CorpusRecord 132962

Monroe Township Board of Education 04.27.16 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
15,569 words · about 87 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001just stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you Mr Gorski we have a roll call I didn't think to call CU I changed my call Miss armenio yes here Mr Braverman Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman here Mrs kapano here Mr noin here Mrs Corino here Mr Ryback here Mr Russo here and Mr rutsky here board president you have a quarum present this [Music] evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted April 22nd 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you and now we can have our student

002board members report okay so the first thing I have is uh earlier in the month a bunch of students went on the youth and went to the youth and government New Jersey conference uh this year Monroe did really well we won the Premier delegation award which is uh awarded to the delegation that uh submits all of their assignments on time and over all just acts well during the conference uh a lot of students got their bill bills passed at the conference we even had one student win an award for having an outstandingly written legislation and we had one group uh one courts group that won outstanding brief and a lot of students also were nominated for the Kona summer internship program which is affiliated with youth in government uh there's a Deca conference going on

003this week which is what Nick is at and he said he would speak more about it at the next meeting when he's back uh high school students are gearing up for AP exams in the next 2 weeks and those are going to be held uh for the next two weeks in the high school in the morning and afternoon um girls and boy State delegates have been chosen in the high school it's a summer program that encourages Civic engagement and it's held at Ryder University and if you want to read about that it's in the high school's College and Career counseling Center's main newsletter and the last thing I have is that the drama club spring musical has its open show tomorrow right here in the high school so I think you should all go try

004to go to that that concludes our report thank you very much uh now we have our a water testing presentation by Dr Richard Lynch and I I'd like to thank Mr Lynch for coming here personally to present his findings thank you good evening Board of Education it's uh it's been my uh sincere pleasure to support the mission of this District over the years with your air quality and water quality related issues and it's a pleasure to be able to present this to you this evening as as everyone is aware the Flint Michigan crisis sort of got people very interested recently in the quality of water and shortly thereafter a district in northern Jersey found that they had some pretty severe water contamination problems with respect to lead once that was uh determined to be the

005case uh the Monroe Township Board of Education decided to do a screening for water quality here within the district and in mid-march the uh Monroe township utilities department arranged for some samples to be collected from sort of random places throughout all of the schools and the board also authorized my firm environmental Safety Management Corp operation to also collect uh samples throughout the district the uh the Utilities Authority results came back largely no uh uh no lead detected in any of the samples the action limit the New Jersey and federal action limit for lead and water is 15 parts per billion and the great majority of the samples that they collected Were Far Below that or non-detectable they found one sample that was above it and um that was actually labeled to be in a faculty

006room over at Applegarth unaware of those results because those results weren't available we also collected samples throughout the district our plan was to collect samples not sort of random randomly but more in accordance with the EPA protocol for lead sampling and our sampling included uh sort of the closest place where the water was coming into the building initially as well as in the uh the kitchens where food preparation is occurring the sink that it's used for food preparation and we chose to also sample the most commonly used water fountains in the schools as sort of our sort of standardized sampling approach uh none of the drinking water samples or kitchen samples came back with any elevations above the action limit uh for lead in three of the schools the the old Boiler Room utility sinks

007that hadn't been changed since who knows when our initial a couple of our samples show some slight elevations just above the action limit but those did not represent any risk to to uh to Le exposure because those are not used for consumption by students they're used um by custodians and maintenance persons for you know utility use they presented no risk we presented those results to the district and as a as a matter of caution the facilities Department arranged to have those uh fixtures in those in in those older utility areas replaced which is certainly a a good precaution no risk there we then uh uh another thing that the uh that the facilities Department did was they replaced the the uh faucet in the Applegarth faculty room which had been labeled as showing high levels

008of lead U I examined that faucet and it was my opinion that that was very likely a labeling error made on the part of the uh of of of the of the of the utility department what we actually think is that they mislabeled that sample for the sample collected from the abandoned wood shop utility sync that they also collected in Applegarth which probably hasn't been used in years and any water the first draw sample that would have been pulled out of there would have been sitting in those pipes for literally years and so that kind of explained the uh the the higher than expected result in that location we made a recommendation that that sink uh so we went back and sampled that sink and in fact found that that sink had higher levels we

009made a recommendation that that sink be taken out of PL out of service until such time that those old faucets can also be replaced and there are special order uh so they'll be I I I I know they're being replaced I'm not sure if that's occurred yet because they're kind of hard to get so in summary uh the air the water quality in the Monro Township Schools from all indications is excellent uh it's it's my professional opinion that there's no risk for elevated uh lead in water from fountains from kitchen sinks and even coming into the building and even in utility rooms anyone who would drink from a utility sink uh I I wonder who that would be but we've gone ahead and uh change those anyway so uh that's my report I see no

010risk for for elevated lead levels and I'd like to open up to any questions that you may have Dr Li I was very confident to hear and you know safety for the students and the staff is out in this district and um I think on behalf of the board we're all uh glad we contracted you to do this and especially to get the results we getting I am going to open the uh floor up for questions or comments from the board and then the public so would anybody in the board like to have a question Mr noin um thank you very much for the for your report I just have some questions is there any um any type of a PM that's required or that you would recommend with your expertise going forward to maybe

011flush uh you know the water system periodically or put that on the the maintenance PM schedule for yearly or whatever basis thanks for the question uh there there's there's there are some general guidelines that people suggest that schools follow just as you would follow in your home the main uh recommendation that the EPA makes is you know after water has been sitting you know for 6 or eight hours that first flush you might want to let it run for 15 to 30 seconds until it gets cold what that does is that flushes any of the uh any of the sediment that may have sort of leeched out of the out of the pipes into the water and goes down the drain before you actually would put a glass under it to to drink that recommendation

012is one that uh they also make for schools uh there's not a broad-based recommendation for a of any periodic flushing or or or you know equipment that requires filtration unless you decide that you want to you want to take extra steps or if there's reason to do so but the main recommendation that the EPA recommends is an initial flush and of course they also always recommend that you never and this is true of your home as well and having been involved in a lot of cases where you have hot water heater failures and things I will reiterate the recommendation you never ever ever ever cook with hot water uh because the sediment that accumulates inside of hot water heaters and the chemistry that happens because of the heat causes metals to leak to leech out

013of the the metal container and it sort of settles in the bottom of those containers you get a lot of sediment and lots of metals from hot water sources so as a rule you always cook and drink uh or consume from the cold water side even if you have to heat the water up you don't get a head start by starting with hot water but broadly I would say the same precautions that you would take at home especially here in a district like Monroe your infrastructure is not that old you know the the your water I I reviewed uh the Monroe Township utility Department's annual water testing report your water actually comes from aquifers that are sort of ground water aqu aquafers and 10% of it comes from um um American uh water you don't

014have old pipes that you would expect to see the kinds of problems that we saw in North Jersey uh or even in Flint Michigan so normal precautions would apply and is there any um recommendation for periodic testing every five years every 10 years what would your expert there's no rule uh the the rule is that the utility department has to test water on a periodic basis and it depends and that frequency depends on the kinds of results that they're getting here in Monroe Township they are uh because of the excellent history of results that they've that they've collected over the years they are on a three-year testing cycle at what they call tier one locations throughout the district and those would be the older properties and they have their last report actually was dated in

0152013 and they're coming up on their next cycle of threeyear tests um that's to make sure that the water that they deliver uh is clean and I reviewed their test results and they're great so um you know districts you know I I would say that districts that are in higher sort of risk areas might take on a program of more periodic testing uh but what I would recommend is that if there are observations odors discolored water or other things that would make you suspect that there may be a problem uh let facilities know about it and Facilities can kind of arrange to make sure that that's evaluated uh and I think that that's a reasonable approach okay thank you if you see something say something in other words yes than you anyone else from the

016board Miss arminia thank thank you Mr Lynch um my question is did you test for anything else other than lead we did not so it was just that's what you were looking for we were specifically looking we were specifically looking for lead um uh some districts and and this sort of goes back to the answer to the previous question we've seen in some districts where they have brown water like sometimes you'll get brown water coming out of a faucet and that's the kind of thing that can make people concerned it might be the kind of thing that would suggest asking a question sometimes you get brown water because the the the municipality is Flushing hydrants and they're disturbing the bofilm and the and and and and other sediment that may be in the pipes sometimes

017you get brown water because you actually get leeching of iron which is not a primary water contaminant meaning it doesn't have health effects associated with it but it has aesthetic effects when we see that we'll we'll test for lead but we'll also test for iron and a couple of other things maybe even manganese because those are typically associated with discolored water uh in this case uh given the results that uh that that were available from the utility department that indicated that you know the levels of microorganisms that they're sending to us are are fine and all the other sort of primary constituents given the current concerns we focused on lead has the EPA raised the levels though recently for for lead consumption I know sometimes they change what what is um acceptable or not well

018they they've not changed they've not changed the the levels for lead consumption but but over since I since I was working on my doctorate degree I've seen that they've lowered the recommendation for blood lead levels in children that would suggest followup evaluations from their Physicians down to 10 um uh micrograms per deciliter of blood that that level has lowered maybe over the last decade that's an improvement yeah that's it's the opposite that concerns me sometimes when they they raise a level of um concentration yeah they say it's it's no longer as as problematic as we used to think that happens uh in a lot of regulatory uh settings um the action limit but the action limit for L as far as I'm as far as I can recall has not been stillo 15 parts per

019billion thank you anyone else question Ry hi so if I understood correctly 15 parts per million billion billion 15 parts per billion it's a about more so that's the area of concern is there an average number you could say that we our scores came in at uh so we know how close we were or how far away we are uh most of yours were less than three okay non detectable gotcha non-detectable on some of the uh utility syns we were get we got some numbers that were in the neighborhood of five or so five to six um you know on initial on the initial draw sample but then on the flush it it it went away in other districts and it depends on where you are in the state and sort of where the water

020comes from and how how corrosive the water is it's common I've SE commonly I see levels in in in buildings that don't have a problem of even five not just the first draw but even the flush samples so here your data your data look great okay thank you very much any other board member have a question I'll open the floor up to the public just remind anyone from the public wishing to make a comment or have ask a question that you'll have three minutes to do so and if you come up just state your name and address anyone from the public wishing Dan ask question not seeing anyone we could move on um a short time ago we asked Dr kosak to update thank you Dr Lynch thank you thank you I'm sorry thank you

021Dr Lynch we ask Dr kosak to uh update our strategic plan and I know he's ready to do so right now I'll turn it over to all right thank you Mr President on the board of education uh I was tasked with um providing an update to the Monroe Township strategic plan which spans a period of 5 years and uh the nice thing about Google Docs is we work with our leadership team and uh we each took different sections and looked at it as a team and uh we worked on it together and and I'm going to go through the results for everyone right now so there are five goals the five goals uh first one is curriculum and instruction the second one is community engagement SL bus Partnerships the third is finance and Facilities technology

022in the Arts is the fourth and Communications is the fifth within each goal there are activities uh and what you see across the chart is it's basically an action plan so you see the staff the resources the constraints the timelines and indicators of success the very last column on your right the status update April 2016 is what uh the the annual progress is for this year so the first area is to was to audit current curriculum documents to determine updates as required this is curriculum docu documents uh the audit for the school year 1516 has been completed all documents up for for revision have been identified and will be revised of this during the summer and the curriculum office will be implementing the atlas curriculum mapping system beginning in the summer of 2016 which will

023make uh tracking all the curriculum curricula and revision so much easier so much better second area to Prov provide teachers with Shar a shared file for each curriculum to enable sharing of best practices shared files for Content areas are present in Google Drive they're created collaboratively uh with teachers they're shared during professional development session and collaborative planning meetings and materials and resources uh reviewed or are reviewed on an ongoing basis by content supervisors and building leadership the next activity is requiring lesson plans to include evidence of use of available technology to improve learning and differenti differentiation of instruction um that's done I mean as you can see in the column there the lesson plans are collected they're done online uh certainly having the on toone initiative with the high school certainly helps that we use

024Google Apps for Education also and trainings are provided through the 15 and 16th school year a standards based report card which our curriculum committee just um heard about tonight uh is included and trainings also for K to3 teachers our Park assessment samples are uh distributed to all staff and they are aligned to the common core and uh into the common core and our year-long PD courses are aligned to the common core and Core Curriculum standards to uh next section is provide teachers and administrators with ongoing professional development on the common core standards the all the staff from K to 12 receive ongoing professional development to facilitate infusion of mandated Next Generation science standards and the stem which is the science technology engineering and math and steam which includes the Arts initiative districtwide second objective with

025that is to integrate character education prek to2 to develop positive personal growth at school at home and in the community at large first activity was is to develop and Implement a program to recognize students who demonstrate good character and make responsible choices in personal Behavior our ongoing character education programs uh conducted in all the schools including week of respect assemblies classroom lessons challenge day Rachel's Challenge uh random acts of kindness programs are at the schools we have senior Awards uh we have self- assessment grades and uh one student at each grade level is recognized by the Monroe Township human relations commission with a character award second activity of that objective was to develop a character education program that teaches basic social behaviors that are developmentally appropriate and are reinforced systematically every school has a comprehensive

026Hib training which is harassment intimidation and bullying uh they have that training program for staff the students are informed the lessons and programs through our school schoolwide character education programs and um which are implemented and provided throughout the year the next activity was solicit parental expectations regarding the development of character education parents are solicited and actively involved via School committees orientations and programs and app parents are aware of the HIV process in the second to the right column you see a lot of the U ways that this is accomplished our schools go school goals committee school safety Teams Parent organizations back to school nights parent assemblies so you can look at both columns for really evidence of how these goals and objectives are being completed and lastly in this section communicate effectively or uh yeah

027effectively behavioral expectations for students to parents and community and Community me Members excuse me parents are made uh via assigned code of conduct which is uh done for every school and the availability of such on every School website part of the character education program provide appropriate opportunities to bring community members and parents into the school as volunteers as role models we have uh actually in the spring the mayor in the Town Council awards for good character the police and doctors um visit the school we have senior citizen Rave readers we have read Across America which just recently occurred we had V members we had uh the mayor and members of the community different parents coming in we have Multicultural assemblies celebrations and also career days takes us to number to goal number two which is

028community engagement and Business Partnership first activity was to convene a committee to work and collaborate on identifying Community Resources create a guide to assist in working with local businesses enabling identification of friend of the district who would be willing to provide opportunities such as career internships financial resources or other experiences the resource guy was completed and is available the guy will be updated annually the high school students are placed in a work study uh which are paid and non-paid internships they have job shadowing there are structured learning experiences and community service for um through our senior option program and in the column I won't read through the whole column but if you look right to the left of that it it really goes into much more detail of the different resources that are available the

029next section was to develop mechanisms to create symbiotic relationships between businesses in the district that would encourage and support their involvement in educational programs providing scholarships and support for other student entrepreneurial Endeavors students have provided scholarships from local businesses and and organizations students have created signs actually today uh the mayor visited the high school and I was there and our uh grapics art Department Dr har yes uh created a sign for the historical society which will be placed with and it's a replica will be placed with the one School uh or one room Schoolhouse uh in town so it's pretty exciting they are involved in the community with that and uh internships are provided by the local businesses and organizations for our students we're currently investigating strategies for engaging our alumni to create networks for

030our students highlighting their successes and possibly supporting the students through scholarships so we want to build that the Alumni network and get them uh get the you know prior students to get involved and uh either offer technical expertise in their careers or you know possible Financial incentives for the students next area was to continue to strengthen relationships with established Partners such as Monroe Township Public Library the shade tree commission and the Monroe Township environmental commission the township uh envirom mobile and the township Firehouse trailer visit schools and provide instructions to elementary students the Monroe Township Library collaborates with several elementary schools in database instruction and Library nights and our Monroe Township Library also offers Consulting Services as it relates to literature recommendations for special projects and summer reading programs we also have collaborations with the

031annual Arbor Day celebration Sustainable New Jersey Grant which we receive two this year our township Green Fair School Gardens envir Environ envirom mobile sorry uh and our Ruckers University um summer Institute for scientific research goal number three finance and facilities and and after this presentation you'll hear a very good report from Mr Gorski on our finances and our budget uh this the first major activity was to identify the scope and the specifics of information needed to be conveyed fixed cost cost comparisons cost drivers categorial spending tax rate analysis and additions SL deletions to the budget the district has produced a budget that is near final approval which will happen hopefully tonight which has received more public uh accolades and has been recognized by the county for many best practices unlike any time in the last

032decade planning and the successful efforts of the business administrator to create efficiencies was largely responsible for the unique creation of a surplus which supplanted the need to raise taxes by $600,000 the next section is to develop an annual budget calendar to ensure transparency convene an annual budget steering committee in September of each year of of um the representative stakeholders the budget calendar is complete and was largely in part responsible for the increased public interest in the budget budget process new this year was a portal to immediately answer the Public's questions about the budget and uh lastly in this area to determine what media to use for communicating financial information we do that through our website our Public Presentation committee uh and committee presentations next area to was to or was to uh conduct an assessment

033to establish priorities for maintenance and upkeep to both buildings and grounds this year we included a project uh project costing over a million dollars in the 1617 budget to replace the Woodland roof and we are well into a student growth advisory committee to plan for future facility needs based on our enrollment growth and or also our degrading facilities next area is to establish and Implement a schedule of needed maintenance for all buildings and grounds and to provide Financial Resources to adhere to the schedule a job order process is in place for staff to request minor repairs and improvements to facilities and is mentioned um in the above subject of the facilities meeting the demands for an increasing student body which is as mentioned being studied by the student growth committee the next area is to

034conduct a space audit to identify all usable classroom space in each of the buildings to ensure Optimum utilization of all available spaces and this is being studied currently as part of the student growth advisory committee go fours technology and the Arts our first activity in that section was to develop an inventory and assess needs at the building level the elementary iPad inventory was conducted in December of 14 a complete inventory was completed and submitted to the assistant superintendent in April of 2015 and an ongoing inventory is maintained by the technology staff next area is to uh was to identify prog programmatic needs for virtual learning environments classroom instruction and park assessments uh interestingly again something that was mentioned tonight in the curriculum committee parked information provided via multiple methods includes video presentations by the assistant

035superintendent and content supervisors parent information nights throughout the year prior to park and the website is updated regularly Google Drive and Google Classroom training opportunities uh through District professional development have been offered professional development opportunities for teachers in the virtual learning environment genre including flip classrooms Google Apps for Education and iPads have been has significantly incre increased for this year 2016 and or 17 for next year I'm sorry and Chromebooks have been purchased for utilization at the elementary level next area is to identify a protocol for refreshing and protecting District digital equipment including iPad learning tools there's an apple refresh at the high school that took place in the summer and this past fall or will this fall coming up and some Chrome Chromebooks were purchased for the elementary level next area is to assess

036Community needs for technological related Services student interns student created products is a revenue source and providing practical real life experiences we had a constraint with this area to you know there's legal and tax implications when you get into students producing things and selling it outside of school so it is limited with what we can do with that um but we do have uh some collaboration as I mentioned with our town historian uh for projects that uh we can do next area is to assess current Arts programs at the building level identify areas programs to expand in both fine and Performing Arts such as instrumental theater uh theater Graphics audio and visual design the K12 art and music programs utilize iPads and computers with programs such as Artsonia to create digital portfolios and video technology to

037enhance reflection of performance-based Assessments it is amazing walking through the school and going into some of the classrooms and seeing what the students are capable of doing and how well prepared those students will be no matter what field they go into but especially any students that are going into the digital media field and graphic arts TV production uh really it's they get an excellent education in that area and lastly communication goal number five first first activity was to create an online survey survey for all target groups to solicit feedback on educational programs hot topics and to the best means and find the best means to communicate effectively parent student and teacher surveys were completed for cluster the cluster grouping pilot and this program is now integrated into our instructional program next area was to create

038flexible focus groups that are representative of the various constituency constituencies in our community the superintendent uh myself has been meeting with the PTO PTA presidents the senior community groups along with our board president the League of Women Voters student Liaisons and other groups our student growth advisory committee which is comprised of Representatives of the various constituencies in the community has been meeting monthly the next area was to create opportunities for interactive communication venues through the use of Technology including Skype TV hotlines etc for focus groups technology such as Facebook Twitter Constant Contact and webites are used for interactive communication another area was to develop Town Hall meetings a town hall meeting model for in-person input for focus group and key communicators and our student growth advisory committee I think is a is an excellent example

039of that uh it is in a town hall format where um you know we we are receiving input from uh various stakeholders throughout the community and that group or some version of that group will most likely continue into the summer and fall and winter of next year and Town Hall formats are certainly uh slated on they're on the agenda for that the itinerary for that under objective two to update the alert nail system to reflect parental preferences regarding best the best number to contact uh to contact them the preferred methods of communication this is done annually our online updates are still being investigated school and District highlights broadcasted on a reg regular schedule through local cable channel of uh the njaa classroom Focus uh for us we use the Channel 28 and other sources such

040as the Falcon flyer the Falcon Express Facebook and Twitter uh to broadcast school and District highlights each school also maintains a digital format such as an e-newsletter Twitter and Facebook um also for communicating their highlights and I believe this is the last block here to explore utilizing social media such as Facebook and Twitter as a viable option for the district and to create an electronic newsletter to communicate school and District news and I think basically what I just said has met that so I would like to uh just commend the board for its uh Vision uh when you created the Strategic plan uh although I wasn't here I I you know read about it the the history of this and the collaborative process that was used with the community and I think it's a an

041excellent document and uh the board certainly uh showed its wisdom in creating this document so that concludes my report Mr President thank you Dr kosac uh does any board member have a question for Dr kosac concerning the plan yes Mr n uh nice job Dr kak uh looks like a lot of effort and a lot of thought uh went into achieving uh the results I just had a question um before I find it on uh goal one OB object objective two item two to develop a character educ education program um I I know that you're a data driven person and I I I respect that and I I I am also um under the indicators of success yes I would like to have seen and I know that um I'm sure that you didn't even

042make that up but I think that was lacking in that it would have been nice to see some sort of data to see if our uh HIV cases are actually in fact decreasing I see that one of the things on here one of the items is an annual state anti-bullying grade is that reflective of the amount of Hib instance yes so uh let me answer you you mentioned a couple things first you right it did not have anything to do with the indicator of success because that was done a few years ago the Hib um grade from the state is looks at all the information do we train everyone do we provide proper training for staff for parents for volunteers uh are the number of cases reported have there been an increase or decrease so

043we have been scoring very well on that it's an annual report that the state uh puts out uh there's a very much of a self-reflective process involved in that and I agree with the data is very very important we have now this year we just purchased and are using uh a program called hipster and you're familiar with it the board is familiar with it because other that's the program that I draw the reports uh that I rep that I bring to you and I report to you every single board meeting on any HIV cases and I did run a report uh just for repeat offenders that I was going to share with the board um in close session it was a question that was asked before we have very few repeat offenders uh for HIV

044in fact we have two repeat two students that were identified as repeat offenders and one was only for two cases the other one I think was three or four um and repeat victims one and that in in of itself is a pretty good indicator of the environment that's that's created uh we can easily run a report over the past couple years to see where we are with with the HIV uh the number of HIV cases reported the last I looked we are on a steady decline um you know are we ever going to eradicate all bullying in HIV probably not because it'll show up in different forms but I feel that by educating students parents um and you know anyone we can that we will constantly uh create a a a safe learning environment for

045students and when we when issues do arise we look at not only uh punitive measures to address what's been done but we look in a very proactive measure and say are our programs sufficient can we improve our programs can we create a better environment so it's a systems approach it's an ongoing approach excellent thank you very much thank you anybody else okay not seeing one we can move on um Dr kak mentioned that our last uh board meeting we had a very positive preliminary uh budget presentation for which we we thanked Mr Gorski and the finance committee it's now my pleasure to turn the mic over to Mr Gorski for the uh public budget hearing thank you Mr Rybeck for disclosure purposes the order that will do the um budget presentation and the resolution will

046be as follows um first we're going to start with a quick PowerPoint presentation which largely remains on change from the preliminary budget which is posted on our website I will then read a resolution followed by board deliberation on the resolution and then we will turn it over to a public forum for comments and questions on the Budget prior to the board's vote so on behalf of Dr kak superintendent of schools Dr Dory alvik assistant superintendent and myself we would like to welcome you to this year's final budget presentation of the Monro Township's Board of Education members of the Board of Education include president Mr Steven Ryback vice president and finance chair Mr Tom noin Mrs Michelle armino Mr Marvin Braverman Miss Jill Deo Mr Luke cman Mrs Kathy kapano Miss Don Corino Mr Frank Russo

047and our Jamesburg representative Mr Paul rutsky the finance committee which was very instrumental in the design and challenge that Administration was given to produce this year's budget consists of chairperson Mr Tom noin Vice chairperson Mr Luke halman Mrs Kathy kapano Miss Don karino and an alternate of Miss Michelle armeno vision statement of the district monor Township Board of Education commits itself to all children by preparing them to reach their full potential and to function in a global Society through a preeminent education the mission statement is the Monro Township Public Schools in collaboration with the members of the community shall ensure that all children receive an exemplary education by well-trained committed staff in a safe and orderly environment the district goals were established um at around the same time that board philosophy was last October and

048you could see those three District goals here they are also posted on our website and throughout the District board goals and the executive summary the Monro Township school budget for the 1617 school year was developed within specific parameters set forth by the board's philosophy directive and the finance committee's challenge to Administration to prepare a comprehensive budget meeting the needs of 250 to 300 additional students addressing aging facilities without any expectation of additional state aid and while suppressing taxes by staying under cap by $600,000 that is a remarkable feat considering that in this budget we have a $1.1 million roof rep placement project we are educating almost 300 additional students and we are $600,000 under the state's cap limit to raise taxes this board wanted to send a message to the public in the community that

049we mean business that we when we prepared this budget we went through every expenditure through committee process and uh with a zerob based approach to a lot of the areas that starts with a clean slate not a percentage increase or decrease over last year and develops organically what your needs are for next year based on the enrollment based on uh special education needs and um facility needs and that's that's how this was prepared on behalf of Dr kak Dr alvic and I this challenge was was accepted and our mission was accomplished this budget has been professionally constructed to afford every student an opportunity for an exemplary education by well-trained committed staff and a safe environment opportunity is made available through a comprehensive curriculum which offers diverse course offerings and co-curricular clubs and activities we believe

050that our proposed budget continues to become more efficient as evidenced by a successful County budget efficiency review that Dr kak Dr alv and I engaged in in January at the County office where Monroe was exemplified amongst our peers for many best financial practices key budget considerations are as follows number one increased student enrollment is Paramount you'll see some slides in a moment that demonstrate that visibly that that should get some um reaction from the public when you see how many new students we've educated and what we're anticip ating to educate in the future our facilities are aging and they used to have a cap exemption for construction uh repairs things like roofs and parking lots no longer is that the case they all fit within the cap they all share the same resources as teachers

051and student supplies student teacher ratios are very important um Dr Alva could speak to this but there's a lot of research that demonstrates that low student teacher ratios are critical at the elementary levels and we maintain parity amongst our schools and do our best to keep those numbers down we are $600,000 under the cap where we could have gone and spent an additional $600,000 but we intentionally chose not to because of the last item the tax consideration on the community board members are residents of this town and Jamesburg adjacent to Monroe we also have an open door and open phone policy to the public quite often Dr kak and Dr alvic and I are taking calls from members of the planned retirement communities and parents throughout the township about tax issues and we are very

052cognizant of um of of the trust that's given into us um to put together a budget that's responsible what is the budget creation timeline it all begins with the budget philosophy that's where the board tells Administration what kind of cake to bake and that begins around October we first study historical enrollment patterns because the size of budgets is determined by the size of and number of students we review staffing needs we then develop a budget at the schools with a zerob based approach starting from scratch go in the closet see what you have anticipate your needs and Order and produce a budget accordingly then the governor gives his budget address two days later we receive our state aid award we adopt a tenative preliminary budget and then tonight is the final public hearing what programs

053are in the budget I'd like to turn it over to Dr alocate this time to highlight some of the wonderful educational programs and all of the educational needs that we've met in this budget thank you um I I was not able to be here during the initial budget presentation but I did work with our high school students um to create a video which is available online which has a little bit more information but I just want to highlight some of the programs that we were are able to include in this budget for our students um we're continuing with the Common Core implementation so uh even though we received uh our state testing um results very late in the year we did look at them and use them as a guide as we were moving forward

054um are there were there professional development needs are there curricular revision needs um how can we best help our students to be successful on these on these assessments um during the next two years we're going to be implementing the Next Generation science standards as required next year we will be implementing for grades six through 12 the following year grades K through five um so we're working very closely last summer we began the process through a curriculum mapping program uh process uh that Miss caletto uh LED with with some of our teachers teers so we are already in place to move forward with curriculum writing this summer to implement those standards next year each of our schools has a school garden many of them through grants uh that were received from the New Jersey Agricultural Society

055or the Sustainable New Jersey Grant so we are moving forward really having our students with Hands-On programs in our schools um stem is another area that we're moving forward with and really encouraging our teachers and using professional development for our teachers to get our students to really think and prepare them for college and careers we are we have aligned our assessments to all of the uh common core standards and we use the dr2 assessment in the lower levels and we are looking at um some online benchmarking tools for our students to begin using next year um as a way for us to evaluate our curricular programs and also to help prepare our students for the online assessments that they're that they are taking we have many Athletics and co-curricular activities for all of our students

056throughout the budget um as Dr kak mentioned earlier we have a very involved character education program which has been helping uh as we Implement all of the laws and requirements through the HIV law um we currently offer 28 AP courses at our high school with over 820 students enrolled in those courses obviously many of our students are taking multiple AP courses uh during the year all students are expected to take the AP exam at the end of each of those courses we have a very strong special education department uh we meet the needs of all of our students um kudos to the pupil Personnel Services because we have brought back many of our students from out of District saving the district money in those areas um we also have a model professional development program where

057most of our professional development in the district is offered by our own teachers who have been trained as trainers so we're not we're saving money by not sending teachers out of District for much of our professional development we're doing it in-house and um our model is actually a national model at this point um for our professional development program we've also received many accolades and I just want to highlight some of our um data from last year for our 20145 graduating class our graduation rate was 97% 86% of those students attended either a two or a four-year College uh 3% attended career in technical schools 2% % entered the military 5% entered the workforce um our average scores for our Monro tanip high school students who participate in the S and ACT score they score higher

058than the state average uh we are also one of 10 districts that were originally uh inducted into innovate New Jersey because of all of the um Innovation and practices that we're using with all of our technology throughout our school our balanced literacy approach and our um our our uh hybrid program that we use at our elementary schools for World Language where we have um we use Rosetta Stone but we also incorporate uh on a part part-time basis for our students with the world language teachers um and we are also recognized as a transformative School our High School uh which is this award celebrates Technology Innovation and Alternative Learning in America's High School classrooms so even though we uh took our time we really spent a lot of time with the budget defense rounds we are

059still meeting the needs of our students and we do have a lot of great things still available to everyone in our budget thank you doctor key facts on state aid there's two categories of Aid first is Equalization Aid that is the largest area of resource for state aid and it's designed to support a District's adequacy budget what is an adequacy budget it's a hypothetical model created by a state think tank of of former Educators and state officials and some members of the public to come up with a hypo what a hypothetical school should cost what a hypothetical special education population should be what a hypothetical teacher guide should look like and so on and it's an extremely conservative model that basically is a barebones uh School District District Equalization Aid is designed to support through

060state aid the equalization budget and it is C calculated and the state funds are distributed based upon a districts wherewithal to support their local fair share themselves and if they cannot the state then pays for it in the in the area of state aid based upon property wealth and income levels property wealth coming from the aggregate uh net valuation ratables in the town and income levels coming from that 4digit code on your New Jersey 1040 income tax filing Monroe is very wealthy and very affluent and because of that on um uh statistic the state gives us zero Equalization Aid to support the largest operations to run a school which is the adequacy budget categorical Aid is a specific categories of state aid designed to reimburse school districts for different areas where they qualify for um

061this this state aid type Transportation Aid is one Monroe's transportation department is the most efficiently rated transportation department in the county um we qualify for the largest amount of state aid in this area but it's limited because of our over adequacy status and what they give us is advertised over a 5-year period we also receive special education Aid that's another categorical type of Aid that has a decrease in the 1617 budget compared to the prior year even though our special education numbers are growing uh very steadily and state aid is only 3.09% of our total revenue to support the school budget and one of the lowest state aid per pupil ratios in the county we've talked at length about District um areas of address in this category we've even drafted our own in-house legislation that

062was sponsored by Senator Greenstein um to fully fund the formula for Monroe and that unfortunately that never gained traction Dr uh kak and Mr Ryback and I uh met with Senator Sweeney recently um and Senator Greenstein at the arrangement of Mayor tamboro and we went down to the state house and we presented a plethora of financial information lobbying our case for additional state aid and why the the distribution of Aid is unfair specifically to Monroe and um we were quite enthused because they knew our data before we got there they were familiar with our our our issue and um Senator Sweeney offered a solution that could bring Monroe as much as $2 million to quote him in the 1718 budget by a running of the formula and an elimination of the hold harmless provision what

063that is is a few years back when State revenues dried up and state aid uh became scarce they just held districts harmless and said everybody's going to get the same amount you got last year plus or minus some window dressing um that is particularly hazardous to Monroe because we are picking up 300 new students a year and other districts are having decreasing enrollment and their student to state aid ratios are growing while ours are decreasing we are confident uh pursuant to our meeting that that's going to change and that there is hope on the horizon and we are going to keep the pedal down on this issue and be relentless to get more money because it's a disgrace that 85 cents of every dollar to support public education in the township of Monroe is coming

064from the local tax levy local tax levy from taxpayers who pay not only income and sales and excise taxes um that are being diverted to other areas of the state other than where you live and and uh we will continue our address of that I've handed out two handouts um one is a comparative sources of revenue they are also posted on our website and what's not noteworthy from schedule a is that fund balance applied from last year grew um about $2.2 million that was due to the direct efforts of administration to finish the 1516 budget as efficiently as possible and um through efforts of intense negotiations with Horizon to keep down uh health benefit costs through the fruit of Labor negotiation agreements with the various groups who have given back a lot through negotiations including

065medical and um uh other concessions and through purchase order freezes initi initiated by the superintendent we closed last year with residual money left in the budget of $2.2 million exceeding the prior year $975,000 was directed by the board to go into a capital reserve account to deal with facilities in the future and it could be used as also a down payment on a bond referendum and um $600,000 was used for new appropriation needs $600,000 was dedicated to go under cap we also reached a very amicable agreement with Jamesburg as I mentioned previously and Jamesburg board of education is doing their part to um fulfill the needs of maximizing the tuition estimate paid to Monroe and then when it gets compared to Monroe's actual cost there should be an Arbitrage that will be applied back to

066the indebtedness that existed a few years ago as a result of the 2010 cap which left Jamesburg without the means to raise enough budgeted money to pay Monroe I also provided a comparative state aid schedule and and unfortunately the net result of this is that for the 1617 school year we saw an increase of state aid of only $155,000 I mentioned that we're expecting about 300 new students the state's contribution to those 300 new students is to pay for about one of them with additional state aid funding and finally I gave a 2-year comparative appropriation d detail schedule what's noteworthy in there is the significant decreases as a result of zerob based budgeting some of the only increases are the negotiated labor agreement increases a lot of which were offset by concessions throughout other areas

067of the budget this budget contains 22 new full-time equivalent staff to handle growth of students $1.1 million to replace the Woodland roof 354 passenger buses and 324 passenger vans with two drivers or a um replenishment and Recreation of the tennis courts on Schoolhouse Road which was paid for three by $300,000 um given to us by the township through an agreement and um many other areas of addressed in the curriculum that Dr alvic mentioned our miscellaneous sources consist of the following information on this chart and it's a small percentage of Revenue so I don't want to spend too much time on it and here's our enrollment projection from our demographer as of March 2016 projecting 258 new students through those various grade levels for next year that's a very conservative projection as we've seen historically this

068chart shows that budgets are driven by student enrollment and the Monroe Township Board of Education has picked up 1,330 students over the past eight years and our anticipation is is that that pace is probably going to pick up in the future this unfortunate slide shows the inverse inverse relationship between the growth of students and state aid funding as you could see um the 2008 school year we were left with about $258,000 of general fund Aid and then we experience a dead cat bounce up to about a $2 million or $3 million level where it has remained flat due to the hold harmless provision despite the fact that our enrollment is growing so aggressively we experienced over the last 8 years a 39% decrease in state aid while absorbing 25% more students where does the money

069go when you calculate the benefits in the orange portion to those of teachers and bus drivers and those who directly uh touch students the percentage of expenditures on instruction exceed 60% the money does not go to administrative costs and you could see the inverse relationship between the county limit per pupil in administrative costs and the decreasing per pupil cost of monro's administrative cost spending the administrative cost areas are the uh school administrative areas principal Vice principle uh the central office areas the information technology and the superintendent's office due to efforts intentionally designed by the board to create savings such as bringing in a quality inhouse counselor instead of paying a large firm for legal advice the Monroe Board of Ed for that one example saves over $100,000 per year and increased the service to everybody

070in the district this is a comparative schedule for adequacy status and it is no surprise that with going under cap by $600,000 and by absorbing increased enrollment of students that are above adequacy status has decreased 32% in the 1617 school year compared to the prior year 4.3 million that's an important statistic because the amount of above adequacy phases out categorical state aid and also may be a factor in the new state aid formula that's under design they could limit um a w based on how much you're spending above the adequacy model we have numerous cost savings from shared services our food service department uh provides lunches to the uh middlex Regional ed Service Commission we recycle everything you can imagine here including cardboard glass paper paper Metals batteries computers and um profit from those recyclings

071transportation services aggressively solicits the sharing of bus routes with other districts who intersect with ours on a routing map purchasing I just received a letter from the county um Regional ed Service Commission that to date since we joined the County Purchasing Consortium three and a half years ago we've saved over $2 million in purchasing supplies and supplies are anything consumed in one business cycle they're a very vast category we buy everything through their um a bulk purchasing Consortium and compared to buying from State contract or bidding we've saved over $2 million technology Services we participate in e- rate funding insurance coverage and benefits we participate in uh New Jersey school boards Association Insurance Group and with the municipality uh again they're they are restoring our tennis courts on Schoolhouse Road and have offered to us

072in preliminary stages two potential land donations one for um future construction of school needs if that should be the result of the ad hoc committee and the other is adjacent to the administrative building which could uh is desperately needed for additional bus parking and uh could be easily used for that purpose what factors influence the tax rate number one state aid if Monroe was to receive just the state aid that South Brunswick received you would have a tax reduction this year that would make your head spin so state aid is the largest variable in what affects the tax rate next is fund balance appli that is something that we can control fund balance is a result of of underspending the budget from how you designed it and you do that by competitive Contracting and and

073purchasing efficient purchasing uh purchase order freezes and Joint chur and by aggressively fighting with Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield for insurance premium relief and of course budgets are driven by students how does this all affect the pocketbook there's so many wonderful programs in this budget we've met every educational need every special education need every Transportation need every curricular need every facility need last year the budget increased 4 and A5 cents this year by the excess Surplus that's been applied by going under cap and by a lot of the cost-saving elements constructed throughout the budget we are pleased that the budget is only increasing 32 cents that is less than half of of the 10-year average last year a 4 and a. half cent increase resulted in an increase for an average assessed home of $138.4

074this year we're pleased that the increase will only be $18.66 I'd like to thank everybody who participated in this budget particularly all the principles and directors in the back of the room um this was a true group project that began back in October and um there were some very stressful moments in its construction but the net result is something that we're all very proud of that serves the community and um our students especially very well our main objective in putting this budget together is meet students needs and um be responsible to the community second and this Bud budget does that uh extremely well so now I would like to read the resolution and then turn it over to board discussion and deliberation it is recommended that the members of the Monro Township Board of Education

075approve the following amounts and resolution for the 201627 final budget be it resolved by the Monro Township Board of Education that the 1617 general fund budget be adopted in the amount of 108,000 $769 and a general fund local tax levy in the amount of 95,4 31,6 184 and a special Revenue Fund in the amount of $1,124 557 and a Debt Service budget in the amount of 10, 831,687 and a Debt Service local tax levy in the amount of $10 m212 65 whereby the 167 budget totals 12,170 1043 and whereas the Monro Township Board of Education has been notified of state aid amounts and whereas such state aid amounts are for the 201617 categorical special education Aid is $1,976 18119 and the 201617 categorical security Aid is $13,750 and a 2016 17 categorical Transportation Aid is

076$57,600 46 and for the 2016 2017 other state aid amounts consisting of Park Readiness Aid of $58,900 and per pupil Grant Aid of $58,900 and professional Learning Community Aid of 62,000 515 and host District support Aid of $43 whereas the Monro Township Board of Education has estimated a state aid amount pursuant to application and for the 2016 2017 the estimated extraordinary Aid amount is $214,400 and whereas School District bylaw 0147 policy 3440 policy 4440 and njac 6A col 3B hyphen 1.2b provides that the Board of Education shall establish in the amount annual school budget a maximum expenditure amount that may be allotted for such travel and expense reimbursement for the 2016 2017 school year now therefore be it resolved that the Monro Township Board of Education hereby establishes the school district travel maximum for the

077201617 school year at the tenative sum of 8,422 and be it further resolved that the school business administ minator shall track and record these costs to ensure that the maximum amount is not exceeded and where is a result of the extraordinary budget efficiencies created by the administrative stewardship of the budget which led to an increase in excess Surplus as an alternate Revenue sourced taxes the board budgeted $600,000 under cap not withstanding the continuing inequity in state aid funding as well as the significant student growth and widespread facility needs in the district and now therefore let it be resolved that the superintendent of schools and the business administrator board secretary file the required documents with the executive County Superintendent second thank you uh I'd like to open the um floor up uh for questions by the

078board questions or comments I have a question first of all I want to commend you on such a good budget um and my question is in the year-to-year comparison under the administration I'm just curious as to um how you're decreasing supply cost by 54% a significant contribution came from the budget development from the principles um there has has been some significant cost cutting in the areas of administrative supplies and um also the comment that I mentioned before about our joining the middlex regional Ed service commission for a purchasing Consortium of supplies has created efficiencies in purchasing that has also helped reduce those administrative supplies thank you any other question or comment from board members from so many of does that category have to do with Google Docs yes ma'am does it yes okay it's your

079favorite one better get on board Mr Russ just I wanted to bring it up last time but uh Dr Al Rich wasn't here great job on the video uh I didn't know that students helped you it was very professional so for those people that maybe didn't get a chance to see it I would urge them to take a look at it good work thank you anyone else at this point I'll open the floor up to anyone from the public who'd like to make a comment or ask a question I'll remind you that you'll have three minutes to do so come to the microphone state your name and address is there anyone from the public wishing to yes good evening Dr kak members of the board my name is Mike karski I reside at 25 Avenue

080K and um I have just have a couple very brief questions and it's in regards to to one of the budget considerations uh for new staff at the middle school it's my understanding that there's eight new teachers that are uh proposed to be hired for the upcoming budget am I correct Staffing for that yet I'm not sure yeah I Mr Chari for the actual amount of Staffing yes we are hiring new staff I don't have that data right in front of me but if you would like to uh email that question to me I'd be certainly happy to reply to you with that sure I'll do that and my actual uh what I'm trying to get at is that a special education teacher would you know if that is in the works to hire at

081the middle school because it's one of the the reason I'm asking sir is it's one of the budget considerations that's on the uh District's website yeah uh anytime a district hires new Staffing it's not always specific to a certain school so if an opening occurs somebody retires somebody leaves an opening could occur of course student population shifts require different Staffing so we do put staffing issues in our budget which are all detailed our budget is online uh and certainly or will be available after tonight um but as far as the specifically where they go we have to determine that throughout the year throughout now between now and September to make sure that all positions are filled appropriately okay so getting back to the uh budget regarding the special education instruction for new staff on page

082one here uh maybe Dr Gorski is familiar with the salary proposal of $4 [Music] absolutely um budgeting for new staff is a particularly cumbersome process in the budget it's driven in the general population uh more easily by enrollment projections and by pup pupil teacher ratios and to create parity in the schools we try to keep it lower in the elementary levels uh as best we can special education is a little more different it involves a lot of coordination between the child study teams and the director of special education to ascertain what the everchanging needs through IEPs individual educational placements are for the next 12 months and to align staff accordingly to handle those specific categorical needs um they could be anywhere from multiple disabled teachers autistic teachers um behavioral specialists and and so on in

083the 1617 budget the following positions are proposed at the Monro Township High School there's a 1.0 1.0 means one full-time position 1.0 business teacher 1.0 history teacher that's to handle increased student growth at the high school at Brookside school there is a 2third of a reading specialist for grades third and fourth at mil Lake there's a one-third reading specialist at Woodland there's a one-third reading specialist at Monroe Township Middle School there's a 1.0 fizzed teacher and a 1.0 English teacher at the middle school there's a 0.17 that's an additional section for algebra at Oak Tree there's a one-third Edition for reading specialist at Applegarth there's a 1.0 for grade five teacher and at Applegarth a 13d reading specialist at the high school there in the special ed category there's a one .0 multiped disabled teacher

084at the high school there is 2.0 par Professionals for multiped disabled programs at mil Lake there is a resource teacher and there are two resource teachers at the high school at the high school there's a 1.0 parah for the resource room that's a special education program at mil Lake there's a 1.0 autism teacher at mil Lake there's a 2.0 Paris for autism and throughout the district there is a shared 3.0 positions for speech OT and PT in addition to that there's finally two bus drivers full-time and that's a total of 22 full-time equivalent positions many of which are in special education programs and have been intelligently designed to meet the exact needs of the students so this $49,000 salary is not necessarily for the Middle School it could be for any uh position in the

085district am I correct with that if you're referring to the summary sheet that's correct okay thank you thank you anyone else in the public Robert roach orfield Boulevard um the mon the Monroe Township strategic plan I assume that's a multi-year plan um and was the cost determined for the the the year 16117 as to what this plan would cost budget wise um Mr President I can attempt to answer that I'm not you have the answer I I was going to um approach that question by saying a strategic plan by its nature is a five-year plan and uh it would it would be very difficult to assertain any individual one of the five years components in the budget there certainly are comp components throughout the budget um but we it would be very difficult to tie

086that back exactly to the Strategic plan well have you estimated what the fiveyear cost would be can I ask is there um is there a specific area that you're looking that because there's multiple areas in there from programs to professional development to the purchase of technology to I mean there's all different areas in there uh a a lot have a cost a lot do not is there a specific area that you're looking for when you develop a plan and you're implementing a process I would assume one of the factors would be what's it going to cost absolutely as well as the educational process for it the value of it and I think you should be evaluating the cost versus the value and just making a determination sure absolutely and every program is also evaluated as

087it goes through the budget process so you can develop a 5-year strategic plan it's it's hard to predict cost 5 years out but every year we have an annual budget process and every part of that plan that is put forth to advance would be looked at from a cost perspective and also a value added well well many many businesses do long range planning and they figure out the cost of it I I would I would assume that the school administration and the board would do the same type of thing when they're developing a a long range plan doctor sure the Strategic plan is more of a vision it's a more broad stroke uh approach to the district's needs in a macro consideration for the next five years it would be impossible to segment each of

088the years of that five because of the incredible variation in student needs and revenues from all different sources but it it in so much as it's not designed to be a five-year budget it's more of a five-year Visionary plan in Broad Strokes on the district's needs and goals and then the actual mission of accomplishing those goals is performed in the annual school budget right thank you and I'd like to compliment you on the at Le saving the $600,000 on a cap I'm glad to see the board Administration developed a new recipe for baking the cake that they've been baking for so many years the same old way and I hope they continue with and don't throw away the recipe thank you Mr Ro thank you your words Mike thank you anyone else from the public

089seeing no one we could move on to the um committee oh sorry we have the vote [Music] Yes Mr board president members of the monen Board of Education this roll call is for the final budget adoption moved by Mr calman and seconded by Miss armeno Miss armeno yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kpano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and with an eligibility to vote Mr rutsky yes thank you sir Mr board president motion passes unanimously thank you sir congratulations to you Mr gsky and the finance committee for such a great job thank you now we can move move to committee reports is any committee chair yes so it's Board of Education meeting I so that can only mean there was a curriculum Comm meting um

090went through a couple of agenda items five in particular I'm going to go through them in really no particular well yeah there's a particular order um first one we reviewed a policy which is looking to go forward to the policy uh committee with respect to the entrance age review um keep me honest we're talking about setting a minimum age of 6 years old at 1231 to make sure that the kids coming into our school can be tested at the same age to determine if they're ready to come into kindergarten this would be students who did an outside kindergarten program who want who are looking to come in as first graders so it's setting a testing deadline for those students but we'll bring it forward to to policy the next item was uh to review the

091preliminary report card which is now I guess lowering um well actually I almost say lowering because it's really not lowering it's presenting a uniform scorecard platform or format for all grades K through three correct okay good thanks Fe um we also reviewed a proposal to speak to the development a creation of a Monro Township High School hall of fame um which will be uh at least initially looking at athletic um students and then we talked about maybe alternating every year for just not just Athletics and the following year it would be you know for the whole school and to determine in the future what kind of format that would be whether it would be you know a case or something U maybe more um 21st century well I guess discussions will be had on that

092um also we talked about the national English Honor Society um the committee was all in favor of that to push that forward but the big piece of cake yeah sorry it's big to me um arguably for I'll I'll say conservatively for 10 years uh some of you have heard me repeatedly make requests on presenting some kind of program where 100% of our high school students would be required to take some type of online course didn't really I don't really care what it was but it would be a course which 100% of our students would be required to take and it would be online uh that would put our students in a position to be more adaptive um in a 21st Century Learning model where you know let's face it in in the professional world you're

093learning you're corporate training what have you it's all online you're required to learn it online and it's certainly when you get into college it's a requirement well I'm happy to say that we're um going to launch in I guess September uh our first online for personal finance and economics um because that's a requirement for graduation uh both of those courses they're going to be online first year we're going to have it as a online course but it's going to be in a classroom and then we're going to kind of move it forward to be 100% online uh so it won't have to take up class space we'll be able to open up the opportunity to take the course in the summer so again taking a course to get it out of the way of the

094schedule and let students take it um when they wish and really the big gun here is well this is a lot this is very big for those of you who don't know this is huge uh the other option here is to also present these courses since they're online open it up for other districts to uh take these courses uh for a fee and uh uh also provide uh content material to other districts and uh you know let Monroe reap the benefits if you will so very big day shout out to Terry Weiss thank you for for finally doing this took a while but it's done more to come thanks that's all I got thank you Mr cman any question from Mr calman mrin that sounds amazing um with the uh online I just have a

095question is um so I can understand that our our our teachers are going to be teaching this online and then we're going to provide that content to other districts eventually down the road so basically we're freeing up uh it's mostly space that we're freeing up and also getting them used to using that uh sounds like a great idea thank you any other committee chair Mr nin thank you Mr board president um we had a finance committee meeting on Tuesday at 6:00 p.m. at the central office and uh guess what we talked about the budget um we pretty much uh went over exactly uh what we went over here so I'm not going to uh uh dwell on that um we also discussed the uh Falcon care and the ECE financial statements um as happy as

096Mr calman is um with the online courses I am equally as happy with the uh the uh profit statements from the uh Falcon care and the uh ECE programs the ECE program has uh is showing a profit of uh three $255,000 and the uh actually the opposite the EC has a profit of 91,000 and the Falcon care has a a net profit of $255,000 so um we're very very pleased they're above the uh uh projections that we had originally uh thought and uh things are moving along quite well in both those so uh I I commend the staff uh who runs that and um I I commend Miss Sharon Jensen for all her hard work and and her staff uh in keeping this all together for the board um we also had a uh Falcon

097care proposal an ecce proposal um for an upgrade in uh vendor software there has been some issues with billing Etc and uh communication with the parents and this will solve those problems uh and along with that we're going to be uh increasing the tuition uh slightly uh for both those to cover some of these added expenses um and that concludes my report Mr board president thank you Mr nson any questions does any of that go toward repayment of the loan has that been calculated yeah Mr President yes we talked in finance that since the board passed a resolution um directing Administration to pay back the loan $5,000 a month which goes back probably three years ago to December we've made those payments religiously and with these handsome um net incomes we would first like to

098establish a little bit of roots in the program a little retained earnings and then in the immediate future after that um probably make a significant contribution toward a loan um payoff and and you don't have to answer this now but it do we have a balance on that loan at this point off the top of my head I think it's about $170,000 left yes that's extraordinary that's about half of of what the original loan was is that correct 300,000 yeah so thank you very much thank you the uh finance committee to really work that out thank you any other committee chair board president ryck uh the uh the policy committee was did not have the opportunity to meet in the short time so we will be doing that prior to the next meeting okay thank

099you anyone else not seeing anyone we could move to our first public forum uh this is to address items on the agenda uh again anyone from the public wishing to um come to the podium you have three minutes just need you to state your name and address is there any interest in addressing the uh agenda okay not seeing any one we can move to our superintendent report sure thank you Mr thanks uh Mr president at the last board meeting there was a question about our substitutes and receiving uh health coverage um so I would just like to provide a response to that at the uh last Board of Education meeting on April 13 2016 during the public forum two substitute teachers in the district inquired as to why they were not being scheduled to work

1005 days a week as reportedly they have been in past years in response to this inquiry I'd like to State the following Staffing decision decisions are within the sole managerial prerogative of the Board of Education the decision to utilize Personnel including on call substitutes is determined by examining a variety of factors including but not limited to District needs qualifications and prior performance board of education is fortunate to have a large substitute database containing the names of many qualified substitutes who would like to have the opportunity to work in the district in utilizing the on call substitutes the administration Endeavors to provide opportunity for substitute teacher or teaching to all qualified substitutes in an equitable manner in accordance with the needs of the students of the district I would also like to on a separate uh

101item mention that uh the 201516 New Jersey principal and supervisor Association middle sex County outstanding student award for our high school went to Kush sha who is our valuan and will attend Columbia University Kush is the first in his class and valoran he is the Monroe recipient of the middlex county chapter of the New Jersey principal and supervisor Association nominated by his building principal and the event was held last night uh at the njpsa headquarters in Monroe and was attended by Mr godo um Kush and his parents also um had an opportunity I'm trying to get to as many of the student events as possible and um are our not only our Academic Teams doing well and I include that in every week in our in the board's weekly confidential um students are just knocking

102it out of the ballpark academically I mean really really doing well uh and our sports teams are doing well as also so today after U before the board meeting I ran over and I wanted to see the softball team play The Varsity softball team but there was a mercy ruling our team had done so well that they they ended the game before it ended uh so congratulations to our girl softball team um I'll have to get over there quicker they got that that came so quick I was you know uh I mentioned girls across before and the baseball team uh when at the time I left to get over to the committee meeting it was uh we were up uh three nothing and uh the team looked great so kudos to not only the players

103but also the coaches as well and um with that that concludes my my report I think you've heard enough of new speak tonight it's always a pleasure to have new speak okay on the Personnel can I have a motion to approve items a through J move second vote Mr kski Mr board president did you want to ask any members if have questions any questions personel a through [Music] J okay see no questions we can vote now miss armeno yes Mr Miss Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes stain on H so noted thank you Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky I abstain with the exception of items d e f and g where I vote Yes thank you sir Mr board president Personnel items

104a through J passes okay we're ready for I believe the business administrator I have a motion to approve board options a through k j j second second okay any uh comments questions V board action items a through J Miss armeno uh yes on everything except I policy 168 recording board meetings that's a no that's a no thank you Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kpano yes Mr nosin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky uh I abstain with the exception of items A and C or I vote yes thank you sir Mr board president board action items a through J passes thank you now we're ready for the Dig administrator report yes sir Mr board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended

105that board action items a through C be approved by consent roll call some some moved yes Miss armeno yes Miss Deo yes Mr cman yes Mrs K panowich yes Mr noin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rety so for clarification purposes I may have spoke too soon on the last one okay but on this one I do abstain with the exception of items A and C and I'll go back and abstain from all on the last I believe okay so noted I we'll record that in the minutes um appreciate that clarification it's a little uh challenging with the Jamesburg voting our our business office staff and our board attorney go through every agenda item and determine the applicability for Jamesburg in advance and we try to Aster that but

106uh sorry about the confusion my my apologies yes sir okay we can do the board president's report I have a few things I need to talk to everyone about and kind of kind of something that uh is important to all of us you heard Mr Gorski talk about state aid you heard to mention about the hold harmless portion of the um state aid formula we get a pittance of what I believe we should be getting especially if you look at the amount of growth that we're experiencing and will experience in the next couple of years I went to the taxpayers guide uh to education spending and I looked at what other districts are getting Oldbridge gets 39% North Brunswick 20.6% South Brunswick 23.6% Spotswood 30.6% what are we at 11.2 state aid yeah less than

1073% less than 3% I have it listed incorrectly then over there um that being said we need to Lobby our state legislators because we certainly deserve more and we can't keep footing the bill for Quality education unless they start helping a little bit and giving us what we deserve now we know that Senator Sweeney had a great idea but we just can't leave it there we need you all of us to write him call him call our state legislators and show our support support so that we get more state aid it's unfair for these other districts I'm not saying they don't deserve their state aid all I'm saying is we deserve more that being said on another topic that's a little lighter I'd like to congratulate the cheerleading team uh who won the Grand National

108Championship in Myrtle Beach so congratulations to all of them and their coaches yes they deserve it appuse and their parents yes and their parents that's true on another issue um this is concerning you know the student growth advisory committee we have a meeting May 9th um it is imperative that every member of that committee be present at the middle school at 7 o'cl in the cafeteria and let me go through briefly uh why it's so important on um April 10th there was an article on the opinion page of the home News Tribune uh concerning affordable housing basically it was titled A costly failure on affordable housing in the newspapers we read about the transportation fund we read about gas tax we read about Atlantic City when have we when have we been reading about affordable

109housing the um this this article basically states that the state has dropped the ball on this because nothing has been done for the past 16 years so it went to the courts and the courts are telling the towns not just Monroe it's all over they're telling the towns that you have to now make up what you should have been doing for affordable housing for the past 16 years and the next 10 what does that mean it means a lot more housing equ but you need to understand is for every unit of affordable housing a developer could build five of market value so that's an awful lot of housing um we had what we thought were numbers that we would be working with but about a week ago or so mayor tamboro uh called myself the

110superintendent Mr Gorski and Mr T the director of facilities to his office to meet with him and his staff to tell us briefly or give us an update as to the um tentative uh affordable housing settlement well the numbers changed greatly they went up and he emphasized to us what the town has been doing they didn't just accept that they've been negotiating actually in the court using everything every means possible to get that number down uh if they fought it and they went to court chances are they felt out the attorneys for the town believe that we would lose and the numbers would be greatly higher so this uh student growth committee now has to rework um very much what we've been doing because the numbers it's a whole different game um I do want

111to emphasize that we do have commercial uh space included in this and as a matter of fact in in many developments where where is mixed use uh after a c number of residential units they have to build commercial and have to close on it before they continue on and we'll go through that uh with the uh student growth uh advisory committee I just have to emphasize to you the importance of what's happening and what it means to this town it's not our fault it's not the town's fault the state dropped the wall and the courts took over with that I'd like to turn the mic over to Mr Gorski would like to make a few comments thank you thank you Mr Rybeck um in conjunction with the material event that's been disclosed to the board

112of ed pertaining to new housing starts where we're expecting uh a significant number of new housing starts a multiple of what we were uh producing enrollment projections off of when the uh uh student growth advisory committee started there's a need now to redo the enrollment projections known as demographic reports and pass a resolution for the demographer to immediately begin that process and it's a cumbersome process involving lengthy discussions with Administration Mr T Dr kak Dr alvik um and I along with the Township's attorneys and Mr Rigs and Mr Hamilton and mayor tamboro um so members of the mon Township Board of Education it is recommended that board the Board of Education approve Ross habber Associates Inc to update the demographic study which will Encompass the short-term and long-term impact on the schools due to the

113recent changes in the Monroe Township's affordable housing requirements at a cost not to exceed $99,000 including expenses the board president and the business administrator board secretary are here by authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the Board of Education I have a motion to approve uh move second discussion discussion discuss um this is the third time we're engaging in this this demographics study is that correct particular yes a as we mentioned before demographic studies do need updating but this is extraordinary due to this new um disclosure of housing coming as a result of settlement last week no I get that but the problem is if if the the district as the Board of Education doesn't get the uh the numbers be from the township on a regular basis and

114that they're not accurate we keep incurring costs because we're not getting accurate information and we've had we had that problem over a year ago with Mr HR when we had a very big public meeting and people were outraged that the numbers were all over the place now it's not maybe not necessarily his fault but it we can't keep just spending money on demographics without good data as we all know bad data in brings bad bad results so my my only objection is that this keeps going on and on and and and very quickly I would just take this exception with um board president Ryback's assessment that it's not the town's fault I'm not C I'm I wouldn't use the word fault but however we are in this and yes I understand all the co-a regulations

115and all but we are in this predicament because of the massive growth over the last 15 years there were this is a third phase COA regulation and they're actually changing the name to fair share housing um but it's an affordable housing element that has been on the books for 20 years and just like you know when we we bemoan the fact that we're not getting state aid we've known that for a long time we can't Beman the fact that we have an obligation on affordable housing these laws have been in effect for many years and it and I think there's some bad planning that has gone on We were originally at 2,332 affordable housing obligations were down to 1,133 I attended that court case last Monday so I was I heard what was going on

116but it's a consequence of the rapid building that we've had so the demo the demographer we keep spending money I mean at some point we have to be clear that these are the right figures are are we closer to these being the right figures do you think or can we ask them I will say that uh Dr kak uh Mr T uh board president Ryback and I have met with Township officials no less than three times in the last uh week or so and we've also had multiple exchanges over the phone um and uh we we have um expressed the need to have accurate spreadsheets of new housing start information that's uh clearly presented so that our demographer can do uh a proper enrollment Pro I would agree you're you're at a disadvantage and it's

117it's essentially you know inaccurate information essentially renders the previous demographic studies useless that would be my only s my only thought I mean okay Mr yeah I mean and I understand what you're saying M armenio um and I'm looking at it from my perspective when I'm looking at I'm trying to keep it balanced you the the demographic study that was done most recently uh is projecting I think will still be somewhat of an accurate uh prediction for the next five years I think the impact that we're hearing if I'm hearing it correctly and the three of us were you know in multiple meetings is that especially with the affordable housing that it's being rolled out over a 20 plus year uh time span so that we may see our original demographic report or our most

118recent demographic report might still be somewhat accurate for the next five years but it's changing our picture for the 10-year period where we may be looking at Phase One and phase two of uh student growth and I don't want to say that that's 100% accurate that's my interpretation of that I I well after this vote I'm going to make ask for a resolution but at the court at at the uh law I don't know it's a lawsuit it was before judge uh wolson they said that it's a 10year buildout they have to use we have $113 million in our affordable housing fund that has to be used to zero within a 10-year period And I believe there the agreement is and I could be wrong I'm not an expert but this is how I understood

119it uh that there are 1,133 affordable housing units and that's only 20% of the actual build outp so you have to multiply I mean 80% is going to be market rate so but it's a 10year built and I think they were very very clear my notes say zero out the fund after a 10-year period and that fund has $13 million in it that's the information that was discussed at the court that sounds I just like to uh make comment uh I just want to emphasize how involved we've all been Mr T sitting there he's right along by way I went as a private citizen not as member of the board and I just listened I'm sure you did a a and we keep emphasizing to the town the importance of activate information um we've gone

120back to them where where we thought there was errors and and they were very open corrected uh the other thing I just want to make clear as my comments is are not opposed to affordable housing it's it's it's it's it's um the amount of housing that we're seeing along with the market rate uh housing that uh the impact will be on on our town because it's going to change the look of the town it's going to um you know uh certainly uh impact uh all citizens including the the school system Mr R yeah um I just wonder where did they get that one to five ratio who comes up with that number fair I don't know who came up with the number I imagine it might be a court do you know I believe it's

121the either the old COA regulations but moving into the third phase again I'm not an expert but as I understand it the third phase is the fair share housing um they develop that plan and and and each municipality has to fit their fair share housing element into such a plan and that's where that should come up thank you house they have to build it's five Market raid housing for every affordable and that and the Builder wants that the Builder gets that's an incent the builder takes that any I mean since Monroe is experiencing so much building is there any consideration to the environment of Monroe I mean like we just discussed earlier we get all our water from the ground I imagine the sewage is processed in the same area well when a builder I

122know applies for development um it does have to get checked by Environmental Protection uh agency well but we see what happened in Fint I mean we know longterm sometimes there are unforeseen circumstances once you continue to build it could later cause more problems well I can say is I hope that that you know the different governmental agencies consider what they have to do as serious more proactive in that area I'm sorry should we be more proactive in that area it is it can be an environmental issue I think I think uh it's incumbent upon all citizens to be uh Vigilant of that not just the Board of Education uh we do everything we can uh very involved with them but I think uh you know there are meetings that you can go to there are

123people you could write and I think that it's incumbent upon all citizens to be aware of what's happening and voice their views but you're having meetings with those decision makers can you raise that point absolutely absolutely any other board member Mr Calin yeah so I'm going to vote no on this thing and I'm going to tell you why because I don't have a question really that we need to do a demographic study all right um we just did one and while we may need to have one do we need to have one immediately I don't know reason why I'm I'm going to vote no is I have a problem with the firm not the quest same firm used multiple times for a enormous amount of time there have been questions about both the the mechanics

124the methodology the what have you can't believe that they're the only game in town can't believe it um but before we go ahead and really do this right you guys know cuz you guys are closest to the numbers to see exactly based on the projections that were made to what was delivered if it's acceptable and it's reasonable from the way it was presented I just have a feeling that things were missed Michelle brought up some good points about those meetings while that's never a good meeting to have they weren't done very well and there were some follow-ups that had to happen about new data coming out didn't have the new data how do you not have the new data that's your job you're the data guy you got to have the good data right so

125um I just feel we we need to be working smarter not harder and I I'm just not sold there that Mr President oh never happens Mr President and uh members of the board to Mr cowman's comments and um I certainly understand where he's coming from there's two main players in the enrollment projection Arena White Hall and Associates and Ross habber and Associates the last round of enrollment projections we Ed both simultaneously um because more data for us provides a better analysis and um through many meetings with Mr T uh Dr kak Dr Alik and I we compared the results and we found that whiteall and and Associates projections were materially understated compared comped to Ross haers we found Ross habr to be more um in our view predictable of what future events are going to

126occur and that is why it it is our recommendation as Administration um to utilize Ross habber for enrollment projections much of the frustration we had before with Ross habber had to do with his uh redistricting and his presentation skills not necessarily uh the math and the computation of um trend line analysis and everything that goes into enrollment projections so um that's why you know we we've presented uh Ross for this next study and um we also got much quicker results from Ross last time and when we are under the gun to the second point do we have to do these enrollment projections did they materially change can you still work with the ones that we did only a few weeks ago the answer is yes uh we received information of a material nature due to

127a significant housing settlement where the township is predicting much more housing to occur in the next five years and and then a less visible component in the longer term to 10 or 15 years in the future that depends on Builders build outs uh they have the ability to build but when they do depends on economic situations and and a host of other things that um a demographer like Ross habber who's got experience with Monroe over a long period of time can best serve us in our opinion to produce projections that can best anticipate when these things will come online as he's done in the past Mr nin I too have concerns um with this presentation first of all I'm a little disappointed this was I didn't see this on the agenda did I miss it

128or was it just not on the okay um I mean I would like to have seen this on the agenda so we could have asked some of these questions um before the meeting and and I actually would have lik to have seen this come through maybe the uh the bg& or the finance committee first um where we could have hammered it out in much greater detail um $99,000 uh to me for a study that was just done not that long ago seems like a lot of money I don't see why we have to like start from scratch again when we could basically uh take the numbers that we have that we're admitting are are are are are pretty good numbers and maybe just compare them with the current projections and extrapolate from there um I

129think 9,000 that that number rings a bell like maybe that was close to the original uh uh study before we had any uh you know when we really had a stale uh demographer study so um that that's my concern um I understand the issue that there's only two firms out there that do this um but uh at some point we just have to say you know you go you go to you go to uh go to war with the army that you have and um to me to keep going back and going back I would just like to see the difference between the houses that were uh estimated in the last study as to and to the new one and I don't see why we just can't extrapolate from there I think this is a

130not not necessarily a good thing Mr President um uh in respect of M nin's comments the uh you know we were called into a meeting with the township as we had progressed pretty far with the ad hoc committee and we were actually looking at designs for um facilities to handle the increased enrollment over the next uh five years um this material disclosure about the housing settlement turned that all of that upside down and as Mr Rybeck said requires us to start from scratch it will change and affect materially the 5-year projection and the longer term projections and ideally we certainly would have taken this to committees to discuss this bg& and finance would been uh suitors but we have a real sense of urgency here with the ad hoc committee scheduling so not to lose

131momentum lose the interest of the volunteers who have committed a lot of their time already to this process and there and and I'll use the word again there's a real sense of urgency to get this report updated as quickly as possible and as accurately as possible and and and is our opinion and belief that Ross habber can accomplish that many uh is is Mr Haber still using the 2000 um I think with the 2000 census ruer study is that he's using that as a basis the answer to that is yes that's the only model that the state will accept ccept White Hall and Associates would also be using that same model that's the problem that's really the issue uh that's also bad data by by the author's own admission so I don't know I don't

132know Mr President yeah Mr T I see you at the if I can add some detail to that Dr Haber did indicate that he spoke to and I forget the woman's name eileene someone she's the professor at ruter who handles the ruter study and he reached out to her specifically regarding our situation because he's concerned regarding the affordable housing and the numbers that will be used for those projections and ruter indicated to him that the Monroe data that is included in the ruer study should not be referenced for uh the study that he is going to do so he is going to be doing leg work with John rigs to determine affordable housing that currently exists and try and extrapolate from that what the new numbers should be and in essence do a new customized

133ruer study that will be reflective of what is in Monroe and what is projected for Monroe so it's a little bit different he's not going to strictly follow the ruter model based on his conversations with um those facilit because the model is obsolete absolutely and ruter has indicated that to him and told him not to follow their model therefore he has to do uh the leg work specific to Monroe just one more comment maybe we can we can talk to our state representatives in this area and ask them and I think I've said this before maybe we can write a letter asking them to either update the ruer study or allow other studies to be used to extrapolate uh enrollment and and projections Because by the author's own admission I think Mr Rybeck you were

134there at ruter with me in the same room and he said that it's an obsolete study yes I couldn't Ag and so was Miss Greenstein she was in the room also so she has firsthand knowledge of the studying being obsolete that's the very least they can do at the state level and allow us to get accurate information to help to help our students no problem with that I I will do what I can to make sure that that message gets conveyed anybody else I guess we could vote on the demographic study Russ Haber resolution moved by Mr Ryback second Ed by Mrs colano Miss armeno I reluctantly say yes if you think it's that important and necessary Mr Mayo yes Mr calman no Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck

135yes Mr Russo no and Mr rutsky yes support president motion passes thank you thank you good discussion good points uh being raised okay we're ready for um any other board of education Business board member Mr noin um just going back to the uh to the budget and the state aid uh situation um just to kind of show you how sorely underfunded we are even with a $2 million increase that's still going to be less than 5 % of our of our budget so I mean it's a sad reality that we have to be getting excited about covering 5% of our budget but um the one thing I do sometimes do in my spare time is I do actually go to other uh districts websites and look at some of their meetings it kind of tells

136you that I don't know much of a life obviously but um it also shows that I don't think there's any state whether they're getting uh 15% 20 or 25% of their uh budget from state aid I didn't hear one person saying other than they're not then they were all underfunded so it's it's a tough fight and and I understand it and uh all we can do is keep you know fighting that good fight well I just like to comment on that that the budget that we just passed uh shows the seriousness and and and the understanding that the finance committee Mr Gorski here also um uh in developing the budget demonstrated uh we don't take it lightly uh and we Bak the right cake this time and hopefully we'll continue to do so any other

137board memb on many would it be appropriate now or we can save it to the next meeting I I would like to ask or or have a resolution or consider a resolution to ask as a shared service opportunity for a copy of the um the court case that was held um and I have the docket number for to to give us all the on the on the affordable houses yes so we would have that information firsthand Mr RC sure do that I I have actually worked with our board attorney on this matter um she and I contacted Township we asked for a copy of the settlement um we called on Wednesday it's settled on Thursday um I don't believe we need a resolution but I will tell you that administratively we will follow up on

138this and we will get a copy of the settlement agreement and send it to the board with the superintendent's weekly confidential and may I just for the Public's sake just say the docket number of this Ina because the public has a right to go to actually the courthouse and get this information it was a note it was a uh compliance hearing for the township of Monroe County of middlex for the Township's housing element and fair share compliance plan for affordable housing period of 1987 to 2025 docket number capital m capital I Capital D- capital L 336 5-15 and that would be available as a public record I do have copies if someone request them I'll be happy to give them to you thank you anyone else see no one we can move to our second

139um public forum uh this is where the public can address uh question items not necessarily on on the agenda um you'll have three minutes to do so if you come up to the podium to state your name name and address Mr Po uh good evening Doug PO for tamarak uh Road uh I've got five different items so I'll try to see what I can do uh the first one uh is this demographic study um unless the the settlement uh indicates the number of units and how many bedrooms are in those units and where those units are going to be built uh and until a builder uh indicates how many uh market value houses he's going to be building and where they're going to be and what size they're going to be Etc I don't see

140how the demographer is going to be able to produce anything uh so I I I personally see that this calling for this demographers report seems to be premature but I haven't seen the the court settlement but uh the demographer has always worked with what is on the books in terms of how many houses and how many bedrooms are going to be in those houses a and I can't imagine that we have that information at this time so it's just a point I'd like to raise about that uh secondly uh some time ago the Board of Education approved an expenditure for a study an outs excuse me an outside group to come in come in and study our special ed it's my voice would you like some water special ed program I can get that right

141there yeah to study the uh special ed program and uh I know we did an inh house study as well as a a an outside firm but I have not yet heard the results of that study presented at a board meeting so I hope that uh that is forthcoming um third item uh this past Sunday in the Star Ledger uh front page was uh a big story about median salaries of teachers in the state of New Jersey uh so I went to the taxpayers guide uh to uh check on the median salaries of all the districts in in uh Monmouth County and I understand that it's already been shared with the board but it has not yet been shared with the public and I think it's important for the public to know that in terms

142of uh the 23 districts in Middle sex County Monroe is the third lowest paying in terms of the median teacher salary uh so I'm sharing that with the public because the newspaper did not uh indicate that information um and the next item uh Mr Coffman had mentioned an online course that would be approved uh but there was no mention of what the cost of that would be I I would think uh unless this is being totally done inhouse that there's some kind of cost involved in that and personally all the studies that I have ever read and anything that I've read in any of the educational journals or newspapers uh questions the efficacy of online courses uh they have always found that the students do not do as well they do not retain the material

143as well in an online course as they do in an actual interactive course with an active teacher um and you a few more seconds take okay fifth item uh the uh US News and World Report released their uh rankings of high schools again uh and I see we still have our sign advertising us as uh having a silver award uh when I looked it up uh on the internet I found that uh Monroe has no ranking but it also has Monroe listed as having two high schools so I pursue that and I found out that not only uh is the Monroe Township of middlex County uh the our results are being somehow pulled together with the Monroe Township which is down in Gloucester County I believe it is uh I don't know why that didn't

144why that happened this year but didn't happen in previous years but I felt that it was a disservice and I hope that someone uh in the administration is looking into that so they can sort that out thank you thank you Mr Po I appreciate you coming and we will be checking into that thank you anyone else from the public Mr roach Robert roach J Yorkfield Boulevard um I I guess what I've heard here tonight is I I think that uh the state's giving us now they used to just give us $2 million are they giving us $4 million now towards our budget cost uh or is it still just a $2 million it's approximately $4 million uh several C years ago I I mentioned this discussed this with the administration um I was at a

145meeting and uh you know when the you know the budget was still always a problem and I uh and mandates had always been a problem the administration had always talked about the cost of mandates how much it's costing us and so I asked Governor chrisy at that point in time suppose we don't do the mandates um what will happen he says gez I don't know I don't think anything will happen and he he set up a was qu meeting for some with some of his U State administrators and they never came with a clear uh answer as to what would happen if we didn't do some of these mandates and I talked to the some of the administrators at one of the meetings and board people and they said it would be too difficult to

146figure out you know some of these mandates are involved with other programs and things this nature but I I think uh with our tough times here it uh would be worthwhile to see if there's some way to determine if we can find out how much these mandates that the state is uh forcing on us that we may feel is are not necessary and to the extent we can do that say hey we're not going to do them and and you know use that money there funds for other other things that we feel are more important it's just a thought I think you uh I would appreciate it if you would give some consideration and figure out how you can do it thank you anyone else from the public seeing no one we can move thought

147close session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through1 col 4-21 to discuss the following subjects Personnel matter following closed session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists so I have a second Mr nin um any discussion we could vote all in favor I Iain abstain one about how long you think no I'm going in I just about 15 minutes we'll be back okay we're still in session session I'm ready for our third uh public forum but I see no one from the public so

148I'm assuming no one from the public wants to come to the podium with that let me state that the um next schedule board meeting is Wednesday May 11th 7 o'clock here in the high school I'd also like to remind everyone about the May 9th uh student advis growth advisory uh committee at the middle school at 7 o'clock uh we're up to adjournment can I have a a motion to adjourn second okay all in favor I I no opposed okay we are returned thank you eight motion carries good

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.