CorpusRecord 132939

Monroe Township Board of Education 03.12.15 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
36,076 words · about 201 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001three of us are here Mar go right on the end the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will now come to order please rise for the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for do you want to sit want to sit on this Mr Gorski roll calls miss armeno here Mr Braverman here Mr Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs kapano here Mr nosin here Mr Po here Mr proso Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting

002to be published by having the date time place thereof posted March 6 2015 at all schools in the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski at this time I I will read the Clos session resolution the it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session and accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 to discuss the following subject superintendent search deliberation process the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists I anticipate that this session May last uh up to 45 minutes I apologize for that but this is a very important matter that we have to

003take care of this evening so move do we have a second okay uh n and Ryback okay so at this time we will move to close session and I anticipate we'll be back uh around a quarter of seven I'm sorry oh I'm sorry yes we have to vote on that don't we's here okay all all uh in favor oppos extensions copain so noted so the motion passes we'll now move to close session thank you the Monroe Township Board of Education would now like to resume with our public meeting at this time we will hear report from our student members Mr thorney yeah just right there um uh good evening members of the public and of the board uh the Mone clubs and organizations throughout the district and the respective students therein are continuing to engage

004in programs for the extension uh and the betterment of their education as well as the school Community the mths media center participated in the 11th annual book read uh this consisted of a community of students as well as uh staff to further engage in literary analysis um as well as recreational reading the DECA uh the at the DECA state conference uh several teams as well as individuals in the high school were recognized for their hard work preparation and success uh in their respective business marketing finance and administrative uh administrative related categories and have qualified for the DECA International Career Development conference where they were will go will they will go on to continue uh with the next stage of their competition in addition uh students through the monter township high schools chapter of the future

005Business Leaders of America also um had several students Place uh in their conference in qualifying for the national competition and a uh group for a second FBA competitive event uh also plays third within the nation hey um excuse me uh the wrestling team uh also won the uh District 20 championship title and second place in the GMC competition and the girls basketball team um will go on to participate for the first time in the greater middle sex Conference Championship the winter track team uh won the divisional relay race and the uh Youth and government chapter will be participating in the pre- legislative conference this Sunday at North Hunton Regional High School where they will have the opportunity to interact with students who have similar interests in uh government and politics as well as uh developing

006and working on their uh bills as well as uh bills or um assignment projects the program consists of a uh legislative judicial uh Lobby uh Lobby Corp uh press and um executive branch through which students are able to participate in a mock session of the New Jersey state government uh Miss alpie a counselor at the uh high school was nominated uh for an award through the national uh life insurance uh life group insurance company uh for her dedication to student development and making a difference in student lives and finally uh the mil Lake uh the mil Lake School will be organizing a kicks for a cause event at 6: pm. at the monor tanip recreational center um for a uh benefiting a mil Lake preschool ER who is battling neuroblastoma uh that concludes the student

007board memb report thank you Mr thorney Mr President may I yes um Mr thorney was uh and maybe and I have to apologize for not bringing the article in the newspaper it didn't have anything to do with the school but he won a um award and if you can just give him a minute or so he I don't have all the details so I'm going to ask him to just t I think we should be proud of him for what his accomplishment is so may I all right uh thank you so that was a uh program that was organized within the American Legion it is an oratorical uh contest that the high school takes part in um uh a couple of students throughout the high school were developing uh orations which consisted of a memorized

0088 to 10 8 to 10 minute speech on a um citizen duty to government under the Constitution and then I had to memorize uh four three to five minute speeches on different aspects of the Constitution relating to topics on signed amendments and then students who uh competed in the high school through the local American Legion Post advaned to the county and then you know would continue further and what was your reward uh first first in the post and then second in the uh County I don't know if you heard that first in the post and second in the county we should be very proud of him and the school system that brought him there thank you thank you at this time we we will have a presentation by uh Mr ventrillo and Mr Gorski followed

009by a public hearing on the preliminary 201516 school budget can't turn good evening everyone and thank you for attending the uh tonight's Board of Education meeting I'm Mr V the inum superintendent this is Mr Gorski our business administrator and board secretary uh Dr avoc is uh not able to attend this evening she has a little touch of the flu tonight has been a collaboration as far as the budget presentation collaboration a collaborative Endeavor and I want to give credit to Mr Gorski especially for the endless hours and believe me there's been many as he puts into that he put into the budget process and tonight's presentation also want to thank Dr alic as well too very want to thank uh introduce maybe each of the board members as well too if they could just maybe

010just turn around and raise a hand so this way everybody can see you I didn't want me to put you on the spot but since we have a lot of people in the audience maybe could just do that uh Mr Doug por the board president Mr Thomas noin vice president Miss Michelle armino Mr Marvin braan Miss Jill de Mayo Mr Luke Hoffman Miss Kathy cupano Mr Anthony proso Mr Steven Ryback Mr Robert zareski uh the Jamesburg representative and also and certainly we value our student board Representatives uh Corey haer and Nicholas thorney finance committee I want to thank the the members of the finance committee for all the time that they put in deliver liberating on the budget um Mrs uh Kathy C Pano is the chairperson former board president Mr Thomas knin Vice chairperson

011Mr Luke Hoffman former board president Mr Anthony proso former uh Finance finance chairperson and Miss Jill the mayor our vision statement the Mona Township Board of Education commits itself to all children by preparing them to reach their full potential and to function in a global Society through a preeminent education the mission statement mono public schools in collaboration with the members of the community shall ensure that all children receive an exemplary education by well- Tred committed staff in a safe and orderly environment District goals goal one continue to adopt a strategic plan and implement the goals articulated in the plan including communication and Community engagement over the 214 215 school year and our strategic plan is an ongoing document goal two identify and develop a schedule for and reviewing evaluating and assessing uh assessing current programs

012and structures including AP and Aid programs as measured by student academic success and cost Effectiveness and Mr Gorski maybe could just have a couple words on that yes get out of your way yes uh from an organic start we met with the uh principles and administrative stakeholders in the district on AP and Avid programs and we have fruit to bear in this year's budget pertaining to both of those um AP testing the district has grown from years ago where we only offered five AP tests to currently over uh 30 40 it is and all of those are going to remain in the budget they're expensive to Proctor and to offer and they will all remain but the cost of the exam will now be passed through to the parents and that's commensurate with all the

013other school districts in the county that we've surveyed and uh many many many if not all of the districts in the state the way that works is the student takes an AP test uh you get a four or a five score which is the highest score and you get waved out of certain 101 type classes at a college level so you save those tuition costs so it's only a fair matching that the that the cost of taking the test which leads to the saving on tuition be passed to the parents um instead of the taxpayers and the AVID program we work closely with Dr alvic and we've eliminated $166,000 of redundant training for the program and instead we're going to use a turnkey program where those who have learned and mastered the material to teach

014Avid are going to pass it through to U their colleagues and that saves $6,000 thank goal number three is to seek viable sources of alternative District Revenue to provide support to the tax levy and Mike maybe want to just talk about that care as well too so the TR care yes currently the district um has a lease agreement with the before and after school network for using our facilities to incorporate a before and after school care program and it's been the desire of former board president Mr Luke halman and many board members for years to take over this endeavor and to reap all the profits inhouse and we have a very fine um member of our central office team Sharon Jensen um and and Dennis villo and Dr alak and I have worked and we

015have developed a program that's going to be an in-house before and after school care program called Falcon care and instead of receiving revenues for a use of building totaling $100,000 per year which was our current agreement with the before and after school care network uh we anticipate conservatively to have net income between $2 to $300,000 a year from bringing that program inhouse and from speaking to my uh educational cohorts there's going to be more of a uh curriculum and more of an educational component to the program than ever before leading to help us accomplish many of our district goals the board goals thank you Mike uh successfully complete the search and employment of a new super tenant that's why they went to close session this evening complete the 214 board self evaluation and review the

016results go three review the board committee organization and structure processes goal four receive Rie uh review and act on the recommendations of the Ed hoc committee on growth and Facilities the executive summary and this is important the mono Township school budget for the 15 16 school year was developed within specific parameters set forth by the for by the board's philosophy direct directive it's been professionally professionally constructed to afford every student an opportunity for an exemplary education by well- trained committed staff and a safe environment opportunities made available through a comprehensive curriculum which offers diverse course offerings and co-curricular clubs and activities we believe that our proposed budget continues to become more efficient as evidenced by a successful County budget efficiency review was the first one that I went as a as an inim superintendent with

017Mr Gorski and just to let you know is that so the superintendent and the Bas and I'm a little bit off the line here right now but I wanted to just say something um is that there was probably about maybe six districts in one room with the county superintendent there was no doubt in my mind obviously is that Mr gorski's presentation our presentation was the best in the room and it was complemented by the county superintendent as well as the other business administrators and superintendent so Kudos again to Mr Gorski to you um now this one is really important I want to stress that student growth continues to weigh heavily on the budget there would be actually a decrease in general fund Appropriations compared to last year except for the Direct effects of student growth

018construction of new Staffing requirements specifically driven by growth caused the general fund Appropriations to increase by 2% compared to the prior year so once again is that our general fund budget would actually be less than last year if it wasn't for the increase in student enrollment in previous budget meetings we were asked why can't you curtail your costs and um Total Line and and not have increases and we've we've shared the example in the past you know if an analogy is if you have a family of four at home um you can control your your food cost by perhaps uh you know shopping down instead of buying the brand names buying the house store name brands and buying uh you know more in bulk and more efficiently but you throw twins at the table and

019you bring the number up to six and it's very hard to show a decrease or contain that same budget that's that's similar to what Monroe has been facing over the last few years we've picked up over 1,200 students over the last six years and the state has off has currently giving us less state aid than six years ago despite Our obligation to educate all of those 12200 students regular students special education students you name it we're obligated to educate them we do a fine job but that that has a cost and we're very proud to say that this year under doc under um superintendent vent trillo's uh leadership I did like the degree change though I did you've earned it so far um we've asked all the principles and directors to to go into this

020budget year with an empty shopping cart with a zerob based approach that only reflects additions to the budget that you absolutely need look in every closet see every Supply item you have for next year don't just reorder if it's not necessary and and this really deserves emphasis our general fund appropriation which includes teacher salaries which are going up from contract deservedly so health benefits which are increasing Beyond any control that we have because we're we're Affordable Care Act um complications and so on um and all the handling of student growth our general fund Appropriations would be less than last year if it wasn't for Capital construction projects budgeted for the Middle School to create more classrooms which are desperately needed and new teaching staff to fill those classrooms that's that's remarkable this is yours key

021budget considerations for this year are number one increased student enrollment I have a uh slide coming up which shows a demographer projection for next year and again we're expecting a half of an elementary school of new students for next year comprehensive curriculum Monroe has grown incredibly over the last decade to go from a rural community to uh an elite suburban school district right on the cusp of the best in the state in our group student teacher ratios we are working diligently to keep parody in the district if you have two elementary schools with the same grade levels that the student teacher raos uh should be the same between the two schools and we're we're we're working now with a demographer we have a report on tonight that'll talk more about that aging facilities folks without

022with the exception of this school and oak tree every one of our facilities needs roof address um uh we have SI we have schools like Applegarth that have boiler systems that were bought with New Deal money back in the 1930s we have Windows systems HVAC systems all which require Capital intensive uh Improvement some of which were're able to put in the budget remarkably with the cap others require a bond referendum but for the five years that I've been be the ba we've picked up a roof project every year and we continue to do so this year to the tune of about $2 million cap limitations to go to cap does not afford US enough money to meet all of our financial obligations that are new for 1516 it offers part of what we need to

023finance that the rest has to come from efficiencies created within the existing budget and finally Community impact we are very sensitive to the taxes paid by this community going back to the 101th school year the state shifted its obligation to fund public education to you by by taking $4.4 million or 95% of our state aid and reducing it and giving a special allowance to roll it into the levy many districts use that because it would have a catastrophic effect on the operations for next year if you did not so essentially the state shifted $4.4 million of State funding for schools into the local Levy where it has remained ever since 85% of the revenues to support the school district come from your local tax levy and that's unprecedented we feel your pain we understand that

02464% of the community resides in plann retirement communities we're doing all we can to be responsible but still to meet our number one goal which is to educate students what is the budget creation timeline well it begins over the summer in August we have a special Board of Education meeting for the development of a board Philosophy for the forthcoming year we study historical enrollment patterns because the budget again is driven by student enrollment we look at staffing needs to correspond with the new students we work with the principles again from a zerob based approach to determine what's needed at every school to educate every student we then engage in budget defense rounds where Mr ventrillo and Dr aloc and I make sure that all of the requested budget Appropriations meet board goals if they do

025not they are not included in the budget and they do not proceed we then wait for the Governor's budget address state aid by Statute is required 48 hours after the budget address then we adopt the tenative budget which is on on the agenda for this evening and finally we have a public Hearing in April what programs are in this budget Mr ventrillo would you like to explain these sure Common Core State Standards we've been consistently revising our curriculum to meet the state standards and each summer we consider uh which curriculum needs revisions and we map our curriculum for vertical alignment our English language arts program for grades K through 8 includes a balanced literacy approach which also includes phonics grammar skills Reading Writing speaking viewing and listening components in grades K through five uh envisions

026math and connected math in grades K through 5 students are taught the math standards through the envisions math program and through uh grades uh in grades 6 through 8 the students utilize the Connected Mathematics program Wilson Reading is a um help students in special education classes helps those special educ students to develop their decoding strategies and that certainly is a great program for the for the children each school offers the opportunity to participate in Hands-On science programs including our school Gardens and many schools have partnered with Community groups and boy girl uh Scout Troops to build and enhance our Gardens another great activity for the children uh this year we've we've implemented a World Language Blended learning environment for all students in grades 3 through 5 students utilize the Rosetta Stone program to learn Spanish

027and also meet weekly with with the World Language teacher for lessons on culture and diversity um you've heard us talk about our preparations for Park testing as you know this has included technology integration throughout our classrooms including Study Island word processing and assessment preparation through the test NAB site our students utilize technology daily in lessons and research the dr2 assessment in grades K through three we utilize that assessment it's developmental reading assessment um it's an individually administered assessment of a child's reading capabilities it's a tool used by teachers to identify students reading level accuracy fluency and comprehension and once the levels are identified a teacher can use the information to modify instruction we offer many athletic and co-curricular programs for all of our students uh many of our sports teams have won championships and our

028clubs and tag programs offer enrichment programs in many subjects for our students and I think you heard this evening also is the fact that the high school girls basketball and the high school wrestling team uh have run uh have just a a achieved some um trying to think what tournaments they achieved but they were just very were're very proud of their accomplishments since the Inception of the hi law we have continued to expand our character education programs throughout our schools uh the decrease in hi instances in the uh is evidence of the success of our programs we currently offer 25 AP courses and have 695 students enrolled all students who are enrolled uh in an AP uh course take the AP exams all special education program offers many programs to meet the needs of our

029diverse population and preschool utilizes the high scope curriculum and we have continued our integrated preschool program we use adaptive technology for the children in the special education programs as well too uh we also offer assessment and placement for any English language Learners and the extended school year program is also in place to assist those students who need it so there is a minimal loss of skills over the extended summer break many opportunities available to the adults in our community Through the adult education program and the offerings include uh the Arts computer technology culinary arts Finance family history Health well-being history language photography and Sports and Fitness the teen prevention education program that's teen pep is a program where students are teaching students about the importance of sound and informed decision-making and equipping them with the

030skills they need to make healthy decisions our professional development program is a model program across the country staff members participate in year-long PD courses or create a project in collaboration with other staff members under the supervision of a district administrator we also train our own security staff our power professional staff and transportation staff every 10th grade student participates in the PSAT each year for Avid advancement via uh via individual determination that teaches skills and behaviors for academic success it provides intensive support with tutorials and strong student teacher relationships it also creates a positive peer group for students and develops a sense of hope for Personal Achievement gained through hard work and determination these are just some of the wonderful opportunities for all of our students monu Township School District um is one of 10 districts

031in the state of New Jersey that has been recognized in innovate New Jersey innover New Jersey uh supports Innovation and practice by fostering sharing and collaboration among school districts we have been recognized for our one toone technology integration at the high school our aid program and our world language Blended learning environment in grades 3 through 5 um we were one of the first districts as a matter of fact to be recognized by this organization mon tanip high school has been recognized as a transformative School the first annual transformative School awards recognized Innovative high schools that utilize Alternative Learning and Technology to modernize the educational experience the high school exhibits an incredible focus on technology as a learning mechanism and has actually set a bar for connected classrooms programs and include iPads for students and teachers

032to extend their education via 24/7 access to information online course options and Amplified in-class experience through Apple TV collaboration based wikis electronic books and one-on-one electronic communications between parents and staff members US News and World Report identified mon Township High School as one of the best high schools in the country by awarding us the silver medal in 2014 there were numerous New Jersey schools in 2014 at that time um there I believe were 24 for gold medals 19 for silver and 32 for bronze and these are some of the programs that are currently that we offer our staff and students and they've led us to these Awards and we will continue to provide an excellent education to all our students lots to be proud ofi ladies and gentlemen this is the return on your investment

033best high school top transformative schools top schools by innovate New Jersey educationally we are succeeding in our mission let's get into some of the numbers now please there's two types of state aid number one is the larger type of state aid called Equalization Aid um many districts in the county that are similar to ours such as South Brunswick receive in excess of $20 million a year in Equalization Aid this is determined by two factors property wealth and income levels property wealth comes from ratables income levels come from the aggregate New Jersey 1040 filings where you have that four-digit Municipal Code the code for Monroe is aggregated and according to the state our district wealth and income is higher than that of our peers and we are not eligible for any Equalization Aid separately is a

034type of Aid called categorical Aid and uh by its very name this is a type of state aid for various categories that District qualifies for Monroe receives special education Aid um also Park Readiness Aid security aid but we only receive a fraction of what we should receive we have the most efficient transport service in the county one of the highest in the state and that's determined by a rating from a very voluminous uh Dr trsf report but yet our state aid in these categories is limited and phased out because of our wealth and affluence and and a factor called over adequacy status which the state has frozen the model for the last two years to let it properly calculate and show the progress that we have been making red reducing over adequacy state aid is

0353.19% of our total revenues to support the school budget and is one of the lowest in the state and um has the lowest state aid per pup ratios in the county there are two um reports that I handed out one is titled A and one is B please refer to a for the next uh few minutes comments sources of revenue is what defines the budget you cannot have Appropriations that exceed your revenues for the budget and number one we faced a a challenge this year because Surplus also known as fund balance has been shrinking as we've been budgeting more appropriate uh more more efficiently more tightly to the line and we've been using our annual school budget to address large construction infrastructure projects like like roofs we have a reduction in Surplus from last year

036to 1516 by $1.1 million that means our 1516 budget is $1.1 million shorter or shrunken than the prior year Debt Service is also reduced by 149,000 for a total of $1.3 million less in Surplus than last year now we may recall a board meeting U many years ago where a resident came up and challenged Dr Hamilton and said you apply all this extra Bond money to keep the taxes lower through the direction of Jerry tag and then Administration previous we built this high school and had $8 million of referendum Bond money left over as Surplus and we've returned it all to the taxpayers um we've done it on installments which was intelligently designed to stimulate the tax uh situation in years where we've had a decline in ratables and then to wean off in years

037like the last two where we've had a a stabilization of ratables this year we only have $273,000 remaining in this Bond account to close it out and we are throwing it all at the tax levy to reduce it but that means we are increasing The Debt Service tax levy by $22.26 million compared to the prior year that does not affect the size of the budget only the tax has a consequence local taxes pursuant to the board's philosophy uh uh directive we are at cap we are not asking the voters for a special referendum to exceed the cap although we certainly have uh uh means uh in order to spend the money if needed uh there are uh construction projects throughout the district that need address but hopefully we can package those into a bond referendum

038in the future other Revenue consists of tuition from Jamesburg and that's uh $271,000 less than last year state aid is essentially the same as it was last year and it's $500,000 less than it was 6 years ago despite the fact that again we have over 1,200 addition students to to educate federal aid does not contribute much to any school district's budget they consider that uh funding an obligation of the state and the total revenue this year is proposed to increase 1.2 $11.92 million slide B shows the state aid history and again I've touched on most of this already but we are in equably funded compared to our peers for state aid what did we do about it well we've written our own in-house legislation that was sponsored by Senator Greenstein um you could see all

039that information on our website it died in the closing of the last Senate but it has been reintroduced into the Senate and the assembly and it is still very much alive and we still speak with Senator Greenstein the likelihood of this becoming law is remote but we are demonstrating that we are doing everything possible including writing our own legislation I'm not an attorney Mr ventrello is not an attorney but we wrote Our Own legislation inhouse that was sponsored by Senator Greenstein and uh put on the floor miscellaneous revenue for this year we have use of building fees that we project to raise uh bring in $120,000 we have solar energy credits from Oak Tree School $10,000 a year they were much higher before when there was uh more available Federal subsidies adult education program $25,000

040Transportation joint shes and trip 65,000 if we could find a colleague who's driving through our area we'll we'll share the cost with them and and save money preschool integrated program $100,000 a year interest income 9,000 Admissions and sports 25,000 Oprah fees recycling grants rebate 79,000 this is an excerpt from Ross Hab and Associates report on enrollment comparing the 1415 and a 15 16 school years as you could see there is an anticipated 267 students for 156 that we don't have right now that's a new school every two years and we and this is nothing new but it is intensifying them where does the money go we're very proud that over 60% of our expenditures when you add direct instruction expenses benefits pertaining to teachers and direct instruction Athletics co-curricular transportation is over 60% of every

041dollar spent appropriation detail is handout C forgive me for the handouts but you could never incorporate these kind of schedules into a PowerPoint presentation what I would like you to not is from handout C is the incredible number of reductions from this year to 1516 as a result of again the zerob based budgeting approach going through and really scrutinizing everything in in the finance committee meeting we had board member concerns that we have enough in the budget and we're not cutting enough out to run short next year what's going to happen if fuel prices rebound and don't recognize the savings you have in the budget and admittedly you know I am I am nervous because this is one of the tightest budgets that we've presented but um it's responsible to the taxpayers and I and

042we believe as Educators it meets the needs of the students most importantly some accounts turn into our favor uh like energy costs uh dropped others still continue to be a challenge health insurance the state health benefits fund which was designed to be an aggregate Insurance Fund for health by the state of New Jersey is projecting increases next year at 133% because of our our um claims history Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield which is a monopoly and controls 70% of the health insurance Market in New Jersey gave us a proposal for 15 to 16% increases for next year on an account this size that's more than we could even grow the budget but through collaboration with our broker who is one of the largest brokers in the world and brings a lot of clout to Horizon

043when they when they negotiate on our behalf and through my tenacity uh in negotiating we got Horizon down to an 8% increase next year and through chapter 78 contributions from staff the health insurance increase is 2.8% for next year that is very well controlled um and it and it kudos to the board and the board's negotiating committee and the Union's collaboration in agreeing in the last Labor contract to pay tier four the highest rate for chapter 78 contributions not for the first year of the contract as required by law but for all three that's over $3 million a year 3 .4 million a year we collect from staff and that's how we're able to bring 8% down to 2.8 administrative costs Mr ventrillo and I are very proud to demonstrate that while the regional limit

044that you cannot exceed continues to increase District Administrative cost per pupil is decreasing we work diligently in the business office to save money on every opportunity possible no matter how small Food Services we we provide lunches to the ed Service Commission we recycle everything we can to get any uh scrap salvage value transportation services will share any jointure with another District that's within reason to share the cost of the route purchasing since I've been the business administrator the board was supportive of joining a collaborative purchasing um process for supplies with the ed Service Commission and to date we've saved over a million dollars just on supply cost from buying through the Consortium as opposed to buying Under State contract or bid technology Services if you look on your phone bill you'll see a federal tax

045well that's one benefit to the school district is we get rebates on technology expenditures for utilities and uh insurance and coverage and benefits we have Property and Casualty Insurance in school boards Association Insurance Group and the Eric North subf fund what factors influence the tax rate well number one state aid if we receive $20 million of equal Equalization Aid like our colleagues uh the tax rate here in Monroe would be significantly less but we don't we're considered again affluent and wealthy and this is what we have to deal with and you know the Public's tired of hearing about this but that's the truth number two fund balance applied I talked about that earlier number three ratables we're fortunate this year that we have a 2% increase in ratables and what are ratables ratables are the

046property valuations throughout the township that share the local tax levy based upon their property wealth and number number four increased student enrollment has a great effect on Appropriations again general fund appropriation spending would be less than last year had it not been for the required construction and and the teachers needed to fill the classrooms for growth how does it affect my pocketbook next year well well it's a 4.5 Cent increase to the budget which for an average assessed home at $39,000 is $138 increase however without the effect of the Middle School construction which is required for growth to house students and the and the requisite number of staff to fill the classrooms we would have a 2 and2 cent a 2.6 Cent increase or 81.7 $6 folks I've been here 15 years I've seen a

047lot of tax schedules this is attractive this is below the median this is extraordinarily attractive um but you know some things you don't have a choice on finally over the last three years had it not been for the effects of growth which we actually went through the last three years budgets and calculated specifically there would be a cumulative decrease to the tax levies and finally a lot of professionals have collaborated in the Prof in the Assembly of this year's school budget it's a process that begins back in April it's not over yet and I would like to to thank laori Allen and Dr alvic and especially Dennis vent trillo who took a much more conservative approach and had the respect of his colleagues this year like never before in putting together a budget that is

048very conservative and most importantly meets the needs of every student thank you now this evening we are going to have a public hearing as soon as uh we're seated and that's an opportunity for the public to ask questions specifically and only about the school budget we tonight good job coffee good job for your convenience this evening there's a microphone in both of the aisles so use whichever one is most convenient uh for you at this time we will take uh comments or questions from the public on the uh budget presentation for next uh the next school year uh please keep in mind that when you come to the microphone you need to state your name and address and all Al uh keep your comments to 3 minutes or less we we thank you for your

049cooperation uh in follow and abiding with those uh regulations okay the floor is now open to questions or comments specifically on the budget good evening my name is Joe castal Lucio 20 Ashley Court Monroe uh thank you Mr Gorski that was a very good presentation Mr villo um I've mentioned this before and I I really hope that we can get somebody to step up to the plate you talked about creating your own legislation you already have this legislation it's called the US Constitution the 14th Amendment specifically the one thing I don't understand is why our students are not treated equally when we talk about how there's leg legislation that says we're affluent that we don't get what our peers get uh it's a little bit of bias there a little bit of prejudice there and

050equal protection under the law which is the again you cannot have a state law that trumps the US Constitution and the US Constitution says that every US citizen which includes the Monro student teach uh Monroe Township students should get treated equally how can the state make legislation and determine who gets what tax dollars we put tax dollars in we should be able to get our fair share back like everyone else I know about the PC part so I'm not going to go there but nonetheless we have to have somebody that steps up to the plate and uses the US Constitution that's there for all of us our students should be getting exactly what everybody else is getting quite frankly you should be getting a little bit more but I'm just going to tell you that

051if we could get a group of people that'll put a little time in if we can get some I'm sure there's a retired attorney in one of the retirement communities and maybe there's somebody who's not retired that would be willing to put that we can fight it and we can get it I think the people in New Jersey Feinstein whoever I don't care whether they're Democrats or Republicans they're all doing this for political reasons and we must be able to step up to the plate use the US Constitution 14th Amendment equal protection under law was written with the 13th and fth 15th right after the Civil War that's what we need right now and we need somebody to do it and I hope somebody here will step up to the plate and I'll be willing

052to donate as much of my time and energy to it I hope that you could take that challenge thank you Mar k s cruncho Court back from Florida um what the gentleman just said is true when it comes to the federal government but more so is what I preached for the last two years or longer is a state constitution section three paragraph 1 and two uh paragraph one states that uh the New Jersey government is responsible for providing free public education to all its residents ages 5 to 18 that's free public education to all paragraph two the state legislature is responsible for setting aside the funds to provide free public education to ages 5 to age 18 if we the taxpayers are paying 97% of the cost of Education that is not free public education

053and that's in violation of the State Constitution as far as the meeting that we had at the budget and Appropriations Committee in Trenton supposedly uh Linda Greenstein was pushing to get help us get more money that was a ploy that was to get more votes I was there I heard what some of the Senators responses were it was a bunch of baloney the reason why we don't get off fair share and I think Mr Gorski will uh go along with this or correct it is the fact that they go by property wealth so they take total population divide it by the students and that's property wealth well if you have 50% to 55% of your total population over ages 55 with no children that's a false figure and we're being penalized for that I would

054like to see as I've said for that we look into suing the state to get our fair share according to the state constitution thank you I started thank you uh Sandy efon at 110 Turnberry Drive I'm not sure if uh this is in the budget are being considered it's Mecca meca and uh this is something unfortunately that that is a program that um I'm against excuse me sir but your your comment has to apply strictly to the budget there will be an opportunity later on to speak to that topic so it's not in the budget it's I don't believe so well it's not being considered for the budget go ahead uh Mecca has no budget implication and as board president has mentioned there will be an opportunity at the next public forum right after the

055budget's concluded to address Mecca as well as anything else on the agenda cor correct me if I'm wrong is that's a money losing proposition and as such isn't that part of the budget consideration sir it's a different fund it has nothing to do with the budget that we're speaking to so I ask you to please hold your comment until the next public forum which will be in a few minutes oh okay good evening Ira tesler 11l Drive I'd like to thank Mr Gorski Mr villo for excellent presentation uh one quick question question about the budget um I know you were uh looking into the one uh 101 initiative the iPad initiative and there wasn't any mention specifically in the budget about that and what is included in next year's budget for that initiative yes the

056onetoone initiative is a a program that has been established by the board previously uh it is currently offered as a onetoone educational device to every High school student and staff member there's learning that is being presented on the devices the devices encourage student collaboration after hours and uh excitement and interest in learning that is hard to do with just a textbook um that said there is a lease appropriation in the budget for $400,000 for 156 school year and that number was calculated conserv ly working with Mr Reggie Washington and Dr Dory alvik to determine the various platforms that are being considered now what we would recognize is uh as an estimate of the bid for sale for the current devices that have exceeded their useful life and the net effect on a lease and again

057that figure that's in the budget is 400,000 it will remain in the budget as a program until recommended by the super intendent and and uh and then it would take a resolution of the board to remove it so there is an appropriation for $400,000 for the iPad continuance not necessarily iPad one to one initiative in the budget right so the money's there but we're not sure exactly what what device is going to be used yet that's correct thank you I'm I'm 30 Castlebury um I just have a quick question which I tried to understand you said this year this transfer from other fund $2.5 million down to$ 273,000 in this year what can you again explain what that is sure I'd be happy to when we built this High School Bonds were sold to the

058public through Municipal Bond sale right um to get the revenue to build the school right and through the direction of Mr Jerry T who's in the audience the project was completed on time and $8 million under budget okay and we've taken that $8 million and returned it on installments over the last few years back to the taxpayers as tax relief instead of raising Debt Service funds for interest and principle needed for the next year we substituted the bond referendum proceeds in lie of the that tax levy that money is now extinguished except for 273,000 so comparing to last year there will be an increase in the debt service tax rate because you no longer have that surfplus to substitute for principle and interest required to be raised to The Debt Service Levy okay so Debt

059Service that's why the debt service will go will then how come your debt service is going down from 155,000 to 5 5900 in your fund balance Deb service The Debt Service uh revenue is increasing 6,170 I'm sorry 2,724 1833 compared to last year so the amount of money that we have to raise through The Debt Service tax levy is increasing 2,724 1833 from exhibit a yeah I'm looking at so I'm sorry I'm talking about the fund balance Debt Service it says it was 55,000 it's going down to only 5,900 yes the state statute requires that any fund balance be appropriated to uh subsequent years's budget use instead of raising taxes and we had $149,000 of surplus uh decreased in The Debt Service fund because we had 155,000 remaining before and only 5900 from last year

060the reason we had so much from that prior year was a bond refunding where we able to save that on interest cost through uh the refunding of bonds okay thank you thank you I recognize the budget is very complex and I would welcome any email or call on the subject matter Nelson Chen for Ashley Court again very nice presentation on the budget I'd like to thank you and the rest of the board for working so hard uh I didn't get here early enough so I don't have the handouts but I did notice on one of your slide presentations that you talked about revenue and there was $100,000 I guess from the latch key program coming in is that correct I beig pardon $100,000 from what the Latchkey program the After School Care Program yes um

061currently the before and after school care network has a lease agreement with the district to pay $100,000 a year for use of our facilities to provide a before and after school care program okay um the board has passed a resolution directing Administration to create our own in house before and after school care program which will be in a future known as Falcon care and that program is anticipated to bring in between two and $300,000 of of net profit um exceeding what we were receiving from the before and after school care network uh perhaps it's in the handout or not but like I said I didn't get the handouts was there any Revenue attributed to the mecca program on that slide I didn't see that on there I'm just inquiring I know there's another section that

062that will be discussed but the the mecca program is a separate fund it is not included in the general fund Debt Service fund special project F under that Revenue section I'm told no no there's nothing in the revenue section pertaining to Mecca uh am I to understand from that that there was no income from that there is income from that it's been paying back the loan but it's not part of the budget presentation it borrowed money from the general fund years ago and has been paying $5,000 a month religiously since resolution's been passed by the board okay thank you thank you hello uh I'm Natan uh six barlay drive and uh this is regarding the the before care and after care right now it has been taken care by bass and you said like it's

063going to be by the in-house which is really know appreciated but my question here is now uh previously I was staying in piscar there we I was like paying like 250 for before care and after care here it's like close to 500 so it's double the price right so with the in-house you know okay we are planning to raise some fund from there is is there going to be like some advantage to us also they kind of reducing the cost from high 500 to something less um there has been no fee structure that's been expressed yet for the Falcon CARE program so I'm I'm unfortunately I cannot compare to what you're paying now but I can say that the projected Revenue structure for the Falcon care Revenue will be less than um what we understand

064to be charged right now by the Before and After School Care Network stay tuned that'll be released shortly okay thank you thank you hi hi Deb pela 15 Louise Lane quick question regarding US Constitution New Jersey Constitution I was there at the meeting in Trenton when Senator Greenstein went up and presented and I remember Senator Ruiz turning around so bluntly saying well maybe there's someone in my district who wants more money so why would I give your District money and it was very disheartening and I think we were all kind of took it as gez this is getting nowhere so out of curiosity besides getting a lawsuit against our own state is there something else we as the people could do to help fight that we're only getting the 3% and you know what else

065can we do is there any direction you can give us to maybe make any sort of difference or make our voices heard whether it's Governor chrisy or whomever thank you yes um the district under um the current and previous administration of superintendent has looked at every Avenue to address the underfunding state aid we've met with Council from wance Goldman and Spitzer the former Bond attor uh the former board attorney and we were advised against proceeding with a lawsuit against the state the reason for that is the state has an obligation under the Constitution to fund the schools to ensure that the school's adequacy budget is funded what is the adequacy budget it's a very complex calculation that takes in consideration your number of students your number of special education students um and it multiplies it

066by a think tanks model of what a school district should cost per pupil in those various categories and comes up with an adequacy budget the state hasn't followed that model for the last two years and they haven't used current enrollment information so the the model is has been suspended but the state feels that a um a local fair share is the obligation that's required by the population to fund the adequacy budget and in Monroe's case the state has determined that Monroe can meet its local fair share on its own and they're happy to let you do so what can we do about it we've looked at the possibility of a lawsuit we've written our own legislation which is on our website and I would encourage anybody to look at it it's very complex and it

067was a great endeav by our district to do it's still a and has a shot I would recommend writing to the state legislature and the governor and say that you're fed up with the amount of taxes that you're paying in Monroe it's not an administrative problem at the district level it's a funding problem and address it that way because the governor likes to make claims that yeah I know about Monroe uh they went over cap referring to a immaterial error that occurred with the municipality years ago both the municipal and the school district are very well-run we could be run better and more responsibly to you if we received our fair share of state aid and nobody can convince me that South Brunswick should receive over $20 million of adequacy Aid Equalization Aid and Monroe

068receive nothing I drive through the communities I don't see that great of a wealth and income level can I come again can I ask again okay okay so again Manish B 30 c um one quick question you showed and I think you tried to show that analogy that there were like 267 additional students this year you try to show the family of four going to six that makes sense as long as if there is no new homes being built and construction so I'm assuming that when 267 students are coming additional students in each year there are be no lot of new construction that's going on um I'm in one of that new construction um even though I was past mono resident myself but I can tell you for sure at least from what I have

069seen around appleg road that definitely 100 homes that have come up in last one year for sure has this budget taken into account the additional tax revenue that the that Monro will receive because you're showing 3 and half million increase in general fund when we know based on the tax assessment that we are receiving that our taxes now which was 100% of the assessment last year is going to be 96.9% this year so innovates about 3 and a half% increase just by that and you are also showing about 3 and a half% increase 3.88% so if there are going to be so many new homes built and if they're going to be those homes are approximately give or take in the range of 600,000 give or take whatever it may be at that rate at

070what you showed and whatever the taxes may be if they come out to be I'm assuming I'm giving all ballpark numbers don't quote me on that 600,000 2.4% 13 14,000 100 homes $1.5 million that is that being accounted in this I mean when you say 267 students I'm pretty sure they come with their share of taxes along with them not all of them some of them maybe more than half of them them question uh number one in addressing your question I would like to talk about first the impact of the students on the district uh every student on average is about $155,000 so 267 times $15,000 is $4 million of cost that the district's going to have to incur to educate those students on average there is uh in some states something called an impact

071fee that's where the builders who are profiting by building the homes have to pay a certain search charge or um or bounty to the school district to make up for the consequence that it has on the schools and the infrastructure in town that is not allowed in the state of New Jersey it does increase the rateable base as I mentioned previously the ratables have grown 2% so when the ratables grow more people are sharing to pay for the levy and everybody else everybody has to pay a little bit less because there's more Shar sharing so inherently the new homeowners that are moving in are sharing with you in the burden to to educate the schools and run a municipality and and so on but there you know there's no other relief for the school district

072other than the fact that ratables grow which does reduce your tax rate period so so I'm not saying it should provide relief I'm not saying I don't know how much tax rate has at all reduced at least in last so many years um like I said I was a no resident on mil lake side now I moved towards applegath road but the point is yes you said it came with $4 million you're showing general fund increasing by 3 and A5 million your difference at the bottom of the total revenue is 2 million right that's what you're showing that the increment probably people will have taxes increase or whatever you might be considering you're showing at the bottom the total revenue increases by 2 million that's your Gap I mean increase from last year's budget so

073in essence when 200 67 students additional students come for education or join the schools they would come not only are the taxpayers paying more taxes than last year or will pay more taxes than last year based on what we are hearing from County tax assessment office but they also come with additional taxes I'm not yet 100% sure like if if I'm just looking at the high level the numbers 3 and a half% increase taxes sir the sir the time's up but I get the essence of your question and and there is something in New Jersey called a tax levy cap that was uh implemented in the tax law of 2010 I know that that allows you to grow your budget from last year's general fund Levy by taking last year's general fund Levy adding an

074enrollment adjustment which is conservative multiplying it by 2% and adding a health care adjustment which again is is really immaterial so the amount you can grow your budget by is capped the enrollment adjustment does not keep up with the number of students here so we have not enough Revenue coming from taxes to keep up with the with the Appropriations needed to educate 267 new students which requires us to go into existing programs and services operate more efficiently and save money to make up the difference okay if I may um yes but just just let me comment on that gentleman's question there uh I believe this was in your question uh in determining the amount of Revenue that would be raised through the property taxes yes any new homes that were built since the last time

075that that was determined a year ago has been taken into account so all new construction that has been finalized that's on the tax books that does bring more Revenue into to the school system but as Mr Gorski pointed out if and and this is not a hard figure but if it takes $115,000 on the average to educate one student for that year and if you buy a home and you have one child going to the school system and let's say you pay $110,000 in school taxes someone else is having to pick up the other 5,000 it's having to because you're not you're not bringing in enough tax to pay for the education of that one child if you are sending two children to the school system then that's $30,000 but your taxes are contributing $10,000

076that leaves $20,000 yet to be made up now if if in fact you live in a much more modest home where maybe your taxes are only $4,000 then that leaves a difference of $111,000 that has to be made up by other taxpayers so it it's unfortunate but those are the facts in terms of how the the property taxes work 56% if you want if you want to come to the microphone you can do that yes Mr cast Lucho thank you Mr Gorski can you just go over the debt Services because when the bond was issued a number of years ago interest rates were much higher is there a refunding provision that you have where you can continuously come to Market and take advantage of lower interest rates so that the debts funding Services would beow

077low yes I'm I'm glad you asked and in fact with the business administrator's report tonight I want to talk about a current bond refunding that we're engaged in for the 2008 series which is the high school bonds um but I can say that we've had two prior Bond refundings and if you bear with me one moment I have a schedule on that I don't want to hold you up but let me find it and when I get my business administrator report I'll tell you what we saved from the death service obligations for those two prior refunded bonds and we just did a $60 million Bond refunding we priced the bonds last Monday um and I have an interesting story to talk about briefly when I get to my uh business administrator report but we look

078at every opportunity where interest rates fall to where we have a 3% Net Present Value savings on the bonds and that includes the cost of refunding and uh we've met that Benchmark two times previously and we've refunded those at Great savings numbers I just have to find them and we have another one tonight that I'm very proud to show you in a few minutes are there any other any more questions or comments on the budget hi I'm farola 6 Sher Lane um it seems like an a Comm thing that's being said tonight is that with all the new construction you know there's so many more students and it's really um sort of creating a crisis for us in the school system especially you know those of us who have little kids were obviously very concerned

079like does anybody here or anybody talk to like the zoning board or people who are in the position to like approve these monster developments um like something like celebrations which is going to be all small unit um I don't know apartments condos you know 450 units you know they're not going to probably generate a lot of tax but I can guarantee you at least half of them are going to have one or two kids each um I'm just wondering like is there any communication with like zoning or to say listen we're having a big problem in row you can't keep approving such big developments excuse me I'm take that yeah you yes I'm pleased to say that we do work very collaboratively with the zoning and planning board uh also the Township officials the mayor

080uh Wayne Hamilton and I I can say that from my knowledge with the township there has been an emphasis to try to create more commercial ratables and less Residential Properties um for the um sensitivity towards the schools so we have a very um good collaborative relationship with the township uh the mayor was very influential years ago in getting the land donated from a developer that we built oak tree school on which saved taxpayers from bonding for it otherwise so uh we the answer is yes we do work very collaboratively with the township okay thank you anyone else Mr Klein are you coming to the microphone the young lady who just spoke where she quoted 529 units let me update you you have roughly four to five family communities being built as of today you have

081two approved condo and apartment complexes one on uh spots with English town road across from the stone Museum which will be roughly 529 condos and a apartments and the same Builder has been approved on panzo Road from where makeer wish Castle is to 33 and out that's going to be 729 or 749 condos and apartments so something that was brought up and Mr Po hit the nail right on the head it it cost $115,000 a year to educate a student in Monroe and they purchase a home the federal average per family is I believe they say 1.7 children per family rounded out to two if you're paying $122,000 in property tax and you have two children you're in a hole for $115,000 that we have to pay for when you go into these condos which

082are going to be owned and their property taxes will be a lot less or the apartments which are going to be rentals and how they work out taxes on that is beyond me all you got to do is go towards Englishtown and right before you get in Englishtown look on the left those tow houses that was supposed to be affordable housing they pay no school taxes they pay pilot which is something in place of taxes go take a look at how many bicycles are on The Terraces how many kids are going to those schools the problem we have here today we knew about five six seven years ago the problem was that the superintendent that we had at the time did not want to address it all this study was done originally onri Mr Klein

083I'm almost finished no no no you are finished thank you okay and and that's the story and I I I want to point out that when people come to the microphone their comments and questions should be addressed to the board and not to fellow members of the public so please keep that in mind in the future uh I felt that Mr Klein had a relative a relevant comment though uh since we were talking about budget and taxes so I did permit him to go on but normally that would not be uh allowed any other uh people want to speak uh with questions or comments on the budget Okay so sorry still open or well you you you've had I think about three opportunities to speak yeah I did um I'm not going to take 3

084minutes I'll just take half a minute is that okay excuse me um just very quick question what you heard from the previous gentleman what the lady said and we saw your budget does school district have any kind of structure to project what next 2 3 5 years will look like and do can you give any insight of what what steps are you guys taking that's all I'm asking yes and later this evening if you're still here there is a presentation on projected growth over the next 5 years okay the floor is now closed to comments or questions on the budget I believe we have resolutions are we going have disc before the resolution uh the the floor is open for board questions and comments on the budget Mr P alsoo the 2% cap what is

085not covered in the 2% cap use your microphone there everything is covered in the 2% cap again the calculation for it is you take last year's general fund tax levy which is available and delineated on every school district's userfriendly budget which was required to be on their website so if you take the general fund tax levy you add to it a state automatic adjust adment for enrollment which is conservative considering the effect that it has on Monroe's budget inflate it by 2% and add a small Health Care adjustment compared to how your costs align with the state health benefits plan that is the general fund tax levy cap everything in the general fund budget is included in there years ago if you had a capital construction project like a roof you were allowed to go

086above cap there was a cap exemption for that if you had a tuition issue with a sending receiving School District you could have a tuition cap waiver all those cap waivers are gone in 2010 everything's in the cap any exceptions no any other questions or comments from the board um M armenio okay so the 20 on um exib the a sheet a the budget for uh 205 and 2016 will be 115 milon 6599 120 that that's the number we're voting on tonight I have to elaborate on that um that is the total revenue source to support all funds uh there will be a sophisticated resolution that I'll read shortly which will delineate the amount for each fund and the tax levy for each fund there's two tax levies one for the general fund and one

087for The Debt Service fund um and I'll read that in in great detail shortly okay so let me also at uh where on here shows our debt Ser uh not The Debt Service so much as the total debt owed the total debt owed expands beyond the 1516 school budget right we have amortization schedules going out over 20 years um if you look to the comprehensive annual financial report for 2014 you will see that the total debt service currently obligated by the district is about $148 million1 148 million and that's over 20 years payout that's approximately correct approximately and then when you recast the uh some of the bonds that changes a little bit yes when when you refund the bonds due to uh falling interest rates we've taken advantage of every refunding opportunity I'll speak

088more about that later that reduces current obligations in the next year's budget for interest and Principle as well as future years The Debt Service that's contained in the 15 16 budget is only the amount of principal and interest required to pay all the existing bonds for that school year and um president poy I would just like to make a few comments about some of the things I've heard from the public um the the board there are members on the board and certainly uh who have been in in the public sphere before they were on the board who went to uh board uh meetings of the zoning board and planning board and it is not just a a board obligation to go to those meetings it's a community obligation if I mean this is where we

089are given the uh responsibility of educating the children that come to us and I know uh past president K pan has always said we are tasked with the responsibility of educating the children but speaking for myself not as a board member but as a community member since 1980 um public participation in zoning and planning and Township council is where these was where things happen um we this is the end game at at the Board of Education the end game is educating the children that are brought to Us by the decisions that are made on the municipal level so uh if if you it is not just a board obligation to be informed it is the is the community and the public to be informed as to what's going on we certainly welcome all of the

090new students in the community but in order for us to manage uh the growth it is the obligation of every resident to either be informed and to participate in that in that experience at at the municipal level so we again are the endgame and we are obligated to certainly um give the best education to the children I certainly would like to do that and in and doing in having made that statement I'd like to thank um the teachers and the principes um who have tried I'm sure very hard to reduce spending because when I was a civilian before I got on the board I said we have a spending issue the school State uh Aid is a small portion small portion of the budget that we are tasked as board members to oversee so sometimes

091we have to make decisions uh regarding spending that are not always palatable but they are a responsibility of of the board um but certainly resident input is is very very important so um going back to the principles the administration um looking into the budgets and trying to do the best is appreciated uh we have a lot of we have a lot of work to do in the future and we want to give the best opportunity for our children to continue a good education so thank you all for that thank you Mr armeno anyone else Mr noin first off I'd like to first off I'd like to thank uh Mr Gorski and interim superintendent uh Mr ventrillo for their hard work um this is a I think a very tight budget and uh that's exactly what

092I always like to see uh I just had one question to Mr Gorski um and I'm sure the public may have some interest in knowing the send receive agreement that we worked out with uh Jamesburg how is that uh going forward and is it does it look like it's going to meet our expectations uh of of it when we signed it yes um speaking of that agreement when we just had a bond refunding as I've reported to the board and for the benefit of the public the outstanding litigation that we had with Jamesburg according to our financial adviser would have resulted in a bond rating decrease by S&P for the school district's bonds which means that everybody who's paying uh interest on the bonds would be paying more because of the creditworthy ESS of the

093dist District fortunately we are have an agreement with Jamesburg where Jamesburg recognizes their obligation to the school district which came about from the state cap Levy of 2010 which eliminated a tuition cap waiver and did not allow Jamesburg to budget for their anticipated tuition costs for when their children began coming to the mon Township High School so the current agreement um is uh very much in the favor of the County office and we are very much optimistic that it will pay back the aage and quite frankly it's the only means necessary we have other than a lengthy murky litigation process thank you um and with regards to some of the the comments made from the public tonight with the the zoning uh issues I came to Monroe in 1985 and I'm sure when I moved

094into my development of 90 homes there were a lot of people looking around and saying H there goes the neighborhood there's 90 more homes we have to increase uh the spending in the schools Etc um we're all here because Monroe is a great place to live and more importantly the schools are unbelievable how many people in this room and I'm not looking for a show of hands but I will guarantee you a lot of people did their due diligence and said I'm moving to Monroe because the schools are so great and that's a credit to our staff and the the the administration so there's a lot to be said for that uh I'm I'd like to almost say this is what we could call a good problem uh but I'm not quite there yet but

095it it is definitely uh the reason that you know it's almost like a self-fulfilling prophecy so I just want everyone to keep that in mind too that that's why we're here because of the good school system thank you thank you Mr notin uh Mr Ryback thank you president po um I've been a member now for a little over two months and for about two months I think I've been a daily fixer almost at the district office and I want to thank Mr ventrello Mr Gorski for always being receptive to me um I come all the time with questions and they answered them so I've been involved in the in as much as possible in in this budget development and I really want to compliment them both uh on on the care they've taken and the

096sensitivity they've shown to the need needs of the tax player but even more importantly I have to say to the needs of our our children and that's what makes uh Monroe such a wonderful school system that's important we have to keep providing this quality education and you have the right people over there uh developing that uh a budget that demonstrates that I just like to uh tag on to what my colleague Miss arminia was talking about before about growth this is an endgame the passion that we've been seeing with you're here for uh the budget or whether whether you're here for the um uh new schools or the districting or whatever it might be this is a result of all the growth that we're seeing Now growth in itself isn't bad but where you need

097to put your energy the passion that I see out here the passion that I see when I uh talk to you and certainly in all the correspondences I've been reading I've been reading all of them and I'm sure my colleagues are doing the same that passion has to be brought to the state level because you have laws on at this in Trenton that allow developers to come into towns build developments with no regard to uh space in schools students uh wouldn't it be wonderful if if with all this development the developers would would have to build a school that would be able to uh accommodate the numbers of students coming from their developments or build build a wing onto a school at their cost not yours because you're going to be paying for it so

098on one hand you know the growth is great but on the other hand uh these developers are coming in building these developments getting the money and leaving and guess who's who's holding the bag who's going to be paying for these uh uh schools you are so the passion that I'm seeing and feeling bring that to the state level they have to hear it we have developers who are Al represented by um state representatives what does that say that was the illegal Council so talk about David and Goliath We're The Davids we have to fight the Goliath so you have to unite and bring that energy up up to Trenton um thank you very much thank you Mr Ryback anyone else boy I didn't sound someone fall asleep back there okay at this time uh we

099will have a resolution read by Mr Gorski if you haven't fall asleep yet uh you will after these two resolutions please bear with me they're lengthy uh but required to be read resolution of the Board of Education Township of Monroe in the county of middlex New Jersey designating the transfer of certain unexpended Bond proceeds to fund 40 for Debt Service this first resolution transfers the remaining money in the bond account which built the school closes it out and puts it all against the tax levy for Debt Service reducing taxes whereas on March 4th 2008 the Board of Education the Board of Education of the township of Monroe in the county of middlex New Jersey issued its $41 mil 900,000 School District bond series 2008 the 2008 bonds and whereas the 2008 Bonds were issued to

100finance a the additional cost necessary for the construction of a new monra Township High School as previously approved by the the voters of the township of Monroe in December of 2003 B any necessary improvements upgrades appar inures equipment furniture and site work and see certain incidental expenses collectively the 2008 project and whereas the proceeds of the 2008 Bonds were deposited in fund 36 fund 36 to be used for the 2008 project and whereas the 2008 project has been completed and as of December 31st 2014 $273,300 86 of the proceeds of the 2008 bonds remain unencumbered and on deposit in the fund 36 the unencumber 2008 proceeds and whereas the Board of Education hereby desires to designate the transfer to fund 40 Debt Service the unincumbered 2008 proceeds and any investment earnings thereon from fund 36

101and whereas the Board of Education hereby desires to close fund 34 and fund 36 now therefore be it resolved by the Board of Education as follow follows section one the Board of Education hereby author authorizes the board secretary business administrator to transfer all remaining unincumbered 2008 proceeds and any investment earnings thereon from fund 36 to offset the tax levy for fiscal year 201526 section two the Board of Education hereby authorizes the board secretary business administrator to close fund 34 and fund 36 as such funds will have a zero balance section three the resolution shall take effect immediately adopted March 12th 2015 I will now proceed with a roll call um they need a motion and a second so moved Tom Tom and Mr braen Mr musty and Mr Braverman Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman yes

102Mr zareski yes Mr Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr nosin yes Mr proso so noted Mr Rybeck yes Mr poy yes Mr board president resol resolution designating the transfer of certain unexpended Bond proceeds to fund 40 Debt Service has passed next I'll read the resolution for the preliminary budget be it resolved by the Monro Township Board of Education that the 2015 2016 tenative general fund budget be adopted in the amount of 103 million 725,000 and a tenative Debt Service budget in the amount of 10,822 $666 and a tenative Debt Service local tax levy in the amount of 9, 8639 73 whereby the tenative 20156 budget totals $5,695 120 and whereas the Monro Township Board of Education has been notified of state aid amounts and whereas such state aid amounts are for

103the 2015 2016 the categorical special education Aid is $2,485 and for the 15 16 categorical security Aid is 92,5 and for the 201516 categorical Transportation Aid is $496,500 and for The 201516 Debt Service Aid is $679,500 and per pupil Grant Aid of $58,900 and whereas the Monro Township Board of Education has estimated a state aid amount pursuant to application for the 201516 the estimated extraordinary Aid amount is $214,400 and whereas the state's failure to fully fund the school refunding form Act of 2008 as well as other factors has provided insufficient financial support for programs and services contained in the budget necessitating the application of $239,999 of unused spending authority to be included in the base budget and that said needs will be completed by the end of the budget year and will be not be

104deferred incrementally completed over a longer time and whereas the school district bylaw 0147 policy 3440 policy 4440 njac 6823 B- 1.2b provides that the Board of Education shall establish in the amount an annual school budget in the maximum expenditure amount that may be allocated for travel expense reimbursement for the 15 16 school year now therefore be it resolved that the monor attention Board of Education hereby establishes the school district travel maximum for the 15 16 school year at the tenative sum of 8,422 and be a further resolve that the school business administrator shall track and record these costs to ensure that the maximum amount is not exceeded and now therefore let it be resolved that the superintendent of schools and the business administrator board secretary file the appropriate documents with the executive County Superintendent of

105Schools so move second I will now roll call roll call M armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr nosin yes Mr proso abstained so noted Mr Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president I'm very proud and pleased and I thank the board for the resources necessary to educate a growing number of students and uh the preliminary 1516 budget has passed thank you thank you Mr Gorski okay we now come to the public forum uh which I am sure that many of you are here for that um although Mr Gorski does a wonderful job of reading those resolutions but before I open the floor to comments uh there's a couple of things that I'd like to remind everyone about uh if you

106come to the microphone during this session you are to state your name and uh your address also any questions or comments uh it's actually comments that you make must pertain to items on the budget on the agenda on the agenda I'm sorry on the agenda uh there will be a second public session later this evening where you can bring up anything else that you might care to bring up your statement is not to exceed 3 minutes even if you are complimenting us you have to keep it to three minutes and all statements are to be directed to the board president you are not to address or question any individual members of the board nor members of the public and likewise I ask that individual board members are not to comment or respond during the public

107comment session your cooperation in adhering to these rules will provide for a smooth public forum uh because we have two topics that I'm sure some of you have come to speak on tonight uh I would ask that we do it in this order we will first hear comments on Mecca so if you want to make any comments on meca we will we will entertain those speakers first once we are done with that we will then hear any comments from people about redistricting once we have finished hearing your comments about redistricting if there's anything else on the agenda which you wish to speak to then you will be heard in the third group I would appreciate you please keep that in mind so at this time uh the floor is open to hear comments on Mecca

108Monroe employee Child Care Academy it's a proprietary fund segment uh that operates outside of the budget as I mentioned before okay since this gentleman was up earlier and I I shut him down I'm going to let him speak first thank you and I apologize for uh coming before my time um unfortunately I'm against Mech and I'll give the reasons for that I'm sorry could you give us your name and address please it's Sandy Eon I live at 110 Turnberry Drive in Monroe Township uh I'm against Mecca because the money should be used for other needs and it's unfortunate that as we know through the budget that money is tight as I understand it the mecca is a money losing if it was a private business it would go out of business uh there's 42 children

109if I'm correct and the break even as it was projected should have been 75 um it's not the purpose or the Mandate of the school to have this type of program we we should use the money for K through 12 why should the public subsidize some employees and not all citizens with children who want to work and need child care and that is unfortunate but you shouldn't have one one party subsidizing another Mecca or Mecca like programs are not the norm in other districts and certainly not the norm in private industry uh we need the rooms if rent was uh included or considered as part of uh the uh payments uh then it would make the loss even worse uh we don't need to uh take our taxes and unfairly U subsidize to unfairly compete

110with private uh industry there are Godard and other um organizations that have child care there are alternatives I commend the uh uh board from previously that this was an experiment it's good to experiment uh but unfortunately the program did not come close to meeting its Financial projections there are alternatives for those within the uh District who need uh child care and um we need to use our taxes for what is mandated in that is for K through 12 thank you thank you for your comment next good evening everyone my name is Sarah gter um I live at 51 canid Street in Burlington Township I'm a teacher in the district uh for 9 years now and I'm currently on maternity leave um with my six-month-old daughter my eldest attended Mecca last year and I hope you

111read our letters because our children have had a Priceless experience at Mecca um I know that the board took out aan and I feel that it would be unfortunate to cut the program before it really has the chance to financially flourish um I really hope that you read my letter specifically because I teach at mil Lake and I also use mecca for the township students um I teach first grade and I bring my class over to Mecca to collaborate with the younger students and the joy that I see in those children's eyes that read to younger children when they didn't think they could read in the beginning of the year is um invaluable um you heard from uh Mr gorsky's presentation that our teachers are providing topnotch New Jersey programs and we are actually the

112one of the lowest paid teacher districts in the state and we deserve top-notch care for our precious possessions as well our babies and I just want to leave you with um a little story that happened before I left my house tonight my daughter who attended Mecca uh almost four years old said Mommy if you ask them nicely not to close our school maybe they'll keep it open please don't close their school please thank you thank you for your comment next hello my name is Don Marie capus I live at 21 Avenue H in Monroe in reference to Mecca which District employees pay for I'd like to thank you all for reading our emails and listening to our suggestions for maintaining Mecca I understand that you have a very big decision to make tonight I know

113that ultimately you will make a decision that is best for the school district I'd like you to be mindful of a few things keeping the best Educators in our district because they can rely on the mecca staff many who are here today to care for their children rather than losing these Educators to other districts is what's best for our school district continuing to strengthen the relationship between the Board of Ed and the mtea by supporting a program our Union uses is what's best for our school district giving your District employees peace of mind that their own children are cared for and loved while they are inter caring for our Town's children day in and day out is what's best for our district our district has over 6,300 students who are essentially your children for whom

114you have helped to make decisions which are best for them additionally it's important to remember that Mecca is also a part of our district which means our own children who attend Mecca are also your children and now we're asking that you also do what's best for them don't take away their school their friendships their teachers and their learning environment Mecca parents and supporters of this program have gone to Great Lengths to reach out to you with Solutions and ideas pleading with you to please hear our voices and be the people who work with us to turn something already amazing into something that other districts will strive for let us be the model that other districts follow so they too can support their employees they too can keep the best Educators in place rather than spend

115money on Replacements and long-term subs for extended maternity leaves be the people who took the time to listen to parents and who chose to work with them because you value our school community and most importantly value our children all of our children please keep Mecca open thank you thank you for your comment next Maggie Fedora ad Jeremy Court good evening I'm standing here today as a parent a teacher and fellow mono Township Community member I'm here because I support Mecca and believe in the value of the program with the many supporters standing next to me and behind me and even more who signed our petition you can see that I'm not alone in this belief I recently came across an article which I shared with the board via inner office mail about the value of

116District run Child Care the article indicated that programs like Mecca are a growing Trend in United States Public Schools the research I've done indicates that Mecca may be one of the first of its kind in New Jersey but States like Texas and California have instituted such programs with positive results and success for some time now interestingly the article stated that while it's a business the overall goal of most districts are to have a break even Venture only after attending last month's board meeting Board of Education meeting and the finance committee meeting I quickly came to realize that our District's goal for Mecca was a little different as such on February 23rd 2015 I requested an interim in Revenue statements from Mike Gorski via Oprah based on the information supplied to me I with the help

117of other Mecha parents created a proposal propos deficit solution which you have all received via email and in office mail the proposal was created because we truly believe that with continued operational discipline and and improved stakeholder partnership to Mecca Mecca can be a viable long-term Enterprise we believe this as Mecca has shown continued growth 150% growth in 2013 15% growth in 2014 potential 12% growth in 2015 based on our survey results and further expansion in the F in future years as also based on our survey results in addition to the Positive Growth Mecca has experienced and is forecasted to experience we found that it that with the elimination of the of food service a nominal tuition increase and accurately dividing up General Supply expenses 80% for Mecca and 20% for the enrichment program both programs

118are able to show a profit $3,688 for Mecca alone or combined with the kindergarten enrichment program a profit of $ 29,548 combine this positive profit with the Positive enrollment forecast I've Speak of and profitability will continue to increase additionally Mecca parents are open to the idea of opening up available spaces in Mecca to the community of Monro Township teachers and Township employees would continue to have preference in priority and any additional classroom space can be opened up to the public a lottery system can be put in place if demands are greater than Supply with the limited number of child care options available in Monroe I can I can say with confidence that demand will definitely be greater than Supply this proposal was brought to you to show that Mecha is a viable program and by

119working together we can continue to keep it open in such a way that renders positive results for all stakeholders the board the teachers the staff and the children please support Mecca thank you for your comment is there another speaker hi suea 331 Karen Court Freehold I'm here to discuss two very important concerns regarding your decision to close Mecca first I worry about the message that you are sending to the community when you shut down a program that is positively valuable to so many people second if parents lose Mecca the cost of Monroe staff absences and paying for substitutes will greatly increase not to mention the loss of teacher time in the classroom there are currently 11 teachers that will lose their positions if Mecca does close to some of you that amount of people doesn't

120seem to be too large it seems small however the teachers that are employed at the center have a very reputable rapport with other staff and community members and that is huge 36% of Mecca's staff actually reside in Monroe and have children in our school system these teachers mean the world to me and other Mecha parents and it would be devastating to see them go I question the Integrity of a board who sends a message that letting go of such wonderful teachers is a wise decision these teachers will have to find employment elsewhere which is an added stressor that no one needs in this current economy that we now live in these teachers who are so valued to all mea parents will be forced to start over and lose very meaningful connections with children who are

121part of the Monroe Family the past boards have always tried to give back to the community and cutting staff positions really does not send that message as a member of the staff Mecca allows me to be close to my children in any emergency situations I can easily leave work during non-instructional time and be back to teach my students whereas driving somewhere farther than Mara would not allow me to return to work and in such instances a substitute teacher would be required and teacher instruction time would also be lost Mecca also has access to the nurse at mil lake so parents actually do not have to leave work if there is something minor that the nurse can deal with and this saves the board money by not needing a substitute and it also saves time spent

122looking for Teacher coverage such as a principal who may have to find coverage for that particular teacher and that wouldn't happen at any other daycare facility the cost of paying for substitutes will be a large additional budget component for the board and over the past months we have offered you many suggestions on ways to keep Mecca operational and functioning so please consider them all and keep Mecca open thank you thank you for your comment before we uh entertain any other speakers I would ask uh that uh if you're not adding something new that we haven't already heard that you uh reconsider making a statement uh we are aware of much of your concern of the value of the program to you because of the emails that you sent us and uh the last board meeting

123we also uh provided an opportunity for people to speak on that topic so we have quite a bit of input there so if you have something new to offer then certainly feel free to come to the microphone thank you Jason Walters 5 St James Street so you've received our emails you know in three minutes I have time to try to change your minds or or white might be the overcasting mentality here of what we're thinking about Mecca um but there's more to that there's gratitude and I don't think that's been brought up in our letters and our emails or anything we've sent yet and we've talked about numbers we've talked about benefits the love everything we've gotten out of this but at what point do we are we grateful for what's standing right here you

124know as a Monro resident I have three kids in this District in Mecca in the schools and I go every day happy our kids are in a fantastic school system because of our board and here's an opportunity in a time when contracts are negotiated benefits are taken away pensions are strike all these terrible things are happened to these wonderful people here we have an opportunity to give back to them and give them something they really truly need something that a couple years ago we thought of as a board was a great idea it needs a little bit more time you know this is our opportunity and your opportunity as a board and myself as a taxpayer to give back because this is a huge benefit for our teachers we see it every day I see

125it in my children I see it in these teachers who stay way longer hours because they have that ability to do it and that's a big part here don't forget the Gratitude make this decision with a little bit of GRA I hope that that we're thinking about that part and the value not the dollar value on that but the value that brings to our community and ultimately to our kids I think it's extremely important thank you thank you for that comment Nelson Chen for Ashley Court while I sympathize with with all of the uh uh teachers there and their children as a father of Two and a a household where there was dual income parents I fully sympathize with you you and I understand my wife and I struggled with those very issues with our

126two children commuting every day trying to figure out who's dropping the kids off where who's going to babysit these problems will never go away as long as there's dual income households the problem is that the center is not profitable in these days of counting pennies Mr Gorski had in his presentation that's literally what we're doing here counting pennies if it was a profitable situation and we were it was even breaking even I think it would be a great deal and I understand that and like I said I sympathize with you but the bottom line is it's costing the taxpayers money money that should be going towards the school to do what we're supposed to do educate K through high school and I'm sorry but that's the way I feel thank you for your comment I

127just told you can't do that I'm sorry you you you next speaker hi I'm Stacy Blum uh 3es Grove Court in E brunck I'm also a teacher at Barkley Brook School um I'll just summarize I know that you've heard a lot of things already I know that you've heard how much the children love this school um so I'll just State some of the things that maybe you haven't heard yet about some options since everyone seems very focused on the expenses um I know that we would be okay with a small tuition increase or to take away some of the lunch um options or snack options and add payment for those options or opening up the program to the community is another option I know that um at the finance meeting there was a lot of

128discussion of the ECE program and using the building building to expand that but the problem with this is there's no evidence that there would be enough interest in this program to fill the building and currently there's no waiting list for the ECE which means there's no guarantee of enrollment and if there ever was full day kindergarten and it comes to our district one day which might happen that would shut down that program also so I just want you to please consider some of those things and I love Mecca and its program thank you thank you for your comment Mr Tesla thank you IA Tesla 11 laa Drive um as a tax pair I fully support the mecca program I don't have any kids I don't have any teachers uh in my family uh I would

129like to uh I think our community is better off with the mecca program I think it's not always about the money uh it's about supporting our staff and our our staff's children and maybe a crazy idea I don't know if it's something that's been looked into or or thought I know we've been talk a lot of talk tonight about the Falcon Care Program maybe the mea program and the kindergarten enrichment and the Falcon care be all rolled into one entity and with two to $300,000 of profit forecast on that program alone the whole program at a whole would shortly show a profit I don't know the finances on that but maybe we can hold off on any kind of decision tonight maybe that's something to uh look into thank you thank you for your comment

130go ahead my name is Miriam Lavin 42 Narrows way I am not a Monroe employee or teacher however I do stand up here in support of our teachers AR Monro employees and Mecca I encourage the board to find a way to make it work the one thing that has not been mentioned is morale it as a full-time working mother I work full-time with two children Plus uh I know what it feels like to be able to feel confident that my children are cared for while I'm at work uh my particular employer um has gone to strides um in different times throughout my career to make sure that my family's been provided for so that I can go to work and these teachers and employees who are here if they are comfortable with their children being

131in a child care that works for them they are going to give back to the rest of our children and they're the teachers a few of them I see here have taught my kids I applaud you I stand with you please board find a way to make it work there suggestions have been put out and I encourage you to uh help out all of our our employees and teachers who are going to give back to the rest of the children in the community thank you thank you Joe calucho 20 Ashley Court Monro uh maybe you could clear up some things because I'm hearing a lot of people and I all I want to see is the right thing done um so correct me on some of these numbers somebody said there are 35 uh parents

132or 35 participants in it there 42 children uh somewhere somebody said the it was supposed to be 75 in the program I understand the program in June will be going on for three years um although some people have said it wasn't meant to be profitable but certainly we don't run businesses for losses either so how do you get it to be break even I I I just don't understand why we can't do something to maybe make this work but it's really comes down to to Dollars and cents I think in your presentation Mr gorsy you talked about the AP where at one point you were paying for the AP and the test and now you decided to put some of the cost of the test on the parents uh because the program is expanded why

133can't this be the same type of thing where maybe we have to increase the tuition if there's a tuition or or I think one uh young woman said something about uh taking away some of the things to reduce the cost so if this is a good program and I don't know much about it so again I'm I'm not here to say I'm I'm against it I just want to see why can't this be a break even item why can't some of the numbers you know you could do anything when it just boils down to money if it's about money how you just increase the expenses and increase the in Revenue and knocked down the c i i i don't know why that can't be done so okay thank you anyone else want to bring up

134something new on this topic do you know that 17 teachers are out on maternity leave this year that can send their children in the fall and I'm one of them 17 new students we pay money just like any any uh daycare center we pay a lot of M money and we deserve a a facility like this it's great 17 thank you against Manish Castle bway um I don't know much about Mecca um I initially I started thinking it should go away then I heard I thought thought it should stay my bottom line is can boat present ways what we heard recently is how you can make it work um obviously be care for our teachers obviously we don't want to lose money but if Falcon care can be clubbed with Mecca or if there is

135anything to increase Revenue decrease expenses can board present possibilities or options of how they can bring Mecca not to profit but break even does there is there anything that public can put in terms of request or what do we have to do is there a process where we can request the board to make those suggestions or presentations to the public thank you um that's a question that's I realize that but we don't answer the questions right now we'll be deliberating on this in a few minutes hi Dominique Walters 5 St James Street Monroe um just I don't know a point was missed um Mecca in combination with ECE last year did make a profit of $75,000 so combined with the ECE we did make a profit which is should be noted thank you thank you

136okay we thank you for those comments I'm now going to close this part of the session uh with uh from the discussion of Mecca and we will now move on to uh any members of the public who want to speak to the matter of uh redistricting of our elementary schools no nope I checked off there is any uh Orlando for Lis Lane there is any presentation about it there will be a presentation but uh when I checked on this earlier I I was informed that we should uh during this public session first have uh comments on the redistricting how can we comment on something that we don't know come on come on I I I do understand the dilemma I do do you have a comment so I I I have two comments I mean

137I think what gentleman what said he's absolutely right I think public your name and address please sanjie heg I live at 12 Wood Court in monra um so I mean there are a lot of people new here who probably don't know everything about redistricting compared to me I've been attending a lot of these redist related meetings and I have comments to make but I would like to hear what what is new in this meeting compared to Prior one and also last time when we had that meeting in the library there was a proposal made and the board went back and they were supposed to make some decisions so trying to see what came out of it and I have additional comments after I hear board what they have to say about the risting what's new

138about it I'll come back later all right thank you okay so let's see where we are hi uh it's Katherine Crowley and I live at 56 Bruce Meadows Drive I guess um I'm pretty certain that all of you have made your decision on redistricting and um I sat here and just listened to Mr Gorski say about how the enrollment numbers is a very conservative number and on the redistricting plan I saw that 87 kids are coming out of this community on the spot English Town Road there that's insane to say that 87 kids are going to come out of 400 somewhat units he said it he said that it was a conservative number so how could you guys continue this redistricting plan with such low numbers I I failed to understand it the first time

139and I still don't understand it today and and I just think it's really unfair in a couple of years when that District go when that uh Community goes up and 200 Kids come out of that place now all of a sudden mil Lake and Woodland is overcrowded and we're going to start moving kids again those numbers don't seem right and I just I fail to see how you guys can continue even considering the plan with such numbers further my kid is going to be one of the third third graders that are going to be affected by this splitting of uh the third grade at Barkley Brook and Brookside I would really really really like to hear from the board how you guys and the principal and the staff is going to make certain that if

140my kid is a third grader at Barkley Brook they're not going to be out of this different than the kids at Brookside because I think just like special needs children are advantaged when they're in a regular class you're taking that Independence or whatever you want to call it away from those three grades of three classes of third graders at at Barkley Brook and it's a concern for me cuz I don't think it's fair thank you sorry this sanjie again 12 wed would courot are we going to have the chance to come back and comment on what board has to say about redistricting yes during the second public session okay there is another public session this evening will that be right after no it will not hi Deborah Pella 15 Louise Lane I would like to

141see the presentation I thought the next form would be right after that but guessing it may be several hours later um I guess my first question would be considering the redistricting I was at Monday's meeting I understand there have been some changes since Monday's meeting um I'm only aware of the redistricting proposal that happened Monday questioning other things that I've been hearing from other residents had there been other things thought of that have maybe not been made here publicly about trying to find room in classrooms I've been keep hearing there aren't enough but I've heard of other solutions to possibly find room in these classrooms at Barkley brook or Brook side are there other are trailers completely off the table because losing the ones at Barkley Brook are there any thoughts to just moving new

142communities that are not yet even moved into these homes that we're accommodating where our students are ingrained in these classrooms and we're trying to accommodate 100 new homes where these students aren't even there yet and in these schools for 6 years 4 years and moving those children over a school to get new ones in that haven't even been to the new schools yet I just want to know I get Transportation logistical nightmares I just want to know is the only way to shift hundreds of students how many students are we talking about that are going to move what are the numbers how many families are really being affected maybe it'll all show up in the presentation but I'd like to know thank you thank you yes I'm sure if uh once you go through the

143presentation uh once we have the presentation the board will then be deliberating uh that uh proposal and you will hear that deliberation taking place here so in in many cases your questions will get uh answered maybe not to your satisfaction but at least they will be answered uh this sanjie the 12 wed wood courot again so I don't know when the next time I'll get an opportunity so I'll take a few minutes to talk about my concerns about school rist you raise your mic please talk the mic raise your microphone raic can hear you thank so uh I'm not new to the school redistricting I've been attending these meetings for over the last four months um and I it's very dear and close to me I moved to Monroe Township because and I chose the

144home I live in looking at the schools that my kids will be attending for the for the first few years of their life at least right so now I have been told that that the school I chose and the house I chose the schools to which they'll be going I'm going to be dropped out of that and my kids will be going to some other school and I know that the new school that they will be moving to uh based on what I know and based on the statistics are not on par with the current schools that they're going to so my my first concern is from that perspective my kids are going to lose significantly and over the last 4 months a lot of the parents have been talking about the social aspect of

145this which is we're going to take the kids from third grade and put them into some other school and they're going to lose their friends and they're going to redo the whole social life over and over again and I strongly feel that that opinion hasn't been heard at all I haven't seen any effort made to say I have heard this comment from people but we have made an effort to see how we can fix it I don't think that has happened at all and I know that the the board has spent money in time to understand how to take kids from one place one school to another so that there is equal number of kids across the board over the you know next few years but then with respect to you know seeing there was

146gentleman who made a in a suggestion you know last time around said why do you want to move kids from appleo into brockle Brook and then move the brle brook kids into the the new schools in mil Lake why can't you move the appleg into I'm sorry but sir but your time is up all right so know your time is up sir and you've had three opportunities to speak already okay Mr poy I have a point of order your your agenda says board discussion relative to the mecca program uh I have something to discuss about Mecca I haven't yet closed the public session though the public forum he was saying am I missing something it says here board discussion relative to Mecca and then the public session uh you you evidently have the old agenda

147it was revised this week I I understand your confusion because I only discovered the same problem let me know when I can discuss it okay please yes sir uh president po I just do have a question too I know our board our board policy states that we should have presentations prior to the uh public forum I don't know why we're doing this back but I I feel that the people who attended the committee meetings they may know what's going on but the majority here do not so how can they even ask us intelligent questions with regards to redistricting I I completely understand your comment Mr nostin and I did pursue that Avenue but I was told to abide with this agenda who aren't you the president I mean I mean I the board policy is

148pretty explicit on this U when the agenda which is collaboratively pred between Administration and the board president was completed it wanted to afford the public an opportunity to speak to the two main topics that we anticipate they're coming for tonight that's Mecca and the redistricting so your point is heard and there has been a building grounds Transportation committee meeting that has been made public regarding the redistricting there are slight revisions to the presentation tonight but nothing material and the reason again the public forum came first before the presentation is to afford the public to express their viewpoints before the board deliberates and takes a vote on the matter and then hears from you there is a second public forum if were you welcome to be heard again but that's why the agenda was constructed in

149this manner excuse me but the second public forum is already after the vote correct and the first public forum is before the vote to hear from the public but but before the presentation exactly it your your your comment is well taken Mr noin uh at this point though since we've already gotten into this we need to proceed do you have a comment on this redistricting yes I do um gazala Bora one Miko Drive Monro Township um I have three School of three boys in Barkley Brook Brookside schools and I am standing here because because of a plan that was proposed at the buildings and grounds committee meeting on Monday it's been there were slight revisions is what your words are Mr President but I think there are there are significant revisions um if my child

150was being redistricted to another school I would be far more concerned but I still think the reason I'm standing here is my son is going to go to third grade next year and um I have an older child who's gone to barle Brook and Brookside and I know I love both the schools but both the school serve different purposes so if third grade is going to be split into B Brook and Brookside um U Mr vow you will understand my concern as a parent while Bary Brook is a nurturing School Brookside is the three years that a child needs to get ready for middle school and high school so I don't understand how the Board of Ed is handling the different Administration strategies for the same grade in two different schools with two different admin

151two different principles and two different staff how is this going to be achieved and in which and how is it possible that it will not be fair on half the children who stay back in Walker Brook and maybe Fair on the ones who move to Brookside so I would urge the boat to please not do this not split third grade into B Brook and Brookside there has to be a better solution thank you Mr ventrello for tonado for Lis Lane excuse me one second be before we go forward just let you know that from the other evening to today there have been many revisions in this demographers report uh I just want to let you know though hold on one second though is that it's been addressed as far as you know the concern has

152been about the splitting of the grade three that is not taking place yes sir yes since we haven't seen the presentation and uh I believe that you're going to vote before before we know all the criteria based on uh which this redistricting has been made okay could you please at least explain what are the criterias based on what we basically have one area that has been reassigned and other area that has not been reassigned I have two boys that right now are 1.2 miles from school and they will go 7 miles away from another school so it's just a nonsense sense so could please somebody like give a presentation before you vote answer your question before you vote he unfair to vote before you give us the the criteria the general criteria and last thing

153hold on one second last thing there is any way that we can challenge this because who picked up the gentleman that uh did the demographic and everything else I I'm sorry I I couldn't understand everything you were saying but as soon as we finish this public session we will get into that presentation and then maybe many of your questions will be answered when do you when you go on Bo as as almost as soon as we finish with this public session this is ridiculous this is ridiculous if you would then what we talk about it there is nothing to talk about it you make a decision before yes that's go mam Lavin again 42 Nars way um 42 Nars way is considered a forestgate community um that my comments are based upon the knowledge that

154I know of which that uh forestate communities would be moved from Oak Tree Applegarth over to Barkley Brook Brook side so my comments are based upon that if that's not true great I could sit down um but based upon the fact that from what I've heard they are um I just want to make a comment that uh and I want somebody else echoed the same thing too when I purchased my home I made an intelligent ision based upon where I work in Newark and the schools Oak Tre Applegarth was in close proximity to my house the turnpike and the schools I made my decision based upon that and that is where my you know my home is right now my children have known Applegarth and Oak Tree their entire uh School careers my daughter is

155sitting here telling me I don't want to move out of oak tree and Applegarth she's an oak tree student right now I've been a tireless member of the oak tree and Applegarth PT ta I have developed relationships with the principles the school staff everything from the teachers to the custodians to the support staff to the par professionals um my my children I talked about this before with morale my children have school spirit and morale they want to stay where they've known for the last several years they shouldn't be forced to move because of other developments that are coming in I believe someone else said the same thing in terms of my kids have already started there let my kids finish there and other any other kids that have started there new homes that are coming

156in shouldn't be able to kick my child out when she's been going there for last several years and again when I moved to 42 Narrows way I was told my school district is Oak Tre Applegarth had I not had I known that I had to go to to all the way down to Buckaloo wouldn't have bought in 42 Nars way nor would I probably have bought in Monroe so this is affecting a choice that I made many years ago which was based upon the information that the township gave to me when I purchased my and I'm not making this without any prior knowledge my oldest daughter did go to uh to um basket Barkley Brook and it was a commute I'm sorry about your time I thinket that all right but I'll abide by that

157Mr may I have a point of order I would to the public session no to suspend the public I don't know if it's possible no disrespect ECT to I'm I'm I'm going to make a motion to suspend the public portion until after the presentation with no disrespect to the agenda and the way it's done but I think with respect to the public and we can vote on it if it doesn't pass and no disrespect to you Mr Po I honestly think that having been in that seat for many years that the public should be fully informed before what is your motion M armeno that we suspend the public session and reopen it after the demonstr after the demonstration I second okay so then can I I'm sorry right now there's a motion on the floor

158we have to address it sorry can't please everybody okay is there uh there's a motion on the floor that we suspend the public session okay so that we can proceed to the presentation is that correct Miss armeno yes it is okay I'll second that it's been seconded seconded okay is there any any discussion from the board on that on that motion no no discussion yeah yes I just want to you know reiterate my concerns that uh I I take public input very seriously I've been on the other side of the mic for a long time and I think that in order for the the board uh for the public to speak intelligently they absolutely have to see this presentation and it's not going to impact us at all yes Mr gski roll call vote please

159M armeno yes Mr Braverman Mr bra no Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mr colano yes Mr noste yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Bo president public form suspended until after the presentation okay at this time I'm going to call on our interim superintendent Mr vent trillo who will introduce our next presenter minut I know but meca is next on the agenda this evening we will have a presentation by Dr Ross habber of Ross Haber and Associates on District en Roman projection facility utilization and redistricting now that presentation will be in PowerPoint a copy of which will be posted on a District web page tomorrow excuse me Mr V yes Mr Po can we take at this time a 10-minute recess second okay there is a motion that

160we 10 Rec convenience break it's been seconded all in favor I I opposed Ione one opposed okay extensions okay then we're going to take a 10-minute recess thank you that's okay that's okay by me I mine how are we going do this okay let's try this again Mr vento will you please introduce our presenter I'll continue where I left off as recommended by the aded hoc committee on facilities and growth the board engaged the services of Dr Joseph Richardson of whiteall Associates to prepare a demographers report this report provides long range projections for student growth using cohort survival methodology as required by the New Jersey Department of Education this report also provides data on projected housing growth and its impact on student population Dr Haber who is also a demographer uh was contracted to prepare

161a redistricting study utilizing this demographic and Housing Development data over the past month while updated housing data was being received from the township planning department Dr Haber met twice with the buildings and grounds Transportation committee the committee also also received a recommendation from the principes and District administration to undertake redistricting that would help to effectively rebalance elemente class sizes tonight's presentation represents the final recommendation various working models were reviewed some which led to public questions and confusion we ask that you disregard any previous reports and focus on tonight's proposal ready okay so now let me just begin to add to the confusion um first of all I just want to just give you some I have a few remarks before I start my presentation um I I am three things that are that that relate

162to what is going on in this District the first is I am a demographer meaning I do enrollment projections for school districts I've done them throughout the state of New Jersey and basically all over the United States and I've got 20 years experience I'm a facilities analyst meaning that I can go into school buildings and make some determinations in terms of class sizes classroom needs and program needs but I am primarily an educator I spent 22 years as as a classroom teacher and as a high school principal here in the state a teacher in New York and a high school principal here in the state of New Jersey so my perspective comes from not only the statistical and the facility notion but it comes from the education notion and I I try to make a

163point of getting to know uh the Personnel in the districts that I work with and getting into the school building and I there was a remark made a little earlier tonight and I just want to make a statement I've been in all of the schools in this district and they are amongst the finest schools in this state and in this country I every element I would send my child and my grandchildren to Barkley Brook Brookside mil Lake Woodland Oak tree apple gooth in a nanc so uh if anybody here is being switched schools you may have a lot of reasons for not wanting it done but not one of them is the educational opportunities afforded to your children and I think that's really important okay second thing I want to take a couple of things

164off the table is uh as M vill said um there after Monday's meeting information got out into the community and some some of that information caused a little bit of AA and I want to put that AA to bed so to speak at least a little bit before we get into the real aggravation uh the first is Barkley Brook Brookside is not going to have a split third grade that is not going to happen we met with after I've done about 15 iterations on this redistricting most of them based upon the program programs and classroom distri distribution as they exist uh didn't work without splitting Barkley Brook and Brookside but I took one more shot and I I reloaded all of the kids back into Barkley Brook Brookside in third grade on Wednesday I met

165with principles and there were a number of little tweaks that could be done a little bit of tweaking to the redistricting model that was presented Monday night and it ended the it it it ended the need to split bark the brook brookite so that's off the table uh the second thing that was a little bit confusing was a I had a bad number um uh when I when I referred to some of the tax maps and I had mislocated uh uh cha man bonro chase a little bit east of where it should be and people thought that meant they were being redistricted out of oak tree apple goth not going to happen um as you saw from the maps that are laying around Monro Chase is put back in its proper place and that's not

166an issue they will not be redistricted because they just can look out the window and see oak tree Applegarth okay third thing the purpose of the purpose of my task was to allow the board to do long range planning we've heard from Mr gorsky's presentation and we've heard from the superintendent's presentation and from the board members uh that this district has experienced incredible growth over the next 10 years and is going to continue to experience incredible growth um if I can just uh and and so when I present the numbers and the housing units and all those things understand where they're going and what they're going what they're going to cause but also keep in mind that we don't want to have this meeting as an annual meeting okay we don't want to meet annually

167and have the same discussion we want whatever plan comes out of this to last for as long a time is reasonable and I believe from what I believe from what I've done and what I've worked with the principes and what I've worked with um Mr G uh Mr T and Mr Gorski and superintendent I think we have a solution that will go beyond five seven even as far as eight years uh for the elementary schools it's important to do that because again unless something unforeseen happens and no one's a magician I really believe that uh we can make this redistricting model work for a long period of time will it cause some pain nobody wants to move and I understand that but here's the problem the district is like and and again I want to

168stress that all of the new housing is not going to come in in 5 years but you've got to compact the plan into something that gives you an ability to make a long range plan um and if you kind of see the district is a bit of a seesaw with oak tree and appleg being over here and Barkley Brook Brookside being the fulm and mil lake or Woodland being the other side of the Seesaw the Tilt is is going this way enrollment is increasing at this end of the Seesaw significantly it's declining at this end of the Seesaw space is opening up in these areas so logic and rationale says we move we have to move kids this way we have to move kids out of Oak out of oak tree Applegarth into Barkley Brook

169Brookside and kids out of Barkley Brook Brookside into Mid Lake Woodland that's truly that's truly the only way this can go uh and we're not talk talking about building a school now we're talking about doing this in a way that meets the needs of this community so again last thing before I do the the the presentation there are several incontrovertible issues things that really are they're just not convertible because they're true the first is that they're going as of right now as of March 2015 and this comes from the municipal government it comes from the Planning and Zoning Board uh the the Town manager agrees with it of course the uh supervisor of of of Planning and Zoning agrees with it that in the future there are going to be 2,323 non-ag restricted housing units

170coming into this District when they come in it's overtime no one can really predict that but the fact is those are the numbers those are those are straight from planning board and they're as of March 2015 over time this number of unit is going to introduce more than 1,800 new students into this District now this is modified and again over time that's going to happen this is modified a little bit because there's a natural attrition in the school district you've got X number of seniors graduating X number of kindergarten students coming in and that causes an attrition so those 1,800 new children over the years will net out at more than a th000 which is going to be significant to this District um the plan the uh the basic idea here is to give the

171board the ability to come up and create a plan that's going to last for a long period of time so again we're not having these meetings every two or three years they can go on maybe six or seven years um and finally that the Central and building administrators are in support of the report that I'm bringing to you tonight so those are the kind of um incontrovertible issues and now I'd like to go on with the actual report okay the purpose of the study the purpose of the study is to provide the Monro Township Board of Education with data and information to help with long range planning for the entire School District in the period affecting this study monal Township will see an increase in the number of non-ag restricted housing units as of March

1722015 there are 2,323 new housing units which have been or will be approved for construction it cannot be determined with any degree of accuracy when these units will be occupied however we must plan effectively for this eventuality and address a current and worsening imbalance with Elementary class sizes the majority of these units and that's all bit one will be constructed in the part of the community which is currently zoned for the oak tree and Applegarth schools this study is based upon the following assumptions one that the new housing units will be completed over time and need to be considered in the long- range planning of the the board two the current school conf zone configurations will allocate most of the projected new students be assigned to Oak Tre Applegarth those schools simply do not have

173the space to accommodate these added students and three the high school and middle school will be impacted by these new students as these children pass through the middle school and the high school and these two schools do not have the capacity to accommodate these students okay these are the two basic recommendations of this entire study one the realignment of the current attendance zones to more evenly balanced class sizes at the elementary schools and two moving third grade from Woodland into mil Lake um Woodland has the room mil Lake doesn't although there's empty space in both classrooms but the principles agree that this solution uh is a good one okay okay guiding principles of the study okay balancing class sizes in all the K5 schools to ensure that eventually there'll be little variance in class slides

174throughout the district not going to happen overnight but over the period of time of this study enrollments will balance across all six of of the uh of the schools and B keeping bus rides as short as reasonably possible for students in the real line attended zones some students might have a longer bus ride but they're not going to be there's there's not a bus ride that will exceed the maximum lab by this board of education and one other guiding principle that I didn't put here but it's to keep St to keep neighborhoods intact in other words I don't believe in the study any developments was split up uh any neighborhoods were split up kids we didn't CH I didn't cherry pick children saying okay I can take 10 from here and three from here and

175five from there they were done in large clusters so that kids were moving at least with a majority of kids that they know and I think that that's important uh these uh by the way the oh this this is a just an outline map the red outlines indicate the current number the current number I'm sorry the current attendance zones for each of the schools the top one that's Middle lake Woodland this is Barkley Brook Brookside and this is Oak Tree Applegarth that's the current attendance zones what you're looking at are the location of all of the new housing units and you can see with the exception of JSM celebrations U which by the way confuse the heck out of me I took months looking for something called Mount Mills thank you very much uh that

176was development people said have it's actually JSM uh celebrations uh that's the that's the only development that is not in the current uh Barkley Brook U I'm sorry o oak tree appleo the tenant Zone um you'll see something called sarlo sarlo sarlo are conversions for maor restricted to non-ag restricted developments the numbers that you're seeing on here are numbers of non-ag restricted units those are not numbers of children those are numbers of non-age restricted units um I understand that this present ation is going to be on the district website there's going to be a CO there's going to be another um set of documents um maps maps that are going to be PDFs which are clearer than these so you'll be able to look at the presentation and toggle over to the PDFs which you'll

177be able to zoom in on and get a much clearer picture they'll be more like the maps that you see around the room tonight okay impact of new developments okay a total of 2323 new n age restricted housing units will be built in the township this number of units and the subsequent student yields are for the purpose of long range planning no timeline can really be set for the completion of these new structures over time these housing units will yield a total of 1,866 units during the 5-year projection period there'll be a natural attrition of about 831 students uh which is 2,632 graduating seniors minus 1,8 1 entering kindergarten students that equals 831 so the net student growth based upon the new housing units is estimated to be 1,035 okay okay this next table I

178want to take a few minutes or this next page I want to take a few minutes to explain because to some to some of you it's going to be a little counterintuitive so let me go let me go through it I'll explain what the data means and where it comes from the first column indicates the name of the development so and the first the first few the first rows are single family homes okay so the names of the developments single family homes if you and these are to be built homes that are remaining to be built some of these developments may already be in play but these are the houses that still need to be built and it's a total of 1,464 single family units okay now to give you an idea of why you

179can't say these are all going to come in in a five year period while it'll be more time this total agreement with the municipal government and with the Planning and Zoning Board that JSM Marketplace is going to happen uh which is 618 units uh it's more than that but 115 or 120 are age restricted so it's 618 non-age restricted units um now but site development has to take place EPA testing has to take place so it may it might not see shovel in the ground for 3 four or 5 years but again it's going to happen and you have to plan for it okay the next column over if you look at the top highlight if you look at the highlighted um just got to get something here if you look at the highlighted lines

180that tells you what the student yield is per the type of unit what I'm holding in my hand is the Bible okay it not the Holy Bible it's the Bible as per rutus University okay this is the study that rutus does every 6 years which goes through every type of housing unit in every Community throughout the state of New Jersey and based upon that they assign a yield number to each each individual home like you may say you may look at me and say 200 2,323 units how could it only yield 1,866 children well the fact is because not every home is occupied by school AG children there are some homes that don't have school-aged children some homes that have kids have left the system some homes that send kids to private and prial schools

181So based upon and and the only the only way to really determine this aside from just doing a sentence of every house in the district which is I've done just an impossible job is to use the data so according to the rutu study and it's a study virtually every demographer in the state uses and and what the state requires if we're going to do additions to an a longrange facility plan um enrollment projection okay for elementary schools it's 70 6 now it's a little higher for um uh for affordable housing but there is no but affordable housing doesn't there's no affordable housing here it's all been taken care of with the with whatever Arrangement is made to do that okay so every Elementary every um single family house yields 706 Elementary School students so that

182means that over the period of time when this construction takes place there'll be 1,034 new Elementary School students in roduced into the system okay for Middle School it's. 224 and for high school it's. 164 meaning that we'll see 328 middle school students and 240 high school students from single family homes townhouse and condos numbers are lower and I have to also add that that there are different categories for different size houses two bedroom houses three bedroom houses well there hasn't been a house built in this community that isn't four and five bedrooms so I've used the maximum I've used all Maximum numbers same thing with the town houses and condos so in the townhouse and condo the yield and these are the these are the ones that are Avail and by the way I'm sorry

183the where it says current Zone that's incorrect that should say redistricted zone I'll change that those are the schools that will pick up the um developments you can see with the redistricting the only School aside from Applegarth um and oak tree that's going to pick up uh pick up from these developments is um is Mid Lake and and and Woodland okay so from these developments will be there's 859 of them coming in 164 elementary school kids with the Migra with the um yield ratio 0191 um 60 I think that's 60 uh middle school kids with a ratio of 07 and 40 high school kids with a ratio of 0.47 now on the bottom of the screen I show you the summary the summary is if you take the total of uh of the total it's

1841866 kids coming in 2,632 graduating seniors 1,81 um entering kindergartens and the net is 835 students so that's the plan that needs to take place this next map that I'm showing you this map has with it the red outlines indicate the red outlines indicate um the current School boundaries the solid colors indicate the the propos osed redistricted boundaries and just to kind of let you know where everything is this this this area would be moved from would be moved from um oak tree Applegarth to Barkley Brook Brookside this area would be moved from Oak Tree appleo to Barkley Brook BR Brookside this area in purple would be moved from Barkley Brook Brookside to M Lake Woodland so in in Ence what we're looking at is that oak tree apple goth becomes sending Schools they're not

185receiving any new students in this redistricting is sending students out Barkley Brook Brookside becomes a receiving school and ascending school it's the center of the fulm and finally Mid Lake Woodland becomes only a receiving school now again population it's important to not and you'll see as we go through this a little more in this presentation enrollment is decre declining in Barkley Brook Brookside enrollment is declining in Mid Lake Woodland in fact Mid Lake Woodland does have open classrooms okay and enrollment is increasing substantially in oak tree apple gooth okay you you know so so that's why the movement moves in this direction to balance the enrollments it's the lar school so again let me just review and you you know you'll see it again current oak tree appleo boundary we would move this section in

186into Barkley Brook Brookside this section into Barkley Brook Brookside we move this section out of Barkley Brook Brookside including JSM celebrations as the only development we would move that into Mid Lake Woodland okay and that would begin to balance out the enrollments over time so that that would that's that's how that is working in terms of the that's that's the redistricting model okay okay now let's take a look at let's take a look at the the hist uh the enrollment history as you can see in 20089 there were a total of 5,380 students in this District that number jumped to 6,361 and that's a huge huge increase and keep in mind that the recession was in the middle of that so in spite of the recession this district has absolutely grown at an incredible rate

187now if we go to the if we go to the bottom and we include the new housing units this district will go up to 7,396 units probably Beyond 2019 and 20 but that is the Planning number that the district needs to use in terms of creating classroom space on the bottom and as you see on the left you see the annual growth rate and that's where the the the 1035 net comes in if you go across the bottom um there are two um there are two numbers or there two U tables on the bottom okay the first is the cohort project ection what the cohort projection is that's the Baseline in enroll projection it's what you do to create an enoll projection based upon student enrollment history and not counting any new developments or any

188new housing as you could see that if there were no developments and no new housing your District would come to about 6700 students manageable with the new housing when you add all of that in we're talking about 7,396 students so we're looking at an increase from the current opening of 6361 to what would have been 6700 which is kind of in line with what's happened in the past to almost 7,400 kids that's based upon the added the added new housing and these graphs I'm just going to show you a series of graphs and again these are going to be online tomorrow these show you the Steep the trend lines actually of where you know of where this enrollment is going this is the he this is the entire district with new housing these are the

189K5 enrollments with new housing uh k235 but okay you get the idea this is the middle school with new housing and the middle school is already um tremendously overcrowded I believe there's going to be some new construction this summer to relieve a little bit of it and the high school and the high school when it hits about here goes over capacity and goes all the way up to 2600 students so this growth not only impacts the elementary schools it impacts the middle school and the high school but of course there's no redistricting because they're District they're districtwide schools now just again this is a closeup of of of the changes uh this is the Barkley Brook the S line is the Barkley Brook boundary this is the movement to Oak Tre Applegarth this is the

190movement uh this I'm from Oak Tree Applegarth and this is from Oak Tree Applegarth so the blue is the new is the new uh attendance zone for or the recommended redistricted attendance zone for Barkley Brook Brookside now let's take a look at what's happening at Barkley Brook Brookside this is going to be a little tricky to understand so I'll try do my best to explain it if you take a look at the enrollment K5 let's just take K5 for a moment um enrollment it went from 886 to 859 that was the total that's the total number number of of students in that in that uh that that existed that went to K5 Barkley Brook Brookside the 790 is not a reflection of that what this the 790 does not equate to the current enrollment what

191I needed to do is I needed to take the new attendance Zone take the kids living in that attendance Zone and create a number so I could create a new projection for that particular school okay so in other words that 790 repres present that if we redistricted today there would be 790 K5 students living in Barkley Brook Brookside is am I clear on that do you follow what I said because I I don't want people walk away say we don't have 790 kids in those two schools we have more you do but this is based upon the redistricted boundaries I needed to do a projection to see if the redistricted boundaries would hold up in doing that you take a look you'll see that the Barkley Brook Brookside enrollment with three District boundaries is showing

192a degree is showing a decline it's not a significant decline but it's enough of a decline to show that there's not going that growth is stopping that area unless of course some new development comes in but I think that area is beginning to get a bit built out and I'm not including JSM celebrations in the Brockley Brook Brookside area so overall barley Brook enrollment is declining and could handle take with with the new attendance Zone and can handle students the the students students that are coming in from Applegarth what this table is and I know it's impossible for you to see okay what this table is is the table that lays out the number of classrooms needed in the buildings for each of the next five years based upon this projection based upon the redistricted

193zones the average class size and any rooms that might be left over for other kinds of programs with this redistricting boundary Barkley Brook Brookside Barkley Brook and Brookside have room to grow have room for either class size reduction or to accept new students or to take on districtwide programs if need be so with this redistricted boundary and keep in mind also that Barkley Brook lost six Portables so those are gone so we're only basing this on 21 classrooms we worked we worked with the principles of both schools um and uh they they agree they're in agreement with this there supportive of this um and there's no cut in any programs there's no music on a cart there's no art on a cart all of the programs that exist in the building stay intact in this

194redistricting plan okay now Mid Lake Woodland okay the the the S the the red outline that's the current attendant Zone the entire purple or Violet whatever that color is uh is the projected the projected redistricted Zone mil for mil Lake Woodland again like with Barkley Brook Brookside I took um I took all of the students that live inside the new Zone and created and it came out to 1776 K5 students so then I projected off that number now everybody I think is aware that that that's the area where there's the most declined enrollment and even with the redistricted boundaries you'll see there were 1,76 it goes to 1,1 and it declines all the way to 826 so what you're looking at is you're looking at with the new redistricted boundaries projected decline in enrollment in

195Barkley Brook Brookside and a projected decline enrollment in Mid Lake Woodland in those two schools so and as those enrollments decline classrooms open up and if we look if we look at the if we look at this chart again this is going to be online tomorrow so you can do a little more analysis at home um the uh the this show again the number of classrooms being used and the only and everything going forward the the enrollment diminishes it frees up more classroom space for either other district-wide programs or for class size reduction but if you but if you look the one issue that may occur for one year and according to the principle it probably won't happen based upon kindergarten registration they may have to put music on a cart in this school for

196one year but I think we said that was pretty unlikely correct yeah okay that was a yes in case you didn't hear it um but but after that the numbers of Cl the classroom space increases almost geometrically okay and again this is within the redistricted boundaries okay and again giving you an idea that that there's room for growth in Barkley Brook and Brookside now we get to Oak Tree Applegarth okay oak tree Applegarth now becomes the green area it's here around like this and up to here so Barkley Brook Brookside gives up two two Spa two two areas to um to Barkley Brook Brookside and let's look at the enrollment again that 8810 represents the total number of K5 students that live within the redistricted boundary I needed to project off that that particular number

197so if we take a look at that that 810 becomes 990 that 990 becomes 1042 1042 to 1077 all the way up to 11:33 so we're talking substantially over 300 new Elementary School students based upon the new housing construction coming into oak tree appleg goth but based upon the new redistricted boundary we went through this and with the possible exception of the out years 2 of 2018 and 19 okay there's enough classroom space between the two schools and there's possibilities the only school that may run short of classrooms in 20189 is oak tree is oak tree but there's enough space in Applegarth in that year to move a program over there if they have to to pick up the classroom space so again the principles do support that this is all doable they've looked at

198these charts they've gone through them with me they've looked at the room counts we've reviewed the floor plans with Jerry tag we've done the counts over and over again we're absolutely certain about these numbers okay and again based upon we know is coming into the district and again just um and so here's the big question okay the one okay how many students will have to be moved as a result of this okay so from the total oak tree the total oak tree appleo to Barkley Brook is 202 students we we're getting out of oak tree Barkley Brook from Barkley Brook Brookside to Mid Lake we're moving a total of 259 students again it's based upon current population in the new redistricted boundaries that is a total student movement of 461 based upon a an elementary

199student an elementary enrollment K5 of 2359 that's 19.5% or one out of it's it's almost 20% of the elementary school students are moved in this scenario okay uh now if you're looking at this table what this table is this 1 through five is really your current K4 okay in other words I was looking at this for September 2015 so grades 1 2 3 4 5 are really currently kindergarten 1 2 third and fourth because next year's kindergarten students will not be moved they're going to go to the school in which they're registered and the fifth graders will be off and into the into the middle school okay so that's why so that's where that's why that says 1 2 3 4 5 although it's actually currently K through four and finally final comments okay the

200residential housing uh information is based upon the latest data as of this month as of a week ago actually provided to me by the township and through the municipal planning board uh that data is available to you I believe it's even online you can look at all of the developments all of the sites the section block and lot numbers the number of units those designated for residential for non-agri red those so that information public information it's available I'm fairly certain it's online if not you can request it from the Planning and Zoning Board the housing yield factors are based upon the ruer Center for Urban studies and statistics uh if you're interested in looking at that it's online you just key in who lives in New Jersey and if you just key in the study

201will come up I warn you the studies about 700 pages I think there is an executive summary for it but it is broken down by community it is broken down by by it's broken down by County it's broken down by community so you can you can kind of scroll through till you find Monro Township to get to see what the yields are like and also it gives you an in-depth discussion if you're interested in how how this study is done um you'll see it's a very complex very complicated study as I said I I brought a copy with me um it's hardly bedtime reading okay and finally the class size is shown post redistricting for all K5 schools are in the 20 range 23 22 23 uh this could increase if you know if down

202the road new construction comes in that we're not aware of we can only deal with what is certified to be happening from the municipality which the study does and with that I finished my presentation and we're ready to address questions I guess I don't know what the protocol is yes yes yes we will uh we will now reopen the public session for questions on this redistricting plan and then the board will have an opportunity to also ask questions on that is it possible to turn this down and turn the house lights on it's really kind of interrogation are there any members of the public who wish to ask questions based on this presentation thank you name and address uh goam from 3o Drive um I have a comment about about uh housing yield Factor um

203so without going through 700 pages of RG study can you speak into the microphone oh sure um without going through 700 pages of rgas study my educated guest based on new construction that occurred in Monro for Last 5 Years uh for single family houses uh I would say the yield is around 1.5 and not7 so so um like is there any other eeld study that was included if I I I didn't understand everything you said but let me try and answer the question okay okay we have confirmed 2323 housing units nobody can believe that you can put up 2323 housing units in a 5year period okay can happen Okay let me finish okay let me finish my thought the reason it can happen is because you need site plans you need EPA approval you need

204a lot of things I understand I know I know all the procedure my question actually was little different what I'm saying I'm questioning 79 ill that was assumed okay the question okay the what I'm over time that will be the number of students it may not be in 5 years but the point is the point it may be in seven years it may be in eight years but the point is that we want to make the plan now to meet the need we don't want to come back here every two or three years and make a shift you know the big the big development the 618 that may be down the road but a lot of the 40 50 and 60s are going to come in it's they're going to jam and that's going to

205happen within 5 years and they're going to jam up oak tree Applegarth so we want to make a long range plan that long range plan so that the next time that we meet you'll be meeting my successor because I'll be having moas in Cuba so so but that but that's but that's really it's important that the board you know we talk I think someone in the audience pointed out that 5 years ago a plan should have been made and three years ago when I did this someone said seven years ago now is the time for the board to take action no no I agree I think I command you know this is a this is great first step but what I'm saying is I think we are underestimating the need of schools and class size

206or classes that will be needed based on new housing that is being proposed that's what I'm saying so the yield that we are talking 79 I think that is underestimated it should be lot more than 79 okay I I'm not sure what you want me to answer no but then oh it's a statement okay no no but so so even if you have rest of the numbers exit if the the main number which is the uh yield the housing yield if that number is not uh convincing okay then how can you project the total again are you referring to the yield ratio yeah 7 the okay 70 okay again again we anybody who's in business here has a business or is in education whatever runs statistics and you know statistics are not what you eyeball

207you can be on your block and you could say I know that every house people moving with seven kids I understand I I I work I I do big data so I know everything about what you're saying the only parameter does does the RGA study break down by demographics and new construction does it do that this AG again I'm having a little trouble understanding you but I think what I'm saying here is this is what you need to rely on when you're doing the counts okay because there's really no other way to do it but does the RKA studies has a breakdown or yield based on new construction new single family I'm you know I I again can you you slow down because I I truly I'm not I'm not sure what you're asking me

208basically I'm I'm saying we should reconsider the housing ELD Factor yes that's correct what yes um hi Manish balchandani 30 Castle very simple question I'm trying to simp into the microphone I'm trying to simplify what he was trying to question and I have the same concern you say the eel factor is 70 correct 76 Elementary 76 right does that your bible say that it is based on the specific age group of the people that are moving in so 7 6 does it take into account which I'm sure you can find out maybe through public records that most new construction have age groups in the range of mid 20 or late 20s to late 30s which means most have more than one kids and that is you can I mean you don't have to go for

209the eyeballing you can probably there are public records you can find out if you tell us that yes 7 yield is based on that demography of the age group we are fine the point Our concern is you underestimate I okay okay the 706 is based upon ruus studying Monroe Township three and four bedroom home uh four and five bedroom homes in Monroe Township specifically in this community look look listen do you want me to come here and say that every home is two kids I can't do that I got to do it based upon what the study tells greatly and so I think you're just getting the comments from the general public that and this is for the board to that you might want to look into that further I'm not saying to reject the

210plan I'm not suggesting anything of that sort but this is the general concern and I'm taking the gentleman's point it is possible based on what we are hearing that if you take the yield of 7 and what we are seeing or our observation is you may have to come back in 3 4 years and say hey we may have to again go through redistricting because we underestimated 4 years ago that's my yes go ahead yes I mean please into the microphone it's very difficult to hear up here sorry about that name address Orlando for Lis Lane second time that I said do you understand me now okay good all right long-term projection you start your speech with a long-term projection okay and then I'm still not hearing I'm sorry you start your speech with with

211long-term projection right when you say that all your study is meant from now to 2020 and later okay then you introduce this Factor 0.76 okay on housing that you consider four or five bedrooms which is way overestimated okay now you are a demographic you are not a statistician right so have you used any ation on your statistics I don't know you didn't you went straight with a linear analysis that a kids of third grade can do it which doesn't work in this community because also as a structural engineer in construction I know that you cannot build that number of a housing in this short period of time I think I therefore let me finish therefore okay why rushing and putting a vote tonight on on something that is way over conservative and doesn't work your

212model is not working and I challenge your model and if I have any of the parents that want to help okay I will hire myself somebody else to prove you wrong okay let me make it very clear I don't I said very clearly at the outset that 2323 units will not be built in 5 years don't do it right now let's I I would app appreciate sir if you would offer me the same courtesy I offered you okay okay thank you okay what I have said clearly is that the Board needs to do long range planning very early in the discussions I had with the board and as recently as Monday it was said to me how long out can we plan for and I said you need to know what well you know I'll

213tell you what I'll tell you what I'm not going to argue with you here's the deal you can get the statistics from the township you can get the enrollment from the school district okay and do a study I mean you know I've go I follow protocols from the state education department I also have been doing this for 25 years in about 250 school districts okay I've been rehired by every school district so I'm not defending myself I'm just saying that what you see anecdotally is not what is produced statistically okay that's okay next I'm sorry next question we respect next speaker please uh Chrissy scurby 8 seminal Court um I was there on Monday night I listened to the full presentation um I know at the end those numbers were guaranteed to us um tonight

214we come back and there's a whole new set of numbers new set of maps and that's being guaranteed to us I'm very concerned because when I look at these maps on Monday night there was a large section that's now in blue that was going to be going to Barkley Brook Brook side that is now being put back into oak tree Applegarth there's big development in there with a lot of students that's now going back to Oak Tree where on Monday it was going to Barkley Brook Brookside there's the forestgate development that are 13 to 15 years old most of those students are phasing out of elementary school so you're moving basically only that development and a small area up Federal Road that does not have any large development with a lot of elementary school children

215going to Oak Tree Applegarth you're really not taking a large portion out of oak tree and Applegarth to make a difference and if you look at all of that new construction that's all getting put into oak tree Applegarth we agre we we see in the um agenda there were 17 new students that came into oak tree from February to March it's a real concern but moving out a development that's already phasing out of elementary school isn't going to fix the overcrowding in oak tree you need to do something with some of that new construction because as those houses are going up no not even as the houses are going up as people are signing contracts they are coming into our school they're not even living in Colts run right now but they're coming to our

216school because they have a contract that's the real issue here and I'm not saying that people buying new construction shouldn't go to Oak Tree but what I'm saying is thank you miss gerby your time is up you have to deal with the new construction coming in not the phasing out devel I'm I'm fairly I'm fairly certain that my pres I'm fairly certain that my presentation addressed the construction in oak tree apple and by the way that little area that you just talked about that redistricted area that's only that's 40 That's 40 children not you know that the the the southeast area that's 40 children and by doing that by moving that by moving up that boundary we were able to create the space in Barkley Brook Brookside so that we didn't have to split the

217third grade and it still didn't impact appleg gooth Oak Tree in any great measure remember again that the board has to face whenever it is this huge number of kids coming in they need to plan for it now it's not it's not something you can't you can't do a peace meal we can't come back every year and take a little piece and move it it should be done now for the longterm term and then move on to do other things that need to be done yes ma'am um it's Katherine Crowley at 56 Bruce madow So based on what you have said what the board is basically telling us is that you are not at all putting forward a referendum to build a new a new elementary school for this town at all this is the

218plan going forward the only referendums that we're talking about is possibly expanding the high school and the middle school is that correct no well then if that's the case then this you didn't let me finish okay go ahead I'm sorry this plan is simply to deal with the overcrowding that we presently have in oak tree Applegarth and it is it is redistricting just to take care of that overcrowding that is anticipated if we don't do something within these next the span of the next five years it's a separate issue in terms of whether or not we need to build a new school and What that particular new school would look like it might be an elementary school it might be some other kind of school but no this does not deal with that issue this

219simply deals with how do we find space for every child to have a seat so that the classrooms are not overcrowded but yet you're clearly indicating that 2,000 students are not coming into the district for possibly seven years so why are we sitting here moving kids back and forth if you really will put up a referendum I'm I guess I'm confused confused about that I mean if in 2 years you decide you're going to put up a referendum and we get a school built then this whole thing gets it's garbage it's it's got to be totally redone I guess what I'm asking now is can the board tell us that no referendum for a new school is off the off the charts it's just not even discussable it it it does not it's not being

220discussed in connection with the redistricting the Board of Education this year will be looking at the question of a building referendum to take care of our building needs this simply addresses the overcrowding that we presently have and we know we'll have in the next two to three years we have to solve that problem so it's going to take four to five years to build a new building even if we said tonight we want to build a new building it that new building won't be in place ready to use until four or five years down the road that's simply how long that takes well if that's the case then all those developments that haven't had a shovel put in they're 5 years is out too U Can I just ask a quick question of the building

221principles do any of you have any class sizes in the 26 27 range do any of you heading towards class sizes in this 26 or 27 range so we got one school so 25 and more so we're heading to but we're up we're up getting up to high class sizes this redistricting reduced es the class sizes it also does another thing it balances it balances the class sizes between all of the elementary schools so you don't have one school averaging 24 and 25 and another averaging 21 and 22 so it's another part of the design I'm sorry I just wanted to ask a question go ahead hi Deborah Pella 15 Louise Lane first I just have good B good first I have a question for the board so I understand tonight I understand the presentation

222is happening is the vote deciding if a redistricting happen right after this with you after the public forum is that what's happening tonight the board will be discussing this plan tonight and it is possible that there will be a motion dealing with the adoption of this plan okay thank you my question in regards to the presentation I want to make sure I understand this correctly on one slide it said that from Oak Tree and Applegarth to Barkley Brook Brookside will be 202 students moved from Barkley Brook and Brookside moving to mil Lake in Woodland will be 259 students okay my understanding that's a total of 461 students the difference is 57 children so we're moving 20% of the population earlier if I'm understanding so that we are actually finding room for 57 children is there

223an easier redistricting where we redistrict one neighborhood of 57 children perhaps to get that number it seems like we're moving Barkley Brook in Brookside over to mil Lake to make room for Apple Garth and Oak Tree over at Barkley Brook but that different number number I'm getting is 57 how how is that number happening it's no it's it's I I think you're kind of misunderstanding my chart okay okay then explain it please okay we're taking we have we're reducing the population of oak tree Applegarth by 202 students correct by moving those 202 students we're not exchange okay we're not doing an exchange we're doing a movement no you're doing a domino right no no we're not doing exchange between schools there's no wash here it's not taking I could understand your argument if we were

224taking a section of oak tree Applegarth moving to Barkley Brook and then taking a section of Barkley Brook moving it to Oak Tre Applegarth that's not being done there's no wash here we're taking oakry appleg is a sending school it's sending 202 students the closest school to them to the areas I'm sending is Barkley Brook to create space in Barkley Brook okay I need to move those th those 259 students out now I understand where you're getting the 57 students why can't those 57 students be left in Barkley Brook because if you do that Barkley Brook will not have the classroom space to handle those students I'm not saying leave 57 children and and I'm saying not move 202 and 259 it seems that there only needs to be moved to 57 I I am

225completely not understanding what you're saying okay because because again I'm I'm just completely at a loss because keep in mind we're taking here's a buck okay I'm going to okay I'll maybe I am miscommunicating to you I'm going to I'm going to try it because I'm not communicating I am understanding that 202 students are being sent from one school which is Oak Tre Applegarth and you need to make room for them they're sending to Barkley book Brook and Brookside okay that's 202 students but now you need to find room for those 202 students so we need to send them to mil Lake and wood Woodland so now we have room at Barkley Brook right so now you're sending them away I'm sorry but your time is up okay I'd like the question answer then if

226he's not understanding it can sir the anger has to stop discuss so stop being so angry okay we're discussing this I'm trying to explain I think that I think that there I want to explain again to you what I'm talking about okay and if anybody in the bo can help me ask you please do we're taking two we need to reduce o tree Al we need to we can't put any more kids in them because they be getting a load of kids from the new hous are we agreed on the IM new housing or the fiveyear housing are we agreed that okay so the question is we need to move if we do this in boat we're taking 22 kids out of O appart moving to Barkley Brook to accommodate them we have to create

227Trace in Barkley Brook where's there room for the kids in Barkley Brook it's in Mid Lake Woodland so we take the 259 out of Barkley Brook with out of Brook Brook so I'm moving to Mid Lake Woodland so now we have a balance in all of the buildings and that balance is the long range plan that the board is talking about tonight there there is we're moving 57 more kids out ofy Brook to to M Lake Woods I agree with that but that's more than you need to that's because of breakage you the concept but the overall number though of our entire District then is the 20% number that we're moving 20% of all elementary school kids are mov right which to me is a is High number it's a high number one out of

228five children's lives are being disrupted need to do to accomplish this SCH that's what needs to be done okay next speaker Miriam Lavin 42 Narrows way let me just interrupt you one second please when you come to the microphone please State your question listen to the answer and that's the end of it it's not going to be a debate we could be here all night if we go back and forth back and forth back and forth so make sure you stay the question that you have Dr habber will then answer the question I do not expect a debate to be taking place between Dr Hab and a member of our public I mean we could be here until 3:00 in the morning and and you know it's just not productive thank you go ahead I

229actually have a statement to make not debate my statement is to to the board to please consider the impact to these children my older daughter did have to get bused to Barkley Brook and it was a 40-minute commute for her these are 7 and 1/2 year-old children that we are talking about there is no quick route from the forestgate communities to Barkley Brook that Dock Road is closed you cannot exit through there you have to come back around so I believe that there was a fallacy in the information previously provided because you can't go out the that side of of for you have to come back around it's about a 40-minute commute as compared to being on Links Drive one straight road to Oak Tree and Applegarth and these are young kids that are going

230on a much longer uh bus commun and are being moved out booted out of their schools that they've been in and I'm asking the board to please consider the impact on these young young children that are happening thank you Mr Goody want to say something you're goodon we discussed you want to answer that yes I I'll um Mr P yeah go ahead very briefly our transportation department has been intimately involved in the redistricting study and that statement is false there is no Transportation hiccup at all with the redistricting plan no student will be on a bus for an inordinate amount of time next speaker gazala Bora one Miko Drive um I don't have a question for you but I have a question for the board uh Mr President a few meetings ago when the first

231report came out through the ad hoc committee it was kind of this came from the public that can we get another demographer to look can we get revised numbers now I'm going to put this in a Layman's Layman's thought that if I have and sorry to be so sadistic about it but if I have a terminal disease and I need to find a cure for it and a doctor that I'm going to says cut an arm off I would want to get a second opinion so I as a taxpayer for the town am requesting or asking the board that I know this is a proposed plan but to all our Common Sense this plan does numbers are not adding up um I live in a development of 12 homes we send 16 people to B

232Brook Brookside 16 children every day on the bus so the numbers that that 706 does not add up this is not a long-term plan from the way we are looking at it this plan is going to get us into another redistricting map within 2 years and we would have moved kids for no reason um this you know our request as a community is not to rush into this cuz this does not look like it is well thought out can we please get another opinion and another plan that more people are in agreement to and that affects lesser number of kids um and it's more long-term and it does not outgrow itself within a year thank you so much all right thank you for your comment hi I'm Maya MAA with 16 Dominic Drive uh my

233first question for the board I guess is what is considered to be an inordinate amount of time to be on a us I didn't understand the question Mr bo uh that cannot be determined at the time but our transportation department has f i I'll give you an estimate okay if to satisfy the groans 45 minutes would be the maximum we we would want an elementary age student on the bus this would be under that we're looking at stuff in the 30 minute range there is there's this um hysteria that's building up over it this Transportation question this was Ed to me earlier and it's false there's no child who's going to be an inordinate amount of time on the bus take our word for that okay um the reason I asked is because uh we

234live in Woods Edge which is a mile and a half from Barkley Brook and Brookside and in kindergarten my kids were on the bus for 45 minutes they would fall asleep every day on the way to school and I started driving them because it was insane so now we're going to go from a mile and a half to Barkley Brook and Brookside to 4 and A2 miles to these other schools so we're going to run into the same problem so you're going to have more people driving cuz they're not going to want their kids sitting on the bus that long how is that more financially responsible for our town to have these buses driving all over creation to get the kids to other schools when we have closer schools where they can be I get

235the red distric thing I understand it I know it's necessary I'm not fighting that my point is there has to be uh there has to be more research more solutions more things put in place for this to happen it's being rushed it can wait another year I know some of you have said it can wait another year um there are kids that are going to go to three schools in three years my daughter's one of them I have a son too who will be impacted but he's down the road I'm not as worried about him she's in fourth grade she's in Brookside now she'll be in Woodland next year and she'll be in Middle School the year after that's not fair for a fourth grader I understand the need for it it's just something's not

236right you've all been parents some of you are grandparents look at it that way have a heart please okay just I'm I'm just asking please delay it one year that's all I'm asking keep us informed let us know what's going on don't make us read about it on social media keep it fair okay we try to do what we can for the town you guys do what you can you're here as volunteers we get it we appreciate it please do what's right that's all I'm asking for and I hope you understood I'm sorry speaker hi good evening Angela varos 5 Nicholas Avenue um this is probably a feta compete however I I do feel I need to speak my piece about this and I tend to look at these things more long-term long-term effect to

237the child 45 minutes 30 minutes is too long to say on a bus but when my son who's now 7 is 23 is an extra 5 or 10 minutes on the bus hopefully that's it really going to matter probably not however my son has some social issues that he's working on with the school fantastic um uh Team of teachers and the social worker Mrs Mahoney the um principal has been outstanding working with my son the um uh speech therapist his teachers for two years if he moves to the other school we start again Ground Zero developing those relationships developing those rapports that have been so beneficial to my child for the last two years and that will all be gone that will affect my child when he's 23 years old not sitting on the bus

238for an extra 10 minutes when he's seven but the this the socialization the attention the love and support he's getting from that child study team that I cannot just with moving and starting again thank you thank you hi Marina todor 224 Federal Road I was just wondering would it make more sense to take the children coming into the school district and then sending them to the different schools rather than taking the children who are established and have just love their schools and have relationships with their teachers and their principles and um I think it would be too traumatic for these children to be switched out of their schools and to have the new children who are coming into the town and have them go to the appropriate schools wouldn't that be easier and make more

239sense thank you lauan Fernandez 24 Cassandra Court I have a question I'm really confused when is the new build when is this building happening when when of the new kids coming in when of the families moving in is it 2 3 years or is it 5 to 7 years it's it's I'm down here because it's just easy to hear it's reverberation from backstage it's over a period of time some of the developments are have shovel in ground now some will have shovel in ground next year what does shovel and ground now mean that does I'm not construction has are under construction you drive around you see has under construction the point is the and I I really want to stress this point the point is that the town and we had um some discussions with

240the town administrators as as as early as Tuesday as late as Tuesday this week the town has told us in no uncertain terms these 2,323 units are coming in nobody can predi predict exactly when they're coming in we understand that they can come in in a rush for some of the smaller development 50 60s 70 80s they could take more time 6 or 7 years for the 618s but the fact is are going to happen the we know now that oak tree apple goth are be are getting jammed up they are very crowded we also know that Mid Lake Woodland has open and empty classrooms so we know that we can make moves now that will prevent us from having to do this next year and the year after and the year after that we

241need you need every you know earlier in discussion there were people talking about long-term Solutions we are looking or the board I get is looking to make a long-term solution to get them to wherever they have to go in the future I can't my question still isn't answered when is this happening you don't even know and we're in a do this I feel like I'm sitting here and my kids a number like we have six seveny old 8-year-old kids who love their principles their guidance counselors love their cafeteria and made friends and now they're being told they're going to go to a new school and then next year they may go to a new school is this a Band-Aid or a solution and I I again you're all you all parents and grandparents you have

242no idea the effect it has on our little children especially when you have a child who is scared to death to go to school and has worked so hard to get to know Miss Mahoney and to get to know that guidance counselor who finally wakes up every morning and smiles to go to school after two years okay we we will allow one more speaker and then we have to move on one more speaker the the lady there standing did you want to speak this will be the final speaker hi um Lisa cutro 230 Old Forge Road um so I've been to multiple meetings about the redistricting and I do understand the problem that we're facing I don't think that anyone here would say that we don't have an issue with overcrowding and I also understand

243the need to want to plan ahead I do however think that as much as we want to plan ahead equal thought should be given to who is currently in the schools so we seem to be putting a lot of emphasis on making sure children that will BEC coming into the schools 3 five and seven years from now are accommodated at the possibly at the expense of the kids who are currently in the schools and I think that everybody on the board wants to do the right thing for all the kids I've talked to a lot of the board members personally I do see that there is a lot of um interest and care in to make sure the kids are accommodated but I feel like we might be putting too much focus on 7 years

244from now and not necessarily on today's kids so if there is a possibility to be able to phase in some redistricting not make it so much of a traumatic thing moving so many kids at once having second graders be in three schools in three years having fifth graders be in three schools in three years if there is another way um that it could be scaled down backed down a little we should look at that and if the thing that's preventing us from looking that is we think we have to do it right now so it can be ready for September then we're doing it too fast and we need to slow down in some way and accommodate the current students and accommodate the future students and that's the point that I would like to make

245thank you the public session is now closed and the board will now have an opportunity to ask uh Dr Haber any questions regarding this plan Mr Ryback I'm going to use the mic so the audience can hear Dr Heber um on page seven I just I don't know if the if this would affect anything but I'm yeah I think it's important for everyone to see I don't know if this would affect ultimately the numbers but just some questions I had about the makeup of of two developments it's page seven yes okay um on the JSM Marketplace I know the application if I'm not mistaken hasn't been approved yet you have 618 single family homes actuality uh it's a combination of of three-bedroom town homes and two-bedroom Apartments what is the um Marketplace which one the

246marketplace J some Marketplace the application hasn't been approved officially yet but you you have it listed 618 single family homes but there are no single family homes in that development It's a combination of three bedroom town homes and two-bedroom apartments from the financial impact analysis originally originally presented by the developer uh he had 3 37 3bedroom uh town homes and 234 two-bedroom apartments so there's no single family homes there I thought I lost you which one are you looking at the um Marketplace JSM which one JSM Marketplace yeah JSM Marketplace is 600 it says to be built 618 yeah but you have it listed on that's my question you have it listed under single family homes there are no single there's no single family homes in that development It's a combination of two-bedroom apartments and

247three-bedroom Town Homes according to that's the one on um Marketplace is the one for 33 EXC JSM Marketplace 618 under 618 to be built yeah but I my question is the the application I spoke with John rigs on this and the application hasn't been approved yet no we understand right so I I thought maybe you just use the number under the single family homes my question to you was does it really matter that it's not all there's no there's no single family homes going in that development then I've got to talk to John this this docent tells me this by the way is I didn't make this docum this is from MP well I spoke with him today let me just let me just address this about the approval sorry I have another question uh

248I'll back up I'm getting a lot of exercise tonight um we SP spoke with um the town manager and he included these 618 in the 2323 and he said yes they haven't been approved but he said with certainty that they would be improved now your question is a good one because according to this sheet the single family homes I will call John tomorrow now if that's the case reduces the numbers a bit and the other question I had with is the celebration um you have 456 tow houses right uh celebrations is is about 80 town homes and about 376 Apartments again take look here the way it's broken down the way it's broken down is town houses but again we can celebrations is broken is 376 and 80 but I counted for that in the

249numbers words okay I just want them to be clear that also was here that's right that's correct okay other questions from the board Mr noin um Dr Haber if the if this redistricting did not take place what kind of class sizes could we expect to see on the Applegarth oak tree uh schools we'll start to see class sizes next as the 26 and 27 and this will bring it down to what this will bring it into 22 23 range thank you Mr H we're already I just I just need to clarify that I know we already up to 28 at average across the board okay you know one of 28 one of 20 average I just this is I I understand Dr Dr abber I just want to make sure that it's clear to everybody

250in the audience you already have class sizes of up to 28 students at Oak Tree 28 again you have class sizes of 28 students at Oak Tree on the other side of town you have empty classrooms uh Mr Haver I have a question uh regarding slides 18 and 19 slide yes in slide 18 for the uh year 20151 uh your projection shows uh 1190 students what page about 18 18 18 oh it so I got it okay I was looking okay 1190 on the app right yes it shows 1190 but on slide 19 when I look at uh the total students for mil Lake Woodland I take uh the students at uh mil lake at 636 and the students at Woodland is 407 uh there's there's quite a discrepancy there no it's the discrepancy is

251that in the classroom count in the classroom count special kids if you look at the last colum that counts PK I was looking only at K3 four five for I was looking for classroom space with the general ed students okay all right but but how many uh how many special ed and and prek and all that is there because well because those rooms were counted for in other words in other words I'm simply talking about student enrollments you have 1190 projected for uh mil Lake Woodland for the year 201516 and and and yet you have on the next slide if I add those numbers together you have 1,043 now that's a considerable difference in my opinion almost a difference of 150 students and and and doesn't make sense to me that there's that large of

252a difference I'm sorry you know what number so you think the numbers lower well I I'm simply saying the numbers should be more consistent they're not consistent and and that worries me but let me move on to another point that I'm concerned about I want to check that oh yes you can make a note to check that uh but I noticed that uh with the with this particular plan we would have a 11 11 first grade classes would have 25 to 27 students per class I I I am uncomfortable with that I mean if we're if we're doing a redistricting I think first grade first grade classes need to be smaller than 25 to 27 students and and the and if we're going to redistrict then we need to keep that in mind and there's

25311 classes in this plan in the first grade that would have that number of students once again you can take another look at it I'm also uh concerned with how well this redistricting plan works because I noticed over that uh 5year span Barkley Brook Brookside they they en enrollment will drop by 55 students in terms of the total enrollment it will drop by 55 mil Lake Woodland will drop by 366 students over that 5-year period And yet oak tree Applegarth will grow by 323 students I am uncomfortable with that it doesn't make sense to me if we're redistricting that we're going to have such an imbalance in terms of how much one school is growing and two other schools are dropping distribution I looked at classroom availability the classroom availability so we sir we're friends

254again anyway uh um okay in doing this distribution okay if you take a look okay at these sheets there's workable space for class class size dedu reduction what we haven't worked on are some of the program exchanges the principles have to do for example if you look at M Lake Woodland the 137 students um comes out to 20 class size 27 but we can with some we have three additional open rooms in um Woodland we can take one or two of the programs out of mil Lake mil Lake mve them into Woodland to create classroom reduction space in in in in mil Lake the principles need to we haven't worked out all of those deals all those statistics but that's we we know we have to make some program exchanges to to adjust the classroom

255sizes if you go down you'll see the number of classrooms open up as the years go by through the reduction of enrollment so we know we are aware of that we can do the classroom reduction we have the space to do it we just have to we talked about things like moving KP from one you know moving KP from one of the combined schools to the other combined schools opening up a child study team room that's a full-size classroom that doesn't need to be used full-size classroom resource rooms that you know that can can be reduced so there are a number of things that we still need to do to get this to get this working in terms of program program changes and program reductions so I agree with that you know okay I I

256I'm well aware and I'm very sensitive to the overcrowding that we have in some of our schools and uh as the president of this board I'm going to read to you excerpts from a letter uh of a teacher that works in Oak Tree in grade two uh because she made me even more aware of what that problem is with the overcrowding and and and it's almost a two-page letter but bear with me i' I've really cut it down to just certain select sections uh with differentiation and targeted instruction being so important pulling small groups and is a valuable part of instruction in the classroom room when you have between 25 and 30 students small groups are not so small or there are too many small groups that you can't possibly see them all trying to

257manage behavior and taking in large classes and I'm sorry and talking in large classes is quite challenging especially when you have multiple students who are on behavioral plans teachers in each School are given the same amount of money to spend on class room supplies money gets spent faster in those larger classes and teachers cannot order as much as they can in a smaller class when hosting classroom celebrations are doing science experiments teachers often spend some of their own money to purchase supplies teachers who have larger class sizes are spending more of their own money on those things lines of 25 to 30 students long take a long time to move down the hall this has been cutting into the students lunch times as well as the teachers lunch and prep periods if more classrooms are

258needed it is possible that art and music will be put on carts also special teachers would not have ready access to supplies that might be needed and will take extra time between periods to travel from one class to the next forcing periods to either end early or start late finally during the winter when there is indoor recess the students will be stuck in the classroom all day except for a 15minute break for lunch the kids get cabin fever and it makes it very hard for them to focus in a room all day long similarly putting basic skills teachers on a cart makes it hard to do quality instruction other school professionals such as as guidance CST speech OT reading specialist nurse Etc might also be working with increased number of children compared to the other

259schools the number of desk in the classroom and I have been in some of these classrooms so I know this is quite true the number of desk in the classroom make it very crowded which makes it hard to navigate around the room and teach learn effectively now this comes from one of our second grade teachers in the oak tree School uh I don't deny that that we have a problem with that building being quite overcrowded and that is why the board must look at how to resolve that problem we cannot put up a building overnight it takes quite a few years to do that to move in trailers is very expensive we finally have gotten rid of the trailers that is money spent that we never get back it is not a capital investment not

260only is expensive to lease the trailer it's expensive to set up the infrastructure for that trailer to bring it in and then when we take it out we've got to go through the expense of of doing that it is a very expensive proposition to use trailers so I do not deny and this board doesn't deny that we have a problem with particularly the Applegarth Oak Tree schools being very very crowded and we've got to do something about it are there any other questions or comments from the board Miss armeno yes um more of a comment um oh well let me ask a question first when we were talking about the 200 students in the on the the final page the are what though that movement is not scheduled isn't that moving over time the 202

261students and the 259 students that makes the redistricting 461 total is that I'm sorry that would happen that would that would be the change right now that would be changing now so in September it the the possibility that that movement would occur in September yes and that and that is projected to last according to this report for how long for up five to six years I think even given given the rate of construction longer than 5 years I would say 7 is s is seven is a safe guarantee so the students that would be impacted would some of them would be entering a a different School let's say some of them would be entering a different school not necessarily leaving another one to enter a different school someone will be entering a different school for

262the first time kindergarten students okay if I'm hearing you correctly kindergarten students would be entering the new school would not have changed schools because they had never been in the school okay uh some some of some of the rest of the children of these children and again if that last page by the way parenthetically that number is 406 not 595 I just copied it wrong okay okay anyway but let's go to the last page okay is this nope not that one that one okay so where it says grades 1 2 2 3 45 that is actually this year's K12 34 okay those students it would those students if they all moved that would be the total move and that's broken down by grade level okay thank you my comment is that while um Mr H

263Dr habber uh has collected this data we may disagree with it or agree with it it is not he's not the one building the houses in in the community he is not the one one that is responsible for when the houses are developed and when they are are closed and then thus the students in school nor nor is the board once again the but it is imperative I think I've been in this community since like I said before 1980 and it is imperative for us to make changes and this is a gradual change this isn't an immediate change we have been thinking about this and worrying about it and and there's a lot of anxiety in the whole community over it for many many years I think for myself I'll speak that we would be

264remiss if we didn't address these things now no one wants to do this but we are compelled to do it we have no choices and hopefully we'll move into the future and and if we have a a referendum for a new school we will go through that process as well it is not a pleasant for anyone certainly not pleasant for the people making the decision we would all prefer that that it was much easier but I think we would be remiss if we didn't address this now if we didn't work it out and certainly the administrators the principles the central office is working very hard to try to accommodate each child and and the parents needs as well and I think that the board is is directed and correct me if I'm wrong the board

265is directed to make a decision whether we need redistricting or not I think everybody agrees we do the implementation of that may go slower and may be you know um decided through the administration through the principes through the schools those the Educators make those decisions but I think we can all agree that we have a need across the board to make some decision going forward very quickly so that that would be my concern and me it seems to to Bear out whether whether the calculations are exactly correct or not in my personal opinion I think we're going to have more students than are projected and I think that it's going to be a more rapid pace and if the market changes if the real estate market accelerates and like you said we go going through

266the um recession we didn't it didn't hit us so much it might have hit the prices but it didn't hit the uh building out of Monroe so if the market real estate market starts to accelerate the there will be an acceleration of students into the community so I think if we don't do this in another year or two we'll have a public meeting where people will say we were irresponsible for not addressing it so I just think we need to go forward and make a decision Mr Rybeck I just I'd like to make some comments and and I do have a question but comments first uh safety is is a matter that we have to consider when you have schools that are overcrowded go a bid if they have to go to lockdown or even

267moving through the Halls it could be a dangerous situation when you have overcrowded uh classrooms um you know we have many teachers here today I know they have to uh uh work on the um student growth objectives and and everyone's looking at the test scores and the state government I seem to be down on the state today but so be it and the state is um making all these rules but no none nobody from the state is concerned about your class size they're concerned about the school the student scores but not about the class size I was in the classroom for 21 years I know what it's like to teach with uh a lot of kids it's very difficult um my hat goes off to you we have to be very cogniz of that we

268have to uh correct the imbalance in this system so that all our students have equal access to the Quality instruction that all of you teachers provide you're doing a great job but we have to make it fair for you so that you could do the kind of job that you want to do we have to give you the resources and we have to watch the class size because uh that's extremely important uh Dr Haber my question to you is um and and I guess to the the board and Mr vello if if this plan is accepted it's not carved in stone obviously it can be tweaked because I think that would satisfy some people out here along as we go along I mean the plan could be tweaked in a couple of ways number one

269principles have to sit down change I mean and the principles have to sit down and and work out the programmatic issues okay you know teaching teaching step and things like that uh but yeah it Point yes administratively we have options to wiggle around and maneuver M um but the important thing is that this redistricting plan and the change in attendance zones is is moved tonight so that so that we can operate safely with parody amongst the schools next year and not have programs offered on a cart or removed from the budget I absolutely feel that we you know we have to move forward but I just thought that knowing that there is some wiggle room administratively that that might satisfy some questions out there yes and and by wiggle room I mean once the plan's

270adopted administratively of course we're going to have to make changes along the way because nothing is set in stone there's things you don't anticipate and that's why you have an Administration thank you any other questions or comments okay then a uh motion has been prepared that I will read uh I move that the Monroe Township Board of Education accept the enrollment projection facility utilization and redistrict ing study prepared by Ross habber and Associates dated March 2015 and let it be resolved that the Board of Education Direct the superintendent and business administrator to redistrict the attendance zones in accordance with that report is there a second second second who was that Mr Kaufman okay uh Mr Gorski roll call vote Please Mr armeno yes yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski I abstain thank you Mr Mayo

271yes Mr calman yes Mrs Co Pano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr P I vote Yes but I must express my displeasure in the report and the concerns that I expressed earlier I just hope that uh this is the right direction I know that uh that oak tree Applegarth has a severe problem problem has to be solved I just wish the plan were a little bit more satisfactory particularly in terms of those first grade numbers that will be reflected in the minutes um Mr board president motion passes okay let see where we are oh my God okay uh at this time the board will uh the bo board will deliberate on the uh Mecca the Monroe employees Child Care academy uh and the deliberation is essentially on whether uh to

272uh discontinue this program as of the end of this school year uh so the people can make comments Miss kapovich um I need to make a statement before we go into the deliberation of Mecca okay can you use your microphone on advice at Council I would like to read the following statement in advance of our discussion and vote on Mecca recently a question was raised by the oak tree Applegarth PTA president regarding whether it' be ethical for me to vote on this particular motion before I cast my vote I want to be perfectly clear that I consulted with the B board attorney who advised that there is no ethical concern with respect to my participation in this vote the individual who raised this question expressed the concern regarding my recent attendance as a general member

273of the PTA at a PTA meeting during the PTA meeting a vote was taken concerning whether the PTA should send a petition to the PTA General membership to see if there was interest in supporting the continuation of Mecca I did not vote on that motion instead I remained silent during the vote as I did with regard to every other vote that was taken that evening the principles who were in attendance at that meeting also remained silent during the vote and did not vote on the motion however there was no call for extensions or recusals during this particular motion or any other motion that evening I acted in this regard so as to avoid the very conflict the individual in question is now claiming exists Additionally the board attorney referred the individual in question to a

274school ethics commission advisory opinion which held that a quote board member May simultaneously serve as president of the local PTA in the same district end quote the commission determined that the two positions were not inherit inheritant in Conflict quote such that a board member service to the PTA might reasonably be expected to Prejudice his independence of judgment in the exercise of his or her official duties end quote in fact the Comm found that the two positions were compatible rather than in conflict in view of the foregoing I am not conflicted from voting on the motion regarding Mecca uh thank you Miss kapovich uh just to remind the board uh we this was uh previously on an agenda and uh I had asked that it be returned to the building and grounds committee for further discussion

275uh and the building and grounds committee uh did uh carry out that discussion and they wanted uh the discussion to be done with the full board and so that's why we are looking at this tonight uh so you might consider this a committee of the whole on this particular question and that's why we are opening the floor uh that is we're opening the uh the the time now for the board members to uh make any comments uh that they want to about this Mecca program Mr Braverman well let me understand we're now speaking about Mecca yes if if you have any concerns and there's no motion on the floor but I can just not not as of yet well as um as I recall about two years ago the Board of Education directed the central

276office administration to have this program become solvent and I'd like Mr Gorski to bring us up to date on that yes go ahead uh that is absolutely correct about about nine months into the operations of Mecca as a standalone segment at the time there were attendance figures that were not matching the projections and the fund was losing money and there was a lot of public criticism and there was no at that time um address of the loan and the board directed Dr Hamilton to come up with a solvency plan for Mecca and administration accomplished that by working collaboratively with Marietta ruella to make Early Childhood enrichment another segment and when the two are Blended together the operations were solvent that's important for the public to understand there's been some questions about profitability there are two

277separate considerations here one Mecca as a segment by itself and the other as a Consolidated proprietary funds okay so we're pretty solvent actually so I don't understand what the problem is here with this Board of Education um it's it's a good program we're taking care of our own people contrary to the gentleman over there that says he feels for you but he can't afford it we're talking about pennies so I'd like to make a motion to maintain this program maintain the mecca program can I have a second I'll second it I'll I'll second that okay Kathy second I did Kathy pred Jill the mail oh I don't know I think Jill second okay okay so the motion has been made you said to continue it well it's okay we'll go with that to continue Mecca

278uh it has been seconded and so now we can uh continue with discussion okay Mr noin um just a a some questions um when we took over this endeavor of Mecca um we had no business plan I was pretty outspoken uh from the other side of the microphone at the time that I knew that this program had potential my concern was that it really wasn't too well thought out um currently the definition of profitability is kind of like a moving Target when some people think of profitability they are not taking into consideration that we are also spending $70,000 a year extra on the leasing of Office Space over an Applegarth Road for pupil service which were displaced when this program came in so if we were to get rid of Mecca and get rid of

279ECE we would see and move pupil Services back into there we would actually realize a savings right off the bat of $80,000 now people can say that that's pennies but we are always looking at the monetary issues of this uh District I realize that this is a great program and I know that it's a great program because it's being run by uh the Monroe uh District administration and and teachers so I I totally get that but as a board member I also have a fiduciary responsibility to the taxpayers of Monro um I don't think it's it's fair to put their money um to to benefit basically 35 teachers so I am voting no for this uh this motion thank you okay Mr Ryback thank you um Mr gski a question would Mr noin raised the

280issue of the rent on on the uh new for the offices would be Are We Wrong in figuring that that rent should be counted as a cost against Mecca it's an interesting question the rent here's here's the scenario for for the Public's benefit we had uh special services in the M Lake Annex and special services was displaced into a trailer which required a lease payment and continued uh the lease to house them while Mecca was created in the annex from an accounting standpoint they're two separate transactions and the lease does not flow into the financial statements of Mecca or profitability however it's an interesting analysis because it's like an opportunity cost that you have now because you had to move special services and I understand that currently we have a a three-year lease and we're

281going into I think year two on that lease um on the special services uh rental condo I know when I was on the other side of the microphone um they had pupil Personnel Services and the trailers and we were spending about 230,000 a year on those trailer rentals um now we're spending $70,000 a year and all of this was necessitated to make room for Mecca which is taking up five classrooms now um expanding e ECE would give us the ability or capability of of making about $800,000 if I'm not mistaken on on on ECE and you know when you we doing our presentation before I'm looking at District goals one of the district goals was to raise revenue I know the board was interested in in creative ways of raising revenue ECE and and and

282Falcon care seem to be very creative ways ECE is a proven Money Maker um Mecca is a financial loss I understand the importance of it to the teachers as I said I was a young teacher one time my wife was a young teacher we needed Child Care also so I do understand that but we do have a fiduciary responsibility to the public and I think that uh you know to say that uh something might be pennies well I don't think the public would appreciate that I think that every cost has to be looked at and um it is quite a bit of money uh up through January 31st I think we lost almost $43,000 and the operating loss right now is over $133,000 and that doesn't even count the $770,000 in rent a year that

283we're paying for uh pupil Personnel Services so um my vote would be no okay M kapovich I've been a supporter of this program going back many days to days of Dr Ferry and I've stated many times over the years why Mecca did not start off well so I'm not even going to go there today it can always be about the dollars and cents in the past three years the amount of staff using Mecca has tripled this is about our staff and hiring and retaining quality people to work in our district and teach our children this program is an opportunity for our board to offer something to the staff that other other districts can our starting salaries are not equivalent to other surrounding districts so this program isn't a good attraction for the young employees and

284I've heard teachers say to me that they came to monreo specifically because we have a Mecca program this is about District morale and the quality of life for our staff over half of our District employees signed petition to keep Mecca intact they are not going to trust this board if they feel that every program that we have or this program or any program we're going to hold over their heads every year if we're looking at a referendum down the road we're going to need the support of all of our District employees to help us pass one and if they don't trust one if they don't trust us as a board we're not going to get their support our Meera parents are willing to work with us to help this program Thrive by offering to increase

285their tuition and eliminate the district funded lunch snack program to keep it open where do you find employees that are willing to raise their their their tuitions to help us out um per the information given to the finance committee at a meeting on February 18th there were currently 43 Mecca students and 38 ECE students with no waiting list for a total of 80 students if we eliminate Mecca there is no guarantee that we will be able to make up the money lost to the mecca program plus there are areas that we just can't put a cost on how early an employee returns from maternity leave and the amount of subtime we wouldn't have to pay reduced employee absenteeism and increased employee productivity decreased health care costs having the school calendar and the child care calendar

286coincide so that you're not paying for a whole week of child care if you're only working 3 days the security and peace of mind knowing their children are well cared for in safe loving environments run by our district the convenience of having daycare so close to work knowing their children are safe and loved allows the staff to do their job to the best of their abilities without worrying about their children they can concentrate on what they do best which is teaching our children this is not just a daycare center but a learning environment for our students we all know that when we are less stressed and we're happy at work we will do a better job our Mecca parents are happy and I don't know how you can put a price on that and I

287employ our board to find a way to work with our staff and help to continue this absolutely wonderful program anyone else here to make a comment Mr Mayo um I've thought about this long and hard and I've read every email that has come my way and I feel that closing Mecca is wrong it was designed as a benefit for the teachers who are the lowest paid in middlex County it was never meant to be a profit Center but in conjunction with ECA it does make a profit uh there are families who have come to rely on it for their children and feel that their children are well cared for although you can't directly measure in dollars employees satisfaction you can look at employee absenteeism how quickly employees return to work after having a baby the

288retention rate of teachers after maternity leave and employee morale I think the discussion should not be about closing Mecca but to how ensure how to ensure that it has a zero impact on the budget on a continuous basis it was profitable last year and it can still be profitable this year Mr cman I just want to uh answer a couple of issues that came up tonight uh when Mecca was originally started um I was in full support I was there when we all talked about it and thought it would be a great opportunity uh to provide this type of service to our staff uh first thing I want to address is this this activity was never ever ever meant to turn a profit because we all agreed that whatever service we provide to our staff

289we shouldn't be looking to make a profit we would be looking for it to cover its costs but we would never look at it to uh make a profit in fact in a recent uh probably about a year or so ago the the question of uh whether or not we should raise the price of Mecca and ECE came up in one of the finance committees and we were trying to think about what kind of dollar and cents to figure out what we should do and I believe I made the recommendation that it should never ever be more than whatever the salary increase for that particular year would be for our staff members wouldn't make sense if we have a 2% increase for staff but we rais the mecca cost 10% wouldn't make sense right kind

290of cutting your nose despite the face unfortunately as you move the clock forward we have a situation where e now appears to be carrying more of the financial load than Mecca and that's not solving a problem that's moving a problem if ECE is bringing more money to the table to turn the combined effort into uh profitability status then the ECE parents in theory could be paying more because they're covering the cost difference that Mecca is coming short on so it's really not fixing anything it's really kind of just moving something and it's not fair to the ECE parents either um if we had a solution and or a recommendation that provided a scenario where uh Mecca was covering its costs that would be a different thing right now the numbers that we've seen um and

291we don't know what that number could be if you know we don't want to say it's It's All About Numbers right but if at the end of the day we have to wind up doubling the cost of Mecca just to be able to cover the costs then then it may be a a numbers thing for some of the people that are currently enrolled in Mecca because it now is a number thing right so until and I haven't seen it yet based on the numbers we have we have reviewed by the board and was discussed during finance that I can't support something if it's not at least covering its costs uh because again it was never meant to be a profit-making Endeavor but it has to at least cover its cost and it's not doing that

292Mr Po Mr Oro I'm sorry pleas yes um as as a program and I heard everyone's passionate concerns I agree with that and as hopefully as a progressive person I would like to think that we could have child care across the board for um our our teachers our community um however when this program was instituted it first of all is not a mandated program it's not a requirement uh for the district and secondly it was formulated as a self-sustaining program so I was not on the board when this was brought up um but I think that as a board member now um again Our obligation is to make tough decisions make uncomfortable decisions and it's not about the money for me at all it is except that an the money that is not that the

293money that we are that is is costing can go to mandated programs and needs of the current student population uh so I feel that there's a responsibility to use money that would otherwise go as a loss to a program that's not man mated to put into mandated programs and to increase the educational system that we we are responsible for the other thing is I do remember um and I could please correct me if I'm wrong that during the audit presentation the auditor did say that the loan that calculating the cost of the mecca program uh cannot be even considered profitable until the loan is actually paid off and Mr uh poy and if you'll allow Mr Gorski to correct me if I'm incorrect but somehow I know that I asked a specific question about that

294the fund has an accumulated deficit and that accumulated deficit would be reversed approximately the same time the loan is repaid so that's a fair statement from the auditor okay it's not that it wouldn't be profitable there could be interim times where it is profitable in the segments combined are are are profitable but uh to to be able to consider um and have a retained earnings and have an accumulated profit you have to pay back the loan which is basically eroding the accumulated deficit okay so again it would be for me about the majority of the students and of the district in its entirety and the the value of of all of the instruction that we are mandated to to pursue so I I find it a very worthwhile Pursuit but I'm not sure that um

295we can go forward anyone else have comments Mr Braverman I've been sitting here for a long time tonight but a lot of years and a lot of things become very amusing when you've been here long enough and you know some of the story uh yes Mecca is not a mandated program but several years ago one of the board members here who's going to be voting against Mecca came to our board meeting and needed a summer program for his students and his students classmates we didn't have any money in the budget for it it wasn't a mandated program but we knew it was the thing to do and we approve the program that gentleman tonight that gentleman tonight will be voting against your Mecca program and you will be losing 5 to four that's the way

296it goes I'd like to call the question just hold on please you're out of order uh I have yet to speak because I wanted everyone else to have an opportunity I I've looked uh I I too as Mr mayo and I'm sure many of our other board members I read every single email about Mecca I looked at the PowerPoint presentation that you sent to us uh even though uh I only got it recently but I had also looked at the figures uh because it does come down to that and uh I will tell you uh when this program was first proposed uh I I felt that it was something that uh the Board of Education should not be doing um it it it simply did not strike me as being within their focus and what

297they should be all about they should be dealing with the students that they need to educate K to 12 they should not be distracted by something of this nature and I I often spoke up as a member of the public uh asked a lot of questions about it made it very clear that I was very opposed to it so uh but taking everything into account I know that it is of Great Value to our teachers and um that is important it does help them to do a better job could they find uh Child Care somewhere else yes because if we never had Mecca that's what they would have done uh but I I move to modify to uh amend your your motion uh Mr bravman and I would I would like for that uh amendment

298to be that uh Mecca continue with a percent increase a percent increase on the tuition fees so that it not only pays the expenses but also returns $5,000 per month so we can get that loan paid off and if you are willing to accept that I did some calculations according to my calculations I am a former math teacher by the way but according to my calculations uh and it it was even supported by work done independently by uh a group of Mecha parents uh it strikes me that uh we would have to raise the fee by about 20% uh now uh and I know because many of the mecca parents said that they were willing to to pay more for this but that is the only way that I would vote to continue with Mecca

299is if it pays its way and it pays off the loan under any other circumstances I would not support it so uh I move to amend your motion I don't know if there is a second can can I ask a question about paying off this yeah uh we do this yeah go ahead all right I'm not quite following how the loan is not being paid off between Mecca and ECA to me it's like a mortgage it's not something you pay it off all at once it's like a depreciation so can you further clarify that for me the loan balance as of January 31st 2015 is $239,200 a month since the board passed resolution back in I think November of 13 uh moving that the loan be paid back with proceeds of income from the fund

300so but it is true that going going forward with the with the uh increase in expenses that we have this year that uh the repayment of that 5,000 per month is not going to be happening is that correct Mr gski the loan repayment right now is coming from Surplus cash not from net income being generated and if the Surplus cash dries up then we will not be able to pay back the loan at $5,000 a month on current performance that is correct question can I ask one certainly um I know Mr Po you did your calculations on a estimated 20% increase on the on the fee Mike did you get a chance to to run that number through your model because you know we got all the numbers about the stuff reflective of of its

301profitability and loss would you have a number that you could collaborate with on what you think a increase in tuition would be to at least cover the cost to answer your question directly I did not run that scenario through that's the first time I heard it just now do Mr poy and I did talk about this but it was based upon a hypothetical of a 35% increase in the fund um and I believe and I and and I hate saying this because I don't have any any calculations to back it up but my gut is that if you increase the fees somewhere between 35 and 40% that this could uh become solvent as a segment it's very difficult to ascertain because the services vary in price structure and they are very fluid okay so let's

302do something completely crazy let's say the number conservatively is 40% we have a number of 20% and we have a number that's 40% let's say we said 30 we have a unique situation here with a large contingent of me consumers in the room by a show of hands if that number tests out to 30% and you're all here are you saying you're willing to pay 30% more intuition to continue the program just stand up you have to talk to your president I just needed to see if there was a because not everybody was even to no we're not Mr Mr calman uh you know there was some uh a projection that came over on a PowerPoint presentation there was a consideration of expense there was a challenge to the accounting of of split between the

303funds ECE and Mecca there is no expense consideration of cutting out lunches that's going to make this fund profitable I just want to emphasize that the only thing that's going to bring this back is a significant price increase in the tuition do we have to put a oh I'm sorry you can cut out all the lunches you want you can stop supplies it it that's an immaterial expense 85 or 90% of the cost of this is salaries and benefits who's going to pay the loan there's a motion on the table need a call to order all right please the the floor is really not open I and I apologize because I know Mr Kaufman asked for some kind of a poll there but uh well it's important only because if you're going if like you're

304recommending of increasing the tuition is 20 and your constituents aren't willing to pay it that's that's a torpedo right there so well Mr Po can I say something M kapano why don't we I would second your motion if we don't use a specific uh percentage but we work out the percentage and and see what it is we work with them to figure out how much we can we can grow that program I I mean to say 20% or 40% or 50% right now we we really can't do that Mr qu we had two finance committee meetings on this never has this issue about uh coming up with a solvency plan for this specific segment come up and it's really inappropriate to bring it up at the meeting now to try to throw a dart if

305it's 20% 30% I caution the board against that if that's the board's Direct C to to to make Mecca as a segment solvent it has to go back to finance committee and and it has to involve Sharon Jensen it has to involve enrollment projections cost projections to have a an intelligent answer to that M Mr Mr Ryback I'm having a problem with all due respect poy with what you were proposing you know if I'm not mistaken when Mecca was first proposed um the superintendent at the time uh based opened it uh based on a survey and not not uh uh deposits in hand or you know it seems to be kind of halfhazard way of doing this we don't have the figures uh we know that it has not been um it we know that

306it's been uh operating at at quite a loss uh we don't know what what it will bring we don't know you're we're asking people now last minute if if they would go a 30% rate I don't think they really could make that decision I don't think we it's fair for us to make a decision on I think we have to move forward um to either approve it or disapprove it uh and then uh you know in the future who knows what what will be but right now we have to work on a motion we can't make a decision uh based on what you were proposing with 30% we don't know why it'll be we know it's operating at a loss we've been there for 3 years um it's a difficult decision I certainly understand the

307the um emotions here I read every letter also uh but but uh you know we do have a fiduciary responsibility and continuing with this new proposal seems to me kind of halfhazard and um with all due respect I I I I know you mean well but I I think that uh it's creating a an unfair situation for the board as well as for the people in the audience there's a motion on the floor is there a second to Mr Po's motion what is Mr Po motion to continue with the program at a percentage increase so that it pays expenses and the loan and is solvent doesn't Mr I I would second can you speak into the mic please yeah I would second that doesn't Mr Braverman have to amend that his motion first if a

308majority of uh the amendment motion passes then it's amended okay okay and we and we have a second now okay we we're we're doing a roll call vote on the amended motion could you read the amended motion please it is recommended by Mr poy to continue with the mecca program at an undefined percent increase so that it pays expenses and the loan and is solvent first by Mr Po second by Kathy cound you like me to take a roll call this would require a majority of the members eligible to vote on this matter which in this instance would be five and then the motion would be amended Miss armeno no Mr Braverman I didn't hear the I didn't hear the amendment and I thought you have to vote on the amendment before you vote on

309the on the we are voting on the amendment now I'll I'll repeat it for you if you'd like repeat it for me sure please it is recommended by Mr Po to continue with the a segment at a percentage increase that is undefined so that it pays its current expenses and the loan and is solvent yes Mr z zareski i abstain thank you Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman no Mrs colano yes Mr noin no Mr proso no Mr Rybeck no Mr poy yes Mr board president Amendment does not pass that goes back to the original motion made by Mr Braverman to continue with the mecca program Mr ning um just for your point I Mike I thought that we went over you know I know I wanted to beat a dead horse but I think

310I actually asked that question and I thought it was closer to 65% um that we would have had to raise the rates to uh to accomplish it I never I know I asked that at the finance committee meeting the second one because that was a concern I think that was one of the things that prefaced the second finance committee meeting um so I I think that I'm sorry the I'm sorry you're out of order as far as the payback of the loan is concerned um I think that if the ECE um according to your projections um we could help an additional 400 uh students in ECE by eliminating the current Mech approach program so um my concern is that we can actually help more children by going with the uh ECE than uh continuing with

311the 42 for the mecca so I just wanted to be clear that I just think that that number wasn't anywhere near 20% uh it was actually closer to 65% and I don't think there would have been too much interest at that and also uh the reason I voted no for that amendment was that I think that any that would have to make this break even would also have to include that $770,000 lease uh that were currently obligated uh due to the uh the mecca it's you're right it's a separate balance sheet but at the end of the day it's still a $70,000 cost that I don't think our taxpayers should have us to subsidize okay we will now we will now vote on Mr braverman's motion to continue M I say one last thing they're

312right now is 38 people in the ECA Mr Gorski 38 30 38 is the number that I have believe that's correct there's no guarantee that we're going to get 39 people in the ECE next year so to eliminate the mecca because we're expecting 200 ECE students is is kind of ridiculous because we could be losing the money from both programs you're not get so why the pro projection was that we would get 200 ECE students and give us 800,000 nothing says that we're going to do that okay we will now vote on Mr braverman's motion the motion is to continue to maintain the mecca program as it now stands Mr Gorski please do a roll call Mr armeno no Mr Braverman absolutely yes thank you Mr zareski abstain thank you sir Mr de Mayo yes

313Mr calman no Mrs kapano absolutely yes Mr noin no Mr proso no Mr Rybeck no Mr Po as explained earlier no Mr Po motion to maintain the program does not pass good okay uh I have one more motion on this matter it is recommended that the members of the Monroe Township Board of Education approve the dissolution of the Monroe employee chalk care Academy segment at the conclusion of the 20145 school year for reasons of economy budgetary considerations restructuring of program components in Monroe Township School District and for other good cause the interim superintendent and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all steps necessary to implement this action of the Board of Education including but not limited to the provisions the provisions of notice to be uh to all affected

314individuals as soon as possible and I'm sorry but here is a copy of that if you didn't so moved second what's this Tom noin second roll call Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman quit absent Mr seski I abstained thank you sir Mr Mayo no Mr calman yes Mrs kpano no Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr rybec yes Mr Po yes Mr board president motion to dissolve passes okay okay uh the minutes of the meeting of December the 10th public Board of Education meeting those minutes I move that we approve them are there any corrections so moved second um Doug Koy move them Michelle armeno second yes thank you all in favor I Iain Mayo obain thank you I have to myself Doug yes did you take a um a roll call for the votes on

315approval of minutes that's doing right now yes I wanted to what we is there a correction no I I are we voting on this now yes we're we're voting on the approval of the minutes okay we we're going to vote on it yes okay motion made by Mr Po second by Miss armeno to approve the minutes of the public board meeting December 10th 2014 Mr Mayo abstains all in favor I opposed abstention was Mr de Mayo noted okay any recusals please speak up down here I'm abstaining um I'm sorry I out you're saying for the minutes of December 10th 2014 thank you sir okay I I move that we approve the minutes of the closed session meeting of December 10th 2014 do I hear a second second Mr noin all in favor I opposed exensions

316abstain Jill abstain abstain abstain Jill Ryback I'm sorry Jill Jill Deo Luke Hoffman and Ryback Steve ryack okay tarious ready to go again okay I move that we accept the minutes of the public Board of Education organization meeting of January 5th 2015 Mr noin second Mr moved by Mr Po second by Mr noin all in favor I opposed abstentions recusal pass okay uh we will now hear any committee reports do any committees have a report Mr Ryback yeah well the um Personnel committee actually met twice I was a little overlapping I'll be brief February 18th um Mr ventrello discussed the process for the uh principal selection at mil Lake we talked about the postings there was committee consisting of three Elementary principles two teachers nonm Lake two parents the Personnel committee was in agreement with

317that um also we approved U or recommended job description uh changes for the superintendent um that's in the agenda so I I won't have to State it it's all um laid out in in today's agenda um also in the discussion on the the superintendent's communicating information with the community which we certainly want to do more of the committee discussed the possibility of Reviving The School Story something that was a mailing that was sent out to each household and uh we' want we'd like to have it investigated I'm not sure which committee that would go before but um I think we we'd like to see that go before that committee and some uh investigation start to if that's a possibility would that be uh uh finance committee or uh which committee would that go before or

318uh policy uh who's in charge of the cor committee yeah somebody's not here my neighbor come under that on the communication curriculum okay uh look into that stage okay and uh then finally on March 9th we met the um the committee unanimously approved the hiring of 14 power Professionals for the oak tree school as per the superintendent's recommendation to help alleviate the high class size of 28 in grade one the pars will be used for seven classes one for am and a different power for PM this will avoid having to pay benefits these positions will be terminated at the end of this school year we've received the resignation of the head football coach for the high school the current one is taking a position at seille will be looking for a replacement and finally uh

319this is concerning the mil Lake uh principal position we received 50 applications for principal of mil Lake 16 candidates will be interviewed a recommendation was made to ask each candidate to develop a writing sample as part of the interview process interviewing will begin on Friday although the panel will be interviewing Mr ventrell will be making the final decision ultimately the finalist will uh meet with the Board of Education thank you any other committee report M kovich um we had a bg& te meeting this past Monday March 9th um there was only one item on the agenda which was the enrollment study and the redistricting study and since we had the presentation already this this evening I'm not going to go into it again um we also had three finance committee meetings this past month uh

320the first one was held on Wednesday February 18th the purpose of the meeting was to discuss MEA Mecca and we already know where that one went um the second finance committee meeting was a closed meeting held on February 25th to dis conduct two residency hearings the first hearing was an appeal of a student by the student's mother from the interim superintendent of school's preliminary notice of ineligibility with respect to the entitlement of the student to attend school in Monroe Township based on residency the committee found the weight of the evidence supports the reming that the student is not domiciled in Monroe Township and is recommending a discussion by the full board in close session this evening this the second hearing was to consider the appeal of three students by their mother from the intern superintendent

321of school's preliminary notice of ineligibility with respect to the entitlement of the students to attend school in Monroe Township based on residency the at the conclusion of that second hearing the finance committee requested to continue the hearing for the purpose of receiving additional documentary evidence from the administration as the committee wished to receive more information The District truancy officer was directed to conduct an additional investigation for the purpose of confirming residency the parent has disenrolled her children from the Monro Township School District and their last day of school in our system will be tomorrow and our third finance committee meeting was held on Monday March 2nd for the discussion on the preliminary budget and we also had that um um tonight so I'm not going to go back into that again we've already discussed it

322and that concludes my two reports Mr armeno yes uh the policy we've only had one policy committee so far this year it seems that the snow has prevented us from from all the others uh so on February 23rd we finally had a policy committee meeting uh the meetings of the policy committee are open to the public public however since there is not a quorum of the board membership present it is a committee meeting for uh and no uh full board meeting and there is no public forum but the public is invited to um listen uh we went through several policies uh most of them were mandated uh you can see that on your agenda we did have um operational policies Personnel records uh public records and Student Records I would encourage all the parents to

323take a look at the public records and the mandated policy regarding that um there was one uh operational po policy public participation in board meetings uh which would be appr propo for this evening um the full committee except for me I must say um was in agreement with the changes I would like to just make a note of the changes to that um on the policy uh Z excuse me I have it here um policy 0167 the change is that a participant may speak no participant may speak more than once at each public forum on the same topic at the same me meeting that was agreed to by a majority of the committee however I disagree with that so um even as chairperson I feel that I should go with the majority because that's how

324the committee works but I do have a problem with that based on the open public my interpretation of the open public meetings act um but I want to be clear that it's number three and it says that no participant may speak more than once at each public form and there may be more than one public form in a meeting and um but my issue is that any subject should be addressed to the board uh from the public that's what we have the public meetings for that's my um personal position and I also have a little bit of a disagreement with number five where it says the presiding officer May interrupt warn terminate a participant statement when the statement is too lengthy abusive obscene or irrelevant I certainly don't believe in IR uh irreverence or um

325inappropriate or abusive speech however I think that um irrelevant is a subjective position and I think every person even when they're displeased with me should be able to speak uh to the board so that's my report there I would again encourage everybody to go through the policies thank you any other committee reports okay at this time we will hear a report from our superintendent Mr villo Mr President is recommended that the members of the mon t board of education approve board action items uh number a through J some move second okay roll call vote Mr and and before we do that just to let you know that I just would like to point out for letter F I gave you a second uh copy and that is the draft you'll see it says school calendar

326for next year it says draft on the left hand side I give you two calendars one says draft one's got a school bus on it look at the one that says draft just want to let you know is the fact that it it has four days four snow days on that calendar is there a First and a second on board action items a through J yes l l and myself any any questions for Mr ventrillo and if we can before we do add as a approval look at please letter J look at please letter J I just want to let you know is that that's the calendar that has the school bus on it and please turn the uh the page to uh turn it so this way you're on the back side where it

327says April I'm making a recommendation this evening Mr President members of the Board of Education uh we have to make up a snow day as we have to make up that snow day it had been considered as far as Friday April the 3rd if you'll take a look at the count calendar on the back of that uh sheet you'll see Friday the 3D but to the fact that that day is also good Friday it also is the beginning of Passover it also is a state holiday Mr ventrol I'm sorry could you speak into the mic I can't hear you absolutely thank sure can again as I'm asking the board of education then is that we have to make up a snow day and I've given you a calendar and that calendar is the one that

328has the just want to make sure that we're looking at the right one it has the school bus on it and if you turn that calendar over you'll see Friday the 3rd April the 3 we have to make up a snow day yes I it thank you and as I said we were considering that Friday the April the 3D that is also good Friday the beginning of Passover and a number of our staff and obviously parents want to observe that as a religious holiday with that said is that my recommendation is to go to the 10th Friday the 10th would be a full day of school it is during the spring break but we do have to make up that snow day there are no other days to be considered we can't do it at

329the end of the year we already have graduation in place Kathy are we doing board action items that's what he said yes did we do Personnel it we'll do that next okay cuz I thought I thought it might have been me I know it's late okay any other discussion or questions for Mr vento on board action items a through J wait a minute a through J yes board board action items a not Personnel action items so I'm sorry so the 10th is going to be a day of school yes that is correct J and the third's only going to be a half day no the third is off is it a half day or it's off third is off third is Off full it is Good Friday Also Passover begins and it's a state holiday

330okay roll call please okay this is board action items a through J first by Mr calman second by Miss gin Miss armeno and if we're talking about uh I uh with the bylaws policies and regulations I vote Yes for all except um B 167 so noted else is yes Mr Braverman absent Mr zareski yes Mr Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs colano yes Mr noin uh yes except for policy uh Bravo 167 Mr proso Yes except for Bravo 127 16 Mr R 167 sorry yes Mr P yes Mr board president board action items a through J passes Personnel items yes Personnel items Mr President president has recommended that the members of the let me go through first no I'm going backwards now is that right that's Mr President is recommended that the members of the

331mon Township Board of Education approve personal items a through W so moved second I second by luk thank you any discussion or questions roll call vote Please Mr many yes Mr braverman's absent still Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano Mr noin Mr proso Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president Personnel items a through W passes Mr ventrell does that complete your report yes it does Mr Gorski Mr P may I take a proceed with yours thank you sir um pursuant to the conversation that started before about refunding previously the board refunded the 2002 series bonds and saved 1,500,000 that refunding we also had an opportunity to run refund the 2003 series which saved $2,569 this week we priced bonds for the refunding of the 06 and the

332' 08 series on last Monday because of the timing and the and the very fortunate circumstances of the pricing occurring on Monday the Board of Education saved $ 3,898 787 on this refunding for the 2006 and the 2008 series had the board waited till Tuesday market conditions fell apart and we would not have been able to refund the 2008 so as required report of the board secretary as to the award of the bonds in accordance with the provisions of the school bond law njsa 18a 24-1 and the resolution adopted by the Monro Township Board of Education in the county of middlex New Jersey the board on February 11th 2015 relating to the sale of the school district funding bond series 2015 of the board I hereby report to the board the results of the sale

333as of said bonds as follows as delineated in the report handed out earlier and schedule a uh there there's no motion that's required that's just a divulgence of the report Mr board president and members of the mon Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through e be approved by consent roll call so move second Doug Po and Tom noin um any questions any questions about that no okay roll call Mr Mino yes Mr thank you Mr Gorski for that thank you I'm still absent Mr ESI yes Mr Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kpano Mr nosy Mr proso nice job Michael yes thank you sir M Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president uh board action items a through e passes that concludes my report thank you very much

334can you talk faster okay we uh will now hear any other board business anyone want to bring up any other board business doc can I just like to make a comment um this Tuesday I had the pleasure of um going to the girls basketball game and um unfortunately the results weren't as we all hope but uh we were all so proud of them and their coaches and and I think we have to really shout out uh you know go Falcons to them because they they really deserved it the the sportsmanship on both sides was terrific and uh um we have every reason to be so proud of them it is always next year okay thank you um I do have a statement uh that I would like to make in terms of my report I

335would like to commend our administrators for the relatively smooth Park assessments that are occurring this month the board especially appreciates the preparation and support rendered by our technology staff and the classroom teachers who are helping the students adjust to the new style of testing former Governor Tom Kane who also served as president of Drew University had a piece in the March 8th issue of the Star Ledger in entitle demanding more for students I would like to share with you some excerpts from that article while mentioning the fact that New Jersey students consistently outperform others on standardized tests he goes on to say we cannot relax or feel comfortable our children deserve better in this state and in this country we must discover our weaknesses and do what is necessary to fix them our future depends

336upon it he then went on to say park is fully aligned with New Jersey's AC mic standards Parks questions are designed by Educators not bureaucrats 30 teachers review every test item for fairness and efficacy now they can truly assess students grasp of our state's academic standards rather than just memorizing facts why would any parent want to opt out of that report and that are those are the quotes from uh former Governor kan's article my own personal view based on more than 40 years in education is that the role roll out of the park was accompanied by too much political noise teachers faced with having part of their annual evaluation based on the outcome of the test in many instances became anxious and transferred that anxiety to our students parents became confused from all the media

337hype which never accomp accompanied the implementation of Statewide testing in the past some saw the results of the test as threatening to their child instead of an opportunity for the school to determine how well our kids are learning what the standards call for schools cannot remain what they were when those parents were in school we need to give time for the schools to identify what adjustments may be needed time to identify how to improve the test which are not perfect without most of our students participating in these tests we will not be able to do that the results of these tests should not be viewed as a Scarlet Letter they are one more measure but not the only measure of a child's progress on a different note the board appreciates the work of our Administration

338and especially its business office and achieving a doublea minus Bond rating which is the highest attainable Bond rating for a school district Mr Gorski reported that over $60 million in bonds will be refunded which will result in a savings of approximately $3.9 million over the life of the bonds this saving works out to be about $250,000 per year fortunately the pricing of the bonds as Mr Gorski mentioned earlier occurred one day before uh there was a significant increase in bond yields uh at this time I will read the resolution to go into closed session wait I'd like to say something can I say something yes okay in response to your talk about the park as a parent who is watched the formation of the park from the get-go if this test was so important to

339the state then they should have funded it and we have spent millions of dollars on this test where that money could have gone directly to the education of our students so as a person as a board member I have to support the park as a parent I think it's a disgrace what this state has done to our districts regarding the funding of the park meski un unofficially I was asked by SE and sleary to get a number of students that opted out of park from our district here so Mr V if you can when the park testing is over just give me a doesn't have to be the exact number but roundabout number on how many students opted out in our district also I'd like to extend a little invitation to all board members about

340the middle sex County board meetings that we have our next one is until May 20th I believe and I am also entertaining any thoughts on any training or any topics that you'd like to possibly have in the upcoming years and also as a member of the legislative committee for New Jersey school boards if you have any questions or topics or any statements you'd like me to put across a legislative committee please email me those questions I'll try to have an answer for you thank you anyone else no Satur okay then be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session and Accord with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 to discuss the following subjects to discuss student residency matters

341to discuss a student matter and then to hear the superintendent's report on harassment intimidation and bullying this this discussion conducted in Clos session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exist uh how much we have a first and a first by Mr presio second by Mr armeno um less than five minutes less than five minutes is correct okay so we anticipate between travel time and getting back here at 10 minutes uh we have a first and a second all in favor I I opposed extensions okay let's go to it uh at this time we will reconvene the board meeting and uh open the floor to the second public forum is there anyone who wants to speak you're kidding I think they I don't know I just

342leave them here Thomas Petru it's hene wait say your name Thomas patru it's h shene slowly Thomas P Thomas petritz cherine all right so just to clarify you guys took back April 10th for the snow day yes ain't nobody going to come to that there's there I I doubt that anybody is because it's the last Friday of the spring break I don't think anybody's going to come to that so I don't know you might you guys might have to do another thing at the next board meeting just to redo that so thank you Tom yeah no problem nobody's coming to school but don't tell anybody I'll be a nice hi Patty Lang 74 McFarland Circle um I'm here again to address the park I must say I'm very disappointed by your comments Mr board president

343the park is not a good test it was not done by teachers I had one of a very well-respected high school student who was here tonight come up to me and explain to me how his AP class has met for no more than than 30 minutes in the last two weeks and he said to me Mrs Lang how am I going to pass my AP test and I put that question to you how are these children going to pass the AP test which you're now going to put on us as parents to pay for by the way thank you so how are they going to pass them when they're not having their AP classes because their class time has been taken up with Park testing today North Carolina an entire State voted to remove themselves

344from the common Corp and park what is wrong with New Jersey I put it upon you again I asked you at the last Board of Ed meeting stand up for us as your parents stand up for your teachers stand up for your students and say enough of this high stakes testings does not make better schools and by the way I have two master degree in special education a bachelor's in special education and before being knocked down by Two Strokes I was a special educator in ldtc I know what good teaching is good teaching is inspiring good teaching is engaging it is not teaching to attest and our teachers in this District have spent months prepping these students to pass the park test we have had children who have come home and tears we are still

345getting refusal letters every day aren't we Mr V cuz the parents have had enough I'm asking you we voted you in you might have signed a hypocritical oath with God himself but we voted you in take a stand for us stand with the other districts in this state and say enough of this we trust our teachers we trust them to teach our children that's why I moved here to Monroe because we have great teachers we have great administrators Park test is ruining education for everybody and you're destroying a whole generation of kids with this testing they were in front of the state senate today and hesie himself lied to people we have been lied to left and right about what park testing is 95% people don't te take the test we're going to lose Federal

346funding we don't get Federal funding so don't lie to us anymore we know what the fact are so please stop lying to us take a stand with us thank you for your comment any other comments the next scheduled Board of Education meeting will be Wednesday April 15th at 7M here at the high school I move that we adjourn the present meeting second is there a second yes okay all in favor I I I like to stay longer okay passes thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.