CorpusRecord 132968

Monroe Township Board of Education 09.14.16 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
18,827 words · about 105 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001this meeting of the mono Township Board of Education is now called to order I'd like to ask our um student board member Mr Jamal to lead us in the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all Gorski you have a roll call certainly Mrs armeno Mr Braverman here Mrs Deo here Mr calman here Mr K Pano here Mr nosin here Mrs Corino here Mr Ryback here Mr Mr Russo here and Mr rutsky here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by

002having the date time and place thereof posted September 9th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski uh before we have our student board members uh report i' just like to uh welcome back both both of you Mr Jamal and uh welcome Miss scalesi Stephanie scalesi who's a junior in the school and um we certainly welcome you to this board of education Mr Jamal do you have the a report um before we begin our board report uh we're going to have our new student board member introduce themselves for a little bit um hi again I'm Stephanie scalesi and Ana junor at mon Township High School um I'm a part of three clubs the student council um The Poet Society and Tian

003Honor Society and I'm glad to be here so nice to meet you all welcome nice to meet you too okay so for our report the first thing I have is this was the first summer that we were allowed to keep our iPads over the summer so the way that helped the school year so far is in the beginning of the year we didn't have this two or 3 week period where students uh were waiting to get their iPads and some teachers were like they were really delayed and starting to teach or they couldn't teach uh the way they they usually do so having the iPads definitely helped with that and we got into learning new stuff much faster um the sports update dates um for September 8th the girl soccer loses in overtime to Piscataway

004and volleyball beat Edison um the for September 8th also uh boy soccer scores two times in last three minutes to win 2 to one and for yesterday boy soccer beats Piscataway 3 to zero that concludes our report thank you both very much now does anybody have a question or for student board members okay thank you both uh at this time I'd like to have Mr Gorski do the budget philosophy [Music] there plenty yes good evening welcome to the 201728 board development for a budget philosophy this is the kick off to the budget uh process the budget season and it begins with a board meeting of the minds to discuss their priorities and what they feel is important to them next year um as in terms of the budget and what the budget should provide for

005should they focus on new curriculum needs should they focus on new student enrollment needs should they focus on facility needs should they focus on reducing the tax rate or all of the above uh the administration is prepared tonight to provide evidence to help and facilitate the board in developing their philosophy and then Administration will take it from there immediately developing a budget um because with the timetable specifically together by the state we need to begin working with the principles the supervisors directors getting out enrollment information class information uh to determine what their needs are and there's a lot of information that gets compiled for the budget development I'd like to introduce the Board of Education board president Mr Steven Ryback Mr Tom noin V board vice president and finance committee chair Mrs Michelle armeno policy

006committee chair Mr Marvin Braverman building grounds Transportation committee chair Jill Deo Personnel committee chair Luke halman curriculum committee chair Kathy kapano Frank Russo Don Kino and our Jamesburg representative Paul rutsky we wanted to add the committee chairs to this introduction because the it's not just the finance committee that determines what should be in the budget certainly there's a strong argument that policy building grounds Transportation personnel and curriculum has a direct effect and is interwoven throughout the budget and they should be recognized in their process as well okay we we inserted a couple pictures into our presentation to talk about really what's driving our budget philosophy this year probably more than in past years of course our budget is for uh our core Mission which is to um continually improve the delivery of Education to all

007our students and to help our students enter into a successfully into a global Society but as most of you know if not all of you know our student enrollment has been growing by Leaps and Bounds and I wanted to uh bring a couple pictures in just to remind everyone that the construction has already started in two of the areas and um there plus there are developments that are still being finished uh behind oak tree School the development behind oak tree school they're still building the tow houses and just uh yesterday morning or this morning I drove by and there I saw a um a backo in a place that I had seen before so it's still building some of the single homes there uh but it's it's continually growing so U this picture and um

008scores you could click to the next and I think we might have one more right so for those people who are not driving by the uh the two main areas that are being developed right now it's just a little reminder of what's facing us in a little bit I'll talk about the uh the number of students that we've had enrolled just in over the summer and the increase and it's steadily growing and we know that we expected that we've had a demographic report but that growing student enrollment is um putting a drone or on on our uh is drawing on our resources our available resources so we will continually have to add staff we're going to have to add facilities Furniture desk all those type of things and it would be irresponsible of us to

009wait until we're ready to build a new school to open a new school to start planning for that it's going to be enough of a financial burden as it is on the community and we're very we're cognizant of that we're we're we're sympathetic we we we're just dealing with the situation we have and we welcome our new students and we want them to feel welcome but we have to plan for that and part of this budget philosophy is really planning for the amount of students are coming in and preparing and anytime that you build a budget over several years or you plan over several years you don't you try to avoid spikes so that you have one year where it's just a spiking cost so part of this philosophy is how can we plan for

010the future which is pretty much here right I mean they're they're building and the homes are going to be built and open and sold before we'll have an opportunity to open a school so what is a budget philosophy once again the budget philosophy of establishing the annual school budget should entail the creation of a framework for a budget that supports a democratic plan of appropriate funding for the implementation of educational programs so that students May develop and learn from quality experiences based on educationally sound and fiscally prudent planning a solid Financial base is Paramount to assuring that the school district will be able to meet the responsibility of preparing our students for an increasingly competitive environment and the budget philosophy stage should be macro focused rather than micr focused as much more refinement will be

011required and implemented in the future through the rigorous budget process this is a conceptual idea tonight I don't want anybody to focus on any of the individual numbers or concept this is basically just presented tonight to be a forecast of what spending needs we see coming next year and what new resources are available to the district as Dr kak said budget Appropriations or spending is driven by student enrollment and over the past nine years the district has picked up 1757 new students that is extraordinary and and it's and it is very difficult from an administrative standpoint to keep up with uh facility needs as well as student instructional needs this is a comparison from our fall report of last year which is we we do a report called the application for state school aid and

012we count every student in the district what grade level what school special educ ation what um tearing they're in and it used to be that this report drove how much state aid you get it's it used to be dependent upon the students and with a direct correlation it is no longer but the report from October 15 2016 shows a total of 6,728 students throughout the district our projections which were recently prepared by our demographer Ross habber and Associates Project 7 ,55 students by the 17 18 school year as you could see that's an increase of 427 new students in one year's time that the pace of enrollment growth is accelerating and 427 new students is a small school in some of our uh surrounding uh school districts and that's just one budget increase for Monroe

013now I'd like to go through and highlight some of the budget appropriation considerations on a macro scale for next year what we did here is Dr alvik and I reached out to all of the principls assistant principals supervisors directors including the director of facilities and the director of transportation and said what do you forecast your needs to be for next year we want to give the board uh a presentation of what may be coming for next year doesn't mean all of this is is going to get into the budget and I emphasize that again but this is a first prediction of what's needed 454 passenger buses with cameras totaling 396,000 two 25 passenger vans with cameras 126,000 three additional contracted drivers with benefits $144,400 from this schedule 354 passenger buses are required to be taken

014out of service and replaced because of the state's requirement for removing buses depending upon years every 15 years you have to uh remove a bus from service and that also coincides with board policy we're asking for more however in the terms of one additional 54 passenger bus above that and two 25 passenger vans above that require M because of enrollment growth and the need to reduce contracted routes and reduce our dependency upon contracted busing uh as Dr kak Dr alvic and I know too uh intimately nine out of 10 of our busing problems this year were directly related to contracted buses and we did a Herculean effort above last year trying to rectify some of the problems that we had like requiring dry runs by the contracted drivers so they get familiar with the route

015they preview the route uh we had a Contractor on our on our rout our jobs for the second year now so they should be familiar with our streets but the driver shortage um resulted in the low bidder on our transportation routes subcontracting it from Marlton to Neptune so Neptune of division of First Student provided our transportation services for this year and once again it was like their first time on the job getting familiar with their with our roads and the rotation of drivers that we thought would have been effective uh I'm I'm sorry the dry run of drivers which we thought would have been effective um in previewing the route to the drivers turned out not to be so because they rotated them um on a daily basis so we're having a lot of problems

016with contracted buses and it is our recommendation to chip away at this as best we can by bringing them in inhouse the one of the constraints we have is is where to park them because our parking lot is out of space we have U staff parking on grass and um we are in the process of a land transfer from the township directly across the street from the administrative building on Buckaloo Avenue behind the firehouse and we are exploring with our engineer what it would cost to develop that for a busing parking lot so we can expand our Fleet further additional budget appropriation considerations are Barkley Brook School partial roof replacement every year the district the board of education has included in the budget not only the needs of new students which is extraordinary but also

017a periodic Capital project I have performed four roof replacement projects closed Apple Guard School remediated um asbest put a whole facelift on that school and when it was reopened um converted the high school to the middle school when we did that whole transition all of that was done within the budget cap in the capital outlay fund and we want to continue with that progress by replacing the Barkley Brook roof next year $632,000 we also plan on constructing a bus parking lot as I just said on the new site on Route 522 the engineer has given us a preliminary cost estimate very crude of $1.5 million for the development of that property including grading excavation removal of trees um um and Paving and striping and fencing and and um and cameras security cameras also included in

018in bullet number two is to repave the Board of Education parking lot at 423 Buckaloo Avenue which has been patched and patched and repatched pached every year and it looks like a quilt now more than it does a parking lot the cost of both of those $2 million additionally we have asphalt paving needs throughout the district at Barkley Brook School Monro Township middle school and believe it or not at Oak Tree school um because at Oak Tree there's a need to seal the parking lot and restripe it to prevent uh of erosion $264,400 another project is to replace prek and kindergarten playground surfacing and equipment at mil Lake school because of safety concerns $137,000 Restore paint and structured steel exterior columns at the middle school $888,000 replace carpet at the monip middle school performing arts

019center instrument and music classroom spaces $44,100 and to replace a dump truck and another truck replacement both of which are used for snow plowing $133,800 total Capital Improvement considerations for next year $3.3 million it's important to compare that to what was in the capital outlay budget last year to see what's the increase and $2.2 million was in the capital outlay budget last year and that leaves a new Demand on the budget for one $ 1.1 million again not all of these are going to be incorporated and Mak it into the budget but this is the first blush forecast of need additional appropriation considerations have to do with salary and benefits 85% of the budget is fixed the majority of which is coming from um salaries and benefits we are a labor intensive organization the approximate

020wage basee of $65 million times last year's percentage increase of 2.75 is just a projection of what we would have to budget for for salary increases for next year 1.7 million it is important to note that the monra township administrators Association and the monra township uh Education Association contracts end June 30 of 1 therefore we do not have a number percentage increase in a guide to accurately project this for next year but just as a bookmark we're using 2.75 benefits are over a $2 million budget appropriation line item the 2016 2017 premiums were 22,200 th000 the projected increase for next year conservatively is is a 8% taking it to 23, 991,00 that is not all a district expense because there has been significant contributions from staff required by chapter 78 and before that the 1.5%

021of salary role over the last few years our health insurance broker and I project that next year we will collect approximately $3.1 million from health insurance contribution staff wide toward health benefits leaving $2,875 th000 as net premiums or an estimated increase in benefits for next year of $1.7 million health insurance has been one of the greatest areas of gain and and and cost reductions for the district through sidebar negotiations with the mtea we have offered midc contract year some cheaper Alternative Health Plans like the direct access plan and the EPO plan through the fruit of negotiations with the board and the mtea the traditional health plan which was one of our most expensive greatest examples of a Cadillac plan is is uh closed and due to be completely sunsetted at the end of their contract

022June 37 and co-pays have been pushed steadily higher every year in addition to these bargaining groups negotiating to agree to chapter 78 contributions which which are no longer required by law curriculum budget appropriation needs I'd like to turn over to Dr alvik okay so as Mr Gorski said these are just considerations these are not items that are in our budget we haven't started that process yet but these are some things that have actually been on our consideration list many of them for several years now but they've never made it through the budget process because there are other needs that were more pressing in order for us to meet our budget requirement which um will is one of the things that will be set tonight by the board of education so some of the needs that

023we see uh forthcoming next year um technology updates and Replacements every year we try to keep on top of this and replace some of our older um computers laptops um and teacher computers that are in our schools so we try to keep this on a rotating basis so that there's not a huge cost at any one point we are in the process at the elementary level and the Middle School level of replacing lap the laptops that we're currently using with Chromebooks which are a much cheaper version um and then we're spending the time really uh giving professional development to our teachers of how best to use these in our classroom with our students so we want to um continue to do the rollover replacement for some of our older models of our technology at the

024high school we have the onetoone um initiative with our iPads for our students and again due to increased enrollment there will be a need for about 170 iPads next year uh with the with the increase in student enrollment to make sure that each of our students has the device that they need when we think about facilities with curriculum um some of the things that are coming up our industrial arts equipment we have industrial arts equipment at both the middle school and the high school and each year it's import it's imperative that we have it uh inspected and checked for uh to make sure that it is safe and reliable for our students to use so that's that's a cost that we need to look at each year to make sure that those machines are are

025available and up to where they need to be for our students um due to the increased number at our Middle School we are out of student lockers so as we continue to get more students at the middle school we need to in uh increase the number of lockers available for our students and we also need to look I know we already mentioned the classrooms around the Performing Arts Center at the middle school but we also need to think about the morasco pack updates and maintenance um at the middle school the we need to look at possibly um updating our lighting board the curtain and the stage these are all things that need some updates again this was something that has been on for consideration the last couple of years and we're moving them forward some

026other considerations that we've heard about quite a few times I think uh at some of our Bo board meeting some requests from parents some of our um parents have been very vocal about some of the teams that we do not have in our district at our Middle School we currently had about over 400 students go out for fall Sports we only have 150 spots for those students so we would like to increase some of the sports programs at our Middle School um in order to have more offerings for our students um at the high school we do not have a boys volleyball or a swim team and again this is something that has come up several times over the past couple of years that there is an interest for this we are the only division

0274 school that does not have a boys volleyball um program and I know that we've had Parents um come up to the board and and request the swim teams so these are things that are that are there's an interest in the community for us to look at them some of our uniforms are in need of replacement our marching band uniforms are 15 years old so this is something that we should be looking at it shouldn't they really are need need some updating our football uniforms they have usually been replaced about every 3 years we are on the fifth year of that cycle so again these are things that we have we know have needed to be replaced but we keep moving them forward just because they're not fitting in um with our our priorities um

028expanding some of the Middle School career uh creating a career center at the middle school and expanding some of the clubs um again because of the increase in student enrollment making sure that we have enough opportunity for our students and also looking at our senior option program this is the program where our students leave early their senior year as long as they've met all of the requirements of graduation and have enough credits they leave early they can go and take college courses they can go and work in different places around our community um any of those things so really looking at that those options for our students um textbooks uh one of the resources that we use in our classrooms in the Middle School grades 6 through 12 actually this year we implemented the new

029Next Generation science standards so our middle school science textbooks are in need of replacement in order to update upgrade those to the new science standards so that really is the big cost here um is looking at a new science program um we are moving forward with our reading workshop model in all of our um elementary schools moving it into fourth and fifth grade well if if we want our students to have a choice of reading we need to make sure we're offering them those books in the classroom so expanding our reading libraries in our classrooms at fourth and fifth grade um looking at exploratory business textbook so it's really looking at updating it with with the curriculum changes that have been made to the exploratory Business course and moving it more towards an intro to

030Business course and math iBooks again because of student enrollment we need to be able to purchase we do not need a new math textbook Series in any of our high school classes but we do need more student licenses for the students that are incoming to our school the Personnel list is quite extensive that is really it's all due to student enrollment so if we look at this list there are 21 certificated staff positions these include Middle School teachers High School teachers a reading specialist um elementary teachers a child study team and a nurse those are the certificated staff positions that are there the way that the amount have been um have been calculated is we took the average for a teacher to come in we multiplied it by the the percentage of what the teachers

031earned this year the 2.75% as Mr Gorski had mentioned and then we also included the benefits amount for the teacher so that most of those numbers include benefits we also would like to add two more technology staff members our with all of the technology going on in our district we really um need the Technology support within our schools also adding two security guards again because of student enrollment because of growth um because our buildings are used all of the time it's imperative that we have the security at our buildings uh a secretary is needed at the middle school in the guidance and child study team office so it would be a shared secretary for guidance and child study team um looking at possibly some Administration help again with our numbers in our schools we need

032more administrative help for the coverage of our buildings so looking at uh possibly two assistant principles one at the middle school one at the high school um a morasco pack coordinator so this would just be a stipended position it could be for someone who's currently working in our district but they would help to organize um anything that's happening at the pack which is pretty much a full-time job um with all of the activities going on in our building and also along with uh the certificated staff looking at Power professionals um for FTE FTE is full-time equivalent so we try not to hire full-time power professionals we usually hire them at 3.75 hours um so that it does not include benefits and then we have more flexibility with the hours that they're working during the day

033to make sure that we're covering the needs within our schools so that's total curriculum needs of two just under $3 million for next year and as Dr alvik said it's it's all attributable to growth so in summary format the total appropriation considerations for next year Transportation 666,000 salary increases are projected to need about $1.8 million benefits just about the same $ 1.8 million curriculum $3 million for a total of $8.3 million of new appropriation needs for next year to offset the Appropriations you have to have an equal amount of revenues the budget has to match Appropriations has to equal revenues we cannot submit to the state an unbalanced budget or a budget deficit so some budget resource consider ations for next year number one the bond referendum is closed you may recall that with this

034high school we had $8 million of surplus due to the effective management and construction of the school that has all been returned back to the taxpayers as tax relief there is no more money available to be infused general fund state aid $2.8 million was awarded in 1617 and despite the incredible efforts of board president Mr Ryback Dr kak Dr alvic and I meeting with and I would just like to talk about this for a minute because this is important on state aid issue we've met with the following people on a Pursuit for additional state aid for fair funding for Monroe because I will say to you we are underfunded and we receive an inequitable amount of funding we met with the governor's chief of staff we met with Senator Linda Greenstein about a half a

035dozen times we've met with Senator Sweeney who is the Senate President uh two times at least we have been accompanied by mayor tamboro and before that mayor poochi the district has written their our own inhouse legislation to qualify for additional state aid we went to Senate education budget hearings on that legislation where it found favor in Trenton but died in the closing of the Senate has been reintroduced with a new number that's posted on our website and is still alive but unlikely to be uh turned uh crated into law and um and uh Mr uh Rybeck is going to present more on this topic during his his superintendent's report I understand but a board president report but we have done everything you could expect from an Administration and a board and more um to to

036solicit fair and Equitable state aid funding because there is a gross Injustice where the taxpayers of this community have to pay for 8 88 or 89% of the resource is required for public education and the state commits less than 2% uh proprietary fund to um explore new Revenue sources which could be infused into the general fund budget to reduce taxes we have new proprietary funds Falcon care and early childhood enrichment both of which are very profitable and are are paying off the previous Mecca loan and are creating retained earnings and thanks to the very successful negotiations with the Jamesburg School District we have a agreement in place for tuition and Jamesburg always has and is is paying their fair share of tuition to Monroe the dispute occurred as you know from the past because of

037the imposition of a state budget cap which prohibited Jamesburg from raising the amount of funds that they had agreed to to pay Monroe in their budget mechanically they just could not do so so next year we have a schedule of cap for use in the 1718 budget excess Surplus I'm sorry this this is the cap schedule this shows the prior year general fund tax levy which is $95,400 th000 the state's calculation of how much you're able to grow your budget adjust that prior year general fund Levy with an automatic enrollment adjustment of $850,000 that's a minuscule adjustment to the cap for the volume and amount of students that are being um introduced to the district that gives you an adjusted pre-year budget general fund tax levy of 96 m281 th000 then you inflate that figure

038by 2% that brings it to 98 M27 th000 there's an adjustment for health care costs where the state gives you a $750,000 adjustment to the cap and we project that next year the general fund tax levy cap will be $98 m957 th000 the district has available banked cap from last year because the district did not budget to the full amount of cap available by law because of the handsome amount of surplus we had last year the budget was created for 16176 $100,000 under cap and also put $975,000 into capital reserve so the general fund tax levy cap for next year can grow $3.5 million without the use of Bank cap and $4.1 million with the use of Bank cap we are going to post all of these slides on the district website so um please

039don't feel it's necessary to copy all the number numbers excess Surplus is defined as the difference between actual revenues recognized in the year and budgeted revenues plus actual expenditures and budgeted Appropriations it is required that excess Surplus from June 316 be used as a revenue Source in the 1718 budget the 1415 excess Surplus calculation was 5 Mill $10,000 our estimate for 1516 is $6.1 million in layman's terms that means we grew our Surplus or our leftover budget Appropriations from the preceding year by 1.1 million due to the effective management of the budget by controlling costs by joining purchasing consortiums by concessions from the labor organizations and by um very constrained spending habits so to summarize we showed before that we had $8.3 million of new appropriation or spending needs for next year the new Revenue

040sources to offset that are tax levy cap without the use of Bank cap $3.5 million the excess surplus of $1,100,000 above the previous year is new Revenue source so what we have is Appropriations in excess of revenues projected for next year of $3.6 million well what does that mean if that means that $3.6 million is going to have to be cut from some of the projected expenses that you've been previewed for next year or remov from existing programs and services within the district now or when we put together the budget we're going to have to try to maximize other Revenue sources in order to close that but right now our anticipated needs are greater than the amount that the state allows you to grow your budget and how much we contributed as an Administration by

041Saving and underspending last year ratables are very important in the calculation of taxes the rable base in town is the aggregate valuation of property values that's the tax levy is distributed based upon how much your property is worth compared to yours you would have a greater share of the tax levy um than you would that's the Equitable means of sharing the tax levy the tax rate goes down and this is one of the benefits of growth in a district with the new residents moving in the more residents and property values that come online in the equalized valuation rable calculation the more people are sharing in the in the in the tax levy it's like renting a movie and and then everybody shares $2 but you have more people join you to watch it everybody's going

042to then contribute less it's the same thing with ratables we're anticipating a 2% growth in ratables for the 1718 school year and that will be a significant Tailwind to the tax rate by reducing it so this is one of my favorite slides because it speaks to what are you getting for your money so our graduation rate for our class that just left us in June of this this year was 97.3% so 97.3% of our students graduated in June now that does not include the number of students that finished up and and did their credit uh replacement that they needed to do over the summer so other students over the summer have since graduated um that was this is just the number from June and of our June 2016 graduating class 86% of those students attended

043College 2% are attending Career technical schools 1.2% entered the military 7.1% entered the workforce and 3.7% were undecided or non-g grads 1% of those were undecided the 2.7 were the ones that were that were the non-g grads and again that that number has increased over the summer we spend a lot of time um and really look at our AP course offerings in our high school and we do offer quite a few AP courses for our students AP is advanced placement so these are courses where our students can actually earn college credit uh while they're still in high school by taking these AP courses we had 34 students who have participated in our AP testing this spring and of those students 81% of them scored a three or higher you must score a three or higher

044in order to earn the college credits while they're taking the the the test and um again we just received our at our scores on the SAT and ACT and again this year the Monro Township students scored higher than the state average on those SAT and ACT scores so what does this all result in very high District performance and numerous best practices as pointed out by the county office during our budget efficiency reviews every year plus comparatively low taxation equals incredible value for this community you're getting a lot for your money you're getting an incredible product our students are performing very highly and um we we intend on delivering that again with the 1718 budget so I would like to read a resolution at this time and then we can engage in um um deliberation it

045is recommended that the Board of Education establish and adopt the budget Philosophy for the 1718 school year to responsibly meet the demands of continuing significant student growth and facility needs as well as program and service requirements by budgeting to cap without the ability to utilize Bank cap and without consideration of budgeting above the by going out to a vote to the voters while while prioritizing the following items subject to restrictions presented by Administration the first priority is construction projects as presented the second the curriculum recommendations as presented the third the salary and benefit increases as per contract negotiations and as presented and fourth Transportation recommendations as presented this action by the board will enable the board to fulfill its educational responsibility to the district students and a thorough and efficient fiscally prudent manner while ensuring

046the maintenance of District resources and Facilities second any that concludes our presentation and we turn it over to Mr Rybeck any discussion questions from the board on the resolution Mr ntin thank you Mr board president um I'd like to commend um Dr kak and Mr Gorski and his financial team for the hard work that went into this I know this is um always a very busy time we had the cfer uh audit in the process and to go through this is is probably a very huge undertaking um some members of the board probably May realize that we're doing this at a different time this year last time we did this um in August when we did our district and board goals and it was determined that it kind of made a little more sense to

047do it now since uh Mr Gorski and his team have a a firmer grasp especi especially with that excess budget calculation uh in place that we typically would not have in the summer when we used to do this meeting um so once again I thank them for their hard work in in uh making this come together um one of the questions I have for um Mr Gorski is that if we were to go below cap what would the repercussions of that let's say if we tried to go below cap like we did last year um could you elaborate on some of the things that uh could occur if we were to do that certainly missp president thank last year because of the effective management of the budget and the constraints on spending um mainly through

048saving millions in purchasing consortiums the fruit of Labor negotiations and the incredible negotiations that we engage in with Horizon healthc Care by getting competitive quotes from other carriers threatening to leave um and getting the rate down to every year be becoming the Envy of of the other school districts in the county and the state um we grew excess Surplus which is the leftover residual amount of each Year's budget to a very handsome amount that enabled us to pay a dividend to the taxpayers last year by going under cap by $600,000 while still meeting all the educational needs of the ever increasing student body the this year the rate of growth in this district has has um increased to a level that we've never seen before we've showed you a projection of 427 new students next

049year many of which are special education needs we have many aging facilities in the district that the state has really no mechanism or funding currently available in order to fix and maintain just today I met with our director of facilities who came to see me on an urgent matter because our former supervisor's office where we met in close session and the other office at the corner which was um used for a different purpose were converted to student classrooms because of incredible growth demands on the district that could not be anticipated his concern was that we had to buy um electric work and computers and um and do some some walls all of which were not in the budget the demands of student growth on the district um have been extraordinary and it's been very difficult

050to maintain within the cap and last year was a really extraordinary year where we were able to maintain that fix our facilities and go under cap but unfortunately with negotiations upon us with two of our largest groups Monro Township administrators Association and the Monro Township Education Association and not having a fixed number of uh increase in order to budget for that contingency requires us uh to be a little more conservative um the amount of special education needs in this District have grown exponentially and are very costly our Autistic Program for example requires that one teacher serve no more than eight students and we have about 120 resource class and in-class support staff teachers in the district about 28% of the budget goes for 18% of the students in the special education categories so Mr notin

051to answer your question directly because of the contingency with negotiations but mainly because of the incredible growth that we are managing in this District um it would be in my opinion irresponsible to budget under cap as much as we would love to pay another dividend back to the taxpayers we believe we have done so with the excess Surplus calculation and the money that's coming over as a resource with the budget but to project a budget on revenues that could be less than what is needed to meet the demands of the district next year could be very hazardous I would hate for every example to build a recommend a budget to this board that could not provide the resources to meet a a long negotiated contract with either of those um um bargaining groups or restrict

052them in any way thank you very much for that uh uh very very uh elaborate answer um my question also now we are not looking to go above cap correct we still have the capability we could be going $600,000 above cap so almost 25% um if that was the case is that an accurate uh assessment that is that is exactly correct you can U grow the budget beyond what we're recommending by utilizing the $600,000 that we did not go to cap last year which is called Bank cap and we have another option that would not be really unheard of and that would be going to the voters and going above the cap because of these extraordinary needs which we can demonstrate in this budget but we are not recommending either of those measures at this

053time but we are recommending just going to the regular tax cap and using the excess Surplus calculation as required by stat statute but even with um all this uh you know going to cap and and the excess Surplus there's still a lot of work to be done in in in slicing and dicing this budget um so I am actually recommending that uh this resolution and I urge my fellow board members to um go ahead with this I I've as chairman of the finance committee I've had numerous discussions with Mr Gorski uh on certain it items and um certain Avenues but at the end of the day it's this board's responsibility to make sure that we are funding the educational system in Monroe as Mr Gorski has told me numerous times he's been uh adding a

054lot of Hamburger Helper to the uh to the meat and at this point uh we're almost at the point where we're just going to be eating only Hamburger Helper so I I think it's uh incumbent upon this board to uh unfortunately we have to go to cap but I think that to not go uh to cap uh would be a dereliction of our duty so I I urge that uh this board to uh consider the budget philosophy as presented thank you very much thank you Mr n any other board member with a question or comment Mr armeno um can you just explain a little bit more for me um the in the resolution where uh it's the third line where it says without the ability to utilize Bank cap and without consideration of budget budgeting

055above the cap I got the budgeting above the cap we're not going to do that even though technically we have the ability to do so so if you can just ex sort of explain the first part of that the ability to utilize the banked cap yes the Board of Education last year um resolved a budget that was $600,000 under this maximum spending Authority also known as the cap that was a dividend back to the taxpayers due to the extraordinary spending constraints that were put through during the year and did have an effect on the tax rate because $600,000 is material that $600,000 is not lost by The District's um lack of use in that budget year it actually can carry over for use in the next three years before it expires so that that unused

056spending Authority or Bank cap from last year in a dollar amount of $600,000 remains an unused tax cap adjustment um that we uh do not recommend administratively the need to use at this time however um with the projections of student enrollments going forward there was a lengthy discussion about portable classroom trailer units this year and um we anticipate that even under the best circumstances there may be a need to talk about trailers not in the 171 18 school year budget but maybe the 1819 and when that happens um that will require the utilization of probably any and all Bank cap to to match those new needs in the budget okay I just just having reviewed the budget and the uh budget philosophy and the since I am a member of the U the facilities committee

057I I have to say that we are at least keeping up with our facilities and that's a very big expense and knowing that all of the housekeeping that has to be done very often if if we don't do our budgets properly um and some other schools systems you know sort of don't pay attention to the facilities and the care and maintenance of the facilities and they have have to go out for referendums and that's sort of a frightening thing because keeping up with them I think is essential it's less costly even though it seems like millions of dollars spent on roofs and asphalt and things like that it's less costly to do it within our budgetary constraints and also keep up with it so we don't get a crisis situation so I I've been watching

058that um so I I think that that's admirable that the our facilities director and also the Administration has been keeping a close eye on the needs of the district in terms of keeping the maintenance of the facilities up um also I think this year I've seen the most money spent for curriculum uh than we have in the last few years which I'm glad to see because I always thought that we were sort of short changing the actual instructional necessity of of our system um so seeing the bump up it's again and no one really wants to spend a lot of money but for science books and and our math things I'm I'm glad to see that the curriculum is getting a boost um and it has always been my personal philosophy not to go to

059cap but I think we are constrained by the necessity that we have no control over and that is the Construction and building that we can't stop as a board unfortunately it's being extended in in other forms of our municipal government but we we we pay the dues and we pay the price for that so um again I would I think I voted in the past not to go to cap but I think we are compelled um to to serve our students the students that have come in so I'm going to change I have a change of heart this year thank you m anyone else Mr Mr Braven um you've you've been the uh the the uh presentation that you made indicated that we're really going through to be going through extraordinary growth and in my

060mind I would much rather pass a resolution that says you can go to what is ever legally admitted uh legally appropriate for the growth uh keeping up with facilities might be a good idea in some Minds my thought about facilities is keeping ahead of it so you don't have the problems that will eventually grow I personally will not vote for this I think we should we should be able to give the administration the tools to go and build a budget which will give the students the appropriate tools that they need and at the same time be prudent so if you don't have to go to it fine you can come back to the board tell us you did a great job but I I I think this resolution puts handcuffs on you people you've got

061extraordinary growth you've got a lot of things going on in the district and we're telling you you can go you can go to cap but don't worry about the negotiations because they'll collapse and they'll come in under under cap and don't worry about anything we know you can do it no I'm going to vote against this because I don't think it's appropriate for the T iens did you have any comments no sir oh okay any other board member with a comment or question Mr Russo I have a question I keep you know we keep hearing about fair share and from the state state a and I'm just wondering what is that what would be fair share what amount the state of New Jersey um established a Consortium Think Tank to come up with what would

062be an adequate school district and the amount of dollars to support an adequate School District which we never strive to be in Monroe is what's called your adequacy budget the state's mechanism to fund the adequacy budget is a type of state aid called Equalization Aid which because of Monroe's affluency affluence and property values we receive none zero no state aid in that category at all while South Brunswick gets almost $30 million a year in that one category my answer to you would what would be our fair share would be the state supporting at least the adequacy budget by giving us equal equ ization Aid equal to that amount okay and for how long have we not been getting a fair share we have not received Equalization Aid in the 17 years that I've been employed

063by the district okay and as I understand it we keep talking to the same people and we get the same results that that is a fair comment yes okay I think I think everyone and the public in particular should know that okay would we ever that R I will say I will say to you that um in that regard I am I'm as frustrated as anyone here I would love to have a download of the state aid award in a particular year that allows me to offset the currently used tax levy with State funds a problem happened here in the 89 school year where the state cut our Aid by 95% and in essence shifted 4.6 Mill million of what was the state's obligation to the local taxpayers where it's been ever since we have

064done everything humanly possible to get a platform and get audience to fight and present information uh to get our fair share of state aid including having the administration write legislation I'm an accountant I'm not I'm not a legislator but we took it on and we wrote a very nice piece of legislation which is on the District website that actually passed the Senate education committee um I think what's left for us and we talked about this with the board president is to encourage the residents to go into a letter writing campaign because no disrespect to the politicians but I was told by my predecessor they're concerned about two things getting elected and staying elected and there's 40,000 residents on Monroe who can deliver the the message a lot louder than those sit at the table right

065here a simple letter expressing their displeasure with the amount of funding to support the schools would go a long way I agree with that Mr May um I lost my train of thought as usual Mike you do a phenomenal job generating these numbers and letting us see what goes on you know behind the scenes and I have to say as a parent who has kids in this district and who talks to other parents there is a great concern out there about you know the size of classes and especially in the elementary schools where the classes are getting up to 28 29 kids and I feel that you know we need to take a look at that so that those kids can be in smaller classes and I'm hoping that this will help lower those numbers

066so I'm voting for it thank you any Mr cman yeah I I said to myself well hopefully I'll be able to get through the next few board meetings and not open my mouth but you know whatever not um so so here we are a year ahead of where we were last year and the board got a lot of great press out of you know lowering the budget going under cap for 600,000 but it didn't solve a problem it just moved it it moved it from last year to this year so My point being is as you move forward in time and you come through these philosophy things and you start putting things in taking things out be very cautious of when you go under budget because you create a situation out with the public of

067incredible swings and tax rates because now you're going to have a dip and then that dip is going to be propagated to now an increase which doesn't always buy you anything other than being able to say for one one year look what we did right as a future taxpayer a lot of people out there may be questioning how were you able to lower it one year and then come back the following year with such an incredible increase so point being be very mindful as you go through this process of what the Fallout is between one year and the following year because it's possible that that $600,000 from last year could have paid your bus thing for this year I'm just that's all I got to say any other board member just call upon I I

068too want to congratulate Mr Gorski for fantastic presentation we've been doing these budget advis budget things for the last few years and I think it's helping the public understand what we're doing and where we're going um I just to clarify for me everything that is in this presentation are considerations for next year's budget is that that's correct and we're still going to be almost $3.7 million over the cap so that means that some of these things might not be included in the budget or we're going to have to cut other places in the budget so this is just what we would like to have in the budget and as we move forward you're you as an Administration is going to have to feel what's most important for kids uh I I like the fact to

069as Miss armino said that we're doing a lot for kids this year through the curriculum and I always try to vote for what's best for kids and I I think having even through Sports having every kid involved in something gives them a connection to the school district those kids that don't get involved they don't feel like they're part of the school district so if we can give them more to do and have them feel that connection and then have their parents feel that connection I think it's good for us um and I'm going to support this resolution thank you any other board member let me just make a brief comment uh first of all I'd like to congratulate the entire administrative team because I know they all had a part share in this and Mr

070Gorski is always uh you you um never cease to fail us uh to um to um R not fail I'm sorry but to um come up with a outstanding uh presentation for us I apologize but that slip um we do have a serious problem here this this um budget know represents a philosophy well the philosophy has to be sensitive to the taxpayers it has to be sensitive to the students the staff you know how do you come up with this balance um so it it it takes a a tremendous amount of work and and uh you know just sitting here and seeing a presentation is one thing but knowing what goes behind it the hours the Manpower in coming up with this is is incredible um we have to keep this school system uh up

071up to par above par we're an outstanding school system these students deserve a quality education our taxpayers deserve uh really quality fiscal management and I think we're working hard to to provide that I'll go into it a little bit more later about uh state aid but um you heard from board members and you heard from Mr Gorski um that the state aid just isn't there and the only ones we can come to are the taxpayers for this so uh I again I congratulate this is an outstanding uh budget philosophy I encourage my board members my fellow board members to vote in favor of it uh and and um hopefully we'll be able to move forward in a positive uh sense and that we'll be getting uh some uh state aid for what this school district

072needs I guess we can go to a roll call vote now one more question we spoke already yeah we spoke already yeah we're going to roll call M armenio yes Mr Braverman no Mr Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo no and Mr rutsky who is eligible to vote eligible I vote yes thank you sir Mr board president motion passes eight yay two nay thank you yes just a very short thank you to the board of education for your continued support I know this is not an easy decision and I know a lot um you have a lot to consider but I just wanted to thank you uh for your support thank you all we can move to uh committee reports any

073committee chair point to report Mr calman sure so we had a curriculum meeting this evening we went over the curriculum material for AP Chemistry introduction engineering Thermo and equilibrium chemistry I think that's a one I can't I don't have glasses uh AP Psychology Health than health grades for and five foods and French honors we also heard a presentation on two upcoming clubs which are Health occupation students of America HOSA HOSA HOSA and uh economics and finance team as well uh the economics and finance team is not going to have any cost because it's like all online and the Health Occupational students of America again it's going to be their first year so the first year uh is graus so uh that's we talked about today right that's it any questions for Mr C any other

074committee chair Mr nin thank you um the finance committee met uh last evening at 6 o'clock the first order of business on Mr moraldo and Dr alvik introduced a online uh Finance Comm I mean an online uh personal finance course I believe this came through curriculum uh meeting or two ago and um the finance committee got the presentation in great detail and it was very very well received the idea of the online course at this Junction is it was offered as a pilot program last year uh as during the normal uh course of the of this of the school day the idea now is to take it to the next step which would basically be uh doing it as a ninth period class and or Andor during the summer what this does is twofold it's

075going to introduce uh students that have never taken an online class to uh the online class structure which is very prevalent in uh colleges going forward so it's going to really help prepare our students for the for the world in which they're going to be presented going forward after after high school and uh additionally as a nice added benefit Mr moraldo went into detail he actually did a uh an economic study of the program to provide us with uh numbers of actually making Revenue off of this basically if it's offered during the summer um it would be there would be a tuition charge for it and if it was offered as a ninth period there's a tuition charge offered uh to it with it also what this does this enables students that may want to

076take other elective classes during the course uh of the school year to to now get this mandated class uh I don't want to say out of the way but it will give them uh the credits that they need for this mandated class so um the committee uh was very positive in this and the uh the committee uh did recommend the continued development of this course and possible policy and sidebar consideration and this course would be or would be available uh as early as next summer um the next item of discussion we we talked about was the Delta te group proposal which the board will see in there um it was actually an addendum to the uh uh backup data from uh Mr Gorski it's basically a uh a par par professional uh temp situation because

077we don't have enough power Professionals for the special ed so um that was that was presented and the uh the committee recommended the proposal to the board uh Mr Gorski also went into detail about the lease purchase update you remember from last meeting we didn't have any biders well we did get biders this time and uh with some very favorable um returns and um uh we the committee did recommend that uh bid the uh 27 2018 budget considerations uh we basically went into the excess Surplus calculations uh pretty much of what we talked about this evening we also had uh another item on the agenda for the evening The Adult Ed uh program discussion but that was tabled to the next meeting due to some time constraints because um we had so many questions with

078the uh personal finance course Mr board president that concludes my report for this evening thank you Mr any questions for Mr nin just as a point of clarification Mr nin the Delta Group the shortage in parent professionals with for the bus it's not just a shortage and power professionals that's for theolog that's no that's just want to clear it up okay seeing no other uh committee chair wanted to report oh we do I'm sorry but some no I just I just wanted to say that we had uh a previously um scheduled a policy meeting but it was cancelled so I hope it didn't inconvenience anyone in the public but we'll try to get a policy meeting before the next U meeting thank you thank you and now we can move to the public forum and

079invite members oh am I missing uh I can invite members of the public up to the microphone uh to address items on the agenda please state your name your address and uh you'll have three minutes at the mic get good evening Chrissy scurby uh 21 pness Drive um under board action a item number three um about the um maab Environmental Services uh to provide aesus testing what uh schools is that for it's on page 14 on page 14 of the agenda number three reads it is recommended that members of the mon Township Board of Education approve mccab Environmental Services LLC to provide Professional Services for adhera asbest inspections adhera is the district's asbest management plan which is on file in Mr P's office and gets sent to the state regularly this would provide for inspections

080testing reporting for the 16 17 school year and it would pertain to any schools or facilities where asbest remains in the district um which are lessening and those are all disclosed in the adhera plan could you tell us which schools they're at asbest was taken out of service in the early 80s I believe so I know there are some asbest remaining at the Mona Township Middle School there's some asbest remaining I believe at Woodland School all of which is non-friable most of which is probably in the floor tiles and will in the professionals view would be fine to remain there unless if there's a disturbance like construction that is why the district removed and remediated the remaining asbest and pipe fittings at Barkley Brook school because of the um anticipation of the need for construction

081and uh now that school is free from asbestos um Applegarth school has been completely remediated from esbas and the newer schools of course don't have any because it's no longer used in the building process um and then under um board action what page is this number 10 um a residency contracts um it's to approve uh The Residency contracts for the enrollment of the children uh how many contracts are there I'm looking it up I have it on the material here six six which uh developments can you tell us which developments they're from um they have I what's that usually just giv you yeah I have the address I I couldn't really tell you the developments I don't know the street especially the new street names that well in the developments okay and how long are

082they uh that has to be what within 60 days they have to close on their homes yes exactly okay um last go if it goes longer than that then the parents are responsible for tuition okay uh last month I had asked uh why we weren't including the enrollment numbers on the agenda for each of the schools and they're not in this months either right the traditionally the enrollment numbers are not included in the August and September uh board reports because they're always a month behind so I did pull up the enrollment reports just because you had asked that question last uh last month and I can give them to you but it's if you look at previous years it's always month behind so August we don't have anything for July September we don't have anything

083for August and October through the rest of the uh school year that's when the enrollment reports are included in the agenda but if you would like to know I have them right here sure yeah uh particularly how many um new enrollment I guess at Oak Tree from August to till now so see I I I'm just accustomed to coming to every board meeting for the last I don't know eight years and the enrollment numbers are in every agenda I'm just curious I checked last year they were not in last year and I didn't go back any further but normally in every District I've been in but you don't report the enrollments for the summer we can certainly provide that but I know it was not in there last year that's September September yeah in September

084it's always I think it's always in September checked it today okay well do we know how many um students are at Oak Tree currently as of now as of September 14th we have 677 students in oak tree as of June 30th we had 642 okay so that's a pretty big increase just from June to September yes okay uh you had mentioned last month that if the enrollment continues to grow drastically before we can build another School you would consider putting trailers in at what point will the district consider doing something like that cuz our enrollment is increasing drastically yeah well that's what um we spoke about during the budget philosophy presentation we don't anticipate the need to put trailers in for this school year we're going to have to continue to monitor the uh the

085developments and the registration if you drive by the the pictures of the developments that I showed uh the one development at 33 Applegarth they're moving along pretty quickly but again once they get the houses up and they sell how quickly people move in and register their children have yet to be to uh be determined but we're planning not for this year and we're hoping to not use them at all but we may have to so at what point would you consider how many students in a class would you feel would con constitute needing to go to a trailer CU right now I think they're up to about 27 28 in a class right and I think it's a little premature to speak about that right now other than to say we've been looking at every

086available space in a school as example as an example tonight we referenced the high school and we've done that in the elementary schools as well to see if there are other classrooms or other spaces that we can use for classrooms and that would also require and that was part of our budget philosophy the hiring of new staff because we want to keep our numbers low as Mr Mayo has stated earlier I understand but what would you say is a class size that would be unacceptable because they're getting they're they're growing it's growing very fast if you you obviously drive by what's going on on the corner of 33 in Applegarth they are going up very fast when um the development the um Orchards went up the students started enrolling in January by June we were

087up I think 60 or 70 students at Oak Tre in 6 months they go up quickly and the students come in very quickly I know they lost the music room over at Oak tree this year so they're already down that my concern is we're in the middle of a land a land study still we're we're we're nowhere near we're at least a year out for a referendum if that fails I don't know what that means and then we have probably another 5 years till we get a new building what is going to be the plan because we don't have five years at any of these schools now obviously we don't and a plan is flexible it's again premature for me to say to you well when we reach this number we're going to put a

088trailer in or we're going to add another classroom we are constantly looking at the available space that we have the the size of the our the number of students in our classrooms uh what's available and we're looking at the possible land transfer that's feasible it's not a simple process of just deciding that okay it's available now I wish it was I wish I could move this along quicker but we're moving as quickly as we can and we'll determine uh as we move along what's needed to meet the educational needs of our students okay so what do you think is an adequate class size and what do you think would be unacceptable oh great size for a class at an elementary level would be 20 students and I know we're way above that 25 students there's

089not there's no but at what point will you do something I'm saying will you wait till it gets to 35 40 45 we have been doing things and we'll continue to uh do what we need to do to meet the needs of the students as we said already we don't predict that we'll need trailers this year but we'll be examining that on a daily basis and looking at that okay um she pass three minutes and when will the land study be done well they predicted six months but we're look hoping for it to be done a little bit earlier okay and then what is the process after the land study if it is buildable well once if it's again we have to determine is that site um a potential site that we can use is

090there opposition to that site which there is you know how is that going to play out if that if there is opposition and we can't build or we can only build one school instead of two we have other options that we're looking at so we'll have to look at all of those believe me it's not something there's not a day that goes by that we don't have this on our minds and that we're not examining this and we'll have to see then if the land is not available then we're going to have to look at the existing schools we have or is there any other land available which we've been exploring into our knowledge right now there really is no other land so we would have to look at our existing schools and say can

091we build onto the land that's where existing schools are can we add an addition uh all those things are being considered but again it will be pretty mature for me to say well this is exactly what we're going to do there's too many contingents that are playing into this decision oh okay because I I was under the assumption that if the land study came back okay that it was buildable that the board was going to move forward with that land well we would like to move forward with that sure but if if you I think you were at the last board meeting there were there has been some opposition to that um by some of the residents and we have to see where that goes I just want to add to that um m scurby

092not only just what Dr kosac said but the land technically hasn't been transferred to us yet we can't build on on property that I understand but you're using my tax money to survey it I understand that yes but we have to find out if it's buildable and that's what the engineering reports no I understand that but you are considering using the land you know yes you're not waiting until you get the de until it's deeded over to you you're you're starting now that's why I'm asking these questions and it was my understanding that that would be the land that the district if it was buildable would use and now I'm hearing that it it may not be and we don't have any other options for land as there is not a lot of available land

093in the township however that doesn't mean that we haven't that we're not looking and as I said we do do have land that is part of our current schools you know that's uh that our current schools are on that we could use as an option it won't be our first option we've considered all the different options that we have the our first option is to use the land that we're hoping to have transfer to us from the township and to be able to put two schools that's what we put out a couple months ago an elementary and a middle school and an add an addition to the high school if that's doesn't prove to be feasible then we're going to have to go to our other options we're going to have to look at that

094and we're going to see is part of the land available is all the land is none of the land available and we have to proceed from there so that would it that would then cost the district more time well unless you can move the engineers along and everyone not to oppose it I mean I mean but I'm I'm being very honest with you I'm just these are the the things that are are uh constraints to us no I I understand but I'm saying if we don't use that land it will take more time in the process is that I just have the the time is up so if you can wrap I don't think it would take much more time no okay if I could just say I I I was here last month and

095I did recently just move into the cultur Run neighborhood um I am not opposed to using that land um and I know there are other residents in that neighborhood who are not opposed to it I think it's a fabulous idea I think it's a good use of our tax money that that land will be coming to us at no tax burden to the taxpayers and I think it's unfortunate that some people are shortsighted and can't see that this would be the best thing for the district and the students thank you Mr anyone else God bless you yes sir please state your name my name is John elbasan I'm at 8 Belmont Court uh board president I want to thank you and the board and the administrators for your tireless effort in passing such a prominent

096budget uh one that hopefully services our students our residents in our community alike and for that I thank you I also want to sincerely thank and acknowledge Miss scurby uh for her tireless effort in front of this board over the last eight years improving uh various activities that have proven fruitful to our uh to our Township student body as well uh especially highlighting the asbestos remediation that she championed several years ago uh for Apple gar Elementary School uh I think what's uh strikingly important tonight and I'm going to be uh up here for both public uh forums I'm up here under the guidelines of the forum for tonight as it relates to what you've passed this evening the second half is to highlight to the Community some of the questions Miss scurby brought to light

097uh in terms of is there other land available in the township uh and I will share that information in detail with maps that I have and hopefully we can uh present it on an easel so that everyone has an opportunity to see that um I think we're all passionate as uh homeowners in this Township to make uh the township stronger and better and hire really worldclass Educators and have world-class administrators run the school uh I think where we fear and what we hear from working uh in this Township now for 15 years with residents is a lot of residents are packing up um you know they get their kids through the school system and they say you know $116,000 a year for this four bedroom Colonial just doesn't make sense anymore uh the fixed income

098earner that bought in Concord salson your comments at this portion have to pertain to the agenda they do they do and and I I'll I'll touch on that you get to absolutely um I guess what I'm highlighting here is just the impact right uh and so coming back to budget uh something Mr Kaufman said which which is my point in uh request to the board uh is that within the budget it would be helpful uh if Mr Gorski would have an impact study that shows a forecast over the next two to three budgetary fiscal years that takes into account uh the potential buildout of two schools uh the redundancy of administration and Personnel that would be required to run those two schools uh so that we can understand better the tax burden that uh we

099will face into the future uh because we agree uh getting a bill as a surprise around August of every year and seeing it swing several hundred dollars if not a thousand or more every year is a burden and and this is a communication that has been loud and clear by the township so is uh the board president willing to uh work within uh the board and the administration to provide forecasting data uh so that all these resolutions that we're passing and the impact of them over the next two three three and 5 years can be SP spelled out to the community so that we can hold uh the board as well as the township accountable as well as ourselves accountable to the impact that it may have on our ratable let me answer that that's

100a direct question when we right when we're considering this we we we try to consider all all the ramifications of it and and uh clearly you know the cost to the taxpayer the cost uh um to the district really uh is is a key consideration I hope that answer is a question uh it's not a committal so it helps answer that we're doing a one-year by oneyear study even though we're forecasting impactful projects that have Capital expenditures and Personnel impact well into the future that we won't know unless we are in that fiscal year is that a fair statement president sure it's not exactly this budget philosophy presentation tonight is not a budget by any means it is as Mr nus um compared last year is the board telling us what kind of cake to

101bake do you want devil's food or Angel's food it's a directive to Administration to begin to prepare a budget in accordance with the overall goals of the board it is a one-year strategic plan but I will tell you that we are always focused on three years at one point in time not just one year's budget there are no projected expenditures in this budget presentation tonight for the aid of the board in developing a philosophy that pertained to Future costs with the bond referendum when we opened this High School the state pulled out from under us a cap waiver called opening a new school cap adjustment and we had to fit 1.8 million of costs associated without outfitting this school in the general fund budget which re required uh a complete review and removal of a

102lot of the items that were already in there so that that that's all I can tell you now based on past history and uh as this um Bond referendum plan materializes and as I have talked with our superintendent and board president there will be a need to plan on how to get that magnitude of annual budget Appropriations amassed very quickly without that cap waiver I appreciate that Mr Gorski I I think in response to our personal lives uh in our professional lives to be specific we're faced with the burden of providing to our businesses and corporations that we service forecasts that are 3 years and 5 years in the making that take into account various different impacts that we may hypothetically take advantage of or we may not that's the rigor from a fiduciary responsibility

103that we're held to uh in the in the private sector I just have to ask you to wrap up your time is up actually beyond that already that's fine and I'll be happy to I'll leave off with the public service announcement that there will be uh a new uh election cycle where there will be seats up at this board and I think I encourage all residents to look at those seats that are available and who those seats will be filled by and what their mandate is for the betterment of this of this Township pertain to the budget so thank you very much for your and also lastly we can't we can't but in terms of if you understand then you have to Mr Rybeck can you speak to me about how you established uh right

104now the U minutes allocation for what I'm speaking to you is that you're time is up my time is up and and I cannot allow this to go on anymore I'll defer my my next question for the next open form thank you okay thank you anyone else from the public of order technically good evening Ram rnat 6 Owen Drive um southfi Estates again thanks to everyone involved really in uh projecting uh putting together the vision and really openly discussing the the thoughts on the budget and kind of what's we're going to be seeing for next year um you know just going through that I just want to uh second the previous gentleman's comment that you know it is as part of the vision uh the projection part is is important and it is really beneficial

105to see 3 to 5 years out uh what will be happening otherwise it feels a little blinded and in fact I think if that rigor had been happening I guess over the last few years uh you know uh while uh it was nice to see the picture of the backhoe and so on there right uh you know we need to be actually talking about this when those permits were actually issued by the township right so so that's the power of forecasting and bringing that so again I would second that and see how do we incorporate that uh in the future vision and budgeting process um that's point one point two is uh again I support uh Chrissy's uh Chrissy curby's points and again uh appreciate all the efforts she puts in place and I think

106the important Point she raised uh and other folks have raised is really uh you need to be looking at the operating expenses of these the new location putting out schools in the new locations it's not just building it it's like the buses and the administration you know there are a lot of these things that need to be looked at so when you actually take all that into account and the I guess there's a lawsuit also now right I think some uh homeowners have sued saying that that is preserved land and so on it makes a lot of sense to be just extending or building adjacent to the existing Oak Tre Elementary and apple go for example uh you know there's there's a baseball field I've not seen anyone using it um and again you'll avoid

107a lot of the ca duplication of cost of buses teachers Administration um and so given all these concerns and this growth to me it seems like you need to quickly start looking at Plan B and looking at some various Alternatives before we start really hitting that 3540 uh per per classroom in oak tree uh you know at the rate we are going um uh then the third aspect is um uh you know uh we talked about some of the uh issues I think Mr Gori made very eloquent points and very helpful about how kind of we're not getting that 30 million for example that South Brunswick is is getting and we're getting Short Change in many ways it'd be helpful if the Board of Education and other members involved here can use some of our

108Facebook forums uh to really start to Advocate some of these things so that the 40,000 people can really start to be partners with you and start to take these right to Trenton or wherever it is or even within our elections uh here within the township I think that transparency that information if you can help us I can we can help you and we can help each other thank you very much yeah and last comment is I'm hoping that the uh you know the one of the things only things I liked about what chrisy has done the proposing the fairness formula right for the state funding I I think it's about a 1,600 1700 benefit for the mandro taxpayers uh hopefully some of that comes through and that helps us uh in the process otherwise we

109really looking at some increased taxes pretty soon I have to say thank you this point your time is up yeah thank you thank you very much for your comment anyone else from the audience okay not seeing anyone from the P do we have somebody else yes name is Samara one Harvest View Monro would you talk into the microphone please so Samara one micro Harvest View um somebody mentioned about the uh the fairness but not somebody Mike mentioned it um they said Sou Brunswick is getting more money than Monro what are we doing wrong and what is South Brunswick is doing right to get the funding um this has been happening 17 years right that's what you said so what are we doing something that South Brunswick is you know they're doing right they're getting big

110money we're not and second thing is you said uh we people can raise the wise and who should we raise the wise to is like State we send letters to the state government uh what I can address that uh when I when I speak in in a few minutes because those are some of the things exactly that I'm going okay thank you that's all I have thank you very much Mr President to the gentleman's comments what what are we doing wrong uh that South Brunswick is getting Equalization Aid to support their adequacy budget to the tune of almost $30 million a year Monro get zero it it's based on a u funding formula that considers the distribution of State uh resources based upon an abilities a District's ability to come up with what's called a

111local fair share and the local fair share takes into consideration income and property wealth the income comes from the aggregate New Jersey 1040s that you file with the four-digit municipal code and we are more we have a higher income um than South Brunswick and we have higher property values than South Brunswick both of those factors um according to the state formula result in the uh inequality but I I argue and we have uh vehemently that there needs to be either a more of a graduation of that distribution so that some districts aren't left with nothing like Monroe um or a minimum amount per student and we're exploring all those Avenues and we've been uh fighting for that for a long time unfortunately every time we visit them it's uh the same Administration um at one

112point in time we actually considered suing the state individually or with the Consortium of other school districts of of the same suffering um but our legal council from W told us at the time that it would be fruitless and although you know it was some very attractive attorney fees involved she advised us against it so you know we we've taken every effort to try to remedy this and we're not finished yet but from our vantage point right now the most impactful one the one that could stimulate change the greatest is for the politicians to hear from the community and to hear that it it is unfair um for the residents of this town to provide for 88% of the cost of the education to support this school district it's a public school we are required

113to U Implement numerous State mandates and we receive a very inequitable amount of funding in order to do so and and Sir one final thing it what we are doing right in this district is living in that environment and um making the most out of every dollar and and every consideration for the taxpayers who are overburdened and that's why we work very hard last year to pay a dividend back by going $600,000 under cap thank you Mr gy anyone else from the public before we move on not seeing anyone from the public we can move to our superintendent report Dr kosac all right thank you Mr President school's open for students on Tuesday September 6th and except for a couple of minor speed bumps pun intendant with Transportation School openings went extremely well we feel

114that we have received the or resolved the minor Transportation issues and we are happy that the procedures we put in place in transportation work well Dr Ali and I visited each of the schools and you could feel the excitement in the air the kids were excited as well but uh it it is a nice it really is nice to see and as I say over and over and over again we try to promote the positive occurrence that that that go on every single day in our classrooms through our Facebook and our TW Twitter page and our website and our newsletter and even with that we can't really um bring out enough the the wonderful education that's being delivered in the classrooms in every one of the classrooms the teachers the staff uh the administrators they're

115all doing a wonderful job as well as the parents who are sending us their their children the all the building Renovations that were uh planned for during the summer were completed before school open last week and and um on behalf of the Board of Education I hope I can speak for the Board of Ed on this that I would like to uh extend a thank you to all of our staff for the hard work during the summer our back to school parents sessions have started and um I've been attending and with the middle and high school it's a little different there's not a public form for all the parents but at Woodland Elementary School there was and some of the uh the rest of the elementary schools there will be and um I'll be speaking

116at each of the schools just about our continued student enrollment growth and what that means and the need for a referendum and how we will need to work together and we'll need the support of everyone to work together to ensure that we provide the um you know the classrooms and the classroom space and the schools necessary to provide to continue to provide an excellent education for our students on the um agenda for the board I would like to just bring to your attention a couple items that were new from when we sent the agenda out on Friday Miss barell did send out the uh the uh notice that these are new items but I just in case you didn't get a chance to see your email today I just want to let you know under

117Personnel items B and C we received two resignations this morning from staff members there'll be 60 days out uh so that's items B and C items n m I'm sorry MN o q and R uh is various or leaves for various employees there is a typographical error in um item R the second sentence has a mistake please change the word she to he section BB double b items 21 to 23 uh are new items it's a volunteer coach it's our communication facilitator replacement basically the person who puts the Falcon flyer together uh and a leave replacement for one of our teachers and in the column in section BB the First Column number 16 again a typo I apologize we try to catch everything what page oh I'm sorry uh I don't have a page number

118what he saying 10 eight eight BB I thought he said BB yeah yeah eight yeah and number 16 uh there should be the name uh for Dr uh Pang pangus thank you uh Dr pangus it's instead of uh that should be in column one with all the rest of the Personnel it's just a typo in section Double C 13 and 14 the it's just a correction of a step on guide for uh our power professionals and a cafeteria power professional replacement under board action of the superintendent section right under personnel there our field trip request we have some very talented students who are chosen chosen to perform with the All State band Andor chorus and that was added into the agenda uh just so the board knows that the transportation is being provided for by

119either the parents or the New Jersey music Education Association and with that update Mr President that concludes my superintendent report and I would like to move on to the Personnel section absolutely thank you any any questions about that before I move on Aro you okay I know I went through a lot of changes they're on the agenda I just wanted to bring it to your attention thank you with that I would like to recommend the U Personnel items a through Double D for approval so moved second second um Mr President yes Mr President uh we would be remiss under Personnel items if we did did not acknowledge um Personnel action item a on page two which is the retirement of Mrs Barbara dah The District Human Resource director effective January 1st 2017 Mrs dah uh

120took on a Herculean task with the director position for HR out of a void of any Department in the district of 1200 people in the human resource area and she has done a fine job supervising two staff and reformulating a lot of processes to better serve the district and the staff and the taxpayers in that regard prior to that Mrs d uh served the district as the benefits coordinator and work closely with me to bring Galler Benefit services to the district which has um saved the district an enormous amount of money in health benefit costs so be of Dr kak and Dr Alvi and I we thank Barbara do very much for her service and wish her a happy and healthy retirement I second that on anyone else on the bo for the discussion and

121then in that case we can vote Mr armino yes Mr Braverman Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano um yes but on a I would like to say no but I'm going I'm going to say yes with regret so noted Mr noin yes Mrs Keno yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and congratulations and Mr rutsky Bo president Personnel action items a through Double D passes thank you Mr Gorski we go to move on to board actions on page 10 I need a motion to approve board action items a through Q I moved second any discussion items a through Q not seeing any discussion we have a roll call vote Miss armino yes Mr Braverman Mrs Deo yes Mr cman yes to all recues on g n p g and P thank you

122Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Kino yes G and n g and N so noted Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and reu on GN nnn thank you Mr rutsky Iain abstain with the exception of items J K L M thank you sir Mr board president motion passes thank you you might as well hold the microphone course we up to the visi administrator report board president and members of the Monro Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through I be approved by consent roll call no moved second any discussion good vote Miss armeno yes rman yes Mrs Deo yes Mr cman yeah Mr panovich yes M yes and recuse on Hotel H for hotel so noted Mrs Keno yes Ryback yes Mr Russo yes Mr rain the exception of

123A4 D thank you sir so noted Mr Bo president motion passes that concludes my report thank you so I just have a few words for everyone I know we were all talking about the um budget philosophy and um you know what its impact on the district uh we're talking about state aid last month this board of education I'm proud to say unan unanimously passed a resolution um really um outlining the lack of state aid we have and and and our resolve to to improve it Mrs kala panowitz correctly I couldn't agree more said we can't leave it there we have to do more it's been done before and we need to do more and and if we're going to get a little success here we need the public you heard Mr Gorski outline to you

124uh the years of our attempts to deal with legislators Trenton as I said last month moves very slow and um very often seems to be nothing more but a battle scene between legislators but nothing seems to be getting done that's going to help this school district we see other school districts getting uh schools built and after we're told there's no money so that's kind of a shock for all of us here we need you the public to stand up and and and um voice your uh complaints to Trenton a letter writing campaign who you're going to write to your representatives the governor uh that's easy enough to find out uh to get that information um we have to help start turning this around we can't let this go on anymore it's unfair that there are

125other districts getting so much money per student and we get nothing it's unfair it's unfair that we have citizens that are paying so much money for the schools because they care they want the children of this District to get quality instruction nothing less than that is acceptable but we can only come to you for that because the state just says no and when they say no and then give other districts schools uh and and pay 85% of a bond referendum for one district and it's building two schools in another District I sit and and say to myself well I thought you just said there's no money so there is money but not not for Monroe that's unacceptable we need you to join us in this effort we need you to start to write a letter

126to make a phone call to voice your complaint because what's going on what's been going on is totally unacceptable I thank you for that um is there any other order uh Board of Education business Mr the maale I have a few things sure first of all do you want this oh yeah um first of all I'd like to say that um a bunch of us went to teachers opening and Mr Schneider's percussion Ensemble played and they did a fabulous job as usual but it was they they were it was really nice and it really added a nice element to the day um that's the first thing secondly I went to the New Jersey State Board of Education meeting last Wednesday and there were a few things um commissioner hesie is resigning effective October 1st and

127Kimberly Harrington is going to be acting commissioner um there was a resolution and recogn recognition of parent teacher Association PTA membership month and another thing which was interesting was that there was a um a new regulation requiring school buses manufactured on or after July 17 2016 to be equipped with sensor to determine the presence of op objects in the front or the back of the bus which I noticed you had in your budget philosophy um I also went to the Senate education committee meeting on Monday which was very interesting um there was a bunch of bills on security that went through and I just where did I that uh that got passed through committee that people may be interested in one requiring school buildings to be equipped with emergency light and panic alarm linked to

128Lo local law enforcement um another one was annual school security training for School Employees to be conducted collaboratively with emergency responders and requires law enforcement officer to annually attend at least one school security drill um and require certain school security measures to be incorporated in the architectural design of new schools but what was really interesting was um a resolution brought forth by Senate President Sweeney and Senate uh Senator Ruiz who is head of the Senate education committee and this resolution to create a school aid funding fairness commission and this commission will be comprised of six public members appointed by um various people and it will be the duty of this commission to study the impact of the adjustment Aid and state aid growth limit provisions of the school funding Reform Act of 2008 and to

129make recommendations for revising those Provisions in order to maximize in order to provide full funding of the school funding Reform Act of 2008 over a 5-year period and to bring fair and Equitable funding to all school districts for enrollment growth over a multi-year period and what's interesting about this it's not a bill it's a resolution and this passed that a committee and once it gets passed by the Senate and the companion resolution gets passed by the assembly then it becomes enacted and it does not need the governor's signature for that so I thought everybody might be interested because that will have an impact on us if I'm not mistaken um is that I know it goes right into legislation but is it an up and down vote it doesn't need I know it doesn't need

130the governor's approval it's an up and down vote yeah it's thank you I I I'm sorry are you finished yeah okay and that's it post that on our would it be appropriate to post that on our website the the the resolution yeah I mean it's public knowledge I mean no you can can ask asking all right okay yes Mr k p um I have a few things um the first one I I think that it would be helpful for us and the administration to get the addresses of our legislators and the governor and put it on the website and this way it's there for people and they don't have to look it up because they have to look it up they might not do it but if it's there and available we might get more

131people to to write a letter can I can I just interject sure well you know what let her finish it's exactly what you talking about that's okay just and I would also recommend we put Senate President Sweeney's address on there too for people to write to um I I got an invitation this evening to attend a cocktail reception with our 14th District legislators tonight so it was Senator Linda Greenstein assemblyman Wayne D'Angelo assemblyman Dan Benson and it was from 5:30 to 7:30 obviously I left there early to get to here but I had the opportunity to speak to assemblyman Dan Benson and I talked about the 427 new students that we were expecting next year and that the level of growth is way more than the 200 and the 200 to 250 that we're experiencing

132or we expected and they understand what's going on they would like to help us not everybody in Trenton feels the same way so again as Mr Ryback said it's important to get the parents and the and the community and our seniors together to write these letters um I know Jill talked about the commission and uh assembly men Benson talked to to me about the commission and I think the the the good piece is that whatever they come up for has to go to it for a vote so whether it's voted up or down it will be voted upon I how long it will take I have no idea um we probably won't ever get our full Fair of full share of fair funding um say that three times but to get more is better than

133to stay where we are right now and and that's what he said he felt that we should be able to get more than we are getting now but we're probably not going to get 12 13 $14,000 per child so um I think it's important I've spoken to him I've spoken to others to get everybody out there to do the same thing and they do understand it's Trenton doesn't always work the way we wanted to um the next thing is I happened to be at Barnes & Noble the other day and the New Jersey monthly New Jersey monthly magazine came out with the top 100 high schools so I grabbed it because I was excited to see see where we were on the list and um I looked through it and I didn't find us so

134I bought it and I took it home um in 200 2014 we were number 82 so I know that to get there it took many years of hard work and it's something that when we made it in 2014 we anticipated keeping we're moving up the list so that we instead of 82 we're moving we want it to be number one but this year we're number 126 so I was disappointed to see that it's very hard to get up in the into the top 100 but I think once you do that you want to stay and not say yay we did it once so that's it we that's we don't need to do it again um I I think I know that they changed some of the criteria to get on the list so I the

135indicators are grouped into three categories the school environment the St performance and the student outcomes and I would like to find out I don't know about the rest of the board what happened to make us fall out of the top 100 where did we fail if we failed or or what happened to make us go down and how we can work together to get us back in the direction we're we're back in the 100 the top 100 high schools so I don't know if that's possible but I think it's important to get there can I sure absolutely I have one more thing you me a comment on this now sure all right thank you Mr yeah I was disappointed as well a couple of things to keep in mind that data is two years old

136that they're using so it's from two years ago where they uh where were what we being ranked on not last year and certainly not this year uh that's part of it they did change a criteria and uh Dr Ali and I had a conversation for my understanding the data the data that they might be relying on from the state might not be 100% correct specifically in regard to the number of students who participate in arts classes uh because that number why I know it's not correct just because of what we offer our students and the enrollment so that had an impact on that uh study as well the um I'm using that data from that as well as other Publications that rank this higher much higher uh that is a local you know New Jersey

137monthly but uh I am using that data to continually look at and say how can we continue to improve I'll be very interested in seeing how this past school year and this upcoming school year of how we Fair um you know but it's it's it's it'd be it would be nicer if it was more recent than always looking back two years I know the list comes out every every two years and even the number of of students this like last year that uh took part in our advanced placement test which is part of the criteria and it scored three or better you know we did very well on that uh we always do well on that and I think I didn't compare that particular uh data set but that seems to have been going up

138uh as well as Dr Al are there other parts of that as well that I'm missing it has to do with how sometimes how we code some of our courses on schu in and that's where some of the art classes were missed for example graphic arts was missed as one of our art classes it should have been included in that um the state is constantly changing how we need to code the courses I know Mr Washington and I have gone to several workshops over the last couple of years and every time we go they tell us something different um so we're trying to keep up with all of that with how we code our scheduling courses I I just wanted to see if there was anything that the board can do to support something that

139maybe we're not doing right now and if there's something that you could bring back to us that um if we have to add or subtract or something because I think it would be nice to get back up into that I think one thing that'll help is we we focus we're focusing a lot on data uh last year and again this year and we're really looking to drill down into the data and to see how did other schools do better than us and and what parts did we do better than than uh some of the other schools so even looking at uh um even like student faculty ratio the the top school chadam school district was 12.4 for students to faculty uh we were 12.9 East Brunswick was which was rated much higher was 13.2 so

140their their ratio was higher than ours um the number of AP courses or International baloria courses offered the top rated District had 28 we offer 28 East Brunswick not the pick on East Brunswick it's just a neighboring District I just happened to pick uh look at um they only offer 25 so when you look at it sometimes it depends on how you look at the data and what lens you use to to look at uh the number of students with taking at least one AP course now this is where we were low uh percentage wise so that's something we want to look at can we encourage some of our students to take more AP courses one of the things that it does speak to is there are a lot of students who might take uh

141college courses and not take the AP course so it doesn't mean that they're not being successful they're going at it from a different route it's it's almost better to take it at the college than it is to take the AP course because not every single College will accept the AP course credits um so again at face value it looks like well we're not doing as well but when you look at it in a different way we'd have to look at the data in that sense as well uh again the art classes that Dr Alvi already spoke to the number of students who score over 1500 on the SAT and I'm not sure this has to be the old SAT I would think because it was two years ago right that was the old SAT uh

1421600 not counting to 2400 with the writing po because a lot of colleges didn't take that the um top school in their their ranking uh had 74% we had 51% of 1500 or higher 1 1600 being a perfect score I applaud the students and chat them if they have 74% of their students almost reaching perfect scores that's pretty impressive I don't know too many other the districts that are coming close to that but I applaud them for that's that's commendable that's something we'll certainly look to do to see if our students can score higher a lot of colleges and universities don't even use theat because not everyone does well in the SAT so there are a lot of other indicators that colleges look at and I think if you look at the universities that our

143students are getting into that's pretty impressive the um percentage of AP courses that students receive three or higher three being the level where the colleges will take credit uh we had 78% um again not bad uh top school had 7 91 so you know I applaud them but uh so these this is the these are the kind of uh statistics that uh we're looking at and we're going to continue to to look at and part of the goals that we have for this year is you know the Partnerships with colleges also looking at how our students Faire in college and continue in a four-year college so we'll continue to to explore all that because we would like to be number one if nothing else at least in the top 100 but again keep in mind

144this is one Journal that ranked this and other journals ranked us much higher so I applaud the schools that scored higher than us uh and we'll continue to look to see what they're doing and how we can improve but again we're also ranked higher in uh with other rankings or other uh ratings as well and then I I just have one more um Township two Township um activities coming up for families the first is the annual green fair being held on October 8th at the high school from 10:00 to 3:00 and the second is the annual October Fest down at the um rec center on Sunday October 16th 12:00 to 4:00 both of them are really good family events that concludes my report I ask Mr Russo to go course I just what I what

145I wanted to say earlier uh in making an effort to get the public to help the board um would it be possible to draft a letter and getting back to the letter writing campaign have it posted on the website District website where parents and students who want to send those letters off can draw that letter down sign it and send it because the addresses will be there uh in this way maybe some of the nuances the sentiment will be maybe written which is uh more appropriate maybe for communicating what we want although I think that's an excellent idea and we're talking very seriously about getting a letter writing Campaign together and I have a meeting with the PTO and PTA coming up in the beginning of October and I wanted that that was one of

146the agenda items I would have to check the legality we you have to be very careful with a public uh School District website that we're we don't do anything that's perceived as being political it it seems to make sense to me for what you're saying we're giving the information we'll make it bipartisan Republican Democrat we're just asking for parent support but I will have to check that legally to see if we can do that okay thank you yeah I just I just have a question Dr kak to what you said before what are the other journals where we are ranked higher like can can you uh well it's not know if it's a journal was it Niche is the one that's up on our website I think Newsweek Newsweek US News and World Report or

147Newsweek I I didn't write that down just minut so I'm not real sure um but I think it was one of the two of those news week I just heard someone say news week US News and World Report okay thank you Mr Calin so I just want to go back on a couple things tonight um when a member of the public came up and asked you questions about what we're doing with the new referendum and thinking of moving forward um I want to clarify something I thought I heard one of the things that you had said was you know there's a lot of things that are going on we're going to be looking at a lot of different things um and one of the the other things that are going to be under consideration is

148is local opposition or local feedback to to you know where the school is going to to go forgetting about where it's being proposed to go I want to take that off the table so for a general discussion so I can have a clear understanding what do you mean by that because if if a property is deemed to be feasible for our use if it meets all of the DEA if it meets all of the criteria that we need the wet lands and all of those believe me Myriad of things that it has to fall into do how how is local opposition going to impact the decision no okay yeah so the first the land has to be transferred to us from the township I I don't mean the mechanics all that has to fall I

149get that all of that has to happen again not assuming the land we talked about before right but taking that off the table we're going to be looking to put something up somewhere right and generally speaking nobody wants it in their backyard believe me right I got a little experience there right so that push back from local people near the area it's coming whether it's the place where we're thinking now or a future place that we don't even know about cuz I don't know maybe we'll invade cranberry and I personally think we can take him and we can get more land right but something is going to pop up whether it's this land or somewhere else how is the local residential feedback going to either influence or not influence you to make a decision yeah

150um with all due respect to the the residents because you're right no one really wants that school put in their backyard and um it we have to look out I think it is our job that we look out for what's in the best interest of all the students in the in the school district and we have to look at what's going to provide some sort of of a benefit to all areas of the township as well which also played into our thoughts of where schools were being placed and where the growth was occurring and what would it mean for for residents maybe on the north end of town as opposed to the south end of town or the east or the West so all those things are are considered but really what drives it for

151us is we're looking at 1500 students coming in we broke it out the demographic reports we're looking at at the elementary um maybe I don't know seven or eight you know 800 students um uh so many at the middle school and which is already over capacity so we wanted to build another Middle School to relieve the stress on our current middle school for those unhoused students that are already in our schools and then the high school where all of our students eventually get to uh this building you know that's why we went and we drove up to South Brunswick and we looked at other districts who had experienced the same growth maybe 10 years ago and who have high schools with Capac capacity of around 3,000 students so it I wouldn't say that the a

152resident opposition to a school being built there would stop us from proceeding if we had the land and if we had the availability and I say that with all due respect to all the residents because I think you're exactly right we're going to experience opposition no matter where we propose a school we off out to see where can we build and and properly house students if if we have a lot of student growth going on in the southern end of town around 33 in apagar uh in the existing developments there then we have to see where can we build something that will accommodate the students without a long bus ride um so all those type of things are considered and the oppos the only reason I mentioned the opposition is that we don't have that

153land yet that was that the township offered to us so it sounded great when it was offered to us but like a lot of things you have to fully investigate it and that takes a a period of time and then at our last board meeting some residents got up and spoke that they were opposing that and that's what I was speaking to it wasn't really that they were opposing us but I think they were maybe opposing the township but whatever but until that Land Is Ours we have to look at all the different areas in town M cof did that answer your question no no that that clears it up because like I said having gone down this road before and knowing what's um what last week I used the term the darkness is coming

154right um it it this type of thing has a tendency to both make a community great and put up some roow barriers and some divisions and people start you know sitting on one side of the room versus the other side of the room and it's not fun right so um for the folks that are going to look to you're G to be your uh stakeholders the ones that are going to get out there and try and push the vote you need to make sure that that if there's going to be opposition to it yes we're sorry that there's going to be opposition but for the greater good of the community we kind of have to press forward on this because you don't want to pull the rug out from your supporters who are there to

155help you sell the product and then not have you be just as willing to stand up and to defend the decisions you guys all have to make because it's the best for the community so I just wanted to make sure I was clear on that because it was also mentioned earlier that you know people are coming in and see people are leaving the district and going out because costs are going up unfortunately as we talked about tonight the math doesn't jive to that you may have people leaving for a wide range of reasons but you still have hundreds and hundreds of new homes being built and from where I live the houses are sold but people moving in have 2 3 four five kids so the the aggregate number is only accelerating and only going

156up that that's only even when we were in 2008 2009 the worst economic period of the United States it was like it didn't affect Monroe the sales kept I don't know what it is about this place but the sales kept coming and and the grow kept coming so um okay I'm one more thing little thing I promised I know I I said I was never going to speak speak up uh really tiny thing um if you're speaking about an agenda item and a board member has a question and wants to come back to him just just as a thing um he didn't Advance the agenda he should have had a chance to ask his follow-up question um that that's just you know I'll take so I'll shut up it's okay I just want to comment

157on what you said um doing what we're doing you know we can't please everybody that's a given but we have to do what's best for this enti fire community and that's what I know we're going to be working all of us very hard uh to accomplish very quickly I too have had experience in um referendums and land Acquisitions and and land acceptances and uh I think the difference this time is that the board and the administration is doing due diligence they're making sure that there are no obstacles um yes does it seem like that's postponing the situation I think it's better than putting um than going through the gamut like we went last time um we would have saved maybe money and time had we done our due diligence in advance as we're doing now

158so um there are um caveats about land and purchases and availability and uh D issues so I think that what seems to be a Slowdown of the uh proceedings is uh prudent in order not to really go so far and then have a standstill because there are other issues either legal or environmental so I think that the difference is we're doing the due diligence upfront instead of having a crisis in the middle of the process thank Mr Russo you have my apologies for before thank you very much on that I have one one more one more again it's a the letter writing campaign just something to consider many of the residents may be new so so having a draft that they can pull down off the website in that way would help because they would

159have some historical background because they wouldn't know what to write okay is there any other board business I would like yes sorry I just thought of this don't be sorry um it was announced at the at the State Board of Ed meeting um last week that they are changing the the percentage of the currently in a teachers evaluation those teachers that there's um that Park that those teachers that teach that have a equivalent Park um part to them were 10% of Park was going towards this teacher evaluation and the um the New Jersey doe just announced that they are raising that to 30% without public input or anything like that and I just wanted to say I am vly opposed to that because I don't think park has been tried and truee and hasn't been

160and I think it's very unfair to teachers to have 30% of their evaluation based on a test that's only a couple years old thank you Mr anyone else in that case we can move to the next public Forum where you are not bound to the agenda but I will ask you to be bound to the 3 minutes state your name and address is it Mr Chella Ken Chella 116 prola Avenue I just have a I I just have four points I'm going to make them quickly and then you can answer what you want to answer uh I apologize in being late uh with this but I was sick um I spent some time in the hospital but from what I understand the superintendent was given a bonus what I'd like to know is that true

161no no no um no if I'll I'll take that right now um as part of the contract he has mered goals in the second and third year of his contract okay so we the board came up with merried goals there were two quantitative and one qualitative that we gave him he has to earn that he has to accomplish it it was not given he was not given any raise it depends on whether he accomplishes the goals or not okay um as far as the uh the the going forward with the referendum I just want to caution the board that without land or land that or you know basing our referendum on land that's locked up in a legal battle is not smart uh the we had a legal battle over this high school for for

162those of you who are here and remember that and uh we went out for a referendum we got uh caught up in a legal battle and it cost taxpayers $40 million more so I would just say that if we're going to go forward with a referendum that we have to use caution and that we should be really doing our due diligence to make sure that we have land that it's in our hand that it's not something that's promised to us that it's not tied up in some way and that we're going to uh we're going to really have it um as far as a letter writing campaign I think that's great but I think we've done a lot of things the board's done a lot of things and uh trying to get legislation passed speaking

163to various uh elected representatives and it's gone nowhere I think what this Board of Ed needs to do is contact other uh Factor groups other districts that are like our group our district and Sue the state I think that's the way to go I don't think they're going to listen to a letter writing campaign or email or text messages or anything like that I think they're going to listen to uh a Democratic town not voting you or or threatening them with not voting Democratic if they don't do what's right for our taxpayers regardless of the party and I think that's what that'll get their attention and I think they don't want that they won't want that news they won't they don't want that kind of bad press and maybe they'll do something for us for

164once uh the other the one of the other things and then I'll get off is uh Mrs calapan talked about some of the uh events that are coming up well this Saturday there's also an event being hosted by the Indian Cultural Association of Monroe it's free it's at die farm and uh uh it's a great it's a great opportunity to meet our neighbors we have a a large and growing Indian population in Monroe and uh it's a wonderful a wonderful culture uh over the years I spent a lot of time going to their events and and making a lot of friends in in the Indian Community and I can tell you that it's a it's a very warm and wonderful Community plus they have good food um but I would just say that if uh

165if people can get out to that it's a great opportunity to learn about you know about some of our uh residents that live here that's it thank you Mr anyone else from the public yes sir my name is Dave Bosco I live at 16 BMA Court over in colun um we're talking about you know possibly using the land that's adjacent to our property my question is the land that uh the land that's not I'm sorry the land that's that's over where Apple Gart school is um not Oak Tre the I think it's about 15 to 20 acres where Apple Guard School is has that land been thought of as a possibility or has it been looked into so are you talking about the land that Applegarth school is currently on yeah correct yes all right

166and yeah it would I mean it wouldn't be large enough it it wouldn't fit our it wouldn't meet our needs but yes we are considering that okay okay thank you before you begin I I know you mentioned a presentation um let me tell you you have three minutes to do a presentation we had a little problem before which I'm I regret having a problem because you're a member of the public and we want to hear what you have to say but you have three minutes any kind of presentation that would take more than 3 minutes would have to be pre-approved by yes we'll break it into chapters I hate Cliffhangers I'm waiting for The Walking Dead to resume so I know who got killed on Walking Dead But if you want to break it into

167three minute segments I'm happy to do that so we'll we'll postpone some of this for the next meeting that's fine um but I think this is all going to be your name again please sure sure John elbasan AEL monor I think this will be informative for the board because there were some questions raised about the land use in particular there's a lot of misconception out there uh we will also keep this available for after if anyone has questions so this here is uh currently the wetlands uh New Jersey Department of Environmental Protections overview this is an official mapping that is used by surveyors it's a publicly available website anyone here can go to it uh this clearly uh lists the area of southern Monroe uh and what is currently uh listed as uh Wetlands uh

168I'm going to show the area in question so that everyone at the board knows exactly the overlay of these 64 Acres so looking at the map here we need a microphone need to use the mic so looking at the map we basically have 64 Acres which is right in this quadrant here this is the box that we're talking about these are the homes that have been built to the right and to the north this 64 Acres if you notice those shaded sell areas are the wetlands from the 2012 image survey that shows also the three tributaries running par perpendicular to that land uh which is also causing uh the wetlands to expand east to west uh this was uh transferred in terms of Deeds over the last 40 years for $1 because the value of

169this land is abysal so this is a classic Gift Horse scenario folks uh this was also identified by the township as proposed Green Acres in the 20 uh 2006 environmental commission study and in the 2010 environmental commission study it's also uh listed under the master plan as a a priority acquisition land for Green Acres so that's the first map we have down to about one minute so we we'll make this a cliffhanger uh I'm happy to answer questions for the board because we will be transparent about this this is a classic gift hor scenario and this is a classic transparency issue in public government and we're being held to an arbitrary Sunshine limit of 3 minutes which is not for the betterment of this community nor for this board Mr President so I respectfully object

170to your three minute statute you could object it's not arbitrary it's what we have in policy this map is uh depicting pinville Road where the current uh Monroe Middle School is and where the current Monroe High School um and my mic has cut out again so between uh the US Post Office on the corner of Pineville and between the Middle School is actually a separate parcel of land it is 14 acres Mr Gorski are you aware of this land parcel in question I would have to study that map a little more closely I've looked at quite a few with our architect and with Mr tag and I'll admit I'm geographically challenged so I I'd have to look at it a little more closely and figure out where exactly you are we'll be happy to over

171the next several meetings uh block number 49 LW 2 6.01 12 acres of land historically owned by the Board of Education of Monroe Township it is perfect land that is situated to the south of the middle school no one in this Township wants to bifurcate the Middle School to a north and south designation we don't want to have kids be basically arbitrarily split into two in their most in informative years we would rather have a unified Middle School that feeds organically into our high school okay I I'm sorry the time is to be continued to be continued thank you Mr ryck I know I'm I'm asking you a question uh could could you ask the gentleman to provide those documents to the board he said he was going to I think he said you going

172to leave them I will I will say afterwards and then we will formally through Council submit these to the township okay okay and lastly uh in speaking to the mayor's office there is no lastly I'm I'm sorry your time is up I can't have you you did that the last time it's so unfortunate that we have to unfortunate what's unfortunate is that you don't respect the three minute limit so I have to say we cut you off next next no I'm sorry you're done next board meeting is Wednesday October 19th at 7 p.m. oh I'm sorry someone else yes I'm I didn't see you I apolog Sten manfrey 12 Belmont Court I seed my time to John elberson um you cannot that's not our policy you're able to do that yes Mr board president you

173are able to okay if they want to speak R woman over here did you want to speak okay want to speak thank you Patricia Lang 74 McFarland Circle how are you guys tonight um I wanted just to piggyback on two things one that Jill said and it kind of piggybacks on what you were saying earlier Dr K kak is that um when we when Kathy was talking about how our district was raid and and you brought up how it's really hard to use data in those really specific ways and to look at it but this is what our governor wants to do to our teachers this is what he wants to do using Park which is a substandard test which hasn't been verified and hasn't been proven kids are struggling because it's written so poorly

174and now we're going to use that to judge our teachers at 30% of their evaluation that's a really scary Prospect especially in light of the fact that you've noticed the real Trend to good Educators who have been in education for a long time retiring because enough's enough and with us going into a negotiations year I think there has to be some consideration as what do we do as a board of ed what do we do as a public to say you can't do this to our teachers anymore 30% based on a park test on one test is absolutely insane so that was number one number two I just piggy back on Mr Russo was that I do a lot of work for the um American Heart American stroke Association as a as a Survivor and

175one of the ways that we get our word out to our government officials with different bills and things that we need is they actually have a website that you can go on to and it sends the letters directly so I think that letter writing campaigns when letters trickle in over a period of time don't work because they get lost in a pile but if there was a mechanism through a website and they're sending the letters directly where it's already pre-print printed it would be much more effective so I just wanted to share that bit of information but Mr Russo had brought it up before me so that was good so thank you very much for my less than three minutes thank you anyone else from the public okay the next schedule not seeing anyone else

176from the public we are resuming our three minutes that was given by Mr manfre a res say what I'm willing to do uh you're obviously speaking for a group am I correct we have an aggregate of minutes so we'll give you another three minutes uh I'll extend another three minutes View and then that's it this is over and and I'm not sure it's over I think this a conversation okay just just let's not make it so terminal okay so okay it starts now Mr board president would you prefer a special committee meeting to be established for this conversation at a later date to be determined in either September or October I think so then we motion for that and if that could be a resolution passed tonight then I will satisfy my three minutes and

177return it back to the board okay um in that case uh well I will ask the committee chairs uh if they are willing to accept that and I always see that to the committee chair that's why they're the chair that would be the procedural vote Yes okay thank you next schedule um Board of Education meeting is Wednesday October 19th at 7 p.m. this meeting is adjourned wa no wait a minute I'm sorry don't we have A's not closed session we didn't see you no we we're not having any closed session I'm sorry got to got caught caught up with this m scurby did you want to speak absolutely I didn't see you there didn't didn't didn't see you a little hectic for a minute that's okay uh Christy scurby 21 pre uh Drive sorry it's

178a new uh new residence um I just wanted to say piggyback on something Mr Elon said um about a uniform Middle School um I think that we do need to really look into um if we're going to have another Middle School in town and what that truly means um I've been thinking about that a lot being involved in the schools um you take on a lot of uh changes for the students uh right now our Middle School sports teams are thriving um there are several of them and I think the board just needs to really take a look at what that would mean if you split a middle school in two um you're going to need more Fields uh currently the Middle School field for baseball is not used by the middle schoolers they are

179busted over to Oak Tree school to use those fields so if you had another Middle School you would have to create another set of fields um for all of the sports because right now the sports fields are across the board soccer um baseball they are being utilized to the full extent um so I think that's something that the board really needs to look into um clubs as well uh you were going to need an entire new staff for the Middle School um I think that maybe we want to pursue looking at what has been suggested by the ad hoc committee or the student growth committee has having a um 56 building and a 7/8 building and then High School 9 through 12 um this way the students are moving together instead of being split until

180high school that's all thank you anyone else in the public yes hi Kim shabs to uh horseshoe Court um I live in the area I've lived there for nine years I appreciate Mrs skur's comments but she's very new to the area I have some very serious like safety concerns and um if you guys decide to go forward with the schools I hope you really um sit with the township to go over the roads there wintertime there is a nightmare um North Wind is about 28 feet across it's very narrow that road when it snows at any capacity we we're almost like trapped back there the one time we had a blizzard the wind was blowing and there was 3 ft of of snow in the middle of that road and I couldn't get out and

181I'm just really concerned of buses coming off of Old Church Road um onto from Apple guard to Old Church Road I don't know how they're going to make that turn so that has to be done the other issue is if there's ever an emergency there's no way out there only two ways out is if you go down um England or Old Church Road you have to go through Southfield Estates is another way if they were looking into opening Long Street which is nonexistent because now I look to for the sign it's not even there anymore if that was open at least that would take you out onto to uh Pineville without that being there I really think bringing 2,000 kids into that area with teachers and everything I think it's become it will be a

182really a huge problem if anything happens any kind of emergency we we can't get out there's no way out so um I just wanted to let you know and the other last concern is when they put in Colts run for us my my property backs up to the millstone River the amount of water that I see on a bad rainy day it really frightens me and then and to add now another area where you're building a school and it's going to come the water is just going to keep coming so I don't know how it's going to really impact me in the bigger picture but I just want you to be aware like I've been there enough long enough time to really get an idea of what you're dealing with so I would just appreciate

183if you guys are really seriously doing it please go out in the middle of winter when there's a snowstorm and see what I'm talking about and and really travel those roads and really look at how much it just I can't see how it would really make sense so thank you thank you very much anyone else in the public did I see a hand come up okay there is no closed uh session uh so we could skip 14 and 15 uh let me just say the next schedule board meeting is Wednesday October 19th at 7 p.m. here in high school um I have like to make a motion to C to uh close all in favor I unanimous meeting is closed

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.