001this meeting of Monro Township Board of Education is now called to order uh I'd like to ask everyone to please rise and join me in the pledge IED aliance to the flag of the United States of America to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you Mr gorsy ready for a roll call yes sir M armeno pres Mr Braverman here Mr Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs Co Pano here Mr nosin here M Kino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo and Mr rutsky here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the
002date time and place thereof posted April 8th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you very much let's move to the approval of minutes uh can I get a motion to approve the minutes of the public luk Board of Education meeting February 10th 2016 so moved I have a second okay any discussion all in favor I any opposed I one exstension motion carries um can I get a uh a motion to approve the minutes of the closed session meeting February 10th 2016 second any discussion all in favor I any opposed abstentions I abstain two extensions any recusals motion carries the okay we can move to the student board members uh report thank you Mr board president uh the park test is started
003being implemented in all of the schools uh including the elementary schools and the middle schools the high school Park testing started on Monday and will go through Tuesday of next week um additional starting next Friday there will be uh the DECA International Career Development conference approximately eight students from the high school have qualified to go and there will be students from over uh eight countries um and all of the 50 states uh recently um between the previous board meeting and now uh course selections uh have taken place where students have met with their guidance counselors in order to select courses for the upcoming school year and the uh Junior Statesman of America club and the do the impossible club which were if you will recall was uh approved at the last board meeting have since
004held their first meetings um and they getting started up in preparation for the next school year thank you Mr th uh so this weekend 50 of our high school students are going to be leaving for the YMCA's Youth and government program it's a weekend long conference and students have prepared mock bills on topics they're passionate about and some other students have completed assignments on other like other topics that aren't legislative and they're going to debate on their issues or topics and we have 50 of our students going to that uh last week the high school had a college fair all Junior students went down during their second block and sophomore students were given the option to go down during their lunch uh the mths academic team went to the the finals of the Bridgewater ritton
005Invitational Tournament and they won second place and were awarded 1, for their Victory and finally the winter Color Guard placed first at a competition in brick memorial high school thank you Mr Bo president that concludes our report thank you both very much than can move to uh committee reports any committee chair wanted to report Mr calman sorry curriculum committee met this evening um and we went over the new high school chemistry curriculum document as well as the summer reading program um if the board would like I could read into the record the 2016 2017 course study inventory 15 pages long double-sided going once are you sure I would like are you sure I could if you want we need a motion to extend the board meeting by two hours for that though uh okay so
006I won't then um and then the last thing we talked about was this new uh application that we're looking to bring in house Rubicon Atlas to help uh facilitate a more streamlined effort to do curriculum development with at the board so um looks like it's going to be a good tool that our staff can use to help with curriculum writing uh that's it that's all I got any questions from Mr calman any other committee chair Mr mayil um we had a Personnel meeting yesterday um we have a recommended candidate for supervisor of special services on our agenda tonight um that is Mrs Monica Hines is being recommended for this for this position she is replacing Marie Pepe who is retiring um Miss Hines is assistant head of school was a principal assistant principal and taught
007special ed for seven years she has two master's degrees excuse me and she was chosen by a committee from an applicant pool of 50 candidates thank you any questions from Mr ma mrin is that a new position or is that um it filling an existing position it's a u it's filling a retirement at the end of June 30th M Mur Pepe was put in a number of years and we're very sorry to to see her retire and leave but we wish her the best but that is to fill her position actually I I didn't it was actually the wrong question I me I knew she was filling her position will she be undertaking any additional uh uh job descriptions or it's going to be the identical job description I guess that was what I should
008have said is the new candidate candate yes uh no the the job description is pretty extensive as it is okay thank you any other committee chair Miss arminia uh the policy committee was held on Thursday April 7th again it was open to the public we had two public uh two members of the public join us uh it was an extensive committee meeting we was a 2 and a half hour committee meeting where in the past they've been an hour so we went through a lot of uh policies us most were mandated uh by reg and uh by regulation uh just let me go through a couple of them there's a public participation in board meetings we're keeping some of the language about a 3 minute uh time frame for people to come to the public
009forum and and speak uh nothing has changed with the public fors we still have three public fors but each time a uh person comes up to speak it'll be for three minutes if after that time uh and the and the chair uh agrees and someone needs to come up for a second time it'll be another three minutes per Forum okay uh recording board meetings um that will allow board uh members of the public to record meetings with small devices as long as they do not interfere with meetings uh with the meeting uh prior permission is required for recording from an area other than the area designated for the public uh athletic competition requires cardiac screening as part of all uh Sports uh sports physical and the next one is medical examination prior to participation on
010school sponsored inter Scholastic or intramural team or Squad accompanying the regulation uh is I'm sorry accompanying regulation to policy so what we're doing was we're just um making the policy and the regulation coincide all these again all these policies are on the Monroe Township uh District website uh Health Services we have a defibrillator that will be requirement and new Administrative Code have been added Health Services again regulation to the policy so we have a regul we have a policy which as the attorney has explained to me is the law the regulation is the procedure to follow the law so uh when you see a p before one of the letter one of the numbers that's the policy when you see an R it would be the regulation for the instituting the the policy requirements health
011and physical education uh merges physical education policy uh one's on the agenda to be AB abolished and health education policy it includes new statutory requirements we also have a policy that is and most of these are mandatory administration of medical marijuana we have a regulation also uh about medical the administration of medical marijuana High School graduation I would ask people to take note there are some Park recommendations uh actually they're mandated recommendations on Park as regulation for graduation requirements I think if I can just asked the superintendent uh Council I mean council president um Rybeck just it it it gets instituted in what the Year may I sure Mr R want me to elaborate on that please sure so the graduation requirement um there are multiple assessments that students can take to meet the graduation
012requirement the SAT the uh act the PSAT acup Placer uh and Park and right now there's multiple assessments and this new policy gives updates on what the minimum score is to be considered proficient on each of those assessments um PSAT has its own way of scoring and act so the state had to take their scoring and adapt it to what's the minimum score that that a school district would consider uh to be the minimum to pass so that they a student can graduate with a degree in the year um 2021 as it stands right now park is slated to be the uh required uh graduation requirement in the year 2021 barring or you know barring any changes between now and then so the policy does mention that but uh it also the the biggest change
013I saw was giving the minimum score scores that students need to pass all the uh assessments that are available and uh and and this policy comes as a mandate from the state is that correct yes yeah it's mandated because we have students taken all these different assessments and we have to have a policy in there that states what the minimum requirement is for them to graduate from our high school next one is eligibility of residents and non-resident students an update including uh allowing a student to remain in school if the move is related to a victim of of domestic violence sexual abuse or family crisis uh reporting potentially missing or abused children there's change in departments to report incidents and outstanding Food Services charge again a change in reporting requirements these are all available this
014is the first reading of these this evening there will be a second reading in may not on the 27 27 or it could be on April 27th that's what our next meeting is so we could have the second reading then okay so that would be a second reading and if there are any comments from the public that we could be emailed okay that's my any questions from Miss Armenia okay I think that ends our committee reports uh excuse me Mr board president I'm sorry I have a I have a committee before um I'm sorry that's okay the uh finance committee met on uh Monday uh the day before yesterday and uh we had some unfortunate news uh the summer camp STEM Academy um which looked like a fantastic program I would like to thank Dr
015alvik and all the teachers that participated in making this program uh try to come to fruition and ends up that uh after much effort the we had 300 slots available for the stem program summer program uh we needed 216 students to basically say it was a break even point we can we can proceed with it and unfortunately as of that Monday two days ago we had 146 students registered so um they did put out another notice through the through the Monroe letter and some other uh connects that we were going to attempt um but it doesn't appear that that's going to uh happen we felt it was uh imperative that we let the parents know as soon as possible so they can make alternate plans for their uh for their summer um the committee talked
016about Alternatives um as far as maybe different ways of marketing it but um Dr alvic explained that it is a very competitive market there's a lot of school districts that are currently employing uh this type of a program during the summer some have been in in effect for quite some time so this was U um a great program and uh we're we're definitely hoping that we're going to attempt it maybe again next year and maybe do a little more Outreach just to the surrounding communities um a little earlier so but again thank thank them for all their work for that um we also discussed the Woodland roof replacement bid award uh looks like there were six biders um one came in Integrity Roofing uh came in as the as the winner of the bid the
017plan is that um we're going to do a complete replacement and uh ripoff on the 1950 portion of this of the Woodland Avenue School and we did also um find out that there was a study done with uh infrared to determine from the 1998 roof um the sections that were in need of repair so they're going to be repaired uh as the unneeded they'll rip off what was damaged and uh and replace as needed uh third item that we we discussed um we had a huge issue this month um with the payroll um I'm sure M I'm hoping Mr Gorski will elaborate a little um on all the efforts uh that his himself especially and his staff uh had to go through to make sure that we did not miss a payroll our our uh
018prior payroll service pay serve uh was sold so it created quite a headache and a concern um for the business administrator who did a fantastic job uh to get us through this very very scary situation of potentially missing a payroll um we did have to go to a different payroll provider uh ADP and uh the cost of that was um was more more than pay serve but it's uh a Cadillac service that we're getting now and um the finance committee agreed that one of the most important things uh that a school district does um next to of course the education of the students is making sure that the uh employees are paid all um you know 1,00 plus of them so um we're going to go with ADP going forward um and on the good
019note also on item number four we had a budget update and the budget was uh was approved the tentative budget was approved by the state and the uh the final budget will be voted on at the uh April 27th meeting Mr board president that concludes my report thank you Mr ntin any questions for the finance chair uh Mr Nan if you don't mind I'd like to just make two comments on what you said one's the um stem summer program uh it's really ashamed that enough people didn't uh sign up hopefully they have till this Friday I believe um it the program is just devised in a way that it's a it's reinforces the science technology engineering math uh it's Hands-On it's interactive and the cost is actually more attractive I think than any other program
020of its kind so we hope it's not too late that people uh send their registration in for their uh children and also if I might uh Mr Gorski I certainly would like to thank you uh for all your efforts and getting us out of that potential crisis that we could have actually not been able to make a payroll for 1100 employees and I think that uh the credit to you and certainly to allore Allen as well uh to to um help out in this in this situation is is uh welld deserved and thank you very much Mr President sure um while we're on while we're on the topic it seems um most relevant to discuss it now I was going to update everybody during the business administrator's report but um Tom gave a great introduction
021there um our payroll service provider who we've been with for 25 years by the name of pay serve was recently sold and a financial dispute arose between the buyer and the founder of the company and the seller and um that caused the founder of the company to resend an offer of 9 months service to to get the buyer up to speed on this very complicated ated payroll system uh Monroe's School payroll system is extremely complex it's the most complex I've ever seen because of all of the different tangents with um pers pension tpaf pension dcrp pension all with different rules and regulations New Jersey Pennsylvania IRS um requirements and different wage limits Medicare Social Security garnishments all the tech sheltered annuities chapter 78 s125 medical um and I can go on especially the Affordable Care
022Act has put a great burden on on payroll so unfortunately um our my payroll department came upstairs on March 22nd two days before the March 24th payroll and said that we have a crisis we just got a call from pay serve and they said that we better go to the bank and make sure we have enough check stock in case we we have to cut checks uh from gross to net by hand manually for 1,00 staff members and I got on the phone with pay serve and over the course of a few hours I was able to um you use psychology to encourage the sole employee left after everybody had quit to run the program one more time for Monroe and give it another shot and and it worked the net pay went out for
023everybody um on 324 and then the system crashed we received no reports we received no um amounts that had to be paid for taxes through the withholdings we received no amounts for garnishments the 403b amounts and all those were um withheld so we had to immediately come up with a plan to uh find a successor and um once I had heard that the business was sold I went to paychecks and I had an interview with paychecks they came to our office and they said due to the complexity they're choosing not to bid on our on our account at this time systems 3000 is another one that Services a lot of school districts it's a regional firm and they said that due to the um the tax of the Affordable Care Act that's had on their
024firm um they're not taking any new business at this time either so uh then this crisis hit and um I called a DP and I negotiated a contract immediately with them um on an on it's not an emergency contract the contract doesn't have to be bid even though it's over the bid threshold because of the type of service it's exempt from bidding because it's so specific and unique um so ADP came in uh they I also was able to negotiate above a 35% discount over their uh first presented fee so we have um a sutor that will safeguard the payroll function here which is really a most critical element of a very labor intensive organization will safeguard all of the employee data which in which is just a treasure Trove of sensitive information including names
025and Social Security numbers and dependence and bank accounts and routing and account numbers um birth dates if I didn't say that and we'll hold it in the most secure environment you can they have separate locations all across the country in case one goes down to a national natural disaster the other one's up and running you couldn't find a better service we got a fee that's competitive with um paychecks they're they biggest competitor they're like the Coke and Pepsi of uh of payroll and we had to then transition very quickly ADP said all right our normal time to transition such an event is 6 months I said I need it in three weeks so um my staff and I worked diligently and feverishly over um over spring break and up until this morning and one of
026the biggest hurdles that we had was providing year-to-date information to ADP because otherwise they'd be processing a payroll in the blind not knowing year to-day wages for all the employees we had back into that with a good 315 report and manually add everybody's pay stub from 324 and unfortunately that file had 41 corrupt pay stubs that were missing that I had to then put into Excel and go gross to net for these 41 people add all this information together and I'll spare you that to details but it was a harrowing experience to say the least um the thought of of of sending out an email to 1100 staff members saying I'm sorry but we're not going to be able to fulfill Our obligation to pay you this period was was just a remarkable feeling that
027I hope I never um encounter again these are people who um are not the uh the the highest paid individuals for the most part these are people who have paid a lot into medical um and um have automatic payments for college and cars and mortgages that would have been financially in turmoil if this event would have occurred so um this morning when they all clear came from ADP and no errors on the 415 payroll and all systems were go it was a wonderful feeling of relief and I would sincerely like to thank um yourself Mr Ryback and Mr nostin as Finance chair and Dr kak for the support um during this period because this really could have been a crisis of grand proportion that was averted and although as Mr noin said the the contract
028is greater than what we had before that was a 25-year contract and the fee was never inflated and um and uh what we're getting Now is really a market rate service for something that's the highest quality so um I would like to also thank Laura Allen because she was instrumental in this um whole Endeavor and the payroll department thank you thank you we all appreciate what you did Michael okay we can move now to the first public forum this is to address items on the agenda uh if anyone from the public is interested in coming to the microphone we ask you to state your name and your address and uh please note that you'll have three minutes to address uh your question I asked that you um speak to me uh not individual members of
029the board is they cannot respond to you that being said is anyone from the public interested in coming up for this first public forum seeing no one we can move on Mr superintendent to your report sure thank you Mr President I just wanted before I begin my report just um thank our student Representatives once again uh I look forward to their report every month and uh I'm aware of the achievements that they had mentioned tonight but I just hope that the members of the audience both members that are sitting here and the members who maybe are watching at home uh recognize how well our students are doing and especially in some of our academic clubs um the advances that they've made that the the achievements the the recognition that they're receiving Statewide uh it's really
030something to be uh to be proud of um and as always both of you uh report it in a very eloquent Manner and uh both very well spoken so just wanted to recognize you for that and thank you for those reports um there are some activities that uh I wanted to mention as well that our students involved in uh are involved in uh yesterday I had uh an opportunity to go see our girls lacrosse team and our boys lacrosse team and our boys lacrosse team of course uh when I got to the game uh were doing very well uh it's a very strong team and uh they won the game I believe it was 10-3 was the final score maybe 10-4 our girls across when I um got there during the first half was uh
031I think it was um 93 uh they were losing uh they ended up winning uh in overtime and I believe it was 1110 was the final score so uh a little shout out if you will to uh our girls lacrosse for um you know really coming back uh and not to take anything away from the boys they did well also but our girls really came back in that second half and of course to our coach uh who made some uh coaching moves there and um you know really says something uh about the uh the kids uh and our coaching staff of course I don't want to not mention or yet to be remissive I did not mention that baseball softball track golf tennis uh all of our teams and if I missed any please uh
032you I want to make sure I include everybody uh they're doing well kids are doing well so it's nice to see that that the students are doing well academically uh both in classes in our academic clubs and of course in the extracurricular uh sports activities as well I also wanted to mention that April is Autism Awareness Month and there's a lot of activities taking place in our schools the light uh refer to his light it up blue in uh recognition of that and raising awareness and and much needed uh finances for research in that area we have a a strategic plan that was developed uh it's a 5-year plan and at the August 27th board meeting there will be an update on that plan I'm sorry APR April did I say you said August August
033oh my apologies thank you Mr President April 27th um must be the spring weather I'm thinking warm weather my my apologies on that uh I would like to note to the board that on the agenda our 20156 school calendar the calendar for this year uh because we did use all of our built-in inclement weather days that uh there will be two additional days that students will have off from school I believe the days or I believe they may 27th and the 31st the Friday before Memorial Day weekend and uh the Tuesday immediately after Memorial Day weekend and uh Mr President that concludes my report we move to the go to Personnel uh okay can I uh get a motion to approve items a through y on the Personnel so moved second anyone second any discussion
034Miss armenio yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes to all recuse on why thank you sir Mrs kpano yes Mr nosin yes Mrs karino yes Mr Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo and Mr rutsky yes thank you Mr board president motion passes thank you can move to board action it's on page 11 I I get a motion to approve board action items a through M moved yes Mr um I have some reservations about policy 5460 section c the graduation requirements I'd like to make a motion to remove that policy um and discuss separately okay well I'll I'll second that okay could any discussion I have some questions on it about the uh no we just have to vote to remove it right first before we discuss well there it's a motion to remove
035it so we have discussion on the motion oh on the motion motion yeah yes um was I guess your objection was was related to what we said before what was raised before my my problem with the policy that specific just section c is that these new requirements did not follow the proper regulations to become graduation requirements um in order to become a graduation requirement the New Jersey doe has to follow the New Jersey administrative procedure act which outlines how changes to the law must be followed um it includes the point of order I I I think we have to vote first on the motion to remove it from Theo there's a motion on to to vote for all of the um of a list of things it was never seconded it was second second we
036have to just we're not on we're not discussing the policy at this it was just a vote a a motion to remove it from the other vote and I believe you're correct yeah she is yes I didn't know it was seconded I'm sorry yeah I I it was seconded yes she's correct so there's no discussion on the policy per se there's a discussion on whether we want to remove it or not from the vote is that correct motion to change the order right okay so guess we could take a vote on that okay the motion on the floor is Miss Deo seconded by Mrs kapano to remove policy 5460 from the consent roll call and address it separately Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes
037Mr nostin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo and Mr rutsky yes Mr board president motion passes then I believe we will have a roll call then on the rest of the board action items with the exception of 5460 yes um is there any discussion on any of those items uh you know what I will I will discuss sorry Mr President yeah I I just want to discuss policy 168 uh I'm going to I'm going to be voting no on that and I just want to explain despite the fact that I was the uh chair of the policy committee we had a rigorous and uh very good discussion about the recording of board meetings and everybody else was in full agreement um but I I just think that I was I believe that
038it should be audio audio taped uh the Clos session recording and then we follow procedure for the um open public records act the open public meetings act I know it is not something that our board attorney would recommend but just on a personal level not as a chair of that of that committee so that's I just wanted to make that statement if somebody else wanted to have that discussion before the vote that's fine NOP any else I guess we can um there's no further discussion can vote we're voting on board action items a through M with the exception of policy 5460 armenio uh yes on everything except policy 168 recording of board meetings and that's a no right ma'am that's correct 68 is a no Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs
039K Pano yes Mr nosin yes Mrs Keno yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo and Mr ratsky I abstain on all with the exception of item e where I vote yes thank you sir Mr board president motion passes and that leads us to okay so the problem I have with section c is that these new requirements um did not follow proper regulations to become graduation requirements in order to change um the regulations for the new doe and many other parts of the state they must follow the New Jersey administrative procedure act which outlines how changes to the law must be followed first the New Jersey doe must publish in the New Jersey register the new rules and allow for public comment there was none of this was followed and this allows for transparent government and the
040New Jersey doe blatantly disregarded the law when setting forth these changes to graduation requirement as a result there are children at risk for not graduating um and I have the the rules if anybody's interested currently the education Law Center has brought a lawsuit against the New Jersey due challenging these requirements I feel it's premature to adopt them as a policy and especially since the New Jersey doe has not proper follow prop followed the proper law in getting these um to become graduation requirements any any discuss I have something yes I'd like to say um well I I appreciate what you're saying I'm having a problem in in saying in determining what's legal what's not legal I think that's that's up to the courts it's certainly up to legislature we we here as a board we
041have to follow what the state Ed Department um mandates to us and follow the law it has not been determined that anything has been illegal that's all that's where I'm you know where I'm coming from and and I think that until and unless that happens it's incumbent upon us to support the law and that's really all all I have to say about about that I mean we we are mandated to uh give the park exam and in 2021 unless it changes uh that will be the case if it changes if that holds true then we will change the policy but until that I think we have to as a board of education follow the law which right now is saying that the park will be um mandatory for graduation uh as of 2021 but that
042doesn't mean we have to adopt it as a policy I mean we can not adopt it as a policy still follow the law and basically it says to the New Jersey do doe we do not we want you to follow the law and we want a public comment on this which has not happened I I think you could say that anyway Mr may but I think that what vote on here is is following the law I think anything less than that uh would be I think detrimental to us uh as as a board of education I don't want to take that that they're not following the law that's not up to us to determine that's what we have to remember that's not our choice that's not our decision yeah I I'm I'm just just in
043general not not necessarily in particular to this partic this uh policy but if you know governments are made of you just like us you know people and humans and sometimes we sometimes error or or or procedure has not been uh properly followed and if that is the case and I'm not I'm not saying that you're wrong I'm saying I'm not aware whether it's the case or not if it is however the not the case that some procedures from the Department of Education were not followed properly and the public again was not given proper notification and proper time for a hearing I would be opposed to um accepting the Mandate because if it w if it wasn't done properly I mean you know I I I expect my government and I just like I expect the
044board to follow proper procedures if everything was followed properly I may still not like it but I would understand our mandate to to follow through with it so I'm just saying that if it is the case that uh um government entities are not following their own rules which I I know to I know to be the case in in many Avenues of government um then I would ALS I would be opposed to it on that level at the very least anyone I know it's I'm not part of the board but well you could just make a comment um my concern with not adopting the policy is not to comment on park one way or the other but a big part of the policy is the uh is the minimum score on all the assessments so
045I'm raising kind of a rhetorical question if we don't adopt the policy and we have high school students that um graduate and it's not part of the policy what that cut score is technically it's a state setting the cut score the minimum score but it's also part of our policy would then our students be officially graduating from our high school without an official policy stating what they need to pass what you know like the the minimum score they need to pass let's say on the PSAT or the SAT or another assessment let's see what's the driver can you hear me well as long as everybody else can hear you what's the driver for doing it now for something that's going to impact Us in 2021 is there something that is affecting us for for this
046graduation Year yes in the policy that's that's what I'm referring to the right now currently and for the next couple years students can take a multitude of different assessments to demonstrate the Proficiency in order to graduate act PS all those type of Assessments this policy outlines the minimum score they need to to achieve in order to consider that they passed that assessment so that's my concern that's the immediacy of this policy to me and I'm not commenting on whether the government followed the right procedures or not for Park I'm looking at it just for our high school seniors um you know who will be graduating this year that we have something in place that states here's what you need to uh you know achieve on on whatever assessment they took so what we're doing now
047what this vote is going to impact graduating seniors of this year well I feel like it could be possible I I feel like it could I and that's why I said it's somewhat of a rhetorical question because I don't have the answer to it the state sets the minimum score but each district maintains its own policies which basically determine for instance each School District determines how many credits are needed for a high school student to graduate the minimum is 120 by the state our number is is 130 so although it was a minimum set by the state we have as a as a district established we desire 130 credits technically the state has said here's what the minimum score is is that you need for each one of these assessments and that's outlined in the
048policy it's a separate score for each assessment if we don't approve this policy I don't know what the answer is technically the state sets the scores but we don't have a policy in place that the that states unequivocally yes the student graduated because he or she pass that score so that's my concern and I again I don't have uh I would need a lawyer wellers in that area to advise me but that's my fear of by not having this policy approved M arm so so two things uh that that come to mind right now is that the the policy that we're talking about 5460 High School graduation not only stipulates things about Park which which we all know is a controversial issue but it has other elements in it yes that do not have to
049do with Park that are necessary as requirements for for graduation absolutely so this is not about is not all there are elements in this policy that H impact uh the park situation uh but it is not in its entirety only about Park so my second thought was that there are unintended con consequences if we don't have a set policy yes okay potentially un unended consequences okay and since excuse me and since this is the first reading there can be a further discussion about this on with board members okay um to miss arminio's Point um are we changing the requirements for for example uh sat reading and act and accuplacer or are those the existing uh thresholds that are already in place well the state set those thresholds and this is our policy to demonstrate to
050to show that but obviously the only addition here would be the park correct no prior M miss the I'm going to ask you please okay any comments to me I I don't want to have debate going across this way so I'm sorry Mr no could you that's fine um so with regards to the thresholds um which ones are new uh I don't see like a little line next to the the changes obviously Park is new this is the first time we've seen the threshold for that correct they're all new as of this year because um the state came out with the minimum scores of what was needed to graduate so they never had minimum scores before well they never all these other assessments were never uh offered until was it last year that we offered
051they once they once they uh took away hespa hespa was the old graduation requirement once they took away hesa the state came up with this list of alternate requirements so basically we need to know this so obviously if they needed to go through a portfolio like an alternate way we would know when to say hey you need to go through a portfolio is basically what we're saying here is that accurate yes correct yeah absolutely so we right now if we don't do this we wouldn't know when to say you need to go to a portfolio for alternate way to graduate correct thank you calman and then I think Mr May did you want to say something first Mr calman first I'm sorry so I I guess fundamentally forgetting about what the changes are fundamentally I
052have an issue with if we don't do anything whatever the policy is today carries us through through the end of this year because if you don't make a change the current policy carries you my question to you guys is if we make a change to the policy two months before graduation and it negatively impacts one student because we now have a new standard that wasn't in play what do we do can I answer yeah please okay this information was shared with us at uh the beginning of the school year we used this information from the state to guide our current seniors so we know for a fact that our current seniors either met one of those requirements or has gone through the portfolio assessment okay so we're good we are good for our current seniors
053okay Mr did you want to say something no I was just referring to the hesa it was all new um when the port first came out I didn't maybe because I didn't understand I didn't think it would affect the class of 2016 um I could support this policy taking out the piece about um SEC uh part C the park assessment and holding it off till next year because I do not think you should ever change a policy in the middle of a year to affect that year I think any change in a policy should affect the following year so I could not support this policy the way it is right now for the class of 2016 I mean with the changes so the changes in the policy add with the inclusion of Park I can't
054support for the class of 2016 yes Dr if that's the case then we may have some students that did not meet one of the requirements because some students are using that Park assessment from 11th grade as their graduation requirement for this year I would have to go back and look at the list I don't know how many students that would that would we have an Excel sheet for every senior and we've listed every single assessment and we've tracked it throughout the year the guidance counselors um Dr Celli myself have looked at it throughout the year to make sure that all of our students are meeting one of those requirements so I don't know if it would affect any of our seniors if we took Park out as one of the Possible graduation require assessments so
055if we leave it with the park we're guaranteeing that everybody will graduate this year yes and if we take it out we're not guaranteeing that everybody will graduate this year I could not guarantee that this evening I would have to go back and look back at that spreadsheet and see if any students if that's the only assessment that some of our students may have passed I don't know the answer to that Mr n so um just help me understand the uh prior policy we just had threshold level for hespa is that accurate the current policy the current policy yeah no I'm checking the current policy right now I was doing that and checking in it we do have some we do have thresholds on there um that's what I'm just I don't haven't checked it
056word for word but there are thresholds on there threshold scores but for which tests because obviously we were just concerned with uh hespa at the time correct uh sat as act and others okay so the only so are are those thresholds the same yeah I'd have to I'd have to go back and check if I could Mr President suggest that it is a first reading and policy committee will most likely meet um well I don't know about before April 27th but we could put this second reading off until May uh and this policy could be looked at so fine do we need a motion to do to do that or you still want to vote on this to I am but it would take me time I mean that's why we have two readings too
057okay yes the motion that introduce board action items a through m made by Mr noin second by Mr Mayo still applies to this uh the order was only changed so we already have a motion in a second we just need a roll call okay specic specifically on 5460 is that correct yes ma'am that's ready So the plan is to to take a roll call on this and then do the second reading in May after the policy committee after the policy committee okay can we add that to the motion that the policy committee will look at this before again I have no problem with that I don't know I didn't hear a motion to table a motion to table would take this off for the vote tonight and defer it to the next meeting or it
058can if I could yeah sure or it could stay on there because it's still voted on in the second reading and the changes could be looked into and if the changes were meable to everyone at the second reading then you could either Vote or not vote uh there could be changes made to the policy based on the feedback that we received tonight if the changes are legal we'd have to follow that yeah and my point is just to make sure that it does go back to the policy committee again before we vote on it at the whatever meeting it's going to come up at so I don't know if you need that as part of the um motion or we will just I think we can have an I mean I would I would be
059amable to putting it on policy for for the next meeting if that's all that M if if we need a formal vote what I think I'd like to do is I guess what would settle is it if is if I direct Miss armino to to do this i' be happy to yeah for the May uh meeting I think it's important second reading okay now we have a vote on 5460 Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr Mayo yes Mr cman no Mrs K Pano no Mr noin yes Mrs Kino no no thank you Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes Mr rutsky yes board president motion passes for adoption okay thank you okay I guess we now ready for um business administrator's report mic right back to you Mr board president member of the Monro Township
060Board of Education it is recommended that pardon I lost my space after all that exchange okay it's recommended that board action items a through H be approved by consent roll call so moves second M armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs Co Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky okay so I have a list for you so I abstain with the exceptions of items b d e g and h b c e g and H which is a yes correct thank you sir thank you Mr board president presid motion passes and that concludes my report thank you Mr morski I'm ready for the board president's report um on a lighter note uh on March 24th Mrs carap panowitz and I
061had the pleasure of attending the third annual Falcon Pals event um Miss Kathleen Dylan is the um uh coordinator of health and PE and and uh certainly is doing a fabulous job this program is an elective for uh seniors and what they do is um they work uh together with special needs students in a very non-threatening kind of environment in this particular case I think they were doing yoga uh and uh the camarad camarad that we see was uh really something very special and the support from the parents was very special and uh it was a um a well attended evening and a fun evening and it's a seems to be a very worthwhile program so congratulations uh Miss Dylan and all her students one other item I just want to mention is um something
062that was in today's Star Ledger on the front front page and it had to do with uh our um state aid and the area of hold harmless uh we have been as I mentioned before uh meeting with our elected officials and um we had a meeting with um Senator Sweeney the idea of this hold harmless came up and and where it's coming from is we have different areas other than Monroe that uh their um wealth Factor has been increasing their student population has been decreasing and yet they're getting the same amount of state aid as they've had in in the past and we're still getting nothing now we're not the only one like that uh but uh Senator Sweeney uh has um recognized this and uh is working uh very hard to uh make some
063changes so that we could perhaps see some more money I know the the report today also mentions that the idea has the support of Senator sarlo as well and um I believe commissioner uh Hesby so we're looking forward to that and again I also want to uh and I mentioned this before I'd like to thank our mayor May mayor tamboro for reaching out to Senator Sweeney and giving us the opportunity to meet with him thank you that ends my report uh do we have any other board of education business I have something yes actually to exactly what you said because last week I went to the Senate budget and appropriation Committee in Trenton where the office of legislative Services um reviews the governor's Pro proposed budget um and this week I went I couldn't make
064it so I listened to commissioner Hesby present to the Senate budget and Appropriations Committee about um education and in both meetings Senator Beck talked about that bill and she's it's a bipartisan Bill and she's um um working on it with Sweeney um so I got very interested in the bill it hasn't doesn't have a number yet it hasn't been finalized um so I reached out to Senator Greenstein and I talked to her about it and she told me that she has been talking to Senator Beck about it and voicing her concerns about Monroe um and she I asked her you know as soon as the bill gets a number and is available to the public can she send it to us so that um we can take a look at it and actually sit down
065with um Mike and Mary and determine how it impacts um Monro so she's going to do that for us it's it's nice to that we finally getting the first base over here it's been quite a few years and it's been quite an effort but I think we're finally seeing some light at the end of the tunnel um but I guess the key word here is show us the money because that's what it's all about uh any pres yes if I may just add to that um add to the optimism with the with this bill um in our meeting with Senator Sweeney we were told that this could affect the very next budget year for 1718 and could lead to increases in state aid that are are amortised uh for districts but could be a significant
066increase even as as early as next year so we look forward to that so I guess the key thing to say is let's keep those cards and letters going out to our elected officials everyone it's uh it's important any other for other board business because I do have something on other the board business I'd like to bring up it's come to my attention you know we've switched to All Digital here on computers for uh Communications and that's been very good as far as uh uh committee reports but when it comes to the agendas I know some of us have been printing them out and then there's changes and there's more printing out and it's a lot of paper and a lot of ink and on our little uh on our little printers uh so I
067want to throw that out there as far as uh a matter of discussion uh difficulty level of difficulty in in dealing with the the paperwork and and Communications if anybody's been experiencing anything like that uh oh yes I I if any board member would like to comment I I'd appreciate that oh yes yeah I mean I been finding it difficult using not necessarily the Google Docs but not having a delivery of the paper because I keep reprinting and reprinting and it would be nice just to have the agenda and the meeting minutes in hard copy anybody else yes M call yeah and I've always done the same thing I've always made a copy of the agenda at home and brought it with me because I like to take notes and I like to do it
068on a hard copy instead of correlating a a you know computer with a pad and everything so um I don't have a problem with any of the backups or the Googles or uh committee reports yes but I would I personally would prefer a hard copy of the agenda but I would continue to make my own if if that wasn't impossible wasn't possible anybody else Mr nin I I love it the way it is and I I congratulate us for moving this way the only thing is uh I why don't we give people the option uh like I said I would I prefer not to but obviously some people do so what the heck another idea I I I had mentioned to superintendent that I just think that I'm learning I'm still learning Google Docs but
069things are buried in there and I don't have um I feel that I I'd like to have everything available and I know it's available there but if I can't find it it doesn't matter so um know I have also printed out my own materials to do the same thing I keep records and notes and then I have that record if if we look only at Google Docs which is fine and I'm happy to learn new things um but then I and I lose any record of anything that I've either comment or especially with with the policies and and the like so there is some Advantage although I'm a tree hugger I would like to uh you know I I'm I'm I'm ambivalent about printing everything but I just want to have access to all the
070information before board meeting one of the reasons why I abstain from the M meeting minutes is because I couldn't find them on D Google Docs I'm not going to vote on anything that I can't review so um there's there's maybe a learning curve that still has to happen but i' I'd like to I'd like to have the information you know I think it's important before I vote sure uh first of all just my own personal feelings that as board members uh you're volunteering your time it's an unpaid position you all are very busy with everything going on in your life and the last thing that I want to do is cause you more um stress or or or anything else related to that uh at the same time um uh so I want to meet
071you at your comfort level if that means printing out an agenda I'll certainly print it out for you the the issue um that I would like to point out and possibly compromise would be this as you fully are aware uh this is a you know a sizable district with a lot of things going on and a lot of moving parts we try to gather as many items as we can by the Friday before the board meeting so that we send you the most updated agenda however things do occur after that Friday between Friday and Wednesday so to um when we add things to the agenda we have a couple different ways that we could handle that we could send you a hard copy Friday with the agenda and I don't know whether you want all
072the backup material because that's considerable or if you would feel comfortable enough with going to Google drive to see the backup material I'm seeing heads nodding I'm going to take that as at least affirmative in some areas um but the um when it comes time to Wednesday now we have a couple we try not to but many times we have a couple additions to the agenda they're not all on one page they may be throughout the agenda so I'm imagining and based on experience with other boards that you you P your agenda on a Sunday morning you have your cup of coffee you're writing your notes standing all the agenda okay now you get here Wednesday we walk in we say hey we got the revised agenda for you yeah but I have all my
073notes on this one so now you have two agendas and you're looking back and forth so a Poss possible compromise might be this we give you a hard copy on Friday any additions are that are made we put up a monitor a screen between each board member so that you both can see it and that will have the updated agenda and we will cons scroll through so you don't have to do anything it's just there there won't be there won't be a keyboard it'll just be a screen we'll have a daisy chain together so that we're operating from up here Dr ALU has kindly agreed BB command Central uh and any links that go on the agenda we she could easily click and you would see it on your screen but you would still have
074your hard copy to copy notes down and any updates if there was an uh you know add it number or letter N or number two or whatever on the agenda we could point it out to you and if you didn't have the hard copy version you could look at your screen for that so you don't have to answer tonight but I just thought that might be a nice compromise to keeping things as digital as possible while still giving you the the comfort of having something to keep your notes on so why don't we do this um why don't we think about it and then maybe you can get back to me call me email me something and then I'll be speaking to Dr kosac on that and in the meantime if you would um m
075board president I'm sorry if you would uh if you want the hard copy and I have a good idea of who those members are that want the hard copy uh please let us know I'd be more than happy before the 27th to make sure that you get a hard copy delivered uh to your door for that okay thank you okay um I think we can move to our second public forum now this is not necessarily pertaining to the agenda if anyone from the public would like to come up and make a comment uh I'd ask you to step up to the microphone state your name address and be limited to three minutes Mark Klein 7 crore um what you just brought up about U Senator solo and Senator Sweeny are going to try to listen
076to you and help you you got a better chance of selling the Brooklyn Bridge uh I was at that budget and Appropriations hearing as a resident and I saw firsthand the disrespect shown to our superintendent Dr Hamilton and to our business administrator Mike gski I saw you you mentioned Jennifer Beck before she heard anything she voted against us okay the only one that was for us and paid attention was Senator panaco I saw total disrespect by Sweeney to other people sitting on that committee because they were probably Republicans they're full of baloney and uh later on when I can well I don't know can I speak about something else now or do I have to wait until later okay so that's the story there okay um I've always brought up about the state constitution about
077free public education and I spoke to Tom and Tom said well what really is free public education we pay for it and I I thought about it and at first he was right but he's wrong the money that comes from the state is income tax Lottery money everything other than property taxes and then some property taxes also so in reality free public education paid for by the state isn't only paid by us in property taxes unfortunately we are paying it here in Monroe was that me you got another minute only another minute oh give me a break I um can I come back a second time if I can't finish to finish this I know want to try finishing um as we already know that the money that's in the State education fund 60 to
07865% are going to 31 school districts you brought up about the Newark education Law Center they're the ones that brought up at something like 14 Abbot decisions to the state supreme court so if they are going against this graduation standards that the state set I'm sure it's not going to benefit our school district okay so that was the part that I wanted to say about the the free public education then I said fair share we're entitled to our fair share and and Tom again said well what would you classify fair share and it was the same thing I always said is other districts that are rated the same way we are should be getting the same he's absolutely right there were other circumstances involved but something that I said when I was on the board
079and the senator from Warren came out with it 3 years later or four years later I said that every child in this state I just ask you to to finish up because your time is up can you just let me go a little further to finish this please give you another few seconds I need more than two seconds but anyway every child in this state is worth the same whether they're from Trenton Princeton uh Newark East Brunswick Perth Amboy North Brunswick and Monroe they're all worth the same the state is telling us that the students in Monroe Township are not worth the same as the student in per Amo Newark or Trenton I have to stop you there I thought we just going and take a few more seconds it's just going to be a
080few more seconds Mr Klein we don't have that any more time we're really out of time it wouldn't be fair to anybody else that want you open up again I can come up again no I don't think so wait yes I'm sorry yes we changed that yes yes or no yes yes yes for the third public forum thir no no is anybody else yes can you hear me push it down there you go my name is Donna manoni I'm a substitute teacher in the district um my name is Usha sing I'm a substitute teacher also certified the question we have is we'd like to know why substitute teachers are no longer all allowed to work a 5-day week in the district we're only limited to 4day work week I can answer or you can answer
081I I wasn't aware of of uh of Regulation or or policy limiting that I mean we have substitut that do work more that are full-time M um so the substitutes that I know even if they have a long-term position are working four days a week and then the extra day that's available another sub comes in to fill in I I was I was mentioning to Dr kak I wasn't aware of any inhouse procedure limiting the time that a substitute could work we don't have any policies to that effect uh we do try to go through a rotation for substitutes and we have a very vast substitute list maybe that could be the reason to sharing the hours but but let me clarify though if I could Mr President sure uh long-term Subs when you say
082long-term Subs if they're going to be in for an extended period of time we do put them under contract and they do work every day okay I know of some substitutes that work for teachers perhap uh perhaps uh maybe on an extended sick leave they're only put they might not be certified teachers at this point they're still considered substitute teachers they're working a 4-day work week and then someone else will come in for that fifth day I've been substituting in the district for 15 years this has just been implemented in the past two no explanation was given to be quite honest with you we thought it was because of Obamacare that Federal mandate that you cannot have an employee working 30 hours a week or more without offering benefits however neighboring districts East Brunswick North
083Brunswick South Brunswick have substitutes working five days a week so now I'm starting to think this is not a federal mandate that you know law across the land well I would say for the healthc care law and I would defer to Mr Gori that there is a minimum or a number of 30 hours that if they work that so you're right about that um and as far as what East BR Brunswick does I'm not 100% sure what they're doing but right but if if it's a you know federal law across the land it should be implemented across the land other schools shouldn't be able to have substitute teachers working 5 days a week unless they are offering them health benefits and they're not Dr kak I can't speak for respons there is an Affordable Care
084Act requirement right that requires um the district providing um health insurance right when a part-time worker exceeds the number of hours that's that's certainly one issue and that's the law but there is no Monroe policy limiting substitute hours to skirt or circumvent that law it's just not in place so how do we get around being blocked on asop when once we already have our four days filled the teacher cannot request us we're done for that week I don't know who it benefits cuz here's a situation I'm me it doesn't benefit the teacher nor the students because for example I work three days this week for one teacher she wanted me there for another day I couldn't accept that other day because I already had the fifth day I I'm working on Friday so I work
085for one teacher Monday Tuesday Wednesday can't work tomorrow because I have a day filled in for Friday so now another substitute teacher comes in for one day no continuity different it's difficult even when you have a teacher that's requesting a specific sub I'd like the sub to be there for me for this one week she knows my student she knows my plan it's not happening let me say first of all let me thank you for bringing this to our attention um I think at this point I have to ask our Administration to look into this because I think we're unaware of of everything that uh that you're aware aware of and we need to find out and get the bottom of it so thank you I appreciate it thank you very much thank you thank
086you is anyone else from the public other than Mr Klein Mr poy good evening Doug poy for Road um and I told Mark I said I want to get up there and speak before you jump back up um uh but uh I I'm afraid at least what I'm reading in the newspaper I'm not as optimistic about uh Monroe's future uh based on the Sweeny Beck uh Bill the the possible bill that may come about uh because ever since I heard of this I've been following it very very closely in the newspaper and reading everything that I could get my hands on uh regarding that and from my understanding is that um yes they are they are looking at reducing uh state aid that they are giving to districts that have been losing students but the
087the extra Aid that will go to other districts are only for those districts who are spending under adequacy and this district has always been an over adequacy budget District so I am not at all optimistic that Monroe will benefit from this and and I just want to raise that I I'm not I'm not the kind of person that likes to be pessimistic but based on everything I've read in the newspaper I do not think we are going to benefit from this change as I presently read uh in in reports that appear in the Star Ledger uh and that's basically been my my resource on that so I just want to caution the public as well as members of the board uh I don't think the picture is as rosy as it was being painted tonight
088by some of the comments that I was hearing thank you thank you Mr Po let me just say that um you know that we've been very diligent on this and we're watching it very closely and communicating with our legislators um at this point I think you know we we've been optimistic but as I said a few moments ago show us the money and that's that's where our our attitude is so uh it's a wait and see thing we're not legislators we only hope that they come across for us anyone else from the public Mr Klein crunch let me know when I have 15 seconds left please um these comments are not against you or the board it's just that we've seen what transpired in person with the losers in Trenton and they all losers what
089I when we talk about Fair share we always said fair share was based on the way a district is uh socioeconomically versus others and in reality that's wrong you know what fair share is fair share is that every student every child in this state is worth the same and I'm not going to go through the towns again okay and what I said when I was on the board is let's just take a figure of $6,500 and fair share is that every student and every District I should say every district will receive $6500 in state aid per student and then based on the amount of special Aid students you have you receive extra funds special circumstances we're talking about breakfast and dinner and all this other crap those schools would get more money but at least
090you're starting fair you're run the same level for the base funds but when you have school districts and we're talking about Trenton Nork per Amwood that is spending anywhere from $30,000 to $440,000 a student most of it if not all of it is state aid they get all their schools built totally for free and we had that discussion about New Brunswick High School $187 million paid for by the state we had a fight to get 15 million it was promised to us is that that fair no it's not so to me a f year and this senator from Warren came out a few years later and he came out with a flat amount of like $7,200 period what I'm saying is come up with a figure and then allow the districts that have a larger
091percentage of special ed extra money then you have Fair funding so the baloney about uh fair share compared to other districts that's a bunch of loone because if that was the case old bridge when I was on a board was getting $4,700 per student we were getting $400 per student okay I'm finished with that now one thing I do want to bring up is 30 seconds 30 seconds good I received an email from a journalist in Westchester last week wanting me to comment on what transpired at this meeting between Dr Hamilton and myself I refused to do that I'm letting the board know I did not answer she left the phone number I'm just letting it die he's away he's doing well I'm doing well it's over the last thing that I want to say
092and this you have to give me time for is I want to compliment all of you for the budget it's the first time that I'm totally comfortable with what you people have done for the new budget I finally have confid and that you did your best to make the increase as minimal as you could and again I thank you my neighbors thank you uh who else can I thank everybody in the town should thank thank you Mr anybody listening that's fact thank you very much anyone else in the public not seeing anyone we'll move to the Clos session uh resolution be it resolv that the Board of Education of the township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa
0931046 through 10421 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying Personnel matter following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in Clos session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists how much time discussion second well let me let me vote all in favor I I opposed one opposed abstain recuse the motion passes how much time do you think we're going to need let's say 30 minutes okay we'll be back in about 30 minutes thank you meting all right we're still in session uh we're um going to begin now with our um third The Forum um we have two resolutions one on HIV one on HIV matter and the other uh Personnel uh if anyone from the public is interested in speaking on
094these matters I can come up to the microphone okay if not I going to uh read resolution one at a time and we'll vote first one uh it's recommended that the Board of Education approve the suspension with pay of employee number 3977 retroactively upon the commencement of the work day on April 7th 2016 pending further action of the board the superintendent and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action of the Board of Education sove second have a vote Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K panowich yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky I abstain thank you sir Mr board president motion passes thank you okay second resolution
095it is recommended that following a hearing requested by a parent to review an initial determination by the superintendent of schools pursuant to the anti-bullying Bill of Right Bill of Rights Act I'm sorry of the Board of Education one affirmed the superintendent's initial determination regarding in the harassment intimidation and bullying complaint involving student number 8281 16 and two direct the superintendent to provide a copy of this resolution to the parent go move second second okay we can vote Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo and Mr rutsky Iain thank you sir Mr board president motion passes thank you uh next scheduled meeting of our board of education is Wednesday April 27th 2016 at 7 p.m.
096right here in the High School uh do I have a motion to adjourn second all in favor I any opposed I don't think so thank you oh allose thank you