CorpusRecord 132973

Monroe Township Board of Education 11.16.16 Regular Meeting

A searchable transcript preserved as part of the Discourse Corpus. Passage numbers provide stable references within this record; verify quotations against the original recording when available.

Source
YouTube / Monroe Township School District
Date
2025-02-14
Location
Middlesex County, NJ
Material
Transcript
Extent
17,547 words · about 98 min
Collected
2026-06-19

Transcript

Verbatim source text

001good evening this meeting of Monro Township Board of Education is now called to order well I I'd like to ask everyone to please uh rise for the pledge and have our student board member Mr Jamal lead us in that pledge I pledge allegiance to theedge flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands one nation God indivisible with liberty and justice for all G we have roll call Mrs armeno here Mr Braverman here Mr Deo here Mr calman here Mr K panoi here Mr nosin here Mrs Kino here Mr Rybeck here Mr Russo here and Mr rutsky here Mr board president you have a quarum present this evening that's good in accordance with the provisions of the New Jersey open public meetings law the Monroe Township Board of Education

002has caused notice of this meeting to be published by having the date time and place thereof posted November 11th 2016 at all schools the home News Tribune cranberry press and filed with the clerk of the municipality thank you we can move through approval of minutes I'd like a motion to approve the public Board of Education um meeting of August 31st 2016 don't move um second second any discussion I we can vote all those in favor I any opposed can I say hands for oppos no okay exensions recusals motion passes uh a motion to approve the close session meeting August 31st 2016 I move I have a second second thank you um any discussion we can vote all in favor I any opposed I'm one exstension no recusals okay motion passes I need a motion to

003approve the public Board of Education meeting September 14th 2016 I moved second anyone second thank you okay any uh discussion we could vote in favor I any opposed abstentions recusals motion passes now we could move to our uh student board members report Jamal so not too many things to talk about today but the first thing is that uh our high school football team picked up a win against Princeton winning 38-13 a couple days ago uh another highlight is our boy soccer team made it all the way to the state semi-finals before losing to 100 in central who went on to win it all it's the best season that uh I think the boy soccer team has had in a while and everybody's been very excited for their progress and the last thing is something I

004found out just earlier today actually uh our high school marching b band placed fifth out of 21 bands at a national tournament and in a couple of weeks they'll be going to Hawaii to perform in the 75th anniversary of Pearl Harbor along with other state bands and the US Marine band that concludes my report thank you very much uh we have a presentation on harassment intimidation and bullying HIV hi welcome I'm Lori McConnell I'm the um district coordinator for anti-bullying good evening um my presentation is the biannual report for harassment intimidation and bullying we need to present this at a public forum uh two times per year if you look at the next slide you'll see our first report is from January 1st through January 30th that is period 1 July 1st through December 31st

005is period two um this report is for the period one so that would be from June January excuse me 1st 2016 through June 30th 2016 the next slide I'm not sure all of those can see but I believe the board members at least have a copy of it it is actually the definition of bullying I'm not going to read you the whole thing and bore you with it it's quite extensive but I do want to point out the first bullet um any Act of bullying has to be reasonably perceived as being motivated by an actual or perceived characteristic we will go into what those characteristics are in um further slides our anti-bullying Specialists um at each School are listed on the next slide we have one in each of the elementary schools we have two

006in the middle school and two in the high school typically in the high school and the middle school the two investigators or anti-bullying Specialists do investigate together whenever possible so from January 1st through June 30th we had 19 reports of um harassment intimidation and bullying 15 of those cases were founded four were on founded when we look at the district data this is where it gets into the protected categories um there's actually two slides on this I did not fit them onto one um and you can see by category what they are I like I missed one yeah I'm one ahead I'm sorry um so many you know a lot were based on race color religion um um and as you can see some two on sexual orientation one on disability and the other there

007are other things that are included that may not be um identified as one of the protected categories but they are considered bullying um the next slide you can see the confirmed incidents um we had zero at Applegarth zero at Barkley zero at Brookside one at mil Lake seven at the high school 10 at the middle school zero at Oak Tree and one at Woodland School seems to me we're doing pretty good um this NE the next few slides are the breakdown by school of what um protected category the incident or incidents were bullied were um founded for um we had one for race for the middle school we had one for sexual orientation I miss something here and nine were other for the high school we had five for race two for religion two for

008sexual orientation and one for disability for mil Lake School there was one issue based on race and for Woodland School there is one issue based on disability when we look at um bullying we usually have to impose some type of discipline particularly if it's founded um so I wanted you to know that the discipline is really determined based upon the code of conduct the investigators typically make a recommendation to the school principal the superintendent also looks at that and then they make a final determination um whenever possible or appropriate remediation is provided to both the offenders and the victims we have uh vast array of programs that go on in the schools to prevent bullying as you can see in the next list those are many of them probably not 100% inclusive but we try

009to generalize them we also provide training for all um staff and um people that work within the district and you can see the list on the next slide that's it any questions yes ma'am um are we finding that there are reenders not very often but occasionally I would say the out of those 19 and I don't have the the statistic right with me but a general one might be two maybe three okay yes um yeah just a a comment and then a question the comment is that uh when I was at the uh the workshop I went to a training on this HIV and one of the interesting things that they brought out believe it or not was the um distinguishing uh characteristic and the they ruled actually that uh veganism is now a distinguishing

010characteristic that's fascinating to me because I have not heard that one yet exactly it was fascinating to a lot of us and um I guess you know that's where we would put it under other right and that's where a lot of the you know incidental type of things that you wouldn't you know you can't possibly list everything and that's why you saw I think it was nine under other which is significant when you're looking at 19 cases but I guess my question is who determines I mean uh obviously ultimately I think it's an administrative law judge but I I think um you're absolutely right that's exactly what determines it I mean we would probably make a recommendation to the best of our knowledge within the district but when it's a new thing such as veganism

011you know we might consider that a type of bullying we we'd have to look at the rest of the definition in order to determine that um sometimes the anti-bullying specialist will contact me I will contact our lawyer and we'll see we'll get the best information we can at the time but case law usually determines the final findings on that we're pretty um good about saying if we really think it's a type of bullying it is and I just my question is are these numbers going down do we plot these oh my gosh I I talked to Dr kak earlier this week and I said um so far since September we've only had three cases so that's tremendous to me I don't know I hope it continues so to speak but um I was very impressed

012with that there's only three cases right now at the middle school thank you very much can I ask another question I don't mean to be pessimistic but I find it hard to believe that we've only had five in high school and what are we doing to encourage students who feel they're being bullied to come forward and report it well those programs that I spoke of let me go back to that slide all of those programs are going forward uh oh I'm sorry yeah that is the slide correct uh I keep jumping um all of the everyone is trained which is very very important and we're very specific about that training I meet with the anti-bullying specialist twice a year to go over this information um I have heard it particularly I know you're speaking of

013the high school but at the middle school they're doing a lot a lot a lot of proactive approaches um which is interesting because they're the only ones who have had cases this year but we know middle school students so to speak um are I can't say enough about our anti-bullying Specialists and how proactive they are about trying to address these incidents um and really the other thing we try to look us at as well is really looking at the bystanders to speak up when they see an incident of bullying and we do we have found that sometimes somebody thinks somebody's their best friend and they'll stick up for the other person so that's a good thing kids may not come forward because they feel it might aggravate the situation and make it worse and you

014know that does happen that does happen I think we but if you look back to the law it is our responsibility if even if a kid does not want to come forward if we get any kind of report if we believe it is a type of bullying it is our responsibility to conduct an investigation so regardless even if the student says no no no I don't want to do it I don't want to do it we still have to do it that's part of the law thank you okay yeah um race seems to be one of the higher reported issues how are we handling that within the district I mean I know you said we're going through all these things but is it is it serious is anyone getting hurt or you know the degree

015to which that these things are I can all of last year and I I I I did look at all of these but I can't remember off the top of my head there was only one I think extremely s fairly serious issue last year there's one at the high school there was one that I was pretty disappointed with at um at Woodland School and that was based on disability um and the one at the high school that I'm thinking of um had to do with sexual identity or gender um identification um they're usually not they're just I I hate to say this because I don't ever want to minimize this but a lot of times it's it's kids just being okay obnoxious and rude and you know not thinking before they say or do something

016and that's where the remediation is so important with these kids you know I didn't really mean to say that blah blah blah and I don't mean to because I I really don't like I'm not minimizing it in any way shape or form so I don't want you to think that we take it very very seriously and most of them as I said before are not repeat offenders because they know this is it you're done so programs tend to work they really really do and I think evidence of that is the fact that we've only had three so far this year let's hope it stays like number I know I saying everybody knock on wood thank you for your efforts no problem anyone else let me thank you for the presentation no problem okay well we

017can move on to uh committee reports any committee chair Mr calman so we had a curriculum meeting this evening we had really just three agenda items one was to approve art discussions art applications art applications and that's at the middle school correct yes uh we also um spoke about the new um criteria and new requirements that are going on in the student teacher uh Arena spoke a little bit about some of the new requirements relative to videotaping uh the instruction and I think we're going to go back and keep looking at what we can do to tighten up our requirements around that and also protect the identity of our kids protect the identity of our school and de identify all information that's humanly possible and we also had an an intro to a gentleman who

018is looking to come into the district he's one of our residents uh to provide some business um related type of uh pilot SL Club SLC course um uh we're going to talk this was really just the first intro to that uh and we're going to discuss this at Future curriculum meeting uh at least the next one in December to figure out exactly what the program is going to look like uh very interesting gentleman he has a lot of business background and to spend a lot of his time working with our students to try and bring some business related type of activities directly to our kids so uh I think I don't want to speak for the whole committee but we all felt that the idea was very good I think we just have to kind

019of vet through the logistics and uh and the if you will red tape uh to make sure that we do it the right way so that we can do this more and and make sure that we are doing everything we possibly can to you know protect our programs protect our children and vet everything from Soup To Nuts so uh more at the next board meeting thank you any questions from Mr Cal it it just seems to me that we have a lot of if school activities clubs that are duplicated and we we one of the clubs that we support is DECA Deca has all the business components and we spend thousands of dollars on that a year sending the kids to conferences etc etc don't you think you'd be duplicating that that's a great question

020came up at the meeting and that's going to be part of the second meeting that we're going to have to talk about well how does deca fbl some of the other stuff that we already have what's the net new for this program so more to come good question any other questions any other committee chair Mr nin thank you um the finance committee had a meeting last evening uh first up on the agenda was the budget update uh Mr Gorski and Dr kak informed the committee that we're currently um have started the budget defense rounds and that the um enrollment growth is really starting to finally not finally but it's really starting to impact every single department and discipline demanding more and more resources um additional staffing needs driven by increased class sections is a requirement

021as is additional uh support staff so it's it's it's starting to creep in now and we're starting to really uh be under the gun um second up on the agenda item was a letter of intent discussion and update Dr kak and Mr Gorski informed the committee of recent meeting with mayor tamboro whereas they learned that the proposed letter of intent will not be considered by Town Council um if you recall last uh meeting we actually passed a resolution uh proposing to go ahead with the uh the the site study uh on Church Road but the board felt it prudent at that point in time to suggest that we go with a letter of intent to make sure that we actually were going to get the land now that letter intent will not be provided uh

022by the uh Township the committee agreed although not unanimously to recommend the board uh to amend the resolution made at the last meeting to include uh no letter intent requirement uh requirements many many committee members expressed disappointment in the town council's perceived punitive reaction to comments by Board of Education member um item three was land broker Services uh the we agreed that uh we need to engage in a multi-pronged attack to our problem of uh overbuilding and the administration presented the need uh that we're going to engage a land broker service to facilitate with the option of exploring and procuring land as part of a referendum in the future uh also the uh architecture of record used for student growth consideration um the committee agreed to recommend to the board a resolution which is on

023the agenda tonight expanding the scope of the architect of record services to include exploring existing facilities for expansion and options with the Aged apagar facility stage replacement additionally on item four uh demographer study update the committee agreed with the administration's recommendation for an upgrade to the demographer report for a cost negotiated down from 15,000 to 5,000 that concludes my report Mr thank you any question from Mr nin any other committee chair Mr braveman um we discussed the uh Wetlands that the township almost gave to us uh so I it's a ditto to the finance committee the other things that we discussed was the tennis courts they'll be finished when the weather gets warmer uh there might be uh some addition to our um bleachers as well as a replacement and we are going to have

024a contract with the or an update of the U uh contract for the ground ground Keepers and that's it thank you Mr braveman any question from Mr braveman Miss armeno um in the minutes of the August 31st uh um in the minutes of the August 31st meeting there was mention about the additional uh cost for the tennis courts for about $46,000 and I I am reported as having uh mentioned that we were going to seek reimbursement from the township because that was their original um agreement with with the board that they would uh Supply the the costs up front for the uh for the tennis courts so have we had any additional I know we requested I think it was a verbal did we can we put it in writing and or have we gotten

025an answer I can answer you on that oh okay the request has been denied and as far as a reason I suggest that we ask you ask the town the township because okay because actually the $300,000 that was agreed upon was contingent on um the Board of Education waving the $30,000 of cost from from the municipal budget for a 10-year period so it seems to me that really just getting a loan not a uh an actual payment for it and I you know again anything that we have to take out for uh for the for the School District budget is taking out for educational purposes and instructional purposes and and maybe even a teacher or a parah or something so I'm disappointed that U that agreement didn't go full you know fully um as a

026reimbursement thank you Mr brav I I Michelle I I don't understand what you said about the $330,000 um well it there was part of the reason why we got $300,000 up front was because we waved as a board we wait for the Arts commission I don't think that's what the contract says that we have with them Mr President yes you can correct me Mrs armeno is correct the board reclassified the mighty Oaks and the mayor's Cultural Arts commission to be tier one users exempt from the use of building fees and that was historically about $30,000 a year um that was in exchange for the township providing $300,000 for the tennis court rest restoration however if we want to get out of that contract we have to pay them back to 300,000 not less what we

027anticipate they might have it might have cost us them yes is that correct yes there is language in the exact contract for what would happen if there was a dissolution of the contract so it's not $30,000 against the 300,000 they're not getting a credit each time they use the place that no it's true it's $300,000 we're in we're in the hole for it if we ever want to get control of our facilities again okay okay thank you thank you okay we can move on to the uh public forum now this public forum addresses only items on the agenda um you'll have three minutes to uh make your statement or ask your questions whether you use 3 minutes or less than 3 minutes if necessary that's the time you have I ask that you will if

028you have multiple questions you ask all your questions so you can get it into the time and uh we will if if possible answer your questions now we'll get back to you or'll take your statement under advisement when you come up please state your name and your address and direct your questions to me anyone from the public wishing to uh address the board on the agenda yes sir come on up good evening good evening prakash parab from Monroe Township uh page 16 item number seven uh for the feasibility I see the cost per rate per hour like to know what is the total cost involved in that I see the rate per hour but like to know what is the total cost that resolution on page 16 number seven authorizes the board and its Administration

029to utilize and expand upon the services of the board architect of record to facil facilitate the board with planning for a referendum to handle student enrollment and aging facilities and at this time that scope has not been yet determined what Avenue we're going to go into it could be additions to one or two schools if the 65 acre parcel of land that's being considered to be donated is feasible for one or two uh buildings to be put on there uh it could expand further and it could also include uh a study on a staged replacement of appleguard school so we cannot give you a definitive range on those fees at this time but because we're still too early in the exploratory uh part of this okay but we will have the you will evaluate and

030you will get the cost okay yes yes thank you when the when and if the district engag es the professional uh in these areas of looking at additions to the schools or or the uh the study of appleg school would be presented to building grounds transportation and the bill would be put on the monthly bill list when their uh percentage of completion is finished Anthony foso a a question your way Michael what's the $46,000 for the extra 46,000 U it was my understanding that we had an estimate yes and we had we had it all laid out that we were going to pay a certain amount the 300,000 for the courses and now it's that's correct the history on this is the school district attempted uh over a few years to get the restoration of

031the tennis courts into the school district budget and for multitude of reasons it never stayed and and never made it through the defense rounds cuts and and uh never made it into the budget because of other priorities um former superintendent even applied for a rod Grant to the Department of Education where 40% of the cost could have been reimbursed but it was denied uh we attached that to the curriculum and the gym class which uses the courts but the Department of Education denied it so we we requested from the township at the direction uh directive of the building grounds Transportation committee to seek reimbursement for the costs of the restoration of the tennis courts and at the time the only estimate that we had from the architect was $300,000 for the complete restoration of both

032sets of Courts uh the township agreed as we discussed before when they were uh the cultural arts and the mighty Oaks were reclassified to a tier one exempt fee user and they gave us a check for $300,000 um procurement laws require the school district to go out to bid for the services of the restoration of the courts and the low bid well the first time it was bid the bids came in so high it had to be all rejected we rebid the project a second time and we had a bid of approximately 300,000 40 $346,000 so we were $46,000 short so at the request of the board Administration contacted the township and said it was your intent to pay for the tennis court restoration uh the bid came in a little bit higher would you

033be willing to reimburse us the additional $46,000 that it's going to be required to uh refurbish to courts and as Mr Rybeck said U the request was denied thank youing to the contract though that's iron clar correct I guess our lawyer looked at the contract yes yes thank you Mr President thank you uh good evening Chrissy scurby 21 pness drive I'm just looking at the enrollment numbers um and I just want to point out that we have9 new students District districtwide since the close of the end of the school year uh there are 36 new students to Oak Tree 43 to Applegarth 87 at the high school since June and 18 at the Monroe Township Middle School my question is what are we going to be doing in the inter um to alleviate the massive

034amount of students coming into the district even before the two large condo townhouse developments are up right now as I um so I reported last month uh even with the influx of students we are um trying to keep our class sizes as low as we can so our average class size at Applegarth is a little high is at 26 Barkley Brook is at 22 23 for Brookside 23 for mil Lake 22 for oak tree and 24 for Woodland so as these students come in we're going to continue to evaluate and monitor uh the students coming in if we need to as certain developments Town housee developments open up we may need to look to send the new students to some of the schools where our enrollment has gone down okay uh you didn't mention the

035high school or the Middle School the average class size at the middle school is 34 35 there's a class with 36 I don't know if the average is is quite that high but you're right there are some class sizes that are larger and that's the same at the high school are you aware Dr kak that at the middle school they have rotating schedule for when the tables are called to go and buy their lunch students some students if it's their day to be called last they have 2 minutes to get their lunch sit down and eat and on the majority of those days they have to throw away their food that they haven't even had a chance to eat and go back to class how is that acceptable well first of all uh I am

036aware that they rotate tables to eat lunch and that's a normal procedure in any given middle or high school as far as students only having two minutes I will certainly have to take that up with Miss Chanley I have not heard that students are throwing away their lunches Miss Chanley is however working on a schedule to look at uh ways to um provide more time for students to eat but I have not yet heard of any students that only have two minutes to eat lunch it's all over social media if you check out any of the um Monroe Township Middle School face parent Facebook pages it is that is a constant complaint by parents of that their children are coming home from school they've had 2 minutes to eat because it was their turn to

037go last and it's unacceptable Mrs Chanley is doing an absolutely wonderful job at the middle school trying to handle this she's out of room she's completely out of room and it's not fair will you consider doing something next year to help alleviate the overcrowding yes what you want to send your question to me in an email I can give you a more detailed answer you can tell us today what the plan is if I can I just you know when I started I asked everyone if they would um State all their questions or make their comment in advance and that we will answer if possible and get back to you so I will ask you if you would um are email Dr kosac uh and he'll get back to you with that okay so we

038have no plan thank you all right so on page 15 under board action item the pre-referendum planning I was at the meeting when the board passed this resolution it took uh a very long time to come up with the wording and it was discussed at length why we should have a commitment letter from the township before we start spending money surveying the land now it was said that the Town Council will not give us the the letter of intent I went back and watched the last several Town Council meetings it's never been discussed at any Town council meeting so when you say it's the Town Council has anybody spoken to the president of the Town Council because you keep saying you've spoken to the mayor has anybody spoken to the Town Council well let let

039me answer that um yeah we're getting short of time I'll I'll answer it as briefly as I can and if it's not good enough we could speak later uh later um the mayor was uh telling us he was going to be speaking with the Town Council the Town Council makes decisions like you as a board at open public meetings they've not discussed giving us I know I know they haven't I know they haven't and uh the mayor's uh comment to us was that they were not going to have on the agenda a letter of intent however he guaranteed us orally that he was going to the town was going to give us the 6 uh transfer the title of 65 Acres uh to to the school district so have you spoken to the president of

040the Town Council I have not spoken to the president of Town Council because I was told it was will not be on the agenda so they the council hasn't the council hasn't discussed it at their meetings they won't put it on their agenda but you can say 100% that the mayor the mayor told is agreeing that the council will give the Board of Education the mayor no the mayor had told has told us that the town will be deeding over the 65 acres to US based on what they haven't discussed it B based on his word as the mayor I I see no reason why that's not his decision correct I see I see no rise reason why we shouldn't uh believe what he said well he also said he would be giving us a

041letter of intent my my suggestion is that maybe you want to bring those questions to him uh no I'm bringing it to you because you want you're asking this board to take away a portion of the resolution that you passed contingent that you were going to get this letter before you spent money this uh well now you're asking the board to go back in our discussion I'm sure you've heard it in our discussion we um felt that uh we have to pursue the engineering report not having this letter of intent prevents us from pursuing this engineering report and the mayor of this town insisted that we will be getting the 65 acres so we felt it was without the approval of the Town Council maybe they will but as of now it's not on the

042agenda for that well I urge the board to really consider sticking with the resolution that you took a very very long time crafting and making sure that we have serious uh commitment from the Town Council not just the mayor's word before you start spending any more of our taxpayer money researching land thank you okay thank you anyone else from the town okay Mr Po I'm going to just request again that if you're coming up to speak please have your questions in advance so you can speak to us in advance and then when you are finished we can respond as long as it's within that three minute time period go ahead Mr poori good thank you very much Andy poori 16 St James Steed Monro I think it's pretty clear from the previous uh speaker who

043came up here that there's a sense of frustration in the community in terms of of lack of housing of our students and I hope you guys hear that loud and clear uh yes my daughter does come back at 2:30 and has has a lunch at home uh so that's a normal practice a couple of questions on page number 15 item number five it says that you're engaging Brinkerhoff Environmental Services uh to do wetland delineation and habitat study goes back to the same question Chrissy brought up you don't even have the site why are we keep spending money on a site that we're not even sure if we have it if that's even feasible can we first establish having the site before we spend any more money on doing test tests at this location is that

044are you finished with your questioning okay second question is I think one of my my friends here brought up the question about the hourly rates and I think uh uh Mr groski answered by saying that once the task ORD of the scope is defined then the approvals will go in place so the question is that with the board and the public get a chance to see before you approve uh the specific tasks that come out of this uh agreement with the di group architecture LLC and the third question is uh on page 17 item number D there's a 9.78 million uh that need to be ratified by the board do we know what those costs are associated with and I plead ignorance because I missed the last meeting if there is already discussed I didn't

045mean to waste your time but if not I would like to see what the 9.78 million is attributed to those are my questions okay thank you very much let me address your first one um no matter what land we're looking at we have to do an engineering report before we go ahead and consider purchasing it or putting it into a referendum uh so that's you know so we we need to go ahead with this property to find out if it's viable for us uh before anything whether it be this property or some other property we still have to do an engineer I completely understand being an engineer for 32 years I think I know that's the process but the question really is that you already engage somebody to do I believe Environmental Studies did the

046report come back and is it seem like even a viable thing to invest more into this that's the question really what we what we found out was uh that there is some you know environmental uh concerns more than uh we originally anticipated but we don't know really to what extent uh until that engineering report comes back with more depth so my suggestion is that we wait engaging the Brinkerhoff Environmental until we get the report to see if the site is visible for more money to be invested into this site that's what I'm trying to get at okay second question did you have second thank you evening Mr flori uh the second question as I stated before the administration if this resolution is successful authorizing the expansion of the scope of the architect of record to

047consider additions to existing Monroe school facilities or for renovation and replacement of appleg guard school all of those items would be brought and fully explained and and presented to the building grounds Transportation committee as it will also be presented on an installment basis on the monthly bill list which was your number three question the the item that you referred to was the sum of the monthly bill list for the Board of Education which is required to be approved uh by the Board of Education before these dispersements can be released the checks are prepared in my office and awaiting Board of Education approval these are for budgeted items uh that have been satisfied and that we have uh complete and proper paperwork substantiating them the sum of this month's monthly bill list including all of the

048Appropriations for payroll is 9,782 552 22 C thank you Mr groski thank you Mr board president welcome back thank you good to see your face uh just a couple of quick questions and then if you just kindly answer them uh last month U Mr Gorski was very confident in the passing of the resolution he said it was a done deal uh and that the township uh Council would be approving it eminently uh during that guidance is what passed that resolution there was a very much an adamant tone in the council meeting to pass the resolution on this done deal in the township Council so uh my question to the board is why is there no longer any due diligence in light of now this not being a done deal uh to challenge this resolution or

049uh to challenge the proposed amendment to this resolution that's my first question secondly one of the reasons the impetus for the resolution uh moving forward Ward was that it was deemed from Mr Tag's uh testimony last month uh he was here present Mr Ryback uh he said that there were potentially Woodland Turtles as defined by the NDP and other uh regulatory agencies that look after it and the migratory season for the Woodland Turtles would be ending early fall uh and so it's extremely important to get this uh environmental study in uh to not further delay the potential acquisition of land or the potential build of land uh that migratory season for Woodland Turtles has now closed uh the next migratory season for Woodland Turtles is now uh mid-spring into early summer uh so I'm not

050sure how you can have a full impact study from the funds you're looking to disperse If That season is closed so I'd like to understand if that's been taken into consideration uh thirdly uh what we've come to realize is that uh there's a lot of studying going on on this land and the township has not uh necessarily given you a letter of intent and it's currently owned by a private developer so I'm not quite sure who's giving you as a board the authorization to allow these uh these environmental agents that you're hiring as a an entity onto yourselves as a board of education so I'd like clarification as to who has approved and given the board authorization to hire an environmental company to study land that does not belong to the town but still isn't

051under the aices of a private developer that's a publicly traded company thank you finish um let me SL with the um the third one uh we were told by the mayor that uh this property will be forthcoming to us and that uh we will be able to do these Environmental Studies uh he's obviously in in in um speaking with told brothers who I believe owns that property now that's correct um has no has no problem with us um doing this environmental study uh and and board president just to be clear so have you been in contact with to brothers or are you just going on here say from the mayor let let me ask your time was up so now it's my time okay um we're dealing with the mayor of the town I see

052no reason to disbelieve what the mayor is telling us so you know we in our discussions we're we're going forward with uh with that one let me move to your first question was uh Mr G you have it there I believe the first question referred to the resolution um and the one requesting an amendment of The Brinkerhoff Environmental Services okay uh we you talking about the letter of intent obviously and Mr Rybeck I know you weren't here last month so I'm not sure if you read the minutes but there was a very animated conversation at the board and Mr gorski's comments were very well documented okay uh let's talk about the letter of intent um without that letter of intent we can't we can't begin this uh we can't pursue rather or complete the environmental

053study which we need to do as I just said for no matter what land we're doing uh this land if we could get one or hopefully two schools on it would be financially very advantageous to this District uh it also I think is advantageous for the town the town is going to get this land from Toll Brothers uh as part of a cluster agreement they have to turn it over to them if when they turn it over to the town if the town does nothing with it no taxes are being collected on it if they turn it over to us and we're able to use it then we're saving the taxpayers a few million dollars by not having to go out and purchase land and we could use it to build schools which is uh

054greatly needed and Mr Ryback just let meish yeah please go ahead please I'm finishing you had your time you're done Mr Ryback just for the Mr Mr alberon please yeah but for the public record you've changed the rules tonight just so we're clear It's my prerogative to do that I'm just making a statement okay and that's it you're done making statements um so we found that advantageous uh in our conversations I think if the board decides to go this way tonight to uh resend this letter of intent so that we can complete uh an engineering engineering report and make a educated decision as to where we're going to put building and and what would fit yet next question did you want to uh Woodland Turtles first for a matter of record I I did State

055at the last meeting that the letter of intent was was forthcoming yes and that came on Direct uh advice from the mayor an event occurred um that that led the township to retract that offer and the letter of intent now is off the table so for full disclosure that's what happened with that um there was a few resolutions on are you willing to clarify why there was a what this event was I have the floor sir mron you had your time you had your questions we're responding I really don't want you interacting now that's it I'll defer to the next public open then thank you there's a few resolutions on the business administrator's report uh this evening that all went through the finance committee and were also discussed at last night building grounds Transportation committee

056uh the first one is to re amend the resolution previously passed um prohibiting the engagement of and it the habitat study until we get the letter of intent as we've learned that the letter of intent will not be forthcoming now which we did not have at the last meeting in order for the district to proceed with the exploration of the land in a timely manner it was determined by the committee and and certainly recommended by Administration to amend that resolution of the board with the information now that the letter of intent is not forthcoming so that we can still do our due diligence on the land and that includes a habitat study for the turtles which by the way can still be conducted uh in a timely manner that's why the reso is on tonight

057and number two also to engage in uh with environmental the engineering study um so that we can determine the extent of the wet lens and the feasibility of the land at all because as of right now we have an idea we can at least build one school on that property maybe we can build two or it might be possible if the wetlands are expanded with the turtles that it might not be feasible at all or the remediation cost might be prohibitive so you know as we discussed at the committee level knowledge is power that's why we're proceeding with all of these in addition to that there's a resolution to do an updated demographic study and also to engage in a land search because if the exploration of the 65 acres proves that it's not suitable

058for school building purposes we will need another immediate Avenue to turn to so that's why all of these are co-joined and and um uh priority tonight and uh they are administration's recommendation thank you thank you Doug Doug PO for tamarak Road um it seems to me that the uh whole issue of the land on Old Church Road uh is holding up progress in terms of dealing with our building needs uh I was on the student growth advisory committee I know the committee as well as the administration uh has recommended that we have one big referendum but I think in that quest to have one big referendum uh we're getting caught up and uh we're back in the summer we talked about we needed to move ahead and I really don't think we're any farther ahead

059than we were back in July uh I would urge the board to reconsider how you may want to approach this referendum I think you may need to go for smaller referendums you already have the land for the high school the high school needs to be expanded so why not move forward on that I believe but I could be mistaken I believe that there is sufficient land over between the where the playing fields are and the Middle School by relocating a couple of the playing fields particularly the varsity baseball field if you relocate that field which would be relatively inexpensive compared to going out and buying new land somewhere else you could build a multi-story 56 gr 56 building on that land that building would serve the entire Township's needs not simply one section of the

060township it's clear that the middle school is really Under Pressure if you build a 56 building simultaneously with the addition to the high school you would then be able to lower the present population in the middle school and lower the population in all the elementary schools by taking grade five out of those schools you might then find that you don't need two new Elementary schools you might even find that you don't need another elementary school but if you did need another Elementary School I would propose that there is either sufficient land on the Applegarth property or even sufficient land at the Oak Tree property to build another Elementary School there is a baseball field at the uh oak tree school which is rarely used that belongs to the district so why not build a multi-story

061elementary school behind the oak tree school and it doesn't take up as much land and you could have whatever you need without I know you had a concern about having an overly large Elementary School we'll have two elementary schools on that property if you needed to but I think you need to move ahead with resolving the issue of what's going on in the high school and what's going on in the middle school you're getting held up with this whole question of do we have the land do we not have the land and are we going to have to go out and find land somewhere else you need to move forward in my opinion and I think you need to consider a different referendum and a different approach to the problem thank you thank you Mr

062Po anyone else from the public hi good evening good evening board president welcome back I'd like to wish a Happy Thanksgiving early Thanksgiving to the board and to you as well Stephen manfrey uh 12 Belmont Court uh two questions and a statement uh first is there any precedent for us to be studying land uh or having feasibility studies that we don't own why don't you ask all your questions that's the first question uh second question are we doing similar studies with any land that we do own and the last uh statement you uh board president had referred to the land the 65 acres as economically advantageous I think I have a different opinion I think it's environmentally Reckless and it ignores what is the pressing problem right now as our enrollment balloons and there is

063just a perception amongst the public uh real or perceived that this board doesn't have a plan to address it and I think at some point in the very near term the public whether it's at this form or some someplace else is going to have to hear some detailed plan on what this board intends to do to address the problem thank you very much thank you I can address uh certainly answer some of your questions if you'd like to hear them now um the first one pertaining to the uh the land and and and the engineering and the Environmental Studies we need to know what we're dealing with we don't know uh if that land is buildable because of whatever how many Wetlands how big the wetlands we have Turtles uh we need to know that

064uh as far as it being economically advantageous if we could build a school on that land and not have to purchase the land that's what I'm talking about we but but still we need to look what we're doing tonight is opening up Avenues so that we could still do land searches because we could find land someplace else that after all is said and done is uh buildable and more economically advantageous than the 65 but we won't know that unless we were able to do all these studies so that's why uh that's what we're talking about tonight yeah the first question though was is there precedent for us doing this sort of land study with land that we don't own need we need to have this all information uh to submit to the state if we're

065going to be doing a bond referendum we we have to have all this done I Mr Rybeck I appreciate you uh educating me on the process but again the question is what is the precedent for this board to conduct a feasibility study on land that we don't own have we ever done it before yes or no the answer to that is yes the board has done it before uh when we built this high school there was a great exploration of this piece of land um as well as another piece of land where it was originally proposed before the district owned it the Department of Education requires that when you submit a project for referendum that it has uh you know a detailed plan for acquiring Land by the time you have the referendum so you

066don't have to own the land first and it is incumbent upon the board to to study the land of course which was a requirement of the Department of Education before uh you can proceed with it and um so so happen before there was there was a precedent a very similar circumstance and our are we studying uh land that the district owns in a similar capacity and the answer to that is yes the district does own some other land some of it was mentioned previously it's in back of the Middle School the majority of that is wet it was previously studied and determined to have been wet uh but all of the land that the district owns our whole inventory will be studied uh partially with the resolution that we have on tonight with the with

067the architect okay all right so that that that's help thank you thank you very much anyone else in the public M Cur before you come up I just want to make sure anyone else who didn't speak who did not speak before okay JP Evan Joey 49 jelski Road um I just have a general question on uh how estimates are taken because you guys mentioned that it would be an estimate of $300,000 to uh fix the tennis courts and then now you guys are going for $346,000 that you guys would need based on the bid you guys received and then I guess another question would be is how is the brid process done do do the companies come to you do you like put a general like ad out and companies come to you or do

068you go to individual companies that specialize in doing construction type of work and do you get estimates from them G answer excellent questions um in the first instance the board had asked asked um the architect architect of record who was approved by the board with that varying fee structure that you have in the agenda tonight to put together um an estimate of what it would cost to renovate both sets of tennis courts on Schoolhouse Road at that time the cost for renovation was $300,000 we paid the architect for his Services put it in the budget it got cut from the budget we tried a couple subsequent years again put it in the budget it got cut for other priorities because we didn't have the cap room and then uh the state denied our application for

069Rod grant to get reimbursement from the state so we just could not get it accomplished through the budgetary means with the other priorities in the budget so then the township offered to pay it based upon that previous architect estimate of 300,000 but we're required to go out to public bid and any expense uh that's over uh $40,000 so this project obviously is estimated to be more than that so we put together bid specifications on what the project entails they were advertised uh for a period required by law we also solicited bids from companies that were uh reputable in tennis court restoration and that type of construction to track them to bid through this fair and open process the first time we did it the bids came in very high be as Mr T said it

070because it was perhaps a bad time of year when there was a lot of other construction work so this was uh not attractive for the biders so they came in high the second time we bid it the low bid was 347,000 approximately difference is the time and the increase in construction cost from the first time the architect gave us an appraisal to what the actual cost came in at so we we we were found short okay if I'm allow one more followup question when was the estimation done actually you know what I I I really asked everyone to get their questions in okay so if there's any further question would you please email it to uh the district you don't know what what year they did the estimation it's it's just a matter of the

071process today ah you guys said something I got to know now that you brought it up we'll tell you when you contact us you can email us I just want to keep it consistent I don't know if I have I'm sorry well I'm sorry we see him after after the meeting all right thank you this is the first time I'm coming to the meeting I'm bit confused just state your name prash you should ask name for others also are coming I have not heard that okay be consistent um the land 65 acres I'm just confused is belongs to the town and it belongs to the to Brothers what mayor is talking to whom we in public want to know which land you are looking at 65 acres and before you spend any money on visibility

072we want to be understand it in the next meeting thank you thank you Mrs scurby Christy scurby 21 pness Drive um on page 16 number eight uh it talks about the Ross habber updated demographic study um when we met with you Dr kak the um uh the dec group um the presidents of the PTO and ptas uh in October you said you had recently gotten an updated study is this another study or is this to pay for that study Mr President yes okay we received a study from Ross saber oh probably um 6 months or more ago and uh that would be the only study I would be referring to this is to get an update that with buildings that have occurred or that have started oh okay because you told us you had just

073recently gotten an update okay um and I I would just like to say to the board to um really look at all the money that's being asked of you um to give control over to Dr kak um I did attend the buildings in grounds and transportation committee meeting last night and I was very very upset as a taxpayer and a parent to hear Dr kak ask for quote the shackles to be removed from his arms um and asked for unlimited spending and for trust in the board to do uh what he thinks is responsible um I'm glad Mr Braverman address that um and I really hope this board will make a sound decision tonight with all this money that being asked of you to be given thank you Dr kak I think you want to

074respond sure I just like a quick response no one is giving me money so clarifying you had your question um the money is being offered not money but the ability to acquire the services on behalf of the administration to look at other land to look at have an architect uh look at possible additions to the building so it's not me personally let's just get that clear and um we did discuss that with the uh committee and all cost any money that is spent is accounted for to the board on a monthly basis as Mr Gorski talked about earlier through our bill statement or through any other processes but the board is well aware of any money that is spent and myself Mr Gorski Dr Al we all stay in close communication with the board on

075any anything that is appropriated thank you exactly but that was a terrible comment to say take the shackles off and let me do what I need to Doby thank you anyone else who hasn't anyone else who hasn't gone yeah um my name is R Chan five bman Court um just hearing the discussion for the schooland um gentleman mentioned that the high school you know uh the Middle School the the Apple guards the oak tree School the district already own and they uh however we are talking basically the discussion spending money for the land the township doesn't own yet uh let along the uh School District my puzzle is that why what's the reason we spend money on studying the land the township doesn't even own later on the district other than the school the uh

076the school in the back of the Middle School the elementary school the district already own what's the thought process what's the decision you know is made based on what kind of uh consideration well we we we addressed already the the uh reasons for us going forward with the environmental study on that land um it's based on what the mayor has told us emphatically that it will be transferred to us um it's as far as what we're doing one of the things that we're doing today is um if it passes is giving us the authority to go out and and do studies with uh Architects to find out and Engineers to find out what uh we can do with the current buildings uh so that and if we are able to look at other lands as

077well so that we can make decisions we need this information to drive our to inform our decisions we just can't make decisions sitting around a table if we don't know uh whether the land is buildable uh whether a building can be expanded what might be on covered if an old building was that was built in the 1930s is expanded will it impact uh with the fields behind the building are they buildable or are there environmental problems there so we need to have this all all all down so we can make an informed decision I understand that but um the what what still aples is that because uh um it sounds like you prefer using this uh um piece of land 65 acre well let let me I think I know where you're going with this

078and and right now uh it's a very viable uh option for us because there's no cost however if our resolutions pass tonight we will be looking at other lands because as I said a few minutes ago it may be more advantageous for us to purchase land elsewhere than than accept this land uh from the town but we won't know that unless we're able to do land search we're able to do engineering uh reports on the land we still need to do land uh research or land search not land research for the property in the back of the schools existing schools that the dist already own we we need to do uh any kind of engine engineering and vial studies before we can go further uh with any kind of decision on expanding a school or

079or building something we still have to do those studies yeah the other thing I I just want to ask I had asked everyone to please ask their questions you know we can't keep going back and forth like this right but this is related question and um cuz you know it's it seems like a you know we we hear from the uh mayor that you know the district will get the the land right it's like almost sure thing 100% 99% but you know this is something that on the promise verbally you know if we hear from an investment adviser okay your $1,000 will become $20,000 in you know five years you know we base on our decision on some perspective you know a future but not really concrete you know it's all based on the market

080or anything you know like a lot of factors that may change the whole picture I I don't think it would be a prudent decision um politically or economically for the town to um not give us this property but just sit with it it's got to be going to them because of a cluster of agreement so toll has to give it to them uh if they don't give it to us when we have to go out and buy other property that money's got to come from tax money from the residents so it it's not a really prudent decision not to offer this that land I think it's uh advantageous for them to do that okay so if I Mis if I understand correctly there are two Choice 65 or purchase new land the existing School the

081back of the school we still no we're still looking we're going to be working with Architects if if the resolutions pass to find out about uh other options using our current buildings okay right thank you thank you Mr Al before you come on I just want to make sure if anybody else yes sir hello Ram rat 6en strive um again congratulations to all the new members uh who are here hope that uh this will uh really make the conversations and decisions much more uh fluid um I I guess I missed the last meeting I've been here for the last few meetings and uh really I'm surprised now hearing the town um you know does not really have the land I thought was just of it being deeded to the Board of Education you know and

082so I'm very surprised I just feel that seems like as a risk manager a very slippery slope of and probability seems dimmer and dimmer to me uh and as many of the people have asked and I hope your resolution gets passed I think I think what you're hearing loud and clear from people is that let's be very careful and time wasting more time searching for other land we know there is land next to Apple guard land next to Oak Tree I think the high school obviously uh you know can we aggressively pursue those and then second I think as some members suggested can we split up instead of going for this Holy Grail referendum uh go with smaller chunks uh because we are all getting concerned that time is passing by and and I guess

083we are encouraging can we take that kind of aggressive parallel look and move that forward everything you said will be taken under advisement and thank you thank you good points I think that's it for anyone who hasn't spoken Mr alberon thank you John elbasan Belmont Court thank you for your time uh so a couple things uh from our last conversation that came up you know we're a Township of Common Sense and we're uh many of us are working parents uh to family working parents and and we're trying to get these kids into our uh school districts in a safe and sound manner with good uh classroom ratios so the question make sure are you speaking to the agenda I am okay so so the question I have is as follows because a couple things you

084brought up about the cost of the land uh relative to acquiring new land um so what I'd like to bring up Mr board president is uh one should ask themselves if there's 65 acres of land that supposedly is pristine to be used for building premises uh how did the build uh developer not build on that land to begin with how did they build on two other major lots of land for a major development back your point about cluster zoning and not build on this supposedly pristine 65 acres of land and the fact is that it's a non-contiguous zoning variance that they received from this Township why did they receive that non-contiguous zoning benefit they received it because the lots that the homes were built on are much smaller than they were supposed to be by

085our own municipal so New Jersey has a law for that and it says that if you have non-contiguous land and a zonian planning board approves this cluster variants three separate part cells of land well one land can compensate for the other two pieces of land and so what that triggers believe it or not in New Jersey statute law is that the land is deemed open space because you've lost the space elsewhere that you were supposed to preserve and you've put it now into the trust of this piece of land and you know what really frustrates me as a common resident here is I pay quite a bit of money into my property taxes to protect open space one of the reasons I live in Monroe is our Charter says that 50% or more of our

086land is open space so it is a bit disingenuine to say that there is some economic benefit to the Board of Education where there's an economic deficit on the other side of the equation that's one two the other issue that we have is that when you build on compromised land FEMA and other state agencies require a higher rigor of Building Construction so your estimates for building need to be adjusted if you're allowed to build on this land to begin with because now you have to compensate for that soil composition you have to compensate for the wetlands near my you have to compensate for femous flood planes that exist on this property that's two three you mentioned studies we live in a very information driven age I could now go on and everyone in this Township

087can go on GIS it's a state sponsored website that overlays all the flood planes all the soil compositions and I got to tell you the land that the building of appart school sits on is pristine there is no incumbrances the footings that sit behind this High School are pristine they should be built and waiting for some perfect elaborate concocted referendum to build is inexcusable and it will not be tolerated in this Township any nor I can assure you that there is an activist movement in this Township and this board should take advantage of that movement thank you m alberon anyone else from the public to address the agenda okay not seeing Mr poor change your mind no I haven't changed my mind uh I just want to make one point actually not a question it'll

088be easy this is not us zig versus them or anything like this is a problem CommunityWide I just fail to understand why we cannot discuss with the Council on what we're talking about and make a a reasonable investment and also there's tremendous resources in the township that you should be tapping into this is my town this is our town we're all here to help so how can we bring the community together to solve the problem the problem is real we got kids coming in with no classrooms and the student teacher teacher ratio is going tremendously High we got to change that so tell us how we can help you let's try to find a solution together rather than going back and forth so is there a liaison from the Board of Education I know the

089answer to the council where there's a constant conversation that takes place back and forth so that everybody's on the same page rather than hearing somebody saying yes on some instances and then going back and saying no and we keep spending money on doing uh you know studies Mr B I just want to say I appreciate what you said but I'm asking this these comments questions are supposed to be pertained to to the agenda that would have been more suitable for the second public sector all right all right I'm a rookie at this anyone else from the public seeing no one from the public we can move on to the superintendent's report thank you Mr President just wanted to make mention um that our high school once again another report came out uh but it placed

090us as 100 out of 371 high schools in New Jersey for the best elll t uh Park scores from 2016 from last year uh that we placed higher than Princeton High School West Windsor High School North and South Livingston high school and North Brunswick High School so just a congratulations to the students uh teachers parents yes leadership team and the board of education for supporting our schools thank you the um I attended the one of the many presentations on the presidential election at the middle school and I think the students did an outstanding job on researching along with the help of their teachers of course in the administration researching the four different presidential candidates the vice presidents uh they even had kids portraying the Secret Service uh they did a very very nice job explaining

091the Electoral College and um I just want to commend again all the students and the teachers for that uh it's good to to see our students gain that kind of educ education and knowledge of the uh whole election process there was also a concern um from a number of people that you know post election would we see any problems would we uh you know hear of anything some of the protests some of the things that we have heard uh that have occurred on some University campuses and in other places and we'll all always be vigilant and and monitoring the situation but I I did meet with a group of middle school and high school students today who are part of the student liaison committee and they reported according to them that really other than some

092social media between the kids of you know oh my party won or your party you know your party lost that there hasn't been any uh mean or vicious comments toward one another and and I you know hopefully we won't see any of that um certainly want to commend our students you know yes sometimes students just as adults make some poor decisions but I would say that the high percentage High majority of students that I come in contact with are manly they're they're they're nice to one another even the student Le aison group today when they came in they're helping one another they this is routine for them um it's really nice to see the behavior the overall behavior of our students and how they treat one another and how they interact and treat the adults

093with the um agenda I just wanted to make note to the board that item j under uh Mr gorsy SE section actually is the approval of the online board agenda software uh that is something that the board had made a goal of um the uh people that input the data the secretaries and others preview we previewed several companies and we found this company to be um something that we feel would be very user friendly for the board and also be very organized and would be uh user friendly for the people who have to import the data so if the board should desire to move ahead with that uh we would set up the training in January at the first um January board meeting the full meeting not the reorganization meeting the full meeting and normally

094the curriculum committee um meets before the board but the January meeting the curriculum committee routinely does not meet at that time so that could be a good time for training maybe from 6: to 7 if the board uh would so desire so I just wanted to bring that to your attention with that Mr President I would like to recommend the Personnel items a through V second have a second any discussion did I hear a question over there I just want to make sure I'm on the right okay take a moment a through uh V I believe V is in Victor um not we're not stopping at 14 or are we going to the board not board action right no not board action that's the next yes okay second then no discussion okay no discussion Mr

095G if we can vote Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs kapano Mr noin yes Mrs Corino yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo yes and Mr rodsky yes boort president motion passes thank you okay under board action I would like to recommend the board approval for items a through J moved second second any discussion Mrs K ponit yes I have um a question about e on page 13 the bylaw on nepotism uh you weren't here at the last meeting but we it was on the agenda for the last meeting for first reading and there was some comments and suggestions by board members that we return this to the policy committee for a second review and um I don't believe there's been a policy meeting since we had no the last

096committee meeting the last Board of Education meeting so many you uh you want to answer that is there a question that's the question the question there hasn't been so it it it is the uh the the requests of change have not been reviewed so it hasn't been so it this this policy stands as it was presented for the first reading um again Poli policies are fluid we that there was a time frame we just couldn't get the meeting together so let me just be clear so um are we going to put this back into the policy no it it it was not it was not reviewed again it can be in the future but way this this is the second reading second reading right but there was a directive by the Board of Education to

097revisit this bylaw before we put it on the agenda again and therefore I'm going to be not supporting this because I feel that if there's a director from the board it this looks like we're being not very transparent where we're just putting it on the board you like to table it we could table it for next next all right why don't we do that make a motion to table a motion to table it Mr then I make a motion that we table um bylaw 01421 nepotism until after it has been reviewed by the policy committee have a second roll motion is to table letter e on page 13 Mrs armeno yes Mr Braverman Mrs Deo yes Mr calman re cues so noted Mrs K Pano yes Mr noin no Mrs Kino no Mr Rybeck yes

098Mr Russo yes and Mr rutsky yes Bo president motion to table e has passed thank you Miss K thank you M alino for clarifying that for us appreciate that and we can go ahead now the rest of it the board action uh we have to take a vote on it yeah we have think we have to think okay the the the motion on the floor is board action items a through J with the except ception of e which has been taed Mrs [Music] armeno yes Mr Braverman Mrs Deo yes Mr calman yes Mrs K Pano yes Mr nostin yes Mrs kreno yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo and Mr rutsky so Iain on everything up two but then I vote Yes for I and J so noted thank you Mr word president board action items

099a through J with the exception of e has passed thank you okay I think we're up to the business administrator's report yes sir get I might as well leave it there thank you board pre excuse me board president and members of the mon Township Board of Education it is recommended that board action items a through K be approved by consent roll call second any discussion prior to hearing about the 65 acres I suggested we build behind Apple goth put an addition on Oak Tree and get it get going with the high school I was very uncomfortable at last night's meeting I do think we're shoveling money against the tide I always feel like I'm blowing in the wind with this board I don't understand what's so important about that 65 acres we should be spending

100the same money for the Architects to do the work that we have to do the properties have already already been approved they're ours I I just don't understand what's going on I mean we were pushed to do this high school here I voted against it at that time the the property that we originally wanted they put a senior center on which would have been much nicer for this school and would have been twice the size for half the price so so I just don't understand why you keep pushing for the 65 acres so I'll probably be voting against it it's just you know you're I'm blowing in the wind and and give it some thought you thank you I ask the audience to please not shout out okay uh they didn't even do it during

101the presidential debate so we can't do it here either maybe we should have a presidential debate on this level yeah yes Mr Cal so a couple things I know we've done it in the past we we've done a lot of this work when we don't own the own the land we've been successful at doing some very Innovative things and this building is absolutely living proof of it what's setting this process a little different than the other one is the fact that it from my perspective and this is just me speaking this Board of Ed is assuming the entire risk because it was brought up earlier about risk right and we try and do your due diligence you try and do as best you possibly can but it seems to me as the board here us

102we're assuming the entire risk here and the reason why I'm bringing that up is because we went along with good faith that that letter of intent just like the land was a done deal right and then you start thinking about you follow the money you think about well why wouldn't they give us the letter intent when they're so adamant or at least the mayor is so adamant just the mayor and this problem is these are conversations that are being had between the administration yet our forum is out here in the public on TV right we're all out here talking about it right but when you're talking with the administration you know they they can deny everything that these conversations were had right cuz we are assuming the entire risk here we're laying out the money

103to look at the land we're doing all this stuff up front and if it turns out that it's really not suitable or billable well they're not giving you they're not giving you the letter of intent because they can't they don't own the land so they can't tell you that they're giving it to you because they don't own it so in effect Toll Brothers in theory could walk away from this whole thing and only the Board of Ed is left holding the bag just something to think about as you move forward because whatever happens with this land you're is going to happen with this land whether it's good or it's bad all I'm saying is we have to be very cognizant about when we think about looking at different properties and truly weigh the ultimate cost

104because it's not just you know laying out money for land because you get what you pay for this land was different this was publicly owned land it was a park it was owned for by the park for eons it wasn't private land that was owned by somebody who as when mentioned earlier because of trade swaps trade swaps sorry because of land swaps or what have you it came up to be available for us right so just think smartly as you move forward in time that's all well taken Mr nonin yeah just a a couple things um a couple people were up tonight that they're kind of under the impression that we're not really doing anything else um will someone from the administration please um help me to understand what I heard last night at the

105committee meetings that basically said we are doing something else we are moving in a multifaceted approach um I know Mr Tay gave a a very detailed synopsis of what's going on with the high school I think Mr Po said that uh we should be looking at that it's and it is my understanding of the board member that we are could someone from the administration please help the public to understand that uh we're not just focusing on 65 acres we are doing a multi-pronged attack on this uh huge issue sure we can both actually you want to talk you want to talk uh okay so Mr nin a good question and Mr T uh did present that last night that uh he has been working with the architect for the high school in particular looking at

106that they had the architect at the high school I believe it was yesterday uh we've already gone to South South Brunswick because their layout of the high school is very similar to ours we did that last summer to look at what the addition would look like behind the high school to look at the hallways we we found out what worked what didn't work uh in South Brunswick we wanted to make sure that we didn't repeat the same mistakes so that has been moving forward looking at this building here we were going on the recommendations of the student growth advisory committee to go after one referendum but having said that nothing is written in stone so we have to be flexible we've listened to people that has been recommended more than once that maybe we should

107go out for multiple referendums part of it is what will the taxpayers be willing to Bear they are they willing to Bear a referendum now another one in five years um so that's something that certainly has to be considered because this Township uh I know I've only been here a little over a year but I know the history there's there's been a number of refer ROM since I believe 1990 and um there's been an incredible growth in this town and the township has supported that through uh a number of years uh but that is a consideration for that regarding all the other schools again with between the demographer and the architect looking at what we have at each school where is the location how long would the bus ride be for students is it centrally

108located so the 65 acres the reason why we are asking for to us for us to finish the process is it's a due diligence question in my mind the board approved us looking at that 65 acres because we didn't know we would have to do this with any plot of land to see whether it's of you know if it's wet lands or not wet lands um the mayor has assured us that it's just a matter of of time that the that they would send give the land to us but if we do the study and it's not really worth our effort or the cost would outweigh the the uh us having the land then it's not worth us to take the land either uh and that has been discussed um you know I I can't

109speak for the communication between the mayor and the Town Council but you know my contact has been uh or I should say our contact has been with the mayor as the mayor of of a Municipality of a Township um the land behind the middle school we looked at that we drove around we looked at that area we we consulted with uh Mr T from previous studies and as Mr Gorski has already alluded a lot of that land is wet and it might not be might not really suit our purposes we've also discussed the idea of building a 56 behind the middle school and again while everything is on the table because we want to explore all options that puts a large number of students in that area uh which is already between the high school

110and the middle school um you know it's is it a possibility sure sure it could be but we'd have to study and see how much of that land is usable what would be the cost of taking that field leveling it how much room behind it so as with any project the it's a process building onto the other schools Applegarth has always been on the table to either build behind it or to raise Applegarth it was decided way back with the student growth advisory committee to put Applegarth off for right now because we thought this 65 acres was usable and it seemed to fit the purpose of an elementary and middle and the high school that's what what we presented to the community that's what we send out information for between the Falcon flyer between board

111meetings we've been totally transparent with that uh at the same time you know it's it's a process you have to see it through at the same time we've been working to to explore what our other options are but we also feel responsible to not ask the board to continually approve well let's let's pay for this let's pay for that let's see what this one's worth first it's very frustrating for us as well I wish this could be done could have been done 6 months ago or even longer but we have to get through the process we know we start the environmental study they come back to us well you know EPA says there could be turtles in that area you have to study that okay so then we have to come back to the board

112and we you know we seek and move in that direction but uh we certainly have been looking at all the options where even you know the land search 56 building if we can find a five area for a suitable for a 56 building that would be uh centrally locate so that students won't be on the bus that long and it would address the needs that certainly could solve our problem keeping the sixth grade in our elementary schools that is also a possibility we we looked at that we discussed that part of what we look at is some of our buildings are more suitable and there's some land around some buildings but not all there is also the chance of as you start uh working on some of our older buildings that there could be other

113issues bringing them up to code there's a lot of things to consider we've had these conversations I certainly appreciate the the feedback that I've heard from the community tonight uh and I'm Mr no I can't thank you enough for bringing up that question because it seems to be be the perception that we are sitting here not doing anything when the reality is that this is a daily a daily concern of ours I drive by the building at 33 in opor every day just to see where they are where are they at now we're looking at a demographer to go back because no one legally has to come no developer has to come and say we're starting a building now or we're putting this in here or we're going to change us from this bedroom to

114that bedroom so we have to constantly explore all those things um I can empathize with the community on how frustrated you must be and I respectfully ask that you understand that we hear you and we understand that frustration and I feel we are doing everything possible to try to come up with Solutions and try to come up with answers um you know we're we're relying on and we have to rely on Experts you know I consider Mr T an expert he he has been here for all the different building projects in the referendums some of our board members have been here and certainly offer us valuable advice uh we rely on Experts such as environmental Engineers or whatever the title is I maybe I'm I'm not calling them the correct name we rely on Architects

115we rely on our demographers you know that's why we're going back and getting a revised demographic study I can only ask to respectfully ask that you understand how much this weighs on our on our mind uh and we want the people in the community to be happy we want people to understand when we heard about 65 acres and I talked did the superintendent North Brunswick and he told me the millions that they're spending to buy land I thought the community is going to be thrilled what a great partnership between the mayor the township Town Council and and the school district because there's a lot of Partnerships a lot of things that occur between the town and and the school district that maybe aren't mentioned uh it seems to be the negatives a lot of times

116that we focus on but there's a lot of things including how they recognize our students sometimes at Council meetings uh how they they they call us up and say hey can we do this for you oh you need more land for transportation for your bus garage you know what we have some land over here that maybe you guys can use for a bus garage that stuff's not brought up but there is a cooperation there is a Cooperative attitude at least from my point of view and I understand that I haven't been here for years and years and years I understand that but I can only tell you what I see so that's what we're doing we're continuing to do that uh we appreciate the board's support in that in allowing us to uh move in

117other directions to explore all the options there's been some great ideas mentioned tonight a lot of the ideas have been discussed in the student growth advisory committee and that's okay we'll continue to look at them if somebody can come forth if we thought it would make sense to get another committee together to say let's explore this again I'd be willing to do it I certainly put out time as all did to to to meet at night and to Justice and and to bring the community into the process so we certainly want that um it's it's just it's a process it's not easy it's long it's frustrating um but we we are aware of that uh Mr Mr gski Please add to that if if you could Mr President thank you thank you thank you uh

118with respect to that because the letter of intent now is not forthcoming according to the mayor it will not be considered considered by Council respectfully to the Board of Education members without numbers 5 6 7 and 8 which are on my report being approved by tonight Administration will not have the authority to conduct the habitat study with with that has a very short window of opportunity left will not be able to engage in a completed Wetland study with the engineer because that's partially dependent upon the habitat study we will not be able to use the architect for referendum planning because the architect of record fee structure is not inclusive of referendum costs which are much more material and we would not be able to update the demographic study to determine not only the new number

119of students as of October 15th to coincide with the Assa fall report but also to determine uh where they are located throughout the town so that when we're making important considerations for adding on to buildings if that should be part of our plan we will how many students are being affected in those various uh attendance zones so without 5 six seven and eight we're going to have a a very ill afforded pause in this referendum process because again we do not have the authority to continue to explore those uh important options at this time thank thank you both for your very concise answers um I have some other questions Mr board president I never really I don't want to give up my time yet um with regards to item five um the letter of intent

120um I I was very concerned when we initially did this uh I I think we did it at finance and I really was kind of insistent upon this letter of intent at the finance committee and I believe that's uh why it made it into the resolution and that's why this board approved that resolution uh last meeting my question I guess to the uh Administration that's met with the mayor um did he give any reason why that he is not giving up giving us this letter of intent I can answer that and and and uh the answer is uh no we'd have to I think present that question to the town all we were told is that it is not on the agenda for the Town Council and will not be we gave no indication of

121of the reasoning no that's a question for them for the town um okay I also have a question regarding um my colleague Mr ruty's um asteris I I if Mr Gorski could just uh walk me through this on uh items 2 three5 six s and six and seven if you could tell me how that cor correlates to page 20 items 1 through 4 prior to each meeting the agenda and all of its consent items are thoroughly reviewed by uh by Dr alvic by our board attorney and me and our board attorney feels specifically with the aster items on page 15 and 16 that the Jamesburg representative would be able to vote on those um if you would like we could certainly follow up with her tomorrow um and engage a conversation of what her rationale

122was for approving those but they were specifically approved for the Jamesburg vote okay well I I I take that under protest because I I can't see how any of these I actually thought that the um asteris were misplaced um why would he be voting on Tiny Tots therapy um I'm a little confused about that in particular and uh also about the uh the the uh pre-referendum planning since this has absolutely nothing to do with the high school but that's just me thank you very much I'm I'm done anyone else no I just wanted to say as you know I I wasn't here for the uh tennis court deal and that that didn't seem to work out too well and now we have this land deal 65 acres and basically as L said we have all

123the risk on us and we're being asked to trust um what I wanted to ask is let's say this deal doesn't go through we can't get to 65 acres um let's say we we can't get any land what what do we do then yeah thank you Mr President um if the land the 65 acres is not available and If there is no other land in the township that is available we certainly have what we have discussed is building higher which we would rather not do but I mean behind Applegarth you know we were looking at around 900 to a th000 elementary school students coming in so behind Applegarth you know the you talk about what's the optimal number for an elementary school you know there's no hard and fast figure but we would think somewhere

124in that 6 to 700 range and then and again where is it located in relation to where all the homes are being built or the new homes are being built so uh we were looking at on that 65 acres building an elementary school to possibly up to hold up to 900 students Elementary if we build behind Applegarth uh I don't know if we have the the amount of land to do that that could be a possibility the other possibility that we could look at would be let's keep the sixth grade in the three uh possibly the three out of the six elementary schools that currently have fifth grade and possibly do additions on to uh those schools to accommodate that possibly move around it would it would affect impact all of our schools and how

125we would have to reconfigure uh especially when you get to the younger grades with kindergarten which schools have bathrooms for you know there there's uh regulations with that with having bathrooms in the classrooms but it's certainly something we would have to look at um it's didn't it never seemed to be our best option to just build onto our school it certainly was an option but it didn't seem to be the best option the demographic studies that we have go out further than 10 years we're restricted by the state and we also thought Common Sense would would lead us to you don't want to predict too far out because the economy could impact housing um there's so many different factors that could impact housing so you know we have to be cons considered of that but

126if we just build on to our schools that we have the the predictions from the original demographic report indicate that the building's going to continue for 15 to 20 years so we thought if we had again that that land that that would offer more flexibility in the future 5 10 years down the line I certainly wouldn't want I don't think any of the board members would want somebody coming back and say why did the board the superintendent the business you know everybody why didn't they think why didn't they look at they had the demographic traffic report so we we try to take all those things into consideration but certainly what we're going to do what we need to do um to try to rectify this this situation we're in we're looking at we think we

127can get through another year without adding any trailers without doing anything like that uh we can't predict too much further ahead than that um but certainly we're trying to move this process along as quickly as we can so let let's say for example we we don't get the 65 acres and we can't find any land on the market yes can we can we tap into the inventory of the open space land which is already paid for by the taxpayers is that possible to look at that inventory I I don't believe legally that we're allowed to use open space for uh putting any kind of uh facility on like you know school any kind of a building on I'm pretty sure yeah M yeah me ning and Mr bra were nding I'm pretty sure that's legally

128we can't do that it seems to me then the best thing to do is um maybe start looking at building on existing properties well yeah absolutely but also if there were land available that we could do that in addition to building onto existing properties that's also another solution which is why we want to do the land search at the same time that we're looking at building onto our our current buildings and doing a land surge means hiring a company my understanding is that it's done on on a contingency basis meaning that we don't pay for it until land is acquired and we can also put out a public notice I don't know um public notice for land rised against that yeah I yeah I mean I think if we get somebody that does a land

129search they're they're well that's their expertise they know where to look and which land might be available for uh for purchase that might not be um I think it would be in our best interest to use an expert in that area because I mean looking at what we have to vote on based on the history of dealing with you know the same entities that are making this offer it's it is very risky one it is but if if I can answer uh the risk that we've already invested money to look at this this land so our risk is to finish the process to see if the land is usable that's all we're asking is to finish it and then then we'll know for sure whether there's land available or not available if it's determined even

130if the land is available let's say that we get the report back and they say you have room there to build a school and we look at all the other factors and it seems that the the space that's available for that school or maybe other costs that could be associated with that might not be worth it for the school district to and the Board of Education to pursue it doesn't cost us anything to walk away from it we have not we haven't paid anything for the land we're not committed to the land um this is only uh a probe I guess for lack of a better term to see is this you know uh a viable uh piece of property that we can build onto but there's no commitment to the board that I'm aware

131of that says that we have to take the land I understand I'm just going by the history sure yeah M alen okay um just on number five the pre-referendum planning that is number five is solely specific to the block six lot 5.21 is that correct the church yes land okay I just have to make a couple comments regarding it uh first of all oak tree school was built under the same cluster Zone provision as what we are discussing now and Church Road so if everybody's satisfied with the way uh uh o oak tree has uh been built and constructed and placed and located um that was under the same cluster Zone provision uh a as as church so that's one issue also uh and I'm not saying I agree with this but what I'm saying

132is these These are or again historic um precedence uh the Township's interpretation of cluster Zone and how to use it how to convey the property uh instead of open space as land for municipal use again it's precedented in this town uh I have over the years been very much against it um and at every meeting that I've attended Planning and Zoning I have said that it should be uh conveyed in as open space it has not no one else very few people Mr noin on is usually there um we have uh we have um offered our opposition to that however the rest of the community hasn't been there and the township has gone forward with their interpretation of the cluster's own provision by accepting the land as Municipal uh use so we may be stuck

133with that uh like I said whether I uh approve of that or not um so the so that's the historic interpretation of that I also attended the most recent Township council meeting and I was hoping that that there was a resolution on the uh the council agenda and I must tell you that I'm was very disappointed that members of the public who were concerned about these 65 acres were not in attendance um we've had discussions with the community about where the decisions at this point are are lying and uh unfortunately again uh without public uh participation in these things we we we come to uh an evening like this where we're still going around and around um and uh Mr Kaufman mentioned that the the property is privately owned at this point he may be

134correct um under the definition of that but the Builder agreement with the township um controls the site plan and that says that the township is going to be uh given the property under uh the agreement under a uh valuable consideration that the the way the site was uh approved so while it is still in the hands of the developer I believe that contractually and again I'm not an attorney but the way these things have seemed to play out contractually the township is uh going to get this land because the rest of the development and the approvals have you know and the construction has been made so my my point is that I don't think it's particularly private at this point I think the township is pretty much guaranteed under again their interpretation of the cluster

135Zone provisions and the fact that these properties have already been built that that land is pretty clearly going to go to the township now why it is not a a letter of interpretation so like and again not being an attorney but I think that a letter of interpretation would have been prudent and would have been decent of the township to to put forward whether it be the mayor or the councel I mean that's unfortunate um you know so I see this as a dilemma of diverse opinions and V and and a lot of various Solutions um we have tried uh over the last year or so I mean there's Mr kak is correct there has been a discussion at almost every meeting there there have been deliberations I think there isn't anybody who isn't doing

136due diligence including the people who disagree with mayor and that I disagree with um in terms of what we know we know what the need is we have different um uh Avenues and options and in some cases the same people who are saying we're not moving fast enough are saying we're moving too fast on certain issues we can't have it both ways we are doing both we are trying to move fast in the areas and in my opinion we are trying to move fast in the areas we can move forward with and we are doing due diligence in the areas we must be diligent with yes we're expending a certain amount of money but it's not the same amount as taking uh trying to take an open space provision where there there are really incumbrances

137on the property so I I I'm I'm disappointed that we're we don't have uh this letter of interpretation but the but I do believe that we are actually doing exactly what we're supposed to be doing and being responsible stewards of both the money and the process so um I'll see how I still haven't decided how to vote on number five any other board member Brave I think it would have been more interesting had we been given all the options analyzed all the options and then proceeded to vote on which options we thought we should pursue Mr mail yeah um something to what Michelle said I also think that we you know we need to we can't be Pennywise and pound foolish and I think that goes to what the last part of what you said

138that's just a statement the second thing um I think we need to explain especially to me as a non- educator and to the public what happen you know you talked about an elementary school optimat is at 700 kids what happens in an elementary school when we go above 700 kids that you know you're talking about first and second and third graders I mean that's not ideal and what you know can you please expound upon what happens yeah absolutely um there's no hard and fast rule there's no solid research that I'm aware of that says this is the the optimal size for an elementary school what I'm basing that on is uh looking at what most elementary schools how how much they house now I know Dr alvik and I have had has this discussion that

139we had up to I think a thousand students at Brookside and Barkley Brook just Brookside just Brookside when I started right um so could we go to a thousand sure yeah we could um is you know if we have the option without it costing any more if we have that flexibility to have less than a thousand students in an elementary school I think that would be preferred but not at the expense of um but what um what I'm asking is when you have a thousand kids in an elementary school what how does that impact their learning their development their you know how they're being taught their safety I would like to I think Dr Al I'd like to hand that over to her I mean I think yeah no absolutely good question when I began

140as the principal at Brookside school we had over a thousand students in the school it was grades three through six at the time that was when sixth grade was still in the elementary school um because of the size of Brookside the fourth and fifth grade students were out in trailers um the problem comes in it doesn't come in with the education that students are getting in their general education classroom because the whole idea is is to keep those class sizes at an optimal level for the teachers the problem comes in more with the core facilities getting the students through the cafeteria through the lunch line having enough time in the daily schedule for students to have gym class without having three classes in the gym um there are there are 35 periods a week where

141students could be in the library if you have more than 35 sections one of those classes is not having library in the library that week they're having it in their classroom so it's looking more at those core facilities um than than what's happening in the classroom thank you great answer that was an overcrowded school if we're building a school that will contain those the Thousand students we would make make accommodations for those other activities and when a teacher closes the door the learning goes on I understand that but you still have to accommodate all those extra buses and it's not you know it's not I want to try and avoid this cross conversation um certainly the comments are well taken you can talk later any other board member uh let let me just uh take

142my turn if I can um you know to the community we're part of the community we're community members we're volunteers we want what's best for this community as well we feel your pain and you know you could see even amongst us there's concerns with everything um but but yet we have the charge to do what's best for this uh this school system and community in in thinking about this 65 acres to use the term Soo said due diligence if we walked away from it and let's say down the road found out that it was very buildable and yet we just spent millions of dollars on some property how are we going to account to all the other taxpayers that aren't here right now we realize the ones that are here uh basically live close to

143that Community I'm sure most of you but that's neither here nor there you have one point of view but there's there's a lot of other point of views out there and I think we have to be accountable to them so we need to find out is it doable to build schools there at the same time that's why that's important to resend uh that letter of intent because we if we don't resend that letter of intent we'll never know if that property is buildable and I think that would be preventing us from doing our due due diligence as as a board at the same time we're asking the board to approve other measures because we know time is a factor we have to find out if these other schools uh can be expanded how much you

144know it's nice to sit here and say we could do this and we can do that no we need professional opinions to deci determine what we could do this and we can do that we need uh Architects and we need Engineers we have to have the professionals opinion we can't do it based on hearsay or you know just our opinion it has to be a professional opinion otherwise it's not going to fly so I have to you know ask the board when you're thinking about all these resolutions think about that we need to move in multiple directions because we're under pressure the time is a factor Dr kosac correctly said these kids are coming all of us know that they're here and more will be coming we need to uh respond to this growth and

145we need to do it uh with with a knowledge with a good knowledge base so that we can provide the proper environment for these students at and not um and consider taxpayers as well because we're all here together in the community Mr poori alluded to that I couldn't agree with them all we're all part of this community we're in this together you need to understand that this board is trying to do the best possible thing for this community whether we agree on certain things or not the intent is to do the best thing for this community that being said I think we're ready for a question I very quick sure I I have and I'll let the community know this I I I wanted to vote no on number five however after hearing some of

146the community members and um and hearing uh some good ideas about uh whether we get verbal commitments or non-verbal commitments can we um in addition to this number five can we put something forward like a resolution a request for the Town Council and the mayor to respond to us as to what their intentions are with the land in writing so we have something that and I and I just thought of this so I'm sorry it's it's not something that I had a preconceived idea I got it from the conversation and the deliberation that we could actually look we're asking this the state we keep telling we're asking the state to help us with funds let's ask the municipality to give us an idea because I think we we don't we we don't want by the

147way I don't want to take away from said you gave me an idea as long as we're talking about the state oh we need impact fees if we had impact fees a lot of this WOW would be taken care of and that's something down the line that we have to think about uh when we deal with our state state legislators let me ask uh Mr Gorski you want to yes with with um regard to miss arminio's comments if directed by Administration will be more than happy to send a letter to the mayor asking and inquiring in writing as to their intent mayor and the council to the transfer of the land the mayor has indicated to us before he for the correspondence begin with him so that's why I would suggest to go to the

148mayor first he took offense to before when we send something right to the council um you know I I understand that Mr Gorski and but I think for Mr Aro that um if it was copy to the council president and to the mayor I would be satisfied and I think the public would be satisfied with that as well I I and that is what the letter of intent was all along it was a written request of the Township's intent to transfer the land but if we if we were to send that out tomorrow if this is passed tonight uh I think certainly something that it can hurt to wait we sent a letter we actually sent a letter of intent yes we actually drafted a letter of intent reviewed by both attorneys the boards and

149the townships okay it was never presented to the council and then it was um um stopped so like to a to to answer one of our I think it was Miss skur's Thing H have we asked the council and have we asked the mayor yes the answer to that was yes letter of intent was drafted went through so we don't have to I mean they did not form did we ask them to respond in writing yes yes that's unfortunate okay I don't know if the second one is necessary yeah I just want to say asked and answered next well it wasn't answered that was the intent of the letter of the intent right okay they answered by not answering right that's an answer well that's all right we can vote there we go okay voting

150on board action items a through K under the business administrator's report motion made by Mr noin seconded by Mrs kapano Mrs armeno yes on everything but I am compelled to vote no on five please don't it's not worth folks I have to ask you to please refrain from commenting whether applauding or verbal Mr Braverman no on A5 yes on the rest this Deo yes on all Mr calman yes Mrs Co Pano yes Mr noin yes to all except item five which I vote no Mrs Keno yes Mr Rybeck yes Mr Russo I'm very reluctant but due to the urgency and the need to move ahead I'm going to vote Yes and Mr rutsky so I am going to vote Yes and let me give you my list of those that I'm abstaining from so A1

151I abstain in out of respect to Mr nin I'm going to abstain from number A3 because of the Tiny Tots probably not taking care you don't know students I will abstain from A4 because it's the middle school I will abstain from letter b letter c letter G and letter K that's my [Music] book you have that to repeat it I'm sorry no these are this is the spread out I I have it I have it um Mr Rybeck motion passes okay is there anything else in your report that concludes my report thank you very much okay thank you then we can move to the uh board president's report to change the um tone of the uh meeting a little bit I'd like to uh take this opportunity to congratulate Patty Lang Ken chela on their

152election to the board I'd also like to congratulate Michelle almino for her re-election as well I have to also thank Mr nin Mr poy and Mr poori for stepping up up and volunteering to run for a position on this board of education Mr calman we won't forget about you and your many years of service we'll do more next month like to talk a minute about state aid it seems as though the national election is trumped the Statewide discussions on state aid did you just say that seriously I our situation remains unchanged and there's been no recent movement that I have seen on behav of state legislators to correct the inequities in order to better facilitate some action we will be updating a letter which is currently on our website this letter can be copied and

153sent out to legislators governor and education commissioner and contact information will be provided we need the public to help us in this matter as politicians see potential votes and respond numbers matter we're also willing to visit our active communities and to our other community groups to explain our state aid predicament and answer questions if you're interested please get in touch with the superintendent's office contact information is on our website and make sure you go to Monroe Township Schools middle sex County I don't know Dr kosac did you want to add something to that about meeting call meetings for the for the state aid yeah for the state aid um no I think I think you've said it well okay uh now we can move to the um Other Board of Education business anybody yeah I'll

154just give you one okay Mr Cal only because I have to and I only got one more shot at it so just a suggestion because I know you guys are going to move um in a few months to a new Administration and a new board you're going into a very difficult time you you're heading into the wind and it's it's going to be tough when it comes to allowing the public to speak and allowing the Board of Education to speak to each other I think it's important that the dialogue happens here that you allow free dialogue between board members allow them to speak and most certainly allow the public to voice their frustrations and questions it's it believe me when I tell you the darkness is coming right it it's coming I assure you you

155could write it down and people get very frustrated when they feel the board is either limiting or restricting their ability to vent right so just you know realize that there's two sides to this coin and it's going to be a rough road and just have to get along with everybody because we're all benefactors here so you know we're trying to do it thank you L appreciate that okay um any other board of education business now we can move to the public forum uh I'd ask anyone in the public this is not you do not have to uh speak to the agenda this is more open you have the same three minutes uh to make your statement or ask you questions three minutes or less if needed I ask that you um ask all your questions

156and uh hopefully we'll be able to respond fly uh prakash perab again hi uh appreciate about the state aid we want to understand how we can Lobby and help you all okay uh without that how you can be transparent to us so we know what way you're approaching uh so that we can participate as a community talk to the legislators if you want we can we can plan and do okay so I appreciate how you can you can communicate to the community okay uh second thing uh second question is I'm hearing from the friends I have not seen the maintenance of the middle school is not good so uh I request one of the um talk to as for the himon Patel who spoke to me on that so I would like you all to

157look into it one of the board member can go and see the facility as for the mission I read that safety of our children is very important safety of the staff everyone is important there they have to be safe and healthy okay so I would like you all to look about the maintenance of the school okay we cannot save $100 but make sure that our schools are maintained well okay thank you very much thank you very much anyone else from the public Mr Po once again Doug PO for tamarak Road uh I'm just going to bring this up a second time because I do think it's a very viable proposal and I do hope the board will give it serious consideration and that is to building a 56 building uh because I think it would

158uh be less expensive than a Middle School uh to build a new Middle School I think also it would require that if you build a new elementary school that it would be uh smaller because you would only have to accommodate grades uh K through five and not K through uh I'm sorry K through four and not K through five and in terms of Transportation if that 56 building were built and I think it doesn't have to be built behind the Middle School it can be built to the north of the Middle School if it were built there then those children that come into uh the middle school for grades uh seven and eight could be on the same buses as the kids coming for five and six it would be centrally located your transportation issues

159would be relatively simple and I think you would have a buy in from the entire Community for something of that of that nature uh okay on my second item and this is really just uh and I hope it won't be misunderstood but I've looked through the uh agendas I've looked through the minutes I've looked through videos and I think we need clarification on something that occurred this past summer uh at a special meeting of the Board of Education I believe it was in July July 27th if I'm not mistaken at that time the board approved Merit goals for our superintendent and to those Merit goals there was bonus pay attached I cannot find in the minutes nor can I see in the video uh any specific mention of what the uh bonuses would be if

160those Merit goals are achieved and I think the public is entitled to know that I also think that the whatever the goals are need to be clearly delineated because there uh they uh at the meeting where they were approved it says as previously submitted well when I looked back at what was previously submitted I only saw two goals and yet I think there were three goals so I would appreciate it this evening if we could have a clarification on what are the three goals that this board approved for our super superintendent to pursue and what amount of bonuses would be paid to the superintendent for the accomplishment of those goals I think the public is entitled to that information and it has not been directly forthcoming thank you okay okay so um just to answer

161that Mr pu the U as far as the amounts the the whole idea of the miracle and you were board president when when I was hired as part of the contract is something that governor christe uh put in place uh regarding Merit goals and it's very clearly regulated and delineated and that is a superintendent is allowed to request because there are salary caps and in a lot of cases salaries of other people in the district are now higher than the superintendents in a lot of school districts the Governor Christie when he put that into place allowed for merit goals that don't count toward a superintendent's pension but would allow superintendent to uh achieve additional pay based on the completion successful completion of a miracle the superintendent's allowed to have up to five Miracles uh they

162are negotiated between the superintendent and the Board of Ed uh that the I can speak you know I know there's legal parts that maybe I shouldn't speak about because it's contractual but I want to be honest and I want to be transparent so there are three of the Merit goals the uh State defines them as either quantitative or qualitative quantitative meaning you can get 3.3% of your of your salary um in that amount so it's a couple thousand per uh each quantitative goal qualitative I believe off the top of my head is 2.5% so should that goal be completed then that would be 2.5% which again is somewhere in that I again off the top of my head I want to say around that $2,000 or $3,000 range the goals are submitted to the board

163for approval because it is a contractual issue you're right it is done in closed session I've been advised by the board attorney uh that you know we we weren't disclosing them but I certainly have no problem with talking to you about them the goals also have to be approved by the county superintendent they were approved by the county superintendent they were approved by this board of education at the completion of the goals I have to show evidence of successfully completing the goals the board again has to approve that as well as the county superintendent has to approve it is very heavy heavily regulated my preference would not to have be to not have them at all but that's my only that's just an opinion um the actual goals themselves uh basically it's around student achievement

164Partnerships I don't have the goals right in front of me and I would like to at least consult with the board attorney before I put all that out there because originally it was decided to be put into closed session so should the board attorney uh you know give me that clearance uh I certainly had no problems I as I you know I try to be transparent with with everything I do here and um you know my goal with Merit goals excuse not the unintended pun there is is certainly to improve either um student academic achievement or opportunities for students with that thank you hi John elbasan Belmont Court uh I just want to be brief just a comment I want to thank everyone for their deliberation tonight they're Earnest in reviewing all the uh facts

165you have in front of you uh I think you're caught in a bit of a Crosshair just between our uh Municipal entity and obviously being the benevolent group that you are as the Board of Education um it it's worth noting that this Township has been successfully litigated against for uh poor Fair unfair practices about real estate tax and assessments in recent years it's been successfully litigated against uh under coach for affordable housing uh it has been uh in the past successfully litigated against land deals uh Miss armen's point about cluster zoning uh there is there is a Divergence of opinion about what state law is and what past precedent has been in this Township and I think what Mr Kaufman speaks of of dark storms Brewing uh is that uh there will be another assessment

166of where the overreach of this Township is uh and it will be decided in the courts and unfortunately that's going to put us at a disadvantage of getting prudent results in our current School District with the land assets we have so the trend is there those that have brought up the issues about the sincerity of the town I would say this if the if the town was truly sincere like any title uh change of hand they would have accepted title of that land they would have cleared it for themselves knowing what municipal use if any they could have had with that land and benevolently they would have then offered it to this Township this board of education which is a separate entity from the municipality and in turn you would have not undergone the Litany

167of questions you're going to get from myself and others until this matter is resolved and that's as as succinct as I can distill this issue we must get clarity from the municipality uh we have petitioned the min P legal attorney uh and several things are ongoing that I can't speak to uh so I assure you uh there are pressure behind the scenes as well as with the developer but it's unfortunate because as Mr bravman has said and Mr kak has not witnessed at this Township because of his new tenure and I wish him complete success because my my children's success depends on Mr kak's success is that we've had in this Township working working ideas and plans that need to get started and I I strongly urge Mr Gorski to rethink the strategy kindly rethink

168the strategy get prudent results as it relates to our high school as it relates to Applegarth and the last thing I'll say about Applegarth is as I poll people Applegarth our community does not want Applegarth that land and that building to become just an administrative building we feel that that's a decay of asset we ask that that building be raised and be built immediately and I'll leave with this Mr kak from his own lips today and it'll be in the minutes and I'll ask for the Oprah so it'll be there I'll leave with this is that he said in a year's time we'll be back to trailers the referendum will still take four years to build buildings for us to move our kids in let's raise Applegarth let's build a quality School building let's build

169the extension of the high school let's get prudent results and we can all be happy about that thank you good night thank you anyone else even manfrey 12 Belmont Court I just want to uh add to a few comments here uh first and foremost a lot has been made of the partnership between this board and the township Council and I have to say you know as an outsider looking in it doesn't look like a very good partnership and I'll ask the same question this week or at this meeting that I asked at last meeting what sort of conversations are we having with the township with regards to the type of assets that they could make available to the Board of Education and to our kids and does this 65 acre environmentally questionable parcel of land

170represent the best that they could do for our kids and does it represent the best that we could ask of from our Township I'll leave that with you uh there's also just been some comments about public participation and I think I want to make clear that uh just because you haven't seen us maybe show up at some of those meetings it doesn't mean that we're working diligently behind the scenes and I would urge all the board members apply some common sense to what you're seeing and hearing a letter of intent has been sent it hasn't been answered what does that tell you what does that tell you thank you very much thank you anyone else in the public not seeing anyone else we can go to close session resolution be it resolved that the Board

171of Education of the town ship of Monroe hereby moves to go into closed session in accordance with the Sunshine Law chapter 231 of the public laws 1975 njsa 10 col 4-6 through 10 4-21 to discuss the following subjects harassment intimidation and bullying following Clos session action may be taken the discussion conducted in closed session can be disclosed to the public at such time as the need for confidentiality no longer exists Dr kosak talk about how long you think it might be 5 minutes 10 minutes 5 10 minutes okay thank you thank okay I think we're ready with to move on we're not adjourned so we can keep going uh I see no one from the public I think we can dispense with the public uh Forum next scheduled meeting MO is Wednesday December 14th at

172700 p.m all like a motion to adjourn I second okay any discussion all wait a minute I vote no all in favor I unanimous Happy Thanksgiving everyone Happy Thanksgiving

This transcript may contain errors introduced by automated or source-provided captioning. Bracketed descriptions such as [Music] are retained from the source. Passage divisions are editorial aids and do not alter the wording.