CorpusRecord 132971

Monroe Township Board of Education 08.31.16 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
8,944 words · about 50 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening this meeting of the Monroe Township Board of Education is now called to order I'd ask that you all join me and rise for the pledge I pledge Ali to the FL of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you Mr Lori may have a roll [Music] call M armenio yes Mr Braverman here Mr de Mayo here Mr calman here Mrs Co Pano here Mr nosin yes Mrs Corino here Mr Ryback here Mr Russo here and Mr rutsky here board president you have a quarum present this evening thank you okay we can move for approval of minutes oh I'm sorry state in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe

002Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted August 26th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski now we can move to the approval of uh minutes I need a motion to approve the minutes of the special uh public Board of Education meeting May 18th 2016 second any discussion you can vote all in favor I opposed had 100% in favor um motion to approve the minutes of special uh public Board of Education meeting of June 7th 2016 no moved second second thank you okay any discuss I abstain I don't think I there any discussion could vote I all in favor I any opposed that passes um

003a motion to uh approve the Clos session meeting of June 7th 2016 moved second thank you uh any discussion all in favor I oppos abstain okay motion passes I'm up to the June 15th I think yeah um a motion to approve the public Board of Education meeting of June 15th 2016 second thank you um any discussion we could vote all in favor I any opposed or any extensions okay motion passes finally motion to approve the closed session meeting of June 15th 2016 I moved second second okay uh any discussion on many uh that that closed session on June 15th was the issue resolved it was the superintendent's evaluation so it was a resolved issue right or we completed it right yes we just that there was nothing on on the close session minutes that said

004that once something's complete it could be said like how the discussion was so could we get something we need to do something there was nothing on it then that wasn't the goals no it wasn't the goals it was just the finale had nothing to do with the marit okay that's fine I just not be any action there may not be any action there was no action afterwards but the but the minutes could have reflected some discussion right afterwards or no it has to have action it's it's fine I just wanted to establish that okay okay we can vote all in favor I any opposed one one oppose any extensions one exstension motion passes correct yes motion passes okay we can move thank you we can move to uh committee reports any committee chair wanting to

005report Mr calman so the curriculum committee met this evening uh we went over a uh a large number of curriculum items that were adopted falling into the areas of US history there were some math things language art things Health uh Health couple of special ed things right um in addition to those curriculum documents we did discuss the question that was raised the last board meeting which had to do with uh Civics in our district and uh we did you know go over the areas um in which and while there may not be a standalone Civics course that's taught uh we do cover Civics in every grade level from K through 12 at some point in the uh in the curriculum across the board so um we we probably got more information than we really needed

006to about where Civics was being taught so we're uh pretty comfortable there we also discussed the selection criteria for our summer reading program um that we go through each year um and the process is pretty lengthy uh if anybody needs to know more detail about what specifically goes on we could certainly publish the information uh that we have out on the website so um trying to think that pretty much is about it right any questions from Mr calman yes Mr nin um with regard to the Civics question I'm just kind of wondering I know that um uh I've heard kind of Rumblings that while it is a subsid of program um at the end of the day is there any way that we could maybe even just give something as simple as that 20 question

007um citizenship test actually it was brought up in the sense that there was a um a there there were two things that were were done in the past there was one like a requirement for finance related topics and then there was one also related for like a um an assessment for civics related topics right keep me honest the finance one was approved by the state to move forward and they got they got the funding or what have you the Civics one for whatever reason um never got funded uh so it never there's no like assessment across the board like we do have in the finance stuff so possibly in the fure future there may be one but I believe part of the process through your whole assessment beginning to end from year to year will

008include those subject matter things so are you're asking if if we have a what do you know about Civics at the end of the year maybe not but the topics are covered throughout the the history components and I'll let the experts because I have no idea so so yep so what Miss Caleta uh shared with the curriculum committee and I will have these electronically for you in the curriculum committee Google folder um one of the documents that we follow when we look at writing our curriculum for history and social studies are the C3 standards framework this these are the federal standards for social studies and it includes the Civics and government piece um and we also use the New Jersey standard so she actually took some time to go through um some of our curriculum

009documents to highlight the Civic standards that we currently cover throughout our and we cover all of the Civic standards that are included in the federal documents as well as the state documents so they're they're there um it's also recommended from these standards that we embed them not teach it as a separate course but embed them with the history of whatever the students are studying at that time so we actually start in kindergarten with you know teaching Stu students learn right from wrong they learn um how to be uh how to be a friend it goes through our character education program uh third grade we start looking at our community and what the roles in our community are um students actually build a community within their classroom and they become the the people in the community

010and and act that way all the way up through our US history courses um and American studies courses through the high school where we embed all of the Civics and government within those courses okay thank you very much yeah good okay any other committee chair yes braveman uh we met the other uh last night uh tennis court project is uh the bid has been accepted for $46,200 and it will be repaired this fall um we are transferring two vehicles to the fire department they're expired vehicles but it seems that they'd like to do some training on them uh they land transfer from 522 the Route 522 which is right behind the firehouse across the way from the board office uh that transfer was okay and we'll be parking buses there which will make make them

011more Compact and we're updating on the engine in review and proposed land tro transfer at uh Church Road and we have to go ahead for further study uh it seems that there's a lot more Wetlands than we thought uh we anticipated putting two buildings on that property but maybe we'll be able to put one on at any rate it's marvelous that the township is transferring that property to us eventually and and then we had a uh discussion relative to the building Pro to the referendum and we're going on with that and we'll report that later date thank you Mr braan any questions for Mr braan from board members I do yes Mr did the transfer from 522 the 522 transfer to the Board of Ed did that was that completed I Mr President yes the

012building grounds Transportation Comm committee studied a drawing of the proposed transfer of land and how it's going to be divied up the parcel on Buckaloo Avenue behind the firehouse across the street from the Monroe Administrative Building um there's an area of wetlands that will remain in the Township's portfolio of land uh to remain as Wetlands because it uh serves no purpose for either the firehouse or the Board of Education to hold such property the firehouse is going to expand out their backside to allow for in andout traffic for their fire trucks and there's going to be Road access on Schoolhouse Road and Buckaloo Avenue for both the fire trucks and the school buses which would greatly enhance School transportation performance to the schools the drawing is only an update to the committee um there is

013no deed to be transferred yet that will have to be done via formal resolution to the board once that materializes thank you yes how many buses are we going to be able to keep over in that section there's not a definitive number yet uh we can't ascertain that from the drawing but it will be a substantial number that will be a good complement to our Fleet and it will solve our transportation issues with having buses where we can now have more in-house busing probably maybe it will solve it will solve the parking aspect of that the financing and budgeting of that is another issue I just was Wonder about space yes but spacewise for oh space yes space right space but spacewise it would afford a parking area Miss alino um May I just a

014answer um Jill's question Mr Mayo's question about whether the township the township has uh a resolution on its agenda for Monday night um I think that's is that the fourth or fifth it's just a holiday probably not Monday not monay the the the maybe the following Wednesday the next the next public Township Council agenda uh Township council meeting there's a resolution on there to uh I think they haven't sub subdivided the land there's three Parcels one's going to go to as as Mr Gorski said one's going to go to uh fire district three one is going to preserve the wetlands I guess as open space in the open space inventory of the township and then this the third parcel is going to uh hopefully be transferred to the the district um there's an $1,500 um

015resolution to give it to the Township's um engineer to I guess um do a study uh dividing that property so that's the next public meeting to Township thank you okay uh any other committee chair want go Mr knin thank you Mr board president the finance committee met um last evening at 6:00 p.m. and uh for first item of discussion is basically a continuing discussion on the adult ed program the committee had requested um an audit basically of this program to see um if it was uh you know worthwhile uh worthwhile to continue um based on the fact that at the last meeting we learned it was actually losing money um to the tune of almost $34,000 a year so miss Nori was uh um kindly uh was kind enough to come in and present uh

016the information that we requested um such as how courses are decided um the minimum number of participants Etc um to to run the program at the end of the meeting um there was some dissatisfaction with the fact that there was only um roughly 200 people um per semester to register for this and um we're going to still continue looking at this going forward there's some other questions that will be presented to to miss Nori through Mr Gorski that the committee had recommended so uh this is still an ongoing process to see if we can make this this um I I think the consensus was at least to break even um instead of subsidizing some um residents and maybe even some nonresidents uh in this program Mr Gorski explained also uh on item two that he

017did the audit update it is that time of the year again where the cfra the uh comprehensive annual um financial review is up again and it's it's time for um for them to go through everything and actually they're at the process now of testing the transactions um and making sure everything looks good and um the committee has the utmost confidence in uh Mr Gorski and his team that uh they will assist them and everything will uh work out as usual in a good fashion um Mr gor you also mentioned the lease purchase financing we budgeted for some lease purchasing and uh we went out for bid and we didn't have any bids that were received so basically uh we're going to go out and start you know as he said shake the bushes to maybe

018attract some other uh biders but the idea is right now is that we feel that the interest rates are very low so it isn't uh that uh lucrative for a financing company or a bank to come in and do this so um we're going to still continue and uh last but not least the finance committee uh recommended that we go ahead with uh the cost for uh developing the uh the methods and the criteria for a referendum that's going to include a financial adviser a bond counselor and an architect proposals um time is of the essence and this proposal for the financial adviser Bond counsel and architect it's not incumbent upon the current 65 acres that we're looking for it's a very very generic study um of course not the architect necessarily but the other

019the financial adviser in the bond Council so the committee felt it was uh made sense to go ahead with this because uh time is of the essence and we have to move forward and um that concludes my report Mr President thank you Mr nin any questions for Mr norstein not seeing any questions and uh we can now move to the oh I'm sorry Mr Mayo um I apologize okay there was a Personnel meeting last week to review all the new hires for the school year um we have a substantial amount of new hires coming in um in addition earlier towards in the beginning of the uh the spring I had concerns about all the people I saw resign and I noticed that there was a bunch of teachers leaving in midcareer which raised concern for

020me so I had the administration create a list of all the staff members and why they were leaving over the past year so we could look at that to make sure we're not losing valuable Talent um of the 77 that resigned this past year 29 retired 23 left for a new job elsewhere um nine didn't give a reason six reloc at two are attending school uh three left to care for children and five left for other reasons um we need to keep an eye on this because we don't want to be losing teachers um to move to other districts because we know that Monroe is one of the Lesser paid districts so the Personnel is committee is going to keep an eye on this to make sure we aren't losing valuable Talent thank you any

021questions from Mr May okay okay yeah I'm sorry I just have my report sure okay um this is a report from the policy committee uh on uh for this month prior to this meeting we entertained 17 new policies and regulations I'm not going to go through them each individually uh but they're on the website and this is the first reading for those uh on the agenda this evening there are 31 policies and regulations that we put forward last month and are on tonight's agenda for a second reading so um we had quite a busy two months thank you thank you any questions for not seeing any questions we can move to the first public forum um let me just say that when you come up to the microphone we'll ask you to give your name

022and your address and uh this pertains only your comment or question can pertain at this point only to the agenda and um we are going to have a three minute time limit I ask that you respect that time limit anyone from the public interested in speaking good evening my name is Doug boy I live at Ford tamarak Road uh you are dealing with the goals for both the Board of Education as well as the district goals for the year 201617 and I see that you do have them up there although I don't think anyone would be able to read them uh from back here but if they picked up a copy of it over there then they can read it uh the second goal under the district goals uh it says uh use targeted data

023to create a long-term plan based on data analysis derived from the special ed external program review it then goes on to talk about analyzing multiple data elements uh to improve individual student achievement it's that that additional part there that I just would like clarification does that apply to all of the students attending schools in the district or or just basically to the students that are in the special ed program since the lead off is talking about the special ed program I have Dr kosak respond to that it's primarily we we had the the study of our special ed services to look to see if we if there were gaps in uh students learning that were our special needs students but the really the study overlapped into our general Ed studies is uh or with students

024as well and especially when we look down at the younger grade levels the K through second grade levels and what's referred to is uh response to intervention RTI and our intervention and referral services and basically what we're looking at are services or strategies to maybe improve students reading skills so they either are not classified or at least brought up closer to grade level you know before they are classified so putting in interventions that can be applied before they are referred to the child study team so this goal there were I believe 19 or 20 recommendations that came out of this study and each one of those recomend a had subcategories as well we're we uh are prioritizing the recommendation so that we can employ new strategies over the next several years the multiple data points

025will refer to we might use a map testing uh we might look at writing samples we might look at math scores so that's the multiple data points and really if we work to improve how we deliver instruction to all students especially those students are struggling some of those students may be General a and some of those students may be special ed Mr P does that answer your question I believe so okay okay it's just that I I found the statement of gold to a little confusing because as I said it starts off talking about special ed right and yet as I read further I said well it sounds like it's also maybe including some general ed students as well yes it it does really does okay the under the board goals uh and I don't

026claim to be The Brightest Bulb uh on the chandelier but I read this board goal I've read it multiple times a a and uh it I don't know what this is saying I I don't know what this which one are you talking about goal number two I I it's a total Enigma to me in terms of what I read so I hope the members of the board understand it and I hope someone can explain to me what it means as let me try um I think we're U similar age and we have about the same ability and level in in technology so I think we we'll talk along the same plane uh basically what we need is uh a system where any one of us could access information and feel comfortable doing it and do

027we have a system for that no that's what we're going to be looking to to come up with so we'll be looking into it and and hopefully come up with the system so if we want to look at uh look up a policy uh for examp example it would be easy for us to do it and understand how to do it because there's you know 10 of us here with different ability levels and in technology and uh so we need to come up with some idea that it'll make it um easy for board members to find access information from whatever topic they they need but we don't have the answer yet that's the idea that and having been on the board I I would completely support that because I know I struggled at times myself

028trying to find information I think what threw me off is where it says it will support everyone's requirements and actually what you're talking about there is every board member's requirements yes okay and one final question if I still have time uh there is an item under board action uh I'm sorry under the uh business administrators report item L which which talks about uh spending about $63,000 or so uh on this web based map uh if someone could simply explain to the public what is that what students would that be applied to and how will that information be used Mr President yes uh may I ask Dr Alvi to take that that's letter L on page 27 nwaa map is an online assessment system to take the place of our benchmarks it's standards based to help

029us to make sure that we're preparing our students before they have to take the state assessment um so it's an online assessment the students would be tested three times a year in math and reading it would take the place of the current benchmarks that we have that were District developed benchmarks um and they're more standards based so that information will be available immediately after students finish the assessment to the teachers so teachers will have that data in order to drive their instruction instead of waiting like we do to get the information back from the state assessments and and what grade levels are students does it apply to for this year we're looking at K through 8 we're going to Pilot it in a couple of classes at the high school because we're not sure it

030meets our needs at the high school at this time so we weren't we weren't going to move forward with it at the high school um K through two uh no I'm sorry K and one are more of a primary assessment um screening uh letter recognition sound recognition that type of thing um basic math principles um to give the students and it's much obviously a much shorter assessment for those students in the younger grades it gets a little longer as they move up to the higher grades the longest the assessment is is 45 minutes and like I said we would do it three times a year we're currently doing benchmark assessments four times a year in math and language arts um and this would take the place of that okay thank you thank you Mr good

031evening uh chrisy gerby uh 21 press Drive um I was going through the agenda and I can't find um enrollment numbers I was wondering if somebody could um tell us what the enrollment numbers are um what the changes have been over the summer the new enrollment yeah the enrollment numbers aren't on the agenda we start putting them on on in September I know that this summer based on the person who registers the students she told me that it's some around 200 students that we have registered uh this summer alone and um so that would put our number we we probably it's 65 6600 6700 somewhere around that we still have students registering pretty much every day uh but the September agenda we will have that um exact number okay and where has the biggest enrollment

032been is there one particular school um I I don't have the data in front of me I know that we had students enter the high school and I was thinking maybe just Elementary but we had students entering the high school the middle school and Elementary uh spread across um I didn't bring the I can look it up actually I have it I can probably find it online oh no I can't it's some my to hard drive uh but I think it's spread around the different elementary schools uh although probably the I if I had to remember correct you know if I'm remembering correctly I would say most of it's probably in the oak tree area oak tree Applegarth area although we did see increases in all of our elementary schools how many students will oak

033tree be starting with this year for for how many in oak tree like by the end of the year no uh next week yes again I don't I don't have that data we don't know how many students are starting at Oak Tree all together yeah um I can look it up I'm I'm just curious to see what the how much that has increased um before the building goes up on the corner of Route 33 the condos in the tow houses which my next question is um how many outstanding um residential contract students are coming in that do not currently reside in Monroe do we do we know how many that is yes we have that's actually part of the background material uh that's with this and I can look that up I have the number

034here I would say that's oak tree okay 688 students for oak tree and as far as the number of people that are have registered children that don't have a house built yet our policy allows them up to 60 days and when I was reviewing the materials for the board agenda tonight I believe it came across about uh 10 but I can look that up in a minute and give you an exact number okay so it's 60 days from the time they signed their contract 60 days from what time period so if if their house will be built within 60 days they can attend the school by policy if it goes beyond that then they're charged a uh tuition rate per day oh how much is that 7475 hours a day I think it is somewhere

035around that $75 a day I think so around that they Contin around that amount I believe okay so if if they're got pushed back they can continue in the school district for $75 a day well but they have to they have to um produce documents from a builder they have to produce legal documents that says the state that they're moving in to the district okay they're having a house built yeah I'm just curious how soon um children can start attending uh with the building that's going to be starting and we don't have what is what is the time frame um for when we're going to go out possibly for a referendum and then start building a new elementary school because of the timelines that the state imposes we need about six months to go in

036for the referendum process and because of the time that we're using now to study land availability and other um concerns we're probably looking at fall of 2017 to go out for a referendum that's just to go out for the referendum yes so Mike my question is Oak Tre starting at 688 by the end of this year going into 2017 they could be over 700 what will the board be doing as a stop Gap measure to make more room in that school between now and I guess maybe what four or five years until we get another Elementary School will you entertain the idea of trailers I think we may have to as much as I hate to do that because you're it's cost so much money but I think we may have to do that as

037a stop Gap measure as well as the Middle School the middle school is way overcrowded today yeah with last summer as you probably know we we uh reconfigured some of the spaces to add additional classroom space we did that also this summer in our High School uh to use some other spaces for instruction so yeah we're up against the wire with that and you know I pass the construction every single day looking at that and that's why we're trying to move this process along um it's a it's a rather complicated process I wish I could move it quicker uh because the builders will will outpace us with houses before we're able to build new schools absolutely now is it uh a definite I I missed the last board meeting um is it definite going to

038be a new elementary school and a new Middle School well again a lot of things come into play We we need to house elementary students and we need to house middle school students our high schools also could use an addition there are questions of land Ava availability the usability of a land that might of land that might be available the cost of what a referendum would be and what this community would be able to support the um I mean you know there's educational concerns as well I don't see any way that we could get away without building a new elementary school and the middle school seems to be our option as of now there are other things that we looked at with the student growth advisory committee such as keeping sixth grade in our current

039elementary schools which would then require adding additions to our current schools we're exploring that we're exploring as many options as we can because we're not really sure until we get all the reports and all the studies back you know what will be available okay so we're not we don't have a concrete plan of what we're going to do well we don't we don't even have the land yet so we have the land being promised from the township but we had to engage uh Engineers to look at the land to see as Mr Braverman mentioned from the buildings and grounds report you know are there concerns are there some of the area Wetlands uh we it's 65 acres originally we thought middle and an elementary school but we have to wait for that report to come

040back to tell us us will that still be able to house a middle middle in an elementary school you know we will we have to look at Applegarth doing something behind Applegarth well we have to look at possibly adding additions to other schools we have to keep all of our options open until we can get clearance for the land especially that's probably our our number one priority um you know uh and then anything else that comes up okay just wasn't sure how far along we were in the process to add one thing what Dr kak was saying um we do have a plan uh it's for a new Elementary a new middle and extension on the high school well that's what I just asked is that a concrete that is the is that the concrete

041plan that's been approved and what Dr uh kosak was saying we can't make anything concrete yet because we don't have the information that we need uh as far as you know okay so we don't have a definitive plan that we're following yeah it's that's what I was want are we still looking at other options or is it still a possibility instead of a middle school having an intermediate school of you know Sixth and sth having K through five at the elementary a 67th school and or a 56 school I'm sorry I feel that's you saying and and the answer is right now we're we're looking at a middle Elementary right and we're waiting to get all our answers back so that we can go forward okay and when when will we have those that study

042done is that study being conducted currently oh it's in process yeah so we we're receiving little bits of information but nothing definitive yet they normally need about six months we've asked them to uh move the process along as quickly as they can being the you know we have so many houses being built in the township that uh 6 months is a long time so they're doing the best they can to complete the report in a shorter time span okay and how much is that study uh Mr gki what was the amount of that study Mr President Edward Edwards engineering who's doing the engineering study was about 13,000 right 13,000 okay all right thank you thank you anyone else from the public not seeing anyone from the public uh in addition uh we can move to

043our superintendent's report Dr KAC sure okay well as I'm sure all of you know by now students uh schools open for students on Tuesday and I think I can speak for everyone saying that we are all looking forward to seeing the students and the excitement for learning that they bring to our school buildings our building Renovations will be completed before school opens on Tuesday on behalf of the Board of Education I would like to extend and a thank you to all of our staff for their hard work this summer there was a lot of our maintenance workers our custodians um you know teachers staff there was just a number of people that work throughout the summer so we do appreciate that our bus drivers um I've been in contact with SE several parents and community

044members who are helping to facilitate our college and corporate uh partnership initiative and um I'll have more news on this in the future but I'm pretty excited by what we're by the the uh the parents who reached out and and are more than willing to help us make connections with corporations and with universities to offer resources for our students uh we we have some pretty uh what I consider to be pretty exciting ideas and and uh possibilities that are open uh but we're still in the very early stages of that Mr Ryback Mr Gorski and I have continue to explore strategies for securing additional State funding by meeting with legislators over the summer and I know Mr rack normally uh updates everyone on that so I won't go too far on that other than to

045say that we're continuing to try it's it's it's been a little frustrating at times but you know we're meeting with everybody we can from Senate President sweene Sweeney to the commissioner to uh assemblyman and you know Senator Greenstein and others and our mayor uh but it's a it's an ongoing struggle not only for mon Row for other districts as well but it's it's frustrating uh to say the least and Dr Ali Mr gorby Mr Gorski Mr tag and I have continued to explore options pretty much what I was just answering related to the how to housing the growing number of new students that we have received over the summer our transportation department has worked diligently this summer to ensure our buses and our drivers are ready to trans transport our most precious resource and that

046is our kids our students and due to the uh continued registration of new students there may be changes in some of the bus routes during the first couple of weeks uh but we are striving for the most safe and secure manner of Transportation of over 6,500 students on a daily basis and uh as we do every year we ask for our parents to be uh understanding of that and to be patient uh we really I know last year we had some issues and we've worked very hard to try to correct those and uh I'm uh hopefully I'm I'm optimistic not hopefully I'm optimistic cautiously optimistic if you will uh that we'll have a smooth opening with a minimum of uh speed bumps uh no pun intended and lastly uh on the agenda is um I

047think Mr Ryback has stated uh or I'm sorry Mr Mayo uh we have many new staff members to add to our district District to fill the vacancies created by our retirees and resignations and it is my absolute pleasure to recommend this excellent group of candidates to the board for approval tonight so with that that concludes my report Mr President thank you Dr KAC um we can move the Personnel I'd like a motion to uh approve items a through dou soved you have a second okay uh any discussionin thank you just a a quick question with regard to the hiring um how many new hires new positions are uh in this uh tonight that we're approving uh Personnel for douc I me to take that yes Mr President yes Mr notin if your question is how

048many new positions were in the 1617 budget the answer is 23 and are they are all being filled tonight or not yet I believe most of them Dr kak could better answer that but I believe most of them are um not all you'll see a lot of other hires that are due to retirements and um and resignations and things like that but there are 23 new positions in the district on the account of very strong enrollment growth thank you any other discussion Mr Russo just want to ask if can we include on a monthly basis like we have the number of students at each School uh include the number of staff at each school could that be included as well I yeah I guess we could do that do you are you talking about teachers

049Pate professionals custodians employees there are I'm sorry so we know how many employees there are yes well we do but there are there are employees to travel from one school to another um okay but if it's broken down by you could like you do to students could be broken down by schools or as a well yeah I'm saying I can but I'm asking you how inclusive do you want that do you want the the um the custodians the security the yes the numbers by schools by schools okay with thect with the understanding that some staff travel from school to school sure that's okay sure okay anyone else discussion in that case we can have a roll call Vote Yes sir Personnel items a through SS Miss armeno uh yes and I abstain on RR so

050noted Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr kelman yes Mrs kapano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes and I obain on e e thank you very much Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutzky yes Mr board president Personnel items a through SS passes thank you now move to board action um I just like to before I we take a vote any further I'd like to just uh ask people from the audience and certainly on the board we have the district and board goals uh noted on the screens uh for you to see um I'll take a second and take the opportunity to read them so that we can all uh have clarity as to what we're going to be doing uh the the the district goals for 201617 goal one initiate implementation

051and CommunityWide communication for district facilities planning in anticipation of increased enrollment goal two use targeted data to create a long-term plan based on the uh data analysis derived from the special education external program review continue to analyze multiple data elements and identify areas of opportunity to improve individual student achievement identify achievement gaps analyze Benchmark data from NJ dooe on 2016 Park results and possible gaps between district schools goal three conduct an IND District climate survey board goals for 2016 2017 one each board member will attend one training session in addition to the state mandated governance training each year goal two establish a plan and implement the cohesive document data management system which will support everyone's board members um requirements and provide an intuitive library system for all district data and documentation goal three evaluate and

052adopt the plan for enrollment growth and facility needs I'd like a motion to improve to approve items a through o on the board agenda mve I have a second second any discussion I have a discussion yes Mr may it would not be it would be remiss of me if I didn't talk about the high school graduation policy okay so while I'm voting yes for this policy I would like to reiterate that I believe the Statewide assessment section allowing only one option for the graduation for the class of 20 2020 and Beyond is wrong for the students of New Jersey furthermore the education Law Center and the New Jersey ACLU have detailed multiple ways while this VI policy violates State Statute and I'll just give you one example the state statute requires that State graduation tests

053measure Proficiency in grade 11 using Park Ela grade 10 and park algebra exam the algebra exam is only given the year that the child takes Algebra 1 um violates the state law um I have their statement on it if anybody's interested it is my hope that the New Jersey doe corrects this before the students in New Jersey are adversely affected by this thank you any other discussion saw many um board action uh two The Residency contracts a just want to remind the public that it's policy 5111 and tonight we're approving uh if it's gets approved 10 residency but I my question is during the year we're approving it for this month it could we we may be um we get we may get more throughout the year and like next month may have some additional

054ones is that correct it's an ongoing yes situation okay and there is there is something in the letters um that the parents are signing that does talk about an end date for if they if they don't actually live in the Community by that after the 60 days so yes people can take a look at that if they're interested thank you any other discussion Mr gki we have a roll call President yes I'm sorry to do the vote I just wanted to provide clarification on an answer when if you let's do all vote okay board action items a through o Miss armeno yes Mr Braverman Mr Mayo yes Mr calman yes to all I'm going to recuse on alen only because there are so many that I would have to do individually I'm just going to

055do them all thank you sir Mrs K Peno yes Mr nosin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky so I obain on everything except item H where I vote yes thank you very much sir Mr board president board action items 8 through o has passed thank you uh Mr Gorski we now up to the administrator's report recommendations Mr board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through n be approved by consent roll call moved second second discussion any discussion yes Miss KS um I noticed that we are doing we are having a resolution that will ask the legislators from the state of New Jersey to F fulfill its con constitutionally assigned duty to distribute thank you state aid

056for education in mono because we don't get our fair share and I know we've done this many times I'm sure many of us around this table have spoken to many people during the year year years many years going back and while this I think is a great continuation of what we're doing I think we need to start using the Press more um working with the TV stations working with the newspapers to get our um what our concerns out because I don't mean to cut you short but could you hold that until I I I do my report on the resol because this is I don't think this pertains to the resolution doesn't pertain to what Mr Gorski was talking about and I certainly want to hear what everything you have to say but we're going

057to have an up opportunity to do that when I do my report we're not doing this resolution Now not no not now I was going to do it as part of president's report okay I'm sorry I thought it I thought it was in the no I apologize I I now you make me forget I want to hear everything no I want to hear everything that you have to say but I I I'm sorry I thought it was Mr gorsky's report no that's okay okay uh we could vote Mr M oh Mr um thank you Mr President um just a quick question with regard to the tennis tennis court restoration um what is I I see we're obviously awarding that bid this evening I'm just wondering what is the time frame for that and um are

058they going to do them all at once so they'll be shut down or will it be in in segments yes you I'm at a loss on the time frame I have to uh ask Mr tag as far as that had everything else specific for the bid um in preparation for tonight but uh the time frame escapes me but it'll be um the during a time where it would be least invasive to the students and and gym and and co-curricular programs I apologize for I actually thought of it last night after the bg& meeting and and then I forgot to tell you today but okay thank you oh I'm sorry one more question board president may I um on L the the evaluation Association the webbased map um uh is that an online assessment system for

059what the students are learning or is it a test prep system or both but which is [Music] it you okay okay um I'm going to say both but that's not what it's meant for it's meant to give the staff the information that they need more information about how their students are doing with regards to the standards and they'll do it at multiple times throughout the year so they'll have this data at their fing finger tips multiple times throughout the year there's actually short assessments they could give in between if they chose to if they wanted to do more assessments than that but it's basically for that I think one of the benefits is it will give our students more practice with online assessments so it's not NE it's not necessarily a test prep program it's

060more to give data to the teachers for teaching but they will be asked instructional questions is that correct they will be tested on their in instructional learning yes things that they've learned okay okay thank you thank you anyone else just just a follow-up question to Mr mino's Question um I remember vaguely correct me for this was all um approved by the curriculum committee right I this went through there I remember a report in the past okay thank you Mr notin uh the answer to your question just came to me amazing according to Mr T our facility director um the tennis court restoration will be completed this fall by mid to late November and it will be staggered in a way so that it it will at least impact the programs thank you very much Mr

061T and you and um I just want to thank um Mr Gorski we are going to be voting on N is that correct yes that's the the tenis court but I'd like to thank you for actually explaining the bid process putting letting people know that there were three bids on this and how we have to do it choosing the lowest bid and actually putting the number that the taxpayers are going to be paying so I think it's wonderfully transparent and I really appreciate the detail in the resolution so our residents know um exactly how the process is going and and what the bill is so I really appreciate uh all the efforts on that President yes uh thank you very much Miss armeno for that comment and we have some additional um information on the

062tennis court matter that uh I don't want to steal the Thunder from our board president but it's forthcoming so stay tuned okay Kathy and I will be waiting anticipation anyone else I think we can vote now okay board action items a through N Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs colano yes Mr nosin yes yes and recuse on K so noted Mrs Keno yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rky so I think it's easier this time if I tell you the ones I say yes to and any letters I don't give you I abstain on very good so I'm going to go yes on a 1 through3 d e f h i m and n you very much that was very easy Mr board president board action

063items through n has passed that concludes my report thank you Mr uh before I give my report I know Dr kosak has some information that yeah just to answer the question about the registrations although we don't have the student registration for August yet because still August as as of right now uh I do have the information for July so for I'm going to give you the information for the total number of new students for each of the schools our high school for again this the month of July um 14 students the middle school 11 Applegarth 6 Brookside 2 Woodland 1 Barkley Brook 4 mil Lake 7 oak tree 24 and one out of District school but yes so that's a number thank you thank you okay up to my report um I just like to

064touch base on what Mr bravman was talking about Mr nin was talking about it has to do with the tennis uh Court um we learned that our building grounds and transportation meeting that uh in fact the U the lowest bid was $46,200 more than we had anticipated we authorized um Mr Gorski to ask the town since the town was uh originally uh said that they would be paying for the uh tennis uh court if they would also pick up this extra $46,200 Mr Gorski did so and today we got a a verbal reply that um it is being considered so I feel very positive about this our mayor has been very helpful to us through this whole process with the development and um uh certainly is is willing to to help us further with this

065extra $46,200 and and I publicly thank uh mayor tamboro for that uh let me move on to um our next uh situation which has to do with uh uh our state aid and hopefully Mr Kalan which I'll be addressing some of your concerns that you've brought up um it's no secret that our state aid has been inequitable to say the least our district is growing and we've spoken about this time and time again and um not going to stop until we get some improvement we're not going to quit as Dr kosac said we're going to keep going at it um we have right now I think over a thousand unhoused students and and and that's just the tip of the iceberg these developments are coming in and we have to prepare for them and we're

066doing everything possible and we're also considering foremost the education of the of the children class size is extremely important uh we we know that taxes are extremely important we all pay taxes we hear we talk to the community and we know what's concerning you and it concerns us as well um there have been resolutions in the past I'm I'm POS positive of that I'm going to introduce one uh uh this evening which probably has a little different bent on it some different information but the goal is to continue until we get some recognition a positive recognition in the form of improved state aid from Trenton it seems that Although our state legislators are working with us and and and sensitive to our issues Trenton in general moves very slowly and and getting things done is

067is not that easy uh All of Us wish it could it could be easy but it's not what is that easy button that they advertise on on TV I wish we had one because we'd be pressing it but it's it's not there uh and and yes we do have to uh have press releases and we do have to take other B very we're very very sure of that but that doesn't mean that we shouldn't still send up resolutions and show our resolve for improving state state aid we need to get this and we're not going to take it it's not going to go away we're going to keep going at it with them uh until we see some improvement and some action because we deserve it we're working very hard we're getting excellent results and

068we're just not getting the money from Trenton that we deserve so that being said I'd like to move the following motion and hope that the board will will approve this whereas the Monroe Township Board of Education board attests that the state's ongoing failure to fully fund the school funding Reform Act of 2008 is continuing to place an unreasonable burden on the Monroe Township District and the taxpayers of Monroe and whereas over the past eight school years School enrollment in the district has increased in excess of 1,330 students it's upwards of 25% and whereas over this same 8-year uh time period the district has experienced a cumulative decrease in state aid of 2,122 n26 it's minus 39% and whereas fair and Equitable state aid funding is essential in order for the district to be able to

069continue to meet the comprehensive and diverse needs of its growing special education population which currently encompasses 18% of the total student population and on which 25% of the district's annual budget Appropriations are expended and whereas the board and District administration have pursued all avenues to reverse this pattern in of inequitable state fund funding and whereas the state aid and the board will receive for the current fiscal year is only 3.09% of the board's total revenue to support the school budget and is one of the lowest state aid per pupil ratios in the county and whereas the deficiency in state aid funding noted above has placed an undue burden on the tax payers of Monroe Township who are left to Bear the burden of 87.9% of the financial resources necessary to support the annual budget Appropriations

070and whereas this undue burden is substantially increased in view of the fact that more than onethird of the residents of Monroe Township are 65 years and older and most of these residents are living on a fixed income and whereas as a result of the inequitable state funding the board is now confronted with more than 1,000 house students in the district with over 1500 more expected in the next 5 years as well as aging facilities and whereas in order to be able to continue to provide the comprehensive Educational Services and programs necessary to meet the needs of the district students fair and adequate State funding is needed now therefore be it resolved that the Monroe Township Board of Education hereby calls upon the legislature of the state of New Jersey to fulfill its constitutional assigned duty

071to distribute state aid for education to the Monroe Township School District in a fair and Equitable manner in order to ensure free and appropriate public education for district students and two directs the business administrator board secretary to send a copy of this resolution to the Governor Chris Christie Senate President Steven Sweeney Commissioner of education and all legislators representing Monroe Township moved I have a second I second okay thank you uh any discussion now Mrs Cal I forget what I said before um but you were talking about I know I I remember um I I think this is great that we're continuing to con yes to contact the people that we need to contact and we've been doing this for years we've written our own legislation we've gone to Trenton many of us have talked to

072our Senators and our assembly people um and recently I was reading that Freehold and Lakewood got money from the state that the state said they didn't have to give anybody that's right so I I we're going to be asking our taxpayers to fund a re a referendum in the future and I think we need the publicity to let them know what we're doing why we're doing it and why we're not getting what we need from the state I think press conferences I think getting the newspapers more involved and giving um our side of the story because outside of a resolution or what we hear nobody outside kind of listens to us we go to Trenton and Trenton doesn't they ignore us and I think we've been ignored too many times maybe if we got more

073media coverage that it will help us because I think the bottom line is we need a referendum and if they're not going to give us any more money we need to work with our taxpayers to get everybody to understand what we're doing why we're doing it so while I think this is good I think we have to continue to do more I couldn't agree more and and um I think that the board the superintendent uh and I think you maybe want to address some of this but uh um I think uh press releases uh are are a key thing we have to find new ways of getting this out there because you're absolutely right uh about Freehold and uh uh there was no money we were told there's no money and then all of a

074sudden I think the state came up with um 85% of the $35 million bond for freeold uh and Lakewood and and Lakewood came out to 7.2 million dollar uh to form a Consortium for busing so for that they have the money but for Monroe they don't so I don't know what's going on in Trenton I know our representatives are are working with us but it's more than just them Trenton is a lot lot more legislators than just that and uh I don't want to get into Political push and pull but um you know we have to get our message out there in every way possible and I just like to add one and I'm going to speak to the the residents I think it's important for all of you to contact the legisl legislature uh

075your representatives and express your feelings about the lack of state aid that we have and how deserving we are of it we are in desperate need of state aid it's very difficult for us to come to you and ask you to fund uh so much of the educational bill but it's it's all we have to do this because we're not getting anything from the state and that's got to stop we deserve more than that so you're absolutely right but I think that we have to continue with this oh absolutely any any other discussion on this Mr Gorski Mr President yes Mr President having been involved in this issue for over a decade now and and having written the in District prepared legislation that was sponsored by Senator Greenstein um U assemblyman D'Angelo and Benson which

076is still alive um it's with a great sense of frustration that I also appreciate this resolution and I think that the greatest stimulus for change right now in state funding will be from public pressure we need to turn up the heat on Trenton particularly to the governor and and State president Senate President Sweeney and demand Fair funding for Monro Township Schools that is one of the most effective means for change that will be the residents voices in this regard we're doing all we can administratively we're meeting with everybody who will meet with us but we need we need the support of the townships 40,000 residents okay Dr Co yeah I mean I and I I agree with Mrs k panovich Mr um Gorski Mr Rybeck and and the entire board Dr Ali you know we've

077been we've been reaching out to commissioner legislators and I feel that the people that represent Monroe are working hard to try to get that funding but with the number of students that we have coming in it's just it's ludicrous that our funding has stayed flat well while some other districts where their enrollment has gone down they're still receiving funding for the number of students that maybe they had two three four five years ago so you know I like the idea of trying to get it out more to the media um and publicizing it and I also agree with Mr Gorski that you know from talking to legislators over the years it really they really do listen when community members contact them sometimes when super you know School superintendents or school officials or Boards of Ed

078come in it's like okay we've heard them we're hearing them again but when the individuals in the community start reaching out and writing letters and contacting legislators and letting them know that you're dissatisfied with the enrollment that we're re or not the enrollment the state aid that we're receiving in this District I'm hopeful that they'll be more willing to listen we need to approach this on multiple fronts so I'm all in favor of that and we'll continue doing what we're doing and we'll try to expand the um our message through the media thank you any other discussion Mr Russo I was just going to say I I think that the residents do contact them um they keep getting elected right just same people we've had for many many years so they believe they're doing the

079right thing thank you I don't want to get into Political discussions I just wanted noted that we are not getting the state aid that that we we need and how the public handles that is is up to them any other discussion from the board I think Mr Gorski we can have a vote M armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr de Mayo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kapano yes Mr nosin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Ryback yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky yes Mr board president I'm pleased to announce that the motion has passed unanimously I thank you all thank you very much could move to Other Board of Education business is there any other board of education business Mr C I got one since we just approved the uh board goals up there on

080item number two which deals with the special aded um if we can at maybe not the next curriculum meeting but the one after that have a detailed implementation plan of the 19 or 20 recommendations that the outside company had how exactly are we going to implement them in our district and how are we going to measure the success or failure of each one of the implementations and and feel free if you decide that of the on they we're not going to implement it because it was base but they gave we spent a lot of money on it I want to know exactly how we're going to implement it down to the the nook and cranny thank you anything else okay not not seeing any other hands uh we can move to the open public forum

081where you're not limited to the agenda I just remind you to please state your name address and and please respect the three minute time limit anyone from the public yes sir come on uh good evening Mr chairman members of the board uh my name is Ron gajarski I'm an attorney with offices at 54 Broad Street in Red Bank New Jersey I I'm speaking this evening and I've listened to the comments of the board up until this time and I'm aware of the fact that the board is considering the construction of two new school r on certain property which is located within the Colts Run subdivision I have been retained by residents of Colts run uh to oppose that proposition uh it is their position upon advice for me that the property in question is in

082fact a part of the subdivision when it was created it's open space it's carried in your inventory of property within the community as being open space uh they've retained me to take whatever actions are necessary to prevent that transfer to the board of education for the construction of those schools now I respect your position I'm here this evening to put you on notice with regard to that so that perhaps you're not misled in some fashion and that's my only comment I thank you for that and I'll I'll just answer that we'll be referring all this to our attorney okay thank you very much thank you for your time thank you anyone else from the public okay not seeing anyone else Mr oh Mr Po I'm sorry thank you Doug PO for you're much faster than

083I am Mr Ryback um uh just a couple of things uh I I I want to commend uh Miss Deo for expressing her concern about uh the teachers that we lose a and the fact that we are losing teachers to other districts possibly because of the pay scale uh I think that is something that the Board needs to take into consideration uh what really matters and I speak as a very experienced educator what really matters when it comes to the education of children more than buildings more than textbooks more than technology are the teachers that work with those kids and if you want to improve education you got to have the best teachers that you can get and they will do the job so we certainly don't need to be losing teachers we need to

084be attracting the very best teachers that we can to F any position that we have uh Mr Ryback I want to commend you for the resolution that you've read and I know we've had resolutions like this in the past uh I would suggest that uh the board explore how we can get more Community involvement uh with that resolution uh also whether or not we have people living in the community who might be in a position because of their past experiences but are that are now retired living in adult communities who could assist us because they have worked in the realm of working with politicians in a lobbying sense uh I'm sure we have people out there that could help us with that um and uh oh yes uh Mrs K kapovich uh your call for

085more attention to publicizing uh our plight uh I absolutely agree with you on that uh uh we unfortunately have a community that does not have a community newspaper and so it's very very difficult to get all the people of our community to know what's going on uh regardless of our efforts uh so and we really do need to make a much greater effort the Board needs to make a much greater effort to bring this to the attention of our residents uh and see if we can't get more assistance from them uh so that's all I have to say uh thank you for your your time and your attention thank you anyone else from the public okay I took my time Mr boy I'm making sure okay uh we can now go uh to our closed

086session resolution um be it resolved that the Board of Education of Township of Monroe hereby moves to go into Clos session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 colon 4-21 to discuss the following subjects Donaldson appearance following Clos session action may be taken the discussion uh conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confident for confidentiality no longer exists do I have a second any discussion Mr n um could you please explain for the uh benefit of the public uh what a Donaldson appearance is please sure support president yes Donaldson appearance is an appeal on behalf of an employee of a public Board of Education to the board regarding um their employment matters

087and as such we have a a former employee with representation here this evening to appeal to the board to be heard to have their story presented to the board thank you okay uh any other discussion okay we could vote all those in favor I I be opposed all right this should motion carries this close session should take approximately 45 minutes that's you we're still in session and we can move to the next public forum should we wait for Mar peace here no one from the public okay our next scheduled meeting is Wednesday September 14th at 7 pm at the high school right here uh do I have a moved second that was terrific motion to move seconded all in favor I guess no one's opposing okay this meeting's adjourn motion passes thank you night everyone

088good

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.