CorpusRecord 132953

Monroe Township Board of Education 05.14.15 Special Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-18
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
10,469 words · about 59 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001special public meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education for May 14th will now come to order I ask that you please turn off any cell phones that you may have or put them on vibrate so that they are not part of our recorded meeting at this time uh Mr thorney would you please lead us in the pledge to the flag pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all Mr Gorski roll call please miss armeno Mr Braverman here Mr de Mayo here Mr calman Mrs K Pano here Mr nosin here Mr poy here Mr proso pres Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Mr board president you have a quum present this evening is s

002many is noted as present in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the mro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted May 8th 2015 at all schools home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski at this time we will open the floor for the public forum please keep in mind that any comments made during this uh during this forum must deal with items on the agenda if you uh want to speak please come to the microphone giving your name and address you are allowed three minutes for any comments or statements that you have to make all comments and questions are to be directed to the presiding

003officer and each speaker should speak only once on the same topic your cooperation in uh abiding by these regulations will be appreciated so at this time the floor is now open for the public forum anyone wishing to speak please come to the microphone okay seeing no one then we will close the first public forum and we will will now enter into the board discussion of the onetoone instructional initiative but prior to any other board member speaking I would like to uh clarify both to the board as well as the public the reason why this particular uh item is being discussed in the special meeting of tonight uh last week I did not feel it was appropriate to include that on the agenda we did have a meeting last week uh because some of our board

004members would not be present and uh I agreed with uh one of the board members saying that they felt that all members should be present for this particular discussion uh and then again last night we had a situation where all of the board members could not be present so I and I knew that in advance and so I chose to not have this item dealt with at that time for that reason uh so it was scheduled for a special meeting for tonight not to uh remove it from our regular meeting but for the purposes of having all members present uh Mr Koffman is not here tonight because this is a matter uh in which I believe he is conflicted and therefore his presence is uh noted and for that reason uh so we have all

005of the people that can uh vote on this particular item they are present tonight and that is why the meeting is OCC occurring tonight uh so at this time the uh the board will now discuss bring up any questions or comments that you might have uh you have received quite a bit of information from our Administration uh since this item first came up some time ago uh you've had the opportunity to uh read uh answers to many of those questions and also then to pursue additional questions on your own to the administration and uh I suggested that you direct those questions directly to the administration and not to me because I would not necessarily have the answers so I think you've had adequate opportunity to explore this uh and I'm not quite sure exactly what

006else may uh be asked tonight but uh this is the opportunity to ask or to comment on the initiative anyone Mr Ryback thank you well I guess I'll start and hopefully uh we'll pick up the pace after that um in in thinking hard and fast about this the first thing I want to do you know it's very easy to say what we should do better but I'd like to start with what we're doing right and that's educating our students uh the results uh are are evident and and I certainly compliment the teacher teaching staff our students parents and this board of education for uh providing the tools and means for uh our students to get outstanding education that being said um this is a big ticket item and uh I know all of us have

007been laboring over this over this uh this is the second meeting on this and it's not easy for any one of us uh because we are concerned about uh the education and and the cost this is uh expensive so I have I'm going to ask you to bear with me I have some thoughts even that I wrote down because I didn't want to forget anything uh I'd like to start out with uh discussing about spare units uh in the question answer packet that we all received as board members it noted that the teacher iPads do not need replacing so after speaking with uh Mr Washington and getting his opinion on how many spare units he feels we need I'm suggesting that we consider ordering 2200 units I think that's um reflected in uh the agenda

008today uh in the motion rather um that we're going to consider and I I'd like to thank Mr Gorski Dr alvich and and uh Reggie Washington and of course Dennis for always uh being available to me for my badgering on a weekly basis and but I know you understand where we're coming from and we have to resolve this on our own minds um another key factor is uh the timing for these discussions as a former School administrator I understand the importance of getting orders in on time especially at this juncture in the school year you know the school year is busy enough but the beginning and and the end are the most busy and and uh you know making decisions that affect the beginning of or the end of a school year uh or impact

009it in in any way a negative fashion is is uh um to me something that we just have to do everything to avoid however the discussions at the board level that we've been having on this issue uh in some way have to begin earlier I know some of you may feel we've started it early enough but I think we need to discuss this as an entire board because uh the last time we discussed this there were questions and uh raised that didn't come up in committee and I think that we need to have the advantage of sitting down together and and listening to a presentation or discussing it especially with a with a big ticket item um I'm not faulting anybody I just think it just that way but we owe it to our students

010and taxpayers to begin the discussions on Big Ticket items well in advance of crunch time um lastly my last comment is and I think you received something uh that I had uh written and presented for uh your consideration today but I'd like to explain it first um I think that you know we started with apple and uh let me say in January uh when I first came on board as I was leaving a teacher came up to me after the um the the technology fair and said to me Mr Ryback please uh let us have a vote for having our iPads again it took me a while to get used to it and I'm using it effectively now and switching now would be difficult for me and you know um what the teachers are saying

011what the the high school principal says is uh very important because they're the ones that are using it they're the ones that are doing it we're not they are and we have to respect how they feel and listen to them as far as results there many other options out there I know personally myself I like the Chromebooks uh but according to the teachers they don't meet the needs of the school and that's important um but I see something that we're doing I think that's boxing Us in for lack of a better uh expression into only using Apple products I think the professional development that we have is geared toward Apple so of course on Apple's uh uh side it's a bit self-serving uh I think that we would stand uh better if we varied our

012professional development so that teachers staff members uh could get a a um a good working knowledge of some other apps or some other platforms so that if we uh make a decision in the future to change a platform go to a different machine it wouldn't be catastrophic they wouldn't be so nervous about it because they will have had some experience with it I think that's very key factor so that being said uh I'd like to raise the following motion if I may Mr President um uh it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the creation of In-House professional development technology opportunities which are varied rather than platform specific so as to better enable staff members in the district to develop technology skills that will be adaptable to a variety of different technology devices in

013the future okay is there a u is there a seconding of that motion miss armeno all right so we have the motion uh this this deals specifically with in-house professional development yes okay and nothing else and essentially generally it is that there would be a more uh General type of professional development not specifically geared to Apple but to uh infusing technology so that somewhere down the road if we wanted to get off of Apple it would not be so difficult that's the way I'm understanding it is that correct and also uh it should be at no additional cost I discussed this with Dr alvic and Reggie Washington and uh um it's basically and correct me Dory from wrong we're basically showing them different apps that are available and we have a Windows technology right here

014here so that if we do need a different type of platform it's available to demonstrate with the staff it's my hope that this would uh Again Begin and and and be reinforced so that down the road uh two years from now two and a half years from now the teachers would really feel comfortable making a switch if need be because we do have to start saving money can I ask a question before we vote sure absolutely okay my question to Dory is how do you see logistically how do you see this working in the professional development um our professional development is very differentiated and and diversified as it is um within the package from Apple we do have apple workshops that will so Apple we will continue with those that's in the package um but

015for other opportunities we can look at other um uh other presenters coming in to present just basically on technology use in the classroom rather than Apple products in the classroom um we can also include all of those different pieces um in any of our workshops we do um one of our teachers currently at the high school is teaching a flipped classroom year-long course and it's already filled to capacity for next year she's a teacher at the high school however the people in her class are K to2 teachers so only the high school teachers have the Apple products the K to a teachers have the windows products so she's already having to diversify and and differentiate within her class classroom to begin with so we do have those opportunities available within the district so to make

016sure that we're putting a focus on that I it will take a little bit of work but I don't think it'll be a difficult task to do and you don't think it'll put a huge pressure on you know PD time and everything like that you think it'll be feasible yes absolutely thank you other questions or comments on this Mr seski shouldn't something like this as far as a new procedure or platform be looked at as far as the curriculum committee and then maybe the finance committee to see if there's any more interest in this where it can be expanded and then to the finance committee as far as if we have to go out and bring people in to teach us PD I mean that's a cost in itself we have we do already have

017in the budget um some money for outside presenters to come in so that that's already something in the budget that's um my professional development budget um we offer so many different courses throughout the year most of them done by teachers within our district so it would be offering those trainers more professional development we can use Reggie's office and the tech and the tech department and the new technology facilitator um to help inservice those presenters that we already have in our district so that whenever they present anything with technology they present multiple Platforms in their classes so that wouldn't be an extra charge that would be something we're already doing in house with professional development we have over 130 teachers currently trained as trainers in our district and they're the ones that off that run all

018of the year long courses throughout the year during the ins Services they also run many courses throughout the year um and all of that has been in our budget so it's it may not be it's not going to be fully just new technology PD courses but whenever technology is incorporated into our professional development courses we want to make sure that there's a focus on how the technology is used not on the specific platform being used m k panovich um is this a recommendation that's coming out of a committee or because of a board member and I think that's what Mr zareski is trying to say it did not come out of the commit and I thought we worked as a board of committees and not as a board of a whole so something new like

019this should really be brought to the committee level for discussion a motion I'm not going to make a motion but I'm just saying that because every we we can't have every 10 board members making 10 different recommendations every time we have a meeting that's why we are a board of a committee some something that's Rec and I'm not saying this is a good or a bad recommendation I'm just saying if it's coming from a board member it to an administrator or to anybody to the board president it should really go on an agenda for a committee discussion and the recommendation coming from a committee because that's how we work on this board of education okay uh and and my perception may be wrong but I I recall I believe that it was it first went

020to curriculum the iPad initiative and what to do about that and then curriculum from curriculum it went to finance and if I'm not mistaken Finance had uh recommended that the matter of the iPad uh and the onetoone initiative be brought to the full board for discussion so that's why I I I see that this uh that's not what we're talking about we're not talking about the iPad we're talking about um think shoulds all right well miss kapovich go go ahead we are not talking about the iPad oneon-one initiative we're talking about a developing a technology an in-house professional development technology opportunity which I know never came to finance all right Mr armeno um I understand your position um but we we do have a full board here and I think it is is acceptable by

021Roberts rules for any any assembly to that any member can bring resolution so it would require a vote Yes or no um if it if it if it doesn't uh pass then perhaps it can go into committee but I believe that any board member can bring a resolution up and it it's open for discussion and a vote I could be wrong Mr Rybeck if I'm not mistaken Dr alvish didn't this in a way come up in the curriculum committee when we you it was mentioned during the curriculum committee presentation so there was some discussion in the curriculum committee on it I know that's what got me thinking thank you but but there yes there was no recommendation on this coming or was there a recommendation com there was no recommendation out of the committee it

022was a discussion during the during the committee discussion during the presentation well I my once again I'm going to give you my perspective on it because of uh we will be voting on a resolution tonight that includes the uh possible purchase of iPads and uh MacBooks and I believe part of that contract or purchase involves professional development being offered by Apple is that correct yes so I I I I I don't see this as being something that's totally separate from what we from what we are here for tonight uh because we're approving a total package or not approving it one way or the other with apple and I think what Mr Ryback is simply doing is saying that we we don't want to lock ourselves in forever to Apple he wants to see professional development

023being a little bit more diverse and more inclusive of so that a shift to a different platform at some point in the future is possible Miss armeno yeah and I think part of the discussion uh all along with uh the recommendations from technology department and also from do alage is one of the arguments is that the teachers are um have been trained on Apple and it's difficult to change uh at this point so I think it's actually pertinent to the overall discussion because again one of the arguments is that we've already been through this series of training and we can't really change now because we're sort of stuck or if you want to use a different word um going forward with this technology because of the professional development if we have diverse professional development as

024we like to have diversity of teaching in the classroom if we have diverse development for our profession that would give us an opportunity to broaden our choices in the future I think it's a good idea I mean whether whether this this other resolution for the iPad passes or not I can't see why I and I may be using the word wrong but I keep hearing differential uh educate differentiate I mean it it would be good to have our teachers having Diversified exposure to different Technologies because there is and I think Mr um Washington aptly put it we're not really sure what's going to happen in the future what would be the better and actually Dr alv let me give you credit as well I think you agreed with that that we are not sure going

025forward what the opportunities for educational technology will be so if we start early and expose teachers to the differences maybe we will actually find that there are technology educational technologies that suit our students needs better so I I mean I think this is sort of part and partial of it but we thank you Mr borski thank you um in the administrative deliberation on this one to1 initiative um there were differences of opinions on the platform and as Mr Rybeck mentioned one of the limitations was teacher training and the amount of time going into next year so an administrator actually brought this resolution in fourth not as articulated as you Mr rbec but but in a similar fashion to differentiate the professional development to allow an ambid dextrous approach to considerations of new platforms going forward

026because as this process has showed us this was rather difficult to consider switching to a different platform at this stage because of the important piece of the teacher training as that's so intricately involved in instruction Mr norstein um so often we always speak about you know being proactive and everything and um you know looking more towards the future um I feel that this this resolution by Mr Ryback is is is in that direction obviously we are not um happy with the idea that we're locked into to one platform as you say um there's definitely significant cost advantages with um having the flexibility of saying we're going to go to with different platform just from the vendor standpoint where they know that um they have to compete for our business as opposed to us being locked

027in I think that's an important piece of the puzzle and I think by this resolution uh not the resolution but this this uh this I guess a resolution of Mr Ryback that we're speaking to now I think that's why that is a uh an important part of that puzzle piece to make sure going forward that we're not locked in that we do have um some com Comfort level with other platforms so I I think that this is a good thing may I recommend to the board also is that as a new superintendent comes on board that this becomes either a district or Board of Education goal okay anyone else have comments Mr Braverman I happen to agree with Anthony there's a point of order that we missing we're here to talk about this resolution and

028the adoption of or not or not adopting the iPads I think we should take that up and after that I would like to amend what Steve was saying in that we should have an ongoing committee to evaluate what we're doing and what we might be able to do we keep talking about being a having a onetoone uh process here in in the in the district and I I think we most of us agree agree with that but at the same time I think we should look Beyond The High School uh I'm sure all of us know somebody that's in college and every one of them that I know has been asked to bring a specific computer to that school I haven't heard us talk about that at all should we be preparing kids beyond the

029high school um and in terms of a variety of of computers my God there's probably an as many computers as there are teachers they all have one they all have two in the school they they have an iPad and I think they have a laptop no they not no but they do have others in school not at all I used to at any rate I I think we should take that up after you after the board makes a decision on the on the iPads and then we can go home there's a motion on the floor though correct I mean we have we have to address the motion on the floor yes we're presently discussing this motion that Mr Ryback has made um you have you're you you were suggesting an amendment though Mr Braverman could

030you clarify exactly what that amendment was I I was I would amend it to includ to include an ongoing study of how we use the iPad and What U how we use computers in the district and what what needs the students have Beyond High School uh you know speaking from just getting off the cuff for a minute speaking uh from a personal point of view I have a grandson that's in engineering he uses an iPad he uses a laptop and very often he prefers notes with pen and pencil so and and I'm sorry am and we have to okay have one more comment yes the current literature on on um computers in the schools indicates that they should be used as supplemental material okay so uh Mr Gorski uh who is basically our parliamentarian uh

031says that since we do have a an amendment that has been suggested we have to see if uh that amendment is going to be seconded does anyone want to Second Mr braverman's Amendment doesn't Mr Rybeck have to agree to amend it no it would require a second and then the majority of the board and then the motion would be amended well Mr may I ask what what the language would be I think to I could suggest may I suggest something I wrote down verbatim What Mr Braverman said as the amendment I could repeat it if you'd like okay I'm was going to change yes go ahead Mr braverman's amendment to Mr Ryback's motion is to include an ongoing study on how computers are used and what the needs of the students are After High School

032Mr proso how long would a study like this be I mean microne formulate committee by the time we get a committee together how long would this process take I mean it's like dragging off feet he made a a motion that save us money down the down the road if we ever change our platform our teachers will be prepared so just putting a committee together what does that mean how long is that going to take or is it going to prepare us Mr braen if if the object is to save money down the road put it into your motion that shouldn't be the object the object should be to have something valuable for the students to use and know what the ongoing process should be EXC okay I'm still looking for a second to Mr braverman's

033Amendment I'll second it okay any further discussion on this Mr Ryback I think Mr braveman certainly has Merit in in his thinking of you know what to do I think uh we certainly need some more for how that would develop but I just want to comment on one thing um the purpose of my motion is to better equip teachers uh for uh the value of what they're using with the value what they're using and and certainly I I I would have to consider cost but clearly the education value it be uh it behooves us to uh give them the the educational instructional opportunities to look at what's out there and how it could benefit them in the classroom instead of being locked into just apple and that's really where I'm coming from on this would

034it save money of course it would save money because we could make decisions we uh a a platform can come up uh three years from now that would be much beneficial uh have a longer warranty and why shouldn't we take advantage of that but my purpose is why shouldn't we allow our teachers to have the uh the ability to switch to different platforms instead of just being locked into something what if down the road Apple turns out to be you know the U the worst of a lot and yet that's the only one our teachers have experience with and feel comfortable with I think that would be a mistake and that's where I was coming from any other comments or questions okay I I do have one comment and then we will do a roll

035call on the amendment I think what Mr Braverman has proposed in his amendment has Merit that we do need to look at on an ongoing basis uh What uh our students would be facing as they go off to college and chances are that will change over time and that's why we probably need something on an ongoing basis however I don't see that it is of U of A pressing need at this particular moment that we do that this is a long range type of thing that would be uh something that could possibly be established uh for the uh beginning of next year and then ongoing uh I think I think it's very worthwhile to evaluate the technology that we're using in the sense of is it doing the the kind of job we hope it's

036doing for our students and are our students at some kind of advantage or disadvantage as they go off to college uh possibly because the colleges are using a different type of technology I think that's the kind of thing that Mr Braverman is after and I think there's Merit in that however my own personal opinion is that we don't need uh to make that necessarily a part of uh the motion that we're dealing with tonight uh any anyone else that want to comment before we do a roll call on this amendment which we have to that's the the thing that has to take place next Mr notin um I I I definitely agree exactly what uh Mr Po has said that I think that you know we don't want to rush into this I think that

037there's there's so much Merit in there want to get it right um with that amendment I think that uh maybe we need to bring that in front of a policy committee to write a policy and come up with the committee how you know the nuts and bolts of what you're suggesting because I really think it's important all too often uh we tend to throw money at technology figuring that it's helping uh education I I think we need some to maybe even develop some metrics in that um technology committee maybe to to come up with a a way to to say yes this amount of money did did help our students because at the end of the day that's all we're really that's that's the most important thing is that we're making sure that the money

038that we're spending on technology is actually accomplishing what it's set out to do and currently I don't see there's any there's no way to really do that currently the way it's set up so I I think what Mr Braverman is suggesting is a great idea however I think that it definitely needs uh to be firmed up in in a much more succinct fashion and to have more uh of the the nuts and bolts and details uh of how that's going to happen so that that's how I feel Mr Ryback I couldn't concur more uh Tom Marvin I think that was a really extremely beneficial uh idea but I do think it needs uh some more structure and I agree with what Mr norin was saying I'm just curious Dr alage um as part of what

039you do uh do you is it are you able to integrate that into your normal working as far as looking at technology working with the technology committee uh to say see if what we're doing is uh beneficial or should we heading in a should we begin heading in a different direction no absolutely I I think that that getting a committee together of students staff Administration possibly board members and parents also and bringing everybody together and looking at exactly but I think we do need to have a plan of what exactly we want to look at um my head is kind of spinning with action research ideas on this and um how we can move forward with it but I think it's definitely something that would be beneficial and we could actually look at some data

040and see where we I think it's something that has to be ongoing because we're looking we're looking at a threeyear period here so I think by year two we should be knowing whether or not hey we want to stay with this or maybe we have to move in another Direction but it's only through an ongoing type of committee or Research into what we doing that we'll get that kind of uh um you know information abely Mr poy can I answer one of the other questions that came up um one of the questions that had come up before was have we talked to colleges I did reach out to the colleges that to three of the colleges that are in New Jersey Ruckers Ryder and TCNJ Ruckers and Ryder did both get back to me and

041basically said they do not require any specific device or platform when their students come in however some of their um specific departments do require something specific um but for the most part when a student enters College they're not they're not required they're not requiring any specific device or platform okay uh Mr Gorski roll call vote on the on Mr braverman's Amendment Please Mr armeno uh I'm going to vote no but I I do hope we can pursue this in the future and I think we should have a separate resolution um and I'd like Mr uh Braverman perhaps so I'm going to vote no with the hope of restructuring it thank you thank you Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes m PA Pano yes Mr noin no Mr proso no Mr Rybeck I'm

042going to Echo with my colleague U Michelle armino said I I I'm going to vote no but it's with the hope that we can bring this around so that it's restructured in in a very structured Manner and that uh you know we have some real Direction there so I hope that it's brought up again reported as no Mr Po no Mr board president an amendment is not passed that takes us back to the motion on the floor moved by Mr Rybeck it is recommended that the Board of Education approve the creation of inhouse professional development technology opportunities which are varied rather than platform specific so as to better enable staff members in the district to develop technology skills that will be adaptable to a variety of different technology devices in the future okay is there

043any further discussion on that okay Mr Gorski roll call vote on that one Mr armeno yes ask some questions yes I did but you should we have a budget Mr P go ahead I believe pertaining to cost and budget um Dr alvik was asked if this motion would require any additional computers and cost and the answer was no that there is already an in-house professional development budget which would just be uh would have a a flavor change so to speak to be more differentiated instead of just Apple the answer was no costs no additional cost no additional cost then I just have one question about that if there's no additional cost the money that you have in the budget now wasn't that earmarked for something specific or we now changing that take the sh um

044our professional development budget is used on an ongoing basis um depending on what the needs come up throughout the school year so no it's not earmarked for anything specific at this point um we use it as needs come up for example when the speech and language Pathologists have a professional Learning Community together that they need um someone to come in to to cover their license their uh they have to earn a certain number of credits towards their license we would bring someone in for that so it's not earmarked for anything specific we could kind of utilize it in the way that we need it for our staff okay any other questions or comments on this on Mr Ryback's motion Mr seski I just trying to recall your comments last night that this was going to

045be a discussion on the iPads only on whether or not we had discussion on this or not this seems to be something that is totally different has nothing to do with the specifics of the resolution to either go with the one onone initiative or not I'm still going back to where I believe that this should go through the proper committees because like Miss konish has said we are a board of committee not of a whole yes I do agree with Michelle as far as resolutions can be brought up at any time but I think this needs to be more investigated on how to do this what to go about doing with this and then we still have if this iPad initiative goes through we have three years to come up with another platform and development

046through that time where this should only take a matter of maybe a month or two to put together any information we need to go forward with more professional development for teachers and staff but I just remember that our that your comments yesterday was that our discussion today was going to be on the one in one one to one initiative only I appreciate your comment although I do disagree because I think the professional development it is mentioned in the iPad uh contract that we are considering uh that there would be a professional develop development provided by uh apple and I think uh this is pertinent to that uh that particular initiative uh I think what Mr Ryback is doing with this motion is trying making an effort to uh not have us locked into apple with

047all the future training uh even though the the the training will be provided by Apple uh as needed but to open that up so that we're we're not faced with what we heard earlier that uh to try to bring in a new platform for next year uh would not not be possible because of the uh impact on the teachers uh the time element Etc so I think this is addressing that particular issue we we may disagree but that's the way I see it Miss armeno yes um um I'm to Mr chesky's point I I understand but I think without a definitive without definitive language and this resolution sort of suggests definitive language about beginning this process you mentioned that we have three years to go through and then change well we're just coming out of

0483 years and that didn't happen so perhaps we do need the definitive language sort of as uh uh Mr vent trillo suggested as a goal for the future sometimes because we get caught up in the crisis of the moment or the the budget issues I mean we every month we have serious issues to consider and I think without a direction for which I believe this resolution is we may not address it may take two years or two and a half years and we may find ourselves back within three years uh having the same issue so I think the purpose of this is to set down a goal if you will um and a direction for us to start addressing it now and I think it's a it's it's something we need to consider so I'm

049ready for a vote SC panovich um there are sometimes uh an issue that board members bring up that have gone through committee that we've discussed for months and months and we say we don't have enough information let's bring it back let's wait till next month let's get more information this is just something that's come up today I don't feel I have enough information to make a decision I believe that again we work as a board of committees this I don't see that we have to rush into to approving a a resolution today and I know many of our current board members have sat here and said oh we rush into we rush into we rush into transparency and so here we are we've talked about this for 40 minutes and we're now rushing to make

050a decision okay Mr Rybeck I can't agree uh Kathy I I think that uh number one I think this is absolutely directly linked to the iPad um uh issue that we're we're thinking about today and I think delaying it and putting it through committees and delaying it is is really not serving our teachers we're here we're listening to our assistant superintendent tell us that this is something that she would support and it's something that that can be done uh without uh um stress at least and and we're looking to uh provide that support for the teachers which will ultimately benefit the students as well as the taxpayers uh I can't see delaying this uh we don't as a board we don't tell say specifically what professional development is but yet we have our assistant superintendent

051intendent who did bring this up at at a committee and it was well received and uh telling us that this is something that can be done uh I can't see delaying this I think this is something that has to go along with the iPad issue I think we owe it to our teachers we owe it to our uh our the taxpayers and M mainly to our students because that we want to keep them at the Forefront of technology and uh um I think delaying it would just be a disservice all right any further comments or questions before we do the roll call vote on this okay Mr Gorski Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr zareski no Mr de Mayo yes Mrs K Pano no Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr rybec yes Mr

052poy yes Mr board president motion passes thank you Mr [Music] Gorski okay I will now read the a resolution regarding the authorization for the acquisition of instructional technology whereas njsa 18a 18a d42 authorizes the Board of Education of the township of Monroe to enter into a contract exceeding the fiscal year for the leasing of equipment of every nature and kind and whereas the board has a need to acquire 2,200 new iPad units and 200 MacBook units collectively referred to as equipment for school purposes and whereas the board desires to acquire the equipment through State contract now therefore be it resolved by the board as follows section one the board hereby authorizes the superintendent the board secretary and the board's counsel to proceed to draft documents and conduct such and conduct such other activities as are

053necessary to accomplish the acquisition of the equipment through State contract section two the board hereby directs the board secretary to process the necessary purchase orders and contract to acquire the equipment section three the board president and the board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to determine all matters in connection with the acquisition of the equipment not determined by this or subsequent resolution of the board as permitted by law section four a copy of this resolution shall be placed on file with the secretary of the board section five the making of and submission to the county super intendent of the application as required by njac 6A col 26-10 point1 D is hereby authorized and approved and the board's Council along with other representatives of the board is hereby authorized to prepare and submit such application and

054to represent the board in matters pertaining theret section six this resolution shall take effect immediately that is the resolution is there a second so moved okay before a vote are any additional questions or comments Miss Deo we're getting 200 less so did Apple agree to the same price no apple uh Mr vent trillo and I had a conversation with two Representatives who are higher up with apple they had um thought amongst themselves that they would be able to accommodate the same price with 200 units less but they were going to check with um the Senior Management of apple and they have come back and and um not been able to give us the same price I believe that the units now are approximately $20 higher M Dr Al the new um the new proposal that

055they they've given us the original proposal for the 2400 units was $498 which just so I can remind everybody that's already $200 cheaper um so they had given us that deal originally with reducing the number to 2200 units they increased the price to $513 per unit however they did reduce the unit price of the teacher laptops from $1,255 to $1,821 and there were other reductions um with the PD the case and the service and support line items so the original quote for all for the whole package for the three-year lease from Apple was 1,610 $60,100 with with the 200 less is 1, 151,000 $953 can you repeat that last number yeah 1, 151,953 so it went down approximately a little over a few dollars over 100,000 okay thank you Dr Mr Bo apple is also

056um granting 0% financing on this deal still which would then um prevent us from having to go out to bid for financing that's a savings of about $36,000 on financing costs that that that's not new that was in the initial proposal M ormeno that's that's over the three years or that three years correct so there won't be is there any Clause increasing the interest rate if it changes in other words is it a floating interest rate or is it a it's a it's a fixed interest rate of Zero no interest over the three years over the three years yes Mr nosin I think you wanted thank you just a couple concerns I I I heard Dr alvich said that they're giving us a $200 discount or originally they were giving us a 200 I never

057saw that talk to the mic I never saw that 200 um savings because basically the cost of a uh of the 32 gig iPad Air with uh Apple Care is 550 to the general public we're paying now 513 okay originally we're paying you know a little over 400 so there was never a $200 discount um as was mentioned so I mean I just I don't know Apple doesn't seem like they're really being too uh they're not too ready to negotiate let's put it that way for somebody's in the who's in the position that they're in um on the plus side I think that by having the the discussion that we had we've saved over $100,000 and and that's a big plus and that's a credit to this board for taking the time to discuss it

058like we are because that's what we have to do we asked the taxpayers in the last budget to Pony up 7.67% extra taxes we have to show the public and we have to show um each other that we're willing to say we have to spend wisely you know we questioned right off the bat why the teachers needed to have 200 uh new iPads when there should be really in in pristine shape my other concern now is are there others that we could possibly use that aren't in pristine shape um if we can knock out another 200 out of this that would be another $100,000 savings uh that that definitely um can help us I'm happy to see that there's some concessions made and that's very important because I think unfortunately when this technology committee started

059to go about their task there was no criteria as part of the process of a budget there was no criteria to say let's we have a specific amount of money that we need to get under or a specific savings that we need to have from the last time that was never part of that and I think that going forward um in the next go round we need to present uh to the committee that's looking at this that it's not just a bottomless pit that we just can't say we want the latest and the greatest that we have to have h a cost savings uh less than what the last go round was we've accomplished that this time and I'm very proud of the board that we did ask these these these questions so I just

060wanted to uh state that can I ask some clarification yes Mr Mayo um Mr noon you said MacBook airs are $500 but we're not getting MacBook airs we're getting iPads iPad Airs yes we're getting iPad Airs you said MacBook airs okay so that's well they're different MacBook Pro we're not getting MacBook a we're getting MacBook Pros and we're getting iPad Airs right excl excuse me if I uh no I'm I'm just confused that's all okay so the price of the iPads to Consumers are 500 over 550 exactly like we're configuring them with the Apple iare okay okay and we're paying 513 okay thank you Mr proso are we going to use these new iPads for the park assessment tests yes yes and the positive um piece of this uh Mr Washington I think talked about

061it at the last discussion the the current iPads that we have now that we use this year for the assessments are the older version iPads obviously the students have had them um in order to prepare to get them ready test ready we um the tech department actually had to configure each iPad for the testing with this new version of the iPad there will be a way to switch over to the testing mode remotely so Mr Washington will be able to switch over to the testing mode to the testing mode of each students iPad so students will be taking the iPads uh taking the the park assessment on their own iPads it will also alleviate some of the scheduling difficulties we had this year at the high school with with park because students will be able

062to take the te the Assessments in their regular classes in their regular math and language arts classes so it will not um we won't have to set up testing centers if you will you had to set up those iPads that were had last week you would have to do that next year if if you use them as with testing if we did not get the new ones yes we would have to do the same thing we did this year but with the new ones we wouldn't have to do that out of these 2200 that we're getting and how many are backups I don't know that answer um from the uh scope of the discussion that Dr alvic had um with certain board members presumably you're going to not trade in or sell 2400 units any

063longer you're going to trade in 200 units less than we had anticipated before so you would have 200 existing units as loners we and we the reason the information we don't get I didn't know we were doing this now there were 200 iPads out there for testing and they were in excellent condition those could be used as backups now I'm just hearing that's what you're doing you're keeping those no we're keeping the two the reason we're going down 200 the 200 that we're keeping are the ones that the teachers are going to use just point of clarification the teacher units the teacher iPads are not of the same year as the students iPads they were purchased subsequent to the students purchase orders so they're varying degrees newer than the students they they we we could

064use those for backups in our discussions with the technology department and the the la the iPads that were being used for testing we did we do have some on hand as spare so that if students break it or it goes down we're able to give them a replacement and then we send theirs out to um wherever it needs to be to go to be replaced keeping some of those yes so those yes and the ones we used for testing were those spares plus we collected all of the teacher iPads in order to use them during testing 2100 how many are we going to send out for auction then this 2200 doesn't really Mr Washington answer about 1800 18800 1800 1 1800 go would go out for resale as well as the current the teachers current

065uh MacBook Pros would go how many how many do we have I'm sorry how many total iPads do we have now and we're selling 1800 Mr Washington could you uh possibly come to maybe to the podium over there could hide forever re we currently have about 2,65 iPads in the hands of students Point presumably those would be all sold we would only hold on to the existing teacher units yeah we're going to keep the teachers units give them back to the teachers and we'll hold a few of the current student iPads to use as spars since we're anticipating opening school with somewhere around 2200 kids then we have a need to have some spares and what we'll do is when we collect the student iPads at the end of the year we'll try and keep

066the best 200 of those and sell off the the remainder you had about 200 for the park assessment test here not too long ago and they were excellent shape I was wondering if it's cost efficient to sell all of them when we maybe possible using them down down the road for something else the the 200 that we were using for testing were collected from the teachers to be used for testing those are the current those are the teachers current iPads M armenio um it's not stated in this resolution and I sorry I failed to ask it sooner but if we're selling the iPads the the current ones that we have will that money be earmarked to defay the cost of this specifically or will it be going into the general fund Bo as was the

067case previously when we comply with the state's procurement laws for the sale of the existing iPads all the proceeds are used to offset the new purchase there's nothing residual that went into the general fund or was used for any other purpose it it is not part of this resolution this is the authorization to purchase 2200 iPads and 200 MacBooks under State contract there is no fin financing component otherwise that would have to be a separate financing bid and then you will have a a subsequent resolution proposed for the bid for sale of the existing stock and in that resolution would we be able to specifically say state that that money is to defer defer the cost yes would you be opposed to that Mr gisy I have no opposition okay that that would be acceptable

068okay thank you g bring an amendment to this no Mrs armenio did not offer an amendment to this we're talking about a forthcoming resolution that's not introduced yet correct oh thank you Mr nelin just a quick question with regards to the um Apple Care and Spares I thought that Apple provided a 24-hour uh spare if their uh if a unit goes down that is correct they provide a 24hour um notice to give you a new iPad however that's 24 hours from the point in time they receive a purchase order a normal repair on an iPad is $49 so we have to go through the process of uh securing a purchase order to have those iPads repaired now we don't submit a purchase order every time a single student breaks an iPad we wait till we

069got about 10 to 20 so that we're not constantly bombarding the business office with POS but the first year um there should be no charge correct sir that's not correct you PID The $99 for app care and then every time there's a crack screen on an iPad you pay another $49 well I understand for the crack screen obviously if that you know that's not a warranty issue but that's really only the only item that we're looking at that would be uh of of issue in other words if if a unit goes down there's no purchase order required for the first year because it's under warranty correct that is correct there's no purchase order required for manufactor defect right okay so just just basically a crack screen situation that's correct I mean real realistically we shouldn't

070be too concerned about a lot of spares at this point in time because these are brand spanking new units correct well our history has shown that uh even when we had year one of the iPad we still experienced about 400 crack screens per year so I would anticipate the same thing and also part of the uh I know the original uh presentation to the finance committee uh gave the option of a three or a 4-year Finance has that been uh discussed or will that be discussed Mr Po yes the interest free financing that was negotiated with apple is for a three-year lease if you extend the term longer than three years not only are you exceeding the asset life with financing which is never recommended but Apple then would presumably charge an interest Factor because

071it's going out much longer I S the finance committee it was the same price for both I have the the original presentation it was the same cost for three or four years a total outlay that was the asset total cost divided by the term the asset total cost didn't change but I believe the financing over four years compared to three would change M armeno yes I am oh I'm sorry um just and this may be boilerplate language but um in the I guess it's the second paragraph um the fiscal year for leasing of equipment of every nature and kind um does that language mean that there could be other costs incurred and we might not be talking about the 1 million5 no no that's General language you're going to get 2200 new iPads and 200

072MacBooks in addition to that there's some covers and um as Mr Washington said there's a warranty that's an additional cost that's included in that price there's uh ancillary uh peripherals that come with the ipit and that's what that language goes to what you're getting is what you see here 2200 iPads 200 MacBooks and related peripherals and uh section three um the language again um authorized and directed to determine all matters in connection with the acquisition of equipment not determined by this or subsequent resolution of the board as permitted by law I guess I just need an explanation of what that means to what's not clear about that I'm and it's really not a trick question or maybe it is um the Pres board president and the board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to determine

073all matters in conjunction with the acquisition of the equipment not determined by this or subsequent resolution of the board there's a lot of procurement laws that that go into this uh for example the state contract um we would have to confirm that Apple has a valid State contract number for the devices these are all activities that are um part and parcel of the purchase and that authorizes and directs the uh the board president and the board secretary to make sure that all those are handled as well essentially there we're giving you permission to fill out the paperwork the uh the purchase order is listed here that's the paperwork um and uh you know there's there's nothing other than what you see here is what you're going to get 2200 iPads 200 200 MacBooks related peripherals

074uh purchase through State contract whereas everybody may be familiar with that term that's where the state goes out and does bidding on these items already and the districts join in on that state purchase to the lowest bidder and we then avoid the um the bid spec costs and attorney costs and things like that and I know you've said that for the most part we've done very well with the state contracts and I accept that but are are there times and I don't know if this would be a time when the state contracts would exceed what we can get in the yes there are times where State contracts exceed that but when you're talking about the volume that you're purchasing here um I I think it's safe to say that this is the best price that

075you're going to get on that many is through the state contract purchase okay so you have confidence in in that proc yes and in fact one of the questions that came up before had to do with the refurbished units and uh the price of the refurbished units forgive me I don't remember the exact number but a refurbished old used unit was almost 80% of a new unit and and uh $435 yeah so so the state state contract price is is very good the state established that to be the lowest uh price that um through their bidding process uh Mr Washington I I do have a question because of I we keep hearing about the cracked screens and I thought I thought there was some type of new cover that we were getting or that we

076have started using to reduce the chances of crack screens am I mistaken or no sir you're absolutely correct the uh new iPads would have a new cover and the hope the hope is that they would provide better protection but without that experience I would not say definitively that they will so I'm just going to go by our past history and that's been been that we crack 400 a year if we crack fewer that's all the better please keep in mind that these are mobile technology units and just by that very nature they're subject to dropping even by the most uh careful students and um they are subject to higher braking and crack screens than would be a PC um stationary on a desk and that's why that number probably is is seemingly High to some

077folks these these devices are carried around back and forth to school every day um and that's just the nature of the device uh also I I think we're all aware but but I'll I'll bring it up just in case uh the classroom environment is very different than the home environment uh classrooms do not have carpeting classrooms do not have sofas and soft cushion seats uh they are very hard surfaces the floors the walls all the furniture it's all hard surface so uh dropping an apple in that environment is very different than if you're at home or even if you're here in the media center where there's carpeting on this floor that would soften that impact so uh it's not necessarily that the students are throwing these things around they occasionally will slip but if they're

078in the school environment there's a greater chance that they're going to get a cracked screen I'm assuming that that's correct right that's absolutely correct sir okay uh Mr thorney you've been sitting there very quietly but you're our student rep you're one of the people that uses the iPad you have uh friends that are also students using the iPad uh I I know I called on you the last time to make any remarks but you have heard what we've been talking about tonight is there anything that you want to add to that uh when you say add what are you looking at any specific um issue you want me to comment on well we we we're for example we're talking about how they get broken in things of that nature uh I I assume you've never

079broken yours no assumtion have have you ever been present when one has cracked there have been I two close times but I've never actually seen one crack um out of 400 seems quite large to me that large number um I again I these seem pretty durable I know that uh if you know for people if they do crack them then the new ones tend to get replaced with a uh different protective cover believe it's Autobox thing it's similar to an auto box okay yeah uh that protects it better to ideally to help prevent future cracks again you know i' I've never really uh experienced any issue with that um I've had you know glitches with some of like the the software on the iPads but uh never any uh residual damage of that nature okay

080is there anything else you want to add um uh not really um I I do like uh Mr Ryback's um idea earlier of looking at um you know students needs and assessing you know students needs teachers needs and uh assessing that going through uh forward through a committee structure uh I think that that might might be something best done at the high school level so that they can help um both Implement immediate changes you know where necessary and also come with the recommendation to the board okay since you are a in the 11th grade you're a junior I would assume this Summer that you'll start looking at colleges and visiting campuses uh yes I'm busy over the summer but hopefully I'll find some time for okay and or or at least in the fall you'll

081be doing some of that so that you'll decide on where you might want to go to school where you want to apply you'll be visiting college campuses well if you do let me put it this way if you do then I hope that you can help us by inquiring uh in terms of do they use a particular platform uh is it a matter if the student provides their own platform or they are required to have a particular platform uh and maybe inquire about are there any colleges that are using the iPads in an instructional capacity and if not what are they using okay okay because uh you have an opportunity to do that and you can bring back some useful information absolutely all right okay thank you any other any other discussion on this Mr

082proso part of the discussion I'd like to ask the doctor have before we sell these units and some of them are probably going to be very good did we think about having them in the resource rooms or using them for the special needs Department we have not because we were looking at them to help Finance the purchase of the new ones it might be coste effective maybe to look at helping them in the resource rooms we could always ask Marietta if she coulding what would you think of the moving the iPads to other classrooms uh we could certainly do that uh I I wouldn't I don't know how many will be salvageable like that but I'm sure there will be some that we can utilize in other um areas of the district um certainly I

083wouldn't want to give them other schools something that's not going to be reliable would be just for the resource rooms if that's possible I mean we can look and see at the ones that that are available that we'd be able to use um also know that we have been purchasing some other technology devices um throughout the district using Title One funds uh we just did did some for the title one schools um the ptas have been very generous um and giving some some of the some of the ptas in different schools have been very generous and giving money to the schools and and they've been used to purchase to be able to use in the classroom um and those resource rooms were specifically uh designated Anthony just let you know right and part of Mr

084Washington's budget also was um possibly looking at some type of a Chromebook pilot down at some of the lower grades specifically with the third grade moving to mil Lake they're going to need te technology there for the park testing next year um so that's another possibility that we're also looking at um so that would also give us another piece to how can we use other devices um and and see how it's How we could use that if that that could be another option M kovich you at the last meeting when we discussed um buying the iPad we had looked at buying 2400 and now we're buying 2200 so where did that difference of 200 come from what did it come from a discussion did it come from a a um recommendation from the [Music] administration

085part of it you you want to take that one I think we were trying to do the best that we can as far as you know some of the questions that came from the Board of Education to the administration as far as how to not only uh uh be more cost effective but also at the same time is that you know what could we do obviously to instill you know we we need to go forward on this uh I guess is that the best that I can ask for you to do tonight is this I I think that the administration I think that Mike Reggie Rob Dory myself is that we've answered every single question that you have presented to us uh we have done this you know somebody matter of fact I think even

086Steve had mentioned before as far as even the timeline I need to bring this up to the attention of the board is that we've been doing this since December since December we've been having this conversation uh the the Techo at that time uh took place the committee work has done we've gone before the Committees we've done the finance committee the curriculum committee we've discussed it here at the board level as well too the questions have come to us we've answered every single question uh Mr Washington certainly has been here at least twice that I'm aware of uh dory's obviously been here as well too Mike has answered the same questions uh the so back to your question then Kathy and it's a fair question but obviously it's a compromise the administration is basically trying to

087compromise uh to meet the needs of the board as as you are obviously being very sensitive to the needs of the taxpayers we're helping you to do that uh we we still believe obviously is that this is the way to go we've negotiated with apple on a number of occasions Mike and I have certainly been very strong with the negotiations as well too we you know just let you know that the haggling that we did back and forth was very strong-handed the best that they could do they kept on coming back with obviously listen Apple's in in they're there as a business they are there to make money um but as far as you know where we are back to your question again this is an administrative compromise teachers are not getting the new laptops

088iPads rather will we have enough um or will we have to buy more for any new students that come into the district in the high school next year I think we're okay Reggie is that correct yes we should be fine because um obviously we're going to give the teachers back their original iPad so they won't be getting new we're going to reserve a couple of the iPads the better ones that we can find from the students and keep those for spares or possibly issuing to new students who come in after school year starts and again with the taxpayers here as well too is that I want you to say is that want to say is that the board has done their due diligence as far as making sure listen they they've held us to the

089fire so to speak to make sure the fact that we've done everything that we can do to decrease the cost everything that we can do has been done um and and and I have to be honest with you that they have certainly been very uh demanding and insistent as far as you know getting the questions answered and trying to reduce the price uh and Dory even mentioned it before as a matter of fact it was at one time 1.6 mil it's down to 1.5 that's $100,000 in savings and teachers are not getting new ones I hope I answer that c Mr P alsoo do we we have to hire new staff in order to accommodate the new iPads there are no plans to hire new staff because of this initiative any further questions okay then

090I move that we uh accept this resolution and oh it's already been first and second I'm sorry okay lost track of time there okay Mr Gorski rol vote then miss armenio despite Mr braverman's often objection to my going on a a small Soliloquy I have to say that I I was prepared to say no to this initiative just because I think we've been um held uh in a a revolving door with this particular technology um however this was a great me meeting this evening I thank all the Professionals for giving and answering the questions and um actually changed my mind as of the last few minutes so I appreciate everybody's input and I will vote yes thank you that's recorded as yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes thank you sir Mr Mayo yes Mrs

091K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso I too I agree with Michelle that at least we're trying and we save $100,000 right now at least we had one option and I was going to vote no but now I'll vote Yes vote is yes thank you sir Mr Rybeck yes and Mr Po yes Mr board president motion passes unanimously thank you thank you Mr gor thank you I did not do that maybe we could buy a few more microphones all right uh at this time we will open the floor for the second public forum second public session anyone wishing to speak uh this is the Forum where you can speak uh on any topic you're not restricted to the agenda please come to the microphone state your name and address and restrict your comment or

092questions to 3 minutes please my name is Victor Cooper I live at 525 Abbot Court in Monroe Township I haven't been privy to your previous discussions but two questions occur to me after hearing your very very uh excellent consideration of this um purchase one of the questions is aren't any of the existing units usable aren't they in good enough shape to use to further reduce the numbers of new unit that need to be purchased that's one question I'll ask another one when that's answered that question was raised by board members previously and Mr ventrillo and I had lengthy conversations with very high up Apple Representatives about the lifespan of the iPad the clear answer that we were given from Apple is that the iPad is designed to last between two and no longer than 3

093years then the problems that arise are that uh new operating systems are downloaded uh that cannot be installed on the old devices we've seen that on the the first initiative and buttons frequently wear out there's a main button that's touched every time you have to use the device and the onoff button at the top and the volume buttons they're just not meant to last that long so right now the the devices are in the hands of students 2,65 devices are in the possession of students the only way we would be able to assess which one of those are still functional is to recall them back to the technology department that goes beyond the scope of what a teacher can do in a classroom by saying who's got a good unit raise your hand it just

094would not be uh productive so from the existing stock of student units they have exceeded their useful life for the purpose that they're going to be used and it's administration's recommendation based upon Apple's lifespan's um um a recommendation that they be taken out of service and replaced okay that's interesting I have grandchildren in school in Ry North Carolina who have been using these for five years interestingly and and content also is requiring uh newer devices because the apps and the software programs that are used on the devices are becoming more uh resource demanding than the old units can provide the second question I had is currently there are 3,400 non-ag restricted homes under construction or approved for construction in the town going to generate approximately 2200 students over the buildout period during the next three

095years which is the term you're considering for use of these devices have you projected how many additional units you'll need due to new students coming in and how do you intend to handle those needs that's a trick question as Mr Washington stated before we are going to hold on to some of the existing stock once it's recalled to the tech department and an assessments made and then the 200 teacher units are going to be held because those are bought subsequent to the students units and it is our understanding at this point that we have enough with this resolution to satisfy the next three years of students how many current current students are you projecting for next year in the high school I don't know specifically for the high school left hand I know districtwide the

096number is 267 for next year two 267 new students districtwide next year okay what's the projection for the year after that I don't recall um probably in the same uh range probably greater because the buildout is well under way and some of these houses that are being being built I have from firsthand knowledge have not one family but two family not one student not two students but three students there's going to be a deluge of students that you need to accommodate and if you can use the existing apples for teachers and the existing apples for new students why can't you use them for all students doesn't make sense to me what you're saying Mr Po uh if you'd like me to comment to that we could hold the existing units and not sell them but

097what that is synonymous with is an exp expansion of the program to different grade levels then and that is going to require a a very big price tag that has not been considered by Administration yet I'm talking about students coming into the high school not not to the school system to the high school I believe I've answered the question that we have enough units to handle the next three-year students with this resolution I I appreciate your concern about the uh growing enrollments in our district because of new hous is going up but we also have to keep in mind that as those new students are coming into the high school we also have students that are graduating each year so uh graduating classes are now what about four 500 about 500 students in the graduating

098class they're getting higher than that now okay so and often with new houses uh the students that are coming in are of a younger age and so the impact of that is not immediately felt at the high school but uh with the demographic study that we did uh have done recently uh the ad Administration and the board uh has an understanding that yes there will be an impact of these new students but when you're talking about 2200 students coming into the township keep in mind that that as as time progresses we're also moving students out of the school system but thank you for your comment anyone else Mr roach Robert roach J te mfield Boulevard I too would like like to congratulate the board on us delivered the process I think it was a very

099very well run board meeting and uh you guys really put a lot of effort into it I thank you for it um a question I have is so the um the budget for this is 1.5 so I guess it's over three years so uh the budget for each year will be what 500,000 a year to pay for the uh the iPads is that correct Mike [Music] um that's right if you take the 1.5 million divide by 3 years there's no interest it's about $500,000 a year however the proceeds from the sale of the existing stock is going to be put down as a down payment reducing the 1.5 million by a few hundred, in addition to that there is Insurance um that's collected from parents and um any surplus from that will also go towards

100the um the down payment on the units so this will fit with in what has been budgeted for the lease amount of $400,000 I I seem to remember from prior years and I I may be mistaken but I thought that if the students broke the screen that the parents were supposed to pay supposed to pay for that or was that something else that the parents were had to pay for each unit has $100 um app Apple Care on them um and the crack screens are subject to a a parent U charge of Reggie is it $50 that is correct Yeah so basically the school is not the the school budget is not paying for the crack screens is that correct that is uh that is now correct um you know one question I I have

101and it sort of was raised before the prior speaker and is that um I you know the iPads to me it's three years and and out for $500 a unit seems ludicrous myself as a citizen I would not go B and pay $5500 to buy an Apple iPad if I knew it wasn't going to be good after three years and so I I don't understand why we couldn't cut this the cost down by one quarter by telling the current Juniors to take their iPads into their senior year and use them the senior year and I understand Mr Gorski saying that certain programs couldn't be on on that but I don't know whether that could be worked out and then have the and then just by instead of uh 2200 you know 3/4 of that and

102and from the 2000 some that are being set set aside not being used use those for backups I mean that just seems like a a to me a logical idea but I just throw that out I mean I don't need any comment unless somebody really wants to comment dominant on it and one of the other things that I would recommend that u based on Mr Po what P Mr Po mentioned to the young man that I really enjoy listening to I'll tell you he's a great kid and uh is I think you uh should consider a some type of a study looking at what other schools in your middle sex County in your same geographical not geographical but same rating area or even just middle sex County Schools what are they doing what are they

103using how are they having success with it and and just uh you know to more um I get give you more historical uh perspective as to what is the best way to go thank you thank you Mr roach you anyone else all right then I will close the second public session the next schedule Board of Education meeting will be Tuesday next week May 19th it will begin at 5:15 here at the high school uh we will open the meeting and then immediately go into close session for purposes of interviewing candidates for the superintendent's uh position I would move that we adjourn this meeting do I have a second so moved all in favor I opposed meeting adjourned yes meeting is adjourned

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.