CorpusRecord 132961

Monroe Township Board of Education 02.10.16 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-18
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,582 words · about 48 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001of education is called to order um I ask everyone to please rise for the pledge and I'd like to have our student reps lead us in the pledge tonight I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all roll call Miss armeno Mr Braverman Miss Deo here Mr calman here Mrs P Pano here Mr nostin here miss Corino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here Mr rutsky here Mr board president you have a quorum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted February

0025th 2016 at all excuse me at all schools home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr corsky um first order of vision will be approval of minutes uh can I have a motion to approve the minutes of the public Board of Education meeting for December 16 2015 so moved second any discussion okay we could vote in favor I I any opposed I guess no abstentions or recusals motion passes do I have a motion to approve the minutes of the Clos session meeting December 16th 2015 moved second thank you any discussion in favor I I opposed no extensions or recusals motion passes uh do I have a a motion to approve the U minutes of the public Board of Education organization meeting January 6th 2016 still moved second

003any discussion we'll vote all in favor I I any opposition extensions or recusals motion passes student board member reports Mr thorney thank you Mr board president since the uh last meeting the high school's MTH trial team competed and placed uh within the county and had the opportunity to complete at regionals um and they did an excellent job doing that the drama department at the high school also put on a murder mystery show um and the high school chapter of future Business Leaders of America held a karaoke fundraiser um with the proceeds going to f in the March of Dimes and they were able to um donate $200 to the March of Dimes and um recently the high school held a freshman orientation to allow for the incoming freshmen and their parents to get familiar with

004the um courses course programs and um some of the extracurricular activities that the high school has to offer okay so as usual I'm going to start out with some of our sports updates uh two of our wrestlers have ad Advanced to the county finals which are Lombard and golf the wrestling team beat Jackson Liberty to ad advance to the county quarterfinals the girls basketball team beat JP Stevens to take the first place spot uh and the girls's basketball team also beat North Brun North Brunswick to maintain at least a tie for the division championship our ice boys ice hockey team be Edison to advance the states and is going to play South Brunswick in the county finals uh also our high school's academic team won third place at the High-Tech high competition a few weeks

005ago this competition is a quiz b quiz Bowl style competition that tests both academic knowledge and trivia thank you okay thank you president report thank you very much uh next is the Henry rickless Holocaust Memorial committee award presentation David Rothman is with that committee and um comes to US every year and uh it's just astounding what a great job that these kids do and the job you do Mr Rothman with them thank you my pleasure it's good seeing you all board members uh president and the new superintendent of school glad to see you let me share you with you a few thoughts and you'll see what a great program this is uh we go before and and first let me compliment uh Matty philippus on your staff and also Bonnie castelletto believe I have that

006name right uh they just make it seamless for us and and it's just easy to do the freshman class is invited to an auditorium uh so for the 1-hour auditorium we bring in three speakers who are Holocaust survivors from our committee in fact Paulette is sitting here uh next to Liz and she's one of our speakers who happen to be there this year they share their life histories uh with the audience the audience then may ask some questions afterwards and then they're challenged and they're challenged to write an essay after it the essay could be what would you say to a holocaust Den if you met them um what would it have been like we asked them to interpret some uh statements about the Holocaust and we challenged them to do this and we invite

007them to uh they're not required to or anything else I'm so proud to tell you 266 freshmen from last year found the time in June when they've got finals and everything else to be able to write those essays we had 266 not all can be winners but I will tell you that 12 from our committee were outstanding just outstanding they were on the scale of one to five they were all fives I have many of those students here with us and we are going to give Awards to those 12 just Flawless essays but before I do um Steve was nice enough to say okay you can have two people speak that's it so I would like to invite if I may is and if I pronounce the names incorrectly please correct me Alexa quarino are

008you here please come forward do you have your saay with you yeah great I want you to hear just this one and we have one more after thank you it is very important for students to learn about the Holocaust for the very same reason they should study and learn all of history those who do not learn history are doomed to repeat it the quote was most likely due to George sanana and in its original form it read those who cannot remember the past are condemned to to repeat it however this quote became famous when Winston Churchill was Sur sounding alarm Bells about Hitler in a speech at the House of Commons on May 2nd 1935 Church Hill said when the situation was manageable it was neglected and now that it is Thoroughly out of hand

009we apply to late the remedies which then might have affected the Cure there is nothing new in his in the story it is as old as the Cilan books it falls into the long dismal catalog of the fruitlessness of experience and the conf confirmed unability of mankind want to foresight unwillingness to act when action would be simple and effective lack of clear thinking confusion of council until the emergency comes until self-preservation strikes its jaring gong these are the features which constitute the endless repetition of History not his not learning history completely removes the possibility of patent recognition hence dooming us to repeat it this gives a deeply disturbing insight into how Britain rejected Winston Church Hill's warning like little children Parliament tried to hide from the brutal reality according to several historians Britain and the

010Western world came dangerously close to being conquered by Adolf Hitler how profound are his words that historic speech could have been given right here right now as we watch the slaughter of hundreds of thousands of biblical Christians all throughout the Middle East and yet we close our eyes and pretend we do not see this is very personal to me as I am an Assyrian and Armenian descendant and I'm here in the United States because my great-grandfather fled turkey to during the Armenian Assyrian Greek Holocaust perpet Red by The Young Turks my Assyrian ancestors still reside in their homeland of Assyria which was conquered and now called Iraq and they are the people of Isis that Isis are beheading in Northern Iraq in the biblical area Nineveh not only are they beheading the Christian men but

011they are also raping and selling the women and children into slavery for a mere pack of cigarettes we are still sitting back and watching the Christian Holocaust occur and we are doing nothing Christians should not be beheaded for their beliefs children should not be forced to marry at 7 years old because of their gend and people should not be thrown off of root Toops for who they are just like the Jewish Holocaust too many people will die unnecessarily because of because our leaders have chosen to do nothing as Dietrich Bon hoofer said silence in the face of evil is evil itself God will not hold us Guiltless not to speak is to speak not to act is to act why do we continue to ignore or hide from the cogent warning messages from the past

012These Warnings should be like a flashing red light in our memory today what price will we have toay pay for forgetting Americans must wake up to the ongoing brutalities and mass murders in the Middle East if we do not unite against this evil now then the indictment will come upon us tomorrow as a Christian I do not know how the Jewish people could trust us when we say never again as they watch us do nothing to save our own from a genocide when the Middle Eastern Christians have all been exterminated Isis will turn their attention to Israel and try to fulfill their promise to wipe Israel off the map wake up America never again as now [Applause] okay here is another essay and this essay was in in response to the question what would you

013do or say if you came in contact with the Holocaust denier uh C vam are you here please come forward I hope I pronounced right okay thank you I am astonished at the resilience and sheer determination you have shown I have fallen in love with your compassion your kindness and your caring it is unfathomable to me how one would begin to withstand what you have and still lead a productive life and give back to society it is also beautiful that even though what you went through was horrible you gladly share your experiences without fear to a new generation to teach them lessons without going through what you had to go through it is because of you that the way I respond to the follow following situation is the way it is the Holocaust as you

014know was the mass genocide of Jews Roma the disabled and criminals it has been documented by pictures memorials museums records the Nazi kept and of course people like you so if I met a holocaust dener my first reaction would be one of rage and anger however then I would stop and think of what happened in the Holocaust and of how many people were persecuted because of their beliefs if I did the same without learning about why this dener is the way he or she is then I would be just as bad as the Nazis after calming down I would ask the Holocaust denier questions about why the denier felt the way he did or she did about the Holocaust whatever reasons they would tell me the only reactions I would have are sadness and pity

015I would feel a deep sorrow not for denying the atrocities committed by Hitler or the denying of the tortures that the people went through I would feel sorrow for the denying of the one 11 million who lost their lives as victims to the Holocaust the denying of their very existence of course what they went through was horrible but without their memory to live on in us all their suffering would be in vain I feel pity for those who deny the Holocaust as they do not realize that it can and might happen again if we don't do everything to prevent it in addition to this they lose the Abundant Treasure Trove of life lessons those who were victimized in the Holocaust left us if I could not convince the Holocaust Deni of the existence of the

016Holocaust I would walk away and make 10 more people believe that such atrocities occurred and that knowledge would be passed on and live on forever so history as it often does doesn't repeat itself please stay in front uh I'd like to list off the names and hand Awards uh you may or may not have known it but we're giving out $50 gift certificates just for your efforts so without further Ado uh let me start with cast thank you and uh please take your award [Applause] uh is Ilana Bernell here was wonderful Elana well that's another one for Matt okay uh Megan Cavanaugh Megan Kavanaugh here please come forward excellent okay Julia kavaz off please come forward thank [Applause] you an excellent essay congratulations thank you Taylor van con tellor are you here thank you janica

017Lebenthal [Music] J excellent Katherine strich [Applause] Kiera [Applause] Sears thank you Aya cuaso I hope I'm pronouncing that right a another one for Matt okay Mahin [Applause] sha thank you thank you and of course you've already heard from her Alexa quarino [Applause] you great and that concludes our presentation thank you for the time thank you very much I thank congratulate and thank all the winners uh it was really a treat listening to those essays and um to the committee keep doing the work you're doing because the words are never again are as relevant today as they were in the 1930s so thank you very much next order of business for the board are committee reports do we have any committee chair that Mr C sure we had a curriculum committee meeting this tonight thanks G

018uh we went over a couple of curriculum uh documents on Aerospace and laboratory physics uh generally speaking these things had just a overhaul and a refresh of the content material uh in addition we went over a proposal that was given to the curriculum committee a while back on a stem Summer Academy and we went over some of the initial uh um statistics and information about this project uh which we I guess going to do for the first time this summer if I'm correct um we're going to be looking at uh a program which will be open to students uh in grades who will be going into grades 2 through six uh it will be focusing on our uh science technology engineering and Mathematics uh programs it will be be offered in the summer it will

019be from August 1st to August 19th uh from 9:00 a.m. to 3 p.m. uh we will uh the the total cost of the initiative uh including uh the Staffing that we're going to be requiring is approximately $59,000 uh it will be uh looking to at least have or um bring in 216 students to clear costs uh we are going to be asking parents to pay in advance so other than the money we're expending right now which is just for staff to develop the program the entire cost of the program will be self- sustaining um even in this very first year and then we'll be looking to you know depending on its success looking on different ways to expand it uh in future years as I understand we we may have a waiting list already or

020at least parents have been uh contacted through a questionnaire to see if there's interest so we'll be bringing the numbers before the finance committee uh just to let them know but again it's not going to be an impact to our budget other than the the Staffing cost that we have today uh in addition to this program we also talk about our Summer band camp proposal uh which is basically the same one that we've had in the past um if anybody needs some information on that particular program I have a a couple of copies here or you can you know seek the band director to get more details uh and we also reviewed two Club proposals for do the impossible Club um and uh junior state of America Club um I don't know if I could

021do it justice but the junior I mean the do the impossible Club is focused on doing things like fundraising and other uh student oriented activities as and the junior state of America club uh is a I guess nationally sanctioned group that we're looking to bring into our district again this first year is free there's no cost to the district and we'll assess its success um I guess a year from now um that was basically it thank you Mr calman does anyone have any question from Mr calman any other committee chair Mr mail um on Monday night we had our second student growth advisory committee um we started off by reviewing the housing developments that in progress or approved for development um based on the number of housing projects proposed and districtwide enrollment projection we should

022be seeing an influx of 1327 new students through 2021 we were then giving a list of all the responses from last month as to possible solutions to the growth issue all the responses were grouped into one of nine categories um an example is category one was re Reed restructuring grade level configurations at schools and related redistricting um we were then tasked with coming up with more solutions for each category and as a group we were given a large sheet with one of the categories on it we were then to list some ideas specific to that category and then we passed the sheet to the next person and we did that until our original sheet came back and each sheet probably had about 10 new ideas on it finally we picked the one top suggestion from

023the category we started with um it was a very productive meeting everybody was engaged there was a lot of thoughtful discussion and um I think we're we're moving ahead very well so our next meeting will be in March thank you any question for Mrs the May any other committee chair so I'm any up okay we had a uh policy committee meeting uh we discuss as as is in your agenda uh pre prevention and treatment of sports related concussions and head injuries as a regulation uh we rein stated a policy that was abolished in 2 2010 uh to match the regulation that uh exists so that was a reinstatement of a policy uh about acceptable use of computer network computers and Resources by teaching staff members we also uh reviewed the family leave which was mandatory

024and revised it and another family leave uh two different uh categories of employees so those have been revised uh this is our first reading it will be on the March uh agenda so if anyone's interested in those please take a look at our website we also discussed uh for a future policy meeting we're going to be discussing the board committees as was as we were tasked to by our president uh Mr Rybeck and also we're looking into policy one uh 01 43-2 student represent atives to the Board of Education that was a discussion we needed further clarification from our attorney and we'll be speaking to that in March thank you thank you Mrs armeno any question from Mrs armeno Mr calman yeah I'm the p332 excuse me could you use the mic thank you on

025the p33 21 acceptable use policy is there detail in there which kind of lists websites that should or the question is is there consideration to list websites to be included in a list where we shouldn't really have access to them for any school purposes whatsoever uh no I don't believe that that's in the policy maybe it should be but it we would have to talk yeah I mean if I could Mr President could I respond sure absolutely I I I think one of the things that we have to be careful with with policy is if we get too specific new websites new things come up all the time uh the proper use of uh anything on the internet any web related uh information is pretty well documented through several policies just personally I would just

026be a little reluctant to try to be very specific with with um certain websites um you know because as I said they change they change names um so that's just my initial reaction to that but I'm not sure if there's more to what you're asking I mean acceptable use is is is a vague enough term as it is I would question why we would have just basically open season on any website for example a retail site walmart.com kmart.com as far as you know even if you wanted to bulk them into categories like retail sales or or something of that nature so because I would question what's its validity or or requirement to be accessible during you know school hours for teaching purposes yeah absolutely and we do have filters as you know uh as far

027as specific sites looking at not in this particular District but looking at those sometimes you wonder why the um maybe the internet seems to be moving slow and then if you trace it and you find out that maybe you know somebody might be on a site uh streaming uh could be a video um so you know we have to examine that and you have to keep a close look on that because you want the use of the internet to be used for instructional purposes again there was a period of time when when the internet was first coming into school districts that uh even things like CNN and and and even a retail site uh like a like a Walmart let's say could be blocked the problem that I think you could run into is instructionally

028there could be a lesson given on sales taex and to give the students a real life experience they might go to an online site like Walmart um I'm not saying that we couldn't do that I think that there has to come a uh there has to be uh supervision at all levels from the teacher to the student from the supervisors to the teacher the principal Etc uh as well as our technology department that looks at how our our technology is being used and to see if is are there inappropriate sites um so you know it it could warrant further discussion I would say um the only reason why I'm asking is it's a common business practice in Industry where certain websites are blocked there there's no business reason for employees to be you know on

029certain websites and you can categorize them however you want right the same the same logic would apply here if I have a lesson on sales tax I don't need to be on you know keep walmart.com open for one class one grade lesson on sales tax yeah and we may have a lot of those sites blocked I I don't want to speak with certainty because probably there are a lot of them that are blocked um but I'm just going through you know from experience situations where in in districts you try to block as much as you can and you end up restricting uh the good use of you know somebody wants to go to that site uh but we can certainly look into that though Miss Armenia yeah I I would I would hope that I

030mean just from using phrases that I've heard in the past um that we could have if a reasonable person you we can all judge it on if a reasonable person thinks that a website is inappropriate for use in the in the school district I think that that would not be an arbitrary or capricious uh restriction or sensor of that so I think that there's some I I think you know there's mostly all professionals here and I think reason ably we could we could determine what uh categories and what kinds of websites should not be used thank you any other committee chair Mr noin thank you Mr board president um I actually have a couple tonight uh Mr Braverman is not here so uh as the assistant uh chair of that committee the buildings grounds committee

031I'll just briefly uh explain some of the things that we did at our February 4th meeting um first item on the agenda was the request by Toll Brothers for a property line enhancement on Oak Tree School basically they want to uh seed and remove a silk fence that uh is currently on site it's just a beautification type of issue and the uh recommendation of the committee was to allow Toll Brothers to uh to go ahead and and proceed with that um we also discussed the township uh land donation on Route 22 uh across from the uh administration building right behind the firehouse um I believe it was 9 Acres approximately and we did discuss that and we did recommend that the uh the board go ahead and accept that for a dollar so I think

032it was 522 not Route 22 I'm sorry yeah okay you're right this says Route 22 but you're right I got just remind you please no cross conversation just a correction thank you thank you um so we did recommend that uh the uh that that was accepted for a dollar and uh we also discussed the diamond Club donation of the bleachers and accessories that's on the agenda tonight uh the recommendation was to accept their generous donation um we also discussed the annual landscape contract renewal um which is again on the agenda this evening and uh it's with a 0% increase which is always uh music to everyone's ears we also discussed the Woodland School roof replacement project uh going forward that's 1.3 million uh expected cost the bids are going out on uh TW uh February

03324th for that we also discussed the annual review of the written IAQ program which is indoor air quality program during that discussion it came up that the the committee felt that uh it might be a good time to test the water quality especially uh with the uh incidents of lead and up in Flint Michigan that we did that we uh test the oldest schools basically uh Applegarth and um and Barkley Brook schools for uh lead and uh Mr tag is going to proceed with that um that ends my buildings grounds and transportation just want do we have any question on that's I'm going to tell you I'm done with that okay let's appreciate we I'm sorry yes M many Mr nste were they also were they also considering um Woodland and Applegarth as well Apple

034I think Woodland might yeah I think we said yeah I think we said all three I said the three oldest schools oh okay and and probably twice a year here we we don't know we have to get um we have to get some quotes on that no I think Mr T is going to do it it's not it's not a big ticket item he said so it's very easy to do our our our Personnel will do it okay thank you send it to a lab anything else for I have a finance committee report yes okay uh finance committee met on February 4th uh first item on the agenda was the Falcon Falcon care report uh Mr Gorski provided a history with regards to the Early Childhood enrichment program in the Mecca and went on to

035explain the current financials for the Early Childhood enrichment in the Falcon Care Program which is the former bass program that we now run Falcon care currently shows a profit of $116,000 early child hood en Richmond shows 29,000 and that's just for five months ending November 30th both numbers are very encouraging and combined profits are projected to be in the $300 to $400,000 range and ECE is currently at capacity and has a waiting list so that was uh definitely a bit of good news we also discussed about the repayment of the loan and how that we might uh uh accelerate that going forward uh we also discussed item two was the Jamesburg tuition agreement um Mr Gorski received the a41 and the a42 details and we discussed them with him explaining that the um he also

036went into detail about the uh the agreement between Jamesburg and Monroe and that the agreement's premise of a declining tuition rate at the high school is Right On Target and has fact decreased the tuition has decreased by 5.65% to uh $1 15,290 per student in the agreement Jamesburg um is budgeted for 267 students and they can't go below that according to the agreement and they have to um go at a tuition rate that is equal to or greater than the department of education's calculated rate which right now looks to be about for 14,520 the difference is because the doe does not take into consideration any interest on the bonds which is why there is a difference a meeting was held today with Jamesburg to discuss the payment amount and they will bring it to their

037board meeting tomorrow and report back to Mr Gorski um we had a budget update the governor's address was changed so now that caused our board meeting to change to I believe the 16th and that's on the agenda for approval tonight also um Mr Gorski mentioned that the budget is in good shape and he is working hard to negotiate the 16% increase in health care cost we're trying to negotiate that down to a more manageable number of 8 to 9% to enable us to go to the $600,000 below cap that the board has directed thank you my report thank you Mr nonin any question from Mr nonin okay that being the case we're ready for our public forum I just want to take a minute to explain because it's still relatively new what we do with

038the public forum we actually have three the first one uh you're invited up and it have to you have to address um one of the items on the agenda the second one is a open it's not necessarily uh confined to an agenda item and the third one is uh concerning the closed session when you come up we ask that you um give your name speak slowly and your address uh you are limited to 3 minutes and then we have a buzzer here to let you know when your time is up that being said is there anyone in the public that would like to come up to address the agenda okay seeing no one we can move on to our superintendent report Dr kak he thank you Mr President before I ask uh make any recommendations

039to the board for items to be approved I would just like to mention a few things um some of our students our students of course uh as always gave a an excellent report and I just wanted to mention a few additional items that were mentioned uh in the principal reports that I I received uh in mid January 23 of our middle school students audition for the uh Central Jersey music educators Association uh intermediate region choir and 20 of the students were selected to sing in either the treble or the mixed choirs a number of uh middle school students successfully auditioned also into the South Jersey mea Wind Ensemble symphonic band uh or percussion Ensemble our high school teams our athletic teams are doing very well and um a recent note that I I sent out

040to the board and we put out on Facebook and Twitter has been a story of one of our swimmers now everyone on the board understands we don't have a swim team an official swim team and one of our coaches is kind enough to uh she herself was a Collegiate swimmer she volunteers her time to um take our students to these different swim meets you know with the parents and uh have the students compete so they get a chance to compete in these uh different swim events one of our swimmers a uh Rick forell or Rich forel he um he achieved the first place in the 100 meter backstroke but inadvertently didn't understand that he had a cap on a swimmer's cap that had the name of a private club and by the rules that's not

041allowed so he was disqualified even though he broke I think it was a 15year record and M the matachin um swimmer who was in second then took first place now Rich also had the same cap on for another event but the judges didn't note it and you know nothing happened so that for that event he you know there was no problem um our athletic director has appealed the decision and it went to the commission and they decided to stand with it they said regretfully we're sorry I there might be another appeal forthcoming um but this story has really picked up it was it was run in the home News Tribune and online and it's really picking up national attention uh because not just of of the story but the matachin swimmer uh Michael spark came

042to our high school and presented his first place medal uh to our swimmer to Rich and uh even though our swimmer did first turned it down he said no no no it's the rules and he didn't want to take it um the mouin swim swimmer really persisted you know with that and uh uh so he did accept it but it was that kind of Sportsman ship and you know good character if you will that that I think really speaks volumes uh for kids uh not only in ourish school but in other schools and I think that's uh really was very nice and it it seems to be picking up a lot of attention from um various news media Outlets both local and National so I just wanted to mention that um I also wanted to

043mention that we were fortunate to have Congressman congresswoman Bonnie Watson Coleman visit the oak tree school and uh our Union president president Karen custado was instrumental in in arranging that and she came to Oak Tree and she met with one of the classes for um a project they're doing the Valentine's for veterans where she visits various schools and the kids write Valentine's cards and they and she arranges to have them sent to our veterans and they uh you know definitely appreciate that uh she's also involved with a contest of of um naming a post office but the the the students in the classroom were excellent well prepared their questions were excellent they asked her about her experience in Washington in Congress uh what her day is like what what she does as a congresswoman um

044what it felt like to become a congresswoman uh the history where she got there and uh these were third grade students it was it it was impressive it was quite impressive so it was I was fortunate to be able to see that and um you know I just wanted to pass along that information to the board as well uh with that uh I would like to move to the Personnel section of the agenda okay it's item four Personnel um do I have a motion to approve uh items a through double coved thank you any discussion I think I heard a second second thank you Mr cman any discussion Mr Gorski thanks Personnel items a through CC Miss armeno yes Miss de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Miss Corino

045yes we acc's on Z so noted thank you Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr retsky yes Mr board president Personnel items a through CC has passed thank you uh board action item number five I have a motion to approve items a through n sove second thank you uh any discussion Corino yes I just wanted to discuss um number 189 and 190 the teen pep it's it's a teen pep um field trip it's considered and um I know a little bit about this program and there's uh some potential potentially like inappropriate um sexual teachings in this and I would like to make a motion we table this from the vote until the next meeting so that we could um better investigate this program and see if it meets you know the the morals and

046values of Monroe Township is there a second to miss corino's motion can we first find it in here where where is it located field trips I think it's um item C under what action it's it's concerning field trips but that's under background information yeah uh Miss corino's motion is a priority motion that must by parliamentary procedure go right to a roll call wait a minute so the motion to table is a priority motion yay would be uh to table and a would be to U pres conclude and um it would require the majority of the members present in order to be tabled Mr President I will uh make a roll call okay can does Dory have any input onto what the curriculum is that this is about that doesn't matter for a priority Mo we

047have to do the motion yeah the motion has to come first uh motion to table comes first so uh Mr Bo president and I will take a roll call this is a motion to table um per Miss corino's address Miss armeno yes Miss de Mayo no Mr calman no Mrs k panowich no Mr nosin no M Corino yes Mr Rybeck no Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky does this involve the high school believe that it does sir then I say n thank you Mr board president motion to table does not pass and then um the motion for board action items is back on the table okay SL again um do I have a motion to approve items on the board action a through N I think I think we have that already okay any any

048further yes Mr nottin um I'm just the reason I voted no to table is because I'd like to ask some questions about it before I vote on it so I don't I'm afraid if we tabled it we might have lost the window I don't know when this field trip is uh obviously it might be before our next meeting so that was why I voted no to table um can we please shed some light on this situation um someone the teen pep program is a program that was approved by the curriculum committee and the full board um the last curriculum revision was I believe November of this year um so the curriculum document is online it follows the standards the New Jersey standards for health and PE um which include um it it does include uh

049uh sexuality it includes lifestyle habits it does include um actions regarding sexual behavior that impact the health of oneself and others the teen pet program is a group of seniors this trip actually is to take place in May um this this trip is these seniors who have signed up to kind of become um the students who will be teaching the younger grades uh this content we've done it for the last couple of years so that the the students are work with um Mrs Dylan at the high school and Mrs volman at the high school um they're the teachers that teach the program they work with these students they develop lessons and then they present these lessons to the younger grades um kind of a peer-to-peer type thing uh sometimes students hear from um uh their

050peers better than they hear from adults and and that's the the premise of the program um it does include the sexuality aspects but it also includes um dealing with peer pressure dealing with stress there are about four lessons throughout the year that students are exposed to um and the curriculum is overseen by those two teachers that are doing the program so this this trip actually would just be their first meeting um they would be current Juniors so next year as seniors they would be presenting this program and this trip is a team building program working with the team pep program where is this trip to uh it's down near the shore thank you Spring Lake I know it was down near the shore thank you Dr Al any other [Music] question when you said that

051the students will are teaching younger students the uh subject matter are teachers in the room when they are teaching that subject matter yes and it f it follows the uh state New Jersey state standards so yes the teachers work with this I've actually observed both parts of the lesson um I've observed where the gym teachers are working with the seniors to prepare the lessons and then I've observed where um they go into the classroom into the um uh Auditorium and and they do the lessons with students there's a lot of role play that they've worked out with the teachers that's that's a lot of what it is um where kind of act out the scenes and how students could respond to it um but yes there are teachers present at all times and it's those

052students that are that are that are presenting it well what what kind of scenes do they act out um for example one of them could be um a a peer pressure type thing where students are um trying to get them to do something that they shouldn't be doing such as going to a party where there may be alcohol involved and how can students say no to that and what are ways that they can say no so that would be something that they may act out and there's the this has been going on a a while a couple years yes what is the is there uh any evidence that this is this this works I mean do we have any kind of I don't have any data about how it works um I am working right

053now with um Lieutenant Robinson um actually I met with Nick uh Mr thorney last week also with Lieutenant Robinson through the youth Advisory Group and that's another piece of it because that was the that was more of the alcohol awareness type thing going on so that's another piece of the program also is there any way that we are are recording EV you know the the results of this I mean how do you know that a program is working especially a program such as this I I guess this would be something where it would be more of a survey type thing or the the a decrease in the number of um issues happening you know I'm not sure if there's another way to really record that data thank you thank you so this gives students skills

054to deal with situations that they may be in that they in order to get out of these situations yes okay any other question and it comes from peers so it's kind that's kind of like a double um peers overseen by the adults yes okay so good Role Models yes okay thanks Mr Calin yeah two questions really um Michelle got all my other ones so thank you um have we had any issues from parents or students you said have been done for years have any issues or concerns or anything been raised by not that it's been brought to my attention no and it Mr Thorne is he like firsthand experience in this thing no he's working with the youth advisory council with the municipal with with with Municipal officials okay not to put you on the

055spot okay um okay no goody uh just to clarify my role is not with the team pep program um I met with lieutenant Robinson and uh Dr alvd about the youth advisory committee to the township which is also looking to do something about um you know alcohol awareness uh we're currently working with the high school about that to possibly um du like a uh a mock crash that would be conducted by the police department and the emergency services but that's not um through the team pet program corre thank you any other discussion Mr Corino Mr President um yes um the reason that this is an issue is it's been a controversy in a couple of other school districts because um parents in Monroe were not given any permission slips for their children to go to

056this and they are you know showing them how to put a condom on and they're showing that a solution is abortion and there are a lot of religious leaders in the towns that are having big issues with this and people who are faith-based families have issues with it um and and it's you know potentially inappropriate rated R type of um things and I I feel that a permission slip at the very least should be given a parent should be able you know it's it's the parents rights you know really it's their job to teach their child you know about sex the way that they want to and it's not really the public school's job to do that so at the very least the parents should have should give their permission for them to go to

057the Mr noin and Mr thne is um is that possible is it absolutely that would be so this isn't um uh a mandated course standards are mandated yes um but it's absolutely possible to give a permission slip for for parents to opt out of the of the program opt their child out of the program and what are your thoughts as as as the uh um assistant superintendent um we are required to follow these standards and and exactly what Miss Corina mentioned are in the standards so we are required to teach those standards as part of our ninth grade health curriculum um as a parent my in Robinsville uh my child actually went through the program last year um so for me as a parent not speaking as the assistant superintendent it was a positive um

058experience because it kind of opened the doors to some conversations that I wasn't didn't know that I needed to to be ready to have with my child um but you know I I can certainly understand you know the concerns of parents and and if if a a permission slip is needed I have absolutely no problem sending a permission slip home for this so so based on that how would we um Mr board president could we maybe find out if if if Miss Karina would be uh willing to accept that if we did at least go with the permission slip how how does she feel about that M I just want to clarify that I'm on the new jersey.gov website right now and this is not like a mandatory program you have to decide that you

059want to do it and in Middle sex County there's only six towns that are doing it there are many many counties in New Jersey that not one single town is doing this program because it is controversial so it's not like a mandated where the children teach other children about sex and you know in the way that they do on the stage and I and I just want to say that I actually say it myself so I'm not just you know speaking you know in the air so but I at the very least feel like I didn't get a permission slip and I know permission slips didn't go out because there was no there was nothing the whole entire class was sent to the um you oh you have an assembly today and they were sent

060down there so there wasn't there there weren't any like oh a teacher had to stay in the class for the kids who couldn't go no everybody went and so at the very least as a parent I would want to know what the program was and give my permission for my 14-year-old they are they are it's Juniors and seniors that are doing it and they're targeting the freshman and sophomore so you have a kid that just leaves middle school that's barely 14 maybe was just 13 barely 14 now going into the school and learning you know how to put a condom on and learning that if you know it's I felt when I was watching I felt like it's you know we tell our kids not to do drugs so we but we wouldn't put on

061a show for them and say look we know you're going to do the drugs anyway so here's how to do them so you don't overdose so like I felt like the program was just almost accepting that we know you're going to have sex so here's how you do it so you don't get pregnant and you don't get STDs and that was just how I felt about it thank you Mr thorney and then I'll I'll have a thought um I I certainly sympathize with the concerns that Miss Kino brought up if that's something you know the board might want to uh look into with the permission slip um you know I wasn't in the the teen pep program but uh they did come and present it before the different um health and gym classes and in

062my experience at least the I don't and I I talk to a um I don't think that they presented any of the scenarios that Miss Karina was describing I don't know if that's something they may they might do in other schools I think there was a different program that addressed some of that but um at least in my experience um they it was just more of um a basic presentation about like what uh Dr Auber said about making uh good choices saying no to drugs saying no to peer pressure um and stuff like that and you know if uh the the matter at hand it seems is not about the the program itself but about the field trip which consists of students who uh opted to be part of that team pep program which means

063um odds are their parents already signed off for them to be in the class so uh let me just ask um M Dr Ric I'm sorry and Dr kak would it be possible even looking in the future to make sure that we have permission lips to opt out of of anything like this so we make sure that absolutely we currently do that with our fifth grade um Health curriculum because that's the introduction to the reproduction systems um and we currently send home letters to parents uh with a link to our our health curriculum that includes that so I don't see that as being an issue um with doing that for this program okay thank you any other questions concerns Mr calman um why don't we get permission slips for every field trip at every grade

064level I I don't think that's the question that's at hand I think no I know I'm just asking we do get we do do permission slips for every field trip okay yeah okay that's what this is field trip right this is this is different the field trip is for the students who will be presenting the program next year um for their orientation and their team building um but yeah we absolutely do field trips for every single field trip permission slips for every single field trip okay so for clarification we're talking about giving um permission slips for the people to attend the assembly not for the field trip is is that what we're talking about that's my understanding any other question to comment one last thing um I know there's a challenge day that we do

065in a school and it's actually like a wonderful anti-bullying love one another kind of thing I was bombarded and bombarded with permission slip the permission slips are due emails oh they're due in three days they're due constant constant you know get us the permission for challenge day and I just thought to myself it's such a wonderful thing and we're we really need these permission slips but then you can show the children something like this and the parents have have no idea what their children are seeing I just thank you okay seeing no other questions uh let's go right to the vote this is I'm sorry to approve items a through n correct Miss armeno yes Miss de Mayo yes on everything no on G so noted thank you Mr calman yes Mrs Cole Pano yes

066Mr noin yes and I recuse on item F asent Francis so noted Miss Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky I abstain thank you sir Mr board president board action items a through n has passed thank you uh now we have our business administrator's report back to thank [Music] you Mr board president members of the Monro Township Board of Education I would just like to thank a moment uh take a moment on behalf of Dr kak and sincerely thank Mr Paul rutsky and Mr Tom nosin and also from Jamesburg Mr Rob zareski uh their superintendent Betts and business administrator Brooks and yourself Mr board president for your time and productivity today at our meeting for our tuition agreement um it it's a complex agreement and we're all worked toward the common

067goal of reducing the aage and I believe that we're on the right track um I think we all as Mr noin said we see um the the the strong potential yield of the agreement in then the term that it's provided and um it was a very encouraging meeting today so Mr board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through J be approved by consent roll call some move second discussion any discussion any questions Miss armeno yes Miss Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes recuse on F again thank you Miss Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky so I abstain with the exception of item a number six and seven I say yes and then

068items Z and G where I vote Yes a six and seven d and j yes sir thank you Mr board president that concludes my report thank you thank you uh now we can move to the board president's report um I first of all want to just reiterate my my gratitude to the uh Diamond Club for its contributions every year not only this year but last year I think they contributed or raised over $220,000 um we have a lot of great clubs that help us out and do great things for our students and I think they all have to be uh acknowledged certainly I'd like to start with the Diamond Club so thank you very much on Tuesday I was very fortunate to be invited to the high school to um participate in Mr Snow's design

069development engineering class where I saw projects students developed projects that were just incredible to me um I think uh we have Mark Zuckerberg's in the making uh at at at Monro Township High School um it was just incredible and uh the way they presented their thought their really understanding of of the business end of it I think it's uh really an incredible uh demonstration of integration of curricular and and and the benefit of of a project driven instruction uh and uh I think all of us uh should be very proud of of uh what's going on in all our schools but what I saw yesterday was just incredible um Monro Township High School Model United Nations team under the advised leadership of Mr Joe Romano earned the distinction of outstanding delegation for contributions and conduct

070at the 2015 2016 annual model un conference a special congratulations to Jason Delina Karina thala Amy Williamson Sharina Park our own Nicholas thorney and iav ready for winning multiple Awards it's a uh a wonderful thing to be able to uh note these accomplishments um let me see uh we we mentioned the student uh growth advisory committee uh I just uh want to stress the the um the commitment to to the uh uh task at hand and the work ethic that they all uh demonstrated it's really a pleasure to participate in this and uh and see us as Mr Mayo said coming to A finalization it's it's coming together and I think that uh it'll it'll serve to benefit our our entire Community okay uh I think now we're ready for um our next public forum

071I'm sorry other the board business I thank you I have a few things okay um on Monday I was invited by the state New Jersey State Board of Ed to give input into the state board's strategic Five-Year Plan um I felt honored to be asked to participate in this I gave gave a lot of thought of how I would like to see education proceed in New Jersey not just in Monroe but for the whole entire State and when I thought about education and this was part of my talk that I gave to the State Board my first discussion was about funding because without funding a district can't grow and we've had flat funding for seven years um in addition our state budget our budget not our state budget our budget is being eroded by forces

072beyond our control um number one is the flat funding we've had for seven years unfunded mandates and I pointed out to the board that the largest unfunded mandate that we've had in SE the past several years is the park um I've gave them specific examples such as you know Newark had to spend $5 million on new laptops kennworth had to spend $10,000 on substitutes for the park um and Charter Schools I talked about how hatia is affecting our school as well as other districts um around us and I also explained to them how the growth in Monroe and the flat funding is making us making it um challenging to deliver our high quality education um as a result of this erosion I told them we are seeing more crowded schol schools and larger classrooms and

073I know that we're not the only District in this situation um I and then when I talked about what I'd like to see as education I talked about you know authentic instruction and smaller class R rooms and classrooms and educating the whole child I felt those need to be the forces that drive public education in New Jersey um and I also told them that um the one thing that they don't have when they talk about education in New Jersey is giving children the Lifelong Love of learning which I feel is missing when we talk about College and Career Readiness um and I feel that's one of the G greatest gifts we can give children they were very receptive to my ideas and um it was an honor to be invited my second thing that I

074wanted to talk about is um I contacted Senator Greenstein and asked her to reach out to commissioner hesie about Tia charter school I sent her an email outlining how much we are spending on it how much the other school districts in her legislative district are spending on it um and she was very receptive to my request she contacted commissioner hesie she shared my email with him and agreed that the charter school should not be granted the additional seats he said he was just beginning to look at this and not had made a decision and he was open to talking to her in the future and that's it thank you thank you any other board member uh I have uh something that I want to finish it has to do with h board goal number three

075which is the review of the board committee organization and structure process um I think that we've naturally just by working together have U worked out any scheduled problems I know that uh um some uh committee chairs work together so that we we limit the number of nights a week that we're spend spending uh doing committee work uh so that's working out the time factor is is another factor that U I ask committee chairs to be cognizant of their agenda so that uh if they need more time maybe they could work that out especially if there's another committee waiting to come in or they can uh take the last spot uh Communications between committees have uh thank you Dr kosak for this because uh because of Google Drive we can now go on and see what

076each committee discussed so it makes our awareness of what's Happening uh that much greater uh anybody else want to share any ideas uh for um uh board goal number three Mr norstein um yeah I was just wondering I I know I learned actually at a meeting today that the Jamesburg Board of Ed is now decided to go to a committee of the whole I think that's an accurate assessment and I would love for going forward if uh maybe Mr Rus could uh report back to this board and let him know what uh Pro or uh negative or positive aspects of that decision I think that would be pretty interesting I certainly welcome that but I I just like to say uh Mr nin that it's been my experience as an educator for many years that

077uh usually a committee of a whole works best with small districts such as Jamesburg but when you have a district our size uh it could lead to extremely long meetings and um not not as efficient as as what we're we're experiencing so I sort of want to caution you on that and certainly you know we're always welcoming new ideas and always looking to improve and um I look forward to what you have to say yes you want to say something now sure well sure I'd be uh once we get there I'll be happy to report back if it's an improvement over last year's committee versus this year as a whole um there were thoughts at the end of last year's budget process that not every not everybody knew everything and that's not obviously uncommon when

078you have committees because that's why you have committees and then it's their job to then come forward and report that to the rest of the board and it just because we're small I think we're going to give this a try to be a committee of a whole as far as the budget for everything else we are a committee of the whole it's only on budget that we've now made this change and so we're just starting tomorrow basically in that endeavor and so once we get through this I'll be happy to let you know if I think it was uh time well spent better use of time um then when we were a committee I'll definitely report back on that thank you anybody else quick question how many committees do you guys have well they a

079committee of the whole again we're a committee of the whole so in the past you had separate committees right just budget and finance okay that was it everything else policy or what have you it's all of the whole how many we have five six seven five or that operate on a fairly regular basis I believe yeah the fin five five yeah five just doing the math in my head so that's five minimally five hours added to board meetings okay just curious okay yeah so we I maybe it's a luxury but yeah as a small town we get we get to sort of do everything as the whole at the meeting or leading up to the meeting and Mr no I think another concern is I think on our um our policy I think we actually

080list uh all the Committees and one of them is a legislative committee I think that we may need to present that to policy either we you know follow the policy or we change it and I think I absolutely agree time to change it if you would take that up as an agenda item um Mr calman I just want you commented about five hours um looking at it with a number of committees I I can see where you say that but uh uh you have to look at you know the effectiveness of of a meeting five hour meetings can can sort of wear wear somebody down um and I think uh when you break up with into smaller committees especially when you have uh the kinds of uh uh items that we have and the number

081of items that they have that have to be discussed uh it it really is more effective and as long as we're now able to communicate better between between committees I think that's a key factor something we have to consider anything else for the board business okay uh next is a public forum which is U um not U necessarily pertaining to the agenda do we have anybody in the public that would like to come up Mr poy PO for tamarak Road uh I'm speaking in reference to the uh sports related concussions and head injuries uh I think the board approved a regul uh tonight uh there's obviously a policy already U approved um my concern is that I don't believe the regulation calls for any kind of reporting uh to the board in terms of how

082many concussions our students uh experience during the course of the year and do we have any students that uh experience multiple concussions uh I think that's important information for the board to have uh the public uh myself in particular but I think the public at large has become much more aware of the permanent damage that concussion does to a person's life somewhere down the road and I think it would be beneficial since it's at the high school level that we have concussions occurring that uh the board get an annual report on the number of concussions experienced by our students and also multiple concussions experienced by individual students uh so that we can see whether or not we're doing all that we can do and whether or not uh that policy or regulations needs to be

083revamped uh possibly even considering uh after X number of concussions to a particular individual that that individual uh not be allowed to continue in that sport for the remainder of the year uh but that would depend upon medical advice we all know how much coaches want their athletes to play particularly if they're a good athlete we all know how much parents want their child athlete to play uh but I think the board has the role of making sure that we protect the student uh protect the student in uh against uh an overly ambitious coach or a parent who is maybe not as aware as they should be about the danger of concussions to their children thank you thank you Mr P anybody else from the public seeing no one we'll move through our close session

084resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of Township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the sunsh Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 and JSA 1046 through 10421 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying following close session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists moved second any discussion in oh in favor I I's opposed we know how long it's going to be yes about 45 minutes to an hour anyone from the public want to address the board concerning the uh Clos session seeing no seeing no one um the next scheduled meeting uh of our board of education is Wednesday March 16th at

0857 pm right here in the high school and then we have adjournment do I have a motion second any discussion I all in favor we're jour thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.