001good evening this meeting of Monro Township Board of Education is now called to order I'd like to ask our student board member Nicholas thorney to lead us in the pledge to to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with li Li and justice for all thank you before we go on I'd like to ask everyone for just a moment of silence if you could stop we you're standing uh just a moment of silence for the victims of that tragedy in Orlando thank you all very much much be seated Mr Gorski we can have a roll call Miss armeno Mr Braverman Mr de Mayo Mr calman here Mrs kapano here Mr noin yes Mrs Corino here Mr Ryback here Mr Russo here
002and Mr rutsky here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Mona Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof hosted June 10th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you very much could move to approval of minutes I need a motion to approve the minutes of the public Board of Education meeting of April 13 2016 so moved I have a second second okay any discussion we can vote all in favor I any opposed extensions refusals motion carries I need a motion for the approval of the closed session meeting of April
00313th 2016 so moved second second thank you okay um any discussion second I heard that any discussion no we can vote all in favor any opposed extensions or recusals motion carries it's now my pleasure to move to the recognition of our retirees Dr kosak thank you Mr President I'm going Mr President I'll be going down to the floor to recognize our retirees I going ask e knock around so I mention should up here bring it here so good evening gives me great pleasure to recognize the men and women who are about to announce their names for their years of dedicated service and when I look at the number of years that these men and women have given to this community to this school district and to the students and the community and the staff of
004our district what I really have trouble understanding is when I look at some of the retirees with maybe 30 plus years they had to start when they were four years old they had to they look so young but they they look like they're ready when I've talked to them and they certainly it's welld deserved for all the work that they have done over the years so with that just so you know for procedures how we're going to do this we're going to call each person by name we have a few of our retirees who were not able to attend and I will announce their names at the end but but I ask that when we call your name that you stand up to thunderous Applause I mean you stand up and uh come to the
005front and we have just a little token of our appreciation that we would like to present to [Music] you Dr alvik always on top of things suggested that I read a resolution which is absolutely appropriate the resol resolution reads whereas the Board of Education of the township of Monroe County of middlex State in New Jersey has been apprised of the retirement of and I'll go through all the names after that be it resolved by the Board of Education Township of Monroe County of middle sex in the state of New Jersey that the said Board of Education wishes to acknowledge its appreciation for the service rendered to the students and citizens of Monroe Township who will and then the person's name whereas it is desired to express recognition for the many years of faithful service now
006therefore be it resolved by the Board of Education of the township of Monroe that it does hereby express its warm appreciation and heartfelt thanks for the dedicated and faithful services in the performances of his or her duties and of the Integrity with which he or she carried out his his or her responsibilities and regrets the loss of such a respected employee be it further resolved that a copy of this resolution be spread upon the minutes of this board of education and that and that a copy be given to the retiree passed unanimously by the township of Monroe Board of Education at its regular meeting of June 2016 and with that we will start okay our first retiree would miss Diane allander please come to the front [Applause] Mr Mr Daniel bavel [Applause] thank you very
007much miss Karen [Applause] Casto Fame congratul thank you so much Miss Carol DeVito [Applause] Miss Susan Faulk [Applause] missell fennessy [Applause] thank you missell Hughes [Applause] Mr Jacob kusher [Applause] conratulations Terry mpola [Applause] you miss yanair [Applause] Miss Marie peepe [Applause] Miss Susan Rosati Miss Eve solo [Applause] Miss Sandy [Applause] Talbot congratulations thank you very much I will miss Andy bigus [Applause] conratulations for the retirees who could not attend I would just like to read their names and we can offer a round of applause to recognize him we have Grace legina Robert absolutely Robert CTO nen Jordan Mar oi and Michelle rockov [Applause] I I respectfully ask that you allow us to uh make a slight change in in the order of our presentations because our girls basketball team uh has a game tonight I
008was told and they are uh on their way to the game so I said that we would put them up a little further in the agenda so I hope you know please accept that [Applause] okay uh we wanted to recognize the students who have achieved an academic um or an athletic or an artistic achievement and we we formed the committee to to develop the criteria because so many students are have you know they achieve at High levels throughout the year so it was very difficult but we looked for students either uh you know by themselves or in a group that have achieved either a state county or a national recognition and when I say County it's like it's County State uh recognition so the following names I'm going to ask for the students to to
009stand and be recognized I do have certificates but for the sake of time we will hand out the certificates at a different time but I would ask that you stand and be recognized uh by everybody in attendance so first I would like to start with our girl our girls basketball coach Lee vman for be for being nominated the greater middle sex County coach of the year [Applause] we would also like to recognize our entire girls varsity basketball team would you please stand and be [Applause] recognized our girls basketball are the Central Jersey group four Champions [Applause] and and coach and girls we we understand so whenever you need to leave we understand if you need to leave before the end next we have our girls varsity competition cheerleading grand national champions could they those girls
010please [Applause] stand there we go that's it okay next we have our Special Olympics of New Jersey bowling gold medalist CH Madu and Jacob barrero congratulations good job good job [Music] [Applause] good next we have our shriber cup UniFi team gold medalist again chy M Casey Phil Pho Philo I'm sorry my apologies Caitlyn mascali and RJ [Applause] Reynolds all right the following are we have some individual students and some pairs of students we have Monique legaspi for making the All State Wind Ensemble there we are all state Jazz B was Graham kak no relation [Applause] All State chus Gabriella jimnez Peter Toto Taylor [Applause] Viana and we have Ivy TR Tran for first in New Jersey in the DECA food marketing series category [Applause] next we have Nicholas Ryan and Sam Weiss first in New
011Jersey and a DEA in financial services team decision-making [Applause] category Emily wo first in New Jersey in a Deca apparel and accessories marketing category Nicholas sty oh yes yes for first in New Jersey in a Deca financial consulting presentation [Applause] category we have Paul aart first in New Jersey in the DEA professional selling event category pmer stoy and Owen rean first in New Jersey in the FBLA future Business Leaders America computer game simulation and programming [Applause] category Shane Patel and Karen Deep Run Ron Howa for first in New Jersey in the FBLA management information systems category [Applause] our model un high school team one I'm sorry we have Karen deep rhawa for the management information system category okay and Owen rean for the fbaa computer game simulation and programming [Applause] category and the model un
012high school team outstanding delegation we have let me there's certain categories in there Jason Delina and Karina vanala earned Premier first year delegates in their [Applause] committee Amy Williamson won Premier delegate and delegate and her team earned Premier brief in the courts [Applause] shr paric won Premier County research [Applause] paper [Applause] there and two students Nicholas thorney and abani uh abinav I'm sorry ready were selected to Kona the youth conference on National Affairs which will be held in North Carolina this summer this highly regarded conference yes the conference host all stars from the model un and youth and government programs from around the country and last but certainly not least our National History B Regional and national competition regionals first place winners from state competition and those winners are Audrey Chen Joseph [Applause] dla back
013Owen [Applause] D Grace Fox [Applause] chrish rupapara [Applause] Akash [Applause] schula and Gabe Toto [Applause] for all those students we will make sure that you get your certificates next we have our support staff of the Year recognition and I would ask I would ask that when I call your name that you please come down to the front from Oak Tree school we have Miss Nancy Simon [Applause] for mil Lake School Mr David [Applause] tessan next we have Sandy maula [Applause] s's not here okay we have Miss Ellis Hansen from Barkley Brook [Applause] School [Music] congratulations right that's thank you Mr Christopher gross from the middle school middle school next we have Bacha gir lakowski from Brookside school she's working she's working okay that's appropriate IA next week from Woodland School igy R Ras rasmusen [Applause]
014sorry next we have we have Sandra bario from appar school [Applause] next we have Jerry Sullivan from [Applause] Transportation thank Miss Florence munz from pupil Personnel Services okay at this time we have a special presentation for you uh Tyler Mahan a senior at the high school was the keynote speaker at the Dare To Dream student Leadership Conference held at middle County College on May 12th of this year the DAR to dream student leadership conferences highlight strategies and information to prepare students with disabilities for College and Career this year there were nine different conferences held in the spring throughout the state each conference conference features keynote presentations from accomplished students and young adults with disabilities who have demonstrated exemplary self- advocacy and Leadership skills so I'm proud to ask Tyler to come and share his speech
015with us uh good evening everyone I hope everyone's having a good night um so this is a again this is a speech that I spoke at uh the Dare To Dream uh student leadership conference um basically to just encourage others with disabilities to kind of not let that stand in the way of them uh going to college and I guess proceeding on in life um um so here it goes I have been categorized as a person with a disability however for me it is all how you look at it I don't like it to be called the disability I like to refer to it as a challenge I did not get to choose the challenges that I have faced they have chosen me most of the time I've been able to deal with my challenges
016and face them headon which has made me a stronger person I realize people are always going to judge you some that bothers me not so much much early on in life it wasn't always easy for me as you can see by the way I walked up to the microphone I don't walk like everyone else I was diagnosed with Cal paly at a very young age my parents were told by different doctors that I would probably never walk I was very fortunate that once I had the right doctors I began physical therapy and occupational therapy and had them both up until the fifth grade along with wearing braces to position my feet properly I have been receiving special education services at the high special education services since I was in preschool at times growing up was
017difficult because of the way I walked kids didn't want to be friends with me and I was bullied off and on throughout elementary and middle school I also had delays in early reading and writing skills and received Resource Center instruction in language arts and math so throughout the years I have faced physical challenges and had specific learning disabilities in the areas of basic reading skills reading comprehension and math computation being in the resource room for language arts had also prompted kids to make fun of me but once I got to the eighth grade the remark stopped the kids realized I was just like them just a little different in my own way today I have many friends and have been very successful in school I think I have always had incredible self-determination I am goal
018oriented driven to achieve all that I set out to do and I believe that I have always had an incredible work ethic and have studied more than most students I have never used the accommodations in my I AP as a crutch to get out of doing work as a senior ready to graduate I mainly use extra time to complete tests and a calculator for math this year I am in all general education classes I have participated in an activities that I'm very proud of all 40 Years of the high school I've been on the school golf team I enjoy the sport very much and hope to continue playing in My Le in my leisure time I have participated in the police explorers as part of the marel police department and I've been able to achieve
019the rank of Captain I've been with the program for 3 and A2 years as a captain in the program I oversee 35 explorers between the ages of 14 and 17 and assist them at events when necessary for example the marble day or the marble Township Soccer Tournament we were crowd control and traffic assisting the police officers during the last few Summers I have attended the police academy as an Explorer and I received an award for being the most determined and recruit I was very fortunate that the seral poliy only impairs my left side therefore it did not stand in the way of me getting my driver's license for the last year uh I have also worked part-time at Wawa as a customer service associate finally one of my most proudest achievements was this year having
020provided instruction to the younger students as part of the lead program law enforcement against drugs at the middle school in town I am passionate about police work and I ask my transition coordinator to help me connect to the detectives that teach the lead program at our Middle School being an excellent self- Advocate has helped me do well in school and achieve my goals throughout high school next year I will be attending Brookdale Community College to further my education and have an eventual career path in the area of law enforcement when I spoke at the darare to dream conference I left the students with a challenge the challenge was as follows we all know that one kid that sits alone at lunch go over to him or her begin a conversation you never know where it
021could take you it could blossom into a good friendship and remember don't judge someone just because they are different from you and always pursue your dreams always pursue your goals until your dreams become a reality thank you [Applause] okay now it gives me a great pleasure to take over the microphone I'd like to call our student board member Nick Thor up to join me over here Nick come on up you know Nick's been a board member here exemplary board member for a couple of years but that's not all he's into you could tell I'd like to read to you some of his accomplishments Nick was a member of fbl deca National Honor Society cona delegate selection youth in Government Model un student board board member intern at legislative district office Monro Township youth advisory committee
022American Legion Jersey Boy State Delegate will major in in business and focus in law I believe he will be attending ruers University what can I say is this some active this is somebody we're all proud of let's give him a round of applause Nick it's been a pleasure congratulations congratulations again okay and now we're ready for the recommendation from the spokesperson of the student growth uh advisory committee uh I've asked Mr Douglas PA to represent that committee Mr Po thank you Mr Ryback at your request I wish to report to the members of the board to our Administration and to the public the consensus of the student growth advisory committee that the board develop a referendum which will address the need for adequate space for the anticipated increase in students in the near future the
023advisory committee was comprised of a cross-section of the community which included parents teachers administrators senior adults students and community business people we began meeting in January to develop a common understanding of the current ability of our schools to house our students and an understanding of the anticipated increase in students due to new housing our process involves sharing of concerns and providing input for consideration by our board and administration it is important to note that the anticipated growth was based on a demographic study using housing and student population specific to Monroe from the beginning of the committee's work it was made clear that all decisions rest with our board we are asking that the administration share with the board the many ideas and suggestions which came out of our meetings as they proceed as you proceed
024with your deliberations it is our understanding that the central Administration will share their findings and thinking with the boards building and grounds committee furthermore after appropriate deliberations that committee will ask the board for authority to contract an architect financial advisor and other pertinent professionals so that specific plans and cost can be developed the building and grounds committee will further deliver liberate in an effort to advance a proposal for a consideration by the finance committee any recommendations coming from these two committees will then go before the board for further deliberation and a decision on authorization for a referendum at this time we are pleased to present the three major ideas generated from the work of the student growth advisory committee and I believe that that will be displayed uh via PowerPoint gentlemen in the back do
025we have the presentation Brian do you have one from that has the list from the uh student growth advisory committee do you have a PowerPoint from that in the absence of a powerpo I would ask that uh someone at the board's table and Dr kak if you would read the three major ideas that were generated by the student growth advisory committee yes Mr P read thank you option A is to add a ninth grade Wing to the high school the sixth grade sixth grades would move to the or remain at the elementary schools build two new elementary schools and all elementary schools would be K to six schools option b add a ninth grade Wing to the high school build a fifth sixth grade school build one new elementary school and all elementary schools would
026become kindergarten through fourth grade option C build a new Middle School 7th and eth build two elementary schools and split the high school so that 11th 12th grades would remain in this school and the current Middle School which was formerly the high school would house the ninth and 10th graders and all elementary schools would be K through six kindgarten through six thank you Dr kak uh clearly I think you can see from those three ideas that the district is faced with uh not a simple obstacle or challenge in the past they've had to decide about building one elementary school or they've had to decide about building a new high school but these options show that they're having to take under into consideration what to do about the high school what to do about the middle
027school what to do about the elementary schools it's a much more complex problem than I recall they're ever having faced in the past our student growth advisory committee trust that our work will be useful to the various committees and the board as those bodies work to address the physical needs for classroom space in the years to come thank you thank you Mr poy I also like to publicly thank all the members of the student growth advisory committee steering committee uh for all their hard work uh and dedication now I have a resolution I'd like to read I hereby move that the Board of Education one acknowledge receipt of the recommend ations of the student growth advisory committee and two authorize and direct District administration to engage in a limited design study for potential referendum project
028subject to further deliberations and recommendations by the building and grounds Transportation committee and the finance committee and ultimately for deliberation and consideration by the full board so mov I'm not finish here the board president superintendent of school and business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action on the board of education of the Board of Education Some Mo we have a second anyone second I'll second it all right Mr G okay Miss armenio there well there's no discussion yes sorry first of all we really couldn't hear the resolution down here could clearly it's difficult that do you have a copy of it there you could read it again I certainly I could read it again just I don't know how to let me try one more
029time I hereby move that the Board of Education acknowledge receipt of the recommendations of the student growth advisory committee and two authorize and direct District administration to engage in a limited design study for a potential referendum project subject to further deliberations and recommendations by the building of grounds Transportation committee and the finance committee and ultimately for deliberation and consideration by the full board the board president the superintendent of schools and the business administrator board secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action of the Board of Education it was moved we have a second I'm sorry I have a hearing problem to begin with the Acoustics in this room are not very good people sitting next to me that have good hearing can't hear very well are there cop
030you should I was told you had copies of the resolution you don't I can't hear either it's really it's cop of The Resolution there too much could we turn the monitors up as well please I'd like to say that the buildings and grounds committee discussed this last night and we've come to a recommendation of our own and I think you're usurping uh The Authority or the the uh the decisions that we made at the buildings and grounds committee uh I think there's time for this I think it will come along but I think this is premature could you explain to me why Mr braan why you think we're usurping that at at our meeting last night we engaged in an extensive discussion and review of the student growth hat hoc committee process and they request
031and we requested that the administration returned to the building and grounds and transportation committee with a recommendation for facilities expansion I think I think you've taken it further than that and it's and I don't think we should be doing any more at this time so if you proceed with that motion I will be happy to vote against [Music] it I think it's necessary for uh a motion to pass so that we can authorize the um Administration to deliberate and then send it officially send things back to the uh to the um buildings and grounds committee I think you know from what I understand your deliberation was uh was about a process not about any kind of a plan uh for for development of schools M armeno um I would uh the first part of the
032resolution um acknowledging the receipt of the recommendations of the student growth advisory committee I accept that and I agree with Mr Braverman that there was a discussion disc there was ample discussion about authorizing a limited design study for potential referendum I'm not sure what that means um I'm against authorizing the spending of money unless we know in what direction we should go I think if we start engaging Architects and they come up with plans and then we reject the plans we're just going to be spending money that we shouldn't spend until we have an idea of which um option or or closer idea of what option we're going with so uh this the second part of the resolution I think is U premature Mr President yes if I may um at the building grounds Transportation
033committee a different resolution was presented one that authorized the use of professionals including the architect financial advisor Bond counselor and engineer to facilitate administration of of course at a cost of professional fees that was not approved and recommended at the committee level and therefore this resolution that you have before you tonight is simply authorizing receipt of the recommendations on behalf of the student growth advisory committee and two authorizing District administration to engage in a limited design study which will not engage professionals and presumably will not have outside costs that was the recommendation of the building ground Transportation committee last evening yes M okay so I need clarification is number two authorizing any expenditure of funds no no so there's no expenditure of funds in this resolution correct as as recommended by the committee any other
034questions yes call P who will be engaged in the limit design study for potential referendum projects because it was my belief last night also at the buildings and gr grounds committee that we would not be authorizing anybody to do anything until the the administration comes to the buildings and grounds committee with a plan for building for building out um we we had said that we would not be authorizing any money to go to anybody for a plan when we don't even have any clue yet what we want to build do we want to build an elementary school we have three options none of them have been given to the buildings and grounds committee so yes the buildings and grounds committee the only thing they authorized yesterday was to come back to the buildings and grounds
035committee with a plan Mr President that that's it so I can acknowledge receipt of this student growth committee report but I cannot I could not um accept number two Mr President yes number two I just want to clarify again I don't mean to be redundant directs Administration the superintendent the assistant superintendent the director facilities and myself to engage in a limited design study amongst ourselves with the data accumulated by the work of the student growth advisory committee to come up with an idea to further deliberate at the board's committee level specifically building grounds transportation and finance committee and then ultimately to come back to the full board for a discussion but without the second part of this resolution nobody is authorized to go forward in this endeav at all so quick question Mr Cal so
036if it's all being done internally and there's no expense of any money sorry if it's all being done well if it's all being done internally and there's no official expense of money why do we have to give you approval to have a chat have a what a conversation exactly Mr President um it it's because this endeavor of coming up with an idea for a potential solution to the student enrollment stress that will be forthcoming based upon the projections that we have is certainly beyond the scope of the the emergent responsibilities and either of those AFF forementioned job responsibilities it's a separate project that we would like memorialized in the minutes that's beginning at this juncture so there's no let me just clarify something this is kapano because I know you you raised this up um
037there is no spending of money because we we need the the um buildings and grounds committee will get um some information from the administration after they deliberate and then the buildings and grounds committee deliberates and if they when they come up with a design that they think might be workable that's when they ask the board for permission to go out and hire uh professionals like uh Architects and Engineers so there's no outlay of money right now Mr nin thank you Mr board president uh with regards to the uh the resolution on the uh the second part right correct me if I'm wrong the way I see this going down would be that the District administration would basically I I I see where maybe the sticking point here is this design study if we could maybe
038change that I'm not proposing it yet but if we could change that to a cost study for the potential referendum Project based on option A B and C uh I think it could be uh uh may be more palatable uh in the sense that now we're going to be looking at the cost of each option and then once we then have those estimated rough rough at best I understand costs then that would go then to the bg& committee where basically they would have more information of the three options to hopefully work up an option before we spend money actually going out for a quote design study is that maybe where we're headed with this correct me if I'm wrong with you want to answer that yes thank you Mr President um with regard to Mr
039no's um comment in order to have a cost study something of the scope of a b and c presented earlier it absolutely will involve experts it will involve an architect it will involve an engineer it will involve a financial advisor um the cumulative expertise of such a a grand scope of that type of initiative would have to involve professionals what this resolution again directs is a very general concept idea to be put together by Administration to be further deliberated and and refined at the board subcommittee levels any other question or comment were you able to hear down there m Corel did you hear maybe want to repeat that a little louder they couldn't hear um all the statements are clear that's beg your pardon um I'll repeat what I said to Mr no's comments in
040order to have a accurate cost study how much would option a option b or option C cost it absolutely will involve the use of professionals and including an architect who who is very well-versed in current cost per square footage uh also the specific design of the school is imperative in that calculation the financial adviser will have to be engaged to determine how that fits within the district's amortization schedules and the and the predicted ratables that will carry the burden of the levy Engineers willn't be involved so to have a cost study will absolutely involve the use of professionals at this juncture this recommendation does not call for that it simply directs Administration and once again that's the superintendent the assistant superintendent the director of facilities perhaps the director of transportation and myself to collaborate and
041and brainstorm some general ideas on how to handle the incredible enrollment growth that was predicted and studied at our student growth advisory committee level and then go back to the board subcommittees specifically building grounds Transportation Finance to further deliberate and refine those concept ideas can I ask a question why do we need a resolution to do that once again to memorialize the um initiative which is beginning to take place on the heels of the student growth advisory committee and to direct Administration to begin working the number of hours that it will take to perform that beyond what is currently in our job responsibilities it's a memorialization and a directive for us to come up with a concept idea to take back as as a a concept to the subcommittees of the board without such a
042a a resolution there is no action to be directed or taken the uh student growth advisory committee concludes and we resume our normal business any other comment i' like to say something though um you know what we're facing with is is a very large situation very large problem that we have to deal with and I know all of us because we've expressed this want to be as exact as possible although we're learning it's not quite an exact science but we want to be as effective and as efficient as possible there's also a Time factor and we're sensitive to that we discussed that the developments are going up and it takes longer for us to build a school than a developer to build a development because there's a lot more rules and regulations obviously necessary ones
043that schools have to follow but this uh resol solution seems to fall in line at least in my opinion and I think the administration as we talked about it with what came out of the buildings and grounds committee yesterday it's not spending any money it's really just asking the the uh accepting the uh information the statement from the uh student uh growth advisory committee and authorizing the administration to uh Del deliberate that and bring that back to buildings and grounds for further deliberation nobody is authorized to hire any Engineers or Architects at this point it's simply a matter of input and deliberation from board members and the administration well well then I think you could have said Thank You for their findings and we will proceed with with that from here on I don't think
044you need to memorialize it Steve yes just a quick question um from not not mistaken one of the superintendent's goals is to do this that's your memorialization because it's one of his goals so then he has the power to pull whoever he wants from within the district to that end so I guess I'm I'm still confused if there's no money expenditure and it's one of his the superintendent's goals why do we need to in effect REM memorialize the memorialization that we need to do this it seems it's a little Overkill well I'm not an attorney but I think we were advised that we need a a a motion passed a resolution to memorialize this so that we will be able to get voted I don't know Mr gorsky did you get that information from uh
045um our attorney yes this resolution was prepared um in conjunction with the attorney so that might help answer the question Mr calman I just you know want us to proceed legally and uh you know do everything transparent and above vo as possible I hope we answered your questions I mean this is not cost there's no cost here it's strictly uh authorizing the administration to uh take the statement from the student growth advisory committee and deliberate so that we can finally formally start this process delaying uh is I think detrimental to the students and the taxpayers we need to start working on this to make sure that whatever plan we come up with is one that meets the the well best meets the goals uh of this school district resolution so we have a second uh
046I think we can vote Yes this I want to make sure there's no other deliberation M alino did you raise your hand there did I see oh okay we can vote Mr board president what was the recommendation from building and grounds from last night Mr President the recommendation that was uh presented to building grounds Transportation committee last night included a board authorization to engage professionals to refine this concept idea further and by professionals again that's the architect engineer Bond counselor and financial advisor so that when it went to the committee level building grounds Transportation or Finance intelligent questions like what this project costs what is the square footage how many floors you foresee can be answered uh more professionally than a raw concept idea but we are pleased to serve at the board's desire in
047this endeav and if that start of this process is just a development of a concept idea by Administration that again is what this resolution directs but we can do that anyway without this resolution right Mr President yes the I I believe after the buildings in grounds committee last night we were trying to merely put the wording that the buildings and grounds committee recommended into the wording of a resolution and I guess more importantly it's not that I need a directive by the board to do the work I already know I I'm going to do the work as well as you know Dr ALU Mr T and Mr Gorski I believe the more important part was was to put into when memorialize or put into the minutes that the board accepted the findings of the student
048growth advisory committee to me that was the more important part of the resolution um but in the discussions last night with the buildings and grounds committee there was two there were two parts to it and I think that's what we were not I think that's what we were trying to capture in the resolution that's all no cost we were trying to capture exactly what the buildings and grounds committee requested um I think it's just the wording of the resolution that's causing concern but the intent and after discussion hopefully everyone understands that the intent is merely to accept the findings of the student growth advisory committee and for the administrative team to Begin work on the three options and looking at those and to take that information that the administration team develops back to the buildings
049and grounds committee and I I believe that was the intent of the buildings and grounds committee I again I think it's just a wording of the resolution that's causing concern Mr President yes Mr one one final thing because on could you talk into the mic because I can hear too well wow okay um and I just want to be clear I I think I am clear now that we're directing the administration to provide um guidance in the plan before we start doing anything else but on the uh tonight's board agenda on page 58 we are saying we have an architect of record and a civil engineer of record that's K and L and if we approve this is that we're not necessarily approving to engage them yet I I just want to make sure that
050these two resolutions don't compound our issue with the Mr G resolution on the table yes Miss armenio the um the resolutions for the architect of record and the other item that you referenced um are General District Affairs for example uh a pipe breaks in one of the schools and has to be reconfigured regarding the services of an architect we have the authorization of the board then to call the architect and begin the repair I'm just making that up just that those resolutions tonight are for General business purpose and would not be used for the magnitude and scope of a bond referendum project and if I may add um to some of the comments before I you know as the minute Keeper of the board I can go back to the minutes when this high school
051was built and I can tell you from start to the middle to the Finish how that process initiated the initial seed idea where it came from how the members voted where the authorizations came from along the way for the use professionals um the bids that were accepted and um and so on therefore you know I posed a question to the board wouldn't it be nice to begin this Monumental process with this resolution which does nothing more than document and memorialize the start of this process on the heels of all the work and labor put forth by the student growth advisory committee okay thank you thank you any other discussion all right Mr Gorski you can vote Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman no Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs k panowich no Mr nosin
052yes Mrs Corino yes that was a yes ma'am yes thank you Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo abstain and Mr rutsky is eligible to vote on this per our board attorney review yes Mr board president motion passes okay thank you and thank you everyone for your questions too because um we certainly want to um get all these questions answered out in the open I have to apologize one thing I in my excitement to give our uh student board rep member Nick thorney his um due credits and award I neglected to have his report so Mr Farney if you don't mind let's give your student uh report and Mr Jal okay so the first thing we have for today was uh today was the first day of finals at the high school and they're going to be
053going on until Monday and then two days after that on Wednesday is going to be the high school graduation in Trenton and this weekend the boy State and girl States delegates and alternates are going to be heading out for their weeklong program in Civic engagement and they'll be back I believe on Thursday next week uh there are some summer assignments being passed out throughout the high school for various AP classes math classes and language arts classes another thing happening over the summer is the annual fly Camp which is Falcon leadership for Youth Camp it's run by a few of the gym teachers in the high school and it's a 2-day long summer Leadership Camp um one more thing is that the high school recently implemented a system for students to keep their iPads over the
054summer if they pay their technology fees before the school year ends uh also relating to the iPads there was recently a District's uh app for the iPads R rolled out to all the students and on the app students can see Board of Education meeting dates General announcements and the tech department can push out announcements to each student's iPads and there are a few other features in that too and before I give it over to Nick I want to give him a really big thank you for being a great mentor this year uh I couldn't have done it without him cuz I would have had no idea what I was doing at all and I have really big Sho shoes to fill next year and good luck next year in college thank you all right thank
055you um the drama club is already planning auditions for the upcoming showcase next year uh the youth and government chapter and I know a te touched on this last meeting had um its conference a while back in Trenton um even though they weren't here to there were many students who were recognized um at the state level for that um including uh outstanding State Statesman Awards um legis uh legislation Awards including one student who's recognized among four of approximately 600 students um there were several uh uh Premier Awards like Premier delegate Premier first year delegate um Premier brief uh as well as a couple delegates elected for Kona from that as well um and the high school amongst all of the other chapters in the state was recognized as a premier [Music] delegation um finally uh
056o not finally um as we touched upon the different you know Awards uh Deca a while back had uh its International Career Development conference where some of the students who are featured here today uh were able to compete amongst uh students from all 50 states the territories and approximately eight different countries and fpl's national competition will be coming up as well um to en students to compete in business finance uh and marketing related categories the senior award session was recently held which thanks to um a members of the community different organizations they were able to recognize a large group of students uh for their accomplishments and we' certainly like to thank the community for their generosity some of the classes within the high school um have been working on a uh a voter uh registration
057campaign based on information provided from the League of Women Voters du due to the recent change in state law um on the 10th there was a Relay for Life event which was an overnight event that raised awareness and funds for the American Cancer Society and finally as my term as a student member on the board of education comes to a close I would like to acknowledge the incoming student board member elect Stefani scalesi who will be serving alongside a te next year um of course I'd like to thank the board for the opportunity to serve as a represent resentative of the student body um I truly believe that this position provides not only a unique learning opportunity and Civic engagement uh but it also provides a participatory role in the governing body that perhaps has
058the greatest direct impact on our daily lives from board meetings to to initiatives like the student growth advisory committee or the committee uh that evaluated the one-on-one techn technology integrated learning initiative at the high school uh so it has certainly been a pleasure um and an honor to work with such a great board and to represent my fellow students so that being said Mr board president this concludes my final student board members report thank you thank you much Mr Mr thy and Mr Jamal it's been a pleasure having you as a colleague on this board of education thank you and now we have our special education program review by PCG education president I yes thank you Mr President I would just like to as we're getting the presentation set up on the screen uh just
059like to introduce our three panel members from PCG public Consulting Group first we have Dr Jennifer Miller who is the PCG senior consultant and former director in specialized services for the school district of Philadelphia we have um will Gordillo who is the PCG senior associate and former executive director responsible for exe exceptional education for the Palm Beach County School District and we have Lauren pecky the PCG data analysis and project support former special education teacher and case manager for the school district of Philadelphia and I would ask that you come up on the stage we'll give you a cordless microphone so that you can present from up on the stage if you're can you would you uh can you see from would that be better I think that might is that is that cordless I
060think you can just take that I don't have enough hands now we have coess microphones up here can't get it out yeah okay we have up [Music] here we have up in the front here [Music] Oh I Think I'm Gonna Leave This right here too hard to at one time oh you're okay good evening everyone wo um we'll just wait a second I think some folks are going to move down to be able to see their presentation okay okay well good evening everyone thank you for having us here tonight we're going to spend the next 20 minutes or so um going rapidly through our report um I believe the board members have a copy of the full report and the executive summary um so as Dr kak mentioned my name is Jennifer Miller I work
061for public Consulting Group and we were hired by the district to do a review of special education um and really determine the strengths and the opportunities for improvement um around this program and to offer recommendations so the purpose of the study was to understand the effectiveness and efficacy of your current programming um and to really go in depth into understanding the policies procedures and practices um and their impact on student outcomes for students with disabilities the final report is organized into six different themes um the first one being multi-tiered system of supports um which is we will refer to as mtss and the referral and eligibility for services um process the the final report also has a significant section on demographics where we're looking at um student information um about the district and comparing it
062to comparable districts and uh in New Jersey and also some state and federal numbers same thing with the achievement for students with disabilities uh we have extensive data in the final report uh we also have a section on educational settings or leas restrictive environment data indicating where students with IEPs are being educated if it's in the general education classroom or if it's in a separate setting um the bulk of the report is around teaching and learning so how are students with IEPs accessing the general curriculum and what supports and services they receive um or should be receiving to improve the programming and the final section is around support for teaching and learning so the the organizational structures and procedures that need to be in place to ensure that students with disabilities can can learn most
063effectively we started working here in January um this has been a six Monon project where we've talked pretty regularly to the district I would say almost every week uh we spent a significant amount of time here um in February doing lots of interviews and focus groups um we talk with parents um community members board members students uh we did School observations and that was really to immerse ourselves into the program and understand what it looks like here in Monro Township um then we went off and we studied a lot of information about you um there was a lot of information provided to us I would say hundreds of documents that we analyzed um and information that we pulled together to develop a draft report um and then we're here uh we presented we've been presenting
064all day today um we were with the leadership team this afternoon uh the curriculum committee of the school board um a few hours ago and now here this evening to ensure that everyone understands the scope of the study that we did and the recommendations that we're making and then we'll come back in a few months as a check-in um just to see what support the district might need if there are questions about the recommendations and how they've played out here uh we'll be resourced in this next couple months oops this is a a slide that summarizes our methodology and how we go about this kind of work um it's a very much a research oriented activity um where we are coming to findings and recommendations based on three different areas of data collection and Analysis
065the outcome analysis is looking at student achievement data and um trends of student placement um the organizational and program analysis component is looking at how you've documented policies or within policies um and procedures uh and descriptions of programs so that we get a basic understanding of how this comes together um and then the research and practice literature is um pulling in resources um pulling in information about National Trends so that you as a district understand where your um program is uh fits into those National um Trends as we've mentioned to a number of the groups we work with today Monroe Township is a high performing District the recommendations that we're making have to do with how to raise the bar even further um and have better outcomes for students with disabilities uh we want to
066make sure we highlight a lot of the strengths that happen here um because there are many many these are Big buckets um but the full report does have an extensive number of strengths that the district has the first one is the consistently high expectations for all students um this is something that it really stems from the inclusive manner that um that the district treat students with IEPs uh welcoming them into clubs and having um teachers be very oriented to how to differentiate instruction in the classroom there's just a very high expectation and a culture of acceptance here the second piece is around positive post-secondary outcomes for students Monro Township has one of the highest graduation rates for students with disabilities um that we've seen it's in about 91% for the last year that's nearly 15
067to 177% higher than the state Target for that indicator um and also for comparable districts um so it's really a point of Pride here um there are a variety of interventions for struggling Learners um we'll talk more about that will we'll talk more in depth about about an intervention system and what it looks like and what components you have in place here already uh it's a very effective special education department that you have um they they cooperate and and clearly communicate with um all the other departments and it's a reciprocal relationship um and so very smooth operations here um there's a Continuum of placement for students with disabilities and what I mean by that is over the past few years the district has had an active interest in bringing students um back from out of
068District placements in order to do that there had to be a growth of programs um in built internally to support students with varying needs um and so there's a a because there's been an emphasis on it there are a lot of different options for students here and just to expand further on the collaborative culture piece uh it's very clear that the leadership team here works well together they know this is a huge component of their work um and so their partner ship um among all the different areas of the district there were 17 categories of recommendations um as you will the board will see um there are is a lot of detail that goes behind each one of these um we're going to move quickly through them tonight because we don't have a significant amount
069of time um and we're going to go in- depth into a few of them and kind of move past others um but they range everywhere everything from an intervention support system to transportation to developing manual procedures so um this is will be the framework of the rest of the presentation turn this over to well thank you so as my colleague stated um we really looked at 17 clear areas that were areas that that were specific in need of some action and recommendation and really focused on you know what would be the best way to have some action steps that would move the work forward in those particular areas as as has been mentioned you're a high performing District High performing in many measures in your academic achievement of the students General ed students but also
070when compared to other uh students around the states your special education students are also High achieving in those measures and as a district it's important to note that every District in the state of New Jersey is measured by their performance on the state required uh State performance indicators and on those indicators your district is is performing at the highest level which is meeting requirements but again you know in in in every area that you meet requirements there's always opportunities for improvement so we want to focus on those opportunities for improvement that we saw as a result of this review number one is multi-tiered systems of support and the district has already strong structures in place that have been implemented with response to intervention at the early grades and and that is a good foundation to
071build upon the district also has the inrs or the intervention and referral services process in place for students that are referred for special education testing and evaluation and then eligibility where we see that that there is a strong need is really in in integrating and unifying those processes under what nationally is happening Across the Nation and in the state of New Jersey and unifying them under what is called multi-tiered systems of support or a process of providing supports to all students in two areas the academic areas and the behavioral areas and being able to to Really provide clear core instruction targeted interventions and intensive interventions for those students that are struggling because when you are able to raise the bar for those students that are struggling and improve their growth then you raise the continue
072to raise the bar for a district that's already doing well and could continue to improve in outcomes for all their students so we we're recommending that you build on the RTI process and the curricular Frameworks to develop and Implement a comprehensive districtwide system framework that addresses the academic areas the behavioral areas and the social emotional areas for all students and you know I we highlighted in the key findings and I think you know hopefully you've been reading some of those as we go along the way that that uh you know there are areas that obviously would would need some attention and so the those key findings are are areas to really look at in building that framework for response to intervention and unifying the existing systems that you have into under one umbrella and do
073I have the clicker there you do okay the second one is evaluation and the evaluation process is very tied to what's happening uh for all students meaning the instruction interventions that are being provided to students when you look at the evaluation process is really what guides the students that come in through the door and become eligible for special education services and when they become eligible for special education services they come they become eligible under certain disability incidents categories which are listed there we looked at your data and compared your data in those incidents categories with State and National to see whether whether you know you were within the standards or underneath the standards that that are there uh for Benchmark comparison and when we looked at those uh the areas that really Rose as areas
074that showed a little discrepancy uh based on your data was that you seem to identify more students in the speech and language area and other health impaired areas in your classification rates than the state and the national average and you also under identify or have less Le uh students identified as specific learning disabilities and or emotional disturbances than again the state or the national rates and lastly that certain subgroups of students for example africanamerican students are more likely to be classified as having an intellectual disability and uh more white students tend to be classified as students with emotional disturbances datas tell stories and stories sometimes make us dig into the why reasons and so the purpose of looking at data is is to really see what causal effects might be in place and how you
075can develop some strategies if the fact that those those elements in your data are data's data points of concern based on the analysis that is done independently so you know again it's important to to highlight that what happens in the Forefront of multi-tiered systems of support meaning the supports for all students really will have an impact on that process meaning there may be less students that come in the gate into special education because they're getting the right supports in general education which perhaps they weren't getting and that's why they were being referred but again the the concentration on evaluation is making sure that that you know the right students are being evaluated and getting through the processes for the right supports that are necessary data collection is also ingal in in another area of uh
076our recommendations and really it's it's looking at you know what is happening in the district with the use of data and you know we saw that there was a lot of variances in the reporting processes uh that were occurring with the data that is available and the procedures that are used for for that process and also in the use of the data uh in order to make instructional decisions for students uh the good news is that you know we we heard that you had been implementing already uh a a really important assessment platform form as part of that initiative to really work and use your data uh which was management uh by no it's performance matters and so that that's being implemented and so that really will help with the next pieces of of the
077action plan which is designing a system of data collection and Analysis that will enable the superintendent administrators principles and teachers to review student growth and identify patterns and solve problems and make decisions so that that data is accessible and usable at the classroom level so that the teacher is informed on what to do instructionally for students at the school level so that the school leaders and those responsible are addressing the needs of the students that are struggling based on the data and at the district level looking at those snapshots across the districts and the schools and school communities to address those students that that that are in need of supports and interventions preschool is is also an area that uh that Rose as an area of opportunity to improve because it is again a measure
078in your state performance plan and one of your indicators is around preschool and when we looked at the state data it appeared that in the six data elements that were being reviewed uh by the state as reported by the district the district did not meet the requirements in five of the six only one of those uh was the one at the very top on the right functioning within age expectations and that is in the in the area of positive social emotional skills in all the other areas the the district when compared to the state did not meet the the requirements so here you know our recommendations are on expanding the capacity of the preschool programs for students with disabilities on providing more inclusive placements including providing services and supports to children in community-based child care
079programs and uh that effort you know would would be able to address you know some of some of the pieces uh that that are impacting your data the good piece here too is that you already have the foundations for what reports up to the data which means is a strong curriculum and you have highscope curriculum which is being implemented in your school district in your classrooms with the students and that curriculum is is highly aligned to those areas that that are reported and so strengthening and working with that curriculum and the instruction that is happening will really help to to affect change in the data that is up there and opening more opportunities for kids in inclusive settings will also do that clicker problems today so I believe the next one is inclusion right and
080you'll see inclusion twice one uh this one here in the general education setting and what we're showing you here is you know what it looks like uh for students by settings in uh the Monroe Township and when we we looked at your data across settings we saw that we really have less students in in the school district spending time in general education settings special education students than you see uh at the state level so that's an area of need but the state I know also has a challenge and has been working very strongly uh in addressing the challenge that the state has had with LR and with the districts that are that are targeted in that particular area so in the area of uh inclusion in the general education classroom our focus is on you
081know looking at providing supports and services in the general education classrooms to support access access to rigorous Common Core instruction and that is is done again you know by looking at underserved students in general education students who might be in other some of the other settings that you see there that might benefit from inclusion looking at the processes of the IEP to make those decision decisions to move more students uh into general education for primary instruction with proper support and looking at those Frameworks that support students uh for instruction in that area vertical transition was another area of uh need it's already strong and that you already have processes if you look at the very last bullet of the key findings which is the one that I want to focus on there is a strong
082process for preparing students for grade and school Transitions and uh it you bus students you take them to the school sites that they're going to be going to be become familiar with the sites there are processes for developing the IEPs for the students that are transitioning and identifying the needs that would uh be appropriate for children in those settings but uh many of the staff that actually are doing the work at the school level did not express an understanding of the planning process so our recommendation is really strengthen the plan you have you already have clearly communicate that plan and ensure that those that are in the field doing that day-to-day transition vertical articulation for students are well-versed in that process so that it really happens uh smoothly and inclusion model again I that one
083ties into what uh we had previously and that is to develop supportive structures that allow effective co- teing teams to create efficiency and partnership that uh helps build investment so really that one is focusing on the process you're already using co- teing and strengthening co- teing and and strengthening supports for those areas and transition programs is another area it is an area of strength because you have a lot of them but like any strength there are always missing links and so the recommendation is to develop a districtwide team consisting of key stakeholders to review the current programs and how they can be improved and expanded and where they are missing links uh for services that tie into outcomes for students to create those so Jennifer thank you U I know we're R we're rushing through
084these um we want to make sure we get to all of them very quickly um so out of District placements I've mentioned previously that um the district has had an initiative over the past few years to analyze if students really do belong in out District placements uh we want to commend them for that but also make sure they don't take the ey their eye off um the fact that you always have to be considering who should be in out District placement and continue to build internal programs um the organization we've mentioned this briefly as well that um there is a strong Department here that's viewed as Fair responsive and effectively managed we don't use those words in every District um that is certainly something very unique to Monroe Township um doesn't mean there isn't work
085to be done and our recommendations uh there a lot of them but the key ones are around mtss focusing on instructional outcomes for students with disabilities and then ensuring that students are served in the least restrictive environment possible um case loads and support was a this was an extensive part of our study to determine where ratios fell um for for Staffing here um the two I want to point out are around special educ special Educators and Par professionals um special Educators um the the ranking here is that uh for every special educator there they serve 8.4 students with disabilities that's the third lowest ratio of of the 53 districts that we've looked at um so it is something to think about in terms of how resources are used and could be an artifact of the
086uh fact that students are coming back from out of District placements and you need to have more teachers internally um same thing with par professionals um the ratio is 9 to1 um which leaves the district ninth in terms of lowest percent lowest ratio um of par professionals to students with disabilities um the other part here is to emphasize that there is a process for documenting case loads and workloads um it just needs to be more docu more transparent and and in a written format uh around par professional AIDS um our Focus here was around ensuring PR professionals are part of the process that they understand where they can best be used in the classroom and supporting students um and that our our Focus here is on ensuring that you have the the appropriate supports for
087students but there's also a plan to pull those to fade those supports away as students gain independence professional development is a key component of the district tier it's part of the culture there are significant number of offerings um and so our recommendation is to con to continue to expand upon them and think of lots of different ways that teachers and others can receive professional development perhaps uh via technology or Blended learning options um and throughout the report there are recommendations of additional kinds of professional development topics to offer um that's what we would recommend here is to continue to expand wow this is finicky okay um transportation we understand there have been some significant concerns around Staffing this year um making sure buses are are going the right supports are in place um what we
088recommend here is that um there will be a leaon between parents and the between parents um communication and the uh transportation department dep and the specialized the special education department to ensure that parents are getting the right communication and the timely communication about um any concerns they have with Transportation um parent and family engagement um was another big focus of ours um it certainly was reported that um that parents and families moved to minroe Township for the strength of the special education programs here um it's there's a belief that the programs are strong um and that there's still more Outreach that can be done for parents to bring them together as a community perhaps not driven by the district but um organized in a way that helps parents connect uh we also really focus on
089the website and that there's an opportunity to provide a lot more information about program Services who to contact um so that parents can find out information um ahead of time if they want to um along the same lines of documenting procedures we recommend documenting um how policies play out here not just the regulations but how they come to life in the district um and there has been a framework started for this manual already and the final recommendation has to do with um ensuring that the district is holding itself accountable for improving results around students um student growth for students with IEPs um it's there certainly are documentation um policies around student growth but they don't go into in-depth um detail about what that means for students with disabilities so the summary now is that um
090the district has been working to prioritize recommendations um and the board is is a key component of in of determining over the next one to to five years really um what's going to be allocated in terms of funding or or Personnel um and then how they will determine um what's how to hold themselves accountable um and so that the public will know the progress made on all the recommendations I think that's it thank you for your time tonight here thank you very much oh sure you want to stay up here and we'll ask the board to return to their seats and uh open it up for questions okay y sure allow me to thank you very much for all your work and your report okay I think we can move now to oh I'm sorry
091I didn't see ma unfortunately this is the first I saw it so I haven't had a chance to read it but on first glance um I noticed that we talk about the you talk about the IEPs do you delineate IEP in terms of when you looked at the study like those children with minor IEPs like a speech compared to those with more um pressing needs well you know the the I is individual we don't delineate that I mean an it is developed based on the criteria the eligibility criteria for that child and the the services and support that are needed a kid with speech for example that's speech only that that's very different than a child that is you know receiving more extensive support we don't delineate for that okay and when you talk about
092the achievement gap between students with and without IPS and reading math how big is that achievement Gap that that that Gap is significant and in the report that uh that you will have you'll see in the graph the the discrepancy that exists within your district for students with disabilities and students with with that that are general education students but again that Gap that you have in your District I want to point out is just as significant for just about every other District they have there's a big discrepancy in the gap of the performance obviously because a student does have a disability and a disability does have an effect uh you know so so that that is a piece can I just add in also that um the some of the charts will show that the
093achievement Gap here I think it's also important to point out that um students with IPS here compared to the state average um by far you're trending from from um yeah right from for the Elementary grades up to 8th grade you're you're very much above the state average and um at ninth grade it falls off um and the district is below the state average both in reading and math so but when we talk about some of these IEPs and um like children with developmental delays how do we know that can that we can bridge that achievement Gap or that there are some children that just will never make it so we're looking at so how can we know if that's a significant gap for the student really the significant Gap is really based on you know
094looking at the the the expectations you know the grade level expectations and the standard expectations for performance and promotion and grade to grade for students and whether the student with the IEP you know how is the student performing what are the gaps and what are the supports and services that might be needed for that student in order for that student to access instruction in general education which is again you know the primary place for instruction that that is most align to a pathway for student to meet the standard requirements from grade to level but there are some student that's can never meet those standards correct and we have we have students that are there are students with disabilities that are following a more modified standard there are students with disabilities that take a different type
095of assessment and uh you know they they follow that pathway so that they they get on a p it's more of a modified pathway of instruction you know and that doesn't mean that they're less than that is what is right for them instructionally and that leads to graduation for the students and links to post-secondary school transition outcomes and how do you account for that in the achievement Gap the the transition or the the students well the modified okay well again they're me they're not equal you measure them differently right so you know the you you their assessment and their requirements for the assessment are different and the the assessment has levels of performance for students so you know there are levels of performance that that a student needs to meet in order to move forward
096you know with that and the majority really when you look at the modified assessment students or those students what data shows you that the majority of the students that are on the mod modified pathway taking the assessment are meeting the standards of the assessment and the instruction that is that is happening where the greatest gaps occur the greatest gaps are in the students that are following the standard pathway for instruction and the expectation that they graduate with a diploma and move on to either College you know or vocational program or you know Higher Learning opportunities so if you have a Main Street mainstream student who is meeting the expectations and then you have the modified student who's meeting their expectations there's no achievement Gap there the the achievement Gap that we have been talking about
097is based on the state performance assessment that is required for students not on the modified so you're telling me that students who have modified then are you not including them in the achievement Gap they're not they're not for the purpose of how we are looking at the discrepancies of achievement between students with disabilities and students with that are not disabled general led students we're we're basing it on the standard State assessment expectation not on the modified assessment expectation so that's really not but then you're comparing apples to oranges no we're we're comparing the like students because as I mentioned earlier you don't have a gap there isn't a significant Gap in the achievement of your modified students based on the standards and that they're expected to perform on and the assessment that they're taking where
098you have your Gap in achievement is between the students that are following the standard Pathways of instruction and the state required assessment okay so those modified are not in this statement that um there's an achievement gap between students with and without IEPs and reading a minut correct correct thank you okay thank any other questions I'm sorry Mr Mayor I didn't see your hand for the question so I apologize okay now we can move to uh committee reports any committee chair ready to report M calman yes in addition to uh discussing the um special education review uh this evening we had three other topics that we covered uh we had a presentation on the technology Student Association and sorry that the anacronym is TSA um the uh program has to do with an engineering um uh
099group that is going to be down at the middle school um this is going to be a new program that's going to be coming on board next year uh we will be replacing an existing um club or group with this um uh program and and if anybody wants additional information they can see Zach um there's going to be no cost to the district because there's a net we're getting rid of one club and putting in a new club in its place uh let's see if there's anything else for TSA any questions on TSA this one not the TSA okay uh we also have 13 students that are going to be participating in the Waxman student scholar program um this is an engineering and biome biomed yes yeah engineering biomedical 13 students applied two students were
100accepted 13 students applied two students accepted uh this is a program that's sponsored by ruter University uh there is no cost to the district and parents will be picking up the cost to transport the children to the program and the other program was a adoption of a map uh software product which is an online assessment tool that we will be um uh implementing I guess next year and the cost savings is going to be realized by uh work that had been done with uh consolidating some of our software licensing agreements on other products to uh get rid of uh products that we no longer use or found that we had similar or like products in other areas that did the same work um I miss anything okay thank you any questions from Mr calman any
101other committee chair Mr braveman we discussed the Barkley Brook ASB bestus removal project and recommending the uh bid for the board tonight the tennis courts upgrades uh the two there were two bids and they were both uh they were just both rejected the Brookside PTO donation of basketball hoops we accepted that we're recommending that to the board and then there's been a sore connection with the RO clean Manor that's been going on for about four or five years that's finished now they've gone other ways and then there was a committee discussion relative to the use of professionalism for the pre-referendum process I guess I must have left the meeting before that went on because I can't report on that any questions from Mr braveman any other committee chair Mr noin thank you Mr board president
102the uh finance committee met on Tuesday June 14th um the first item that we discussed was the payroll provider uh if you recall that we uh had some issues with an old payroll provider that we've been using in the district for some time uh they decided that they were not up to the test so we had a stop Gap emergency situation and we went with uh ADP after several months it was determined that uh they are not meeting our needs and they will not be able to meet our needs um Mr Gorski and his staff was under a lot of pressure they came up with a another company called CSI not to be confused with the TV show but basically uh it's a much better fit for the district it provides the services that we
103really need the reporting Etc and more importantly um they're going to be able to uh provide this um with all the uh requirements that the business administrator needs plus to add icing onto the cake um their uh first year costs are roughly 73% lower and their seconde costs are 91% lower so it's actually a win-win we're getting more of what we need for less money uh the second item that we discussed was additional state aid appeal um our District administration uh is at along with our board president is working tirelessly to make sure that we get as much state aid as we can um it's not even as as much as we deserve because we don't think we'll ever get that pretty much but we're constantly fighting and we've been told that there is some
104extraordinary uh state aid that we may be um allowed to apply for and the administration uh especially Mr Gorski is actively uh looking looking into that um and that's it for the finance report oh also there will be no lunch increase uh going forward thank you Mr n any question for finance chair can I go back can I go back to a question for buildings and grounds sure so I'm just curious with regards to the tennis courts with the bids failing I assumed the timing was going to be for the the tennis courts to get done over the summer I assume while school's out but I don't understand your sorry okay so the tennis courts B fail are they going to be able to the whats failed on tennis will they a tennis be able
105to be this summer oh tennis courts yeah tennis courts they think they might because I assume it can't get done during the school year no could it get done during the school year Mr President yes yes um Mr rutsky we received two bids on the tennis courts and unfortunately after attorney review they were both deemed to have material defects in addition to the material defects which requireed a district um uh dismissal they were both over the amount that was in the budget so we are going to rebid the project as soon as possible but that's going to put a lot of pressure on the summer timetable so I guess that's my my question is is it something that can be done during the school year or I don't know what season tennis has played in
106unlikely no we wouldn't do that during the school year Jim Gym classes also use the tennis courts okay thank you m did you have a question yes the uh policy committee met on June SE uh 6th uh there was really No Agenda it was sort of just an open discussion we were not discussing any policies per se we did have a discussion and we spoke to the administration regarding just some questions some of the board members had and I will read them uh we don't have answers on these yet we're just reviewing some things and and we had just uh some open discussions one of the questions was can all positions be submitted through Apple track Apple track for um the employees seeking jobs in Monroe uh Apple track is a internet system that uh
107people can apply to uh the other question is can apple track notify including those who are not selected for any interview after the finalist is approved by the board uh we're not sure we know that Apple track uh gives some sort of indication that the uh resume was received but we we were thinking that it would be uh it was just a question uh if the people who did not get a job were notified about it and got some kind of receipt based on that and the third inquiry was can the process of how employees are hired be put in writing there's no uh policy to that effect uh we don't know that a policy is necessary however we would like um some kind of formalization so everybody knows how the process is uh done
108so those are just questions again there was no policy discussion and we have not gotten any re any answers to the questions that that'll probably be for a future policy meeting thank you Mr any questions any other committee chair wanting to report not seeing anyone uh we could move now to our public forum this is the area where um you come up to the microphone please give your name address you have three minutes uh I'm going to ask you to please adhere to that uh those three minutes and you can only address items on the agenda at this portion anyone from the public wanting to come up just go up to the microphone my name is Charlie lurman 11 Dell Drive um I was I was on the the resident advisory committee and I'm pleased
109that Mr Rybeck brought this resolution uh up to a vote um and the reason to me is obvious that the process must must get started and uh and it passed and I'm pleased that it passed uh what I do question is the no votes and I question that because I'm not certain that the people who voted no fully understand the the severity of the problem that we're all facing so I would tend to think that semant semantics should take a back seat and you should seriously start the process especially when the initial process is not going to cost the taxpayers one dime now I want to begin with what I prepared this evening I will Begin by stating that the municipal portion of the township budget is St is stated at 20% and those officials
110responsible for the municipal portion mayor and Town Council have stressed this statistic before the before their constituents it is also pointed out that the school budget is responsible for some 60% of the township budget it is my opinion and I stress this many times before the Town Council and planning board that decisions made by the planning board Town planner and our elected Municipal officials have negatively impacted the school budget thus the 20% is not transparent in particular the present master plan which was adopted about four years ago has in my opinion called for out of control non-ag restricted housing thus putting a tremendous burden now on our schools as well as the education of our children that plan calls for a tremendous number of non-ag restricted development I do not believe that the school board
111had any input on the development of the master plan which if correct is troubling wherever you drive through monreal Township one sees many signs advertising new developments a direct result of the present master plan in addition the newly negotiated affordable housing formula which calls for every one unit of affordable housing the developer is allowed to develop four market rate units thus a 4:1 ratio which compounds the burden in my opinion this was the best the town could do under the circumstances and in my opinion did a good job in the in the negotiations but we have to understand that this will result in significant non-ag restricted units which will further burden our school system your time is up um can you finish two about a minute and a half about a minute left to go
112can I please have ex minut I can't not I can't give you another minute what I can do is when the other speakers are finished you can come back and finish can I just summation okay okay just one more paragraph in the summation in summation this school board has been dealt a very difficult hand at no fault of their own the master plan which I spoke about and the affordable housing which is mandated by the courts will put a tremendous burden on education as it presently stands some serious and probably unpopular decisions will have to be made by the school board if given a choice would not be made but the facts speak for themselves I am confident that the school board will seriously consider the education of our students as well as a Keen
113Eye on the taxpayer responsibility in the resolve of this monstrous problem thank you thank you anyone else from the public good evening I'm Christy scurby 8 seminal court on behalf of the Barkley Brook Brookside PTA I would like to ask that you approve our request tonight which was discussed at last night's buildings grants and transportation committee meeting to donate two basketball hoops and the installation of each at Brookside school we strive to provide our schools with things that can further enhance the students experience these basketball hoops will be a great addition to the pr playground area for recess as well as outside gym classes our mission is to give back as much as we can to our schools with that said I would like to take some time to address what I've experienced this year
114in seven years being a PTA president in this district for two different sister schools I have never had a year like this this is the first year that I can honestly say that I feel there is a great division between the district and the parents and the parent groups there have been roadblock setups that set up that do not allow us to reach our full potential for raising money for our schools for example this year the district has allowed the rec center to book every gym in every building every day from January through May I was told that the district now has the parent groups at the same level as the rec center and we can no longer bump a Rec Center basketball game however school events can but we are not considered part of
115the school this has caused our PTA to not hold events that directly put money back into our schools this year while the rec center does not pay one penny of to rent the space in our district furthermore the schools send home Flyers that they copy to raise money for Charities such as Jump Rope for Heart and pennies for patients while I I think it is great to teach our children about those in need and how to donate money these fundraisers do not bring money into our schools however the parent groups were told this year that we could no longer use the school copiers for most parent groups it caused an issue because this expense was not in their budget the middle school PTO does not have its own copier neither does the high school we
116are forced to pay a fee every month at the Barkley Brook Brookside PTA to rent a copier this expense takes away from the money that we can be giving to the school but again we are told we are not part of the school it is simply outrageous how we are being treated we need to work together our parent groups are strong and we need to come together with the district to pass the referendum that's coming down the pike I am asking this board to please take a look and see what the parent groups do to support our school district and not alienate us Dr kak when you met with us last July you assured the parent group leaders that you could handle Monroe and the situation we were in you asked us in October at
117our district education council meeting to give you until June and you would have a plan to recommend to the board I cannot believe that we sit here tonight June 15th and we still do not have a solid plan we were given three options tonight you were part of that committee you should have it should have been your responsibility to come and present a plan that came from that committee we are no further long than we have been this was the second ad hoc committee that's been going on for years I was part of the first one with parent group leaders this is the second one and we're back to the same recommendations now we have three options how much longer is it going to take until we get a solid plan in place because our
118we are 1,500 students unhoused this year Mr scur you're out of time but if you could wrap it up in just a few more seconds I'd allow that sure we we we need to move forward quickly we are out of time we are out of room in our buildings and our students are suffering thank you anyone else from the public yes sir hi my name is Peter Tano 10 kathern Street uh my question is does the is the board considering moving the election back to spring so that the residents have the option to vote on the school budget we have not disc discuss that as yet and not prepared to make that decision is this at this time okay anybody else from the public yes good evening could you talk into the mic maybe it's
119not on name and address and your name and address please I couldn't my name is now I hear you my name is Tracy Valley and I live on Lower Machop ponics in Monroe my question is is the board considering changing the policy for um kindergarten students regarding widescreen testing we currently I'm here tonight because I was directed by mil Lake School um administrators um that the board was going to be deciding on changing the date at which a child can enter first grade I I couldn't make out what you're saying about test I'm sorry the Acoustics weren't good did you get the entrance age policy you I believe it's referred to as widescreen testing yeah no okay uh just to make sure I understand your question are you're asking about the um the date for
120students to be admitted into the school district correct I was told that the board was going to be deciding tonight whether or not to change that date from October 31st to December 31st and if they went if if they decided that way then the widescreen testing would no longer be available for a child such as our own who is on a first grade level but doesn't meet the cut off right not changing the date it's putting a date in you want to respond okay just put we're not vo no I don't no I I know I'm familiar with the discussion uh I don't believe it's in the agenda tonight but we were talking about changing the date for entering first grade correct right but no I'm pretty sure it's not on the it's not on
121the agenda no no it has been discussed but no it's not on the uh agenda tonight okay so no decision has been made to change that previous to I just want to make sure that that we're that everyone's understanding okay um what the change it that's being discussed at policy there's no change for students entering kindergarten that October 31st date is still going to be continuing so students must be five by October 3 first in order to enter kindergarten the question that's come up and the question that's been discussed is for students who have completed a kindergarten program outside of the district those students W up until now have been tested to see if they are ready to enter first grade correct it would be putting a a a date on that so students must
122be six by December 31st in order to be tested for first grade if they did not do kindergarten in the district has that been decided that's I think policy it's it's on the agenda tonight for a second and final reading okay that's why I'm here okay so that will be decided tonight yes my apology I didn't quite understand that's okay I probably didn't explain it as well as I could have yes that is on the agenda we had a first reading uh the last board meeting board meeting and tonight is the uh second reading of that for the adoption of that policy okay okay thank you sure sure thank you sorry for not being able to hear the acustics were not good okay anybody else from the public seeing no one uh we can go
123to the superintendent's report and recommendations Dr Kai thank you Mr President at this time uh considering the length of all the presentations um I did do not have a superintendent report to present so I move that we move on to Personnel okay we have personnel um need a motion to approve items a through triple n do we have a second items a through triple n second second by Mr Mayo okay any [Music] discussion any discussion all right I don't see any hands I think we can go right to the vote Mr Gorski Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes to all req on Triple J I think it is I'm accusing on one of them I got to look it up now sorry you could you could recuse by name
124if you wish no Mr calman should we pass yeah okay thank you wa from we'll pass on Mr calman and come back Mrs kapano uh yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes but I recuse for Unice fona Ricky dong Douglas Gillan and Robert Nash Mrs CR would you please repeat the first name Eunice fona thank you so noted in the minutes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo obain abstain on everything yes thank you Triple L Mr Mr rutsky yes and back to Mr Calin that would be Triple L lul lul so am I correct understand that's a yes on everything but a recusal on Triple L correct thank you sir Mr board president motion passes thank you we can move now to board action I need a motion to approve board action items a through k
125don't move do I have a second second okay any discussion anyone no Mr Gorski Miss armenio yes Mr Braverman yes Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kapano yes Mr nosin yes Mrs Carino yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky so I abstain with the exception of f and g or I vote yes thank you sir so noted Mr board president board action items a through K has passed thank you and now we're ready for the buiness administrators report Mr Gorski Mr board president and members of the monor Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through double X be approved by consent roll call move second M Mr President Mr Ry I think it's a through Y is that well also um there is a removal of
126something on the donation Mr um Gorski can I ask you to hold that one second I just want to make sure that we're correct on the um number of items okay now Mr Rybeck I believe you have a um an outdated agenda it is in fact double x x okay um Miss armenio did you have a comment there's is it I don't know if we're on to that point we have to remove one of the donation items from the agenda yes that was the confidential donation yes where is that is it the camera yes which number is that I had it and I lost it a camera and a monitor I believe KK all right so Mr board president board action item KK correct Mrs armeno yes KK KK is an anonymous donation to The
127Board of Education um that is being tabled so the motion for board action items is a through XX with the exception of KK which is tabled and we have a motion by Mr nostin and a second by Mrs colano Right and I asked for discussion I don't think was there any other discussion and we can go to vote Mrs armeno yes Mr and am I recusing on are we all way to the end not I'm recusing on the Travel resolution the recusing on the Travel resolution so noted thank you aome Mr Braverman yes Miss de Mayo yes but refuse on CC could you repeat that please refuse on CC CC thank you Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes but I'm recusing on CC so noted Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes
128Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky yes Mr board president board action items pass a through XX with the exception of KK which was tabled thank you sir that concludes my report thank you on of time I will pass the board president's report and move to Other Board of Education business anyone I do I do um I sent all the members of the Board of Ed an email about my concerns that's currently before the State Board of Ed they are re in the process of reviewing the graduation requirements for the classes of 2017 and through and Beyond um for the class of 2016 as I mentioned in a previous meeting that the education Law Center brought a lawsuit against the New Jersey doe that these uh graduation requirements hadn't followed the law and the follow-up to
129that was yes the judge determined that the New Jersey doe broke the law by not following proper procedure as a result of the lawsuit the New Jersey do is giving students in the class of 2016 more options to fulfill graduation requirements the current proposed regulations regarding graduation requirements for the classes of 2017 2018 and 2019 also give students multiple Pathways to graduation such as the SAT the ACT Park accuplacer and ASVAB for the class of 2020 and 2021 students who take all the endof year Park exams and don't mean the graduation cut score they can then move on to the portfolio appeals process so in order to meet the portfolio appeals process the students must take 9th 10th and 11th grade park for 2020 there is a paragraph about the commissioner determining another test for
130graduation but none has been delineated for the class of 2021 and for right so so the 2021 the only AB Pathway to graduation is through the park I have concerns about making Park the only Avenue to graduation and I'm not advocating getting rid of it an assessment is required under the federal law overseeing education I only ask that we ask the New Jersey doe to create other Pathways to graduation we need to support our students by giving them multiple Pathways to graduation and this doesn't mean lowering the standards children learn differently and express themselves differently and an online test may not be appropriate for every child this just recognizes that we can measure students success in multiple ways that is why I'm making a motion that we have the administration write a resolution for the
131next Board of Ed meeting to be given to the State Board of Ed requesting additional Pathways to graduation similar to the New Jersey school board delegate assembly resolution passed on May 14th and I will second that motion thank you Mr May is there any resolution no I I'm requesting the administration write a resolution for the next Board of Ed meeting I think that requires a vote no so there's no vote and any question from Mr ma okay thank you move on um we're up to our next public form we have to vote on it uh no I don't think she did yes and I second all right I I couldn't hear okay I'm sorry hear okay we have a motion it's seconded uh any discussion Mr board president yeah uh for the accuracy of the
132minutes may I ask Mr Deo to please repeat the motion because I could hear it either we couldn't hear anything down here about any motion okay I make a motion that we have the administration write a resolution for the next Board of Education meeting to be given to the State Board of Ed requesting additional Pathways to graduation similar to the New Jersey school board's delegate assembly resolution passed at their May 14th 2016 meeting thank you and we have a second this is konz okay any discussion yes missel I actually have a question the could you talk into the mic thank you so you're you're looking to use the content of the New Jersey school board resolution in this as a basis and you've indicated that the state is revising some things and we just don't
133know what that is yet well the process is that um similar to like policy the they propose these graduation requirements no I got all that oh I'm saying you you may you you're saying that as a result of the lawsuit the New Jersey doe is giving students in the CL more options to fill and why would I mean I understand your reasoning for resolution because that's what people are asking for but if the state doe is reviewing things should we not wait for some of those things to come out so we can have I don't I don't understand the question I'm saying why can't we have wait for the state doe to review their options to fulfill graduation requirements they're changing some things right yeah and they've already been proposed and they're taking public testimony
134on it and so this is the option for us to present a resolution to them because so so what you're saying is based on the the time that they're taking public testimony you want the our board to well send something in during by August or September they're going to finalize the graduation requirements okay does that answer your question I'm not sure okay any any other question comment Mr nin I guess just a point of clarification um once this resolution is written then the full board would have to vote on that resolution right we're not authorizing a resolution to be written and given to the state Boe is that accurate No we're we're authorizing the administration to write the resolution we'll vote on it at the next meeting if it passes it goes to the state
135DOA thank you anyone else I'll just make one comment uh and um I think that we all need to think about rigor uh and standards um I don't think this is what you're referring to Mr Mayo but I I'm just going to bring it up as a point of conversation really uh in today's Star Ledger uh I read an article about uh some states or a movement for students not wanting to take the um required graduation exam so they're using their transcripts and and some other alternative assessments portfolios or something it didn't seem like those St states there was any kind of rigor we need to make sure that when our students graduate they don't have to go into remedial classes in college that's too I'm seeing that too much from other states I see
136states that are uh forac excuse me but for lack of a better ter dumbing down their standards where students that are approaching satisfact satisfactory grades as far as meetting meeting standards or getting diplomas I don't think that's the case here I just want I'm just bringing up as a point of conversation that uh I think that's something that we have to be cognizant of we have to know that our standards are high and that when our students graduate they're ready for the world of work and they're ready for college and not needing to go to remedial classes thank you okay uh now I think we could uh vote Mrs armeno [Music] um it's a tough decision but I I will vote yes thank you Mr Braverman yes Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs Co
137Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo and all of stain thank you Mr rutsky yes Mr board president motion passes thank you any other Mr Mr braveman yeah I'd like to move that the PTO and PT be permitted to use the copy machines and their respective schools can I have a second please a second there okay we have a second uh any discussion yeah um yes Mr calman I I don't necessarily have a problem with the PTO or ptas using the school copying machines as long as is it's not during instructional hours when there are students in the schools and teachers need to use the equipment should be on off hours okay um any any other discussion question Mr noin um yeah I just have I guess I have
138some questions I I know there has to be uh I think we've had this discussion at bg& at some point and uh I I too am an advocate I think that you know it should be a no course to the uh to the PT is in the PTO they do a huge service to our students and it's much appreciated by this board and I know by the parents in the community and also the students but I I do have concerns with um taking away building principles uh Authority um a as a building principle uh that person is in charge of that building and they have uh the right to to dictate who uses their equipment because for all intents and purposes it is that building uh principal uh equipment at that point um my other
139concern is uh I understand from the information that was given to us at bg& some of these copy machines are in uh highly classified areas where there may be teacher bins uh with possibly student grades accessible to uh to the parents that may be in there at that moment and I think that while this is a great idea I think there are some Logistics that need to be figured out and that is my concerns for this uh resolution and I would rather hear input from our our District administration namely Dr kak on what his thoughts are on this you want to address that now sure thank you Mr no um this this topic was discussed uh several times with our leadership team our principles and I agree with what you're saying and and what Mr
140Braverman saying and I certainly recognize the positive contributions of our parents and our PTO and PTA groups they do wonderful things they're volunteers they come in they volunteer at the time they work endlessly to for the kids in the district and I tried to find um some sort of a compromise with the building principles with stating that if we change it's not just a PTO it's there's there are other parent groups that are of consideration it could be anybody from the band parents to the football club to whoever I not that anybody ask but there are different clubs and I asked the principles to work very closely with the PTO and PTA and to get whatever they needed uh I believe there's at least two of the uh schools or more that the PTO uh
141leases copers and I ask that you know if they needed extra copies they needed Staples a machine please work with them they they they are our partners I also discuss with the PTO presidents the push to move more to a digital format um as been as you stated we have had many problems with our copers it's one of the teacher leaon complaints that have come up multiple times that the copiers don't work they're getting jammed and there there's just millions of copies being made on the copiers and as we moved with the Falcon flyer and other types of things and outside organizations we tell them that we we're not going to distribute paper copies please send us a um a digital copy and we'll distribute it via the Falcon flyer if it's a community based
142based organization so we did discuss that to move can we please move more towards a toward a digital format and respectfully the PTO presidents have indicated there are times that they need a parent signature and I certainly understand that and it's not an easy thing to just turn it over um but I would offer again uh to work with our PTO presidents I understand the concerns I would like to resolve it with them uh and I would make an open invitation right now uh I've already had a discussion today I believe with um one of our parents that I would be more than open to meet with them at their convenience uh as early as tomorrow and try to resolve some of these issues but you you are correct it's it's a little bit more
143of a a complicated issue than just simply saying uh yes we can do it but I do want to emphasize I do want to work with the PTO PTA presidents and the all the parents um because they are really our Partners in education yes Mr n um yeah I also have a concern as Mr Braverman is a senior member of this board um this to me seems like it's a bit of a micromanagement issue our purview up here is to not run the schools but to see that they excuse me to see it that they are run well and and that is my concern I would like to see this and I will make an amendment to this resolution that we put this to the policy committee to come up with a policy that we
144can direct the District administration on uh uh guidelines how to run this do I have a second on that motion for a uh an amendment to this second I second C can you reiterate that I'm sorry we's the amended yeah what's the amended motion who was the second okay I'm sorry we're we're up to discussion I couldn't hear if anyone seconding we can't hear it they need could you repeat that Mr n time it would be I don't think these monitors are working whoever's doing the sound over there I don't think they're on we can hear he anyway I'd like to amend the current uh resolution on the on the floor to send this to policy to come up with a policy uh along with the District administration to uh make a fair and Equitable
145policy for the use of uh copy machines and printers at the district schools just point of order does the person who originates the resolution have to agree to the amendment I I believe that that might amend first too complicated Mr Braverman uh Mr board president yes Mr Braverman this issue is governed by a use of building policy and may I recommend that you resend your resolution allowing Mr noin to take this back to policy where I am certain it will find favor no we started that we did that in October I was told in October that there was this was settled it hasn't been settled and I just realized that within the last couple of weeks I would like to say though I'd like to amend my motion to include all certified and official parent
146groups in the district jez Mr R I have a second for that Amendment second Mr Rybeck yes may I just point out that Mr braverman's resolution as amended would conflict with the use of building policy I I think I well I can amend that to to include that we change the policy I yeah I think that Mr bra um if you don't mind I just want to interject one thing I think what we're saying is that we have a policy here um that has to be amended before we can take any kind of resolution it can be taken care of in the motion confused okay we have a second on that Miss Al I just as policy chair I'd like to agree with Mr Braverman that that the subject has been brought up on several
147occasions it hasn't gone anywhere and if it is his uh wish if we can put a date certain that by the next meeting we have an affirmative policy on this that would satisfy um the the use of facilities and the uh parent groups I mean we we we have been going around on this for quite a while and there hasn't been a resolve I would absolutely agree that we need to resolve it okay and by by July at the next meeting we should have we should really have a a set policy so everyone is on board with it I mean that's up to Mr Braverman that would be just from a policy standpoint any Mr Bren did you hear what MIA was saying what did you say about the policy standpoint if if we have
148a date certain that it has to be resolved by July the next me in July I said that we've gone all around for quite a while okay let's take a vote that's silly I mean well just as an aside I I taught for 35 years in every school I've taught in in every District I've taught in the PTA and parent groups have been able to use copy machines and we thank them and when teachers needed to use the machines they stepped aside we don't need a labor management decision for this okay any other discussion I'd like to say a few words if I can um as a former building principal I can't tell you how important it was to me to have the PTA we didn't have PTO in New York City but in PTA
149um in our schools they were an integral part of the school and partners with the administration uh I think it's important to recognize that and and um do what we can to help them and if they need uh you know certainly if they need something copied that shouldn't be a problem uh for these organizations so that being said we have a motion Mr Gorski can you re read that motion so people can be clear on what we're voting on I'll do my best sir um the motion is to at the next policy committee meeting entertain no that's not the motion the motion is his motion is on the table I made a motion I thought I heard right that the PTA and parent booster groups that are officially representing kids in this school district be
150permitted to use copy machines in each of their respective buildings and the in the future the policy should reflect the same and so Mr Mr President as a point of clarification should Administration ignore the current policy while this if this motion should pass shouldn't the policy be amended first it would not be objected to by Administration icy is nothing more than a guide it's not a law it's a guide and it's on the books and this board has the right to change it now Mr President yes I think there was an amendment to that motion so don't we have to vote on the amendment first yes we do and I thought there was another amendment from Mr Braverman to his original motion so you have a motion I think we had a motion and two
151amendments yes okay but but if I might yes this is getting a little just just a a a Point what you said I have spoken to and this is in general for policy um Mary Smith our attorney has indicated to me that a policy is actually the law and the regulation is the procedure of that law so I think factually you made you said the opposite the policy is the law of the district as as I understand it and the regulation is how we proceed through it so we can't I don't know about the legality or the um we don't have the attorney here right no but but but the policy is the losser according to our attorney well then I guess you should vote appropriately Mr President yes I believe that the first motion
152on the floor still stands and must be voted on if it's not moved or or passed then it can be amended okay there's no no further discussion on that first motion let's vote on the there there was there was an amendment to Mr braverman's motion by Mr by mrin and then Mr second I think you have to vote first on the I think that we have to vote first on the amendment yes you need Bob's rules should I go get your Bob's rules all right let's take a vote on I have a question yes when we talk about the using the photoc cop can they use it anytime they want could you say that again can they use the photoc cop at any time or or will it be designated times we haven't worked that
153out yet and I think that's something that the they would have to work out with the building principle well that but then the resolution doesn't Encompass that I mean I think the PTO and the ptas do a tremendous service to this community but I am completely complely uncomfortable usurping the principles and if they need to put parameters on when the copers can be used they should be allowed to do that that's why it might be a good idea to bring this to policy where that all can be worked out we can't because we to vote on this yes so first we'll take we have to vote on Mr nin's Amendment check with our okay we're getting a legal opinion it's getting kind of complicated Sen I think it's short I'll fill in the The Silence
154Mr President are you singing a song for us or I'm not going to be singing um I think it's depending on the legality of things I think it's clear from the board that the board wants to cooperate and allow that parents groups and PTO and PT the ability and uh access to copy machines so I think that that statement could be clearly made just in terms of philosophy yeah I absolutely agree just a matter of how I think that everyone clearly wants that to be you know available to the PTO sure m m armeno in the board respectfully uh since the date is June 15 and I guess Mr Braverman uh with the summer months approaching it would give us time to work all the details out uh before the start of the school year
155so I don't know if that would have an impact on anyone's decision but I just wanted to state that I don't think you we're just waiting I think we have our legal opinion Lifeline thank you thank you okay all right Mr president I I spoke with the board attorney and she concurred with my recommendation that the original motion made by Mr Braverman and seconded has to be allowed to be voted on first before it can be amended by a different member of the board you can resend your motion if you wish and then it can be um amended by other parties but right now your motions on the floor sir as originally made so I can call the question question you could resend your motion okay you needed an attorney to tell you that Mr
156Braverman I gave advice on this that the attorney confirms her that's fine as long as we get these people to use the machines okay so you're resending the all all right so now we can vote on okay resend it all right so the original motion is resend it okay now the second has to resend it as well there was no yeah the original motion is rescinded per Mr Bran's request is that how it's to be noted in the minutes and then the second whoever seconding very good so the first motion is now pulled would somebody like to make a motion now at this time I move I will make motion that we come up Mr nin has the floor oh I'm sorry Tom I make a motion that we come up with a policy that
157is all inclusive that makes the pto's and all the parent groups um happy and that we actually have include them in the policy discussion and I request that the policy chair we'll call them in and have them explain the situation in detail I am on the policy committee Miss armenio is the chair and that we can finally come to a uh a resolution that's satisfactory to everyone thank you do I have a second second all right any discussion I didn't hear him so can I have sign language please you want to repeat that sign English you want to repeat it from the phone we're going to come up with a a a policy at are you listening more you're going to come up with a policy we're going to come up with a policy at
158at the policy committee that's going to be reflective of what the parent groups need and we're going to do that with the input of the parent groups which will be requested to be at this policy meeting to give their input and what is the timeline in your motion uh there is no timeline on the motion but we can def I will definitely put that I would like to see this in place by the beginning of the school year got to have a timeline I just gave you a timeline end of AUST oh no let's have it by July there shouldn't be too much activity in July so I think that in order to give us um uh a chance to get this done so that we don't come back and say it's not done uh
159I'd much more rather have that's my motion September 1st if we do it by July you'd have to make an amendment I'm sorry we'd have I I'm sorry I one all right we have a a motion on the floor do we have a second Mr Russo second Mr Russo second any discussion okay let's vote okay we're voting on Mr no's resolution to take back the policy and have representatives from the PTO and PTA and I'm paraphrasing change the existing use of building policy to authorize and allow the ptop pta's use of the copy machines to be done by 9116 did I do that Justice very good okay thank you um Miss armenio yes Mr Braverman okay what did he say thank you sir that was an okay that was an okay Mr too yes Mr
160kman yes Mrs kapano yes Mr nosin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky yes Mr board president I'm pleased to announce the motion has unanimously passed thank you Mr R get that I have another motion for this board of education to consider this is very important so I want your full and undivided attention speak clearly into the mic can you hear me now yesk I move that this board of education never ever have a board meeting with this acoustical design again second outstanding do I have a second I'll second I think you have a unanimous second discussion I favor have a discussion I I'd like discuss that discuss you want to discuss that I can't hear you in 1959 I know I don't look that old but I taught
161in a new school that had terrible Acoustics in the auditorium and for one week the superintendent of schools took kids into that auditorium at different times of the day with Architects and sound people and by the end of the week everybody loved the sound I can tell you that two or three years or four years ago my community started using this facility for their entertainment once a month they did that and we found out that if you open the back door you don't have the the bouncing off the walls like you do now it's much better but it's still not terrific and I can tell you when the school opened and we had the ribbon cutting ceremony I sat on the stage and the audio was just as bad then as it is now for
162you and the audience we all sound great for us up here you have no idea I can barely hear Tom and he's right next to me it's like sitting in a fishbowl if I'm on might it's very frustrating when a a fellow board member makes a motion and it's seconded and the superintendent myself and Mr gorby had no idea that anyone made we couldn't hear a thing how much time did we waste tonight Mr Robert make one yes uh just if I could respectfully make one comment that the Acoustics may be uh difficult ult for the board members but I would respectfully say that that in no way is a reflection of our staff members and students who work doing the Audio I think it's more a statement about perhaps the speakers or the walls
163or the sound bouncing off uh because you know they they I just wanted to make a statement that the the staff and the students work very hard so the Acoustics were it is very difficult I agree just for the sake of time I imagine there's no more discussion on this could we go to a vote on this motion uh this is Mr kelman's motion never to have a board meeting in such an environment with these Acoustics again does that satisfy that's yes it's good Mrs armenio I'm gonna I'm going tostain on abstain yes thank you we never I never say never that's recorded as an abstention Mr Braverman yes Mrs Deo no Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano no Mr noin no Mrs Corino no Mr Ryback no Mr Russo uh since this was one
164of the more humorous meetings I'll say no thank you Mr rutsky I'm going to go with no and and suggest that Mr Braverman put his suggestions into use sooner in the meeting if he knew that the doors being opened would have helped we should have done that 3 hours go so noted Mr board president motion fails they never ask thank you I'm assuming There's No Other Board of Education business are they at Mrs calabo with yes but this is going to be okay there's no motions involved I just we're here for kids and there's nobody out in the audience but we're here for kids and I just want to commend our seniors because they have been awesome um I was able to attend three recent events and I know Mr Rybeck you attended two with
165May um as the Board of Ed rep to the municipal mun Municipal Recreation advisory aard I attended the Ninth Annual scholarship dinner for some of our senior athletes and they were honored in uh the area of sports lacrosse cheerleading soccer softball baseball and basketball so it was a great night and many of our students were recognized then I would like to commend the high school PTO who honored our seniors at the annual senior Scholastic achievement dinner at forestgate Country Club it was well attended and every year we have more and more students who are recognized and finally the communities of monreal and Jamesburg honored our students with scholarships and Awards in the areas of academics and sports and the Arts and Music among many others so I just want to congratulate all of our awardwinning
166seniors and wish them um well because they will be graduating next next Wednesday and Mr Carney it's been a pleasure working with you thank you and we will miss you that's that's my report that's okay thank you any other board of education business not seeing anyone we can move to our as a matter of fact I have something we have someone we had a question in the audience before and I see that man is left he asked about moving the ction to April I know it's very unpopular with Boards of Education I know it's very unpopular with administrators and particularly business administrators but I for one would like it in April because I think the public should have the right to have a say directly and the more the more keeps happening in in November
167the more political it becomes and not only does it become more political but you're pushed off to the little side of the ballot which makes no sense at all so it's it's just a comment I know it's going to go nowhere uh but I thought I'd like to say that okay I I do think it might that might require some legal research but thank you for bringing it up anyway okay uh we're up to our second public forum where you do not have to uh uh speak to the agenda you could it's more of an open situation is anyone from the public wishing to speak Mrs scurby you've been waiting very patiently for this second thought thank you m on oh you're um I just want to say thank you for passing that motion um
168my intention bringing up the copers in my original um comments earlier was not to take away any um anything from the building principles I have worked with the building principles for many years at Oak Tree and Applegarth and going over to Barkley Brook Brookside um it was not a debate over um should the principles have the final say what I was told was it was the Board of Education that was telling them we were not allowed to so I don't want it to look like I was asking um for the board to take away power of the principles the principal at Barkley Brook and Brookside this year was telling me that it was the Board of Education that said we were not allowed to use the copers so I just wanted to be clear with
169that that I was not intending for the board to take away um the the building principal right to uh run their buildings we work very hand inand with our principles um they support us in many ways um Tom I know you had mentioned about um confidentiality um I know that it was mentioned at a buildings and grounds meeting I think or a policy meeting that the copers are in areas where mailboxes are uh the PTA has a mailbox with the teachers we regularly check our mailbox we are allowed access to that area so that is not a restricted area and that should not be a concern for the Board of Education letting us choose the copiers most of the copiers in all of the buildings are not located by any mailboxes anyway at Brookside there
170is a copy room at Oak Tree there's a copy room at Applegarth there's a copy room um they are nowhere near the mailboxes but like I said the parent groups all have mailboxes alongside of the PTA and the PTA actually delivers mail to all the teacher mailboxes so we are in those areas um I look forward to being a part of the discussion when the policy committee does meet thank you thank you anyone else from the public okay not seeing anyone oh wait oh I didn't see I'm sorry we're back so once again um we're here representing our daughter who is currently 5 years old not old enough or does not meet the date requirement to enter into first grade in September can everyone hear me I really can't hear no no one you know
171what why don't you come down right in the front and talk because that microphone it's we just can't hear you yeah but then they can't get it on the record Steve I think she can talk loud enough from there micone first grade but because her birthday fall a few months after the October cut off day we are now kind of like in a waiting game um waiting for the testing hello perfect should I start over no we're good yeah we're good okay just give your name and and address Tracy Valley and I we live on yes with that said the the determination of the boards decision this evening regarding that testing is going to directly affect whether or not our child will be given that that testing from what I understand the testing is done
172in the last two weeks of June so the school itself is waiting to find out what the board decides I say for us as well as other parents that may not be here but I know that our child is not the only one that the testing is very important important because it all children are not the same and when you have a child that is academically and socially um above their grade level they should be given the opportunity to go to school and be excited and be challenged um at this point if we're if our s isn't able to go through the testing and enter into the first grade kindergarten for her is just going to be repetitive she's already had kindergarten in private school and she will be bored so to keep her challenged
173and to keep her learning the testing serves that purpose for children like her she's reading Dr Seuss books she's doing you know math on a first and second grade level she's already learning multiplication and there are other children such as Sadie that are a little bit more advanced and how do we you know as a community how do we also um make sure that those children are being challenged and that they're in the right place in school as well you want to answer that yeah well um first of all thank you for coming and thank you for being so patient for waiting till for many hours to come up to make your comment the the question of for any parent or regarding their child and advancing a grade is a complic at it one and
174I support children being able to move ahead to their potential I fully support that um I I I support working with our struggling students our students who were maybe considered in the middle of the road and certainly sometimes my own personal feeling is that these students who are very Advanced are often not in Monroe but in general almost neglected by you know a lot of schools thinking that you know that that that they they'll do fine now having said that I want to speak a little bit about what's offered in the Monroe Township School District I was in the middle school about a month ago maybe a little less and I was in a math class with eighth grade students they were outstanding they were truly outstanding they were working at a junior level and
175the reason for math that was a particular class I was in the reason why I bring that up is that this District offers many many opportunities for our children to move ahead at at the their individual level we promote that and an individualized instruction the we do that from kindergarten uh really even pre but Kindergarten right up through 12th grade there's um a lot to be considered as I'm sure both of you are aware of the social emotional aspects of moving a child ahead and having dealt with this issue many times with over the years with many different parents and also adults who skipped grades there's and and there's a body of research on that and it really can go either way but students as they get into high school and they get into the
176more complicated areas even middle school and then high school they're if a student may be very Advanced at a young age but it it may not they may run into complexity uh complexities that they're really not prepared for when they get the middle or high school and I know that the parents at you as parents are very concerned about your child and we are as well and we it's such an important step that you can't make a mistake with that there's an author I wanton to go off too long but there's an author author called Malcolm Gladwell and he's a well-known uh he writes for the New York Journal he's put out a number of books Tipping Point blink there's a book he has called David and gath and he speaks to this matter of
177the big fish in a little Pond and sometimes it's better to be the big fish in the little pond because they do better and we can use that analogy almost for a student who maybe excels at a young age I w't want to close the case on this but I would say that it's it's a complicated issue it takes a lot of um thought and process we certainly want to work with our parents we also have logistical concerns as well to make sure that can we accommodate students who move up um you know spacewise and everything else now that shouldn't be held against a child so we don't certainly don't want to do that either I would invite you to perhaps come in and we can explore the issue maybe over the summer with Dr
178aloc and myself I can't guarantee that we could change a policy again it's a very complicated issue uh but I certainly don't want to close the door to your concerns okay thank you thank you and thanks again for your patience any anyone else from the public I don't want to miss anybody okay not seeing anyone uh we can go to our closed session resolution I well let me ask the board um there is no HIV and um we have no no issues with the superintendent's evaluation is anyone in the board still want to go into Clos session concerning superintendent evaluation I think if the I think the superintendent has been waiting if he wants us to do it we should finalize it if not well I just said that yeah he just didn't hear oh
179you couldn't hear me why don't why don't you tell them Dr So Co I was just saying that I was fine with the evaluation I wanted to thank the board I will thank the board publicly U for your hard work with my evaluation I appreciate your feedback I take your suggestions and recommendations very seriously and um I said to Mr Ryback because of the length of this meeting tonight that you know we could discuss uh this even in July or another time uh but I would certainly leave it up to the board if you wanted to have a discussion on this I thank you on behalf of the board uh is anyone Miss Armenia I mean I'm willing to go into close session I don't know how how the other board members feel you want
180to go into Clos session I'm not sure what we couldn't hear the conversation okay maybe we should do all right let me read the resolution we'll go into close session I don't think we'll be very long anyway be it resolved that the Board of Education and Township of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with Sunshine Lloyd chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 and JSA 10 col 4-6 to 10 4-21 to discuss the following subjects superintendent evaluation following Clos session action may be taken the discussion uh conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidenti confidentiality no longer exists we'll be back and I would say no more than 10 minutes Mr Mr Rybeck yes we need a first and second
181I'm sorry I'm sorry we need do I yes do I have a second for that motion Michelle yes any discussion vote everyone all in favor yes okay Mr okay yeah last public forum anyone from the P public I don't see anybody so we can move next scheduled Board of Education meeting is Wednesday July 27th 2016 700 p.m. Monro Township High School no July 13th is July Retreat board retreat that's right 14th it's the the 13th we have our board retreat that's right at 6 o'clock in the high school yes 6 o' yes six o'clock on July 13 I be and uh the 27th is a regular board meeting at 7 o' now I need a motion to adjourn I motion to adjourn second second second Mr rutsky who was first um Mich all in favor
182I unanimous thank you we rejin thank you everyone