001the Monroe Township Board of Ed is currently open for business uh if our board me our uh Board member Miss scalisi would please lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance here he is here's our friend I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation under God indivisible with liberty and justice for all thank you okay just to let everybody know I am not Mr Ryback Mr Ryback's wife had surgery and she's doing very well so he is uh tasked with taking care of her and he's doing a good job from what I hear Mr Gorski if you would please proceed with the roll call Mrs armeno here Mr Braverman here Mrs Deo here Mr calman here M goano here Mr noin here
002Mrs Kino here Mr Ryback Mr Russo here here and Mr rutsky here Mr board president you have a quorum present this evening thank you Mr Gorski if You' read the statement please in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted October 14th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune the cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you Mr Gorski the uh next item of business is the approval of the minutes do I have a motion to approve the special public Board of Education meeting for July 13 2016 so moved do I have a second second thank you questions or comments okay all
003those in favor I I all those opposed all those abstaining or uh recusing motion passes thank you do I have a motion to approve the closed session meeting minutes for July 13 2016 uh motion second questions comments all those in favor I all those opposed extensions recusing motion is carried L thing do I have a motion to approve the minutes of the public Board of Education meeting July 27 2016 motion second anybody second questions comments all those in favor all those opposed abstentions recuse okay passes we have a motion for the Clos session hearing minute approval of July 27th 2016 motion please motion second second all those in favor I was opposed extensions thank you okay that appr the approval of minutes is complete um next up is the student board members reports please okay
004so not too long ago the high school held the monor township Green fair and at the green Fair there were people from all over the community who came together there were a lot of vendors and different activities that kids could do and basically anyone could do and it was all focused around how to be more energy efficient and more um ecologically friendly and a lot of our sports teams are doing really well this season so one of the first things we have is the girls volleyball team won the division championships and the boys soccer team also won their Championship the girls field hockey team reached semi-finals and this morning the sophomores and juniors took PSATs and the freshman and seniors came in on a delayed opening schedule thank you very much for your report anybody
005have any questions for their report see not M Armenia do we have any information on how the band did I think there was a big band um Saturday Saturday big competition uh I'm not sure I didn't hear about anything about the B please um the band is the marching band has had three competitions so far this year and for all three competitions they have placed first in their divisions excellent thank you for that okay next up it's Dr alix's presentation on the state assessment data board presentation that she probably just did in the curriculum but she's an expert at it so okay so one of our requirements every year is to present with you present to the public all of our performance data for the state test so this is the second year that we
006did Park so the presentation that you have before you are our Park results from the spring of 2016 and they are compared to the first year that we did Park in the spring of 2015 um just a reminder we give Park to all of our students grades three through 11 in English language arts grades three through eight in math a end of course Park assessment in Algebra 1 end of course in in geometry and end of course in Algebra okay um just so I will post this whole presentation online on the website tomorrow so you will have access to it online um the park reports out for each of our students on five performance levels level one the students are not yet meeting grade level expectations level two they're partially meeting level three approaching level
007four meeting level five exceeding the state requires um the passing score for our students to be a level four or a level five the first set of data as I said I know there's a lot there this will be posted on the website tomorrow the first set of data that you'll see are are the comparisons for the state of New Jersey scor so this is all of the students who took the assessment in the state of New Jersey and they compare um the 2015 percentages to the 2016 percentages so for each grade level what you'll see across the row and this is for language arts um so for example the first row you look at is grade three grade three in 2015 there were 15.1% students SC uh scoring at a level one which is
008the lowest level in 2016 that number dropped to 13.6% you want to see that number drop because that means the students did better in the other levels um and you go across that it shows the uh comparison for 2015 to 2016 um for each of the performance levels the last two columns at the end show the percent of change in level one and level two and compare to the percent of change in level four and level five you want to see the arrows going down in that First Column because you want less students scoring at the lower levels and you want to see the up arrows in the farthest column because you want students to be per more students to be performing at the higher levels okay again this is for the state of New
009Jersey results um in English language arts I'm not going to go through every single row we will be here till tomorrow so the next page is the math results so again for each grade level you have the results up to grade eight Algebra 1 Algebra 2 geom um Algebra 1 Algebra 2 and geometry you have the percentage at each grade level from 2015 to 2016 and the last two columns at the end show you the percentage of change so you see for the state results all all the percentages um the change in level one to level two decreased which is good less students are scoring at the lower levels and the all of the percentages at for the change of percent the percent change at levels four and five increase that means more students are
010scoring at the higher levels so that is the math results for the state this is the total number of students that took the test across the state and the increase in students who took the assessment okay so it's comparing 2016 to 2015 so 56,000 more New Jersey students took the assessment in the second year that's in language arts and that's in math can they have the they have the other presentation up too thank you okay so on this slide what you'll see is the Monroe Township students results in English language arts again there's a comparison from 2015 to 2016 you want to see less students scoring at the lower levels more students scoring at the higher levels our percentages in each of the areas are higher than the state levels so this is by grade
011level for the English language arts and then by level for the math for all of the students in Monro Township Schools at each grade level this slide compares the same as we looked at at the state level it Compares our percentage change at the lower levels and at the higher levels so um as you can see for English language arts there was no change in the levels level one and two at fourth grade we increased um our our students at level level one and level two at fifth grade but the rest of the grade levels we have less students scoring at those lower levels and then in for the percentage of students scoring at the higher levels at levels four and five we had an increase at all grade levels except fifth grade went down
012by 1% and eth grade stayed the same that's an English language arts and in math all of our students all of our percentage changed for level one and level two decreased with the exception of grade six which stayed the same but all of all of our percentage of chains we had more students score at the levels four and five across the district than we did the previous year and you can see our percentage of change is pretty high I know uh one of the things we looked at last year um we were concerned about was the high school some of those percent changes are pretty high in levels four and five 22% more students in Geometry scored at the four and five level than they did last year the next few slides actually break it
013down by school obviously Middle School is one school the high school is one school but at grades three four and five you have different schools across the district so we're comparing the schools across the district um and again it's the percentage of change so what we're seeing at in third grade language arts is that all a lot more more of our students increased to four or five this year that's language arts and grade three then you have grade four um and then grade five oh grade three math grade four math and grade five math I am not going to go through each of the next phases of the presentation these are all of our Park results broken down by our subgroups however any line that had a subgroup of less than five has been deleted
014they are not on there it's there there would have been too much of a chance to figure of um Crossing that line of anonymity for our students and confident it for our students so that those were deleted but other than anybody who had any group that had more than six students six or more students taking the test are included in this presentation but I'm not going to go through each one because this is broken down by each School each grade level each subject so there are a lot of slides that take you through all of that and as I said it will be available on the website um for you to peruse actor Leisure so I'm going to go to page 50 so what are we doing with this what are we doing with this
015data our principls and teachers and supervisors have been meeting um they've been digging into and Mining the data that the state has provided so they don't just give us these percentage numbers we can actually mine down to specific questions that students answered on tests and take a look at where are any of our gaps in our curriculum and how maybe we need to reorder some of our curriculum documents to make sure that all of the students are getting what they need prior to the testing dates in March um we are using this data as teachers are preparing their sgos student growth objectives every teacher has to prepare one or two student growth objectives for the year and they have to meet those objectives this is some data that they can use as they're looking at
016those um objectives for their classroom to make sure students are continuing to improve um we're also looking at our professional development and is are there things that we need to provide for our teachers to make sure that our teachers have the tools that they need to address any of the areas that are coming up in the park data so they've they've been meeting regularly um right now each administrator is is involved in meeting with all of the teachers as they create their sgos which are all due by October 31st um and we're continuing to move forward with that so because we now have two years of part data it's a lot more data for us to look at and take a look at where our gaps are so we have made some adjustments already um
017specifically to some of the order that we're teaching math specifically in the algebra 2 um because what we're finding there was a lot of trigonometry and the trigonometry area wasn't as high as we wanted it to be on the park assessments so we've kind of tried to reorder that in the in the algebra 2 classes to make sure students were getting more trigonometry before they have to take the Assessments in March there are resources for parents these are s similar resources to what I've uh shared with parents last year as we were uh preparing for getting the test results back for your children and for um helping your children as we go through how to read the score reports so they are still there um and they are still available for parents that's it thank
018you very much thank you very much Dr alvic um now I'd like to ask the board if they have any questions of course I have a question so I'm looking at the 11th grade English language literacy scores what page and page eight and I add passing is level four and five so level one two and three are not is not considered passing you add up level one two and three for 2016 and 75 that's 75% no it's not I'm sorry I'm 23 I miss it's 48 47 48 48 okay 48% so we have 48% of the kids who took the test did not pass so that they're seniors now so some of them may be in danger of not graduating so do we know what percentage of those 48 passed via the other options given
019to them we are in the process of compiling that data right now at with the the high school um now that M now that Dr Celli got this information okay um we also had students just take a round of SATs okay students took PSATs today although that wouldn't be the seniors that would be the sophomores and juniors so she is in the process of compiling that as we speak she's been working on it this is a for SE 600 students this takes some time to really look at it so I don't have that number for you but once I have it I will definitely share it okay good thank you any other questions Mr calman yes so of course the concerns are going to be where we've gone up in like the level ones or
020the level twos so my I'm just looking at the stats here for grades three four and five and I just something just popped out that's kind of weird and I just wanted to know if uh it's it's the set of them from like page 12 all the way to page 17 and when you take a look at the stats for grade three and five we have a smattering between Brookside and and um Applegarth Woodland where we've gone up instead of down in the not yet met expectations right but across the board grade four hasn't gone up across the board but three and five have I mean is there like well first then what's the what's the next steps for getting the you know that to go in the right direction what do you mean well
021if you take a look at grade three in Brookside it went from 5% to 7% from 15 to 16 that's bad right okay um same thing for grade five Brookside it went from 3 to 5% same period Applegarth went from 2 to three Woodland went from 5 to six but when you take a look at grade four for their numbers which are on Page in all cases across the board for for this mathematics nothing went up it all went down from 15 to 16 but three five yeah for level one yeah cuz that's the bad one you don't want going up year to year yes okay we all AG that well actually two and three are yeah I'm just saying the worst okay that's the end of the spectrum you don't want going up right
022it was this odd that grade four didn't have an uptick it had down tick like it should so but one of the things that um comes into play a couple things that come into play one of them is last year we did not get the data back in a timely manner I think I presented to you in January with the information because we just didn't get it back so we weren't able to make those adjustments last year plus it was the first year of taking an assessment we weren't sure so now we're not comparing the same students we're comparing the same grade level so this is a different cohort so if you go kind of of down I I would want to look at that also um so this year now we have two years
023of data again we made some changes from last year to our curriculum those changes weren't in place when we took it the second year yet because we had just gotten the results back in December January the students took the assessment in March does that make sense I'll give you a pass okay mostly because of 2015 was you know 16117 there's no pass well speaking kind of to that how how many years does it take to get a good read on how the students are actually doing I don't know I I think it's going to depend on you know is the test going to change that was something that we had happen with the New Jersey ask as we were going through year to year um we would be doing really well and then the test
024would change our scores would drop so it's so new I'm not sure you don't have we're looking more we're not we when we look at the the results we're not just looking at these percentages we're really digging down into the questions and the content and the standards that were being assessed and how that can be um addressed in the classroom with the instruction so it's not just we're not just looking at just the percentages we really are going down deeper than that but when we change our curriculum moving something from the end to do better better on a test is not making our curriculum better we're just switching it around so we can do better on the test well that that's one thing but we are rewriting curriculum you me think about all of the
025documents that we've looked at this year and we've been increasing them and realigning them to standards remember New Jersey also just changed their standards again so that's going to be another process next summer of looking at those curriculum documents in language arts and math right um so it's not just moving that's that was that's an that was an easy thing that we could do without rewriting an entire curric um document was re re um rearrange some of the topics but we we're also looking at all of the the practices that are happening and the way that we're writing curriculum you know I think we did 51 curriculum documents this past summer yeah I know yeah any other questions for Dr alvik so if I could I think you just touched on uh something I was
026thinking about so these seem to were comparing last year's third grade with this year's third grade and so on at some point is it going to be helpful to look at last year's third grade this year's fourth grade next year's fth grade yes and so you can tweak the data to sort of study that progression yes we can do a cohort study rather than just the year to year it just too soon to do it now with only two years of data it would really wouldn't give you much information gotcha plus the test was completely different the first year there was two testing periods so I mean it is kind of comparing apples and oranges yes would you think the increased numbers is that just because all the parents that didn't particip all the students
027that didn't part participate last year they all of a sudden felt like it's okay to take the park test this year and no um yes there was definitely a different different group of students however um we also rearranged our schedule do you mean across of state or in Monroe both both yeah sort of just curious yeah in Monroe we rearranged the schedule at the high school so students were coming in on a delayed opening um so students weren't being pulled out of classes or you know worrying about getting back to a class that they might have been late for so I think that made a difference in our high school with our high school numbers um and yeah the the um opt out movement um still continued throughout the state but I it seemed to
028be less in our area got any other board members have any questions I just have a question um I I definitely see uh that that the scores have improved what what do you attribute that to at this stage of the game I think it's just our ongoing professional development our teachers and all of the work that they put in the assessments that we're doing ongoing in our classrooms um specifically the drra assessments um this year we've implemented Maps so that's not obviously reflected here um looking at our RTI process really looking at our students taking it it's it's using the data um so I think that that's again there weren't there weren't a lot of changes that we could have made from the time we got the results from the first round to when we
029gave the second round um it was and again part of the high school piece was that change in schedule and well so I I think I heard you say that the um the assessment drives the sgos is that accurate um the data drives the sgos okay so they're not using Park they're not using Park to say 70% of the students will score a four on park because they're not going to first of all they're not going to get that data back before the end of the year when sgos have to be completed but they're using their data and what they know about their students to create those sgos excellent thank thank you very much this is a lot of lot of numbers to look at and I think we probably all need to look at
030this much closer than this uh you know the cursy look we took tonight so but thank you for for for your reference here okay next order of business is the committee reports uh any committee would like to any committee chair would like to make a report Mr calman sure we had a curriculum committee meeting tonight and we went over grade 1 to three fed grade four to 5 fed digital photography and instrumental music uh we also went over a couple of clubs that were proposed the danced Fusion did I say danced Dance Fusion you said it right I did yeah you I did WOW marked the calendar and then the other one was here's a here's a real test pause for cause um it was recommended it's p a WS not the other one um
031uh this group is going to do fundraising and all kinds of good things for our uh animal community our four-legged friends and the Dance Fusion uh is not being recommended at this time Greg's going to take that back because we've got a couple of dance opportunities we're trying to coordinate and combine them together to figure out the best step forward so more to come on uh the dance if you will uh we also had some conversations on the possibility of US changing our Football Conference uh we gave Greg Byer the license to do what's best for Monro Township because it's rather complicated and of course there's going to be a cascading effect uh we we have to decide as a group for example if we decide that we don't want to go but the rest
032of the conference does we're going anyway but um I for one I can't speak for the other board members that were there felt confident that Greg would be able to accurately represent the district and our goals for our sports program relative to football um and I'll if any other board members want to speak to that they can do that um Dr ozelli gave us an update on the NJ seal of biliteracy uh this is something that's offered to seniors it's an assessment that's done if you take the assessment you get a seal that you're bilingual it goes on your transcripts um anything else about that it's really cool have it it really is a benefit for all of our students it wouldn't even just be the AP students it could be students that have a
033second language at home um and one if they the assess the cost of the assessment would be the on the parents responsibility um so there would be no cost to the district for doing this okay great uh we had something that came up uh relative the American Legion um uh competition that we participate in uh we're going to ask the board to do something a little unique tonight um I don't want to steal Mr noste Thunder but he's going to make a a recommendation before the board that we T trying to take action tonight um and he'll give you some more color and we're going to ask uh Bonnie uh to come up and maybe uh give a couple of minutes uh update to the board of what we're looking to try and do it's
034rather unique it's rather time sensitive so that's why we thought we'd be bringing a before the board uh tonight to to possibly do something na Mr yeah why not okay good evening everyone Bonnie caletto I'm District supervisor of Sciences and social studies so this evening at our curriculum meeting we spent a good deal of time talking about an upcoming competition that our students will be participating in and that's the American Legion sponsored voice of democracy or rhetorical competition this year we have five students who are very interested in competing that's an an increase of about 150% in terms of student participation um in the past we've been challenged over the past few years to really have kids become engaged in this competition and it's really a a fabulous multi-tiered competition where our students progress um
035from the local post level they then participate at a county level if they are successful there and win either first second or third prize they progress to the state level and ultimately have an opportunity to progress to a national competition where I believe the prize is about a $15,000 scholarship at every level there is a scholarship prize for our students the competition focuses on the the United States Constitution students are really um engaged over a long period of time preparing an 8 to 10 minute speech that focuses on the Constitution so that's segment one of this competition and then segment two there are four Constitutional Amendments that the American Legion identifies every year for students to really immerse themselves in and those four amendments become the focus of impromptu question for the participants so the
036students really have to stand and respond to questions on the Constitution so I'm I'm really thrilled to report that um you know our the increase in student participation one of the glitches that we have moving forward here is that because we had a lack of enrollment for several years the stipend had been dropped for this so right now we have parties that are in interested staff members that are very enthusiastically interested in supporting the students but that stien no longer exists in terms of being budgeted for this year however contractually that stien does exist so as we discussed at our curriculum meeting I think we're faced with um how can we best support these really enthusiastic kids and and go forward um and help them understand the Constitution and increase our Civic literacy and um
037in light of everything that's going on in in our election process in the world around us I think um we really would be well founded in in trying to find um the funds to support uh this advisor um going forward so I think that's what uh the proposition is thank you very very much M caletto I appreciate you staying extra and and and filling the board it's much appreciated um just to kind of follow up with uh what Mr calman said and what Miss caletto said um this happened about a year ago uh Commander Nick Fredo uh approached me and he was interested in trying to get this in in the schools and he wasn't didn't really know who to contact so um I followed the chain of command and I I I gave the
038information to Dr kak Who who ran with it and and I and I I appreciate that because it really looked like it was a good program and now we're at the point where it's going to be a reality but we need to authorize a uh correct me if I'm wrong $1,721 stiping for this position so with that in mind I am making a motion that we approve this stip in position for $1,721 for uh I don't know the exact name of it in oratory work with me American Legion oratorical competition there you go by Sir do I have a second for that second all those in favor is this a roll call yes yes please do a roll any questions or comments we also have a budget for the students is are there expenses for
039the students I don't believe so sure absolutely Mr Dr Mr braan I I don't believe there are expenses for the students because it's uh they're writing uh essays and they're they'll have their um faculty adviser helping them with that uh Dr Al you may be able to help me with that but as far as I know there are not any expenses for the students they don't go to any conferences well if they advance to the next level then yes there would be so that we would have to come backp to the yeah Transportation if we we'd have to come back to the board and request that in a timely fashion yes we would uh we apologize for the uh late notice of this but it's just been evolving anybody else any other questions can Mr
040Gori roll call I'm sorry Mr armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mr Mayo yes Mr cman yes Mrs PA ponit yes Mr noin yes Mrs Keno yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky yes Bo president motion to reestablish stipend has passed thank you Mr Gorski okay continuing along with the committee reports is there anybody else Mr Cal yeah and it just so happened we kind of lued out because Tom and I were both in the same meeting and we talked about it and thought it would be a good idea to put it before the board so um the other on item that we did talk about for most of the meeting was the special education program update uh Dory and Company went through the uh 1719 17 recommendations that were provided by the outside uh service
041provider and uh uh if anybody's interested in how we're going to execute against those recommendations we're going to be probably posting it out on the website uh the good news is most of the things that were identified uh in the audit were things that we are already we had been doing for a while and we're looking to improve them uh so that's a good thing uh we did uh find out um that there were a couple of areas that we can uh certainly approve on and things like communication and some other areas but for the most part uh we seem to be running a a fairly good program so uh more to come in the future on on that as you guys move forward and and I think that's it I think I'm done thank
042you Mr calman does anybody have any questions for the curricular chair seeing none is there any other uh chairs that would like to report Mr Mayo we had a Personnel meeting yesterday um we are in the process of interviewing for a full-time special ed contained classroom position we are looking for two ldtc which are learning disabled teacher Consultants um I think we have one on the agenda now no we need two we've had seven new hires between August and September board meetings and we have seven new open positions a Director of Human Resources a staff accounting a custodian oh2 ldcs um an interent nurse a teacher of the handicap and a Spanish Middle School teacher um and that is it I we had seven people resign this month and um that's it thank you Mr
043Mayo does anybody have any questions for the Personnel chair M are the um the new hires that we're looking for the new positions we're looking for are they based on student enrollment increase or because people are leaving um the I can tell you that the uh ft special ed position is because of an increased in special Edge students in a class it's a um it's a it's for a self-contained class the the seven higher the hirers that I the open positions some of them are because people have left but and I think we and I'm not sure what Dr kak you want to elaborate on that yeah kindergarten also uh we had a halftime and we're going to a full-time due to increased enrollment yes and the the seven position are from vacancies though right
044and there were retirees I believe they were retirements not resignations I believe any other questions for the Personnel chair seeing none of there any other chairs i' like to report Mr Mino yes the um policy committee met to review the nepotism policy uh there were some additions to restrictions on nepotism that are enumerated in the uh in the package and also we had some housekeeping issues with um or the website so there's some additions on that and uh in in the policies I just like to point out generally in the policies there are very often um notifications that uh each policy is defined in njsa and then numbers afterwards and those are basically the state laws that guide the policies or bylaws so very often while the policy is a few pages long the state
045uh the state statutes that also guide these or have a lot more in them so sometimes just by definition or title they are enumerated on the policies so we also uh changed some of those things so I would encourage people to take a look at the website and see the changes in the policy we had a discuss oh and U the uh the policy committee met uh Mr rman wasn't able to attend and unfortunately the alternate wasn't called but Kathy kapon witz was in the room so we uh we had enough for our committee meeting and everybody agreed to some of these changes uh unanimously uh to present to the board we also had a discussion that is not on the table this evening but we're going to further discuss it about uh what it's
046not a policy yet we're thinking about it if someone is leaving the either resigning or retiring uh prior to uh well let me put it this way if someone's going for training or or we have to pay for something and they're retiring before that right or right after that we are going to ask them to resend either that training or uh if someone's going to a convention or something like that if we know that someone's retiring within a short period of time we're going to ask them to not take the training or or not cost the board um that money even in terms of stud uh um education as well because we want it we want to uh have the board if if we're paying for things we'd like to have people stay longer so
047if we know that someone's retiring we we'd like them to resend any training or cost to the board at that point that is not formulated yet so I apologize for um being a little cryptic about it we've just had that as a table discussion we'll discuss it again tomorrow uh next month any questions for the Mr Braverman has a question the policy chair Mr Braverman sure not affili I I don't I don't understand why you would have to resend the training if they can't have the training unless the board approves it why would we approve it in the first place well no not this is non Affiliated so a lot of times the training or education is does not need a board approval so that that's all right if you want to just expl if
048I could clarify yeah uh the the training might be approved two months six months prior and in that period of time the person may then submit their resignation so if they were approved for their training in in July and in uh September they decide that they're going to retire or the resigning and the training is is isn't until November then I think if I'm capturing this right then we would ask that person to and that's not affiliated to not attend the training wouldn't it just be cleaner if you just made that a part of the motion when you initially give them the approval for the training that it's automatically rescinded if you well that was part of the discussion we're trying to we're trying to formulate how to approach it it was just a discussion
049item that I wanted wanted to let the public know we were discussing and and this doesn't mean that if if a teacher is retiring let's say June 30th but they have uh field trips or anything they are still welcome to complete all of those things it's just that um when we know someone's retiring if they're going for a costly training or Transportation or anything like that we'd like them to I I do have a question on a nepotism okay um did did the state legislator legislature pass the law about nepotism they talked about it in the year 2011 but I didn't follow up on that well I had a discussion with the attorney prior to the committee meeting so what's here has been reviewed by the attorney so I don't know the def the the
050answer to that question but we did an add something to the policy that was state law that was not on the policy and that's by title what's that what did you add uh it had to do with administrative um definitions and I was looking I was looking for exactly which one it was it was it should be I I on here it's it's 6A 23A we have to a and ab but it should be to I I and if it's not on here then we That was supposed to be have been added this policy doesn't have a mandated thing on it so this isn't a mandated policy it's it's mandated based on the statutes that are they entitled but some of the changes are not mandated correct so what are the changes that you made
051that are not mandated if you'll look at the it it's actually the bylaws so let me correct it it's not a policy it's a bylaw 01421 and page one of one it talks about um board member and no relative of board employee employed in any of the following positions and they're enumerated in those positions and so you added extra positions yes and which positions did you add all of the ones under superintendent of schools you prior I can elaborate if you want it's I have it from the notes if you would like Mr Mayor I can tell you what the positions are yeah okay well it's okay is it okay Mar no please go right ahead okay um if I could just go back to Mr braverman's comment too the the state did mandate that
052the nepotism uh policy would be that no relative of a board member or a superintendent were allowed to be H recommended to be hired so that's the the state and I believe it was 2011 or maybe a little bit earlier Mr rman but I believe that was what you were referring to okay oh actually what I'm referring to was um the reason for this policy and as it happened uh the state was very concerned with districts like medicon and uh Bloomfield and a couple of others where nepotism was going crazy but I think in interesting that uh in around 2004 the state New Jersey state supreme court or the New Jersey Supreme Court uh indicated that at that time there was no law against nepotism in fact they suggested that there not be a law
053because you're really punishing uh friends or relatives of board members that might be better prepared than other candidates so you know that's that's part of my problem with this and then to list just the few positions that were listed in the policy frankly I think it should go back and list all the people in town government why not the state legislators they've all got tentacles um I mean why is it always just the board members and people in the school districts it's that the other thing that I noticed on the U nepotism policy was it was 18 months before one of these relatives friends or whatever can be employed by the uh District however the state law only requires six months for a board member to be off the board before they can be be
054employed so I I really think with all due respect to our attorney and I know you've been on this for a long time I think you really should look at some of the finer points anybody have any questions I can answer Mr May the specific positions the positions listed would be principal assistant principal board attorney and directors in addition to the board superintendent assistant superintendent and ba and so we added those three or four those four and then we increased the amount well there's more than four actually it was only superintendent and board before so it's principal assistant principal board at attorney directors all of them assistant yes assistant superintendent God bless you and ba and so and then we added we changed the date the amount of time that a it's a recommendation at
055this point so we increased the time that someone any so we're increasing from 6 months to 18 months that any former board board member or relative of of a board member for at least 18 months after the former board member secession of the membership on the board following a school election resignation or removal from the board okay so a relative of a board member who resigns or decides not to run can't look for a job in the district for 18 months that's what it says instead of six months and what's the thought behind increasing that time period well basically we feel that it there's having being a board member being a superintendent and being people with supervisory positions have a great deal of power and it is incumbent on the boards yes to get the
056best people but also to enable diversity and allow PE and allow everyone else an equal opportunity to be hired but if the board member resigns and they don't have any more power cuz they're not on the board that's not entirely that's that's not necessarily the case then how would they have that's the thought process it's it I'm sure it's interpreted differently Mr Mayor this is just the first reading tonight so um you can you know obviously feel vote as you feel compelled but well I'm just trying to went through the commit because excuse me did this go through the committee went through committee unanimously out of committee unanimously so this is a committee recommendation at this point so it can be we we can have another discussion about it and have changes to it for
057the next can I just say something actually it was proposed for 24 months that's correct and we cut it down to 18 and I think the policy originally went from 12 months to it went from six months the last policy said 12 months I believe yes there's a there's also an we just noticed this there is a clerical error on the back of that policy it says the last revision was March 2010 and that is not correct the last revision was December 18th 2013 which carried the one year no that was remember we found out that was tabled 2013 no it was tabled in January of 2014 this was the accurate there was it wasn't properly listed on the website so that was the housekeeping that we had to change yeah know so in December
0582013 it was raised from to one year correct and this time we it was proposed for 24 months but we only going to go to 18 that is correct Mr calman so I got some interesting points only because you know other than everybody looking at me um I actually happen to like the fact that you guys added the the real people who have power which are the business administrator the principles and the directors and stuff because at the end of the day board members when you have a conf conflict it actually Cuts you off at the knees it actually totally restricts you from a lot of things that are are are prevalent today and it's you know it's probably a good thing right um but the concern I have is that if you if you
059cluster this group as the we'll call them the exceptions on the first page I think to your point and to Marv's Point too the the second thing the 18-month thing that should apply to the same exceptions on the first page because it's not just a board member it could be any administrator that decides to leave or or or what have you so if you're going to have these um these identified positions on the first page that shouldn't be hired in the first place you should carry over the same whatever whatever you decide is the time period uh carry over to that same group of people it shouldn't be different it should be the same group that are applied to the exception in the first place if you're going to do something it shouldn't be just
060for board members because like I said when you're a board member and you have conflicts in the in the district it hurts you more than it helps you trust me I know thank you Mr calman Mr we can take that under advisement and that would be the um the committee's you know the committee can discuss that next month so we can still do a we can still do a first reading tonight and then we can still take it back to committee will you make that happen to go back to the committee on that thank you and I think I just have a clarification um Mr Braverman kept speaking about friends this doesn't affect friends correct that's correct okay I just wanted to clarify that um okay um any other Committee in in other words if
061I have a friend I can recommend them you sure well you a board members shouldn't be Rec well it I I think then then there's a then there's a conf you can't pick your relatives that's what they say I can't tell you how many times I get approached by some grandfather in the village that I live in well that's an ethical issue that we know you would do the right thing and we appreciate that um okay uh next up I uh finance committee met on Tuesday um the first item of business was an audit update Mr Gorski uh explain that the it's that time of the year again the comprehensive annual financial report is uh the annual audit that's done that's mandated by the uh Board of Education and the State Board of Ed and
062that is going uh in the process right now it's a very rigorous process and the uh the first draft of that report will be uh coming out in about a week uh an ongoing item on the uh agenda for the finance committee has been the adult education program discussion um basically uh it was learned that the adult education program is basically losing money to the tune of about $30,000 a year uh the finance committee was a little concerned about that at this point and what the finance committee has decided to do was that they've they've asked Dr kak to come up with a a corrective action plan basically uh to revise the course offerings to make them more attractive to increase the fees as needed and to ensure that the programs uh loss decreases by
06325% next year so we're setting uh basically some parameters on this we think that the uh the program has some benefit to the community uh we did look at the numbers of the number of uh Community participants it's roughly around 150 Community uh participation with the outlying areas I don't know the breakdown of where but about another 50 to 60 from excuse me from other areas uh of the uh of middlex County so basically it's about 150 uh from Monroe so that is what the um the committee has recommended to Dr kak um on a very plus side we had some very very good news about the Falcon care uh ECE financial statements were uh introduced to the finance committee and um it's better news than we actually had thought the um ECE met expectations
064for the year we had revenue of $47,000 $ 47,3 $47,000 34 and total expenses were $291,000 for a net income of 11 15,500 Falcon care uh in its anoral year exceeded with revenues of $829,000 and expenses of 416 for a net income of $412,000 almost $413 so that is fantastic news because what the board has done we've taken a failing program and through uh Mr Gorski and the District administration has turned this into a very very profitable what we call an Enterprise fund an Enterprise fund is h a fund that we can actually make money on and then spend it on students and on whatever way the board decides um and that's going to actually um lead me into a discussion on the meca loone initially Mecca was the uh Monroe Early Child Care initiative
065that was implemented several years ago ago and it borrowed money from the Township in order to start this well that was a losing proposition this board took it over and basically turned it into a profitable one but that loan was still outstanding so every every month we've been paying down that loan from 300,000 plus it's now down to $154,000 So based on that tonight I would like to make a motion in the middle of my committee report since that's what we seem to be doing tonight um I hereby move that the Monroe Township Board of Ed approve the utilization of available funds in the ECE and Falcon care proprietary accounts to pay off the mecca Loan in full do I have a second on that thank you Miss kovich is there any discussion on that
066motion I have a question certainly can you define proprietary accounts can I define do I look like an accountant um no but Mr Gorski I will assure you could thanks thanks most of the school district accounts are within fund accounting and they're not designed like for the corporate model of accounting where you have a profit and loss proprietary funds are different they do they are more like an income statement with a profit and loss and retained earnings we have a few here in the district the cafeteria program is one um the use of any surplus in there is restricted because there are federal reimbursements that are included in the monies the other proprietary funds that we have is Early Childhood enrichment and Falcon care at this time okay so we're going to use are we
067going to use the money from the lunch no that's in that's in the uh the cafeteria program that's separate DC and Falcon care yes ma'am yes ma'am and and that's as the board determines um depending on this this resolution will pay off the loan and then in the future you can anticipate some handsome profits that as Mr noin said could be applied to the budget to reduce taxes to provide additional program Services whatever the board sees fit thank you Mr gski is there any other questions or on to the motion U Mr that was originally 300 300,000 or a little bit more as a loan yes ma'am so in in the what three years you were able to reduce it to half and now we're paying it off yes we we've been in compliance with
068the board resolution to pay I believe $5,000 each month against that loan from the the earnings in the fund and now it's down to 54,000 and we still have sufficient funds after that payment is is zeroed out to collect money from from the from the prog correct because because the performance of this fund exceeded our expectations um the design to develop some retain earnings uh is is constrained and we can actually pay off the loan now and still have ample cash going forward because I know it was very it's very difficult for a board um to to to oversee a program see it not working and then ask to it to be dissolved I know there's a lot of controversy about that there's a lot of disappointment but I think it is a responsibility of
069of the board sometimes to do things that are uncomfortable and that was one of the things that I think we succeeded in re reviewing uh a program that wasn't working established a program that was and and now we're making money I mean and I don't know this is a long time ago and I don't know if anyone knows it or if my information is accurate at one point point the after school program that we were only collecting $100,000 from that was a but prior to that we weren't taking any money from it wasn't there like a 10-year period that they were just using the facilities and we were not getting any reimbursement for that didn't we have a we had a well this is you this is you you take you could take this one
070uh yeah so um Basque was here for forever um it was a proprietary business bu they were using our facilities and for years um we had gone to them saying you know you're collecting all this money it's you're making money don't you think you should give the district a little something I mean there are are there are facilities you're using and they had always said well you know if you if you want us to do that that's fine but then we're going to pass that cost on to the parents so they we were kind of held hostage if you will for quite a long period of time and uh about four years ago I guess close to that um we decided to be you know turn the tables around and we tried at first to
071take over the program at that time uh so you know onsight being 2020 we could have been pocketing this money four years ago but the district at the time uh wasn't in the right place and we had to do something immediately we had to resolve the issue so um the bask folks were kind of I want I want to say put up against the W but we were about ready to pull the plug but they agreed to share more than they had been before so at the time we were making about $100,000 and I don't know what their income was but it was a lot uh and the intent at that time was to make sure that when that contract was up which was three years I think we had mik correct because they wouldn't
072do anything for anything less than that we were we were just not in a place to do anything we we for whatever reason I'm not going to go into it but we weren't in a place to take it over so we had 3 years to basically invent what we have today and um you know hindsight being 2020 would have should have could have four years ago but at the end of the day we took over the program I think we put something better in its place and uh that was the original intent had we not had to kind of wait the three years but we were contractually obligated to wait so uh we did it now can I just make one final comment and dur during the uh Finance meeting we did have a discussion
073about making sure that the that the cost to the community who are who who are using the system uh is going to stay affordable um you know there may be I don't know if there's any intent to increase or anything but we want to make sure that the community is served and the people who um are best served can afford can afford the program on on going basis thank you anybody else have any questions Miss kopano yeah I just want to say that the Falcon CARE program should be called The cockman CARE program because this is something that Lou has been advocating for for at least six seven eight years that we take over the Basque program so I think we should change well it's a good Evolution sorry thank you Mr car P um
074also um on the resolution too I just want to also I think what Mr armino said about the um the size of the program is both programs are already at full capacity and we do have a waiting list and I I mentioned the contributions from the administration but we also uh I would be remiss if I didn't mention Miss Sharon Jensen the director for all her hard work and really turning this into um such an amazing program that it is so I I think we need to thank her too uh if there's no more there's not any further questions I will ask Mr Gorski to perform the roll call please m sarmo yes Mr Braverman yes Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr Rybeck Mr
075Russo yes Mr rutsky is not eligible Mr board president I'm pleased to say that motion passes thank you very much everyone I just have one more item on my committee report um the board was apprised of a legal uh proceeding uh that we uh Su were successful in in it was uh the efforts in we're giving the initials here but he informed the committee that the board attorney will be seeking a judgment against M shahat for failure to pay back tuition of 8,766 as ordered by the administrative law judge basically this was a um an issue where the student a residency issue basically where the student was found to not be a resident of Monroe and um we we then sued the uh parent and they we've W to uh a judgment against that parent
076so now we have to uh go back to court and I guess file I guess a lean or something to uh to try to make that payment happen um and that concludes my report are there any questions okay seeing none the next item up uh is the public forum I'm going to ask the public to uh anybody who comes up to speak at the microphone please State your full name your address and any um affiliation of a group that you are with and this first public form is strictly on anything that's on the agenda and you are limited to a three minute time period uh Mr Chell good afternoon my name is Ken chirella 116 Bola Avenue mon Township obviously um I have a question regarding the uh approval of the minutes from July 27th
077so when I looked in into uh at the detail regarding those minutes I see the Merit goals for the superintendent for 2016 2017 listed in there um I don't see any dollar amounts uh for those for the uh Merit increases that that seem to be approved by this now if I'm reading this correctly from what I know from being a prior board member is that once the minutes are approved this causes the approval to move forward and go to the county for their approval um so my question is if we're if we're going to do something like this where we're giving the superintendent a bonus or Merit increases based upon goals why aren't we listing the amounts for those increases and why aren't we being you know being transparent so you know this board from
078what I've heard is priding itself on transparency and and being on the up and up and uh doing all the all the uh the right things for the taxpayers and things like that and then here under the cover of Darkness on a superintendent whose salary is capped we slip through a $116,000 merit increase with goals that have nothing to do with things that really matter to the district like for instance solving our growth issues so the goals that I'm seeing here are uh establish a post-graduation tracking system investigate and then number two is investigate the potential to initiate a plan to establish Partnerships with local industry and universities and colleges to expand student offerings and achievement all great things I guess but uh nothing that's solving our immediate needs which to me are things that
079have to do with our the growth and our student population and educating our kids and so that our taxpayers understand because the board has let us down on this the three increases or three .3% of the cap salary of the superintendent so the first one is 3.3% it's a $557 bonus the second one is also 3.3% $ 5,577 and then the third one's 2.5% at $ 4,187 and again that's of cap salary so I have to ask is this a way to get around or the superintendent cap um or is is there something else going on here and what you know what the the thing that i' I'd really like to just get across to everyone is you know when we talk about transparency and doing the right things for the taxpayers we need to
080make sure that we're not spinning things and trying to do things under you know under the guise of uh you know some some goals that just seem murky and and and not really defined for me anyway and that don't really address some of our our main issues and uh I guess that's it but thank you well I mean I I would like to address uh some of the things that Mr chel said I I think that um as a former board member he's aware that these are contractual issues um when we were when we hired Dr kak in his contract that I was on the uh the contract team with Miss kapano and actually Mr Po and we actually um decided that we didn't want to have any Merit goals the first year it was
081just uh you know first year kind of getting your feet wet um so we did not provide any Merit goals uh for the first year in the contract there that we signed and this board agreed to and voted on we had Merit goals that we had to uh initiate in the second year and that is what we did we followed the contract uh on on that and you as a board member knows I don't know if youve ever been through a super search but um that's part of the the contract what I'd like to know though with all due respect is why we wouldn't list that and list the amounts everything else you know we we we talk about listing and the importance of listing and being being transparent and open to the public and
082we're watching every dollar we're squeezing every penny we're going and making sure that we're doing the right things for the for for the taxpayers but then we don't list $116,000 for a superintendent that's capped seems I think it's a great Point um unfortunately what happens in the minutes uh way back when when I was going to these board meetings back in 01 we actually used to record the board minutes and then there'd be a transcript okay obviously we don't do that anymore the the state or the uh the law says that we have to have comprehensive minutes now that's a very nebulous term if you will so it's not as clearly defined um to your point I would love to see more comprehensive minutes I would love to see a recording and then a transcript
083personally but it's very costly and it doesn't really help the uh the the the student achievement but uh this this board is not trying to hide anything because you were able to get that information too so it's not like it's a hidden information correct well I could get the information but I'm a former board member don't think that the the taxpaying public can get that information as readily as I could so I think it's incumbent upon board members to make sure that that we're giving that information so even if even though we don't have B verbatim minutes it the board this board should go the extra mile and make sure that these kind of things especially when it has to do with tax dollars are listed I agree and your time is up thank you
084anybody else go our County approved to count Timothy verasa 7 Collins Avenue uh good evening evening thank you for your service on the board um my question is reserved to uh section five I which is which is into uh the creation of a new learning language disability uh self-contained class I was wonder if you had more information as to what grade level that pertained to um that would probably be a question for Dr alic possibly I hate to put her on the spot but it's better than me um we're looking at our student enrollment at the K through four level so will'll probably be K through four students um but there there's can only be a 4-year age span in in correct that class okay I that was really my only question if any of
085you know me I sent the letter at the beginning of the year and I want to thank you your attention to this matter thanks thank you for your questions good evening Chrissy scurby uh 21 pness Drive um in reference to board action item number 12 on page 21 um the additional uh study for Block 6 lot 5.21 is this the land on England Road that's correct all right um it says that um it's forgo forgoing is the subject to the board's receipt of an executed letter of intent from the Monroe Township Council uh my question is have has the Board of Ed received official legal advice from a land use attorney for this land I have no idea Mr Gorski do you have that answer yes our board attorney did do research into land acquisition
086and was very comfortable in practicing in this area and um uh drafting a letter of intent with the township and all related documents with this so you haven't asked an outside land use attorney for advice on what that land would be considered CU I know the question there is a question whether it is municipal use or open space and I know the Monroe Township has an ordinance that says um land acquired from developers um coming from uh cluster housing is given to the township as municipal use however there is a New Jersey municipal land use law that would supersede the ordinance and that says the land coming from developers from cluster housing is deemed for open space uh to the first question we did not consult outside uh land attorneys in this regard our board
087attorney was Express Comfort level with this engagement and uh to the second point the municipality has explicitly uh expressed to us that the land is is municipal use and um that is delineated in the letter of intent which is signed Now by our board president has been reviewed by both councils the boards and the townships and is now just waiting Town Council approval and we should have that fully executed and back in a in a less than half a month I I understand that my concern is you're going to move forward with spending more taxpayer money studying sewer issues and Turtles when there is a question from residents in the area whether or not that should be deemed as open space it would I think it would be better use of money to first get
088an official legal advice from a land attorney because there is New Jersey Law the New Jersey municipal land use law that says um land coming from a developer from cluster housing being turned over to the township comes over as open space Monroe has an ordinance that says it comes over as municipal use that ordinance would not stand up against the New Jersey Law that's an excellent point and I and I and I appreciate your comments the um the issue here though is that we don't own that land okay so we wouldn't be looking at a lawyer to talk about the land this is a this is a Township issue at this point with the land the um reso that we're going to do this evening is contingent upon getting that letter of intent and that
089letter of intent as Mr Gorski mentioned will stipulate that it is for municipal use so according to the township but maybe not according to the state and you're going to drag this Township you're going to drag this District into litigation over the use of that land whether it's open space or municipal use so before you go and spend our taxpayer money on land you do not own maybe you should be asking the township to study the land and find out if it's viable well that's precisely what we're going to do that's an excellent idea um this this board already talked about that and we are going to ask the township if they're truly giving us a a piece of property that it should be unencumbered if you will so well then why are you asking
090for $31,000 to further study it for turtles because time is of the essence as we uh I don't think you were at the finance committee last night but at the finance committe I'm sorry at the bg& uh meeting last evening we went over the reason in the timely fashion that we need to proceed with this because uh these box turtles uh they kind of go into hibernation in the winter so they need to do this study between now and when it gets cold or else we lose our window and then we can't do it till next year so I can't stress how urgent this need is to get moving on this so what you're talking about looks great if we had a lot of a lot of room down the down the road and we
091weren't so uh overpopulated and the growth wasn't continuing uh we would be having the same discussion that you're having but why aren't we looking at land we already own we own more than 15 acres of land over on Applegarth why aren't we looking at that why are we continuing to spend money looking at land that we don't even own well that's a that's a great question but we have looked at that and we've looked at all Alternatives I don't think you give the board and the administration enough credit sometimes we we are aware of everything so what is the reason for not using Apple Garts land I'm sorry what is the reason for not pursuing the land at Apple gorth well we may end up using that land it's not that's not over yet either
092we have alternate plans right now the best plan that we have on the table is using the land that we're studying and what should the plan be if that does not work out uh we have plan B we have a plan C I'm sure what is it uh you don't know you don't have a plan B well Mr Gori does and time is of the essence we have we have hundreds of unhoused students where are they going to be going you spend more time tonight talking about Park and how long we need to wait to hire your relatives than we due to where we're putting unhoused children we are no further along do you want to have a dialogue or you want M to answer it [Music] um I think I'd like to answer the
093question about the alternate plan because that's really important all right the Board of Education directed the superintendent uh pursuant to the student growth advisory committee study of this process over a six-month period of time to come up with a recommendation to um fulfill the need of the unhoused students in the district and the plan that was recommended to the board uh which is the most favorable we'll call option one and it's as follows first there's going to be a need for an addition to the Monroe Township High School that that this school opened at capacity when uh we cut the ribbon and it now has a large number of unhoused students and requires an addition to handle the current number of students and the projected here second on the on the transferred piece of land
094that the township is offering the plan is to build a new Elementary School K to 5 and a new Middle School grades 6 s and 8 we are also going to close appleg Guard School which has become unreliable for instruction due to very aged facilities and we and with all plans we are going to have to do a redistricting to reallocate the student burden with the new facilities and make it all fit the second plan uh is similar but if the land that were we're studying from the township pursuant to the Edwards engineering report stipulates that we can only build one school on that property instead of two hopefully it will be a middle school and we will build a Monro Township Middle School a second middle school for grades six seven and eight on
095the new land we will still put an addition on the high school we will construct a new elementary school at Applegarth um in a very clever way that Mr T uh came up with to begin Construction in the back of the property while the students are still educated in the front section and once we get the certificate of occupancy for the back area of a school we would simply transfer the students over as we did with mil Lake and then tear down the existing Old appleg Guard School and build another Wing there to accommodate up to as many as 700 elementary students at Applegarth with a new school facility we will also have to addess Barkley Brook Brookside and oak tree with additions and redistrict those are the first two plans how much would a
096referendum be estimated to be for either one of those options very roughly um and I emphasize very roughly because we don't have size estimates square footage estimates yet it's just a very rough shot from the architect uh conversation it would probably be in the $ 30 $140 million range for all segments of this including the hangover piece having to do with the high school and how soon do you see is going out for a referendum depends upon the land transfer and um getting all the applications into the Department of Education um the very best option would probably be January of 2018 to go out for a referendum to have a referendum correct and then a school building open two years later okay M Kirby thank you your time is up please feel free to come
097back and ask any and what are we going to do in the interim in the interim you can just uh wait because there's somebody behind you so you're not going to answer what we're going to do between now and 202 what we're going to do with the students until that until the right now there's other people waiting and your time is up great way to care about our children oh we do care about our children and that's what we're here for hi good evening board president uh thank you for taking time to answer some of my questions um I was curious uh we tend to view oh sure it's John elbasan a Belmont Court I'll be a familiar face for many months and years um with with respect to the school construction uh we tend
098to view the expansion of schools as mutually uh inclusive of all these projects uh this question is directed to board president and to Mr Gorski uh why isn't if there is no incumbrance to build upon Monroe Township High School that that in initiative doesn't begin immediately and if you could pause the time sure um well it's my understanding that you just can't build unless we have a referendum I mean we've been very fortunate in the school district we've actually added on classrooms 11 classrooms at the middle school without having to go for a referendum but I think that amount would just be uh prohibited and that sounds like a fair statement I guess the concern is that within the township um when you have a multifactored referendum people do get a bit confused and a
099bit worried by the sum so if something can be built today and there's no encumbrance to build upon it those that are in need those kids that are getting ready to go into the school district could benefit from that Township High School expansion in the next two years and not have to wait till 2020 or 2022 before they see something it's definitely an EXC an excellent point and I appreciate you making it but um the student growth advisory committee actually were the ones that actually recommended going out all at once um we had a very very detailed discussion on this because it's all different ways of thinking is it better to go out in small chunks or is it better to go out for one and then what happens if the first uh referendum that
100you went out on uh if that were to fail you can't come back to the public for that same question for what I think 18 months or 12 12 months there there's a time limit I'm not 100% sure and that time limit would coincide with when the next opportunity would be to actually send a referendum from what Mr Gorski said about January 2018 and we did discuss it that's actually like a philosophy shift or or a a strategy I guess is the better way to put it because um the basically what you're saying is pretty much every electure we're going to have a referendum and just throwing cards up at the table to try to get something passed um at least this point I think it's the board's thinking that we're going to have a
101a referendum with everything and if it if it fails then we could still come back and modify that and maybe then do what you're talking about Mr nin um Mr Gorski wrote something on a piece of paper there for Sunshine lows can you disclose what he wrote on your piece of paper you pause the time please I can't read it Mr Gorski can you outline what you wrote on his paper we're not it's not like for open public it's is this not work product here I mean uh actually that that violates Sunshine Law right there and I think people on the board would actually agree with that Mr noin uh what I was what I was reminding you uh was our conversation about uh the the uh very favorable interest rate environment now to bundle
102all the projects and do them once unless if we would like to incur additional finance charges from the historic low rates where we are now and will these historical rates be guaranteed post 2018 please stop the time probably nothing is guaranteed we can't predict the the Federal Reserve board so then it would be in our interest to take advantage of these low rates today please stop the time yes I would there's a delay in your timer stop with respect with respect back to Applegarth U being that there's a delineation of wetlands issue is it not in our interest to then bundle a referendum for the expansion of Applegarth and Monroe Township High School for the next available referendum period like I said before we've had this discussion and it's the board's decision that we decided
103not to do it that way right now Mr naon when you mentioned the board's decision the uh special Advisory Board is not a championed or commissioned uh standing board it would be the buildings and grounds board that Mr baverman uh d conducts would it not correct so then why can we not put on the agenda a continuation of this discussion formally within this Township and not put it under the guise of a makeshift commission that has no legal standing that's something for the board to decide you don't the board decides the agenda items so as board acting board president would it be incumbent on you to put that agenda item in place what do you mean for tonight for next month's meeting oh no I'm not going to I'm not going to the board president
104next next meeting I'll tell you that right now yes that would be something that the board president Andor him or I would have to uh put on the agenda that is correct you see a packed house and this will only grow if there's no transparency I Echo Mr trell's uh comments here this is the kind of inaction that is uh completely uh holding us hostage from improving the uh the the school opportunities for our school age children thank you very much for your comments I disagree with the lack of transparency um anybody who knows me in this in this Township will know that that is not what I'm about so I appreciate anybody who who brings out what you're considering lack of transparency because trust me that's the last thing that I would be for
105Mr I appreciate what Mr Trella said about uh what he what he viewed as in inadequate minutes and I tend to concur with him any other questions I question in there so I'm asking Mr bski he he actually is now penalizing me because I've asked the question and he heard it don't worry about the timer I will you're going to work many of the Township Public that watched the video last time clearly worried about my inability to get my thoughts and so I'm very concise tonight well I and I appreciate that but um what is your question Mr Gorski heard the question I said what time do I have available Mr B his question should be directed at the chair yes you have to direct me I only I only I can answer your questions
106you have uh 28.3 seconds left Fantastic Mr Braverman again direct me with respect to uh the buildings and grounds committee meeting from yesterday could you speak to why there's a need to study the environmental impact and wetlands of the land in question uh yes I can speak to that back in ' 05 there was a letter of interpretation that came with the property and that letter of interpretation we asked to extend that and the D said they would not two finance committee meetings or bg& meetings ago um we were hopeful that that Loi was going to get extended but it didn't so now we are uh we are tasked with going forward with that I I equated it last night and uh with Mr Braverman it's almost like uh your car you have your your
107uncle gives you a a 15-year-old car and he says yeah it's in pretty good shape okay next thing you know H I'm going to put Tire into it okay well you put tires into it then it needs brakes at some point you have to know when to fold them and that's what very closely that this board is looking at because we don't want to get into a situation where we have so much money invested in this property that it's it's wasting the taxpayers dollars we don't want to be there but you have to appreciate that any money that we spend on any land if we were to buy it ourselves we would be spending money on that property so the board is very mindful of of not throwing wasting money down a tube to keep
108buying tires brakes and uh and transmission on a car that's never going to run I get that and so does this board so we're very mindful of that and that's why we're going ahead with tonight's resolution we're going to it's going to be on the agenda later for a resolution to spend uh approximately $31,000 on further studies but it's going to be a tiered study where if certain portions of that study um come back unfavorable then we know no longer have to proceed with anything else so we thought it was prudent and that's why we're proceeding thank you are you aware of why the environmental commission would like to do a revised assessment of the wetlands uh as far yes I am I it was because our letter of interpretation has expired are you also
109aware that njd D post Sandy had to do a revisit of all tributaries and wetlands that was enacted in 2012 yes that was brought up last night were you given the 12 maps and the impact of that on that particular piece of land no I was not maybe the administration was Mr uh if Mr T wants to speak to this and then that'll be your last question because your your time is up am I at zero I'm sorry is it at zero yes it is yes if if you will Mr T I hate to put you on the spot good evening Jerry T from Central Administration the board is considering accepting from the township 65 acre parcel of land near Church Road in order for a school district to accept Land There is a land
110acquisition process set forth by New Jersey Department of Education specifically njac 6A colon 26-7 point1 and 7.2 the Board of Education engaged Edwards engineering to facilitate that process part of that process involved receiving documents from the township and the de developer on the parcel that this being offered in 2005 the developer had a Wetlands interpretation done on that property and received a letter of interpretation a letter of interpretation essentially delineates on his site what areas are wetlands and how they have to be dealt with that particular permit is set to expire in June of 2017 we need to know if we can utilize the data on that or if things possibly have changed Edwards engineering arranged for a meeting on our behalf at the NJ DP headquarters the meeting was on October 5th it was
111with representatives of the njd land use regulation Department as well as the njd Water Resource Management and they also requested that representatives from middlex County planning board attend two individuals came down from New Brunswick also to review our situation prior to the meeting Edwards engineering had provided them with all of the documents that we received from the township primarily the letter of interpretation mapping that we have uh Etc the D said that we could not rely on that letter of interpretation to the gentleman's point about Hurricane Sandy they indicated that there was a permanent extension act related to Hurricane standy that extended permits and that is why this particular permit has been extended out they could not comment at this time as to whether or not the land has changed whether or not there are
112additional Wetlands the report that that we have from 2005 does identify some Wetlands on that property the question is has the land changed have they expanded in furtherance to that there is another aspect that must be taken into consideration and that is the landscape project the landscape project is a GIS database which documents the existence of threatened and endangered species in our case it is the wood turtle so that area is identified as a potential habitat for the wood turtle now how does this affect what we do well the proposal that the board is considering tonight from a environmental science firm Brinkerhoff provides four primary tasks the first task is to map out the wetlands as they see they will do a Wetlands mapping um of the site and they will flag the site and
113through a GPS program will'll be able to produce a map that shows the wetlands as they interpret them the other important fact is to do a habitat analysis to First determine if it is a habitat for the wood turtle and secondly further down the road if it is determined to be such to then actually have to do an inventory to determine if the turtles are there they actually spend several nights there and they physically count Turtles and identify them so what do the turtles mean to the site well if you have a wetland feature that has to be dealt with and we know there are some and it is a site that has protected species on it then your area what is known as a buffer zone increases dramatically there are some for lack of
114a better term trenches that go through the site we're unsure if they are man-made or naturally occurring those trenches being a wetland feature have a 50-ft buffer zone on it so on that 65 Acre Site we know we have at least these main features going through if it happens to be a habitat that is occupied by this threatening danger species our ability to work around those is greatly impacted instead of being 50 ft off on both sides we're about 150 ft off on both sides so the proposal that is put forth before the board tonight has four tasks the recommendation that the committee reviewed last night was to proceed with two of those tasks again first to map the area with the known wetlands and then second to jump to task three because of the
115Season that we're entering and get the wood turtle habitat assessment done at that time you will have a map of the current known wetlands and then you will be able to determine if the hab feature is going to affect what we can do with that land at that point the board can look at the 65 Acre Site and the architect can look at it and say I will be able to fit this much of a building on it this much of a building on it or no building at all on it at that time the board can make a decision whether they want to bail on the property or if they want to continue to the additional steps that will be involved thank you very much Mr T stepen manfrey 12 Belmont Court uh I
116have a follow-up question in relation to this study uh I'm looking at the total here $317 73.5 and it's uh for the wetlands delineation and the habitat study uh by my math those two items should only cost $976 uh my question is why are we approving $331,000 uh for uh these services but we're saying we're only going to do two of them here shouldn't we be approving the 9,000 excellent question and we we discussed that last night the the 31,000 is what they they tend to call a not to exceed amount the engineering firm needs to have obviously that number to work with and they give a proposal based on the full plan but as Mr T just eloquently stated that uh if we if we do the mapping and the uh the wood turtle
117study then um we're not going to go further so we would only pay him for the services that they performed okay uh thank you for that explanation I guess you know I'm not a lawyer I've watched a lot of Matlock looking through the proposal uh I don't see anything that gives us an out uh as a as it pertains to uh stopping the study is that in this proposal well I mean correct me if I'm wrong but you only pay for what you uh what services are provided and that was question last not the way this reads right because it's not saying at any point uh the township has the right of refusal for following Services Mr T I'm not a lawyer or a uh can you use the microphone Mr T I'm sorry I
118want everybody to hear Jerry T again um if the board authorized proceeding with this we will issue a purchase order the purchase order is essentially the contract and the purchase order will stipulate that the board has the ability to only proceed with certain steps we have communicated that verbally to the firm and are fully aware that we may not follow through with all the steps thank you for that Mr T I guess my question would be in the spirit of transparency before we approve anything we should be seeing what the final purchase order is because this document right here does not give any sort of right for this Township and the taxpayers to cancel Services we're on the hook for $31,000 the way I read it and unless someone could point me to something that
119is uh giving us an opportunity to to step back from this this would be uh poor poor stewardship of the taxpayers money thank you any other questions I do um so you referred to uh the land as a gift from an uncle no I was referring to a vehicle a vehicle I didn't say a land it's like a vehicle well let me just say in the context of this debate some uncle right well I was actually going to elaborate and say that Uncle actually destroyed your vehicle and he gave you another one that's really what's happening cuz that's what the township has done and they're the ones that actually on the blame at this I didn't want to know how far to carry that analogy but it's exactly right as if your uncle ran into
120your car and basically rendered it useless and now he's going to give you another car and say Well it needs breaks it needs this and that's where we're at and I get that and I and I appreciate that M Mr no I think the residents appreciate it and we really appreciate the hard work and the effort that this board puts in my ask to you would be to make sure that we are constantly asking the township and we will do it ourselves does this represent the best that they could do for our taxpayers and for our kids because this looks like garbage to me right now if this is the best that they could do giving us land that has never been used before for this sort of purpose it's an embarrassment I I I
121agree I agree and like I said we're we're in this situation it's not a situation that we created but we're we're here we need to house the students we have a very very critical situation right now and I get that so is this board and I I appreciate that and and everyone should be on the hook including the township the mayor and the township Council and I would urge the board to vote for a proposal that clearly states our right as it relates to this study and not a full Freight $31,000 which how it reads today so if Mr T uh does have a purchase order or something that's going to uh you know create an out for us let's bring that next month and put that in front of uh the board members and
122give the taxpayers an opportunity to review it because this proposal right here does not do that okay thank you very much time is up good evening Patricia Lang 74 McFarland Circle um my question is maybe I missed something but we had committee reports but we didn't get one from buildings and grounds that's right okay didn't call on they didn't call on you which is well did I I'll say disrespectful but that's okay when I was in here in August I stood in front of this Board of Ed and I said why are we spending $10,000 or $133,000 at the time to study land that was a gift from the township if it was being given to us by this Township then the township had a produci responsibility to study it at that time I was
123reprimanded for calling it a gift we are still looking at it now it's August we are still looking at this gift which last night was called taking a pound of Flesh for every deal that we make with this Township I think it's really sad the wood Turtles go into hibernation in the middle of of November what happens when they don't get out there and find them and we go into another lawsuit like we did with the parks Savers and it costs us another $40 million to fight to have a school built that $40 million is the equivalent of $11 plus million dollar today imagine what we could have done with that money and on top of that we sit here and we argue over land that is probably useless that the board that the township
124was more than likely aware of the fact that it was useless and you still do not have a plan for the children that we have coming in on a daily basis I have heard board members brag that they saved us $150 Million by taking away the trailers knowing full well that we were going to be facing an overcrowding situation what are you going to do now to bring back those trailers what is it going to cost where are you putting our children my own daughter a seventh grader is being homeschooled right now because you turned 11 you turned our library at the middle school into 11 classrooms we have 550 Plus kids in a lunch period in middle school as an educator I can tell you that's a recipe for disaster how do our kids
125even have enough time to eat how do they have enough time to socialize I am more than disappointed in the actions of this board of education and your lack of responsibility to our children because the very first thing that we are supposed to be doing as members of a board of ed is to make every single decision based on what is in the best interest of our children and at this point in time you need to stop and think and put into a plan and activate that plan to provide classroom space for every single child that moves into this District whether that means trailers or whether that means that we move into the senior center I don't care find a space for these kids where talking about 2020 before we get classrooms what are you
126going to do for the next four years for these children thank you very much perfect timing there's really not much no comment we don't have to Lisa wethal T McFarland Circle um I'm I'm getting back new into this again so I happened to see Channel 28 last night and it occurred to me that um there wasn't a good explanation for at least I couldn't find one in the last board meeting for and maybe you can share with me why has there been any consideration given to building out on the existing Middle School I understand there's acreage and available space to build out to expand the middle school and then use the plan to expand Applegarth which I understand is old and needs complete renovation um why is that plan not being considered viable only in
127the light of the fact that there is urgency and you need to house students um and having gone through the debacle that was this high school and the Fiasco of the land that was given for free nothing is free so having gone through five or six years of that effort to get this High School built can you share the rationale for negating those options absolutely welcome back first of all it's good to see you back at the microphone um I know one thing is for certain is that to build onto Applegarth is something we would never want to undertake because what happens when you build onto an existing School you need to bring that building up to the current code and that would mean uh accessibility ramps uh I thought that's what one of the
128plans was no the plan was never to build on to build on that property and on the property okay so that's that yeah but it was it's not going to actually touch Applegarth and that plan that is a plan B are are we're very we're somewhat confident I want say very we're somewhat confident that worst case scenario is that we'll be able to build one school on the new property okay and that would help us tremendously especially if it was a middle school on the new property so and the reason the exist building out on the existing High um Middle School is not an option is there's not enough space but IOD elaborate offer please um some of the things that we're considering are uh parking spaces for staff uh the loss if we build
129on to the Middle School the loss of uh the fields that are there that the high school currently uses and I believe and I I hate to put Mr take on the spot again but I believe some of the land that uh is behind the Middle School may not be usable um you know to to build upon okay but but we are looking at as many different options including uh as you know um you know like building behind Applegarth School we're looking at as many different options as we can to make sure that we have space to build build so so rather than trying to jam everything into three minutes as has been suggested is I know that it's been done in the past to have somewhat of a public discussion of the options and
130why you've chosen to pursue the options that you are not withstanding the time frame that is of the essence why is I mean I feel I feel very much like everything's jammed into three minute segments and I know that's the public discussion but is there an opportunity for us to have more of a robust discussion about this well I mean that's how the board is made up I mean we're actually very lenient believe it or not I I talked to other board members and they said you give three public sessions are you out of your mind and I says no we're not out of mind we're we're interested in hearing from the public okay um so we've actually that is a key a key consideration and it was also brought to my attention there's a
131lot of board if you go online and look at other board um meetings they don't have the dialogue or the Rapport that we have they'll come up to the microphone and then we say thank you we'll take it under advisement very rarely do you see this board doing that because we we I love this part of it to be honest with you okay previous boards did not allow this interchange no they they were much more restrictive so that's why I'm asking in light of the fact that there this probably is not a well-known subject out there I think there's five people that know about it plus whoever lives in Colts Run is it um there's very few people that know about what's going on um so so I'm just suggesting as a way of getting
132feedback and educating your PO the the communities out there if we want these referendums to ultimately gain traction with stakeholders this is an opportunity for you to communicate with the public I agree and we've we've had numerous times where we presented this plan and we've had the student growth advisory commit committee um that they were very well over 100 people were involved with that um so this is not something that we just decided tonight to say hey let's do this I mean this has been an ongoing process we've involved the public as much as possible we've taken their input and we've listened and now it's ultimately we're the ones that you elect and if you're not happy with it November 8th is the day I get that you know and I'm if you're not happy
133that's the time to change it up but right now you have to rely on us to to to look at your best interest and that's what we intend to do thank you thank you thank you for letting me talk Charlie deiro uh 33 England Road um I own a property over there and I'm well familiar with the building because I built a lot of homes a lot of developments in town and I've been here for a long time to understand the politics and I understand everybody on this board's position and I know with November 8th as Tom just said you know it's it's a decision that we all have to make but Toll Brothers got these approvals to build these homes right next to my property and I got notices from from the environmental so
134did they do phase one and phase two on this entire property or just what they built on and please stop my time please m unfort Mr Pi I would have no way of knowing what the township uh or what the Builder did and and I don't know if anybody up here would know that either how about Mark raso it's our Township engineer how is he playing to this uh Mr President he's the township engineer we're not the township yeah but did he give you guys any uh guidance on his property not to the best of my knowledge is have you been in contact with him Mr T Mr Jerry T Mr raz's office provided all the documents that they had on the property which was the 2005 letter of interpretation and the studies that went
135along with that thank you because I did I did open their their records and I will have it but unfortunately I think this board should table this number 12 until they do own the property because I I don't believe the township even owns this property yet I don't think the Deeds were transferred last time I checked uh Toll Brothers getting the credit back on the taxes and the township doesn't even own it to the best of my knowledge and I I as Mr Gorski just said it's only been signed by the president and and the board Ed I don't understand how you guys can spend money on on a track of land if it's 9,000 if it's 31,000 it it you know it's it's a you guys know that we don't know that we trust
136your judgment but I don't know how you can spend that land that money on that land that you don't own that's an excellent point and that's why um this board has demanded that we not spend a penny until we get that letter of intent from the from the township and what happens is it's the way the meetings of the township are falling um they had the agenda meeting and then the full council meeting so right now that won't happen until they have a a council meeting how many how many acres are on Wetlands on the old Loi I don't know I haven't haven't have it memorized yet nobody knows that well I'm I'm sure somebody up here does how much of the land is Upland you know what I I we can't answer these questions
137we don't have a p how then how can you make a a professional we're not professionals we're Bor no I understand that then then you should have that consultant here we actually you have residents here you have residents here and taxpayers I pay taxes you know on about 10 properties on Mon row okay I own a property right across the street the 300,000 that just spent on that tennis courts was a loan to to this border ed I have a copy of the agreement and you know there's a lot of things that are going on here between the border of Ed and the township and I think the transparency is very important and you guys are doing a fine job but by the town giving us that over 7500 Acres of open space that's the
138best they can do these people that just bought homes over there spent some of them spend like a million and a half did Toll Brothers disclose that I'm a real estate broker I know how it works I know you do and that's why you got to be knowing that you're you're talking to the wrong people here but have you been saying all this and I hope everybody has been saying this at the municipal meetings but in all due respect Tom I don't want to see us all in court one day and us spending more money this building that we're standing in right here my wife and I we fought for for the Mt muua that charges almost $2 million for a reimbursement for water and sewer okay we have a pump station here and I
139own the house right across the street from here and I'm going to tell you something something they're going to do the same thing to us taxpayers when they own the mtud which they're not supposed to take any reimbursement I opened every single building that they built and they did not charge any reimbursement to the township but they charge us at the board Ed and that's not right give us those documents thank you very much any other uh members of the public wishing to speak going once going twice seeing none next up that that concludes the uh public forum of uh phase one there's still two others though so keep your hopes up um okay next thing is the uh superintendent report item 10 m Dr kak thank you Mr President as bless you bless you
140uh as uh required by the uh State we have our annual violence and vandalism report to detail any violence and analism reports between September of 2015 and June of 2016 for that year we had 33 incidents at the high school seven incidents at the middle school two incidents at Barkley um Brook which were property damage one HIV incident at mil Lake and one HIV incident at Woodland the incidents at the high school and the middle school do include include uh HIV incidents as well as what would be considered violence and vandalism a fight uh things like that the um student enrollment as we know has been going up it's in the agenda but I have been looking and we're tracking uh and I just wanted to give our average class sizes for our elementary schools
141uh the the middle and high school is a little harder to track because of a different CL classes and the schedules but currently our average for Applegarth is 26 students Barkley Brook is 22 students Brookside is 23 students mil lake is 23 students oak tree is 22 students and Woodland is 24 students we tried to look at that when we hired new teachers or open new classroom space to take that into account I would like to make special mention um our um Middle School National Junior Honor Society inducted 74 8th grade students into Which chapter on Thursday September 29th over 100 students were selected this month after a competitive application process at the middle school to take part in a traditional Middle School simulated election students were chosen to represent each of the presidential and
142vice presidential candidates for the Democratic green libertarian and Republican Party I'm going to be attending those uh next Friday for the different grade sixth seventh and eighth grade and then on Monday they're having a follow-up um I encourage any of the board members if you're available I think it's a it's a good process uh that the Middle School uh does with their students on this past Monday evening Dr Alik next to me uh held a parent information night for all K3 parents regarding the standards space report cards I believe there were about 80 parents in attendance is what you wrote I'm taking these right from your notes as you know and uh the elementary principles and supervisors were also there to answer any questions from the parents and parents were particularly interested in how map
143would get information map is our assessment new assessment we give information for their children and it was explained that they would be getting very specific information related from that uh Kyle nosier of Team Senators was elected to represent the middle school for the the Gandhi art and writing contest at Princeton University and earned third place honors for that and he is currently a freshman at our high school and also kudos to miss guiano for supporting Kyle in the contest the high school fine arts instructor Mr David verel was selected as the millstone times teacher of the month and uh Mr verell teaches Studio Art one Studio Art 2 art careers and AP art history at the high school he is also the adviser for the national uh Arts National Arts Honor Society as Dr Rob
144already mentioned or student representes our high school marching band um finished the first of its two events so far this season and um under the direction of Mr Alf hadinger the band was top rated group 4A band at the North Brunswick and E East Brunswick competition and last Saturday they uh also hosted their annual uh marching band competition at our High School Mr Roy dbor is a Community member that uh very unselfishly volunteers his time to attend I think he's at every one of our athletic events all year long and he's a professional photographer and he takes thousands of pictures of our kids and he freely disperses them to the school to the media we've gotten so much coverage so I just wanted to say a public thank you to him uh for that he
145does that just all the you know I've talked to him at football games and different events and he he's he's it's really I'd like to commend him for that uh he also brought to my attention that this was something we had a committee meeting on I I couldn't attend the girl soccer senior day had uh in his words a really touching moment last night when their manager their student manager for four years who was a senior uh Megan Fanon was suited up well she was suited up and and participated in the game she's normally just a manager uh and scored a goal and did very uh did a very nice job for that so it was uh a nice moment for the student and for the team um you know and her parents I'm sure
146our high school boys that was already mentioned they clinched a first grader middle sex conference Red Division title since 2005 our girls volleyball again our student Representatives mentioned that won their division on the agenda I would like to bring some things to your attention just before you go through the agenda uh Personnel uh first I like just like to announce that the newly announced retirees I wish them all very healthy and happy retirement letter F under Personnel Dr um staro is leaving uh to accept a promotion in another District I wish her well she's um will be a loss as any of our other personel that are leaving letter K just mentions that uh well well it talks about Mr Jinx but he will be taking the place if the board so approves him as
147Dr staar's replacement at the middle school and letter HH uh Jean Bara is being recommended to a full-time kindergarten position due to the increased enrollment also due to the increased enrollment a new language limited uh disability classroom is being formed due to the increased enrollment for special needs children so with that I would like to um ask the board to recommend Personnel items a through JJ so moved second any questions uh to Dr kak seeing none Mr Mr Gori a roll call please Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman I'm sorry I didn't hear what the motion was Personnel items a through JJ a through JJ yes [Music] sir yes thank you Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs colowit yes Mr noin yes Mrs Kino yes of sayain Unice fona so noted thank you Mr Russo
148yes and Mr rutsky yes board president Personnel items a through JJ has passed I'd like to Mr President for board action yes thank you like to recommend to the board that they uh the appr the approval of items a through Q under board action so move second second questions or comments uh for Dr kak seeing none uh can we have a roll call vote please yes sir Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman no on N yes on the rest no on n as in Nancy correct got it Mrs Deo no on N yes on everything else Mr calman uh re yes everything recuse on n and O Mrs colano yes Mr nosin yes Mrs Kino yes Mr so yes and Mr ratsky I abstain on all with the exception of letter G letter P and letter
149Q where I vote yes thank you Mr board president motion passes thank you very much um that concludes my report Mr President thank you excellent thank you um next up is the uh business administrator report Mr board president and members of the Monroe Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through H be approved by consent roll call second second somebody is there any questions uh to Mr Gorski on his uh business administrator's report M col panovich I probably have a few questions so you you could bear with me on number 12 um since I was not at the buildings and grounds meeting yest yesterday and there's been a lot of stuff going around today I I do have some questions um the way I'm reading this is that the board
150cannot start this or approve or we can't start the survey until we get the letter of intent from the township is that correct that that is correct and so we're not expecting that for another two to three weeks after they have their their meeting their council meeting I would say yes okay um if when we if if they approve that which I guess we're assuming they will and we approve this study when will we expect to get the results back from this studyi it's your report Mr T are you aware when the results are expected one month one month is the answer okay thank you and after this survey will we be doing more surveys will we need have the need to do more surveys on this land if the surveys came back okay will
151we need to do more being familiar with the process I'm going to say the answer is probably yes and would we have any idea how much a different survey could cost us there's various department of education requirements uh soil testing and so on that'll all be presented to committee and the board um as we progress with this so that would be another time constraint yes yes and that that is the the essence of why there is a sense of urgency to move with this and I understand that so Dr kak with all this that we're doing are we still okay for a referendum next September well as was mentioned earlier tonight as much as I would like to have a referendum there's as you know there's only five dates so we said September right uh
152we said September but I don't know if September was one of the dates but the the first F available fall date was what I was really hoping to have as with any thing any plan uh there you run into bumps in the road you run into all kinds of things that have come up so as this is moving along and as we started to you know we thought at least I thought the land will be usable and by the way these studies to my knowledge we would have to do with any plot of land so you know as the studies are taking more time and then we have to stop and we have to go back and come back to the board and then vote for something additional uh much to my chagrin uh it
153looks like we would not be able to have a referendum out in the fall but as I heard tonight possibly January my hope would be to expedite this process as quickly as possible uh you know we we're doing the best we can as you heard the class sizes not terrible uh 22 to 25 for our elementary schools I know in our Middle School some of our classes have gotten higher um but the quicker we can move through with the process the better so you know unfortunately it's not when I want to have the referendum vote it's when we can complete all the studies and then the State wants us to give them 6 months when we submit our paperwork now my understanding is that they might complete it sooner than six months but I have
154no way of knowing that so there's some things that are out of our control so unfortunately the quicker I try to get this resolved it seems like the more um impediments or or things that that get in our way that that are pushing this back so because I I think I'm one of the few people on this board who was involved as a board member for the referendum for the high school right and that cost us 40 everybody says it all the time an extra $41 million because it took us four years to even start the process of building the high school plus another three years to build the high school we we don't have that time to wait anymore and I'm looking for um I I've asked you know in reconvene the steering committee
155because I think we need to have a plan B and a plan C in place in case this isn't going to work we can't wait for all the studies to come back and then say okay now we have to look for something else yeah and and that's can I answer okay that that's very true uh what we've been doing is meeting with the architect meeting with the demographer and saying if we can only build one school what what are our options and we have options kind of fleshed out if we can only do a middle school if we can only do an elementary school that changes it if the land is not usable at all well we're we're faced with the decision then to do another land search or do a land search not another
156but a land search which I know from other like North Brunswick what they're going through or have gone through for land search and the cost and then the cost of acquiring the land what that would be and then or the other option is to look at our existing properties which we've looked at and to say okay can we go vertical you know Applegarth is a perfect example 15 Acres you know how far back how much can we build up how how can we still leave room for parking what will we do with the students in Applegarth could we would we have to put them in a trailer over by oak tree to house them if we had to raise Applegarth to build something new so we're exploring all those options the one thing that we
157talked about is is we're working as with as many people as we can but we want to stay true to the process we went through a year study or at least a six-month study with the student growth advisory committee we looked at many different options we looked at the history for what was done in the past in this this District um and we're looking to see you know how we can move forward for it and we determined that at the time we thought we had land that was usable you know we're going on a trust Factor as well we've been working with the township we relied on them to provide all the documents we've met with their engineer we've met with the mayor the business multiple times over this this period they supplied they told
158us that there was no other land available if there were people in the public that feel that there is other land well I you know we we we we did what we could to see what else was available other than paying for a land search so should that land not be available yes we could look at possibly using the middle school we we got to we got to be careful with the parking the fields um possibly uh making Applegarth bigger than what we had planned on doing we have three schools of our three of our elementary schools that we have already identified as schools that we could build onto those schools but but as you know Mr T his knowledge in this is um I'll just say you know for everyone you probably know this
159already is invaluable that the knowledge that he brings forward to the school district on the the the legalities of things or the the building codes you know but one of the things he mentioned is as we start going into our other elementary schools you start uncovering things that right now are safe that aren't harmful but now you're you're held to a different code an updated code so that might require changing a lot more than we would have to to currently change um I know it may not seem like to people in the in the you know the public in the audience that well we're just sitting around twitting our thumbs waiting for something to happen but that's the furthest thing from the truth that there is well there's a there's a lot of rumors going
160around the township I think there's a lot of people who expected that we would have referendum last June and they're wondering what included what's going on and I think one of the things that we need to do is be more transparent in reaching out to people Channel 28 would be a great if we could get on there and give people the news or the information and why we're doing what we're doing and the other thing is maybe we need to we did that many years ago have a community relations committee where we had somebody from every one of the planned retirement communities and the PTA and give them the information they can bring back I don't think they're getting the information that we need and the other concern I have is um losing teachers to
161other districts if we're not quick enough in getting what we need done because they can go to other towns and work in a with a 20 Child classroom instead of a 30 child classroom they could but also there's a lot of towns with declining enrollments and they're laying people off too and you you know I would like to think that the teachers that are working in our district uh anybody can leave and you know what I mean but they they have stayed and that and during prior uh increases in enrollment when this high school was built and of course I wasn't here I understand people could have left at that time EI you know also but they didn't because I think they believe in what we're trying to do together uh the the communication that
162you mentioned we had actually discussed that we discussed that the steering Comm uh committee as well which you're a member of and but I think at least my understanding was once we had a plan that we were moving forward then we really pushed forward uh communication on that my monthly newsletter that goes out to the community and we you know try to get it out to the Senior Communities as well I I give updates every single month on where we're at and it's look I'm more frustrated than I won't say than anyone else I'm very frustrated but I understand that when you go through something like this it's complicated and there are a lot of things that that come up there are surprises there unexpected things to go on so why I keep that post
163in my office the road to success is almost always under construction because things come up and we have to deal with it we we can't walk away we have to deal with it and when we first started this process he you know a year and a half ago I thought by June we would be going out for a referendum last month um obviously there were things that came up that prevented that from occurring but I I understand and if we need to communicate where we're at I would like to at least have some answers back from the study and and you know the company said it's a six-month study I think we waited six days and we said can you give us an update you know and and we're constantly asking them for updates and
164they were very honest they said it's a six-month study I I I would like to go out to the community with some tangible right now I don't feel like I have that but maybe you're right maybe the idea is to go out and to say we don't have anything tangible we we we're working on Alternatives we also don't want to throw money in 15 different directions or throw energy into 15 different directions if this comes back and we find out that part or all the land is usable we don't want to divert away from that either I think they just need to know that we've taken this step and this step and this step and they would at least feel better knowing they don't know what we're doing and I think that's part of the
165problem but I will support this only because I know that no matter what piece of land we have we would have to do the same kind of study we might not be looking for Turtles but we would be looking for something else and I know that because of past experience with referendum so that's the reason I would will support this sorry if I took up too much time you get unlimited oh thank you anybody else have any questions uh for Mr Gorski Miss armeno um we passed a a a resolution for the $133,000 and we have not utilized or used all of that money pre uh to the to date is that correct that's that is correct okay so I think the public needs to know that we went out for third and that encompassed
166a beginning of a review and Survey of what was going on but since we have now gone into this other phase we put a hold on the use of the remainder of the 13,000 is that correct that is not correct okay so can you explain that yes Ed Edwards engineering is doing a different study uh they're doing a feasibility study for the land based upon our um our our plans and that is still commencing uh they are getting paid on an installment basis as the work is getting done but if if so we're H we're allowing them to give us a study of either two buildings or one building are they aware I mean why would we have them do a feasibility study on construction if we're not sure that the land like if we
167can hold off on that I thought that's what was discussed last night yeah that's that's what I understood sort of in the same vein as this if we go in increments in order to if if certain things disallow the use of this land in whole or part then it then we know we've done our due diligence and we're done with it and and we haven't spent all of the money and I do um and I and I voiced this last night I I do agree with members of the public that feel that there should be a list of of how we go and time frame of what we do first how much we spend and I mean I would I would like this resolution to have some kind of stop Gap um limit but I
168understand look it seems to me that we're in a a really difficult place and it always seems like there's a crisis but the crisis again is not of our making the crisis is of population we don't have control of the population and again as members of the public said we have an obligation to house these children but we have to house them in a re in a reasonable fashion and and a responsible fashion I mean I have historic memory of this school being built and the land crisis that went on here and I think instead of spending 40 million extra to go through what we had to go through on this we're spending and I'm not happy happy about it but we're spending tens of thousands rather than Millions to determine whether the land is
169feasible or not I think that seems to be more responsible because if we think about it we were supposed to get 35 Acres of this property and as it turned out which contributed to the cost of the 40 million part of this property we could not use because of incumbrances of historic preservation issues so I think I certainly have learned a lesson from this building that we need to do our due diligence on other property whether that property I mean we don't own the property it would be perfect if we if we own the property and I do believe that it's the responsibility of the township to if they're going to transfer property to us they should transfer it in in the best and most pristine manner but again we're we're up against a rock
170in a hard spot because there's we have an obligation and yet we don't have control of how this is going and the rapid enrollment that we're we're doing so um I just think that we're in the same predicament we were and we're going to continue to be in this predicament until we we change the the rapid construction that's going on again from a different government body um but we are responsible a and it it it's very difficult to to make these decisions I'm not happy about it but if we don't make this decision then we'll be accused of not moving fast enough toward referendum if we do make this decision then we're irresponsible we're we're saying that we're irresponsible because we don't own the land if we wait to see if this land is coming
171our way then we have to begin these surveys and everything anyway and then so then then we've been irresponsible by not having foreseen this issue so I it's it's a very tough decision but you know we're all grown-ups we have to make it so I hope the public understands it's it's it's complicated anybody else have any questions for Mr gor's report Mr I I just want to piggy back on that I do have a question so a I do I thought we said last night at the bg& meeting that the 13,000 for the um the study to figure out where the schools go or one or two I did thought I did think we talked about it it was sort of on hold as you said that I did recall that you're you're correct I
172guess my point to that is so B then we're looking to spend this let's say $10,000 for this next phase of the study and then if that comes to be useless the prop then we shut down everything we don't spend the second half or 21,000 of this and we don't spend the other half of the 13,000 and then so just for the record then we don't own the property and then why would we want to own the property because then it's just something that's on our books that some way day we're going to have to maintain in some way shape or form so to spend $10,000 to find out if we want the property again to me to Echo your point that seems like the smart fiscal decision to make at this time from a
173responsible standpoint so that's just I just wanted to clarify thanks s Sure Mr calman just a real point of clarity because I heard something earlier so we're the number 12 here I don't have a problem with the money management actually if anybody is going to be worried about money getting DED out of this District inefficiently or inappropriately this is not our first day at to Rodeo this is not the first time we've gone through this this team over here is going to shell out money in the appropriate time in the appropriate amount and not risk any Financial challenges how how many millions did we 8 million did we return for this High School correct over aund and something million dollars so get over that um but I do have a question about the ownership of
174the land today so based on this are we do we know that the township now owns and has been deeded that land that they're writing the letter of intent against according to Wayne Hamilton who I spoke with yesterday the township is in a process of acquiring it it is still owned by Toll Brothers they anticipate that transfer soon so just to be clear we're approving an intent of an intent with all best intention tche and that's mainly a timing thing I guess what we're saying is because they're going to get it they got the letter staged up and ready to go I just want to make sure that uh you know it you I I get the timing thing again it's not the first time we've done this but um it would have been better
175if the town actually had the deed and my my question would be do they not have the deed to the to the land because they too feel it's questionable you know I that's the only concern I have so if they don't get it we're giving you the go-ahead to go ahead and do this on the land but um I got my question answered I guess I actually have a question too to to to Mr cowman's point it is a concern with the time frame now let's just say we're we're on the assumption that at the next council meeting that they're going to sign this letter of intent let's say that doesn't happen at what point do we say hey let's bag this well number 12 is conditional upon the letter of intent being executed so
176if we don't have a letter of intent executed we will not proceed with number 12 but there's no deadline on I know we could say well the town we say we're going to sign this letter of intent in January and we're not going to we're not going to proceed until we get that it would already went through both uh parties councils and it's just awaiting a council meeting at this point it's a done deal so that's what I want here Al so I have a question based on your question that you just asked um the letter intent only means that they're going to give us the land after they get it they intend to give us the land after they get the land that's correct so we have no idea when they're going to get
177the land do they have a letter of intent from told Brothers to get the land Mr no time oh I'm sorry Mr Min um and I you can't hold me to this but just my um engagement in the in and planning board and and zoning board meetings when I've seen them generally they because of the cluster Zone provision it is an arrangement that the land will be deeded to the township at a certain level of construction and a certain level of delivery of properties to the homeowners so and it it it is and Mr T may know or or the other professionals may know exactly when that is because it's in the approval process the site approval and the construction approval and variance approval all of those things are in the in the approval process
178from either the planning board the zoning board or the township Council so they're the ones who have there's a thing called um technical Review Committee TRC Technical and that's when the township officials and the Builder and that's not a transparent um procedure when they sit down with the officials and they talk about when these things are to occur so again I'm not an expert on this but just given my my exposure to it it's my understanding that it's part and parcel of the approval process and there is a time frame that we can probably figure out that they will it it's part of what I remember being at that meeting and it they talked about the 65 acres and it was due to the agreement between the township and the Builder that that land would
179be delivered to the township at a certain point in the construction process and I think it's close to that but I'm not sure but that's how that t tends to work but someone can add any further questions from the board seeing none Mr Gorski a roll V Mrs armenio uh yes Mr Braverman no on a12 yes on the rest Mr too yes Mr calman yes Mrs go Pano yes Mr noin yes and Rec's on F thank you Mrs karino yes Mr Russo yes on anything and no one and Mr rutsky I abstain with the exceptions of items uh letter A numbers 1 through 11 letter D and letter G where I vote yes thank you Mr board president motion passes and that concludes my report thank you I just wanted to uh point out also
180under item h i I should have done it before uh that um Mr Herbert Mars was very generous and very kind to donate a uh a slide projector uh with trays so who knew they even existed um um next up is the board president's report um uh I don't have much to say because I'm only board president for a day and um the current board president St Steve Ryback wanted me to uh let the members of the public know and let the board know that um he has appointed a uh negoti ating committee because it's that time of year again and the negotiating committee will consist of uh Mr Steve Ryback um Michelle armino and Mr Tom notein myself so we look forward to uh that procedure starting I guess uh probably sometime in in
181mid mid December at that point and that concludes the board president's report is there any other board of education business that any other members would like to discuss question Mr Braverman um I think last month or the month month or two months ago we mentioned the high school falling out of the top 100 did you investigate that come up with any conclusions as to why that happened uh yes M right yes Mr bman uh actually I reported on that either last month or whenever it was but I I went through I did an analysis of other schools that made it why uh in some categories such as um the number of Arts courses that students take we reported our data a little differently than other schools um that they changed some of the criteria in
182how they selected schools from previous years and the data is from two years ago so we looked I I used a couple schools as an example I used the East Brunswick School District uh and the number one school district chadam who had extremely high uh graduation rates and and everything else so in some categories we scored a little higher and others we scored lower but they did change the criteria so we were I think 80 and then we dropped down to I don't know 30 or something uh out of the number of high schools in New Jersey use your microphone the they took out the technology my understanding is because again it's two years old the the data my understanding is the last time there was something in there about technology how it was used
183and with this High School in particular with a one toone initiative uh that would have boosted this District up very high had they use that criteria but they replaced that and used the number I believe it was the number of Arts courses that students participated in and when we looked at the report we looked that that number was very low for and we were surprised and I think it was how the data was reported because there are different types of arts art courses that are available to high school students digital media and graphic arts and whatever and I don't think all of those courses were reported in that category uh which again doesn't explain the entire drop but that was part of it though because a lot of the other categories if you look at
184it we were pretty close with a lot of the other categories uh not number the the chatam you know they're talking 99% in a a lot of their categories but for a lot of the other districts uh we were close in a lot of these a lot of those categories but that data is from 201415 that they're that that they use for that study any other board members questions seeing none it is time for the second public forum other board business oh other Oh I thought okay I'm sorry I thought that's actually what we're doing I thought other board business we did it already but if there is I one sorry Z out I would like to hear Mr braverman's bg& sure he had his opportunity before but he can always have it again want
185to hear it I do sure we do okay let me find it oh I got it right here because I knew you were G to ask okay we had five items and I think at this point before I go into the five items I ought to tell you that there was not a lot of Refreshments left by the time my committee met the first item was the eagle scout made a presentation that he wanted to put paint the United States on the playgrounds of oak tree and we approved that then we had an update on the engineering review now you want me to go over that again no I'm good I'm afraid right now actually but no I'm good then we had a report on the close out ASB bestus removal project at barlay Brook
186now I know that most people thought we had none left but we're getting rid of the rest of it now we had a report on the solar system at Oak Tree and we had a report on the roof design proposal at Barkley Brook thanks for asking the only reason I came tonight we left we saved the best for last marved is there any other uh Board of Ed business at this moment seeing none we will proceed to the uh the second public forum where this is uh the opportunity for the members of the public to speak on any item that they uh that they want to with with no bounds except the three minute Rule and we ask that you state your name and your address and any Affiliated group that you are representing step
187manfrey 12 Belmont Court and I am not representing an Affiliated group uh at last meeting uh board president Ryback uh had uh generously offered to run a special committee meeting or put it by the committee chair to run a special meeting on the topic of the uh land in question uh on England Road to my knowledge nothing has come of that so I want to resurface that tonight and see if we can get uh sort of resolution or vote uh possibly from Mr Braverman to have that session I think we've heard from the public this evening that there is an insatiable appetite to learn more about the contingency plans related to uh future building of schools as well as um this particular uh parcel of land and the proposal so uh I would respectfully submit
188to uh Mr noin Mr Braverman a request to have a vote and get that session scheduled well first of all I think that's an awesome idea because um that is actually the the best place to bring this to that's why this board we function as as a board of committees which means that the Committees are the ones that really do the research they do the the real leg work and and the hard work and the close work with the uh district and with the experts so um it's my understanding that Mr Ryback did actually ask and requested that uh you contact him so that to set that up so at this point uh Mr Braverman is the chair of the buildings grounds on Transportation I think that's where this probably is a good place to
189start at um it's just as simple as no vote required it's as simple as either he contacting you or you contacting him to set that up and I I too am a member I'm the the vice chair of that committee and I I would welcome that yeah that would be excellent and just to um kind of re uh the Mr Ryback last month said that that was something that he would have to initiate so if it would be acceptable to Mr Braverman uh considering we're both here right now can we get this special session scheduled you are correct that Mr Ryback has to initiate it that's our board policy okay so that seems to be in conflict with with well it is I mean I'll check the board but I'm I'm the chair of the
190finance committee it's my understanding I can ask anybody to come in and and be in front of my committee and that's that's as far as I know that's how our board policy reads but obviously if there if there's a discrepancy in that we will correct that and I will make sure that Mr Rybeck gets the message to authorize Mr Braverman to reach out to you to come to in front of that meeting because I think it's a it's a great idea okay it sounds like a lot of red tape and we're all sitting right here it seems a little silly it usually is whom can I follow up with and what's the contact information to be able to do that well uh like I said we're we're all online we're the the mon Township Board
191of Ed website all our our names and addresses are are up there and an email would be sufficient more than sufficient because it's actually operable so your your document will be an operable requests and the time will be date stamped so if there's any question that he got it or not we'll know okay and uh am am I correct to assume that that request will be approved um Mr Gorski just reiterated what I said the committee chair is the one who sets the agenda I know I do it at Finance and I assume Mr Braverman does it at at bg& our next meeting is November 15th November 15th that sounds great Mr Braverman I will be in touch uh to speak further thank you very much thank you let me let me give you my
192email address that sounds great be the board email address if it's on the website I could I could grab it from there thank you very much Mr Braverman johon Court Mr braver and thank you for voting no and and showing your uh conscience on that vote I really appreciate it and hopefully the public sees that effort um question uh number one uh more of a clarification the tributaries that were discussed by Mr T that affect the 65 acres of parcel land uh are actually uh through area photography date back as far as we can tell from some uh airplane photography back to the early 1900s uh so these are tributaries that have been on that land for an extensive period of time with respect to the letter of intent uh the letter of intent is
193a very uh very much a double jeopardy because there is an action that has been motioned against to Brothers uh for the land in question I also did uh have a conversation and Oprah request will show the telephone records of calls from Mr Hamilton uh and the mayor's office and the mayor specifically to me about their belief in how soon that land can be transferred so if they are to be believed the land in question uh could remain uh in the developer hands for a minimum of 9 to 12 months uh so that's I think of of relevance to this committee uh thirdly um we're dealing with a bit of language semantic here and it it just it annoys me to no end as a citizen I appreciate going in front of Mr braverman's Forum
194but Mr braverman's Forum does not have the Quorum of this board of education Mr Braverman trans form as a subset of this this fine group of distinguished people uh what we are looking for and what I asked for last month and what Mr Rybeck entertained uh is a full special meeting of the Board of Education where it is disclosed to the public in the newspapers so that this discussion can be fully had and everybody including media can have an opportunity to understand the situation that's unfolded in this Township that's the type of form that I'm looking for and that's the form that Mr Rybeck enter ained last month but I've not seen any conclusive resolution along with your body of laws that govern this Quorum uh to allow that to pass uh Mr board president
195Mr interim board president will you allow a resolution to have a special meeting of this board of education with the full Quorum for public discourse now basically what we what we would like to do I'd like to see you come in front of the building grounds and transportation committee because that's how this board works we're not a board of the whole if they were a board of the whole we would have these type of presentations in front of everybody you mentioned that it's not a quorum at the committee meeting well it better not be a quorum at the committee meeting because then it's got to be announced as a public record so we know that we're mindful of that and that's why we operate that way and that's how it's always been and we just
196had matter of fact last year one of the board goals was to potentially change that and we didn't so that's how it works that's the constraints that we work under and under those constraints what would be a success criteria within that committee meeting to actually hold a special meeting of the Board of Education that actually might absolutely typically what happens in a committee Mee Mr Gorski if you stop the time please thank your pardon don't don't instruct me on how to operate the CL I understand but you have a tendency to delay the stopping of the time Mr Gorski with all du respect pleas with all du respect Mr Gorski I want to work with you here we're on the same side just remember that okay what we what we want to do here is
197we want you to be heard and I and I want to hear you and this board wants to hear you but by you looking at that clock I'm the one who looks at the clock I'm the one who's going to give you extra time because I'm working with you okay so let's just stop that right now now secondly on that on that note Mr Enter president um I I appreciate the fact that I I was harassed last meeting to provide information that I thought was relevant to the public uh at the time by Mr Gorski uh and the board president so I'm a bit shellshocked this month coming into the same form to provide critical information that can allow actionable Decisions by the systemed Board of Education and I appreciate your concern I I don't
198think that that um you look too harassed last week you look like you were in control but the bottom line here is you were treated fairly Mr Ryback worked with you gave you extra time as I intend to do tonight I appreciate that now getting back I even forgot the original question the the original the original question um oh about uh after the committee meeting yeah that's actually where this needs to happen at the committee level and then what happens the committee then will mull over what you have to say We'll look at your information and then it's that point they make a recommendation to the full board at a public announced meeting that's the way it works and that's the way we're going to follow the rules that's helpful guidance thank you and lastly
199uh with with having the esteem Mr T here tonight um he brought up some publicly now known information about meetings that were had with middle sex County Planning uh and other types of relevant events relating to this matter there's an outstanding Opera that was furnished to the board of education and I believe also to the uh to the Monroe Township facility uh being that this information is now in draft form email Communications have been have meeting attendees and itinerary has been had I'd like to reemphasize that we'll be uh requesting those opras so that we can uh in turn collect that information in real time excellent I and I appreciate Oprah is your friend time's up time's up thank you so much thank you any any other members of the public seeing none the next
200item of business is item 15 we have a Clos session resolution that I will be reading be it resolved at the board of education of the township of Monro hereby moves to go into close session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws of 1975 njsa 10 col 40 4-6 through 10 4-21 to discuss the following subjects one harassment intimidation and bullying item two personal matter level three grievance following close session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists do I have a motion second um all in favor I all opposed going to take a b so noted he was opposed whoos Brave that okay the Monro Township Board of Ed is
201back in session after Clos session um we have a resolution to read it is recommended to the Monro Township Board of Education by Administration to hereby deny the level three grievance regarding employee number 004 313 dated October 17 2016 the superintendent of schools and the board's business administrative board secretary are authorized to take all steps necessary to implement this action of the Board of Education needs a first and a second do you have a first yes second second okay any questions or comments okay Mr Gorski roll call vote please Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman yes Mrs Deo yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr nosin yes that is all of of the eligible voters uh it requires a simple majority that is unanimous five motion passes thank you Mr gki okay this brings the next public
202forum uh but only to speak on items that occurred as a result of the executive session are there any members of the public wishing to speak at this time seeing none I need a motion to adjourn so mov second all those in favor all those opposed thanks