CorpusRecord 130282

Asheville City Board of Education Regular Session 12/9/2024

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Asheville City Schools
Date
2024-12-10
Location
Buncombe County, NC
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,400 words · about 53 min
Collected
2026-06-21

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001e e e that you will well and truly execute the duties of the office of member of the Asheville City Board of Education according to the best of your skill and ability and according to laws so help you God thank you for your service congratulations thank right thanks distance all right pppy sibo do you Jose sibo IV solemnly and sincerely affirm that you will support the Constitution of the United States and will you be faithful and bear true allegiance to the state of North Carolina and to the Constitutional Powers and authorities which are or may be established for the government thereof and will you Endeavor to support maintain and defend the constitution of said State not inconsistent with the Constitution of the United States to the best of your knowledge and ability I do and

002you Jose asbo IV solemnly affirm that you will well and truly execute the duties of the office of member of the Ashville City Board of Education according to the best of your skill and ability and according to law I do congratulations thank you for your service thank you great thanks all right George seberg you would like to do you George seberg solemnly and sincerely affirm that you will support the Constitution of the United States and will you be faithful and bear true allegiance to the state of North Carolina and to the Constitutional Powers and authorities which are or may be established for the government thereof and will you Endeavor to support maintain and defend the constitution of said State not inconsistent with the Constitution of the United States to the best of your knowledge and

003ability I will and I do and to you Geor Lord seberg solemnly affirmed that you will well and truly execute the duties of the office of member of the Asheville City Board of Education according to the best of your skill and ability and according to law I do congratulations thank you for your service all right well let's congratulate our reaffirmed and newly affirmed board members and while we transition um to the next phase of the meeting I wanted to give an opportunity for any of our board members to get photos and we also have some cake in the back so we're going to take about a 5 minute get photos if you want them with any members that are here with you and then um we'll have some cake if you want it and then

004we'll get started e e e all right if um members of the board and audience could take your seats we are about to begin the next um phase of the meeting which is election of officers all right uh um so um we will call the meeting to order officially once um the officers are sworn in and the board has taken their seats but is there a motion for a nomination for board chair um so the the motion has been made by um board chair seberg um to nominate um board member thornberg as the chair it has been seconded by board member pepio Sao um so is there a vote um from the board I I okay uh that is a unanimous vote for I just noting that um board member Amy Ray is not present

005tonight all right so with that board chair thorberg please come at this time is there a motion for vice chair Nom okay is there a second okay I'm not hearing a second which doesn't reflect on any any of Liza's good abilities so but thank you for that motion is there a different motion I'd like to motion make a motion to elect um Rebecca ster as Vice chair is there a second okay Jesse we have a motion from George seconded by Jesse all those in favor of Rebecca strer for vice chair please say I I okay any against okay thank you we and I believe the other board members can now come take their seats and your name tags are over there your name thank you for okay at this time I'm going to call coming

006out of recess thank you so I don't have to go okay at this time we are going to come out of recess and this evening I will start by reading the equity statement in Asheville City Schools we are committed to equity and anti-racist policies for all students and staff to learn and Thrive we recognize that our positions come with power responsibility and public service for the entire ACS Community we will model our commitment to equity through our practices and decisions during this meeting we invite a pause if harm has taken place a moment to name the harm and space to practice repair thank you um we do have a quorum this evening Amy Ray has a work commitment that prevented her from being with us but she wanted you all to know she's in full

007support of the um new board leadership and we look forward to her joining us at the next meeting and at this time we have the Pledge of Allegiance IED alce to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice thank you um at this time I will be looking for a motion to approve our agenda and um we're one thing we're going to do slightly differently than had been our practice um just in an effort to make this a little more streamlined if any board member knows that they're going to take an item off the consent agenda if you want to say so now so that as we approve the agenda we can note that change so looking to

008board members uh yes please um which item would you like to remove from the consent agenda oh I see I'm learning the ins and outs um policy code uh 5030 Community use of facilities and then is there a uh one of our policies uh had a little technical difficulty but one of our policies about the that includes the oath um uh needs a little bit more work so I'm wondering if we can take it off since it's not urgent board members can take any motion off the consent agenda that they wish and I think that is 2110 um yes pepy that is the 2110 includes among other things the oath of office and so you're asking for that to be removed from the consent agenda also yes please okay um shall both of those be

009the motion okay but do you want to take care of this okay all right um so those have been removed from the consent agend agenda and what is before the board is the remainder of the agenda our entire agenda for the evening including the consent agenda less those two items is there a motion to approve the agenda as modified so moved second okay thank you the agenda as modified is approved and I we turn now to Kim dekant for good news apologies we had a motion and a second for the approved modified agenda all those in favor please say I I I I okay thank you sorry about that good evening chair thorberg Vice chair stammer Dr Ferman and the board I'm excited to come to you this evening with a lot of good news

010uh we have so much good news to share in our district from staff going out of their way to give up to give back to their Community to athletic victories that put Asheville City schools on the map and we want to share with you just a few of the great things that have been happening what we're going to ask is I think uh after uh we go through all the good news we'll ask everyone who's here for good news to come up to the front and we'll get a group photo with the board so if you'll stay with us till the end of good news that would be great first we would like to recognize caverns of gold compilation album Asheville Middle School teacher Joe hooton has been leading and organizing for caverns of gold

011a compil a compilation album featuring over 250 bands of musical artists to raise money for Hurricane Relief in Western North Carolina 100% of the proceeds from the sale of the album will benefit beloved Asheville a local nonprofit dedicated to providing relief and long-term support for the community the album has raised over $115,000 to date an artist range from local musicians to World recognized bands like RM and thank you to Mr hooton for tapping into the vast musical talent that exists in our community and for leveraging your passion to give back you can purchase the caverns of Gold album for only $10 on band camp let's give Mr hooton a huge round of applause [Applause] another Ashville High teacher who is giving back to the community is Mindy McCormack she organized a cougar crew bird making

012fundraiser to benefit artists in the river Arts District who've been impacted by the hurricane staff and students had a great time molding and shaping the hollow Birds to be glazed decorated and sold our staff's creative ity sworded with birds sporting chicken-like features and top hats students and staff partnered with uncommon markets this past weekend and sold the birds at the Haywood Park Hotel in Asheville thank you to Mandy for organizing and leading this therapeutic and creative experience that gives back to our local art community and you can see all the U the bird some of the birds that are on display up um at the board and also the there's some on this front table that um the students and staff made so thank you Ashville Middle School cross country um the Asheville Middle School

013boys cross country team took first place by two points winning as the conference Champs in November and the girls took on an overall second place win even though the athletic season was interrupted by the hurricane our student athletes maintained their Fitness and each broke their personal best time comes we are so proud of our cross country teams and want to extend a huge shout out to coach Anna wck and Coach Katherine Miner for leading our students to Victory we are also fortunate to have Logan root with us this evening who took second and overall in the conference meet the Asheville City schools foundation's in real life after school program held a successful fall session that provided 110 middle school students and 18 high school students with fun and Hands-On learning experience after school just the

014few of the awesome clubs offered included knitting and Fiber Arts cooking slack lining carpentry and hiking the Dream High School mentors also ran three amazing student Le clubs this fall season Dungeons and Dragons cultural art club and basketball we are incredibly grateful to the Asheville City Schools foundation for ensuring that our middle school students have access to fun and engaging activities like these and that the Asheville SE schools Foundation is promoting a popline of leadership for our students and we're very thankful our very own Ernest sesum received an honorary doctorate we are so proud of Mr sesam's our elementary and federal programs director who received an honorary doctorate on November 2th fth from the school of Great Commission Bible College in Columbia South Carolina he said that he has this has inspired him to go

015back to school and complete his own doctorate congratulations to Mr sesum on this incredible honor and we are so glad that you have joined the cougar crew Lucy s Herring Elementary School had a Ruby Bridges day and on Thursday November the 14th they walked to school it was a walk to school day it's a national day of commemoration to Ruby Bridges the first African-American child to attend an all-white Elementary School in the south in partnership with safe routes for schools land of Scot and several Asheville City School staff and volunteers this day was filled with dialogue centered around univ Unity cultivating a sense of belonging and anti-bullying students learned valuable lessons that they can use in their own lives and and at school to advocate for anti-discrimination Miss Casey Jones cheater ended the day with

016an incredible performance as Ruby Bridges telling her courageous story thank you principal Jamerson and everyone who worked hard to make this day possible as a cougar crew let's remind ourselves of the power of unity and continue to create a strong sense of belonging for everyone thank you it's hard to believe that we're wrapping up the year and it's time for Go Local cards um they're now available for $25 and the Go Local card will give you access to discounts and Deals of hundreds of businesses across Asheville and Western North Carolina provides us with an opportunity to go out and to celebrate and support our local businesses funds from Go Local directly support our students and Educators and our district has received nearly 275,000 since the fundraising program began in 2015 shopping local and supporting local

017businesses is more important than ever so we know that 2025 will be an extra special year for investing in our local economy and supporting public education get yours today we have so many events coming up in the next week that we want to share with you um because we won't be able to capture them in good news next month but please mark your calendars for Saturday December the 14th we have the annual band programs 5K fundraiser it it will take place at Asheville Middle School beginning at 9:00 a.m. every step you take brings us closer to providing our middle school and high school students with musical opportunities like master classes and private lessons and I think we have several people in this room who are signed up to run also that's this coming Saturday the

01814th we have a huge toy giveaway and that we encourage the entire family to come and enjoy the toy giveaway will begin at 11:00 a.m. and it will go until 3:00 p.m. and it's open to children from birth to age 14 and that will be at Asheville middle school and it is the toys are being provided by one of the New York fire departments who will be traveling down here to support our families the other we will also be hosting on the same Saturday an event um which will be in Asheville C schools wide families together holiday celebration that will take place at Hall Fletcher Elementary School we will have over 500 hot meals over 25 artists and vendors to shop from 800 Comfort Care kits to take home and 1,000 drawring act activity bags

019not to mention music crafts and special giveaways this event will take place from 11: to 1 at Hall Fletcher please don't miss out on these fun activities that the entire family can come out and enjoy and we are also excited to kick off spirit week next Monday December the 16th staff who dress up have the opportunity to go into a random drawing they have to use our hashtag um on their post um which has been shared out in parents square and there will be a random drawing every day for a gift certificate um courtesy of Dr Ferman so we're excited about that um and we will every day there's a different theme and we know uh the middle school and high school have already established their spirit week but we're hoping that all of the

020elementary schools will join us and we it'll be across the district so please remember to check your school calendars and the website for updates on all the amazing events that are taking place in December so at this time I would like for all of the individuals who are recognized during good news to come up to the front so that we can get a picture with the board country job cross country good please please and you'll see that Greg Hall are ourl directors joining us up front to help us celebrate um ourl success this semester once again let's give these individuals another round of [Applause] applause and we have a special recognition uh from the board tonight and I will uh go to the next slide and turn it over to um chair thornberg um we

021are super excited to celebrate our own Kimberly Jones tonight we are very proud of her she is graduating on Friday from Mars Hill with her degree in social work and a minor in business um she has worked very hard and we are so proud of her also of note I'm Consulting my notes Kimberly was an original member of the black Educators excellent cohort which is funded by our own asille City Schools Foundation um and she is yet another graduate of this sustained tuition support provided through the Ashville City Schools Foundation um the black educator excellent cohort now functions as an affinity group within the district and is open to all staff of color and Kimberly has been a strong leader in the evolution of this group and we are so proud of [Applause] her all

022right thank you um at this time we turn to public comment and I do not believe anyone has signed up I'm sorry no one oh excellent so we can dispense with reading we have Lucia's hearring Ana wait I thought you said there was okay okay we'll okay we do not have any one signed up for public comment um the report from Lucy Herring will come at another time um and so at this time we're going to move to the consent agenda I note that it includes the approval of draft minutes student releases to bunkham County contracts memorandums of understanding policies on second read except for 4 2110 and 5030 um it also includes a budget resolution that we discussed in the work session last week um as well as a ACS expenditure report all of

023that is coming before us on the consent agenda um I do want to mention one thing just in a full disclosure that I've talked about with many people up here um one of our new board members Pepi AO is on both our board and the board of Francine Delaney a charter school in town and so we talked with legal counsel about this and if there had been a conflict of interest to our system Pepe would have recused himself from this vote because this budget resolution comes to us as a recommendation and we receive it without discussion his participating in the vote is not a conflict to us and so it's appropriate for him to join in this vote and I just wanted to explain that so at this time I would ask for a motion

024to approve the consent agenda so moved thank you George second second thank you Liza all those in favor of approving the consent agenda please say I I I I any opposed thank you all we now welcome our auditors for Madam chair board members Dr uh thank you so much for allowing us to work on the audit report for 20 thank you for allowing me to be here this even testing sorry about that my name is Tyler barwise on behalf of Anderson Smith and white and I'm just going to go over a few highlights of the audit for 2024 and answer any questions you may have so I'm pleased to report that the district received a clean or an unmodified opinion this is the best opinion you can receive and I know a lot of hard

025work has come from the finance team and the district as a whole to achieve this um so I do just want to congratulate you on your hard work um in a separate letter there were no significant accounting estimates that are not typical for any school board audit seen across the state uh there were also no misstatements and we had no disagreements or difficulties with management throughout the process I know personally it can be a cumbersome process um with all the information we ask for so I really just wanted to take a minute and thank the finance team for getting us information in a timely manner and an organized fashion from a fund balance standpoint we focus primarily on the general fund um this is where your unrestricted funds are going to be for the district

026to use at their discretion um so the fund balance in the general fund is going to work sort of like a personal savings account as you can see this year the district saved 2.1 million in fund balance and ended with about 12.7 million in fund balance of that 12.7 million you'll see that about three and a half million has been U assigned to the fiscal year 2025 budget likely due to Esser funds expiring and you'll have a remaining 9.1 million in unassigned fund balance and just to take a Qui quick look at budget versus actual expenditures for the year I'm pleased to announce that the district did not overspend their budget or the Amendments that the board put in place during the prior fiscal year we'll also take a quick look at Child Nutrition typically

027you'll look at Child Nutrition from a cash standpoint rather than fund balance as it's going to be a more accurate depiction of Financial Health in that fund um so as you can see this year the district spent about 183,000 in cash and ended with about $274,000 this is going to be something you're going to want to keep an eye on in the future um because at this rate the general fund will need to cover expenses in the Child Nutrition fund moving forward um we've seen this as a trend across the state especially in smaller districts so it's just something to keep an eye on moving forward we're also pleased to announce that there were no financial statement Federal award or state award findings this here I'm sorry about this for one second for Kim do

028you want me to forward you a copy of what I have okay okay let me forward you from the email that I have got so we will just quickly go over some supplementary information to the financial statements okay so this graph here is going to be a historical representation of Revenue over time um one thing to note here is that as state revenue increases typically expenditures such as salary and benefits will increase along with it um but the main thing we want to focus on here is going to be the F federal revenue um as you can see the changes from 2018 to 2019 onward that is going to be your Esser funds that I just wanted to point out here and we will just take a quicker look um at those Esser funds as

029you can see in 2022 covid related spending peaked at about 7 and a half million and in 2024 there was about 2.5 million in Co related expenditures that should leave about $720,000 in E Esser funds remaining at year end and of the $720,000 um purchase order need purchase orders needed to be issued by September 30th and checks need to be cut by the end of the year um we say that because the district is likely working on right sizing to a budget without Esser funds and as we've seen over the past few years uh inflation has taken a toll and the dollar does not stretch as far as it has in previous years the last thing we'll take a quick look at is fund balance over time um this dark red bar here is going

030to be the general fund fund balance and it was at its lowest in 2020 and we just want to point that out because the district has done a great job of building that fund balance over the last few years um but as Sesser funds are expiring we're going to recommend that you only have one time expenditures hitting that fund balance and there are no reoccurring expenditures coming out of fund balance so I apologize for the technical difficulties this is going to be the end of the presentation for the audit report for 2024 are there any questions I can answer for you board members do you have any questions for our auditor all right thank you so much for your time I appreciate it we appreciate your time very much I wanted to note it is

031um always reassuring to get a clean opinion and I also want to note as um Ty noted that Heidi and her staff did a lot of work to make this a good audit and we really are grateful to her and her team for working so well with our Auditors um we appreciate you all and to the board this is something we'll vote on um a little bit later in the agenda um I turn now to Rachel sawer Rachel joins us from the bunkham county strategic partnership and I will note that commissioner Al Whitesides was with us earlier for the swearing in and I asked him why he was here and he said he'd been invited so he came so apparently that's all it takes good evening uh chair thurberg and superintendent Ferman and members of

032the board and staff and anyone who may be following Along online my name is Rachel Sawyer and I work as you noted for bunkham County government in strategic Partnerships which is a grants and funding and Community collaborations role during regular times I will take a moment of privilege and just want to thank superintendent Ferman and the entire ACS team for uh being such great collaborators over the past couple of months as our community has responded to uh to the tropical storm Helen um we've had an opportunity to be in the emergency Operation Center and other spaces tackling and problem solving topics um around water around reopening and that recovery work will continue and and change as we proceed and we'll be talking about other topics that are storm related that uh relate to education like

033um trauma impact to students and families and others within the system so thank you uh for being great Partners I'm here tonight to share an update about the school consolidation feasibility study you will find that most of what I have to say is fairly procedural bringing folks back up to speed about where we are um on the process and what we have coming ahead of us in terms of project background this is a this is a mandate that came our way from the state of North Carolina General Assembly who passed the bill and uh the governor signed into law a year ago in September of 2023 um at that time the board of education for the Asheville City Schools as well as the bunkham County Schools each voted to designate bunkham County government as the

034lead entity for the study which was accepted by the Board of Commissioners for the county we like to include the exact text of the bill in these presentations for anyone who wants to follow along and read the exact language of the bill there are a few items that are bolded for your attention um essentially being mandated that the bodies jointly study the feasibility of a merger between Asheville City and bunkham County Schools um to include looking at economic impact as well as other factors any other relevant information and ultimately reporting findings and recommendations to the general assembly back to the state by February of 2025 which may have felt like a long time into the future uh when we when it first came our way we jumped right into action um the superintendent and County

035Manager uh the superintendent for both systems and the county manager appointed participants to serve on a project team sort of a local Steering group if you will um which included people with subject matter expertise who work within the systems administratively HR and facilities and finance and also included people with perspectives and expertise that might be impacted by a decision of uh impacted by a recommendation of whether to merge or not such as principls teachers parents and students that local project team began their work work designing the solicitation bunkham County government accepted the role of lead entity but it's not our staff that are carrying out the study we hired a firm to do so and we'll talk more about the scope of the of what the contracted vendor is bringing to the work um so

036bunkham county is offering coordination um I've been sort of standing in that communication and project management role the systems have um been at the table contributing to the study responding to countless actually not countless because there's a specific number on a future slide responding to very many requests for data and providing input on the scheduling of community uh surveys and Community meetings Etc so a lot of collaboration going into the study the scope of work um that bunkham County included in our contract for our selected vendor um who is Prismatic Services was informed by the work of that local project team who communicated three top priorities Equity Community engagement and data as as um fundamental to a successful study and we looked for a firm that would bring a rigorous approach to a comprehensive set

037of attributes which are named here and and speak to what we heard in the in the bill we want to understand the financial implications and we also want to understand academic and student well-being and policy and procedure operational facility Etc so impacts from a broad range of perspectives we've asked that they look at similarities and differences between the systems that they include both short and long-term impacts as well as projections and scenarios and ultimately come back with a comprehensive report uh describing their work and their research methods as well as um what the findings of the study are risks and benefits um recommendations um and if uh any recommendation is made that would require action implementation considerations snapshot of work that has occurred um some by the numbers information here one of the uh key

038features of Prismatic Services proposal was their um large amount of time on site so we're at 87 days that they have spent here on site requesting and reviewing data across a wide range of topics holding focused groups with um community-based partner organizations that uh work with our school systems in education and education report conducting interviews with people with a r a wide range of uh perspectives and expertise hosting Community forums Gathering surveys and conducting observations in our schools a little bit more about the survey um and Community input results these were early results that we were able to share prior to getting the final uh result of the report I'm going back one slide to remind myself it was over 7200 survey results and the breakdown of Community member versus parent versus staff versus student

039is included here and all of this will be provided in detail in the report so we received the legislative mandate like I mentioned back in September of 2023 formed that team went into the request for proposals process um and ultimately made that award so the vendor began their work in April and has been carrying it out through December what I'll say here is that we were quite fortunate in terms of the project being able to move forward in relation or in light of Helen Because by the end of September the community the data had all been submitted the interviews had been conducted and Community meetings hosted and the survey results had all been collected at that time um I know that there was some inquiry about whether or not the end deadline of February 15th

040is is flexible or not it is written into statute so that's the date that we're mandated to meet and we're well well poised to do so so the firm that I mentioned is based out of Charlotte uh which means they're nearby and have in close contact and they were able to continue their work they didn't have the same kind of service interruptions that we experienced here um in October and into November so what next the reason that I'm here with this board is during December is to remind you as I did last week with the bunkham County School Board and as I will next week with the bunkham County Board of Commissioners where we are where we've come from and what to expect next we will have our report in hand no later than December

04131st we've asked the firm to provide the comprehensive report including all the elements I mentioned as well as a slide deck an executive summary when I receive those materials the report will be marked as draft that way we have an opportunity to identify if there's anything that needs to be corrected your Liaisons on staff as have I been going back and forth with the vendor throughout but when we get the report we want a chance to take a look and see if there's anything that we need to correct it will become a final report at when it's presented to the public on January 16th that is the date of a joint meeting between bunam County School Board Asheville City School Board and bunkham County Commissioners um so those three governing bodies will come together and

042hear the presentation but as soon as I receive that report and materials I will be sharing with our elected boards and with the local project team so you've got some time to digest and formulate questions and prepare for the discussion that will occur on January 16th that gives us about a month until the report is then submitted to the state um it's an option if this board or one of the other two governing boards wishes to provide an endorsement of or comments on the study um this is this is the process that we have arrived at so that we're getting the recommendations from the The Firm that is doing the work and so that our governing boards may have an opportunity to respond to that um if there is a desire to have that comment

043or endorsement included as we submit this information to the state in February um we are happy to include that that can also occur later should the should any of those boards wish to do additional diligence or host um engagement opportunities for your stakeholders what we know is that we will be submitting the report what we're offering is the opportunity to also include any endorsement Andor comments should the board choose to do that and I've worked with Dr Ferman and her team to understand what the meeting schedules of all the different bodies are to ensure you have a time that you'll be Gathering between the 16th of January and the 15th of February so that is all of the prepared information that I brought and I'm happy to respond to any questions thank you Rachel any

044questions from the board thank you so much for working on this I know you put a lot of time and effort in this uh working with pra uh Prismatic and working with all the staff um just to be clear uh the boards will receive a preview copy we're expecting on the 31st of December and have until approximately two weeks if there are any comments or Corrections that the boards would request is that accurate staff will be looking at it from the perspective of Corrections and so your chair or your superint intendent might offer to to collect that if any come from this selected board uh but it it it serves two purposes the governing boards really get it for the opportunity to dive in and digest Meanwhile we're we're um reviewing it for any uh

045accuracy if there's any corrections uh that that happens with reports as as extensive as this um the reason and you're not asking this that we are doing it simultaneously is that we wanted to make best use of the time and not keep the board waiting while the project team did their work it'll happen uh simultaneously okay and so if there are comments or observations from this board the protocol would be for us to get with our board chair or superintendent to transmit that comments and observations um will be invited at on the January 16th meeting agenda as part of discussion if you have clarification questions that are around something that staff can run down um they would send them to us in advance okay thank you I just want to thank you again for taking

046on this gigantic task and shepherding the process thank you Rachel you're welcome anyone else okay thank you great thank you I was a little closer to the microphone than my colleague from the accounting firm Tyler um at this time I believe Heidi is going to present information about the um 26 Calendar 2026 calendar good evening um Dr uh Ferman has started drafting this uh document for you to have some of the legislated and policy requirements for the budget process and then I suggested that perhaps we also include the reality of the budget process in the same document so we can kind of just start keeping that in our mind as to what timeline we'll be looking at moving forward so in December right on task we're bringing BR in your budget calendar um so right

047now um taking a look forward um I don't see any potential problems except for one month I want to touch on with you um in January obviously you're going to have the retreat not a business meeting we're going to have a lot of discussion about the budget at that time and then the county usually gives us a call and has a preliminary meeting with my budget team and their budget team to talk about kind of where are we where do you think you are I'm assuming this year it's going to be really strongly focused on Revenue projections um as we talked about a little bit in the work session and so that was last year about February 15th um we will also request that our departments and schools give us some information in February and

048then in March um this is where things start getting a little tight because even though if you look through the green and it seems to very easily and cleanly progress to June for everybody to get their work done at the county level backs into us getting all the work done here before that so that those legislated and policy deadlines really don't mean a whole lot because everybody needs that information sooner so um by the time we get to March we really have H will have to have some significant budget conversations and um drafts going on because with the way we have the conflict so to speak coming up in April with spring break we have a work session before spring break and a board meeting after spring break so the 21st of April is going

049to practically be too late um to get any work done on the budget so we're going to have to Target that meeting before spring break which basically puts all all our work back to February and March so I just kind of wanted to run through that and then of course by the time we get to June we should have some information from the county we never know if we'll have that information from the state so we may have a local budget and have to pass an interim budget but that is required by June 30th does anybody have any questions about that how do you have a question that's probably tangental to the calendar but thinking about previous conversations with County Commissioners prior to Helen there was a real um desire I feel like mostly from

050the County Commissioners but heard a little bit here um of doing multi-year budgets as opposed to a single year budget do you have a sense at this point post toine post election if that's still a conversation or is it like year by year as we kind of well they definitely talked about it to the extent enough for it to be in the paper but they have also had new elections recently which changed the board chair and other positions so I assume they're going to have those conversations again yeah um and then we're all meeting all three bodies together on the 16th so I would assume there could be some conversation at that meeting as well um if they want us to take a different direction on that this year but I have not heard anything

051I don't know if Dr Maggie's heard anything about that and I bring that up again I recognize it's somewhat tangential but thinking about the compressed calendar and timeline what it would be to what it would like how much more I I want to curious to know this before we have that joint meeting in January from your side from the finance team side how much more work would it be in that condensed calendar to do a three-year budget or a fiveyear whatever they might be requesting versus a onee I want to advocate for you is what I'm saying I appreciate that um I guess my biggest concern here in that whole conversation is I don't get the information I need to do a one-year budget where are we going to get the information we need to

052do a three-year budget I mean we have a a state that doesn't pass a budget ever right now um we have pieces of the budget um what we're having is ADM and AAR but that only gives us a onee window um Federal budgets we didn't get until November some of them December some of them we still don't have right now um and then the county you know is going to be struggling honestly with projections because of the turmoil from the hurricane I mean that's going to drive a lot of what they've got to do and I feel bad for them at this moment really really trying to make those projections so how when you don't have just like we talked about a little bit last month even a solid I'm going to have my first

053solid month of payroll this month to project a year how when you've got a hurricane year that's affected every month except for two in this fiscal year then try to project out two more years I think it's I think it would be a very difficult year to start that I'm not saying it can't start but that process would really have to be designed to be very f flexible and be able to be adjusted and not something that was locked in right now um so I mean I'd be glad to entertain it but I do think this would be a very difficult time to try to start that I appreciate that that helps inform January conversations thank you hi I have a followup question based on that I heard you say that the way the state

054money flows to us you know it's we never know and I wonder if to George's question the idea of just looking at local funds in a multi-year way would that ever be useful or does that you can't because I am curious what are the projections for sales tax and I mean maybe there are many but maybe I'd like to know all of them and just for us to be thinking about you you told us at our last work session that it takes a long time for that sales tax sort of to become the reality it's not that the taxes are paid this month and then we get them the next month it's it's a longer ride Window M is there any utility in just looking at projections on local money over multiple years from your

055P just your so it's kind of like if we if we look at our checkbook at home versus our checkbook here at at home we're buying things we're we're not buying people right so if if you wanted me to look at okay this will probably go up 5% 10% down 20% you know we we might be able to come close on those things but when we don't have any idea what money is coming in to pay the people we have or the people that we need to have and we don't know from the state what that mandated salary infringe benefit increase is going to be that's really those numbers that drive the whole process so if we had zero people paid at a local could we focus our attention on say local and capital and

056make some projection and and make some progress yes but since people are involved in every aspect of all our budgets without some of those key pieces of information it's almost impossible I mean I can make my best 34e you know guesstimate and and and and give it a good start but without some help it it won't be spoton I'll just guarantee you that so I appreciate and I think what I'm understanding that you're saying is because we do use significant local money to pay salaries and all the Fringe costs associated with that right then to separate that from State money is impossible they one follows the other the state sets rules on salaries and we have to follow suit with our local money right thank you and the federal money so Heidi I just thank

057you for everything that you shared um I just want to say out loud I appreciate that you were answering Rebecca's question off the cuff um I think your reference to the purchase of people was meant from a budgetary sense that most of our budget is personnel and just recognizing that was a little awkward of a phrase but I know I'm sorry it's okay I just wanted to put it out there that we recognize it was an awkward phrase but I understand that you were responding to the question other questions from the board Heidi gratitude that you're here and you are working on uh making our district uh as financially solvent and flexible and supportive of our staff as you possibly can so thank you very much thank you yes thank you Heidi we really appreciate

058this do you need me on the next so to the board we turn now to our two action items this evening the first one being bonus pay in light of the uh hurricane tropical storm Helen we have discussed this recommendation at several meetings you all have it in front of you and um I would entertain a motion to um vote on this I what I would propose if there's a motion and a second and then we would open it up for discussion is there a motion to approve I'll make a motion to approve thank you is there a second I second okay thank you the motion is now before us for discussion well I believe that we should somewhere somehow give our staff the opportunity to receive a bonus for just just for the work

059to they done so um let start the conversation right there I will say that I would prefer that every staff member and all of Asheville City Schools get a bonus but this is what we have been brought and I've been encouraged by the Asheville City Association of Educators to go ahead and improve something that is not perfect but is good and recognizes uh staff who regardless of what was going on at home and with their families and with their neighbors we're able to um be in attendance and help out at critical times so thank you very much for bringing this to us Maggie uh to add to that I think we need to quickly within the next maybe uh two months or three months to try to find a policy so that during the snowstorm

060or any other uh damage that requires some type of uh questions about this we it would be in place at least it would be a beginning so I do agree with um py uh about giving those that are that was recommended a um a bonus I think that's what you said right those that among other things yes okay but I do appreciate it thanks I just wanted to vocalize um the the reasons that I do not support this recommendation um or just the things that we have hashed out again and again in in work sessions um and previous meetings that uh the inability of of folks to have this these opportunities communicated to them in this very unique tragic situation um I the inequity of the ability of all staff to have the opportunity to

061show up and volunteer um I didn't feel comfortable supporting this recommendation um without a policy in place I agree with the sentiment thank you Isa I actually don't have much to add other than what what Liza has just said so I agree with what Liza said and at this point two big driving factors for me are the actions of bunkham County schools and the survey results of the acae and therefore I will support this proposal okay thanks everyone um at this time we have the motion and the second we have had discussion and I'm going to call for a vote and I do anticipate this will be a split vote um so I'm going to maybe ask you to repeat yourself but those that are in favor of this motion please say a i i

062okay you say in favor of the bonus right yes in favor of approving the recommendation brought to us yes okay yes so I believe that is for Rebecca Sarah Jesse and pepe and those against no no okay so 4 to two the recommendation carries um it is approved and I think Maggie has heard over the past weeks our concerns and about this um and has Will has work to do so thank you and thank you to the staff um our hand ringing over the policy is not a reflection of our gratitude to all of you for all you did during that very very difficult month so please know that all right I will did he actually leave poor Tyler left couldn't stand it anymore um at this time I'm going to call for a vote

063um we have receed the audit we've had an opportunity to ask questions and at this time we vote to approve it that is the process by which the audit is accepted by us I move that we accept the results of the AUD AIT second we have a motion and a second is there any discussion about approving the audit report a only to reiterate um the finance department's excellent work on this um these are it's great to see a clean audit and question Miss Heidi will you be able to answer any questions that we might have according to this audit okay thank you for those online Heidi me said that she's going to cover some of these uh items during our board retreat in January okay all those in favor of uh approving and receiving the

064audit please say I I I I I any opposed okay any unanimously accepted and we do thank Anderson Smith and white um very much for their hard work they've worked with us for years and um it was a very good report and at this point I'm going to turn it over to Maggie for the superintendent's report for um while they are figuring that out I wanted to also extend my thanks to Heidi and her team for their great work with the audit that is not an easy task um to get all the documents for those audits especially for an organization with a budget of our size um so I want to thank her and her team for all of their hard work and how they are diligent about keeping good accounting practices first and foremost

065in her policies and procedures as she runs her Department um sometimes it people get a little frazzled when she asks for something a certain way but there's a reason for that and her great accounting has really helped us keep that high rating um for our credit score there do you need me to resend it to you forbidden 43 okay let me just let you know as well too I sat in on aasa um session on FEMA um today with three sets of panel experts that have gone through not just one disaster but multiple disasters and they um all suggested having a policy on pay moving forward and they are actually going to distribute some samples to us so I will be glad to share those with you when they come in thank you thank you

066Heidi um I also um regarding the school consolidation feasibility study want to thank Mark Dickerson Mark was doing an instrumental job behind the scenes getting all the data chasing folks down when they had delayed to get their data um so he did a really great job making sure that all of our information was sub aded and just carried on a huge extra um load of work to help make sure that that consolidation um feasibility study documents were submitted on time so thank you Dr Dixon I appreciate your help all right so here we go okay um wanted to show a picture um the principles and myself and a few member of Blair Johnston's team attended the El National Conference last week it was a wonderful time for us to get together as a team um

067really make some connections and learn more deeply about e practices and how we can use the expertise and knowledge and structure of e to help us move towards our um vision and Mission um of making sure every student feels like they belong making sure we are teaching our students in a challenging and relevant um format as well as really making every second that we have with our students an opportunity for a positive interaction so that was a a great conference and um we've got lots to share I always forget this okay um the board did complete my evaluation um was it last week when did we finish that the second um they well they completed the evaluation in November and then I brought to the board the goals that I'm going to focus on for

068the upcoming year um based on their comments and feedback and the first area of um the first goal area is around communication of our vision on priorities um so spending some time this year making sure that every staff member is able to clearly articulate the vision the goals and the priorities of not just our school system but for what my vision is for our um school system um and to make sure we will be measuring that um with a stakeholder survey um to gather some information on that um the second area is is really deeply focused on our Equity work um so I've already started working with uh Miss ala and Dr second on what our Equity action plan will be so that we can really systematically move forward and move away from different random

069acts of equity to be a very much more um succinct and systematic process and then our second goal here is really focused on our staff of color to make sure that they are feeling like they belong as part of our Asheville City Schools crew um we do have a a crew survey that we are going to be sending out for Baseline and then collecting that data again at a later point for checking progress and the third go goal area focused on building our strategic plan um making sure that all stakeholder groups when we look at them regardless of race that they overall have a a positive feeling that they were engaged and that they were included in the process um so the three Focus areas there um that we'll be working on over the next

070year um the timeline for this um following our typical plan du check act um process so really working now that those goals have been approved is developing action steps um fine-tuning who will do what what roles different people will have um getting those communicated also collecting some baseline data and then implementation implementing some of the action steps that I'll have outlined mid year around May we'll collect um an update on data we'll rep Analyze That and report to the board where we are with updates and then based on that making any changes to implementation plans may December so that is kind of an update of the goals and the action steps and I'll be reporting out to the board probably every other month on where we are with taking steps towards implementation and achieving these

071goals um doe then also want to give an update on our strategic plan um we are going into partnership where our Contracting Services from Dr lavender and Julie keki um to help us facilitate our strategic Plan update and I'm thrilled to have such expertise um with these two individuals so as I've been working with Dr lavender and uh koneki we really selected to First what is the approach going to be for building a strategic plan what are some of the guiding principles that we want to lean on um and first and foremost we really came to the agreement that this needs to be collective learning and knowledge sharing that this isn't a one person or a group of people doing the plan this is a collective Community effort um but then we also want to

072focus or um do focus groups and listening sessions um to make meaning with in the Asheville City School context we know this is a very unique District that has a deep history um and we want to make sure that we are respectful of that and that we are building this plan within that context um and then also as we do these working sessions we want to um make sure that those that are closest to these issues are brought in to collaborate and inform decisions that are going to be made um particularly focusing on our most marginalized groups to make sure that they are at the table and engaging in that discussion the other thing we really then kind of teased out is if we were at the very end of the process what would we

073say would have made it an effective strategic planning process and some of the deliverables that we want to kind of overarchingly achieve as a strategic planning kind of the the three of us is to make sure that whatever we do we have built a unifying and inspirational vision for Ashville City schools that were focusing on what can be done and inspir Inspire new thinking and creative and innovative solutions so not just hey we've done this this has worked in the past but really is trying to think outside of the box on what are some new ways that we can recreate the educational environment so that it works for every student um another area that we were very um very much committed to is to making sure that we acknowledge past harms particularly to our black

074community um and that we're challenging current realities and also to the to the extent that uh we will be asking the board to write and construct a a resolution acknowledging past harms and commitment to doing better going forward um we also really want to focus on making sure this is a continuous Improvement cycle as well as a continuous Improvement community and that being as we are working on the Strategic plan always evaluating are we doing what we should be doing in this process if not what do we need to Pivot and change so that we can make this process go better for our community and we also said it needs to be sustainable so this can't be a strategic plan that sits on a shelf and it's just words it really needs to be a

075plan that everyone can understand anyone can pick up and say hey I understand what this plan is about I can understand what I need to do as my part of it and regardless of who is sitting up at this level of the table or who's sitting in the superintendent's office or a principal's chair we're able to keep this plan moving forward and then I loved this one it was they said we really want this to be a fun and engaging process that helps build our community even stronger as we go through this process we've got three kind of simple phases but a lot happening in these phases um and I love that they started actually with phase zero which is really Julie and Dr lavender taking time to review this just huge amount of data

076that we already have um so we have tons and tons of academic data we have lots of enrollment data and Staffing data and perception survey data and listening session data we just have a this wide depth of data so their first phase is to really dig through that data with intentional ways to find patterns toine themes that kind of really rise to the top um and that then they take those themes and patterns and start sharing those with our community to see if this has resonated with the right kind of findings that we would um be able to take some action upon and that phase is um they've already actually started kind of digging through the data but really taking January to fine-tune that data and come up with the a final report phase three

077is then really digging into or phase two digging into I know phase one thank you phase one um is when they'll start really digging in and meeting with community members stakeholders and that's really setting that vision for our future in March and April and then taking that and mapping what our current state of education is and where we want it to go so a little more detail phase zero um is digging into that history um implementation of different strategies and what is our current reality in Asheville City Schools um revisiting all the listening session data that we've collected over time the mometer data when the superintendent search was going on and then taking that data to refine that data through oral history of key groups so taking that data going to some key groups in

078our community and then saying here's what we're F we're finding is this still relevant for your group um in our community and then also they'll be doing a big deep dive into all of our qualitative data and the deliverable here will be just a really comprehensive historical report and their key findings from digging through all of that data phase one um is what they're calling setting the vision for the future and here's where they're um are really hoping to really Foster this Community Vision for our Asheville City school students as well as an overall vision for Asheville City Schools so they'll be developing a graduate profile they'll be updating our vision for Asheville City Schools identifying what structures systems and practices that adults need to make sure they are using across the district that will

079make sure every student can experience that vision and that graduate profile that they will be um defining with our community um the second phase here is identifying um is mapping the current state and this is when they are going to really take that deep look um and say okay what are the assets we have what can we Leverage What can we scale um what are gaps and barriers in our current state of Asheville City schools that are blocking us from getting to that desired Mission understanding some of the root causes um for the gaps and the barriers and then identifying what are the Strategic priorities that will help make the most impact on moving forward the second part of phase two is the final deliverables and this is that culminating strategic plan um that will

080have that historic um vision for ash or historic U report on Asheville um the vision for what we want to accomplish in the future our assets that we need to leverage challenges and barriers that we need to address as well as milestones for growth and improvement over the next 3 to 5 years and then those priority action areas so once they have completed this process then it is very much an internal team that starts building the action steps going forward so then once we have this final report my team and I will then start building okay here's what the lovers are that we have here's the priorities here's how we're going to um Implement um the plans to get us to the next phase any questions on that before I move on or comments Meg

081I've got a a couple um just one clarifying one and then another deeper one when when um in phase one I believe um the updated Vision does that also include an updated Mission or is this when when they say Vision are they talking about mission statement Vision every right because the mission is really going to be The Graduate profile oh okay so it's kind of that piece really folds in as well as our three promises okay so really there isn't much need for a new vision if those well and it will depend on if the community Comes Around The Graduate profile and comes around the three again kind of reaffirming the three promises because that really is our mission so the vision is where we want to go mission is how we're going to get

082there and that's by um making sure we build a sense of belonging we provide challenging and relevant content and we make every second count so that's kind of our mission um how we're going to get to that Vision okay uh so but if I'm not mistaken what's written on the website right now is that Old Mission yeah we yes that will be revised yeah so okay and come to the board for approval okay um and then I noticed that from my experience granted limited um but my experience that typically what we see in phase two that is mapping the current state m typically comes before so you can understand what the state is comes before what's written in Phase One and so I just I've got some curiosity around have there been conversations around the

083order especially between phase one and phase two and that's why I think phase zero is really important because that is really an assessment of where we are what we have and then where do we want to go and then inventorying okay what why are those gaps there we know here's where we want to go but here's where we are what's causing those gaps and doing that root cause analysis at that point Thank you any other questions or comments all right I just wanted to highlight a couple upcoming events at some of our schools that W that are not on the calendar later um Asheville high silsa is having their Winter concert Monday December 16th at 6 pm and uh principal Edwards is that going to be in the new Auditorium yay woohoo yes awesome um

084Clon on Thursday the 19th is holding its holiday meal H Fletcher on Tuesday the 10th which is tomorrow is having at 5:30 an arts and reading night um with performances by their kindergarteners and first graders and then Jones has On th Tuesday the 17th excuse me at 6 p.m their Winter concert wanted to give a quick update um from our community Partnerships um they have received at this point $25,000 in community foundations grants and then $10,000 from a United Way grant for Hurricane recovery and they're using these funds to support our students and staff um and remediate learning loss in partnership with the um project serve that Miss baggot has submitted and an update on the project serve Grant we did get a little bit of feedback on some improvements or things we can tweak

085with project serve Grant and we'll be fully submitting that for consideration here in the next couple days um in collaboration with the foundation they have distributed us with the foundation have distributed over $100,000 in Hurricane Relief funds to our staff that were most uh most greatly impacted by that um and then we are continuing to coordinate with organizations and individuals to donate uh materials and fill our Resource Center um to date and we've got donations of toys and books and clothing um and as Kim mentioned we've got a toy drive um or a toy giveaway um this Saturday so still lots of great support pouring in from all over the nation um to support the community of Asheville and I'm really thankful for that over winter break our resource will be transitioning to its permanent

086space um at the William Randolph campus it's just one room kind of down the hallway where um the social workers and uh levette Campbell have already started to set up a resource center um but then we'll be transitioning out of the gym so the Randolph campus can have its gym back um and we'll be operating out of that um um out of that after the winter break that concludes my report for the board this evening are there any other comments or questions thank you Maggie for that report that was good information um at the end of everyone's yes I'm wondering if I may take uh a moment of personal privilege you may and I'll thank you very much um I want to say how excited I am to be working with the board um I

087have a gift for each of you uh when my uh when I learned that I would be sworn in and what goes with that I uh asked my daughter well what book do you think I should put my hand on and without skipping a beat my daughter said to me why are children can't read and what we can do about it by Diane mcginness and so I have a lector's item for each of you a book that I swore my oath of office on that is also an excellent resource regarding early literacy and I will just say that my big goals for the next four years um when I look at all the gaps that we need to address where I start is we in order to close the equity gaps the achievement gaps opport

088opportunity gaps testing gaps where I start is closing the early childhood education Gap and early L literacy gaps and so this is just a tool and it has the complete spelling code in it and about seven pages of it so I'll pass that out if it is okay with you Sarah while Pepe is doing that I will take a moment to note that four years ago this was a fully appointed board and as of today it's a fully elected board that was done four of us elected two years ago three more this time and so um that is fairly significant um while Pep's doing that I'm just going to kind of point out some of the things at the end of your agenda you will see holiday breaks it's been um noted that Thursday January

08916th is an education and budget Retreat uh which is with the bunkham County school board thank you and the bunkham County government um Martin Luther King Jr day is um observed on Monday January 20th I'm just going to remind everybody that on January 18th the Saturday before there is a prayer breakfast at the Crown Plaza and ashel City Schools is a bronze sponsor of that and has always been a sponsor of that event and has bought extra tables so whoever is listening that works for the system if you would like to attend what is always an excellent event please see U Miss Jones um we have a board retreat in January instead of a board meeting so the next time we will be back here um in our official capacity will be in February and

090I am grateful to serve with all of you um I want to express my appreciation to George for two years of service as board chair he had a bunch of rookies and he patiently um brought us in and on board and we are grateful for that George um we appreciate having Pepe as a new member Among Us and um I hope to be as gracious to you as George was to us um and we have a lot of work ahead of us that needs to be done um and so unless there's anything else I would accept a motion to adjourn so moved second second all those in favor I I any opposed great thanks everyone and happy holiday please

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.