CorpusRecord 132942

Monroe Township Board of Education 12.10.14 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,968 words · about 56 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001what's the last thing you're say evening good evening the meeting of the Momo Township Board of Education will come to order please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance Alle to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all may we have a roll call Mr Gorski certainly miss anelis here Mr armino here Mr Braverman Mr Chella here Mr calman here Mrs goano here Mr noin here Mr Po Mr proso Mr zareski here madam president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof

002posted December 5th 2014 one at all schools two home News Tribune three cranberry press and four filed with the c Clerk of the municipality and you will notice that last month we had a new person sitting over here Dr alvic uh new assistant superintendent of schools she is on her way to the meeting she has been I believe in Nashville at a learning forward conference that is related to a coaching Grant which improves leadership so she should be here shortly so at this time we will go to our student board members reports good evening everyone um so for the report tonight Barkley Brooks school is registered and will have the opportunity to earn cash through Stop and Shop A+ bonus bucks program what you have to do is log on to stopandshop.com A+ to register

003and after you register with your card each shopping trip at Stop and Shop can earn cash for the school and the school will receive cash a cash check at the end of the program that can be used towards the school's educational needs and attending to the simple process will provide assistance to Barkley Brook so ask friends relatives and neighbors to register their card for Barkley Brook also um on Wednesday December 17th the National Honor Society members at the high school will be wrapping Christmas gifts for needy families at the Presbyterian Church in Jamesburg um mon Township High School's Fellowship of Christian athletes held their annual children's movie night last Friday where ch in the community came to the high school to enjoy a fun holiday film and all money benefits the FCA seniors through scholarships

004and the oak tree students concluded their annual Thanksgiving food drive and brought in hundreds of canned and boxed food items that were distributed to local monor Township families and during December they will also conduct a holiday gift drive thank you uh the tanip high school student council is uh holding a holiday toy drive uh students in the monor tanip high school chapter of deca are uh starting to complete their online testing for the regional competitions in finance marketing hospitality and business administration uh the mths future Business Leaders of America will also be holding their competition shortly um and in January the January and February the high school's mock trial team team will be competing uh in the county and state events uh through the New Jersey State Bar foundation and the local chapter for the

005model United Nations will be attending their conference in Hershey Pennsylvania okay that concludes thank you for your reports and at this time we are going to the student recognition essay contest in Mr vello we will turn this over to you we have a special presentation this evening uh for one of our middle school students and I would like Middle School teachers Miss Jardine and Miss LeBron to come up to the microphone maybe give a little overview of the essay contest and then introduce the student and the family thank you Mr V good good evening everybody it's an honor to be here we're here to recognize one of our former sixth grade students Miss Deja Darden last spring we received an email regarding an art and essay contest that was being sponsored by the Association of

006Indians in America the South Jersey chapter the timing couldn't have been more perfect as we had just begun a unit on a Hima or non-violent action in the ancient um Indian unit of the curriculum and for many of us when we think of nonviolence the first person that comes to mind is mahat m Gandhi the topic of the essay was to respond to his very famous quote you must be the change you wish to see in the world Mrs LeBron and I saw this as an opportunity to integrate literacy across the curriculum and in language arts the timing was also perfect we had just finished our Holocaust unit which ends with a discussion on how we all can be agents of change to make the world a more peaceful tolerant place to live uh all

007students on team Visa did participate in the essay contest and we submitted the essays in June within the first few days of this current school year we did receive notice that d as was one of the top 25 finalists out of 2,000 Middle School and High School candidates Julie could you say that again please yes she was one of the top 25 finalists out of 2,000 middle and high school students across the state so the association let us know that they were having a ceremony at Princeton University in October where they would announce the top three winners so um it was no surprise that when we learned that Deja had placed third overall and she was awarded a certificate in cash prize there and um there were some performances and it was really a lovely

008event um as her family just shared with us and it does remind us these moments um do remind us of the real reason that we we go into teach and the rewards that it can bring at times like this so Deja was an Exemplar student all year long she really brought us pride and joy every day so it is with great honor that we bring her up and celebrate her [Applause] together so should we read this together okay in recognition of your academic excellence and placing thir out of 2000 New Jersey students in the essay content sponsored by the Association of Indians in America South Jersey chapter this certificate is issued to Deja thank you teachers thank you principal Chanley I see you back there and I also see supervisor Kelly Roselle as well thank

009you all thank you congrat congratulations from the Board of Education and that's why we're all here too so that we can honor and celebrate the great things that all of our students accomplish so this is quite a a great accomplishment so congratulations okay at this time we will go to number seven on our agenda and I'm going to introduce amenis who is president of the Henry Ras Holocaust Memorial s committee thank you the Henry rickless committee is made up of volunteers and Holocaust Survivors the mission of the Henry rickless committee is to spread the word of what happened back in the time of the Holocaust in the hopes that this kind of thing will never happen again the rickless committee does various programs we run um our annual yamasa Memorial we do a library we

010work with the Monroe Township Library we make donation of $500 a year in order for the Li library to buy books about the Holocaust but one of our best achievements is our essay contest and um what happens is our survivors go into the schools and speak to the Freshman Class giving their eyewitness account and then the students are asked voluntarily to write an essay and I'm going to turn this over to Mr David Rothman who's the chair of the essay committee and he can talk about what happened with this class thank you Dave board members parents teachers and a special thank you to Matty philippus and also Bonnie caletto they make the process Flawless they bring they invite the Freshman Class to come for an auditorium somewhere around June beginning of June we bring three

011of our survivors they each have a very different and unique story about what they had gone through share their life hisory Mysteries and then the students are invited to totally voluntary to submit an essay on one of four questions uh one may be what would you say if you ran into a holocaust denier what would you say or do did you share this with family or friends and what was their reaction why is it important to study the Holocaust and lastly we had some quotes and how would you interpret it what was what was the author meaning by this year last year I came before you and I told you we had 232 out of your freshman class I thought that was not going to be topped until this year 286 essays were submitted my

012committee went through it and to come up with um truly outstanding ones was a feat trust me we came out with 11 that are just absolutely outstanding and we have gifts certificates for all 11 but I'd like to share with you just one of them so you get a sense of what we were going this is amazing this is amazing it coming from freshman one of them is here with us today uh Miss perie Pandy I'd like to call her up I'd like you hear what she had to [Applause] write almost every year we recap at the tragic events of the Holocaust and every year I learn something new I'm continuing to be astounded yearby year of the cruelty and inhumanity of one person that led to the loss of 6 million innocent lives a

013story to share recently I was R raging through a drawer in my home it was overflowing with a surplus of old childhood photos suddenly rushing memories came back to me small milestones in my life captured in a photograph and stored away for later generations to see though they may be wor worthless to any other Outsider to me and my family they are Priceless just like I have these keepsakes almost every other family in the world does as well including during the Holocaust when I was presented with this quote by Frank Towers a liberator I often wonder what this world would be like if those 6 million had never perished I immediately thought of the photo drawer the record of my life just because they are from different centuries doesn't mean my childhood and the childhood

014of those 6 million people people was any different we all had Memories and Milestones however the only slight difference is that those 6 million people had no privilege of being able to grow up and look through those keepsakes instead they they perished just like their owners as a liberator who witnessed many atro atro atrocious sites to's quotes provokes thought on the value of human life if 6 million lives had not been inhaled what would the world be like I think Tower's Main goal from this quote is that it may not have affected our personal lives in a drastic way but it would have changed history forever 6 million families would have been complete 6 million life goals would have been achieved 6 million people would have been able to look back on their life the

015main takeaway message is that we take many things for granted we don't think about the small details of Our Lives those six me we don't think about the small details of Our Lives those 6 million people would have given the world to relive we must truly realize the impact this event alone has created upon the world and instead of learning it as a Collegiate seminar actually feel its imprint upon the world thank you thank you I'm going to call out the names I'm going to ask two of my associates on my committee uh Evelyn Goldstein and Judith Sherman by the way Judith Sherman is one of our survivors who shares her story with the students wow and I'm going to call the names of the 11 Award winners and uh if you two will uh

016help out thank you first one is Lauren Ramirez Lauren are you here excellent job thank you next person up is Henry Sloan I know you you here I can't cat it in it's in your name okay and let me invite back up uh perie [Applause] Pandy thank you perie Rachel Fernandez are you here good Nish Patel [Applause] thank you great great job next Caitlyn [Applause] Z thank you next one um hopefully I pronounce this properly a poor cetti cetti how should I have pronounced it I did thank you thank you Miranda Crowley are you [Applause] here thank you great job uh par Patel are you [Applause] here you congratulations great job and Nick Lumbard [Applause] conratulations great thank you and this augers very well for our society's future thank you for your educational program and

017you have a great bunch of students thank you another excellent job by our students thank you for continuing to run this contest and at this time number eight on the agenda um it's our evening or time to recognize two valuable board members that will no longer be with us because they have decided not to run or re run for re-election to the Board of Education this year so um sort of a Bittersweet moment because both of them have been very invaluable to the board and we hate to lose them but they're leaving on their own and I think they both have um aspirations to go beyond the board of education so at this time I'm going to ask Mr Chella to come up to the microphone and Mr [Applause] V you know the news reporters

018I'm going to read this presented to Kenneth Chella in sincere appreciation for dedicated service to the students and schools of Monroe Township while serving as a board member of the Monroe Township Board of Education from 2008 to 2014 Mr tiella thank you very yes it has been a pleasure and an honor to work with you well I appreciate it and I and I just want to I just want to thank everyone for allowing me to serve um I've been honored to be able to do that uh you know I've tried to take it as seriously as I as I possibly could and to always do what I thought was right but I just want to say a couple things quickly because I think the full board is often misund misunderstood you know we have a

019bunch of good people on this board that work card for free who do this because they think they want to you know they want to be able to change they think they could change the way we do things or help the way we do things and so they they take their you know their their their personal experiences and they come to the board and they volunteer their time and I think that you know what we see here A A lot of times is in fighting and we see this as oh maybe we have good people on the board and bad people on the board I don't think that's the case I think we have good people on the board who are trying to do what they think is right but under some circumstances that are

020extraordinary and sometimes extraordinarily diffic difficult so for instance you know with unfunded mandates and with rampant development that we have going on in this town and then on top of that we you know we have things like uh lack of State funding and things like that so you have a bunch of people trying to do what they think is right but often butting heads because everybody's trying to do what they think is right and that and that sometimes causes some dissension but I think they're all trying to do the right thing and I'm just my advice would be just they all just remember to serve educating our children first put our children first before anything and I think that will be will be okay the other thing is and then I'll sit down is that

021I I have asked I asked uh Kathy if she would think about naming this school after me and she said yes but I have to change I have to change my name to Monroe Township High School so that's in the work but I just want to thank you very much personally what we're going to miss the most is your sense of humor because we've always counted on you when things got really tough or when we needed a little levity so you're going to be missed with thank you thank you Ken miss an Tellis Kathy when you're done could you come over here for a second what you done this is like deja Fu it is presented presented to Amy and Tellis in sincere appreciation for dedicated service to the students in schools of Monroe Township

022while serving as a board member of the Monro Township Board of Education from 1992 to 2010 and again 2011 to 2014 um Amy you you've seen more changes than anybody except Mr V I think um I've seen him change that when I started there yeah so it it's knowing where we come from and where you are and how much input you've had into where we are today and the thousands of children that you've had um that you've worked for it's just impressive and I don't think will'll ever happen again so this is for you congrat congratulations a brief I just want to say my goal on this board from day one was always about the kids um try to be fiscally responsible I'm a taxpayer but it was always about the kids and over the

023years maybe the board members have disagreed with each other over certain aspects of education but in the end we always came together as a board and it was always about the kids I also want to say one of the things I'm going to miss most is the staff I love the staff in Monro you guys are great and um I went through years of negotiations um and you guys have just always been wonderful and I'm going to say the best for last um dealing with the administrators I've been through four superintendant and uh principles but Dennis and I have been here from the beginning Dennis has always been the Rock in this District uh from the day I met him as an administrative assistant opened up schools for us and you know what Dennis thank

024you for always being there and I really need to say that so thank you to body to everyone who's voted for me but thank you mostly to the staff and to the kids for making my time on the board memorable thank you thank [Applause] you thank you go right ahead um I think I had mentioned before that um one of the people who makes the seamless is Matty philippus and he did it again I missed someone so he immediately tackled me before I could leave and said you know you forgot one more uh student so if I may Naomi Doshi are you here my error thank you outstanding job and I'm glad I didn't forget I'm glad M remind hey at this time number nine on the agenda Food Service program presentation at FDA requirements

025and menu offerings I'm going to turn this over to Mr Gorski thank you madam board president members of the Board of Education and members of the public I'd like to introduce at this time miss Nancy mitac our longstanding food service director who runs a very exceptional food service program for the welfare and the benefit of our students Nancy it's Nancy mitr Still Still [Laughter] Standing um the hardest thing here is figuring out how to speak to everybody in this room so I'm going to take this and just step back all right um I would like to thank the board of education for the opportunity to address you just um about a few topics that have come up recently and um hopefully I'll be able to answer some questions that have been asked and um just

026um maybe boast a little about my program um or our program I should say um I put together a packet which I believe has been uh passed out to all the board members and basically it's just um a little snapshot of some of the changes that have taken place over the last few years in the school nutrition programs um in 2010 there was uh an Act passed in Congress uh the healthy hunger free kids act uh with that there were sweeping changes to the Food Service program uh regulations um the goal was to increase fruit and vegetables um and introduce more whole grains uh to bring more validity to the nutrient content of the meal so with that uh there has been a progression of changes uh beginning in 2012 um and the changes are

027going um to 201 16 so each year we're we are bringing in some further changes to the program um so for the students I I think that they have certainly noticed uh a lot of the changes um I'm pleased to say that um when we as a Food Service Association first heard about all the changes we were really really concerned that we were going to lose the student population and I am very very pleased to say that we have not uh we have a very vibrant participation in the school lunch program and um as a result we have been able to sustain ourselves not only in last few years but um the last 31 years so I am Overjoyed that um our department has not uh cost the taxpayer a single Cent um in my

02831 years here in the district um and I'm also pleased uh that we have a very loyal and um I I believe involved uh student um student food um participation through our sorry okay Nancy all right believe it or not in 31 years I've only addressed the board once so uh I it's okay I am a little bundle of nerves okay um so if you look in your packet you're just going to see some of the changes that have um taken place in the last few years uh as far as fruits and vegetables I think the big big change is that students are now required to take a fruit or a vegetable with their lunch and uh as a result um there have been a number of concerns about kids throwing fruit and vegetable out

029in the trash um so basically students have to be offered five components in the lunch and um the five components are protein grain milk fruit and vegetable uh they must select three of those five components and uh the one of those components must be a fruit or a vegetable so um I think my my Frank observation has been in the beginning students weren't even taking their fruit or their vegetable to their table we had a lot of kids dropping it off on the way um over the last two years though I really am seeing a significant um change I I do think the kids are really taking the fruit and vegetable more often or actually eating it uh which is a great thing and all of these regulations are really um for this for the

030health of our students uh you know we really as a society cannot um ignore the fact that childhood obesity has become a growing issue and um I think that as schools we need to model the uh um proper proper nutrition um so I guess um with that um we've off we've we've increased the offerings of fruit and vegetable uh our high school we have um you know a lot of the the offerings we have fruit uh we have um salads we have uh soup which is um we have a lot of vegetable offerings with uh within our soup component so um I've also been asked to address the um growing diversity in our community I did put a um something in your packet that and I did go back to the October 15th report just

031to look at exactly what the breakdown of our student population is districtwide um H this is uh by ethnic and racial subgroup um and as a district um the the fastest growing is Asian uh currently we're 29.4% Asian 4% black africanamerican uh 5.4 Hispanic 02 Pacific Islander uh 59.3 White 09 American Indian Alaskan and 1.92 or more races um so with that there has been um there is a a growing change in the the uh dietary needs of our community and certainly uh we are very much uh trying to respond to that we are obviously getting a a much greater call for vegetarian meals uh and uh so the two two areas that really really do inform um what we do in terms of um our menu planning uh is that we look at participation

032records and we can really see uh we keep records daily and we can see what the favorites are of the kids um and the other thing is the feedback from the students I meet regularly with student Food Service Groups and um combined um we really come up with menus that are the most popular and uh so we've had a lot more um additions to our menu I was uh speaking to someone recently and and uh it really is just rather than doing like a chicken Caesar salad we are doing a a Caesar salad with the choice of chicken or chickpeas um rather than Taco beef on tacos it would be Taco beef or refi beans so we're trying very much to um add and supplement a vegetarian option if you can see in your packets

033that I have include included menus and the menus if you'll notice I two months ago I realized that a lot of people are not really aware of how many vegetarian offerings we really do have and with that we I came up with a little logo there uh that indicates if it's vegetarian it's a little green V and um looking at the elementary menu I mean 65% are vegetarian items so um or they have an vegetarian option so uh at for those who have not been to the um to our schools the high school and the middle school they are food court Concepts um and we have what is a a main menu but we also have a dely we have a pizza station and a grill so all of those areas we have identified all

034the vegetarian offerings I was counting up at the high school uh we have about 35 offerings a day and of that about 15 of those are vegetarian so you know we are continually looking for new ways um to serve our community um I have a very creative uh chef at the high school who uh we we brain storm a lot and she the other day I came in and she came running up with a hummus um pizza with uh it had tomatoes and it had cucumbers and it was phenomenal so we do interesting things like salad pizza we do um for anybody who has not been to our high school we actually make our own pizza dough uh from scratch we we uh sell about a 100 uh pizzas a day that's not slices that's

035actual 18in pizzas um and uh we have great participation our our are I I hear compliments almost every day so that that makes me happy uh and um I hope that we can continue to serve the uh Community the the school Community as we have uh and that um our our students and our staff are are satisfied with uh what we are doing and if not we'll change it so I open it up to any questions you may have Nancy weren't we recently acknowledged by the New Jersey Department of Agriculture for our food service program yes we were we had impressive we had uh a visit back in September um by the secretary of agriculture and he um he was very very complimentary of our program as he should have been and um I really

036have to say that I have an incredible incredible staff and I can never take the credit for what we do every day there are 50 um very dedicated cafeteria Associates who worked very very hard uh to make sure that uh quality uh that that the quality is there and that the customer satisfaction is there so I really do credit my group but um it was quite a compliment it really was so thank you any questions for Nancy from the board members Miss armeno well first of all thank you very much and I'm glad you've allayed Mr chell's fears about carrots versus cookies I think in a in a in a past meeting so that's good I guess it's just a matter of getting used to and and um this Pro this I have two question

037question one is there or how much flexibility is there in in menu preparation do you have a lot or do you have to go by really strict guidelines we have very strict guidelines um if you look in your packet the the last page of uh the provisions uh they are very specific I mean not only do we have to offer vegetables but we have to offer a certain amount of orange red a certain amount of green a certain amount of legumes in a week so it is really very very uh detailed uh what we have to do in terms of regulations truly it could be a several day um program uh that's how how entailed the menu planning has gotten um so it's hard to really mix it up a lot because you don't have

038the you have time constraints as as well sure sure yeah and you know you really need to look at like our elementary schools we really have more heat and serve kitchens so the reality of you know of that is that you're going to see more heat and serve items uh however we do have the most state-of-the-art kitchen here at this high school and we are so grateful to this board of education for provid in us with us it is just a dream to work in and I do think the end result is that we're able to do a better job because of that so thank you for all the support you've given us through the years excuse me thanks anyone else Miss antelis um many years ago when I first uh got on the board

039we actually were in charge of the food service within uh the district and we decided to go outside um and hire an outside contractor but at that time even though we did it we um asked Nancy to stay with us and become our food service director and it's been uphill ever since um I remember my children coming home complaining about the food when they were little hair and I was at board meetings and um we don't hear those complaints anymore I I only hear great things and and we've been a role model because of you for our school lunches so thank you Nancy for what you done thank so muchy thank you Mr tiella yes hi Nancy hi I think you do an excellent job I just want my question at a prior meeting wasn't

040about you or the program my fear was that the regulations that that the federal government's putting on us uh it's creating an atmosphere that is almost impossible for us to be able to operate under and I think you spoke to that with menu planning and things like that and then the flip side of it was I was wondering about how much waste was generated because kids are kids I have I have six of them you know they they they and they do complain that the cookies got smaller I did tell them it wasn't you though that it's a federal government so I'm I'm creating Anti-Federalists I I walk around with a Placer it's not my fault but um but but but that's what I was that's what I was talking to and talking about and

041I think that's just something that the Board needs to be cognizant of that if if the if the federal government isn't going to fund these mandates and they're going to put these regulations on us and then generate waste on top of it that's wasteful you know use of our taxpayers dollars that maybe what we should do is take a look at maybe pulling ourselves out of that program that that doesn't mean getting rid of you or you know or or or stopping our kitchen but but just creating an atmosphere where it's easier to create meals that the kids will eat and that still have you know the all the nutrition in those meals but that isn't just so honorous on on the taxpayer and on on our system um at this point one of the

042things that uh this I I had this conversation with someone recently and uh a federal mandate is that a public school must provide free and reduced meals to students whether they are on the school Food Service program or off the school Pro Food Service program um if they are on the school Food Service program they are are then reimbursed so if the district chose to go off the school lunch program it would then become a cost to the taxpayer uh because they would have to fund the the meals there would be no more reimbursement coming in now as far as regulations um you know this really was an act of Congress so um it's not something that I we have lot of um say in uh but you're right there there has been a real

043concern about the uh acceptability and these rules were uh developed over the course of two years uh from 2010 to 2012 and each year they keep modifying them uh so this year was a tough one because we had to go to 100% % whole wheat uh uh with all of our grains and you know some of the kids just don't like the pizza if it's whole wheat and um but I'm hearing that that may change so we've already had a couple changes to the original uh mandate and I think it really is they're trying to find a place that is acceptable to students uh because you're right at some point it's not helping if uh if students aren't eating the meal so um I think it's it's finding it its place um but I have

044had um a lot of feedback about those cookies and uh you know shrunk them it um you know I it's not my fault when when I started here and Mrs antelis probably remembers this we made our own cookies and I am not kidding when I tell you they were this big they were good n they were they were black and white cookies right no the OD SP oh even before that we made our own batter and they were big and they were good so but no more no anybody who hasn't had a chance to go into our cafeteria and have a lunch there is missing something because it really is a phenomenal program and phenomenal food coming out of your your department so congratulations to everybody over there well we've tried to I mean we

045are we've always been very aware of cost in our in our program uh we do pride ourselves on the fact that we do have I mean amongst the lowest selling price of um any District that we know of uh you know a high school meal is 220 so Elementary is 210 and and we know if you have multiple uh students going to the school that adds up so we've always tried to make that meal a value and um I for for the price I mean it is a a pretty amazing meal our our high school students they can enjoy an entree uh two vegetables two fruit um Middle School it's an entree one fruit two vegetables and the elementary school as well so plus of milk so it's really you know it's really a great

046value Madam yes as Nancy may have alluded to uh we make full application for for federal Commodities whether it be cheese or meat or fresh vegetables from the federal government it's a a timeconsuming process to apply for these food items from the government they all come you know in perfect order in perfect condition they're inspected before we we introduce them to the the food serving process and this saves us about $220,000 a year in what otherwise would be purchases we as Nancy just mentioned we have the lowest prices uh among the lowest prices in the county we've we've had been the lowest price for many decades um through ny's direction we have a point a sales system at all the schools that's where you point and click at the menu item and you get out

047of the line very quickly enabling everybody to eat and socialize during their lunch hour and number four we have exceptionally High participation and that's not just because of the food or the prices it's because of what Nancy brings as the human element that she introduces into the lunch program and Nancy's recognized amongst the state who come in and audit our food service program regularly as being one of the true experts and one of the best directors available so we're very fortunate to have her under our [Applause] employee thank you anyone else have any okay thank you Nancy all right thank you thank you for the opportunity to speak and everybody please have a wonderful holiday yes you too okay at this time we go to the public forum anyone from the public wishing to speak

048to the agenda please come to the microphone and state your name and address for the record Gary's going up Gary yes Gary you have something to say I seeing no one we do have a hand raised we do where through the the agenda anything on the agenda Maran Lester 44 avenu I uh page 12 your new policy concerning trans dender students can you please explain your policy on that I'll take it if you want um beg your pardon I I I can help you with that one uh Dennis let me let me me just begin about the background for the um the policy was created by Strauss Esme who have a series of attorneys who are on The Cutting Edge of law making sure that school districts are up to date on all of the

049legal um impacts on policy and they regularly send us updates that we introduced to the board the transgender policy is one of them um and it aligns very closely with existing District policies already under the affirmative action program and also the uh anti-discrimination programs that we have in the school districts um as more um students are identifying in this category um this specialized policy in a somewhat of a redundant fashion re iterates what's already in the affirmative action policy and the anti-discrimination policy in more specific detail um as far as um as far as restroom facilities that you mentioned the law is very much on the side of the protection of the student however that student identifies they are able to use those facilities that they identify with and they have the law behind them

050and there's plenty of cases where school districts are fined heavily for not complying or pushing Alternatives that made the the child uncomfortable in those circumstances we work closely with our attorneys on this policy from the Inception um Mr ventrello added a very humanistic approach and met with parents and students and made sure that everybody was very comfortable on our campus no matter who they are Dennis well I guess I need to know is there a specific question that you have would would you please come to the microphone we just want to make sure that we answer your question or you concern um I don't want to deny anybody their rights and you said um in as the students but um what is the recourse say for example is a transgender student and um in high

051school or locker rooms and a student is very uncomfortable well what's their recourse for that if they they're very uncomfortable with this situation another student perhaps I think usually that'll fall under the the supervision of the building principle but also you should know that by federal mandate and federal law as well as the anti-segregation laws the anti-discrimination laws Etc is that that transgender student is entitled based upon their identity uh their identification of whatever gender is that obviously they're entitled to use those facilities so whatever gender they're identifying in their head your say we also provide a uh plethora of Staff training professional development training on this particular topic to make sure that everybody is Unified and on the same page in accordance with law and we also have a lot of student workshops and

052student uh training programs and and you would be surprised thus far we have not had uh one instance of anybody objecting to any of the implementation of the policy okay I also in in defense of those students those transgender transgender students and their parents they're very sensitive to the fact of obviously that it might make other people or other students uncomfortable so they're very empathetic about that okay but is there recourse for if there is a complaint from a parent or a student there is some Rec bring it up to your building principal okay absolutely okay thank you anyone else from the public Karen castaldo mtea president for Cypress Point Lane Jackson New Jersey and I'd like to personally thank am me and Ken for their years of service and the hard work that they

053have done for this board and our students always putting kids first and I think Ken you you were part of that kids first slogan years ago uh but you you both have done tremendous work for our students putting them first and for our entire staff and it's been a pleasure to work alongside of you beside you and uh I'd like to take you both to lunch you will receive a phone call we will not go to Anton because that's where we got food poisoning and I'd like to also congratulate Steven Ryback I'd like to take him for coffee but we we have rules and rs that we have to follow and I'd like to also congratulate Jill de Mayo who's back there and wish them the best of luck in your places and again thank

054you for a fantastic job and Nancy you do a bang up job with your food being Italian we had our first liaison meeting when I have a meeting I like to break bread and talk about problems that way and we did that we had a very successful liaa meeting and the food was delicious Nancy your cookies are smaller but they're fatter happy holidays thank you thank you Karen anyone else from the public wishing to speak to the agenda hi coring Masters and I'm Michaela Court I just want to ask M Mr what percentage of students are on freeing reduceed lunch in the district uh total there's about eight and a half% district that's thank you anyone else from the public wishing to speak okay seeing no one we'll go to committee reports are there any

055committees that wish to report this evening Mr noin I know this is the appropriate uh appropriate place to report this this was based on the tech is that considered okay um our Madame board president had asked me to be on a committee that was being formed uh at the high school to discuss the uh technology uh on the onet toone initiative going forward uh I met uh with them on the 123 at 3:00 in the afternoon uh Mr Robert Goodall and Mr Reggie Washington were kind enough to form this committee they made it clear that the reason that they formed this committee was because they want to be uh more transparent they realized that there were maybe a few stumbles on the last onetoone initiative and we're trying to learn from our mistakes so I

056applaud both of them for for being proactive and uh taking the uh the early lead in this um and then uh also there was a great showing of the teachers and the students on that day it was a 3:00 meeting in the afternoon um everyone had a half a day that day but yet they hung around till 3:00 so I I applaud that because that's the kind of input that we need from from the staff because they're the ones that are going to live with this eventually and uh the students too so I I I appreciate that uh the gist of the meeting was that the current iPads they're basically at the end of their their life cycle and they're uh no longer cost effective to Ure uh statement was made that the current insurance

057policy really probably wasn't uh really supposed to be going forward it was almost an oversight on the salesperson of the insurance policy because um it was not really the intent to insure them for another year like this but we did lock it in um the the the biggest failures that they're seeing on these are are currently is that uh that one push button in the center of the iPad um from from use it's just going it's just uh very uh it's a weak point basically and and it's causing a lot of Hardware failures and also the headphone Jacks we're seeing they're seeing a lot of that too um so basically going forward uh we're looking to uh to see what are the alternatives to these uh iPads there were five different platforms that were that

058were handed out for the the the committee to look at we got to touch them and open them and and and play with them a little um the plan is to decide what's going to really meet the needs of both the the teachers and the students going forward the Chromebook uh was a big issue that was definitely discussed um the IT department Mr uh Mr Washington expressed a concern that due to the uh the increased burden on the bandwidth of a Chromebook because uh for those that uh don't know that a Chromebook basically um resides on the whole operating system resides on the cloud unlike uh typical storage like the backpack that we currently use in the high school um that's only for your own unique documents that are that are on the cloud Chromebooks

059put everything on the cloud so if you don't have a broadband connection you can't even fire up your laptop so the concern uh with the Chromebook is even though they are very inexpensive for the initial purchase it's the uh the increased burden on the on the uh bandwidth that's a that's a major concern um item discussed there was definitely a need for a rear-facing camera that was brought up by a student because they do take notes of of the uh this as the teacher is doing the notes on the Blackboard or whatever we call I don't know what we call them blackboards anymore but um but whatever we're doing up there on the on the Smartboard or whatever um so that was that was a key thing um textbook license applications uh that are available

060for the new platform was obviously discussed that that's a big concern uh durability another major concern obviously these these take a beating um weight size obviously we need uh a platform that the students and the teachers are both going to be able to use um biggest one of the biggest concerns was uh the new platforms all seem to be a Windows 8.1 there's been there's a lot of trepidation with the big change over from the IOS operating system to to a Windows operating system um so that we you know we discussed that a little um and it was asked uh you know for the uh for our district to look at other districts to see what they're doing and it was conveyed to us that because we were an early adopter of the onetoone initiative

061that other districts are looking for looking to us to see what we did and what we did right and what we did wrong so there's not too much uh of of resources available out there for that um it was also conveyed that a lot of the districts just jumped on the Chromebooks currently with the park assessments coming up that was a quick down and dirty cheap way to go just to get through this park testing um Next Step going forward uh the vendors will present a tech a tech expo on December 17th um the members of that committee will be invited uh to go to that and then I'll report back after that thank you thank you m Mr noin um while this is not a board committee it is a high school committee but

062I thought it was important to have a presentation to the rest and the public so that they know what is going on with the iPad um initiative so thank you Tom um any other committees okay then we will go to the superintendent's report Mr vento Madame President uh before we get into my report I would like to address the board certainly The Exchange amongst board members at our last board meeting was disturbing to many including parents and residents there's no doubt that it was also upsetting to our student board members it's no secret that the public perception is that we have a divided board an individual members having different views and approaches to their roles as board members my concern is that the impression given to our community is that we cannot function as unified

063board it's apparent that we need to do a better job of coming together and working collaboratively and cooperatively for the sake of the school district and community and by the way please always remember that our meetings are publicized on a local TV station for all the state the recent election process was contentious to say the least political campaigns usually are but let's not forget that each indiv idual who recently elected or was elected to the board was voted in by thousands of residents each board member must recognize the fact that your fellow board members represent thousands of parents and residents as you have your constituency they have theirs together you represent our entire Community that's the Democratic process as members of the Board of Education there is nothing wrong with having differences of opinions or

064approaches or even agendas but the expectation must be that we will work together together with a shared Vision beliefs and values effective school boards lead as a United Team working together with the board secretary and superintendent each from their respective roles with strong collaboration and mutual trust effective School boards have a shared vision of high expectations for student achievement and quality instruction and have clear goals to address that Vision they work together as a team so then how can we become more effective as a board one area is individual responsibility as a board member you are held to a higher standard of behavior and action and you must abide by the code of ethics as a matter of fact the New Jersey school boards Association is seeking amendments to strengthen legislation by which board members

065must abide by standards of ethical conduct and they want to establish even more effective penalties for improper conduct so please know this going forward you must be responsible for your actions with regard to ethics violations the board under the leadership of the president and at a public Board of Education meeting must review annually the code of ethics and roles of a board member this is a mandated this is mandated by our policy and administrative code I also suggest the New Jersey school boards Association be contacted to provide inservice training regarding this matter ethics violations charges are a complete distraction to the important work that needs to be done by you by the board they are counterproductive so please act accordingly thus ensuring there isn't a breach of the code of ethics as a board you're

066now involved in one of your most important responsibilities selecting a new superintendent that's personal to me now more than ever you must put aside your differences and come together as a board to select a new leader one who will represent the students staff parents and residents of our district and Community the monreal community and School District are exceptional we all want an outstanding leader to be our Point person my concern though is that if animosity amongst board members is displayed or if there is less than a united front then this will negatively impact the entire process and the interest of the candidates please consider this especially as you get into the interview phase of the search process our next meeting is in January it's your reorganization meeting you'll be determining who your President and Vice

067President will be who will lead you going forward these are positions with an extraordinary amount of responsibility so please Choose Wisely and then give your full support to these individuals going forward for now let's turn the page let's be more respectful of each other let's be more positive and let's be more collaborative going forward I know I can count on each of you help us all become more effective as a board and I look forward to working with each of you towards this end now on to my report Madame President it is recommended that the members of the monen Board of Education approved Personnel items a through S by consent roll call so move second Chella Mr noin any comments or questions for Mr vello I seeing none we'll have a roll call Mr prese

068oo yes Mr noin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr cherella yes Miss armeno yes Miss anelis yes Mrs K Pano yes madame board president Personnel items a through S passes thank you madam president it is recommended that the members of the mon Township Board of Education approve board action items a through I okay Mr CH missis again any comments or questions for Mr Vell Mr noin just have a quick question on that uh transgender 5756 is that a mandate policy or are we being proactive on that that's mandated okay because it didn't have the M underneath on it should be okay not a problem thank you good question Tom thank you anyone else Mr armino yes could we just have a a brief explanation of the changes uh the revised supervisor of mathematics

069and education technology job description I believe it was a matter of the the title if I Remember by title that's correct I just want to be clear about that okay thank you anyone else okay then we'll have a roll call Mr proso Yes except on H policy 5756 abstain so noted thank you Mr noin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr cherella yes Miss armenio yes M anelis yes m Paul Pono Madam board president board action items a through I passes thank you and Madame board president I just congratulations if Mr Zach moraldo is here as the new art supervisor congratulations to you [Applause] Zach we've got big feet to fill or big shoes to fill follow following um now we will go to the business administrator's report Mr Gorski thank you Madame board

070president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through I be approved by consent roll call so move second Mella Miss anelis are there any questions from Mr Gorski proso Michael um contract renewal ice rental agreement can you explain that please yes and is this going into the next budget it's uh it's currently in the budget uh this is an extension of a contract that's already in existence and this will be the third year of the contract and the year of expiration was June 305 the first year of the contract the hourly rate was 3 $75 an hour the second year $395 an hour the third year $415 an hour this rank provides an area um for our hockey team to uh practice their Sport and

071play uh games and tournaments and such on as we do not have a hockey rank on our campus annually we spend about $3 $40,000 um for rental of ice time is this full this is all coming out of this present uh budget all three years sir yes sir it it's been in the budget since uh Inception and it still remains in the budget also associated with that you know you have the ice rank rental as I mentioned before you have stiens for the staff you have uniforms okay so this whole contract is in the present budget this contract cost is in the current budget correct not the the extension though is not every it it is budgeted for it is budgeted for if the board was to deny this third year of the ice rink

072uh we would have a surplus of about $40,000 in the budget thank any other questions M armeno yeah going but we but tonight what we're we're not just voting on this third year we're voting on an extension for another three years no we're only voting on the third year and then the contract expires and then it would have to be renegotiated oh I'm sorry I thought this was a renegotiation I thought it was an extension for the fourth year going forward no no next year will be okay and then we anticip well there's no sense in anticipating okay then I I apologize because when I was when I was reading the contract I thought that we were committed we are committed until 2014 to this yes it was the I thought we were we we're

073extending we're I'm sorry approving every year no just the third year just okay just the third year um from July 1st 14 to June 305 okay that's why I didn't understand I thought it was a three-year lease that's what I thought it was no no okay already it's already been in existence but it needs an annual approval okay so it does need an so the first and the SEC the first year it was approved annually the second okay yes my my understanding was that we were extending it Beyond 2015 tonight that's that was my confusion okay no no it requires an annual approval okay thank you very much anyone else comments or questions seeing none we'll have a roll call Mr proso yes Mr noin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Cher yes

074M Areno yes anelis yes Mrs Cola Pano yes mam board president board action items a through I passes that concludes my report thank you okay we will go to board president's report uh first superintendent search update as of today there are 49 applications taken out by those people looking to apply for the superintendent position in our district I understand Mr ventrella was not one of those 49 people that is correct yeah the compl the completion date for all the applications to be in is January 9th 2015 so we have about another three or three and a half weeks or so the final report from the superintendent search input session from the community the staff and the administration is complete the online survey data has been compiled and this information will be reviewed after the reorg

075meeting in January so we're still moving forward with the search mad Madam president if I may also to the entire Community you should just be understanding of the fact that if you have 49 applic was 49 yes if you have 49 applications out there as candidates that are that are interested in the superintendency here in Monroe that is an extraordinarily High number you should know that uh the between the economy between the salary caps all of that out there is actually creating a cloud over the superintendency uh positions if there are that many people out there that are interested that's a plus to say that there's something very special here in Monroe Township um just want you to be aware of that also is that and and certainly I I can't say anything other than

076this if there are residents if there are people out there if there are teachers out there Etc this is your time to let the Board of Education know of your interest of maybe what you're looking for in a superintendent if you didn't make the deadline as far as you know um maybe what was on the website whatever the survey may be if you have an interest in Sharing something with the board the board would want to know that there's no doubt about that this is the most important decision for the entire Community just keep that in mind but again 49 people says a lot for our community thank you man president thank you Mr Mello um I'd like to speak to an issue that occurred during The Other Board business portion of our last Board

077of Education meeting in which there was some criticism as to how it was handled Mr Kaufman brought up a letter that had come to the attention of the board members and his comments were not well received by some board members and a few members of the public I've always prided myself on being ready to handle situations that might arise during board meetings so I had received attorney advice just in case this letter was brought up by anyone as I stated at that time and I am stating it again a board member has the right to speak on any subject that they feel is importance to the board Andor the school district the board president has no right to shut down a board member that letter that was mentioned by Mr Kaufman was not a confidential

078document it was not a Personnel matter nor was it a personal matter therefore there was no legal reason to discuss it in Clos session unless to receive attorney advice which no board member requested at that time there was mentioned that the attorney advice was wrong unfortunately we can't always pick and choose excuse me which attorney advice we are going to accept so I went back and checked again both our attorney and New Jersey school boards will confirm that the this the issue was handled correctly and in the appropriate manner a board member cannot be shut down just because you don't like what they are saying what happens all the time on this board is that when you don't like the message you shoot the messenger we talk about transparency but it only seems to apply

079to certain situations the problems we have on this board is not about leadership doing the right thing can sometimes be very difficult put anyone else up here and you'll have the same problems the problem we have is about a board that can't or won't work together it's about who I want to work with and who I don't want to work with it's about a lack of respect for the leadership position we are supposed to be a team and not two separate boards working against each other decisions are supposed to be made at the table and not behind closed doors this board will only work well when every member of our B board learns what roles are and decides to work together for the benefit of the district and especially our children it's about following the

080code of ethics at all times and knowing what we can and cannot do it's about following our policies it's about respecting the recommendations coming from the superintendent and the business administrator it's about communicating our concerns to the administration in appropriate manner it's about respecting the opinions of others even when we don't agree it's about a lack of trust it's about accepting the decisions made by the board as a whole and then letting it go it's about working for the whole community and not just one segment of the community it's about being independent thinkers and putting the needs of our children first and the past year or so our district has received a lot of state and National recognition families are moving into Monroe because of our school district where we are now is because of

081good leadership and proper planning and that doesn't happen overnight in the next year we have so many more important decisions to make the search for the next superintendent a redistricting proposal a possible referendum the one-on-one iPad initiative getting ready for the park Assessments in January the majority of our board will have less than two years on this board and with all these important decisions coming up it's time that we all need to decide to work together as a team I hope that all of us take some time over the holiday break to reflect on this past year and decide to make some positive changes for the sake of our children that concludes my board president's report and we will go to Other Board of Education business missis um like to follow up a little bit

082with what you were talking about um I also read this letter and I wasn't at the last meeting and I'm very concerned about what I see in here um not so much about a board member harassing um an employee but about doing it in front of a 14-year-old child inappropriate behavior um I'm not going to debate the facts here I'm not going to ask questions but what I think should happen is and I'm not sure if Miss C castaldo is still in the audience but any staff member if you are out somewhere and you are confronted by a board member you can see us on TV and you are ask these similar questions it's okay for you to say this is an inappropriate conversation I'm uncomfortable with it and walk away our staff should not

083be harassed when they are out in public um I think there's a lot of training that needs to be done here I've heard the word transparency for the last eight years by a board member this is the second time this board member has represented themselves in the public as we the board the first time I can understand didn't know the second time was blatant um if I was staying on this board tonight I would be holding uh asking for a motion to file ethics charges I think this is way above what I've ever seen on this board it's a disgrace anybody else on the board Mr Kaufman so there's no way I'm letting you two out without saying a couple of things right uh first is Ken uh you haven't been here nearly as long

084as Amy because nobody has been here nearly as long as um but I just want to thank you personally for all the Insight the the personal feelings the the comedy relief that I know I need at many board functions um to get through some of these uh difficult times and uh for everything that you do in the community not just here in the board but outside the community uh thank you for everything Amy I forget that Amy doesn't know the first time I actually saw Amy was when my kids were still at Barkley Brook School and they were getting their blue ribbon and she was there speaking on behalf of the bo I think you were board president at the time I I don't even know but um too long ago back in the day

085when that that school was half the size it was I don't think anybody in this room including myself can understand and appreciate the amount of weight that Amy Has Lifted over these number of years being on this board uh for about superintendent searches that's that's that's water under the bridge but just literally if you think back of how this District looked back then when I was a parent and I had to be in Barkley Brook in that gym in that sweat Hall with all the other parents for back to school night and and where we are today the people in this audience cannot even comprehend where we were so for that Amy thank you for all those years and sorry to see you both leaving and uh you know hopefully you're you're go on to

086do other things here so God bless thank you anyone else wishing to speak okay seeing no one Madam oh Mr kski Madam board president as board secretary I was asked by Mr Po Mr Doug po to read a statement and with your permission if I may sure Doug PO requests that current and future members of the board consider his desire to serve as president recognizing that he has served only two years on the board he is cognizant of the limitations that such limited experience provides however if elected he believes that the more experienced members would lend both their support and expertise to him with the goal of helping Foster the best education that our community can provide if elected he would work to achieve the following goals number one develop a more collegial board one

087in which all members demonstrate respect for each other number two cultivate a more inclusive board where each member's input and opinions are sought and respected number three provide for differences of opinion where members May disagree without being disagreeable number four support the goals set by the board based on itself evaluation which is done annually number five employ resources available through New Jersey school boards Association to improve the board's ability to work together for the betterment of the district as well to provide training that will assist all members especially new ones in the performance of their duties number six Elevate the importance of improving student achievement by incorporating reports on curriculum educational initiatives and student outcomes into every monthly board meeting whereas this goal is of highest importance its accomplishment will occur concurrently with that of

088the first five Mr Po realizes that none of the above will be accomplished without every member being willing to join his effort he believes that it is more important important that we strive to build up the board then look for opportunities to tear down fellow members he ask that you consider this statement as you reflect on whom you wish to lead the board in 2015 again the following statement is from Mr Po thank you thank you Mr Kaufman sorry I forgot very quick after I stop um this is the end of the year so this is my statement uh is there anybody else thinking about running for president that we know of me you I I think Mr interim you want to be interim president yeah yeah you got twoo much forget about you go

089okay just want to [Music] know and and I forgot something in my report too um the board self- evaluation less than half the people have have um put their input in so at this time we should be doing this before the end of the school year in order for us to move forward with the Board of Education um so if you would like to put your input in we could use it in January okay close session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into close session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa ten 4-6 through Ken col 4- 21 to discuss the following subjects Personnel matters and Hib incident number 10 the discussion conducted in Clos

090session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for con confidentiality no longer exists I need a motion Mo second Mr noin and Mr Chella all in favor opposed extensions and at this time the board will move into close session okay hey I'm garbage at this time the board will move back into public session and I believe Mr ventrello has a couple of um resolutions yes it is recomended that the Board of Education approve one the suspension with pay of mechanic James Lincoln retroactive to December the 3rd 2014 through December 10th 2014 and two the termination of Mr Lincoln's employment by the board of effective December 11th 2014 the superintendent and the business administrators board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action of

091the board of education so moves second Mr cherella mrin comments or questions none roll call please oh did you have Mr proso yes Mr noin yes Mr calman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Chella yes Mr Miss armenio yes Miss anelis yes Mrs K Pano Madame board president motion passes thank you resolution number two it is recommended that the Board of Education approv one the suspension of substitute bus driver Irene Covington from her driving duties eff of December the 11th 2014 through December 17th 2014 the interim superintendent and the business administrator board secretary hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action of the Board of Education no moved a second Mr nin Mr proso any comments or questions roll call please yes Mr proso yes Mr noin yes Mr calman yes

092Mr zareski yes Mr Chira yes Miss armenio yes Miss anelis yes Mrs colano Madame board president motion passes thank you and that I have report okay then this time we go to the public forum again anyone from the public wishing to speak please come to the microphone state your name and address for the record good evening Ira tesler 11 OT drive just like to wish everybody a happy healthy holiday season look forward to a wonderful 2015 I'd like to Bri very briefly thank Ken and Amy for all their service all over the years uh it's a sometimes well a lot of times it is a thankless job but we appreciate your service for the kids and I also like to mention and uh thank uh Kathy as board president over the many years since when

093Lou ask you didn't throw your hat in the ring I assume you're not going to seek that position next year as a logical conclusion so I'd like to thank you again for all your service as board president over the years again it's a thankless and a difficult job and we appreciate your your work thank you thank you thank you anyone else from the public sorry Lou Masters and I'm Mela Court um I wanted to commend Nancy but she left so good job Nancy um oh she's right there oh she she's hugging but she's hugging she said she was going to leave before sorry good job man forget it it's now it's ruined uh I just wanted to make sure the board is keeping on top of the growth if you've noticed the Delta at Oak

094Tree almost equals the Delta at the entire Middle School um which is a pretty telling statement we had a um a zoning board meeting Michelle was there and um the Builder added was it 17 more units or 17 Town yeah he added actually 17 more tow houses then took away uh commercial ratables which was the uh 10,000 square feet of commercial ratables and added 17 units so that's that's a big deal even if it's one per it's 7 more down there so that's that's a pretty big deal um let's see oh the tech meeting with no was talking about would would the public be allowed to attend that um that is Mr Goodall's um high school committee so if anybody has an interested in being on that I would contact Mr Goodall at the high

095school okay sorry and again I want to say congratul or great job not congratulations to Amy and Ken it's it is a very thankless job and as a lot of hours put in um I think you did a great job as a parent and a taxpayer great job and I hope to see you again doing more bigger things um also congratulations to Steve uh on the election and Jill and Kathy what Ira said was true good job Kathy thank you everybody have a nice H thank you L anyone else from the public okay seeing no one our next scheduled Board of Education meeting is Monday January 5th 2015 7:00 p.m. at the Monro Township High School which is our reorg meeting I want to wish everybody a very happy and healthy holiday season and look

096forward to seeing you next year motion to adjourn Mr Mella second by miss anelis all in favor oppose meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.