001order Mr thorney would you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all Mr Gorski roll call please miss armeno here Mr Braverman here miss de Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs col Pano here Mr nosin here Mr Po here Mr proso here Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Mr board president you have a quarum this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted April 2015 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and
002filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski at this time uh Mr Thorne will you give us the student report uh thank you Mr P uh good evening members of the board and of the public uh given the recent board meeting my report will be fairly brief tonight some of the elementary schools within the district have organized collections for the midd six County Food Bank also in order of autis Autism Awareness Month schools across the district have been organizing activities including fundraiser opportunities Barkley Brook and Brookside Elementary Schools help the variety show on April 24th at the Middle Middle School's Performing Art Center the M Township High School drama club had recently put on a production of Young Frankenstein running from this past Thursday through yesterday in the high school's Performing Art
003Center that was open to the community as a whole students currently enrolled in advanced placement courses will be participating in the AP exam testing during the month of May uh now I know Mr gdal gave a brief presentation about the AP courses and opportunities last meeting so I'm not going to take a long time to address this however these course offerings further prepare students for college allow us to further challenge ourselves and allow us to possibly earn college credit and or Advanced staing uh standing in terms of introductory courses in postsecondary education uh and it is a um it's a a very fortunate opportunity that we have these courses at the high school and I know that um all of us who are currently taking or have taken AP courses are very appre itive of
004this opportunity additionally some um some students in the high school have been able to qualify for the DECA International Career Development conference uh where these students are competing in the next step of their competitive events in business finance and marketing related categories seminars and keynote speaker events are also taking place as well at this conference finally Monroe students in the New Jersey youth and government program uh had recently attended the annual conference from Friday through yesterday Sunday April 16th the program serves as a mock simulation of the state government and state politics where students have the opportunity uh or have participated in the legislative program the judicial program the executive branch press Lobby course or the executive response committee uh this program primarily took p uh took place at the state house uh which we
005have the privilege to utilize and there were also uh some guest speakers including United States Congressman Donald Payne Jr uh and for New Jersey governor Christy Todd Whitman and uh that concludes the student board members report thank you thank you Mr thorney we'll be going to the first public forum but before doing that I would just like to remind uh anyone coming to the microphone that uh this part of the public forum is restricted to what is on the agenda this evening any participant coming to the mic microphone should give their name and place of residence your statement should not exceed 3 minutes and you're asked to speak no more than once on the same topic all statements are to be directed to the presiding officer and addressing or questioning individual members of the board
006is not permitted we will be having a presentation on the budget for next year immediately after the public forum and you will have an opportunity at that time to also ask questions so please keep that in mind if you wish to speak do we have anyone wishing to comment or question the agenda tonight all right I see no one interested in that so uh we will move on to the public budget hearing and the final adoption Mr Gorski thank you Mr Bo since the preliminary budget hearing where the public was introduced to the tentative 1516 school budget uh the Board of Education had nine members and one abstention on passing the tenative budget resolution There's an opportunity between the preliminary budget hearing and tonight's final adoption for changes to be made or recommended uh to
007the finance committee and um I'm pleased to announce that there were none um I take that as a reflection of the hard work that all the stakeholders had in the preparation of this year's budget from the school levels where everything was zero based from scratch um literally the teachers and the principls and the vice principals started with an empty shopping cart making determinations what they needed for next year by inventorying their supply cabinets by providing for an additional 267 new students that we anticipate next year um we had some favorable aspects to this budget our energy projections that are done by professionals uh are significantly down from the prior year ratables were also very favorable and that's another indication of the growth that we're experiencing in Township ratable growth helps a a real significant downward
008push on taxes and therefore the information that is posted on our website including the userfriendly budget for the 15 16 school year um summary of revenues that's a comparative summary to last year a summary of Appropriations PowerPoint presentations all of which is much more than the law requires we we try to be as open and as transparent and invite the Public's input into the budget process as possible all of that remains um tonight on change and the result of the budget by going to cap which is required for uh not only to to educate the new students but also to do a major construction project that the high school I'm sorry the monre township Middle School is uh the reasons why we have to go to cap the consequence on taxes is a 4 and
009a. half cent increase which is $138.4 on the average assessed home and as we mentioned in the last meeting had it not been for direct Appropriations attributable to student growth the growth of the budget by itself would be 2.6 or $81.60 19,000 which is provided by the township so this budget provides for all the needs of the growing student body um addresses our aging facilities and does so in a very tax um responsible Manner and um that said and also because there were no changes from the preliminary I'll turn it over to the board and if there's any questions I'll be happy to entertain uh thank you Mr Gorski first of all are there any questions from any members of the board Mr nasin just want to thank uh Mr Gorski for all his hard
010work uh the budget is uh I feel um a very tight budget we have have to work within the constraints that we have namely the 2% cap to do uh to do what we're doing uh I think it's $ 1.9 million uh you know expansion at the middle school with five classrooms uh to do that and take in an anticipated 267 students all without having to uh go out for a referendum is is quite remarkable in my opinion so I want to thank you for that um my next question though is what what is the next step now does this go to the county or has it already gone there or just is there any other timeline or this is just it um good question as indicated um for the Public's benefit we have a
011budget timeline which is on the website also I forgot to mention that before tonight is the final budget adoption after tonight assuming that I have the majority of the members and support of the adoption I will then transmit the budget again to the county office with the certified resolution tonight um um passing the budget and then we will wait for an electronic communication from the county office that the final budget is approved now being that there have not been any changes from the final from the preliminary and the preliminary was approved very quickly for advertising with the complements of the County office I expect that turnaround time to be very quick and then we can begin the process of posting the budget in the accounting system begin the per uh um purchase orders for the
012construction project that the Middle School that you mentioned because a lot of things like doors and windows have a lead time and also begin the arduous process of Staffing any other comments or questions from the board okay how about the public any members of the public oh I'm sorry Miss armeno U Mr Gorski just uh for just a reiteration and for or the for the Public's um standing uh when we go to cap there are some things that the when when we get a higher enrollment does that change the calculation of the cap yes last year the state um gave us an additional $133,000 of growth to the cap because of enrollment it's an automatic budget adjustment this year it was more material than we had anticipated um and that comes from the state's trend
013line analysis of our enrollment right but that and that's very hard to anticipate ahead of time right but but what the state gives us as 13,000 that that that doesn't translate into uh something even for us it still costs us more money for the more students we enroll is that correct yes uh it costs us more money yes because the way the tax levy cap works is you take your preceding year general fund tax levy you then adjust it for automatic enrollment increase that's calculated by the state you then uh multiply it by 2% increasing it for the next year and then you're allowed a health insurance update those are the adjustments that are applicable to Monroe um generally that would take a 2% cap to about a 3% cap with those adjustments but that
014does not offer any any relief for Monroe because of course then that that requires you to raise a higher Levy to support the schools what we've talked about our need being all along was more state aid more Equitable state aid funding but also the increase in um the development over in the community itself uh has increased our enrollment sort of exponentially a lot more than surrounding areas we're getting almost 200 children a year in the last few years correct yes the de Dem demographer calculated 267 new students expected for next year and that's material and that that actually go goes to um when we say new sections there if if people look at the agenda and I not necessarily on this one but in the past when it says new sections being added what that
015means is like a new classroom right that's exactly correct and we have to hire teachers and sometimes par that's correct Paras and additional and that increases our our position in terms of our budgeting issues yes ma'am and and just one more thing we're actually not because of of some of the things that are not involved in the cap we actually are going beyond the 2% right right it's going slightly above 2% because of the enrollment adjustment which again is automatic and a health care cost adjustment and that was due to our most recent contract negotiations is that correct in in 2014 that's part of it um you know health insurance is a budget all by itself and it's a process that we engage in starting in December where we get the preliminary rates from Horizon
016Blue Cross Blue Shield and as we mentioned they control 70% of the New Jersey Marketplace and it's basically take it or leave it uh the board um changed health insurance brokers two years back and we've had much more leverage with the new broker um negotiating with Horizon this year Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield projected initially a 16% increase in our premiums that's on a $20 million account so that's substantial that's almost our full growth of the budget by itself we negotiated that down with the broker's help down to eight and then with the staff's contributions which are a a fruit of negotiations that 8% dropped down to about 2.8 a very manageable increase for a budget our size and then just one more comment about um you've Ren renegotiated some loans some bonds is that
017is that saving in the 2015 2016 budget or part of that savings part of that savings is yes that's correct any is there I'm sorry I believe the figure that I gave to the finance committee was that saves about $200,000 a year in interest costs and it will do so for the next 20 years and these two series that we just refunded recently saves about $3.5 million on a Net Present Value basis over time yeah over the 20 year duration of the bonds okay thank you anyone else from the board Mr PSO Michael what was the amount to be paid by the taxpayer what what was that increase by you can give me a percentage taxes for the general fund are increasing 3.88% $3,449 th000 3.88% taxes for The Debt Service fund is substantially higher
018because as I mentioned at the preliminary meeting last year we we appropriated $2.5 million of bond Surplus to reduce what otherwise would have to be raised in The Debt Service budget with that fund and that Surplus extinguished there was only $275,000 of surplus remaining for it to be closed out so there was a need this year to to raise more to the the normal amount for The Debt Service fund without that stimulus coming from Bond Surplus the amount in a budget paid by the taxpayer increased 6 and a half% this year beg a pardon the amount of the budget to be paid by the taxpayer increased 6 and a half% in the aggregate for the two funds that is exactly correct is that because of the bond we have no yes it's a it's a
019disparity In the comparison which is unfair comparing this year to last year because again last year you reduce the amount that you would have to raise from the taxpayers by $2.5 million this year you could only reduce it by $275,000 so although that shows a a substantial increase this was planned for all along and it has coincided with the rable uh re um normalization in town and the growth which offset that so we have a linear tax um increase year toe and we don't wind up with these spikes any other comments or questions from the board okay comments or questions from members of the public Robert roach at Team mfield Boulevard um as Mrs Armenia was talking about the 2% cap and as Mr Gorski just indicated the uh the general fund did increase by
0203.88% which is almost double the 2% cap so the 2% cap is sort of a a non- entity type of thing but uh one of the things that U I found little concerning and I recognized that it had an issue because of the um the bonds the money's from bonds being used for Debt Service but the tax rate has increased this year 7.67% and that's really difficult for some of the older people that are on Social Security in this community and I really do feel that it's incumbent upon the board when they're looking at the budget to consider the the uh uh the income level of C certain people in this this area and you know many of us can afford it but there's many that can't so you know you're you're really putting some
021people really really in tough Financial Straits and I mean I know the budget's going to be improved and all that kind of stuff but going forward I really think you have to have to consider this and I know I you have a tough job trying to balance the educational needs with the with the people who are paying it and I know the whole problem is is the is the uh State not giving the funding and I'm you know I don't know what's going to happen with the funding whether we're going to get what's promised because of the the whole problem with the Pension funds and you know so uh the the state may just say hey we're going to cut down some of this funding and put more money in the Pension funds and we
022may get more be getting less than we're even anticipating so it's a really difficult problem but there's a lot of people that are really having difficult times making that meet thank you for com your comments Mr roach anyone else okay seeing no other uh people coming up to the podium I will now uh close the public session and Mr Gorski you have a resolution to read yes thank you this resolution is for the adoption of the 201526 school budget it is recommended that the members of the Monroe Township Board of Education approve the following amounts and resolution for the 1516 final budget be it resolved by the Monro Township Board of Education that the 201516 final general fund budget be adopted in the amount of 13,725 261 and a final general fund local tax levy
023in the amount of 92,3 18,6 45 inclusive of the allowable adjustment for health care costs of $240,600 and a final special Revenue Fund in the amount of 1,119 N3 and a final debt service budget in the amount of 10,822 666 and a final debt service local tax levy in the amount of $9 million $863,000 whereby the final 20156 budget totals 115 M 65990 and whereas the Mona Township Board of Education has been notified of state aid amounts and whereas such a state aid amounts are for the 201516 budget categorical special categorical special education Aid is $2,485 and for the 1516 categorical security Aid is $92,500 and for the 1516 categorical Transportation Aid is $496,500 and for the 1516 Debt Service Aid is $679,500 state aid consisting of Park Readiness Aid of $58,900 and per pupil
024Grant Aid of $58,900 and whereas the mon Township Board of education has estimated a state aid amount pursuant application and for 201516 the estimated extraordinary Aid amount is $214,400 and whereas the state's failure to fully fund the school refunding form Act of 2008 as well as other factors has provided insufficient financial support for programs and services contained in the base budget necessitating the application of $239,999 of unused spending author already to be included in the base budget and that said needs will be completed by the end of the budget year will not be deferred or incrementally completed over a longer time and where is the school district by law 0147 policy 3440 policy 4440 and njac 6A col 23 B- 1.2b provides that the Board of Education shall establish in the annual school budget a
025maximum expenditure amount that may be allotted for such travel and expense reimbursement for the 20156 school year now therefore be it resolved that the Monro Township Board of Education hereby establishes the school district travel maximum for the 20156 school year at the final sum of $158,400 and be a further resolve that the school business administrator shall track and record these costs to ensure that the maximum amount is not exceeded and there are now for let it be resolved that the superintendent of schools and the business administrator board secretary file the required documents with the executive county superintendent so move second so moved second first uh Kathy Kon second by Mr nin any further questions or discussion by members of the board okay we'll then go to a roll call vote Miss armeno um before I
026vote I just want to make a small mention of recognizing the enormity of the budget and how difficult it might be to um get everything in order um I still think that we're reaching a Tipping Point in our community uh and in consideration of of people in the community who in some cases can't afford to pay the taxes and are moving out um in my business I've seen people in my career of 30 years I have not seen so many people buying down uh real estate um as they've had to in the last few years since the last recession and the recession hasn't isn't over for most people so um it's it's been a very difficult decision for me I'm going to say yes to the budget however I would like my colleagues to really
027consider when we do our goals in in August to consider our spending habits and certainly not hurt the children in any way but I think there are things we need to review a little bit more diligently but yes and I and I hope we um can control the budget a little better next year thank you Mr Braverman the truncated version of this vote is yes Mr zareski yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs Cole Pano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso I agree with Michelle but only I'll vote no so noted Mr Rybeck yes Mr poy yes Mr board president adoption of the 15 16 budget passes and I would like to thank all the board members for their contributions to this budget it was a very uh difficult process beginning with the
028budget philosophy meeting over last summer we've had many um good finance committee meetings where a lot was discussed and um I believe this to be a very responsible budget one where we have really cut to the bone as much as possible um anticipating the 267 new students that is again a half a school worth of new students coming next year and with a tax rate that is below the median and and thanks to uh Mr ventrillo and Dr alvic for their contributions as well thank you sir clearly it isn't uh easy to uh put together a budget for our district uh in light of our growing enrollments and the lack of uh outside Aid uh and I do commend our Administration for being conscious of those demands in terms of the process and uh I
029voted yes because I do feel that uh looking at the particulars of the budget it it was about as good as we could expect to do uh I understand the sentiments of Mrs armenio that uh it would certainly be nice if we could find some way to reduce uh expenditures uh with the demands particularly at the middle school of the construction we're having to do there uh and and not having a referendum a separate referendum to cover that uh I I I think we're rather fortunate that we can provide for those changes to accommodate the children in the Middle School uh within that budget uh at this time we're going to have a discussion of the onetoone instructional initiative I believe this was the recommendation of the finance committee at last week's meeting I'm not
030sure who would like to begin uh to comment on that uh the one toone initiative essentially uh for for purposes of the public it refers to uh having a u a computerized device uh presently it's the iPad uh for each student in the High School uh that they are using in an instructional capacity uh this is now we're wrapping up I believe the fourth year of that initiative if I'm not mistaken and uh so we need to uh make a determination as to what direction we'll be moving in uh for next year and possibly subsequent years so anyone wishing to make a comment on this particular topic Mr noin um I'd like to start off have uh first of all I have a question um in the presentation that we were given at the finance
031and I believe it was given at the curriculum also um the price of the individual iPads are uh $4,980 um $498 does that include the Apple Care uh of $99 and let me just interrupt before we get an answer to that uh Mr Washington could you join us at the table over here because I'm sure that we're going to need your expertise uh in in answering some of these questions and uh Mr thorney could you possibly pass that microphone over so that it'll be convenient for Mr Washington thank you thank you uh would you like that question repeated sir okay could you I'm sorry um I I know we're showing the the uh iPads cost at $498 each does that cost include the $99 of Apple Care per unit yes sir it does it does
032okay that that's great um I have big concerns with this idea of a three-year life cycle um I am definitely on board I feel that the onetoone initiative is the way to go however we also have to keep in mind that $1.6 million every three years is very very expensive for the for our taxpayers um what I would like to see or actually like to ask you is there any way that we can reuse any of these I know there were some concerns about damaged power buttons on some of these um I went online and it's a $60 repair for for a button it's um 190 for a glass screen $85 for a charger port repair 65 for a front camera repair $80 for a battery placement and 85 for a volum volume button now
033it seems to me that if that is the primary problems that we're experiencing with these existing ones that if we could go through and take Pro maybe 50% and hold on to them only purchase another thousand going forward for the next year service the ones if they need if they need servicing I I believe we would still be ahead of the game at that point um and if you're tell telling me that there are none that are serviceable then I almost have to say are we looking at the right platform because to me a three-year life expectancy uh is just not acceptable in in our situation it's it gets very costly and I have to think that it's just not a good platform at that point um so I was just wondering what what some
034of your thoughts are Mr Washington concerning the uh three-year lifespan that's uh simply has been our experience with the iPad if you're asking me how many of them will be serviceable after this year I won't know that until we collect them at the end of the year uh historically we find that uh when we collect the iPads at the end of the year 25% of them have the crack screens and uh many of the kids continue to use them because they don't want to be assessed that that penalty of $50 to to repair it so I don't know how many will be serviceable what I do know is the iPads that we issued out this year uh we thought they were in good working order but by the time many of the students started using
035them they would uh report to us that the home button wasn't working nor the digitizer wasn't working and it just appeared to me that the lifespan of the iPad is about 3 years uh beyond that I don't see the device as being something that we could I could stand in front of teachers and say I can guarantee you that that device is going to work um there's only three buttons on the iPad the home button the onoff button and the volume button so those three moving parts we out and that's what I have seen from the four years of experience with the iPad yeah I mean I I totally understand that and that does make sense that those would be the parts that are wear out but when you hear that it's only you know
036$80 for power button repair versus $498 for a new unit and to me that's the advantage of sticking with the platform that we're on if we if we only wanted to replace uh 75% of them we can do that because we're not looking for for new functionality in the in the new platform we're basically duplicating what we have we're not gaining anything other than you obviously the IP iPad Airs are are are a little quicker but that's really that's that's not the big issue here the big issue is the non-service ability of the existing iPads sir um is that that's accurate correct that is correct sir okay um and I I know that um we did negotiate this deal but I mean even without just a regular consumer going online uh we can get an
037ipid air for $449 so to say that the iPad you know with the Mac care is roughly $100 a unit um it's not like a fantastic fantastic deal when you're buying 2200 of these um my other concern is on the teacher side we're buying uh 200 MacBook Pros and 200 iPad Airs for the teachers now if if any of the units should be in pristine shape it should be the faculties so I don't understand why we just can't say okay again we're on the same platform why can't we just keep the MacBook and the iPads existing for the faculty that would save 200 and I would like to possibly see or look into what is the chance what are the chances of negotiating a four-year Apple Care with um Apple uh we can certainly look
038into negotiating a 4-year Apple Care protection plan to see if that's even offered uh but as far as the MacBooks themselves the teachers's current MacBook that unit is no longer manufactured which makes it very difficult to get parts for it in addition to that much of the training that we do with apple is geared towards the current product so there are some things the new Macbook can do that the old one simply can't do so when the teachers are going through their professional development it puts some challenges in front of them because the the machines that they have which are four years old now and will be five we decided to keep keep them going into next year there will be some functionality that it will not be able to do but if the if
039the person doing the PD knows that he just wouldn't train them on that section of it that's correct we will have to inform them ahead of town and we have to tailor the training to Monroe uhuh um so I mean that that's pretty much all I have I like I said I think the i iPad initiative is a great thing but I have to really question when I hear that we're having servicing issues already uh and the units are only three years old uh I have to question is that the best choice for our students and our teachers if we're having service issues only after three years thank youo uh Mr nin uh pointed out something and and Mr Washington when you said this it sort of also made an impression on me the current
040product I mean I suppose any technology that we get that would all be an issue but it seems that we will always be behind the eightball and not always having the current the the current product I mean that it's almost like um a planned obsolesence in technology that companies especially big ones like and and I'm I'm not disparaging the choice I'm just trying to figure out if it's our best choice um I if the if these products become obsolete fashion I mean I would like to see something like four years because that's how the students would be in the in the program for four years in the high school schol for for years that would almost be ideal hopefully five if we could really make it work but also um so so the fact that
041that products are obsolete I'm wondering if there's other types of technology that don't go that don't get obsolete that quickly that you've researched well the the products we research uh there were mainly three uh different operating system the Macintosh operating system Windows and the Google Chrome obviously if you've been reading any of the trade Publications Windows is in in a little bit of a state of flux with the current uh OSB 81 but Windows 10 is on the verge of being released probably be released around July so that that's um something we haven't seen yet it's new we don't know the other product was the Google Chromebook uh we took a look at that product uh we came up with a list of requirements that the product whatever we chose had to meet and that
042those list of requirements came from teachers and students I'm not a certificated educator so I depend greatly on teachers and administrators telling me what are the educational needs of the school once they tell me that I try and come up with a product that I feel can meet their needs that's the first requirement even if it causes us to do a little bit more work we got to meet the needs the educational needs of the kids so with with that list of requirements we we looked at those platforms and overwhelmingly the teachers and and students said the Apple product met their needs so that's what we kind of went with do do we have a a standardized list of those needs for the high school because right now we're just talking about what the high
043school that is correct right so is that standardized that all the teachers or the administrators are on board with that list of criteria well I would never say all of anything it just never happens but the overwhelming majority of the teachers who who I spoke with or who we surveyed or who participated in that's what they said um Mr Po may I ask a question of Dr alvid in this certainly yeah we're discussing um and Dr alage was part of the curriculum so so can maybe you answer that question about the standards like are we providing this are are we are we looking at at the technology and saying okay this is as close to our needs as possible or are we going out and saying this is what our criteria is and we would
044like to find the technology that matches our criteria is it vice versa the second the the first thing you said we sent when we were um soliciting proposals from all of the vendors um we sent them our list of criteria that came from the students and the teachers in and including included with that was also our PD requirements our professional development requirements that we wanted um and then the the vendors came back with their proposals Meeting those requirements and um so you're saying that the iPad met most of the requirements that we have that we need at all of them met all of them yes okay and in terms so that's the hardware correct yes how about the software um will it when we're talking about the cost of the hardware that doesn't include the
045ongoing cost of the software that that is used for that right well fortunately for us on the iPad once you buy an app you own the app so we can move that app from one device to another and there is no additional cost only time you will get an additional cost is if the enrollment increases well what about the ebooks and what about the Pearson software that goes now books are different than apps books you have to buy per student every year unless a kid repeats a course then they can keep that same book but books you have to buy in most of the books are $4.99 each that's the uh ebooks that is the iBook the iBook yes sir yes ma'am and they change every year so the well the books belong to the
046kid so if if one we buy say we buy 21 year and those kids Advanced to the next grade level and now you got a new group of 20 you have to buy two 20 new licenses of that book so the book belongs to the student not the device but I'm sorry forgive me for being OB to but say that again about the licensing every year we have to buy a licensing agreement for to for the use of those books for the use of those books if that's given that it's a different student the the book belongs to the student not the device but years ago if we had a hard cover book the book came back to the school so that's not the case anymore we're essentially buying a new book every year with
047the iBooks that's correct but the cost is cheaper for the license than it is than it would be if we bought hard cover book not over time probably right depends usually our textbooks last for about five years and then we read look then we look at them to see if they still meet our needs but if a book is let's say $20 they're not $20 okay so let's say let's say the software is $20 but we have to renew it for the four years for that students what's that a um it's not $100 that's he says $4.99 so you figure $60 for the year most textbooks are more expensive than that right but we don't have to buy the textbook every year we can keep the textbook for four years let's say so how does
048ites even out no it would cost more money to do the paper the paperbook okay and are we restricted to certain softwares like again we we had Pearson do can we do we only have to buy from Pearson no we can we buy as for the iPad we can buy anything that's in the App Store and that includes products other than uh Apple products it's pretty much anybody who creates an app and and gets it approved by Apple we can purchase that I guess confed between an app and a book yes they're two different things okay so can you answer the question about the books do we have only one supplier of books no no we can look we can still look at all of the different companies um even Pearson right now is looking
049at converting all of their books to ebooks um so iBooks are specifically to to Apple ebook is is for any platform um so no P we Pearson is not the only book company that we use do they own rights to books they're all publisher publishing companies [Music] yes if he has a suggestion maybe he can clarify do no that I'm sorry I didn't hear your question if if there's if you want to clarify your microphone or I'm sorry I didn't hear you no if there's more clarification CU I'm I might not be asking the question properly about the books yeah okay so let's say the books are $15 just use round numbers if we the lifespan Mo I think the um adoption cycle every 5 years in Monroe so let's just say you spent 15
050Time 5 which is $75 I think what Dr Alf is saying is most books are more than $75 so you would have bought another hard copy anyway because of the adoption cycle okay Mr Ryback thank you I have a just a couple of comments in a question um I'm sure as most of my colleagues here uh I want to see our district remain at The Cutting Edge and therefore certainly you know what's going on education today I think uh the onetoone initiative is is is not unique to Monroe although I know we were one of the leaders in it and I'm happy about that and it's important that we stay there uh but just as important that we don't repeat mistakes of the past we owe that to our students and to the taxpayers as
051well um so I know at the uh prior curriculum committee meeting I know I walked in and I was thinking Google Chrome and then I was listening to the administration and it's important that the teachers get what they need to teach they're the ones that are doing it I know that was recommended met all the needs and then I understand Dr alvic was saying that the Apple uh lowered the prices considerably and made it a lot more uh attractive to us so we decided to well that's obviously the way to go it's met the district's needs they lowered the price and everything but in listening to what Mr nosty was saying today I personally would like to see and I certainly see the importance of it Tom I think it's a very good suggestion that
052we try to get that Apple Care for four years instead of three I think that would make a world of difference and it would give us another year of $1.6 million I'm not refuting the Apple I'm not refuting the you know the iPad or any of that I'm just thinking is it possible to get them to go for a four-year uh Apple Care I I will certainly ask the question I I haven't seen that listed in their uh documentations that come out originally Apple Care was for two years then they extended it to three years because the schools are saying this this is not long enough I'll ask about the four but I have not seen that in any of their Publications that they put out but we can certainly ask the question you know
053my thinking is they they lowered the price considerably making it more attractive I know they're selling less machines than they have because obviously there's more competition right you know um they you know it's worth a try and that's all I'm saying yes sir thank you Mr Koffman sure Mr Washington can you talk about some of the other intrinsic values that we're getting at the district level uh with regard to PD from Apple that we have as part of our program because it's in effect part of the package uh and then you can answer that in one second but I want them to make sure everybody's crystal clear on because I saw a lot of weird faces in the audience when we're talking about the different modalities of textbooks and everything so keep me honest and
054I'll be brief if it starts with an i it's Mac or apple so an I book is typically something that runs in a Mac environment if it's an ebook it typically is more Broad and it can run on almost any type of device the thing to keep in mind too that the the way these documents or these books are delivered also varies sometime you can have a text book or solution that's delivered and it runs completely on the network so you can use a particular device that has no local storage to access the information because the book itself isn't resonant on the device it's on the network we also have textbooks in our district that are actually delivered to the physical device like our iBooks right so these documents or these textbooks have to have
055local storage to be able to carry that book along because you have to be able to use the book without a network connection right so all of these things come into play when you're making decisions not just what kind of e or I book are you're going to develop but what kind of equipment do you have to deliver this to if you only have a Chromebook solution then the only type of electronic book you can get is something that's running off a network because there's no local storage there's no way to run it without it being connected to the network so these are just some of the things that went into that list that was shared with the curriculum of the business requirements if you will of students versus teachers and we did do a
056little different this time because we actually did have a technology day where we actually invited to the whole community in to take a look at all of the vendors and we also asked for people to give feedback of what they thought of the different providers that came in that day so two questions back to you it's the one I asked before and and if you can briefly talk about what the results were from the surveys when people came in for that Round Table Open Session uh you did a very good job of explaining the difference between the iBooks and ebooks and we do have both we do have uh some of our curricular areas they use ebooks which are published to work on any device and from a vendor's standpoint that's ideally what they want
057in the beginning they started out with everything was I iBook because it was an Apple device so manufacturers wrote for the iPad now just like any business they're in business to make a profit so now they wanted to expand their Horizon and they start publishing ebooks which don't limit you to just the iPad it'll work on any device so the the Trend in the publishing world right now is to go E versus I so that they don't limit they're not excluding the iPad but they are including the windows devices so uh thank you for that explanation some of the intrinsic values that Apple has brought to the table I mean this a lot of this terminologies the educational terminology to be quite Frank with I don't that's not my My Chosen profession but my understanding
058is Apple has come in and really showed the teacher and leverag their product to flip the classroom where no longer it's the teacher the center of the stage in the classroom but the kids are actually in charge of their own learning and I'm only hearing this from other Educators I'm not in the classroom I don't know all of that that real good stuff like that but um they have come out and they've worked directly handson with our teachers and they use a turnkey approach where they train a core group of teachers and those teachers in turn go back to their colleagues and they sit and work with them so I've certainly seen the classroom itself changeed from being teacher centered to be more student focused I hope I answered your question Mr cofman yeah it
059was good the one last comment and I'll I promise I'll shut up E versus I I feel like I'm I'm a member of the public that comes before us every now and then talks about what the Staters is or isn't doing for us so this is my my two seconds on the Soap Box in in lose perfect world in the future we forget about e we forget about I we should be developing our own content we talked about that a million times so that we can completely disconnect ourselves from licensing agreements with these big vendors uh because you know we whether we have a single year or multi-year agreement it's still content we still have all of these devices with all of this technology to be able to have students in a flipped class environment
060developing the content let's leverage the content reuse the content and break us completely from dependency on public sure so we have our own material and in the perfect world we could start selling it to other districts that's it I'm done Mr Bo Dr alage um just so that everyone is aware the presentation that we made to the curriculum committees and the finance committees is available on our website we have posted on the website at at the request of Mrs calano um so it's there included in that presentation are several examples from teachers at the high school of how they're using the technology um there's a math example there is a science example and there's a language arts example there and the teachers have shared this with me um to show how they're using the iPads
061and how they're using the technology in the classroom so it's there for you to to to to look at Miss col panovich yeah I have a couple questions um the technology committee that was put together that met what two three times you mean the High School Technology commit yes ma'am met twice and then they had that technology Fair yes ma' so the the recommendation to go with the iPad and I don't know who's going to answer this question did that come from the tech committee surveys it did ma'am it did okay and some Financial questions um we just passed the budget for next year Mr Gorski was there a line item in that budget for new technology for next year yes there is an existing line item in the 1415 budget for the Apple iPad
062one:1 initiative lease and there is a line item in the 1516 budget of approximately $400,000 and the way we calculated that was we considered the various platforms that were before the committee at the time uh we considered the the way we would have to bid for sale our existing units and what we could expect is AR range for receipt and um we factored that over a three-year lease and that came to um just about 400,000 so there's about 400,000 in the instructional purchase Services line item for the one toone initiative okay does that 400,000 include the sale of the current iPads yes ma'am it does and and we can make a a good amount of money off of that I believe the figure that was Cur conservatively represented to the finance committee was to sell
063all the existing iPads and the teacher iBooks iBooks iBooks was about $200,000 and and at the past I I believe the parents for each iPad that was purchased put in a I think it was $65 for an insurance fee that's correct and if we did that again this year because that's not a given that would offset some of the costs also yes ma'am about $130,000 could be raised from the insurance and that would offset the cost okay that was the board's directive when we made the policy for the insurance one ask question Mr Coffman you said something reminded me of something if I'm not mistaken last year when we when the topic came up about the um insurance program for this year there was conversation even last year about starting to refresh last year and
064we decided to get another year out of the program and and and reschedule it for this year so it's not like this is new news we talked about it last year so it's just this is next year right okay yes and and and for the procurement of the new iPads and the the teacher computers if the board moves tonight we will again put the existing units up first bid for sale and take those proceeds offset the new amount as a down payment by putting that again it we would put all the residual balance in that parent money fund toward that purchase also I don't know the exact balance off the top of my head but I think there's about $60,000 in that account and also the the new proceeds from the uh the fund would
065help offset the price also so you will wind up paying significantly less than the $400,000 that's in the budget because of all those variables and of course we're going to procure these as uh efficiently as possible through State contract Mr P alsoo Reggie are we going to take a survey the iPads that are already in service to see which ones are in great condition and which one not which ones aren't that's at the end yes so we generally collect the iPads from the students on on their last day of testing so um it it's pretty crazy day that that last day of school when we're going around to get the iPads but we do take a survey of them at that time so the bo the board will see that right oh you're welcome to
066see them is that a one of the iPads that the student choose how old is that one that particular iPad is three years old three years old yes sir that's in good shape that one isn't it yes sir thank you and uh question to Dr alich do we have plans to move the uh onet to1 initiative to the middle school not at this time but didn't we talk about that at the finance meeting we we had talked about it it was um something that we were looking at maybe piloting something possibly with Chromebooks next year at the middle school but it wouldn't be a full scale once one it would just be a pilot to see how they work it would be the start of a full scale possibly depending on the outcome of the
067pilot we would also in every three years possibly look for more money for the middle school if it was the if it was the direction that we wanted to go in yes okay thank you Mr armeno who who are we anticipating selling the current iPads too thank you I honestly couldn't say I don't have an answer to that because what we'll do is we'll put together bid specs for the sale advertise it to solicit the most competitive bids for the existing units and in this case sell it to the highest bidder and believe it or not there are a lot of companies who who business is buying used Apple products and refurbishing them and then selling them Market it's not like another school is going to possibly buy who bought them the last time a
068company that uh was in business to refurbish them and then sell them to the private sector so again to go back to the very beginning of the conversation is it anticipated that every well well now it's if if this is on on the agenda for approval tonight is that correct yes ma'am disc no it's discussion and now that it's on for resolution I understand that there's a a resolution that's been prepared if it's the will of the board okay because I I'm a little I'm still a little uncomfortable because I I did anticipate this just being discussion and trying to get a little bit more information on it um is is it I don't know if it would be the will of the board to have a specific um technology special board meeting to to
069review this and open it to the public as well I I mean that would that would make me more comfortable talking about it little great length but my question is if it if it if we're trying to look for like perhaps a four-year um um Apple Care um we really shouldn't talk about approving uh talk about voting on it tonight and and if if I can finish um if if it is only three years are we anticipating and what was the cost about a million something that every three years that will be the cost to this million 6 a million6 almost $2 million million6 is the purchase cost however you can anticipate selling the existing 2,000 units will bring you in a good amount of money so the cost is not a million6 it's less
070than that um there again there have been um Tech committees at the high school that began when Reggie when was the first meeting it was it it be the tech committee began with the strategic planning from Dr Hamilton when was that um three years ago two years ago when we first and and then the high school had a technology committee to study the onetoone initiative recently when did that begin over the sum the beginning of this year so beginning of the summer we had the platform then it went to the curriculum committee then I went to finance committee and my only concern that I would like to represent to the board is you know this is the natural maturation process where it comes to the board and action is taken at the conclusion of that
071and I'm concerned that if it's if it's tabled or deferred longer that there could be um time constraints with the bidding and the state contract resolution for the purchase and getting these items ready to go by September is that a valid concern Mr Washington yes sir but I I think we should have did this K the um technology fair that we had was open to the public so that anybody who had a ticket um was able to come in I don't think anybody was turned away and also I think there was the majority of the board members who was at that fair that night so we had the opportunity if you so desired to visit every single platform or company that was there and get some information and then fill out the survey um I
072I I believe that night and I don't think it was the one of the better nights that we've ever had um there was over 300 people there from the from the the public who had that opportunity to come in and be a part of that Tech Fair yeah no one was turned away we we were able to accommodate anyone who wanted to who wanted to attend Mr noin um I I want to make it perfectly clear I don't I think maybe um people are thinking that I'm not for the iPads I want what's best for the students and the teachers and it's been pretty much I think settled that that's what they want that's where their needs lie I I don't I'm not arguing that or or to me that's not even a discussion item
073my discussion item here is the fact that have we looked into being more cost effective for example Mr Gorski just mentioned that there's a company that takes these back and refurbishes them and then sells them well have we looked at that as an option um we have a unique opportunity here in the fact that we're not switching platforms if we were switching platforms the time crunch that we're talking about would be real thing but since we're not switching platforms if we don't implement this until November it's not the end of the world because it's the same platform we're not gaining any extra uh functionality by going with the new uh MacBook Pros or the or the iPad Airs so my concern is are we being and using the resources that the public gives us in
074a uh in the correct fiduciary manner that we should be uh everybody likes new stuff I do too I'm a gadget person I love getting new stuff but when we're using other people's money I think it's really incumbent upon this board to say hm is there a better way of doing this is there some way that we can buy refurbished ones is there some way that we can uh uh use uh the resources that we have and say you know what we're only going to replace a thousand of them or 500 or something to show the public that we're really being stewards of their money and that we're not just going to say well it's 3 years they're old let's let's get new ones because obviously there is a a need out there people are
075going to buy them a company's going to buy them and refurbish them costs to refurbish these are not that much and if we can cut our costs in half even if it's in the budget already that doesn't mean that we can't save money so it's not a matter to me that the technology committee said well of course that's what they said because that is I feel right now that's what meets our needs the most is the Apple product but I think because of that we need to be more cost conscious that's all I'm saying thank you question Sor the contract we negotiated with iPad or apple excuse me um was that for a specific number of iPads like yes I believe that the um proposal that we received was for that quantity of iPads uh
076because we are a return vendor Apple wanted to maintain our business and was reduced to a per unit cost by $200 I could say previously when Dr Gorman negotiated both prior iPad purchases with apple uh they wouldn't even give us free covers because um you know the device was new and um I I think now that it has CAU on and that many school districts are following Monroe's lead in in this onetoone initiative that Apple would like to maintain us as a customer and they've been much more competitive so if we went back and said we didn't want as many as we had previously negotiated we'd have to renegotiate the whole entire contract I believe that's fair to say that if we ask for a lesser amount that we would receive uh maybe not as
077much of a discount that that's usually the case okay thanks Mr P also we're going to vote on this tonight without knowing our options I mean I just asked if we could uh take a survey on what's working what's not and evidently some of these are in very great condition why would we vote on buying something new when we don't even have options taxes may I rephrase your question Mr proso in other words out of the 2,000 plus iPads that we presently have if we found that 800 of them are in great condition don't need any uh repairs or refurbishing uh then why not keep those 800 and only have to worry about buying another 1,600 is that basically what you're getting at there sure Mr uh Mr Washington can you respond to that we
078can certainly take a look at the iPads when they come back from the kids but uh there's certainly going to be some that are in pristine condition like this one there's no doubt about that but there are certainly will be a greater percentage of them that are damaged I can almost guarantee you that the exact numbers I I don't know but we can do that I mean schools out I think the 24th of June and uh we can do an inventory on them at that time now that does put you under a tremendous crunch because all schools are placing their orders at that time so once School budgets are passed in April uh schools generally start cutting purchase orders so now we're going to be we can potentially be dealing with an inventory shortage just
079putting that out that as as a precaution there are some that are pretty good we could give them to the Freshman we don't we could save some money buying these new iPads most of them anyway and like I said there's no options we're just going to vote let's get new ones I certainly don't have the expertise that Dr alvic or um Mr Washington have in this area but understanding how these devices are used in every classroom now I'm concerned because I've seen firsthand the consequence of what happens when a device fails it almost instantly stops the classroom lection lecture um a call goes down to the tech office help has to come and an opportunity to teach is lost I would just like to the board to consider that if you're using a three-year older
080platform that has lived beyond their useful life and that's what I'm hearing that there's a risk to education from that standpoint there could be Interruption and we don't really have a staff that in place to handle that kind of attention that older devices would use we've been dealing mostly with new platforms one that was refreshed only after 10 months as you push it down the road and you use an older device that may or may not be suitable for updates from Apple anymore um with button problems it could disrupt instruction because these are so critically used now um can I ask a question if if we do what Anthony's talking about then we have two sets of iPads with different functionality right because the newer ones have different functionality than the older ones yes and
081some of the issues will be the updates we wouldn't be able to update them um as apple is a business and they want to sell the they want to you know sell new devices so as they get older you're not able to update them in order for our students to be able to use them to the best the other piece of the uh newer devices would um we would be able to run correct me if I'm if I'm not using the right terminology Mr Washington the uh we'd be able to use them um easier for park because you can set them up so that Mr Washington would be able to easily flip them to park mode um so the students would actually be using their own devices for testing next year rather than having to
082put some aside set them up specifically for park for the students to use the other concern that I would have with the devices um is we can't get insurance on them so any device that went down after this um any of the older devices that went down we couldn't replace them for the students so if the students are able to use their own devices for the park that will free up other devices so that we could have more children doing the park rather than you know the way we're doing it now yes and then they would be able to take the the park within their classrooms okay and then that would be less of a loss of instruction times okay Mr noin um correct me if I'm wrong um Mr Washington but I have not
083seen that issue where you're not able to upgrade the IOS operating system other than what Apple kind of messed with people's minds when they did the first gen uh two years later you couldn't upgrade the iOS well there are certain there are certain I pass we have currently that you cannot put the latest IOS on them that is not hasn't been the case with the ones to students currently have but we do have others which was purchased um by the pup Personnel Department earlier they cannot take the upgrade now I would be concerned at the high school because you have mixed grade level classes if you're if we're thinking of giving one particular grade the older iPads what's to say those kids are not in the same class say if it's a GE geometry class
084we might have 10th and 11th or ninth grader in there so you have to be careful at the high school level because you have mixed grade levels in a particular subject so it it's harder to to break that up you can't just go by all all ninth graders get this because I don't I can't say what class that ninth grader is in they may be in a class with other upper classmen no I I understand that but basically what you said though the ones that the students currently have are all capab of being upgraded to the to the uh to the new iOS system correct to the current one the current one exactly correct now Apple P pushes out an update certainly every September October and I'm I don't know if it's going to run
085on the older iPad realistically some of these upgrades for example the last iOS upgrade just enabled you to use the Smartwatch so these are not mind altering or or gamechanging type of upgrades for the most part for the most part that's correct but the one prior to that actually enabled us to use the iPad in park because there were certain features that were available they discovered later on on the iPad that apple had to release some restrictions so that kids couldn't bring up say the thes SARS and things like that so sometimes they're critical when they come out but as of now they they can they can use them for Park there's no uh there's no nothing stating that they're not going to be upgradeable in in the next to the near future so as
086of April 24th at 8:15 that is correct right but these updates come out all the time but it's kind of scary that we're locking ourselves into a platform that does that that's my big concern you look at Microsoft I still have customers using XP okay and so when I hear that you're you know I know what they did to me when I bought the first gen Apple okay two years later no more upgrades five is the best that I can do that's not really a good company that does that in my mind um they're they're locking the schools in and it's hurting the students because you just said that some of these upgrades you know could hurt the students and here we are going again to purchase the same platform um I don't know if
087the teachers looked at that or the uh or the technology staff looked into those kind of details it was really just what do we want now front-facing rear faing camera Etc nobody said what's the most bang for the buck okay first of all nobody said what's going to have the longest life cycle nobody said uh upgrade capabilities these are all things that are coming after the fact and that's why I'm not quite sure that we're in a good position right now uh to be locked into this without really thinking at a bigger picture at this point and saying let's let's negotiate better with apple because quite frankly this isn't to me in my mind a great deal Apple's sales are down for their tablets there's no question there's a lot more competition they're hungry so
088I think this is our time to strike and say it's a good platform not a great one but it's a good one and that's what we like so let's save some of the taxpayers money that's all I'm asking um I'd like to hear from Mr thorney I know I'm catching you off guard there but uh you are I believe in the 11th grade correct just about two in another couple of months you'll be finished with it so you've had three years experience with the iPad could you share with the board uh your thoughts on how uh having that iPad has improved your learning your achievement uh how have you found it beneficial uh Mr Po so um like you said I'm in 11th grade so almost three years of using this uh uh device and
089I've also had the pleasure of serving on the high schools committee uh for the technology and I've attended the technology um Exposition as well uh I think that this iPad has you know definitely improved my learning in terms of its capabilities uh its applications and the iBooks as well and I know that um within say you know while saying uh within the realm of fiscal responsibility in in terms of the applications with the exception of the iBooks uh the school can spend you know minimum amount of money and deploy them on all of the iPads um I believe that at the technology Exposition I got figures from Mr Washington I think that the school uh for one year had spent less than $200 uh in terms of Ju Just the applications and deployed them on
090over 200 iPads or no not 200 2,000 uh you know I think that's um right there very beneficial and as far as the ebooks and the iBooks uh cuz I know that was brought up earlier there was um my freshman year I was I I had iBooks on the iPad um which once the redemption code was entered it was strictly associated with my user and uh since then at least with my um AP calculus course now we're currently using uh cor smart which means that instead of giving you having to purchase you know the iPads and giving to students Where It's associated with their ID forever it's more of a rental type thing where you have it for I believe about a year and then uh it expire it expires um and you're also able
091to use that offline and on computers as well uh in terms of the iPad itself um it it I think it really depends on the class for example uh in my history class there's very minimal projects um it's primarily lecture style class because it is an advanced placement class uh the most that the iPad could really be used in that sense is uh for taking notes or uh doing doing some research perhaps at home but uh in that class it's it's not necessarily as uh useful uh compared to some different honors courses or science um or even uh calculus with the textbook with the AP Central for our uh preparation for the test it's a little bit uh more integral within the curriculum uh using projects enabling uh peer-to-peer collaboration uh although from my understanding
092the Chromebooks may or may not uh further enable that because it's hard it's sometimes difficult to uh try to collaborate when you have multiple people uh and the file only is residing on one of the only one iPad and it's difficult to sometimes send that back and forth especially if the student uh web mail server is down which that happens frequently but uh overall I I think that the uh District's deployment of the one1 initiative uh within the iPad so far has definitely been a beneficial asset in terms of our uh our education um with you know different apps that enable us to you know um conduct Labs or uh send homework back and uh back and forth between teachers and uh students we're working to to um collaborate with other students on certain projects
093uh and activities and the the different apps that allow you to have a broader access of of information within the classroom okay I I appreciate that and as I told you I know I caught you off guard and I do apologize for that but you were here tonight and I thought it might be beneficial for the board to hear your your feedback on that thank you uh I know many and Mr nin referred to this uh you said getting getting the biggest bang for your buck and I know because of expense that many large quality high schools in New Jersey have gone to the Chromebook right and they probably did this and I'm now really addressing it to Mrs uh Dr alvich and Mr Washington uh they I'm sure they did this because of the
094cost Factor but uh I'm sure they did it also after doing some research uh it would help me to understand uh if how what can we do with the iPad that we could not do with the Chromebook I mean specifically how much if we went to a Chromebook platform how much would that really alter our program in terms of the academic content uh activities uh student learning and I don't know if anyone can answer that I once again I'm catching you off guard with that question I realize that um I've been able to visit uh Robinsville high school that's where my daughter attends school um they have recently instituted Chromebooks as a pilot this year to see how they've worked with um Park what I found is and and what I've learned from the assistant
095superintendent there is they did it because of the cost factor that was the reason they went with the Chromebook not so much for how they could be used in the classroom but for the cost Factor because it was cheaper they were able to get more devices um to help them with the park testing um the difference with the Chromebook is everything is on the cloud there's very little storage space on the computer so for a student a student wouldn't wouldn't necessarily be able to have an entire textbook available to them at all times like they can on the on the iPad because it's on the cloud so if they weren't on the Wi-Fi they wouldn't be able to get the textbook um they could download pieces of the textbook if they needed a chapter for
096homework or something like that um because there's a small a small amount of of um of space of storage space the there are the there are differences between the Apple apps the applications that we can download onto the iPads um there's a difference between them and Google for Education Google for Education is increasing their number of apps but they're not where apple is with the apps that are available um the tech department did look at a list of they they actually sent um Google a list of our current apps that we're using in our building in our schools here um and Google sent back what their um what their uh compatible apps would be um and they weren't all there either Mr Wasington did you want to add to that yes I just wanted to
097add I think one of the things we do well in Monroe is we don't allow the technology to drive the curriculum the curriculum drives the technology and based upon the curricular needs it's we try and find a compatible technology to meet those needs perfect point certainly the Chromebook is a maturing technology and three years from now I couldn't possibly tell you where they're going to be I think they probably will be the leader as of this point in time I don't think they are certainly they can do word processing spreadsheets and presentation the students in Monroe have gone beyond that we're talking about actually putting together full Motion Audio enable presentations in the classroom so we're not talking about just typing a document here anymore we're not just talking about putting together a basic spreadsheet
098they've gone beyond that and the things that the students are doing on iPad there are no apps in the Google Store that can do that today I can't say that three years from now it'll be a different world but Google is making big strides it's certainly a technology we're going to have to consider but for the 2015 2016 school year I don't think they'll be where the iPad is I I have one more comment and then I then I'll stop um and I recently read and this has always been a concern of mine uh and possibly Dr alvit you have some information on this although I wouldn't expect you to to share it with us tonight but uh a lot of high schools have jumped into this uh technology train they've jumped on it and
099uh it is very very new but I'm not so certain that we have the research to support the fact that uh it increases or improves learning uh in fact recently I read an article in the newspaper uh where a study had been done that found that people who read an old-fashioned book where you turn the pages as compared to people reading that same book in an electronic format the people who were reading it in the old-fashioned way had greater retention of the material than the people that were doing it electronically I've also heard of students that have have been given assignments and what they do is they simply go and and they uh search they do a search for that particular topic and lo and behold if the questions that they're being asked are not
100right there so they just basically dump the answers that are there so they're not really doing anything except learning how to use that technology but but my greater concern is really the fact that we're spending millions of dollars and I had this concern back before I was on the board and I heard that we were going to iPads we we're spending millions of dollars and we're talking about committing the spending of millions of dollars future and and yet I'm not so certain that we have any research that tells us how effective that is for student learning it may make for a more Dynamic classroom it may give you more rasmas in terms of the Productions that are done in the classroom the presentations and yes those are valuable in the business world uh but I'm
101not so certain that uh without some some research and we we're not in a position to do that that has to be done at a university level uh by people who know how to conduct research but I'm I'm just not so certain that uh this is going to give us every thing that we would be hoping for final say on that uh oh I did look at this document I'm sorry it's not my final say because you presented in here I just want to call this to the attention of the board members um there was a lease option of three years versus four years uh it looks to me as if it's the same amount of money uh for for both of those if I'm not mistaken uh but if we go with a three-year
102plan which means that we then have to pick up another year at an additional cost uh the way I calculated it it appears that we would be spending $894,000 have an iPad for 4 years uh and this is just based on the cost of the iPad not all the other stuff that comes with it it would be $ 894 but if we went with the four-year plan that was here then the cost would be $671 per student I I I'd like to know if that's correct or not because to me that's a significant difference you know that's that's over $200 uh difference there and yet it's the same amount of money now this was on uh the cost proposal it's the same amount of money uh it's a 0% financing from Apple so it just
103spread the the total cost over four years rather than three that's why it's that that's why it's cheaper per student because it's four years the problem with the fourth year as we've mentioned before is the Apple Care we have to we we'd have to purchase the insurance which is what happened this year with the insurance okay but even if we had to purchase that insurance I I don't I I'm sure it would be less than $220 for the for per iPad I'm not sure how because that's what the differential is here uh we're going to have some challenges with funding the insurance if if you can recall this year we had to go to the insurance company because there was no Apple Care the insurance company informed us that they compete for Apple Care so
104if if your device doesn't have apple care or it's not eligible for Apple Care they don't want to Ure that device because they know it's it's going to be problematic so if we went with the four-year lease that fourth year we'd have to try and find someone who would provide Insurance our current insurance company will not cover it we'd have to try and find someone else rman I have a a question looking at the specifications that the teachers wanted and what they wanted for the students from my point of view and I'm certainly far from very knowledgeable about these Compu computers or technology but what I see on the specs is you want a camera for the students and you want a camera for the teachers other than that could this do the same thing
105as an iPad the laptop uh has that capability of doing the same thing on the iPad the challenge with the laptop is it's different so you're saying that it's can do the same thing the laptop certainly can okay so why I'm sure that every student that has an IID is not taking pictures I I can't believe that 100% of these kids are taking pictures and if they are they're not taking them at the same time so I would I would think in view of whatever I'd like to send this back to the committee with with the permission of the the uh board and come up with a plan for something other than the iPad that we can use that might be more economical and if they need cameras you can get cameras for 15 bucks
106pass them out to anybody that needs them let them throw them away when they're done but the point that I'm trying to make is if it if it's just cameras that making it different forget the cameras I I I can't believe that every kid is using the camera at every time at the same time I I just if that's the only thing that's making it different we have a problem Mr Mr boy Mr Goodall was integral in our and so maybe he can offer some of the things that we're uh that the high school's been using for I was I I was made aware of that and I wanted to call him up I just wanted to make sure that all members of the board had an opportunity to speak on this anyone else have
107a comment or question to make Mr Ryback Mr Wasington I just want to clear something up in my mind um you said that if we didn't buy an entire school's worth let's say we just bought I'm just picking a number you know 2,000 new units or something in other words the the older units may not be uh have the ability to do what the new unit will do because we really don't know what the new new units uh are capable of at this point today the older units can do what the new units can do today but I don't know what's I know they're going to release another iOS and close to December time frame will that update go on the older ones that I don't know I guess what I'm getting at is we
108bought new ones today for whole school right it would basically be compatible with the ones we have now that's correct that's so so no student would be at a disadvantage that's correct if we bought new and and following you know Mr braven's line I I one of the things I'm not faulting anybody it's just a shame that I know it's almost May and here we are talking about this and time is a is an important factor here in making a decision but so is money and we're talking about a lot of money so I you know everybody is sensitive to that you know I'm aware I'm aware of that um I I just want to make sure that you know again what we have what we what we're thinking about is is going to be
109correct and and especially for the future and I just want to emphasize the I think important idea that I'm hearing of of getting the Apple Care for four years I can't see voting on anything today if it's possible for us to get apple care for four years and and covering it I mean that's for me that's that's a key issue right there yes sir I'll certainly ask the question tomorrow and I'll probably have an answer tomorrow uh but as I stated I haven't seen anything in the Apple price guide that we get that mentions a four sometimes there nothing like sitting down and bargaining with somebody personally yes sir one Mr cofman so Reggie this is not new news right we've had laptops in the district since the dawn of time right um clearly the
110cost per unit for a laptop is much higher than the cost of a tablet can you speak to the cost differen iation because we're talking about you know it's all cost right if it gets down to the fact that I can buy three or four iPads for the cost of one laptop that's one issue versus what it will be like in the future if we were to give out 2,000 of these with infinitely more moving Parts than the iPads that we have today what the impact is going to be for weight in the backpack cost of repairs all of the things that we're talking about here and and to talk to uh answer um uh Tom's question about in your professional judgment given I know you're not new to the the rodeo you you have
111experienced with all of these devices you've looked at all of the questions that we've come up to today is what is your recommendation as the best return on investment for the district for Monroe in my opinion it is best that we stick with the Apple platform and the iPad and let me tell you why I say that I don't know if you know I'm a Windows guy windows I that's my my baby I love windows so why not Windows well I can tell you one thing September will not be a nice place to be in Monroe High School if we switch platforms on teachers they will literally I might not make it out of here I might not make it out I would be very very concerned the teachers when we switch from Windows from
112the old school to the to the mac and the new school that year was rough I'm I'm sure I aged 10 years in that one year now they have gravitated and they love the device they know how to use the device I think the worst thing we can do for teachers now is to make a switch on them cuz then we're going to send a message we don't know what we're doing and they're just going to wait us out it took a lot of work to get them the teachers to say you know what this really can change instruction it was a lot of hard work went into that in four years later we're there now the teachers have spoken they've told us what they want and now they're going to say you know why
113do we take these surveys if we tell you what we want and you don't you don't listen to us I would love to go to Windows I can control Windows like nobody's business but you know what at the end of the day it's not about me it's not about what makes my life easier it's about giving the teachers the tool to do their job and they've spoken if we switched and left the iPad if you want to say all right let's stay with with the apple and give them a Macbook we can never afford it a Macbook for every student in this high school we can never afford it so you would then be compelled to look at the windows I've given you my reason why we can't go to windows at this point in
114time we've got what's critical IAL in school and I've only learned this because I've been working here for a while PD is critical to the success of a program in a school system it's critical it's unlike businesses my part-time job they tell me straight up you will learn it you'll do cbts there will be no teacher in front you'll do it on your own hey that's just the way it is schools don't operate that way schools do not operate that way I can recall the first day we gave teachers laptops and you had to literally pull the paper grade book out of their hands and it was hard we've got we have made a lot of tremendous progress here a lot of tremendous progress we looked at the windows 81 the surface I love the
115surface I thought it was a great product it'll never hold up in the hands of students it's not enough protection on the surface and that's the Microsoft products running Windows 81 we looked at Dell products running A1 we looked at uh HP products running 81 the learning curve is it's steep it is steep and we're on the verge of Microsoft releasing Windows 10 I think that's going to be a game Cher but we got to let those products mature they're not there yet just as apple and the iPad it's a mature device now the Chromebook is a great tool when you had nothing else when you had nothing else the Chromebook is a great tool but when I talked to my my colleagues around the county they said if I had my brothers an iPad
116versus a Chromebook they're going to go with the iPad it just offers so much more at this point in time as to Chromebook matures I think we have to take a look at it but it's just simply not there at this point in time Mr Aria you had your hand up and then we'll go to uh I just wanted to iterate Mr Washington that was brilliant I I mean I I I really get that but I I don't think and I'm with Tom and I think most the others I don't think we need to change the format I I get that the iPad is where we belong based on everything you've said but I think the only thing we're asking is again to sort of renegotiate the situation for us and see if there isn't
117a way for us to um just extend the life expectancy and and the care and the the PD is essential I I'm not great at technology and yet every time they change something in my business I want to pull my hair out when they change more than one thing at a time it really gives me the Jitters but but I don't but I think that if if we took a poll most of us don't have a problem with the format you've you've declared that that's the best and the teachers want it and the students want it and Mr Thorne's is very eloquent about it I don't that's not my issue my issue is can we see what the numbers are and do better and try to get an extension of this because again being held
118hostage it feels like sometimes like you say being held hostage to a business and Dr alage said it they're in the business to make money so but we we're in the business to educate our students but also to protect the position there was call it what you will the first iPads that were purchased because maybe they were new didn't work I feel very compelled not to to make that that kind of era again so I'm just more interested not so much in you changing anything but trying to get a better situation for us in order to go forward with it I I will certainly ask those questions tomor the number one question being can we extend Apple Care to a fourth year number two question is if we bought not the 2400 but 1,400 how
119would that change the unit price and I'll come back to you with that information and and if you feel the the difference between the units is as long as they can still do the job and if you know and again if the 2400 unit is going to have a better life expectancy I mean I just like to know what the details are I mean this is the most detail I've gotten that I understand so I appreciate that and I appreciate Dr Al's but I think this is what needed to happen that we had to figure out that so I accept your recommendation I'm just asking for myself if we could do better I will do that ma' thank you okay Mr Goodall principal of our high school thank you Mr py um hearing a number
120of the comments in the back and so a lot of great comments I just wanted to give you a little bit from my perspective um in embarking on looking at what the next steps are for the high school um we talked about transparency we talked about not rushing into something and uh I thought we covered that over the past year and looking at the next steps for the high school with the high school Tech committee the tech expo um coming to both uh committees to make presentations we didn't want to uh repeat some I guess sins of the past where um teachers might have felt rushed or it was a decision where everyone wasn't included without question amongst the vast majority the iPad is the best device it's beyond and I know Mr braen brought
121up the camera it's beyond what they offer in terms of an engaging tool for kids the educational app the workflow that exists between teacher and student so many other things that we can go over at a curriculum committee meeting uh the iPad is definitely at least from my perspective and many many others the best device for our kids that's out there in addition to that Mr Washington was fantastic and why he's recommending the iPad the PD that Apple provides for our teachers and how far they've come in the four years in terms of embedding instruction in their lessons um it would certainly going to another platform uh set us back significantly I think um and I wrote a couple of notes so I'm trying to touch on a couple of points um going back when
122we opened the high school we made a decision not only to go to a onetoone initiative but also to a mobile one toone initiative where the kids would have the iPad to device they can freely carry here in home uh we eliminated the existence of desktops and I know in a lot of high schools they have four five maybe 10 desktops in a room the teacher has a desktop uh with at this high school right now there's only a limited amount of desktops and that was at a significant savings when we went um you know using that format to go to um so the life cycle of a mobile device is certainly a lot less than your standard desktop device so we knew going back there um the uh board members at the time the
123administration that the recycle and refresh of these devices would come sooner uh rather than later uh compared to desktops or maybe even laptops so that you have to keep that in mind when you're making your decision about this that going back we knew that because we were using mobile devices that the life expectancy of those devices um just don't measure up to desktops so that was a big part of it um and I think everything else has been covered and let me just make sure so we can make an informed decision um really the big uh advantage of the iPad for the students is uh the organizational aspect of it all of the educational apps the workflow between teacher and student and to May the Apple iPad is the best uh tool for engagement that
124I've seen and I was very open I wasn't tied to any plantform um but seeing the presentations at the tech expo and working with the vendors as the principal of the building I strongly recommend we continue using iPads the business part of that in terms of how we Finance those and uh long-term lease agreements you know I would leave up to uh the board of Ved but certainly know that in going to the mobile device we knew that it would be a sooner refresh rather than later so I think that's important to understand that moving forward and um if there were any questions of me I certainly could answer them but I appreciate the opportunity to speak in support of the initiative any questions from Mr Goodall okay thank you Mr Gall all right I
125think we have had uh sufficient time to discuss this as was recommended by the finance committee um does anyone want to make a motion relative to this particular item miss kovich a resolution thank you it is recommended that the members of the Board of Education approve the following resolution entitled resolution of the Board of Education of the township of Monroe authorizing the acquisition of instructional technology whereas njsa 18a Colin 18 A- 42 authorizes the Board of Education of the township of Monroe the board to enter into a contract exceeding the fiscal year for the leasing of equipment of every nature and kind and whereas the board has a need to acquire 2400 new iPad units and 200 MacBook units collectively the equipment for school purposes and whereas the board desires to acquire the equipment through
126State contract now therefore be it resolved by the board as follows section one the board hereby authorizes the superintendent the board secretary and the board's councel to proceed to draft documents and conduct such other activities as are necessary to accomplish the acquisition of the equipment through State contract section two the board hereby directs the board secretary to possess the necessary purchase orders and contracts to acquire the equipment section three the board president and board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to determine all matters in connection with the acquisition of the equipment not determined by this or subsequent resolution of the board board as permitted by law section four copy of this resolution shall be placed on file with the secretary of the board section five the making of and transmission to the county superintendent of
127the application as required by njac 6A col 26-10 point1 D is hereby authorized and approved and the board's councel along with other representatives of the board is hereby authorized to prepare submit such application and to represent the board in manners pertaining theret section six this resolution shall take effect immediately okay is there a second to that motion question well we first is there is a second okay all right uh questions or comments Mr pre also resolution says that U 2400 is set in stone correct and we have no other options okay anyone want to comment on Mr preo's Point Mr Ryback comment on his point um I haven't done this before so I hope I'm correct but I'd like to make a motion to table that motion until Mr Washington can get the answers to
128the questions that were brought up here today and certainly uh I I'd like to guess a time limit I you said you might get the answers by tomorrow or so I I know time's a factor but I can't see approving a motion uh when we have you know critical questions that have to be answered second app but he has a table motion to table it's a primary that's a primary motion to table that we take okay is there a second to that motion of Mr Ryback Mr noin has seconded we do a roll call to table the present motion until we get the information that Mr Washington uh will provide I have a question uh this this is a primary motion to table about the table motion we have to take a vote first I
129can't hear you we have to take a vote first a primary motion it's got to vote first for the table yes yes motion has been made and second to table that's correct deliberation stops until the vote Miss armeno yes s Braverman I abstain Mr zareski no Mr de Mayo no Mr calman so noted thank you Mrs K Pano no Mr nosin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes motion to table does not pass the original motion is back on the floor for discussion because you need six affirmative votes to pass you got five any a majority of the board majority of the board is six um including Mr zareski uh Mr cowman's recusal does not change that the threshold is six and there was five so motion does not pass the table
130the original motion by Mrs Co Pono is back on the floor that table was a wrong motion okay any further uh discussion on the motion that's on the floor that's Mrs kapovich is motion okay then we will proceed with a roll call vote on the motion made by Mrs kapovich I think you all have we're given copies of this you found them there on the table all right Mr Gorski thank you this is Thea Pano motion Mrs armenio uh I'm not disputing the choice of device but no to the details so no thank you Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman refused thank you sir Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin voting yes for the Apple iPad initiative but no on the finances of this the motion on the floor was
131Mrs K Pano is that's correct I'm voting no basically you're voting no thank you sir confused Mr proso again with being forced to vote no your answer is noted as no Mr Rybeck unfortunately I um to vote no um basically because I can't see voting yes if we don't have the answers to key questions I I to me that's like a repeating mistakes of the past and uh I have to vote no Mr Po no motion does not pass okay before we proceed with the uh rest of the agenda I am going to I make a motion that we uh recess for five minutes I have break second all in favor I opposed extensions okay we will resume at 9 o' the board will now come to order we will the regular agenda going to
132the approval of minutes because some of you will have to uh abstain or recuse we will have to do these individually as we did the last time so I move that we uh accept the minutes of the public Board of Education meeting of February 11th 2015 so moved second by Mr yes all in any questions or comments all in favor I opposed okay I move that we accept the minutes of the closed session meeting of February 11th 2015 so moved second uh you move the motion I moved it and Ausin actually tomus thank you any questions or comments all in favor I abstentions I never know when I'm in when I'm Mr boy I I I move that we approve the minutes of the special public Board of Education meeting of February the 12th 2015
133I'm moved second questions or comments all in favor I opposed abstentions uh question is that the one that's what is that one special one I know it's special they all are to me right I just don't remember whether it was a superintendent one then yeah Mr bo uh a point of correction did did uh Mr calman have an opportunity to abstain on the first minutes for February 11th on the Clos session first public Board of Education February 11th oh I didn't have an opportunity no you wish to sir I think so I think I was there okay than that was a regular meeting fabulous meeting right oh that's right that's the um where are we February 12th uh okay Marvin asking me a question oh have a question yes oh he's abstaining so noted I
134move that we accept the uh minutes of the meeting of the closed session meeting on February the 12th so moved second questions or comments all in favor I I opposed abstentions Mr prman cman in bra I move that we accept the minutes of the special public Board of Education meeting of February 19th no moved second comments or questions all in favor I I opposed abstentions just the meeting that we hire the people to find the superintendent search the 19th I don't have the minutes before me I think so it was a special meeting I don't think we had a special meeting for anything else okay yes so noted and finally I move that we accept the minutes of the Clos session meeting of February the 19th so moved second comments or questions all in favor
135I opposed extensions okay that completes the approval of the minutes we will now go to committee reports does any uh chairperson have a report to make to the board Mr Coffman curriculum fans yes we did have another curriculum meeting uh this evening uh second one for the month we went over the SAT mathematics program um Miss Gasco gave an overall view of uh how things have been going and what the uh new changes are going to be moving forward apparently there's a new SAT coming out um shortly uh and questions were raised about uh how or if or when this SAT prep course for mathematics may or may not be adjusted to accommodate the ACT exam uh so more to come on that um we were presented with the summer reading program um and for
136anyone that is interested once it's approved it'll probably be posted on the website um we went over the course of study for 2015 and hold on I can tell you what was added and deleted we added an AP Physics C for grade 12 we added an AP human geography class uh we also deleted Mandarin via distance learning and we revised fundamentals of literacy offered in Grade 9 through 12 uh and also in the Arts we uh had a curriculum name change from World of music to modern music uh we also received a PD update from Miss Alvi Dr alvic um on some of the new uh changes that are going to be coming down uh the pike for our professional development and uh we had a very Lively discussion about yet again offering these things
137for pay to other districts as a Enterprise Mike loves Enterprises that's what he lives for as another Enterprise uh effort to try and build some income into the district because apparently other districts can't afford PD and what do they do they go out to other districts or other locations make them come to us that's it any other chair people chairpersons have a report Mr kovich we had a finance committee meeting and most of the stuff we discussed in finance we have already done um the first was uh the budget Mr Gorski gave the committee a review of the budget which is unchanged from the tentative budget and we voted on that tonight and it passed uh the second item was a discussion on the oneon-one technology initiative um we had Dory Alvi our assistant superintendent
138Mr Reggie Washington the director dtor of technology and Mr Robert Goodall the high school principal present data from the one-on-one High School Technology committee and Dr vich recommended to the committee that we go with the Apple iPad and as you saw a few minutes ago um the motion did not pass the third item that we discussed in the last item was the mecca loan recommendation Mr Gorski presented the February 28th 2015 fin fincial statement from Mecca and recommended that the existing loan from Mecca to the general fund with the balance of [Music] $234,200 comme met and we had some changes uh but I would like to point out to the board members that if you received a hard copy on Thursday of the policies that was incor they were incorrect uh not all of them
139but uh some of them were Incorrect and a uh due to a clerical error and the new ones were emailed to everyone on Monday I believe is that correct Mr Gorski yes okay so uh the policies uh some of the policies that had been suggested uh the committee decided to re have them REM I'm sorry some of the policy changes that were suggested uh the committee decided to have them stick with the original policy not the suggested and primarily that was for board self- evaluation the committee recommended that the board be uh as accountable as we expect everyone else to be so we're keeping with the more stringent uh board evaluation policy and um the use of social network sites uh bylaw 0135 is a new newly created policy so uh I hope everyone reviewed
140that for tonight's vote thank you any other committee [Music] reports okay thank you uh we will then go to the superintendent's report Mr President Mr President it is recommended that the members of the m t board of education approved Personnel items a through U Steve Ryback move the motion is there a second second okay any questions or comments okay Mr Gorski roll call vote thank you M armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman Mrs kapano Mr noin yes Mr proso Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president personel items a through U passes thank you uh Mr ventrillo uh for board action Mr President it is recommended that the members of the Mona Township Board of Education approve board uh action items a through G moved move by
141Mr no second by Mr Rybeck a question okay questions or comments uh bo action e the Avid and also on professional leave request there's $8,600 for leave that's not including that's not included in this uh registration fee correct and and and Anthony if I can address as far as item me I guess the question is as far as the the cost is that is that what the question is well there's professional Le requests on some of the paperwork that we received one's for 7,000 for Avid summer Institute and another one's for also from the Avid Institute for500 that has nothing to do with item e correct did they District leadership training and it is it is all part of it it's part of the contract it is part of the contract that's it's the aid
142District leadership training is part of that cost total and then just let you know as well too is that there's a savings there and you should just be aware of it there's a savings this year different one says 7,170 the other one says 7,100 they're two different ones and one says 2,97 and the other one says $1,559 sure okay the total costs under the professional developments are based on um not only the registration but it's also the the um mileage fee and the hotel fees so depending on where we're coming from because one of them is um my registration for that summer Institute um depending on where we're coming from the mileage may be different that's why the amounts are different is based on the mileage of of driving because it the summer Institute is
143held in Philadelphia and the reason and mine is higher because I'm I have to go through the leadership training um since I'm new to the position know why the figures are different yeah that's why they're different it's the mileage any other questions or comments okay I have a question about the policies uh it's listed as being first reading uh so my question is uh does that mean that uh these policies can still be modified before we finally uh adopt them since this is a first reading if if the policies are tabled or do not pass tonight they could go back to policy committee and be revised yes it would be recommended that they go back to committee for any amendment to it Okay the reason I asked that question and I did look these policies
144over and I did attend the policy committee meeting but um in doing a second reading of them since that committee meeting uh I was looking at policy 5460 which deals with high school graduation and there are numerous references to the HSPA and I think they since the HSPA no longer exists uh and is no longer a requirement for graduation I I would propose that we uh review the wording of that policy and uh my suggestion is that we remove any references to HSPA and replace it with something like the annual assessments as mandated by the New Jersey Department of Education sure that's fine so so does that mean that uh we remove that particular policy from this if if that's amable to the you know sufficient number of the board um it's a first read
145uh Mr ventrillo can make those deletions sure can that's a simple thing it's not a real big change in the in the policy so that's a simple fix we could roll that out in the second reading yes and I do apologize for not having caught that earlier as I said I only found it on the second reading and I oh that's good eyes thought let's clean that up if we could okay so uh do we have a motion to accept board action items a through G okay seconded that's already happened though and we've done the discussion any further questions or comments okay then roll call vote M armeno yes Mr rman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po
146yes Mr board president board action items a through G passes and it is noted that Corrections will be made removing those items that you brought up Mr President that ends my report thank you Mr ventrello Mr Gorski Mr board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through H be approved by consent roll call moved second the motion has been seconded any questions or comments no questions or comments roll call M armeno yes Mr Braverman Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman Mrs kapano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president board action items a through H passes that concludes my report thank you okay I have uh as board president I have two brief uh statements
147to make uh one is I'd like to commend the uh the staff as well as the students from the high school who put on the production of Young Frankenstein uh it was a very animated uh production and clearly we have some very talented young people that hopefully someday we may see appearing on Broadway our TV uh also I'm I'm uh directing uh Mr Gorski uh to have a special meeting of the Board of Education uh for Tuesday May 5th at 700 pm. here in the library uh this meeting will be for us to receive uh the information from our search team for the superintendent uh he will deliver my understanding is that he will deliver uh at that time the applications resumés of the candidates that he is has uh uncovered for us to take
148a look at as our next superintendent uh I would encourage all of you as much as possible to make any changes in your schedule so that you can uh make that meeting we will do things differently uh than we did the first time uh once we receive the information and hear whatever it is that Mr uh Dr morasco wants to share with us uh and that will be done in closed session uh we will then not review the applications and resumés that evening uh you will have more time to do that uh they will immediately be available at the board office uh starting the morning of the following day uh this is as early as we could move it up I know some of you have some plans uh I was hoping that we Monday
149unfortunately Dr morasco said that Monday would not work so we will have to be doing that on uh Tuesday evening uh the other thing is I believe that we can by that time we'll have the information from Mr Washington and we could in a public session uh deal with the item of the onetoone initiative uh which some people were asking for so we could have a motion at that at that meeting uh what whether to approve or or not approve uh whatever the motion might be regarding the onetoone initiative so you can anticipate that as well at this time I will read the resolution regarding uh I'm sorry is there any other board business Mr Mayo what time on the 5th did I missed that 7 p.m. 7 p.m. okay thanks yes and I do
150apologize uh for the short notice although it's it's a week's notice uh we were anticipating that we would be doing this the first week of May I think uh you knew that from some time ago I've been pressing Dr morasco for uh to have that meeting take place uh and this is the earliest that he can possibly do it uh Mr nasin um also I want to notify the board as your uh uh appointed delegate to the New Jersey school boards Association a delegate convention uh I will be meeting with the delegate vention on uh May 16th and there's only one resolution this year and basically um the the idea is that they want to Advocate the legislature to change when we can hold our reorganization meeting um back in the day when the elections
151used to be in April we would have the election not that far we could have it any time up to two just two weeks after the election now we're waiting basically from November first week of November until January 1 so the concern is there were some uh issues in the past with other boards where they couldn't uh uh appoint a super because it was basically a lame duck uh uh board so the uh proposal is to to basically put it back to the way it was in April by saying two weeks after the election the board can have a reorg meeting right away so that that's what that's on May 16 that's the only resolution if you have any strong opinions one way or the other on that please uh shoot me an email and
152I will convey that to the delegates thank you any other board business Mr cofman um okay so um had a very interesting evening tonight again one that is for the book so I want to ask the administrators here if we're going to come back on May the 5th to deliberate the uh onetoone initiative again do you guys know exactly what you need to get to answer the questions that were provided here because there were so many mixed signals and direction resets want to make sure you guys know exactly what it is that you're supposed to get and the questions that you and the answers you need to provide for that May 5th and is May 5th okay for you Mike can you wait that long or do you have to have a meeting before then
153that's next week May 5th was the meeting for superintendent search I believe Mr Po just said yes right I did and I said we would also try to deal with this are you going to take that at that meeting well I thought it would be helpful to the district the only problem is that uh there's a question of whether administration's going to be present at that meeting we have not been at the past when the superintendent search went on uh if I may uh the meeting opens in terms of a public session and we would go into close session for the superintendent search piece of it so that we could deal with this uh we could deal with the initiative one toone initiative during the public session of the meeting which would be at the
154start of the meeting okay to answer Mr cowman's um question I I believe one of the questions that was brought up was would Apple's discount be affected if you bought less than the amount of items included in the resolution tonight Mr Washington was going to check on that is the four-year Apple Care available is there a 4-year Apple care warranty period available Mr Washington was going to check on that I believe that we could have both those answers by the next meeting those are the only two questions that resonated with me are there any okay see because there are other qu I want to make sure because there may be flavors of this like if it's 2400 for this price and 2,000 for this price and 1,500 for this price what's going to satisfy the
155board and I know other questions were asked about well what's the inventory what's what do we expect to have come back be a and I know you won't I know Reggie's not going to have he doesn't have a crystal ball he won't know what percentage are recyclable for the following year I just want to make sure that we could put closure on May 5th that we don't have deliberation again that any questions that the board has get answered on May 5th to best abity um I I that's a great idea because I was thinking the same thing as far as we were kind of all over the place but I I would like to go one step further and just say uh with in the next 48 hours if we can get all our questions
156to Mr Po so he can steer them to Mr Washington because there I'm sure we may have other questions and we want to get resolution to this item is in in a timely fashion um one of my questions right off the bat is I'd like to explore other options for buying refurbished iPads you just said that they're going to buy our old ones refurbish them and resell them is that an option and if so what is the cost savings so that's another question that you can add I'll still email if you want but see my conern sorry Mr Bo now that now these questions are expanding may I recommend that the board be directed to send the questions to you for refinement and then redirect to Mr Washington yeah although so far what I've heard
157are the same questions that I heard in the earlier discussion it just might be that they were not it was not clear in ter for Mr Washington that those questions needed to be answered okay so let's do that instead of trying to deal deal with it tonight if you have a specific question regarding the onetoone initiative for Mr Washington please get it to me as soon as possible so that I can get it to him so that he has enough time to you're going to need a date get it to me by this date because this way this is Monday night I I need these by Wednesday evening at the latest but if you can get it to me by tomorrow that's even better because as soon as I get them I will forward them
158to him and if there's any question if there's something I don't understand I'll get back to you before forwarding it okay any other board business Mr seski the middle sex County school board meeting was originally scheduled for the 20th of May that is moved up a week to the 27th of May at that meeting it will be discussed the trying to remember the exact title of it I it had sliit my mind but it has to do with internet and computer language and me social media and what repercussions that has as far as using it how you should and should not use it as a board member also that evening are the presentations of certificated board members and master board members which I am pleased to say Kathy and I will receiving Master board member
159awards that evening and I invite any of these board members here to go all it's free of cost and all you have to do is get with Mr G ski and he will sign you up that's it anyone else time is that uh it's at 6:30 dinner starts and it's at Pierre's in South Brunswick anyone else all right then be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go in to close session in accordance with Sunshine Law chapter 231 of public laws of 1975 to discuss the following subjects pending litigation Kathy kapovich versus Anthony proso Monroe Township Board of Education middlex County refer uh agency reference number c1314 oal docket number e 9925 d2014 n also to hear a report on the uh harassment intimidation and bullying from
160Mr ventrillo as well as to deal with a Personnel item on the mil Lake principal the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confid confidentiality no longer exists do I hear a second second all in favor I opposed okay extensions how much time you think half an hour tops okay uh it's estimated that we should be no more than a half hour in closed session uh possibly we'll be back before then yeah the public will uh the board will now resume with its public meeting we will now go to our second public forum is there anyone in the uh audience that would like to come to the microphone okay seeing none I will then close the public forum Mr President it is recommended that
161the Board of Education appoint Ms Kristen MCN to the position of principal of mil Lake Elementary School effective August 1 2015 uh through June 30th 2016 at an annual salary of 111,000 86 and13 cents pro rated the board president the interim superintendent of schools and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the board of education so moved okay is there any discussion questions or comments by anyone on the board okay Mr Gorski then roll call vote please m Areno yes Mr Braverman Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman Mrs kapano Mr nosin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes and Mr Po yes Mr board president motion passes congrat ulations congratulations Miss mnol for appointment as principal of M Lake School
162her in front of the camera because no one step in front of the camera she certainly can as a matter of fact Kristen why don't you just stand up so this way they can catch you on the camera that's it that's a good wave I like that that's a principal wave you would know okay as I announced earlier next meeting of the Board of Education will be on Tuesday May the 5th 5th at 700 p.m here in the high school media center and following that we will have a our regular monthly meeting on Wednesday May 13th 2015 at 7 pm here at Monroe Township High School is there a motion to adjourn some second second just just you might want to mention about the teacher Awards too before that that meeting for everyone on the
16313th the 13th the teacher awards are right before that meeting you might want to remind people I don't know yes yes yes when you when you you get to come early and and have lunch with our teachers of the year right dinner dinner dinner din you can come you can come for lunch okay all in favor I opposed extensions meeting is adjourned