CorpusRecord 132957

Monroe Township Board of Education 01.13.16 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-18
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
16,880 words · about 94 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001they should have it they should have access actually I good evening everyone uh this meeting of Monroe Township Board of Education is now in order uh I uh know we have a training first um I don't know if we do the pledge at this point I think so right uh I'd like everyone to stand and please join me in the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you Mr gy roll call please yes sir miss armenio Mr Braverman Mr Mayo here Mr calman Mrs K Pano here Mr nosin here miss Corino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here Mr rutsky hi Mr board president you have a quarum present

002this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted January 8 8 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski at this point um we have something I know we're all looking forward to it's a a training for us on Google Drive and I'm going to turn it over to Dr kosak all right well uh thank you everyone for coming early to uh go through the Google Drive training Mr Washington is going to run through the training and um I just wanted to just to mention a couple quick things some of

003you may be familiar with using share drives whether it's uh Microsoft Office 365 or Google drive but it's uh just a a way that we can keep the documents in one place uh you'll be able to access the current and past documents as well as if there's interesting material in there uh you'll see once we open it up all the folders the committee reports are all in a separate folder it's just like opening up a file cabinet and looking at all the files in there uh so we all have access to that uh there is confidential material in there that's only for the board anything that is a public nature goes out on our website but this Google Drive I respectfully asked that you keep it confidential because there's student information in there that we

004have to be very careful uh to protect okay so with that M Waton I'd like to turn it over to you good afternoon members of the board members of the public uh as Dr kak mentioned we're going to go through some Google Drive training today so you may be asking said well what exactly is a Google Drive you probably hear a lot of talk about oh it's out in the cloud well Google Drive is that same concept it's a place where you can store files in the cloud or actually out on the internet and you it enables you to collaborate with other users uh the board asked us to look at this almost a year ago as we were looking at the refresh of the high school Dr kak has been a tremendous proponent of

005Google Drive and actually the staff and students have begun using it so Dr kak said this would be a nice tool to use with the Border bed as well so we're going to take you through the Google drive what are our objectives tonight I try to keep them very simple if we can accomplish these five things I will consider this a success how do you log into the Google Drive how do you navigate the Google Drive access accessing shared documents within the Google Drive creating your own folders in Google Drives and how to copy files to the Google Drive if we can accomplish these five things I think we have met the goal of navigating Google Drive okay after we take a look at Google Drive I will give you opportunity to ask any questions

006I have handed out some documents one are your network credentials for the Google Drive that is on a little uh um card here you'll have your Google Drive account name and password the second document I handed out was just this presentation with a space for you to take notes if you so choose to so at this time what I would like to ask you to do is if you're using your computer double click on the icon that says Google Chrome I'm going to do the same thing that you're doing now Google Chrome is simply a web browser much like Internet Explorer or Safari on the Mac or even Firefox simply it's going to allow you to see content on the internet US password Mr Washington the uh the username and password are not sticky when

007or do we use the one on the card the sticky is for the initial screen yes the initial screen okay sticky oh this I did that I didn't do that the other one so we had to put this now in here oh you guys are ahead of the cve no I'm not I put I put we there yet I got put our email in there yeah no that you already did this how you get this is right just to get onto the computer tonight sorry then I just that's for uh the Google thing so we should have a sign in I did okay this what I should just going a little slow okay when you get to if you click on Google Chrome you should see a screen that looks very similar to the screen

008I have here if you see this screen where it says email address you're going to enter your Google account name there should your first name. last name at monroe. K12 nj. us all right we're still boting up over here okay it takes a so far I did I did this y you're fine there the next screen actually it's a great tool and I I appreciate you great I it's really work on a hold here so I think you should be sitting I am very Tech illiterate no problem it's easy Once you tpe type in your login name you can go ahead and type in your password which again is on your card right next to you sorry I Che the password there you go oh I accept I guess click on that that icon right

009down there I would let it don't let it memorize your password it says please my password did you only the password is not the login name yeah that's what I meant password is casens I I did I go back yeah yeah did you put your put your email in email because if you put your yeah so it would be sign it in you tou you got older than mea yes ma'am 6831 that's okay now here just type in drive.google.com that's weird isn't that weird google.com had you in there already that's what it was maybe I know let's talk to reie you know it sounds like you were in there already with one password please change my password yeah that's that's weird she might have been in already on another password it's asking her to change

010your password uh try putting the same one in again I did and didn't take it no it asked us to change our password too put it in one more time please yeah the change on here oh this is the password this is absolutely the hardest part of this got to jump you can have more than one I was just saying it asked us to change our password too so we did already that's fine go to drive just put your choose a password you haven't previously used it's not letting me put that one in then put another one in just that you would have to remember okay try that I have to use it would be unfortunate so just say oh got it okay regie are the passwords case sensitive passwords are case sensitive oh yeah

011maybe could that be Kathy when you put the initial one in did you do Capital KK got to put in my thing right okay I had to change my password that's where my Google Drive is better write it down yeah cuz this is not going help you now I know machine moving a little slower than everybody else by far the hardest part of is is logging in okay oh he just pulled up with my drive that's great you're good we'll just click out of some of those things never you don't want to save your password yes I do not on this computer yeah I use a password Google password manager I have to put in a new password okay if you need to reset yeah so I put my myw so I'm sorry Castle my

012drive you're in so hit okay got it okay I'm always the crazy person that can't do anything you're doing great I just type drive.google.com drive.google.com know I didn't know to okay where is it's desktop but it's probably the okay I you have to Google that I suspect you great excellent excellent you don't mind no's okay I'm not doing anything I don't know good it's doing it myself that's that's what I'm I have a different problem just a comment just came up when the board members go home tell me the dress code today was if they want to open up Google Drive at home maybe the end of the presentation we can just touch on I'm try to wear that perect okay thank you I don't know why go back up so everyone's screen should look

013very similar to this one yes you might not have any files in yours in your drive yet because what you're looking at is your drive okay this is your personal storage space in the cloud I happen to have a couple of files in my storage space okay you might not have any yet because you haven't placed anything there what we want to take a look at first are the items that Dr kak has shared with you so if you will click on shared with me okay is anything confidential that um no we're just going to pull up the agenda you you're going to see the titles but we the only thing we'll open up is the agenda okay and actually I have something else which if we have time I'll show you but it's not

014confidential okay okay once you click on share it with me you'll see items which have been shared with you in this case it'll be uh by Dr kak but it could be shared from anyone anyone in the world shares things with you will appear in this folder the folder that Dr kak is going to be using with you is the folder titled Board of Education [Music] 2015 okay so if you double click to open that folder okay why doesn't it say which which folder did I don't know my folder's already open oh okay so go into Board of Ed and then you should see oh there it is folders got you what am I supposed to do to open the folder to open the folder just double click on the folder I I clicked on

015the folder which folder the Board of Education one okay you know you can look at it in two ways if you want to if that view is fine or that little uh icon there if you click on that it'll put it down in a vertical way so whatever you're comfortable looking at the I that's why oh is that what's he has his in a vertical I can open it so if I did this and if you click it back again it puts it back in a square so it's whatever you're comfortable however you want to work with it but it gives you that option this one's better because it has are we doing good to list view like so what you should feel comfortable doing this time is log in and we're going to we're

016going to cover the login process again especially when you go home but you should be able to navigate the folder simply by double clicking on the folder to open them so look for the folder called Boe agendas here I am January 13 inside the folder called Boe agendas is another folder called January 13 2016 open that folder now hold here I want to show you a couple of things about Google and Google drive if you notice my screen there are some folders or some files there has W that tells me that that's a Microsoft Word document Google has the ability to read Microsoft Word documents Okay Google also has the ability to use its own word processor and create a document in what it call Doc docs started look at the blue folder the blue

017file with that like a square that tells me that's a file that was created in Google Drive by Google Drive in other words it was not created with Microsoft Word okay now if I double click on the file that has the W for Microsoft Word it's going to open it in a viewer which means I cannot edit it I can only look at it so Google Drive cannot edit native Microsoft documents cannot edit them you can view them but you can't make changes that's a subtle difference but it's an important difference and you'll see why here shortly so let me say that one more time if you see a file with a W that tells me that file was created in Microsoft Word I'll be able to view that document in readon mode I cannot

018make any changes to that document if you want to make a change to the document it will convert it to a native doc Google doc document then I'll be able to make changes and I want to show you that process yes ma'am does I'll be looking at these on a Mac so are the sub subtleties the same same thing as long as you're using Microsoft office for the Mac it's the same thing if you're using Pages which is default word processor I don't know if it'll read a Pages file but what you can do with Pages you can convert that to word and then upload it okay yes okay okay what Dr kak just said to me in his folder that he's giv you to you can only view it okay you cannot make changes

019to it just to explain why for those who don't know I'm sorry Mr watch for those who don't know when you open up that Google Document it's a live document so anything you do to it changes it for everyone and the first time I used it at one of our leadership meetings somebody highlighted all the text went to copy and paste it into something else and accidentally deleted it 2 minutes before I went to start for my very first meeting for the school year I opened up my laptop I said all right we're all set to go and it was like it's gone so so with all due respect I didn't think you would have any reason to edit anything so you have viewing only okay just so you know that now if we take

020a look at this screen here it's telling us a lot of information first I can see everyone who's logged into this folder the letters here represent different usernames you can attach your picture there that's why my picture is there so if you think about this from a teaching perspective the classroom teacher got all of her kids there they're working on the same document editing the same document at the same time that's powerful collaborative features that's not the purpose of the meeting here but just translate to a classroom environment okay now so do you feel comfortable navigating the shared with me folder yeah okay cuz what I want to show you how to do is how to create your own folders in your own documents so when you go home tonight I'm sure you're going to

021go home and be eager to practice oh yeah we can do some of that okay we're g to go over to Mom's house is your home phone number that's how eager I am are we just volunteered Tom we're going to go over his for more L well he'll serve one for moment let's click on my drive so click one time with the mouse on my drive now my drive is exactly what the name says it is a place in the cloud for you to store your own fies s hard copies so when your kids ask you do you are you have a presence in the cloud you say yes I do now the key to computerization is having it organized in other words if you have documents those documents should be in folders so that

022you can quickly find them otherwise you'll just have a long list of documents and it's hard to find anything so I always say the key is your organizational skills in my drive which is just like the C drive on a PC or the Macintosh hard drive or Macintosh HD on the Mac my drive is the same thing so if I want to create a folder on my drive to keep my board agendas I can do that and it's a simple process and I'll show you you will click on new anybody want to guess what else you will click next folder folder you're going to create a new folder and you can call it Ed documents oh in the in the window that comes up it says just start typing automated documents whatever well documents is

023suggestion you get the folder name and you click create so if we create a document can other people edit it or we only on the read only they can only edit what you share with them right now we're not we haven't shared out anything Shar we generally do this in this in the school environment we share nothing at first get used to it play around with it come back later on and say okay now let's share we keep everything tight and control first and then we give the range because if you give the range first you'll never real them back in I've been using it so we created a folder now if I had a file such as blank iPad sign out form that I wanted to put in that folder you don't have any

024folder any files right now I just want to show you this I can move up to that file name I can right click on it when I right click brings up another menu I can say move to should I click on it's like to me where do you want to move it to I want to put it in my board of education document folder say move you notice the filed is removed from this list if I open that folder it should be there and that's the whole file you just that's the whole file okay so whatever's in there's more than some one thing in that file probably this is this is one file not a whole folder but I could just as easily move a whole folder oh okay sorry okay now when you get

025home you're going to say I have documents on my home computer I want to put up in my drive it's a good play good way to back them up for one and the best part of it is as long as you have a device that has internet access you can get to your documents that's a very compelling argument your hard drive crash it's here Google's going to back them up for you okay so let going show you how to move a file now from your local computer your C drive at home or your Macintosh HD at home to your Google drive again I can come over to new should we do this too with you in just but you don't have any files on here this is as if you were home you want to

026is there if there's word on this we could open up a Word Microsoft Word document text type in test sure and then they can learn how to upload it if sure if you would like to sure I know what my time limit looked like all right so um let's take a chance here I'm going to take a chance that on every one of these computers there's at least one document that we can pull up there whether we created it or not okay I'm going to take a chance so notice what I did and I want you to do what I'm doing click on new and let's first select file upload file upload it should bring you to in the case of these computers your C drive you can see files that are on the C

027drive okay let's see if we can find something good here let's just move any file for now the file we're going to move now you're not going to be to edit it because it's a it's a system file okay but if we had Word document on here we could do that too but I just want to show you the process of putting a file up there any file okay on your computer now you should see a list of folders and files select any one file you want doesn't matter which file just select a file double click it you should see that file get uploaded to your documents now yes okay so that's how easy it is to move a file from your local computer to the cloud we did that with one file if you

028had a folder at home on your home computer and it had hundreds of files in them you can move that up as well okay Google doesn't care how much space we use they're very generous to us okay can you upload them that as in one big swoop in one big swoop yes instead of selecting from new oh it's still uploaded oh okay you're going to say select folder upload and you'll upload the whole folder how we doing now still uploading still uploading you chose a big folder how do we know if we chose fig I chose did you just St put words yeah it's it's got 18 and I got to get up to 32 I would like to show you at least one more thing and what I'd like to show you is let's

029assume you don't have word at home but you want to create a file in Google Docs you want to to create your own document okay I want to show you the process of creating a documents in Google Drive so again we're going to come back to New click the new word and we're going to create a new Google doc okay so let's click Google Docs it's going to bring up what looks like a word processor okay does everyone have something that looks similar to this okay let's I'm uploaded now Hillary didn't need them one of the other great features of Google Hillary didn't need Google saves automatically you don't have to save it'll save by itself so the first thing I do when I create a new document in Google I give it a name

030so if you click where it says untitle just say give me your document and the name my first go my first Google Document enter enter and just hit enter so that document has a name now now let's type some information in your document I'll type hello world that's always the first thing you do with a programming language you learn how to say speak to the world you say hello world hey notice I have not saved the document I never hit save so if you you've typed your narrative in your document just click close that tab by hitting the X in the upper right hand corner notice I never saved it notice here's my document my first Google Document that's the name I gave it and if I open it it will have saved my contents

031and I never hit save open the document got it okay says hello world I I'm not there cck just how we doing this is where I was just here okay I don't want to give you information overload but your homework assignment go home and create your first Google Document do you have any questions as far as a overview of how Google Drive Works yes sir um could we just go over over how if we wanted to share a document with the board give send somebody a link like uh uh like Dr Kovac did to us before okay I'm going to close out this document my first document now the document we'll look at a document you share in a folder would be the same way except it's a entire folder versus a document I did

032select the document you want to share sorry put you and you right click on it again it brings down another menu you select share s get a complex no no no sorry when you select share it's going to ask you to enter the name or email address of a person now there's something subal here that I want to show you so if I'm sharing this with you Mr noin I'm going to type in your name your email address addess tomin and notice here to the right it says can edit if I leave it at can edit you will be able to make changes to this document however if I say it can view you can only see it it'll still be shared with you but you can't change this document doesn't mean you can't take

033that document and move it to your drive and edit it you could do that you did that already now if you're sharing with multiple people you just hit enter where I type your name and enter the next person's email address and it will share with all of them and they receive a notification that you have shared the document with them is that okay perfect any additional questions yes sir um for the purpose of tonight I mean if if people are comfortable uh can you show them how to open up the agenda for tonight and also open up maybe the the backup material so that um they can have the tabs and they can just read off the computer tonight if they want to follow the agenda tonight it would be a good practice you know

034even if you keep your hard copy next to you it would be a good practice to go through just to follow through okay so we're going to go through the process of opening tonight's agenda and we'll open the backup documents so that you can look at them at at your leisure as the Board of Ed beting is is going on so here I'm just going to cancel out of here I'm not going to share this document okay it's this okay cancel out if I'm back here and I got here who knows how how do I get back to my to back here link my data I hope I was supposed to okay so let's n navigate to the shared with me folder oh I have to type in that right up on the top correct

035and then I clicked on shared with me okay thank you with me you're going to open the Board of Education folder we're actually not supposed to be using you're G to open the folder that says b agenda but see what happens with this agendas come down to January 13th 2016 Google vers of it double click that you see seven files in that folder seven so the actual agenda you have two different versions of the G agenda I would probably guess they're the same document one's created in word the other one's created in Google Docs so you can probably open either one of them I'll open the word one okay so that's the agenda that's what we're going through now okay yeah thank you very much how can we keep the agenda open and the backup

036docks at the same time got to the next page this tab to the left no you do it to the left here and it'll keep this open one and then just do back up thank you just can't hide it and they'll all stay open how can and I can navigate get in the agenda right just pressing on it okay okay no because everything is now going to be on google doc I didn't know how to when I open this on the top it list Marvin Mike and Steve does that mean they're looking at the same of the document as me yes okay pretty cool huh yeah pretty scary how come I don't have that because you opened the word version oh all right did or did you open the I no you're you're right that's

037why because the word doesn't have the the smarts that the Google does to to know okay so now if I wanted to open the Google version just close it close this open this you can always move your mouse if you're on the PC you can move your mouse down to the the uh Google Chrome here you can see the various things that are open and just switch in between them we have three M click on that that will show you all of your accounts so when you're at home you're red well I'm not there you'll be able oh I could add that account okay how we doing okay good thanks how did you open you don't see you I don't see [Music] me okay no you're pretty and if I just put my account and'll

038just add it to the yeah cuz that's the thing find over there say yeah you have to go back and forth in order to get I need help because I could probably help you now just took me a second hit the oh you have your own place card here yeah so that's your address Lear personal computer so then I maybe I have you have to go back and go yeah you have to okay add both accounts thing is I got to use it they're all open like the glitch and I think Reggie said that it was my home account that was the now one thing I want to show you because I know thank you uh when we set up your accounts many of you have Gmail if you have Gmail you already have a

039presence on Google it's going to be very very very important that you log out of one account before you log into the other otherwise you won't see your documents like when you're using Gmail you really are logged into Google so you need to able to log out of one account and then log into your board account otherwise you won't see the material okay so I'm going to show you how to log out of Google okay okay so here I'm going just go back to drive.google.com which takes me to the beginning drive.google.com and that's on the handout you have and I switch between these alas this all the time I confuse myself who I'm un logged in with so to log out you go to the upper right hand corner and you look for the symbol

040for you either be a picture of you or the first letter of your name or something like that and left click on that once you do that you should see who you're logged in as and if you're in Gmail it may say uh Kaufman gmail.com okay because a lot of you use Gmail so you have to sign out that logs you out of your Gmail account on the computer I use all the time I probably got five different accounts here it depends on what I'm doing so this one will always stay now the reggie. Wasington monroe. K12 but you could add in a different account and this may be where you want to have your Gmail account and that's how you keep things separate it's kind of confusing in the beginning oh Add accounts I

041should but always know who you're logged in as that'll give you a clue if you're logged in with your Gmail account you will not will not see the files and folded you have to be logged in with the lou. Coffman monroe. k2. nj.us I'll do it or marvin. braj us so it's important you have to log in with that account that's probably the most common support call we get I don't see my files so who are you logged in at me gmail.com you're correct you don't see your files you have to log out and use the district account the district account will prevent any ad from coming up you'll get no solicitation none of that stuff you see out on the internet happens with a school based account all right at this point in time

042I'm getting the hook guess I'll talk to you later thank you very much thank you very so if you want to stay logged in and use the agenda the agenda is the most current the most current agenda is up here another Advantage for us is we send out the agenda on Friday we get uh all kinds of different things coming in between Friday and Wednesday the board meeting so if you get used to using it on the on Google Drive you'll see all the latest updates and we don't have to keep on sending out updated Word documents and things like that all right okay uh we have a photographer here for uh tonight and um I'm going to ask him to come over and direct us in what order how you want the picture taken

043picture first grou picture okay where would you like us to be um you want to set it up here please with the flags in the background yeah okay yes yeah I'll put it on the floor a thank you sure okay and you ask you want everyone to come up here yes we're going to do two row sitting and standing sitting and standing pull the chairs out who's your suit who's your suit I'm going to sit okay next to Mr board president whatever okay I didn't wear breath I feel terrible photo okay just no signals okay and then we need individual head shot folks okay me gentlem let's the jackets nice and tall slide slide forward picture okay okay slide a little bit more to right there I won't that I don't even bar over here

044favor let's do a little bit uh can you stay in the middle a little uh triangular composition here okay man can you can you switch on the other side me go to there you go close everybody there go oh no I I didn't know good smiles to the right I want to give him some room let's do individual head shot all right let's do on the plane background individual they didn't tell me I didn't my hair I didn't get my did I'll take the can't I didn't tell you I've been sending out notices for like a week [Laughter] that's funny but it's scary that you know would have found it too much information actually I stopped using Bondo oh you're not Corvette guyo is what they fill in in car I was able that was

045good like that I know you didn't like I got back here look I'm back sheets repl who you are yes did you notice that I'm being punished okay have to go to the bathroom so I might as well must had a lot of angry not too manys but definitely uh [Laughter] internally day but it's going to catch up [Music] it you can do Google middle school he problem sticking up right they put on website like other districts or a lot of districts have got go that's what I mean you're saying yeah they put a face that's true that's a good too [Laughter] man science is true everything in there is true do we get everybody everybody get an individual picture we got everybody the yearbook advisor for the high school she's the one in charge

046the individual shots as well yes can give you get it you know you can get the pictures thank you so much this something we need every time we open up the computer computer yes yes to log into the computer it's kind of like the guest username and password to get on the computer you could approve the minutes if you want once everybody gets I'm going to make mention that the students yeah of course I won you can actually if you want anything on the but but the individual pictures will go to Oh Mr the E brook adviser the yearbook advisor to Elliot so we can put them on the talk my financial advisor I don't know ADV just to keep them on his toes I got into I don't know never 50 and it's been

047I'm trying to catch the falling KNE say go to the yearbook ADV hey I told him take some money out so I said who gets the Bond Fess I don't know either that's told we ready everybody took the picture when do I have a meeting I was debating that same we have two yearbook advisor thing myself today exactly yes sir are we ready ready everybody you're minutes early I I will we're still in session I just like to ask the board members to take their seats okay next item is the um approval of the minutes see you I like a motion to improve the minutes for the public Board of Education meeting of November 18th 2015 so moved have a second I know that because does anybody second that second thank you Mr corsky any

048question okay I thought it was a roll I thought it was a roll all in favor any opposed no extensions no recuses okay I'd like a motion to approve the minutes of the Clos session meeting November 18th 2015 so moved second second thank you all in favor I I any opposed assume there's no abstentions or recusals okay thank you uh at this point we have the uh student board members report Mr thorney thank you Mr board president um since we just had a meeting the report's going to be fairly brief um as you may have mentioned um the student growth committee uh recently met in order to assess the effects of uh the student population growth on the district which of course is a big concern for the entire Community um as I uh mentioned

049in my last report there were two conferences going to be held in between the last meeting and this meeting one of which um was Deca in which students from in this case across the region uh competed in various um business finance marketing and Hospitality related events against students from other schools uh many of them um involved both a written exam and a presentation portion in order to assess their skills and we're proud to report that um there were over 30 students who placed and um over 21 of them uh 21 or um around that area were in instructional related categories um this of course being an extension of a lot of the skills uh that they're learning in the classroom and there were many students from Monroe who are not only finalists who are eligible

050to move onto the state conference but who also placed within the top three of their respective categories um also the model United Nations conference uh last weekend that conference included um students from schools across four different states totaling over 1,00 students um for this program students are assigned countries and committees they uh conduct extensive research in regards to their country their country views and the topics to which their committee has been designed and then act on behalf of that country and we're proud to report that many students from the uh monant delegation were also recognized among the 1900 other students for their um excellent performance in either the committees or the court section speaking of which the mock trial team had a recent event tonight conducting a mock trial at the municipal building um I

051think Dr kak I think you said you were going to that I'm not sure if you I did until we had the board meeting that was I I agreed to it before we had set the board meeting so unfortunately I was not able to attend uh in any event this work was done in addition to the competition that the students were already preparing for um last last year they uh placed I believe second in the uh County which was excellent and they're going to have that competition later and they're doing this recreationally in addition to their preparation finally the last thing I want to touch upon is the AP testing that's being coordinated this year um for the past many many years the high school has offered advanced placement courses uh which um because of

052previous presentations I know the board is very familiar with uh after meeting with the co-coordinator today um I'm happy to report that we are uh between the students um and uh the classes that they're taking we have the potential for roughly 755 examinations um some of these are going to be students taking multiple exams but of course that uh is um a very good representation on the teachers and the students within our district as uh the students take higher level courses and attempt to get college credit Mr board president that concludes my report tonight thank you thanks Mr Thor it sounds like you've been a busy uh young man there thank you very much uh next we have a uh presentation by Dr alvic for the uh Park data good evening every year we present

053our uh assessment data out to the public and to the board of education for your review um I'm also working with all of the schools to make sure that they have all of the uh the same presentation and the data and they are working in their buildings to really drill down on the data um so tonight I'm just going to share with you some of the state park assessment data as well as our district assessment data so in 2008 the New Jersey high school redesign steering committee finalized their report and as part of their report um they were focusing on creating a vision statement that will lead them through the adoption of standards and the adoption of our assessments they noted that while New Jersey standards were high they weren't aligned with college entrance requirements

054so in 2009 they adopted new cour taking requirements for the regular high school diploma such as four years of English and three years of math including Algebra 1 geometry and Algebra 2 and then in 2010 they adopted the Common Core State Standards in language arts and math which are widely understood to be higher standards than New Jersey's prior standards and they are focused more on the kinds of skills and knowledge that students will need after they leave High School in 2012 The College and Career ready task force reviewed the work to date and confirmed this impression of the standards also in 2008 the high school redesign task force stated that New Jersey's old high school assessment the high school proficiency assessment or HSPA hespa wasn't measuring college or career Readiness and it was all but

055ignored by colleges so the recommendation was clear and that's when they came up with a uh series of end of course Assessments in English and math that we now know as know know as the partnership for assessment of Readiness for college and careers or the park assessments we gave the first assessments to our students this past March and May so the park assessments replaced our old assessments students are taking the assessments beginning in third grade they were online assessments the one thing that did come out of this group was students who were in 8th grade and above did not have to take the eth grade grade level assessment if they were in a higher level Math course so students who take Algebra 1 and e8th grade took the algebra 1 end of course assessment and

056did not take the eighth grade test so in park students outcomes are divided into five performance levels level one is not yet meeting grade level expectations level two is partially meeting level three approaching level four meeting and level five is exceeding grade level expectations the the state of New Jersey has determined that in order for students to be considered passing the park assessment they must score at least a level four on the park assessment both in in uh the English language arts and in math so to share with you some of the state results so these are the results across the state of New Jersey this chart and this presentation will be available on the district website um as of tomorrow so that you'll be able to uh view it closer I know it's hard

057to read some of the numbers um from a distance so if we look um at this chart the way that it's been organized by grade level grades three through 11 the First Column is students that met the percentage of students that met a um a level scored a level one the second column scoring a level two level three level four level five and then the final column in blue are the percent of students scoring a level four or five which which basically means those are the percentage of students who are passing the park this is the state data so one of the things that they have noticed and that we are that all of the uh districts in the state of New Jersey are looking at is these are lower percentages than when we looked

058at the New Jersey ask scores however um it is a new assessment it is higher standards and we and every District in New Jersey is looking toward that we also have the math assessments and again it's um this organized the same way the percentage of students at each level and then the final blue column is the percentage of students passing or or at a level four or five of the park assessments again noting grade eight students um we any student who was taking Algebra 1 and e8th grade is not listed in the grade A the grade8 col uh row they are listed in the algebra 1 assessment what the state has looked at um it's very difficult to compare Park to New Jersey ask we're testing different standards it's being tested in a different way

059so what the state looked at instead was comparing the park to other uh assessments such as the um the nape which is the national assessment of educational progress and the American diploma project in Algebra 1 um so they look to compare comp more at that they're also looking at to see um how the scores compared with the SAT scores and the ACT scores and what they're finding is there's more of an alignment in the percentage of students passing um the the park with those assessments so we're going to continue to look at that and the state is continuing to look at that to see where we can um how we can move forward the state also looked at um let's see the state also looked at end of course math outcomes and meeting the expectations

060so if we look at the total number of students so you have the count of how many students in New Jersey took the assessments at each each of those end of course assessments and then they compared it with the um algebra assessment that was given in 2011 the ADP assessment um and again what they were finding was it's more aligned to those National assessments rather than the park assessment results they also took a look at comparing the um Park Algebra 1 assessment results with the percent of students scoring a c or higher in the course we have to report out through New Jersey smart every year our course grades in the high school so it's it's reporting out um that students who there there a higher percentage of students scoring a c or better in

061Algebra 1 so across the state what they're trying to propose and look at that um is looking at the standards and seeing what else do we need to do how do we need to bump up our standards for these math courses so that we're meeting the expectations so those are the state results the results for Monroe Township the way these are organized is Again by grade level there is a count of the valid test scores in order for a student to receive a valid test score they had to take the PBA which was the performance-based assessment March and the eii the endof year assessment in may they had to take both sections of the assessment in order to get a valid test score and they received one test score um for both of those assessments

062so the way that it's organized here for you is you have the by grade level the number of students who we received test scores for and if you look at those numbers we had a very high percentage of students that we received valid test scores for then by levels so the percent of students scoring a level one level two level level three level four level five and then the second to last column is the percent of our students passing the assessment so scoring a level four or five as compared to the last column which is the state average so we can if we compare our scores to the state average notice that in in many cases most of the cases we are higher than the state average we have noticed that our high school scores

063are lower than the state average and we we've begun to look at some of the reasons um at at the high school one of them may have been some of the scheduling last year it was difficult to schedule um the assessment so students may have been missing a class in order to go to a to go and take the test so they were rushing through the test in order to get back to their class because they didn't want to miss content um another issue was there was a lot of negativity um through the press and um with the parks and we know high school students are are aware of all of those pieces so that may have played into it so we are really taking a look at individual scores and seeing does that score

064make sense for that student so the high school each school is actually creating a data team to look at this the the assessment data and look and see what we can do so um the other thing we also took took into account this year is we've changed the high school scheduling for the testing and students will have a delayed opening schedule so that they all students will just be involved in the assessment and then they're not missing class time they'll then be able to go to their classes so that is the English language arts assessments for our district these are the math assessments and again it's organized the same way with the number of valid test scores um the percent of each level the second to last column is our percent of of students scoring

065a level four or higher and then comparing it to the state average in the blue column and in all cases except geometry we are above the state average so again it's something that we we are looking at um as we move forward with the test data and really taking a look at it in our when we compare all of our middle school and our high school students obviously there's one one Middle School one high school in our district so we're we know that that that uh includes all of the students so uh we broke down for you the um percentage of students scoring a level four or higher at each of our elementary schools um again looking at each of our elementary schools compared to the state average they are all above the state average

066um oak tree has only third grade in their school that's why oak tree and Applegarth are split there Applegarth is fourth and fifth um Brookside and Woodland had third fourth and fifth grade last year this year obviously um the third grade from Woodland moved back to mil lake so it'll look a little differently next year when I'm presenting this information so that's our language arts scores and this is our math scores by Elementary School and again all of our scores are above the state average so what are our next steps as I mentioned each school is creating a data team um they've already started to look at the data through New Jersey smart and the park information online the um we are actually able to even drill down all the way to individual items that

067students answered on the assessment as compared to the standard and seeing where they are so we're taking a look and seeing are there gaps are there strengths in our existing curriculum instruction so do we need to um rearrange some curriculum revise some curriculum add add in some professional development for our teachers and that's what the teams are looking at now we are able to drill down into this data by school level um by District level by subject area um breaking it down by standard looking at it by subgroups item analysis and student level analysis and we're using all of those options as we start to look at this data but remembering that this is one picture this is one snapshot of our students this is one assessment piece that we use we use multiple Assessments

068in our district for any of our um when we look at course course assignments when we look at eligibility for tag advanced math um basic skills we look at multiple sources of data for our students this is just one of those sources but it's one that we have that we can use so we're going to use it to the best of our ability I just want to share very quickly some resources that we do have for parents um I have been working with um the supervisors to prepare some videos one went out uh Sunday evening through the Falcon Express to parents um and community members on how to read their child's score report parents receive the score reports the end of December um another one another short video will be going out in a couple

069of weeks um on resources that parents can use to help their children children at home on the assessment and then there will also be a third video um going out from Dr Roselle and Mrs Gasco our language arts supervisor and math supervisor on what does each section of the park mean what does it look like in the classroom what does it mean um with the content that that's involved in each of those and as I'm going around and meeting with all of the schools I'm asking them that if they are hearing questions from parents um to shoot me an email because we can always set up something else and more information we want to get as much information out to parents as possible about it so there are some resources for parents understand thec score.org

070is a great website for teachers and for parents um it goes over uh each of the parts of the assessment it offers a uh a video for understanding the score report it offers a parent Guide to the score report it also offers um some skill practice for parents so if there's a student if their child fell short in one of the areas on the assessment they can go in and practice and actually go in and just practice on that one specific skill um and um be a learning hero is is one of the learning tools that they can use at home um also we we're hearing a lot of questions about well what about typing did that affect our scores um one of the uh free a free program that parents can use is is

071typing.com um we're also looking at a pilot program in our media centers in the lower element Elementary and the upper elementary schools to try and get students to use the um more of the typing skills to help them with with the assessment and teachers are using technology in their classrooms all the time especially now as you just learned Google Drive teachers have been really exploring that option also in the classroom so getting students to use the computer as much as possible I was also at a faculty meeting this morning and um Leah Wagner from the mon Racha Public Library was also there and Dr Roselle goes to the monthly meetings um with the uh mon Racha public library and she's had a lot of questions from parents on how can I help my child do

072you have Park Prep um in the in the library so this is a program that she's offering um to any anyone who has a library card they can go on and use this and all of our teachers also have access to this in their classrooms so you know it's it's a great partnership with the public library um to help to help share resources also and that's it I try to do that yes I thank you Dr Al appreciate all the information and the way it was presented thank you our um next item is committee reports however the Committees were just formed Mr noty I'm sorry yes I didn't see any hand so that's fine I just know that was at this point um from from an administrative standpoint um were there any surprises in the

073results uh for either Dr kvx or uh or you Dr alv from talking with all of the staff members overall we were pretty pleased with our results um for for a first time taking this assessment and the high level of the assessment and the the fact that it was all online we were pretty pleased with our results um as they're going through now they're really now just taking a closer look on drilling down into the data so I don't have any specific things that they're going to work on yet um if there's something that's glaring coming out as I said the the high school's not thrilled with their results um they but they want to work toward showing what they're doing in their school um I had a meeting with the high school staff this

074afternoon with Mr Goodall we had a faculty meeting where I presented the information to them um and they had some um um some reasons why they thought that the scores were lower um and they had some ideas of how how we could help improve it by being more positive in the school um encouraging our students encouraging our parents that this is an important piece uh something for the students to take take uh seriously and hopefully we'll have a better um outcome with that just with that piece um but we're just starting to look at it and drill down to see if there's any changes that we need to make with curriculum instruction and PD respond to as well sure can I add to that as well uh Dr ACH is is absolutely correct uh but

075I just wanted to add to what you were saying regarding the high school I meet with a group of students from the middle school and the high school it's a student leaon group so our last meeting meeting I said what what did you think of Park what were your thoughts on it and it was interesting to hear the students say I had to leave my AP class to come and take the the park I went in did a couple things and I got back to my AP class as soon as I I could because I know that it's not a graduation requirement for me I already met that I had no reason to do anything with that that was repeated several times from the students to address that we have now as Miss as Dr

076Al uh has already stated we're now going to have a delayed opening so there will be no reason for anybody to leave a class or to miss a class and it'll be maybe the first two hours in the morning for that one week we also made sure that every single student in order to accomplish that has their own keyboard with her iPad so that uh everyone's will be working on their own iPad so it's not an excuse this occurred last year with the testing I wasn't here obviously my goal and the goal of Dr Alvi and everyone else is to say okay here are the results what are we going to do about it how are we moving forward how are we going to address this so we're hoping with the the uh strategies that

077we mentioned as well as what Dr abic uh talked to the staff about uh and they in turn will talk to the students that they realize that you know um it is an important test and they should do well on it um is there any issue I mean to me we're getting the results awfully late these these 11 11th graders they're almost done the ones that took in 11th grade they're done with their senior year almost um is there any plan going forward uh to maybe get the results quicker or you know so we can be more you know on top of it yeah according to the State Department of Education um the reason that we got them as late as we did this year was because they were actually figuring out what the cut

078offs would be for the levels so it wasn't just okay we're looking at the results and getting them out to you so they're Hope from what I heard the hope is that we get them early in the summer um that remains to be seen but that's that was the plan the reason it took as long as they did is because they had committees working to set those cut off cut cut off scor and that was only because it was the first year corre so okay thank you any other question Miss Armenia yes um I still I want to reiterate you know some of the concerns we had from parents and students about missing instructional um classes but also we're not not going to teach just to the test right I mean we really should have

079a clear picture that that's not going to be acceptable that we want our children to learn and and we certainly want them to perform well on standard tests but that the learning process is more important then and how are we going to balance the need you know you're going to get all the data and you want to improve on our scores how are you going to balance that with keeping our we have never had the the practice of teaching to the test test or test prep um but what we should be doing is teaching the standards and that's what our curriculum is aligned to so if our teachers are following our curriculum and our our Assessments in our curriculum then they will be preparing our students for the assessments and for College and Career and

080may I absolutely question um how compared to other tests you said two hours we're going to have for testing in the next round it's a delayed opening sched so yeah it it depends on there's different days required different minutes for the assessments and didn't didn't standard certain standardized tests are an extra day outside of the school day and the parks are done during school hours we've never had SATs and all don't they sats are on the weekends right that's what I mean why why can't park assessments be done so we don't lose instructional time or is that a mandate from the state yeah we have to do it on certain days yeah we have a we have a specific window away from the instructional time I know no one wants to come in on Saturday

081to take a test but that'll change the instructional time thing okay thanks Mr braan I I find it interesting that you said the I find it interesting you said the staff is disappointed in the results not ever being a proponent of block scheduling everything you read on the website about block scheduling says that scores get lower it's it's it's the way it it's it's it's the way the structure of block scheduling is that affects the way kids learn in terms of these articles that I've read and I know it's the hot thing now schools are putting in Block scheduling but interestingly enough there's a school in North Jersey and one of the reasons why they got rid of their superintendent was because he insisted on block scheduling and they just couldn't see it so it's

082I think because it's the first year of the test I think that's why we're seeing a dip in our scores we had seen an increase in our scores with the New Jersey ask I understand your concerned with block schedule and I just have a couple points to make when I met with a student Le aison group I also asked them what they thought of block scheduling and every one of the students especially advanced placement students that the students taking advanced placement courses said we absolutely love block scheduling because we go much more in depth into content and It prepares us much more for college I would also say that if we take the park aside and we look at our SAT scores and we look at other indicators other data indicators it clearly demonstrates that

083our students perform well so I wouldn't want want to rely on just this first year administration of the park test when the scheduling wasn't the best as it could be kids were missing class time there's been a lot of controversy around the the exam if we saw low test scores in our SATs in PSATs in all other types of Assessments at the high school level I would say we have a concern that we need to address and perhaps block scheduling is the culprit I know that I'm not saying block scheduling is the very best uh you know there's many different kinds of schedule modifi block a block not having a block at all um but right now it it doesn't seem to hold notwithstanding the park scores all of our other assessments don't seem to

084support the idea that they're they're not doing well with the block scheduling D may I just respond to that I think unfortunately when we're dealing with students it takes too long to come to some positive conclusions and during that time students are losing out um I think over the years a lot of uh research has been done on this and it seems that one of the negatives about a lot of administration ERS is they don't res they don't look at the research and one of the big things about the block scheduling when it was put in here was it'll be a lot easier to schedule Laboratories well a lot e that's you know that's just terrific for the administration but really how about for the kids mrman if I could Mr uh Mr President Mr

085bman uh respect you uh as a as a board member as a person as an as an educator and I you know I didn't put the block schedule in place here but but at the same time uh I am very interested in making sure that that we as a collective team as our leadership team is aware of the latest research and does check it and I would you know uh be very I would love to sit down and discuss block scheduling some of the research with you and Dr alvik and and uh maybe members of the high school administrative team um because I think it's important if we if we just become um um LAX days agoal with with with the way things are then you know we maybe we don't have the best schedule

086so I'd be certainly open to anytime that you would like to sit down and go through some of that and even uh put together a team to to look at different um types of schedule and as as Alternatives um to at least so that we we examine everything okay is what okay to to come in and meet would you be agreeable to that I'm not an expert block scheduling I think there's a lot of information out there P Delta Kappa the Harvard Education review there's plenty of plenty of uh stuff on the website I I think you just should look at it all right we will we absolutely look at that thank you anybody else no so the New Jersey numbers weren't the best could be oh sorry New Jersey numbers weren't the best they

087could be you know kudos to the schools here that looked like you would do really good excluding the high school how did New Jersey fa nationally against everybody else get a park is National exam I don't have those results I'd have to get those for you okay we don't have them but right now nationally I believe there are about six or eight states that are using Park the other states are using either a there's another test called uh I believe it's smartar B Balan assessment Pennsylvania created their own assessment um when this first came about Park and smart the the smarter balanced I was really hoping that nationally we would have one assessment because I too would like to know how do the the New Jersey students fa against California Texas Massachusetts um you know

088other states out there um unfortunately things have changed and we don't have we know no longer have one assessment like that because it's stupid that we go to a common core which is a National Standard and we have flavors of exams it it just you know whatever it's what it is but I do know that when the Stu when the parents received student score reports the student score was compared to the school average the district the state and the park Consortium average so I'm sure there's a report somewhere that I can find that will compare our scores to other states um the other thing we have to remember though other states also put a three as passing where New Jersey decided that four a level four was passing so we would I would have to

089look at that but I can definitely look at that information for you Lou uh I remember reading something uh in in the U Star Ledger that noting that the U the state Jersey actually did pretty well I think I think it was sixth or something but we did we did pretty well nationally uh I do appreciate your comments about the uh actual test because the you know a National Standard having different tests um it doesn't just measure up Dory I'd like that you said something and you touched on this but I think it's important to to um just bring it out and if I'm correct I need your comments on it again I was um spending some time you know just looking for information as I'm sure we all do and um I read something

090that said that as far as teaching to the test that uh you know with with common core and park aligned teachers aren't teaching to the test if they're if they're teaching to the stand standards so that sort of eliminated that concern I know it's a concern that many school districts receive um I just wanted you a comment on it or or and that's that's exactly it we've aligned all of our all of our um curriculum documents to the common course standards and we've included assessments um our benchmarking assessments that we use in all of our courses across the district are more Park aligned type questions to help give students practice but it's really to um have them more problem solving um and and higher level thinking with with all with everything that we're doing in

091our classroom so anything that the teachers are doing in their classroom will be helping the students to prepare for the assessments thank you anybody else I just wanted to mention having a daughter in the high school that I could tell you 100% that they did not take it seriously some of the kids were writing c-spot r on the essay and they were very upset at the national takeover of the education system and um so don't I it's useless the date is useless really for us and block scheduling the children absolutely love because they wouldn't be able to do all the activities that they do if they had to do homework every single day so I just wanted to say they do love the block scheduling but you know the students the high school students who

092did take Park seriously that date is very important to us we will look at that data like Dr alaka said to see are we you know is the delivery of instruction as good as it can be other gaps uh so we will look at that we you know for our purposes for programming I know it's very controversial and I know there's all kinds of things but I I can't dwell on that I have to dwell on what's best for our kids and what's best for our educational programs so we look at the park data as well as all the other data and see you know can we improve um so that's you know that's why we take it seriously but you can't really tell how how do you know who took it seriously and who

093didn't well because if you have a student and we have five data points oh they class grades other things and then the park data is close to that or nearby then we know that they took it seriously if it's uh the very high very low most likely very low it's an anomaly then we can't use it anyone else okay let's move on um knowing that we just reorganized and the Committees we just formed I'm going to assume that there are no committee reports today we'll do yours with mineing committee I'm sorry oh we'll do that with u with my report yeah okay um public forum uh first of all I'd like to thank everyone that U came out in the cold weather today uh to to uh to this meeting we really appreciate it we

094really want to hear from you uh this we have multiple public forums uh during this uh uh session uh the first one however is uh geared toward the agenda so if anyone would like to come up and speak to the agenda uh this is the time to do so we'd ask you to uh just very clearly state your name your address direct your comments to me your questions to me uh board members uh will not be responding or commenting on on any question or comment that you may raise uh is anyone in the public interested in speaking uh during this public session the next public session uh a little later on this evening we could speak on any topic you'd like yes good evening members of the board and administrators my name is Darcy sesti

095I'm actually not from Monroe I'm from Highland Park I'm actually the president of the Highland Park Board of Education um I'm in the third year of my first term so I know Michelle and I know Tom where did he go there he goes we did our uh a new board member training together a couple of years ago which was um fantastic and I'm here today to talk to you about um something that is on your agenda which is the um hatia International Academy Charter School um this is an issue um being from Highland Park that we are very familiar with we've been dealing with Charter School issues for about five years now um first in defeating a charter school that wanted to locate in our district and um and now dealing with hatia and their

096um what have now become chronic I would call expansion requests um just to give you a little bit of background information because I think this is something that's somewhat new to Monroe because um as the costs are increasing I think you know you're becoming more aware of it but has kind of flown under the radar until now um hatia was approved in 2009 um by the commissioner of Education opened up in 2010 so they've been in existence now for five years in that time they've had two or three expansion requests they've started as a k 5 school with 45 students p uh per classroom then they expanded to a k to 5 school with 50 students per classroom now they've expanded to a k to8 school with 50 students per classroom now they're looking to

097expand to a k to8 school with um 75 students per class so as the years go by the school just gets larger and larger and larger um the thing that impacts your District impacts my district is that although hatia was only approved to serve East Brunswick students they have now essentially morphed into a Statewide Charter School um they're approved to serve one district one District only only one District gets um notified when they want to expand only one District gets notified when they come up for Renewal um but now they are pulling students from 28 districts in Seven Counties across the state and all 27 other districts other than East Brunswick are um being charged by the state for the the costs of those students so Monroe your district has gone from one student in

0982010 at a cost of about $10,100 n um dollars and just to give you some perspective Highland Park being a little bit closer to East Brunswick this has been more of an issue for us from the beginning we started off at a cost of $61,800 in 2010 we're now up to $318,400 and we're a district about the quart a quarter of the size of your District we have about 1,600 students so this has really become extremely imp imp acting on our budget um one thing that I do every year Michelle and Tom you all appreciate this um is I open their waiting list because it's not publicly available um I actually had to file a GRC complaint to actually get it the first time I did it now I just get it because they know

099I'm serious um but on that waiting list there's another four Monroe students that are just waiting to get into the school for next year this would raise your um oh that's my time limit isn't you can finish up okay um so that would mean an additional $40 plus, to your District and this will keep going on year after year an incremental increase of two students here four students there three students there and then before you know it your costs have risen from $100,000 to $200,000 to $300,000 a year and then it starts becoming more of an issue because now you're actually cutting teachers you're cutting programs um and your students are losing out and in case there's any perception that this is like hey well you know we lose a few students it's saving us

100some money this saves you no money if you lose eight students over seven grades none of your cost cost come down you don't lose any teachers you don't order any less books your electrical costs aren't any different your costs may stay the same you still have to serve the same number if not more students as your enrollments increase but more money is going out the door that you have no control over so Highland Park has appealed the last expansion um now they filed another one on top of that one but we're still going forward with our appeal and Highland Park is also um challenging the state's ability to even charge Highland Park or Monroe or any of those 27 other districts tuition at all because our attorneys have found that there is no Provisions under

101the state um State Charter School law that allows the state to charge a district other than East Brunswick tuition for the students at attend just like a public school sure I'll wrap it up just like a public school if um if you accept a student from another District those parents would pay tuition to your District our argument is that the same should hold through for a charter school so um I know that there's a resolution that you're um considering tonight I would hope that all of your board members um all the board members would support that tonight Highland Park has been fighting these battles um sometimes alone now we have Addis Edison who's joined our appeal but the more districts that work together um to push back against this the more successful we'll be and

102if there are any questions from the board president um I'd certainly be more than happy to answer no I think we're fine thank you very much I appreciate you coming to share your thoughts pleasure anyone else from the public okay seeing no one else from the public um I think we'll be able to uh move on to that discussion on hot Tik um Mr May uh you I know you have a motion you want to stop by reading that motion sure whereas the hitia international Charter School is located in East Brunswick but enrolls students from various public school districts across the state including students from Monroe Township Public School District Monroe and whereas the New Jersey Department of Education requires public school districts including Monroe to pay for the students who reside in their districts

103but attend at Tia and whereas it is anticipated for the 2015 2016 school year approximately $91,500 of taxpayer funds will be diverted to hatia that otherwise would have been used to educate Monroe students and whereas over the past six years approximately 211,000 and and 2, 200,000 200 200 $1,020 of taxpayer funds will have been diverted away from Monroe to hatia and whereas haa has recently applied for and received permission from the New Jersey doe to expand its enrollment to include grades 6 through eight and whereas as the result of this proposed expansion additional students and taxpayer funds will likely be diver removed from the district in order to support hatifa and whereas as the New Jersey de Doe's approval of hatius expansion application is currently under appeal in the New Jersey Superior Court app pellet

104Division and whereas on or about November 10th 2015 hatia applied for permission from the New Jersey doe to further expand its en student enrollment from 450 students to 675 students over the next eight school years or alternatively nine school years and whereas any such expansion will further negatively impact Monroe as additional students and Tech paay funds will likely be removed from the district in order to support hatia now therefore be it resolved that the Monroe Township Board of Education hereby one opposes of Tia's expansions into grades 6 through 8 two opposes the pending application bya for expansion which is currently under review by the New Jersey DOA and and three directs the business administrator board secretary to send a copy of this resolution to the commissioner of Education the governor and all legislators representing Monroe

105dated January 13 2016 thank you moov second so move uh any discussion Mr n um yeah I think that uh I had some conversations with uh Mr mayo and with our our uh our business administrator and with our uh lawyer and um they gave me a lot of information that I was not aware of on this one of my concerns I am a charter school supporter um I think that the intent of charter schools is a good thing uh roughly 30% of the student population in Camden and New Brunswick um currently attend a charter school and I think the results are very good um however I I would like I I'm I'm going to support this resolution wholeheartedly um but I would like to also possibly have the board look into um taking it to

106the next step I think that um this is a a a small first step I would like to see and maybe um with Darcy's uh assistance and input um maybe we could work together and come up with a resolution for the uh uh the delegate convention in May of the uh the New Jersey school boards Association so that then we could um have a resolution presented there that would make them legislate against these future expansions in high performing districts I I think that in a high performing dist I think there should be a test for a charter school if it is in a high performing District I don't think that they should be um as easily accepted as they would be in an underperforming District because the the intent of these Charter Schools the way

107I understand it at least is to give parents in an underperforming District uh an option because as board members we advocate for all children throughout the state not just the Monroe students so I I think that there has to be a test for a charter school and I think one of those tests would be uh whether the district is high performing or not so I said I I hope that my fellow board members um will will will support this resolution and I hope that uh maybe we can get a dialogue with another um with the Highland Park Board who I know has presented um resolutions in the past to the school board um going forward thank you thank you m anyone else look other than the fact that this is New Jersey and most of

108the things happen here are stupid um if a charter school gets a charter from the state of New Jersey to service the city how are they able to just go ahead and start offering the services to other cities and allow that to go through if the charter is to help improve uh as Tom said a underperforming district and that was really the intent of of providing the service H how is this allowed to happen to allow to this the the creepage if you will to other districts that might be in the area it does can can you I don't I don't get it I think that's a rhetorical have some comments too got nothing no okay Mr calman after speaking to our board attorney on the matter when charter schools are approved they're predominantly designed

109to attract students within the township such as the Princeton Charter School and there's a lottery that actually opens up where there's a lot of demand for the school to select the students who go there I would assume that in hati's case there's not enough demand within that town for um enough enrollment to fill the uh the ranks so they open it up to other towns which is customary for charter schools so other than that being stupid on that part for not doing the business analysis to know whether there's a demand in their Town you're just saying just because they didn't have enough and I don't know sounds like 70 kids in a classroom is enough based on the average standard right um how much is enough like how how are they telling us that 100

110students per class will cover their costs but but we're subsidizing their cost and you're get it the math doesn't work anywhere if if if you read their application for the expansion one of the reasons they give is for more money to do what just to have more money well apparently the amount of students they have now are not fulfilling what their coffers need so if they're getting $10,000 from the state and our our number is 15,000 okay so they're getting 10,000 from the local districts right so but there's we operate at $155,000 per seat ours cost that but that's a different calculation when we you talk about the money that's going to pay for the students going to charter schools that comes from the general fund that's 85% of total revenues when you talk about

111the $155,000 you're that's calculated based on total revenues so you can't say the $155,000 you can't compare the $115,000 to the $110,000 cuz it's the calculations are different so are they saying they need more money to cover their costs I I don't know they ju I mean because I you know I don't care about class size because if a parent wants to sign up for that deal of 75 kids in a class that's on them because they sign up for charter school we don't send them there it's our choice right okay I don't care whatever but Paul can I just ask a question can I assume that we have no say in approving them to go to the to hatikva they want to go we have no say in the matter we have no say

112we had no say that the charter was approved um and when kids decided to go we just got the bill we weren't be but by the sheer fact that we were not the District of residents for the charter we had no notification in the process we have no notification in the process of their application to expand when the kids want to go we just get the bill there is no say by the taxpayers of Monroe if they want their money to leave to go to that Charter School pretending what J Jill is saying you know charter schools are certainly sanctioned by the Department of Education but you're bringing up an excellent point is that's out of our district um Tom you brought up a very interesting uh uh way of looking at things and Lou

113you brought up a very interesting question I I just feel uh necessary for me to comment personally that you know when we're looking at Charter Schools um as was brought out uh historically they came because of underperforming schools and districts and they and giving U parents a choice Monroe is not an underperforming District we stellar and we need to support our public school system I think um charter schools and the original antenna Charter Schools I'm going to say it's a bit too um not only or offer an alternative but to some degree undermine uh the public education system and and I think it's incumbent upon us as a board of education and all Public School Board of educations to support Public Schools uh and realize uh you know the um the uh implied threat of

114a of a a a charter school uh yes we need to look at what they're doing that's making them successful absolutely we're always looking what what we're doing is always uh you know some some self analysis there and and and as uh Dr kak and was saying we're looking at the park scores it's important for us we want to maintain the Excellence that we have for our students this is an excellent school system there aren't many that that are are ahead of us uh and and um well I just think that we have to do whatever we can to make sure that Monroe students stay in Monroe and our state aid is as little as it is stays in Monroe because uh every dollar counts any other comment just one other yes Paul by comparison

115am I correct that for votch for students in high school that go to votch that is not a cost on the district that is picked up by the state the county count County tax county county picks up vote tax and I think the state so that's obviously Mr rutsky that's absolutely correct when when Monroe sends student out of District to uh votee it is paid for directly by the state it's not paid for through tuition which is how Charter School um enrollment is paid for directly from Monroe's general fund to the Charter School unfortunate but okay Kath um when we when people send their children in our district out to another school a private school whatever we have to pay them for transportation in L right Mr Gorski Mrs scan that is correct these students

116specifically going to the the charter school hatia for example are eligible for a in L um which is approximately $884 per year to reimburse the parents for transportation so it's not only the cost of $10,900 a student but you have to add to that the almost $900 of Transportation Aid in L so that's almost another $7500 or round figures for the total amount of students I believe that's correct I I believe that because of in Monroe we do not get much money from the state the taxpayers are the ones who are footing the bill for our education in Monroe and I would prefer to see the taxpayer money stay in Monroe and educate Monroe students as you said we have a stellar educational system here and for people to choose to go someplace else it's

117their choice it's not like we're sending somebody out because they need that program as in special ed special ed is mandated to go out of District because if we don't have that program here and that's where our per pupil cost gets higher because our special ed um the enrollment is high here so I I would prefer I'm going to support this because I believe the money that our taxpayers give to Monroe should stay in Monroe I want you to speak on the mic but you're done Tom did you want to say something no I wanted her to speak any other sorry you to say it all over again uh I don't I don't know if they picked it up did you hear her out there okay I Michelle I'm sorry oh Frank yeah I understand

118the part about supporting the public schools but I find it hard to tell a parent or a student they don't have the opportunity to go to a charter school when it's not like at least from what I hear that we don't have enough students or more than we can even handle in terms of space well we're certainly handling the numbers of students we have now as a matter of fact and that's why we have the uh the ad hoc committee and and the student growth advisory committee uh is because we want to be able to be prepared so that when the numbers increase we will be prepared to offer these to continue to offer the Sellar education that we're offering everybody now so uh we do not want to be in a situation where we're

119going to have 40 50 kids in a classroom that's uh that's unacceptable one other question um has anybody spoken to the parents or to get any kind of feedback from those who are choosing to go to the school as to why that's private data we can't have access to that but can we can anybody ask them we don't know who they are it's not our business if they wanted to come to a public meeting by you know uh voluntarily and speak that's that's F you know that's up to them but we can't Mr Mayo is absolutely right we information it's it's private private information it's like someone can't come into the high school and ask about students taking AP courses you know for specific names and stuff like that um yeah I mean that would

120have been a good thing to maybe to at least uh have that as requirement where if a student does want to go to a charter school in a different uh town then they should State the reason why they would like to leave this school can't make it a requirement they can go wherever they want yeah it's according to the state uh the Department of Education um I Heard Luke mention it he's absolutely right uh it's there the option is there it's given to them by the Department of Education and then they just have to apply they don't have to State any reason all right and does this cost anything no no there's no C Michelle the resolution is essentially just about not approving expansion we're not asking the students who are already going there not

121to go we're just saying that it it's the the opinion of the board that the expansion that we we don't really adhere to the expansion I mean it's we're not saying that that Charter Schools shouldn't exist we're not asking it to you know change the their position the way it stands now we're just saying that our our position is that we're not looking exactly it's it's we're not threatening a lawsuit there's there's no money involved here it's just our position right thank you want to be clear so I'm still trying to square in my head that if it costs us $155,000 for a student and we send them 10,000 or so for those students and it's not like we don't have enough students or you know we're a small District that now we may have

122to lay off a teacher because we can't fill a classroom I'm wondering like Tom what did you you said you because that was your position the last time and so what did you learn that changed just the financial part of this because I still can't figure out I mean I had governance one over the weekend and I was discussing with an attorney there one can I stop you for a minute I don't think we're supposed to be doing cross conversations or or questions that way I mean you can direct to me if you have a question or or a comment but you know well well because apparently there were some private conversations that about having more information about why this is now you know something that everyone's against you can ask a question here well

123I I am the financial part of it that's what I just I can't square that Mr board president yes um Miss Kino the um the board budget philosophy used in average per pupil cost of 15,000 um when calculating a total annual cost for the projected new students coming into the school district the $155,000 you uh was an average from the certified tuition rates from the state of New Jersey the per pupil costs vary per grade level at the at the kindergarten grade levels the per pupil costs are less than they are at the elementary level which are less than they are at the high school level which are far less than they are in the special education departments where they could range in excess of50 $60,000 a pupil for special ed programs so to to

124give the board a taste of of the financial consequences of taking on 200 250 new students we multiplied the number of new students by $155,000 which is an average that is completely different than the way that the charter schools calculate tuition which is statutorily defined by taking your preceding Year's um um aid from the state to support your adequacy budget called Equalization Aid which Monroe receiv zero so that's not part of the equation and then it takes 85% of your preceding Year's general fund tax levy increases it by the CPI then gives a pro-rated amount of categorical Aid based upon the number number of students leaving the district to the Charter School by the total number of students and that's how they calculate the $10,800 so to compare the hatius the tuition per pupil um

125that's charged by the state as Miss Deo said is is comparing apples and oranges to the average per pupils cost used in the uh the budget philosophy presentation but it is 100% factual that the district is being invoiced from the state directly about $10,900 per pupil who elects on their own to attend the charter school and we have to pay them Transportation costs of uh $884 I believe thank you Mr gley any other question or comment we had a second so uh now I guess we're ready to uh vote on adopting this motion Mr kski thank you motion on the floor was made by Mr de Mayo to essentially resolve an opposition to hea's expansion into grades 6 through 8 an opposition to the pending application by hatia for expansion which is currently underviewed by

126the new New Jersey Department of Education and directs the business administrative board secretary to send a copy of the resolution to the commissioner of Education the governor and all legislators representing Monroe Township Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Miss Corino no Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo no Mr rutsky I abstain thank you sir Mr board president members of the B Monro Board of Education motion passes thank you uh now we're ready for our superintendent report Dr KAC okay thank you Mr President um at the request of um one of our board members uh back in December and uh this is something I would do anyway I prepared just a short uh midyear report on the uh District goals um give me a

127tough back to follow there you know hopefully this be a little little bit later um we had three District goals that were identified and the screen is up there I know it's difficult to see uh eventually when everyone's using Google Drive you'll you'll see it right up there but uh the first goal was to develop and present a plan to the board for its approval that will address enrollment growth and facility needs and to begin implementation of the board approved plan I'm going to go through the first goal if you could um scroll down thank you [Music] and okay the uh this was developed at the uh board retreat back in I believe it was August and at that time then I developed an action plan after that Retreat based on the goals so the

128first several columns you see were the action plan that was developed and I submitted that to the board uh probably in August September at the latest and I added a column here that just basically says midyear status so I'll go through each of the activities briefly and just um let you know where we are with that so with that first goal the first activity was to develop or dis I'm sorry to discuss overall concerns regarding enrollment with the board and administrative staff that uh activity is complete the issue of our growing student enrollment has been addressed via Retreats board meetings leadership meetings and in the Falcon flyer the second part of that was to design a plan to outline steps to engage the community in discussions of growing student enrollment and create a steering committee

129and AD ad hoc committee that too is complete at this time both the steering committee and the ad hoc committee have been formed and are operating the steering committee is overseeing the plan of engaging the community and the adhha community has studied the current and projected effects of the grown student enrollment the next activity was to engage a Services of a district architect facilitator and other professionals as needed this is ongoing an outside facilit facilitator has been approved by the board and is currently working with the steering ad hoc and student growth advisory committees in facilitating the uh Community engagement meetings and our first one with the entire group about a 100 uh community members uh and staff and Board of Ed members occurred this past Monday night the district architect is not engaged as

130the recommendation from the uh various committees have not been identified yet and the overall goal was that the recommendations would come more from the community on how to address it they would make the recommendations to the board and the board has the final Authority on how to proceed with that the next section is identify methods of communication to invite members to participate in our meetings this is complete although it um it's still ongoing with the communication but constant contact email Facebook and Twitter and the Falcon flyer have been implemented the next section is to schedule initial meetings with tentative uh with a tentative schedule for future meetings meetings are are scheduled and they are ongoing the monthly meetings same thing with the next they are ongoing we have our monthly meetings occurring the to uh

131the next activity was to plan the agendas and informational sheets to be used during the monthly Community meetings that is complete at this point we have informational fact sheets and present present ations that have been de developed by Mr tag Mr Gorski Dr Alik and myself in collaboration with the board president in uh what needs to be uh addressed and you know the the areas that are stressing our uh facilities and our schools to uh the monthly meetings were ongoing as I said and they developed the potential models for dealing with the growing student rment is in progress we're not at that point yet this is a year-long goal the last part of this would be the presentation of the models to the public and again that would be planned at a future date as

132well as uh the ad hoc committee discussing the models and uh working toward a final model Endor solution these are all things that have not uh been accomplished yet the second goal was to the expansion of two-way communication with all stakeholders in the Monroe Community including but not limited to the the utilization of Constant Contact social media and in-person meetings the um I won't go through everything every single part of that but basically we have the Falcon flyer now we also have a Falcon Express which is used the falcon fly comes out once a month uh details information in the district talks about the student growth advisory committee uh we have Community Information on that uh and the Falcon Express comes up with when we have something to send out during the month that we

133feel that would be of interest to the parents Andor Community we have encouraged uh as many people as possible and it's still open for anybody to sign up for the Falcon flyer I believe right now we have somewhere in the vcinity of U 5,000 to 6,000 people receiving this every month the uh one of the um parts of this goal was to attend the back to school nights to meet and greet parents and discussed an expanded communication initiatives uh back in September I attended 10 of the back to school nights uh the middle school had multiple back to school nights and um I addressed the parents at those meetings talking about where we were headed where we were going and uh the goal of in you know increasing our communication two-way communication so that we

134hear what the parents and the community have concerns about as well as us being able to disseminate the information of what's going on in our schools the third goal is to complete an external audit of the special education program from K to 12 to ensure continued delivery of the highest quality services to meet the needs of our children in the most coste effective and efficient manner possible the initial uh part of that is complete we looked at we had a committee in the district that looked at three proposals that were submitted we selected uh one of the uh firms we submitted it to the board for approval the board approved it and we just had our first weekly conference call this past Monday we have identified the three IND district meetings where they'll come in

135and conduct interviews with community members board members uh staff parents um nothing confidential no student confidentiality will be breached and uh that it will occur in the last week in February after that they will compile the the results of not only the interviews but the multitude of data that we are sending them uh plus the public the data that's available through the public domain and they will come back to the leadership team and to the board to pres present their recommendations their findings we're hoping to be able to use the recommendations as a plan as a road map if you will for the next maybe three to five years and hopefully be able to uh improve as we has been stated tonight we continually try to improve our services to our students and uh we're

136hoping for some very good recommendations based on this firm's work with districts not only in New Jersey they also worked with the city of Philadelphia and they've worked with school districts throughout the country so we're hoping uh that their panel of experts will be able to come in and uh at least provide some valid recommendations that we can use to uh improve our services that con concludes the uh my superintendent report Mr President and then I would like to move to yes we have uh personal thank you Dr kak uh on the Personnel uh page six on your agenda um I'd like a motion to approve items a through S all moved second second right uh Mr gski I think we do a roll call on it cor right yes begger pardon who was second

137Kathy Miss armenio uh any discussion on those yes sorry um actually I think I I don't have a discussion sorry if anybody else does anyone else no sorry okay you want to try that again Mr Gorski I'll ma'am I'll respond properly sorry about that Miss armeno yes Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kapano yes Mr noin yes Miss Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky yes okay thank you passes motion passes um item five board action um items a through K I'd like a motion to approve items a through k no moved second any discussion now we'll do a roll call vote I I do have one on it on on page 10 I um board action from a to on professional development um I think I had a

138question regarding would that be the the background information professional leave requests would that be the yes there there is some information in the uh background information but I I is there something in particular that I I think I was asking about the um football Clinic yes I I checked with our athletic director Mr berer on that and uh there actually is besides the football Clinic there's uh there are other members of the staff who are who are also attending non-f football clinics uh that is not costing the district any money uh those uh individuals are paying for the uh professional develop themselves and they are simply asking for the uh the day to attend the professional development there's four days yes I think they're all Fridays they're at different months and because it's sponsored by

139uh I forget who sponsors it but they're held at different locations right yes and we're not picking up any transportation costs or anything uh no trans they they're they'll probably put in for reimbursement for no they're not putting in reimbursement for travel no cost that would have been listed on your backup sheets okay and then I think I also had a question question about the field trips and we we were asking I asked whether um on some of them that it says the it's funded by the district but there was no cost involved just uh like the Winter Guard competition um Winter Guard competitions would be covered um through the athletic budget and it's um it it's a cost for the buses to and from the competitions so if there's no cost there it's just

140the cost of Transportation okay but that's already budgeted within yes but it really is a cost to the district so I don't know it's in the District budget yes okay but it's just the transportation cost to and from the competitions okay well could we make some kind of not not notation that there is that we we don't have to we don't have to put the uh Transportation cost in but we should know that there is a cost some that's where the the second to last column say has a d it's funded by d d is the district s is the student so if it's if there's a d and there's no cost the only the only cost that we're covering is the transportation cost okay all right thank you any other question close M armenio

141yes Mr Braverman Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes to all reuse on H items P 5337 I'm sorry um let me take that from the top recues on all items under H except P 5337 P 5516 so noted Mrs col Pano yes Mr noin yes Miss Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr redsky I believe I'm abstaining on all these very well thank you thank you and we'll move to the business administrator's uh report Mr board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through J be approved by consent roll call so move second any questions don't look thank you I don't see any hands for questions I'll take a roll call then miss armeno yes on everything abstain on J

142so noted thank you Mr Braverman Mr Mayo yes on everything abstain on J so noted Mr calman yes Mrs kpano yes Mr noin yes Miss Corino yes Mr ryack yes Mr Russo and Mr rutsky okay so I believe I abstain with the exception of letter a item one yeah well you're not getting any and letter b f and g where I vote Yes all right I didn't know that thank you though so noted thank you thank you that concludes my report thank you thank you very much uh board president's report uh there two things I really going to bring up and U second one I'm going to ask Mr Mayo to uh report a little bit on some uh What uh uh facts that that occurred uh let me start by saying this past Monday

143we had the first meeting of the student growth advisory committee this is a group of approximately 100 volunteers forming a cross-section of our community administrators teachers students parents and seniors the ad hoc committee members who have been uh who have previously worked through some exercises based on on on growth information joined this group to continue to develop what will result in a series of recommendations to the board on how best to meet the challenges of our growing student enrollment Mrs Deo will now report more specifically on this meeting okay there there was about 100 people there and what we first did is we watched a short film on the crowded hallways in the middle school so everybody could get a sense of how crowded the school is we also watched um the film also included

144Clips on the long lines in the High School lunchroom so people could get a sense of what the High School is dealing with it was this was a way to give the committee a visual of the overcrowding that we're facing Dr Ivory our facilitator had us working in groups of four and five we had a large sheet in front of us and he asked us to write down on the Outer Edge some long-term solutions for our um growth problem that we're experiencing him in a row um and prior to this we had a presentation that actually talked about the expected growth from all the new um developments being brought into Monroe so the thought was that you just write down all your thoughts you know about Solutions whether they're feasible or not feasible then as

145a group we talked about them and we picked the top ones that we felt were reasonable Solutions um there were good discussions in every group um I felt like everybody was engaged in the process and interested in what was going on um and after we were finished we all presented our ideas to the group um there was no judgments made on the ideas we just listened and um then these sheets were taken and they're going to be compiled up and those are what are going to be the notes so everybody can see the ideas that came forward thank you I just think it's important to emphasize that there is no preconceived answers we're really working together uh with the community uh to try and and and meet the challenges of uh of this uh uh

146amount of growth that we're going to see so uh we're looking forward we're we're looking forward to our future meetings and uh we are trying to keep to a timeline because that's a a key factor especially if we do have to start developing or building on to uh making additions uh next uh um this past month Monday yes um just a quick question I was wondering if we could possibly get a student growth advisory committee folder on Google Drive so that we can all have access to uh whatever information is being yes I think that's something that we we're talking about right now fantastic thank you anyone else on Monday Dr kosak Mr Gorski and I met with mayor tamboro business administrator Wayne Hamilton Senator Linda Greenstein her Chief of Staff Jim hooker assemblyman Dan

147Benson and a representative uh for Suman Wayne D'Angelo to discuss state aid and school taxes in general the impact of anticipated new students on the town and school system was the center of our discussion to be more exact we talked about stabilization impact fees the cap on the growth Aid formula limiting the number of new developments CO's impact on the master plan Frozen state aid the Antiquated ruu survey which is what's used by the state in determining the impact of a new development and the very popular topic of unfunded mandates Mr Gorski developed a chart depicting the increase in student population and decrease in state aid since 200920 school year he also developed a second page where he showed the 40% decrease in state aid yet a 16.5% increase in enrollment over the six-year period

148perod beginning 200920 our discussions were Frank and positive I suggested that we invite commissioner Hesby to Monroe to meet with us and to other the schools mayor tamboro suggested we extend an invitation to Senator Steven Sweeney for a separate meeting and tour our elected officials will be looking into the issues discussed we all agreed to meet again uh in the near future I would also like to take this opportunity to thank mayor Tambor for organizing this meeting I don't know if Dr kosak or Mr gorsky you have anything you'd like to add yes thank you Mr Rybeck this is such an important topic if if anything I'm going to say is redundant to what you just said it's worth saying twice um we presented information illustrating the extreme Divergence in the decrease in state aid

149versus the increase in student enrollment 40% decrease in state aid over the last 6 years with along with a 16.5% increase in student enrollment from the Assa state reports themselves we talked about the state aid formula going through the adequacy budget calculation which leads to Equalization Aid in specifics for Senator Greenstein we talked about the inadequacy of the adequacy formula uh specifically for Monroe and two matters that have hurt Monroe greatly recently with the freeze in state aid funding under a term called stabilization um basically if the state coffers are low and they don't have the full amount of money to fund the formula they will stabilize districts by freezing Aid which is wonderful for districts of of large urban areas where they have perhaps decreasing enrollment because are receiving more Aid per pupil over

150time but significantly hurts Monroe with our uh 3 to 4% student enrollment increases every year we talked about unfunded mandates um many having to do with transportation and the demographics in town that require us to spend over a million dollars a year in our transportation budget to safely at uh to commute children back and forth to school and um you need we to this meeting we addressed a topic that was um advocated for by the Democrats and that is to have a constitutional convention to change the state funding formula previously many professional organizations including New Jersey school board uh New Jersey PSA have advocated for keeping the current funding formula and supporting it um but to try to advocate for the state to increase the funding that goes into uh the allocation each year what

151we introduced was a bit unique and and a little bit uh rebellious we said that Monroe um really has no foreseeable gains in the future under the current state funding formula even with full funding basically if the formula was fully funded which it hasn't been since Corine Administration Monroe would receive about an additional $6 to7 million a year that's essentially what our bills s272 and A500 would provide out of out of respect and uh sympathy to the large senior population and the tax burden that they're suffering with so we represented to the Democrats that we would align with them and support a constitutional convention changing the state funding formula because that's the only way Monroe in our opinion is going to get a u a material amount of of fair and Equitable funding and um

152optimistically as Mr Rybeck said we are going to have audience in the future thanks to Senator Greenstein to meet with commissioner Hesby and Senator Sweeney um the senator Sweeney piece is important because Senator Greenstein was unoptimised that we would have any gains in state aid or promotion of our legislation under the current um Administration but if that should change um we would have audience with one of the Front Runners in that race to promote our cause thank you thank you just briefly thank you Mr President just briefly uh Mr Gorski and and Mr Ryback certainly stated everything well in what was said uh I just wanted to add in my visits around the state to um talking with other superintendant and attending the commissioner of education's convocation which is uh he does once a year

153and he has one convocation in the north the Central and the South to meet with superintendents and discuss issues and he brings his Department of Education staff or most of them the question of funding has come up and the answer that we're getting is that yes there is a formula and no we're not following it but if they were to actually follow it the district s that have lost enrollment would lose funding and that they don't want to do that basically so the districts that have gained enrollment Monroe is one of several throughout the state um you know we're we're being penalized for the you know we're not getting any any additional support for the additional students we're getting and the only reason that we're getting back is that they don't want to penalize the

154stud the districts that have lost enrollment so that I mean that's it doesn't seem to make much sense but I will tell you that my conversations with superintendents throughout the state that we are working together as well uh and many of the districts are the superintendents and their Board of Ed Boards of Education are working with the their municipalities and I think this voice or voices are getting louder and louder um and hopefully we'll be heard at the state level and maybe address this uh inequity and funding thank you Mr President thank you would anybody like to comment or question anything okay i' I'd like to move on next to um other board business does anyone have anything to raise or for other board business well I do uh I'd like us uh I'd like

155to consider our board goal number three I think it's time that we have to start having a little bit of a discussion on it and let me read it to you because I know you probably don't have it in front of you it's uh to review the board committee organization and structure processes so uh I'd like to know if anyone would have has any thoughts or would like to bring up any ideas so that we this has to be accomplished this year by the end of the year and if we're going to do something I think we need to start thinking about it any thoughts there how many um the I just want to be clear about the you raise your hand this time um you're talking about how how the board proceeds either as

156a board of a whole or as board committees well I think that can be part of it unless uh maybe someone has some ideas about changing something or altering something or leaving it the way it is I I would be happy to discuss some you know some changes but I I don't have anything specific I'd like to think about it and I think it would be a good idea to sort of Del I just want to raise it as a point of disc discuss and and just you know you can put it certainly uh in in the back of your minds for a moment if you if you want uh I might be able to call New Jersey school boards and ask them to come in if you feel uh we can have an exercise

157as we did last year that might help us uh with some ideas some Al yeah yeah in in the not too distant future future um what I would like to see is a better flow of communication I would like to see the mean between board members between from the committee to the board members because we can't go to all the committee meetings it would be nice if the committee notes got posted in the Google docks so we didn't have to wait until the once a month board meeting to find out what everybody else was doing in their committees I think that's one of the advantages that Dr kosak even put down uh for us on it but yes it's a great suggestion we can still present so everybody in the you know audience can hear

158but it would be nice so if there's any questions or absolutely okay so that's one idea Kathy does not excuse me does Dr kosak do that now don't you include committee reports with your Friday confidential I do that's the with the Friday confidential but if a committee meeting occurs on a Tuesday night that information won't go out till Friday with Google Docs we can put the agenda right in Google Drive you can see the agenda before the committee meets and then we can actually take notes either that during the committee um I'm not the best typus so it's I usually do it afterward maybe that night or the next morning and as soon as I post it into Google drive it would be there for all to see so it would be similar we do

159send it out but this might be just a little bit quicker but we could still do both because for the people who like the hard copy sure thank you Kath I appreciate that I like to get it Tom um just following up on um what Miss K pan was saying we could then have the Personnel uh notes on there for example because they are confidential and yet and of course Google Drive is confidential correct absolutely great Point Mr na absolutely yes so why don't I say this why don't you just think about things and then maybe we can uh next time we come together or we can U be a little more definitive in in in what we're suggesting Mr May I'm in the I'm sorry um I I don't know if it would be

160the purview of the um the policy committee but if anybody wanted to um we could start with Google notes I guess have this discussion but I I would want to make sure that we would not substitute this for deliberating in public because this is a you know public for and and the public should know once we're informed I still think we should have deliberation in public because that's really the essence of the open public meetings act and our our you know our respons transparency is key and I think that that goes without question thank you yes anyone else okay uh and now uh we come to the second uh public forum uh where you can uh speak on uh for three minutes on uh any issue that you're uh interested in again let me remind

161you that please state your name your address and speak directly to me not to individual board members who will not be commenting or answering any spe specific question is anyone in the public public interested in addressing the board okay seeing no one we'll move on to the uh Clos session resolution uh be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves into the Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of public laws of 1975 njsa 10 -46 through 10421 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying following Clos session action may be taken this uh the discussion uh the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to public as at such time as the need for confid confidentiality no longer exists so moved thank you

162thank you okay um I don't think this will take too long maybe 10 15 minutes at the most thank you about all in favor oh weot we vote on I'm sorry all right let's take a vote all in favor I any oppose okay we're ready for the next public forum I don't see one from the public there is there someone okay well the next public forum would be addressing uh the uh closed session is anybody from the public uh interested in coming up okay that being the case let me just say that the next scheduled meeting of our Board of Education will be Wednesday February 10th at 7 o'cl right here in the in the high school I'd like a motion for that's fast any discussion Lou you have a discussion on no okay all

163in favor I opposed thank you we're Jour 10

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.