001okay uh good evening everybody I'd like to call uh to order uh the Board of Education uh meeting uh on February 19th 2025 at 6:30 pm. in the boardroom of the administration building at 7D Conor Road coln New Jersey pursuant to the open public meetings act chapter 231 this meeting has been duly advertised in the Asbury Park Press and is scheduled of meetings dated January 16th 2025 notice of which has been filed with the deputy clerk for coln Township and the requirements of posting of notices have been met if everybody would please rise uh for the flag salute it will be to my right hand side I pledge aliance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible withy and justice for
002all okay uh okay I'd like to uh get a roll call if everybody can please have their microphones on at this time thank you yes roll call Mrs camera present Mrs harwitz present Mr Oro here Mrs Ramirez here Mr Retta participating remotely thank you Mr scales president Mr Scarpa here Mrs VY here Mr Walsh here you have a quum okay uh perfect um I'd like to see if U Mrs camera could uh read our mission statement this evening the mission of cols neck Township Schools is to empower and Inspire students to be confident creative self-sufficient Learners who maximize their strengths and talents and contribute as responsible participants in their ever expanding World okay great um I'm going to um ask for a motion to move uh the minutes um under the approval of minutes resolution
003if I could get a motion motion great okay can I get a roll call please any questions or comments I'm sorry anybody have any comments on those um Vinnie this is actually directed to you um I thought when for vice um president you had abstained but I wasn't sure or did you vote no for me I don't remember I that's what I thought and it's um it's written that he said no on um okay thank you that was a okay thank you Mrs Cameron thank you okay yep so whenever uh you're ready um yes yes Mr Rico yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta yes Mr scales yes Mr Scarpa yes Mrs vpy yes Mr Walsh yes thank you the motion carried okay um at this time uh this is one of the best parts of
004being on the board I I I could guarantee everybody here agrees with me uh these evenings when we recognize our students in this district is such a great honor and uh you know I'm I'm proud to have you all here tonight so I'm G to pass it over um you know to um Dr Gay and she could present these fantastic Awards to these lovely students [Applause] not often am I told I need a microphone but when we're live streaming I do so I want to appuse so one of the as as Mrs fby said one of the best things we get to do here is is provide so many different opportunities for kids to thrive and Excel and be who they are and celebrate that every single day in every which way so tonight we're
005recognizing three um amazing in young ladies from our district who really were shining bright there's a million Awards we could give out every day for things that kids do in this District that we're so proud of but these three were something a little bit special and we want to certainly continue this tradition of honoring kids so the first one person I'm going to recognize is we had two students two students this year um who tried out and made uh the allshore intermediate band um for and representing coln so autumn r r Rik excuse me and Liliana Nicholson are both incredibly talented musicians and made our Cedar Drive Community proud as they were accepted into the allshore intermediate band this year the audition process is quite competitive as students from middle schools throughout Mammoth and ocean
006counties Vive for a seat in The Ensemble through prep preparation of scales solos and site reading skills Autumn and Liliana each scored well in their respective sections and were accepted along with 63 other students auditions are scored blindly with band directors from participating schools serving as judges here in Colts Neck Autumn plays the clarinet in the eighth grade band Colt band and Jazz Ensemble she has participated in the Band program for five years having gotten her start with Mrs Chandler in fourth grade Liliana plays Mallet percussion in the eighth grade band and the piano in jazz en Ensemble she has practi been practicing for many years and even studies piano and composition with Mrs tarby our beloved prior wonderful retired c music teacher the opportunity to perform with the allshore band allows students to perform
007alongside the best of the best this year the group performed musical selection from a wide variety of styles including a March Jazz standards and even a movie soundtrack Bravo to both Autumn and Liliana who would you please join me for your [Applause] certificate and these say so I'm gonna hand them to you ready the Colts Neck Township Board of Education acknowledges that Autumn and Liliana on this 19th Day in February in the year of 2025 is hereby recognized by the cols neck Township Board of Education for their outstanding musical talent and for being an exceptional representative of both Cedar Drive Middle School and the cnck Township Schools congratulations ladies you make us so want to say something do you want to say something oh over here about your experience um allore was very it and
008I'm just really grateful that Mr Brown helped us and helped us get into this amazing group um even though it was hard I'm I'm thankful that I pushed through it and it was a great experience and I learned a lot for from it thank you so [Applause] much you want you want this one right okay you thank you um she was selected um to participate as a student panelist in front of approximately 400 people right who who attended the mammoth County Schools partnership for well Wellness earlier this month and the focus of that event we started a few years ago is focusing really on how schools can support the mental health and needs of students and a few years ago I spoke with Kay I spoke with Kayla before she was on the panel that
009student voice became really important to that conversation it's always great to have a panel of experts and people who know psychology and talk about things about kids but what matters most is when we invite kids to talk about kids right and what their needs are so Kayla participated as a student panelist with three other students and three adults and spoke very openly eloquently and honestly about her herself about her needs and her journey as a student and working with school counsel and her school counselors and the importance of such right so on behalf of the cnic Township Schools Kayla on this 19th Day in February in the year of 2025 is hereby recognized by the cnck Township Board of Education for her outstanding service as a representative of both Cedar Drive Middle School and the
010cnck Township schools for being student panelist at the mammoth County School Symposium on Mental Health and Wellness for the wellness Symposium congratulations did I say anything sure um I'm very grateful for the opportunity to um speak for the needs and the rights of other people and getting to talk about uh having anxiety and getting to talk about my experience with having um such an egregious thing that constantly um consumes my mind it just felt very open and freeing and I'm glad that uh what I had to say contributed to the rights of people who will experience School in the future and I'm happy that um people will eventually be able to um be accessible to the care that they need because of what I've done I guess than thanks [Applause] there's on here okay um
011okay if you take notice um on the presentation we were doing uh reports from student Representatives uh none were able to make it tonight so obviously we're skipping that um if anybody would like to continue uh to stay for the meeting you folks are certainly not you know forced to so if you want to leave now you're welcome to if you want to join us we certainly love to have you and I also just want to say on behalf of the board we're so proud to have all three of you as students here representing our district we're very proud thank you [Applause] yeah so nice very nice um uh okay uh moving on we have uh one communication excuse me to be noted um Mrs Reen had uh shared a wonderful article with us she's
012here tonight I just want to let you know we do appreciate that article I know a lot of us read it and um we definitely you know take all that into consideration on how to bridge that Gap with the the co losses so we we always thank you for your input we always appreciate you being here so thank you all right um that will move uh me into my president report I apologize I did not get a chance to print it out so um just bear with me because my eyes on the computer aren't that good um so good evening everybody I first want to thank all of our student Representatives I know they weren't here uh who continued to work hard and bring about change with their positive ideas and suggestions through our students
013Le aison program we are looking forward uh to your continued participation this year along with our e uh Dr gabay and I agreed that we would um send out surveys uh to you know to the district so we can garnish feedback from all parents I know the parents that were there today uh there was a lot of parents from the primary and the elementary school and the problem is mostly in Cedar Drive so we'd like to incorporate those parents as well because that's where the the issue is at hand um so we will be doing that and we will report back with those findings once they become available um the program was to start this past Tuesday um and I had uh requested that Dr um gabay postponed the implementation of it so the board
014can have a little bit more time uh to think about it and just evaluate if we wanted to even you know start it so tonight maybe during older new business we take a vote just to make sure um that everybody agrees uh that we should put it in place and then you know after that we'll go from there um let me see I'd also like to report uh that our newsletter is coming along nicely Mrs Cera has almost completed the first edition uh which will be highlighting some of our students along with the events happening in our district and uh she will be speaking on that tonight uh we are looking forward to its debut our finance committee has started meeting to undertake the Monumental task of producing this year's budget I'm confident this team
015will lead the district to making the best fiscal decisions for the community with an outcome of a zero tax increase for the upcoming year um I know that uh will be challenging but um you know I appointed uh that committee and I'm you know I'm completely confident in all four of you that you will find where we can cut and um you know where we could uh you know um we could make appropriate fiscal decisions um moving on uh lastly our summer bridge program um uh the bridge interest forms went out today uh other successful year uh Dr garab had discussed um you know briefly with me that she's working diligently to you know adjust that budget I know we touched on that um we will provide the best summer brid program at a reasonable
016cost of the district uh so that basically concludes my report uh at this time I'm gonna hand it over to Mr scales with his thank you appreciate it um yeah we're off to a roaring start it's um it's been a little eye opening I think um you know I think switching our meetings around to be able to attend the Town Council meetings and attend the affordable housing um committees has been great there's been some um planning board meetings that we've been able to attend as well and then last week um I released a one-page fact sheet for uh resident transparency um released that to uh just the general public as as best we could I'm going to ask that we put that up on um our Board of Education website as well too so people
017can reference it as well if that's possible um but the feedback I'm getting is resounding I think it's the first time that some of our residents are are able to see what the potential impact is going to be not necessarily from the student impact but the tax impact I think the student impact as we've seen is a little bit Up For Debate right there's been a lot of stuff you sent me a beautiful email I haven't had a chance to respond to that but I swear I'll go through it I promise so but it's good because that's that's triggering some back and forth of the numbers that we've got as well too so there's a couple studies that we have to go through um we did an independent study that was just based off of
018of regular studies that I've seen across the country and then comparing that to Colt neack and that give gave us essentially a tax base that we can expect from the town as you know there's a a large amount of Revenue that comes from our town taxes were increased anywhere between 20 to 30% in the last two years here in town as well so we're we're confident with the amount of funds that we've got and then the funds that we should obtain um from the Lana Square to help us with any sort of infrastructure I think the most important piece of that too is and again thank than to Dr G for giving that as well it shows us the the impact of how many students that the school can take without being over capacity because
019what that'll do is it'll give us a good idea to figure out well how much can we take without having to look for other additions to the school and I think that's essentially what's on everyone's mind right what is the Imp impact going to be as far as infrastructure to the schools and then again you've heard me you know been pretty pretty loud about the you know not having trailers and things like that from previous EXP experiences that I've had as well too so um I'm happy to report our resolution that we put out to the public we've gotten great responses uh there's been some media Outlets that have picked it up as well too and what it did is again it's uh I like to say friction creates energy as we remember from science
020class so that friction has created a lot of responses from people that have normally had a little bit more of a nonchalant attitude when it comes to what this housing impact would be so again we've created an alert we've created a strong Foundation for all of um us as a board but more importantly for everyone in the town to be on the same page we've called upon experts tax experts we've called upon real estate experts and other people in town if they can provide their expertise for us as well because I want this to be a truly sort of cohesive project where everyone in town is looking forward to it and just to be clear just so everyone is is aware is we're we're not combating the affordable housing what we need to do is
021just make sure that we are looking more for a onetoone transition with the affordable housing uh Mr scarper and I we had the great opportunity last week to tour Soldier on a facility in tinon Falls with uh Mr um O'Brien in town as we all know who loves to attend our meetings as well so we had a great it was about two hours or so we were able to tour that facility to just look at what other options there are for affordable housing just so we can try to avoid that five: one ratio right there's as you attend these town planning meetings you'll see that there's a lot of developers just looking their chops and and colck has a Target on their back and again above my pay grade but I'm going to try to
022do everything that I can to just provide as much data and as much information as possible but again long story short we're off to a great start and as you know I'm here if anyone has any questions and I'll keep reporting um now that we have a a spot here on the agenda so I really appreciate it thank you very much okay great I just wanted to ask a question I I actually know that facility I passed by quite often it's a beautiful facility um and I would certainly I think most of the community certainly would love to have um affordable housing for our veterans um why wouldn't the town uh want to go down that route is there a reason why they wouldn't or is there you know we're you know we're not sure
023again it's it's it's not something that again a comment was made at the Town council meeting which was a little bit alarming which was it was more of a they were using the term separation of church and state as a joke just to explain that you know the the Town Council their responsibility is for the town it's not necessarily to report numbers to the board of education to help us with and we disagree with that right so what our focus is going to be is to look at these options to educate ourselves on facilities like that so we can then go back to the Town Council and the planning board and then present what we think are adequate solutions that are going to benefit the school schools benefit the infrastructure so we have a lot
024of work to do we're trying to educate ourselves on those options but ideally what we would like to do is if there's going to be other seats on the the subcommittee of the town the uh planning board which we hope to be members of as well we're going to be presenting these Solutions just so there's again more of an outside the box look at it um but like you said I think that was the first thing that Mr scarper and I saw when we were there we like wait a minute we've got a base that is here in town this is going to be something that could be substantially just to give back to the community but also really just put a rubber stamp on the Colt's identity which is half of half of our
025property is is in a in a base so we're going to bring it back to the town and we'll see how it goes yeah agree actually can can I just yeah I just ask some questions um so just logistically speaking um Mr skills uh the affordable housing committee you guys met as a committee since I was meeting we so we meet as a a subcommittee right yeah so for our bylaws when a committee is going to meet there should be an agenda that's set and sent to the full board this way the full board can kind of comment on it and see what's going on and have an insight as to far as far as what's going on during those meetings so moving forward I would really appreciate if when there are going to be
026those meetings that the full board is informed Med and that we have an idea of what's going on um that's just keeping in compliance with our bylaws and also being transparent with the full boards that were aware of what's going on um second when you and Mr Scarpa went out were you representing the board or were you just there as private citizens private citizens okay thank you for that clarification and then you stated that you compiled and released a fact sheet um where was it released leased to the general public okay on like how Community page okay um as you as a private citizen as a private citizen okay so before we go ahead and put that up on the website I would like to request that the full Board review that so we can
027see what's in it um I think we should be voting on that as a board to be putting it up on the website versus just one board member creating it um and then you mentioned that we did an independent study can you clarify who the Wii is in that but me myself and I okay um can we can the board have access to that dependent study you do have access to it okay where is that that's it's located in the public as a private citizen and presented it to the public so you have full access to it okay I'm not on social media so would you be able to provide me with a copy of that on via email sure or you have my number I'm sure y um so okay thank you so much
028I appreciate all that clarification uh so we held our first um parent advisory committee uh 2025 last night and this morning as Angelie mentioned uh we had a really great turnout and it was really great to meet everybody and hear you know different thoughts and concerns uh we covered a lot of topics um some of them being social emotional learning program the cell phone pilot program that Angeli mentioned um in the Middle School the use a Chromebook BS um specifically in the primary and elementary schools uh both Dr gab and Dr Beck had some really great insight to share about uh adding some value valuable perspective to the discussion and additionally Angelique had a great idea about um recognizing and honoring students in a different way in our district and we'll be working with Dr
029Beck on that to to see that initiative go forward um you know there were a lot of meaningful conversations that were had and we didn't get through nearly I know um but that's just more we get to enjoy for the next meeting so I look forward to it great um like you said there was a lot of a meaningful conversation it was nice to meet there was mostly I think I knew one person out of that whole group or maybe two uh so it was nice to uh you know to connect with them and uh like Dr gar said it was kind of um long we had a lot to say and we only got to through I think three topics out of nine um so we're going to try to tighten it up this
030way everybody gets a say on those um agenda items at the bottom you know so okay great Sarah thank you and you could just roll right into the PTO okay um so the book swap is still going on donations of age appropriate books are encouraged uh and students will be able to select books on March 5th and any remaining books will be donated to the library the readathon is scheduled for February 24th through March 7th Flyers were sent home but for additional information and signing up you can visit the PTO website um the gala invitations were mailed out a few weeks ago with the RSVP date um approaching um if you want to provide your RSVPs to um you could either drop them off at three pepper Moline or you can mail them in um
031they're also having new merchandise for uh spirit wear available soon with um links hopefully we'll get that uh relatively soon they'll be included um they're including tank tops and shorts and it's always you know the spirit stuff is really nice so I'm sure it'll be great um and lastly if you don't receive PTO emails you can always join and you can find on information on membership on their website both of my mics have um oh it's on now I'm having problems with this this is not charged properly but um okay great Sarah thank you so much um we're going to move on to the coln township uh School newsletter Mrs camera okay so it's finalized um let's plan for release um Monday February 24th that works for everyone awesome along with highlighting different student Liaisons
032and a board of education member um Brian recently suggested including a military Connection in our next issue starting in spring so I was thinking like the Patriot report uh where we could honor service leadership and education and I'm just really excited to see this grow as as we you know collectively gather new ideas so I'm really excited for this yeah me too me too um okay um Mr rugnetta I don't know uh he could hear me um yes if you'd like to do your Le arm report softball registration um is still available uh for uh children uh four to uh 16 years old uh for baseball uh four to fivey olds will be t-ball and for softball four to six year olds will be t-ball uh opening day will be April 5th for both and
033appears uh baseball will go through uh June 21st and softball will go through June 28th plus playoffs and there is also a six week preseason clinic for softball starting uh March 1st and the other thing um go go to coltson xports foundation.com for more information and each uh sport has their own page on that website as well as their own contact email on the website as well and as far as our schools are concerned uh the Cedar Drive Middle School spring musical is right around the corner next month uh they're performing Matilda on the 14th of March at 7M and the 15th of March at 2m and April 1st April pool's day will be the uh uh Telo spring uh concert uh with the band of the element School band performing and both choirs from
034the primary school and elementary school performing thank you great uh thank you Mr rnat we appreciate it um okay um Mr Walsh if you can uh do your senior's report please okay uh seniors are going to be invited to our school play dress rehearsal thank you Dr G for connecting with Mr shabelle our president of the senior citizen um organization along with goodness gracious the vice president Walton Nancy Walton so Dr gar sent out an invitation it's Matilda they put on a wonderful play I'm looking forward to attending opening night the last musical is fantastic so the seniors will be I think you already have a response there ATT and it's fantastic I really appreciate it um I think it's going to be a great connection having them on our school campuses and uh supporting
035our school district and you're not paying the price of a Broadway ticket so thanks again for Dr G uh your work and uh Dr um Rigby uh okay I apologize uh um Mr scarp and and Mrs camon I skipped over you I I'm really blind I'm so blind so it's difficult to read these uh the agenda sometimes I have that's all right uh so miss camera Mr scales and I attended Township meeting on February 12th was a very interesting meeting and a good meeting uh affordable housing as Mr scales uh discussed was uh first and foremost on the agenda with a lot of good information received a lot of actionable items resulted in the communication by Mr scales after the meeting um Mr scales and I both spoke at the township meeting to reinforce a
036message for clear and actionable data to be shared when available with the board so that we can best prepare for the expected influx of students in the coming years so all in it was a good dialogue it was a good opportunity to educate and to carve out some of the uh channels that we're going to be expecting in 27 and on so um all in a good meeting and thanks again to the combination of our schedule with their schedule so that we can afford this opportunity so great thank you um Mrs C did you want to add anything okay I just want to make sure we don't miss uh okay moving on to Naval Weapon Station Earl Mrs scarp and Mrs Ramirez you're welcome to uh sure I'll I'll give it a start uh we're
037meeting with uh the naval weapons station on Friday March 21st thank you Dr gabay for setting that up at 2m to tour the base and and just St oh State meting okay okay um it's which basically support our our families and students here the next Board of Education newsletter uh will feature a student Spotlight that Miss uh phis mentioned uh in our quarterly communication this is an opportunity to to sort of highlight unique students you know that Hey listen look at this look let's tell their story so we figured let's choose one or two students from the Naval Weapon Station to specifically highlight in this feature share some pictures sh has some stories and we're excited to extend this to the to the larger student base as we proceed forward without newsletter so very excited
038about that there is a science opportunity with en Naval uh a base uh Mammoth University currently has a program that works with the base to develop and maintain oyster reefs uh these are natural defenses while restoring their environment and oysters are own ecosystem Engineers they're very unique creatures so the thought is to work with our student leaon to see if there's an interest in these programs perhaps we can have students from M University visit our schools and present this program to the students at a lunch in learn uh this came out of a conversation that I was having separately with momth University and then the bells and whistles went off and lo and behold that they have a program with naal weapons station Earl we' love to speak to all the aison about that and
039maybe we can work on something in that space uh I know field trips could be expensive but maybe we can get someone from MTH University into our schools to speak about the oyster program something I'm noodling figure that out um work with the affordable housing opportunities of interest uh Naval Weapon Station are also reports an honor guard detail these service men and women provide the sacred right to all eligible veterans to receive military funeral alers at the end of their life at at the naval weapons station a select group of dedicated Sailors maintains a tradition of honor and respect to those who serve the United States Navy and to loved ones left behind so again the bells and whistles are going off if we can work out a program where we actually have some qualified
040affordable housing in the veteran space Maybe we we create created interplay with the weapon station and bring on forth a service that they already provide to our our newly built housing opportunities again some opportunities in this space that's all I have great thank you Mrs Ramirez no Brian went over everything thank you okay um all right moving on um to the state and County School boards uh just have a couple things um the school boards has nine Statewide training programs available starting April 4th uh any board member that's in interested is welcome to register uh I know sometimes that could be difficult Mr morasa always offers assistance uh you know we're registering uh so you're more than welcome to reach out to him if you have any uh questions uh as you know we get
041all the Schoolboard emails so you can find those uh those courses in those emails um also uh the New Jersey school boards uh is calling for entries for Innovations in special education award for 2025 um I know we touched Grace Phil said sent an email um special ed week is May 12th through the 16th the entries must be received by March 21st um I'd love to have Dr Garay um submit an entry form on our behalf uh highlighting one of our many special education programs uh I certainly think we would have a great chance of winning uh because our programs are absolutely fantastic so if you're willing to do that for us we certainly would appreciate it the district sign okay all right so um that's great so we're going to be moving forward with
042that and just lastly I just want to remind the board members especially the new ones um to make sure that you're uh you all have your new board member training um before that expires I know the dates coming up um your financial disclosures I actually had an issue with mine um I think we have till April I believe to hand that in I'm going to try to do it within today or tomorrow uh but just a reminder for everybody to make sure that you're up to date with all your training uh requirements um okay let's see um moving on we're going to give the floor to our superintendent for her superintendent report want to use mine okay thank you um thank you Mrs vpy um the first thing I just want to do before I
043jump into the report is that as we're going through the new format format of the agenda and you know you look at it and TW twice check it and three check it um when when we move into action items we'll actually be voting on action items 1 through six because an information item that appears is are our very generous uh minig grants the PTO mini grants that go forward and that actually needs to be accepted uh and approved by the board of education for as applicable funds so when we make that motion it'll be a motion for one items one through six under action items it's currently included underneath information item so I just wanted to make that know you just remind me I certainly will absolutely um I also wanted to to just take
044a minute to to really celebrate the children that we honored and thank you the board for taking the opportunity to to do that it's not easy for kids to get up and try out and and play their instruments and be committed and it's an it's really a a celebration and when when our students who remember aren't high school students they're 14 years old maybe 15 at most when they're leaving us and they're out there trying out whether it be for plays or they're trying out for musicals and they're representing us on a large stage um there's a really big sense of Pride that comes along with that and I'm just proud of um you know those young ladies for doing that and in that moment with the the mammoth County Schools partnership when I tell
045you that Kayla shined she shined what with your articulation that was demonstrated here um was represented and resonated and I had several people from that night reach out to me say are you sure that girl's that young lady's in eth grade and I said she absolutely is and she she makes Cedar Drive proud so thank you for always um on behalf of the staff always supporting those things that push kids and give them opportunities to thrive in multiple environments regardless of what their interests are and allowing us to expose them to new interests uh because as they're developing who they are as people which is great so I just want to thank you for that um for my last president's report I'm president oh my God no superintendent report no offense no offense um from
046my last superintendent Sports it's a busy time of year um you know we're uh Mr masas and I are deeply involved on a daily B basis of articulation with our principles our department managers with regards to the budget development uh sharing information as it come some of it will be sent through the um ad hoc finance committee some of it will be shared in the weekly update for the board um so it's it's a process we're also coming to that point in year where Mr rasco and I and many of us are have one foot in the 2425 school year and the other foot in the 2526 school year so you'll see that on tonight's agenda there is a recommend ation for the first part of the 25 26 C calendar so that is so
047we can start planning vacations and things whatever families do moving forward into next year but then also taking feedback because one of the things that's in this year's calendar are our spring conferences right and through the parent advisory committee and through in working with our teachers and administration we want to revisit that next year we know that half days um can sometimes be difficult for parents to manage and it is feedback so we do after this year after this years's fall conferences which are spring conferences excuse me which are next week we're going to send a survey out to our parents and our teachers and say like listen is this something with the availability of communication um you know ongoing communication between teachers and parents and emails and calls and things that can happen do
048we still want to dedicate that time in the calendar and we can revise that if that's something that moving into next year we don't necessarily need to do um on the school calendar you also see that uh there are snow days emergency days they used to be called snow days mergency closure days because when you have to close for wind and power and things it's not a snow day um which I'm going to bring back to this school year which is uh right now we've had some good luck with regards to inclement weather uh this year in the 24 25 school year there are three emergency days built in so we'll be monitoring that and by the end of March beginning of April there'll be conversations and recommendations for the board to where those three
049days are going to get taken back so whether they come off the end of the year or it comes off sometimes we go for the Friday before Memorial Day different things like that but um hoping we get through march sometimes March can be a little challenging as we've seen in in past years so we'll we'll get once we get to about the end of March those that decision with that but stay tuned uh for a change if we're able to give those three days back because we build in those three days um when we can as uh and then we get them back um on the agenda as I said for the action item I just want to extend my sincerest appreciation and gratitude for the PTO as always with regards to the minig grants
050you can see that's a pretty big number of $24,988 that's afforded to our teachers to provide additional things to students in the classrooms there's an application process that begins very early on it is extremely organized and inclusive um we they ask for a very thorough review in terms of how it matches with our our curricular needs supporting environments class trips uh assemblies all of these things are represented in there so um I just want to extend my sincer thanks and appreciation for all that they do to fund raise because that's a direct um this action item on on the agend tonight's agenda is a direct reflection of their hard work and their commitment and giving back to our students in every way what they do so I can't thank them enough on behalf of the
051district okay I'm going to slide in working with president fpy on the conversation about the pilot program the cell phones uh at Cedar Drive Middle School so and then I'm you can either take questions or whenever you feel it's appropriate we can chime in it so I'm gonna once upon a time when cell phones became a thing in uh schools and students were became frequent users of cell phones um that were not flip phones when when they were first phones there was a policy that was implemented okay and that policy is from 2013 and that policy was about that no phones were to be used in school they had to be hidden away they have to be on the person you can't take them out that was the 2013 policy 2016 a new policy came
052out that would relates to electronic recording devices that are not permitted and have to be stowed away so when you merge the two of the technology evolution of the cell phone right which then became capable of recording devices um our policies our practices deferred to the 2016 which meant that cell phones with recording devices had to be away and stored into cell into into lockers the reality is and this is the reality the policy states they're away and in cell phones the reality is they're not right they're carried on their persons for for a multitude of reasons um and it's a distraction it's it's be it's a distraction in school um and our job as Educators is to always provide the most conducive learning environments to support the learning of students and when and where
053we can eliminate distractions in that or things that May compromise those learning environments we should be diligent in doing so that's really what we should be doing and so a few years ago and really it is probably about two years ago some of the teachers at Cedar Drive recognized the fact um that students were carrying their cell phones on them and remember that Cedar Drive just like in every other building in in the district you strive to create a culture where students feel a sense of belonging they contribute to the community you want to have a good rapport you don't want to be constantly disciplining students for their use of their cell phones right which is innately now become such an an important part of of them you know and connection as you as you
054hear so in our physical education department they also recognized that the cost of a cell phone was at Jeopardy when students are running around playing volleyball playing Cedar ball whatever it is they're playing that there was a a a a potential for a damages so they implemented the practice of anyone who did not have their recognizing you may not have put your cell phone in your in your locker could you please put it in a pocket and and the way I can describe it best is that you ever see the door hangers of shoes where there's multiple pot I mean that's the best way I can describe it visibly and I'm happy to bring in a model if anybody wants to see it as well but that's really what it is and so that is
055available and students come into the class they hang their cell phones it is visible to them but is not accessible to them during the physical education period okay and that goes for if they leave to use the restroom or anything like that because another common occurrence not just responding in the moment in class if it's vibrating or they're checking to see who's sending that it's also something that we've seen recurring the calls to go to the bathroom the calls to respond those types of things where um you know that that's tempting them to leave the classroom and to meet up with their friends they're we understand that so two other teachers in the district also adopted this as part of their classroom practice as part of their classroom routines you walk in the classroom you
056put it and fizzed and two classrooms this has been occurring so Cedar Drive has a culture and has h a rapport with its teachers where they kind of level set and say all right where are we going with the year and multiple times a very similar and recurring concern of the staff is student use of cell phones right and if they spent all day reprimanding students for having them on their persons can't we find another way to not just embrace the culture of what the reality is while also protecting the learning environment you know and compromising with it building in an opportunity which we everyone we we had it out actually at the second meeting today which is the anxious generation which is a book that talks about the addictive Natures of cell phones giving
057them a tool to empower them to physically disconnect from a cell phone and allow themselves to be present in the moment of their instruction right while still having visible site to their phone so I think in conversation with the teachers there was a a with the administration and support saying can we expand this to almost like a consistent practice throughout the district and throughout excuse me just seat or drive to try it can we just try it to implement it schoolwide it is not in any way shape or form trying to take a cell phone and away from anyone or privacy it's giving them an it's asking them to disconnect from their phone having it still visible if there's a comfort level to it and then them being able to take it at the end
058of the class and take it to the next class with them so no one is asking them to turn it in we know that we want to get feedback from our staff our parents once we implement it but I think one of the things that we encourage here is US trying new things for the betterment of of kids and seeing if we can solve a problem in a realistic and compromising type of way that fits the reality of a situation so that the approach and that's what was the asking for the board and then working with through the policy chair and the board to say all right so how would we adopt the policy to because we are through a pilot working outside of the the policy for it so we want to try it
059and we want to see it and then through the feedback make a final decision if this is something we want to go forward with or it's not well if we get feedback that says you know I think a good point and I'm sorry to bring this up but at a good point in the parent advisory committee that we heard back was also a situation where um we don't want it to ever become combative because I think that's another level of of concern where they're saying what if a child doesn't put it in the pocket refuses to well that's a different story you know you've got to deal with that from a from a a code of conduct point of view but we also want to be sensitive if a child does have anxiety does have
060issues we're going to encourage through the communication from the administration of the building to the parents to say let's talk that through right and let's let's let's have a conversation about how we can get them to the point and never ever has a child you know asked a teacher or a parent to say like can I please I need to text my mom for this right or I need to and I think that's the kind of culture we have that if they need to get in contact as a mom of twostep mom of three I understand that I made a joke during the parent advisory my 23-year-old was was flying home from Dallas today from from from work and like a fool I'm watching him cross the country on my United app there's nothing I'm
061going to do if something happens to him but I felt the need yeah watching the little plane come up from Dallas to Newark but I felt the need to be watching I understand and we actually even said sometimes I think our need to connect might be bigger than theirs but understanding that's also reciprocal it's a direct line and we want we I appreciate all of that because it's a Mom's perspective parents perspective it absolutely Safety and Security all of those things we get it so that's why I think we're trying to also maybe say maybe the locker is a is is we can move from that and have them still here but invite them and ask them to detach from it as as that's what we're asking them to do in this process and we
062want to try it you know we we have a small U microcosm of a pilot that has been working successfully without any type of thing and I think the feedback from Mr M is here with us tonight and so if we were able to kind of move forward and look at it and say all right what's the feedback what did we run what were the problems that we had what are the parents saying what are the students saying what are the staff saying and then come back and make a final decision so that's the ask from the district um I like to make a comment I don't want to carry on too much with this uh to make the meeting brief I just wanted to um give my viewpoint on this uh briefly I know
063I said it two meetings already um obviously I agree we're here to learn and educate our kids I I don't want um my daughter as versus anybody else texting and distracting the class um the reason I had an issue with this is um you know like we discussed there's kids with severe anxiety and um mallerie I think you were here and Tara we we had a great discussion and um they all feel they support the program um the reason being um kids with anxiety that is their one connection to their mom or dad um and the other thing was like knowing my husband for so many years being a police officer we have experienced a lot of tragic things and knowing that my kid may be in school and something horrific happening um knowing that
064she's a phone call away these things matter to me um and you know there's some young ladies you know have menstrual accidents and they don't want to go to the school nurse they're embarrassed they want to call their mom mom I need pants Mom I need this a lot of people you know don't realize there's that like privacy issue um but I do uh respect the fact that I do not want our teachers to be uh working double time and spending their entire day reprimanding our kids for cell phone usage um so I'm kind of torn I do want to speak for the parents that don't agree with the policy although um it was you know predominantly you guys all support the policy once again your your younger children um compared to you know some
065of us on here we have mostly uh older kids well not everybody I'm sorry Sarah and Jess have younger kids um but I just wanted you to hear you know my point I certainly don't you know want to cause uh the district to do any uh extra work but I just wanted you to hear from some of the parents why they would want their kids to have their cell phone um just so you hear two sides of the story so that's all I wanted to say um and like I said I uh you know if you you know if the board wants to move forward and allow um the district to implement it at this time I'm certainly okay I think it's a fair shot to get the feedback see how it works um and
066uh whatever you guys decide is fine so we got to make a decision tonight so we could move forward and not hold up uh the implementation so I have a question uh have there been any um exceptions made in the pilot program where the students with anxiety and stuff like that they might need that connection has that come up and a one off make the exception um so to your point we're always working one-on-one with what students needs are and if there is a need or if a child actually has to leave and go you're taking your phone and maybe going to the the nurse or going to another place if I have to there's an emergency we work with kids you know and so we re we recognize them so um is something directly
067coming to mind no is am I 100% confident of of that I can say yes to your your your question yes I can um I like the idea of before we implement the program to actually survey the parents of Cedar Drive Middle School and then based on the survey make a decision um about the pocket policy I'm not for or against it I I really would just like some data from from the parents about their concerns um I definitely like the idea that we are being flexible we understand that kids are not keeping in their lockers and I think you know changing that policy is important um would the first step be maybe letting them keep it in their Chromebook cases and then as a second step the pocket policy like there might you know
068it might be um something we want to look at like step one step two depending upon students who are too immature or don't want to follow the simple policy of keeping in their Chromebook case um so my only concern with the pocket policy is if all these students have a different number in each class right each period sometimes you're number 18 sometimes you're number 17 there there's a chance that a student could accidentally take someone else's phone so it's it's just something that was like my biggest concern when I when I heard about it so that that's my only real concern um but I do agree with with Angelique we we our our number one purpose is to educate our students and I definitely wouldn't want the same thing teachers don't want to be reprimanding
069constantly like that takes the joy out out of their job and it it really hurts the relationship with the students and that's that you know before they're learning you have to have those relationships so I'm just in favor first starting with a survey and going from there um I was just going to ask um kind of on what Phyllis was saying when the cell phones are quote unquote taken from the students are they being asked to go up and put their phone in their respective pocket okay so they're not giving them to the teacher who's then putting them in the pocket and then is it also the same in the reverse are they going up and just taking them out of their pocket or okay so maybe to solve uh what Phyllis was saying we
070could do something where the cell phones are handed directly to the teacher I know that puts a little bit more ownership on them and then the teachers putting it in the pocket and then same thing before they leave I'm sure that takes up some time during the class but it would also eliminate someone's cell phone being taken by the wrong student um we know how teenagers can be we know that there's you know been issues before not only in our district but in others where there can be bullying and harassment and whatnot and I would hate to see someone's cell phone taken and then it creates another issue for our district going forward so um there could be something like that and again if it's numbered also like Phyllis was saying then in one classroom
071they have one number another classroom they have another number so um maybe it's a consistent number assigned to that student so even though those Pockets then might seem a little disorganized when they change classes but um it could be you know that's their specific number um I think there's ways around this that could maybe work out some of those concerns but and maybe you already have some thoughts on that as you your head of me I think I well and I app again I think all of this is good feedback for us I don't know I don't know to delay it is going to give us information that we wouldn't get do you know what I mean and I understand it the the par and it's a tricky place because parents own the phone there
072aren't kids in middle school who in for the most part who own their phone so it's a parents piece of property you know that they're allowing their child to bring to school but at the same time right now that property is supposed to be in a locker and it's not right so we're trying to protect the property right and saying what we're doing so I think it's a double- EDG I think the teacher's input in this is equally as valuable as the parents because the parents are going to respond possibly and I don't ever want to speak for for anyway could potentially um be in favor of it because they want that disconnection as we heard in the parent advisory but I also understand the perspective of the of them saying like that listen we
073bought that phone that's your phone you know and they don't have a a right to take it or whatever the case may be so I think we're just trying to find that balance and I don't know you know I I and I I respect whatever role or whatever Direction the board wants to go in um I'd like to try it and see what then what what the feedback is and then Implement things and and I don't know that we could plan for every Safeguard of what would happen I think we can deal with it as it's evolving like we have with many Pilots that we've done that's just my you know I'm sorry one more what would be the like the pilot like how long would it be 30 days 60 days 14 days like
074what are what are we thinking I I think we could TR we could try it and I could give reports to the board you know at the board meetings going forward we could try it for the remainder of the year we could try to go whatever the time frame we want to do and if at any point we decided you know from feedback that we were just receiving even via board email was terrible and we were like all right we need to put a Hal to this we could just do that at one of our meetings we could go on that right because remember the board policy is still the board policy right that's why this is the conversation of the board L because the board policy you could say like listen it's it's there
075right so we're actually looking to say we want to Pilot something that is outside the realm of the board policy okay if the board we're going to make a decision tonight um regardless um if we move forward with it and we agree to give it a shot how quick would the survey go out to the parents to get the feedback about it um we send out communication to the parents first about that it's going to happen you know and I think that through that we could invite them to say if you have any question like we do always if you have any questions or concerns please let us know so that communication will go out first and then we could follow up in we a Google survey takes this much time to do hey how
076we doing you know and just get that automat that you know how we're doing it's a quick survey so we could do that you know every two weeks every month we could do it in a month we and then report back as as we're following it you know as a as a progress I'm out of battery but what I would I'd recommend like we just don't overthink it um we have to act quick that's what I mean so um I'm in favor although I'm not in favor of taking the phones I'm in favor of trying it so I think we should just do a quick vote so we can move on with the meeting um if anybody has anything else to say I'd certainly listen oh I'm sorry I'm so sorry Mr Retta I I
077did not I did not hear you sorry about that if God forbid there is an incident um and the and the phones are and their lockers and I'm and I'm just talking about the the very small likelihood very very small likelihood but the worst thing that happening that the the phones are in the lockers that it it makes it virtually impossible for the kids to be able to get to that phone to notify the parents that they're okay I'm just I'm just putting that one thing out there I agree that was one of my concerns so I I appreciate appreciate your feedback on it as well um yes hopefully that would never be the case but uh if people you know realize um I think earlier in the year the high school had an incident
078and I know a parent that has a child there and the fact that that child was able to call during that lockdown was um just worth a million dollars that that mother knew God my my kid's okay I just heard from her like I said the chance of that happening but you just never know in this world so and we just um it's harder for the state to change a policy once we have a new one in place and Murphy wants to take them away completely so that's an infringement on freedom and it's illegal so before he gets his hand and everything we have to do something so I think it's a happy medium so it's at least there because he's coming for cell phon all right so um let's move forward we'll take a
079vote everybody wanted to implement it um you know just to see how it goes I just want to add one I actually have a different take on what Vinnie was saying as much as I agree I actually think that it hurts us to have the kids if there is some situation at the school to be texting their parents right away because what happened at the high school was there was a lot of misinformation and a lot of Gossip without actually knowing what happened so a lot of times I think it makes more sense for them not to have access to you know there is let me know if I'm wrong but there is a own in the classroom so if they need to reach anybody that's you know you have a teacher there to help
080you along with that but I think children just automatically texting their parents like oh my God there's this this is happening that's happening that's how a lot of misinformation gets you know gets thrown around so something to consider okay anybody else before we do a STW poll so we could um WRA it up um if if the Google survey is so quick I just I don't see the harm of of just implementing the survey by letting us know the feedback within you know 48 hours and waiting a week to um you know to start the policy based on on the parents information I just think that's fair to the parents of the middle school students we'd have to wait till the next meeting then to do a straw poll then to start it right because
081we've sent out the Google survey and then we'd have to wait until our next meeting before we could start it yeah so the Google um the parents are in favor couldn't the policy start as soon as we have the data we we'd have to direct it so it would be it would still be two weeks we could have the survey vote for the survey right we vote for the survey and based on the result of the survey it's implemented if the the majority of the survey results so you know 51% say yes then we imp let's say starting Monday of next week so just for for clarification you don't have to vote on a survey that's we can do that by ourselves there's no there's no STW on in that yeah the preference why right
082right right in order to implement the program the parents of Cedar Drive Middle School we we need 51% to want to implement this program so then I would also ask that I also be I'm also going to facilitate a staff survey so that so the board can have votes you know four so that the one you know there's there's equal representation of of those uh two stakeholder groups you know that they can be looked at right we assuming St yes yeah yeah I just want to make sure yeah absolutely okay so moving forward we're we're gonna take a straw poll the survey will go out first we'll take a straw poll uh like philis said um 51% or whatever the majority and then uh whatever the data reads will implement it right away or we
083won't everybody clear and everybody agree yeah okay fair okay all right let's move on so we can um yeah yeah we could just move on um okay we're gonna take notice of yeah sorry I'm sorry um okay we're going to take uh notice of the information items listed uh um we're we do have to you said about accepting the grants uh so how how would you like me to do that a motion to accept one six okay um a motion to accept item uh action items one through six if we could get a roll call on those oh I'm sorry comments from attending oops I missed the most important thing of the evening yes let's open the floor to comments tonight if anybody wants to get up please state your name and address for the
084record um and you're welcome to do so at this time okay nobody um all right we're going to close uh uh public comments um all right if we could resume and get a roll call on those action items yes and it's one through six six being the um resolution on accepting the PTO mini Grant correct uh Mrs Cameron yes Mrs harowitz yes Mr Oro yes Mrs Ramirez I just want to say thank you so much for um to the coln PTO for the minig grants um this is always just so nice to see um it's amazing that to have that much money uh for our schools to be able to utilize so um I know in previous years we've done some good things with these minig grants and so um just thank you so much
085for that um and yes thank you Mr Retta yes Mr scales yes Mr scarper yes Mrs vpy yes Mr Walsh yes thank you the motion carried all that um okay uh can I get a motion uh to move items number one under buildings and grounds motion second okay can I get a roll call please any comments question I'm sorry any comments questions no sorry about that um okay buildings and grounds Mrs camer yes Mrs harwitz yes Mr Rico yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta yes Mr scales yes Mr Scarpa yes Mrs vpy yes Mr Walsh yes motion carried great thank you um can I get a motion to move uh the one item under curriculum please motion second any questions or comments Mrs Cameron yes Mrs harowitz yes Mr R yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr
086Retta yes Mr scales yes Mr Scarpa yes Mrs vpy yes Mr Walsh yes thank you the motion carried okay under fin Sor keeps dying yeah mine they're going out of B sorry it I have it on the whole time I like to keep mine on the whole time and you guys are welcome to do so just so I don't forget on but this one is not working that well um okay um okay under uh Finance um this year you know due to the fact that we needed a little more time on some of the items um uh we were going to uh table it table items number two um and number three um until the March 5th meeting if everybody's okay with that we'll take a vote to table those just to give the members
087of the boards that were unable they were pretty lengthy reports I know some had concerns that reached out to me before the meeting um so to make it fair for everybody uh if we can take a vote to table those until that meeting can I can I just ask a question for that sure are we able to do that because don't we have to um approve it within 60 days and it was for December 31st or am I not counting correctly that is that is the the the standard to to accept the reports I mean um because that puts us over the 60 days correct March 5th does but I suppose if you know if there's an actionable table it has to be accepted that way you know I I do respectfully make sure we're
088in compliance no yeah she um she actually went over that that it did have to be 60 days I was aware of that but like I said to you know I I can't force forcefully have members vote on stuff that they're unprepared for so um I like to table it take a vote to table it and we'll we'll go from there that's fair yeah um Mr Rico okay um all right so a vote oh I didn't did you um first yes I was calling for a motion to table we have comments first or you want to go right to the table um you can okay um all right so was there a second to table second it was put forth by Mr R sorry about the confusion okay sorry you're you're tabling number two number
089two and finance item number three and then we'll go back for uh the other on is there any unclarity on the resolution itself okay um okay so we get a roll call to table it sure Mrs Cameron yes Mrs harwitz yes Mr or yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta yes Mr scales yes Mr Scarpa yes Mrs vulpi yes Mr Walsh yes motion carried okay so we are going to go back to finance again um I need a motion to approve um under Finance I'm sorry just give me a minute to get my my ey straight uh number uh four I'm sorry did I miss 14 five and six I apologize I'm sorry all the okay okay so motion to approve those I apologize guys very difficult my eyes motion second okay great can I get
090a roll call yes on items two four 5 through nine Mrs Cameron yes Mrs harwitz yes Mr R yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta yes Mr scales yes Mr scorpa all just just to clarify it's four five through nine right it's not 124 it's 14 14 5 through n yes yes right okay yes thank you yes is that a yes Mrs vpy I'm sorry yes Mr Walsh yes thank you the motion carried okay now we'll be back on the track for this um I need a motion uh to move items under policy items one uh one and two motion second okay any questions or comments no okay if I could get a roll call on those items policy items one through two Mrs Cameron um yes for everything no for um attachment P4 Mrs Horowitz
091yes for one two and three no for four I'm sorry attachment for you meant attachment not attachment thank you Mr Rico yes on number one on number two yes for P3 and no for P4 Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta yes Mr scales yes for one two and three no to four Mr Scara uh yes for attachments one two three uh no for attachment four Mrs VY um no to P4 a yes for everything else Mr Walsh yes for policy one two and three no for four okay uh motion passed with the exception of attachment four uh okay um moving on nothing under negotiation Transportation okay moving uh down to Personnel um uh I'd like to make a motion thank you for you help um to move items one through nine under Personnel motion motion second
092thank you Vinnie um okay uh this is pretty lengthy I don't know if anybody has any questions or comments uh you're more than welcome to I have a quick comment um I just wanted to thank the teachers um for their professionalism and commitment to furthering their education I was very impressed um to see teachers that have their masters plus 30 and Masters plus 60 so I just wanted to recognize that right thank you anybody else uh want to make a comment question okay can I get a roll call personal items one through nine Mrs Cameron yes Mrs Hartz yes Mr Rico yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta uh uh get a inuse from two to four two numbers two and two through four due to my employment with the New Jersey family leement disability and
093yes to the rest thank you Mr scales yes Mr Scara yes Mrs VY yes Mr Walsh yes motion carried um okay great thank you everybody um we're moving on uh to our last um comments from attending constituents uh this will be on all subjects if you have something to say once again state your name and address for the record okay hi Alison denoya for Westminster Drive um since you guys did not pass P4 if if the public could get a working definition of what parents rights are that would be great okay so when you get that together you let us know what that is so so we can all work from the same thing thank you thank you very much for your comment okay um anybody else for public comment all right um we're going
094to close public comment at this time um we are going to open the floor to any new business at this time new business new business oh okay I'm sorry who said that's Kev go okay yeah you like a senior yes okay it's all right I like being a senior um I like to maybe have some type of event where we can had the parents that have children in private schools come back to our our schools highlight our successes as a district highlight our great teachers we have and our special education let's attract the students that are attending private schools and have them parents come back to our schools that's a great comment I think hopefully when we achieve Blue Ribbon status I think people are going to flock here more than they are already um
095but I I I of course I would like that too um but um you know like I said that would be an initiative to bring you know people back but i' certainly you know agree if Dr gabay would be interested in implementing something like that to um engage people to come back I'm all for it you go about that I have no idea either I think we just need to take a an ad out if we wanted to keep adding kids to our schools could keep doing that if we want to we GS have a lot of opportunities to do so right the but tax p a lot of money ,000 them out dou tax sure and I think that that's it's a it's a really good question and I never question a parents you
096know decision to send to a private school right some have gone through parochial schools or private schools themselves and that's the path they choose for their children um we certainly when student students are actually disenrolled by their parents we do send an exit survey to their parents um to try to keep tracking and sometimes obviously you can't force people to answer you know and respond to that but we try to collect that data to reflect on that the the reasons for um so uh you open houses highlights um I know that and I think it is in a couple of the magazines CBA and rany and okil take out you know have full page articles and things like that are that are in in there um it is a different budget line but that's I'm
097always open to anything you know especially when we have our kindergarten previews and we have our preschool you know it it's it's a hot commodity when when we're bringing in our our little ones and parents come um so I'm always open for any ideas any ideas to celebrate and highlight our kiddos absolutely yeah absolutely in that same ve I'm glad you mentioned a survey uh what is the data shown from the surveys um you know I think sometimes it's it's their personal reasons from whether it is uh you know curriculum based I think that there's things that they've uh um from a whether it's a religious standpoint or or just uh going back to the concept of parent rights and and public schools have a very comprehensive you know uh exposure to to things that
098you know that that uh parents have differences of opinions on sometimes sometimes uh it is about um a child's need to be in a smaller environment you know and it it's very it's focused like that whether there was a conflict you know of something we take that you know very seriously too as well so I think that we have um there's a variety of reasons and then um you and we reflect on that yeah but I can definitely but I can provide that yeah yeah um Mr Rico you said you had new business oh here I'm sorry you yes so this uh this afternoon roughly like right around three o'clock you know the we received uh we received a late email I think um regarding the regular Action meeting here we received the PDFs of
099the board secretary report the treasurer's report and it was added to the bull revised agenda the this was really last minute and at 3 o'l about you know three hours before the meeting it was about 46 Pages worth of information that you know obviously everyone would want to or part of the you know finance committee or the entire board would like to review in this way you know you know being able to votee on it I think it was really short notice um you know I don't know you know I was working and you know by the time I did see the email it did come in at around 3 o'clock and I just it was just too short notice for I believe it to be added to the regular Action meeting um you know
100for vote so I I mean and in my opinion I would like at least for something like that at least a day before you know if not maybe even 48 hours before so we could review that uh you know that that information with the board secretary's report the treasurer's report and um you know looking over and interpreting that information is you know hard enough so I think at least a 24 to 48 hour window for that information would be would be great yeah yes thank you and we we when and I think I I in the email to the board the follow-up email after I we had heard from uh for that it is a lengthy and it is very small print and very tedious to be going through it recognizing that and as I
101said yesterday it was in the attachments folder with the minutes that went out in Miss in uh the email that the board received however we said that you can also review all the attachments we didn't identify that that was in the attachments folder so it was available yesterday afternoon so that was a misstep on our end we recognized that in the in the email that I sent following that up so that um we certainly will absolutely it was there and so we hear that that is uh we recognize that and we you know always want to provide the board timeliness to be able to review information so without a doubt um I have some new business this is just more of um an update so um just before had thanked the PTO um for all
102their mini mini projects all the grants and we know that the per pergola project is something that they are funding and I had mentioned at the last cow meeting if there was any possibility that um the board can set up a VMO or PayPal account allowing residents to donate directly and I just wanted to know if um we were able to get any more information about that I think at the Cow Mr mesco and I are going to be presenting some information about the structure of donations you know what's what's the most appropriate from our uh you know we can speak with our auditor who will you know there's we're like I said I think I I I even reference we're always open for donations that's you know and and uh we've been beneficiaries before
103as District so it's more about just the the way that we want to uh is the best way through accounting procedures to uh be able to set that up for people yeah so we can share that out uh at the Cow great anybody else would like to add new business I've got uh just few things um from just a policy perspective so again keeping politics out of schools is our main focus but unfortunately we're finding ourselves at the crossroads of a fight between the federal government the state government regarding a um an executive order handed down by our president that talks about removing Dei from the schools right all that so um that's a challenging that's a it's challenging and I know it's going to put a strain on you so why don't you take
104I would what I would recommend um again is we'll you know we'll work through it um to figure out because ideally what can happen and I kind of explained it last time is that when there's a an executive order the threat is that if we're not complying all of our federal dollars will be removed right flip side of the coin is if we comply with the the federal directive but you're all familiar with Supremacy law the federal law always supercedes state law right but the threat is our governor of the state of New Jersey is willing to reduce our funding in order to fight that funding so we will be in The Crossroads State funds obviously account for more of our budget than federal funds do right so what we need to do is be
105strategic because there's going to there's a couple policies that it will impact and we've been proactive um as far as verbiage and adjustments policy um 2260 equity in school and classroom practices um it's what I would recommend just because of the impact of our resolution on affordable housing is I recommend that I will draft a resolution for all of our board members to review and what this resolution ideally will call for is to make sure that our school and our district is not caught up in the crosshairs of the federal and the state fight right so we what we need to seek is Clarity on what those actual penalties would be the timing of when those penalties will happen and when and if funds could ever be actually taken away from our schools because again
106we have a fiduciary responsibility and a policy responsibility to follow federal law and in some cases there is some state laws that are instituted that don't necessarily follow federal law because Federal la will sorry I apologize we're having a lot of difficulty tonight um just want to see what your thoughts will be because I know you had some questions on the previous resolution so I want to be I want we need to be you know again on the same page when we send something like this because the last one um got some some media attention and it may happen again you could see what the other school districts are repealing some of the transgender policies so we're expecting action from the state on those as well too to appeal the judge's decision so again just
107trying to be our main focus again as we've talked as we were also elected for the board is to be proactive not reactive right so we need to take a proactive approach and prepare ourselves very similar how we're approaching with what the impact would be from an affordable housing and a development perspective we need to take a similar approach with the politics coming from the state of New Jersey so i' recommend again I don't know where we start finding that where that's in the curriculum and all that but at least identifying some areas whether or not it would be strain on you and the operation to figure out how to do that so sure do you want me to respond yeah I'll see some when you're done yeah the um the large push that came
108out last year it was the equity and education grouping that came out so there was a that's really a main focus of where you know those um sentiments lay or in writing um the other part is with uh staff development there's requirements now with with staff development pieces of it um that have been Incorporated so those are really the two that come into practices and uh that are codified in and that type of thing so so I guess I I have two questions on that one would be why would we draft a resolution versus just updating and amending our policies what's the push behind the resolutions the the problem is is is we we'd be in a fight so for example unfortunately our governor is very we'll call it financially Reckless right so if we
109were to make a change to our policy that's not in direct correlation with the state policy then we're sub we're absolutely susceptible to a state lawsuit so if there's a state lawsuit then they can pause the funds and coming into budget season we'd obviously have to to recognize where that is so my whole point of this is to find out what the penalties would be when those timing would be because the resolution will allow us to it'll protect us it'll allow us the the fact that we're looking into it and that we won't tolerate the fight between the federal government a resolution is an opinion as Angelique pointed out last meeting when I requested there to be our legal councel involved in the resolution we don't need legal involved in it and what you're describing
110sounds like we would want to be getting legal counsel for a resolution of that nature so while I know we don't need to have it a lot of the things that you're saying oh it protects us how do we know that I would want our legal team to and Council to say this does protect us so this is a good idea for your draft because I don't know that that's true um my understanding is it that's not not sure a resolution does not protect us our resolution is an opinion piece that's why we don't need legal councel on it so it protects Us in the it protects Us in the court of public opinion okay so that is so what happens with again with the a resolution again it's resolution yeah but what it does
111is it at least it alerts our state officials and our federal official that fall for us protection Tove forward because we're essentially giving them no it's okay we're essentially giving them sort of a we'll give them a a preemptive piece of verbiage that we're going to be proactively looking at this so then it allows us in again the court of law to use that as a reference point in order to delay delay delay if there was ever to be a lawsuit or something along those lines so it allows us to essentially to give you more of an idea it's it lays a foundation for legal recourse where then our attorney also would know what page we're on and then the other attorneys that are in the state that would it perhaps could deter them from
112suing us as well so we have to be clear on what we're providing and there has to be something in writing sent to the public codified by the board of education for us to ever use that if we were to be sued by the state I completely understand what you're saying and I'm following along makes sense what I would request is that we not only have our legal team involved in it on this time um because if they're going to eventually get a copy of it I don't know that we sent them a copy of our last resolution I think it's wise that we would send them a copy of our last resolution but also I think that this sounds like something that we should be advocating for then right this is why we have
113our advocacy and government Relations Committee um so through the chair we should be doing more with our legislators right we've had before where our legislators come here and we talk with them we have meetings with them so maybe instead of drafting a resolution in a silo of one board member I think we should be doing it as a committee of a whole in the public with public input because we have a responsibility to have input from our stakeholders on how they feel about following along with all of these changes and then in addition to that get our legislators get our Senator involved figure out what they can do for us and involve them in the resolution if we're going to be drafting a resolution I think think it even holds more weight if we have
114some of these individuals who as you said can go to bat for us let them be involved in it then see what they say about it um so those would just be my my requests you know thinking off the cuff here and again I'm really going to stress we're a committee of a whole one board member should not be charged with drafting a resolution and then that being what gets sent out to the the full Committee of a whole we should be doing that work in the public for the public to see for them to comment on to see that process when you're a board of committees you do these things in small committee meetings behind closed doors but a lot of work goes into it's not something that's just done by one of those
115committee members and then the other two or three of them come together and and say yes we like this no we don't there's work that's done on it and I think that that work should be done on it in a committee of a whole um and again with the stakeholders and i' like the comment I think we should go forward and draft that resolution we're elected by by our residents to be proactive and take the lead and and listen to our constituents that's why we're here so I'm all in favor of going forward with that resolution what res with what resolution and drafting yeah draft it'll be that's what we're speak for the board my original point was because your original comments were it'll be there it'll be presented so it'll I guess again I
116don't know the email rules and all that stuff it's sent to you and then you send it out to every time the board had over 72 hours to review that resolution I decided that I would not contact legal counsel not to squander money when I certainly didn't think it was necessary I think that resolution was more than well received by this community and uh I also do support you in drafting uh the resolution I'll make sure the board has ample time to review it and then we will vote accordingly all right anybody else have any other uh new business yes I do I just want to say that I'm extremely disappointed that policy 92 40 uh changes to policy 9240 did not pass this evening um I think that every parent in this District including
117those of you sitting at this table even though I know you voted against it should be upset and concerned about that uh this policy was drafted and reviewed by the former board prior to December uh or prior to January of this year um it was voted on unanimously with several of the members sitting at this table here I know that there were some concerns we discussed them via email when it was brought up last meeting no other board member other than Mr scales said anything no one had anything to say about any concerns whether or not they shared those concerns so I won't speak or assume what why others at this table did not vote in favor of it however when we tabled this policy it was taed and we all just voted on unanimously
118on the meeting minutes from January 8th it was tabled until legal could review it legal never reviewed these changes again they did review them last year which was stated that legal opinion was shared with the full board none of those changes went against any federal or state laws we know this as per our legal councel so the only comment that I received back from anyone on this board was Mr scales who said that he thought it opened us up to liability despite what our legal team said this policy did not just give rights right the state laws give those rights to our parents but what the changes in this policy did was it committed this board and this District to working with our parents in this District so I urge any parents that are watching
119tonight or that will watch on the replay of this to reach out to the board reach out to our Administration and let them know if you have any concerns if you have any questions about what your current rights are because the changes to this policy emphasiz Iz where the board stands and what they what they believe the relationship between this district and the parents are and while it doesn't changed anything legally because nothing changed legally between the current policy and what these changes were I do believe that it further explained and emphasized what this board and what this District was committed to providing to our parents as rights so um again I just want to say how disappointed I am that that did not pass thank you okay thank you for your comments um anybody
120else would like to oh I'm sorry Mr can we please meting I Amo lose ridiculous okay all right Mr Walsh I am working on that okay I am working diligently with Dr Garb and we are going to uh tighten it up a bit uh prioritize and um I uh I take your concerns uh as a priority so we we will uh correct it okay um okay if there's nothing else uh anybody else oh I'm sorry Mr scarba oh I'm sorry anybody else I'm sorry so you had both addressed this um briefly but I just wanted to like explain a little bit more um so I sent an email request to Dr gabay Who discussed with Dr Beck um the possibility of entering the inovate Innovations and special education award in 2025 um it would showcase
121you know all the outstanding programs and services for our students with special needs so I really just wanted to thank you and Mr and Dr Beck because the application process I looked at it is incredibly lengthy it's it's a lot of pictures and so um I had offered my my help so it's still there but it so thank you because I I I I looked over it and I was like this is a lot so I appreciate it if we win this award it would be well worth your efforts and we certainly appreciate it as as a board but it's a tremendous amount of work so I just I wanted to know that thank you for uh sharing that with us Mrs Cameron um okay if there's uh nothing else um we are going to
122go into an executive session it'll probably be all about 10 minutes um it will cover uh confidential personal matters at this time live stream uh yeah no action will be taken um the live stream will uh will be um yeah it will be ended at this time and we will not be going back to live stream uh so I'd like to make a motion to move uh the board meeting into executive session at this time motion second all right and uh like I said uh we'll we'll be immediately done after that so there's no need for the public to to stay after hi okay great thank you very much awesome and then big