CorpusRecord 132958

Monroe Township Board of Education 01.06.16 Reorganization Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-18
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
4,041 words · about 23 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001charge don't start with me today that day good evening members of the public superintendent Dr kak assistant superintendent Dr alvic members of the Monro Township Board of Education the Monro Township Board of Education organization meeting is now called to order in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted December 31st 2015 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality this is a unique organization meeting where it begins without a board president as chair and as board secretary it's my role to uh begin the meeting until such time as we have a successful nomination process for president and if

002we don't then it would be a successful nomination process for vice president who would chair the rest of the meeting presumably would you please join me in a pledge of allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God invisible liberty and justice for all moving right along number four on the agenda is election results these have been sent to all the board members in your packet and there's member uh there's there's copies available at the front desk for the public the election results have been confirmed and certified by the county it is now my duty to administer the oath of office to the following individuals who I hearby request to join me at the microphone and the and the

003table up front Mr Marvin Braverman Miss Dawn Corino Mr Frank Russo and Mr Paul rutzky can we can he sit [Music] okay please repeat after me I state your name do solemnly swear or firm doly swear orm that I will support the Constitution of the United States that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the constitution of the state of New Jersey and the constitution of the state of New Jersey and that I will bear true faith and Allegiance I will bear true faith and algian to the same to the same and to the government established in the United States to the governments established the United States and this state and this state under the authority of the people under the authority of the people so help me God I do solemly

004swear or affirm swear orir that I possess the qualifications prescribed by law I possess the qualific by for the office of member of a board of education for the office of member of the Board of Education and that I will faithfully and that I will faithfully and partially partially and justly perform all duties of that office perform all duties of that office according to the best of my ability so help me God so help me God I I do solemnly swear or affirm do Solly swear or affirm and declare that I am not disqualified and declare that I am not disqualified as a voter pursuant to as a v pursuant to rs19 colon 4-1 rs9 41 and then I am not disqualified I am not disqualified to hold this office to hold this office due

005to a conviction of a crime to a conviction of a crime or offense or offense listed in njsa 18a 12-1 so help me God congratulations civil liberties see this yes sir it's been reviewed by the attorney and New Jersey school boards just going to take a thank you very much please uh you're now welcome to join the board of education at the board table sign this in a minute welcome welcome Paul who is that me I think that's you okay hi you know Steve we met it is my duty now to proceed with a roll call Miss Armenia here Mr Braverman here Mr Deo here Mr calman here Mrs Co Pano here Mr nosin here miss Corino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here Mr rutsky here let it be known that we have a

006quarum present this evening next we'll move up to number seven on the agenda election of a board president um I will open the nomination process at this time is there a nomination for anyone to make for an individual for board president Mr noin yes I'd like to nominate uh Mr Steven Ryback uh for board president second seconded by Miss armeno are there any other nominations for board president at this time seeing none I close the nomination process for president and I will take a roll call for Mr Steve Ryback to be board president of the Monroe Township Board of Education a yes vote will be for Mr ryack to be president of the Board of Education Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs k panowich no Mr noin yes

007Miss Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes it is now my pleasure to introduce the new Monroe Township Board of Education president Mr Steven [Applause] Rybeck Mr Rybeck will you please join me to my right where you will resume the chair of the meeting thank you come on thank you Michael before we continue I'd just like to take a minute uh and just say thank you you uh to everyone um I'm honored at this position I'm honored to uh also work with this board who has worked so well together uh this past year it really a pleasure working with you and uh I look forward to great things to come and uh certainly biggest honor is working for the uh students and and school community of Monroe uh I'd like to thank Anthony and

008Doug also Doug you're going to be a hard act to follow but we'll give it a good try um let's get back to the agenda now I'd like to open uh for nominations for Vi vice president do we have any nominations for vice president miss armeno yes I nominate Tom noin Tom noin is there a second second okay any other nominations for vice president Mr Gorski I guess we could take a roll call you okay that closes that closes the nomination process for vice president uh yay would be a favorable vote for Mr Tom noin as vice president of the Monro Township Board of Education Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr de Mayo no Mr calman yes Mrs kpano no Mr nostin yes Miss Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky

009I thank you sir Mr Rybeck this is my pleasure to introduce the vice president of the Monroe Township Board of Education Mr Tom noin congratulations Tom good pleasure working with you okay uh moving on to uh item number 15 15 other board business um I'm going to turn it over to um Mr Gorski for a minute we have I know we have one notice from the mayor and then we have the preference sheets uh which uh I think have they been given out they'll be given out well I just want to make fast mention that on Monday at 7 o'clock in the middle school we have the student advisory committee uh and um we're looking forward that's the first meeting for that particular large group of about 100 residents and the board members uh so

010um we're well on our way in dealing with the uh um the issues of uh the numbers of students that are coming into our school in the future Michael thank you [Music] sir Miss tley faroh is pancing around the committee preference sheets please specify the Committees uh that you would like to participate on and if possible if you could please return them to me by the close of Friday uh that would be appreciated as Mr Ryback has indicated mayor tamboro has scheduled a meeting with the leadership of the Monroe Township Board of Education who include board president Mr Rybeck superintendent Dr kak and myself to be joined by our representative Senator Senator Linda Green Stein assemblyman Wayne D'Angelo and assemblyman Daniel Benson to discuss the biggest issue facing the township which is the very limited

011amount of state aid that we receive the state aid by its underfunding has put an unfair financial burden on the township residents and we will work collaboratively to push our district design legislation s272 and the assembly version A500 and discuss any and all other possible remedies to rectify this inequity Mr Rybeck thank you um is there any other board of education um business at this point Mr Mayo yes um as we all know since 2010 Monroe Township School District has been underfunded by the state which refuses to fully fund the school funding Reform Act of 2008 Monroe has seen over $10 million lost due to the state's refusal to properly fund the school districts of the state despite the efforts of the state to hurt school districts Monroe has been able to maintain a quality

012education but I oppose efforts to further erode our ability to do so there is a charter school in East Brunswick that draws students from our district the state mandates that when a student attends a charter school school it is the sending District that must cover the cost for these students to attend that school in Monroe's case there are eight students attending hatik F Charter School in East Brunswick costing the district and taxpayers over $90,000 per year of our operating budget this is the cost of approximately two teachers which we need in order to accommodate the growing student population in our district and keep our class sizes at a reasonable level in addition there are four more students on the waiting list which would mean another $45,000 out of our operating budget the school has just

013received approval from the New Jersey doe to expand from elementary school grades into Middle School grades and they want to expand by adding more classrooms at the lower grades these expansions will open the door for more students to attend hatia further draining money from the district's operating budget again this is mandated by the state of New Jersey Department of Education therefore I move that we direct the board attorney to prepare a resolution for us to consider at the next board meeting opposing the expansion of the hique for Charter School into the middle school grades and further expansions as it would harm Monroe's budget and our taxpayers I'll second the motion any discussion Tom um yeah I just have some questions with regards to the numbers could you repeat it was eight students at 95,000 they're

014at about 990,000 we're paying a little over 10,000 a student now is that above and beyond the $15,000 that we currently pay per student estimate in the district no that is on top of the 15 so it's 15 plus 11 no it's just the 11 that's a deal that's a bargain do we pay for it's not really a bargain we're paying 15 with calculated cost per student correct um basically what the transaction is doing is taking the state aid per pupil allotment for those children and sending it directly to hatia and um hatia is responsible for the transportation cost which are not then included in that tuition cost so um it is a burden on local school districts East Brunswick Board of Education I know from speaking to the business administrator um has complained for

015years how that District spends over $1.5 million out of their operating budget directly to hia Charter School for the children who decide um to go attend that that uh alternative education setting I guess my question maybe I should rephrase it is what is the actual cost of the district because obviously if we're losing eight students we're there's some savings there to the district because we're currently uh spending roughly 15K per student correct the 15's an average um it's costing exactly $10,000 a student uh which we have to pay to hatia for tuition so again I guess my question is is this is is this costing us how much is this costing us above and beyond what it would cost um if they were educated in our district sure that's U you're right in a way

016financially if you look at it in strict terms in that regard uh it would be a savings but when you look at the way education is funded the cost per pupil that we receive in state aid which we know we receive a very little amount in state aid is based on the assumption that you have so many kids in a classroom and that each the the funding for each individual student uh really covers when you you compile that funding that that accounts for the cost that we have to uh expend On Any Given student if you're removing individual students from different um parts of the program each one of those students representing $10,000 it's that cost that $90,000 it doesn't go into the operating budget which would really come out to it it's it's not

017just $10,000 per student you know we only receive so much state aid it cost a lot more so that money contributes into our general operating budget to assume those 10 students isn't really going to cost us $90,000 we're not going to have to add a new teacher to have the 10 students back here we won't have to add anything else not even Transportation there's probably room for 10 more students out of all of our buses I'm sure they're not all coming from the same location so this argument with Charter Schools is a common argument throughout New Jersey in districts especially in districts where they are high performing districts and where you have a quality education that's being offered the argument goes back to do is there a need for a charter school I'm not talking

018about the spe this specific charter school I can't really speak to this specific Charter School may be a wonderful school but we also have a wonderful education program so anytime somebody decides to leave they decide to go to a private school the parents pay tuition if they decide to leave and they go to a charter school now that little bit of State funding that we do receive is now diverted out to whatever the charter school would be so just in general terms that's been the argument from public school Educators um for any of the charter schools throughout the state I guess what I just have a problem with is when we do the budget philosophy meeting I hear that we're getting a hundred new students in and then they say that's going to cost us

019$150,000 and now it seems like we're doing the opposite we're saying we're losing nine students and now all of a sudden that $115,000 per isn't applicable and I just feel that we just can't have it both ways it's either costing us this amount per student or it's not and I guess that's where I'm trying to get the answer here I'm still confused right and I I don't really want to engage in an argument with that it's not my intent um if you add students if you have so many kids in a class and you're adding students to that that I get it and right that could result in hiring new teachers new like that that's kind of but I'm just kind of using this because this is what we seem to get at the philosophy

020meeting and nobody makes the point that you're making at that point okay and I think it's a valid point but I just I just get confused when when it's this amount of students it's cosing US money it's only 10,000 a student but when it's this when it's new people it's much more and that's my my whole concern here okay thank you any other discussion yes Michelle um yeah I'd like to understand the aspect the financial aspect of it also but also the the philosophy I too and maybe I'm under a misconception that um charter schools are for or or were established initially philosophically for because under the district school was underperforming so I personally I'd like to just have a little bit more information on the philosophy why it would be necessary to send anyone

021out of District in a high- performing School District which I know we have um so that that would be something not not an argument I don't and I don't think you know um Mr not state was arguing anything I think we're just seeking some information and that would be one of the um kinds of um discussions I'd like to have because I too think that um having a high performing District it seems like Charter Schools sort of are a surrogator something almost for private schools and that my that's my personal opinion not a board opinion so I'd like to understand that a little bit better going forward if there's a way where we can have if a resolution comes forward if we can have a broader discussion and maybe get some um you know Ed

022Educators to sort of explain the difference briefly or if you want to do that now well just to just to maybe to hopefully provide some clarification if we send a student out to a school it's usually because we can't meet the needs of that individual student right in this case the students or their parents or end and their parents have decided that they want to place their child in that school voluntarily they withdraw the student if a parent decides they want to send their child to a private school or they want to have homeschooling that's their choice that's the prerogative if they're sending their they're they're withdrawing their child to send them to a charter school the maybe the implicit argument is that that Charter School uh offers something that we don't and that's okay

023except that in this case as opposed to the private school and the homeschooling there's no funding that that follows a student with in those cases in this case the funding follows a student so that's again it's the parents decision to to remove their child we're not sending the child to that school does that help I don't know if I answer question yeah again it's I guess I I need to do some research on the philosophy behind the purpose of charter school I know there's a big wide range and it's a big political I kind of have an answer for thatter keg the charter law was written in 1996 and the the the initial um it was written to allow these schools to step outside the educational box and educate students in a different way and

024the thought process was that these students would be pockets of innovation and they would share their Innovation with other public schools and that has never transpired um over the course of the last six 20 years I mean there have been um you know some schools that have popped up but now during the current um you know last five years they have been the new thought is that Charter Schools will allow children in failing schools to get out of failing schools and into a charter school where it's supposed to be better but the jury's out on whether they are actually perform better or not some do some don't on average most of them perform at the same level of their local school or Worse regardless of if it's a high performance school or a low performance

025School President right back president just just a followup um so this could lead to people seeking out um different kinds of school systems and calling them or or really would have to be it have to be a qualified chart or a certified Charter in order for somebody to correct right so un unless they are then we're not at risk of having people just sort of send their kids to all different kinds of of schools and US pay for it right yes at this point I'd like to just get more information about about the BR thank you just a basic question how are the charted schools able to do it at such a low cost um I'd like to answer that but I think you have to ask permission go ahead Jo um they get donations

026and they have funders the hatik F charter school has a uh billionaire fun who's helping them some also get funding from Private Industry too well we get taxpayer funded so what do you mean tax payers fund the school here right well that you ask why they can do it cheaper they get extra money from philanthropy and we cannot are the they have they if you go on their Charter website it talks about you know their funders and who's funding them I mean but it it's still costing $10,000 you said I know but there's the economies of scale that say you know at some point you can take one kid out of a classroom and you're giving that $10,000 away but you're not saving any money because you can't fire a teacher there's not you're not

027eliminating a whole classroom okay anything else you know I was thinking um why don't we just do a roll call this is just a draft Mr board president I believe Mr Mayo's motion was to direct the attorney to draft the resolution um where further deliberation on this topic will certainly be be provided at the next meeting along with the reso okay you want to do a roll call yes sir Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr de Mayo yes Mr cman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin no Miss Corino no Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo no bo president motion passes and uh will notify the the board attorney to draft a resolution in accordance with Mr Mayo's wishes and further deliberation is expected um with the presentation of their resolution thank you um I

028have to apologize I did skip a few items um we I would like to go to number nine Mr Gorski thank you sir number nine is the code of ethics um code of ethics was passed out along with the statutes governing this uh section to all the board members prior to the meeting I have some back that are signed already thank you very much uh so I'd like to recommend that the members of the Board of Education acknowledge receipt and acceptance of the New Jersey school board association's code of ethics so moved second any discussion then we take a roll call Mr armeno yes bra yes Mr Mayo yes Mr cman Mrs K Pano Mr nosin yes Mr Corino yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky and this one yes thank you

029sir item number 10 suspension of the policy bylaw it's recommended that the Board of Education suspend the operation of policy bylaw number uh 0164 to permit the board to conduct only one public forum at this evening's public meeting so moved second all in favor I I oppos stain and I guess there's no recusals I don't see any okay that being the case um I'd like to invite members of the public up to the microphone to address the board uh let me just remind you you have three minutes uh please state your name your address address and speak directly to me not any board member in particular uh they uh will not be answering or responding to you only I will any members of the public yes uh good evening my name is Harold Kane I

030live on Newport Way in Rossmore um Mr Ryback said that in the next I guess few days you'll be having a meeting with the legislators from the 14th District U Senator Greenstein and the assemblyman Benson and D'Angelo um I would bring up a topic they probably don't want to hear but unfortunately affects everyone in Monroe on the school funding issue uh the residents of mono including everyone in this room pays a substantial amount of money in taxes to Trenton through income tax sales tax gasoline tax excise tax and everything under the sun and basically we get nothing back for it but when you wind up doing some research you find out that other people pay very little taxes and get a tremendous amount back uh one of the some of the research we did on

031property values were U the new hannanian building in Jersey City of 55 Hudson Street a $1.8 million Waterfront condo with views of lower Manhattan pays $300 in property taxes for the owner and that's because of pilot agreements in Jersey City you have condos and Long Branch uh they're approaching $2 million on the waterfront they had a huge fight with the residents there on eminent domain several years ago because they're all small single family Bungalows for summer Winters the developers wanted the land they finally got it through eminent domain and this was the end result um you have somebody like Eli Manning who lives in a high-rise condo in Hoboken pays about $4,000 a year uh for the taxes on his condo a substantial number of the residents of monoe probably majority pay more than that

032and yet he has all the whatever Hoboken offers the city and one of his neighbors was former Governor Corine so that's the quality of the place he was in what this comes down to and here's why they don't want to hear it is the property tax issue with the Abbott municipalities there's a the three I just mentioned should no longer be Abbott municipalities because they suck all the tax dollars Adam Monroe and they get it all because we subsidize the governments down there schools and and the municipalities uh they need to lose their Abit status and make it on a page a go basis uh one thing I researched a few years ago U looking comparing monoto Long Branch uh we were a group four school school district they're group three which means they have

033substantially fewer students probably in the neighborhood of a thousand when you see it yet they actually had more employees than we had Well yeah if the states feed money and like there's no tomorrow of course they're going to have more employees and nobody's going to say anything about it well maybe it's time that you said something to them about this and using those three uh municipalities as examples if they're not throwing tax money out of Monroe taxpayers there's money down in Trenton that can help us out basically we're getting our money back is all we're doing if any of you want more information I'll be happy to email it to you something you can take to a meeting and uh instead of just speculating on it you actually have documents to back yourself up thank

034you okay thank you very much for your comments anyone else from the public that being the case I'll close this uh session of the public um report and uh I want to move to um the organizational items um number 12 Mr borski thank you sir number 12 is the organizational items defining the meeting dates the policies the designation of banks or depository and the newspapers for legal advertisements I would like to recommend that the members of the Board of Education accept and approve item 12 organization items letters a through d as and be approved by consent roll call no moved second by Mr Rybeck any discussion I will then take a roll call Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes M Corino

035yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky yes Mr board president motion passes thank you now have our student board members you have a report Mr thorney Jal I'm sorry that's okay uh so the first thing is the high school is going to be holding its first Relay for Life event on June 11th the program is an overnight walk to raise money for the American Cancer Society I volunteered at a Relay for Life event last year in merer county and it was a really nice experience and I'm really happy that our high school is doing one this year uh in December the high school also hosted the annual Vex robotics competition this competition allows students to build and program robots to compete in annual tasks the Falcon robot team had to go through uh

036the first few rounds with a few malfunctions but after a while they did fix their um issues and they won the judge's award for overcoming their troubles and for one quick sports update the girls basketball team beat Allentown in the Monro holiday classic game with a score of 59 to 42 all right thank you uh the high school's drama club recently held a cabaret night back in December um also before the school uh was dismissed for winter break um the uh the show choir and the choir um clubs and groups uh held a concert for both students faculty um and a concert for members of the community as well additionally fbaa and deca are um continuing with regionals actually fbaa finished um we have a significant amount of students um who competed in business marketing

037Finance related events and who are now moving on to the state level in fpla and um students in Deca will be um continuing with the second part of the regional testing um specifically with the performance-based assessments tomorrow Kane University and finally the mous chapter of the model United Nations um will be attending their conference this weekend Friday through Sunday will they where they will have the opportunity to meet with over 1,800 students from across four different states in order to engage in simulation of the United Nations um through General General assemblies and uh and committees Mr board president that concludes our report thank you very much gentlemen okay um I guess the next schedule board meeting is uh January 13th is Wednesday at uh 7 o'clock here at the high school I'd like to just

038remind yes Other Board of Education business respond yes are there any other board members yes Michelle I apologize I I would just like to welcome the new board members um I remember uh two years ago uh I mentioned that everyone brings something new to the table so I I recognize that and I am very grateful for the new board members and our old uh veteran board member Mr Braverman um and he is constantly re bringing things to the table uh for all of us to um to discuss and deliberate uh for the benefit of our community so welcome and looking forward to working with everyone this year thank you Tom I'd like to Echo uh M armin's comments but I'd also like to welcome uh our new representative from Jamesburg and hopefully we can uh

039uh keep the good rapport we have going with with Jamesburg and and we appreciate your uh your uh uh representation happy to be here anyone else okay in that case just uh a fast reminder that please your preference sheets do into Mr to gorski's office by Friday close of business on Friday and um the next board meeting will be Wednesday January 13th at um at the high school right here um I'll make a motion that uh this uh meeting is uh adjourned second all in favor I opposed I didn't think anyone would be opposed thank you yeah A J no this oh that's

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.