CorpusRecord 130281

Asheville City Board of Education Work Session 2/3/2025

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Asheville City Schools
Date
2025-02-04
Location
Buncombe County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
21,166 words · about 118 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e like to go ahead and get started Liza's just in the restroom she'll be right with us um thank you Lisa timer um and here's Liza Tim is passing out nice things um I'm GNA ask Pepe to get us started by reading the equity statement are we live are we ready to go okay in Asheville City Schools we are committed to equity and anti-racist policies for all students and staff to learn and Thrive we recognize that our positions come with power responsibility and public service for the entire ACS Community we will model our commitment to equity through our practices and decisions during this meeting we invite a pause if harm has taken place a moment to name the harm and space to practice repair thank you pepy um all members of the board

002are present and we have a quorum so at this time I would accept a motion to approve the agenda I move that we approve the agenda second second it's been moved and approved anyone not in favor of approving the agenda as presented by consensus the agenda is approved um just a few notes at the beginning before I turn this over to Dr Fairman we're excited to have pepy with us for his first official uh work session oh sorry um we're excited is there a lot of feedback or is it just me um we're excited to have pepy with us for his first work session um I'd like to um we can't we have important work to do and it takes the time that it takes I think a typical meeting would typically be about two

003hours I know we have an hour of legal training I just wanted folks to know in my head I am working as if we had about two and a half hours for our meeting this evening um there may be some items we have non-closure about we talked about that the retreat last week and we'll pick them up again it's all an important work we may not be able to get to all of it tonight so I just wanted everyone to know that um as we go through the meeting I'm going to try to keep us moving acknowledging where we don't have closure and we may um move some of that to a subsequent meeting um at this time I'll turn it over to Maggie all right thank you chairman thorberg um good evening all board

004members some of you I didn't get to say hi to personally um so couple things on the agenda um first thing is consolidation report so we all attended well many of us attended the presentation hopefully we've all had a chance to review that so we have to send a response to um will we are asked if we want to send a response of the study with the report when they send it to the legislature and if the board wants to send a response just curious on how we want to draft that as a letter as a resolution so that we can start moving the pieces forward it has to be submitted by the 15th um so we need to just make sure and then if it is action that the board has to you know

005take action on a resolution we would need to have that ready for next Monday so just curious thoughts um on what we want to do with that and how we want to respond to the report Maggie have we gotten any um recommendation from any of our local legislatures about what they would recommend no okay no I haven't reached out all transparency about it um but yeah I mean the reason I ask is it's you know the the findings of the consolidation study are fairly clear to me that doesn't mean it NE might be clear to others so I don't know if that if um it would be helpful to add a resolution or if that would I hate to operate from the space but if it draw attention to to it yeah to be honest

006I think to me a resolution would be powerful for a couple reasons and one of them being particularly if it's a joint resolution between the Commissioners the county and Ashville City Schools board um on saying hey we've done the study if says no no consolidation and we three bodies agree to that let's lay this down and move on but do we know the other two bodies agree with that sentiment I believe they do I definitely believe monkam County School Board does um I get the feeling that the just based on the feedback from the Commissioners at that meeting that they were I mean Al Whit side was really the only one that said you know we should go ahead and consolidate but I think he would have at least the chair um and vice chair

007for the Commissioners I don't know the answer to this I feel like Rob Elliot told me that bunkham county in the month of February does not meet in the first week and they meet the second week so I guess I'm just putting it out there there'd be a an issue of getting them on board do we want to take a moment and and have everybody here check in or do we feel like we've got consensus do we need to for the public reiterate the findings of the study what are our steps that you're looking for right now Sarah I think as Maggie presented we have an opportunity to um make a resolution if we feel it appropriate um I think now is the time for board members who have feelings on the topic to say

008So speaking only for myself I'm pretty neutral um I be I don't oppose a resolution I don't know that we need a resolution I mean to me the report's pretty clear we were told to do it we did it I mean I don't that's for me what do others think I think um for my part my only concern is that what Asheville City Schools wants is not necessarily typically what the legislature wants and so I'm a little concerned that if we um if we pass a resolution that may not help uh normally I would think it would help and I would be in favor of it I do believe that if we I will say this much if we can get bunkham County Commissioners and bunkham County School Board to agree to resolution and somehow

009they're able to um meet and agree to a joint resolution then that carries some Force I'm not sure that ours alone is especially helpful because I feel like we're the least likely to be persuasive to a majority the general assembly but I that might be paranoid thinking on my part so that's just my gut no it's good um Amy but my thoughts were the same if we can get the uh the city to give us a backup and help you out but we only have a week right uh can it be done if it can be done why not give it a shot if everyone else support us and we all stand one piece up I also tend to think though and I'm not trying to anyway that What Sarah Said is also correct that

010in some ways the study is so powerful um it is a powerful uh case against consolidation and maybe it speaks for itself if we're not able to do especially if we can't do anything joint I think that's the best way to just say we did the study here it is yeah thank you typically Schoolboard members you guys would be the ones to reach out to the Commissioners or to the bungum County Board I'm happy to reach out to ail and Rob to kind of see if they have an overall feeling about like how easy would it be to get all three people on the same page or everyone to sign one letter instead of three separate letters um so I'm happy to to coordinate that as well um either way I think I think that

011makes sense I also think a letter simply saying that the results of the study are consistent with our own data and our own um our own understanding of what would be best for our district um might be useful just as a letter here it is I don't know I don't know though who sends this study to them we will send our um whatever we write as a response we'll send it Rachel and then she'll send it in when she submits the report okay she has a specific email address that goes to a committee that's going to review it and take it from there what I'm hearing is some folks have said if we all three sign something and Maggie's offered to find out if that's even pable to the other two boards um come back

012with something I did find out the bunkham County School Board meets the 13th so there would she would be talking I suppose with Rob Jackson and um alal do you all want her to proceed I'm trying to gauge where people are are you opposed to that we could get the County Commissioners those are the people that really want behind us if we can get them I think we should you okay you know you're noty you're nothing I am thinking that it would be appropriate for us to vote I guess we're doing voting next week to specifically vote to accept the results of the study and in and um I think it'd be appropriate for us to ask Maggie to pursue what she's offering today and just to clarify I don't think we have to vote

013on the study the study's been done I mean we don't have to vote on it we just have to decide are we going to let it be submitted to the state with no further information from us or do we wish to send a letter with it that's the only thing we have to decide is a letter or no letter I'm in favor of a letter if it's joint from all three so thank you for offering and otherwise I would say put the put the study forward without anything else yeah I I assume it would have to be a special meeting that bunkham County School Board would have to call um potentially and that's up to them anyway yeah it seems to me procedurally let Maggie do some groundw work she may find out early on

014that there's not consensus so put a put a a footnote there and we can deal with this on Monday she might find out that yes there is consensus I'm assuming on the shortest possible couple sentences right the L said um and she could bring that to us next Monday we could always vote contingent on the other two boards approving it so that if the County Schools ends up next Thursday not approving it then ours would not take place um so procedurally I think that's how that might work yes pepy uh quoting from the presentation that was done um at the beginning of the study process uh and I'm assuming that this is quoted from the statute the bunam county Board of Education and the Asheville City Board of Education shall report findings and recommendations to

015the standing committees of the general assembly hearing election matters no later than February 15th 2025 and I'm just playing Waring paper with you I reach out to Rachel sawer who reminded me that in her December presentation to our board she said endorsements of and or comments by County Commissioners and school boards not required okay that's great that's what I got I think the study itself satisfies the statute so what I'm hearing as we move on is we'll let Maggie reach out to the bunkham county schools and the County Commissioners see if there's traction we trust her to figure that out bring it back to us if there's not traction we're probably not voting on anything next week and we'll take it from there is everybody okay with that yeah okay excellent oh sorry George I

016would like to add that even if they're not in favor I know I might be dis dissenting opinion here but I think it still would behoove us to write something to have some kind of statement I know that I hear what what Amy has said um but I'm of the opinion that we don't operate from kind of some paranoid mindset and I think the study is significant enough and if we as a district um are satisfied with that study and from my perspective I certainly am I want the general simply to know that so even if bunkham County School Board and bu County Commissioners do not agree to son on again I might be dissenting voice here but I I think it would behoove us to go ahead and have a um something that we

017send along with the study no matter what thanks George um I've heard different things about that would you all be okay for tonight we let Maggie see what she can find out next Monday if she finds out there's not agreement we could have a vote on whether we want to say something or not does that work for everybody okay as I find out you know what the appetite is with the other governing teams um you know I'll start drafting a letter and then if there's no I'll just draft a letter that would be specific for Asheville City Schools as well so kind of depending on what I hear I'll start drafting a letter that I can share in the board materials so you can review it prior to the meeting thank you okay um next

018up another thing I will remind you is the city school Consortium in North Carolina pays for a lobbyist ours is the policy group Steve meaf and his son John meaf represent Asheville City Schools as part of that contract with the city Consortium City Schools Consortium and they are planning on going and you know putting you know work in the back rooms to talk to legislators um on our behalf as well so that's also happening and I will probably consult with them on what they think is the appropriate language to put in the letter it's always really helpful um okay next up uh governance are our U board norms and we did spend some time going through those um at our Retreat and um just want to know where are where is the board are we

019ready to formalize these um typically a board will vote on their Norms to so that you have that concrete agreement so um you had the opportunity to review these again um was there any feedback or suggested changes or are we okay as we look at these Norms to move forward with more of a formal action not necessarily next week um but going forward at some point I think we did not get sorry go ahead the ad hoc okay sorry um I should anyway I think we didn't discuss the ad hoc Norms last time so maybe it's okay if everybody's reviewed them but I just want to make sure that um we sort of tie that up um if we can so um does anybody want to comment on I mean and I I know because

020Amy and I we worked on these and I think they may not need to be alone they may fit into the other categories so I think there is some work to do to figure that out um so yeah if I remember correctly we had pretty good consensus on um most of these but the ad hoc we didn't get a chance to look at do we want to take a look at those now or do the board want some more time and we come back well I guess my wondering is the first three governance communication and meetings we've had a chance to review those we discussed language if the board's okay I'll clean up this copy and then we can put it on the agenda for next week for at least those three and then we

021can pick up ad hoc at another time time could you also when you're looking through cleaning them up consider if the ad hoc Norms maybe fit into and don't need to sit outside or if they need to be recategorize as something different that that I I think that'd be an efficient way to bring them in I can I can definitely do that I'll keep them in a different like type phase so we know that those are the ones we still need to to talk through if they there's more discussion on those board members is you all okay with this sound good okay all right that are those are my two oh the last one is policies so there is a board um policy about standing committees and I think the couple things to discuss here

022is what we listed in there in that list where do Dr Cosby had came up with a bunch of committees for board members to be part of or attend but those really aren't like board standing board committees they are staff committees that the board would attend just to hear and listen so the I guess the question is those really wouldn't be what we would link into this policy as standing committees I mean we can definitely look at which board members want to you know peek in and and attend some of these different committee meetings if they still would like to to do that um so the question is does the board want to create standing committees and if so what would those be can we yes and that's a a discussion but for this policy

023is it appropriate to have a section D other committees that just explains that when we are attending a staff committee we're there as non-voting we're not we're you get the tone that I'm looking for but it's just not thing my my preference is that actually the board doesn't attend staff committee meetings that would be my preference because they're there as staff meetings it really is an opportunity for staff to do their work and get input I feel if the board attends those may not be as free flowing of a conversation because a governance team member is there so I would actually prefer that board members would not attend those committee meetings and we can report out to the board on what's happening in those and give reports after you know give a summary at meetings

024but um that would that would really be my preference to help create that really clear line between governance and operations yeah I was I was going to request if we could get the minutes perhaps um I mean I I don't I wouldn't think there would be we could sh those upon request if you want them um but and have access you could have access to them like in our Google Drive that you can check them and read them at any time we could do that my only reflection is that when I did attend a couple of them that was Illuminating I mean just to to understand better what each of those committees does so I do think that occasional reports I'm not talking about lengthy or um fre qu reports but just to kind of

025get a sense of what the commit I don't know that that's something I I like the idea of but at the same time we do have long meetings and I'm not interested in adding to them unnecessarily I'd be curious to know what other board members think so Magie are you saying so for example the the linked Google doc that has board committee board member of committee assignments which I know is um outdated because it has James his name on this um you're you're saying that for that whole list of committees you would prefer board members not be a part of any of those mhm I wonder if you could tell us a little more like if we could take just like a little bit of a step back help us understand because my memory is

026when I came on this board we were all asked to sign up this is under Cosby and he wanted us going going out listening learning by watching the work you know that that sort of thing and since like the the groups don't seem to be meeting in the same way as is as operations are evolving so do you see these groups as do these committees operate on will they continue to operate as having like monthly meetings where work is is that really how the work of the district is getting done okay yeah no and that's like I understand you know how these were created but like calendar committee probably meets two or three times a year and then they bring their findings to the board and their recommendations to the board because you've got to

027take action on calendar um same one with like Title One or except like these committees do that work but not always like on a monthly basis it kind of comes and then they end their committee and then they regroup next year but always the end product from a committee is going to be to draft a recommendation or information for the board for things that you might need to take action on policy wise or um like the student health like we have to have a board approved like student mental health plan so the student mental health committee would get together work through the process and then bring their plan for board approval um so that's I can't really explain to you know give ration Auto why Dr Cosby wanted the board I I get that it

028helped you as many new board members coming on at the same time really understanding schools and the operational um Logistics um so it's just yeah to me it's it's a crossing a little bit of the line between the governance of the board and the daily operations I as as you might expect it makes me uncomfortable the the siloing of the board from the operation of schools uh I know that board members in over the past 10 years have attended for example the calendar committee meetings we've always had a few board members attend that a few board members have attended others I don't know that this list needs attendance from all the board members um and then you know combine that with the request that we not um ask staff questions unless we go through you

029during the work sessions I'm just concerned that because I because I have seen decisions made in the past where board members didn't have realistic understanding of how our schools actually operate any opportunity to observe and understand I think is helpful but I also understand and respect that we don't want board members to be disruptive of a process and so I can see both sides of this I guess the only comment I would make and well one clarification does that include the EAC technically yeah okay um I guess the only comment I would make is there have been instances where having a board member um for example I don't remember the name of the committee but Tim Shelton's committee um where I think Sarah and names were members of that committee pardon me facilities facilities thank

030you and they were able to actually offer expertise to the rest of us that because they had been really closely involved and there have been a few instances like that where I have found it actually really helpful to hear from another board member who had special insight into because I hear you that but but anyway it seemed helpful to have that in addition to the report um that said I'm with Pepe in terms of I defer um as long as the information we get of course obviously is accurate which I know it will be and we've had a history in this District of receiving inaccurate information so I say that only to acknowledge both that I trust you and your team and I think that for those who are listening from the community there's going

031to be potentially a concern that we won't get accurate information so I just want to I just have to say that and acknowledge it um yeah I guess that's it for me I'm good I want to keep the first part of this conversation on the what I'm going to call the district committees this list and do other we've heard from some of you George um I just want to lift out the equity Council um considering that that's been um that is and necessarily has to be a focus of this District in terms of resolving some real inequities in our district um and I know that I that part of it is personal for me having been a part of that Council for quite a few years um and seeing the value in it um uh

032you know not quite sure where I was going with what I wanted to say but I just wanted to highlight the equity Council and um as a district that has equity in its mission statement that we talk about it and should be talking about all the time how that might play out if board members are not part of that Council what the other thing that if the board wants to keep attending these the one thing I struggle with is then George has a lot of information about the equity that the rest of the board doesn't have so if board members are going to attend these meetings I think it should be their responsibility then to report out at the following board meeting here's what this committee talked about here's the agenda so I think it's

033yeah this is up to the board I mean I would prefer not but if board members want to attend these meetings when they happen go for it um I know yall have tight schedules that as it is um but like it's that's up to you as a board and knowing that then what after you attend the meeting at the following board meeting there would be a report out from George about the equity team I was just going to propose that we rotate through the Committees um you know that three or fewer of us attend when we can um and then I'm in favor of reporting back to the board following the meeting I feel like having us report or and having somebody from the committee report is just unnecessary and um makes longer conversations I

034think I'm leaning toward myself just personally I don't think we should treat any committee differently for many other I think the EAC and Equity are kind of twin uh in some ways deal with some of the same stuff um anyway I I'm fine with not having us attend but I do agree that if we're going to attend rotating through is a good idea I wonder if in the vein of of just work and non-closure right that you know I think that if we look at this list there are some of these that meet on a very regular basis and some that meet very infrequently some might be in on Hiatus right now and we'll have a new life you know as you continue to build the culture here and that maybe there are that this

035isn't the list right right that actually what we're getting to is during leadership transition we got this this and now it's time to rethink and there are there's something I don't it's not fully formed here and I'm grateful for a longer time to figure this out that I don't think we need to go to all these but I think there may be some places where our staff comes together to discuss or work on things that it would actually be great for board members to observe and listen but I don't know what that is yet and I'm okay with that like maybe we can build this a little more yeah so we would unlink this from the policy number one number two are there any standing committees that we would put in that policy for the

036board the only one I can really think of would be enrollment when we have those hearings but that's not really a committee it's more of a you know four board members coming to hear an enrollment uh appeal or the discipline appeals come to the whole board I think we're too small to have standing committees yeah I would just I would I have a curiosity around a budget committee only because the budget is so big but I also understand that like having only a few board members being a part of that might not be the best use of a standing committee in that way because the budget is so big but so I have no skin in the game I just wanted to bring up budget because of course it's all about the budget can we

037look at it in a different way can since we have uh work sessions every month we can always look at the meeting and figure out if anybody wants to go you know within right now you got three in February we can say hey if anybody wants to attend you know who would like to No One say then we can look at next month we look at March you know I mean I mean we could bring them up we can put them on our calendar and just say uh you know look at the meetings and see if anybody would like to attend you know and that way we know when meeting is that month at least we have that knowledge and then the second knowledge is uh anybody want to go hey let's see who wants

038to go oh who have time so here's what I'm hearing from everybody and I just want to sort of break this down I hear Maggie saying we would take this list off of this policy and I believe we're all in agreement with it if for no other reason then these aren't standing committees and this is confusing okay so we're going to get to this policy ler later tonight and we'll come back to it but I think we're delinking the Google link I've heard folks say they trust Maggie and we don't want to micromanage I've heard vocalization of fears of siloing and um maybe we wouldn't get information that we would want to get I happen to like Jesse's idea which might be that and I don't know where this would be available but a list

039of the Committees that meet and it would be on us as board members to let Maggie know if we want to attend and if we do attend that there'd be an expectation of sharing back um I I don't know that it's realistic that we're all going to go to all of them I mean I think that's such a great idea but I'm GNA fall short every time on that um and so I I guess I'm going to ask first board members if what I said sounds like what you all were saying and then I'm going to ask Maggie to respond to that but sorry okay thank you I think the only thing that wasn't in what you said was the invitation to think about actual standing committees and maybe we need to continue that to

040another conversation as well um is it the I George say sure like a budget standing committee so that there's a group of board members who can really get in there but then there obviously has to be a way of sharing that and I've like maybe a policy standing committee are you aware of any is it not typical to have standing committees I mean we have this policy that says standing committees but now we're saying it's not really what's what's been your professional experience of this really depends on districts and the preference um and the board's preference on you know three board members you know going to a committee and starting to you know guide decisions on policy or guide decisions on the budget and then bringing that back to the board the practice here I

041think has been all seven board members are engaged at the same time instead of a group kind of out there steering one way and maybe the other four are like um that's not how we want to steer this um so it's it's really board preference and it's usually for much larger school systems that have so much you know just operational stuff that they've got to really divide and Conquer um I agree Rebecca that maybe a policy um standing committee would make sense and it might discuss policies that are separate than the ones that are uh coming to us from the North Carolina School Board Association and that might be a place to grow I know the board has discussed in the past um what kind of policies do we want to initiate and so yeah

042um and then you know you mentioned budget but I understand George's um wise comments that maybe all of us need to be involved in budget but then how do you get into the details um so I don't think we have to have standing committees and it may be that the board chair working with the vice chair can set up some ad hoc Comm committees for things like we might want to have an ad hoc committee with bunam County Schools to look at our district maps and uh what kind of approaches we wanted to have with enrollment across districts and bringing in enrollment from other counties and enrollment from charter schools and and private schools T TMI good idea um examples for February we have facilities we have student health advisory we have Safety Council and

043we also have transportation now if this if the flood was last month I think facilities would be a good one to go to but you know who want to go to it now seem like everything is running well I mean everything is you know April right um no wait yeah she's in charge uh let's look at a student Health advisory you know uh Safety Council uh Transportation you know if you want to get up early and ride a bus and see how Transportation does it you know that's your you know if you feel like it you know we can just say hey I go I'm not saying I would go but you know you say hey let's go and take that Transportation but you know that's how we can look at it uh trans I

044mean if I had a choice right now of February uh meetings I would probably say uh I'll probably pick Transportation see how the see how the um buses are nowadays and see how the routes are and just to uh you know just have it feeling you know but I mean you know that's you know but February nobody want to then we can just say hey nobody going and we can look at next month we look at uh March Jesse I'm not sure these months have anything to do with no but but I mean this is what we have right now that we're looking at for example it was that it's I mean I'm not sure they still go according to the months but um whenever they do go you know but just trying to see

045if we have consensus tonight and we might not um we Rebecca I think said it well if other folks will agree we be thinking about about standing committees there might be space for policy or ad hoc committees or other committees I'm not hearing a ground swell about one particular one so I think we'll just be thinking about that um is I'm I'm just trying to restate what I heard before are folks comfortable with Maggie keeping us surprised of when meetings occur if we want to go whether that's ride a bus or go to a meeting we would just say to Maggie hey we'd like to go in more with the understanding that we would then report back are folks come just before we have any more comments let me just check okay yes absolutely comfortable

046with that may I suggest that instead of spending any time on standing committees that we defer to our board chair and vice chair to if we decide that we might want a standing committee that we just try it out as an ad hoc committee and see how that goes for us I don't have any problem with at all I think it would if you if what we're saying is if you have an idea for one and you want to bring it to Rebecca and I that's great I think we would still want to take the Pulse of the board about whether they all want that particular committee don't want to Promise Too Many ad hoc committees yeah Amy um one quick observation policy and budget go to the core of what we do as a

047board many of these committees do not and I hear that Equity is sort of in the core of what we do but not really in our governance um um and so I don't think a committee a subcommittee on budget or policy is a good idea because I think that that is the respon that's like the core thing that all of us are responsible for that's just my I think we're good on this Maggie are you good on that okay excellent thanks everybody um at this time our own Anna gpie is back to fin I think she's going to quickly cover what we didn't get to at our board retreat and do the rest of our required legal training thank you Anna can you hear me now we can hear you okay awesome um so I

048know we already did half of this so we've got to do one more hour um there were two topics we didn't get to in our first hour I didn't include them in the presentation but they're pretty quick so I'll just cover them pretty quickly the first one is social media essentially Our advice on social media is you're going to see things that upset you on social media um and when you do take a second think about whether a resp response is necessary think about who you actually want to get that information out to that you want to respond to and clarify something if you do see something on social media you think you need to address um and then think about the format that you want to address it in because just because something came

049up from social media doesn't necessarily mean you want to respond to it on social media you may want to do a more targeted response so that's pretty much Our advice for social media oh and think before you you post uh if you wouldn't want to see it on the front p page don't post it that's our advice for social media um the other one is close session we have a statute that lays out all of the bases that we can go into Clos session the big ones are attorney client privilege Personnel information student information um and there are some others obviously but those are the big three that you're going to see the most frequently um whenever we have a motion for Clos session we lay out the reasons for it within the statute 143

050318 11 and then we name a whatever that goes along with it and the reason um so that's pretty much all it is for closed session those are the two we missed now we can get into the new stuff if nobody has questions about yes um I also want to appreciate the last week's uh core training from the North Carolina Schoolboard Association and they added one other piece of advice that really stood out to me which is think before you delete and that it is better to if you post something you've got regrets or something isn't accurate um to Archive it just in case it's a public document sure so this part um is all about conflicts and statutory duties so this is really going over the statutory requirements for you here uh and okay

051so the first thing is ethics um you know generally people kind of have this idea of what ethics are some of the principles that we generally think of trustworthiness respect responsibility fairness citizenship civic virtue that sort of thing um and this is just an example of the guides from UNC School of government we have a specific policy in Asheville City schools and many other school districts policy 2120 that lays out the code of ethics for school board members um I do suggest you go and read it um and you ever have questions it comes from these two statutes which both just say you'll have a code of ethics that's what those statutes say um and so the policy really lays it all out for you in detail um the big the first one is your

052requirements of course obey the law um that's a good one obey the law so we'll start there um the other one is to uphold the integrity and Independence of the office of course um invoid impropriety in the exercise of your official duties perform your duties faithfully and conduct the Affairs of the board in open and public manner complying with the applicable open meetings laws and of course we all know as we just discussed with closed session there are exceptions to that when we can't talk about things in public but generally the Affairs of the board are public information so we also have specific commitments of board members those were your requirements these are also your commitments within the policy which is to attend board meetings regularly as much as possible make sure that you're informed

053when you're making the decisions as a board member um try to make policy policy decisions while keeping in mind that you're trying to provide students with a sound basic education which they have a legal right to in North Carolina um and try and only make those decisions after full discussion in public um then render all decisions based on the available facts and independent judgment that you have so just don't be influenced by others um make the decisions based on your own judgment don't let others make them for you yeah um Civility and integrity to others I think that one's kind of you know we we say it's for board members but it's also for kind of everyone I would say but yeah so try and just model Civility and integrity since you guys are the

054face of the community in a lot of ways for this um and then respecting the confidentiality of information that is privileged Ed is a huge one as your lawyer so just make sure you're not sharing information that you received in a confidential setting through your position um so that's a big one and then also work with your fellow board members um to establish policies and Authority so just try to work together okay also um communicate with each other and your superintendent um especially you know if there's something that you think is going to be a public reaction in some way make sure you have open communication with each other to discuss that learn about the current issues know what's going on in the world especially that's impacting Your Role or your schools as board members

055and keep those in mind when you're coming to the table to do your work um so oh yeah receive your 12 hours of training and with the end of this hour you'll have completed your two hours required for ethical training sounds like ppp's already ahead on the rest of the training hours required as well so good job on that um support okay so yes so you know Maggie will bring you recommendations for employment um consider those and make sure that you are supporting the best qualified individuals to work in our schools that we can get um also refrain from investigating or trying to resolve complaints that you receive because the community is going to come to you with their concerns of course they are you're their board members um but you really can only function

056as a group and often times we have processes in place that those would flow through so don't take it to like you have to solve it yourself bring it to the board if it's something the Board needs to solve if it's something that really needs to go to Maggie to be solved take it to her to solve I really recommend if you ever get a complaint or have a concern that's brought to you taking it to Maggie first um and so she can help sort of direct where that needs to go and how that needs to flow through our processes in place um oh yeah and avoid being placed in a position of conflict of interest um or using your position for partisan gain so on that conflict of interest Point refrain from participating or

057deliberating or voting on or influencing anybody um if there is a matter pertaining to the employment of you or your spouse involving the board um you can't do that we'll get more into that piece of it in a minute um and don't take any private action that would compromise the board or Administration so that's another one so then our last one is remember that a board Member's First and greatest concern must be the educational welfare of the students attending its Public Schools so at the end of the day that's the thing to keep in mind we're here for the students and we're trying to do what's right by them oh yeah so another statute we like to make you aware of in this is willfully failing to discharge duties this is a criminal statute and

058it is a Class one misdemeanor for board members to Omit neglect or refuse to perform the duties of their office um one of the sanctions on top of the misdemeanor is removal from office so just things to keep in mind as you're making decisions um generally this doesn't come up but it has in my time at Campbell shy so I'll just leave it at that now there are several conflicts of interest laws in North Carolina five of them to be partic like to be precise that apply to y'all and so we're just going to go through all of those real quick so the first one is the prohibition against benefiting from public contracts you guys are familiar with this one um you can't make you can't make or administer a contract that you derive a

059direct benefit from that's really the big thing um and we'll get into what deriving a direct benefit is here in a second but and there are exceptions to this of course because nothing is that straightforward we'll get into all of that the second one is um you can't derive a direct benefit from a contract or and you can't be involved if somebody else is making or administering the contract and you would derive a direct benefit from it you can't influence them so even if you step back and say hey I'm conflicted out of making this decision if you do that you cannot try to influence your fellow board members or anyone else involved in the contract on how you think it needs to be handled oh yeah you can't solicit or receive gifts favors rewards

060anything like that um to influence the award of a contract and we kind of I'll get into more um sort of how gifts and favors are defined but I think it's fairly clear you know on just a logical level what that would consist of oh yeah no presence no presence okay so like I said we're going to get into the making of a contract or the definitions a little bit more so making a contract is if you're involved in the development of the terms or the preparation or the or the award of it so you know generally you guys aren't necessarily drafting the terms of the contract yourselves but you are reviewing it and determining whether to sign it generally or for example if it's like something that we have like rfpd or something you

061may be determining who to award that contract to so that would be part of making it um and this kind of goes to that point that I was making about you can't influence others you can't get around this by just saying you're not going to vote on it you can't be involved in any piece of that contract not just not voting on it O Okay so administering a contract is the other piece of it and that's the person who oversees the performance of that contract so making sure that things are done for example like if we have an agreement with somebody to develop something for our facilities Tim is generally administering that and handling that oversight but so you guys can't administer those contracts that you're conflicted out on as well that doesn't include ministerial

062duties so that's things like sending a notice like things that aren't necessarily like they don't take any personal opinion or anything to do so if it's like a notice that's generated automatically and you're sending that out that's not considered administering it direct benefit is a big piece of it so you derive a direct benefit when you or your spouse either have more than a 10% ownership or other interest derive any income or commission directly from the contract or acquire property under the contract so that is how we Define direct benefit for the purpose of conflicts you're not involved and we kind of just talked about this ministerial duties so it's not a ministerial or it is a ministerial Duty that isn't a conflict if it's something that doesn't require discretion and that's kind of what

063I was trying to say a second ago is just if it's like I said if it's like you have to send a notice that's automatically generated or even just a notice that you're like hey this is whatever that's not necessarily administering a contract that's just a ministerial Duty okay so scenario one Betty board member owns 100 shares of stock and Office Depot other than this Betty has no connection with Office Depot is there a problem if the school school system enters a contract with Office Depot for the purchase of office equipment what are your thoughts I see George shaking his head I see several other head shakes all right answer you're right no there's no problem there she doesn't own 10% of the company there's no problem with her voting on whether to get those

064supplies or not turns out Office Depot has a lot more than a 100 stocks as you might okay so here's our next next one you're employed as a salesperson by ABC Car Dealership before you were elected to the school board you earned commission from selling vehicles to the school system first question after you're sworn in as a board member May the school system continue to buy cars from ABC Car Dealership I see nodding heads all right okay after you're sworn in can you continue to receive a commission for selling vehicles to the school system okay after your after you're sworn in May your spouse who is also a salesperson for the car dealership receive a commission for selling vehicles to the school system good job guys you got them all right good job you guys

065don't even need me up here um yes so the school system can still buy cars from them um you just can't get that Commission because but you don't own the company that's our assumption in this is you're not an owner you don't own 10% or more of the company um with that assumption in place yes they can continue to contract with them um but you and your spouse cannot earn commission that is correct because that would be a direct benefit to you or your spouse okay after you're sworn it as a board member may your brother who also works for ABC Car Dealership receive commission from selling vehicles to the school system I see a okay okay that's right brothers are not prohibited that's not your spouse God huh yeah I know if your family

066owns the dealership we'll have to ret talk it but yeah but based on this yeah no they're fine he can still get that commission now the question is does anyone have a problem with that answer though you think you shouldn't it has the appearance of impropriety and so yeah no that's fair and those are fair concerns and yeah I I wouldn't disagree with you and it's interesting because this is one that kind of we'll tie in because we're going to go over Federal conflicts as well uh in a minute but yeah so scenario 4 you own a party supply store and regularly sell balloons paper products and Banners to Local Schools after you're sworn in can you continue to sell those to the school see nodding heads or shaking heads not nodding shaking okay that's

067correct you're the owner you cannot sell those to the school they're going to have to find someone new buy Party City sorry it's gone um but yeah so you cannot okay and and for the record it doesn't matter the the problem is selling it it doesn't matter whether you're making a profit or not and so that's something we like to make sure we make a point about is even if you're selling it at Cost or at you know a great deal that's still making a contract it still counts as a conflict all right you own a landscaping business after you're sworn in as a board member may you donate your time to plant trees at the high school from your business I see Peppe nodding his head I see George nodding his head see Amy

068shaking her head Li okay yeah this is an interesting one but yes Peppe uh it's already answered but yes you can donate your time resources whatever you want you can donate you can't charge for it that's the disting that's the distinction there um and like I kind of just mentioned the issue is not profit so what it is is even if you sold it below cost you're still selling it and that's the problem yes Amy question I just have to ask yes can you put a that's such a law school exam question a good it is I would say answer that I just think it's so fun to think about it is I would say that um it would if not being a direct conflict would give the appearance of impropriety and it would give

069you you would be um getting some advertising out of it and therefore I would say don't I would say even if it's not directly forbidden it's a bad idea yes pepy so if I were to make some children's blocks hypothetically speaking and donate them to a classroom and not have any logo on them and not tell anyone is that the line where is the line here well I mean they're not labeled they're nothing like or anything like that I think that's I don't see it I mean yeah okay so these are our exceptions to the prohibition on benefiting from public contracts the school the school board can employ a board member's spouse that's fine um or the spouse of the superintendent that's also fine I realized when I was reading that slide though that it

070did not make sense with the wording on there um but anyway because I was like or the superintendent yeah you can employ the superintendent also like probably should that's kind of your job uh okay but so the sanctions on if you violate this we've kind of gone over this already but this is Class one misdemeanor criminal offense punishable by a fine sometimes imprisonment depending on the prior criminal record so that's if you violate the statute so there's other sanction other sanctions um there's this case Gibbs V Mayo so this was our court of appeals held that a Board of Commissioners was required to pay over $270,000 he received in payments for repairs so what happened is County residents and taxpayers sued the County Commissioners for entering into a contract where one of the Commissioners received

071County funds for repairing buildings and the commissioner who was like the chair he was one of two licensed commission or two licensed contractors in the county and he gave himself the job to repair the courthouse and the health department um as his position as a commissioner um and the board never sought competitive bids for the work on the courthouse and received informal bids to repair the health department so the value of his work was irrelevant to the court in making this determination he had to return everything that he was paid even if it was fee you know even if he put it into buying the materials didn't matter had to return it so that's kind of just one of the other examples of how this can go misuse of confidential information you know we already

072talked about in your policy that it says don't share information you receive that's confidential um it's also in our criminal statute stes so it is unlawful for you to share that information as well um if it has not been made public and here hold on so it to it is unlawful for you to acquire a pecuniary interest in any property transaction or Enterprise through confidential information that you hold or Aid another to do that so essentially insider trading don't Insider trade with all of the knowledge you gain as board members I know it's hard resist okay so criminal conflicts which we just kind of got into a little bit again you're prohibited from soliciting or receiving personal financial gain from your position um through intimidation undo influence or misuse of employees so you can't all

073those things you see in the TV dramas don't do um that doesn't include financial gain for lawfully acting in your official capacity or with approval so that goes back to those exceptions that we talked about like you know the board employing your spouse or something like that that's kind of what that's about but violation of it is a class H felony um so that's yeah this one's a little more serious if you violate it and that's punishable by imprisonment for four to 25 months um okay so then boards contracts with nonprofits this is actually a new statute that was just adopted in 202 so I say new I mean relatively speaking um but it's something that we've made sure to include in this so it applies to public officials which is y'all um and you

074can't knowingly participate in making or administering contracts with a nonprofit with which you are associated and so that is a new that's a relatively new thing um so that includes awarding money to a nonprofit that's grants loans Appropriations other things anything like that um so if you're connected to a nonprofit you have to record your recusal on those votes before the board enters into that contract which is kind of the same as you would kind of expect with any conflict you would think that you would recuse yourself prior to the board entering it okay so this includes again making or administering languag is in there again so for what that means for this policy it's deliberating or voting on the contract so the same thing about discussing sharing your view attempting to influence others that

075goes back to what we were saying again too or soliciting or receiving any gift so all the same things that we've already said are no no are still no no okay contracts and violation of this are void um automatically under statute which is kind of interesting um but they can remain in effect if it the it would harm public health or welfare if we terminated it IM immediately or the continuation is approved by the local government commission following a request for us to continue it so we would have to take it to the local government commission I'm going to be honest we don't want to do that so let's just avoid this situation um but so violations of this statute are a misdemeanor again like we've kind of talked about with other ones unless it

076was between the board and Banks Savings and Loan Association Public Utilities or is foreign interest in property conveyed through condemnation then it's not a Class one misdemeanor or is an employment relationship between the board in the spouse or stud oh yeah accepting gifts or favors don't but we're going to just give a little detail because like you know you guys go to events all the time and they have like swag that they give out and things like that so where does that line come in when you guys are out and doing stuff so this is kind of what we wanted to talk about um so y'all and covered employees um are prohibited from accepting gifts from contractors and potential contractors um and we're prohibited from giving you gifts I say as one of your contractors

077we we're prohibited from giving you gifts and favors um so the school board members of course you're covered people and but some of your employees are as well so anyone who prepares plans specifications or estimates for public contracts Wards or administers them or inspector supervises construction so those are some of the people that are covered by the statute um so a lot of time that would also be Maggie for example so it also extends to contractors subcontractors or suppliers from giving gifts and favors um if they have a contract with you right now or have performed under a contract during the past year so you may have contractors who you've worked with recently who are still subject to this and still can't give you gifts and stuff or if they anticipate bidding on a contract

078in the future them too so if they haven't if you're not working with them now but you might be in the future still can't get gifts and this is what I was kind of talking about before whereas vendors will get you in trouble gift card of the month drawing free lunch or dinner to tell you about what we can do for you um all expenses paid trip for an educational seminar sporting events during a conference like you're at a conference and they're like hey let's go catch this concert real quick all of those things will get you in trouble so these are the exceptions to that so this kind of is just to help you draw that line between you know what is a vendor doing something that's a no no versus what is something

079do gifts and honorariums for participating in meetings so if you're being recognized yeah if you're being recognized that's okay or you know if they're like hey here's a cookie thank you for coming that's that's cool we're not that worried advertising items or Souvenirs of nominal value you get a stress ball you get a izie I don't think anybody's going to say you've got a conflict of interest on that yes though the term honorarium I've heard used for code for big checks handed to um doctors by pharmaceutical companies so I really want to know not that I think I'm in danger of this but what is an acceptable honorarium and when would that ever happen with us that's a great question so um the language comes from a statute that's applicable to not just like board

080members but like every public servant in the state and so I don't think they had in mind necessarily like I I think those were the kind of honorariums they had in mind with this statute and I would say as board members use your discretion if you get an icky feeling about it um and you're like hey I probably shouldn't be getting a check for $110,000 for showing up to this meeting um you know I I think you guys kind of can figure out where that is so but if you ever have a question about it give us a call and we can you know talk it through and see the more specifics of it but we we shouldn't be receiving a check for attending a meeting or any money or anything of value anything useful

081right that is correct thank you okay thank you I'm done I rest my case he's got it we're good everyone's got it he nailed it right there um oh yeah meals furnished at Banquets so yeah if you're going to you know a award ceremony or something and they're serving dinner that's fine you can eat the dinner um if they're taking you to the steakhouse that is not a banquet um that is a bribe so let's just get real don't do that you guys will know if that's the case The Grove are uh The Grove Park hen has a wonderful banquet um I think that would be excluded as well correct the one at Christmas time where they do the oh um that's a good question I would probably say we can't buy that for you

082guys as contractors I would say we probably shouldn't yeah so that that's a good point though um okay donations to professional organizations to defay meeting expenses where governmental employees are members of such professional organizations that's one that's okay actually that's not a problem so that's more it's because it's not covering you specifically it's just helping defay the cost overall and that's kind of the difference so like you know I said earlier they can't give you an all expenses paid trip to Florida for a conference but if they're you know saying hey we're going to make this donation to this organization and help keep the cost low for everybody going to whatever that's different according to our statutes um so then customary gifts and favors between people who have a relationship outside of trying to contract

083with you that's another thing that's acceptable but you guys should kind of have that idea of like we already have an existing relationship outside of this contract that's where it's okay um so yes so this is gifts permitted to legislators are also allowed for you guys they have those same rules but for example food and beverages for immediate consumption in connection with public events so you go somewhere and they have snack set out they have fruit punch or something you guys can drink that and eat the cookies you're fine um informational materials relevant to the officials duties so if somebody just wants to give you something and say like hey for your consideration like here's a brochure that's not considered you accepting a bribe essentially um reasonable actual expenses for attending educational meetings speaking at

084a meeting attending organizational meetings that's also acceptable and that one does kind of get tricky because of what I just talked about with you know you can't get the all expenses paid trip to Florida but you can get like they'll pay for your parking if you're going to go talk at the Renaissance Hotel downtown for a conference or something you know I think that's kind of the example I would give but like that's another one where if you have it come up and you have a question about it we can look at the specific situation and make that determination but I think you guys kind of have a sense of what's reasonable versus you know an all expenses paid trip PL or non-monetary momento that you did not buy yourself and put in front of

085your trees in the campus you can accept that that's fine that's not a conflict um and Gifts accepted on behalf of the school system for the benefit of the school system so again that $10,000 check if it's written for Asheville City schools and you're just the person shaking the hand you are more than welcome to get that um it just can't be a $10,000 check to you that's the difference some more um if they're like making something available or Distributing it to the general public that's fine that kind of in my head I'm just picturing the cups and Koozies and stress balls again for that one um gifts from family members or members of the same household so if it's somebody in your family you can accept that gift as well that's not considered a

086contract a conflict um gifts given as part of a business relation again the relationship outside of your relationship Contracting with them that's fine food and beverages for immediate consumption if not given by a lobbyist um so that's different or if provided during a conference or meeting under certain circumstances which the statute doesn't Define uh but but yeah so essentially the same thing if you're at a conference or somewhere and somebody's like hey do you want me to grab you a cup of punch that's fine um food and beverages at an organized Gathering where you're invited to attend for relation for reasons related to your official duties same thing somebody invites you to come to a formal breakfast or something that's fine you can eat the food um okay but violations of this if you are

087accepting that $10,000 check for yourself Class one misdemeanor um and you can't claim them as a tax deduction so important the so our attorney general has interpreted this statute as prohibiting those who are doing business or seeking to including us as your attorneys from taking you or others out for meals so I'm very sorry we will not be getting yall Ruth's Chris um that is we are not statutorily allowed and we do not want to be criminals um okay so like I mentioned earlier I was going to go over the federal conflict of interest as well because of course there's a lot of overlap but there's also some differences between the federal conflict of rules versus the state conflict of interest rules um so this comes from the IRS uniform guidance we'll see ug throughout

088this a lot um and this does apply to y'all um particularly when it comes to contracts with Federal money that's where the federal principles are applicable you all yeah so all of the titles Ida nutrition car's act Sesser money not as relevant now on the Sesser money but yeah so we have to have a written policy that includes these uniform guidance rules we do it's already there um and purchasing rules procurement procedures we also have those um so your requirements are you can't have a real or apparent conflict of interest interest in a contract involving Federal money that's essentially it and so how that comes up would be if you or um your family so that's the other difference here we kind of talked about the brother earlier and how that kind of felt icky

089for some people if it was dealing with Federal money it would be a conflict so it makes sense that you wouldn't feel great about that um but yeah so if you or someone in your family or your business would get financial benefit financial gain or another tangible personal benefit from the contract award then it's a conflict under the federal laws but keeping in mind that that's only for contracts involving Federal money okay so similar to under state law you got a conflict you can't deliberate vote on or participate in the contract in any way don't tell us if you support it you can't do any of that um the consequences range from audit findings up to loss of federal federal funds which is a lot of money so that would be bad um and it

090can also lead to a criminal referral for individual board members if they find reason for that as well so this is just a handy little chart you guys will have on hand that you can kind of see the differences between that uniform guidance from the IRS and what our state requirements are um the big one to me is the whole where do the federal rules apply um so I think that's our biggest piece of it is we've I've talked that one to death um it also applies to benefit obtained by the employee or board member or your immediate family so that difference as well where State it's only you and your spouse it's you and your family and your business partners for federal and the benefit standard is very broad because of that tangible personal

091benefit language um that's a lot broader than sort of those limited three reasons that it's considered a direct benefit under state law so that's something to keep in mind as well um and it applies to any Financial or other interest tangible personal benefit ever received by a contractor for federal law um whereas it's not quite that broad for state law um because it's for that specific contract under state law not any ever so the big takeaways the federal rules are more expansive um they don't come up as often because generally when we're dealing with Federal money it's not as many like local people that you know that we're getting involved with so it doesn't come up as much but it does come up um these are federal purchasing standards but it couldn't lead to federal

092or state criminal laws being violated with the conflicts of interest being involved um and if you're in doubt air on the side of caution give us a call we're happy to talk to you if you ever have concerns so before we jump anybody have any questions on conflicts feel I you guys I I I feel good about y'all in this I'm not going to lie I I feel good about y'all so I I'm not too worried about y'all with that one okay so these are some other duties that you guys have under the statute you have a duty to provide General control and supervision of all School matters um and so the specific thing there is that that duty is for the things that are not expressly conferred and imposed upon some other official so

093a lot of those control and supervision things are imposed on Maggie and that's why we do that training on you know here's where our line is um because y'all's duty is for those things that aren't imposed on someone else you do have General control and supervision of all matters um in the public schools and your respective administrative units and to enforce those rules um so here's an example the duty to provide Financial oversight I mean Amy you already already said it budget is one of the biggest things for y'all that's at the core so you are required to have an annual Financial audit of all accounts that happens it's already happening um and you're required to get a copy of the audit and review it and your internal audit procedures and submit a plan for

094corrective action where necessary to the local government commission this one is one of my favorites um because it's got a lot of case law history I'm not going to get into all of it but we're going to get into it a little bit um but so you have a duty to provide an adequate school system so North Carolina's state constitution gives everyone a right to a public education to a sound basic education it's in our constitution um and so our courts have defined this in a case called Leandro that I'm sure you guys have heard of it's almost as old as I am um and the kid who was the plaintiff for that case is a partner in a law firm it's been going on so long so it's it's a little and it's still

095going we're still waiting for a new ruling on this but in this case they defined what a sound basic education is um and so this is what our courts have said it's the sufficient ability to read write and speak the English language and sufficient knowledge of fundamental mathematics physical science to enable them to function in society then we also have to provide sufficient fundamental knowledge of geography history and basic economic and political systems for them to make informed choices so continuing on this and you see our case site there that was the first time it went to the Supreme Court um it's been bounced up and down several times it's it's anyway um but so the other requirements are sufficient academic and Vocational skills to enable them to successfully engage after graduation and to allow

096them to compete for formal education or gain ful employment in a contemporary Society that's what Leandro says that's kind of what we've been working off of as the model for almost 30 years now um but we have this new case that came out 2020 one or two I don't want to say for certain because I'll get it wrong um called deminsky versus the State Board of Education this added to that definition of what is a sound basic education in this case a student was subjected to really really terrible harassment um I won't get into the details but essentially nothing was done to address the bullying that this child was experiencing and it was so severe that the court determined that we have to provide a safe environment where learning can take place in order to

097meet our requirement to provide a sound basic education so we can't be deliberately indifferent to issues of harassment and bullying in our school setting or we could be denying someone a sound basic education um another Duty you have is to participate in certain suits and actions you're required to Institute suit to collect all monies due to it so that one sounds weird I it does um but so the thing that comes to mind for me for that is Bond forfeitures um which y'all have addressed through policy you give us the authority to handle those and then we do it um so you guys don't generally get involved with that but we do handle those on y'all's behalf under your policy um and that's kind of the thing that comes to mind when I see that

098um the other is you're presumed to be correct you get a presumption of correctness in all actions brought against you we will raise that as a defense every single time um but yes so the other party has to show that you aired in some way if they're going to sue you so you also have the authority to assign students to attendance areas um that's kind of you know within your District obviously you can't assign students to another District um but within your District you follow your own policies on how you assign students um you can't transfer your Authority on that um or delegate it regarding student assignment and then if you've been divid or if the local board has divided the geographic area into attendance districts or zones the students are assigned within those zones

099you guys have policies On Assignment we follow those and those policies are based on the statutory requirements so students can be assigned outside of such attendance districts this really isn't this really doesn't affect y'all very much because you have school anyway um but you can for these reasons um and several more so you can one of them is any reason which yall in your discretion deemed sufficient as a basis but that doesn't really come up for y'all too much okay big things no person can be refused admission or excluded from school based on their race Creed color or national origin and no attendance Zone may be drawn for the purpose of segregating students yes yes sure so so that one works a little differently and is governed by a separate statute and policy because it's

100consider because I believe it's considered an alternative learning program and so with that that's governed by a separate policy regarding the assignment it goes through a multi-disciplinary team one of the options is parental consent for assignment there but um there can be an administrative assignment there as well but it has to go through the multidisciplinary team process in order for that to happen so that's a that's outside of this yep well I'm I I think I actually have some guidance already written out on that if you ever want to take a look at it okay fair enough but yeah so that's that's handled separately but yeah so our our own wonderful state has the Supreme Court saying you can't segregate schools um so social emotional learning in the general statutes we do have requirements to

101provide it in certain circumstances um under the idea and section 54 for students who have social and emotional delays and deficits we have to address that in their IEPs or Section 504 plans as necessary um the NC healthful living curriculum also requires us to include instruction on mental and emotional health um and then also both reproductive health and safety education programs have to include instruction on health and emotional problems um and you know we we think this is relevant for this last bullet here um our school Mental Health Initiative for the state found that almost 20% of students in North Carolina have a mental health or substance abuse disorder um and so this obligation is relevant and necessary so you also have the authority to make rules concerning the conduct and duties of personnel that's

102through your policymaking function that's why we have a whole bunch of policies on staff responsibilities and duties and how we address those also have a duty to ensure the freedom of religion within your school system um and so this requirement goes along with our US Constitution of course that we have to ensure both the freedom to practice one's own's religion in the schools and and to prevent the coercion of religious practices on students um so generally um can't infringe on individual rights or or endorse a religion as a public school body um not generally protected by courts exposure to things contrary to one's religious beliefs so students may be exposed to things that are contrary to their religious beliefs and that is not a violation of the First Amendment um that's being a part of

103the public um so that's what that is so some of State um or some case law that kind of addresses and builds those boundaries better for us one of the first ones is Barnett which was which determined that Jehovah's Witnesses can't be required to stand or salute the American flag um Wisconsin V yoders another one and these are all cases that were I mean I think the earliest one was in the 60s but so they're all from around that time moving forward but a lot of them have been in place for a very long time um so mandatory age of attendance for students in Wisconsin who were Amish was also lifted as a religious requirement for them um and religious objection to compuls compulsory military training that was also upheld by our courts um and

104a religious objection to wearing IM modest apparel in co-educational physical educ ation classes so that's also protected so religious rights in schools recognized by statutes statutory opt out so students can engage in prayer and religious activities on school campus yes B I hate to ask but because of the weird phrasing of that immoral or no IM IM modest sorry can you explain that just ever so briefly absolutely so I can't remember what sect it was but it was a religious sect that requires women to you know wear long skirts and dress modestly um as one of their religious requirements and they were saying the requirement to wear pants or shorts for a gym class or change out into that uniform where it was like a t-shirt so their arms were exposed and their legs were

105exposed that was considered under their religious sect to be immodest um and so for the purpose of their their religious definition that was the definition that was applied there yeah but so like I said students can engage in prayer and religious activities on campus um parents can grant or deny their students participation in any portion of sex education instruction um and parents can object to immunization requirements and be granted a um they they don't NE a uh I'm blanking on a word but thank you that was the word it was just completely out of my head for a second but thank you yeah it can be granted a waiver for religious objection to immunization and we can't we cannot say them having a religious objection to immunization means they cannot attend public school that's what

106that comes down to can I ask a question about that one yeah what if there is an outbreak of an of a disease that is preventable by immunization is it within the school's right to exclude children who are not immunized because of risk to their health so that's a great question no they have this they maintain their right to a public education um and so we cannot exclude them I mean if we needed to take emergency protective measures we would have to discuss that and really think through what would be possible without violating their rights um but yeah I mean yeah I think that's yeah that's why everyone went home and Co but um okay but so things we can't do we can't sponsor Bible readings or recitations of the Lord's Prayer um schools can't

107eliminate Evolution from the biology curriculum and we can't require schools teach creationism and science um we also can't invite clergymen to pray at commencement they've made a ruling on that that one is interesting and I kind of like to talk about that one because there are opportunities like boards can take a moment of silence before their meetings or they may want um a prayer or something to sort of uh make it more somber of an event or something but the requirements on that are very strict they're not quite as clear-cut as this the requirements on that are things like you if you're going to invite a clergyman of one type to come and pray at a board meeting you got to invite clergymen from all different religions to have that same opportunity um you can't

108that it goes back to that you can't support a specific religion um but yeah so that's where that comes up the most frequently okay so you also have a duty to establish an alternative learning program and develop policies and guidelines we kind of just got into that so the good news is you guys have policies and guidelines for assigning to the Alternative Learning Program which you have um so you have to have at least one you do and you have to adopt policies consistent with that you already have them all right and you guys have finished your two hours of Ethics training yes you're welcome too that's why we give you the opportunity thank you very much good evening um tonight we're going to take just a little bit closer look at C I think

109many of you remember previous conversations about the community eligibility provision available through our school nutrition program I am going to admit right up front I'm going to give you the overview and we have the experts right here in case you have some more in-depth questions um but it is time to take another look at this for a lot of reasons and I I know a lot of times you're approached very often about parents wondering why we are one of the few districts that don't quite take advantage of this program yet so um wh there we go all right so you know overall everybody knows our school nutrition program is the program that actually provides our um lunches and breakfast to all our students we do have one school current Curr doing the free uh not

110free but well it is free uh fresh fruit and vegetable program and um we do summer feeding as well um that model changes every year depending on the programs that we have and how many children are going to participate um obviously some some of our students pay for their meals some of their students have free meals some of our students have reduced meals and then all of those meals are actually covered in some amount um by USDA reimbursement but that's something that we have to look at a little more closely as we're talking about uh C and what everybody really needs to understand is because of that USDA reimbursement component of our program um Melissa and Nick have to be very cognizant of what all the stringent requirements are um to meet the federal back

111to Anna's Point uh Federal grant requirements um a lot of people don't realize that this is monitored and um Ed as a Federal grant so um School nutrition is also what is considered actually is a very unique thing in our audit report and that they're audited almost separately from everything else because they're considered an Enterprise fund so that's a big long word for somebody to understand that basically they're um you know they're considered a unit like a McDonald's or a or a longhorn or a Olive Garden they're supposed to run that operation as if they're a business so that business is supposed to not only take care of our students but try to run not in the red and in the black because that program is supposed to be sustainable from year to year um

112the main components of our school nutrition program actually our participation just like a restaurant if we don't have enough kids show up is a very expensive program to run they need to show up for breakfast lunch and we need to um hope hopefully build our staff participation as well in order to make the program sustainable um the other larger the larger costs that were involved obviously are food and supplies which now actually run basically through chart Wells through a per meal equivalent that we pay for them to manage the program and then salaries and benefits now historically here salaries and benefits obviously been paid by the district which has a much higher cost of benefits Chartwells um will now hire all the new hires and find any substitutes that are needed and hopefully more and

113more over time um we wanted to honor those employees that were already employed by us and not make changes for them but then as we um transition to the Chartwells payroll hopefully we will secure some savings for the program those costs are balanced by again paid meals supplemental sales and then not only USD reimbursements but we also received some Commodities that um we were able to help reduce the cost of our program I I tried to do this little donut because everybody likes Donuts but the dut is kind of split in half um there's not a lot to say about it basically about half our cost is uh the food and supplies and the other half of our cost really is salaries and benefits now something to think about is um fixed costs as a

114component of this um obviously if we have a school of 200 or we have a school like um Mr edwards's School there, 1600 it there's a certain amount of staff that Nick and Melissa cannot run a c cafeteria with as far as there's only so few you can employ and then as you add meals to that you really don't have to add meals at the rate that you might think to add um add people at the rate that you might add meals so um that's part of the um issue that we struggle with right now is we have a lot of small schools in our campuses across the district so Community eligibility it is a great program um it started a number of years ago um and really targeted High poverty districts uh which is

115obviously in a higher the poverty District you are it's a win-win situation because you fully qualify all your schools everyone is entitled to free meals and this is just a way to be able to let the entire uh community of students eat for free but in districts like ours where those statistics are not quite the same that's when those uh decisions to do this get a little bit more difficult so I'm not going to read all the words on this page but again like I said to you in the retreat I like to have a handout sometimes that gives you the information because sometimes I know a lot of you go back and read it and think about it and I wanted you to have it but what we hear a lot right now is

116well why has an Ashville City School's done this this threshold to enter this program has dropped to 25% and there's no reason we shouldn't be doing this well that's a great Point uh if I were a parent I would be asking the same thing but all that does is let us participate in the program it does not change at all how much the USDA will reimburse us for the meals um that we serve through the program so if you look at those percentages just across the board in that that piece I bolded in in yellow um Melissa can attest that DPI when this first came out said you know you all don't need to look at this program unless you can hit that qualification at at least 60% because it just won't be sustainable well

117then they dropped the elig well the eligibility came out at 40% well look at our percentages you know very you know some of our schools meet it some of our schools don't so what a lot of schools districts did across the state is they'd start serving free meals to just some of their campuses the ones that qualified well in the districts I've been associated with that's very diff difficult then to explain to the other parents well why do these kids get free meals and the rest of these students do not so it it makes it a very complicated decision when you are not high poverty and all districts I mean all schools qualify um so right now I guess I liken that to the fact that some of those budget conversations we've already had you

118know we are very fortunate here on some levels and that we are tier three County you're not economically distressed here so at the same time these percentages are also very low so I was surprised though to find out we are in the lowest 10 to 15% of eligibility in the state and that is largely due to those same criteria and that most of our families here do not qualify for free and reduced meals so um why is that that big a deal you know if it's a little bit of a difference in reimbursement rate you might think well is that still a big difference well in the one of the lower paragraphs there um the difference is that on a a paid students lunch we only get 50 um 53 cents and on a free

119students lunch we get $454 so when you think about that if we provide free meals to a lot of students that don't actually qualify for free meals and we're only getting 53 cents versus $454 that's where the numbers start not working so um the also the thing is you know if you have a huge District and you have a few students that drop in and out of qualification it doesn't M make that big a difference in your final bottom line numbers but in such a small District like we are just a few students can kick these percentages one way or the other so that is another reason why I'm sure in the past that you all have actually um been discouraged from taking advantage of this because even last year our district y percent didn't

120meet the 40% criteria that had originally been set for this program it was only at 39% so um the good news on this would be is if if that decision is ever made to go c as we are right now is what our criteria would be to enter the program and it's frozen for four years so the only thing that could do is go up they review it every year in April April 1 and um so if we could improve our status in the program and our statistics help us they'll change it but they won't ever make it worse and then every year you have an opportunity to stay in or out and every four years then again the entire process starts over um but I'm going to touch on a minute ago I mean

121in a minute just why that is a very difficult decision though to ever walk back once you make that so why are we bringing this up now um one of the things is we hear a lot of you know the the qualifications to get free meals is very low family income has to be really low for someone especially with two or three or four kids so we have a lot of families that are on that bubble that just miss out on getting free meals and could really need those free meals right now especially with the current situation as it is with the hurricane we're still struggling with um a majority of the districts in North Carolina do participate in the program whether it's profitable or not because they've deemed that as something they need to

122do um students obviously we want them to eat nutritious meals we want that participation um we have struggled here over the years with student meal debt which takes a lot of time energy and um um frustration basically on the part of staff and families um last year and currently currently about halfway to what we usually are um in the course of a year and that's usually about $25,000 so that's one of those things that we can't um pursue in any way um and the district or the school schools just have to eat that um deficit at the end of every year um costs cons uh continue to escalate our reimbursements don't keep Pace with the cost participation here continues to lag our um student count continues to decrease which hurts again in managing those fixed

123costs um with our small uh small school sizes so the big thing to understand is historically and and now uh in the the only way for kidss to get free reduced meals is to collect those applications which is not a lot of fun uh folks don't like filling them out as again a lot of them fill them out and just to get frustrated to find out they don't qualify so what the uh C program does which is a big Plus in my opinion is that it does take the record straight from uh the government assistance programs and Medicaid Med uh North Carolina was good and added Medicaid not everybody has done that so that's allowed more students to qualify um so it's really a painless process as far as parents don't have to fill out

124another Form and we don't have to try to get those verify those and have to keep up with those because those are audited very closely as well um I would love to come in and give you some really exact numbers about how well our program is doing right now but bless bless our folks heart I mean they've they've had one obstacle after another if it hasn't been hurt hurricane it's been water if it hasn't you know was covid a couple years ago and it's just very difficult to evaluate the program what we know right now is our participation is not where it needs to be and we are running a deficit like so many other districts across the state and the country um but what I do need to stress to you is if you

125look at this program and move forward with this program it's not without any risk because we see all the time in the news how this is a Battleground question question and it shouldn't you wouldn't think feeding CH children should be a Battleground question but it is so you know the criteria could change cost can and will change reimbursements can and will change student count qualifications can change so all those things could either help or hurt that bottom line and once that decision is made to provide free meals to everybody it is extremely difficult to ever walk that back so I just want to stress that as we continue to talk about this this um as far as financial implications go I already mentioned the student meal debt um what the situation is is we do

126have about 300 to $350,000 worth of income every year uh every year from students that actually do pay for their meals which if we go with free meals obviously they will no longer be paying that but our lunch participation um currently is only about 33% and our breakfast is only about 11% so I think honestly we have a lot of room to grow and what the C program lets you do is it lets you encourage students to take the tray take the breakfast go let's make alternate serving models let's serve breakfast in the classroom do more Second Chance breakfast we get uh we meet with our administrators and find a way to partner and make sure that this isn't something that interrupts their day but something that benefits all the students to the largest extent

127possible and we get more and more and more participation and the more more participation the more successful the program and the financial results will be um our regional director with Chartwells ran some numbers for me Melissa ran some numbers for me and with um no change in participation it looks like going with this program would lose an additional $80,000 a year but with just a 10% increase in participation that would shrink to a $440,000 loss and with just a 20% increase in participation that would become really close to break even and I do not see how with the numbers we have right now that would not be doable yes ma'am hey can I just clarify this said that currently the trajectory I'm sorry this is sorry currently the trajectory was about 500,000 in loss and

128then the next paragraph says an additional 80,000 I just wanted to make sure we're saying 580,000 combined at the moment and now last spring I do want to say last spring our results kicked up considerably and so if we get our water back we get our water back you know hopefully they will see those kind of results again and that might be smaller but I'm laying it out there just very real right now to let you know that's kind of where we are um may I ask a quick question also about this on this slide um does that take into account or not take into account the $25,000 in debt in other words if we um if we if we give all free and reduced lunch then there's no debt right I suppose that doesn't

129really matter in terms of our bottom line result for the district that I did not put that in this number because we've always had a make up for that on the side but that would be a benefit yes um something that stood out to me was ISP is multiplied by a factor of 1.6 so in Practical terms the ISP is that data or that number is pulled from what is it supposed to roughly represent the kids that would that would be predicted to qualify for free what they're trying to do is make up for the fact that not everyone is going to be picked up through direct certification is that not kind of what it had in mind right but the 1 point6 adds to the number of free meals we can get because I

130think they're trying to take into account we no longer get the applications and currently you do import direct certified um uh kids into the system based on children whose families are receiving Medicaid or um uh SNAP benefits is that correct yes I import that file every day to catch as many students as possible awesome and then the other thing that I think is important for board members that I learned some years back is that a family could qualify in a month when they have low income and they don't have to re-qualify for the rest of the school year and so this might be a perfect time to qualify more families if we make an effort to do that am I somewhat accurate on that yes um in anytime a family's income changes they're more than

131welcome to reapply if they've applied already thank you does that also apply to post Hela when people qualified for the Emergency snap yes yes thank you so basically in a nutshell I mean in the near term we're looking at still committing some local funding in order to supplement the program in order to make this work but in the long term and with the help of Chartwells and the expertise they bring to the program I really um sincerely think that with the work we can do with our administrators across the district we can increase those participation numbers significantly and make this a viable option for us um I can't guarantee it though and that's kind of what I'm want to bring it very loud and clear today you know and it's not an instant overnight process

132because that takes time and it takes a lot of work um to change some of those mindsets and processes and check do they have enough time when they get off the bus to even eat you know is is the best scenario for this school every school's set up differently every school wants different services in different ways so um what I like personally like about it is every everybody gets free meals um the um variety uh that we could offer and the serving models that we could offer to better accommodate our students is good that stigma around free and reduced meals uh is completely eliminated those administrative um complexities of monitoring the application getting applications in families all that frustration is eliminated um and the stress and the countless hours dedicated toward collecting that School Meal

133debt is eliminated through this model so obviously it it's not a an easy decision but it is information we wanted to bring you at this point and give you the timeline as to when this would have to happen so um as U Melissa said we get the new official qualifying information August F uh April 1st um even though what we said tonight should be closed um and then the state communicates that out and they make a spreadsheet that lists every District across the state and where they land on this and then um obviously by the end of the school year is when we have to make a final decision but of course you may want to if you decide that communicate that out to parents sooner than right at the last minut you have anything

134want to add um just the districts we worked with across the state that do like to do c we do T typically see those participation increases that Heidi's kind of mentioned um every school district's different um you know you can't guarantee that a certain number will be what it is but it it definitely has been a successful program in other North Carolina districts that we're in um quick question why why does this um why would this resolve re and I doesn't matter but I'm curious about why this would result in a variety more V greater variety of serving models implemented like what's the what's the difference between what we can serve now and what we would serve under this program sure um I don't it wouldn't really change the food um it would be a

135more like how we could serve breakfast in the classroom a little bit easier we don't have to um you know we can you know encourage students to participate you know that take a if you're going to serve breakfast in a classroom and know 20 kids are going to participate because it's free versus two kids that might be willing to pay okay then you can justify in that investment of staff and time and clean up to do it okay thank you yes sir uh one of the things that I've loved to be able to look at when I look at um uh testing Gap and performance and and efficiency data is the freee and reduced lunch uh demographic data that's on our website um I've shared the link to that with the other board members but

136it's it's visible on the food and nutrition part of the website for the general public would we still be putting out those demographic reports and would it just be the imported data or would we lose the demographic reports in the future it's not a huge consideration for me but I'm wondering if we know what kind of reports we'd be putting out on demographics under this plan well we would have the direct SE information um and they've worked I know Ernest is probably grimacing over there because initially some of the concern with CP and I had it when we were at Rutherford before we started it was that will this impact the qualification in our federal programs because that has traditionally been free and reduced lunch count but using the modifier with the 1.6 Excuse Me

137multiplier um they've adjusted for that at DPI with the grant process so we don't have to worry about that aspect of it that's a huge relief thank you very much so that actually brings up the question I wanted to ask which is and it it could be on here and of course granted there's a lot of information on here so I apologize for missing it so C p is funded by the state or it's ultimately funded by the federal government no it it's funded it's a federally funded F it's Federal USDA reimbursement we just get the pay that we would get the free rate okay for up to that percentage the 40 some percent times the 1.6 becomes a 70 some percent that is the number of students up to that percentage that we would

138get free reimbursement for versus I mean yes free versus paid okay so not to split hairs too much but you said said it's through the FDA not through the Department of Education I justda USDA USDA administers the school the the lunch and breakfast programs okay um it does go through DPI again I'm just you know with with the things we're hearing about what's happening in Washington now the governor that was something I put on one of the slides the governor just made a proposal to try to suggest that again which I think is a great idea un unal free breakfast and lunch for all kids while we're not doing that already I'm not sure but um he has proposed that maybe the that our state consider Bridging the Gap you know whatever the Gap is

139between that Federal reimbursement gotcha and free that's what they would do which would be great too so and they did a similar thing with breakfast and reduced meals right want to check in with board members um Heidi and Chartwells folks are here to take questions I see on the slide you know is there more information we need I think what I'm checking in with is everybody think this is a good idea and we would vote next week do we need more time and we want more information what do you all need I do not need more information or time does that mean you're in support absolutely okay just check in other if we had it on the agenda to allow voting for de today I'd go for it um perhaps uh voting to do a

140four-year trial of this you know knowing that things would change or potentially change in four years but to re-evaluated in four years I think that's kind of implicit in the model isn't it I mean I think we have to reconsider it in four years that's fair I don't need any additional information I'm in favor of it appr I think we're ready to put this on the agenda next week Heidi that was super helpful though I appreciated the how it's going to tie into our budget conversations as well can I just ask a budget question because mostly a math question so we're currently trajectory 500,000 loss we might see another 880,000 and then you wrote when we see an increase of 20% we would break even do you mean we would eradicate the 500,000 loss or

141is it I just want a reality check that the program might still continue to run at a loss but not as big a loss it will continue to run at a loss for the immediate future but that 20% increase would bring us really close to Breaking assuming all the other things stay the same that's another you know so um anything anything 20% above if we like for example in Rutherford we knew we could Target breakfast better than lunch so we really put those other breakfast models out there and we almost nailed 100% breakfast participation so then lunch could be lower and we still I mean it took what is it this this past year was the first year they really saw so what is that four years or five years I mean it could be

142a four or five year process easy but it it it should get us back on the right track and like you said then we can can always reconsider our options thank you very very much for that information you're um I think we go back to Maggie for board meeting calendar all right so on in the agenda we listed out the board meeting I'm so sorry um I'm hearing that we are at the two-hour Mark let me ask board members this do you want to take a f minute break now do you want Maggie to finish this and then we come back to budget not meant to be loaded question to you I would prefer to break now but okay is is that okay Maggie we'll take a five minute break yeah all right folks e

143e e um it's not quite the budget meeting calendar it's just the regular board meeting calendar but it is the tentative dates um up for the board's consideration for our meeting schedule um in 2526 followed our normal protocol for the first and second Monday when possible um except for like Spring Break um kind of messes us up in April and then January we tentatively scheduled board Retreats and a weather makeup day um and I know there was a question from a board member about making like regular and work sessions so what we could do is we could adopt those as a regular meeting and a work session um or keep them on as Retreat and make a modification later but I wanted to go ahead and get the calendar for the most part set so

144we can start because that will drive the rest of our meeting calendars um for admin um I had the pleasure of um having coffee with a former board chair John ledgerton last week um and and Delvin into a little bit of the history he mentioned that we used to have um two board Retreats uh which allowed us to look at mid year and then after the end of the school year um uh just proficiency testing data and all of that and so I'd love to hear your perspective of of um how we can address that yeah I mean we can definitely schedule a retreat for that um for the February 10th next week's regular board session we are scheduled for Shannon and her team to do a mid-year review of student proficiency data um so

145we can do it during a regular board meeting or you know if the board wants to dedicate you know extended time to talking about it that's something that we could also do at a retreat but we do have it Incorporated in our regular board meeting schedule I I was thinking in regards to next year's calendar how best to do right that's what yeah so the board could decide do we want to switch and add a retreat at different times to do that or we can continue with what we've been doing last year and had planned for this year which is to embed it in a regular scheduled meeting so that's up for the board but let me just ask a more pointing question to board members in January what is your thoughts about should we

146have a regular work session and regular meeting in January only if the staff I mean if if Dr Ferman thinks it's helpful to do that I'm open to it the Retreats I find difficult because they're all day so I I mentioned that in a emailed a Dr Ferman earlier today who was expressing some sort of um support for the notion of two Retreats I'm open to that but I'd prefer that they not be full day that's just I have to take a day off and I'd prefer to do more of like a half day even if it's five hours I can still take half a day instead of a whole day so I'm seeing a lot of head nodding while eating cinnamon buns um so what what I'm hearing is let me just try to

147find out that yes there's appetite for two Retreats during the school year at half days if they seem appropriate yes py or two opportunities to look at at the data a mid year and a after the close of the year that's that's all that I was expressing however that fits into the schedule uh my inclination would be to to the the content of Retreats would be up to Maggie to set I mean I don't I don't intend to get into that I think also we actually do get data twice a year we get it when we get the last year's data in the fall and then we get midyear data in the spring am I right about that in terms of like yeah after we do our midyear assessments right and then I mean we

148get the official data from the prior year in our October meeting I think something like that November anyway Y and then as far as I I still yield to whatever Dr Ferman wants about a work session and board meeting in January I personally coming off the holidays love the vacation but if it's something that we should do I'm totally supportive I I am in favor of the idea of two shorter Retreats and having a regular January schedule um whether it includes both a work session and a um but I do find that the whole January becomes sort of this period where we don't have sort of regular business happening and it becomes tricky for us this January was unique with everything happening around County Commission and consolidation so there was all this extra work but

149I can remember in previous years it was it felt like a long time to go without sort of doing regular business but the idea of having to half day Retreats makes that all feel more doable I like I think it supports the Cadence of our work I I also like the idea now that I'm heing the two half day Retreats of somewhat following the structure that this District itself follows where you've got Educators coming back to The District in August I'm not obviously it's whatever we deide as a group but us kind of following that example and we come together in August to kind of tee up the year for us and a kind of a half day way um half a retreat way and then come back together after the holidays similar to the

150semester ending it's another chance for us to kind of reconvene so um and then I also Echo what Rebecca said it just feels it's a long slog from our meeting at the beginning of December into February where I feel like in years past we have had to call a special meeting almost every January to get some work done so having it already in place so I'm hearing generally support for adding a work session in a um Regular board meeting in January and um I think giving back to Maggie that we're open to two halfday Retreats for you to fill in as needed and we can always cancel a meeting got it is that board members are okay with this okay great thanks Maggie now it's um so the first um budget is the amendment and

151expenditure report where did oh Heidi if you want to talk through those that'd be great sure this evening you do have the expenditure report that syns up to the current budget amendment um the majority of the state budget um Amendment items had to do with Hurricane Relief just for your information we received 89,1 $99 for mental health support and $114,000 to try to make whole the month of hurricane leave granted to the school nutrition employees and the chart worlds employees which came out almost exactly right so I was I tickled with that um in fund two obviously um we are showing a decrease in Revenue based on the recent County decision and for the moment um as a placeholder I have only added in an addition $500,000 of fund balance because I'm still trying to

152evaluate where we are on indirect costs and those type of things for this year and um where we're standing on our spending so I I put that in there but know that it could be that we may have to bump that back up just a little bit more because that that decrease from them was a little over $700,000 and then fines and pull fores were coming in Anna and her firm are not getting all no I'm kidding no they're uh I think what happened last year is that covid caught up is that there were a lot of things postponed and put off and so our fines and forfeitures were actually a lot better last year than usual and this year we're kind of back to normal is that fair that's part of it and then

153also the hurricane impacted some of that as well and delay still kind of well yeah and you know there were also fewer charges and fewer misc dates because of the yeah so so it's a combination of things thanks for the clarification I appreciate that um so then in federal funds we've had very little adjustment at the moment um we are we did get some um amendments from Mr sesum and we're working on those this is the time of year everybody starts looking at what they have left to spend and we'll have some changes on that and there are some allotment adjustments will need to be posting soon I in the capital outlife fund don't get too excited we didn't really just get two2 million new dollars but I did put a placeholder in insurance and

154in federal support because um we will be getting some kind of we have to have a balanced budget so we will be at some point getting some insurance reimbursements and feem money probably won't come in this soon but in order to have the expenditures on one side I have to have revenue on the other side so what I've done right now and we have no idea what that total is yet but I put a million dollars in each of those line items as a placeholder so we're starting to put in purchased orders Mr Shelton and his team are starting to get some of those things replaced so we need to have a budget in there to cover those um and then School nutrition fund I have lowered our expectation for revenue and expense there a

155little bit as a placeholder for now again we'll be reviewing that more in the spring when we start ramping back up hopefully our participation and then in fund eight we just had a few minor adjustments for some small grants and donations that's all I have at this time any questions for Heidi about this amendment this looks great I I guess this is more of a side comment I'm just wondering how we managed in this document last year to get an extra looks like $5 million into the general fund and I just wanted to thank you for um all of your efforts members comments questions about the budget amendment um so this will go on next Monday's agenda for us to vote on thanks Heidi all right next up is now let's start looking ahead for

156the FY 26 budget um and this is you know as we start planning budget we know a little bit more about what we could potentially anticipate from our local assessments and looking at that staying steady or potentially decreasing um you know we need to understand from the board what your priorities might be what are things you're like don't even go there with um so just wanting to assess from the board's perspective and um I think this is a time to start thinking a little more how do we get our public behind us particularly for increasing the local Ashville City School tax um so I've been kind of coming up with some strategies to to get the word out into the public and make sure that the public is putting some of that pressure um if

157they hopefully they support increasing that tax um into the full 12% but you know have some strategies around that and um just this is that opportunity for our board to share you know what do you want us to make sure we focus on whether it is keeping class sizes constant whether it is um you know what kind of pay raises can we give keep class sizes constant so you know we get a limited amount of funds and we can always look for additional Grant funds and opportunities to expand our our Revenue knowing that you know usually that's one time type funding that we can fund things for but not necessarily Personnel um so just curious this is that this is the time for you to share that information with Heidi and I so we can

158start looking around and also what questions you might have so when we have the board work session for Budget on the 18th we also can start pulling data for you um Maggie I'm really interested in looking back at last year and what we asked of the county 3 whatever million it was mostly to find mental health and recognizing that we now are facing a reality that we're basically back two years um in terms of funding from from local funds um is there any where do we stand in terms of providing adequate mental health support for our students and our staff um and is there room whether it's fiscally or even you know operationally to provide more support for our students and staff coming out of okay um the hurricane that's yeah that's a great question

159that we can pull more resources for and gather some more information for the 18th but yep writee that one down that's a great question I know that for me um not reducing our class sizes um providing uh some flexibility for our principles in figuring out the the budget puzzle and the Staffing puzzle is important um I don't want us to fall out of compliance uh with licensing due to uh any forced reductions in staff um I am uh wanting at some point to Circle back with the board members um on uh the issue of potentially voluntarily providing money back to the county this year um and working with them because right now they've got a shortfall in meeting their goals to uh maintain the AAA Bond rating which does affect us um I am wanting

160to pull all the board members at some point to see where they are with that this might not be the moment but just having that conversation and seeing what other creative ideas we may have whether it is expanding the district um uh boundaries into commercial zones or working with um uh bunam County schools on the district map um um and uh just trying to um figure out how we can as I've put it before make lemonade out of lemons um and uh build support for as Maggie was uh talking about um uh building support for restoring our Asheville City Schools tax and whether the County Commissioners might be more supportive if we were to as a board in advance Advance vote to allocate the last quarter Cent half cent hypothetically speaking from that to early

161childhood education and I would want um uh Maggie and Heidi and our uh um uh Susanna Smith to to weigh on in on what that could mean for uh serving our school district and our County I want to hear from other board members and they can weigh in on their thoughts at that time that might be a good way to gauge with onot I'd like to Echo um providing flexibility for our principles in Staffing their buildings appropriately knowing that from year to year the the challenges very very widely from building to building um and uh I I am in favor of approaching the the idea of um raising the tax again related to the sorry is that are were you done I just okay awesome um related to so two questions one I would love

162at some point for Anna for you to give us some advice on this whole District boundary thing because my understanding is that has to be done at the state level if I'm wrong then Enlighten us um but um or any other impediments or opportunities that you see related to that um I would love to see us figure out a way to Garner public support for the higher tax and one thing that occurs to me is I know we survey our families to death but it wouldn't be a bad idea it seems to me to to ask our families if they would be willing to pay a higher tax rate if it meant whatever we want to say it would mean um you know the the possibility the you know basically trying to counteract the reductions

163that everybody knows we've gotten um the other thing that is I'm always mindful of is what we're hearing from the Commissioners and what we heard loudly and clearly is that they want cooperation and I know we've talked um informally about looking at early college and other places where we might be able to collaborate but they also want us to continue looking at and this was something the consolidation study showed was our smaller schools and we just heard it again from nutrition so this isn't for this year but it is something that I think we have to be mindful of um if as we move forward whether or not our footprint as I've heard Contin needs to continue to be examined um with the hope that we don't have to change it but the the facing

164the reality of what the our primary funding source is asking us to do that doesn't have to do with this year's budget so it's a little off topic but it's planning for the future for this year I'd like to focus on how we can try to Lobby them I agree that keeping class sizes where they are is is a great objective but and I'm concerned about whether or not we can afford to do that and maintain the mental health supports which I think um if I had to choose whether to have larger classes sizes slightly by one or two class you know students and maintaining or increasing mental health supports I'm going to go for increasing mental health supports um every time right now in this environment so that for me um I also want

165to make sure that our Randolph school is well and adequately funded for the growth that we hope to see there um and that kind of thing so anyway um I did meet with acae last week they are ready to you know work their their I guess their Avenues to try to help us get the public support for um increasing that um we even brainstormed some campaign language like you know ACS needs your two cents and then yard signs that say I'll you know we'll support we support our public we support Asheville City Schools we're giving our two cents so kind of a a a visual campaign for people getting the word out on the street I think the difficulty that I would anticipate will get to is that tax will also increase for organizations like

166Mission Health Omni Grove Park so I could see those larger businesses pushing back on the Commissioners with their influences to try to keep that lower so I have a an indication that that might be something that would challenge them to do that but I think if we can bring some overwhelming public support I think it you know hopefully they would go ahead and and allow us to do that or would do that on our behalf and my other you know as we think about some outside of the box thinking is really asking the school board instead of hey we need $3.9 million taking it a different approach and saying we need you to Levy two Mills on our behalf and that becomes separate from their current budget assessment and it becomes its own School line

167so much like the Asheville City schools has its own tax for students in our dist for the families that live in our district separating the school funding on a totally separate line as its own millage rate instead of being kind of like all scooped up in one big pot so that's another strategy I'm starting to pull numbers and try to get some understanding about um to try to say look we're just asking you to Levy this tax on our behalf and look at the support we have from our community please Levy this tax for us Dr Ferman along those lines and I really appreciate that line of thinking and when it comes to advocating for the tax and I'm curious if your conversation with AC started to pick this up I've heard from Commissioners that

168there's a discomfort with growing the um the funding for Asheville City Schools while not growing the funding for bunkham County schools because the commission supports both districts and you know we've talked about all kinds of ways to discuss that topic um you know not the least of which is they can do that and so with that last thing you were saying does is there space because like Amy said I'm aware that out of this consolidation report we've you know we have what feels to me like a growing um Readiness to work together between the Two school boards with the County Commission and so are there aspects of what you just said that you think are particularly helpful for that trickiness of one district is saying we want more but it doesn't support the whole all

169the kids in the whole County you know and I to be honest I the citizens of our School attendance Zone had supported this so it's out really to me outside of the County commission's Business just to be completely Frank like they our citizen said we want to pres you know have this tax to support Asheville City schools that is separate and then the county has its own tax that it then divides up heror Ely based on attendance between the two districts um so I I hear their argument and they're already doing it so what's the big difference of an extra two cents per $100 and knowing that that's a concern so I think you've got to go into it knowing that um so I don't I don't know if that answers your question or not

170but did you already say something okay okay can I say something yeah sorry um I wanted to share a couple things but I wanted everybody else um to talk I think for me Maggie what I what I'd like to convey to you is and you sorry you did a good job of this I thought at the County Commission meeting that we remind the Commissioners that our most important goal is to look and change the disperate outcomes in our students along lines of race and so and for me like the rest is not incidental but I want to just keep saying that because I do think that's important to what we do I I wanted to just acknowledge what Pepe said I have concerns we can't tax our ashell city school district people and use their

171money for purposes outside Ash City Schools so I just have some concern that we would say we would take this money and use it like for early childhood education I'm not sure we can use it to benefit kids outside our district I don't know the rules I just have concerns about that I don't want us to set ourselves up for criticism that we could avoid if we can just be super focused about what we want and how we get there and um the last thing I wanted to say because I've had Commissioners talk to me about this and Amy alluded to it the um feasibility study talked about our schools are um can't think of the word underutilized whatever the word they used and we've got to look at that and because the County Commissioners

172aren't going to do anything for us if we continue to just say well maybe we can grow our schools and whatever I just think we have to be super honest about where we are and what we want to do and that they will appreciate that so that's what I wanted to say let me yes I agree and we were actually just talking about that this morning about this notion of right sizing looking at our property not just our schools but also our three places where we are hosting now central office staff we started last year um to look at a a deeper feasibility almost like Capa not capacity but um facility study and I think we need to breathe some life back into that because what we really need is some very detailed financial analysis

173of here's your projected student en M data here's what we know based on just standard population growth which they said you know across the district we'll get 105 new students next year total in bunkham County so that's split between Asheville City that's split between bunkham so we know it's that the the rate of increase is pretty flat so we can get comfortable with a certain level of enrollment knowing that we'll have a pretty flat enrollment rate how do we then plan for the long term for financial stability does that mean looking at selling a property does that mean combining all you know Central offices into one building instead of spreading us out over three um so I think we need to take a very comprehensive Financial look that includes student enrollment projection that looks at

174our facilities we have school buildings that are 100 years old does it make sense to combine schools and put a lot more more students in a 100y old building versus one that was built in the 60s so we need to take all of those variables we don't have the expertise on staff to complete that type of analysis so I've asked April and Heidi to start looking at writing an RFP on what a study like that what we would want to see and we would actually you know that's where we're moving ask for some board input as well and what are some Financial indicators you need to help you make a decision if we have to again get to a point where we're looking at combining schools hey um I changed my mind all right okay

175um on the tax on the tax situation here what was the community feedback on the consolidation do they support do they support as City school I mean I mean what would their feedback if uh the anecdotal feedback I've received from community members and parents they the community did not support consolidation okay they didn't support consolidation so maybe we can use that as a way for them to give or to support us I mean if the community don't want it I mean they might as well support us right now I've got even more to say um I will start with um The Grove Park an example um I've shared on online I have shared with the board members uh that right now if we were to go up to the 12 cents based on the properties

176that are in the Asheville City Schools district that would be $1.7 million a year if we collected on all the properties that are currently um uh the the current uh property assessments understanding that some of those properties don't exist anymore that there will be some issues with elections but that's the number we we are not receiving 1.7 that we would if the Commissioners had not made the adjust of the tax to keep it Revenue neutral and we are now in a situation where um uh we are not raising the tax yet to keep things Revenue neutral so we're the we have seen the taxes reduced to keep things Revenue neutral but not rais to keep them Revenue neutral there is that piece when we are talking about uh commercial properties like the Grove Park in

177one of the reasons why I would put out we're going to take a quarter Cent or half a cent of that which would be$ 300 to $600,000 if we collected it based on the current numbers um using that maybe half of it goes to slots and half of it goes to subsidizing because we know that the reimbursement rates are not where they need to be to cover costs and that's the reimbursement rates based off of what we receive for Head Start slots and NC pre slots and part of the issue for that is that different regions of North Carolina get different reimbursement rates I did attend the Western North Carolina co uh early childhood education Coalition meeting this past week and they are starting an initiative with lobbying to uh request a single reimbursement rate

178floor for all of North Carolina which would greatly benefit our existing prek program if we are able to expand that program like the the numbers of that that um 1.38 cents to get up to 12 cents the number numbers for the Grove Park in is $2,148 not to be too precise and I suspect that businesses like the Grove Park in if they had greater access to child care and early childhood education that that's something that would benefit them the taxpayers and that they might also support and the same might be true also for Mission and that even if it only serves students who potentially students of parents who work in the district but absolutely students of parents who live in the district it would still make more spaces available throughout our County when it comes

179to enrollment and that the predictions of flat enrollment for the next you know 30 years 20 years whatever it was in the consolidation study I think that we miss that we have families who are working in Asheville who are driving down from Madison County or driving from other counties who would send their children to Asheville City Schools if we weren't charging additional fees but instead they can send their children to charter schools in the city of Asheville and there is no additional fee so like we are looking at the C program so that we can serve more children and it makes Financial sense to do so even though we aren't getting the exact same reimbursement from every single child it may make sense in serving the city of Asheville and bunam County if we look

180at um allowing a fee waiver for out of District fees as a trial basis and then after we have some results from that look at potentially eliminating fees because of those parents also are working in our district and we have businesses that are supporting it so there's my soap box and thank you very much for humoring me very quickly the only I was just going to respond to Rebecca's um concern which I think is a valid one but I I suspect that bunam County would be less likely to support a school tax I think the the citizens of bunkham County might be less like ly to support a supplemental tax on their property taxes and that's the justification it's exactly what you said but stated slightly differently I agree I I appreciate you saying that

181way Amy because that's that's actually at the root of my concern and I think the Commissioners know that and I think it's why they think this is sort of a toxic topic because they don't think they can put it in the county there won't be the um you know the electorate won't want it and then it leaves them playing something that might look like a favorite by increase in our funding while not and then they just don't want to mess with it so I'm grateful for the creative ways of communicating about it of thinking about it because I think that is where they've been that's what Commissioners have said to me you know like that's that's why it feels toxic to them so changing the narrative feels important uh I I think that when we

182look at the school tax maybe one thing to convey is that the school tax only covers the Asheville City Schools district and it's not covering some of our places that were hardest hit by Hurricane Helen there are families that were hardest hit in our district and certainly I I know parents and teachers whose homes were destroyed uh but it is not it doesn't include swanana NOA it doesn't include Fairview and so it's the only tax right now that the County Commissioners have that they can increase or restore that doesn't hit everybody in the county and so it's just a lever that they can pull to provide some more resources whether it include early childhood education or not I do want to mention one thing about um if you didn't notice there they did put off

183the reappraisal from this year to next year but there will be a reappraisal and I think that was a wise decision obviously because we hope some things at least will rebuild by then but back to your point about Revenue neutral you know everyone has always been in this Revenue neutral this way but we may be looking at a revenue neutral this way depending on how those things assess out based on the growth of the existing properties that didn't get damaged against those ones that got destroyed or eliminated so that's something to just think about and keep an eye out for as we continue to talk about this I guess the only other piece of information is that same Coalition is also going to be lobbying for the state to pay for child care for preschool

184teachers and it might be we have some deadlines coming up for legislative agendas and it might be something that we want to advocate for for all teachers because if the state will pay for stuff for teachers then that's more slots for ear childhood education good ideas thank you I know Maggie will take all this and she and Heidi will bring us back more information um I I want to start by saying that we're not going to get everything on the rest of the agenda this evening I think and I want Maggie to speak to this um some of what is on for second read and first read andus would typically then end up on our consent agenda um I don't knowing that we still have closed session um what would your preference be Maggie should

185we start just on second read see where we have consensus um what what would be helpful to you um so for the second read policies I guess it would be are there any that you the board would want to pull for further discussion and that way we can move forward with the ones that are on there that are good to go so I'm looking at board members which of the 10 15 I don't know how many there are um are you not comfortable with wanting to have more discussion with pepy um I would say that I'm comfortable with all of them however I think the policy code 2302 remote participation in board hearings is a little messy and that may be um and difficult to tr and there is uh the tobacco products um uh

186student policy and the smoking and tobacco products policy I believe needs more specific language around vaping CBD things that are not tobacco related and so that could be an offline discussion that I would have with Maggie or appropriate staff I think let me do this Pepe I hear you that you have specific concerns about some of the language in these policies um I don't know I'm just gonna ask the board how much stomach we all have for extended conversation about all of these policies um speaking for myself a lot of these come down for the School Board Association their policies we already have we're fine-tuning them Kim Dean can speak more to that I guess I'm going to call the question Pepe because and other folks can join in are you saying you want to

187have conversation about each one of these before we would say they move to the consent agenda and there's no wrong answer please hear me say that I just actually want to find out if that's what you're saying uh what I'm saying is there are some clarity issues and so I don't know that it requires the whole board to have conversation so you tell me can I just yes please so um you know we do the two readings and so both of those are an opportunity if you you know feel like there's some language that needs adjusting or something you can like go ahead and let us know that and then um I mean it can still as long as there's you know we've already had that discussion then it can still go to the consent

188agenda for next week if it's something like that so I mean if it's something where it's like you just you know want us to be aware of like something that you think should like be changed and then the board is okay with that I mean as long as everyone's on the same page we can do that and move it to the consent agenda for next week that's okay for the second so how would that work Anna after tonight's meeting pepy would share that with you well no I was saying it would be if we like if everybody's up for it we can go ahead and get whatever concerns people have for those because that's because that's what both opportunities with the readings are for the first and second read at each one you like board

189members have the opportunity to say I think we need to change this and then we change that next reading or we change that're good to go so that's kind of I just wanted to offer that understood so does that mean we should take these up one at a time and see if we can get a couple done tonight is that what I'm hearing no what are you saying I'm asking whether it's appropriate to direct me to either Mackie or Kim or I I don't know if whoever the appropriate person is to say hey can we we and that's where I think you're going to run into trouble from the rest of the bo yeah right okay I don't know that everybody would agree with what you want to do and that's what I've concerns about

190is that we're just so I I feel like maybe we just need to I I really am committed to being respectful of everybody's time and trying to end these meetings so folks can get home to families and I know we still have closed agenda closed session so would what is the board's thoughts on this do you want to just pick them up one at a time and see if we can get a few down by eight what would you like to do um if I may suggest let's just pull the ones that Pepe thinks are a problem or some portion of it how many are there how many think you would like to talk about about all of them Pepe no no um the the ones that I think need and it's along the wordsmithing

191um lines is the two that mentioned tobacco products and the one on remote participation in board hearings not substantive changes but clarifying changes just to clarify all the other ones more substantive changes or no changes to any of the others that are listed on the second read everything that's there for second read I support and want to move forward on excellent I misunderstood so so my suggestion if I may would just be to pull the two tobacco products and the remote particip in the board hearing and table those if unless there's some reason that they need to be done this month is there a reason that they need to be done this month no you would we would move them back to par three but we wouldn't I would need to know what changes you

192wanted made right so so my my thought at least would be that Pepe would propose those changes circulate them to all of us and we would have that conversation at our next work session that sounds like a great plan three policies so did Kim and Maggie track which ones can move forward and which we're gonna pull okay other board members are all good with that I'm just looking at you guys okay um next on the agenda is actually contracts andus and then we have policies for so Kim how about I let you do your thing because it sort of took a it's okay um you have a list of all the contracts those are information only and Theus does anybody have any questions about those okay all right then you have policies for first read

193and so um and Anna can speak to this these are policies that you're reading for the first time and I ideally this is where you would have the conversation and work session where you say we are not in agreement with this we want to make changes and that's when I make changes and run it by ant like that's where that would happen so um because the um at the last board meeting uh we did have 2110 and 5030 on there for first read but during the board um Meeting those were asked to be removed um so we removed those but we need to to know what what needs to be changed in order to put those back on for first read the one the four that you do the four new ones that you have

194for first read the technology responsible use they've taken the consequences and moved it from the first page and the School Board Association has moved those to the very end and there's a standalone section for consequences uh the one of the biggest things you'll see in the web page development is um ex that our page has to be accessible to individuals with disabilities Matt and his team make sure that that's the case um and then 3420 um you know we've added the state has made the new general statute requirement of career development plans and so 3420 just um encompasses the changes of those Career Development plans and the legal guidelines around that and then Federal grant Administration kind of goes back to a little bit what Anna talked about out and the the addition there is

195like if if you were if if we had somebody who was writing the bid proposal for Windows it couldn't be a window owner who then bids on the window so that just some clarification there and also um um and and some you know what the Violet consequence would be as far as the violation the next part is 2310 that's a recommendation coming from Campbell Shatley that's information only and that is public participation at board meetings and that's a change that I'll let Anna speak to yeah so we have this as information only because these are changes that aren't coming from ncsba and so we've kind of offered some alternate language that we think fits better the model that you guys are kind of using but we would didn't want to put it on for first

196read unless we knew that you guys were actually in interested in altering the policy um so if it's something that you're interested in then it can go on for first read but we just wanted to present you with the information that we were kind of proposing thank you so I'm looking to board members to talk about what could move forward from first read to Second read versus what needs further discussion and heavy I do have a question on the web page development um uh my understanding from the open meetings law is that there and from some my understanding with food and nutrition is that there are certain things were mandated to put up on our website uh that would include policies and whatnot and announcements of board meetings agendas and all of that what I've

197noticed in the past is that if I go to the search bar on the the main website I won't pick up the content or I won't be able to find the content that's on the policy website or the food and nutrition website I understand that there is that there are ways that we can address that technically but I want to just bring it up as as a concern for parents families myself and in being able to just go to the search bar do a search and find the information and I don't know exactly where that fits with all this um if I could respond I totally appreciate that concern I don't think it's a policy level concern so I think that's a procedure concern or a implementation administrative concern but I don't think that has

198anything to do with the policy I mean I don't think you would alter the policy to I agree I agree it's a compliance oversight concern right so I don't think that would delay that one um Kim you asked for clarification on policy 2110 and 5030 why they were originally pulled or removed um and if I'm not mistaken part of 5030 and pepe I think you can speak to this probably better than I can but Community use of facilities had something to do with um the requirements around PTO insurance and all that kind of stuff correct that's what I recollect yeah so I don't know if that means we're we're ready to move it now into the next read or if there's still some things to clarify about that and I'll defer to Campbell Shatley on

199um about facilities use and requiring liability insurance and I would like to have conversation in close session about with um uh attorney advice about whether I'm allow in this moment to participate in discussions or not on the subject matter and how that impacts things so just for clarity where we are in the agenda is whether these policies are acceptable to us to move on to Second read so sort of by definition I think there continue to be questions about 5030 and tonight is not the night that we would talk about them so and 2110 I do have some specific things for that so do we want to hold off on that or I would like to yes I think what I I I so are there any policies and I pepy I'm just gonna start

200with you because I know you have a lot of questions and that's totally fine it just seems easier to start with you is there anything under first read that you are okay with as is everything under first read those four sets of policies are are good to go to Second read as far as I'm concerned great does any other board member have concerns about the first four so those could move on to Second read um I don't know and I'm looking to Kim and Maggie if we're I for 2110 and 5030 we need to find time to have discussion on these as well as the three or I forgotten how many you pulled off a second read would it be appropriate to allow time on I don't to allow time on the agenda at the

201next work session and just TR to tackle what becomes five yeah we can do that way to do that I'm gonna jump in if I could do you mind and say that I think the public participation at board member meetings I appreciate the changes you've suggested I also continue to really want something to help us when we have challenging public comment and in it's possible to clarify that without violating the First Amendment if this is the best we can do that's all I need to know so that was kind of the line we were trying to walk with that um but we also did update the script to be read before public participation to match the changes in policy and to kind of detail that a little bit more um but I wasn't going to

202present that to you guys if you weren't interested in the policy changes be aligned with those so I don't know if we want to talk about that more or if you know like I'm fine with that uh myself these changes as they are um and that means they could be put on for first read I think they're information only so I don't no they're on for information only right here and I think they what were you saying did I miss they does that mean they didn't move to first read or they're just okay so ye yes they can move to first read also if you guys don't feel like you need more discussion about it you can skip first read and move them to Second read it's really up to you guys on that because

203you have had the opportunity to look at them but it's is you guys can do it either way looking at board members move it to first so can I just ask a clarifying question um and maybe it's just maybe it is semantics but when it says information only that always leads me to believe that it's it's not up for a vote when it says information only but these we will need to vote on so why are they called information only well so this one was just called information only because it wasn't being presented for first read we were presenting it outside of like what was already given for first read to see if you guys were interested in this at all this came from our office this didn't come from your staff this this was

204just a so it's a rare occurrence that it would be information only and it was just because we weren't sure if you guys were interested in this going to first read or not or being a change that was being made or not okay so I'll just jump in because the question's been asked I'm fine with it going to Second read uh I'm I'm agnostic either way we're going to get it past I think unless somebody has the concern that comes up later I'm seeing nodding heads yay second read it is okay so so we will keep 2110 and 5030 um you'll see them again next month at the work session for first read correct thank you okay I think um I will now entertain a motion for our board to enter into a closed session

205pursuant to General statute 14331 1811 for the following purposes under subsection A1 to prevent the disclosure of privilege and confidential Personnel information pursuant to General statute 115c 319 through 321 and under subsection A3 to discuss matters protected by attorney client privilege is there a motion to adjourn our meeting and go into Clos session so moved is there a second may I suggest that we not adjourn the meeting but we're just going into close session right that is fine I'm reading my script it's just a motion to go into close session and I had a motion from Amy is there a and I second second by consensus are we all in agreement we will now move into close

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.