CorpusRecord 132940

Monroe Township Board of Education 11.19.14 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
13,357 words · about 75 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001I had I had my stuff here so thank good evening the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance IED to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for it stands nation under God indivisible liy and justice for all um we have a roll call Mr Gorski miss antelis miss armeno here Mr Braverman here Mr Chella here Mr calman here Mrs kapano here Mr Lin here Mr Po here Mr proso here Mr zareski here Adam board president you have airum this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place there

002of posted November 14th 2014 one at all schools two home news Triune three cranberry press and for filed with the clerk of the municipality and before we move further on with the agenda I just like to on behalf of the Board of Education like to congratulate our newly elected Board of Education members Miss Jill Deo I don't know if Jill is here or not and Mr Steven Ryback we look forward to your joining up board in January and for a good year so at this time we will go to our student board members reports students good evening everyone um just to start off tonight mil Lake School recently conducted a week of respect within their school and they thought the week was very productive and children learned how to treat others with kindness and respect

003during the school day they learned what's unkind and how not to act like a bully to other students and the principal was very pleased with the climate at mil Lake during during the week um at the high school select Deca members will be attending a leadership and Entrepreneurship conference in Washington DC this weekend and they will attend workshops and compete in real life business situations um MTH Deca is also proud to say that they have raised $3,000 to date for the Wounded Warrior Project and still are going to continue to fund raise um and also Deca is hosting a hypnotist show on Monday the 24th at 7:00 at the high school's Performing Arts Center and all the community is encouraged to come out and enjoy the great show and all the proceeds are going to

004benefit the seeing I Inc which is hosted out of Morristown New Jersey um mon Township High School's own Mikey Nichols was recently on the hit Sports Talk Show Boomer and carton so if you'd like to go online and check that out he was very inspirational and well received and then the mon Township High School Footlights Club will be hosting a cabaret night including great songs from Broadway on December 11th at 7:00 p.m. in the high school Commons tickets are $5 and the community is encouraged to come out and enjoy the great show he doesn't know what it is thank you um the monor tant high school's National Honor Society recently uh included a Thanksgiving food drive uh with the rise food banks of New Jersey uh the drama club had also recently put on a

005showcase as a fundraiser event um as well first marking period has recently ended for students and finally at the last meeting uh I had mentioned the mths uh fbl's haunted high school fundraiser um in which the mths future Business Leaders of America in conjunction with uh some of the other school clubs organize an event um for the younger children in the district to benefit the mam Mar Breast Cancer Foundation and I'm happy to report that we have raised just over uh $1,400 in support of breast cancer awareness month and the intent is to continue the event again next year thank you very good um before we move on with the agenda I I think maybe the public has noticed we have a new face at the table today and I'm sorry that I forgot to

006introduce you um Miss Dr Dory alvid who is our new super assistant superintendent of schools we're very pleased to have her in place and um we're glad to have you here thank you congratulations thank you yes um student recognition essay contest uh that administrator is not here tonight so if we can just postpone that okay no problem so then we will go to the presentation of the 2013 20104 comprehensive annual financial report Mr Gorski thank you madam board president um I'd like to turn over to Mr jary stowit CPA from Samuel kleining company who is engaged by the board to be the independent auditor as required by Statute Mr stanitz thank you uh Michael um members of the board uh and the members of the public um here tonight to uh present to the board

007and the public the uh annual comprehensive financial report of the district's operations for the fiscal year end June 30th 2014 this is an annual document it's an annual event however I don't look at as just being here for one or two months in the fall to audit the records I I view and I was trained as an auditor that an audit is a yearr round uh event it's important to be available to the client to uh help them through any problems or to discuss any potential concerns that they have that may have audit impact because of a decision they may or may not make so um we actually Ed this audit actually a year ago when we came in and we audited the uh the uh application for state school aid as well as the

008free and reduced applications and the uh the special education uh the IEPs so we we kind of start off early on in the process and um do a rather extensive audit maybe more so than our competitors I'm I'm not here to to boast or anything but I just was trained from an old practitioner that you know trained to go over and above what what needed to be done uh and and sort of exceed the minimum standards um and that that's actually my choice um the other thing that we do during the year is we do testing part the root word of audit is is sample audition so we test a lot of uh transactions um in the area of payroll we we um we run a sample from the beginning of the year to the

009end of the year we select certain transactions and it's not certain ones it's it's statistically determined we can't discriminate if that number pops up we have to test that item so we will test payroll for the fact that a is the payroll properly authorized and that that means by the board or is it in accordance with the contract the Union contract or the bargaining contracts uh we test to make sure the withh Holdings are proper we test to see especially in in this uh era the that the health benefits withh Holdings are proper we make sure that the um that the payroll taxes are paid timely we also want to know though that our payroll taxes are actually wired into the uh to the government both governments the state and the federal and that th

010those wire transactions just so you know to keep you informed is th those transactions are actually looked at by two sets of eyes no one has unilateral authority over that in this District so we we test in the area payroll we test also to make sure that the payroll taxes are paid not that they're paid but they're also paid timely okay uh the government the federal government is not so forgiving anymore about being a little tardy or a little late so we we we check in that area too we also will run not only our normal statistical sample but we will run what we call a uh a block sample or a random sample of a halfhazard sample we'll just pick a certain payroll and look at the items there regardless rather regardless of U

011of whether it's a sample or not we're just trying to spot check things we'll do that for base pay for employees it's over and above what we normally do we do that for part timers and overtimers there's a lot in this District of extra compensation that goes through to the teachers Andor the um the custodial maintenance department it's it's extra pay it's okay and it's it's got to be properly documented and it is there's various levels of approvals that it goes through before it hits the payroll department who then just pays it and they are I think pumping out 20 pays a year of about 1,00 paychecks which is is pretty heavy action um and and they do a pretty good job job and I want to compliment and thank them for that and and

012that leads to um you know the fact that we have you know a good cfra a good opinion here one of the other things we do is we test expenditures um again we run a sample from July 1 to June 30th okay but the audit just doesn't end at June 30th we look at at at expenditures and in from July 1 of the subsequent year right to the date that we issue the report okay to make sure that there's nothing that's done that's improper that should have been thrown back to the prior year okay so we that's what we look for so the bills here in in this District are cut off properly and that's of major importance because uh Mr gorski's office provides the board with financial information you need to have a comfort

013level that when you're looking at something you know that a it's it's cut off properly that you're getting one year is worth of bills to look at not two or not 14 months when it should only be charged 12 months of either electric or health benefits or gas or even legal which is actually is no more but um so we look at that stuff what else we look at is uh we look to see that all the documentation was proper and to make sure that everything is supported by an invoice we also make sure it was properly approved by the internal internal management that no one's buying something and then saying here guys uh pay it now well we can't have that okay that's not supposed to be the other thing that we have too

014is that we're in compliance with the public school contracts law we do a rather extensive test and engage a lot of uh individuals within the district in terms of inquiring from them okay okay well we bought this we bought this where's the documentation where's the quotes where's the bids we're fortunate in New Jersey to have some other school districts that that have um created a a buying Co-op uh whereby they they group several school districts together uh in fact it's the middle sex Regional Services Commission what they do is they they'll they'll they'll group all the needs of bunch of districts for certain things it might be pencils it might be paper it might be you know lime or whatever and they go to bid they'll they'll determine how much they need to meet their

015support group and they'll bid it so although we're not bidding it someone else is okay and we're and I believe one of the items that's in the mdna is that there there was a significant savings by using these co-ops we could bid it on our own but by doing that that increases the burden on the administration to to write specifications and legal notices and legal review and all that stuff so having these co-ops was a good thing so so we're in compliance with the public school contracts law we're in compliance with proper documentation and we're in compliance with cutting the expenditures off properly but also too we will run a statistical sample but we will also run samples that are based on dollar levels you know we'll look at every bill over x amount of

016dollars uh we'll also just may grab one entire months bills and and flip through them and make sure that everything looks pretty good it's not as extensive as our samp because when we do our samples both for payroll and for expenditures we have these they're called attributes and it's a it's you know other did is this on file is this here is this here it's a series of attributes that we test and and our testing has revealed really no problems um no errors um that's been the case here I believe the the finance office does a pretty good job um in in making sure that everything flows through properly um no one wants to lose their job for making a silly mistake or missing or not having a certain piece of paper on file um

017so basically yeah we we go and we do I think a rather extensive job on reviewing uh both payroll as well as expenditures um in this town too obviously there's payroll there's expenditures and there's revenue and the bulk of your revenue is quite easily auditable it's tax levy it's state aid and it's it's grants um very easy to audit uh we do uh also look at your grants in terms of your you have Title One title two Ida you don't have a lot of it compared to most places but we do look at to make sure that you're in compliance with the with the accounting requirements for those grants you also run a food service fund um which is sort of heavily regulated by the government where you get reimbursements uh based on meals free

018meals reduced meals and paid meals um we monitor and we look at your food service uh vendor we look at their bills um and we look at their payroll we do little tests on that they're they're not our employees but we take a look at it anyway to make sure that we're not getting build unfairly for anything um and and I think that that whole situation is a very nice situation there it it's a good thing not having to worry about running a food service operation on your own you have professional help there so we found that to be a very good result as well that's a pretty big operation so uh um we also look at Student Activities funds uh we don't do as extensive a job as you might think on those we

019rely that it's being audited internally before it gets to us in the auditing profession and the accounting profession and even in large corporations a system is supposed to be in place within a district or company that it can catch an error before it gets to the auditor if an error slips through to the auditor then you have a different problem it's probably a bigger problem we did not have any of those problems otherwise we would be talking about this smaller document which I'll get into there would be comments in there U so as a result of all of our testing all of our inquiry the time we spent here the time we spent down in that basement running up and down the steps bothering people asking questions um I get a good workout in there

020too uh we we ended up with um two documents one is the cafra which is is actually a joint venture between my firm and the business office where in they actually present us with the financial records for audit our job is to audit them and because of the accounting requirements we assemble them and we we create them and put them into accounting format that's to be used not only by the board but people in Trenton and even people on Wall Street who are looking and evaluating at the town of Monroe okay they're they're looking at certain things so we kind of put that into into usable format it's also in compliance with the um accounting regulations of the Department of Education which says we are to use governmental Accounting Standards which is a nationally recognized

021organization created by the accounting industry to to regulate um accounting requirements uh there's the governmental Accounting Standards Board for government agencies and then there's the Financial Accounting Standards Board for commercial entities and and private companies so basically what I I just wanted to do was highlight a couple things in this larger document and for the record um prior to issuing this report okay um we had a Dennis will vouch for this a rather extensive uh exit conference uh with myself my staff Mr Gorski and Mr ventrello to discuss the audit prior to issuing it it's an opportunity to review a draft of the report before it's get released because a lot of this information in here is actually that of the district okay and then it's also a chance for management which is them to

022refute any comments Andor recommendations that we have okay so basically this document contains a lot of financial information but I just wanted to highlight some of the stuff that we you know are involved heavily in the first of which is the independent auditor opinion which starts on page eight and basically what it says is in more technical terms than I describe what we do is uh We've audited the financial statements of the governmental funds of this school district okay and the business type funds which is the Food Service fund and the child care initiative fund management which is Mr Gorski and his staff is responsible to prepare and present the financial statements for audit okay our responsibility is to give an opinion on those they kind of broken this out where they have these paragraphs

023broken out where it makes a little more sense than it used to they they used to have this whole opinion bunched into one document and you can never really comprehend it now they're breaking it out so so management presents us with the financials our responsibility is to audit them and in the middle of page 10 is where we give our opinion and the opinion is that the financial statements referred to above present fairly in all material respects the respective financial position of the governmental activities business activities and each major fund and aggregate remaining funds of the board of education for the year ended June 30th of 2014 um that 50 or 60w paragraph there is a result of many many hours on our part however a lot more hours internally of the payroll department uh

024the the accounts payable department uh it involves all the administrators who are responsible for requisitioning goods and services uh including not only people on the education side but people on the construction side uh like a a Jerry tag um we were we were happy with the results from our our testing as to some of the physical plant uh improvements that are done and repairs and all that that that is quite well monitored in terms of of the getting the best pricing um we're required to I mean we can't just go on higher we we have a bid threshold of $36,000 here so any project greater than 36,000 needs to be bid unless it's available through one of the buying co-ops or through the state contract method otherwise it has to go to bit we're in

025compliance with that as I've stated so we have a what's called an unmodified opinion it used to be called a unqualified and then they it was a clean opinion okay but now it's called unmodified it all means the same thing it's unmodified because there's no deviations from what it should be okay it's all presented fairly it's all in this document here presented hopefully not too not too confusing not too detailed but just enough to get a flavor for how a school district operates and how this particular District ended up during the fiscal year um there's other stuff other information in here that is actually included in the management discussion and Analysis thanks to Enron we're required to add these 10 pages of information and um but they do have information about the operation of the

026district some of it's aad Overkill um we're required to convert your basic financial statements to that of a corporate model we add into appreciation and acrs for sick pay and acrs for interest which your basic financials don't really have that we'll get to that as well the other um again there's a financial statement in here on page 25 uh which does that conversion to look like more of a corporate model um I I don't spend a lot of time on it because a corpor a government entity can't really be a corporation I mean you could take a business-like approach but it can't be a corporation we're not here to measure profit or to produce profit for our shareholders we're here to provide a service than question yes you mentioned Enon does sarban Oxley apply to

027no doesn't apply to government entities it's shareholder based okay and although maybe all your taxpayers are in effect shareholders it's that's based on providing shareholders information that are in in accordance with the Security and Exchange Commission which I don't do any of that work thank God okay the other uh page I want to go to within this document um is and prior to getting to the bigger fund is exhibit B5 which is page 32 you're you're running two types of business uh entities within this district one is the Food Service fund which has revenues of around $2.4 million and expenses for about the same and you know you had a $446,000 um so-called profit except I look at that as as as a Break Even situation you you've met the requirement you've provided meals for

028the kids and you made a few bucks but however in the end you know another year you could have a little bit of a loss okay so you you do have some fund balance that's accumulate there and but for the record that fund balance can only be used in this food service fund it cannot be transferred to the general fund for tax relief um that's specific to Food Service because it's it's heavily government fund it and they don't really want you profiting off of that the other fund is the child care initiative which in the prior year had experienced probably what would be called a startup type of a loss it has you know 390,000 of Revenue 316,000 of operating expenses and it ended up with a $75,000 profit which further reduced its deficit position

029from a deficit of 215,000 to $139,000 so in time that hopefully will and I believe it will turn around but right now now that's where it stands as of June 30th of 14 which is really what I'm actually engaged to opinion on that after this exhibit here on page 35 starting with 33 it there's I don't know there there's notes to financial statement that describe the uh accounting requirements that school districts are required to follow probably every school district in the country with the exception of one state that that doesn't mandate gby follows the same if you were to pull a city of San Diego or Philadelphia or poral they would have the same type of financial statement basically all it describes is the various accounting mechanisms and various accounting requirements that we we have

030to follow in the district it's exciting reading for a lot of people but it you know your your bottom line here is that you uh have followed the accounting and auditing requirements of the profession as well as the the state department of education's requirements for various items there it's a lot of information it's a lot to go through in one night um I I want to get you to page 75 and if you turn the document sideways you're Ty this yes real no um the general fund is the main operating fund of the district and obviously you have a budget that goes through a rather extensive preparation process and again that's also a year- round process as as we know we're not involved in that I just know that in the districts I work in

031the budget is a year round function and basically you have you know your revenues if you look at the actual column uh you'll see that's pretty much um you know you've met all you seem to have met your obviously your tax levy you've met that requirement you you have tuition Revenue uh from Jamesburg you have transportation fees also from Jamesburg you have miscellaneous revenues then below that you have your state AIDS okay and there's a couple State AIDS at the bottom there they're called on behalf payments million 6 2.6 million and 2.9 Million those are funds that are paid by the Department of Education on behalf of the district to the division of pension and treasury they don't go through our books but it's there as an information piece to show show the district okay

032that look it's not only costing you you know 94 million there's also an additional 6 million that is paid on your behalf on behalf of your employees on behalf dist to the pension board okay it's not mythical Revenue those are real numbers okay but they just don't come through our books we have the revenue and back in the further back in the document we also show the expense it's basically a wash but it's for information purposes lets you know it grosses up like the the the real cost of the district runs about $6 million more than when goes through the books so you have your various um budget to actual you have no overe expenditures which is desired and a good thing um and if we could get to page 855 we we are showing

033on page 85 that we started the fiscal year with $ 10,963 th000 and as a result of our operations we um experienced a we don't call a loss it's called a excess of expenditures over revenues of $212,000 okay and down below you'll see uh on the page to the right underneath the actual column recapitulation of fund balance okay it's not that we have $1,750,000 free and clear it's actually broken down into components $25,000 is incumbrances reserve for excess Surplus which was the result of the 201314 school year that will be earmarked for the 1516 school year is 3.8 million our capital reserve which is the Minimus uh is $2,000 our excess Surplus that was a result of the 1213 fiscal year that's a mandatory Revenue item in the 1415 school year which we're in is

0344.9 million and the 2% amount that we're allowed to keep Otherwise Known previously known as the free balance is 1.8 million okay so there's $1,750,000 but probably 8 million of it Mike approximately is sp is spoken for okay so we're really our free balance is really about a million 8 and we keep that that's the statutory um maximum we're allowed to keep it can be lower if you don't have it it could be lower but if if that was lower then you wouldn't have the excess Surplus either so as a result of our operations here we end up the year at $1,750,000 the the rest of the book um has a lot of statistical information about the operation of the district it has statistical information about the town rable information debt capacity of the district

035allocated debt from the county allocated debt from the municipality itself all that information is contained in the back section here it has information about your largest taxpayers um I it's pretty amazing that Costco has $150 million rable here uh a warehouse so tell me what page you're on please that is Page 110 and just may I does the public have any copy of this at all Madam I was going to address that afterwards it would be cost inefficient to put out the copy of this comprehensive very comprehensive annual financial report but uh when I was going to say a few words later I was going to suggest that if any members of the public would like either the comprehensive annual financial report or the smaller management report on a administrative findings contact me and I'll

036be happy to email you either one or both so that there's we're required to present our top 10 taxpayers again that's not that's all un audited we we merely assemble this together from information provided by the tax assessor uh and again people on Wall Street look at this information if you're ever going out for financings or if the town is looking to get raided and other statistical information that is is is it's quite voluminous but it all it all points towards telling someone about the school district without actually having to come here and look around it it it does it does provide a lot of information um and that is the uh sort of the end of my presentation on the thicker of the two documents um again inside this document is an opinion that

037we would not have gotten to had we not gotten successful results from our audit our audit testing um the other document is the thinner of the two actually has my firm's letterhead on it is my presentation to the board uh some districts they actually produce this document most districts aren't capable of of doing it but because you really have to know what you're doing but uh you have to be in it every day you know to know all the technicalities um this other this other document talks about the compliance with what we had talked about previously was with bill paying requirements with public contracts requirements with payroll requirements payroll withholding requirements Grant requirements purchasing laws the Food Service it everything that I verbalized is sort of written in this document here and there is in

038order for something to become a comment with a recommendation it it would have to be something that would rise to the level where it was a problem within the whole bill paying or payroll cycle the whole process of that but again we did not have that it that that hasn't happened the staff here does a pretty good job in in processing the purchasing as well as payroll so and we I do want to thank them they they do work very hard and they are concerned during the audit process that that that they're doing correctly and you have a you know a pretty experienced payroll Department which uh keeps things moving along and it also helps the audit move along but you know every now and then we will get a new employee our employee who

039will say okay go do the payroll and they they they do a quite extensive uh review of it so there's other information here about your meals that were served there's information in here about how the 2% calculation Works 2% calculation is based on your expenditures and that's what you're allowed to keep that is actually on page 18 and 19 and it's also file electronically I mean we we do this document but uh there's also been an electronic version of this filed through the state through What's called the odd suum and that's the information they use they download that into the um into the budget document and they rely on that for comparative information and for statistical information that's like a key document that has been filed so um and again in the end there's no

040there's no recommendations and we have an unmodified clean opinion and I think Michael wants to address uh some thank you very much Mr stankowitz to you and your firm for all the extensive testing and work that you've done uh it's we very much appreciate your cooperation throughout the year always being there if we have any need to uh raise an issue about anything and and your cooperation it's always appreciated um we're not here tonight to talk about um the Proficiency in accounting or auditing uh we have much more pressing issues to get to but if you'd indulge me I'd just like to take a few brief minutes and go through some of the highlights of the cafer briefly um to highlight some of the more significant issues um that occurred during the year financially again

041this is called the comprehensive annual financial report if anybody wishes send me an email and I could send you this in PDF format it's a very voluminous document um it's very hard to read even though the state has tried to simplify it I'll admit but I'll be happy to answer any questions um or anything you may have and this is called the Management's report on administrative findings I could send you that also as a PDF or both this document is prepared by management with the exception of the auditor's independent report on pages 9 through 11 and in this independent Auditors report as Mr stanitz has said um he has offered an opinion that the financial statements are in in compliance with generally accepted accounting um standards are liable and are free from material misstatement on

042page 12 is the management discussion and Analysis letter that's been required since Enron as Mr sangit pointed out some of the important fiscal highlights for the year are as follows number one for the 1314 school year state aid was flat 2,637 528 in general fund state aid which was Frozen from the prior year uh despite the District's requirement to educate many additional students the amount was further reduced by $163,000 for mandatory withholding for Debt Service on SDA funding in response to the fact that only 2% of revenues required to support the 134th school budget come from state aid a direct consequence of the insufficient and inequitable state aid funding District administration drafted legislation known as s237 and a 3478 which was support by Senator Linda Greenstein and State assemblyman Wayne D'Angelo and Dan Benson um

043these these uh legislations provide elimination of the growth limit for budgets whose population consists of greater than one-third senior citizens age 65 years or older out of respect for the senior population in town the state should remove the growth limit and afford more state aid this year would have given us $4.7 million of additional Aid those bills died in the last legislative session but they've been in reintroduced as s272 and A500 and we're going to continue to push and do everything we can um for those items this year we used $3.5 million of unexpect unexpended bond proceeds which we applied Against The Debt Service tax levy to reduce taxes this $3.5 million came from Surplus from the construction of the school which was done on time and about $8 million under budget this just about

044fully extinguishes uh the bond money um in addition to that and living within the very constrictive 2% tax levy cap we replaced the morasco center roof for a cost of $55,000 that's very difficult for districts to do within their operating budgets but we accomplished that and we've been doing it every year the district has recognized savings exceeding $1 million since entering into a Cooperative purchasing Management program since May of 2011 the district has saved 3,382 n81 in health insurance costs by negotiating out of a direct claims based coverage plan and into a prospective based coverage plan which better serves our population of of Staff as they are more senior in demographic age um and we very aggressively negotiate premiums with carriers we went to war with the insurance company this year we saved $3.4 million

045that's documented savings for the district and the taxpayers we put into the budget about $350,000 of costs to upgrade security um establish communication with administrators bus drivers police and the municipality um we're in compliance with s701 accounting regulation we entered into a rental lease agreement for 3,780 square ft of commercial leasing space for special services and that saves about 11,250 for per month compared to the prior uh portable classroom unit rental and management was faced with turning around the mecca program which had a uh um an unprofitable first year and um was very unpopular with a lot of residents what we did to um fortify that segment was to come up with an early childhood enrichment program which is an extremely profitable segment and we're very proud to say that for this year and June

046314 Mecca has turned around and has a profit of over $75,000 in addition to that it's been paying the loan back $5,000 every month and that loan is now reduced to $274,200 sources come from and all the expenditures by category and where they come where the money went to most of which 60% in Greater went on instruction what page was that Mr that's on page 18 18 of the larger document to comprehensive uh man uh audit report uh as Mr Stang noted that accounting requirements are such that you have to accountants have to footnote a lot of transactions that uh the the um figure figurative information doesn't do justice to one of them here that's Mo most noteworthy on page 73 is the tuition receivable from Jamesburg as we mentioned a meeting ago or two

047meetings ago we're very pleased to have come to a settlement with Jamesburg on the tuition reage issue and starting in the 156 budget which we are beginning preparation of now Jamesburg will be essentially overpaying tuition each month based on the higher 1415 tuition rate from the preceding year that money the end of the year will be allocated toward the aage and we expect it to pay back the $949,000 capital leases 145 m527 th000 that's on page 112 that number decreases every year and we have additional borrowing capacity if we had to go to referendum of approximately $128 million that's based on ratables in the township the unemployment rate in Monroe dropped from last year of 10.2% to 88.7% and for the Last 5 Years the percentage change in cost per pupil spending is as follows

048an increase of less than 1% a decrease of less than 1% an increase of less than 1% 1% and 2% that shows that money is being very efficiently spent and handling the very increasing numbers of hundreds of students each year one final note with an organization uh with $115 million of annual revenues many people if they went to visit that uh establishment would ask what building is that accounting and legal department in or what floor if you come to 423 Buckaloo Avenue and you walk down the hall and make a right we occupy One Wing of the building and about $115 million is is handled by or accounted by eight very dedicated people supervised by Laura Allen for many years we've now had uh very clean audits we've had perfect scores on NJ cusac and

049we're subject to regulation by many federal and state regulatory agencies and we've come up very clean on all of those instances we want to be transparent we're here to serve you and we thank you for the opportunity and I would like to thank the superintendent and the board for the resources to do so effectively okay um I believe there's information that needs to be made [Music] sorry Mr proso as chairman of the finance committee it is recommended that the me members of the Board of Education accept and approve the compreh comprehensive annual financial report and the auditor's management report on administrative findings Financial compliance and performance and hereby approve and authorize the submission of required corrective action plan to the county office indicating that there are no recommendations for fiscal year ending June 30th 2014

050second by Mr Braverman is there any comments or questions by any member of the Board of Education M AR Minal um just a couple questions about the um the food service and the child care uh any any surplus out of the Food Service I'm Mr stankowitz is that how you say your name I'm sorry okay uh that goes back into the food service because we are we have a lot of funding coming from the federal government is that right it has to stay within the fund right so whatever that money is used for it would be within that department correct okay and the the mecca or and the child care initiative it it says the expenses are about 70 uh I'm sorry revenues exceed expenses $75,000 where can that money be used I'm sorry on

051page 19 right I'm looking at it yes the $75,000 ex exceeded expenses where can that money be used or to what purpose that money has been used this particular year to to to recoup the accumulative loss that has occurred all of it uh yeah you there's a there's a there's a net deficit of $139,000 in that fund you you can't really do anything else with that fund until it becomes solvent okay okay so net deficit of 13 is that anywhere on here it's on page I'm looking at page 32 okay which is the financial statement you're you're looking at the page where it just verbalizes some information the right page page 32 is where the actual Financial statement is and then okay so I'm looking at change in net position which says 75,000 and where

052is the when you say reduced it is it 100 yeah look at the very bottom of the page oh the 139 744 it's in Brackets because it's in the negative the previous year it was 215,000 in the negative okay and to be truthful you really you know you can't do anything with that with any profits that are earned need to restore you back to a positive position there and then from there you can deal with what what you need to deal with so we can say it's profitable but it's not really finished its obligation to pay back is that is that the loan that's a fair characterization yes okay Mr presiosa what was the Surplus this year or which fund the budget from last year here well let's see we're looking at page um 85

05385 well let's see we didn't generate U we had $102 million of expenses and 102,400 th000 of revenues actually the operation lost $212,000 okay we started the fiscal year with 10,963 and ended at 10,750 so you could say we got back to square one I mean 212,000 is not a lot of money on 105 million okay so yeah we we kind of we're for that we got back to square one but you know you don't know what the future obviously will bring if you you'd be happy to get back to square one I I personally can't predict that and quite frankly that's not the function of the audit but yeah we're we're we're we're at 10,750 and of which I indicated about 8.2 is already spoken for thank you madam yes to elaborate on that

054that answer um last year the excess Surplus was just under $5 million that recycles two years later as a a mandatory requirement to the budget to reduce what you otherwise would have to raise in taxes that number dropped by about a milion $100,000 in the 1314 school year for use in the 1516 budget so in layman's terms that's going to restrict the 1516 budget by about a million dollars compared to the preceding year that's what I wanted the rest of the board to hear anyone else have thank you Jer that was oh problem Anthony Mr bin um I was on the uh finance committee meeting the other night and we obviously got into this a lot more detailed uh probably close to two hours so all my questions were answered um but the one thing

055that I did uh I did learn a lot uh is that um the dedication of our staff here uh with Mr Gorski heading it is phenomenal I didn't realize and Mr stankowitz uh had mentioned it that not all boards have the uh expertise that we have it's not uncommon to have a former teacher as a business administrator so uh we are very very fortunate to have Mr Gorski at the helm and it's shows in this un uh unmodified uh report that uh has come through and I just want to thank uh you know thank the uh Mr gorsky's department for their hard work because there there's a lot of information here and it's like just when they're done it's time to start again and uh it's pretty amazing the amount of work that goes into

056this so I would really like to thank them and um this is quite an accomplishment to to have these uh unmodified uh reports every time so I I thank you thank you Tom yeah anyone else okay at this time we'll have a roll call Mr proso yes Mr Po yes Mr notin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr cherella yes Mr Braverman yes Mrs armeno yes Mrs K Pano Madame board president motion passes thank you okay thank you and then we can move on with our agenda uh number eight public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak to the agenda please come to the microphone and give your name and address for the record okay seeing no one we will go to the approval of the minutes for the public Board of Education

057meeting of September 23rd 2014 need a motion in a second Mr Chella second second by Mr Kaufman any additions or Corrections all in favor opposed extenstions okay the approval of the minutes for the closed session meeting of September 23rd 2014 so move Mr Chella second by Mr nin uh any additions or Corrections all in favor I I opposed or extensions and that has passed at this time we'll go to committee reports are there any committees that need to report this evening Mr Kaufman sure we had a curriculum meeting this evening we discussed the the following topics under curriculum documents uh we reviewed the modern music elective for grade eight multimedia for grade seven fundamentals of literacy for grade 11 and dynamics of algebra uh additionally we heard a proposal uh by Greg berer for a

058debate club and I think some of the uh members of the committee were pretty shocked that we don't already have a debate Club but apparently we don't have a debate club uh so we're going to be looking to put that in for next year it'll be free for the first year as everybody knows and then we'll reevaluate it at the end of the cycle to see how well it does um The Debate Club really for that first year will be an internal uh debate uh where there I guess the groups will debate with each other um hopefully we'll be able to spawn some future litigators out of that it's always a good thing we world needs more litigators right um uh additionally we spoke about uh the Spanish ebook revision and connected math for grade

059six uh we're going to be bringing something before the finance committee uh shortly for request for uh uh some shuckles for the new um uh connected math grade six program so we'll talk about it when it comes before the board did you want to Dory do you want to just talk about it briefly or we'll just wait for the committee meeting your call okay wait for the committee meeting um we also uh spoke a couple of minutes about the standards based report card uh there's going to be a committee that formed to talk about that for the uh lower elementary kids I forgot what grades K through three k to three uh we also discussed an ice hockey benefit that's coming up uh as was mentioned earlier um Mickey was on WF and there was

060a uh discussion about hosting a um benefit um I think February 3 second 7 7th sorry um so there we're going to I think Mike and uh Steph is still reviewing the insurance to make sure we're all covered on that and I think we'll go well talk about moving forward on that uh the other issue that came up and I wanted to let the uh members of the committee know was uh was brought to my attention a few weeks ago that a uh a staff member had shared or um demonstrated a website uh in front of her uh students and they were um I I forgot what grade but it's the elementary level and the content of the the website was I guess can best be classified as morbid uh without going too deep uh

061so uh there was an investigation done the ad Administration took ownership of that um but as a result of that we're going to ask the administrators to put a maker Checker program in place uh certain websites that we use in the schools are pretty safe they're educationally based and you can feel feel very confident that the material there is has been vetted well other things like uh maybe YouTube or something that's basically wide open for any use um really should have second eyes on when uh being used to uh used for Education it shouldn't be just the teacher that says oh this is um appropriate material to show to students I think we really need to have um a process in place to make sure that we can track the request to use the website

062and also track the approval so that somebody can say yes I think it's a good website and so and so said it's a good website and they vetted it um and we have a paper trail so um of asked story and the administration to lead the effort in that and if you could get back to us at the next meeting to give us an update on uh what your implementation plan is and when you expect it to go live um if anybody has any questions shoot if not that's all I got any other committees the Mr Gorski you want to give uh buildings and grounds uh update yes on behalf of Amy anelis chairperson of building grounds Transportation there was a committee meeting on November 10th 2014 uh number one and most prominent item on

063the agenda was the ad hoc committee recommendation for redistricting and attendance zones Administration provided a handout titled review of recommendation for redistricting attendance zones this document provided a summary of the work by the ad hoc committee a review of demographic which is enrollment and redistricting feasibility study data and offered a recommendation from Administration to effectively rebalance class sizes by utilizing unused classrooms after much discussion amongst committee members it was recommended that Administration put forth resolutions to proceed with a redistricting study that would receive full board endorsement and authorization to proceed no no later than April 1st 2015 and to update the enrollment report from the numbers in the October 15th uh Assa report second agenda item uh Grant acceptance for Applegarth fire panel upgrades Mr T and I aggressively pursued a grant from the New

064Jersey school boards Association Insurance Group Eric North Safety grant program uh we received the grant for to the school community garden the mural would be part of a Grant application that teachers are pursuing the committee endorsed proceeding with the mural however in lie of painting directly on the brick surface removable panels were recommended by the superintendent to be used so that the mural can be better maintained and be a less permanent fixture number four baseball scoreboard donation administrated noted that the Diamond Club has offered to pay for a new scoreboard including installation at the varsity baseball stadium the approximate cost is1 14,000 Administration confirmed that there would be no public advertising on the scoreboard and number five Lawn Care contract renewal recommendation Administration recommended that the board renew the contract with Pleasant View Landscaping for

065lawn care services for the 15 16th season past performance by Pleasant View has been exceptional the administration will pursue a 0% increase to the contract base and finally classroom trailer status update Administration confirmed the removal of eight temporary classroom units at appleg Guard School and um inform the board that after June 30 of 2015 the remaining the only remaining trailers in the district at Brookside school will be removed thank you okay thank you anyone else Miss arm Mino I just have a question about the report um when when we're talking at the ad hoc committee about or we're proceeding for a redistricting study when we talk about rebalancing classroom sizes do we count the uh student teacher ratio um including or excluding if there's Paras or other assistants in the classroom how is how is

066the student teacher ratio counted that that student teacher ratio is one to one by that I mean is the fact that it's one teacher to the to the child so there is no that does not include pars Etc so if there is a par or an assistant in that that's a one:1 ratio then what I'm asking is if there's a teacher in a classroom and there's 20 kids that would be 1 to 20 1 to 20 right and if there's another teach if there's if out of if one of those 20 children has an assistant that's just a one to one that's not counted that's correct you might have those type of specialized classes icr is what they're called as far as in class resource where you have another teacher in there but it's that's

067not throughout the entire day uh and obviously they they follow the children is what they do so are there any classes with higher numbers that have assistant teachers in them no if you're asking is that based upon the enrollment that's in that class have we assigned an extra power or an assistant to that classroom to help out the answer is no okay thank you good question Madam uh in regard to miss arminio's question the um the teacher ratio statistics are really represent core classes yes um not electives where the numbers could be skewed by on uh a lesser population and so on okay so the student teacher ratio is with core classes yes that's how it's developed okay my other question on the um there's there's a renewal application for temporary instructional space that those

068are the eight trailers and that is only to June 30th of 2015 correct so we'll have to Red discuss that in the near future right about what we're going to do with those or is um the board has acted already I believe to remove those trailers as of June 30 right um the capacity and the enrollment in the building uh will be comfortable uh without those trailers and uh it will eliminate that on this necessary expense and I know we're going to discuss it in the resolutions but there was no price tag on that for the for the um savings classrooms how how much it's going to cost us between now and June correct that that that contract has already been executed it was a long-term contract by uh my predecessor and that will conclude

069June 30 it's so so the renewal of this because it says renewal application that's to the county office okay so it has nothing to do with the change in price correct okay thank you okay any other questions on committee reports then we will go to the superintendent report Mr ventrell uh Madam president it's recommended that the members of the Mona Township Board of Education approve Personnel items a through double n by consent roll call Mr Braverman second second by Mr noin any com yes go ahead Miss Army I'm going to have a question on R page seven uh the yearbook business manager is that stien for 2438 twice or is that a stien that two people will be sharing I wasn't really clear on that uh one person had already start the position in the

070uh in September so it was before the 3 months and then the next person was picking it up at the end of those three months so it's basically it's the same stipend for those two people okay and let's see if I hold more we approving Personnel items is just Personnel yes up to a through n okay and um Double D could you explain Odyssey of the Mind the what page are you on Michelle I'm sorry nine n page nine D that's a club I see the Double D yes it is uh and it's an after school club and the Odyssey of the Mind basically how can I explain it it's a um it's more like a gifted program is what it is and it's a new program that we have it's being implemented and that's

071why the pay is accordingly as far as its instruction yes but what is it what are they doing I to see the Mind as a gifted program I guess is that it's basically a challenge it's a u a talented and gifted program if I may u and obviously is that you know there the students are there Dory I don't know if you can embellish but it's basically it's it's considered a gifted program as what it is is it academic is it Arts well it's certainly is challenging like an academic it's actually a club that um if you you you can actually Google it and look it up because that's that's what I did to figure out what it was um it's a competition and the teacher starts with going over problem solving skills and teaching

072the students the specific criteria that that the club entails and then the students actually participate in competitions with each other and other other school other schools M and it's been around for a long time but it's an academic based Pro uh absolutely oh absolutely it's for gifted children is that it Michelle I think that's it on this and did you fill in those two positions I matter of fact I did Michelle if you can go if everyone can go to page 18 and I believe let's go to page 18 31 you'll see one blank there as far as for a teacher and the teacher's name is Keith Hudak and he is a history teacher at the high school and on page 31 and again thank you for the heads up Michelle is that on you'll

073see on page 31 in the middle desire farer is a family consumer science teacher thank you any other comments or questions by members of the board I seeing none we'll have a roll call Mr proso yes on everything no one Double D and abstain yes on everything on double I but abstain on so noted thank you Mr P uh yes Mr noin yes Mr calman yes to all recuse dou F on I'm sorry recuse on double F thank you Mr zareski yes Mr Chella yes Mr Braverman yes Mr armino yes yes Miss colano yes madame board president Personnel items a through double n passes thank you we will go to board action items uh Madame President it is recommended that the members of the mon Township Board of Education approve board action items a through

074o Mr rman is there a second second second bit manstein Mr Pros you have a question position uh no it is not any other questions seeing none we'll have a roll call Mr proso oh miss armino yes I'm sorry I would had to find it um no I'm sorry I'm good thank you actually I had a quick question U will we will we will we find out what's going on with g i I read the separation agreement or can we shed any light onto that separation agreement since it is a personal item I'd rather not talk about it at this time um Mr pesos item K this is not a course correct this is the first Year's without a cost I I believe that it was it's not a cost they were approved at the

075last curriculum meeting last month Mr cofman thank you oh yeah these were from last months these aren't new we brought these up what's the Zumba Club um it's exactly what it sounds like it's an athletic club that was they went through the same process got all the names they presented a case to Greg berer it's uh freebie this year um and Greg did actually say if memory serves that uh it's so popular it's so successful so far that they may actually be looking to incorporate Zumba in the Athletics program in the future but uh it's still an eval this year we'll see where it ends up next year thank you I think I think that the public received these the agendas that you handed out it's missing the P A through yeah y that that

076was uh rectified there was initial copying problem thank you any other comments or questions okay roll call um M this is board action items a through o Mr proso yes Mr Po yes Mr noin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Chella yes Mr Braverman yes Mr armino yes Mrs Co Pano yes madame board president board action items a through o passes and if I may have uh just one word um since I volunteered pursuant to a vacancy three years ago it has been my honor to serve the board in the unpaid position of District affirmative action officer this is a position of great importance within the district as the affirmative action officer is charged with the responsibility to carry out the board's commitment to provide an instructional and working environment which is free

077from unlawful harassment and discrimination I have every confidence that Dr Dory alvic as my replacement will continue to fully out fully carry out the board's commitment in this regard thank you okay congratulations Mrs alich or Dr alich you're here one day and you've already got more work okay um business administrators report Mr Gorski Madame board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through M be approved by consent roll call okay Mr Braverman second by Mr noin comments or questions from anyone Mr armino guys are moving too fast um in the trans the are we up to the transfer Mr Gord is that in this one yes okay what is the transfer amount I think it's in it was the total I I didn't see

078a total do you have a total yes Madam sure um transfer number four uh reflects normal operating expenditures between account line items which is per permissible by Statute without um approval by the county and superintendent as they don't exceed 10% of the advertised line item there is no total because the twos and the froms where the money's coming and from and two offset each other and it's a zero uh balance the only time you would have a balance is if we're getting some external Revenue source that we're recognizing in the transfer but they were usually within the same Department as I try to understand it from the paperwork the back backup paperwork quite often we'd like to do it in the same department for example if an unforeseen um uh need for textbooks arises we

079would ask the principal to look within their approved budget for other sources of money and to go without something for the rest of the year to offset that cost in certain areas um you know it's impractical we have to take it from another account and uh one of the items that Mr stankowitz noted with the um comprehensive annual financial report is how tight we are to the actual budget with transfers through the year our largest line item in here teacher salaries only had a net transfer effect of $200,000 uh which which demonstrates very accurate and precise budgeting and adhering to the budget okay um is the number I also in this on page 52 learning Sciences International yes okay um is that a yearly or is that one time is that something we're going to

080be doing on a yearly basis and is that contractual um I observation is an instructional and Leadership Improvement system at collects manages and reports longitudal data from classroom walkthroughs teacher evaluations and teacher observations teacher growth and Leadership practices from professional development differentiated to individual learning needs for every teacher and leader to increase his or her classroom Effectiveness each year the $5,600 amount is being used to add non-teaching staff nurses guidance counselors Etc to the system and it's a one-time setup fee oh okay so it's it's sort of it's an overview of what's going on and then what you'll it's collecting data for the administration yes ma'am and then do we get reports on that or does that does that go to teacher evaluations and things like that yes exactly correct okay and is this new

081this year yes it's new for this uh subgroup of nurses guidance counselor CST so can can do you ever pull reports and share those with the boards on on things from this or is that something we're going to consider uh it's mainly used in the evaluation of these uh subgroups nurses guidance counsel CST uh there's a separate teacher evaluation principal evaluation system that goes into their reviews okay um I'm not aware if that's ever shared with the board so it's used that for for the supervisor's purposes is that is that it it's used for uh Management's purposes to review um staff okay thank you Mr knin just a quick question with regards to item M um I imagine this is really just uh kind of uh a statement we're not really moving anything because this

082we currently have like $2,000 in that fund and it's my understanding from Mr stankowitz his report that that's actually uh the money that the state has in the past just come and taken from the districts is that an accurate assessment that is exactly correct the capital reserve account is one which the district can transfer money into for specific projects within your five-year longrange facility plan this resolution is required annually and it shows the estimated total cost of the 5-year uh plan it's just under $8 million it also reflects the amount of State grant money that could be uh estimated for that doesn't mean any of these are in process but it's required resolution and um some of these items we are proceeding with uh but it's not being sourced by Revenue in the capital Reserve

083account for example the internal Renovations at the Monro Township Middle School to provide additional classroom space is coming from the budget um and therefore it's not coming out a capital reserve saving account but it's still within this U venue anyone else roll call please Mr proso yes Mr Po yes Mr noin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr cherella yes Mr Braverman Mrs armenio yes Mrs K Pano Madam board president uh board action items a through M passes that concludes my report okay thank you uh this time we'll go to the board president's report and I want to give an update on the superintendent search on Monday uh this past November well November 3rd couple Mondays ago Gwen Thorton from New Jersey school boards came to Monroe to facilitate a conversation with the community

084as to the characteristics and the philosophies they would like to see in our next superintendent unfortunately it was not very well attended so I hope that anyone who didn't get a chance to come that evening um to attend that meeting and speak to Gwen was able to fill out the online community input survey that was on our we District website which I believe is no longer um available to be utilized for that um input a copy of the ad uh for a new superintendent has been placed in the following nework store Ledger the Trenton Times the Jersey Journal Staten Island Advance Express Times South Jersey Times new jersey.com for 30 days with job video after college workplac diversity.com military vet jobs.com and education am.net in addition to these publication the ad was is placed in

085all 21 County roundtables some colleges and universities such as TCNJ seatan Hall University of Massachusetts Harvard University of Pennsylvania Rowan Stockton and many others it was also placed on professional association websites including New Jersey school boards Association principals and supervisors Association and njasa which means Association for that's the superintendent Association it was also placed at the New Jersey school board's Workshop in Atlantic City at the end of October when we attended as of Monday November 17th there have been 37 requests for applications for the position the deadline for receipt of all of the applications is 5:00 p.m. on January 9th 2015 after all the applications are in they will be divided into three different categories exceeds criteria meets criteria and does not meet criteria the board members will then have an opportunity to go through

086every single one of the applications and then decide on how many they wish to interview so that's the latest update since the applications are in due until January probably might not be a another op update in December and the other thing I have for the board members is uh board self- evaluation which we need to complete by the end of the calendar year and then speaking with Glen Gwen Thorton who monitors and tallies all of the uh superintendent eval and the Board of Education self- evaluation for a district there's plenty of time to do the evaluation um I will be handing out directions on to the board members on how to log on to the board self evaluation and I'm asking that it be completed by November 30th since we have a very early December

087board meeting um the November date will give Gwen enough time to do her part and get it back to us so that we can have a discussion at the December 10th board meeting and the survey is online at www njsp.org and it should not take very long to complete there are no board members who are conflicted out of this process everyone is able to participate so it would be we should have 10 people participating and as with the superintendent evaluation all responses are kept confidential and nobody will have any idea of who said what and the purpose of this study and this this survey rather is to identify areas of concern what we are doing well as a board what we need help in and then move forward with any appropriate training that might be

088necessary so at this time is there any questions from the board members because if not I will be handing out the um self- evaluation update Tom um when we get these uh these applications back from potential uh candidates um will will Gwen have already gone through them yes okay so the ones that we get are going to be pretty much the qualified ones from her standpoint we're going to get them all but she will have them all divided into these are the ones that meet ex expectations these are the ones that exceed the expectations and these are the ones that don't exceed expectations so we will have access to every application that comes in now is there any way that we can get them so instead of just waiting until like for example if somebody

089sends in a a completed app and she looks at it and she says it meets uh meets the criteria um is there any way of us looking at them instead of us having to potentially look at 37 all at ones can we kind of look at them a little early um I don't believe that's how school boards does it they wait until they have all the applications they go through all the I don't know when they go through all the applications and then they they return them to the board of education and then there are property so we so nothing will happen basically until after January 9th right Mr zareski if I can if I can probably add part of an answer to your question once Gwen and her staff I think it's about three

090or four people get all the applications and after the deadline they do sort them them out Gwen will come here with a modified report on each of these candidates that fall into our criteria and she'll give us a basic rundown so we don't have to sit and pass around each application to 10 different board members she'll have a brief summary on it and then we can take it from there as far as where we want to go okay thank you anyone else okay so that concludes my board president's report and then we will go to Other Board of Education business is there any other business by any member of the Board of Education that needs to be hard tonight Mr zareski yeah I just want to add not actually add one thing I just want

091to say one thing uh December 3rd is a middle sex County School Board Association meeting at Pierre in South Brunswick and any board member here is willing to attend that we have some pretty good training and information that can be passed out to board members not just here but other districts in Middle sex County that's December 3rd all you have to do is go online to New Jersey school board's website under middle sex County and register thank you anyone else okay please after you oh after you I got one thing and I'll go to you Mr Chief oh Mr cof um and I'm sorry I should have made the comment we were doing the board action uh for the uh the staff before um Mr presos so you had um said yes to everybody except

092one person who was that person you said no to was okay um and maybe I was a little bit you know um he abstained I think he re accused he recused I did for that heus no he said no to somebody no he recused recused you said but you said no to one person wait wait a second Mr Gorski I believe that Mr proso abstained based on advice by Council or he actually recused I thought yeah I thought he' recused he did I know I did I don't know what he he the recuser abstained I know he did I thought he said no to a particular individual I have uh in my notes that he abstained on I I uh Laura tesler I I Laura tesler and that that was the recommendation that was made

093in advance by Council um because of okay litigious to the Double D thank you I got that one no to Double D was got that too good okay Mr cherel yes I just wanted to let the board and let everyone know that on Saturday I attended the Indian Cultural Association of Monroe D the Dali dwali celebration it was excellent uh had a great time we we have a great uh great community in the Indian Community you know they value Family Values educ educ ation and hard work but it was really wonderful to see all the presentations and the dances and the kids and uh you know everything that that uh they're part and they bringing their Community to life so I just wanted to bring that up if if uh the board members get a

094chance to attend those they should you know they should do that next year they'll have navati and then Dali but it's a it's it's educational but it's also a great experience thank you anyone else Mr Braverman in the past we have spoken about absorbing the before and after school program to to uh have that income for the Board of Education here for the district I was wondering how that's progressing Madam you want me to take pursuant to recommendation by the board uh the superintendent uh Dennis ventrillo and I are are planning the inhouse uh structure for a before and after school care program this will be one of the superintendent goals uh for the 15 16 school year and as you may imagine to do it correctly it involves the preparation of a business plan

095uh it involves uh projections of Revenue expense Staffing considerations all also um what I understand to be the case this is going to have an educational component to it too with the curriculum that's going to be um not just uh um your Bas of the basic H daycare service it's going to be somewhat more educational to promote the kids advancement to the next grades yeah this this will probably uh bring in probably hundreds of thousands of dollars uh I wonder if by December 10th our next meeting we can have a timeline as to when to expect how this is going to come off so we're not behind the eight ball in September yeah I believe that um Dr Gorman who had said that we should be getting a um some input by March we would

096have a a finalized report by March was either Dr Gorman or Dr Hamilton I I was at a past meeting so we can get an update by December to see where they stand and and you're right Marvin because we'd have to be prepared when you think about it not only as far as facilities but also but staff but also to inform the parents uh a lot has to be in place obviously before we leave in June okay anyone else is there not a contract that we have with the current system and when is that expiring Madam sure currently we have a rental lease agreement with the Before and After School Care Network to lease our facilities through June 30 of 15 so we do need to get that moving on that if we're if we're

097thinking about something thank you Mr gra anyone else Mr Kaufman uh sure so um I guess the board members received an a memo hand delivered a couple weeks about a week or so ago no no the document is still um dated November 13th and Mr cofman if if this is what I think you're going to be bringing up a letter um please make sure that you don't use absolutely been here I okay I just want for the whole board the name of any person or position yep okay um other than people that are here at this table yes okay so it's been brought to our attention that a board member had a conversation with an employee at a um local location and uh the contents of this letter are very disturbing to me now I've

098been on the board for a long time probably longer than I really should be and I know I know the job and what it entails and the realities and there have been times in the past when people say things that board members have said or board members have done and and a lot of times when it's done and it's accused it's always Anonymous people kind of hide in the shadows and don't want to come forward and you kind of take it with a grain of salt you know we're up here and you kind of take the good with the bad and that's the nature of the job that you you can't really um avoid it um but this situation um I think needs to be treated a little bit differently uh the issue here is

099that we have a uh conversation um and I'll refer to the person here the employee um and it relates also the employees supervisor um as far as I understand from the information here and in the spirit of being transparent and we all want to be transparent um this occurrence happened on October 25th at a local store of which I'm not going to name um Miss armeno uh started the conversation with the employee uh after overhearing a conversation between uh the employee and the store um Mr Mr Koffman I just want to say it's the alleged um allegation it's an alleged and correct okay uh in light of the uh conversation um regarding the previous I'm Sorry Miss Armenia stated um with the conversation with the employee um after overhearing um her speaking or the employees

100speaking to the store employee um after a light conversation regarding the pr and again I'm not reading the entire document because it's many many pages long um after a light conversation regarding a previous business transaction with the employee uh you proceeded to uh give the employee your business card uh you then asked how her Supervisor was uh of which she was quite surprised um you then identified yourself as a board member which is fine I mean we we all do that all the time but then you Pro uh proceed to ask questions related to again alleged right on how that uh supervisor or whether he was smart whether he worked hard or he knew his stuff um and and that that right there if we didn't go any further that would be questionable to me

101um you know things like that when you I'll get through and then I'll well these are allegations that are not substantiated and I don't think you should be you can quote whatever the person said but you can't imply that that's exactly what I said so I would I would caution that agreed we discontinue this unless there's a unless there's a um however well violation think anything Mr Kaufman is finished with his comment yet well he's not it's not his comment what he's reading are allegations that are not represented as as having been confirmed so I think the the nature why this is a little bit different is because in the past we've had situations where this has occurred and there are things that have been said in here about what may or may not have

102been said but in this particular case we have a situation where an employee Not only was concerned about the conversation but the employee went to that particular supervisor regarding the nature of the conversation and it didn't stopped there that employee went also to provide the same information to our house counsil that's a completely different treating of information as it comes to the board and as I understand you were given the opportunity to come before the administration with Kathy and Mike and and whoever else Miss Smith to present your perspective of what happened again it was one-sided but you were given the opportunity to present your your say and from what I understand from this conversation that not only didn't go well but if if what is said is here is true you know making a

103a comment like you better drop it to our administrators is really bad and one of the administrators is here and was on the phone so if you're going to say that didn't happen then say it say you did not say to the administrator you better I don't believe this is an inquiry and I'm not going to comment on it any further thank you what happened if you transparent it either did or didn't happen if there's an allegation brought to the again with the allegations here and I'm going to get off myself box in a second the other question I that that raises a level of concern also again alleging that it may or may not have happened is a statement that says with respect to the hiring practices within this District right that we and

104I don't know who the wi is are looking to get rid of people who either don't know their stuff or know people in the district again it's all alleged but it's not we I understand that they were given you were given the opportunity to to tell your side of the story and you didn't do it I think you probably should because if some of this is true even a portion of this this is really bad and there's a lot of Ethics violations here and I respect you for your comment in here about not willing to file charges but you know there there there's a lot of things that you can and cannot do here one of the things really is you shouldn't be talking about staff members or making a statement that we are looking

105to do things because without going through all the board members here and polling them to find out who the we are it's just not a good practice it's not a good face to put in front of everybody else if we're trying to do a good job here that's why all my point is Madame President if I may Mr Po um I'm not quite certain what the point of the recent comments was in terms of helping this board uh I resent the fact that it was presented in this particular Forum I think if board members want to address the actions or behaviors alleged or otherwise of other board members than it should be done a forum that is more suitable to that uh I I I I greatly resent what has just occurred here um I

106feel badly uh for for Mrs armeno I know I would not want to be subjected to that I think it was highly inappropriate and I want to formally register my complaint that this was allowed to happen at this board meeting this should have been dealt with in a closed session as a and if that's not legal then we have to find a way that it can be dealt with we've got an attorney so we need to explore that but this is something that should not have occurred tonight that's my opinion Mr Po Mr Gorski myself Mr ventrello and our attorney spent many days on this it is not a closed session item it was something that was sent home to the board did not speak to any of the board members um I I happen

107to be away at a um New Jersey school board's Workshop when this happened I was called into the office when I came back it was discussed with me on how to handle this I asked Mr Gorski to please call the board member in to speak to somebody whether it was me and and Mr Gorski or Mr Gorski and Mr ventrello or our our legal counsel legal uh the the request was denied nobody came in to speak we did not get the other side of the story and this needed to be documented it was we asked our attorney this needed to be documented and a copy sent home to the board it is not a closed session item if anybody needed to bring this up it had to be brought up in Open Session and um

108Mr Gorski you might want to add to this because um we we tried to figure out any way that this should be a closed session item and it wasn't well I'm I'm sadden to hear that and I still I still object to what has occurred here uh I think out of respect for fellow board members even though we may disagree with one another and we may object to the behavior and actions of of board members uh then I think we should deal with that on a private basis I know if I have a concern with a fellow board member uh I will individually speak with that Bell that fellow board member I I don't see the value in making this a a public issue as it has been made tonight I'm not questioning the process

109that preceded it what I am questioning or what I am saying that I strongly object to is what has occurred this evening as board president I do not have the right to withhold anybody from speaking any person any member of this board has the right to bring anything up as Mr Koffman will attest I did not know he was bringing this up this evening this was him as as board president I have always felt it was my philosophy that if there was an issue we would call a board member in and we would talk to them unfortunately when we tried to call the board member in the board member would not come in speak to anybody so I we could only get one side of the story and it needed to be documented so it

110it it was um I I think with Council and with their advice we followed the council advice Mr Gman I happen to agree with Doug I think it was poor advice that you got even if it was an attorney I think a telephone call would have sufficed and if it didn't suffice then I would have had a meeting but I I think the letter right off the bat I think that did nothing more than antagonize people I thought I thought it was terrible when I when I got the letter I agree this is this has caused more damage than anything that happened in that letter as far as to this board um that in and of itself in my uh opinion is an Ethics violation we're uh individual board members should not be doing anything

111that's going to damage this board um I would love to know what was the point of Mr calman bringing this out tonight because it did not accomplish anything secondly did Mr calman reach out to M armeno and ask any of the details I would have to pretty much guarantee he did not because the intent of this uh basically showcase by Mr calman tonight was nothing more than grandstanding and trying to make another board member look bad that to me is the biggest ethics violation here and it's a Despicable thing that he tried to accomplish tonight and I am very disappointed in what I formerly thought was a fantastic board member and it also goes towards our board leadership I think that um Mr C Mr calman should have talked to our board president as we

112were all instructed to do anytime we bring something out we should always ask the board president so that there's no what they told us as new board members would be a gotcha moment well if this wasn't supposed to be a gotcha moment I don't know what was and I'm disgrace I'm disgraced at what I saw tonight well first of all Mr norstein you don't have nobody has to come to me and tell me what they need to say if there's an other board business I don't believe anybody has ever done that in the past if they're bringing something up um again we requested somebody to to talk on the phone there was a refusal to talk on the phone there was a request to have a meeting with whomever this person wanted to have the

113meeting with there was a refusal our attorney because I don't do anything without attorney advice gave us the advice to write this letter we did it with the attorney's approval of the [Music] letter Mr arino yes I would just like to say that I believe that any employee or anyone of the public has a right to make an allegation and has a right to put it in writing I have no issues with that what I my comment is that it is unsubstantiated uh the the tenor of the allegations are incorrect and any uh I felt that it wasn't necessary to proceed because there were no ethics violations if there are ethics violations by all means move forward however just a a common disc discussion in in a retail store um ju I I just won't

114I just won't proceed with any other comments on that I mean it just doesn't make sense well this board is here to protect our employees too and I agree that every employee should be protected and every employee has a right however one have can have an opinion they have a right to their opinion they don't have a right to the facts if the facts are incorrect but we don't know the facts are incorrect unless somebody I'm not going to get into a contest with someone the person the employee had a right to do what they did and I respect that but I'm not I'm I'm not going to dignify it with a whole dramatic uh procedure thank you Mr zesi I think first of all this could have been all avoided if somebody would have

115spoke their side in private which is what I'm hearing from other board members would have liked to have seen if said person came forward and said okay I'll talk to you about this none of us probably would have heard any of this this would have been handled internally by our superintendent by our board president and by legal councel by the three people there and yourself and possibly this other individual by not doing so and not taking any further actions to defend this is what happens sometimes when it gets brought out and other board members want answers as far as ethics violations from what I can see and what I heard saw in this letter it's possibly there you're representing yourself in a public place to put the word simply we when you're identified yourself as

116a board member that is a problem okay is there any other board of education business any more gotas Ian there's always a gacha in this board Goa I'd like to say something maybe that's why some people don't want to go to a meeting in the in the board office because this always happens and it's always against a new member and this is terrible it should have been done in private well Mr Mr proso I remember some meetings last year when we called you in and you came in and we resolved our issues we we did that many times and that's the way I we didn't re we didn't resolve the issues a lot of times it was used against me so I don't blame her for not showing up that's all I got to say

117Okay then if there's no further business we will go to the Clos session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 colum 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subjects Brookside principal interviews harassment intimidation or bullying incidents 5-9 the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public as such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists comment oh I need a motion to second first Mo second okay Mr Koffman Mr nin I was G to recomend that first and a second uh first second I me who would like to make a motion I'll make a motion okay and second by

118Mr nin okay comment and I'd like to make this comment now we are going into executive session to discuss the interviews for the principal position at the Brookside School upon legal counsel from Jamesburg I am going to exclude myself from any interviews conducted by or for a principal by this board as this is not part of our duties as a board and I am going to look for an advisory opinion from the SEC which is a state ethics Commission on this I will be more than happy to sit in on the HIV thank you Mr Mr nin um I don't see why Mr zanaki would have even been in this because this is for a Brookside principal I would have asked for him to be excluded anyway so thank you and I agree um they

119wouldn't be on a brook side the we we've been told not to sit into with interviews but I I feel that um our our attorney has given us advice that we could be in interviews as long as we don't participate in the interview so I will be going in pursuant to our attorney advice um all in favor I opposed extensions and at this time the board will move into closed session okay at this time the Board of Education will be back in public session and I believe Mr ventell has a recommendation it is recommended that the Board of Education appoint staff member Antonio Pepe to the position of principal of Brookside Elementary School effective November the 20th 2014 at an annual salary of one uh 11,863 per rated for the remainder of the 214 215

120school year the board president the interim superintendent schools and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the Board of Education dated November 19th 2014 so moved second Mr nin Mr proso any comments or questions we will have a roll call Mr proso yes Mr py yes Mr noin yes Mr calman Mr zareski re thank you Mr Chella yes Mr Braverman is absent Mr Aro yes Mrs K Pano yes madame board president uh I am pleased to announce that six Y for the resolution and it passes okay congratulation Mr Pepe on your appointment principal of Rook I'm sure Dr Alit would be very happy right now since we've given her more work she doesn't have less work over there now okay um we

121will be going to the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone and give your name and address for the record my name is mine Ryback I speak for myself and I must be Clairvoyant may I have your address please sorry 23 Riviera Drive I'm a retired New York City teacher having earned a BS degree in education an MS degree in special education and 30 credits past my masters in technology when I began my career in 1970 I taught in an extremely volatile racially charged District but at no time to my knowledge was communication by a private individual and CC to Schoolboard members blatantly falsified and plagiarized and shared with the public How can any of us ever feel safe communicating our thoughts privately to our elected officials not

122knowing how it can be used in the future the word ethics appears to be used by members of this board I read the code of ethics as it applies to all New Jersey school boards and I suggest this and all future school boards in any Town revisit this code frequently as I reviewed the code of ethics I also reviewed the responsibility of school board members whomever the president of the board is now or in the future please read roman numeral 2 Under The Heading conduct board meeting which states and I quote keep discussion to point involvement of all members members maintain Democratic procedures protect minority opinion again protect minority opinion ensure Fair hearing for all points of view full discussion of issues refrain from discussing elements of board deliberations outside board meetings unquote and I

123would like to include only make public documents and Communications that have been verified as authentic have the approval of the board as well as the author we need to be a United Community that can trust our Representatives filled with Community spirit and respect for each other this starts at the top let's choose a new superintendent that has a strong background as an educational leader has excellent communication and people skills is a team player respects differences of opinion understands the fiscal needs of the community and willing to reach out to the community to make our school system whole I hope the future school board and the one after that and so on will work together present themselves in a respectable ethical transparent Cooperative way thank you thank you thank you anyone else from the public Stephen

124Steven Ryback 23 Riviera Drive GNA have to try and follow that one my purpose in speaking today is to help try to help heal a serious situation not make it worse however I do feel compelled to speak on a few of the issues when unverified Andor plagiarized documents appear on campaign sites of BOE candidates they send a very wrong message to our community that must be expedi expeditiously addressed and corrected we can't allow a double standard to be set for students and Boe candidates or members what we do tell students what do we tell students who have received serious consequences for falsifying or plagiarizing a document it's not right for you but but it's acceptable for Boe campaigns the email I'm speaking about while it had my name as the writer was not written by

125me it was altered plagiarized by someone and placed on a campaign Facebook page clearly without proper verification this must be addressed corrected and future actions clearly reinforced or established to diminish any reoccurrence in upcoming campaigns however not taking any action here sends another message that will diminish the public trust in this board of education how can you expect the public to believe what you say going forward if there is no response by you on this matter we must reassure our resid that our standards are high and we will never take that for granted I'm excited to be joining you this January and one of my goals is to assist in making it a more cohesive supportive unit where differences of opinion do not become personal differences we must all work together for our students staff

126members and Community it's my sincere hope that we all participate in this effort thank you very much is there anyone else from the public wishing to speak uh good evening David Kini five ellingham Avenue um I wanted to just ask as a followup uh to the building uh building committee uh meeting from uh a couple of weeks ago uh I wanted to find out if and I'm sorry for not being able to come to the earlier part of the meeting this may have been disc discussed uh what was the uh results of the enrollment data that you were waiting for on 11:13 uh to help us make more coherent plans um what is the designation or has that been discussed of what the designation of the building that was potentially going to be built at

127the time of that meeting it was between a um uh possibly a districtwide 56 or is it going to be an elementary school and I wonder if that's progressed at all um what is the plan B if the referendum fails uh and then of course my question always is you know so where is the mayor and all of this because I think it's really important that uh while we need to maintain our individuality with the Board of Education that the there is somehow integrating what's going on with the zoning board and what we're doing here so that we don't continue to have these same conversations and asking the taxpayers to continue to pay out money so we can build new buildings the enrollment data is not available yet we're in the process of getting that

128information so that when we get that we will we'll bring it to a board meeting a future board meeting give that out in the public and put it on our website and we are not at the uh stage yet where we're we have a referendum so we haven't even talked about a plan a so we definitely don't have a plan B and since we don't um have any referendum plan we haven't even gotten into the stages of talking with our municipal government yet okay uh I know that that some of this was planned for a a quarter 1 vote and so but it you know quarter one happens pretty quick around here so I wasn't sure how how much further the conversation went it was just about redistricting and what we had we had I

129think we asked to have another redistricting plan come and with the new data right and that I think won't be available before January okay so everything else tabled till then okay thank just to elaborate on on those words by Mrs K Pano the uh building grounds Transportation committee directed Administration to update the enrollment study also known as a demographic study with the um enrollment data that's very recent and relevant as of October 15 2014 as reported to the state in the asssa m then we were further directed to update the redistricting report using that new data making sure that um all all developments and everything are as recent as we can get Provisions for from the township um with the last demographic report all of the information contained about developments and potential developments was furnished

130by the township as relevant as the report was prepared um number two when the when the committee eventually um begins to plan for a referendum it would certainly involve the municipal figures the mayor has been involved with school construction projects in the past and was very supportive of this facility being built and District administration will be as aggressive as possible to get as much State Grant and participation in the construction project as possible okay yeah no and and I thank you for that I know that we've been short shifted on on our state funds and so I recognize we're all trying to make up that that difference um but again continue to build causes a lot of these problems as well and having that conversation thank you thank you anyone else from the public wishing

131to speak okay seeing none we'll close public forum and our next scheduled Board of Education meeting Wednesday December December 10th 2014 7:00 p.m. at the high school motion to adjourn Mr Kaufman and second by Mr zareski all in favor opposed this meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.