001evening everybody I want to call to order the Township Board of Education meeting uh January 22nd 2025 at 6:30 p.m. in the boardroom of the administration building at 70 Conover Road in coltsneck New Jersey uh can I please have a roll call yes you may Mrs no I'm sorry wrong one apologies give me that calling sheet I'm gonna rip it up I apologize I have an old cheat here Mrs Mr Rico I'm president Mrs Ramirez here Mr Retta acknowledge remote participation tonight Mrs vpy here Mr Walsh Mr scales here Mr Scarpa here Mrs harowitz here Mrs camer here okay thank you um okay moving on we're going to go through the legal notice of meetings uh pursuant to the open public meetings act chapter 231 this meeting has been duly advertised in the Asbury Park
002Press in a scheduled of meetings dated January 16th 2025 notice of which has been filed with the deply Kirk for Colts Neck Township and the requirements of posting of all notices have been met uh if you all would like to join me in a flag salute it's to my right hand side iedge algi to the flag of the United States of America and to the repu for it stands one nation God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay um we're going to start off tonight with the um appointments uh for the board chairs and the Liaisons um I've appointed myself to the um uh the U uh New Jersey County school board's of Representative um I'm going to go through the board committees uh once once again I just wanted to go over we
003are working as a cow but we I figured we'd still keep uh uh the meetings um the Committees established just in case we need them behind the scenes for uh budgeting purposes uh uh Safety and Security and so forth uh so we're going to start off with the buildings and grounds um I'd like to keep Kevin as the board chair and Sarah Jason and Brian will be um on that committee Communications will be Brian Scara Phyllis CA and Robert scales will assist in that curriculum will be Phyllis camera Sarah and um Jessica Ramirez can assist in that Finance negotiations will be led by Jason Oro uh Phyllis camera Brian Scarpa and Kevin Walsh policy will be led by Mr Robert scales uh Jason Aro and myself uh advoc advocacy and government relations will be led
004by me uh Phyllis camera and Robert scales will be joining me and uh the newly uh the new addition of the ad hoc committee for affordable housing will be led by uh Mr Robert scales and Phyllis camera Jason Rico and Brian scorpa um the board Liaisons will be as follows uh parent advisory committee will be uh Miss Sarah harwitz uh the colck PTO will also be Mrs Sarah harwitz uh the township uh the colck township committee will be Brian Scarpa and Phyllis camera uh the cols neck Township seniors will be Mr Kevin Walsh uh the newsletter will be taken over by Phyllis uh camer uh the colck Township School arts and extracurricular activities will be Mr Vincent Retta and the naval weapons station early ason will be uh Mrs Ramirez and Mr Scarpa moving on
005to the new board member mentors uh will be as follows Jason Oro uh will Mentor Mr Robert scales um me uh I will be mentoring Phyllis CA and Sarah harwitz and Kevin will be doing um mentoring Brian Scara uh we're going to need a roll call to approve that correct all right oh okay great okay great um all right moving on um we're gonna uh do the approval of minutes uh if anybody has any questions or comments we're going to take a motion to move those minutes can I get a motion motion all right um Mr marusa can we get a a roll call for that than you that's okay that's all right yeah just to remind everybody the newer board members if you weren't here or if you didn't follow along you have the
006right to abstain on that vote okay Mr scales abstain Mr R yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta yes Mrs VY yes Mr Walsh yes and Mr scar Aban thank you the motion did carry okay um we have a presentation later on um with Mr Tan so we're skipping over that right now there's no Communications that I uh and we're already into um my president's report okay all right good evening everybody uh I want to welcome everybody here and those that are viewing at home uh thank you all for coming I first want to thank all of our board members uh for responding to my requests for to fill the liaison and board chair positions um I'm happy to report that all member requests were granted and I'm looking forward to working with each of you
007to better district and to reach our mutual goals uh as I explained during the January 8th meeting our board will continue to work as a cow a committee of a whole working this capacity will help assure board transparency however there will be times where board members must meet to discuss security operations the yearly budget and unforeseen circumstances that may arise I'd like to highlight some changes on the agenda regarding committee liaison positions um I've removed the Sports ad hoc committee and reassigned it to aa's onos uh the board likes uh would like to continue to Spotlight all of our Sports and extracurricular activities and looking forward to Mr Retta continuing his role as that liaison I'd like to highlight that I added um an ad Haw committee for the affordable housing I'd like to thank
008uh Mr Robert scales for leading this committee uh the committee once again will consist of U Mrs CA Mr Scarpa and Jason Oro these members were selected because of their extensive background in finance real estate and education I'm confident that this team will help guide us in the critical decisions that need to be made regarding the influx of students that will occur starting in uh 2627 I want to thank all of them as this task will certainly be challenging with that coltsneck had a public meeting addressing the affordable housing on January 14th uh Dr gabay Mr Walsh Mr Scarpa uh Mrs camera and myself we all attended uh so can we we could be updated on any new developments uh let me see I'm happy to report after working with Dr Garay all Board of
009Ed meetings will operate on opposite days of the township committees uh we do have the um you know conflict of those five that we're currently working on uh and that'll be out probably the next agenda okay perfect uh this will ensure our community will be able to attend and participate both meetings I'd like to also highlight the addition of a second public comment section that's been added to our meeting starting this evening this will ensure that all questions can be addressed on the agenda topics and also after any presentations that are made I want to thank Dr Garay for working diligently so these changes can be made by this meeting tonight the second meeting of the year so thank you for doing that very quickly um uh January's Board of Education recognition month I'd like
010to extend a heartfelt thank you to all of our board members uh with this position comes long hours countless meetings and in many cases it's a a thankless job um our biggest reward is to work with great people to make meaningful impacts on this district for our children so once again thank you to my fellow board members who continue to serve this community uh this evening uh Mr Tan from New Jersey school boards Association is here to give us our first training session of the year which will be on ethics uh the public is welcome to join us for that um if not you can leave I think it's coming after new business at the end all right lastly uh today our district was scheduled for the on-site New Jersey CAC monitoring by the Department
011of Education um this evaluation happens every three years uh as Dr gbay had explained they monitor and evaluate our schools in five key components instruction and program fiscal governance and operations and Personnel um I'm sure the day was very stressful for our superintendent and Mr morasco so uh I hope you survived it and we appreciate all the hard work I know this uh testing isn't evaluation isn't easy for you guys uh so we do appreciate all your attention um and uh I'm looking forward to Dr gb's feedback on how the district did I'm confident that her attention experience and expertise have ensured an exemplary report for our district and we are looking forward uh to those results in about few months a few months uh okay great so uh that uh concludes my report for
012this evening all right uh we are going to um moving along quickly uh we are going to go to the board chairs uh since this is only the second meeting of the year uh the new members that took over chair positions uh don't feel you need to say anything I know no no meetings and we haven't had our first cow so uh you're welcome to you know say something if you have something prepared uh we will start with the building and buildings and grounds chairperson Kevin Walsh yeah I like to um just let the community know that we received a rebate for Energy savings for energy saving INF infrastructure project of 371,000 dollar uh on January 10th so in total that's excellent with the investment in our district and upgrading all our facilities we've received
013$530,000 back am I correct so it's paying for itself it's a big investment but long term it's going to benefit our our district our kids and our community solar installation is ongoing the roof racks and gas pipes for the all the roofs and uh we have sound panels in Cedar drrive Middle School C to dry Middle School schol gymnasium is looking awesome I attended a few events basketball games the lighting is great you know it's looking really good and uh that's it for my report um okay great on the communications uh I believe uh Vinnie was uh the chairperson at the time at the end of the year um Mr scarp is taking over so you're both welcome to um you know say something at this time uh thank you uh yeah from a point
014of communications uh key to our program and our new year is transparency so we are here to serve the town we look forward to working with you we have opened up the second portal of public Communications at all of our meetings as described by Miss phy so we do encourage Communications and feedback it is Our obligation our intent to get back to the public in an efficient manner so we look forward to working with you and work those feedback um opportunities because we do believe in that level of transparency we do believe in and frequent Communications and that is why we're opening the door to new liaison specifically around the new buildout programs for four maybe five phases so Communications will be key there'll be a Cornerstone of our go forward strategy and if there's
015any questions or any or concerns in this matter please do not hesitate to reach out to the board from a point of communications um uh the website uh we are going to look we will be developing our websites that we heard you this is what we heard heard a a conversation portal and if You' like to contact us it'll be it will be present we're going to work with the infrastructure team to build out that portal of communication so if you happen to see something you want to talk about it please don't hesitate to reach out to us that is why we're here to service thank you all right uh thank you Mr Scarpa um Mr ragnet would you like to add anything great thank you Mr Retta um moving on uh to curriculum U
016Mrs camera um I'm just very excited to be on the curriculum committee and I look forward to working with Erica Reynolds as well as our entire Board of Education all right thank you um Finance uh Mr Oro yes I'm looking forward to working with the superintendent and Mr morasco and the finance committee in hopefully achieving another 0% tax increase for the taxpayers of cols neack and I'm looking forward to negotiating contracts and reviewing rfps with everybody okay thank you very much um the policy committee um uh Mr scales and uh the former uh policy chair um Mrs Ramirez you could both you're welcome to both uh say something um so we have we did not meet since our last meeting or since last year um as everyone's aware um I did reach out to uh
017both word president Angelique and our superintendent this week um with some concerns but my understanding is Mr skilles is going to be touching on some of those things tonight anyway so um I'm sure he'll take the floor at some point tonight and discuss some of those concerns that I have um so yep absolutely uh first of all thank you for disappointment it's an honor um and rest assured just the for the general public to understand um we've got a lot of work to do there's a lot of policies that came from the government our new president of the United States of America has also made some uh pretty Stark policy changes and with direction to uh lot of Board of Education in New Jersey and we'll follow that we'll follow that direction will work with
018local government um but most importantly um I've read every single policy um that our school board has we have a great opportunity now where we be switching policy holders so it's a good way to kind of clean out things and look at what was you know obviously instituted over the last couple years um but more importantly um the the voters made a choice these last couple years um if you look at sort of the overwhelming sort of I would say voting for for our president Donald J Trump um especially in New Jersey there's overwhelming um especially in coln so I want to just assure all the people who had voted for us as well that we're going to work with you and if there's anyone that opposes anything that we do as kind of Mr
019Scarpa had mentioned before as well please it's an open Forum there's going to be a lot of different public comment we listen to every voice everyone has a voice I had mentioned a a long time ago when I was here at a meeting we the people were here for the people so we want to hear what your voice is for the policies um to Mrs uh Ramirez concerns as well too um policy 9240 there was a lot of time that was spent on developing this policy but I had found a lot of different things that makes the district very susceptible for Unnecessary liability so we've done a full overhaul and look at this policy as well and then I'll be presenting my finding to the board as well through communication um and a direction that
020I'll recommend going forward um before we all obviously vote on it because we did vote to table that for the future as well so um again thank you very much um all of your comments from board members obviously as we do committee as a whole is going to be really instrumental as moving our district forward but um we have a lot of work to do so going to appreciate all your assistance and all your help and and thank you for what you've done previously Mrs Ramirez as well so uh that's it for me thank you uh great thank you Mr uh uh scales um okay moving on to advocacy um um I'm pleased to resume uh taking this committee over um I'm looking forward to uh advocating for um new laws and like Rob said
021uh there's going to be a lot of um probably District changes in the future so I'm going to be looking closely at that and Reporting out um and that's all I have for that moving on to board member leaon um uh Mrs harwitz uh the parent advisory committee one y thank you um yeah I'm just I'm looking forward to collaborating with parent advisory committee um to strengthen the schools and enhance our Student Success um working closely with Dr G to make sure that we're discussing our strategic Direction and ensure alignment on our goals and priorities so I'm eager to start that and I'll touch Bas with you this week great thank you you could um roll right into the col snack PTO Leon Angeli I'm sorry I have a question yeah I'm sorry yeah um
022do we have a a date for the meeting for the next meeting we don't yet I was going to touch base with you this week and we can get you know okay have some dates okay perfect thank you yeah of course um so PTO I'm looking forward to collaborating closely with Kim and the entire PTO board um everyone knows the PTA is incredible and they play a vital role in our um you know our strong School Community um sharing the success of our students as well um I'm going to uh excited to work with them and support everything that they've been doing um see their next general meeting is March 12th at 6:30 some key upcoming events is the 41st uh annual Gala which is on March 21st at the Southgate Manor um they also
023have a Valentine's Day fundraiser with um Valentine's Day Pizza which is adorable and those orders are due by February 3 uh the PJ has many exciting great specific events that are planned and details can be found on the it or in their emails lastly last year the board generally uh donated an iPad and I will be reaching out to the the board this week to discuss what our contribution is going to be um ahead of agala thanks great uh thank you very much Mrs harwitz um okay moving on um you know like we we discussed we're gonna you know start with our uh Colt Township School newsletter and I'm honored to have Mrs camera taking on that role thank you you're welcome um that will be part of our work in communication so I'll be
024working closely with Brian Scarpa with that and right now um we are thinking about trying to do one seasonally so it'll be about four per year and we will be drafting it shortly so thank you great thank you um okay Mr rugnetta would you uh do your Le on position for the sports and extra okay uh first I to thank president Angel VY for keeping this Focus uh with the board uh but now as a Le is on position which I uh I do think it works better with and we're able to um put forth to the board and to the the public what is going on in our town as far as Sports and we could still also uh put out there what's going on with the schools as far as extracurricular activities and
025uh concerts and so forth going on um I'd like to uh just let everyone know that the boy col boys lacrosse is a sign up is uh right now available um for K through 8 grade uh there'll be two practices a week um and the season will begin March 24th through May 19th there'll be one game a week uh which will be on the weekends and the registration is open until February 15th and the registration fee right now is $125 and go to ksports foundation.com uh for more info to uh sign up uh also uh flag football which is for uh co-ed boys and girls is uh available right now uh right now there's 50 spots left uh as of January 17th we got the notice that there was 50 spots still left and that
026of course is uh kindergarten through 8th grade and I believe there in high school as well too but I would uh email them uh to look for more information that but definitely through K through 8ighth grade uh which the season would start um March 22nd and the playoffs will start uh there'll be six six games regular season games uh with playoffs uh May 10th and May 17th and the Super Bowl will be uh May 31st uh right now there registration fee right now uh through uh February 15 is $185 and again go to colck sports foundation.com to to sign up um baseball uh sign up is available uh right now it's $195 through uh February 7th um and the the the early which is the early bird uh sign up February 7th and uh there's
027no volunteer Fe fee this year so there used to be a $100 volunteer fee and that has now been waved so hopefully that'll entice more people to sign up which would be nice and right now they're taking um registrations for kids born August 21st uh August of 20 sorry August of 2021 through September of 2009 uh if you're born through that time period and uh that's it for now thank you uh great thank you for that sorry I'm sorry opening opening day will be uh May uh April 5th opening day is May 5th I'm sorry April 5th is opening day and usually goes through the third weekend in June sorry about that thank you uh great thank you uh Mr Retta for that very detailed report we really appreciate it um okay moving on for
028the Colt Township committee um Mr Scarpa uh yes thank you uh a key to us is the communications with the town I'm very happy that we have coordinated our calendar to not conflict with the town committee so I we do encourage both board and public participation in each other's meetings so uh we look forward to the next meeting on January 29th for a key piece of the um the buildout program uh phis c i I refer to you is there anything am I missing I will perfect thank you yep um Mr Walsh the senior yeah we have a new president Ray shabel I should say judge shabel I've known him for 30 years great man he taken lead of the president of the senior citizen Association he's got a great service record to our town
029Fire Company fire police he's out day and night aside from running a big law firm and being a judge um I really I spoke to him at length I really want to encourage the senior citizens to attend our events which Dr g bay is working on collaboration with Dr Rigby I furnished the phone number to Dr uh garab so he you're going to reach out uh I think we're going to have a great response by our seniors uh from our conversation I also encourage the senior citizen to actively attend our meetings I I told the judge I attended the meeting on January 14th most of the people in attendants weren't parents they were senior citizens we had over 150 people attending you know it's going to beig a big impact affordable housing and um specifically
030our leadership as a board of education and making sure we properly educate all the kids coming in our district and seniors are significantly impacted by taxes so I told them come to the meetings and talk to the Board of Education we're here foremost to make sure our kids have the best education number one but we want to have them as a participant and communicate uh how they feel about what's going on in our town uh great uh thank you Mr Walsh I I'm so pleased that you really care so much about the seniors I you yeah is that why um the fact that you really go above and beyond to include them in our school Community is amazing and I really give you kudos for putting that time in so thank you um uh Mr
031Scarpa and Mrs Ramirez will be the um uh liaison 2 uh Naval Weapon Station Earl we have two Liaisons this um uh department is very very dear to me me and uh Mrs Ramirez did a fantastic job um being that liaison last year and Brian is very very supportive of our military families and I thought you two would make a fantastic team in advocating for them and I'm looking forward to both of you um doing great things for that community so either one of you you're both welcome to speak uh during the meeting do you want to say anything yeah um so thank you Angelique um I just wanted to say I'm happy that this is uh the Leon was actually appointed prior to the adoption of the policy which is on the agenda for
032tonight for us to vote on um I believe it was inadvertently left off for us to vote on uh during our our last meeting so I'm happy to see it back on the agenda for this evening um we're excited to work with Ida who comes to all of our meetings religiously um and uh the good work and so as you know Ida if you have any questions concerns comments you can always bring them to our board and I know I'm certainly excited to be working with you Brian likewise it's very nice to meet you and and uh feel free to contact me with any questions you might have but I look forward to working with you and establishing this relationship uh for the benefit of the school board as well as the naval representation thank
033you um okay the last one the state and uh State and County School boards Association which is myself um uh I just want to remind the board members to please make sure uh that you registered for your governance uh one two or uh some of us may be in our third training uh session Mr morasco will be happy to set that up um there were several options to do a virtual and live in person um also uh please remember to fill out your financial disclosure forms uh that went out via email I believe it was December 13th don't quote me on that that is due by April 30th um if anybody has an issue um you know Vince makes himself very available to help us with that um just not to be repetitive but Mr
034Tian is here we're having our first board training course um and uh the public is welcome to stay um March 21st uh the New Jersey Schoolboard associations is having their annual women's leadership conference it will be held at Mercer County College uh from 9:30 to 3:30 if anybody would like to attend that um and once again I know I said this earlier but January Schoolboard recognition month and I'd like to recognize all the sitting board members and thank them for their dedication and commitment to this District um and that is uh all I have for that all right which brings us into uh our superintendent report thank you Mrs Volby good evening um just to reiterate I wanted to and you mention and thank you so much for mentioning um our qac with the New
035Jersey quality single account ability Continuum or as we lovingly refer to it as qac uh is the Department of education's monitoring and District self-evaluation system for public school districts it is a single comprehensive accountability system that consolidates and incorporates the monitoring requirements of applicable state laws and programs and complements uh federally required improvements um that being said and without going into all the things that go into it's five main areas as you said which are our dprs which are uh uh program instruction and program or imp fiscal governance operations and Personnel within each one of those indicators there's anywhere between 15 to 26 what they refer to as weighted measures within each one of those weighted measures there could be literally between five to 25 pieces of evidence that the state department comes in to
036look at and monitor and they range from policies of the Board of Education to makeing sure that they're up to date and they've been board approved minutes from meetings Personnel from start to finish onboarding physical examinations everything that basically it's a complete exercise of public school compliance is really what it is for the State Department of Education and so I too am very excited to uh receive the result it usually takes a few months um uh to receive the results back because there are several school districts were in cohort 3 in the state Department's uh uh cycle of of QC monitoring so it'll take a few months and in addition to the site visit and in addition to information that we provided them to review remotely uh in advance of today's site visit uh there's
037another facilities walkthrough that they do that they come back and walk the facilities to see that the physical grounds is also in uh compliance with with their uh requirements so it is a lengthy process I want to give a huge thank you to the team um there's been several meetings that started in the summer with looking at all of this pieces of evidence and looking at everything that we've done so um there's a lot that goes into it um we always aim for 100 under each between 80 and 100 indicates a high performing so that's always something that we strive for we've done it two times before uh under the administration's been here so we're hoping to maintain that record of Excellence for our families and our communities um so stay tuned okay um more
038to come on that um I gave each board member this is a public document that was issued today by the State Department of Education uh the came out in a special broadcast which is guidance on school related state and federal requirements pertaining to immigrants students and families um this is something as I said that is a public document on the state department of education's website uh there is a live link to a website that's been created um on the under the office Department of Education School uh uh preparedness and emergency planning um both this document I was was also shared with our local police department as well as our legal counsel for any further information that we may need to understand with regards to any um actions with going on so stay tuned I'll also
039include this in my week updates of the links are all there for the board of education but I just wanted to make you aware that this came out today okay um I also wanted to touch upon um the parents and guardians of Cedar Drive Middle School received the letter that uh indicating from the uh December uh with regards to Chronic absenteeism okay so for the 2324 school year uh Cedar Drive uh Middle School was designated as a school with chronic absenteeism and as I've explained or and that's on the Department of Education website chronic absenteeism means that 10 more than 10% of the student population has been absent 18 or more days okay so that being said Cedar Drive fell at 16.6% uh for the 2324 school year and as a result in addition to
040many things school districts are required to do a corrective action plan or a cap so uh part of that cap part of our process is surveying parents uh talking to students talking to staff and putting together an action plan that action plan needs to be reviewed and updated look accordingly based on what we're seeing in our Trends uh and absenteeism and the cap remains in place until the absentee rate Falls below the 10% so the other buildings as well as the district overall for 23 24 were were all under 10% but it was Cedar Drive as an individual school so in a a future board meeting in February Dr Rigby will be coming with Dr Reynolds to speak uh and present to the corrective action plan which is also a requirement that it's part of
041a Board of Education meeting for a questioning and what measures we'll take and again what we're looking at probably a parent advisory meeting that we'll be doing uh talking about the importance the correlation between high performance and achievement and attendance and all the things that go into that so more to come on that and we do encourage as we as Dr rby put in his letter any parents that have any questions please do not hesitate to reach out to him uh about it or if there if you have any questions for the board has any questions for me you're more than welcome to ask for that as well okay um I also want to reiterate on tonight's agenda there is a resolution for uh New Jersey school boards Association month school boards month and I
042just like if you don't mind to if I can indulge for a second to read uh that I'm going to recommend uh under action items that whereas the New Jersey school boards Association has declared January 2025 to be the school board recognition month a time when all residents can acknowledge the contributions made by our local school board members and whereas the Colts Neck Township Board of Education is one of 581 local school boards in New Jersey which sets policies and overseas operations for public school districts and whereas the cnck Board of Education Embraces the goal of highquality education for all New Jersey public school students and whereas the New Jersey local local school boards can help determine the educational goals for approximately 1.4 million children in Pre kindergarten through 12th grade and whereas New Jersey's
0435,000 local school board members who receive no re remuneration for their services act as advocates for public school students as they work with administrators teachers and parents for the betterment of public education and whereas School boards strive to provide the resources necessary to meet the needs of all students including those with special needs and whereas Boards of educations provide accountability to the public they communicate the needs of the school district to the public and they convey to school administrators The public's expectations for the schools and whereas the new J New Jersey can take pride in its schools which rank among the nation's best and key achievement indicators such as the national assessment of Education progress scores and the preparation for college through advanced placement offerings and sat assessments now therefore be it resolved that the
044cnck Township Board of Education does hereby recognize the services of local school board members through throughout New Jersey As We join communities Statewide in observing January 2025 as Schoolboard recognition month and be it further resolved that the cult Township Board of Education urges all New Jersey citizens to work with their local Board of Education and Public School staff toward the advancement of our children's education so on behalf of the staff of the cnck Township Schools we extend our sincere thank you and appreciation for everything that school board members do throughout the state and those sitting at this day yes thinkk and that concludes my superintendent report thank you very much um okay we're going to move on uh we'll take note of information I items uh one two and three um I'd like to make
045a comment if I may on number three um I just want to um remind everybody this year I believe it was back in December that uh you had asked us to participate um last year um me and former uh board member Mrs dooya volunteered to um go in and participate uh in a panel um to pick uh teacher of the year and uh it was actually such a fantastic experience for me uh to go in see the children you know in their daily activities and to sit down um you know with the administration uh Mrs denoya and to hear about uh the wonderful teachers that were uh recommended for this position uh and uh everybody was so good it was very difficult I actually when she walked in I said don't ever ask me to
046do this again because it was such a hard decision uh all the teachers that were picked were fantastic and uh um but I just want to say I was proud to be a part of it and uh uh I wanted to list the names of these teachers because they're very well-deserving uh of these accolades uh so the con Conor Ro Primary School um uh the teacher of the year uh Linda uh wagel please correct me I'm sorry wiel um the art teacher Connor rro Primary School Mr uh Mrs Taran berer uh Conor Ro Elementary School Shannon Eisman uh Conor Ron elementary school Ellen Hannon uh Cedar Drive M Middle School Carrie Sullivan and Cedar Drive Middle School Felicia lenta so I just want to thank all of them and uh for doing such a great
047job with our students so thank you very much all right do we have to do a motion to do that no okay so moving on uh we're going to start taking comments from the attending constituents you're welcome to come up to the podium just state your name and address for the record and anybody's welcome to come up at this time okay hello uh my name is Christine Scarpa 11 dear Path Lane full transparency I am the wife of Brian Scarpa I wanted to congratulate you all uh for being elected as the Board of Ed um this has been a very lovely meeting you all seem to be working cohesively together coming together for the benefit of the children uh you have a mandate by the col Township and being uh who I am I will
048hold my husband very accountable as well as all of you um to ensure that you use the Colt neck budget wisely to ensure that it is um used accordingly to promote and Foster the best education possible to move our school district to even higher standards bring it to um a blue what is it um sorry Blue Ribbon School District thank you so much um and really prioritize our children and their education and their well-being and to really promote higher level education um to provide the proper resources for teachers so that they can facilitate and Foster education and have the resources that they need to do that effectively um I hope that you take this job extremely seriously it seems like you all will and it's very refreshing to see such great minds um and working
049together very very well so thank you so much I appreciate it and uh we look forward to seeing what you all can do for the betterment of our children thank you um before we move on to the next speaker I'd just like to make a comment to your comment um this board uh is definitely determined uh to be fiscally respons responsible on every level um and the fact that we do Take This Job seriously um we care about all the kids here and uh there's no doubt that this board is a fantastic group of people and uh we are going to make this community proud so I just wanted to share that thank you Mrs kucho can you yeah um 67 black Brier um Mr scales I think he's and um Dr gab for the
050uh getting ready for the col snack matter I just wanted to say that I did a little scouting there is a project I don't know if you're aware of it on Beacon it's on Lloyd Road it's I believe it's called Beacon Hill it's being built by Kushner is a carbon copy of what we're getting in town I'm pretty sure it's pretty close in number maybe a little bit less or a little bit more so if you were just for expedience sake call and keep in contact with the their school district it's Morganville um you should get a a working approximate number because they're the same one two and three bedroom units I took a tour of the place I went over and wanted to see and it's built by Kushner same exact blueprint everything is
051the same so it should give you a working number of what is going on and secondly I just wanted to say after 35 years in education from the classroom to Consulting to working as a supervisor Region 2 in the Bronx working for prin to review and then being my own private math consultant looking at education from every every single um aspect it's the toughest but the best and most rewarding job you can have and I wish you all the best this year thank you for your comment anybody else like to come up all right um before we close it I just wanted to uh to add um you know we did make a commitment this board uh to have the two uh comment sections and I am committed as president uh when there is a
052question um uh presented to us that we will have an answer at the time of the meeting um and if we cannot we're committing to uh having an answer within 48 Hours uh so I just want to have that on record that when you come up and uh ask uh and are looking for an answer we're going to commit to giving an answer within 48 hours if we can't produce one the night of the meeting all right so uh nobody else we're going to uh close the public comment section all righty moving on to action items uh one through four uh can I get a motion to move action items one through four motion second okay uh anybody uh want to discuss any discussion all right uh can I get a roll call please on
053superintendent action items one through four Mrs Hartz yes Mrs camera yes Mr scales yes Mr Rico yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta yes Mrs VY yes Mr Walsh yes and Mr SC yes thank you the motion carried unanimously okay uh nothing other buildings and grounds uh curriculum can I get a a motion to move uh items one and two under curriculum motion second anybody uh like to discuss all right can I get a roll call oh I'm sorry are you going to say something no oh I'm sorry um can I hear the roll call yes you may I thought he was going to say something curriculum items one through two Mrs har um yes to two I'm gonna abstain from one thank you Mrs Cameron um yes Mr scales yes Mr or yes Mrs Ramirez
054yes Mr R yes Mrs V yes yes Mr Walsh yes Mr scarp uh yes to two abstaining from one thank you the motion Carri okay uh can I get a motion to move items one two three under Finance motion second I had a question yeah um on number three I was just curious about the um the criteria that our facilities manager used to evaluate and select um troll electric as the vendor for the project Mrs V with back i' I'd ask Mr morasco to answer that question is that okay okay I thought you were just going to do I have to tell you to I am so sorry yeah can you answer that I'll do my best thank you um it's the criteria is used like any other criteria in selecting a vendor to do
055um contracted work uh he um contacted colleagues in the field who has who have used this vendor um and gotten information from the Ed Services Commission of New Jersey which is the administration organization that carried out the bid uh that this company has been awarded and um do we know if um there are other bids or like is was this the lowest bidder and you have other quotes it didn't require formal bidding okay formal advertisements okay and um in the future is there a way that as a board we can just get more like um oversight of vendors like I remember when he came and he did a presentation is that something we can see more of before we select the vendor may I may I so one of the things that we do is
056we work in the Ed Services Commissions and they we work with them as if we're a part of them as a district as a board of education they actually are Ed a contract to go out and get low bids so when PE when they are actually doing our bidding processes they go out and vet it out for us it's a service that we're a part of so when anyone is recommended through them and if we're looking through if they're under a state contract is what they refer to it as it means that they're uh working with us to provide us a service that is more um competitive than if it was the private sector okay so that's what the Ed Services Commissions do for us great thank you appreciate that um okay anybody else have
057uh questions or comments for items one two three I just had one question um from a point of communications uh it a total amount 38,000 in change uh is budgeted against the fiscal year 25 was there a separate line item associated with this or is that in a general account that ITW us from just my own edification there were I believe one or two line items in fund 12 that accounted for the $40,000 budget okay so it's within the budget it's it's on the budget actually very good thank you yes okay anybody else okay if not uh we'll take a roll call on finance items one through three Mrs harwitz yes Mrs Cameron yes Mr scales yes Mr R yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr Retta yes Mrs Wy yes Mr Walsh yes Mr scar yes
058thank you the motion carried to uh okay can I get a motion to move um items under policy uh one one through three under policy motion second any uh discussion comments may I just add one comment um with the changes to the lay on positions and the changes to the ad hoc and the extracurricular for the fifth there'll be some first drafts that I'll be working with the policy through s first that they'll appear for revisions which will um edit as I mentioned uh regulation 0155 which lists the charters so we'll be putting together some languages from that and hopefully get some first reads for that with working for the board for the fifth meeting on the fifth okay so just a t FYI thank you very much uh anybody else want to comment on
059those Angel May yeah absolutely um so I'm very happy to see that we have um a second comment section added to our meetings um hopefully it's uh well used I know that uh this is actually a pretty good turnout for our meetings um so hopefully our constituents feel welcome and able to stand up and have that uh Second opportunity after we give um our presentations for in the future I know sometimes there's been uh constituents that want to comment when people give the presentation so I think it's a great addition that being said I just want to note that um I'm not in favor of us suspending our bylaw I know it's obviously well within our rights and in accordance with Robert Robert's Rules and orders to do so um I do believe that that
060should be done so for emergency situations only and I don't believe that um having that second comment section tonight was for an emergency purpose again I'm very happy that we're adding it um but suspending that uh by law I think it just opens the doors to a slippery slope for not only this board but for future boards right because we set a president for future boards and in having the ability to be able to suspend a bylaw for something again that's not an emergency reason I think it uh opens the doors to suspending that bylaw for the same reason for having it be um a first read and as we're all aware there was um a second read for one of the policies that was tabled last meeting so had we susp ended that bylaw
061back in December um we could have pushed that through uh before a new board came on and we wouldn't have had the opportunity for um us as a board member us as board members and also for our uh public to have the ability to comment on that and say um their piece on it so um again I I will be voting in favor of this um because for the item number you know for the purpose of changing uh the conduct of the board meeting again I'm happy that we're having that second comment section um just wanted to put on the record not happy with us suspending a bylaw for that thank you great thank you anybody else like to comment okay uh seeing none uh can I get a roll call motion I think did
062I motion already yes we have a first and a second okay Robert scales and Phil all right Mrs Mrs harz Iain Mrs Cameron yes Mr scales yes Mr R yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr R yes Mrs VY yes Mr Walsh yes Mr Scarpa I'll obain thank you motion carry okay all right um nothing under negotiations or transportation uh so we're moving right into Personnel um if I could get a motion for items one through nine thank you very much one through nine under uh Personnel oh thank you thank you Vinnie all right and you got a second need a second second okay great Mr scales okay I'll take a roll call oh I'm sorry we've got comments on this anybody anybody have anything to say comments questions I just want to point out on that
063personnel number one recognizes Mr Andre Rodriguez who will be retiring from the district as a maintenance worker after 28 years of service of Maintenance his expertise in plumbing hbac um he has been a gem for this district for a really long time and we are certainly so happy for him and want to wish him the best in his retirement at the end of this school year boy will he be missed so on behalf of all of us I want to wish him the best of health happiness and just relaxation and hope he hasn't doesn't have to fix anything for a really long time when when he retires so I just wanted to recognize that on the agenda for this evening uh great thank you very much Dr G uh okay there's no other questions or
064comments just one comment I'm so sorry sure go ahead I'll that same point and number one talking about an individual have a 28e that's a tremendous amount of Enterprise knowledge in that space so uh whenever I do an exit interview with my employees I certainly look to say what are some of the takeaways so just for again for my own edification what it is the dialogue with someone like this who's been around he actually knows the about all the skeletons in our facilities and stuff like that and what's the go forward strategy for setting up someone new in this space because 28 years old someone coming on board with one or two days so what's that transition like absolutely so um one there are two many facets of this job that I I enjoy so
065much and one of them is onboarding teachers and then when you get an appointment calendar where you have someone like Mr um Rodriguez who is coming in for an appointment that you don't see in a regular basis you know what it's about and so uh we take an opportunity to speak about that about about experience um and hopes for the Replacements and positions and go so we spend time together uh in retirement conversations uh when notifications are given um and then we work with the facilities manager for the needs for the positions um there's always opportunities with Personnel for discussions with regards to structuring and different things um thinking about things but obviously there's a skill set right and sometimes when you're when you're looking at different perspectives whether it be custodial staff bus drivers
066maintenance those kinds of things you look for a school a certain skill set and sometimes you have to look far and wide for it and attract uh you know contact multiple areas of Medias for advertising school boards does a nice job for us you can websit so it's really kind of reaching as far as we can to get our best candidate um to um obviously experience and history of the district and the operations and the systems and things is something that someone new uh won't have but we hope to uh bring them in with transition and also maintaining the staff we have who have also been here for a couple years that can bring in and have like almost like a mentoring or shadowing for a little bit as they're coming on and they learn
067um we always we try to look for people work with Wells right and that's a big one that we try to work with find um an HVAC knowledge you know we there are different um attributes of Staff in maintenance and custodian we look for strong points you know for different things for our that service our needs you're welcome great anybody else like to say something all right if not um we'll take a roll call yes Personnel items 1 through nine Mrs harwitz yes Mrs Cameron I'm going to abstain from number four and yes to everything else thank you Mr scales yes Mr Oro yes Mrs Ramirez yes Mr RN Department Labor dis yes to all the thank you Mrs a yes Mr Walsh yes Mr scar yes thank you the motion carried okay um we're
068going to open the floor again for our uh newly uh new addition for our second uh public comment welcome to come up to the podium state your name and address for the record sure hello my name is mallerie Reen I live at 165 l Road um I've heard a lot of comments on the board tonight about how much everyone really wants to get community feedback um get the opinions of of parents and you know family in the district and as somebody that attends a lot of the board meetings I do really appreciate that um I will say I was in the parent advisory committee last year um several of you were here when those recommendations were made I think miss Cameron you might have even participated in the the parent advisory committee just as a
069resident and parent and one of the biggest recommendations from that committee was to not get rid of seal but in inrease it parents were big fans of that um and I know that you said one of your priorities in the first 90 days is to start cutting back on that I obviously can't speak to howal is implemented at other school districts I only know the Colac Township Public School District but it has been life-changing for my family for other families here um my oldest son this is his third year in the school district he's really benefited from it he's never come home talking about what you would consider like a political politically motivated agenda it's never it's never about the things that you see in the news that are tied toal he comes home learning
070how to manage his emotions and how to interact with other students and and how to handle it if he loses a board game how to be a good loser and congratulate the people that won instead of getting really upset so as a parent that's what I have seen it do for my child and my family so I'd really really urge you to look back at those recommendations and make sure that you're taking into account what so many parents in this community have said they want um you guys have all run on campaigns about wanting political agendas out of the school this is this doesn't have to be a political agenda this could just be what is best for our students so please take that into consideration thank you thank you uh I just want to
071thank you for your comments we will take them uh into consideration um I will actually uh be attending uh some of the parent advisory committees to hear that feedback and uh uh we'll certainly take them into consideration so thank you y all right hello Christine Scara again uh I appreciate your comment um where I do also feel that um focusing on mental health and the ability to navigate one's emotions and one's feelings is extremely important so um investing in that for our children is um extremely important um but for um number two under Personnel um as a parent who has a child in the school district um I was I constantly look for after school activities for my son and you um the school does provide a nice variety however I have seen a lack
072of um like reading programs um I see a lot focus on math um is am I just not looking correctly or is there um an option for in like Young Learners who are experiencing challenges in reading and writing um would is that an option to add to after school activities uh yeah go ahead and then I'll make a comment but yeah absolutely so um one of the things we did when we received a lot of uh additional funding for Co for from as a result of pandemic Sr funds ARP funds different things so we invested heavily in the after school programs as um for that type of remediation very targeted in terms of whether it was uh a certain skill set in Reading mathematics we did science we did a couple different things a lot
073um we do a lot of uh so there are opportunities these are NE these are more like um like a club which is more like an extracurricular type of thing that said though we do have academic based after school programs um when and we used a lot of federal funds that aren't available for those anymore that said um the answer is is yes are there opportunities most of them are usually during the day through a a targeted Intervention Program through identification of our Matrix uh through you know that type of thing like IEP nope it they don't have to have an IEP for it it's for general education students so if you haven't um received anything like that with regards to academic progress or as you've been monitoring please don't hesitate to reach out to
074your child's teacher okay um start there and then because there's several different uh tiers of intervention that we offer based on what a child needs at any moment in time they might need a little bit of support for a certain skill or they might need uh more long-term support you know which is also a different conversation so definitely start with your child's teacher and then um sometimes students are directly recommended for programs um things like summerbridge which we've done in the past uh it's while it's open for all students we've made specific Outreach to uh to families for students who we feel will truly benefit from the program um so start with your child's teacher and then um we can go on from there awesome thank you you're welcome great thing actually it was more
075appropriate for you to address that um I was just going to make a comment that it was more like a fun Club thing uh but you took care of it very nicely so thank you um anybody else like to come up and make any final comments before we close Public public comment okay we're going to close public comment um we're going to move on to uh our new business um section of the meeting just to let the new board members new business you could pretty much bring up any topic or concern that you have any ideas um uh any issues that you want to address now would be the time to do it so I wanted to bring up screen time and Chromebooks okay okay I've heard a lot of concerns in the school district
076when it comes to parents and their kids using the Chromebooks and the school systems here um so what constitutes that screen time TV video tablets smartphones gaming and computers the CDC recommendations for screen time by age group children two years of age and younger there should be no screen time at all 2 to 5 years old no more than one hour per day co- viewing with a parent or sibling 5 to 17 years old no more than two hours per day the CDC screen time statistics now this is right off the CDC website according to the Kaiser Family Foundation kids ages 8 to 18 now spend on average a whopping seven and a half hours in front of a screen for enter each day uh four and a half of those hours are spent watching
077TV uh over a year that add up that adds up to 114 full days watching a screen uh that's just the time they spend in front of the screen for entertainment it doesn't include the time they spend on a computer at school uh for educational purpose or at home for homework um and I just wanted to point out the negative health effects on screen time and if any of this sounds familiar in today's society I think uh it's not going to come to a surprise to any of us uh digital I strain is a group of related eye and vision problems caused by extended computer or digital device use symptoms include eye discomfort and fatigue dryeee blurry vision and headaches excessive screen time like the seven and a half hours that they get per day
078um leads to problems in social emotional development including obesity sleep disturbances depression and anxiety which is rampant in today's society between Children of the ages of 8 and 18 no surprise uh it can impair emotional comprehension promote aggressive behavior and hinder social and emotional competence screen time overloads the sensory system fractures attention and depletes mental reserves uh everyone knows and the CDC recommends kids get at least 60 Minutes of physical activity each each day uh the time kids spend watching TV playing video games surfing the web is time they could be physically active and having more face-to-face interaction with peers which promotes healthy mental social behaviors and to the cnck parents I just wanted to say I hear you loud and clear on this issue with the Chromebooks it is a top priority of mine
079and I will work with everyone on the board and the in the administration to make the necessary changes as uh soon as this upcoming school year so and the reference is you can read this for yourself it's at the cdc.gov nih.gov and the osfhealthcare.org so for your references um and I think that teaching would be way more consistent if there were there were you know pieces of paper pencils in front of the children and the teacher is teaching on the uh the school board um in front of the kids um the chalk board back you know when I went to school but um I think that would be way more advantageous um and then there would be I believe that would create consistency uh the children I think the teachers it would be way easier
080for the teachers to know hey what kid is ahead what kid is on par and what children are behind um and that's the take on that uh thank you Jason I'm thinking maybe one uh depending on the meetings if we can uh attend with Sarah on the parent advisory committee to maybe you know see what the parents think uh you know and then bring it back to the board during a count meeting so we appreciate that Viewpoint all right thank you yes may I also recommend through curriculum uh getting teachers opinions and value and of their teaching practices and the resources that are available to do that we utilize you know with regards to uh the tech use and and also like having I think teacher input as a resource of for how they teach
081I think is also something an important perspective to also bring to the conversation as well for consideration so maybe that would be something okay that board would also want to look at definitely a thing that you know we have to get different viewpoints of course so move forward on it and then I just wanted to also point out sorry great thank you great thank you very much um okay anybody else uh with some oh I'm sorry Vinnie I didn't see you please go ahead top of your head do you know's don't top I I think when with with regards to the program I think that what the references made regarding mental health are usually on social media phones and those types of things things that are not the research that has been brought to my
082attention and that I've also looked at as well isn't necessarily related to educational use while educational use is a considered a screen time it is um it's not necessarily anything that I've been privy to with regards to the contributions of anxiety or the other uh issues that have been linked to accessibility to information that may may or may not be monitored at home frequency uh you know that uh immediate gratification for information connectivity not um you know you you used to not find out till Monday mornings that you weren't invited to the sleepover now you see all the social media posts that you weren't invited to and those yeah that definitely is something and as the more a child has access to those screens that demonstrate or may have the uh create the invoke those
083emotions then um that's the type of thing that we were talking about so helping students to navigate those things um I know a couple years ago we had our wait until eth program that was is very well received and it is something that school districts can uh look at to say that it's a a pledge that you can work with your families to say you know that waiting till 8th for a smartphone not necessarily a phone for communication but has that uh uh really introduces students to a world um that may or may not be able to be monitored all the time so that might be something again through maybe Communications or the parent advisory that we look to bring um at a district level it's been popular In Pockets type of thing but we
084can can certainly continue to do something like that there's also a lot of conversation right now um in the media and different state levels on cell phone banss and we did bring to the attention at a for uh a prior board meeting um we already have a no cell phone policy in place here in the district they're not supposed to have them on them so that's already something that our board adopted many many many many years ago but again it there's a lot of that uh there's a lot of conversation sure not to interrupt you if I could ask you um to clarify the policy on the cell phones because I know uh Governor Murphy was trying to um ban cell phones um I'm in disagreement with that I do believe cell phones should not
085be uh anywhere out in a classroom um but I do not believe they should be banned a child should be able to take them to school so our policy is they're allowed to bring them in but they're supposed to be put away um in lockers correct correct they're not supposed to be used yeah I mean I I think that's a practice I think it is that they're not supposed to be around it but the practice is is that we understand and we've partnered with families and things but I the the policy is non-use of electronic any electronic communication devices which includes recordings or anything like that tape recorder or anything like that that that would um to your point it's they're not in use that's really what the main focus is is not in news
086okay uh I agree with that and you find the district you know um everybody works according to that policy the kids I didn't say that Mrs VY no I said just think it because I I I do agree cell phones are very disruptive um I certainly teach my daughter uh to have the phone she is allowed to just off for a bit of any type of school emergency as a parent I'm you know I'm comfortable with that but if she's ever caught with it out she knows um the ramifications and I'm I'm hoping most parents would teach their children you have it and you have to respect the law of the school the respect the teachers in the classroom um so I'm just curious if the teachers do have a problem with that if there's
087a problem in this District so I think that I I think I can get information uh more information specific information on on very on specific issues that we run into many times it's social media checking your insta checking your this checking your Snapchat those type of things when you say issues I think that if you're talking about specifics have we run into situations that happen more or less outside of the district but then the complications and the ramifications are brought into Social Circles within the district and so for an example something may have said or not have been said investigated reported through snapchat it's brought into the district because it's carrying over because the tensions that are created as a result of the ACT are then need to be dealt with through the school and
088that that takes time to investigate that takes time to work through and um we partner with our uh sometimes local law enforcement needs to be involved in that as well so there are a series of actions that take place based on social media which is really the Baseline for that wait until 8th that they developmentally they might not be they might not be ready to handle the responsibility of that that access that they have have we are currently also partnering for some parenty for the spring and last year the mammoth County prosecutor's office um did a really nice presentation for parents and we hope it's uh even more widely attended this year this when we when we're able to do it which is on cell phone and dangerous apps and things and many parents left
089that that Parent Academy saying my child is never getting a cell phone who attended so we're going to be looking into that as well so um we're just waiting on a on a date back from that person um so I hope that answerers your question yeah I can comment that too miss fpy the you know like most policies in the district are you know Colt policy is fair right we've we've done a great job over the last couple years Governor Murphy's is is merely a recommendation to uh the state government to move forward with a full band on it um it's from what I've read so far like most of Governor Murphy's policies it's a a tyrannical overreach so what it's designed to do is make sure that a student is not able to have
090a device on them at all in in any time so for example if you were to go to an Afterschool activity most of our children have cell phones with them so they can contact us when they need to be picked up so obviously when and if it does come down our committee will fully bet everything before we even come close to instituting anything like that that Governor Murphy has his hands on so okay yep I appreciate keep us updated on it yeah we'll do all Angeli if I may yeah um so I have a few things for new business um so one Jason I wanted to um just comment on some of the screen time concerns that you brought up in my research and we've been dealing with this for the last two years that
091I've been on the board there are at least nothing that I have ever found on any of the CDC the American psychology Association the American Pediatric Association um World Health Organization there's nothing that delineates between entertainment and education screen time so one of the challenges that I found over the last two years and us taking public comment and the parent concerns on screen time into account is where do we go from there because yes we all know what the guidelines are and we don't want them to have uh you know too much screen time I think all of us as parents probably struggle with that in this day and age to some extent but how do we Implement that in an educational standing because we don't know what happens when the kids go home and
092how much screen time they have there so if we've even if we have them at whatever that minimum is here in the school district uh during their day between the school day here and then their homework assignments um you know if they're going home then I'm sure we'll be getting email after email from parents telling us well now they can't put on the TV when they get home because now we're already at our Mac so I think it just becomes very difficult ult to distinguish between that entertainment and that education most of the guidelines um when you dig deeper into them um not just the on the first page of those websites but when you actually dig deep into them um it really is for entertainment usually there's an asct somewhere in the research or
093when you actually look into um the studies that show that um educational purposes are usually outside of those numbers anyway um so definitely something for us to be mindful about um I think it it and we've said this now for the last two years it's going to involve um more research talking to our teachers finding out how it's actually being implemented um and then the other part of that is we're raising these tiny humans to be part of the Next Generation I remember when I was a kid we were told well you're not always going to have a calculator on you so you have to be able to do this math on paper but I actually do always in fact have a calculator on me so we have to be mindful that when we are
094teaching our students in this District that we're doing so with the mindset of Technology is only advancing um we have ai now and that we have to be mindful of that that the we need to prepare our students in this District to go on to high schools beyond our k through eight District here that will be using technology and if they're not prepared if they're not able to use Google teams or Google classroom or um I don't know what else they're learning these days but anything outside of that or how to safely use things like um AI then I think we're failing our students and um you know I know when I was in grad school we were in the process of transitioning over from uh paper tests and scantrons into um everything being digitalized
095because our board exam is on the computer and so what our professors did was they had all of our tests for three years everything was taken on a laptop because we had to know how to sit in a small cubicle and take our board exam on a computer and it's very different than taking an exam on paper and pencil if you've ever had to you know switch between the two and so we have to make sure that we are preparing the students in this district for the future which is unfortunately or fortunately depending on what you think of it probably a little bit of both um it's it's Technology based so um just something for us all to keep in mind um I do think we need to find uh a happy medium there is
096uh a pilot program or actually might be out of the pilot part now down in Texas where they took students and uh they only taught them for two hours a day only using art icial intelligence there was no teachers in the classroom at all and the students actually scored ex like Head and Shoulders above their peers that had teachers in the classroom and they did this for at least two years and it's a phenomenal study if you uh don't have anything better to do with your time um but if that's the way we kind of see our education shifting or somewhere in between hopefully um you know we have to prepare our students for using technology to some extent um so again just things for us all to keep in mind I don't think it's
097any one extreme I think it's somewhere in the middle like most things in this world um a couple other things I just wanted to make note of um I'm extremely happy to see that there are mentors on the agenda tonight that were um assigned to our new board members um I think this is very important going into my third year here um on this board there's so much to learn it's a very steep learning curve you kind of hit the ground running and so I know that last year there were some board members that um were adamantly against having mentors and so I'm very happy to see that our new board members were all assigned mentors so um kudos to you and leque for assigning U mentors to them um and on that I heard
098um a few different of our action items tonight there was um a decent amount of of abstaining and since there was no uh reference given to why there was an exstension of your vote I'm not sure why but I do hope that your mentors are providing um some background and understanding behind and I believe Tim will touch on this tonight if I'm not mistaken after hearing this now for my third time um why you should be abstaining or recusing um or voting in favor of um so there is a a very specific reason for that and so um I hope that the mentors are are uh providing that Insight so that our new board members are um utilizing their voice which is your vote um while you're on the board and finally if I may
099um yester no this morning this morning I um participated in a um or listened to I should say there was not too much participation on my end um for the New Jersey Schoolboard Association webinar um which was a a coffee chat on uh brewing and education law coffee chat um and it was a great uh webinar so for some of the new board members that don't know I know uh some of you have been on the board already you obviously get these emails and you know but um these webinars will um occur periodically you'll get the emails to your board email um they today they went over um different case studies uh for the um New um uh commissions of Education cases today the next one which will be part two of the series is
100going to be on January 31st um and that's going to be on the ethics commission um the the school ethics uh commission and there's also going to be some advisory opinions so um it's really interesting to hear the different cases these are actual cases that were brought forth um this past fall uh through December of last year and um they go through in detail you know what happened what the case was um what the outcome was um um and something that was a good takeaway for me was there are a lot of uh advisory opinions and and uh School ethics commission cases that are heard and I'm grateful that our district uh has not at least not in my time on this board um seen too many of those with regard to um Hib cases
101so um again something else for us to uh participate in um as we members so just wanted to bring your attention to that as new board members and that's all thank you great thank you very much for um covering all that um anybody else like to bring new business yep just uh one comment in mind about the ad hoc committee for affordable housing since it wasn't on on there today um we you know having the the cow meeting structure is going to help us a lot right because we're going to call upon a lot of different committees um to help us with this um the meeting last week was is what it was um we're about to get walloped in this town um I feel it's it's an unfair Target on Colt snacks back we
102and if anyone knows how many residents we have in cols neck we have just over 9,000 residents in cols neck um the state mandate that's coming down is astronomical to say the least um you know throughout the last couple months just meeting constituents um um we thought that you know it would be good to have this committee because people are very concerned and I just wanted to let the public know and be aware that you know we're going to take this very seriously um a lot of the renters as you know a lot of the units will be renters they are non- taxpayers so if we look at the percentage of the tax that we receive as a board I believe it's um 70210 is that correct 70 local 20 State 10 Federal um the
103committee we're going to look at everything possible to increase that 20% from the state um dramatically it's not fair to taxpayers um that a state mandate comes down um on the constituents and then we have to foot the bill for this so as you saw through the last couple meetings we we also have to take care of all the infrastructure in town as well so we're going to hold the state accountable to make sure that it's fair and it's balanced and I'll call upon each of these board members to to help me with it um but there's a lot as some of you might have seen throughout when I was campaigning to take this Eve um I had a very personal story about this happening to me in another town um so I do have
104a lot of experience with it and you know rest assured we're going to work very tirelessly to make sure that everything is fair and balanced and I'll say and balance as much as I possibly can um so if you have any comments on it I'll be writing a charter this week we'll be having that available so you can see what the the committee's goals and Mission will be um and then that'll be available to the public for you to read because it'll be a part of uh the policy as well too within within the district so again if any there's any questions please reach out to the board but we're excited to to uh to get to work we have a lot of work to do so thank you very much thank you Mr scales
105Rob and Jon I don't know if you two can probably better explain this than I understand it so I understand that renters don't necessarily pay directly for property taxes but someone owns that property and someone does pay taxes on that property so how does that work with the affordable housing it's the it's the investor who owns it who has to pay the the uh the property taxes okay on that property and a percentage of that goes to the school district 68% of it goes to the school district and everything else is chopped up between the state the county yeah so so there are taxes from those renters going to our school district that even though the renters aren't specifically paying them the renters are not so if somebody rents my house those renters are not
106they're not paying taxes but I'm still paying taxes as the homeowner and the property owner to the township and a percentage of that does go to the school district whether I have kids in the district or not correct whether you have kids in the district and whether my renters have kids in the district or not corre correct what will happen when there's a large there's a tax abatement for a number of different years so the the district won't see tax revenue from a lot of those so I don't that's going to be part of what the committee's mission is going to be is to find out exactly what the tax implications will be because as you know we'll measure the revenue um that's going to come to the district and that's when we'll be able
107to find out well what shortfall are we going to see number one and then when we can B balance the infrastructure that's needed in order to improve we've got a lot of different studies that we have to we have to call upon the gentleman's name to provide updated numbers as well too um but we're right now it's very it's unfair and it's unbalanced because the money that again the estimates the tax revenue that we're going to receive from that won't be there for a certain number of years but we just have to find out exactly what it is and then to my comments is that when that money um when you're a renter because there's no locally funded from that rent right so if there is an abatement for a number of years we have
108to we have to go to the state well the property owner again won't be paying taxes for a number of times that's part of the agreements of and when they place the proper when they do ultimately it will be retroactive paid to the school district then at that point we have to find out we don't have any information there was none of those uh questions answered at the the committee meeting they had last week so once we know the implications then we can we can measure where we're going to be but again that my comments is that we have to look to the state right so if there is an B let's just say for example it's five years 10 years we have to look to the state to make up for that shortfall from
109now because it's we it's not going to just be the the flick of a wand we'll have another wing on the school we have to find out again what the impact is for the amount of students that are going to come in what's the revenue that's going to come in to to be for the infrastructure then how long that's going to take for us to even get that money so obviously us and Vince we have a lot of work to do and where our shorall is going to be and I've seen tax abatements anywhere between five years and I've seen tax abatements on some of these buildings that last 30 years correct uh yeah just a point on that January 29th it's an absolute critical point to bring up to the township there will be
110tax abatements with these construction this is gives the Builder the incentive to build they generally don't go back and provide retroactive uh monies after the fact know it gets graduated in afterwards so we have to build into that shortfall so a conservative approach is we're going to take on X number of units with no increase for a period of time that graduated scale needs to be part of our conversation so we can support the infrastructure you we're talking about north of a thousand units that this that this has to bear and it's way north of the projected numbers you know anyone with a reasonable mindset can appreciate this way northly the projected numbers of personnel coming into our schools we can support X maybe we're at x minus y right now but what what is
111that real differential so 129 good question is what is the real number that we can expect so that we can properly plan for the infrastructure and support of our schools and yes to be prepared for tax abatements because that will negatively impact our Revenue opportunity and I imagine they already know the tax abatement uh time frame that seems like something it's not a guessing game there that should be something that's written into a contract or you know the incentive for the Builder I imagine that's already you know drawn up so they should know those numbers whether or not they're giving them is another story but that those numbers should be known um I used to live in a community that had moderate income housing um and uh it was this was known it was nothing
112um and it is all public knowledge they should be posting this or it should be somewhere um so I think it's just a matter of finding it and that might give us a little bit better idea too to find out is it one year is it two years is it five years is it a million years you know it's tough for us to base numbers off of things that we don't have um and we can assume all we want but you know we all know theel saying what assuming does thank you um I think Mr Rett is motioning go ahead Vinnie I'm sorry uh a committee uh reaching out uh with informed letter or anything else uh once we have all the facts especially with the amount of kids we're expected to get and the
113tax burden we're going to have and what we don't know what we don't war poity and sewage quality um to try and Advocate before they break ground on the next sites to try and suspend it suspend this before we know uh the the total impacts we're going to get on all those criterias um to try and try to put a some kind of a suspension or a pin in it um to help out this town before it uh before everything goes down i' like to make a comment I think it's the Township's obligation to be forthright honest and transparent with the figures January 14th an opening meeting to the public they put the planning board in charge of answering Township committee questions this impacts our school board specifically and I think these numbers we shouldn't
114have they should be supplied by our town Supply to uh Dr G superintendent we shouldn't be waiting this long we should have an expectation of the numbers the round one two and three are approved round four we justed so I don't I don't see why there's such a delay to have our superintendent um you know get ahead of this we shouldn't be waiting to June July August and September it's not fair to the superintendent it's not fair to the school board uh I think there's a little bit of an incompetence factor with the township committee um and hopefully uh that'll be rectified uh rather quickly um back to you know try step up and out toate government uh ABS absolutely Vinnie I I um I absolutely agree with you it's a fantastic idea and I
115I back you 100% And we could certainly move forward uh with doing so thank you great than you yeah okay anybody else um so as we prepare for our 2526 budget um at the next c meeting I'd like to discuss in the Middle School um the possibility of a naval science class for um for our middle schoolers which is inspired by the jrc the junior Reserve Officers Training corpse program and it could provide a foundational introduction to leadership teamwork and the principles of Naval science um being that colck High School has the ROC program I think it would be advantageous for our children I know Wall Township now has that program so um so I I would like to discuss that in the cow meeting and hopefully we could approve that and then um in
116terms of our our literature and our books and just Communications with transparency and um accessibility for parents do we have some kind of digital library or any any way our parents can access all our all the not only I know we have Atlas for the curriculums for the actual books in the classroom that students are reading and the books in our libraries absolutely so all of our to to your point answer your first point what you already said yes all of there is a digital transcript of everything that's in the libraries right that's takes place moving forward and I I put this in my updates moving for is that we are working on what we're referring to a scan and shelf process for all classroom libraries that we're using um book Source bookshelf for and
117uh it's look actually Dr Reynolds and Mr capasso uh presented recently as like an Innovative practice that's currently being explored in the county um that actually will give parents access to all of the classroom libraries um with also information about each book not just a list it's not just like an Excel list it gives a little bit about like the reading level the content so on and so forth that's vetted out because we do want to be ahead of conversations and any concerns and have parents be able to have access to things that you know aside from just the library right and saying like here's what it is so we are taking um we've heard time and time again regarding the concept of transparency and having that access to the resources so I'm excited to
118have Dr Reynolds bring that forward with Mr capasso as a project um that we've been trying out we spent a lot of lot of time and when I say trying out a lot of time and effort has been put forth by the teachers uh putting forward because as you know classroom libraries are extensive and so as we're going through that but not only just the what but the how so also looking at how our district in reflection is um going through the process for the selection of books and things like that for our classroom libraries how that that is and um you know reviewing and revising that process for procedures for our teachers as well working with the administration and the teachers for that um and then there's also policies in place like with regards
119to how that process is isn't done so that's something that we can look at as well if there's any concerns uh that is also a policy and one of those policies deal with not just staff members but also deals with resources and materials for the processes that are in place for parents that have concerns so that's something that yes so we I'm so excited so called scan and shell that's the that's what we're calling it so I don't want to steal Dr Reynolds thunder so or Mr Capac so that's what we're looking at it's kind of that's what we've called it there two different resources that we're using one is to actually get the information in and the other one is going to be an outward um you know profile of the literacy uh resources
120that we have in the district okay that's wonderful I love that we're going in this direction so thank you yeah any other uh new business anybody else okay uh I think at this time we are going going to um take a break before we move on to our ethics training with Mr Tan so if anybody would like to take a quick uh few minute break to use the lavatory grab something to eat uh you're more than welcome to do so and once again the public is welcome to stay and enjoy our ethics training with us um if not um okay uh great so we're going um do I have to do a motion to go into break okay we're just going to do a five minute uh recess at this time thank you yeah sure
121yeah for a minute there I thought we were in a cow like wait are we in I was like wait a minute are we in a c I could remember all right let me text Gia tell her to oh e e e e e e green you're on perfect e for e for e e I think she's com you're still live streaming it's okay Mary Jane is here so I guess we can start before we do though I just want to say Jessica I was on the same one this morning with the webinar and they they are both awesome and um yes I'm interested in the cases some of the cases are actually in here um yes in that crazy oh my go yeah it was it was an interesting case where 25 years ago
122the person the employee of a district was actually um arrested for a crime and it was never caught and so all of a sudden they terminated him when it became known that he had this criminal activity from 25 years ago and so of course you know he appealed it and so on and so forth and he ended up losing his job and um so just like those are the kind of cases that they were talking about during you know the uh webinar that she was talking about so if that piqu your interest there you go it's a little plug for it but I will be at next month's too but if you didn't make it they actually even though you don't get board member credit for it you can actually go to YouTube the New
123Jersey school board's YouTube channel and actually watch it so you can do that as well you don't get credit but you still get the information so they didn't they they said what it was but but I didn't catch exactly what it was ludis it was ludis but it was ludis with like a family member it wasn't like public so yeah so interesting yes it's got to be public sorry all right so this is ethics training and we always start off by saying first of all I'm not an attorney and I don't play one I'm I don't pretend to be one all this information that is in here is Legal Information it's not legal advice you get your legal advice from only one person that is your board attorney because that's the person that's going to
124have to defend you when you've done something wrong so the school ethics Act is there basically to ensure that you as board members are behaving ethically and giving the impression to your communities that you are abiding by the ethics the code of ethics that have been written so that they can have faith in all that you do so it is a minimal minimum standard that's established obviously we would love for you to be more ethical than what's delineate it as a 10 tenants but know that that's the minimum requirement that you as a board member have to abide by so there's four different areas that the um School ethics commission the SEC um has as part of the ethics the code of ethics and that's a code of ethics mandatory training prohibited acts and disclosure
125statements as board members you're required to do all four of those the administrators within your District they actually only do the two on the right okay they don't have to go through the code of ethics though they do they do adhere to it and they do not have to do the mandatory training you all do have to do those and we're going to talk about each one of those so the school ethics commission also known as the SEC is supposed to be made up of nine individuals that are broken up in this way five non-school officials two school board members and two School administrators a year ago when I was here doing ethics training I said to you at that time there was only six people that were sitting guess what there's still only six
126people that are sitting on this these open seats are two School Board member seats are currently vacant and one of of the school administrator seats are currently vacant people have asked how do you get appointed to that well the best answer I can give you is we don't know it's it's a it's by the governor so it is a political connection so you need to reach out most likely to your legislator and ask them if you're if you're interested in being serving in one of these capacities you could reach out and say hey I would like to be considered for it um it's important to understand for those that don't know there there's something called advisory opinions we're to talk about but in order for an advisory opinion to become public it has to be
127um approved by six of the individuals six of the nine when there's only six that means all of them have to be there in order to approve it when there's not which sadly there's not always not all six show up to the meetings so when that happens then even if they feel that an advisory opinion could would have a far-reaching impact across the state they can not pass it as being a public advisor opinion it only will be passed as going to the individual that had requested it so what happened in December and that's what for the next one they're talking about for the next um coffeine conversation or whatever they called it um they're going to talk about the 11 advisory opinions that popped up really all popped up in December and it uh
128finished creating this and then we had to go back to the drawing board and incorporate those um 11 in here so I know it said tonight about the financial disclosure statements that they went out that is electronic you are required to do it if you're a brand new board member you have to finish within 30 days otherwise you have to finish as a school district by April 30th and that's every year for those that have never done it it's not going to ask you how much money you make it just simply is asking you where are your sources of income so who do you get paid by and the reason for that is to make sure that you do not have a conflict of interest so it's all under ethics and just so everyone knows
129everything that I'm going through tonight is not Jersey school boards this is the SEC so and this is by Statute and code as well so know that if you have an issue with something that's in here it's not us we're just sharing the information with you so the mandatory training that we were talking about before there are four different um that we call them governance 1 two 3 and four if you're brand new board member you have to do governance one within the first 90 days of being appointed and sitting as a board member not when you're voted in but it's when you're actually sworn in that gives you your basic foundational knowledge so that you can at least hit the ground running as best as you possibly can and I know it was shared
130during the board meeting that um you know there's a learning curve here as being a board member like you you when you're sitting in the public and you're seeing what's going on you have a certain perception but the reality is very different so it's not until you're actually sitting on the board and you're actually part of all these committee meetings and the discussions and the private confidential information that's shared that all of a sudden you have a better understanding of why things are done the way that they are done so that governance one kind of gives you that basic foundational information information so that you can hit the ground running at the when you're re your second year of being a board member anytime during your second year you're going to take governance to which
131is going to focus on finance and policy now if you think about it Finance impacts anything and everything you do within a school district policy is one of the primary functions of a board so we try to give you a solid foundational information in that as well by the end of year three that's governance three and that's going to focus on student achievement and also labor which is like negotiations and then every year that you're reelected so every time you're reelected you have to do governance 4 which is legal updates now I've said this to people before they've asked me can I take governance for because I I'm really interested in the law and and a lot of new laws come out and there's new cases and everything yes you can take governance for every
132single year just tell your ba and he'll sign you up for it just understand though that when you get reelected you still have to take governance four so even if you took it in year three you still have to take it when you hit year that that re-election year okay so but yes you can your by all means you're able to take that all these are provided in person virtually like live virtual but also self-paced so virtual so it's it's up to your schedule and what you want to do and how you want to do it and then for new board members we also offer a new board member orientation a weekend program which is really in-depth we have it coming up this weekend and then again in February so advisory opinions as I said
133advisory opinions any school official and all of you are school officials can request an advisory opinion and what that means is you're you're saying hm I have something that I might consider doing but before I do it and misstep I want to ask for an advisor opinion to tell me if I do this am I going to get in trouble is it going to be an Ethics violation so you when you fill out that request and you send it in for that advisory opinion you will get an answer back from the SEC that will tell you whether you can or can't when they do that if they feel that it's not just specific to you the question or concern that you have could be impacting districts and Boards across the state that's when they try
134to vote to make it get a public um advisory opinion so the ones that you're going to see that are linked are all public advisory opinions the private ones we don't know because it only goes to the individual that requested it so these are being proactive meaning you're trying to head off doing something wrong the reactive ones are actually the ethics complaints that's after you have potentially done something wrong and now you know you have to try to defend it we got this question from somebody in another District that said do we need to actually abide by The Advisory opinion because it's only an opinion okay that's true however the advisory opinion we we equate to a police officer if you're driving down the road and you're speeding and the police officer pulls over and
135says you were 10 miles over the speed limit if you do it again I'm going to let you go this time but if you do it again I'm going to give you a ticket and you say okay that's his advice don't speed right you go in speed what do you think is going to happen when he pulls you over again you're getting a ticket so that's what this is all about you're making that request or someone has made a request and now it's a public advisory opinion about whether if you do something is it going to be wrong when they come out and say yes it will be wrong and then you choose to do it I guarantee you and they will tell you this that they will find you as in violation of Ethics
136so yes even though it's called an advisory opinion you really need to abide by it when you do fill out an advisory opinion please be very specific and detailed in your information because they make their determination whether something is um like you violate it or it will be a violation or not based upon the information that you give if you don't give the full story then the answer they give might have been different if they knew everything then you could still misstep so be honest and be very detailed so I sent to Mary Jane I don't know if you emailed it to everyone yet okay that's which is totally fine I sent it to her late today um but it and normally I do it the next day but I it early I'm trying to
137be a little better but you're going to get a PDF of this that PDF each one of these is a hyperlink so if you're nerdy like me and you like to read the cases you can click on those links and it'll bring you right to the case Okay the cases are not short these are very short summaries of not only the explanation of the case but also the sec's response sometimes when you look at these two sides it doesn't make like you sit there and you say doesn't really make sense how did they come up with that decision however when you click on the case and you read the 3 10 15 pages that are for each case it starts to shed a lot more information on the case that sheds light on why they
138made the decision that they did um so when I'm not going to read all these cases to you okay but I will highlight some of them the first one is an important I think it's an important one because it's it's a case of where a board member wanted to be able to review the resume of canand Cates you have to understand that as a board the superintendent makes a recommendation to you for personnel matters they will say I'm recommending this person for the position it is not your job as a board to say that's nice can we see all the other people that applied and we want to go through their resumés no you're that's not your job okay that's a superintendent's job that's her team's job so in this case the board M wanted
139to have all the resumés they wanted to review everything and they were basically told no okay the second one is an important one because there's going to be another um slide in a little while on negotiations and whether you have a con if you have a conflict of interest how does it impact whether you can be involved in the negotiations or not in this particular case the question was that um can they participate in negotiations if they have an aunt that's employed in the district who is not a member of the Local Union meaning they're nonaligned you have certain staff in your District that are considered non-aligned they're not part of a union your ba sitting at the table is one of them a lot of times the technology crew is usually non-aligned in many
140districts so you have certain pockets of Staff members that are going to be considered non-aligned so the question was can you as a board member if you have a relative that um is nonaligned can you then still participate in negotiations the answer was basically no okay but we're going to talk about there is a caveat to that and the reason why it was no because and Mary Jane will probably say this is absolutely true if you a superintendent and you have settled agreements with your teachers and your administrators for a certain percentage increase if you do something drastically different for your non-aligned that will come back to bite you as a superintendent okay somebody will throw that into your face so generally you're non-aligned are very close to where your other settled Agreements are and
141that's why that's considered a reason why you can't be in negotiations because even though is not aligned it will still have an impact if you can show though and that's going to be on that other slide if you can show that there is no connection in that District then in that case you as a board member probably then participate in negotiations as okay that's going to be a perfect case of if you're in that situation where you're going to want to talk to your board attorney give them the very specific information and let that board attorney make the determination whether you can or can't be involved so with these other ones the second one down um somebody board member received uh an endorsement from the local union can they participate in um matters that were
142relevant to the union members so in other words said hey we want to support you can I be involved the answer was they can it will always come down to whether you got a financial contribution or not though if you got a financial contribution chances are you shouldn't at least for one year okay so any kind of financial contribution means that you benefited from that endorsement as opposed to somebody just saying hey we support this candidate uh the fourth one down this is uh you had a board member who had a pretty bad history with the district and the superintendent they ended up getting fired and they then ran for the board and got on okay can that person then be involved in evaluating the superintendent the superintendent's contract the answer is no okay and
143this you might say well why would that happen it's been happening where staff members have gotten fired from a district and they go into actually get on the board and then they make try and they go on and run under I'm going to get rid of that person the reality is they find out that they can't even be involved in the contract negotiations the new contract existing contract or the evaluation so you know these are all the things that are important that uh you as board members understand because what you believe when you're in the public is very different when you finally find out that you're on the board and the things you thought you could do you can no longer do so an Ethics complaint and that question came up to me right we
144were talking before um an Ethics complaint you have 180 days to file an Ethics complaint anyone that wants to file it has 180 days to do it um I actually shared with um Dr gabay before I sent an email while the board meeting was starting okay so there's a reason why she has not sent that out either um because um Mrs vpy had asked me hey what does it look like basically an Ethics complaint so it was a sample ethics complaint like sample blank form that you can look at and see what it would look like process is pretty simple in the sense that when somebody wants to file an Ethics complaint they have to say who it is that which board member um violated the code of ethics which code of ethics they violated
145and then they have to provide factual evidence to support that that they send then to the SEC and then the SEC after they look over everything and they feel that everything is in order it's a complete um complaint not that they're making the decision at that point but all the information that they need is there then they reach out to the board member that the the complaint was filed against and they say okay you have a a complaint that was filed against you by so and so and this is this is the um terms of why they say that you violate it and which code of ethics you violate it you as the board member that it was filed against have about 30 days to respond to that then the SEC will look at both
146sides of that story they'll get the whole picture and that's when they make their decision so you know between that information and the sample Complaint Form that should give you a good idea about how this works so when the SEC makes the determination they're going to make determination of either there's no grounds here there's no ethics violation or they're going to say there was and if they say there was then there's four different things that they can put as like a sanction or punishment the first one would be considered a reprimand which is like a slap on the wrist where they're going to say to you yes you violated the code of ethics don't do it again and that's it the second one is a centure that is public so that's where you as a
147board have to have a resolution on your agenda naming the board member that um had the ethics complaint filed against him and it was found that they had violated it which tenants were violated and then it has to be board approved so it's very public suspension is where you've done something egregious enough where the SEC says you're not going to be on the board for x amount of time could be a week could be 30 days could be 60 days could be a year okay so they make that determination the last one is removal where the SEC says what you've done is so bad you're off the board and you can't serve again so those are the four different levels so there's 10 tenants to it and I'm going to point this out that the
148top part actually comes from statute which is NJ sa 18a the bottom part is code which is 6a so each one of the tenants has both of these the top part is telling you what you as a board member have to do or can't do the bottom part says is that if somebody has violated this this is the factual evidence that needs to be provided to support that um claim that that uh code that tenant was violated so there's 10 of them the first one is that you have to uphold and enforce all laws rules and regulations in other words you have to follow the law you might not like the law but you still have to follow it there's other avenues that you as an individual can follow or you even as a district
149can follow if you don't like a law law but saying we're not going to follow it we'll get you in hot water somebody can and will file an Ethics complaint against you and they will win the next one is decisions have to be made at this board table in the best interest of all students not just the ones you like not the ones you don't like it has to be every single student that's in your District it's not about the students or the families that believe the same thing that you do you have to know what is in the best interest of your kids and what the community really wants you to do and that's the decisions that you make the third one is you're going to make sure that you stay focused on policy
150planning and Appraisal that's your job as a board member if you deviate from that and you start to try to run the district which is the next one then once again you're going to get in trouble I I will say this if you have roles and responsibilities which we might have planned I think I'm not sure but if we do you are not the how something gets done you are the what what do we as a board what do we want to see for this District okay so we could say we want we want rigorous classes or courses being offered and I'm going to pretend you're high school uh district for a minute so in other words we want like AP courses offered that's a what that's what a board can do you can say
151we want more AP offerings you do Do not sit there and say we would like AP History 1 we would like physics 4 because now you're getting into the how the how is a superintendent in the team that's running the district so the minute you start to say this is what we specifically want you've overstepped and anyone that hears that is going to say oh they're trying to run the schools and that's not your role your job as a board member is not to make personal promises nor any private action you only get your power when you're sitting here at a publicly advertised board meeting when you have a quorum okay and when you pass resolution that is on the agenda where it actually you have enough affirmatives where it passes that's where your power
152comes from yes when you R your campaign at whatever point in time you did it you might have said to the community this is what I'm running for this is what I'm going to do guess what that's a personal promise that's not what you do okay that's not how this works as a board you have to come to an agreement on what's important that's how that works you cannot uh surrender to special interest or political groups schools are not politics yes we know Across the Nation politics are making their way into schools it's not supposed to be this is not what it's about you are here for one group only and that's the students so you shouldn't be talking about politics it the things that you're doing shouldn't be involving politics now does politics play
153a role in impacting schools absolutely laws are passed you guys were talking tonight about uh Housing Development that's being built does that come into play sure but that's not your primary focus that's for the township that's for them to handle you can share as a school district what is the impact but it's not your job to fix the problem and I know I don't know exactly because you guys were talking about the housing I was saying to your ba like are you guys talking about pilot funding that's different I don't know if that's what your housing is but if it's a pilot fund trust me that's a totally different animal okay it's not Pilots okay well that's good but it sounded like based upon what you were saying that there's a five to up to
15430 years where there's a tax abatement it kind of aligns with what a pilot is um so but I'm going to send you some information on that this to me is probably the one of the most important um tenants which is confidentiality when you're in the community you think you know what's going on in the district you don't when you're sitting at that board table you do why because you're going to be privy to a lot of information that's confidential that's one of the reasons why you go into executive session there's nine or 10 different items I always forget all of them but it's basically student issues staff issues um Safety and Security some of those um legal matters and then even like purchasing properties because it's pending litigation which is legal matters so there's
155a whole bunch but your ba and your superintendent will make sure that if you try to deviate during a regular public meeting into something that's supposed to be executive session they will tell you that the same thing is when you're in executive session if you deviate from what was on the agenda that's a no no if your agenda says legal matters that's the only thing you focus on you can't bring up something else when you're in executive session okay but that's confidential all that information that you have in that executive session stays in executive session if one of the other board members wasn't there guess what they're not priv to that information they were not part of the conversation and some board members can't be there because they might be conflicted okay so keep that
156in mind so your job is to appoint the best Personnel those Personnel will be recommended to you by your superintendent like I said before it's not your job to go through resumés but it's also important for you to know that for some positions there's not many applicants so even though it might not be the best candidate it's the best of what you could have gotten and I say like School nurses like every time you see a district where their school nurse retires or leaves it is so difficult to fill so you know in those cases you might only get one candidate um so keep that in mind that you know the superintendent has a process in place that her and her team are going through to find out who is the best candidate so when
157she's making that recommendation that's exactly what she's recommending is the best candidate that they could find your job is to support and protect School Personnel the second part of that improper performance of their duties so in other words you do not go to school Personnel you do not bash them on social media or even out in the public you do not go to the soccer field or the football field and say ah that teacher or that administrator or that superintendent or that ba that's not your job okay that's not protecting the school Personnel however if a school Personnel does something where let's say for example they get arrested and it becomes a big issue and it's in the news and all that do you have to protect them not necessarily however you also can't bash
158them so you still are silent and and I will use the words my mother has always taught me which was if you can't say something nice then don't say anything at all as I said if you can't say something nice shut up okay because it's if you bash that school Personnel then you've violated this ethic so make sure you don't refer all complaints to the chief administrative officer it is not your job as a board member to fix issues that come to you yes you should be listening to your community members that is part of your job as a board member when they come to you with those concerns by all means you can sit there and you can listen not say yes yes I agree don't do that because now you're speaking on behalf
159of the board you can say thank you for sharing that then your job is to redirect them to the proper level on the chain of Comm nine times out of 10 that is the classroom teacher and you actually heard that tonight you actually did it exactly what should have been done where the the one parent was saying about you know the programming and you said go go tell your classroom teacher that's redirecting someone to the chain of command yeah I was goingon to say you know I think she was like prepping me for this I was it was like perfect um your job then also is to tell the superintendent though you can say like Mrs Jones came to me with this concern I redirect it Mrs Jones to the classroom teacher but I just
160want to make you aware that's it your hands are done you've done all that you're supposed to do as a board member it's her job to fix the problem okay so these are going to be cases that are related to the code of ethics you'll notice that these are ethics complaints when you see the C when you see the letter A that means it's an advisory opinion once again these are all hyperlink so and and just like the other ones I'm not going to go through all of them but this gives you an idea in the first case a board member felt a staff member personally attacked him at board meetings so we called her principal remember the one I just said about protecting staff members okay your community and that can include staff members
161that are in your District can come to your board meetings and they can bash you that's the wonderful thing about the job that you all elected to do okay you are on the firing squad you are the front and center of complaints you cannot then try to stop them from coming to the board meeting which is essentially what this case is about so if you do that then that will result rightfully so in an Ethics complaint you'll see that it says censure so that was an example of a case where uh the SEC said because of this that board member has now been censured you'll notice it just has the word censure and the reason for that is because there's a two-step process for this for the Seca when they look at a case they
162make a determination and they say it might say recommend it or recommend censure they're step one once they do that recommendation all that information along with the recommendation go to the commissioner of Education the commissioner of education then makes their determination on that same case they may agree with the SEC they might modify it when you see just the word censure that means it's been through both levels it's final there's no there's no changing of this so in this case it was a censure if this said recommended censure that would mean that the SEC heard it and it's now in the hands of the commissioner and that could change and we do see sometimes where these change not only change they change for the worse um I had a district recently I was talking with
163they had a board member that was recommend it uh suspension and then the next thing I know it was termination they were removed and I was like whoa what how'd that happen well it happened because the commissioner of Education felt that it was so egregious that they had to go and so that's exactly what happened so the next case is um a board member was involved in ongoing efforts to reverse an Hib and code of conduct violation in her child's record so you got to remember as a board member yes you probably are also a parent or a grandparent not always but a lot of times you are your your child may be involved in HIV case or some kind of disciplinary case if that happens you should remove yourself recuse yourself from that and
164not be in the discussion at all and you should not be influencing or trying to influence any of the board members if you do then you're going to find yourself that you were in hot water use something called common sense when you're in these meetings if you're in executive session and a case comes up and you weren't aware that it was you're going to be your child's case though the superintendent and the ba probably do but if that slips through the crack and you start to hear the casing you know what yours get up and say I'm sorry I didn't realize this is my child I'm accusing myself and step out and let them do their thing okay that's how you'll say safe this resulted in a reprimand uh this case a teacher was to
165be discussed in executive session a board member sent a text message to the teacher so they basically circumvented the superintendent and ba and they act the content of that uh text message to the teacher was hey did you get riced because if he didn't get riced I can make an issue of this and create a problem for the superintendent so your job as a board member is to never contact staff member also it would be an executive session which means it's confidential which means you shouldn't be sharing what's going to happen in executive session with anybody so this was a recommended reprimand in this case uh you had a 15 plus Year Board member took inappropriate action that was beyond the role of a board member this is roles and responsibilities 101 this is a
166lot of these cases will have something to do with uh a board member overstepping into the role of running the district and that was a recommended suspension of 60 days so it gives you an idea that this was pretty uh seen as pretty bad this one is a board member recorded an endorsement video for a slate of three board candidates that referenced the board and the members position on it while wearing a school identification band badge so this gives you an idea that it's okay to say you know or or endorse somebody or whatever during elections however you you got to remember that now that you're sitting on this board that is being perceived by the community as you are speaking on behalf of the board and you're not you can't it's in your your
167bylaws that there's only one spokesperson for the board and that's the board president the board president cannot speak on behalf of the board if the full board hasn't had a discussion about whatever it is they're going to talk about so they don't have the cart blanch to say what they feel it has to be what the unanimous board feels so understand that um you have to be very careful when you're supporting any kind of candidate for any position and there's a lot of intricacies within that case so it was brought up before about recusal and exstension when you're sitting here and you have an agenda item before you if you do not have enough information that's when you abstain okay perfect example is your brand new board member you're approving the minutes from the previous
168board meetings that you weren't even here for okay being a member of the community is not the same as being a board member that is a perfect example of when you're going to say I abstain it could also be um an agenda item that you really just didn't have enough information about you didn't read let's say it's your fault you didn't read enough okay you were given the information you didn't read it um so you have to make sure that you have enough information and that's the only time if you don't that you abstain you do not abstain when it's a controversial agenda item and you want to avoid being looked at by your community where they say oh so so and so vote it that way on it that's not what the exstension is
169for sadly that is used by some board members in some districts to avoid any kind of controversy a recusal means that you are not permitted to vote on that agenda item because you may have a conflict of interest so say for example um you're a we'll use negotiations you're a teacher in another district and you're part of a union and there's an agenda item to approve the contract you might have to recuse yourself because you cannot based upon the conflict of interest you're not allowed to vote on it but by saying recuse you're telling your community being very transparent and saying as much as I may know the information or not know the information as much as I may want to vote on this item I'm legally not permitted to to order to understand whether
170you are conflicted or not you're going to give your specific information to your board attorney to make that determination okay these are a list of prohibited acts so if you fall within any of these like you're getting a you're getting a gift from or a favor or something from some group you should be recusing yourself because that's a conflict of interest benefit benefit and this is sometimes um debated people say yeah but I didn't really benefit from whatever it was it's not always about whether you actually benefited from whatever the item was it could be the perception that people believe you benefited from it if somebody believes that you benefited from it then that can create a problem for you so that's a case where if you have the perception you think the perception will
171be out there in the community that you're benefiting because people know you have a tie to something then you should just recuse yourself these are conflict benefit cases I'm not going into these but once again you see recommend it reprimand recommend it censure that's because it's only been through the SEC so far relationships relationships are actually going to be what causes your conflicts if you have any of these people these different groups in working in the district or even in another District that could create a conflict of interest for you when you are on the board and that includes the ba and the superintendent or actually sorry not the ba the superintendent you are not allowed to hire your family members doesn't matter if you have 100 family members already working in the district that's
172okay because they're already there however when you get on the board you cannot hire any of your family members or relatives because that will that is not permitted and it actually creates a conflict of interest because now you're allowing somebody to be hired there are a limited exceptions and I I'll go back to the nurse as an example let's say the only person the one person that applied for the position was for the nurse was happened to be a family member of a relative of one of your board members in that case the superintendent can make um a request of the executive County super inant to ask for a waiver who then will give some guidance on the process that she needs to do might be to advertise again so on and so forth and
173then as a result they can allow that waiver for that one time doesn't mean that now every time you know you can get another family member in it's those unique cases and they do not happen often so this is collective bargaining and this is the case that I was referring to before it's cited up here on the top so in this case the media family member they work in the district they are a non-aligned employee can you participate in negotiations notice it says yes yes with an asri that's because like I said that case gives that out if you can show that there's no connection at all between that non-aligned employees um increases versus what the contract for the aligned employees or the ones that are in a union it doesn't happen often it's very
174hard to prove so therefore chances are that's going to be the same as the next one which is no no okay if you work in the district if you have a family member I mean that works in the district and they are part of the uh a union in the district you cannot be participating in negotiations meaning you can't be there for it you also can't be in the discussions about where the negotiations are going and you cannot even vote for the ratification of the contract the rationale for that is the way it always works and this is just the reality is that if if I'm in this district and let's say I'm I'm on the board and I have a family member that's working in this district and we give you a really good
175contract the next District over is going to look at what your settlement was and they're going to point to that and say who hey we want what they had and so that's why you as a board member when you're inflict it you can't be involved in the negotiations because even though you're not necessarily benefiting you might have a relative in another District that will benefit from the settlement here so um self immedia family member not working in the district that's what I was just talking about but yet they're part of a union that's another reason why you're not going to be able to participate in negotiations however once all that is done and you have a final agreement before you that's when you can vote because you weren't involved in creating that it's just the
176end product and then the last one is if you don't have a relative who doesn't work in the district and you don't have a relative that's in any kind of Union you can be involved in negotiations I was just in a district where four of their board members out of nine don't fall within this so only four of them fall here so they only have four people on their entire nine member board that can be involved in negotiations the other five are all conflicted so this is serious if you have family members that relatives that are working in um a position in another District or this District yep yep yep no but once they become so when you initially started negotiations you were not conflicted because they were not part of a union and then
177all of a sudden three months later you're already you're involved in negotiations all of a sudden they become um part of a union somewhere else and it creates a conflict for you that's when you'd have to step out and it goes the other way too let's say you were initially conflicted because you had a member that or a family member that was working and created the conflict for you however two months into negotiations that person is not employed anymore okay can you then become part of negotiations absolutely you could because that that has changed and I was working with a district where that that's actually what happened they had a family member um that created many conflicts for it's actually one of these cases and as a result they were and they were the board
178president they weren't allowed to be involved in all these different areas that person was no longer in the district all of a sudden all those conflicts went away and they were able to be part of the uh superintendent evaluation so on and so forth all the things that they weren't allowed to be part of so yes it changes so if your particular situation changes once again share that immediately with your board attorney and then they can guide you on what you should or shouldn't do okay yep oh way back okay no nope nope because once again it doesn't become public unless um there's a finding and that that even like a reprimand isn't necessarily going to become public either I mean it will because they'll publish the case because it's an ethic complaint but it's
179not public in the sense of within your community somebody would actually have to be looking at the cases which the reality is most people are not looking at all these cases okay yep I don't care whichever one um there isn't isn't and the reason I say that is because there could be but once again it's going to the uh School ethics commission would have to look at the case and say this was truly frivolous there's no there's no ounce of um credibility to their claim and in that case if they found that then they could actually Levy a fine I think it's $500 or $300 to that person that filed the frivolous claim however they would have to look at that case and and feel it was frivolous that's a that's a new thing that
180came out um I haven't heard that it's actually happened yet so I don't know if there's any teeth to that or if it's just you know something that has been put in place you um if you file an Ethics uh complaint against someone how long is it from the day you file it to when they would receive it it could be a little while um you know the wheels of the state don't move fast um but generally out it wouldn't be like within a week it would be no it probably be 30 to 60 days would be my guess it could be longer it depends once again is your is the initial filing made by the person was it complete did did the SEC feel that the initial filing was complete if it wasn't then
181they're going to kick it back to you and say hey you who filed this there's not enough information here um so that would extend that time frame even even if if the um uh situation was regious or something bad it would still be that amount of time yeah like the severity of the case isn't going to change them speeding it along no no because you got to remember they're getting a lot of these cases so they're looking one after another there's no one that's looking through them and saying well this is like you know a red level this is a yellow level they're not doing that they're going Case by case as they come in and that's why they're all actually numbered when you look at all the cases like c1024 it tells you exactly
182you know when that case was received received and and reviewed and so they kind of give it a number tells you the year the month all that so that gives you an idea that that case was 10 which is October of 2024 so so like you can read all these like next one is October of that's an advisory opinion because it's an a advisory opinion of October 2018 yep and then um from last year I can't remember what you had said if someone does something bad whatever it is is there a time frame that you could report like let's say it's five months ago and some lady's like you know what I'm going to report that one for doing that 180 days0 days okay of course it's not the one I thought it was right
183there but it's not there it is so it's 180 day window okay and so it's from the time that the person committed the alleged offense and so there's 100 there's a half a year basically where somebody can file it so they can't go back two years from like prior and say two years ago you did this and because I watched the board meeting that was recorded and I saw that it's too late so um the only time the SEC would allow something to happen multiple years ago is if there's a pattern of it meaning that you did it two years ago and then you did it again you know a year ago and now it's 180 days you just did it again and so that in that case when they're filing it they may file
184those other two that fell outside that window because they're connected to the current claim and so the SEC would look at it that way but that one would have to be within the window otherwise they won't even look at it that answer it yes thank you okay all right so this is just uh campaigns and collective bargaining agreements um this is once again and I said this in one of the cases where if you're receiving uh Financial contributions for your campaign that's where it's going to create a conflict for you and generally your recommendation will be that you do not become involved in anything for the first year so this is the case that I was talking about this was um a board member and this is the first one is actually two different board
185members in the same district the first one was a board president they had a child that was an instructional assistant that person's situation has changed from when this ruling came out which then changed this and where she's she actually is the board president again because I just talked to her yet this morning she all these areas that she was not allowed to be part of she's now can be part of because her situation changed so her conflict changed but as a result because her child was in the district she as a board president was not allowed to be involved in anything to do with Personnel anything to do with negotiations nothing in curriculum instruction and nothing in the finance which kind of took her out of a lot of things and if you think about
186it you're also the board president what is one of your jobs crash question you just got it right I'm not going to be on the spot but you appoint all the other board members to committees she's not able to do that either because she can't be involved in any of those committees so really took away a lot of the responsibility of the board president as a result of this conflict of interest in that same board there The Other Board member had a family member that worked in the technology department and as a result they were not allowed to be involved in any anything with Personnel negotiations or the finance committee the last case is a newer case and that one is um a board members domestic partner was a transportation specialist so they were recommended
187not to be involved in any agenda item that had to do with Transportation so let's say it was you know approving the transportation company that the district used they weren't able to be part of that the advice of council um you have to actually hit all four of these in order to make a claim as a board member that hey I didn't do anything wrong it's the attorney's fault because the attorney gave me the advice okay that may or may not be true you have to make sure that first of all the attorney that you're talking to was actually the attorney you're supposed to be talking to in other words they're approved to be the person that you are talking to you also have to be that the the individual that's offering this um is
188somebody who you were even supposed to be talking to because remember as an individual board member you do not to have the right to call up the board attorney in your bylaws it will stipulate that it's usually the ba the the B um superintendent and the board president okay your bylaws may be different go read them but that's nine times out of 10 that's what a district has so if you as an individual board member need to talk to the board attorney about a situation that's when you ask basically permission and then they will give you the approval now there's a financial reason for that as well well as many other things the financial reason is every time somebody talks to the board attorney it costs money so it's a way of limiting how much
189money is being spent on attorney fees because there is a cap that a district cannot go over and if they do you talked about before with a corrective action plan guess what you're going to be on a corrective action plan okay so it has to be all that and just like I said with the um when you're looking for an advisory opinion you have to give all the information so you when you're asking you know a board attorney for advice you have to give the board attorney all the information if you withheld something then that's not going to fly in terms of using this as a defense and the last one is the individual actually abided by what the board attorney said okay you can say the board attorney said this but they may not
190have and so you have to be able to prove that what they said is what you followed as board members volunteering yes you can volunteer in a school you can become involved but make sure how often you're there is curbed so you're not in the buildings all the time otherwise you give the impression that you're running the district also you should never be in a position where you're volunteering where you're have Authority or perceived authority over staff members says once again if you do that that's going to create problems that's also just detailing a little more information about volunteering social media social media as we as you brought up before during the board meeting you know screen time well guess what as adults you're probably worse than the kids okay because we're all on the
191phone and you know a lot of phones will tell you hey you your your screen time is increased by X number percent today or this week so social media is a big part of that screen time for adults that are sitting on a board when there's going to be a complaint about something that's on social media they're going to be looking at the content of what was posted they're going to look at the substance of what's posted and the context of how it's posted nine they look for what they call a Nexus which is a connection nine times out of 10 if you were talking about board business on social media you are going to get yourself in trouble because that's not where it's supposed to be happening it's supposed to be happening here at
192the board table that's where board business is discussed so in other words keep your social media for your private fun stuff nothing to do with the district nothing to do with board business if you do post on social media it is the SEC suggests that you use that disclaimer which basically says you're speaking as a private individual and that you're not speaking on behalf of the board do you have to use this this disclaimer no but it's going to help you if you do if you don't use it you're going to automatically get in trouble no because it's going to actually be more important based upon the content of what you post and if your content has to do with board business that's where you're going to get in trouble whether you're using the disclaimer
193or not which is what this is a Q&A on all those different combinations so social media General guidance if you used a social media platform when you were running for the board you should not be using it anymore not for posting anything to do with board business and you may say well you know I disagree with that that's fine but notice this is not me that's saying it this is actually an Ethics complaint that was filed that was founded and the person had the res uh ending result from it and it's funny because that that case is like I think eight pages long and that part where it talks about that you should not be using it is on like page six of it so you had to wait read through five full Pages before
194you actually get to the point where it's saying don't use it um so that's an important part of that the account that uh if you have an account that's actually somewhere on it says that you a board member anything that you post is going to be perceived as being something based upon board business or based upon uh what the board feels and once again you're not a spokesperson for the board you should not be talking about that stuff you can like or share things and um the administrator if you administrator of social media Pages you have to make sure that um you are responsible for the content that's on there so if somebody's posting something about board business and you're the administrator of it you're going to be held liable for it and that was
195my last slide thank you for the wonderful high paid job you're doing any questions yep nope you are you are a parent you should be going to those parent teacher conferences because number one thing is you are an advocate for your child however when you go do not go in there and say I'm so and so I'm on the board because now you're using your position to influence that or intimidate that staff member so like I always suggest that when you go in to talk to a even if it's like because of a disciplinary issue whatever it is do not go in there and say well I'm a board member once you that those leave your mouth just overstep the line so don't do that um don't look for any special you know um accommodations
196for like schedules or anything like that because you're a board member you're just like any other parent but yes you absolutely can go in there and do all those things Class party that's fine to do be part of just once again don't go in there don't handle money um and don't you know don't be telling the teach what to do yep and that's was a good point volunteers they colle money for things yeah it's an awesome way for you as a board member to get out of doing that part and like in some districts where they have like a high school and they have a football the you know the the parents and me might work to Snack Shack guess what you can work it but you don't have to handle any of the money
197you can make the hot dogs you can serve it but you shouldn't be handling any of the money and it's not because you're going to steal it but there's that perception that if money is missing you could be accused of it and you don't want to put the district in that position leave that up to somebody else anything else all right e e for