001and my friend Al lives and that's Ally That's Aly the special meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education August the 19th will now come to order uh Mr thorney would you mind leading Us in the pledge to the flag pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the repu for which it stands one nation God indivis andice for all roll call Mr Gorski miss armenio here Mr Braverman here Mr Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs colano here Mr noin here Mr proso yes here Mr P here Mr Ryback here Mr zareski Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you Mr Gorski uh in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of
002this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted August the 14th 2015 at all schools the home News Tribune the Asbury Park Press and file with the clerk of the municipality at this time we're going to move to our first public forum please keep in mind that any remarks or comments or questions should pertain to whatever is on uh tonight's agenda you are also uh if you come to the microphone please state your name and address and if you have any group affiliation to include that as well and we would appreciate your uh keeping your remarks questions statements to uh so that there are three minutes or less in duration and all comments questions Etc are to be directed to the president of the board and I believe that's it
003so do we have anyone at this time that would like to uh address a question or concern with our agenda Robert roach J te mfield Boulevard and I'm involved with Monro citizens for responsible government I guess that's a new thing we start to have to do now huh giving group affiliations but anyhow uh what I would like to uh just ask the board in their deliberations on their budget philosophy that they remember that they really have two responsibilities one to determine a budgets that's necessary to provide a quality education for the students but also to consider the the burden on the taxpayers for the uh the taxes that the the taxpayers will have to incur in that uh in their philosophy uh decisions thank you very much thank you Mr roach any other members of
004the public okay seeing no one else I will then close the first public forum and we will now engage in a discussion on budget philosophy Dr kak one okay well good afternoon thank you Mr President and uh hello again to the uh Board of Education and to our members in the uh in the audience I would ask that uh before we begin the budget philosophy the discussion of the budget philosophy that we can we remember that this is a uh it's a critical initial stage of the budget process this is the the very beginning of a process that really spans from August through March or April of next year and there's a lot of work that the the Mr Gorski myself Dr alvic and the rest of the leadership team uh has cut out for
005us that's basically to look at the programs to to be able to evaluate to be able to determine the programs that are most educationally sound for our students and to look certainly look for areas to where we can contain or reduce cost the um there are during this budget philosophy there will be mention of really provision of resources for our students and not to steal Miss gski Thunder but I know there will be mention of our growing enrollment being the newest member here uh I can only rely on the history and the information and the data that I I have available to me but it seems as though the enrollment uh over the last maybe six or seven years has grown to the point where we could really almost outfit an entire new school there's
006I believe 13 or 1,700 new students just over the course of six or seven years and based on that information and the information that we have going forward that I asked the board to consider all of that information that data as well as uh looking at the uh our workable resources and the challenges that the district faces uh particularly or specifically related to student growth in your consideration of this budget philosophy and trust that I and uh Mr Gorski and Dr Alit uh along with the entire leadership team will certainly take our direction from the Board of Education in how we develop our district goals and how we proceed to construct a budget that hopefully by the time we reach the um the stage where the budget is presented to the public next March or
007April that is agreeable to everyone on the board and in the community and at the same time meets the needs of our students and our future students thank you very much uh Mr President and if I could I will turn it back to you or turn it to turn it over to Mr Gorski Gorski thank you thank you Dr [Music] kak thanks good evening thanks for your attendance at this very important meeting that kicks off the budget process for the 167 school year um we'd like to begin with a PowerPoint presentation and then provide additional details along with it and I think you will notice a common theme developing throughout this presentation and that is um why the district spends in the manners that we have why the budgets have grown in the manners that
008they have the cause and effect from um the community and the student growth that we've experienced and are projected to continue to experience um and how that affects the budget uh this philosophy um presentation has been prepared through the collaboration of Dr kak Dr alvic myself Outreach to the principls vice principls supervisors directors teachers as many stakeholders as we could find in this process as well as numerous board members we would like to recognize the very integral contributions to this process by our members especially Mr Doug poy our board president Mr Tom noin board vice president Michelle armeno Marvin Braverman Jill Mayo Luke halman Kathy kapano who is the Finance chair committee person Anthony proso Steve Ryback and Rob zareski through a an opinion with our counselor many of the items throughout this budget are
009interwoven with the four items that Jamesburg is allowed to vote on per statute so Jamesburg according to the legal advice that was rendered does have a right to vote on this budget budget philosophy excuse me what is a budget philosophy the philosophy establishing the annual school budget should entail the creation of a framework for a budget that supports a democratic plan of appropriate funding for the implementation of educational programs so that students May develop and learn from quality experiences based on Ed educationally sound and fiscally prudent planning a solid Financial base is Paramount to assuring that the school district will be able to meet the responsibility of preparing our students for an increasingly competitive environment and the budget philosophy stage should be macro focused rather than micro focused as much more refinement will be required
010and implemented in the future through the rigorous budget process which you're going to see before you today is a very rough first blush look into what we have solicited from our principles Vice principles directors and supervisors understanding the new needs and mandates upon us for next year what drives a budget what is the DNA of any budget it is student enrollment and this graph shows District increases enrollment over the past s years in 200920 B pardon 200920 we had 5,500 students we are right now we have an excess of 6,600 students the projection was for 6628 at the end of the year I believe we're we're we're right at or past that now and the projection for next year's budget 16117 which we're here to to uh work on today is 6852 ladies and gentlemen
011that is a large District by student numbers and that is an incredible rate of growth 1,300 students over the past seven years that is two large elementary schools at capacity of additional students that we've had to educate over the past s years here's a chart comparing the 1516 by grade makeup of enrollment to 16117 we are projecting 224 new students for next year now the average student cost which I base Upon A certification of tuition cost from the state of New Jersey is approximately $155,000 these tuition rates vary by grade level preschools about 10,000 high schools about 16,000 and some of the special ed categories uh learning disabled multiple disabled autism range from 21 to 55,000 and it's not uncommon for an individual special education placement to cost an excess of $100,000 a year so
012that is a very conservative number at 15,000 20% % of our students have some classification requiring additional resources additional monies Beyond uh the mainstream on a conservative average this new student growth for 1617 will impact the budget by about $3.4 million that number is not included in our forthcoming appropriation list it is just for accent for this discussion now we're going to begin with the specific Appropriations that have come uh through the presentation from the principal supervisors directors VPS transportation and and and folks again I'm going to I'm repeat myself these are first blush request lists from the schools uh we have a very rigorous budget defense round where every one of these items is going to be compared with board goals District goals and and of course to make sure that it fits within
013the very constrict Ive State cap model which was designed to limit taxes and limit spending by districts it is not uh a large a Ford by the state at all for transportation it has been recommended that we have three additional 54 passenger buses with cameras and and um radios 297,000 325 passenger vans with cameras 190,000 two additional contracted drivers 78,000 total mandated and recommended Transportation cost 564 th000 two of the 54 passenger buses are required to be retired by state mandate at 15 years we have to get them off the road the other ones that you see there the the third one and the Vans um are in their latter years not requiring replacement yet but when you get a 54 passenger bus and it's on the road according to our tiered schedule which means
014it's running all day long um basically all year long they experience wear and particularly rust and we have a problem with a few of our buses that uh the rust is making them unsafe and the uh Financial commitment to make them safe is not worth it Michael please please hold all the questions let's get through it I think you'll get a general theme and then I'll be more than happy to entertain everything at the end Capital Improvements first you recall that terrible winter we had a couple years ago that caused the uh collapse of the pork store Mall which is near our Woodland School that also battered the Woodland School roof um beyond the structural engineers uh rating which occurred before that winter which was that it is safe and can continue uh on in
015its life this was in the budget last year and uh it was deferred because of the tight cap it could not fit and as a matter of priorities the $2 million that we interjected in last year's budget to address the Middle School growth by creating 11 additional classrooms within the school was more of a priority and uh the structural engineer said this roof can make it but it needs it needs replacement soon so that is a recommended budget priority for next year 1, 78,000 according to Mr T who is an invaluable asset in our facilities Department the mil Lake roof needs some metal work in order to um stop water leakage and prevent future problems which just exacerbate when you ignore a roof issue $54,000 we need some new facility Vehicles including two pickup trucks
016which cost about $100,000 total they're 1998 and a 2004 model with Incredible miles and these vehicles are used um rigorously and an item on here that's new is a a bus scraper Depot right now I would like to give you a little image of what our bus Cleaning Service is like at the dawn hours of a snow uh uh event here in the district all 65 vehicles have to be cleaned that requires overtime for all of the trans portation of facility staff members to come in to open up folding ladders on top of ice and snow in the in the near Darkness with brooms to clean the buses that has led to accidents workers compensation claims increase in insurance this bus scraper unit would allow a bus to drive under this device for $366,500 and
017clear the snow now as always we're looking for folks to share in this cost so we're reaching out to municipality and other school districts in the area so that they could use this and share the cost now let's talk about salaries and benefits we're a very labor intensive organization over 80% of the budget is salary and benefits we have four bargaining units here in the district mtea Teamsters principal supervisor central office support staff Association they are all in contract now the board of education has worked very diligently and cost effectively through these negotiations and the weighted average salary component of those negotiations is a 2.6% increase next year on $65 million of approximate salaries that's an addition to next year's budget of about $1.7 million that was not the only item that came out of
018negotiations the 2.6% there were givebacks and concessions that I'll talk to in a moment from a benefit standpoint the 1516 budget for insurance premiums was 2,471 1953 through very intense negotiations with our broker and myself we have had an elimination of the A4 sirar charge that Mrs kapano mentioned once before as finance committee chair that saves almost a half a million dollars of insance insurance premiums that was the latest Cherry to come out of negotiations with Horizon takes premiums down to just about 20 million through the fruit of negotiations all employees of this District are locked into tier 4 chapter 78 contributions which is the maximum level of contribution there are 13 districts that I'm aware of across through the state that have negotiated back on these mandatory contributions toward health insurance uh that would
019be fiscally fiscally impossible for us to consider with the very tight cap we have employees are paying over $3 million to reduce premiums up to 35% of their benefit cost in in many cases that takes net premiums down to about 17 million our broker anticipates an increase next year of 8% that's 1, 356,000 that 8% will probably be negotiated lower because um we have a special interest in in doing so however the state health benefits plan which was the state solution to health insurance cost increases is expecting increases in the 12 to 13 range again so we're significantly lower and we do a better job and our staff Bears a lot of the pain here and I emphasize that because we have staff members in this District in the majority who have not seen a
020net increase in their compensation over the last four or 5 years and I said a net basis because of all the contributions the additional ones for health the additional ones for pension curriculum Appropriations Dory would you like to run through these um generally so I worked very closely with the supervisors this past year and each Supervisor has a five-year plan for their curriculum and to revise and update their curriculum as we go through so many of these um items have come out of those those discussions that I've had with supervisors and with principles many of the these things have also been uh deferred from previous budgets because of the cap so these are all items that we are in need of understanding that we will go through the budget defense rounds as Mr Gorski said
021and make sure that we are um really looking closely at what we have and what we need and what the priorities are so one of the needs that we have um had in the district over the last few years is technology we've done a uh Mr uh Washington has done a fantastic job of getting the technology that we need for our testing and to make sure that our students are prepared with the technology um instruction that they have in their classrooms however one area that we really haven't focused on is the prek to2 area and that's where the um prek to2 Administration is kind of looking for uh some more some newer technology for the elementary schools one of the things that Mr Washington and I are looking at this year are several different Pilots
022throughout the district um using the technology budget one of them being Chromebooks and using them in a lower level lower level classrooms to see if those are appropriate and how we can use them um but that's one of the um needs that we're seeing in the district we do have some needs for some facilities um and uh equipment that we're using in our schools one of them being the industrial arts equipment maintenance uh we have many industrial art classes both at the middle middle school and high school and all of that equipment needs to be updated and maintained um and that is a Safety and Security issue for our students also as we're allowing them to use these devices and these tools in the classroom we want to make sure that they're safe um several
023needs for some of the sports bleachers for baseball in the cage turf fields there we have many more students involved in sports many more parents and community members come out to watch the sports so we need the space there um and the tennis courts need to be refurbished but again that's another thing that we're looking at for shared services um to try and and help that cost there just to elaborate on the tennis courts um we received an offer from the township because so many community members enjoy playing on the tennis courts uh for a contribution from potentially open space money that may be available for tennis court refurbishment these courts go back to 1979 the cost is 305,000 of which all or part may be picked up by the township and that's another example
024of all the collaboration that we've had had through uh the mayor's office and working particularly with Wayne Hamilton and then our pack is used a a lot through the community and through our schools the Middle School pack so there are some needs there for some updates and some maintenance um some of the clubs is increasing our careers awareness and our careers education at the middle school that so that would be one of the new programs also Al looking at our curriculum and our textbooks and what our needs are again each supervisor has a 5-year plan some of those things have already been deferred to the point where we have some textbooks that we are currently using in our district that we can no longer get replacements for because they are no longer in print so
025looking at options of where we can move for that so you're so that's where you're seeing some of those come in um also looking at um Health we we have an updated Health math was another one that we were looking at elementary math we over the past two years we have been looking at in we have improved the math uh series at the middle school because we've made it more common core aligned with the connected math we need to continue to do that the same at the elementary school our curriculum is common core aligned but the books that the resources they are using right now are not so so we do a lot of work with curriculum to make sure that we're meeting the common core and then as Mr Gorski pointed out with the
026increase of student enrollment there is an increase in Need for Staffing so that is this page and looking at Staffing um specifically at the middle school in high school be due to increased enrollment also looking at um one of our initiatives is the stem initiative the science technology engineering and math initiative that we're pushing forward with throughout the district um possibly getting a stem instructor there to help with some of our project-based learning that would go along with that initiative and some additional technology staff to help with all of the technology standards that we are using in our district also related to the impact from growth from over the years and from the fruit of the ad hoc committee for uh facilities and growth there were two recommendations from that ad hoc committee one was
027for redistricting which we have in place through the efforts of uh Dr alvic um Dr kak and many that's ready for this September We Believe and the next one is to begin planning for referendum um more information will be coming from the board president on that initiative but as part of planning for a referendum it is recommended to earmark in the budget some Appropriations for the various professionals that we're going to have to reach out to as part of this process including architect demographer financial advisor Bond counselor engineer and auditor the anticipated cost for that is $100,000 many cost as related to a bond referendum can be deferred until the project is approved um some cannot so let's take a look at a summary of the total appropriation increases Transportation construction and Facilities salary benefits
028both of which are contracted and mandatory transportations many of them are mandated from the state curriculum which is mainly based upon growth pre-referendum costs which is based on growth $7 million approximately of additional Appropriations are in our view right now and I'm going to say again this is raw unrefined information and has to go through the budget defense round because quite honestly we could not fit that amount anywhere in the cap let's talk about budget resource considerations for next year the bond referendum to construct this school is closed there are no remaining months funds to transfer against a Debt Service fund tax levy like we did last year in the previous years over a series of installments of $8 million of surplus from building the school efficiently all of that $8 million has been returned
029to taxpayers for monies that otherwise would have had been raised in The Debt Service fund to pay the mortgage payments here general fund state aid has been flat for the last two years and we expect the same level of funding next year I could say as an Administration we've done everything humanly possible to increase the amount of general fund state aid including writing our own in-house legislation which is still alive and before the Senate and assembly but it's got It's it's a long shot because of the the nature of politics so what can we do on our own well let's talk about proprietary funds we had a lease agreement to open up our facilities before to the Before and After School Care Network they paid us $100,000 a year that lease was not renewed due
030to an initiative to take that inhouse and to recognize revenues of about $300,000 as a revenue source and to run our own program called Falcon care a great deal of work and investment has gone into that program and that is also set to open this September another proprietary fund that we're working on is summer campies this was the recommendation of Mr Rybeck one of our board members and we are in the design stage through many efforts of Dr alvic to come up at summer campies and um these are anticipated to contribute to revenues in future years both Falcon care and summer campies are separate proprietary funds from the general fund budget and the board's philosophy has been number one once the Mecha loan is paid off that that retain earnings that remains in these funds
031could be used for tax relief or to supplant other wise monies that you would have to raise through the general fund budget which is permissible and finally the Jamesburg agreement uh is the fruit of many hours of the previous board and um that agreement affords that this year Jamesburg will budget for an appropriate number of students coming to Monroe at a tuition rate defined by the the state's budget program let's talk about the the last remaining Revenue source of material materiality and that's the cap and I would like to emphasize that when you are projecting what the cap will grow to next year it is a projection is an estimate and subject to change the formula begins with the last year prior year tax levy from the general fund the $92 M38 th000 you receive
032an automatic adjustment from the budget software for an enrollment um uh uh addition to Levy that's calculated based on trend line analysis from the state we cannot have access to that and not cannot predict what that number is but we'll use something similar to last year 663 th000 which is a fraction of the 3.4 million of cost that I identified before that comes up with your base then it's adjusted and increase by 2% to 94,3 1,000 then there's another optional adjustment for health care cost that the district is eligible for again that's an estimate last year was in a range of 250,000 and that's compared to how well you're doing compared to the state health benefits plan and you get an adjustment for that and that's all based upon the state's everchanging budget guidelines so
033our cap can grow in the general fund to only $95 m817 compared to last year that's an increase of 2,772 432 that is a very conservative amount of growth for a district this size with with what you're anticipating for Capital needs new student needs and uh mandates from the state and special ed spending so your Appropriations total $6,995 one, and your revenues can grow approximately $2.7 million Appropriations in excessive revenues are projected right now at 4.2 million this will require programs and services to be reviewed to maximize efficiencies in order to even balance the budget I can't underemphasize the amount of work that goes into the budget process the budget defense rounds um the evaluation of existing programs as well as those requested for next year to meet the needs of students with the resources
034we have let's talk about taxes next ratables are the most significant variable in determining the tax rate preliminary reports are that ratable growth will be slightly higher than the preceding year 1516 which increased by over 2% this will very favorably impact rates for 16117 that is very good news the more people who share in the tax levy the lower everybody's rate how does Monroe compare for taxes with all the other communities in in the county um you know we had a reevaluation there's a lot of pain being expressed a lot of people are getting a re-evaluation up to numbers that they probably should have been valued at over the last 15 20 years so of course there's an inherent injust with that but Monroe and and this comes directly from the state's website this is
035an average property tax assessment that includes Municipal and School Monroe is $672 which was actually a decrease from 2013 of of 1.8% and what I want you to understand from this is that Monro is in the bottom percentile for average property taxation in the county many of the districts that are even below us receive an incredible amount of state aid which offsets the tax levy with the with the IM with the immaterial amount of state aid that we receive we are still in the bottom 20% South Brunswick for example is over a 20 million of of uh of of Aid type that we don't have and um New Brunswick I'd have to get my calculator so let's talk about our accomplishments that we achieved uh with the use of those critical tax dollars doctor okay
036so since I wasn't able to be here for the budget meeting because I was sick I'm happy that I'm able to present the slide again um about our accomplishments and what we done so I did update the information for you from the budget presentation uh last year because we have our graduation rate for the students that just graduated in June we were up to 98.5% of our students this year who graduated which is a great um great thing for for all of our high school staff absolutely um our June 2015 graduates um 86% of them will attend either a two or a four-year college so again that's an increase from the student from the the rate last year we you have 3% attending career in technical schools 2% entered the military 5% are entering the
037workforce and 4% are undecided or non-g grads uh we are continuing to enroll our students this year they're finalizing the schedules at the high school but we are almost over 700 students this year who will be enrolled in our AP courses and our average scores on the SAT and the ACT are again higher than average they actually increase this year even more so than last year remember for all of our AP courses all of our students are required to take the AP assessment and they must score a three or better and we have a higher average than the state for our students who are scoring three or better on that exam and that's where some of our Awards have come in the top um the best high schools the US News and World Report we
038have we received the silver medal in 2014 because of the number of students who have scored so well on our AP exams and that's we were recognized there the top 10 transformative schools in 2014 this was the first year that this award was offered and we were one of those school districts that received this award it basically looked at how we are utilizing technology and being Innovative in our practices in the school and we were one of the first schools to receive that award and we are still a part of innovate New Jersey which is a State Department of Education initiative and we continue to work with them it puts districts together who are working um in innovative ways with technology uh some of our Blended learning flipped classroom practices that we're doing in our
039classroom the iPads um and Ono one at the high school but it it includes more than that and all of the um instructional practices we're doing in our classroom and we continue to be a part of that but we all we were one of the inaugural districts um that were accepted into that program so we are still doing all of those things and as I said you know the high school um the numbers did increase this year for their graduation rate high performance as Dr Alvi just outlined and numerous best practices Mr ventrillo and I were um received an incredible amount of accolades at last year's County Roundtable budget meeting when we and our colleagues met for a county review of our budgets for efficiency um there are so many best practices going on here
040with regard to health insurance and and on and on that the meeting actually stopped and we got Wows from our colleagues High Performance Plus numerous best practices and relatively low taxation which is again in the bottom 20th percentile of total average property taxes in the county equals incredible value for the resources of um raised to educate children therefore it is Dr kak Dr alvic and my recommendation as the business administrator board secretary to develop a budget to stay within the very constrictive state budget cap while prioritizing the following subjects uh to cap the following areas subject to cap restrictions number one construction projects that we discussed number two two curriculum projects that have a lot of refinement to do with the budget defense rounds number three salary increases as per the contracts benefit increases and
041transportation increases I'd like to thank everybody and the board members who contributed um all along through this process I would like to just highlight a couple other areas that are noteworthy that I didn't have time to incorporate into another slide I mentioned this before but it's worth saying again for the last three budget years 1516 1415 1314 I went through the very large budget book and I pulled out all Appropriations that had to do with growth additional sections additional classrooms additional teachers um uh construction related to growth and when I edit up the budget amounts for the last 3 years and I subtracted all of the new Appropriations that are very specifically attributed to growth there would have been no aggregate tax increases for the last 3 years had it not been for the effective
042growth on this District so how do we run the district how do we create efficiency here well through the efforts and initiatives of the previous Finance committees and building grounds Transportation committees and policy committee meetings and curriculum committee meetings and administrative meetings and defense around meetings we have and this board deserves a lot of credit for the following budget efficiencies that I'll go through briefly number one an opt out of insurance was initiated which led to an agreement um uh two negotiations ago that's has saved over $4.3 million with over 160 staff saying I don't need insurance my spouse has uh suitable elsewhere and that reduces Appropriations uh the traditional plan which is the most expensive Catal black health plan that we have is frozen and will be eliminated at the end of the current
043uh njaa mtea agreement chapter 78 negotiations are locked in place at tier four for the whole duration of the new mtea contract we've refunded the 2002 the 2003 the 2006 and the 2008 series bonds saving well in excess of $10 million of Interest cost over the next 20 years we've engaged purchasing consortiums for District supplies that has saved over $1.5 million in the last 3 years as evidenced by a letter from the purchasing Consortium group through middx Regional and Service Commission we saved about $439,000 on brookside's roof by changing it from metal to Asphalt with a longer useful life that came out of a lot of effort at building grounds transportation we have returned to taxpayers $8.3 million of excess high school bond Surplus against the debt surfice tax relief the mtea has come forth
044and agreed to sidebars for two less expensive health care plans the direct access plan and the EPO for members to join reducing combined health care costs we've had numerous rfps for banking um Jamesburg agreement insurance has saved over $7 million over the last three years by changing Brokers by changing the type of payment methods that we have by opt outs and by concessions for the first time in 17 years the 1415 school budget produced a school tax decrease of $114 on an average assessed home at $3,079 when compared with the preceding year the Monro Township Board of Education achieved mutually agreeable favorable settlements with the Monro Township Education Association the support staff Association the teamsters and the principal supervisors Association leaving net budget impacts of 2% for the mtea um 2% for the education support
045staff Association 1.66% for the teamsters and 2% for the principal supervisors and net I mean salary increases minus the material concessions that were negotiated as part of the group and are an integral consideration you can't just look at the percentage increase taxpayer guide educational spending just came out and if you look at there and and I would encourage everyone to do so take a look at Monroe's teaching salaries and benefits compared to the county and administrative salaries and benefits it is extraordinarily low I mentioned before the agreement with Jamesburg School District um within the very constrictive tax levy cap we have on installments worked on at least four roofs and renovations to schools making room for growth the district has eliminated all portable classroom trailer uh items from uh the conclusion of the 1415 school
046year at the peak 89 portable classroom units were rented and deployed through the district and their elimination saves at least $1.5 million per year in rental payments and the board's um initiative into new proprietary funds is expected to generate revenues that will have an effect by reducing otherwise needed general fund levies in the future once they get off the ground and the creative thinking of this board and the creative imple implementation of policy that was created by this board will continue to make this District more efficient in the future Monroe is a very efficiently run District we value every taxpayer dollar that is raised and used it appropriately of course there's a a line item in any budget that you could find that any individual can disagree with but if you look at the aggregate
047large numbers here we are doing very well and that concludes my presentation and Mr P would you like to open up for questions uh yes and thank you Mr Gorski for that uh very thorough presentation uh keeping in mind that all of this is quite fluid in terms of any specifics that might be mentioned here uh so I'll now open the floor uh to questions from members of the board Mr Ryback I have just two questions Mike one for you Dory one for you I'm sorry Michael um with the increase in transportation although I have a feeling I know the answer would be the answer is probably going to be negligible if anything can we uh expect an increase in categorical Aid I very much appreciate that question categorical Aid includes an aid type for
048transportation efficiency monro's transportation department is the most efficient in the county and among the most efficient in the state we run four tiers throughout the day so that means that $100,000 bus that's on the road is being utilized all day long it's not dur it's not delivering six kids and then sitting in the yard all day um that efficiency rating makes M Monroe eligible for millions of dollars of Transportation categorical Aid however the state of New Jersey's uh budget formula reduces that amount number one by amounts that the district is over adequacy so that has a reducing effect on the amount of Aid that you're actually awarded through even though you're entitled to it and number two because of the state's hardship in in raising revenues they defer your award over a 5-year time period
049so you only get 20% per year now the state's problems that they've had in the last few years um they don't even look at the calculations anymore they're holding districts harmless which means you're Frozen basically at the amounts you've received last year which is very hazardous for Monroe because of the increasing students and demands that we have upon us any The increased uh special education classifications and and all that we are responsible for thank you TOR this had come up previously so when you were talking about AP courses I just thought of it what uh percentage of students that take AP courses take the exam 100 all of the students unless a student is absent during that time every student in the that every student that takes an AP class is takes the AP exam
050do we pay for the test or the parents we have in the past that was one of the things that we had decided to cut from the budget thank you MH M arm Min from this budget this budget the AP testing is being cut or or a future budget the 1516 budget 156 budget was cut current year okay thank you Mr Koffman uh the 663 th000 that we get from the state for the adjusted growth you mentioned before that uh you know it's kind of like a a number that you get right with everything that has to do with the state it's It's Magic numbers they kind of make it up as they go do we have any way to determine if that 66300 is accurate it is not accurate um when my first year
051as the business administrator the first thing I engaged in in the business in the budget process was to try to untangle that calculation and um and and see how much we're actually getting and if it merits um our efficient icy you know what we're should be entitled to and it does not um the the state has their own um cohort survival methods for enrollment and they they provide their own trend line calculation on those enrollments and then they align those enrollment increases to suit the eligibility of funds for distribution okay so it's impossible to calculate it's approximately that number but again 600,000 compared to 3.4 million which is actually what those new students are costing does not even allow your budget to grow enough to accommodate the new students which means you're going to have
052to inevitably do belt tightening on your own and eliminate some programs and services or create efficiencies in order to balance Mrs armenio um I just need further clarification on the uh page a total additional appropriation [Applause] considerations total appropriation considerations are $ 6,961 44 I I guess I just would like clarification and I don't want to put words in your mouth so please correct me um you said at this number we we would be well beyond the 2% cap is that correct absolutely that is correct when we project our cap overall for next year we are projected to be in excess by $4.2 million that is going to be reduced through the budget defense rounds by eliminating some of these new requested items by creating efficiencies by going to battle with health insurance carriers and
053looking for competitive quotes Amer Health versus Horizon uh Etc um and by eliminating some uh some programs and services that the district currently engaged in that are not necessarily align with board and District goals or are determined to be of of a lesser value okay so again if if everything were equal and we had a windfall of funds this would be this would be what what everybody is asking for at the time that is the first blush unrefined wish list um which everybody has intelligently comprised based upon the new enrollment needs the new state mandates and the new facility requirements for next year and I think you did mention this and forgive me if if you have to go find this given the new enrollment our cost based on the new enrollment is is what
054out of this number about $3.4 million which is not included in there specifically that was just an accent for discussion purposes just to let you know what the average new student costs there is no number for new students times that 15,000 that's included in this new appropriation list okay this new appropriation list is is specific to items that are requested now yes so we are anticipating a cost of potentially I'm trying to 3 million if we get another 224 students or is that the projection yes on average 224 students cost 3.4 million our appropriation projections for next year are that for specific items we will need about $7 million of new new Appropriations When You Subtract that from what the cap will afford you at only 2.8 million you're left with $4.2 million of Appropriations
055in excess of Reven revenues which is going to require a lot of refinement and review of programs and services appropriation in excess of Revenue yes and do we know how what our we do know now what our Revenue will be well for the for the 2015 we know what our revenue is well we hope we know uh the state has cut state aid midye so we know what the award was but we haven't recognized it yet well you know what at this point I mean I I think we really have to not consider state aid at all almost because for 15 years I it's not just the last few years for 15 years we've been talking about you know what we're put through not having state aid so we might as well not even have
056that discussion if it comes it would be almost like it would be hardly a gift but it would be you know something to have to spend uh but so so really the bottom line is and it's and my concern with all this is that there's this money there's the potential for a lot more students that we haven't budgeted for where are we going to get that like in mid year let's say we get uh 200 students you're shaking your head I mean some can you explain that we can't a you know what along that theme um uh the oak tree principal Patty Dinsmore is here and um oak tree is one of the schools that is most affected by growth that's the area of town that's really booming Patty would you mind coming up and
057talking a little bit about our previous conversation about how your actual numbers are exceeding even the demographic projection and how at this stage of the summer we've we have experienced a shocking number of new registrations talk off my head here but um when I started uh four years ago we had 575 last year I ended with 740 um with the redistricting I was supposed to start at 5:15 I'm already up to 590 and just talking to Central registration they have 20 folders um appointments every day I anticipate I'll be over 600 with in by September 1 that's after the redistricting yeah so so so so let's bring it to um we're getting most of these are are I think safe to say from new construction yes that we have no control over how I would
058say 9% right so the density of the new construction has caused us to have this blossoming of enrollment um is it calculated the first year of taxes on a new home does that come to us that year do we get the tax revenue in other words are people contributing they're they're giving us their lovely children are they are are new construction properties contributing to the tax levy in the immediate first year um my my understanding is no it it takes for a a re a a reevaluation cycle of the ratables so we are we are absorbing the cost for the benefit of any tax revenue in the initial year yes that's a lot though if you're saying that 200 and some odd kids a year are coming and it's approximately a $3 million cost and
059there isn't there isn't even anything that's being put in for that cost if we have to raise taxes we're raising taxes on other people other tax other shareholders wow okay so we have a lot to consider when it comes to that cost I mean because that the only place it looks like you're saying we're going to get funds it is from the tax levy if everything else is if nothing else is coming through yes ma'am I think we need more shared services because the T there there is some kind and then there's Builders put in some kind of money or something like that that doesn't get in even to the municipal budget it's not calculated in the municipal budget but it's collected in the municipal budget correct I I will say this you know we
060we engage in numerous shared services that are all defined in our budget which is posted on our website um we have a very aggressive shared service Outreach and many of them are with municipality uh we were at the early stages now of a very material um Grant from the Township in terms of land consideration for a future referendum I don't want to discuss that yet as um I don't want to steal Mr Po Thunder uh for the ad hoc discussion but um you know it's a sensitive area right now it's in its infancy and we were working on a lot of shared services with the township uh we have very positive indications um both regarding the tennis courts and also a contribution of land similar to Oak Tree school's contribution of land which was valued
061at $3 million to open that school which otherwise would have had been raised from the taxpayers to referendum other questions or comments alsoo yes we recently had a discussion about the iPads and the problems that it was having for for me with the amount of money that was being poured into the I remember asking Dr alage if we were going to have this go down to the middle school and the elementary schools and the answer was no to app point to the middle school now I see over here in the technology and the appropriation considerations you're thinking about hiring two Tech staff and exposing our children to uh Chromebooks is that what you're saying possibly Chromebooks that's one of the one of the te new technology pieces we're looking at yes but it wouldn't be
062it wouldn't be a onetoone where the students would take it home these are just the technology that we would need in the schools I understand that but this word here sitting at Circle time I have two children in the schools I know what Circle time is and I think that these kids don't need technology they need teachers to teach them and to imprint what we believe and not what the let me finish what what they not what they're going to see from their Chromebooks or the internet and I also see that we're growing in Leaps and Bounds in this technology department we're having a hard time getting money together and we're talking about expanding we're hiring two new staff members supposedly when we could be taking that money from the staff and building two new
063classrooms that we need so desperately so I don't understand why we don't even have a pilot program that was one of the big mistakes we made when we first got the iPads now we're looking to expand down to our little children and without to without any pilot program to see how's how would it it affects them or or if it helps even all kids that have them this wouldn't be onetoone for the students this would be just just technology for the teachers to utilize in their classroom this is the first step yes but it doesn't mean that it needs to be an iPad it could be anything that's that's why I said Mr Washington and I are very involved with looking at multiple platforms right now and looking at all of the different types of
064technology that are out there but this would not be for the students to have in their hands this is for the teachers to use as an instructional device in their classrooms I understand this is a first step you're hiring new two text there that's a separate piece from that other one it's still expanding the program well the the technology resource resource Personnel would be more to help the teachers to use the technology in their classrooms more effectively um and it would be so they would be the staff we used to have technology Personnel in each of our schools it was cut out of the budget several years ago with all of the new technology that we're getting in the classrooms it's part of our PD program to uh train all of our teachers in the
065technology so that that's what that the role of those technology teachers would be right now we have one we have one for the entire District we have it was uh Karen O connell's position I'm sorry if I may keep in mind that uh as was mentioned earlier this is somewhat of a wish list and to dwell on the specifics at this point uh probably is counterproductive uh I I certainly don't want to sty me any discussion or questions but uh keep in mind as well that anything regarding curriculum uh must go through the curriculum committee and then get the full approval of the board or the board the approval of the full board uh anything dealing with uh other matters that are in here will either go uh you know before building and grounds it
066all depends upon what the particular item is so it's not as if we're approving anything in particular at this point uh and I know Dr kak wants to make a comment but I just want to make an observation and see if I'm correct here Mr Gorski uh when I was looking at uh the boat the budget Appropriations and I suppose it would be just for the purpose of everyone else it's the third page of budget Appropriations uh where it talks about salaries and benefits uh and that figure comes out to be uh you know well you can see it a, 356,000 or 357,000 uh now my understanding is because this is uh based on the negotiated contracts and based on benefits that uh this is uh not a this is somewhat of a fixed figure
067this is a definite cost correct that is absolutely correct this is a contracted obligation that is present for next year and is non-negotiable um and and the total between salaries and benefits which is non-negotiable for next year as you could see is about uh $3 million of the total of seven new Appropriations for next year plus there's a lot of mandates from the state um and and Capital Improvements that are really a very high priority right now and again I I if I could I'm sorry if I could just you know you can never shut me up if I could refocus you know the attention there's going to be a lot of Need for contributions like Mr prosos during the budget refinement process at the committee level and so on for today if I could
068refocus the attention back on the philosophy development at the macro level I I believe we've demonstrated that we have approximately $7 million of new appropriation needs upon us as Mr P you said most of which are contracted now or mandated by the state and revenue growth only allows for uh uh two .7 leaving a short P fall of about 4.2 when you think about that for a moment and you TR trying to develop a philosophy and you're trying to consider student needs and the effect on taxes you feel a little bit helpless at least I did putting this together that we are so overwhelmed with new needs and our revenues coming from the state are fixed and finite while our revenues from the taxpayers to going into cap are also so constrict icted that $4.2
069million is again going to have to be eliminated through the refinement process to the budget or the elimination of of existing programs and services our work is cut out for us in the next few months as an Administration and a board level just to get this to cap even by the development of an hopefully anticipated philosophy of going to cap today uh thank you Mr Gori and I will I will now continue with the observation that I that I wanted to make I'm also looking under transportation where it appears that we're mandated which means required to replace two passenger buses now uh looking at the figures here that's about $200,000 so if I take that 000,000 and add it to the uh salaries and benefits I get it I get over uh 15 well I
070get over a, 500,000 okay I then look at what we're allowed to grow the cap to and I see that mil 500,000 is more than half half of what we're allowed to grow the cap to so I mean it's it's obvious to me that even though we have a tremendous wish list here there's an awful lot of stuff and I'm talking about curriculum I'm talking about building repairs there's just a lot of stuff that we're not going to be able to accommodate uh no way I mean there's just no way that we're going to be able to do it and that's not even taking into account the cost of the additional students just taking into the account what we're required to pay in salary and benefits to the staff the two buses that we are
071required to replace I mean those were costs that we don't have any flexibility on is my understanding is that correct absolutely correct okay so if we have no flexibility on that then out of the uh two 2,772 ,000 uh dollars that we're allowed to increase the budget by more than 50% of it it is already eaten up you know uh I just want to make everyone aware of that uh that that really there's only about uh 1200 a milon2 200,000 dollars left to try to accommodate all these other needs I you know it's it is crazy it's absolutely crazy Mr Kaufman yeah and and you know that's a great Point everyone's bringing up such great points and you know being on the board for a while you see these Trends over many many many years
072the other thing to keep in mind too is even though we have this incredible growth we have a incredible growth disproportionate to other districts with respect to special needs children right and we already demonstrated that children with special needs tend to cost a little bit more than children without special needs so when you factor in everything you just mentioned and the fact that you know when I first started on the board I think the percentage was close to maybe 13 or 14% of our kids had special needs and Mike I think you said we're closer to 20% uh where we are today that that number just by itself could represent another chunk of that dollar that we have no control over because we happen to be a great District we have to be happen to
073have a lot of the special education stuff that we do is is top of the shelf and people are coming here because it's highly recognized and and folks come in here we bring a lot of these activi ities in house where we can but some things we can't do we have to send out to other facilities and again adding to that cost burden of stuff that we can't control so you know we're kind of almost a victim of our own success if you will but these are things that have been happening over since I've been here and it's been probably longer than it should be but um all these years that we've been here that it's just an incredible growth of of cost so that's another thing that also comes into play when you're thinking
074about the things we have to have or have to have nice to have versus things we don't need thank you Mr Koffman anyone else Mr proso Michael on property tax averages uh we're minus 1.8 now to change and that is correct this information comes from the state of New Jersey and the average property tax which again in includes Municipal and School District as well um was a 1.8% decrease from the calendar year 2013 to the calendar year 2014 so that's before the evaluation uh that was the year that was part of the re part of the reevaluation but that's why it went down because of the evaluations I wouldn't say it is definitely because that is that is part of the reason it went down however think about what a reevaluation is I mean you're
075still going to raise the same Levy you're just spreading it differently amongst the universe of people paying because some folks bought homes 15 20 years ago and are still paying taxes on an assessment at that same value it was as low as 50% when they did the reevaluation so it was part of it perhaps with a a fair uh equitable distribution of the raising of the levy but uh there was also Bond reference ROM money to the extent of $2.5 million that was returned to reduce the uh The Debt Service tax levy and a lot of other variables in that Mr nin just a couple uh quick I guess questions or comments um I know last year we went uh we had 5.4 million in uh anticipated uh growth if you will growth I guess
076or expenditures based on the uh at the budget philosophy meeting um we opted to go to cap at that point and uh obviously the cap last year uh was less than this year the growth um what happens a lot I see is that at least from my constituents I get the questions of we have a 2% cap why did my tax rate go up 7.67% why did the budget growth 3.88% last year um I get that but what I'm trying to understand is let's say we went to cap is there any way for you to anticipate what the tax rate growth estimate would be the answer to that directly is no at this vantage point we don't know what the ratables are going to be for 1617 the ratables are the population sharing the levy
077there's two components to this there's the taxpayers sharing the levy and the levy itself and without knowing the aggregate property values um from the taxpayers which is called the uh ratables we cannot calculate that formula uh we know the uh the appropriation side we know that ratables are growing which is very favorable and and we know that ratables are the most important variable in determining the tax rate my first year as business administrator ratables dropped $70 million my second year they dropped 75 million you'd have to look back in in over 12 years to find a drop in ratables of of any magnitude near that when you have a drop in ratables of $75 million you have an automatic tax increase for every taxpayer of about 5 cents um that that's extraordinary and that's that's
078because there's less people paying everybody's individual rate goes up up so we'll be able to answer that more definitively as time goes on and we get the ratables in January late um and also you know if we receiv received our fair share of state aid that would also reduce the amount of tax levy that we would have to raise to meet our needs I also noticed um last year that the automatic adjustment for enrollment was only 20,000 this year it's 663 th000 is there a reason for that even though we had you know we had less last year but not quite that less yeah there's no doubt that our enrollment is growing incredibly higher than our colleagues there's no doubt that the enrollment adjustment to cap should probably be in a $3.4 million uh capacity
079but the state's calculation and their trend line uh study to control taxation limits that to only 660,000 for 1516 and it was only 20,000 the year before that um it's a it's a formula that we don't have access to and uh conservatism in budget establishment is to try to base it on what you received the prior year not to overestimate it by any means because then you'll be left short I also noticed that the um if I'm reading this correctly that the it looks like the adjustment enrollment adjusted enrollment adjustment that gets uh inflated by 2% but the adjustment for healthcare is just an add-on is that accurate that is absolutely correct yes um I know you've told us in the past that give you the cake you want us to bake and you'll bake
080it and and and I get that um if we were to tell you we want to just go raise 2% in other words raise the tax levy by 2% how difficult would it be for you to show us or at least let us see what the budget looks like at that point that would be very difficult because you're taking the tax calculation which is at the tail end of this process and the tail now is driving the rest of the dog and the dog being the appropriation development to meet student needs in that instance student needs and the and the requirements of the district would be ignored for the priority of of determining a tax rate first I can tell you that every emphasis is placed upon lowering that tax rate and nothing tickles administratives
081fancy more so than say the tool the school tax levy is decreasing like it did two years ago and and we are on the same page with with the taxpayers and the Board of Education in that process to minimize that burden nobody hates taxes more than we do but our first priority and the first priority of the board must be students needs first and that's why I would not recommend that method I'm not saying to to look at the tax rate I'm saying basically that's what we're doing here we're increasing the tax levy and then working backwards except in this case we're going uh 2% plus enrollment adjustment in healthare if we were to request as a board that we want to see what the budget looks like with basically the enrollment adjustment and the
082health care uh adjustments backed out that would actually just be inflated of last year's budget by 2% I'm not talking the tax rate because of course we could never predict that I'm just saying let's instead of Growing Up by 2 .7 million let's grow by 1.8 million because that's what 2% is of last year's uh general fund tax levy that's an interesting observation it's all along the same lines as your first question how do we calculate this 660,000 um the 660,000 is the available cap adjustment for enrollment when the actual cost is 3.4 million so we're already suffering a a millions of dollarss by uh lack of cap growth from only 600,000 to eliminate and Abate the 600 would only exacerbate that problem and really put us up against a revenue shortfall in trying to
083meet the needs of the students in my opinion okay thank you Mr Ryback mikae I just want to see if I have this straight and I think if if I do then I think it's important to underscore it you're saying that the um the state will cap uh at a certain amount 6 how much was 660 something by by going to cap we can grow the budget $2.8 million well whatever they they will cap what they're giving us yes and then the reason for that as you mentioned obviously is that they want to uh uh not raise the state taxes they so basically what they're doing is transferring the burden to the municipality and school systems Mr Rybeck I'm so delighted you brought that point up because back in the 10-1 school year Monroe School
084District lost 95% of our state aid 4.4 million of 4.6 was taken away from Monroe what that did was shift the state's burden to fund public education in Monroe to the tune of 4.4 million and push it into the tax levy and say eat this taxpayers this one's yours and it remains there ever since and they go around saying how they keep taxes down at the state level yeah but okay I just I just want to bring that out many but again we we've been we've been Paralyzed by that for many years and while it it is our it is the burden that we have so we have to um um try to make do I think with with understanding that burden to to to keep saying that it it's happened we get it I
085I get it that it's happened I think it's you know unfortunate and it and it puts us in a very great disadvantage but it is our burden also um to recognize um I I'd like to go back to and and this was from before I was on the board where is where was The Tipping Point between having increased enrollment and and the cost of the p uh the the pupil cost going down and now the cost Rising because at one point when we had more students we were able to accommodate it and actually the cost was going down I think at one point it was 14,000 I think that was about three or four years ago and so I'm just curious as to where the Tipping Point was in terms of enrollment as to now
086the I mean I get the increase because we've had to get more classrooms and more sections but where where was that Tipping Point because at one point we were saying we were absorbing it in a way that was very efficient and we were getting reduced cost I think the per pupil costs have um slightly been increasing um over time probably over the last decade an interesting statistic is on page 119 of the comprehensive annual financial report where it shows the percentage change in per pupil spending um if you take the average over the last two four five years it is below a 2% increase in per pupil spending and I'll read you the last few years it's 0.98% increase a negative. 39% increase a 0.85% increase a 1.05% increase a 2.3% increase per people spending
087is increasing over the last five years less than 2% that's probably less than inflation so I guess that's what we were that's what we've been talking because I know it was within the last five years we had we had those discussions about per pupil cost but now we're seeing an enormous increase because of just we're satiated I guess in terms of facilities when you have an enormous increase in pupils and you have a fixed and finite budget cap it will reduce per pupil spending and that's part of the essence of the Jamesburg agreement Monro per pupil spending is expected to continue to um you know slightly increase or decrease in the high school line item in particular which if Jamesburg budgets more for as per the agreement that Arbitrage that difference will be applied back
088to the reage and that's that's driven by Monroe's very handsome pupil spending if I'm understanding that last remark uh and that's what I'm doing is I want to check my understanding um the the per pupil cost that now and that's all encompassing if you're talking about the total per pup cost the total per pup cost can decrease simply by the number of students increasing correct correct okay that does not translate into a lower budget however correct okay all right okay maybe that I just want to clarify of my question yeah because even though the budget goes up if your if your number of kids are increasing the per pupil cost may be going down even though your budget's going up because it's you know it's having to go up to account for all that additional
089expense Mr Po yes but but the cap has essentially limited how much the budget can go up you teach your hat on it was very good good explanation let any other questions or comments on this Mr noin uh Mr gorsky you brought up the point of the the Jamesburg uh tuition agreement I believe somewhere I saw in here that it was uh 1.67 of the total revenue I believe uh or 1.65 something like that um what exactly is that dollar amount and how is this uh working out is this uh is this helping us with the uh because I noticed uh the state on one of the sites I looked at today I believe the Jamesburg uh tax rate went down five 5 and a half% um I'm just wondering are are are they at
090are they uh allocating enough money uh to increase the tuition spending as we had anticipated the percentage of Monroe's revenue from Jamesburg tuition is 1.64% Jamesburg also pays transportation fees uh which slightly raises that percentage uh that is the tuition Reven Vue component of the overall budget um it is important and it is advantageous to Monroe to have a receiving relationship with Jamesburg because Jamesburg pays their per pupil rate times the number of students and they also help Monroe uh sharing a lot of the fixed cost in the district so there is an advantage of of that relationship to Monroe oh no AB absolutely but I'm just wondering how is that agreement working out is it are we on track of what we had anticipated yes the agreement is really in its infancy stage it's
091a seven-year agreement um the reason that duration was extended that long was to allow it to materialize and for the pupil per pupil spending difference with the actual tuition cost paid by Jamesburg um to work future reports will be given to the finance committee and the board on the um the fruit of that agreement as it matures is this excuse me that 1.64% is that uh up or down from last year's uh budget as far as its contribution to our budget I would expect it to be very similar and is that is that the goal going forward or should that number start actually probably the number will probably go down as our budget goes up is what you're saying I would expect that number to go down as the budget goes up as you anticipated
092no president yes ma'am the automatic adjustment for enrollment that estimate you said last year we got 20,000 correct and so was that a random act of the state saying this is all we're getting despite what you what the what the calculation says I don't think it was random I think it was a very creative calculation because certainly our enrollment growth is very steady every year and it should afford our cap to grow 3.4 million as I said said before but it only afforded US 20 million last year which means you got to do a lot of belt tightening in order to fit that growth and this year it's only growing 600,000 ultimately it's meant to suppress the size of your budget as is the cap and it has done that last year we got how
093many new students 267 for 15 16 and so this year I I guess I'm not understanding the 20,000 versus the 663 th000 it's a huge difference in it is a huge difference from 20,000 to 660,000 it should be 3.4 million so it's not affording our budget to grow uh consistent with the amount of student cost that are coming in all right I understand that what I don't understand is so are they changing the formula every year yes the budget guidelines and the calculation changes every year and we don't know what that calculation is for that we do not I called the county office I called the state department in my first year here um trust me I'm very uh persistent in my calls and efforts and I got no answer so I based it conservatively
094on the prior year and that's all I've been able to do over time but I will say it's very difficult for the district it's very burdensome because the cost of the new students that are compounding is not is not meeting the growth in in the cap so existing programs and services are having to be refined in or efficiencies created to make up the difference have we tried opening that um no I haven't considered doing that no thanks yeah quick question on that though when you try and calculate based on a prior year with this incredible pendulum swing from one year to another how are you going to do next year because in the past couple of years you had 20,000 land next year 600,000 this year what number are you going to use next year
095it it could go back to 20,000 how do you figure this after you have your budget through the defense rounds and done that's a very late calculation that comes through very late that's probably late February um time frame and it's going to require hustle in in hours number of time by Administration to make cuts to make it fit and you're going to have to very quickly and very undemocratically make cuts to programs and services and that's without the cooperation of the principles that's without the um information [Music] Dr yeah that's I agree with you that is it's a tough decision and it's a decision that a lot of districts or all districts face uh one of the things one of the goals that we're hoping to do uh to accomplish is to prioritize as best
096as possible the items the that would require Appropriations or expenditures in the budget and um that would be somewhat of a democratic process meaning the entire leadership team all the administrators would have you know principal supervisors directors Etc would have input into that with the agreement that and that the last couple days of the budget cycle when those numbers come in we won't have time to go back and discuss so we'll have to have that agreement ahead of time should the numbers come in at 20,000 this is you know these items will most likely be cut should it a little higher well maybe that'll be saved of course that'll also be a discussion that will be held with the board uh Board of Education prior to that those numbers coming in as well so that
097you're fully apprised of where we're at and if I could just add one thing we're not there yet but there will be a discussion uh soon uh talking about the district and the board goals and uh one of the air one of the district goals that I would like to advance uh might be to uh you know help address some of our rising cost specifically in the area of special education and I don't want to talk about it now I'll wait till the goal um portion of the meeting comes up but listening not only to what I heard tonight but also information that I've found through uh you know prior to tonight uh that's an area that I'm hoping we can move in to maybe help uh reduce or at least minimize some of the
098rising cost in that area Mr noin Mr Cal brought kind of the point that I was intimating before about backing out the cost of the automatic adjustment for enrollment um that is a concern because as we mentioned it was 20,000 so I mean I would like to see what the budget would look like let's you know last year and I know at the a couple of the the finance committee meetings we talked about what would you cut or give us what you think you could cut out of the budget and that's why to me I have to admit I think if we had a 4% cap we'd be sitting here tonight talking 2.7 million times two I think that we would obviously be growing the budget to 4% because that's where it needs to go
099there's there's no there's there's nobody that can admit that that's not true um so what I don't I I would really like to see let's see what the budget looks like at a strict 2% over 923 uh 92 million and and work from there and then if if if we don't like what the budget looks like at that point then we'll have to you know maybe rethink things but to me it's got to be very difficult from an administrative standpoint that at the end of the budget process when the state comes in and says well we're only going to give you 20 or 30,000 now like you said it's total crunch time and we're cutting things that may really not that should not have been cut if we were given enough excuse me if we
100were given enough thought in the process so I I think now this is what we're doing now this is the long drawn out this is the big picture this is the macro here let's see what the budget looks like um at 92.3 million inflated by 2% one thing's for certain our presentation has Illustrated that there's approximately $7 million of new costs and I would estimate out that 74.5 to5 are mandated um there's a deficit of new costs over the amount that the cap will allow you to grow under its current estimate of about million it's going to be a Herculean task to get this budget to cap and to balance with that kind of deficit of need over restricted resource growth to so to restrict resource growth even further just exas exacerbates the problem it
101is administration's recommendation therefore to take the very conservative Capal allotment as it exists whatever that number will be as defined by the state which is meant to be suppressive by its nature and and budget to that amount and make up the $4.4 million through the budget uh refinement process and the Very rigorous budget defense rounds cuts are going to be needed they will be presented to the Committees along the way we will need board members participation in that um but you know from a macro standpoint Now using the very big numbers presented to before $7 million of new needs 2.8 million under the very suppressive cap growth leaves a 4 something million dollar headache for administration and the principles and the and the vice principles and the supervisors and directors to deal with again we
102are not getting the number of resources to keep up with the demands in this District even by going to cap Mr proso I can't forget that we're looking to pass a referendum and if the taxes go up any a they did last year it's never going to pass and we're just going to throw away a $100,000 in the pre- referendum costs so Tom's got a pretty good idea that at least we should try to see if we can keep that to the 4% anyone else Mr Ryback you you no he said four I thought he no look on your face you had a question or something 2% I think okay anyone Mr no I just don't want to beat a dead horse but but we do from what I'm hearing is that there is a
103chance that the enrollment adjustment might be backed out anyway down to 20 is that correct there's always that chance there's a chance there's a chance that it could grow more there's a chance that it could grow less depending on how the state allows you to grow your budget cap but one thing's for certain and it's indisputable the cap is not growing enough to meet the district's needs even by going to cap we're over $4 million short and and U as your Chief Financial Officer as the expert in the district's financial affairs I say to you that it's going to be very hard to meet the students needs of this District by budgeting anything less than whatever the cap allowance is from the state still we're $4 million short and I just was was wondering if
104isn't it easy easier now since we have 12 months or or 6 months in advance to see what the budget would look like should the 663 th000 turn to 20,000 isn't it more uh beneficial to the students to look now and and and really uh cut things that we may want to cut because we can look at the big picture as opposed to uh having four weeks to cut $640,000 no it it seems for my understanding to be squeezing a uh a bigger square into a smaller hole um uh you know the the professionals who are in in the business of constructing the budget here Dr kak Dr alvik and I are are are really raising the red flag and crying Uncle here at this meeting because we can't close the doors on the new
105students coming in nor can we ignore the facility needs with Ling Roes nor can we keep buses on the road that are unsafe um and and nor can we ignore the specialed mandates for resource room and inclass support do you know that resource room placements uh require one teacher for eight students and most of those settings also requires a power professional we are really up against it even with going to cap going to cap is no luxury it is a suppression of spending and um that should be the starting point we will have to refine this budget over 4 million dollar just to get it to cap from there to start at a lower Point scares me very much okay I thank everyone for your questions and comments uh and this is one of the
106reasons why I had talked to Mr Gorski about our not uh tonight uh actually making a uh taking any action in terms of of the budget philosophy so that everyone has a little bit more time to think about this uh to look at this information that we've been given tonight and if you have additional questions you can certainly I would think direct those to Mike or Dr kak uh but uh I did not want us to feel that we were rushed into having to uh support a budget philosophy uh the same night that we were receiving the information on it so I I hope that you will take advantage of the time that you will have uh and I believe that it will be on next week's agenda uh we haven't yet okay so uh
107you might anticipate that we would be looking to uh uh actually act on a resolution concerning uh the budget philosophy next week Miss kapan did you have a question comment you want a resolution read tonight uh well you you you could certainly make a resolution I I I I would prefer that we I mean this is my own personal opinion and prefer to give the the the board more time before they are asked to actually vote on this but if you want to make a resolution then we can we can uh we can vote on the resolution to see what happens Mr yes you know the the consideration of a resolution it will result in a directive to Administration to begin this process you know with $4.4 million of new Appropriations in excess of you
108know the suppressive cap we we need to be that as quickly as possible if the board was able to pass a resolution tonight and make that philosophy to go to cap it will begin the construction um I would recommend no later than the next meeting for an adoption of a resolution either way because we need our marching orders we we need to know in Mr no's analogy what flavor of cake to start mixing at this point I I completely understand that but I don't think that waiting one week is going to uh greatly set you back uh in in uh beginning to do that budgetary work but uh is there a resolution that someone wants to make on this m AR it be appropriate um in Roberts rules if I ask to table that until
109next week to table what table the resolution resolution has been made all right we'll make one and I'll take I know it's coming okay I move that the Board of Education establish and adopt a budget Philosophy for the 201627 school year to responsibly meet the demands of Contin ing significant student growth and facility needs as well as program and service requirements by budgeting to cap without the ability to utilize Bank cap and without consideration of budgeting above cap by going out to a vote while prioritizing the following items subject subject to the res restrictions presented by Administration one construction projects as presented two curriculum recommendations as presented three salary benefit increases as per contract and as presented for transportation recommendations as presented this action by the board will enable the board to fulfill its education
110educational responsibility to District students in a thorough efficient and fiscally prudent manner while non-committed ensuring the maintenance of District resources and Facilities second okay you've heard the motion it has been seconded we've already had a rather full discussion but is there any further discussion well I AR table it until next week okay then then are you making a motion to table that moved to table the motion okay then we have to vote on tabling that resolution Mr Gorski roll call the motion to table is a priority motion um which immediately requires a vote motion to table made by Miss armeno and seced by Mr noin Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr zareski no Mr Mayo no Mr kelman no Mrs k panowich no Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po
111yes motion to table has five yeses that is not the majority needed motion to table does not pass Mrs kono's motion is back on the floor um point of order I just have a question I know that you had said that the Jamesburg rep is eligible to vote could you please just tell me which of the four items uh in the agenda where it says he's El eligible to vote on uh would pertain in this situation please many of them the one for facility needs the one for curriculum uh and teachers uh um these were intimately discussed with Council prior to this meeting so that I'm prepared and it was council's opinion that because those four items are so interwoven in so many of the new initiatives that you've seen in the presentation that James
112Burke is allowed to vote on the budget philosophy okay I mean I I I will definitely like to see maybe we can get a uh an advisory ruling from our legal council on that because I really don't don't see uh how a send Reed District who has their basically their tuition uh fixed at this rate uh to Monroe uh would be eligible to vote on this because uh their tuition will not change no matter what our budget philosophy is I appreciate your comment we could uh seek an advise written opinion from Council I am reiterating what our conversation was before she definitively said yes um okay so that brings us back to uh Mrs kapovich is U resolution it has been seconded is there any further discussion all right then we will go to a
113roll call vote okay this is Mrs Kap Pano's resolution this is to go to cap it's it's to to go to cap prioritizing the projects um in in uh in a manner to get to C cap um M armeno no Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kapano yes Mr noin abstain your abstention is noted Mr proso no Mr Rybeck abstain Mr Po uh I have a question for you uh before I cast my vote um this same resolution can be introduced if it if it does not pass tonight it can be introduced again at next week's meeting is that correct yes it is correct okay then I vote no that's five Ys motion requires a majority of the board which would be six appears we have a stalemate
114on the resolution motion does not pass okay thank you uh I see that we're about at two hours now I would suggest before we move on because there's going to be another presentation with quite a bit of deliberation uh I would move that we go into a recess uh so that uh we can refresh ourselves a bit go to the restroom I think uh there there are some drinks uh in the back room here and Miss Thorton since you have been here the whole time and we'll be doing the presentation you're certainly welcome to join us okay this is not going into the Clos session it's just a recess of about I'd say maybe 20 minutes something of that sort all right thank you okay the Board of Education will now come to order again
115and at this time we will have a presentation on the board self- evaluation being given by Gwen Thorton our njsba uh that's the word I want F rep correct that is correct that is correct it's a pleasure to be back um and I I have to tell you that I thoroughly enjoyed listening to your um budget philosophy conversation and I commend you for having that now because the construction of the budget is such a timec consuming piece for your administrators that providing them with adequate Direction now will really make for an easier budget process moving forward forward so really having that discussion now and coming to agreement around how you want to move that budget forward is absolutely imperative and so I congratulate you for taking the time to really go through that um at
116the macro level you'll be working on it all year right through you know March um and unfortunately you know things have not improved at the state level such that we could in any way think that there are going to be any additional monies that are going to be coming forward um so I think that that's an important piece to keep in mind um you did your self- evaluation your self assessment um and you have um in front of you I know that Mike sent it out to you via email and also in hard copy um the final report on your self- evaluation and typically your self assessment is really used to help you identify um what you were effective um most effective at in terms of your governance processes and procedures and also to identify
117moving forward those areas that are of priority for you as a board and those areas that perhaps you would like to do some additional professional development so they really should guide you in creating your District goals as well as your board goals um you will recall that your board goals refer solely to the way you operate your processes and procedures and your District goals are the ones that you are responsible for developing in collaboration with your Administration your Administration will create action plans to make progress toward or to achieve those goals and you will evaluate your superintendent based on the progress toward achieving those goals um at the end of next school year um and so really it's about developing a shared Vision around where you would like to see your District be at the
118end of the coming school year 20156 um and really you know one of the pieces around your budget is that whatever goals you set you need to make sure that you are providing the financial resources necessary in order to achieve those goals you cannot hold someone accountable for achieving goals without providing the financial wherewithal um to accomplish those goals so as we think about goals for the school district in the coming year you need to be mindful um of the costs that would be involved in those particular pieces um I think that this is a wonderful opportunity this year you have a brand new superintendent Dr kak um who is a very experienced superintendent I've had the pleasure of working with Mike um over the last several years in several different districts over my time
119with the association um and so I'm delighted to see him here in Monroe and I think this is a wonderful opportunity for the board and your administrative team to move forward in a very collab abative way um and to really create a a new a new day uh here in Monroe where you can come to consensus around what needs to be addressed what is important to you one of the pieces that I found most exciting and delightful about your self assessment was that you identified student achievement as your top priority and I think that speaks volume Monroe is a highquality school district and one of the reasons for that is because your board has always put student achievement first and foremost and so I would encourage you to continue in that vein and Direction because
120as you know that is why you are here goals are really the foundation for Effective policy development um you rated your policy as being up toate and going well um it really does help you in terms of looking at your total program and figuring out those things that are most important excuse me um it is a way to communicate to your community and to all of your stakeholders what your priorities are for the coming school year what you are focusing on um it should be a part of your every day every week every agenda um piece that you do as a board of education it should drive the work of your committees so that if you have a finance goal for example that would be worked on in the finance committee if you have a
121curriculum and in instructional goal you would work on that in your curriculum committee and so forth okay um looking at your goals we know that every part impacts another part you can't work on one without impacting another um and so really taking a systematic approach to goal setting is important um and there's a governance cycle that I know most of you are aware of we're setting goals now for the 20156 school year those goals will be um place for September and then you will receive updates periodically on the progress to those goals and then use them to evaluate your superintendent in the May June time frame and then next summer create a new set of goals um for the following year so it's a cycle and it never ends but it is a way of
122making sure that you have a specific Focus for your District okay we really do believe that looking at various pieces of data can help you to develop wonderful board goals um in Mike's budget presentation he showed you the data around student growth he showed you the data around the costs for various items Capital Improvements um roofs and all of those kinds of things your buses all of that kind of data really does help a board to be able to make well informed decisions and there are a number of places that you can look at for data um around student achievement um and around all areas of operation of the school district so um we really do believe that it's important to look at those kinds of things in addition to looking at data around student
123assessment and achievement you can look at the other kinds of data to look at school climate and culture for example you can look at violence and vandalism suspension reports um culture and climate surveys that may be done with students and staff and community members all of that provides you with additional data points and information that will help guide your work okay the state and the FED have produced certain Benchmark standards that are included around all of those areas that you need to be working on as you know your curriculum needs to be aligned to the Common Core um for the moving forward in all areas they've established turnaround principles through the federal government you don't have any schools that are turnaround schools in your school district but we do have some um and there are
124a series of changes that districts sometimes are required to make if their schools are really struggling um to succeed and those are the turnaround principles so in terms of of goal development the district goals are really owned by everyone you set them in collaboration with your Administration and we will be talking with your Administration tonight around what they've identified as being the priorities um your superintendent may have Merit goals that tie back back into the district goals in some fashion if that's in the contract and then of course you have board goals around your processes and procedures so as you're thinking about developing your goals um we suggest that you look at various pieces okay and I want to go to here is your mission statement the Monroe Township mission statement here is your vision
125statement that speaks to um what you want and I think the most important important piece really is the vision and I think it's worth reading um out loud because I think it's so critically important and that is that the Monroe Township Board of Education commits itself to all children by preparing them to reach their full potential and to function in a global Society through a preeminent education um I I think that that is a wonderful vision for the children in your community um and I think you need to keep that in mind as you talk about shaping the goals um moving forward you have in place a strategic plan that was done several years ago there were three goals Incorporated in that strategic plan these were the very broad-based objectives that came out of that
126um and one and first of all was to create a userfriendly system that provides all stakeholders to help shape um the educational program and Facilities transmitt of information to all stakeholders um actually you know this is a lot of lovely language that really means you want to communicate and engage your community um I think that that is an ongoing challenge for lots of boards of Education all across the state you talked a little bit about the need to go to referendum so making sure that you are communicating on an ongoing basis with all stakeholders not just parents but with all citizens in your community is absolutely essential um and I think that this provides some level of framework for this year's um goals the second one um regarding District finances to assess current and future
127facilities needs you've begun that process you have an ad hoc facilities committee correct that is looking at what you need to do to make sure that you have uh adequate classroom and educational facilities to support the increased enrollment of students all across your district and then the last one which should probably be listed first is really around curriculum and instruction making sure that you have articulated the curriculum across all schools all grade levels provided equity for all students um and using curriculum that is evidence-based um research based and aligned to the Common Core that integrates technology and character education and I think that goes back to your vision for the whole child um that you talked about in your particular Vision so these goals are still there these are really very broad goals and as
128you think about your goals for next year you may want to align them in those three categories or those three um areas okay here are last year's goals that um my colleague Alan NADA developed with you um last August um when I was not here and that was to continue to adopt the Strategic plan plan and implement the goals that we just looked at um identify and develop a schedule for looking at some of your programs including um AP Advanced um placement and Avid programs as measured by Student Success and then seek viable sources of alternative District Revenue which I heard um Mike talk about in terms of the preschool After School Care Program being um run in District as a way to generate revenue and there was another one sum camps thank you summer
129camps um again as a way to to raise revenue so I think clearly you have met that goal um around alternate revenue and you're to be congratulated that's not a small piece um districts again are all trying to find ways to generate Revenue as the state aid remains Frozen or even less in some districts even though they're talking about hold it harmless so is we think about goals for next year um I always like to ask our administrative team what their priorities that they've identified as being what you need to focus on this is what last year's goals look like these are what your strategic planning goals that you have in place look like but you have a new superintendent and I really would like to ask from his perspective um what he has identified
130here to for um as being those key pieces Mike well thank you when based on information that not only from tonight but conversations that I've had with the board uh my research into the district and the previous goals uh concerns and challenges that the board has brought forth and of course certainly the information not only from Mr Gorski and Dr alage but also the leadership team uh meaning all of the school administrators uh principal supervisors directors uh assistant principles principles uh I've come up with a couple uh areas to look at now these are General type goals that I think would be aligned with um the Board of Education and the direction of the district is going in uh I certainly do not have them refined or developed into any sort of an action plan
131tonight was just to introduce these ideas so I'm going to mention a few of these areas and U then we'll open it up for discussion on that the one area is uh communication and uh there is communication uh there there a communication system within the district however I think that an expansion of that commun communication system could uh only benefit the uh school district and what I mean by an expansion of that is in addition to areas of what I'll call meet and greet uh where I would like to get out into the community perhaps have meetings in the Township Library perhaps the community centers uh invite people into the the district at either morning meetings or or evening meetings uh that would give me a chance to uh meet members of the community who
132I might not normally have a chance to meet during the uh school year uh and it would give the people the the members of the community a chance to also voice their concerns um the things they like the things that they think are challenging or that are concern of concern to them along with that I would like to move into areas uh such as Facebook and Twitter social media um we already started the process of looking at there's a system called an contact as a way to get disseminated information on a on a pretty regular basis out to the community and you know so many people now rely on um on their phone that this would be almost a push out type of notification so in addition to hard copies which we could put out
133in the library and different places um we would also open up the opportunity for people to receive regular updates through either email or text or social media so that they would be able to receive that on their phone laptop U iPad whatever device that they're using uh I think that many of the families and community members now are used to having information sent to them rather than to go out to a website so that would Encompass a number of different areas one school districts uh public school districts in particular are no longer Monopoly and I think that's a u a discussion that's been occurring and I think all of you received the uh school boards magazines both the New Jersey and and National and that certainly was in one of the last editions the idea
134that you know what distinguishes our school district from other um you know sources of Education out there for parents so we have to get that information out to them kind of the way a business would look at marketing or branding and I think that the communication would enable us to do that on a regular basis there's a there's so many wonderful things going on in the classroom every single day and I I had the privilege of visiting a number of the classrooms back in June before I even officially came on board and just through one or two days of walking through the schools and seeing in the classrooms let alone all the research I did based on test scores and other types of information this is a a this is a preeminent school district and
135I think that too often people in the community may not be aware of all the wonderful things that are going on so the more ways the more methods that we have to disseminate that information I think the better and I think that also keeps the focus on what I believe our core mission is and what Gwen certainly alluded to and that is the uh instruction delivery of instruction to the children in the district there's also the concern that there could be a need for uh a referendum down the line for additional uh building expansions of facilities and this would certainly create a vehicle to both send out information and receive information by increasing uh areas of communication so it would serve you know more than a dual purpose really a a multi-purpose in that area
136another area that has come up uh so that would be one goal would be would be kind of couched in the area of communication expanded communication another area there's a concern with rising cost in the district and I think that every District faces that um you know certainly you know lack of State funding uh many different you know areas that concerned with that one of the the drivers of cost in any given District are our special education cost and while we certainly want to provide the very best services that these students need we also want to be cognizant of of how we deliver those services and are there more efficient ways to look at that and maybe another way to address that so with that idea what I would like to propose is possibly um
137having an external audit done of our special ed services that would look at all the services from kindergarten through 12th grade and would come up with ideas based on ideas that are being implemented not only in New Jersey but in school districts across the country I've uh had the Good Fortune of having an audit done in another district and for the cost of the audit the information that came back I thought was extremely valuable and it helped really uh bring new ideas and strategies into our district which definitely would benefit our students uh but it also streamlined some of the services as well well so I would like to explore that area as a possible uh idea or method to not only to look at are we providing the best Services we can to the
138students but are we doing it in the most efficient way of course increasing students academic performance is always uh an area that I'm interested in and one of the the ways that I think we need one of the things I think we need to do is to really use data to look at that and uh just like Mr Gorski uh Gorski tonight presented so much information and really had great uh data there to support that I think it's important that we constantly use data to look at how are we delivering education how are the programs working uh how are our students achieving and we have a summer administrators Workshop uh basically called Saul that just occurred uh the last today and Monday and Tuesday and today we had uh we brought in a u a
139company to present uh well actually several companies to present different programs and they were basically both very centered on data uh the initial feedback I received and Dr ACH maybe you could you know elaborate on that that seemed to be very positive on really using that data to disaggregate that uh the student population to really drill down and to look at skill areas and to look at different areas and see are we delivering education uh in an equitable manner across a district uh are these interventions that we're applying are they working how do we know they're working is a data to support that and it's um the technology we we H this district has certainly invested uh considerable Revenue towards technology in this District this type of data and these types of Assessments would work
140very readily with the existing data that we or existing technology that we have so I think it would be a nice complement to what we have in this District to be able to implement some of these uh programs and teachers are they're busy they're busy teaching for them for for us to ask them to now devote time to create something to pull data to type data in to data entry I mean that's really beyond what they should be doing for we're hiring teachers to really care for our children to teach our children to their time should be spent on taking existing data that's presented to them and saying okay now I have this data let me look at how I can apply this in my classroom how can I use this to further benefit the
141students in my classroom or classrooms in the case of middle and high school and how can I use this to really help Drive the instruction so using some of these systems takes the the cumbersome task of typing in something and and creating something and why reinvent the wheel these are there are there are uh systems there are strategies out there there are assessments out there that we can uh certainly use that would apply to our district uh the one uh system that we looked at today actually there's a shared data section where uh constructed item responses that are aligned to park that can be done in any District the number of them in New Jersey are shared and basically what the the person was saying was again why weit the wheel this is already done
142this is it's I mean a lot of teachers do this already through Pinterest and other types of social media uh teachers paying teachers they're out there creating ideas and they're they're sharing them with other teachers so I think that would be a good use of that uh to do that so basically that goal would be revolving around using data to um you know look at our programs and to help inform our instruction with the academic programs not as a separate goal but really part of that is is you probably know I have a very strong interest in uh what I'll call steam the science technology engineering Arts and Mathematics and certainly that would fall under the um what I'm looking to do with uh with in you know driving instruction or informing instruction and with
143that I also looking to try to look at corporations and universities to become our partners uh in helping us uh achieve our goals so in the case of universities um there's many different ways that we can do that by using the expertise of professors of programs of possible apprenticeships internships um anything to bring interest to our students to especially some of the careers that there where there there will be jobs available when they graduate and in the case of Corporations uh very similar type of things where they we they bring in maybe their research scientists and certain uh engineering firms or certain other uh corporations that have those those kind of uh uh people on staff that could come in and help uh find financially certainly that's something I'll be looking at there are a
144number of corporations that offer grants um that really you know would require having a person devoted to that fulltime uh to really go out looking for Grants it's it's a pretty cumbersome process but it is something I am I am interested in doing and I would like to start that process this year to look and see if there are any type of corporate grants out there that can help us with the uh moving the direction we want to move in specifically in the area of uh stem or steam so oh you were writing all that down thank you GW trying to chunk it into categories so that then the bo could think about each of those [Laughter] categories no I'll h give you the microphone back okay thank you yep I've got it um you
145may have noticed on your self assessment um final report that was sent to you today the challenges that you identified um and you did talk about the need to expand public engagement with Community stakeholders that was identified by the board um maintaining teaching and learning as a priority which I think speaks to that um curriculum piece that Mike was just um speaking about um and the use of data um and the audit of special education I think goes to looking at those efficiencies when you were just talking about um to Tom's point about budgetary pieces um doing that audit I think will help you to find perhaps some additional efficiencies I I would point out and Mike didn't point this out but the state only provides you for state for special education based on a
146particular percentage that the state has said a district should have and any percentage of students you have classified above that percentage you get nothing from the state and it's about 14.7 149% that the state says every school district should have so they are only giving school districts special education aid for 14.9 of of the 20% of your total students who are classified so uh I think it's important to note that that's another area where the state is pretty arbitrary in how it remunerates school districts or provides um state aid to them so looking at your special education program making sure that you are providing really high quality services in the most effective and efficient manner um benefits both the district but more importantly it benefits the students um so perhaps that's an area you want
147to think about um but those were the challenges the only one that's not um here that you really identified but I think you have already gotten a handle on that is around the growth of of enrollment and facilities and that is already on the agenda um for you as a board for the administration through the ad hoc committee and through the work that you're doing on that so you may not need to reiterate that as a district goal um but how does this strike the board in terms of um priorities for the following for next year I'm sorry am I in your way can you see this I'm sorry I'm trying desperately not TOS sure let me let me just read them to you um and these are just my notes they're not put into
148goal statements they can be refined into goal statements but expansion of two-way communication not just putting out information but having a dialogue with your community with the stakeholders um through the use of Constant Contact social media um inperson meets and greets at various times with the superintendent um I think that will also go a long way to establishing your new superintendent as your educational leader which is a critical piece that I know the board is interested in um the second one was around an external audit of special education to provide quality services to meet the needs of the children in a more efficient and cost effective Manner and then the third one was to improve student academic performance through data analysis to evaluate program Effectiveness Drive instruction drive and inform instruction in the classroom through
149differentiation and whatever the data shows that needs to be done um within the classroom thoughts Tom I guess my my only concern is how are we going to uh quantify how we going to quantify uh the third item there I think the others um you know we could probably uh we could probably see but how how how would you plan on quantifying the third item third item is which one uh improving student performance through data analysis to evaluate program Effectiveness um my take on that is in terms of of me deliverable so that it's measurable it would be to look at for example the data that comes out of some of the assessments that are being used and then be able to show to the board how instruction was either changed or program was eliminated
150or a program was added to respond to the data that is collected around student achievement because at the end of the day I think that's the point that you're looking to do um is to use that data to drive and improve instruction as well as eliminate programs that perhaps are not as effective as you had hoped they would be and Implement new programs that would be more effective I think I if I correct me if I'm wrong I think the action plan typically has uh the metric that you're going to be using is that correct oh it does it does it it's a they're smart goals so it has to be way to measure it uh and Gwen I would add on on the academic uh part the third goal usually in in that area
151when I would set a goal in in that with that regard I would be looking at a specific area of uh academics so we looked at all the data and we decided that math in grades 6 to 8 was below the area that we were looking hoping to achieve we would look and say well okay what can we do to strengthen our program or the delivery of instruction and how we measure that so if let's say using New Jersey ask data when it was New Jersey ask we saw that there was 80% of the students were proficient in grade six uh and we wanted to raise that to 84% that's an easy way to set a quantifiable goal the challenge that I would have this year is with park being administered last year we don't
152know what those scores are going to look like it's it's going to be pretty tough so what I would like to do if we used that goal we could do it one of two ways certainly the way Gwen mentioned it which was looking at programs although to quantify that it would be kind of tough uh but you can have quality goals as well uh they don't necessarily mean you can you can kind of quantify a qualitative goal if you will uh by assigning some sort of a rubric to it and doing things like that but if we kept it as an academic achievement then I would certainly work with Dr alich and look at the areas we have and the other types of assessment data that we have currently not including park park right now
153is too Volo I just we don't know we haven't got the results we don't know you know how many kids participated didn't we don't so using other types of data we could look at that and see if there's any area from K to 12 that we feel that we would want an improvement in academically and then set goals based on that data so it again would come back to a level of proficiency and increasing that level of proficiency um my my only concern is is there a way to uh to do that say and uh look more at the uh the parity of grades across all the schools because uh I think we we've had that discussion relatively to to to the different schools being in certainly and you know we now we looked at
154two programs today as I was mentioning and the one uh that I was really interested in and I think that re performance matters that received the most uh positive feedback uh that's a a system it's a software system that's used in Montgomery Township it's used in Cherry Hill it's used in uh school districts across the country uh and when you look at it they're usually High performing school districts that use this particular software um that certainly gives us the ability to look at the instruction uh with the outcomes if you will from grade to grade from school to school uh down from student to student I mean this I Doug in particular I was being you're a former math teacher I believe right I was in particular I was kind of wishing you were there
155today because the the the gentleman used a lot of examples in math particular uh and it's it's pretty powerful uh so that would certainly be able to provide us the type of data that we would be able to look at at and you know any good school district just like any good business really needs that data to be looking to look at and to examine are we doing what we hope to do and where are the areas that we are our strengths and where are the areas that we have concerned that we need Improvement on uh but you need the right tools to do that and uh so absolutely I could do that that but I would need the software to to go along with that uh to make that possible I mean you know
156but certainly that's a we can certainly do that uh and you can break it down this I was I was I like data and things like that so I don't know you know I might come across that way but I was really excited about this they can break down that data by um all the different uh you can disaggregate that in almost any way that you want to do it and you can sort it in that way that's basically all just glorify Excel spreadsheets but you can disaggregate it by socioeconomic means by uh ethnicity by uh cohort level by high ability low ability where they're moving what the expect uh expected rate should be the expected growth if you will uh so you can really break it down into multiple different multiple ways and based
157on one of the videos I saw of the of the board meetings here before I was here when I was doing my research to interview I went back and looked at as many uh board videos as I could uh I I do remember hearing that as a a comment uh that actually Dr ACH presented that did a very nice job presenting data um and I think that this would even be able to give us even better data and You by you nodding your head I take that as an affirmative um but and I think that the board would really appreciate uh having that and I certainly think think that it would help our administrators and our teachers to be able to look and say this is working this isn't um and how can I you
158know address this uh Mike I just didn't notice it up there I don't know if it should be included number three but the partnering with the universities and the businesses and the seeking grants yeah I was I was almost afraid to put that out there to be honest with you um Mr robc uh it's something that I've done other districts um I've you know had connections I've met with the provos to drexo I've uh worked I've gone to other corporations and and universities um but again that's a hard and when I try to measure that that's a hard one to measure because you never know what kind of reception you're going to get um you know I had we had Exon Mobile in one District that that sent signs teachers down to uh the mikkelson
159Science Academy for training but sometimes that's a hit or miss uh depending on the corporation so uh and I also you know I wanted to be realistic in looking at we have growing enrollment there's a possibility of putting an ad hoc committee together to be you know which I'm assuming I'll be a part of that to be moving ahead to be looking at possible expansion plus these other goals and I didn't want to overextend myself as well but I wanted to kind of throw it out there that is it's certainly an interest of mine and it's certainly something that I've done before and I would continue to to do that I was just a little reluctant I probably shouldn't have even thrown it out there but I was a little reluctant to throw it out
160there because I would be afraid if I put too many goals out there that they wouldn't be achievable yes the second one the audit of special education it seems to me that that's the bullet point of where you want to save money why can't we do all the programs to see where we could spend money from top to bottom save money from top to bottom well uh I would that's not a bad idea but I would take one step at a time uh the audit for special ed just to give you an idea of the what's involved in that um the the the district that I did that in was only slightly smaller than this district and the amount of time it took to collect the data was probably two to three months they volume
161I mean volumes of data uh and that that was that taxed put that taxed the resources the district because we had people scrambling to gather that data for them to send to them then they came out in three full days of interviews with uh parents with teachers with um they didn't interview students but uh administrators Board of Education members and they took all that and it compiled all that data and then that was that took them another month or two to put that together in a presentation it was a year-long process so I think if we start it with special Aid especially hearing the numbers around 20% um and that could provide a road map for us and I I wouldn't expect anything magical to happen in the first year but it would provide a
162three to five year road map to implement things such as a stronger RTI program which is a which is a it's called Uh the acronym stands for response to intervention and it's part of also something called a um systemwide um of um what's that the other acronym of uh systems and supports but basically the IDE AA is to work primarily in that K to3 area K to2 area and try to provide as many resources as you can to the students before they become classified to try to help students and um you know a lot of times with reading comprehension and reading and writing skills and communication skills and try to work with those students early on to see if you can get them up to the level by the time they're grade three I mean
163there's a lot of Arch it says that if you can get them to reading level by grade three they they're okay you know there's different levels of uh maturity and kids you know Advance at different stages but if you can get them to the same level by grade three you have a better chance it doesn't mean that you won't ever have students classified but it means that it's a more rigorous process before they're classified you go through three tiers the first tier being what kind of interventions can I do right in the classroom and by the way this is this in involves a group of people meeting together and analyzing data and looking and saying what's working what's not and then the second tier is okay what kind of resources can we um apply that
164are maybe uh outside the classroom to bring into the classroom or bring into the student and then the third tier by the time by the time you go through this if the student's still struggling then the third tier is possibly looking at uh either classification or some other kinds of services I'm sorry who's going to do the audit well the way we did it before we put a a um RFP out a request for proposals and we received um we received proposals from I think it was five or six uh companies surprisingly all of them outside of New Jersey to give you an idea of the cost that we were talking about 4,300 students and the cost was around $35,000 to do well the the proposals ranged from anywhere from about 22 to 23,000 up
165to 125,00 we looked at all the proposals and again that's time intensive as well and after reviewing all the proposals uh the group of Administrators that I worked with we then went to the board and presented the companies that we had uh and the one that the company that we recommended based on that and the cost was around $35,000 for that entire audit to be done to be completed that included the you know the people flying in three days uh you know data crunching I mean really over all the the the data that was sent to them plus the data that they were able to collect off of our website the State website uh in different areas that they could go through and I remember a a board members you know after looking at the
166cost he said okay so what does it cost to send one student out of district and we said well you know anywhere from 50 to 100,000 so he said for so for 35,000 you're telling me that we can do an audit of our entire special ed services from K to 12 so the board agreed to do that now I can't guarantee that it would come in at 35,000 I don't know what the prices would come in at but the idea is to at least put something in place to um you know to look at what we're doing and the company that came in and did this in the other District the ideas they brought back were um were wonderful ideas uh you know things we could create in District to help us identify these students
167to provide services uh and they'll take any direction you want the board wants if the board says that if they do see that there's a 20% savings somewhere that they're going to cut the budget for special ed for 20% or 15% whatever it is and you might not see we might had we just might take that money away from those kids who need it the most right and put it someplace else I well uh I can't speak for what could happen but I would certainly think and I would certainly say for myself that it's labeled special education so that's where the money come out of abely absolutely and the idea that I have found and this is not only from this audit but in really my entire time work as an educator I never want
168to take anything away from a student who needs what they what they you know need to do areas some of the areas we did look at though were things like okay so I mean this I I don't want to I don't want to predict something that might not come out of the audit but as one suggestion you have certain number of power professional over the course of a district I mean uh in an entire district is there a better way to deliver the services by maybe putting two teachers together who you have not hiring anybody additional and meeting the needs air is there another way that you can maybe a standard operating procedures so that what you what we found is in some schools when the child study team the case managers met they might
169offer these type of services in another school they might be a little different so it provided more of a consist y of you know how things should be looked at the kind of services uh but it was never ever meant and nor would I ever advocate for anything that would take anything away uh from a student especially our special needs students when I go into those classrooms and I work with those kids your heart goes out to you know not in sympathy of course um but there you know some students are faced with some pretty severe challenges this is not in any way to diminish that not at all all and I would point out just and I'll be quiet um njsba had a special task force looking at special education because it is such
170a significant cost for many almost every school district across the state um and there's a report on the website that talks about doing those kinds of audits finding additional ways to provide quality services at a cost that is more affordable for districts and I think that's the intent here not the demun of services at all for kids right but rather to be able to do it in a way that really meets their needs and perhaps is a way to do it more effectively and and if I could just interd one more thing some of the um and you pull it get the hook to take me off I'm talking too much but some of the uh research has shown that some of the students not the students with more severe needs but some of the
171students who have been classified over the years in many districts and in many states they found that you know looking at students Maybe in seventh or 8ighth grade that a lot of these students just couldn't read and it wasn't that they couldn't it it was that when they were younger maybe reading didn't come as easy to them as it did for other students so maybe by looking at different approaches and more intense Services when they were younger they could we could help them become better readers when they're younger all right so there's a program called reading recovery that was used in a lot of districts around the state and that was a whole of that to put really intense services at these uh for these kids directed to these kids at this young age to
172really help them uh help themselves to achieve those skills so certainly again not to take anything away but to help them early on and give them the services they that they need when they need them it's easier to give it give these services to students at a young age usually by the time they get to be six seventh and eth grade sometimes they become discipline problems because they're they're so frustrated you know it's like going in and and to a foreign country and not understanding the language and you go into to order something in a restaurant and the waiter or waitress keeps on talking to you in the native language and you're saying well I don't really understand and you can't even point to a picture and they're just like keep on speaking there's just
173that lack of communication so the kids get frustrated so the idea again is to is to help them did in your previous District did you find any efficiencies to save you money and if so how much well it was it again it comes back to the direction the Auditors will work in any direction you want so some of the the um the uh the companies that sent us our proposals some of them promised you know and some of those uh companies were asking $125,000 they promised all kinds of savings and when we looked into them and these proposals are sometimes 100 Pages longer more their basic strategy was to go to all your aded District students and bring them back in the district well first of all that's not always effective sometimes the district doesn't
174have the resources needed for those students so it's a short-term win that you might save money the first year and then you find out that it doesn't work for the students you don't have the resources it's really not sustainable so we looked at we were looking for very specific things this District might look at something else if we said to these um companies we want to look specifically at how can we say save money they'll do that if we say to them we want to look at ways to um provide uh consistent measures of how we apply our services to special ed students they'll do that they'll do both if you want to a limit they'll you know how many goals it's something that's achievable so it's it's hard for me to say that they'll
175come in and do any one thing they come in it's it's individual they come in they sit down with the administration they sit down with the Board of Education and they they talk to and they look at all the data and then not only do they get your input they get the input of teachers of parents uh of you know they look at all this and then they come back and they make recommendations it's not mandated they say based on all the information based on the direction you gave us here's what we recommend and to move forward so I I found it very interesting I'd be foolish to sit here and promise you anything and to say if we do this we will save X number of dollars I can't do that that would be
176irresponsible for me to do that I can however say having gone through this I've had audits in two separate districts that I thought were very informative that the information that came out of both of those audits really helped our child study team our special ed teachers our administrators our principes our general Ed teachers uh and ultimately that benefited our students and it's it's hard benefiting the students that you can't look and say well did they increased or test scores right away you know did you decrease the number of students who are classified that's over a 3 to 5e period there's no magic uh bullet or fixes that you know you can come in these are complicated issues you know we're talking about kids here we're not selling products uh we're talking about kids lives you
177know and and they get one one chance at each grade we don't want to mess it up you know we want to do is the best we can for these kids uh so it's really with the goal of looking how can we improve uh the services and just in all fairness I I you know because this is a board of committees when I spoke to uh Mr P about this you know I was going to bring this to the curriculum committee uh as a topic but um since we were talking about goals and the committee meetings are tomorrow night I thought it best to address it tonight yes um talking about data and and data Gathering I have no objection that I think it's it's good um but to and across the board not just
178for special education I mean I think we should do some type of data Gathering and then um you know analysis and everything by by the leadership uh teams but my as a goal that I would like and we it's sort of a raw goal like we can sort of um refine it but is disseminating this information by explanation not by raw data oh absolutely and and by perhaps and I don't know how feasible this is perhaps having workshops in at least one Workshop a year a school year in each school about that school about the data you gather depending on what what direction it goes in and have teachers administrators and parents and you know even maybe us once in a while they attend these workshops just to listen I mean that's an Outreach it's
179data Gathering it's helping people explain again it's just an idea some kind of goal I'd like to see well it would be I would think part of the action plan for both the communications goal and the data analysis piece would be part of your action plan that would that would include that Outreach to the community at least once a year with explanations around the data to help educate and inform parents yes but it but more specific than that that's too broad I'd like to see um a a goal of actually communicating in each school well if I could speak to that for a second part of what my goal would be uh is to make the use of data not a special event but an ongoing type of the way it's used so for instance
180one of the things that I've always stressed is when parents come in for parent teacher conferences and I haven't been here in Monroe so I'll certainly speak of my own experience as a parent parent and I'll certainly speak of districts that I've worked in too often a parent comes in and we and you know you sit down with your son or daughter's teacher and yes they're doing great here's the report card maybe this or that wouldn't it be nicer to have here's the reading level that your son or daughter had in September and here are some interventions and here's where they ended up here here's where math is here's a so that the use of data doesn't become a special event it comes embedded throughout the district now as far as special presentations by school
181we have to be careful with some of this as well the one system I looked at today that I like because there's with an easy click on the part of the software you get rid of the names we are very we have to be very careful with the use of student data uh and also teacher data and how that is disseminated we can't identify specific things we can certainly look at it by school we can look at it by District to present the data out to the school and to the parents uh I certainly would talk to the principles I think that's certainly a a place that when they have parent meetings whether it's a back to school might be a little early for that right but at different times during the year that they
182can certainly um you know we used to do some things in different districts where maybe on a certain night uh we would have something at 7 but at 6:00 we'd have parents invited in to look at a special presentation maybe on on a program on data on you know we used to do it for when Park was coming in we did it when the Common Core was so it would be a special walk in the park night or a common core night and we invite parents out just for about an hour more than that we may still be excited but you know the eyes glaze over presentations are great we we and I think they're informative but I'm looking more of an an engagement with parents an opportunity for them not to be spoken to
183but to be more like a round table kind of thing so that would be something that I would see as a district goal some somewhere uh I I could be off base here and Gwen I I'll certainly ask you to tell me if I am but I I think it's it's the responsibility and duty of the board tonight to essentially set some goals and not get into uh how those goals are going to be accomplished because that's really getting into the action plan and that's the job of the superintendent and the administration and the building principles to design how are we going to accomplish that goal our I think we just need to focus on what do we want those goals to be and let them determine what the action plan is uh because if
184we get into discussing how we want them to do it I mean we'll be here till midnight just trying to figure out one goal uh I I also want to be I'm I'm I I'm a little leery of having too many goals particularly in your first year Dr kak because you're new to the community you're new to the district so I would say let's don't go beyond two or three District goals I I would not recommend going Beyond three District goals which which is why might came up with those three I threw them up here um the board is responsible for saying what they want to see happen expand Communications evaluate programs um Outreach to the community the how it happens Doug is absolutely correct is the responsibility of the administration and you will be
185able to see that happen through the development of action plans that will outline the house here's how we're going to accomplish that goal which I think would incorporate what you were just talking about in terms of those roundtables dialogues and and I think that's reflected in the two-way communication piece um those action plans will come to the board so that you can see them you don't get to approve them or disapprove them you will hold your superintendent accountable for his performance at the annual evaluation now when you look at those action plans and if you see that there's something that you think is so critically important that's missing certainly it's worthy of a suggestion to the superintendent um but the how those things happen is really their job you need to say what you want
186to see happen and how it happen is really his responsibility and the onuses on your Administration to make that happen L yes so we got three of these up here right these are the big ticket items right correct the way I see it two of two of them I can measure easy I could put Dynamics again I could put analytics against I could figure out whether we're good or bad one we can't do is the communication communication one that we have as it as it's outlined there is not measurable and my concern is that we're missing one entirely important goal that's nobody isn't brought up and that's the addressing an immediate need of addressing the growth and facility needs that we have in this District that is a goal that is should be number one
187goal of that a deliverable can be expansion of the community expansion of the communication because having lived through that a couple of times here there's not just the immediate need of getting information out about what we're doing but managing dis and misinformation because sometimes not every everybody agrees with what we're doing and there could be a contra group that's going to go out there and kind of say the reverse of everything we're doing it so that should be a deliverable or an action item of the meeting of the district's facility and growth needs as being the goal make that a deliverable instead of a goal that's the goal is important stuff that communication one the when we have it out out there right now the constant contact thing or social media or stuff that's a
188byproduct or or an action item of a bigger goal the bigger goal in my mind should be the facility and growth issue but that's just me thoughts can can I ask you a question okay so um I agree with what you're saying and and and that's certainly an important area and I guess for my purposes the question is are there are there board goals and then are there District goals as separate goals or are we looking at one and the same are the board and District the same here they not the board goals refer to their processes and procedures and they should in a sense support the district goals but the district goals are your responsibilities not the board now if one of the goals was to address the enrollment growth and Facilities needs then
189perhaps one of the board goals is to help communicate the need for a referendum or to support the solutions developed at as a part where the board supports the administration but not doing the administrative work yeah and Mr gofman just so you know I mean I did think about that as listing that as one of my goals but I also knew that there was talk of an ad hoc committee and and I thought that might become a board goal and certainly a board goal I feel that even though I'm not a a member of the board if you will a voting member of the board that's a certainly something that I would be very heavily involved with uh but I can certainly change this goal to to make that more of to deal with the
190expansion because that is a very real issue I agree in the past so what we did was it was a uh superintendent goal because you know you would be the educational leader leading the you know be you know leading the ad hoc to a certain extent we have a chairman that ran it but you kind of lead and guide us you know through the forest right um but the board in their goal would be to support your activities there attend the meetings participate in other working groups that might break out there and clearly you know if there's policy changes that need to happen or whatever we support that infrastructure to make that as a deliverable but I think it's so important that it needs it needs to be like the the the the big goals
191yeah because there's so much tie to it if I can uh just to clarify and maybe it's only going to confuse the issue L uh last year when we discussed and adopted District goals and board goals okay um it was a board goal to uh receive review and act on the recommendations of the ad hoc committee on growth and Facilities so that was a board goal last year uh I don't think any of us are denying the importance of of of what we have to tackle uh but there may be some confusion as to what category does it fall in is it a district goal or is it a board goal uh and I don't know if it makes a a big difference one way or the other because we know it's the it's got
192to be done you know uh so maybe Gwen you can throw some and I would think that it really is the superintendent goal meaning it's a district goal because you're going to have to mobilize all the resources of the district to develop a plan and then to begin that process moving forward your business administrator is going to be intimately involved as you complete the question for the referendum and you get Bond counsel etc etc I think to lose point the board goal should really be to support the efforts and plan that is developed and recommended by the administration take care of either way I just think it's like you mentioned it's a district goal that that's where that should be yeah I would agree for my own I I'm fine with that I think that's
193a good point so would the board be comfortable with um implementation of a plan to address growing enrollment and and Facilities needs that's a good way to put sounds good enough for me thank you Lou although that will never happen without good communication I think instead of impation when if I may instead of implementation I think it's just development of a plan because wouldn't the implementation be the actual uh the building itself well I think it's beyond just the need to develop a plan I think you need to move forward right so I think it's perhaps to plan and begin implementation in other words I don't think the board wants to go another year without a solution am I wrong I mean I mean I think you there's a more immediate need so I didn't
194want to just say a plan because that would seem to me to say we have until June to figure out what we need to do and I'm not sure that you have that full year but that's up to the board I'll write however you would like um but I I think it's a more immediate need perhaps and maybe I'm interpreting it incorrectly no I think you're right I mean I think we need to have a plan and start to move forward whether you know and and I would tell you if it's a if the plan ends up being a referendum that's a multi-year goal because you're not going to accomplish it in one year in a year you might be able to get that referendum on the ballot hopefully it passes in year two you're
195going to begin going out for bids beginning construction it's going to take you know it's a 36 48 month goal essentially to do this between the time you decide to do it and the time you open a new facility of whatever type that happens to be so it becomes a multi-year goal and I think you need to chunk that in your action plan here's what can happen in your you know what you intend to do in year one year two year three and year four and that will depend on the plan that you all agree to um moving forward that's why I think it should be develop and Implement because in the action thing we'll see the development of the plan [Music] and then you'll make the I'm assuming you will make the communication piece
196uh an action item under that goal around to support the goal when I just just on one of the handouts you gave us yes says everyone owns the district goals the superintendent in our case is responsible for their completion so so technically we are we are and and we're doing it now but we are involved in the setting the district goals not just the superintendent oh absolutely that's that's why we're having this discussion I mean truly the board goals and the district goals need to align no the board goals and District goals will will absolutely mesh but my point is it's not just with all du respect to you that your position on the district goals it's collaboration it is it is a collaboration and and that's why but we always begin with really asking
197your educational leader what they have identified because they are your educational leader they are responsible for the full District we really begin and then the board says you know yeah but no we need something else to lose point this is really the burning priority and that would needs to take precedence so I'm just reading the hand down okay good job all right good points from reading that now everybody reads everything okay are you all comfortable with those three goals so the first one would be the develop to develop and Implement a plan again this is not in final language but uh a plan to address um enrollment growth and Facilities needs external audit of special education to provide quality services to meet the needs of children in a more efficient and cost-effective manner um and
198then improving student academic performance through data analysis to evaluate program Effectiveness drive and inform instruction can I just yes please proove academic performance goad but we can use whatever language you would like yeah to improve the academic performance without having the benefit of having at least a year in the district and even though I looked at a lot of the data the data that I looked at the New Jersey ask is no longer relevant and we don't have Park data so I'll be looking at new data um it would be hard for me at this point tonight to be saying specifically yes I'm going to improve academic data could we possibly change that to um you know using at least data to uh you know help inform what we're doing uh I because I do
199want to quantify things and I have done that very much in the past where I've Quantified you know 3% 5% 6.2 I've done all that but I'm just without even knowing what data I'm going to be even looking at at this point I think it would be a little hard to quantify it just at this point you want to say using um most current data no but he's to inform you yeah using data sources to inform or instruction and I can certainly wanty that I guess or or at least qualify that with showing the steps that was that were taken to provide the tools to provide the uh you know the resources for administrators and teachers to use and then be and once we have those systems in place it'll be much easier than to
200quantify and say now that we've looked at the existing data I think in this area this grade and that grade we can certainly look to improve the academic achievement is if that's fair with the board if that's agree you know if you're agreeable to that well I I I I just want to be careful that this this communication item that we first put up there uh is not lost sight of because uh I think the district has recognized it's in our strategic plan that we developed some years ago as one of the goals was to improve communication uh I think in our own self- evaluation we felt as if we were lacking in community relations and communication and uh certainly when it comes to talking about a building referendum Communications will be vital to that
201but uh what we need to communicate both two way extends Beyond just the building referendum you know I I think we need to be we need to be talking to parents in terms of are you happy with with the instruction your children are getting are you happy with this program I mean you can get a lot of valuable feedback from parents that way uh you know are you comfortable with with the uh homework assignments you know the length of homework the amount of homework are are you comfortable with our starting time Etc you know all kinds of different question questions can come up that have nothing to do with the building referendum but that have to do with the quality of your school system and I think it's very important because I I've always felt
202we didn't do enough communicating in the community particularly with with these huge number of uh you know uh retired citizens that we have that that provide so much of the tax money to the community uh we're we're there's not there's really minimal communication that's occurring there uh and I think it's important that we don't lose sight that communication maybe needs to be a separate District goal the Improvement of communication and in terms of how do you measure how do you measure it excuse me how do you measure it EAS to be accountable for how you measure it well how many times did something go out this way or that way I know Dr kak has already set up uh this email newsletter okay and people can get his newsletter once I don't think you've done
203your first one yet the the opening letter is out there but but uh where you can receive the uh his newsletter you don't have to go to a website you don't have to get the newspaper it'll simply come in your email and I thought that's a fantastic way to communicate or if I set up meetings at different places maybe for a year or whatever that would be another way to measure it as well I think it's all my challenge is over the last few years because we used to have the the what would the what would I forgot what we called it was key communicators n we had a we had a newsletter we sent out like every month School Story School Story sending it out and getting it read two totally different things oh
204I understand that I understand that and I actually thought it was a waste of time and money from what was in there I thought it was a lot of fluff and not a lot of substance but we have that channel 28 Comm uh uh you know the the Community Access station a lot of people watch that and a lot of people watch it and I think we make minimal use of it we have that fantastic TV studio right here in the high school that I think we're making minimal use of that and I think we can make a lot more use of those things in terms of communicating to the public uh that wouldn't necessarily be so costly like sending out a hard copy of a newspaper that you don't know if anybody reads it
205or not well you don't know if people are going to tune in but they're more likely to tune in because I I just know from the way people talk I don't know about you Marvin your community but I know in my community they watch Channel 28 I'm I'm amazed that how many people do watch and I might tell you that I just had a com I just just had a comment yesterday guy told me he watched our last meeting and there's no reason why we shouldn't get paid more than the Town [Applause] Council so so so I don't want to lose side of the point I just feel that Communications is important enough and it's been so lacking and it's been identified over and over again it's in our strategic plan it's in our board
206self evaluation that we need to make it a district goal okay I president po I think You' sort of contradicted yourself though I mean we didn't want to give Dr kak too much but could we ask him to take one more little goal well I think it's a matter of deciding which of these are are do we want to go with we don't necessarily have to go with all of them well there's only four now if if we well there's three well currently we added the facilities one and we said you could subsume the communications piece is an action piece under that but I think Doug's point is it's too important to subsume it under the facilities enrollment goal right so then the question becomes are you comfortable with having four goals as opposed to
207three I think that's a lot not that I'm putting you on the spot or anything no not at all in this CER fa not a problem uh I am comfortable with four uh with all due respect I just hope that everyone remembers this come next May or June you know uh because there will be a lot of work in each one of those goals the you know certainly getting the information out about uh the possible referendum and and I mean that's a lot of time as well yeah the meet and greets the those kind that takes a lot of time the special ed audit takes a lot of time and certainly using data but I think they're all really valuable and important things for the district so I would God bless you God bless you
208bless you I would like to take I think the four goals are are um you know I don't mind doing that I I I feel like I'm I'm a hard worker and I'll I'll I'll do that and I think I have a great team here but I would also ask that that I'm uh able to afford the uh the some of the resources that I will need to accomplish that such as if we do an audit then it there be request for proposals there will be a cost to that if we hire someone if we use the data there will be a cost to get one of those Data Systems uh not an outrageous cost well that's too relative of a term but you know for me to attempt to to accomplish these goals I
209do need resources to be able to do that so and and again if it comes to the point where the audit recommendations come in special and proposals and the board says no we don't want to do that that's okay but then I I won't be able to accomplish that part of it Mike just fast question the data systems is that a one-time uh cost or once you buy it you have it usually usually it's a one-time cost but there with any service um there's always an annual cost with it the the annual cost from my experience and from what I even heard today it's minimal compared to the initial cost the initial cost is they have to upload your data there's professional development to train people so that first year you get hit a little
210harder and after that once it's up and running there were maintenance fees some of them as low as a few hundred some some uh you know few thousand doll uh it would vary and I I with all you know in all honesty I don't have we didn't get to that part of the conversation to get actual quotes today was just a presentation but um there are some recurring cost as with with any system even the systems we're using now there's always a recurring cost yeah I'm just going to say one more thing about the communication thing and then I'll shut up I promise for the rest of night probably um don't promise I think what's going to happen is when we go and we start doing the things that we outlined here in these goals
211especially the the district growth and Facilities thing a lot of these things are going to happen by attrition right so the community involvement is going to happen because you're going to have ad hoc the dissemination of information is going to happen because the PTO people will be there they'll get out this information you're going to have the coffee things anyway to talk about the district plans and all these other types of things so a lot of that stuff is going to happen by attrition that's also something that we're going to be able to measure too because Steve I think you could remember when we had the last ad hoc the very last ad hoc meeting wasn't the best meeting right so we kind of got that if we're trying to think think about how we
212measure things and what what's quantifiable that we could figure whether it was a good thing or a bad thing those three we could do right and the communication thing because it's a byproduct of what we're going to do and it was a byproduct of what we had in some of those meetings we're going to know if we're getting our message across if it's if it's going well or information's dropped off or disinformation caused us to derail or or who knows what happened so I think Doug's point is valid it's very very important does it rise to a goal level I will still say no because it will be assumed by literally all of those other activities that are up there because we're going to have to be telling people why we're spending money on special
213education audit and it could go the other way we could do the audit and find out we're underfunded you don't know because it goes the way right the other things that we have up here about analytics about re viewing where we are for the performance there's numbers you could tie those to things and we could figure out what we're doing and where we can cut cost and how things are going to go better so again I'm just going to say one last thing that I think that the communication piece a lot of the things we have relative to communication we already have at play we have the Global Connect thing when we have to send out an emergency notice there's a lot of things that we already have today we have Channel 28 that'll continue
214if we're going to talk about uh communication expansion you know maybe you can host these TV events talking about the the the referendum thing and have it education night on Channel 28 there's so many other things you can put in there but there pieces of that other deliverable it's again I'll just say I don't think it rises to the level of a communication goal because it's going to be interwoven into all of those so what does the rest of the board feel um just I've been here just a little bit longer than Lou and even before I got on the board the number one issue has always been Communications so no matter what we did or how we did it people would still say well you're not communicating I didn't get the message and we
215do a lot more communicating than we did 15 or 20 years ago um I I I do think we can do all the communicating we want we can't make people read what we what we're disseminating and I think that's the issue um maybe a communication survey to see how the best way to communicate we had a a we used to have a community relations committee remember and we had the whole Community coming together and they would disseminate back to whatever organization whether it was a PRC whether it was the PT whether it was the League of Women Voters and we still got well we don't get any of the information so I I I I believe with what Lou says that communication is part of everything we do but I don't think it needs to
216be the goal that that what we're doing everything we do needs to be communicated we just have to keep working on finding that best way to reach everybody back in the day I made a comment at a board meeting we literally used every medium of communication except smoke signals we had literally print we had video we have stuff now where you can see our board meetings Channel 28 because they're archived there's so much out there and we still have people coming in getting it wrong because they heard from somebody else and telephone or what have you so again um that I I said I should up but I love other thoughts from board members perhaps what we need perhaps what we need is an organization an an organized process of using Channel 28 the problem
217on Channel 28 frequently is we have some School production that was recorded by some amateurs you can't hear them well you can't see them well and I'd rather have nothing on that channel than that kind of junk and that's a problem we have Channel we have the studio as you said before but we've never invested in people to run that studio and that's what we need if we're going to be the eyes and ears to this [Music] community I just want to add I mean I'm I feel kind of funny because I'm agreeing with everybody uh so one thing I Michael one thing you said I think that we need to be aware of is is uh I think a live kind of communication where like like in in the library or you're going to
218a development or something where they can actually because we had Channel 28 which I think is great um we've had articles written and sent out but and and admittedly that they haven't served the the the purpose or the goal successfully uh but I I I wonder how often we tried actually sitting down with people like there you are and inviting them to come see you in the library or going into the library where so many people are there every day and I have to agree with that inperson you can send out all kinds of communication but in-person communication is still I think probably the best way now having said that one of the board members already has me scheduled to uh for an an in-person uh meeting and I certainly yes Mr Braverman thank you
219and I certainly welcome that uh I I would certainly be relying on the board members to help me with identify where would be the best place you know or is a community center or a different place uh to help me with that as members of the community I would certainly need your guidance and assistance in that matter to you know identify important areas that I could go to so um that and I think that would help that that inperson communication in addition to the other kinds of communication one thing you can do this year right now don't have multiple back to school nights on the same night give the school time to have you present you should be at every single back to school night don't double up on the back to school nights cuz
220board members are challenged too if they want to go to a back to school night they got to kind of split between this school or that school don't double them up I and and I haven't looked at that schedule yet but I agree I usually go to all the back to school nights and the other problem uh that that having back to school nights on the same night presents is uh parents with kids in different schools different grade levels now if if it's their sister school I mean they're across the town and they're on the same night it they wouldn't affect the parents I understand that uh I know that scheduling has got to be you know it not got to be scheduling is a nightmare when you try to schedule that I um Dr
221awich do we have the back to school night scheduled are there are there any on the same nights there may be because the the problem is there's only so many evenings I'm sorry there's only so many evenings in September um that they're able to schedule them and with eight schools that's the difficult piece so um there may be somewhere it may be Woodland and Brookside may be on the same night because it doesn't involve the same part could we stagger the times done that where maybe one starts at six and one starts at seven I'll go to to one school at six maybe just short reading to people um talk to some people and then they usually want to go out and see their their kids teachers and then that'll give me time to get
222to the next school um so maybe that's a way that we can look at all right so where are we in terms of the communication piece does the board want to just not have that as a separate goal Doug would you be comfortable with not having it as a separate goal well I as I sat and listened to the to the communication that happened here tonight it became apparent that communication is quite important and yet uh many people voice the fact that it has been less than effective which to me raises the need to improve Communications so personally I feel we need to set as one of the district goals the Improvement of communications but I you know I I'm just one person right we could go with four goals as as when you mentioned
223well I I I would rather I would rather go with a few goals that we can really do well that that we don't have to spread yourselves too thinly to try to get them done and and while we do it because I think one of the things that we were lacking on in the past is that we get timely progress reports on how are how is that goal developing so that we can we see the action plan by a certain date this was supposed to have taken place and then somebody reports back to the board that did or did not take place or well we didn't quite finish it we expect to finish it this coming month uh because sometimes we don't get those progress reports and that was something else that was mentioned in
224this board self- evaluation and I would strongly suggest looking at your board calendar and identifying three meetings between now and May and do an update on the district goals exactly that way label it as such give it on whatever goals you agree upon on each of those areas and provide an update I mean I think that's really helpful oftentimes boards get that information but it may not be labeled an update and so you all are so busy and there's so much going on sometimes you lose track that you've gotten that information so I think labeling it as such it also helps your community to really those who are watching it on 28 or who may be in the audience to really understand these are our areas of focus this is what's going on this is
225what we've accomplished and I think that's an important piece for them as well so I can build that into the action plan okay and and the board should you know we should put that on the agenda too so we'll Identify two or three times between September and June absolutely perfect okay but we have no resolution here on on the goals yes Jill I think since the data one and the special ed one are both going to cost money we should eliminate one of those and I think in my opinion we should eliminate the student data one because the special ed one will look at efficiencies and that may help us um in other areas in money money or in maybe even classroom space that's just or delivery of program or a delivery of program I
226know the student data is your something you love well can would it be fair to say that if we eliminate it as a goal that if it's affordable and that can still be accomplished that we still proceed with using data or using some sort of way to measure data yeah I'm it's a freebie goal if it's what like a freebie goal a freebie go now I I I actually think that one of the things that we've always talked about is efficiency and getting efficiency across the board I almost think that that's very very important I mean uh data the the data and because we're looking for efficiency and Effectiveness and as Mr Gorski pointed out in order to get to the numbers that we need we're going to have to be very effective not necessarily
227cut things but very efficient and effective and that is going to be a clear way I mean sometimes you have to spend a some money in order to to save a larger amount so um you know depending on what the numbers are we could always say that it's it's unaffordable if we find that sure yeah and if we say it's unaffordable then it wouldn't be fair to Dr kak to say he did not you know get his goal measured so I think this segment of this meeting should be very clearly um uh or you you should have a very good minutes on this SE segment and keep it in your file I just want to add for use of data jel I understand where you're coming from but I think uh you know having data
228as uh really systemic part of your of your system is key in in maintaining academic Excellence is one of the things that we pride ourselves on here and and uh if we lose s sight of that we may see some diminishing returns there and I hate to see that happen he's agreed for Mar I I personally I don't see it as a goal I see it some as something that should be ongoing and it it's just it's just something that should just keep on going it shouldn't be a goal except pulling it out of the air somewhere okay so would the board be some exent anyway we're yeah our district has been doing that for the last two years using data to help with I'm sorry I didn't mean to interrupt uh using data I
229think that was something that the board two or three years ago had said that we would start to do that and I think we've been moving in that direction more and more okay well in a couple things there yes the data should be ongoing it should just be a part of that and I and also to what you're saying I think data use the use of data is ongoing in the district I guess from my point of view it would be to expand that um use of data uh there's many and many different ways that collect the data and in all fairness you know with Dr but she she knows more about this than I do uh based on the what you saw today not to put you on the spot but based on what
230you saw today in the systems we have in place do you think what we saw today would be a duplication of what we have the program that we saw today I don't think would be a duplication of what we have in place but I think it would definitely enhance what we're already doing part of um what we do right now is in K to2 is the RTI process the response to intervention process and that each team at each of those schools meets every eight weeks that's the reading specialist the basic skill teacher the classroom teacher and and the principal and they look at the what Dr kak mentioned the tiers of intervention um and how they can help these students and really looking at what the teacher can do in the classroom so it's not
231an extra cost first so looking at what the teacher can do in the classroom how they can differentiate their instruction in the classroom right now that process is paper based so every child the the the principal has a binder about 6 Ines thick by the end of the school year of all of that data so to have something like we saw today to be able to input that data in and give us instant analysis would save time for all of those um um certificated staff that's that's putting in so much time to do this to meet the needs of the students it would enhance what we're already doing okay so is that like a software program that you're looking at or couldn't that be put in the budget as a priority yeah that's what I'm
232in that's what I'm saying it doesn't necessarily have to be a goal it could be it really should should really should be just an ongoing part of operations but when I was looking and listening to all the different concerns and different items brought up uh and the data one in particular I went back to whatever month it was last year I mean I looked at so many videos uh I don't remember what month but I I pulled that out of one of the um the board presentations or the the board meetings so I I put it up as a goal to float it out there to see but if but I do agree it's really it's not a goal so much as it should be just a part of operations yeah yeah that's the way
233I see it too yeah so we will remove it as a goal it will be part of standard operating procedure implemented through the budgetary process hopefully as a priority and then we will keep the first goal around addressing enrollment and Facilities needs the second one around Communications and the third one around special education is that good for the board okay all right perfect um the last real piece to this evening is really looking at your board goals um I have up there the goals that you had for 201415 um I'm delighted to say that the first one we absolutely can say with certainty you accomplished sitting there we don't know yet okay um secondarily oh wait see I knew that one not only did we accomplish it I think we did a good job you
234did that's what I mean um secondarily you completed the board's self- evaluation um I would hope that moving forward that all of you will participate in that process moving forward this this year we you know it was more of you than last year there wasn't even five of you that completed it last year so this year we got to seven which was great um so that I would say is partially complete um but but hopefully next year you will do it again and really be able to look at how you have functioned um does does does the Jamesburg representative uh complete that part he should have completed so we should have had 10 yes you should have had 10 absolutely because he's a full voting member of the board even though his voting is limited
235to items that concern Jamesburg he is still a full voting member of the board um the last the next one and you'll have to tell me review the board know I just want to clarify he might have done it I'm not saying he didn't I I don't believe he did because he was not on the well I know why because and and it is a point here um he was not on the district listing which meant he couldn't get in to access it and I don't have access to the database it does require your business administrator to go in and do that so moving forward just so you know Mike you need to go in and enter him as a member of your board or whoever is the Jamesburg representative after reorganization so that they
236can then participate in those processes because if he's not on the board list don't F and interestingly enough in nine out of 10 times when we have a send receive they're never listed and I don't know why and we keep after our it people because for us in the field it's a problem with board members they get upset and I don't blame them and then the Bas get upset because the board members complain so we want them we want them listed because they are part of the board they absolutely are um review the committee the board committee organization structure and processes I don't know what you accomplished in light of that this year nothing nothing is that still something that you wish would wish to carry forward looking at your committee structure and how you
237work through that I don't know well there's probably a need once again based on use the mic Mr things that I read in the board self evaluation there there's probably a need for us to uh SP spend some time talking about that uh in terms of the communication among the various committees uh among themselves as well as communicating with the full board uh I noticed that some some members of the board said that uh that communication was not happening they didn't always know what was going on until they got to the board meeting or until they got you know to something a and so there seems to be a need for us to uh do something with the processes probably and I'm sorry but Mike if I'm wrong correct me didn't you say that you
238were going to put in in in your every Friday your report that uh the updates the committee reports you're uh once again you're you're uh very timely in your in your statement there I did and it's actually a lot of information is already there I I haven't gone through that and shared it with everybody because I talked to Mr Washington Reggie Washington the the IT director and we were trying to figure out how he could come in and offer a training to the board on showing you how to access it but I already started putting agendas in there it's all set up almost set up and ready to go uh and that would certainly it would be uh a shared folder so that everyone would have access to it you would well as board members
239it would only be available to board members but if the committee met on a Tuesday night and the information was put in on Wednesday with the notes in the agenda then everybody especially the people who are not a members of that committee would be able to access that so we're pretty much ready to roll it's just a matter of trying to figure out when I can get that training in because I think there's varying levels of comfort with you using uh Google share drive so um as soon as I can get that training in we're we're ready to go and hopefully that'll help with that process okay will that address that concern uh well I'm not sure because I don't know you know uh if there's other members of the board that have concerns I
240know Mr Port President we had a discussion about uh what members can be on certain committees and you had told me that we were that's part of our board goals to address that committee structure and uh the members of the Committees so well yes that does bring to mind two questions I know uh there was a question about which committees could the Jamesburg rep be on or or should should should not be on you know that and I don't think we've actually definitively discussed that or had that resolved and uh we would probably need to get a board attorney's advice on that and the other question uh wait a minute sorry it was there and now it's gone Story of My Life everybody's play oh there was also the question although I I keep revisiting
241it because I I guess I'm finding it difficult to accept the answer in terms of how many people can be on our Comm committees because of of the makeup of our board and and what some and what gets discussed at some of those committees because sometimes the committee is only discussing items which have nothing to do with Jamesburg and yet the Jamesburg rep may be on that committee and we and in a case like that we should not have five members present at the committee meeting at least that's my un my understanding of the way it works because then we have a quorum right you cannot have a quorum for a committee meeting that's right no matter who constitut that Quorum on that topic I just want to reiterate the legal opinion that I had
242from V lordy at the time at w and and um she emphatically said that in the instance where a matter has nothing to do with one of those four items that Jamesburg is statutorily able to vote on a quarum still exists of six not five because it's not a James vote and you exclude him it's still the majority of the members Seated on the board which is six six that's the opinion from V Lordi okay keep in mind you don't vote in a committee either you only recommend to the full board but you still can't have a quorum that's key right but you still can't have a quorum quum would so you can have five people but you can't have six correct so five people on any of the Committees in Monroe Township's District right
243can be present correct so okay so six is the Quorum regardless of whether the jamesb representative is a voting member or a presid okay oh and also I think going forward uh Mr President I think that we also may want to talk about maybe potentially different uh committees I I know uh Miss karanovich brought up tonight that there used to be a a community outreach or something relations commit community relations um that may be something we may want to look at especially with the concerns of the board as our Communications with the public concerns that may be something we may want to revisit and so I think personally yeah maybe a technology committee I think personally it might be something good to keep as a board goal going forward so so certainly you can keep
244that as a as a board goal so just and I just made some notes here around which ones you want to have what is the makeup how are you going to communicate I mean to the go doc piece which is fine any other thoughts around District goals I mean excuse me board goals would you would you like to have a board goal around support of the plan for the facilities and enrollment growth since the board goals should support the administration's goals makes sense yes no how do you measure a support you don't have to measure it oh it it well how do you measure you're not in terms of the boards you're not really measuring it in the same way you would be measuring the superintendent's performance but you would be looking at I I
245that's very hard to answer because it depends on what it turns out to be is the solution for your enrollment growth if you decide not to go out to referendum then you're not going to be going to public meetings supporting a referendum and talking about it and educating the public you might be doing something altogether different I don't know because I don't know what the plan will look like um but so maybe that's not an appropriate goal then maybe that's not do you I guess my question is with the superintendent goals they have to be measurable correct the board's goals have to be as measurable cor no they do not okay that was where that question came from they do not I mean they they can be as measurable but they don't have to be
246because you're not employed you're elected okay then that's fine okay does that work for the board or are there other things that are of concern to you you're looking skeptical though I don't know did we did we conclude the discussion on the Committees I don't know do we does anyone have anything to add well I I'd like to say that our committee makeup uh we have a policy for that and I think the policy committee can handle that I don't think that has to be a board goal um so you think it can be addressed through revision to policy right make a recommendation to the board and the board would vote on it you you could do it in that fashion if you wanted as well um it it's really up to the board to
247I'd like to see it kept as a board goal obviously it was a on there last year policy didn't do anything about it um and I think that it's it's pretty important at this point that we come up with something um I think it's asking too much of policy policy typically has a full plate and I think that this is important to have this as a board goal well and one of the outcomes to looking at this may be to make recommendations to policy with revisions to whatever current policy exists so if you're going to change for example and you're going to add a community engage committee or you're going to add a technology committee you would probably need to add that to the policy so that could be a recommendation from the full board
248to the policy committee to make those revisions um to your existing policy so you could do it in that fashion as well but in terms of a second board goal does that work to provide appropriate support in your role as board members um once the plan is developed for addressing enrollment growth and Facilities who wrote this are you just so tired and sleepy you just want me to be quiet and that's okay if you say that too I'd be happy to do that money pardon me be committed to finance you're not committing you're supporting you're agreeing to provide support to whatever plan may be recommended but before it can go forward the board has to approve that plan so you're not going to support something you don't approve of do okay so you're not committing
249yourself to any one plan here or any one solution You're simply saying as a board when that recommendation is made and whatever that recommendation is that the board finally approves then you will provide appropriate support is that good okay okay I will get all of this back to Doug and Mike in the form of a memo um so you will be able to review it hopefully you will have it by next week's board meeting please tell me it's not Monday night oh if you wanted to add a third goal okay um I think it would be nice to get 100% of the board to complete the um 2015 board self- evaluation and the superintendent evaluation you can't get 100% on the super well I know that 100% of the 100 of non-conflicted board members for
250the supal and 100% board remember participation for the self you it's 100% if you're conflicted out you're conflicted out you don't get counted as not participating that's not your choice that's the state's choice for you so um that would be fine certainly measurable can we increase the bonus pool if we make it to the 99 100% yes I'll triple your salary yeah that's right figured I I knew you'd be excited yeah it let them eat cake get up cake should be after two now okay so you know that the next steps in in accordance with all of this is your Administration will be writing action plans for the implementation of the goals sharing those with the board um and then you will have all of this and the cycle will move along so um yes
251Michael rate for me to write a resolution for the board to adopt both sets of goals at the next meeting absolutely on your email pleas yes absolutely you would do that at the very next meeting Andor if you would like you could wait to the first meeting in September only in the sense that you might have additional public who might be attending to hear those goals I you don't have to do that but we often suggest that sometimes you either wait to September or adopt them at your next meeting and then ratify them in September when there are staff present you know your Association reps are here just as a way of communicating that these are your focus for the year that's why we suggest it so okay thank you very much as always it's
252been a pleasure to work with all of you and good to see you if you need anything if you have any questions let me know I hope to see at least some of you at Workshop in October in Atlantic City um It's a Wonderful opportunity if you have never been um to see it and to really um make use of some of the resources available so thank you so much you thank you Gwen wish I WR like that okay scribble I scribble uh under our next item on the agenda which is Other Board of Education business uh Dr Kaka said he he wants to to have a word and uh Mr Gorski also wants to have a word [Laughter] and I just want to say that I distributed to you tonight a report just a
253simple that's on the per pupil cost okay the last page of that report I have to take a second look at that I discovered it tonight during the meeting that there's something there that I'm not so so certain of so the very last page uh it looks like this okay I think is your very last page uh for right now don't put uh don't put full Credence in the information that's there because I have to check on uh some of the some of the ranking information there I need to I want to do a double check because I'm not certain that that was accurate everything else has been double checked but that one I know I did it just the other day and I was looking at it tonight I says wait a minute I'm
254not so sure that that's correct so I I will straighten that out for you though uh and give it to you in the future um I appreciate all the time that everyone has put into this tonight uh I think we've had some very good deliberations I I think everyone uh spoke up and they felt comfortable speaking up I certainly hope you did uh and uh even though your idea may not have prevailed just like my idea does not necessarily Prevail I hope you haven't taken any personal offense by that because uh we're acting as a board and uh we're not going to always be in 100% agreement on things uh but I thought it was a productive meeting I know it's not the most Pleasant kind of meeting to have but it's one that we
255need to have from time to time so that we can where we're going uh yes great that we did it we did it today instead of Saturday agreed yes very much agreed um just a very quick only a couple words the committee meetings tomorrow just a reminder we have policy at 4 Personnel at 5 Finance at 6 and buildings and grounds at 7 to bring up a point about the committee things they're too close we cannot especially in finance we don't have enough time sometimes to finish our meetings and we're rushing through I sometimes this hour is not long enough we have to be more flexible flexible where we we're able to to at least discuss what we want to discuss uh I I I I I see validity to your point Anthony because sometimes
256we've had to uh either delay another committee starting or we've had to go without completing the business of that committee and uh I think that would probably come under this uh reviewing uh the committee processes and structur for together tomorrow I mean so so that's never I don't know if anything can be done in terms of tomorrow night I'm sure that all of this was set because of our next board meeting on Wednesday and and you're just having returned this week yes is that correct uh just on that point uh Dr kak and I uh also notice that and we have been limiting agenda items uh on a priority basis so that we don't overextend into the time general or just for tomorrow General starting yeah you'll see a difference starting tomorrow we should be
257done in in the allotted time if not we'll discuss you know making the time longer with the committee chairs okay because that was one of our concerns once that we don't have enough time and especially at Finance yeah and I I agree with you Anthony I I've said that the committee meeting should be an hour and a half if it goes goes less it's good well at least give it a buffer where you have an opportunity to go so they're not right on top of each other yeah you know somebody could speak for 10 minutes which is important because we're making a recommendation and you know it as well as I do we never get out of there sometimes and sometimes Personnel jumps on top of finance and all the way through so um good
258point yes Mr Gorski is now going to uh uh apprise us of some information that he received during the course of the meeting tonight after checking upon the situation yes um first of all I beg everybody's pardon this is the first time that this has happened to my knowledge um for a budget vote it's required that you have a majority of the members Seated on the board to pass that uh resolution so that would be six and with the resolution that Mrs kapano moved tonight it requires not what a budget would require six about a simple majority and this was brought to my attention by a member and I have reached out to Mary Smith on the phone and I have also uh consulted with Gwen from school boards everybody concurs that the resolution tonight
259whose vote was five Ys three Nays and two extensions does meet the simple majority um uh stipulation and has passed I I apologize for the confusion um again I align this with a budget and it is it is budget philosophy and is different well we have to look forward may I speak yes go ahead Mr PR sometimes people are voting because maybe abstaining because they don't have the information at that time now if this was brought up before the vote maybe some people wouldn't abstain because it was important whether they believed this was going to go through or not so all of this stuff should be done before we even come to vote I don't think it's fair now that it's being overturned Mr nin this goes back to a complaint I've had for some
260time I've expressed it to you Mr board president regarding the Jamesburg rep I don't understand why we can't have our agenda items listed in the order of the ones that he can vote on I have sent you an agenda from Somerville High School Branchburg is a very large send receive to them their agendas are very straight forward and it's never a doubt of what the Jamesburg member can vote on and what he can't I realize that's not the issue we're that's in in question tonight but nonetheless um I think that that this confusion this constant confusion of whether he can vote and that will affect some members votes possibly knowing it's either a five or a six vote uh uh uh uh majority and uh that so I I think it's imperative that we do
261something about this I I said I've expressed it a few times and I don't know where it stands but I I think we have to make a move on this okay just hold on Mr prman I think Tom is 100% right Mr never on that point James BG's allowance in this particular vote is irrelevant this passes with or without his vote with still a majority that's but I did as I mentioned before receive a legal opinion on this one that he would be entitled to vote on the philosophy I I I try to be as transparent about that as I could okay and and I appreciate that and but I understand that what Mr noin is is saying is a is to a different point uh it's just that this this happened to be a
262catalyst for it but I do want to clarify ification here uh and since this has come out and Gwen you're still here are you listening I am and I am I was under I my understanding has always been that whenever there is uh there are votes that are uh listed as abstained abstentions that those votes are counted in with whatever the majority of the votes were I thought that's in Robert's Rules of Order Robert's Rules but it does depend on what your policy says sometimes affirm depending on your policy your policy can say that it aligns with Robert's Rules and they are counted in the affirmative okay with the majority or it can say that they're completely neutral they are neither a vote with the majority nor the minority on a particular vote I don't
263know what your policy manual says do does anyone Kathy do you because you've been on the I iy I can't there ay yes I I can tell you that they have never counted toward the affirmative and an exstension has always been cast when perhaps information was limited and and a poor person missed a meeting um or just chooses not to vote it would never have counted and the policy does not count that as an affirmative absolutely not well would our policy committee check on that please just somebody make a note just so we get that clarified because I know Robert Rules of Order and we supposed to we're supposedly operating under Robert R of order with the exception of when it states otherwise in our bylaws it does say that abstentions count wherever the majority
264of the votes were heard you got it there I have it here but I don't look it may take a while to find that from V let's bring it up next week I I don't ever recall putting the abstentions as an affirmative or a negative I think they were just you had three categories at that point sure sure now um Jil so the budgetary process has a different voting balance in the rest of the votes that we do yes you're voting on Monday there are very specific requirements around certain types of motions okay require two3 majority to pass okay adoption of the budget purchase of land removal of an administrator from an administrative position are some of the cons requ a super majority to pass okay but an ordinary motion or resolution wins by a
265simple majority and and when you say it requires 2/3 then on our board that would require seven votes for that resolution if the James BR person can vote no we just because because 23ds of 10 is is more than six which means you have to go to seven I don't think you mean a super majority is like if you make a motion to uh uh there's certain Robert rules that require I I know to uh to table a motion indefinitely Or to stop discussion on a motion okay that requires a su majority but there are very specifics outlined in 18a that say you need a 2third majority vote affirmative vote of the board to do the following things and they're very specific I know what you're saying exactly but we we have never done those
266well you you've adopted the budget but that's six that's six but there are some things that are 2/3 so you just have to be aware of those and I know that Mike is funding is an example that's that's a a super majority sale of bonds very big impactful property yes and that's superintendent Mike is this stuck in the policy policy super I'm the policy oh to remove someone you don't have to all right is there any other businesso I think that we should have Mary come to the meetings because I'm convinced that will you go if we knew or some of the members knew that there was a majority needed they would not have stained there's different information there so this is not the first time this happened if I'm not mistaken so by her
267being here the questions could be asked before we take a vote instead of after the meeting because there's some people here that are experienced for I'm a I'm a one-term member there's some members here that are experienced they know the more rules than I do and we're at a disadvantage but if the councelor is here we have an opportunity to ask the questions Mr Braverman there's there's a list put out I think by New Jersey school boards tells you exactly how many votes you need for every situation point I had oh I had Mr Gorski send that list when I was President List year M that comes during orientation I have that list in my regular board book and and I've complied with that every meeting for six years now there's never been an instance
268of course to my knowledge where we've broken that requirement and just to put this to bed you can't re you can't bring it up again to reconsider unless you are yes vote oh I I don't think anybody's bringing it up to reconsider at least I didn't interpret it that way I think there's just some people that are a little uh displeased with the way things happened tonight okay win some and lose some I've lost a lot you're correct but they're just simply registering you know their their opinions on things okay any other board business all right then uh I move that we adjourn the meeting second second all right all in favor opposed oh we didn't have our second public forum the meeting is now adjourned