001this meeting of the Monro Township Board of Education is now called to order can you rise for the pledge please I pledge to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all okay Mr gski we have a roll call please certainly miss armeno Mr Braverman ready to go Mayo yes here Mr calman Mrs K Pano Mr nosin here Mrs Corino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here Mr rutsky here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening and in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted July
0028th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski um we're up to the first uh public forum which you'll be able to address items on the agenda if anyone from the public is interested they can step up to the microphone and please give your name and address and you'll be limited to three minutes Mr Po I can't see you but there you are uh good evening uh Doug poy for tamarak Road uh I looked at the resolution that I believe is on the agenda tonight and I had some concerns or questions um and the various whereases the the second one uh from the last or the next to the last it says uh altern alternative methods of achieving state and federal
003requirements for graduation uh I just wasn't aware that there were any federal requirements for graduation uh I think all the graduation requirements are basically controlled by the state uh but I just point that out and I could be an error there uh also as I went through all the whereases and and I kept double-checking I went then to your uh what you were resolving uh or at least proposed to resolve here um and it seems that a as I as I read this it appears that uh you may be uncomfortable with the options uh that are being provided for 2017 through 2020 uh because there are options being provided over that time period so I think the the resolution may need uh you may need to pay a little bit more attention to when you
004want these things that you're asking the state department to do to go into effect because I believe the intention is that they go into effect for the year 2021 uh but take a look at that because um as I said in number two you're saying you urg the department to provide multiple Pathways to a high school diploma well they're already doing that for the years 2016 through 20120 and you acknowledge that and your whereas is up here so I think it's a little confusing to me exactly what you're calling for in the resolution uh also you're urging them um to provide these multiple Pathways to a high school diploma that includes Alternatives not based on standardized test uh as an educator I have a great concern about that because if you don't have standardized test
005I think it's very difficult for your District to determine how well the students are meeting the curriculum uh as well as how they're doing compared to other districts in your state they have to compete against other students in terms of college admissions and if you don't know how well your Stu or our students are doing compared to other districts and the only way to know that is some type of standardized test uh then I think uh you're missing out on some very valuable information there so I just share those concerns with you because I read the resolution uh as many of you know uh I have many many years of experience as an educator and also an administrator and as I read this I was just troubled by those points that I brought out thank
006you thank you Mr P uh one comment maybe um we can expand on a little bit is the federal involvement I I think that's the new law uh every every student succeeds Act is that I get that right yes so technically Mr Po the there is no federal requirement for as far as an assessment for graduation um in that the states decide their you the requirements but the states that have adopted the common core and follow or that are following the every student succeeds act and also even prior to that that the race to the top initiative um followed the guidelines which are that there were our standardized test assigned that even goes back prior to the No Child Left Behind back from President Bush and others um that that started then and the testing
007the testing at each grade level from 3 to 8 and in high school was a part of that so it does address Federal requirements in a way uh and it's always seems to be a contentious area between the states and the um the Department of Education at the federal level but good point though thank you not seeing anyone else from the uh public uh what I'd like to do though just for the flow of uh the meeting is to Interchange six and seven so I'd like to move to uh other board business right now and um Mr Mayo we have your uh resolution would you like to introduce yes um I make a motion for this the following resolution whereas the New Jersey Department of Education NJ doe has proposed new regulations regarding High School
008graduation requirements which eliminate the Alternative High School assessment and replace the mandatory High School proficiency assessment with the partnership for assessment of Readiness for college and careers Park assessments and whereas the New Jersey doe proposal provides that students graduating in 2016 through 2019 can satisfy graduation requirements by demonstrating Proficiency in English language arts and Mathematics through a means other than endof course Park assessment including achieving a passing score on a substitute test such as sat or act or meeting the criteria of the New Jersey portfolio appeals process and whereas the New Jersey doe excuse me proposal provides that students graduate in the class of 20 20 can demonstrate graduation profic proficiency through the same alternative means as those in the classes of 2016 through 2019 provided that St students in the class of 2020 take
009all end of course Park assessments for which they are eligible eligible as of the effective date of the regulations and whereas the New Jersey doe proposal requires that students graduating in 2020 one and thereafter who have not demonstrated proficiency in English language ARs and Mathematics through the end of course Park assessment by their senior year can demonstrate graduation proficiency by meeting the criteria of the portfolio appeals process and whereas under the proposed regulations for the classes of 2020 and thereafter with exceptions for students with disabilities and English language Learners students will be required to take all of the applicable end of course Park exams in order to be eligible for the portfolio appeals appeals process and whereas the Monroe Township Board of Education believes the state should provide alternative methods of achieving state and federal
010requirements for graduation and whereas the board further believes that students who are unable to demonstrate achievement through the park assessment should be offered reasonable Alternatives as determined by the New Jersey doe to show they have met the requirements necessary to meet graduation standards now therefore be it resolved that the Monroe Township Board of Education hereby w support supports alternatives to a uniform Statewide test as a method of assessing whether students have met New Jersey state standards two urges the New Jersey doe to provide multiple Pathways to a high school diploma that include Alternatives not based on standardized tests and three directs the business administrator board secretary to send a copy of this resolution to the commissioner of education and all legislators representing Monroe Township so moved I have a second second okay uh any discussion
011I'd just like to make one one statement um while I'm in favor of this I I I uh I do have one concern for the future and and that's how we're going to um really look at assessments and how they're going to in be used different assessments and how they're going to be used to inform instruction I think that's something that the state Ed department needs to work out uh and that's just one thing that I I have to agree with Mr Po that I that I uh share his concern with any other discussion Mr minum I just want to make a statement before I vote on this um number two also uh gives me some concern um I don't want to dilute the process of um standardized tests and and also uh you know
012Gathering data to help to help children so since this is a resolution to go to the state asking them for for other um consideration I'll probably vote for this but number two sort of concerns me that it's too open-ended and it um and and we should have some kind of standard testing I suppose if for a lack of a better word and not not to dilute the process of finding out whether our children are being pro properly educated or not um which is beyond you know something that I can assess but I do believe that assessing our children to to Really further their ability to succeed in the future I don't want to dilute any process that just um dumbs down our educational system I think we have some Global issues I know this is
013Monroe Township um but in the bigger picture and the global issues I want all of our children to be as as rigorously to to use um uh Steve Ry words uh rigorously educated as possible so although I support this initiative I I I do want to caution us as a board not to get to not to dilute the process so much that we're not we're not using can I absolutely can I just say something um to that effect um the way the regs are written right now the only way to graduation is by taking the end of year um Park courses and the purpose isn't to dilute or to take away from the assessment but is to say that every child learns differently and there are some children who may not be able right to
014take the assessments so they need Alternatives and the way the regs are written they are very narrowly written with this is the only option and I think this says that children are different they learn different they express how what they've learned differently and we need to take that into consideration when considering graduating okay and while I would agree with that uh we don't want the regulations to be too stringent but I I'm just commenting that the language in two in my opinion is too broad um so we we can always go down the road and you know be cautious about that but that's really all I I just think that being too stringent is one degree of um of a problem and and being too broad can can open up another whole issue that you
015know unintentional uh as it might be thank you Mr nin did you have your hand raised yes I did thank you Mr President um there's a saying that we're we're preparing we don't prepare our students for graduation day we prepare them for the next day and that is to me is the most important thing that we're doing here because at the end of the day um it's what happens after they graduate that is impactful on their future careers and and uh uh Cho and education choices So based on that concern uh I would love to hear what um Dr kak has to say about this resolution and get his input here yes absolutely okay so well thank you Mr norin um for giving me that opport or asking me for my opinion on this and
016and I want to preface what what I'm going to say with um I respect the controversy of swirling around Park test and standardized assessments uh you know out in the community not only in New Jersey but throughout the country and I also want to preface it with saying I have the highest respect for Mr mayo and we have had many discussions about education and I think we're very much in agreement in that we both feel that we want the very best for our children so having said that uh there's a couple things that I think that are important for the board to consider we've just hit the 50y year anniversary of the Coleman report which was done uh I guess it was back in the sometime in the 60s or maybe early 70s and and
017basically the Coleman report uh just like other reports that were commissioned by the Department of Education the Federal Department of Education looked at it education in America to see are we preparing our students um you know properly to enter the you know the day after graduation if you will which is a very nice thing and might of that some of that may have been in a um reaction to sputnick even going back even further and looking at how our students compared to at the time students from the USSR uh now we have to look at uh you know China and Russia uh India uh and many many other countries and the Coleman report brought up the importance of having standardized testing and the reason for that is that many students especially our special ed students
018were too often it was just well you know what they're they're not they're not quite ready they're okay and we had no standardized way to look to see whether we were really properly preparing all of our students our most needy students our struggling students and holding standards high for them that opinion was brought up again in the report that was Commissioned I believe was President Reagan was in office and again later on uh with President Bush and then certainly when President Obama uh took over so it's a bipartisan type of viewpoint um and and that is we standardized testing gives us a means to look at all of our students and uh you know our high achieving students um you know as you know some of our students this past year are leaving here and
019they're going to MIT and Columbia and University of Penn and we want to make sure that when they get there that we know that we're doing our job that we' prepared those students for that what many of these reports have shown is you get students to go to a college or university and some students are from New Jersey some are from Michigan some are from Massachusetts some are from Mississippi and some students did better than others even though they all had A's in their respective high schools but what we found out was there was no standardized measurement of where we're preparing our students so I feel that it's a disservice for us not to hold high expectations and not to hold uh some standardized method of assessing how we are doing I tell teachers I
020tell our principles I tell our teacher candidates who come in to interview that I really don't want to hear comments made to students that you need to know this for the test that's not our intent our intent is to have the students gain the knowledge gain the the skills the strategies for continued learning throughout their life the tests are for us so they shouldn't the kids shouldn't worry about when they come up and oh I got a park okay they have Park they have New Jersey ask they have whatever it is maybe it's sat you know uh because some states are adopting sat in in louisv park so but I think that that data is so important for us to look at we disaggregate that data you know Dr AB can tell you we go
021through that data line by line we look at all this different data to say are we doing what we need to be doing and with that a standardized measure of knowing that it it's hard to to to achieve that now there are students that Mr Mayo is absolutely correct that don't do well in standardized assessments I think there are plenty of other measures that uh we employe in our high school currently that provide evidence how these students are doing and the state has allowed for a port portfolio assessment uh for those students but at the same time the skills that these students are going to need are so important whether they go on to college or whether they go directly from high school into a career you know I've mentioned this before some of our
022traditionally considered or considered Blue Cow type of uh jobs maybe an auto mechanic maybe you know something else like that the level of reading that the students need to read the the technical manuals is at at a second year college level so you know it's it's the board's um prerogative on on on you know which direction to go in but I I I do agree with Mr Po I I caution the board to to seriously consider this um I think the number of students who have not been able to achieve proficiency on Park uh you know this is the first couple years of this is is pretty small in the big number and by the time they've had a chance to take the test either again or or another type of assessment they've been okay
023um but personally I've been hearing this for years from comedians you know on talk shows and late night shows and ah isn't this funny we're going to ask this high school graduate or this college graduate that they know where this city or this country is and they love to make fun of education and educators well you know this this we're raising our expectations and and I think we're doing a a pretty good job of it and I think we're doing a better job of preparing our students now than we have been and think about the disruptive type of careers that are out there and I use the word disruptive very purposefully you know we talked a couple years ago that well you know when we came through there was no internet there was no Google
024there was no apple now the talk is well there was no Uber there was no Lyft there there was no uh you know you name it uh s autonomous cars look what Tesla's doing well are we preparing our students to go and work on that what's a car mechanic going to do when all of a sudden you have a a Tesla pulling in and saying I need work on this actually you probably won't because they do all they do updates they stream updates onto the car that process alone is moving along so quick much quicker than than anticipated that's a disruptor to the automotive industry the same Elon Musk the same person has been a disruptor with the space agency you know he's seriously talking about Mann um missions to to Mars we need to
025prepare our students to to go into careers like that now are all of our students going to go into that no they're not but even going back to Thomas Freeman talking about the World is Flat and saying well there's certain jobs that are kind of protected you know like accountants no not really you know oh sorry sorry Mr Gorski he stay you can do it online okay there's so many of these careers that have gone online there's you know there's different ways they've become individualized and um so and plus there's enough research out there that students or or now they're not students once they you know students who graduate and go on the college career they may change their career four five six times during their lifetime so we need to provide the skills to
026give them that flexibility to be able to do that and I and I I I don't want to speak for Mr mayo and I don't think she's intending for us to W anything down by by a long stretch and I and I I can't tell you enough how much I respect your opinion our conversations have been really wonderful I love those kind of conversations and I think that's what we're about about educ education I love that that we're having discussions about that and there's certainly many students who may go into certain careers um that you know is algebra ever going to benefit them or or biology maybe not you know but again it's that it's that right brain left brain type of thinking that we want to encourage and we want to uh make sure
027our students have those skills um and when we go to our goals there's going to be a lot of uh I I would like to bring up part of that discussion i' I've actually brought a few things along with me just to use as examples um that I think it's important that we look at in the direction that we're we're helping our students so I know I'm a little long-winded on my response but um question I think I'm very passionate about it uh as as Mr Mayo is and and I hope you really understand that I say that in the most respectful manner uh because you know I want you to understand that I I do respect your viewpoint on this and I understand and the the parents and and the community members who believe
028that there's too much testing and and maybe standardize or Park assessment isn't the right way to go but I it's it's gives that data is so important to us to make informed decisions on making sure that our students are learning that i' be hesitant to want to remove the standardized aspect of that thank you anyone else from the board yeah I would just like to comment that the resolution doesn't ask to remove the standardized test it just asks to asked the New Jersey D to add alternatives for those children who may not be this may not be the right pathway for them and it probably in the end that will probably be such a small amount of students most of the kids will be using the park as their High School graduation requirement I know
029for me uh what you said meant a lot because I saw that where the Alternatives have to be approved by the New Jersey Department of Education I believe not every district is is supporting that so there obviously is a standard there that we you know we we're expecting and I think a very important standard as well uh the other thing about the U standardized test yes we we need some sort of a standard to measure uh growth and and how we're doing but we're also and I know be talking about this when we talk about board and District goals we also um are going to be using a lot of data to inform instruction and give us uh you know uh really uh the ability to make these these kinds of decisions and look at
030how we're doing internally you know while that the Park's important there's a lot of controversy about that and uh we need a test that doesn't have this kind of controversy that states like Illinois recently just pulled out of Park we need to know that we have is is is uh something that we'll be able we'll be able to use uh in in making decisions on how we're look at how we're doing and making decisions on how we're going to be teaching and I think uh you know using the data as your you've been a real uh proponent of is is key for us to keep the level of Education uh that we're giving our students High because rigor is important and equal rigor among uh among the kind of exams we're giving is is important
031also anyone else Mr Gorski think we can take a vote on this Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mrs Deo yes Mr nusstein yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo and Mr rutsky yes Mr board president motion passes unanimously okay thank you [Music] and thank you all for your input on that also so well taken uh now uh it gives me great pleasure to introduce um once again Mary gasman from New Jersey School Board Association who's going to lead us in an exercise on determining board goals and and District go Mary hello how you doing hello hello okay okay he better okay um did everyone get my email yes and do you have copies with you or get that gu I I provided copies I mean I I made copies for everybody if
032um okay I have a corrected copy we had a late arrival that came in on Sunday night so I do have other copies here it did not change the data okay uh the numbers changed just slightly so okay I I'm not sure if I have the updated one from Sunday or or uh don't think so uh the one that I sent out uh it was updated from that copy okay if you have copies and I'd appreciate you Distributing I'm going distribute them now but the the important thing is that all of the data that you had to review all of the comments there was only some a couple of minor changes which I'll point out as we go through want me to pass [Applause] that it's the six piece oops thank you oh thank youo
033thank you what do you think of the process of getting the material ahead of time so you had an opportunity to go through it before we pull up to the table yeah better huh yes yeah because tonight you guys are doing the work I'm not doing the work you're doing all the work I'm just here to write it down and try and facilitate it that's the word they use good good verb that's right good verb okay all right so I guess you've had um you've done this before several times and um it's not it's not any different than it was several over the past several years so what did you find most interesting about this report that it's similar to last year's a similar yes yes it is what else I guess it allows you
034to reflect on on what we've done as a board and what you do as a board member yeah that's how the process itself gives us the the opportunity to stop and think about uh where we are where where do we want to go where have we been um one of the things that any organization does is they assess themselves and it was interesting listening to the conversation regarding assessments I mean we assess every day we assess ourselves we assess our organizations so that's what this is okay okay what else did you find you were going through this when you were looking at the results pretty good well if I may I think in in many instances you see wide variance ranging all the way from commendable to unsatisfactory so there's certainly not a consensus view
035on on most topics good observation that's that's correct no no you got plenty more to do you have to speak five more times five you wanted to get in first right but yeah I did notice that yeah and that that is true and that was across all elements did you notice the the value yeah the top scores are always higher than the bot I mean the bottoms are always higher than the top you think yes that's an interesting concept and that's from board to board to board you always the board member always believes that they are doing everything right it's the board the other guy that's not doing it and those numbers were reflected in this report exactly the same way um the value uh all of the members of the board Place High values
036on all of the elements um your lowest which is certainly not low it's above a three the thing that you would look for is anything below a three would cause concern uh but your board staff relationship that's the lowest and I would assume that that's because you work through your Administration and some of the questions that are asked kind of indicate that you would be talking directly to staff which I know you don't do okay how about some of the other things in the report I think the comments were worthwhile because people got a chance to express themselves right uh on on individual aspects of whatever we do that they feel we could do better or that we did well on um did any comments jump out uh any comments that we would like to
037talk about we should be talking about I don't want to hog everything but I read it a lot if few few times um I think some members of the board would want some um professional development uh in in in areas that we deal with yes yes there was a interest in um professional development expressed on on the comments on the last page um how about um trust there were there were a couple of comments regarding trust how about trust yes well it's that Collective we that kind of bothers me we have found where did that come from we have found that's the Royal we yeah it's I think um this is the time to stop and say well that it did surface it surfaced on a couple of the comments so when we set when
038we to uh set the goals and in the next few minutes when we start talking about board goals that might be something to think about okay um there's another word respect I saw the word respect in the comments you're very quiet I think that has goes hand in hand with the trust issue okay okay um on a separate element okay uh there was uh discussion on the back um identifying the challenges facing your District what was your common thread there what's the common thread growth growth yeah and from everything that I've learned over the past few months uh you definitely um have a challenge ahead with the growth in the in the community um I think that would be something uh board considers as well as your District when we move into the district goals
039that might be a consideration there um funding funding an issue yes always inadequate state aid funding yeah well we have a solution I guess never never get through interesting interesting comment or concept it rolls back to years ago and well it seems to me that that you know while we're always hopeful that the state aid situation will improve and we're continuing to work with our legislators yes we the only thing we can count on is what we know and what we have that's true basically no no state aid it would be an improvement and I'm sure be welcomed by every board member here but we have to function on what we know and right now it's only talk right right but it is helpful it is helpful when districts put together those resolutions to go
040forward to say hey hey guys it's it's just not working you know the pendulum and then the answer to that is to swing the pendulum all the way to the other side well there's got to be something in the middle that will help this situation but funding was addressed here uh throughout the document um what else when you were going through it what were some of the thoughts that you had as you're trying to answer some of these questions how difficult they are to answer without W with us being truly a board member who sits on the outside of the whole process and yet we're expected to fully understand all the internal workings of the process so it for me I find it extremely frustrating to try to do an evaluation like this and I
041just ass soon make sure we hire the right people and we have the right people in place that we can trust to do their jobs effectively and and lead the district so I find it really hard to go through the whole exercise and and give a lot of critique when we're I am personally just not involved in data day operation of the school district right and and that's a good thing you should not a good thing it's absolutely a good thing think I put that in one of my notes as a reminder that we are supposed to be on the outside but the the board itself as a governing body I mean we talk about plan uh we talk about policy we talk about oversight and that's critical and uh the where you talk about
042um the board governance the better your board governs the higher your student achievement that's a true formula it's a true formula Mary if if I can touch on that because I think it's important what we're saying um and and I'm going to go back to the request for professional development discussion I think sharing information sharing knowledge uh amongst us all is because nobody knows everything is is uh very important and and for example we have to be careful not to uh micromanage I know that was something that was being brought up uh it was we don't go and uh observe teachers and rate teachers or rate principles we have administrators that are uh very qualified to to do that um so that's something that we have to really share that that's you know what is
043our job what is our responsibility well not so much responsibility but what what can we do do what can't we do what shouldn't we do as board members even though we may want to we can't you know and I think that maybe all Ro roles and responsibilities and visiting those roles and responsibilities in in a workshop setting where you can talk about some of the well what if what ifs what ifs are always good to use as examples and to work through because many times you're uncertain as to whether are you doing the right thing are you making a mistake are you overstepping well the easy answer to that the golden rule is no surprises you talk with either depending on how your board operates you either talk with through your board president or you
044go to your superintendent that's your chain of command okay yeah Tom I see one comment here that kind of jumps out of me about you know somebody mentioned micromanaging before it says that they feel there are too many substandard teachers in Monroe at the high school level I don't think we do enough to weed out the bad teachers at the high school level that is definitely not a board function as far as I'm concerned sure true that it's not a board function um it's it's something that if that concern if that concern uh is there that would be a call to the superintendent um I have concerns I have concerns because can I come in and sit down and talk with you um the communication with board members and administration is critical in the functioning
045of your District uh if you if you one person did come back with with that comment and and if you're feeling that that's the time to go and talk with the superintendent because that in itself is not a board is not a board role um sure ask yes I'm sorry comment on that yes please um depending on how Mr Ryback would like the communication to go whether to go through him or to come directly to me I certainly would welcome that uh there were a couple comments that being one Tom that you mentioned that uh jumped out at me and I was like wow that this is the first time really hearing it or seeing this and that's something that I I treat very seriously I would want to address that and know if there
046was a specific concern uh with you know an individual uh teaching member or staff member and certainly like the opportunity to you know to address that and to look at all the data and everything else involved in that so yeah and like I say Communications and visiting with roles and responsibilities we talk a great deal about Communications and the more you communicate the better functioning board you become okay there was another one in that was uh it's under recognizing that our board's highest priority is to improve student achievement what are three major challenges currently facing our district now that true that is part of the New Jersey school board's U form but one of the comments said um there was an objection to the way the question was written and it said this is what
047New Jersey school boards believes to be the highest priority for Monroe Township and then it goes on the comment goes on that says student achievement is not addressed in mission statement or the district vision statement and I was somewhat confused by that um because reading your vision statement and your mission statement uh certainly it involves student achievement in order to deliver I mean that's the business that we're in so that's why that statement is written that way but I'm I'm not quite sure why that is why that comment came follow it seems to be some maybe that person took it literally uh you know the mission statement says you know to provide to receive prepare students to receive exemplary education clearly involved in that is student achievement student achievement but it states clear yeah so
048I I mean and and these these in themselves are they can introduce discussion I don't think that there's much discussion coming from these tonight I just had just had a question I mean one of the things that I I know um as an evaluator in my in my job that an evaluation should never be a surprise that to me has always been my Mantra um because if it's anything on an evaluation is a surprise we're missed we've missed the point of the evaluation um and unfortunately there are some things that are a surprise to me so to me that means that we as a board are not doing our job to communicate the issues with each other and that to me is a concern and that's a very very good observation because agreed when when
049we do evaluations and I'm sure that this is true although I have not worked in a in a a classroom uh I'm sure that if a teacher is not performing uh the first time they hear about it is not at their first assessment or their first observation um in in my world uh your employees if they're not functioning or they're not doing something correctly they're going to hear about it at the time of the incident not waiting until their semiannual or their annual review so Point well taken is you don't expect to see surprises on these forms you should be talking about it as they come up um on a day day-to-day monthly basis yeah well okay the thing about surprises or having these discussions I mean really then anything that's on this evaluation should
050be discussed in public and it's difficult I think for board members but I mean none of these issues are like closed session issues so PE we should be discussing them at a public meeting because we're transparent correct so but I think that there is a human reluctance to discuss some of these things in public so there's a little bit of a difficulty there I mean I don't have a problem discussing these kinds of things in public however it may seem like oh will it embarrass the board it'll embarrass the district um you know there's a there's a tough line in some cases it it appears that it's one individual has this feeling about this so that if that discussion is held with the administration um that may not that may dispel that observation well that
051that's my point it shouldn't be held in in with one person and first of all it doesn't matter if it's just one person one person is as important as a whole in my opinion so if someone has these feelings I think we should all you know you know at least listen to them and and and discuss their Merit not say oh they don't you know I think respectfully I would like to discuss the Merit of anyone's feelings but but the point is if if we discuss these kinds of things they probably should be held at a public meeting and that's usually frowned upon even by school boyss well so where there's a little bit of a conundrum there but well training training is it can be done one one um training can be done on
052one one on one training so in other words training to change somebody's mind no no sometimes it's training it's a training that uh helps someone understand the process that's being used that's uh and we do train individually so or you can train as we're doing tonight this is in public session sure so okay um did you the strength of the board as a result of this the strength what's your biggest strength what do you believe your biggest strength is I think it's evident that there's a lot of board members that feel very positive about the collaborative effect collabora yes and there's actually a comment here about the the the the board president um enhancing that collaborative effect so that's that's very impressive that was a that was more of a theme that was more of
053a theme throughout the document um if you take a look to just take a look at the the charts uh chart one that shows the board ratings as compared to the board's uh value assignment to each of those elements um chart two shows issue the board to individual and chart three is a comparison between last year and this year okay there any questions on that data okay any additional comments on the form before we move to board goals okay um you have do they have do you all have copies of of the this year's board goals I don't think so oh it was it was placed on the table right over there then yes I do I have an extra sheet no I I didn't realize that that's what that sheet was I'm sorry yes
054I it only one sheet I got it he was waiting to do that okay to have 100% participation on the board's self AAL and the superintendent's evaluation we get it nope prob we had 90% though right you you had you did very well I was going to say I'm teasing with you because you did you did really well this is difficult you are volunteers you're giving so much of your time and this is not this isn't such an easy process so you had close to 100% you really did okay um to provide support for the board approved plan for enrollment growth and Facilities needs once the plan is developed and moved forward um on that what do you think we don't have a plan yet yeah I would just like to remind the board on
055that one when this was prepared the the enrollment plan that the board had was to redistrict and um and that was implemented this past September okay so it so that has been other plan well that's the beauty of a plan you go to the next plan I I'd like to to reiterate what Mr Gorski said I think the um despite even some of the differences in how to proceed or or some subjective issues um that the board worked very well to redistrict it was a very strenuous um process uh emotionally and for the administration it was very very difficult um but it succeeded um you know nothing's perfect so I'm sure there are some people who feel that it it didn't go over well but it worked um and it was smooth relatively smooth we
056only had some minor busing issues so I think that we succeeded as a board but certainly the administration exceed exceeded expectations because they got us through and to to talk about the enrollment and growth facilities I know there's been some comment about not having a specific plan but but the board as well as the administration um had a a very difficult time and we talk about data and getting the right data getting the appropriate and accurate data to go through and devise a plan and we have been styed in many occasions by not having the right uh U information and we got the information most recently so not to have a specific plan uh I think has nothing to do with the the board the board has been rigorous the Administration has spent countless hours
057on trying to get things worked out we have um Community involvement I think it's been very very good so not having a plan per se doesn't mean that the work wasn't done and that things aren't in place I I just think given the obstacles uh that were not in the power of the board of the administration I think we do have a plan I think we've moved very closely to getting it set so I think we achieved is that something that is since we were addressing enrollments throughout the uh um the report is that something that we would consider as a continuing board goal for the coming year I don't know if you do you want to rewrite yeah and and and one more comment about that um specifically for the for the public since
058this is being recorded um the the development plan this I think this board and the administration worked very hard to get the accurate data and we and there were with Community involvement and board members and this Administration the the district Administration we actually got the state because we were told that the state used out out dated data and that was the only thing that they were allowed to consider we fought to change that so not only did did we stay with our goal and and and get through that but we actually changed the um standard for the state at least for for our district to use the right data so I think that that may be something that most people wouldn't even realize but that makes an enormous difference going forward in in getting the
059right information in order for us to provide the right facilities for our students so again that's sort of under the radar but that was an enormous task and and I I think as an organization and and and with the help of very very um committed people in the community we were able to change the nature of the formula in order to get a more accurate picture of what we need going forward so again I'd like to add that to our go I like to say very well said and and um to highlight the the difficulty in in change in general because there's always opposition to change and and to uh to bring this out in the open the inequity in using the you know the the kind of information and formulas that the state uh
060has been using I think was a big step forward for this District so that we were not bound to use the rodu survey to me just to mention one that would if we did use it would definitely impact negatively in whatever plans we we would be bringing forward okay that's that's great but we still will still need yes this is a continuing continuing okay um review the board committee organization and structure processes um I'm sorry I didn't hear what you said uh review the board committee organization and structure processes we did that you did that's that's completed yes we did that that's the reason we take a look at these is to see if you want to do the continuing into next year all right so the other part you were going to think about
061uh what you would like to consider as goal for the coming year thoughts well how about we made mention of um board training how about training um that's an interesting thing is and I don't know that we should know about individuals because I that again that's objective is every board member certified to be certified on for the year that they're there that every board member should have the certification some mandated mandated certification does someone check that that's what I'm saying there have been years though that that some board members have not fulfilled the training obligations yes Nancy tle faroh and I um spend a lot of time monitoring M the board members required training and we prompt board members um and offer courses through school boards and other means to satisfy them there's Online requirements
062uh that could make it easier and um everybody to my recollection has met those requirements except for maybe certain instances where somebody was resigning from the board um that's the only one that those are those are the mandated trainings the gov one the gov two the gov three all three are taken in your first term uh go four is the first year of all subsequent uh terms so uh it's also monitored by New Jersey school boards uh we run the report we just ran a report on 30 June and uh that report those individuals who had been reminded several times um they were forwarded onto the ethics commission uh which is where that report goes um but the mandated training um the training that I'm referring to is more um uh either board collective training
063uh there was some indication in the report that finance that you might like to have more knowledge of uh the finance and how to get through the finance reports and that um and I'm sure that workshop for that uh Finance um at a sure what you're asking for yeah I take days there's there's any there's several different levels that could be addressed but um also uh there was ethics uh there were a couple of things on ethics um I'm sure you have in-house attorney right you have an in-house attorney and and school boards also can can assist with that I mean we have we have an Ethics program that we do annually with our boards um and in recent years we've been traveling with an in-house attorney because um the laws associated with confliction and
064volunteerism and all kinds of that kind of stuff I've gotten so complex that we travel with an attorney now um but maybe ethics all right um what else I think that's roles and responsibilities did you want that one okay all right well is that going to all go in one like I think at least minimum requirements the mandatory minimum requirements should be satisfied for each board member first you know well you say well no that that H that has to be in order to satisfy your role as a board member that must be done so okay yeah have about a goal to attend one training session in addition to the mandated training for each board member anyone else well are we putting I I like the idea of the work the financial Workshop is that
065that that we all attend a workshop for budget issues I don't know when there school budget 101 I don't know if want all of us I think it should be a choice okay so if individuals okay that's fine maybe other people have weaknesses in other areas that they want to look at I think that's why I said if generally if each board member to were attend one training session in addition to the mandated training of their choice because anything that you're going to learn you're going to learn better if you picked it are you going to are you going to turn key back to you're going to turn key back to your board the individuals you mean bring the training back to yeah do a workshop here for the board members they do that in
066schools a lot train the trainer um I just want to be clear one thing what we're doing now is uh basically brainstorming and you're making a list of ideas this isn't necessarily going to be the final product I just want to be clear of that yeah right um so what did you say Finance ethics and roles and responsib respons responsibil there's legal I mean there's tons yeah there's yeah legal is a good one too oh yeah it's good to know about it's not going to be all of these obviously you just want to take it quick going to an organiz going to a meeting um not a meeting going to a uh a district uh meeting with school board's uh organization oh County County there you go County meeting all right County meeting anyone else
067did you want to write a turnkey information down or turn key for the other board members you think individual training okay these are all right what that would be is a global training goal um broken down to board and broken down to individuals and what I'm hearing is that perhaps the board would like an overview yes I think this is related maybe where to where the direction you're going Mary but uh I don't know if all the board members are aware of all the training opport um the training opportunities afforded to them through New Jersey school boards either online or in person and the other possibility of uh you coming to a board meeting and providing training so when you know the the just to mention of uh all the board members you know there's
068the mandated to requireed training I get that but then if you go over and above that like Tom suggested uh maybe just again I'm not sure if everyone has that the list of all the trainings that are available uh if it was in the packet that I passed out the last time however what I will do is when I get back to my office hopefully tomorrow I'll I'll send it out to you it's a just a listing of all of the courses and there are courses that we can bring to you um sometimes it's a special meeting sometimes we tack it on to the board meeting it's very difficult to tack onto a board meeting because you'll you'll wind up here until you know so but you you make that decision okay there also webinars
069that website we have just go some someone just mentioned legal twice a year we do legal updates do you go to those the legal updates or I I guess not because haven't but our our board attorney has yeah that's what I was going to say she Mary probably goes I've been to the legal ones they're excellent yeah yeah and I look forward to those because it just as a lay person it just brings you up to date so and each and every one of you should be if if you received the emails over the weekend each and every one of you should be receiving emails like five a week from New Jersey school boards uh you get a lot of like the Schoolboard notes comes out um there's sustainable Schools is coming out uh soon
070you will be getting um Future Ready schools will be coming out at know if you know about that that has to do with the technology um Future Ready um there's all kinds of information that comes through it's almost an information overload real including the legislative updates yes that'll come out as well yes and we have an app that you can actually put on your phone if you so choose and we will let you know the moment a legislative update comes out but um but what's that app called I'll send you I'll send you to with the instructions um I have to do that I'll do that tomorrow I have to do that for my office because I can't remember it um all right yeah Mr I just wanted to remind the board of the um
071accountability Act and the travel regulations it it probably would be advantageous to have a brochure of events UPF front so that they can get board approved for the travel costs and the event costs in advance because the retroactive approach that prohibited usually they try and send that information out soon enough but the yes you're right the the late registrations don't always work if you're going to uh apply for travel I just want to uh just another thought on the type of um workshops that we may be interested in and that's um using data uh you know we're having all this uh data that we're using in the schools you know to uh take a look at instruction and successes I think uh it might be advantageous for the board to be able to understand this
072data and and and see you know so we could see how it's being used and understand the importance of it yes yes depending on every District that would be internal to your District that type of training because every district is doing different things I mean they're they're using data they're managing by data they're making decisions through data which is a concept that's used in the technology world all the time um but uh each district does it a little bit differently so that's something that would be trained internal to your District um how I'm sorry yeah how about training on the the main source of what finances the school something to do with property taxes the real estate market because we're often told that we can't get um for example funding state aid okay and because
073the community is too affluent then we don't know who and how all this data is collected okay and when you have to make decisions on expanding a school and stuff like that you need this information and there a formula that fills about a page um that they come up with those numbers but I guess that could be something that could be put together um the funding sources and how that's derived was that at the training that we went to the first training we this wasn't I wasn't addressed it was one question I had brought up they don't seem to touch on that issue okay I don't know if I have anything in house on that I will have to look is that part of I think the gentleman's referring to something as broad as the
074school funding uh Reform Act of 2008 right but keep in mind that the department of educ a finance and budget Department can change the laws affecting each Year's budget depending on revenues and and so on so quite often they deviate from the school funding Reform Act to suit this year's distribution of money well I mean that's that's good but I'm also talking about every Community is different and our community has to fund our school yes and we should have a good understanding of what that Community is capable of funding so for example um when we had the budget meeting earlier in the year we were given a certain amount that we were eligible to uh referendum right it's a figure borrowing capacity borrowing capacity and does that take into account other entities like local government
075the open space uh group from borrow because they're also borrowing so if everybody's borrowing are we looking at the same because it all coming from the same Source the property taxes are we looking at that you know if I can I just like to make a comment Mr Russo I I think that having good communication and then we're certainly improving on that with the community would certainly give us some information feedback as far as what the community feels on uh about taxes and and allows us to work together to to uh formulate budgets and ideas that will um you know reflect the concerns of the community we also have to worry about uh you know getting the best possible Ed Ed ation for the for our students so I think that um what you are
076saying uh is certainly developing a sensitivity to what the community's needs are and I think that we're we certainly have that our our budget this year certainly reflects that uh which we're all very proud of and um I think we're going to continue with that in the future you know that's our budget you know we don't operate in a vacuum so if we're borrowing so much money on referendum and the township is the same thing and open space is doing the same you end up problem Mr bra oh thank you you're welcome picking up on the best education for our students recent the recent cover of consumers report says I wasted my life going to college and they talk about the debt college debt and it's very low I think it would be important if
077we had a a good strong followup on high school graduates and from that review our curriculum so that we know we're training the students for what they're doing we quite often hear that gee we're doing very well 85% of our kids are going to college I I don't know that that's always true but it makes you feel good I so I would suggest the board gold to do uh a comprehensive follow-up study on graduates and from that develop a current appropriate curriculum I think also I'd like as a board goal that we get together with perhaps the community college in Mera County uh middle sex County I'm sorry and perhaps they would share some expertise in that they would teach some courses in our high school so that we don't have to teach English for
078example if they came in and taught English to Our seniors those seniors might be able to get the the the community college credit and at the same time get credit for our graduation I think we have to have an imagination in this day and age and stop talking about gee you know we can talk about money all you want but the fact of the matter is kids don't vote and the only time anybody talks about any the only time politicians talk about money is during an election year that's now is this captured you uh bringing Community College courses into the high school okay uh brainstorming I just want to follow up on what what Mr brond said because he's he's absolutely correct I mean I read that article too it was very interesting and it's
079it's it's very unfortunate that no matter what major it seems uh students have in college most of them walking I'm walking out with debt of like $60,000 $80,000 you know um we have we really need to prepare our kids for the world of work and college so that they could be successful in college and successful in work using Community colleg is a good idea I was reading something about the using community colleges where uh they help prepare uh students for the world of work uh you know giving them the skills maybe they have Partnerships with uh with industry so that these these students can come out and go right into a paying career I hate to use the word job because I think we need more careers for for people than jobs um but but
080I think that the unfortunate thing is is that uh no matter what the major is they're coming out of there with a lot of debt that's uh that could be expanded yes Partnerships with not only not only the universities and colleges but also your business and and our Township you have a wealth of business that could help I well as I'm driving through I you know it appears that you do it appears don't aren't you heavy in pharmaceutical well I would if I could add um I I if not Monroe Township in the surrounding area in the surrounding area even Beyond middle sex uh County but certainly that's something that I would would like to talk about as we get into District goals but the Partnerships with uh corporations uh they don't have to be
081necessarily in Monroe Township but certainly there's enough corporations and we have I don't have this for a fact but from my qualitative my informal discussions with some of the parents uh I think we have enough parents that work in some of these industries that could uh help guide us in uh making connections with some of the corporations and if I could uh comment Mr Mr bran I think you bring up an an excellent point about tracking our students and seeing what they're doing and how you know how we prepared them uh it's it's not always easy to do but it's certainly right but it's certainly something that we can strive to do um well I think it's important that if any of these goals require financing that we come up with a budget as well
082as the goal I think things is excellent point on that um and some of the uh as far as let's say middle sex County College professors teaching in our school uh that also is a as a possibility um right and I I'm I don't want to assume but I I think you know that you know a lot of our high school students do have that opportunity currently to uh take college courses but it's certainly something we could expanded upon okay I'm a little confused are we talking board goals here or District goals because we're we're a little we're a little bit over into District goals okay of the the goal the board goals are typically how you will conduct board operations uh what what the board goals are for the coming year as far as
083the board I think for board goal I I can't see from here but I'd like to go back to board goals justed working on that uh I think we need to uh continue word something that shows our support for uh a Bo board approved plan for the growth uh and facility needs uh reiterating go two from last year yes because go to from last year was really considering something else we did it but keep doing get it rightly I think we'd be remiss and not yeah well it's not finished yet it's right right just to if I could just address at the July 27th meeting or 28th um the plan right now is to is to present the plan to the board at the July 2 I think it's the 27th right meeting uh we
084have a meeting actually with our buildings and grounds committee next this coming Tuesday where we're going to present that plan and um as Michelle if you you very stated very well earlier you know the data was changing and especially with the affordable housing and we were trying to regroup and and have all that uh but I'm hopeful that we'll present a plan that the board will approve at the July 27th meeting so the goal would be now really taking that plan to the public right and addressing it to to Garner support for that plan I can't see what you wrote here I just said repeated from uh 15 number two repeated the next phase of it the it's not the same yeah it's different it's it's a different it's different so you need need to
085word it differently needs to be rewarded to um communication communicate plan how about that again she's just taking notes we're going to we're going to find two I think we have to use the word expansion plan how would we it almost word it the same as last year no well that was based on um it's based at a previous meeting um Administration was directed to come up with a plan to deal with the student enrollment growth and the enrollment projections and the current facilities and future facility needs okay so I think the goal might be to um to evaluate uh and adopt the administrative plan for um enrollment growth and Facilities okay because the process as I understand it and as has been directed to the superintendent and an Administration is to take this now
086to the subcommittees of the board and begin there and refine the plan and then at some point uh bring in experts such as architect Bond counselor engineer financial advisor um that once it goes through building grounds Transportation finance committee perhaps curriculum committee uh that the plan is well thought out and refined and ready for board discussion breaking it down into smaller elements that the global plan yes yes um evaluate and and adopt the growth plan is that what we the growth plan enrollment growth enrollment growth and Facilities okay well okay would it would it be appropriate to put a date on that that we're aiming for December for a referendum that's the first one isn't it yeah um Mr B and Mr Gorski can speak to this the department of ID to my understanding needs
087about a six-month window before we can even uh before they'll allow us to even go out for a referendum so they give us five dates throughout the year if we're working backward uh December is too soon if we looked at even June we that would put us maybe in that September October range in there um but but I agree we need to to move on that because uh we have to adhere to that six-month window so the longer it gets pushed back you know the further uh potential referendum will you know the date will be there's there's statistics as to when you placed your your referendum um two success rates the administration is very aware of that and has you notified uh all of us of of those limits okay yeah strategic so we have
088three you have so far right now you have two you have the training component and you have the uh evaluation and adopt the en uh enrollment um growth in facilities uh I think tracking the followup of the alumni I don't think that really counts as a board goal I think that's what think that that that really is a district goal and maybe we could pull on that a little bit because that's that's really will give you give you a lot of good data um but also the communication okay um we need another yeah Tom one of the things that I I noticed from the board um uh eval was um some some people not even just that from meetings um I know know that I don't think we're quite there yet with a cohesive document
089system for disseminating the information to the board um we've gone back and forth I mean Google Docs is great but quite frankly it's not updated I I can't there's nothing up there anymore it's like stopped so I don't know whether to look at Google Docs I don't know whether to look at my packet uh it's not up there really I okay I'm sorry I thought it was kept up no it's not it's not organized easily now we just got this school leader magazine and there's something in there called board docs that is a service um that looks interesting it could be too much for us I don't know I but I I would like to maybe use that as a goal I had written it down to implement a cohesive document system that all members
090are comfortable with and have archive data easily obtainable excellent board goal I a great I think that would include more than Google do I think um like policy for example everything everything just make so much easier the notely it's it's data management right um and you take a look and you have naming conventions and you you uh your naming conventions are intuitive you're able to search uh and I think that that's one thing I'm not I haven't sat through the training on the board docs yet that's brand new It looks interesting but uh they're trying to do that because school districts do have a considerable amount of difficulty because because the data is all over so all right so instead of me rewriting that do you have that Tom oh yeah okay you know what
091if you number two number two is this your only copy yeah but I have another one at home but that's fine all right let me just do this so everyone can see it um what did you say Implement a cohesive data system that data management data management system document management document management sorry I have data on my mind because I have one I don't want to mention I believe there's medication for that yes thank you welcome [Music] all right so what we have is a training component we have the increased enrollment component and then we have how about process and procedures documentation process and procedures expand that one a little bit so that you're looking at um your overall operation yeah sure okay and training for it if necessary yes oh you know that's that's
092something that is frequently forgotten because oh it's just a filing system it's more than a filing system well that's why it's important that everybody is comfortable with it and the only way for everyone to get comfortable with it is for that training uh component right it's got to be a little ongoing too you know learning is ongoing Comfort takes time you can't just have one session sou Comfort takes the more you use it the more comfortable you feel okay how's that he's having a good time up there who's not having a good time I'm enjoying Mr R ruty's comments just I warn you I'm just getting he's on fire tonight on fire moving over to this side okay board goals District go District gos District district goals we finished board goals are we happy with
093those yes they'll be Rewritten I'll pass them up and then you guys can massage them all right District the partnering we University if if I could um I think it would align very well with the board goal as far as looking at the student enrollment uh to have a goal that that basically is to take this message this plan once it's presented to the board and approved by the board and um you know whether it's at the July meeting the August meeting whenever that's approved and that's just going to be the beginning the next phase then will be really going out having Town Hall meetings talking to the community going to the Senior Communities um you know back to school night out there really as I said ear you're gonnering support so I see that
094District goal could align very well with the board goal if the board you know agrees with that yeah say something along the lines of uh communicating expansion plans throughout throughout the community right I I say expansion plans I'm not sure I like that word that might be well we could Wordsmith it but the general idea would be to U facility plans I facility plan right yeah facility exactly facilities plan to address the the student enrollment growth if if the board's job is to evaluate and adopt an enrollment growth and Facilities plan then the district goal should be to implement those facili plans not just communicating not just communicating it Implement okay uh yeah that's probably it's it's over that's going to go over your one-year period of time it it'll carry from year to year
095so um yeah well sometimes you need long-term goals this this is I think I think it's that's a very important aspect that we have to mention okay implementation is a very broad um good term to use because there's so M much uh different components of this referendum project if we want to call it that at this point that it will involve Community involvement certainly from an early stage it will involve applications to Department of Education um um it's some marketing so many different steps and there are phases to implement implementation so yes yes absolutely so it could it is continuous and actually the the goal could be broken down to the phasing almost the same as you would do in your strategic plan right um just break it down that way um okay what else
096thoughts we had a uh a special ed external program review done last year and I'd like have a District goal to prepare a longterm goal action steps or an action plan and Implement after board approval based upon the special education external program review based on external the special education external program review I mean it may not be feasible for all of their recommendations so maybe the administration should recommend what they feel will have the yeah yeah Absol good point Joel prioritize and even if it's a multi-year plan say here's year one yep here's the action plan to run it out here's your two absolutely but part of the reason why we're starting to get these studies is not just to have a study but to use use the information gleaned from the study and not
097all of it is pertinent to probably our curriculum or our our programs so the study is an overview and to to go through it and determine what we can use and what we can't but we should not just have studies and and then not have and and sometimes there's no change right but if there is we we need to go forward with it and actually it's it's a great goal and just so you know we didn't just stop at the study we've already started that process uh but I would love I love that idea of I think we need continue ous review The Board needs to be updated it's it's an updating process on we spend money for this stuff or you or even if it's in-house that we do uh program reviews The Board
098needs to get updates and we need to have a again a Continuum of information so we when we make decisions every month there could be something in the agenda that actually relates to that so so we're not saying oh wait a minute I know we had a study but I I don't remember what the results were so yeah I think that's important Sometimes some districts have um with the administrator's report that's coming through they will thread sections of their report back to the action plan or the goal so that because sometimes the elements in that report you don't necessarily connect with with the goal and that helps you to also helps at the end of the year uh when you're trying to remember all of these different things it pulls it together for you and
099to Mr braverman's point and I don't know if number three lends itself to that but I think as a district goal we should have calendars of information you know like when when we when should we get information on something that we've uh uh voted on in the past so like some kind of calendar of review and again it could be fluid but at least we have an idea that at some point within the next three months or for example we're going to get a review of something we voted on three months ago if if it's you know if it requires that we have um I don't know if that was clear or not we have the the board calendar which deals with the routine um business of the district you to take that calendar and
100expand it to the reports if if you your study was due to come in on such and such you wanted to report out in three months but it does it gives you a definite flow to to the operations and um maybe how about over here the calendar okay um include include the calendar there while you're talking about a calendar I just think it might be important to um think about you know the kinds of things we're going to be getting reports on and the public will be getting reports on uh not of of course you know the the special ed audit of course is uh is something that's key here but in general the park exam any kind of standardized tests all of that information should be presented to us you know so we know
101when it's going to be presented and the community will know when it's going to be presented when you're I don't know is the park coming more consistently now I I it is because initially time per year yeah yeah and we do uh Dr aboc does a report in the fall and it depends on when the state releases the data that's really what holds us up to know it's hard for us to say in November I mean it used to be with New Jersey s we kind of knew November was the month that we did the the the report to the board and the community on student achievement based on New Jersey ask right Park it's we're getting a little bits of data we're not getting data so it's a little hard to tell but maybe
102instead of just keeping it to park if one of my goals is to increase the use of data of uh you know student achievement and that's not just park there's other types of data that we that we use and that we look at so perhaps um using uh data you know uh uh providing reports to the board and to the to the public on student achievement at different points through the year yeah actually actually have written it's like this looks like you read my paper here um oh Tom sorry I have this it says use targeted data to analyze and identify areas of opportunity to improve individual student achievement uh for example analyze the Benchmark data provided by the New Jersey doe from the uh 2016 administration of the park identify achievement G gaps and
103this this is what jumped out at me in our bardal there was a lot of notes in here about um inequities between teachers Etc and one way that I feel to um to close that Gap and that or that perception is to use the targeted data uh you know from just School level to school I think we've had this discussion in the past too um even a perceived uh achievement gap between schools in our district is a huge concern for parents and us as board members um so I would like to use the data um and I know Dr kak is is data driven also and I I think that um that would be one way of either denying or actually showing that there is this Gap and then coming up with an action plan
104uh of how we're going to correct that um and to Mr braverman's point I actually had written down also to ensure graduates are College and Career ready by establishing a post-graduate tracking program to measure success in postsecondary education now again I know it's difficult but that is something that might be a good District goal um yeah just uh with that Tom a couple things that we could could possibly use would be uh College boards is uh you know we can get some data from them um we can survey our students if we can get the information about where they've gone and if they respond and so we can certainly move in that direction um I can't guarantee 100% but I I certainly would be very interested in seeing the results of that data because really
105that's once they leave our district in 12th grade you know we may feel like we've prepared them but how do we really know so I love the idea of that um and I'll just have to be a little creative in finding out how to get that data um and hoping that you know students will respond to it and I mean you know emails everything changes so their contact information unless the the family has siblings still in the district we we'll we'll have to figure it out it's it's more right Joe's gonna go I was just wondering if um we could get data from the community colleges like you know there's this whole remediation thing that everybody's saying that we have students who need remediation when they go to Community College well it would be interesting
106to know how many m students went to Community College how many needed remediation how many didn't how many graduated in two years how many dropped out I think that would fall in line with tracking yeah students that data from middle sex County College would be interesting I can tell you that I got that data from Burlington Community College and it was interesting it was uh it was interesting so I would love to see how our students now middle sex County College I understand our students do much better but we can get that data uh because that's a local uh college so um we can certainly get that data and I and I think it'll it's an eyeopener when you when you look at that uh the number of students that are able to complete their
107their education in two years how many remedial courses they need that's very very interesting that that's an excellent point Mr Mayor I have to say and and what they told us we Mr Min and I attended governance three this year and one of the things that just scared the heck out of me was they said 70% of students going into college require remedial uh courses and that is telling me that we're not doing the job we need to be doing well could I caution on that I have an issue with that right blanket statement because a bunch of statistic it's not Monroe no but but part of the problem is when they use say that statistic they say you know 70% of kids going into Community College need remediation well the question is how many
108of those are recent College grads and how many have been out of school for three or four years and are going back to school and need remediation it's statistic you know I mean against Community College just College in general it was College in general I I can I it is even if even if you have that number I was going to say no matter what you know it's statistics but no matter what I think uh it it's alarming um to know that students who are graduating high school and I don't mean Monroe in general now uh have to take remedial uh courses uh I've I've read numerous articles that uh you know the colleges themselves feel like this isn't what we should be doing you know well that's and that's true I mean it's it's
109kind of interesting uh close to me I mean I had a student that went through 13 years of Spanish and Spanish Honor Society straight a whatever got to University and did not test out for Spanish too now there has to be something wrong there it's just so I mean I I I'm not sure about that statistic but they pulled it from somewhere there some kind of Disconnect there and I'm not saying like where is that disconnect everybody's blaming this high schools but right you know right could it be the problem with the college itself yes there's a disconnect there and I don't like to put the blame all on the no thank you Mr Mayor thank you so much for that because no I agree with Mr and if I could comment one of the
110things that I looked at and again it was another District but I would certainly love to look at it here as well and I've talked to our leadership team about this is the expectations of the County College how aligned are they to a K12 education so for instance there is a math test that acup Placer that you know that that students are expected to pass going into Community College not just middle sex Community a lot of colleges use that well most of the K to2 education has sh shifted to a common core to another area and that math entrance exam may not reflect what we've been teaching in K to2 so it sometimes it's it's incumbent upon the colleges to stay up to date with um making sure that their assessments accurately reflect what students
111are learning um and that's not just in math that's in other areas as well so Partnerships would be that much more Advantage advantageous if we if we uh talk and communicate more with the colleges as far as what we're doing come full C Dr kak I would just say don't forget Brookdale and Mercer I mean I know middle sex is our County but a lot of our students go to Brookdale and Mercer County as well so if you're going GA statistics you might want to okay out of them as well I mean I don't want to belabor this but I also would like to make sure that we don't look at this as a criticism or something against it you know using this data um as a criticism it's it's a it's a tool to
112make sure we're we're helping our students achieve that you know the minute we get our get concerned about oh my God we it might not be reflective of of Monroe um we sort of lose sight of what what the goal is and the goal is to get an and an accurate picture of what uh what our students are achieving or how we can help them so um but it's it's interesting because if the colleges have expectations is it because they have an older version of what what the um the global market needs or a newer version I mean so again we have to be careful of dumbing down the curriculum because we think the colleges are wrong or like who's what what is the real problem I think and that's like beyond the board right
113now but we again we need to be cognizant of what what the the full picture is and prepare our students globally but also I mean there's been some criticism of the way we're teaching right now and I know the method of teaching evolves over over time but you know we we may not be teaching the kids we may be teaching them to pass standardized test but we're not really teaching them to think so you really have to coordinate that that's the critical I'm only smiling because again I wrote down a whole I wrote down probably 20 different things but no there's actually 12 but um things that I that I would like to focus on this year and some of them will be on the district some of them would be actually um at a
114later point I would like to present as maybe Merit goals but but the dispositions or habits of mind of getting things to think critically and and using creativity that certainly fits in very well with that did you look at my notes Miss well and and just let me say this I'm going to do a feel-good statement that despite the evaluation where in in some people seemed a little critical of other board members this is the kind of thing that overall board members want student achievement we want to support the administration in its goals to do the right thing and as you can hear from uh Dr kak he's not just interested in scores and I'm honored that that he's not and I'm glad that we're having this discussion because we're having a discussion about doing
115the right thing for the students so I you know so I'm I'm patting ourselves on the back but also thanking the administration for this type of discussion so despite some of the little Snipes think that we're in the self- evaluation I think that the board is really looking for the right the the right thing to do you can see that yeah yeah yeah yeah if I can I I just want us to look at how many you know goals we have I and and consider whether we want more or or is that sufficient do we have five there I'd like to do one more now we might not take it but I'd like to do one more I'm thinking because of some of the things I've seen on on the board self- evaluation that perhaps
116we should have a district um survey like a a climate survey we learned that at school boards and I'm think an in an IND District in District yeah okay not a community survey but an IND District survey like of Administrators teachers that kind of thing yeah in spite of what New Jersey school board would say if I was a teacher leader that would be so skewed you have no idea well we would try we would try to have it where it's Anonymous so no one knows who it is and people look wouldn't matter we trust the teachers surveys um well okay school you know I'm just I'm just putting forward my training well you need more of it well thank you Mr braver I hopefully I'll be able to do another term where I'll learn
117even more uh District climate survey okay um those they're tough because of of the way you assemble and we do them we do them when we're doing the uh superintendent searches and we do them for strategic planning and they are very very difficult if they're not worded exactly correctly and people earn their livings writing surveys so um but oh we're a tough CR it's I was going to say we can handle it it's a it's a good it's a good tool to collect data particularly if it's done Anonymous I would ask Mr Gorski he's been here the long M has Monroe ever done a 2012 clment survey 2012 was the last one oh just four years ago oh okay was that before yeah that was just before the strategic planning I think that was Dr
118Hamilton was the superintendent yes and did you feel that that was a good use of time I mean when when this when the results were sort of compilated did certainly you could you could get benefit from from results it's nice safe answer I see politics in the future I've been here a long time that's why he's been here a long time in addition to his no right climate survey it is can I uh ask and I I respect that m m armia but um when we say School climate boy that covers such a broad area um I I think we you know I would are there underlying assumptions or thoughts of or areas that that you you have in mind uh because you you can Define climate in a in a multitude of ways well
119even well we've and and I think that this is just thrown out and we can hone it to something that works for everybody but like just one of the things that we've heard um parents and students bring up um information about how frightened the teachers are about uh the park situation and the the teachers feelings and yet no teachers came before the board so I would like a more accurate idea you know maybe we could put a question about park or the kind of testing or even the kind of do teachers feel that they're teaching to ATT test or they're teaching to education um you know just how how student how teachers feel in general maybe morale issues so I don't have anything specific but those are the things that come to mind and if
120it's truly an anonymous um piece and that and that would be the that might be the difficult part because I know if if you if the teachers respond to surveys there may be a number or something that identifies them and I wouldn't want that to be the case we might have to just have an outside or a third-party uh Survey System um to give a fair estimate of of what's going on so I I'd like to ask uh maybe Mr Gori remember and really reflects on what Mr Braven said earlier what would the cost be for a survey like that well I think what whatever we decide we're going to go the costs of everything there not just this there's a lot of new tools that make it cost effective like Survey Monkey for example
121or for a couple thousand you could get a good um temperature reading of of but it's the questions though it's like the survey B is the instrument to deliver the survey it's designing the questions and that's really what Mary had Mary gasman had said that is crucial I I agree with that you have to design those that people make their living doing that uh and I know from going through research courses and you know how you design those questions is so critical and so important um but yeah maybe a third party or you know I don't know yeah and then those the third parties get a little pricey when you're asking them to design it you know based on well now is that a district goal or a board goal because I think that are
122we asking the the district to come up with the questions or is that something that maybe could be uh for example maybe the curriculum committee um could come up with a set of questions then that would then be approved by the board for the climate survey um because I don't know which would be I don't know which you know which way say I don't I don't know I that would be my opinion and is that that would be a district goal um as a as a board goal you you might say that you you know you want that to happen um you want to understand the climate in your District um that's okay but to actually conduct the survey and get that job done that's going to be uh on the district overall the board
123shouldn't really be involved in that um you can say that you want to Target curriculum uh or you it's a morale if if you're concerned about morale if you're concerned about the testing you can provide suggestions as to what you're concerned about But there again your administrators need to make the the final decision on well I I thought again having gone to training with with school boards um it was one of their suggestions I'm sure there's some kind of um template or something that school boards that's a question I'm going to have for them tomorrow because I haven't heard that of although I take that back I mean they're big on surveys we run them all the time uh but I don't know for sure where that was okay I'm sure I'm sure they would
124have um advice yeah actually at the meet I guess because we went to the same uh governance 3 they actually said a they had a listing of the uh symptoms or the uh uh what a high achieving School District looks like and one of those uh traits that a high achieving School District or high achieving uh School Board had was that they did a climate survey and that's so that's I think that's probably was okay okay it's a governance three folks okay um I just have a question about the district survey like what talking to the microphone oh sorry what would we be looking for specifically with a district like what would be our goal with the district survey well I think we just established that we uh that needs to be discussed and we
125need some advice from school and I actually will um I I'll try to get the background data on that because I do not have that um and get that to you then you can you can decide and discuss it at your next meaning as to whether um taking taking the temperature of your district is never a bad thing it's just how it's taken you know because you're doing good and you don't want to do real I was think the same no side bars um I'm going over here I'm glad the microphone wasn't close enough didn't okay how are we doing um what we have is the Partnerships with the university and Industry um to implement the uh facilities plans and that needs to be all of these need to be expanded and have words wrapped
126around them but the concepts um prepare long-term plan based on uh the special ed external review that and that's understood okay data analysis we want to see more done with data and we want to see more reports come back on the data analysis um and we'd like to come up with some way to track graduates through University and Community College now um when when we say at the University I mean there several different ways that you can do that but that's that's a big that's a big element okay and then the the district climate survey Miss Gman what's the number of goals that you have up there six six okay I just you know uh in addition to the other running the district and well that's what I was just going to go there because
127you have to remember that when we set these goals there's there's day-today stuff that has to be done you know so if you had to prioritize these what would be number one on the Hip Parade number two number two which and what's could you please read number two facilities that's the implementing the facilities plan okay okay let probably draw it out you put it on the other side like on the right side yeah okay okay um number two can't see maybe could could you please uh read the goals again so that everyone sure knows what they are partner with University and industries those Partnerships investigating to set up as many of those as we can uh prepare the long-term plan based on a special ed external review data analysis that's looking at all data uh
128tracking the graduates through University and the district climate survey so what would be your second highest priority number four number four the data analysis I say number three because we already spent 50,000 on this on this study and I think you know we need to move on that before the data gets stale okay can I ask a question about that cuz it's just something that's I'm questioning is that really a district goal should that not just be assumed and I hate to use that word of course but should that not just fall into what is now administration's followup on a project that cost 50,000 and came back with results not 50 but okay just 30 this is community that's right I think it was 30 30 something but but wouldn't you automatically take that information
129and now go forward with it in the next year or two yeah I mean almost every goal is you know are things that we would do in process but part of the I think the goal is setting it and saying this is what we prioritize and this is what we want to see to come back um like I said just informally sitting down before like at a different time by myself I came up with 12 things easily that I want to address could see that as being an actual District goal and not just something that should happen anyway anyway I could go either way with it I mean I'm going to do I'm just curious I'm going to do it it can it can certainly be a district goal uh if you want to Market
130and then I think as you go through and Mark a couple other ones this may come back again if we still end up with five or six I mean what what's the number that we're looking at for district goals cuz last year there were three great but he was a beginner I was a trained professional they didn't tell you that part of the deal he already knows how long it takes him to get home at 10 o'clock at night I was going to say home okay so if that is truly a district gold then then I would argue that data analysis should be three then right if it's not going to be two it should be three yeah you can combine kid you what number four should be number three should be number three right
131yeah okay uh what about your Partnerships yeah that's important that one can I um comment on that one as I mentioned before there are mer goals that I want to present so I would like to see that goal either in a district or either way I think that's an important goal and the reason why I'm bringing that up is if there's another goal that you want to put as a district goal I will certainly resurface that goal because I I think that's very very important it's something I really want to move in that direction well I think we might be able to say that we would support partnering with universities M but you're implementing it well yeah well no this is not a board goal this is a district goal I know that right I
132thought you said you weren't sure whether it should be a board or District goal no I'm just saying be a mar District but but my so my point is I I think it's a very important goal and it's something I definitely want to pursue and if you're if you're looking at the five goals here and say you're not sure whether uh maybe another goal should be included I'll include that goal either in either place but if we okay and hate to get down to the nitty-gritty in terms of money but if we if we include it as a district goal it's part of what our expectations are for a general contractual yearly um work product but if we put it as a miracle then there's there's money uh attached to it correct yes okay okay
133I I was just at just an assign I don't want to take too much time on this but I was at a council meeting recently a Township council meeting and I question some of the professionals as to why they were getting paid extraordinary money after their original contract and I'm not saying so I have to be careful because I made a particular statement about certain things so I i' like to understand what would be the board's expectation of of a superintendent on a on a regular basis contractually with their yearly income and then the difference between so I don't know just and just so the miracle no reason I'm bringing that up as it is part of the contract that we discussed and um my understanding would be that America go is like over and
134above what would normally exactly so my my question would be if we if we went in that direction why would that not be some some is it unreasonable to have that as an expectation ordinarily for a superintendent it is it is above and beyond is consider beond the typical programming you know where you're reworking where you're reworking but out there um okay I th the board this is the board's decision as to where they put them um such a go I'm sorry how would you meas this whether you whether you've gotten your Partnerships or whether whether you have even if you were at the point that you were in contracts with them uh you're talking you've got maybe a course has come in on University you have that information so it's it is measurable and
135that would have to be outlined in the action plan a smart go how do you measure it and then it would have to be outlined consider successful with you know to what degree I mean that that would all be outlined in in detail yeah the actually that one's that one's more measurable than some others some some are really tough to measure um the achievement on them but are we saying that we do you want to include that here as a priority in your District goals include what is a priority number one number one are we going to are we going to move it off to to be resurfaced as as what Merit goal Merit goal I think we have to be clear what we're talking about well I so wait a I'm a little confused
136here because I thought the contract was remaining unchanged the second year right then uh we have a merit goals in the contract in in the first initial contract in the contract we made yes the one we made a year ago yes okay do we have a copy of that yes I don't have it it's available I mean it's yeah are we discussing that tonight no okay I think the conversation we're having is whether that number one partner with un should be a district goal or a merit goal and I think um um well listen I think number one is the most important thing number two yeah we put it as number one that's I'm totally identif facilities plan is the most important thing you take pre over everything that's your number one priority yes yes
137your number two priority is to prepare the long-term plan uh on your special ed review okay and number three is this data analysis number four might be a good Merit goal personally speaking that's kind of to me a little above and beyond a district goal it has that the data yeah it has that milu if you will with it um that it could be not something he would do in his normal day-to-day type of situation just my opinion I'd have no problem moving that to a a miracle because we still have the district survey I'm sorry we still have we still have the district survey um that we'd like to add to that would be the fourth one I would hope and then maybe move number one or the the new number one on the
138top to uh a merit goal either qualitative or quantitative but Merit right Tom I think when you started that speech you said number four and I think number four is the climate survey and we have to I still want to include that as a as a district goal okay got it that's yeah it came out differently okay I'm sorry all right okay the climate survey you want to in you want to include that as a district Bill personally yes and then the data analysis we're saying that that would move to well I think we can have four District goals I mean there's nothing out of certainly can yeah you know for the benefit of the conversation I think that the special education audit is certainly a form of data analysis so you could almost combine
139uh the long-term plan for the special education review and continued data analysis right okay you like thank you Mr G I agree with you much appreciated it takes a CPA to figure that out why don't we take all six goals and put them in no never mind I'm just kidding I'm just kidding oop that's a good idea I'll go don't blame me for that one no now down oh you doing that anyway I think that works mathematics through Park all um what about tracking our graduates it's that's got a nice that's got a nice mer ring yeah that's got a merit ring to it he's writing see I'm asking graduates as they going into school oh there a survey all right District gos number one priority is the facilities plant implementing those right uh number
140two priority is data analysis to include the special ed review and number three is the district climate survey yes for me okay now it's it's moving on in time I think we've talked about the successes in the district quite a bit this evening was there anything else that you saw as board goal or District goal that we may have missed through the conversation or have we hit everything I think we hit everything you want me to go home I'm G to go home okay all right the next step is uh I take the the scratchy notes home and come up with a report for you and try to wrap some words around it which I will send up in draft form very much in draft form and then hopefully you'll have them for the meeting
141you said it was on the 27th so you will definitely have them then I'd like to thank you very much for what you did tonight facilitating this and we certainly uh uh met our goals for tonight so thank you very much all right okay uh the next item on our agenda is a public forum uh I I don't see anyone from the public is there someone sitting in the back that I maybe can't see not seeing anyone we could skip that then to our close session resolution be it resolved that the Board of Education of the town Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa oh I'm sorry njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 colum 4-21 to discuss the following subjects
142harassment intimidation and bullying following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in Clos session can be disclosed to to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists I moved I have a second second thank you all in favor all in favor folks I need you to vote I is it in that misso Mr we in favor of the closed session yes yes I it's it's unanimous there's no opposition thank you how long should this be 10 minutes 10 minutes 10 minutes that's okay all right thank you we'll be back in 10 minutes okay we're still in session um we're up to the next uh public forum I see no one from the public so we could skip that next schedule board uh of Education meeting is Wednesday July
14327th at 7 p.m right here at the high school and now I'd like to make a motion to um adjourn um so moved do I have a second second we could vote all in favor I I unanimous like we are J that was