CorpusRecord 132955

Monroe Township Board of Education 09.16.15 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-18
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,360 words · about 69 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001okay the public meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education Wednesday September 16th will now come to order uh Mr Thorne would you please lead us in the pledge to of Allegiance oh let's move the SC I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all I know put a picture of uh Mr Gorski would you take the roll call please certainly Miss armenio yes Mr Braverman yes Mr de Mayo yes certain Mr calman here Mrs K panowich here Mr nosin here Mr poy yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Bo president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings

002law the mon Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meting meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted September 11th 2015 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski uh Mr thorney our student rep of the senior class right yes okay would you give us your report please thank you uh the 2015 2016 school year has started for all schools in the district as of September third uh also various clubs and extracurricular organizations are looking to start early at the high school and the high school will be conducting its second annual Club Rush Event this September which will allow students to become familiar with the extracurricular organizations that the high school has to offer uh

003additionally uh the schools within the district will be holding uh back to school nights for parents uh during the month of September Applegarth um will start the band and chorus zero uh zero periods um on September 22nd Brookside will start for uh zero period SE or sorry Applegarth will start the 21st Brookside the 22nd and Woodland will be starting uh the zero periods for Banning course as well uh oak tree and Applegarth PTA will be participating in the township Green Fair on Saturday October 3rd at Oak Tree from 10:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. uh this is a Township event and the community is welcome to attend uh finally there will be a 4-Hour session on September 22nd and uh schools will be off on the 23rd uh the dates of yam kapor uh thank you

004thank you Mr thorney okay we will now uh move on to the approval of minutes we will have to do these individually in case you need to recuse or abstain I move the public oh I'm sorry didn't mean to do that Overlook the first public forum okay this is the uh opportunity for members of the public to ask questions or uh make statements regarding the agenda only so if anyone uh has any statement or question that they would like to make at this time please come to the podium state your name and address and if you have any group affiliation also include that uh all statements should be kept to a maximum of three minutes and they should be directed to the uh president of the board do we have anyone that cares to make

005a statement at this time can I ask a question first uh is the um going to be discussed tonight on the policy about the transgender bathrooms is that on the agenda tonight uh that is on the policy it's under on the policy so okay I'd like to make a statement if I could my name is Richard Gibbons 415 Schoolhouse Road I think the um you're going in the wrong direction I I I think as a society I said I don't know where we're going with this but um for years boys and girls bathrooms have worked and to accommodate somebody in this particular situation to me is ludicrous and also um the fact that a board member cannot discuss this apparently from what I'm hearing without the threat of a civil suit or the board being

006sued on this is absolutely ridiculous I think that if you look around as guys as a board just look at Society in general if you don't see what's going on in society I think you guys have blinders on I just think that this this accommodation policy is absolutely ridiculous you just see it all over the place you're trying to where the point also is where does it end where does this type of policy end you you're accommodating a transgender now and and and again where where do you stop it that's basically all I have to say I just would like you to consider that thank you for your comment any other comments or questions regarding the agenda hi uh hi my name is uh Richard Gibbons and I'm going to be actually running for the

007Board of Education this year um 415 Schoolhouse Road as well same name um basically I have the same thing to say on the uh transgender uh bathroom policy and also the locker room thing um kind of just to back up what uh my dad said earlier I I really don't agree with it um I think it's something that it's a direction the board should not be going in um just I mean look at California now and their college entrance ex um college application there's six different Choice gender choices I mean it's just getting out of hand as to all the stuff that we're trying to accommodate I mean at some point you just have to say female male bathrooms I mean they were created for a reason they weren't created because of what the person

008looked like on the outside I mean it's for a reason and to me it's just not the it's not the time to be considering this I mean right now we're taking 1 2% of the population and uh letting that represent too much so that's basically all I want to say on that okay thank you for your comment anyone else D Corino 13 Fox Hunt Drive I really don't have any comments written down or anything but I just want to say that I do have a daughter in the school system and I'm very upset about this policy that you guys are looking like you're going to pass I want to know what's going to happen to the 99.9% of the other children who are now going to be extremely uncomfortable going into the bathroom knowing that

009there's going to be an anatomical male next to them potentially or the opposite also and I did call uh Governor Christie's office today to find out where in this new law does it say that if we do not let a transgender pick whichever bathroom they want how are we violating that law um they didn't know how to answer that so they sent it up to the Department of Education they did not know how to answer that so they sent it to the law of Public Safety they did how to answer that so it was sent up to the attorney general and I haven't heard back yet so as far as I know we are not violating any anything no discrimination by not allowing someone to choose whichever bathroom they want to go to that's all

010I have to say thank you thank you for your comment anyone else okay then I will close the first public session keep in mind that there is a second public forum uh close to the end of the meeting and at that time you can ask any questions or make any comments uh regarding anything at all that you care to bring up uh at this time we're going to have a very brief uh but special presentation by our director of Transportation oh you want me to do that first okay Mr Gorski says we he wants me to get the minutes approved first so we'll take care of that so Mr Gillan just uh relax there a couple more minutes all right we'll have to do these individual I move that we accept the minutes of the

011public Board of Education meeting on June 17th second all in favor I opposed recuse abstain all right I move that we approve the minutes of the closed session meeting of June 17th no moved second all in favor I opposed recuse I'll recuse I don't remember what it was about but I'll recuse abstain all right I move that we accept the minutes of the special public Board of Education meeting on June 22nd so moved second all in favor I opposed abstain and recuse recus Okay so we've got two recusals thanks I move that we accept the minutes of the closed session meeting of June 22nd move second all in favor oppos recuse recuse and extensions none okay I move that we accept the minutes of the special public Board of Education meeting of June 29th no

012moved second all in favor I opposed abstentions recusals recuse abstain recuse two abstention okay exstension and two recusals and I move that we accept the minutes of the closed session meeting of June 29th so moved second all in favor I I opposed recuse and abstained looks like two obst that's all of right okay so now we will go to a special presentation by our director of Transportation uh Mr Gillan good evening um I attended to building grounds and transportation committee meeting on September 8th and I have compiled some data for the committee regarding number roots and late arrivals to school there was an updated okay on the screen you're seeing a um bar graph of the week one routes um in blue is the number of roots for the week and in Orange is the

013routes that were late uh we had 168 high school routes 11 of which were late we had 152 middle school routes 42 of which were late we had 40 Woodland routes 16 were late we had 82 mil Lake routes 22 were late um 96 Barkley Brook Brookside routes with seven late 94 Applegarth oak tree routes with 16 late for a total of 632 in District routes and 114 were late um some of the reasons that the routes were late were contractors um did not know the area as well as we expected them to they're supposed to do dry runs um in the afternoon and the morning delays either dropping off at the schools or boarding because when they boarded in the afternoon they did child for child um we had 300 new students um Falcon

014care was created some issues of being late as well as some confusion of students um we had a typical first day pictures and students not wanting to get on buses um and so that always takes a little bit longer redistricting was an issue uh with some confusion of people trying to get on the buses from the previous year uh so we had students getting on the wrong buses on last year roots and we also had an issue with some of the um special education late IEP uh requests and changes um so that was for week week one for week two uh was actually for four days um only two in week one the high school had 336 routes only two were late the middle school had 304 routes 30 of which were late 28 of

015those late routes were um between 805 Bus drop off and the 810 Home Room Bell uh Woodland had 80 routes with five late mil Lake had 164 with 20 late Barkley Brook had 192 with two late um abor 188 with three late that's oak tree as well for a total 1,264 IND district routs and 62 of which were late to correct the issue we spoke extensively with the contractors and what our expectations are making sure that they gave drivers the new uh bus routs um any changes to stops um they seem to not give the um student lists so we had to make sure that that was done we had to split a couple of routes to make them shorter uh we offered drivers for the contractors to either ride along or come in the

016office office we would show them uh we typed up directions that said um you know stop at your Seventh Street which is 7th Street um go two blocks make a left on um Avenue G Etc um rather than just hand them our typical Versa trans directions we found one of the issues was down in Al cult I guess they're missing a lot of street signs um Mike Gorski spoke with the contractors and told them we would be holding payment because they were not giving the um service that they promised it's also yes yes on that note um it was Dr kak and my feeling that the taxpayers did not get what they contracted for with the contracted bus routes from at least two vendors this year these two contracted vendors picked up a lot of

017the new students um simply because the district is at capacity for adding buses uh our our service Bays can't accommodate anymore we have no place to park them and have the block heater accessories and uh so we we contracted the routes out Doug his requirements for contracted routes are the same for in District routes uh we require a CDL license um we require a dry run which means that the drivers perform the route with no students to make sure that they can do it in the time allotted uh that the drug testing and all of our district policies regulations are followed and the taxpayers did not get what they contracted for this first week and we are going to hold the contractors accountable to the fullest extent of the penalties available within the contract uh

018furthermore we may uh look at different contractors for next year but the district is is uh in a legal difficult position not to take the lowest Contracting bidder on these bus routes and uh also to break contract is extremely difficult it's a legal process it's beyond our control so we try to motivate the contractor to perform by all means necessary and um and Doug did a nice job with that thank you um in the past we had a contractor Phoenix who did a lot of IND District work and renewed the routes year after year this year Phoenix is doing no work in Middle sex County with the exception of um East bronswick so we had um two contractors sending drivers in who don't know Monroe um having been a driver here in 0607 it takes

019a while to get used to the fact that um you have streets that that you drive down and then you make a right and it's the same street you have Spotswood Gravel Hill Gravel Hill Spotswood it gets you know kind of confusing um none of that is an excuse for them not going out and doing their routes we offered to like I said have driers show them their routes in fact next year they will be required to come to the office sign in and have a board employee go out with them to show them the route and make sure they have it down so we won't have this issue of them the first day of school not being able to find um streets we did have um One driver and her son in the office

020doing a dry route and first day of school she was actually terminated because she just messed up so bad uh 90% of the is issues this year are due by the contractors um it's just been a little uh it's been been a strange year with the redistricting and stuff um since then they've received drivers have received additional training from their companies um has been added time learning the routes been given explicit directions which I've already said um and that some routs were split um we're going to look into like Mr Gorski said STi for penalties um for next year um our in-house Fleet is performing satisfactorily um like Mr gorsky said we don't have the abil the capacity to expand our Fleet at this time uh so I won't go back into that uh another

021issue that we had this year was Immaculate Conception School um the bus companies from last year did not renew the routes and did not receive any bids um I went through incredible effort to obtain busting for immaculate on August 5th I met with the principal Gloria Martin the secretary Joyce Castello and Kim chorba from The New Jersey network of Catholic schools at that meeting we discussed different uh ways to get busing for Immaculate and we decided that the routes would uh need to be shortened and stops Consolidated um Joyce Castello went over to students and picked most of the stops for these routes um I worked with two commissions contacted bus companies put together packages to get someone to bid on these routs and um had no bids on these roots been U accepted parents

022would have been a would have been forced to transport their students to school um and the parents that were Beyond two miles from school would have been paid 8 and Lou which is currently $884 for the year per pupil and parents that are less than remote or to 2.0 miles would not receive any payment um that's pretty much what I have um the growth has been a big issue with 300 new students this year we've had to um last minute adjust a lot of the bus routes with moving stops just so to not not add bus routes but uh move stops between buses which has added to some confusion but um that's what we've done any questions question yes Mr Mayo how did we go from 600 routes Week 1 to 1,00 routes in week

023two because uh week one was Thursday and Friday and week two was four days oh so okay anyone else with questions Mr Braverman how how many contracted bus routes do we have there are 75 75 contractors outside contractors contracted Roots we only have I'm sorry that's the number of roots we have um first student is the biggest contractor in the district right now and so is dorm and then we have some other contractors that do the special needs but how how many do we have doing the roots in the morning um I don't Outsiders by route or the number of contractors I'm sorry Roots by Roots there's um total of 35 Roots um and most of them are tiered three roots to a package I I hope I'm not getting confused you call our drivers

024contract drivers don't do you no sir no okay sir so you're talking about 35 outside buses doing routes it actually works out to probably 12 because they do three routs they do a high school a middle school and an elementary and out of that number how many were late and you were disappointed in um I'd have to say probably 70% of them probably closer to 80% and you just said a few minutes ago which I thought was very interesting you had to take the lowest bid and we both know that it's the lowest responsible bidder and if these people were late and they Prov they're not responsible why don't we correct it now and not wait till next year when we write new rules Mr Bo yes you're absolutely right it's the lowest responsible bidder

025um and and uh First Student in particular is a contractor who had most of the issues this year and and Doug correct me if I'm wrong but we had decent service from them before that would not have led us to anticipate that we would have such a collapse in the number of routes that we experienced that's correct and and Mr Braverman even going forward next year if first student was the low bidder again and we were completely dissatisfied with their service this year it's still a legal process to exclude them as the low bidder and go at the second lowest bidder and uh it requires more than just bad experience with them from this year which we experience it's I'm sure that's true and I know you have to have a hearing etc etc but

026the same time at our last the last committee meeting that I was at they said we had a number of spare buses why aren't we looking for drivers and hire and using our own buses that number of spares included buses and and a great number of Vans it it was a total of 14 it didn't wasn't broken down it was buses and vans that um simply could not accommodate the number of students that we have contracted right now and a lot of those vehicles have been taken out of service and are are not reliable enough for for three tiering of of systems that we have Mr Ryback just to follow up about what Mr braveman brought up uh is it possible that um one company may not want to take over a contract even if

027we were able to offer it to them because of uh uh the fact that they were already working or or maybe they just don't want want to uh come into somebody else's territory so to speak or or be competitive with another company the whole process is designed around competition so that you define the route and and various bus companies which is usually several who who commit to these bids um you know sharpen their pencils and give us the lowest rate to provide this service and they have to comply with all the district policies regulations we require cameras on the buses a whole great extent of requirements that we put on our our own vehicles um and and uh you know that would be collusion if that ever happened and I'm not aware of that ever

028happening before where some just don't participate I will tell you that with the non-public routes which is the private school transportation that we're required to provide the contractor's bids came in just above the a andl amount per pupil in other words requiring the district then to pay Aid in LOE to the parents of the non-public students and with with no transportation service as opposed to Contracting out and paying a bus service where the per pupil cost comes under the $884 this was a widespread problem throughout the county that I'm hearing from all of my colleagues as the in the business administrative fields and um and I and I don't know if there's really an appreciation for What doug did with Dr kak and my uh recommendations um to work with two commissions and to revise

029the routes to lower the cost to make it um under the $884 so that the parents of Immaculate which is about 70 something actually were provided Transportation as opposed to being told last minute the contractors didn't uh bid and here's a check for $884 fend for yourself Mr noain I viously this was a a big problem especially for a certain amount of people that were affected by it uh it wasn't a problem for the roots that were on time um I had received a lot of phone calls you know with what's going on and everything and basically I I told people that they needed to to call Dr kak but more importantly I'm a little concerned why wasn't this on the agenda as an item tonight because I would have loved to had the public

030see this so that they come in and have their concerns assuaged by this presentation I'm just kind of you know because I unless I don't have um the current agenda maybe it was added and I missed it but I think this is something that the public really really needed to see because um there that's where the problem was um it's one thing if you have problems but we want to address those problems and make sure that the public knows that we are so um I don't know what happened why it's not on the agenda but that's that's a little um a little bit of a concern for me why it wasn't on the agenda yeah uh to answer your question sir the reason it wasn't on the agenda is because Mr Gillan presented to the

031building grounds Transportation committee about the hardships uh in in the most expeditious fashion to inform the committee who is um really responsible for the oversight of Transportation about the hardships that we were having and the corrective measures that we were taking so as a continuance of that report it was it was thought to um do it during committee reports um it would it we could have done it uh with the board presidents uh Buy in as a separate agenda item but that's why it was done as a committee report anyone else okay I I I just have one question for you Mr Gillan uh I noticed in both uh the first week and the second week that uh the high school and Barkley Brook Brookside they had uh the least number of lates and I

032found that interesting uh they were and they had extremely low number of lates compared to all the other schools uh do you have any explanation for that well for the high school it's the first here so um the buses come in they do the route they drop off and they leave so that that's the biggest part of the reason why they don't have it and in the afternoon they're the first here in the afternoon as well so the buses come in they load up at the high school the high school gets them out and then they go to the next one um one of the things about Barkley Brook is that and Brookside is the time they're 10 minutes long 10 minutes later than mil Lake and that extra 10 minutes helps I see do

033we have any contracted uh routes going to Barkley Brook Brookside we do oh okay all right thank you anyone else with questions all right thank you Mr Gillan for for your report uh are there other committee reports tonight Mr Coffman yes we had a curriculum committee meeting this evening we went over a few items um uh NG GSS update and a summer mapping program um we went over uh some work that had been done over the summer uh with a wide variety of uh pictures and and Graphics uh talking about some of the science programs and some of the changes that the district is going to be going through uh over the next uh 3 to five years um fairly good material and I'd ask that we can get the information published on the website

034for those who'd like to get a little bit more in depth information we also reviewed curriculum documents for laboratory Chemistry Grade K language arts and literature grade one language arts and literature grade two language arts and Literature Grade 9 through 12 French 2 grade 11 through 12 Italian for honors as well as an industrial arts and transportation techn techology update uh in addition uh the board is going to be hearing more as we move forward with respect to a program that we're looking to launch this year which is a science oiad and maybe perhaps in the next board meeting or two uh Miss alvik if you can give us a presentation for all the board members I think it's very interesting to see uh the direction that we're looking to take with respect to providing

035another venue for um expression and Desires in the uh uh science technology and math areas um again this is stuff that kids that may not be part of tag will be able to take advantage of uh as another Outlet to uh compete with other schools and provide uh a really good environment to uh look at some of the more uh comprehensive Technologies uh that are out in the world today so more to come on Science Olympiad that's it thank you Mr cman do we have any other committee reports Mrs kapovich you may have sure I have two reports this evening the first is on buildings grounds and transportation and this might be a little redundant to Mr Gillian's report but I'm going to read it anyway because I think it's important um we discussed or

036we went through two issues the first one was the transportation issue the committee discussed the busing challenges that the district encountered during the first two days of school due to a perfect storm of issues that included but are not limited to um the new Transportation routes the redistricting of the community the opening of the Falcon care special requests from parents new students that continue to arrive in the district on a daily basis and every time a new student comes we have to find a spot on a bus so we might have to change routes right in the middle of a week um all of the IND District Monroe buses or the majority of them performed extremely well and the issues seem to be from the as we heard the contracted buses mostly in the northern

037part of the district um steps have been taken to deal with it and put some new um responsibilities in place so that this situation does not occur again those steps include tracking or buses at all schools using GPS trackers on all buses having cameras on All Buses is an accountability of bus drivers on their Dy runs revisiting our policies in regard to Transportation withholding payments to contracted buses and more training for drivers um 90% of our bus rots are in-house and 10% are contracted we would love to have all 100% inhouse but we can't due to a lack of where we going to put our buses and how we going to maintain them so we apologize for any inconvenience that that was caused and I know that the Administration has handled many many texts and

038emails and phone calls over the last two weeks so after the bus discussion we had a tour of the stop Gap construction project that was done at the Monroe Township Middle School over the summer and we got an opportunity to see all the new classrooms in the renovated areas the contractors have completed 95% of the work and a temporary certificate of occupancy was received so that we can use utilize these classrooms on the first day of school work continued the past two days to install technology equipment and windows which were backordered a punch list is being prepared and will be addressed in the coming weeks and I I think we' now utilizing every space we can at the middle school except for maybe the principal's office and and she would like to keep it um

039I also like to commend Mr Jerry tager director of facilities in the Middle School custodial staff for the excellent job they did in making sure that all this work was done over the summer this two months of summer vacation so that the classrooms were ready for the students in September and walking around the schools I did notice that there were Class A lot of class sizes in in the 30s already over there at the middle school so I think that's something we need to be aware of then I have a that includes buildings and grounds and I have a transportation um meeting update and this might be a little lengthy no did I say Transportation it's a finance transportation's over so it might be a little lengthy so please bear with me um the first

040item the committee discussed was adding a link from the school district website to the Mets culinary management website Mets is the Our Food Service um Pro provider for6 $5 a year we can utilize their website to professionally customize a web page for our district that website would include the monthly menus for all the schools allergy information nutritional information catering our district nutrition policies and anything else that the um Board of Education or the administration feels should go on that site this way everybody will be able to find all the food service information in one one convenient place and currently all the information can be found on our website but it's all it's scattered so it's not um packaged very well so the committee agreed with that recommendation then we had an audit update the audit

041is 75% complete with the general fund portion just finished so far everything is looking good and the auditor has indicated that our district audit will be into the county offices on time then the audit update led to a discussion on a 2014 2015 capital reserve transfer and Mr Gorski if I don't get this right I'm sure you'll let me know and correct it because there's a lot of numbers the audit showed an excess Surplus in the 2014 2015 operating budget of 2 million 93,7 37 to be used in the6 16 2017 budget it was recommended to the committee that we restore the capital reserve account with $975,000 of that excess Surplus money which then can be used to fund any Capital project in our fiveyear facilities plan or it could go towards a bond referendum

042pre-install plan the main factors that led to this Surplus was a direct claims based insurance that was switched to a Pres prospective plan the elimination of the A4 sirch charge for retirees Health Care the 14 15 reduction in negotiated rates a purchase order freeze and receiving the full state aid award and that doesn't mean that we're receiving our fair share it just means what the state said that they would give us that year they gave us the committee agreed with that recommendation to put the $975,000 in the capital reserve account it was then recommended that half of the remaining Surplus which was which is half of that is 69,0 $118.6 go towards meeting the appropriation needs of the district and the other half which again would be $ 69,1 188.50 go towards a reduction in

043the tax levy which would bring the budget for the 2016 2017 year below cap while the board voted at the budget philosophy special meeting in August to go to cap it was done before these numbers were certified by the auditor so now it would bring the projected 3% growth in cap to approximately 2% the excess Surplus money shows that we are conservatively structuring a budget and aggressively managing it during the year to make sure that our district does what it can to save every nickel to return back to the taxpayers so we need need to thank Mr Gorski and the business department for watching all of our pennies and again the committee again agreed to this recommendation and Mike do you have anything to add to that piece thanks just just to reiterate some of

044the numbers that Mrs kapano stated the tenative figure for excess Surplus for the year ended June 30th 2015 is just over $6 million exceeding the prior year amount by $2 million the reason for the growth in excess Surplus was no longer do we have to fund a termination reserve on a balance sheet account uh where we were putting $900,000 um for when we left the claims-based health insurance method we also negotiated hard with Horizon and we eliminated A4 S charge saving 350,000 also in 1415 we reduced the preliminary rates that were proposed by Horizon by $97,700 and they were frozen and as Mrs kapano said if we were ever to prepare a budget where revenues were tightly matched to Appropriations for the next year we could be in a very precarious situation because more than

045once the state has not paid us the full state aid award in recent memory there was a $1.8 million freeze in state aid funding that if we did not have the flexibility in accounts to manage we would be probably instituting a riff of teachers midyear and an elimination of programs and services so when you have the unreliability of state aid funds even after they're awarded to you at budget time um it it pays to have a little bit of flexibility within the budget but it I want to make it clear that the budget did not have more Appropriations than deemed prudent it was ju it was really unanticipated and very effective management of the budget that led to the growth of the Surplus and most noteworthy with the $2 million of extra Surplus 975,000 is

046going to restore the capital reserve account that was established by the board several years ago for expenditures in the five-year facilities plan and uh the remaining surplus of 1.2 million is going to be split about $600,000 to meet a new appropriation needs due to growth in the district and the other $600,000 to actually go below cap um for the first time in a few years and that's a remarkable feat that we're projecting to be able to do to accommodate $7 million of new appropriation costs mainly surrounded by uh stemming from the growth and to restore the capital reserve account which as Mrs colon which said could be used as part of bond referendum funds for example if you had a $41 million Bond referendum and you had a million in capital reserve you would only

047have to bond for 40 million then or you could fund the projects in your capital reserve account which include boilers Windows roofs HVAC systems and parking lots and Main big projects like that and um to to be able to go under cap is is quite remarkable and that's um due to the board's oversight of the budget through the administration in place and I I need to continue um and after the discussion of the the reserves and the extra money uh we had a thorough review of the new Falcon CARE program by Sharon Jensen who is the director of the program who shared with the committee the Falcon care business plan the goals of the Falcon Care Program are to provide quality care for after school hours where children and students can engage in lessons and

048activities to extend their learning experiences to provide parents with affordable before and after after school care for their children in a safe and productive environment and to create additional revenue for use within the school district every Elementary School will now be a falcon care site with a site coordinator and at least one group leader and one assistant group leader at each School currently we have 431 students registered in Falcon care and 113 students participating in the early childhood education program and I just like to thank Sharon Jensen for the very comprehensive and enlightening plan that she shared with the committee and lastly um I know that Mr Gorski has added a budget link to the district website and I suggested for the sake of transparency and in support of our new communication schal that it

049might be a good idea to add a portal to that budget link so that the community members of our community will have the chance to go on that link and ask any questions they have regarding the budget or the finances and they can those questions can be easily answered by the the business department or the finance committee and then everybody is going to be getting the same information at the same time and with a potential referendum down the road we hope that we don't go through another there's a pool in the new high school that we did with a past um referendum that we know it's on on the website we can refer everybody to the website so that will be going up and at this point the meeting was concluded and we have no

050further data as of right now that concludes my report thank you Miss Kap panovich uh point of clarification Mr Gorski uh in terms of state aid we do not get all the Aid at a given time do we how does that occur the state aid is paid over uh a 12-month period on installments and uh as I mentioned before um with state revenue shortfalls in in recent years the state notified districts um Mid midpoint through the year and said uh they're unable to make any remaining payments through the rest of the year in our case that was about $1.8 million uh that was very difficult to adjust the budget and make it through the year when the rugs pulled out of you financially speaking and you don't have the revenues that you've designed to a

051budget around and you have programs teaches and services in place and now you don't have the funding source to meet it um and and not only that but as you may know the last two payments of state aid have been perpetually deferred so we're always playing catchup for those two payments and that's due to um uh State budgeting um tactic so do these come in monthly quarterly I mean they come in monthly the check com they come in monthly the check comes once a month it's actually wire transfer but the state could notify us at any time that you're not going to get the next three months because we don't have any more money that's exactly correct we have about a $4 million state aid award and it and and um it's unreliable okay thank

052you I'm sorry want to discuss anything else or I a question related to to the finance report yes go ahead great um so yeah I during the finance committee I I have no problem with the fact that we're going to bring money back and put it into the operating fund but what I did have a little challenge with and I'm still wrestling with is the fact that we're going to be looking to return about $600,000 uh back off of the budget in in favor of tax relief and my challenge is because if as we discussed in the meeting it takes about $1.2 million doish to represent a penny to the average consumer uh with respect to uh what they can see as far as their their return and my challenge is you know $1.2 million

053is a lot of things and what the average consumer gets back is and and I understand how we want to watch our pennies nickels and dimes but my challenge is this this is a roll of candy cost me a do six the amount of money that the average taxpayer will receive with respect to tax relief by lowering our budget by $600,000 the tax person in our town won't be able to buy this roll of candy until the year 2 215 it'll take them 200 years to buy this roll of candy with the amount of money that we're rolling back off the budget and given the fact that the state isn't really good at giving us money giving the fact that we have some busing issues that $600,000 may not solve but it could certainly help

054personally think $600,000 will go a longer way by addressing needs of the district than my ability to buy this roll of candy in 2,215 that's all okay do we have a Mr noin in line with what Mr calman is stating um Mr Gorski do you feel that we are sacrificing the needs of the district I I I can't believe that we will be doing that under your uh stewardship but please elaborate yes yes um never would Dr kak or I or Dr alvic um Short change the needs of the district uh through the budget process and put our names on the budget after the the uh board philosophy meeting where we identified to the Board of Education about $7 million of new appropriation needs for next year and by going to cap new Revenue sources

055of about $3 million leaving a shortfall of about $4 million uh there was a lengthy discussion about taxes and we are very sensitive to the fact that 85 cents of every dollar raised for education in Monroe comes from the local taxpayers it's extraordinarily burdensome and and the board members who who um stated that concern about taxes properly um spoke for the residents of the Town who are bearing that burden and feeling that pain Dr kak and I met and when we confirmed this um Surplus number which we knew was going to be good but but would have been premature to discuss at the budget philosophy meeting um back in August when that number came in so handsome generating the fruit of a lot of the savings initiative that we achieved during the year we actually

056thought that we could satisfy both sides we could meet the new appropriation needs we could restore the capital reserve account and be responsible to our facilities which are are in in need of address in in just about any facility that you look at even this one our our high school is overc capacity and the voters built this school on an installment plan at capacity knowing that it was going to need an addition in the near future and the footings are already set up for that so by by restoring 975,000 into the capital reserve and splitting the $1.2 million remaining excess 600,000 for new appropriation needs and $600,000 to go under the cap and not use any Bank cap is remarkable and we feel confident that we could satisfy all the needs of students through a

057a very rigorous budget process by by only approving budgetary Appropriations that are in accordance with board goals and District goals and um showing the taxpayers that we are responsive and we hear them and uh we we want to lower their burden as as best we can and we were able to do that this year through um very handsome savings again through the budget year okay are there other committee reports Mr Ryback I hate to change this interesting topic but it's one thing I could talk about is Personnel committee um our head of security Mr Puro um came before the committee and made uh his case for creating a Cadre of trained substitutes um the importance here is the training that these uh uh Subs will be getting because what we're dealing with really is the

058is ensuring the safety of our students and staff so the committee was absolutely in favor of that thank you said it be short Mr PR ELO I'm Vice chair of the policy committee and uh September 10th we reviewed six different policies there were some minor changes in wording but the majority of the policies we went over to uh discuss a recommendation to include Cultural Arts and a mighty Oaks as a class one user and I guess when I'm finished Mike you could explain that and uh the committee was in favor of these changes we also changed a few wordings in the outside activities another policy was staff members use of cellular telephones that was also changed administration of medication by parent to student screening for dyslexia and uh changes to the trans transgender student policy

059but uh Michael if you could explain how the 30,000 year an award was waved for the 300,000 Mr uh the topic begins with the uh the Monro Township tennis courts which are located on Schoolhouse Road there's two sets of tennis courts there the initial one was constructed in 1978 the other one was built in the early '90s with referendum money and both sets of tennis courts need uh desperate resurfacing every year the district and the taxpayers spent $115,000 for repairing cracks because of a water runoff and and uh problems with the the Aged facilities to um res to uh restore the tennis courts by going down to the subbase and a new Surface and new um grading and fencing we have a an appraisal for $300,000 now the district had applied for a rod Grant

060previously uh that's where the state reimburses regular operating districts up to 40% of these um expenditures even though they said turf fields and tennis courts and things like that were excluded we craftly designed the application saying that uh our our fizzed team uses it and it's really part of the curriculum and therefore it is an approvable cost but it was denied we've had several other um unsuccessful attempts to get the tennis court restorations in the budget it's a capital outlay project so in the past I reached out to the municipality um Mr Wayne Hamilton and I asked uh being that it's mainly Community use of those courts and to a lesser extent student use would the township be willing to contribute some money toward the restoration and uh we never received a favorable response recently

061I reached out a second time and I I asked for cooperation again and um we were much more successful this time where the township said that there was some open space money that could be available and um in fact through uh extensive negotiations they said they would pick up the full cost of the tennis courts up to $300,000 if the uh District would in a in a spirit of um collaboration consider reclassifying the mayor's Cultural Arts commission and the mighty Oaks players for from the use of building tiering from tier 2 to a tier one user a tier one user is uh a a student group oriented user who is exempt from use of building fees and the me and the uh Township's position is that many Monroe students participate in the um Arts performances

062through the cultural arts and attend the shows at the mighty Oaks players and therefore there really is a great student uh involvement and participation in those events therefore they should be a tier one user um so it was recommended to the policy committee to make the change reclassifying the mighty Oaks and the cultural arts commission to a tier one user and uh and a collaborative Spirit of of U working with the township and in the bigger picture of understanding the um the uh the interconnectivity of the township and the school district especially with some of our our plans for a bond referendum and Township contribution of of land perhaps in that endeavor so it's a it's a it's a it's been it's always been a wonderful exchange with the township a very collaborative relationship and

063um that was the recommendation thank you oh and one final thing the annual fees that are currently collected from the cultural arts and the mighty Oaks players is about $30,000 annually so the district would forego that $30,000 perpetually going forward because it would be reclassified in exchange for a $300,000 immediate restoration of the tennis courts a shared service agreement is being put together by Council armeno yeah my my question is will that $300,000 come in um uh a one lump sum to do the restoration or will that be over time my understanding is it's going to be a lump suum UPF front and it would pay for um nearly all of the restoration um we we have to update the uh the estimate the last one we had was 305,000 but uh nearly all if

064if not all of the restoration will be paid for by the township up front and the mighty Ys players and the uh the the commission the Arts commission is that $330,000 each that would be forgoing or just $30,000 a year with the both of them it's $330,000 total from the both of them annually in use of building fees and when we were collecting those fees at 30,000 was that a um a wash there were there was no we did not make any money from that is that correct that is that is indeed correct that $30,000 is not profit to the district it it is intentionally designed simply to reimburse us our cost for hosting those events so the cost then now um in in terms of uh salaries and use of the the facilities will

065be absorbed from by the school district yes ma'am did I also I just want it's a point of clarification that I also understand you to say Mr Gorski that that we're spending uh approximately 15,000 a year on the maintenance of those facilities yes sir because of uh the cracks and the way the tennis courts are prone to cracking we're chasing cracks annually to the extent of $155,000 per year sounds like a lot of money to fill cracks okay okay are there any other committee reports I just oh like to say one thing on the some of the uh policies to come before the committee were the district subscrib to a policy service that sends policy updates to the school district based on recent legislative action and court cases the purpose of the school district policy

066is to provide guidelines on how to adopt the procedures based on these legal statutes so the board does the I'm sorry the committee doesn't put these policies together we we're reviewing them from the uh the policy service that we subscribe to is that correct yes that's it that concludes thank you Mr proso anyone else M armeno I want to thank U Mr proso for chairing that committee meeting I wasn't able to attend but also um the review of policies some are mandated just to reiterate I know we've said this in the past some are mandated by law and Regulation and some are and they're we can always review policies when we uh put a policy together and it doesn't maybe function well or the the actual um the actuality of of putting of procedures don't

067work then we could always review them again is that correct yeah absolutely and in that particular policy that is a revi a revision of an existing policy that policy was already adopted to my knowledge last year right by the district and this was a revision and the policies are in place really to protect the district uh and the students and to Pro provide procedur procedures and regulations on how to enforce um you know reg well certain things that come down there are um you know when a law was passed uh we have to follow the law um personal beliefs aside we have to follow the law and make sure that we're doing what we need to do to protect all the students and to protect the district as well and also it seems to me

068that it gives everyone sort of a standard or a baseline from which to behave to understand and and again moving forward we could always review things if we we find the in actuality they don't work absolutely okay at this time we will turn we will turn to the superintendent's report and recommendations Dr kak thank you Mr President well I have some good news to share with everyone and uh Mr godal thank you to Mr Goo our high school principal who sent this to me last night and uh I looked at this and I wanted to share this with the board and with the public it seems that there is a organization out there called um Niche maybe it's Nic I'm not familiar with this particular organization but they rate school districts not only in New

069Jersey but across the uh the the uh the country and is that for me no I'm just kidding I'm sorry um the uh I'm just going to read a little bit based on the criteria that this company uses uh they explore the best school districts to teach uh to I'm sorry they explore the best school districts to teach based on teacher salary experience and attendance as well as the district's academic safety and re uh resources grade a high ranking indicates that that the district contains great schools with exceptional teachers who are offered excellent support and compensation and our district was rated uh and I didn't write the number I believe it was 44 out of you know we have what 600 uh districts in the state um and there's also a national ranking and they

070they use uh the criteria that they that I just stated is what they um they use to rank all the districts but they also if you go to the link um they have a uh they they have comments people from this community have written and I took time there was there's probably a couple hundred comments but I read through probably at least about a hundred of them and these are comments by parents by students some students who have recently graduated and they comment on what they like about the school about their teachers and it was it was really heartwarming to to see the the comments especially I think with for me mostly it was the students reading what students actually wrote about how their teachers were supportive of them how they helped them how they

071helped them to move on to college to prepare them um you know there was uh and there was some you know some usual uh High School type comments you know I think there might have been something about a lunchtime being longer or you know something like that but uh overall the comments were were very positive and uh again from the community and from the uh the students so I wanted to bring that to everyone's attention um you know part of what Niche looks at is the teachers work in a safe well-resourced schools and are compensated appropriately for the work the district is invested in its teachers and provides a good environment for teaching and learning and that teachers are invested in the district and students I'm sorry the district and the students and work to

072ensure the best outcomes for students so kudos to the wonderful staff that we have in the uh District the administrative the leadership team and everyone here and certainly um I was not a part of this so I'm not going to take even try to take any credit I would love to but I'm not uh and certainly my two esteemed colleagues both to my right and to my left here Mr gorsy and Dr alich who have done a a just a wonderful job and again to everyone out in the district so I just wanted to share that those those that good news I think we need to celebrate our successes and I think that's certainly a success are you going to be oh some should raise my hand Mr are you going to be putting that

073information up on the website because I think it's important for everybody to know uh I certainly yes I will now thank you for that great suggestion um yeah I will put a link up in a little of the criteria there absolutely that's a great suggestion thank you the um going to ask to I'm going to hand uh this action plan out to the board and we have on our agenda tonight the district goals which the board worked with the New Jersey school boards Association in creating our not only our district goals but also our board goals and what I'm handing out tonight is just an action plan that I I worked on to uh to uh to state how these goals will be implemented yes so I'm not going to go through each section of

074it but I am handing it out for your perview and uh you know for you to look at these goals and the action plan and perhaps uh bring any feedback we can certainly do it through the Personnel committee um you know or the board as a whole you could certainly send it back to me but I I wanted to just address the the three goals and basically State how we were are uh you know with the or how we were going to carry out these goals and if if I could Mr President I'll just read three goals go ahead okay goal number one is to develop present a plan to the board of education for its approval that will address enrollment growth and facility needs and to begin implementation of the board approved plan uh

075and that's basically as I think the community knows and the board certainly knows that the you know our our student enrollment is certainly growing every year and we're certainly um we want to address that how you know how our schools may be becoming uh overcrowded our classrooms and this is going to be something that will involve the community as I stated I was been at some of the back to school nights and I've talked to some of the parents and I know Mr py our our president has certainly stated the you know Poss or uh the creation of an ad hoc committee but these are the Community Schools the parent schools the community and it's it's going to be very very important for us that everyone in the community or at least each section of

076the community has a voice in how we address this growing student enrollment um this is you know it's very important in that the schools are a reflection of the community and that the the community has a voice in you know how they're structured and how we address this growing student enrollment so you're going to be getting more information about that uh there will be meetings set up probably monthly meetings and I I strongly encourage people to um to get involved and to make a commitment to come out and really invest there will be some time I mean you know there's going to be some time that you're going to be required to put in but to invest your time and energy into helping us uh address this growing student enrollment and along with that um

077that kind of leads into the second goal and that is the expansion of two-way communication with all stakeholders in the Monroe Community including but not limited to the utilization of Constant Contact social media and in-person meetings and basically uh the goal is for us to exchange information about the wonderful things that are going on in this District every single day every single day and I think our our esteemed uh student board representative I mean certainly the reports that you provide to the board and to the community certainly speak to that uh but it's important that we get at this information you know sometimes it's it's like teaching is on an island and we and you know there's these great things occurring in the classroom we want to get this information out to the community and

078we also want to provide vehicle for the community to give us information it's a two-way street it's a collaborative process it's not simply us giving you information we want to hear what you have to say we want to hear your concerns we want to hear what the community um thinks about uh this the the uh schools and how we're doing and certainly we want to hear what the students think as well so we're looking to just up that type of communication the use of Twitter and Facebook certainly there's ways that you can get the Twitter messages just by a text you don't have to be a member of Twitter or belong to Twitter and Facebook you know it gives us opportunity to get pictures and things that are going on in the school uh or

079schools and uh we want to use those type of resources and the in-person meetings all the technology and social media and all those type of things can't really replace the face-to-face meetings so to that end I've been trying to go I've been going to the back to school nights I intend to go to all the back to school nights and talk to parents uh meet parents we want to have meetings uh meet and greet type of events where I'll invite uh parents and community members to either come into one of our schools for a meeting or perhaps I will go out to a community center uh the town library whatever the the venue would be uh but we certainly want to open that communication up uh to the to the township and uh our third

080goal is to complete an external audit of the special educ education program from K to 12 to ensure actually it's pre-2 I guess to ensure continued delivery of the highest quality services to meet the needs of our children in the most cost effective and efficient manner possible our special need students uh we certainly want to provide the very best services and we want to provide consistent Services across the board and this in no way is any reflection of the delivery of services that we now offer but this audit could provide a better understanding uh and a a a quantitative look and as well as a qualitative look at how we provide services to our special needs populations our population and to ensure that we're providing the best Services by looking at models not only throughout

081New Jersey but throughout the country uh there's a lot of good programs and it's really important that we um you know take time to really investigate and research some of these programs out there so this will be a process where a request for proposals and RFP if you will would be put out by Mr Gorski and we would accept bids from different uh contractors and the we would review the the um the bids and we would present them to the board of education for uh possible approval there's no guarantee and if it would fit the needs of this district and if it would fit the needs of our children and if it would bring a better Ser a better delivery of services if we can improve our services or if we can do it in

082a more cost efficient manner without sacrificing any benefit to the children of the district so that's the proposal for the goal is to explore that option to see if we can uh better the program to that end and um I already uh mentioned expanded communication I know parents have have already received a newsletter that from the the what we're calling a district newsletter Falcon flyer and we're certainly hoping to expand that out Outreach to our non-parents so for any non-parents community members who have not received this please I encourage you to visit our website and it's a very easy process to click and you link and you give us your email address and now text I I did ask that we could expand it to text because a lot of people rely on their phone

083and uh please enter your email address and uh phone number if you desire to receive text so that we can provide not only our district newsletter but ongoing communication I hope to really increase that to make it really on an ongoing basis um and that concludes my superintendent report um which would lead into Personnel Mr President I just like to clarify one thing in terms of signing up for Dr kak's newsletter that's a one-time operation once you sign up you're you're good to go uh you'll receive any newsletters automatically coming into your email so you don't have to go to the district website each time and search for it once you've signed up given it your email address then you will get the newsletters automatically uh sent to your email address or to your phone

084yes now the new it'll be text as well because we want it to be user friendly whatever people's preferences thank you thank you Mr President at this point um I would uh I am recommending to the Board of Education items under Personnel items a through the for approval and I would like to um bring note that the we sent out our our agenda a week before we tried to send it out the week before so you can review the agenda however we did have uh an opportunity today to meet with a high school physics teacher and uh she came in and did an interview and um a demo lesson High marks across the board I met with her and I was very very impressed um due to the fact that we need a physics teacher

085and we want to provide the services to our students and the school year has already started I um talked to our president um Mr py and I talked to our chairperson of the Personnel committee Mr Rybeck and I asked respectively respectively if we could place this item on the agenda without having going to Personnel the Personnel Committee just so that we can get this teacher on board and bring the teacher into the District so that is an item that was not on your agenda when you received it I guess Friday last Friday oh the item number it's on the top of page nine thank you Dr number 30 under action or wait until vote on t under T number 30 okay so I already announced a so to go 28 have to get a motion

086okay I I move that we accept the superintendent's recommendations reflected in items a through V okay are there any questions that's items a through V under Personnel N I don't have okay seeing seeing no questions Mr Gorski roll call please thank you I don't have it either Personnel items a through V Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs Co Pano yes Mr nosin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president personel items a through V moves thank you all right we will now uh move on on to board action under the superintendent's recommendations yes thank you Mr President I ased the board consider approval or approving items a through o under board action so moved do we have any questions

087or comments board action items a through o all right seeing no questions Mr Gorski roll call please miss armeno um yes on everything except policy 7510 and your vote on 7510 no thank you Mr Braverman yes on everything accept policy 5756 polic 7510 where you're voting no sir correct or NOS Mr zareski yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes to all no on policy 5756 thank you sir Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso yes on everything but on policy I 5756 no Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president board action items a through o passes Dr kak can I put you on a spot sure policy 2622 can you just explain what we talked about assessment policy oh okay this is for the public so they know that sure

088absolutely um I'm going to actually pull up in the policy just make sure I grab all the reports today I just give a high overview okay just about student assessment uh I mean is there is there a specific area that you want me to okay okay that's the sheet is not really part of that policy but I'd be happy to talk about that yes the policy okay thank you absolutely all right related to the policy so the policy that you're referring to is student assessment and the conversation that we had um was in regard to our uh State assessment the park assessment and the park assessment is a state U assessment that that all schools in New Jersey uh administer the assessment I know it's been a very controversial um assessment and has been it's

089raised a lot of concerns throughout not only Monro Township or not not only through throughout Monroe Township but uh also community ities throughout the state uh and in other states what um Mr May was referring to we talked about is in other districts um one that I worked in previously along with other districts in that county the superintendent basically got together and said you know how do we address parents' concerns in a respectful manner for parents who decide that they do not want their child participating in the state assessment in park and we RI to this on the state for guidance and uh I don't know if the state quite anticipated the the backlash that occurred and uh but we wanted to be respectful to the parents who decided that they didn't want their children

090participating um I know there's a lot of concern I will state that as an educator that we certainly look at all kinds of data um to see how not only our students are performing but how we are doing as an educator in the delivery of instruction are we doing what we're supposed to be doing and I didn't want to get into the the concerns and the fears that some of the parents have brought up as far as how the data is used uh they could be legitimate you know I I'm really not qualified I don't know if any of his are to really State how that is going I can only state where when how as an educator we use student data we use Park testing or well if we get it when we get

091it just like New Jersey ask uh State testing data as one point one data point it doesn't certainly doesn't reflect the whole child and our goal is to look at multiple data points to see is a child learning and we try to look at that on as on an individual basis as much as possible so that we're looking to say is this student was here we want to make sure that this student should be our expectations is to progress from let's say point A to point you know n and if we can go to point Q that's great or if we see that we're making Point N on a consistent basis bis maybe we need to up the the you know raise the bar a little bit so that's certainly how we use data as

092as an educator uh but not to digress too much I just wanted to state that we really do rely on data and standardized data is helpful to us um to at least look and say it's the same you know and it's an objective data and there's reliability reli and validity on each test item and there are companies that you can use to do that uh in addition to your assessments that you do in hand else so again the state assessment is just one data point but to go back to I think the point that you're going to is that uh if a parent decides that they do not want their child taking an assessment I think we need to just be respectful of that and and see how we can provide um you know there's

093space limitations I can't say that we can you know uh put students in other classrooms but we know we're respectful maybe they can read a book or or do whatever um so that we can be respectful to the parents and the and the children uh and at the same time do what we're required to do uh as you know we're directed by the Department of Education on how we do things so I I hope that addresses that and the wording that I gave you is a sample of uh I took it off one of the district's websites a lot of the districts in this was in Burlington County it seems that they removed the wording and I think uh we put put it on our website last year when I was working in Burlington County

094but but I think a lot of the districts are waiting to see how Parks being rolled out this year and they wanted to just take a step back and say okay how are we going to address this are there going to be any changes there have been discussions at the state level that that maybe they'll come out with some guidance we would certainly uh appreciate that because as I would tell you as a as a superintendent and I think for all the entire leadership team we felt very caught in the middle you know we really felt caught in the middle we're trying to do what we're what we're required to do uh at the same time we're want to be respectful to students and parents thank you sure not not uh not to beat the

095horse but for tag I know that standardized testing could be a component or a data point to determine eligibility I don't know what percentage it represents with respect to being able to be either in or out of tag but my concern is that if it's a key component 25% 20 % 10% right and a parent pulls their child out of standardized testing but still wants them in tag that assessment in effect regardless would be incomplete yeah I would I would say that and Dr aan there's mulle data points but I would go back and I think this is an answer that might speak to that when I was my point I was trying to say when when as Educators we use data it's it's helpful for us as Educators to look at multiple assessments and

096data and I know this concerned about over testing and and I'm very well aware of that but we want to use we're always looking to improve what we do so it's important that we have data to determine that um you know without getting into whether Park the right vehicle or not it but we do want to have at least consistent and we want to we want to be able to have the same data for all the students this cof and I think that's part of what you're addressing and and specifically for tag make it complete if it's not complete then it's not complete no credit for participation okay Mr Gorski the business administrator's report and recommendations thank you Mr P um noteworthy in my report this month is the bill list and secretary's financial and

097cash report for the months of August in compliance and up to the date uh as far as you can go uh for that statutory requirement uh the law is that the board receive timely financial information in the board secretary report and also the review of the bill list no more than two months after month end you could skip one month but you can't go past two and we are current and up to date number two is a part a recommendation for participation in Eric North uh which is a school Insurance Group fund as part of that participation we were awarded a grant called a safety Grant for $15,452.57 [Music] down number one is a shared service agreement for um for web and TV hosting with the township and number two is a joint Transportation agreement

098with the South Brunswick Board of Education to share Transportation costs and as such Mr board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through L be approved by consent roll call second any questions or comments okay Mr Gorski roll call please m armeno a l Mr a through L uh on page 14 up to okay yes thank you I just didn't want to vote for something I wasn't supposedly V thank you Mr Braverman yes Mr areski yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr nosin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr poy yes Mr board president board action items a through L passes that concludes my report thank you all right I have a few brief comments and then

099uh if there's any other business that the board wants to bring up they may do so at that time Miss armenio I think I did make a mistake Mr Gorski was I'm supposed to on J I apologize that's what I page 18 of the rised agenda Mr board president uh point of correction on board action items a through L Miss smino's vote will re be report counted as yes and a recusal on the Travel regulation J J yes thank you good catch thank you I I couldn't find it before thank you actually thank all right uh as Mrs kapovich announced earlier uh I think the custodial staff and uh our uh building uh Facilities Management people under uh Jerry T did a great job of uh handling all those Renovations that occurred in the middle

100school over the summer uh if you haven't been into the building then you wouldn't even be aware of what was accomplished in there but they added quite a few extra classrooms and spaces that were no longer functional because the building was originally designed for high school purposes and was and those rooms were not suitable for middle school so they converted those into standard classrooms as well as small group instruction rooms uh and that certainly is going to help manage this year uh the huge number of students that we have in the middle school but uh our commendations and thanks to our custodial staff and our uh building uh maintenance staff I'd like to point out to all the board members uh in case you didn't see this because I just saw it this afternoon that

101Gwen Thorton will no longer be our field rep we have a new field rep her name is Mary gasman uh there they have created a new uh District which includes uh Monmouth uh middlex and I think it's Hudson County uh I don't quite get the connection there but at any rate uh we will be serviced by Mary gasman so check your email and it'll give you her email address as well as phone number uh also a reminder and and you can help me out here Mr seski uh of the county meeting that's coming up over in South Brunswick uh what's the date of that September 30th September 30th there is a presentation by a member of the Department of Ed I believe on uh on the park uh and so that would probably be quite

102beneficial uh for you to attend there is no cost uh and you can go on online and get signed up I believe sign up through Mr gorson for that one I signed up myself directly then they changed it yeah okay well they Chang way you can do it yeah check it out because it might be worth your while and uh you get a free dinner as well that night okay all right uh and one other thing uh Dr kak alluded to it earlier uh the steering committee on uh on the uh building facilities for the future uh will be meting meeting again tomorrow afternoon at 3:00 I believe we're going to be meeting with the uh architect uh just to get some uh information from him and also to discuss the proposal that uh we

103received from Dr uh Ivory who has facilitated this type of projects in many other districts uh so we have to look that over and see whether or not it meets with our liking but that's at 3 tomorrow and I once again uh please stay tuned uh to the website and if you're a parent than to uh any kind of of phone message that might go out regarding a signing up for uh serving on the committee that will be looking at the capability of our various buildings for future uh growth uh because we will want your participation in that we will want that from parents non-parents members of our retired communities uh as well as our staff uh so that should begin to start happening I would anticipate in October so please uh try to keep

104your eyes and ears open for that um and that concludes concludes my report is there any other board business Mr zareski uh on the state level again there's a legislative committee meeting in Trenton on Saturday September 26 the members here you're all welcome Public's welcome you need to sign up on the State website and today I had a meeting with assemblyman D'Angelo which was facilitated by New Jersey school board representative Chris Jones who's in one of our legislative contacts and I was able to bring up our issue here in Monroe about the funding that we don't receive for the adult communities that are in our district and various talks have gone on in the past that we all know we've been talking about this for years and it's still alive it's just basically on hold

105hold uh one of the biggest problems is most of our legislators including our governor out doing other things Campa campaigning for the upcoming elections uh they just got back in a session here several weeks ago and it hasn't been brought up yet but it is still out there still floating around still being talked about one of the other issues that is facing that is there's other communities that are experiencing the same problems we are mostly in the shore region and you're getting those folks on board and they're getting well we are along with them are getting battled by your bigger districts uh presumably some of your Abbott districts your newars your Trenton that feel that there's no reason why they should give up their money they're getting being overfunded to give to districts like us

106who are being underfunded by the state that was a conversation that went on for quite some time also conversation led into the funding formula which we've all experiened problems with every district has again revolved around the abbid districts and why are they getting hundreds of million dollars more when they don't even have resources to use this money for that's basically sitting there why aren't we getting it and there is a exploratory committee trying to be formed to figure out what to do with it they want to try to work the formula again but they're having problems doing so they don't really know how they want to but they don't know how that was disussed for a while and there was one other point oh the construction issues that we're facing with the growth it's just

107not in our community it's in other communities I brought up our community because I was there and I brought to his attention the fact that you have developers coming into certain towns where the developer gives the township themselves money to put in sewer lines here's a million dollars for this here's million for that take care of us let us get our development in the town and the one thing that is not representative or one group that's not representative is the schools you're bringing 200 new homes in you're getting 600 new kids where are they going to go who's funding that it's on our backs and bringing that to his attention he right away instructed his assistant to look into the laws that govern that I presented him the fact of knowing that there are laws

108that stop businesses from giving two school districts and he was quite intrigued to where he actually instructed his like I said his assistant to look into what are these laws that restrict them from giving money back to the community and giving back to the school system so that's something that I'm hopefully uh I'll have a meeting with him in couple more months to find out where that's going and that's all I have thank you thank you Mr seski Mr Rybeck Mr zesi if you don't mind I'd like to just piggyback on what you've said because it's so important impacts our schools and taxpayers um clearly uh the the uh elimination of the cap on the growth Aid formula is something that we all need to strive for Mr gski if I'm not mistaken about a

109year or so ago would cost us $4.7 million or thereabouts that we lost uh in that situation and and I know we've been trying as a district to eliminate that cap but we need a lot of support uh from our residents um you know as far as um uh towns and looking at developers it's actually if I'm not mistaken illegal for a town to say uh well what's the impact on the schools going to be when a uh developer uh presents his impact uh study uh uh to the town for approval why would that be illegal is beyond me but um I think that's something that we need to push for as well there's no reason why a town can't consider the impact on the school system uh when a development is being proposed so

110I think that's something that all of us need to uh um push um for there's no reason why we can't have that kind of uh involvement or transparency in in in a um in a proposal thank you okay any other business for the board all right then I will read the Clos session resolution uh for the uh information of the public we anticipate that this will be a very short closed session we only have to uh briefly discuss a harassment intimidation and bullying report uh some of us may also need a short restroom break so uh once we go into Clos session all together we'll be out for about 10 minutes be it resolve that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the

111Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 to discuss the following subject uh harassment intimidation bullying report following the closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exist do I hear a okay all in favor I opposed extensions okay so we will resume in about 10 minutes from now okay thank you we can save some money well at least most of the public has faded away free oh that's heat that's more expensive I was getting AIT turn the a off and open up the window that's all you need I wonder how much they waste on the AC how do you make the air warmer I wonder how much they waste the AC on

112every class it's freezing how do you get it to 7 you must you must heat it if it's 72 I had a teacher Miss Holmes for for most of the year she had to wear a winter jacket in the class our next good right Rob come to sit down always car the board will resume with its public session and at this time we will uh entertain any comments questions or concerns from the public in our second public forum anyone wishing to make a statement make a comment whatever please come to the podium state your name and address any group affiliation please remember to keep your remarks to a maximum of three minutes and they should be directed to the president of the board thank you hi um Patricia Lang 74 McFarland Circle mom so my

113concern is with Goal number three that you discussed tonight and that had been brought up at the curriculum meeting of last month and it was mentioned briefly tonight about doing an an external audit of special education I'm speaking to you as a parent of three students that were classified and went through Monroe Township I'm also speaking as a special educator of many years I am bothered by the fact that our school board we are so strapped for money and we would consider spending 30,000 20 to $30,000 for an external company to come in and I don't have that paper that was given out but on page six of that paper there are grammatical and SP spelling errors so if this was the company that your previous District spent all that money to do there should

114be no errors in my experience in the past being part of self assessment which was called um where every District had to do a self ass assessment it's part of Special Education Code you can get the form on this the website I would guarantee you maretta and the school board has copies of our self assessments we should be looking inhouse first we should be talking to our parents and our teachers please consider not spending money that we don't have so that you can find out we either need to spend lots more or you're going to cut from our most needed students because historically the first group to always get cut are the specialed kids thank you very much thank you for your comment anyone else you're to than me Cory Masters I'm Michaela Court um

115I just want to say thank you Mr T called me about the front of Applegarth and it's all fixed now so now I won't have to about tripping when I go in or any of my children and do you know the um and this is maybe for Dr Al the dates for the sixth graders for the park that they're taking it I didn't see it on the website for the Middle School may we don't have the actual dates for the specific grade levels yet we we just have the window on the revised calendar okay yeah that I saw it's just it's just a window there hasn't been because we haven't gotten specific spe yet about how some of the testing um pieces will change for this year we haven't picked specific dates for specific grade

116levels we just have the testing window that's there okay has the state given you any idea when you'd be getting that information or there are updates that come out from Park and from the state um almost weekly and we're continuously reading through them and and seeing what's going on um there were some changes made obviously we've condensed it now to the one testing window rather than the two testing Windows um they have made some changes to how many sessions for language arts how many sessions for math at times and some of those sessions um that's what we've gotten so far nothing concrete we're awaiting the results from last year's testing um hopefully about the same time we'll probably get that to to start looking at that once we get the specific dates then it comes

117down to the schools looking at their schedule their technology and how they can incorporate in the CL into in the schools okay thanks you welc blue Masters and I'm Mel Court the money the township is using or is getting for the tennis courts where did you say that was coming from I was informed that it's open open space funds so the money they usually use to purchase land for open space they're going to use to fund the tennis court renovation I have to admit I'm not familiar with open space money as it's not really Germaine to the school district um but uh they did check with those in the know on the township level that might be their attorney and came back and said it was a permissible use okay thank you somebody's offering money

118uh the hands out I I haven't voted for open space since this school was built Tom vesan to Fernwood Lane uh just regarding the tennis courts if the board hasn't already you may want to research a product called Premiere it's a court surfacing product you leave the existing Court in place this gets placed over it uh I've seen it installed other districts have it you can probably check it out on the website and see what other districts have it and maybe get some feedback from them on how they like it or not the other question is if you could please contact your buildings and grounds and ask them when the last time uh the two turf fields have been groomed that is uh maintained there's a a piece of equipment that is used to groom

119them fluff up the infill fill which is the black beads that are in the turf itself uh I would just like to know when that was done last thanks sir if you wouldn't mind uh just give me your number and I'll be happy to contact you back with that information sure on my cell number getting a lot of phone calls while that's taking place is there anyone else that cares to make a comment or have a question it's called has been sold so may good evening Ira tesler 11 Leia Drive uh just a comment about the school uh use policy um basically I think that um the deal that we're having the town is benefiting the town and not us uh I think uh what we should do is maybe invest in the tennis court

120ourself and maybe charge a fee to use it because at best if we're um going to be losing uh $30,000 a year in Revenue maybe we get a 10year return on investment and then my taxes uh on the school budget are going to fund uh these projects which um collect money for tickets and make a profit so uh I don't think it's a good deal for the school district thank you ref to the tennis court okay anyone else okay then I will close the second public session our next scheduled Board of Education meeting will be Wednesday October the 14th here at Monroe Township High School at 7 p.m. I move that we adjourn this meeting so moved all in favor I opposed if you're meeting is adjourned he

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.