and then hourly staff not only get their hourly salaries but the supplement on top of that and that makes salaries a little harder to project but we do have a projection on those and we'll keep revising that um obviously

022we have four months left to go um we still have four months of spending and then we could have possible emergencies or whatever that come up and then for fun just for fun this year we have the insurance and FEMA uh issues to have to contend with which I hope knocking on all wood available but between the two of them we're going to come out pretty whole on what we've had to fix and repair and um the maintenance departments had to deal with um but obviously we don't know that 100% for sure at this time um and then for next year some of those same um uncertainties because I feel fairly sure based on what the county said and what I've read that the sales tax and property tax um uncertainties may go on for

023two three four five years we're not sure yet um it depends on how quickly everything recovers um obviously uncertain at this time is because not only impacts us directly but it impacts the county budget directly so whether there will or will not be any further adjustments to the local current expense appropriation or Capital funds we we don't know um obviously this is the start of the new bi anual budget season I I would just be so excited this year I don't really care when if we would just pass a budget in North Carolina um but we will see um that's still you know a lot of new folks are in office right now and we'll just have to see how that goes and then obviously I'm sure you've all been watching the very um um

024entertaining news coming out of Washington um at the moment uh so right now the word is that they intent is to get Congress to assist um the president and his special um employ employee thank you I was struggling with that um to um shut down the Department of Education but move the vital services that they actually handle right now to other areas um and there is not talk of actually aing all that funding that we received from them um largely just as a reminder in case you know you've lost track of what that that part of our budget is it was about 7% but it is almost and without Esser it's um a little under $10 million um but that does provide a lot of critical tutoring and support services and then large the biggest

025chunk is obviously for our exceptional Children's Program so um hopefully if that is all reorganized at least the money will not go away or go away significantly for a period of time um obviously the big number that drives Absol absolutely everything we do are the whatever the mandated raises and Fringe benefit increases will be um just a little heads up on that um right now there are meetings going on with the State Health Plan and um treasur fwell apparently did not do us a lot of favors um by only continuing to really ratchet up the employer side he left the employee side flat well at a time years ago when and raises didn't exist it was it was very politically favorable not to increase employee premiums and basically not only not give people a raise

026but increase their health insurance and really make them move backwards but we've been getting raises and for some reason they chose to leave the employee premiums stagnant and leave them almost the same so um what they're considering now is a salary based tiered um healthc care premium which at first I was like no no what what um right now the tiers don't look hugely significantly different than what we would pay now um but it is an increase for employees um but they don't I was worried when they said salary based you know we could have somebody paying $20 and someone else paying $220 but it really looks more like a 20 to $40 difference per tier that they're trying to establish and that part of that they hope is going to help balance the deficit

027in the State Health Plan fund now the the positive part of that for us on the budget side of things might be is if they apply that to employees for a year or two maybe our employer increases that impact the bottom line on the budget won't be quite as big because you know last year was the biggest one ever um which was several hundred dollar a person so um we'll just have to see where that comes out they're still meeting on that they're supposed to make some kind of final decision obviously feeding into the budget process so we'll hear more about that soon um and then obviously we just hope like always that we don't find a lot of new unfunded mandates in the course of the budget process for this year does anybody have

028any questions about that all right so just also a refresher for the board that we um have settled on a staffing allotment formula um and the Staffing allotment formula is in that First Column the second column is what are the company that we hired Cooperative strategies to give us a enrollment projections for this for the upcoming school year um but what I did is I looked at their projections I looked at our current enrollment and their survival ratios so as they studied our enrollment they were able to give us a very um accurate survival ratio which means you know what we see in a class of a 100 if a 100 fifth graders are in our elementary schools typically only 85 of those students attend our middle school but if 100 eth graders are at

029the middle school typically 138 nth graders show up so we have different ratios of um ups and downs and we're current currently always monitoring um new student enrollment as well so I'm updating these charts um on a regular basis so did just my best estimate of a projection kind of taking in what recommended in our current enrollment to do an adjusted projection um for next year and using that enrollment projection you see that we are um slated to go down several students uh next year but I felt that their enrollment projection for next year was significantly lower than I thought it might where we would actually end up so they re they enrollment projection was give putting us at 3,500 students just above that um because we were sitting at 3800 students um I felt

030like we're going to be closer to that 3700 Mark for next year so I've allocated those allotments across the district um based on the number of students at each school um so you can see those so one teacher for every 18 kindergarteners one teacher for every 16 first graders and so on down um through 12th grade those get divided up by schools at the elementary school we're able to we have to we have to round those so if a if a school earns 3.25 kindergarten teachers we've got to decide do they need four or do they need three kindergarten teachers so at the elementary schools we do have to make that decision um whether to round up or down typically if it's around 3.5 I round up if it's below I round down sometimes though

031knowing that some schools will get more students we may round up even if it's like 4.7 um so the next page are other positions that we've allotted um for our elementary enhancement teachers elective teachers for middle school counselors assistant principles and then our music teachers the third page of allotments shows per school allotments so for Ev at every school we allot a principal a student support specialist the middle school and um elementary schools get an instructional coach uh we have a digital Lead Teacher at every school elementary get a media specialist um high school and middle school I didn't put this on there they get two media Specialists per school well one at the high school because they share campus they've got two media Specialists and two at the middle school um elementary schools get

032a clinic worker all schools get a lot at a stellar sub and High School Middle School get an alloted um in school suspension teacher so there's other categories such as social workers um clerical staff that I didn't put on here but we do have some formulas that we use to a lot those positions as well any questions on Staffing as you can imagine as we Implement our staffing formula as enrollment goes down that is teaching positions that we have to matriculate out so just as we watch enrollment we adjust our staffing allotment based on those um we've done our staff intent to return forms so now what we're doing is looking at of the positions we have to reduce based on decreased enrollment what we're anticipating do we need to go ahead and not refill

033positions as they come open so that is a conversation now um and then looking at if enough teachers are not deciding to go somewhere else or retire we may have to make a decision again this year whether to reduce some positions question here when we uh reduce teachers position does it also include your office staff also no and and what I wanted to point out kind of back in um the Staffing allotments is the work of the central office and the work that happens in maintenance has to happen whether we have 400 you know 4,000 students or 10,000 students so there is an amount of work that needs to be done regardless of the number of students that we have so we can't reduce non-teaching staff Beyond a certain point so we do obviously look

034at do we need to do central office are we overstaffed but I do feel confident that this is not an overstaffed central office um oh wow I kept my microphone on that whole time we heard you surprise surprise um we that was also that was also confirmed by the consolidation study correct I just want to note that that they really um sort of strongly stated I think that our central office is not overstaffed thank you agreed yes I can tell you this office staff central office staff districtwide maintenance I mean they are all working every day all day extra hours on the weekends I couldn't ask them to do another task um okay so let's look at some of our Revenue projections I'm GNA let Heidi cover this slide well this this might have been

035more exciting before this year it's really not at the moment um it's going to be my recommendation if we don't get any better information from the county that we basically just budget flat Revenue until we get any other information um now that said that's flat compared to where I've already reduced it now um I did have to I highlighted that one line um because that's honestly one of the pieces that I need to make sure you understand that um in the past the supplemental sales tax that's deposited in fund a has has pretty much been expected to cover the local supplement that's where it was budgeted that it was always actually there was more collected than what the local supplement cost but with the increase in the local supplement the decrease in the sales tax

036and now the constant larger raises than had happened historically if if and I'm just right now the estimates that you're going to see in these slides estimates a 3% salary increase a 1% increase in retirement just as a starting place because we have no information um the cost of the local supplement will be up to almost $6.2 million next year and right now the expectation for this sales tax money is only about $ three and A5 million so in just that one line item we we could be significantly short in meeting the fund funding for that initiative so and I'm not saying that that has to be the only funding stream for that but I'm just saying as this district has moved forward that funding stream has covered that cost before and now that's not

037quite the same situation so when we start talking about where we're up and down as far as looking at the budget for next year basically the local supplement is costing it will begin costing us more and more right this year it's at if you see that line where I well I had originally calculated $1.2 million but then with the short fall in Revenue if we don't get more than $3.5 million for supplemental sales tax this year it'll cost us about $2.5 million of fund M to pay for that but next year it could be more it just it's a lot of these numbers are going to completely depend on how well that sales tax recovers this year Heidi can ask a followup question is this the first year that the local supplement isn't going to

038be covered by the supplemental sales tax actually last year was the first year if I cut off part I think you've got the whole slide in your um packet I cut it off so you could read it better here but last year um in 2324 because of the increase it went um in the negative $79,000 last year it's in red on a line near the bottom the second page of the smaller handout yeah mhm yeah so last year was the first year we had collected actually um let's see we collected $4.5 million and it cost $5.2 million to pay the supplement last year so up until last year it was kind of paying for what it was supposed to pay for and starting last year and now with these projections continuing thank you I'm sorry

039no no go ahead Jesse looking at this it goes from 2013 to 2024 which year do was um which year do you wish that we will start with with the amount I mean I'm looking at numbers but what is the amount that we need to start next year next school year what is the amount I mean there's no amount here on the on the do well we're we're going to get to more what we are actually going to need on a later slide I just wanted to talk to you about the things that are coming into the budget at the moment and we'll get to the actual total need for next year yes sir but I mean I really hope we get some better projections before the end of the year they they have assured

040us that they're going to continue to work on those each month now where they usually just give us one number and they're kind of done for the spring so I hope I hope we get some better news Ed I have a couple questions if you don't mind I want to make sure I'm tracking a few things and then I want to go back and ask about your comment about holding County funding flat so don't let me forget that one but am I interpreting this correctly that 2023 2024 the supplemental sales tax brought in about 4.5 million but we paid our local supplement which in my mind is our local funds that we use to pay salaries not covered by DPI and benefits so tell me what the is just your local salary supplement the amount

041you pay over and above the the N9 to 15% or whatever okay I wanted to make sure I was G thinking about the right thing but that costs us 5.2 million and so we saw this 79,000 deficit and then this current year they're predicting 3.5 4 million yet our local supplement went up to 5.7 thus both ends changed one question I have is if we looked at 2022 was the sales tax that much higher or was our local supplement that much lower or both both um I think I only have this back to 2223 the actual back to 2223 was a surplus of $200,000 so like I say first of all and and we talked about this some when we talked you know when we all talked as to you know what to increase the

042supplement if you were going to increase the supplement and that it's a percentage and a percentage is dangerous in that it it takes it out of your control what everyone else approves that we have to do so in the Years where we had 0% increase or half a percent increase or whatever that local supplement unless someone changed the category would stay the same or almost the same or manageably same sales tax growth historically here has especially in the last decade before this storm had been you know 2 to 10% so you know the the natural growth of the sales tax would cover those increases but so as a percentage if someone gets a 3% raise then they're not only getting the 3% raise but they're getting the 20% up to almost 20% now on top

043of that so it's like a double increase so that it's almost like an exponential and we increased it last year as well so I I that's really part of what I wanted to note is that when we increased local supplement that had an effect and decreasing sales tax and so that's going to have to be dealt with somewhere so I just wanted to make sure I was interpreting that right my second question is you said you're assuming the county is going to keep us flat but you took into account the loss of 4% correct right have they said anything that makes us think they're even going to give us that much like so that could be an overly optimistic projection starting place for next year oh they did say that okay but starting in that

044starting in the budget talks not to say that's where they'll end up okay meaning they would not start us back at where we were at the beginning of this year they're going to start at the cut level when they start working up their budgets and but they haven't understanding that we have to take the 4% cut into account but have they given any indication that there would be even further Cuts or not not yet they've not said either way okay thank you um on the next slide I wanted to I know it's a little small but we gave you the handout as well um so Dr Mackie did a good job of actually looking on the enrollment side and looking at staff tied to enrollment but where there's a disconnect sometimes is and it should

045be better now that I think I described to you in the last budget process how DPI started funding us in a so it is more our funding is more based on actually the numbers students we have in the building or slightly more so that that's good um so there's not as much disconnect but over the years there has not necessarily been a direct connection between how many students we have show up and how much we how many we get the money for so I just wanted to give you that history because I didn't know if you'd had it before and then looking back when we try to figure out I mean a lot of you were here for a lot of those years of budget conversations and when I look at some of the notes

046I I see notes that say Well if you know like to the county presentation if you'll give us these things we'll cut these things but a lot of times those cuts didn't really actually come to fruition um so even though we have a slight trend downtrend line with Staffing it's not nearly to the extent of how many students we've lost over the last 10 or 15 years so we have actually lost since 200 17 18 679 students so over that course of time that's really $5 million so when we look at the fact that we are very thankful that Esther grew our fund balance or helped us grow our fund balance by being able to you know leverage those funds had we not had them we would have had these more dire conversations about budget

047cuts we may need to make a lot sooner than we're having now um for next year the good news would be is that the rear did start last year and and like Dr Maggie said the projections are looking pretty good um for next year and we'll hope those hold so we're only losing from 3,900 students to 3,800 and 24 students in our funding so that's only a half a million dollars this year of State funding that we would be losing as opposed to what has been a lot bigger number so I that is going to be set in stone now how that impacts the local funding and our our relationship with bunkham County Schools the way the county money comes down might be another conversation but at least the state funding is only going to

048reflect that 76 student decrease this year okay I got one question yes sir it might be two or three after I finish um each Elementary can hold a different amount of students right this this at the end is the total amount that we project for 2425 correct is there a somewhere this is the funding summary not the one that Dr Maggie did on actual enrollment yes sir this is what we're being funded for right this page okay I guess I'm gonna have to go back and look at some of the other pages but is if I go back and look if I look and see Hall Fletcher how many students can Hall Fletcher hold as an elementary um we'd have to look that up in the capacity study and that would be for each and

049every Elementary also with the middle and also with the high yep so nowhere here I can see that no okay my question I'm I'm a little bit confused by this um chart and I apologize and I'm sure it's me but the top part we have two different groups in both of them say best one of two actual 24 to 25 so what's the difference so I see the numbers are different so right now what I did is I took the the top section is the best one of two that we got funded for this year okay and then moving all the grades up okay and then getting Dr Maggie's projections for kindergarten and Ninth Grade I wanted to be able to show that to you for the 3824 students we be funded for next year

050so it's really 2526 it will be 2526 funding based on the 2425 ADM best of one or two so that's what they're doing that's why they call it in rear so we'll actually be funded for next year based on the best of month Warner two count from this year which obviously was the month one by the way this year it's usually month two but we had like an obliterated month two so month one was much better this year so so 38 47 the total that's on the second column second I don't know whatever block mhm um is higher than so that would almost suggest an increase in enrollment but you're saying which is what Dr Maggie's numbers showed that's because it's in AAR and not prospective is that right right so they're they're continuing those

051trends when they when they're the ADM from the beginning of the year is usually always lower than the end of the year and then we're hoping that those enrollment projections actually hold and we don't lose more kids to the charters see that's the other part of the mix we never know is how many and then with the new Voucher Program how many students will we actually lose even though they've done all their due diligence and making those enrollment projections some of those unknowns are still going to come into effect here but overall this is good news for our state fundings and to build on that can I just check in to make sure I understand because I I remember you explaining the funding in AAR instead of these every year you get these projections where

052they use these wild formulas to project how many students will have and then if it's wrong they claw it back and so they're doing away with that which is great so this is this chart on the screen is to show us really how they're going to fund us whereas this chart that shows a projection of a loss of students is separate because this is really to show us they're going to fund US based on how many students we have now and then next year that'll be the number that they use to fund for the following year so this is showing a projection of more students here but not here so if it ends up that way I mean it it it is nice in the Years you get funded for more students than actually show

053up but we won't know that for some time yet okay and I guess the in terms of the schools and numbers the only Trend that I so with [Music] silsa the capacity is what I don't have that well they're capped at 90 okay per class per grade level so so looking at this though it looks like even under our best case scenario we're from 87 for the 12th grade down to 76 for 9th and 10th is that right am I understanding that right yeah rightor class but well here's the slide nobody's been waiting for um so um I'd like I'd like to bring better news and I still hope that some of this will bring better news at a later date but not at the moment so the best thing I can do for us

054today and you know I think I told you at one point in my old District the coo used to call me April wouldn't be so mean to me but the COO there called me the the bearer of Doom and Gloom um so right now um our we've got to go with the assumption that we may spend up to $4 million of fund balance this year so that is a cost to operate schools right now it's $4 million more than the revenue we took in so we also need to add to that the $500,000 in state funds that we just talked about that we'll be losing the $718 ,000 in local funds that it looks like we will be losing um the if there is a bright spot um when local Revenue goes down Charter Schools

055don't get as much money so unless we see a big increase to any of our local charter schools in numbers especially those ones that are in the city we should not have to budget nearly as big an increase in Charter School payments for next year as we have been having to budget so that I've just put in $50,000 as a placeholder at the moment and then we did talk the other night that if we go with C that there will be at least initially a loss in our school nutrition program that we would have to cover which we technically already have but I'm making sure we account for that now Heidi just a quick question I get the charter payments and school nutrition and the local current like the bottom three those are new like

056things we didn't have to deal with last year but the $4 million fund balance don't we always allocate like didn't we think we were going to use three like is it a true extra four million am I making any sense that sense well it depends on how you want to look at that so normally a budget should balance with revenue and expenses okay but we have a a gap okay understood but this could it we thought it was going to say three million like that wasn't a surprise so I that's I appreciate you pointing out the math of it but for our purposes it's not like this additional 4 million that we weren't counting on no but it is money us time and thank you and is no longer available yes yes absolutely you're correct

057I see where you're coming from now so um then on the other side every year um we just talked about local supplment a little bit that'll be about a $300,000 increase but until we know those Fringe benefit and salary increase rates we won't know but generally that number is very solid between either 1.2 and $1.5 million for the raise and the increase in Fringe Benefits unless we end up having fewer people employed and then obviously that number will decrease somewhat um for right now I just stuck $200 a person for the increase for the State Health Plan just because that's a rough average of what it's turned out to be um we do still have some utilities saying they may have an increase for next year and as you know we didn't really close the

058Montford building we repurposed it so that utility cost did not go away and then all of them are going up somewhat and then I honestly have no idea what to put in here as a placeholder for property insurance for next year but I don't think it's going to be good um so that this year I think if you remember I put a $75,000 increase in for last year I believe it was and then it came out to be a little less than 50 so we came out a little better off than the estimate but I'm just putting that in there basically as a conversation point so we're aware that I mean there is no way these insurance companies are not going to make some massive adjustments this year because their losses have been incredible so

059we just will hope we keep Insurance because some of the insurers are actually pulling out of a lot of the markets where they've had a lot of damage so um anyway that'll be something we'll see more about later so um where this number number was in the $5 million range this year obviously because of salary increases and all if we we've made a few budget cut adjustments that that could mitigate this somewhat but it it's not nearly to the extent that we need yet so um question does that mean that like so we did although we kept the Montford Building open the Randolph building open we also saved a lot of money in consolidating our middle schools and and in um other I can't I'm I just lost my train of thought but oh in

060not paying rent in a few places like we have moved all our staff to different places and now we have a a much smaller footprint in terms of where we're paying to house staff or students I assume that those savings were in last year's budget analysis and that's why these are increases for this year is that right well and at this point right now like I say we still don't know with four months remaining how much money we're going to spend so as we get a little bit closer I want to get better numbers for better numbers for you on what um the actual savings was for each of those positions because we had a lot as always Personnel com and go com and go come and go and I want to get those finalized

061and then hopefully better actually spending estimates closer to the end of the year so it one of the next budget presentations I want to bring you more detail on those line items on what we actually saved and speaking about the consolidation of the two middle schools is we didn't actually cut as much as we could have so we did eliminate some positions as teachers from mfort decided or Asheville Middle School decided that they you know found another place to work or decided to move to a different industry or town but we did allow other Staffing at the middle school last year which is going to have to come into realization this year or for next year sorry so we look at this slide um I'm like as we've talked about that four million in the

062fund balance has Revenue loss um I'm looking at this as like the real Doom and Gloom slide like you said you're the bearer of Doom and Gloom this is like a worst case right because like the idea that we're going to use four million in fund balance I think this 7.7 shortfall means that would mean we pay ourselves back fully to the fund balance in order that's what the 7.7 shortfall if we were to somehow make up the full 7.7 shortfall we would be paying our if we didn't want to spend any more fund balance next year this is what this is what it would take to have no fund balance plan for next year and I think I'm understanding to to get the fund balance back to the level it was no it would

063leave us where we are on that worksheet we would not use any more but we would not be back to where we were so the fund balance even with this 7.7 million shortfall we would see our fund balance shrink because we use it this year thank you um this slide is actually more um for discussion because I would like to know your feedback on some things you may want included when we get to the point of presenting this to Commissioners I have struggled ever since I got to North Carolina and trying to get County governments to understand who they're funding for some reason the county commissioner group and the public school Forum which has some wonderful reports but they don't include the Char schools correctly they either have them in part of the reports and

064not the other part and they aren't always Apples to Apples there there's apples to oranges so last year it was very obvious I was very optimistic that here it might be different because Sam is um riddle is a former bunk of County Schools employee but what they did is just what all the other counties seem to do is pull the information from their County Commissioner organization which does not include the charter school in a lot of their presentations so I came up with this graph which you know if you you you know from going to meetings they want to portray Lea ADM going like this across most of the state well when you add in the charter schools it's more like this and I feel like this does show that and I would like for

065them to visually see this and maybe that oh God I got stop that I got the Italian thing going tonight uh we talked with our hands you uh so um anyway so um the um the big change for us did come in the last couple of years and I try to make notes along the bottom as to notable things that happened in some of those years um so really if you look at the line AC the blue line across the top I mean since 201415 there hasn't been a lot of change countywide I mean it's and Bun's numbers are very similar to ours we're about 15% Charter now I think they're about 133% um but Grand totals you know these last couple years showed a good little bit of um loss in total but we

066also know that we had covid Co sent a lot of people to homeschool and other you know education options and so I really think over the course of this many years this is pretty consistent and I mean because most of the presentations that you see on the county levels really stress the fact that we need to be funding you all less because there's not as many kids here I mean and they they stick to that rhetoric over and over and over and it's not just here it's it's like Statewide everywhere and really if you've put all the groups of public school students together there has not been a material change and so there's not a a basis for making a material change in that local current expense appropriation can I can I just share an

067an observation just to speak it into the room um looking at slide 24 the ADM numbers um I just I noticed looking at the pattern of like the previous era where we were consistently losing ADM um which was 2006 to today it's a a loss of only 14 students and then the bottom our our bottom number for ADM was 3724 um and the the highest was 4503 which is a difference of 779 um and then to today it's a it's a decrease of 679 so I just so I mean you make a good point when you go back to what the size of this District originally was we really are about the same yeah there were just some high years in the middle which is what we seem to keep getting you know right and

068I I would be really curious to to see the just so we could compare apples to apples the the tax rates and all of the things that we figure into these calculations that are you know so much Doom and Gloom when it comes to our deficit and it's it's really not that different when you look at the raw numbers so yeah anyway um I have a question um on this Charter School slide I'm trying to understand it which is I I need a key to tell me what these colors are but oh sorry um so if you do present this put a key in there um so the blue is the charter school that's okay what's the gr the at the top it it's the grand is it not the grand total no it isn't

069the grand total the grand total is the two together I'll take that it's just excess okay so question um that I have though basic that I should know um I know that we have to Dole a p that we that the uh State funds pass through to the Charter School do the county funds also pass through to the Charter Schools okay okay so yeah so you heard your years ago that rhetoric the the money needs to follow the child so on the state level the state sends it directly to them actually we get you've seen that a lot M report I've given you with 20 or 30 different yes they get the average of all those added together divided by the number of students in the state they get the average let's say that costs

07065 let's say all our allotments together it's $6,500 a student they get $6,500 student basically put in PRC A36 they can spend out of one allotment with very few rules exactly the same money that we receive from the state but the flow through on the county the money has to come to us to send to them and that's what made some of the friction years ago between the two entities is that we got kind of caught in the middle of that whole process um but it's still the same appreciate apprciate that this I thank you I do appreciate that this slide shows if you're going to call sorry if if charter schools are public schools then this um graph shows that my only hesitation is that it also shows that we're losing students to Charter

071Schools um more students than we used to that there is a trend um in one particular direction on that but I do agree that you know it it certainly does show that like overall the number of students who are going to what what what legislators would characterize as public schools hasn't changed and I appreciate Liza's reflection that it also used to be you this may just be right sizing in some ways after a bubble during which a lot of people moved here and found themselves able to live within the city schools district and then less and less so over the last whatever it's been since 201 17 or 21 or whatever it was 17 yeah make more affordable housing and we'll have more students thank you so let's talk about a kind of the approach

072to our request to bunkham County and I wanted just to frame this with some context so the snap shot that you have here is for their fiscal year 25 which was based on their tax year 24 and their um tax rate or their millage rate of 52 cents 5235 cents per $100 of property value so that was the assessment done not including other like Woodfin has a separate assessment North bunam like there's other assessments this is just the general County fund um so you can kind of just keep that number of 5235 cents and if you look at a tax bill um what you see is it's all lumped into one payment so bunkham County tax on this um property the point um one the0 5176 and the amount um and then this properties in

073North bunam so they have that additional tax so just kind of keep that because I want to share what it looks like in other states in just a second so of all that money that comes into bunkham County they allocate 28% of that to schools so the total of that was um 126 million um give or take and bunkham County got 98 almost $99 million Asheville City and this was before the 4% reduction um and then our share of that was before that reduction was 18.3 but then I wanted to share for comparative purposes public school funding in other states and what you'll notice on this tax bill this comes from um a home outside of Atlanta not city of Atlanta um but a county um tax a county school um you'll see how they've

074broken out all the different taxing reasons so instead of just one lump sum they say here's how much we need for operations here's how much we need for hospitals and in Georgia the school scho districts can Levy their own tax so they say hey we need we know we're going to we need to increase Staffing we want to increase salary so we're going to Levy a tax for x amount and they levied here I think this is daab County um a millage rate of .0 2288 everyone following okay so my wondering is approaching our funding request to County a little bit differently this year now we know the state is supposed to fund Public Schools instruction operational expenses all those things um the county bar per Constitution um should fund our Capital expenses but we

075know from the Leandro case that that doesn't happen um and this pie graph that's on the left on the right side of this chart is in general for every single Public School District in Georgia 47% of their funds come from their local tax levy so we should expect that there should be a local tax that school districts should be expected to get from the local government and because we can't Levy the tax we should be asking the bunkham County government to Levy a tax on our behalf instead of thinking that we are cumbent and need to beg them for every penny that we we get because if we're going to fund public schools in a way that's going to be sustainable we need to say hey here's what we need you can fund through title

07639 or article 39 our Capital stuff that's great but here's what we need for operations because we know the state isn't funding us there so what I am asking is is the board have an appetite for asking the Commissioners to Levy a school tax um instead of saying hey we need $19 million this year but instead of saying that pull whatever proportion that we think we need for funding out of your general tax allotment and let us Levy our own tax or Levy that tax on our behalf so just thoughts of discussion because I just it's not the I just think it puts us at odds with the county um when they really should be letting hopefully it's some Point North Carolina will let school boards Levy their own tax and because we can't we

077should just ask the county to Levy that tax on our behalf so Maggie would the idea be on our bunkham County tax bill where it says a 0. 5176 county ratees in theory if we were saying I I just want to follow the logic not that this is a great example if we say we want um a point 0 2% tax if they wanted to keep it flat the county tax would drop to 049 we would get 0.02 taxpayers would pay the same right just for whatever it's worth I did the math at 0 5176 if we get 28% it's only .144 so I find that fascinating decator getting .22 that's a lot of money yep um and that's typical so the the millage rate in Georgia ranges and I looked it up the highest

078you can go is 23 um but some districts go as far down as like 0.9 so it does it fluctuates based on the need the other great thing about this this funding model is when taxes go when your property value goes up but your operation costs stay the same you can lower the tax rate so you actually can say hey here's how much we need and this is we can get this from X number of millage X millage rate so it can be more responsive um and also I think sheds more light on how much funding the city the county is collecting that actually is going directly to schools provides to me more transparency yeah so I wonder I appreciate this Maggie I think it's um there's a lot to digest here um and I'm

079thinking in terms of [Music] um how best to to put the narrative out there to taxpayers Across the county what their tax dollars go to um and I wonder if there's a baby step before asking them to give us a mill rate to say buam County would you consider breaking out your tax bill in a way that shows all taxpayers this is where your dollars are going as opposed to having to go through a bunam County website and try to dig through that um I'm not saying that I'm not saying don't ask for that that from the county but I think it's helpful for taxpayers to see you know to to Sarah's point 7 or whatever it was 0.17 going to school as oppos versus 022 or what or and so folks can see anyway

080I'm repeating myself now but that's my point Y no I that's a great a a good argument to help prove a case um you good um I love the I love the comparison of U setting these things out now I I think if I'm remembering my tax bill correctly though I just glance at it and then like cry but generally um it does set out our supplemental tax it does yes and that I think is a separate campaign to address well I guess what I was thinking is that um they already do that for us and why don't they do that for everybody so that's one thing but the other sort of counter the I mean just you know we all know this I think we've heard from some of the Commissioners over and over

081again about how much we get how much we are funded compared to um I mean the implication is that per pupil we are overfunded not under funded um and so I guess my my reason for noting that is that that to me is the Crux of sort of trying to counter that assertion why are we not overfunded and we can see our deficit and we can show all of that um and I think that the part of the key to that is going through in granular detail the allotment formulas how we are right sizing and making the point that right sizing takes time you can't just say oh we're going to chop our school district in half in terms of the physical plant or we're going to you know that all of these things take

082time and we are very deliberately and intentionally making these painful choices all with an eye toward being really outstanding stewards of the dollars that we have and so I think that has to come before this if that makes sense in a request which is let's show you what we have cut let's show you how we are working to right size and one of the more difficult conversations we may need to be having is anticipating what might be the ways we're going to continue to um make painful choices as a way of showing that we're good stewards because we do have because what they're going to have say in response is the consolidation study says you are under capacity in all of these schools that is what we are going to hear loudly and clearly and

083so if that's the case I think we need to um address that directly and how are we not going to be underc capacity I also want to say that as I've been really thinking about this and I don't I hope this is appropriate to say like as part of the budget context but I think it is that as I've been like mulling over elementary schools and what the consolidation study you know what just keeps coming back to me is that elementary schools in particular are pillars of a community that they are spaces where people play ball where they have Community dinners where they you know it is different I think than a high school or a middle school it is a it is just a place that when you close an elementary school or you

084choose to consolidate elementary schools you are depriving a community of a place in a space that they have previously enjoyed that doesn't mean it doesn't have to happen perhaps but it is something I'd like to say directly to the Commissioners when you talk about under capacity let's remember what El's capacity the capacity is it is a community building capacity in addition to a capacity of teaching a certain number of children every day who come into those schools and that that capacity may be just as critical to our community as the number of students who are coming in and out every day and I just I I've been um I've just been thinking about that as a as a way of countering the overarching what I think it's like we all see these reports and we

085see what we want to see in them and what I think some of them wanted to see or at least expected to see and did see was that we were under capacity but I think we need to be describing what that capacity is I hope that that makes sense um so I love this and I think it's going to receive a ton of blowback unless or even if but but that blowback will be lessened if we can really show that we are in good faith doing what they've asked us to do and that we can anticipate and let's think about where we can anticipate um some additional savings or whatever um as we were trying to really tighten it up thank you that was long sorry I wanted to just add that looking at this

086one of the things that feels like a it just feels like a game Cher for the conversation and one of the things I as I'm thinking about like why wasn't it this way what you know well this was never an elected board and I think it is an elected board now and if the county changes the narrative to we're we're willing to say the school boards tell us what you need and then we Levy the tax on your behalf we become the people if if County Commissioners are worried about not getting reelected because raising taxes makes you get not reelected we're asking to make that ours am I Incorrect and so I wonder if part of this narrative could include that we're putting our jobs on the line when we say so that and you

087can I know North Carolina might not consider that legal or you know like they can't just give up their responsibility but that maybe that's a way of helping people understand that in doing it this way and in demonstrating it on the bill where they can see like right now it's just a big pot and then who knows what the Commissioners are doing with it show it to everybody and and clarify and then if people are really mad about their taxes getting increased they don't have to vote us back in they don't have to vote for a school board that keeps raising their taxes right like that's the logic of it I do want to clarify that only a fifth of bunam County residents vote for the school board board and if we're saying for the

088that bunam County puts this across the entire the entire County that argument is a little you know isn't as isn't as strong but I see your point everybody well they vote for their own school board right I mean right but but could like what I guess that then begs the question would bunkham County School Board also have the same ask it would it would need I think it would work if it it would have to I mean I think it would it would be like kind of you get the enchilada or you don't I mean because they'd have to break down that bill all the way through and across um I love that Rebecca and oh darn what was I about to say um per pupil funding question we do keep hearing that the per

089pupil funding is so so High um does that Charter School chart start to answer that question in other words the chart that you had that shows that we our pupil per number of pupils hasn't gone down or does that still the per pupil funding is still okay thank you just to sort of piggyback on that um and the idea of demonstrating the implications in the future of con continuing to put the burden of right sizing our district on us um you know just looking at the the loss of students from the closure of an elementary school to the the newest Charter opening its stores was a loss of 90 students and you know that's that's considerable especially if we continue to have those types of conversations so have a quick thing to make sure I'm

090keeping two different things straight the idea posited here which I think would have to be in conjunction with bunkham County Schools is going to the county and saying instead of here's the number that we need we would I I don't want to get too In The Weeds on this but we'd come back and we'd say hypothetically we need 15 cents of what you're going to have okay and so I totally get that and we would ask for that in addition is our Ash City supplemental tax and should we choose to ask to go to the full 12 cents that remains an option to us also and I think I'm saying for today's purposes we may want to do both but being mindful that um those are two separate things both dependent on them permitting us

091to do it and and we just would be precise in our wording I think I just wanted to make sure I'm getting that straight yeah I think you know the levying tax on our behalf as a whole County I think is a big ask something that maybe not be next year but like George said like maybe there's a step to say here's how here's how we have kind of allocated the millage rate per different objects in their budget but I I 100% think we need to come in very strong and ask for the 12 the restoration of the 12 cent supplemental tax um i' have had a conversation with ACI they on board to help support with any public campaign um and I think I think just the conversations I've had with folks that live

092within the Asheville City School supplemental tax tax district there is support for that uh we just need to get the word out like we need yard signs that say I give my two cents to Asheville City Schools right make sure they know come to the commissioner meetings tell them let your voice be heard right not a full two cents but you know it's catchy we get it well and then so I want to make sure that so I'm hearing that there's sort of two conversations happening immediately we're going to advocate for people to give their two cents because that's that is our Asheville City School supplemental tax and then as a long-term approach we could be collaborating with bunkham County Commissioners and bunam County Schools board exactly what we want to be doing to start

093a conversation about changing the narrative about taxes because we do get in this over and over again every year we look like we're hat in hand they feel frustrated that we're not better with our money and that it's not getting us anywhere it's certainly not the collaboration I think that we're all envisioning I'm very appreciative for like oh it's a very different way of thinking about it and they may find they really like the idea of us being accountable when we want taxes raised to our voters as opposed to them being the only ones accountable but that's a longer term and that would I would like to see that apply the 12 cents we're going to shoot for that and that's just going to be there and then it's maxed out and this is separate

094from that that we do in collaboration with bunam County yeah thank you how much does that two cents or not quite two cents get us right right now the uh estimates about1 and A5 million dollar but the um I asked for an update today but the assessor first of all there's an interim assessor bless them in the middle of this mess trying to get make sense of all these numbers and then on top of that you know it is a it was a very normally time consuming project this year even more so so they normally would have that new calculator out to us by the middle of March they said it might be closer to the end of March but it it basically just takes that rate times the new assessment and that's what we

095really need to know is what that new assessment is going to be so um right now it's a little over one and a half million and I think to this discussion part of what that could help if both School boards are on on board with this is and part of the reason you all advocate for that change in the from the 10.62 to 12 last year is that would address our need we had this need and that would directly address our need when the county adds two cents on top of the entire County's budget they can carve that out however they wish and part of the reason they carved it out year before last was because they had a salary study in bunam County schools had a salary stud and they they agreed to honor

096that well then depending on what their population is and our population is and the population of each of ours in all the charter schools is how that's actually broken out and what we end up getting so we may need $2 million we may get one and a half or we make it two and a half it just depends on how that formula works so if in this bill each individual need could be broken out then it is going to be much more clear what we've asked for and what it is that we need and whether whether we got that or not I think I mean it it it I'm like her it comes very odd to me that North Carolina works this way because all the districts I worked in in South Carolina were physically

097independent and there's like 20 line item was broken out on the property tax bill and the school board every year made a decision how much money do we need to operate you turned that dollar amount into the county they would get the current assessment numbers and they would apply that millage once everything was turned in and and you were account I also like that this speaks in a certain way to the conversation we started with bunkham County last year about is there a way to move Beyond a year-over-year request and thought thinking more long term about multi-year requests and yeah yeah it really it changes the decision making like it I mean and kind of what Rebecca said is it you know the school board has more local control over your finances and therefore changes

098the tenor of conversations with bunkham County Commissioners it has the possibility to because right now we're asking for an amount of money I mean if that millage rate is on there and by just like we talked about sales tax normally has a natural growth factor assessment has a natural growth factor so it might be that that millage rate could stay the same for 100 years but the assessment is gradually going up to cover all our increased costs and then there is a lot less of that feeling like you're always having to I'm sorry beg for everything that you really need and we really shouldn't and then when I was thinking back to working in another state where it's you're not begging your County Commissioners for this this is every school board in America almost except

099for North Carolina I think is maybe the one of maybe one other or two states where school boards can't Levy their own tax I just want to say thank you for your creative thinking really appreciate it we'll see where it gets us well it may not you know it may not but this year but it's the C you plan it's consistent I think I'm I'm back on the ash supplemental tax I'm the going to 12 cents 90 years ago the taxpayers of Ash City School said yes you can Levy this tax and then the County Commissioners I mean I understand they had reasons but they lowered it and I feel like it's really appropriate for us to say we want back what the taxpayers ask for we're all elected this is on us I mean

100it why that has to still be this tension between us when it seems pretty easy the voters wanted it we just put us back where and you won't have to hear from us again on this but um Maggie you always close conversations like this with um uh like requests and so I'm assuming that that would be part of this conversation as well so um I have a few requests so um one thing is that like Heidi saying like the possibility of showing that that graph that um with show in charter schools when we present to the county um I I'm curious from the rest of the board would it do you think it would be helpful for in that presentation bless you um to also present what the state allocations are to a school district

101because I don't know if bun County Commissioners have a full idea of the how the allocations work because we always talk about per pupil dollars but the state allocation isn't all based on per pupil you know and so could it be helpful to have that be a part of the conversation when we % like we get you know for every 500 kids we get one principal whatever I can't remember all those but there are so many um and some of them have not kept up with the way that schools have changed you know and again I'm just asking the board what do you think that could be helpful as a presentation tool I'd like to also throw in the um implications of the um executive branches reductions and how that would impact us as well

102I'll just respond that I think George to George's question that I think that would be helpful es I mean how much detail you go into is a separate question but I think for example when we look at the the assistant principles is a great a great example like I'm sorry but there's not any commissioner who's ever had a child in Asheville City schools that would say their school their child's school should not have an assistant principal there's just nobody that would say that and nobody that has had kids in the schools in the last you know 15 years would say that like Asheville middle school or Asheville City uh High School shouldn't have one per grade um but anyway that kind of sort of take the best examples of what the state does not fund

103and illuminate that um another request I'm sorry I'm feel like I'm Domin in this portion but I appreciate youall humoring me um when we think about any of these um considerations that we're asking in the county whether it be um the give your two cents Ashville City Schools or whether it be to break out the tax bill in a certain way um or eventually get our own millage rate um I my request is that we really I mean you said it yourself like how do you sell that right how do you get that narrative out in the community um way ways that we can I almost think of it as a marketing plan right um and what that plan would be in terms of not only our own social media and yard signs and all

104that but how we're engaging the news media and all that to say this is a request right um and not to make it combative with buckham County but to say these are things and this is why we're wanting to do this because I think that will help bring more people and front of the Commissioners who might support the the ideas we have so that's number two and then and then third I want to go all the way back to that um the most sobering slide that shows the possible $7.1 million shortfall and um when it when it becomes time to have this next conversation and the best way we can that is not pinpointing anybody in this District I since joining this board I've always had a question about the purpose of our supplement and

105whom does it serve so I would love to know I my understanding is every single employee in this district has the supplement other than superintendent um and I would be and I'm sorry that I'm saying this in front of a lot of people who serve in central office but I'd be really curious to know how does that supplement support the salaries of the highest paid people in our district and is there a way that that can be we can look at that if if we have to start making some real tough decisions about something like a supplement with whatever comes from our local dollars are there other ways to write contracts so that they don't have to have a supplement that would go up every single year or something like that I might be off

106base here but it's just this question I've always had I don't know if we're how many districts across the state have every single employee receiving a supplement I'm just have some curiosity around that so um first um most districts not all um and that information actually is for the most part in the statistical profile on DPI website um have a local supplement the original intent as I understand it for most districts was to give teachers a salary supplement ruford is a great example the commissioners of of long ago backed that support and gave them $1,100 each flat amount they have not changed it in 30 years $1,100 that's it that's all they get and it's only teachers no one else gets it other districts give all salar staff the supplement but not hourly staff our

107district gives hourly staff not only the supplement but at the same levels as all the salary staff which you know bunkham has a limit on theirs as far as there's one amount for all noncertified staff so um it varies just to say that um I will I do want to just throw this on the table for throwing things on the table at the moment um because if we're talking about C you know benefit to the district intent to manage a budget and still reward our employees for the hard work they do every day there is an alternative in that that percentage can be changed to a flat amount so something Mark wyers I saw again um if you don't know him he was a senior um finance officer at Wake County schools which you if

108you've ever seen that budget blows my mind to this day how much money they manage there but they used to give a percentage supplement and they realized very quickly how they could no longer manage that because of that double effect that we were talking about earlier every time a raise happens you're basically giving a double raise so as far as another tool that we could look at would be to change at from a even though it could still be tiered but it would be tiered at a flat amount versus a percentage so you would have a way to better manage it again you could still review it periodically and change the amount but it would not just through means beyond your control always ratchet up ratchet up ratchet up where you have no control over

109how much that's increasing every year I think um that reminds me that um you know one of the challenges of having the percentages go up I guess we do it based on years of service so I suppose that this isn't but I mean basically what I've noticed in my own work is you know a 3% increase in my salary is a lot different from a 3% increase in a brand new legal assistance salary and it's not really fair um that I already make more by a lot than that person and yet my 3% is going to give me so much more of a raise that year just in dollar terms so I don't know I'll just I just throw that out there because it's the same idea I think of what George is saying is

110that um you know when we're looking at our highest earners who've been here a long time getting that kind of multiplier every year it's just a lot when you have some who are new to the district getting the lowest pay and their supplements are also the lowest now I will jump in the teacher the role for a moment here um because something that most teachers that work here now probably don't remember but there are a group that still do back when the teacher salary schedule was really changed at the state level they they they did and you can still find it online where they put longevity in the teacher salary schedule but they no longer get the longevity payment okay so one thing our local supplement does in a lot of people's minds is still

111recognize that longevity where they feel like they lost it even though it was rolled in the schedule no one feels that um so that is something that the the noner staff and all the other salaried staff that aren't teachers paid on the certified salary schedule still get except for principles unfortunately um so everybody else still gets longevity so those folks do get longevity and this the teachers get longevity teachers are the only ones teachers and principles are the only ones that do not yes thank you it's a separate payment everyone gets longevity based on their anniversary date so the month that their anniversary date comes up based on the year's experience they get their longevity payment like I said except principls and teachers any other things as we kind of go back Crunch and update

112numbers that you would like to see in the next presentation I assume the next presentation is going to or we're going to start to look at strategies for how to deal with the Doom and Gloom slide yes okay thank you forever known as the Doom and Gloom slide that's it we're done that's all I got board members this was again the sharing of information a chance for us to speak additional information we will have the budget on our agenda at the work session on March 3D and then again at the board meeting on thank you the 10th um just was kind of checking in with everybody if they need anything else tonight or additional requests okay good I think everyone is pleased with this information um are you going to share what board member as

113Sabo well and I'm happy to do that I don't and I think I would have um Pep's permission to do this I mean he was much more in the specifics and whereas I view the information we got tonight as just information to form our our thinking um I mean the things that pepy asked me I mean I'm happy to say these again um he's looking for win-win ideas that if we ask for additional funds that some portion of it be um tied to early childhood education efforts um looking for ways to collaborate improve collaboration he he said all these things before but I will say them out loud um do we want to give more than $719,000 to the county as a show of fair play to bunkham County Schools um he notes that he

114hears sales tax receipts have rebounded um but he's not seen that in writing so I don't know that anything was real specific to tonight but those are the things that he's mentioned and I'm sure we'll continue to talk about as we all search for good solutions for everybody if no one else has anything for us to consider is there a motion to adjourn we'll make a motion that we adjourn second by consensus we will adjourn thanks everyone

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.