CorpusRecord 132948

Monroe Township Board of Education 05.13.15 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-19
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
9,539 words · about 53 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001my father did when he was 85 me one public meeting of the Monroe Township the public meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education Wednesday May 13th will now come to order Mr thorney would you please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance FL flag of un United States of America to the stand indis Justice for All Mr Gorski the roll call please M armeno here Mr Braverman here Mr Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs K Pano here Mr nosin Mr Po here Mr proso Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to to be published by having the

002date time and place thereof posted May 8th 2015 at all schools home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski uh Mr thorney would you please give us your report please uh thank you Mr Po uh the report tonight is going to be fairly brief um the high school's National Honor Society will soon be holding inductions for uh recently aced members for next year additionally uh class officer elections will be taking place uh some banners and signs are also visible throughout the school for that AP testing will be finishing this week I believe the last exams are on Friday um and finally the uh health and physical education department at the high school will be coordinating uh an armed an armed service Appreciation Day the Friday before

003Memorial Day um other clubs and organizations to the high school such as the history Club are getting involved as well um and it's meant uh to honor the veterans and active service Personnel within the community and there will be uh competitive events for those students who have opted to participate and that concludes my student board members report thank you thank you Mr thorney we will now recognize our teacher of the year in educational special Educational Services Professionals of the year uh with the awarding of uh plaqu earlier this evening they were honored at a dinner just prior to this meeting and I believe this presentation will be done by our superintendent Mr vent Trello uh I just want to thank everyone for uh for attending this evening and we just had a wonderful dinner recognizing

004the teachers of the Year for 2015 as well as for the educational services professionals as well for 2015 uh it's always a special time having that dinner to be honest with you because it's it's honoring and recognizing teachers and obviously the district obviously other than students is all about teaching with that said is that I like Mr Po and myself will come up over here by the table and we can have uh we'll call up the individual teachers and Educational Services professionals you can take your uh your families can come up whoever you would like to do this take some nice pictures we'll be there and we'll just get through this all right thank you for your cooperation [Music] Chris [Applause] good [Applause] congratulations Educational Services professional poetry school is Lauren cold flesh [Applause] my

005at the high school we have lorine [Applause] certain [Applause] at Barkley Brook School naren Clifford [Applause] conations you hired a really good phot congratulations AB thank you very much yes good [Applause] Barkley Brook School Kristen Miller teacher the year [Applause] Brookside School Educational Services professional and that's Diane allander [Applause] Diane conratulations [Applause] teacher of the year at Brookside [Applause] school a little different that's not Apple Guard School Educational Services professional and that is [Applause] congratul Apple guard school again a teacher of the year Su vot soon [Applause] h s middle School Mary Howard [Applause] teacher relations to Ben Howard it is or minus know smil congratulations good thank [Applause] you education professional K Pigman for the middle [Applause] school picture [Laughter] holding [Applause] congratulations Woodland School uh we have have Jamie roach for Educational Services

006professional and we also have Lisa Pinsky as teacher of the year congratulations for both of your St thank you got yep got thank [Applause] you from Mil Lake School we have Brent lutka Educational Services [Applause] thank you so much than thank you so much we're take a [Applause] picture for a teacher of the year mil Lake School Jennifer Worth [Applause] educal Services professional mon attentive high school we have Michelle Rockoff I believe that Mr good is u representing Michelle Round of Applause for [Applause] Michelle conratulations big round of applause everybody behalf of the Board of Education and the entire District thank you for all that you do for the kids in mon thank you thank due to the time factor I did not get to make any uh personal remarks at the dinner but I

007would like to congratulate all of our teachers and educational Specialists of the year but I also want to thank you for the great work that you are doing you are an inspiration to your colleagues and I hope that you will continue to be that it was very nice to hear you speak of your schools and the families that you experience there in the school among your colleagues and just remember that you were there just as other teachers have been there to console to support and to encourage and we wish you well in the years to come thank [Applause] you teachers and their families if you want to continue staying for the Board of Education you certainly may or you may want to use this time at any given time obviously to leave the meeting at

008this time we have a testing presentation uh which one are we doing Dory we doing the talented and gifted no cluster group and I guess that's Lori McConnell Lori you're up at this Podium already hi my name is Lori McConnell I'm the supervisor of Grants testing and special projects and I'm here to do a brief presentation on um our talented and gifted program in Monro Township I'm sorry I have a little bit of a cold so um so that you know um all according to New Jersey um mandate we are required to have a k to2 gifted and talented program that um um I'm sorry um where we identify processes for gifted and talented students using multiple measures um students are compared to peers within their district and this is a board approved program our

009programs are as follows we in K to one we use differentiated instruction for gifted talented students within the district within the classroom for grades 2 to8 we have an after school program as well as differentiated instruction within the classroom the after school program is by subject area language arts math science and art the classes meet one time per week in grades 9 through 12 we use advanced placement and honors classes by subject area for our gifted and talented program in addition we have a cluster grouping um process for grades this year grade four and next year for grades 3 to five this is for highly gifted students within the regular classroom I will um highlight that later in this presentation so that you know our tag numbers and students of students and teachers we have

010quite a few students that are in our tag program in math 374 teachers 25 for math this would be from grades um 2 through 8 in science we have8 students and 12 teachers in language arts we have 146 students and 18 teachers in art we have 110 students and eight um teachers so I want to take this opportunity to talk a little bit about cluster grouping this is something we piloted in um the 2014 15 school year cluster grouping is a method for providing full-time gifted Education Services um with the potential to raise achievement for all students what happens is gifted students are purposely placed together into a mixed ability classroom um so it's not a homogeneous classroom it is a heterogeneous classroom and these gifted students are based um placed in this classroom based

011on their abilities potential and achievement um the back one so the purpose of cluster grouping is to challenge our very highly gifted students every day all day rather than just like one day a week um it also creates learning and Leadership opportunities not just for the highly gifted students but for all students it empowers our teachers by expanding awareness and providing preparation it also provides ongoing assessment of students strengths and needs and it also provides Extended Learning opportunities for all students for 20145 our pilot year we had four fourth grade classes totaling 22 students in 2015 and 16 um our tenative numbers because we haven't finalized the list yet um we will have actually 16 classes is in grades 3 through 5 and potentially it will involve about 77 students that would be the maximum

012it will go down potentially a little bit from there so ongoing we really um try to collect data to support this program um each and every year some of the things that we do both for identification and to um monitor the success of the gifted talented program is we look at coat test scores we look at teacher gifted rating scales we use parent rating skills um this however is only used for the cluster grouping we look at Dr reading levels we look at mathematics benchmarks um for art tag we look at artistic creativity and we have also looked at parent teacher and student surveys I'm going to leave um a stack on the table where you picked up your agendas um of some of the results of the cluster grouping parent student teacher surveys if

013you would like to pick that up on your way out so regarding the costs tag includes tag meaning the after school program that's what we refer to as tag in this District includes a teacher rate of $16.54 for 1.4 hours per class um in addition to that the teachers receive supplies of materials of $250 per class that varies a little bit some classes get a little bit less um things that use a lot of supplies like art use a little bit more but on average it's about $250 cluster grouping on the other hand is a totally coste effective way to meet the needs of gifted students there really are no additional funds we simply use a teacher who is current teacher within the the classroom um the only additional funds for that um would be

014professional development for these teacher and we cover that through title 2A funding and that's it any questions seeing none thank thank you for your presentation and all the information as far as the other cluster grouping uh program thank you at this time we can go right into the next presentation uh Dr Al I'm gonna stay here but I just have to find the clicker now where did the clicker go that is the question while Dr alage is looking for the clicker I'd like to remind all members of the uh audience to if you have a cell phone with you would you please either turn it off or turn it to vibrate since this meeting is being both video and sound recorded and our equipment is directly uh in the area where our public sits your

015cooperation in this will be appreciated thank you okayy so as one of our requirements of uh qac is reporting out each year on our state testing data so that's what I'm going to be sharing with you this evening so whoops sorry so the first thing that I'm going to um share with you is a comparison of the student cohorts so we followed students over the past three years um the number that you'll see is actually the percentage of students who have scored proficient or advanced and advanced proficient so any student that scored above a 200 on the New Jersey ask so this is a third grade cohort so in 2012 the these those were the third grader scores in blue is the L score in I guess it's kind of a orangey color is the

016math scores so this is the same group of students over three years so in third grade it's the first two columns in fourth grade their New Jersey ass scores in the middle two columns and fifth grade in the last two columns the difficult part of comparing year-to year with our students is they're taking a very different test and I'll be able to share with you um as I go through the presentation you'll be able to see the comparison with the state average and our DFG average so I think that's a better comparison this is a fourth grade cohort so this was in 2012 the students were in grade four in 2013 the students were in grade five and in 2014 the students were in grade six and again the blue is L the the Orange

017is math here's a fifth grade co- Court in fifth grade in 2012 6th grade in 2013 7th grade in 2014 and a sixth grade cohort so it just kind of gives you the comparison again it's difficult to compare from year to year these are the same students but they're not the same tests they're different tests and different standards so a better way I think to compare it is to look at how we compare to the district Factor groups the district Factor groups are other communities that are relative relative to us in our socioeconomic status um we are a f FG FG District Factor group so this is comparing to um other there are 86 other districts in New Jersey that are in the same factor group um again the data is um the percentage of

018students scoring above 200 which would be proficient and advanced proficient so in 2014 on the hespa that's the high school proficiency assessment the in the blue again is Lal in the Orange is math the First Column for each of them is the state average the second column is the average of other DFG districts in in the state of New Jersey and in the third column is how our district compares to them and what you'll notice as we go through this is our district has is always above the state average and the DFG average so this is the high school this this is the 11th grade test that our students took last year this is our third grade comparison so again we're compar comparing our district which is the third column to the state and the

019DFG average and again you can see we're higher in in both areas this is our fourth grade fourth grade there notice there's a third set of columns that's because in fourth grade they also took the New Jersey ask science and they will continue to take the New Jersey ask science even though we took the park this year fourth and eth grade and 11th grade are still taking the New Jersey ask science and again you'll notice that our our district averages are higher than the state and the DFG averages here's our fifth grade students fifth grade takes uh L and math and again the third column is is our district compared to the DFG and the state average here's our sixth grade here's our seventh grade and here's our eighth grade and again eighth grade has

020the third set of columns because they do the science I will post this presentation on the district website so that you can look at the numbers more closely um so basically taking a look at this our um as I've said already the our scores are higher compared to the districts Factor groups the other the other 86 districts in New Jersey in the same district Factor group and the state average we are going to continue to review our curriculum and our assessments we have a five-year plan with that all of our supervisors um and myself work uh worked on that so there's a five-year plan to review our curriculum and continue to um improve our assessments and our benchmark assessments in our classrooms now that we have seen what the new state test is requiring of

021our students we also will be continuing our teacher evaluation model um we are increasing our requirements for teachers to be um effective and highly effective next year um as that was our plan as we rolled out the new teacher evaluation model but it is unclear for next year how the state is going to be comparing the park assessment results with New Jersey ask assessment results um but they are have assured me I spoke with uh Dr Morano the the uh County Executive County Superintendent that they're going to be offering us some templates of how we can present that data uh we do not expect to get the park data into the district until October of next year and then we'll be able to take a look at it as we move forward and that's it

022any questions any questions from the board thank you Dr Al thank you Dr Ali that was very comprehensive um I'm I'm wondering when when we do these assessments does this take into our the use of our technology and things like that or this is just purely the test this is just State testing data it's one of the requirements that we have to do that we have to present this to you and to the public each year with New Jersey qac this is just State testing data tting it's not data or testing or anything okay so it's just comparison with everybody else taking the same test yes okay thank you uh Dr alvich I do have a question even though it didn't seem to be broken down in terms of uh um below proficiency being proficient

023and above proficiency but I know many districts uh they've they have put a concerted effort in moving students from the proficient level to the above proficient level and and could you elaborate it all in terms of what our district is doing in that effort yes that's done it's done at the building level through our school goals committees the school goals committees actually look at all of the data that comes in from the state which is I tried to make it brief for the for for purposes of the presentation but we do get we do get data broken down by um the different groups in the district male female uh different races uh special education general education so we do get that data back at the school level and that's what the school goals committee look

024at look at and then the school goals committee create their school goals and their school sgos based on that so yes there there has been and since Dr Hamilton was here there has been a concerted effort in the schools not only to raise our students to the proficiency level for those students that were below proficiency but also to move more students into that advanced proficient range okay and and what's what special efforts are made with those students that uh are uh not proficient below proficiency on on the test it depends on where the students's needs um if there special education we look at their special education um accommodations modifications teachers work together um at the K to2 level they use uh response to intervention so they're meeting every eight weeks the administrators the teachers the

025reading Specialists and and the basic skills teachers on how they can um Implement different strategies and interventions for students as they move forward at the three to five three to eight level we use MFR which is the managing for results process where principles meet with individual teachers and teams of teachers to look at the data specifically and what strategies they can Implement in the classrooms to help improve that and then the teachers are actually bringing data sample assessments student work to those meetings so that they're really they're really looking specifically what's going on in the classroom and how we can improve that anyone else with questions Mr Kaufman yeah one last thing um it happens every couple of years and sometimes the format changes I think it's beneficial for this board to get a breakdown

026school by school because we have some grades within the standardized testing where we know at certain grade levels it's the middle school of the high school but at the elementary school it'd be very important for us to see how our schools stack up to each other to see if there's areas that need Improvement or or things that are doing great so we can get a better picture of going at the school level okay I can get that for you anyone else questions comments okay then we will move on to item nine uh the board reorganization uh date discussion uh and Mr knin is a he is our uh board delegate to the New Jersey uh State SCH school boards Association uh and he unfortunately he is not here tonight uh he he is a way

027own business uh but I believe that uh one of our members of the board had felt that we should spend a little time discussing this uh so that we could give some direction to Mr noin he has a meeting I believe this Saturday and there will be a vote taken uh Mr noin had mentioned this at a prior board meeting um and I believe you have just received a uh resolution that I will read so that the public can have it and then we will uh have a discussion uh it is recommended that the Board of Education requests that the board's delegate to njsba either support or oppose the resolution of the Lyon wall board of education in Camden County regarding reorganization meetings at the May 16th 2015 delegate assembly of the New Jersey School

028Board Association the board president and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action of the board of education so uh our task tonight is to decide do we want to support uh this resolution of the Lynden wall board of education which I believe is to uh have reorganization meetings occur uh more quickly than they are currently occurring currently uh the board the new board members are elected in November at the general election uh the current board uh remains in place until the end of the calendar year uh and in fact until the first organization meeting and in the past that meeting has been held in early January usually within the first seven days of January uh this lynen wall resolution and it's the only

029item I think that the delegate assembly is voting on the lyen wall resolution is suggesting that uh the reorganization meeting uh occur in December and I would assume it would be early December with the election having been in November uh so uh right now what we need to do is uh discuss this for a bit any comments uh about this and then we need to decide whether we want to support uh the lyen wall resolution or oppose it so that we can uh share that Direction with Mr noin so that he will know uh as our representative to the State Assembly how we would like that to be voted upon anyone have any comments about this Ryback I don't have a comment I think I I'd like to hear um the board members thoughts on

030on what would the advantage be for moving it up you know one month one not I I I think that's where you know the conversation has to be I mean is there an advantage to what advantages might there be and I think the public has to hear that as well for moving it up okay well uh does do it does anyone on the board see that that it would be advantageous to do that because Mr Ryback is asking what are the advantages so I'm not really certain if any of us see that there are any advantages you know where it's at Miss armeno can go first okay Mrs kapovich well not to answer Mr Ryback's question m i don't it wasn't so much question it was just a thought for leading the discuss and I

031and I don't have an answer to that okay but we're being asked to support or oppose a resolution I'd like to see the resolution I we don't know exactly what the whole resolution is so how can I support something if I don't see the resolution when we support something as a board from Monroe we get the whole resolution so I can't support something when I don't know what the resolution is or oppose something okay Miss armeno did you have a comment or statement to make well I just think that the question is and I agree with uh Kathy konitz that we really should know exactly what the language is of the resolution before we actually vote on it but it really seems to me to be the people who are duly elected or their term

032ends on December 31st so technically they have the right to make decisions up until that time I do understand that it's sort of a lame duck issue if new board members replace the the ones that are there and that you would want to do any business and have those people make decisions but perhaps if I I mean I don't know which like I said without the resolution I don't really have a a comment about it specifically but I think I understand that's the purpose um so but you know there's a lot to be said that the new board members going forward should have a the ability to make decisions for the next year but also that the people that were there are duly elected until December 31st so it's a little bit of um I

033think it's a tough decision but I think there's pros and cons on both sides so without the the full full language of the resolution I would agree with Kathy Mr Ryback now that we had some discussion maybe I can bring some thoughts that I have um Kathy I couldn't agree with you more I can't see voting on something that we don't know how it reads and we don't see it but um you know to um tell the board members that uh are duly elected through December 3 first you may call them lame Ducks but are we to say that they don't care anymore that they're less professional than they were when they first started or less motivated I find that insulting I think that um every board member who's elected through December 31st I would

034think has just as much care in them uh and as as when they started and uh certainly a lot more experience uh so I I think that it would could be a real disservice uh to move it up and an insult to sitting board members whose uh election is is up their time is up and on the board Mr Coffman I think I want to Echo what Steve was saying um I think the challenge is really figuring out what what if any you know impact is there into our baau so things are going on in November to January time frame and there could be board members that have been part of a process that is being implemented or have been participating in in committee meetings or what have you for that whole prior year I

035think the challenge really is when a new board member comes in in November and they find out that they've been elected to this job there's an incredible ramp up that occurs from the time they get elected to the time they actually have to sit in the seat over here and some people are very active in the community and they come to board meetings and they're very familiar with what's going on but we do have a lot of folks that you know put their hat in the you know hand in the Hat or whatever hat in the ring or you know throw their bird in some cases throw their white glove into the ring whatever and and and they may find themselves a little bit behind the eightball of having to get up up to speed

036on all the nuances and all the connectivity between all the decisions that we make and how all these different committees are connected to each other and all these different activities we do uh how they interrelate to each other so it's very I think it's very challenging for a new board member when they come on board to really speak with authority on a lot of things that we do in committee having not been in any of the Committees previously so um I think we have to really to your point think about what that resolution is and the reality is if we're talking about December to January what are we talking one meeting it I mean yeah it's a month and calendar time but it's like one meeting I mean if we're talking about doing the reor

037if if if elections happen the second week in November then if we're talking about doing a reorganization meeting right after elections at least that's several more meetings in advance and you can eliminate that link name duck I'm just concerned with folk sometimes it happens where you get elected and now you're in the Limelight you know it's going to be your job and more often than not we'll start seeing people that may have gotten elected now come to board meetings and at least they have a few under their belt to at least get the idea of what's going on but I think any new board member will say just sitting out there is not the same as sitting over here uh so I think we have to you know think about what the pros and cons

038would be you know relative to any baau operations that we have Mike or Dennis if you want to comment CU that November December time frame with budgets and everything else you know I would I would ask if I may just maybe Mike could you just talk about as far as the impact on the budget because as I'm thinking about that Mr yes I I've read the resolution and the Crux of the whole resolution is moving the board's reorganization meeting as Mr Po said from the first week of January to either November or December that would be school board's position then to recommend to the legislators uh for a law change it is unclear if anything will come to fruition even if School Board supports this Movement by uh that school district to move the reorganization

039meeting earlier one of the challenges that we face is that board members are not sworn in until the reorganization meeting and until such time they're not entitled to confidential iial Communications of the board so you know that that ramping up period um is difficult without um admittance to the board because you're not entitled to any of the communications which are lengthy and frequent um so again the resolution does not go into law and how the law would treat the uh some of the anomalies that would occur with the existing board um you in Monroe has bylaws that we have a nine member board and a one member um member from the receiving District so we have 10 members on the board if you had a reorganization meeting earlier and you allowed three new uh board

040members potentially to join you could have as many as 13 board members that would require a bylaw change or it would have to require the um the departure of some of the existing members who were voted in by the community to serve a full term so there's a lot of Cl regarding the law and I've spoken to our board attorney about this and she concurs that it's it's quite muddy legally even if school boards takes the position to support moving the reorganization meeting earlier and and for that reason um not that I have a staken like a board member but a board counsel and I felt that this is a little um a premature and undefined at this time okay thank you Mr Gorski anyone else have a comment um Mr yeah thank you I

041think New Jersey School Board Association doesn't support this resolution is that correct I don't know do we know that I do not know did they take a stand resolution that we wrote um allows the board to go either way I forgot the exact position that they took on it okay okay and it's unfortunate that Tom is not here since he is the representative right is that I don't know what information Tom actually wanted as as he was going to this meeting so maybe that has to be tabled then is maybe that maybe there needs to be no action obviously I can't presume that that's up the board president to the Board of Education Without Tom being here it becomes difficult to know what the intent is well I I I think one of the reasons

042this was put on the agenda um was there was some concern that if the board's delegate to the assembly is going to be voting on something then that delegate needs to have some sense of what the board's wishes are and that makes sense to me personally uh as opposed to we don't give our delegate any kind of Direction uh that would mean that the delegate is free to follow whatever personal beliefs that delegate has and I don't think that's necessarily a healthy thing to do uh I I I am going to put forward a a slightly different motion than what is read here uh because we this was simply a reading of a motion it the motion was not yet made uh I am going to put forward a slightly different resolution that I think

043might be uh a little bit clearer in in terms of what we might want and and that resolution essentially would be that we would direct our our delegate uh not to uh vote in favor of anything that would change our present uh timelines and procedures of reorganization meetings and board elction you know uh just have to get that wording correct Miss Deo you have something could would we put something in there without discussion of the full board I'm sorry like you're saying you're telling the delegate not to change anything that we currently have in place but should we include something in there that says you know we need to have discussions of the full board prior to any voting like oh so you're speaking also of future uh future resolutions that the delegate might be

044voting on okay that's a that's a little bit broader yeah uh and we could we could certainly make such a motion and deal with that tonight U Miss uh armeno but as a point of order this is the resolution that's on the table right so we would have to either vote for this yes or no before we could move on to another resolution I I just want a clarification haven't we hasn't been it's just a discussion and I only read it for so that the the audience would know the public would know what it was that we were discussing okay thank you okay I I didn't make it a motion all right okay okay any yes Mrs kapovich just to to clarify what happens at these meetings I don't know if you've ever been to

045one but they get more information than we're going to get so they will have the discussion and they will have other um administrators there to give them the pros and the cons and being able to vote so this I think they only have one or two meetings a year and and usually they have a whole agenda full of items that you cannot bring back to your board and then ask for um a discussion so that you can vote in the future it it kind of needs to be done at that same time so I I don't know that you're um you didn't make a motion but that that would work for um anything that they bring up so so they don't get the agenda ahead of time and know what they're going to be talking

046about yes that I believe they rob Mr seski you have something to offer use the microphone Rob the delegates assembly gets the agenda approximately three to four weeks ahead of time the Motions go up for this meeting this is May you're asked to give a resolution a board would be asked to give a resolution ution or guidelines to a resolution about 4 months in advance so in the beginning of the year I think the cut off is February then it is written up by attorneys and then presented to the delegates assembly by the individual District who brought the resolution forward and the delegates for each individual School Board is given I got mine probably about a month ago to read so there is time there is time it's a short amount of time and we

047are given information that can be shared if the delegate wishes with the other board members well why don't we have it if you had you might recall at a previous meeting Mr noin did share with us uh the fact that this resolution was going to be voted on and he also said actual resolution and but he also mentioned that it was the only resolution that they were going to be voting on which I thought was a little odd because I know normally it is quite a few even though I've never been a delegate it but just from reading the literature we get from the school boards Association there's usually quite a few resolutions but Mr noin had said that there was only one and he was apprising the board of that fact uh in a

048prior meeting that we had yeah I'm just questioning that I know that was an agenda item and it's going to be discussed but if there is actual content behind this why isn't it here for us to see because they going to vote on it on I'm assuming they're going to vote on it on on the day after tomorrow so I'm assuming if they got it three weeks ago that there was content shipped out a while ago why isn't it here and I'm asking you I know you may not know well well well well uh yes what I am saying is that um I I understand your point and I agree with that point uh we were not asked by Mr noin to necessarily discuss this uh this particular thing I I think it it it

049came in the broader sense that uh should I should the board's delegate to the assembly uh be empowered to uh vote without having any idea as to what the wishes of the board on particular items uh what the wishes of that board are uh and I understand Mr seski it sounds as if maybe some resolutions but I don't know this for a fact do some resolutions get introduced that very day or are they always known in advance the resolutions are known well in advance what happens on that day is they sometimes get slightly too highly modified as far as the words so It ultimately depends on what the resolution is you can go in there with a one paragraph resolution ends up to be voted on it's three four paragraphs long because different Representatives have

050different ideas onto wording situations with the 260 some school districts most of them being represented on that afternoon or that morning things do change yeah we we really have no idea at the end what amendments to the motion will be made what changes to the motion will be made and how it goes from the original motion to the motion that will be finalized and voted upon so I mean it it we really don't know what it's going to be let one more one more thing to throw a fly in the ointment right so we have a motion that we're supposed to support as far as yay or nay correct well it really hasn't been hasn't been read yet in theory it's going to be a yay or nay but the the motion itself has options

051in it it's either oppose or support so that by itself we're either going to support it by voting yay or saying no to it it's ambiguous as well no the way that I think the way that was written and I didn't write this myself but I think the way it's written is that we would choose one of those words okay that's what would be and that would be the motion got you okay okay all right so one more thing I just want you to keep in mind that whatever Goes Forth as a delegate assembly there's many more steps that need to be taken before any action or any law any mandate is given on this this is only step number two or three in a board like ourselves trying to make change in state legislation

052rules or mandates all right so uh I'm I'm sensing somewhat from the discussion that uh there's one the issue of it might be a bit impractical for us to try to direct our delegate as to how they should vote on various resolutions that will be dealt with uh that's one of the things that I heard and the other is that um without knowing the specifics of the resolution without knowing what amendments might be made to that resolution uh can we really direct the delegate at this point uh to do anything one way or the other so I guess I'm saying uh do we want to make any motion at all to deal with this matter it appears not okay I I I see a lot of heads going this way I don't see any heads

053going this way so okay we we have discussed it we see that you know it is a is it is a bit of a quandry uh and we will leave it at that at this point is that satisfactory pickle all right thank you thank you uh at this time we will open the floor to the public forum uh I will remind you that uh during this first public comment session uh you are restricted to items which are on the agenda and you should identify uh your name give your name and address any other questions or comments that you may have that are not directly on this agenda you must wait until the second public session later this evening your statement is not to exceed three minutes of duration even if you're making statements of a

054complimentary nature and no participant is to speak more than once on the same topic all statements are to be directed to the presiding officer and you are not to direct any questions our comments to individual members of the board we would appreciate your cooperation in those guidelines at this time the floor is now open for comments on the start the clock yet Mar Klein 7 cruncher Court first I'd like to congratulate and compliment all of our teachers our Paras our principes administrators toig a superintendent and the assistant superintendent along with the board members for making us as successful as we are and as far as the report made by the assistant superintendent it's the first time in all the years that I'm here to include the three years I was sitting on the board that

055it wasn't just one two or three grades that showed us doing well and the other grades were not shown the report was full I appreciate it as a resident um second thing looking at our population our student population we grew this past year to 6,400 students it's an increase of 181 students knowing our state aid going back roughly at least two years ago if not three years ago I think what we amounted to was about $500 a student if the state does not give us our fair share of money and we have the increase in population School population we're getting nothing for the students here we a winning school system we're doing everything right we play the game they want the way they want to see the game played and we get penalized so you

056guys really did a hell of a job and I'm I'm proud to be part of Monroe the last thing and this pertains to the closed session I would just like to say one thing before you go in and speak when I sat on this board there were a few instances where there were major major ethics violations I and another board member at the time asked our president president our sitting president at the time to file ethics charges one was against an administrator one was against the board member nothing was ever done and they were serious what's going on now and whether you want to believe it or not I have no idea what Mr preciosa is having ethics charges against and I'm not asking excuse me Mr Cent and help me here Mr Gorski I'm

057not sure if your comments are related to the current agenda agenda well it it's on the agenda here all I want to do is make a statement so when you go into disc go ahead go ahead okay so there were ethics violations that were serious two board members one was a long sitting board member uh board member wanted to bring ethics violations against these two people it was turned down now I can't believe anything was done so serious by Mr preciosa that they have to carry this as long as they have God knows how much we've spent it's got to be 20 $25,000 already and I really would like you to think about it and they got to be damn serious to go to another hearing when perhaps a reprimand would do it could it

058could have been ended like something else could have been ended I just ask you to think about it do the right thing thank you thank you Mr Klein for your comments any other comments from the public on the agenda okay I will then close the first public session and we will go to committee reports do I have any committee chairperson to to make a report tonight no committee reports tonight all right then we will move to the superintendent's report Mr President before we go into my report I just want to uh take us back a second uh for the uh to recognize all the students that were involved in tonight's uh teacher and educational Professional Services uh dinner and I'm just going to read off their names and and dory's actually helped me over here

059uh for the cooks it was Olivia Kio or Casio Miguel Cortez Jamie Kirchner Danielle Hansen Michelle Hansen hel Dal Salvo and Chantel LeBrun Michelle Becker and Laurel Fox for the servers it was Ariana Moody looks Chevron sang Jenny du Amber Lee Tyra Malone Dimitri Davis amaru young deila and for the staff members it was Amanda Dockery uh she was the event Chef Jill caler C aner she was food preparation and cooking I think I mentioned some of these names as a matter of fact when we were there but I wanted to to say it again Desiree Farah for the decorations Marg a day for the staging uh jod rarin for the decorations Pam Fano for the Linens and Julia Bley for the graphic design and printing a round of applause for all the the students

060and staff thank you Mr President is recommended that the members of the M Township Board of Education approve Personnel items a through JJ and board members I did give you the uh the addition as far as JJ item JJ so we looking at items a through JJ M call has moved okay Mr Ryback has seconded it are there any questions or comments Mr armeno on page are we on page 41 with the is this including um the following revised job description I'm sorry is this on page 41f uh the recommend I'm sorry j is that is that is that on this vote because I that's not under this one okay I'll wait for the next action second was that seconded it's been seconded okay other questions these Personnel items uh start on page six and

061continue through page 40 40 okay okay including JJ so it's items a through JJ J any questions comments okay it has been moved and seconded that we approve the superintendent superintendent's recommendations items a through JJ J Mr Gorski roll call vote Miss armenio yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman uh yes to all recues on x y z g g XYZ g g so noted Mrs colano yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president Personnel items a through JJ passes thank you Mr Gorski Mr President it is recommended that the members of the Mona Township Board of Education approve board action items a through U now move now do we have a second Mr Mr Mayo okay we have a first and a second that we approve uh

062board action items a through U are there any questions or comments Mr armeno just can can I have an explanation on the recommended of the revised job description educational technology facilitator which item is that F on page 41 we made a few adjustments to the job description um Karen O Connell is retiring so we will be hiring someone in in her place so we looked at the job description to see how it met our needs now with all of the different technology since the previous one was quite old um so a couple of things we added um we wanted to um we added the preferential number two under qualifications preferred Masters and instructional technology that's a preferred requirement so so it's not a requirement um we also added under number three under qualifications we added

063um a couple of the programs that we're currently using in the district Genesis Genesis lesson planner and my learning plan uh we add number four was the ability to work with a variety of technology devices across platforms since we're under both Windows and Apple in the district um we changed who the person reports to because uh the person will be reporting to the assistant superintendent and the director of Technology uh director of information information systems sorry Mr Washington um and then we added some of the job goals would be coll not only um taking that teacher leadership role but also collaborating with the technology Network managers um making sure and the workstation specialist to ensure a communication and making sure that the needs of the teachers are being met so that it would kind of

064be the voice of the teachers with the technology and designing professional development courses appropriate for the needs and goals of the district with with the professional development team um and in the uh under performance responsibilities we changed uh for number one teaching experience from three plus years to 5 plus years so those were all the changes that were made to the job description I have one more question on Jay um or well really the on G approval to for the staff for okay that's different I'm so so sorry um the from G to M are any of these requiring additional salaries I think L is requiring additional salar is that correct could you restate that Miss I didn't understand it myself all right let me be more specific um when we make some changes or

065we add uh we recommend an person for an appointment to an additional coordination like in ex like Jay are we getting additional salaries giving additional salaries for that appointment it's a it's more of a an additional to the job description there's no stien for that position no stien for that okay it's part of the job responsibility and any of the others to M I know L has a a stien that's fine L isn't a stien that's a uh a contract with Project Lead the way to work with them so it's not a stien for any specific staff members it's it's something that we pay Project Lead the Way to come in and uh work with it's a professional development okay y thank you okay I'm satisfied thank you any other questions comments on board action

066items a through U okay Mr Gorski roll call vote please M armenio yes thanks for the clarification thank you welcome rman yes Mr zareski yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs Cole pit yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president board action items a through U passes unanimously Mr President that ends my report thank you Mr board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through F be approved by consent roll call move second any questions or comments on board action items a through F of the business administrator's report okay seeing none Mr Gorski roll call vote Mr armeno uh yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman Mrs kapano Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po uh yes

067except I must recuse myself on items B and C because I'm on the uh middle sex Regional Ed Services Commission so noted Mr board president board action items a through F has passed and that concludes my report thank you okay at this time board president's report I have a few uh few items they they will be brief however uh I believe you've all been notified uh through email uh and I would encourage as many members of our board as possible to attend the annual annual legislative dinner on June the 11th uh that is I believe a Tuesday or a Thursday it's a weekday at any rate uh there will be a legislative panel discussion remarks by the president of the State Board of Education and also the keynote speaker will be David hesie who is

068our state Commissioner of Education I I think uh our attendance at this could be worthwhile and if you are planning go uh please communicate or give a call to someone uh it's possible to form car poool since the uh the dinner will be down in Trenton uh that's on June the 11th and the deadline for registration is June the 5th and I understand there is no cost involved I don't know who's picking up the tab but at least there's no cost to our district uh on behalf of the entire board uh I extend our sincere wishes to Karina vanala one of our students who uh was seriously injured this past weekend uh in an automobile accident she was uh standing out on the street while participating in advertising uh her track team's Car Wash and

069uh we wish her a speedy and a Total Recovery uh I move that we uh I would also like to move uh because there's been some questions about this um I am moving that we have one represent from the Jamesburg Board of Ed assist in handing diplomas to members of our graduating class I believe it is my understanding but I stand to be corrected uh I believe that uh members of the James Ed board have always participated uh have been present at the ceremony and often set on the dis but uh in terms of participating in handing out diplomas I know at times they've been restricted to only a family member at least that's what I was led to believe but since uh this is the first time that I'm dealing with this as the

070president I wanted to make it clearer that since uh part of our graduating class comes from Jamesburg there is no reason that I see that we should exclude them from assisting in handing out the diplomas so that is my motion is there a second second second second okay Second Joe was first Mr May okay uh any any comments or questions about that before we vote want to be more clear on that uh okay well you have a question then because then I can be clearer maybe you're you're allowing any member who has a graduating student no I did not say that I said there would be asking no my my motion is that one member of the James board James Berg Board of Education would assist the other board members from Monroe in handing students

071their diplomas okay in the past since I've been here and in the past going to the graduations and it's always been an extended courtesy to allow those board members whether they're sitting on this board to have the privilege of giving their students and or relatives diplomas whether it be the person who's sitting in this chair or other board members from the Jamesburg Board of Education being that you had stated that we are accepting in this District Jamesburg students I feel that it is being a big misrepresentation of other board members in their participation in this high school so I would like to I I I you're you're I listen very closely Mr seski but I really didn't understand what you were saying at the end I'm trying to understand the motion that you only want

072the person who is sitting on this chair to be the representative for Jamesburg and not have those other board members have the honor or privilege of giving their students their uh children their diplomas that courtesy has always been extended to any Jamesburg board member in the past not restricting it to just one Mr Po thank you in Mr zareski is is correct that in the past it has been um a courtesy to allow a Jamesburg board member to hand out diplomas along with the Monroe board however your motion is is still a good recommendation to have it now on record in an action item approved by the board and I believe that Mr Po's motion was to allow any Jamesburg board member one to uh facilitate in the handing out of diplomas is that correct

073yes I and and not to exclude other Jamesburg members from handing out uh a diploma to their own family member no that was never the intention to exclude that but to to basically make it official that uh there is no question in the future going forward that a member a representative of the Jamesburg board actually participates in handing diplomas out to all of the students not just to you know one or two family members I don't know if that's making it clear or not that's why I was asking for clarification because this year alone we have I think three board members that have children graduating and like in the past it was extended as a courtesy to those board members to allow them to give their uh children their diplomas and it just so happens

074that we were asked because I've done it before you want to give out more diplomas so now that you made clarification on that thank you yes yes maybe if we changed one to any well I I I what I want to avoid is I want to avoid a lot of rotating uh people I mean it's pretty pretty rot it rotates quite a bit as it is right now and that's why I was restricting it to one who would assist in the General Distribution of the diplomas okay and certainly any board member from Jamesburg arm Monroe that wants to to present the diploma to a particular family member uh I don't intend at all to exclude that from happening I'm just basically trying to make it official because I I don't think there's anything in the

075record that basically says we can have a member of the Jamesburg board participate in the handing of diplomas among all of the students and not just family members Mrs Areno my question for clarification is Mr zareski is a Jamesburg board member sitting on our board are you talking about that one person or an additional person too Mr chess well that that's I just need you know I I I don't have any intention in terms of who that person would be okay no no but as go ahead if I can get this straight this way we all understand we're going to basically say that the representative from Jamesburg will hand out diplomas to all students as far as being in the rotation except for the fact when another Jamesburg board member's child comes up that person

076at that time is allowed to give their own child just that diploma and nobody else now doing that in the past it's kind of hard to watch when your child is coming up in whatever group it is to try to run out there excuse me and get in line to hand out that diploma it was always easier here comes my child here comes my niece my nephew get in line hand out the diploma to five six other students before their child gets there and then sit back down again I that would in my eyes cause more confusion and stop the ceremony to try to get one person to give one diploma to one person I I understand your point there out Doug oh it's Mrs kapovich been done in the past it's like past practice

077because it's never been anything official or unofficial it's just that the the board member from Jamesburg who sits on this board represents Jamesburg always gave out diplomas as part of the Monroe Township Board of educ a representing the Jamesburg students so they did it the same as any of the Monroe board members but if there was a board member from Jamesburg who had a student who um was graduating or a a niece or a nephew or relative they always were able to give that student um a a diploma it's never been an issue about where you came in um we were we always knew because we always spoke about it but I'm giving this diploma to this certain person and always just gave up that spot so that a Jamesburg rep could give their child

078a diploma so it's never been an an issue um it's just something that we've always accommodated Jamesburg with which I believe is the right thing to do Mr P it it's always worked informally in the past I really think you should just withdraw withdraw your motion and and based on the discussion I'm happy to do that uh I thought it might help to to make it uh you know an official uh motion and and have that understood going forward uh the question arose because I had gotten a request from a member of the Jamesburg board I responded to to participate in uh in that distribution and and that that that request seemed to at least uh did not restrict itself to just that board member's family members but a more General participation uh so I

079was trying to get that clarified but uh it appears that there's really no need to uh and we'll let Jamesburg deal with who is the Jamesburg representative in terms of the General Distribution of the diplomas and if there is a family member then that can be accommodated all right uh I'd like to update uh the the public because the board has been updated but I'd like to update the public on the superintendent search we will begin interviews next week and we hope to we hope to schedule the second round for uh sometime around May 28th uh we are hoping to enter into contract negotiation shortly thereafter and we would like to submit a contract to the county superintendent for approval by June 15th now the reason for the June 15 deadline is because it is

080my understanding that the county superintendent's office requires 30 days and they won't seem to do it in anything less than that so working backwards from 30 days uh if if all of that falls into place and it's a big if but if all of that falls into place then we will have someone to replace Mr ventrillo hopefully around the beginning of school and Mr ventrillo can go back to his happy family at the uh Apple at the appleg guard school which is very much a desire of his even though we very much appreciate uh the job that Mr ventrillo is has and is doing for us uh that concludes my report is there any other board of education business Mr Mayo um just back to the legislative dinner that you're talking about he's also speaking

081during the day from 8:30 to 2 so if anybody wants to go during the day to hear has commissioner has be speak you can do it during the day well that's the only time it is isn't it it was a dinner well well I mean well it's it's over lunch I'm sorry you I okay yeah you have to excuse me that was probably my my Texas upbringing dinner was always at lunch we didn't have lunch for some reason I thought he was speak had dinner and supper so you'll have to excuse that no it's from 8:30 in the morning until 2: in the afternoon yeah sorry about that Mr Coffman uh many years ago the board went paperless and we didn't get our uh board packets on paper it was all electronic we get it

082copies anyway all of a sudden the last I don't know how long maybe the last couple of months or whatever we we get weekly packets again why why are we killing trees for us I get everything electronically I don't need this okay then you might request of the superintendent's office that they not send you a packet I have personally requested to get a packet because I I'm oldfashioned I like the paper and pencil I like to be able to jot down things and write comments and questions Etc and I find that I can't do that so well and I don't want to use my own printer ink to print out all these pages I don't need mine anyone else I already sent my request in C to cancel mine too you canel your subscription and

083I did too you did too yeah I did there's a little thing on the bottom say click I have uh just to confirm so I have Lou I have Kathy K and I have Rob not asking for already got my hard copy okay anyone else just let me know you can email me if you change your mind if You' like copies let me know okay any any other board business all right then uh be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of enroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 to discuss the following subject harassment intimidation and bullying as well as an update on litigation yes an update on pending litigation uh regarding uh Mr Anthony proso and

084the Monroe Township Board of Education of middle sex County the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exist I would anticipate this closed session would last 15 20 minutes 15 minutes okay at which time we will return and have our second public all in favor of going into close session oh I'm sorry I need a first and a second okay armeno and that's I didn't know that that's fine all right all in favor I opposed okay any abstentions all right fine we will now go into uh Clos session and hopefully we will return uh prior to uh 8:45 or sooner we will now resume with the public portion of our board meeting and go to our second public forum anyone wishing

085to speak please proceed to the microphone at the podium at this time thank you yes IA tesler Live LA drive I'll just be brief I would just like to thank the board and the staff uh for all their work this year I know the culinary students um cook the uh dinner tonight as they always did in the past the teacher dinner and uh my middle daughter Rebecca is graduating this year uh she's a senior and um she has participated in the culinary program uh for the first 3 years and now she does her senior option uh in The Culinary class uh every day fourth block uh she's actually finished her hours she doesn't need anymore but she loves it so much she uh stays every day to participate and help the students um so I'd

086like to give a little shout out to the Amanda do dockerty the teacher uh for her uh four years uh of service to her and uh my daughter is going to Johnson and Wells this year to pursue her dream of baking and pastry so I'd just like to give a shout out uh to the board of ed the St and uh and everybody who uh helped her in achieve her goal thank you thank you thank you for your comment hi my name is Jimmy C and I'm from 406 Morning Glory Drive I'm um thank you for giving me an opportunity to speak um we just I just moved to the to Monro Township like a month back so I very excited to be here uh my daughter goes in uh first grade um we live

087in monome Manor which is south of uh Route 33 um there are a few things that I wanted to bring up regarding transportation and all which are basically from all of us uh from that Community um right now in that Community we have three buses playing and uh there are um for one of the roads uh there are two stops uh actually two stops where each stop has 40 kids getting into the bus so uh especially in Winter it creates a lot of traffic related issues so I wanted to mention that uh we need uh additional stops on that road it's Morning Glory Drive um so if um um we can work on that that'll be really great um also the buses number of buses the three buses especially and this is for um uh

088Elementary School which is oak tree and applegrath um the three buses playing are insufficient um each bus has about 40 45 kids um and there are only three stops so um if if the board can look into or the transportation department can look into um adding some buses uh looking at how many total kids are there and how many buses are required that'll be really great um other thing we wanted to bring up was the number of kids in oak tree and apple grth um my daughter's class has about 29 kids um same is the case with others she's in first grade um so I want to see if there is a plan to increase the number of classes um with all the new families moving in and all the increas in kids um we

089know in September there are additional kids going to be going to kg and first grade and uh the final point was uh regarding the before and after care for um um the elementary schools op tree and applegrath uh we were um initially told that board of education was going to take it over I'm not sure if it was Final um and they were not aware of what the plans are so if we could get some direction in that because it's very important for working parents um that we have before and after care so um uh just wanted to bring up those points if if the board uh has any um any anything to say about those but U just wanted to bring up on those points I have your your questions I wrote them down

090just to let you know we'll take a look at that information I can assure you though that as though there's 40 kids on the buses that there are 54 seats on the bus okay so much as much as it seems like that bus is full it is not filled uh the other thing too as far as you know your question about the enrollment adul Tre school that's all part of our redistricting plan so that the impact that will change then come September as far as as we reorganize the schools and the enrollment numbers so those numbers will be lower and as far as the before and after school care program that's now been replaced with Falcon care that information is starting to get out there as well too it's on the okay and it's already

091on the website so you can take a look at that appreciate it um regarding the number of number regarding the increasing the number of stops on Morning Glory Drive um because one there are two stops which has 40 kids each so um that creates a little bit of traffic problem and in the morning it's a lot of rush so and I and to your question so feel free then if you don't mind just give me an email tomorrow as far as with some of the particulars and I'll look into that absolutely on your I have this paper if you want to take a look I just feel free to give it to me y absolutely thank you very [Music] much Mar Klein 7 crore um 18 you're showing the next meeting Thursday May 14th that's

092got to be a mistake you really having another one tomorrow yeah we're having all kinds of fun you mean I got to come back again okay and then as far as the uh the close session this is the first time in all the years that I've been here that you came in sooner than what you said you were going to come in I would gather being that the attorney isn't here that you probably didn't discuss the case that's pending you right wrong oh you can't say anything okay well that's that's my assumption but anyway thank you very much say you disc okay any any other comments or questions from the public okay seeing no one uh coming to the uh microphone I will then close the second public forum our next scheduled Board of Education

093meeting is tomorrow evening May 14th 7 o'clock here at the high school media center uh the this will be an open public session we will uh it's been specially set up so that all members of the board uh could be present for uh coming to some kind of a decision about the iPad uh initiative uh going forward into next year uh that is the only topic I believe on the agenda uh all the board members have received it I just haven't looked at it today but that's what we're talking about tomorrow night uh that will be the only topic but the the public is welcome it is an open meeting and the board will be taking action at that time okay I would move that we adjourn this meeting so move second all in favor

094I opposed objections extensions okay that's it

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.