001[Music] e e e meeting is called to order uh is there a motion to approve the electronic participation by School Board M so moved second Mr Conor and Dr Tinsley uh Madame clerk would you please call the RO Mr Conor yes Mr Andrews yes Dr day yes Dr G yes Mrs Preston yes Mrs La yes Dr yes thank you you're on next is Pledge of Allegiance Dr D please rise pledge IED aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you thank you Dr day is there a motion to approve the agenda so moved second Dr Tinsley and who second I heard you and Mrs L Mrs Lowry any discussion on the agenda Madam
002clerk would you please call the room Mr Conor yes Mr Andrew yes Dr D yes Dr yes Mr Preston yes Mr depal Mrs laor yes yes thank you next one is special presentation Ed Hawks superintendent SE committee Dr Tinsley yeah so mcferson and Jacobson should be online to give us kind of their breakdown of the Stak from what they found from the stakeholder meetings but before I turn it over to them I just want to recognize some of the ad hoc committee members that are here tonight so uh Dr NIS is the co-chair he's here tonight uh principal Bey is here as well miss Lowry so thank you all for being here can I say Dr Nas would you please come on the podium he's a former School Board chair he was a chair when
003I came on the school board very level-headed person he ran the previous search when we hired our Dr Edwards he was chair of the school board so we appreciate your service it requires a lot of time beond your busy work sir and and and I would like to also say I guess uh Miss day thank you so much for uh everything that you've done in this search you've done all the behind the scenes work and I know mcferson and Jacob Jacobson have uh sung your Praises from beginning to today so thank you Mr chair that's yep they should be ready to go yes sir is a way to call them up and saying let's get going rolling or do you want me to move to the next item let's move to the next item until
004we figure out what's going on technologically here Dr D were saying something I just got a text from Mr uh depal saying he's trying to get connected but he might but he's having some trouble we'll get the logis uh next one is School Board member recognition I think M day you have handed out the vsba certificates right yes sir each board member has a certificate this is a school board member appreciation one and uh on behalf of Dr Copeland I we appreciate everything you do for the school district want to say a few words certainly nothing like put me on the spot there um I prepared comments for earlier in the day but I'll see what I can come up with right now um it was mentioned at the previous meeting that you were all
005volunteers and you had to submit an application to do this um so I thank you on behalf of all of the teachers and staff and students of Lynchburg City schools for taking on that responsibility it takes a group of people that keep children at the Forefront of everything that they do uh or may have you know teachers and retired to directors and and transportation folks and and firemen group to to carry out this job uh it's great to work with a a group of people that have their focus in the right place um there are roughly 7500 approximately out there that rely on us every day uh to do the best that we can do for them uh and I guess the part that that people don't think of often is the parents send us
006the best kid that they have and they want great things for their children every day so uh we're doing what we can it takes a dedicated board to continue to move us forward uh and a definite dedicated board clerk to keep all this stuff going thank you for all you do look forward to working with you thank you sir and from my personal note I appreciate everything uh you do as a team you know it's uh I I call you all the time most of the time sometimes at odd hours depending on how the situation is and you're not being compensated and compensation is not the uh it's the goal here is to serve the community is the goal like you take calls in middle of the night your guy shows up at my house
007at 2:00 in the morning happy and smiling and be able to do what needed to be done but it cannot be done without the help of the staff Dr Copeland your staff is amazing hard working and working day in day out uh on any needs which come arise from this board or from the community so it's a joint team effort and the city council today as they said they're part of the team and three uh Administration the city Administration city council and School Board hopefully uh if you work together we can do amazing things in this city so I appreciate everything they're here here mcferson is there so this item we move back to the item number one Dr Tinsley you're back on the floor sir all right well I I've already said my piece
008so I'll turn it over to mcferson Jacobson M Dr Ferry yes thank you can thank you for having us once again we'd like to thank you for the opportunity to work collaboratively with you on this superintendent search and our goal tonight is to present our findings from our stakeholder meetings and uh we provided the full document for you and hopefully this evening after we review this you will post this up on your District website we will post it on our website in our home office and we will also make it available to potential applicants so they are fully aware of uh the challenges and concerns that we learned during our uh time that we spent in the community so uh Dr uh White and Dr louder with me this evening they had the wonderful opportunity
009of spending three full days in Lynchburg on February 3rd 4th and 5th and we certainly like to thank the Lynchburg School community and certainly uh Tina day for helping coordinate their uh visit which um was very well organized and streamlined throughout the three days and they could talk a little bit about that during that time I had the opportunity to meet virtually with board members I also had a telephone conversation with one board member and I also had the opportunity to meet with uh City Council Members the mayor and vice mayor and uh I I'd like to thank them for spending time with me during that time and uh appreciate Alicia for the work that she did helping organize that uh process with me as well uh so with that we are going to review
010the overall themes and I do want to highlight on the front end that we are reporting out directly to you what we learned not only from the in-person conversations and the virtual conversations but also through the survey that K12 Insight conducted and all that information is included in the document uh so we did uh summarize this into overall themes and then we'll answer any question questions uh afterwards I do want to say that the application closes on the 27th of February uh to date we have 14 applicants which is um very good because normally we get a majority of the applicants much closer to the closing date so with that I'll turn it over to Dr White and Dr louder and then we'll uh go from there so Dr White thank you um Dr Ferry
011and good evening to everyone there I certainly Echo the thanks of Dr fairy on your hospitality during our visit to pburg uh we had an absolutely wonderful State and enjoyed en enjoyed immensely meeting everyone in the in the district and the community I I am going to briefly share with you uh the themes and ideas from questions number one and number to um as you remember when we met with each stakeholder group uh we asked them four questions so that we could gather their insight into the qualities and characteristics of your next leader so the first question was what makes your community a good place to live and we heard these sentiments in a resounding manner throughout each group that we spoke with uh first of all just the location you know location is everything
012and now having visited Lynchberg I certainly agree with everything I heard about how beautiful it is there uh the scenery the mountains the beaches just where it is located all of the uh opportunities that nature uh provides for those who live there because people feel like they can live a well balanced life um just because of the location so uh that was we can't wait to share that with your next leader I know that they will love uh the geographic location of Lynchburg school system um people also talked that talked about how the resources that the community is able to provide makes it a good place to live and uh in resources they shared with us that Lynchberg offers um a great health care System access to colleges and universities uh they talked over and
013over again about about how the downtown area is growing and developing to be a place that the full community can enjoy through the Arts the restaurants and the culture uh they certainly get and enjoy a a small town but they feel like they have through the resources access to the same things that people who live in larger cities have um what makes it a good a good place to live is it's a family oriented place and we heard that over and over again and people feel like there's an influx of jobs and opportunities uh again uh going back to the central location of Lynchburg school um School District now the second question was what makes this a good school district for students and staff and we took the time to ask this questions as a
014part A and A Part B because we wanted to drill down far enough to learn what makes it a good school district for students and also for staff and again these themes came up over and over again I don't care who we talk to but people are very proud about about what the School District offers to both groups the college and Workforce Workforce preparation opportunities we heard this over and over again uh the School District offers lots of innovation uh for students and for staff members through the types of support that they are able to get there's lots of Pride around the extracurricular activities even down to the transportation that is provided for those who might need that uh for the for participating in the extracurricular activities uh there seems to be a lot of
015teacher and administrative commitment and that is felt throughout your the school district there everybody talked a lot about how much commitment is seen and felt uh from the teacher teers and the administrators everybody there agrees that there's a lot of love for each other um in in Lynchburg teachers support each other administrators support teachers and everybody supports the students so that is a brief summary of this of the themes and the ideas that we received around the first two questions and good evening my name is Chris louder um and I'll be going over questions three and four and I just want to Echo what Dr said we had a great visit to your school district um it's really nice when you get to be in a lot of schools meet teachers principes administrators but by
016far our favorite groups were your student groups so extremely engaged um extremely knowledgeable about their district and what was going on they were really really impressive so thank you for the opportunity we love meeting with your community question three let me kind of go over question three and then summarize what we found uh question three is what are the issues that a new superintendent needs to know about as he or she comes into the district so what issues what challenges are there very prominent in those responses was to talk about politics and we kind of said local state and National politics are major challenges for for a lot of school systems the perception is that the relationship between the city council and the school system is not necessarily good or is not exactly cohesive and
017needs to be nurtured that came up in in almost every meeting number two perceived lack of common vision and Mission from the school board and the superintendent the new superintendent along with the Board needs to create a very clear strategic plan a clear facilities plan and a plan to address the possible closure of schools I know that came up and that's something you guys are familiar with but um you know understanding ex what what the plan for that is and communicating is something that came out um quite a bit teacher turnover is another ISS issue that came up the perception is that teachers are leaving the district because they there's not competitive pay compared to the state average there's also a lack of consistent discipline and a strong competition in your area from private schools
018and home schools um the achievement Gap is something else that was mentioned in a lot of groups um within the first five or 10 minutes of those stakeholder groups it was pretty common for somebody to say that the demographics of the school system do not reflect the demographics of the community and that the school system um is significantly poorer than the community and there's an achievement Gap that's been there for a while so that's obviously something that the new superintendent will need to work on um the transportation department was also brought up a lot of it was again brought up around the closure of schools and U trying to find drivers for buses and that maybe even Transportation drove some of the bail schedules um and so that was something that they really wanted someone
019to focus on and look at also stated there should be an emphasis on academic achievement student discipline and attendance that those are issues that are there and that need attention and there must be significant Improvement again very quickly people would say that communicating um with all stakeholders especially the positive aspects and achievements of the district um to parents Guardians the community at large and in particular the city council to make sure that they were aware of everything that was going on positive um in Lynchburg school system question four the last question was what skills or qualities and characteristics will the new superintendent need in order to be successful in in your school district um there are many personal qualities the superintendent should possess visibility came up um very quickly with all groups including the student
020group just saying like we need a superintendent that's going to be at our schools in our schools in the community out downtown we really need a you know someone to be that figurehead and be VIs ible so that came up quite a bit also with you know very um general characteristics of just honest ethical transparent and somebody who's empathetic and understands the problems of the area the new superintendent Al also must work well with the city council and with the school board to kind of work with both of those groups the group stated the superintendent had to be assertive and brave but also be able to compromise and work with others if they were going to be successful there and the last thing is again just a very iation of the same thing the new
021superintendent needs to be a great communicator that was the first thing that came up with with a you know kind of an open door policy where people could make sure that they saw and could interact with the superintendent and they also said they'd really like somebody who was here for the Long Haul and really was going to make an investment in Lynchburg so does anyone have any questions I'd like to also say though that when speaking to candidates I am emphasizing the opportunities that Lynchberg presents I believe there are outstanding opportunities for an educational leader to come into Lynchberg and work collaboratively with the Board of Education and the city council and the community to really address the issues that we heard as consistent themes and there's no question about the fact that uh improving
022academic achievement addressing the discipline issue in terms of consistency and working on some cohesive strategic plan that has a Clear Vision for everyone and uh we've been involved in strategic planning as educational leaders and uh I've had the opportunity to develop many strategic plans and they were always developed collaboratively with the city and the board of education so everyone knew what the plan was for that next five years and that's critical particularly in budgeting the challenge that we have with budgeting going forward because one of the questions I always asked was when someone asked for something in the budget well is this in our strategic plan does this support our strategic plan and that's a question that uh in in Virginia particularly with the way schools are funded that it's important because uh the city
023and the board to be on the same page there so uh with that we'll answer any questions and uh continue our work to recruit the next uh two weeks okay uh Dr fa we're going to take some questions now and I think we'll start with our chair Dr Gupta I had a question and a request the question was on your ad uh somebody emailed me or texted me says teaching experience requires let me just tell you the process going forward for us and then so the next two weeks we'll be recruiting the application closes on the 27th and then with uh your ad hoc committee pres we'll start betting candidates and present candidate to the ad hoc Dr Dr Ferry did can you hear me yes okay all right my question was your ad says
024teaching experience required and the I was with Heritage High School uh with you and uh the consensus was it's should be open whether you have a teaching experience or you don't have a teaching experience so yes when we interview to consideration because many of them may not apply seeing the wording teaching experience required instead of the word preferred uh well what I what I'll do is I'll contact the home offer at home office uh tomorrow and ask them to put preferred this way it'll open it up and then my second uh request for Dr Tinsley was um in the share of could we have the audience be able to ask questions yeah so that that way anybody who wants to have a thought or a question they can ask so feel free to come at
025the podium if you have a question to ask is that fair I I I will just I'll kind of maybe preempt a couple of questions so F first off the the results of this stakeholder these stakeholder meetings we had 21 of them and the the report that we will post and I'll talk about that in a minute we are going to utilize that information in our interview process so as we develop interview questions and those types of things this will be a part of that that's number one and number two we will be posting the entire report that was given to us by mcferson and Jacobson I'll say within the next couple days I just don't know with the snow and everything it might take us a day or two to get it up but
026we will post that on the website for the public you go ahead the floor is yours all right so any questions from the audience if you do step up to the to the podium there and Mr cor got you yeah I just would like to know um what type of response have you gotten so far for applicants 14 so far we have 14 completed applications is that on par with your usual what you see or is it a head or behind it's on par because of the app fill out and complete the applicants very close to the closing date to change the word teach education experience required to prefer the number may go up it may open up a new set of applicants any other questions this is your time Dr NIS so out of
027the responses that that you um that you you had was there anything that really jumped out at you in terms of Might being unique to Lynchberg or uh I know you hit the high points from all from the individual questions but I I was wondering if out of out of those if there was something in particular that uh struck you as being maybe a little uh specific to our our school school division um I share one thing um The Innovation opportunities that was shared over and over and over again the Beacon of Hope is a real sense of Pride for Lynchburg school system so of course when you visit different districts you're going to hear different ways that they are uh you know different things that are unique to those school systems so for me
028the Beacon of Hope the Futures program the Governor's School that makes Lynchburg stands out um I'm excited to be able to share that uh with applicants um and and that's how I would answer that question because we heard it everywhere we went um in in your school district the the innovative ways that Lynchberg uh um tries to make sure that students are prepared for whatever step they want to take to you know After High School um that it takes it takes guts for a school district to step out there and meet students where they are and answer the question uh what do you want to do after school and then provide a way for them to get there that certainly makes Lynchburg very unique uh in my mind I think also uh and we're seeing
029a a trend but not as significant in terms of what we saw in Lynchburg is the disparity between the demographics of the city and the demographics of the school district so if I was coming in there as a superintendent I would want to know I would want to do exit interviewing for parents who are leaving the district find out specifically why and hopefully be able to address a lot of those issues in addition to that uh it's really important that the next superintendent communicates all of the positive and outstanding aspects of the school district to the community to the city council so that there's a clear understanding of not because very often we hear of all the challenges and negativity but it's really important to communicate the positive as well and and I know that
030uh Dr White and Dr L were very very impressed with the opportunity to have conversations with the students and and that's where the strength is Dr free would you like you are from Pennsylvania you and I talked about what is the going rate for a superintendent salary in your neck of the woods well it depends each uh up in Pennsylvania we just placed the superintendent and don't fall off chairs there but the salary for that person that was on the mainline near Philadelphia was 335,000 uh up on Long Island and New York of course standard the the you know the qu the cost of living is much higher housing Etc the salaries are in the upper 200s uh to lower 300s uh so you know it's it's all depending upon the region and uh certainly
031you do want to be competitive in terms of your region and we can work with you on that but it's it's going to be different depending upon the region of the uh country and the size of the district is there anyone else that has a question Mr Robertson this is your chance to ask a question if you want to M you have a question no Wellen you don't have a question to the powers of I don't want to be [Laughter] involved you good so uh Dr F I'd like to thank you and your team for all the hard work you've done thus far and what you'll continue to do with us as we move down the road on the search and uh the report that they've prepared I I feel compelled to say this as
032well the report that they've prepared is not just a summary there's a very detailed report and when that is posted it it's a multi-page document actually breaks it down to every of all of the 21 meetings it'll tell you what was said at each of the meetings it will tell you what was said generally by other stakeholder group so it's a very detailed report and the ad will be changed tomorrow to a teaching experience preference required I make that call first thing in the morning first thing but we appreciate every Dr D go ahead where will the document be posted uh on LCS website LCS website okay thank you and we let make sure that the process is open and transparent absolutely and um as we move through the search process uh the community sessions
033will continue as you bring candidates or short list candidates absolutely and then of course at every one of our meetings here I'm giving an update so we're trying to keep this in front of the public and I just want to make sure that I know we here teachers are not represented but to me custodian cafeteria staff bus drivers everybody is important and they should be and will be involved AB in the process of hiring the next Dr NIS is that correct sir you're co-chair of the I'm just putting board president in terms of AD make the ad is changed on your website I'll send a new position description so it's changed on your website we'll change it on our website and we'll send out the pos position description to the 2200 uh superintendents that we
034have in our database recommending that is that fair no that's fine teaching experience required just takes out a group of people who are just administ I'm just picking on Dr V I suppose he wants to apply or somebody you know it just takes out people with administrative skills and experience to be able to apply or CEO of a company who wants to apply thank you we appreciate everything you're done sir thank you very much thank you all thank you that's all I you we good Dr Tinsley that's all I have Mr chair yes sir next one is um bass Elementary 2025 calendar Dr Dr copelan uh yes sir thank you Dr Coan and good evening members of the board um you will remember that just a few weeks ago you adopted the LCS division calendar
035um and at that time I told you we would come back and do the bass calendar as we do every year um so miss Hendrick always just does a great job of uh adjusting her calendar based on what we did with the L LCS uh it is before you to consider tonight um uh as for information and we can either approve it tonight or it can be brought back at the next meeting if you'd like it like a moment I just had a technical question about calendar once the board approves a calendar and there's a change in that does it need to come back to the board or uh I got an email that uh this sow days were you know early dismissal was taken out does it need to come back to the board
036or just administrative issue I think it depends on what it is um what the what the change may be um generally we would want to take that to the board of major changes like that but I think um the superintendent should have the the the right to make any minor adjustments as needed to to address the hours and things like that but you know if we're we're changing significant changes to breaks and things like that that would usually are starting end times that might be something would come back to the board but you generally the superintendent will make smaller adjustments as necessary so this day change was within the perview of the superintendent okay well I'm glad you kept the same as the regular calendar for their Thanksgiving and Christmas so that was good I
037have a question about the calendar looking at it um the at the bottom it has a lot of green but I don't see the green at the bottom uh so that that that'll be inter session so we can we'll make sure to add that um I can publish it sir and Dr what other he think I bass is all year round school but what I have heard over the years is it's a dual track right some are year round some are not year round well the TR the the um the tap program the the transition Alternative Program uh is is a normal schedule with LCS but the but the rest of sort of the general bass Elementary School is the is the extended calendar we sometimes call it year round but it's really just an
038extended calendar because there is still a summer break and that sort of thing it's just a little bit longer it's not a opt out for anybody to be out of that extended calendar is there a motion to approve the calendar motion Mr L Dr Day Madame clerk would you please call the role Mr yes Mr Andrews yes Dr day yes Dr G yes Mrs Preston yes Mr depal he's not there yes yes thank you next one is student services policy updates Dr kopin previous board meeting uh Dr Brown and his team were here to give the presentation uh we ran out of time so they are back here tonight to answer questions that continue the question and answer period there might be a few refresher slides yes no um no two there's the student service
039policy that's what we're doing now then there's the Ed yeah sorry I have some boring stuff before we get to the fun part um but if we're good to proceed I know um I met with Miss Preston and and hop towns are attorney um to go through our policy review for some student service policies that just needed a three-year review and some other updates um as reflected as some um codes were added and references to other um um resources and uh just was seeing if there's any questions about what was in the board package uh the vsba updates and everything were pretty straightforward and didn't know if there was any questions but we're happy to entertain those at this time if there are yeah I had one question about one of the policies yes sir
040uh policy Jo about Student Records um I think we should include as a cross reference policy J bbz that's our gender policy because it did refer to um how a student's name should be listed in policy J bbz we said that students legal name should be the name in their official record but policy Jo doesn't refer to a official record it refers to a directory listing yes so how do we reconcile those I think a cross reference um to that policy would be appropriate should should we in policy Jo should we where it says students name should it be students legal name I think if you want to Define that as a board um and make sure that that's cross referencing the policy I think that shes that up if that's the desire of the
041board um could be added line on names will be as per as defined by policy gbz jbb um so just to show you where it was um new [Music] notification trying to locate it in Jo I'm not sure I can do it on the Fly oh direct is under directory information directory the bottom um sir yeah student directory information is is defined to include the following and there's a list sir the first item on the list says students name and I'm asking if it should say students legal name um definitely creates a stronger policy if that's the desire of the board to do that and it's a simple change is the is the directory listing different than the official record directory listing under um fura fre um is information that can be disclosed about a
042student and we Define directory information so do we have a separate official record on the student is there a difference M there is a difference yeah directory information is what we would what we Define in most School divisions def Define it including these um a student's record is an actual physical record and they're all different kinds of things but their legal name is on the record is a it's a paper folder um this is just referring to information that can be publicized released okay yes so I I don't want to push the issue any further unless someone else has a an opinion about it I just had a question for attorney towns on drugs in school have you looked at this policy attorney towns we good prevention and intervention I reviewed the policy and as
043far as any suggestions or changes um there was nothing from a legal standpoint that I had any concerns about thank you it's a motion to adopt these policies I move we adopt these polies second Mr Andrew second any discuss further discussion Madam clerk would you please call the room Mr Conor yes Mr Andrews yes Dr day yes Dr gutter yes Mrs Preston yes yes Dr yes now continuation of alternative educ now back to where we were a few minutes ago now let the fun begin so um yes so just wanted to we gave a long presentation last time I really appreciate the opportunity to spend that amount of time going through our LCS restore programs and just as a refresher because it's been a little bit of time I don't want to blabber the point
044and U we also have many of our leaders from our alternative system and our restorative system here um as well to answer any questions that you might have but just want to go over a few slides as Refresher um and just a really 30,000 foot ver eye view of the program so on slide nine um just to highlight remember to this point this year we have served over 500 students in our programs um the suspension rate was around 60% 59% um before we had any of these interventions students being resuspended so getting in trouble being suspended at home and then getting in trouble and receiving another suspension was 59% we've reduced that all the way down to 18.3% since um implement these programs um we are even more proud of the same reoffence for the
045same offense um so students aren't going back for the same thing we've reduced that resuspension rate to the suspension Center down to 8.6% um as far as academic outcomes for our secondary restorative Academy students are coming in with a GPA of on average 1.06 which is a d average and then they're leaving with a GPA of 2.6 and we also Define academic progress and academic Improvement by the number of classes that students are passing of their core classes and so we didn't want to just look at growth to miss Lowry's point from your question last last meeting we're not looking just to see are they improving the GPA or improving the grades but are they on track for graduation and on track to receive those verified credits and locally verified credits by earning and passing
046those courses and so we have seen that at our um at for Hill at almost a 93% um rate of students maintaining or improving their grades at ra secondary 100% of those students um have maintained or improved those grades and furthermore we have a vast majority of those students that are improving their grades not just maintaining um to the tune of 60% approximately at Fort Hill and 75% at secondary ra um at the secondary uh ra Elementary 100% of those students are passing the math and reading courses which we know is extremely important for the grade levels that that program serves which is kindergarten first grade we want to keep those kids on track not to be retained so that they don't get further behind and really um address the issue at the root if
047you recall the U Upstream being upstream and not just pulling kids out of the river later on doing interventions but really trying to stop the kids from getting into the river and then at tap um transition program uh 73% of those kids are passing all of their core classes um and we looked at uh those upper grades for that um and then just talking about the division impact we had a slide on slide 22 if you recall where we have looked at composits from referrals from all of the um different categories not all of the categories but some of the top ones that I know was key and important for the board to reduce across the division um violent offenses fights assaults threats classroom disruptions all have come down um over the last two years
048and we're seeing those referral numbers decrease and improve do we have everything fixed and is everything sunshine and butter cups no not at all um we still have a lot of work to do um this is the perfect storm I've said this since I've gotten here perfect storm for like student Behavior to be poor um we have increased social media use and just unregulated social media use we have easier access to substances and a lot of research coming out about how marijuana THC impacts adolesence and developing Minds um and then the isolation and all the things that came along with disruption of school systems and schools during covid in that time that time period so a lot of time trying to put some really intentional um interventions in place so that we can try to
049curb those behaviors and get us to a better place and we do see that as working um and I think one of the things that's really important to highlight especially for a board um who wasn't necessarily many of you weren in your positions um when we first started putting some of these interventions in place but there were was a time where um you know we were struggling to take care of kids in preschool and kindergarten programs and teachers were pulling their hair outs as you know they didn't have any strategies we didn't have any Mental Health Services or um social emotional Behavior Support Services in our schools or in our alternative schools um there was a time where for Hill um was really really tough for principes to get their kids out of their base
050schools into for Hill because of the structure of the program so we've tried our best um on a very meager budget um with limited resources to put a meaningful system in place we feel like that's making a huge difference and impact um and again it's garnered um Regional State and international attention um which we're really really proud of and I would like to just take this time to transition and say um it's not all me at all it's um wonderful folks behind me that show up every single day um I mean it's hard to be an administrator it's really hard to be an alled administrator um you get it from every angle like uh these are kids that have behavioral challenges for whatever reason and so um it's like the Charlie Brown Christmas tree those
051kids just need a little love and these folks show up every single day with the teachers and IAS and restorative Specialists and clinicians to give those kids those love um and show them we're not just going to throw them away we're not just going to lock them away in a building and forget about them let them serve their time but we're going to restore them to what we know they can be um because it's important here in LCS that we take care of every child by name by need to graduation and beond so at that I'll entertain any questions and um our folks here are eager to mention talk to you as well thank you Dr D yeah um so um I think as board members know both Mrs Lowry and myself uh wrote down
052a list of questions that went to Dr Brown and he very thoughtfully gave us written answers for them and I'm very grateful for that fun exercise thank you sir um I'm grateful always always Fise really well then I'll give you a longer list careful what you ask for got some snow days but I also wanted to thank all the people that you just thanked who work with these kids every day I could not do what you and your folks are doing it's just beyond me so I realize how incredibly difficult a task it is um I did raise one question at the very end and I want to read my question and your response and then I just have a follow-up question for that yes sir um the the last question that I ask is
053well it's not really a question it's just sort of a thought yeah in some cases maybe behavior modification and keeping up academically are too much to try to achieve at once perhaps the philosophy should be behavior modific modification and classroom skills first with the plan that they will restart and repeat the same Academic Year in regular classes in the coming fall that was the issue I was Raising just thinking that maybe you know it can be hard to pull the student out put him in the restorative Center and at the same time as we're trying to train them to behave more uh constructively and get them ready to reinsert them back into their home class and have them up with their classmates it seems like an awful lot to try to do and so I'm
054just raising the issue could we put the students through the restorative system and then in the next fall they restart that year that was the issue I raised and Dr Brown's response was it is important to try to keep students on track to graduation without just passing them along we want them to earn their diplomas by holding students back prematurely they could age out a public of public ad and become a drop out and so I appreciate those concerns as well so my follow-up question is if if the problem is that they would sort of age out of the system is there any way we could make policy changements to allow a student who needs to repeat a year because of time spent in the restorative system give them an extra year to finish high
055school so that we wouldn't be pushing them out the door before their time ran out and if there was a way to do that would it be good yeah I appreciate the question and the thought um I think it's a thoughtful suggestion and it's um through State policy and code that students can only stay in high school to certain age and then once that age expires then you know they're not able it's a little bit different for students with IEPs um they'll have those accommodations they can stay longer um but if a school board made a policy change to allow for that it wouldn't be aligned with code but also I think a lot of these kids um are really bright they just have that behavioral challenge in in front of them and we're seeing
056that we're able to intervene one of the things that we want to look at longterm is what's the longitudinal data and so as students are returning back we know that they're staying there now for the short term but over the last next couple years that's something that we'll be studying to get that longitudinal data to see are those impacts maintaining and staying along um but I do think that it's um always our educational philosophy that we set the bar just above where our highest kids can reach and AR riseing TI raises allips and so if we can get our kids that opportunity to stay on track and graduate and get into the workforce um the college their next phase of life I think um our community colleges that's a good opportunity for them to do
057uh ideally you're exactly right so Herculean task to try to work on Behavior I know Mr Martin um and all of our Miss um Miss Scott Miss Dr Glover all of them can attest if they get the opportunity to speak um it's really challenging trying to change behavior for kids like that's a science and Mr Ferguson our bcba um knows how much of a science that is to try to replace behaviors and get kids to understand they're in a different environment and they don't have to use the certain behaviors that um they need to to survive um they don't need to use those in every environment and so it would be ideal that we could do something like that but I don't think that we have that opportunity in our legal system in in public
058Ed it's more of an and um than a or and you all know better than every anybody about the the and we have to do this and we need to do this Dr Glover's here good evening good evening good evening um I was just going to add a couple comments related to what Dr Brown was saying so one of one of my jobs last time excuse me when I came was to try to convey some of the complexities of alternative education and the students that are entering in transitioning back and forth um because of how it affects our day-to-day operations and also the Student Success and I think this is another one of those areas so research and and I can pull some sources for you if you'd like but research um would indicate that
059that um it's not a particularly students get older but just in general holding students back often doesn't have the effect that we think it would have have in fact the dropout rate increases um when students are retained um and I think another complexity with the idea is that some students would have because they're entering all different parts of the year so say you've spent the first three quarters in your base school and then you get sent to Fort Hill for your last quarter do you then repeat do you then repeat your whole grade because of one quarter I understand um but additionally I guess I think it does kind of bring up the opport Unity like we just and I'm bending over a lot because I'm taller than Dr Brown it does bring up the
060opportunity just to kind of have a conversation about some of the complexities of alternative education because you asked this question I think Miss Lowry was asking this question too about the balance between academics and behavior and that is not an easy thing to figure out exactly what that balance is um there's a high correlation between academics and behavioral problems so students that have low um academics or higher um needs academically often have higher behavioral problems and vice versa it's like a chicken or egg conversation um but trying to figure out that balance is challenging because at Fort Hill and I know at the other schools we are trying to follow the pacing guides or the logs to try to keep kids on track essentially with their base schools but sometimes that's not what they need
061in the moment they need something else in the moment and sit you're trying to figure out how to give them what they need and also keep them on track and that's never an easy or exact science I don't think I think that you should be commended though all of you because yes it is it it is walking a tight rope it's finding that place that you are encouraging the student to be successful but that that you're also encouraging them to be the best person that they can be but that requires that you have a relationship with that with that young person as well so it's a tight RPP and the fact that you walk that tip rope so successfully um all the time every day it is is really commendable so thank you for all
062that you do Mr Conor go ahead I've got I didn't send the thing in but I have two questions um the suspension and I want to talk to the suspension and a guru Mr Martin my question is about the suspension Center is how effective is that because I think growing growing up I was you know hopefully y'all don't pull my school records but I might have been suspended a couple times and um when I was in school you didn't hear that do but one of the things that um kept me from continuing to get suspended is um my mother having to find daycare for me or babysitter or take off work because I wouldn't I didn't have a suspension Center to go go to how does this suspension Center create the same resistance to a
063child wanting to repeat hey I can just I can act up because I can go to the suspension Center spend three days my second part of that question is how do in those three days are we providing transportation for them to get to the suspension Center and the second part of that question is um how are they how are we communicating with because I'm assuming you got 13 14 different schools coming to the suspension Center all different grades how are we how we keeping a continuity with their academics yes sir um so student get suspended from their base school I communicate with the principles the principles uh then send a work request form to their Bas their core teachers the teachers have a timely manner to fill that out everything is done within the 24-hour
064window to give that time to process over for the student to be suspended um I put in a rule to where if it's after 1:00 in the day the student cannot be added on to the suspension list to give that process time to occur for the academics because that's one of the key pieces want to focus on um once the student arrives at the suspension Center um they're scanned in and according to their amount of days if Jared Martin is there for 5 days the first thing he's going to do is an entry ticket which is going to pinpoint the things that they did to get suspended the next thing is going to do is they're going to pull out their school handbook policy handbook and they're going to go over the um code and
065which they violated and so that they know the things that they' done um throughout the course of that they're going to do their schoolwork and we have other restorative um work that we can do for the student um we also Circle up with the student and talk about some of the things that they did as long as things that other students have done and so we just make it really tough for them not to want to come back and don't make it inviting for them um and keep that component out of there we want to make it a place that they don't like but we also want to make it a place to where they learn and they understand and they get educated on what things not to do understand the rules and how to
066follow the rules and obey the rules and just not break them and what's the parents participation in that is there any uh the Bas School contacts the parent um and until the student arrives at my building the base school is responsible for them so say for instance Jared comes and arrives one day he has five days but doesn't show up it's my responsibility to contact the parent to then reach out to make sure the student is now coming one of the things that they also make sure is that students have a plan and goals going into the school like apologize anybody what they need to do so that they don't do that again um and we also Mr Martin left out um this most fun part of the job is taking their cell phones um
067when they arrive because it's a restorative process and a lot of reflection that goes on there so even before policy changes that was one of our rules that um phones are in Yonder pouches um so the kids aren't are distraction free um as far as Transportation yes transportation is provided um we have a special shuttle bus that goes to Heritage glass and our three middle schools um for the students who are at the suspension Center can you just clarify the grade levels that the suspension Center covers please so would be just secondary so your middle school and high school elementary y so yes and then my last question is this might be for if you had a genie here that could say boom what would be your solution to go from where we are now
068to being an exceptional um alternative education center what would that Wish List look like a bigger building and more staff to be centralized or to be centralized yes yeah I know they have more but that will be my thing I'm in two different loc right now I'm Tina kie I am the program coordinator for the transition alternative program and since you asked it would be wonderful if we could figure out how to house us together in some fashion because the thing that we struggle with is Staff when things are happening like today we had three things going on at once I'm out in the street and I've got other staff back at the building trying trying to keep things together but if we had a whole building and maybe were housing some of our um
069School social workers had offices and some of our school psychologists in a building then we would be able to have some more resources to be able to help in those emergency situations so that's my dream my dream is shared with you Kim Scott with the elementary restorative Academy the exact same that she stated um and in addition to that we also serve as students with disabilities as well so um the the level of of work and collaboration that it takes for us to work along with the Bas schools for the work that we do we're having to tap into those resources and Staffing because of our shortage with Staffing um and the needs um and so even though we're at kindergarten in first grade the level of needs is so intense because those level of
070needs are extended because of the things that the students bring to the table when they come to us so um again we do work in conjunction with all the base schools but a lot of the needs are exactly the same so we do the best with what we have we make the most of it because the kids are on the receiving end of that they don't we don't get they don't get more time because of the things that we don't have so we have to make the most of who we have and we have to be patient and sometimes what that does is that can lack our ability to be able to move the students forward as quickly more quickly than what we're able to do just simply because we do have to to wait
071and be patient and again um understand that it takes a lot of work to be able to meet the needs of the kids when you don't have sufficient amount of Staffing um so I would love to me everyone hey most of you know me as the guy that does the data um I want to take a minute and go back to this data this is wow data I need you to take a second and look at those numbers go that's pretty good I tend to approach most of these things with a little bit of a pessimistic attitude because I think if we're looking at something it's probably because we see a problem I did not expect to see GPA going up as high as they did I did not expect to see behaviors going down
072as far as they did we need to we need to acknowledge how much gain is being made with a very thin group of people and be aware of the impact that that has because I think sometimes we look at they go oh growth is great every time I did stuff I looked at it and I said I think I did this wrong this looks a little better than I expected and I go back through and I go back through there's a lot of good stuff there so if you haven't really looked at that data to to the point where you feel comfortable quoting it then you've missed some big nuggets in there because there's some really good stuff that we need to say If This Were a hospital we wouldn't be talking about whether or
073not we want to run it we'd be saying how do we better equip it so that's all I have thank you okay thank you Chuck I just wanted to add to what Chuck said uh last year when I spoke in front of the board um we talked about these programs as they were being initiated and built and we related to to small businesses and generally it takes three years for the average small business to start showing a profit we are uh a year and a half into this and we are showing immense profit we are far ahead of schedule in comparison with any small business out there and part of the reason why I think we're see such growth in academics is many of our students come to the table and they're not able to
074access the academics at all if you refer to maso's hierarchy of needs which I'm sure everybody here has seen a thousand times but you know the the the physiological needs and the Safety and Security and then the esteem needs and learning really happens on the fourth and fifth step of that after you take care of their safety and help them feel connected now people are in a psychological space where they're able to gain and retain new information they're safe enough to learn and so once that work is done and this speaks to the question also of academics or behavior and the answer is yes because very often what we do is we we get a student in who can't access the learning because they're in crisis through the on the through to their level they
075just can't navigate it and they can't access the learning but once we teach them to self-regulate once we build trusting relationships ship with them once they know that their environment their learning environment is predictable and safe and will meet them where they are and build those capacities then when they do grab the learning they tend to grab it with both hands because now we're on the fourth step of that which is where you're getting your self-esteem needs met and where you're start and the fifth step is where you're starting to self-actualize and for anybody that's gone through that process themselves you realize oh this is a thing and once you start having that success it starts building upon itself and so what we're seeing are gains that are being made that are outsized sometimes of
076the actual intervention because they're able to the students that we have many of them are are very intelligent they're just using that intelligence in order to survive and once they realize that they're safe enough to learn well then they start applying the full force of that intelligence to the learning process and those are the results that we're seeing one more this one do we have any students that become acclimated to the alternative and because we're talking about transitioning back to school are there some that would do better completing their education in the alternative program versus going back to a base school and how would that look is there a V is there a way a child can say hey I'm doing good here let me stay here because this fits me would you do yeah
077that's that's the rar exception um sometimes temporarily yes but you also start one of the things we do in the alternative program is once that student starts feeling ready once they are being successful there you immediately start pairing that success with their ability to navigate The General Ed environment so often we partner with general education classrooms we'll bring an extra adult with them in those classrooms and that's where the the rbts come into play and they help them navigate that environment and there there's a high level of reinforcement that's associated with that so now although they feel safe and they feel connected there they're also getting a lot of reinforcement for that achieving in the regular classroom environment and that starts to overtake it so it's the rare case sometimes functionally if a student is
078limited and they're not able they're not functionally able to go through those processes then we have to look at other options or if the mental health needs are are too severe and that person is is living in a crisis and one of the parts that we designed into LCS restore with the restor ofies the ideal goal is for them to learn the appropriate behaviors be able to function and then go back to the base school but it's also a a intersection um and so sometimes we find that those students need more than a quarter to work with that staff and so they're able to go to Fort Hill with Dr Glover for a longer stay um we do have some students at Fort Hill that are there for an extended period of time and and
079do better in that smaller environment we also have students um with special education accommodations and needs IEPs that go to private day situations and so sometimes um the base school is not a one-size fit all for everybody so this is Lou in last question I going to say Thank you Mr Ferguson you answered one of my questions because last time you guys talked about all the great things Mr glove was saying that they do to get the kids all you know cheered up to go back but nobody said you go in the classroom so thank you for saying someone goes with them in the classroom they spend time there with that help that's good my other thing is and this is just as an educator and I don't know how this would fit in an
080ALT Ed but let's say yeah I read that you put in one of the um answers that their reading levels are so low is there like a hour where you take it's just that Tut during hour or section where you say okay I have four kids on a second grade reading level we're going to read second grade book and we're going to work from there or are you always just giving them the high school or the Middle School the reading material which they can't read yep so at ra we've Incorporated a tutoring portion so we're Allin tutoring so each um three days a week we do tutoring and we focus on the court classes to where we're doing reading math or science within there or whatever the students are struggling in so we've Incorporated that
081the other two days a week are restorative days is that where you're using like is Miss Pew did you say that tier is it tier three is the transition the the the for the OG though or gingham because that's using in one of the tiers is that tier one or tier three it's not tier one it would probably beer oh tier oh so I'm going the wrong way so is that something used in the tutoring because I found that's very very helpful yes we've been doing that so we've isolated the students and we take them oneon-one with the teacher or you go with the IIA or um maybe our sped lead and we give one-on-one help during that time so we really things down to make sure that they're getting a tutoring portion in I
082think that's why you're seeing some of the numbers within the data and for that Genie question um that's what I brought up at the Joint meeting tonight with the city that there that the city find a building where you all can be in one place so and then um actually Nick Caputo also would like to be focused there as as his office centralized there as well and then you could have the other offices for social workers so I that is what I brought to the table tonight so um to go back to your reading levels or literacy question one of the things I would just add is um particularly for secondary most teachers in secondary weren't trained in foundational literacy skills because it's an elementary um something that's typically done in elementary or not elementary
083school but when you're trained to be an elementary teacher um and so we have had that challenge our teachers trying to figure how do we develop some of these literacy skills that are lacking and some of our students so the um Virginia literacy Act is something that was passed by the state legislature and the governor recently and so it requires all elementary and middle school teachers to go through this training that lasts about 25 hours miners had to go through it as well um but we have at Fort Hill we just are partnering with some of the trainers from UVA that help with some of that stuff and they're coming to our building to start working with our teachers so that they know those skills um cuz he can't do what you don't know yes
084um so that's one of the things that they're working on all right awesome that's great I do want to say thank you for all you do yes all of you guys love job y um and I think I just had I think Miss Scott had one testimonial she wanted to read um if that's appropriate if not we can email it if we need if we're on just go ahead quickly yeah so um I think it's so important that through all of this that we do hear the good things publicly um as well and I think I've just got actually several connections from different places that have actually pursued us and who also just want to recognize and hear more about us so we had an LCS senior uh senior in the AP AP research class
085at EC glass reach out to us to the restorative Academy in support of their topic Focus to contribute to research gathered throughout the year to the College Board at the end of the school year they were interested in how restorative justice plays a part in discipline policies and Pur procedures for LCS haven't been reading a great deal about restorative practices and hopes that their research addresses this important topic so um a restorative specialist was able to go out to EC glass um to meet with that senior in to contribute to their particular research uh Liberty University School of Education and faculty sponsor of the urban education Club reached out to invite us to speak to the students the purpose of the club is to prepare students for the realities and challenges of working in urban
086communities their particular theme was creating calm classrooms emphasis was placed on self-regulation deescalation focus and student engagement they reached out to inquire about us coming to speak to approximately 50 students about the work being done at our restorative academy uh Montgomery County Public Schools has reached out to us wanting to gain a deeper understanding of various alternative school programs across Virginia their goal is to explore different program models best practices and Innovative strategies that support Student Success and alternative education settings per their direct they reached out and would appreciate the opportunity to visit our program and learn more about the structure interventions and support systems that we have in place for our students this visit would allow them to gain insights that can help strengthen their approach to pursuing alternative education within their division we
087value your expertise and look forward to the opportunity to learn from your program and then a testimony from one of our very own uh darington Elementary School one of our students who transitioned back uh just this past December the first grade student is adjusting and this is part of the general education classroom teacher um whose classroom he is a part of he's adjusting well to our class he participates in class discussions completes his work and seems to be making friendships and doing well socially he occasionally gets frustrated or overwhelmed and cries but I just keep reminding him to ask for help and we work through it and he says I remember that he won an attendance award this was just this week he won an attendance award and the stem award was for all always
088participating in stem lab and for showing enthusiasm and excitement about the activities he is a joy to work with and we love having him in our class thank you to you and the restorative Academy it's very important that we hear those of um reports and just know uh that we take pride in the work that we do and we appreciate your support and look forward to great things to come thank you thank you thank you thank you and I just want to leave you with uh if there are no other questions just want to leave you with two thoughts Dr Tinsley you had a question yeah I don't want to open it Pandora's box but I'm very curious about this so in the past year or so we've changed some policies on uh student conduct
089and has resulted in an increase in the number of cases student discipline committee has heard I know the primary effect of that is you see more students coming through ra and in Fort Hill and other places I'm curious about the second and third order effects of of those policies can you speak just generally to to any of that um would you be I need a little more context like the the stress and strain on the system or like positive yeah positive unintended con okay yeah um yeah so it's interesting um because there are so many factors at play when you look at student discipline alternative education um so it's a really complex question um I do know that there's body of research that speaks to exclusionary practices and suspensions that they don't really exhibit many
090positive if any positive outcomes for students um I do think that being that we have a restorative system and students are able to come into it and receive those Services it's um a lifesaver I do think that if we just had those um suspensions and Hardline policies without any interventions then it would be really detrimental to not just our school uh schools community and students but also our community at large because those students are um going to be out of school more um when they're in our suspension centers and our restorative cies attendance is accounted for and um that helps our accreditation um so it's just all around positive impact um I do think that it's important to realize um that with the increase of suspensions and uh expulsions U longer suspension times to RSC
091uh that does put a stress and strain on a system um that we really just kind of peacee um just to be honest with you like we went out and we fought hard for Grants um I always have do anytime I have a initiative I have Dr Gupta like on my shoulder saying how are you going to sustain it how are you going to sustain it and so I always try to think through that and we don't want to put things in place um so we went out and F fought for Grants um because we don't want to just ask for money and say city council or put you guys in a position to ask for more funding for something we think might be a good idea um but we went out we found the
092funding we found amazing people to work and run our programs um Empower them to go do that work and we're seeing positive in outcomes and now we're at a point where you know I think I say boldly we need to sustain these programs um especially if we have those policies in place because I think it will um be hindrance for students if we don't thank you Dr Brown for all your hard work yes sir you appreciate you and your staff amazing things in our school district sir have um thank you Dr kin um Dr gup can I leave you with two things it'll be 10 seconds 10 seconds Tommy um hard commercial break right do so um I think it's important to realize that it's not just a preventative program but also uh if these
093students weren't going to these restorative cies that's a great likelihood especially if they have IEP that they're going to private day um situations and that's has a really heavy expensive cost to it for our city for our school system so there something to keep in mind and also I would appreciate your advocacy for one building and as you heard from our our folks um I just add the caveat Nuance that it would be really important to have a Elementary building and a K12 a secondary building um think about K12 putting all K12 kids on a bus or you know I have enough school that's K12 um there a lot of different needs and um that could be a little bit um challenging but if we had two separate things it could be helpful and so
094if they're in the same building though you could have two buses and yeah and then you would have your secondary in one and your Elementary in another you could have your Elementary come in one door and the secondary come in a different one in the building together so there's and they're going to be in the building together yeah they're going to be in the building they doesn't mean that they're going to be on the same floors you know there's a whole lot to it so it's a lot of thinking through still it's a work in progress I just I would um encourage and and welcome like we're here to help and ask and um you know be advised during these kind of talks and negotiations we're planning and we we want to have um be
095a a resource for you all and support the work that you're doing so you know you're out there fighting for us we appreciate I'll be keeping in touch thank you that's a long so the next one is the special board committee reports I'll open up for anybody who has any reports instead of going around in the circle and I seeing um I've got one from go ahead uh Laurel um that they let me get the right paper out okay so the modular is going to be replaced by one large one that what we said the one big one a big building and it comes to 52,000 but with the budget there'll be money left over so there'll be a positive balance when that's done um also um amazement square is involved with our um Laurel
096and they're doing the true story of The Three Little Pigs they're an iPad so they're working with our the students at Laurel as well and also um most of the dates of the things they've done are past but um the Boy Scouts troop came with Martha lipsum um uh they did the special bench in memory of the former speech therapist Martha lium I'm sorry and the amazing sports program it's a two-year special program stem sessions with the kids trips to Amazement Square um it started February 4th and then uh they're doing the Kumba African dance drum ensemble will be there it was there February 7th and Partnerships with Jojo and University of Lynchburg DBT are going well um the Lynchberg grow partnership is also going well um work rated skills and trips for the younger
097students they had a Valentine's um talent show and um and a party and the EC glass team um was invited as well as Heritage High School to attend so um and they just say happy Schoolboard month excellent thank you anybody else um the next one is informational items academic success committee on February 25th next school board meeting March 4th next finance and Facilities March 11th lacr on March 18th next school board work session uh I think it's March 18th right it's just a typo February discipline data Review Committee is March 13th and academic success committee meeting has not been scheduled in March well the then then there's two options the 18th or the 25th so I don't know we will work that out okay all right the meeting is AJ thank you