CorpusRecord 132946

Monroe Township Board of Education 02.11.15 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
11,688 words · about 65 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001the meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will now come to order Mr thorney would you please lead us in the pledge to the flag I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all that and I give it back Mr board president I will now proceed with a roll call Miss armeno here Mr Braverman here Mr de Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs Cole Pano here Mr noin here Mr Po here Mr President oo here Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening got in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused

002notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted February 6th 2015 at all schools home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski uh at this time we'll hear reports from our student reps good evening everyone so for tonight's report mil Lake School focuses on good character traits specified for each month and for February the theme is trustworthiness and students show understanding of these good character traits through art class activities and pledges of respect signed by each student the Monro Township middle school students artwork is being displayed at the monra Township Public Library in the exceptional Student Art display five students from the Middle School Advanced to the regional finalist level of the 2015 National History B the monor Township

003High School Media Center is promoting and reading is promoting reading and literacy analysis and discussion through its annual one book read which will take place on the evening of Thursday February 19th 2015 amongst high school students and staff the incoming freshman attended an orientation at the high school last night where students listened to a a brief presentation received a tour of the high school and learned about some clubs and fall sports that are available and the student council from the high school and some of the elementary schools are actively engaging in current and upcoming fundraising events some of these efforts are geared toward raising money for the student council and the respective School While others are supporting recogniz recognizable charitable efforts uh the mths booster club recently held a uh comedy night fundraiser event for

004athletics programs uh and scholarships uh The Debate Club had its first meeting today after school uh the club held an informational session for prospective competitors um the club intends to hold School level competitions later this year uh most likely in around the month of May uh seeing as it uh seeing it as is the uh club's first year um that will be operating the competition will be schoolwide um this year and then beginning next year uh they will intend to compete in pre-existing State national uh debate organizations Additionally the mths uh chapter for Youth and government is finalizing registration and is preparing for the pre- legislative Conference next month with students from across the state of New Jersey encouraging the more active participation and understanding in political process as well as current um current significant

005socio economic and political events affecting them and the state of New Jersey as a whole and uh student participation and engagement um in the high schools chapter um of the organization has increased tremendously from years past students in Deca and fpla are continuing their testing for um the state level for those students who uh qualify it Advanced um part of the supervised online testing uh for Deca uh will uh will be completed by the end of the week um and fbaa testing will take place on the last week of um February at the annual um at the actual state conference um in addition fpla also help a recent karaoke fundraiser at the high school benefiting the March of Dimes and finally um with a conclusion of the second marking period at um all of the

006schools students uh in the high school and the middle school are preparing for um course requests for next year uh students will be meeting with their guidance counselors uh to submit their individual requests for the variety of courses offered at the high school to prepare them for careers as well as postsecondary education as outlined in the program of studies located on the high school's website thank you thank you Miss hater and Mr thorney I will now read the closed session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 to discuss the following subjects to receive attorney advice regarding the matter entitled Kathy kapovich versus Anthony Pros Monroe Township Board

007of Education middlex County agency reference number c 13-14 oal docket number e 9925 d2014 n to discuss student residency matters and also excuse me and also to hear a report on harassment intimidation and bullying the discussion conducted in Clos session may be disclosed to the public as such time at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exist we anticipate that this closed session will require 30 to 45 minutes if it runs beyond that time then we will come out and give you an estimate of how soon we anticipate we'll be able to uh resume with the public portion of our meeting so at this time we will go into close session for second Mr all in favor opposed oos okay abstentions we got this already stain okay e Patrick dunan Mr zes is

008not here too the Board of Education will now resume its public portion of the meeting and at this time I would like to introduce Mr Patrick Duncan of the New Jersey school boards Association Mr Duncan will be uh helping train the board in terms of a superintendent salary it's important that we have this presentation since we are in the process of attempting to find a replacement for Dr Hamilton and we need to have it done before uh we get into the actual stage of uh drafting any s any contract or looking at it so welcome uh Mr Duncan and uh the floor is now yours uh thank you very much for having me I appreciate it um it is one of the most consequential decisions that the board's going to make in hiring the superintendent

009I know you guys have been doing a lot of hard work during the superintendent search um and we provide this training all around the state I have to say this is by far the largest crowd I've ever given this training in front of so um that's interesting um but I just want to take a little bit of time and walk you through kind of the legal requirements of um uh what you need to do and the time fres that you need to follow and the regulations that you need to follow in order to negotiate the contract um at any time after this presentation if you have questions you have my card um please feel free to pick up the phone or email me or what have you I'd be happy to follow up with you

010um if I provided a packet I hope everybody has it that was handed out to you um if not it'll be handed around to you um there are some uh long-standing legal requirements you need to be aware of uh one is um in this of course makes sense but um when you do um vote on the new superintendent um you have to do that in public obviously it has to be a roll call vote um and it requires a full majority of the board doesn't matter what the Quorum is you need to have a full majority of the board in order to uh ratify that contract um the contract can be a three-year contract a 4-year contract or a 5-year contract um those are the options in front of you um and another it's a

011little bit of an oddity but um that contract has to end on July 1st not June 30th it has to end on July 1st it's just kind of a quirk in New Jersey state law um so one other requirement that you need to know that's kind of on the end of the superintendent contract is um if you decide for whatever reason reason at a later date not to renew the contract that you signed with your superintendent say you sign a three-year contract with this superintendent and after two years you decide you're not going to uh uh reup on that contract you need it's very important that you provide three months notice for every year of the contract so if it is a three-year contract 90 days four years 120 days and uh 5 years so

012on um why that's so very important and I do mention in this presentation is if you miss that deadline the consequence of missing that deadline is that you've just bought yourself an automatic renewal of that contract on the same time term so you would buy yourself another three-year contract so that's an important thing to know so in addition to those kind of basic um statutory requirements uh 2008 2009 pretty much the whole ball game changed uh for a couple of reasons one was the uh accountability regulations and obviously the superintendent compensation package and employment um uh contract has to be consistent with the accountability regulations and also the superintendent salary cap okay so we're going to talk a little bit about both of those um first of all on the superintendent salary cap the packet

013of information that I gave you uh on the right hand side there should be um a sheet of paper that has the Caps depending on enrollment uh my understanding is you have about 6,100 students um so that makes the superintendent salary cap um for this District at the base level $65,000 $165,000 but didn't Panic you there for a second right $165,000 um obviously you have a high school in this District so you get a bump of $2,500 so you're up to 675 um so that is the the cap on base level compensation for the superintendent um as part of the superintendent contract you're not requir first of all you're not required to be at cap that's just the the maximum that you're allowed to pay um you can also provide for certain Merit pay criteria

014to be negotiated into the contract and I'm not going to get too deep into the details here um but you can have certain qualitative um Merit criteria you can have um it's uh uh two of those and you can have three uh qualitate I mean quantitative Merit criteria and I've provided you examples of those uh criteria uh in the materials that I gave you um but if you add all of those together in the maximum payout uh the potential Merit pay for the superintendent would be uh 14.9% of the base compensation um so uh you can do that um what you need to know that is if you if you want to explore the idea of having Merit pay um the structure for that the framework of that has to be negotiated into the contract

015uh at the beginning of the process um and the Merit criteria that that you discuss and arrive at as a board has to be pre-approved by the executive County Superintendent um prior to that year taking place you can't make up the Merit criteria Midway through the school year um they have to be easily identifiable at the beginning of the year and that way you'll know whether you hit those criteria or not at the end of the year uh one other thing about the uh the Merit uh pay is that it's not pensionable it's a one-time payment um so if if they hit all the Merit criteria and get the 15% bump in their in their pay it's a one-time payment it doesn't feed into their it's not pensionable it doesn't feed into their their base

016level salary uh they start over again uh at the beginning of the school year okay um so that's the basics of the superintendent salary cap um now part of that 2007 Avalanche of regulations was also the uh accountability regulations so part of that was that the executive County Superintendent has to pre-approve the contract that you reach with your superintendent um and what they're going to look at um is they're going to look at the total compensation package for um the superintendent that you're offering and they are going to number one make sure that it is below the cap but also how it Stacks up against um comparable school districts uh uh throughout the state um and what they need in order to make that determination is they need you to f out this very detailed

017sheet of what the compensation is what the um direct wages are what the benefits are and I provided you a copy of that um spreadsheet that you're going to need to fill out and and um provide to the executive County Superintendent um now it's also important um especially that you know what the the time frames are the executive County Superintendent has to approve that contract um before you ENT into the contract and before you give notice to the public that you've selected a particular candidate um and so um you need to give um the notice requirements are that you need to give 30 days notice before you take a vote on the superintendent's contract and you need to give 10 days notice before you have a public hearing on the contract okay so that's the

018basic time frame that you're looking at um the the contract that you going to be negotiating though is a new contract and there's a little bit of a wrinkle on the law that I need to explain and that is that because it is a a a new contract right um You technically don't need to give public notice um the law says that they encourage you to give public notice um but that can be very tricky in the situation where a superintendent Works in an exist district and they don't know for sure whether they have the job until the executive County Superintendent signs off on the contract so I'm just making you aware of that uh Wrinkle in the law it's not strictly required in those circumstances it's just encouraged um if you're renewing a contract

019or something like that absolutely you have to have um uh public notice in a public hearing okay so um I just want to talk briefly about some of the things that are required in the uh accountability regulations that ESS stuff that you're not allowed to do when you negotiate the the superintendent contract um you are not allowed to provide for uh a severance clause in that contract that allows for a payout if you guys go your separate ways in the middle of that contract it's limited to uh three months of pay for every year remaining on the contract um that's the maximum um separation Clause I guess allowed in the contract you can negotiate something less than that but no no more than that or the executive County Superintendent will not approve that contract um

020has to be consistent with the travel regulations so uh under New Jersey travel regulations you can pay mileage but it's limited to 31 cents a mile you can't play the IRS rate that's just one example of that um you can't um um pay somebody's FICA taxes or um uh things of that nature because the way that the executive County Superintendent views that that's just kind of a way around the superintendent salary cap is providing compensation in that fashion um um there are certain criteria that you need to be aware of in terms of a sick leave and vacation uh I'm not going to get into the details here um there are Provisions that you can if you are not at cap okay you can provide in the contract that there is a an automatic increase

021as long as they are performing satisfactory in Year One two or three of the contract um so you could negotiate something that says I'm just making numbers up now but you know your your salary is $150,000 the first year um satisfactory performance will increase your pay by 2% that's permissible under the accountability regulations to provide that into your contract um you can also have um um kind of another type of Merit pay as part of the contract saying that you know the base level increase will be 2% but if you meet predetermined criteria and again it has to be pre-approved by the superintendent including your contract we could provide for a salary increase higher than that um uh another thing you need to be aware of um and this is a particular issue when it

022comes to health insurance and that is that um by law you cannot treat the superintendent any better than you treat your teaching staff so um this is a little inside baseball but if your teaching staff are paying um at phase four of chapter 78 you can't say to your superintendent we'll let you pay at phase one they have to pay at the same rate that the teachers are paying um so um just be aware of that because that's something that you might hear from the candidate that they'd like to pay less and who wouldn't for their health insurance um but that's not permissible under the law um the other thing is is this seems common sensical but you must have a provision in the contract that says if the superintendent loses their certification they lose

023their job the contract's null and V it just happens automatically and that's consistent with state law but now it says that that has to be you know black letter in the four corners of the contract so just be aware of that so I just gave you a truncated version of things that can't be in the contract and things that need to be in the contract um so it seems like a lot to to kind of Digest but the good news is the state um provided you with plenty of guidance uh and so what they've did is um they tasked the New Jersey school board's Association and uh the association representing superintendent to sit down and kind of hash out a model contract um and it's not technically required under the law that you follow that

024model contract but the executive County Superintendent wants to see the basic outlines of that model contract um so you you know you you're likely going to have an attorney help you uh draft the final contract that's the template that they ought to be following um and it will certainly speed the process of being approved by the executive County Superintendent if you use that format um that was um this uh the kind of a truncated version of that training um I know you guys have a full agenda tonight I'm happy to take any questions any questions for Mr Duncan I have a question sure if we go from student enrollment if we're now under 6,500 if we bump up over 6,500 how would that play into the contract the the contract would be the contract for

025the term uh that you agreed to um you could um make uh you could uh make make a motion is the wrong terminology but you could you could you could ask the superintendent whether it would be okay to open up the contract at that point um to provide for some higher salary increase the other option if you think that is a likelihood um then you might be able to try to include that in the terms of the contract that if you bump up over 6,500 um using official state numbers that the pay will automatically go up truthfully I don't know whether the executive County Superintendent will approve that or not um I find it unlikely but um you know that's not something that is Crystal Clear in the law so um something you might speak

026with your attorney about out any other questions no other questions okay we thank you Mr Duncan for that presentation I'm sure we find it useful thank you let's see where we are okay at this time we'll be going to our first public session I would like to uh read some of the regulations regarding that so that there's there is no confusion and I do ask that uh both our public as well as our board members abide by these guidelines during the first public comment session participants are restricted to items that are on the agenda for that meeting it will be helpful to the board if the speaker identifies the specific item of the agenda that's that's going to be spoken of other comments questions or concerns are restricted to the second public comment section participants

027when you come to the microphone you should state your name place of residence and any group affiliation if applicable your statement is limited to no more than minutes and this applies also to statements of a complimentary nature all statements are directed to the presiding officer you are not to address or question individual members of the board nor are individual members of the board expected to comment or respond to you your cooperation and adhering to these will provide for a successful uh public session I will remind you essentially the public session is not intended to become a debate it is an opportunity for you to bring up concerns or points to the board we are making a special exception this evening uh Mrs Lang are you here okay uh Mrs Lang uh I had some conversations

028with her and we are making a special exception for Mrs Lang due to some medical circumstances that she is dealing with uh we are granting her permission to speak on on a topic which is not on the agenda but this is a very special exception and uh we'll now hear from Mrs Lang and then other speakers can come to the mic to speak on the agenda thank you thank you um I'm Patricia Lang I live at 74 McFarland Circle here in Monroe I um am going to speak about Park and Common Core I am the parent of a fifth grade student and the representative of a group of over 300 parents teachers and residents who are questioning our involvement in park testing some of us have notified the district that we are refusing to allow

029our children to participate in park and others have not regardless of whether or not we intend to refuse Park this year we feel strongly that the Board of Ed needs to develop and Implement a policy that will support a parents right to refuse to allow their children to participate in this testing we understand the constraints that you are border under we also are aware of our rights as parents to refuse to have our children participate in Statewide standardized assessments it is our desire to work with our board to develop procedures that will recognize our parental rights to refuse Park we request that the Board of Education Institute a policy that would help protect the privacy of and minimize the amount and type of data that will be col collected on our children for whom we

030are refusing the park assessments being that students under the age of 18 are minors it is our responsibilities as their parents to make decisions in their best interest parents who have chosen to refuse standardized testing for their minor children should be offered options as to what their child will do while testing and test prep is occurring it is our desire for the district to develop a policy that will respect our right to refuse the standardized testing and maintain our children's dignity and self-esteem we also request that the Board of Ed look to the longrange negative impacts of Park and Common Core and do what they can to stand up against it if the state continues to force the park incom core on our local Educational Systems we hope that you our Board of Education will

031work with other boards and other entities around the state to protect the rights of parents who are refusing and Implement policies that minimize the negative effects of this testing on our children if the use of Park continues the district will need to explore alternate educational and assessment opportunities for our children whose parents are refusing the testing a district-wide committee to do so should should be established and parents along with classroom teachers should serve on this committee the district needs to explore how to minimize the impact of standardized testing on the educational environment other districts are doing away with content area tests in order to allow for greater Focus to be placed on Park Prep the shift to a park focused educational environment is denying our children the opportunity to explore and master non-park subjects it

032is taking away from their time spent learning Science History world languages and the Arts we need to find a way to put education back in education we believe that Park and the Common Core need to be stopped we come in front of you today wearing red to stop Park and the common core from ruining education for our children and our teachers thank you you timed that perfectly Mrs Lang thank you and thank you for sharing your concerns okay is there anyone who wants to uh address any items on the agenda good evening and you can tell me if I need to sit down uh I'm I want to address the super Karen castaldo president of the mtea uh for Cypress Point Lane Jackson New Jersey um addressing the superintendent search do I need to sit

033down or can I address it at this time I just want to make sure I'm clear I just have a comment I know the superintendent report went out so I'm confused okay Mr Gorski advises me that you are permitted to speak on this topic at this time thank you uh I'm here not only talking on behalf of the MTA but on behalf of the entire ire Monroe Community I've been in this district for 26 years uh I enjoy this District I love this District I um been president for about 14 15 years in all of the years that I have been here even prior before my presidency there has always been a committee uh in regard to the superintendent search consisting of not only mtea members but parents in the community community members administrators uh

034some students and it occurred when we had finalists and those meetings were in my opinion best practice meetings uh in terms of hiring a superintendent that is good for our Monroe Community I understand that the that this has all changed based on some legal uh whatever legal whatever um but anyway I know that the legal issues are there and I am only asking the board to consider when you're at the final when we're at the finalist time point in time that a committee be formed so we can put our community back in the table back in the game uh and move forward from there because there are many members many community members many parents that feel slighted or left out and we don't really understand why thank you very much thank you for your comments

035Miss castaldo anyone else wish wishing to speak to the agenda okay seeing no one else we will then close the first public forum and move to the approval of minutes all board members were given uh copies of the minutes for the public board meeting of November the 19th are there any comments or questions on that Corrections okay do I hear a motion to approve those minutes second uh p a second all in favor I okay opposed extensions one obain anyone recusing okay those minutes are there approved uh then we have the minutes of the Clos session meeting of November the 19th are there any comments or Corrections there okay is there a motion a second do we have a second on that motion second all in favor I opposed abstentions I I'm sorry I I

036I have to recuse myself on both of those uh obviously for obvious reasons yes you you weren't on the board at that time correct okay all right also Mr Mayo so thank you all right at this time we will hear the superintendent's report and recommendations oh I'm sorry sorry I overlook that are there any committee reports this evening if so just let me know okay Mr coffen sure we had a curriculum committee meeting this uh evening uh we had two presentations one was on the new Academy platform that will be implemented uh this September and I think it would be a good idea if we have a public presentation and the material maybe later in the year just before the this year ends uh to give everybody a view of what the new Academy structure

037is going to look like uh at the high school uh additionally we were providing Ed a technology survey which I believe were given to the uh freshman class just as soon as they got their iPads this year just to get an idea of how technologically proficient they are so we can have like a benchmark of uh our St our our students where they were when they first entered the high school and we're going to keep track of how technologically proficient they are as they move through the high school and and look to move that technology proficiency down to the lower grades as well um so more to come on that that's it thank you Mr Kaufman any other chair people miss miss kovich okay I have two reports this evening uh the first is um

038buildings grounds and Transportation uh the first item is the Monro Township Middle School site work the outside work on the middle school is substantially completed but all of the work has not been accepted there have been some issues on the concrete work on the sidewalk and the stairs so the board is is holding some money on that contract until those issues are addressed uh second item is the structural report on the district bleachers the bleachers at the high school middle school and the soccer fields are good the football stadium bleachers are in good condition and could last another 10 years except for the um there's wooden floorboards to walk on to get to the bleachers and um with the wear and tear and the elements of the weather uh should be considered for replace within

039the next 5 years and the syn Synthetic Turf field is nearing its 10year anniversary and probably should be looked at um currently there are no cameras at the Fieldhouse and the playing fields the closest cameras are located at the middle school and the bg& committee agreed that installing cameras in that area would be a good idea especially with the amount of people that are attending games so it was agreed by the committee to solicit quotes from from vendors for pricing before going to the full board for approval and the last item we discussed was redistricting Ross habber gave us an update on his redistricting report using the October 15th Assa enrollment data he is working with the township engineer on attendance zones and the most recent tax maps he is also awaiting the mayor to

040sign off on updated construction information on the section block and lots of new developments as soon as he is in receipt of all that information the committee will reconvene to discuss whether or not to move forward with the redistricting and then bring a recommendation to the full board and this decision needs to be made in a timely manner so that if we do move forward with the redistricting for this September parents can be notified as soon as possible and our schools can begin preparing for the new look of some of the schools so that includes concl UD bg& are there any questions on that okay then I'll go to finance the finance committee discussed the refunding of the series 2006 and Series 2008 bonds that will give the district a cost Savings of $2.4 million

041that will go directly back to the taxpayers there is a resolution I believe on the agenda this evening to approve that refunding of those bonds then we talked about the upcoming 201526 budget um we we discussed the status of that the operating budget the budget is being compiled based on the parameters set forth at the board budget philosophy committee meeting back in August of 2014 there are no instructional programs being eliminated there will be no more trailers in the district after June of 2015 and Staffing requirements are very conservative including in included in the budget are Renovations for nine additional classrooms at the middle school giving it much needed more classroom space a temporary solution to the roof at Woodland School a payment for new technology devices at the high school and the costs for

042the additional 200 plus students that we're expecting to arrive next year we have not received the amount of what our funding from the state will be nor have we received the ratables numbers from the town so at this time we do not have a tax implicate implication to our community uh the preliminary budget will be unveiled in March Public public meeting at which time the public will have their opportunity to speak to the budget there was also a discussion on Mecca the ECE which early childhood education and The Basque programs it was unanimously decided by the committee to bring a vote on the elimination of Mecca to the full board this evening for discuss disc and a possible vote but it's my belief that the committee decision has now been sent back to the finance

043committee for more information so that concludes my finance report thank you Miss kapovich is there another Miss Mar AR Mino yes thank you board president po um this is in reference to the policy committee that never met we had three opportunities but the uh weather super proceeded that and we had to cancel the policy meeting three times so I apologize to the public uh but what will be on the agenda when we finally do get another date um are some things that uh currently the public may be interested in there's a policy that will be discussed um 8110 which is attendance areas um p uh pupil records which is policy 8330 uh if if parents would like to review those policies uh right now nothing has changed but we are re in the process of

044reviewing our policies and the policy meeting when we get one uh hopefully the weather will hold out is open to the public thank you thank you Mrs armeno any other reports okay now we'll move to the superintendent's report thank you Mr President is recommended that the members of the monen Board of Education approve Personnel items a through X okay uh is there a motion to approve items a through X okay okay I'm sorry okay are there any questions or comments no questions or comments okay roll call vote Mr Gorski thank you m armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr ranesi yes Mr Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs colano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr P yes Mr board president Personnel items a through X passes regarding board action Mr President

045is recommended that the members of the manship Board of Education approve board items a through H second are there any questions or comments Mr ntin just a quick question with regards to uh E I know in the past we've always had this but but I just was had a uh a semantic question basically this violence substance abuse estimated violence vandalism are these just the costs because we used to also just list the incidents uh if there were no CS are these M Mr board president Mr notin there are no incidents being reported this month um that's why there's no cost associated with it but in the past as you probably recall if there is an incident of vandalism or uh vandalism in particular to the district the student is responsible or their parents are responsible

046to reimburse the district for their costs and that has always been submitted to the business office in previous okay now but OB was mainly just I mean I just wonder were there any uh uh substance abuse incidents that weren't costly that didn't cost us anything so basically we' had no incidences at all okay thank you very much okay Mr Gorski uh would you now give us your business administrator's report oh no I'm sorry sorry about that uh do we have a motion to approve item a through J motion approve second a through h on board action yes okay it's a through H yes okay that's items a through H I'm sorry about that okay all right okay uh board action items a through H was moved by Mr noin seconded by Mr Braverman I will

047now proceed with a roll call Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kapano Mr nosin yes Mr proso Mr Ryback yes Mr Po yes Mr board president board action items a through AG passes Mr superintendent does that conclude your report it does that takes us to the business Ministry report Mr Gorski would you now give us your your report please yes sir um Mr board president members of the Board of Education members of the public there's an 11-page resolution on tonight and this resolution sets forth the parameters for maturities interest rates underwriter discount etc for the refunding bonds with the actual terms to be approved by me within such parameters it also appoints two Underwriters an escrow agent and a verification agent our financial adviser

048and I solicited bids for all appointed positions due to the size of our refunding and our exceptional credit quality of the district bids from six Underwriters were solicited and all responded to the request the resolution also requires uh me to report back to the board with the actual sale terms of the refunding bonds which based upon current schedule will be at the April meeting I do not have to read the 11-page resolution it was previously submitted to the board so we're spared that this evening so m Mr board president and members of the mon Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through J be approved by consent roll call so move any questions yeah any questions or comments Mr brayman under under under professional appointments number one aren't all our

049buildings handicap accessible yes that's correct then why do we need somebody to evaluate whether a wheelchair will come aboard I believe that number one is to conduct wheelchair assessments uh for the specific equipment not for the facilities it's it's for a professional to come in and uh work on assessment of the wheelchairs any other questions or comments okay uh we have a roll call Vote Yes and uh approve items a through J yes and for full disclosure the resolutions for the refunding require a 2third majority vote they're unique in that nature so I wanted to point that out Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs colano yes but recuse on letter D recuse on d as in David So noted Mr noin yes Mr proso yes

050Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president board action items a through J passes thank you that concludes my report thank you Mr Gorski uh at this time I will I'll give a brief report I would like to give an update to the board as well as the uh community on our current status of our superintendent search the deadline for applications was January 9th at which time we had received 38 completed applications screenings were done by the New Jersey school boards Association of all documents that were received they also conducted interviews of those candidates and that yielded 37 candidates who met or exceeded the criteria set by this board back in the fall of those 37 18 are currently serving as superintendents or assistant superintendents eight are currently serving as principles or vice principles

051nine are in a position of being a director or supervisor three fell into other categories 21 candidates held Doctorate Degrees 32 were from New Jersey and six others were from diverse States Pennsylvania New York Florida Massachusetts Illinois and Virginia on January 21st the board met in closed session to review the resumés and select those that we wanted to interview we also formulated the questions that each candidate would be asked we we selected 11 people to interview but two withdrew before we began conducting the first round during the first week of February which was last week we interviewed nine candidates and we are now in the process of conducting our second round of interviews I would also like to uh offer some congratulations to some of our uh teams here at the high school on January

05220th our academic team placed second among 38 teams in a rigorous competition held at High-Tech high school in Monmouth County the team consisted of brat nadendla Sherry Bay Tatiana Dr drish skaya Neil Patel Michelle banker and Elena Mna on January 15th over 100 Monroe High School students volunteered to take test after school in biology chemistry and physics this test was conducted by the New Jersey science League science supervisor Bonnie caletto indicated that only 17 students from our school had participated in this competition about eight years ago it is good to see that this past year we had over a 100 students which is a sixfold increase in students interested in competing in the uh area of Sciences uh finally our mock trial team they were crowned middle sex County Champions on February the 4th they

053went on to compete in the Central Jersey Regional finals against winning teams from Mercer Union Somerset hunon Monmouth and Burlington counties and uh that concludes my report at this time we'll hear any other board business is there any other Miss arbino um I I'm I just like to congratulate all the teams uh for their efforts and winning and that would be it's wonderful yes thank you thank you anyone else Miss Kap panovich yeah um at the January 14th Board of Education meeting um Mr Gorski stated in his ba report and he talked about the refinancing of the oak tree bonds and it would be a cost Savings of $2.4 million during the life of the bonds and there was a comment made by one of the board members that said quote that's the kind of

054money we're talking about and I was a little taken aback by that comment because that's the kind of money the board has always tried to do so I went back and did some research and I'd like to give the public because I know that there were some questions from the public an idea of some of the significance cuts that we have made in the past we refinanced the 2002 series Bond saving 1.5 million we refinanced a 2003 series Bond saving 2.5 million and we refinanced the 2006 2008 series Bond savings 3.7 million that's $7.7 million that went directly back to the taxpayers the board authorized the district to become a member of the middle seex County Purchasing Consortium saving us $1.2 million so far the high school bond surplus of 5.5 million and the oak

055tree Bond surplus of 350,000 were given back to the taxpayers most of the districts would have used that money to enhance their building projects our board decided it was more important to help out the community we negotiated an insurance opt out with our staff that saved us 4.3 million so far we also negotiated the continuation of chapter 78 contributions with the mtea that will save us $6 million over the last two years of the contract chapter 78 sunsets this year and many other districts are not negotiating a continuation of um chapter 78 we've saved $3.7 million in changes to health care and by eliminating some of our programs that we have saved over $400,000 um these are just some of the significant cuts that we we've made to our past budgets in the past 5

056years the district has saved 30, 8343 which we have eliminated from the budget we have negotiated in the budget or have given directly back to the taxpayers so I I just wanted the public to to to know that we have always passed boards done our due diligence and making sure that we have come up with a fair budget that helps our children and yet is fiscally responsible to our taxpayers and that concludes that report thank you miss kapovich that was uh interesting information and I'm sure that it'll be appreciated by our public as well as all the members on the board thank you for that report anyone else okay at this time we will go into the second public session uh I will not uh reread the rules uh I will simply enforce them if

057if it becomes necessary just keep in mind that uh during this session anyone coming to the microphone uh will be limited to three minutes thank you good evening my name is Kathy Lenard I live at 8 Cyprus drive here in Monroe Township I'm here tonight to express my concern about Park and the common core standards as an educator both old school and new school I have participated in the changes that common Corp has mandated these changes are not in our students best interests the common core is one size fits all we all know children they're many sizes same families have different children um what I have experienced they're not developmentally appropriate we're asking too much of two young children we're setting them up for failure um I tell my students success breeds success and the

058opposite failure breeds more failure um Park the park tests are not differentiated good teachers differentiate their instruction minute by minute to meet those needs of our children then we subject them to a test that is not only not normed it's not like a test standardized test like the cat or the teranova it is completely different um the time spent preping for these tests is ridiculous I've spent three weeks of every quarter preparing my students for the test because where I work we did prep tests before the tests and we had a prep for the prep test and we had a retach after the prep test their entire education was learning how to test what I'm asking you tonight is to join with Dr Chris tin and Diane renich and others to return common sense to

059education to get good teaching practices back into the classrooms this country was founded in the belief that citizens have the right to change what is wrong the common Corp is wrong we need to stand up and let the legislators know that this is not right for our children that we need good princi teaching practices that meet the individual needs of each child in the classroom that they are not cookie cutters expected to do the same things at the same time there's too many differences out there to go that way quit comparing us to Japan or other countries where they only teach an elite group thank you thank you Mrs Leonard for your comments years hello my name is Christine Walters I live at 31 Texas Road in menro I was previously in the early childhood

060education field for 17 years and I'm currently a senior nursing student I have three children in the district and three different schools I would like to start with a little history of common core and how it came to be five people along with two lobbyist groups small capitalist organizations and federal government were funded $150 million originally by The Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation to create Common Core behind closed doors and implement it into our schools in a way that makes it impossible to pull out Bill Gates has spent $2.5 billion today on Common Core we have spent much more promoting it and buying off grots to get on board to nationally Market it my question to you all of you is what qualifies them to do so New Jersey along with originally 45 other states

061accepted common core standards before they were even written in exchange for 5 bill ion dollar of American taxpayers money and they were told that they would get a waiver for the No Child Left Behind Act which Ed which Educators did not believe in somewhere along the line a group of people who were not qualified to do so decided that standard-based education is the best for our children outcome-based education is Le less important where the kids are met in the classroom and the focus is on where they they end up at the end of the road so inevitably teachers will have no choice but to teach to the test our children are individuals who grow and learn at different rates one size does not fit all Common Core boasts the enhancement of critical thinking skills this

062this would require a fully developed prefrontal cortex which is responsible for critical thinking and is not fully developed until 21 years of age Common Core decre decreases reading by 50% and increases writing by 50% if we are only telling the children to write without reading we are not allowing the development of the prefrontal cor cortex we are then indoctrinating them with informational politically charged texts instead of Ethics morality and character when we ask the kids to write critically using emotionally charged language to P persuade instead of inform the thought process is then directed to the lyic system and the child goes into fight or flight mode this constant state of stress is stati statistically linked with long-term psychological issues depression and PTSD developmentally our children do not have the ability to temper their judgment so

063we teach to the test that has never been benchmarked against any other country before I'm appalled with the Common Core with a lack of explanation the poorly designed materials and the infringement upon my parental rights as well as my child's privacy rights my daughter came home with an informational taex last week from school titled should parents help with homework homework can be stressful but help for Mom and Dad might be the wrong answer coupled with texts that site your state and National elected officials care about what you are learning and think it's important for you to learn X Y and Z as it's stated in my daughter's social studies books what kind of message are we sending our children My Hope Is that you will all join us in taking the first step in getting

064back local control so that we may continue educating our children in a safe healthy productive manner I expect that you will support me my children and the growing number of families that will be refusing the park exam by implementing an appropriate policy that is best for our children thank you thank you for your comments Mrs Walter how you doing Doug Dale 653 spots Intown Road I decided not to have my daughter a sophomore take the park my decision is based on three factors one I don't trust the test I don't feel the state's Park rollout preparation has been sufficient it's confusing it's unorganized there's there have been many unnecessary Rush there has been an unnecessary Rush of the state to get the test out the districts with little care in actual academic interest of the

065local school district I'm simply not going to put her through days worth of testing on content that is different from what she has learn is learning in her classes now this is not a reflection to the teachers Administration or the district so on the state that this test has not been directly linked academically to what New Jersey students are actually being taught the state says it's Common Core linked but the way the Pearson company has worded the questions is not how students are learning two my daughter's welfare is more important than the park I don't feel that she should be put through a stress of taking this test when the results will have little importance to her as a student there's enough pressure just being a 15-year-old high school student looking at going on to

066college in the short two years and having to perform her best just to get there she's anxious enough knowing that she'll have to take the S soon adding on the demands to do well on the test that she's not prepared for will surely be detrimental to her well-being enough is enough on high stakes testing three I don't like the idea that the state collecting data on my daughter May have a negative impact on her future if she doesn't do well I don't like that this data will follow her around good or bad it hasn't been made clear on what the data will be used for or where the where the where it will go and I don't want her name being connected to irrelevant or possibly damaging information I don't like that a for-profit company

067will be using her information for more profit and I don't trust that this current state government will not use this information for political reasons so until this becomes a mandatory reason for mandatory for reasons related to her graduation or College acceptance my daughter will not participate lastly what I think is most important for the children of Monroe not taking the park I'd rather this District whose number one core belief is noted that all decisions are made on the premise that children come first take the lead in Middle sex County by establishing a suitable alternative location as educationally sound for students who are refusing to take the park please don't take the easy way out by just repeating commissioner hp's prepared tough talk script of refuse the park and you will sit and stare at the

068walls as punishment or be Trent if you stay home that's not Monroe we're Educators and the sit and stare policy is not an educated life lesson we should be teaching our children thank you for your time go Falcons thank you Mr Dale my name is Taylor Walters and I live at 31 Texas road I am seventh grader at the middle school and I have been an honor roll throughout my school career I have also pride in my in making a difference in getting involved in programs like character crew and circle friends and up until yesterday the technology student student Association or TSA after much thought I decided to drop out because there is great pressure from Common Core and Park Prep I spent endless hours on homework being drilled in ela and math our math

069book has minimal instructions so when we are confused there are no references in ela we write the same things over and over again until our hands hurt I'm frustrated because my teachers tell me on a regular basis that we will have to cran for Park I don't believe that we are learning anything of value in class the focus is only on acing the test how does anyone Express us to expect us expect us to absorb information with poorly designed textbooks fast lessons and the stress that comes along with it all I feel defeated I stand here tonight with hope that this won't be our lives for years to come I believe that the first step to making the change because nothing is unchangeable is to refuse the park in the beginning I was scared to

070refuse because I was afraid of punishment but now the frustration is unbearable and I have hope that the policy for non- test takers test takers is fair so that students like my my 10-year-old sister will not be fearful of going to school on Park days I hope that someday soon we will be able to go to park go to go to school without Common Core and park hanging over our heads thank you thank you Miss Walters hello I'm Kevin colie 33 lywood Drive in Monroe I'm a parent of two students in grade seven and nine here in Monroe I have another child that graduated from Monroe High School and is away at College um I'm not an education professional I happen to be a credentialed professional actuary for 25 years my exposure to Common Core

071is that my youngest daughter I was unable to help her with my math homework as essentially a professional and Applied Mathematics the basics long division simplifying fractions proportions when I tried to help my daughter with her homework the answer I got is we don't do it that way we have to show it some other way I said fine show me the examples I don't have examples I said where are the materials this is crazy let's figure this out it was completely frustrating I I did some searches on the internet internet these other methods we have to show some sort of special way of explaining how to do it it's nonsense uh my friends and I were uh did advanced math in in in a public high school just like Monroe and uh we all did

072fine this is a solu a solution in search of a problem it's crazy um the teachers aren't ready I don't believe the materials are ready this thing was rammed through um they say explain how you do it everyone knows the way you do these problems is you do a lot lot of different word problems and that's how you learn it that's basic one of the gentlemen up here explained about all the high school students that achieved these Awards and everything they they didn't have Park they didn't have common core all through the way we all know people Engineers lawyers scientists they didn't have common core they didn't have Park it's crazy we're spending way too much time on this we need to have respectful procedures for students that are opting out of this um and

073I thank you for allowing me to uh make these remarks and anyone who says people that are against Park are against testing that's nonsense we all did testing growing up the Iowa thing you did it once a year you filled in the circles they figured out if a school had a problem this is common sense this is not rocket science this is a waste this is a money grab there's Consultants foundations you follow the money do some internet searches and you'll figure it out thank you thank you for your comments sorry good evening my name is sueza I'm a fifth grade teacher at Applegarth elementary school and I live in Freehold when it came to my attention that there's a complicated decision to eliminate Mecca I had to ask myself what is the most important

074responsibility as a board member and mine as an educator in Monroe in both of our roles the commonality is the children we are here to enrich and Foster our youth to ensure students success our jobs are rooted in the development and well-being of children the Monroe employee Child Care Academy isn't just an institution to enhance young minds prior to entering kindergarten but it happens to be a family of nurturing teachers since it's a newer business more time needs to be given to understand the trade-offs between a child's development and the ability of using its Financial gains I've been a fifth grade teacher in Monroe Township for 15 years now one including a maternity leave of one year one of the reasons that I actually returned was knowing that Mecca was an option for my husband

075and I to enroll our children having peace of mind that my twin daughters are well taken care of enriched and cherished adds to my productivity as a teacher I enrolled my daughters when they were 1 and a half years old and I'm so greatly appreciative of Mecca I found another I could have found another child care facility near my home and not returned to Monroe but then I wouldn't be standing here today this year's Applegarth teacher of the year voicing my pride in Mecca's program several excellent teachers returned to their positions after maternity leave due to Mecca so please think about how many exceptional teachers you might lose if you close Mecca's doors upon exploring exploring other child care centers I found that for 5 days a week tuition can be around $850 from 7:00

076a.m. to 7:00 p.m. including before and after care I pay over $1,000 a month for two little girls to attend Mecca only 2 days a week another facility's tuition was about $300 less for the two days a week so it's just very interesting that 75% of the research child care centers are less expensive than Mecca however I still choose meca I'm unable I am able to give my students my undivided attention and teaching skills since I'm not weighed down by the uncertainty of who's taking care of my children my focus on teaching may not be as evident had they been in another facility research shows that employee productivity increases when you definitely have satisfied workers I choose Mecca not because it was any convenience or less costly for my family but because of the staff

077and the family there they're part of the Monroe Family and have an excellent reputation for nurturing youth my daughters are part of a school setting where they feel extremely safe and then I feel secure trusting that the staff will take the very best care of them although like I said tuition is not the cost-efficient way for me with this Center I continue to utilize the facility due to the fact that our three-year-old twins are very happy while learning so my confusion lies here since all staff members who have children enrolled in Mecca do pay tuition how could it be such a substantial budget component where you feel that it would have to be eliminated I strongly urge you to keep Mecca's doors open thank you thank you for your comment good evening um my name

078is Don Marie kappus I live at 21 Avenue H in Monroe Township and I'm standing here tonight as a representative of our Mecca parents and I am the mom of three children all who attend Mecca I love that you got to see a poster so I'll show you three of my cuties the vision behind starting Mecca was that it would allow for teachers who are on maternity leave to return to work sooner and since Mecca's opening and fall of 2012 I know of at least 12 teachers who have taken half a year of maternity and then enrolled in Mecca which directly correlates to this vision and this provides a cost savings to the district I can tell you personally I came back after four months with my second and four months after my third I

079attended the board meeting in 2013 where the previous board asked dror Hamilton to create a solvency plan to enhance Mecca's profitability and the kindergarten enrichment program was created both programs have flourished and continue to grow there are currently 42 children enrolled in Mecca and 35 in the kindergarten enrichment for a total of 77 students just to compare the first year of Mecca that it was open there were four children in my oldest son's class and now there are 15 in his prek class keep in mind that Mecca also gave up a classroom to the kindergarten enrichment program which hasn't affect on enrollment we could expand the age range for each classroom and open enrollment even further if we had that classroom back there are 12 Mecca families that are also Monroe families as is mine

080who will be entering our school district we can provide you some more factual information in the very near future through a survey we have created and we will be sending out to our staff the mecca parents and supporters of this program are urging the board to listen to suggestions we sent you via mail or email to help continue to increase Mecca's profitability and ask you to support and continue to service this program which is not only necessary for working parents as you have just heard but which we and our children hold near and dear to our hearts and I can tell you on a personal level honestly I don't know what I would do without Mega and I am beyond grateful that our district has put something in place for working parents such as me

081thank you thank you are there any other speakers hello Amy antelis 10:49 Morning Glory Drive um I don't think I need to elaborate any more on the park um I think the heartfelt concern that was um addressed tonight by the parents and the students here was enough but I'd like to um urge the board and the community to actually go to Chris tin.com and the article that Mr T that I'm sorry Dr tinkin wrote Dr tinkin is a well-respected educator and curriculum person in the state of New Jersey and I would just like to read the last paragraph of this article because I think it really sums it up he says we have the ultimate assessment system already working in our classrooms it's called the teacher let's invest in developing teachers assessment skills instead of

082spending millions of dollars on tests that do not tell us anything new about our children thank you thank you Miss anellus hello Board of Ken Cher 116 perol Avenue Mr Po congratulations on your presidency thank you uh I just want to thank Mrs Mrs Lang and all the parents that came out today to speak about Park and Common Core um I just want you know I just want to reiterate that what you heard here is the need for a policy so my hope is that when you adjourn and you move forward that you look at a good comprehensive policy that will enable our parents and our and our students to be able to know you know that if they decide to refuse what the what the parameters are and their recourse is I think that

083one of the things that we have to remember here is that everybody likes to talk about transparency but I think the reason that you're probably not hearing from a lot of parents is because they don't know that they can refuse and I can tell you that when you when you talk to parents and you are a parent like I like I am uh you see it for yourself you see what common core uh has to offer or doesn't have to offer you live through the homework which I hope there aren't any kids here is really um and and and you go through that over and over again just to then be assessed on a test and have all that anxiety I I just think that there may be parents that decide that they don't want

084to opt out or opt their children out or refuse but they they might want to know that they can do that and I think that that's an important part uh and just a just you know just a couple other things I think that with common core we what we need to do or with you what you need to do as a board is to let our teachers do what they do best which is teach and and not have to teach to attest they teach what they know and uh teach our children so that they're successful the the uh I have I do have a couple other questions though one is that last year we were told that Mecca was well on its way to being a money-making venture or was a money-making Venture would be

085pay would be paying back the loan and uh would be profitable and now I'm hearing that we're looking or you're looking to scrap it is it not profitable now is that why evening evening um that's a a common misunder understanding and um I'm glad you brought it up Mecca as it was originally uh initiated was uh a child care service and the model for that service was not to have a profit generating uh business function it was M mainly designed to break even and provide a service for staff the break even point point for Mecca was approximately 75 uh enrolled students it has never materialized to that number and in fact the number is uh about 42 as we speak but it it fluctuates um so the mecca segment for providing daycare has and still

086is uh a money losing Endeavor the board directed Dr Hamilton to come up with a solvency plan and as somebody mentioned that's when Early Childhood enrichment was uh was initiated the two fuse together are profitable because Early Childhood enrichment is quite a profitable model and when you blend the two together under the name Mecca which is Consolidated in the same fund it is breaking even uh profitable at times and as the financial statement which I'm going to present to the finance committee next meeting it has now um dipped into the negative once again and that's simply a result of uh you know fees being generated so Mecca as a daycare segment has and still loses money it is brought to solvency with the infusion of revenues from Early Childhood enrichment okay and can you tell

087us what uh what the outcome of close session was I I know we there was a lengthy Clos session but I'm not sure what happened whe was there any resolution was there is there going to be any action taken tonight uh the entire discussion of closed session is still uh confidential we cannot share any information with you at this time okay I'd ask as soon as that is uh you know as soon as that's resolved that the public gets to hear about that and find out what went on in there thank you hi I'm Stacy Blum I work at Barkley Brooks school and I'm requesting that you keep Mecca open my children were among the first to enroll when Mecca opens its doors in September 2012 we could not have been more pleased with the

088school teachers and the program and it's so nice to have a daycare so close to my school and on the same schedule plus we are saving a lot of money by using Mecca over other daycares so and I know the school is growing every year and I urge you to please keep Mecca open to continue benefiting my child and more children for years to come thank you thank you Esther Gregory to Kelly Court um speaking as a parent um I refuse for my fourth grader to take the park test uh speaking with Educators it is not developmentally appropriate for him to take it I have a fourth grader he I refuse for him to take it we would request we have access to another classroom to read study complete homework or special projects I also

089have a second grader so I'm trying to pair him for next year I have a seventh grader which I on the fence of should he take the park test um my kids are capable of testing I just think it's inappropriate at this time and I'm speaking to a lot of parents and I'm hearing back about how this will place for basic skills tag accelerated classes honors and special education and they're concerned I'm listening to them I'm trying to and thank you for Patty Kathy and Christine with working with me and helping me on this one so thank you for listening but I refuse for my fourth grader especially it's inappropriate for grades three through five thank you thank you for your comment this is nice uh L L Masters Nam Mela Court this is very

090nice congratulations that was good um I was going to talk about common core uh but most of my thunder was let's talk about Pearson um if you remember last year I'm not a big fan um last year we had that vote which I was very upset with most of the board where we actually had Pearson this was Pearson's recommendation Pearson had their own Consultants come in to tell us whether the Pearson software was actually working and whether or not we should buy more Pearson software um it's ridiculous Pearson's actually being investigated by FBI in California for bid fixing uh Rucker's graduate school won't allow him to submit bids any anymore um it's it's a bad bad company somebody said it's all about the money it is all about the money originally they were going to

091make now these are their numbers $24 per student which by their original estimates was $240 million on this exam one exam every time somebody takes it or administers it it's now down since all everybody's been backing out to half of that they're at a 50% utilization rate with this exam they're down to $120 million though one exam um they also there's something called the student privacy pledge which things like the National School Board Association has has um um put put a lot of work into the White House Congress Pearson will not will not sign that pledge why they want to monetize student data it's plain and simple um we need to also put into our policies something wording to the effect that they cannot sell any of the information on our students from these exams

092they're going to do it and then do you want information following your students for the next or following your kids for the next 15 20 years it'll happen Our Generation worried about cookies now you're going to be worried about the park exam results that I took when I was in fifth grade and whether or not I can uh go to college I think it's a joke um back to refusing uh I refuse my kids every every test I could take I refuse with this um every kid I I refuse um I think it's very very poorly uh mandated it's very poorly structured um who do I depend on some said it perfectly I depend on the teachers I don't care about these exams um my son's bringing home these paragraphs he's asking me what they

093means I don't know half of what they mean and then he asked to type and he only typed seven words a minute he's not going to finish the test on time you know what I refuse the entire thing um the big issue I think is all the hearsay that's going around I know there was some uh information and the lack I mean we're getting a lot of course from the public a lot of rumor mail we're not getting any from from the Board of Ed um I went through and I kind of categorized some of the nastier ones and I like maybe a response um somebody posted that if a parent refuses they can be legally forced to have their child take the exam that was one um if a child refuses their child will

094be sent home um if the child refuses they will not be admitted into other programs some mentioned it before tags uh anything like that um that's it thank you Mr tesler Mr Masters wrong one he's in the back but thank you this is nice Karen castaldo mtea president for Cypress Point Lane Jackson New Jersey uh on behalf of the parents what I'm listening to and the students in regard to park my father used to tell me if someone told you to jump off the bridge would you follow that person or if someone told you to do I don't know run across the street and uh we'll give you 50 bucks on a highway would you do it just because we're getting a dictate a mandate from the state or from our even County Superintendent stating

095that we must do this and there's a hard stance taken in the county do we have to do it the parents are only asking for an opt out policy a place a safe place for their children where they can go to with educational resources that's what they're asking for we can debate about Park all night I can tell you I'm totally against park that's just my opinion and everything I know about it uh so what they're asking is for an opt out policy there are 108 districts that have created an opt out policy thus far in New Jersey four are in our County right now Woodbridge Edison North Brunswick any Brunswick so just because someone tells you to do something and you think it's wrong doesn't mean you have to do it so I hope

096that this board would step up to the plate and support our parents and our students who choose to opt out and where this goes we will know in the future let's see what happens when this test occurs and then it'll be a political nightmare and we'll move on and move past that so um I asked the board to consider an opt out Poli policy thank you m castaldo hello Dominique Walters 5 St James Street Monroe New Jersey um I just I can go on and on about Mecca and how much we all love it here um we it's it's unbelievable but what I want you to all realize before just shutting the doors and boating it down you have many options that you can exhaust before doing this there's many ways to make Mecca profitable

097as a mother of three I have used other day carees for my older daughter I had increased absences with those other day carees many of their events were during school hours I also used home babysitters where I had to take days off when their children were sick or they themselves were sick Mecca is unbelievable I can go on and on everything that was said already but please don't close their doors hi Karine master and I'm Michaela Court um two issues one is I just want to say my first grader last week on Monday and Wednesday got two new students in his class so he is now a 26 my third grader is at 26 children in his class and my fifth grader is at 28 students in his class the large classes are ridiculous at

098this point in time at Oak Tre and Applegarth I work at a title one school I have 18 students in my class and the average class size is 20 it's kind of sad when a title one school has less children in a class than a district like Monroe my second issue is as a special educator currently becoming a park Proctor I've chosen to opt out my third grader and my fifth grader at this time I will not let my children be guinea pigs and polit for the political gains of other people in this state it said that my children have not had a lot of opportunities to read novels but rather spend all their time bringing bringing home and reading informational text I've had it with the informational text we need to get back to

099actual reading for enjoyment other than just graphs and true things it not every child response to that and some children like to read other things so give my two cents and lose said the rest so thank you Hi D marce DZ school counselor here at the high school and on the subject of Mesa I have two daughters there right now and I actually just recently returned from maternity leave in October and I only took three months maternity leave um and the reason that I did that is because I knew that I had Mecca here for my child um rather than repeat many of what you've heard today you've all heard from me personally as well I'd like to make a suggestion when Mecca was in talk of opening they sent out a survey to the

100staff to generate an assessment of what it's enrollment would be like what you would profit from that program I'd like to suggest that before having the finance committee make a decision based on factual data that you have right now also consider sending out another survey generating some information I think that you might find that there are at least 17 people on maternity leave right now that have strong intentions of enrolling their children in Mecca upon their return I think that you would find that give it given it more time that you'll have increased enrollment which also would generate um more funding so I I think that it would be important and beneficial to look at that data before just making a unilateral decision based on a financial committee's recommendation thank you thank you seeing no

101other public speakers the public session is now closed okay one more speaker uh Dave varelis mro Township High School 1 degree Terrace right here mro Township um I didn't prepare anything beautiful for Mecca uh but I can vouch for the beautiful people that take care of my beautiful daughter every day they're uh they're amazing uh and at the end of the day every single day uh I walk out of that school and I hold her hand and she says I had fun at school you can't put price on that thank you okay public session is now closed uh are there any comments from uh superintendent or assistant superintendent or the business administrator on anything if I may Mr President yes uh Lou as you mentioned that you had a couple questions as a matter of

102fact as far as you know the impact on students by the uh by the test by the testing Administration by teachers by the Board of Education just want to make it very clear is that obviously as we go through this process of the park test uh standards Etc you know it's all become very political there's no doubt about that but right now as we go forward I need to assure everybody in the community uh that the Board of Education the administration the teachers uh principes there will be no hurting of any children obviously for the sake of a test you need to know that uh obviously the board will be receptive to what you said this evening uh but you should know also as the fact that as far as what we can do and

103what we can't do is dictated obviously by the mandates of the state but also you should also be aware you know and I heard a couple things tonight as far as uh class sizes you should know that's actually impacting as far as what we can do for Park and what we can't do for Park uh just to give you an example that if you do have let's say 27 students on one side of town and you had the 15 or maybe 18 or on the other side of town you should just know that when it comes to testing and those of you that are Educators know this is that if you have let's say 27 kids in a class and you're pulling out maybe five or six or seven let's say for special needs or

104small groups or maybe learning disabilities whatever it may be you're then requiring other classrooms uh for that test so you should just know that oak tree is probably limited there's no doubt about that the high school may have some some space to do an alternative setting uh we can't do it uh Brookside does not have the settings as well either so we're being dictated by that that's one concern the other thing too is that you should just know is that listen I I hear and I I understand the concerns and the pain that you have you should know that probably know since I've been around for a while as you know uh as an elder in the Monroe Community um it was the MBS I think it was the minimum basic skills test then it

105was espa then it was the gppa the gepa then it was the HSPA then it was hspt uh then New Jersey es we had the Teran noas Etc with each testing uh Administration came more parent anxiety more teacher anxiety Etc we got through that uh certainly is that we'll get through the park assessment as well too uh but again is that I just wanted to make sure as the fact that you understand no child will be hurt you can be guaranteed by this board obviously and by the administration by the teachers um and they heard you board heard you this evening but again is that there are realities as far as what we can do there may be a compromise maybe I'm thinking is that at the very least of that if a parent wants

106to opt out so to speak as you use that phrase the child would stay in the testing environment but maybe just do some quiet reading uh if we can't provide the physical facilities at least there would be that sort of a compromise um I think you just understand though is that we are counting as a as a board of education as the administration we are counting on that Park data though to make assessments of our instructional programs based upon how well the kids do or don't do uh so that assessment is needed and that is required but again is that we may be able to do something like that that would at least maybe appease some of the parents but you should just know is that right now there's nothing on the table as far

107as an alternative setting we're receptive but that is up to the Board of Education thank you okay I have a few comments uh relating to what uh Mr ventrillo has said and essentially um I I'm going to uh quote from some materials that we received from the New Jersey school boards Association uh regarding the park assessment uh the State Board of Education has identified the park assessment as the state's testing program beginning with this Academic Year students uh State regulation contains the following provision and I quote all students at grades levels 3 through 12 shall take appropriate Statewide assessments as scheduled and as I said the park is the Statewide assessment so we have no choice in terms of that we we must give the Statewide uh the park test also uh there's a matter

108of the code of ethics that every member of this board swore to and signed off on at the beginning of the year it says that I will uphold and enforce all laws rules and regulations of the State Board of Education and court orders pertaining to the schools desired changes shall be brought about only through legal and ethical procedures now since the state board has mandated essentially they have required that the park be the state assessment this year the board has no choice in this we would be in violation of the code of ethics if we did not support the administration of the park test I understand your concerns I am a former educator I was a math teacher and I have grandchildren in the school system and I have looked at some of the sample

109tests that they have on their their website and if you haven't done that yet then I would suggest that you might do that so I have some idea of what those tests are like and I I certainly sympathize with the Actuarial father that spoke earlier uh even when it's not Park related uh sometimes my grandchild will come to me and they'll say papa I need you to help me with this and I will look at it and I know that there's various ways of doing it but I'm also very much aware that if I explain it differently than they've heard it in the classroom it's going to be confusing to them and so I have to tread very very carefully with that for a parent who's not trained in math education it's very frustrating for

110you because you know the one way that you learned it but it is being taught by different methods those skills and those understandings so I understand your frustration I really do and uh that's all I have to say at this particular point on the park except that the board must Rely Upon Our Administration and that is our central office administration as well as our building principles they will be the one implementing the testing and we have to rely on them to do the job that they see fit for the children of the township and I trust that they will I I have no doubt about that in terms terms of the mecca since several of you spoke on that topic tonight as you know if you sent me an email I responded to it and

111it was because of the things that you wrote in your email that I discuss with our superintendent whether or not we should have further discussion on the mecca program by the finance committee so I do thank you for those emails I appreciated what you had to offer some of you were very constructive in your ideas I have shared those with our business administrator as well as our superintendent and that is the reason why uh there will be further discussion by the finance committee on the mecca program your voices have been heard on both Mecca and park tonight and I certainly appreciate your cooperation and your civility with your presentations uh I thank you and at this time we will adjourn the meeting thank you toj yep I I keep forgetting these little procedures I make

112a motion that we adjourn do I have a second second meting okay our next board meeting will be tomorrow night okay but that is a meeting strictly for the superintendent search process it will not be open to the public thank you could you second that

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.