CorpusRecord 132970

Monroe Township Board of Education 07.27.16 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
12,428 words · about 70 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001are this meeting of the mon Township Board of Education call to order I'd like to ask everyone to please rise for the pledge I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you Mr G can we have a roll call Mrs armenio Mr Braverman Mrs Deo here Mr calman here Mrs kapano Mr noin here Mrs Corino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here and Mr retsky here board president you have a quarum present this evening in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monro Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted July

00222nd 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you uh right now we have approval of minutes uh i' like a motion to approve the minutes of public Board of Education meeting uh April 27th 2016 still moved I have a second second any discussion all in favor I I any opposed okay motion carries there um I need a motion to approve the minutes of the closed session meeting April 27th 2016 so moved second second thank you Mr Russo all in favor I no oppose okay I need uh appr u a motion to approve the minutes of the public Board of Education meeting uh May 11th 2016 I moved second thank you any discussion in favor I I unanimous passes and um I need approval

003uh uh for the minutes of close session meeting May 11th 2016 so moved second second second in favor I I oppose yes no one no one no any abstention no okay uh we're up to committee reports any committee chair Mr calman sure we had a curriculum committee meeting this evening we had only two agenda items one agenda item was to approve the uh new physics program uh which went uh forward unanimously the other item was something that's on our agenda to review the uh uh impact study and uh ad hoc recommendation so uh well I'll defer to you guys when you do the presentation that's it any other committee chair Mr nin thank you Mr board president um the finance committee met last evening and uh the first item on the agenda uh was the

004review of the adult education program I had requested a review of this um going forward it hadn't been looked at the books uh much and it ended up that the um when all is calculated in the loss to the uh adult education program is roughly $53,000 uh the committee suggested that we look further into this um and they weren't too excited about the loss but we realize it is an asset uh in some respects to the community to offer this program so uh we're going to look at further details such as um attendance Etc and see what might be uh going forward uh a better way to address this um secondly we had a discussion on the 167 17 lease purchasing and financing um that's on 31 page 31 of your agenda are the items

005that we're going to be going out for uh lease SLP purchasing and the rates are very favorable now so the finance committee agreed that that would be a good way to proceed uh third up on the agenda last evening was the student enrollment growth and Facilities plan uh update that they presented to the uh Finance committee and I'm also a member of the bg& committee and the chairman of that committee is not here this evening but we also had that presented at the bg& meeting also that is going to be an in-depth presentation this evening so the public will be aware of that presentation the committee last evening um uh approved or suggested that it be presented to the full board with the committee's approval um to go with an engineering study of the land

006that is being uh possibly deed to the township for the uh planned uh increase uh to build two new schools and that concludes my report Mr board president thank you Mr nin any question for Mr nin Miss Amenia um yes board president the uh there's something on the agenda regarding the adult program the adult disabilities program is that you were talking about the regular adult education program can I answer that Mr yes that's that is correct okay so the what's on here regarding the adult no um there's nothing on our agenda this evening for that the thing that's uh the item that's on our agenda this evening is on page 31 pertains to the lease uh uh financing purchases that we're going to be going through thank you for the clarification thank you Mr Alo

007anything that you want to report okay any other committee chair did I want a report did you say oh for yes for uh policy we had an extensive policy uh meeting if you'll uh turn to your page 22 and 23 those are all the policies this evening for for the first reading um most of them were mandated changes some of them were very limited changes from uh uh mandated uh for us so we review them but they're for a first reading this evening which means that uh between now and the next meeting if anyone has any concerns or uh changes or recommendations they could uh email uh either Dr KAC or myself as a chair and uh we would review them for the next so uh they're presented tonight they are for review for the

008board and the public and then on the second reading they will be put into practice in for the board um and if people were tuned into to last month's meeting we had an extensive and rather um uh I guess interesting discussion about copy machines and the ptas and pto's and by the way I'd like to compliment um the committee meetings are open to the public the board committee meetings are open to the public and I would like to extend gratitude to the PTA uh and PTO members who came to the board to that meeting um and we talked about the copy machines and the result essentially is that the copy machines will be available to ptas and PTO within the schools we are still giving the principles you know the autonomy to uh work that

009out with each individual group but we are pleased and grateful and and you'll see in the agenda tonight that one of the pto's and ptas uh donated nearly $77,000 to one of the schools so we're very grateful for their participation and uh all that they do to the schools so thank you thank you any question from miss armino any other committee chair okay in that case uh we're up to the presentation of plan to address the impact of student enrollment growth in the facilities uh of the school district and I'll turn it over to Dr KAC Mr gors Dr Albert and Mr T I believe will be involved it's not don't do me any FV [Music] okay good evening board members members of the public uh tonight is a we're going to present uh the

010plan that we have to recommend to the board of education to address our growing student enrollment or student enrollment growth I have Dr Ali with me our assistant superintendent and Mr Gorski our business administrator board secretary and Mr T is in the audience as well should we need his assistance he's our director of facilities the plan to address student enrollment growth this is really the culmination of work that began about a year ago in looking at the uh the housing going up getting demographer reports and looking at our our registration or student registration as it was growing and growing we formed a steering committee small committee from the board and a couple administrators to plan how we're going to go about doing this and from that point we had the um an ad hoc which

011developed into a student growth advisory committee which started out with maybe about 80 members of the community uh we had representatives from our school teachers administrators board members uh students our Police Department Rec Department our Senior Communities um parents teachers number of people and although we didn't maintain everybody till the end um we had what I think were very valuable discussions during that time and we looked at all different possibilities including School configurations ways to address address both short-term and long-term needs of the school district as our student population continue to grow so what I'm about to present to you tonight is the result of after taking the input from this student growth advisory committee listening to community members residents um going out to the senior community and taking information from the demographer report and

012other reports and from the very beginning we stated that the ultimate decision is the Board of Education it's their decision on what they decide to do and the Board of Education tasked myself and the administrative team with coming up with a plan to address the student enrolla growth the key tenants of the plan are as indicated and I I won't read this word for word but I'll just give you an overview so the first part is an addition to the high school to this High School right here currently we are overc capacity from the amount of students that this this school was built for and we're looking based on our demographer reports and based on all the other information we're looking to hit a a a um a the top number of around 3,000 students

013that we're expecting in this high school and we're expecting that anywhere between 5 to 10 years maybe even 15 years so our recommendation is to build an addition to this high school that's very similar to what South Brunswick has done and we would and visited South Brunswick High School just to see what it would look like and we also learned from visiting South Brunswick some of the things that worked for them and some of the things that didn't work for them for instance some of the hallways weren't wide enough they had a bridge going across from the addition to the main building that they decided once they opened the building they found it was just a little too crowded so we learned uh from some of their I don't want to say mistakes but some

014things if they had to do over again that they would do differently I also consulted with superintendent and uh other people from other districts including East Brunswick North Brunswick and to see what they how they have handled their enrollment growth because those districts have gone through this enrollment growth probably in the past 10 years or more and all of those high schools are around 3,000 students somewhere in that vicinity so we talked to them about what they did with their buildings what they did in with their Elementary their middle school their high school and um looking at that that's the the one area that we would need is an addition to this High School the addition would be on what's I guess could be considered a footprint that was that was designed when this school

015was built and there was room left or or designated that could be used for an addition should the need arise well the need arose okay we're here um so that's the first part the second part I have in here is to repurpose Apple school and that's not something something that would happen right away but we've heard a lot of concern about the the age of Apple gar school I believe it's 1932 that it was built and the infrastructure the pipes leading into the building the boiler we can't get parts for the boiler anymore um we have another school Barkley Brook that's pretty much as old but that it had received Renovations uh in Prior years appar School wouldn't be any would not incur any cost to the district right away way but what it would

016do if we repurpose that school to house administrative offices at this point it would save us $70,000 a month that we pay in lease fees for our uh special Aid administrators and and other people that there's just no room anywhere else to house these uh people so that building not 70,000 a month that we're paying that we could save and think of the annual value of that the bottom part is to build a new elementary school and a new middle school and that would be on land that the township has promised to us to transfer over to us um that I'm told it's I believe it's 65 acres and I'm told it could be in in the value of somewhere between 7 to10 million that's a huge savings I know that North Brunswick is looking

017for land right now and they're looking to pay you know millions of dollars for land so that be a huge savings for us the rationale that I provided here on the screen is uh two direct quotes from our demographer Ross saber and he talks about basically the need to address the student enrollment growth and also that based on his study the bulk of the the new housing will occur within the next 5 years so it's in our best interest to act now to start to prepare for that uh and then the rate of growth will slow somewhat but it'll continue going up to 10 years fif and maybe even toward 15 anything beyond 15 years is extremely hard to predict we'll have a new governor we'll have a new president the economy there's housing there's

018so many different issues that we would have to contend with but we feel that the plan that we're presenting to the Board of Education tonight will address the educational needs of our students for the next 10 to 15 years and we believe it'll be done in a fiscally responsible manner Dr Co just as a point of clarification because I didn't want everyone from the public here to get nervous the rental that we're paying for the special services is 70,000 annually I know you had mentioned 70,000 a month oh my apologies I did I I I thank you for that correction I was turning a little pale there I want to $7,000 was a year my mistake I wasn't I was thinking of something else my apologies for that thank you Mr Ryback for clarifying that

019the pictures I have the next three or four slides are pictures of the construction is going on right now every day I drive by different areas that the construction has started so it's it's beyond the question of will this be built to it's being built so the first picture the first two slides slides I believe are from um the Housing Development being planned over by um s what's the road that's 33 I thought the other picture I thought this was by Regency okay this is 30 by 33 Route 33 and Applegarth uh that's one picture of it these are all then from 33 and Applegarth I believe okay um but you can see that they're building out there luxury town homes are being planned and number of units are being planned in that area I

020don't have a picture but there is another area where they have also started and um that is on and I continue to forget the name of that road yes thank you thank you there's several yes yeah yeah there's several and there are other other developments that are planned some approved some still need to go to the planning committee but we looked at those projections and we tried to take the numbers that we felt were appropriate that we could expect this satellite picture is a picture of the land that the township has uh promised to us and the lime green kind of color outlines the 65 acres now tonight there's a resolution to ask the board to approve us to hire uh a an environmental engineer to check the land out to make sure that it's

021usable to make sure there are no issues um we we've been out to visit the land some of of our board members have gone out some of us have walked on the land or at least walked around it and it seems to be usable but we really need the opinions of an expert to tell us to make sure that there's nothing that we don't know about um I have another satellite view and for this well actually before I get to that I'll talk about this this is just a chart outlining the elementary middle and the addition to the high school a five-year projection meaning this is what this will meet our needs in five years and then the 10 years the you know non-applicable or the non applicable um Na on there is that we

022wouldn't need to do anything for 10 years really 15 that we can see uh based on the information we have so we realize that this is a lot of building and it's certainly not a position that I want to be in um or of us but it's a reality so we have to deal with this the alternative we have is leasing trailers and you know the district has gone through that at the cost of many uh millions of dollars and I'm you know we would like to avoid that if we can because you don't get anything for the lease the next slide I'm going to um hand the mic over but I want to go up and I'm going to manipulate the slide a little bit to show you it's another satellite view but I

023I just can zoom in a little bit by working on the screen so I'm going to go over to the laptop you mind I need to record this mic uh so this picture I zoomed in a little bit this is just a satellite view it's a more recent view of the same land that I just showed you and this is off of Old Church Road uh which runs off of Applegarth and there's land back there which is 65 acres as I was saying and you know I don't know how well you can see it but there is one spot that looks like a dark it seems to be mostly part of a rectangle and we believe that to be uh drainage man-made you know Swale or whatever that was built maybe when it was Farmland

024uh but that's something the environmental engineer will certainly check out for us to make sure that there are no environmental concerns anything that would prevent us from building on this land and I have uh the next slide I'm going to show you you is a is what it could look like with an elementary and a middle school on the land it's another Township it's another Township that went through an enrollment growth probably 10 years ago and they took a very similar approach they took a plot of land and they built a middle school and an elementary so I just want to clarify this this is what I'm going to show you is not oh thank you Dr Al if you can just go to the slide at the top and um the um you'll see

025it's not it's not going to look exactly like it but just to give you the idea of what it would look like to have two schools on a plot of land to share the fields um and the other uh Dr if you go to the back to the presentation it's the gold square at the top there you go and uh just click on that no no click right on the uh link just okay and if you just on the screen if you just squeeze it the screen itself it's a it's a touch screen and you can pull it in so this is a middle school and an elementary school in another Township and you can see that it would be a similar type of not exactly but it would be similar this is what it

026something could look like uh also to note are the roads nearby they're two-lane highways so one of the things that we were concerned about what would the congestion be like with traffic what would you know the roads be like well with an elementary in a middle school on that road on that plotted land the time the starting and dismissal times are different so it would be staggered and this middle school and high or uh Elementary School also work on that staggered schedule so it seems to operate very well in that area and with this school there's even a neighborhood right across the street and um it's manageable could you go back to the presentation please thank you all right so the next steps and by the time we're we're at the bottom part of the

027slide now this presentation has was presented to our buildings and grounds committee they recommended that we move forward with this plan and send it to the finance committee so we met with the finance committee of the board the finance committee listened to the presentation discussed several things and then recommended that they go to the curriculum committee which we did tonight and now finally we are here to with the Board of Ed and the public presenting the plan okay there will be a public comment so there'll be room for questions from the public about this but uh Mr President I was would it open up to the board members at this time unless you direct otherwise uh well I have a resolution I'd like to read but if they have questions what I'd like to do

028is read the resolution and have discussion by the board and then what I'd like to do was before the board votes open it up to the public for discussion just on this plan okay so that being said I'd like to read the following resolution it is it is recommended that the Board of Education one direct District administration to proceed with referendum planning regarding the building of a new elementary school and a new Middle School on the land which will be transferred by the township to the board and in addition and an addition to the high school and two authorize District administration to solicit proposals for the proposed referendum project from professionals including the board's architect Bond counselor and financial advisor for further deliberations and recommendations by the building and grounds Transportation committee and the finance

029committee and ultimately for deliberation and consideration by the full board the board president the superintendent of schools and the business administrator slbo secretary are hereby authorized and directed to take all necessary steps to implement this action of the board of education so move I have a second second okay I open it up for discussion from the board first and then the public any discussion from board members have a question Mr Russ on the diagram the walk into the mic yeah on the on the map there's a lot of vacant land surrounding the proposed land that we are going to be given right uh do we know anything about that land who owns it what will be built there any future plans yeah yeah abolutely there were two two satellite views as you know we talked

030about the other night one was from an earlier satellite view and you didn't see any houses uh across the road and the second one was a more recent and you could see houses there there's a road that runs along the side of the the land that takes you to a development that's already completed but it winds way back in there and there's a there's a culde saac Rob and I we drove through there um I'm not I'm I'm picturing it now I'm not real sure about the land on either side of it from that point and Mr T I'm not sure if you have any information on that that you could share with us I believe those are so around those dark lines there'll be homes built there are homes built there now they're finishing

031that project let me just uh say I think Mr Russo the dark lines sort of like a rectangle or maybe trapezoid uh those uh may be used for educational purposes on the land on the other side of the road going there's a road and that's where it's a culdesac and that's where there are homes it's not on on that land no I'm not so the construction site is going to be within those black lines that's what I understood no no that's beyond the the dark lines that were the trapezoid as Mr R said or the you know kind of a rectangle there that's on the land that that's being provided to us okay so we're looking at that is we think that was just drainage okay but how much of that lot is it is

032it the whole lot that yeah the original shot that I showed you with it was like a lime green that went around it that's the entire area the the rectangular lines in the middle of that is just one section of it but we would own all we would have all the land so many Bo president if I might um if my uh memory is correct and I understand I was at a either a planning board or zoning board meeting when that land was um suggested was going to be uh transferred to the township based on approvals so all the surrounding land to to uh answer Mr Russo's question will be built upon that land that is sectioned out that 65 acres was part of an approval process for I believe like a cluster zoning provision

033which means the builders were allowed to put more density on the land with the provision of segregating out that parcel now it was it it's generally when you have that kind of provision it's generally to to remain as open space but I believe that the um municipality is going to accept it as land for municipal use but it's based on a valuable consideration given to the Builder so the Builder will probably be building all around that land um a development and to to my question would be that has not been deeded over to the township yet is that correct that land I think that's correct so do we have a time frame as to when that might happen absolutely I know you know I understand the process that that there's there's a process for deeding

034it over but do we have any time frame um one of the suggestions that came out of finance committee was to get a letter of intent from the township to transfer the land or or show intent to transfer the land to the school district and we'll talk more about that later included in that letter of intent from the township is going to be a timeline okay and more details on on how the trans is going to uh materialize okay thank because my next question was do we have anything in writing so I I we can proceed at this point without yeah some drafts are going to go back and forth between our our Council and the attorney attorneys for the township on that letter but I expect we will probably have that in hand within

035a matter of a week or two okay and as soon as we have it um all the board members will have it thank you thank you some any any other question uh not not at this time Mr Mr no then yes thank you um I just am a little confused because I was under the impression um based on the finance committee and the bg& that we were just going to be authorizing the board or yeah the administration to spend $13,000 on the Edwards engineering study uh to see if the feasibility of this uh uh a transferred land will meet our requirements um I'm a little concerned with directing them to proceed with a referendum planning because if this Edward study comes through and we don't have the land um it seems like we're we're kind

036of fighting uh against each other with this resolution um number one the the resolution offers a framework for the concept idea um for administration then to proceed with a lot more work in its development uh the initial step of that of course is the Edwards engineering recommendation that's on the professional appointment uh recommendation list tonight because that will determine if the plan that's been developed so far by Administration is feasible if that land can sustain two school buildings on its property um and if there's any other issues that we should be aware of that could hinder that plan but um again the reso identifies the fact and that um through this process that Dr kosak delineated before that we have currently 1,000 onh housee students in the district we have 1550 students projected over the

037next 5 years that will leave 250 students unhoused and over the next 10 years it grows from there I don't have the get add another thousand on top of that so it it is imperative at this juncture because a lot of time has passed with um the secession of uh superintendent and the interim process and the ad hoc process to now uh um engage in actual pre-referendum planning and that's what this resolution was intended to do to provide some framework for administration to collaborate with the board and other professional um to refine this plan to something more functional and um clear now the hazard if we don't have a resolution is that we will be having a brainstorming sessions with different parties all over and it will lead to uh inefficiency in the process this

038was the culmination of the ad hoc committee's work and administration using that data to put together um plan in order to house all of those students for the next five or 10 years we believe that this does so as efficiently is possible and this is the board's U memorialization of that in this referendum process Mr um that yeah and I I totally understand that I'm I'm totally on board with that but I I I'm a little um concerned that there is no dollar amount on this re uh reso the uh proposal that we were looking at from Edwards um was clearly delineated as being $113,000 and I would like somewhere to maybe see that how much are we spending on this resolution right here I I beg you pardon I misunderstood the only um professional

039resolution that is before you today is for the engineer to do a feasibility study on the land um the we we will begin to work with the other professionals here financial adviser architect Bond count councelor soon and we will be soliciting proposals from them as a directive from this resolution those proposals will certainly be brought back to the board of education for authorization at a future meeting as early as August that totally clears it up for me thank you Mr Gorski thank youin yes M um thank you Mr Gorski um I was too going to ask on number two authorized direct administra and direct I'm sorry authorized District administration to solicit proposals for reference so on Mr nin's um question the solicitation uh for proposals does not really cost us anything right they'll be essentially

040submitting either a a description of what their services might be and the cost if we choose to go forward yes ma'am so if any of those um professionals if we deem them e have we decided on the professionals if we deem them not who we want to to go with we can we can ask for proposals from other people as well absolutely that's 100% the board's Authority okay so it's really just a proposal um for uh just information at this point the only thing that's on for tonight is a recommendation for Professional Services for the engineer Edwards engineering $113,000 to determine if this land uh can sustain two buildings and if there's any issues that we should be aware of with the study I've the first step here you're putting um the card ahead of

041the ORS and then second we're are going to work soliciting proposals from other uh professionals who will serve the board in future processes of this referendum and uh that will that will only go through board resolution as the Edwards engineering is on for tonight I read that letter I'll have questions about that later thank the mail you had a yeah I have questions about the proposal from Edwards can I ask that now it talks about researching the New Jersey D and federal databases for soil information and it says it will not include testing soil testing at what point does soil testing come into play for this process maybe when we get the land Mr President um I asked Mr T to um uh give us some expertise on that but I can tell you from

042past referendum the Department of Education has always uh requested soil samples um to make sure there's no contamination for any facility that's that students are going to be um housed Direction on that will come from the phase one study that Edwards does so if during their research they determine that testing of a specific nature needs to be done they will come back to us and they will help us engage an environmental engineer Edward engineering is a civil design firm they are not an environmental firm so if there is testing to be done there they would help us solicit proposals from testing labs to have that testing done give you a broad example if the research through the database indicates that there were apple orchards there at one time apple orchards historically have used chemicals that

043cause problems with soil if that is evident then they would recommend testing in that regard there is other types of soil testing that will take place down the road and that is where you dig test pits and you determine groundwater level um determine the structural stability of the soil and that is necessary to determine um for example if you need to import you know thousands and thousands of tons of soil if the quality of the soil is not there structurally it can also affect the design whether you would have to put pilings in rather than standard footings those kind of things affect the cost um so those are the the testing that will happen you will likely during this process with Edwards we'll get feedback at some point maybe Midway through we'll come back and

044say we recommend that you start uh testing for these parameters now would Toll Brothers for all the areas they developed have done soil testing for the other areas their testing requirements are not as stringent as those for the Department of Education okay so we have New Jersey Department of Education has a regulatory checklist that we have to go through in the land acquisition process okay um which is very different from a homeowner uh building a residential building okay thank you if I might I I just want to add that's one reason why we really need to consider the time Factor because it does take a lot longer for us to build a school than it developer to build build a development we're under a lot more requirements and I think the key thing to remember

045here is is the um proceed uh with a referendum um uh planning I think the word planning really says it all because that we can change from one uh specialist area to to another one uh and that's the key word for everybody to remember here any other board members Mr one more question if Mr T can answer it in connection with the road if he sees any problems with the two-lane road near the school certainly welcome Mr T's expertise on this topic too but I will tell you that as it exists now on the map uh those roads would not be suitable for um housing two schools in accordance with our plan we have spoke with Township officials who plan on widening the roads to make the roads suitable for traffic for two schools and

046whatever else exists in that area we're fortunate in that that's not a a an area where traffic flows through it's kind of a niche in the corner and it's not a thoroughfare I believe is the word so there is not a lot of traffic on there like that exists at many of our other schools um and the township um is is going to address the road widening that would also be in writing I guess we we this whole process uh will be done professionally and um and managed that way yes and then just one more question just in the immediate area is there any commercial developments that are going to be built in that immediate area not to my knowledge okay any other board member have a question or comment I'll now open it up

047to any member of the public to address just the uh development issue um let me just say uh when you come to the microphone please state your name your address and you'll be limited to three minutes three Mark Klein 7 kurew um I do have a lot to say and I guess most of it'll have to be in the second uh public portion I want to compliment you on what all of youve done uh in preparing for the future uh what you mentioned about Gateway the other development is called shared properties uh the new catchphrase in New Jersey is overlay Zone and what an overlay zone is is a combination of residential and Commercial so you're going to notice in many towns now they're building commercial on the bottom and they're putting apartments above like

048they did in perer Village okay so that's that part as far as C now this is something that's very very important um not going changes the last planning board meeting there was a rewriting of the master plan for properties on Route 33 probably between Pineville and appleo and that area and the reason why they did it basically it's the same developer who's going to build two very large communities town houses and apartments for families evidently he owns property on the other side of 33 and it's been rezoned now for about a thousand residential units what happened with COA is and Michelle can probably help me with this COA no longer exists that's the committee on affordable housing because for about eight years they did not really do what the government expected them to do it's

049now handled by a judge and Our obligation originally was 2300 units of which only 20% have to be affordable so so with 2300 units you'd have to build 8,000 units um the way it's being done now the way it's being broken down and I'm not I'm giving you what my understanding is only a small portion can be over 65 a small portion could be seniors about one minute Mr Klein go continue I got to start over again and then they have a part that's going to be truly affordable and then they're going to have one that's very very affordable and that's going to be about 100 units and when they say very very and that's what I'm trying to get uh clarification of does that mean Section housing um there should never have been a

050cola they that what they're doing is totally wrong we're being overpopulated overbuilt in too quick of a time and I got 10 seconds left yes um so you got to count that in with that now this is another thousand units that could be there it could be 5 years 10 years 15 years what helped us with this and just bear with me instead of 2,300 units by going along with what the judge wants it cuts Our obligation down to 1,00 units which means roughly 4,000 units would have to be built so that's something you should get clarified my suggestion is I know the township helped us in the past with land I'm ask asking the powers to be to meet with I don't know whether it's John rigs or or mayor tamburo and and let's

051all work together I know they want to work with us they know what we're in the problem that we have just for the sake of time let me that we thank you we we we are we have open discussions and very positive uh relationship with our elected officials and uh we look forward to working with them to benefit of of the town and for our purposes the school system okay now for later if it is later talking about um christe's plan for more raid for our town can that be handled in this session which I hope I can I had surgery today now you have to wait for the second public session I'm sorry I pass out if I pass out call Robert with Johnson we'll take you anybody else from the public yes sir

052hi uh my name is Amba Sula and I live uh on to Shar coat which is not that far from where you're plan to build a school so I'm somewhat familiar with the the the land um uh my concerns are the following uh I um I'm just trying to understand which other Parcels of land uh was considered because I find this particular choice very odd considering um on the south side of it it's also swamps preserved forest with like few uh uh houses there on the east side of it there is John homman Sons which is like a septic company and that land is actually in your map marked as contaminated land okay and um and the roads that lead to this they are I think we spoke about that already there single land Road

053no traffic light nothing I mean there's some major expansion would be required for you know uh 10 or 20s or 30s of school buses to be coming in there right so you know it's a small partiel of land uh I think uh it's uh I don't see if in the future there's a need for expansion how or where are you going to expand I mean I think it's blocked from all sides it's already very cramped uh to put two buildings in there uh and if we have to expand there is no space for expansion so I I'm just trying to understand like what other uh areas that you looked at and how you figured out that this is the right place to you know go for a school in this land in fact is was

054supposed to be open preserved land is from what I hear uh but I guess they change their mind on that um so yeah that that's that's my question well let me just say one of the reasons why we have the um uh engineering report is to find out about the buildability uh on on the land um and as far as the size uh the people the experts we've been talking to at least informally have uh assured us that uh 65 acres is more than enough to accommodate two schools and um again the engineers will be looking at at that property to see if there are any problems because that's what we need we need that uh report yeah I mean the fact that we cannot expand appleg or oak tree or any of the other

055schools that are out there says that the planning was not right so we have to you know that's uh so you know 65 acres is 65 acres it's not the the the engineers going there are not going to make it 120 Acres right it's still 65 acres so how you going to expand I mean let's say 5 years down the line we realized that these other builders they were talking about they put another 5,000 houses right how you going to expand where well this the state only allows us you know to uh go out maybe five years we're looking at 10 also let me just say to you that we did have a a student growth advisory committee we did have uh members we had NAD committee uh before that um and we had about

056a 100 members from the community that all participated uh in in this um uh process so it's not an unknown factor it's been out there it was on channel televised all the meetings on channel were televised on Channel 28 as well so uh you know it's it's not a secret this was not done in the back room it was very open and transparent and that was one of our goals is is to make it open and transparent to everyone so is it transparent which other lands you considered or that's not transparent just so much land that that's you know available that that could accommodate the needs of the school system uh there's not as much available land as as you think out there uh this not for us yeah okay uh if I have to

057raise uh uh these issues in in terms of uh just using that land I mean of course this is not the zoning board when is that uh hearing going to happen just just just so that we know and we can come back again and talk talk about that I don't know when the zoning board or or any will be looking at this first of all we have to see the feasibility of the land itself with the engineering report and have to get our Specialists uh in there and that's one of the purposes of of this resolution to move ahead with the planning process and that's all we're doing right now we're in the planning process nobody's building anything yet okay and all that information is Mr gy just reminded me of course will be shared

058with the public when it comes out thank you yes okay thanks anybody else from the public yes thank you U Michael camlet uh s Constitution Drive Stonebridge Community um two years from now are we going to have the two schools built already I don't think so okay so that's what I'm asking basically how how far into the future are we looking to get the uh schools built because I know you do have a student student population and increasing rapidly I'm going to turn over Mr wol yeah in in general terms subject to change uh it takes a year to um get the approvals and everything once the board authorizes the the plan to go to um Department of Education and then get on the ballot so it'll take a year from the time the board

059decides upon this plan to go on the ballot and then it will take at least another two to three years years uh for the bidding and then the construction of the school so the very earliest you're looking at a school building again I emphasize the very earliest is September of 2020 okay so the light on pinville may get here before the schools are built we believe so yes thank you very much thank you yes come on up I I'm uh RAM rnat from six ens Drive Southfield estate it's again very close to this uh land that you're considering couple of things I I looked at at the last meeting the uh kind of the recommendation from that student growth advisory committee and I don't see this option kind of being kind of one of them

060I know they didn't talk about the particular spots but they had come up with those different combination choices I don't recall this specific one being one of them maybe I'm mistaken um the uh second thing is that that area is already going through a lot of growth as my neighbor indicated uh there are two new developments the Hidden Ponds as well as the CO's neck col's run uh and uh I think there two phases of that one here one back um also there is a commercial property called The Gables uh on Apple guard uh probably less than a mile I guess uh from again this location uh and uh and keep in mind all the new houses are coming on Apple G this road also touches Apple guard uh so I'm really concerned on the

061traffic and all those situations that are going to be created uh so I would like make sure people take that into consideration and so part of that Edward study my question is will is a traffic study also going to be done or is that a separate thing that also needs to be funded and and proceeded on sir to your first point about the Strategic growth advisory committee um that was a six-month process as as Mr Ryback said there was over a 100 volunteers at various times of that engagement that studied um and brainstormed a bunch of different options there was numerous table games where everybody's idea was documented and and thought out and developed nobody's idea was ever um uh disregarded in any way and everything was was uh Advanced from there and then um

062the the best ideas from the group were put forward and um reviewed by the committee there was three and the committee concluded by offering those ideas to Administration um but ultimately it's admin it's an administrative responsibility to use that Community process to make a recommendation to the board in order to um satisfy the number of unhoused students and develop the facilities uh accordingly so that although it was not exactly one of those three ideas I will say in all honesty as as this process has gone along that way that it it has been a very evolutionary process and parts of those three ideas have been incorporated into this ultimate plan that's before you thank you and about the traffic study traffic study will have to be performed absolutely okay and then the last point I

063wanted to make is you mentioned about Apple got being modified uh to whole administrative um offices and uh save that 70,000 in expense one thing is I don't know I'm sure people will be raising this apple go obviously has some historical significance as a school people would want it to remain as a school um so that I think something I'll just ask people to consider you know can it be refurbished and improved uh and expand expanded upon and then second I guess the Senior Citizen Center I live right opposite it I don't think it is heavily used there is some space probably there to put in some of the administrative offices so why take up the entire Apple guard school for that purpose so we have a land there maybe we can we just have

064to build one school instead of two so I would propose or request that be considered thank you thank you thank you thank you anybody else Miss Lang take your time hi Patty Lang 74 McFarland Circle I just have a couple questions um during your presentation you said that the study was an environmental engineer but it's not right like there this this first thing that you're voting on tonight isn't wasn't an environmental engineer it's just that during the presentation it was quot so I just wanted to clarify I I misspoke that's okay that's okay number two um if the land is being gifted by the dist by the township shouldn't the township have already found out whether or not it can be built upon is a gift that's going to cost us $113,000 before we even

065know if we can use it truly a gift we desperately need this the school we need the school I think the plan's a good plan my concern is we're going to spend $113,000 which we don't have $113,000 in our back pockets to find out whether or not the land is even buildable and that doesn't include the study as to whether that's environmentally safe to put the children on the land so I I just I'm a little confused like how are they gifting us this land and costing us this money I know you can't really answer that but yeah I'm let Mr Gorski answer that evening Mrs Lang um uh first the the transfer of the land from the township um occurred before the township had any understanding of how the school district was going to

066use the property um perhaps if they had that foresight and crystal ball ahead of time and they known that this six-month a hoc process would have leted us into this direction to need two schools on that parcel um uh that some of those engagements could have been done uh but they weren't and unfortunately Administration will say and we have said this all along we are are time is not on our side here in this process um there's been a couple um problems so far um stemming from the um the superintendency being vacant um fortunately now we have Security in that position and and we've had some some great contributions from Dr kak in this plan and we're proceeding accordingly these expenses $113,000 for an engineering study uh traffic study Bond counselor architect they are in

067the budget right now they were deliberated when the budget was put together I believe we have over $100,000 in an account Reser reserving those funds and they are a minuscule expense in my opinion to the total cost of this project uh interest rates as you know are at a historic low um we have over a thousand on house students now and uh pretty soon if this plan does not go in accordance to um the timeline we have set up we're going to be looking at some pretty drastic consequences and I don't want to get into those to to you know take the Thunder out of the do we have ownership of that land at this point or are we still waiting for the we do not what what I've asked the township for today and

068I'm working on that with our board attorney is to get a letter of intent okay um this this as Mr noin recommended at the finance committee uh will give a strong basis for the district to engage in those type of expenses to um develop the land and research the land and and all the other aspects of this project so that letter of intent will show uh the ownership and the timeline of transfer of that land to where it is ultimately deeded and accept accepted publicly by resolution by the Board of Education and my final question is in the in the agreement with the um engineer it says we estimate the phase of work shall be completed within 6 months is there any way for you guys to get them to do it sooner because 6

069months is a long time for us to wait to find out whether or not we can use the land so can you change the agreement to make it three months I just want to let you know I was smiling because that's been the question at the finance committee and and all of us and the key word is really within and we want to do things as expeditiously as possible the engineering company is aware of that and and I think it will from the feedback we've been getting that will happen in less than six months good thank you very much anybody else from the public yes good evening uh Andy poori 16 St James Street hi how are you as Mr Cent indicated uh I'm part of the planning board and I know the statistics a

070little better uh but I think the numbers that he presented to the board today are pretty much on target uh the only difference is that some of this affordable housing as well as the associated uh residential development is not going to take place in the next 5 to 10 years but it's going to take place 15 to 20 years from now uh in terms of realizing their full potential or the maximum growth um the couple questions that I have is there's a discussion that's going on I'm a little confused I'm an engineer so be warned um that there's a $133,000 there's an environmental study there's a traffic study there's a fe feasibility study um what was done so far what's going to get done soon and what is the $133,000 about uh because $113,000 for

071a phase one study uh is quite a bit of money and it does not take 6 months to do it I can tell you that that my fir will be more than happy to assist you with that um so we we need to get down to this a little faster quicker uh absolutely the need is there uh and I think it's going to continue to be projected to be a tremendous need in the township that we need to meet one suggestion to the board is that the documents that you actually put out there today I don't think everybody got it um probably one tree from Monroe was killed to put this together uh a lot of people who come here don't really understand some of the jargon that's used here and I'm very familiar with

072it it may be a lot easier to get your points and our points across to the general public by creating a summary sheets that you can put them and hand them over rather than giving a large material for them to go through it's always easy to put stuff on the website and say that the information is available we make it available but it be available to to General Public in such a way that they can comprehend it quickly and be able to make a decision um I request that for example how many by 5year periods or 2-year period what the population growth in in enrollment is going to be and what is the current enrollment and at what point do we need a new school that should be clearly laid out so that it's easy

073for us to to to review so that's just a suggestion to the board to see if you can simplify the the information that you have so that people can comprehend faster all right thank you very much thank you any any body else from the public seeing no one from the public we could vote on the resolution Mr borski have a roll call vote I have one question oh I didn't see your hand one more question got to raise your hand on okay uh has anybody from the student growth advisory committee seen this land well I've seen I think Mr Leo has seen it too yeah Mr RAB yes the um the student growth advisory committee was handed maps and um some schematics and and a lot of uh geographic information about the land uh it

074was studied and deliberated at that committee level to a large extent because it's a it's a a big condition of this project and members of the committee have actually as members of the board have uh seen the property physically okay I haven't I me I wasn't part of the committee and I wasn't here when it started so uh thank you Mr brck uh just to clarify on the availability of information uh it's been said several times but all of the minutes uh from the student growth advisory committees uh committee meetings are online we videotaped every single meeting and broadcast it over Channel 28 streamed it and it is available online um we have information uh is you know is is we try to make it uh we try to make the entire process as transparent

075as possible involve people in in decisions uh make sure that information was available and as the board is well aware uh I'm very much a proponent of doing many many things online having said that there are still a number of people that are more comfortable with paper copies so as much as I am reluctant to make paper copies uh we still have a concern we've had comments about that that material is still made made available in a you know hard copy but uh if anybody wants to go to our website we try to make it as easily accessible as possible and visible uh all that information is there very quickly and the demographic study is still on the website is that correct and it's in pretty should be good detail about projections and when schools

076will be needed so that's already been been exposed to the public for a long time now so just have to get on there and take a look especially coming from somebody who was always Trump or you know saying that we need to be transparent so thank you and that and and I think we've had many um we've had many board meetings with the demographer there we've had discussions about uh Adam fitm really about the the numbers and the accuracy of the numbers so the board has done a great deal and the administration especially has done a great de to make those numbers accurate and um understandable to the public so that the latest demographic study is is available thank you I I'd like the board to vote on this Mr torski Miss armeno yes Mr

077Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky is permitted to vote on this yes thank you sir Mr board president I'm very pleased to say that motion passes unanimously thank you it's nice to hear and and we can now start moving forward okay uhic if I could before absolutely Dr coak all right thanks Mr President uh just one clarification was brought to my attention on the agenda agenda I would like to bring to the board's attention and members of the public uh under letter N there is a uh motion to it is recommended that the board approved the following curriculum for the 201617 school year I would respectfully ask that you change the word curriculum to programs since some of the items um

078are not what page what page is that on oh uh 24 sorry you want under which letter n not that's not on 2 I have numbers on 24 have numbers too um page 22 at the to 22 n thank you that was the revised was different Bo approved F I want some recommendation uh to from the word curriculum please cross out and substitute programs thank you thank you okay um I believe the super attendant really has given his report already in detail uh so we can move to uh personnel which is on page six uh I need a motion to approve uh on the Personnel items a through double O So moved do I have a second second any discussion question page nine CC it's recommended to approve the following certified uh Personnel to do

079professional development is it to teach professional development or to participate in the training professional development Dr yes absolutely this is to be trainers in our district they have been trained as trainers already um but because it is a paid position because they do get paid for the planning for training um it has to be board approved that they're that they're board approved trainers okay so this is all in-house training that we do um instead of sending people out yes and they've all been trained so they they're not trained necessarily in the same thing they're all trainers for different aspects of professional development correct we have about 17 yearlong courses um each year and though they are trained that each one would take one of those courses and teach those courses they also are trained to

080do many courses throughout the year for our on demand professional development so it does save the district money because they're training our staff instead of our staff going out right and are they are they all different um hourly rates depending on the individual or is their one hourly rate for the training it's based they they do not get paid for the time that they're already being paid for their school day um what they get paid is a preparation time and that's an agreement with the Union they get so many hours for a full day training and it's also a different amount depending on whether they've done the training before okay they get less if they've done the training before because it's not it would just be an editing instead of creating a new course thank

081you and I might have another one before o and I do not thank you okay any other question comment and we can have a roll call vote Miss armino yes Mr Mayo yes Mr kman yes Mr noin yes Mrs Keno yes Mr Rach yes Mr Russo stain Mr rutsky yes board president Personnel items 8 through 00 passes thank you okay we could move to um board action um that's on page 20 i' need a motion to approve board action items a through Q moved I have a second second any discussion we can have a vote Mr borski Mr armino yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes to all recuse on M because there's so many policies I would recuse on under Q I'll just recuse q and much easier thank you sir that's a recusal

082on M as in Michael and Q thank you Mr noin yes Mrs Keno yes abstain on M and how do you vote on M I have to abstain on M stain on Main on M yes thanks um Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes then recuse myself from M and Mr rusy so I abstain with the exception of e j k m and n where I vote Yes thank you Mr board president motion passes okay Mr gorsky we're up to the business administrator's report before I do the board action is there any report you'd like to give or comment yes Mr Ryback members of the Board of Education I I did want to go into the Edwards engineering contract which is on uh my consent roll call and ask again if there was any questions um

083after I give you a little introduction to the process Ed Edwards engineering was recommended through the building grounds Transportation committee initially um after the expression by Administration that we need an engineer at this juncture and it was recommended to have an independent professional that reports to this board of education um and and as such Ed Edwards engineering was recommended uh mainly through the contribution of our facilities director Edwards engineering has performed admirably on the oak tree construction project last year's Middle School driveway and drainage project and also some trailer projects in previous years and that is a uh key and integral part of getting started with this plan that Administration has put forth to determine the feasibility and suitability of the land if it if it suits our purposes or not otherwise a lot of

084time could be wasted and more money uh could be uh spent than this if we proceed without having this nailed down um as was discussed it says up to 6 months in the contract Mr T called uh the professionals from Edwards today and we expect that to come sooner however there are some unknowns because that's why they're engaged if for example something is determined to be um requiring additional study of an environmental nature or whatever it could be it could take up to that longer period of time but we don't expect that or anticipate that and $113,000 fee was also aggressively negotiated by Mr T um I certainly appreciate the way he engages in the negotiations with these professionals every single one he points out that these are budgeted monies that would be better consumed

085in the classrooms and um he worked them over pretty good that's it yes sir um so members of the Board of Education Mr board president it is recommended that board action items a through U be approved by consent roll call removed second discussion yes I have some comments and some questions about the uh proposal for the engineering um first of all the in general the one of the tasks just to I think the public should be made aware of that they'll coordinate with Monroe Township Toll Brothers on the procurement of available survey and site plan mapping that have already developed in conjunction with the adjacent uh residential housing developments and we discussed this in build uh buildings and grounds and transportation that um they do or some you know do a open public um records

086and get all of this so that can help us determine the future need for other not that we should rely on it because you know we should do our own due diligence in my opinion but it is a good first step to see what has actually been done and if there is an impact study done or an uh uh um a gentleman mentioned about Wetlands uh um a Wetlands uh letter from the state should be in that also um so if we see like a preliminary information based on what the public records say that would be I think helpful so I think that's a good idea um I do have an objection as as I have on the general conditions where they talk about the land developer that is donating the property my objection to

087the word donating is that it is not a donation the uh Toll Brothers is receiving valuable very valuable consideration for providing that land to the Township in a uh based on their approvals for their their development so I would ask them to use a transfer word or change the wording because it it does not really uh explain what's happening um and I think the last question is um there's some some confusion that I have about them talking about the owner of the property so when when when we do this particular proposal the owner of the property it says monthly and payment for services rendered monthly invoices will be submitted to the owner based upon percentage of proposal work completed by that date are we considered the owner of The Proposal is that what it is

088not land that's spoiler plate language owner refers to the Board of Education although we do not technically have ownership of the land yet okay all right I think that's the only questions I have of that but I do have some other questions of the other actions may I and U Mrs armeno I will um I will go through the contract and um supplant any word um donation with transfer okay okay before uh it's executed thank you um can I ask on some other yes items okay um on number seven page 24 it's recommended that we approve someone from Nebraska uh for drill design is that going to be done over the Internet or are we paying for expenses to bring him to New Jersey it's um I'm sorry marching band drill design for a fee

089of $3,000 number seven on page 24 yes the the person is from Omaha Nebraska so I just wanted to know if we if they were it was this a an internet design we're not going to be paying for travel expenses or anything do you see it oh no yeah um can I answer s okay the sorry I didn't get you I didn't tell you that in advance yeah that's no that's fine that's fine uh to my understanding that is a drilled design uh that they're not going to actually come here but you pay the March uh you know a consultant whatever to design it umph it oh I see yes okay and that could be done without having a first class ticket to Monroe which would be a wonderful thing but okay and then um

090I just want to make one more statement oh in uh 27 the trade in the trade in of property and I know last time I saw this on the um agenda I was confused this is property uh not real property is that correct Mr Gorski uh the sale of property we recommend that the Board of Education acknowledge the certified purchasing agent uh yes ma'am that's that's a blanket authorization um for example when we leaste purchase the buses we have some that have gone by past their useful life of 15 years and the state will not allow us to use them use them anymore so this authorizes me to perhaps trade them in uh to um the person that were buying the buses from through the bid and or auction them off if that's if we

091can get a better price word there I have no objection to that but I'm saying could we put in parenthesis not real property like not land I always think that well maybe my from my background I'm thinking the sale of property we're talking about land but we don't really that's not what this means this means just no real property could only be traded and transferred um um go by resolution of the board no doubt about it okay there there was a a sale of land that happened um probably about eight years ago there was a building lot that was owned by the board that was sold and that was all on through committee and then board resolution with a different a TI a totally I I just can't go unloading property okay um no it's

092just that it was you know I was just hoping that we can clarify that um and then I just want to just make a point that a real donation um on P page 25 C and that we accept the donation from the Barkley Brook PTA at the value of $6,995 that's a donation and I I thank them for that yes and a lot of hard work on there on their behalf correct Mr nin thank you Mr board president um I just had a question and uh one of the gentleman I guess you already left um kind of uh made me think of it has any but looked at what the uh Toll Brothers when they were forced by the cluster ordinance to deed this property to the township do we know how the township accepted

093this property was it for municipal use or was it for open space because the gentleman made an issue that it was open space and we all know the issues um with trying to get open space reclass uh reclassify Mr reic I don't believe Mr notin that the property has been transferred to the township yet U we could certainly get you that information um or it may be um uh delineated in that letter of intent I talked about before yeah that would be key a key thing to get obviously because that does change the whole dynamic of this project if that's the case um also I believe Miss Lang mentioned that this is a gift um it's not really a gift it's a gift is something that uh you do out of the goodness of your

094heart this is something that um the township uh is was given this property um because they uh the T Brothers had to give this property to the township because um the the penalty to the township for the Toll Brothers uh giving this property to the township and and eventually to the school board was that they've gotten many more houses built with much higher density therefore more students so it it it really hurts me and it really bothers me when I hear people saying that this is a gift or that they're giving this to the township um or that the Builder gave it to the uh to the school none of that is true this was a law that's on the books based on cluster development and that is one of the main reasons why we're

095in the situation that we are thank you Mr President thank you Mr notin anybody else vote M arm Mino yes Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes atin yes Mrs karino yes Mr Rybeck I vote Yes on everything except item four where I have to recuse myself so noted thank you Mr Russo yes and Mr retsky you ready for this Mike yes sir okay I abstain with the exceptions of items A1 through A1 m o r s and t thank you that wasn't so bad thank you sir Mr board president uh motion passes that concludes my report thank you thank you ready for uh board president's report very briefly I too Mr armeno beat me to a little bit I'd like to thank the Barkley Brook Brookside PTA for their uh donation and contribution of uh

096of time because they're all volunteers and certainly uh for almost $7,000 of basketball hoops parts and and installation and paning uh one other item on uh July 18th Dr kak and I went to the oak tree school and we visited the extended school year program which is basically for identified special needs students and um we got to really interact with the students going into the classroom and it was wonderful to see them so positively engaged and to also see the staff uh so dedicated for what they do I'm really kudos to everyone it's it's great because if these kids didn't have that program they would certainly regress academically and and uh it's a real positive uh for for these students and and for our district okay um any other board of education business in that

097case we can have the next public forum which is open to uh topics not necessarily pertaining to the agenda Mr PR ELO please state your name address and you have three minutes Anthony proso I live at a equestrian Way Monroe Township that flag in front of us it's a beautiful flag it represents our government and our nation I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands this is a pledge you and I make before every meeting these are the words our children recite every day in school and make the same pledge these are the words that made America a place where our fathers and forefathers were willing to give their lives for the sacrifices of our families and the freedoms that we have in

098the opport OPP unities we have today with these opportunities it enabled every board member in front of me to own a home and have a comfortable life most of you have children and your main goal in life is to see that they have every possible Avenue to a free and prosperous future in order to raise a family and buy a home and live comfortable like you do you strive to prepare them to do better like you did you are teaching your children the American way not of my point many graduates of the school system past and present will be eligible to vote in the upcoming presidential election as you know in recent months a majority of our young college students have supported socialism why are our children supporting socialism why have we been teaching them

099and giving them the information they need to make intelligent choices for their future are we teaching them the opportunities they have as you would teach your own children it seems certain that we are not they really don't have any idea how lucky they they are to live in America instead of somewhere else once in college these young minds are unprepared to know the difference between fact rhetoric radical opinion and propaganda this has had this has been happening for years and is grinding down America we see what is happening to our nation but we don't do anything we are lucky enough to live in America and having the right to vote for any party we choose but many students are coming out of our school system without any of the vital statistics uh vital Civics education

100necessary for them to make it uh a decision as active voters well because we give our pledge of allegiance to our flag and country it should be a priority to teach our children what it truly means to be American to teach them patriotism and pride and love of their country country not to impose our will but to teach them the difference between what they think what they want what they have and what they can achieve attaching these teachings to the social study curriculum in a four years of high school would help instill the seeds of Freedom now and give them a chance to make Intelligent Decisions for their future if we don't teach our children we will lose everything our forefathers died for and the foundation of our great nation will be will be replaced

101in future elections you know president once said freedom is never more than one generation from Extinction we didn't pass it to our children in the bloodstream it must be fought for protected and handed on to them to do the same M Mr pres I have to ask you to wrap up your beyond your three minutes uh I asked the board if they would consider and discuss the issue okay thank you thank you want to comment sure good evening Mr proso um I share your thoughts on this country being a great country I certainly appreciate the fact that I was raised in this country and that I'm able to raise my children in this country and I certainly appreciate what our children in this school district and the the entire Community um has as a result

102of the efforts of those who have come before us as well as those who are currently in office regardless of what political party or affiliation they with but I do have to question you on on a statement that you're making as fact without you know that I'm a data guy so it's not going to be a surprised um I would respectfully disagree with your statement that we being the Monroe Township School District are not educating our children properly and with that hard data to show me that our students upon having left the school district do not have those values I would respectfully disagree and say you may have you should have been or you've been to many of our events where we honor our veterans where we respect our country there are Civics uh education

103that's instilled in in our curricula throughout from kindergarten through 12th grade and I would say that we do teach our students to be critical thinkers and to um be thoughtful in their process and I believe from everything from our Armed Forces Day which I don't think you were at but certainly many veterans and community members were at and seem to be very appreciative of that to even the days when we bring our police force in that the values that you espouse are certainly values that we teach our children so I do respect your opinion and I understand uh maybe you're concerned but I would say that uh we take that task of educating our students very seriously and I believe we do accomplish that task than you have Civics we have Civics integrated throughout our

104uh social studies curriculum throughout the entire curriculum and yes it is taught it may not be called Civics because there's many different areas to be taught but yes Civics is taught uh what I'd like to do because I I don't know if we have the time to you know pursue all this uh uh at this meeting I'd like to uh turn this over to to the curriculum committee Dr alvik and Mr calman and they can discuss it there and get more information for you okay anybody from the board want to comment there's more people anybody yes I thought I saw a hand up uh good evening folks Richard Gibbons 4:15 Schoolhouse Road in regards what the superintendent said and what Mr proso said uh one way to clear that up would be to um uh

105give the possibly the senior class A Civics test and if all of this curriculum is incorporated um give them a Civics test before they leave school see what they know um I'd be willing to bet that most of the kids probably don't know for instance one example would be the first amendment what freedoms do we have under the First Amendment I'd be willing to bet that probably 80 or 90% of the kids wouldn't be able to answer that so I think that would be one recommendation to give the pacifics test and see what they actually know thank you very much well that's one reason why I wanted to turn it over to the uh curriculum committee so they can discuss it uh there uh I think I just want to make one comment I think

106that um you know this is this as you're perceiving it um I think most districts most school systems throughout the country teach Civics in American history uh the question is I think what we're up against is a media problem because there's no way we can compete with what the kids see on TV and uh you know and magazines Etc and and on their computers so that's that's I think part of the problem it's just a comment I want I wanted to make it's hard to compete against that media it's hard to go up against the celebrities that's seems to be a little bit more attractive unfortunately than than um you know Civics but that's what we're up against and and um uh we have to keep pursuing this and I'm sure the school systems throughout

107the country do all right thank you anyone else from public again Mr Klein Mark Klein seven kenure uh I I have something else to say but in this case it's this generation never served or many of them the bulk of them never served in the armed forces they never served in war they never fought for this country or represented this country and I'm not saying you know maybe it was uh um misunderstood but we're not comp well they're not complaining about what's taught in our schools what I see is throughout the country they're being inundated with I'm going to call it propaganda but anyway what I came here for is those of you who heard or read about Christie's plan for more money Equalization of State funds he basically came up with a plan that

108I mentioned eight years ago and that was that every student's worth the same no matter where they lived um if you went on the site you were able to put in your Township under his plan at $6,500 a student we would receive $46 million not the three or4 million 46 million which we said years ago was our fair share okay um he did bring up in his report in Nork New Jersey the charter schools were graduating upwards of 89% of their students whereas it was reported that their regular Public Schools were graduating about 45% their public schools are spending $30,000 a year per student to educate them these Charter Schools were 13,000 to 17,000 now they're in line with what we spend so you figure something like this we know that the formula is wrong

109we know that giving more money to the 31 districts is a fallacy it doesn't promote better education this is the ideal opportunity to have bipartisan support in Trenton but what you have is you have the Democrats refuse to support it they want it to go the way it is they're worried about cutting money from the inner city where the money is wasted Newark New Jersey my friend was a teacher after he retired out of New York York they had this elementary school they had store rooms full of brand new books never used store rooms full of brand new computers never used because they're cutting deals with their suppliers so there's Kickbacks there's theft as we found out with camon when they got audited okay I have sent letters lately after this for support of his

110plan the letters went to and bear with me please the letters went to Chris Christie to compliment them on finally doing the right thing chief justice rabner could you wrap it up oh give me a break I am come on I'm bleeding give me a break so I can get home I'll give you a few seconds more that's it no I need more well I'm almost finish chief justice rabner state supreme court they have found in the Abbott decisions there were 20 decisions of which the nework education Law Center one roughly of those 201 17 of them they never rolled back Christie's cuts for them but they did I did they cut for them they reversed for them didn't do for us or any other districts Mr K give you okay you've had listen you've

111had your time if there's any let me ask you is there anyone else in the public wanting to uh speak all I want to do is it's a couple of more minutes it's I'm not complaining I'm trying to give you pertinent understand that I can sit down and I can come back after they finish speaking Mr CL I we may have to do that I'll do it you have to speak thank you okay okay so now you had Sweeney you spoke about that Senator Sweeney well I should say Senate President Sweeney was going to cut a deal to give us more money I spoke to Sweeney at the mayor's breakfast he knew who I was and he says don't worry if my program goes through you'll get $2 million more $2 million doesn't cover our

112increase from one year to the next I said well what he was going to do is there was there was a a uh District a school district in his district that was getting 145% of their budget from the state another uh District was getting 65% and he says well that's unfair I said I agree with you what about if you're only getting 3% I said why can't you go after the 31 districts that the money's being wasted oh we can't touch anything that the Supreme Court Judge yeah came out in the decision well baloney how many more hundreds of billions of dollars is this state going to waste and that's exactly what they're doing at our expense um now what I am going to do now now those letters went out and those of you

113that I I am I'm finished now that have their EMA I have your email address I've sent you the letters I will now send them them to you Doctor thank you Mr CL lastly no lastly last thing Mr I am now going to find out how much the Newark education Law Center receives in fees for every time they win and you got to be talking hundreds of millions of do you've gone Way Beyond your limit that's it I have to end this your time I didn't say I didn't say it wasn't valuable I said you went beyond beyond your limit okay anyone else from the public I don't know if they're getting up or leaving yes okay I appreciate thank you very much give five minutes uh just a quick qu wait what I have

114to say my name your name your address you have jeppe banov uh 49 jeli Road uh just a quick question for the new uh schools that you guys plan on building on the lon land uh what is the expected uh way to fund the construction is it through taxes increase or or is it just through Gathering we would have to do we would have to uh do a bond referendum which is vote the public will be voting uh to approve of bonds to secure the money for those okay might I propose that when that referendum is set to allow the the township the Comm the residents in the township first option to buy those so that the the the money that's uh being spent stays in the Comm has an opportunity to stay in the

115community instead of being sent out to let's say the banks and uh other International investors that buy these bonds um as Mr Rybeck said the financing source will be um tax-free municipal bonds sold by the district and there will also be a component of state aid through death service relief that will help uh reimburse the district for principal and interest subject to annual appropriation by the state um as far as the bond sale itself to maximize or in this case minimize the interest exposure to the district the bonds are sold through public bidding public auction and those um auction houses bidding on the bonds with the lowest interest rate which would in essence keep down the borrowing cost to the Monroe Community um are the ones awarded the bid so it would not be a

116fair in process to um make it subject to Monroe residents first although I I appreciate the creativeness of the idea I just say because you don't it would rather keep the money in the community so that it could be spent on local businesses instead of outside and uh I guess to the guy uh I'm a graduate of mon tan High School 5 years ago and the first amendment is freedom of speech um okay anybody else from the f are you just saying hello there no this is only one sentence that you wouldn't let me finish all of those letters copies was sent to state senator Linda Greenstein State assemblyman uh Wayne dangelo and state assemblyman um Dan Benson I hope they are watching this they can no longer give us an excuse that it's the

117other party or it's somebody else this has to change now you cannot the state cannot expect Township residents in Monroe Township to pay for schools that they badly need when you go into um New Brunswick they built a high school for 187 million we're around 123 million we came an under budget they were over budget all paid for by the state they had two new elementary schools totally paid for by the state and we can't get nothing from the state thank you very much and I leave my two minutes to somebody else thank you anyone else in the public and not seeing anyone from the public we can go to the Clos session resolution before we do however um because we're going to be talking about uh superintendent meral Administration could not participate in that

118so it's recommended that the Board of Education appoint Tom noin as temporary board secretary for the remainder of this meeting in accordance with njsa 18a colon 16- 1.1 so moved second second all right all in favor I any opposed okay that passes and now um uh be it resolved that the Board of Education of the Tas Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 23 1 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 4-21 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying we we will not be doing Donaldson appearance uh today and we will be discussing attorney advice discussion regarding superintendent Merit goals pursuant to the employment agreement between the superintendent and the board following close session action may be taken the discussion

119conducted in close session can be uh disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists some moved I have a second second all in favor I any oppose okay uh we'll be going in the Clos session we would take approximately I'm saying approximately an hour okay well let's get back we're still in session um I'd like a motion to approve the following it is recommended that the Board of Education one approve the previously previously submitted Merit goals for the superintendent of schools for the 201617 school year subject to approval by the executive County Superintendent of Schools and two direct the superintendent to submit the Merit goals to the executive County Superintendent for review and approval so moved second I'm sorry you go ahead no no you go Paul all

120in favor I I too much time unanimous unanimous on that okay um I seen no one from the public so we can wait wait wait hold on a second I think you have to do a roll call on yeah oh it just unanimous roll okay sorry secretary sorry sorry I thought I thought we only had to do the uh St sobody from the public Mar Klein wants to talk okay thank you Scot okay all all those uh we're we're going to be voting on the reso um Michelle armino yes Miss Jill Deo yes Mr calman M Miss dor Steve Ryback yes Frank Russo accused okay Mr board president no Paul oh yeah I'm sorry go next I'm sorry Paul Mr Paul rutsky yes Mr board secretary Mr board president the motion you get his vote

121Yes yes the motion has passed with four voting yes uh and two recusals based on the majority of a quorum being for no five should be five five yeses oh boy Mike's got a tough job give you this job once yes you voted right Mr yes I did not count my own vote exact sen a motion passes yes thank you good okay uh next scheduled Board of Education meeting is Wednesday August 31st 7 p.m. right here in the High School uh I'd like to um M Mr Rybeck could you see if there's anyone in the public you have to announce the public forum did oh did you I did oh I'm sorry that's that's okay I know we're all a little tired apologize that's right you're in time I'd like a motion to adjourn soov

122all all in favor we don't need a roll call vote on this now

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.