001the public meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education will now come to order will one of our student reps please uh lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America for it stands one nation God indivisible with liy and justice for all thank you Mr thorney uh Mr Gorski roll call [Music] please miss armenio here Mr Braverman here M Deo here Mr calman here Mrs kpano here Mr noin here Mr Po here Mr proso here Mr Rybeck here Mr zareski here Mr board president you have a quarm present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and
002place thereof posted November 13 2015 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski at this time we'll have the report from our student board members okay so the first thing is the high school's music department is holding its annual coffee house tomorrow in the high school where students can sing and play instruments as part of a fundraising event uh to earlier today the fellowship of Christian athletes and Italian Honor Society held a volleyball tournament and I heard it went well um and for for for some of our sports teams the boys soccer team Advanced all the way to the sectional finals against Freehold they lost the game with a score of 3 to2 but they had over 650 fans show up
003which was a new record uh for a monre home game the girls field hockey team made it all the way to the sectional semi-finals and the girls volleyball team is set to play in the sectional quarterfinals um the girls tennis team won the division title and they've moved up from White division to Red Division and our boys cross country team went undefeated this season and and with all that being said we'd like to congratulate all of our sports teams players coaches and trainers all right thank [Applause] you yeah now for my part um the model you club and the youth and government organizations are hosting their second annual day of service for the year involved with students um across multiple districts in order to promote Civic engagement and volunteerism um prior to their conference that
004will be uh conferences that will be held later next year uh Deca held a anel car show at the high school and was involved in the Township's October Fest to raise funds for operation shoe box an organization um that is dedicated to delivering care packages to active duty military personnel who are currently serving across the globe proudly representing our great nation uh the mths chapter of deca was um recognized once again by the township with the mayor declaring November Deca month in honor of their involvement in the community and the event is also hosting a hypnotist show tonight to help raise funds for the chapter specifically uh to support students in competing in Business Financial and marketing related categories against students from other schools as part of their uh as part of this internationally recognized
005organization so if the meeting ends early and anybody wants to go get hypnotized that's going to be in the Performing our center tonight um the high schools chapter the future Business Leaders of America recently held a second annual haunted High School event um which was a charity event targeted toward younger um children in the district and this was a community service Endeavor led by fpla um and it was a collaborative it was orchestrated in conjunction with uh several other High School clubs and organizations to serve as a fundraiser for the mama mayor Breast Cancer Foundation in honor of October bring Breast Cancer Awareness Month um with uh many students uh with many student volunteers and teachers including Miss Dale who did a wonderful job coordinating the event as the adviser and of course the community
006um fbaa was able to successfully raise $2,400 for worthwhile cost while students continue to prepare uh to compete against students from other schools and business related competitive events and the club also organized a presentation from a national representative from the March of Dimes organization with whom the club uh will be working with in future charity events Mr board president that concludes our report thank you and uh before we move on I would like to commend all of our fall athletes and their coaches that I know they put a lot of time in uh and I know their parents also put a lot of time in transporting them back and forth to practice and then coming and attending their games and we appreciate the effort that they put into this in representing uh Monroe Township High
007School uh we're now going to move to the first public forum and I would just like to share with you remind you of the rules that we have for that uh this the first forum is designed for members of the public to speak about items which are on the agenda I would ask that you uh please identify the item number listed on the agenda so that board members can quickly find it and know exactly what you're speaking of the second public forum will be open to questions of any nature or concern that comes later in the evening when coming up to the microphone please state your name your address and if you have any group affiliation please indicate that and your statement should be no more than three minutes and all statements should be directed
008to the president of the board and I thank you at this time do we have anyone who wants to speak to the agenda looks like we have an innocuous agenda tonight so we will then move on uh to the approval of minutes I move that we accept the minutes of the special Board of Education meeting held on August the 19th moved second all in favor I opposed recuse recuse minutes are adopted I move that we accept the minutes of the public Board of Education meeting of August the 26th move all in favor I opposed recuse the minutes are accepted I move that we accept the minutes of the Clos session meeting of August the 26 second have to on this all in favor I did opposed recuse bra the minutes are accepted of that meeting
009I now move that we accept the minutes of the public Board of Education meeting of September 16th all in favor I opposed recuse the minutes are accepted and I now move that we accept the minutes of the closed session meeting of August I mean of September the 16th 2015 second all in favor opposed and recuse those minutes are accepted as well we will now go to the committee reports does any uh chair committee have uh chair of the committee have a report to give us Mr Ryback thank you uh the Personnel committee met uh yesterday there was a number of items um um one item we we dealt with was the superintendent of professional development plan Dr kak shared his a plan shared his plan with us and it was quite comprehensive in scope and
010for the sake of time I'm just going to give one example of the goals and activities listed there were professional learning goals that's core content State Standards uh he will enhance his Knowledge and Skills to support and evaluate district-wide implementation and align curriculum professional learning activities where he will TurnKey the content of South Jersey study Council workshops with the leadership team to support a continuous Improvement model of learning school leader training needs uh for example he will attend uh uh School law update update professional training workshops and he also included his professional plan progress summary the goals uh and activities all reflected New Jersey standards for school leaders we also had a discussion on the workstation specialist technology salaries we compared our salaries scaled with three other districts near us and we were the lowest
011on the scale we've already lost some employees to other districts after having invested training time with them we're not attracting the most qualified candidates as well unfortunately there'll be more uh information pertaining to any recommended changes at the December board meeting um just for your knowledge uh the media specialist for the Middle School uh interviews uh will be conducted as soon as a good pool of candidates is achieved haven't achieved that as yet I believe uh Park portfolio assessment writers uh we have a number of students unfortunately who have not passed any of the standardized tests for diploma according to the state another option for them is to complete a portfolio however we need to hire teachers per session at the non-instructional rate totaling about 10 hours to develop these portfolios that finalizes my report
012thank you thank you Mr Ryback no go ahead Mr caufman you don't want to go um okay so we had a cul meeting this evening we went over a couple of items um we were presented with a uh overview of Project Unity which will be something that the high school will be looking into for next year correct or this year um it's going to be a uh an interesting program for our children with special needs co-sponsored by um the Special Olympics committee um certain areas like bowling track and field and other types of events will be um created and managed our students uh cost of about $4,500 is going to be picked up by Special Olympics and they'll pick up things like equipment and transportation and um uniforms potentially even in the future whatever types
013of uh uh things we might need uh this will be the first year that we're doing this and uh um hopefully it'll be a great program it sounded like it's going to be amazing uh we also discussed uh student um data transfer and information uh privacy issues and we've asked the administration to definitely button up their processes on making sure that we have the correct controls in place when uh talking to vendors about using software packages engaging in different types of uh data transfer relationships to ensure the protection of of our students privacy and to make sure that not only are we protecting the privacy of our students but we're also protecting against things like data breaches and uh other types of uh issues that can come out um related to you know engagement of
014third parties and services and moving student data outside to protection of our Network so more to come on that we also had a presentation on a step program uh which is basically uh a uh a teaching tool for our parents um this was the first implement or the first uh overview of this program uh which is targeting U parents of special needs children or I think we discussed it's going to be open to all parents from grades one through five and it's going to cover different topic areas like how to understand your child's Behavior how to listen and talk to your child disciplines that makes sense and a few other things so as that program uh begins to develop and this sent that we'll probably provide future updates on that as well uh we also
015reviewed two curriculum documents for health and physical education for grade 12 and the district comprehension sorry comprehensive School counseling programs grade K through 12 and we'll have another exciting curriculum meeting next month to talk about the ones that we didn't get to because we had so many other interesting topics to get to to this night that's it that's all I got thank you Mr Kaufman Miss armeno yes um last night we had a policy Mee meeting we were uh given uh several policies that were mandated um and I will just speak to them um from their titles uh they are again on the website uh we had uh evaluation of superintendent that was mandatory re uh mandatory and revised uh evaluation of teachers also mandatory and revised policy uh evaluation of teaching staff members excluding
016teachers and administrators uh ALS Al mandatory and revised valuation of Administrators excluding principles Vice principles assistant principles mandatory and revised evaluation of principles Vice principles and assistant principles um most of the language on these policies are very similar however there are some differences based on the uh the employee and the uh the designation uh there was also a mandatory Family Leave revised there are two um an animal service animals that's a new policy that is policy 5337 and policy 5516 use of electronic communication and recording devices and that's for students that's a revised policy I would recommend that students and parents actually take a look at that that's a policy 5516 and that will be at the second reading at our December meeting thank you thank you Mrs armeno Mrs Kap panovich yes um finance
017committee meeting we had on October 22nd where we the the committee um reviewed the shared services agreement with the township on the tennis courts which is on tonight's agenda the commune the committee unanimously agreed to support the agreement and send it up to the township for their perusal um and possible vote um back in September I believe of this year here we talked or I talked about adding a portal onto the financial section of the website for members of the community to ask any Finance questions that they might have um this was done so that any questions asked would get the accurate information in writing from the school district instead of relying on rumors or misinformation and I'm happy to report that that portal is up and running and welcomes any questions that anybody in
018the community might have and that concludes my report thank you any other reports I don't have a report but I have a question is this a a good time to ask if it's a about a committee report it sure is um the uh I believe it was Mr Ryback's uh report you mentioned about these folio writers and I see it on the um the agenda tonight could could someone please elaborate a little on this because it I believe that Mr Rybeck said that it's for students that didn't pass the park and therefore can't graduate and I didn't realize that Park was a was a was a requirement to graduate sure go ahead okay all right uh I'll speak to that and Dr a I think we can both speak to that um Park is not
019it is one of the graduation requirements the state of New Department of Education for the state of New Jersey offered uh several Alternatives uh this is the first year or last year was the first year that Park was admin administered and uh the students did not have the opportunity as they did before with the hesp test which was the state test to take it multiple times students have an opportunity to take the accuplacer PSAT sat uh Park asab uh what was the other asab asab um all these acronyms uh uh to demonstrate their uh proficiency um students who are seniors now who have not demonstrated their Proficiency in any of those assessments have the option to complete a portfolio and a portfolio is a pretty rigorous process uh it's not it's it's not new this
020uh has been around it's just changed names really to portfolio but it allows students to demonstrate their knowledge of uh the different uh subject areas specifically math and language arts uh and Science and throughout the year collect evidence our teachers would then not only uh be there to uh create the portfolio folio but also to assess it the initial assessment then they would have to send that to the state to the Department of Education for final approval so it's a rigorous process um we have um I believe around 50 students this year uh I think that's pretty much in line with what a lot of districts have uh percentage wise and um these students who are e8th grade and nth grade I think we have a better opportunity having had more exposure to the Common
021Core aligned curriculum uh to demonstrate their proficiency by the time they become Juniors uh the state uh certainly has raised a bar with Park as far as what's expected of students and I think that explains part of the reasons are part of the reason for some of these students who did not pass park on the initial run Dr you want to add to that um just for your information on the district website we have a park section that we've put together um about I'm going to say the end of October we received an updated menu of Assessments from the state department um and we have updated that information so we've known about this menu the menu has been um communicated out to parents it's been on our website for the past year but the they
022just gave us the cut off scores for the park assessments um so now as we're starting to receive scores in the near future for all of our students um we will be looking at that too so so we may have students that did pass the park that would be uh taken off of that list that Dr kak mentioned we also to just today we administered the asab to um a group of students at the high school who opted to take it um that's one of the other assessments and we are in the process of coordinating uh the test called the acup Placer the acup Placer is usually used by the um County colleges for admission to see if students need to take need classes or not when they get to the to that school that
023is also on the menu of options of Assessments um and we are we did get um certified by college board to be able to provide that for our students here um so we are in the process of planning for that test also so we're so the portfolio is kind of the um final piece we're trying to get students to pass one of the assessments prior to having to do the portfolio assessment because it is very involved I guess like the portfolio is kind of like the last Resort at that point I got you yes and and it was before it was just called a different name okay cuz I never heard that okay yeah so it was an option prior to park what was it called before Assa yeah I'm I'm looking back at my
024supervisors to make sure I'm I'm correct but yeah Assa they're shaking their head yes Assa was the alternate School assessment or something I think that's what the acronym stood for what the state released in October for the portfolio assessments is kind of guid lines to the district of how to prepare them but it is up to the individual District districts to prepare the portfolio assessments okay thank you just to Ed Tom thanks for bringing that up because I noticed I think the problem the confusion was actually in the wording on the agenda because it says Park portfolio assessment but it's really for kids who have failed uh to pass any of the assessments we give that's why they need to create that portfolio because that's their last ditch effort really to get a diploma it's
025actually not park at all yeah the department of Ed then commissioner hesie has certainly spoken to this to say we want to provide students as many opportunities we realize that we raised a bar so we want to provide students as many opportunities as we can knowing that some students are not good test takers so um you know here are are plenty of uh different ways that students can demonstrate their knowledge uh one question for Dr alage uh how late in the year could a student take for example the SAT or the ACT uh and not have to then go through the portfolio assessment is there a cuto off for that there there is a cut off uh I think it's January is the cut off I think the January um assessment window because we have
026to be able to get those scores back and it takes time to get the scores back in order for us to assess that to to plan for graduation so I think January is the final cut off for the um for the SAT scores acup Placer we can continue to do because that those we can get those scores back um pretty pretty quickly so so there's still opportunities for those students to demonstrate proficiency yes and we are trying to utilize every opportunity that we can for our students thank you all right we will move on to the superintendent's report hey thank you Mr President first um you know I'd like to try to highlight some of the Student Activities uh and our student Representatives did such a wonderful job tonight uh as always uh really bringing
027out a lot of the activities that are students are involved in both in athletics in music in uh other activities so thank you again for a very comprehensive report uh with that there were a couple things that I just wanted to add we have four of our high school students uh three of whom were in a picture uh that we just posted because we knew of three who play who participate in our school athletics and then we received information on a four student who actually participates in uh a sport that the high school doesn't offer and that is rowing crew so I would just like to give recognition to those four students uh there are also at least three of them are on our Facebook and uh uh page Twitter and our website but we
028have glana parate who was an all conference pitcher for the mon softball team last season she signed a letter of intent to wrote for the University of Miami in Coral Gables Florida next year for uh crew so um although she played softball for for she's signing for crew which we do not offer uh Grace Martini is the captain of the girls field hockey team uh won the county championships or won County championships in field hockey and softball played in a county in sectional final and basketball earned all conert selection in field hockey and all division selection in softball she'll be signing a letter of intent to play field hockey at East Stroudsburg University Rico viani and I apologize if I'm not correct if I'm not pronouncing the names uh the last names correctly uh Varsity
029letter winner in two Sports basketball and baseball uh won a county championship in baseball played in a county and sectional final earned all division selection in baseball he'll be signing a letter of intent to play baseball at Wagner College and Robbie pedo who is a varsity letter in baseball won a county championship in baseball played in a county and sectional final earned All Conference selection in baseball and rated as one of the top 10 Senior High School pitchers in the country by um it just says USA I forget the I think it's US US News I'll be signing a letter of intent to play baseball at the University of North Carolina and again as uh our student representativ is uh so elegantly mentioned our boy soccer team uh nj.com uh made a mention of not
030only it was a a wonderful game a hard-fought game uh the kids really played well even though they ended up Shy a goal it's 3-2 in the final score um nj.com uh gave accolades to the entire sports program and especially the the students and the fans who were in attendance last Friday and I got to witness that and uh a lot of school spirit so that was really really nice to see and nice to receive that recognition uh on the um and there's a lot of other great news in in your principal report uh the superintendent report that section of that please take time to go through that uh there's a lot of good activi is going on in our schools um one note on our board agenda under board action I um item letter
031I if you would this was brought up to me by the board president very um thank you thanking him for that uh it was a mistake that the stien amount to be paid to the advisor uh per policy 2430 dictates that the first year of a new activity is voluntary and unpaid so I would ask that you strike the stien amount for the advisor that is letter I under board action of the agenda page 15 15 thank you thank you and that concludes my report Mr President all right and now if you want to uh give your recommendations under personnel absolutely I asked the board to I recommend to the board to consider approving Personnel items A through Z so moved second second okay we have a second all right who made the first I
032did any questions or discussion on Personnel items A through Z all right seeing none Mr Gorski roll call please M armenio yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K panowich yes Mr nosin yes Mr proso Mr Rybeck yes Mr poy yes Mr board president Personnel items A through Z passes thank you and now your board action items yes I ask that the board uh recommend to the board that they approve items a through o again noted that item I that statement am man has been deleted so moved second okay uh do we have any questions or comments Miss armeno yes on um board action G and H uh for uh funded grants we're applying for them are they will if we get them will they be for a
033specific purpose and do we require matching funds um yes will'll be for a specific purpose and I believe we just got information afternoon no we didn't have that okay all right we we did get information last week that we did receive the first grant so the Grant in letter G the njaa funded Grant in the amount of $2,000 we did um we were awarded that Grant and I apologize for just shooting this at you now but do we know what that will be used for I mean sustainable so it's environmental I would imagine it's it's environmental it's to begin a uh working at the high school with a garden uh using it within our Foods um classes there is actually a green team that will be involved in um coordinating all of that that's a
034student team it's students it's parents it's administrators it's teachers yes and this is under um the supervision of Mrs caletto our supervisor of Science and do we have to fund that as well or is that just a straight Grant nope it's just the grant that we do not have we do not have to provide matching funds and information on H is it's it's a the second part of that Grant um they recommend that we apply for both grants the smaller portion and the larger portion to fund the whole activity so it's really a combined Grant um but we have we have we have been awarded the first one we haven't heard yet about the second it's likely however that if you get award don't know we don't know okay great and I think I have
035another question on I um so the first um Bulletin we're we're scratching to $254 as an annual stien yes but we are keeping the the materials and the um transportation to the state Science Olympiad program correct so it's 500 the 4 now is that is that sort of the our attempt at getting into the robotics is that our am I allowed to say that this no sure is it this was the presentation that Mrs caletto did with the students at the last board meeting right so that's what this this would be approving that program the start of that program and her three-year plan for implementation this would be the first year will that lead into robotics uh the two are not related although there are some robotic portions to the O Science Olympiad uh we
036do have a high school robotics team and we are hosting the competition this year uh that Middle School robotics team it's in the planning phases okay sorry I'm ready to start it I in the planning pH but we have to follow procedures and policy just like everyone else has to and I won't go on about how valuable Middle School robotic would be but thank you thanks Mr any other questions uh just an aside based on Miss armen's questions about those grants uh it reminded me that when we approved uh Mets as our food caterer uh one of their commitments uh was that they would be building a greenhouse here at the high school and I have not heard any update about that um Nancy mitac is actually a part of this green team and they
037will be working together to do that that will be part of it and Mets will be building the green house will be working with us on that also yes okay thank you no further questions or discussion all right then Mr Gorski roll call please miss Areno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr zareski I abstain from I abstain with the exception of items J and N I vote yes thank you sir Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs col panowich yes Mr nosin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr P yes Mr board president board action items a through o with the modification on I to remove the STP and piece passes thank you and would you now give us your report and recommendations Mr board president and members of the Mona Township Board of Education
038it is recommended that board action items a through I be approved by consent roll call so moved second bless bless you oh I'm sorry Mr Mayo has me distracted over there with her sneezing it's part of the record right bless you okay do we have I believe you're going to ask if there are any questions on the business administor rep you have a first and a second yes sir okay so do we have any questions on any of Mr gorsky's recommendations no questions okay roll call please miss armeno yes with the exception of G the shared service agreement between Monroe Board of Education and the township of Monroe tennis courts uh I vote no on that not because I don't believe it's essential that we have the uh residents using the tennis courts I find
039that the use of the tennis courts for the benefit of all the members and residents of Monroe is reasonable enough for the township to share the cost of repairs I disagree however with the condition of it regarding the um art uh commission so I vote no on that on that basis thank you Mr Braverman yes on everything except g g is and no thank you Mr zareski Iain thank you Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mr proso yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Po yes Mr board president board action items a through I passes and that concludes my report thank you thank you Mr Gorski uh just a uh few uh comments uh as part of my uh president's report uh I wanted to with the uh Schoolboard elections
040uh now a thing of the past I wanted to congratulate uh Frank Russo and Don Corino uh who I'm not sure are if you're here tonight please stand up okay well I extend to you my congratulations nevertheless and uh also to Mr Braverman on your reelection uh I would like to mention that uh Mr Gorski uh Dr kak and myself uh met with our town officials last week uh it was a productive hour to an hour and a half meeting uh we talked about various topics one was the shared service agreement but uh more primarily uh going forward uh whether or not they would be willing to meet with us and our state representatives from the assembly and the Senate uh to see what assistance they might be able to give the township uh in
041terms of uh somehow ameliorating our financial situation uh also we talked about uh several other issues uh the possibility of putting uh they mentioned that uh there's a possibility of putting up a u what do you call those a cell tower uh one of them somewhat near the school and uh I I think they are inclined not to uh not to favor that uh and I forget if there was anything else that you might want to add to that either of you that discussion that we had with them I know I've caught you off guard here um no it was it was a like you said it was a very productive meeting we also talked about um potential uh of different land sites which will be recommended in the future to the ad hoc committee
042for uh consideration the sites um would be contributions of land from the township to the school district similar to what happened with oak tree school where we received the donation of land to construct a school on saving $2 million which otherwise would have had to been bonded for and uh these Parcels of land look very attractive at this juncture but there are no predetermined um uh Notions going into the ad hoc committee and uh we were starting there from scratch and the committee will decide whether that's feasible with um their recommendation and finally I would like to report on the first meeting of our ad hoc committee we met uh I guess it was Monday night of this week having a lot of meetings lately but we met on Monday night uh everyone that we
043invited to be part of that committee uh was there with the exception of one person and he had previously notified us of his inability to be there uh I wanted to update the uh the board as well as the community uh and remind you of what the makeup of that committee is we have a total of uh nine parents uh from the various schools in the district we have four members of the central Administration we have three building principls we have four teachers at various grade levels there are four members of the Board of Education four uh Senior Communities were represented uh we had two students from the high school uh we also had a member of the police department who was also a parent and a member of the wreck department and uh I
044thought it was a very good first session uh ran for about an hour and a half uh a lot of give and take a lot of input our next meeting will be on December 7th uh the I will also state for your information the charge of that ad hoc committee uh and I'm going to read exactly what what I uh gave to them uh on Monday evening uh the charge of the ad hoc committee is to understand and evaluate the impact of current and anticipated growth in student enrollments on the facilities and programs of the Monroe Schools and to formulate recommendations for consideration by our Board of Education on addressing those impacts uh they will be working with a student growth advisory committee which will be much larger the the ad hoc committee is about
04533 members alog together uh we want the student growth uh committee to be uh anywhere up to about a hundred people uh and we already have quite a few people on the list who have expressed interest and we are looking for that student growth advisory committee which will meet for the first time in January we are looking for it to reflect the community and by that I mean we want more parents okay from throughout the community on that committee uh we want more teachers on that committee we welcome other members of the board uh to participate in that committee we want more representatives from our Senior Communities and if you happen to be a senior and you don't live in one of those communities you are also welcome uh to to join that committee we
046want more students both high school middle school and possibly Elementary uh we are looking to make this all-encompassing so that we get a diversity of thinking in terms of what we can do do to address the impact of uh student growth uh this is a wonderful opportunity in my opinion for the community to involve themselves in assisting the board in determining what the schools what direction the schools should move in in the future uh if you happen to see this uh meeting on Channel 28 or if you're sitting here tonight I would strongly encourage you that if you are not on the ad hoc committee and if you have not yet applied for uh membership on the student growth advisory committee uh that you please consider doing so uh and the sooner you let us
047know uh the better because we will be uh attempting to finalize the list of people that will be on the advisory committee now you uh I also encourage you to tell friends neighbors relatives that live in the community that you think might be interested uh there will be one at least one nightly meeting per month that's the commitment and the meetings will run for about an hour and a half uh you can the probably the easiest way for me to tell you to communicate that interest would be to call the superintendent's office or email or email the superintendent's office uh giving your name your address uh your phone number and why you would like to be on the advisory committee but we really want the community to be involved in this it's a very very
048important step in moving forward not only for our schools but also for our community because as you know it is our community that has to finance our schools for the most part and that concludes my report uh this evening let me get back to the agenda here because I always tend to screw up here okay so let me now ask uh are there any other business that any of our members would like to bring up Mr Ryback Mr President um your report just now gave me a wonderful segue into uh expressing a few things that have been on my mind for some uh some while now let me start by saying certain things are very difficult to achieve I hate quitting and um it's just my makeup and and I'm sure most of us uh
049here feel the same way number of years ago our district lobbied very hard um for legislation to uh remove the cap on the growth Aid formula as a matter of fact we're losing Mr gorsky you could probably tell tell me correct me if I'm wrong somewhere is around $6 million a year um it went before the senate committee and and uh uh it passed but it never got it never passed the Senate itself however it is still active on the floor of the assembly and nothing's been done about it we don't hear about it uh I think we need to do something to rekindle that uh flame um is difficult as it may be uh I just can't see walking away from it because the job really isn't done yet and and uh I think
050uh well there's a few things let me just say a couple other things and then I'll give you my idea if this a matter of discussion um we're looking at taxes that certainly affects our taxes but I look at areas like Jersey City and hackin saac and I see their per capita income growing and growing and growing yet the amount of state aid they get is based on a number of years ago a lot more than ours why isn't that being changed what are our legislators doing legislators doing excuse me for that we have something called um impact fees now that's illegal why is it illegal this is my opinion because of the Builder Lobby they don't want to pay for uh schools new schools because of the impact on uh of uh New Growth
051which we're certainly experiencing um I was uh told by our legislator is that they would not be opposed to bringing that up again uh before the legislature hasn't been done yet um I think uh you started um doing the right thing by meeting with our town Representatives I'd like to ask you to um ask the administration if we can continue speaking not just with the town Representatives but our state representatives as well for all these issues to discuss these issues to see what we can do to help our taxpayers and to help us maintain First Rate education for all our students um I don't think this has is a matter of of emotion because I think this has already been discussed a number of years ago and I think and knowing that the district already
052participated in something like this uh I would ask uh you Mr President if you would uh speak with the administration and see if we can't get something like this going and have a meeting and certainly it's up to you but at that meeting if you want to include a number of board members off the top of my head I'd say maybe one to four but that's certainly uh something that uh you have to decide on thank you anyone else Mr Braverman when when Mr GOI asked the town to contribute towards the refurbishing of the tennis courts and they agreed but with a caveat I said Gee they never do anything really just out of the goodness of their heart so I said to myself I'll start following the money so I did I looked up
053njsa 54475 and that's how the the township is supposed to be giving us the revenue to run the schools and it says the township must make an initial payment to the board of 20% of the school taxes on or before must make an initial payment on or before August 10th each school year without a request by the board voluntary they're supposed to just do this it's on their calendar thereafter the township must pay school taxes within 30 days after a request by the board in the requested amount provided such amount does not exceed the board's required expenditures for a period of eight weeks following the request now I understand that we pass on the re at the reorganization meeting a schedule for the township to give us pay us the money every month I understand
054that however it's against the law we all take an oath when we when we swear on the Bible or whatever when we when we are uh elected to this office that we will be law abiding so I'm suggesting I'm suggesting that Mr Gorski and central office administration take a month to get on schedule now you might be saying we're already collecting on a monthly basis why upset the apple cart that's already been fought and Court by the Board of Education versus Fair Lawn in 1976 and the court said the municipal budget upon which the annual real property tax is rate is based has three distinct components the amount to be raised for municipal purposes the amount to be raised for County purposes and the amount to be raised for school purposes as to the county
055and school Monies to thus to be thus raised it is an essential part of the overall scheme that the obligation of the municipality to include these sums in their budgets to collect them and to transmit them in accordance with the statutory directive is absolute and unqualified These funds moreover once collected are in practical effect in a trust their trust funds until transmitted to the school district the M the municipality is mely a collection agency so what I'm I'm suggesting and if I need a motion on this just to follow the the law and for this board to be law abiding I'll make a motion but it seems to me that Mr Gorski with his know I mean this guy knows numbers he should be or the board with the president's signature should be notified in
056the township by certified mail probably by January that we're getting on track and this is what we want to do as far as the law is concern the township doesn't have a choice Mr Bo yes uh to Mr braverman's comments with all respect sir first the process begins with the a passing of the School District budget by the Board of Education a big component of that budget is the tax revenue which is raised by the municipality and then paid to the school district that calculation for taxes to be raised on the general fund and The Debt Service fund is reported on form a4f on a split year basis because we have to reconcile with the township and they're on a calendar year basis I then as the business administrator prepare a tax payment schedule uh
057for 10 monthly payments from the township and that payment schedule is front-loaded in accordance with the statute to accommodate the heavy debt service load that our district has in September and other months it's an intelligently designed schedule which is in full compliance with law and District policy and I asked respectfully that Mr Braverman follow up on this um misunderstanding by a meeting with Mary Smith the board attorney and I so that we could review this a little more in detail well with all due respect to you Mr Gorski I got this from Mary Smith but sir I think you're misinterpreting it with all respect because every year our our school board is audited tell tell you I'm in full compliance with the law and I and I have to correct that when the statements made
058that we are not respectfully sir we are in full compliance with law and board policy on a tax payment schedule not if you're not if we're not doing it on the state form every eight weeks it's on if it's on the state for and uh we are collecting more than an advertised straight line amount because of the heavy debt service we have early in the year the schedule is actually to our advantage and I'll be happy to discuss that with you in private I think it should be discussed publicly that's why I brought it up then my only last comment is again we are in full compliance with the law and board policy with the tax payment schedule the comment that I have uh Mr bravman is I listen very carefully to what you were
059saying and reading uh and I'm not quite certain uh and and I'm being very honest and truthful with you on this I'm really not certain exactly what the issue is that as you see it in your mind are we being short changed are we not getting the payments that we should get I mean I I just failed to realize what what it was that you were driving at I think we are being short changed I think if we get 20% of the revenue right up front we have quite a bit of money for investment and then we pay our bills every eight if if we structured to pay our bills every 8 weeks we still have that cushion this is the money that they're floating and they're getting the interest on we're running a school
060district and we should be in control of that money just one final comment on that in the months of July and August we get front loaded payments which again I'd rather discuss this in private but we do have additional excess monies that do get deposited in our cash management fund which has millions of dollars in Balance throughout the year is it 20% we get 20% by the statutory deadline we are in full compliance with the law I I I discussed this with today with Council she agrees that we are in full compliance with the law and board policy on the matter than thank you any other business that any member wants to bring up no all right then I will now read the closed session resolution I anticipate that this will be a very short
061Clos session and I will also I'm sure to the joy of our public let you know that in December you will have the opportunity for the second public session prior to our going into closed session because just tonight we passed the revised policy on that uh so that will go into effect in December but but unfortunately tonight you're going to have to wait a few minutes while we go into close session before we get to the uh second public session so be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 to discuss the following subject harassment intimidation and bullying following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed
062session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exist how long are we anticipating this will require five minutes five minutes all right we will we will promise to be back out here in 10 minutes okay so moved all in favor okay any opposed all right okay all right we will now return to public session and there uh brought to my attention that there was one other piece of uh board business that one of our members wanted to bring up so Mr proso yes I would like to address a news article that recently came in the the news about uh board member admits to ethics violation okay uh this ethics violation they're talking about is Kathy konowitz versus Anthony proso I tell you what I admitted to
063I sent out for an invitation only email to three people up for uh I'm sorry I sent out an information email that three people up for election have special needs children in their lives I wrote and I quote being a parent of one of God's special children myself I have an interest in who will be my CH child's most and I explained that the candidates had special needs children in their family I needed support for our special needs kids this was a way to inform grandparents and parents who in my opinion as a parent would have our loved ones best interest out of the 200 special needs parents and grandparents I sent this email to one special education teacher received the same email and that was the violation I admit to this charge it was
064an email I sent out but it was an email to help kids the ethics charge cost the taxpayer all of us tens of thousands of dollars tens of thousands of dollars to have me to go to one sensitivity class this money could have been better spent on our kids it's a shame now all of you might say now Kathy konowitz and a few board members might say well there's other ethics charges filed against me absolutely they were all because I asked too many questions because I did not get answers as a board member or a chairman of the finance committee no matter how they twist and turn these charges to make me the bad guy they are off asking questions that in the past administration I was not getting answers to all of those charges
065the rest of them were all withdrawn now I have another one to address Mr Ira Tesla versus Anthony proso this also cost the taxpayers St thousands of dollars I made a statement to Mr Tesla after a board meeting the quote in the paper says you're Jewish you should not raise your hand like that because of this statement Mr Tesla filed a police report against me and he also filed e ethics charges against me this was thousands of dollars later the court dismissed all the charges because of this action I had to endure many people that didn't even know me accused me of anti-Semitism I kept quiet through all of this because no matter what I said the people that wanted me off the board would have found a way to keep it going now I'll
066tell you why I made that statement before I was married I lived in the same home for 16 years with a wonderful person that person was a holocaust Survivor we had a relationship like mother and son when I made that statement it was a concern for Mr Tesla and the way a certain hand gesture might be taken that's all it was I have given my time and effort to all people especially special needs kids I spent my own money in court to fight for that summer program that we had for years during the time of Hurricane Sandy I was at the municipal building every day bringing bags of food to all the seniors that were left out of their homes I offered my home to anyone at at that time that didn't have shelter to
067say to stay these were for all people and over the years my family has opened up their doors to special needs kids for parties at our own expense and even this year my family is giving their time and effort pre PR preparing shopping bags filled with holiday gifts for a 100 kids now to have anybody paint me as anti-emetic or being prejudiced against anybody this is the lowest form of an accusation shame on anybody who thinks that's the truth that's it okay now we will go to our second public session at this time uh people coming to the microphone please give your name your address if you have any affiliation please state that please keep your comments to three minutes or less thank you well that's tough Doug joean card 11 Gravel Hill Spotswood Road
068Monroe Township retired special ed teacher uh but still I like to keep my hands in things so I like to stay aware of what's going on my questions uh relate to the portfolio assessment writers um I do I am aware of the new graduation requirements but I'd like to know if the assessment writers are the ones who are going to be grading the portfolios or just writing what has to go into the portfolio we do not grade the portfolio assessments they have to be sent to the state and be approved by the state the state has given us guidelines to write the assessments and to write the problems that have that students would have to respond to that's what the portfolio writers will be doing all right have all have has all of this been
069outline to the parents and the students yes so the specialed students would most likely fall into that portfolio assessment yes possibly uh right now they're in the process of uh all of the IEP meetings for any uh special education student or elll uh limited English Lang English language Learners um they are in the process of meeting with those parents now the child study team case managers um some of those students may be exempt from Tes if they were exempt from the hespa they would be exempt from this graduation requirement so they would not have to go through the portfolio assessment so they would be totally exempt from any of these graduation requirements correct correct um my other question rep uh applies to the acup Placer I'm I have some familiarity with it and um well
070then I guess if there if our specialed students would be exempt it wouldn't make any difference correct but is the accuplacer going to be given given during the school day more instructional time lost no this would be given after school we would also offer review time after school prior to giving that assessment and we're still in the we're still in the planning processes of that nothing has been set in stone I have a meeting Friday morning with Mr Goodall and Dr Catelli to to come up with the action plan of how we're moving forward and when will the will the portfolio have to be completed by in order to be assessed by the state there are dates I I don't know the date off the top of my head so I don't want to give
071a date and give you the wrong date um but the state has given us guidelines of exactly when we would have to submit it to the state we can begin submitting portfolios for review to the state in January I don't know what the final deadline is for that okay um I was more concerned about the special ed students because I know the difficulty of those tests all right thank you very well Cline seven cruncher Court um Mr preciosa basically precioso um finally said what had to have been said if you remember last time I asked about what the cost was to the district to go through this this ethics baloney and I call it baloney because that's what it was uh I was able to file an Oprah request to get all of the uh
072the attorney's fees and I went through it and anything that applied to Mr precioso I added came out to $50,000 wasted any of the ethics charges could have been handled with a reprimand never had to go to court the reason why I'm bringing this up now is this should be a lesson to the board that if you're going to go to the ethics board it's going to cost that $50,000 could have been used for many many different things um so let that be a lesson to all of you and anybody else that's on the board thereafter that it does have a cost and it's costly uh the next thing is um that was brought up during the meeting is we we always give um uh the teachers the opportunity for professional development in many cases
073it's very costly and when I was on the board I suggested that Any teacher that will sign up for any of this development that they sign a letter stating that they will stay for three years after they complete the course nothing was ever done and what I think uh Mr Rybeck had said I think it was Mr Rybeck that you have teachers that take the development we pay for it and then all of a sudden the following year they leave our district to go elsewhere so that's something you should address um you brought up about the legislature more funding which I fought for many many years and you all know that um in the newspaper before the election there are at least three bills in the State Assembly by the Republicans that would give us
074uh property tax relief and more money towards your districts it's been there as I understand it well over two to three years it's never called up for discuss as far as the builders to pay towards the schools it's illegal I tried to do that when I spoke up at a planning board meeting and I asked the Builder the applicant if he would pay towards the schools and Bob Smith who was a Senator and he's a power broken middle county says we don't have to do that the state says we don't have to do it uh I'm on the zoning board I brought it up on the zoning board to an applicant the same thing so that's got to be changed in Trenton the last thing I know my time is up but the last thing
075is Doug you did a hell of a job you're going to be missed the vote was unfair we didn't have enough people out voting because evidently they just don't give a damn and in odd development alone we could have picked up easily 38 votes this is proof again we had it with Joe hoki when he lost because he was number five and three I'm done five and three and you were seven please run again next time thank you thank you Mr kleene uh I I do want to share one piece of information with you uh in the latest uh teacher contract that we negotiated that is now in effect uh we do have a a clause in there that takes care of teachers that are going to graduate school and being reimbursed uh they do
076have to remain in the system uh a certain number of years after taking that course otherwise they have to reimburse the district for the cost of that because we did feel that that was uh something that was not working to our advantage necessarily so that has been corrected thank you thank you can I clarify one thing Mr no no otherwise it gets into a debate yes hi good evening my name is Nisha namara and I live at 28 Carnation Drive um tonight I am here to advocate for a swim club at the high school at Monroe Township High School and usually just as a side note every night at 8:30 I'm actually putting my six-year-old and my 5-year-old to sleep um this evening uh my six-year-old and my 5-year-old both asked me where I was
077going do you have another meeting to go to you know why are you always out in the evening blah blah blah and I said actually I do and tonight I'm going to speak in front of the board to try to get us a swim club and my son looked at me and he and he touched me on the shoulder and he said good luck so I have the full support of my children which was most important before coming out here but now I want to gain the support hopefully of the board um as well as the entire Monroe Community and the letter that I submitted uh not only on my Facebook page but to Dr alvich this evening as well as the athletic director uh Greg berer is as follows and I will just try
078to highlight some of the reasons that I think it is um undoubtedly compelling that we have a swim team here in Monroe dear Board of Education we are parents who are supportive of the athletic Endeavors of our children and we thank you in advance for your careful consideration the argument on behalf of a Monroe High School swim team as I mentioned is very compelling first of all we have a tremendous interest in a swim team in this community we have hundreds and hundreds of parents and their children who are taking their children to swim lessons teaching them to swim competitively and that's all happening uh you know in Monroe families um across the community I put up a Facebook page entitled swim Monroe and within one week over 300 people had visited this page and
079I garnered 150 signatures of people who are just interested in allowing their children to compete in swimming at the high school level so the public has definitely spoken and the message is clear we want a swim team second almost every school in Middle sex county has a high school swim team I was shocked when I moved to this area and I found out that we didn't have a swim team it's basic in a few words our efforts are long overdue in order to remain respected competitive and engaged with schools in our County we need to establish the same third as most of you know uh swimming swimming is a lifelong sport while the medical benefits are many improving circulation uh weight loss more importantly swimming breeds camaraderie students carry these relationship forward as adults remembering
080promoting and reliving their times at Monroe High School decades after they graduate and fourth our children need to develop a sense of community we need to pull our community together one more second currently those who swim competitively are doing so in Freehold Petty and even Hamilton our home is Monroe Township and we need to stand proud wearing our colors and the school name when we compete so members of the board specifically the curriculum committee who I understand is going to be discussing this at the December curriculum committee meeting I ask that you look very closely and that you carefully consider a swim club for Monroe High School thank [Music] you thank you for your comment and uh let me just say that I personally uh believe that as high schools get larger that you do
081need to expand your extracurricular offerings to provide for the various abilities needs and talents of the larger number of students that you have however I am mindful of the fact that uh we are only allowed to grow our budget by a certain percent each year and right now we're faced with such a problem because of the number of students that are simply coming into the district just trying to house those students provide for the educational needs to those students really makes it quite difficult for us to add new programs and I will also mention because I have studied this even before I was on the board I look at it every year uh the per student cost uh compared to other districts in Middle sex County and for reasons which I still do not fully
082understand uh Monroe spends more money on their extracurricular program per student than almost every other District in the county uh and somehow we have to find a way if we're going to put something like swimming in we're going to have to find a way to fit that in and yet not exceed the budget cap and I don't know exactly what that would mean but I'm glad that it's going to be looked at by the uh curriculum committee because they are the ones that should be studying it first yes my name Laura MRE I live at 112 D Grove Road I am on the ad hoc committee and also on the historic preservation Commission um I am also Osa swim official so I'm one of those people on the deck in the white shirt walking around
083um I have to say swimming has been a part of my family my entire life my daughters swim and I understand um the impact and the students we have coming in I live on the oak tree side and I see it weekly uh it's not a sport that really costs a ton of money a pool yes but to to go someplace and swim it's not a a big cost you need a swimsuit some goggles some fins and the kids are done um I mean I can sit here and talk about all sorts of great statistics on GPA and and kids going off to college and all that stuff but really it does we all know that I mean other sports can can Dazzle us with their statist statistics too um I just think that we
084really need to be able to compete in that area we have so many kids coming in the interest is huge I just realized tonight alone a small group we have we represent three different swim teams in this area and um we should all be home we we should all be here I know my daughter swims with some of the fastest swimmers in the nation I mean that's just in this area alone and there in their age group I mean that says a lot not just in the state in the entire nation so we have such swim talent in this area that I'd love to see that come to Monroe and for years and years people are constantly asking me how come we don't have a swim team how come we you know I mean I
085understand it's it's a process and it's going to take time but I hope we can start seriously considering it and maybe moving towards that in the future you thank you and as I listen to your comment uh it reminded me of something that I think the public needs to be aware of you're you're quite accurate that in order to have a swim team does not require that you have a swimming pool in your school district most high schools uh they rent swim time at YMCAs uh at other schools Pools North Brunswick has a pool in their school I know uh and I know that West Windsor has pools in their school I'm not sure about South Brunswick or East Brunswick but there are places where you can find uh pool space that you can rent
086somewhat like our ice hockey team uh uh does uh nevertheless there's still the cost of the coaching and there's still the cost of the transportation uh that's involved in that but certainly it is much less than what many of the other sports uh do require anyone else no one else from the public wishes to speak all right then I will uh close the uh second public session once again I just want to remind you about our student advisory uh committee that that will start up in January uh please keep that in mind uh encourage uh friends neighbors Etc to consider signing up for that uh our next meeting of the Board of Education will be Wednesday December the 16th here at the High school at 700 p.m. I move that we adjourn this meeting move
087okay all in favor is anyone opposed meeting is adjourned