001can you get I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liy and justice for all Mr Gorski a roll call vote a roll call please certainly miss armeno here Mr Braverman Mr Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs colano Mr noin here Mr poy here Mr proso here Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening read this in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted January 16th 2015 at all schools home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the
002municipality thank you Mr Gorski and uh this evening we're privileged to have uh Gwen Thorton of the New Jersey school boards Association she is the field representative uh for Middle sex County as well as several other counties and uh we're going to have a code of ethics presentation led by Gwen well good evening and thank you it's a pleasure to be back Happy New Year to all of you I haven't seen you since 2014 sounds like a long time ago right um also with me this evening over to my left is Jesse Adams Jesse is the latest addition to New Jersey school board's Field Services Department um he will be serving Burlington Mercer and half of hunterton um but he came along with me this evening because I told him what a lovely group you
003were and that it would be a wonderful opportunity to meet all of you as he gets to know board members all across the state so here's he's here with us as well um my intent this evening is to really talk about school ethics and I have a very hard time standing here still um the code of ethics is something that I've always been very proud of in my years as a board of education member um going back to way back when and we won't talk what year um the code of ethics was actually promis delated by board members at a delegate assembly and it was became part of our policy as an association for boards to adopt later on it was enacted into statute by uh the assembly and the the senate in New Jersey
004but you are the largest group of public officials who subscribe to a code of ethics and I say this all the time and I know that I'm on tape so I'll probably be in trouble for saying this but I keep wait waiting for some of our leg legislative Brethren to agree to live by a code of ethics but I'm not holding my breath um the School Code of Ethics really does lay out for board members um an expectation on behalf of your public that you will operate within the best interest of all children within your school district um and that you will make sure that your conduct um ensures and engenders both public trust that you are in fact acting on behalf of all children and a 100 years ago when I taught High School
005um I thought the SEC was the Securities Exchange Commission and then I became a board member in the state of New Jersey and I quickly found out that the SEC stood for the school ethics commission and the school ethics commission is the body responsible for hearing ethics um complaints as well as for adjudicating those complaints board members um are unique in the sense that any member of the public anyone in a district can file an Ethics charge against a board member and when that happens it goes before the school ethics commission um the ethics commission is composed of um and this is all in your PowerPoint so that you have it in front of you even though it's not up right now nine members they're appointed for threeyear terms um two are school board members
006to are School administrators and the remaining five are non-school officials but you can have no more than five from the same political party on the entire commission to ensure that in fact it is a um impartial nonpartisan group of individuals some of you may have seen in your email since and most of you who are uh experienced board members are used to it you have seen the request for your financial disclosure forms they are now all filled out online um we've joined the 21st in that regard thank goodness um you are asked to fill that out and submit it it is part of the school ethics law you must disclose where the majority of your income is derived from and that gets submitted electronically to the state it is a public document and any member
007of the public can go online you don't have to open it you can go online and see click on a board community and look at board members and pull that up um we at New Jersey school boards the professional staff are also considered school board members and school officials as a result I file a financial disclosure form the same way all of you did um will be doing if you haven't done it in the past or you have done so I've been doing it for close to 20 years now I routinely fill out that form I also have to agree to um the code of ethics in the same way that all of you do as well um so we are held to that very same standard that all of you are held to as
008board members and I think that it's important for you to understand that um failure to file a financial disclosure form by uh the timeline that's outlined in the email you received will and can result and you're being removed from your board of education um typically the SEC will determine who has not filed their appropriate Financial disclosure forms and in the past and continuing forward um they have removed board members who have failed to file those documents generally they will suspend you initially until such time as you fill it out they will give you a timeline if you fail to fill it out in that timeline you will be permanently removed from your board of education so the SEC has jurisdiction um over any complaint that is filed against a board member around the code of
009ethics the SEC will not take up any complaint if the complaint in includes either a civil or a criminal action that is pending on the same issue so for example and none of these these are all actual examples I know this is hard to believe but a board member at one point took a swing at a coach um at a game because his son did not get sufficient playing time um there was a criminal complaint filed against the board member understandably for assault and battery um there was a civil case against the board member m a suit from the board from the individual staff coach member to the board member and there was an Ethics complaint that was filed until both the criminal and the civil action were resolved the SEC will not hear a
010case it will only hear a case in their jurisdiction so if there are multiple um issues either civil or criminal in relationship to a complaint filed the SEC will not um do anything until such time as those other issues have been resolved at the criminal level and on a civil basis as well um another interesting piece to the SEC and this is something I like especially new board members to be aware of if on a prospective basis there is something that is coming before the board that you think might present a conflict of interest for you to participate in and you have a question about whether you should participate in a discussion on a particular issue you can request an advisory opinion the SEC meets once a month and when they do that they look
011at all requests from board members for advisory um positions so if there's something popping up um let's say you have a family member that is a member of the same uh Teachers Association as the Teachers Association the tenure district and you would like to vote on the contract you already have a memorandum of agreement you're not sure whether that's a conflict and if we didn't have information which we do and I can tell you what the answer is but if that were the circumstance and there was no case law or advisory opinions on that issue you could write to them ahead of taking that vote to get a determination as to whether you should or should not participate the answer to that is you are allowed to participate if indeed you have a memorandum of
012agreement and additionally all of the salary guides are completed as well then you would be eligible to vote sometimes it is not a matter of law but a matter of public perception with ethics and so my recommendation to my boards is always to air on the side of caution if you think that there is a public perception that you have a conflict around a particular issue often times the board is better served if you recuse yourself from participating because it's not just the actual law around conflict it's the public perception so you need to be just cautious around that as well um about 80% of all complaints that come before the SEC end up being dismissed as not having sufficient Merit or cause to move forward um and they don't move forward the SEC has
013the opportunity to ad if they find a judge that someone has violated the code of ethics the SEC retains the authority to determine the punishment so they will recommend one of the following a reprimand a censure a suspension or a removal and it is the SEC that recommends to the commissioner and then the commissioner um either agrees or disagrees with that and then moves it forward to you the board member um so you need to be aware of that boards can only discipline each other as board members as a full board on issues that are not the Parview of the of the SEC so you can't censure a board member you can't reprimand a board member you can't suspend or remove a board member except in extraordinary cases for good cause but we'll talk about
014that um in a little bit questions that you may have around the secc um again you know roughly 80% of the complaints do not scrutiny um if someone files a complaint against a board member the requirement is that they file it with the they have to sign it so that it's visible as to who did it um it is main kept confidential they also have to have it notorized um the notorized is to really get people I believe to think about um not filing a frivolous complaint if you have to get it notorized think about it you're less likely to file a frivolous complaint if someone does file a frivolous complaint against a board member the SEC has the authority and they have used it to find the filer of the frivolous complaint up to
015$500 and they have done that and finded people they do have that Authority under the law um to and it's a protection for board members against people filing um a frivolous complaint against a board member okay in terms of conflict of interest um there are two different sets of definitions there is the definition that goes with the ethics law and there's a broader definition of um relatives that is operative under the nepotism law the definition of relative under the nepotism policies that you all have to have in place is much broader than the definition of relative under the school ethics act so under the school ethics act a member of your immediate family is only your spouse or dependent child of a school official residing in the same household um a relative is a spouse
016natural or adopted child parent or sibling of a school official so for example your superintendent is forbidden by law for to recommend any relative of a board member for employment in your school district um those of you who may have had um family members employed in the district prior to your becoming a board member they are grandfathered but your superintendent cannot recommend now or anyone in his family as a school official um it applies to superintendant as well in that particular sense so you need to keep that in mind so in terms of recusal um you need to make sure as you move forward that you think about um not participating if you have a business interest that you're voting on as a board member if there's a contract pending before the board and you
017are a majority shareholder or an owner of a business um that the district is doing business with you should not participate you cannot use your position to secure privileges for someone else um that particularly is important in the area of personnel and I think it's important to remember that Boards of Education employ one person in their school district you employ the superintendent you hold the superintendent accountable for the performance of all other employees the Board of Education can only hire someone with the affirmative recommendation of the superintendent which means that the superintendent is responsible for all Personnel for those recommendations for doing all of the administration required for employment of employees in your school district and that's something that you really need to keep in mind that's one of those areas that can be problematic
018but essentially what that means is that board members are not involved in the day-to-day operations of your District in any area but especially in the area um of personnel because it could be perceived or real that you are trying to secure privileges for someone who you are either friendly with or know in some fashion um anytime you have any Financial involvement in anything that comes before the board um you need to make sure that you recuse yourself um you cannot accept any gift or favor that is offered to you with the intent to influence your decision so that if a particular vendor were to provide to the board expensive gift at holidays time you need to not accept those um it sometime it doesn't happen very much anymore because vendors are aware of that um
019if it did um my recommendation is to collect them and give them to the charity of your um you know find a food bank find someone in town uh a worthwhile charity and donate it because you do not want to have that um happen um so you just need to be mindful of both public percep ction but also what the law is again always there on the side of caution recuse yourself if there's any possibility um that you could perceive it to be difficult Andor you can check with your board attorney and if need be you can also seek an advisory opinion okay the SEC will issue advisory opinions to you the board member when you request it but sometimes an advisory opinion has such widespread impact on all boards across the state that they
020will make advisory opinions public after removing any identifiers but it will then be able to provide advice to board members all across the state so in terms of evaluating and hiring the chief School administrator we have a lot of advisory opinions and a lot of case law in this particular area um and so um they have expanded the exclusions the SEC over the time I have been doing this work um board members that had family members employed in the school district used to be excluded from participating in the CSA evaluation or in a search for CSA if their family member was in the line of supervision but if you had a family member who worked you know at an elementary school let's say and reported to the elementary school principal you wouldn't have been excluded
021but they have expanded that now so that anyone who has a family member employed in the district on a full-time basis is completely conflicted out of participating in either superintendent search evaluating the superintendent um negotiating the terms and conditions of employment of the superintendent's contract you are not part allowed to participate and they are continuing to expand those limitations around board members with family members employed full-time in the district so that's one of those areas where we got a lot of advisory opinions they're actually included in the njsba folder that I gave you there's a lot of background information on the left hand side of that packet there are lots and lots of advisory opinions around those particular pieces because they're fairly recent and so that packet is provided to you at um information that
022you can read at your leisure it's just background and information um so you just need to be aware of it in terms of the nepotism policy and this is the sort of broader piece um you're required obviously to have this um I will point I would point out to to you that the nepotism policy goes to ethics and conflict of interest um all of the Abbot excuse me all of the Abbot districts see I'm not good at standing here and not moving all of the Abbot districts actually had this in place long before it was a requirement in law for all school districts um and so what this says is that you may not hire a relative of a board member or your Chief School administrator um your CSA cannot recommend any of his family
023to you um and a district administrator might not exert exercise authority over the relative of an administrator as well now there are exceptions to that rule um but again those are typically people who are grandfather Ed and have been in a district a very long period of time in a particular position so for example if you have a family member employed in the district and they want to apply for um another position um you'd have to get that approved by your executive County Superintendent say if someone wanted to move from teacher to vice principal and they were related to a board member in order to be able to promote them you would have to provide a rationale that they are the best available person for that position and get it approved by your executive county
024superintendent so you're not forestalled from promoting someone who's related to a board member in the district but they have put checks and balances in place to ensure that there is nothing that is not above board and I think it's very helpful for you to understand um their premise and that is they want to be able to engender from the public a level of trust that Boards of Education are ensuring that everything they do is both transparent and in the best interest of children as opposed to being in an individual members of the board's best interest okay and the definition under nepotism as you can see is much broader than the definition under the ethics law because now we've included civil unions domestic Partners stepparents son and daughter-in-laws um half Brothers half sisters aunts uncles nieces
025nephews um and whether related to the individual or spouse by Blood marriage or adoption so this is a much broader definition I believe that at some point the legislature will attempt to align the definition between um the nepotism law requirement and the ethics also notice under this definition it no longer requires the child to be dependent which means if you have an adult child who is not a dependent okay under the nepotism policy you can't employ them even though you're not gaining any Financial benefit from their employment even if they are um not a dependent child okay so I think that that's noteworthy Steve did you have a question no oh okay um in terms of collective bargaining here's another piece um that often picks up um and people have questions so if you're a
026relative of a board member um in the same IND District bargaining unit you as a board member may not be on the negotiations team you may not discuss negotiations you may not set parameters for um you know negotiating that contract you cannot participate in any way um if it's the same Statewide Union as in njaa because most teachers in New Jersey are in a njaa and not AF okay um then you may not participate in negotiations or discussions until there is a memorandum of agreement including all of the salary guides and then you may participate in approving that contract or in voting no I mean obviously that's your choice but you may want to consider whether someone would perceive that to be a conflict one way or the other um but you are legally allowed
027to do it so um in terms of the code of Ethics itself um You probably have already seen this um in your packet on the right hand side of your packet later on you will see an acknowledgement of the receipt of the code of ethics and you can sign that and turn that into your business administrator before you leave under New Jersey qac New Jersey quality single accountability Continuum um having an annual ethics discussion became a requirement when I sat on my board of education we re used to read this is terrible to admit but it's true and it was the practice all across the state we would read the code of ethics into the minutes at our reorganization meeting we post it on the wall and we were done um you now as a
028board are required to have annual training and that's really what this is about tonight and I certainly do commend you for doing it um so close to reorganization because I think it's important to have a shared knowledge and understanding of what the expectations are um and once you sign that acknowledgement I will tell you that this School ethics commission will not Brook the argument that oh I didn't know it was a violation that's not an excuse It's like we have kids that would say that to their teachers too I I didn't know I couldn't open my book during the test um that's not an acceptable excuse so um they have an expectation that you will all be aware of what these are um and make sure um that you are familiar with them and really
029the first one pertains to you is public officials this is really a requirement for all public officials at the state and National level um and that is you are responsible for upholding all of the laws and statutes and regulations um of the State Board of Education the state of New Jersey and the United States so that that doesn't mean we only have to obey the laws we like it means we have to make sure that we as a district are compliant with all of those um so you certainly don't want to be seen asking anyone to bend the rules um because that really does compromise the board and the credibility of the board um so very often sometimes when board members might think well it's just a little thing to do whatever it is um
030it's not a little thing it compromises the Integrity of the board and at the end of the day what you have is your individual integrity and your Collective Integrity as a board of education the next piece talks about making decisions in terms of the educational welfare of all children and I think it's really easy to talk about this one um you can't base your decisions on what's good for your child um sometimes you may have to make decisions that may not benefit your child and in fact you might perceive does not benefit your child but your obligation is to all of the children of Monroe Township not just the band parents not just the ice hockey team or the football team or the magical singers or whatever group you know that you may have a
031fondness for or you may have a child in it means for all children um you know special interest groups can come up and and talk to the board and Lobby the board on behalf of their position um teachers have um a process for getting their concerns before the board even if it's in um a grievance there's a process in place same thing is true for administrators the only only people without a voice in the educational process is who the kids so you have been elected by your community to really be the children's representatives to do what is in the best interest of all children not not the people you know who who don't want their taxes raised although you certainly can listen to them and everybody has a point and has input but you need
032to make decisions in the best interest of all children while being being fiscally responsible so I'm not suggesting that you ignore the will of your community and not balance everybody's ability to pay and support education we need their support but what I am suggesting to you is that it is a balance and you are here to be the voice and the conscious conscience of the children okay and to do what's best for them as you make your decisions while being accountable and responsible to your community at the same time time so I thought it would be sort of fun to give you some hypotheticals um here's one for you what do you think the Personnel Committee in response to complaints from the parents um sends the elementary principal negative evaluation of of a third grade
033teacher along with a note saying they have grave concerns is that ethical Behavior no board members are not here to run the district you are here to see the the district is well-run what would you do in this circumstance if you had a concern or you heard from parents about a particular staff member um that maybe gave you some concern as a board member what would be the appropriate approach what would you do yes speak with the superintendent you would contact the superintendent you would go to the one person that you employ and make him aware it does two things it puts the responsibility in the onus for addressing it appropriately where it belongs number one and number number two it it validates the fact that you were not here to administer the district okay
034um and it goes to the first rule of good board governance which is no surprises you don't surprise the superintendent and the superintendent doesn't surprise the board so if you hear that there's a concern out there in the community um that's bubbling up your first call should be to your superintendent to make him or her aware so that you don't get to a board meeting and there are a 100 people here with an issue that he or she knows nothing about so it really does serve a dual purpose um and that really is the very first rule of effective board governance no surprises for anybody um and you'll ensure that you remain compliant with the code of ethics okay the next one um is confining your board action to policymaking planning and appraisal and that
035you will frame policies and plans only after the board has consulted those who would be affected by them um your one of your major roles is to develop policy your policy provides a framework for the decision making in the school district your policy manual should be your best friend in the sense that there are it provides guidelines to your community to your staff to you the board about how you operate what are the expect ations what does your curriculum look like what does budget development look like in every area of board governance and operations you have policy so when you have a question or a decision to make your first question should be what does our policy say what does our policy say about how we handle a particular issue um and that really does
036help you to become more focused as a board if you look towards your policy manual for guidance you may find that your policy is silent on an issue if that's the case then your policy committee needs to think about perhaps creating a policy or like many boards you may go to your policy manual and find out that that policy hasn't been looked at since 1993 and it's out of I'm kidding of course but but it could be old and no longer being followed so in which case you'd want to revise your policy to reflect current practice again it goes to your major role as a policymaking body um planning you really are here to translate the vision of your community into reality in terms of your goals for the school district that's one of your
037major responsibilities so planning working with your Administration about translating your vision as a board of education reflecting your community members into actual goals that then can be worked on and moving the move the district forward is a huge piece to what you are responsible for for um appraisal that's oversight you make sure that you're reviewing on a monthly basis your financial reports for example making sure that everything is in order you evaluate you appraise the performance of your superintendent you hold him or her accountable again for the everyone's performance in the district and if you have a concern that's where you can articulate that and address it appropriately the next one is making sure that you carry out your responsibilities to see that the schools are well run um your responsibility is to work as
038a board but it is not the day-to-day running of the district you should not be in the buildings you know looking for um cracked ceiling tiles or monitoring how many teachers are leaving or sitting in the parking lot to see when the staff comes and goes um that's not your job and believe me there are board members who have done those kinds of things that's not what you're here for um it's not appropriate and and in fact it opens you to um possible issues so here yes I'm sorry if I could just interrupt for a second uh this is a a what if okay uh what if a board member uh because they have a child in one of the schools a board member uh enters a school and uh I'm going to give you
039two uh in walking into the school let's say they find uh a dangerous surface condition maybe there's a pothole maybe there's a lifted sidewalk where they're concerned that somebody might trip over over that and fall and potentially well not only the person would be injured uh but the board might be liable you pick up the telephone when you either leave or get home and you call the superintendent but you do not go to the school principal and say or to the the maintenance guy in the dist in the building and say John fix this that's not your job there's a process in place for addressing issues around facilities um and you want to make sure that you're respectful of that so you would contact the superintendent not the not the building principal because you need
040to make sure as a board of education you are observing the chain of command which means again that when you have concerns that you go to the appropriate person and for you as a board member that would be your superintendent and uh back on the uh can I interrupt you for one second sure I I just would like to point out I am not suggesting that as a parent you you do not have an appropriate place in a school building if your child you have a parent teacher conference you have a they sing in the choir they're in the School Musical they're you know running a relay and they're on the track team whatever it is you are certainly always welcome in your child's school at public events um you're welcome at any public event
041anywhere in the district because it is a public event um keep in mind that the day you became elected um the reception from staff of of you changed and it reminds me of Hester prin in The Scarlet Letter um instead of an A on your forehead you have a b and it stands for board member it takes about 20 seconds once you enter a building for the entire staff to know you're in a building and so you need to be particularly circumspect about the kinds of things you are doing in and saying in a particular School building some of you may have friends that are teachers in the district no one is suggesting that you can't be friends with staff members what I am suggesting to you is you can't be discussing School business with
042a staff member they know what the chain of command is if they have a concern around their classroom or they're a building principal around their building they know who they need to talk to and it is not you the board member they need to talk to their supervisor or their next immediate um person responsible for overseeing them so I just wanted to point that out okay and and I do have another question that's cropped up in my mind several times whenever I see it uh and it's probably in a slide or two back it says I will confine my board action to policymaking planning and appraisal and I will help to frame the policies and plans only after the board has consulted those who will be affected by them and it's that last part that
043has always given me a little bit of trouble in my mind so let me give you an example uh let's say that the policy committee is working on uh a policy concerning uh automatic defibrillators okay okay and they want to make sure that all the athletic teams when the coaches go out even for practice that they have these defibrillators okay so that affects those coaches all right now my question is how does the how does the board consult those who will be affected by it they would do that through your athletic director who I am assuming um at the direction of the high school principal and the superintendent has had a discussion around the expectation that they will be trained so that if they have cause to use hopefully they never do um but if
044they need to use that defibrillator they know how to do it that they've been trained and certified um what the district plan is for making sure that everyone who's out there on the field as a coach has one you know and it's readily available um so they would be consulted through the chain of command so that when that policy came to the board it will have already been vetted through those people who are affected by it and it generally takes place through your administrating Administration and the administrative process there are certain kinds of policies that if you were going to adopt them you certainly would want to involve your students for example if you were considering having a uniform policy okay that all students would wear uniforms for example you would probably convene a committee
045of parents and students as a district through your Administration would do that um so that the board could get input or perhaps You' do a survey online in addition or instead of I don't know but that is a way of getting that input from those who are most directly impacted um you know in the D defib um example um that that's for your staff the kids we should just have them for the kids whether they you know think that's great or not I'm sure if they needed them out there it would be great um and I think it's wonderful that we have them now yes um so if a district has and I I'm I'm not familiar with what what Monroe's district is on dress policy okay okay but if a district has a dress
046policy that applies to all students then uh and they're going to change that policy in some way and let's say they make the change and they have not consulted uh students or parents I I think that's an it you know we have a legal department many of you don't know those individuals CU they don't come out periodically um but but my very favorite attorney in our department when I ask a question his typical answer to me is it depends and so my response to you would be it depends if we are talking about making minor changes to the dress code policy I'm not so sure that you have to do it in a formal way if you are making a significant change to that policy then I would certainly recommend it and let me give
047you an example several years ago um a a district actually in Burlington County decided that um flip-flops or thongs I I don't know what you want to call them for your feet and that's what I'm talking about I better clarify that I just never know anymore um for your feet um really were not safe okay and it was at the high school particularly and at the middle school because kids were tripping because they are I guess from a school perspective potentially a hazard um and so I I I will tell you they changed the policy without based on a safety issue Without Really surveying the student body and so at graduation every senior um wore a pair of flipflops and I went to do goal setting with this board you know late June early July
048and they said well we need to talk about the f word and I went excuse me and they said yes flipflops now I would not have thought that flip-flops would have generated that level of um concern and angst in public input but very often when you make a change and you haven't consulted there was another District um in another one of my districts that decided very late in the game that eighth graders could not wear um sleeveless dresses to the eighth grade dance okay the district had KYW you know Channel 7 Channel 4 um CBS pick a channel they were covered widely they had a new principal who just decided that you know she thought sleeves were more appropriate than some of the strap you know you couldn't wear a strapless dress you had to
049have a dress that had some you know spaghetti straps or some kind of something um it caused to dust up like you just can't imagine in that instance unfortunately it was one of those things where that was a major change people had already bought their dresses girls as you know sometimes start months in advance as the mother of three I can tell you that they can start 6 months ahead of time looking at for the perfect outfit buy it and of course then they had the dress and now they were being told they couldn't wear you you know what I'm saying so I always think that when you're going to make something major that has the potential you're always better served by at least asking for comment ahead of time you may come down and
050exactly the same place you know the board may have ended up in the same place on that policy that said no strapless dresses for eighth grade dance or they may have ch not I don't know I don't think they know but they were never given the opportunity so I think it's always better again air on the side of caution ask for input it takes a little longer but I will tell you I think that both students and parents and community members always appreciate and remember that they were asked they may not like where you come out on something but they will know that you asked you valued them enough to ask for their opinion you listened to it you weighed all the options you went through it carefully and thought about it and made a
051decision because the other way even if it was a thoughtful careful decision uh it won't appear that way to the public so I think it's always behooves you to ask sometimes you don't need to go through all that but any kind of major change it's always good to get public input okay so here are some hypotheticals um a board M visiting schools to check on the technology upgrades no if if the education committee or your curriculum instruction or your technology or facilities committee wanted to go see what those look like and you did it as a board committee with the administratively aison to that committee and the informing your superintendent that could be set up and appropriate but an individual board member should not be wandering around the school checking out technology or anything else
052not appropriate the board's Personnel committee directing the CSA to rotate principles among schools in the district absolutely not um the administration would be recommending what would be educationally sound to the Board of Education not the reverse okay yes sir question there it it says the committee directing okay what if this were changed to the committee uh discussing if the if the committee wanted to discuss they certainly could but here's here's what I will tell you the work of your board committees should be driven by your board goals let's say someone raises rotating principles and the Personnel committee discusses it if a majority of the board committee on the Personnel committee believe that it's really an issue that the Board needs to address they would give a committee report to the full board that says the
053curriculum committee or the the Personnel committee excuse EXC me recommends that we look at rotating principles then the full board would have a discussion if the full board adopted it then the superintendent would begin to look at it your Administration only acts at the direction of the full Board of Education no committee has the authority to bind the board to action no individual member of the board has any more Authority than anyone else in this community except when you are sitting here at this table at a duly advertised meeting of the full board where a majority of the board takes action then your Administration acts other than that you have no more Authority as a board of education member in Monroe than I do and I live several counties away okay um and you have
054to know also I would also say to you that your goals should provide your focus for the year and every request even that the full board makes to an Administration that is not aligned to your goals takes time away from working on those goals so you need to be thoughtful about it so that the work of the district as well as focusing on those goals can continue to make progress just as a a sort of a side um the board directs the CSA to develop a process that engages the staff the community and parents in a strategic planning initiative yes absolutely fine that you know it's the full board the board wants that to happen um and makes that um recommendation and then it would happen there is no difficulty with that that in fact
055recognizes um the full authority of the board okay the next one resting we've just talked about this um that the Board of Education rests with a full board and not making any personal promises that or taking any private actions that would compromise the board of education so you know what this means is that you are respectful of the fact that you are required to protect School Personnel in the proper performance of their duties which means that no matter how much you don't think that the soccer coach knows what he's doing you are not at Liberty as a board member to criticize his coaching practices on the sideline or at a get together of your friends and parents uh you know of the booster club um it means that you will not um cross-examine staff it
056means that anytime um there is a concern that it gets addressed and taken to the superintendent um you just do not want to be seen as though you were taking advantage of the board um yes ma'am Doug may I sure um I'm I'm just curious as to uh participation in the community and I think when we talk about perception sometimes the perception of the public especially if they know a board member they can come and have discussions with the board members uh Express their concerns ask for um ask for your help yeah okay and here's here is um what you need to remember and that is you are here to provide policy planning oversight and Appraisal which means you have no Authority nor any ability to solve their problems okay I get that but but
057that being said that doesn't mean that you should not listen to the concerns of your community members so what you as a board member can do is direct them to the appropriate place where they can get help and a solution to their problem so if your neighbor comes to you and says you can't believe you know my child was not selected for ex and she's gifted and talented or you know your neighbor says to you and of course they always get you in the frozen food section so by the time you're done talking to them you're frozen to death um or you know when your kid is about to score the goal right and you miss it because you're listening to your neighbor um but what you can say to them is look I hear
058you I appreciate your concern but I wanted to to share with you that here are the next steps that you can take if you're concerned about a teacher or a coach you need to talk to the building principal have you talked to the teacher first though would be my first question and if you have and you're not satisfied then you need to talk to the building principal if you're still you know uneasy about the resolution then you would talk to the assistant superintendent in charge of curriculum and instruction or if was a busing issue did you talk to the bus driver maybe it was a one off that they were an hour late um if you're not satisfied with the response of the bus driver then you need to talk to the director of Transportation
059so you can and and say and that's John Smith you can call him at you know 732 I know that he would be delighted to hear your concern and we'll work with you to resolve your issue look board members are good people you're volunteers you're giving up your evenings you're here cuz you care about kids so I know it's natural to want to solve problems I think it's even worse if you're a woman and I don't mean that as a sexist remark but I think as moms I know you can be offended Dennis I think as moms we're used to trying to solve problems for our kids our families it's sort of what we do so I think sometimes it's just that automatic inclination to want to help but the best way that you can
060help is to direct them to the appropriate people you can go so far as to say look if I involve myself with you at this level and it gets to the board because you weren't able to resolve it I won't be able to participate I will have to excuse myself so let me suggest to you here are the people you need to be talking to and and here are their phone numbers here's the best time to reach them whatever kind of information you can convey is the best way to address it you can be empathetic you can indicate that you understand their concern um you can't engage in in staff bashing even if you happen to personally agree with that person you need to keep that to yourself but you can give them the appropriate
061guidance and direction as to where to go to get help to solve that problem and often times people need someone to talk to they just a they want a vent or they need to vent we've all been there and B they they may not know how to access the system you know how to access the system you know where to go what to do and how to do it so share those skills with them so they know where to go what to do and how to do it that's the service you can provide okay this is a hypothetical next question and very quickly if if someone's expressed frustration that they've gone through that process then what happens they've gone all the way through and met with the all the way up through the superintendent I
062mean it's hypothetical so okay if that were the case then they could request to be heard by the board and how was one do that one would write a letter to the board president copy the superintendent requesting it detailing the issues involved um and then it would come to the full board um you would sit with your attorney and your Administration and you would make a decision in that regard okay as to whether you wanted to move forward with that okay thank you you're welcome I mentioned a couple of times that the CSA is the person that the board hires correct is there anybody else in the in the hierarchy that the board should be directly involved with like interviews or any of that type of stuff other than the CSA no anyway very often
063um when there are administrators being hired in a district um principles um directors or supervisors very often a district will have a districtwide committee that participates in that process um there are parents sometimes on those groups um or PTO members as a way of involving the community um the board it's going to come to you as a recommendation um very often when the superintendant is making a recommendation in employing an administrator they will bring them before the board for an introduction and a um I don't want to say a Q&A an interview but a sort of opportunity to have a conversation the board always has the opportunity to vote no on any recommendation of the superintendent including person as long as your decision is not arbitrary or capricious but there is no way that board
064of education members should be involved in any way in the hiring of or interviewing or screening applications for any position um below a superintendent certainly not teachers that's completely inap that's not why you are a board member that is not your role that is the administration of the the day-to-day operation of the district um certainly you have the right to to and should ask for example if you have a Personnel concern um what process was used who was involved okay so that your superintendent can say we had 35 applications for the Elementary media specialist we paper screened those eight people were brought in for initial round of interviews four people were brought back um they were interviewed by the following people the elementary school principal um three teachers you know from third fourth and fifth
065grade whoever was involved and should be able to describe that to you um the board is perfectly it's perfectly appropriate for the board to say um can you share with us why you are making this recommendation what about this individual's background experience and skill set makes him or her the best candidate for the job so that you have a comfort level before you make a decision but those are process questions you are legally entitled to see every resume for every position um that is advertised and that comes in but I will tell you if you are to go in and to read all of those you will be heavily engaged in micromanagement you will actually be and then the issue really isn't about employment it's about trust and that's the difference okay um you're hiring
066and paying a superintendent and an administrative team who do that hiring because typically principles are involved and that's what I mean by administrative team for their expertise for understanding what the needs of their individual buildings are of individual classrooms of individual programs within those you know classrooms um such as ESL or special education you know if it's a particular specialty and so um you really need to believe that they are doing their jobs and you hold the superintendent accountable for the jobs that get done in that okay yes Michelle this is this is really an important issue I think for me anyway um okay so so I I I got two different understandings from you so I I need more clarification certainly um without interviewing anybody the board couldn't sit in on like the last
067two candidates no just listening no no observation or anything now is that statute or is that a recommendation that is a best practice it's a best practice and I do believe if you attempted to do that you would be removed from your board for micromanagement under this under the code of ethics so for example there have been boards for example that have have attended although not participating in exit interviews for people who have chosen to Lo leave the district okay um that was found to be an Ethics violation um so this is is based on extrapolation from case law and E and actual ethics decisions that have been rendered where boards have involved themselves in the area of personnel okay so it seems to me just on a practical level and I I know I'm
068getting myself into Muddy Waters here but it seems to be on a practical level if you are recommended only one candidate at a time how does one know I mean it it seems that really not goes to those process questions that I just articulated so if you have those questions um as a board and then you certainly and you have closed session Personnel it's the exception you certainly can explore those process issues around a particular position and a particular name that's being put forth um prior to a meeting so that um you have your answers ahead of having to vote so that you're comfortable when it comes to a vote whether to vote Yes or No for a recommendation do you know what I'm does that make any sense it it's still confusing I mean
069if if if if we're presented with one candidate and even if we ask question but you said we're entitled we're entitled to see the resumés of all the candidates by law you absolutely are it's case down from Clear viiew Regional absolutely so how about if the board asked to see the last two candidates or the the resumés of the last three that's still but then it's teaching position no no no not a teaching position maybe um prin uh assistant superintendent supervisors principles that's it um you can't hire someone without the recommendation of the superintendent so okay but let's follow your thinking here why I'm saying that so even if your superintendent brings you two people right um and allows you to quote interview both um in addition to micromanagement um at the end of the
070day even if the board says I want candidate a and the superintendent is recommending candidate B without his recommendation you can't hire a so it it so it's superflous additionally hard to believe but there have been instances or perhaps speculation that there were these instances but I if you wanted candidate a and you're the superintendent you bring the person you want and then candidate B who are you going to bring right think about it right right so I so what's the point of the vote when if I may Michelle please so I think this is an opportune time as a matter of fact because this has had has been an issue for this particular board as I came on board as an inter superintendent we've tried to work through this cooperatively and collabor atively and
071it's it's something that's different than past practice and I think obviously that that threw us off as a board and as a as an interim superintendent as well uh the process is and and I guess I'm just asking for your recommendation on this now publicly so they can hear this as far as recommendations for anything below an assistant superintendent and a principal so that would include supervisors department chair people teachers Etc it's my recommendation it is not their involvement in the interview process correct is that correct that's absolutely correct let's go to the next level the next level what has been done unfortunately in the past here in Monroe is that I believe that you know the board has been actively involved in the interview process I believe that that was incorrect and by that
072I mean is the fact that as far as principles and assistant superintendant up to that level up to the point of the superintendent's position I believe is the fact that the superintendent is still making the final recommendation the board is not to be involved in the interview process only to the degree that the superintendent wants the board to be involved in that process is is that correct that is correct ultimately also please the final recommendation is mine the board as a individual board member May certainly they can certainly vote yay or nay that is their prerogative uh can they have access obviously to the teda process I certainly have shared everything as far as the individual processes for hiring the um the task force the Committees the people on those committees the time the applications
073the number of people that applied I've given them everything that obviously I believe that school boards has recommended that I give them as part of best practices is that correct correct that is absolutely correct share the process who was involved last question one I have is that right now is that we have a process that was agreed to by the board is that on the level of let's say assistant superintendent and principal if there were two candidates we would be in Clos session and we agreed is that they would just participate and this is interpretive they would participate just by observing the interview process as I interview the final two candidates I'm uncomfortable with that in other words is the board's participation by observation is that still participating in interview process I guess I'm looking
074for an answer on that one if you're present physically and you're present mentally you are participating whether you ask a question or not because it's going to influence the decision that you come to as a board member I mean I don't think you can divorce them I I think it's particip so let's just go there for a second because I think it's really important for us as a board if we're going to move forward on this is that obviously then even just by observing me interview they're participating and therefore they should not with the exception of at the principal level and assistant superintendent I would absolutely agree with the except so let's just be clear again because I I think I just raised the question with Michelle on the assistant superintendent level and on the
075principal level if the Board of Education in closed session with me if they're observing me are they participating I would say yes but I would say that most superintendents will bring their recommended one candidate one to the board to allow the board to have a conversation with that person prior to appointment okay not an interview but a conversation to meet the person to get a sense of who they are to have a little bit of dialogue led by you so that they get a sense of that individual before they employ them and that is after my own recommend and recommendation this is the candidate I'd like you to introduce I'd like to introduce Mr X or or Miss Z to you here they are correct Jesse did you have now Now's the Time to ask
076some questions I a quick comment yes still sitting on I'm still sitting on a couple of boards right now and I'll be off here in about a couple of weeks but personal experience with this same question in one in one of the two districts I'm on because because the past practice was a lot of board involvement in the interview process and and that was not proper and we worked with the superintendent to develop a process so that we understood what the superintendent and the district's process was for the interviewing panels etc etc and the and that information was was provided to us the superintendent wanted to new superintendent wanted to build some credibility with the board because like I said there were a lot of long-standing board members who this was really raising their dander
077up because it was just the way they did business and it was inappropriate the superintendent for like the first year or so through hires would invite you know would would say would some one board member like to participate in in one of the levels of the interview process and so we had a couple board members who wanted to they were not allowed to ask questions they were only there to observe and they and and after a couple of uh couple of rounds of interviews with several um different candidates they said you know I really don't I don't think we need to this is a good transparent clean process there's a lot of input from the staff and the members on the panel so there was a confidence level that the process was a good process
078um board members were always allowed to you know if there were three three finalists and we wanted to see the resumes we're allowed to see that because you do have to make an informed decision but as Gwen said if you you may look at the three and like candidate two superintendent's recommending one you're voting on one and if the board decides no on one then superintendent goes back and red do has another search two may never show up in the next round so it's still always ultimately the superintendent's decision it's just a matter of are you comfortable with the process is it transparent enough do you think you you know do you feel confident that the superintendent is bringing good strong candidates for your District um and if you do that like I said you
079do have the opportunity to go look at rumes and things but in the end the superintendent is the person making a recommendation and and you know you you don't have a right to be in those in those sessions superintendent can invite you but it's still his responsibility to administer your policy on a fair Equitable meets all the laws Etc hiring process so so we it took about six months for our board to get used to that but in the end there was a confidence level because superintendent made us feel confident that the process was right so Mr seski I just want to let you know Gwen that the the SEC was asked for an advisory opinion on this same subject just recently so keep a lookout in probably next8 weeks for an opinion on it
080I will I I don't think it'll be any different honestly than what we already currently have in place in terms of advisories around this I also have I guess a quick question there you were talking about the board member being involved in day-to-day operations whether it be with the the principal or Administration whatever that one two or three board members should not make recommendations on hiring even outside Personnel like contractors or stuff like that absolutely and you should have a process you should have a process in place for Professional Services which I'm sure you do when those need to be looked at with rfp's request for proposals for Professional Services um if it's a bid process believe me there are gazillion state and federal laws I'm sure Mike could talk about those that you're required
081to comply with for the bid process again to make sure that you have a legally um defensible process for going out to bid on whether it's busing or whatever service or or product that it is um NF rfps um generally that's reviewed by committees it's done you know there's a process in place in your bylaws to accomplish that as well well but that should be that should be done as a board of a whole that what I'm getting at basically board member doesn't have the right a board member whether it be one two three or four have the right to let's say I don't know go to Administration and say listen we want like the way he's cutting the grass we want you to find committees and individual board member committees can recommend to the
082full board individual board members have no authority to you know you can say to someone in the district I think so so and so is wonderful but that's all it is it's a comment no board member has the right to have Administration act no committee has the right to have Administration act they only recommend to the full board yes um you said that you can't vote no if doing so is arbitrary and capricious right so what would allow you to vote no I if you believe that this person did not have the qualifications necessary to fulfill the position that would not be arbitrary or capricious arbitrary or capricious would be I don't like the suit you have on I don't like the way you part your hair some and I'm being a little bit absurd
083here but for some very um non-job related reason you voted no that someone could say you didn't vote for me because you didn't like that I lived in a town or you didn't like that I don't live in your town that's arbitrarily capricious it's not a reason to exclude someone from employment if you felt that someone did not have the skill set to do the job or you felt that there were other individuals out there and you were not satisfied that a thorough screening had be done been done you could vote no that's not arbitrary or capricious uh Gwen I'm just going to uh interrupt here for a minute uh because um I'm I'm looking at the time I know me too and this is being this is being very helpful very beneficial and I'm
084I'm very pleased with the questions that are being asked um I'm just wondering for the closed session how much time would you estimate we will need for that a while like two hours exactly or more okay so then what what I would suggest to the board is that even though this is very informative we might be able to resume this at another time okay uh and so I would like just to show of hands if if you are comfortable with our terminating the current discussion so that we can then go into closed session and we will return to this uh Gwen maybe make a note of where you left off so we can pick back up there but a show of hands who would be in favor of terminating this present discussion okay so so
085it looks as if the rest of you want to continue with this discussion okay uh uh then I would say uh we'll give it another 15 minutes if we're not done in 15 minutes I promise we're going to terminate it yes Anthony would it be out of line if a board member would ask a possibility question to the superintendent like uh if a board member approach the superintendent or called him up and said would it be possible to hold up on a hire or a uh before a before we get to a Personnel committee or finance committee um I think I would contact and that circumstance the chair of the committee as a board member and say I have a concern around a particular appointment on the agenda um would you please explore that with
086your committee and with the board president so that the superintendent would be made aware and because here's the other thing guys you never want to get someone out here sitting here waiting to be appointed and then have the board vote no well no this is a no no I'm just talking in General Anthony so you always want to be mindful of that so you don't want to let the process get to a point where the person is here and his his or her family is here waiting to see that they're being appointed to whatever position and then have the board vote no so if you have a concern around someone again it goes to all items on the agenda not just Personnel if you feel you don't have enough information to make a decision around
087awarding a bid for construction or you feel you don't have enough information then you when you read your packet your information that comes to you whether it's in hard copy or electronically I say packet because I was a board member before Electronics um but if it comes to you electronically you have a a question about it your responsibility as a board members to do your homework ahead of time call the chair of the committee ask why suppose you are the chair of the committee and then you need to contact the board president and the superintendent and say I have a concern about this here's why I've heard from some of my board members or board members have called they want to know why we're choosing this vendor or whatever the issue is so that something
088doesn't move forward and become a surprise to anyone because you never want a potential appointee to be sitting here and then have the board vote no because it m it it makes you appear less than professional it's embarrassing for the individual sitting there and it's embarrassing to you as a board so you never want to find yourself in Personnel in that circumstance okay right would any would any of those scenarios we just brought up recently the past five or six of them be ethics violations or close to it well I I I don't remember P scenario like Mr proso brought up like Michelle was talking about before like I mentioned those are like kind of borderline if not ethics violations yes they are thank you speaking to the superintendent would be no no no no
089no no no not not your example if you have a cons if you called up and you directed the superintendent to remove an item from the agenda okay no no that I think that's what Rob meant if you have a concern and you're the chair of the committee you can share that with the board president and the superintendent to say I have a concern about this I wanted to make you aware you're not directing Administration to act you're conveying information that's not an Ethics violation directing them to take something off the agenda as an individual board member could potentially be a violation question on that real quick yes just to be clear I'm trying okay I want to make sure that the right thing should be done should that board member be talking to the
090superintendent about an agenda item being removed or to the board president since it's the board president's meeting well in in most circumstances it it you need to notify both sorry you need to notify both okay because nobody should be out of the loop if the board president God forbid something happens and he doesn't get to talk to the superintendent and you get to a board meeting then you've submarined the the superintendent not on purpose okay and vice versa do you know what I'm saying both is good I'm good with both okay yes okay I have a question um first of all I I certainly understand everything that that we're saying uh but something you said really struck my my curiosity so I don't know if it's a good idea if it's ethical one um during
091these searches you said something about um an informal kind of a not a committee not because it's not for interview but just an informal setting there like a meet and greet type things that's acceptable it is and you can invite whom to these kinds of meet and greets just the Board of Education just the Board of Education okay close session close session so it's not necessarily interview situ just an opportunity to meet them on a informal basis correct okay um in a principal situation does a school uh do that with parents or something invite a PTA members or PTO members it depends on what you're um interviewing for well it depends on who's involved in the process what the process is that you've used in your District um very often on principal ships there is
092a committee that includes either PTA members or PTO members parents staff members um it does supervisors directors you know a wide swath uh of people across the Spectrum so that they have an opportunity to be part of that process and and Gwen if I may as well St would answer your question is that uh these and you I'm sure that you Doug and and others as far as you know previous administrators in education have been experienc have experienced this is that these task force or committees these search commit Etc um ultimate is that it's a unanimous um recommendation one that's coming up to my level and obviously I put a lot of a lot of credence and obviously in that recommendation as we go through the interview process of the number of those candidates that
093are interviewed by that task force after the fact just to answer your question as well too is that um after that person is approved on by the board of education then obviously there's probably that time for the meet and greet with the entire School Community thank after that approval and and I would certainly recommend that so that the new person gets to come in and meet all the parents all the staff everyone um ahead of their really sort of taking the job after appointment I'm GL because I think it's a good idea for the school Community to obviously have a meet and greet with absolutely oh absolutely person absolutely and and before we just drift off of this is everybody clear as far as so can I ask by a raise of hands if I
094may and maybe I need to add respect to you then go ahead is just is everybody clear as far as the next level because we do have a principal's task uh task force search committee coming up now we all understand as far as your role as a board of education is that even as far as in that closed session room now it is not there to observe me interviewing are we clear with that I'm not just just curious we can actually go in and we can actually watch we can talk to the the candidate that he's going to eventually recommend that night correct at the meet and greet that he would bring in for the recommendation in in an executive session yes of the full board correct but not during the interview process okay so
095time so it it would it would bring to an end the process where I'm bringing in two candidates on the principal and assistant superintendent level to interview them in front of the uh the board in close session that would bring an into to that process but it would be is the fact that obviously as I come to you with the recommendation for that person that we're going into close session and saying hi this is either Mrs X or Dr X or whatever it may be you know and these are the qualifications i' just like to introduce you so this way obviously you can you can see who I'm recommending that that's perfect that's that's the right way to do it um that's all we strive for is the right way my concern is this something
096that should be in our policy because obviously um we get a lot of this is how we've always done it well just because you've always done it that way doesn't mean it's right so my concern is um obviously this is a huge fuxa for this board needless to say and my concern is should this be something that should be in our policy I think you may want to look at your policy around Personnel your bylaws in that regard look at them review them um again this is not meant as an advertisement but we have sample policies not only from our perspective that we do as model policies but we also have samples from districts all across the state that you know our policy people can share with you as a full board your policy committee
097so that you're not Reinventing the wheel um and so that you can see that it's not just what Gwen said or what Jesse said um but that it is the best practice um for districts to to undertake and certainly that's something that I would recommend if that's a policy that you think perhaps needs revision that you might want to be looking at moving forward to make sure again you know often times in districts things evolve over a period of time depending upon the Personnel dep depending on the climate and the circumstance but that doesn't make them either right or wrong so I I wouldn't Tom be so um so um critical of the board to say that it's a serious FAA I think I can tell you from my experience over the past 20 years
09810 as a board member and going on 13 with the association that very often these things evolve and change it's not because anyone's set down to do something wrong it's that practice and people change and so it sort of evolves and gets away perhaps from best practice but that's one of the wonderful pieces about having nine different board members is that there's Collective wisdom that comes out of the sharing of all of or 10 out of all of the sharing of your different perspectives and viewpoints and having discussions like this and and training so that you do hear you know what other districts are doing what is best practice what should we be doing what shouldn't we be doing and the SEC you know sends out regular monthly um you know all their decisions are
099up there so that you can read those for advice as well um and you know sometimes board attorneys Chang so their perspective might shift just to hair based on their perspective do you know what I'm saying so I don't think it was anyone sit down to do or set out to create something that wasn't a good thing I think just depending upon personnel and times things Morphin change and so every new board year is an opportunity to sort of bring that back to Center and say okay what does best practice looks like what should we be doing and I think this discussion has helped refocus you around that issue and that need to do that to make sure you it really has for this board to come together and and to go forward this is
100important and it's important you know just let you know it's not important because of me I won't be here but it will be important for the next superintendent as you interview them for them to find out what the process will be as far as you know hiring and firing for them it'll be very very important relative to to this current topic that we're discussing I would like to remind the board that uh because of the confusion and the questions that we had back uh last year uh the board did consult uh their current attorney and the attorney did say that it would be okay to do the process that Mr ventrillo was describing where members of the board could be present during the interview but they were not to ask questions or make any comments
101so we did have a a board attorney's blessing to do that but as you say attorneys change and thinking even changes and I just this week discussed with Mr ventrillo uh my thinking that we need to revisit the policy on interviewing particularly interviewing at the superintendent level and possibly incorporate in that policy uh more specific statements about who is who is not involved in the process uh just because of of of the thing that we're going to be doing tonight issues come to our mind that we didn't think about previously um and the SEC continues to change and and those people conflicted in conflicted out evolves over time right so it's much broader now than when I was a board member the exclusions are wider than when I was a board member so that evolves
102you know as well to that point I agree okay we have five more minutes and then we have to go to uh we have to offer a public session okay okay all right we're going to move forward um refusing to surrender your independent judgment to special interest groups again we've already sort of talked about this that you as a board member are responsible for all of the children not a particular special um interest group and then we have some more hypotheticals I'm going to to skip the hypotheticals because I really do want us to get to the end of the code at least here um holding confidential all matters pertaining to school districts if I asked you what part of the code is most often violated this one would be the one that is most
103often violated that the SEC spends most of its time discussing okay and that is the need for confidentiality excuse me that means you cannot discuss confidential matters with your spouse your children or anyone else okay it really does mean you can't go home and say to your wife you just can't believe this wait till I tell you you can't do that or your husband or your child please um you know sometimes board members are talking to other board members on the telephone and you don't really realize who's listening to your conversation uh especially with the Advent of cell phones um please be mindful of that that even if you're discussing a closed session item with a fellow board member um please be mindful of where you are and what you're saying and who might be
104listening okay um this can in fact information that is confidential that becomes public either in the area of personnel or particularly in the area of students where it's either a discussion of a special need or discipline or whatever can really open the district to liability to really significant issues you just need to be mindful of that um and yes is there anything confidential between board members any information that's disuss discussed in closed session that board members discussed remains confidential I'm not sure I understand your question let say board member says that the superintendent's mentioned this to them and they said don't tell anybody okay um is there any expected or implied confidentiality between board members no okay I didn't think so but but that being said you know here's here's what best practice looks like
105and that is if the superintendent is conveying information to one board member it should be conveyed to all board members at the same time period okay so quen this is purely hypothetical by the way thank you for clarifying that about what about a superintendent's weekly confidential that's clearly disclosed as confidential um containing some deliberative information oh that's absolutely confidential that they receive because they're in the capacity of board member that's confidential clear that that's all confidential that is absolutely confidential I thought you just me that's not my question my question was among board members right I understand that so so if there's information that is not confidential okay clearly not confidential and a board member says to another board member well the superintendent told me X Y and Z and it's not confidential um what
106I would say to you is it's not confidential there's no expectation of confidentiality but I will tell you that that's a way of fostering issues on a board so your superintendent I know and most superintendents routinely if they're conveying information to one board member that's not confidential and if it even if it is confidential it gets shared the same way it's just remains confidential but a non-confidential item should be shared with the full board at the same time so let's say there's a fender bender tomorrow morning we're going to have snow okay and there's a fender bender but everybody gets to school and everybody's is okay the superintendent is going to send you an email that says bus 3 had a fender bender everybody's okay in school we're good to go that should go to
107all board members at the same time so that no matter what you all have that same information it's not confidential but if the superintendent just called one board member and the rest of you didn't know it and you were out in the community and someone says oh my God because you know rumor control by now the bus has been total you who knows you don't want to be in that place so information that is shared should be shared with all board members at the same time confidential information cannot be discussed Beyond board members and no board member should have confidential information that the full board doesn't have it's the same with that does that help clarify but all confidential information needs absolutely to remain confidential until the need for confidentiality no longer exists and you
108are not the people to make that determination that's your board attorney who makes that determination who and there are some items that will remain confidential forever student issues okay because students have the right to expect confidential that will never become public a student name in conjunction with anything Personnel that will never be made public because they too have rights um to confidentiality around their employment so some things will never but if for example you were negotiating in private for the purchase of land which might be confidential during the negot negotiations or you're negotiating a teacher contract that's confidential until you sign the memorandum of agreement then that need for confidentiality no longer exists because you either buy the land or you don't buy the land you settle the contract or you don't settle the contract
109so once the need for confidentiality no longer exists it goes away okay and it's public then it can be discussed freely okay okay thank you so much Gwen we uh we're at 7:30 so I'm going to close the current discussion and uh we will uh ask you uh we'll arrange for you to come back I'd be delighted and continue the discussion with us at a future date AB at this time uh the board will hear any public comments or questions relative to the agenda only there will only be one public session tonight because we'll be going into closed session and there will be no business taken up after that any questions from the public okay I see that we have no questions from the public public uh we will be moving to close session uh
110uh prior to doing that though I do want to explain something uh based on our board's attorney advice and I I did inform the board members of this but I want to remind you again uh Mr Gorski our business administrator Mr vent trillo the interim superintendent and Dr alvic our assistant superintendent they will not be participating in any aspect of our superintendent search that includes the work that we'll be doing tonight uh any of the interviews that we'll be doing in the future nor will they be participating in any uh site visits to uh the schools of those finalists that we select they will have no involvement whatsoever in the selection of the next superintendent uh I think we do lose something by not having their participation in that because they have a lot of
111knowledge and expertise that uh members of the board do not possess but never less our board attorney did look at this this is her advice and uh I strongly believe that we are to follow the advice of our attorney so I just wanted all board members to realize that once we go into Clos session uh and do our work in the future uh these three uh administrators will not be present for that I have a question yes once we get down to whether it be two or three finalists they are at that point I say most of the time by most districts invited to do a site search as you put it who will be taking them on that walk through the district at the end you're talking about the finalist that visiting here or
112our visiting there no our finalist that we have here normally districts invite them to come look at the school dist you are one of two people one of three people it's a proper courtesy to extend to those future superintendents to come in and look at the facilities look at the building so now when they go to that last interview process when we ask them questions they in turn ask us questions who is going to take them around if Mr gorsky being the our board secretary keeping him away from the business administrator he's our board secretary who will then take these superintendent or prospective candidate around the district to show okay it's a good question and I don't have the answer to it presently because that question that specific question hasn't Arisen but we certainly have
113adequate time to find uh get legal counsel on that and we will certainly do that a quick question yes before Gwen leaves because I think she's a great resource she I know you're going to be in there but I won't be um excluding um Monroe percentage wise how many of the the districts have the ba and assistant superintendent or whoever sitting in that seat participate in the CSA process excluding Monroe they are involved on the back end not the front end so the district visit that Rob just asked about um is typically an opportunity for the candidate or candidates to get to meet and speak with um your administrative team central office they would spend time in each of these levels elementary middle and high school they would typically meet PC Ed Foundation mover and
114shers you identify um leadership of the association for the teachers leaders of the association for the administrators bargaining unit with central office um and the board would ask for feedback from all of those groups to help inform their final decision making that is typically the process so I think that's a conversation that Doug needs to have perhaps with your board attorney we do have time for that because that's not going to happen in the immediacy um certainly they have wisdom knowledge background and experience as your Educators here around the climate and the culture of Monroe um that no one else has access to you as board members don't because you're not in the buildings running the day-to-day buildings they are they know issues from a different perspective so I think that they are a valuable
115resource um and my recommendation would be for Doug to have that conversation at some point in the not too distant future around whether that would be a possibility I think perhaps we will revisit this a little later down the road I I don't know if that answers your question but yep I'm good okay at this time I'll read read the closed session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 to discuss the following subject superintendent search candidate selection the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists first second do I hear a second Tom
116L second all in favor say I I I all opposed abstentions recuse recusal yes okay so uh let's take about a 5 six minute break uh in case you need to go to the restroom just stretch your legs and then we will go into Clos session at 7:45