CorpusRecord 132963

Monroe Township Board of Education 03.16.16 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,857 words · about 72 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001joined us in the pledge I'd like to ask our student board member Mr Barney to lead us in the pledge of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you we have our roll call Mr wski miss armenio here Mr Braverman here Mr de Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs K Pano here Mr noin here Mr Corino here Mr Ryback here Mr Russo and Mr rutsky Mr board president you have a quorum present this evening thank you very much let's move through approval of before we do that in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the

002date time and place thereof posted March 11th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you now we'll move the approval of the minutes um do I have a motion to approve the public Board of Education minutes of the meeting meeting of January 13th 2016 I have a second okay any discussion could vote all in favor I opposed abstain recused motion passes uh can I have a motion to approve the minutes of the Clos session meeting January 13 2016 motion second second okay any discussion could vote all in favor I opposed I don't hear you folks pause abstain recuse motion passes we'll move through our student board members report try not to spill this okay so the first thing I have is the

003girls basketball team won the Central Jersey Championship the entire school is really proud of their work and wishes them the best of luck in the future uh the winter Color Guard placed first at a competition at Hatboro horim High School later uh late last month and the coral department is holding a coffee house this week where students can sing and enjoy uh various snacks and my last thing is the academic team has advanced to the finals at the bre bright competition and is competing for first place next week the uh this year's Mr Monroe um competition was recently held which is a fun-spirited competition amongst some of the seniors in the high school um this Friday fbaa will be holding holding its uh second karaoke night which will serve as a fundraiser in order to

004help uh provide scholarships for seniors and send students who qualifi to the National Conference at um the DECA state competition there were several members who qualified as finalist and uh a few who qualified for the international Career Development conference uh in which they will be competing against students from um all 50 states DC and over eight countries in their respective events uh this Sunday the youth and government pre- legislative Conference was held at um uh was held which uh consisted of uh several hundred students from across the state of New Jersey engaging in a mock mock session of um of the state government this leading up to the conference in April and finally the student growth advisory committee met in order to discuss the concern of the increasing student population um at this point it's

005uh more of narrowing it down between some of the options that we have as well as uh Pres presenting challenges and advantages for uh each of the options that were proposed to the administration for further consideration Mr board president that concludes my report thank you both very much and now I'd like to move to the presentation uh and public hearing for the preliminary 2016 2017 school budget and for that I'd like to turn over to Dr kak and Mr Gorski gentlemen thank you putting the lights down I guess sets the atmosphere good evening everyone as you know um it's my honor to present the 2016 2017 budget along with my esteemed colleague Mr M Michael Gorski our business administrator Dr Alek uh is on District business and unfortunately could not uh be here tonight but

006uh she's with us uh in spirit I would like to start out by for the Public's um point of view just to introduce the members of the Board of Education starting with our board president Mr Steven Ryback Mr Thomas noste our vice president Miss Michelle armenio Mr Marvin Braverman Miss Jill Deo Mr Lou Koffman Miss Kathy calapan Miss Dawn cor Corino Mr Frank Russo of course our Jamesburg representative Mr Paul rutsky and our two student Representatives Mr sead aib Jamal and Mr Nicholas thorney I pronounce it correct okay all right the construction of the budget takes the work of a lot of people and for the board the finance committee is course uh Primary in uh helping to construct the budget so I would like to introduce the finance committee the chairperson of the finance

007committee is Mr Tom noin Mr Luke Koffman is our vice chair Miss cath Kathy kapovich Miss Don Corino and Miss Melle Michelle armeno is our alternate member and uh at times as last night um Mr Russo stepped in as well we appreciate that our vision statement the is the Monroe Township Board of Education commits itself to all children by preparing them to reach their full potential and to function in a global Society through a preeminent education the mission statement is the Monro public schools in collaboration with members of the community shall ensure that all children receive an exemplary education by a well-trained committed staff in a safe and orderly environment and our district goals goal number one is to develop a plan to recommend to the board to address enrollment group and Facilities uh needs

008and to begin implementation of the board approved plan goal number two expansion of two-way communication with all stakeholders in the Monroe Community including but not limited to the the utilization of con uh Constant Contact social media and in-person meetings and our Third District goal to complete an external audit of the special education program from kindergarten through 12th grade to ensure continued delivery of the highest quality services to meet the needs of our children in the most costeffective and efficient manner possible our board also develops goals and the board goals are the first goal is to have 100% uh particip ipation on the board's self- evaluation and the superintendent evaluation goal number two to provide support for the board approved plan for enrollment go growth and facilities and facility needs once the plan is developed and

009moved forward and goal number three to review the board committee's organization and structure process brings us to the executive summary our role is as I'm not going to read this exactly off of the slide but I like to elaborate rather than read it to you can all read it and either now or you know whatever time you would like to but our role as Educators is to meet the needs of the students I believe we met that obligation in this budget the programs that we are providing uh in this budget are comprehensive and rigorous which which will prepare our students for college and a career one of the challenges we that we face is our growing or our increasing student growth which adds approximately 250 to 300 students per year the finance committee challenged myself

010Mr Gorski and Dr alvic after the budget philosophy to meet the needs of the students deal with the underfunding by the state and still present the budget underc cap by $600,000 which is a feat that we have uh met we have not met in several years however this budget does meet that goal we are doing this while still meeting our Capital needs such as replacing the roof at Woodland School to present a budget that is under cap and meets the needs of the students and the facy needs well if you don't mind me saying it's it's it's extraordinary this budget does it and does it effectively we are also continuing to collaborate with mayor Tambora and Senator green Greenstein and recently we met with Senate President Sweeney to present our case of the increasing student

011enrollment and the flat State funding from this budget presentation I respectfully asked the board and the members of the community to take four points away from this presentation basically they are number one that this budget meets the needs of all students so that we may continue to prepare students to be successful in college career and in life that IT addresses The Faculty needs that it's that the budget manages with a budget cap and with the current underfunding by the state and that the budget presented is $600,000 under cap with that I would like to turn the presentation now over to Mr Gorski thank you thank you doctor key budgetary considerations for this year number one this theme is a carryover from previous years with increasing student enrollment we have a slide uh coming in a

012few that will really impactfully uh present to you how our enrollment has grown over the last eight years plus we are doing our job by having projections for the next five and the next 10 years and the uh the rate of student growth is only going to intensifying we have aging facilities a number of our facilities need roofs Windows HVAC systems and large items your board of education has been been very responsible and has included in every budget in the last seven years at least a capital outlay project including renovation of the Monro Township Middle School renovation of Applegarth school when it was closed and reopened and um numerous roof projects Dr Alvi could better speak to the Core Curriculum content area but there are numerous expenditures throughout the budget including replacement of textbooks to

013an additional staff to meet The Core Curriculum content area requirements the first item increased student enrollment is leading to larger student teacher ratios we're becoming uncomfortable at the middle school and at the high school and we currently have a ad hoc committee um for student growth which is addressing that for a longer term solution keep in mind the budget is only a 12-month financial plan but we are hitting that at both ends and um addressing that so that we don't lose any children in an over clouded classroom or over tax a teacher so that they could teach to their full potential we adopt we met over the summer for a budget philosophy meeting that's where the board sets the tone for what they expect and prioritize in the next year's budget subsequent to that the

014finan committee met and issued Administration a challenge not only to meet the needs of 250 additional students not only to continue with our Capital Improvement programs uh this year we're doing the Woodland roof to not only to that but to expand our bus and transportation Fleet by three buses and three vans and two full-time drivers but to do all that income $600,000 under cap as Dr kak said that is a remarkable feat considering the fact that the cap is only designed to meet your operational instructional needs Monroe is meeting the operational instructional needs we are we are creating areas of higher performance within that we are upgrading our facilities and we're we're sending back to the taxpayer $600,000 out of concern for the last item on there which is the tax impact on the community

015this board and administration is very well aware of the pain and suffering that goes on when you receive your tax bills we'll get to the reasons for that in a little bit what is the budget creation timeline I mentioned the budget philosophy meeting we study historical enrollment patterns because that projects for the next 12 months what your staffing needs are going to be and what your supply needs are going to be we then uh ask all of our principles directors and supervisors to to um create budgets with a zerob based budgeting standard that means you start every year with a clean slate as I mentioned to the finance committee I taught a uh master's class at Ryder University and uh School finance and I asked everybody to bring in their budgets and um many many

016Bas put a percentage on last year and their budgets can be uh completed in a little folder that black book there is this year's School District budget and it looks the same every previous year I could tell you every Supply item I could tell you where it's going and what the cost is there is no percentage no fluff over last year no spend it or lose it philosophy here in Monroe then we put the principles through a rigorous budget defense rounds that's where we look at their budgets in in very close detail and make sure that every item is student focused and complies with all the board and District goals if it does not it is excluded it is also scrutinized for efficiency if there's a cheaper and more effective way to do it it's

017recommended then there there's a governor's address the third week of February and state aid is to follow 48 hours after that date um then we adopt the tenative budget that's this evening's purpose once it's thoroughly presented to the public and then finally in April we have a final public hearing thank you for the opportunity to share with you the great work that we will be continuing with this budget I apologize that I could not be there this evening but if you have any questions I will be happy to answer them for you with the implementation of the Common Core State Standards in 2010 we have been consistently revising our curriculum to meet those standards including professional development for all staff each summer we consider which curriculum need revisions and are mapping our curriculum for vertical

018alignment our English language arts program for grades K to8 includes a balanced literacy approach which includes Reading Writing speaking viewing and listening components Monro teachers utilize a combination of direct instruction and workshop models to implement balanced literacy this ensures that we are meeting each student at their level and planning instruction for individual students Wilson Reading and the decoding strategies are used for students in elementary special education programs for those students with decoding deficiencies in grades K to 5 students are taught math standards through the envisions math program and grades 6 through 8 utilize Connected Mathematics program both offer our students real life authentic problem solving while instilling the skills necessary to achieve the higher levels this year we are incorporating the common course standard align versions of our programs this year we are required to

019implement the Next Generation science standards in grades 6 through 12 we have been planning for this transition over the last several years and are ready to design curriculum and instruction for implementation in September grades K to 5 will be implemented the following year each school offers students the opportunity to participate in Hands-On science programs including our school Gardens many schools have partnered with Community groups and Boy and Girl Scout Troops to build and enhance our Gardens we have also received two grants to help fund these efforts STEM Science technology engineering and Mathematics are being implemented and promoted throughout the district this integration gives students the opportunities to solve real world problems think Al and engage in the design process you have heard us talk about our preparations for Park testing this has included technology integration

020throughout our classrooms including Study Island word processing and assessment preparation through the testnav site our students utilize technology often as evidenced in teachers lesson plans and visits throughout the schools more teachers are using Google Apps for Education and Google Classroom to enhance the collaboration between teacher and students in grades K to3 we utilize the Dr 2 assessment developmental reading assessment dr2 is an individually administered assessment of a child's reading capabilities it is a tool to be used by teachers to identify a student's reading level accuracy fluency and comprehension once levels are identified a teacher can use this information for instructional planning purposes we are researching other standardized assessment tools to ensure we are giving our students every opportunity to meet the standards we offer many athletic and co-curricular programs for all of our students many

021of our sports teams have won championships and our clubs and tag programs offer enrichment programs in many subjects for our students we have worked together across the district to analyze the success and involvement in all of our programs to ensure we are being fiscally responsible while giving our students opportunities they need to prepare for College and Career Readiness since the Inception of the Hib law we have continued to expand our character education programs throughout our schools all schools offer incentives for students caught doing good and each School implements the law and procedures to their Fidelity the decrease in HIV instances is evidence of the success of our programs we currently offer 28 AP courses and have 820 students enrolled many students take multiple AP courses each year and all students who are enrolled are expected

022to take the AP exams our special education program offers many programs to meet the needs of our diverse population the preschool utilizes the high scope curriculum and we have continued our in gred preschool program if there is a need for adaptive technology we have implemented processes such as the iPad for students who are non-communicative we offer assessment and placement for any English language Learners in several of our schools and the extended school year program is in place to assist those students who need it so there is minimal loss of skills over the extended summer break we've received a grant to support our Falcon Life program at the high school where our special education students partner with our general education students in activities and community service many opportunities are available to the adults in our community

023Through the adult education program current offerings include courses in the Arts including fine and Performing computer technology culinary arts Finance foreign language health and well-being history and Sports and Fitness our professional development program is a model program across the country it offers our staff a differentiated approach to meet their professional learning needs staff members participate in year-long PD courses or create a project in collaboration with other staff members under the supervision of a district administrator we currently have over a 100 staff members who have been trained as trainers and run our PD courses throughout the year we also train our security paraprofessional and transportation staff every 10th and 11th grade student participates in the PSAT every year Avid advancement via individual determination teaches skills and behaviors for academic success provides intensive support with tutorials and

024strong student teacher relationships creates a positive peer group for students and develops a sense of hope for Personal Achievement gained through the hard work and determination students apply to become a part of this program which runs from grade 6 through grade 12 Avid strategies are best practices for all students so this year we've Incorporated these strategies into our professional development courses so that all teachers have access to use them with their students at all levels these are just some of the wonderful opportunities for all of the students in our schools great things are happening every day in our district we have been incorporating stem activities and Technology throughout the grades schools are growing gardens and learning about the world around them our extracurricular activities are flourishing and our teams are succeeding students are challenged at

025all levels and our teachers and administrators are Hands-On we continue to have a growing Fleet in transportation and our facilities are being used around the clock with all of the programs and support that we offer our students we have received multiple accolades the 20145 graduation rate is 97% this is a great achievement 86% of our students attended College 3% attended career in technical schools 2% entered the military 5% entered the workforce and 4% were undecided as I mentioned on the previous slide 820 students are currently enrolled in 28 AP courses and will be taking the exam in May the average scores of MTS students who participate in the SAT and ACT score higher than the state average Monro Township School District is one of 10 districts in the state of New Jersey that has been

026recognized in innovate NJ innovate NJ is New Jersey's initiative to support Innovation and practice by fostering sharing and collaboration cultivating projects and convening practitioners and partners we have been recognized for our one-to-one technology integration at the high school our AVID program and our world language Blended learning environment in grades 3 to five innovate NJ is inviting other districts to participate in this endeavor but we were one of the first districts to be recognized Monro Township High School has been recognized as a transformative School the first annual transformative School awards recognized Innovative high schools that utilize Alternative Learning and Technology to modernize the educational experience the awards celebrate Technology Innovation and Alternative Learning in America's High School classrooms mths exhibits an incredible focus on technology as a learning mechanism and has set a bar for connected

027classrooms programs include iPads for students and teachers to extend their education via 24/7 access to information online course options an amplified in-class experience through Apple TV collaboration based wikis electronic books and one-on-one electronic communications between parents and staff members US News and World Report identified Monroe Township High School as one of the best high schools in the country by awarding them the silver medal in 2014 there are numerous New Jersey schools in the 2014 US News best high schools rankings including 25 with gold medals 19 with silver medals and 32 with bronze medal medal this award is based on our student performance on AP tests as well as District data the programs that we currently use and the support we offer our staff and students have led us to these Awards and we will continue

028to provide the excellent education to all students thank you for allowing me to present via video tonight I fully support this budget it is a challenge to continue to do all of the great things and include all the new demands from the state but our staff does an amazing job thank you [Music] as Dr alvic mentioned we are expanding our bus fleet with three 54 passenger buses three 24 passenger vans and two full-time drivers we had a uh less than satisfactory School opening as far as Transportation this year and a lot of our problems most of our problems were directly related to contracted routes where drivers were familiar with Monroe areas due to turnover of drivers even though they had been previously required to have a dry run by bringing back these runs in in

029District we can ensure better service and uh more continuity of driver and Service as I mentioned before also in this budget is a $1.2 million Woodland roof replacement project the picture on the left shows an aerial view of the Woodland roof and it's all being replaced what looks to be uh somewhat new is that black area but that is nothing more than a rubber membrane tarp that was put on there for a 5-year temporary um um pause in the water leaking so that we could address it through the budget key facts on Monroe state aid there are two types of state aid the first Equalization Aid is a type of state aid which is the larg type and it's designed to support a District's adequacy budget the state requires that every student receive a free

030and thorough and efficient education that is provided by a District's adequacy budget there are two metrics that determine how state aid is distributed through Equalization Aid it is based solely upon wealth which is the aggregate filings from your New Jersey 1040s with four-digit municipal code and also the valuation of ratables from your particular town both of those metrics uh in the state's determination uh are require that Monroe receive zero Equalization Aid because the state deems us to have the wherewithal to provide their full adequacy budget we have addressed this uh with State officials and we're going to talk more about that in a little while categorical Aid is the second type of state aid this is based upon different categories and um you qualify based upon number of special education students for special education Aid

031your transportation Aid is determined by your transportation efficiency rating which is part of a large fall report that's prepared by our transportation department by the way our transportation rating is the highest in Middle sex County and among the highest in the state and qualifies us for the largest Transportation award however that's not what we receive because all the categorical categories Transportation special education security Aid and more are phased out for the amount of money that a district is over adequacy spending above what the state hypothetically has determined a a prototypical school should cost and furthermore it is phased in over a five-year period state aid in the 16117 budget only repres resents 3% of the total revenues to support the school budget and that's one of the lowest state aid per pupil ratios in the

032county I draw your attention to the first handout sources of revenue that's where all budgets Begin by identifying what Revenue sources you have for the next year we were set up extraordinarily well in the 1617 budget year because of incredible efficiencies created in the 1415 budget that was the year that was just audited and there were numerous accounts where we spent less than what we appropriated or recognized revenues greater than what we had budgeted the aggregate of those two creates a Aid Surplus uh uh called extra um uh excess Surplus and that carries over over 2 years from 1415 to through battles with Horizon Healthcare through purchase order freezes at unnecessary times for purchases during the year from purchasing consortiums where we've saved over $2 million in the last four years on District supplies we

033created a surplus that that ballooned $2.2 million more than the previous year from that $2.2 million the board put $975,000 responsibly in a capital reserve account that could meet the needs of any project identified in our five-year facilities plan or it can even be used by resolution as a down payment on a bond referendum if that should be the result of the ad hoc committee you may notice the second item on there is transfers from other funds previously we had uh transferred $8 million over installment period into the B Debt Service budget which lowered taxes there was some concern what's going to happen when that money runs out then we're going to see the real taxes coming through well we plan for this and we use the stimulus of that Surplus money from the savings

034gained on this construction of the school when ratables were dropping 70 to 72 million each year and when that money was extinguished we are we are now in an area where we have 2% uh ratable growth to create a stable tax schedule another Revenue source of importance is the tuition we receive from our receiving uh District Jamesburg to meet the obligation of the indebtedness and in the in the spirit of the agreement Jamesburg has aggressively budgeted more tuition um than what could be reasonably accepted from the agreement and that will lead to um paying off that obligation sooner we have every confidence that in the seven-year period you will see major gains in the reduction of that number if it's not completely extinguished by then state aid is a very disappointing category there's another handout

035I'll get to in a minute but we received an increase in state aid this year of just about $15,000 net despite what you read in the papers our net state aid increase from the different categories was only an increase of $155,000 basically the cost of what it what uh be to take on one additional student not the 250 to 300 that Dr kak alluded to that we're expecting before next I draw your attention to the state aid history um handout which is letter b and you could see the different type of state aid categories from that sheet and that's a cumulative schedule and I want to draw everybody's attention to the 10-11 year because a fundamental shift in the responsibility for financing Public Schools occurred that year and affected the taxpayers in Monroe greatly state

036aid was cut to the general fund to a low amount of about 238,000 $4.6 million of state aid was reduced at a very last minute in the budget cycle the state put in a a crafty provision allowing districts who didn't have enough time to manage a $4.4 million cut right before the preliminary budget was supposed to be done to roll that into the local tax levy to sustain their programs basically the state shifted $4.4 million because we were able to cut about 200 into the local tax levy from an obligation which used to be theirs and it's remained ever since this is a pie chart of what makes up our miscellaneous Revenue category our schools are used throughout 24 hours a day seven days a week uh we have a lot of Revenue coming from

037use of building fees we have solar energy credits from the oak tree School adult education program brings in about 25,000 our transportation director aggressively seeks trans Transportation joint ches which is a fancy word for sharing a ride with other districts where we may have kids going in the same place to save money preschool integrated program brings in about $90,000 of Revenue inin comes down to about 10,000 Sports admissions is about 30,000 and we recycle every product that has no use here in the district and that brought in is projected to bring in $88,500 this is where the budget begins with enrollment and according to our demographer the 16 17 school year is expected to have an increase of 258 students and ladies and gentlemen I'll tell you that's a very conservative number we're expecting more

038along the lines of 300 this is an analysis of our enrollment over the last eight years we picked up 1,330 students over the past eight years students Drive budget cost this slide shows the disparity between our enrollment growth and state aid as you could see in the 10-11 year State a dropped to an incredible level including Debt Service Aid of 860,000 but the general fund only had 238,000 of that money to spend and then there was a deadcat bounce where it's about $3 million now and it's stayed there ever since despite the growing enrollment our state aid is one is is 39% almost 40% less than what it was eight years ago despite the fact that our enrollment has grown over 25% where does the money go when you combine the benefits allocated to the

039teaching staff which is about 3/4 of the benefits p over 60% of expenditures go directly on instruction Transportation about 5 and a half% other is maintenance of plan and Facilities 7.69 grants capital projects administrations 2.8% Debt Service is about 9% Athletics co-curricular one and benefits as I'm mentioned is is 20% I could talk for an hour just on on the benefits line item in the budget it's one of the most material line items we got a uh projection this year from Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of a 16 a half% increase through aggressive negotiations through competitive contracts from a mer Health who's in Monroe and would love to get in here we got uh alternate quotes and went back to Horizon and negotiated the 16 a half% increase down to currently 8 A2 that's a

040savings of $1.7 million from the initial proposal and we're not done yet and we're not going to be completed until late July when we have to finalize the schedule we're waiting for claims information and we're going to we're going to present every argument we can to negotiate Health Care down to a manageable number last year Health Care Net on on the budget was about about 3% increase the this year we're looking at about a 7% net increase through the fruits of the negotiation labor agreements all staff now are paying tier 4 chapter 78 rates up to 35% of their health benefit costs which total $3.4 million to reduce that category this year we have an offsetting um uh amount to that because there's a need which a lot of it has been P pent up

041over the last few years to hire 22 additional staff the majority of which are teaching members and all those full-time staff are required to have benefits the unions have negotiated two cheaper health benefit plans have negotiated out our Cadillac plan which was the traditional health plan to save money co-pays have gone up every single year and staff is is truly uh pulling their weight with health benefits where does the money go it does not go to administrative costs I can show you that from this chart despite the fact that the county limit for administrative spending grows to this year1 1900 $1,990 per pupil Monro per pupil spending has decreased for the last three years initiatives like taking in a legal counselor inhouse on payroll instead of um um paying W Goldman Spitzer has been benefited

042the district with over $100,000 of savings and has brought um good legal advice to Administration making all of us more productive I'd like to draw your attention to the Appropriations detail which is the larger stapled item from this sheet you will notice that a lot of the salary line items have increases of 2.75% some are less depending on what bargaining group we're talking about but that doesn't tell the whole story because there were major concessions on on other benefits and um conferences and and stiens being eliminated so the net effect of that across the board is really only about 2% but it's spread through different categories I mentioned we have 22 new full-time equivalents the majority of which are teachers teaching staff members are required because of number one student growth number two special education

043needs to meet a student's least restrictive environment an autistic class for example requires eight students per one teacher ratio and it's it's very costly but requirement uh that we face and um that that's and I mentioned we are hiring new bus drivers and that's 22 new full-time equivalents a lot of these were truly needed for the past few years but have been deferred and cannot be deferred any longer the middle school which is where we're seeing the most um congestion is getting a full team of teachers which is a total of eight 354 passenger buses 324 passenger vans two drivers um we are replacing bleachers at the high school and a $1.2 million roof replacement project at Woodland School what you should draw from this report is the amount of negatives that you see throughout

044in various categories that's a result of very meticulous zero based budgeting um at its best healthc care is under control and um Dr kak and I and the administrative team are very pleased with the appropriation detail that we've presented tonight I mentioned before how our district is harmed by being over adquate quacy adequacy is a hypothetical model that the state created from State officials retired superintendents members of the public to design what a typical school should cost what a typical School labor agreement should consist of how many special ed and at risk students this typical school should have and they Project based upon your number of students an adequacy budget this year's budget for 1617 reduces our over adequacy budgeting uh spending by 32% a decrease of $4.3 million that will make us more eligible

045for categorical Aid going forward and demonstrates the efficiency created in this budget we have numerous cost savings from shared services our Fine Food Service Department led by Mrs mitac who's here um provides lunches to the academy Learning Center to share costs we recycle everything that's possible and it brings in extra Revenue transportation services with joint ches I mentioned before purchasing we've saved over $2 million by buying anything that can be considered a consumable supply item through the district through a countywide Consortium that buys in bulk technology Services utilities charge a e-rate tax we we apply for that tax money to come back as an offset of our technology purchases and we get about $100,000 a year from eate insurance coverage I mentioned mentioned before plus we pull our risk in uh the New Jersey school

046boards Association Insurance Group for property and casualy and we have um growing alliances with the municipality to save money for the taxpayers the tennis courts are being restored on Schoolhouse Road at a cost of $300,000 and there's two potential land donations that are on the table that are being studied by the ad hoc committee the municipality and the school district recognize that whether it comes from the left pocket or the right pocket it's coming from the same taxpayer and we're coordinating our efforts to to reduce the burden what factors influence the tax rate number one on IRP disputably is state aid we receive zero Equalization Aid only 3% of the budget is from state aid and if we were to have a reasonable amount of state aid if the state was even to fully fund

047the formula that they designed to support schools we would have a tax reduction put through that would make your head spin fund balance applied this is one of the factors that Administration can control by aggressively managing the budget and um recognizing every Revenue possible sharing every cost and creating efficiencies ratables is the aggregate property Valu valuables through the whole Township and and fortunately they grew over 2% for the 1617 school year which basically means that there are more people sharing the tax levy which makes everybody's individual rate lower and finally but not last is increased student enrollment that has had a great effect on Appropriations I mentioned last year that I went through three years of those budget books there that you see and we have a lot of detail in there and I was

048able to to create a list of every appropriation that has to do with student growth when they are aggregated and removed from the budget and the tax recalculated last year we would have had a zero tax increase for the three-year period had it not been for the effects of growth how does that affect your pocketbook we're doing all these wonderful things student performance is growing last year's budget increased 4.5 cents this year's budget with all those additional items by going under cap through all of the gains that we had in budget efficiencies and excess Surplus which carry over to next year as I mentioned 3.5 Cent increase the 10-year mean or average increase for the school district is 7% uh 7 cents this year's budget for 1617 is half the mean a very attractive rate

049of increase how does that affect an average assessed home last year an average assessed home of $39,000 went up $138.4 this year that burden of increase is reduced to $18.66 significantly less and that's on an average assessed home this year of about $36,000 now of course if you live in a in a more extravagant home maybe valued twice that then you would simply multiply that increase by two and then it would be as much as $216 for a home assessed above $600,000 but the average home according to the municipality from all the data that they have is $366,000 and the increase in burden is is a very reasonable $18.66 the School District budget has has not been below cap since the school funding Reform Act of 2008 and this is truly a remarkable feat in

050my opinion to be at this stage and give $600,000 back to the community to take $1.1 million at least and repair the facil the facilities that belong to this community meet the needs of all students coming in and there are very diverse needs and very costly needs in special ed categories and to do so with a very below the mean reason reasonable tax increase I would like to thank everybody and especially the finance committee and the administrative staff who contributed to the development of this very complex and sophisticated budget I will now read the resolution then the board will deliberate on the resolution and then we will open it up to a public forum thank you be it resolved by the Monroe Township Board of Education that this 201627 tentative general fund budget be adopted

051in the amount of 108,411 3,769 and a tenative general fund local tax levy in the amount of 95,4 31,6 184 and a tenative special Revenue Fund in the amount of 1,124 557 and a tenative Debt Service budget in the amount of 10,831 8177 and a tenative Debt Service local tax levy in the amount of 10,225 whereby the tenative 201627 budget totals 1220 m1704 and whereas the monre Township Board of Education has been notified of state aid amounts and where as such State a amounts are for the 201617 categorical special education Aid is $1,976 18119 and for the 16117 categorical security Aid is $13,750 and for the 1617 categorical Transportation Aid is $ 57,7 2017 and for The 16117 Debt Service Aid is $68,400 and for the 1617 other state aid consisting of Park Readiness Aid

052of 588,000 980 and per pupil Grant Aid of $58,900 and professional Learning Community Aid of $62,500 whereas the monre Township Board of Education has estimated a state aid amount pursuant to application for the 1617 the estimated extraordinary Aid amount is 24,4 53 and whereby School District bylaw 0147 policy 3440 policy 4440 and njac 6A 23b 1.2b provides that the Board of Education shall establish an annual school budget a maximum expenditure amount that may be allotted for such travel and expense reimbursement for the 16 17 school year now therefore be it resolved that the Monro Township Board of Education hereby establishes the school district travel maximum for the 201617 school year at the tenative sum of $158,400 unchanged and be it resolved that the school business administrator shall track and record these costs to ensure that

053the maximum amount is not exceeded and whereas as a result of the extraordinary budget efficiencies created by the administrative stewardship of the budget which led to an increase in excess Surplus as an alternative Revenue source to taxes the board has budgeted $600,000 under cap not withstanding the community and equity in state aid funding as well as the significant student growth and widespread facility needs in the district and now therefore let it be resolved that the superintendent of schools and the business administrator board secretary file the required documents with the executive County Superintendent move you beat me to it thank you um we have a motion to approve the resolution uh and it was moved do we have any discussion Alin well first off as chairman of the finance committee I'd want to thank uh the

054administration uh for all their hard work uh especially Mr Gorski this finance committee gave them a challenge Mr Gorski always says you give us uh give us the cake that you want made and they will make they will make it with the and they'll come up with the recipe I think that's the exact word um and we did we we gave them uh a cake that we wanted we wanted to come in under cap we wanted to make sure that the public knows that we're good stewards of your money it's so important um with all of the growth in the community to make sure that when your taxes go up that they're not being wasted that they're being utilized in such a way that the efficiency level makes the taxpayer say hey I understand this

055I know why why we're doing this would we like to come in with a flat tax rate you bet you I mean I pay taxes too uh it's important to know that we all pay taxes and that we all none of us want an increase that's the bottom line but we're also realists I know when I was on the other side of the microphone I always understood the fact that I didn't like paying it but when I I saw the board working and making the effort to pinch every penny twice before it went out um that gave me some Solace knowing well it's for the kids it's for the education it's the most important thing we do as a community so uh I I'm firmly in support of this budget and I really uh am

056confident that going forward that we will continue to make the strides that we do every year in the budget because it is the most important thing we do we are tasked with educating our children in a thorough and efficient education and I believe that this budget truly does that so once again thank you to the administration thank you Mr nin anyone else Mr calman El one of the other factors that I think needs to be uh kind of highlighted because it in a way it kind of got buried in the presentation is the fact that we have a lot of commitment to special education in Monroe and that commitment and that success has a double-edged sword currently we're operating at about I think we said yesterday about 19% of our students currently in Monroe have

057some type of special education need so that that's one in five that's a ridiculously high number uh if I'm not mistaken a couple of years ago when we looked at the state average it was somewhere around 10 or 11% of the average district has uh students with special needs so we're basic basically double what the state average is and as you probably can assume that children with special needs have a tendency to increase the cost because they have special needs um so over the past few years we've been doing a lot of work to try and bring a lot of our uh special education programs which we used to Outsource to other districts uh inhouse because that's a cost saving for the district but even having done all that over the last few years we're

058still in a place where we still send out approximately 60 children a day to 28 different facilities to provide special needs uh for what their individual requirements are so given all of that which is over and above the average cost of uh students to be able to be where we are today and come in under budget it it's crazy I mean because the demands that are on the budget just by the numbers almost dictate that you can't do what it is that we're doing so um keep that in the back of your mind because sometimes these numbers when you see them on the budget they kind of get lost in the shuffle we see things that are pulled out for special education and the staff members and whatever but that equates to an enormous number

059of children that are getting Services provided not only by you know top shelf District staff but it's also being done inhouse so we don't don't have to have the students uh on buses for two or three hours so um just think of that as well when you're contemplating all the stuff that that we do on a daily basis and again thanks to the team to for doing this I don't know how you do it but thank you thank you Mr calman anyone else yes Miss k pwit um I I think it's important to note too that I believe Mr Gorski you said that we received $115,000 more from the state this year than last year and I know that as of February 25th of this year we've had an additional 347 new students enrolled in

060our district so the $15,000 covered one student and so therefore we have to ask the taxpayers to cover the other 346 students and um not that's not fair I also noted that um we are receiving almost a half a million dollars less this year than we did back in 2009 and 2010 and over that period of time we've added approximately 1,00 students so we're adding a lot of students we're not getting our fair share of tax money and we're obligated obligating our community to pay for all our new students so I I just thought that was important to note thank you Miss K any anyone else uh i' I'd like to um chime in and just support what my colleagues who was saying you know it's miraculous I have to use that word to to

061have a budget that meets the educational needs of this District so that we can keep surging forward the way we're going especially with the new numbers of students that we're we're U seeing every year and yet come in $600,000 on the cap uh it's a credit to our Administration Mr Gorski Dr kosac Dr Alvi and certainly to our financial committee I congratulate all of you uh I know we're sitting here all in in in in Wonderman and how we were able to do this but uh I guess we have the right people working in the in the right places so um we were able to do this and it was a great accomplishment thank you all M armonia um I too am um appreciative of the efforts that have been put in uh by the

062Board of Education and the staff espec um with the amount of residential housing and construction going on in Monroe in in enormous uh amounts um and and that residential construction obligates the community to pay for more and more students and which we and the staff does a very good job in welcoming but I do need to point out that we are in a very rapid growth period with uh and it's difficult for the Board of Education to plan but everybody is really pitching in and and doing uh a wonderful job and I so I'd also like to thank the budget round participants um as Mr Gorski and Dr kak has said uh the principles and supervisors and school administrators all got together and actually um I think did a very very good job and made

063sacrifices I'm sure that the board is unaware of because we don't really micromanage those issues um but the Administration has heard our our budgetary needs and has done a very good job and also when I was on the other side of the aisle I also worried about the spending habits because it's about spending I think it's been over a decade now that we haven't received adequate uh state aid so I've always been concerned that we really need to concentrate on what we do in house and I would like to thank um and acknowledge some of the decisions that have been made by the board but also the recommendations of the superintendent and uh Mr Gorski uh he brought in a fabulous I have to point this out and I'm sure I'm leaving out a lot

064of other things but he brought in a fabulous attorney for us an in-house attorney that has been absolutely wonderful and had has reduced our costs greatly and I know that administrators have pitched in and even the teachers and staff that have changed their benefits and had to um incur some of the cost so they've shared they've shared the pain with uh all of the residents so I do appreciate that and I have I mean it's it's good to to go into the schools before a budget hearing because I was able to go to some of the reading uh read Across America and I read I think four times along with some other board members um in the schools and to see how the schools function on a daily basis um is very important and I

065am really grateful for everyone who has who's done a great job and the budget reflects a lot of hard work so I appreciate Mr Gorski and Dr kak and Mr uh noin who I think is brilliant on the finance committee so I'm very grateful for his um his efforts and and I rely on him a lot to explain things to me so I want to say thank you thank you m anyone else in that case uh we're going to have a special public for right now uh just on the budget if anyone from the public is wishing to come up and speak uh you'll have 3 minutes uh time limit and also I just ask you to state your name clearly and your address is anyone from the public wishing to come up and speak

066to the budget not seeing anyone uh we can go to vote mron Miss armenio yes Mr Braverman yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr C man yes Mrs Cole Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky yes Mr board president it is my pleasure to announce that resolution to accept the tenative budget has passed unanimously and and likewise I would like to thank Dr aloc Dr kak and and Mr noin and the rest of the board for This truly group project and putting together the budget thank you thank you Mr bski thank you all again okay we can move to uh committee reports I know we must have a few is there any committee chair that's wishing to report at this time an outside well of course

067we had a finance committee uh meeting that kind of goes without saying I'm not going to dwell on that um we just had uh a proposal for a temporary bookkeeper to fill a leave and uh the board uh recommended uh to go with that um I'm going to defer to Mr Braverman we did have a a building grounds and transportation or will you be giving a um no you can go right ahead um yeah okay that concludes my finance committee now you want to do the bg& yes I'm the vice chair of that and I wasn't sure if he he was going to do it or not but obviously uh if you're not going to do it I'll do it um we uh went into a little more details on on the township land donation

068on Route 522 um behind the uh Firehouse there was some discussion about how that land was given to the or potentially given to the board of ed it was my our understanding at the committee that it was actually um listed as open space and there were some concerns as to whether that was the correct uh dedication of that property uh when it was felt it should be for municipal use so we were concerned with there maybe there were some other uh requirements that we would have to go through so the uh Administration said that they will check into that and then get back to the building grounds and Transportation uh committee uh we went over the uh details on the Woodland School roof replacement that Mr Gorski elaborated on in the in the budget uh

069about the bids coming in uh the low bidder was Integrity Roofing um we also went over the uh tennis court upgrade project We R red some of the drawings and uh Mr Tay gave an a fantastic presentation on the facility's workforce overview he went into detail um basically right down to every single uh uh urinal cake um and and and all the the efforts that the that the staff does you know kind of behind the scenes that you know we're as the building grounds of Transportation we're not even aware of it and it was just phenomenal to see uh how it all comes together and it it was very very informative so I thank him for that great um that great presentation uh we also went into the middle CES County manal and Watershed projects

070uh there were some uh potential grant money to uh come down uh Mr John rigs from the environmental coordinator from the township he basically uh said right now they've done the study but there may be money to uh try to improve the uh the amount of the impervious ground cover in the district so that was that's part of a a grant that could be coming uh in in the future and of course last but not least is the water testing with the water testing uh in the news uh practically on a daily basis now especially even in New Jersey at the last building grounds and Transportation uh meeting the committee suggested that we test the older schools for lead um it has now been the committee's recommendation at that point to test all the schools

071uh with uh and using an outside uh independent contractor the uh mtud the Monro town utility department is also uh going to be doing uh the same uh sampling the same testing using a different lab so we're going to really since this is such an important issue we're going to have two independent Labs two independent uh Samplers uh taking these samples and then coming up with the results because uh we want to make sure that the Integrity of the testing um proves the the results are the same no matter who does the testing so that was also something that was tested and I think there's a I see something here I think to uh recommend that for tonight for on the agenda so um and that concludes my report Mr President thank you Mr nin

072any other committee report yes M Mr May um the student growth advisory committee met on Monday March 14th um this is our third meeting um from previous meetings we had identified five possible solutions to the growth problem we are experien this meeting we took those Solutions we broke off into groups of four or five we had about eight groups and we looked at each possible solution every group created pros and cons for that solution um and you know we got to comment on all of them we presented them to the group the administration now is going to take those consolidate them they're going to go back and do some rough estimates on the cost of each of these Solutions um that will probably take them we're giv them to May to do that they're going

073to come back in May and give us some cost estimates and then we're going to um review them again so the next time we meet is in May thank you Mr Mayo I just to ask a question on that committee reporter now I'm Sor may I ask a question oh absolutely uh what are some of those potential solution Solutions or are we not going to no no no um uh some of them were split session an addition to the high school a new K to 12 Elementary School K to K to eight K to8 excuse me K to 8 K to six K to six you're confusing me now K to 6 Elementary School and possibly um what a four five and am I missing one 56 56 56 a 56 school thank you 4

074five6 56 56 it's 56 Mr as soon as those minutes are are typed up we'll put them in Google Drive as well any question any other question any other committee chair Mia okay the policy committee met and we did go over several policies uh there are policies tonight uh that we're going to to put on I think for a first reading and then there are policies for second reading this evening uh policy 143 point it's not actually a bylaw thanks to Mr thorney's um involvement uh it is a bylaw not a policy and it has to do with student representation to the Board of Education one of the things that was uh just sort of stipulated by a recommendation from our in-house attorney uh is that uh the the students can uh serving serving on

075the Committees which we welcome uh the students as well as the public to come to committee meetings uh they cannot however participate or participate in a way that uh is in an actual deliberation fashion so we had to just um change some of the wording in that to match the next policy which was Zero uh which was also a bylaw 0155 which was board committees so we also on the board committees removed a non-existing committee uh so we would be consistent with the reality and we removed a governance committee uh the next uh regulation was 2431 uh member of a public Mr poy last uh week me uh last month mentioned a concern he had about the regulation for uh prevention and treatment of sports related concussions and head injuries that recommendation has not been

076put into this policy from for tonight's reading but we will be in uh incorporating uh it's not incorporated into this policy this evening but it is under advisement and will be re-evaluated by the policy committee it was a good idea uh the reg the other policies are uh accept uh teachers and staff members acceptable use of computers computer network and computers and Resources by teachers and staff members it's just uh standards that we just wanted to update and revise and they are again all on the uh mono Township Board website Family Leave which was mandated uh it was this teaching uh teaching staff members family leave and it's just a mandated policy that we again revised and and are just um hopefully approving this evening any question from Miss almeno committee report thank you all

077um we now have our public uh forum and this is to addess the agenda only if any member of the public is interested in coming up and asking a question or making a comment please state your name clearly your address and you'll have a three minute time limit uh to do that Mr boy uh good evening Doug PO for tamarak Road um just a clarification in terms of revenue for next year uh what is the amount that we're anticipating from the uh KP program in combination with the uh before and after school Child Care Program evening Mr Po those two proprietary programs that you just mentioned are not part of the overall budget they are separate Enterprise funds um I was pleased to present a interim financial statement for both and and I'm going by

078memory now but for the four months of the year where we reported ECE had a net income of about $40,000 and the new Falcon Care Program had a interim profit of about $100,000 so both funds are doing well and we um we're pleased with the results they have exceeded our expectations but again they are not part of the school district budget which just consists of the general fund special Revenue fund which is Grants and CB idea um Capital outlay fund and Debt Service fund uh thank you uh then how do how or at least clarify for me how those funds get expended going into the future if they're not part of our operating budget we had uh prepared a business plan for both of those activities and uh through adherence to that plan and constant

079uh management of the financial statements we actually just met uh this week administratively and recommended um that the revenues and the prices uh be addressed for next year and we'll report on that at the next finance committee meeting okay I still have a question I'm sorry about that uh I was under the impression when I was on the board that the money generated from that proprietary fund would help reduce uh or would be considered or used as Revenue to the budget but but it sounds as if what I'm hearing tonight that's not the case that's an excellent question and um you're mostly correct um it was uh recommended by the Board of Education to allow these programs to develop some roots and some foundation in the form of retained earnings um also meeting the obligation

080of paying off the loan to the general fund and at such time that the each of these has ample retained earnings then um it'll be our recommendation that uh the finance committee study the use of that extra money okay thank you uh one other comment uh I I both in the budget presentation as well as in a comment made by one of the board members uh it's mentioned that student growth is uh somewhere the vicinity of 250 to 300 students per year and yet when I look at the student enrollment data that's in the agenda tonight and that has been in the past agendas for this past school year I see that the uh growth over the past well from one month to the to the same month a year ago has been about 150

081students so I just find that a little confusing and I I want to raise that issue uh because when we're talking about student growth in the community uh we're seeing one thing in the agenda but we're hearing other things when uh members of the board or Administration are commenting on it uh and that's just a comment uh but on state do I still have time yes two minutes on state eight I did some calculations based on the figures uh available on the uh New Jersey Department of Education website and I think it might be informative to the public if not to members of the board uh to share some of that information with you uh briefly for each Dollar in state aid that Monroe receives Malborough receives $411 that's for each dollar that we receive

082East Brunswick receives $635 East Windsor $6.60 Manalapan Englishtown $7 South Brunswick $835 Oldbridge $15.8 for each dollar that we receive ande whole Township $18.21 for each dollar that we receive I also found it shocking that two of our Urban special need districts in middlex County New Brunswick receives $43.75 for every dollar that we receive and Perth Amboy receives $56.64 for every dollar of state aid that Monroe receives when I see those numbers it clearly says to me that the formula for state aid is completely out of whack in terms of the reality of the situation I know I'm preaching to the choir but I think it's beneficial to the public as well as to the board to uh hear that information because it to me it's one of the reasons why Monroe is having such

083a difficult time T trying to provide for Quality education and yet keep our taxes uh in a reasonable level I cannot see how we are that radically different from South Brunswick from east wsor from freeh hole Township uh from Marlborough I mean it's it just makes no sense to me whatsoever and particularly when you take into account the ratables that some of those communities have in terms of commercial development thank you thank you Mr Po you want to comment yes um Mr board president Mr Po the figures that were in the um PowerPoint presentation the slide particularly with the um graduation caps which represented student enrollment increases over the past eight years was substantiated with the state report application for state school aid where we actually count every student as of October 15th and report

084that to the state which is audited um we used a projection from Ross habber which I believe projected 258 students from the last Assa reporting 10515 and as I mentioned that's a conservative number the depending on the inter term reporting um that you see in the superintendent report you could see some variation through different months but talking um annually and projected even further um I can say that the rate of student enrollment growths here in the district is um going to be significantly more and will exceed the rate of growth that we've experienced in the past just briefly uh Mr P and others with regard to the enrollment I know we have an enrollment breakout uh breakdown on the agenda and there's also I received monthly reports and I have a uh report stating we

085had 28 students um in the past month doesn't go necessarily from February 1st to March 1st but uh based over 10 months it's been around that average plus the number of students we received in the summer so I think when we add all that up that's where we're coming up with the numbers for the year i' like to mention also M po about um state aid uh this board of education has not and certainly with our Administration has not stopped lobbying our uh legislators uh for more state aid we we certainly addressed every one of the inequities that you you mentioned I know you know that we're fighting for this and I want you to know that uh we haven't given up we haven't stopped and I'm going to ask Mr Gorski to just add

086to my comments a little bit yes it's my pleasure to um announce to the public that through the efforts of uh mayor tamboro um mayor Tim Boro Dr kak Mr Ryback and I met with uh state senator Sweeney who and members of the um Department of Finance Department of Education who were well versed in and Senator Greenstein thank you who were well versed in Monroe's um challenges in state a areas they they knew a lot of our statistical information before I could even give them a handout and um although we were sworn not to divulge the intimacy of some of the conversations that we had um I think that Dr kak and Mr Rybeck and I all feel comfortable that change may be coming and it may be substantial um there's some there's some conditions

087in the funding formula right now that are harming Monroe greatly and those are the hold harmless and stabilization Provisions basically what that means is districts um cannot receive more state aid because the state's coffers are low so everybody gets the same amount as you received last year that keeps large uh Urban blocks stabilized um without running the formula that way but it's it very unintelligently harms Monroe where we are picking up that much more responsibility in an obligation from the new students and we are getting less and less of a state aid per pupil ratio each year I think our state aid per pupil number right now is about $450 per pupil which is basically a couple texts and um there was there was um knowledge and sympathy uh that we found at the state

088and we left very optimistic that that change may be coming as early as the 178 school year um and finally we have our own District prepared legislation that was sponsored by Senator Greenstein um we found that um a sobering uh information about that that that legislation um is probably extended Beyond its life and and um most likely is is dead at this point however please be assured that we will continue to fight this state aid is the number one Financial issue that this District faces and um our legislators know us by name now thank you Mr gy M Masters hi Green Masters and I'm Michaela Court I just want to ask about the donation of the ukuleles what are we going to do with them is they're going to be like a strings teacher that's

089going to come in and use them or what is the plan for them I don't know I don't have the answer for that I apologize I I uh don't have the answer for that but I will get the answer for you we know like who can teach you gele like you could use it as like an in like you know trumpet or trombone or uh it it could be a lot of high schools in the past couple years um started to you know some of the students start to have some ukulele type of clubs there's a couple pretty popular songs one by uh a group called train and others that utilize ukulele and I think that caught students interest uh but I will get an answer for you it was just an interesting donation that

090they were making so I just wanted to know if there was a plan for them ABS I think one of our administrator has an answer in the back Mr you know this is the wonderful thing about having administrators there ready to to come up with the answer thank good evening everyone um the ukuleles were donated to us and they were identified by one of our music teachers at the middle school and given the nature of our sixth grade music General music cycle the ukuleles were deemed to be a little bit more um adaptable to the situation in our music cycle which meets in a limited basis um very short amount of time and we found it to be um very popular in middle schools for musical instruction and more conducive to the schedule which is

091limited as opposed to learning the guitar and we are very grateful and fortunate that we were able to come into this donation so we're excited about that so they will able to take like as like a bandage oh yeah it basically they will be learning it um and uh we found that it is a little bit less complex than the guitar and given the time constraints of the sixth grade music cycle it was a little more conducive to that schedule okay but it's only for the kids to take the music cycle then that's right the kids that are uh enrolled in the sixth grade music cycle okay so if they're already in band or they're already in course for the year then they won't be have the opportunity that's correct okay good thank you Mr

092marado hope that clarifies thank you okay thanks anyone else from the public not seeing anyone else we could move to the superintendent's report okay thank you Mr President uh there was a question last month regarding um student concussions and head injuries and I I did some research and uh worked with some of the staff members who were kind enough to provide the information and for the uh 20156 school year up from August until now we've had 20 diagnosed concussions we've had six students that were um sent for evaluation but not diagnosed with the concussion We are following the new procedure outlined by the state uh diligently and making sure that students get the proper treatment the assessment and when they are um ready to come back by you know when they receive medical clearance there's

093a 5-day period where they slowly work their way back so they might walk a couple laps one day maybe work on a stationary bike this another day uh but we are very on top of that to make sure you know students student safety is very important to us okay so with that I just wanted to answer that question uh that was posed last month um because of the budget presentation I uh I know you'll be disappointed but I did not present or prepare my normal normally long superintendent report uh and our student Representatives do such a wonderful job presenting what's going on in the schools so with that I would like to turn the uh Personnel section over to our board president uh to discuss the Personnel items and also the board action items thank

094you uh well i' like to have a motion to approve the personal items a through GG moved second any discussion yes Mr nin yes just a quick question with on that concussion um um is that an increase or or is that uh in other words is that a normal number for example over over the years how many uh would we expect to see that's an excellent question uh of which I am not prepared to answer however it is an excellent question but I would say that uh you know the focus on concussions and safety student safety has really been heightened uh certainly through the media through the NFL through all different things and that has um you know raised the awareness at the at the high school and the middle school level as well so

095I I don't have the data to support or to answer that question in an intelligent manner as to whether it's an increase or not I would venture to say without hard data so take it with a grain of salt that the the number is probably higher than it was 10 years ago when concussions weren't really looked at as as uh you know as through the lens that they're looked at now so but I I don't have it for the last several years thank you any discussion on the motion yes um just just a quick clarification on uh Personnel item I and J uh it says that the uh due to a resignation uh there's spring student staff athletic manager position for 50% of that position um is there somebody else I mean I I can

096you just get a little clarification of what that is is there somebody else at the other side of the 50% doing that job yes yes okay so they're they're okay yeah so and you'll see the you both items actually that right yes we're not losing we're we're losing half of the staff so it's still staffed program right there's still staff members just for that stip in position they're just um they're they're resigning from half of what the responsibility is okay are we are we going to leave the other person with full responsibility we're going to replace these half position half positions yes we'll be replacing half positions yes okay that's it any other discussion on on Personnel items a through GG in that case we can move to a vote Mr Gorski yes Mr armeno

097yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs colano yes Mr noin yes Mrs krino yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky yes thank you motion passes thank you Mr gski Mr ma Do you have a I don't did you have a question no I was asking oh okay um uh board action items a through M I'd like a motion to approve I'll move second any um discussion oh I have never mind board action board action a through M um I have a question on Jay the vandalism and the cost of the district if we can identify the Vandals do we charge parents for that yes yes and did we identify who vandalized this or not well there's there's two damage to properties the one if you're referring to the

098Barkley Brook the sign yeah no we were not able to identify we think that was somebody driving by that threw something out the the window unfortunately it's yeah any other question on um board action a uh it says recommend the board approve the previously submitted list of requests for staff professional development in our packet is that the same as professional leave requests I just want to make sure it was the same thing there was a list of leave requests that I would imagine it's for professional development uh it our professional development almost all of it is handled inhouse okay so it shouldn't be the same as the leave request okay the professional development is U occurs year long so um so it wasn't in this package it might have been a package previous yes okay

099yeah all right that clarifies that and um B uh previous the submitted field trips um some of the field trips don't have any cost attached to them but they are funded by the district are those already included in the budget I would assume I think I asked that question last month right so if there so in other words for a departmental budget they've already been included in that departmental budget if yes yes the schools um under the supervision of Dr alvic budget for field trips within the budget okay and I just have one question about new clubs um or I know that on G I'm sorry new clubs are uh for the first year they're not they're not charged to the district but then they are subsequently are I I would just sort of I

100just thought of this that I would ask that maybe the curriculum committee could give us a little synopsis sometimes of what the clubs can we do that or no I believe Mr yeah the last month because the curriculum committee met and um Mr cman provided an overview of the clubs at last month's board meeting um I don't know I can pull the notes up from Google Drive if you it's fine I I'll oh they're in Google Docs yes okay I was I was going to say if the that's on me yeah I was going to say if the notes were in Google proficiency has there's a lot of information in there so so I apologize Mr Mr cman okay any other discussion yeah Mr calman question so I can't remember them all but I know

101the one that is hardest to explain is the one that I remember which is do the impossible Club that's really the one that's impossible to explain I can't I can't possibly explain what the no um what they are actually as a fundraising group uh and they are looking to try and do fundraising as well as some team activities uh within themselves so um that's what that club is the junior state of America Club is another um I I would classify it as a um uh I don't know it's a sanctioned it's a real organization that you join that are have multiple jurisdictions in different places U the other thing too that I mentioned when I gave the synopsis um was that one of the things we as the curriculum committee are asking of new clubs

102over and above the free for the first year that they need to have a self-funding component considered so that as because the stuff that's grandfathered that they're kind of grandfathered in but as you want to induce new clubs if you can self- sustain yourself who cares how many we have let's get more kids in but let's let the club sustain the entire cost of running itself so that's one of the things we're looking at trying to do thank you very much for that thank you Mr cman anyone else in that case we're ready to vote on board action items 8 through M Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes so you're fast so yes to everything except I'm going to recuse on m332 so noted thank you Mrs Co Pano

103yes Mr notin yes on everything except no on I thank you so noted Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rety so I am abstaining on everything the exception of items e and G or I vote yes thank you sir Bo president motion passes thank you might as well leave the mic with you because we're ready for our business administrator's report thank you um I would like to read a resolution in addition uh before beginning my report and this has to do with the water testing that Mr dusin mentioned before Township has generously offered to test all of the school facilities and um the building grounds Transportation committee also met and decided although I understand it might be redundant testing um that it was worthwhile to have another licensed lab um

104take a look at the results and therefore it is recommended that the Board of Education approved the previously submitted proposal for water sampling Services by the environmental Safety Management Corporation dated March 14 2016 at a cost of $5,500 to ensure that the mundro Township School District maintains excellent water quality for students staff members and visitors business administrative board secretary is hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action by the Board of Education no moved no moved we have a second second okay uh any discussion V yes all right uh we'll vote all those in favor I opposed extensions recusals motion passes thank you Mr for yes okay Mr board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through G be

105approved by consent roll call so move that any discussion I have some questions yes um under the number three the psychiatrist that is going to provide evaluations to us under the contract if under 24 if there's a cancellation under 20 less than 24 hours before the appointment or if there's a no-show we have to pay a $300 um fee to them if a parent does this and it's not on our part do we charge that to the parents how does that work um it works as stipulated I can say that we've never had that occurrence so therefore we've never had to charge a parent for such a thing but that is a provision in this professional's contract okay um my next question is number six epic we um Liberty healthc care has switched um um

106part of our services to Epic Healthcare and they will honor the pricing that um Liberty Healthcare has set forth how long are they honoring those prices for this resolution is for one year one year okay thank you thank you any other questions discussion we can vote all those in favor I oh you want to take a roll this uh this a roll call on board action items a through G Miss armenio yes m Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman Mrs colano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr ryack yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky I abstain and everything with the exception of item a number four and item date where you vote well I vote yes thank you sir thank you for that reminder thank you Mr board president motion passes

107that concludes my report no we're ready for the board president's report um few things I want to touch on I want to follow up on Mr borski's Motion in in speaking about lead and water it's been um in the news um past couple of days um concerning lead found the water in Newark I think it was approximately 30 schools last week Monroe superintendent and business administrator were called by the county executive superintendent of schools to attend and participate in an almost immediate dual County meeting with middle sex and Mera counties to address media reports about Leen school and also to identify communities at risk Monroe was not an identified community at risk but out of an abundance of caution Monroe township utilities department will be conducting Township wide testing of water at tap including all

108schools and we thank the township for that but additionally uh Monroe Township School District will uh separately conduct water tests by environmental safety uh management and I'd like to credit our building grounds and transportation committee for their work and support in this in this matter uh I'd like to address the district strategic plan something that's on our district website I noticed that it was updated in February 2015 yet much has happened since then that I think um might be looked at I'm going to ask the administration to review it and um update that plan sure so we can all um the entire Community can know exactly what we've been doing thank you um on a lighter note I think Miss arminia referred to read Across America uh we had a lot of fun in in

109Reading I know everyone uh who participated uh did and I'd like to congratulate uh the parents the teachers and the school administrators for all their work um the girls basketball team Mr Jamal I think you you mentioned that and what I'd like to comment on is the sportsmanship they had showed great expertise in playing but they showed fantastic sportsmanship and I'd like to credit that entire team and their coaching staff uh for exhibiting uh such a such a a wonderful uh sportsmanship and finally in in talking about the ukuleles maybe think I'd like to me I'd like to uh thank the Caleb band uh music company for its donation of those 30 ukuleles and also I'd like to thank Miss Evelyn cman for the donation of Visual Arts and supplies and materials you know the

110gift of music and art is something that will reap many benefits and I'm sure all of it will uh go to um uh good use for our students thank you any other board of education business I have a few Mr yeah um this past week um Mr Schneider had um a composer William Owens into the district who worked with the children I think at element all levels um I know my son was at the middle school level and he got to work with him and um it was really an amazing experience for the kids and it was um quite an honor to have um Mr Owens there and they played one of his pieces and you know they he taught them and they learned from him and it was it was really exceptional it was

111a great experience for my son and I'm sure the other students um and I have two more things last week the New Jersey doe denied the EXP expansion of hatik vter school thus preventing our tax dollars from leaving this District um because we know that $43 really didn't offset the 90,000 we had to spend and I know everybody put forth some effort and helped with that and I'd especially like to thank Senator Greenstein for reaching out to commissioner Hesby for us on that um so this is a positive for our district on a different note um on the New Jersey doe has issued new graduation requirements okay and current seniors can fulfill the graduation requirement by several Avenues um and the current seniors one of those Avenues is the park and the current seniors can

112fulfill it by passing a certain score on the the park which was um I think it was level three on Tuesday the joint committee on public education met um and Stan karp the director of the secondary reform project from the education Law Center presented to the committee on parking graduation um and what he explained to the committee which I found extremely disturbing is um number one the new graduation requirements weren't set forth by proper um proper channels I guess for lack of a better word um and he talked about how compared to hespa which typically had a gradu passing graduation rate of 80 to 90% the park passing graduation rates for 30 to 40% which is wouldn't be disturbing if it wasn't being used as a graduation requirement and he also said that 54,000 current

113seniors um will not be able to use the park for the ELA because they didn't meet the requirement and 30,000 current seniors cannot use the park for a graduation requirement for Math and as a result throughout the whole state there are a lot of students out there rushing to um do the portfolio so that they can graduate this and they may not have passed the park but they've met all the requirements for their school so my concern is are we seeing this in our school and how are we dealing with it well um so have we seen an increased rate in the portfolio appeel process yes okay but it's to answer your question in a in a more thorough manner okay uh we had over a 100 students originally that did not pass one of

114the graduation requirements okay that means it could be park it could be PSAT sat accuplacer a lot of these students were given um remedial work and were able to pass on the second attempt either the acup plure or another assessment the number of students who are required to complete the portfolio assess a portfolio assessment and again I don't I don't have the numbers right here but I want to say it's 30 or so okay some uh are are classified okay uh some students are classified and we have people working with them um to help them complete that good good because I was concerned thank you oh um absolutely again have our administrators here there's currently between both math and language arts six students who need to go through the portfolio assessment we have assigned one

115onone to work to remediate the skills to practice the skills our they're called CRTs the um assessments that students would take right submitted to the state we're waiting for their feedback and approval students will take those tasks they're locally scored and then we send the entire portfolio package to the state for final approval okay good thank you okay thank you Dr Rosel thank you any question anything else Mrs Kyle Pono did you want to say not to her I have something different okay I I would just like to add one thing about the hottia um you over the six past six years we actually had 21 um ,20 diverted uh and uh that's money that we could use right here yep so can I ask you a question yeah so on that note it's not

116that HTI is shutting down it's not that that's not going to continue it's just not expanding which would enable more more students to go there so we're still in the same situation it's just not getting any worse the year for this current year they can come back and reapply I believe every year yes I'd have to ask you to to direct your comments I meant to you exactly so we don't have any cross compensation thank you um anything else in that case we're ready for the public St oh I'm sorry now you're raising you I did when I was talking oh sorry um I know Mr Rybeck you mentioned read across America day and I had the wonderful opportunity to read to students at Applegarth school um so I'd like to thank the oak tree

117apple gorth PTA for the invitation they've been sending it to me and I've been reading to the classes for many many years and it's been um one of the most fun days out of the whole whole school year um I also was wonderfully welcomed by a door that had welcome Mrs kalap Pano and I was surprised they knew how to spell my name name so I I thought that in itself was a good thing and then um I had received letters from all the students in the class um thanking me for coming in and and that to me is when when you get something like that from students it really means a lot so thank the school and I thank the PTA for cons uh continuing to hold this event because I think it's very

118important for us just to get into the classrooms and see what the kids are doing I received letters similarly uh from Mrs VI's fourth grade class at abalo and uh uh they all quoted Dr Seuss s and it was just incredible how how well written these letters were and and and the amount of depth of thought that was exhibited yeah so it was a terrific experience nice to walk into a classroom where 25 kids are excited to see you yes any other uh board business in that case we're ready for the uh public forum where uh members of the public are invited up to speak to topics not necessarily on the agenda once again I'd like to remind you to state your name clearly and address and you will have a three minute time limit

119any anyone from the public interested in making a comment asking a question Mr P uh something I wanted to call to your attention uh I as I was looking at the board agenda available on sorry Doug poy for tamarak road as I was looking at the board agenda for tonight and I looked at the attachments uh I found the list of field trips available which I was a bit surprised about because I know many districts do not make that available to the public for purposes of uh student security and safety uh I don't know if that's a practice in this District or not uh I had not ever noticed it before I did notice it this afternoon though and I was disturbed by that because obvious reasons it allows predators to know exactly when Elementary

120age children are going to be offsite and possibly they would have access to them I realize that rarely occurs but at the same time I think that's something that needs to be considered uh on a more positive note I attended an empty bows uh brunch that the was held at the senior uh Center the senior community center uh last week and uh that was put together by the director of the center uh Bonnie libowitz and one of our teachers from Brookside School uh Mrs Anthony uh and I don't know how many of you are familiar with empty bowls uh but the children make ceramic bowls and uh then they are auctioned uh the money that's raised from the auction of those bowls is then used to uh to supply local food pantries and other areas

121uh Within in the United States uh for feeding the hungry uh but it was such a nice opportunity an intergenerational opportunity for members of our senior community to interact uh and see these young children from both Brookside and the middle school and I complimented both Miss lieberwitz and uh and Miss Anthony on such a joint uh Venture as that and I said it would be nice if we could find more ways to expose our senior community to various things that are happening in our schools uh and I just wanted to mention that to the board in case you were not aware of that and I believe the auctions for the schools will take place possibly in the month of May so uh if some of you are available maybe you want to auction on the

122money and uh contribute to a very worthy cause of uh feeding the hungry all right thank you thank you Mr Po any other member of public not seeing one we'll go to our closed session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of Township Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of public laws of 1975 njsa 1046 through 10421 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation bullying following closed session action may be taken the discussion uh conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists second okay any discussion just how how long do you think it will be and and that there's a public comment after in favor I I oppos oos want

123oppose any um extensions or recusals okay motion motion passes for close session seeing none at this time let me state that the uh next schedule Board of Education meeting is Wednesday 8 13th 7 p.m. right here in the high school ready for adjournment yes second second could vote all in favor I it's unanimous thank you

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.