CorpusRecord 132937

Monroe Township Board of Education 02.19.25 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-20
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
20,852 words · about 116 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening everyone it is Wednesday February 19th 2025 it is the Monro Township Board of Education monthly meeting can everybody please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance got it I pledge Al to the FL of the United States of America and to the repblic for it stands one nation under God indivisible liberty and justice for all Miss alen can we have a roll call please Miss Alvarez here miss Bora Miss Dean here miss Fabiano here Dr P here Mr Piro here M Ratner here miss Sharma Mr Tano Mr zeichner here we have aarum in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the monor Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published an electronic notice provided by having the dat time and place thereof posted October

00225th 2024 February 7th 2025 and February 11th 2025 at all schools on the district website the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of M thank you our next item on the agenda is our closed session resolution whereas the senator Byron M Bear open public meetings act and JSA 10 colum 4-6 provides that the Monro Township Board of Education May hold an executive session from which the public public is excluded to discuss matters that are confidential or are one of the nine subject matters listed in section 12b of the act and whereas the board hereby declares that its decision of the following subjects will be made public at a time when the Public's interest in disclosure is greater than any privacy or governmental Interest being protected from disclosure now therefore be it

003resolved by the Monro Township Board of Education that the board shall go into executive session to discuss the following items additional items may be determined and announced as needed uh pending or anticipating litigation matters covered by attorney privilege matters involving employees in terms of their employment have investigation involving students be it further resolved that said discussion may be disclosed to the public when reasons for discussing and acting upon it in closed session no longer exist action may be taken on any of the items stated above is there a motion motion second second all those in favor I I the board will return in approximately 1 hour around 7:15 ladies and gentlemen also in executive session okay we are back from closed session there is no action being taken so we are moving on to the

004next item on our agenda which is the approval of minutes um the first approval is for our public Board of Education meeting minutes January 15 2025 motion second second motion by Mr Zer second by Miss depay are there any questions all those in favor I I any abstentions or recusals okay seeing none then the next one is our Clos session meeting minutes for January 15 2025 is there a motion motion second motion by Miss Alvarez second by Miss tan any questions any extensions or recusals all those in favor I I okay um the next item on our agenda is our student board members report welcome back ladies thank you so much good evening everyone um hope you all are staying warm so we'll start off with Barkley book Brook's updates uh Barkley Brook Elementary School

005celebrated the 100th day of school with the schoolwide spirit week culminating with the 100th day of school which is on Tuesday February 18th on the 100th day of school they were invited to dress as if they were hundred years old or wear a themed shirt Barkley Brooks Community Committee organized a Valentine's Day C drive for the residents at Monroe's local assisted living facilities with the hope that this small act of kindness would spread love support and compassion to many members of this community students colored pictures and wrote heartfelt notes to the residents Barkley Brook collected hundreds of Valentines and they were able to distribute them to four assisted living facilities in their Community Brookside connected their schoolwide spelling be on January 28th the winner for this Belling be was yosa nund from Mrs Dar Carlo's

006fifth grade class congratulations from the student council the 100 Days theme day was held from February 10th to February 18th and the 100th day was on February 18th the student council organized a coin Wars fundraiser for the California wildfires we raised over $2,300 thank you to the students involved the students earned a variety of Awards this month for displaying Great Character which included board games with Mr Sidler podcast and audio books with Mrs Lynn guitar with Mr akam Vado and soccer with Mrs cine parent teacher conferences will be held on February 19th and February 20th with evening conferences being held on February 20th next up is MIL Lake Elementary School uh February has been a busy and exciting month at mil Lake mil Lake kicked off the month with their 1,000 box Domino serial Box

007challenge on Valentine's Day and it was a huge success students and staff work together to build an incredible Domino chain before donating the Cal boxes to the Monroe food pantry local churches and Senior Cent centers spreading kindness and generosity throughout their Community adding to the spirit of giving mil lak's third grade student council led a super bull collection in the days leading up to the Super Bowl Gathering much needed donations for the Monroe food pantry their hard work and dedication made a real impact the month also featured the exciting PTO book fair from February 4th to 6th where mil Lake breeders eagerly selected new books to enjoy the event also included a special Woodland mil Lake family night bringing families together to celebrate the joy of reading during the week of February 4th mil Lake

008welcomed Dental Professionals for educational visits teaching students the importance of oral hygiene through engaging and interactive lessons in honor of President's Day students partic participated in a variety of educational activities that highlighted the achievements and Legacies of past US presidents these lessons helped deepen their understanding of history and Leadership on February 18th mil Lake celebrated a major Milestone the 100th day of school students and staff took part in fun and creative activities making the day both memorable and meaningful throughout the month mil lak's SE social emotional learning committee Focus has been kindness and mil Lakers have truly embed this theme mil lake is excited to highlight and celebrate acts of kindness during the upcoming monthly assembly reinforcing the importance of compassion and Community spirit this week they are hosting their winter conferences providing a valuable

009opportunity for teachers and parents to collaborate in support of Student Success next month the school is gearing up for re Across America with the theme March mystery Madness the excitement begins on March 4th when the school genre study starts featuring special guest readers leaders from the community and from District leadership a highlight of the celebration will be a visit from renowned author David a Adler best known for his Cam Jansen book series festivities are capped off with the Beloved annual night of reading on March 13th they can't wait for another month filled with learning literacy and school spirit stay tuned for more updates and exciting events at mil Lake and now we're moving on to Woodland Elementary School Woodland School has had its script spelling be families of the classroom winners were invited to attend

010as well the school winner overall was vajde Saha this seal character goal assembly of friendship was held and top winners were treated to a free snack in the cafeteria in partnership with the Monro Township High School Woodland students has Woodland unified students participated in a unified event the PTO held a book fair for Woodland students and a family night with Milik families Mrs Herman and Miss Fleming coordinated a wounded warriors assembly as well well next up is Oak Tree Elementary School Oak Tree students raised over $16,000 as part of their kids heart challenge to support the American Heart Association and they celebrated with a dance party during the monthly pep rally grade three students and their parents attended the annual hour of code night on February 6th local dentists visited oak tree classes as part

011of dental health month teaching ways to care for students teeth and proper brushing grade 2 students participated in the second and seven program high school athletes visited the classes and read to them oak trees PTA is hosting a sweetheart dance on February the 22nd and unified paint night will take place on February 26th and now we'll move on to Applegarth Elementary School throughout Applegarth class has worked on Valentine's for veterans during the month of February and Applegarth has also hosted a career fair on February 4th several members from the school Community volunteered their time discussing working fields in such as as Law Public Health artificial intelligence and Entrepreneurship thank you to the community members and participating students the PTA sponsoring a February frenzy classes compete in activities such as Sports Jersey day wear red day

012hat day and pajama day to win prizes while helping to fund St school activities this kids for heart challenge concluded on February 13th classes participated in healthy heart healthy activities in the gym after raising thousands of dollars for a worthy cause parent teacher conferences will be held at Applegarth on Wednesday February 20th Thursday February 21st the remainder of this week will be early dismissal for students as well our PTA is hosting a sweetheart formal on Saturday February 22nd come out for a fun evening Applegarth and Oak Tree are hosting a unified paint night on Wednesday February 26th at Oak Tree School sophomores from Monro Township High School former appleg guard students have been presenting a public speaking class class to current aard students on Tuesday afternoons after school the high schoolers are teaching the students

013about impromptu speaking how to appear confident answering questions with poise at job interviews and many other valuable skills another high schooler is sponsoring a recycling program at Applegarth during February and March the class that collects the most batteries for recycling will win a pizza party next up is mro Township Middle School congratulations to the mtms math team for placing third in in the math counts competition on February 1st the two top scorers were Akil venat and Kean vnav February 21st at mtms will hold its seventh grade winter white out dance they are looking forward to seeing the seventh graders have a great time in a more social environment February 10th through the 14th um the middle school held its annual week of optimism this week celebrated the life of om perq and his cont contributions

014to the middle school they promote kindness optimism and culminate the week with a day of optimism on Friday the 14th where 's family visits the school to see the efforts made on 's behalf on March 6th and 7th mtms will hold its American Heart association's American Heart challenge the goals of the challenge are multifaceted including being prepared to Save a Life by learning handson CPR learning how to take care of their heart and brain and raising funds to help kids born with special hearts on February 18 the middle school held its annual Honors Society induction ceremony parents of seventh and eighth graders celebrated with the middle school as they watch their children inducted into the Honor Society everyone at the middle school like their parents are very proud of them congratulations to the January students

015of the month for the Middle School in sixth grade Elijah Zachary in seventh grade sahana rames and in e8th grade Noah mcalli and now finally we're moving on to the monra Township's High School many important Sports compl accomplishments have happened this month for the students the wrestling team won their first ever State sectional title in Monroe Township history defeating the favorite Oldbridge High School 34 to 31 the ice hockey team has also defeated Oldbridge coming back from two goals down to win their second colog cup the GMC championship in a row Evangelina Francisco has led her team to a GMC tournament win becoming Monro Township High School's all-time leading scorer in girls basketball history Steven Barbara won the state sectionals in a 3200 meter race for indoor track running a personal best time as well

016Steven's time is considered Elite and a gold standard by mil split us congratulations to all of these amazing athletes and their accomplishments thank you thank you thank [Applause] you thank you very much as always for your comprehensive report um the next item on our agenda is a presentation from EIP it's for the Energy savings Improvement plan um last month we had begun talking about this and we as a board said that we would like to have them come and give the presentation to the public so we do have representatives from Honeywell that are here um and we also have our bond Council present so um I'm going to hand it over to you sir thank you can you hear okay thank you very much appreciate it uh appreciate the opportunity to be here tonight to

017present to all of you the board and the public about the great project that we feel we put together for Monroe Schools and uh under the EIP program which is the Energy savings Improvement program which we will talk a little bit about as we go through this so appreciate the opportunity to be here first of all my name is sha Yates I'm a sales leader for Honeywell uh been working in the state of New Jersey for some time with my team over here uh conducting similar projects to this within school districts all through New Jersey so here we go okay so in terms of the program that we're working under we're working under the Energy savings Improvement program which is legislation that was passed back in 2012 by the state of New Jersey the the

018program itself is as I said put together by the state and it's administered by the Board of Public Utilities in New Jersey so that's a department of the government and we work with them in the development of these projects to make sure we're going through a solid process and they actually have some checks and balances throughout it the legislation itself was originally implemented within the state of New Jersey in order to help public entities to implement energy conservation projects with no taxpayer impact and that's because the Energy savings themselves are used to pay for the project over time so in terms of how the project works and how the funding is set up you can see here on the slide so there if if we walk into a building such as or a district such

019as Monro Monroe School District the first thing that we do is we look at and assess your profile from a a cost perspective so that's before the improvements that you see on the Le hand side of the screen here we determined that the cost associated with utilities in the mono School District was about $2 million after going through and and identifying opportunities to improve the buildings and improve the efficiency as well as the the classrooms the educational facilities Etc we were able to identify ways to reduce the costs within the buildings reduce the utility costs by $800,000 and in doing so we're actually improving at the same time improving the facilities for the the students and staff and improving the educational environment so some of the pro some of the benefits of this program are

020first of all the fact that there's no upfront cost associated with an EIT program so we do all the work to develop the project on our own up front we then then go forward and we can actually identify and leverage any available utility rebates that we might be able to F that we might be able to find within the state of New Jersey and there's also no debt limit impact because we're actually using the budget that you're spending today so the key takeaway from this slide is if you look at the fact that the pi doesn't change size right the budget that you have today is shown on the leftand side before improvements is the same size as the budget that you have after the improvements on the right hand side the difference is instead

021of sending the $2 million to the utility company now you send $1.2 million to the utility company and $800,000 to the finding Finance year or funding entity in order to refund that payment as far as the the implementation of the project Honeywell actually does the implementation ourselves so we're responsible for developing designing implementing overseeing the project so the project is our responsib ility from the very beginning to the very end working in partnership with this with the board and the school district in order to to ensure that we're achieving their goals at the end of the project we do offer a guarantee so that the board has the option to take that guarantee that's always available and required under the esip legislation so in terms of utility senses within this project that we put together

022for for the Monroe School Town Township uh project what we're able to identify is over $600,000 worth of of utility incentives so that $600,000 is helping to offset the cost of the project for the the school district in terms of the process as I mentioned earlier we have to go through this this EIP process and it's actually it's actually overseen by the Board of Public Utilities there's a very rigid structure to it to make sure that we're we're doing there's checks and balances throughout first thing that we have to do is after we develop all our Energy savings calculations and what we call an energy savings plan that details out how we're actually going to improve the facilities and generate these Energy savings we have to submit that to a third-party engineer the third party

023engineer then takes that information and they actually will will ultimately go through all of our calculations make sure that they're all done in accordance with the standards that have been set by the state and that they agree with the fact that we that we will actually generate the savings that we're projecting so we did go through that process and we were successful in gaining their approval once that's complete we have to take both that that review that was done by the third party Engineers sorry once that's complete we take the review that was that was done by the third party engineer and we put that together with the Energy savings plan we submit that to the Board of Public Utilities and the Board of Public Utilities that the state actually reviews all that information and

024then they approve the plan and they've done that as well you can see actually the approval email is in the uh upper right here touch you uh as far as the scope of work goes so this is a great project that we've developed we we really feel you know very proud of the fact that we can implement this with no cost to the taxpayers and ultimately these are the the different energy conservation measures that we've identified and worked in conjunction with the school district to select to move forward on so those projects include districtwide lighting so there will be new lighting both in the classrooms exterior to the building throughout the entire District we're looking to upgrade the control systems and the building management systems within the high school the Middle School Administration building as

025well as Transportation building and that's obsolete there's obsolete equipment there today so we'll be replacing that upgrading and implementing new control strategies for efficiency we'll be replacing boilers in the middle school and barlay Brook and then in terms of building envelope the idea of building envelope is essentially insulation what we want to do is we want to actually seal the buildings so that outside air can't get into the buildings and in doing so it makes the the buildings more comfortable reduces drafts and it helps to improve the educational environment in general as well as save energy so we'll be doing that throughout the district from an HVAC perspective so the heating ventilating and air conditioning equipment within the district a handful of it will be replaced through this process you can see it will be

026replaced we'll be replacing rooftop units at the TV studio we'll be replacing two air handling units at the lecture hall an a kitchen air handling unit in the Middle School homec air handling unit in the Middle School uh and then a couple of rooms you can see there room 100 will'll have a couple of units replaced in the middle school as well from a chiller perspective so this is the equipment that actually cools the buildings and helps to to produce air conditioning within the facilities will'll be replacing the chillers in both Woodland and baray Brook and then finally solar so the solar aspect of this project is is a power purchase agreement that we help to facilitate and that power purchase agreement will actually ensure that the district gets a lower rate for their utilities

027than they're paying today and it will also implement solar in all the schools that you see here so appleg bar Clay Middle oak tree Woodland as well as transportation and admin building and there'll be a canopy solar system at the high school so the solar not only reduces obviously it's renewable so reducing your greenhouse gas production but at the same time it's saving money because you get a better utility rate than what you're spending today with your utility in in the local area from a financial perspective you can see the financials of the project laid out here key takeaway here is capital contribution is zero um the project itself is $12.1 million over the term of the project we are projecting that it will generate $4.1 billion in Energy savings we're looking at a so

028a a solar I'm sorry a utility rebate incentive of $664,000 to help offset cost and the so that I just spoke of that will actually save $4.6 million over the course of the term so the 15-year term based upon a A reduced utility rate there is positive cash flow to the project and there is an optional energy guarantee as I had mentioned earlier where we're at in the process today in the schedule moving forward so today we are currently in we just finished phase one which is development of the project we are starting phase two which is essentially secure funding and then move forward with design we'll then be moving into phase three which will be the the bidding and securing of all the work that will complete in January or I'm sorry June of

0292025 and then we're looking at about an 18-month construction cycle from June through November of 26 and then we move on to to the ongoing measurement and verification guarantee period if you so choose we really appreciate the opportunity to work with the board the school district the administration and everyone to put this project together we feel that it'll have a great impact for all the all of the students and staff within the community as well as the board and obviously help the PX spers as well appreciate the opportunity to present thank you thank you very much for that presentation um I also do want to thank Mr tag uh for being here tonight we appreciate your presence also and um the I want to start off with the board does the board have any questions

030that they would like to ask at this point otherwise we're going to open it up to the public Miss Ratner um yes thank you I just had two questions um I guess I'll direct it this way um so my first question is regarding the the rebates and incentives um so from what I understand those are the rebates and incentives that are available as of today is there any situation where these incentives rebates are no longer available while we move through the project and I guess in a positive manner would there be a potential chance that there would be additional opportunities for those sure I this is working okay yeah so as far as the rebates go they are actually um the rebates are from the utility company they are renewed on an annual basis it's

031it's these are programs that have been around for many many years so could they change yes we certainly don't expect them to change though and there's actually more opportunity that we're looking at as we're going through this process so that there's some grants that are potentially out there as well as there's there's a lot of changes happening to the rebate program right now and there's potential to bring forward something called direct install which is another opportunity to save uh costs and and to get help to expedite work and and offset some of those costs so as we go through the project what we have today you know the project that the scope that we've put together that's kind of locked in but certainly we are always looking for as honey well we're always looking for

032opportunities to help our customers to to get more done within their districts and to help offset more costs so that'll be something we'll continue to look for thank you um and then I just had one um just quick followup um regarding the guarantee I know we spoken about it as our you our committee and then as the full board but because we are having the hearing for the public today I was hoping you could just explain a little bit more so the you know the public can understand what the guarantee is you know on the presentation and like how it would kick in when it like how it wouldn't kick in until a certain threshold and things of that nature sure so I'll do my best to explain high level and then I might turn

033it over to my team to get into the details so U as far as the guarantee goes uh so what we guarantee is we guarantee energy consumption so what we do is we look at your actual consumption day and then we we establish a Baseline and then we basically after so then we do our implementations and then we look at the consumption at that point and we compare it against the Baseline so that we can compare the two if there if we do not actually generate the the savings of consumption that we had that we had projected then we will pay you for for that differential based upon the rate that's identified today because we have to kind of we have to lock everything in at one point in time so we lock everything in

034based upon today's today's structure and then we basically pay the difference if if we happen to um so if we do happen to have a shortfall which is happens it's it's it's unusual right very unusual and and if there is a shortfall it's generally very honestly very insignificant in the grand scheme of things um but if we do we would then also have the opportunity to come in and make further improvements to get you up to the level of savings that we that we had guaranteed so that that's kind of the two remedies is either we pay you or we come in and we improve do further improvements to get you to the level that we had guaranteed uh but it is actually you know consumption is what we look at so I don't know

035anybody wants to add anything to that good okay hopefully that answers question Mr P the the guarantee has there been could you tell us how many times you had to pay the guarantee out so I I mean we we've been doing performance Contracting as it's referred to nationally and and globally really we've been doing this type of work for since like the mid 80s so in reality I I can't tell you like exactly how many times we've had payouts um I will tell you it's happened and and we we have um we have a running tab within our business that that accounts for these things but it's generally over the I guess that's what 40 Years of doing this I think we run in like the I'll use a wide range because I'm not exactly

036sure but it's like 2 to 5% is is you know where we would ever have a payout in in that range so it's generally very low low payouts when they do occur because you know ultimately um there's there's different ways to look at it some of it is you got to look at your breakdown of Energy savings where the Energy savings are coming from because some energy conservation measures are going to be less risky than others right so you kind of balance all of that when you're when you should be considering the guarantee in itself to see how much risk there is in actually producing the savings I mean for instance a lighting upgrade the lighting is generally low risk is the reality of it right because it's it's a known quantity for the most

037part so if you if you look at things from that perspective it should help you gauge um the risk level that you're at okay thank you sure any other questions um I just I just one good um how many projects of this nature have you been implementing honey well have have done so so um he's Whispering next to me um 50 plus New Jersey I mean I will tell you that you know I I work uh globally for honey well we we do we've done we talk about the fact that we've done over 6,000 projects um but we've been doing this for 40 years so we've done a lot uh 50 in the state of New Jersey since the legislation was available which is like 2012 thank you anybody else okay so then the next

038portion of this is the public hearing on the bond ordinance so I'm going to open this up to the public if anybody would like to come up to speak on the fond ordinance just talk about the bond itself do you sure please sure um good evening everyone I'm Jackie shanus from Accord in English I'm Bond counsel is it on is that better okay I'm Jackie shanus from a Carter in English I'm bond counsil to the Board of Education um in January the board introduced their bond ordinance and what that Bond ordinance did was it authorizes the issuing of up to 13.5 million of bonds to finance upfront the cost of the Energy savings improvements um by law they have to hold a public hearing which is being held tonight and they had to go for

039approval to the local Finance Board of the state of New Jersey which is a public entity that looks at the financing and the terms of the financing to Grant approval before they can finally adopt the bond ordinance so right now they're going to do a the public hearing on the bond ordinance and subsequent to that hearing they will do a final adoption by vote of the bond ordinance after that and I'll sort of give you a little upfront so there's a resolution on the agenda tonight which authorizes the sale of the bonds which we expect to take place in March um subject to market conditions and Anthony anderso is here from the fa for the board who can talk more in terms of the financial ramifications of the bond issue but as you heard from

040Honeywell the way this has been set up in the state of New Jersey is the Energy savings are set up so that they are verified to be able to pay the cost of the bond over the life of the bond issue I'm happy to answer questions from the board or the public or however M president like do that do any any board members have questions M Ratner um and I just wanted to clarify as far as as the bond usage we only are responsible for bonds if the certain projects are completed so if if it's up to the amount it's not necessarily of that we are required to take the full um we we we authorize a larger amount as a precaution because we have to go and get the state approvals I think we're

041estimating that you'll probably need what was it 12.3 million about about 12.3 million right now but that will get finalized with the market when we sell the bonds right so that extra million plus of authorization will will go away you know because it's not being used so you would only be obligated to pay what we need to finance the projects which we're estimating is around 12.3 million now now that could change but it's not going to go from 12.3 million to 13 million it's probably going to be you know plus or minus $100,000 somewhere in that range are there any other board members with questions okay so I would like to open it up to the public if anybody has questions regarding the bond ordinance or esip um while we have all of our Representatives

042here please uh come up to the microphone you'll have four minutes and please state your name of municipality for the record and just to be clear this is the bond hearing public bond hearing uh it started off as being also for the technical portion and now we're we're into the bond portion so there is no public hearing on the technical portion there's a required public hearing on the bond I heard you but we will we will he and answer my question excuse me sir we will hear you on anything that you want to discuss related to the esip or the bond you don't have to be confrontational thought you were um you said that the build the buildings would be sealed what is the what is the makeup erir in in these sealed buildings I'll

043I'll ask uh our engineering team to address that question address ceiling so your your should be on real question your your makeup air is going to come in from where it normally comes in that's your your air handling units your unit ventilator units in the classrooms so you're really not any makeup air that's coming into the building that's supposed to be there uh is is not going to be touched okay and that's the air that you're actually conditioned we're more concerned about the air that's leaking in from basically roof wall joints basically where steel meets mortar um that's where the ceiling will occur but as far as uh the proper amount of makeup air uh for students for Education uh that will not be touched that was what that that that that air will not

044be touched makeup air will basically be what was required for uh for educational purposes okay what is the life expectancy of the equipment if the Project's over 23 years and and you're putting in some new equipment is the equipment's going to last as long as the bond period address that I yeah so so there is as part of the esa process there's actually a uh valuation that occurs related to the useful life of the equipment and it's a weighted average that is used in order to determine that and that is less than the 20-year period of the of the bond so the useful life weighted the weighted average of the useful life of all the equipment that is being installed is less than the 20-year Bond no it's just it's the opp it's the opposite

045by law the equipment average useful life will extend past the life of the bond issue I'm sorry thank you so which so it's it's longer than the 20 years right so so the analysis was done um because as as Jackie mentioned by law we cannot issue bonds greater than the weighted average useful life of the projects being financed so um our bond issue extends for a total of 21 years um the I don't remember exactly off the top of my head but I think it was around 25 years with that weighted average uh term of the projects so we have to it has to be certified that we are issuing the debt for a period less than the weighted average useful life what what is the estimated rate what I'm looking to find out is

046what is going to be the overall cost if we buying 12.3 million what how much are we going to repay over the period of the the bonds I can answer that um we're estimating an interest rate of 4% um and we think it's going to be you know ultimately when we sell the debt it'll be less than 4% but uh but that's been what we've been using for the estimates at this point um and that once again is you know the 12.3 million would be issued at that interest rate for that 21-year term okay so the the overall cost is how much are we going to repay in in the 21 years uh we're estim about we'll call it $7 million of Interest over that term so you know 19 $19 million you know $19.3

047million in total um which is less than the projected Energy savings okay so we're we're going to borrow 21 million and we're going to pay back 19 no no no you're you're borrowing 12.3 million and the interest on that 12.3 million is about 7 million okay okay so you're you're paying back over that period of time um you know the total of those two numbers all right thank you show our Mino Monroe Township so what I didn't see in some of the repairs was Applegarth furnace Applegarth boiler that we've been talking about that for a long time as a very important project how come that is not included in this like address take yes Apple grth school is being handled independently we received a rod grant for that okay so that's going forward yes the

048entire HVAC system as well as all the root and Al are being addressed thank you um uh could you explain how there's no cost to the taxpayers if we're running the bond and if it's a $7 million uh of Interest over the course of the Lo so when will so the board is going to issue the bond when does that interest begin to acrew and when do we start paying it back after the project those are all great questions questions that I'll gladly take um so the timeline is that we expect to issue the bonds um on or about March 19th okay so you know middle to the end of March uh your first interest payment on those bonds would be September of 2025 however uh we are uh structuring what's called capitalized interest with

049the bond so um the bond proceeds will pay uh interest for um the first year so that September and and um March 2026 interest payments would be paid by the bonds so there's no obligation out of the school bud I'm interrupt because my time is limited so so we're going to get the money and we're going to start paying interest from that money from that principle that we're borrowing correct okay I'm sorry go ahead just wanted to be clear cor yeah okay yeah and so but during that time you will be receiving Energy savings from the projects as as was mentioned you know lighting is is some of the first things that that we understand will be done and those will be generating savings so those savings will will will come to the school district

050because they're not needed for the bomb payments initially um and then from there you're um you're paying the uh principal interest on bonds over that that 21-year period as as we mentioned so through March of 2046 and you you'll be receiving Energy savings that are estimated to Total about $19.8 million and then um as I mentioned to the previous gentleman um in total there's about 19 um call 19.3 million of of obligations on the bonds um but then we we net out that capitalized interest which is about 570,000 so you're about 18.8 I'm going to ask the since this is a $14 million Bond I'm going to ask for a little extra time so the public can understand this so can I can um Madam president can can you ask our Finance U uh person

051to explain are we are we budgeting for this for this year and over the next years I mean for it I know it's the bond and we're going to just SOL use the B Money to finance everything and we're not rebud getting anything can sure miss alen yeah so yeah so when we start paying um off the principal and interest on the loan um we will be realizing Savings in the utilities line items so those savings will be basically applied to the to the debt so it's going to be a wash what are we anticipating those savings to be so every year there's a chart um that because you're counting on it being a wash yes there's a chart so every year it is it has been determined how much the savings will be so

052how much the the debt will be and how much the um utility savings will be um and we will it's we have to guarantee that the savings will be higher than the debt so we we have I wouldn't say $36,000 maybe extra on top of that every year that that's correct that um this project you know with the estimated savings and projected savings from the energy projects will be more than enough to pay the debt service and there would be about 35 30 35 to $40,000 of excess savings each year above and beyond the debt payments so we can hold everybody to that right everybody's agreeing that that's going to happen and I would just like to ask um to narrow the focus of the question about um honey well dooing the project I would

053ask that um how many payouts in New Jersey in the last 5 years has honeywall paid out in their projects the guarantee on the guarantee yeah so the answer is none okay that sounds good and um I know you did a project for Oldbridge I believe how's that going are they reaping benefits are they coming through like is it the promise coming forward so the Oldbridge project um I was the the project manager my name is Tim um I think we finished it in 2019 2020 um they had yeah they had a good project the savings was I think in excess um of what we projected um that was also the time when we we were able to get them increased uh incentives um any numbers can you give us fact hard numbers I don't

054I don't have numbers I think it was a 15 million do project roughly um and they re much roughly similar you know similar to this this size project um I I I couldn't tell you the Energy savings off the top of my head but it was it was about $15 million project so so one last question thank you for your Indulgence so through the life of the project we're not so we don't have to pay this Bond back for 23 years is that what the bond the bond will extend 20 21 years in total okay so but are we anticipating reaping the benefits of this whole project and paying that back sooner is that how that works or do we just hold the bond money out because I know in the past when we had

055construction um business administrators have used the money in the bonds to pay interest rates and stuff I understand what you're saying uh yeah so you're not going to pay out all $12.3 million on day one so yes the money will will be um utilized over time um so you will be able to earn interest off of that money um you will start paying back the bond um in um March of 2027 will be the first principal payment and you pay annual principal through the life of the issue so you start paying it down um so hopefully that answer your question okay I just think it's a it's a big debt to have on top of probably I think what do we have still $100 million in debt from previous bonds about 90 yeah close somewhere

056around there yeah pretty close for very close okay thank you for your time thank you are there any other members of the public who would like to come up to speak about the bond ordinance or esip have any questions okay then we oh oh oh sorry do I still have to State my name I can't remember the rules name of municipality okay Ros sham and Road Township um so first of all just wanted to thank you all for looking into like an energy saving initiative I think it's great that you guys are doing this I think you guys are putting a lot of energy um into it so it it is appreciated I did have a couple of questions I've watched um a couple of the bg& meetings and just just a couple of things

057so um one in terms of like the total bond amount right are we paying honey well like a separate fee or is that inclusive of the bond amount right so that's one question and then is there a possibility for us to do this inhouse versus hiring Honeywell that's that's another question I had and the reason I bring that up is like I'm someone in my career I hire a ton of Consultants I've hired consultants for $500,000 projects to like $20 million projects and what I found is you hire a consultant they do the work they go away and it's it's just hard to manage it when questions come in you have to go through the consultant ask them the question get the answer back right versus if someone internally is managing it I think it

058could be um a lot more beneficial um so that was another question I had should I pause um it's up to you if you want to ask all of your questions and then we can ask them when you're done so I'll just if it's okay I'll just pause and see if you have the answer yeah uh so your first question um Miss Allen can you just repeat your first question again um just if we're paying Honeywell like a separate consultant fee in addition to the bond amount that's being taken out no everything's included it's all inclusive in there in in that amount yes okay um and then just doing it inhouse versus like using in-house resources versus hiring H to do something like that is that something that's an option or something that was considered

059or looked into Mr tag some of the components of it could be done in-house over time we don't have dedicated staff to do this over the last several years we have taken on many of these lighting projects ourselves uh projects such as the boilers the chillers Etc no they cannot be done in house they would have to be done as capital projects yeah the the only thing I would ask is you just have more control over it right when it's in-house versus when you're hiring someone external and when someone when the community has questions you have a direct line into them so that's something I would just ask you guys to consider for whatever could be in housee if you guys would consider that um and then the other question I had I I was

060reading a lot about like a potential guarantee right so are we going to do that guarantee is that something that we're going to make sure that we include as part of the total bond amount I feel like that's really important like why are we spending all this money if it's not going to be guaranteed I just feel like that's something that's really important that we consider um so that's another question of mine yeah that's something that we as a board will discuss um after the hearing is over I do have a resolution if needed if the board feels like it would like to go in that direction okay so that's something that might be decided tonight okay great um and then the last thing is I heard something about like a solar program and US

061potentially looking into a solar program um is that something I I I read something about like leasing space and them leasing space from us versus like for example us owning the solar right and I know there's big differences between the two I was just wondering if someone could explain that program in terms of what we're looking into and um just what the ramifications would be of that sure I can take that um so what the district is currently um looking at is a power purchase agreement so that's where essentially there is a a a third party that leases the the space from from the school district and then they install solar there and then they sell that that power back to to the school district the benefit especially for for a school district um there's

062there's been some changes recently with with the inflation reduction act that that affect this but in general um historically school districts have signed up for power purchase agreements because they have not really been the beneficiary of tax incentives and those tax incentives can be realized by a a private entity now um I will you know say that as of right now within the inflation reduction act a public entity can actually get a tax rebate um we don't know if that's going to be continue to be the case but that is the case today okay um but the challenges the other challenges associated with it is just essentially they have to maintain the the the equipment make sure it's operating all the time so there' be a maintenance cost associated with it making sure that you

063have the power because essentially right now the way that it works is the power purchase agreement provider is incentivized to keep the system running because they're selling you the power right so they're going to want to keep that system up and running 24 hours a day they take care of all of that and they give a very good rate to to the district because they're able to realize a lot of the tax incentives and they have you know partners that have tax appetite and they can benefit from all that financially so um they can give a really competitive rate and ultimately the district says I'm not responsible for this somebody else has to maintain it and take care of it so we've found it's been the best situation for for public entities we have looked

064at it in the in the other aspect as well in terms of of ownership and we did a lot of analysis here and ultimately it worked out that it's better financially for the district to do a Power purchase agreement so that was what the the recommendation was yeah thank you that was my other question like did you model out what it looks like when we own it and then did you model out what it looks like if we're just leasing the leasing it back I mean I own I have solar panels at my own house and I know it's different than having it in a school district but there is very little maintenance so um I hear what you're saying I just think like over the long term I think it's just more beneficial to

065to own versus just lease it back um especially if you model it out right I I think you're you're better off financially um if you do that so that's the only thing I you know had a question on okay hopefully that answers the question yeah thank you thank you could for Miss Shaw could we just um explain to her I believe the insurance like to guarantee is it costs us I believe 30,000 a year for the guarantee M but we only recoup that money if they're under like the $30,000 savings and when we asked about the other districts um they said that some of the districts in our surrounding area had taken a guarantee yet every District had met the needs so it's kind of we're trying to figure out where we stand do you

066spend the 30,000 a year and then if we meet our expectations or if we're 23,000 below we still cost us 30,000 so that's what we're trying to figure out um where we need to be I I totally hear you the way I think about it is it's a hedge right we're we're hedging and saying you know let's pay the 30,000 and see if we get it I think if we're spending all of this money I feel like the Hedge is necessary the only other question I have is um you know I know we were told by Honeywell that that was the case did we confirm that with other districts that that was the case like did we actually talk to um the other districts that have used honey well to make sure that that was

067the case um I just think that's important right I just think it's important that we do our due diligence um when we're making such a big financial decision that's all I also just wanted to um piggy back on what Mr airo said and I I know you said you watched the meetings I kind of asked almost the same questions that you had about solar and everything but for the guarantee from my understanding it wasn't the same amount that we're spending it was the threshold was above that so like the guarantee is 36,000 but we would have to it was something like 40,000 or like it was more than that so there was the chance where even if we didn't necessarily realize that savings it would have to be more that we spent above the amount

068that we be spending on the guarantee above the guarantee um yeah I just want I don't know if I explained thatly it could be more than the 30,000 is your point Well we'd have to see a I guess a cost that would be higher than what the total cost of the guarantee is in order for it to kick in for us to get the guarant the back the money back yeah I mean if that's the case and it's just an exorbitant amount I would just say we should confirm with other districts ourselves that they indeed did not have to they did not take the guarantee and they they were fine they didn't need it right I just think that's important that's all thank you just remember the guarantee is annually so it's just one year

069for that the the guarantee was an annual fee so it's just that one year for the $36,000 it's year each year so every year we'd have to right right so understood but when you're talking about you know 13 something million it's kind of a drop in the bucket no thank you thank you very much good evening uh Chrissy scurby Monroe um I just uh I know Miss Shaw asked a question I don't think she got an answer how much is the district paying honey well for their services for this nothing correct we are not paying honey any money you make no money on this we're not there's noost into the contract obviously there's a fee that honey will be getting what is that fee that will be going to Honeywell they're not doing it for

070free let's be real what is there okay so so there is there is a uh a we call it a markup a fee and the services for all the services we provide which which are the design the development the overseeing of the project the in the installation as well as um just checking everything out at the end of the project to make sure everything works properly so we take everything off of the district's plate essentially we have project managers Tim who introduced himself earlier uh is is the project management leader Katherine is is our project manager that will be assigned to this project so we have a cost associated with that and as well as the detailed design we put together so we h an engineer the engineer designs the project so that we can

071put it out the public bid we oversee that process and all of that when you wrap it all up is about 28.8% on top of hard costs so that's the way that the project so roughly could you give a dollar amount I honestly an estimate I mean I'm sure you know an estimated dollar amount I I I honestly don't I could do the math um Got Back 2% Miss G do you have any other questions while he's doing the math uh yeah um again for Mr Yates uh if he could explain that guarantee because I I I understand it differently than I did at the previous meeting when it was explained is it sounded like it was explained that the guarantee is they're guaranteeing our usage of energy not our savings of energy or maybe

072I heard it wrong I'm sorry I was too Cal the guarantee what exactly is the guarantee I thought what you said was you guaranteeing our consumption that's correct so not these savings so so we guarantee the consumption which gets translated into a dollar value into a monetary value so we can't we can't guarantee the the the dollars of savings because ultimately that's going to change what we what we that's going to escalate over time so what we guarantee is is your Baseline of consumption today cuz last time they were talking about a $500,000 savings per year for the lighting okay so and then the guarantee would cost $30,000 to guarantee getting that 500,000 that's how it was talked about at the last meeting I'm not sure if that's exactly accurate so you would pay the

073$336,000 to guarantee that you got the $500,000 of savings it's the total the guarantee covers the total Energy savings so it wouldn't just be the lighting savings it would be the lighting lighting plus all the other energy conservation measures that are included in the project so it will guarantee all of that so what exactly could could you go through what that it guarantees so it's the lighting the is it the boilers the yes so so it's everything the scope of work that we talked about earlier which is so it's the lighting it's the control system upgrade it's the boiler plant so the boilers that are replaced it's the building envelopes so the insulation of the buildings um the replacement of the HVAC equipment throughout the district uh and then and and that's so that's the

074guarantee piece of it what is not guaranteed the so the the solar is not included within our guarantee the solar rate is guaranteed by a power purchase agreement provider will the board be entering into that agreement or will that be honey well the board the board will correct okay so um as Miss Shaw said too I would recommend my opinion as a taxpayer here that we do spend the3 $36,000 on a guarantee because it is obviously it's guaranteeing a lot of the project everything except solar is that correct yes so the solar again yeah the rate is guaranteed by the PPA provider so that's a huge that's a huge dollar amount and it's a small amount to pay to have that guarantee and I think you owe that to the taxpayers to ensure that they

075will get that we will have that that savings I I don't think it's and maybe even just for the first year see how it goes for the first year because you right you don't have to take it every year you could decide one year so I think for the first year getting into a new program like this it would behoove the board and show the taxpayers that you are being uh diligent with our our money um you're getting us into you're getting the town into this debt it is a debt and we are the taxpayers and I hope that you will strongly consider um doing the guarantee at least for the first year thank you are there any other members of the public who would like to speak anybody wants to come up for a

076second time does anybody have any additional questions even if you've already spoken if you'd like to come up a second time since it's a hearing no okay then we will close the public hearing um then we're going to move on to the adoption of the bond ordinance I have some a couple of um I guess we'll call them resolutions here um the first one it is recommended that the members of the mono Township Board of Education approve the adoption of bond ordinance is there a motion motion second motion by Miss Alvarez second by Miss Ratner can we have a roll call please can I oh sorry any question discussion question for the public um so just I just have a couple of of quick follow-up questions um in regards to I know you spoke about

077some of the work that can be done that like I guess has been done by staff regarding lighting and things like that if there are certain components of the project that can be handled I guess in District depending on uh you know work flow and things like that is that something that can be I guess transferred and then reduce the overall cost of what is being spent um so so I we're not I'm not opposed to that idea in general it it just I I'd say it's complicated right because we we build a project as as a whole and so we have multiple contractors and we may have uh contractors that are doing multiple different ecms the same contractor potentially and coordination from a coordination standpoint through the construction it gets complicated so I mean

078to answer the question we'll work with the district however the district would like us to work with it but at the end of the day I think it's an hon frankly I think it's in the district's you know best interest to do it as one project rather than um having contractors that are going to be you know conflicting with each other during the construction process if that makes sense okay thank you another question was regarding the guarantee but that's a separate resolution so it can ask that um okay so any other questions and can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss depay yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner yes Mr ziker yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes okay the next item Dr P I um Dr pack I'm sorry yes thank

079you the next item is um it is recommended that the Monroe members of the Monro Township Board of Education approve approve the resolution I'm sorry approve authorization form and sale of the refunding bonds is there a motion motion second I don't know did you motion motion by Miss Ratner second by Miss Alvarez um any questions or comments from the board okay can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes Miss depay yes Dr P yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner yes Mr ziker yes M Fabiano yes motion passes okay so then the last one is um it is recommended that the members of the Monro Township Board of Education approve the EIP guarantee is there a motion I'll make a motion second okay questions discussion Miss Ratner so I remember when we spoke

080about this whether it was at this meeting or at our committee meeting I don't remember for sure but that we did not have to make that decision at the same time that we were moving forward is this the point where we would need to decide if we are taking this guarantee or is this something that we can decide at a future date if we wanted to consider that could we table that till the next meeting and then she's asking a question right now have Mr T that's what Miss that's what Miss Ratner ising right now so uh Mr Weiss would you know the answer yeah so um if whoever made the motion withraw the motion is interested in withdrawing it they certainly can do that so I withdraw it with the stipulation that we do

081some research to find out other districts in our area and their savings and whether they took the guarantee and if they did what was the uh outcome of it well I think the other part of that question Miss Ratner if I'm not mistaken is can we do we have to vote on this tonight or can we vote on the guarantee next week I think nextone I'm your bond counsel I'm not your energy lawyer but um based on the meeting I attended the committee meeting in January it was my understanding from Caroline who was at the meeting that in order for you to sign your Energy savings contract and I don't know what your timing is for signing the contract you have to make a decision because it goes into that contract yeah so I I

082would caveat the answer by saying depending on when you what the time frame is to sign that contract will be when you need to make a the decision and and I can say that the um contract with Honeywell is still under review at my office so that has not been finalized as of yet I would just um you know to the extent that Honeywell is in agreement that that's the way to go then I'm okay with that yeah we're we're fine if if uh even even if we wanted to um have that contract um allow for a time period to make that decision we're fine with that as well great thank you okay thank you very much so then you're withdrawing your motion and we will talk to Mr T about you know doing some

083research with other districts on the guarantee okay so the motion was withdrawn so we don't have to anything else okay so then that would be the end of the EET presentation okay so then the next item on our agenda is the committee reports are there any committees that would like to give a report start curriculum Miss Alvarez I have three reports to give tonight but I'm going to space them out so I'm going to give my first report for curriculum um actually gazala uh Bora the chairperson is unable to be here today but she did provide me with the reports I'm going to be reading it on her behalf okay so the curriculum co-curricular Athletics and public and pupil Personnel committee meeting met on February 11th it was a remote meeting due to the weather

084event that evening the first item on the agenda was an update on the ice hockey team by the athletic director Mr Baron DEA I would like to start by congratulating the mths boys hockey team under incredible GMC Championship Victory soon after this curriculum meeting the committee was informed that night that the high school may not have enough ice hockey players next week to make a full team the conversations have started with Hillsboro School District to figure out a co-op Arrangement which could help us continue to offer the program to our players by having them practice and play as a joint school team the process to do this would require an application to the njsi AA as the two teams Monroe and Hillsboro are part of two different divisions Mr barandika will be taking all the

085necessary steps needed and the expectation is that as a result of this Co-op we will see some Savings in the per puple cost of running the ice hockey program once we enter the co-op we will stay in it for at least 2 years but the committee was assured that as soon as we have enough players to field a team we will consider reverting back to the current setup next on the agenda was the curriculum document for dynamics of Algebra 2 presented by Mrs Gasco the standard change in 2023 and this update aligned the curriculum to the new standards next on the agenda was some very exciting updates on the summer enrichment programs by Mr morala it gives me great pride to share that after discussing this need for several years thanks to the effort of

086the District administration beginning this July students will have the opportunity to earn Credit in Geometry or honors geometry during our all new summer advancement initiative class sizes will will be capped at 25 students students must have success successfully completed n9th grade to be eligible for the mths summer Advance 2025 interested students can speak with their counselors to get further details on this program committee would like to note that for many years our students have paid our neighboring school districts or Petty school for this Advanced opportunity they will hopefully now enrolled in these programs in Monroe be taught by our teachers and the district will be able to generate revenue for our own programs Mr morala then shared the plans for offering an extended duration specifically a 5H hour program for prek through 2 grade aged

087kids in the upcoming MTSD summer season 5 this will include two programs Falcon Nest Summer Academy for ages 3 and a half to 5 years old and summer of stem mind and motion Academy for grades K to2 lastly Mr moral shared the plans for introducing premedical and medical technology programs for both Elementary and Middle School age kids as part of the MTSD summer season 5 next the committee reviewed the new AI policy that Dr Layman presented this was the second discussion on this policy but the draft had been updated significantly since the original version the curriculum committee agreed on the proposed draft and passed it on to the policy committee for approval lastly the committee discussed student achievement policy 5440 the administration proposed a revised policy for all third all three grade levels Elementary Middle

088School and High School while there was brief discussion on the middle and elementary criteria that wasn't change much a lengthy discussion took place on the high school change being proposed the current policy allows for students taking honors classes to be included in the principal's list if they get 85 and above while all other classes would need 90 or more for principal's list the proposal was to remove this and make it 90 and above for all classes irrespective of the rigor after both sides of the argument were discussed at length the committee decided to send the policy back to the principles for another look to determine one if the criteria can be standardized amongst all three School levels and two should the students taking AP and honors classes be allowed to be on the principal's list

089with a score of 85 and over Dr Chanley will have discussions with her team and bring back a recommendation for the next meeting in the meantime the committee has requested that we follow the current policy that allows honor students with 85 and over to be in the principal's list the discussion on this policy started as parents brought it to the intention of the board that the policy was not being following followed this concludes the curriculum committee update thank you Miss Alvarez does anybody have any questions or comments I have a question so the existing policy we not following it no currently we're not following at the high school level at all it's actually it's at all three it's at all three levels middle high school and middle scho why why aren't we having the policy

090followed it's not is there could Dr Chanley explain so we could at least let the parents know why we're not if we have a policy why we're not using it so as far as the middle school policy up until 2021 we were following it so that if you did get an 85 you were recognized for principal's list after 2021 of November I'm if you're saying we're not following it I'm going to agree um Regarding why it's not being followed I am going to acquest to Dr Layman because this is specifically his area um it's one of those things where we didn't know that it was not being followed until it was challenged but Dr Layman has a little bit of background on it I think I mean Dr chandley said it it was the policy

091was generated in 2008 uh it was generated and from what we have found as we we had one person that we knew that was a part of the discussion the revision in 2008 um what the policy looks like now was not what was discussed in 2008 so the high school adapted all of their uh recognition based on what the changes were going to be um so what it comes down to is they did not know that the policy was written the way it was for the past 17 years uh we five superintendents or 10 superintendents five High School principles it wasn't known new so when it was brought to our attention uh we took a look at it and now it's in committee to be addressed uh and the conversation now is debating uh the

092recognition of the honors and AP because right now it's written as honors only so if you're in an AP class you need a 90 if you're in an honors class you need an 85 so if we're talking about recognizing consistently students taking a more rigorous class the policy as it's written doesn't follow that either um because it doesn't mention anything about AP it only recognizes honors so that's a long-winded answer to say when it was brought to our attention we began to look and figure out why there was a discrepancy between what was being done for the past 17 years and what what's actually written in the policy and now we're taking steps to again standardize and correct everything and moving forward we'll have this cleaned up and uh it'll be something that will be

093from the the Vari discussions it will be a series of compromises because there are definitely uh perspectives about recognizing classes with different rigors in different ways and there's valid arguments on everybody's side about how that should be handled um and then layer in that recognition at different levels elementary middle and high school so what seems like it could be a simple conversation to say hey just this is just the criteria Let's Do It um when you layer in the different parts of the conversation it's much much more complicated but the answer to why it wasn't being followed is no one knew so now we know and we're correcting it and that's what we're in the process I assume we got a lot of emails so I just want to make sure that in recent times

094we have yes that one y yep so we will have something at the next policy meeting and then we'll have something curriculum I think it's going to go to curriculum first curriculum policy and and then we'll have it on the board agenda for March thank you y thank you Miss Ratner yep um so I know um Miss Bora had brought this up um and I know you know she's a parent of high school students now um so she hears from them um I just wanted to shut a little bit regarding the Middle School um I think one of the which I see it it changed in the current proposed policy but what I think might have been confusing is it says right now in the current policy as it stands today it says to be

095eligible for the honoral pupils in grades 5 to 8 must achieve an overall average of 85% in the courses taken during the regular schedule at school day and so when you said overall average it's taking all of the courses that are there whereas what you know we had been told was it's in that amount in every course um and so I think like I had heard you know as well I'm I personally actually experienced it myself with my daughter so um I think that's where the confusion sort of came in um and so I see now it's changed that it will be a grade of 80% based on the proposed policy um for The Honorable um as well as um a 70 to 5 to 79% in honors and advanced courses at the middle school

096um currently it was 75 to 79% in one course for any level um at the middle school um and so that was something that I think also was just a bit confusing based on what was being done and I guess what was there um and then my other question that sort of just came up this week because there was the jior National Honor Society I don't know if when this was created in 2008 if we had a junior National Honor Society you're not calling it by the right name I'll correct you okay so that might but I guess because we speak about the high school Honor Society in this policy um which you know is an an average of all of those you know marking periods from what I understood with the middle school is

097it's every single marking period every single grade has to be you know above a certain thing which is honestly harder than the high school where it's that average so if you have one bad marking period you know it's okay you might still be considered whereas with the middle school if you have that one marking period where you may have gotten one point below then you're no longer eligible um but you know I tried to like see where that is in one of the policies and I I couldn't find it and I wasn't sure if that was there was a reason for it okay I can speak on the middle school so you the reason why the middle school first of all it's not a National Junior H Society specifically and I will tell you why

098for many years we had no Honor Society when I was principal probably 10 years ago I'm I'm just guessing don't quote me 10 or 12 years ago we then decided to join the chapter and that's why I'm going to correct you because it is an actual National Honor Society due to the rigor that was required by the National Honor Society because it's not required in middle school so there it's not a policy it's not required we decided that it was not fair EX exactly what you said the requirements at a middle school level were more stringent than the requirements at the high school level which really from an educational point of view makes no sense right so we went ahead and made the decision to no longer follow the National Honor Society and we just

099created a Middle School Monroe Township Honor Society so that we were able to lessen the requirements now that is what happened prior to me leaving okay I cannot speak at this time although I'll be happy to look into it of what it is that they follow now but I will let you know that when I was still principal we did not follow the National Junior Honor Society any longer we followed the Maro Township middle school because we wanted to be able to lessen the criteria you cannot lessen a criteria when you follow anything that is state or nationally driven you must follow their criteria so all I can do is say I understand what you're saying it is my understanding that as of November of 2021 it was not a National Honor Society but I

100will be happy to discuss it with the principal into it and it makes sense rather than just to provide you the answer because the public is listening when we have our curriculum and then we have our policy meetings this can be part of the discussion thank you you're very welcome are there any other questions or comments for curriculum Miss Fabiano really quick aside from that policy I also just wanted to say that I really appreciate the idea of the um the preschool program um because I having kids that just got out of that age the rec program doesn't start until a certain grade and there's really like this Gap in what you do with that age level and not only will this provide an opportunity but it also can sort of get them acclimated to

101our district so I just wanted to you know give some praise for that idea thanks anybody else are there any other committees that would like to give a report yes building and grounds go ahead so the building and Grounds held their committee meeting on February 12th at 7 p.m. at the mon Township High School Media Center present was Miss Fabiano Miss was virtual Miss Ratner myself Dr Chanley Dr Layman Mr T Mr Selby and Miss martyr from Transportation uh we spoke about the Applegarth Rod Grant project update Administration reviewed in detail an agreement for installation of electric distribution facilities that covers jcpnl installing a new electric service transformer for the Apple Guard School Rod Grant project the committee will make a recommendation that the board approve this agreement at the upcoming public meeting the Transformer

102appears to be available and ready for delivery as needed the 1936 roof project change order was closed out Administration reviewed the details of the three separate change orders for the project that resulted in a final credit of approximately $115,000 um from this project allowance and those funds will remain with the ra Grant account and available for any forthcoming roof projects uh bidding uh remaining building roof projects Administration advised that the plans and specifications are being finalized in the bit for the 1960 1979 and 1983 roofs at alar school will be advertised for public bid on March 18th and a products are slated for construction during summer of 2025 uh that's the update on the r Grant uh Mr Tay explained us that they do a shared service agreement with the town for road salt storage

103uh he shared with us and we have a resolution we will be uh acting upon to formalize a longstanding agreement for the storage of road salt uh product at the Township Road Department the township has been quite generous in allowing us to store material and provide all the labor they've provided all the labor for loading and unloading our trucks as needed during the winter season uh the committee support supports formalizing this matter and the board legal council will prepare a resolution for a board action accordingly our district grounds care uh contract renewal the administration recommends the committee also supports renewing the contract with boss landscaping for lawn care operations during the 2025 2026 school year the contractors entitled to a 2% increase on their base contract of 140,000 boss Landscaping has offered to forego an

104increase and renew at the base cost the committee will recommend this for board action at this meeting the esa project update um we just went over the update we had a a um presentation here for the public tonight uh the transfer uh out of service vehicles to Firefighters for safety training so the district has three 20 plus year old um vehicles I believe they're Dodge Durangos and we will be doing a resolution um to give those vehicles to Monroe Township Fire District 3 to use for life safety training so um we drafted up a it should be noted that one of the three vehicles was actually donated to the board by the police department several years ago for use bar security staff so these three vehicles are all out of service and the Fire District

1053 said that they would be able to use them for Life Safety training uh we also did a transportation overview with school security and those we talked about safety measures but those safety measures are confidential information uh that concludes my my meeting thank you does anybody have any questions or comments for Mr Pio are there any other committees that would like to give a report Miss Ratner you want to okay I I can go okay Miss Ratner will go okay and then you can finish um so the legislative advocacy and Community engagement committee met on February 11th um Board of Education members present were myself Miss deine Dr peek and Miss Fabiano and the district administrators in attendance were Dr Chanley Dr lemman and Mr miralda the committee began with the discussion of current legislative

106items we looked at some of the updates um on the New Jersey school board's Capital watch page which which was a recent addition to their website and it provides updates on various education bills that are at the state level um and then in addition to speaking at the uh funding Reform Act hearings we also shared some of our other um advocacy steps that have been taken by the district um one of which was um that we had an exciting meeting with some of our key stakeholders at the state level um present at this meeting um from the district where myself Miss Fabiano Miss Alvarez Dr Chanley Dr Leman Miss Allen and Mr morala um and so the um stakeholders from the state that were present were Mr damer um who was the interim Commissioner of

107Education um as well as a few members of his staff um it also included Senator Greenstein who played a key role in putting the meeting together for us um members of her staff as well as some staff members from the governor's office um so this was a really um exciting opportunity for us to sort of meet people from multiple Parts at the state level unfortunately we couldn't have the meeting down in Trenton because that's when there was inclement weather that day but I still feel like it you know it was helpful to have that meeting and we sort of shared some of our challenges um both surrounding full day kindergarten which was the initial reason for the meeting um because we know that they want to mandate that Statewide and we are one of a

108few districts left um so sort of explained why we are unable to do that right now um and they shared some solutions um some which we've already discussed as a district and others which I know you know we said we can look into um and then we also discussed the funding formula um because while they said there's not going to be any major changes to that this year this year is more about the transparency of the formula um they are going to be looking at that and it would be the Department of Education that's ultimately tasked with that um whether it's a revision or an overhaul or anything like that so we sort of explained how we've been penalized for so long um because of our unique Community um and so they definitely listen there

109I was impressed with some of the information that the commissioner was aware of um I think that it was you know it's always ongoing you know I know that this has been a goal for us for a long time and you know I would love to say that we're getting closer um but I definitely appreciate that they all took the time to meet with us um so we had sort of shared that at the meeting um the next thing that we discussed was the district advocacy website uh we reviewed what is currently listed there and we spoke of additional ideas of things that can be added to the website um we also spoke about finalizing our advocacy letter um that is currently there so that it's updated to our current needs um and have it

110published there um and I also had mentioned at the meeting that I had heard from a board member in a nearby District that Monroe came up at their board meeting um as an example of what they'd like to see in their District um as an advocacy um effort so I just wanted to say you know kudos to everybody who's been a part of that past and present um I wrote this CH but we reviewed the advocacy letter um and then um I also just wanted to share while not directly part of the lace committee meeting um it's part of legislative advocacy myself Miss Fabiano Miss Alvarez and Miss deine also attended the county meeting for New Jersey school board and the headline speaker was Senator gopal um who is the Senate education committee chair it

111was a very busy day um and so um it was really exciting to be able to have open conversations with him he really was willing to take any and all questions and as you guys know I took advantage of that opportunity um and he said that he's actually heard about Monroe and um you know that he looks forward to meeting with us to sort of understand what some of our unique challenges are as well so I did just want to share that as well thank you okay um does anybody have any questions or comments for Miss Ratner can I just answer to sure um also by the end of that meeting um there's supposed to be the governor put out um recommendations for a cell phone non-usage in the in schools so that was brought

112up at the end of that committee meeting and some of the people were asking questions at uh South Playfield she's the president if it becomes a fact that we have to not have cell phones who's going to fund it and Senator gopal was very insistent on saying that if we needed and which I got from it or any District that needed funding for anything and I I would say our full day kindergarten and for the pouches that some of the districts use for the kids to put them in uh he would insist that the state fully fund any of those mandates yeah so like what I've always said in all the years I've been a board member State mandate State doesn't pay so I hope Senator goal stands up to his promise that day with

113anything that we need and that's what he said that the state he will help the state to pay help us pay for these needs so if we do have to put a policy together we'll go through policy on cell phones and uh some districts have started it uh but it's nothing written in stone thank you yeah he did definitely say he would not support an unfunded mandate so yeah anybody else have any questions or comments okay Miss Alvarez your turn all right so the policy committee met virtually on Tuesday February 11th 2025 present at the meeting were Dr Chanley Dr Layman Mr barandika Mrs Sher or shayer shayer Mrs Fabiano Dr peek Mr zner and Mrs Ratner Mr Banda was present to discuss policy 9163 spectator code of conduct for inter Scholastic events this is

114a mandated policy and Mr barandika worked diligently to make the necessary adjustment Mrs Scher our director of Food Services also attended the meeting to review policy 8500 Food Services and policy 8505 School nutrition 8500 states that if 20% or more of the students enrolled in a school in the district as of October 1st of the preceding school year were federally eligible for free or reduced price meals under the national school lunch program or the Federal School breakfast program The District shall establish a school breakfast program in the school in accordance with the provisions of njsa 18a 33-10 as a result Woodland and mil Lake school now offer breakfast the high school currently offers allaart breakfast on Fridays the numbers will be reviewed to determine if the breakfast program will be increased at the high school

115for the 202 25 2026 school year regarding policy 8500 there was a question asked about how alart options are monitored at the elementary level parents can request through their respective schools that a limit be set on their child's accounts the committee continued to review the policies under stra SME alert 234 and are on tonight's agenda for a first read the use of school facilities policy was sent back to Administration to consult with board counsel for revision to the current language and the policy related to school security and policy and regulation 5516 use of electronic communication devices was tabled to the March meeting and the revised organizational chart is on the agenda for board approval this evening this concludes my report does anybody have any questions for Miss Alvarez Miss Ratner I just wanted to get

116clarification on the organizational chart um I don't know Mr W Maybe you want to help us with this is this I guess considered a a policy in itself or um is it a policy to to have a a actually I have the answer because I did consult with u Mr weisser ready so uh the policy says that we have to have an organizational chart the organizational chart itself is not a policy so that can just be approved tonight this evening so the chart is not on the agenda as a policy for a first read the chart is just on the agenda as has to be approved but the policy what is it 11 1100 or something like that something like that it's just that we have to have an organizational chart so it is actually

117right on the agenda now as a first read but there will be a motion to correct that okay any other questions or comments okay then with Personnel okay the P the person person El committee met on Wednesday February 12th present at the meeting were Dr Chanley Dr Layman Mrs Fabiano Mr Pio Mrs depan there were two resignations due to retirement the administration is recommending a candidate this evening for the supervisor of special services position uh the board appreciates how quickly this position has been filled lastly there is also a transportation secretary for approval on tonight's agenda this concludes my report does anybody have any questions or comments for Miss Alvarez oh Mr Pay yeah unfortunately due to the bad weather we couldn't get the CAC members onto a zoom meeting we were worrying about them

118all coming together so there was no CAC meeting this month but if everybody's listening out there who are members uh the next meeting will be March 11th 7 o' at the high school thank you are there any other questions for Miss Alvarez for personnel okay then we're going to go to the next item on our agenda which is our public forum for agenda items only any members of the public wishing to speak you'll have four minutes to do so please come up and state your name and municipality for the record George gunman 5 Kelly Port Monroe I I have a question mostly directed to Jerry T I guess um street lights um in our parking lots or the school's parking lots it's my understanding from security that that the school has about the same luck

119with JCP now as the rest of the community which is not much um and it occurs to me that there's quite a li liability that gets passed on to the school should someone be injured in a parking lot that was attributed to poor lighting and I'm wondering with this project that we that was discussed earlier with improved lighting understand understanding that that project was talking about internal lighting uh in in the buildings not parking lot lighting uh that is currently with jcpnl but might we want to look at that and and maybe go to LED that are managed by the school as opposed to being dependent on the undependable jcpnl which doesn't seem to want to respond to street light outage I would just say that yes it is our desire to bring those parking

120lots that are under jcpl inhouse uh we have done that on some occasions most recently I believe it was 3 years ago when we did the underground storage tank replacement project at the transportation garage I used that as an opportunity to upgrade those lights and take those back under our control I applied for a grant which we receed which paid for the lights and then we had those installed so we we do take that approach it should be noted that the majority of Lights though parking lot lights are owned by the district for example the entire high school facility is owned by the district and operated by the district Brookside School Barkley Brook the Middle School former High School is jcpnl as is um oak tree primarily jcpnl okay so do you do you think

121that this new project will address these or that something we need to do in we would have to do that as a separate Capital project it's not included in the scope currently all right thank you sh our Mino monra Township um the lights since we're talking about lights in the fields is there a time when they automatically go off because especially in the winter when no one's really at at the fields utilizing them they're still on later than they should be and if we're talking about um you know Energy savings that should be one of the things we should be controlling now and I've know I've mentioned it before um in these meetings and I still see the lights on all the time are they automatic um or you what's the story with those the

122field lights are controlled by a calendar schedule primarily controlled by Mr Barona and the athletic programs as well as the Township Recreation Department I will tell you that possibly on some occasions when you've driven by when you see the lights on if an event ends for example at 900 p.m. Mr Barona very wisely allows the lights to stay on for about 20 minutes thereafter okay to allow I'm going to interrupt you again for timing thank you for that but I can assure you that in the cold dead of winter there's no events going on and the lights don't need to be on so somebody needs to be in charge of shutting those lights off especially if you're SK if if no events are scheduled I mean I live around the block so I'm passing them

123all hours of the night and they're still on so again I appeal to this board and to the administration to look into that and make that happen um did you want me to oh I don't want to waste your time go ahead cuz I do want to make hockey team um and I missed that cuz I went out I apologize um how many uh students do we need for the hockey team and how many do we have so it she didn't include the amount of the that we need for a full team well full team yeah okay well if you don't know let we can we can go back and get you inform information that's okay please so the the current team is a varsity team previously we've had JV and varsity the ballpark is

124about 16 to 18 Athletes right now um we don't anticipate being able to feel the full team next year which is why uh many teams that can't feel the full team will join a co-op uh the co-op costs are proportional to how many athletes you have participating so we wouldn't commit to a a number it's only paid per athlete um because there's tryouts between the two teams and they fill positions as needed all right my thought was because it's about $60,000 I believe for what a three-year or $60,000 a year I for I I I would never want to take anything away from our students or our athletes either a academically or recreationally but if we can't get a team we shouldn't spend that kind of money under the circumstances so I think one of

125the options is just not having a team if we can't put it all together so the co-op would allow the shared ice time and that's the largest cost and it would be divided equally or proportional to the um in terms of the policy committee I I watch the policy Comm I would like to thank um Miss Alvarez and miss rner you did an excellent job um you're really terrific at running the meetings and going through the policy so I appreciate that but I did try to go to the buildings and grounds committee meeting and the time was changed on the um meeting times it said it was 8:00 and then when I went to look cuz I try to do things on a mon LLY basis and write in the times and then it said

126it was 5:00 so somehow I missed it but do you change the times if you look at the dates that come up for the year when you make the um schedules I thought it said 8:00 so I was going to attend that meeting at 8:00 but then I looked because there was no meeting and it was said 5:00 can someone to explain that sure so our committees were affected by the weather last week so we had we had want W up condensing some meetings on Tuesday night to be virtual and then with the schedule shift there was a we needed to move buildings and grounds to I think we moved it to six there was no clance committee meeting so so w it was still on Wednesday but it was at 6 o' when was

127that put on the computer or on on on the website um I don't know the public needs to be informed when and it says on the bottom to your credit you know time subject to change but people like me maybe there's not a whole lot of them but I still want to go to the meetings it at 8:00 I was prepared to go at 8:00 I'm driving home at 5: so I missed it we can we can make it the adjust the time on the website if we change it because I know we put the links up with the time on the website so we can make sure that the links are adjusted on the website that would be great and how what so that was that a last minute change based on know okay

128thank you are there any other members of the public wishing to speak yes Brian Fabiano Monroe Township it's been a been a while since I've been here in person I come to police because I know it's election time and all the members of the uh running parties will be here with their nonsense but uh I got a lot to say in the next uh section but what I'll say in this section is this I find it really hard to believe that the superintendent can sit here and say I mean we pay we pay the superintendent multiple hundreds of dollars per year to supervise the school district to sit here and say that you don't know whether policies in the district are being followed or not is just ludicrous I don't care if you left the

129Middle School in 2021 if you left it in 2020 if you left in 2022 it's your job to make sure that the policies in the school district are being followed and it tells me that if this policy is not being followed What other policies are not being followed in regards to busing regards to student time whatever there's no excuse to sit here and say I don't know as a superintendent that policies are not being followed and quite honestly Dr Layman there's no excuse to sit here and say it's 18 years old we we we don't it doesn't matter policies are policies and they should be followed and I question if you're not following this what else are you not following it's the board's job you're elected to represent the interests of the community and part

130of that is to make sure that the policies of this school system are followed so to sit here and say you don't know is nonsense that's that's what I want to make in this in this uh in this section um I also just wanted to just briefly talk on the esip no questions but there's been a lot of negativity from you know the the usual one or two um call them posters in in the uh Community uh one who was overwhelmingly defeated in the last election um but I truly as a resident appreciate the work that that Mr T and this Administration has done the time you put into this EIP program we need to be as a school district innovators we need to go out and find ways to save money so that money

131can be allotted to other programs and other ways other things that we need by having this program happen it brought money into the school district we were allowed to we were able to aot money to get the much needed uh changes and updates at at Applegarth as well as other programs so I don't think there's a lot of negativity really around this program I think there there should be really Applause from the community yeah work out whether want to ensure it or not and you I can go both ways on it but to see us undertake something like this that will bring savings into a program or into a school district that that certainly needs the money is something that I think should be celebrated not you know uh politicized um for some some political

132benefit um so that's all I'll say here uh and then I'll come back to the next section with with quite a bit but uh also wanted to uh wish a happy 21st birthday to uh Mr pay on her birthday today thank you thanks for getting the age right she told us no she are we are they allowed to sing I said you told us no no no no that's okay no singing hi Ros sha happy birthday um I just I wasn't going to come up and speak but I was just listening to the discussion about the curriculum committee and uh the principal's list and honoral and I just wanted to confirm something um my son is in the Middle School um and I don't want to put his grades on blast on on something that's

133recorded but he did receive like between an 85 and a 90 on an accelerated in an accelerated class and on his report card it did say congratulations on achieving the principal list so all the other grades were 90 plus right and one of his accelerated class grades was between an 85 and a 90 and it did say congratulations on achieving the principal list so in the middle school it is being followed because it was a big deal for him um for him to be on the principal's list so um I just wanted to confirm that for you because I was hearing some of the discussion um and so just wanted to let you guys know I have no questions or anything like that just wanted to make that comment thank you thank you Sita GOI

134here um actually about the principal list the question um where the policiy is not being followed was brought up uh last May that was me and it took almost 9 months and we did not get to the consensus how can we avoid this going forward I mean policy is policy and there can be decisions made much sooner correct policy you're right policy is policy and we should be making sure that this policy is followed um I know Dr Layman and Dr Chanley have both expressed that the and we've talked about it in policy and curriculum the policy is being revised but up until the revision is final the current policy should be being followed correct but the amount of time it to you know to come to on this stage can this be you know

135expedit any such any such future um issues Dr J Dr L do you she said it's it's been you said nine months correct that's me um is there a way to expedite this to move this along a little bit faster I mean I know I know as a intention of the administration n months so just to let you know on March uh whatever we said the date was I'm just trying to think of the committee dates I don't know top of my head 11th on March 11 the decision will be made decision will be made will be brought to first read in March and then it'll be brought to Second read and and will be confirmed without question and any future uh issues like this it is better if they can be uh looked into

136sooner instead of waiting for you know this long I don't know probably you guys have process yeah as soon as it comes as soon as the board is made aware of this we brought it to curriculum I think we started the conversation not this past month but maybe two months ago um so we we started it we have started the conversation as soon as the board became aware um and then it takes there is a process that we have to follow before it becomes an actual policy once the policy gets put on the agenda that becomes a first read and then the following on it becomes a second read and then it goes up uh to be an official policy so that part takes time on our part um but we know we always encourage

137if you please reach out to I know we've received several emails recently and it was I respond yes yes and it's been helpful um to see those so we do appreciate that thank you good evening Christy scurby Monroe um I just had a question about the um organizational chart policy policy 110 is District organization and that mandates that you have to have an organizational plan 1110 is the actual organization chart and for as long as I can remember coming here anytime there was a change to the organizational chart that policy was changed the or chart was changed and the board did vote on that so I don't know if the board is going away from that I don't know why we're saying the organizational chart is not a policy because it is and it's listed

138as that organizational chart policy 1110 the one before one one1 one0 is District organization that mandate you have to have on work chart um and just to comment on the curriculum I I think that part of the discussion that wasn't recapped in the curriculum committee update was the fact that the weighted average is being used for certain accolades at the high school where the principal's list was not using the weighted average and that seemed to be the issue for the parents that brought it Forward was you're using it for National Honor Society admission you're using it for um validator and but you're not using that weighted average to give the Accolade of principles list and if you're not going to use it for that then you shouldn't use it for anything and quite honestly something

139that Mr ziker said at the committee meeting struck me as parent um when you said that we're not making our children achieve higher that we're we're lowering the standards we're not in fact when you don't give that child that Accolade of the achievement that they've gotten which is a weighted average you're going to have more more students not want to take the AP course and take a regular course so that they can get the Accolade of the principal's list to put on their college application so these kids are taking a very more rigorous course and we're waiting it we're telling them we're waiting your average because it's that much more rigorous but then we're not giving them the accolate so my worry would be that we would we've and AP courses is not in the

140policy because when that that policy was created we offered very little AP courses over the last 10 15 years we've increased our AP courses tremendously so we had a lot of honors back then that's why it says the 85 add the AP in there as well um but I would really caution you want our students to be wanting to take the AP courses and the honors courses and with that you want to you want to treat all of that the same you don't want to say well we're going to use your weighted average for this but we're not going to use it for that that's not really fair to the child it's not so I really hope that when you're discussing this in policy you will look at that because you don't want students to

141start not taking those more rigorous classes because after all we get an award right Dr Layman for how many AP courses that our students take so I mean and that is a a tremendous um Accolade for our district is what we're offering now because we didn't offer and now we are and now we're winning awards for for offering that many so I I just really hope you'll look at that um that policy and really consider what it means I don't think we're making it less rigorous I think we're giving the accolades to the students that deserve them and Dr Chanley I just want to apologize for the torture that you go through by certain people it's really unprofessional it's unacceptable and having been the board president with you as a superintendent I know that it

142is your desire to make sure that all policies are followed we've seen that and the district knows that so ignore the noise because that's all that is thank you are there any of members of the public wishing to speak okay seeing none we will close the public forum and go to the next item on our agenda which is our assistant superintendent report Dr Layman sure uh as usual our student board members highlighted a few things that I was going to bring attention to specifically and the accolades for our recent winter uh sports teams um and we will be recognizing them uh in the near future at a board meeting for their accomplishments as well but one thing I do have uh that I can highlight is the njmea state music education conference will take place

143over the next three days in Atlantic City so best of luck to our monot tonship high school honors Wind Ensemble mot Township Middle School chamber singers and the mot Township Middle School Falcon Jazz Ensemble who all auditioned and were accepted to perform over the next two days as part of this conference this is the most performing groups Monroe has ever had accepted to perform uh at the event and the most performing groups this year of any District in New Jersey so that's uh a testament to our tremendous program and additionally congratulations and best of luck to we have four mono time chip High School band students and four monoton High School chorus students who auditioned against students from all over New Jersey and were accepted into the njmea which is the New Jersey music educator

144Association All State Wind Ensemble symphonic band and treble choir um all will be rehearsing over the next few days with their respective groups and we'll have performances both in Atlantic City as a part of this conference over the next three days and then this Sunday they perform at the New Jersey pack in Newark uh for one of their uh State performances so congratulations to uh our arts program as you hear almost every month we have have a tremendous uh essentially 4 through 12 uh band and chorus program uh as well as uh the theater programs and this is just testate of our ongoing Student Success so congratulations to all those uh teachers as well as students and that concludes my report thank you Dr lemman um Dr Chanley uh good evening everyone and um we

145have a few retirements that I'd like to start out with so um we have someone who came to us um who had already had a career somewhere else Carolyn McCory um high school special education teacher she's with been with us for 5 years and now she'll be retiring Melanie rayum grade fourth teacher at Woodland School 20 years and Rosina vento is a parro oak tree for 18 years we always wish our Falcons well on their next flight for retirement and to enjoy um a very happy and healthy um time where they can continue to um just have a have a great opportunity to be with family and friends and wherever they decide to land additionally um similar to what Dr Layman said our school board student members do a fabulous job um on the various

146different events and all the different um activities that go on in many of the schools whether it be the 100 Day celebration or activities for wellness healthy heart month um the nurses Step Up um as well as school counselors I have the opportunity to visit schools that is something that I I myself on doing quite often and I had the opportunity to um celebrate day of optimism last Friday it is um a culminating activity in the Middle School um in regards to um om PRI who was a student there who lost his life to Pediatric brain cancer um I think it's important to comment that many organizations here in Monroe um join together for um the celebration of his life and uh the Legacy that he leaves in order to raise money for um pediatric

147cancer a save the date if I could just give a shout out is May 18th it's a walk wathon and it's also I believe a five mile and you correct me I think it's five miles five mile run I only do the walk I definitely don't do the Five Mile 5K 5K I apologize 3.3 miles but 5K thank you very much president Fabiano 5K um so for those of you um a lot of the information will be coming out and and sharing that with you um he is not the only child that has lost his life um we have had sadness I've been here here whatever 20 plus years we've had sadness and what we like to do is just whatever possible to be able to raise money for the research that just helps to

148find cures that's that's all we could say um it is a wonderful organization and I believe IAM and mic are two of major um organizations that help to to create this wathon uh whether it be a 5k or just a mile mile walk a mile run so you'll be looking you'll be seeing information regarding that and um I think it's it's a sh out that we're very fortunate here because many organizations whether they be at the elementary middle school or high school really raise a lot of Financial Funding for different organizations and a lot of them unfortunately are cancer and pediatric cancer so I did want to make that comment um on that note I will get directly to my uh recommendations so under Personnel for a 10 member vote it is recommended the board

149approve the attached Personnel items A through Z motion second motion by Mr Alvarez second by Miss Ratner are there any questions or comments Miss Ratner um I just had a quick question on letter P that's before Q right yeah um the head coach for Cricket I remember when this had come to the board initially it was being considered a a club if I recall is has that been changed now that it it's now a sport um I remember the person who came was so enthusiastic when he spoke about it but I remember when it came it was initially at the club level so as they work through their Pro it's essentially probationary time they do transition into a club and then involves um I don't actually I think it may have actually been a non

150club last year as well because we have stiens in place that are in agreed upon with the association um coaches are paid based on the tier that their sport Falls in um and this is already predetermined so this is not a new sport in terms of uh this is the first time it's being approved as a sport okay yep um and then just looking also at that um and this is just sort of generalization um do we I know every year we do like an audit of our clubs to see what we need and what we don't do we do the same in regards to coaches because I know there are some sports where we have more athletes and less um so I just wanted to ask because obviously we can see that on the

151agenda yes so the athletic director uh and again I think hockey is a perfect example right so we evaluate the participation and the need for support for every every sport and I I I think we're living through you know the EB in flow of uh almost like the the waves of students that come through uh we went through this a few years ago with uh the softball teams uh we weren't able to field the freshman team at one point um and now we're back to supporting that and it's just the interest level of students as they progress through um and that will EB and flow again we wouldn't have five coaches for five athletes right so it's everything's proportional all right thank you are there any other questions or comments okay can we have a

152roll call please miss alen yes Miss Alvarez yes to all abstain on letter n and letter O Mr Pay yes Dr P yes Mr pero yes M Ratner uh yes recuse on letter V okay uh Mr zner yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes under Personnel n member vote is recommended the board approve the attached Personnel items double A to BD motion second motion by Miss Alvarez second by Miss depine are there any questions or comments okay can we have a roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes yes M depay yes Mr pero yes M Ratner um yes reuse on uh letter ax um from Miss bruy liow um and letter BC for Mr Ratner okay uh Mr zner yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes on board action 10 member vote it is recommended the board

153approve the attached board action items a through H motion second motion by Miss depay second by Miss rner are there any questions or comments from the board I'd like to make a motion to pull the organizational chart and vote separately on it letter E the only issue with that is that there's a motion pending um that you want me to take it back only if you'd like to well I have to think about it but I'll uh I'll oh gee I'll take back the motion that I just made about the that section and the or chart okay so miss depan is resending the motion so now Miss Alvarez yes to make it again has to I'd like to make a motion to pull the or chart and vote separately on it second second okay can

154we have roll call okay um Miss Alvarez yes Miss dep yes Dr P yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner yes Mr Zer yes M Fabiano yes motion passes and so now I would suggest that someone makes a motion to approve all the items with the exception of the orc chart I make a motion to approve all the items except the orc chart second it was mray and Miss Ratner okay okay any questions or comments I did just um really quickly want to um thank the administration for listening to um the concerns that we brought regarding next year's calendar um for those who may have seen it on there it's not there and it will be review taking some commentary into consideration um and then brought back next month roll call please yes Miss Alvarez yes

155okay um Miss depay yes Dr peek yes Mr pero yes Mr Ratner yes Mr zner yes Mr Fabiano yes motion passes board action nine member vote we oh I apologize I got do you all no we did both did that they pul they pulled they tabled it first and then they voted on everything else no we didn't we vote on the or charart no think we voted on the or chart we V pull the or chart okay so now we need to make the motion to bring the or chart someone has to make a motion to approve okay my turn again I would like to make a motion to approve the organizational chart second was second by Mr Pay questions or comments Miss Ratner um so just looking at this I know we had spoken

156about um the state stuff and I think we had initially said we would take it off before the the State Board of Education on it's there at least from the agenda that I have um so I didn't know if I mean I don't think it exit heavily either way but I just know we had spoken about this the electorate no leaving the electorate in the New Jersey this is what comes up from the agenda so well it's not it's it's been corrected no it's been corrected got this the other day Okay this is what's on the the the agenda for the meeting we got this was that in Personnel yes okay what's on the agenda for the meeting still has that there so it's two different things I guess okay yeah it has be I'll

157have to confirm my suggestion would be since there are two different order charts that apparently were circulated um and since there's nothing pressing that requires it to be done tonight um my recommendation would be that we clear the deck so to speak and do this in March so I make a motion to so withdraw my motion yes Miss Alvarez can withdraw her motion okay but I make a motion to clear the deck and move the or chart to March would we table whatever he said whatever Miss Alvarez pulled her motion um so I think we are adequately covered yes she already she already made the motion to table it is that okay happy birthday okay so I think we can go to the next one yeah so on the board action n member vote it

158is recommended the board approve the attached board action items a through R I'm not saying anything is there a motion motion motion by Miss Ratner second by Miss depay are there any questions or comments board action nine member okay 29 okay no okay can we have a roll call please yes uh Miss Alvarez yes M depay yes Mr pero yes Miss Ratner um yes recuse on oh my gosh uh letter r um yes recuse on letter r okay um Mr zner yes Miss Fabiano yes motion passes that concludes my report Shing everybody knows s can I do a just a quick point of procedure is that what it's called point of point of order thanks so with the organizational chart I'm fine with the action we're taking but from my understanding you had made the

159motion to vote on that separately so we're not voting on it we don't need to table it even though we're not voting on it my recollection is Miss Alvarez pulled the motion so there's nothing to vote on nothing okay be corrected so we all okay thank you'll be corrected so yeah I understand what we're doing okay so what was so okay Miss alen yes business administrator's report okay um it is recommended the board action items a through L be approved by consent roll call under a 10 member vote motion second motion by Miss Alvarez second by Miss depay are there any questions or comments see m a roll call please okay um Miss alare yes to all recuse on letter B items related to The Learning Tree okay Mr depay yes to all but recuse

160on part of J where my name is there going to a um conference okay Dr Dr PE yes Mr perro yes Miss Ratner uh yes recuse on um the bill list um for uh Mr Ratner uh Mr Snider and Miss abuy liow um and then also um that's all're thank you okay um Mr Zer yes uh Miss Fabiano yes motion passes just recommended the board action items M3 Q be approved by consent roll call under a nine member vote motion second motion by Miss Alvarez second by Mr depay are there any questions or comments seeing none go ahead Miss Allen Miss Alvarez yes Miss depay yes Mr Piro yes M Ratner yes Mr ziker yes M Fabiano yes motion passes that concludes my report okay so the next item on the agenda is the board

161president's report I'm going to keep this brief brief um I do want to congratulate Miss Ratner for earning her certified and master board member certification um I one of the things that the public doesn't get to see that we do is we do attend a lot of professional development um there are a lot of meetings and trainings that we attend um and Miss Ratner has earned uh the highest level of individual certification that a board member can achieve so congratulations to miss Ratner is very well deserved um um also I know it's already been said but I do want to thank our legislators especially Senator Greenstein for setting up the meeting that we had with um commissioner damer in well in Trenton um it was very much appreciated appreciated and I'm hopeful that we were

162able to continue the conversations with her and hopefully bring in Senator goal soon so that we can have a follow-up conversation what's interesting to note in all of the conversations that we have had is um know who we are they know Monroe um and um it's good that we are able to keep our name out there for them to you know kind of get to know us and you know what our needs are so again I do we are very appreciative for their time um what sparked that initial conversation was the conversation surrounding F day kindergarten um that is a thing that I know that we have been talking about as a board for three plus years now um and it is part of our strategic plan and it has been um continuing discussions with

163Dr Chanley and Dr Layman of you know hopefully what that could potentially look like for us so um there are lots of exciting things that are happening for us and as a board and as a district and I am appreciative for everybody here um sitting at this table because it's through all of our efforts that all these things are happening so thank you to everybody um and that that's it that's my report so we're going to go to the next item on the agenda which is our other board business are there any board members who would like to speak Miss Ratner I would also like to congratulate Miss Fabiano on achieving the certified board member certification um so congratulations to her um and I also did want to share Miss Bora is this close to

164it as well she just needs to attend a delegate assembly and then she's there um when the three of us were elected you know we really said that we were going to you know really try to achieve this and I know all three of us had gotten the new board member certification um and you know I know we all do a lot of professional development so you know congratulations Miss Fabiano on achieving that as well um I also um did want to share that I do have an upcoming legislative committee meeting um in March um and I look forward to sort of hearing some of the things that are going on there one thing that was brought up um was that there was um Cor respondents sent from the state that uh no districts will

165be losing more than 3% of their funding um that hasn't really been our issue but I'm interested to see how that might affect because they have a certain amount in the budget so how that might affect us um and I know we get those numbers I believe it's at the end of this month so you know we'll cross our fingers and keep communicating fingers toes all of it um I um did want to um also I know she's not here anymore but our student board member um seaj I learned that she was cast in the role of Sebastian for The Little Mermaid at the high school um so I look forward to seeing her in that role congratulations to her um and I ultimately just wanted to you know thank everyone I know there's been

166a lot going on the last month a lot of meetings a lot of discussions um and so I really appreciate you know everything that is is being done by you know my fellow board members and administration Miss Fabiano yes M oh and Happy Birthday oh okay that's good I still think we should say that's enough it's almost over um um I know I was looking on Facebook and it was brought up at one of the county meetings that quite a few boards have gotten board certification yeah and I think I had asked at the one meeting that it's 12 or 14 meetings in attendance full board in a matter of four years so I think that's a goal we should put aside for oursel I mean there was quite a few boards that received it

167and like you said we've been working so cohesively together and I think it would do justice for us and give us the credit and Merit that we have for working so hard to be you know certified through njs ba so I think it's something to work on I appreciate that and I do we have kind of started that process by um we submitted the policy manual for review through New Jersey school boards um actually I probably should reach out to them because it's been they said six to nine months because they had so many that they were reviewing yeah um but that's one of the requirements for um for that so okay thank you anybody else Miss salare I just want to pay back on some of the comments that were made here today I'm

168really proud of this board and how cohesive we've been working together I feel like that's been a big factor in how we've been able to move forward and get heard and seen by our legislators we've gone to hearings people know Monroe people know our faces people know our issues so I just want to thank everybody on this board for being so cohesive and working together it's really a pleasure and yeah Administration as well I'm sorry I didn't mean to leave you out but the administration as well including attending these meetings with us and on short notice sometimes but we appreciate it very much Mr P I just have a couple uh things I'd like Rectify for the public uh one is high school graduation um Dr Chanley could you tell us why we moved it

169um back to Trenton instead of of having it at Ruckers why why we mov it back to Trenton of course and it was do recall what the cost was for Ruckers so off the top of my head please don't quote me it was 30,000 plus if I'm not mistaken the difference was a 20 C what was $23,000 difference does that about something difference approximately 23,00 yeah it was very sad that we had move and they incre well they also they increased their price there was like a 30% price increase from Ruckers so Ruckers was way overpriced and that's why we okay um my next question is I I don't really trying to understand that so uh originally we had the uh school calendar for next year on the agenda we had taken off who makes

170the school calendar that's a question right yeah okay so Dr Layman and I sit down we look at the school calendar we try and keep any holidays that have been given usually religious oriented we try and keep so if you get a holiday we try not to remove it okay then we look at we have to have a minimum of 180 days days we try and put in at a minimum one snow day we do look at the we do look at the calendars around us East Bruns South Brunswick North Brunswick New Brunswick one of the reasons why it was pulled is one of the questions that we were given and Dr Layman are trying and I are trying to work it out is about early dismissal days so the way early dismissal days work

171there are a few that are contractual so for example because the contract of the MTA states that they only have three evenings per year year if a teacher does more than three evenings in order to compensate them they would then have to have a early dismissal day it's not a half day because it's not half day it's early dismissal because it's a 4-Hour session so that was some one of the things the other thing is uh historically before the Jewish holidays because a Jewish holiday unlike a regular Christian holiday begins at sundown we have many uh Jewish teachers and if they get out of work at 4:00 and Su down is at 5:00 or 5:30 we've always did an early dismiss because it gives them the time to go home to have the holiday whereas

172a Christian holiday is actually on the day that you're off for the whole day so that's the other early dismissals additionally early dismissals have always been long before Dr Layman and I before Thanksgiving and the Christmas vacation so when we started looking at all these things I agreed I agreed with the board members that brought to my attention that we'd like to look and see how can we get rid of or at least change the early dismissal days so for example if you have early dismissal day for junior prom and high school senior prom why should it be for the whole District if I confirm with Miss Mo that it doesn't affect Transportation then we wouldn't have it for elementary which we know is the issue because Elementary children normally do not stay alone whereas

173middle school and high school could have early dismissal and go home additionally one of the things that I implemented when I became on when I became acting was that we gave off the week in November so normally you have school Monday Tuesday Wednesday or just mesday Monday and Wednesday I did look at the neighbor and districts a lot of them have ref for election day and some of them do not so you go to school on Monday and Wednesday for continuity of instruction having school Monday and Wednesday and not Tuesday Thursday and Friday this is my opinion really breaks up the continuity of instruction however this particular year we did work with the township and we no longer have voting in high school and we no longer have voting as a polling place in Oak

174we have two schools left we have it at Brookside and we have it at Woodland I am in the process of having my next meeting I don't know if it's going to make a difference with um the county electorate to say can you move these two polling locations because then we would be open Monday Tuesday Wednesday so when I originally looked at the calendar with Dr Layman and we were trying to make it work because one of the other holidays which we all going to be giving is the second day of Eid our neighboring districts do give the second day of Eid similar to how we have two days of Russia Shel we try to accommodate the diversity in our district so when we did that we realized that in order for us to make

175all the days that we need not graduate on the 25th by by the way I did look on South Brunswick and and a couple of districts they are graduating on the 25th and 26th um and really try and keep it as close to we trying and keep that third week we saw all of these issues so rather than just go ahead and do the and push it through forward whether we get a yes Vote or a no vote I I listened to what I heard and I agreed let let's sit down and look again to see what if anything can be done number one with the early dismissal days because there are also four other early dismissal days in the calendar that are there because we instead of having a full day off for in

176service for our teachers we do an early dismissal because we are required contractions to provide them with inservice hours and training so these are the different things that we're looking at to try and make these changes so that is why it was pulled and and you know I just want the public to understand and this this is the way I perceived it and I learned this a lot by being a board member is that um the board only approves things we don't decide who gets hired we don't decide what companies to use we don't decide what days to have off that's all done by corre Administration and then you bring it to the board and then the board either approves it or disapproves it correct okay right you I I mean I'm always open to

177hearing anything that's brought to me if we can make something creative sometimes you could just flip back you know instead of doing the week after Easter if you flip it back would you gain a day because you have to also do Passover always do Good Friday you know Easter Monday is something that we're considering Easter Monday is is not to my knowledge and I could be corrected it's not a Christian holiday but it's always something that we've been giving off long before me however all of our neighboring districts don't give it off so perhaps we would come to school on the day rather than have off completely on indigenous people Columbus Day and Veterans Day we are in by been making an early dismissal we could get rid of an early dismissal but we do

178that for anybody who wants to participate in activities because it used to be a day off so we brought it back by saying we're going to have it on the calendar but we will do it as an early dismissal day so you all correct though Mr Pio um the the Board of Education approves or does not approve they do not micromanage and get involved in the creation calendar 100% have opinions as we do in all of our meetings but they do not make those decisions Dr Layman and I really try to do the best we can to look at the neighborhood districts and and make it as best we can thank if I can just Pigg you back on on the calendar really quick um which you know I sort of mentioned like I appreciate

179you listening to the feedback and I think one thing that's really great about our board is that we have a very diverse board right we have parents that are at the elementary level high school level we have you know seniors um so we're hearing you know we have we all have our own opinions which you know I'm never shying sharing as you you guys know um and then we also hear from you know our constituents about things that they're concerned about and so ultimately while we don't create it then we can bring back you know both our feedback as well as the feedback from the community that we're hearing um you know and sort of you know it's not NE it's not guaranteed we can make everybody happy because you know there are people that

180will want to have school on Election Day and there are people who will not right and there so I think you know what we try to do is just listen to as many people as you can and you know find a solution that works for for as many as possible can I say something please um I have a daughter that teaches in New Brunswick and grandson that goes to school in East Brunswick and East Brunswick has a lot of days off and of course grandma always gets the grandson which I utterly love having him so she calls me up today and she said we got our calendar in New Brunswick today and I know you guys have been working on it and she always looks for the Easter vacation to see if it sinks with

181hers and the last two years it's been sinking East Brunswick and New Brunswick so that means I'm off the hook babysitting but I miss it because we love having him but she also told me and we were talking about graduation that New Brunswick does not pay to go to the ruter to the the rack is it called the rack Jersey mik well whatever it's a sub Arena so whatever after a sub right Jersey Mike I've been there but I can't remember um they get it for free because I guess they're part of New Brunswick but they have places in piscatway and other places or middlex but we're middle sex County and I don't understand why don't they don't give all of middle sex County free to go to the Jersey Mike Arena so I'm just

182voicing my opinion to I hope they hear that I hope that they are listening I hope you're yeah I'm sure they're up listening to me the chancellor of ruers if you're listening uh all middle sex County Schools should graduate at your your sub Arena Jersey Mike's Arena thank you Dr P uh just to kind of picky back on the calendar um as a Jamesburg resident a lot of our high schoolers go home to little kids and when the calendars don't match up sometimes those half days that we have and Monroe doesn't or just that mismatch calendar can be hard for the child care because sometimes those older kids are in charge of watching the younger ones so if we get chances to communicate ahead of time too that's always great and just so you know

183I do work with Dr valani on the calendar because we will even change our I work with her because she'll bring to my attention she'll call me and say um it doesn't work out the way you have your uh conferences we will switch conferences with her so I do work with her to try and coordinate but our contract language does provide more early dismissal days I will say that I haven't read your contract but I'm going to make that assumption so that is some of the difficulty that we deal with yes I mean I know there's all I sat down with the contract today and I'm working with Dr Layman to see what's actually written in the contract that I must follow and then some of the things um that we don't have to making

184sure that we still have the professional development and trying to meet everybody needs I want to thank Mr Payne she did make a comment to me when I walked in and she said Char can't make everybody happy we are really trying very hard to be respectful of everybody's choices you know whether or not that week in November works it would be fabulous if we could just get the last two schools not to have voting and then we'd have 3 days of continuous instruction so we're really going to try we're going to we're going to take another shot at it and take some more time to really look at it listening to some of the opinions that I received but ultimately um the decision um we we present it for approval it is the recommendation of

185the superintendent and then the board makes the decision through their voice of a yes or no vote thank you thank you and thank you Mr Pi for bringing that up making it clear that it's not me that makes these decisions but that you bring them to us and we approve or like you said disapprove um anybody else okay then we are going to our second our third public forum of the night um any member of the public wishing to speak you have four minutes to do so please state your name and municipality for the record Jessica ISO Monro I think it's a little closer maybe tilt it up oh the clock was taken um the lack of communication with parents has led me here to bring awareness to the December 19th bus accident and the

186ongoing circumstances surrounding it kids can be a little wild at the end of the day but I have watched these kids act with impunity this year beginning with the first day of school when about 30 of them forced their way off a bus on a dead end Street and stampeded haphazardly up a main road it was such a spect that it was reported on social media in the following months they would mock the driver with racial slurs spray everyone with water and Gatorade screaming that it was urine and semen they would throw things spray cologn whip seat belts in October a boy shouted at a girl to jump out the window and kill herself and the screaming I always knew when the afternoon bus arrived I could hear the screaming from a block away inside

187my home the day before the crash I was told a Stanley Thermos was being thrown around the around near the driver this was typical Behavior I urge parents to review the related police report The Habit described in the minutes leading up to the crash is what was referred to by many children as a calm day go read what calm was on that bus there was no control though most parents were unaware of what their kids and driver had to endure on a regular basis few parents were and we did express our concerns I called transportation in October and I emailed School administrators on November 21st detailing the behavior on that bus and asking for help because I was AF afraid they would cause an accident we had relief for a day but nothing stopped them

188an investigation by the bus safety division in Trenton revealed zero communication between ABC and the district before the crash in response ABC's corrective action plan includes reporting all infractions to the school so that's why no one raised the alarm that the bus company wasn't reporting these kids they weren't required to weeks after the crash we switched to a District bus but our Aid was removed the same day the kids quickly resumed their usual Antics un ated until parents reported them to Administration this is what got us into the first crash so much for updating protocols and operating procedures last Monday I asked what would be done to stop this and if we would get an aid on the bus again but there was no response as usual the next day our kids reported to us

189that an aid was back but again no communication Keeps Us Vigilant it's frustrating to keep asking for information and getting no response but that's why I'm here the whole experience has exposed a larger problem that isn't isolated to our route parents and students should not carry the burden of keeping our buses safe administrators quickly respond to parent concerns but there needs to be follow through to ensure the bus stays in order and our drivers clearly need more support to do their job safely it's the same as making the kids wear seat belts after the crash then slacking off just to enforce it again last week when there's an issue there's no consistent oversight knowing that the accident was preventable and the cause is ongoing I can't rest assured and neither can my kids we don't

190need your empty assurances we need a districtwide corrective action plan that Bridges the communication gap between buses and schools so the bus contract that is meant to keep everyone safe can actually be enforced what steps are you taking to get that done and can you confirm that our Aid will be permanent so we can finally feel at ease [Applause] [Music] this has nothing to do with anticipated litigation I don't know why we can't get any it actually has everything to do with anticipated litigation I'm trying to figure out a way that you can get some answers so just bear with me for one moment thank [Music] you for that particular okay thank you so as as part of our uh plan of action moving forward the aid was placed back on the bus the aid

191will remain on the bus for the remainder of the school year um in regards to that particular bus thank you you're welcome there any other members of the public wishing to speak this will be two-part first part is this the last board under Christy scurby broke the law many a times we had we the district spent thousands of dollars to defend a court case where the board illegally appointed a board member on January 21st the commissioner of Education just released another decision that says the superintendent was illegally extended on contract twice in 2022 the commissioner of Education said that those contracts must be revoted on by the Board of Education let me jog your memory while on those illegal contracts the superintendent recommended herself for a permanent position that was approved then when the illegal

192board member was brought on he was the deciding vote to extend the superintendent contract two almost two years early the pattern of unlawfulness out of the last board is just it's it's it's I don't even know how to describe it but it continues to unfold even with a new board in place we're finding about all of the illegal acts that the last board did so my question is and you can answer it when I get to the next part when is this board going to follow the commissioner of education's decision on January 21st and revote on the two illegal contracts that were given to the superintendent in 2022 and if those contracts don't pass I have no idea if they will or they will not are the members of this public going to be refunded

193the money for those illegal contracts I would like to know as a taxpayer because in anything in this world there's a contract and there's a repercussion of final repercussion the Department of Education and the commissioner of education and the court system just ruled that those contracts given to Chanley under Chrissy scurvy's board leadership were illegal no different than the e-legal board member appointment you can answer my question after the second part of this is the transportation I cannot sit back as a parent who's gone through the same things with my son on the bus and hear silence and see nothing being done because you're afraid of legal action we don't care about illegal action legal action that's going to come when kids get nearly killed on a bus because you don't take action when parents

194bring It Forward okay I don't care I as a parent M deorum you need to maintain deorum atone because you ignore parents when they bring these things forward it is unexcusable so you can sit quiet and you can make excuses about legal we're going to get sued yes you're going to get sued because kids were close to being killed and if that tree didn't stopped that bus it would have rolled and children could have been killed so I'll say this and I'll ask this question to the board right now there are seven of you here who will make a motion at this board me at this board meeting tonight to call for an independent investigation where you bring an outside attorney or an outside expert to come in and see what is being done to

195prevent this moving forward what is being done to fix what happened what is being done to make sure that this doesn't happen again will any one of you seven board members make that motion to bring in an outside person to investigate I'm all ears I would bring that motion for an investigation absolutely your time is up is there an answer on the first part about when you'll vote on the illegal contracts your time is up silence there any other members of the public wishing to speak Michelle McDonald modern Township I was here last month and I said what I wanted to say about the bus accident and now here we are a month later and I still have no answers so my question today is as a parent who had two children on that bus

196who now come home and say what's happening sometimes we have an aid sometimes we don't what's my answer for them are these parents me and all the other parents going to get some direct communication about what happened and what's being done to fix it the same statement I cannot discuss the situation but I will tell you there will be an aid on that bus for the remainer of the school year okay but what else is happening about the children that are misbehaving on the bus children that are misbehave when a code of conduct is infringed upon we are not at Liberty to discuss anybody else's child I'm not asking you to discuss anybody else's child the code of conduct is followed and you would not know because we are not at Liberty to discuss other

197people's children and I apologize for that understood you're not allowed to to discuss other people's children from what I know based on what my children tell me if you're following that code of conduct these children shouldn't be on the bus anymore I'm just going to make a blanket I'm just going to make a general statement in general removal from bus from a bus comes with various different infractions there are other forms of consequences which could be suspension after school detention um and everything is specific to the child so although I totally respect what your kids say and I'm sure a lot of what they say is absolutely true they would and I mean that sincerely I do because I'm a mother too but I will let you know that um detailed records are being kept

198and appropriate consequences are given when appropriate and I I can't discuss okay and you can't tell me whether there will be any communication to the parents the parents not not the township as a whole the parents who were affected by this my children who come home and say oh the bus driver's speeding because they're scared of course they're scared will there ever be any communication to the parents so the communication to the parents is the same communication from any bus so for example I understand what you just said the bus driver speeding I I yes the bus driver speeding and I've emailed about that with no response so what I need to know is will the parents ever be EMA emailed about or or phone called or whatever about what happened on December 19th at

199this time I I have because it's been months with nothing okay so according to the principle of the school I called and spoke with the parents of the children that were taken to the hospital I called and spoke to the scho yeah there were children who went to the hospital after that first day just so you know and that's correct and I wasn't informed of that that but I will let you know that according to the principal every parent received a phone call from the principal or the assistant principal or the school counselor because we also asked that every child be called down on a regular basis to speak with the counselors regarding how they felt if they were upset and so forth I and I have no problem with the fact that that they

200were asked how they felt and knew that they could speak to somebody if they were having problems with it that's a whole other issue that they were spoken to though about the accident and what caused it without their parents being there that's a whole separate issue that's not thank you okay thank you could I make a comment if I understood her I believe she was at the last meeting and said that she never received any phone call in reference to the accident believe did I don't I don't know if yeah if there's any if there's nobody else wishing to speak we're going to close the public forum is anybody else wishing to speak okay then we will close the public forum um there is no second closed session so we move on to our next

201scheduled Board of Education meeting which is March 17th 2025 um can I have a motion to adjourn motion second all those in favor I good night everybody

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.