CorpusRecord 132938

Monroe Township Board of Education 10.15.14 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
20,845 words · about 116 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which stands Nation Under godis with liy and justice for all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski Miss anelis Mrs armeno here Mr Braverman yes Mr Chella here Mr calman here Mrs colano here Mr noin here Mr Po here Mr proso Mr zareski here Madame board president you have a quorum present this evening thank you very much in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro town board of education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted October 10 2014 one at all schools two

002home News Tribune three cranberry press and four filed with the clerk of the municipality and at this time we will go to our student board members reports and I believe we have a new student board member with us this evening for the first time Junior yes Mr Nicholas right correct thorney well congratulations and welcome to the Board of [Applause] Education good evening everyone um it's been a busy week here at the high school it is spirit week and the high school football team has their homecoming game this Friday at 7 so come out and support the Falcons Deca chapter officers attended a leadership development conference today where they learned how to lead effectively and how to positively change themselves in order to make an impact Within schools um the sophomores and juniors had PSAT testing

003today the monor Township High School girls field hockey team is currently undefeated so congrats to the girls and keep up the good work the green Fair took place this past weekend at Oak Tree School while the weather put a damper on some fun activities like the Bike Rodeo inside the gym there was a variety of other booths and fun activities for families to take part in while learning sustainable practices at the same time and the monor Township High School drama club is putting on a fall showcase about great songs and scenes so try to come out and enjoy the great show uh the monor Township High School will be holding its uh second annual Club Rush on Friday October 17th allowing students to learn more about the wide variety of clubs uh that the high

004school has to offer uh also the monor Township High School future Business Leaders of America club and conjunct in conjunction with other mths clubs is organizing a haunted High School event uh for the younger children in the district proceeds will be donated to the mama May Breast Cancer Foundation in support of Breast Cancer Awareness Month um and to conclude the student report uh just to introduce myself my name is Nicholas thne and I will have the pleasure of serving as the junior class's student board member thank you thank you and welcome again okay we will go to the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone give your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 3 minute time limit of course

005Mark Klein seven crore the enrollment uh there's a lot of rumors going around of uh how much overcrowding we have in the schools uh can you basically break down the schools and what the situation is the reason why I bring that up is uh I don't know if Mr Trill was able to report on this from the planning board but uh the develop M That was supposed to be built on Mount Mills and spots with Englishtown road which consisted of 529 apartments and condos um they took us to court and uh the settlement was that based on a percentage of the commercial property that they get leas they develop and get leas they're allowed a certain percentage of these family units to be built but the same Builder is building on per well um put

006an application in for Pineville Road and Route 33 which was turned down by the planning board that's the one that they took to court and the settlement on that was no restrictions in other words they can start my not to my knowledge and maybe Mr terella can uh can explain it to my knowledge there are no restrictions which means they can start building right away so it's something that you're going to have to keep in mind along with all the developments in that part of town that they're building I don't know what you're going to do for schools so uh I don't want to take up your time now but I'd like to get a breakdown of what the overcrowded situation is and then when we come back into a public forum later I'll go

007down a breakdown of something that broke on the news today which is very interesting thank you very much I don't think we have that information for us today at this meeting the breakdown okay I can get that another time okay Madam Mr Gorski um Mr Klein today is October 15th today we will conduct student counts through all of our schools and Report the Assa to the state we're going to then update all of our um enrollment studies with that very relevant new data I could provide you with the district that we have on hand but I don't have that I'll get the office and just the last thing which is part of this is um per booy it was just announced in the home news today that they're going to build a high school for

008$19 $ million paid for by the state and we know what happened with New Brunswick with their high school with their Elementary School we know last year we needed expansions and new schools and they do nothing for us so that's something I'll bring up later on okay thanks M thank you thank you good evening stepen Ryback 23 Riviera I'm a board of education candidate I'd like to speak to on page 16 Roman number a five board action number four I proudly signed the recently circulated petition against redistricting as proposed because it represents a positive step forward for our citizens it also demonstrates the need for a greatly improved line of communication between the school board and our community we must amend processes that could potentially impact our schools to best ensure the board is Consulting

009and brainstorming possible solutions with its community members especially the board creates an ad hoc committee which is told its input and expertise would help shape a recommendation it's not enough to offer a yes or no vote to the members of this committee without a true voice at the table or use of its expertise when possible solutions are to be developed this board of education must create a culture that Embraces meaningful interactions and communication within the community you are voted into office by the residents listened to stakeholders and Pro prove to them that their input is valued thank you anyone else from the public Robert roach J team mfield in Boulevard I would just like to uh say that the the young ladies who have always been the student Representatives have look very nice and I

010just like to compliment your new the new young man there he's very looks very professional thank you thank you looks it's our new dress code [Applause] right anyone else from the public wishing to speak Lou Masters and I'm Mel Court um since it is on the agenda I was going to wait but um I've been reading a lot of this stuff on Facebook and I've really in my entire tenure on the board and being in t I've never seen just a negative reaction to a community trying to do the right thing I've been on the ad hoc since the exception of ad hoc which was two years ago we've been doing this for two years prior to that I was on the the Strategic committees that fed into the ad hoc the community outreach fiscal

011accountability with Michelle a couple other people that are here um I was also on the board when we received the recommendations from the ad hoc it went through buildings and grounds or the the committee that it had to go through and then was processed through the board the ad hoc Committee just made recommendations to the board they have no power the board has the power for two years again the the Ed hoc committee has been coming together they've been gathering information we've been touring schools we've been talking about issues we've been arguing about issues uh working together doing what we thought was right uh and in the best best interest of the schools in the town we've had multiple tasks and recommendations along the way I have all the meeting minutes we did the uh

012stop Gap measure we did stuff like that that was implemented and it's helping uh with growth um and again the overall task was the goal was to bring the community together and get some stakeholders involved and figure out what to do with this growth that we're experiencing um with the final wreck the board that's coming around tonight we have a big problem um and I think what's Happening Here is it's being used as a political tool by certain people in the in the community um it's not about children of growth it's no longer about children of growth it's taken on it's about votes now plain and simple if you don't want to hear it that's what it's about two years of the community coming together now and working hard is being called a sham that

013wasn't worth it two years and some of those people that are calling it a sham been on it for a couple months for the sake of the of a campaign sound bite people are willing to discount two years worth of work by 20-some people at one point it up to 27 27 Township community people coming together making recommendations to try to improve the school district that's all it was the Recs tonight from the ad hoc committee are simply requests for the board to be proactive which we've everybody's always yelled at us the board has never been proactive now we're trying to do that we've always been called a reactive board and too late now there's a chance to get ahead I don't like to see kids being moved around schools are a community they're a

014family my kids are in a certain school they love the kids they go to school with I agree with that you don't want to see this happen I agree but it's a chance right now to get ahead even a little bit of this growth we're experiencing now some of these issues that we're talking about Facebook antisocial Network that it is is politically politically fueled fearmongering and it's getting in the way of what we have to do the ad hoc committee made recommendations to do redistricting or to look into redistricting and I think we have to try to work together and discuss it instead of all this BS that's going on on Facebook people complaining um telling lies telling all kinds of wild stories about what's happening I really think we need to come together as

015a community and talk this out thank you Mr [Applause] Masters good evening Chrissy scurby 8 seminal Court um as a member of the ad hoc committee I stand here tonight and want to express my support for the school district along with the other parent groups represented here tonight we work tirelessly in the name of the children to provide the very best for our schools we are asking the board to look closely at the proposed redistricting plan we feel that the numbers represented in this report do not take into consideration the growth Pro projections for Monroe on the mount Mills on the mil Lake Woodland side of town alth those student enrollment dropped by approximately 35 to 40 students at mil Lake Woodland this year the schools do not have the capacity for 225 new students

016along with students coming in from a 500 unit condo development going up on Mount Mills Road Ross habber stated during his presentation to the ad hoc committee that he did not factor in the 500 unit condo development into his plan he presented to us we are asking the board to have this development considered when coming up with a redistricting plan we do not want to be here 2 years from now now asking you to reduce the class sizes at mil Lake and Woodland because the plan backfired additionally we do not think it is right to split up the third grade between mil Lake and Woodland School lastly this plan does not address the immediate need of the middle school students are overcrowded in classrooms at the middle school which poses huge issues around the Lunch

017Period the Board needs to focus on a solution immediately for that thank you thank you anyone else wishing to speak good evening Ira tesler 11l at trive I am not a candidate for Board of Ed I thought you funny um I find it very interesting that um now that we're in election season people use issues like redistricting for their own personal agenda I was on the ad hoc committee Mr Rybeck voted for the registrating plan so why would he sign a petition against it that's kind of odd thanks anyone else on the public no we're not going to have a debate [Music] okay do you have something new to add to M sure enough okay Mark Klein s cruncher uh Chrissy the 52 unit on Mount Mills I believe that's going to be on a

018back burner because of M Mr Klein you address the Board of Education okay I'm sorry of um they're going to have to build and lease commercial property but if what really happened at the planning board and I'm going to Source all the information the one that you have to concern yourself with is the same Builder building on pinville road to Route 33 that's going to be 749 family units that's in the part of town where all the growth is that's where all your family communities are being built so you're going to affect Apple goth and oak tree and that's where we really got to do something I think oak tree you have enough room that you can expand it Apple gooth I don't know what you're going to do and you're probably going to need

019new schools um I'm just going to go over what I have now and then I I'll leave you alone knowing that Perth Amoy now is approved for $190 million to build a high school we know when this school was being built uh New Brunswick was building a high school it was $187 Million I believe the capacity was about 200 more students than our school and they were at 187 million and this board built the high school Under what the budget was I think it came in a little over 120 million and people complained also in new Bruns there were three elementary schools built totally paid for by the state something I've complained about all along is enough is enough we need schools we need expansions the state has to work with us my last statement

020is and I've mentioned this many times all children no matter where they live are worth the same and should be treated equally if the state is able to spend billions of dollars on the 31 abbit tile one school districts each year and then also pays for their new schools we should receive our fair share of school funds school aid and we should receive a major amount of money towards on new schools and expansion and I don't know what we have to do that the the uh the Senate 2307 that was a smoke screen that was done for votes and not here done for votes at the state something has to be done my opinion and the parents who are here are going to disagree with me is you cut what we don't need you hear

021yet to be educated you're not here to play sports you're not here to do music and you can boo me if you want when the state starts to see thank you when the state starts to see that we can no longer support these programs on the back of taxpayers maybe they'll get off their tails and do something but all we have proven in none of the years before I got on the board the years I was on the board and the years now is that we could run a highly successful School District District without hitting a state for money I'm done I heard thank you I I will say though was that both um the high school and Oak Tree school was done on time and under budget absolutely yes anyone else from the public

022we gonna just take turns in a circle numbers for you oh sorry L Masters and I'm Michaela just to capitalize what Mark said in case you don't know there's a new bill in front of these L 3724 um uh Dan Benson uh asked me to kind of talk about it so we can draw some support what it's doing is it's trying to add um what do they call it they have a nice little name for it um converted development assistance Aid all the developments that were converted because of the Sno act school districts will get uh a certain amount of money up to what they cost per student times the students that are coming out the realistic numbers that are coming out of there this just went in September 2 second I believe he's been

023asking a lot of us we're supporting it uh my group um D'Angelo is on it Linda's on it uh Sweeny's on it I think even Bonnie's on it so they're all trying to push this through to give Aid to to places like Monroe like what Mark said um that are kind of getting the uh the shaft because of some of these converted um developments so again 3724 it's something good to look up and maybe write your legislators and really push it's something we could use it'll directly I mean if you look at some of the numbers we're talking this would be tens of millions of dollars that would come our way okay thank you do anybody have any more comments to the agenda David Kini uh five ellingham Avenue uh I am kind of new

024to all of this uh I'm an assistant principal uh out on Staten Island I would disagree with Mark in terms of extracurricular programs I think we do need to keep them and I think you have a very difficult job uh in just in regards to redistricting uh my daughter just started at U mil Lake she's been there in her first grade she loves uh Mrs worth and I would just hate to imagine uh the idea of students that are going to be in the third grade that's split half going to one school half going to another school and the sense of community that's kind of torn apart she loves where she goes uh I think it's really important to keep that Synergy and um we just built this beautiful new building and the idea that

025we're sitting here and talking about we need to build more new buildings then this was something that came up when we had I believe the School Board elections where is the school board's voice when we're talking about all of the all of the new developments that are going on and how are we working in in collaboration with that to make sure that we're not coming back every two years asking the taxpayers for more money or putting up by Bond and and again I might not know all the facts so I apologize for anything I'm not accurately capturing but the idea that we're continuing to come back 2 years after building this unbelievable facility to ask for more space let's build up another place how are we taking care of it and how are we making

026sure we have maybe the accurate data that was referenced earlier so that we're not making this same conversation two years down the road thank you I I just want to say too um the board of education's responsibility is to educate every child that comes into this District we have nothing to do with the development of this Township that is a municipal government they have their own rules and responsibilities we do have a member of the board Mr cherella who's on the planning board as a private citizen not as a board member we also have Mr Masters who is on the zoning board so we're working with the township they understand our or difficulties but again it's two different governmental entities and we have our Ro rules that we have to follow and they have theirs

027and and and that makes complete sense uh however to to think that one obviously ly doesn't marry really importantly with the other and and again I can't say that I've gone to all the zoning board meetings to say who's been there and taking attendance but I know that was a really direct comment that was made out to the board and uh to the El at least the elected officials uh last year and no one wanted to say that they would be the ones to go to those zoning board meetings and again I just think it's really incumbent especially because schooling seems to be one of our largest issues and we must be doing something right our Township continues to grow and I'm and I'm sure my time is up but you know we still need

028to make sure that we're getting our voices out there and you play a big role in that Stephen Ryback 23 Rivier I just want to clarify something um about the atot committee I voted no for the uh redistricting and I voted no because myself and U many other people on the atot committee felt that our expertise was not used um I went to just a few meetings but I heard at that meeting that through the other meetings um many people uh were not given a chance to uh look into information and express how they felt and while uh I want to be clear while redistricting may have to happen I just didn't want the plan that was offered because I knew the data had changed the numbers had changed so I voted uh no on

029that redistricting plan that was proposed by the demographer uh and I just want to be clear on that thank you thank you um Mr Klein you've already already been here twice right but I just want to explain somebody brought up the solo act most people here have no idea what the solo act is how it I know but it's not on the agenda so it's all pertaining to the same thing that they've spoken about I'll be done in two minutes no we we hold that for the next what's that follow the rules we will hold it to the Mr Klein I you follow the rules Mr cin okay M Mr M I'm not no not getting into an argument cuz last time I got to an argument that was on 1015 you want me to

030hold this for later I'll hold it for later no problem that's all I was ask no problem but he's out of order by the way I know I and I'm going to say please don't do that again we we won't do that again hi um Morin draig 19 Tree Tops Drive um I just want to make a comment about the redistricting um I feel that as parents we really weren't that informed and I don't think there was enough transparency we don't even know what this plan is all about are you're going to allow us to review it before a vote is taken there's not going to be a vote taken today there is no plan there there's no plan no and in my board president's report I will be talking about I think commit there's

031the concern is there's a lot of miscommunication um and I went on to Ross haers Associates and a lot of the information they gave is that the district along with Administration should really keep the public informed absolutely there hasn't been anything on the website as far as there's nothing to put on the there's nothing from the ad hoc and all the planning any updates or any information there's no information to share with us no at in fact the ad hoc Committee just met on the 30th and they will be bringing their recommendations to the board this evening so we we as an ad hoc committee we know what they are but the board does not know what the recommendations when does the community get to be involved were involved in the ad I'm talking a

032few people were parents lar community in the public who wish to be on that ad hoc committee okay but in viewing the website your Board website there's very limited information unless it's hidden in the agenda or in um documents it's very difficult to find and that that's just what I want to say there's very limited transparency okay excuse me [Applause] unless you have something different to say we're gonna I just want to clarify uh could you please leave your give your name and address chy scurby 8 seminal Court under item H number four it says receive review and act on the recommendations of the ad hoc committee are is the board going to be acting on them you just said no then why is that in the agenda receive review and act on the recommendations

033we can can act on it by doing nothing so we need to get right we will be getting a report today from the ad hoc committee the board can accept that report or it cannot accept that report right and if it's accepted it will be acted on as the lady before me just had mentioned that yes it will be acted on den and I would just like to say as a member of the ad hoc committee like Steve had said I voted no for the proposal for the reasons why I brought up already other parent parents on that did as well because we felt again that the numbers in that report did not reflect what's truly going on so again I just want to reiterate to the board if you can please when you get

034that recommendation really look into those numbers because the parents that were on that board the majority of us voted no that evening for that reason yes we do agree it would be lovely to redistrict and have 20 22 kids in classes we don't see that with the numbers that were presented to us and leaving out developments that are coming in out of that report is is a grave mistake so again the there were a lot of parents on that committee there were other parent leaders from parent groups from the Middle School we voted no to this recommendation Mrs scurby if I may as the superintendent I understand that obviously there's a lot of misinformation out there regarding the the reporting as well as the ad hoc commit committee and the intent of the ad hoc

035committee being on the ad hoc committee for the past couple of years I think what's happening right now is that it's premature and it's too emotional so right now is that obviously a lot of the parents on either sides of the chairs maybe the senior citizens on either side of the chairs but you don't have the right information at the very least what we should do out of respect to Mr hoki and obviously as the chairperson of the ad hoc committee and to the members of the ad hoc committee is wait for Mr homoki's recommendation to the Board of Education at that time obviously it's being received by the Board of Education they'll receive it not receive it whatever it is that's the board action after that that's when the process actually begins if there's

036a question about let's say the demographers report or the statistics or the data that's there well the N it come out but that's the board's prerogative then and if you want to make some suggestions then help the board make the right decisions but as of right now I understand that obviously it's a concern it's an emotional reaction but don't let that cloud the issue what has to happen tonight is that the ad committee the chairperson Mr hoki has to make the recommendation to the Board of Education they receive it the process begins as we do this I just want everybody in the community just to keep in mind we have to make some serious decisions coming up as a principal of Brookside school that was redistricting as a principal of oak tree school that was

037redistricting as the principal of apagard school that was redistricting what you should know that that in a community sense is that a community that's thriving redistricting will happen all the time it does a district that is downsizing redistricting happens as well too you can think about closing schools or you can think about building schools but redistricting is happening all the time with that said you should also just keep in mind and I understand that some parents may want this school or that school Etc and the principal is all in the back right now and all the other administrative teams are here as well too but you should just know is that the quality of Education in each of our schools is exceptional ask anybody so if you have let's say one parent that goes to

038Barkley Brooks School if you have one parent that goes let's say to Barkley Brook School and because of the fact that they're satisfied with the culture and the academics there and their child is having a great time at that school and it's a great learning environment they're happy there of course they don't want their child to move move but I can attest to the fact that every school is an exceptional School institution don't don't don't not think about that that I think that's the most important thing redistricting will happen but at least tonight please what you're doing right now is you're just wasting time let Mr homoki make his report then obviously as an ad hoc chairperson to the board of vet that has to take place first thank [Applause] you Jody decide to Northwind

039Court um I just want to say I just want to urge the board to make sound decisions on whatever it is I think we're all just up here con as concerned parents um whether it be redistricting or referendum um I was at the ad hoc committee committee meeting for a short while and something really responsible that came up was um Mr poy had said something about the possibility of an intermediate school something that has the most impact on the community as a whole and that we can get the most behind I think what's out right now people are just questioning it so much it's causing unease um we just want to be informed and educated and again we want the best chance like was that was mentioned at the referendum about the referendum that we

040need to take the steps towards what has the best chance to be successful and um I just want the board to to come together and realize that thank you thank you Jody anyone else wishing to speak seeing no one we will close public forum and we will go to the park presentation Mr ventell who's doing the park okay would you please use the yes okay okay good evening my name is Dr Kelly Rosell I'm the supervisor of language arts World Language and media literacy uh Bonnie castelletto who is the supervisor of science and social studies and Sue Gasco who is the supervisor of math and education educational technology uh we're going to review the Park website uh some of you may be familiar with its contents others this may be the first time you're seeing

041it uh but this is one piece in our step towards Park preparation that we want to introduce not only members of the board of education but also members of the public too so on the on the homepage this is awkward okay on the homepage we have a timeline uh of when Park assessments began development which was actually in 2010 uh we began having more serious conversations about the park assessments last year and of course this year this year will be the first time that students are assessed in the spring uh they will take two types of Assessments ch gu you can go to the assessment tab in March students in grades 3 through 8 will take performance-based assessments uh in language arts that's a literary analysis task a research simulation task and a narrative task

042for the mathematics um one of the key components is the the PBA which is otherwise known as the performance-based assessment is going to be an open-ended problem solving application task that they're going to do um pretty much the whole thing is going to be like that um it's going to have higher level critical thinking um their very very much reading comprehension is going to be involved and they're going to be hands scored which is why that those are the earlier ones the second assessment which is going to is called the eoy it's known as the end of the year assessment that will include 90% of the material where the first one includes 70% of the material uh the rationale for the 90% % is that we obviously want to do 100% of the material but

043it gives them leeway in case one type of concept is not on there from year to year um that that that's the general consensus that they're using that one is going to be completely machine scored and the idea is that there should be a quicker turnaround on that one and that's why that's going to be the one that's going to be end of May early or end of April early May when they're doing that one um in those type of Assessments there's going to be three types they call them task one two or three in the assessments and that's going to have the level of complexity that goes along with them technology okay as far as the technology con component um that's obviously one of the main concerns across the state um the what we're

044going to do in this district is grades three through eight which is the elementary and the Middle School are going to be using personal computers um every student is going to have headphones that go along with it for the accountability um um for the different types of I'm losing my words here uh the different types of accessibility I'm sorry accessibility that they're going to have to use them the high school will use iPads it will not be the ones that the students have there's going to be ones that they have that are set just for the park so they cannot have extra apps on there that they could use and they will use the earbuds that they've been given throughout the year in terms of the mathematics grades 3 through five will not have a

045calculator component which originally they were going to have that grades 6 through 8 we'll have a calculator component that will be for function for grades six and seven and scientific for grade 8 the high school the algebra 1 geometry and Algebra 2 will have graphing calculator components that will mimic the ti84 and those are going to have drop- down menus with them for the language arts one of the most significant differences between the assessments students previously took and the assessments they take now is the addition of of multiple sources uh so students May view video clips they may see still images that's part of the technology in the language arts in the English language art section uh students will take two types of multiple choice questions one is a selected response another is a technology

046enhanced response so students might be asked to click and drag different statements to create a summary of a passage that they have read when students create their Pros construct response in response to literature they will have the features available to them similar to what is in any word processing whether it's Microsoft Word um or Max Pages they have the ability to have bullets numbers uh to change uh whether it's bold or italics and most importantly a spell checker and that is because students have those tools available to them um every day and their ability to use those tools is also uh part of the assessment process um Bonnie caletto is going to talk about the resources available to our Educators to um parents and to students as we continue our Park preparation good evening everyone

047the purpose of our sharing this with you tonight is to begin a process of educating you about how these tests will roll out and how it will engage our students so one of the um core components of the new website that we put up and I hope that you'll begin to explore because there are some really great resources located here is the resource tab so Chris if you'll click on that resource tab for us please okay great so what we have here is a scaffolding of uh hyperlinks that you will be able to explore that will take you to some pages that will give you further information and then I think it is the intention of Sue Kelly and to come back and give you periodic updates and ask you to join us on this

048journey as we begin to prepare our students for the park assessment in this spring okay thanks everyone thank you Mr Kaufman yeah uh ladies before you walk away um back in the um August curriculum meeting we had talked about the park assessment and getting the word out to the parents while I know we have a lot of folks here tonight uh can you tell me what the date is when we're going to have the parent night out for the park assessment we're still working with the calendars for the parent nights what we have organized um is the professional development for teachers so for example in the past two weeks uh I've been working with Middle School teachers in the upcoming weeks I'll be working with grades three to five teachers so that they can also

049engage um more thoroughly in those conversations with parents uh but we are still in the planning stages of the the parent meeting because we want to avoid as many conflicts as possible with conferences Games extracurriculars Etc okay and I think we also spoke at the time about having some type of executive level type of material while the content that's out there is very deep I know a lot of our parents are going to really know what what do I as a parent need to know without digging through all of this so like an executive overview quick type of stuff like an FAQ or ex summary you know 90% of the parents are here what what do they need to know that's to affect them and and all the other stuff for the 10 centers that

050will go out to every link that's out there and click on the links of the links that are links on links okay to get every possible known information to man but okay you know provide a service to all the parents because they're the ones that are going to be impacted a lot too absolutely okay thank you anyone else from the board have a questionin obviously there's a lot of trepidation uh from the public I I get that and I would be the same way if I my my children were were impacted by this um I think it's imperative that we keep the parents of you know on the right track so that they know exactly where we're going with this and uh to alleviate any fears any concerns that they have and really be proactive

051in with regard that you're doing a great job and we appreciate it but we really really need to keep them you know on on on board with this one of the one of the reasons why we created the Park website was because when we personally look at the material that's out there from the state and from Park it's very overwhelming and very uh there's just a lot of it to look at so what we did is while it looks like there's a lot of links we've taken the pieces that we think are the most important and the most helpful uh we've tried to streamline the website and our plan is to update slowly so that the roll out just keeps continuing and keeps happening but we're not overwhelming anybody at anyone shot um and we've

052learned because with the park there's Park online which is one of the links that we've sent the teachers to their first initial response is where am I supposed to go what am I supposed to look at so we're trying to handpick the pages that we think that are most helpful and uh when we're educating the teachers as time goes on and we're educating the students and that's why we're going to do the parents next um I can tell you though as terms of the parent night um we want to do it in the fall so we're looking at probably November hopefully not too into to December but we have to watch um like I said all the different activities and the conferences and the games we want to make it so the most amount of

053people can be there that want to be there great Tom that was the original for that exact reason you spoke of that was the original reason we brought up the park night because you really need great idea this is a great forum and people maybe watch 28 on their way from 27 to 29 right um but really the the stakeholders here are the parents and we need to set up a special night so that they know it's scheduled plan for it come out if you want to know everything there is to know about bark that's theight and to a sage concerns as well um we feel tested in the spring we were one of the fortunate districts to have field tested in the spring uh it was incredibly successful not only um students response to

054it um but also the teachers with whom I spoke uh students use words like liked and interesting which you do not frequently hear with assessments and a great deal of the trepidation that surrounds the technology our students did not seem to have any issues with it they were um fluent in the technology that they needed um and we filling in any gaps where there might be Mr Mino yes I I think it's great to get out in front of this in the fall but uh right before the park could there be another um assessment or or opening for the parents you know right before like maybe in February or something like that or a hotline that the parents know for two hours or three hours uh you know in the spring they so the parent

055you know you can you can learn something and then months later when the time comes I think You' start to Panic again so if you can have another uh public form or some ability for the parents to maybe ask some of the final questions or just maybe a review of what's gone on in the fall maybe you can see some of the uh hot button issues or the main questions and just review in the spring right before I think that would take a lot of anxiety off and again I don't know if it makes sense but some type of hotline definitely we also spoke about um recording the session are having screencasts or being um and having those accessible on the website because obviously not every everybody would be able to um attend in person

056and we always encourage um parents to reach out um to us when they need information thank you email or call they could email or call anytime they want absolutely okay but to concentrate it on on you know right before so people won't have that anxiety I think our goal is to do this at multiple stages that's great thank you very much thank you okay at this time we will go to the approval of the minutes for the special public Board of Education meeting of August 23rd 2014 there a Mr Braverman Miss armeno actually any additions or Corrections all in favor I opposed extensions Mr Koffman abstains and the approval of the minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of September 10th 2014 no moved Mr noin M armino any additions or Corrections all in

057favor opposed abstain Mr cherel abstains and committee reports are there any committees that need to report this evening Mr Kaufman I know you do sure we had a curriculum meeting this evening um uh Dennis let us know that we're going to have to make a slight change to accommodate some Park testing in the school calendar and that's going to be coming down the pike later on uh we also looked at curriculum documents for the following French one accelerated math grade 5 project-based learning math grade 6 math Advantage Program grade six Math Advantage Program grade seven math Advantage Program grade 8 as well as speech for K12 ESL for K12 strength and conditioning one I'm sorry two thank you um health and fitness uh education grade six and Falcon Pal's adaptive physical uh education program um

058for those of you don't who don't know I don't think I would do it justice and he's probably going to kill me for it but Greg if you're still here could you talk about two minutes about what the Pal's program is is he did he run did he's gone okay he may have left um we'll come back to the public to present what that is I don't want to I I would have no way of doing it justice but it's an incredible program where we interact students with special needs and some of the other seniors to do uh physical athletic programs uh together um small classes it's really an unbelievable program that they have here so uh kudos to the team for uh putting this forward um additionally we uh looked at a few clubs

059that are being asked to be put on the roster um science National Honor Society Zumba club uh TCH event um which is a Technology based uh type of event um it's a technology type of club uh we got all the information that we have as far as the signup sheets uh we are getting very strict with the clubs as far as uh increasing the requirements for not just folks that are wanting to start a club but also to make sure that at the end of the initial uh year that the buyback or the benefit of the club is really assessed to make sure it's worthy of continuing on and ultimately getting funding these are not going to cost anything these are the first years you know first year is the kind of the freebie um

060the other thing that uh Craig also mentioned about the Zumba club uh besides the fact that there's a huge number of folks that have signed up for it uh we're also using that as a test bet to see if we're going to actually incorporate that into the inter mural program when we go after this first year it's sort of like a test to make sure because it's definitely athletic based and we're going to test the waters to see if the you know the um attendance stays up and it really takes water so to speak um that you know we could TR consider putting that into our actual program and then not have it be a club um of course National National Science Honor Society is a huge thing uh so that's a really great program

061that we're going to be taking a look at um that's uh and we also have one club uh that we're going to get some information back regarding uh things like insurance coverage and that type of thing uh so that's pretty much I think all the News That's fit to print from curriculum thank you anyone else have a Mr Mino could I ask Mr Kaufman a question sure okay good um so has the curriculum committee made a a change and essentially you said they're going to be determining different criteria for clubs is that in writing is that something that the rest of the board can review and will you be keeping actual track and will be able to in a sense audit it at the end of the year yeah as a matter of fact if

062you remember last year uh we did get a report back from Greg on the on the clubs and the ones that we kind of weeded out because they weren't kind of like successful anymore um one of the things that we suggested to the administration is that they own the process of developing the assessment program then bring it to the board for us to review uh because one of the questions came up well can you can you tie it to Numbers number of attendees you really can't because if it's I'm just making it up it's a very high level academic Club maybe and if we set the bar where it's so high you have to have a certain academic um GPA to even qualify then we may not have 1 15 people we may only have

063five that meet the criteria but if it turns out that it's a competitive club and it's going to do great things so we really basic basically said look we will we will support these types of things moving forward you just have to justify it right so figure out how you're going to assess it because I can't assess a club that may be athletic atically based with the same rigor that would be academically based the the criteria should be different right let them figure out how to assess the value and then after that first buyin year I also recommended that in addition to the stuff they do now and it is pretty substantial what that what Greg puts them through when they want to create a club you kind of have to submit a lot of

064documentation go out get a lot of names and and as he said in the meeting a lot of times people have really great ideas about club and then when they find out they have to do all that work they don't want to do it so um and it is the students that are doing it not you know uh they also have to go out and find the academic advisor who's going to work ratus for the year it's a it's a lot involved but the challenge is not just making it tougher for him to get on the plate to even for the freebie year right right but once that year is over then then we have to decide if we're going to support it and approve it right so once you get to that point demonstrate

065that it's going to value as Doug said that we're going to have value back for just not just the student but is there uh Community value is there value are are you being self-improved in some way you know figure out what your criteria are so we can better move those stuff that stuff forward and always on an annual basis constantly review the clubs to make sure they're that we're getting you know everything that we would expect to get that they're popular because you know after a few years maybe a club just isn't cool anymore I don't know but that I would I would would the curriculum uh committee be um open to perhaps either April or May audit or report of those clubs so we can have some sense of that we're actually tracking it

066and we're reviewing it and so you know maybe we could have an actual schedule so we have find out from Greg when he did it last year and we'll just keep with the same I don't remember when it something makes me say it was in the G do you remember Mike when we had that what it for the clubs I I specifically remember it um I don't remember the actual date though yeah we we'll get back to the date and just one other thing does the programming Club will that be involving coding as well or is that the same programming Club I don't have a program oh is that is that media programming we didn't have a media program we don't have that not for this evening programming Club on May was taken off I've

067got here's what I had for tonight oh sign National Honor Society Zumba special strides student transfer acclamation team which we kind of decided uh probably not that that particular Club activities could probably be done out of a pre-existing club that we already have a lot of that kind of do that type of stuff um and teex Little X event okay te DX that's tedx I'm sorry right it just say was okay okay all right I got it is there any other committees that need to report seeing none we will go to Mr ventell a superintendent report uh Madame President before we get into my report I have a few updates and some comments for the Board of Education and the public the board's Personnel committee has been informed that postings have gone out for the

068Brookside school's principal's position the Arts supervisor position and we will be posting a post a uh position for the acting uh High School assistant principal position at the high school that position came about when Mr Higgins was appointed the acting principal at appart school taking my place as I became the interim superintendent so uh you can keep an eye out for two postings that have already gone out that's the principal's position at Brookside School the Art supervisor position for the district and also now you'll have an acting High School VP position at the high school um at our board meeting on September the 23rd I'd recommend Mr morala for the position of Arts supervisor a board member raised the question in Earnest uh as to whether my recommendation and interview process were legal as Mr

069morala did not have his supervisor certificate at the time of the interview we did get prompt legal advice that night VI phone call from the board's legal council it was cited uh she cited Administrative Code that it was legal as long as long as the employee had the certificate prior to being employed so for clarification purposes since that was on video for clarification purposes it is not unlawful for a staff member to interview for a position which requires a certificate um and that person does not have it at the time of the interview I do want to say just in summary that Mr Moralo did have the certificate prior to my recommending him for the position and so Aro therefore both my recommendation and the process were legal since that was on video on another

070note since we have so many parents here and obviously we all can be concerned about the saval incidents uh I want to assure all the parents here the locker rooms in the Mano Township School District are supervised by appropriate personnel at all times that students are present the locker rooms are treated as they should be like a classroom and when students are present in the locker room they are supervised in every respect in the same manner as if it was a classroom uh the safety of our students is of Paramount importance to the board of education and to all of the staff members in our district I know I speak for the entire Community here in Monroe that obviously our sentiments really go out to obviously the victims of those incidents in sville and to

071their at this time Madam president it is recommended that the members of the mon Township Board of Education approve their personnel items a through doubleb by consent roll call Mr noin is there a second Mr Po is there any comments or questions for Mr vello Miss armeno um uh you it's recommended that the board approve the following Personnel pending enrollment could you just explain that a little bit that's a title one grant that we have so most of that is all funded by Title One funds and that's enrollment for the for a particular yes that's that's a Saturday Academy the Saturday Academy that's correct yep good question anyone else then we will have a Mr proso I'm an alternate for personnel and U twice I was not given an opportunity to make it a meeting

072and be able to attend so I'm going to abstain from the vote okay Mr Gorski roll call Mr Po yes Mr noin yes Mr cman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Chella yes Mr Braverman no on S yes on the rest no on S thank you Mr going to recuse on S Mr calman recuses also on S Miss armeno yes Mrs K Pano Madame board president Personnel items a through Double B passes thank you Madame President it is recommended that the members of the mon Township Board of Education approve board action items a through K and K is the uh for board members that's the single sheet that I just handed out Mr noin second second by Mr armeno any comments or questions from Mr Chella if I'm not mistaken this Falls the uh adhoc committee

073recommendations falls under this no no it's the um school goals that when we met in in August it's one of the goals that we would act and review and receive the recommendations of the ad hoc committee Ken just to clarify so on that Saturday when we met we developed as a as a team we developed the board goals as well as District goals now you're just approving that that's exactly what you know we're approving those those particular goals that we developed as a team okay I just want to make sure that we're not approving the ad hoc committees because we haven't seen theend no no can I'm sorry I think I might have didn't did I just vote on H not yet not yet we haven't had a when we're ready I need a question

074ask well we're asking questions I know that it was something that and it's on the U minutes that we just approved that when we were at the uh that the board goals that we we said that we would receive and act on the recommendations but on here I'm wondering if we can change and just just say receive and review on the recommendation s on the growth and facilities for the ad hoc committee if we could just remove and act at this point so we could just have a review I think based on some of the public comments and and and Michelle if I may is the fact that you know the receive review and act as a board of education is obviously you have to act on that recommendation how how the board would like

075to act on that recommendation is obviously up the purview of the Board of Education uh just I just want that to be clear because I think there was a discussion about that at the ad committee that how strictly is that being interpreted I I think as you received Mr homoki's report as the as the chairperson of that committee once you receive it that's acting on it you received it that is the act just receiving it okay I I think the confusion tonight and I'll say it again is that I think the confusion tonight is that people are one is that obviously it's premature that they're not they don't even have Mr hok's report yet to you plus also is they think that all the data that was discussed during the ad hoc that's not part

076of his presentation I don't mean to speak for him he's basically saying is that he's probably making his his own suggestions but they're probably more conceptual than they are data driven and may I just Mr tiella yeah I and and and I and I do agree with Miss ormeno because the way I read it is receive review and act now if we receive a review that is act so acting though to me is following through on the anoc committee recommendations and and implementing those korski act in this instance is defined as um engage at a future time okay okay not take action upon at this meeting that would require a resolution a second and a vote okay and that's not going to happen tonight that's not on the agenda so this act means to address

077at a future time okay oh I'm satisfied with that thank you any other questions then we will have a roll call Mr proso yes Mr Po yes Mr noin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Chella yes Mr Braverman yes Mr armeno yes Mrs Co Pano Madam board president board action items a through K passes thank you thank you and that concludes your report and we will go to the business administrator's report Madame board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through H be approved by consent roll call I am recommending to pull item I as there is some new information about that agenda item that requires it to be pulled at this time so it's a through H move Mr no Miss

078armino is there any questions from Mr Gorski Mella number the letter F uh it says that a Right Aid pharmacy technician will be giving those flu shots administering those flu shots and I'm not saying this just because I work for CVS this is a concern I think but I I didn't know that pharmacy technicians the way I understand pharmacy technicians from CVS are are able to give flu shots so I just want to make sure that that's if that should be worded as a pharmacist that we have that right because I don't want to be giving our having our staff receiving flu shots from a pharmacy technician who isn't certified in giving flu shots you know this anytime a staff member is getting an injection this certainly would go to legal and it has um

079uh the council wrote the resolution for this and based upon the contract was comfortable that everything was okay it also went to the insurance carrier and they were comfortable with it maybe CBS next year when I'm gone any have questions or comments seeing none Mr Gorski roll call Mr proso yes Mr Po yes Mr nosin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr chera yes Mr Braverman yes Miss armino yes Mrs K Pano Madame board president board action items a through H passes unanimously that concludes my report thank you thank you um at this time we will go to the board president's report and um Mr Masters before took away a little bit of my thunder he must have read the report on my report before he spoke on how he did that but I'd

080like to talk a little bit about the ad hoc committee and its purpose Mr hoki chair of the ad hoc committee will be giving the board uh the committee's recommendation in a little while under the excuse sorry under the public uh Forum portion the second public forum portion of this evening's M meeting um but I'd like to explain the committee's purpose per our policy an ad hoc committee may be created and charged at any time by the president of the Board of Education the president shall appoint members to any committee so created and they Shall Serve until the committee is discharged which will be this evening the president will establish the scope and timeline and the committee shall report to the Board of Education periodically which it has two years ago I created this ad

081hoc committee for the purpose of having the community members give input to the board on how we should deal with our growing student population and our facility needs I appoint appointed Mr hoki as chair of this committee for many reasons he has been a board member and he's been board president he is a senior member living in our community he is very respected by everyone and he's been involved in ad hoc committees in the past I did not appoint specific people to this committee as I felt that it would be more important to have anyone who wished to be a part of this committee join because I I felt that as we could use as many voices as possible for about a year maybe a little bit longer I asked at this meeting at all

082of our board meetings to request people to attend this meeting but after a while you have to close it up because if they you don't start at the beginning you you it's really difficult sometimes to come in during the middle um lately I've heard that this committee was a sham that it was a waste of the members time and it didn't do what it was supposed to do so I'd like to report on what the committee has asked for and received so for what they've done the first couple of meetings were informational Dr Hamilton who was here at the time Mr Gorski and Mr T who is our director of facilities they spoke about our growing student population our facility needs and the financial side to different options I spoke about the reasons I created

083this committee and what we were looking for at the conclusion of the committee the members then requested and received information regarding all of our schools and classroom sizes a referendum calendar events that would show them exactly how long it would take if uh a referendum was um dis uh recommended how long it would take to get from A to B um and the rest of it a tour of all the schools in the district they asked for updated enrollment reports prepared by our professionals and the committee made a recommendation to the board to renovate Monroe Township Middle School to add much needed classroom space the board approved that recommendation and it is now our stop Gap measure project in the Middle School to add nine new classrooms phase one of the stop Gap project which

084is was the ASB bestus removal was completed this summer phase two which is the interior renovation of the boys team room into two Health classes is currently being done with the District Maintenance staff phase three which is adding the additional classrooms will be undertaken next summer and is currently planned for in the 20152 2016 budget and it will definitely help with the overcrowding at the middle school last spring the committee asked to have a redistricting survey done it was completed before the end of the school year but Dr Hamilton had requested further information on the study and sent it back to the demographer with additional questions therefore it was not available until sometime during the summer a copy of the Dem demographic facility and redistricting study was sent to each of the committee members in

085August for review and consideration at the next scheduled meeting it is important to note that the numbers in the report changed almost daily with the addition of new students registering in our district for instance just in the month of August we added um I think it was 150 new students and that could change the demographers report drastically the final enrollment numbers as Mr Gorski said won't be available in until October 15th which is today the committee did not meet over the summer for two reasons the changes to the administrative team over the summer and the fact that any recommendation that would have been made and recommended to the board would not go to a in effect until the next school year anyway the last meeting of the ad hoc committee was held on September 30th

086the topics that were discussed were redistricting and the need for a referendum it is and always was the purpose of this committee to recommend options for the board to consider it is not the committee's role to recommend a specific plan as New Jersey school boards will tell you if it's the responsibility of the superintendent then it is not the responsibility of the Board of Education or any other committee the when the recommendation comes to the board this evening from Mr hoki that recommendation will be sent to the buildings grounds and transportation committee for research and discussion as it should be because we are a a um we work as a committee level if the bg& committee agrees with the ad hoc recommendations it will then be the task of the administration to come up with

087a plan using the demographic and redistricting study as a tool in their planning when that happens and a plan comes before the board then it would be open for discussion and approval there is no plan at this time there's been rumors going around that we will be voting on a redistricting plan this evening we will not be voting on any plan there is no plan there is no plan until the administration comes up with a plan lastly if you were if you as an ad hoc Committee Member did not get a tour of the schools or all the information that you needed to vote on this recommendation it means that you were not part of the committee at the beginning but came in some time during the process after all this um we had the

088tour of the schools and the information that we needed at the beginning so after Mr homoki makes the recommendation this evening the role of the ad hoc committee will be completed and then I hope that this helps to clarify some of the misinformation that's been going around the community and the other thing that I need as need to tell you as the board president's report is that um the Monroe Township School District superintendent search Community input session will be held on Monday November 3rd 2014 at 7:00 p.m. at the high school media center it is the opportunity for the community the parents um any community members to come to the high school talk to our representative from new New Jersey Schoolboard Miss Gwen Thorton and give your input as to what you would like to

089see in the next superintendent that input will be compiled and give it to the or uh Board of Education if you cannot attend this meeting there will be a survey on the website that you can fill out so you have two the two opportunities either the website or at that meeting on again no Monday November 3rd at 7:00 p.m. and that concludes my report and we will go to Other Board of Education business M armo yes um could you is that date and invitation to the community going to be on the website it should be on the website okay under what category do we know do do we know we could put it at the top superintendent search we'll put it at the top yeah put it on the calendar large letters yeah I bet

090you'd want that on top the the other thing is um some community members have uh notified me it is this is on the website is that correct the um sorry the demographic the demographers is there a a the map that the demographer used when he suggested redistricting yes I don't don't know but we can we can look into that if you can put that on the website and this is not um in color that we received if we can get I don't know is it possible to put a we could put a color map on showing the recommended redistricting I think people should have all the information and my my only other comment would be if there is some it using the study as a tool as you mentioned if there is some discrepancy between

091the data maybe we can just mention that or well by by the time that that we get the recommendation and then it goes to the buildings and grounds committee if they recommend that we need to do that it won't be done it won't even be started until November we would have to look at the new data and grounds Community can ask to consider some of the new developments yes absolutely in in in addition to the study and I think it would be very important to do that thank you and and I just want to mention to the public too that that committee is open to the public so they can come in and re and view the committee's um deliberation and discussion thank you if we can I think we should have the buildings and

092grounds committee meeting maybe here because I think it's going to be well attended and I don't think everybody's going to fit and that's going to you know alienate some people who won't be able to attend I mean that's a very small confined space so I think if we could have that here or in another venue that would you know enable us to accommodate more people that would be great good idea we're still on other board business right yes okay I just have a couple other things if I may one is I just I I asked and I don't know if policy took it up or if they're going to take it up but the one thing that I asked the policy committee to take up is just to look at uh gym class deferment for

093or opt out for for kids who were enrolled in sports who might want to opt out of gym in order to take that as a study period from what I looked at and some of the documents that I I I provided it looked like it was it was legally viable for those for kids to do that some of the things that I'm hearing about from from families that have kids enrolled in sports is that they're out late uh at practices and at games they're trying to do you know they they come home and now they're doing their homework late and then the next day they're going to school and then they have gym class and they could probably study during that period if they were allowed to opt out of that since they're already getting

094that physical activity as enrolled in in one of our Sports so it's just something that I'm asking the the policy committee and then the board to take up and look at and then the uh the other thing I just want to address Mr Klein quickly just that I I missed the last uh the last meeting of uh planning board I'm sorry getting old and uh because we had the special meeting here so I I didn't answer you you know when you ask those questions because I'm I'm just not up on on exactly what's going on there because I was here and I think that's it Mr Chella we're going to take your request to our legal advice to see if we can legally do that before we take it to the policy okay thank you

095anyone else other board business okay then we are going to the closed session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sun Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subjects one mtea negotiations two Jamesburg settlement agreement negotiations three harassment intimidation intimidation and bullying incidents 1 through 4 the discussion conducted in closed session can be discussed to the P disclosed to the public at such time as a need for confidentiality no longer exists so move Mr noin second second by m Armenia all in favor opposed exstension the board will now go into close session and minutes to an hour we'll take about 45 minutes

096hopefully no more than that wait e Rob told me to do it where'd he go oh sorry we're just waiting for a couple more board members you're ready to go you you're ready to go I wasn't coming tonight at all it's cold a knock on the door for okay when you get old you know you got to help each other very close board yeah I'm done Michael what did I do with my water open did it m oh that's good we near two hours all that did he forget come right now it's coming it's coming it's coming he said it's coming hey okay at this time the board will go back into public session and I will turn over the meeting to Mr Gorski for a resolution thank thank you Madame board president Madam board

097president members of the Monroe Township Board of Education members of the public it is with great pride and sense of collaborative achievement between the Jamesburg and Monroe Township Board of Education s that I recommend to the Monroe Township Board of Education to approve the previously submitted settlement agreement in the matter entitled Monroe Township Board of Education versus Jamesburg Board of Education Agency reference number nine hyphen one13 comma oal docket number edu 0279 3 hyen 20113 n as a Nancy the board president and the business administrator board secretary as ATT testing Witnesses are authorized to execute the aformentioned settlement agreement on behalf of the board so move second Mr cherella Mr Kaufman is there any comments or questions mrin uh yes I just would like to uh first of all thank especially Mr Gorski and all

098the people that had input in this this is a uh historic agreement and I really feel that a lot of work went into this a lot of effort from the Jamesburg Board of Ed members and also our board that to come up with this agreement is it's definitely a win-win and uh I will be definitely fully supporting this tonight and uh I just want to thank you Michael for all your hard work thank you Mr noin same thing this has been a long protracted um issue um I thank our neighbors in Jamesburg and welcome um as always the students and I'm glad that maybe we can put this to rest and and move on and Mr Mr Gorski I know you always do a great job um working things out for us and thank you

099Mr treski and your board in Jamesburg for your um collaboration thank you anyone else oh Mr cofman uh yes I would also like to uh thank Kathy for her leadership I mean some folks in the town may not realize how long this process has been going on when I was board president back in 2010 uh L Masters and I attended some Jamesburg board meetings and uh some board members at that time also came back here to attend our board meetings so back in that time things between the two districts were were very heated and to come up with this unilateral agreement where we can all walk away whole where Monroe is not absorbing any of the uh expenses in this manner is a huge Testament to just doing the right thing uh for both towns

100and and Kathy has spent inord amount of time both with our leadership here and down in the state house so uh you know as board president uh she needs to you know take a lot of the credit for for leading this effort and resolving this this this issue it's been long time coming thank you Mr cof um anyone else then I would like to just um say a couple of things um this this agree agreement started in in uh many years ago but since 2010 it's been a big issue we go to the county for help they send us to the state we go to the state they send us back to the county we go to the uh the uh Department of Education and they can't help us we go back to the state

101the state says take us to court and it the only people that are getting rich from this was our attorneys so in working with Rob Rob and I sat down and said we got to do something because we we can't let this go on it's it's causing a lot of issues and hardship and and we were able to work um with the county it was um the board presidents the Bas from both T both towns and the um superintendent from both towns and we sat at the County office for quite a while we reached an agreement in conception and it's been going back and forth for the last few months to that the eyes cross the teas and I just want to thank Rob for his input and his help and the James board board

102of education and the administration for supporting this it it is a a huge um agreement for for monio and Jamesburg and I think the collaboration between us is going to continue for many many years to come so thank you Rob I can I'd also like to take this time to thank Kathy and Mike for all their hard work and getting the support of this board also for this agreement also I'd like to thank an person who is here is Beth Brooks our board secretary and business administrator I'd also like to get the support that I believe in the back is also my wife who's another Jamesburg board member along with our mayor uh Marlene leand who's here without their support in all this and especially with Beth and Mike this wouldn't have done a lot

103of this as most of you know when it comes to a contract negotiation or any kind of agreement there are numbers going back and forth and without the two of them working together and the hard work there and also our attorneys to try to end this even though their wallets were getting fat they wanted to see an end to this too because they know how difficult it is to sit here and manage a school and get through with everything we have to do which is best for the children and this is an agreement that I'm very proud of that we should all be proud of in what we did and what we're accomplishing tonight so thank you all good job anyone else I see no one we'll have a roll call Miss armeno yes Mr

104proso yes Mr Po yes Mr nosin yes yes Mr calman yes Mr can't Mr zareski is going to re recuse Mr Chella yes Mr Braverman yes Mrs kapano yes madame board president I'm pleased to announce that it motion unanimously passes thank you very much do you want to read another one yes ma'am okay Madame board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that the Board of Education approve number one memorandum of agreement between the Board of Education and the Monroe Township Education Association mtea for the period July 1st 2014 through June 30 2017 MOA and the previously submitted addendum to the mo MOA between the board and the mtea dated September 8th 2014 the board president and business administrative board secretary as ATT testing Witnesses are hereby authorized and

105directed to sign a collective negotiations agreement which incorporates the terms of the mo MOA and the addendum the business administrator board secretary is hereby further authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the board of education so move Mr terella Mr Braverman any comments or question questions I do I just want to I I just want to thank the the negotiations committee Mike uh you know the administration in the mtea we had it this was a long road this was uh the negotiations were tough we even all got food poisoning together which was which was not fun uh and some members were hospitalized but we got through it and uh so we're here tonight with a finished product but I just want to thank everyone for their collaboration and and

106you know moving forward and creating this great District that we have today that's it yes and some members had to go overseas and get food poisoning too that was a good vacation anyone else Mr noin I too would like to thank uh the negotiating committee on both sides I know it's never it can never be an easy deal uh I've done enough of these in the private sector to know that uh it's very timec consuming and and it's uh it only gets done with the mutual respect on both sides so obviously that's present um I do have a concern tonight though um basically we were informed as a board that we would not be ratifying this or voting on this uh until possibly next month uh when I saw the closed session uh agenda item

107this evening I assumed that we were going to be discussing the terms in closed session and then ratifying it next month um based on that I would like to make a motion to table uh to postpone this until the next scheduled Board of Ed meeting I second second B Mr Mino any comments questions I think we just have to go right to a with a table L for roll no debate it just goes right to a roll on table Ling motion to motion to postpone is different than not to table I want to postpone it till the next meeting that's different motion to postpone until the next scheduled meeting correct beg your pardon Mr proso yes Mr poy no Mr nosin yes Mr calman accuse Mr zareski no Mr Chella no Mr Braverman no Mr

108armeno yes Mrs kapano no madame board president motion to postpone until the next meeting does not pass so then we go back to the original motion of um please ask [Applause] hold we haven't done anything yet so um so we're back to the original motion of of approving the mtea agreement with us yes okay yes so any comments or questions then we will go to the roll call on the agreement Mr proso that was a perfect example what Tom brought up we were told that we were going to vote on this next month it has nothing to do with the contract it's just the way we were told that we were going to go in there and discuss it we're going to vote in November anyone else roll call Miss armenio abstain Mr proso stain

109Mr Po yes Mr atin abstain Mr calman than Mr zareski yes Mr cherella yes Mr Braverman yes Mrs K Pano yes madame board president this motion requires the majority of the board's consensus the consensus is six the majority is four we have four Monroe board votes yes and one receiving member yes that's sufficient to pass just with the Monroe votes alone motion passes thank [Applause] you and before we go on to the public for Forum I just want to thank our um board negotiating team Mr Chella Mr Po Mr Gorski and Dr Hamilton at the time and Mr ventrillo very late um and the mtea and your negotiating team and your negotiator um it's always been a lot of fun but it it was really done with good faith and with the children in mind

110and I think the bottom line should always be what is best for kids and working together we will always be able to accomplish that so thank you for working with [Applause] us so now we will go to the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone give your name and address for the record and we will adhere to our 3 minute time limit hi hi Karen castaldo president of the Monroe Township Education Association for Cypress Point Lane Jackson New Jersey and I'm here to thank those board members who voted yes and did not abstain I app truly appreciate your yes vote as do all of our members uh we have our team sitting right behind me we represent not only teachers power professionals bus drivers secretaries media coordinators child

111study team members related services and security we are the heart and pulse of this District we work with children day in and day out and we are we we've received many numerous Awards not because our people are not great professionals and respectful but because we earned that negoti I'm sorry I I I CL I guess I could should say um but we are we work so hard to get a fair and Equitable settlement and I thank you again uh those who abstain I certainly would like to know why other than the fact that you were told that this was going to be voted on next month that confuses many of our members here uh and it certainly concerns us so again we thank you for passing the M the contract and we look forward to

112more collaborative uh meetings together to resolve any issue that we can't resolve and it was worth the food poisoning every bit of it I don't know about that thank you anyone else from the public Mar Klein s cruna what I wanted to say before is while you had your break many of the residents and parents here asked me about the solo act when Mr Masters brought it up about possibly getting more money what the solo act was was this was sponsored by Senator solo it allowed developers who were previously approved to build prc's which is AG restricted housing which has no effect on your schools it allowed them if they did not take a deposit to apply to have it turned over to a family community this was done only for the developers as was

113um state supreme court with the Mount Laurel decision what happened was we had two developers here one I testified as a resident against and it was supposed to be 300 and some odd prc's age restricted homes they wanted to convert it over to 300 and some odd families you were not allowed to use the impact on the school system to turn it down and I questioned them and I asked how long do you own the property five years when did you get your approval three years what did you do in three years to promote selling it nothing they wound up voting it down they came back and they split it half and half we and this is hannanian so you have half is families which are all sold out already the other half is prc's

114they haven't built the second one which is the one that was um by McDade which is Renaissance properties that was 135 units the zoning board which I had to recuse myself from I am on a zoning board for nine years um they approved it and what Renaissance properties did at once it was approved is they sold it over to Toll Brothers what's happening is between Mount Laurel and affordable housing which is now COA and the solo act they are forcing townships to overdevelop family communities without controlling what's going to go on in the schools so a lot of people asked me about it that's what I wanted to say before before was rudely interrupted and that's all I had to say is let the people have a better understanding of what the state is doing

115to us and not giving us money when they force all this on us thank you for a job that you all did very very well thank God the bit with Jamesburg is over I can talk to Rob now and just congratulations everybody thank you anyone else from the public just talking what happened to you while we were we were in that room for a little while I tesler 11 aah drive as uh everyone probably knows I'm very passionate about education I like to thank the board for all their hard work on the uh agreement tonight with the teachers union I'd like to thank all the teachers and administrators for uh teaching my kids over the years and my older daughter Rebecca just got into Johnson and Wales University in the culinary program so I'm proud

116of what our our schools have to offer especially our culinary Labs I'm very passionate because I want I'm very um concerned this year I know we have uh an election coming up and last year when I ran uh there's a group in town called the Monroe citizens for responsible government which sounds pretty good uh they supported uh Tom and Michelle and Mr Rybeck last year and they called Mr Kaufman a part-time board member because he has a relative uh in the district which is true this year they're supporting um Mr rbec um Mr ious and um Frank Russo who has a wife who's been working in the district for since 1999 so I don't know how an organization can flipflop more than um John carry on its issue and support candidates like that uh so

117I would encourage everybody when they go to the polls to pick candidates uh supported by an organization well not supported by this organization supporting a candidates that are going to be for the children and for education thank [Applause] you anyone else from the public Mr hoki I know he's someone else hi hi Deborah Pella Louise Lane I actually thought someone else would come up here and it wouldn't be me so I just have a question earlier I walked in a little late I apologize something came up about redistricting and I heard that uh there's been some rumors about the redistricting and it wasn't going to be addressed tonight so I'm not sure what are rumors and what are facts because it has not been detailed anywhere that I can find out about it is there

118any detailed information that we can find a report or what the committee has done or what the maps are of the redistricting Etc to you might want to wait until Mr hoki makes his a presentation okay perfect okay thank you you're welcome I know Jo this is gonna say we made you wait a long time I'm sorry Joe hoki 61 Hoffman Road uh I heard my name at least a dozen times and what I would like to do is I'd like to just turn around and face the audience so they know who joam Moki [Laughter] [Applause] is all right uh Kathy uh you mentioned many of the same things that I will mention but I think it's worth repeating some of these things the committee was formed by the president of Board of Education Kathy

119kapovich and its purpose and I think it's very important was to review and study the proposed growth in Monroe Township and its impact on student population and Facilities that is the purpose of the committee she asked me if I would be chair of the committee and she caught me at a a weaker moment moment and I I just said yes I don't know why but I said yes I just want to tell you that we had a total of 35 members of the on the committee but we never had 35 members present at any one of our meetings just very briefly we had presentation by ex superintendent Hamilton by Kathy kapovich and by Jerry Tay and Jerry Tag's presentation was very powerful he spoke about the long range facilities plan and all the members of

120the committee heard this he talked about the functional capacity of each school and then a number of students in each school he also said that there's an unequal distribution of students on the elementary level and he also said that it's possible to create additional classrooms in the Middle School provided there is money and a recommendation from the committee board and I'll get back to it in a second Mr Gorski also made a presentation and I think it's very significant because to build a school if that's the direction the board takes it doesn't happen overnight you first of all have to have Community involvement you need support from the community if you don't have that you know it's not going to happen there has to be a site selection there has to be a decision knowing

121what the uh impact will be be on the programs that we have bonding procedures State approvals referendum construction and so on and between all these things that I just mentioned to you things always go wrong and there are always delays so what I'm going to say at the end is to start as soon as possible we as a committee looked at the uh whiteall associate demographic study and the committee unanimously agreed that the data that that study had was not adequate to make any kind of a decision so the committee decided that we need a new study and we made two recommendations to the board of education and I I'll just read this because I think people who don't know that much about this will understand this the this is the unanimous recommendation of the

122ad hoc committee approximately halfway through our deliberations authorize a new democratic study to be performed by an alternate demographer the new study shall provide growth projections and include separate report detailing options for redistricting number two this goes back to Jerry T when he said that he can create some classrooms in the Middle School authorize the architect of record to proceed with a limited design study and educational specifications for reservation and conf reconfiguration of existing interior spaces of Monroe Township Middle School that could potentially create seven additional classrooms and my understanding is that not only do we have seven but we're in our works to get a total of nine is that correct Mike that will be correct we'll be talking about now which was a a great decision and the board unanimously accepted this and

123this was unanimously passed by every member of the board who was present we also Al provided for the committee opportunities to go to our different schools we planned a date we had a date and any board member I'm talking about adack Committee Member who wanted to go to an elementary school that they never saw before we made arrangements that they would do so and uh we did the same thing for the middle school and for the high school I'm not too sure how many people uh took this up because many of the members of the committee had been to quite a few of the schools now as of was of the recommendations that we had that I just read to two of them we had another report which was the Russ habber report which would

124was presented to the full committee at our last meeting uh this was in great detail and it outlined basically a building plan with dates as to when we should have a school in place and also had a redistricting plan and it was a little bit difficult to to convey to the committee members that this report is not edged in stone it's only a recommendation and it will be up to the board to make a decision whether you redistrict or not so I want to emphasize that because I don't want people to think that this report whatever is said is the end line there were lots of questions and a lot of uh recommendations now none of the recommendations that I will read to you now were really adopted by the committee as a whole but

125I just want to mention a couple of them for example somebody suggested that we reconfigure the district for a K5 setup another one suggested that build a central five and six school to potentially eliminate the need to expand Monroe Township middle school and provide relief for the elementary schools another suggestion was to build a k26 school for the oak tree area in lie of lower elementary schools let me just flip over again I was trying to emphasize to the uh to the committee members that our recommendation is simply a recommendation to the board and nothing else the real work that will begin will be after I'm done over here and it's in your court now one of the things that I uh I heard very clearly from the members is that they want to be

126more involved they want to know more they want to be more involved D and I believe Kathy you may have agreed to this but if you have any kind of committees that deal with redistricting or with building the committee members that were on my committee should have first priority to be on the committee and the other thing is there are a number of people in the audience who would like to be on some of these committees but don't know where to go don't know who to go to so maybe you can do something with that or maybe put it on uh I don't know what but let them know where they have to what they have to do in order to get on a committee but again I I would like to thank very much

127all the members of the committee and uh my goal was that everybody would have a chance to say whatever they wanted to say and obviously everybody did not agree on everything and these are the recommendations that we have and I want to read exactly what it it says the first recommendation to the board is it is recommended that the administration redistrict attendance zones maintaining the sister School concept okay I mentioned before that Jerry T talked about the uh unequal distribution of students in the elementary school so if there is if the board decides to go in the direction of redistricting it's very strongly recommended by this committee that we keep the concept of sister schools alive not not to deviate from that and the second recommendation it is recommended to the board of education to

128begin planning for a bond referendum I outlined before very briefly all the steps that need to be taken in order to have a school in place so with that I'd like to just say that again I want to thank the committee members I hope everybody had a chance to say what they wanted to say everybody didn't get exactly what they wanted but that's the way a committee works but again these recommendations going to the board you don't have to approve them you accept them you review them and you from that point on you make decisions and I think the real work that will begin will be now and uh obviously there's a sense of urgency and you will have to start forming a committee or whatever you want to do but it has to be

129done starting almost immediately and uh that's the end of my report do you have any questions board members thank you Michelle it was a thank you so much Joe for agreeing to shair this committee and for keeping everybody in line because it it did get to be a little crazy last one um what we will do now is take your recommendations from the ad hoc committee and we will send it to the buildings and grounds committee for their review and and their discussion and see where it goes from there um as I said before that committee is open to the public so anybody who wishes to attend can attend um I'd like to just say one more thing and I I sort of skipped that but uh In fairness to those people who didn't support

130this it was a majority on both instances on one and two that approved the thing it was not unanimous right okay right thank you thank you again welcome thank you [Applause] Joe yeah anyone else from the public wishing to speak is Young yeah was night Lou Masters and I'm Mela Court I also want to thank Joe for that um we always didn't see eye to eye but we both really wanted that what was best um and it was a lot of hard work especially the last meeting can you disclose the details of the Jamesburg agreement or will it be disclosed you don't have to do it right now no no does if if we could do that after your three minutes if you'd like okay that's a good Mark you're right okay good thank you

131um and again uh that threw me off right um thank you to Kathy and Rob um to be honest with you I thought this would never happen I can say that now because I'm not on the board anymore um there was a lot of intricacies to that and it was a big mess and everybody else that I know everybody else had a hand in it and it's I'm actually pretty impressed with that I can't wait to hear the details um thank and the negotiation committee I want to thank the negotiation committee that's a really nasty job I'll say it again I could say lots of things now um and the MTA um the only other thing is this miscommunication um I'm just curious was it um was the agenda changed was there I'm I'm just

132curious about it I mean it sounds pretty bad um was it only certain board members thought it was or got the notice it was next month and certain board members this month I'm just curious because it that's a massive uh ethics violation if that's true right so okay that's it just curious about the details Mr gorsky will hand both questions you want me to go back there you want me to Stand Here stand are we going to fight no no fighting remember the accolades that preceded uh my contribution to the superintendent's weekly confidential that goes to the board had an error in the date where the agreement was going to be discussed it was referencing the November board meeting where I have in my mind the audit probably that's going to happen at that meeting

133and not the October 15th date so it was it was my error in the reporting in the confidential when did the agenda go out uh the the agenda for today's meeting went out Monday Monday Monday and it did not change with regard to the closed session agenda items so it had the error on it no it wasn't the agenda it was the Friday confidential okay so it wasn't the agenda the agenda was correct you remember the Friday confidential oh yes I do especially when they were hand delivered because it was going to be too big to email remember those Mark okay and then just about the Jamesburg but sure I'm done um I'll be brief because it's late in the hour since 1979 Jamesburg students have been coming to Monroe on a tuition basis um

134the way that the way it works is that the budget software every year calculates a tuition rate for high school students and you multiply that rate by the number of anticipated students that Jamesburg provides that's the tuition that they pay through the budget then at the end of the year you calculate the actual rate from the actual expenditures and the actual ad average daily enrollment and you settle that between the budgeted and paid amount this has been done throughout since 1979 with es and flows in the amount back and forth to the districts without a problem and in fact when Monroe was planning this high school and we had worked with the financial advisers we met with representatives from Jamesburg this is uh 10 years before the opening of school and we proposed the the

135the amount of debt service and particularly interest that would be forthcoming that would be shared between the two districts based upon their percentage of enrollment um we had an agreement with Jamesburg to pay said interest as part of the tuition cost but a problem occurred in 2010 when Governor Christie signed a budget law of 2010 it eliminated a tuition cap waver which had always been in in existence before it also eliminated a building a new school waiver for all the costs associated with getting a new school open we had to fit this in the budget that year and we were quite shocked because of that law it also imposed a 2% tax levy cap which prohibited James Berg from budgeting the amount of Interest necessary to satisfy the tuition obligation the cap would have required

136hundreds of thousands of dollars of cuts into already decimated programs due to Jamesburg loss of state aid in order to uh to do that so we appealed to the county office um the county understood the problem we went to the Department of Education finance department we were unsuccessful there we appealed to Governor Christie and we met with Governor Christie's Chief of Staff who did not have a solution for us and instead said why don't you litigate the matter um we had no other Alternatives and our Council recommended litigation so we app appealed to the commissioner of Education through litigation where Monroe spent approximately $119,000 to date on legal fees and Jamesburg I don't mean to speak for the district but I think it's about 45 both U very consequential uh uses of of resources that

137are desperately needed even if Monroe was successful through the court process of determining that this debt was owed to Monroe the second leg of this would have been the requirement to pay and with the cap law still in place and with the state unwilling to contribute any more state aid and with the state unwilling to offer a tax cap waiver there would be no ability to pay and we would be back where we started that it was this lack of clarity and frustration that prompted the board president to call a meeting at the County office to see if we could negotiate agreement amongst ourselves um very willing um we agreed uh with Jamesburg and we met with James Berg's board president I'm sorry James James BG board president ba and superintendent and the same counterparts

138for Monroe it was a very difficult meeting a very emotional and raw meeting this followed our attorney's advice to demand a school warrant from Jamesburg which is a basically a note a promiser note or the to lock out the Jamesburg students this is where this was heading and how bad this was becoming this agreement at the County office was was um almost discontinued if it wasn't for some promising contributions from both sides and the back and forth between the district has created an agreement as follows Monroe's High School tuition rate has been steadily decreasing since we opened this school because of the cap because of the fact that we fortified a lot of the supply expenses when we built the school and don't have a need for additional teaching staff and supplies and mostly because

139our enrollment in the school is steadily increasing when you divide the costs by the number of increasing students the rate goes down that decrease in Monroe's tuition rate is freeing up room in James Burg's cap which they volunteered to commit toward the aage of about $950,000 of previous tuition and interest owed and that is the agreement uh Monroe also will not pass through any costs associated with new bonds for the construction of a new high school or an addition to this High School to Jamesburg because Jamesburg uh enrollment of about 267 students is stagnant meaning plus or minus five kids a year and is not driving the need for neither an expansion of the school or a new school it is Monroe's enrollment and thus it was decided that it was fair and Equitable to

140um alleviate Jamesburg from that future burden because it's Monroe's uh need that's driving it if the agreement doesn't materialize uh the district has a right to return back to litigation um however all trend line analysis and and all the study and work that went into this both in the district level and at the county level shows that this has a very high probability of success I projected out that it's as early as 5 to seven years that this debt could be completely paid off and uh I am enormously grateful to Rob zareski Kathy kapano and the Jamesburg Board of Education and administration for for offering to meet us on this agreement we solved a problem that the state created that the state failed to address that the state failed to alleviate by ourselves and that

141deserves a great amount of of accolades [Applause] yes hi uh I'm ASF from one Walker code and actually I have a request but I'll apologize before I say that uh because I'm I'm coming coming to to this meeting for the first time and I don't understand all the workings of it uh my request is that you know the public forum can it be done before the Clos room meeting because there are a lot of people who had great ideas which left because you know it's a school night and they have kids so just a request I and I don't know you know if it this was really uh you know required between but I thought it's not so again just just a request from you we we we try never to have a closed session

142this long it it's kind of an anomaly because we had two legal issues that we had to discuss thank you you're welcome hi um Lisa cro 230 old for Ro I have some additional questions about the redistricting proposal I'm wondering if it's possible to get the specifics regarding who will be redistricted what families will be impacted where they'll be going like very specific details is that going to be made available posted somewhere a more complete presentation that we can read and really understand all of the nuts and bolts of The Proposal I feel like we got a high level and it was um appreciated to kind of understand a little bit more but I still have a lot more in detailed questions and I'm wondering where they can be answered and my second question is

143when will a vote be taken well first of all right now there is no plan we're taking the concept that Mr hoki gave us which is to redistrict and we're going to take it to the buildings and grounds committee they will do their research and ask a lot of questions if they decide that redistricting is the way to go then the administration will come up with the plan where to redistrict who to redistrict where the lines will be drawn what schools they will be going to when that happens and and the and the plan is brought back to the buildings and grounds committee if it is and the buildings and grounds committee approves that then it will come to the full board for approval but that's a few months down the line there is nothing

144specific now that um we are looking at okay so we can confirm tonight that the ad hoc committee's proposal does not include at this point any specific locations that people are currently living in this group will be redistricted that group will Beed there's nothing specific at this point no there is not okay and where does that specific information come from from the next place it goes to which is the transportation will they be the ones that say it should be this group it should be that group who does that they will recommend doing a redist if if they recommend doing a redistricting plan it is up to the administrative team Dr do I gave you doctor thank you thank you for that congratulations Dennis sorry that was easy um Mr ventrello Mr Gorski our buildings

145uh director of facilities they will all get together and come up with a plan using um the recommendations as a tool uh and looking at a future growth for our district updating numbers and then the plan will be able to go back to buildings and grounds okay and will that um type of meeting be something open to the public where the actual decisions are made of who should be moved and where they should be moved to the buildings and grounds committee is always open to the public but the meeting that Mr ventell Mr Gorski will have will that be open to the public probably not because it's not a board um responsibility it's an administrative responsibility okay so if we wanted to voice our particular concerns about our you know area being impacted where would

146we direct that and to be sensitive to you as a matter of fact is that we talked about this before is that so we could probably be posting information on the website uh I don't see why there can't be obviously you know questions being submitted to the central office administration or even to building principles as well too because decisions do have to be made it'll impact the entire community there's no doubt about that but you will be heard absolutely okay thank you no thank you thank you hi Christy scurby hm the court just want to clarify because I was part of the ad hoc committee the presentation that I have that I received that is not going to buildings and grounds that had the plan that was proposed by Russ habber is that not going

147to buildings and grounds that will probably go to the administration for them to use if the buildings and grounds committee decides to go to look at redistricting okay so it is correct that there is a plan that Russ habber came up with that did have neighborhoods it's not a plan it's a um a recommendation but it did lay out neighborhoods that would be moved it did have in there that the third grade would be split between mil Lake and Woodland so that is what is going to Administration into buildings and grounds yes okay thank you information hi Katherine Crowley I'm at 56 Bruce Meadows is there a time deadline that this redistricting has to be put through by I mean it can't be done August 31st so at what point do you have to make

148this decision if I may I I think there there's a couple things that you have to consider when you're redistricting first you should just be aware as of right now as a matter of fact is as the principles actually do their budgets that that process starts in September goes all the way probably through December when they finally make a final recommendation for budgeting principles at that time will have to consider as far as you know where the students are in the district uh as we go into this process you want to be considerate not only of where the students will be but also at the same time as far as communicating with the parents because the parents have to be informed all along the way um I would imagine and and Mr homoki said it

149quite clearly is that as it's presented now to the board the board will have to act rather quickly on this time is of the of the essence as far as making the plans you know for redistricting if that's what the board decides to do second I have heard that this condo unit that is going to be built down Mount Mills is the demo the demographer came up with a crazy small amount of students that would come out from that neighborhood is there any plans to have that rechecked is can you tell me what the numbers are proposed because maybe in a better economy families don't move it you know families do not have children that would go to schools in there but at this economy where people are losing jobs and they just they would

150love to move to Monroe it was it's a great place to live and if they have to squeeze their two kids and their husband and themselves into a house into a condo they will so I have been hearing that there are not that many students that are supposed to come out of that dist that neighborhood and I find that very difficult to believe can I com do you have I believe I believe just a to respond to that to that statement and I think that Mr Klein had made mention of this as well the concern I believe from some of the members at the aded hoc committee uh was that maybe the mounts Mills Area uh and obviously that you know the expectation was that there was going to be a large amount of kids

151coming out of that area and the demographer report was not anywhere near that number uh the best I can offer to is the fact that since the board still has not even acted on this yet is that obviously those numbers will have to be reviewed by the board at that time well I guess my I guess my family is not affected I'm only here because I do not want to see in two years that this board has to come back and say okay this community went up and now we have to redistrict again I don't think that that is good for any of the children I mean I've had I've had children who have lost their friends just one I cannot imagine come September when they lose 10 when oak tree left my daughter never

152went back to those friends and they're no longer friends in high school so that is a relationship that has been severed and I think that that would happen again and in two years later you're going to come back and say oh we're back I don't think you can do that to the children and whatever redistricting plan that goes through I think has to take that into consideration if you're all about the children because you know I mean as it is is we're asking the children to go through four schools before they graduate from here it's a lot thank you we'll certainly take that into consideration anyone else from the public oh miss armino oh so I just just as a point of clarification to the public um there have been several different demographic studies um

153excluding the one that we have now from the Board of Education uh when Builders come to the Township in in the uh planning board and Zoning Board they are very often required to do what they call a fiscal impact study um some of those Builders are that's where the very low numbers of child impacts have been brought to the um the public so it the those numbers have been very skewed um Mr zagorski and Mr back um and there are some people from uh the adult communities who have gone to those meetings and challenged those figures and as a matter of fact did extensive research and additional studies to challenge the Builder figures which also were brought to hear and then we did our own demographic study so the very very low numbers really have

154been um G given from Builders and of course obviously it's in the best interest of the builders to say there's going to be very little impact so I think think the public our demographics are far better and yet the most recent demographic study I'm on the ADW committee he the de demographer admitted that he did not take into consideration the two very large developments uh he didn't put them in his study so uh kudos to the board for and Mr hoki for opening that up and we will probably be or the buildings and grounds will take into consideration but I want the public to know it's not the board's de Dem grapher that has the low numbers when when developers come to the town they try to make the most appealing um design and it

155was their demographers that were challenged by fortunately members of the public who frequent the zoning boards and planning board meetings because that's where the real issues lie so I just wanted to clarify that my name is Jennifer Clark and I'm at 16 Schindler Lane and this is the confusing part for the majority of us out here you're saying there's no plan however Miss scurby gets up and talks about a plan so it's very confusing to all of us you're all saying that there's no plan there's no plan but there are specific communities that are being picked out that are saying that they're going to be redistricted you just agreed to it but then you're trying it's like word semantics I don't understand it like why is it not being explained what exactly the ad hoc

156committee is prop proposing I know it's a recommendation but what exactly are they recommending build another school and what is the redistricting plan do it right away next year when it there's not enough information for any of us to even get up here and give a good argument to you as to why I mean it's just hearsay what we see what we've heard on Facebook I've been one of the people too had no clue until I just saw this all on Facebook and I will tell you from what I've learned on Facebook which seems to be more information than I'm getting here tonight I don't want to see a first grader we have a first grader I have a first grader other people have children are first and fourth grade it is not fair to

157take these kids out of these schools move them over here you might be there one year you might be there two years take the when they get to third grade maybe you're going to be at this school or this school so we're going to split up your friends again then you go back to Woodland you'll be there for two years then you're going to run over here to the middle school it's ridiculous that you're supposed to be here for the kids that's what means the most you're all voted in here to do what is best for all of our children here and the plans that we've seen on Facebook because that's where the only information that we seem to be able to get specifically is not I don't think anyone here agrees with any of

158these plans to spit up a third grade to take these poor children out and move them redistricting needs to happen but it needs to be done at the least amount of effect on these kids cause them the least amount of stress I understand Monroe is is growing and everything else and it needs to happen but it's just not the recommendations that we're saying that came out of this it's just not totally unacceptable totally [Applause] unacceptable and and I'll go back to Mr hoki and the ad hoc committee he was the chair the committee asked to have a Democrat a democratic demographer do a redistricting study that study was given to the ad hoc committee for them to look at the recommendation coming out of the ad hoc committee was for the board to look at

159redistricting right that plan or it's not really a plan it's a map will be given to the administration should the Board of Education committee decide to look into redistricting right but this is our chance to speak now and none of us have the information that we need we don't have any other information yeah but there is there is specific information Miss scurby just got up here and gave more information that she was on the adoc committee that was specific he was the chairman and he and we didn't find out anything more until she got up here and said some and said gave us more specific information that's what we're asking for is most I know but that plan is not the plan that we're going to to use to redistrict so to send that to

160the community would be um totally wrong on our part for you to think that that's what we're going to do nobody said that that's what we're going to do that that that study is what we're going to is going to be the end result that study stinks that is not the way it should be done that's not the way it should be done that's not take two third grades and and put them in two different schools and like I said those specific four first and fourth are going to be the ones most affected by all of this well thank you for your comments we will give them to the the administration that's great because that's the only way that we seem to be able to get any information please make it noted thank youin um

161I would just like to talk I was at the ad hoc committee as a member of the public I was not on the ad hoc committee and and there was a distinct plan that was spelled out with boundaries and Border Lines uh what children would go to what school um and there was a lot of push back from the public uh especially the the parents there uh there was a concern about that so I too got the impression at the ad hoc committee that the districting plan was actually what Mr homoki's group was going to present to the board which was going to present it to the buildings and grounds committee I don't understand why why a redistricting actual plan was put forth at the ad hoc and I think that a lot of people

162thought they were probably voting on that at the ad hoc committee I know if I were to have voted I would have thought that um but now it appears that that really wasn't I don't even know why it would have been presented because the ad hoc committee requested that redistricting survey it came from that was a request from that committee unanimous request that they asked for a redistricting survey and that's what was given to them Madam M the redistricting survey is different than the demographers report is what you're saying the demographers report they received the microphone they received a demographers report early on the demographers report gave them the schools and everything um what was in the schools who was who was coming in how many kids they had expected and then when the the

163idea of redistricting came up they requested it wasn't the board it wasn't the administration it was the committee who requested a study let's have a redistricting study and see how we can make parody through the southern in the middle the Central and the northern part of Monro because it's not un I mean we're all aware that all the building is in the southern side of the the um Town we've had parents come up and say we need to do something about the high classes in in the oak tree Abarth area where mil Lake and Woodland's classes are not as high as down there so they had the study done the study is a tool that will be used in conjunction with some more information that will be needed in order for the administration to make

164a a a fair and Equitable decision for the kids that that makes total sense but I I have to appreciate the fact that I could understand where this concern is coming from secondly um obviously as a obviously as a board we're not doing our job if we're not communicating correctly to the public um Bas based on that what I think we I would like to see is can we have something on the website to spell out in very very detailed uh terms what exactly the ad hoc committee is going to recommend um what is the next steps where is this going to go from there because our main function as a board is transparency and input with the public and obviously we're failing on that so I I accept the failure but now we have

165to correct that going forward yes we'll we'll put something up there uh Kathy I would just like to uh reiterate what said by Mr nin there were two recommendations made by the uh report the Russ hav report one was a timeline for building construction and the other one was an actual plan that he came up with with boundaries and everything else for redistricting I just want to let everybody know that the re districting plan was not accepted by the committee okay but the committee did say if we have to redistrict which will be up to you please keep the sister cities Sister schol Sister schools intact so it was not accepted the only thing that was accepted on the first part was that there should be a building program no dates or anything like that

166so I just want tell people that nothing was accepted and if you hear any there is a plan but the plan was not accepted by the committee nor is it accepted by the board the board can use it as you see fit okay I just want I think it's very important that people understand that that we did not approve either one of those recommendations Mr hoki Mr hoki is it fair to say that the redistricting plan that was put together by Ross habber utilized the demographic information contained in the enrollment report and Justified the need for redistricting which is just the the most efficient use of the district schools by by reallocating students where there is a a vacancy to where from where there is overcrowding and that he further recommended it but it was

167just part of the substantiation of the need to redistrict which is inherently obvious to the committee that's absolutely correct it's absolutely correct just miss Seria yeah I I mean I I think what the public would like and I think I tried to allude to it before is that we can put on the website we contracted a study we paid for the study it's public record let's put it on the website and say this is merely a study yes there was a redistricted plan that we paid for because we felt the need to be informed and it is not something that has you know have whatever the language is to inform the public that this is exactly what happened and this is just uh the beginning of the discussion I think that's all the public wants

168to know that that and there's no reason for it not to be so I mean it's public record anyone should be able to get a copy of it but it should be on the website to make it easier for people it's and and Mr noin said it it's about transparency it's about starting the discussion and at at the adhoc committee we talked about it and and I think one of the reasons why I was worried about acting upon the recommendations was because of the miscommunication that yes we contracted for a study people should know about it but it's not necessarily something we're moving forward with until we do further study so please make it clear on the website what exactly it is and then we can have a community discussion which is really what we're

169looking for to begin with let's finish our public forum U Morin dck 19 Tree Tops Drive I just have one question is this study complete with with this company with Ross habber is this study complet is it completed are we done have we paid him he's yes okay because there is a a letter from their company on the website showing that they for fee for $6,000 for continued um working with the board for the 20145 school year so that tells me it's not complete Madam that is on the website I found it the study is complete the the board can ask Ross habber to update the report depending on the October 15th enrollment information which is very Germaine to the report that hasn't been suggested yet and I can't say uh with certainty if Ross

170Haber has been paid or not I know he's emailed me the invoice but I can't say with certainty it's been processed okay this is for the upcoming year though this current year is during these meetings with the next the next phase of this when it goes to the buildings and facilities and grounds um will he be presenting what was already given to what you have now or is he going to update those we can request that if the buildings and grounds committee so desires to request an update which we probably would okay because you said enrollment numbers aren't complete until well I know the study was done in the in the spring and the numbers were different when we talked to him in September okay so he really should do an updated version absolutely we

171would need to do an update hi gazala I live on um one Miko dribe and I'm kind of going to reference back to uh what was mentioned about one of the demographers who study was whose report was used by the ad hoc committee and for a lack of better word you said it was an unreliable number the the mount Mill's number that we talking about the new development so if the demographer report is kind of inaccurate or unreliable why has that been factored into a recommendation given by the ad hoc committee why is that recommendation not being thrown out before giving to the board of ed because it's out there now ma'am uh Madam May address the information on the developments and the um the demograph the information specifically on the developments how many units

172and so on right was directly provided by the Township from that information Ross habber extrapolated the number of students that would be coming from there using his own method not the method that the builders use right and um and I'm going to put the numbers in front of you from what I know what what all of us know we projecting about 500 homes oh Ma'am regarding the mounts Mills uh there seems to be some question about whether that's valid that was not presented to us uh from the Township in the form that it's being presented on Facebook so we are reaching out to the township to validate that but as of now we have no confirmation of that I believe that Mr haber's report is materially accurate and can be relied upon for the purpose

173of understanding that we need to redistrict and we need to plan for a bond referendum and that is all the committee recommended tonight and our understanding as from the information and I'm not saying Facebook from the information given to us by the people on the ad hoc committee was that that number was used in the redistricting plan to move children to mil Lake because that's the only projected number of kids coming out of that development going into mil Lake and Woodland School that if that number is wrong we are going to end up having that and and I'm talking about the plan that has been recommended to the board we're going to have another crisis in our hands in a year's time when 150 students come out kids come out of that development and go

174into M so I'm sorry to go through this all over again but what I'm trying to say is that inaccurate information was used for that recommendation that and I know you guys are going to make it out public for us but why is that recommendation even with the Board of Ed knowing that that information is not it it's those numbers are not right and I know you just told me that you have accurate information M Madam to a point of correction there is no confirmation that any of the information in Ross haber's Report was incorrect I want to be clear about that the report is is is materially correct and accurate it IT projects enrollment information which is inherently subject to variation but the development information that we have was recently provided by the township

175and we we believe we can rely on it for accurate numbers based upon the uh cohort survival method used by Ross habber there is no incorrect information that we're relying upon to determine that we need to redistrict so the number is wrong five out of 500 homes 14 kids will be going to the school is that number something that we making up or is that was that on the report that's your statement I'm telling you that the information we have from the township on the developments was provided by the township we're relying on it for the report the enrollment then is is projected from Ross habber and we believe it to be completely reliable and justifying that there is a need to redistrict period And I hope you're right but I as as as a

176parent I would like the board to take recommendations based on on on reliable facts thank you I will say though too um we will be putting all the information and numbers whatever you need on our website and I think that would be more reliable than looking at Facebook and having people write things and absolutely right so just because it's on Facebook doesn't make it true and your time is up so we have to go to like I said not just Facebook it's me I understand thank you who were telling us the number thank hi this is sanjie heg 12 Wedgewood Cod um what's becoming apparent in all these discussions is that U there is certainly a plan and you know there is some hesitance in making it public and now we agree that you know

177it's going to go on the website which is good um but as a as a citizen of Monro Township um how do I know what are the next steps that you're going to have in this process before you so the what I'm gathering is that you know there is hesitancy in basically saying that look we are going to plan this out over the next month or you know 6 months or a year and this is how it's going to work and I also heard superintendent saying that the Public's voice will be heard my question is how can the public be more informed or how do I know because I can do this you know come to these meetings meetings um every time this happens but if I have a proper schedule from you guys maybe

178I can I can attend those and you know raise my concerns right and the second part is when the superintendent says the Public's voice will be heard in what form will that be is this the form we come back and talk about it uh based on recommendation or there is some kind of a voting or or what is that what we would what we will do is um like I said go to the buildings and grounds committee that committee when scheduled will be on the website so everybody will know that that committee is scheduled anybody can come to that committee and watch the deliberations we will also have times during public forum when we will open it up we we might I'm not saying we will um but we probably should have a uh specific

179agenda item for redistricting where we give the public just uh time to speak about just redistricting we do that with the budget we've done that with other major um initiatives that we do so it would probably be very feasible for us to have a night where we we just have a redistricting uh agenda item where the public can speak to whatever you know you get your three minutes you just tell us what you want not a you know okay that's perfect and again we will try to keep as much on the um website as possible okay is there a schedule of these meeting specifically on this topic that that I can find out I mean it will be on the website it is there is no meeting scheduled right now for for November but if

180you go under the board of education on the website we will we have all our committees listed and we will have um dates when the committee will be meeting where time and place okay thank you hi Denise Caprio eight Boxwood Drive just a clarifying question when you go to the um buildings and grounds are you going in with a clean slate where they go and they're going to look at redistricting regardless of what their proposal was so starting from scratch right we will go to the buildings and grounds committee it will be an agenda item we will talk about the the need or the responsibilities of what redistricting would be and they'll decide yes we need to look at this further or no we're not going to redistrict so that map or that proposal that

181was identified won't necessarily go to them it'll be almost like it could be part of their decision when they look at the map so they know where the the students are but they want it's not that that committee that will be creating the redistricting plan I guess I'm wondering when they look at this do they already have a pre thought of well this is what they already identified so we're going to go with that or we're going to say let's look at this from scratch and say okay you know considering the homes and the numbers might have been wrong and we're starting knowing our committees they ask a lot of questions before they make any decisions okay because I think we might have thought that something's already going forward and it's not right okay right

182let's I know we're going to finish public for first I know it's late I just want to change the subject a minute and touch on Ryback 23 Riviera Drive I'm sorry touch on what Michelle or manyo said um when the developers submit fiscal impact analyses uh the development that I'll I'll use as an example I'm really talking to you I know but I I want the public to know it's really for them as well is the one on Mount SMS of 613 that's a development of 522 units yet the developers demographer the um uh developers Jack mors his demographer used a study that was 10 years old and said said it would only bring 80 students to the school which is ridiculous 522 uh units is going to bring 80 students to the school he's

183building another large development of 749 units and he said that's going to bring around 200 I think 220 students to the school which is out of balance with his first one and just as ridiculous what we need and this is something that I think all of us especially you and the public have the power to do is get our town to create a standard a template so that if Builders want to build a development here they have to use the information we give they have to use our multipliers and uh and um so that we know that the uh tax revenue the anticipated tax revenue would be on Target and that we know the numbers of students would not be as outrageous as the ones that we're getting thank [Applause] you if you ask him

184about Jamesburg again I'm getting up listen my version brief and Mr accountant version of brief widely vastly different Mike brief holy cow L Masters now Mela Court um Mr Rybeck said is exactly right um being on the zoning board there's actually it's called a coefficient um and a while back when JSM was going in their coefficient was 0.15 so they said for every home that you build there's 0.15 kids going in which was wildly crazy um mayor pooie at that time was pushing for the township to adopt a similar coefficient which but it was point 75 now what happens is you can you can create whatever coefficient you want what it relates back to is to try to assess an impact fee on a developer is illegal so you can say whatever you want we

185could say there's 8,000 kids coming out and we can go to Mike and say guess what 8,000 all right too bad we can't do it in the state of New Jersey what you're talking about is against the law we what you really got to do is you got to change the law you have to allow impact fees again the coefficient is is nothing right now if you can't link that to a monetary value based on an impact fee period thank [Applause] you anyone else from the public come on dude hi this is sanjie he again 12 Wedgewood code I'm just trying to you know find I'm trying it I'm finding it difficult to difficult that the you know the the people who are sitting here are are coming about these recommendations saying that you know

186when the plan for uh you know redistrict and things like that are made or when the new building permits are handed out that you know we should have a formula as to how the you know number of students uh that are going to be increased is estimated right why wouldn't that be done by a a school board like yours can I take that sure number one the mathematics that's involved in that and the formulas are very scientific number two the more we can do that in the business office and give you an enrollment projection I've done them before just for budgetary purposes but it lacks objectivity whereas an outside consultant can bring objectivity to a professionally prepared report for the board that's the difference I understood but here it seems like there is a basic

187you know there is there is basic stuff that public who doesn't attend these meetings on a regular basis can relate to in like half an hour compared to you know you guys are you guys are in and out you know into this every day and and day out so I'm just surprised that you know this is coming to the public coming from public's opinion as opposed to coming from you guys you know I'm just I because we as taxpayers rely on you guys right we understand we elected you and we expect something like that to happen out of you as oppos sitting and saying Hey listen I'm on the education board I get a recommendation I I basically you know manage the School side of things but when the new houses are built I have

188no say in it right you're right we have no say in the development of this community our our responsibility is to educate every child that comes into Monroe Township every child but we don't have anything to do with the development of the community so it's the township who who approves everything based on the master plan the zoning board the planning board they they are aware of our schools and how they overcrowded they are but I I I know that they have to follow certain rules and regulations just as the board of education has to follow rules and regulations I'm just saying that there is I I believe that there is no proactive effort from you know again here I I see that there is no proactive measure in in in questioning these things you know

189when when when basically a survey is made take it and run with it as opposed to questioning some of the basic stuff which us as public have to do it I mean sitting here we were trying to be proactive by creating an ad hoc committee and getting a a a recommendation from the community as to what they would support because we have to do something whether I mean our options are very limited whether we redistrict whether we get trailers again or we we go with a referendum to build something to add classroom space to our district anyone else I would I would I would just like to clar make one clarification M of the public um asked about the Clos session resolution um the closed session resolution with the mtea uh on the today's agenda

190was uh was distributed on Monday afternoon and the resolution just states that MTA mtea negotiations would occur in Clos session so there was no agenda item that said at an action would be taken I mean we all know that if if the if um the action is resolved in close session and an action could be taken but again there was um there was another impression on there the other thing is um when Mr Gorski uh Madam president could you ask Mr Gorski when we went into Clos session what time that was this evening oh I he might know what time mad approxim we went into Clos session at 8:19 p.m. okay I would just like the public to know that's when those of us who were not on the negotiation committee first saw the contract

191just as a matter of of fact that was the first time we were able to see and take a look at the paperwork and the documentation on the contract and um as a as a board member representing the public I just felt um and I requested a sufficient review of the documents in order to make uh an a Very informed decision how to move forward with the agreement um after all it's a three-year contract it affects many people and um to receive it this evening with all the documentation necessary um I just wanted the public to be aware of that thank you can I say something Mr cherella yeah I just I think that I don't know what happened here with the adhoc committee and where the wires were crossed but I know that I

192was even receiving questions about it I had no idea as a board member I had no idea so I could imagine how confused they were because I didn't even know and I was getting maps and I was getting told that uh I was shown that my kids were even being redistricted and I had no idea what was going on and then I was told that we were voting on it at this meeting and I had no idea that you know except to to to see the adog uh the the bullet point there but somewhere either the the the stream of thought changed or or the or the or there was just a big commun miscommunication error but from what I understand there were board members as part of that ad hoc committee that thought that

193they were voting for something that was going to be brought here tonight that would cause redistricting to happen you know so some of the things that I want to know is if they thought that who thought you know who voted for it number one uh and and then why was it brought to us in in this you know in a way now that the public is kind is confused about I'm confused about I think that one of the things that we really need to do is just to make sure that we're communicating to all the parties make sure that the ptas and the PTO are aware to make sure that we also have emails going out we we I get 19,000 you know if it snows a little bit or there's a little bit of

194ice or I get a global connect they get all kinds of stuff going on I think we need to send something out to the public saying you're not being redistricted and then you know just to answer some of the questions from some of the people that came up about the committee I'm on buildings and grounds for for now I'm I'm off the board uh in January but I could tell you that some of the things that I would look at is you know what are we doing as far as trailers now I know that the t word is a bad word we just got rid of the trailers now we're going to bring them back but we have to have a way to house these children but I would think that the main thing that

195we need to do is take the children into account before we move them around because people are absolutely right and you take you take an 8-year-old an 8-year-old child and you take them away from their friends you're you're ripping their whole life apart they might never make th you know those relationships back again and we just need to really think about that before we take the politically expedient route or there just a thing that's going to make an overcrowding situation go away well I I do know that um Mr vello you had a meeting yesterday with the PTO presidents yes and the redistricting was discussed in that meeting it was so hopefully they're bringing that information back to their PTO and their memberships and again I think when something is written on Facebook and people

196believe that when it's not true um it causes a lot of issues but it gets it gets on the Facebook because it's it's fed because of a lack of information so order what what we can do and what we heard tonight was the fact that obviously there was a lack of communication and there's a need for more communication so you can hear it from me right now is the fact that obviously tomorrow I'll be working with Mr Gorski and other people as well too and we'll make sure as the fact that information is on the web page uh and we'll just update that obviously as the buildings and grounds committee meets as information is shared with them as people want to also and you heard Kathy say this as far as maybe at public forums

197is that you know we can maybe address those con concerns at that time as well too so the message that I received tonight was the fact that we need more communication there's no doubt about that but I do want to emphasize to you the fact that there is a timeline involved here if redistricting is needed tough decisions have to be made at the same time is the fact that as you think about those tough decisions that have to be made again I can attest personally as we as we did Brookside that was a redistricting as oak tree was redistricting as as Applegarth was redistricting yes obviously at times is because of the fact that friendships are going to be separate because of the fact that obviously one kid is going there and one kid is

198going there I get that but at the same time you need to understand is that the board's responsibility is to educate all the children you'll have the other side of that fence where you know what as Mr cherella was just saying bring in trailers I'd like to see that conversation with everybody raising taxes if that's the case then you make you make that case to the board of education but at the same time you also need to understand is the fact that we District has to take place if you build another school in a couple more years and it might take two to three years to build that school will you be redistricting again the answer is yes that's just part of the growth that's what I was trying to present to you before either

199you're getting it on the on the side going up because you're a thriving Community or you getting it on the side going down because of the fact that you're you're you're downsizing the community either way but but redistricting this is not new when you think about it the last redistricting actually took effect but it didn't impact you maybe but obviously for those oak Tre parents it impacted them as they went to appart school redistricting is always going to be taking place in the thriving Community thank you anyone else from the public before we close public forum okay we will close public forum and our next scheduled Board of Education meeting you need a motion to accept this report do we need a motion to accept his report yeah I think so okay um I need

200a motion in a second to accept Mr I move to accept the ad hoc committee's report Mr Kaufman who's seconding that anybody Mr gin any comments or questions ah let's uh can we just do we need a roll call no all in favor I opposed Mr Braverman is opposed abstentions then the motion passed and we accept the report thank you Mr coff our next schedule Board of Education meeting Wednesday November 19th 2014 7:00 p.m. at the Monro T High School motion to adjourn Mr Chella Mr all in favor all in favor good night

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.