001good evening public meeting of the Hillsboro Township Board of Education Hillsboro did I say Hillsboro hello excuse the [Laughter] slip the public meeting of the Monroe Township there we go that's a Board of Education will now come to order try to cut that out Mr Gorski roll call please M armeno here Mr Braverman here Mr Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs Co Pano here Mr noin here Mr Po here Mr proso here Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Mr board president you have a quarm present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has cause notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof hosted December 11th 2015 at all schools the home News Tribune the
002cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality okay at this time I would ask that you please rise and join me in the pledge to the flag I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all normally that uh that particular uh privilege is given to uh one of our student board members but I see they're both absent tonight possibly because they're involved in the uh the Winter concert uh which is taking place in the auditorium at this time okay we'll move on to the approval of minutes I move that we accept the minutes of the public Board of Education meeting held on October 14th don't moved second all right any uh
003Corrections or questions all in favor I opposed minutes are accepted I approve that I I move that we approve the minutes of the Clos session meeting of October 14th no moved second any questions or comments all in favor I opposed okay those minutes are accepted I move that we accept the minutes of the special Board of Education meeting of October the 26th moved any questions or comments all in favor I opposed oh I abstain I was not at that meeting is that correct Mr B abstention noted thank you thank you all in favor I okay did we do that one already okay Michelle threw me off there with her okay I move that we approve the minutes of the Clos session meeting of October 26 so move second any questions or comments all in favor
004I opposed obain abstention Mr armeno okay uh we do not have any student board uh members here tonight so we will dispense with that report and at this time we will have a presentation of the 201415 comprehensive annual financial report often referred to as the cfra uh Mr Gorski are you going to introduce our auditor yes thank you Mr Po members of the monor Township Board of Education members of the public as per statute each public school district is required to have an independent audit performed annually by a CPA with a public school accountant license issued by the state the board has engaged Gerald stankowitz partner with Samuel kleinan company to perform that audit this year Mr stanitz uh good evening everyone uh thank you for the introduction Mike um the the cfra is a
005uh the is there's 's two documents in front of you actually the cfra is the thicker of the two and the cfra is actually uh Financial document that we put together in conjunction with the business office um it information in this document belongs to the Board of Education the only thing inside this document that belongs to us is the independent Auditor's opinion which I will get to the chase expresses an unmodified opinion otherwise known in the old days as a clean opinion or an unqualified opinion I I'll get to how we get to that point shortly the other document is my letter to the board uh as to the operation of the business office if you'll note the the smaller of the two has my firm's letterhead on it the other one doesn't because the
006thicker of the two like I said is actually the board's document um the audit is conducted as Michael said in conjunction with the statute um we are hired by the board to audit the records of the uh Business Administration Office of the district uh we are independent Auditors we we have to be independent of the records we're not allowed to touch the records of original uh Source documents documents of origination um we we're not allowed to we don't do that if we do then we are uh violating our independence um and we're unable to express an opinion on the documents we get presented with a set of Records uh for audit and and for the record prior to this uh for the rest of the board members there was a a uh meeting of the
007business I believe and operations uh committee I believe we met last when were we here last Wednesday uh and we uh discussed the contents of the audit uh pretty much in detail uh and prior to that a week before that we had what's required to be called the uh formal exit conference with the management of the district that occurs before the audit is actually issued it's a chance for management to review the report before it's issued to the board and for them to for a chance to them to refute any comments or any information in the audit um they're allowed to refute it but in the end I I I uh it's it's my call as to whether you know something gets included or excluded and for the record there there were no findings uh
008so there wasn't really much to discuss in terms of any re refuting of of our of our points so basically our audit starts um a good audit I would say starts on the first day of the fiscal year under audit um we we come in in actually uh we're here in the summertime looking at information relative to the prior year but at the same time we're looking at documentation relative to the current year as well uh we're looking at paid bills uh in the current year to determine if they have any applicability to the prior year and also that they're also correct and and moving forward we we also audit in November and October we come in and we start with the Assa audit we audit the drtr RS we audit the IEPs we audit
009the free and reduced loan applications for the next fiscal year um getting back to the actual audit though our staff comes in generally in July reviews the minutes we start reviewing preliminary information we start pulling the audit samples and again the audit the root word is sample it's an audition so to speak uh believe it or not so we we come in we we select our information for our samples and we sample expenditures we sample payroll transactions which is the two primary areas of the audit um we make our selections we give our our requests to the staff they pull the information um we also audit the Food Service fund we look through their records and uh make sure that that even though they are a subcontractor we still have the board still has the
010legal right to look at their records and we do that we look at their expenditures we look at their payroll we look at their their procedures and how they formulate the monthly meal counts for which we send the claims into the government um we also look at their handling of cash receipts on behalf of the board we found no problems in that area they are also required to submit an internal control report to the board that their internal controls because they might represent 50 75 districts everything's being channeled through one business office on their end so we make sure that that report is lined up and that report is on file and actually is required to be on file when you contract with them so we go through that we also look at expenditures of
011the board itself um we kind of I uh as I expressed to the business operations committee I I kind of like to do a little bit more than the minimum let's say required uh audit work because that's just how my training was you know you do a little bit more U don't rely totally on the minimum standard of the profession we look at a little bit more and that's important for me I came from a very small firm and merg into a larger firm and I still use the same things that I was taught by my mentor so we I try to make sure that it's I get a little more Comfort level when I sign my name to the report and and we were comfortable I I had one of my staff uh doing
012the expenditure testing we run a sample we run a statistical sample based on the the check numbers the check ranges so we sample uh transactions an individual check we also look at every bill of a certain dollar level we look at your transportation bills we look at your tuition bills we go through your maintenance accounts we look at uh what we call significant items we look at health benefits bills so we get we look at Capital outlay just want to make sure all with the intent of making sure that it's a it's all properly documented B it's charged to the right account C that it's in compliance with the public school contracts law and at the tail end of the year we want to make sure that that the bills were cut off properly uh
013with respect to the end of the fiscal year there are bills if you work in business that are incurred prior to the fiscal year end however they don't get paid till July or August or September we make sure those bills are thrown back in all those areas we found no exceptions okay and I and like I said we I use a little bit more aggressive tactic when I go through the bills at any place I do again that goes back to my training um we had good results from that we also spent a significant amount of time in the biggest area of any school or any business is in the payroll um your your payroll office uh provides us with the sufficient data that we need to to form an opinion as to its operation
014uh again we do a random sample of payroll checks from A to Z and we'll sample and make sure that in each case that the the person who's there has all the proper paperwork on file that they're properly paid in accordance with board authorization that their withholdings are proper and most especially in the area of the required health benefits withholding uh make sure all that their documents are on file and current I9 w4s all that stuff that if you work somewhere you'd be required to file and have on deposit as well so we go through all that we also expand a little bit um we will take a couple payrolls and look at every part-time and overtime uh dispersement that goes through there I don't know in a district de size that running a standard
015audit sample gives you gives me and the board a sufficient Comfort level that things are operating properly so we will look at and it's rather cumbersome but it's not difficult to audit it just takes time and we look at part-time and overtime over and above what we normally sample and for the people who we do sample we make sure that they got paid exactly what they were entitled to base pay coaching stiens extra pay lunchroom coverage all that all those different items so payroll is operating properly as well um in terms of Revenue that's relatively easy to audit here obviously you have you have tax levy and state aid those are kind of easy and you also have tuition coming in from a neighboring Community which we you know we we look at the documentation
016on that so the three major areas Revenue payroll expenditures we got good and successful results from those we got good results from our our audit of the Food Service fund um the most important thing that and you've heard this expression before that cash is King okay the general ledgers as presented okay we're all in agreement with the supporting documentation and most importantly your bank reconciliation on a monthly basis tied to the general ledger okay now in some people's businesses they don't worry about that too much but in a government entity uh on a monthly basis and you all see the certifications monthly between the treasures reports and the secretary rep the cash is the king as Wayne holiday used to say and it it has to time monthly and I we can assure you that
017that's all all done and performed you know properly we uh got good feed feedback also from any person within the business office who we talk to um they are concerned they want to do a good job um and whenever we had a question they were more than happy to answer it but for the most part the system here is is is is pretty well set up that it actually minimizes uh really how much talking you have to do the bills are all there on the wall the bank statements are all there on the binder so we I send my staff in and uh they go through everything what I do with them though is I alternate them for example the young lady who did the payroll this year she probably will do it again next
018year if you know and in the third year she won't she'll shift over to another thing it gives a second set of eyes within my organization I alternate people because I a I like them to know the whole job and B U it gives a second set of eyes to look at internally what's going on the staff is in the trenches doing the bulk of the work and uh under my supervision and I certainly review it and spend time in the basement with them going through it so uh the general ledgers presented we take those we transform those into an audit report actually into What's called the comprehensive annual financial report inside this document there's a lot of of U description a lot of verbiage um there's information that's provided by uh management by the
019superintendent and Mike kski the business administrator and it's just information about the township of Monroe now it's not audit information but but it's part of the whole cfer process um 20 years ago the Lords of the profession decided it was good to have this so that someone say on Wall Street or somewhere else could pick up this book and look at it and determine a little bit more about Monroe Board of Ed either from a financial standpoint or educational standpoint just what's going on here all in this this rather thick document here there's a lot of verbiage there's a lot of standard verbiage there's notes to the financial statement that describe the accounting requirements that we have to follow and by all means we follow them you know you have three uh well two CPAs
020who formerly did school board work as well as a former employee uh of mine who works in the office there as well who's very good so we the infrastructure the human being infrastructure is is pretty well set up and the uh it just helps enhance the whole Control process of the audit they know what we're looking for they know how to get the good end product we do our testing our inquiry we get good results okay um as a result of all of our successful auditing uh test we end up at the end with and I'll refer you to the page um page 10 which is the independent Auditors report it's in the thicker of the two documents [Music] basically what it says is that uh We've audited the accompanying financial statements of the governmental
021activities the business activities uh and the remaining fund information of the Board of Education of Monroe Township for the year end June 30 2015 it breaks it out they started this about five yearo years ago with the opinions it makes it a little clearer to understand management is responsible for presenting us with the records we're responsible to audit those and it's Our obligation to the board to issue an opinion and our opinion is is that we have a clean set of records and that the operation uh was proper and everything was properly documented sufficiently and over and above what's required to give me the option the right to sign off on the independent Auditor's opinion um a lot of it is standard wording um want to point out there's also a management discussion and Analysis
022which is actually authored by uh the business office in conjunction with the superintendent where they discuss the operations and highlights that are not normally part of the audit we we don't really go to Highlights all our job is to tell the board that the financial statements present fairly and to tell them also whether there were any operational problems um it's not our job to say you're you have healthy Surplus or it's a bad Surplus or whatever our job is merely to give an opinion on the records as presented maybe down the road Mike might be able to give a little talk more about the management discussion and Analysis it talks about actually it's a good opportunity for superintendent and theba tutor horn about the operation of the district again these are designed for someone else
023somewhere else to look at this and know a little more about the district um you're going to see some interesting numbers and the reason why we are late is because several years ago um somewhere along the line people in the public all over the country had questions as to just what it costs to operate a government entity however what it costs for what they're on the hook for for pension and for retirement pay I mean we spent a lot of time discussing that at the uh exit conference and what happened was they contrived this document called governmental Accounting Standards Board it's a standard number 68 it's all numbered U and basically what it was was to require to measure the pension the longrange pension obligation of government entities that data was not released in New
024Jersey until November 13th it took us all in the industry a little bit of time to to get a feel for like well what are we supposed to do with this we translate that into the audit document um and they they gave us some numbers as to what uh what Monroe's allocated share is now the numbers may appear to be significant it's not an immediate liability we're not on the hook for it immediately um and there's two different numbers one is the PS employees that's one of the pension systems Our obligation there is about $30 million however it's not an immediate obligation it's actually uy determined it could change if the interest rates change and it's based on mortality rates and a lot of other factors at actuaries use I'm not an actuary I can't
025really go too deep into it but it's it's a number and it's nothing to panic over but we're required to incorporate it into these financial statements there's another number for the tpaf employees okay that is not our obligation there is a number allocated to us but it's the primary obligation of the state of New Jersey therefore it doesn't enter into our records okay it is a mention in the notes as to what our obligation is again actuar determined and put together in a report by a very large KPMG accounting firm so uh basically those numbers are in here as well there's a lot of comparative information uh there's a lot of statistical information again most of it is a joint venture with ourselves and the board office but within the bigger document our opinion is
026that the financial statements present fairly the other document is my letter to the board that about the operation of the district it contains required information contains your 2% Surplus calculation it contains information on the Assa which is the enrollment counts it contains information about the net cash resources of your food service fund it contains meal count information um even though it's our letter to the board the state kind of dictates what we have to put in it but it's also our opportunity to indicate that everything I described previously was done in compliance with the state requirements and and also importantly in requirements with generally accepted auditing standards and generally accepted auditing standards for government entities as well it talks about the fact that we you know we went through the claims we went through expenditures
027we went through payroll uh we went through tuition we looked at bills we looked at expenditure we check for coding we check your travel policy we check the expenses for travel and the maintenance expenses we look at the uh Student Activity funds but not as closely as you may think they're they're a small amount of money compared to the overall scheme of things here and um we like the fact that they are pre- audited by the business office um it's just a good thing to have if any of you work in a corporation you have an internal audit staff well it's the same thing and we have the cap they have capability to flag down any problems that occur in those areas before it gets to our level we also have have information here about
028our compliance District's compliance with the public school contracts law the compliance with the food service requirements and uh basically as a result of our testing uh and inquiry we end up with this smaller document which contains a statement that there are no audit recommendations um the the the office there has a lot of good hardworking people and qualified people and as a result we end up with uh this document here that shows no what it recommendations um our audit was conducted it starts like I said early on the bulk of our work is done in August and September and we're usually here in either October or November but like I said there was a delay in getting the information out and I still believe there's probably hundreds of school board orders that haven't been issued
029yet they're basically all due Monday yours was filed effective about two weeks ago when we concluded it so you were the first one of our firm issued so basically that is my presentation I I want to thank publicly the members of the business office uh and especially Laura Allen who had a a much larger role this year in operating with us and and the go between and answering questions and providing us with documents and also providing us with the proper computer runs and general ledgers uh that we needed and uh we're thankful to her but the uh business office staff was very cooperative and we're appreciative of that so we have an unmodified opinion and no audit recommendations this year and at that point I don't know Mike if you want to do some of
030the highlights that are in the cfra yes Mr Po um the purpose of uh the public meeting of course is to focus on students and programs and instruction so I'll I'll be brief but I want to present some highlights from this year because this really was a remarkable 12 months of operations here in the district and please anybody as a member of the public you have a a right to an electronic copy of the comprehensive annual financial report as well as the auditor's management report on findings simply uh give me a call or shoot me an email and I'll tell you how to uh request these documents via Oprah at no charge because they're submitted electronically and you could have uh all this information accessible to you and there's a lot of good information in
031here uh in the beginning of this report there's a a plethora about curriculum accomplishments this year and there were many under Dr alvic um as Mr stankowitz mentioned there's an independent auditor report letter this document and the financial statements contained within and all of the other representations are the responsibility and the representations of school management Dr kak and and myself and they uh they are audited the only thing in this larger document that is the product of the audit firm is the independent auditor report their job is to express an opinion on the financial statements and they have done so with an unmodified clean opinion there is a management discussion and Analysis letter and we went through some of the key financial highlights but just very briefly again we had $8 million of bond Surplus
032from this high school construction 2 A5 million was applied against Debt Service taxes which otherwise would have been raised through the budget for the first time in 17 years we had a average school tax decrease on an average assessed home the district conducted an ad hoc committee to study um The District student growth and there were two recommendations one to do a district redistricting which was successfully performed this September and the second was the plan for a bond referendum that has led to another ad hoc committee being uh formed which is in process now and we are in uh in a clean slate of studying enrollment and making recommendations on how to handle the incredible student um increases and uh stress that our facilities are facing we received uh we we mutually um engaged very
033favorable settlements with the monra township Education Association whose net budget impact was 2% on the budget less than the 2.75 that was budgeted um the mon Township support staff Association net impact on the budget was 2% less than the 2.75% that was budgeted and the teamsters Which is 1.66 less than the 2.56 that was budgeted uh these favorable outcomes were the result of major concessions in the area of health benefits the traditional health plan which is the most expensive we have is being eliminated at the end of the contract year copays increased stiens were eliminated and a lot of Reform was created we refinanced $65 million of 2006 and 2008 bonds which were outstanding saving $3.9 million of Interest cost over the next 20 years we we mutually uh came to a settlement and litigation
034between the Jamesburg Board of Education and the Monro Board of Education and that that specifically led to our successful Bond rating with SNP when we went to refinance the bonds that was a key concern that that was mitigated part of that agreement Monroe Monroe will um be repaid all of the aage um as per the agreement within a very constrictive tax levy cap we were very productive in um doing Capital Improvements and applying for a state reimbursement under the rod grant program of up to 40% of those costs we save $3.3 million in health insurance by negotiating out of a direct claims based plan into a perspective and another $970,000 um by battling with Horizon and and um threatening to leave in comparative shopping and very aggressive negotiation $1.5 million was saved in a supply
035Consortium with the ed Service Commission and the Monroe employee Child Care Academy Mecca was closed this year due to economy budget considerations and restructuring of the program and for other good cause and the board did not renew the lease agreement with Basque and instead developed our own in-house CARE program for students known as Falcon care there's $214,000 of money owed from Mecca previously to the general fund which will be repaid and will be inherited by the new remaining funds Early Childhood enrichment program and Falcon care Mr St what covered the ition so I'll skip that but again keep in mind it wasn't long ago under the Whitman Administration that we had a bond Surplus so you know my colleagues and I are not too concerned about the financial disclosure right now with interest rates pegged
036at zero and no earnings accumulating in the pension uh Investments with that number that has to be repaid back as mentioned in the cfer even slight in increases in interest rates which occurred today will result in Greater earnings and a lower pension obligation going forward and the district generated much more Surplus this year than ever before we put 975,000 via B uh board resolution into a capital reserve account $600,000 is committed to go under cap in the 16117 budget for tax relief and the other $600,000 is dedicated for new student needs throughout the district based upon new student enrollment the total outstanding debt obligation of the district in bonds is about 139 million and the borrowing capacity of the district within our limit is an additional $136 million if the board should be so inclined
037to uh need to bond that much which is unlikely the unemployment rate was always of Interest before that has dropped from 10.2 to 8.7 to 6.5% in Monroe for the year end of June 30 2015 and a very noteworthy schedule is on page 136 showing increased enrollment conservatively increasing operational expenditures and a percentage change in the cost per pupil um ratio which for the last five years is about 0.5% about a half a percent increase in the cost per pupil increases that's what an average cost is per child to educate in this District our student attendance percentage is very high there's a penalty of state aid if that goes below an amount and um again there's a plethora of information in here that I'm not going to bore you with but please you know I
038would welcome any request for this information I would like to thank the board for the resources that they provided in the business office and I would like to thank Dr alvic and Dr kak for um making this report as as successful which is a um a managerial feat thank you thank you Mr sanitz as well as Mr Gorski um it's always good to get a an audit report in which no recommendations were made uh which means that we're doing quite well in in terms of handling our financial operation I had also asked Mr Switz uh last week when we met with him uh besides recommendations were there any suggestions and he also responded that no he did not have any any suggestions either so that's even a uh uh a double Plus for us in
039terms of the financial uh uh operation of our district uh so I thank you for that report and Mr Gorski I thank you for those highlights uh it looks as if we're going to have a presentation of plaqu uh Dr kak are you gonna be taking care of that Kathy Kathy wants to make a motion oh I'm sorry Miss kapovich yes um it is recommended that the members of the Board of Education accept and approve the comprehensive annual financial report and the auditor's management report on administrative findings Financial compliance and performance and hereby approve and authorize the submission of the required corrective action plan capap to the county office indicating that there are no recommendations for fiscal year ending June 30th 2015 Moor any questions or comments Mr nin um I too just want to
040thank um Mr Gorski and the business office for all their hard work uh we went over this uh in uh very much more detail than we did tonight at the finance committee meeting and uh I just want to thank them for their all for their hard work um just one quick question um I know and I I should have written it down but um the a a41 a42 the the calculation for the tuition when is that uh going to be due so we know exactly what our cost is per student Mr Po thanks the a41 a42 is a tuition calculation report at the state department of education issues it's available now and we are currently working on that at the conclusion of the audit when this audit is accepted by the board we extract a
041plethora of data from this report report and enter it and allocate some into the forms a41 a42 it's about a 200 Page legal siiz page Excel spreadsheet and it calculates a per pupil cost in all grade levels and um special education disciplines and so on then we do the actual ad calculation for students including those from Jamesburg and we do a settlement between what they paid in the budget to what the actual cost and what the actual enrollment was we should have that information in about a week or two and we'll report that to uh a future finance committee excellent thank you any other questions or comments all right uh roll call vote Mr Gorski Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski Iain thank you sir Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs
042K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck and Mr Po yes Mr board president motion passes thank you thank you have a nice holiday thank you very much okay thank you Mr President um we have three plaqu here to present to three of our board members and Mr President if you could uh allow me just a a couple words to say about each of the members I would appreciate that is that certainly go ahead okay uh well we'll start with um you uh Mr President okay um and and you Lo it before you even knew what I had to say so that there's some trust there and I I appreciate that uh it has been my honor and privilege to have served under the leadership of the our board president Mr Doug
043py for the past five and a half months Mr py brought a unique perspective to the position a board president having been an educator and having served as a high school principal in where was that oh it's hillsbor that's right I hope you don't mind I'm having fun with you I realize that it's respectful trust me it's um Mr P is not averse to asking tough questions I've sweat it through a few myself uh but always always in a respectful Manner and he certainly expects the district leadership team to ensure that the M the Monro Township School District remains in the Forefront of innovative educational practices and to ensure that we contribute or continue to be a highly performing School District Mr Po spearheaded the steering committee to study the effect of the growing student
044enrollment on our schools and facilities and he insisted on a balanced group of community members students and Educators in um the uh composition of the ad hoc and the student growth advisory committee there are many other things that I'm sure that Mr Po did before my arrival here in July and there's many many other uh achievements and things that I could point to um but I think there is a time limit and there are two other people uh that I would like to mention as well uh but I would like to just finish with saying that Mr Po is certainly one of the best port presidents that I have worked for so uh with that I we also just Round of Applause and for this um we have a plaque um you don't sell this
045okay it's budget's tight okay we cut back it's but it's a uh present it to Doug py in sincere sincere appreciation for dedicated service to the students and schools of Monroe Township while serving as a board member of the Monroe Township Board of Education from 2013 through 2015 thank you so much thank you next we have Mr proso Mr proso is a champion for our special education students his passion to ensure that our students with special needs receive the best education we can offer certainly evident in his comments and actions Mr proso provides a huge howy party for special needs students every year is actually this past Saturday and I can assure um Mr prosu that we will continue to work to ensure all children receive a quality education that will prepare them for successful
046experiences in college and a career please deserves a round of applause the plaque says presented to M to Anthony proso and sincere appreciation for dedicated service to the students in schools of Monroe Township while serving as a board member of the the Monroe Township Board of Education from 2013 to 2015 thank you thank [Applause] you say something sure president yes go ahead this plaque is very nice thank you I would like to thank every board member Jill Kathy Lou Robert Steve Michelle Tom and Marvin we do this job without pay and I know we put a lot of effort into it and this is for the kids we do it for the kids we have personality problems but we do it for the kids and I just want to thank everybody for doing their job
047and for giving the effort that we give for these kids and you Doug too I'm sorry thank you thank [Applause] you Mr sheski Mr seski is committed to ensuring all students including our Jamesburg students receive the best educational experience we can offer to them his commitment to education is evident through his own training as a board member and being an advocate for the children in the districts and I districts I plural Mr seski uh although is will still be on the jamesw board of education is um transitioning I guess that uh the the the position of the representative to another member of the Jamesburg Board of Education so I just wanted to thank you for again my brief time spending with you um and I would like to read this plaque to you that this
048is presented to Robert seski in sincere appreciation for dedicated service to the students and schools of Monroe Township while serving as a Jamesburg representative of the Monroe Township Board of Education from 2013 through 2015 Stanley Cup this way okay okay our new Jamesburg representative is in the audience if you would like to stand up and be [Applause] recognized and uh that concludes the presentations um Mr President okay thank you Dr kak uh at this time we will go to committee reports do I have any committee chairs that wish to make a report Mr Coffman thanks Doug uh we had a curriculum meeting this evening and we went over the following items uh we had curriculum updates for uh media literacy grade six language arts grade three Advanced web design grades 10 to 12 computers and
049business world one grades 9 through 12 family and consumer science uh for grades seven and 8 in addition we had a complete Club update by Greg berer uh Who provided us some details on clubs that are currently ongoing uh as well as uh clubs that have been cut over the past year we had a uh high level Park update uh to uh give us some information on where we stand with uh uh doing our uh data reviews on the information that's come back from the state regarding the park uh more to come uh January big big thing in January right Big Show on January okay um we also had a update on the special education audit uh so we were uh given a result of the survey that was provided uh to us and taken
050from the staff on uh various different measurements throughout the district related to uh our special education program um as as some of you may recall we had asked that if we're going to be doing an external audit to take a look on how we do things here with special ed it'd be kind of a good idea to take a baseline snapshot of of uh our district and our members here today so that we can kind of compare what we perceive our program to be against what an outside vendor perceives our program to be so that we can kind of do a gap analysis to determine are we kind of on par with what they're doing or did we find stuff that they didn't or vice versa so we got the results of that and I
051think we're approving the vendor for doing the outside services this evening yes and and so we're going to have more updates sometime early next year on the external audit I don't know how long it takes a month to probably around may I would expect the board presentation to the board okay and we also got an update on a uh a service that we are looking to uh obtain uh for performance matters which will give the District administration the ability to um analyze the data that's produced by our own internal grading systems which is Genesis against the park data that we get from the state uh to try and slice and dice the data uh in ways that we never were able to do before by down to the uh student level uh and match uh
052their data and statistics across the district so um I think it's going to be a good effort to be able to kind of project and see um where we're where we're strong where we're not where we could use Improvement um where you know we want to go from good to great so um more to come on that is that also develops over time and anything we know about the standardized testing knowing that we're in the park world it's an emerging science right we're going to be years away from kind of nailing both the exam and the assessment of the exam so uh more to come on that that's it Mr Coffman anyone else Mr Rybeck just very briefly the Personnel committee met on Monday we'll be we will be recommending a position for a media
053specialist at the middle school anyone else M col panovich um as mentioned before we had a finance committee meeting this past Thursday December 10th and the only item on the agenda was a discussion on the audit which we just approved um Mr stenis I think gave a good um update on what we discussed at that meeting and Mr Gorski gave the key financial highlights um I'd like to commend Mr Gorski and Laura Allen for continuing to run the business office in an efficient manner and being fiscally responsible to our community and I think this was evident by the fact that um in this year's audit we were able to to for the first time in 17 years have a tax decrease not a tax rate decrease but a tax decrease of $114 for assessed home
054but I also like to thank the whole business office we as a district have been getting larger we have more students we have more um staff members we have more Transportation Food Service everything and as we've gotten bigger they've taken on a lot more responsibility and have not had an addition to the business office so I think that they have done a remarkable job so I just want to publicly thank the business office and that concludes my report thank you any other chair people s meno I just want to point out that on uh this evening's agenda there are policies for the first reading policies and regulations uh that have to do with the evaluation of the superintendent valuation of teachers teaching staff members um and evaluation of Administrators excluding principles vice president they're all
055on the uh board on the board website the uh District website and then go to the board information and all the uh policies are there for review and we will be having a second reading uh next year so if people are concerned with those policies I would recommend that they uh take a look at them there's also policy evaluation of principles Vice principles and assistant principles there's a policy regarding service animals and then of course the use of electronic communication and recording devices so those are all uh very important policies I would like the public to take an opportunity to take a look at those thank you thank you anyone else okay uh I'm going to report on the uh work of the ad hoc committee that we've done uh this is for both informing
056the board as well as the public since not all members of the board are involved in the ad hoc committee uh this committee met on December the 7th we had 30 members present Dr Ivory who served as our consultant facilitator for these meetings suggested that the participants focus on issues that the middle and high schools will possibly face over the short term by that we mean 201617 and 2017 18 the participants broke into smaller groups for purposes of brainstorming and then consolidating the key points within each group during their group presentations to the entire committee the following issues surfaced find new ways to expedite Food Services during the lunch periods in light of anticipated crowded lunches uh we learn that one of the lunch periods at the middle school is already having difficulties due to
057the number of students in the seventh grade we also suggested or the committee also suggested that they consider various options for transporting uh of students to and from school uh and finally uh they maximize to consider ways to maximize the use of traditional instructional areas and also explore a more flexible use of other spaces for instructional purposes keep in mind these recommendations are shortterm and we would anticipate that our uh district and building level management will deal with those problems in a successful fashion uh the ad hoc committee uh which I said consisted of 30 members at the last meeting will be meeting with the larger student growth committee starting in January uh and those meetings will then continue on the second Monday of each month uh the steering committee which is much much smaller
058we met on December the 14th and the uh which was just this week the role of the smaller committee is to take care of organizational aspects and planning for those ad hoc committee meetings uh we consulted with Dr Ivory over uh the phone he was not able to attend the meeting and we arrived at the following uh decisions uh the meeting in January should provide all members of the student growth advisory committee with current and anticipated enrollments as well as an overview of our current facilities and Transportation uh this uh larger committee will consist of approximately 110 to 120 people each member will receive enrollment data demographers projections and other relevant information in advance of the meeting since this will be the first time that this larger committee will be meeting it is important that
059everyone understand the data and come prepared for questions the agenda plan for the meeting in February uh will focus on uh small group brainstorming activities to develop uh various scenarios uh for what may be needed in the district uh when we have increased by an anticipated 1,000 students or more by the year 2020 uh I might mention that uh since the beginning of this year we've uh had an increase of almost 200 students alone and that has somewhat been reflective of the past four or five years uh we also finalized the uh list of people that are on this large student growth advisory committee we noted that we would like some additional uh parents or residents from the northern part of the township uh which is served by the Woodland and M Lake schools so
060if there are any people in the audience or anyone that might watch this uh on on the Channel 28 if you are interested we suggest that you please contact uh Dr kak's office as soon as possible so that we can get your name on the list because we will be closing out the membership of that committee presently uh for the 110 uh 10 to 120 people that we have on the committee uh it breaks down as follows 46% of the committee is made up of parents 18% is made up of senior citizens 133% are teachers 4% is municipal government 8% % is District administration and the remaining 11% are made up of a few board members some students and a few uh adults that are not parents in the district they live in the district
061but they do not have children attending the school I would also like to add that it was decided that going forward uh since Jill Deo has been on the steering committee all along and will continue to do that that she will be providing the reports at the monthly meetings uh to keep the uh board as well as the public uh informed uh so that concludes that report we will now go to our first public forum uh I will remind you that anyone coming to the microphone you are restricted to speaking to items that are on the agenda please state your name and your address if you have a group affiliation please include that as well and you are restricted to three minutes or less seven cure taxpayer uh concerning the agenda on uh enrollment for
062special ed I see 50 children from our district four from Jamesburg 27 schools now I can understand that there are schools that have certain Specialties that the students need but in reality 27 schools sounds like an awful lot and to go along with this what is the cost for transportation that's something you'll hit after my 3 minutes are up uh page [Applause] 15 uh under e where you said there's 124 projects a 5year period should cost about 7,997 I perfor I uh prepared um a report which I'll give later on on the Abbott decision and not only is it my commentary but I broke down the reports from the education Law Center who brought all of them and to show how it um affects us and our taxes and not only is it my commentary
063but it's stuff that uh people can go into snoops and check um this is from the people that brought the original um Abbot versus Burke decisions and that's what's affecting all the funding in our schools um I'll go over that later on I I'm under three minutes for the first time in my life and and uh at the second open meeting then I'll go over the other stuff that's in that report um Mike has the reports that I made that I am hoping he'll distribute so everybody will see he gave it already good thank you thank you Mr clle respond to the special yeah sure okay Dr kak wants to make a response okay um in regard to the special ed schools uh there's a number of things you have to take into consideration uh
064we might only have one student go to a particular School uh here or there and when you look at 50 students compared to 6,500 it's a very very small percentage of students that we have at a district especially compared to other other uh school districts the other thing is the transportation and the tuition well sometimes there's tuition sometimes it's a uh public offering uh but it's it is expensive uh it is a driving cost for many many school districts throughout the state however we take advantage of jintur such as the middle sex um Regional executive um school council to uh share cost uh as far as Transportation so if they pick up one student from our district excuse me they may pick up students from other districts and we all share the cost on that
065uh we do try to provide the best service for these uh children um in the most uh economical way possible um but the the decision on what school they go to is a joint decision made by parents and Educators on the best uh on what is the be what will be the best fit for the needs of the child again it's a very small percentage it is expensive um I think everyone acknowledges that but compared to a lot of schools it is very low so we try to do as much of that inhouse and we do have special programs inhouse as we can and we reserve the students being sent to an Adda District school as somewhat of a last resort after we have exhausted all the other uh possibilities in District can we get
066extra funding from the state to that uh we do and not to engage in an ongoing discussion I'll just stop with that but yes we do there's the the the state does provide different extraordinary aid for cost that goes over a certain amount and there's a lot of different formulas on that so we're on top of all the different ways that we can uh even through uh Medicaid reimbursement I mean every single way possible that we can get any kind of reimbursement we take advantage of uh for with that thank you sure anyone else from the public Robert roach team your field Boulevard um staying with that same subject matter I see that the Jamesburg is listed on the same schedule with having four students it's my understanding from some time ago that we do
067not pay for the Jamesburg students is that correct Mr Bo yes go ahead evening Mr Ro that's absolutely correct those tuition contracts go to the Jamesburg board of education however as those students are enrolled in our high school we get the approval for the added District placement so that's why they're included on the schedule because of the approval process that we had yes sir okay thank you very much by the way just one last thing I would like to thank very much uh Mr proso and Mr poy for their their great work and effort and their three years on the board thank you anyone else anyone else from the audience for questions or comments on the agenda okay seeing no movement I will enclose that uh part of our agenda and move on to the
068superintendent's report and recommendations Dr kak thank you Mr President uh before we go into the uh agenda I would just like to highlight a couple areas for the uh for the board the first is uh project unify which is under board action item H page 13 that is a pilot program and it's Grant funded uh and it involves and Dr aloc will help me on this uh our students our students working with students uh involved in Special Olympics okay um the it's um well this program will only continue if the grant funds can be procured otherwise we'll have to go through the curriculum committee as an approval for a new club the yes you know how much that cost that program well it's Grant funded so it's not costing the district anything but it's the
069the cost is I have that is $4,500 that's the grant that's the that's the am of the grant I'm sorry it's $4,500 Mr armeno actually on that matter I had a note to myself um so the for the first year it's Grant funded and we don't have to have we don't have to do matching funds on that I think I asked that already right and then and so the and you answered the question the amount of the award is 4500 and that will be a review next year first of all if it's successful and secondly the cost if we don't get a grant yes and is it is it anticipated that assuming if we don't get a grant next year the cost will be around 4500 every year absolutely the cost would depend on the
070activities planned through through project UniFi it's a program for our special needs students to work with general education students um some of the activities may include bowling um some social activities some some activities inhouse um and and that's we talked about it through the curriculum committee about what what are some of the activities that would be planned um basketball track and field uh the grant was received from the Special Olympics um so that's who's funding the program this year the Grant from Special Olympics can cover any of our activities um any of the uh transportation to and from the activities it can also um cover the cost of any stipend to a staff member but as we always do the first year there is no stien for the staff member staff members doing it voluntarily
071and don't we have a program I mean I went to a program last year for buddies Buddy Buddy Buddy ball buddy Ball but that was limited to just not that many special needs children right because that was a smaller group correct so now is that going to be incorporated into this or this is something no this is something in addition mhm okay will there be a more special needs students able to get into this program yes it expands the attendance yes okay thank you [Music] uh item K under board action is the um middle sex County Regional Educational Service uh Services Commission they're basically uh that is a school within middle sex County and there are Representatives on their board from every school district in the uh County uh there are superintendents on the board
072as well or board members so up until now Mr has been our representative and uh since his term is ending this month uh on the board at middle sex um it has come up they look for a resolution to approve a new representative I've offered my services as to to be the the uh District representative because the meetings go from 8:30 a.m. till 10: which is immediately preceding my Roundtable meeting my County Roundtable meeting which is in the same location the same building in Piscataway however if any board member would like to um be the representative you know it's up to you but it's up it's the board's prerogative on that um I I think that's a great idea that you'd be willing to do that but I I I would love to have the
073experience of Mr Braverman if possible on there would you be willing to do that uh Marv 8:30 in the morning in Piscataway sure we'll hire a car would you be willing to because I mean I think it's I mean it's it's tough you you have a full plate we all know that and and we appreciate you stepping up but if you know in the past I think we've always had a member of the board on there um and obviously uh the people that work uh outside the home uh obviously can't do this but that's why I immediately thought of Mr Braverman unless someone else is uh is willing to step up but okay uh we'll need a motion to that effect I make a motion to uh nominate Mr yes goad make the motion Marvin
074Braverman as our representative to the MCC uh representative team second okay um any questions or comments I do have a question uh Mr Braverman were you asked previously about doing this because in in in my doing it I have found that I I often because of the traffic that that you experience in trying to get from Monroe up there I'm having to leave at about 7:30 in the morning just to get there in time for the meeting uh just to make you aware that it's not often an easy trip to do I don't know if the board knows this but at one time I was president of the State Association of Educational Services Commissions I was also president of the mo mescom for three years and served on that board many more times yeah I'd
075look forward to it probably nobody left that I know I I just wanted to make sure you were comfortable with it since uh professional driver okay all right should we ask Mr bran if he wants to attend tomorrow or I mean I was planning on doing a thank you okay okay then uh roll call vote Mr Gorski Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr daresi Iain Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes to the appointment no to the car good move the record that was not a part of the motion M tono yes Mr notin yes Mr proso yes Mr Ryback yes Mr uh yes congratulations Mr Braverman motion passes do we have to re that's going to be uh on the it's in the agenda already so when I get to the board action just
076we'll just have to exclude that then okay have to that yes yeah and uh just quickly before I ask for a recommendation for for um motions to be approved I just wanted to to bring to your attention you receive uh reports uh from the Well from me as a superintendent report but they're comprised of uh information from all the different schools and just a couple highlights there was the Harlem Wizards were brought into a few of the schools to great success um we had we have stem challenges going on in all of our schools it's part of our overall stem initiative and some really exciting things going on uh in the schools and a number of the in the principal reports you see some pictures and some things going on there we had a Chef
077Joseph RI rayola who is a winner from the Food Network show Chopped and he visited the middle school and I chopped his name up I'm sure but uh that went over very well um the robotics competition that was mentioned earlier hosted at the at our high school last Saturday uh was uh I thought not only run very was it R it ran very well but the students uh it was great seeing the students involved in that uh what they were doing uh a good good you're a good man Charlie Brown at the middle school last about a week ago on Friday night I attended that and again very nice production there was a toy collection to benefit Joey's little angels um Miss Sherman organized the collection of food and Vol she's one of our Tech
078Representatives organized the collection of food and volunteers to feed the less fortunate on Thanksgiving day they gave their time uh and resources and our teachers and Educational Service professionals who recognized today our teachers of the year and Educational Service Professionals of the year and if you go on our district Facebook page uh all but one is listed uh one person uh well there were some absences in one of our schools so we couldn't we couldn't name that person but uh tomorrow morning uh at the uh at the middle school I'll be there in the morning along with M Chanley to uh nominate the person uh should they in school um but if you want to see who the people are they were they are on our uh Facebook page with that um Mr President and
079the board I would like to recommend under Personnel items a through S for approval okay any questions or comments Mr nin I'm just looking at the agenda and just correct me if I'm wrong this includes the uh Personnel committee's recommendations for the salary adjustments is that what we're voting on right now uh or is that under board I believe that's under in the business section no it might be under here it is it is in the Personnel report is that that's what we're voting on right now okay great um I have a question with regards to these pay raises I know it went through the Personnel committee unanimously I did some of the calculations and um basically some of the numbers work out to be uh anywhere from uh 6% up to 11% pay raises
080um based on their salaries and just throwing a $44,000 uh increase on top of that I'm just a concerned I'm concerned that that's an awful it's a large amount of a salary increase and I I just don't know how well that's going to sit with other people namely the teachers that got like a 2.5% that's one of my concerns my second concern is is there going to be a step guide made up so that going forward we don't run into this situation where we just have to throw a pay raise arbitrary pay raise at somebody well Mr President yes uh Mr noin this was discussed at length at the uh Personnel committee meeting which I know you're not a member of that committee um so I'll be happy to share with you some of the
081non-confidential items that were brought up we have here currently uh eight members of the tech staff who have a base starting salary of $36,000 that salary was tied two decades ago to the starting salary in the teachers guide as you probably know the teachers guide um increases uh with percentage increases each contractual period and that also extends to every step including the entry level step the tech staff are non- affiliated positions and that $36,000 figure for a 12month tech person has never been adjusted in the last two decades so so Mr Washington the director of the committee presented me with a problem that three of his very valuable staff members including one with specialty in Apple products were were offered significantly higher positions in other districts municipalities upwards of 1520 ,000 two have left creating
082a hardship on the department one was loyal enough to stay this is not a raise that is presented before you tonight this is a base salary adjustment to properly align the base starting salary for the tech staff and all those who were employed under it to a reasonable Market condition figure which still Compares disadvantage disadvantageously to other school districts so whereas I I respect your uh comment about the percentage this is not an increase it's a base salary adjustment it's something that should have been done more periodically but was somehow overlooked um as far as a guide is concerned we talked about that at the committee and Mr Washington felt that a guide would restrict his ability um for placement of Staff particularly those with uh a lot of seniority and uh due to the
083flexibility that he needed and the deployment of Staff with unique Specialties which is not unusual for non-affiliated staff members who are not in a homogeneous group it was Mr Washington's recom recommendation and I supported him not to have a guide in that area um obviously we must have looked at other districts I imagine in this uh search and that's how we come up with this number in that looking at other districts did we uh notice or not if they had a step guide when they were when we were going through through this some did have a step guide many did not and the ones that we followed uh on these percentage increases did they typically have a step guide or not or paron repeat the question that the uh numbers that we're basing our increases
084on did those are th do we base them on the districts that typically had a step guide very conservatively yes that is correct we still compare um with a disadvantage to the districts that do have a step guide our our our salary is low in these areas um this is a reasonable adjustment to to lift all the boats that have been affected by a low starting salary increase uh Which is less than a custodian in the district for 12-month Tech person thank you any other questions or comments this is items a through S of the Personnel part of the agenda okay Mr G roll call please M armeno yes Mr Braverman Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes to all recuse on o what a recuse on O So noted Mrs Co Pano
085yes Mr noin yes Mr proso yes on everything but no on o no on oh so noted Mr Rybeck yes Mr poy yes Mr board president Personnel items a through S has passed and uh on board action recommend items a through n excluding K which was already voted on so a through n I'm recommending for approval so move second Mr Ryback first Mrs K Pano second I didn't hear you speak so moved second okay do we have any questions or comments this is items a through n of board action with the exception of K with the exception of K all right Mr Gorski roll call please Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski I abstain with the exception of items h l and m I vote Yes HL and M which are a yes
086thank you very much sir Mr too yes Mr calman yes they all recuse on G thank you sir Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr Ryback yes and Mr Po yes Mr board president board action items a through n with the exception of K passes thank you and we'll proceed to your report Mr Gorski thank you Mr Bo Pres president um as a point of correction to an assertion made at the last meeting I have a brief PowerPoint presentation that I would like to show it's very brief and this pertains to the tax payment schedule and the collection of those monies required by Statute a large portion of the revenues of the district are tax payments which are collected by the municipality the statute requires that the first two payments be
087collected uh by an August date and that's driven by njsa 54475 which in summary requires that the municipality shall pay over to the board secretary within 45 days after the beginning of the school year 20% of the monies from the school tax due forgive me um the next slide shows the first two payments which come within that 45 day window which are the payments that we' received on July oops beg your pardon July 10th and ju and August 7th dat total 22,170 564 those are the payments that were received within the first 45 days of this school year the total District tax ta per the tax Schedule which was adopted by the board is 102 m172 68 and as I mentioned that's general fund taxes and Debt Service Levy taxes 20% of that figure is2
088m4345 which uh the difference is excess payment received on behalf of the district above the statutory requirement of $1,737 th000 $40 which was deposited as required by law in the tax manage uh the cash management savings account earning interest and we received a legal opinion that after a complete review of the statute and and understanding the schedule of the tax revenues which was approved by the board of education for the 15 16 school year uh our attorney confirmed that the business office offic is in full compliance with legal requirements governing the payment by a Municipality of school Monies to the Board of Education thank you very much Mr board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through M be approved by consent roll call
089moved second thank you any questions or comments armeno um this the student achievement data agreement is in this right Mr Gorski yes ma'am okay just um I think we just had some discussion about can you just explain a little bit about private information and time frame for analysis I would like to defer that question to Dr kak Who investigated it yeah absolutely thank you so the uh there's two things there that you brought up one is the data privacy and the contract the hosting service agreement and I just reviewed this with the curriculum committee uh specifically addresses that area and basically it is that the district owns the data which is very very important and that there are uh reasonable um uh firewalls and and other things in place to protect the student data uh
090also the that all student information provided to Performance Matters by customer shall remain the property of the customer performance matters will not use such uh student information but for any purpose other than providing services and support to customer and will not use any student information to the detriment of the customer performance matters will not sell assign lease disclose to third parties other than what is allowed in section B and section B basically talks about they will only do so under the penalty of law if they are required by a um uh you know by a court or a judge that's the only time they would do that or commercially exploit any portion of the uh student information upon termination of this agreement performance matter shall return to customer all student information provided by the customer
091in a usable electronic form and will erase destroy and render unreadable all such student information formally stored on performance matters servers okay so that's the security and and our tech department reviews every piece of software that contains student data they come in and review all that to protect uh to make sure that our student data is well protected and uh kept confidential the second part of your question I believe has to do with the uh the benefit maybe if yes okay thank you the um you know I learned a long time ago uh from very smart wise uh wiser older people than than I was when I was a teenager in my 20s trying to fix a c or something around the house that if I didn't have the right tools it's that much harder
092to complete that job basically this will provide us the district with the correct tool to be able to look at and disaggregate and aggregate student data to look where the gaps are in either an instruction uh or learning and that's very important for us it'll also be one data entry point rather than sometimes there's redundancy where people teachers are entering the data in this are in in another area uh let alone you know talk about privacy where data is recorded paper and pencil and you know hopefully it's kept locked in a file but you know that's some things can happen so I feel a lot better knowing that the data would be in there uh this will allow us to look at our data from not only the state assessments but also our local assessments
093our benchmark assessments um and any other assessments it's a very powerful tool and it's only as good as we want it to be and you know it'll do whatever we ask uh highly successful school districts such as East Brunswick and South Brunswick have had conversations with people in both of those districts about you know that they have they like it they've been using it for several years and they the teachers and administrators absolutely love using it uh so I think we'll find a great benefit thank you for the district okay ELO two questions there would it matter if we use a number instead of Student's name we discussed that in the curriculum committee and because the data is protected uh I want a name on that I don't want to be teaching numbers we don't
094teach numbers we teach students so when we're discussing how a child is doing and that child could be a junior or senior I still use the term child or student or young adult uh when we're discussing uh how we can help that child I want to put a name to that data I want to put a face to that data so that we know so we it's a constant reminder to us that we're talking about kids here we're talking about real people not just manipulating data one way or the other so it's very important to me that we use a name yes we have student ID numbers yes we can hide the names we can do all that um but it's it's important when we break out our data into Data teams and that's something
095that as a leadership team with all the principles and supervisors we're starting to do more and more and I've encouraged uh as Dr ALU has uh our principles to to have the data teams in their schools when they're looking at that data it's very powerful when you're talking about a particular student and saying this student seems to be struggling in this area let's all talk how can we help this this student and then teachers in different subject areas all look at that so that's why I want the student names there but my concern would be since data never leaves it's always there will they be identifying the special needs children um only as much as every other data that we use that identifies special needs when it's confidential we talk about the special needs students
096and and when we when we we have to you know discuss that they're special needs when we're talking about the type of accommodations they need and making sure they we ensure that they get the the right services so um we look at all the data and there's all of our software I mean it's all coded so it's not publicly available but that is protected but in confidential inside when we're discussing that uh that's absolutely important for us to know if that's student has a a specific learning disability that we need to be aware of thank you sure any other questions or comments all right then Mr Gorski we are looking at items a through M roll call vote please yes sir Miss armeno yes Mr pman yes Mr zareski I abstain with the exception of
097items a 1 through 3 d g l and N I would vote thank you sir Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes to ores on M cu's on M and Michael y thank you Mrs kapano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes and Mr Po yes Mr board president board action items a through M passes that concludes my report thank you very much uh we now move to uh the president's report uh since this is my last uh meeting uh as the board president uh there are a few things I would like to say first of all I I did not do this last month uh but I would like to thank all of those people who supported me in my campaign those who voted for me those who put uh signs up
098allowed me to put signs up on their property uh and I really do appreciate uh that support uh I I do see that our newly elected board members are here tonight uh Frank Russo if you don't mind standing up for just a second and Don Dawn Corina I think she's right there okay those are our new board members I'd like to congratulate you and uh they will be installed at the organizational meeting on January the 4th uh I thought it would be appropriate since we are at the end of a calendar year uh if I uh highlighted some of the accomplishments that we have achieved this past year some of these you probably you may have already heard tonight but I put this list together independently of either Mr Gorski or Mr kak uh as
099Mr Gorski had mentioned though uh we did refund our bonds and this is going to result in a savings of about $3.9 million over the life of those bonds and I understand that that will translate into about $250,000 a year if I'm not mistaken that's correct uh we did in the financially failing Mecca program which was uh draining money from us uh they were not able to pay back the loan or meet their existing costs uh and now we are able to accommodate more children in an extended kindergarten program uh which will provide a better start for all of those kids uh more kids than we've ever been able to accommodate before uh we also ended our uh privately operated Basque program that's the before and after school program and we've replaced it with our
100own uh board operated Falcon CARE program and in the years to come this will not only repay uh the loans that were given out for Mecca but it will also bring Revenue into our budget and we're always looking for additional sources of re Revenue Beyond uh our local taxpayer uh something that I think we should really be proud of is the fact that we were able to renovate during the course of the summer we were able to renovate the Middle School uh and we did that out of the regular operating budget uh we didn't have to go out for any loans uh which is great and we were able to provide 11 additional classrooms for that very crowded building uh and I think that was a very uh terrific accomplishment that we could do all
101of those things in such short time and without having to go out and borrow money uh we did uh approve and successfully implement the redistricting plan according to the recommendations of the demographer study and this has created a better a better balance among our K among our K to5 schools uh I know it was an unpopular thing uh the board did not choose to do this the state did and the board was by law obligated to support it and we did have a relatively smooth administration of Park uh planning for this for several years in the making uh this board made sure that our facilities our computer hardware software uh and uh our students would be ready uh with a minimum amount of glitches and I think uh we will hear on in January from
102Dr alvic uh the results of that that first Administration uh we did approve a three-year iPad lease as part of our onetoone technology initiative uh but we got a commitment from the district that it will prepare our teachers to be comfortable with other Platforms in the future in in case we find that other platforms are uh less expensive but comparable to the iPad um and after six months of intensive search and I do mean intensive search uh we had meetings after meetings after meetings uh looking for a new superintendent and we successfully appointed Dr kak over here Dr kak joined us at the beginning of July and has been with us since and uh from all the reports and things that I'm hearing uh seems to be uh things seem to be going well and
103he's adjusting well to our community uh with careful planning we have the ad hoc committee and the student growth committee which uh have started to do some work and will continue to work throughout the uh coming January through May uh and that is they're trying to find recommendations and ideas that they can suggest to the board of education for how we're going to handle our student population four to five years from now as I indicated earlier since the beginning of this year the first 11 months of this year we've added 186 students and we've been adding about 200 students every year in the past and it looks as if we we will continue to do that going forward uh the qac there was an item in tonight's agenda about the qack uh in case you're
104not familiar with that uh this is a tool used by the state of New Jersey to make sure that uh well basically to evaluate how each district is performing in five different components uh instruction and program fiscal management governing personnel and operations and we scored high enough on the qac report that uh we are in a position to apply for a waiver so that we do not do not have to go through a full three-year uh a full review in another three years and I'm very very pleased to say that we were only one of four districts in the county of middlex uh to uh fall into that category the other districts interestingly enough are our neighbors East Brunswick South Brunswick and Spotswood so I think we join a very uh Elite group of uh
105school districts in uh showing that we are performing in all components at a very high level of performance uh and as you heard uh earlier tonight we continue to receive very favorable audits of our business operations I want to commend Mr Gorski ever since I've uh been working with him for the past three years he continually looks for ways to save money to renegotiate contracts to uh negotiate uh our cost of health benefits uh he works with us on negotiating the contracts with our various uh unions uh and his assistance and his expertise is really invaluable to this District uh at the board's urging uh and this largely probably came about through our interviews during the interview process for the superintendent I think it became clear that the board was very concerned with improving Communications
106uh for all the uh constituents of the community and I applaud Dr kak's efforts already to do that uh he has uh gone out to social media and any member of this community that wants it can either be updated via their phone I believe uh as well as their uh iPads or any other technological devices by simply getting connected to it once you're connected you'll always receive the information you'll be getting electronic newslet newsletters and notices keeping you a breast of what's going on in the district I believe uh there's also a a system in place that one of the board members suggested and I forgot who and I apologize for that so that if people had questions about the upcoming budget development that they could uh they could send those questions in uh and
107that information I believe is available on our website uh so that is another new component in our efforts to better communicate uh not only to the community but for the community to communicate with us uh it was mentioned tonight that we are presently uh conducting a review of our special ed services uh the PO the purpose of that and bringing in an outsider is just basically to validate what our own self-study May uncover uh we're looking for areas where we might make improvements in delivery of services as well as any costs cost-saving measures that might be considered and finally I I believe of course uh uh maybe this is a little boastful on my part but uh I think that we have had a much better working relationship uh during the current year among the
108members of the board uh I've heard members of the public say that I've heard some of the board members say it I've heard administrators say it so I think we should all give ourselves a pat on the back for uh working together so well um going forward I do want to thank Mr proso and Mr zareski for their services over the past three years uh all the time and energy and effort that you've given to that and uh finally uh my parting words is that I would encourage the board to be mindful of the district goals and the board goals that we set back in September uh we have three District goals we have three board goals uh I was looking at them again the other day and I think we're making some pretty good
109progress there but you do need to uh be mindful look at those from time to time uh get an update from the superintendent in terms of the district goals from time to time and I think Dr kak said he's January going okay going to do this in January uh this way when we uh arrive at the end of June uh we are prepared to uh say how well we've done in terms of Meeting those goals uh being a member of the board of education is indeed a privilege but it's also a huge responsibility it requires a commitment and a willingness to listen to All Points of View before making a decision I personally enjoyed my work on the board and I trust that our new members will do likewise and for that I thank you
110and that concludes my report [Applause] uh uh let's see we are now ready I believe to go to our second public forum the board business oh there's other oh other board oh did it again okay do we have any other board business Miss armenio I just I just like to make a comment um I would I would hope that we could um in in its entirety in verbatim I would make a special request that uh president Po's remarks would be included in the minutes I thought they were profound and very good and I'd like going forward I'd like to constantly refer to them so I thank you for that and I would also like to thank you for your service and dedicated service at that and and you've been an intelligent and able leader you've
111brought theorum and Clarity and conis information to the board and to the public and I know that your continued interest in the community will ensure your participation and I look forward to um always always meeting you publicly and privately and and being very very grateful for your service so I I appreciate your leadership and it's been an honor thank you and and the community has been well sered thank you Mr K panovich as a board of education member for couple of years or so um I've had the opportunity to work with many board members over the past years um it's been easy it's been hard it's been disagreements there have been conflicts there have been good friendships made um I can say that as a board member I have personally learned something from every member
112of the board that I've had through my years of experience on the board and I'd like to thank you Mr Mr poy Mr proso Mr zareski for the time and the effort you have given us over the past three years it's not always an easy thing to be on the board of education I think people when they're sitting on the other side of the table have a different perspective when you get over here things have changed so um your service to the to the all the children in Monroe Township has been um greatly appreciated not just by me but by I know the members of the public and I just like to thank Mr zarett I um when I was the board president your leadership had helped me become a better leader because I know
113if I was looking for something or if I wasn't sure I know that I could count on you haven't been in the same position so I'd like to thank you for that any other Mr Ryback I just couldn't let the evening go by without chiming in a little bit um first of all marf I'd like to congratulate you on your reelection and Anthony and and Rob thank you so much for your service Doug um I guess your years of experience in education your professionalism and your honesty have not only earned the respect of everyone on the board but this community as well uh it's been an honor to serve with you on the board an honor to have you as our president and a special honor for me to be able to call you colleague
114thank you [Applause] you Mr Coffman so it wouldn't be December without me asking my favorite December question um since Doug I know you're leaving I'm I'm guessing you're not going to be seeking the presidency well because you won't be here so I was just curious to know who from the board is intending to run for president at the reorg meeting other than Anthony Tom Michelle Steve okay oh and by the way um echoing what everybody else said about you Doug um it it's not an easy thing being a a first or or or oneye first one-year term board event member uh coming in from really not knowing what this gig is all about to really trying to step up to the plate and taking the leads uh because there's really no really good training for
115this job it's kind of like uh you know you thrown into this gig and you kind of have to figure it out as you go uh certainly the board has had a lot of challenges over the years and you know good B and different you kind of have to inherit what you're you're given uh so as everybody else said you know thank you for your leadership this year and uh uh you did a really good job considering uh you know the amount of time that you had on the board because a lot of people have had that board presidency job after they've been on for multiple terms because you kind of have to know all the nuances cuz again you don't really know how to deal with the Press you don't really know how to
116deal with the public you don't really know how to see and manage all this stuff so you know good job thank you Luke okay any other board business Mr armeno I I just want to say that I attended the um robotics um on Saturday and it was wonderful and exciting to see uh the engagement of the children and it it I'm very pleased that we're involved in it and it was I think we talked about it as being just really um terrific that we're going for with things like that and specifically U Mr presio so thank you for your service and your passion and it was nice working with you Mr seski also thank you for your service okay so we will now go to our second public session uh this is the first time
117we're doing this this way we're doing this before going into close session so that uh we don't uh detain while we're in close session and we do have one I see tonight so once again the rules are when you come to the microphone keep in mind uh three minutes state your name and your address okay your remark should be addressed to me and uh who would like to speak first Mr Gibbons um Doug I just like to add my support to the praise that uh you received from the from the superintendent yourself and Mr precioso was truly deserved uh it's kind of sad though on another note note that it wasn't too long ago that um Mr prosa was brought up on what I believe were trumped up ethics charges it seemed that it was
118never certain board members you know managed to do that it seemed it was never about the nature of the evidence just the seriousness of the charge and the reason I'm talking about this tonight is that once you go after someone's reputation it can be a very hard thing to get back and I think you know going forward with the board before this ever happens again uh the board should be very careful before they put somebody up on ethics charges because I don't think they they would deserve the Mr prosis case and by the way merry Christmas everybody thank you Mar Klein SE crenchaw again Doug fabulous job professional great I thank Anthony You did leave uh many many good things in Improvement to this District um Robert again thank you you know for representing Jamesburg
119and I know I left some oh Doug I said Doug I said you I said you okay this is what I want to get to um if you just read the newspaper North Brunswick had a referendum for $87 million to build two new schools uh their growth is within the last seven years 1,000 new students they expect a 5% growth for the next 5 years of the 87 million 7.3 million was coming from the state a few months ago it was announced that the state set aside $169 million to build a new High School in Perth Amboy evidently Perth Amboy didn't know anything about it because they have no plans for land or development or what have you but that's the state giving them money um I've seen grants in these other schools that are
120not Abbot districts for roofs classrooms Labs all paid for by the state we get nothing um I'm getting to the abbots but just to give you a note Newark receives it's Newark New Jersey receives as of two years ago $1 billion doll in state aid from the um State Department of Education and they're still failing now um I prepared this report uh Mike did you give it to all the members yes it yes okay what you see the first page is basically from the education law centers um website and you can see the way they brag about their quests and that's all at our expense and this breaks it down by years uh I originally thought that the Abbot versus Burke decisions were about five or six there were 20 and um you I would
121like you to read through it when you get a chance I show you my comments on the third page and then you're going to go into commentary from Wikipedia and when you read some of this it's exactly what we've said year after year and they come up with the same thing money does not educate children period cut and dry um on the second page of Wikipedia just below the first paragraph the part of the State Constitution that is the basis of the Abbot decisions required that or requires that the legis the legislature shall provide for the maintenance and support of a thorough and efficient system of free public schools for the instruction of all the children in the state between the ages of 5 and 18 as I've said for years state constitution section three
122paragraph 1 this is paragraph two the educ I'll be finished two seconds the education Law Center used that in one of their suits and that's why when I've been saying all along that we have to file suit and now you have many other districts in the same position we are their schools are overcrowded they're not getting enough money from the state and the taxpayers can't pay it um lastly I know I'm a little bit over how about we do this Mr Klein yeah uh we'll see if anyone else wants to speak and you can return for your concluding one page that I missed and then I'm done okay uh you'll see a listing right after my I guess it's right after my explanation this shows all of the Abbot decisions okay going back to 1985
123and it gives you a brief note as to what they were suing for so that's the 20 lastly 2015 they're requesting more money for construction of new schools we can't get anything to help us put up new schools and you'll see the waste it's here thank you very much for your time thanks for all of your reference for the years that you've been on the board okay anyone else all right we thank you for your comments Mr kleene and I say no one else so at this at this time I will read the Clos session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby goes to moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 to discuss the
124following subject harassment intimidation and bullying the following close session action may be following close session action action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exist 15 minutes time promise yes okay Dr kak estimates that we will be in close session for at most 15 minutes so uh but that essentially is our business for this evening if you want to St you can certainly stay uh but we're going to now go into closed session after we take a vote all right do I hear a motion second second okay all in favor I opposed okay then we'll go into close s we just correct the uh date of the uh organization meeting that it was mentioned that it was
125uh January 4th 6 January 6th it's January 6 yes thank you yes board will now resume with its public session I see no members of the audience uh plus their comments are restricted to anything that might have happened any acent might have taken place after coming out of Clos session and we're not taking any action tonight therefore I will announce that the next Board of Education meeting will be Wednesday January the 6th 700 p.m. here in Monroe Township High School I move that we adjourn this meeting second Happy New Year to all all in faor New Year happy H okay anyone opposed no opposition everybody have a good holiday and and a new year thank you very much I'm going to run to the